An acoustic phonetic analysis of Lewis Gaelic stop consonants
description
Transcript of An acoustic phonetic analysis of Lewis Gaelic stop consonants
An acoustic phonetic analysis of Lewis Gaelic stop consonants
Claire Nance and Jane Stuart-SmithUniversity of Glasgow
[email protected]@englang.arts.gla.ac.uk
Overview
• Stops in Gaelic• Approaches• Research questions• Methods• Results• Conclusions
Stops in Gaelic
• Word initial /ph th kh/ and /p t k/
• Word medial and word final /hp ht hk/ and /p t k/ (Ladefoged et al. 1998)
• (Also palatalised vs. velarised distinction)
Initial stops
bog ‘soft’
pòg ‘a kiss’
VOTVOT Vowel voicingVowel voicing ClosureClosure
Vowel voicingVowel voicing ClosureClosure
VOT vs. Pre-aspiration
• ‘the interval between the release of the stop and the onset of glottal vibration, that is, voicing’ (Lisker and Abramson 1964:389)
• ‘delay in the offset of normal voicing’ (Laver 1994:150)
• Aspiration ≠ pre-aspiration (Silverman 2003)
Medial and final stops
smoc ‘smoke’
snog ‘nice’
Vowel voicingVowel voicing CloseClose
Pre-aspPre-asp
Vowel voicingVowel voicing ClosureClosure
Pre-aspiration zoom in
smoc ‘smoke’
Vowel voicingVowel voicing CloseClose
Pre-aspPre-asp
Pre-aspiration zoom in
smoc ‘smoke’
CloseCloseCloseClose
Pre-aspPre-aspBreathy VoiceBreathy Voice
Approaches
• Ladefoged et al. (1998)• Ní Chasaide (1985)• Sociophonetics and consonants (Foulkes and
Docherty 1999)
Research questions
• A more complete analysis than Ladefoged et al. (1998)
• Is this system undergoing apparent time change?
Methods
• Native speakers of Lewis Gaelic• 3 ‘older’ (45-55), 3 ‘younger’ (20-24)• Recording conditions• Word list data• 2257 tokens analysed• Non-parametric statistical tests
Measures: durational
• Initial: VOT, vowel• Medial: vowel, modal voice, pre-aspiration,
breathy voice, voiceless pre-aspiration, closure, VOT
• Final: vowel, modal voice, pre-aspiration, breathy voice, voiceless pre-aspiration, closure
a c a
Measures: durational
• Segmenting on the waveform in Praat
Modal voiceModal voiceVowelVowel
Pre-aspirationPre-aspirationBVBV NoiseNoise
Measures: dynamic noise-based
• Quantification of noisiness• Anticipatory and carry-over effects (Gobl and Ní
Chasaide 1999)• Adapted zero crossing rate (Gordeeva and Scobbie
2010)• Collaborating with Olga [email protected]• Measure of noise from the glottis in periodic and
aperiodic sections• BV measures (HNR, spectral tilt, jitter shimmer)• Standard zero crossings (Bombien 2006)
• BP filtered at 5000Hz and 1.5 x F0• Effects of filtering (Gordeeva and Scobbie 2010:18)
• Perceptual superiority of this measure
BP ZCR
‘bus’ unfiltered
‘bus’ filtered
Applied to initial stops
càl ‘cabbage’
Results: durational
• VOT in initial stops• Effect of place of articulation (cf. Cho and
Ladefoged 1999)
n = 1285
Results: durational
• Vowel length – the action is in the aspirated series (cf. Kessinger and Blumstein 1997)
n = 642
Results: BP ZCR – Initial system
n = 270
Medial system
• Pre-aspiration longer in aspirated series• Some breathy voice in unaspirated• VOT ns.
n = 54
Medial system
• Vowel length (cf. Ní Chasaide 1985)
% duration of pre-aspiration word medial /ht/ according to vowel length
n = 36
Results: BP ZCR – Medial system
n = 180
Apparent time change
• VOT longer in aspirated series for younger speakers (aspirated series again)
n = 642
Results: BP ZCR – Initial change
n = 90
Speech rate
• Young people speak faster?• Effects on VOT (Allen et al. 2003, Pind 1995)• Ratios
VOTVOT VowelVowel
Pre-aspirationPre-aspirationVowelVowel
BurstBurst
Vowel Start
Vowel Start
Vowel end
Vowel end
ClosureClosure
Apparent time change
• Pre-aspiration shorter• Pre-aspiration different
% modal voice, breathy voice and voiceless pre-asp in word medial stops
n = 157
Results: BP ZCR – Medial change
n = 36
Summary of results
• YP longer VOT• YP shorter and different pre-aspiration• Benefits of a noise-based dynamic measure • Results suggest can separate phonemic
categories and age groups across the syllable
Conclusions: systems
• Support for Kessinger and Blumstein (1997): aspirated series show most variation
• Phonetically aspiration and pre-aspiration are not the same
• BUT aspiration functions as a system:– Vowel length– Change in younger speakers
Conclusions: apparent time change
• Pre-aspiration results:– Diachronic instability of pre-aspiration (Silverman
2003)– Influence of English? (Contact, obsolescence…)– Greying of phonemic categories due to lexical attrition
• VOT results:– Stops functioning as a system so somehow
compensating?
• Implications
References• Allen, J., Miller, L., and DeSteno, D., 2003. Individual talker differences in voice-onset-time. Journal of Acoustic
Society of America, 113:1, pp. 544-552• Bombien, L., 2006. Voicing alterations in Icelandic – a photoglottographic and acoustic investigation. In J.
Harrington, C. Mooshammer, F Kleber, eds., Arbeitsberichte de sInstituts fürPhonetik der Universität Kiel, 37, pp. 63-82. Kiel: Universität Kiel
• Cho, T., and Ladefoged, P., 1999. Variation and universals in VOT: evidence from 18 endangered languages. Journal of phonetics, 27, pp. 207-229
• Foulkes, P., and Docherty, G., 1999. Urban Voices. London: Arnold• Gobl, C., and Ní Chasaide, A., 1999. Voice source variation in the vowel as a function of consonantal
context. In W. J. Hardcastle and N. Hewlett, eds., Coarticulation. Cambridge: CUP. pp. 122-134• Gordeeva, O., and Scobbie, J., 2010. Preaspiration as a correlate of word-final voice in Scottish English fricatives. In
S. Fuchs, M. Toda, M. Zygis, eds., Turbulent sounds: an interdisciplinary guide. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter• Ladefoged, P., Ladefoged, J., Turk, A., St. John, S., 1998. Phonetic structures of Scottish Gaelic. Journal of the
international phonetic association, 28, pp. 1-41• Kessinger, R., and Blumstein, S., 1997. Effects of speaking rate on voice-onset-time in Thai, French, and English.
Journal of Phonetics, 25:2, pp. 143-168• Laver, J., 1994. Principles of phonetics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press• Lisker, L., 1957. Closure duration and the intervocalic voiced-voiceless distinction in English. Language, 33:1, pp.
42-49• Lisker, L., and Abramson, A., 1964. A cross-language study of voicing in initial stops: Acoustical measurements.
Word 20, pp. 384-422• Ní Chasaide, A., 1985. Preaspiration in phonological stop contrasts: an instrumental phonetic study. PhD thesis,
University of Bangor• Pind , J . 1995. Speaking rate , voice-onset time , and quantity: The search for higher-order invariants for two
Icelandic speech cues. Perception and Psychophysics, 57, pp. 291–304• Silverman, D., 2003. On the rarity of pre-aspirated stops. Journal of linguistics 39:3, pp. 575-598
Mòran taing
Claire Nance and Jane Stuart-Smith
University of Glasgow
A word on breathy voice
• Ní Chasaide (1985:139) sees BV as purely physiological
• Some evidence to support this: no place effect• Some against: YP have more in velars
Word initial apparent time change
• Comparison to Ladefoged et al. (1998)• Word initial /th/ and /t/
Word medial apparent time change
• Word medial /hk/, noise and VOT
Closure durations
• Closure durations (Lisker 1957)• Longer in aspirated series• We found significantly longer closure
durations for coronals and bilabials in the aspirated series