1

Agenda of 155th meeting of SEIAA held on 03.08.2016, 04.08.2016 and 05.08.2016

1. SEAC Proceedings held on 18.07.2016.

Sl.No.

Date of receipt of theProposal

File.No Name of the Project Categoryofproposal

District Tahasil Recommendationof SEAC

Observations /Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91. 30-Apr-

1606-May-

1652526/1643-NCM/04-2016

Bhatakumarada-B Stone quarryover an area of 16.770acre Or6.786 ha. in VillageBhatakumarada, Tahasil-Purushottampur in GanjamDistrict of Odisha of Sri KartikaBhanja.

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur

The SEACrecommended togrant EC valid fromthe date of ECaccorded upto thelease period.

2. 29-Apr-16

04-May-16

11281/1636-NCM/04-2016

Kantipal Stone Quarry Over AnArea Of 13.00 Acres Or5.261ha Located At Village-Kantipal , Tahasil-Anandapur,Dist-Keonjhar of Sri MaconsInfratech Pvt. Ltd.

Stone Keonjhar Anandapur

The SEACrecommended togrant EC valid fromthe date of ECaccorded upto thelease period.

3. 26-Apr-16

06.05.16 53181/1627-NCM/04-2016

Baghuapalli Stone Quarry overan area of 12.87 acres or 5.148Ha Located At Village-Baghuapalli, Tahasil-Aska,Dist-Ganjam ofSri Rabindranath Barik

Stone Ganjam Aska The SEACrecommended togrant EC valid fromthe date of ECaccorded upto thelease period.

2

Sl.No.

Date of receipt of theProposal

File.No Name of the Project Categoryofproposal

District Tahasil Recommendationof SEAC

Observations /Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 94. 29-Mar-

1601.07.16 10887/1566-

NCM/03-2016

Ganganapur-B Stone QuarryOver An Area Of 11.918Ha/29.45 Acres Located AtVillage-Ganganapur,Tahasil-Purushottampur, Dist-Ganjamof Sri Bidyut Kumar Pathy

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur

The SEACobserved that hightide line atGopalpur is 1.75meter and decidedto take decision onthe proposal afterreceipt of theclarification fromthe concernedTahasildar aboutthe distance of thehigh tideline atGopalpur.

(Perhaps it iswrongly mentionedin the checklist,which may beclarified.)

5. 06.05.16 06.06.16 11364/1655-NCM/05-2016

Kotadwar sand quarry over anarea of 50.00 acre at villagePatugadadharpur Tahasil Bankiin the district of Cuttack ofTahasildar Banki.

Sand Cuttack Banki The SEACrecommended togrant EC valid fromthe date of ECaccorded upto thelease period.

3

Sl.No.

Date of receipt of theProposal

File.No Name of the Project Categoryofproposal

District Tahasil Recommendationof SEAC

Observations /Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 96. 28-Apr-

1602.05.16 53063/1635-

NCM/04-2016

Nizigarh Baramba StoneQuarry Over An Area Of 21.937Acres Or 8.877 Ha Located AtVillage-Nizigarh, Tahasil-Baramba, Dist-Cuttack ofSri Bipin Prasad Mishra

Stone Cuttack Baramba

The SEACrecommended togrant EC valid fromthe date of ECaccorded upto thelease period.

7. 27-Apr-16

06.05.16 10245/1628-NCM/04-2016

Bahalapalli Stone Quarry OverAn Area Of 19.968 Acres Or8.08 Ha Located At Village-Bahalapalli, Tahasil-Kabisuryanagar, Sub-Division-Chhatrapur, Ganjam of SriHrushikesh Bisoyi.

Stone Ganjam Kabisuryanagar

The SEACobserved that hightide line atGopalpur is 1.75meter and decidedto take decision onthe proposal afterreceipt of theclarification fromthe concernedTahasildar aboutthe distance of thehigh tideline atGopalpur.

8. 11.05.16 12.05.16 11377/1664-NCM/05-2016

Proposal for Sankhari EastWest Building stone quarryover an area of 47.855 acres atvillage Kaipadar TahasilKhordha in the district ofKhordha of Sri Rajanikanta

Stone Khordha Khordha The SEACobserved that thelease period is twoyears and decidedto consider the

4

Sl.No.

Date of receipt of theProposal

File.No Name of the Project Categoryofproposal

District Tahasil Recommendationof SEAC

Observations /Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9Routray. proposal after the

proponent apply forfive years as peramended Odishaminor mineralconcession Rules,2014.

The area of thecluster is 29.218ha. i.e. including 25ha. Hence, EIAreport and publichearing is required.The mitigativemeasures shouldbe suggested forthe cluster in awholistic manner.

5

2. SEAC Proceedings held on 18.07.2016.

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91. 08-Apr-

1608-Apr-16 50691/1

576-NCM/04-2016

BhatakumaradaStone Quarry-DOver Lease AreaOf 13.00 AcresLocated At Village-Bhatakumarada,Tahasil-Purushottampur,District- Ganjam ofSri RabinarayanPatra.

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

6

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 92. 23-Mar-

1628-Mar-16 52045/1

561-NCM/03-2016

Rahadpur BlackStone Quarry OverLease Area Of10.11 Ha/25.00Acres Located AtVillage- Rahadpur,Tahasil-Dharmasala,District- Jajpur ofSri PrahalladLenka

Sand Jajpur Dharmasala The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

7

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 93. 08-Apr-

1608-Apr-16 50810/1

579-NCM/04-2016

BhatakumaradaStone Quarry-COver Lease AreaOf 13.00 AcresLocated At Village-Bhatakumarada,Tahasil-Purushottampur,District- Ganjam ofSri Babu Jena.

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

8

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 94. 08-Apr-

1608-Apr-16 50808/1

578-NCM/04-2016

BhatakumaradaStone Quarry-BOver Lease AreaOf 13.00 AcresLocated At Village-Bhatakumarada,Tahasil-Purushottampur,District- Ganjam ofSri Babu Jena

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

9

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 95. 08-Apr-

1608-Apr-16 50819/1

582-NCM/04-2016

Nimapalli StoneQuarry-B OverLease Area Of14.00 AcresLocated At Village-Nimapalli, Tahasil-Purushottampur,District- Ganjam ofSri Sibaram Dash.

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

10

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 96. 08-Apr-

1608-Apr-16 50816/1

580-NCM/04-2016

Nimapalli StoneQuarry-D OverLease Area Of14.00 AcresLocated At Village-Nimapalli, Tahasil-Purushottampur,District- Ganjam ofSri SibaramPanda.

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

11

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 97. 08-Apr-

1608-Apr-16 50692/1

577-NCM/04-2016

BhatakumaradaStone Quarry-EOver Lease AreaOf 13.00 AcresLocated At Village-Bhatakumarada,Tahasil-Purushottampur,District- Ganjam ofSri RameshChandra Sahu

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

12

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 98. 08-Apr-

1608-Apr-16 50817/1

581-NCM/04-2016

Nimapalli StoneQuarry-C OverLease Area Of14.00 AcresLocated At Village-Nimapalli, Tahasil-Purushottampur,District - Ganjamof Sri BhabagrahyGantayat.

Stone Ganjam Purushottampur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

13

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 99. 11-Mar-

1611-Mar-16 50481/1

531-NCM/03-2016

Baitarani RiverSand Kanpur ToManpur QuarryOver An Area Of14.503 Acre Or5.869 Ha LocatedAt Village-Kanpur,Tahasil-Kanika,Dist-Kendrapara of SriJayanta KumarJena.

Sand Kendrapara

Kanika The SEAC recommended to grant EC validfrom the date of EC accorded upto the leaseperiod.

10. 08-Mar-16

10-Mar-16 50490/1515-NCM/03-2016

Brahmani RiverSand NuapadaQuarry Over 5.058Ha In VillageNuapada, AulTahasil OfKendraparaDistrict, Odisha ofSri sushantPradhan.

Sand Kendrapara

Aul The SEAC in its meeting held on 18.07.16observed that the Kisam is mentioneddifferently in checklist and prefeasibility report.It should be ensured and correct kisam shouldbe mentioned.Further, a certificate from the Tahasildar besubmitted as regards to the distance ofGangadharpur Sand quarry.

11. 09.11.15

10.05.16 SEIAA/2300/824-NCM/11-2015

EC for Gumi RiverSand Quarry overan area 5.07 ha. atvillage Gumi,Tahasil Nuagaonin the district ofNayagarh of SriHadibandhuSamantaray

Sand Nayagarh

Nuagaon

The SEAC recommended to grant EC validfrom the date of EC accorded upto the leaseperiod.

14

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 912. Nil 05.10.15 SEIAA/6

72Proposal forSurubalijore-ASand Quarry overan area 5.06 ha. atvillage Sarapal,Tahasil Rairakholin the distSambalpur of SriAnand KumarKedia.

Sand Sambalpur

Rairakhol

The SEAC re-examine the proposal andreiterates its earlier recommendation.

13. 05-Jan-16

10-Jan-16 SEIAA/38263/1072-NCM/01-2016

EnvironmentalClearance forKuruli MahanadiSand Quarry overan area 5.06 ha. atvillage Kuruli,TahasilKishannagar in the district ofCuttack of Sri SKAbdul Kadir.

Sand Cuttack Kishannagar

The SEAC recommended to grant EC validfrom the date of EC accorded upto the leaseperiod.

14. 10-Feb-16

29-Feb-16 48841/1468-NCM/02-2016

Karjanga SandQuarry OverLease Area Of5.466 Ha LocatedAt Village-Karjanga, Tahasil-Rasulpur, District-Jajpur of SriKailash ChandraSahoo.

Sand Jajpur Rasulpur

The SEAC recommended to grant EC validfrom the date of EC accorded upto the leaseperiod.

15

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 915. 16.03.1

616.03.16 10730/1

546-NCM/03-2016

Chheliabeda SandBed over an areaof 12.64 acres atvillageChheliabeda,TahasilGopabadnhunagarin the distMayurbhanj

Sand Gopabadnhunagar

Mayurbhanj

The SEAC recommended to grant EC validfrom the date of EC accorded upto the leaseperiod.

16. 11-Feb-16

03.03.16 4356/1477-NCM/02-2016

Birtola Sand BedQuarry Over AnArea Of 29.65ac.(11.99 ha.)Located At VillageBirtola; Tahasil-Lahunipara Dist-Sundargarh

Sand Sundargarh

Lahunipara

The SEAC recommended to grant EC validfrom the date of EC accorded upto the leaseperiod.

17. 09-Jan-16

02.04.16 39147/1103-NCM/01-2016

Paitary (B) StoneQuarry MineProject Having AnArea Of 10.11 HaWith ProposedProductionCapacity Of 12500Cum At VillagePaitary (B), TehsilChhatrapur,District Ganjam ofSri ManmohanMoharana.

Stone Ganjam Chhatrapur

The SEAC observed that from the replyfurnished by the project proponent, vide letterno. GPL/EST/2016/51, dated 10.05.2016, it isrevealed that the mine has never beenoperated in the past due to some localproblems. As such the same reduced level(RL) has been shown in the approved miningplan. It has been further reported that the saidlocal problems still exist and lifting of stoneduring the applied period is not possible. Inview of the above, the SEAC opined that it ispremature to issue environmental clearanceas long as the local problems continue. Theproponent may apply afresh with approved

16

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9mining plan when conducive condition isrestored.

18. 08-Apr-16

08-Apr-16 49889/1574-NCM/04-2016

Pankalabadi-BSand Quarry OverLease Area Of5.133 Ha/12.683Acres Located AtVillage-Pankalabadi ,Tahasil-Dharakote,District- Ganjam ofSri TrilochanBehera

Sand Ganjam Dharakote The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided to

17

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9consider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

19. 08-Apr-16

08-Apr-16 49888/1573-NCM/04-2016

Pankalabadi-ASand Quarry OverLease Area Of5.133 Ha/12.683Acres Located AtVillage-Pankalabadi ,Tahasil-Dharakote,District- Ganjam ofSri TrilochanBehera

Sand Ganjam Dharakote The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

18

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

20. 02-Feb-16

15.02.16 8823/1386-NCM/02-2016

Manik Pathar NalaSand Quarry OverAn Area Of13.19ac. (5.337ha)At Village-Manik,Tahasil-Athmallik,Dist-Angul

Sand Angul Athmalik The SEAC recommended to grant EC validfrom the date of EC accorded upto the leaseperiod.

21. 15-Mar-16

15-Mar-16 9965/1541-NCM/03-2016

Sayedpur-1 SandQuarry over 12.80acres or 5.18 Ha.In VillageSayedpur, TahasilBinjharpur, DistrictJajpur of SriSanjeeb KumarSahoo.

5 Sand Jajpur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigative

19

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9measures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shallbe carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

22. 15-Mar-16

15-Mar-16 49607/1543-NCM/03-2016

Sayedpur-2 SandQuarry Over AnArea Of13.50acres Or5.46 Ha. In VillageSayedpur, TahasilBinjharpur, DistrictJajpur of SriSanjeeb KumarSahoo.

5 Sand Jajpur The SEAC observed the following:

1. The EMP submitted for the cluster isobserved to be a summation of the individualfacts lacking the wholistic approachappropriate for the cluster.

2. EMP prepared for cluster does not provide amap showing individual mines, dumpposition, drainage, haulage road, distancefrom population etc.

3. EMP does not provide location of the pointswhere monitoring will be taken up.

4. EMP has not estimated the difficultiescaused to population, domestic animalsgrazing and appropriate mitigativemeasures.

5. The EMP with cluster approach needs to beprepared with proper study. The study shall

20

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of theProject

Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAA Meeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9be carried out taking the combined impact ofall the mines in cluster with adequatemitigative measures.

After detailed discussion the SEAC decided toconsider the case after the proponent submit amodified EMP with cluster approach preparedwith proper study.

23. 16.03.16

16.03.16 50814/1545-NCM/02-2016

Kurulu Nadi SandBed over an area12.724 acres atvillage Heruguda,Kadalimunda,Tahasil Kundra inthe dist Koraput

Sand Kundra Koraput The SEAC could not locate fresh toposheetshowing the lease area though the Tahasildarhas mentioned that fresh toposheet has beensubmitted.

Fresh toposheet may be re-submitted.

3. Clarification / Information received by SEIAA from Tahasildar in response to the clarification sought by SEAC.

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of the Project Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAAMeetingOnline Hard

Copy1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

1. 21-Jan-16

02.04.16 9475/1241-NCM/01-2016

Kendughat Sand Quarry-13.00 Acres

Sand Balangir Deogaon The SEAC in its meeting dated30.03.16 has recommended forEC valid up to 31.03.2020.However, EC is to be issued afterreceipt of a certificate fromconcerned Tahasildar that thereis no other mine within 500 m

21

Sl.No.

Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of the Project Category ofproposal

District Tahasil SEAC Recommendation Observations/Orders ofSEIAAMeetingOnline Hard

Copy1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

from the periphery of theproposed mine lease area.

Now the Tahasildar has clarifiedthe same.

4. SEAC Proceedings held on 16th and 23rd May, 2016.

Sl.No.

Name of the Project Categoryof proposal

District SEAC Recommendation Observations / Ordersof SEIAA Meeting

1 2 3 4 51 Extension of EC of Raikela

Iron Ore Mines over an area45.932 ha. village Raikela,Tahasil-Koira in the district ofSundargarh of M/s NationalEnterprises Ltd.

Mining Sundargarh

SEAC recommended for extension of validity period of ECgranted to Raikela Iron Ore Mines of M/s National EnterprisesLtd. upto 30 years or life of mine whichever is less.

The project was placed in the 153rd meeting of SEIAA and itwas decided that the half yearly progress report submitted byPP is not specific with detailed facts & figures. PP may beasked to furnish specific compliance of the EC conditions overthe last 5 years working.

Now the proponent has submitted the information sought bySEIAA.

22

5. Letters / Documents received by SEIAA, Odisha.

Sl.No.

Letter no. andproponent name

Issues Decision ofSEIAA, Odisha

1 A lette no. 10643 dated30.06.2016 has beenreceived from SPCBoard, Odisha

Proposal for Ispat Sukinda Chromite Mines (ML area 35.6 ha.) at village Kaliapani, TahasilSukinda, Dist-Jajpur for production of Chromite Ore of capacity 0.4 MTPA throughunderground mining methods of M/s Balasore Alloys Ltd.

Present Status: The proposal was placed in the 143rd Meeting of SEIAA and decided thatthey would like to examine the Cr+6 discharge level of all the operating Chromite mines inthis belt and the status of monitoring of the conditions of the Consent to Operate letters ofSPCB in these cases. Specifically, the present status of presence of hexavalentchrominium in the surrounding environment and nallahs may be ascertained from SPCB.

Now a letter has been received from SPC, Board, Odisha Bhubaneswa in this regards.

The proposal was placed in the 154th meeting of SEIAA and the Authority decided to deferit to the next meting.

2 A letter no. 12274/F&EDeptt dated 02.07.2016has been received fromForest & EnvironmentDeptt. Govt. of Odisha.

Tranfser of E.C. for construction of Resettlement and Rehabilitation (R&R) Colony atvillage Sukhabandh, Tahasil Hemgir in the district of Sundergarh from M/s Odisha PowerGeneration Corporation Ltd. to M/s Odisha coal & Power Ltd.

The proposal was placed in the 154th meeting of SEIAA and the Authority decided to deferit to the next meting.

3 A letter no.2274 dated30.06.16 has beenreceived fromTahasildarShamakhunta,Dist-Mayurbhanj.

Clarification on request by the Divisional Forest Officer-Cum-Wildlife Warden, Baripada tostop operation of five logn term lease quarries of this Tahasil.

The proposal was placed in the 154th meeting of SEIAA and the Authority decided to deferit to the next meting.

4 A letter no. NV/MS/126dated 20.07.2016 hasbeen received fromNirman Vikash Pvt. Ltd.

The proponent has informed that SEIAA has asked to submit modified Checklist forMahughara Decorative Stone but the mining officer Berhampur desires that it will beprovided only on the letter of SEIAA. Hence the proponet has requested SEIAA to kindlywrite a letter to the mining officer to provide the required information.

23

The proposal was placed in the 154th meeting of SEIAA and the Authority decided to deferit to the next meting.

5 A letter no. nil dated02.07.2016 has beenreceived fromY. Rajani.

Proposal of M/s Baralanda Decorative Stone Mines over an area of 5.018 ha. at villageBaralanda Tahasil Paralakhemundi in the district of Gajapati.Now the project proponent has requested to address the letter to Executive Engineer MIDivision, Paralakhemundi, Dist-Gajapati to submit the required information as sought bySEAC.

The letter was placed in the 154th meeting of SEIAA and it was decided to defer it to thenext meting.

6 A letter no. nil dated02.07.2016 has beenreceived from Mr. M.Mukund Rao.

Proposal for EC for Jagannathpur Decorative Stone Mines Over an area of 21.748 acres/8.639 ha. located at village Jagannathpur, Tahasil Paralakhemundi, Dist- Gajapati.Now the project proponent has requested to address the letter to Executive Engineer MIDivision, Paralakhemundi, Dist-Gajapati to submit the required information as sought bySEAC.The letter was placed in the 154th meeting of SEIAA and it was decided to defer it to thenext meting.

6. Two nos. of new Minor Mineral Projects received by SEIAA from Tahasildar.

Sl. No. Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of the Project Category ofproposal

District Tahasil Observations of SEIAA Observations /Orders of SEIAAMeeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91. 15-Apr-

1603-05-16 10961/1

595-NCM/04-2016

Gunakhal Sand Bed OverAn Area Of 12.53 Acres Or5.07 Ha At Village-Gunakhal, Tehsil- Kolnara,

Stone Rayagada

Kolnara The proposal was placed in the151st meeting and the SEIAA soughtSpecific information from TahasildarConcerned.Item no 9(i) of the

24

Sl. No. Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of the Project Category ofproposal

District Tahasil Observations of SEIAA Observations /Orders of SEIAAMeeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9Dist- Rayagada, Odisha ofSri Nakula Senapati

Checklist – Name & distance ofnearest sanctuary / National Park(distance is to be measured on theToposheet).Item no 9 (v) of thechecklist – Name and distance ofnearest other mines and names ofthe mines if any located within radialdistance of 500 meters from theproposed quarry site. Item no. 9 (vii)of the checklist-The distances of theembankment of the river near theproposed lease area, from quarrysite.Now the Tahasildar has submittedthe information sought by SEIAA.

2. 15-Apr-16

03.05.16 10963/1597-NCM/04-2016

Khedapada Sand BedOver An Area Of 12.46Acres Or 5.042 Ha AtVillage- Khedapada,Tehsil- Kolnara, Dist-Rayagada, Odisha of SriSadananda Ganta

Sand Rayagada

Kolnara The proposal was placed in the151st meeting and the SEIAA soughtSpecific information from TahasildarConcerned.Item no 9(i) of theChecklist – Name & distance ofnearest sanctuary / National Park(distance is to be measured on theToposheet).Item no 9 (v) of thechecklist – Name and distance ofnearest other mines and names ofthe mines if any located within radialdistance of 500 meters from theproposed quarry site. Item no. 9 (vii)of the checklist-The distances of theembankment of the river near the

25

Sl. No. Date of receipt ofthe Proposal

File.No Name of the Project Category ofproposal

District Tahasil Observations of SEIAA Observations /Orders of SEIAAMeeting

Online HardCopy

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9proposed lease area, from quarrysite.Now the Tahasildar has submittedthe information sought by SEIAA.

26

Any other matter with the permission of the Chairman

1. A letter no. 547/WE dated 13.07.2016 received from CAD-PIM Directorate, Project Management Unit (OIIAWMIP), forClarification on Environmental Clearance of Mahanadi Chitrotpala Island Irrigation (MCII) Sub-Project - The project proponent hasrequested views of SEIAA/SEAC for early implementation of the MCII project.