American Natives

438

Click here to load reader

Transcript of American Natives

Page 1: American Natives

NATIVOS AMERICANOSEdward S. Curtis

( 1868 – 1952 )

( click )

Page 2: American Natives

AMERICAN NATIVES Edward S. Curtis ( 1868 – 1952 )

Page 3: American Natives

Edward Sheriff Curtis, el captador de sombras, como acostumbraban a llamarle los indios que posaban para sus fotografías, nacido en Whitewater (Wisconsin) en 1868, aprendió a hacer fotos y trabajarlas en el laboratorio de forma autodidacta con una cámara que él mismo se construyó siendo todavía un adolescente. Convertido ya en afamado fotógrafo, en 1900 fue invitado, por el naturalista y especialista en temas indios George Bird Grinnell, a participar en la segunda expedición etnológica de Montana, a convivir con las tribus indias de la zona y a fotografiarlas. El mismo Grinnell le enseñó los métodos aptos para registrar científicamente la información. Comienza entonces un proyecto artístico y científico al que Curtis dedicaría toda su vida: fotografiar y estudiar de manera documentada la vida y el espíritu del indio norteamericano, antes de que se “contaminaran” con la irrupción del hombre blanco.Durante una treintena de años, Curtis transitó Estados Unidos, desde Mississippi hasta la costa del Pacífico, y de Nuevo México a Alaska, acumulando más de cuarenta mil fotografías de ochenta tribus indias, diez mil cilindros de fonógrafo, películas, infinidad de notas. Su trabajo se plasmó en la monumental obra impresa de veinte volúmenes The North American Indian. Tan ambiciosa empresa le costó su fortuna y la salud. Falleció en 1952, a la espera de viajar a las regiones amazónicas y a los Andes, sin un dólar y en buena parte olvidado.

( ESPAÑOL)

Page 4: American Natives

“La muerte de cada hombre o mujer significa el fin de alguna tradición, de algún conocimiento o rito sagrado, que sólo ellos poseen. Por lo tanto, la información que pueda ser recopilada para las futuras generaciones debe recogerse ahora o la oportunidad se perderá para siempre”

( ESPAÑOL)

Page 5: American Natives

Edward Sheriff Curtis, the collector of shadows, as the Indians used to call him to pose for his photographs, born in Whitewater (Wisconsin) in 1868, learned to take pictures and work in the laboratory so self with a camera that he himself was built still a teenager. Convert already famed photographer, was invited in 1900 by naturalist and specialist subjects Indians George Bird Grinnell, to participate in the second expedition ethnological Montana, to live with Indian tribes in the area and photographed. The Grinnell taught him the same methods suitable for recording information scientifically. Then begins a project to which artistic and scientific Curtis devoted his entire life: photographing and studying so documented life and spirit of the American Indian, before being "contaminated" with the arrival of white men.Over thirty years, Curtis travel to United States, from Mississippi to the Pacific coast, and New Mexico to Alaska, accumulating more than forty thousand photographs eighty Indian tribes, ten thousand phonograph cylinders, movies, countless notes. Their work resulted in the monumental work of twenty printed volumes The North American Indian. As ambitious undertaking cost him his fortune and his health. He died in 1952, pending travel to the Amazon and Andean regions, without a dollar and largely forgotten.

( ENGLISH )

Page 6: American Natives

During those 30 years (twice the time he had originally planned for the project), Curtis visited more than 80 tribes, from the Apache to the Zuñi, and earned the personal support of the president, Theodore Roosevelt. He worked 15-hour days for months at a time, spent more than $1.5 million of his benefactor JP Morgan's money, was shot at four times, disowned by his brother, divorced by his wife, and went bankrupt. On returning from one prolonged trip into Eskimo territory he was thrown into jail for failure to make alimony payments.Yet Curtis was indefatigable: no amount of adversity could sap his passion for documenting the traditions of a people who didn't always want to be documented. "I have grown so used to having people yell at me to keep out, and then punctuate their remarks with mud, rock and clubs," he once said, "that I pay but little attention to them if I can only succeed in getting my picture before something hits me."He succeeded in taking more than 40,000 pictures, the best of which formed the basis of The North American Indian, a vast ethnographic study, published in 20 volumes between 1907 and 1930. On the appearance of the first volume, the New York Herald declared it "the most gigantic undertaking in the making of books since the King James edition of the Bible".Curtis was convinced that he was capturing the dying days of "a vanishing race". Indeed, such was his obsession with recording arcane traditions that, to the indignation of the academic community, he would often encourage his subjects to recreate rituals which they no longer performed, even providing his own props where necessary. In his rather self-important introduction to the first volume of The North American Indian, he stated his concern that "the passing of every old man or woman means the passing of some tradition, some knowledge of sacred rites possessed by no other.

( ENGLISH )

Page 7: American Natives

Consequently the information that is to be gathered, for the benefit of future generations, respecting the mode of life of one of the great races of mankind, must be collected at once or the opportunity will be lost for all time." His fears were exaggerated, but the fact that American Indian communities have thrived rather than faded in the years since Curtis died does nothing to diminish the haunting beauty of his photography: whether in an unforgettable shot of Red Hawk, in full headdress, watering his horse on the badlands of South Dakota; or a beautifully composed image of four extravagantly coiffed Hopi women demonstrating a traditional method of grinding maize.There is a romantic quality to many of these pictures, an undercurrent of nostalgia enhanced by Curtis's masterful use of soft focus and the unflinching intensity of his eye-to-eye portraits of heroic figures now long dead.Curtis could not have got these pictures without earning the friendship and trust of the communities he was photographing - and he would stop at nothing to achieve it. At a time when it was rare for a white American to have anything to do with his Indian compatriots, Curtis dived headlong into native culture, earning himself a traditional nickname ("the shadow catcher") and joining Hopi tribesmen in their famous snake dance, "dressed in a G string… and with the regulation snake in my mouth".

( ENGLISH )

Page 8: American Natives
Page 9: American Natives
Page 10: American Natives
Page 11: American Natives
Page 12: American Natives
Page 13: American Natives
Page 14: American Natives
Page 15: American Natives
Page 16: American Natives
Page 17: American Natives
Page 18: American Natives
Page 19: American Natives
Page 20: American Natives
Page 21: American Natives
Page 22: American Natives
Page 23: American Natives
Page 24: American Natives
Page 25: American Natives
Page 26: American Natives
Page 27: American Natives
Page 28: American Natives
Page 29: American Natives
Page 30: American Natives
Page 31: American Natives
Page 32: American Natives
Page 33: American Natives
Page 34: American Natives
Page 35: American Natives
Page 36: American Natives
Page 37: American Natives
Page 38: American Natives
Page 39: American Natives
Page 40: American Natives
Page 41: American Natives
Page 42: American Natives
Page 43: American Natives
Page 44: American Natives
Page 45: American Natives
Page 46: American Natives
Page 47: American Natives
Page 48: American Natives
Page 49: American Natives
Page 50: American Natives
Page 51: American Natives
Page 52: American Natives
Page 53: American Natives
Page 54: American Natives
Page 55: American Natives
Page 56: American Natives
Page 57: American Natives
Page 58: American Natives
Page 59: American Natives
Page 60: American Natives
Page 61: American Natives
Page 62: American Natives
Page 63: American Natives
Page 64: American Natives
Page 65: American Natives
Page 66: American Natives
Page 67: American Natives
Page 68: American Natives
Page 69: American Natives
Page 70: American Natives
Page 71: American Natives
Page 72: American Natives
Page 73: American Natives
Page 74: American Natives
Page 75: American Natives
Page 76: American Natives
Page 77: American Natives
Page 78: American Natives
Page 79: American Natives
Page 80: American Natives
Page 81: American Natives
Page 82: American Natives
Page 83: American Natives
Page 84: American Natives
Page 85: American Natives
Page 86: American Natives
Page 87: American Natives
Page 88: American Natives
Page 89: American Natives
Page 90: American Natives
Page 91: American Natives
Page 92: American Natives
Page 93: American Natives
Page 94: American Natives
Page 95: American Natives
Page 96: American Natives
Page 97: American Natives
Page 98: American Natives
Page 99: American Natives
Page 100: American Natives
Page 101: American Natives
Page 102: American Natives
Page 103: American Natives
Page 104: American Natives
Page 105: American Natives
Page 106: American Natives
Page 107: American Natives
Page 108: American Natives
Page 109: American Natives
Page 110: American Natives
Page 111: American Natives
Page 112: American Natives
Page 113: American Natives
Page 114: American Natives
Page 115: American Natives
Page 116: American Natives
Page 117: American Natives
Page 118: American Natives
Page 119: American Natives
Page 120: American Natives
Page 121: American Natives
Page 122: American Natives
Page 123: American Natives
Page 124: American Natives
Page 125: American Natives
Page 126: American Natives
Page 127: American Natives
Page 128: American Natives
Page 129: American Natives
Page 130: American Natives
Page 131: American Natives
Page 132: American Natives
Page 133: American Natives
Page 134: American Natives
Page 135: American Natives
Page 136: American Natives
Page 137: American Natives
Page 138: American Natives
Page 139: American Natives
Page 140: American Natives
Page 141: American Natives
Page 142: American Natives
Page 143: American Natives
Page 144: American Natives
Page 145: American Natives
Page 146: American Natives
Page 147: American Natives
Page 148: American Natives
Page 149: American Natives
Page 150: American Natives
Page 151: American Natives
Page 152: American Natives
Page 153: American Natives
Page 154: American Natives
Page 155: American Natives
Page 156: American Natives
Page 157: American Natives
Page 158: American Natives
Page 159: American Natives
Page 160: American Natives
Page 161: American Natives
Page 162: American Natives
Page 163: American Natives
Page 164: American Natives
Page 165: American Natives
Page 166: American Natives
Page 167: American Natives
Page 168: American Natives
Page 169: American Natives
Page 170: American Natives
Page 171: American Natives
Page 172: American Natives
Page 173: American Natives
Page 174: American Natives
Page 175: American Natives
Page 176: American Natives
Page 177: American Natives
Page 178: American Natives
Page 179: American Natives
Page 180: American Natives
Page 181: American Natives
Page 182: American Natives
Page 183: American Natives
Page 184: American Natives
Page 185: American Natives
Page 186: American Natives
Page 187: American Natives
Page 188: American Natives
Page 189: American Natives
Page 190: American Natives
Page 191: American Natives
Page 192: American Natives
Page 193: American Natives
Page 194: American Natives
Page 195: American Natives
Page 196: American Natives
Page 197: American Natives
Page 198: American Natives
Page 199: American Natives
Page 200: American Natives
Page 201: American Natives
Page 202: American Natives
Page 203: American Natives
Page 204: American Natives
Page 205: American Natives
Page 206: American Natives
Page 207: American Natives
Page 208: American Natives
Page 209: American Natives
Page 210: American Natives
Page 211: American Natives
Page 212: American Natives
Page 213: American Natives
Page 214: American Natives
Page 215: American Natives
Page 216: American Natives
Page 217: American Natives
Page 218: American Natives
Page 219: American Natives
Page 220: American Natives
Page 221: American Natives
Page 222: American Natives
Page 223: American Natives
Page 224: American Natives
Page 225: American Natives
Page 226: American Natives
Page 227: American Natives
Page 228: American Natives
Page 229: American Natives
Page 230: American Natives
Page 231: American Natives
Page 232: American Natives
Page 233: American Natives
Page 234: American Natives
Page 235: American Natives
Page 236: American Natives
Page 237: American Natives
Page 238: American Natives
Page 239: American Natives
Page 240: American Natives
Page 241: American Natives
Page 242: American Natives
Page 243: American Natives
Page 244: American Natives
Page 245: American Natives
Page 246: American Natives
Page 247: American Natives
Page 248: American Natives
Page 249: American Natives
Page 250: American Natives
Page 251: American Natives
Page 252: American Natives
Page 253: American Natives
Page 254: American Natives
Page 255: American Natives
Page 256: American Natives
Page 257: American Natives
Page 258: American Natives
Page 259: American Natives
Page 260: American Natives
Page 261: American Natives
Page 262: American Natives
Page 263: American Natives
Page 264: American Natives
Page 265: American Natives
Page 266: American Natives
Page 267: American Natives
Page 268: American Natives
Page 269: American Natives
Page 270: American Natives
Page 271: American Natives
Page 272: American Natives
Page 273: American Natives
Page 274: American Natives
Page 275: American Natives
Page 276: American Natives
Page 277: American Natives
Page 278: American Natives
Page 279: American Natives
Page 280: American Natives
Page 281: American Natives
Page 282: American Natives
Page 283: American Natives
Page 284: American Natives
Page 285: American Natives
Page 286: American Natives
Page 287: American Natives
Page 288: American Natives
Page 289: American Natives
Page 290: American Natives
Page 291: American Natives
Page 292: American Natives
Page 293: American Natives
Page 294: American Natives
Page 295: American Natives
Page 296: American Natives
Page 297: American Natives
Page 298: American Natives
Page 299: American Natives
Page 300: American Natives
Page 301: American Natives
Page 302: American Natives
Page 303: American Natives
Page 304: American Natives
Page 305: American Natives
Page 306: American Natives
Page 307: American Natives
Page 308: American Natives
Page 309: American Natives
Page 310: American Natives
Page 311: American Natives
Page 312: American Natives
Page 313: American Natives
Page 314: American Natives
Page 315: American Natives
Page 316: American Natives
Page 317: American Natives
Page 318: American Natives
Page 319: American Natives
Page 320: American Natives
Page 321: American Natives
Page 322: American Natives
Page 323: American Natives
Page 324: American Natives
Page 325: American Natives
Page 326: American Natives
Page 327: American Natives
Page 328: American Natives
Page 329: American Natives
Page 330: American Natives
Page 331: American Natives
Page 332: American Natives
Page 333: American Natives
Page 334: American Natives
Page 335: American Natives
Page 336: American Natives
Page 337: American Natives
Page 338: American Natives
Page 339: American Natives
Page 340: American Natives
Page 341: American Natives
Page 342: American Natives
Page 343: American Natives
Page 344: American Natives
Page 345: American Natives
Page 346: American Natives
Page 347: American Natives
Page 348: American Natives
Page 349: American Natives
Page 350: American Natives
Page 351: American Natives
Page 352: American Natives
Page 353: American Natives
Page 354: American Natives
Page 355: American Natives
Page 356: American Natives
Page 357: American Natives
Page 358: American Natives
Page 359: American Natives
Page 360: American Natives
Page 361: American Natives
Page 362: American Natives
Page 363: American Natives
Page 364: American Natives
Page 365: American Natives
Page 366: American Natives
Page 367: American Natives
Page 368: American Natives
Page 369: American Natives
Page 370: American Natives
Page 371: American Natives
Page 372: American Natives
Page 373: American Natives
Page 374: American Natives
Page 375: American Natives
Page 376: American Natives
Page 377: American Natives
Page 378: American Natives
Page 379: American Natives
Page 380: American Natives
Page 381: American Natives
Page 382: American Natives
Page 383: American Natives
Page 384: American Natives
Page 385: American Natives
Page 386: American Natives
Page 387: American Natives
Page 388: American Natives
Page 389: American Natives
Page 390: American Natives
Page 391: American Natives
Page 392: American Natives
Page 393: American Natives
Page 394: American Natives
Page 395: American Natives
Page 396: American Natives
Page 397: American Natives
Page 398: American Natives
Page 399: American Natives
Page 400: American Natives
Page 401: American Natives
Page 402: American Natives
Page 403: American Natives
Page 404: American Natives
Page 405: American Natives
Page 406: American Natives
Page 407: American Natives
Page 408: American Natives
Page 409: American Natives
Page 410: American Natives
Page 411: American Natives
Page 412: American Natives
Page 413: American Natives
Page 414: American Natives
Page 415: American Natives
Page 416: American Natives
Page 417: American Natives
Page 418: American Natives
Page 419: American Natives
Page 420: American Natives
Page 421: American Natives
Page 422: American Natives
Page 423: American Natives
Page 424: American Natives
Page 425: American Natives
Page 426: American Natives

Curtis has been praised as a gifted photographer but also criticized by professional ethnologists for manipulating his images. Curtis' photographs have been charged with misrepresenting Native American people and cultures by portraying them in the popular notions and stereotypes of the times. Although the early twentieth century was a difficult time for most Native communities in America, not all natives were doomed to becoming a "vanishing race." At a time when natives' rights were being denied and their treaties were unrecognized by the federal government, many natives were successfully adapting to western society. By reinforcing the native identity as the noble savage and a tragic vanishing race, some believe Curtis detracted attention from the true plight of American natives at the time when he was witnessing their squalid conditions on reservations first-hand and their attempt to find their place in Western culture and adapt to their changing world.In many of his images Curtis removed parasols, suspenders, wagons, and other traces of Western and material culture from his pictures. In his photogravure In a Piegan Lodge, published in The North American Indian, Curtis retouched the image to remove a clock between the two men seated on the ground.

( ENGLISH )

Page 427: American Natives

Little Plume with his son Yellow Kidney occupies the position of honor, the space at the rear opposite the entrance. Compare with the unretouched original below.

Unretouched original of the image above. Note the clock between Little Plume and Yellow Kidney.

Page 428: American Natives

• He also is known to have paid natives to pose in staged scenes, wear historically inaccurate dress and costumes, dance and partake in simulated ceremonies.[10] In Curtis' picture Oglala War-Party, the image shows 10 Oglala men wearing feather headdresses, on horseback riding down hill. The photo caption reads, "a group of Sioux warriors as they appeared in the days of inter tribal warfare, carefully making their way down a hillside in the vicinity of the enemy's camp." In truth headdresses would have only been worn during special occasions and, in some tribes, only by the chief of the tribe. The photograph was taken in 1907 when natives had been relegated onto reservations and warring between tribes had ended. Curtis paid natives to pose as warriors at a time when they lived with little dignity, rights, and freedoms. It is therefore suggested that he altered and manipulated his pictures to create an ethnographic simulation of Native tribes untouched by Western society. One of the more balanced reviews of The North American Indian comes from Mick Gidley, Emeritus Professor of American Literature, at Leeds University, in England, who has written a number of works related to the life of Edward S. Curtis: "The North American Indian-extensively produced and issued in a severely limited edition-could not prove popular. But in recent years anthropologists and others, even when they have censured what they have assumed were Curtis' methodological assumptions or quarrelled with the text's conclusions, have begun to appreciate the value of the project's achievement: exhibitions have been mounted, anthologies of pictures have been published, and The North American Indian has increasingly been cited in the researches of others... The North American Indian is not monolithic or merely a monument. It is alive, it speaks, if with several voices, and among those perhaps mingled voices are those of otherwise silent or muted Indian individuals.”

Page 429: American Natives
Page 430: American Natives

• Of the full Curtis opus N. Scott Momaday says: “Taken as a whole, the work of Edward S. Curtis is a singular achievement. Never before have we seen the Indians of North America so close to the origins of their humanity...Curtis’ photographs comprehend indispensible images of every human being at every time in every place”Don Gulbrandsen, who wrote Edward Sheriff Curtis: Visions of the First Americans, puts it this way in his introductory essay on Curtis’ life: “The faces stare out at you, images seemingly from an ancient time and from a place far, far away…Yet as you gaze at the faces the humanity becomes apparent, lives filled with dignity but also sadness and loss, representatives of a world that has all but disappeared from our planet.”In Shadow Catcher: The Life and Work of Edward S. Curtis, Laurie Lawlor reveals that “many Native Americans Curtis photographed called him Shadow Catcher. But the images he captured were far more powerful than mere shadows. The men, women, and children in The North American Indian seem as alive to us today as they did when Curtis took their pictures in the early part of the twentieth century. Curtis respected the Indians he encountered and was willing to learn about their culture, religion and way of life. In return the Indians respected and trusted him. When judged by the standards of his time, Curtis was far ahead of his contemporaries in sensitivity, tolerance, and openness to Native American cultures and ways of thinking.”...

Page 431: American Natives
Page 432: American Natives

Me recuerdan aquellas fotos de la escolarización que sufrieron, con gran violencia, niños nativos americanos del s.XIX y comienzos del s.XX. Arrancados a sus familias un enorme número de niños fue escolarizado para "educarlos". Se hicieron fotos de estos grupos de niños "antes" y "después" del proceso educativo occidentalizador. Un ejemplo:

Cuando miro estas fotos que unas autoridades racistas hicieron para demostrar el estado "salvaje" anterior y el estado "civilizado" posterior yo veo justo lo contrario. La dignidad y la libertad fueron sustuidas por inseguridad y desarraigo.

( ESPAÑOL)

Page 433: American Natives
Page 434: American Natives
Page 436: American Natives

Müsica: "Canyon Reverie" , "Earth Spirit"Autor: R. Carlos Nakai

Page 437: American Natives

Presentación: N. Svistoonoff

Page 438: American Natives

fin