Action Taken Report

In the matter before the Hon’ble NGT Order O.A No.893 of 2019 i.e.

Manikchand S Jain V/s State of Gujarat.

1) Major points in complaint:

Running of Yarn Dyeing plants in Kim (Surat District) on Ahmadabad

Mumbai Highway causing huge pollution by Sahar Industries and Proera

Bizcon Pvt. Ltd.

2) Direction:

As per order dated: 30.10.2019 “ Let the Gujarat State Pollution Control Board

(GSPCB) look into the matter, take appropriate action in accordance with law

and furnish a factual and action taken report ”.

3) Latest status of the Industries:

Regional Office-Surat has visited both the units with reference to verification

on dated: 18.11.2019. Salient features of the inspection reports are as follows:

(I) Sahar Industries (Old Name: Navpad Textiles Industries Ltd.)

a. Unit is engaged in manufacturing Dyed Yarns - 60MT/Month

b. During visit production plant is observed in operation and dyeing of yarn

was going on.

c. For the generated waste water from process unit has provided primary,

secondary and teriary effulent treatment facility along with Reverse

Osmosis and Electric type evaporator. Provided units of ETPlant are

found in operation.

d. During Inspection Waste Water ponding is observed outside the

boundary of the unit, in adjecent open plot. Raw effluent collection tank

of the unit is situated besides this plot within the compound wall of this

unit.

e. Though no live Waste Water discharge is observed from the collection

tank to the open plot one sample each of Waste Water are collected

from the raw effluent collection tank and from the Waste Water ponding

area to ascertain the quality of the Waste Water.

f. Result of the sample collected from ponding in open plot is BOD – 58

mg/lit (limit-30 mg/lit), COD – 289 mg/lit (limit – 100 mg/lit)

g. Unit has provided one coal fired Thermic Fluid Hetear (TFH) (capacity

1000 U). Unit has provided cyclone separator followed by bag filter as

Air Pollution control measures (APCM).

h. During visit TFH and provided all APCM are found in operation.

i. Use of imported coal as fuel is going on.

j. Sample of flue gas emission is collected from the stack attached to the

TFH.

k. Analysis report dated 22.11.2019 of air sample collected from common

stack attached to Boiler and TFH through APCM shows concentration of

1. PM = 54.0 mg/Nm3 (Limit=150mg/Nm3,)

2. SO2=27.1 ppm (Limit=100ppm),

3. NOx=9.4 ppm (limit=50 ppm)

l. Overall houskeeping of the unit is very poor.

m. Gujarat Pollution Control Board hence issued closure direction Under

Section 33(A) of the Water Act - 1974 vide letter No. GPCB/CCA-SRT-

149(4)/ID-20998/528491, dated 30-11-2019.

(II) M/s. Raj Dyechem Private Limited

(New Name: Proera Bizcon Pvt. Ltd.)

a. Unit is engaged in Yarns Dyeing -160MT/Month

b. During visit production plant is observed not in operation.

c. Closure Direction to the unit was issued on Date: 11.04.2019.

Revocation to the unit was issued on Date: 24.10.2019. Eletric Power

supply to the unit is found not connected yet.

d. During Inspection no responsible person was available at premisies.

Water ponding is observed outside the boundary of the unit, in adjecent

open plot. Raw effluent collection tank of the unit is situated besides

this plot within the compound wall of this unit.

e. Unit has not made any application for the change of name of the unit

from M/s. Raj Dyechem Private Limited to M/s Proera Bizcon Pvt. Ltd.

Encl:- 1) Inspection report dated 18.11.2019 of M/s.Sahar Industries (Annexure-1).

2) Analysis report dated 29.11.2019 from ponding in open plot adjacent to M/s.Sahar

Industries (Annexure-2).

3) Analysis report dated 29.11.2019 from collection tank of ETP of M/s.Sahar Industries (Annexure-3). 4) Analysis report dated 22.11.2019 of stack sampling of M/s.Sahar Industries (Annexure-4).

5) Direction Under Section 33(A) of the Water Act – 1974 to M/s.Sahar Industries (Annexure-5).

6) Inspection report dated 18.11.2019 of M/s. Raj Dyechem Private Limited (Annexure-6).

Ponding outside plant premises M/s Sahar Industries (Old Name-Navpad Textiles Industries Ltd (GPCB ID-20998)) dated 18/11/2019 adjacent to the raw effluent collection tank side of its plant boundary

Sample ID:270452 - Analysis Completion:29/11/2019

ANALYSIS REPORT FOR

WATER / WASTE WATER SAMPLE

Yarn / Textile processing involving any effluent/emission generating

processes including bleaching, dyeing, printing and colouring / LAB

Inward : 37721

Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Surat

338, Belgium Square

Typical 1st Floor,Opp. Linear Bus Stand

Ring Road, SURAT

Tele:(0261) 2442696

TEST REPORT

Test Report No. : 37721 Date: 29/11/2019

3. Nature of Sample

4. Sample Collected By

5. Quantity of Sample Received

6. Code No. of the Sample

7. Date & Time of Collection & Inwarding

8. Date of Start & Completion of Analysis

9. Sampling Point

10. Flow Details (Remarks)

11. Mode of Disposal

12. Ultimate Receiving Body

13. Temperature on Collection

14. Carboys Nos for

15. Water Consumption & W.W.G (KLPD)

1. Name of the Customer

2. Address

Range of TestingTest MethodSr ResultUnitParameter

Ambient oC - 60 oCIS: 3025 (Part – 9) – 1984(Reaffirmed 2006)CentigradeTemperature 1 30

1 – 14 pH value As on digital pH meter.4500 H+ B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.2012pH UnitspH 2 7.99

2 - to 99 Hazen & 1-500 hazen2120 B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi. 2012Pt.Co.Sc.Colour 3 65

10 – 200000 mg/LGravimetric method. (2540 C APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)2012mg/lTotal Dissolved Solids 4 2920

2 – 10000 mg/LGravimetric method. (2540 D APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)2012mg/lSuspended Solids 5 170

0.01 – 100%.IS11624-1986(Reaffirmed 2009)%NaPercent Sodium 6 45.90

1 - 50000 mg/lArgentometric method. (4500 Cl? B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)-2012mg/lChloride 7 592

2-40mg/lAPHA(22nd edi)4500 SO4 Emg/lSulphate 8 90

5.0- 50000 mg/lAPHA (22nd Edition)- 5220 B Open Reflux Method-2012mg/lChemical Oxygen Demand 9 289

01 – 1000 mg/lLiquid – Liquid Partition Gravimetric method. (5520 B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)-2012mg/lOil & Grease 10 1.2

0.1 – 50 mg/l4 Amino Antipyrene method without Chloroform Extraction (Direct Photometric method) (5530 D APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.) -2012mg/lPhenolic Compounds 11 1.25

05–50000 mg/l3 – Day BOD test. (IS 3025 (Part 44) 1993 Reaffirmed 1999)-2009mg/lB.O.D (3 Days 27oC) 12 58

: REP-Representative/Grab, (Insp Type : OTH-Others/Higher Authority)

: Ms. Desai manali b

: 5 Lit

: 270452

: 18/11/2019 , (1625 to 1625) & 19/11/2019

: 19/11/2019 & 29/11/2019

: From Ponding on open plot adjoining to the boundry wall of the unit ~

: --

: on open land for evaporation & percolation

: No generation of industrial wastewater

: 30 & pH Range on pH Strip :7 to 8 on pH Strip

: SUR-GOWA12 & Color & Appearance :Light Brownish

: Ind :100.000 , Dom :5.000 & Ind :90.000 , Dom :5.000

: Sahar Industries ( Old Name-Navpad Textiles Industries Ltd, - 20998

: BLOCK NO.67,P/2,P/3,BLOCK NO.67,P/2,P/3,MOTI NAROLI,,MANGROL

MOTI NAROLI-394110, Taluka : Mandvi, District : Surat, GIDC : Not In Gidc

Laboratory Remarks : Approved By:274-lab_274 Dt.: 29/11/2019

Dr. A H Sharma, Lab Head

30/11/2019N I C

Note :

1. * - These parameters are NOT covered under the scope of NABL.

2. The results refer only to the tested samples and applicable parameters. Endorsement of products is neither inferred nor implied.

3. Samples will be destroyed after 10 days from the date of issue of test report unless otherwise specified.

4. This report is not to be reproduced wholly or in part or used in any advertising media without the permission of the Board in writing.

5. The Board is not responsible for the authenticity for the samples not collected by the Board’s officials.

6. Total liability of our laboratory is limited to the invoiced amount. Any dispute arising out of this report is subject to

Gujarat Jurisdiction only.

7. Permissible Limits: as per Schedule VI of EPA Rules, 1986 as ammended by Second and Third ammendment 1993 for Effluents

8. Physicochemical and microbiological parameters, Std.Methods for Water and Waste Water- 22nd Edition by APHA.

9. Bioassay test (for toxicity) -IS:6582:Part-2:2001; Reaffirmed 2007.

sample is collected as per is 3025.Field Observation :

Sample ID:270453 - Analysis Completion:29/11/2019

ANALYSIS REPORT FOR

WATER / WASTE WATER SAMPLE

Yarn / Textile processing involving any effluent/emission generating

processes including bleaching, dyeing, printing and colouring / LAB

Inward : 37723

Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Surat

338, Belgium Square

Typical 1st Floor,Opp. Linear Bus Stand

Ring Road, SURAT

Tele:(0261) 2442696

TEST REPORT

Test Report No. : 37723 Date: 29/11/2019

3. Nature of Sample

4. Sample Collected By

5. Quantity of Sample Received

6. Code No. of the Sample

7. Date & Time of Collection & Inwarding

8. Date of Start & Completion of Analysis

9. Sampling Point

10. Flow Details (Remarks)

11. Mode of Disposal

12. Ultimate Receiving Body

13. Temperature on Collection

14. Carboys Nos for

15. Water Consumption & W.W.G (KLPD)

1. Name of the Customer

2. Address

Range of TestingTest MethodSr ResultUnitParameter

Ambient oC - 60 oCIS: 3025 (Part – 9) – 1984(Reaffirmed 2006)CentigradeTemperature 1 37

1 – 14 pH value As on digital pH meter.4500 H+ B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.2012pH UnitspH 2 7.15

2 - to 99 Hazen & 1-500 hazen2120 B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi. 2012Pt.Co.Sc.Colour 3 70

10 – 200000 mg/LGravimetric method. (2540 C APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)2012mg/lTotal Dissolved Solids 4 2490

2 – 10000 mg/LGravimetric method. (2540 D APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)2012mg/lSuspended Solids 5 116

1 - 50000 mg/lArgentometric method. (4500 Cl? B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)-2012mg/lChloride 6 490

2-40mg/lAPHA(22nd edi)4500 SO4 Emg/lSulphate 7 82

5.0- 50000 mg/lAPHA (22nd Edition)- 5220 B Open Reflux Method-2012mg/lChemical Oxygen Demand 8 917

01 – 1000 mg/lLiquid – Liquid Partition Gravimetric method. (5520 B APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.)-2012mg/lOil & Grease 9 3.2

0.1 – 50 mg/l4 Amino Antipyrene method without Chloroform Extraction (Direct Photometric method) (5530 D APHA Standard Methods 22nd edi.) -2012mg/lPhenolic Compounds 10 0.66

05–50000 mg/l3 – Day BOD test. (IS 3025 (Part 44) 1993 Reaffirmed 1999)-2009mg/lB.O.D (3 Days 27oC) 11 202

: REP-Representative/Grab, (Insp Type : OTH-Others/Higher Authority)

: Ms. Desai manali b

: 5 Lit

: 270453

: 18/11/2019 , (1630 to 1630) & 19/11/2019

: 19/11/2019 & 29/11/2019

: From collection tank of ETP(B/T) ~

: --

: In to ETP units for further treatment

: No generation of industrial wastewater

: 37 & pH Range on pH Strip :7 to 8 on pH Strip

: SUR-I7NEDK & Color & Appearance :Brownish

: Ind :100.000 , Dom :5.000 & Ind :90.000 , Dom :5.000

: Sahar Industries ( Old Name-Navpad Textiles Industries Ltd, - 20998

: BLOCK NO.67,P/2,P/3,BLOCK NO.67,P/2,P/3,MOTI NAROLI,,MANGROL

MOTI NAROLI-394110, Taluka : Mandvi, District : Surat, GIDC : Not In Gidc

Laboratory Remarks : Approved By:274-lab_274 Dt.: 29/11/2019

Dr. A H Sharma, Lab Head

30/11/2019N I C

Note :

1. * - These parameters are NOT covered under the scope of NABL.

2. The results refer only to the tested samples and applicable parameters. Endorsement of products is neither inferred nor implied.

3. Samples will be destroyed after 10 days from the date of issue of test report unless otherwise specified.

4. This report is not to be reproduced wholly or in part or used in any advertising media without the permission of the Board in writing.

5. The Board is not responsible for the authenticity for the samples not collected by the Board’s officials.

6. Total liability of our laboratory is limited to the invoiced amount. Any dispute arising out of this report is subject to

Gujarat Jurisdiction only.

7. Permissible Limits: as per Schedule VI of EPA Rules, 1986 as ammended by Second and Third ammendment 1993 for Effluents

8. Physicochemical and microbiological parameters, Std.Methods for Water and Waste Water- 22nd Edition by APHA.

9. Bioassay test (for toxicity) -IS:6582:Part-2:2001; Reaffirmed 2007.

sample is collected as per is 3025.Field Observation :

Sample ID:270451 - Analysis Completion:22/11/2019

Yarn / Textile processing involving any effluent/emission generating

processes including bleaching, dyeing, printing and colouring / LAB

Inward : 37725

ANALYSIS REPORT FOR AIR

TYPE : Stack-Process

Gujarat Pollution Control Board

Surat

338, Belgium Square

Typical 1st Floor,Opp. Linear Bus Stand

Ring Road, SURAT

Tele:(0261) 2442696

: REP-Representative/Grab , (Insp Type : OTH-Others/Higher Authority)

: Ms. Desai manali b

: 18/11/2019, (1615 to 1645)

: 19/11/2019 & 22/11/2019

: Stack attached to Thermopack through APCM. ~

: Imported Coal

: Mcs,Bag Filter

: 5/7289

: 105(stk) & Volume-Absord Media : 100 ml for SO2 & 25 ml for NOx

: 502.0 lit(N) for PM, 58.62 lit(N) for SO2 & 1428 ml for NOx

: 3 & Oper Time(Min) : 30

3. Nature of Sample

4. Sample Collected By

5. Date & Time of Collection & Receipt

6. Date of Start & Completion of Analysis

7. Sampling Point

8. Fuel

9. APCM

10. Thimble & Weight (gm)

11. Temperature on Collection

12. Volume-Gas Passed

13. Parameters

Range of TestingTest MethodSr ResultUnitParameter

1 – 5000 mg/NM3IS: 11255 (Part – 1), 1985 (Reaffirmed 1999)MG/NM3PM-Stack 1 54.0

5 – 500 mg/NM3IS: 11255 (Part – 2), 1985 (Reaffirmed 2009)PPMSO2-Stack (PPM) 2 27.1

5 – 500 mg/NM3IS:11255(Part-7), 2005PPMNOX-Stack 3 9.4

1. Name &

2. Address of the Unit

: Sahar Industries ( Old Name-Navpad Textiles Industries Ltd, - 20998

: BLOCK NO.67,P/2,P/3,BLOCK NO.67,P/2,P/3,MOTI NAROLI,,MANGROL

MOTI NAROLI - 394110,Taluka : Mandvi, District : Surat, GIDC : Not In Gidc

30/11/2019

Dr. A H Sharma, Lab Head

Laboratory Remarks : Approved By:274-lab_274 Dt.: 25/11/2019

n i c

Field Observation : sample is collected as per is 11255.

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARDPARYAVARAN BHAVAN

SecloFl0-A, Gandhinaga. 382 010Phone : (079123222425

lo79l23232152Fa\ : (079) 23232156

Webs e www.gpcb.gov.in

w\!rzGPCB

n,^D

DIRECTION UNDER SECIION 33(A) OF TIIE WATER (PR.EWNTIONAND CONTROL OF POLLUTION) AgT.19?4 IHERXINAFTERR.EFERR.ED TO

^S TIIE 3WATER ACI"] AS AMENDED FROM TIME

TO TTME

(t) WHEREAS you e hrving indusLi&l plet for th€ manufschling of

Dy€d Ym lMEd .r Bt@k No- 67, p/2,p/3, Mori Nlroli, Meerol,

Tal:Me&vi, Disl: Surll.

(2) AND WHEREAS th. Guj@t Potluton Contrcl Board hls SBnted you

conffir utuir rh. previsios ot rhc wsld Ac1 vid. .!nsc.t ordq No-

lO4?E0 d,{ql 24-10-2019 for op€mdon of th. indNlriol plmt for lhe

mout cruft of abov! said prcducts .l the sbov. site willl sp.cilic tem! &

(l) AND WHEREAS your industy wN visitcd on l8-ll-2019 udd s.clion

(21) of Th. water (PrEvention ud Cmuol ol Pollution) AcL_1974 by

.ulbdiz.d otrc4 ofrhc Bod, d 16 dtEri@ by H6'blc NGT in orde.

o.A. No. 893 of2019, datedr 30-10-2019 duriag sdd visit it wN obffi.d

!) wet w.rq pondiry eas ob6drtd ouBide h oP.n plor tovltds

Ew emuent @ll@tion onk side which is adjoccnl (o Ue unir\

bo@d.ry *hich show3 you @ld b. dis.lEEing utr@ted wosrc

wi in odd houv.o workirg h(N.b) Resulr of .mple collccled ftom pmdins in oPo plot h

BOD 5E mtl (rm't- 30 ngD, COD 2E9 Dtll(limit_ l0O mE/l)

whicn shows lhm @ld b€ d6.hrtg. of indBEial reG qtt rftom coll.cdon tank ofyou uit.

c) H()Nkephg of you umr sa foud P@r.clean Guiarat Green Guiarat

ISO-9001-2008 & lsor4o01 - 2004 C€nrfi.d orsani$lionOutward No:528491,30/11/2019

(4) AND WHEREAS l@kint to the ob64arion duing thc said visil you hove

violalcd prcvisios or rhe Envill]mdral l.us od you e in no-compliocc ot the condilioB gtuted to you

(5) AND WHEREAS a norice ws also issucd "'d€ no. sRT-CCA.l49(4y

lD 2099E/ 52E045 drr.d:2611-2019 6 a chue otbcins h6rd and you

havenor rcplied ro the notice in $pul.r.d timelimil.

Under lhe ciEursreces, I, SBhit Vegda Smid EnvircnEenlsl Ensineer of rhe

cujadt Pollurid Cord B@rd issue the diElion undcr s.ction 33(A) of TrE

Wat{ (Prcvmrion and ConEol ofPollulion) Act-1974 s Eder -

lr I o poh,b,l you fror th.3bove said meulactuint acti\lty.

2) To.lok thc opeEriq otyu irdGrrill plMr on rh. above mcnrioned

3) Toprohihit mykind ofheuf&tu.in8 activitiB rhrcush Crprive Pow€r

PlmL ed/q D. c. SeLs

4) To diBl Ue mcm€d Nthdity to slop supply of .l&.lriciry (.xcepl

sinelc phe) md worer with the ilmediste eff@L

It'thc above dimtiohs @.or complied, you @ lable tor prcseulion undcr

Secrim 4l(2) ol Th€ Water (Preven0on ad Conkot ofPollurion) Acr- t9?4 which

provider punishmenr w'th mprisonment lor a term not l6s lhan one yea. und six

,nomhs ed may .xrcnd ro six ycs ed w'rh fine.

lhu order is n{al afler spprcval ol comp.tent aurhoril)

GujMr Pollurion Cdrol

(Surhi

Smid Envircmaal EnsinsOutward No:528491,30/11/2019

w\t7zGPCB

GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOAROPARYAVARAN BHAVAN

Seclor-10-A, Gandhinagar 382 010Phone : 1079) 23222425

lo79) 23232152Fa\ : lo79t 23232156

Website ' www gpcb gov.in

NO: GTB/CCA-SRT- la9(l)tlD- 2wra I

hdurri€ (old n.m.: NNDtrd T.lrit Ltd)B

T.l: M!trdrvi, Dhl I SuEt

COPY TO:I The Vyam Division Ex. Etrgr.

D.G.V.C.L. 66 KV Cmpoud,Natidal HiAhwly No.5,Dhulia R4 vy.n. Dist.Suni---....wirh ! Fquar ro disl:mal dE su!'!'ty

ofEleLiciry (cxc€F sirste phe) wirl lh.itmediat€ .[et of rhe ind6Eirl pl r

M/s S.hu ldustrics (old nme: N3vpadTextile Ltd) Block NG 61, pl2,p/J, MotiN@li, Me&!l, Tol:Mandavi, Disr SuEtmd intimar. to us a@rdingly.

G.P.C.B -StrBr ...... You e dlrrrd to vcdry all di@rids .ndfolloq wU l@.1 &ullority for @mpliec6 or .lldiEclim in cmpl.t m.mr pl€e sd Eport tor

For ed d b€halfofcujmr Pollution Control Boed

(Sushil 8dt)S€nior ENitl)mmtd Fi3inG

Ctean Gujarat Green GuiaratlSOgoOn2Oo8 A lSO1400l 2004 C€diri€d Olgan salon

Outward No:528491,30/11/2019