Advocacy Planning -- Toward the Development of Theory and … · 2019-02-11 · TITLE Advocacy...

4-0

DOCUMENT BESUHE

ED 106 954 El OCT7 147

AUTHOR Hazzio^ti Donald F TITLE Advocacy Planning Toward the Development of Theory

N and Strategy Exchange Bibliography No 241 INSTITUTION Council of Planning Librarians Bonticello 111 PUB DATE Nov 71 shy

- NOTE ^ 10p AVAILABLE FROM Council of Planning Librarians PO Box 229

Honîcello Illinois61856 ($150)

EDES PRICE HF-S076 HC-$15S PLUS POSTAGE + DESCRIPTORS ^Bibliographies Change Agents Change Strategies

Citizen Participati-on^êity Planning ComraquoanityPlanning Higher Education Planning Publications Reference Haterials Social Planning

IDENTIFIERS Advocacy Planning [

ABSTRACT This bibliography lists publications relevant to the-

topic of advocacy planning with a view toward encouragingand facilitating initial or staging research ip that policy area Entries are organized- into separate sections-for articles in professionaljournals books articles in contemporary periodicals and v newsletters- article^ in legal periodicals reports and studies and proceedings and conferences Within each section citations listed alphabetically by authors name (AuthorJGf

Council of Planning librarians EXCHANGE BIBLIOGRAPHY

CD

^ November 1971 laquoi

-1

laquo Advocacy Planning-Towqrd thebevelopment of Theory and Sfrofegy

Donald F Mazziptti 4 y Graduate Program in Urban and Regional Planning

University of Iowa

i

u S OEraquolaquoraquoTWENT Of M6ALTM EDUCATION a ELP ARC

NATIONAL INS1J1TUTE Of EDUCATION -raquo

COUNCIL OFTLANNDJ^CLIBRARIANS Exchange Bibliography 2ia ADVOCACYtfLAWING

r TOWARD THE DEVELOPMENT OF TH30RY AND STRATEGY

Donald F Mazziott Graduate Program in Urban and Regional Planning ^ I raquo University of Iowa

A raw important and difficult problem is emerging in the administration of public planning agencies that is lt there isa growing number of instances of professionalstaff members who dissent-publicly from the official agency position on a planning issue^

I shyThe concept of advocacy planning the origin of which is

generally credited to an article appearing in the Journal of the

American Institute of Planners by Paul Davidoff2- has proliferated

in planning and architectural writings for tihe better part of a 0 --

decade Despite the flurry of writing on the topic by a great rumshy

ber of writers who range the entire political spectrum it would -

be difficult tcr recount an instance where an equally popular notion - - pound

had remained virtually undeveloped in theory and parctice ^

ltHfliileit is possible to trace the political theory underlying

the conceptof advocacy planning to pluralism nowhere does the

literature seek a well-considered theoretical definition ofvthe - ^^ -^

subject Although it is possible to link the advocacy spoken of r

to the subjective urging of a particular person of personson

behalf of a particular group-related issue3 the student

lltpoundarl Finkler^ Dissent and Independent Initiative in Planshyning Offices (Chicago American Society of Planning OfficialsPlanning Advisory Service Report Ho 269 May

Paul Davidoffgt~-nAdSDcacy laquoTMJ Pluraliaitt Journal of the American Institute of Planners THJ (H6vlaquo9Bdbergt 396$) 330L-

i- ampampfltfJ ) i^yensCâmp^

__^^^^ g5^_gt ^2s(^slaquoSiSi3ilaquosaRSisai f^^^fsSfampSampKSiSSsSS sSSSSiSs

shyA n_ -

= laquo -

- r 2 -^ CPL ExchangeBibliography-2lA

r

researchers professor andprofessional encounter an -abrupt gap on-

issues which appear to Be at least r^Tated and perhaps crucial

to group or professional advocacy For exairple the literature - - y ignores any comprehensive analysis of power relationshipsgroup

- - dynamics the logic- of collective as opposed to individual action^

raquo - -- ^ the characteristics of pressure group politics- or special

6interest theories

As planning schools and agencies begin to feel the pressures shyj ^ -- raquo -

of advocacy or dissent approaches to the heretofore professional shy- -- - ^

tests of objectivity and analysis the lack of a1 coherent defini- raquo -

tion an theory^ of advocacy will inevitably lead- to bothdisrupshy f t -

tions in institutional behavior and failures in the practical - t -N+ 4 -

application of such a ubiqutuous notion Indeed- on the heels of shy

Ralph Naders suggestions -for action programs rfat the 197C^ Annual

Convention of the American Institute of Planners and a subsequent

study of the implications of such programs ahdcr behavior^ it seems - ^ -

clear that analysis of advocacy in alaquo planning context has -failed- to - raquo

keefgt the pace of social change 6 -

Based upon the foregoing comments the following bibliography I - -

on the tropic of advocacy-planning has been developed witha view ^ -v

tgvrar^Lencouraging and facill tating inJtiai- or research in S chis policy area -Areas of agreement and divergence of thought be-

i come apparent upon study of the-references included once these

- elements have been identified serious analysis and theoretical

ieSiXff a Professhy

- V

raquo laquoK

A^

V - I

--3 V CPL Exchange Bibliography

dvocacy Planning A Selected Bibliography- c-Professional JourAals

Arnstein Sherry ft A1 Ladder^f^C^tizen Participation Journal-of the American Institute of FLanjiers XXXV (July 2 - 21b-2^ - - - V shy

^ _ I- 3

Berkeleor Ei ^prfcshpps iVviâtts Architectural Forum

Brager George A |AdVbbacy aad-Political Behavior-- Social Work _

of _t^ Americanassociation of Social Workers -Vol 2 (April 1968) 5-15i rrr

Brager George A and Valerie Jorrin -Bargaining A Method in CcaEnrunity^hange 11 Social Work Journal of the National - Associatioa of Social VJorkers Vol 1 llpsk (Oetpber1969) - 73-83- ~r~

BtirkeD-Barlow Jri Howard H Foster ltJr and Pefcefjfi Nash UrbanPubiic-Policy Participation Networks- The( Urban-and Social Change geîewraquo 3 (Spring 1970)

Burke Edmuiid K Citizen ParticipationStrategies Journal of thaÂmericali Institute of Planaet^j XXXIV (September 1968)

-raquo shyChatterjee Pranab and Raymond A KoleskL The Concepts of Comshy

munity and Community Orgahization Journal of the National t Association of Social Worlcers Vol 15 raquoPgt 3 (Jul^ 1970)gt -

82-92 ^^ r~~^ rrT~ - - ~ f

ClarkraquoHSol Todays-Advocate n Case and CoJmnent Vol 76 No 2 (MarchApril 1971X26-3^1 1 v - - - ^ -- -

Davidoff Tlnda and Paul andJfeiV Newton Gold Suburban Action Advocate Planning for-an Open SocietyJournal pf the

gt AToerican Institute of Planners Vol iixvi No 1 (Januazy laquo M97Q) 12-21 ~ ~~~ - -__ --

Davidoff Paul Advocacy and Pluralist in Planning Journal of the American Institute of Planners-^ Vol XXXI (November^ 196

X 331-338 ~ _v shy

Buhl --- Leonard J and Janicp Volkmarui

^Pagicapatory

Deaocracy

- - shy

Netwbrfc gt as a Strategy for Changed Drban and Social-Change7ol 3 No 2 (Spring^ 1970gt ll-12t

5) i

I--

^ 1| CPLExchange Bibliography 2Ul

Editors Advocacy Planning and Hoto it Works itecture (September I960) 101-115

Progressive Archshy

V

Gilbert Heil and Joseph gt Eaton llaquoJho Speaks -for the Poor ^Journal-xof the Ameiican JEnstitute of Planners Vol XXXVI

(November 1970) lill-Wo I - - _

Hatch Richard C JSome -Thoughts on-Advocacy Planning Architecshytural Forum (June pound968)1 -72 laquo

Hyman Herbert ^planning with Citizens Two Styles Journal of the Amerioari Institute of Planners Vol XXXV (March1969)105-12 v

Kahh Alfred J Perspectives on Access to Social Senjices Social Work Journalyf the^Hatagnal Association of Social

Workers Vol 15 No- 2 (AprilV 1970j[-95-101 ^~~~

Kaplan Marshall Advocacy and the Urban Poor Journal of the American Institute of Planners Vol XXXV Ho 2 (March

I 96-101

Xeyes^ Langley C^ Jr and Sdirard Teitcher Tinritations laquoof Advoshy

cacy PlanningA Viqw from the Sstablistoaent Journal of the Anerican- Institute of Planners Vol XXXVI No Ii (July 197C) 225-226 v

i 7

-

V _ - gt w

Norton The Local jCoBBnunity as an Ecology of Games Americari Journal of Sociology Vol- 3U (March19^8)^ 80-87

v ^ r Theodore Decision Making vs Policy Kakingt Toward an Antishydote for Technocracy Pjjbiic_Admnisteati^_BBview- (MayJune1970) 31U-325

Lowry Sitctiie IP Power to the People Political Evolution or Revolution Urban and Social Change Review^ Vol 3gt No 2

gt (Spring 1970) 2-6 -

- Hashy Peter H and Dennis A Task Force Approach to Replacethe Planning Board J of the American Institute of Planners Vol XXX No 170961^

Ohlin amp Rein Social Planning for Institutional ChangeSocial Welfare Forum 85

The

Page Clinton Getting Involved Hews (Deceniber 1969) 28-37

Arcampitectural and Kngi neering

Peattie Lisa R Comraanity Drama and Advocacy Planning Journal of the American Insti-fote of Planners Vol 2XXVI No (Hovenber 1970)

=gtjv j - -

5 - CPL Exchange Bibliography 2lil

Peattie Lisa R Reflections on Advocacy Planning Journal of the American -Institute of Planners Vol XXXIV No 2 T

(Maroh 1965) 80-87 shy

Perloff Harvey New Directions in JSocial Planning Journal of theÂmerican Institute of Planners Vol XXXI (November 1S65) 297-303 - -

- - Piven Frances Fox Comprehensive Social Planning Curriculum

Reforffi or Professional Imperialism Journal of the American Institute of Planners Vol XXXVI Ho U (July 1970) 226-225 -7- ^

Van Til John and Sally B Citizen Participation in Social Policy The End of the Cycle Social Problems Vol 17 No 3

(Winter 1970) 313-323 ~ ^

Books raquo - o laquo - -

Altschuler Alan The City Planning Process A Political Analysis Ithaca Hew York Cornell University Press 1965

-

Angell Stephen L Jr Coalitions The Team Approach to Planning and Development1 in Planning 1970 Chicago American Society of Planning Officials (197O)7 210

^ - laquo

Barer Raymond A end Kenneth 5 Gergen (eds) The Study of Policy Formation New York The Free Press 198gt 370

Blecheri Sari H Advocacy Planning for Urban Development Mith Analysis of Six Demonstration ProgramsT Mew York Praeger Publishers 1971

DAntonio William t

V and Howard

J -

Ehrlich laquo

- Power and shy

in America -South Bend University of Hotre Dane Press7

Dont Mourn Organize SDS Guide to Community Organising San Fran-Cisco The Movement Press-(no date-given)

Hatchj-C Richard Urban Action pTannjng and Co 1970

Kahn Alfred J et al Heigfaborhood Infonaation Centers Hew 1 t York ColumbTa Diversity School of Social Work 19661

Englewood

Emerging CcHBtmity

6 CPL Exchange^ Bibliography

Cglesby-^Carl and Itichard ochaull Containment Change i-cw Yorfc Lacnillan Publishing Co|L967

Olson Ilancur Jr ^Ths Logic of Collective Actiog Public Goods and poundhg Theory of Groups few York Schockeh Books0-96 176

- ^ _ v OJI Collecikve The Organizers Hanual Hew tork Bantam Books

(1971i 305 - vgt -

Seelay John H Central Planning^ Prologue to a Critique Censhytrally Planned Change PrQspectoandl Concepts (ed) Robert Morris New York ilational Association jopound Social Workers 16U

- v - t Shelling Thomas C The Strategyôf Conflict- Canbridge Kass

Harvard University Press 1963 _

Spiegel Bans BCraquo(ed)- Citizen PartJcipation jn Urban Developshyment Vol H Uashington DCt HTL Institute for Applied Behavioral ScilaquoKJe (1969) 23^-273 1

-

Conteaporary Periodicals and Newsletters

Appleby Thomas KStizen Participation in theTO 1 s The Need to Turn to Politics The City Vol $ Ko 3 (JiayJune 1971)52-55 - - -

ein SheiT But lihiich Advocate Planner in Social-Policy Vol 1 Ho 2gt JvayJiugust 1970) 33-3^

Jirnstein irryIU

v t AronovatZj Stanley Roy Bennett Bennett W Berger and Sdgar Z

Friedenberg A Synposium Strategies for Radical Social Change Social Policy (HovemberDecember 1970)- 9-23

Caines RonaldsH An Invitation to SttidentsAdvocacy Planningfor the sSeventiesni repronted from American Institute of Planners Newsletter ^n^ date indicated)

^ Davidoff T-ifo and Paul KAdtocacy Planning Polarizes the Issues -

in Social Policy Vol 1 fto 2 (JulyAugust 1970) 3^-35

Davidoff Paul (interView) Community Planning and^the Advocate in the Suburbs in Planrtlng Comment Vol VH Ho 1

1971) 1shy

7 CPL Exchange Bibliography

IlartmafC Chester (interview) Ooramunity Planning and the Advoshycate in the City in Planning Comment Vol VII Ho 3 1 (Winter l7l)

15-22 laquo -

Hartmen Chester 17 The Advocate Plannee From Hired Gun 1 to Political Partisan in Social Policy Vol i No 2 (July August 1570) 37-38

Lazarus Simon^ Whos the Boss The New Republic Vol 16U (May 1971) 21-23

Piven Frances Fox Rejoinder Disruption Is Still the Decisive VJagOL^n Social Policy Vol 1 No 2 (JulyAugust 1970)

liO-Ul

Piven Frances Fox Vihom Doesthe Advocate Planner Serve in SocialPolicy Vol 1 No 1 (MayJune 1970)

Roberts Thomas H Advocacy ofPoor and Minority Interests in AIP Newsletter Vol 6 No 2 (February 1971) 2

lt Scribner Sylvia IJhat AreaVfor Advocacy in Social Policy Vol

1 No 2 (JulyAugust 1970) ij0 laquo

Starr Roger Advocators or Planners in ASPO Newsletter (American Society of Planning Officials Vol 334 Ho 11 (December 1967) 1-2

Vfisner Ben IAdvocacy and Geography The Case of Bostons Urban Planning Aid Antipode A Radical Journal of Geography 2 (August 1970) 25-29

Periodicali

Cahn S and J Cain The Warden Poverty A Civilian Perspective 73 TaleLJi 1317-133U (196U) ---

s ^ - ----Katin Ernest Advocate as Lawmaker Luis Kutner and the Struggle

for Due Process 23 U KLami L-Rev 397 (WinterSpring

Note Neighborhood Law Offices The New Wave in Legal Services for the Poor 8O garv L Rev 805 (1967)

8 degCPL Exchange Bibliography 2Ul

Reports and Studies

Carter Lisle Cx Jr Law andlaquotheUrban Crisis Division of Urban Studies Cornell University Article 28 1968 (reprintedfRom-UCLA Lav Review Volv 15 No hf June 1968)w j ^~ ~

Brooks Michael P Social Planning and -City Planning Planning Advisory Service Report No 261Chicago American Society

of Planning Officials (September 19Q)39rliU

Davidoff The Bluffs Advocate-Planning Comment Dept of CityPlanning -University of Pennsylvania (Spring 196$) 59shy

X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent

Initiative in Planning -

Offices Planning Advisory Service Report No 269 -

Chicago American Society of Planning Officials (ASP0) Hay 1971 ^ s shy

Hartman Chester W-and Jen Pynoos The Harvard Urban Field Sershyvice An Initial Report The Bulletin of the Association of

Collegiate Schools of Planning 7 (Spring 1969) It-11 - ^

Xravitzj Alan S Âdvocacy and Beyond Planning 1968 Chicago American Society-of i banning Officials 0-969 38-l|6

Uhlig Richard Plannini j in the Urban Environment Next Steps

- Social-Research and Jity Planning Cityof Philadelphia (Technical Report 1gt City of Philadelphia Community Research Program Julyl965)|

i

Urban Extension A Report on Experimental Programs Ford Foundation Office Reports EJ1 Madison Avenue

US^Department of Health Education and Welfare Services for People Report of-the TaskForce on Organization raquoof Social Services Washington DCrl968 (Duplicated) -gt

Proceedings and Conferences

Fifth Annual Conference of Planners for Equal Opportunity The Planneras Watchdog (April 17 1971) V

Proceedings of theNational Confc on Advocacy and Pluralistic Planning Dept of Urban Affairs Hunter College Hew York

- - - Froceedings National Conference on Law and Poverty 5gt7 The

0 Extension of Legal Services to the Poor (1966)

COUHCplusmnL ^ raquo OF fLAJOttMG -- LIBKARIANS -- gt - Sxcnange - gt gt- BiixLlograpcy-i - - ADVOCACY PLANK1HG ~ TOWARD THS DEEEOPlEIff OF THEORY AMD STRATfiGT

of El

-l

Council of Planning librarians EXCHANGE BIBLIOGRAPHY

CD

^ November 1971 laquoi

-1

laquo Advocacy Planning-Towqrd thebevelopment of Theory and Sfrofegy

Donald F Mazziptti 4 y Graduate Program in Urban and Regional Planning

University of Iowa

i

u S OEraquolaquoraquoTWENT Of M6ALTM EDUCATION a ELP ARC

NATIONAL INS1J1TUTE Of EDUCATION -raquo























shyA n_ -

= laquo -


r






6interest theories

















ieSiXff a Professhy

- V

raquo laquoK

A^

V - I




^ _ I- 3









82-92 ^^ r~~^ rrT~ - - ~ f





X 331-338 ~ _v shy


^Pagicapatory

Deaocracy

- - shy


5) i

I--



Progressive Archshy

V








I 96-101



i 7

-

V _ - gt w




gt (Spring 1970) 2-6 -



The




=gtjv j - -



(Maroh 1965) 80-87 shy





(Winter 1970) 313-323 ~ ^



-


^ - laquo



DAntonio William t

V and Howard

J -

Ehrlich laquo

- Power and shy





Englewood

Emerging CcHBtmity





(1971i 305 - vgt -





-




Jirnstein irryIU







1971) 1shy



15-22 laquo -




liO-Ul







Periodicali






Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l























shyA n_ -

= laquo -


r






6interest theories

















ieSiXff a Professhy

- V

raquo laquoK

A^

V - I




^ _ I- 3









82-92 ^^ r~~^ rrT~ - - ~ f





X 331-338 ~ _v shy


^Pagicapatory

Deaocracy

- - shy


5) i

I--



Progressive Archshy

V








I 96-101



i 7

-

V _ - gt w




gt (Spring 1970) 2-6 -



The




=gtjv j - -



(Maroh 1965) 80-87 shy





(Winter 1970) 313-323 ~ ^



-


^ - laquo



DAntonio William t

V and Howard

J -

Ehrlich laquo

- Power and shy





Englewood

Emerging CcHBtmity





(1971i 305 - vgt -





-




Jirnstein irryIU







1971) 1shy



15-22 laquo -




liO-Ul







Periodicali






Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l

- V

raquo laquoK

A^

V - I




^ _ I- 3









82-92 ^^ r~~^ rrT~ - - ~ f





X 331-338 ~ _v shy


^Pagicapatory

Deaocracy

- - shy


5) i

I--



Progressive Archshy

V








I 96-101



i 7

-

V _ - gt w




gt (Spring 1970) 2-6 -



The




=gtjv j - -



(Maroh 1965) 80-87 shy





(Winter 1970) 313-323 ~ ^



-


^ - laquo



DAntonio William t

V and Howard

J -

Ehrlich laquo

- Power and shy





Englewood

Emerging CcHBtmity





(1971i 305 - vgt -





-




Jirnstein irryIU







1971) 1shy



15-22 laquo -




liO-Ul







Periodicali






Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l



Progressive Archshy

V








I 96-101



i 7

-

V _ - gt w




gt (Spring 1970) 2-6 -



The




=gtjv j - -



(Maroh 1965) 80-87 shy





(Winter 1970) 313-323 ~ ^



-


^ - laquo



DAntonio William t

V and Howard

J -

Ehrlich laquo

- Power and shy





Englewood

Emerging CcHBtmity





(1971i 305 - vgt -





-




Jirnstein irryIU







1971) 1shy



15-22 laquo -




liO-Ul







Periodicali






Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l



(Maroh 1965) 80-87 shy





(Winter 1970) 313-323 ~ ^



-


^ - laquo



DAntonio William t

V and Howard

J -

Ehrlich laquo

- Power and shy





Englewood

Emerging CcHBtmity





(1971i 305 - vgt -





-




Jirnstein irryIU







1971) 1shy



15-22 laquo -




liO-Ul







Periodicali






Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l





(1971i 305 - vgt -





-




Jirnstein irryIU







1971) 1shy



15-22 laquo -




liO-Ul







Periodicali






Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l



15-22 laquo -




liO-Ul







Periodicali






Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l


Reports and Studies





X -

Finkler Sari

Dissent -

arii Independent









i









of El

-l

Advocacy Planning -- Toward the Development of Theory and … · 2019-02-11 · TITLE Advocacy...

Documents

Transcript of Advocacy Planning -- Toward the Development of Theory and … · 2019-02-11 · TITLE Advocacy...