algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger...

64
algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atoms PILJIN YI Korea Institute for Advanced Study QUC Inauguration Conference February 2014

Transcript of algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger...

Page 1: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atoms

PILJIN YIKorea Institute for Advanced Study

QUC Inauguration ConferenceFebruary 2014

Page 2: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Atiyah-Singer Index Theorem ~ 1963Calabi-Yau ~ 1978

Calibrated Geometry ~ 1982(Harvey & Lawson)

.

.

.Homological Mirror Symmetry ~ 1994

(Kontsevich)....

Stability & Derived Category ~ 2000.....

Wall-Crossing Conjecture~ 2008(Conjecture by Kontsevich & Soibelman)

.

.

.

.

1975 ~ Bogomolnyi-Prasad-Sommerfeld (BPS)1977 ~ Supersymmetry1983 ~ Superstring Theory.1985 ~ Calabi-Yau Compactification1988 ~ Mirror Symmetry.1994 ~ Wall-Crossing Discovered

(Seiberg & Witten)1995 ~ Dirichlet Branes1998 ~ Wall-Crossing is Bound State

Dissociation (Lee & P.Y.).2001 ~ Wall-Crossing for Black Holes

(Denef)....2008 ~ Konstevich-Soibelman Explained

(Gaiotto & Moore & Neitzke).2011 ~ KS Wall-Crossing proved

via Quatum Mechanics Manschot , Pioline & Sen /Kim , Park, Wang & P.Y. / Sen

Page 3: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

quantum is algebraic

spacetime is geometric

a little bit of superstring theory

how quantum mechanics solved a modern geometry problem

Page 4: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Quantum Mechanics

Algebra

Page 5: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

quantum is algebraic

Page 6: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Balmer / Rydberg ~ 1880’s

Page 7: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Balmer / Rydberg

Page 8: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Schroedinger Atoms

Page 9: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Schroedinger Atoms

Page 10: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Schroedinger Atoms

Page 11: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

General Relativity

Geometry

Page 12: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

spacetime is geometric

Page 13: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Einstein ~ 1915

Page 14: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Kaluza & Klein (~1921) asked :

can the world has more than 3 spatial dimensions or 4 spacetime dimensions

with the extra directions curled up so small to be practically invisibleand, if so, what are the physical consequences ?

after all, space (& time) is supposed to curved

Page 15: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

five superstring theories live in 10 dimensional spacetime

Page 16: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

superstring theory says :

spacetime is composed of 4+6 dimensions withvery small & tightly-curved (say, Calabi-Yau) 6D manifold

sitting at each and every point of usual 3D space,

Page 17: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

6차원

4차원

roughly,

Page 18: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

or, more precisely,

Page 19: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

a little bit of superstring theoryparticles from geometry / geometry from particles

Page 20: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Quantum Mechanics

General Relativity

Geometry

Superstring

Algebra

Page 21: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

basic building blocks in superstring theory

fundamentalstrings

light particles some of which mediate “forces”such as gravity & electromagnetism

Page 22: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

basic building blocks in superstring theory

fundamentalstrings

Dirichletbranes

(as in membrane)

Page 23: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

basic building blocks in superstring theory

heavy particles, typically with electric/magnetic charges

fundamentalstrings

Dirichletbranes

Page 24: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

a particle located somewhere in our visible space

Page 25: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

a particle located somewhere in our visible space= a wrapped brane in the hidden Calabi-Yau at that point

Page 26: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

this means that we can actually detect geometry (loops, holes, cavities, ……) of the hidden 6D space

by detecting what kind particles exist in visible 3D world

Page 27: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

particle vs. geometry

..

Page 28: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

particle vs. geometry

Page 29: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

particle vs. geometry

Page 30: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

particle vs. geometry

Page 31: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

existence of “quantum BPS (bound) states”= existence of “calibrated 3-cycles”

Page 32: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

non-existence of “quantum BPS (bound) states”= non-existence of “calibrated 3-cycles”

Page 33: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

how quantum mechanics solved a modern geometry problem

Page 34: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

generic BPS particle is a multi-center bound state

Page 35: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

thus, wall-crossing has a very simple and interpretationin the particle / quantum mechanics viewpoint

as bound states becoming unbound

Page 36: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

quantum mechanics for many such charged particlesKim+Park+P.Y.+Wang 2011

Page 37: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

repulsive or attractive depending on a sign

Page 38: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

3n-dim dynamics 3 + 2(n-1) dim nonlinear sigma modelvia deformation & localization that preserve the index

Page 39: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

index theorem

Page 40: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Bose/Fermi statistics is essential

Page 41: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

universal wall-crossing formulae from quantum mechanics of BPS particles

Kim+Park+P.Y.+Wang 2011

Page 42: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

2000 Stern + P.Y.wall-crossing formula for simple magnetic charges; weak coupling regime

2002 Denefquiver dynamics representation of N=2 supergravity BH’s

2008 Kontsevich + Soibelman

2010/2011 Manschot + Pioline + Sengeneral n-particle conjecture for Quantum Mechanics Counting

2011 Lee+P.Y. / Kim+Park+Wang+P.Y.general n-particle solution to Quantum Mechanics Counting

2011 SenQuantum Mechanics Counting = Kontsevich-Soibelman Conjecture

Page 43: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Quantum Mechanics

General Relativity

Geometry

Superstring

Algebra

Page 44: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

existence of “quantum BPS (bound) states”= existence of “calibrated 3-cycles”

Page 45: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Calabi-Yau manifold & calibrated 3-cycles

Page 46: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

given a family of Calabi-Yau manifold with a fixed topology,which topological 3-cycles can be calibrated ?

Page 47: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

minimal volume condition+

an extra “minimization” condition

given a family of Calabi-Yau manifold with a fixed topology,which topological 3-cycles can be calibrated ?

Page 48: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

which is the reason why topology alonecannot guarantee existence of such cycles

Page 49: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Kontsevich-Soibelman conjecture :a universal algebra for wall-crossing ?

Page 50: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Kontsevich-Soibelman conjecture :a universal algebra for wall-crossing ?

Page 51: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Kontsevich-Soibelman conjecture :a universal algebra for wall-crossing ?

Page 52: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Kontsevich-Soibelman conjecture :a universal algebra for wall-crossing ?

Page 53: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

the “quantum degeneracy” of a given species of cycle / particle;non-zero if and only if such a cycle exists in the geometric sense

Kontsevich-Soibelman conjecture :a universal algebra for wall-crossing ?

Page 54: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

the “quantum degeneracy” of a given species of cycle / particle;non-zero if and only if such a cycle exists in the geometric sense

Kontsevich-Soibelman conjecture :a universal algebra for wall-crossing ?

Page 55: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

intersection number between the two cycles

Euler number of the moduli space of the cycle

mathematicians say, from 6d viewpoint

Page 56: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Schwinger product

on [ a spin ½ + two spin 0 ] x [ angular momentum multiplet ]l

2nd helicity trace = the “number” of species of such particles

physicists say, from 4d viewpoint

Page 57: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

an infinite dimensional representation of Kontsevich-Soibelman wall-crossing algebra

Page 58: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

-+ sideside =

the conjecture : given the left-hand-side, the right-hand-side is entirely determined via the algebraic identity as follows

Page 59: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

=

for example,

Page 60: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

=

for example,

Page 61: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

2000 Stern + P.Y.wall-crossing formula for simple magnetic charges; weak coupling regime

2002 Denefquiver dynamics representation of N=2 supergravity BH’s

2008 Kontsevich + Soibelman

2010/2011 Manschot + Pioline + Sengeneral n-particle conjecture for Quantum Mechanics Counting

2011 Lee+P.Y. / Kim+Park+Wang+P.Y.general n-particle solution to Quantum Mechanics Counting

2011 SenQuantum Mechanics Counting = Kontsevich-Soibelman Conjecture

Page 62: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

Atiyah-Singer Index Theorem ~ 1963Calabi-Yau ~ 1978

Calibrated Geometry ~ 1982(Harvey & Lawson)

.

.

.Homological Mirror Symmetry ~ 1994

(Kontsevich)....

Stability & Derived Category ~ 2000.....

Wall-Crossing Conjecture~ 2008(Conjecture by Kontsevich & Soibelman)

.

.

.

.

1975 ~ Bogomolnyi-Prasad-Sommerfeld (BPS)1977 ~ Supersymmetry1983 ~ Superstring Theory.1985 ~ Calabi-Yau Compactification1988 ~ Mirror Symmetry.1994 ~ Wall-Crossing Discovered

(Seiberg & Witten)1995 ~ Dirichlet Branes1998 ~ Wall-Crossing is Bound State

Dissociation (Lee & P.Y.).2001 ~ Wall-Crossing for Black Holes

(Denef)....2008 ~ Konstevich-Soibelman Explained

(Gaiotto & Moore & Neitzke).2011 ~ KS Wall-Crossing proved

via Quatum Mechanics Manschot , Pioline & Sen /Kim , Park, Wang & P.Y. / Sen

Page 63: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring theory combines quantum & gravity

quantum mechanics “count” geometry via superstring theory

quantum mechanical proof of the Kontsevich-Soibelman conjecturewhich solves, partially, a 30-year-old geometry problem

Page 64: algebra, geometry, and Schroedinger atomshome.kias.re.kr/psec/QUC/PY-2014_QUC_Inauguration_Piljin... · 2014-02-28 · quantum physics count states, gravity makes geometry, and superstring

geometry as mathematical tools for modern physics

string theory as a physical tool for modern geometry