AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
-
Upload
amsoildealer -
Category
Documents
-
view
217 -
download
0
Transcript of AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
1/20
F I E L D S T U D Y
SAE 50 Long-Life Synthetic
Transmission Oil Field Study inOver-the-Road Applications
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
2/20
Page 2
Overview
Modern manual transmissions installed in heavy-duty, over-the-road (OTR)TRUCKSPOSESIGNIlCANTCHALLENGESTOLUBRICANTS4ODAYSMANUALTRANSMISSIONLUBRICANTSMUSTPROTECTHEAVILYLOADEDGEARSBEARINGSANDOTHERCRITICALCOM -
PONENTSFROMWEARANDTHEEFFECTSOFTHERMALBREAKDOWNTHROUGHOUTEXTENDEDMILEDRAININTERVALS,UBRICANTSINSTALLEDIN/42APPLICATIONSINCAPABLEof meeting these requirements are largely considered outdated and may lead toCOSTLYREPAIRS
Objective$ETERMINEIF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDESTHEHIGHLEVELOFPROTECTIONREQUIREDOFMANUALTRANSMISSIONSINSTALLEDINHEAVYDUTYLONGHAULmEETAPPLICATIONSPRACTICINGMILE
DRAININTERVALS
Methodology!-3/),PARTNEREDWITH3UPERIOR7ISBASED*EFF&OSTER4RUCKINGWHICHHAULSPETROLEUMAGGREGATEFOREST
PRODUCTSANDOTHERFREIGHTTHROUGHOUTTHECONTIGUOUSSTATESANDALL#ANADIANPROVINCES4HEmEETPRIMARILY
HAULSFULLYLOADEDTRAILERSTHROUGHHOTANDCOLDTEMPERATUREEXTREMES6EHICLESROUTINELYENCOUNTER
DEMANDINGDRIVINGCONDITIONSINCLUDINGSTOPANDGOCITYTRAFlCANDSTEEPINCLINESCREATINGTHEIDEAL
ENVIRONMENTFORTESTINGTRANSMISSIONmUIDS
"EGINNING*ULY!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILWASINSTALLEDINNEWMODELYEARAND+ENWORTHTRUCKSEQUIPPEDWITH%ATONMANUALTRANSMISSIONS4HETRUCKSWEREUSEDBY
&OSTER4RUCKINGBETWEENANDDURINGWHICHOILSAMPLESWERECOLLECTEDFROMACROSSSECTIONOFVEHICLESATVARIOUSMILEAGEINTERVALS/ILSAMPLESWEREALSOCOLLECTEDFROM/42TRUCKSEQUIPPEDWITHTRANS-
MISSIONSFACTORYlLLEDWITHANORIGINALEQUIPMENTMANUFACTURER/%-3!%TRANSMISSIONOIL4HETRUCKS
OPERATEDINNEARLYIDENTICALCONDITIONSTOTHETRUCKSUSING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILANDTHEOILSAMPLESDRAWNHELPEDESTABLISHAPERFORMANCEBENCHMARKAGAINSTWHICHTOCOMPARETHE
PERFORMANCEOFTHE!-3/),PRODUCT/ILANALYSISWASCONDUCTEDACCORDINGTO!34-METHODOLOGYTO
DETERMINEVISCOSITYRETENTION!34-$IRONANDCOPPERWEARMETALSCONTENT!34-$ANDTOTALACIDNUMBER!34-$
4HETRANSMISSIONFROMUNITWASRANDOMLYSELECTEDANDREMOVEDFROMSERVICEFOLLOWINGMILESINSERVICEONASINGLEOILCHANGE)TWASTHENDISASSEMBLEDANDRATEDFORWEARSLUDGEANDOTHERDISTRESSBYAN
!34-CALIBRATEDRATER4HISPAPERDISPLAYSOILANALYSISRESULTSFORBOTH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILANDTHE/%-FACTORYlLLTRANSMISSIONOILASWELLASPHOTOGRAPHICRESULTSANDANALYSISOFTHE
TRANSMISSIONDISASSEMBLY
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
3/20
Page 3
Oil Analysis Viscosi ty RetentionThe severe operational environment inside heavy-duty manual transmissions can cause permanent viscosity
LOSSDUETOMECHANICALSHEAR%XCESSIVEVISCOSITYLOSSIMPAIRSTHEOILSABILITYTOFORMAPROTECTIVELUBRICATINGlLMBETWEENMETALPARTS
Transmission Oil Viscosity (ASTM D-445)
Results!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILRESISTEDSHEARANDVISCOSITYLOSSASEFFECTIVELYASOR
BETTERTHANTHE3!%/%-OIL!STHESERVICEINTERVALPROGRESSEDTHEVISCOSITYOFTHE!-3/),PRODUCTCONTINUEDONLYAGRADUALDOWNWARDPROGRESSION4HEOILMAINTAINEDAPROTECTIVELUBRICATINGlLMTHROUGHOUT
ITSSERVICELIFE
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
4/20
Page 4
Oil Analysis Iron Content3OMEIRONCONTENTINTRANSMISSIONOILISNORMAL%LEVATEDLEVELSHOWEVERAREANINDICATIONGEARSORBEARINGS
ARESUFFERINGABNORMALWEAR
Transmiss ion Wear Metal (Iron) (ASTM D-5185)
Results!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILEFFECTIVELYLIMITEDIRONWEARMETALGENERATIONWITHIRONCONTENTREMAININGLOWFOLLOWINGMILESINSERVICE2ESULTSARECONSISTENTWITHTHE/%-FACTORYlLLOIL
ANDINDICATE!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILLIMITEDMETALTOMETALCONTACTANDMETTHENEEDSOFHEAVYDUTY/42TRUCKSPRACTICINGMILEDRAININTERVALS
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
5/20
Page 5
Oil Analysis Copper Content4HE%ATONTRANSMISSIONSMODEL&2/#AND24,/!lLLEDWITH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE
3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILUSEDINTHISSTUDYCONTAINSEVERALPOTENTIALSOURCESOFCOPPERWEARPARTICLES
#OPPERPARTICLESINTHETRANSMISSIONmUIDCANBEANINDICATORWEARISTAKINGPLACE
Transmiss ion Wear Metal (Copper) (ASTM D-5185)
Results#OPPERCONTENTIN!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILREMAINEDLOWTHROUGHOUTTHETEST
INTERVALANDCOMPAREDFAVORABLYTOTHEFACTORYlLLmUID!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILlimited copper wear metal generation in each transmission throughout the entire test interval, demonstrating
THEOILPROTECTSCOMPONENTSCONTAININGYELLOWMETALS
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
6/20
Page 6
Oil Analysis Total Acid Number (TAN)4!.ISAMEASUREOFTHEOILSOXIDATIVESTABILITY!LUBRICANTS4!.SHOULDINCREASEGRADUALLYASTHESERVICE
INTERVALPROGRESSES3HARPINCREASESAREANINDICATORTHELUBRICANTISREACHINGITSCONDEMNATIONLIMIT
SAE 50 Long-Life Synthetic Transmiss ion Oil Delta TAN
Results$ELTA4!.INDICATESTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEEN4!.OFUSEDOILCOMPAREDTO4!.OFTHESAMEOILWHENNEW)T
DEMONSTRATESTHEPERFORMANCEOFTHEOILINDEPENDENTOFADDITIONALDATATHUSVALUESFORTHE/%-mUIDARENOT
GIVEN!NINCREASEOFTOOVERTHE3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILBASELINEVALUEISOFTENUSEDASANINDICATORTHATTHEOILISAPPROACHINGITSCONDEMNATIONLIMIT4!.REMAINEDSTABLETHROUGHOUTTHE
SERVICEINTERVALANDSHOWEDNOAPPRECIABLEINCREASE6ALUESINDICATE!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILISCAPABLEOFSAFELYPROVIDINGMILESERVICEINTERVALS
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
7/20
Page 7
Transmission Component Ratings4OFURTHEREVALUATETHEPERFORMANCEOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILTHETRANSMIS-
SIONINUNITWASDISASSEMBLEDAFTERACCUMULATINGMILESONTHEOILANDEVALUATEDBYAN!34-CALIBRATEDRATER%ACHCOMPONENTWASASSIGNEDAMERITRATINGONASCALEFROMTOWITHREPRESENTING
THEABSENCEOFDISTRESSANDREPRESENTINGCATASTROPHICDISTRESSSEETABLEBELOW2ATINGCRITERIAASDElNEDin ASTM Distress Rating Manual 21WEREUSEDANDINCLUDEBURNISHWEARRIPPLINGRIDGINGPITTINGSPALLINGSCORINGDISCOLORATIONCORROSIONCHIPPINGANDSLUDGESEETABLEONPAGEFORDElNITIONS4HEFOLLOWING
SECTIONSDISPLAYTHERESULTS
Numerical Distress Rating Scales for Gears*
Value Level of Distress
None
Trace
8 4RACE,IGHT
,IGHT
,IGHT-EDIUM
5 Medium
4 Medium-Heavy
3 Heavy
Heavy to Catastrophic
5PTOOFTHEGEARTOOTHSURFACENOTRATABLE
Heavy to Catastrophic
'REATERTHANANDLESSTHANOFTHEGEARTOOTHSURFACENOTRATABLE
0 Catastrophic
OFTHEGEARTOOTHSURFACENOTRATABLE
* Applies to all components in this document
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
8/20
Page 8
'EAR2ATING$ENITIONS
Merit Rating $ElNITIONOFADISTRESSORDEPOSITCONDITIONINNUMERICALTERMSONA
DESCENDINGSCALEFROMTENWHICHREPRESENTSABSENCEOFDISTRESS
Burnish An alteration of the original manufactured surface ranging from a dull to a
BRIGHTLYPOLISHEDCONDITION
Wear The removal of metal, without evidence of surface fatigue or scoring,
resulting in partial or complete elimination of tool or grinding marks and/orDEVELOPMENTOFADISCERNIBLESHOULDERRIDGEATTHEBOTTOMOFTHECONTACT
AREANEARTHEROOTORATTHETOEORHEELENDOFTHEPINIONTOOTHCONTACTAREA
Abrasive Wear 7EARCAUSEDBYLAPPINGOFMATINGSURFACESBYlNEPARTICLESSUSPENDEDINLUBRICANTFUELAIRORIMBEDDEDINASURFACE
Adhesive Wear 7EARCAUSEDBYSHEARINGOFJUNCTIONSFORMEDBETWEENOPERATINGSURFACES
INDIRECTMETALTOMETALCONTACTSHEAREDOFFPARTICLESEITHERREMAINAFlXEDTOEITHERTHEMATINGSURFACESORACTASWEARPARTICLESBETWEENTHESURFACES
Rippling An alteration of the tooth surface to give an appearance of a more or less
REGULARPATTERNRESEMBLINGRIPPLESONWATERORlSHSCALES
NOTE:%XAMINATIONOFTHESURFACEWITHOBLIQUELIGHTINGUSUALLYISNECESSARYTOSHOWTHISCONDITION
Ridging An alteration of the tooth surface to give a series of parallel raised and
polished ridges running in the direction of the sliding motion, either partially
ORCOMPLETELYACROSSTHETOOTHSURFACES
Pitting 3MALLIRREGULARCAVITIESINTHETOOTHSURFACELESSTHANSQUAREMILLIMETERRESULTINGFROMTHEBREAKINGOUTOFSURFACEMETAL
Spalling 4HEBREAKINGOUTOFmAKESORIRREGULARAREAOFTHETOOTHSURFACESQUAREMILLIMETERORLARGERACONDITIONMOREEXTENSIVETHANPITTING
Scoring 4HEDISPLACEMENTOFMETALBYLOCALMOMENTARYWELDINGFROMTHEGEARTOOTHRESULTINGINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFAMATTEORFROSTEDDULLSURFACE
Discoloration !NYALTERATIONINTHENORMALCOLOROFRATEDSURFACES
Corrosion !GENERALALTERATIONOFTHElNISHEDSURFACESBYDISCOLORATIONACCOMPANIEDBYROUGHENINGNOTATTRIBUTABLETOMECHANICALACTION2USTISASPECIALCASE
OFCORROSION
Chipping Ring and pinion gears A condition caused in the manufacturing process inwhich a small irregular cavity is present only at the face/crown edge inter-
FACE4HEEDGECHIPPINGPHENOMENONOCCURSWHENSUFlCIENTFATIGUECYCLESaccumulate after tooth surface wear relieves the compressive residual stress
ONTHETOOTHPROlLESSIDEOFTHEPROlLETOTOPLANDINTERFACE#HIPPINGWITHINMMOFTHEFACECROWNEDGEINTERFACEISTOBECALLEDCHIPPINGNOTPITTINGSPALLING
Sludge !DEPOSITCOMPOSEDOFORGANICRESIDUEWHICHMAYCONTAINFUELLUBRICANT
ANDORWATER3UCHDEPOSITSWILLBEFOUNDONSURFACESOPERATINGATBULKUNITTEMPERATUREANDEXPOSEDTOFUELSANDORLUBRICANTS4HESEDEPOSITSDONOT
DRAINBUTCANBEREMOVEDBYWIPINGWITHMODERATEPRESSUREUSINGACLEANDRYSOFTLINTFREEWIPINGMATERIAL$EPOSITSRATEDASSLUDGEMAYVARYIN
CHARACTERISTICSnCOLORTRANSPARENCYANDCONSISTENCY
Table taken from!34-$ISTRESS2ATING-ANUAL
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
9/20
Page 9
Mainshaft Overdrive Gear
Condition Drive Side Coast Side
Burnish Dull Dull
Wear 8 8
Rippling
Ridging
Pitting
Spalling
Scoring
Discoloration
Corrosion
Results-ERITRATINGSFORBURNISHAREREPRESENTEDBYQUALITATIVETERMSRANGINGFROMdullto brightly polished
'REATERLEVELSOFWEARTOGEARTEETHAREDENOTEDBYBRIGHTERLEVELSOFBURNISH4HEMAINSHAFTOVERDRIVEGEAR
EARNEDABURNISHRATINGOFdullINDICATINGVERYLOWWEAR4HEGEAREARNEDPERFECTMERITRATINGSFOR
RIPPLINGRIDGINGPITTINGSPALLINGSCORINGANDCORROSION2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISE
VERYHIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVELOFPROTECTION
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
10/20
Page 10
Condition Drive Side Coast Side
Burnish Medium Bright Medium Bright
Wear 8 8
Rippling
Ridging
Pitting
Spalling
Scoring
Discoloration
Corrosion
Upper Right Countershaft Overdrive Gear
Results4HEUPPERRIGHTCOUNTERSHAFTOVERDRIVEGEARSHOWEDNOSIGNSOFEXCESSIVEDISTRESSANDACHIEVEDPERFECT
MERITRATINGSINSIXOFEIGHTAPPLICABLECATEGORIES2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISEVERYHIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVEL
OFPROTECTION
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
11/20
Page 11
Condition Drive Side Coast Side
Burnish Medium Bright Medium Bright
Wear 8 8
Rippling
Ridging
Pitting
Spalling
Scoring
Discoloration
Corrosion
Mainshaft Input Drive Gear
Results4HEMAINSHAFTINPUTDRIVEGEARSHOWEDNOSIGNSOFEXCESSIVEDISTRESSANDACHIEVEDPERFECTMERIT
RATINGSINSIXOFEIGHTAPPLICABLECATEGORIES2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISEVERYHIGH
DEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVEL
OFPROTECTION
CLOSEUP
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
12/20
Page 12
Condition Drive Side Coast Side
Burnish Medium Bright Medium Bright
Wear 8 8
Rippling
Ridging
Pitting
Spalling
Scoring
Discoloration
Corrosion
Upper Right Countershaft Mating Gear
Results!GAINTHEUPPERRIGHTCOUNTERSHAFTMATINGGEARSHOWEDNOSIGNSOFEXCESSIVEDISTRESSANDACHIEVEDPERFECT
MERITRATINGSINSIXOFEIGHTAPPLICABLECATEGORIES2ATINGSFORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONWERELIKEWISEVERY
HIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDANEXTREMELYHIGHLEVEL
OFPROTECTION
CLOSEUP
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
13/20
Page 13
Upper Right Front Countershaft
Bearing Merit RatingsCondition Cups Rollers
Wear 8 8
Scoring
Pitting
Spalling
Discoloration 8 8
Corrosion
Roller End Wear - 8
Upper Right Front Countershaft Bearing
Results(EAVILYLOADEDHIGHTEMPERATUREOPERATIONCANRESULTINBEARINGDISTRESSANDULTIMATELYFAILURE)NTHEAREAS
OFSCORINGPITTINGSPALLINGANDCORROSIONTHEUPPERRIGHTFRONTCOUNTERSHAFTBEARINGRECEIVEDPERFECTMERIT
RATINGSOFINDICATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDSUPERIORCRITICAL
COMPONENTPROTECTION
Merit ratings of 8 (trace-light)FORWEARANDDISCOLORATIONARELIKEWISEHIGH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YN-
THETIC4RANSMISSION/ILDEMONSTRATEDEXCELLENTPROTECTION
ROLLERS
INNER RACE
OUTER RACE
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
14/20
Page 14
Output Shaft Bearing
Results4HEOUTPUTSHAFTBEARINGEARNEDSIMILARLYHIGHMERITRATINGSCOMPAREDTOTHEUPPERRIGHTFRONTCOUNTERSHAFT
BEARING4HECUPSANDROLLERSACHIEVEDPERFECTMERITRATINGSFORSCORINGSPALLINGANDCORROSION2ATINGSOFFORPITTINGtrace) and 8 for wear (trace-lightWEREALSOHIGHDEMONSTRATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE
3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILMAINTAINEDADURABLELUBRICATINGlLM$ISCOLORATIONWASKEPTTOLOWLEVELSFURTHERCONlRMINGTHEPROTECTIONPROVIDEDBYTHELUBRICANT
* Disassembly damage on output bearing cup
Output Shaft BearingMerit Ratings
Condition Cups Rollers
Wear 8 8
Scoring
Pitting
Spalling
Discoloration 8
Corrosion
Roller End Wear - 8
ROLLERS
OUTERRACE
INNERRACE
NOT ABEARINGSURFACE
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
15/20
Page 15
Auxiliary Sliding Clutch
Results4HEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHLOCKSINHIGHANDLOWRANGEGEARSSUBJECTINGITTOREPEATEDSLIDINGMOTION
#ONSEQUENTLYITREPRESENTSANAREASUSCEPTIBLETOHIGHLEVELSOFWEARANDDISTRESS
4HEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHEARNEDAlight-mediumMERITRATINGOFFORWEAR4HERATINGFORCHIPPINGWASVERYhigh and denotes a traceAMOUNTOFMETALREMOVAL!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILLIM-
ITEDWEARTOTHEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHEFFECTIVELYDESPITETHECOMPONENTSCHALLENGINGOPERATINGCONDITIONS
3LUDGEWASLIKEWISEMINIMIZEDDEMONSTRATINGTHEABILITYOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSIO
/ILTORESISTTHERMALDEGRADATIONANDHELPCOMPONENTSREMAINCLEANTHROUGHOUTAMILEDRAININTERVAL
CLOSEUP
Auxiliary SlidingClutch Merit Ratings
Condition
Wear
Chipping
Sludge 8
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
16/20
Page 16
Direct Sliding Clutch
ResultsDirect sliding clutches lock and unlock the appropriate gears to their shafts depending on the gear the driver
SELECTS,IKETHEAUXILIARYSLIDINGCLUTCHTHEYROUTINELYENCOUNTERSLIDINGMOTIONANDAREPRONETOHIGHLEVELSOWEARANDDISTRESS
4HEDIRECTSLIDINGCLUTCHPICTUREDREPRESENTSATYPICALEXAMPLEFROMTHETRANSMISSIONANDEARNEDAWEAR
MERITRATINGOFINDICATINGlightSURFACEFATIGUEANDMETALREMOVAL4HERATINGISCONSISTENTWITHTHEELEVATEDDEMANDREQUIREDFORWEARPROTECTIONOFCLUTCHCOMPONENTSINHEAVYDUTY/42APPLICATIONS4HERATINGFOR
SLUDGEREmECTSAlightAMOUNTANDCONlRMS!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDA
HIGHLEVELOFPROTECTION
CLOSEUP
Direct Sliding ClutchMerit Ratings
Condition
Wear
Sludge
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
17/20
Page 17
Synchronizer Assembly Ratings
Results&ORTHETRANSMISSIONTOSHIFTBETWEENLOWANDHIGHRANGETHESYNCHRONIZERASSEMBLYMUSTlRSTMATCHTHE
SPEEDSOFTHEAPPROPRIATEGEARSTOPROVIDESMOOTHGEARENGAGEMENT4HISPROCESSREQUIRESTHElBERMATERIA
ONTHESYNCHRONIZERRINGSTOBEARFRICTIONREPEATEDLYPROVIDINGAMPLEOPPORTUNITYFORWEAR4HElBERMATE-
RIALONTHELOWRANGERINGEARNEDAMERITRATINGOFINDICATINGONLYAtraceAMOUNTOFWEAR-ERITRATINGSFOR
BOTHTHEHIGHANDLOWRANGERINGSTHEMSELVESWERELIKEWISEHIGHINTHEAREASOFWEARANDSLUDGEINDICATING!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDEDAHIGHLEVELOFPROTECTION
CLOSEUP
Synchronizer Ring High Range
Synchronizer Ring Low Range
Synchronizer RingsMerit Ratings
Condition High Range Low Range
Wear 8 8
Sludge
Discoloration Not Rated 8
Fiber Material Not Rated -ATTED
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
18/20
Page 18
Range Shi ft Yoke
Results4HERANGESHIFTYOKESLIDESONTOTHESYNCHRONIZERASSEMBLYANDISRESPONSIBLEFORENGAGINGEITHERHIGHORLOW
RANGE!SARESULTITENCOUNTERSSLIDINGCONTACTREPEATEDLYANDREPRESENTSANAREAPRONETOWEAR!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILLIMITEDMETALTOMETALCONTACTANDWEARTOtrace-lightamounts
ANDPROVIDEDSUPERIORPROTECTION4HEMERITRATINGFORDISCOLORATIONWASSIMILARLYHIGH
CLOSEUPS
Range Shi ft Yoke
Merit Ratings
Condition
Wear 8
Discoloration 8
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
19/20
Page 19
Output Assembly
ResultsThe output yoke and seal undergo nearly constant rotational stress at varying speeds and loads, presenting
THEOPPORTUNITYFORELEVATEDWEAR4HEOUTPUTSEALEARNEDAWEARMERITRATINGOFINDICATINGtrace-light
DISTRESS4HESEALALSOMAINTAINEDPERCENTGREASEPACKINGDEMONSTRATINGNOLEAKINGTHROUGHOUTTHE
TRANSMISSIONSSERVICEINTERVAL4HEOUTPUTYOKEACHIEVEDSIMILARLYHIGHMERITRATINGSFORWEARlight) and
sludge (trace
Speedo Rotor Assembly Output Seal
Normal conditiondue to exposure
to environment.
Output Yoke & Seal
Merit Ratings
Condition Yoke Seal
Wear 8
Sludge -
Grease Packing -
OUTPUTSHAFT
OPENING
-
7/29/2019 AMSOIL SAE 50 Long Life Synthetic Transmission Oil Field Study in Over the Road Applications
20/20
Conclusion
5SEDOILANALYSISRESULTSANDACOMPLETEVISUALINSPECTIONOFCOMPONENTSFROMATRANSMISSIONBYAN!34-
CALIBRATEDRATERDEMONSTRATETHEEFFECTIVENESSOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILINOVERTHEROADAPPLICATIONSPRACTICINGMILEDRAININTERVALS4HE!-3/),TRANSMISSIONOILRESISTED
SHEAREFFECTIVELYDESPITEMILESOFRIGOROUSUSE7EARPROTECTIONWASLIKEWISESUPERIORSAMPLESOF!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILCONTAINEDVERYLOWLEVELSOFIRONANDCOPPERWEAR
PARTICLESINDICATINGITMAINTAINEDITSPROTECTIVELUBRICATINGlLMTHROUGHOUTSERVICE4OTALACIDNUMBERALSO
REMAINEDSTABLETHROUGHOUTSERVICE
!COMPLETETRANSMISSIONDISASSEMBLYANDVISUALINSPECTIONOFFERSFURTHERPROOFOFPERFORMANCE"EARINGS
RECEIVEDPERFECTMERITRATINGSOFFORSCORINGSPALLINGANDCORROSIONINDICATINGACOMPLETEABSENCEOFDIS-
TRESS'EARSEARNEDPERFECTRATINGSINTHEAREASOFRIPPLINGRIDGINGPITTINGSPALLINGSCORINGANDCORROSIONRatings for other components prone to elevated wear, including the high- and low-range synchronizer rings
ANDTHEOUTPUTSEALARELIKEWISEHIGH.ONEOFTHETRANSMISSIONSOPERATINGWITH!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILDEMONSTRATEDANYLEAKINGFROMANYOFTHESEALS4HE!34-CALIBRATEDRATER
DEEMEDALLINSPECTEDCOMPONENTSSUITABLEFORCONTINUEDUSE
2ESULTSOFTHISlELDSTUDYPROVE!-3/),3!%,ONG,IFE3YNTHETIC4RANSMISSION/ILPROVIDESEXCELLENTPROTECTIONINMODERNHEAVILYLOADEDOVERTHEROADMANUALTRANSMISSIONSTHROUGHOUTEXTENDEDMILE
DRAININTERVALS
#ONTACTYOUR!-3/),$EALERFORMOREINFORMATIONON!-3/),PRODUCTSORTOPLACEANORDER9OUMAYALSOORDERDIRECTBYCALLING!-3/),).#ATANDPROVIDINGTHEREFERRALNUMBERLISTEDHERE
Referral #_________________________________