AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

download AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

of 20

Transcript of AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    1/20

    F I E L D S T U D Y

    SAE 50 Long-Life Synthetic

    Transmission Oil Field Study inOver-the-Road Applications

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    2/20

    Page 2

    Overview

    Modern manual transmissions installed in heavy-duty, over-the-road (OTR)TRUCKSPOSESIGNIlCANTCHALLENGESTOLUBRICANTS4ODAYSMANUALTRANSMISSIONLUBRICANTSMUSTPROTECTHEAVILYLOADEDGEARSBEARINGSANDOTHERCRITICALCOM -

    PONENTSFROMWEARANDTHEEFFECTSOFTHERMALBREAKDOWNTHROUGHOUTEXTENDEDMILEDRAININTERVALS,UBRICANTSINSTALLEDIN/42APPLICATIONSINCAPABLEof meeting these requirements are largely considered outdated and may lead toCOSTLYREPAIRS

    Objective$ETERMINEIF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDESTHEHIGHLEVELOFPROTECTIONREQUIREDOFMANUALTRANSMISSIONSINSTALLEDINHEAVYDUTYLONGHAULmEETAPPLICATIONSPRACTICINGMILE

    DRAININTERVALS

    Methodology!-3/),PARTNEREDWITH3UPERIOR7ISBASED*EFF&OSTER4RUCKINGWHICHHAULSPETROLEUMAGGREGATEFOREST

    PRODUCTSANDOTHERFREIGHTTHROUGHOUTTHECONTIGUOUSSTATESANDALL#ANADIANPROVINCES4HEmEETPRIMARILY

    HAULSFULLYLOADEDTRAILERSTHROUGHHOTANDCOLDTEMPERATUREEXTREMES6EHICLESROUTINELYENCOUNTER

    DEMANDINGDRIVINGCONDITIONSINCLUDINGSTOPANDGOCITYTRAFlCANDSTEEPINCLINESCREATINGTHEIDEAL

    ENVIRONMENTFORTESTINGTRANSMISSIONmUIDS

    "EGINNING*ULY!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILWASINSTALLEDINNEWMODELYEARAND+ENWORTHTRUCKSEQUIPPEDWITH%ATONMANUALTRANSMISSIONS4HETRUCKSWEREUSEDBY

    &OSTER4RUCKINGBETWEENANDDURINGWHICHOILSAMPLESWERECOLLECTEDFROMACROSSSECTIONOFVEHICLESATVARIOUSMILEAGEINTERVALS/ILSAMPLESWEREALSOCOLLECTEDFROM/42TRUCKSEQUIPPEDWITHTRANS-

    MISSIONSFACTORYlLLEDWITHANORIGINALEQUIPMENTMANUFACTURER/%-3!%TRANSMISSIONOIL4HETRUCKS

    OPERATEDINNEARLYIDENTICALCONDITIONSTOTHETRUCKSUSING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILANDTHEOILSAMPLESDRAWNHELPEDESTABLISHAPERFORMANCEBENCHMARKAGAINSTWHICHTOCOMPARETHE

    PERFORMANCEOFTHE!-3/),PRODUCT/ILANALYSISWASCONDUCTEDACCORDINGTO!34-METHODOLOGYTO

    DETERMINEVISCOSITYRETENTION!34-$IRONANDCOPPERWEARMETALSCONTENT!34-$ANDTOTALACIDNUMBER!34-$

    4HETRANSMISSIONFROMUNITWASRANDOMLYSELECTEDANDREMOVEDFROMSERVICEFOLLOWINGMILESINSERVICEONASINGLEOILCHANGE)TWASTHENDISASSEMBLEDANDRATEDFORWEARSLUDGEANDOTHERDISTRESSBYAN

    !34-CALIBRATEDRATER4HISPAPERDISPLAYSOILANALYSISRESULTSFORBOTH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILANDTHE/%-FACTORYlLLTRANSMISSIONOILASWELLASPHOTOGRAPHICRESULTSANDANALYSISOFTHE

    TRANSMISSIONDISASSEMBLY

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    3/20

    Page 3

    Oil Analysis Viscosi ty RetentionThe severe operational environment inside heavy-duty manual transmissions can cause permanent viscosity

    LOSSDUETOMECHANICALSHEAR%XCESSIVEVISCOSITYLOSSIMPAIRSTHEOILSABILITYTOFORMAPROTECTIVELUBRICATINGlLMBETWEENMETALPARTS

    Transmission Oil Viscosity (ASTM D-445)

    Results!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILRESISTEDSHEARANDVISCOSITYLOSSASEFFECTIVELYASOR

    BETTERTHANTHE3!%/%-OIL!STHESERVICEINTERVALPROGRESSEDTHEVISCOSITYOFTHE!-3/),PRODUCTCONTINUEDONLYAGRADUALDOWNWARDPROGRESSION4HEOILMAINTAINEDAPROTECTIVELUBRICATINGlLMTHROUGHOUT

    ITSSERVICELIFE

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    4/20

    Page 4

    Oil Analysis Iron Content3OMEIRONCONTENTINTRANSMISSIONOILISNORMAL%LEVATEDLEVELSHOWEVERAREANINDICATIONGEARSORBEARINGS

    ARESUFFERINGABNORMALWEAR

    Transmiss ion Wear Metal (Iron) (ASTM D-5185)

    Results!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILEFFECTIVELYLIMITEDIRONWEARMETALGENERATIONWITHIRONCONTENTREMAININGLOWFOLLOWINGMILESINSERVICE2ESULTSARECONSISTENTWITHTHE/%-FACTORYlLLOIL

    ANDINDICATE!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILLIMITEDMETALTOMETALCONTACTANDMETTHENEEDSOFHEAVYDUTY/42TRUCKSPRACTICINGMILEDRAININTERVALS

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    5/20

    Page 5

    Oil Analysis Copper Content4HE%ATONTRANSMISSIONSMODEL&2/#AND24,/!lLLEDWITH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE

    3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILUSEDINTHISSTUDYCONTAINSEVERALPOTENTIALSOURCESOFCOPPERWEARPARTICLES

    #OPPERPARTICLESINTHETRANSMISSIONmUIDCANBEANINDICATORWEARISTAKINGPLACE

    Transmiss ion Wear Metal (Copper) (ASTM D-5185)

    Results#OPPERCONTENTIN!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILREMAINEDLOWTHROUGHOUTTHETEST

    INTERVALANDCOMPAREDFAVORABLYTOTHEFACTORYlLLmUID!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILlimited copper wear metal generation in each transmission throughout the entire test interval, demonstrating

    THEOILPROTECTSCOMPONENTSCONTAININGYELLOWMETALS

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    6/20

    Page 6

    Oil Analysis Total Acid Number (TAN)4!.ISAMEASUREOFTHEOILSOXIDATIVESTABILITY!LUBRICANTS4!.SHOULDINCREASEGRADUALLYASTHESERVICE

    INTERVALPROGRESSES3HARPINCREASESAREANINDICATORTHELUBRICANTISREACHINGITSCONDEMNATIONLIMIT

    SAE 50 Long-Life Synthetic Transmiss ion Oil Delta TAN

    Results$ELTA4!.INDICATESTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEEN4!.OFUSEDOILCOMPAREDTO4!.OFTHESAMEOILWHENNEW)T

    DEMONSTRATESTHEPERFORMANCEOFTHEOILINDEPENDENTOFADDITIONALDATATHUSVALUESFORTHE/%-mUIDARENOT

    GIVEN!NINCREASEOFTOOVERTHE3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILBASELINEVALUEISOFTENUSEDASANINDICATORTHATTHEOILISAPPROACHINGITSCONDEMNATIONLIMIT4!.REMAINEDSTABLETHROUGHOUTTHE

    SERVICEINTERVALANDSHOWEDNOAPPRECIABLEINCREASE6ALUESINDICATE!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILISCAPABLEOFSAFELYPROVIDINGMILESERVICEINTERVALS

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    7/20

    Page 7

    Transmission Component Ratings4OFURTHEREVALUATETHEPERFORMANCEOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILTHETRANSMIS-

    SIONINUNITWASDISASSEMBLEDAFTERACCUMULATINGMILESONTHEOILANDEVALUATEDBYAN!34-CALIBRATEDRATER%ACHCOMPONENTWASASSIGNEDAMERITRATINGONASCALEFROMTOWITHREPRESENTING

    THEABSENCEOFDISTRESSANDREPRESENTINGCATASTROPHICDISTRESSSEETABLEBELOW2ATINGCRITERIAASDElNEDin ASTM Distress Rating Manual 21WEREUSEDANDINCLUDEBURNISHWEARRIPPLINGRIDGINGPITTINGSPALLINGSCORINGDISCOLORATIONCORROSIONCHIPPINGANDSLUDGESEETABLEONPAGEFORDElNITIONS4HEFOLLOWING

    SECTIONSDISPLAYTHERESULTS

    Numerical Distress Rating Scales for Gears*

    Value Level of Distress

    None

    Trace

    8 4RACE,IGHT

    ,IGHT

    ,IGHT-EDIUM

    5 Medium

    4 Medium-Heavy

    3 Heavy

    Heavy to Catastrophic

    5PTOOFTHEGEARTOOTHSURFACENOTRATABLE

    Heavy to Catastrophic

    'REATERTHANANDLESSTHANOFTHEGEARTOOTHSURFACENOTRATABLE

    0 Catastrophic

    OFTHEGEARTOOTHSURFACENOTRATABLE

    * Applies to all components in this document

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    8/20

    Page 8

    'EAR2ATING$ENITIONS

    Merit Rating $ElNITIONOFADISTRESSORDEPOSITCONDITIONINNUMERICALTERMSONA

    DESCENDINGSCALEFROMTENWHICHREPRESENTSABSENCEOFDISTRESS

    Burnish An alteration of the original manufactured surface ranging from a dull to a

    BRIGHTLYPOLISHEDCONDITION

    Wear The removal of metal, without evidence of surface fatigue or scoring,

    resulting in partial or complete elimination of tool or grinding marks and/orDEVELOPMENTOFADISCERNIBLESHOULDERRIDGEATTHEBOTTOMOFTHECONTACT

    AREANEARTHEROOTORATTHETOEORHEELENDOFTHEPINIONTOOTHCONTACTAREA

    Abrasive Wear 7EARCAUSEDBYLAPPINGOFMATINGSURFACESBYlNEPARTICLESSUSPENDEDINLUBRICANTFUELAIRORIMBEDDEDINASURFACE

    Adhesive Wear 7EARCAUSEDBYSHEARINGOFJUNCTIONSFORMEDBETWEENOPERATINGSURFACES

    INDIRECTMETALTOMETALCONTACTSHEAREDOFFPARTICLESEITHERREMAINAFlXEDTOEITHERTHEMATINGSURFACESORACTASWEARPARTICLESBETWEENTHESURFACES

    Rippling An alteration of the tooth surface to give an appearance of a more or less

    REGULARPATTERNRESEMBLINGRIPPLESONWATERORlSHSCALES

    NOTE:%XAMINATIONOFTHESURFACEWITHOBLIQUELIGHTINGUSUALLYISNECESSARYTOSHOWTHISCONDITION

    Ridging An alteration of the tooth surface to give a series of parallel raised and

    polished ridges running in the direction of the sliding motion, either partially

    ORCOMPLETELYACROSSTHETOOTHSURFACES

    Pitting 3MALLIRREGULARCAVITIESINTHETOOTHSURFACELESSTHANSQUAREMILLIMETERRESULTINGFROMTHEBREAKINGOUTOFSURFACEMETAL

    Spalling 4HEBREAKINGOUTOFmAKESORIRREGULARAREAOFTHETOOTHSURFACESQUAREMILLIMETERORLARGERACONDITIONMOREEXTENSIVETHANPITTING

    Scoring 4HEDISPLACEMENTOFMETALBYLOCALMOMENTARYWELDINGFROMTHEGEARTOOTHRESULTINGINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFAMATTEORFROSTEDDULLSURFACE

    Discoloration !NYALTERATIONINTHENORMALCOLOROFRATEDSURFACES

    Corrosion !GENERALALTERATIONOFTHElNISHEDSURFACESBYDISCOLORATIONACCOMPANIEDBYROUGHENINGNOTATTRIBUTABLETOMECHANICALACTION2USTISASPECIALCASE

    OFCORROSION

    Chipping Ring and pinion gears A condition caused in the manufacturing process inwhich a small irregular cavity is present only at the face/crown edge inter-

    FACE4HEEDGECHIPPINGPHENOMENONOCCURSWHENSUFlCIENTFATIGUECYCLESaccumulate after tooth surface wear relieves the compressive residual stress

    ONTHETOOTHPROlLESSIDEOFTHEPROlLETOTOPLANDINTERFACE#HIPPINGWITHINMMOFTHEFACECROWNEDGEINTERFACEISTOBECALLEDCHIPPINGNOTPITTINGSPALLING

    Sludge !DEPOSITCOMPOSEDOFORGANICRESIDUEWHICHMAYCONTAINFUELLUBRICANT

    ANDORWATER3UCHDEPOSITSWILLBEFOUNDONSURFACESOPERATINGATBULKUNITTEMPERATUREANDEXPOSEDTOFUELSANDORLUBRICANTS4HESEDEPOSITSDONOT

    DRAINBUTCANBEREMOVEDBYWIPINGWITHMODERATEPRESSUREUSINGACLEANDRYSOFTLINTFREEWIPINGMATERIAL$EPOSITSRATEDASSLUDGEMAYVARYIN

    CHARACTERISTICSnCOLORTRANSPARENCYANDCONSISTENCY

    Table taken from!34-$ISTRESS2ATING-ANUAL

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    9/20

    Page 9

    Mainshaft Overdrive Gear

    Condition Drive Side Coast Side

    Burnish Dull Dull

    Wear 8 8

    Rippling

    Ridging

    Pitting

    Spalling

    Scoring

    Discoloration

    Corrosion

    Results-ERITRATINGSFORBURNISHAREREPRESENTEDBYQUALITATIVETERMSRANGINGFROMdullto brightly polished

    'REATERLEVELSOFWEARTOGEARTEETHAREDENOTEDBYBRIGHTERLEVELSOFBURNISH4HEMAINSHAFTOVERDRIVEGEAR

    EARNEDABURNISHRATINGOFdullINDICATINGVERYLOWWEAR4HEGEAREARNEDPERFECTMERITRATINGSFOR

    RIPPLINGRIDGINGPITTINGSPALLINGSCORINGANDCORROSION2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISE

    VERYHIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVELOFPROTECTION

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    10/20

    Page 10

    Condition Drive Side Coast Side

    Burnish Medium Bright Medium Bright

    Wear 8 8

    Rippling

    Ridging

    Pitting

    Spalling

    Scoring

    Discoloration

    Corrosion

    Upper Right Countershaft Overdrive Gear

    Results4HEUPPERRIGHTCOUNTERSHAFTOVERDRIVEGEARSHOWEDNOSIGNSOFEXCESSIVEDISTRESSANDACHIEVEDPERFECT

    MERITRATINGSINSIXOFEIGHTAPPLICABLECATEGORIES2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISEVERYHIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVEL

    OFPROTECTION

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    11/20

    Page 11

    Condition Drive Side Coast Side

    Burnish Medium Bright Medium Bright

    Wear 8 8

    Rippling

    Ridging

    Pitting

    Spalling

    Scoring

    Discoloration

    Corrosion

    Mainshaft Input Drive Gear

    Results4HEMAINSHAFTINPUTDRIVEGEARSHOWEDNOSIGNSOFEXCESSIVEDISTRESSANDACHIEVEDPERFECTMERIT

    RATINGSINSIXOFEIGHTAPPLICABLECATEGORIES2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISEVERYHIGH

    DEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVEL

    OFPROTECTION

    CLOSEUP

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    12/20

    Page 12

    Condition Drive Side Coast Side

    Burnish Medium Bright Medium Bright

    Wear 8 8

    Rippling

    Ridging

    Pitting

    Spalling

    Scoring

    Discoloration

    Corrosion

    Upper Right Countershaft Mating Gear

    Results!GAINTHEUPPERRIGHTCOUNTERSHAFTMATINGGEARSHOWEDNOSIGNSOFEXCESSIVEDISTRESSANDACHIEVEDPERFECT

    MERITRATINGSINSIXOFEIGHTAPPLICABLECATEGORIES2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISEVERY

    HIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVEL

    OFPROTECTION

    CLOSEUP

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    13/20

    Page 13

    Upper Right Front Countershaft

    Bearing Merit RatingsCondition Cups Rollers

    Wear 8 8

    Scoring

    Pitting

    Spalling

    Discoloration 8 8

    Corrosion

    Roller End Wear - 8

    Upper Right Front Countershaft Bearing

    Results(EAVILYLOADEDHIGHTEMPERATUREOPERATIONCANRESULTINBEARINGDISTRESSANDULTIMATELYFAILURE)NTHEAREAS

    OFSCORINGPITTINGSPALLINGANDCORROSIONTHEUPPERRIGHTFRONTCOUNTERSHAFTBEARINGRECEIVEDPERFECTMERIT

    RATINGSOFINDICATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDSUPERIORCRITICAL

    COMPONENTPROTECTION

    Merit ratings of 8 (trace-light)FORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONARELIKEWISEHIGH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YN-

    THETIC4RANSMISSION/ILDEMONSTRATEDEXCELLENTPROTECTION

    ROLLERS

    INNER RACE

    OUTER RACE

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    14/20

    Page 14

    Output Shaft Bearing

    Results4HEOUTPUTSHAFTBEARINGEARNEDSIMILARLYHIGHMERITRATINGSCOMPAREDTOTHEUPPERRIGHTFRONTCOUNTERSHAFT

    BEARING4HECUPSANDROLLERSACHIEVEDPERFECTMERITRATINGSFORSCORINGSPALLINGANDCORROSION2ATINGSOFFORPITTINGtrace) and 8 for wear (trace-lightWEREALSOHIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE

    3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILMAINTAINEDADURABLELUBRICATINGlLM$ISCOLORATIONWASKEPTTOLOWLEVELSFURTHERCONlRMINGTHEPROTECTIONPROVIDEDBYTHELUBRICANT

    * Disassembly damage on output bearing cup

    Output Shaft BearingMerit Ratings

    Condition Cups Rollers

    Wear 8 8

    Scoring

    Pitting

    Spalling

    Discoloration 8

    Corrosion

    Roller End Wear - 8

    ROLLERS

    OUTERRACE

    INNERRACE

    NOT ABEARINGSURFACE

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    15/20

    Page 15

    Auxiliary Sliding Clutch

    Results4HEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHLOCKSINHIGHANDLOWRANGEGEARSSUBJECTINGITTOREPEATEDSLIDINGMOTION

    #ONSEQUENTLYITREPRESENTSANAREASUSCEPTIBLETOHIGHLEVELSOFWEARANDDISTRESS

    4HEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHEARNEDAlight-mediumMERITRATINGOFFORWEAR4HERATINGFORCHIPPINGWASVERYhigh and denotes a traceAMOUNTOFMETALREMOVAL!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILLIM-

    ITEDWEARTOTHEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHEFFECTIVELYDESPITETHECOMPONENTSCHALLENGINGOPERATINGCONDITIONS

    3LUDGEWASLIKEWISEMINIMIZEDDEMONSTRATINGTHEABILITYOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSIO

    /ILTORESISTTHERMALDEGRADATIONANDHELPCOMPONENTSREMAINCLEANTHROUGHOUTAMILEDRAININTERVAL

    CLOSEUP

    Auxiliary SlidingClutch Merit Ratings

    Condition

    Wear

    Chipping

    Sludge 8

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    16/20

    Page 16

    Direct Sliding Clutch

    ResultsDirect sliding clutches lock and unlock the appropriate gears to their shafts depending on the gear the driver

    SELECTS,IKETHEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHTHEYROUTINELYENCOUNTERSLIDINGMOTIONANDAREPRONETOHIGHLEVELSOWEARANDDISTRESS

    4HEDIRECTSLIDINGCLUTCHPICTUREDREPRESENTSATYPICALEXAMPLEFROMTHETRANSMISSIONANDEARNEDAWEAR

    MERITRATINGOFINDICATINGlightSURFACEFATIGUEANDMETALREMOVAL4HERATINGISCONSISTENTWITHTHEELEVATEDDEMANDREQUIREDFORWEARPROTECTIONOFCLUTCHCOMPONENTSINHEAVYDUTY/42APPLICATIONS4HERATINGFOR

    SLUDGEREmECTSAlightAMOUNTANDCONlRMS!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDA

    HIGHLEVELOFPROTECTION

    CLOSEUP

    Direct Sliding ClutchMerit Ratings

    Condition

    Wear

    Sludge

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    17/20

    Page 17

    Synchronizer Assembly Ratings

    Results&ORTHETRANSMISSIONTOSHIFTBETWEENLOWANDHIGHRANGETHESYNCHRONIZERASSEMBLYMUSTlRSTMATCHTHE

    SPEEDSOFTHEAPPROPRIATEGEARSTOPROVIDESMOOTHGEARENGAGEMENT4HISPROCESSREQUIRESTHElBERMATERIA

    ONTHESYNCHRONIZERRINGSTOBEARFRICTIONREPEATEDLYPROVIDINGAMPLEOPPORTUNITYFORWEAR4HElBERMATE-

    RIALONTHELOWRANGERINGEARNEDAMERITRATINGOFINDICATINGONLYAtraceAMOUNTOFWEAR-ERITRATINGSFOR

    BOTHTHEHIGHANDLOWRANGERINGSTHEMSELVESWERELIKEWISEHIGHINTHEAREASOFWEARANDSLUDGEINDICATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDAHIGHLEVELOFPROTECTION

    CLOSEUP

    Synchronizer Ring High Range

    Synchronizer Ring Low Range

    Synchronizer RingsMerit Ratings

    Condition High Range Low Range

    Wear 8 8

    Sludge

    Discoloration Not Rated 8

    Fiber Material Not Rated -ATTED

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    18/20

    Page 18

    Range Shi ft Yoke

    Results4HERANGESHIFTYOKESLIDESONTOTHESYNCHRONIZERASSEMBLYANDISRESPONSIBLEFORENGAGINGEITHERHIGHORLOW

    RANGE!SARESULTITENCOUNTERSSLIDINGCONTACTREPEATEDLYANDREPRESENTSANAREAPRONETOWEAR!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILLIMITEDMETALTOMETALCONTACTANDWEARTOtrace-lightamounts

    ANDPROVIDEDSUPERIORPROTECTION4HEMERITRATINGFORDISCOLORATIONWASSIMILARLYHIGH

    CLOSEUPS

    Range Shi ft Yoke

    Merit Ratings

    Condition

    Wear 8

    Discoloration 8

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    19/20

    Page 19

    Output Assembly

    ResultsThe output yoke and seal undergo nearly constant rotational stress at varying speeds and loads, presenting

    THEOPPORTUNITYFORELEVATEDWEAR4HEOUTPUTSEALEARNEDAWEARMERITRATINGOFINDICATINGtrace-light

    DISTRESS4HESEALALSOMAINTAINEDPERCENTGREASEPACKINGDEMONSTRATINGNOLEAKINGTHROUGHOUTTHE

    TRANSMISSIONSSERVICEINTERVAL4HEOUTPUTYOKEACHIEVEDSIMILARLYHIGHMERITRATINGSFORWEARlight) and

    sludge (trace

    Speedo Rotor Assembly Output Seal

    Normal conditiondue to exposure

    to environment.

    Output Yoke & Seal

    Merit Ratings

    Condition Yoke Seal

    Wear 8

    Sludge -

    Grease Packing -

    OUTPUTSHAFT

    OPENING

  • 7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications

    20/20

    Conclusion

    5SEDOILANALYSISRESULTSANDACOMPLETEVISUALINSPECTIONOFCOMPONENTSFROMATRANSMISSIONBYAN!34-

    CALIBRATEDRATERDEMONSTRATETHEEFFECTIVENESSOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILINOVERTHEROADAPPLICATIONSPRACTICINGMILEDRAININTERVALS4HE!-3/),TRANSMISSIONOILRESISTED

    SHEAREFFECTIVELYDESPITEMILESOFRIGOROUSUSE7EARPROTECTIONWASLIKEWISESUPERIORSAMPLESOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILCONTAINEDVERYLOWLEVELSOFIRONANDCOPPERWEAR

    PARTICLESINDICATINGITMAINTAINEDITSPROTECTIVELUBRICATINGlLMTHROUGHOUTSERVICE4OTALACIDNUMBERALSO

    REMAINEDSTABLETHROUGHOUTSERVICE

    !COMPLETETRANSMISSIONDISASSEMBLYANDVISUALINSPECTIONOFFERSFURTHERPROOFOFPERFORMANCE"EARINGS

    RECEIVEDPERFECTMERITRATINGSOFFORSCORINGSPALLINGANDCORROSIONINDICATINGACOMPLETEABSENCEOFDIS-

    TRESS'EARSEARNEDPERFECTRATINGSINTHEAREASOFRIPPLINGRIDGINGPITTINGSPALLINGSCORINGANDCORROSIONRatings for other components prone to elevated wear, including the high- and low-range synchronizer rings

    ANDTHEOUTPUTSEALARELIKEWISEHIGH.ONEOFTHETRANSMISSIONSOPERATINGWITH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILDEMONSTRATEDANYLEAKINGFROMANYOFTHESEALS4HE!34-CALIBRATEDRATER

    DEEMEDALLINSPECTEDCOMPONENTSSUITABLEFORCONTINUEDUSE

    2ESULTSOFTHISlELDSTUDYPROVE!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDESEXCELLENTPROTECTIONINMODERNHEAVILYLOADEDOVERTHEROADMANUALTRANSMISSIONSTHROUGHOUTEXTENDEDMILE

    DRAININTERVALS

    #ONTACTYOUR!-3/),$EALERFORMOREINFORMATIONON!-3/),PRODUCTSORTOPLACEANORDER9OUMAYALSOORDERDIRECTBYCALLING!-3/),).#ATANDPROVIDINGTHEREFERRALNUMBERLISTEDHERE

    Referral #_________________________________