Achievements, challenges and Satoyama Development Mechanism7390/SDM_A4_report... · Achievements,...

58
Achievements, challenges and ways forward for the S atoyama Development Mechanism: A self-assessment by the SDM Secretariat Yasuo Takahashi, Nicolas Schauffele, Sabrina Mengrani, Andre Mader, Henry Scheyvens, Rajarshi Dasgupta and Federico Lopez-Casero Authors July 2019

Transcript of Achievements, challenges and Satoyama Development Mechanism7390/SDM_A4_report... · Achievements,...

  • Achievements, challenges andways forward for the Satoyama Development Mechanism: A self-assessment by the SDM Secretariat

    Yasuo Takahashi, Nicolas Schauffele, Sabrina Mengrani, Andre Mader, Henry Scheyvens, Rajarshi Dasgupta and Federico Lopez-Casero

    Authors

    July 2019

  • Achievements, challenges and ways forward for the Satoyama Development Mechanism: A self-assessment by the SDM Secretariat

    G e hni al e orto ri ht n tit te for Glo al nvironmental trate ie All ri ht re erve

    Altho h ever effort i ma e to en re o e tivit an alan e the li ation of re ear h re lt or tran lation oe not im l G en or ement or a ie en e ith it on l ion or the en or ement of G f n er G maintain a o ition of ne tralit at all time on i e on ernin li oli en e on l ion that are rea he in G li ation ho l e n er too to e tho e of the a thor an not

    attri te to taff mem er offi er ire tor tr tee f n er or to G it elf

    he n tit te for Glo al nvironmental trate ie G i an international re ear h in tit te on tin ra ti al an innovative re ear h for reali in taina le evelo ment in the A ia a ifi re ion

    Published by:n tit te for Glo al nvironmental trate ie G

    ami ama hi a ama ana a a a anel mail i e i e or

    i e or

    nite ation niver it n tit te for the A van e t of taina ilit A in mae hi a o o a an

    el

    Designed by:at h o t

    Recommended citation:a o a aha hi i ola ha ffele a rina en rani An re a er enr he ven a ar hi a ta

    an e eri o o e a ero A hievement hallen e an a for ar for the ato ama evelo ment e hani m A elf a e ment the e retariat n tit te for Glo al nvironmental trate ie an nite ation niver it n tit te for the A van e t of taina ilit a an

    Acknowledgement:e in erel than all the rantee li te in a le for their ort of the ro tion of thi re ort

    in l in mi ion of f ll ro e t ata in their final eval ation re ort an re on e to the online rve a ell a rovi in hoto ra h for the re ort la o t All the ro e t a ell a the or of the e retariat in l in the ro tion of thi re ort ere finan e the nite ation niver it n tit te for

    the A van e t of taina ilit A e al o than o o atana e Glo al ana er of the G mall Grant ro ramme the nite ation evelo ment ro ramme a i o ana i a the e retariat

    for the onvention on iolo i al iver it r i i ana a r o e Amano an A ami mai A r en i a a ima ini tr of the nvironment of a an an r o i atori on ervation nternational a an for

    their in i htf l omment in the o r e of the ro tion of thi re ort

  • o io e olo i al ro tion lan a e an ea a e are nami mo ai of ha itat

    an lan e here the harmonio intera tion et een eo le an nat re maintain io iver it hile rovi in h man ith the oo an ervi e

    nee e for their livelihoo rvival an ell ein in a taina le manner Glo all on tit te vital

    om onent of iolo i al an lt ral iver it

    he ato ama nitiative a initiate in to lea an international effort to ar taina ilit in

    an there to ontri te to the reali ation of livin in harmon ith nat re a envi a e in the

    nite ation lo al io iver it vi ion he nternational artner hi for the ato ama nitiative

    a e ta li he to romote olle tive effort of iver e ta ehol er for reali ation of thi vi ion A of ne ha mem er in l in national an lo al overnment non overnmental or ani ation GO re ear h in tit te rivate

    om anie an international or ani ation

    he ato ama evelo ment e hani m i a ee f n in ro ramme that ort ele te

    ro e t ro o e mem er he e ro e t ommit to the retention an enhan ement of io iver it an im rovement of h man ell ein

    in he ha orte ro e t in e it e ta li hment in to A ril Of the e

    are om lete an have een re o ni e a eneratin oo o t ome he have emon trate

    the ni e val e of in term of rovi in for h man nee hile on ervin nat re he A vi or Gro an e tive oar re e te the

    e retariat to ro e thi re ort in to a e the overall a hievement of the an to inform it f t re evelo ment

    hi re ort entre on the a an the e tent to hi h the ro e t ontri te to the trate i O e tive an to the Ai hi io iver it ar et A an the taina le evelo ment Goal G he

    trate i O e tive are in hort to in rea e no le e a o t a re the river

    of the lo an e ra ation of enhan e enefit from an enhan e a a itie e

    referre to the A eneri in i ator an G in i ator in anal in

    the ontri tion of the ro e t to the A an the G he anal i e information from the im lementation lan an final eval ation re ort a ell a the re on e to an online rve mitte the

    rantee e i entifie a total of intervention re re entin ifferent oli in tr ment amon the

    ro e t an then anal e their ontri tion to the a ove three oal et

    e f rther e lore the o i ilit that the ro e t ere li el to in e tran formative han e ith arti lar fo on the oli ta e of the ro e t

    o t t the mo ili ation of a itional inve tment artner hi il in an o trea h n a ition the

    re ort rovi e the re lt of a elf a e ment of the erforman e of the e retariat in the re or

    of it ma or li ation an re entation an the eval ation the rantee thro h the online

    rve

    Key findingsAchieving the IPSI Strategic Objectives

    a h ro e t im lemente a mi of in tr ment to a re om le o io e olo i al i e he e in tr ment an e roa l ate ori e a le al an re lator e onomi an finan ial ri ht a e

    o ial an information mana ement an innovative an inte rative he e in tr ment ontri te to the fo r trate i O e tive he ontri tion to O e tive enhan e a a itie a the hi he t follo e the O e tive in rea e no le e O e tive enhan e enefit an O e tive a re

    river

    Contributing to the ABTs and the SDGs ro e t ontri te mo tl to the A on

    a arene of io iver it i e ar et rimar ro tion an other e o tem ervi e

    val e an no le e an a ell a to the G on a ati an terre trial life Goal their

    rimar ro tion an artner hi he re lt al o reveale o i le ner ie amon the e

    ar et an Goal in he total ontri tion to the G a tantiall le than that to the A

    hi ma im l that the G in i ator hi h lar el rel on lo al an national tati ti annot effe tivel

    a t re the re lt of effort an tren in

    or more information on vi it the e ite htt ato ama initiative or or onta t the e retariat i i n e efine a a tem i e han e that re ire more than te hnolo i al han e thro h on i eration of o ial an e onomi fa tor that ith te hnolo an rin a o t ra i han e at ale

    Executive Summary

  • Towards a transformative changeAltho h the ro e t o t ome ere limite

    their hort ro e t ration an mall ale e o erve their effe t to in e a tran formative

    han e o t ro e t emon trate ro re in oli ta e an ort in l in the inte ration of ro e t o t t into national an national la

    lan an trate ie o t ro e t al o o taine a itional f n in to ontin e after the ro e t en e or ani ation ere involve in the ro e t a ro ifferent e tor an roa tive o trea h

    a emon trate thro h n mero li ation re entation or me ia roa a t rantee

    Performance of the SDM – from a self-assessmenthe i ma or f n tion of the e retariat are

    i re arin an anno n in all for ro o al for ro e t ii ele tin ro e t iii fa ilitatin the

    la n h an im lementation of the ele te ro e t iv fa ilitatin ro e t lo in an eval ation v

    i eminatin the ro e t re lt an vi ri in the rantee to ne f n in o ort nitie

    he erforman e of the e retariat in e e tin the e f n tion a enerall ell er eive

    rant re i ient e tion for im rovement in l e im rovin the frame for ro e t e i n an eval ation more aref l on i eration of fiel realitie

    treamlinin ata mana ement thro ho t the ro e t le tren thenin the no le e latform

    to en o ra e eer to eer learnin an a itional re o r e mo ili ation

    Recommendationshe follo in re ommen ation are a e on the e

    fin in re ente in thi re ort

    iel ra titioner an initiate an ham ion initiative that refle t the nee an a iration of lo al ta ehol er an initiative that

    ontri te to ar a hievin m lti le A an G

    iel ra titioner overnment an international or ani ation in l in onor an oor inate

    romote or arti i ate in m lti ta ehol er initiative O t t of m lti ta ehol er initiative are more li el to infl en e oli e re lon term f n in il

    artner hi an rea h more ta ehol er

    Government an international or ani ation an hi hli ht the ontri tion of to lo al

    taina ilit in relevant international ro e e

    iel ra titioner overnment an international or ani ation an olle tivel evelo lo ali e G in i ator for

    he e retariat an im rove the effe tivene an effi ien of the im rovin ro e t e i n an the ro e t eval ation frame or treamlinin the no le e mana ement tem an en rin an in l ive an ontin o no le e latform an

    trate i ort for a itional re o r e mo ili ation

  • Executive Summary

    Key findings

    Recommendations

    1 Introduction 1

    2 The SDM in a nutshell 2

    3 Scope and methodologies 5

    4 Results 7

    4-1 SDM project highlights 7

    4-2 Contribution to the Aichi Biodiversity Targets 21

    4-3 Contribution to the Sustainable Development Goals 22

    4-4 Harnessing the SDM project achievements 24

    4-5 A self-assessment of the performance of the SDM Secretariat 26

    5 Key findings and discussion 30

    6 Recommendations 33

    References 34

    Annex 1 SDM Overview 35

    Annex 2 Contribution of individual SDM projects to ABTs and SDGs 38

    Annex 3 Online survey form 42

    Contents

  • 1

    1

    Table 1. IPSI Strategic Objectives

    oo an material ro tion on lan an at ea i a f n amental an e ential a tivit for h man

    rvival an ell ein he intera tion of eo le ith nat re in ro tion lan an ea a ro the lo e thro ho t h man hi tor have reate iver e an

    ni e lan a e an ea a e he e lan a e an ea a e hile ifferent from inta t nat re

    on tit te vital om onent of lo al io iver it he rovi e ha itat for il e ie ort vario ome ti ate foo an material a ell a lant

    an animal an rovi e iver e e o tem oo an ervi e that n er in h man livelihoo e rit an ell ein o ever h man nat re intera tion in

    ro tion lan a e an ea a e an evolve in ne ative a that harm io iver it an the intere t of h man nten ifi ation an tran formation of

    ro tion tem on lan an at ea riven o lation ro th an in rea e on m tion

    have e ome the rimar a e of io iver it lo a ro the lo e hi h in t rn i n erminin h man livelihoo an e rit a o a hieve harmon et een o iet an nat re it i im ortant to revi it intera tion et een h man an nat re in

    ro tion lan a e an ea a e

    he ato ama nitiative a initiate in to lea an international effort for taina ilit in o io e olo i al lan a e an ea a e he ato ama nitiative efine a nami mo ai of

    ha itat an lan e here the harmonio intera tion et een eo le an nat re maintain

    io iver it hile rovi in h man ith the oo an ervi e nee e for their livelihoo rvival an ell ein in a taina le manner O an

    A he nternational artner hi for the

    ato ama nitiative a e ta li he to romote olla oration for the on ervation an re toration

    of thro h im lementin the a tivitie ontri tin to the trate i O e tive a le

    A of ne ha mem er a ro the lo e in l in national an lo al overnment non overnmental or ani ation GO re ear h in tit te rivate om anie an international or ani ation he e retariat i ho te the

    nite ation niver it n tit te for the A van e t of taina ilit A he ato ama evelo ment e hani m i one of olla orative a tivitie he rovi e ee

    f n for mem er to evelo an a elerate taina ilit a tion in t f n i ro e t

    ever ear an ha orte ro e t to ate in e it e ta li hment in Amon the e

    ere e f ll om lete ith remar a le a hievement

    hi re ort a e e the a tivitie an a hievement of the aimin to inform e ta ehol er in l in fiel ra titioner overnment an relevant international or ani ation on a elerate a tion for taina le a ell a to inform the on ho it an e f rther tren thene After re entin hi hli ht of the ro e t e a e their a hievement referrin rimaril to the Ai hi io iver it ar et A an the taina le

    evelo ment Goal G e then e lore ho the ro e t o t ome an in e tran formative

    han e from lo al lan a e an ea a e efore re entin an i in e fin in an on l in

    the re ort ith re ommen ation

    n rea e no le e an n er tan in of an ma e information i el a e i le that i of relevan e to e i ion ma in val e hi tor tat tren an the fa tor infl en in them in

    thro h mo ili in oth tra itional an mo ern no le e

    A re the ire t an n erl in a e re on i le for the e line or lo of iolo i al an lt ral iver it a ell a e olo i al an o io e onomi ervi e from

    nhan e enefit from in l in thro h en rin the taina le or enhan e eliver of e o tem ervi e for h man ell ein

    nhan e the h man in tit tional an taina le finan ial a a itie for the im lementation of the ato ama nitiative

    o r e

    efine a a tem i e han e that re ire more than te hnolo i al han e thro h on i eration of o ial an e onomi fa tor that ith te hnolo an rin a o t ra i han e at ale

    Introduction

  • 2

    2

    he rovi e ee f n in to ro e t ro o e the mem er an that a thro h the

    ele tion ro e he ro e t aim to retain an enhan e io iver it an h man ell ein in an there ontri te to the A an the G he f n aim to in ate e t ra ti e an innovation in an al o to romote their main treamin an alin thro h o trea h artner hi oli

    ta e an a itional finan in

    ver ear the all for ro o al for ro e t that fall n er either of fo r ro e t t e i omm nit

    fiel a e ro e t im lementation ii re ear h iii artner hi il in thro h a meetin onferen e

    or or ho an iv a a it il in he ele t i ro e t ea h ear an rovi e rant of a

    ma im m to ea h ro e t

    he e retariat ele te ro e t from to hi h ro ortionall ell re re ent all the eli i le a li ation in term of re ion an ro e t t e i re a le Of the ro e t ha

    een om lete A ril a le i re

    The SDM in a nutshell

    0 20 40 0 20 4060

    Africa

    Americas

    A ia a ifi

    Europe

    Applications

    By region

    omm nit or fiel a eimplementation

    ele teResearch

    or ho anconferences

    a a it il in anoutreach

    Applications

    By project type

    ot ele te

    Project typeRegion

    TotalAfrica Americas Asia-Pacific Europe

    i omm nit fiel a e im lementation 6 0 8 0 14

    ii e ear h 1 1 3 0 5

    iii artner hi il in 1 2 1 2 6

    iv a a it il in an o trea h 0 1 2 2 5

    Total 8 4 14 4 30

    Table 2. Project distribution across types and regions

    Figure 1. Proportions of the number of selected projects in all eligible applications by region and project type

  • 3

    ID, Grantee, country Project ID and title Typea Status

    Selected in 2013

    n i eno no le e an eo le o n ation A hailan

    13-1 ortin an romotin the aren in i eno o ioe olo i al ro tion tem in northern hailan

    om lete e

    athman ore tr olla e A O e al

    13-2 o mentation of iolo i al re o r e for re aration an ilotin of o al io iver it trate an A tion lan A in

    three e olo i al ro tion lan a e of e al

    om lete A

    at re an ivelihoo an a 13-3 erimentin on ro tion of hi h val e mar et ro t from in i eno il fr it

    om lete A

    A nternational hine e ai ei 13-4 onvertin e t a allie in tea farmin a otential a e of ato ama lan a e in alien ai an

    om lete e

    A o ia i n A er 13-5 o tin the ato ama nitiative teerin ommittee eetin an Glo al onferen e in

    om lete an

    nvironmental ation enter a ove ni ia

    13-6 lt ral lan a e a ve tor for lo al taina le evelo ment

    om lete e

    Selected in 2014

    A lie nvironmental e ear h o n ation A n ia

    14-1 romotin Green ntre rene r hi for on ervation of ato ama lan a e in the orth e tern Ghat n ia

    om leteov

    A o ha Ghana Ghana 14-2 e toration of omm nit a re fore t to enhan e o io e olo i al lan a e in the ff t ra itional Area Ghana

    om letee

    ational on a niver it hine e ai ei

    14-3 ailorin ato ama nitiative on e t to national an lo al onte t A a e t of the olla orative lannin ro e of a i e a lt ral an a e in an n i eno omm nit ai an

    om leteA r

    A o ia i n ro e arrollo A roin trial e amana A A

    er

    14-4 val ation of the io iver it hain in arren lan a e e o tem re tore thro h refore tation ith Caesalpinea spinosa in the o thern emiari oa t of er

    om lete A

    an are German omania14-5 o terin oo erative nat re on ervation to re erve an evelo the lt ral lan a e in the ar athian e ion of o n hava

    om leten

    e retariat of the a ifi e ional nvironment ro ramme a ifi e ion

    14-6 ealth i lan o ean an eo le On oin

    Selected in 2015

    O A olo i al ol tion n ia15-1 nte rate arti i ation of in tit tional ta ehol er for

    liftment of r ral livelihoo thro h taina le harve tin an mar et lin a e of an A ri ro t

    om lete e

    o ial oli olo e ear h n tit te iet am

    15-2 e toration of lo al val a le tree e ie in the on on er at hment thro h n r er e ten ion of lantin an fiel

    o mentation for en rin taina ilit of

    om letean

    on ervation Allian e nternational Ghana

    15-3 nhan in o oa a rofore tr in Ghana thro h an inte rate Geo ra hi nformation a e G a e monitorin tem

    om letean

    A o ia i n ro e arrollo A roin trial e amana A A

    er15-4 o ar a trate for miti ation of limate han e effe t in

    the oa tal re ion of er in the onte t of the l ino eventom letee

    nvironmental rote tion nformation entre an a 15-5 ato ama nitiative ational et or or ho for GA A

    om letee

    nvironmental ation enter a ove ni ia

    15-6 lt ral lan a e a ve tor for lo al taina le evelo ment

    om letee

    Table 3. List of the SDM projects selected from 2013 to 2017 (status as of April 2018)

    2 The SDM in a nutshell

    a CFI: omm nit fiel a e ro e t im lementation RES: e ear h PB: artner hi il in thro h meetin or ho or onferen e CB: a a it il in

  • 4

    ID, Grantee, country Project ID and title Typea Status

    Selected in 2016

    omm nit a e nvironmental on ervation O en a

    16-1 tren thenin omm nit arti i ation in io iver it on ervation thro h enefit harin an a a it il in

    om lete A r

    A o ha Ghana Ghana16-2 an rove re toration to im rove o ioe olo i al ro tion

    lan a e an ea a e for fi herie re over at the ni oma e am ar ite

    om lete e

    a an nvironmental ation or m an la e h

    16-3 ro e t for on ervin an la e h n ar an A O A A an evelo in it ho a e thro h reatin a tion lan an en rin the taina le e of nat ral re o r e romotin man rove re toration tra itional lt re an ill of man rove

    hrim olle tion

    On oin

    aminathan e ear h o n ation n ia

    16-4 ro lem an ro e t of onver ion for alternate enefit A re ear h a e t from the e tern Ghat

    On oin

    ational on a niver it hine e ai ei

    16-5 a ilitatin the evelo ment of a ai an artner hi for the ato ama nitiative

    om lete an

    an are German ro ean e ion 16-6 re arin the on ervation an evelo ment of lt ral lan a e on a ro ean level

    On oin

    Selected in 2017

    on ervation ol tion Afri a en a 17-1 e of mo ile te hnolo for a e in omm nit an il life e of ran elan re o r e

    On oin

    en a ore tr e ear h n tit te en a

    17-2 e toration of a re a a fore t in en an oa t for enhan e rovi ion of e o tem ervi e an ro t for im rove livelihoo

    On oin

    nna an Onne han an la e h 17-3 e i nin an enhan e io iver e a a tation to limate han e in the n ar an

    On oin

    alien i tri t A ri lt ral e ear h an ten ion tation A

    hine e ai ei17-4 ai an tin le ee fiel inve ti ation an reenho e ollination reliminar or

    On oin

    or ora i n Am iental ore tal el a fi o O O A olom ia

    17-5 e ilien e level a e ment of the e io iver it Area an Antonio ore t an omm nit em o erment on on ervation

    On oin

    niver it of the hili ine O en niver it O hili ine

    17-6 onte t ali ation of the in tr tional material for the trainin of o th to ar the on ervation of f ao i e erra e a a

    ato ama lan a eOn oin

    UgandaKenya

    Chinese Taipei

    Philippines

    Pacific Region

    Peru

    Colombia

    Viet Nam

    Bangladesh

    Russia

    NepalRomania

    EU

    GhanaIndia

    17-5

    15-6

    13-6

    14-5

    14-1

    15-1

    17-3

    13-2

    16-3

    15-2

    17-6

    14-6

    13-4 14-316-5

    17-4

    16-4

    16-6

    15-314-2 16-2

    13-3 17-116-1

    17-215-5

    13-5

    14-415-4

    Thailand13-1

    Figure 2. Location of the SDM projects

    2 The SDM in a nutshell

    a CFI: omm nit fiel a e ro e t im lementation RES: e ear h PB: artner hi il in thro h meetin or ho or onferen e CB: a a it il in

  • 3

    5

    hi re ort a e e the a hievement of ro e t mainl from three an le i e ontri tion

    to the trate i O e tive ontri tion to the A an the G an the effort of the rantee to ale the ro e t a hievement e on the

    ro e t ite an time erio ith a vie to reali in a tran formative han e he ro tion of thi re ort

    a e te the A vi or Gro an e tive oar ee Anne e tion for etail

    in in line ith the nee for a e in the overall ro re to ar the initial o e tive he

    re ort a al o inten e to inform the to f rther im rove it o eration to ar the en ear of the initial lan erio an e on

    he a e ment on i te of three te ir t ea h ro e t a i a re ate into m lti le ro e t intervention referrin to a ommon oli in tr ment

    ate ori ation A o ta et al. i re a i re in the follo in e tion re ent an e ha tive li t

    of oli in tr ment t e referre to in o r anal i hi ro e ena le a ri oro meta anal i

    a mo t ro e t have im lemente a mi of ifferent in tr ment re on in to ni e lo al

    nee em e e in om le e olo i al e onomi an o io lt ral onte t he level of the a hievement

    of ea h intervention re ar in it ontri tion to the trate i O e tive i re a then ore

    in a fo r oint ale i e oint if the intervention en e ith lannin oint if a tion a ta en

    itho t on rete o t t oint if o t t a ro e itho t tan i le o t ome an oint if enerate on rete o t ome i re i ere o t t

    refer to tan i le elivera le the rantee e tool te hnolo ie or tem evelo e o ment

    ro e or re ort li he the rantee

    O t ome refer to han e in a arene attit e ehavio r tem et of the ro e t ta ehol er

    tri ere the ro e t intervention

    e on the re ort eval ate the relevan e of ea h intervention to the A an the G i re

    in a ontri tion level ore i re ii hi h i the ro t of the m lti li ation et een a t o te

    ra ient te relevant to the on e t envi a e in the in ivi al A or G an te tan i le

    ontri tion to the o itive han e in the in i ator varia le for ea h A or G an the ro ortion of relevant in i ator a o iate ith ea h ar et or Goal i re ii inall the im a t level ore i re

    iii a al late for ea h an ever om ination et een a ro e t intervention an an A G hi h

    i the eometri mean of the a hievement level ore an the ontri tion level ore n o r a e ment im a t level ore re re ent the level of ontri tion of ea h intervention to an in ivi al A G

    hir e a e e the effort to harne the ro e t a hievement in term of oli inte ration

    follo finan in artner hi il in an o trea h A the ro e t are inherentl mall ale an

    hort in ration alin i riti al to en re i e an lon la tin effe t an there to ontri te meanin f ll to a tran formative han e to ar

    lo al taina ilit oal

    he o r e of ata for the anal e ere ro e t ro o al from all rantee final ro e t eval ation

    re ort mitte all the rantee ho alrea ha om lete their ro e t A ril an an

    online rve of all rantee on te from a to ne

    Scope and methodologies

  • 6

    e al re latoronomi finan ial

    i ht ‐ a eo ial information‐ a eana ement

    nnovation inte ration

    a) Project interventionsn rea e no le e

    A re rivernhan e enefitnhan e a a itie

    b) IPSI Strategic Objectives c) Global targets & goals

    i) Achievement level scorelan

    A tionO t t orO t ome

    ii) Contribution level scoreelevant to tar et oal or

    ire t ontri tion to in i atorXm n

    ABTstar etin i ator d

    SDGsoalin i ator e

    iii) Impact level scoreA hievement level ore x Contri tion level ore

    Figure 3. Analytical framework for assessing the contribution of the SDM projects to the IPSI Strategic Objectives and to the ABTs and the SDGs.d O e A

    n in i ate the n m er of all in i ator a o iate ith an A G hile m e re e the n m er of in i ator a o iate ith the ame A G to hi h an intervention ha ma e a tan i le ontri tion

    3 Scope and methodologies

  • 7

    4

    4.1 SDM project highlights

    he ro e t olle tivel em o ie the fo r trate i O e tive their a om li hment

    thro h ni e mi e of in tr ment em lo e in in ivi al ro e t eferrin to the ate orie an

    ate orie of oli in tr ment a o te a total of intervention

    ere i entifie in the ro e t i re li t the in tr ment em lo e in the ro e t an in i ate their ontri tion to the fo r trate i

    O e tive ana ement a e in tr ment in l in lan re toration an olla orative mana ement ma e the hi he t an nearl e al ontri tion to the fo r O e tive o ial an information a e in tr ment

    ontri te the hi he t to enhan e a a it O e tive innovation an inte ration to enhan e enefit an enerate no le e e onomi

    an finan ial in tr ment to enhan e enefit ri ht a e in tr ment to enerate no le e

    an le al an re lator in tr ment to enhan e a a it

    Results

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70

    1.2 Legal and regulatory standards

    1.3 Protected Areas

    2.5 Ecological certification

    2.6 Alternative sustainable livelihoods and income sources

    3.1 Recognise and support indigenous and customarytenure, rights, practices and knowledge, including…

    3.2 Recognise cultural properties and heritage inprotecting sites and landscapes

    4.2 Voluntary agreements, partnerships and participation

    4.3 Promote social norms on sustainable lifestyles andpractices, including through public information,…

    5.2 Collaborative management

    5.1 Landscape/seascape management plan developmentand implementation, including zoning

    5.2 Collaborative management

    5.3 Biodiversity registers

    5.4 Land restoration including through nurserydevelopment and planting

    5.5 Sustainable harvest

    6.1 Innovative approach to integrating BES and socio-e onomi enefit

    6.2 Ecological production

    6.3 Generate, integrate, and exchange knowledge fortransformation

    6.4 Ecotourism

    Aggregated achievement level scorePolicy instrument type

    1. Legal &regulatory

    2.Economic &financial

    3. Rights-based

    4. Social &information-based

    5. Management-based

    6. Innovationandintegration

    Generate Knowledge

    Address drivers

    nhan e enefit

    Enhance Capacity

    Figure 4. Categories and sub-categories of the instruments employed by the 30 SDM projects, and their contributions to the IPSI Strategic Objectives

  • 4 Result

    8

    hi e tion hi hli ht the ma or a hievement of the om lete ro e t n er the hea in of the in tr ment t e that ere rominent in in ivi al

    ro e t he mi of in tr ment em lo e in ea h ro e t an the ro e t ontri tion to the

    otivate the re e t from the e ali overnment to ort the evelo ment of it ational io iver it

    trate an A tion lan A an a irin to reali ti io iver it lannin the ro e t evelo e

    o al io iver it trate an A tion lan A thro h en a in illa e evelo ment

    ommittee an vario lo al ta ehol er n thi ro e the ro of eo le mo t affe te the

    Biodiversity documentation Medicinal plant nursery

    trate i O e tive an to the A an the G are re ente in the ore ar for ea h ro e t ee a le for the ore ar le en he ro e t e ri tion

    are lar el a e on the ontent of the revio li ation

    4.1.1 Projects featuring management instruments

    Project 13-2

    Project scorecard

    Documentation of Biological Resources for Preparation and Piloting of Local Biodiversity Strategy and Action Plan (LBSAP) in three ecological production landscapes of NepalKathmandu Forestry Collage (KAFCOL), Nepal

    lo of io iver it ere i entifie an inventorie of threatene an im ortant e ie in l in me i inal lant ere evelo e a the a i for the

    lannin omm nit io iver it ommittee ere e ta li he in hi h the national ar offi er i tri t fore t offi er hool tea her an omen ro

    ere en a e for im lementin the A

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    9

    Table 4. Project scorecard legend

    Instrument type1 e al an re lator2 onomi an finan ial3 i ht a e4 o ial an information5 ana ement6 nnovation an inte ration

    IPSI Strategic Objectives1 Generate no le e2 A re river3 nhan e enefit4 nhan e a a itie

    Aichi Biodiversity Targets1 A arene of io iver it in rea e2 io iver it val e inte rate3 n entive reforme4 taina le ro tion on m tion5 a itat lo halve or re e6 taina le mana ement of marine livin re o r e7 taina le a ri lt re a a lt re an fore tr8 oll tion re e9 nva ive alien e ie revente an ontrolle10 re re on v lnera le e o tem re e11 rote te area in rea e an im rove12 tin tion revente13 Geneti iver it maintaine14 o tem an e ential ervi e afe ar e15 o tem re tore an re ilien e enhan e16 a o a roto ol in for e an o erational17 A a o te a oli in tr ment18 ra itional no le e re e te19 no le e im rove hare an a lie20 inan ial re o r e from all o r e in rea e

    SDGs1 o overt2 ero h n er3 Goo health an ell ein4 alit e ation5 Gen er e alit6 lean ater an anitation7 Affor a le an lean ener8 e ent or an e onomi ro th9 n tr innovation an infra tr t re

    10 e e ine alitie11 taina le itie an omm nitie12 e on i le on m tion an ro tion13 limate a tion14 ife elo ater15 ife on lan16 ea e ti e an tron in tit tion17 artner hi for the oal

    n an la i tri t of a h a ra e h here man in i eno tri e live a a ent to fore t an live lar el on fore t re o r e i ten e a ri lt re an animal h an r the ro e t e f ll e ta li he a omm nit le initiative for non tim er fore t ro t an a ri ro t mar etin involvin oth the tate overnment an lo al

    omm nitie a e on the anal i of the tat

    Project 15-1

    Integrated participation of institutional stakeholder for upliftment of rural livelihood through sustainable harvesting and market linkages of NTFPs and Agri productsIORA, India

    of e ie an their re eneration otential informe oth tra itional an ientifi no le e

    taina le harve t metho ere evelo e an intro e to the omm nitie thro h trainin

    ro ramme he omm nit mem er are no a a le of taina l harve tin ro e in an

    mar etin arra Terminalia chebula ha o a Cassia tora an t i little millet ro t

    Note: ee reen la el in i ate tan i le in i ator level ontri tion hile ale reen in i ate on e t al

    relevan e to re e tive tar et

    Note: ee oran e la el in i ate tan i le in i ator level ontri tion hile ale oran e in i ate on e t al relevan e

    to re e tive oal

  • 4 Result

    10

    Project scorecard

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Azolla growing for livestock feed

    Tara plantation in degraded lands

    Community discussion

    Tara tree in relatively intact land

    e ra e lan an lo o io e onomi tat of lo al omm nitie are revalent in oa tal emi ari tro i al one of er o re tore e o tem an im rove the livin tan ar of lo al omm nitie alternative o io e onomi an environmental a tivitie a a te to ater ar e on ition ere nee e he ro e t eval ate the im a t of t o earlier ro e t that re tore ara Caesalpinea spinosa fore t fo in on the onne tivit et een ater

    Project 14-4 15-4

    Evaluation of the biodiversity chain in barren landscapes ecosystems restored through reforestation with Caesalpinea spinosa in the southern semiarid coast of PeruAPAIC, Peru

    oil flora an fa na he ro e t i entifie the otential enefit from lan re toration in ara tree

    in l in the ro tion of hemi al in re ient from ara ee o ater tora e oil enri hment a ell a relativel hi h io iver it an ar on tora e

    in rote te ara fore t hi information rovi e a o n a i for evelo in national an national

    lan re toration trate ie

    Project scorecard

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    11

    n on on i tri t nat ral fore t ere ra i l e ra e or lo t e to ille al lo in onver ion

    to r er an a a ia lantation an ina ro riate mana ement O ervin ome lo all val a le tree

    e ie for livelihoo lt ral i entit an il life ha itat till remainin in the e fore t the ro e t et

    Seed sowing in tree nursery beds Native tree planting

    Project 15-2

    Project scorecard

    Restoration of local valuable tree species in the Huong Son upper catchment through nursery, e tension o plantings an el ocumentation or ensuring sustainabilit o S P SSocial Policy Ecology Research Institute (SPERI), Viet Nam

    n r erie an e an reha ilitatin the e ra e fore t A i e from the ro a ation of tree ee lin the n r erie e ame entre for lt ral e ational an livelihoo a tivitie an hel e rai e a arene on the im ortan e of nat ral fore t an fore t reha ilitation

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    ver in e the ato ama nitiative a intro e to ai an in late it ha re eive a reat eal of attention from the overnment an the li A ain t thi a ro an re on in to the nee for ta in a more inte rate a roa h to romote the

    ato ama nitiative in ai an the ro e t evelo e a national trate i frame or for il in the

    ai an artner hi for the ato ama nitiative

    4.1.2 Projects featuring social & information instruments

    Project 16-5

    Facilitating the Development of a Taiwan Partnership for the Satoyama Initiative (TPSI) National Dong-Hwa University, Chinese Taipei

    he ro e t or ani e fo r re ional north e t o th ea t event involvin arti i ant

    from ifferent overnmental in tit tion GOO a a emi an omm nit or ani ation

    t al o onvene the fir t national meetin in ai an an an han e vent to m t all

    learn a o t the re ent ro re ma e n er oth the ato ama nitiative an in ai an

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    12

    he ro e t or ani e a or ho nhan in enefit for eo le an io iver it in in an a to

    rovi e moment m for e ta li hin the ato ama nitiative ational et or ore than arti i ant from vario in tit te an or ani ation or in in in an a arti i ate an hare

    information on their hallen e an o ort nitie rin an e r ion to a i toria la e i e omm nit

    Coastal landscape in the rural eastern Taiwan

    SINN Workshop

    TPSI operational framework

    Discussion by lakeside community on their priority livelihood issues

    Project 15-5

    Project scorecard

    Project scorecard

    Satoyama Initiative National Network Workshop for UGANDAEnvironmental Protection and Information Centre (EPIC), Uganda

    the threat from the rea of inva ive ater a inth over the la e rfa e to the fi herie

    e tor in the la e i e omm nitie a i e he evelo ment of etiver ra he e ro a ro o e a a ol tion an thi a re eive ell the omm nit he he e ro an revent

    oil ero ion n trient r noff an la e e tro hi ation tri ere the rea of ater a inth

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Five Tasks

    Addressing issues of SEPLs and formulatin solutions

    Conservation and revitalization of SEPLs

    Internationalparticipation

    Policy research Knowledgeenhancement

    Capacity building On-the-groundactivities

    Think Global

    Adapt National

    Act Local

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    13

    Women braiding wreaths – traditional gifts rooted in cultural landscapes in Russia

    Cultural landscape in Kenozero National Park

    an lt ral lan a e in ia are fo n in r ral area ith lo livin tan ar an hi h

    nem lo ment rate here e onomi evelo ment i rioriti e over lan a e on ervation he

    ro e t tren thene the a a it of rote te area mana er an lo al omm nitie to mana e lt ral lan a e in rote te area t intro e a ne

    n i eno eo le lan a e a ro the orl on tit te vital here eo le live in harmon ith nat re t are in rea in l threatene lo al han e n thi onte t the ro e t o or ani e the

    Project 13-6 15-6

    Project 13-5

    a roa h to mana in rote tin an inter retin lt ral lan a e an evelo e information

    material on lt ral lan a e mana ement hi h a i tri te to other rote te area mana er he ro e t al o evelo e e oto ri m in rote te area

    in hi h lo al omm nitie are involve

    ato ama nitiative e ional or ho in er an fa ilitate an e r ion to an in i eno otato

    ar to ee en the n er tan in an i ion on in i eno lan a e in the Ameri a re ion

    Project scorecard

    Project scorecard

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Cultural landscapes as vectors for local sustainable developmentEnvironmental Education Centre Zapovedniks, Russia

    Hosting the Satoyama Initiative Steering Committee Meeting and Global Conference in 2015Asociación ANDES, Peru

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    14

    Asociación ANDES director briefing on Andean indigenous landscapes

    A field session to understand Andean indigenous knowledge associated with agrobiodiversity

    onventional tea farmin in ai an ha erio l im a te rro n in io iver it thro h the a li ation of her i i e an e ti i e n the ro e t t o tea ro er in alien o nt of ea tern ai an

    to e in e ti i e after fin in that tea leave ama e reen leafho er one of the in e t

    that ere revio l on i ere a e t ro e

    Biological survey in eco-friendly tea farm Socio-economic survey of tea producers

    4.1.3 Projects featuring innovation & integration

    Project 13-4

    Project scorecard

    Converting pests as allies in tea farming - a potential case of Satoyama landscape in Hualien, TaiwanSWAN International, Chinese Taipei

    a ni e hone flavo r in tea hi h a referre the on mer om inin iolo i al an o ioe onomi rve the ro e t emon trate that the

    hemi al free hone flavo re la tea ro tion enhan e io iver it hile in rea in e onomi ret rn an o o ort nitie

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    15

    ten ivel mana e mo ntain ha mea o ha ri h io iver it an i one of the mo t im ortant terre trial e o tem in ro e o ever thi e o tem ha een ra i l lo t to a t re ro lan an a an onment e lar el to it hi h la o r re irement an r ral e o lation an are German an o n hava e ional A o iation

    A olla orate to or ani e the re ional onferen e ana ement of ten ive Gra lan in o ntain

    Area aimin to rai e a arene on the iolo i al

    Regional conference on extensive grassland management Extensive grassland landscape in Romania

    Project 14-5

    Project scorecard

    an o io e onomi val e of mo ntain ra lan an to e re oliti al ort to on erve them

    he onferen e tren thene artner hi et een the or ani ation en a e in lt ral lan a e mana ement a ro ro e t al o rovi e an o ort nit to hare information on ommon i e an e t ra ti e in e ten ive ra lan mana ement in l in on e am le of mar etin lo al ro t ith a nat re on ervation val e to in entivi e farmer

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Fostering cooperative nature conservation to preserve and develop the cultural landscape (SEPL) in the Carpathian Region of Pogány-havasLandcare Germany, Romania

    ative tree tan are ell maintaine in tra itional ar lan a rofore tr tem in mallhol er farm

    in an a o ever the are re entl ein ra i l lo t to ro lan he ro e t e lore the o i ilit to

    evelo hi h val e mar et ro t from native il fr it from ar lan a a mean to motivate farmer to maintain the e tree in their farmlan in lo al

    Projects eaturing economic & nancial instruments

    Project 13-3

    Experimenting on production of high-value market products from indigenous wild fruitsNature and Livelihoods, Uganda

    no le e of e i le fr it an olla oratin ith foo hemi t for ientifi anal e of their n tritional om o ition the ro e t i entifie their n no n

    n tritional val e evelo e re i e for hi h val e ro t h a ine i e an am an e lore

    their mar et eman

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    16

    or erin a m ational ar the entral re ion of Ghana i en o e ith ri h io iver it o ever the ho ehol in ome of the ma orit of o oa ro er in the area a lo e to lo lan ro tivit

    he ro e t traine farmer on oo a ri lt ral ra ti e in l in inte rate e t mana ement an

    re or ee in he e lea farmer in t rn traine

    GPS device training for cocoa farmers Cocoa pod at a trainee’s farm

    Project 15-3

    Project scorecard

    a f rther farmer he e a tivitie re lte in iel in rea e the e ta li hment of tree n r erie

    an im rove a arene of io iver it on ervation amon more than farmer he trainin

    ro ramme enhan e the a a it of more than of the e farmer to rea h level om etent eno h to meet the ainfore t Allian e ertifi ation riteria

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Parkland landscape in Uganda Carissa edulis fruits

    Enhancing Cocoa Agroforestry in Ghana through an integrated Geographic Information System (GIS)-based monitoring systemConservation Alliance International, Ghana

    Project scorecard

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    17

    he e tern Ghat mo ntain hain l in alon the n ia e tern oa tline i no n for ri h iolo i al

    an lt ral iver it o ever it i ar el overe rote te area an th ome n er a eleratin

    re re from lo in farmlan e an ion an other a tivitie o a arene on the role of

    io iver it in livelihoo an limite in entive

    Agriculture landscape in the Western Ghats Processing Terminalia chebula dried fruits

    Project 14-1

    Project scorecard

    for lo al omm nitie n erlie the e threat o a re thi i e the ro e t i entifie lant

    ith hi h on ervation an e val e e ta li he taina le harve tin ra ti e an val e hain

    an o taine A ertifi ation for them he ertifi ation enerate a itional enefit for the lo al omm nitie

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Promoting Green Entrepreneurship for conservation of Satoyama landscapes in the North Western Ghats, IndiaApplied Environmental Research Foundation (AERF), India

    he aren eo le rotational farmin tem i re o ni e the hai overnment a a national

    lt ral herita e o ever it ha een ome n er re re in ae m hai villa e e to e an in ommer ial mono ro in hi h in rea e in ome

    in the hort term t ha a ran e of ne ative im a t he ro e t on te arti i ator G ma in

    of tomar lan e ra ti e an no le e an e the re ltant ma to ain overnment

    4.1.5 Projects featuring rights-based instruments

    Project 13-1

    Supporting and promoting the Karen indigenous socio-ecological production system in northern ThailandIndigenous Knowledge and Peoples Foundation (IKAP), Thailand

    re o nition of the tomar lan e he ro e t al o o mente in i eno ee varietie an their

    ltivation te hni e an oil enri hment ra ti e hi hli htin the role of omen to maintain no le e on an to mana e ee an lant re o r e he

    ro e t al o reinvi orate intere t in in i eno no le e amon o n villa er a ell a hel in

    the villa e maintain it tra itional elf ffi ien an i entif in a ne in ome o r e from il fern

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    18

    Upland rice cropping in rotational farming system A Karen woman explaining traditional crop varieties

    Project scorecard

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    lt ral lan a e e ome a ne le al e t on the amen ment of the lt ral erita e re ervation

    a of ai an in o intro e thi ne on e t in alien o nt the ro e t e erimentall im lemente

    a olla orative a roa h to evelo in a lt ral an a e ite mana ement lan he ro e t f ll

    en a e lo al omm nitie an inte rate tra itional

    Cihalaay indigenous village landscape Hands-on training of agrobiodiversity observation

    Project 14-3

    Project scorecard

    no le e in e ta li hin a lo al mana ement ommittee an evelo in o e of on t for the

    offi ial ana ement rin i le an ana ement lan for the ihalaa lt ral an a e ite he ro e t

    romote or ani farmin an ro t evelo e omm nit a e environmental e ation o r e for

    the lo al o th an evelo e e oto ri m

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Tailoring Satoyama initiative concepts to national and local contexts: A Case Study of the collaborative planning process of a rice paddy cultural landscape in an indigenous community, TaiwanNational Don-Hwa University, Chinese Taipei

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    19

    he ff t eo le are no n for an a e ol ann al A oa ir eer h ntin fe tival hi h em o ie the

    ff t eo le lt re an i entifie an ort omm nit ohe ion n the fa e of threat to the ontin it of the fe tival e to a e linin eer o lation the ro e t o ht to a re the threat

    to the ff t a re h ntin ro n he ro e t t ie fft eo le o io lt ral lin a e ith io iver it a ell a e i tin tomar la he

    Warrior group in Aboakyir festival Reforestation of degraded hunting grounds

    Project 14-2

    Project scorecard

    ro e t then evelo e a trate to involve lo al omm nitie in on ervation a tion an form late

    la to tren then la enfor ement an to romote on ervation effort he omm nit orte the

    enfor ement of la a ain t offen e in l in thro h arti i ation in h ntin ro n monitorin hi

    erie of a tion enhan e omm nit a arene of eo le e en en e an im a t on io iver it an reate moment m for f rther ta ehol er en a ement

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Restoration of Community Sacred Forest to Enhance Socio-Ecological Landscape in the Effutu Traditional Area, GhanaA Rocha Ghana, Ghana

    en a oa tal an marine e o tem have e ome in rea in l e ra e overt o lation re re an limite environmental a arene have re lte in in i riminate man rove oo ttin ea t rtle harve tin an overe loitation of other nat ral re o r e o a re the e i e the ro e t

    tren thene lo al environmental overnan e fo in on the re toration of man rove an the on ervation of ea t rtle an their ha itat he ro e t ro e

    4.1.6 Projects featuring legal & regulatory instruments

    Project 16-1

    Strengthening communit participation in bio iversit conservation through bene t sharing an capacity buildingCommunity Based Environmental Conservation (COBEC), Kenya

    man rove ee lin an re tore ha of man rove fore t t al o im lemente a tem of

    olla orative ea h atrollin that en a e fi hermen an en a il life ervi e taff hi h re e ea t rtle illin half A a tit te for the re o r e that ere rote te the ro e t orte alternative livelihoo in l in o ltr farmin an ve eta le

    ltivation he ro e t al o romote the a o tion of taina le fi hin e i ment

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    20

    Mangrove restoration Releasing a trapped sea turtle

    Project scorecard

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    he fi herie e tor ontri te i nifi antl to Ghana national e onom t it taina ilit ha re eive limite attention he ro e t aime to em o er the oa tal omm nitie in the ff t Area one of the fi hin entre in entral Ghana for

    taina le fi herie mana ement an enhan in the inte rit an re ilien e of oa tal e o tem

    Demarcating core zone Fisheries recovery zone map

    Project 16-2

    Project scorecard

    he ro e t emar ate a omm nit fi herie re over one hi h fo tere rea ine for f t re marine rote te area e i nation he ro e t al o reha ilitate five he tare of e ra e man rove or ani e a man rove litter leanin am ai n

    e i nate a omm nit a te m in ite an initiate omm nit a e a te monitorin an mana ement

    n tr ment mi 1 2 3 4 5 6

    trate i O e tive a hieve 1 2 3 4

    ontri tion to A 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20

    ontri tion to G 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17

    Mangrove restoration to improve socioecological production landscapes and seascapes for sheries recover at the uni Poma e amsar Site

    A Rocha Ghana, Ghana

    Road

    Legend

    Stream

    Buffer zone

    TownOcean

    Salt pans

    TransitionZoneCoreMangroove

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

    ee a le a e for the n m er in the ore ar

  • 4 Result

    21

    4.2 Contribution to the Aichi Biodiversity Targets

    olle tivel the ro e t ma e tan i le ontri tion to everal A arti larl A arene

    of io iver it in rea e ar et o tem e ential ervi e afe ar e taina le

    ro tion on m tion taina le a ri lt re a a lt re fore tr io iver it val e inte rate an ra itional no le e re e te a le

    ifferent in tr ment em lo e the ro e t ontri te to ifferent et of A i re ana ement in tr ment h a lan re toration

    an refore tation lan a e or ea a e lannin an olla orative mana ement ma e the reate t

    ontri tion to ro re to ar the A e e iall o tem e ential ervi e afe ar e ar et o ial an lt ral in tr ment e li

    information an e ation vol ntar a reement artner hi an arti i ation follo e in term

    of ale of ontri tion he ontri te hi hl to A arene of io iver it in rea e ar et

    onomi an finan ial in tr ment ere ran e thir in term of ontri tion ma in relativel tron

    ontri tion to taina le a ri lt re a a lt re fore tr ar et taina le ro tion an on m tion an n entive reforme he

    fo rth lar e t ontri tion a from innovation an inte ration hi h arti larl ontri te to A arene of io iver it in rea e ar et an taina le ro tion an on m tion

    i ht a e an tomar in tr ment ontri te to a imilar e tent nota l to ra itional no le e re e te ar et an A arene of io iver it in rea e

    hro h a mi of the e in tr ment to a re om le lo al o io e onomi an e olo i al i e

    in ivi al ro e t ontri te to a i e arra of A n m ro e t olle tivel ontri te to o t

    of A he ma nit e of the ontri tion of in ivi al ro e t to the A i re ente in Anne

    ntervention ate or

    al e re o ni e 150

    oli inte ration of val e 76

    armf l in entive ha e o t 27

    taina le ro tion on m tion 85

    at ral ha itat rote te 46

    A ati life taina l mana e 29

    taina le a ri lt re a a lt re fore tr 80

    oll tion re e 12

    A ontrolle 6

    rote t oral reef v lnera le e o tem 11

    rote te area other on ervation mea re 29

    tin tion revente 9

    Geneti iver it on erve 13

    o tem ervi e afe ar e 104

    o tem re ilien e ar on to enhan e 38

    A 6

    ra itional no le e 74

    no le e hare im rove 26

    Total* 35 132 90 229 229 105 821

    nt

    e

    ila

    tion

    re

    latio

    n

    nt

    on

    omi

    finan

    ial

    nt

    i

    hta

    e

    to

    mar

    nt

    o

    ial

    lt

    ral

    nt

    an

    aem

    ent

    nt

    nno

    vatio

    n

    inte

    ratio

    n

    Tota

    l*

    Table 5. The magnitude of the contribution of different policy instruments to the Aichi Biodiversity Targets, expressed in the aggregated impact level scores for each combination between instrument type and the ABT.*

    Aich

    i Bio

    dive

    rsity

    Tar

    gets

    m er elo e imal oint ere ro n e off h the total n m er o not ne e aril mat h the m of the in ivi al n m er for ea h item

  • 4 Result

    22

    Figure 5. Network diagram: illustrating the contribution of different policy instruments to the Aichi Biodiversity Targets

    ote ee a le for the name of the Ai hi io iver it ar et A an oli in tr ment t e nt he i e of the m ltiolo re e e t for reen le la elle nt re re ent the a re ate a hievement level ore in tr ment t e a ro

    the ro e t he i th of the an et een nt le an the reen A le in i ate the level of ontri tion of ea h in tr ment t e to the in ivi al A hi h i al late a the m of the im a t level ore for the re e tive

    om ination et een in tr ment t e an the A he i e of the reen A le re re ent the m of im a t level ore for ea h A i e the e tent to hi h ea h A a a re e thro h all in tr ment t e em lo e the ro e t

    4.3 Contribution to theSustainable DevelopmentGoals

    Overall ro e t ontri te mo t to ife on lan Goal follo e ero h n er

    artner hi for oal ife elo ater an e on i le on m tion ro tion

    i re a le elevan e of the ro e t to o overt Goal alit e ation e ent or e onomi ro th Gen er e alit an limate a tion a ea l im lie

    he anal i in i ate that e ifi in tr ment have ontri te to e ifi et of G ana ementa e in tr ment nt hi h mar e the hi he t

    a re ate im a t level ore ontri te the mo t to ife on lan Goal Other nota le ontri tion

    ere o ial an lt ral in tr ment nt to

    artner hi for the oal Goal e onomi an finan ial in tr ment nt an inte ration an innovation nt to ero h n er Goal an ri ht

    a e in tr ment nt to ife on lan Goal an artner hi for oal he ma nit e of the ontri tion of ea h ro e t to the G are

    re ente in Anne

    he total im a t level ore for the G a i nifi antl maller than that for the A hi o l e attri te to either hi her relevan e

    of the ro e t to the A than the G or to the relativel limite o e of the G in i ator

    he G ith lo total im a t level ore ere on e t all relevant to the ro e t t i not

    have in i ator that o l a t re ro e t im a t he offi ial in i ator metri for the G mo tl e lo al an national tati ti an o ervation ata

    an the e ma fail to refle t the im a t of lo al ale intervention

  • 4 Result

    23

    oli in tr ment t e

    o overt 10

    ero h n er 51

    alit e ation 5

    Gen er e alit 2

    e ent or e onomi ro th 4

    e on i le on m tion ro tion 15

    limate a tion 1

    ife elo ater 26

    ife on lan 77

    artner hi for the oal 51

    Total* 8 39 25 57 76 38 243

    nt

    e

    ila

    tion

    re

    latio

    n

    nt

    on

    omi

    finan

    ial

    nt

    i

    hta

    e

    to

    mar

    nt

    o

    ial

    lt

    ral

    nt

    an

    aem

    ent

    nt

    nno

    vatio

    n

    inte

    ratio

    n

    Tota

    l*

    Table 6. The magnitude of the contribution of different policy instrument types to the SDGs, expressed in the aggregated impact level scores for each combination between policy instrument type and SDG.*

    tain

    ale

    ev

    ele

    men

    t Goa

    l

    Figure 6. Network diagram: illustrating the contribution of different policy instrument types to SDGsote ee a le for the name of the G an oli in tr ment t e nt he i e of the m lti olo re le e e t

    for l e la elle nt re re ent the a re ate a hievement level ore oli in tr ment t e a ro the ro e t he i th of the an et een nt le an the l e G le in i ate the level of ontri tion of ea h

    in tr ment t e to in ivi al G hi h i al late a the m of the im a t level ore for re e tive om ination et een in tr ment t e an G he i e of the l e G le re re ent the m of im a t level ore for ea h

    G i e the e tent to hi h ea h Goal a a re e thro h all in tr ment em lo e the ro e t

    m er elo e imal oint ere ro n e off h the total n m er o not ne e aril mat h the m of the in ivi al n m er for ea h item

  • 4 Result

    24

    Figure 7. Number of the SDM projects that were successful in, or making efforts for, obtaining policy uptake or support at national and subnational levels

    4.4 Harnessing the SDM projectachievements

    o t rantee ma e effort to ale the initiative that the have evelo e or romote in their

    ro e t e on the ro e t ite an ration he ro re of their effort in three ifferent form are e ri e elo i e the oli ta e of an ort

    to the initiative the evelo e or romote in the ro e t a itional f n rai in for f rther ontin in

    an evelo in the initiative a ell a artner hi il in an o trea h he e are a oo in i ation

    of the ro re an o i ilit of alin lo al

    initiative in to a i er eo ra hi area an a lar er n m er of ta ehol er

    4.4.1 Policy uptake and supportineteen o t of ro e t a hieve oli ta e

    or oli ort i re he e in l e the inte ration of ro e t o t t into national an

    national la lan an trate ie a le ome ro e t o taine overnment f n to ontin e

    their a tivitie in i atin that there a oliti al ill to romote the e initiative he follo in e tion

    e ri e finan ial a e t more in etail

    National, 11

    Subnational, 8

    Successful,19

    No answer, 4

    Yet to make efforts, 3

    Efforts ongoing, 4

    Level Government entities or relevant policies

    ational he ro e t re are a raft tate trate for o ri m evelo ment for A of e eral i nifi an e an mitte it to the ini tr of at ral e o r e ia

    he ore t a in or orate an arti le on lantin native tree ietnam

    he ational ore t ervi e e the e erien e from the ro e t for the nitiative for the efore tation of e ra e ore t an a e er

    ational A ri lt ral e ear h Or ani ation rovi e a rant to ontin e the ro e t a tivitie an a

    national he ore tr rea a o te the ational trate i rame or for romotin ato ama nitiative hine e ai ei

    he oil an ater on ervation rea e the ro e t re lt to evelo the ral e eneration oli hine e ai ei

    A re ional environmental a thorit in l e the ro e t initiative into it fo r ear a tion lan olom ia

    A o nt nvironmental oli in or orate a om onent on marine re o r e rote tion an e ro o e the ro e t en a

    ihalaa lt ral an a e ana ement rin i le an lan a evelo e hine e ai ei

    A villa e evelo ment ommittee allo ate of the a ri lt re fore tr an environment f n for im lementation of the A in e al

    Table 7. Examples of success in policy uptake of, or support to, project activities

  • 4 Result

    25

    4.4.2 Financing

    o t ro e t have een e f l in mo ili in a itional inve tment levera in the rant

    he ha inve te a ro imatel in ro e t in e olle tivel the e

    ro e t mo ili e a ro imatel in mat hin f n from the rantee or other o r e in l in in in ontri tion Of the om lete

    ro e t rantee are till ontin in the initiative evelo e or romote thro h their

    ro e t il in on their enhan e ro e t o ner hi an on enhan e ta ehol er olla oration in l in olla oration ith lo al omm nit ro an overnment a en ie Al o ro e t attra te a itional f n in from other o r e i re a le

    rai in in total a ro imatel rimaril from overnment an international onor n m the attra te in rea e inve tment

    4.4.3 Partnership and outreach ro e t have tren thene olla oration ith

    an et een mem er an other ta ehol er a ro e tor A total of or ani ation a i e from rantee ere involve in the

    ro e t in l in mem er i re On avera e or ani ation a ro or ani ation

    Otrher/no answer, 2

    Not applied, 5

    Successful, 14

    Applied and waiting, 2

    Applied butunsuccessful, 6

    Figure 8. Number of SDM project that were successful in, or making efforts for, mobilising additional funds

    Type Fund name / donor

    nternational onor G ato ama ro e t Glo al nvironment a ilit an on ervation nternational a an m a Ghana Grant for orl nvironment a m a Ghana ana a n for o al nitiative ana ian m a Ghana

    Government ational A ri lt ral e ear h Or ani ation of an a ai an ore tr e ear h n tit te he o n ation of the re i ential Grant ian e eration ain treamin ai an artner hi for ato ama nitiative ore tr rea ai an

    Table 8. Examples of the donors and funds that provided additional funding

    t e ere involve in ea h ro e t he involvement of GO an ivil o iet or ani ation a hi he t follo e the involvement of lo al overnment national overnment in i eno or lo al omm nit or ani ation an niver itie or re ear h in tit te

    2

    24

    19

    12

    22

    276

    2437

    418

    41

    0 10 20 30 40 50National Government

    Local GovernmentOther Government Affiliation

    Indigenous/Local CommunityNGO/Civil Society

    Industry/Private SectorUniversity/Researc institute

    United Nations/Inter-govermentalOther

    Number of organisations

    IPSI member

    Non-IPSI member

    Figure 9. Number of organisations engaged in SDM projects, by organisation types

  • 4 Result

    26

    o t ro e t al o ma e effort to i eminate their re lt thro h vario me ia n m

    li ation re entation or me ia roa a tin tar etin mainl ome ti or lo al a ien e ere ma e or ani ation i re Amon the e the n m er of onferen e re entation a far the hi he t follo e non a a emi o rnal or ma a ine arti le online vi eo a a emi o rnal arti le ne a er arti le an e a e

    Type Title Number

    olla orative a tivitie

    event

    Glo al onferen e i th

    e ional Afri a

    e ional Ameri a

    e ional A ia an the a ifi

    A

    Other

    li ation

    hemati evie no le e

    hemati evie ain treamin

    hemati evie ivelihoo

    Other

    Table 9. Number of engagements of the SDM project proponents in IPSI collaborative activities, events and publications

    1

    1

    111

    1

    1

    12

    3

    62

    1

    12

    1

    1

    11 1

    13

    2

    11

    1

    0 5 10 15

    1 Academic journal article2 Other type of journal/magazine article

    3 Newspaper4 Brochure or other type of printed media

    5 Conference presentation6 Lecture/training

    7 TV8 Radio

    9 Webpage10 Online video

    11 SNS

    Number of publications/broadcasts

    Global Regional National Subnational Local Other NS

    Figure 10. Number of dissemination outputs by type

    Al o ner ie et een an other relate a tivitie ere o erve even ro e t ere re i tere a olla orative a tivitie ent three

    re entation on the ro e t ere ma e at lo al onferen e re ional or ho a ell a the re lar e ion at the nternational or m for taina le A ia an the a ifi A o rteen arti le on the ro e t ere li he

    in a erie of li ation arti larl the ato ama nitiative hemati evie a le

    4.5 A self-assessment of theperformance of theSDM Secretariat

    he e retariat ha i ma or ta i ro o al all ii ro e t ele tion iii ro e t la n h an

    im lementation ort iv ro e t eval ation v re lt i emination an vi the e retariat al o hel ri e the rantee to ne f n in o ort nitie ithin it a a it Anne hi

    e tion re ent the o t t of the e retariat for international o trea h an the re lt of an online

    rve that a e the rantee to eval ate the e i f n tion of the e retariat

  • 4 Result

    27

    SDM outreachhe e retariat ha een arr in o t roa tive

    o trea h on the a tivitie an re lt of the to it lo al a ien e ithin an e on ntil

    e r ar the ha li he five oo let a mmar re ort an a ane e leaflet i re

    i re an ma e ei ht re entation in relevant international event a le he

    en a ement ith the e retariat an e ert al o rovi e the fo n ation for the G ato ama ro e t

    G ato ama ro e t i a fo r ear me i m i e f n in ro ramme tarte in that im lemente

    ro e t for on ervin in the n o rma the a a a ar an n ian O ean lan an the

    ro i al An e io iver it ot ot

    Figure 11. SDM booklets and summary report (English)

    Figure 12. SDM leaflets in Japanese

    htt ef ato ama net

    http://gef-satoyama.net/

  • 4 Result

    28

    Date, venue Conference/event title Presentation title (presenter)

    l o ohama a an

    ato ama an taina le evelo ment ri in ro e t finan in an no le e eneration A arallel e ion at the nternational or m for taina le A ia an the a ifi

    A

    A oo ra ti e from ortin an romotin the aren in i eno o io

    e olo i al ro tion tem in northern hailan r ra ert ra an ha on A

    ovem er ontreal ana a

    olla orative re o r e mo ili ation an no le e fa ilitation thro h lo al artner hi A tivitie of the nternational artner hi for the ato ama nitiative

    A i e event at the nineteenth meetin of the onvention on iolo i al iver it i iar o on ientifi e hni al

    an e hnolo i al A vi e A

    ato ama evelo ment e hani m ee f n in for enhan in olle tive learnin

    on o io e olo i al ro tion lan a e an ea a e

    A ril ontreal ana a

    olle tion an trate i e of no le e for main treamin io iver it into vario e tor A i e event at the t entieth meetin of the onvention on

    iolo i al iver it i iar o on ientifi e hni al an e hnolo i al A vi e A

    ato ama evelo ment e hani m A hievement in it three ear of o eration an lin a e ith G

    l o ohama a an

    nte rate lan a e mana ement ffe tive a roa he for tran latin no le e into tran formative a tion A

    arallel e ion at the nternational or m for taina le A ia an the a ifi A

    romotin Green ntre rene r hi for on ervation of ato ama lan a e in the orth e tern Ghat n ia r a ant arnai

    A

    A ril ota ina al ala ia

    ain treamin on e t an a roa he of o ioe olo i al ro tion lan a e an ea a e in A ia

    ato ama nitiative e ional or ho in a ah

    ato ama nitiative evelo ment e hani m ee f n in for enhan in lan a e

    a roa h on

    O to er ana a a a an

    he eventh Glo al onferen e General A em l

    ato ama evelo ment e hani m n atin an main treamin e t ra ti e in

    ovem er harm l hei h

    t

    on oli ation an e li ation of ffe tive an a e A roa he for io iver it on ervation an man

    ivelihoo A i e event at the fo rteen meetin of the onferen e of artie of the onvention on iolo i al iver it O

    ato ama evelo ment e hani m

    an ar a o a a an

    lti ta ehol er artner hi to enhan e lan a e an ea a e a roa he for io iver it on ervation an

    h man livelihoo inner event at the onvention on iolo i al iver it e ional or ho on the o t

    Glo al io iver it rame or for A ia an the a ifi

    ato ama evelo ment e hani m

    Table 10. Presentations on SDM at relevant international conferences and events

    re enter i not in i ate for the re entation ma e the e retariat

  • 4 Result

    29

    ro e t ele tion an etter on i er fiel realit not onl ro o al alit he rant amo nt an e lar er an the ro e t erio lon er to ena le lar er ro e t A lar er ro ortion for the fir t in talment o l a i t ith mooth ro e t tart ro e t ho l e eval ate ith horter an learer e tionnaire or even etter thro h ite vi it to n er tan fiel realit

    ort ho l e rovi e for mo ili in mat hin a itional f n for e f l ro e t om letion omm ni ation ith the rant re i ient an e im rove All ro e t nee enhan e vi i ilit an re lt i emination or ho to e han e ro e t e erien e ho l e or ani e

    Table 11. Points raised by the SDM grantees for the improvement of the SDM functions

    SDM grantees’ evaluation on SDMn the re on e to the online rve mo t rant re i ient tate that the a re iate the

    effe tivene of the e retariat in arr in o t all of it i f n tion i re A fe felt a nee

    for im rovement in the e retariat effe tivene for ro e t la n h an im lementation lo in an

    eval ation i emination a ell a in ri in ne o ort nitie he oint for im rovin the ro e e of rai e the rantee are li te in a le

    Very good

    Good

    Fair

    Needs improvement

    Poor

    Don’t know

    Call Selection DisseminationLaunch &

    implementationClosing &evalution

    7

    Newopportunities

    15

    9

    10

    13

    1

    11

    11

    1 2

    1

    8

    9

    1

    6

    7

    11

    1

    5

    9

    1

    5

    Figure 13. Evaluation by the SDM grantees on the performance of the SDM Secretariat regarding its six major functions

    on t no an er ere from rantee ho have not et om lete their ro e t an th annot eval ate the e ro e e

  • 30

    5

    hi e tion mmari e an i e e fin in of the anal i fo in on the ontri tion of the to the trate i O e tive Ai hi

    io iver it ar et an G t al o larifie ho the lan a e or ea a e level ro e t an enerate lon la tin an lar er ale im a t in tan em ith other ta ehol er an ho the an enhan e it

    ort to the e a tion

    Achieving the IPSI Strategic Objectives ro e t envi a e reali in h man o ietie in

    harmon ith nat re in o io e olo i al ro tion lan a e an ea a e nevita l ea h

    ro e t im lemente a mi of everal a tivitie to a re om le o io e olo i al i e hi h an

    e roa l ate ori e n er le al an re lator e onomi an finan ial ri ht a e o ial an information mana ement an innovative an inte rative in tr ment em lo in ifferent mi e of the e in tr ment all om lete ro e t have ontri te remarkably to the four IPSI Strategic Objectives. Collectively, the SDM projects contributed most to the fourth objective ‘enhance capacities ollo e b the rst objective increase

    no le ge the thir enhance bene ts an the second ‘address drivers’. o ial an information in tr ment arti larl the romotion of o ial norm in taina le life t le an ra ti e thro h a arene rai in an environmental e ation

    ontri te the hi he t to enhan in a a itie i ht a e a roa he ma e the reate t ontri tion to in rea in no le e nota l thro h

    the a tivitie to re o ni e an ort in i eno an tomar ten re ri ht ra ti e an no le e

    onomi an finan ial in tr ment h a the rovi ion of alternative taina le livelihoo an

    in ome o r e ontri te to a re in the thir o e tive enhance benefits ana ement in tr ment

    arti larl thro h lan a e ea a e mana ement lan evelo ment an im lementation ontri te

    to a re in the river of e linin io iver it an livelihoo in ta ehol er olla oration

    e on e tor an level a ell a the inte ration of tra itional no le e an ien e to over ome

    Key findings and discussion

    non onventional taina ilit hallen e rovi e the a i for em lo in a mi of the e in tr ment for a hievin the trate i O e tive

    Contributing to Aichi Biodiversity Targets and SDGs

    he ro e t have em o ie the trate i O e tive a e ri e a ove an there made substantial contributions to the ABTs and the SDGs, particularly the ABTs centring around people’s awareness, primary production and other ecosystem services, values and knowledge, and the SDGs related to life on land and below water and their primary productions a le he re lt reveale that the a tion for io iver it an h man ell ein in an lea to the reali ation of ner ie amon the G an the A

    o ever the total im a t level on the G a far le than that on the A hi o l im l in i ate that the A an their in i ator etter over the i e a re e the ro e t t al o

    o l im l that the G in i ator annot effe tivel a t re the ro e t re lt he G ith lo

    im a t level ore ere on e t all relevant to the ro e t t i not have the in i ator to re or the im a t of the ro e t he offi ial in i ator metri for G mo tl e lo al an national

    tati ti an o ervation ata hi h ometime annot effe tivel a t re the tren an effort at

    lo al ale in

    ith thi in min there are t o o i le a to hel more effe tivel re o ni e the ontri tion of

    to the G One i to ale the ro e t a tivitie an o t ome to a lar er atial e tent an lon er ration in a a to infl en e the national

    tati ti an there to im rove the G in i ator he other i to reate lo ali e G in i ator et

    that effe tivel a t re the effort an o t ome in an e li itl lin them to the e i tin lo al

    G in i ator

  • 31

    5 Key findings and discussion

    Aichi Biodiversity TargetsAggregated impact level

    scoreA arene of io iver it in rea e

    o tem e ential ervi e afe ar e

    taina le ro tion on m tion

    taina le a ri lt re a a lt re fore tr

    io iver it val e inte rate

    ra itional no le e re e te

    … …

    Total 821

    SDGsAggregated impact level

    scoreife on lan

    ero h n er

    artner hi for the oal

    ife elo ater

    e on i le on m tion ro tion

    o overt

    … …

    Total 243

    Table 12. ABTs and SDGs to which the SDM projects collectively and significantly contributed, in the order of the magnitude of contributions order of the magnitude of contributions

    Towards a transformative changehe ro e t enerate o t ome that ere

    inherentl limite to their hort ration an the ro e t ite e ho ever o erve the effort the

    rantee to harne the ro e t a hievement to in e a tran formative han e he e effort in l e integrating the project activities and outputs in policies, mobilising additional investments, strengthening partnerships and proactive outreach.

    ineteen o t of ro e t emon trate ro re in oli ta e an ort in l in the inte ration of ro e t o t t into national an national la

    lan an trate ie he a hievement of a ro e t in iet am fa ilitate the in l ion of an arti le in the ietname e fore t la that en o ra e lantin native tree A ro e t on ian lt ral lan a e in national ar mitte a raft tate trate

    for o ri m evelo ment for rote te Area to the ian fe eral overnment

    an ro e t have een e f l in mo ili in a itional inve tment e on their initial life an

    o rteen o t of om lete ro e t e f ll o taine ne f n in after ro e t en he e in l e a ro e t rant from an international onor the Glo al

    nvironmental a ilit an allo ation of or inar et from a overnmental a en in ai an

    An im ortant feat re of the ro e t i that all the rant re i ient im lemente the ro e t in olla oration ith man other or ani ation an

    ta ehol er in l in overnment GO O rivate e tor a tor an re ear h in tit te A total

    of or ani ation on avera e or ani ation a ro ifferent e tor for ea h ro e t ere involve olla oration amon mem er a

    tren thene thro h ro e t ith mem er a i e from the rant re i ient involve in the ro e t he e fi re are evi en e that the a a le to reali e it f n tion of en o ra in

    olle tive a tion of a i e arra of ta ehol er

    he e t ra ti e an le on learnt in the ro e t ere hare ith a i e arra of ta ehol er

    in the ro e t ite an o ntr n m li ation re entation or me ia roa a t tar etin mainl ome ti or lo al a ien e ere ma e rantee he e rovi e material to a elerate m t al learnin

    on an mi ht have ontri te to oli ta e an ort an a itional f n rai in a e ri e a ove

    he a hievement of the ro e t ith re e t to oli inte ration re o r e mo ili ation artner hi

    il in an o trea h a e ri e a ove rovi e a oo in i ation of the f t re o i ilit for alin

    the ro e t initiative to lar er atial an tem oral ale o enerate lon la tin an lar er

    ale im a t rantee ho l on i er ho the an trate i all r e the e fo r area in tan em

    for hi h more temi ort from international initiative an onor ill e re ire

    Improving the performance of the SDMefle tin on the e erien e of the e retariat in

    im lementin the an it o trea h in the a t five ear an on the online rve re lt the follo in

    re ommen ation are rovi e to f rther enhan e the effi ien an effe tivene of the

  • Improve the framework for project design and evaluation: A ne ro e t e i n an eval ation frame or i alle on that oe not om romi e fle i ilit t allo for ro t a e ment a ain t international oal an tar et he ne frame or al o ho l ta e f ller a o nt of fiel realitie in

    ro e t ele tion an eval ation

    Streamline knowledge management throughout project selection, evaluation and results dissemination processes: he no le e mana ement tem for the nee f n amental im rovement he ne tem ho l allo mooth

    ate flo from ata mi ion from the rantee at the ro e t e innin an en to the eval ation an the i emination of the ro e t re lt h a

    tem an re e r en on the rantee an the e retariat for ata mi ion an ro e in an

    al o an a elerate information harin

    5 Key findings and discussion

    Enhance the communications between the SDM grantees on their ideas, results and experiences: A

    ontin o an more in l ive no le e latform an e reate hether it e thro h fa e to fa e

    meetin or online a i h a latform o l e effe tive to en o ra e eer to eer learnin a in on the e i tin a ho o ort nitie rovi e e the ato ama nitiative hemati evie li ation an Glo al onferen e an e ional or ho

    Support additional resource mobilisation by the SDM grantees after the project end hile it i la a le that half of all rantee ere e f l in a itional f n rai in levera in on their ro e t re lt it i nfort nate that half ere not a le to e re a itional f n he an on i er ithin it

    a a it rovi in tron er ort to the rantee for a itional f n rai in e thro h a mat hma in heme in olla oration ith other onor

    32

  • 33

    6he follo in re ommen ation are i entifie for

    fiel ra titioner overnment an international or ani ation a e on the e fin in re ente in thi re ort heir aim i to fa ilitate en rin the

    taina ilit of eo le an nat re in an their ontri tion to rrent an f t re lo al io iver it

    tar et an the G

    Initiate and champion SEPLS initiatives: iel ra titioner involve in are in a o ition to

    initiate an ham ion initiative that enhan e an roa a t the enefit of e i mo t

    li el hen initiative refle t the nee an a iration of lo al ta ehol er an em o an inte rative a roa h to a hievin m lti le A an

    G

    Promote or participate in multi-stakeholder initiatives: initiative an enerate lon erla tin an f rther rea hin im a t an in e a tran formative han e A oor inate a tion of fiel

    ra titioner overnment an international or ani ation in l in onor i e hi h hel inte rate ro e t o t t into oli ie e re lonterm f n in il artner hi an o trea h i er

    ta ehol er

    Highlight the contribution of SEPLS to global sustainability: Government an international or ani ation ma e in a o ition to hi hli ht the im ortan e of in ontri tin to a o t

    lo al io iver it frame or the G an other relevant international ro e e

    Recommendations

    Develop localised SDGs indicators for SEPLS: he ontri tion of the to lo al taina ilit an e ma e more e li it evelo in lo ali e

    in i ator for a art of the lo al G in i ator frame or iel ra titioner

    overnment an international or ani ation an or olle tivel to ta e thi mall t meanin f l

    te for ar

    Improve the e ectiveness an e cienc o the SDM: he ha een emon tra l e f l t effe tivene an effi ien o l ho ever e

    im rove a ne ro e t e i n an eval ation frame or that oe not om romi e fle i ilit t ena le ro t a e ment a no le e mana ement tem treamline thro ho t the

    ro e t ele tion eval ation an re lt i emination ro e reation of a ontin o an

    in l ive no le e harin latform to en o ra e eer to eer learnin a ell a ort to a itional

    re o r e mo ili ation e thro h a mat h ma in heme in olla oration ith other onor

  • 34

    A o ta A et al. ha ter O tion for Governan e an e i ion a in a ro ale an

    e tor in ar i et al. e The IPBES regional assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services for Asia and the Pacific onn German

    e retariat of the nter overnmental ien e oli latform on io iver it an o tem ervi e

    Availa le at htt i e net tem t fi e inf rev f file t e no e i A e e ovem er

    O A O O O A O O O

    O O OG A n i ator for the trate i lan for io iver it an the Ai hi io iver it ar et onvention on iolo i al

    iver it Availa le at htt int oe i ion o o e en f A e e ovem er

    a Summary for policymakers of the assessment report on land degradation and restoration of the Intergovernmental SciencePolicy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services ite

    hole et al. onn German e retariat Availa le at i e net A e e A ril

    Summary for policymakers of the regional assessment report on biodiversity and ecosystem services for Europe and Central Asia of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services ite i her et al.

    onn German e retariat Availa le at htti e net tem t f m e a i ital

    f file t e no e i