Activities and barriers to education for elderly people and barriers to education for elderly people...
Transcript of Activities and barriers to education for elderly people and barriers to education for elderly people...
10 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
Jens Friebe and Bernhard Schmidt-Hertha
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople
Abstract: Adulteducationathigheragecanplayanimportantroleinthepreservationofautonomyandintheencouragementofsocialparticipationinlaterlife.Hence,frombothanindividualandsocietalperspective,itisimportanttopromotetheeducationalactivitiesoftheelderly.Activeelderlypeoplewithpositiveperceptionsofselfandageingmaintaintheirmentalandphysicalfitnesslevels,participateincommunityassociationsandpolitics,andengageinintergenerationaldialogue.Datafromarecentstudyclearlyshowtheinterrelationshipofindividualself-perceptionandtheperceptionofageingandpointtotherelevanceofbothconceptsforlearningandparticipatingineducationalactivities.Aspeopleage,theyparticipatelessandlessinfurthereducation.Thisisduenotonlytoindividuallearninghabits,butalsotothelackoflearningopportunitiesindifferentregionsandresidentialareas.Indistrictsthatareprimarilycomprisedofpeoplewithlowstandardsoflivingandloweducationand/ormigrationbackgrounds,thereisalackofsufficienteducationalstructures,whichhindersparticipationinadulteducationprograms.Qualitativeinterviewswitholderadultsindifferentdistrictsshowthatsocialenvironment,socialembeddedness,andindividualperspectivesofone’sownlearningabilitiesaffectlearningpossibilitiesandlearningreadiness.
Key words: perceptionofageing,self-perception,livingconditions,socialenvironment,biography
UDC: 374.7
Scientificarticle
Jens Friebe, Ph.D., Research Associate at the German Institute for Adult Education, Leibniz Centre for Lifelong learning, Heinemannstr. 12-14, 53175 Bonn, Germany; e-mail for correspondence: [email protected]
Bernhard Schmidt-Hertha, Ph.D., University of Tuebingen, Institute for Education, Muenzgasse 11, 72070 Tuebingen, Germany; E-mail for correspondence: [email protected]
JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013,10–26
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 11
Introduction
Educationalactivitiesduringthelaterstagesoflifeareasignificantpartofdailylivingoftheelderly.Newchallenges,usefulactivitiesandwell-beingatanolderagerequireindividualactivitiesandtheutilizationofpersonalcreativity.Researchonageingshowsgreatinterindividualdifferencebetweenthelivingsituationsandlifestylesoftheelderly.Thesocialdimensionofinequalityhasaparticularinfluenceoneducationalchoices.Ingeneral,atanolderage,issuesofeverydaylifearemetbypotentialsandcompetencies,whichallowforanauto-nomousandsociallyparticipativelife.Thesepotentialscanbedevelopedandsupportedbylocaleducationalprogrammes.Unfortunately,manybarriersimpaireducationalaccessfortheelderlyincludingexteriorbarriers,suchassuitableeducationalinstitutionsandprogrammesfortheelderly,andinteriorbarriers,suchasalackofmotivationandself-confidence.
Thispaperdescribestheeducationalopportunitiesandbarriersforagroupofelderlyindividuals65yearsorolderbasedonthepartialresultsoftheCompeten-ciesinLaterLife(CiLL)researchproject.Inaddition,outcomesoftheEducationforElderly(EdAge)study,conductedbytheLudwig-Maximilians-UniversityinMunichandtheGermanInstituteforAdultEducation,aretakenintoaccount.Significantinfluentialfactorsonthegroup’seducationalbehaviourswerenotedbasedonimagesofageandself-perception,aswellassocio-historicalbackgrounds.Thisinformationcanassistadulteducatorsinthedevelopmentofregionaledu-cationalprogrammeswithandfortheelderly.
Theoretical background: Later life and individual experience
Anageingpopulationisoftenlinkedwithadecreaseinsocialadaptability,butthispointofviewignoresthepotentialandlearningcapabilitiesofolderadults(Baltes1992;Lehr2005).Therefore,itisimportanttosupportthepotentialofolderpeopletoleadactiveandparticipatorylivesthrougheducationandtorecognizethebenefitsoftheirknowledge,experience,andcompetencies.
12 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
Thediscourseonlifelonglearningnecessarilyleadstoquestionsconcerningtheimpactofoldageasaphaseoflifeonthepreservationoflearningabilitiesandcompetencies.Researchonlifelonglearningshowsthattoachievegreaterflexibilityinlifecourses,newstrategiesfortheconstructionandintegrationofknowledgearerequired.Theprerequisitesforthisprocessofactivecompetencydevelopmentarenotthesameamongolderpeople(FindsenandFormosa2011).Theage-basedconfigurationoflivingenvironments,individualhealth,positiveimagesofageing,andacontinuousparticipationinlifelonglearningareimportantfactorsinenablingoldermenandwomentomaintainindependentlifestyles.
Retirementchangesfromalifephaseofconsumptionandleisuretimetoaphaseofsocietalparticipation.Copingwithage-relateddevelopmentaltasksbecomesanincreasinglyimportantissueinoldage(Kruse2008).Takingpartingainfulemploymentandcivicengagement,aswellassupportingone’sownfamily,allowsolderpeopletoparticipateinsociety.Adulteducationplaysanimportantroleindevelopingtheabilitiesandthemotivationforsocialcommitmentinoldage.Olderpeoplewithmoreeducationandthosewhomoreoftenparticipateinadulteducationprogramsoftenshowahigherdegreeofcommitment.Theoppositealsoholdstrue;civicorsocialengagementcantriggerlearningprocessesifolderadultsareconfrontedwithnewchallengesandcompetencydemandsthroughtheseactivities(Tippeltetal.2009).
Educationnotonlycreatesprerequisitesforparticipationindifferentfieldsofsociallife;itisalsothefirststeptowardanactiveprocessofageing.Therefore,weareinneedofresearchfocusingontheequalityorinequalityofopportunitiesforolderpeopletoparticipateinadulteducationthatalsotakesintoaccountregionalandindividualdifferences.
However,educationalactivities fortheelderlyarehighlydependentontheirdifferentbiographicalandsocialcircumstances.Educationalinterestsandlearningattitudesareaffectedbyearlyeducationalexperiencesgainedinschoolorduringvocationaltrainingandbypreviousadulteducationactivities(Schmidt2007).Opportunitiestoparticipateinformalandnonformallearninghavebeenandstillarehighlydivergentfordifferentgenerationsandforpeoplefromdif-ferentsocialbackgrounds(Schmidt-Hertha,inpress).Thisiswhynotonlyanindividualbiography,butalsotheconditionsofbasiceducation(schoolsystem,educationalinfrastructure,authoritarianteachers,etc.)specifictoeachgenera-tioninfluenceboththewillingnesstoparticipateinlifelonglearningandlearningabilities,eveninolderage.Commongenerationalexperiences,asanchoredinthehistoricalandculturalbackground(Mannheim1928),probablyaffectindividualperceptionsofageingjustasindividuals’biographiesandcurrentlivingconditionsdo.Self-perceptionandindividualimagesofageingareimportantindicatorsforeducationalactivitiesandshouldalsobeseenasproductsofbiographicalexperi-ences,individuallivingconditions,andcultural-historicalcontexts(deGracioetal.2004;LevyandSchlesinger2005).Thiscomplexinteractionofsocialenviron-ment,individualresources,beliefs,attitudes,andeducationalbehaviourcannotbeexplainedinsimplecausalities;rather,itrequiresanin-depthanalysisthatcanbeprovidedusingaqualitativeapproach.
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 13
Furthermore,researchonperceptionsofagehasrevealedaninterrelationbetweennegativestereotypesaboutageingandself-perceptionsinolderage.Thetheoryofself-stereotypingisbasedontheassumptionthatnegativeimagesofageingare,atleastpartly,transferredtoindividualself-perceptionasanindi-vidualages(Levy2003).Eventhoughonlyminordifferencesinimagesofageingbetweenyoungerandolderadultshavebeenidentified,theirideasaboutageingseemtobecomeoperativeonceadultscountthemselvesamongtheelderly.Generalstereotypesarethentransferredmoreorlessunmodifiedtoone’sownself-concept(seeibid.).Theperceptionofindividualgainsandlossesrelatedtoageisbiasedinthesensethatitbecomesaself-fulfillingprophecy(Merton1948),particularlywhenexpectedlossesareoverratedandgainsgounnoticed.Nevertheless,studiesshowthatself-stereotypingisonlyoneaspectthathelpsexplainthedevelop-mentofperceptionsofageingamongolderadults;psychologicalwell-beingandsatisfactionwithone’shealthareotherinteractingfactors(Schmitt2004).Theinterrelationbetweenwell-being,subjectiveevaluationofhealth,andperceptionofageingseemstobeareciprocalone.Asimilarinteractionhasalsobeennotedamongself-concept,self-perception,andperceptionofageing.Thereisevidencethatperceptionofageingaffectsthesefactors(e.g.,Oryetal.2003),asitisfortheconversecausality(deGracioetal.2004;RothermundandBrandtstädter2003).Basedontheresultsofthesestudies,theconceptofself-fulfillingpropheciescouldbeagoodvehicletoexplaintheinteractionsdiscovered.
Empirical background: The Competencies in Later Life study
Attheendof2009,theresearchprojectCompetencies in Later Life(CiLL)waslaunchedinGermanytoexaminethecompetenciesofolderadultsandtheirlearningactivitiesandtoexploretheinterrelationofthesefactors.Livingcondi-tions,socialnetworks,challengesofeverydaylife,andeducationalbiographiesoftheolderadultswerealsotakenintoaccount.Thestudy,whichiscurrentlyongoing,focusesonagroupofadults65to80yearsoldandcombinesaquantita-tiveassessmentofadultcompetencieswithqualitativecasestudies.Thestudyismeanttoprovideinformationonthecompetencydemandsinlaterlifeandonthegainsandlossesinthesecompetenciesinoldagewithrespecttocurrentlivingconditionsandbiographicalexperiences.
Thecoreofthestudywasformedusingacombinationofquantitativeas-sessmentsandquestionnairesandqualitativecasestudiesflankedbyin-depthinternationaldesktopresearch.Themainchallengeofthecasestudiesistolinktheresultswithenquiriesofformerstudies–especiallytheEdAgestudyandtheAdultEducationSurvey–andtofundamentallycomparethemtoresultsstem-mingfromthequantitativecompetencyassessment.Inthispaper,wewouldliketofocusonthequalitativepartofthestudy,whichconsistsof42casestudiesofolderadultswithdifferentlivingconditions.
Themainpurposeofthecasestudiesistogatherdataonlivingconditions,onolderadults’everydaylifestyles,andontheneedforspecificcompetenciesarising
14 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
fromtheindividuallifestylesandattitudes.Thequalitativecasestudiesmakeuseofthecase-reconstructiveresearchstrategy(Hildenbrand1991),focusingontherelationbetweengeneralandparticularelementsofeverysinglecase.Thepro-cessesofstrugglingwitheverydaypracticaldemandsandchallenges,individualselection,andinterpretationformthestructureofacase.Thisstructureincludesabasichabitualwayoflookingatone’sworld,ofinterpretingit,andofactinginandinteractingwiththisworld.
Inordertogaindeeperinsightintothisworldoflearningprocessesandcom-petencyrequirementsembeddedindailyroutinesorinitiatedbycriticaleventsinlife,adescriptivequalitativeanalysisusingthemethodofcontentanalysisdevel-opedbyMayring(2003)wascarriedout.Theinterviewswerefullytranscribed,andacomplextheoreticallysoundsystemofcodingwasdeveloped.Subsequently,eachcodingwasattachedtothematerial.Inordertoverifytheaccuracyoftheintercoderagreementresp.interpretiveconvergence(Saldana2008,p.27),someinterviewswereanalyzedbythreeormoreresearchers,andmorethanhalfoftheinterviewswereanalyzedbeatleasttworesearchers.Whendealingwiththetranscriptions,additionalcodesweredevelopedandotherswerepooledorchanged.Finally,asystemof47codeswasappliedtoall42interviews.
TheCiLLstudyalsoincludesastudyparalleltotheGermanProgramforInternationalAssessmentofAdultCompetenciesProgram.PIAACwasorganizedbytheOECDtoassessthelevelanddistributionofadultskillsinthreecompetencydomainsforadultsupto64yearsoldin23countries(Literacy,Numeracy … 2012).CiLLprovidesanadditionalsampleforthe65-to80-year-oldadultsinGermanyusingthesamemethodstodeliverdatainawaythatiscoherentandconsistenttotheGermanPIAACsample.PIAACusesarepresentativesample,andthis,ofcourse,shouldalsoholdforthesampleofthe66-to80-year-oldadults.
Atotalof3,600seniorcitizensin111municipalitieswererandomlyselectedfromlistsheldatGermanregistrationoffices.NinetyTNSInfratestinterviewerswereactivenationwide,and1,325interviewswereconducted,whichequalsaresponserateof38%.ThedataforCiLLwerecollectedusinganelaborateback-groundquestionnaire,whichcoveredsocio-demographicdataandinformationoneducationalandqualificationprocesses,aswellaslabourstatus(includingpreviousemployment).Subsequently,PIAACincludedthreecentraladultcom-petencedomains: literacy,numeracy,andproblem-solvingintechnology-richenvironments.Respondentswithcomputerskillsansweredthetestquestionsbyuseofalaptop;allotherrespondentswereissuedtestbooklets.Almost30%oftheelderlyrespondentschosethecomputerforansweringthequestions.ToensuretheinternationalcomparabilityofthePIAACstudy,includingtheadditionalsampleofolderadults,neitherthequestionnairenorthecompetencytestscanberead-justedforthesampleofthoseaged66to80.ThedesignofPIAACwasarrangedinsuchawaythatexactlythesameprogramwithexactlythesameinstrumentswasadministeredinallparticipatingcountriesinordertoavoidallpossiblebiaseffects.Currently,thequantitativestepoftheresearchprojectisinthedatacol-lectionphase,butresultswillnotbereadyuntil2014.
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 15
IthasnotyetbeendecidedwhetherthePIAACwillbecontinuedafterthisfirstsurvey.Apanelstudyonthecompetenciesofadultswouldbeofparticularvaluetoeducationalresearchbecauseitwouldprovideindicatorstodifferentiateageeffects,cohorteffects,andperiodicaleffectsonthecompetenciesofadults.Forresearchontheparticipationofolderadultsineducationandinlearning,itwouldbeofgreatimportancetorelinquishtheestablishedfocusonthelabourforceandtosystematicallyincludepeopleabovetheageof64,notonlyinindividualnationalsurveys,butalsointheinternationalstudies.
Self-perception and images of ageing and their meaning for learning and competency development
Dependingontheirperceptionsoftheirownlearningcapabilitiesandtheirpotentialforpersonaldevelopment,adultsaremoreorlessopentonewlearningexperiencesandwillingtogetinvolvedineducationalprocesses.Thisfurtherdependsontheirself-perceptionandwhethertheyseethemselvesasactivedesignersoftheirownenvironmentoraspowerlessvictimsoftheirfate(Cross1981).Ofcourse,therearesomemorepredictorsforeducationalbehaviour,suchassituationalfactors,currentcircumstancesofliving,structureofofferingsandeducationalbarriers,socialandvocationalbackground,andnotonlyage.Withoutafundamentalunderstandingofone’sowneducationalcapabilitiesandabeliefinthepoweroflearningtowidenone’scapabilitytoact,participationineducationalactivitiesanddirectedcompetencydevelopmentareveryunlikely.Therefore,therelevanceofpersonalperceptionsofselfandageingtolearninganddevelopmentoftheelderlyisclearbutremainsascientificallyunexploredarea.
Accordingtothe6thReportonAgeingcoordinatedbytheGermangovernment,theartofliving,subjectivewell-being,readinessforsocialengagement,andopen-nesstoeducationalopportunitiesandlearningpossibilitiesarehighlydependentonone’sself-perceptionandimagesrelatedtoageasaphaseoflife(e.g.,WurmandHuxhold2012).Inotherwords,imagesofageingseemtobeaffectedbyone’sprecedingeducationalexperiences,biography,socialcircumstances,andcurrentlivingconditions.Ifsubjectiveideasofageinginfluencethewillingnessofolderadultstoparticipateinnonformalorinformallearningandiftheseideasevenfitwiththemostimportantpredictorsforeducationalparticipationofolderadults(Tippelt,SchmidtandKuwan2009),thenpossibilitiesofcompetencedevelopmentinhigheragearealsolimitedorbroadenedbythem.Inretrospect,theinfluenceofprecedingeducationalexperiencesonself-perceptionandagestereotypescausesonetoexpectamorepositiveperceptionofselfandageforpersonswithhigherlevelsofcompetence(Schmidt-HerthaandMühlbauer2012).However,whichfieldsofcompetenciescouldplayaroleinthisrelationshipandhowfarthesecompetenciescouldbealteredremainunclear.
Theoretically,therearestrongargumentsforaconnectionbetweencompeten-cies,competencydevelopment,andlearninginolderage,aswellasperceptionsofselfandone´sownageingprocess(Schmidt2010).However,notenoughempirical
16 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
evidenceforthiscorrelationhasbeencollectedsofar.Thecausality,inparticular,remainsunclear,andalthoughcomplexinterdependenciesaretobeexpected,theyhavenotbeenexplored.
Onedevelopmentthatclearlypointstothesignificanceofself-perceptionsforlearningactivitiesisPatriciaCross’(1981)chain-of-responsemodel,whichindicatesthatindividualself-evaluationisthefirstcentralstepintheprocessofmakingeducationaldecisions.Evenbeforeattitudestowardeducation,currentinterests,aims,andlearningopportunitiesbecomeimportantforparticipationornonparticipation inadulteducationprograms,theperceptionofpersonallearningabilitiesandlearningstylesiscrucialforthedecisioneitherinfavouroforagainstpursuingfurtherlearning.Whenitcomestotheelderly,imagesofageingarehighlyrelevanttotheevaluationofone’sownlearningabilities,asisself-perceptionforallagegroups.
Ourqualitativeinterviewsprovideaninformativebasisforanalyzingtheinteractionofimagesofageing,perceptionofolderageasaphaseoflife,andself-concept,aswellastherealizationoflearningpossibilities.Onlysomeexplorativeapproachesaregivenhere,providingdirectionandstimuliforfurtherresearch.
Self-perception and perception of ageing
Firstly,statementsrelatedtoself-perceptionandself-conceptandstatementsrelatedtoperceptionofageinghavebeendifferentiated.Bothkindsofstatementsarebynomeansindependentfromeachother,butwithinoursample,wefoundsomeparticipantswhoseideasabouthigherageasaphaseoflifewere(still)onlyverylooselyrelatedtotheirownpersonalityandself-perceptionandsomepar-ticipantswhonoticedcharacteristicsandprocesseswithintheirownpersonalitythattheycouldtracebacktohigherageandthatcouldaffecttheirself-perceptionatleastinsofarastheydifferentiatedbetweenthepresentandthepastwhenitcametodescribingtheirownpersonalityandsociallocalization.Thestatementsofolderrespondentswithastronglinktoself-perceptionpointtothreegroupswithverydifferentself-concepts.Thegroupshavebeenidentifiedbyacomparativeanalysisoftheinterviewsandfollowingtheprinciplesofmaximumhomogeneitywithinthegroupsandamaximumheterogeneitybetweenthem.However,whatwedescribeinthefollowingsectioncanbeseenasempiricallybasedidealtypesinthetraditionofMaxWeber(1922;seealsoSchmidtandTippelt2011).
– Themakerssawthemselvesastheonestobringthingsforward,whoinitiateinnovation,andwhomakedecisions.Withinthisrole,theyexperiencedthesignificanceoftheirownpersonintheirprivateand(former)vocationalenvironment.Theyoftendescribedthemselvesastalentedinseveralareas,competentindifferentfieldsofapplication,andsuccessfulinacting.Thereweremaleandfemaleseniorsofdifferentagesanddifferentlevelsofschoolinginthisgroup.Overall,itseemsthatself-perceptionispoorlyrelatedwithsocio-demographicvariables.
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 17
– Thehelperssawthemselvesnotsomuchastheonestoinitiatechanges,butasfacilitatorsandhelpersinthebackground,whichisanecessaryroletokeepthingsfunctioningsmoothly.Hardworkandahighlevelofaltruismwerefundamentaldescriptionsoftheirself-perception.Accordingtotheseparticipants,iftheyareunabletohelpothers,thentheyneedtoprovideanexcuse,evenifthereasonsarerelatedtohealthproblems.Incontrasttothemakers,thepredominantlyfemalehelpersalsosharedathemeofsettinglimitsoftheirowncapabilities.
– Finally,weidentifiedagroupofolderadultswhocouldbecharacterizedasdrivenbycircumstances.Theydescribedtheirformerandcurrentbehaviourasamoreorlessreactiveresponsestodifficultsituationsandproblematicbreaksintheirlives.Theseparticipantsstatedthattheyusuallysaweventsastroublesomenecessitiestomaintaintheirstandardofliving.Theyreferredtotheirownweaknessesanddeficitsmuchmoreoftenthantheothergroups;theyalsocomplainedaboutalackofself-confidence.
Someoftheintervieweespointedoutthepositiveaspectsofageingingeneralandespeciallyinrelationtopersonalage,whileothersfocusedonthenegativeaspectsofageingorshowedanambivalentperceptionofage.Atfirstglance,norelationshipisseenbetweenperceptionsofageingandself-perception.Whileper-sonswithapositiveconceptofageingratedphysicaldeclineaslessrelevantbutstressedthequalityandbenefitsofoldage,otherswithamorenegativeconceptofageingsawphysicaldeclineasthebeginningofasteadyandirreversibledevelop-ment.Anambivalentconceptofageingwascharacterizedbythesimultaneityofdevelopmentalgainsandlosses.Intervieweeswithanambivalentperceptionofoldageparticularlypointedtotheireffortstopreventfurthercognitiveandphysicaldecline.Thisattitude,whichstressesthenecessityandeffectivenessofdifferentkindsofpreventiveactivities,seemstobepartoftheageingconceptssharedbymanyolderadults(Schmidt2010)butisacentralfocusforpersonswithanambi-valentperceptionofoldage.Incontrast,thelinktoaspecialqualityofhigheragecanprimarilybefoundamongadultswithapositiveperceptionofageing.Mostparticipantswithanegativeperceptionofageingemphasizedtheirreversibilityofdeclineinoldage.Onceagain,theredidnotappeartobeanysystematicdif-ferencesbetweenthethreeapproachestoageingandtheinterviewees’sex,age,familystatus,orlevelofschooling.
Asynopsisofthedifferentperceptionsofselfandageingwasperformedfor26intervieweesinreferencetobothconcepts,whilecommentsfrom18furtherintervieweescouldonlybededicatedtooneornoneoftheconcepts.Table1showsthedifferentcombinationsofself-perceptionandimagesofageing,astheycanbefoundintheempiricalmaterial.
18 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
Maker Helper DrivenPositiveperceptionofageing 4 – –Ambivalentperceptionofageing 4 9 3Negativeperceptionofageing 4 1 1
Table 1: Allocation of self-perception and perception of ageing within the interviews
Withinthegroupofhelpersandthegroupofthedrivenolderadults,anambivalentperceptionofageingwasdominant.Incontrast,themakersshowednodominantorientationwhenlookingattheir imageofageing.Asthelinesbetweenthedifferentconceptsofageingcannotbedrawnstrictlyselectively,apartialaggregationofdifferentcombinationsseemstobejustifiablewhenitistakenintoaccountthatdifferencesbetweenthefouraggregatedgroupsareallthemorevisible.
Self-perception and learning
Withinthegroupofmakers withapositiveperceptionofageing,onlytheolderparticipantswhoperceivedthemselvestostillbeactivedesignersindicatedthattheysometimesmadeuseoforganizededucationalprograms.Theintervieweessoughtlearninginadulteducationcentres(Volkshochschulen),third-ageuniversi-ties,andothersimilaradulteducationagenciesaswellasthroughself-regulatedlearningactivitiesusingdifferentformsofmedia(e.g.,theInternetorbooks)andinteractingwiththeirsocialenvironment.Thesekindsofinformallearningareoftenrelatedtodailylifeproblemsbutcanalsostemfromaninterestinacertaintopic.Theseinterestsusuallyresultfromasearchfornewchallengesorarecompletelyindependentfromcurrentdemandsofaction.
The makers withanegativeperceptionofageingprimarilyfocusedonthepastandexclusivelyidentifiedinformalcontextsaslearningopportunities.Onceagain,interactionswithfriendsandrelativesandespeciallytheuseofmediawerecentralfortheirlearning.Inparticular,booksandtelevisionwerementionedinwhichthecontenthadacloserelationtodailylifebutwasnotalwayslinkedtoaparticularproblem.
Forthehelpers, learningwas linkedtoeffortandhardwork.Theysawlearningasanabsolutelynecessaryinvestmentoftimeandpowerforsolvingcurrentproblems.Learningheremeansself-directedlearning,oftenbytrialanderror(e.g.,whendealingwithnewtechnologiesandmachines).Afterthesegoal-orientedformsoflearning,whicharerelatedtosituationalchallenges,incidentallearningthenplaysanimportantroleinincreasingtheirowncapacitytoact.
Incidentalandnonintentionalformsoflearning(seealsoDohmen2001,p.44)dominatedthelearningactivitieswithinthegroupofthedrivens.Respondentsonlymentionedinformallearningthat,inmostcases,wasnotinitiatedconsciously.Inthiscontext,learningseemstobenomorethanabyproductofproblem-solving,inwhichlearnersseethemselvesasreactingtoacertainsituation,butnotcon-structivelyarrangingit.
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 19
Analysisofthequalitativeinterviewswitholderadultscannotverifytherela-tionshipbetweenperceptionofageingandself-perceptionasdocumentedinotherstudies(e.g.,RothermundandBrandstaedter,2003)forseveralreasons,suchasthecross-sectionaldesign.However,interactionshavebecomevisiblethatpointtoadifferentrelevanceoftheperceptionofageingdependingonone’sself-perception.Inparticular,olderadultswhosawthemselvesasactivedesignersoftheirlivingenvironmentshowedastrongerbackwardorientationwhentheyhavenegativeimagesofageandageing.Thisgrouptendedtoprimarilyconnectself-perceptionandself-confidencetoactivitiesandoccurrencesinthepast.Theyexperiencedtheircurrentphaseoflifeasaslowandunintendedwithdrawalfrombeingacentralactorintheirsocialandprofessionalfield.Incontrast,self-perceptioninothergroupsseemedtobeinfluencedlessbyperceptionsofageingiftheindividualssawthemselvesmoreasfacilitatorsorinapassiveroleindifferentcontextsofdailylife.Nevertheless,thisisprimarilydescriptiveevidencewithveryinitialresults;closeranalysiswithalongitudinaldimensionisneeded.
Furtherdataanalysisshowsthatopportunitiesandstrategiestodevelopcompetenciesareonlypartlyrelatedtoperceptionsofselfandageing.Thisrela-tionshipseemstobemediatedbylifestyleandthehandlingofdailychallenges.Theolderadultswhostillsawthemselvesascentralprotagonistsintheirlivingenvironmentwereautonomouslylookingfornewchallengesandfieldsoflearningthatwerelinkedtotheircompetencies.Otherssawthemselvesconfrontedwithtasksrelatedtolearningandcompetencedevelopmentwhentheygaveahelpinghandasfacilitatorsintheirsocialproximity.Incontrast,olderadultswhosawthemselvesasvictimsoflifecircumstancesorwhohadnegativeagestereotypesandwerefocusedontheirowndevelopmentallossestendedtoavoidnewterrain,preferringtomovewithinsurroundingstheywerefamiliarwith.Forthem,thismeansaminimumofrisksbutalsoaminimumofnewlearningopportunities.
Themotivesforthisbehaviourremainunclear.Further,ourdatacannottellushowfarexistingcompetenciesanddevelopmentalpotentialinfluenceone’slifestyleorifcompetencydevelopmentinhigherageistheproductofanactivelifestyle.Anotherunresolvedquestioniswhetherpositiveperceptionsofselfandageingaccountforalifestylethatpromotesdevelopmentalgainsoriftheseposi-tiveperceptionsaretheproductofanindividuallifestyle.Otherstudiespointtoareciprocalrelationbetweenperceptionsofageingandlifestyle(Schmidt-HerthaandMühlbauer2012;SachverständigenkommissionAltenberichterstattung2010)aswellastoarelationshipbetweenlifestyleandcompetencydevelopmentintheelderly(Kruse2010;Tippeltetal.2009).Anunderstandingofself-perceptionsandpersonalimagesofageinginthecontextoflearningandcompetencydevelopmenthastobetakenintoaccountwhenitcomestointerpretingtheresultsofcompe-tencyassessments.Eveniftheresultspresentedhavetofirstbeconsideredfromanexplorativeapproach,theyprovidevaluableevidencefortakingacloserlookatperceptionsofselfandageingineducationalresearch.
Ithasbecomeevidentthatperceptionsofageingarenotonlyaproductofindividualbiographyandlifestyle,butarealsoinfluencedbyculturalandhistoricalbackgrounds.ThesamplefromtheCiLLstudywascomprisedofagenerationof
20 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
adultswhowerebornbeforeorduringWorldWarIIandwhowereassumedtohavecommonattitudesandinterpretationpatterns(Mannheim1928);thiscom-monalitymayalsoinfluenceperceptionsofselfandageing.
Educational behaviour of older adults with regard to social and historical development
IntherandomsamplesfromtheCiLLstudy,participantsbetweentheagesof66and80wereinterviewed(thosebornbetween1931and1946).Thoseinthisagegroupweresignificantlycharacterizedbythehistoriceventsduringthewarandpost-warperiods.Agenerationaleffectwasapparentthatcouldbedescribedas“warandpost-warchildren”(Radebold2005).Therefore,a“socio-historicalgene-rationterm”(Franz2011)wasusedforcharacterizingthisparticularagegroup.
Historical background
Intheearly1930s,largepartsofGermany’sworkingclasssankintopovertyasaresultoftheGreatDepressionandhighratesofunemployment.Politically,theeconomicsituationpavedthegroundfortheupcomingNationalSocialisteraandHitler’sassumptionofpowerin1933.ThetotalitarianregimeannihilateditsopponentsandtriggeredWorldWarIIwiththeinvasionofPoland.Theeducationalsystemwaspushedasidetofocusonwarinterests.Theoldergenerationquestionedinthestudywerechildrenduringthesewaryears.TheyheardofthedeathsoftheirrelativesandenduredairraidsonGermancitiesin1943.Startingin1944,awaveofrefugeesleftGermanyandoccupiedEasternterritories.TheGermanpopulationinRussia,Poland,andCzechoslovakiawasparticularlyaffected,andmanyGermansescapedfromEasttoWestGermany.TheyoungerparticipantsoftheCiLLstudywerebornafterGermanysurrendered,buttheirearlylivingenvironmentwasalsocharacterizedbythedistressandruinofpost-warGermany.
Afterthewarended,lifeintheFederalRepublicofGermanywasverydifferentthanlifeintheGermanDemocraticRepublic.Withalliedhelp,WestGermanyexperiencedaneconomicrecovery,whereasEastGermanyfacedalackofconsumergoodsandemigration.TheeducationalsystemsinWestandEastGermanyalsodivergedconsiderably.Thesurveyedgenerationstartedtheirprofessionalliveswithlittleformaleducation.Schoolsanduniversitieswerenotinoperationduringthelastwaryearsandrightafterthewarasthebuildingshadbeendestroyedandtherewasalackofteachingstaff.Reconstructionrequiredmanyspecialists,whowereoftenonlysemi-skilledorhadbecomequalifiedafterashorttrainingperiod.Manyparticipantsofthesurveyedgroupsuccessfullyheldimportantpositionswithoutadequateformalqualification.Inthelate1950s,educationalexpansioninWestGermanyrestrengthenedtheconnectionbetweeneducationandprofessionalcareers.Thesurveyedgroupenjoyedfairlysecurepositionsintimesoffullemploymentandwaslittleaffectedbytheupcomingeconomiccrisisduringthe1970sand1980s.Unemploymentwascontrolledbyretiringworkers
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 21
earlywithatransitionalagreementattheageof55,firstinWestGermanyandlaterinEasternGermanyaswell.
Intheirlateprofessionalyearsandduringretirement,thesurveyedparti-cipantswerefarlessactiveeducationallyincomparisontoyoungerpeople.TheReportingSystemonContinuingEducationconfirmsthatthistrendwascommoninWestGermany(RosenbladtandBilger2008,p.227).However,ageisnottheonlyreasonforalowlevelofparticipationincontinuingeducation.Theeducationalbehaviourofseniorcitizensprovestoberathercomplex.Schoolqualificationsandprofessionalpositionsstronglyinfluenceparticipationincontinuingeducation.Thosebetweentheagesof55and64withalowlevelofeducationaland/orpro-fessionalqualificationsrarelyparticipateincontinuingeducation(Tippeltetal.2009,p.57).Womenareparticularlyunderrepresentedinvocationalcontinuingeducation(ibid,p.43)orstatethattheirparticipationincontinuingeducationisimpairedbydomestictasks(KollandandAhmadi2010,p.60).Educationalbehaviouris influencedbysocio-historicaldevelopmentaswellasbiographicfactors.InmanyinterviewsconductedduringtheCiLLstudy,theimportanceofstartingafamilyandthebirthofchildrenandgrandchildrenwasemphasized.Livingsituationandcriticaleventswerealsoregardedassignificantinfluencesonlearninginoldage.
Current life situations and barriers to continuing education
Gerontologyfrequentlypointsoutthesignificantindividualdifferencesoflifesituationsandlifestylesoftheelderly(Backesetal.2004).Lifeandeducationalbehaviourinoldagearenotonlyinfluencedbysocialdifferences,butalsobyin-equalities.Alongwitheducationalparticipation,necessaryresourcesforindividualadaptation,aswellastheadaptationoftheenvironment,tocriticaleventsvary.Thetopics“turningpointinlife,”“criticallifeevents,”and“crises”wereincludedintheCiLLsurvey.Turningpoints,suchasretirementorthechild-carephase–wereseenaslessburdensomethancriticallifeevents.Criticallifeeventswereoftenrelatedtothelossofcloserelationships,suchasthroughillnessordeathofalifepartner.Criticallifeeventsruntheriskofturningintoasignificantlifecrisisiftherespondentbecomesillorneedy.Singleandchildlessseniorcitizens(Schnurr2010)areparticularlyvulnerableforcriseswhenevertheirsocialnet-workbecomesbrittle.Inthiscontext,thefamilylivingsituationisanessentialfactorofcoping.Manyrespondentsstressedtheimportanceofmaintainingtheirfamilycontacts,andseniorcitizensinnursinghomesparticularlycomplainedabouttheirlivingsituations.
Incomparisontoyoungeragegroups,seniorcitizensaremorelikelytobeconfrontedwithcircumstancesthatinhibitanindependentlifestyle(Sachverstän-digenkommissionAltenberichterstattung2010).ThreetypicalriskconstellationsaredepictedbasedonthevoluntaryinformationsurveyedintheCiLLstudy–thelivingsituationofseniorcitizens,materialchanges,andneedforcare.Continuingeducationcanplayanimportantroleintheproblem-solvingprocessindifferentlifesituations.
22 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
– Livingspaceandenvironmentbecomeincreasinglysignificantatanolderageduetodecreasingmobilityandtheresultingincreasingimportanceofaccessibilityofservicestructures.Socialinteractionsoftenoccurwithinthelivingquartersatthepolitical,social,leisure,andeducationallevels.Inthissituation,therisksaresocialexclusion(Kronauer2010)andthateducationalactivitiesareoftendistributedratherdifferentlydependingonthelivingareainacity,district,orsocialquarter.
– Theearlyexclusionofseniorcitizensfromtheworkprocess,theincreasedretirementage,andtemporaryunemploymenthavenegativeeffectsonreti-rementincome.Asaresult,impoverishmentamongtheelderlywilllikelyincreaseoverthecomingyearsandleadtonumerousdisadvantages,whicharelikelytohaveanegativeeffectoneducationalparticipation(Friebe2010).
– Ageoftenalsoholdstheriskofillness,physicalimpairment,andtheneedforcare.Thesesituationsalsoendangersocialinclusionandbeartheriskoftheelderlybeingunabletocopewiththesevariousburdens.Socialcontactsarereduced,suchasinthecaseofdementia,notonlyfortheindividual,butalsoforhisorherfamily.Familieswithsufficientfinancialsupportcantakeadvantageofexternalsupportandprovideopportunitiesfortheelderlyindividualtoparticipatemoreoftenineducationalevents.
Thelifeconstellationsmentionedoftenserveasbarrierstoeducationalpar-ticipationfortheelderly(RosenbladtandBilger2008,p.151).Theirfinancialsitu-ation,aswellasalackofinformationandcompetency,canintensifytheproblemsassociatedwitholdage.Still,whiletheselifeconstellationshaverisks,theyalsoofferopportunitiesofinclusionforseniorcitizens.Livinginestablishedworking-classneighbourhoodscanprovidemoreresources,suchasmutualsupportandlearning,thanlivinginnewlybuiltdevelopments.Dealingwithissuesofmaintaininghealthcanprovideasignificantincentivefordiscoveringnewwaysoflearningandauto-didacticactivities.Thereflectionofthementionedself-imagesandimagesofagecanrevealtherangeofactivitiesinoldage.Insummary,thismeansthatseniorcitizensaremorevulnerabletorisksofexclusion(Kruse2008,p.23),butatthesametime,theystillhavepotentialforinclusionandimprovededucationalactivities.
Practical perspectives and conclusion
Anindividual’shistoricalandsocialbackgroundandhisorherlivingspaceinfluencelearningandcompetencydevelopmentinallstagesoflifeandarepar-ticularlyimportantinhigherage.“Thelocationofageingcontributessignificantlytotheconditionofageing”(KockaandStaudinger2009,p.65).Socialparticipationoftenoccursinone’simmediatelivingenvironmentatpolitical,social, leisure,andeducationallevels.Beingawareofthebarriersthatoftenimpaireducationalparticipationoftheelderlyisvaluabletoeducationalplannersandlecturersofadulteducation.Thefollowingconclusionscanbedrawnforcontinuingeducationoftheelderly:
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 23
– Reflectionontheelderly’ssocio-historicbackgroundrevealsthesocializingexpe-riencesofthisagegroupandformsthebasisforintergenerationaleducationalprogrammesthatmeettheneedsoftheageingprocess(Antzetal.2009).Itisalsoimportanttobeawareofthepastexperiencesoftheseniorcitizensbyexa-mininghistoricalevents;i.e.,ascontemporarywitnessesinpoliticaleducation.
– Imagesofagecontainexperiencesofcertaingroupsofseniorcitizensthatinfluenceeducationalbehaviour.Itistheobligationofeducationalproviderstonotonlyconsidertheexpectationsandfearsoftheirtargetgroupandtomakeageimagesthesubjectoftheirprogrammes,butalsotoutilizetheseimagesofagetoavoidexcludingacertainagegroup.
– Thephaseofoldageisobviouslycharacterizedbyanextremelyheterogeneousnatureandlargelydivergenteducationalprerequisitesduetothelifelongaccumulationofculturalcapital(Blossfeld,RossbachandMaurice2011).Asaresult,thefieldofcontinuingeducationneedstoprovideawiderangeofprogrammesasitrunstheriskofonlyfocusingonseniorcitizenswhovaluecontinuingeducation.
– Publiceducationalorganizationsshouldalsotargeteducationallydisa-dvantagedseniorcitizens.Programmesthatareeasilyaccessibleandfreeofchargecanbeattractivefortheelderly.Theirlivingenvironments,suchastheirneighbourhoods,canberegardedasacentreforpromotingeducationalactivities(FriebeandHülsmann2011).
Generally,inlinewiththehigherlifeexpectancy,opportunitiestoparticipateineducationalprogrammesandtocreateindividuallearningprocessesinoldageareincreasing.Unfortunately,somesocialgroupsdonotyethaveaccesstoedu-cationalprogrammes(BremerandKleemann-Göhring2010).Forthesegroups,neweducationalprogrammesneedtobedevelopedtoopenupeducationalinsti-tutionstoseniorcitizens,providedidacticssuitablefortheelderly(Nuissl2008),andincludeopportunitiesforparticipation.Theobjectiveistodevelopconceptsof“goodlifeinoldage”(SachverständigenkommissionAltenberichterstattung2010,p.423),whicharecombinedwiththeideaofalearningcommunity.Strategiesfor“learninginlaterlife”mightbesuccessfulifsomecriteriaareestablished.Forexample,educationmustbeaccessible,includinggeographicproximitytothelivingareaofthetargetedgroup,barrier-freeaccessibility,andlowparticipationfees.Tofacilitateeducationalaccess,theprogrammescheduleandtopicsneedstobeadjustedtolineupwiththeagegroup’srequirementsandinterests.Themosteffectiveaccessisgainedthroughspecialconfidantsandword-of-mouth.Sotheoffershavetobe“transparent”.Programmesfortheelderly,especiallyforeducationallydisadvantagedindividuals,havetoberecognizableinthelocalcommunity.Theconventionalinformationexchange(printedprogrammes,flyer,pressrelease)doesnotreachthetargetgroup.Finally“networking”ofvariousstakeholdersisparticularlyimportant.Thecooperationofvariouslocalprotagonistscontributestoalargerdistributionoftheprogrammes.Inaddition,linkingvariousprogrammesacrosstargetgroupsallowsforintergenerationalandinterculturalencountersandlearningprocesses.
24 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
Insummary,onecouldsaythateducationalbehaviour isaproductofimpartialconditionsoflivingandthesubjectiveperceiveddevelopmentofone-self.Nevertheless,individualperceptionsofone’slivingconditionscannotreducethedetrimentalrolethatsocialinjusticeandinequalityplayinallstagesoflife(BlossfeldRossbachandMaurice2011).Educationalpolicy,aswellascontinuingeducationpractice,cancontributetopreparingforthechallengesofalong-livingsociety.Maintainingautonomy,theprovisionofguidelinesandthedevelopmentofnewperspectivesinthethirdandfourthphaseoflifeforwhichnewpatternsneedtobefound,isessentialfortheindividualsandthesociety.
References
Antz,E.-M.,Franz,J.,Frieters,N.,Scheunpflug,A.andTolksdorf,M.(2009).Generationen lernen gemeinsam: Theorie und Praxis intergenerationeller Bildung.Bielefeld:wbv.
Backes,G.,Clemens,W.andKünemund,H.(eds.)(2004).Lebensformen und Lebensführung im Alter.Wiesbaden:VSVerlag.
Baltes,P.B.(1993).TheAgingMind:PotentialandLimits.The Gerontologist, 33,Issue5,pp.580–594.
Bremer,H.andKleemann-Göhring,M.(2010).Potenziale der Weiterbildung durch den Zugang zu sozialen Gruppen entwickeln.Duisburg,Essen:UniversityPress.
Blossfeld,H.P.,Rossbach,H.G.andMaurice,J.von(eds.)(2011).Education as a Lifelong Process. The German National Educational Panel Study (NEPS).Wiesbaden:VSVerlag.
Cross,K.P.(1981).Adults as Learners. Increasing Participation and Facilitating Learning.SanFrancisco:Jossey-Bass.
DeGracioBlanco,M.,Olmo,J.G.,Arbonès,M.M.andBosch,P.M.(2004).AnalysisofSelf-ConceptinOlderAdultsinDifferentContexts.ValidationoftheSubjectiveAgingPerceptionScale(SAPS).European Journal of Psychological Assessment, 20,Issue4,pp.262–274.
Dohmen,G.(2001).Das informelle Lernen. Die internationale Erschließung einer bisher vernachlässigten Grundform menschlichen Lernens für das lebenslange Lernen aller.Berlin:BMBF.
Findsen,B.andFormosa,M.(2011).Lifelong Learning in later Life. A Handbook on Older Adult Learning.Rotterdam:SensePublishers.
Franz,J.(2011).IntergenerationellesLernenzwischen(sozialen)GroßelternundEnkel-kindern.Forum Erwachsenenbildung,11,Issue2,pp.34–37.
Friebe,J.(2010).ExklusionundInklusionältererMenscheninWeiterbildungundGesell-schaft.In:M.Kronauer(ed.)(2010).Inklusion und Weiterbildung.Bielefeld:wbv,pp.141–184.
Friebe.J.andHülsmann,K. (2011).Zur Weiterbildungssituation bildungsferner und bildungsbenachteiligter älterer Menschen in ausgewählten Stadtteilen der Modell-regionen (GenRe).Retrievedfromhttp://www.die-bonn.de/doks/Abschlussbericht_Genre_Juli_2011.pdf(Accessedon1.2.2013).
Activitiesandbarrierstoeducationforelderlypeople 25
Hildenbrand,B.(1991).FallrekonstruktiveForschung.In:U.Flick,E.v.Kardorff,H.Keupp,L.v.RosenstielandSt.Wolff(eds.).Handbuch Qualitative Sozialforschung.München:Beltz,pp.256–259.
KDA–KuratoriumDeutscheAltershilfe(2010).AkteureimQuartier.Pro Alter,42,Issue05/06,pp.30–35.
Kocka,J.andStaudinger,U.(eds.) (2009).Gewonnene Jahre, Empfehlungen der Aka-demiengruppe Altern in Deutschland.Halle(Saale):Leopoldina.
Kolland,F.andAhmadi,P.(2010).Bildung und aktives Altern.Bielefeld:Bertelsmann.Kronauer,M.(2010).Inklusion-Exklusion.EinehistorischeundbegrifflicheAnnäherung
andieSozialeFragederGegenwart.In:M.Kronauer(ed.):Inklusion und Weiterbil-dung.Bielefeld:Bertelsmann,pp.24–58.
Kruse,A.(2008).AlterundAltern–konzeptionelleÜberlegungenundempirischeBe-fundederGerontologie.InA.Kruse(Ed.).Weiterbildung in der zweiten Lebenshälfte: Multidisziplinäre Antworten auf Herausforderungen des demographischen Wandels.Bielefeld:Bertelsmann,pp.21–48.
Kruse,A.(2010).BildungimAlter.In:R.TippeltandA.vonHippel(eds.):Handbuch Erwachsenenbildung/Weiterbildung.Wiesbaden:VSVerlag,pp.827–840.
Lehr,U.(2005).Heutegejagt–morgengefragt?Weiterbildung, Issue3,pp.20–23.Levy,B.R.(2003).MindMatters:CognitiveandPhysicalEffectsofAgingSelf-Stereotypes.
The Journals of Gerontology: Psychological Sciences, 58,Issue4,pp.203–211.Levy,B.R.andSchlesinger,M.J.(2005).WhenSelf-InterestandAgeStereotypesCollide:
EldersOpposingIncreasedFundsforProgramsBenefitingThemselves.Journal of Aging and Social policy, 17,Issue2,pp.25–39.
Literacy, Numeracy and Problem Solving in Technology-Rich Environments – Framework for the OECD Survey of Adult Skills.(2012).Paris:OECD.
Mannheim,K.(1928).DasProblemderGenerationen.Kölner Vierteljahreshefte für Sozio-logie,7,Issue2,pp.157–185;Issue3,pp.309–330.
Mayring,P.A.(2003).Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Grundlagen und Techniken(8thedition).Stuttgart:UTB.
Merton,R.K.(1948).Theself-fulfillingprophecy.Antioch Review, Issue8,pp.193–210.Nuissl,E.(2009).ProfessionalisierunginderAltenbildung.In:U.StaudingerandH.Hei-
demeier(eds.):Altern, Bildung und lebenslanges Lernen. Altern in Deutschland, Bd. 2.Halle:Leopoldina,pp.95–102.
Ory,M.,Hoffmann,M.K.,Hawkins,M.,Sanner,B.andMockenhaupt,R.(2003).Chal-lengingAgingStereotypes.StrategiesforCreatingaMoreActiveSociety.American Journal of Preventive Medicine, Issue 25,pp.164–171.
Radebold,H. (2005).Die dunklen Schatten unserer Vergangenheit.Stuttgart:Klett-Cotta.
Rosenbladt,B.vonandBilger,F.(2008).Weiterbildungsverhalten in Deutschland. Band 1: Berichtssystem Weiterbildung und Adult Education Survey 2007.Bielefeld:Bertels-mann.
Rothermund,K.andBrandstaedter,J.(2003).Agestereotypesandself-viewsinlaterlife:Evaluatingrivalassumptions.International Journal of Behavioral Development, 27,Issue6,pp.549–554.
26 JOURNALOFCONTEMPORARYEDUCATIONALSTUDIES1/2013 J.Friebeet.al.
SachverständigenkommissionAltenberichterstattung.(2010).Sechster Bericht zur Lage der älteren Generation in der Bundesrepublik Deutschland, Altersbilder in der Gesell-schaft.Berlin:BMFSFJ.
Saldana,J. (2008).The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers.ThousandOaks:Sage.
Schmidt,B.(2007).OlderEmployeeBehaviourandInterestinContinuingEducation.Journal of Adult and Continuing Education, 13,Issue2,pp.156–174.
Schmidt,B.(2010).PerceptionofAge,ExpectationsofRetirementandContinuingEdu-cationofOlderWorkers.In:Working and ageing: emerging theories and empirical perspectives.Luxembourg:PublicationsOffice,pp.210–226.
Schmidt-Hertha,B.(inpress).GenerationensolidaritätundGenerationengerechtigkeit.In:M.FathandE.Zwick(eds.).Bildung und Ethik.München:LitVerlag.
Schmidt-Hertha,B.andMühlbauer,C.(2012).Lebensbedingungen,LebensstileundAl-tersbilderältererErwachsener.In:F.Berner,J.RossowandK.-P.Schwitzer(eds.):Individuelle und kulturelle Altersbilder. Expertisen zum Sechsten Altenbericht der Bundesregierung. Band 1.Wiesbaden:VSVerlag,pp.109–149.
Schmidt-Hertha,B.andTippelt,R.(2011).Typologien.Report – Zeitschrift für Weiterbil-dungsforschung, 34,Issue1,pp.23-35.
Schmitt,E.(2004).AktivesAltern,Leistungseinbußen,sozialeUngleichheitundAltersbilder–EinBeitragzumVerständnisvonResilienzundVulnerabilitätimhöherenErwach-senenalter.Zeitschrift für Gerontologie und Geriatrie,37,Issue4,pp.280–292.
Tippelt,R.,Schmidt,B.andKuwan,H.(2009).Bildungsteilnahme.In:R.Tippelt,B.Schmidt,S.Schnurr,S.SinnerandC.Theisen(eds.).Bildung Älterer. Chancen im demogra-phischen Wandel.Bielefeld:Bertelsmann,pp.32–45.
Tippelt,R.,Schmidt,B.,Schnurr,S.,Sinner,S.andTheisen,C.(eds.)(2009).Bildung Älterer. Chancen im demografischen Wandel.Bielefeld:Bertelsmann.
Weber,M.(1922/2012).Collected Methodological Writings.London:Routledge.Wurm,S.andHuxhold,O.(2012).SozialerWandelundindividuelleEntwicklungvonAl-
tersbildern.In:F.Berner,J.RossowandK.-P.Schwitzer,K.-P.(eds.).Individuelle und kulturelle Altersbilder. Expertisen zum Sechsten Altenbericht der Bundesregierung. Band 1.Wiesbaden:VSVerlag,pp.27–70.