ANITA Electronics Overview - University of Hawaii at...

92
ANITA Electronics Overview Gary S. Varner University of Hawai , i, Manoa SMEX kickoff meeting with JPL 30-31 January 2004

Transcript of ANITA Electronics Overview - University of Hawaii at...

ANITAElectronics Overview

Gary S. VarnerUniversity of Hawai

,i, Manoa

SMEX kickoff meeting with JPL30-31 January 2004

1Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Overview

• System overview– Intro: prototypes flown on ANITA-lite

• Prototype Testing– STRAW2 Results

– Triggering

– Ongoing R&D

• Critical R&D Items – RF Chain Partition/Packaging

– Digitizer

– Triggering

2Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Proposed Signal Flow

LNA Gain

Digitize

Trigger

[GHz]1.2.3

[GHz].3 1.2

3Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Proposal Signal Flow Architecture

BUSinter−

Dual−Ported

LATCH

LCP

RCP

FPGA

GPS> clock

> Lat/Lon/altitude

2nd stage AMP/Fan−out

faceMemory

Trigger comparator & logic

[X36]

> trigger sequence> multiple hit logic> trigger pattern

thr

thr

Analog in enable

[X36]

> Data pipeline

& SCA data [X36]

BUS

TDRSS

LNA

computer

host

telemetry

& ADC2.5 GHz SCA

antenna trigger

antennaQR horn

DAC

4Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

The Game – Proto flight as intro

• Significant signal power at large frequencies

• Paired with TIGER fast PMTs, SIP RFI

• All noise all the time (thermal noise limit)

5Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

ANITA-lite instrument configuration

LNA/triggerboard

Flight/DAQ computer/ Onboard storage

transducerSuite (T,P,I,V,..)

Fast Digitizer modules (2)

Env. Monitor ADC module

powercontroller

DC-DCconverters

cPC

Ibus

Quad-ridged hornAntennas:

Gain 8-15 dBiFreq. Range:0.2-1.2 GHz

Power fromPV array

RS232 1200 baudTelemetry to TIGER

battery

Acronym glossary:• ADC: analog-to-digital converter• cPCI: compact personal computer interface• LNA: low-noise amplifier• DAQ: data acquisition• PV: photovoltaic

6Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Reality check

7Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Front-end choice

8Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Power Budget

9Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

ALTO Board Specs

•Operation of 4 RF antenna inputs at the thermal noise limit over the 0.2-1.2 GHz BandWidth (BW) •Ability to trigger on band-limited transients•Provision for a VETO antenna input•Computer controlled RF trigger and VETO thresholds•Continuous monitoring of the RF input power•Low power, fast triggering•Synchronization with GPS once-per-second (1PPS) timing marker•Muli-level analog output to allow Multiplicity selection in the Acqiris [4] digitizer module•Instantaneous and averaged Livetime monitoring

10Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

ALTO Rev. B Architecture

• 2x revisions built and tested in a few months

11Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Board mechanics

12Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Details…documentation

http://www.phys.hawaii.edu/~idlab

All details therein,Some highlights

13Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Output to Acqiris

14Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Received RF power sensitivity

15Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

VETO Performance

16Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Payload for the Understanding and Mitigation of backgrounds for ANITA (PUMA)

17Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

DAQAcqiris Digitizers 2GS/s, 1GHz ABW

Vicor Power Modules

Acromag IP Carrier & Transition ModuleKontron CPU

18Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Shielded breakoutsTempMon I/F

ADC I/F DAC I/F

Digital I/O I/F

19Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Acqiris Data Out

20Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

External Storage

USB hub

2GB drives

Vacuum tested

21Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Reality check 2 (not going to scale up)

22Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

ANITA-lite Lessons (1)

• Mostly successful flight:– 1x ALTO channels went belly up– A lot of functionality not really implemented– Direct single channel rate monitoring (scalers) would help– Too many SMA cables

• Global Lessons:– Need better integration/packaging management– “RF front-end” part needs to be modular– Already at 200W for only 2 antennas, 2006 will come

quickly

• Major concern: Acqiris heating• Many items not covered

– Sun sensor, Noise diode, GPS

23Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Lessons Continued• Lack of working software impacted the schedule

• RF lessons:– Need modular packing/higher integration for RF components

– Power/signal distribution – need better solution

– ~ 200W for only 2x antennas (3.6kW scaled up)

– Point heat source objects (e.g. LNAs) may force to run pressurized

– With careful shielding/choking internal EMI manageable

• Services/housekeeping:– Many deficiencies uncovered

– Good prototype for actual flight

– Choice of cPCI seems good

– Working example for RF triggering (& need for VETO?)

– Faster GPS access (serial port/interconn drop only serious problem

– Finer granularity power segmentation – better distribution

24Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Askaryan Signature

0 2 4 6 8

Time (ns)

• Significant signal power at large frequencies

• Strong linear polarization (near 100%)

25Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Transient Recorder Specs

• >= 1GHz analog input bandwidth (200-1200MHz)• multi-GSa/s sampling rate (>>Nyquist limit)• minimum phase distortion for clean polarization • dynamic range (>= 10 bits)• internal Analog to Digital Conversion (ADC)• short record length (100-200ns if optimally matched)

• self-triggering with fine threshold adjustment• bi-polar triggering• deadtimeless conclude multi-hit buffering needed

26Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW3 architectureSTRAW Architecture

40k

20k

10k

2R

R

2R

R

2R

RR

2R

R

2R

inputs

8 RF

inputs

8 RF

Analog

buffer

Trigger Control

AMUX

8

8

Monitor

or Ext. ADC

to Data Acquisition

Global Trigger port

Threshold DACs (32x 20−bit)

Threshold DACs (32x 20−bit)

64x 32−bit

12

timing control

SCA bank: 16 rows x 256 columns

SCA bank: 16 rows x 256 columns

8

8

Trigger

Trigger

AMUX

scalers

Gain

ADC

SAR

2R

R R

2R

R

2R

R

2R

R

2R

DQ

Q’

D Q

Q’

+−

Q

Q’

D Q

Q’

D

−+

+−

−+

−+

+−

+−

−+

+−

−+

+−

+−

−+

• 0.25µm TSMC process

27Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Switched Capacitor Array (SCA)

input• Write pointer is ~4-6 switches closed @ once

28Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 Chip Self-Triggered Recorder Analog Waveform (STRAW)

32x256 SCA bank

DACs ADC

Trigger

scalers

16 Channels of256 deep SCA buckets

Optimized for RF inputMicrostrip 50Ω

Record length:128-256ns

Target input Bandwidth:>700MHz

-LL and HL (adj.) for each channel

Sampling Rate:1-2GSa/s (adj.)

-Multiplicity triggerfor LL hits

On-chip ADC:12-bit, >2MSPS

External option:MUXed Analog out

Sampling Rates>~8GSa/s possiblew/ 0.25µm process

8192 analog storage cells

Die:~2.5mm2

Self-Triggering:

Fabricated Winter 2002

29Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 Evaluation

• RF signal input

• Adjustable: 0.6 –3.4 GSa/s

• 256 samples (70 –300ns)

30Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Better than expected

STRAW2 Sampling Freq.

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Freq. Adj. Voltage (ROVDD) [V]

Sam

plin

g Fr

eq. [

GH

z]

Avg.-cycle+cycleSPICE

31Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Response (1)

• Sub-ns transient ping: <= 100ps leading edge

Scope ET sampling:100 Gsa/s equiv.

32Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Response (2)

• Very nice tool: FFT analysis of RF transient pulse

• Have ideas how to improve –roll-off matches SPICE simulations of storage cells

1/8 ampl

33Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Analog Input Bandwidth –EST.

• Many examples of high sampling rate, but:– PMT readout– Wireless (2.5GHz)

– Very narrow BW

– Naïve calculation • phase• inductance

– 3-D Simulation• PCB, Package, bond wires• BGA necessary?• What is fundamental limit

Component Length/area Unit Factor FunitTotal [fF]

Input traces 5 cm 0.2 pF/cm 1000 w.a.g.bonding wire 150 mil 0.3 pF/wire 300 w.a.g.

input pad 60 um^2 187 fF/pad 187 Tannerinput protection 594 λ 1.1 pF/ckt 1100 SPICE

stripline area 2500 um^2 43aF/um^

2 107.5 MOSISstripline fringe 5 mm 60 aF/um 300 MOSISSwitch Drains 256 switches 5.6 fF/drain 1433.6 SPICE

Open Switches 6 open 87 fF/gate 522 SPICETOTAL 4.9501 pF

.6602

13 MHz

RCf dB ==

π

Capacitance Overestimated

34Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

High-speed Digitizers

• Kleinfelder speed but not high

analog BW

High Speed Digitizer Comparison

10

100

1000

10000

10 100 1000 10000

Analog Bandwidth [MHz]

Sam

plin

g R

ate

[MS

a/s]

ZEUS[12]RD2[13]Kleinfelder[14]Haller[15]ADeLine1[11]DSC/DRS[16]AD9410[17]CLC5957[18]TLV5580[19]ADS5102[20]MAX1449[21]

Desired Max.Operating Region

STRAW2• Analog BW tough

• Comm. ADC very high P

35Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Good News: DC Power

<20mW/channel

Will be even less without on-chipTriggering

36Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 Lessons

• Extremely subtle error in on-chip ADC– Worked in 5 previous designs

– “fixed” a symbol problem elsewhere

• Triggering– Problem with DAC load

– Layout was horrible -- interference

• Input impedance– Target 50Ω, 130Ω actual (used wrong extracted parameter),

but makes the routing awkward

Based upon these results, decided to bifurcate the design:• STRAW3 update STRAW2 with bug fixes – slight bandwidth improvement• LABRADOR dedicated sampling chip with improved ADC

37Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Updated August ’03 Baseline ANITA Sampling Unit for RF (SURF) Board

38Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Self-Triggering

39Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Digital-to-Analog Convert

Main DAC

Fine-adjust DAC

DAC Code

40Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Fine Adjust

R

“2R”

41Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Triggering Detail

42Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Discriminator Layout

Fast Comparator Control Logic Capacitor

43Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Simulation Results

• Use simulated high freq. Response from beamtest data:– works

44Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW3 Data Sheet

16

16

16

SDbusTMbus

ADCbus

2:1 MUX

Out

Sel

B

A

TspySAd

ADDRbus DnA

busDAT out

16

2:1 MUX

Out

Sel

B

A16

1616

2:1 MUX

Out

Sel

B

A

data ready

12

Successive Approximation ADC Timing

1376543

EOC

ADCclear

ADCstart

ADCclk

1 2

Available on the ID Lab web-site –

Should allow any competentEE to design around it(interest from RICE)

45Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

LABRADOR Goals

• Maximum input bandwidth– 50Ω impedance– Simplified architecture (no trigger functionality)– “best” RF coupling into Switched Capacitor storage cells– Classical engineering trade-offs

• Input trace resistance vs. load capacitance• Storage capacitor kTC noise vs. load capacitance• Storage switch Ron vs. drain load capacitance

• Analog Transfer– Optimum speed– Individual channel parallel

• Improved ADC– Ramp type – no missing codes– Massively parallel to reduce conversion time

Address first

46Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Transient Recorder Specs

• >= 1GHz analog input bandwidth (200-1200MHz)

• multi-GSa/s sampling rate (Nyquist limit min.)

• minimum phase distortion for clean polarization

• dynamic range (>= 10 bits)

• internal Analog to Digital Conversion (ADC)

• short record length (100-200ns if optimally matched)

• self-triggering with fine threshold adjustment

• bi-polar triggering

• deadtimeless conclude multi-hit buffering needed

• LOW POWER!! (need 36(40) * 2 channels) + VETO?

[Acqiris > 1kW] Target: 20W/channel 20mW/channel

47Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

LABRADOR Architecture

• 0.25µm TSMC process

48Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW ADC Expectations

“worst case” for mismatch in a previous implementation of same

SAR ADC w/R-2R ladder

Can correct to rather linear, but still differential sensitivity and calibration is a pain

Wilkinson type better – monotonicBUT, slower

49Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

“Wilkinson” ADC

+-

• No missing codes

• Linearity as good as can make ramp

• Can bracket range of interest

NB: SCA output not

linear

50Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

ADC Sim

Wilkinson ADC SPICE Sim

y = 128.25x + 1.324R2 = 0.9999

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Input Voltage [V]

Out

put c

ode

[cou

nts]

Wilk ADCLinear (Wilk ADC)

51Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Transfer Curve

Storage Cell Simulation

y = 6.2891x - 2364.8R2 = 0.993

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

350 400 450 500

Stored Waveform (Vin) [mV]

Diff

sen

sed

Volta

ge (V

out)

[mV]

Rload = 40k

Gain:

mVCkTvstore

rms 23.0==

52Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Readout speed comparison

12.8 µs20MHz©EXTLABRADOR -- parallel

210 µs10MHzEXTLABRADOR -- serial

240 µs100kHz(b)INTLABRADOR -- SURF

410 µs10MHz(a)EXTSTRAW3 -- FINESSE

1,638 µs2.5MHzINTSTRAW3 -- SURF

3,072 µs1MHzEXTSTRAW2 – DALI

384 µs8MHzEXTSTRAW2 - GEISER

Total LatencyspeedADCIC Evt.Size

6kB

8kB

4kB

(a) 16 channels for STRAW3, 12 channels for STRAW2(>300MB/s!!)(b) 12.8MHz effective: 128x ADC; 100MHz clock, 12b eff. – includes additional latency

© 8x 20MHz ADC in parallel

53Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Understanding STRAW2 Performance

• Contributions considered:– Simple Estimates based on R(Z)LC

– Coupling into package leadframe (TQFP-100)

– On-chip “stripline”

• What is the real limitation?– Cannot rule out multiple contributions (2x poles?)

54Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 Model

7mm3.2mm

MOSIS ID

ii

• Microstripinput

55Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 Equiv. Ckt.

STRAW2 Resistance Estimate Input (RF) Input (ref)bond wire

0.0 0.1 pad70 0.2 M5-M4

Metal 4(sheet) = 0.07 Ohm/sq 243.5 17.0 typ length (sq.)Metal 5(sheet) = 0.03 Ohm/sq 1704 51.1 typ length (sq.)

Poly contact = 5.1 Ohm 6 6 0.9 0.9via 1= 2.7 Ohm 6 3 0.5 0.9via 2= 5.35 Ohm 6 3 0.9 1.8via 3= 8.26 Ohm 6 3 1.4 2.8via 4= 11.34 Ohm 6 1.9

56.6 23.6 Total per feed

48.3 Rterminator

Measured: 130 Ohm 128.5 Grand Total

17Ω

29Ω

48Ω

~50Ω

78fF

~1kΩ

~6fF0.11Ω

22-45Ω

50-130Ω

M5 14λ

Lbond=2.6nH(Z=130,L=6mm)

STRAW2 Z~50ΩM498λ

M5 60λ

Z~30ΩSTRAW3 M498λ

56Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Naïve Calculations –EST.

Component Length/area Unit Factor Funit Total [fF]Input traces 5 cm 0.2 pF/cm 1000 w.a.g.bonding wire 150 mil 0.3 pF/wire 300 w.a.g.

input pad 60 um^2 187 fF/pad 187 Tannerinput protection 594 λ 1.1 pF/ckt 1100 SPICEstripline area 2500 um^2 43 aF/um^2 107.5 MOSISstripline fringe 5 mm 60 aF/um 300 MOSISSwitch Drains 256 switches 5.6 fF/drain 1433.6 SPICE

Open Switches 6 open 87 fF/gate 522 SPICE

TOTAL 4.9501 pF

.1.22

13 GHz

RCf dB ==

πBonding wire, series R limit

R=Rfeed C=Cload C~2.5pFR~30Ω

.27.12

13 GHz

ZCf dB ==

πLumped elementZ=Z0 C~2.5pF~50Ω

C probably pessimistic, but 2nd pole?800MHz~80Ω C~2.5pF

57Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Bounding Case

Guidance for Cap Max

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

0 1 2 3 4 5

Total Load Capacitance [pF]

BW

[GH

z]

pure C + ZoSTRAW2

58Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Storage Capacitor constraints

Impact of Storage Cap size

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

0 50 100 150 200

Storage Cap [fF]

Vrm

s [

mV

]

Vrms

STRAW2

For 1V useable input range

9bits

10bits

11bits

12bits

mVCkTvstore

rms 23.0==

Cstore only 78fF !!

Too big??

DC SPICE sim shows can make Rstatic ~ 920Ω, but there is a dynamic component also.

59Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 noise measurementDALI Rev. B, B-1, chip 0 Input-inferred Noise

DALI Rev. B boardunshielded

~0.5mVtyp

60Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Coupling Simulation

.4.62

13 GHz

RCf dB ==

π.4.6

21

3 GHzRC

f dB ==π

.4.62

13 GHz

RCf dB ==

π.4.6

21

3 GHzRC

f dB ==π

die

on-chip 50Ω stripline

Bonding wires

• Utilizes the LC program (FTDT algorithm)– Cray developed, available for free under Linux

61Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

S-Parameters

STRAW2 Packaging S-Parameters

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Frequency [GHz]

S11S21

VSWR:

1.8 [1GHz]

1.9 [2GHz]

62Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

SPICE stripline vs. lumped

Transmission line – lossy (multiple elements)

Two techniques give plausibly consistent results, however there is good reason to be skeptical (GIGO)

One point: @ 1GHz, length of on-chip stripline is approx.4-6o (STRAW2/3)

[~3o LABRADOR]

63Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Response

SPICE Simulations of direct drive onto storage cap, closed switch gaveSubstantially higher simulated bandwidths

64Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Parameter Space Simulation

Sample compares

-0.4

-0.2

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0 1 2 3 4

Time[ns]

Am

plitu

de

unloaded0.25pF loadRef x637fF CstoreBig gateSuperD buffBig CstoreTiny CapGND source

65Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 Bode Analysis

Value from transient analysis

Simulate Waveform Acquisition

66Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

DALI Rev. B Evaluation

STRAW2chips

Delay lines for interleaved sampling

(>5.4GSa/s in lab)

Uncalib.

67Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

LABRADOR case

128x Wilk ADCs8 chan. * 256 samples

8x HS Analog out, 1x MUX out

STRAW3

68Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

LABRADOR Equiv. Ckt.

4.7Ω

28Ω

~13Ω

10fF

~0.7kΩ

~12fF0.02Ω

0.3Ω

50-130Ω

M5 14λ

Fixed

LABRADOR Resistance Estimate Input (RF) Input (ref)bond wire

Length 17000 λ 0.0 0.1 pad70 0.2 M5-M4

Metal 4(sheet) = 0.07 Ohm/sq 71.42857 5.0 typ length (sq.)Metal 5(sheet) = 0.03 Ohm/sq 166.6667 5.0 typ length (sq.)

Poly contact = 5.1 Ohm 6 6 0.9 0.9via 1= 2.7 Ohm 6 3 0.5 0.9via 2= 5.35 Ohm 6 3 0.9 1.8via 3= 8.26 Ohm 6 3 1.4 2.8via 4= 11.34 Ohm 6 1.9

10.5 11.5 Total per feed

28 Rterminator

Measured: Ohm 50.0 Grand Total

STRAW2 Z~50ΩM498λ

LABRADOR M5 102λ

M4 Z~13Ω238λ

69Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

LABRADOR Bode Analysis

70Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Current Status

• R&D into critical (non-standard) components:– Have a near-spec low-power sampler prototype

– Need for a custom trigger chip? (CF success of ALTO)

– Sufficiently low noise LNA? (low power enough?)

• Plans:– RFCeval board in debug – STRAW3 chip “alive”

– LABRADOR returns ~“now” (also test on RFCeval)

– cPCI interface development (DALI Rev. B)

• Discussion Items: (next slides)

ID Lab tour @ some point

71Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RFCeval – 0th order prototype

Quick Reference:

•RFCeval == Radio Freq Comp evaluation board•STRAW == Self-Triggered Recorder for Analog Waveforms•LABRADOR == Large Analog Bandwidth Recorder And Digitizer with Ordered Readout

72Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Design Issues for Discussion

• RF amps/filter mounting– Directly onto back of antennas? (modular)

• Better performance, but power, cooling, cabling issues

– Miteq LNAs adequate?– Sufficient sensitivity (w/ power limit, multi-notch filters) ??

• Trigger architecture:– Global, local, cluster (half-array) ??– Logic on SURF boards ??– Multi-leveled ?? Multi-band ??– VETO ?? RCP & LCP generation ??

• Signal digitizing:– Random interleaving (more samples/longer record length) ??– Realist alternatives to current plan ??– Multi-buffering (ping-pong) depth ??

73Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

RF Partition

Pro ConLNA Payload •Better NF

•Distribute heat•No low-noise inside payload can•Simplifies cabling inside payload can(s)

•Pressurized housing?•External Power cabling•External noise diode signal cables

ConProPayload

•Worse NF•EMI shielding internally; complicates cabling inside payload can(s)•Impedance matching

•Cleaner external cabling•Fewer housing penetrations

74Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Trigger Partition

Local

ARFSURF

ARFSURF

Global TrigRF AMP

•Local holds•Global digitize

RF AMP

SURF

Global Trig

Global

•Global hold & digitize•Potentially lower noise

75Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

A Single-Crate SchemeDuring Aug 2003 Collab Meeting challenged to go to 4 Antenna/Digitizer Card

4 antenna SURF boards

Transition module TURF boards Crate Top ViewCPU

40 channel scenario

•4 spare cPCI slots for other functionality (GPS, housekeeping?)

PCI bus 1 PCI bus 2

7 drops max

76Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

WBS Impacts

• Forgotten issues?

• Specification for overall Power Max?

• Plans:– Milestones?

– Hardware Task sharing (suboptimal in ANITA-lite)

77Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Back-up slides

78Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Zeland Software

Serious Learning CurveBasically as complex as

AutoCAD

Best use of time?

79Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Turn-off Simulation

Switch Transition Timing

-0.5

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5

Time [ns]

Gat

e vo

ltage

[V]

SMP0SMP0b

1.27GHz

1.6kΩ

3.4kΩ

604MHz11.7kΩ

170MHz

11.7kΩ

1.4MHz

80Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

SPICE Wave capture Sims

81Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Raw Waveform

82Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Askaryan Signature

0 2 4 6 8

Time (ns)

• Significant signal power at large frequencies

• Strong linear polarization (near 100%)

83Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

STRAW2 Specifications

> 1GHz ind. Adj.256 ind. Adj.32 OR of 1616 multiplicity

1-2 GHz high+low12 32 bits/ch.

<=16 ms cascadeADC (SAR) bits

Digitize deadtime

High level thresholdLow level threshold

High level logicLow level logic

Comparator typeMonitor scalers

Trigger type

# SCA/channel# of channels# of RF inputsSampling rate

Analog Triggering

STRAW2 Design Parameters

Input bandwidth

• Unique in this design is the triggering requirements – High freq and bipolar

• Large latency strategy:– Multiple buffering

84Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

FFT curves

Vref1

Vref2

STRAW2

85Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Cross-check

Vref Comparison

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Time [ns]

DC

sub

t. Vr

ef

Vref1Vref2Vorig

86Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Cross-check (2)

Vref Comparison

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Time [ns]

DC

sub

t. Vr

ef

Vref1Vref2

87Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Cross-check (3)

Vref Comparison

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Time [ns]

DC

sub

t. Vr

ef

Vref1Vref2VorigVref3Vref4Vref5

88Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Treat as Systematic Error?

BW Comparison STRAW2

-14

-12

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

Freq [GHz]

Atte

nuat

ion

[dB

]

Vref sample1Vref sample2

ContinueStudying

89Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Convergence** Accuracy and convergence options:* absi|abstol : 5e-010 absv|vntol : 1e-006 accurate : 0* cshunt : 0 dchomotopy : All dcmethod : Standard* dcstep : 0 extraiter|newtol : 0 fast : 0* gmin : 1e-012 gmindc : 1e-012 gramp : 6* gshunt : 0 kcltest : 1 kvltest : 0* maxdcfailures : 4 mindcratio : 0.0001 minsrcstep : 1e-008* numnd|itl1 : 200 numndset|dchold : 20 numns|itl6 : 50* numnx|itl2 : 80 numnxramp : 40 precise : 0* reli|reltol : 0.0005 relv : 0.0005 tolmult : 1** Timestep and integration options:* absdv : 0.5 absq|chargetol : 1e-014 ft : 0.4* lvltim : 2 maxord : 2 method : gear* mintimeratio : 1e-009 mu : 0.5 numnt|itl4 : 10* numntreduce|itl3 : 3 poweruplen : 0 reldv : 0.35* relq|relchgtol : 0.0005 rmax : 2 trtol : 10** Model evaluation options:* dcap : 2 defad : 0 defas : 0* defl : 0.0001 defw : 0.0001 defnrd : 0* defnrs : 0 defpd : 0 defps : 0* deriv : 0 minresistance|resmin : 1e-005 modelmode : cachetable* moscap : 0 mosparasitics : 0 scale : 1* scalm : 1 tnom : 25 wl : 0** Linear solver options:* linearsolver : best pivtol : 1e-014 zpivtol : 1e-006*

90Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

LABRADOR – Best Quess onto chip

Component Length/area Unit Factor Funit Total [fF]Input traces 5 cm 0.2 pF/cm 1000 w.a.g.bonding wire 150 mil 0.3 pF/wire 300 w.a.g.

input pad 60 um^2 187 fF/pad 187 Tannerinput protection 594 λ 1.1 pF/ckt 1100 SPICEstripline area 2500 um^2 43 aF/um^2 107.5 MOSISstripline fringe 5 mm 60 aF/um 300 MOSISSwitch Drains 256 switches 5.6 fF/drain 1433.6 SPICE

Open Switches 6 open 87 fF/gate 522 SPICE

TOTAL 4.9501 pF56fF

8fF

.35.12

13 GHz

ZCf dB ==

πHard to get much

higherZ=Z0 ~50Ω C~2.35pF

0.3pF?

2.05pF

.876.02

13 GHz

ZCf dB ==

πPessimistic case: full stripline Cap = .74pF

If use bigger transistors, Ctotal ~ 2.8pF

[Min tran & full Cap = 1.46GHz]

91Gary S. Varner, ANITA SMEX kickoff mtg w/JPL guys @ UH, January 2004

Analog B W Obtained

Cstore only 78fF !!

However, Reff ~ 3.2kΩ (SPICE)

.6372

13 MHz

RCf dB ==

πmVCkTvstore

rms 23.0==

DC SPICE sim shows can make Rstatic ~ 920Ω, but there is a dynamic component which is difficult to simulate accurately, conservatively assign 1kΩ

Use Ron = 1.9kΩ, adjust Cstore to 56fF

.48.12

13 GHz

RCf dB ==

π