Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care...

72
Looking at the Future of Clinical Health Care Services Robyn Tamblyn, BScN, MSc, PhD Scientific Director, CIHR Institute of Health Services and Policy Research Professor, Department of Medicine & Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupational Health Linkage Evidence Interact Learn Knowledge Policy Engagement Action Evidence Communicate Learn Collaborate Renewal Healthcare Share Action Share Healthcare Renewal Policy Change Interact

Transcript of Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care...

Page 1: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Looking at the Future of Clinical Health Care Services

Robyn Tamblyn, BScN, MSc, PhD Scientific Director, CIHR Institute of Health Services and Policy Research

Professor, Department of Medicine & Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupational Health

Linkage

Evidence

Interact

Learn Knowledge

Polic

y

Engagement Action Evidence Communicate

Learn Collaborate

Renewal Healthcare Share

Action

Share Healthcare

Renewal Policy

Change

Inte

ract

Page 2: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The Context Chronic disease and the aging population Health care spending Cost drivers and optimizing return on investment (ROI)

Clinical Program Redesign Examples of high impact redesign The Secret Sauce – Mobilizing key assets

Towards a Learning Health System Emerging models The Canadian approach

Overview

Page 3: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Population Health Challenges

Page 4: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Squires D, The US Health System in Perspective: A Comparison of Twelve Industrialized Nations, Issues in International Health Policy, 2011

Ho

spit

al a

dm

issi

on

s p

er 1

00

,00

0 p

op

.

Comparison of Hospitalization Rates for Ambulatory Sensitive Conditions, 2007

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

500

Asthma Chronic obstructivepulmonary disease

Congestive heartfailure

Hypertension Diabetes

Canada

Sweden

Denmark

Netherlands

Norway

Switzerland

United Kingdom

United States

Page 5: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

1980 1984 1988 1992 1996 2000 2004 2008

US ($8,233)

NOR ($5,388)

SWIZ ($5,270)

NETH ($5,056)

DEN ($4,464)

CAN ($4,445)

GER ($4,338)

FR ($3,974)

SWE ($3,758)

AUS ($3,670)*

UK ($3,433)

JPN ($3,035)*

NZ ($3,022)

Source: OECD Health Data 2012.

Do

llars

($

US)

THE COMMONWEALTH

FUND * 2009

Average Health Care Spending per Capita, 1980-2010

(Adjusted for Differences in Cost of Living)

Page 6: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

CIHI. 2011. Macro-Level Health Care Cost Drivers. January

2.8%

1.0%

0.8%

2.8%

0.0%

1.0%

2.0%

3.0%

4.0%

5.0%

6.0%

7.0%

8.0%

Other

Aging

Population Growth

General Inflation

7.4% New technologies

Broader coverage

Average Annual Growth Rate, Public Health Care Spending, Canada, 1998-2008

Page 7: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The Top Cost Drivers in Sweden

Population Aging

o Older people account for a large proportion of health care spending

o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health systems to meet it

Innovation in Health Technology

o New innovations are costly

o New technologies, even if substituting for an older technology, are normally more expensive

o Increased use of technologies leads to higher cost

o If older people are the principal beneficiaries of these innovations, the cost problems is compounded

Thomson S et al., Financing Health Care in the European Union, Challenges and policy responses

Page 8: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Provided $5/day daycare for a year for 14.6 million children

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

1980 1984 1988 1992 1996 2000 2004 2008

Canada

UK

Cumulative Difference in Health

Spending between Canada and the UK 1980-2010

$659 billion

Average Health Care Spending per Person

With $659 billion we could have:

Sent 23.5 million students to university for 4 years

Built 9,171 Trans-Canada highways

Health Spending & Opportunity Costs

Page 9: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Innovation in the Health System

Interventions

Page 10: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Interventions

Health Policies

Programs

Innovation in the Health System

Health Technology Assessment

Page 11: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

New Technologies When Not Used as Planned Off-label Prescribing & Adverse Drug Events

Eguale T et al., Arch Intern Med, 2012

No. of Prescriptions Off-label Use, No. (%)

Central nervous system 58 914 15 491 (26.3)

Anti-infective 21 000 3599 (17.1)

Ear-nose-throat 10 622 1613 (15.2)

Gastrointestinal 14 237 1770 (12.4)

Antineoplastic 234 28 (12)

Distribution of Off-label Use by Therapeutic Class

Cumulative Hazards of Adverse Drug Events According to On-label and Off-label Use

Page 12: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Chung M et al., Emerging MRI Technologies for Imaging Musculoskeletal Disorders Under Loading Stress, 2011

20

40

60

80

100

MR

I sca

n p

er

10

00

po

pu

lati

on

1995 2000 2005 2010 Year

USA

Belgium Luxemburg

France

Canada

Denmark

Australia

Page 13: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Choosing Wisely

Page 14: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Clinical Care Redesign

Page 15: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

High Impact Clinical Redesign

4 Case Studies:

• Organized stroke care

• Pre-hospital emergency care

• Pre-term birth (elective labour)

• Hip and knee surgery

Page 16: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Annual Number of Strokes, Sweden

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

Strokes Registered in Sweden by the Riks-Stroke Registry

Riks-Stroke Registry website, 2013

Page 17: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Re-organizing the Care of Acute Strikes: Stroke Units

Five year follow up of a randomized controlled trial of a stroke rehabilitation unit. Lincoln et al., 2000.

At 5 years: 45% of patients on stroke unit had died compared to 55% in conventional unit

Page 18: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Reduction in Mortality/Disability with Stroke Programs vs tPA

Systematic Review tPA: Cochrane, 2010

0 0

0

BETT

Stroke Units vs. Usual Care tPA vs. Usual Care

15.8%

New Protocol for Stroke Mortality,

Disability. Gandey, A. (2011). Lancet.

4.9%

Absolute Reduction in

Mortality/ Disability

WORSE BETTER WORSE BETTER

Page 19: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Re-Designing Pre-Hospital Emergency Care

• “The Golden Hour”

• Improved survival in trauma cases

• Trained healthcare professionals to work specifically in emergency medical situations

– Ex: Paramedics

Page 20: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Impact of Re-Designing Pre-Hospital Care in Trauma Cases

The importance of pre-trauma centre treatment of life-threatening events on the mortality of patients transferred with severe trauma. Gomes et al., 2010.

Patients were more likely to survive when their life-threatening events were managed in the pre-hospital phase.

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

Cu

m S

urv

ival

0 100 200 300 Length of stay

1.0

400

Pre-hospital

First Hospital

Trauma Center

Page 21: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

1%

42%

5%

64%

10%

76%

50%

97%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Ontario Population Health Expenditure

$6,397

$1,848

$998

$106

Expenditure

Threshold (2007

Dollars)

Wodchis et al, ICES, 2012 CAHSPR Conference

Within different age groups, the concentration of health care costs is highest for children (aged 0-17 years), with the top 1% of the population accounting for 42% of spending in this

age group.

Pre-Term Birth & Downstream High System Use in Children

Page 22: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Intermountain Healthcare: Elective Labour

Target for improvement: induction of early labour 32,000 deliveries each year Nurse required to fill out form to determine if

elective induction is appropriate If not, the chair of the department has to give

consent

James BC. Health Affairs, 2011

Results: Elective inductions that did

not meet clinical standards dropped from 28% to 2%

Collective length of time in labour dropped by 31 days

1,500 additional deliveries each year (without any additional beds or nurses)

Page 23: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The New Care Path for Hip and Knee Replacements

Alberta Hip& Knee Joint Replacement Projects, Evaluation Report

Primary Care & Referral

-Referral template

-Surgeon access

-Benchmark/monitor

Surgery Post-surgery

-Standard treatment

-Dedicated OR team

-Benchmark/monitor

-Standardize rehab

-Monitor outcomes

Pre-surgery

-Centralize intake

-Case manager

-Patient buddies

WAIT TIMES COST POST SURGICAL QUALITY OF LIFE

Page 24: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

0

100

200

300

400

500

New Care Path Control

Wait Time

95

100

105

110

115

120

125

New Care Path Control

Time in the Operating Room

0

5

10

15

20

New Care Path Control

Institutional Stay

33

34

35

36

37

38

New Care Path Control

Quality of Life

Alberta Hip& Knee Joint Replacement Projects, Evaluation Report Gooch KL et al., Osteoarthritis Cartilage, 2012

Nu

mb

er o

f D

ays

Nu

mb

er o

f D

ays

Nu

mb

er o

f M

inu

tes

Ch

ange

in W

OM

AC

A

rth

riti

s In

dex

Improved Outcomes Using the New Care Path

Page 25: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Reduced Cost Using the New Care Path

0

50000

100000

150000

200000

250000

300000

350000

400000

450000

Do

llars

(in

10

00

)

Total cost

Over 21 million saved in a year!

Alberta Hip& Knee Joint Replacement Projects, Evaluation Report Gooch KL et al., Osteoarthritis Cartilage, 2012

Cost per case

$9447

$9976

Page 26: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

eHealth solutions

Healthcare professionals

Data

Patients Policies and

systems

Transforming Clinical Programs Capitalizing on the Assets

Page 27: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Educational attainment for workers 25 years and older by detailed occupation, Bureau of Labor Statistics

Frontline Healthcare Professionals Have the Highest Education Level

Year

s o

f Ed

uca

tio

n

Health care professionals Banking professionals Police Force

Page 28: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Training Professionals for Practice-based Learning and Improvement Systems

Core competencies of physician leaders

• Leadership

• Strategic planning

• “Systems thinking”

• Change management

• Persuasive communication – Including negotiation and

conflict resolution

• Team building Partnership: CNA-CMA-CCHL-QC Consortium

See: www.cfhi-fcass.ca Denis JL et al., Physician Engagement and Leadership for Health System

Improvement, CIHR webinar

The EXTRA Program

Page 29: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Data Assets and Analytics

REAL-TIME MONITORING, ANALYTICS, AND FEEDBACK

ELECTRONIC HEALTH

RECORDS

Social Networks

Page 30: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Beneficiary Demographics

Name, age, sex, residence [income, education], death

Medical Services

Prescriptions

Date, Provider Location (e.g. ER), Diagnosis (icd9)

Procedure (hip fx repair)

Date, Provider Drug

Quantity Duration

Unique ID

Unique ID

Using Administrative Medical Service and Prescribing Claims Data to Monitor Care Delivery

Page 31: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Weekend Visit Family Medicine

UTI Long Term Care

Hospital admission

and hip fracture repair

ER Visit for Hip

Fracture

Dilantin dispensed 800

mg /day

Hospital admission

Hemorrhagic Stroke

ER Visit Hemiplegia

Consult Visit Rheumatologist Osteoarthritis

Followup Visit

Internal Medicine Diabetes

Coumadin Diltiazam Digoxin

Glyburide Ciprofloxacin

Celebrex 400 mg/day

Female

Age: 71 yrs.

Creating Longitudinal Health Histories with Administrative Data

Page 32: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

1.3

1.4

1.5

1.6

1.7

1.8

1.9

2.0

2.1

Janvier-94 Juillet-96 Juillet-97 Juillet-97

Phase I Phase II Phase III

Ancien régime Nouveau régime

Médicaments essentiels

Observée

Prédite

5% 10%12%

Nom

bre

de

méd

icam

ents

par

jou

r

1.3

1.4

1.5

1.6

1.7

1.8

1.9

2.0

2.1

Janvier-94 Juillet-96 Juillet-97 Juillet-97

Phase I Phase II Phase III

Ancien régime Nouveau régime

Médicaments essentiels

Observée

Prédite

5% 10%12%

Nom

bre

de

méd

icam

ents

par

jou

r

Tamblyn R et al., JAMA, 2001

Assessing Drug Policy: User Fees Reduce the Use of Essential Drugs in the Elderly

Evaluation of the Quebec income-indexed user co-insurance plan for prescription drugs in a random sample of 120,000 elderly

Page 33: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Creating regional data platforms: The ICES Effect

74

175

59

119

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

2006/07 2012/13

Nu

mb

er

of

Scie

nti

sts

an

d

Researc

h S

taff

Fiscal Year

Scientists

Research Staff

Research Capacity: Growth in ICES Scientists and Research Staff (2006/07-2012/13)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

FY 2008/09 FY 2009/10 FY 2010/11 FY 2011/12 FY 2012/13

New

Pro

jects

(d

ash

ed

lin

e)

Nu

mb

er

of

Peer-

Rev

iew

ed

P

ub

licati

on

s (

bars

)

Publication Year The quality, quantity, research capacity building

and impact of ICES work, 2013

ICES Publications and New Projects (2008/09-2012/13)

Page 34: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

SN Murphy http://researchit.uchc.edu/resources/ResearchRepository.pdf

Partners Clinical Research & Performance Monitoring Warehouse

Page 35: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Partners Clinical Research & Performance Monitoring Warehouse

Murphy SN et al., AMIA Annu Symp Proc, 2003

Page 36: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The Clinical Case Registry Model

EMR EMR EMR EMR

CCR: Nightly Screens for ICD9, lab values, drugs=clinical case definition(s)

Clinical Case transmission to

Central

Local Reports

Text Parsing and Data Cleaning

National and Comparative Data Analysis and Quality Reports

Backus et al., JAMIA, 2009

Example: HIV and HCV Care

New Advances in using Distributed Electronic Medical Records: U.S. Veteran`s Affairs

Page 37: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Jick H et al., Br J Gen Pract, 2004

Monitoring the Incidence and Prevalence of Attention Deficit Disorder using the GPRD EMR

Page 38: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Provide person-specific decision support to reduce morbidity.

• Fully integrated patient monitoring solution

• Continuous real-time vital sign and motion information

• Timely alerts for early detection

New Technologies and Predictive Models are Being Used to Detect Deterioration in Health Status

Page 39: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Tamblyn R et al., J Am Med Inform Assoc., 2012

Tamblyn R et al., J Am Med Inform Assoc., 2012

Designing New Smart Alerts that Provide Person-Specific Risk Assessment

nmhazardnmrisk baseline _^11*100_100

lw*0.0023- ci*0.287

gb*0.123 female *0.047 age_65*0.038_ EXPnmhazard

class_23*0.07 class_18*0.147

class_17*0.047 class_16*0.099

class_15*0.106 class_13*0.008

class_11*0.056 class_9*0.225

class_7*0.088 class_6*0.088

class_5*0.105 class_4*0.253

class_3*0.035 class_2*0.304

*__ EXPnmhazardtotalhazard

totalhazardtotalrisk baseline _^11*100_100

Page 40: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Providing Immediate Feedback on the Consequences of a Change in Medication

Page 41: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

epidemic curve

Potential of Digital Disease Detection

SMS Messaging

Micro Blogging

Emailing

Internet Searching

Social Networking

Internet Chatting

Blogging

Online News Reporting

Video/Radio Reporting

Health Expert Reporting

Page 42: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

0

50

100

150

200

1996 2000 2004 2008

Number of days from outbreak start to outbreak discovery

Year of Outbreak Start

Tim

e in

Day

s

20 in 2010

days

167 in 1996

days

Chan et al. 2010. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Page 43: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

HealthMap identified a new pattern of respiratory illness in Mexico in

2009 well before public-health officials realized a new influenza

pandemic was emerging

Real-Time Population Monitoring

Page 44: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Tracking Obesity with Facebook

Page 45: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Patients and Families Experience-based co-design

King’s Fund (UK) – 2013: Experience-based co-design toolkit Working with patients to improve health care This toolkit outlines a powerful and proven way of improving patients' experience of services, and helps you to understand how it can help you meet your aims. A 2013 global survey discovered that EBCD projects had either been implemented, or were being planned in more than 60 health care organisations, in countries including Australia, Canada, England, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Sweden, and the United States.

Page 46: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Healthtalkonline (UK)

Page 47: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Healthexperiences.ca

XDataData

Caregiving module: 35-50 in-depth semi-structured interviews Maximum variation sample; at home or place of convenience

Page 48: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Experiential evidence for system change

http://healthexperiences.ca/en/

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=RGb8AhDpb1w

Drew – on experiences with the healthcare system caring for his mother (since he was 5 yrs old).

Page 49: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The Result? Representative  timeline  of  a  patient’s  ex p eriences

in the U.S. health care system Representative timeline of a patient’s experience in the health care system

Source: Best care at lower cost: the path to continuously learning health care in America. Institute of Medicine, 2012

Analytics

Evidence – on – the - Go

A Continuously Learning Health Care System

Page 50: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Greene SM et al., Ann Intern Med, 2012

Implementing the Learning Healthcare System: Group Health Cooperative

Page 51: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

International Learning System: Variations in NICU Outcomes

Richardson DK et al., J Pediatr, 2001

Canadian Network

Kaiser Permanente

New England

No. died/No. total 418/10 819 (3.9%) 117/5 530 (2.1%) 231/3 492 (6.6%)

Birth weight

˂750 g 387 (3.6%) 85 (1.5%) 321 (9.2%)

750-999 g 501 (4.6%) 138 (2.5%) 372 (10.7%)

1000-1499 g 1267 (11.7%) 373 (6.7%) 898 (25.7%)

1500-2499 g 3755 (34.7%) 1712 (31%) 963 (27.6%)

≥2500 g 4909 (45.4%) 3222 (53.3%) 938 (26.9%)

Characteristics of Birth Weight and Mortality in Participating NICU Networks

Page 52: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

-National Strategy, Provincial

Execution

-Cancer Services uniquely organized

in Most provinces (special envelope)

-Conservative technology/drug

approval

-Modest Spending Growth

-100% Physician/Hospital Coverage

Variable Drug + Community Services

-Ontario: 13.5 million; 1.1 million sq.

KMs; 14 regional cancer programs

Organizational Context & Performance Initiatives in Cancer Services in Canada

Page 53: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI
Page 54: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

54

Ministry of Health and Long-term Care

Cancer Care Ontario

Regional Cancer

Centre

LHIN 1

Regional Cancer

Centre

LHIN 2

Regional

Cancer Centre

LHIN 3….

Regional

Cancer Centre

LHIN 14

Cancer

Quality

Council of

Ontario

Other regional cancer

providers

Other regional cancer

providers

Other regional cancer

providers

Other regional cancer

providers

Annual jurisdiction wide

performance

measurement &

monitoring and public

reporting: CSQI

~ 30% of

expenditures

~ 70% of

expenditures

Mission: To improve the performance of the cancer system by driving

quality, accountability and innovation in all cancer-related services

Cancer Care Ontario: Delivery at a Glance

Page 55: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

55

Program in

Evidence-Based

Care Breast DSG

More DSGs

Lung DSG

Clinical Council

Pre

ven

tion

Scre

en

ing

Rad

iatio

n

Pallia

tive C

are

Mo

re P

rog

ram

s

Clinical Accountability Structures (cont.)

Page 56: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

1. Data/Information

• Incidence, mortality, survival

• Analysis

• Indicator development

• Expert input

2. Knowledge

• Research production

• Evidence-based guidelines

• Policy analysis

• Planning

3.Transfer

• Publications

• Practice leaders engaged

• Policy advice

• Public reporting

• Technology tools

• Process innovation

4. Performance Management

• Institutional agreements

• Quarterly review

• Quality–linked funding

• Clinical accountability

Horizon-scanning

and championing

innovation

Identifying quality

improvement opportunities

Standardizing

development

and guidelines

Developing and

implementing

improvement

strategies

Monitoring

performance

Clinicians Engaged in All Components of Performance Improvement Cycle

Page 57: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The Patient Journey IM Tools Instrument the Disease Journey

Symptom Management

Robust data systems

Recovery/

Survivorship

Structured care plans

In Screen

Integrated

Cancer Screening

Diagnostic

Assessment

Programs

Wait Times

Computerized

Physician Order

Entry

Multi-disciplinary

Case Conferences

Stage Capture

Quality Indicators

Risk factor

surveillance

2010 Annual General Meeting 57

Supported by IM/IT

Disease Pathway Management

Cancer System Quality Index

Regional/Corporate Scorecard

Page 58: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Cancer Quality Council of Ontario

Overall CSQI 2012 Summary

Page 59: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

CSQI results by quality dimension: Effective

11/26/2

013 Cancer Quality Council of Ontario

5

9

Page 60: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Cancer survival in Ontario ranks among best in the world

December 21, 2010 Megan Ogilvie Toronto Star

Cancer survival in Australia, Canada, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and

the UK, 1995–2007 (the International Cancer Benchmarking

Partnership): an analysis of population-based cancer registry data

Coleman et al The Lancet - 8 January 2011 ( Vol. 377, Issue 9760, Pages

127-138

Page 61: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Häkkinen U et al., Health Policy, 2013

Sweden

Scotland

Norway

Netherlands

Hungary

Finland

International Learning System: Comparing Health System Performance Across Europe

Page 62: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The Result? Representative  timeline  of  a  patient’s  ex p eriences

in the U.S. health care system Representative timeline of a patient’s experience in the health care system

Source: Best care at lower cost: the path to continuously learning health care in America. Institute of Medicine, 2012

Analytics

Evidence – on – the - Go

Policy

LEADERSHIP CITIZEN ENGAGEMENT

A Continuously Learning Health Care System

Page 63: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

63

Provincial Learning Networks

Page 64: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Alberta Specialty Clinic Networks

Obesity,

Diabetes &

Nutrition

SCN

Bone & Joint

SCN

Surgery

OCN

Emergency

OCN

Addiction &

Mental Health

SCN

Cardiovascular

Health and

Stroke

SCN

Insulin

Pump

criteria

Rural Stroke

Program

Vascular

Risk

Reduction

C-CHANGE

Enhancing

recovery after

surgery

ART

E-referral

Fragility &

Stability -

Hip Fracture

Rx and

prevention

Inappropriate

use of

antipsychotic

Cancer

SCN

Critical Care

OCN

Seniors’

Health

SCN

Depression

Pathway

Safe

Surgery

Checklist

aCATS

TBD TBD

Hip & Knee

5 year Plan

Lung

Cancer

Elder Friendly

Care*

Select Priorities for Improvement

Page 65: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

The Launch of Canada’s National Learning Networks: The Strategy for Patient-Oriented Research

Page 66: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Network of Networks in Primary and Integrated Health Care Innovations

AB

Network

SK

Network MB

Network

ON

Network QC

Network Maritimes

Data

Platform

Newfoundland

and Labrador

Data Platform BC

Data

Platform

Network of Networks in Primary and Integrated Health Care Innovations

BC

Network

AB Data

Platform

SK Data

Platform MB

Data

Platform

ON Data

Platform QC Data

Platform NS

Network

Atlantic

Network

Network Leadership Council

(Clinical, Science & Policy

Leads)

Network Coordinating Centre

(KT, Communications, Training) NWT

Network

Nunavut

Network

Yukon

Network

Page 67: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

1%

34%

5%

66%

10%

79%

50%

99%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Ontario Population Health Expenditure

Health Care Cost Concentration: Distribution of Health expenditure for ON, 2007

$33,335

$6,21

$3,04

$181

Expenditure

Threshold

(2007 Dollars)

On average, health care spending is highly concentrated, with

the top 5% of the population (ranked by cost) accounting for

66% of expenditure Source: Wodchis et al, ICES, 2012 CAHSPR Conference

High System Users

Page 68: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

68

Network Objectives

1

• Create cross-jurisdictional opportunities to conduct research on the comparative efficiency, cost-effectiveness and scalability of innovative and integrated models of care that build on the foundations of CBPHC and facilitate transitions into and along the care continuum.

2

• Accelerate the timely investigation of new interventions and approaches in primary and integrated care across multiple jurisdictions and sectors.

3

• Catalyze research on and scale-up of cost-effective and innovative approaches to primary and integrated health care delivery.

4

• Support capacity building among researchers, clinicians, decision-makers and citizens/patients/families for timely generation and use of primary and integrated health care knowledge.

5

• Foster the exchange of information and evidence on successful and unsuccessful interventions and innovative models of primary and integrated health care across jurisdictions to inform policy development.

Page 69: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Network Membership Requirements

1 • Tri-partite leadership (science, policy, clinical)

2

• Strategic scope: (1) individuals with complex care needs across the life course, showing capacity to evolve the network's scope over time to include age groups from children to older adults; and (2) multi-sector integration of upstream prevention strategies and care delivery models

3

• Engagement of Key Stakeholders across the care continuum in primary and integrated care re-design

4 • Citizen/patient/family engagement

5

• Capacity for rapid monitoring, evaluation, feedback (linkages with SUPPORT Units)

Page 70: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

6

• University partnerships to develop primary and integrated health care research capacity

7

• Capacity to implement and evaluate e-Health solutions that could improve the cost-effectiveness of care delivery

8 • Geographic scope: Coverage of practices and patients

9 • Linkage to CBPHC Innovation Teams

10

• Partnership funding (1:1 for infrastructure award and research priorities)

Network Membership Requirements

Page 71: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

Network Funders’ Consortium

Network Leadership Council

Member network: A

Member network: B

Member network: C

Co-investment and cross-jurisdictional collaboration: Member networks A, B and C collaborate. A invests $400K to lead comparative cost-effectiveness of the different interventions; B invests $350K to examine transitions in care and avoidable hospitalizations; C invests $250K to examine patient experience and patient-reported outcomes.

Peer review and funding: Network management office coordinates assessment of research protocol. Upon approval, CIHR matches funding on 1:1 basis with member networks ($1M) for a total overall budget of $2M

Network: Entire Network (including all member networks) benefits from findings shared through Leadership Council interactions, Coordinating Centre, and annual Network forums

Priority setting: for example: •New models of home care for older adults (assessing the comparative cost-effectiveness of the different models for managing older adults with multiple chronic conditions to reduce nursing home placement and avoidable hospitalizations and foster transitions across care )

Fostering Cross-jurisdictional Priority-setting and Research

Page 72: Action Communicate ActionEngagement Evidence Looking at ... · o Level of demand for health care will come to exceed the capacity of health ... Diagnostic Imaging Utilization: MRI

In Summary…

• The key challenges in future health systems are to: • transform health care to prevent and manage chronic conditions • prudently incorporate and use new technologies

• There are no magic bullets

• Health systems that produce meaningful improvements in costs and outcomes: • Engage front line clinicians and patients in all parts of the process • Establish information systems that provide real-time monitoring of process

and outcome targets • Align strategic, organizational and clinical goals for ‘systems thinking’ • Optimize enablers and tackle policy-level barriers • Provide comparative performance data and support learning networks for

exchange

• Canada is experimenting with research/ health system partnering programs to engage producers and users of evidence in new ways for health care transformation