ACBED FHGJILKHMNK KHOJPRQ$MSFTFTILUVPXWdemarle/research/MSTHESIS/thesis.pdf · / aja

102

Transcript of ACBED FHGJILKHMNK KHOJPRQ$MSFTFTILUVPXWdemarle/research/MSTHESIS/thesis.pdf · / aja

����������� ������� ��������������������� ������������������� �

!#" � $%�&���� � " $%��' � �����(���&$)��*+����� " �

,�-

.0/21436587:9;.=<?>�/�@BA6<

CEDGF <IHB3JH:HLK ,�M 3 DBD <?5 DGN)DBF <0OP/�Q?K�A D - N OR F <TS(U�361�<?@LHB3 D - N OVS D / F

36UXWY/�@ D 3Z/�A[O\K�A6]YA6A M <?U D^N O DBF <_@B<?`�K�36@B< M <IU D HaO N @ DGF <_5�<Ibc@B<I< N O

>�/�H D <?@ N OVdeQI3J<?UfQ?<

36U

g N M W�K D <?@�deQ?36<?U�QI<

deQ F�N4N A N O g N M W�K D 36U�b

R F <TS(U�361�<?@LHB3 D - N OVS D / F

C K�bcK�H Dih�jcjck

g N W - @L3Jb F�D�Q� .0/21436587:9;.=<?>�/�@BA6< h�jcj�k

C AJA��:3Jb F�D H��(<IHB<?@ 1c<I5

�������������� ���������������������� ������������ �"!#�$�%��&

')(+*�, -/.102'435-76 8935: : 0<;�;=, , >+*�*�-53?. >+@

ACBED�FHGJILKHMNK�KHOJPRQ$MSFTFTILUVPXW

Y D[Z\MNU^]�_ Y IL`aDcb�dSI

e GfMNKgFHGJILKHMhK�GRDCK�PiIjILklbHILDCUmPXWaILDCn�GoQ�ILQ�PiIjb�ACBpFHGJI�BqArdhdSA[stMhkJuvKHOJwiIjbHZxMhKTACbHWanyArQ�Q�MSFTFTIjIVDCkfUP\WVQ�D{zTACb�MSF|W}ZCACFTI�GfDCK2PiIjILk}BqArOfkfUvFTA$P~I�KHDcFHMNKTBqDCnyFTACb�WC_

�����[����� � FTIjZCILk��_f�EDcbH�CIjb

� GRDcb�dSILK Y _R�#DCkfKTILk

��IjFTIjb � _ � GfMSb�dhIjW

�������������� ���������������������� ������������ �"!#�$�%��&

� 0�� >1@ - , >�� 0�� � >+*�*�-53?. >1@

e A�FHGJI��#b�DCUROfDcFTI � ArOfkRnjMhdiACB�FHGfI��tkRMSZCIjb�KHMSF|W$ACB��tFHDCG

� GfD[ZCIpbHILDCUFHGJIpFHGJILKHMhK�ACB Y DLZxMhU^]�_ Y IL`aDcb�dSI MhkMSFHK �RkfDCd�B ACb�Q�DCkfU�GfD[ZCIBqArOfkfU�FHGfDcF������EMSFHK BqACb�Q�DcF��\njMSFHDcFHMSArkfK��XDCkfU�PRMSP�dhMSACuCb�DcwRGRMhn KTF|W\dhI�DcbHI�nyArkfK�MhKTFTILkXF DCkfU�DCnjnyIjwfFHDcP�dSI������� MSFHKpMhdhdNOfKTFTb�DcFHMSZCI#Q�DcFTIjb�MhDCdNK�MNkfnjdhOfUfMNkJu��furOJbHILK��XFHDcPRdhILK��JDCkfUvn�GfDcb�FHK2DcbHI�Mhk$w�dhDCnyI��fDCkfU������ FHGJI�RkfDCdxQ�DCk\OfKHnyb�MSwfF MhK KHDcFHMhKHBqDCnyFTACbHWFTA�FHGJI � OJwiIjbHZ\MNKTACbHW � ArQ�Q$MSFTFTIjI�DCkfU�MhKEbHILDCUfW�BqACb KHOJPRQ$MhKHKHMSArkFTA e GfI��#b�DCUfOfDcFTI � n�GJA\Ard _

� �� "! � FTIjZCILka�_���Dcb��CIjb�����L� ���$#&%(')!��+* �-,".[�+/ �0.21�1��3 4 +!5!

6 wfwfbHA{ZCILU BqACb�FHGJI�`aD{z ACb Y Ijw�DcbHFHQ�ILkXF

e GfArQ�DCK � _f�tILkfUJIjb�KHArk�����L� �87 � ���+!:98 ".{�

6 wfwfbHA{ZCILUvBqACb�FHGJI��#b�DCUfOfDcFTI � ArORkfnjMhd

Y D[Z\MhU � _ � GfDcwRQ$DCk� !��2;<.�=?>E�@!�A�� �CB�%��� +!D#�9 �(.&.2E

����������� �

R F <?@L< 36H /:bc@ N � 36U�b(U�<?<I5TO N @ DGN4N AJH DBF / D /�365 36U DBF < K�U�5�<I@BH D /�U�5�36U�b N O F 36b F�� @L<?H N AJK D 3 N U5Y/ D /f9�7���/ M W�A6<?H%3JU�QIAJK�5f< M <?5�36Q /�A:5Y/ D / Wf@ N 5�K�Q?<I5 ,�- M /�bcUf< D 36QX@B<?H N UY/�UfQ?<�3 M /�b�3JU�bHBQ?/�U�U�<I@BH � / U�5 5Y/ D /#Wf@ N 5�K�Q?<I5 ,�- Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A��YK�365 5 - UY/ M 3JQIH0HB3 M K�AZ/ D 3 N UfH?9�=36HBK �/�A63� / D 3 N U D <?Q F Uf3J`�K�<?H^O N @ AZ/ @Bbc<(5Y/ D /T3JU�QIAJK�5f< N � 36U�<i@L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b N O H D 3JA6A;3 M /�bc<?H � HBK , HB/ M �W�A63JU�b DGN @B<I5�K�Q?< DGF < HB3�I< N O DGF < 5Y/ D / � / U�5T36U D <?@B/�Q D 361c< @B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb=K�HB36U�biHLK�W <?@BQ N M W�K D <I@BHI9� � 3JU�< @B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb M / ��<IH 3 D 5�3��%Q?KfA D_DGN <��f/ M 3JU�< DBF @B<I< � 5f3 M <?U�HL3 N UY/ AVH D @BK�Q D K�@L< 3JU DGF <5Y/ D /f9�� UX/�U 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361c<i@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@ � DBF <=K�HL<?@aQ?/�U M N 1�< DGF <i1436< � W N 3JU D /�Uf5 <��f/ M 3JU�< N Q �Q?A6K�HB3 N U 9 deK , HB/ M W�AJ36U�b�Q?/�U M / ��< DGF < 5Y/ D /iH M /�AJA�<IU N K�b F O N @ 3JU D <I@G/�Q D 361�< @L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b � , K D3 D 5�<?H D @ N - H 3JUeO N @ M / D 3 N U Q N U D <?U D 9�R F <8deQI3J<?U D 36]YQ g N M W�K D 3JUfb�� U�H D 3 D K D <�� H)36U D <?@B/�Q D 361�<@G/ - � D @G/�QI<?@���� � �(/ -�� Q?/�U H N A61�< , N�DBF N O DBF <?HL< W�@ N , A6< M H ,�- <��eW�A N 3 D 36U�b DGF < W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< N OAZ/ @Bbc<:H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - HLK�W[<I@BQ N M WfK D <I@BH?9 S(UfO N @ D K�UY/ D <?A - DGF <IHB< M /�Q F 3JU�<IH /�@L<�<��eW[<IU�HB3 1c</�U�5 N O AJ3 M 3 D <?5 / 1�/ 3JAZ/ , 3JA63 D - 9C A N � <?@=Q N H D QIAJK�H D <?@ N O � g H � � 3 DGF H D /�U�5�/�@B5 F 36b F HBW <?<I5 Uf< D � N @!��36U D <?@ OP/�Q?<IH � Q?/�U

/�A6H N 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361c<IA - @B<IU�5�<I@=AZ/�@Lbc< 1 N AJK M <IH?9=R N W�@ N 1�< DGF 36H � < F / 1c<)Q?@L< / D <?5 / Uf< � @G/ - �D @B/�Q?<I@ � 5�<?@L361�<?5 O\@ N M � � �(/ - � � F 3JQ F @BK�U�H N U_Q?A6K�H D <?@LH?9 R F < W�@ N bc@B/ M 3JH / U 3 M /�b�<VWY/�@B/�AJA6<?A@G/ - D @G/�QI<?@ � 3 DBF / HLK�W <?@L1436H N @#" � N @!��<I@BH H D @LK�Q D K�@B< 9 R F < HLK�W <?@L1436H N @%/�U�5 � N @!� <?@BH /�@L<M K�A D 3 DGF @L< /�5�<I5T/ W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N UfH @BK�U�Uf3JU�b N UTHL<?WY/�@B/ D < U N 5�<?HI9�$ < D � <I<?U)U N 5�<?H � /�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U�HQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ D < N 1c<I@i/ U�< � U�< D � N @%�8A63 , @B/�@ - Q /�A6AJ<I5'& <Ibc3 N U 9 & <Ibc3 N U8/�5f5�Hi/ HB36U�bcA6<0AZ/ - <I@N O / , H D @B/�Q D 3 N U DGNiDBF <^H D /�U�5�/�@B5)U�< D � N @!�T36U D <?@ OP/�Q?< � <IUY/ , A63JU�bi/�H - U�Q F @ N U N KfH F /�U�5�A63JU�b N O3JU � , N K�U�5 M <?HLHG/�bc<IH?9VR F <(Uf< D � N @!�+A63 , @B/�@ - /�A6H N 36U�Q?A6K�5�<?H /=H N O D � /�@B<:5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5)H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - DGF / D M / ��<IH DGF <=/�bcbc@L<?b�/ D < M < M N @ - HLWY/�Q?< N O DGF <=QIAJK�H D <I@^K�HG/ , AJ< 9�(�3 DGF H M /�AJA5Y/ D / � DGF <XW�@ N bc@B/ M @L<?W�A63JQ?/ D <IH DGF < <IU D 3J@L< HBQ?<IU�< N U < /�Q F U N 5�<�9*) N @ M K�A D 3 ��+ 36b�/ ,�- D <1 N AJK M < D @B3JQ 5Y/ D / � � N @!��<I@BH N , D /�3JU+5�/ D / , @L3JQ,��H N U 5�< M /�U�5+O\@ N M DBF <a5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5)H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - 9-( <^<��eW�AJ/�3JU DGF < 3 M W�AJ< M <IU D / D 3 N U N O DGF <^5�3JH D @L3 , K D <?5+36U D <?@B/�Q D 361�< @B<IU�5�<I@B<?@ / U�5/�UY/ A - ?<_3 D HaW[<I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< 9

R N � / DBD 3

� " ����� ��� �

������������� ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ���

��� ��������� ����� � ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������!�"�#�$�

��� ���������%��� � ��&������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� '

�()�*��� +�,�

-/. �10 �����2 � �� � � 0 ����������������������������������������������������������������������������� -

3�. � � �4�� 52768�9��:������������������������������������������������������������������������������ ;

<�. � ��� � 0 ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� -=<

k 9?> g N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@> kk 9?>c9A> g N U�Uf<?Q D 3 N U8/�Uf5 R @G/�UfHLO\<?@ N OV.0/ D / 9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@> kk 9?>c9 h & N bcH � d D / D 3JH D 36Q?H:/�U�5 .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 $^/ @B@B36<?@LH 9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@>CB

k 9 h .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 d F / @B<?5 >�< M N @ - 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@>�Dk 9 h 9A> g N M%M N U � @L3JU�QI3JW�A6<?H#9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@>�Dk 9 h 9 h �:< /�5 � U�A - >�< M N @L3J<?H09f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@>�Ek 9 h 9 k ( @B3 D / , A6<0>�< M N @ - 9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@>�E

k 9 k C U�/�A - HB36H09Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h�jk 9 k 9A> g N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U � <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI<a9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h >k 9 k 9 h .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?58d F /�@B<I5�>�< M N @ - g N M WY/�@L3JH N U=9�9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h�kk 9 k 9 k .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?58d F /�@B<I5�>�< M N @ - deQ?/�AJ36U�b 9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h Dk 9 k 9GF g F /�@B/�Q D <?@L3JH D 3JQIH N O DBF < >�< M N @ - deWY/�QI< 9;9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 hIH

JK. � +* ��� ��4�� 52L2��M�N�L��5OP�M���� �10Q� ��������������������������������������� <�R

F�9?> � M W�AJ< M <IU D / D 3 N U 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 kcjF�9?>c9A> � @ N b�@G/ M d D @LK�Q D K�@B< 9 9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 kcjF�9?>c9 h g N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k�hF�9?>c9 k R /�H!� C HBHL3JbcU M <?U D 9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k D

F�9 h C U�/�A - HB36H09Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k EF�9 h 9A>8S�< D � N @!� � <I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k EF�9 h 9 h g N M W�K D < � N � <I@ 9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF kF�9 h 9 k g N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U#/�U�5 g N M W�K D / D 3 N U g N M WY/ @B3JH N U#9�9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TFUDF�9 h 9GF C @LQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@L< g N M WY/ @B3JH N U 9f9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF HF�9 h 9VB >�< M N @ - 9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TFUE

��. 2 � ����� � � � �� +2P2��M�N����� � ��� �� � � � � ����� �4� � � 0 ��������������� ��-

Be9?> � M W�AJ< M <IU D / D 3 N U 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B=>Be9?>c9A> .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 � N A6K M <?H 9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B=>Be9?>c9 h �� � & 3JU�<� @L<?W�@ N QI<?HBHL3JU�b�9;9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B D

Be9 h C U�/�A - HB36H09Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B EBe9 h 9A> g N U�H N AJ365Y/ D 3JU�b C Q?QI<?HBH)9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D hBe9 h 9 h & N Q?/�A >�< M N @ - C AJA N�D M <?U D 9f9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D hBe9 h 9 k d D / D 36Q C HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D 9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D FBe9 h 9GF .0/ D / + @B/�U�K�AZ/�@L3 D - 9f9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 DUBBe9 h 9VB .=< M /�U�5 � /�bc<I5�>�< M N @ - 9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 DUBBe9 h 9 D C HLH N Q?3J/ D 3 1e3 D - 9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D HBe9 h 9 H . - UY/ M 3JQ $ < F / 143 N @09Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D�Be9 h 9� deQ?/�AJ36U�b 9f9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 H�jBe9 h 9 E g N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U#/�U�5 g N M W�K D / D 3 N U g N M WY/ @B3JH N U#9�9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 H >Be9 h 9A> j�C @LQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@L< g N M WY/ @B3JH N U 9f9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 Hch

�. � 0 � � � � � 0 � � 0 2P� � � � � 6 � ��: ������������������������������������� � J

�*M*� 0 2 � � ��

� . � ��� � 0 �*M* ��� ��4� � � 0 � 0 �� +��� ��� ��������������������������������������� ; R

� . ��()�� 52L� 0 2� +� �10Q� ���%�4�� ��������������������������������������������������� ;��

� 5�% � 0 � ����=����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� ;��

1e363

$)����� " ! ! ��������� �

>c9A> ��/ - R @G/�QI3JU�b � U�< � 3 �e<?A N OV/ E � H � M /�b�< N OVR F @B<?< � , � <IQ D HI9 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 >>c9 h C �(/ - R @G/�QI<?5'� M /�b�<�9V9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h>c9 k C �(/ - R @G/�QI<?5'� M /�b�< � 3 DGF g N4N �#7 � <?Q D H?9 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k>c9GF $ N K�U�5f3JU�b � N A6K M <���3J<I@G/�@LQ F - /�U�5 + @L3J5 C Q?Q?<IAJ<I@G/ D 3 N U d D @BK�Q D K�@L<?H?9 9 9Y9Y9�9Y9 F>c9VB ( N @%� .=3JH D @L3 , K D 3 N U 3JU DGF < � M /�bc< � AJ/�U�<�9 9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 Bk 9A> C H - U�Q F @ N U N K�H=>�<IHBHB/�bc<��i/�U�5fAJ3JUfb�9 9e9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@>CBk 9 h .=3JH D @B3 , K D <I58d F /�@L<?5�>�< M N @ - C @LQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@B< 9^9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9@> k 9 k C HBH N QI3Z/ D 361�<_>�< M N @ - /�U�5 g N M W < D 3 D 3 N U O N @ g /�Q F <TdeA N�D H?9+9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h Bk 9GF g N M W�/�@B36H N U N O S�< D � N @!�8/�U�58.=< M /�U�5 � /�bc<?5 >�< M N @ - 9V9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h Dk 9VB .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@ � <I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< � 3 DBF � U�Q?@L< /�HL<?5 S N 5f< / U�5 R F @B< / 5 g N KfU D H?9Y9;9Y9 hIHF�9A> .=3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 ��/ - R @G/ Q?3JUfb � @ N bc@G/ M d D @LK�Q D K�@B< 9 9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k >F�9 h � UfO N @ M / D 3 N UXd F /�@B36U�b C M N U�b�S N 5�<IH?9 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k FF�9 k . - U�/ M 36Q=R /�H!� C HBHB36bcU M <?U D 9 9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 k F�9GF S�< D � N @%� & 3 M 3 D / D 3 N U N U8>�/ �e3 M K M )Y@G/ M < �(/ D < 9i9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF hF�9VB > > 3JAJA63 N U � � N A - b N U ) N @B<?H D � R N W � 7 5�bc< /�U�5 � U�U�<I@ �i3J< � H?9 9 9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TFIFF�9 D );@B/ M < ��/ D <01c<I@BHB< � N A - b N U g N K�U D 9#9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF BF�9 H deQ /�A63JU�b � F <?U g N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/ AJA - $ N K�U�5 9 9;9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF BF�9�deW F <I@B< ) AZ/ � <0R <IH D deQI<?U�< � 3 DBF ��/�@B5 d F / 5 N � Hi/�Uf5 H�k �+W�@B3 M 3 D 3 1c<?HI9 9�9Y9TFUDF�9 EdeW F <I@B< ) AZ/ � <_>�/�Q F 36U�< g N M WY/�@B36H N U �:<?HLK�A D H?9Y9;9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF F�9?> j ��3Jb F > < M N @ - d D @B/ D <Ibc3J<IH?9T9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B jBe9A> ( N @%��<I@id D @BKfQ D Kf@B< � 3 DGF d F /�@B<I5�.0/ D /f9_9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B hBe9 h h . 7��f/ M W�AJ< � 3 DGF h & <I1c<IA C Q?QI<?A6<?@G/ D 3 N U�d D @BKfQ D Kf@B<�9_9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�BIBBe9 k g N U�H N AJ3J5�/ D 36U�b C QIQ?<IHBH DBN d F /�@L<?5 >�< M N @ - 9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B DBe9GF.=3Z/�bcU N H D 3JQ �i3J< � d F�N � 36U�b%.0/ D / /�U�5 � M /�bc<_.=3JH D @L3 , K D 3 N U 9(9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B HBe9VB d - U DBF < D 3JQ � N A6K M <IH�� d F <?AJA � >�K�A D 3 d F <?A6AJH � � <?@LAJ36U S N 3JHL< � / U�5 ( F 3 D <4S N 3JHL<�9&D jBe9 D �(36Q F�D MT- <I@ � >�<?H F � N 18Ra3 M < d D <IW�H j � FUB � > j � hIH�j 9)9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D�>Be9 H & N Q / A >�< M N @ - C A6A N�D M <IU D /�U�5')Y@G/ M < ��/ D <�9%9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D F

Be9� .0/ D /+R @G/��%Q /�U�5 )Y@G/ M < �(/ D < 9�9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 DIEBe9 EdeQ /�A63JU�b � 3 DGF .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 � N A6K M <=.0/ D /f9 9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 H�jBe9?> j g AJK�H D <?@a1�<?@BHLK�H0d4K�W[<I@BQ N M WfK D <I@?949Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 Hch

3 �

$)����� " ! � �� $%� �

k 9A> g AJK�H D <?@ g N M W N U�<?U D H?9+9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h >k 9 h g N M WfAJ< D <4S�< D � N @%� & 3 , @B/�@ - g N M W�/�@B36H N U �:<?HLK�A D H?9^9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 hchk 9 k deK M%M /�@ - N O S�< D � N @!� & 3 , @B/�@ - g N M WY/�@B36H N U R <?H D HI929[9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h�kk 9GF g N M W�/�@B36U�b DGF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@BHI9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h Fk 9VB d F /�@L<?5 >�< M N @ - + @B/�U�K�AZ/�@L3 D - 9)9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 h F�9A> S�< D � N @%� $^/�U�5 � 365 DGF >�<?/�HBK�@L< M <?U D 9 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF jF�9 h S�< D � N @%� & / D <?UfQ - >�<?/�HBK�@L< M <?U D 9[9;9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9TF�>Be9A> � � � & 36U�< � N A6K M < � @L<?W�@ N QI<?HBHL3JU�bf9a9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9�B Be9 h g N U�H N AJ3J5�/ D <I5 C Q?QI<?HBH DGN d F / @B<?5 >�< M N @ - N U DGF < g ) . .0/ D /%de< D 9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D hBe9 k g N U�H N AJ3J5�/ D <I5 C Q?QI<?HBH DGN d F / @B<?5 >�< M N @ - N U DGF < � <?@LAJ3JU � N A6K M <�9 9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D kBe9GF & N Q / A >�< M N @ - C A6A N�D M <IU D .=< D /�3JA O N @ DGF < >�K�A D 3Zd F <?A6A � N A6K M <�9%9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D kBe9VB . - U�/ M 36Qi1c<I@BHL<)d D / D 36Q C HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D O N @ g )V. Ra3 M < d D <?WfH?9�9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 DUBBe9 D );@B/ M < ��/ D < /�U�58.0/ D / + @G/ U4KfAZ/�@L3 D - 929e9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 DIDBe9 H S�< D � N @%�X/�U�5 .=< M /�U�5 �V/�b�<?5 >�< M N @ - g N M W�/�@B36H N U 9 9f9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 DIDBe9� C HBH N QI3Z/ D 36143 D - R <IH D(N U DGF < g )V. .0/ D /f9;9�9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D HBe9 E );@B/ M < ��/ D <014H?9 C HLH N Q?3Z/ D 36143 D - /�U�5 C AJA N Q / D <?5X> < M N @ - 9(9Y9Y9f9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9Y9Y9�9Y9 D�

������� ����� �

������� " ������� � " �

��/ - R @B/�Q?36U�b 36H#/�HL3 M W�AJ< � /�Q?QIK�@G/ D < � /�Uf5 �Y<��e3 , AJ< M < DBF�N 5 O N @ Q?@B<?/ D 36U�b @L< /�A63JH D 3JQ3 M /�bc<IH?9 ) N @ <I1c<I@ - W�3 �f<IA � /0@G/ - <�� D <?U�5fH O\@ N M H N M <a143J< � W N 36U D 3JU DGN /_HBQ?<IU�<�9 7 1c<I@ - @G/ -3JH D <?H D <I5 O N @=36U D <?@LHB<IQ D 3 N U � 3 DBF <I1c<I@ - N , � <?Q D 36U DGF <)HLQ?<?Uf<�9 C W�3 �e<IAVbc< D H DGF < Q N A N @ N ODGF <:]�@BH D N , � <?Q D F 3 D ,�- DBF <:Q N @L@B<IHBW N U�5�36U�b_@G/ - 9�� F�N Ufb A63Jb F�D 36U�b M / ��<IH N WY/�`�K�<(HBK�@ OP/�Q?<IHA N4N � M N @B<=@L< /�A63JH D 3JQ 9 �:< �Y<IQ D 361c<_/ U�5 @B< O\@G/�Q D 361�< N , � <IQ D H:36U�Q?A6K�5�< DBF <0Q N A N @ Q N U D @L3 , K D 3 N UN O HL<?Q N U�5Y/�@ - @B/ - HI9iR F <THB<?Q N U�5Y/ @ - @G/ - @B< ��<?Q D H N � N @ D @G/ U�H M 3 D H DBF @ N Kfb F�DGF < N , � <IQ D �/�U�5 D / � <?H DGF < Q N A N @ N O DGF <%U�<�� DTF 3 D_N , � <?Q D 98d F /�5 N � H @B<I`�K�3J@L< N Uf< M N @B< @B/ - � � F 3JQ F<�� D <?U�5�H O\@ N M DGF <%3JU D <?@BHL<?Q D 3 N U W N 3JU D0DBN � /�@L5 DBF < AJ3Jb F�D H N K�@LQ?<�9 � O DBF < H F / 5 N � @G/ - 36H, A N Q,� <?5 � DGF <�W�3 �f<IA�36U D <?UfHB3 D - 36H @L<?5�K�QI<?5 9 ) 3JbcKf@B< >c9A> 3JA6AJK�H D @G/ D <?H ( F 3 DBD <?5H D - A6<�@G/ -D @B/�Q?36U�b � / U�5 ) 3JbcKf@B<9>c9 h H F�N � H�/%@B/ - D @G/ Q?<?583 M /�bc< 9R F < M / 3JU /�5f1 /�U D /�bc< N O[@G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b036H DGF / D 3 D W�@ N 5�KfQ?<?H /�QIQ?K�@B/ D < � @B< / AJ3JH D 36Q 3 M /�bc<IH?9

� N � <I1�<?@ � ( F 3 DLD <?5 @G/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b Wf@ N 5�K�Q?<IH=3 M W <?@LO\<IQ D 3 M /�bc<IH?9 C AJ3Z/ HB3JUfb � F /�@L5�H F /�5 N � H

9x7 Image

Object 2

Object 3

ViewPoint

Light Source

Object 1

�%������� -/.#- 9 ��/ - R @G/�QI3JU�b � U�< � 3 �e<?A N OV/�E � H � M /�b�< N O R F @B<?< � , � <?Q D HI9

�%������� -/.A3 9 C ��/ - R @G/�QI<?5'� M /�b�<�9

/�U�5 DBNeN�� W <?@ O\<?Q D�� A N4N ��3JU�b @B< ��<?Q D 361�< / U�5_@B<IO\@B/�Q D 361�< N , � <?Q D H @B<IHBK�A D O\@ N M W N 3JU D HG/ M W�A63JU�bHBW�/�Q?< � 3 DGF 36Uf]YU�3 D <IA - DGF 3JU+@B/ - HI9 g NeN ��� H�� H F�N � <?5 DGF / D /�A6A DBF / D � /�H U�<?<I5�<?5 DGN ] � DBF <?HL</�@ D 36OP/ Q D H � /�H DGN0D @B/�Q?<:HL<I1c<I@G/�A @G/ U�5 N M A - 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 @G/ - H O N @ < /�Q F W�3 �e<?A 9�) 36bcK�@L<5>c9 k 36H/0@G/ - D @B/�Q?<I5 3 M / bc< DGF / D 5�< M N U�H D @B/ D <IH g N4N � � H 5�<IW DGF%N O[]Y<?A65 / U�5 M N�D 3 N U , AJK�@ < � <?Q D HI9d D 3JAJA � ( F 3 DBD <I5 H D - AJ<%@G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�bXU�<IbcAJ<IQ D H_bcA N , /�A 3JAJA6K M 3JUY/ D 3 N U 9 R F < , /�HB36Q / AJb N @L3 DBF MQ / U�U N�D bc<IU�<?@B/ D <:Q N A N @ , AJ<I<?5�36U�b , < D � <?<?U N , � <IQ D H � N @VQ /�KfH D 36Q?H Q / K�HB<I5 ,�- O N Q?K�HL<?5%AJ36b F�D 9R F 36H DGN4N Q / U , < ]��f<I5 � HB3 M WfA -_,�- D @G/�QI3JU�b M N @L< @G/ - H?9 � U�H D < /�5 N O;K�HL3JU�b � FfN U�b0AJ36b F�D 36U�b �/�A6A4Q N A N @BHV/ @B< Q N M W�K D <I5 ,�- Q?/�H D 3JU�b=HL<?Q N U�5Y/�@ - @B/ - H O\@ N M DGF < W N 36U DVN OY36U D <?@LHB<IQ D 3 N U)3JU DBNDGF < HBQI<?U�< 9�R F <#Q N A N @ N O(/ W N 3JU D N U�/�U N , � <?Q D 3JH / O\K�UfQ D 3 N U N O DGF < N , � <IQ D � H+36U�UY/ D <Q N A N @a/ U�5 DBF <_Q N A N @ N O DGF <_A63Jb F�D @L< �Y<IQ D <I5 N U DBN 3 D 9

$ <?Q?/�K�HL< @B/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b 3JH)H D @G/ 3Jb F�D O N @ � /�@B5 � 3 D 3JH)<?/�HB36A - <�� D <IU�5�<?5 DGN /�U - 5f<?bc@L<?< N O@B<?/�AJ36H M 9 $ K D @B< / AJ3JH M F /�H /XW�@B36Q?< � / F K�bc<%U�K M+, <?@ N O^3JU D <?@BHL<?Q D 3 N U Q?/�AJQIK�AZ/ D 3 N UfH?9 CB=> h ��B > h 3 M /�bc< @B<I`�K�3J@L<?H M N @B< DGF / U /#`�KY/�@ D <?@ N O / M 36AJA63 N UX@G/ - H � <I1c<I@ - N U�< N O � F 3JQ F

��������� ������������������� �"!$#&%('*)+�",-#/.103254(68797":<;>=?#&!&25@&�

4A�"@8257CB�#D2 #$@E2 #$%F�",G�H0�IJ@K2L#NM-#$�K�<7-BPOE#$!&2�0�IQ2 4J#R@E!$#$IS#"�8TD7"2L@ UJ�EVJ� 0W@ 0�IS,-XW�"YP2 4J#$�E#Z4A�"@8B[#&#$I�\,-� #$�H2�%J#��HX]7"^_�E#$@E#��"�E!`4(0�IG2 7+�H!$!$#&X�#&�5�H2 #$%F�5���<25� �"!$0WIJ,J�

�R!&!$#$XW#$� �H250W7-Ia@K25�EUJ!&2 UJ� #&@b�E#$%JUJ!&#+2 4J#cIdUS)CB[#&�b7H^L0WIP2 #$�E@ #$!N250W7-Ie2 #$@K25@fBP�g@E7-�E2 0�IJ,h254S#7-BdOE#&!&2 @i0�Ie@ VJ�"!$#<%SUJ� 0WIJ,jVS� #$VS� 7d!$#$@E@ 0WIJ,J�<kl0W2 4 �"Im�"!$!&#$XW#$�5��250�7"Ia@K25� US!&25US� #"Yn�F� �o�e!$�"I0�,"IJ7-� #p)q7-@E2D7"^n2 4J#i7"BdOE#$!N25@D2 4A�H2R0W2�!��"ISIJ7"2DV[7-@E@ 0WBJXW�h4J032��1r8�esot"u-vSY���USBJ0�I(�"IJ%jkl4S0W2Ew25#&%yx{zSs$|.L#&� #CUS@ 0�IS,<4J0�#&�5�"�E!`4J0�!$�"X]25�E#$#$@D7"^�B�7-UJIJ%J0WIJ,+M"7-X�US)+#&@$�1'*I}�QB�7-UJIJ%S0�IJ,qM-7-XWUJ)+#4J0W#$�5�H� !`4G�-Y�<@E0�)qVJX�#b7-BdOE#$!N2f�"!&2 @p�"@p�<@ US� � 7",G�H25#b^�7-�Z�<!$7")+VJXW#N~(7-BdOE#&!&2��b��4J#\!$7")+VJXW#N~7-BdOE#&!&2D0�@1IJ7"212 #$@E2 #$%�USIJX�#&@ @1254J#f�5���h4J0325@�254J#p@EUJ� �E7-,G�H2 #"���AUJ�K254J#&� )q7-� #HYA254J#p@ US� � 7",G�H25#&@�"�E#q,"� 7-UJV�#$%e0�IG2 7j�<2 � #$#c7"^84J0W,-4J#$�pXW#&M-#&X>@ UJ�E� 7-,-�H25#&@$�q���5���}254A��2p)+0W@ @ #&@f�h4S0�,-4gX�#NM-#&X@ US� � 7",G�H25#p#&X�0�)q0�IJ�H25#&@L)+�"IG�<7-BdOE#&!&2 @�.103254h7-IJ#Z25#&@E2$�

� VA�H2 0��"X�@ UJB�%J03M90W@ 0W7-I(25#&!`4JIJ0W�dUS#$@p%J0WMd0W%J#i@EVA�"!$#c0WIJ@E2 #��"%}7"^�!&X��"@E@ 0W^��d0WIJ,Q7-BPOE#$!&2 @$�b��4J#@ 0W)+VSX�#$@K2C#�~J�H)+VJXW#<%J03M90W%J#$@i@ VA�"!&#h0�IG257}�HI���~S0W@\�"XW0�,-IJ#&% ,-�E0�%�x�sovH|��m�����d@\@E25#&V�254J7-US,-4254S#<,-� 0W% !$#&X�X�BG� !$#&X�X�Yn!$7-IS@ 0�%S#$� 0WIJ,�7-ISXW�e7-BdOE#&!&25@C2 4A�H2C�H2\X�#$�"@E2iVA�"�K250��HX�XW��79!&!$UJVG� #$�"!`4

Q?<IAJA 9 � , � <?Q D H D <?Uf5 DBN QIAJK M W DGN b�< DGF <?@X3JU�H M /�A6A=@B<Ibc3 N U�H � AJ<?/21436U�b AZ/�@Lbc<�@B<Ibc3 N U�H N OHBW�/�Q?< < M W D - 9 � U�/ @L<?bcK�AJ/�@0bc@L3J5 � DGF < N 1c<I@ O\K�A6A Q?<IAJAJH_5�<Ibc<?Uf<?@G/ D < 36U DGN / AJ36U�< / @0HB< / @BQ F/�U�5 DBF < < M W D - Q?<IAJAJH Q /�KfHB< U�<I<?5�A6<?HBH D @G/ 1c<I@BHG/ A D 3 M < /�U�5 M < M N @ - N 1c<I@ F <?/�5 9 C 5Y/�W �D 3 1c<8HBK , 5�3 1e36HB3 N U H D @LK�Q D K�@B<IH#K�HB< AZ/�@Lbc<?@ 5�3 143JHB3 N U�H)36U < M W D - HLWY/�Q?<�/�U�5 H M /�AJA6<?@ N U�<IH

� F <I@B< N , � <?Q D H�/�@L< 5f<?U�HL<?A - W�/�Q,��<I5 9 7��f/ M W�AJ<IH 3JU�QIAJK�5f< N Q D @B<I<?H � > k � � /�U�5 , 3JU�/�@ -HBW�/�Q?<%WY/�@ D 3 D 3 N Uf3JU�b � >�D � D @B<I<?H?9 ) 3Jb�K�@B<�>c9 FX3JAJA6K�H D @G/ D <?H DBF < K�HB< N O^/ , N K�U�5�36U�bX1 N A6K M <F 36<?@G/ @BQ F - /�U�5 / @L<?bcKfAZ/�@ bc@L3J5 9 R F <?HL<iH N @ D 36U�b D <IQ F U�3J`�K�<IH M / ��< DBF <�@B/ - D @G/ Q?3JUfb F 3J5�5�<IUHBKf@LOP/�QI<i@B< M N 1 /�A /�A6b N @B3 DGF M /�U�� � A N b�� � H N @ D <?5#HL< /�@LQ F W�@ N , AJ< M�� DGF <iHBQ?/�U#A63JU�< , K � <I@/�A6b N @B3 DGF M @L< M /�3JU�H:/ U�� ��� � Wf@ N , A6< M 9C QIQ?<?A6<?@B/ D 3 N U�H D @BK�Q D K�@L<?H0@L<?5�K�QI< DGF <+U�K M+, <?@ N O 3JU D <I@BHB<IQ D 3 N U�Q?/�AJQIK�AZ/ D 3 N U�H:W[<I@=@G/ - �

, K D 3 D H D 3JA6A D /���<?HT/�U�<?U N @ M N K�H U�K MT, <I@ N O @G/ - H DBN bc<IU�<?@B/ D < /�U�3 M /�bc<�9%7 1c<I@ - W�3 �e<?A@B<I`�K�3J@L<?H)/8@G/ - � / U�5 @B<?/�AJ36H D 3JQ 3 M /�bc<IH @L<?`�K�3J@L< M /�U - @G/ - H+W[<I@TW�3 �e<?A 9 ) N @ D K�UY/ D <?A - � /�AJAW�3 �f<IAJH /�@L< 36U�5�<IW[<IU�5�<?U D � � F 36Q F M / ��<IH W�/�@G/�A6AJ<IAcW�@ N Q?<IHBHL3JU�b F 3Jb F A - < �%Q?36<?U D 9 � U+/�U 3 M /�bc<WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A @B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@ � HB< 1c<I@G/�A M /�Q F 3JUf<?H HBWfAJ3 D DGF < 3 M /�bc< � /�U�5_@G/ - D @G/�QI< W�3 �e<IAJH Q N U�Q?K�@L@B<IU D A - 9) 36bcK�@B<�>c9 B H FfN � H FfN � W�@ N QI<?HLH N @LH=Q /�U 5f36143J5�< DGF < 3 M /�bc< W�AZ/ U�<+/�Uf5 � N @!�83JU�WY/ @G/�A6AJ<?A 9� U DGF 36H)3 M /�bc<#HL3 � D - � D � N M /�Q F 3JUf<?H /�5�5 K�U�36`�K�<Xbc@G/ - A6<I1c<IAJH DGN DBF <XW�3 �e<?A6H DGF / D)DBF < -@G/ - D @G/�QI<�9 � U DGF < N @ - � � M /�Q F 36U�<?HaQ?/�U8Q N M W�K D < DGF <_HG/ M <_3 M /�bc<�3JUQ>�� � DBF DGF < D 3 M <@B<I`�K�3J@L<?5 ,�- N Uf< M /�Q F 36U�<�9 � U W�@G/�Q D 36Q?< � HB36bcU�36]�Q /�U D Q F /�A6AJ<IU�bc<?H%/�@L3JHL<836U DGF <8W�K�@LHBK�3 DN O DGF 36H b N /�A 9 R F < M / Q F 3JU�<IH F / 1c< DGN Q N4N W <?@G/ D < DGN 5�3 1e365�< DGF <�3 M / bc< /�U�5 DBN W�K DDGF <?3J@ W�3 �e<?A6H , /�Q,� DGN bc< DGF <I@?9�� U D <I@G/�Q D 3 1c<0O\@G/ M <=@B/ D <IHa@B<?`�K�36@B<=<��%Q?3J<IU D KfHB< N O /)WY/�@B/�AJA6<?AM /�Q F 3JUf< � H�/ @BQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@L<�9

�%������� -/. J 9 $ N K�Uf5�3JU�b � N A6K M < ��3J<I@G/�@LQ F - /�U�5 + @L3J5 C Q?Q?<IAJ<I@G/ D 3 N U d D @BK�Q D K�@L<?H?9

�%������� -/. � 9�( N @%� .=3JH D @L3 , K D 3 N U 3JU DGF < � M /�bc< � AZ/ U�<�9

� U OP/�Q D � DGF <0Q F /�AJA6<?U�bc<i3JHabc@L< / D <IU N K�b FXDBF / D 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361c<0@B/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b+36H:/+@B<?AJ/ D 3 1c<IA -U�< � W F <IU N M <?U N U 9 � � �(/ - � h D � hIH � � /�H N U�< N O DBF <:]Y@BH D 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361�<�@B/ - D @G/ Q?<?@LH?9�� D K�HL<?HWY/�@B/�AJA6<?A63JH M /�Uf5+/�QIQ?<?A6<?@B/ D 3 N U_H D @LK�Q D K�@B<IH DBN / DBD / 3JU_3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1e3 D - 9 R F < W�@ N b�@G/ M 3JH D K�Uf<?5DGN(D / � <a/�5f1 /�U D /�bc< N O F 3Jb F W <?@LO N @ M /�U�Q?< � H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A�HLK�W[<I@BQ N M WfK D <I@BHVA63���<de36AJ3JQ N U + @B/�W F 36Q?H � � d + � � � @B36bc3JU � k�h�� 9 ) N @ <��f/ M WfAJ< � /�QIQ?<?A6<?@B/ D 3 N U�H D @BKfQ D Kf@B<?HT<��f/�Q D A -/�A63JbcU N U Q /�Q F <TAJ3JUf< / U�5 M < M N @ - W�/�bc< , N KfU�5Y/�@L3J<?HI9 C AJH N � DGF < W�@ N bc@G/ M H - U�Q F @ N U�3�I<?H

� 3 DBF / OP/�H D � M /�Q F 36U�< AJ< 1c<?A , /�@B@L3J<?@I9 � � �(/ - 3JHX/�U&3 M /�bc<�WY/�@G/ AJAJ<IA=@B<IU�5�<I@B<?@ � � F <?@L<DGF <�3JU�5f<?W <?U�5�<IU D @G/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b�<IU�bc3JUf<?H /�@L< DBF @B<?/�5�H#@LK�U�U�36U�b N UHL<?WY/ @G/ D < g � S�HI9 CHBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ DGF @L< /�5 , @B<?/ ��H DGF <_3 M /�bc<i3JU DGN+D 3JAJ<IH � / U�5 DGF < � N @!� <?@ DGF @L< /�5�H:@L< D @L3J< 1c< D 36AJ<?H

� F <IU�<I1�<?@ DGF < - /�@L<=3J5�A6<�9 R F <0HBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D <?@ � H:H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - b�361c<IHa/�A6A DBF @B<?/�5�H^OP/�H D/�QIQ?<?HLH DBN_DBF <:HG/ M < M < M N @ - HLWY/�QI< � H N Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U , < D � <I<?U DBF @B<?/�5�H 3JH /�K DBN M / D 36Q�9

� � �(/ - 3JH /0bc<IU�<?@B/�AYW�K�@LW N HB<(@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@ � Q / WY/ , A6< N O @L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b /�U - D - W < N O N , � <?Q D � 3JU �Q?A6K�5�36U�b=1 N A6K M <?H 5�< ]YU�<?5 ,�- /�@L@G/ - H N O HLQ /�AJ/�@ 1 /�A6K�<?HI9 d N M <:/�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U�H DGF / D bc<?U�<I@G/ D <

DGF 3JH D - W < N O 5Y/ D / 3JU�QIAJK�5f< Q N M W�K D <I@B3�?<?5 DGN M N bc@B/�W F - � g R � /�U�5 M /�bcUf< D 36Q @L<?H N UY/�U�QI<3 M /�bc36U�b � > � � �_M <I5�3JQ?/�A HLQ /�UfH � / U�5�Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A �YK�365 5 - UY/ M 3JQ?H � g )V. � HL3 M KfAZ/ �D 3 N U�HI9 � � �(/ -)M / ��<IH 3 D W N HLHB3 , AJ< DGN 3JU D <?@G/ Q D 3 1c<IA - @B<IU�5�<I@ AJ/�@Bbc<a1 N AJK M < D @B36Qa5Y/ D / HB< D H � hIH��/ D O\K�A6AV@B<IH N A6K D 3 N U 9 � U M <?5�36Q /�AV/�W�W�A63JQ / D 3 N U�H � /�QIQ?K�@B/�Q - / U�5�@L<?H N AJK D 3 N U�/�@L<%<IHBW <?QI3Z/�A6A -3 M W N @ D /�U D 9 R F < D � N @B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb M N 5�<?H Q N UfHB3J5f<?@B<I5 F <?@L<_/�@B<=36H N HLK�@LOP/ Q?<0/�Uf5 M / �e3 M K M3JU D <?U�HL3 D - W�@ N � <?Q D 3 N UfH � >�� � � 9 C U�3JH N HBK�@ OP/�Q?<#@L<?U�5f<?@B36U�b�36H+/�5�@B/ � 3JU�b N O DGF < A N Q?K�H N OW N 3JU D H � 3 DGF 36U DGF <+1 N AJK M < DBF / D H F /�@B<%/ WY/�@ D 36Q?K�AJ/�@�1 /�A6K�<�9 C >�� � 3JH_/ W�@ N � <?Q D 3 N U N ODGF < M / �f3 M K M 1 /�AJKf<?H � 3 DGF 36U DGF < 1 N A6K M < 90R F <%d + � � @L3Jbc36U�36Hi<�� D @B< M <?A - � <?A6A HBKf3 D <I5DGN AJ/�@Bbc< 1 N A6K M < 1e36HBKY/ AJ3�?/ D 3 N U , <?Q?/�K�HL< 3 D HiOP/�H D 3JU D <I@BQ N U�U�<IQ D 3 N U U�< D � N @%� bc361�<?H0<I1�<?@ -D F � , 3 D W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @�/ Q?Q?<IHBH DGN / F Kfbc< M < M N @ - HLWY/�Q?< 9R F < D @L<?U�5 36U F 3Jb F W[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?<^Q N M WfK D 36U�b=3JH M N 143JU�b=/ � / - O\@ N M AJ/�@Bb�< M N U N A63 DGF 3JQ

HBKfW[<I@BQ N M W�K D <?@LH#/�Uf5 DGN � /�@B5 bc@ N KfW�H N @ QIAJK�H D <?@LH N O0A N � <?@%Q N H D � g Q?AJ/�HBH M /�Q F 3JUf<?H?9R F <0W�@L3 M /�@ - M N�D 361 / D 3 N U , < F 3JU�5 DBF 3JH D @B<IU�5 3JH W�@B36Q?<=/ U�5 DGF <0@L<?AJ/ D <I5#Q N UfHB3J5f<?@G/ D 3 N U N O/ 1 /�3JAJ/ , 3JA63 D - 9 R @B< M <?Uf5 N K�H Q N M W[< D 3 D 3 N U03JU DGF <�� g M / @!��< D F /�H 5�@B3 1c<?U 1c<IU�5 N @LH DGN Q?@L< / D <@B<IAJ3J/ , AJ< � W N � <I@LO\K�A /�Uf5�/ � N @L5Y/ , A6< M / Q F 3JU�<IH?9 R F < W�@ N QI<?HBH N @BH � 3 DBF 3JU DBN 5�/ - � H � g H�/�@L<U�<?/�@BA - /�H W N � <I@LO\K�A /�H DBF�N HB<:K�HL<?5%3JU HBKfW[<I@BQ N M W�K D <?@LH?9�(�3 DGF W N � <?@ O\K�A;/ � N @B5�/ , AJ< � g H �@B<IHB<?/�@BQ F <I@BHi/�@B< D K�@BU�36U�b DGN Q?A6K�H D <?@LH N O � g H DGN H N A 1c<_Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/ AJA - 36U D <?UfHB361�<_W�@ N , �AJ< M H HLK�Q F / H DBF < M N 5�<?A63JU�b N O DBF < < /�@ DGF � H M /�U D AJ< N @ DGF < H D K�5 - N O DBF < Q N M W�AJ<��0Q F < M 36Q /�A@B<?/�Q D 3 N UfH 36U0]Y@B<IH?9 C A DBF�N K�b F QIAJK�H D <?@LH /�@B< <�� D @G/ N @L5�3JU�/�@B36A - � <IAJA�HBKf3 D <I5 DBN Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A3JU D <?U�HL361c<TW�@ N , AJ< M H DBF / D 5 N U N�D @B<?`�K�36@B<TO\@L<?`�K�<IU D Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U / M N U�b#Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB36U�b<?A6< M <?U D H � 3 D 3JH=A6<?HBH0QIAJ<?/�@ DGF / D=DGF < - / @B<)HBKf3 D / , AJ< O N @=W�@ N , AJ< M H DGF / D @B<?`�K�36@B<)Q N U�H D /�U DQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ D 3 N U 9aR F 36H=3JH , <IQ /�KfHB< DBF <+U�< D � N @%� 36UfO\@G/ H D @LK�Q D K�@B< DGF / D AJ36U ��H � g � H=3JU DGN /Q?A6K�H D <?@:H D 3JA6A AZ/ bcH DGF <_5�<I5�3JQ?/ D <I5 F /�@B5 � /�@L< � 3 DGF 36UXHBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D <?@BHI9> - DGF <?HB36H 3JH DGF / D Q?A6K�H D <?@ � , /�HL<?5 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361�<8@B/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b N O M K�A D 3 ��+ 36b�/ ,�- D < 1 N A �

K M < D @B3JQ 5�/ D /�HL< D H � � F 36Q F /�@L< AZ/�@Lbc<?@ DBF /�U DGF < M < M N @ - HBWY/�QI< N O+/�U - N Uf<�U N 5�< 36UDGF <%QIAJK�H D <I@ � 3JH0W N HLHB3 , AJ<�9 (�< F / 1�<%5f<I1c<IA N W <?5 / Q?A6K�H D <?@ � , /�HL<?5�3JU D <I@G/�Q D 361�<)@G/ - D @G/�QI<?@ �5�<I@B361�<?5 O\@ N M � � ��/ - � DGF / D 5f< M N U�H D @G/ D <?H DBF <a1c<?@L3 D - N O DGF < DBF <?HL3JH?9�& 3���<a3 D HVW�@L<?5�<IQ?<IHBH N @ �DGF < U�< � W�@ N b�@G/ M 36H 5�<IHB36bcU�<?5 DGN <��%Q?3J<IU D A - K�HL< DBF < Q?/�WY/ , 36AJ3 D 3J<IH N O DBF < M /�Q F 36U�< N U

� F 36Q F 3 D @BK�UfH?9 R F < 5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5 @B/ - D @B/�Q?<I@ 3JH / , A6< N 1c<?@LQ N M < DGF < HLA N � <I@ 3JU D <I@BQ N U�U�<?Q D 3 N U

, < D � <?<?U W�@ N QI<?HLHB3JUfb <?A6< M <?U D H � /�Uf5�<I1�<?U DGN K�HB< DGF < U�< D � N @%� DGN HBK�@LWY/�HLH DGF < M < M N @ -AJ3 M 3 D N O DBF <_W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @BH DGF / D 3 D @BK�UfH N U 9g F /�W D <?@ h HBK M M /�@B3�?<IH+@B<IAZ/ D <?5 � N @!� 3JU�Q?A6K�H D <?@)Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ D 3 N U D <?Q F U N A N b - � 3JU �

D <I@G/�Q D 3 1c<%@G/ - D @G/ Q?3JUfb � / U�5 143JHLKY/�A63� / D 3 N U N OaAZ/ @Bbc< 5Y/ D /�HB< D HI9 g F /�W D <?@ k <��eW�AJ/�3JU�H DGF <U�< D � N @%��3JU�b AJ3 , @G/�@ - DGF / D Q N U�U�<IQ D H 5f3JH D 3JU�Q D <��e<IQ?K D / , AJ<IH � @BK�UfU�3JU�b N U%HL<?WY/ @G/ D <(Q N M W�K D%�<?@LH � 3JU DGN / Q NcF <IHB361�<TW�@ N bc@B/ M 9 R F <TA63 , @B/�@ - � Q /�A6AJ<I5'& <Ibc3 N U � / 5�5�H�/ M 3JU�3 M K M / M N KfU DN O N 1c<I@ F <?/�5 DBN_DBF <aH N Q,��< D AZ/ - <I@ � W�@ N 143J5f<?H DGF @L< /�5 HB/ O\< D @B/�U�HBW N @ D � /�A6A N � H /�H - UfQ F @ N U N K�HF /�Uf5�AJ36U�b N O 3JU , N K�U�5 M <?HLHG/�b�<?H � / U�5 3JU�QIAJK�5f<?H_/#5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - OP/�Q?36AJ3 D - 9g F /�W D <?@ Fi5�3JHLQ?K�HLHB<?H F�N � DGF <a5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5+36U D <?@B/�Q D 361c< @G/ - D @G/�QI<?@ � N @%�4H � F <?U DGF < HBQ?<IU�<5Y/ D / , /�HL< 3JH_H M /�AJA <?U N K�b F DBN , < Q N W�3J<I5 36U DBN < /�Q F U N 5f< � H M < M N @ - 9 (�< /�UY/ A - ?< DGF <W <?@LO N @ M /�U�Q?< N O DBF <�@B<IU�5�<I@B<?@#/�U�5Q N M W�/�@B< DGF < W�@ N b�@G/ M � H W[<I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< � 3 DBF DGF / DN O � � �(/ - 9 g F /�W D <?@�B�<��eW�AJ/�3JU�H FfN � DGF <8Wf@ N bc@B/ M K�HB<IH & <?b�3 N U � H)5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5�H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - DGN @B<IU�5�<?@ AZ/ @Bbc<V1 N AJK M <?HI9-( < /�UY/�A - ?< DGF < OP/�Q DGN @LH DGF / D 36U �YK�<IU�Q?< DGF < <�� D <?Uf5�<?5W�@ N bc@G/ M � H:3JU D <I@G/�Q D 36143 D - /�U�5�/�b�/�36U Q N M W�/�@B< DGF < W�@ N bc@G/ M � 3 DBF � � ��/ - 9 � U g F /�W D <?@ D

� <^HBK M%M /�@B3�?< DGF <^@L<?HLK�A D H N O N Kf@ 3JU�1�<?H D 3Jb�/ D 3 N U�HV/�Uf5+5�3JHLQ?K�HLHVW N HBHL3 , A6< O\K D K�@B< @B<?HL< /�@LQ F 9

������� ����� �

��� $ � ��� � � " ���

& 3 , @B/�@B36<?HaAJ3���< ���0> � > h � /�U�5 >�� � � >CB � / , H D @B/�Q D:DBF <_5�< D /�3JA6H N O Uf< D � N @!�XW�@ N bc@G/ M �M 3JU�b�9 R F <?HL< A63 , @B/�@B36<?H_/�5�5�OP/�Q?36AJ3 D 3J<IH=AJ3���< A N bc3JQ?/�AVHBK , bc@ N K�W�H � F < D <?@ N bc<?U�<I3 D - HLK�W�W N @ D �5�< , K�bcbc36U�b(HBK�W�W N @ D � /�5f5�3 D 3 N UY/ Ac@B<IAJ3Z/ , 3JA63 D - � 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 W�@ N Q?<IHBH Q N U D @ N A � F 3Jb F AJ< 1c<IA4H - U �Q F @ N U�3�?/ D 3 N U N W[<I@G/ D 3 N UfH /�Uf5#H N N U � DGN DBF <iKfU�5�<?@LA - 3JUfbTH N Q,��< D AZ/ - <?@?9����=> � / H N U�< N ODGF <�]Y@LH D U�< D � N @!�#/ , H D @G/�Q D 3 N U AJ3 , @G/ @B3J<IH O N @ QIAJK�H D <?@ Q N M W�K D 3JU�bf9 de36bcU�36]�Q /�U D O\<?/ D Kf@B<?H N O���0> /�@L<0HBK�W�W N @ D O N @ F < D <I@ N bc<IU�<?3 D - /�U�5 Q N U�H N AJ<05�@L361�<?UX5�3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 W�@ N QI<?HLH(Q N U D @ N A 9C O\@B<I<_1�<?@LHB3 N U N O ���0> 3JH:/ 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6< N U�A63JU�<�� h F � 9

� U >�EIE F / 5�@B3 1c< DBN H D /�U�5�/�@B5�3�?< DGF < OP/�Q?36AJ3 D 3J<IH W�@ N 143J5f<?5 36U�A63 , @B/�@B36<?HXAJ3���< ���0>@B<IHBK�A D <I5�3JU�>�� � � DBF <%H D / U�5Y/�@L5�3JU D <?@LOP/ Q?< O N @ M <?HLHG/�b�< WY/ HBHB36U�b�A63 , @B/�@B36<?HI9 C H / H D /�U �5Y/�@L5 � >�� �_bc361�<?H+W�/�@G/�A6AJ<IA Wf@ N bc@B/ M H DGF <#3 M W N @ D / U D O\< / D K�@L< N O M /�Q F 3JUf<#/�U�5 1�<?U�5 N @3JUf5�<?W <?U�5f<?U�QI<�9 C W�@ N b�@G/ M � @B3 DBD <IU N U8/+Q?AJKfH D <I@ N O-� g H(KfHB3JUfb >'��� H F�N K�AJ5X/�A6H N � N @!�

� F <IU 3 D 3JH)Q N M W�36AJ<I5 /�U�5 @BK�U N U / HBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D <?@ DGF / D HBK�W�W N @ D H%>�� � � @B<?bc/�@B5�A6<?HLHN O DGF < U�< D � N @!� 3JUfO\@B/�H D @BK�Q D K�@L<�9 >�� � g � � > F � 3JH+/�O\@B<?< 3 M W�AJ< M <IU D / D 3 N U N O DGF <X>�� �H D /�U�5Y/ @B5 9 & C > � >�� � � B � 3JH / M N @B< F 3Jb F A - D K�U�<I5�3 M W�A6< M <?U D / D 3 N U N O DBF < H D /�Uf5Y/�@B5 9>�� � g � /�U�5'& C > � >'��� /�@B< /�A6H N / 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6< N U�A63JU�<�� h � > � 9

� U�/ Q?A6K�H D <?@ � DBF <0OP/�Q?36AJ3 D 3J<IH DGF / D � �=> /�Uf5�>�� �a/ 5�5 DBN H N Q,� < D HiQ / U 36U�Q?@L< /�HL< @LK�UD 3 M < N 1�<?@ F < /�5 9 ( F <IU�/ W�@ N bc@B/ M N UfA - Uf<?<?5fH OP/�H D0D @B/�U�HLO\<I@ , < D � <I<?U M /�Q F 36U�<?H � 3 D 36HH N M < D 3 M <?H , < DLD <?@ DGN O N @Bb N DGF <+/�5�5f3 D 3 N UY/�A[O\< / D K�@B<IH=/�U�5�K�HB< H N Q,��< D H=5�36@B<?Q D A - 9aR F 36H�36H<?HLW[<IQ?3J/�AJA - D @LK�< � F <?U K�HB36U�b�5f<?5�36Q / D <?5TQIAJK�H D <I@BH � O N @ � F 3JQ F F < D <?@ N bc<?Uf<?3 D - / U�5T@L<?AJ3J/ , 36AJ3 D -/�@L<�U N D N O bc@B<?/ D Q N U�QI<?@LU 9�(�3 DBF DGF 3JH 3JU M 36U�5 � & <?bc3 N U � /�H 5�<?HL3JbcUf<?5 DBN /�5f5#/ M 3JUf3 M /�A/ , H D @B/�Q D 3 N UXAZ/ - <?@ N U DGN W N O H N Q,��< D H?9C QI@B3 D 3JQI3JH M N O DGF < M <?HBHB/�bc<�W�/�HBHL3JU�b <?U�143J@ N U M <IU D 3JH DGF / D DBF <�W�@ N bc@B/ M M <?@ F / H

DGN4N M K�Q F @B<IHBW N U�HB3 , 3JA63 D - O N @ DGF < H F /�@B36U�b N O+5�/ D / / M N U�b WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A�W�@ N Q?<IHBHB<IH?9 R F <W�@ N bc@G/ M M <?@ M K�H D <��fWfAJ3JQI3 D A - Q N U D @ N AV< 1c<?@ - <��eQ F /�Ufbc< N O 5Y/ D /f9 � U / H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ -

<?U�143J@ N U M <?U D � DGF < HG/ M < 5Y/ D /�HLWY/�Q?< 3JH /�Q?QI<?HBHL3 , A6< < 1c<?@ - � F <?@L< � /�U�5 DBF <#W�@ N bc@G/ M M <?@U�<I<?5�H N U�A - <?UfHBK�@L< W�@ N W <?@:H - U�Q F @ N U�3� / D 3 N U 9d N O D � /�@B< 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5TH F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - � df._df> � F /�H , <I<?U)/ U+/�Q D 361�<^/�@L< / N OY@B<IHB<?/�@BQ F

HB36U�Q?< DGF <�AZ/ D < U�3JUf< D <I<?U�<?3Jb F�D 3J<IH?9 R F <�]Y@BH D df._de> � /�H'� ��� � > � � / HL<?`�K�<IU D 3Z/�A6A -Q N U�HB36H D <IU D WY/ bc< � , /�HB<I5 5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5 H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - 9 � D K�HL<?5 DBF < N W[<I@G/ D 3JU�b H - H D < MDGN�D @G/�W�/�Q?QI<?HLHB<?H DGN WY/�bc<IH N OTH F /�@L<?5�5�/ D / � /�U�5 N U�< /�Q F /�Q?QI<?HLH�<?UfHBK�@L<?5 DBF / DXDGF <5Y/ D / � /�HXQ N U�HB36H D <?U D <I1c<I@ - � F <I@B<�9 R F < M / � N @ Q?@L3 D 36Q?36H M H N O � ��� � /�H DGF / D 3 D � /�H3JUf< �%Q?36<?U D � @L<?`�K�36@B3JUfb DGN4N O\@L<?`�K�<?U D Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ D 3 N U � /�U�5 DBF / D 3 D � /�H0HLK , � <IQ D0DGN OP/�AJHL<H F /�@B36U�b:W�@ N , AJ< M H � Q?/�K�HB<I5 � F <IUTK�Uf@B<?AJ/ D <I5 5�/ D /a3 D < M H F /�W�W <?U DGN H F /�@B< DGF < HB/ M < W�/�bc<�9S�K M <I@ N K�H0H - H D < M H F / 1�<+O N AJA N � <?5 DBF / D / DBD < M W D=DGN 3 M W�@ N 1c<+W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI<�9��cK�5�bc<)< D/�A 9 F / 1�< � @B3 DBD <IU+/�UT<��eQ?<IAJAJ<IU D HBKf@L1c< - � kck �4DGF / D HLK�Q?QI3JU�Q D A - <��eW�AZ/�36U�H DGF < 3JHBHLK�<?H 3JU)de._df>5�<IHB3Jb�U�/�Uf58Wf@ N 143J5�<IH�@L<?W�@L<?HB<IU D / D 361c< <��f/ M W�A6<0H - H D < M H?9C M / � N @a5f3J@B<IQ D 3 N U D /���<?U ,�- @B<?HL< /�@LQ F <?@LH DGN 3 M W�@ N 1�<_W[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?< � / H DBN � < / � <?U

DGF <+Q N UfHB3JH D <IU�Q - M N 5�<?A 9� U / � < / ��A - Q N UfHB3JH D <IU D M < M N @ - � DBF < M < M N @ - 36H N U�A - b�KY/�@ �/�U D <I<?5 DGN , < Q N U�HB36H D <?U D 3JU @L<?AJ/ D 3 N U DBN H - U�Q F @ N U�3� / D 3 N U N W <?@B/ D 3 N U�H � /�U�5�36U�bc<?U�<I@G/�AW�@ N QI<?HBHL3JU�b)Q?/�U Q N U D 3JU�K�< � F 3JAJ<�Q N UfHB3JH D <IU�Q - M /�36U D <?U�/�U�Q?<i3JH D / ��3JU�bTW�AZ/�QI<i36U DGF < , /�Q,� �bc@ N K�U�5 9 R F < > 3J5 � / - � F � de._df> K�HB<IH / �436U�5 N O � < / ��Q N UfHB3JH D <IU�Q - Q?/�AJA6<?5 <IU D @ -Q N U�HB36H D <IU�Q - 9 � U�/�U�<IU D @ - Q N U�HB36H D <IU D M < M N @ - <?/�Q F H F /�@B<I5 N , � <IQ D 3JH M /�5f< Q N U�HB36H D <?U D

� 3 DBF /�Q?`�K�36@B< /�U�5 @L<?AJ<?/�HB< N W[<I@G/ D 3 N U�HI9 ( F <IU N U�<)H F / @B<?5 N , � <IQ D 3JH M /�5f<)Q N U�HL3JH D <?U D �/�A6A N�DBF <?@LHi/�@L<0K�UY/ � <?Q D <I5 9C M N @B<8@B<IQ?<?U D Q N U�Q?<IW D 3JUdf._df> 5�<IHB36bcU F /�H , <I<?U�3JU�1�<?H D 3Jb�/ D 3 N U N O0<�� D <?U�HL3 , A6<

H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ -�M N 5�<?A6H?9 C AJ3 , @G/�@ - Q?/�AJA6<?5 g �0> � > H � <��e< M W�AJ3 ]Y<?H DBF 3JH)5�<IHB36bcU 9 C U<�� D <?U�HL3 , A6<#H F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - / AJA N � H_1 /�@B3J/ D 3 N U 36U DBF <#H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ -�M N 5�<?A � H N�DGF / DDGF <�/�W�W�A63JQ?/ D 3 N U�5f<?HB36bcU�<I@�Q /�U D K�U�< DBF < M N 5�<IA DBN , <?H D M / D Q F DGF <�AJ3 , @G/�@ - DGNDGF </�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U DBF / D K�HB<IHT3 D 9 � U g �=> � / , /�HB<%Q?AJ/�HBH_3 M W�A6< M <?U D H_/ @LK�5�3 M <?U D /�@ - H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - /�U�5&HB<?W�/�@G/ D < 5�<?@L361c<I5�QIAZ/�HLHB<?H8<�� D <?U�5 DGF < , /�HL< 36U�5�3 � <?@L<?U D � / - H?9 g �0>W�@ N 14365�<?H D � N AJ/ - @L<?A6< /�HL<0Q N U�HL3JH D <?U D M N 5�<IAJHa/�Uf5 N Uf< HL<?`�K�<IU D 3Z/�A6A - Q N U�HL3JH D <?U D M N 5�<IA 9& <?bc3 N U � H 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ -), N @B@ N � H DGF <iQ N U�Q?<IW DaN O M /�UY/ bc3JU�b 5Y/ D / N , � <?Q D H3JUf5�36143J5fKY/�AJA - O\@ N M >�3J5 � / - /�U�5 DGF < 365�< / N O /�U N W <?U M < M N @ -#M N 5�<?A O\@ N M g �=>�9

���

� U�b N (�/�AJ5�< D /�A 9 � k B � k D � k F � / D+DGF <XS(U�361�<?@LHB3 D - N Oidf/c/ @ , @��KfQ,��<?U F / 1�<85 N U�<#3 M �W N @ D /�U D @B<IQ?<IU D � N @%� N U�3JU D <?@G/ Q D 3 1c< @G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b � 3 DBF W <?@BH N UY/�A Q N M W�K D <?@ Q?AJ/�HBH M / �Q F 36U�<?HI9 R F < - 5�< M N U�H D @B/ D <I5 DBF < A N � Q N M W�A6<��e3 D - N O @G/ - D @G/ Q?3JUfb ,�- H FfN � 36U�b DGF / DO N @)1c<I@ - AZ/ @Bbc< HLQ?<?Uf<�5Y/ D / , /�HL<?H @G/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b N U / HB36U�bcA6< � g Q?/�U <��eQ?<?<I5 DGF <8O\@B/ M <@G/ D < N O� , K � <I@=@B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b N U F 36b F <IU�5 5�<?5f3JQ / D <?5�bc@G/�W F 3JQIHiW�@ N QI<?HBH N @BHI9=R N M / �f3 M 3�?<W <?@LO N @ M /�U�Q?< � DGF < - @L<?H D @B36Q D#DBF <?36@ @B<IU�5�<I@B<?@ DBN HBKf@LOP/�QI<?H Q N M W N HB<I5 N O D @L3Z/�UfbcAJ<IH 36U�/, 36UY/�@ - HBWY/�QI< WY/�@ D 3 D 3 N U�36U�b /�QIQ?<IAJ<?@B/ D 3 N U H D @BK�Q D K�@L<�9 R F 3JH_AJ<?/21�<?H bc<?Uf<?@G/ AJ3 D -�, < F 3JUf5 36UOP/ 1 N @ N O O\K�AJA - N W D 3 M 3�?36U�b_K , 3J`�K�3 DGN KfH D @L3Z/�U�b�AJ< � , /�HL<?5 M N 5�<?A6H?9VR F < - N UfA - /�AJA N � , 3JU�/�@ -HBW�/�Q?<#W�/�@ D 3 D 3 N U�36U�b D @B<I<?H)/ U�5 D @L3Z/�UfbcAJ<%3JU D <I@BHL<?Q D 3 N UfHT3JU N @B5f<?@ DBN�D @B/�Q?< M K�A D 3JWfAJ< @G/ - H3JU WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A � 3 DBF 1�<?Q DBN @^WY/ @G/�A6AJ<?AY36U�H D @BK�Q D 3 N U�H?9 R F 3JH <��eW�A N 3 D H WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A63JH M /�U�5#3 M Wf@ N 1c<IHM < M N @ - Q NcF <I@B<IU�Q?< 9 .0/ D /)U�<?<I5�<?58O N @ N U�<_W�3 �f<IA 3JHaA63���<IA - DGN , <_U�<I<?5�<I5 O N @ DBF <_W�3 �e<IA � HU�<?/�@B<IH D Uf<?3Jb F , N @LH?9 ) N @ F 3Jb F A - Q N M WfAJ<���HLQ?<IU�<?H � DGF < - @L<?U�5f<?@ N U / QIAJK�H D <I@?9 � U DBF <?36@@B<IU�5�<I@B<?@ � / AJ/�@Bb�< QI<?U D @B/�A HL<?@L1�<?@ FfN AJ5�H DGF < <?U D 36@B< 5Y/ D / , /�HB< 9 �:<?U�5f<?@iQIAJ36<?U D H�@B<?WfAJ3JQ?/ D <DGF < DGN W�A6<I1�<?AJH N O / $ 36UY/�@ - deWY/ Q?< � /�@ D 3 D 3 N U�36U�b � $ad�� � D @B<?< / U�5O\< D Q FDGF < , N�DLDGN MAJ< 1c<IAJH N U�5�< M /�U�5 O\@ N M DGF <#HL<?@ 1c<?@I9 R F <#Q?A63J<?U D H M / 3JU D /�36U�/ H M /�AJA Q / Q F < DGN @L<?5�K�QI<DGF <iU�K M+, <?@ N O U�< D � N @%� D @G/�U�H O\<?@LH?9 R N+F 3J5f<i5Y/ D / D @G/�U�H O\<?@ 5�<?AJ/ - � H D /�A6AJ<?5%@G/ - H^b N 3JU DGN /

� /�3 D `�K�<IK�< � /�Uf5%@L< /�5 - @G/ - H Q N U D 3JU�K�<�9 R F <:W�@ N b�@G/ M 5�<?HLQ?@L3 , <?5 3JU DBF 3JH DBF <?HL3JH 5�3 � <I@BH 36UDGF / D 3 D @B< M /�36U�H^/+b�<?U�<I@G/�A � W�K�@LW N HB<=@L<?U�5�<I@B<I@ � <I1�<?UX36O 3 D 36H^U N�D / H F 3Jb F A - N W D 3 M 3�I<?5 O N @D @L3Z/�UfbcK�AZ/ @�5Y/ D /f9 � D Q?/�U @G/ - D @G/ Q?<+HLQ?<?Uf<?H DGF / D Q N U D /�3JU�3 M WfAJ3JQI3 D:N @iW N A - b N UY/�A H F /�W[<IH/�H � <?AJA / H^1 N A6K M < D @L3JQ05Y/ D / � /�Uf5 Q?/�UXK�HB< HB< 1c<?@B/�A /�Q?QI<?A6<?@G/ D 3 N U8H D @LK�Q D K�@B<IH?9S�HL3JU�b W�@ N bc@G/ M%M / , AJ< bc@G/�W F 3JQIH F /�@B5 � /�@L<(O N @ @B/ - D @G/ Q?3JUfb 36H / @L<?Q?<IU D 5�< 1c<IA N W M <?U D 9

�(/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b N U�Q?K�H DGN M F /�@B5 � /�@L< F /�H , <I<?UE3JU�1�<?H D 3Jb�/ D <?5 , <IO N @B< , K D @G/ - D @G/ Q?3JUfbHBW <?QI36]YQ F /�@L5 � / @B< F /�HiUf<I1c<I@�O N KfU�5 � 365�<T/ Q?Q?<IW D / U�Q?< 9(R N 5Y/ - � bc@G/ W F 3JQIH�Q N�� Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB36U�bQ / @B5�H^A63�� < DGFfN HB<iO\@ N M S � � .� C � h k � � C R � � k � /�U�5 N DGF <I@BHa/�@L< � 365�<?A - / 1 /�36AZ/ , A6<(/�U�5X/�@L<, <?Q N M 36U�bT1c<I@ - W N � <I@LO\K�A 9 Ra3 M � Kf@BQ?<IAJA < D /�A 9 � 5�< M N U�H D @G/ D <?5 DBF / D 3 D 3JH O\<?/�HB3 , AJ< DGN @G/ -D @B/�Q?< � 3 DGF_N � DBF < H F <IA6OeW�@ N b�@G/ M%M / , AJ< bc@G/�W F 3JQIH F /�@B5 � /�@L< � kcj � 9 R F < - 3 M W�A6< M <?U D /:@G/ -D @B/�Q?<I@i36U DGF < O\@B/�b M <?U D Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB36U�b#H D /�bc< N O / + � S HL3 M K�AJ/ DGN @ DGF / D < M K�AZ/ D <?H�AJ< / 5�3JU�b<?5fbc<Xbc@G/�W F 3JQIH+Q /�@L5 O\KfU�Q D 3 N UY/ AJ3 D - 9 R F <8/�AJb N @B3 DBF M <?U�Q N 5f<?H D @B3J/�U�bcA6<?HT/�U�5 / @B<?b�K�AZ/�@bc@L3J5 /�Q?QI<?AJ<I@G/ D 3 N U H D @BKfQ D Kf@B<i36U DGN_D <�� D K�@B< M < M N @ - 9 C O\@B/�b M <?U D W�@ N b�@G/ M D @G/ 1c<I@BHB<IH DGF <bc@L3J5 � /�Uf5 Q N M WfK D <IH @B/ - D @B3J/�U�bcA6<^3JU D <I@BHL<?Q D 3 N UfH?9 R F < - Q N M WY/�@L<�/ M K�A D 36WY/�HBH / AJb N @L3 DBF M

� �

DGN /�HB36U�bcAJ<8WY/�HLH , @B/�U�Q F 36U�b /�AJb N @B3 DGF M DBF / D @B<?`�K�36@B<IH / M N @B<8HB36bcU�36]�Q /�U D Q F /�U�bc< DBNbc@B/�W F 36Q?H Q / @B5 /�@BQ F 3 D <IQ D Kf@B<�9�& 3���< DGF <ide/c/�@ , @��K�Q,��<IU @L<?U�5�<I@B<I@ � DGF 36H H - H D < M HB36bcU�3 ]YQ /�U D A -/�QIQ?<?A6<?@B/ D <IH DBF <_@G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b W�@ N QI<?HBH � , K D AZ/�Q,��H:bc<IU�<?@B/�AJ3 D - 9

� K�@ /�W�Wf@ N /�Q F�DBN AZ/�@Lbc<81 N AJK M <�1436HBKY/�A63�?/ D 3 N U 36H#HB3 M 36AZ/�@ DBN�DGF < � N @%� N O g N @L@B36</�U�5 >�/�Q,��<I@B@B/�H � � 9XR F < - 3 M WfAJ< M <?U D <?5 1 N A6K M <%@B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb N U /�);K � 3 D HLK C � > jcjcj � /5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 M < M N @ - � M <?HLHG/�b�<+WY/�HLHB3JUfb WY/�@G/ AJAJ<IA Q N M W�K D <?@?9_R F < - 5�< M N UfH D @B/ D <I5 DGF / DQ / Q F 3JU�b M / � <?H O\<?/�HB3 , AJ< DGF < 1 N AJK M < @L<?U�5f<?@B36U�b N O_5�/ D /�HL< D H DGF / D /�@L< DBNeN AJ/�@Bb�<XO N @DGF < M < M N @ - N O(/�U - N U�< Q N M W�K D 36U�b�<IAJ< M <?U D 9 � K�@+/�WfW�@ N / Q F 3 M W�AJ< M <IU D HT/ HB3 M 3JAJ/�@/�A6b N @B3 DGF M N U M N 5�<?@LU�Q N M%M N 5�3 D - F /�@B5 � /�@L<�9 � K�@_/�A6b N @L3 DGF M / AJA N � H F -4, @L3J5 WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A@B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb � � F <?@L< < /�Q F U N 5f<�@BK�U�H M KfA D 36W�AJ< @B<IU�5�<?@ DGF @B< / 5�H?9 R N / Q F 3J< 1c< bc@B<?/ D <I@3JU D <?@G/ Q D 3 143 D - � � < W�@L<?HL<?U D D <?Q F U�36`�K�<?H O N @ @L<?5�KfQ?3JUfb DGF < U�K M+, <?@ N OfH F /�@L<?5 5Y/ D /(/�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH �3 M W�@ N 1436U�b DGF < F 3 D @G/ D < � / U�5 5f<?Q?@L< /�HL3JU�b DGF < / Q?Q?<IHBH D 3 M < 9

�V/�A M <I@ < D /�A 9 � h B � Wf@B<I143 N K�HBA - @B<?Uf5�<?@L<?5 AZ/ @Bbc<:5Y/ D / N U / F -e, @B3J5 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - M /�Q F 3JU�< ,�- N W D 3 M 3�I3JU�b M < M N @ - /�QIQ?<?HLH DBF @ N K�b F�N K D(DBF < M < M N @ - F 3J<?@B/�@BQ F - 9� K�@^H - H D < M H F /�@L<?H DBF < D <IQ F U�3J`�K�< N O 5�/ D / , @L3JQ,��3JUfb+O N @ M < M N @ - Q N�F <?@L<?U�QI< � 3 DGF DBF <?36@

� N @!�;9TR F <?3J@iH - H D < M 3JHi/ 5Y/ D /#W�/�@G/�A6AJ<IA @L<?U�5f<?@B<I@ � F <?@L<%<?/�Q F U N 5�<+3JHi@B<?HLW N U�HB3 , AJ<TO N @/)HBK , HB< DiN O DGF <01 N AJK M <�9 7 /�Q F U N 5f< @L<?U�5f<?@BH(3 D H N � U 5Y/ D / � /�Uf5 DBF <?U H F / @B<?H(WY/�@ D 3J/�AJA -Q N M W�A6< D <?5 3 M /�bc< D 36AJ<IH O N @ ]YU�/�A 5�<IW DGF Q N M W N HL3 D 3 N U 9 ) N @ , < DBD <?@^A N /�5 , / AZ/�U�QI3JU�b � DBF <?36@H - H D < M � 3JA6A M 36bc@G/ D < , A N Q,��H#/ M N Ufb U N 5�<IH /�Uf5@B<IW�AJ36Q / D <8H N M < , A N Q,��H N U DGN HB<I1�<?@B/�AU N 5�<?HI9 C ��< - 5�3 � <?@L<?U�QI< , < D � <I<?U N K�@ � N @!� /�Uf5 DBF <?36@BH036H DGF / D0DGF <I3J@BH0KfHB<?H / Q?<IU D @G/ AHB<I@L1�<?@ DBN M / UY/�bc< DGF <T5Y/ D / 5�36H D @L3 , K D 3 N U 9 C A DGF�N K�b F DBF <TQI<?U D @B/�A HL<?@ 1c<?@i3JH�/ W N D <?U D 3Z/�A, N�DBD AJ<?Uf<?Q,� � 3 D 36Ha/ , A6< DGN N W D 3 M 3�I< DGF <05�3JH D @B3 , K D 3 N U N O , A N Q,��H^O N @ , < DLD <I@aW[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?<�9>�3JQ F /�<?A g N ��/�Uf5�.0/ 1e365 7 A6AJH � N @ DGF � E � F / 1c< / AJH N 5 N U�< W�@B3 N @ � N @!� N U @L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b

AZ/ @Bbc<85Y/ D / HB< D HI9 R F < - � N @!� 3JU�/�K�U�36W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @#<?U�143J@ N U M <?U D O N @ DGF <�143JHBK�/�AJ3� / D 3 N UN O Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A��YKf3J5�5 - UY/ M 3JQ?H 5Y/ D /f9 $ <IQ /�KfHB< DBF < - @L<?H D @B36Q D DGF <I3J@ � N @!� DGN HB36U�bcAJ<

� N @!��H D / D 3 N U�H � DBF < - AJ3 M 3 D DGF <?3J@(3JU�1�<?H D 3Jb�/ D 3 N U�H DBN A N /�5�36U�b WY/�bc<IH N U 5�< M /�U�58O\@ N M DGF <]YA6< H - H D < M K�HB36U�b DBF < M%M /�W � � H - H D < M Q?/�AJA 9�(�< F /21�<a3 M W�AJ< M <IU D <?5T/ M < M N @ - � M /�W�W <?5HB<I@L1�<?@ DBF / D � N @%��HiHB3 M 36AZ/�@LA - 9 ( <_]YU�5 DBF / D 3JU / 5�36H D @L3 , K D <?58<?U�143J@ N U M <?U D � 3 D 36H(OP/�H D <I@DGN bc< D 5Y/ D / N 1c<I@ DBF <_U�< D � N @%� DGF /�U83 D 3JH DGN bc< D 3 D O\@ N M DGF < A N Q?/�A F /�@B585�3JH%�;9

� �

C U DGN U�3 N + / @BQ?3J/ /�U�5 �i/�U � (�<I3(d F <IU � >I> � @B<IU�5�<I@ AJ/�@Bbc<#1 N AJK M <IH N U � g QIAJK�H D <?@LH

� 3 DBF /_Q N M+, 36UY/ D 3 N U N O 3 M /�b�< � HLWY/�QI<a/�U�5 N , � <IQ D%� HBWY/ Q?<(WY/�@ D 3 D 3 N U�36U�b�9 R F <I3J@ � 36U D <?@LAJ< / 1�<OP/�Q DGN @ � /�AJA N � H DGF <^K�HB<I@ DGN Q N U D @ N A DBF <a@G/ D 3 N , < D � <I<?U DGF < D � N 9VR F < - 5f36143J5�< DGF <aQIAJK�H D <I@3JU DBN � h � bc@ N K�W�H � F <I@B< � 36H DGF < U�K MT, <I@ N OfU N 5�<IH 3JU DGF < QIAJK�H D <?@ / U�5��Y36H DGF < 36U D <?@LAJ< / 1�<OP/�Q DGN @I9^7 /�Q F bc@ N K�W F /�Hi/%5�3 � <?@L<?U D HBK , 1 N AJK M <�9aR F < U N 5�<?H � 3 DGF 3JU8/ bc@ N K�W Q N U�HL<?@ 1c<M < M N @ - ,�- 5 N � U HB/ M WfAJ3JUfb DGF <I3J@aQ N M M N U#HLK , 1 N A6K M < ,�- D / ��3JU�b)36U D <?@LAJ< / 1�<?5X]YA D <?@B<I5HBA63JQI<?H?9�7 / Q F M < MT, <I@ N O DGF <Xbc@ N K�W @B<IU�5�<?@LH%/ 5f3 � <?@B<IU D W N @ D 3 N U N O DGF < HLQ?@L<?<?U 9 C AJAU N 5�<?H DGF / D�F /21�< DBF <THB/ M < @G/ U � � 3 DBF 3JU DGF <I3J@:@B<IHBW <?Q D 361�<Tbc@ N K�W F / 1c< DBF <THB/ M < Wf3 �e<?A6H/�U�5 Q N M W N HB3 D <#Wf3 �e<?Aa@L<?HBKfA D H K�HL3JU�b >�/ < D /�A 9�� H , 36UY/�@ - H � /�W/�A6b N @L3 DGF M � h�j � 9 R F < -@B<IW N @ D+DBF / D 3JU D <?@BA6< / 1c<I5 HG/ M W�AJ36U�b � 3 DGF ]YA D <?@L3JU�b�@B< M N 1c<IH M N H D � , K D U N�D /�A6A � N O DGF <5 N � U�HB/ M W�AJ36U�b)/�@ D 36OP/ Q D HI9 � Kf@ � N @%�#5�3 � <?@LH:3JU DGF / D � < � N @%� � 3 DBF8DBF <0O\K�AJA @B<?H N AJK D 3 N U5Y/ D / / D /�AJA D 3 M <?HI9.0/ 1e365 � N @ D <I@ /�U�5 / D < / M O\@ N M DGF <aS(U�361�<?@LHB3 D - N O >�36U�U�<IH N�D / � h E � 5 N 5�3J@L<?Q D 1 N A6K M <

@B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb N O:AZ/ @Bbc<%5Y/ D / HB< D H N U � g QIAJK�H D <I@BH?9�R F < - Q?@L< / D < /�U�3 M / D <?5 HB<?`�K�<IU�Q?<IH ,�-@B<IQ N @L5�3JUfb /�UX3JU D <I@G/�Q D 361�<=W�@L<I143J< � HL<?HBHL3 N U � 3 DBF 5 N � UXHG/ M W�AJ<I5 5Y/ D /f9 & / D <I@ � DBF < - @B<?U �5�<I@ DBF <_@B<IQ N @L5�<?58HB<IHBHB3 N U N � AJ36U�<_/ D O\K�A6A @L<?H N AJK D 3 N U 5Y/ D /f9 R F < - @B<IW N @ D O\K�AJA[@B<?H N AJK D 3 N U@B<IU�5�<I@ D 3 M <?Hi3JU DGF < D <IU�H N O HB<?Q N U�5�H_W <?@iO\@B/ M <�9 C A DBF�N K�b F�DGF <)@L<?U�5f<?@B36U�b M < DGF�N 5�36H5�3 � <I@B<?U D � DBF <�Q N U D @L3 , K D 3 N U N O DGF 36H DBF <?HL3JH 3JH DGF <�/ , 36AJ3 D - DGN 3JU D <?@G/ Q D 3 1c<IA - @B<IU�5�<I@ � 3 9 <�9 � / DM K�A D 36W�AJ<(O\@G/ M <?HaW <?@:HB<IQ N Uf5 � DGF <_5Y/ D /)HB< D / D O\K�A6A @L<?H N AJK D 3 N U 9

������� ����� �

$ ���&� " �

� > - UY/ M <03JH & <?b�3 N U � �)F <_@B<IW�AJ36<?5 � � O N @ � < / @B< M / U - 9 �>�/�@%�,B �A> j

��� � ������������ ���������

<�.#- .#- ������ ����������� ���"! � #����$&% � '��% 2'�(�)�& <?bc3 N U 36H / U�< D � N @!��3JU�b AJ3 , @G/�@ - DBF / D /�5�5�H 1c<I@ - AJ3 DBD AJ< O\K�UfQ D 3 N UY/�A63 D - DGN_DGF <(K�U�5f<?@BA - �

3JUfb R @G/�UfH M 3JHBHL3 N U g N U D @ N A � @ N�DBN Q N A � R g � � H N Q,� < D AZ/ - <I@ 36U DBF <�WfK�@BHLK�3 D N O <IAJ3 M 36UY/ D 36U�bU�< D � N @%��3JU�b N 1�<?@ F < /�5 9 R F < /�W�W�A63JQ?/ D 3 N U�W�@ N bc@G/ M M <?@ � H036U D <?@ OP/�Q?< � C � � � DBN & <Ibc3 N U 36Hbc3 1c<?U 36U C W�W <?U�5�3 � C 9 R F < , /�HB36H N O & <Ibc3 N U)3JH / g+*,* Q?AJ/�HBH Q?/�AJA6<?5)Q N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ DGF / D<?H D / , AJ3JH F <?H:/TO\KfAJA - Q N U�U�<IQ D <I5 b�@G/�W F N O R g � H N Q,��< D H , < D � <I<?U DBF <0U N 5�<?Ha36U /)Q?A6K�H D <?@?9R F <i/�W�W�A63JQ / D 3 N U%Wf@ N bc@B/ M Q / U Q N U D @ N A DGF <iH N Q,��< D H^5f3J@B<IQ D A - � N @ DGF <iQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ Q?/�UF /�Uf5�AJ<0U�< D � N @!� D @B/��%Q=O N @ DGF <_W�@ N bc@B/ M 3JU 3 D H N � U DBF @B<?/�5 9R N H D /�@ D /�5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5�/�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U � DGF <?@B< M KfH D , < H N M < � / - DGN H D /�@ D / W�@ N��

bc@B/ M N U�< /�Q F N O DBF < U N 5�<?H+36U DGF < Q?AJKfH D <I@?9 C W�@ N bc@B/ M � 3 DGF /�Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @TQ?/�UQ / AJAVQ N M M K�U�3JQ?/ DGN @�� � @LHBWY/ � U�� � DBN H D / @ D W�@ N bc@G/ M H N U DGF < N�DBF <?@_U N 5�<IH 36U DGF <%Q?A6K�H D <?@?9� @LHBWY/ � U � KfHB<?H /8HB<IQ?K�@L<#H F <IAJA DGN A N b 3JU DGN <?/�Q F U N 5�<#/ U�5 H D /�@ D /�UY/ M <I5�W�@ N bc@G/ M 97 /�Q F 36U�H D /�U�Q?< N O DBF < Wf@ N bc@B/ M @B<IQ?<I361c<IH M /�U�5Y/ DBN @ - Q N M%M /�Uf5 A63JU�<8/�@LbcK M <?U D H � 3JU �Q?A6K�5�36U�b � N @%�436U�b%5�3J@L<?Q DBN @ - � U N 5f< @B/�U � � / U�5�/ R g ��W N @ D U�K MT, <I@(O N @ DBF < 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5/�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U 9 R F <=HLWY/ � U�<?5X3JUfH D / U�Q?<IH^K�HB<iQ N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @�� � WY/�@BHL< / @BbcH � � DBN @B< D @L3J<I1�< DGF </�@LbcK M <?U D HI9C^D DGF 36H)W N 36U D � <I1c<I@ - U N 5�< F /�H%/ @BKfU�U�3JUfb�Wf@ N bc@B/ M � , K D U N U�< N O DGF <XW�@ N bc@B/ M H

/�@L< Q N U�Uf<?Q D <?5 9 Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ DGN @�� � 36U�3 D � < , � � <?H D / , A63JH F <?H DGF <8Q N U�U�<IQ D 3 N U�H ,�- QI@B< / D 3JUfbH N Q,��< D AJ36U ��H , < D � <?<IU DGF < W�@ N b�@G/ M H?9 � 36U�3 D � < , � <IH D / , AJ36H F DBF <TA63JU ��H ,�- Q?/�K�HB36U�b <?/�Q F

� �

U N 5�< DGN 36U�3 D 3Z/ D <#Q N U�U�<?Q D 3 N U�H DGN A N � <I@ @B/�U ��<I5U N 5�<?H � � F 36AJ<8/�Q?QI<?W D 3JU�b Q N UfU�<?Q D 3 N U�HO\@ N M F 36b F <?@ @B/�U � <?5%U N 5f<?H?9 R F <:Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @VH DGN @L<?H DGF <a@L<?HLK�A D 3JU�b_Q N U�U�<?Q D <I5 H N Q,� < D5�<IHBQ?@L3JW DBN @BH 36U /_Q N U�U�<?Q D 3 N U AJ3JH D 9-( F <?U%<I1�<?@ - U N 5�<:3JH Q N U�U�<IQ D <?5 DBN <I1c<I@ - N�DBF <?@ U N 5�< �DGF < / W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N U 3JH^O\@B<I< DGN K�HB< DGF < H N Q,� < D Hi5�36@B<?Q D A - 9R F <^Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ DGN @ Q?/�U+5�36@B<IQ D Uf< D � N @!� D @B/��%Q DGN O\@B<I<^Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A DBF @B<?/�5�H O\@ N M

� � 5fK D - 9�� O DGF <aQ N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @ F /�H /0Q N U D @ N A DBF @B<?/�5 DGN @BKfU N U � 3 D � 36AJAe/�H - U�Q F @ N U N K�HBA -F /�Uf5�AJ<�36U , N KfU�5 M <IHBHB/�bc<?HI9 R N K�HL< DGF 36H Q / WY/ , 36AJ3 D - � DGF <�/�W�W�A63JQ / D 3 N U M K�H D @B<Ibc3JH D <I@M <?HBHB/�bc< F /�U�5�A63JU�b)O\K�UfQ D 3 N U�H ,�- Q?/�AJA63JU�b Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ DGN @�� @B<?b�3JH D <?@ M HBbcH � � 9��:<?b�3JH D @G/ D 3 N UM /�W�HV/ M <?HLHG/�b�< � . DGN /iQIAZ/�HLH M < DGFfN 5 N @VH D / D 36Q O\K�U�Q D 3 N U DGF / D Q / U)@B<?QI<?3 1c<:/�U�5)Wf@ N Q?<?HLHDGF <#UY/ M <?5 M <IHBHG/ bc<�9�R N HLK�W�W N @ D+DBF 3JH_O\K�U�Q D 3 N UY/�A63 D - � <I1�<?@ - D @B/�U�HLO\<I@ , < D � <?<IU U N 5�<IHF /�H DGN , <Ibc3JU � 3 DGF /�U � .+9 Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ DGN @�� � HL<?U�5 M HBb�H � � W�@L<?W <?U�5�H DGF < F < /�5f<?@ DBN�DGF <N K D b N 36U�b)5Y/ D / H D @L< / M � HB<IU�5�3JUfb DBF < F < / 5�<?@�/�U�5 DGF < 5�/ D / � 3 DBF8N U�<_H - H D < M Q / AJA 9R F < Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @ /�AJH N W�@ N 1e365�<?H @B<IQ?<?3 1c< M < DGF�N 5�H � � F 3JQ F Q /�U , <%Q /�A6AJ<I5 � 3 DGF 36U

M <?HBHB/�bc< F /�Uf5�AJ36U�b�O\K�U�Q D 3 N U�H DGN W�K�A6Aa3JU DGF <X5Y/ D / H D @B< / M 9 R F <8/�5f1 /�U D /�bc< N O�K�HB36U�bDGF <TQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ � H(HB<IU�5 /�U�5�@B<?QI<?3 1c< M < DBF�N 5fH�36H DBF / DiDBF < - /�@L< DBF @B<?/�5 HG/ O\< 9 ( F <?UM K�A D 36W�AJ< DGF @B< / 5�H+H F /�@B<X/�Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @ � DGF < DBF @B<?/�5�H+Q?/�U�U N D HB<IU�5�HB3 M K�A D /�U�< N K�HBA - �N @ DBF < N K D b N 3JU�b 5Y/ D /�H D @B< / M � 3JA6A , <IQ N M < b�/�@ , AJ<I5 9 R F < Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / DGN @#Wf@ N�D <?Q D H< / Q F HB<?Uf5 � 3 DGF / W DGF @B< / 5 M K D <��[9 ) N @(< �%Q?36<?U�Q - � DBF <+Q N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @:36U D <?@LUY/�AJA - K�HL<?HHB<IU�5 M HBb�� � / U�5�@L<?QI1 M HBb�� � H - H D < M Q?/�AJA6H DGN D @G/�UfHLO\<?@ M K�A D 36W�AJ< , K � <I@BH N O^5Y/ D / � 3 DGF /HB36U�bcA6<0H N Q,��< D�N W <?@B/ D 3 N U 9R F < Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @ DBF @B<?/�5 � N @%��H ,�- A NeN Wf3JU�b)/ @ N K�Uf5�/)HB<IAJ<IQ D � � H - H D < M Q / AJA 9 R F <

HB<IAJ<IQ D W�K D H DGF < DGF @L< /�5 DBN HBA6<?<?W&/�Uf5 � / D Q F <?H8/�A6A N O DGF <�H N Q,� < D 5�<IHBQ?@L3JW DBN @BH 3JU DGF <Q N U�U�<?Q D 3 N U AJ36H D 9 ( F <?U DGF < HB<IAJ<IQ D HL<?<IH /�Q D 36143 D - N U N U�< N O:3 D H H N Q,��< D H � 3 D � / � <?H DGF <Q N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ � � F 3JQ F W�@ N M W D A - @B< / 5�H DBF < M <IHBHG/ bc< F < /�5�<I@^/�Uf5 Q / AJAJH DBF <�/�W�W�@ N W�@B3J/ D <F /�Uf5�AJ<I@?9 R F < F /�U�5fAJ<?@ D / ��<IH DGF < H N Q,� < D � DGF < @B/�U � N O DGF < HL<?U�5�36U�b U N 5�< � /�U�5 DGF <M <?HBHB/�bc< � . � /�Uf5 @B<?/�5�H DBF < @L<?H D+N O DGF < M <IHBHB/�bc< 5f3J@B<IQ D A - 3JU DBN /�W�W�A63JQ?/ D 3 N U M < M N @ - 9R F < F /�U�5�A6<?@ Q /�U W�@ N Q?<IHBH DBF <%5Y/ D / � N @ AJ< D /8Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A DGF @L< /�5 D / ��< N 1c<?@I9XR F <AZ/ D <?@ 3JH W�@B< O\<?@B/ , AJ< , <IQ /�K�HL< DGF < Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @_Q /�UfU N�D @L< D Kf@BU DGN�F /�U�5�A63JU�b'� � K�U D 3JADGF < F /�U�5�A6<?@0@B< D K�@LU�H?9 ) 36bcK�@B< k 9A> H FfN � H / F 3Jb F A6<I1�<?A 143J< � N O /X5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 W�@ N b�@G/ M

� �

NODE 1

communicator::send()

.

.

.

Compute Thread 2

Compute Thread 1

Compute Thread T

Application Program

select()handler1()

handlerM()

.

.

.

NODE 2

NODE 4

NODE 3

communicator thread

�%������� <�.#- 9 C H - U�Q F @ N U N K�H=>�<IHBHB/�bc<��i/�U�5fAJ3JUfb�9

@BKfU�U�3JUfb N U�O N K�@_U N 5�<?H � � F <I@B< DGF < ]Y@LH D U N 5f< F / H�� * > DGF @B< / 5�H+/�Uf5�� @L<?bc36H D <?@B<I5M <?HBHB/�bc< F /�Uf5�AJ36U�b+O\K�U�Q D 3 N U�H?9

<�.#- .A3 � ��� $��N� � �(��� $&��� � $ ���"! 2�� $ � ��� � � ��! � � ��� $� U /�5�5�3 D 3 N U DBN , /�HL3JQ Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U � /8O\< � <�� D @B/ OP/�QI3JAJ3 D 36<?H_/�@L< 3JUfQ?AJKf5�<?5 36U DGF <

AJ3 , @G/ @ - 9 R F <?HB< 3JUfQ?AJKf5�< W[<I@ U N 5�< /�U�5_W[<I@ DGF @L< /�5 M <?HBHB/�bc< A N bcbc36U�b � H D / D 3JH D 3JQIH b�/ DGF <?@B36U�b �5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 , /�@B@L3J<?@LH)/�U�5 5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5�H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - 9 7 /�Q F N O DGF <IHB<X/�@L< N W D 3 N UY/ A �/�U�5 5�<?HL3JbcU�<I5#H N+DBF / D DGF < - Q?/�U , < N M 3 DLD <I5 O N @ , < DBD <?@ <��%Q?3J<IU�Q - 9 de<?Q D 3 N U k 9 h <��eW�AJ/�3JUfH5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - � DGF <8@B<IH D#N O & <?bc3 N U � H N W D 3 N UY/�A OP/ Q?3JA63 D 3J<?H+/�@B<8<��eW�AJ/�3JU�<I5, <?A N � 9R F < ]YAJ< A N bcbc<?@I9 F F / H Wf@B<?Wf@ N Q?<?HLH N @ 5�36@B<?Q D 3 1c<?H DGF / D Q N U D @ N A & <?bc3 N U � H0A N b�bc3JU�bX/ U�5

H D / D 36H D 3JQ?H(b�/ DBF <?@L3JU�b%OP/�Q?36AJ3 D 3J<IH?9 ( F <?U�<IUY/ , A6<?5 � A N bcb�3JU�b%/�U�5�H D / D 3JH D 36Q?H�/�5�5�HL3JbcU�3 ]YQ / U DN 1c<I@ F <?/�5 DBN+DGF <_W�@ N bc@G/ M , <?Q / K�HB< DGF < - 36U�Q?@L< /�HL< DBF <0HB3�?< N O DGF < & <Ibc3 N U � Ha5Y/ D /)H D @BK�Q �D Kf@B<?H � Q / K�HB<iO\@L<?`�K�<IU D ]�AJ< � � � HBW <?U�5 D 3 M <(Q / AJAJ36U�b_bc< DLD 3 M < N O\5Y/ - � � � /�U�5 @L<?`�K�36@B< DBF @B<?/�5H - U�Q F @ N U�3� / D 3 N U 9�$ <IQ /�K�HL< N O DGF 36H � DGF < - /�@B< 3 M W�A6< M <?U D <I5 � 3 DGF W�@B<IW�@ N Q?<IHBH N @ 5f3J@B<IQ D 361c<IHDGF / D Q /�U , < Q N M W�AJ< D <?A - <IAJ365�<?5 O\@ N M DGF <_W�@ N bc@B/ M 9R F < � A N b � M /�Q?@ N H Q N U D @ N Ac<I@B@ N @ � & <?bc3 N U0HBW <?QI36]YQ � /�U�5 /�W�W�A63JQ?/ D 3 N U=HBW <?QI36]YQ � M <IHBHG/ bc<

W�@L3 N @L3 D - AJ<I1�<?A6H?9 R F <I@B< /�@B< D � N 1c<?@LHB3 N U�H N O < /�Q F M / Q?@ N � N U�<_5�36@B<IQ D H N K D W�K DaDGN /)U N 5f<HBW <?QI36]YQ:]YA6< � /�U�5 DGF < N�DGF <?@ 5�3J@L<?Q D H N K D W�K D DBN / U N 5f<i/�Uf5 DGF @B< / 5 HBW <?QI36]YQ:]YA6<�9VR F <(A N bM /�Q?@ N H N W <?@G/ D < N U g+*,* � � H D @B<?/ M H?9

� �

R F <). � deR C R(d M /�Q?@ N <?U�/ , AJ<IHiQ N M M K�U�3JQ?/ D 3 N U8/�U�5�5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5�H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ -H D / D 36H D 3JQ?H)bc/ DGF <I@B36U�b�9 g N M%M K�Uf3JQ / D 3 N U H D / D 36H D 36Q?H+36U�Q?A6K�5�<X/ Q N K�U D N O DBF <XU4K M+, <I@ N OHB<IAJ<IQ D � � � HL<?U�5�� � /�U�5 @B<IQI1 � � H N Q,� < D N W <?@B/ D 3 N U�H � /#Q N K�U D_N O DBF <)U�K M+, <?@ N O ,�- D <?H_HL<?U D/�U�5 @L<?Q?<I361�<?5 � /�U�5 / M <?/�HBKf@B< M <?U D N O DGF < DGN�D /�A D 3 M <#HBW <?U D Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / D 3JUfb�9�._df>H D / D 36H D 3JQ?H 3JU�QIAJK�5f<iQ N K�U D H N O DBF <=U�K M+, <?@ N O /�Q?QI<?HBHL<?H � DBF <=U�K M+, <?@ N O F 3 D H � DGF <=U�K MT, <I@N O @L< M N�D < /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH � DBF < U�K MT, <I@ N O / HBH N Q?3J/ D 3 1c< F 3 D H�/�U�5 / M <?/�HBK�@L< M <?U D�N O DGF < DBN�D /�AD 3 M <�HBW <?U D:N U <?/�Q F /�Q?QI<?HBHI9^d D / D 3JH D 3JQIH^/�@L< � @B3 DBD <IU DGN+DBF <0U N 5�<=HBW <?QI36]YQ0A N bT]YA6<?H � F <?UDGF < Wf@ N bc@B/ M D <?@ M 36UY/ D <IH?9d - U�Q F @ N U�3�?/ D 3 N U�3JH <IHBHB<IU D 3Z/ A03JU M N H D W�/�@G/�A6AJ<IA�W�@ N bc@B/ M H � H N & <Ibc3 N U�3JU�QIAJK�5�<IHX/

5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 , /�@L@B3J<I@ Wf@B3 M 3 D 361�<�9 C Wf@ N bc@B/ M Q /�U�K�HB< / U - U�K M+, <?@ N O , /�@L@B36<?@ N , � <?Q D H �< / Q FN O � F 3JQ F M / - Q N U D /�3JU /�U - HBK , HB< D N O DBF < U N 5�<IH 36U DBF <8Q?AJKfH D <I@?9 � U D <?@BU�/�AJA - /, /�@L@B36<?@ N , � <?Q D Q N U D /�3JUfH=/ A63JH D�N O U N 5�<IH � / U /�@B@L361 /�A M /�@!� <?@�O N @i< / Q F U N 5f<T3JU DGF < AJ3JH D �/�U�5%/ M <IHBHB/�bc< F /�Uf5�AJ36U�b M < DGF�N 5 9 Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @�� � @B<?b�3JH D <?@ , /�@L@B3J<I@ � � � D / ��<IH 36U / A63JH D N OU N 5�<?Hi/�U�5 @B< D K�@BUfH=/ Uf< � A - QI@B< / D <?5 , /�@B@L3J<I@ N 1�<?@ DBF�N HB< U N 5�<?HI9:R F <)/�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U Q / AJAJHAJ<Ibc3 N U , / @B@B36<?@ � � /�@B@L361�< � � DGN K�HB< DBF < , /�@B@L3J<?@I9�R F 3JHiHL<?U�5fH0/ H FfN @ D M <IHBHG/ bc< DBN /�AJA U N 5�<IH3JU DGF <�U N 5f<=AJ36H D � /�Uf5 DGF <IU Q F <?Q,��H DGF <=/�@B@B/ - DBN Q N KfU D DGF <=U N 5�<IH DGF / DaF / 1c<=/�@B@L361c<I5 9�� O/�A6A U N 5�<IH:/�@B<�W�@B<IHB<IU D � DGF <=/�@B@L361c<�Q /�A6A[@L< D K�@BU�H 3 M%M <I5�3Z/ D <?A - 9-� O U N�D � DGF <iQ /�A6AJ3JUfb DBF @B<?/�5HBA6<?<IW�H:K�U D 3JA DBF < , /�@L@B3J<I@ � H M <IHBHB/�bc< F /�U�5fAJ<?@aHL<?<IH DGF < AJ/�H D U N 5f< � Hi/�@L@B3 1�/ A M <?HBHB/�bc< 9

��� � � � � �������,� ����� �� ������ ' ��������

<�.A3".#- ���������� * �����I������� $� U)/ D 3Jb F�D A - Q N K�W�A6<?5 WY/�@G/ AJAJ<IA M / Q F 3JU�< � H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - /�AJA N � H DBF @B<?/�5�H 36UT/(WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A

W�@ N bc@G/ M DGN8N W[<I@G/ D < 5�36@B<IQ D A - N U DGF < HG/ M < b�A N , / AJA - 143JHL3 , A6< M < M N @ - 9 � U�/ Q?A6K�H D <?@L<?5<?U�143J@ N U M <?U D � DGF < M < M N @ - N Oa<?/�Q F U N 5�< 36H Wf@B361 / D < � N U�A - / Q?Q?<IHBHL3 , A6< DGN�N�DGF <I@ U N 5�<IHDGF @ N K�b F Wf@ N bc@B/ M 5�36@B<IQ D <I5 D @G/�UfHLO\<?@LH?9 & <?bc3 N U � H_.0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@_QIAZ/�HLH Wf@ N 143J5�<IH / M <?Q F / �U�36H M � F <?@L< ,�- <I1c<I@ - U N 5f< F /�Hi/�Q?QI<?HLH DGN%DGF <T/�bcbc@L<?b�/ D < M < M N @ - 3JU DBF <TQIAJK�H D <I@?9(R F <M < M N @ - 3JH N , � <IQ D%� , /�HL<?5 � /�U�55 N <IH#U N�D @B<?A - N U DGF < N W[<I@G/ D 3JU�b H - H D < M DBN M /�UY/�bc<WY/�b�<?H N O_H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - 9�R F 36H @B<I5�K�QI<?H DGF <�W�@ N , AJ< M N O0OP/�AJHL<�H F /�@B36U�b�/�U�5/�AJA N � Hk�h � , 3 D W�@ N b�@G/ M H DGN /�QIQ?<?HLH M N @L< DGF /�U,F + $ N O M < M N @ - 9

� �

R F < / W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N U N , D / 3JU�H / .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@ N , � <IQ D ,�- Q?/�AJA63JU�bQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ � � @B<Ibc3JH D <I@ 5�/ D /�HL<?@ 1c<?@ � � 9 R F < M < M N @ - M N 5f<?A=36H#<�� D <IU�HB3 , AJ< � /�Uf5&]�1�<5�3 � <I@B<?U D QIAZ/�HLHB<?H_3 M W�A6< M <?U D(DGF <%.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@03JU D <I@LOP/�QI<)3JU HBA63Jb F�D A - 5�3 � <?@L<?U D M /�U�U�<I@BH?9) N K�@ N O DBF < ]�1�<^3 M W�A6< M <?U D / D 3 N UfH N U�A - /�AJA N � @B<?/�5)/�QIQ?<?HLH?9 R F < @G/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b=/�WfW�AJ36Q / D 3 N UDGF / D & <Ibc3 N U � / H=5�<?HL3JbcUf<?5 DBN HBKfW�W N @ D 5 N <IHiU N�D � @B3 D < DGN DBF <TH F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - 5�Kf@B3JUfb@BKfU D 3 M < � H N 3 D 36H < �%QI3J<?U D#DBN N M 3 D � @B3 D < Q N U�HL3JH D <?UfQ -M /�36U D <?UY/ U�Q?< <?U D 36@B<?A - 9�R F <O N K�@ @L< /�5 N U�A - Q?AJ/�HBHL<?H8/�@L< � HB36U�bcAJ< DBF @B<?/�5�<I5 � 5�36@B<?Q D M /�WfW[<I5 � HL< D /�HBH N QI3Z/ D 361c< / U�5HB<IQ N Uf5Y/�@ - H DGN @G/�bc< M < M N @ - M /�W�W <?5 9 R F < � @B3 D / , A6<iQ?AJ/�HBHa36Ha/)HB<I`4Kf<?U D 3J/�AJA - Q N U�HB36H D <?U DH F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - � 3 DBF ]��f<I5�5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5 N � U�<I@BH F 3JW�/�U�58/ � @L3 D <03JU�1 /�AJ365Y/ D <�W�@ N DGN Q N A 9R F <).0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@ N @Bb�/�Uf3�?<IH M < M N @ - 3JU DGN , A N Q,��H � /�U�5�365�<?U D 36]Y<IH�<?/�Q F , A N Q,� ,�- /�U

3JU D <?bc<I@ ��< - 9 R F <0/ W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N U%HBW <?QI36]Y<IH DGF < , A N Q,� HB3�?<i/�U�5 DGF < DGN D /�A U�K M+, <?@ N O , A N Q,��H

� F <IU�3 D QI@B<?/ D <IH DBF < .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@I9%R F < , A N Q,��H_Q / U , <%/�AJ36bcU�<?5 36U M < M N @ - O N @ , < DLD <I@D @B/�U�HLAZ/ D 3 N U+A NeN �T/�HL3J5�< , K � <I@ /�U�5 Q /�Q F <�<�� QI3J<IU�Q - 9 7 / Q F U N 5�<:/�A6A N Q / D <?H%> + $ N O[A N Q /�AM < M N @ - DGNXF�N A65 , A N Q,��H � , K D_DGF < .� � R > C �=._df>�>�7 > <?U�143J@ N U M <IU D 1 /�@L3Z/ , AJ<+Q?/�UN 1c<I@B@B365�< DGF <)5f<IOP/�K�A D 9 (�3 DGF � U N 5�<?H � <?/�Q F U N 5f< /�HBHLK M <IH N � Uf<?@BH F 3JW N O >�� N O DGF <, A N Q,��H � /�U�5�K�HL<?H DBF <%@B<?H DTN O DBF < @L<?HL<?@L1�<?5�HLWY/�Q?< DGN Q / Q F < , A N Q,�4H_O\@ N M N�DGF <?@_U N 5�<?HI9R F <).0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@ � <?<IW�H=3 D H N � U 5Y/ D / 36U�/�U�/�@B<?/ Q / AJAJ<I5 DBF <T@L<?HL3J5�<IU D HB< D 9�R F <TQ / Q F <?55Y/ D /�b N <IH 36U DBN�DBF <8A N Q /�A^Q?/�Q F < 9&R F < @B/�U � N O DGF < U N 5f< DBF / D N � U�H � < -�� 36H%b�361c<IU,�-��+M N 5���9 � U DBF < N � U�3JUfb�U N 5�< � DBF <�� < - � 3JAJA , < O N K�U�5�/ D <?U D @ -�� �� 36U DGF <@B<IHB365�<?U D HB< D 9 � U�@B< M N D <_U N 5�<?H � DBF < HB/ M < � < - � 3JA6A , <_O N K�Uf5 � 3 DBF 3JU�� HBA N�D H N OV<IU D @ -� � � � M N 5�� � � � F <?@L<���36H DGF <=/�HBH N QI3Z/ D 36143 D - /�Uf5�� � 36H DBF <0HB3�?< N O DBF <=A N Q?/�A[Q?/�Q F < 9R N K�HB< DBF < M < M N @ - � / U /�W�W�A63JQ?/ D 3 N U DGF @L< /�5 Q?/�AJA6Hi.0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@�� � b�< D 5Y/ D / � � � DBN bc< D

/ W N 36U D <?@ DBN�DBF < , <Ibc3JU�Uf3JU�b N O , A N Q,� � 9 � O DGF < , A N Q,��3JH U N�D 3JU A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - � DGF <.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ � 36AJA(HBK�HLW[<IU�5 DBF < Q /�A6AJ<I@ � F 36AJ< 3 D#N , D / 3JU�H DBF < HBW <?QI36]Y<I5 M < M N @ - , A N Q,�N 1c<I@ DBF < Uf< D � N @!�;9 ( F <IU DBF <T/ W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N U DGF @L< /�58]YU�3JH F <?H(K�HL3JU�b / , A N Q,� � 3 D M K�H D Q?/�AJA.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@�� � @L<?AJ<?/�HB< 5Y/ D / � � � DGN O\@L<?< DBF < , A N Q,� � H#HBW�/�Q?< 9 � U , < D � <I<?U DGF < D � N Q?/�AJA6H �N�DBF <?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H+Q?/�U�U N D @B<IW�AZ/�QI< DGF < , A N Q,�;9 R F <#H D @BKfQ D Kf@B< N O�/ DBF @B<I<#U N 5�<#W�@ N bc@G/ M �@BKfU�U�3JUfb D � N /�W�W�A63JQ / D 3 N U DBF @B<?/�5�H�W[<I@iU N 5�< � /�U�5�KfHB3JUfb DGF <+.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@=3JH(3JA6AJK�H D @G/ D <?53JU ) 36bcK�@L< k 9 h 9

���

NODE 1

DataServer

communicator

ds->getdata()ds->releasedata()

thread 1

ds->getdata()ds->releasedata()

thread 2resident_set local_cache

0 3 6 4 1 2 7

shared memory

dsm_application.exe

NODE 2

DataServer

communicator

ds->getdata()ds->releasedata()

thread 1

ds->getdata()ds->releasedata()

thread 2resident_set local_cache

1 4 7 8 5 6 3

shared memory

dsm_application.exe

NODE 3

DataServer

communicator

ds->getdata()ds->releasedata()

thread 1

ds->getdata()ds->releasedata()

thread 2resident_set local_cache

2 5 8 4 1 6 3

shared memory

dsm_application.exe

�%� ��� �� <�. 3 9 .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 d F / @B<?5 >�< M N @ - C @LQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@L<�9

C QI`4Kf3J@B36U�b / , A N Q,�X3JU�1 N A 1c<IH DGF < O N AJA N � 3JU�b /�Q D 3 N UfH?9(R F <)/�QI`4Kf3J@B36U�b DBF @B<?/�5�`�K�<I@B3J<IHDGF <=.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ DGN /�Q?QI<?HLH DGF < , A N Q,�;9�� O DGF < , A N Q,� 36H 36U A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - � DGF <i.0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@M /�@!��H DGF < , A N Q,��36U K�HB< /�U�5 @B< D K�@BUfH 3 D H_/�5�5f@B<?HLH?9 � DBF <?@ � 3JHB< � DBF < DGF @L< /�5�@B<IHB<?@ 1c<IH)/HBW�/�Q?<TO N @ DGF < , A N Q,� � HL<?U�5�H_/ @B<?`�K�<IH D0DBN DGF <TU N 5f< DGF / D=N � U�H DGF < , A N Q,� � / U�5 b N <?H DBNHBA6<?<IW 9 ( F <IU DGF < , A N Q,� � H N � U�<?@ @B<IQ?<I361c<IH DBF <:@B<?`�K�<IH D � 3 D H .0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ <IUfO N @LQ?<?H /0HB36U�bcAJ<

� @B3 D <I@ M K�A D 3JW�A6<i@B<?/�5�<I@�W N AJ36Q - 9 S(<�� D � DBF < N � U�<I@ M /�@%�4H DBF < , A N Q,�#3JUXK�HL<T/�Uf5 HL<?U�5�Hi/Q N W - N O DGF < , A N Q,� DGN#DGF <)@B<?`�K�<IH D 3JU�b8U N 5�<�9 ( F <?U DGF < /�QI`�K�3J@L3JU�b U N 5�<�� H_.0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@@B<IQ?<I361c<IH DBF < , A N Q,� � 3 D @B<?QI<?3 1c<?H DGF / D , A N Q,�+3JU DGN_DGF <�@L<?HB<I@L1�<?5#HLWY/�Q?<i/�U�5 DGF <IU � / ��<IH DGF </�QI`4Kf3J@B36U�b DGF @B< / 5 9

� �

<�.A3".A3 � � � ! � � � � � � ��� � ��$C @B<?/�5 N UfA - M < M N @ - Q / U)<?AJ3 M 36UY/ D < � @B3 D < Q N U�HB36H D <?U�Q -+M /�3JU D <IUY/�U�QI< 5�<IAZ/ - <?U D 36@B<IA - 9

R F < HL3 M W�AJ<IH D+N O DGF <#@L< /�5 N U�A - M < M N @B3J<IH 36H DBF < HB36U�bcAJ< DGF @L< /�5f<?5 .0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ HB36U�bcAJ<Q?AJ/�HBHI9 � D /�HLHBK M <?H#/ HB36U�bcA6< / W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N U DBF @B<?/�5 DGN N M 3 D Q N U�HB36H D <IU�Q - Q F <IQ,�4HX/ M N UfbQ N M W�K D < DGF @L< /�5fH(36U8/ U N 5�< 9

) N @ DGF < M K�A D 3 DBF @B<?/�5�<I5 M < M N @B3J<IH � /#Q N K�U D 3JU�b HL< M /�W F�N @L<+W�@ N�D <IQ D H0<?/�Q F A N Q / D 3 N U3JU DGF <�A N Q?/�A(Q /�Q F < 9�R F < AJ<Ibc3 N U HB< M / W F�N @L< Q?AZ/ HBH#W�K D H / � @B/�W�W <?@ /�@ N K�U�5�/ W N HL3 �HB< M / W F�N @L< DGN KfHB<+3 D /�H0/ Q N K�U D 3JU�b#HL< M /�W F�N @B<�90R F <+HB< M /�W F�N @B<TQ N K�U D H DGF <+U�K MT, <I@N O @B<?/�5�36U�b DGF @B< / 5�H=O N @ DBF < , A N Q,�83JU /#bc3 1c<IU A N Q / D 3 N U 9$ <IO N @L< / DGF @B< / 5�Q?/�U � @B3 D < DBN/)A N Q / D 3 N U � O N @ 3JU�H D /�U�QI< � F <?U83 D @B<?HL<?@ 1c<?Hi/ , A N Q,� DBN ]YAJA[3JU N 1c<?@ DBF <0U�< D � N @%� � 3 D M K�H D/ DBN M 36Q /�A6A - 5�<IQ?@L< M <?U D�DBF <_Q N KfU D:DBN I<?@ N 9R F < .0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@ 5�3J@L<?Q D Q?AJ/�HBH /�5f5�H DGF @L< /�5 HB/ O\< D - DGN DGF <

.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ HB36U�bcAJ< Q?AJ/�HBHI9 � U DBF <?HL< D � N QIAZ/�HLHB<?H � < /�Q F � < - Q?/�U N U�A - @L<?HB365�<+36U�A N Q / D 3 N U�����+M N 5���� ��� ���� � ������� 9)R F <%.0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@ /�HBH N Q Q?AJ/�HBH036H_/�U � � / - HL< D /�HBH N QI3Z/ D 361�<Q / Q F < � 3 DGF / A6< /�H D @L<?QI<?U D A - K�HB<I5#@B<IW�AZ/�QI< M <?U D W N A63JQ - 9 C HBH N QI3Z/ D 36143 D - F /�H DGF <(W N D <?U D 3Z/�ADGN @B<I5�K�Q?<�U�< D � N @!� D @B/��%Q � , K D 3 D /�5�5�H N 1c<?@ F < / 5 9 7 /�Q F A NeN �4KfW F /�H DGN Q F <?Q,� �A N Q / D 3 N U�H � /�Uf5 /�A6A /�Q?QI<?HLHB<?H F / 1c< DBN Q?/�AJA bc< DLD 3 M < N O\5Y/ - � � DGN K�W[5�/ D < DGF < D 3 M <)H D / M W 9R F < .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@ M%M / W Q?AJ/�HBH�36H�U N D /�Q D KY/�A6A - /5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 M < M N @ - 9 � U�H D <?/�5 N OO\< D Q F 3JUfb , A N Q,�4H N 1c<I@ DGF < U�< D � N @%� � DGF 36H Q?AZ/ HBHX3JU�1 N ��<?H DGF < M%M /�W�� � H - H D < M Q / AJA DBNO\< D Q F , A N Q,��HaO\@ N M DGF <_]�AJ<_H - H D < M 9 R F < M < M N @ -#M /�WXQ?AZ/ HBH:5 N <?H:U N�D(F / 1c< /)@B<IHB3J5f<?U DHB< D � K�HL3JU�b /�A6A N O DGF <_@L<?HB<I@L1�<?5�HLWY/�Q?<_O N @ DBF <_A N Q /�A[Q /�Q F < 3JUfH D <?/�5 9

<�.A3".A< 6 � � � ����� � � � � �R F < .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@ @ � QIAZ/�HLH F /�H HB<IWY/�@B/ D < /�QI`4Kf3J@B< /�Uf5 @L<?A6< /�HL< N W[<I@G/ D 3 N U�H

O N @ @B<?/�5 N U�A - /�U�5 � @L3 D / , AJ< /�QIQ?<?HLH?9 R F < � @B3 D / , A6< N W[<I@G/ D 3 N U�H /�@L<.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@�� � bc< D 5Y/ D / O N @ � @B3 D < � � / U�5 .0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@�� � @L<?AJ<?/�HB< � @B3 DLD <IU 5Y/ D / � � 9(R F <+@B<?/�5/�U�5 � @B3 D <8/�QI`4Kf3J@B< N W <?@B/ D 3 N U�H)<IUfO N @BQI<�/ HB36U�bcA6< � @B3 D <?@ � M KfA D 36W�AJ< @B<?/�5�<?@%W N AJ36Q - 9 S NDGF @B< / 5&Q?/�U � @B3 D < DGN / , A N Q,� K�U D 36Ai<I1�<?@ - N�DGF <I@ DGF @L< /�5 N U DBF < Q?A6K�H D <?@ @B<IAJ<?/�HB<IH83 D 9R F @L< /�5�H_Q?/�U @L< /�5 DBF <)HG/ M < , A N Q,� HB3 M K�A D /�U�< N K�HBA - � , K D U N DGF @L< /�5 Q / U�@L< /�5�/ , A N Q,�

� F 36AJ<_/�U N DGF <I@ DGF @L< /�583JH � @L3 D 36U�b DGN 3 D 9

� �

$ <IO N @B< N , D /�3JU�36U�b)5Y/ D / � � @L3 D < /�QI`�K�3J@L<?H M K�H D ]�@BH D U�<Ib N�D 3Z/ D <=O N @aH N A6< /�Q?QI<?HBH DGN DGF <D / @Bbc< D , A N Q,�;9_R F <+W�@ N QI<?HLH , <Ibc3JU�H � 3 DGF / � @B3 D <T@L<?`�K�<?H D M <IHBHG/ bc<+HB<IU D0DGN#DGF < N � U�<?@I9( F <IU DBF < N � U�<?@ HL<?<?H / � @L3 D < @B<?`�K�<IH D O N @ / , A N Q,� � 3 D H .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@ H D /�@ D H `�K�<?Kf3JU�b_AZ/ D <?@@B<I`�K�<?H D H�O N @ DBF / D , A N Q,�;9%S(<�� D(DGF < N � U�<?@ � Hi.0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@ � /�3 D H:O N @�/ AJA A N Q?/�A DGF @B< / 5�H DBN@B<IAJ<?/�HB< DBF < , A N Q,�;9 ( F <IU U N A N Q /�A DGF @L< /�5fH F / 1c<(/�Q?QI<?HLH � DGF <:.0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@ , @ N /�5�Q?/�H D H /�U3JU�1 /�A63J5Y/ D < M <IHBHG/ bc< DGN�DGF <^@L<?H DVN O DBF <^U N 5�<?HI9 ( F <IU DGF < N DGF <I@ U N 5�<?H HB<?< DGF <^36U�1�/ AJ3J5�/ D <M <?HBHB/�bc< � DBF < - � /�3 D O N @ H N A6< /�Q?QI<?HBH / M N U�b DBF <?36@ N � U DGF @L< /�5fH � 3JU�1 /�AJ365Y/ D < A N Q /�A6A - Q / Q F <?5Q N W�3J<IH � /�U�5 DBF <?U HB<IU�5 /�U /�Q,��U N � AJ<I5�b M <?U D , /�Q,� DBN�DGF < N � U�<I@?9 $ <?Q?/�K�HB<XU N N DGF <I@DGF @B< / 5�Q /�U�/ Q?`�K�3J@L< DBF < , A N Q,��/ D DGF 36HTW N 3JU D � DGF <I@B<#Q?/�U , < U N 5Y/ D / 36U�Q N U�HB36H D <IU�Q?36<?HI9( F <IU DBF < N � U�<?@0@L<?Q?<I361�<?H / O\K�AJA HB< D_N O 36U�1�/ AJ3J5�/ D <T/�Q,��U N � AJ<?5fb M <IU D H � 3 D H0.0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@HB<IU�5�H DGF <+@B<I`4Kf<?H D <?5 , A N Q,� DGN#DGF <)/�Q?`�K�36@B36U�b DGF @B< / 5 9_R F < N � U�<?@0Q N U D 3JU�K�<IH DGN `�K�<IK�<@B<I`�K�<?H D HaO N @ DBF < , A N Q,� K�U D 36A DBF <=@B<I`�K�<?H D <?@:@L<?AJ<?/�HB<IH DGF < , A N Q,�;9 R F <=@B<I`�K�<?H D <?@:@L<?AJ<?/�HB<IHDGF < , A N Q,� ,�- HB<?Uf5�3JU�b DGF <(Uf< � Q N U D <?U D H , / Q,� DGN0DGF < N � U�<?@I9 (�3 DBF / U%KfW DBN 5Y/ D <:Q N W - �DGF < N � U�<I@�36H N U�QI< / b�/�3JU#O\@L<?< DGN bc@B/�U D /�Q?QI<?HBH DGN)DBF < , A N Q,�;9

� U DGF <i@B< / 5 N U�A - M < M N @L3J<?H DGF <iQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ DGF @B< / 5 � / H:/ , AJ< DGN HB<?@ 143JQ?<i@B< M N�D </�QI`4Kf3J@B< @B<I`4Kf<?H D H ,�- <��e<IQ?K D 3JU�b DBF <�.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ � H M <IHBHB/�bc< F / U�5�AJ<I@?9 R F < F /�Uf5�AJ<I@HB3 M WfA - HB<IU DaDBF < , A N Q,� DGN+DBF <=@B<I`�K�<?H D <?@(/�Uf5 DBF 3JH 5�3J5 U N�D HB<I@B3 N K�HBA - 5f<?AZ/ - DGF <0HL<?U�5f<?@ � HQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ DGF @L< /�5 9 (�3 DBF � @B3 D < /�Q?QI<?HLH � DGF < N � U�<I@ N O D <?U F / H DGN 5�<?AJ/ - DGF <)@B<?WfA - 9C HB3 M W�A6<�HBA6<?<IW � 36AJAiU N�D � N @%� F <I@B< � , <IQ /�K�HL< DBF < Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / DGN @ F /�H DGN , < @L< /�5 -O N @ DGF < U�<�� D 3JU�Q N M 3JU�b M <IHBHG/ bc<�9 R N , @B<?/ � DBF <#5�<?/�5�A N Q,� � DGF < � @B3 D / , A6< .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@F /�H%3 D H N � U DGF @B< / 5 � /�Uf5 / `�K�<?K�< N O=W <?Uf5�3JU�b , A N Q,��@B<?`�K�<IH D H?9�R F <8Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / DGN @DGF @B< / 5�K�HL<?H DBF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@ @ � � H M <IHBHG/ bc< F /�U�5�A6<?@ DGN <IU�`�K�<?Kf< , A N Q,� @B<I`�K�<?H D H � / U�5DGF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@ @ � � H DGF @B< / 5 Q N U�HBK M <IH DBF < M / D 3 D HaA6<?36HBK�@L<�9

��� � � � � � � �� U DGF 36H�HB<IQ D 3 N U � � <�5 N /HB<?@L3J<IH N O D <IH D H DBN <��f/ M 3JU�< DGF < W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< N O DGF <

Q N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @ /�U�5 DGF < .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@LH?9 C AJA D <?H D HXK�HB<�/ QIAJK�H D <?@ DBF / D Q N U�HB36H D H N O k�h5�KY/ A � g � S & 3JU�K�� � g � H /�U�5�/�U�7�� D @L< M < S�< D � N @%�4H)D��>�D*$ AZ/�Q,��.=3J/ M N U�5 + 3Jb�/ , 3 D7 DGF <I@BU�< D H � 3 D Q F 90R F <TQ N Uf]�bcK�@G/ D 3 N U N O DGF <TQ?A6K�H D <?@=U N 5�<IH=3JH�5�<?HLQ?@L3 , <?5 3JU�R / , AJ< k 9A>c9� U DGF < D <IH D H � <?AJ/�W�HB<I5 D 3 M <=3JH M < / HBK�@L<?5 ,�- Q?/�AJA63JU�b bc< DLD 3 M < N O\5Y/ - � � 9

� �

��� ����� <�.#- 9 g A6K�H D <?@ g N M W N Uf<?U D HI9

������������� ������� �� ��������������� � OJwiIjb�Q�MNnybHA��� Y � �"!

� � kXFTILd�# �%$ n�GfMSw KTIjF ���&(' Y OfDCd � k�FTILd*)#IjArk �c_,+ $ ���.-

���0/ �%1(2 njDCn�GJI�KHM3-jI&�� 4���5��� ��67/ ���c` � ACb�KHDCMSb�] ���98 Y 8 6 `: � <;=�5��>@?"����� � kXFTILd"� bHA � $0$0$BA ) e

Y b�MSZCIjb�ZCIjb�K�MSArkC�J_D�J_ ����E � �FG&(' H.I � Y � 6 �#IKJfACb�nyI2� � � �r` 2 �

Y b�MSZCIjb�ZCIjb�K�MSArk �c_ $ _ �0L �%$M �����9���%NPO� �Q#r� 2 � ILDcurDcFTI � GJIjIjFHDCG � � �%$

���Q/ $0$0$R8 � ` �S 4�����T U Mhk\O�6 �\_D�J_ � $ � H A[Z �0#)�?� $0$ ����������VNWTW4� � ��� �\_ $ _D�XEZY���[T]\�^Q _��G`.N]TWa^K��^Q _4� � I J � ZCIjb�KHMSArk �c_b/

<�.A<".#- ������ �"� � � �(������� * � #% � ���(��� �(�< K�HB< /8Wf3JU�b � W N U�b D <?H D � hch�� DGN Q N M WY/�@L< DGF < , /�HB36Q 5Y/ D / D @B/�U�HLO\<I@ @B/ D < N OaR g �

H N Q,��< D H � & <Ibc3 N U � & C > � >�� � 1�<?@LHB3 N U�De9VBe9GD=/�Uf5 >�� � g � 1c<?@LHB3 N U�>c9 h 9 k 9 R F <:>�� � D @B/�U�H �O\<?@ N W <?@B/ D 3 N U�H0K�HL< DBF < >�� � $ �0Ra7E5Y/ D / D - W < DGN8N M 3 D=D - W[<%Q N U�1�<?@LHB3 N U�3JU D @G/�U�H O\<?@I9� U DGF < D <?H D � /#Q?<IU D @G/�A U N 5�<)Q - Q?AJ<IH / , K � <?@ /�@ N K�U�5 / @B36U�b N O U N 5�<?H � HB<?Uf5�3JU�b DBN / U�5@B<IQ?<I36143JU�b8O\@ N M <?/�Q F U N 5�<%3JU D K�@BU 98R F < Q?<IU D @G/ A U N 5�<%@B<?Q N @B5fH DGF < <?AJ/�W�HB<I5 D 3 M < O N @> jcj�j D @L3JW�Hi/�@ N KfU�5 DGF <+@B36U�b�9iR F <)HB3�I< N O DBF < M <?HLHG/�bc<+/�U�5 DGF <+U�K M+, <?@ N O U N 5�<IH0/�@L<1 /�@B36<?5 9R F <(<?AZ/ W�HB<I5 D 3 M < M <?/�HBK�@L< M <?U D H O N @ /�A6A D <?H D H / @B<:bc361�<?U%3JU R / , AJ< k 9 h 9 R F <i/ 1�<?@G/ bc<

/�U�5�<�� D @L< M <T1 /�AJK�<IH N OVAZ/ D <?U�Q - /�Uf5 , /�U�5 � 3J5 DBF O N @ DGF < D <?H D H0/�@L<Tbc3 1c<IU�3JU�R / , A6< k 9 k 9� 1c<I@G/�A6A � >'��� g � 36H^HBA N � <IH D � R g � 3JH OP/ H D <IH D � /�U�5 & <?bc3 N UX/�U�5 & C > � >�� � /�@B<0@ N K�b F A -<?`�KY/ A 9

& <?bc3 N U KfU�5�<?@ � W <?@ O N @ M H�R g � , <?Q?/�K�HB< 3 D /�5�5fH F <?/�5�<I@BH DBN /�A6A M <IHBHB/�bc<?H � 3 D /�5�5�H�/Q N M M KfU�3JQ?/ D 3 N U DGF @L< /�5 � /�U�5 3 D @L<?`�K�36@B<?H DGF @B<?<8H - H D < M Q?/�AJA6H)W[<I@%@L<?QI<?W D 3 N U 9 C H DGF <M <?HBHB/�bc< AJ<?Ufb DGF 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB<IH � DGF < HB<?A6<?Q D � � /�U�5�@B<IQI1 � � Q?/�AJA6H DGF / D @B< D @L3J<I1�< DBF < F < /�5�<I@, <?Q N M <(AJ<IHBH 3 M W N @ D /�U D � /�U�5 DGF <(5Y/ D / @L<?Q?<IW D 3 N U D 3 M <a5 N M 3JUY/ D <?HI9�& C > � >�� � F /�Uf5�AJ<IHH M /�A6A M <?HLHG/�bc<IHaOP/�H D <?@ DGF /�U & <Ibc3 N U 5 N <IH , <IQ /�KfHB<_3 DaN , D /�36U�Ha/ F <?/�5�<I@�/ U�5XH N M <=5Y/ D /

� �

��� ����� <�.A3 9 g N M W�A6< D <4S(< D � N @!� & 3 , @G/�@ - g N M WY/�@L3JH N U �(<IHBK�A D HI9

S N 5�<?H $ - D <IH R g � � H � & <?b�3 N U � H � & C > � >�� � � H � >�� � g � � H �h > j 9 j ID h k j 9 j E F�> D j 9A> jch B j 9?> j > F

> D j 9 j ID k j 9 j E H B j j 9A> jch D j 9?> j IDD F j 9 j H E F j 9?> jcj > j 9A> j D j j 9?> j IDh B D j 9 j E k E j 9?>I> j F j 9A>I> Hch j 9?> h >�E> j�h F j 9?>�D�> H j 9?> H FID j 9A> DID j 9?> � kF j E D j 9 h F h j j 9 h B=> E j 9 h D E�> j 9 hIH D j>�D k F j 9 F H E k j 9 FUE jIH j 9VB F�> H j 9 B DIE k

F > j 9 h�j B F j 9 h B D j 9 h DIB=> j 9 h UB k> D j 9 h�j j j 9 h B E=> j 9 h DIB k j 9 h F kD F j 9 h >CB k j 9 h D� E j 9 hIH FUD j 9 h E k h B D j 9 h FIF j j 9 h EID H j 9 kcj D k j 9 kckcj > j�h F j 9 k IE D j 9 F k B B j 9GF B k D j 9 FUDIE�>F j E D j 9GD j D F j 9GD k E D j 9 D� k B j 9 H > H >�D k F >�9 k > h >�9 kUH D >c9VB j D >c9 B H�j

> j 9 FIF B j 9GD�> FID j 9 D j >�E j 9GDID k F> D j 9 F B F F j 9GD h > j 9 D j�j j 9GD H FIFD F j 9 FUD F�> j 9GD F k F j 9 D h F j 9GD� H�jh B D j 9 B kUH B j 9 H�j D k j 9 DIEIB=> j 9 H B D h> j�h F j 9 kUH E j 9GEIE jIH j 9 EIE H F >c9 j D jF j E D >�9 k F F >�9GFIF� >c9VB > >c9 B E k>�D k F h 9 EIE k k 9A> => k 9GF k k 9 BIB=>

>�D > >�9A> F�> >�9VB H B >c9GF kUH >c9GD H E> D >�9A> FIE >�9VB D E >c9GF F k >c9GD� jD F >�9A> D >�9 DIE=> >c9GF� F >c9 Hch Dh B D >�9 k F F >�9� FUB >c9 DIBIB >c9GE j�h> j�h F h 9A> F� h 9 H�j h 9GF� k h 9 H�k F j E D k 9 kcj E k 9 H D k 9 D E j k 9GEUB F>�D k F De9�UB h H 9 D F j H 9 H ID f9 h�j B

k�h > h 9VB h > Ff9 k�h�h k 9 j E j> D h 9VB FUB Ff9 k FUB k 9 j E�> 5�365D F h 9 D�> D Ff9VB=>�B k 9 h B kh B D h 9 EID H Ff9�IE F k 9 D h�k U N�D> j�h F Ff9 H E E De9 H FID Be9VB hchF j E D H 9 h D D e9 H�k E H 9 E k ]YUf3JH F>�D k F > F�9VB > Df9 D >CBe9GEUB

�P�

��� � ��� <�.A< 9 deK M%M /�@ - N O S�< D � N @!� & 3 , @B/�@ - g N M WY/�@B36H N UXR <?H D H?9

R g � & <?bc3 N U & C > � >�� � >�� � g �>�3JU8R @B/�U�H O\<?@ � � H � k >�9� F F k 9?> j F h 9 E�> F H 9 k

>�/ �'$^/�Uf5 � 3J5 DBF � > , " H � B F�9� BIB j 9?> B j Ef9 j FIE h 9 C 14b%R @B/�U�H O\<?@ � � H � j 9 HIH EUBe9 k E Ff9A>�D E f9�=>

C 1eb $^/�Uf5 � 3J5 DBF � > , " H � > F F�9 H > kcj 9GD > h H 9A> > hch 9?>

� 3 DBF#N U�<�@B<IQI1 � � Q?/�AJA 9 C H DGF < M <IHBHG/ bc<=AJ<IU�b DBF 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB<IH � & <?b�3 N U , <Ibc3JU�H DGN+N K D W <?@ O N @ M& C > � >�� � 9US N D < DBF / D & C > � >�� � HBQ?/�AJ<IH , < DBD <?@ � / U�5 DGF < W[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?<^QI@ N HLH N 1c<I@ W N 36U D3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<IH � 3 DGF DGF <%U�K M+, <?@ N O^U N 5�<IH?9 >'��� g � 3JH DGF <%HLA N � <?H DTN U /�AJA D <?H D H � /�U�5 DGF 36H1c<I@BHL3 N U N O DGF <)A63 , @B/�@ - 36H=K�U�H D / , A6< / D0F 36b F U N 5�<)Q N K�U D H?9 � D � N KfAJ5 U N�D Q N M W�AJ< D < DGF <D <IH D / D /�A6A � 3 DBF8k�h U N 5f<?H?9

<�.A<".A3 2�� $&� � � ��� � ! ����� �� ! � � ��� � �����"� � $ ���(�< K�HL<�/ @B/�U�5 N M @B<?/�5 D <IH DXDGN /�UY/ A - ?< & <?b�3 N U � H#5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5&H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - 9

� U DBF < D <?H D � QIAJ3J<IU D�DBF @B<?/�5�H=/ Q?`�K�3J@L<+/�Uf5�@B<IAJ< / HB<T@B/�U�5 N M A - Q F�N HL<?U ��< - H?9=7 /�Q F�DBF @B<?/�5M < /�HLK�@B<IH DBF < <IAZ/�WfHB<?5 D 3 M <VO\@ N M DGF < ]Y@LH D /�Q?`�K�36@B< DGN:DGF < AZ/ H D @B<IAJ< / HB<�9 S�UfAJ<?HLH N DGF <I@ � 3JHL<U N�D <?5 � <?/�Q F�D <IH D K�HB<IH k�h U N 5�<?H � <?/�Q F�N O � F 3JQ F @BK�UfHi/ HB36U�bcAJ<_QIAJ3J<IU D(DBF @B<?/�5 � DGF < DBN�D /�A5Y/ D / HB3�?<+36H�> + $ � < / Q F , A N Q,�836H�>�D�� $ � <?/�Q F U N 5�< F /�Hi/ h B D > $ A N Q /�A Q?/�Q F < � / U�5< / Q F QIAJ36<?U D /�QI`�K�3J@L<?H)/�Uf5�@B<?A6< /�HL<?H�> j�jcjcj @B/�U�5 N M ��< - H?9�R F <?HL< D <?H D H)< M W F / HB3�I< DGF <M 3JHBH W <?UY/�A D - , <IQ /�KfHB< DBF <iU�K M+, <?@ N O�� < - H:/�QIQ?<?HLHB<I5 3JH H M /�AJAYQ N M W�/�@B<I5 � 3 DBF DGF < DBN�D /�AU�K M+, <?@ N O ��< - HI9R F <_]Y@BH D(D <?H D Q N M WY/�@B<IH DGF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@:3 M W�AJ< M <IU D / D 3 N U�HI9 R F <_@B<IHBK�A D H(/�@L< b�361c<IU

3JU R / , AJ< k 9GFf9VR F <=<IAZ/�W�HL<?5 D 3 M <�H F�N � H DGF / D DGF <=HB36U�bcAJ< DGF @B< / 5�<?5 M < M N @ - DBF @ N K�b F W�K D3JH F 3Jb F <?H D � O N AJA N � <?5 ,�- 5f3J@B<IQ D � /�HLH N Q?3J/ D 3 1c< � � @L3 D / , AJ<�@L< /�5fH � M < M N @ - M /�W�W <?5�/ U�5

� @B3 D / , AJ< � @L3 D <IH?9 R F < N @B5f<?@0Q N @B@B<IHBW N U�5�H DBNXDBF <)Q N M W�A6<��e3 D - N O���< - A N4N ��K�W /�Uf5�H - U �Q F @ N U�3�?/ D 3 N U Q F <?Q,��H 3JU < /�Q F Q?AJ/�HBH � � F 3JQ F /�@B<:@L< �Y<IQ D <I5 36U F 3 D /�U�5 M 3JHLH D 3 M <?HI9 ( < D <?H DDGF <+/�HLH N Q?3Z/ D 361�< M < M N @ - � 3 DGF / N U�<+<IAJ< M <IU D HB< DiDGN <��f/ M 3JU�< DGF < N 1�<?@ F < /�5�/�5f5�<?5 DBNDGF <)5�3J@L<?Q D M < M N @ - 9 � U DGF < � @B3 D < D <?H D � U N /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH F 3 D � , <IQ /�K�HL<%/�AJA /�Q?QI<?HLHB<?H @B<I`�K�3J@L<U�< D � N @%� D @B/��%Q DBN M /�36U D /�36U#HB<I`4Kf<?U D 3J/�A Q N U�HL3JH D <?UfQ - 9

� �

��� � ��� <�. J 9 g N M WY/ @B3JUfb DGF < .0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@BH?9

>�< M N @ - R - W[< R N�D /�A Ra3 M < ��3 D �(/ D < ��3 D Ra3 M < >�3JHLH(Ra3 M <� H � � � � � � H � � � H �

de36U�bcAJ<iR F @B<?/�5�<?5 Be9 FUD�> > j 9A> H h 9 kckck D=>�Df9 j.=3J@L<?Q D >�/�W�W <?5 Be9 FUD�> > j 9 jch h 9 kck > D=>�Ef9GE

> (�/ - C HLH N Q?3Z/ D 361�< Be9 F HIH > j 9A> h 9 FUD�> D=> f9 k>�< M N @ - >�/�W�W <?5 > H 9 F B De9��> k h 9GD h F B H Ef9GE(�@L3 D / , AJ< �(<?/�5�H Be9 B FUE > j 9A> D h 9 Hch D h Be9?>(�@L3 D / , AJ< (�@L3 D <IH FUDf9 jcj j j B h�k�h 9

R F < /�HBH N QI3Z/ D 361c< Q?/�Q F <�3JH HL<?U�HL3 D 3 1c< DGN�DBF <�/�Q?QI<?HBH8WY/ DLD <I@BU 9 $ A N Q,� @B<?KfHB<�3JH DGF <<��eQI<?W D 3 N U � 3 DBF /�@G/ U�5 N M /�Q?QI<?HLH%W�/ DBD <?@BU 9 g N U�Q?<IU D @G/ D <?5 /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH DBN /�O\< � <?U D @B3J<IHOP/ 1 N @X/ HBH N Q?3J/ D 3 143 D - 9 R N 5f< M N U�H D @G/ D < DGF 36H W N 3JU D � � < D <?H D8DBF < /�HLH N Q?3Z/ D 361�< /�U�5 DGF <5�36@B<?Q D M /�W�W <?5�Q / Q F < � /�U�5�Q F / U�bc< DGF <X/�HBH N QI3Z/ D 36143 D - /�Uf5 DBF < O\@B/�Q D 3 N U N O�HL<?A6<?Q D / , A6<, A N Q,��H?9 � U <?/�Q F @LK�U � DGF <(Wf@ N bc@B/ M Q FfNeN HL<?H @G/�Uf5 N M , A N Q,�4H O\@ N M DBF <:HB< D N O , A N Q,��H DGF / D/�A63JbcU DGN / W N @ D 3 N U N O DGF < A N Q /�A Q /�Q F < 9XR F < H M /�A6AJ<I@ DGF < HB< D � DBF < M N @L< N O D <?U , A N Q,��HDGF / D K�HB< DBF < HG/ M <+HLA N�D � 36AJA , < /�QIQ?<IHBHB<I5 9)R F < @B<IHBK�A D H_/�@L<)bc361�<?U 3JU ) 3JbcK�@L< k 9 k 9 R F <M N @B< DBF <aHB<IAJ<IQ D 3 N U)3JH Q N U�H D @B/�3JU�<I5 � DGF < M N @L<a/�HLH N Q?3Z/ D 36143 D - F <?AJWfH?9 � U DBF 3JH D <?H D DBF < DBN�D /�AM < M N @ - HB3�?<=36H O N K�@ D 3 M <IH DGF <=A N Q /�A Q / Q F <0HB3�?<�9�S N M N @B< DBF /�U#O N Kf@ , A N Q,��H^Q / U H F /�@L</)HBA N�D � / U�5 DBF <_W[<I@LO N @ M / U�Q?<03 M W�@ N 1c< M <?U D H DGN W�H�/ DaDBF <0O N K�@ � � / - Q?/�Q F < 9

� U R / , A6< k 9GF � M < M N @ -�M /�W�W <?5 @B<?/�5�H /�@B< k 9 h#D 3 M <?HiHBA N � <?@ DGF / U U�< D � N @!� @B<?/�5�HI9R F < F 3 D @G/ D <�36H k � A N � <I@ DBF /�U O N @ DGF < N�DBF <?@ @B<?/�5 D <IH D H , <?Q / K�HB< DBF < M < M N @ -)M / W�W[<I5.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@�AJ/�Q,��H�/�@L<?HL3J5�<IU D HL< D � , K D DGF 36H 3JH F /�@L5�A - <?U N K�b FEDGN /�QIQ N K�U D O N @ DGF <5�3 � <I@B<?UfQ?<�9 R F < D 3 M <:HLW[<IU D � F <?U DGF <i/�W�W�A63JQ / D 3 N U /�Q?QI<?HBHL<?H DBF <i5Y/ D / / O D <I@ DBF <=/�QI`�K�3J@L<5 N <?H /�Q?Q N K�U D O N @ DGF <�5�3 � <?@L<?U�QI<�9 � U�A - � F <?U DGF <=/�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U DGN K�Q F <?H DBF < , A N Q,��H 5 N <IHDGF < N W[<I@G/ D 3JU�b)H - H D < M /�Q D KY/�A6A - A N /�5 DGF <_WY/�b�<�9 R F < D 3 M <�HBW <?U D WY/�bc36U�b)3JHaHL<?U�HL3 D 361c< DBNDGF <#HB3�?< N O DBF <#H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - /�U�5 DBN�DGF < �436U�5 N Oa]YA6< H - H D < M 9 ( F <IU DGF <#H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - 36H H M / AJAJ<I@ DGF /�U DGF < W F - HB3JQ?/�A M < M N @ - � DBF < M < M N @ -�M /�WfW[<I5�HB<I@L1�<?@�Q?/�UN K D W[<I@LO N @ M DBF < N�DBF <?@ M < M N @L3J<?H � / O D <?@ DGF <#]Y@LH D A N /�5 � W�/�bc<?H)5 N U N�D U�<I<?5 DGN H � /�W 9( F <IU�WY/�b�<?H(H � /�W � 3 D 3JHaOP/�H D <I@ DBN K�HL<+/)]YAJ< N U DGF < A N Q?/�A F /�@L5 5f@B361�< DBF /�U 3 D 3JH DBN K�HL</ S�< D � N @%� ) 3JA6<_d - H D < M � S ) d � M N K�U D <I58]�AJ<=O N @ N , 143 N K�H:@B< / H N U�HI9

� �

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Ela

psed

Tim

e [s

ec]

Associativity

Choose from 100. %Choose from 50.0 %Choose from 25.0 %Choose from 12.5 %Choose from 6.25 %Choose from 3.13 %

�%������� <�.A< 9 C HBH N QI3Z/ D 361�< > < M N @ - /�U�5 g N M W < D 3 D 3 N U O N @ g /�Q F <TdeA N�D H?9

(�3 DBF AZ/ @Bbc< ]YAJ<IH � @B<?WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U N U�A N Q?/�A 5�3JH%�4H 3JH � / H D < O\K�A 9 �:<?W�A63JQ / D 3 N U / AJH N AJ3 M 3 D HDGF <�5Y/ D /�HL3�I< DGN DGF / D � F 3JQ F � 36AJA^] D N U/�HB36U�bcAJ< F / @B5 5f3JH!�;9�R F <'�V/�@B/�AJA6<?A �i3J@ D KY/�A) 36AJ< d - H D < M � � �) d � � >�E � 36H / Q N M Wf@ N M 3JHL< � 3 D @L<?`�K�36@B<?H U�< D � N @%��/�Q?QI<?HBH � , K D U N N Uf<M /�Q F 3JUf< F�N AJ5fH / AJA N O DGF <%5�/ D /f9 R F 36H M / � <?H DGF <%Uf< D � N @!� , N�DBD AJ<?Uf<?Q,� � 365�<?@ /�U�5 DGF <M / �e3 M K M ]YA6<0HB3�I<_AZ/�@Lbc<?@I9

) 3Jb�K�@B< k 9GF W�A N�D H DGF < @L<?HBKfA D H N Oi/ D <?H D)DGF / D 1�/ @B3J<IH DGF < HB3�I< N O DGF < 5�/ D /�HL< D � DGF <A N Q / D 3 N U N O DGF <^5�/ D /�]�AJ< � /�U�5+Q N M WY/�@B<IH DBF <^5�36@B<?Q D /�Uf5 M < M N @ -_M /�W�W <?5).0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@BHI9R F <)S ) d D <?H D � /�H H DGN W�W <?5/ D B > h > $ , <IQ /�K�HL<�3 D D / ��<IH#/�U<��eQ?<?HLHB3 1c< / M N K�U D%N O, /�Uf5 � 3J5 DBF / � / - O\@ N M DGF < N�DBF <?@:K�HL<?@BH N O DGF <0]YA6<0H - H D < M 9

� U R / , AJ< k 9 F � DBF < � @B3 D < D <?H D � /�H e9 h D 3 M <?HTHLA N � <?@ DGF /�U DGF < @L< /�5 D <?H D � , <IQ /�K�HL<N O H - U�Q F @ N U�3�?/ D 3 N U N 1c<I@ F <?/�5�/�U�5 /%AZ/�Q,� N O W�/�@G/�A6AJ<IAJ3JH M 36U DGF < 3 M W�AJ< M <IU D / D 3 N U 9 R F <3 M W�A6< M <?U D / D 3 N U , @ N /�5fQ /�H D H+36U�1 /�A63J5Y/ D 3 N U M <IHBHG/ bc<?H)/ U�5 � /�3 D H O N @ / Q N M W�AJ< D <%HB< DTN O/�Q,��U N � AJ<I5�b M <?U D H N U8<I1�<?@ - � @L3 D < 9 R F < 3 M WfAJ< M <?U D / D 3 N U#AZ/ Q,�4H(WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A63JH M , <?Q?/�K�HB< 3 DK�HL<?H / HL3 M W�AJ< ] �e<?5 N � U�<I@BH F 3JW�HLQ F < M < DGF / D 36HT3JUfQ /�WY/ , AJ< N OaQ?/�Q F 3JUfb � @B3 D / , A6< 5�/ D /f9C HB36U�bcA6<=U N 5�< DGF / D @B<?W < / D <?5fA - / Q?Q?<IHBHL<?H DBF <0HG/ M < , A N Q,� Q /�UfU N�D Q / Q F <_3 D , <?Q?/�K�HB< DGF <

� �

0.1

1

10

100

1000

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500

Ela

psed

Tim

e [s

ec]

Data Size [MB]

dataserver_mmap nfsdataserver_mmap pvfsdataserver_mmap local

dataserver_direct

�%������� <�. J 9 g N M W�/�@B36H N U N O S�< D � N @!�X/�U�5 .=< M /�U�5 � /�bc<?5 >�< M N @ - 9

U N 5�< F /�H DGN N , D / 3JU 3 D O\@ N M /�U�5 @B< D K�@BU 3 D DBN DGF < N � U�<I@ N U <I1�<?@ - /�QIQ?<IHBH?9 C 5�5�3 D 3 N U�/�AJA -DGF <0HB3JUfbcAJ< � @L3 D <?@aW N AJ36Q - W�@B< 1c<?U D H M KfA D 36W�AJ<�U N 5�<?H N @ DBF @B<?/�5�HaO\@ N M � @B3 D 36U�b DGN / , A N Q,�Q N U�Q?K�@L@B<IU D A - � <I1�<?U � F <?U DBF < � @B3 D <IH^5 N U N�D Q N U��Y3JQ D 9 R F <0<��fW <?Q D <I58W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI<i36U /@B<?/�A /�WfW�AJ36Q / D 3 N U 5�<?W <?U�5fH KfW N U DBF <)@G/ D 3 N N O DGF <)U�K M+, <?@ N O @L< /�5fH_/�U�5 � @B3 D <?HI9TS(U D 3JA/)U�< � .0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@a<�� D <?UfHB3 N U N 1c<I@BQ N M <IH DBF < � @B3 D <0H F�N @ D Q N M 3JUfbcH � 3 D � 3JA6A , < FfNeN 1c< DGF </�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U#5�<IHB36bcU�<?@ DBN @L<?5�KfQ?< DGF <_U�K M+, <?@ N O � @B3 D <?HI9

<�.A<".A< 2�� $&� � � ��� � ! ����� �� ! � � ��� � � � ���#��� �� U�/ WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A:H - H D < M � HLQ /�A63JU�b�3JH DBF <�W�@L3 M < M < /�HLK�@B< N O < �%Q?36<?U�Q - 9 � U & <?bc3 N U � H

M <?HBHB/�bc<_WY/�HLHB36U�b%OP/ Q?3JA63 D - � < / Q F /�5�5f3 D 3 N UY/�A[U N 5�< /�5�5�H DGF <_Q N H D�N O N U�<_H N Q,��< D Q F <IQ,� DBN<I1�<?@ - HB<?A6<?Q D Q?/�AJA 9 ( F <IU M <?HBHB/�bc<IH�/ @B<_3JUfO\@L<?`�K�<IU D � DGF 36H:Q N H D 36HaU�<?b�AJ3Jbc/ , AJ< 9R N /�UY/�A - I< F�N � � <?A6A DBF < .0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ W <?@LO N @ M H � 3 DGF M N @B<8U N 5�<?H � � < D <?H D#DGF <

.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ 5�3J@L<?Q D QIAZ/�HLH � 1 /�@ - 3JU�b DGF <%U�K M+, <?@ N OaU N 5�<?H /�U�5 DGF < U�K M+, <?@ N O DGF @B< / 5�HW <?@(U N 5f<�9aR F < A N Q /�A Q?/�Q F <THL3�I<T@B< M / 3JU�H:Q N U�H D /�U D / Dih B D > $ � N @ N U�< `�KY/�@ D <?@ N O DGF <> + $�5Y/ D /%HB< D 9 (�< @B<IQ N @L5 DGF < <IAZ/�W�HL<?5 D 3 M <0O N @ DGF < D <?H D / U�5�5�3 1e365�< ,�- DBF <TU�K MT, <I@

� �

N O DBF @B<?/�5�H � U N 5�<IH � /�U�5 /�QIQ?<IHBHB<IH DGN N , D /�3JU DGF < / 1�<?@G/ bc< , A N Q,� /�Q?QI<?HBH D 3 M <�9�R F 3JH+36HDGF <=3JU�1c<I@BHL< N O DGF < DBN�D / A[U�K M+, <?@ N O , A N Q,��H DGN K�Q F <?5XW <?@^HL<?Q N U�5 9�) 36bcK�@B< k 9 B H F�N � H DGF <@B<IHBK�A D HI9 C 5�5f3JU�b Q?AJ36<?U D H � � 3 DBF M N @B<_U N 5�<?H N @ DGF @L< /�5fH�W <?@(U N 5�< � @B<I5�K�QI<?H DBF <T/ 1�<?@G/ bc<D 3 M < W <?@ , A N Q,� , K D U N�D AJ3JUf< /�@LA - 9 � 5�<?/�AJA - � 3JU�QI@B< / HB3JUfb O\@ N M D � N#DGN O N K�@iQIAJ3J<IU D H � N K�A655�<IQ?@B<?/�HB< DBF < D 3 M < O\@ N M > h�j � H DBN D j � HI9 � U DBF 3JH D <?H D / 5�5�3JUfb D � N U N 5�<IH , @B36U�bcH DGF </�QIQ?<?HLH D 3 M < DGN E h 9 j � H?9 C 5�5�3JUfb D � N#DBF @B<?/�5�H=36U�H D < /�5 - 36<?AJ5fH �>c9 F � HI9=R F @L<?< DGF @B< / 5�H/�@L< U N D , < DLD <I@ DGF /�U D � N , <?Q?/�K�HB< DGF <I@B< /�@B< N U�A - D � N g � S�HiW <?@(U N 5�<�9 � U , N�DGF U N 5f</�U�5 DBF @B<?/�5#5�3 M <IU�HB3 N U�H � DGF <0/ M N K�U D N O HLQ /�A63JU�b 3JH AJ3 M 3 D <?5 ,�- DBF <iOP/�Q D DGF / D <?/�Q F U N 5f<F /�H N U�A - N U�<�.0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@I9&R F <�HB36U�bcA6< .0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@ , <?Q N M <?H M N @L< N O0/ , N�DLD AJ<IU�<?Q,�

� F <IU DGF < U�K MT, <I@ N O QIAJ3J<IU D Habc@ N � HI9

<�.A<". J ��� #� ��� � � $&��� � $ � % � �� � � ��� � � �"� � �R F <Xbc@G/ U4KfAZ/�@L3 D - � DGN�D /�A HL3�I< � /�U�5 / M N K�U D+N O M < M N @ - Q?/�Q F <I5 /�A6H N 36U �YK�<IU�Q?< @LK�U

D 3 M < 9 g F /�U�bc36U�b DBF < , A N Q,� HL3�?<TQ F /�U�bc<IH DGF < M 36HBH(W[<IUY/�A D - / U�5 DGF < F 3 D @G/ D <�9 C AJ/�@Bbc<, A N Q,��Q N 1c<I@BH M N @B< N O DGF < DGN�D /�A 5Y/ D /�HLWY/�Q?< 9 R F <?@B< O N @B< � / O\< D Q F N O(/�AZ/�@Lbc< , A N Q,� 36H

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

1 2 3 4

Tim

e P

er B

lock

Acc

ess

[us]

Threads per Node

direct 2 nodesdirect 4 nodesdirect 8 nodes

direct 16 nodesdirect 32 nodes

�%��� � �� <�. � 9 .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@ � <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< � 3 DGF � U�QI@B<?/�HB<I5 S N 5�< /�U�5XR F @L< /�5 g N K�U D HI9

� �

M N @B<�A63�� <?A - DBN HB<I@L143JQI< / 5�5�3 D 3 N U�/�A F 3 D H?9�R F < W <?UY/�A D - O N @#AZ/�@Lbc< , A N Q,�4H 36H DGF / D#DGF <D @B/�U�H M 3 D)D 3 M < 3JH A N U�bc<I@?9 (�< /�UY/�A - ?< DGF <8< � <?Q D ,�- D <IH D 3JU�b DGF <8.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ 5�3J@L<?Q D

� 3 DBF 1 /�@L3J<I5 , A N Q,�THB3�I<?HI9�(�<(<?UY/ , AJ< & <?bc3 N U � H 5f3Z/�bcU N H D 3JQ?H DBN M < /�HLK�@B< DGF < F 3 D @G/ D <i/ U�5M 3JHBH(W <?UY/�A D - 9 ( < F�N AJ5 DBF < DGN�D /�A 5Y/ D /%HB3�?< DBN > + $�/�U�5 DBF <TA N Q?/�A Q / Q F < DGN#h B D > $, K D 1 /�@ - DGF <aU4K M+, <I@ N O , A N Q,��H DBN_N , D / 3JU)5�3 � <I@B<?U D , A N Q,� HB3�?<?HI9VR F 36H D <?H D M N 5�<?A6HV5Y/ D /Q N�F <?@L<?U�QI< , <IQ /�K�HL< > jcj�jcj @B/�U�5 N M /�QIQ?<IHBHB<IH M N @B<iQ N M W�AJ< D <?A - Q N 1c<I@a/TH M /�A6AJ<I@ U�K MT, <I@N O ��< - H M / 5�<=O\@ N M AZ/�@Lbc<?@ , A N Q,�4HI9R / , AJ< k 9 B+H F�N � H DGF <0@B<?HLK�A D H N O DGF < D <IH D /�A N U�b � 3 DGF /)W�@B<I5�3JQ D <I5 M 3JHLH D 3 M < 9VR F <?@L<

3JH /_H D @ N U�b Q N @L@B<IAZ/ D 3 N U , < D � <?<IU M 36HBH W[<IUY/�A D - /�U�5 DGN�D /�A D <IH D D 3 M <a3JU DBF 3JH D <IH D , <IQ /�K�HL<M 3JHBHL<?H85 N M 3JUY/ D <�9 R F < M 36HBHXW <?UY/�A D - 3JH8/�W�Wf@ N �e3 M / D <IA - / H D /�@ D K�W�Q N H D N O h�h�j � HW�A6K�H DBF < , A N Q,��HB3�?<85�36143J5f<?5 ,�- /�U / 1c<?@B/�bc< D @G/ U�HLO\<I@ , / U�5 � 3J5 DGF N O+F j > , " HI9�R F <, /�Uf5 � 3J5 DBF 36H�A N � <?@ DGF /�U DBF / D M <?/�HBK�@L<?5 3JU�HLK , HL<?Q D 3 N U k 9 k 9A> , <IQ /�KfHB<T36U DBF 3JH D <IH D /�AJAN O DGF <(U N 5�<IH /�@B<aQ N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3JU�bi/ D DGF <aHB/ M < D 3 M < � N O D <IU Q N M W[< D 36U�biO N @ /�QIQ?<IHBH DGN0DGF <HG/ M < , A N Q,�8HL<?@ 1e36U�b U N 5�<?HI9 & 3���< � 3JHB< DGF <+H D /�@ D K�W D 3 M < 36H F 36b F <?@ DGF / U DGF < M < / HBK�@L<?5AZ/ D <?UfQ -8, <IQ /�KfHB< N O DBF < D 3 M < @L<?`�K�3J@L<?5�O N @ D � N M <IHBHG/ bc<?H0/ U�5 DGF <+3JU D <I@L1�<?U�36U�b#HB<I@L143JQI<5�<IAZ/ - 9 R N HBK M%M /�@B3�?< DBF < @L<?HLK�A D H � AZ/�@Lbc<?@ , A N Q,�4H - 3J<IAJ5 /%A N U�bc<I@a@BK�U D 3 M < , <?Q?/�K�HL< DGF <3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<_36U F 3 D W <?@BQI<?U D / bc<_5 N <IH:U N�D Q N 1c<I@ DBF <_<�� D @B/%Q N H D(N O D @B/�U�H M 3 DBD 36U�b , 3 D HI9R F <=5�36@B<IQ D M /�W�W <?5 M < M N @ - bc@B/�W F 36U ) 36bcK�@B< k 9 F M / ��<IH 3 D QIAJ< / @ DBF / D DBF @ N K�b F W�K D

/�U�5 M < M N @ - HB3�I<0/�@L<=U N�D H D @ N U�bcA - Q N @B@L<?AJ/ D <I5 9�� U DGF / D^D <IH D M 3JHLHB<IH^5 N M 3JUY/ D <�/�U�5 DGF <@BKfU D 3 M < � /�HT5f< D <I@ M 3JU�<I5 ,�- DGF < U�K M+, <?@ N O:/�QIQ?<IHBHB<IH)/�U�5 DGF < M 36HBH D 3 M < 9 $ <IQ /�KfHB<

��� � ��� <�. � 9 d F /�@L<?5 >�< M N @ - + @B/�U�K�AZ/�@L3 D - 9

de3�?< �0< - H R N�D / A Ra3 M < �(3 D �(/ D < R > 3JHBH � @B<?5f3JQ D <?5� $ - D <IH � � H � � � � � � H � � � H �h B D F�>�E F kcj F h 9 h B F k 9 k FUB hch Be9?>�D h�h Df9?> jB=> h h j E H >CB h h 9 kck D k 9GF jch h�kck 9 H D h k�h 9 h�j> j�h F > j F UB H D h 9 B F B k 9 Hch j h B Df9 k E h FIF�9 F�>h j F B h F h � h 9GE jck Ff9A>�E k h E k 9 FUD h D�f9 hF j EID h D h > FIF k 9?> ID B49A>I> k�h Df9 j k > H 9GDUB=>�E h > k > jIHch k 9GE�IE De9 E h > F�> H 9 h B F�>CBe9 k >>�D k F DUBIB k D Be9 B D H > j 9A> D D jck 9?> D=> j 9GD h

� �

DGF < F 3 D(D 3 M < 3JH M K�Q F H M / AJAJ<I@ DGF /�U DGF < M 3JHLH�W <?U�/�A D - � � <+<��eW <?Q DiDGF / D 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB36U�b DGF <F 3 D @G/ D < � 3JAJA bc@B<?/ D A - 36U�Q?@L< /�HL< W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI<�9R F < F 3 D @G/ D <XQ /�U , < M N 5f<?AJ<I5 ,�- /�HLHBK M 3JUfb�Q N M W�AJ< D <?A - @G/ U�5 N M / Q?Q?<IHBH � N 1�<?@ /

A N U�b @BK�U N U � U N 5�<?HI9 � U / 1�<?@G/ bc<Q>�� /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH � 36AJA F 3 D 36U DBF < @B<IHB365�<?U D HB< D / U�5��� � > � �� /�QIQ?<IHBHB<IH � 36AJA KfHB< DGF <0A N Q?/�A Q / Q F <�9 � O DBF <_U N U � @B<IHB3J5f<?U D /�Q?QI<?HBHL<?H � � � ����� 3JA6A F 3 D � � F <I@B<���� 3JH DGF < HB3�I< N O DBF < A N Q / A Q / Q F <�/ U�5 ��3JH DBF < DGN�D /�A HL3�?< N O DGF <5Y/ D /f9+R F < D 3 M <THBW <?U D /�QIQ?<?HLHB36U�b DBF < 5�3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - 36H DGF <IU @L<?AZ/ D <?5 DBN<?`�KY/ D 3 N U k 9A>c9

� ��� � �� ��� >�* � � >

�� ������ * � � � � �� ��� � � >

���� � � ���� � � k 9A> �

� O DBF <�5Y/ D /�HB3�I<�3JH�]��f<I5 � � < Q?/�U�3JU�QI@B<?/�HB< DGF <�U4K M+, <I@ N O%U N 5�<?H DGN 36U�Q?@L< /�HL<DGF @ N K�b F W�K D 9 C 5�5f3JU�b�U N 5�<IH � 3JA6A 5�36143J5f< DGF < 5Y/ D / M N @B<%]YU�<?A - � M / ��3JU�b DGF <#@B<IHB3J5f<?U DHB< D H�H M /�AJA6<?@ � O\@L<?<I3JU�b K�W�HLWY/�Q?< O N @ DGF < A N Q /�A Q?/�Q F < 9 � U DGF < AJ3 M 3 D � DBF < A N Q /�A Q?/�Q F < � 36AJAN Q?Q?KfW - /�AJA N O DGF <_A N Q / A M < M N @ - HBW�/�Q?< � /�U�5 DGF <0U N 5�<IH � 3JAJA , < / , AJ< DBN Q /�Q F < / H M K�Q FN O DGF < � N @!��36U�b HL< D /�H DGF < F /�@B5 � /�@L< / AJA N � HI9R F <X/�HLHBK M W D 3 N U N O:Q N M WfAJ< D <?A - @B/�U�5 N M /�QIQ?<IHBH M N D 361 / D <?H DGF 36H+5�3JHLQ?K�HLHB3 N U 9 � U /

@B<?/�A /�W�W�A63JQ / D 3 N U DBF <#5Y/ D /�/ Q?Q?<IHBH)WY/ DBD <I@BU�H � 3JA6A N O D <?U , < M N @L< Q NcF <I@B<?U D 9�R F < M N @B<Q N�F <?@L<?U D � DGF < M N @B< DGF <:A N Q?/�AYQ /�Q F < � 3JA6A , <�/ , AJ<:Q N U D /�3JU DGF <�5Y/ D / DGF / D 3JH U�<I<?5�<I5 � / U�5DGF < QIA N HL<?@ DGF < DBN�D / A D 3 M < � 36AJA Q N M < DBN%DBF <_U�K M+, <?@ N O / Q?Q?<IHBHL<?H M K�A D 3JW�A63J<?5 ,�- DGF < F 3 DD 3 M < 9

������� ����� �

��� � $)��� � ����� ��� � � ����� ������� ��� �

� � � ����� � ��� ����(��� � ��

JK.#- .#- * #��� ��� � � ��"��� ���R F <:U�< � 5�3JH D @L3 , K D <?5)@L<?U�5�<I@B<I@ 36U F <?@L3 D H /=HBK�W <?@ 143JH N @," � N @!� <?@LH H D @BK�Q D K�@L<(/�U�5 3 M /�bc<

HBW�/�Q?<%WY/�@B/�AJA6<?AJ36H M O\@ N M � � ��/ - 9)R F <%HLK�W <?@L1436H N @_3JU D <?@G/ Q D H � 3 DGF DGF < K�HL<?@ /�U�5 /�HBHL3JbcUfHW�3 �f<IA D / H!��H?9 R F < � N @%��<?@LH KfW[5Y/ D < DGF < 3 M /�bc< � 3 DGF @L<?U�5�<I@B<I5 D 36AJ<IH?9 � U DBF <XQ?A6K�H D <?@ �DGF < HLK�W <?@L1436H N @(/�U�5 � N @!� <?@BHi/�@B<_Q N M WfAJ< D <0W�@ N bc@G/ M H^@LK�U�U�36U�b N U8HL<?WY/ @G/ D < � g � H?9 R F <HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @+W�@ N bc@G/ M Q N U�HL3JH D H N O N Uf< N @ M N @L< 5�36HBW�AJ/ - DBF @B<?/�5�H)/�Uf5 /�Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / DGN @DGF @B< / 5 9�R F < � N @%��<?@)Wf@ N bc@B/ M H Q N U�HB36H D)N O N U�< N @ M N @B<%@B<IU�5�<?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H)/ U�5�/�Q N M �M K�Uf3JQ / DGN @I9 ) 3Jb�K�@B< F�9?> H F�N � H DGF < H D @BK�Q D K�@L< N O DBF < Uf< � W�@ N bc@G/ M 9 � U DGF < 5�3Z/ bc@G/ M �@ N K�U�5�<I5 , N �e<?H)@B<IW�@B<IHB<IU D DBF @B<?/�5�H N O(<��f<IQ?K D 3 N U / U�5�HB`�KY/�@L< , N �e<?H)@L<?W�@L<?HL<?U D Q?AZ/ HBHB<IH

� 3 DBF�N K DaDBF @B<?/�5�HI9 R F <T/�@L@ N � H:@B<IW�@B<IHB<?U D�DGF < � N � N O 36UfO N @ M / D 3 N U 5�K�@B36U�b @B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�bf9C A6A U N 5�<?H U�<?<I5 DBN H F / @B< DBF <0@B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b)H D / D <�9 ) N @ 3JU�H D /�U�QI< � � F <?U DGF <iK�HB<I@ M N 1c<IH

DGF < 143J< � W N 36U D � /�A6A � N @%��<?@LH F / 1c< DBN @B<IU�5�<I@ O\@ N M DBF <�U�< � W N HL3 D 3 N U 9 � U � � ��/ - � /�AJADGF @B< / 5�H F / 1c< /�QIQ?<IHBH DGN H D / D < 3JUfO N @ M / D 3 N U 36UH F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - 9 � U DGF <�5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5W�@ N bc@G/ M � <?/�Q F U N 5f< F /�H /�A N Q / A Q N W - N O DGF < H D / D <�9�R N ��<I<?W DGF < H D / D < Q N U�HL3JH D <?U D �N U�A - DGF <�HLK�W[<I@L143JH N @ 36H /�AJA N � <?5 DGN M /���<(K�W[5�/ D <IH?9 R F <(<��eQ?<IW D 3 N U#36H Wf3 �e<?A D / H!�)@B<IHBK�A D H �� F 36Q FXDBF < � N @!� <?@LH(b�<?U�<I@G/ D <�9 R F <0H D / D <i3JH^5�3 143J5�<I5 3JU DGNTDBF @B<I<0bc@ N K�W�H , / HB<?5XK�W N U DGF <F�N � N O D <?U DGF <01 /�@B3J/ , A6<?H:Q F /�U�b�<�9:deK , HB<IQ D 3 N U)Ff9A>c9 h 5�<?HLQ?@B3 , <IH�36U 5f< D / 3JA , N�DGF � F - / U�5F�N � DBF <_H F / @B<?5 H D / D < � /�H:5�36143J5f<?5 9

� U ) 36bcK�@L< F�9A> � DBF < HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @ <��e<IQ?K D / , AJ< @BKfU�H N U U N 5�<�?<I@ N 9 R F < HLK�W <?@L1436H N @ H D /�@ D H< / Q F O\@B/ M < ,�- , @ N /�5�Q?/�H D 3JU�b DBF <:H D / D <(/�U�5 /�HLHB3Jb�U�3JU�b036U�3 D 3Z/�A D / H!��H?9 C^D DGF <(<IU�5 N O <?/�Q FO\@G/ M < � DGF <05�3JHLW�AZ/ - K�W[5�/ D <IH DGF <0H D / D < � 3 DGF KfHB<?@:36U�W�K D / U�5XW N H D H DBF <0@B<IU�5�<?@L<?583 M /�bc<

� �

NODE 0

NODE 1

Scene

.

.

.

.

.

.

worker_dirt.exe

supervisor_dirt.exe

SceneState

FrameState

TaskState

.

.

.

SceneState

FrameState

TaskState

...Task0

Task1

Task3

TaskN

Image

Display

AuxilliaryDisplay N

Communicator

Communicator

Renderer 0

Renderer N

ViewManager

TaskManager

�%����� � J .#- 9 .=3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 �(/ - R @B/�Q?36U�b � @ N bc@B/ M d D @BK�Q D K�@L<�9

, K � <?@I9�� U DBF < M < / U D 3 M < � DGF <�Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ DGN @ DGF @L< /�5 @B<?QI<?3 1c<?H @B<?HLK�A D H / U�5#/�HLHB36bcU�H U�< �D / H!��H?9 R F <_Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / DGN @^5 N <IH DBF 3JH ,�- Q?/�AJA63JU�b)/)@L<?bc36H D <I@B<I5 5�36HBW�AJ/ - Q?AJ/�HBH M < DBF�N 5 9C K��e36AJ3Z/ @ - 5�3JHLW�AZ/ - Ha/�@L< N W D 3 N UY/ A 9 � , � <IQ D Ha3JU DGF <0HBQ?<IU�< DGF / D /�AJA N � /�5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A;K�HB<I@

Q N U D @ N A QI@B<?/ D < DGF <?3J@ N � U�5�3JHLW�AZ/ - H?9 ) N @036U�H D /�U�Q?< � 3JH N HBK�@ OP/�Q?<)1 N AJK M <?H0QI@B< / D < 1 N A6K M <5�36HBW�AJ/ - H DGF / D /�AJA N � DGF <iK�HB<I@ DGN Q F / U�bc< DBF <=3JH N 1�/ AJK�< 9VR F <0/�K �f36AJ3J/�@ - 5f3JHBWfAZ/ - H � N @!� ,�-K�W 5Y/ D 3JU�b N W D 3 N U�/�A 5Y/ D / � 3 DBF 3JU DGF <_O\@B/ M <=H D / D < 9

� U ) 36bcK�@B< Ff9A> � / � N @%��<?@ <��e<?QIK D / , AJ< @LK�U�H N UTU N 5�< N U�< 9 R F < Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / DGN @ @L<?Q?<I361�<?HO\@G/ M < H D / D <#K�W 5Y/ D <?H)/ U�5 D /�H%��/ HBHB36bcU M <?U D HI9 R F < �i3J< � >�/�UY/�bc<I@+Q?AJ/�HBHTW�AZ/�QI<?H HBQ?<IU�</�U�5 O\@B/ M <#H D / D <#KfW[5Y/ D <?H)36U DGN A N Q?/�A H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - 9 R F <8R /�H%�e>�/�UY/�bc<I@)W�@ N Q?<IHBHL<?HD / H!��/�HBHL3JbcU M <IU D H?9 � D D @B36<?H DGN � <?<?W / , /�Q,��A N b N O � N @%��36U / D /�H%� `�K�<IK�<#H N8DGF / DTDGF <

� �

@B<IU�5�<I@ DGF @L< /�5fH � 3JA6A U N�D=F /21�< DGN � /�3 D O N @�/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D H?9�R F <+`�K�<IK�< ��<I<?W�H DBF <T@L<?U�5�<I@DGF @B< / 5�H , KfH - � F 3JA6< D /�H%�4H=/�@B< , <I3JU�b D @B/�U�H O\<?@B@L<?5 9 �:<?U�5f<?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H � / 3 D�N U DBF < `�K�<IK�</�U�5#/ DGN M 3JQ?/�AJA - 5f<?`�K�<?Kf< D /�H%�4H O\@ N M 3 D 9VR F <�@B<?Uf5�<?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H^5f@G/ � < /�Q F#D 3JA6<i/�QIQ N @L5�3JUfbDGN+DBF <=@L<?U�5�<I@aH D / D <0/ U�5 DGF <iQ N U D <IU D H N O DGF <0A N Q /�A;Q N W - N O DGF <iHBQ?<IU�<�9 �:<?U�5f<?@ DGF @B< / 5�H3 M W�A63JQ?3 D A - @B<?`�K�<IH D /�5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A � N @%� � 3 DBF < 1c<?@ - @B< D K�@BUf<?5 D /�H!�;9 deK , HL<?Q D 3 N U F�9?>c9 k5�36HBQ?KfHBHB<IH DBF < D /�H%� /�HBHL3JbcU M <IU D H D @B/ D <Ib - 3JUX5�< D /�36A 9

JK.#- .A3 ������ �"� � � �(�������g N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U)U�<I<?5�H / M N U�b0O\K�U�Q D 3 N UY/�A�KfU�3 D H 36U � � �(/ - bcK�365�<?5 DGF <:5�<IHB36bcU N O DGF <

5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5�@G/ - D @B/�Q?<I@?9 � UfHBW <?Q D 3 N U�<��eW N HB<?5�HB<I1�<?@B/�A D - W <?H N O^H F /�@B<I5 5Y/ D /f9 � U M N H DQ / HB<?H � DBF <XH F /�@L<?5 5Y/ D / � /�H @L<IO\<?@L<?U�QI<?5 DGF @ N K�b F / Q?AJ/�HBH M < M+, <?@)36U N U�< O\K�U�Q D 3 N UY/�AK�U�3 D_DGF / D Q N U D /�3JUf<?5 /8W N 3JU D <I@ DBN /�U N�DGF <I@ O\KfU�Q D 3 N UY/ A K�U�3 D 9#R F < U�< � W�@ N bc@B/ M K�HL<?H/�5�3 � <?@L<?U D M <IQ F /�U�36H M , <IQ /�K�HL< DBF < U N 5�<?HXQ / U�U N�D 5�36@B<IQ D A - @L<IO\<?@L<?U�QI< <?/�Q F&N�DGF <I@ � H/�5�5f@B<?HLH�HLWY/�QI<�9

� U � � �(/ - � DGF < H F /�@L<?5�5�/ D /)Q N U�HB36H D H N O DGF <_O N AJA N � 36U�b �

� deQI<?U�< � R F 3JH Q N U D / 3JU�H /�AJA N O DGF <iH F /�W[<IH 36U DBF <(1436@ D K�/�A � N @LAJ5 9 R F < � N @!� <?@LH^@B<?/�5DBF <_HBQ?<IU�< � /�Uf5 DBF <_HBQ?<IU�< 3JHa@G/ @B<?A - � @L3 DBD <?U DGN 9

� � M /�bc< � R F 3JH Q N U�HL3JH D H N O D � N , K � <?@BH N O W�3 �e<?AJH � N U�<i36H 5�36HBW�AJ/ - <?5 � F 3JA6< DBF < N DGF <I@36H ]�AJAJ<I5 9 R F < � N @!� <?@LH � @B3 D < DGN:DGF < 3 M /�bc< /�Uf5 DGF < 5�36HBW�AJ/ - H � /�W�H DBF < D � N , K � <I@BHI9

� C HBHB36bcU M <?U D�� Kf<?K�< � R F 3JH Q N U D / 3JU�H DGF <%W�3 �f<IA D /�H%� /�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D H?9 R F <%5�3JHLW�AZ/ -]YA6AJH DGF <)`�K�<IK�<%/ D0DGF < , <?b�3JU�U�36U�b N O < 1c<?@ - O\@G/ M < � /�U�5 DGF < � N @%��<I@BH_5�@G/ 3JU D / H!��HO\@ N M 3 D 5�K�@B36U�b DGF <0O\@B/ M < 9

� �:<?U�5f<?@B36U�b � W D 3 N U�H � d N M <:<��f/ M W�A6<?H /�@B< DGF <�H F /�5 N � /�A6b N @B3 DGF M � DBF <(@G/ - 5�<?W DGFA63 M 3 D � / U�5X/ D 3 M <�H D / M W#O N @^/�U�3 M / D <?5 H F /�W <?HI9 R F <IHB< /�@L<��<IW DaDGF @ N K�b FfN K DaDGF <W�@ N bc@B/ M�� M /�U - /�@L<#O N K�U�5�36U DGF < HLQ?<IU�<8/�U�5 DGF < 5f3JHBWfAZ/ - N , � <?Q D H?9 ( F <?U DGF <K�HL<?@a36U D <?@B/�Q D H � 3 DGF#DBF <=W�@ N bc@B/ M DBF <05�36HBW�AJ/ - K�W 5Y/ D <?H DGF <?HB< 9 R F < � N @%��<I@BH:@B<?/�5DBF < M / U�5 @L<?U�5f<?@(/�Q?Q N @B5f3JU�bcA - 9

�-�

� g / M <?@B/ � R F 3JH:@B<IW�@B<IHB<?U D H DGF < 143J< � W N 3JU D O\@ N M � F 3JQ FXDGF < @B<IU�5�<I@ DBF @B<?/�5�H:5�@G/ �DBF <_HBQ?<IU�<�9

� � , � <IQ D �(<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b � W D 3 N U�H � R F <?HL< 1 /�@B3J/ , A6<?H:Q N U D @ N A DGF <T/�WfW[<?/�@G/�UfQ?< N O /)O\< �N , � <?Q D Ha3JU DBF <0HBQI<?U�< 9 R F <0HBQI<?U�<_Q?@L< / D <?H DBF < M � DBF <0/�K��e36AJ3Z/ @ - 5�36HBW�AJ/ - H FfN AJ5 / U�5M N 5f36O - DGF < M /�U�5 DGF < � N @!� <?@LH�@L< /�5 DGF < M 9

� �(/ - d D / D 36H D 3JQ?H �aC H DGF < � N @!��<I@BH0@B/ - D @B/�Q?<TW�3 �e<?A6H � DGF < - � <?<?W H D / D 3JH D 3JQIHiHBKfQ F / HDBF <)U�K M+, <?@ N O @G/ - H D @G/ Q?<?5 /�U�5 DBF <)U�K M+, <?@ /�U�5 ��3JU�5 N O N , � <IQ D H D <?H D <?5 9)R F <

� N @!� <?@LH � @L3 D < /�Uf5 DBF <_5�3JHLW�AZ/ - @B< / 5�H DBF <?HL<�9

� � @ N Q?<IHBH N @=d D / D 3JH D 3JQIH � ( F <?U�< 1c<I@=/ � N @%��<I@(]YUf3JH F <?H�/ D /�H!� � 3 D @L<?Q N @B5�H DGF < D 3 M <�9R F <T5�3JHLW�AZ/ - Q /�U�@L< /�5 / U�5 5�3JHLW�AZ/ - DGF <?HB< D 3 M < H D / M W�H DBN 3JUf5�3JQ?/ D < DGF <)/ M N KfU DN O A N /�5 3 M+, /�AZ/�UfQ?<�9

� U DBF <X5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 W�@ N b�@G/ M � H D / D < N , � <IQ D H%<?UfQ /�W�HLK�AZ/ D < M N H D N O DBF <XH F / @B<?5 3JU �O N @ M / D 3 N U 9%7 1�<?@ - U N 5�< ��<I<?W�H)/XQ N W - N O DGF <%H D / D < N , � <IQ D H 36U A N Q?/�AVH F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ -

� F <I@B< /�AJA @L<?U�5f<?@ DGF @L< /�5fH�Q?/�U�/ Q?Q?<IHBH DGF < M 9 R F < HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @:K�W[5�/ D <IH(3 D H M /�H D <?@:Q N W -N O DGF <T1 /�@B3J/ , AJ<IH � /�U�5 , @ N /�5�Q?/�H D H DGF < M / D=DBF < DBN W N O < /�Q F O\@B/ M < 90R F < H F / @B<?5 H D / D <3JHa5f36143J5�<I5X3JU DGN)DGF @B<?<_bc@ N K�W�H , / HB<?5 N U DGF <_@B/ D < / D � F 36Q F8DBF <_5Y/ D / Q F /�U�bc< 9R F <�deQ?<IU�<2d D / D <�Q N U D /�3JUfH / AJA N O DGF < 1 /�@L3Z/ , AJ<?H DBF / D @B< M / 3JU�Q N U�H D /�U D / O D <?@ 36U�3 �

D 3J/�AJ3� / D 3 N U 9 R N Q N U�HB<I@L1c<�Uf< D � N @!�&@B<IH N K�@LQ?<IH�5�K�@L3JU�b @B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b � DBF <�deQI<?U�< d D / D < 36HN U�A - D @G/�U�H M 3 DBD <?5�5�K�@L3JU�b�3JUf3 D 3J/�AJ3� / D 3 N U 9 � DBF <?@ 1 /�@B3J/ , A6<?H�Q F / U�bc< <I1c<I@ - O\@B/ M < N @HBW N @B/�5�3JQ?/�AJA - � D - W�36Q /�A6A - 36U @L<?HBW N U�HL< DGN DGF <�K�HB<I@ � , K D N U�A - Q F /�U�bc<�3JU DGF < D 3 M < , < D � <I<?UO\@G/ M <IH?9 R F < )Y@G/ M <2d D / D < F�N A65�Ha/�A6A N O DGF <?HB<01 /�@L3Z/ , A6<?HI9VR F <_R / H!�ed D / D <_@B<IW�@B<IHB<?U D H DGF <D / H!�X/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D `�K�<IK�< � � F 36Q F Q F /�Ufbc<?H�<I1c<I@ - D 3 M <_/ � N @!� <?@i@L<?QI<?361�<?Hi/�U�58Q N M W�AJ< D <IH/ W�3 �e<?A D /�H!�;9 R F < R /�H!�ed D / D <�3JH8/ H D / D 36Q�QIAZ/�HLH � 3 DGF M < DGFfN 5�H DBF / DXD @B/�U�H M 3 D / U�5@B<IQ?<I361c<036U�5�3 1e365�KY/�A D / H!��H?9 deK , HB<?Q D 3 N U�F�9A>�9 k 5�36HBQIK�HBHL<?H:W�3 �e<IA D /�H%� D @G/�U�HLW N @ D M N @B<(O\K�AJA - 9) 36bcK�@B<5Ff9 h W�@L<?HB<IU D H�/�U N 1�<?@L1436< � N O H F /�@B36U�b 3JU DGF <_5�36H D @B3 , K D <I58Wf@ N bc@B/ M 9.=K�@B36U�b=36U�3 D 3Z/�A63� / D 3 N U � DGF <^HBK�W <?@ 143JH N @ /�U�5 DGF < � N @%��<I@BH M K�H D /�bc@L<?<^K�W N U DBF <a3JU�3 D 3J/�A

deQI<?U�< d D / D <0/�U�5 )Y@G/ M <2d D / D < 9VR F <�HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @ F /�H Q N M%M / U�5 A63JU�<(/�@LbcK M <?U D H � / U�5 DGF <

� N @!� <?@ F /�HV/�@BbcK M <IU D H DGN / U�5)3JUfO N @ M / D 3 N U0O\@ N M DGF < HBQ?<IU�<^]YA6<�9�$ <IO N @L< DGF < ]Y@BH D O\@G/ M < �

� �

SupervisorWorker 1

SceneState

1x per run

FrameState

1x per frame

RayStatReq

RayStatReply

1x per frame, on demand

TaskState

Many per frame

Local Task Queue

Tile

1x per run

Image Buffer

Global Work Queue

1x per run

�%��� � �� JK.A3 9 � UfO N @ M / D 3 N UXd F / @B3JUfb C M N U�b S N 5�<?HI9

DGF <%HLK�W <?@L1436H N @_@B<I`�K�<?H D H DGF < H D / D <)O\@ N M DBF <)]Y@BH D � N @%��<?@I9 ( F <?U DGF < � N @!� <?@_@B<IW�AJ36<?H �DGF <�HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ K�W 5Y/ D <?H 3 D H N � UQ N W - � 3 DGF DGF < 3JUfO N @ M / D 3 N U O\@ N M DBF <�HLQ?<?Uf<�9&R F <HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @V/�WfW�AJ36<?H K�HB<I@VHBW <?QI36]Y<I5+bcA N , /�A�Q N M M /�U�5 AJ36U�< /�@Bb�K M <IU D HV/ U�5 , @ N /�5�Q?/�H D H DGF <K�W 5Y/ D <?5�HLQ?<IU�<#/�Uf5 O\@G/ M < H D / D < DBN <I1�<?@ - � N @%��<?@I9 C^D DBF 3JH_W N 3JU D � DBF < � N @%��<I@BH+A6< /�@LU

� F / D ��3JU�5 N O=/�Q?QI<?AJ<I@G/ D 3 N U H D @BK�Q D K�@L< DBN K�HL<�/ U�5 W�@L<?W�@ N QI<?HLH DGF < HLQ?<?Uf<�/�QIQ N @L5�3JU�b�A -, <IO N @L< 5f@G/ � 3JU�b DBF <0]Y@BH D O\@B/ M <�9R F <TO\@B/ M <_H D / D <TQ N U D /�3JUfH�H N M < 3 D < M H DBF / D Q F /�U�b�<+3JUfO\@L<?`�K�<IU D A - 9(R F <THBKfW[<I@L143JH N @

D @B/�U�H M 3 D H DGF < M <I1�<?@ - O\@B/ M < O N @ D � N @L< /�H N U�H?9 ) 3J@LH D � DBF < <��eW[<IU�HB3 1c< W�/�@ D N O DBF < D @G/ U�HLO\<I@3JH 3JU�3 D 3J/ D 3 N U 9 R F <aQ N H DVN OYHB<IU�5�36U�b_/�O\< � /�5f5�3 D 3 N UY/ A ,�- D <IH 3JH 3JU�Q N U�HB<I`�K�<?U D 3J/�AfQ N M WY/�@B<I5

� 3 DBF DGF <iH D /�@ D K�W D 3 M <�9 d4<?Q N U�5 � � <?<?Wf3JU�b DBF < D @G/�U�H O\<?@ HB3�I<iQ N U�H D /�U D /�A6A N � H DBF <iHL<?U�5f<?@/�U�5)@L<?QI<?361�<?@ DBN K�HB<:/=HL3JU�bcA6< H - H D < M Q /�A6A�/�Uf5 /21 N 3J5)Q N U�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A�<��e<IQ?K D 3 N U 9 R F / D , <?3JUfbHG/ 3J5 � DGF <�5Y/ D / 36H /�AJ36bcU�<?5 DBN , < M N @B<:Q N M W�/�Q D 9VR F <)Y@B/ M < d D / D < D @B/�U�HLO\<I@ 36H >CB h ,�- D <?H

� 3 DBF�N K D /�K��e3JA63Z/�@ - 5�/ D /f9-( F <?U DBF <:HBQ?<IU�<:@B<I`4Kf3J@B<IH /�K��e3JA63Z/�@ - 5�3JHLW�AZ/ - H � DBF < )Y@G/ M <2d D / D <H D @BK�Q D K�@L< b�@ N � H DBN / Q?Q N M M N 5�/ D < DBF < <�� D @B/%5Y/ D /f9 .=K�@B36U�b / HB3JUfbcAJ<0@LK�U � 3 D HaHB3�I<_5 N <IHU N�D Q F /�U�bc< 9R F <)d4Q?<?Uf<2d D / D <T/�U�5 )Y@B/ M < d D / D <_Q?AJ/�HBHL<?H=/ @B< U N�D 3J5�<IU D 3JQ?/�A 3JU DGF < HLK�W[<I@L143JH N @=/ U�5

� N @!� <?@ W�@ N b�@G/ M H?9Vd N M < N O DBF <�H D @LK�Q D K�@B<IH DGF / D DGF <(H D / D <:QIAZ/�HLHB<?H DGN K�Q F /�@L<aU N�D AJ36U ��<I5

� �

DGN , N�DGF W�@ N b�@G/ M H?9 ) N @(36U�H D /�U�QI< � DGF < HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @i<��f<IQ?K D / , A6<TU�<I<?5�Hi/ 1 N AJK M <_5�3JHLW�AZ/ -Q?AJ/�HBH DBN QI@B<?/ D < /�K��e3JA63Z/�@ - � 36U�5 N � H0O N @01 N A6K M <?H?9 R F < � N @!� <?@ 5 N <IH_U N�D H D @B3JQ D A - U�<I<?5DGF <)Q?AZ/ HBH � N @ DGF < � 36U�5 N � A63 , @B/�@B36<?H DGF / D 3 D 5�<IW[<IU�5�H_K�W N U � H N DBF < � N @%��<I@ <��e<?Q?K D / , A6<3JH_U N D AJ3JU ��<?5 DGN 3 D 9 R F < Q N 5f< DBN F /�U�5�A6<%H D / D < K�W[5�/ D <IH F / H DBN , < 5�3 � <?@L<?U D , <IQ /�K�HL<N O DBF 3JHI9iR F < � N @%��<?@=/�U�5 DGF <THBKfW[<I@L143JH N @=5�< ]YU�< DBF <+3JU D <?@LOP/ Q?< DBN DGF <+H D / D < N , � <?Q D H036U/ H F /�@L<?5 F <?/�5�<I@�]YA6< � , K D K�HB< 5�3 � <?@L<?U D H N K�@BQI< ]YA6<?H DGN 3 M W�AJ< M <IU D:DBF < 36U D <?@ OP/�Q?< 9:R F <d�deQI<?U�< d D / D <�9 Q?Q /�Uf58d )Y@G/ M <2d D / D < 9 QIQi]YA6<?H^3 M W�A6< M <?U D DGF <iH D / D <03JU DGF <0HLK�W <?@L1436H N @a/ U�5DGF < (�deQI<?U�< d D / D <�9 Q?Q / U�5'( )Y@G/ M < d D / D <�9 Q?Q_]YAJ<IH�5 N H N%DGF < � N @!� <?@?9 C WfW[<IU�5�3 �'$&AJ36H D HDGF < Q N U D <IU D H N O DBF <_H F /�@L<?5 H D / D <_H D @BK�Q D K�@L<?H?9R F <0H F /�@B<I5 H D / D <iH D @LK�Q D K�@B<IH(5 N U N�D Q N U D / 3JU /�A6A N O DGF <�H F / @B<?5X5Y/ D /f9�) N @ 3JU�H D /�UfQ?< �

3 D 36H M N @L< < �%Q?36<?U D DGN @B<?WfAJ3JQ?/ D < DBF < HBQ?<IU�< 5�/ D / , /�HB< , <?Q / K�HB< 3 D 3JH AJ/�@Bbc< / U�5 KfU�Q F /�U�b�3JU�b�9R F <^@L<?W�A63JQ?/ D 3 N U F /�W�W <?U�H � F <?U DBF < HLK�W[<I@L143JH N @ Wf@ N bc@B/ M HBWY/ � U�H DGF < � N @%��<?@ W�@ N b�@G/ M H?9R @G/�36AJ3JUfb Q N M M /�U�5 AJ3JUf<=/�@LbcK M <?U D H^b�361c<i< /�Q F � N @!� <?@(/THBQI<?U�<0]YA6<=UY/ M <=/ U�5XHBQ?<IU�<=]YA6<HBW <?QI36]YQ W�/�@G/ M < D <?@LH?9 7 / Q F � N @!� <?@ DGF <?U Q?@B<?/ D <IH 3 D H N � U_Q N W - N O DGF < HLQ?<?Uf< � N U�A - H F / @B3JUfb3 D 3JU D <I@BUY/ AJA - / M N U�b�@B<?Uf5�<?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H?9�R N�F /�U�5�A6< /�U�3 M / D <?5 HLQ?<IU�<?H � DBF < )Y@G/ M <2d D / D <Q N U D /�3JUfH / D 3 M <^H D / M W 9VR F < �=36< � >�/ UY/�bc<I@ bc361�<?H DGF < D 3 M <^H D / M W DBN_DBF <aHBQI<?U�< � � F 3JQ F/�U�3 M / D <?H DGF < M N 1436U�b N , � <?Q D H � 3 DBF 3JU 9

� U Q N U D @B/�H DTDGN�DGF <#5�K�W�A63JQ?/ D <I5 HBQI<?U�< � 36H M N @B<#<��%Q?3J<IU D+DGN F / 1�< N U�<#Q N W - N O DGF <3 M /�bc< /�U�5 N O DGF < � N @%� `�K�<IK�<�9 � U � � ��/ - � < / Q F � N @%��<I@03JU�HL<?@ D H=Q N M W�K D <?5 Wf3 �e<?A6Hi3JU DBNDGF < 3 M /�bc< , /�Q,� , K � <I@X/�U�5&/ DGN M 36Q /�A6A - @L< D @L3J< 1c<?HXU�< � / HBHB36bcU M <?U D H#O\@ N M DGF < � N @!�`�K�<?Kf<�9 � U DGF < 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5�@G/ - D @G/�QI<?@ � DGF < HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @ � <?<IW�H , N�DBF H D @LK�Q D K�@B<IH�/ U�5K�W 5Y/ D <?H DGF < M O N @ DGF <(@B< M N D < � N @!��<I@BHI9 d4K , HB<IQ D 3 N U�F�9A>�9 k <��eW�AJ/�3JUfH FfN � DGF <:HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @/�U�5 � N @!� <?@BH Q N4N W[<I@G/ D < DGN 3JHBHLK�< D /�H%�4H O\@ N M DGF <(HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ � H � N @!�)`�K�<IK�<=/ U�5 DBN WfAZ/�QI<Q N M W�A6< D <?5XW�3 �e<IA @B<?HLK�A D H:3JU DGN)DGF < 3 M / bc<�9

� U � � ��/ - � DBF < � N @%��<?@LH05�3J@L<?Q D A - K�W[5�/ D < bcA N , /�AJA - 143JHL3 , A6<_H D / D 3JH D 36Q?H?9 � U DGF < Q?A6K�H D <?@ �DGF 3JH)@B<I`�K�3J@L<?H <��eW�A63JQ?3 D Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ D 3 N U 9�R N @B<I5�K�QI< DBF <XU�< D � N @%� A N / 5 � @G/ - H D / D 3JH D 3JQIH/�@L< D @G/�UfH M 3 DBD <?5 N UfA - � F <IU�/ Q D 3 1 / D <I5 ,�- DBF < K�HB<I@ � /�U�5�W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @ H D / D 3JH D 3JQIH_/�@B< U N DD @B/�U�H M 3 DBD <I5+/ D /�A6A 9 ��/ - H D / D 36H D 3JQ?H D @B/�Q,� DGF < U4K M+, <I@ N OY@B/ - H D @G/ Q?<?5+/�U�5 DBF < U�K M+, <?@ N ON , � <IQ D H D <IH D <?5 9 ( F <IU�<?UY/ , AJ<I5 � DGF < HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @ , @ N /�5�Q?/�H D H=/ @G/ - H D / D 3JH D 36Q @L<?`�K�<IH D / DDGF < DGN W N O <?/�Q F O\@B/ M <�9V7 /�Q F @B<IU�5�<I@B<?@:@L<?Q N @B5�Ha3 D H N � U8@G/ - H D / D 3JH D 3JQIH � F 36AJ<=3 D @B<IU�5�<?@LH

� �

W�3 �f<IAJHI9VR F < � N @!� <?@BH N U�A - D @B/�U�H M 3 D DGF <?3J@ Q N KfU D H DGN+DBF <iHLK�W <?@L1436H N @a36U @B<IHBW N U�HL< DGN+DGF <@G/ - H D / D 3JH D 3JQ0@L<?`�K�<IH D 9

� @ N Q?<?HLH N @iH D / D 3JH D 36Q?H M < / HBK�@L<TA N /�5 3 M+, /�AJ/�U�QI< � ,�- @L<?Q N @B5�36U�b DBF <TQ N M WfAJ< D 3 N U D 3 M <N O <I1�<?@ - D /�H%� 9 � U*� � �(/ - � DGF < � N @%��<?@LHT/ 5�5 DGF <I3J@ D 3 M <+H D / M WfH DGN / bcA N , /�A H D @LK�Q D K�@B< 9� U DBF <:5�3JH D @L3 , K D <?5%W�@ N bc@G/ M � DGF <(HLK�W <?@L1436H N @ D / � <?H N 1�<?@ DGF 36H @B<?HLW N U�HB3 , 3JA63 D - � ,�- M / ��3JUfb/ D 3 M <(H D / M W � F <IU�<I1�<?@a3 D @L<?Q?<I361�<?H:/T@L<?HBKfA D 9 R F <=HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @^U�<I<?5�H DBN ��U N � , N�DBF DGF <@G/ U � N O DBF <:HB<IU�5�3JUfbTU N 5�<�/�U�5 DGF <(@G/�U � N O DBF <(@B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b DGF @L< /�5 N U DGF <(U N 5�< DBN M / � <DGF < D 3 M <IH D / M W 9 R F < U N 5f< @B/�U �X3JH:3 M W�A63JQ?3 D 36U DGF < H N Q,� < D 5�<IHBQI@B3JW DGN @ � , K D�DBF < DBF @B<?/�5@G/ U � F /�H DBN , < 3JU�QIAJK�5f<?5 � 3 DGF DBF < D /�H!�X@B<IHBK�A D HI9=R N ��<?<IW DGF < M <IHBHG/ bc<+HB3�?< Q N U�H D /�U D �DGF <�@L<?HBKfA D M <IHBHG/ bc<�Q N U D /�36U�H DGF < DGF @B< / 5 @G/ U �)<I1�<?U � F <IU DGF <�H D / D 3JH D 3JQIH / @B< D K�@LU�<?5 N � 9R F < HBK�W <?@ 143JH N @ � 36AJA[U N�D Q / AJA bc< DBD 3 M < N O\5Y/ - � � KfU�AJ<IHBH:W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @:H D / D 3JH D 36Q?H(/�@B< N U 9

JK.#- .A< ��� $�� �'$)$ ������� � � �R / H!�#/ HBHB36bcU M <?U D 36H^/TQI@BK�QI3Z/�A 5�< D <?@ M 36UY/�U D^N O W[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?< � 3 D M K�H D , <�OP/�H D /�U�5 3 D

H FfN K�AJ5X< 1c<?UfA - 5�36H D @L3 , K D < DGF < � N @%�4A N /�5 9 C HBHL3JbcU M <?U D , <?bc36U�H � 3 DBF8DBF <_HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @I9 C^DDGF < DBN W N O^< / Q F O\@G/ M < � DBF < HLK�W <?@L1436H N @_]YAJA6H03 D H N � U � N @%� `�K�<?K�< /�U�5 DGF <IU�HB<IU�5�HT/�U3JUf3 D 3J/�A D /�H%� DGN < / Q F @B<IU�5�<I@B<?@I9 C H_< /�Q F @B<IU�5�<?@L<?@0]YU�36H F <IHT/ D /�H!� � 3 D HL<?U�5�H DGF <%Wf3 �e<?A6HDGN�DBF < HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ � � F 36Q F @L<?QI<?361�<?H DGF < @B<?HLK�A D H)5�3J@L<?Q D A - 36U DBN�DGF < 3 M / bc< , K � <I@?9�R F <HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @)W N W�H DGF <#U�<�� D)D /�H!��O\@ N M 3 D H � N @!� `4Kf<?K�<8/�U�5 / HBHB36bcU�H+3 DTDBN�DGF < � N @%��<?@I9R F < HBK�W <?@ 143JH N @ D @G/�UfHB3 D 3 N UfH DGN)DGF < Uf<�� D O\@B/ M < � F <?U 3 D @L<?Q?<I361�<?H DGF <_AZ/ H DaD / H!�;9

� U�/ 5 - UY/ M 3JQT/�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D H D @B/ D <Ib - A63���< DGF 36H N U�< � DGF < D /�H%��/�A6A N Q / D 3 N UXQ F / U�bc<?H DBNbc3 1c<%<I1c<I@ - W�@ N QI<?HBH N @ DBF <%HG/ M <%/ M N K�U D N O � N @!�;9 > N @L< HLW[<IQ?3 ]YQ /�A6A - � 3 D 3JH /85�< M / U�55�@L361c<IU H D @G/ D <?b - 3JU � F 3JQ F�DGF < � N @!��<I@BH0@L<?`�K�<?H D /�5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A � N @!� DGN , /�AZ/�UfQ?< DBF <+A N /�5 9R F 36H 3 M W�A63J<?H DBF / D D /�H%�4H M K�H D , < , N DGF / HBHB36bcU�<I5)/�U�5+@L< D K�@BU�<I5 9 d D / D 36Q / HBHB36bcU M <?U D 5 N <IHU N�D Q F / U�bc< DGF < D / H!�+5�36H D @B3 , K D 3 N U+O\@ N M O\@G/ M < DGN O\@G/ M < 9 R F < � N @!��<I@BH �4U N � � F / D D 36AJ<?HDGF < - F / 1c< DBN D @G/�QI<�/�Uf5 H N DGF < HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @%5 N <?H U N�D U�<?<I5 DGN�D @G/ U�H M 3 D /�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU DM <?HBHB/�bc<IH?9 R F 3JH � 3JA6A 3 M W�@ N 1c< DGF < O\@B/ M < @B/ D < KfU�AJ<IHBH N U�<XW�@ N Q?<IHBH N @ F /�W�W <?U�H DGN , <H D K�Q,� � 3 DBF DGN4N M K�Q F � N @%� 9R F < /�HLHB36bcU M <?U D bc@B/�U�K�AZ/ @B3 D - 36H N @ DGF�N b N UY/�A DBN DGF < /�HBHL3JbcU M <IU D H D @G/ D <?b - 9 & /�@Bb�<

/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D HX@B<I5�K�Q?< Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / D 3 N U N 1c<?@ F < / 5 ,�- / M N @ D 3�?36U�b Q N U D @ N A /�Uf5�AJ/ D <IU�Q -

� �

N 1c<I@ F <?/�5�W[<I@TW�3 �e<?A 9'& /�@Bb�< D /�H!��H+Q?/�U Q N U�HB36H D+N O:AZ/�@Lbc< D 3JA6<?H N OaW�3 �e<?AJH N @ N O M K�A D 36W�AJ<D 36AJ<IH#HB<IU D 3JU�/�HL3JU�bcA6< D @B/�U�H O\<?@?9 S(UfO N @ D K�UY/ D <?A - � AZ/�@Lbc< /�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D H8/�@B< HLK�HBQI<?W D 3 , A6<DGN A N /�5 3 M+, /�AJ/�U�QI<�9�(�3 DGF H M /�A6A / HBHB36bcU M <?U D H � M N @L< � N @!� <?@LH%Q NeN W[<I@G/ D < N U�5�3 � QIK�A DW N @ D 3 N U�H N O DBF <_3 M /�bc<�9R F <%5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 @G/ - D @G/�QI<?@ F /�H / �Y<��f3 , AJ< / HBHB36bcU M <?U D HBQ F < M < DBF / D0DGF <)K�HB<I@ Q?/�U

Q N U D @ N A 9 � D 5�<IOP/�KfA D H DGN � � ��/ - � H�5�< M /�U�5 5�@B3 1c<IU�H D @G/ D <?b - 9 ) N @ , < DBD <I@iA N /�5 , /�AJ/�U�Q?36U�b �� < K�HL< / F <IK�@B36H D 3JQ DGF / D /�HLHB3Jb�U�HTAJ/�@Bbc< D /�H!��HT]Y@LH D � bc@B/�5�KY/�A6A - @L<?5�KfQ?3JUfb DGF < HB3�?<%K�U D 3JADGF <i<?Uf5 N O DGF <�O\@G/ M < 9VR F <iUf< � W�@ N bc@G/ M /�5f5�H DBF @B<I<iQ / WY/ , 36AJ3 D 3J<IH?9 ) 3J@LH D � DGF <iK�HL<?@^Q?/�U5 - UY/ M 3JQ?/�AJA - Q F / U�bc< DBF <iHL3�I< N O DGF <(3JU�5f36143J5�K�/�A D 36AJ<?H DBF / D M / � <�KfW DGF < D / H!��H?9 de<IQ N U�5 �DGF < KfHB<?@(Q / U 5 - UY/ M 36Q /�A6A - Q F /�U�b�< DBF <_HBAJ365�3JUfb)bc@G/�U�K�AJ/�@B3 D - W�/�@G/ M < D <?@ � � F 3JQ F Q N U D @ N A6HDGF < U4K M+, <I@ N O D 3JA6<?H+W <?@ D /�H!�;9 C^D N U�< <�� D @L< M < � DGF < HLK�W <?@L1436H N @)5�3 143J5�<IH DGF < HLQ?@B<I<?U3JU DBN <?`�KY/�AaW N @ D 3 N U�H+/�Uf5�bc361�<?H)< / Q F � N @%��<?@ N Uf< D /�H%�;9 C^D)DBF < N�DGF <?@+<�� D @B< M < � <?/�Q FD / H!��Q /�U Q N U D /�36U /�HL3JU�b�AJ< D 3JA6<�9XR F 36@B5 � DBF < KfHB<?@TQ /�U�Q F / U�bc< , < D � <?<IU 5 - U�/ M 36Q / U�5H D / D 36Qa/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D 9 � U H D / D 3JQa/�HLHB36bcU M <?U D � DBF < � N @!��<I@BH Q N U�H D /�U D A - @B<IQ - Q?A6< DBF <^W�@L<I143 N K�HO\@G/ M <�� H:/�HLHB36bcU M <?U D HI9

) N @ DGF < 5 - UY/ M 3JQ HBQ F < M < � / O D <?@ D @B/�U�H M 3 DBD 36U�b DGF < )Y@G/ M <2d D / D < � DGF < HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ bc3 1c<IHN U�<=/�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D^DBN < / Q F � N @%��<?@I9 R F <0bc@G/ U4KfAZ/�@L3 D - WY/�@B/ M < D <I@ 5�< D <I@ M 3JU�<IH DGF <0U�K MT, <I@N O D 36AJ<?Hi3JU DGF <%/�HLHB36bcU M <?U D0D /�H%��H?9 & / @Bbc<I@=1�/ AJK�<IH0W�@ N 5�K�QI<%H M / AJAJ<I@ D / H!��H?9 R F <%3JU�3 D 3J/�AD / H!��Ha/�A � / - H^Q N U D /�3JU / D A6< /�H D N U�< D 3JAJ<:O N @ < /�Q F @L<?U�5f<?@ DBF @B<?/�5 9 R F 36H <?UfHBK�@L<?H DGF / D D � NN @ M N @B< @B<?Uf5�<?@ DGF @L< /�5�H � 3JAJA U N�D H - U�Q F @ N U�3�I< N U /�QIQ?<IHBH DBN HB36U�bcA - /�HBHL3JbcU�<I5 D /�H!��H?9 � UDGF < � N @%��<I@ � DGF < R /�H!�4>�/ UY/�bc<I@)@B<?QI<?3 1c<?H DGF < D /�H%� � /�Uf5 DGF <IU HLW�AJ3 D H+3 D 36U DBN HBK , D /�H%�4H �N U�< HLK , D / H!��W <?@X@B<IU�5�<?@L<?@I9 � O DGF < 3JUf3 D 3J/�A D /�H%�Q N U D /�3JU�<I5 M N @L< DGF /�U N U�< D 3JAJ<�W[<I@@B<IU�5�<I@B<?@ � H N M < N O DGF < HLK , D / H!��H � 3JAJA /�AJH N Q N U D /�3JU M KfA D 36W�AJ< D 36AJ<?HI9 R F <%R /�H%�e>�/�UY/�bc<I@/ DBN M 36Q /�A6A - <?U�`�K�<IK�<?H0HLK , D /�H!��H N U DBN DGF < � N @!� <?@ � H0A N Q?/�A � N @!�X`�K�<?K�< 9i> < /�U � F 36AJ< � DGF <@B<IU�5�<I@ DGF @L< /�5�H � /�3 D+DGN / DBN M 3JQ / AJA - 5�<?`�K�<IK�<XHBK , D /�H!��HI9 (�< KfHB< D � N HL< M /�W F�N @B<?H DBNW�@ N�D <IQ D /�QIQ?<?HLH DBN0DGF <a`�K�<IK�< � N U�<^O N @V/21 /�36AZ/ , 3JAJ3 D - � /�U�5 DBF < N�DGF <I@VO N @ /�QIQ?<IHBH?9 ) 3JbcK�@L<%F�9 k3JA6AJK�H D @B/ D <IH D /�H%� /�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU DaDGN / U N 5�< � 3 DGF D � N @B<IU�5�<I@ DBF @B<?/�5�H?9

� U D <?@LUY/�A6A - � < /�Q F @B<IU�5�<I@ DGF @L< /�5 F /�H)/ , K � <?@ O N @ D /�H!��@B<IHBK�A D H?9 R F < , K � <?@BH F /21�<HBW�/�Q?<aO N @ /iO\< � D 3JAJ<IH � 3 DGF+DGF <?3J@ / HBH N Q?3J/ D <I5 F < / 5�<?@LH?9 R F <a@L<?U�5�<I@B<I@ Q N M W�K D <IH /�U�5 DGF <?UWY/�Q,��H DGF @L<?< ,�- D < � + $ Wf3 �e<?A6HV3JU DGN0DBF < , K � <?@I9 ( F <?U DGF <(A N Q?/�A , K � <I@V]YAJA6HVK�W � N @ � F <?U

� �

Renderer 1

Tile

Task 1

Renderer 2

TaskManager

SubTask 1

SubTask 2Local Task Queue

SubTask 2

SubTask 1

supervisor worker

Tile Tile Tile Tile

Tile Tile

Tile Tile Tile

Tile Tile

Tile Tile Tile

Image

�%� ��� �� JK. < 9 . - UY/ M 3JQ=R /�H%� C HBHL3JbcU M <IU D 9

DGF < DBF @B<?/�5 ]YUf3JH F <?H+/ AJA N O DGF < D 36AJ<?H_36U DBF < D /�H!� � DBF <%@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@THL<?U�5fH DGF < , K � <?@ , /�Q,�DGN DGF <=HLK�W <?@L1436H N @I9 R F <=HB<IU�5XK�HB<IH:/+HB<?Uf5 M HLb�� � H - H D < M Q?/�AJA DGF / D WY/�Q,��H M KfA D 36W�AJ< D 3JAJ<IH �/�U�58Q N U D @ N A F < /�5�<I@BH � 3JU DGN / HB3JUfbcAJ<=Uf< D � N @!� N W <?@B/ D 3 N U 9R F <�HLK�W <?@L1436H N @%@B<IQ?<?3 1c<IH#< /�Q F D 36AJ< 3JU DGF < D / H!��3JU D Kf@BU 9R F <�HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ KfHB<?H /

@B<IQI1 M HBb�� � H - H D < M Q?/�AJA DGN @L<?QI<?361�< HBQ / U�AJ3JUf<?H 5f3J@B<IQ D A - 3JU DGN�DBF <�3 M /�b�< , K � <?@I9�R F <HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ D @L< / D HT<?/�Q F D /�H%��/ H+/�@L<?`�K�<?H D O N @+/ U N�DGF <?@+/ HBHB36bcU M <?U D 9 R F 3JH <?A63 M 3JUY/ D <?HDGF < U�<I<?58O N @:<��eW�AJ36Q?3 D @B<?`�K�<IH D M <IHBHG/ bc<?H(O\@ N M DBF < � N @%��<I@BH?9aR F < HLK�W[<I@L143JH N @(HB<?Uf5�H DGF <U�<�� D /�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D / O D <I@ @L< /�5f3JU�b DGF <:]�@BH D D /�H!�+36U DGF < D 36AJ< � � 3 DGF)DBF <:b N /�A N O F / 143JU�b � N @!�/ 1 /�3JAJ/ , AJ<(O N @ DGF < @L<?U�5f<?@B<I@ ,�- DBF < D 3 M <03 D ]YU�36H F <IH�HL<?U�5�36U�b DGF <_@L<?H D�N O DGF < D 3JAJ<IH?9R F <)H D / D 36Q " 5 - U�/ M 36Q HL<?A6<?Q D 3 N U � D 36AJ< HB3�?<)/�Uf5 bc@G/�U�K�AJ/�@B3 D - Q N U D @ N A6H=/�@L<+WY/�@ D=N O DGF <

)Y@G/ M <2d D / D <�9ER F < )Y@G/ M < d D / D <�K�W 5Y/ D < F /�W�W <?UfHX/ D#DGF < DGN W N O <?/�Q F O\@G/ M < � � F 3JQ F<?UfHBK�@L<?H DBF / DTDBF < � N @%��<?@LH)/�U�5 DGF < HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @T/�A � / - H+/�bc@L<?< N U DBF < HL3�?< N O DBF < D /�H!�M <?HBHB/�bc<IH?9

) N @)H D / D 36QX/�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D � DBF < � N @!��<I@BH%Q N U D 3JU�K N K�HLA - @L<?Q - QIAJ< DGF < A N Q /�A D /�H%� `�K�<?K�< 9( F <IU�<I1�<?@^/0@L<?U�5�<I@B<I@ 5f<?`�K�<?Kf<?H^/ D /�H!� � DGF < D /�H!�+`�K�<IK�<(Q N W�36<?H DBF < D /�H%� N U DGN / , /�Q,��K�W`�K�<?Kf<�9�� U 5 - U�/ M 36Q M N 5�< � DGF < � N @!� <?@BH 5�<?A6< D < DBF <?36@ , /�Q,��K�W `4Kf<?K�<IH^/ D DGF < DBN W N O <?/�Q F

� �

O\@G/ M < 9 � U H D / D 3JQ M N 5f< � DGF < - H � /�W DBF <:O\K�AJA , /�Q,��K�W#`�K�<?Kf< � 3 DBF%DBF <:< M W D - /�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D`�K�<?Kf< 3JU�H D < / 5 9�R F 3JH#<IAJ3 M 36UY/ D <IH%/�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D M <?HLHG/�b�<?H � - < D H D 3JAJA�/�A6A N � H H N M <�A N / 5, /�AJ/�U�QI3JU�b�90R F < / HBHB36bcU M <?U D H D /�@ D H03JU / , /�AZ/�UfQ?<?5 H D / D < , <IQ /�KfHB< 3 D 3JH DBF <)@B<IHBK�A D0N O /W�@L<I143 N KfH 5�< M / U�5�5�@L361�<?U O\@B/ M < � , K D N 1c<?@ D 3 M <%/�H DGF < 143J< � W N 36U D / U�5�HLQ?<?Uf< Q F /�Ufbc<DGF <�A N /�5 � 3JA6A , <IQ N M <:K�U , /�AJ/�U�Q?<I5 9�( F <IU 3 D 5 N <IH � D � N N @ M N @L<:@B<?Uf5�<?@ DGF @L< /�5fH � 3 DGF 36U< / Q F U N 5�<_Q / U Q NeN W <?@B/ D < DBN Q N M W�AJ< D < DGF < H D / D 3JQ0HL< D(N O D /�H%�4H�/�HLHB3Jb�U�<?5 DGN)DGF < U N 5�< 9

( F <?U DGF < D 36AJ<?H_/ @B<%H M /�AJA / U�5 DBF < , N�DLD AJ<IU�<?Q,� 36H_U�< D � N @!� AJ/ D <IU�Q - � H D / D 36Q%/�HBHL3JbcU �M <?U D H Q / U Uf< /�@LA - 5 N K , A6< DGF < O\@G/ M <V@B/ D < 9Vd D / D 3JQ /�HLHB36bcU M <?U D Q /�U /�A6H N 3 M W�@ N 1�< M < M N @ -Q N�F <?@L<?U�QI<�9 $ <?Q?/�K�HB< /+U N 5�< N U�A - W�@ N QI<?HLHB<?HM>�� � DBF N O DGF <03 M /�b�< � 3 D U�<I<?5�H(AJ<IHBH N O DGF <HBQI<?U�<85Y/ D / N 1�<?@%/�HL<?`�K�<IU�Q?< N O�O\@B/ M <?H%/�U�5 Q /�U , < DBD <?@ K�HL< DBF < M < M N @ - F 3J<?@B/�@BQ F - 9& /�@Bb�< D /�H%��H HB<?Uf5 M /�U - D 36AJ<?H � 3 DBFEN U�< D @G/�U�H M 36HBHL3 N U�/�U�5E@B<I5�K�QI<�Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U5�<IAZ/ - 9 & /�@Lbc< D 3JA6<?H0/ @B< /�UY/ A N b N K�H � 3 D=D / ��<IH O\< � <I@_AZ/�@Lbc< D 36AJ<?H DGN Q N M W�A6< D < / U 3 M /�b�<�97 /�Q F WY/�@B/ M < D <I@ @L<?W�@L<?HL<?U D H / D @G/�5f< N � , < D � <I<?U A N � <?@ Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / D 3 N UT/�Uf5 F 3Jb F <?@ A N / 53 MT, /�AZ/ U�Q?< 9�R F <#KfHB<?@)Q?/�U Q N U D @ N A DGF <?HB< DBF @ N K�b F�N K D /�HB<IHBHL3 N U /�Uf5 � � 3 DBF W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @H D / D 36H D 3JQ?H � ]YU�5 DBF < , <?H D HB< DLD 36U�bcH+36U D <?@B/�Q D 361c<IA - 9 C U /�A6b N @L3 DGF M DGF / D 5 N <?H DBF 3JH)/ K DGN��M / D 36Q /�A6A - 3JH:A6<IO D O N @^O\K D K�@L< @L<?HL< /�@LQ F 9

� � � � � � � � �(�<^/�UY/�A - I< DBF < OP/�Q DGN @LH DGF / D 36U �YK�<IU�Q?< DBF < O\@B/ M < @G/ D < N O DGF <^5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5+@G/ - D @B/�Q?<I@

,�- W <?@LO N @ M 3JU�b_/0HB<I@B36<?H N O , <IU�Q F M /�@!��HI9 C AJA D <?H D H � <?@B<(Q N U�5�K�Q D <?5 N U DGF <:HB/ M <aQIAJK�H D <I@DGF / D � / H 5f<?HBQI@B3 , <I5�36U HB<?Q D 3 N U k 9 k 9T7 /�Q F D <?H D_F /�H N U�<)HLK�W <?@L1436H N @_/�Uf5 K�HL<?H / D M N H Dk > � N @!��<I@BHI9R F < D <?H D H 5�3JHLQ /�@L5 > j 3JUf3 D 3J/�A O\@G/ M <?H%/�U�5 @B<IQ N @L5 DBF < <IAZ/�WfHB<?5 D 3 M < O N @DGF <)U�<�� D > jcj O\@G/ M <?HI9 .=36HBQ?/�@B5�36U�b DBF <T]Y@LH D0D <?U O\@G/ M <?H�3JbcU N @B<IH=H D /�@ D K�W Q N H D0DGN M N @B</�QIQ?K�@B/ D <IA - 5�< M N U�H D @G/ D < DBF <)W[<I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< 5�K�@B36U�b /�U 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361�<+HB<IHBHB3 N U 9 ( <)@B<?W < / D< / Q F8D <?H D(DGF @B<?< D 3 M <?H:/�U�5 D / ��< DGF < / 1c<I@G/�b�<�9

JK.A3".#- 0 � ��� � * � #% � ���(��� �

R F < HBW <?<?5 N O DGF < 36U D <?@LQ N U�Uf<?Q D 3 N U�OP/ , @L3JQ N U /�WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A M / Q F 3JU�<�36H /�Q?@B3 D 36Q /�A5�< D <?@ M 36UY/�U D N O W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI<�9 S�< D � N @%�%HLW[<I<?5 F /�H D � N /�HBW <?Q D H?9�& / D <?U�Q - 3JH / M < / HBK�@L<

� �

N O DBF < M 3JU�3 M K M D 3 M < DGF / D 3 D(D / � <?H DBN H D /�@ D / D @G/�U�H O\<?@I9$^/�Uf5 � 3J5 DBF 3JH�/ M < /�HLK�@B< N ODGF < / M N KfU D:N O 5Y/ D /)W[<I@:K�U�3 DaD 3 M < DGF / DaDGF <_Q F / U�U�<?A Q?/�U Q?/�@B@ - 9R N M <?/�HBK�@L< DBF < , / U�5 � 3J5 DGF � � <#KfHB<#/ HB3JUfbcAJ< � N @!� <?@)/�Uf5 AJ< D DBF < D 3JA6<%HL3�I< <?`�KY/ A

DGF <%3 M / bc<+@B<IH N A6K D 3 N U 9)R N <IAJ3 M 36UY/ D < Q N M W�K D / D 3 N U D 3 M <TO\@ N M DBF < @B<?HLK�A D � � <%@B<IH D @L3JQ DDGF < � N @!��<I@ DGN @L< D Kf@BU , AZ/ U � @L<?HLK�A D H^3 M%M <I5�3Z/ D <?A - 3JUfH D <?/�5 N O D @G/�QI3JU�b+@B/ - HI9�(�3 DGF#DBF <?HL<Q N U�5�3 D 3 N UfH � < /�Q F O\@B/ M < @B<I`�K�3J@L<?H DBF @B<I<+5Y/ D / D @B/�U�HLO\<I@BH ��/ );@B/ M <2d D / D < K�W 5Y/ D < � / D /�H!�/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D � /�U�5�/%Wf3 �e<?A @L<?HBKfA D @B<IW�A - 9 R F < )Y@G/ M <2d D / D < � D / H!�X/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D � /�U�58@B<IHBK�A DF <?/�5�<?@ DGN bc< DGF <I@ D /���<+>�E D ,�- D <?H � / U�5 DGF <^W�3 �e<IAf@B<IHBK�A D H D / ��< DGF @L<?< ,�- D <IH W[<I@VW�3 �e<IA 9 R F <]Y@LH DiD � N#D @B/�U�H O\<?@BHi/�@B< H F�N @ D H N /�H DGF < @B<?H N AJK D 3 N U 36U�Q?@L< /�HL<?H DBF < O\@B/ M < D 3 M < , <?Q N M <IH5 N M 3JU�/ D <I5 ,�- , /�U�5 � 365 DGF 9�( <i5f< D <I@ M 3JU�< DGF < , /�U�5 � 3J5 DBF ,�- 5�3 143J5�36U�b DBF <iU�K M+, <?@ N O,�- D <?H W <?@VO\@B/ M < ,�- DGF < M < / HBK�@L<?5 D 3 M < W[<I@VO\@G/ M <�9 R / , AJ< F�9?>aH FfN � H DBF / D � 36U DGF <aAJ3 M 3 D �3 D D /���<?H > h U�H DGNTD @G/�U�H O\<?@ < /�Q F ,�- D < � � F 3JQ F 3JH%D h � N O DGF <i3J5f< /�A;O N @ + 36b�/ , 3 D 7 DBF <?@LU�< D 9

S�< D � N @%� AZ/ D <?U�Q - /�5f5�H D @B/�U�H M 3JHLHB3 N U 5�<?AJ/ - DGN < 1c<I@ - D / H!��/ HBHB36bcU M <?U D /�U�5 @L<?HBKfA D 9� U�HB<IQ D 3 N U k 9 k 9?> � DBF <�@ N K�U�5 D @B3JW D @B/�U�HLO\<I@ D 3 M < N U DBF <�QIAJK�H D <I@#K�HB36U�b�R g � H N Q,��< D H

� /�H M <?/�HBK�@L<?5 3JU / W�3JUfb � W N U�b D <?H D DBN , < k�h � H?9�R F < 5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5 @B/ - D @B/�Q?<I@)5 N <IH, < DBD <?@ DBF /�U DBF / D ,�- K�HL3JU�b & <Ibc3 N U DGN 5f<?Q N K�W�AJ<�HB<?Uf5�H�O\@ N M @L<?QI<?361�<?HI9 ( F <?U DGF <

��� ����� JK.$- 9 S�< D � N @!� $^/�Uf5 � 3J5 DBF >�< /�HLK�@B< M <IU D 9

�:<?H N AJK D 3 N U )Y@G/ M < �(/ D < $ - D <?H > " $^/ U�5 � 3J5 DGF 7��%Q?36<?U�Q -� W�3 � � � O " H � � U�H,"�$ � � � + , 3 D �D F���D F k > jUH 9 > h F F h Be9 H h f9GE j

> h � > h > k F k 9 FIE k F >CBe9 j E FUEf9 k >�E h � >�E h D j >c9 h >I> jUH � >CBe9 j > FUEf9GD kh�jcj � h�j�j D h Df9 j > h j >�EID > k 9 h E B Df9 j Dh B D � h B D k Df9 D >�E D� j F > k 9?> F B Df9GD�k F�� k F >�D f9 D FIF h B D F > k 9 F j BIBe9GD�>F jcj �=F j�j >�D=>c9 D F j >�EID > h 9 IE B H 9 �>B=> h ��B=> h > j >c9 D H DID h > h 9 B=> B Ef9 B HD jcj ��D j�j H B49� k > j j >�EID > h 9 h > D�>c9 jckH�jcj � H�j�j B De9 jcj > F H j >�EID > h 9?>CB D�>c9 k BH D� � H D FUDe9 E�> > H D EIDID� > h 9 j B D�>c9 UB jcj � j�j F h 9VB=> >�E h j >�EID > h 9 h B D j 9 h

> jcjcj � > jcj�j hIH 9 kck kcjcj�j >�EID > h 9 h�j D�>c9 j > j�h F�� > j�h F h B49 H�k k > FUB E h F > h 9 k B D j 9 k >

� �

W�36U�b � W N U�b D <?H D 3JH0@B<?/�@B@B/�U�bc<I5 H NXDGF / D > j N @ M N @B<+HL<?U�5�H /�@L<)3JHBHLK�<?5 � O N AJA N � <?5 ,�- DGF <HG/ M < U�K M+, <?@ N O @B<?QI<?3 1c<?H � DBF <%/21�<?@B/�bc< D @G/ U�HLO\<I@ D 3 M <)5�@ N W�H DGN >�E � H?9%R F 3JH N @L5�<?@_36HOP/�H D <?@ , <IQ /�K�HL< DGF < D <?H D 5 N <?H)U N�D � /�3 D+N U DBF <#@ N K�U�5 D @B3JW D @G/�UfHLO\<?@ N O:< /�Q F W�36<?QI< N O3JUeO N @ M / D 3 N U , < O N @B<+HL<?U�5f3JU�b DBF <+U�<�� D Wf3J<?QI<�9 � U DBF 3JH=HL3 D KY/ D 3 N U DBF <+U�< D � N @!��Q?/�@B5 Q?/�U, K � <?@:HL<I1c<I@G/�A M <?HBHB/�bc<IH � � F 3JQ F M / ��<IH DBF <_U�< D � N @!�XQ?/�@B5 /�U�5 DGF < /�WfW�AJ36Q / D 3 N U DBF @B<?/�5M N @B<036U�5�<?W <?Uf5�<?U D 9�$ <IQ /�KfHB< N O , K � <I@B36U�b DGF < D @G/�U�H M 36HBHL3 N U D 3 M <0/�U�5 DGF < /�WfW�AJ36Q / D 3 N U<��e<IQ?K D 3 N U D 3 M <=Q?/�U N 1�<?@LAZ/�W8H N M < � F / DR N M < / HBK�@L< DGF <�AJ/ D <IU�Q - W <?@ D 3JA6< � � < M N 5�36O - DBF < W�@L<I143 N KfH D <?H D 9 ( <�K�HB< D h

@B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb DGF @B< / 5�HT/ U�5 M /�U - H M /�AJA D /�H%�4HI9 C H DGF < D /�H%��H , <?Q N M <%H M /�A6AJ<?@_/ U�5 M N @B<U�K M <?@ N K�H � DGF < D @B/�U�HLO\<I@ D 3 M < , <IQ N M <?H(5 N M 3JUY/ D <?5 ,�- AZ/ D <?U�Q - 3JU�H D < / 5 N O , /�U�5 � 365 DGF 9R F <0@L<?HBKfA D H bc361�<?U 3JU R / , AJ<+F�9 h H F�N � DBF / D � 3JU DBF <0AJ3 M 3 D � <?/�Q F D 36AJ< D / � <?H(/ D A6< /�H D >�E � HDGN)D @G/�U�H O\<?@I9R F <XU�< D � N @%� W�@B< 1c<IU D H DBF < 5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5�@B/ - D @B/�Q?<I@TO\@ N M HBQ?/�AJ36U�b�W <?@LO\<IQ D A - N @+3JU �

5�< ]YU�3 D <?A - 9ER F < @B/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b Q N M W�K D / D 3 N U D 3 M <�36H D @B36143J/�AJA - WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A(/�U�5 DBF < <�� D @B/N 1c<I@ F <?/�5�/�5f5�<?5 � 3 DGF < 1c<?@ - /�5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A U N 5�<_36H M 36U�3 M /�A 9 7 /�Q F O\@B/ M < DGF <_HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @U�<I<?5�H DBN HB<IU�5 N U�<=<�� D @G/ )Y@B/ M < d D / D <(K�W[5�/ D < � � F 36Q F#D / � <?HaAJ<IHBH DGF /�U kch � H?9 � N � < 1c<?@ �U N M / DBD <?@ F�N � M /�U - � N @%��<I@BH(/�@B<i@G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b � / O\@B/ M < � 3JA6A ]YUf3JH F U N OP/�H D <?@ DBF /�U DGF <

��� ����� JK. 3 9 S�< D � N @!� & / D <IU�Q - >�< /�HLK�@B< M <IU D 9

Ra36AJ< de3�?< Ra36AJ<?H )Y@G/ M < �(/ D < Ra3JA6<0Ra3 M <� W�3 � � � Ra36AJ<?H#" O � � O " H � � � H#" D 36AJ< �k�h � k�h h B D H�k 9 B D B k 9?>I>h � h k D�> D H 9GE�> F j 9 H Eh F�� h F F F BIBe9 IE k Df9GE Hh�j � h�j D H D B j 9?>�E h Ef9 F H>�D � >�D > j�h F k F�9 F�> h f9 k > h � > h > FUE h�j 9 j h Df9GE k � F j EID Ef9 F h > h Be9GE�>F ��F >�D k F h 9GD k h�k 9?> Fh � h DUBIB k D j 9 Hchch F h >c9?> h>�� > h D h > FIF j 9 h�j > k > f9GEUB

� �

HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ Q?/�U /�HBHL3JbcU /�U�5 @B<?QI<?3 1c<�/�AJA N O DGF < D /�H!��HI9 R F 3JH D 3 M <aQ?/�U , <(<?H D 3 M / D <I5 K�HB36U�b<?`�KY/ D 3 N U,Ff9A> �

��� � � � �� ��� >�E � ����� � � �� � � ���� * > h�� � k � � � �$F�9A> �

R N 5�< M N U�H D @G/ D < � � < , <IU�Q F M /�@!� /�U#< M W D - HBQI<?U�< 9�(�<=b�@G/�W F DGF < M <?/�HBK�@L<?5#O\@B/ M <@G/ D <0/�Uf5 DBF < M / �e3 M K M O\@B/ M <�@G/ D <=W�@L<?5�36Q D <I5 ,�- <?`�KY/ D 3 N U�F�9?>c9�) 3JbcK�@L<+F�9 F)H F�N � H DGF <@B<IHBK�A D HI9 S N D < DBF / D DGF < W�@B<I5�3JQ D <?5 M / �e3 M K M H /�@L< Q N U�HL3JH D <?U D A - A N � � W N HBHL3 , A - 3JU�5�36Q / D 3JU�bDGF / D DGF < , /�U�5 � 365 DGF M < /�HLK�@B< M <IU D � /�H DGN4N A N � 9 R F < / UY/�A - HL3JHX/�HLHBK M <?HX5 - UY/ M 3JQ/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D � 3 DGF ]YU�<_bc@B/�U�K�AZ/ @B3 D - � F <I@B< <I1c<I@ - D /�H!� Q N U D /�36U�H:/)HB3JUfbcAJ< D 3JAJ< 9

0

20

40

60

80

100

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Number of Nodes

32x32 tiles, measured32x32 tiles, max

16x16 tiles, measured16x16 tiles, max

8x8 tiles, measured8x8 tiles, max

�%��� � �� JK. J 9�S(< D � N @!� & 3 M 3 D / D 3 N U N U�>�/ �e3 M K M )Y@G/ M < �(/ D < 9

� �

JK.A3".A3 ���� � � � � * ���

� O D <?U DGF < O\@G/ M <�@G/ D <�3JH�Q N M W�K D < , N K�U�5�@B/ DGF <I@ DGF / U U�< D � N @!� , N K�U�5 9 R F <Q N M W�K D < D 3 M <#5f<?W <?U�5�H bc<?Uf<?@G/ AJA - K�W N U @B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b N W D 3 N U�H � 3 M / bc<#Q N M W�A6<��e3 D - � / U�5HBQI<?U�<XQ N M WfAJ<��e3 D - 9�R F <XHBQ?<IU�<XQ N M W�A6<��e3 D - 3JH DBF < W�@L3 M /�@ - 5�< D <?@ M 36UY/�U D � /�Uf5 3 D 36H)/O\K�U�Q D 3 N U N O DBF <_U�K M+, <?@ N O W�@B3 M 3 D 361�<?H^36U DGF <_HBQI<?U�< 9

(�< K�HL< /#O N @L<?H D HLQ?<IU�< DBN /�UY/�A - I< DGF < W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< N O DBF < @G/ - D @G/�QI<?@01c<I@BHBKfH DGF <U�K M+, <?@ N O Wf@B3 M 3 D 361�<?H?9 ) 3JbcK�@L<�F�9 B H FfN � H DBF <+HBQI<?U�< � 3 DGF N U�< M 3JA6AJ3 N UXW N A - b N U�H(O\@ N MDGF < DBF @B<I< D <?H D <?5%1 /�U D /�bc<aW N 36U D H?9VR N 3JH N AZ/ D < DGF <:W�@L3 M /�@ - @G/ - 36U D <?@LHB<?Q D 3 N U Q /�A6Q?K�AJ/ D 3 N U �/�A6AaHBK�@ OP/�Q?<IH K�HL<�� F�N U�b�AJ3 D Q N A N @ � 3 DGF�N K D H F /�5 N � HI9�R F < D <IH D � / H <��e<IQ?K D <?5 N U D h@B<IU�5�<I@ DBF @B<?/�5�H � 3 DBF > D � >�D D 3JA6<?Ha36UX/ B=> h ��B=> h 3 M /�bc< 9

) 3Jb�K�@B< F�9 D=H F�N � H DGF < O\@B/ M < @G/ D < O N @ DGF @L<?<^143J< � H N O DGF < O N @B<IH D HLQ?<?Uf<�/ H DGF <aU�K MT, <I@N O[W N A - b N U�H 36HV1 /�@B36<?5 9 R F <�b�@G/�W F H F�N � H DBF / D DGF <(5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 @B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@ N U DGF 36H QIAJK�H D <I@

� 3JA6A @G/ - D @G/ Q?< HLQ?<IU�<?H � 3 DGF�D � N M 3JA6AJ3 N U�W N A - b N U�H / D /�W�W�@ N �e3 M / D <?A - D � N O\@B/ M <?H W[<I@HB<IQ N Uf5 9 (�3 DGF O\< � <?@=W�@L3 M 3 D 361c<IH � DGF < O\@G/ M <T@B/ D <T/�W�W�@ N /�Q F <IH DGF <+Uf< D � N @!� AJ3 M 3 D:N O k BO\@G/ M <IH W <?@VHL<?Q N U�5 9 C , N 1c< D � N M 3JAJA63 N U0Wf@B3 M 3 D 361�<?H � DGF < O\@G/ M < @G/ D <^5�@ N W�HVW�@L<?Q?36W�3 DBN K�HLA -/�H DGF < 5Y/ D / /�U�5�/ Q?Q?<IAJ<I@G/ D 3 N U�H D @BK�Q D K�@L<#<��eQ?<I<?5 DGF < 3JUfH D / AJAJ<I5 W F - HL3JQ / A M < M N @ - / U�5, <?bc36U DBN H � /�W O\@ N M 5�36H!�;9R N ]Y@BH D / W�W�@ N �e3 M / D 3 N U � DBF < U�< D � N @!� D 3 M < 3JH 3JU�5f36143JHL3 , A6< /�U�5 DGF < Q N M W�K D / D 3 N U D 3 M <

3JH Q N M W�A6< D <?A - 5�36143JHL3 , A6<�9 C M 5�/ F A � H AZ/ � <��fWfAZ/�36U�H DBF < W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< N O DGF < @G/ - D @B/�Q?<I@

� <?AJA 9 � U <?`�KY/ D 3 N UQF�9 h � DBF <+O\@G/ M < D 3 M <T36H DGF <)HBK M N O DGF <)U�< D � N @!� D 3 M <T/�Uf5 DBF <)@G/ -D @B/�Q?36U�b D 3 M < 9VR F < @G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b D 3 M <=3JH DBF < D 3 M < DBF / D / HB36U�bcAJ<i@B<?Uf5�<?@ DGF @B< / 5 D / ��<IH DBN@G/ - D @G/�QI< DGF < HBQI<?U�< � 5�3 143J5�<I5 ,�- DBF <_U4K M+, <I@ N OV@L<?U�5�<I@ DBF @B<?/�5�HI9 R N 5f< M N U�H D @G/ D < � � <D <IH D0DBF < D @L<?<+HLQ?<IU�<%/�b�/�36U O\@ N M DBF < DGN W�1e36< � � � 3 DGF�h B j DGF�N K�HG/�Uf5 W N A - b N U�H � 1 /�@ - 3JUfbDGF <�U�K M+, <?@ N O � N @%��<?@LH?9�) 36bcK�@B< F�9 H W�A N�D H DBF <:O\@G/ M <:@G/ D <i/�H DGF <�U�K M+, <?@ N O Wf@ N Q?<?HLH N @LH3JH 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB<I5 � DGF < 3J5�<?/�A�O\@G/ M < @B/ D < K�U�5�<I@VW[<I@LO\<IQ D HLQ /�A63JU�b � /�U�5 DBF < O\@B/ M < @G/ D < W�@L<?5�36Q D <?5,�- <?`�KY/ D 3 N U F�9 h �

��� � � � �� � � > E � � � � � � �� � � � � * > h � � k � � � * � � � � ��� � � �� �

� � ��� � � �$F�9 h �

� �

�%����� � J . � 9 > >�3JA6AJ3 N U � � N A - b N U ) N @B<IH D � R N W � 7 5�bc< /�U�5 � U�U�<I@ �=3J< � H?9

� �

0.25

0.5

1

2

4

8

16

32

64

0 .5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Number of Polygons [millions]

Inside ViewEdge View

Top View

�%������� JK. 9 );@B/ M < ��/ D <=1c<I@BHB< � N A - b N U g N K�U D 9

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Number of Nodes

2 Threads Ideal2 Threads Est

2 Threads Measured1 Thread Ideal

1 Thread Est1 Thread Measured

�%� ��� �� JK. � 9 deQ?/�AJ36U�b � F <?U g N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A6A - $ N K�Uf5 9

� �

JK.A3".A< ������ �"� � � �(������� �(��! ����� ��� � ����� � �����"� � $ ���R N , @B36U�b DBF <i5f3JHBQIK�HBHL3 N U N O Q N M W�K D / D 3 N U /�U�5 Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U 36U DBN O N Q?K�H � � < M < / �

HBKf@B< DGF < D 3 M <)HLW[<IU D ,�- DGF <%Wf@ N bc@B/ M W <?@ O N @ M 3JU�b Q N M W�K D / D 3 N U /�U�5�Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U5�K D 3J<IH?9 ( <�K�HL< D � N 1c<?@LHB3 N U�H N O / HBW F <I@B<��;/ ��< D <?H D HBQ?<IU�< DGN H F�N � F�N � DGF < HBQ?<IU�<Q N M W�A6<��e3 D - 3JU �YKf<?U�QI<?H DBF <8Q N M W�K D < " Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ D < @B/ D 3 N 9 R F <8]�@BH D 1c<I@BHL3 N U F /�H�E�W�@L3 M 3 D 3 1c<IHi3JU DBF <)HBQI<?U�< � DGF <)HL<?Q N U�5 F /�H H�k �e9 ) 36bcK�@L<�F�9 #H F�N � H DGF < M N @L<TQ N M W�A6<��HBW F <?@L< �;/ � < HLQ?<?Uf<�9 $ N�DGF D <?H D H KfHB<%/ , N KfU�5�3JUfbX1 N AJK M < F 36<?@B/�@BQ F - � @L<?U�5�<I@ � 3 DGF F /�@L5H F /�5 N � H � / U�5 Wf@ N 5�K�Q?<8/ B=> h ��B > h 3 M /�bc<�9�de3 � D - � D � N @L<?U�5�<I@ DGF @L< /�5�H%@B<IU�5�<I@,> D � >�DW�3 �f<IA D 36AJ<?HI9

(�3 DBF E� W�@B3 M 3 D 3 1c<?H%< / Q F O\@B/ M < D / � <?H,B De9 j B M H DBN @B<IU�5�<?@ � - 3J<IAJ5�36U�b�Uf< /�@LA - > O\@G/ M <IH#W[<I@#HB<IQ N Uf5 9 7 /�Q F @L<?U�5�<I@ DGF @L< /�5�HLW[<IU�5�H h�j 9 h D M H W <?@#O\@B/ M < � / 3 D 36U�b O N @/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D H � /�U�5 DBF <?U D / � <?H kUH 9 H M H DGN @G/ - D @B/�Q?< DGF�N HL<#/�HLHB36bcU M <?U D HI9 (�3 DGF�DGF 36HHBQI<?U�< � Q N U D @ N A N 1c<?@ F < / 5 D / � <?H M N @B< DGF / U N U�< � DGF 3J@B5 N O DGF < DGN D /�A @B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b D 3 M <�9 � O

�%������� JK. ; 9 deW F <I@B< ) AZ/���<0R <?H D deQI<?U�< � 3 DBF ��/�@B5�d F / 5 N � Hi/�Uf5 H k �)W�@B3 M 3 D 3 1c<?HI9

� �

DGF <�Q N U D @ N A N 1�<?@ F < /�5 D 3 M < � N UfA - h UBe9 F � H 3JH HBW <?U D 3JU DBF <�H N Q,� < D Q / AJAJHI9�R F <�@B<?H DN O DGF < � /�3 D_D 3 M <)36H_HBW <?U D � /�3 D 3JUfbXO N @ DBF < HBK�W <?@ 143JH N @ DBN @L<I]YA6A DGF < A N Q / A D /�H%� `�K�<?K�< 9>�<?/�U � F 3JA6< � DGF < HBK�W <?@ 143JH N @�HLW[<IU�5�H kch 9VB M H D @G/�U�H O\<?@L@B3JUfb D /�H!��H=/ U�5 D /�H!� @L<?HBKfA D H � / U�5HBW <?Uf5�H h k 9 D M H � /�3 D 36U�b O N @0@B<IHBK�A D H (�3 DGF / D @L36143Z/�A HBQI<?U�< DGF <IU � Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U / U�5Q N U D @ N A N 1�<?@ F < /�5 Q N U�HLK M < k Df9A>�B � N @ M N @L< N O DBF < DGN�D /�A @L<?U�5�<I@ D 3 M <�9

(�3 DBF H�k �8W�@B3 M 3 D 3 1c<?H � <?/�Q F O\@B/ M < D /���<?H�> kcj 9 k M H DBN @B<IU�5�<?@ � - 3J<IAJ5�36U�b�U�<?/�@BA - O\@G/ M <IH=W[<I@0HB<IQ N U�5 9 (�3 DBF�DGF 36H M N @L<+Q N M W�A6<���HBQI<?U�< � DBF <)@B<IU�5�<I@ DBF @B<?/�5 Q N U D @ N A / U�5Q N M M KfU�3JQ?/ D 3 N U D 3 M <(3JH Uf< /�@LA - DGF <=HG/ M < � / Dah Df9 B M H W <?@ O\@G/ M < � , K D DGF <i@G/ - D @G/ Q?3JUfbQ N M W�K D / D 3 N U D 3 M < 3JH M K�Q F AZ/�@Lbc<?@ / D >I> k 9 j M H W <?@VO\@B/ M <�9 R F <(HLK�W <?@L1436H N @ H D 3JA6AeHLW[<IU�5�Hk�h 9 B M H D @G/ U�HLO\<I@B3JUfb D /�H!��H /�U�5 D / H!�T@L<?HLK�A D H � , K D U N � F /�H DGN � /�3 D O N @N> jck 9?> M H � /�3 D 3JUfbO N @=@L<?HLK�A D H?9 (�3 DBF�DGF 36H M 36AJ5�A - Q N M W�A6<���HBQI<?U�<)Q N M WfK D / D 3 N U�Q N U�HLK M <?H IDf9 Hch � N O DGF <@B<IU�5�<I@ D 3 M <�9C A DGF�N Kfb F&DBF < Q N U D @ N A N 1c<I@ F <?/�5 36HX/ W N HBHL3 , A6< D /�@Lbc< D O N @#O\Kf@ DGF <?@ N W D 3 M 3� / D 3 N U �

DGF < @B/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b Q N M WfK D / D 3 N U D 3 M < 36H DGF < M N @B<_3 M W N @ D /�U D , N�DLD A6<?U�<IQ,�#O N @:U N U D @B3 1e3J/�AHBQI<?U�<IH?9 R F <�Q N U D @ N A N 1c<?@ F < / 5 M / -), <�@L<?5�KfQ?<?5 � 3 DGF M N @B<(/�5f1 /�U�QI<?5#HLQ F <?5fK�AJ36U�b+/�A6b N��@B3 DGF M H DGF / D 5 N / , < DLD <?@ � N , N O ��<?<IW�3JUfb DGF < � N @%��<?@LH , KfH - � N @ ,�- � 3J5f<?U�36U�b DBF <_HB36U�bcAJ<HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ , N DBD A6<?U�<IQ,�;9 g N M W�K D / D 3 N U D 3 M < M / - , < @B<?5fK�Q?<I5 � 3 DGF+F - W[<I@ DBF @B<?/�5�3JUfb / U�51c<IQ DBN @ WY/ @G/�A6AJ<?Af3JU�H D @BKfQ D 3 N U�H � / U�5 � 3 DGF DGF <(K�HB< N O M N @L< F 3Jb F A - N W D 3 M 3�I<?5%/�Q?QI<?A6<?@G/ D 3 N UH D @BK�Q D K�@L<?HI9

JK.A3". J � �� � ��� � ��� ��� �����"� � $ ���C M / � N @ b N /�A N O DBF 3JH � N @!� � / H DGN <I1 /�A6KY/ D < � F < DGF <I@V/(Q?AJKfH D <I@ Q N K�A65 , < Q N M W < D 3 D 361c<

� 3 DBF /(H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - HBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D <?@ O N @ 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361�< @B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb�9Vd + �,� H S N U � S(U�36O N @ M>�< M N @ - C @BQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@L< � SiS�> C � /�@LQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@B<_36Ha/ F 3Jb F W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI<03JU D <I@BQ N U�U�<?Q D 3 N U/�@LQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@B< DGF / D 36H > h0DGN B k D 3 M <?H OP/�H D <?@ DGF /�U H � 3 D Q F <?5 + 36b�/ , 3 D 7 DBF <?@LU�< D 9 R F <0d + �K�HL<?H(/ F - W <?@LQ?K , < 36U D <?@LQ N UfU�<?Q D 3 N U8Uf< D � N @!� � 3 DGF /)AJ36U � , /�U�5 � 365 DGF8N O >c9GD + $ - D <0W[<I@HB<IQ N Uf5 / U�5�D jcj U�H � N @BH D%� Q?/�HB<0AJ/ D <IU�Q -%, < D � <?<IU Q N M WfK D <i/�U�5 M < M N @ - <IAJ< M <?U D H � kch�� 9R N <I1 /�A6KY/ D < FfN � M K�Q F�DBF 3JH:5�36HBWY/�@L3 D - < � <IQ D H DGF <T@G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b W�@ N QI<?HBH � � <T5 N HB365�< ,�-HB365�<%Q N M WY/�@L3JH N U�H N O DBF < 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 36U D <?@B/�Q D 361�<%@B/ - D @G/ Q?<?@ /�U�5 DGF < N @L3Jbc36UY/�A H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - @G/ - D @B/�Q?<I@?9

� �

� � �(/ - @BKfU�H N U�/ k�h W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @+d + � � @L3Jbc36U kcjcjcj 9 7 /�Q F W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @ 36H /�F jcj > � �4> h � � / U�5 DGF <^<IU D 3J@L< M / Q F 3JU�< F /�H >�D + $ N O M < M N @ - 9 R F <aW�@ N b�@G/ M � / H Q N M W�3JA6<?5)/ H/5D F � , 3 D , 3JU�/�@ - K�HB36U�b DGF <aUY/ D 3 1c< gag Q N M W�36AJ<?@ � 3 DBF � � k Q N M W�36AJ<?@ N W D 3 M 3�?/ D 3 N U 9 $ N�DBFQ / HB<?H @B<IU�5�<I@ 365�<?U D 36Q /�A�B=> h ��B=> h 3 M /�b�<?H N O DGF <(HLW F <I@B< �;/ ��<(HBQI<?U�<�H F�N � U 3JU ) 3Jb�K�@B<%Ff9�f97 /�Q F U N 5�<=36U DGF <=Q?A6K�H D <?@^K�HL<?H:/THL3JU�b�AJ<(@B<?Uf5�<?@ DBF @B<?/�5#O N @ DGF 36H D <IH D 9�(�< D <?H D � 3 DBF � /�U�5 k�h � k�hTD 3JAJ<IH DGN <���/ M 36U�< DGF <_U�< D � N @%� < �%Q?36<?U�Q - 9R F < @B<?HLK�A D H bc361�<?U 3JU ) 3Jb�K�@B< F�9GEa5�< M N U�H D @B/ D < DGF / D DGF < HBKfW[<I@BQ N M W�K D <?@ N K D W[<I@LO N @ M H

DGF <)Q?AJKfH D <I@ � , K D U N�D ,�- / AZ/ @Bbc<)/ M N KfU D 9 � � �(/ - 3JHiAZ/�@Lbc<?A - 36U�HB<IU�HB3 D 361�< DGN Q F / U�bc<?H_36UDGF < D 36AJ< HL3�I<�9 R F <8d + �,� HTA N � AZ/ D <?U�Q -�M / ��<IH DGF <#/�5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A H M /�AJA D 36AJ< /�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D H<?HLHB<IU D 3Z/�A6A - O\@B<I<�9 R F 3JH /�A6A N � H DGF <�HLK�W <?@BQ N M W�K D <I@#3 M W�A6< M <?U D / D 3 N U DBN HBQ?/�AJ< / A M N H D3JUf5�<I]YUf3 D <IA - 9 � � �(/ - F / H , <I<?U8W�@ N 1c<IU DBN HBQ / AJ<0K�W DGN > jch F)W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @BHI9 R F 36HaH F�N K�AJ5 , <

� <?3Jb F�D <?5 ,�- DGF <%OP/�Q D DBF / D , N�DGF W�@ N b�@G/ M H /�@B<%3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1c< � /�U�5 ,�- DBF < OP/�Q D DGF / D 36UDGF 3JH D <IH D:DGF < QIAJK�H D <I@(KfHB<?H N U�< DBF @B<?/�5 W <?@:U N 5�< 9

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Number of Processors

32x32 tiles SUPERCOMPUTER8x8 tiles SUPERCOMPUTER

32x32 tiles CLUSTER8x8 tiles CLUSTER

�%������� JK. � 9 deW F <I@B< ) AZ/���<_>�/�Q F 3JU�< g N M WY/�@B36H N U �:<?HLK�A D H?9

� �

JK.A3". � � � � �� �� U�<�5 N M /�36U 36U � F 36Q FDGF <�HLK�W <?@BQ N M W�K D <I@ F / H /�Q?A6< /�@ /�5f1 /�U D /�bc<�36H @L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b

AZ/ @Bbc< 5Y/ D / HB< D H?90R F < k�h � , 3 D � ID � g /�@BQ F 3 D <IQ D Kf@B<+A63 M 3 D H DBF <+HL3�?< N O @B<IW�AJ36Q / D <?5 HBQ?<IU�<5Y/ D / , /�HL<?H DBN F + $i9 � U N K�@TQIAJK�H D <?@T< /�Q F U N 5�< F /�H> + $ N O:W F - HB36Q /�A M < M N @ - � / U�5> + $ N O H � /�W HBWY/ Q?<�9 R F <_W�@ N bc@B/ M � 36AJA U N�D , <_/ , AJ< DBN QI@B<?/ D <_HBQI<?U�<IH DBF / D /�@L<0AZ/�@Lbc<?@DGF /�U h + $ � /�U�5�HLQ?<?Uf<?H0AZ/ @Bbc<I@ DBF /�U > + $ � 36AJA @B<IU�5�<?@iHBA N � A -X, <IQ /�K�HL< DGF < N W <?@G/ D 3JUfbH - H D < M F /�H DGN H � / W�1e36@ D KY/�A M < M N @ - WY/ bc<?H , < D � <I<?U W F - HB3JQ?/�A M < M N @ - /�U�5 DBF <THLA N �F /�@L5 5f3JH!�;9d D / D 3JQ D /�H!� / HBHB36bcU M <?U D /�U�5�3JU�H D /�UfQ?3JUfb Q /�U <�� D <IU�5 DBF < 5 N M /�3JU N O 3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1e3 D - 9

) N @ DBF < @L< /�H N U�H <��fWfAZ/�36U�<?5+36UTHLK , HB<IQ D 3 N U F�9?>c9 k � H D / D 3JQ^/ HBHB36bcU M <?U D @L<?5�KfQ?<?H DBF < � N @!��36U�bHB< D O N @X<?/�Q F U N 5�<�9 7 /�Q F � N @%��<I@�H D 3JAJA F /�H DBN QI@B< / D < DGF < � F�N AJ<�5Y/ D / HL< D � H N DGF <M / �e3 M K M 5Y/ D /)HB3�I<_3JHaU N�D 36U�Q?@L< /�HL<?5 � , K D(DBF <_5�3JH%�#H � /�W DGF @L<?H F�N AJ583JHa5f<?AZ/ - <?5 9

� U�H D /�U�QI3JU�b)QI@B< / D <?HaQ N W�36<?H N O N , � <?Q D Ha3JU HBWY/�QI< ,�- /�W�WfA - 3JU�b bc< N M < D @B36Q D @G/�U�H O N @ M / �D 3 N U�H DBN 3JU D <?@BHL<?Q D 3JUfb @G/ - H?9TR F < D @G/ U�HLO N @ M / D 3 N U�H�Q?/�U M N 1�< � HLQ /�A6< � @ N�D / D < � / U�5 � / @BW< / Q F�N O DGF <+Q N W�36<?H?9 C AJA N O DGF <+Q N Wf3J<?Hi@B<IO\<I@ DGN / HB36U�bcAJ< M / H D <I@iQ N W - N O DBF < N , � <IQ D 36UM < M N @ - 9 R F <0/ Q?Q?<IAJ<I@G/ D 3 N U%H D @BK�Q D K�@L<=H D 3JAJAYb�@ N � H^/�Uf5#Q N UfHBK M <?H M < M N @ - � , K D DGF <�AJ<?/ OU N 5�<?H D / ��< K�W N U�A - DGF <_HL3�?< N OV/ M / D @B3 � / U�58/%W N 3JU D <?@a3JU M < M N @ - 9R N D <?H D#DGF <?HB< D <?Q F U�3J`�K�<IH � � < D <?H D#DGF < D @L<?<�HLQ?<IU�< /�b�/�36U 9 (�< D <?H D <?/�Q F�N O DGF <

O N K�@%W N HBHL3 , 36AJ3 D 3J<IH N , D /�3JU�<I5 � 3 DGF D � N N , � <?Q D D - W[<IH /�U�5 D � N /�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D H D @G/ D <?bc36<?H �1 /�@ - 36U�b DGF < U4K M+, <I@ N O:W N A - b N U�HTO N @ < /�Q F 9 ) 36bcK�@B<�F�9?> j H FfN � H DBF < @B<IQ N @L5�<?5�O\@B/ M <@G/ D < � / W�W�A - 36U�b , N�DGF D <?Q F U�3J`�K�<IH DGN�DBF < D @B<?<�HBQ?<IU�<�9!S(<?3 DGF <I@ N O DBF <�@L<?bcK�AJ/�@ N , � <?Q DM < DGFfN 5�HXHLK�W�W N @ D M N @B< DBF /�U D � N M 36AJA63 N U W N A - b N U�H � , K D H D / D 3JQ�/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU DXF /�H8/F 36b F <?@^O\@B/ M <=@G/ D <0U�< / @ DGF <_AJ3 M 3 D 9-� U�H D /�U�QI<?H�/�AJA N � DBF <_@B<IU�5�<?@L<?@ DGN 5�@B/ � O N K�@ M 36AJAJ3 N UW N A - b N UfHa/ D >c9 h O\@B/ M <IH^W <?@aHB<IQ N Uf5 9 C 5�5�36U�b)H D / D 36Q0/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D^DGN+DBF <=3JUfH D / U�Q?<IHa5 N <IHU N�D @B/�5�36Q /�A6A - Q F /�U�bc< DBF <0O\@G/ M <0@G/ D <�9

� �

0.25

0.5

1

2

4

2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Number of Polygons [millions]

Dynamic Assignment, Instanced ObjectsStatic Assignment, Instanced Objects

Dynamic Assignment, Standard ObjectsStatic Assignment, Standard Objects

�%������� JK.#-=R 9 �(3Jb F >�< M N @ - d D @G/ D <?bc36<?H?9

������� ����� �

����������� ������� ��� � � � " $ ��' �

�&���(� ��$)��*)� � � " �

��� � ����� � ��� ����(��� � ��

��.#- .#- 2�� $&� � � ��� � ! � ������� ��$(�3 DBF 1 N A6K M < D @L3JQ 5Y/ D / � DBF <T5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5�@G/ - D @G/ Q?<?@�Q /�U <��eQ?<?<I5 DGF <+A N Q?/�A M < M N @ -

HBW�/�Q?< N O DBF <�U N 5�<IH#3JU DBF <�QIAJK�H D <?@ ,�- K�HL3JU�b*& <Ibc3 N U � H 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - 97 /�Q F U N 5�<+W <?@ M /�U�<IU D A - H DBN @B<IH9> � ����������� ��� N O DBF <)5Y/ D / 3JU M < M N @ - � /�U�5 N , D /�3JU�H@B< M N D <?A - N � U�<?5 5Y/ D / N 1c<?@ DGF <(U�< D � N @%� N U 5�< M / U�5 9 R N ��<I<?W DBF <iU�K MT, <I@ N O U�< D � N @%�D @B/�U�H O\<?@BH)5 N � U � <?/�Q F U N 5�< � <?<IW�H%/ Q?/�Q F < N O(@B< M N D <#5Y/ D /f9 ) 3Jb�K�@B<�B49A> 5�<IW�3JQ D H DGF <H D @BK�Q D K�@L< N O / � N @!� <?@aK�HL3JU�bT5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5#5Y/ D /f9�� U DBF <=5�3J/�bc@B/ M � F <?/ 1 - AJ36U�<?H W N 3JU D^N K DDGF < U�< � Q?AJ/�HBHL<?H /�5�5�<I5 DBN8DBF < 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5�@G/ - D @B/�Q?36U�bXW�@ N b�@G/ M 9 R F < .� d � � N A6K M <Q?AJ/�HBH W�@ N 5�K�QI<?H 3JH N HBKf@LOP/�QI< @B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�bcH � / U�5 DGF <�.0>�� ��� N AJK M <�QIAZ/�HLH#W�@ N 5�K�QI<?HX>�� �@B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfbcH?9�� U D <?@BU�/�AJA -), N DGF Q?AJ/�HBHL<?H N , D / 3JU 5Y/ D /_O\@ N M DBF <(. $ @B36Q,� C @B@B/ - k Q?AJ/�HBH � � F 3JQ F

� @G/ W�H(/ k .�/�@L@G/ - 36U D <?@ OP/�Q?< /�@ N K�U�5 DGF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@?9( F <?U / @L<?U�5f<?@ DGF @L< /�5 @B<?`�K�36@B<IH / , @B36Q,� N O[1 N A6K M <:5Y/ D / � 3 D M K�H D ]Y@LH D /�Q?`�K�36@B< DGF / D

, @L3JQ,� O\@ N M DBF < .0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@?9 � U�/ U�/�Q?`�K�36@B< � DGF < .0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@TQ F <?Q,��H 36O DBF < , @B3JQ,� 36HW�@L<?HB<IU D A N Q / AJA - � N , D /�36U�H03 D_N 1c<I@ DBF <%U�< D � N @!��O\@ N M DBF < @B<?HLW N U�HB3 , AJ< U N 5�< 36O U N�D � / U�5DGF <?UT@L< D K�@BU�H DBF < / 5�5�@B<IHBH N O DBF < , @B36Q,�=3JU_A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - DGN:DGF < @B<I`�K�<?H D 3JUfb DGF @B< / 5 9 � U�QI<DGF < DGF @B< / 5 ]YU�36H F <IH^K�HL3JU�b DGF < , @B36Q,� � 3 D M KfH D @L<?A6< /�HL< DGF < , @L3JQ,� H N DGF / D DGF <i.0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@Q / U @L<?K�HL< DBF / D Q / Q F < HLWY/�QI<�9R F <_@G/ - D @G/�QI<?@aK�HL<?H DGF @B<?<_A6<I1c<IA , @L3JQ,��3JU�b � DGF @L<?< � 5�3 M <IU�HB3 N UY/�A D 3JA63JU�b � /�Uf5 / F 3J<?@B/�@ �

Q F 36Q /�A4bc@B365T/ Q?Q?<IAJ<I@G/ D 3 N U H D @LK�Q D K�@B< O N @ 1 N A6K M <IH?9 $ @B36Q,�436U�bi3 M Wf@ N 1c<IH M < M N @ - Q NcF <I@B<?UfQ?</�U�5%< �%QI3J<?U D A - K D 3JA63�?<IH DGF < M < M N @ - /�@LQ F 3 D <?Q D K�@B< 9 R F <a]Y@BH D A6<I1�<?A , @L3JQ,��H DBF <:5Y/ D / N U DBND F ,�- D < Q /�Q F < A63JU�<IH � DBF < HB<?Q N U�5 , @B36Q,��H DBF < 5Y/ D / N U DGN F � $�143J@ D KY/ A M < M N @ - WY/�bc<IH?9 R F <

���

NODE 1

Scene

.

.

.

.

.

.

worker_dirt.exe

SceneState

FrameState

TaskState

...Task0

Task1

Task3

TaskN

Communicator

Renderer 0

Renderer N

ViewManager

TaskManager

resident_set local_cacheDataServer

0 3 6 4 1 2 7DBrickArray3

D*Volume

�%��� � �� ��.$- 9�( N @!� <?@id D @LK�Q D K�@B< � 3 DGF d F /�@L<?5�.0/ D /f9

DGF 3J@B5 A6<I1c<IA 3JU�QI@B< / HB<?H DGF <%5�/ D /Xbc@G/ U4KfAZ/�@L3 D - O N @ , < DBD <I@ , /�U�5 � 365 DGF K D 3JAJ3� / D 3 N U 9TR F <IHB<AZ/ @Bbc<IH D , @L3JQ,��H /�@L< DGF < KfU�3 D)N O�H F /�@L3JU�b � 3 DGF 5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5�5�/ D / � / U�5 N U�< .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@, A N Q,� Q N @L@B<?HLW N U�5�H DGN�N Uf< � DBF 3J@L5�AJ< 1c<?A , @B3JQ,�;9 � U&HLK , HL<?Q D 3 N U Be9 h 9 F � � <�/�UY/�A - ?< DGF << � <?Q D(N OVQ F / U�bc3JUfb DBF <_bc@G/ U4KfAZ/�@L3 D - 9R N K�HL< DBF <_.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ � DGF < @B/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b)<?U�b�3JU�< F / H DBN M /�W 5�/ D /)3JUf5�3JQI<?H DGN , @L3JQ,�

U�K M+, <?@LH:/�U�5 N � HB< D H � 3 DGF 36U , @B36Q,��H?9 7 `4K�/ D 3 N U�Be9?>=bc3 1c<?H DBF <0/�5f5�@B<IHBH N O /�@L@G/ - <?AJ< M <IU D� � - � i3JU Q N U D 36bcK N K�H M < M N @ - � 3 DGF DBF @B<I<=AJ< 1c<IA , @L3JQ,��3JUfb�9 ��<I@B< � � /�U�5 ���(/�@B< DGF <i5Y/ D /- /�U�5 5f3 M <?U�HL3 N U�H � � 36H DBF < DGF 36@B5�@ N4N�D_N O DBF <%U4K M+, <I@ N Oa5Y/ D /8<IAJ< M <?U D H W <?@_AJ< 1c<IAN U�< , @L3JQ,� � / U�5�� /�Uf5 � /�@B< DGF < HB/ M < M < /�HLK�@B<IH�O N @:AJ< 1c<IA D � N /�U�5 AJ< 1c<?A DBF @B<I< , @L3JQ,��H@B<IHBW <?Q D 361�<?A - 9 C H 3JU � � �(/ - � � <=5f<?Q N M W N HB< DGF < , @B36Q,�)<?`�KY/ D 3 N U 3JU DGN <��eW�@L<?HBHL3 N UfH N O � � -/�U�5 /�U�5 D / , K�AZ/ D < DGN M N 1�< DGF < M N 58/�U�5X5�3 143J5�< N W <?@B/ D 3 N U�Ha36U DBN /%W�@L<?W�@ N QI<?HLH�H D <?W 9R F 36H(@L<?5�KfQ?<?H DGF < Uf<?<?58O N @a<��eW <?U�HL361�< 5�3 143J5�< M N 5 N W <?@B/ D 3 N U�H^5fK�@B36U�b @BK�U D 3 M < 9

�"�

� ������ � ���

�!�%����� �-� � � � � � � � � �� �%�!������� �-� � � � � � � �!�%����� �-� � � � � � � *

�!�%�� �� � � � � � � � � � �� � �%�!������� � � � � � � � � *

�!�%����� �-� � � � � � � �� � �� *

�!�%����� �-� � � � M N 5 � � � �� � *�!�%�� �� � � � � � M N 5 � � � �� � *

�!�%����� �-� � � � M N 5 � � � �� *

�!����� � � M N 5 � � � � *�!�� �� �-� M N 5 � � � � *

�!����� � � M N 5 � � � *

��� M N 5 �-� � *�� M N 5 �-� � *

��� M N 5 �-�

� Be9A> �

R F < . $ @L3JQ,� C @L@G/ - k Q?AZ/ HBH=Q N U D /�36U�H D � N HB< D H N O D / , AJ<IH DGN M /�W�<?/�Q F W N 3JU D 36U�5Y/ D /HBW�/�Q?< DGN , N�DBF / , A N Q,��U4K M+, <I@�/�Uf5 /�U N � HL< D 9 R F < , A N Q,��/�U�5 N � HB< D D / , AJ<?H /�@L<bc<IU�<?@B/ D <I5�O\@ N M <?`�KY/ D 3 N U�H�Be9 h / U�5 Be9 k 9ER F < , A N Q,� U�K M+, <?@ Q N M <IH O\@ N M DGF <�]Y@BH DDGF @B<?< D <?@ M H N O:<?`�KY/ D 3 N U Be9?> /�U�5 DBF < N � HB< D Q N M <IHTO\@ N M DBF <#@B<IH D 9�R F < .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@M /�UY/�bc<IH DGF <_bcA N , /�A[H D /�@ D 3JU�b%/�5�5f@B<?HLH(O N @a< /�Q F , A N Q,� � H N � < N M 3 D DGF < � � � D <I@ M H?9

� ��� ���

�%�!����� � � � � � � � � �!�!� � ��� �-� � � � � � � �%�!� ��� � � � � � � � � *

�%�!�� �� �-� � � � � � � �%�!� � ��� �-� � � � � � �

�%�!����� � � � � � � � �

� Be9 h �

� �

� � � � � ��!�%����� �-� � � � M N 5 � � � �� � *�!����� � � M N 5 � � � � *��� M N 5 �-� � *�!�%�� �� � � � � � M N 5 � � � �� � *

�!�� �� �-� M N 5 � � � � *

�� M N 5 �-� � *

�!�%����� �-� � � � M N 5 � � � � *

�!����� � � M N 5 � � � *

��� M N 5 �-�

� Be9 k �

R F < � N AJK M < Q?AZ/ HBHB<IHTK�HL< / F 3J<I@G/�@LQ F 3JQ?/�A bc@L3J5 /�Q?QI<?AJ<I@G/ D 3 N U�H D @BK�Q D K�@L< DBN <?A63 M 3JUY/ D <K�U�Uf<?Q?<IHBHB/�@ - 5Y/ D / @B< O\<?@B<IU�Q?<IH?9 ) 3Jb�K�@B< Be9 h 36AJAJKfH D @B/ D <IH DGF <i/�Q?QI<?AJ<I@G/ D 3 N U%H D @BK�Q D K�@L<�9 7 /�Q FAJ< 1c<IA N O DBF < F 3J<I@G/�@LQ F - 3JH /_bc@B365 N O � M / Q?@ N Q?<IAJA6H �iDBF / D AJ36H DVDBF < M 36U�3 M K M / U�5 M / �e3 M K M5Y/ D /�1 /�AJK�<IHTO\@ N M DBF <#Q?<IAJA6H+Q N U D /�3JU�<I5�3JU DBF <#A N � <?@+A6<I1�<?AJH N O DGF < F 36<?@B/�@BQ F - 9 C^D)DGF <, N�DBDBN M AJ< 1c<IA � < /�Q F M / Q?@ N Q?<IAJA @L<?W�@L<?HB<IU D H0/�WfW�@ N �e3 M / D <IA - 1 N �e<IAJH?9 C^D(DGF < DBN W A6<I1�<?A �/aHB36U�bcAJ< M /�QI@ N Q?<IAJA�Q N U D /�36U�H DGF < M 3JU�3 M K M /�U�5 M / �e3 M K M 1 /�A6K�<?H O N @ DBF < <?U D 36@B<V1 N AJK M <�9

��/ - H D @B/ 1c<?@LHB< DBF < F 36<?@G/ @BQ F - ]�@BH D � K�HL3JU�bX/ @L<?QIK�@BHL361c< � 3JU�QI@B< M <IU D /�A D @G/ 1�<?@BHB/�A /�A6b N��@B3 DGF M 9 R F <a@G/ - <��f/ M 36U�<?H DBF < M /�Q?@ N QI<?AJA6H DBN ]YU�5 AZ/�@Lbc< HL<?Q D 3 N U�H N O DGF < 1 N AJK M < DBN H!��3JW �@B<I5�K�QI3JU�b DBF <=U�K M+, <?@ N O /�Q?QI<?HLHB<?H DBN HBA N � 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - 9 ) N @ 3JH N HBKf@LOP/�QI<@B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfbcH � DGF <+@B/ - ]YUf5�H=5Y/ D / Q?<IAJA6H � F 36Q F Q N U D /�3JU DBF <+36H N HLK�@LOP/�QI<+/�Uf5 DGF <IU H N A 1c<IH0/Q?K , 3JQ <?`�KY/ D 3 N U DBN�D <IH D O N @T36U D <?@LHB<?Q D 3 N U N O DBF < @B/ - � 3 DGF DBF <#36H N HLK�@LOP/�QI< � 3 DGF 36U 9�) N @>�� �@L<?U�5f<?@B36U�bcH � / Wf@B3 N @B3 D - `�K�<?Kf< N O W N�D <IU D 3Z/�A M / �e3 M K M @B<?b�3 N U�H N @Bb�/�Uf3�?<IH DGF < , <?H DQ / U�5�3J5�/ D <IH?9 R F <%@G/ - N U�A - W <?@LO N @ M H03JU D <I@BHB<IQ D 3 N U D <IH D H N U DGFfN HB<%Q?<IAJAJH DBF / D_F / 1�< DGF <W N�D <IU D 3Z/�A DGN Q N U D /�3JU DGF < M / �e3 M K M 1 /�A6K�<�9R F <�W�@ N bc@G/ M /�QIQ?<IHBHB<IH DGF < M /�QI@ N Q?<?A6A F 3J<?@B/�@BQ F - Q N UfH D / U D A - 9 ) N @ D K�U�/ D <IA - � DGF <

M /�Q?@ N QI<?AJA F 3J<?@B/�@BQ F - bc@ N � H A N b�/ @B3 DBF M 3JQ / AJA - � 3 DGF DBF < HL3�I< N O DBF < 5Y/ D /f9') N @ /)F + $

� �

1 1 12 1 2

2 51 4

23

1 00 0

3 1 1 2 4 6 1 01 1 4 8 7 2 1 0

0 1 3 3 5 2 2 21 2 1 1 3 3 2 2

1 0 0 0 3 2 2 222320000

1,2 1,2 2,5 0,1

1,3 1,8 2,7 0,1

0,2 1,3 2,5 2,2

0,1 0,0 2,3 2,2

1,8 0,7

0,3 2,5

0,8

8x8 Grid of ValuesLevel 1 Macrocell4x4 Grid of Min,Max

Level 2 Macrocell2x2 Grid of Min,Max

Implicit Top LevelMin,Max

�%��� � �� ��. 3 9 h .�7��f/ M WfAJ< � 3 DBF h & <I1�<?A C QIQ?<IAJ<?@B/ D 3 N U8d D @BK�Q D K�@L<�9

5Y/ D /�HB< D � / DGF @L<?<#A6<I1c<IA F 36<?@B/�@BQ F - 3JH�F�9 H > $ � /�U�5�/ O N K�@TA6<I1c<IA F 3J<?@B/�@BQ F - 3JH k E�> $�9$ <IQ /�K�HL< 3 D 3JHaH M /�A6A � � < Q / U @L<?W�A63JQ / D < DBF <_H D @LK�Q D K�@B< /�U�5 ��<I<?W 3 D 36U8A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - 9

$ <?Q?/�K�HL< /�Q?QI<?HBH DGN DBF <T5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5�H F /�@B<I5 � M < M N @ - 36H�HLA N � Q N M WY/�@L<?5 � 3 DGF A N Q /�AM < M N @ - /�QIQ?<?HLH � � < U�<I<?5 DGN @L<?5�KfQ?< DGF < U4K M+, <I@ N O�/�Q?QI<?HLHB<?H)O\K�@ DGF <I@ DGN /�Q F 3J<I1�< 3JU �D <I@G/�Q D 3 1e3 D - 98R N 5 N H N � � < Q N U�H N AJ365Y/ D < /�QIQ?<IHBHB<IH DGN 5�/ D /�/ DTDGF < , N�DBDBN M AJ< 1c<?A N O DGF </�QIQ?<?A6<?@B/ D 3 N U�H D @BKfQ D Kf@B<�9 ( F <?U / @B/ - <IU D <?@LH_/ , N�DBDBN M AJ< 1c<?A M /�Q?@ N QI<?AJA � 3 D W[<I@LO N @ M H�/W�@L< D @B/ 1c<?@LHG/�A DGN M / � <T/%AJ36H D:N O @L<?`�K�36@B<?5 , @B36Q,�4HI9:R F <T@B/ - DBF <?U�/�Q?`�K�36@B<?H�< /�Q F DGN K�Q F <?5, @L3JQ,�)3JU D Kf@BU � Q N W - 3JUfb N K D /�A6A�3JU D <I@BHL<?Q D <?5#1 N �e<IAJH , <IO N @B< M N 143JU�b N U DGN DGF <(U�<�� D , @B36Q,� 9) 36bcK�@B< B49 k 3JA6AJK�H D @G/ D <?HV/ h .&<��f/ M W�AJ< 9 R F <(@G/ - ]Y@LH D 5�< D <?@ M 36U�<?H DGF / D 3 D U�<I<?5�H DGF <:5Y/ D /

� �

Brick 1 Brick 2

Brick 3 Brick 4

MacrocellRay

�%����� � �".A< 9 g N U�H N AJ365Y/ D 36U�b C Q?Q?<IHBH DGN d F /�@L<?5 >�< M N @ - 9

� 3 DBF 3JU DGF < bc@L<?<IU M / Q?@ N Q?<IAJA 9 � U�HL3J5�< DGF < M /�Q?@ N QI<?A6A � 3 D W <?@ O N @ M H N U�< /�Q?`�K�36@B< N U , @L3JQ,�DGF @B<?< DGN bc< D /�AJA N O DGF < - <IAJA N � 1 N �f<IAJH � /�U�5 DGF <IU#W[<I@LO N @ M H N Uf<=/�QI`4Kf3J@B< N U , @B3JQ,�+O N K�@ DBNbc< D / AJA N O DGF < @L<?581 N �e<?AJHI9 R F < UY/ 361c< /�WfW�@ N / Q F � N K�AJ5 /�QI`4Kf3J@B< k�hTD 3 M <?H � bc< DLD 3JUfb%<?/�Q F1 N �e<?A Q N @BU�<I@:3JU D K�@LU � /�U�5 D /���<_U�< / @BA - k�h+D 3 M <?H^/�H:A N U�bf9

) 3Jb�K�@B< B49GF#H F�N � H /#5�3Z/�b�U N H D 3JQ 3 M /�bc< N O / h + $ H - U DGF < D 36Q)H F <IAJA 1 N AJK M < 9 .=3 � <I@ �<?UfQ?<?H 3JU , @B36b F�D U�<IHBH H F�N � DBF < D 3JA6<:/�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D H DBN DBF <�@L<?U�5f<?@B<I@ DBF @B<?/�5�H 3JU DGF <(Q?A6K�H D <?@?9de3 � D - � D � N H F /�5�<IH=H F�N � DGF < D 36AJ<?H:5�@B/ � U ,�- HB3 � D - � D � N @L<?U�5f<?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H?9i.=3 � <?@L<?U�QI<?H=36UF K�<0H FfN � DGF <i5Y/ D /)/ HBHB36bcU M <?U D � 3 DGF 36U DGF <=1 N AJK M < 9VR F 3J@ D - � N U�<0Q N A N @BH H F�N � DBF <=5Y/ D /, @L3JQ,��H N � Uf<?5 ,�- DBF 3J@ D - � N U�< � N @!� <?@LH?9

��.#- .A3 � ��� � ��� �Q* �� �#��� ��$)$ ����� N AJK M <IH F / 1c< DBN , <TW�@B<IW�@ N Q?<IHBHB<I5 , <IO N @B<+@L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b�9( <+K�HB< / U N � 3JU�< W�@ N b�@G/ M

DGN , @B36Q,� DGF <:1 N A6K M < � DGN QI@B<?/ D < DGF <i/�Q?QI<?AJ<I@G/ D 3 N U%H D @BK�Q D K�@L< � /�U�5 DBN Q?@L< / D <=/ F 3JH DGN bc@B/ MO N @ DBF <05Y/ D /f9 R F <0W�@ N bc@B/ M Wf@ N 5�K�Q?<IH DGF @L<?<_/�K��e36AJ3Z/ @ - 5Y/ D /T]YAJ<IH^O\@ N M /+@G/ � 5Y/ D /T]�AJ<�9R F <8]YAJ< � 3 DBF DBF <8]�AJ<?U�/ M <X<�� D <?U�HL3 N U�9 , @L3JQ,� � � Q N U D /�3JUfH DBF <81 N AJK M <X5Y/ D / , @L3JQ,� <?5

� 3 DBF � AJ<I1�<?A D � N , @B3JQ,��H:W <?@:AJ< 1c<?A DBF @B<I< , @B36Q,� 9 R F <0]YA6< � 3 DGF DBF <=]YAJ<IUY/ M <0<�� D <IU�HB3 N U9 M QI<?AJA � � Q N U D / 3JU�H DBF < � AJ<I1�<?A 5f<?<?W M / Q?@ N Q?<IAJA F 3J<I@G/�@LQ F - 9 R F <0]YAJ< � 3 DGF DGF <_]�AJ<?U�/ M <<�� D <?U�HL3 N U�9 F 3JH D � � Q N U D /�3JU�H:/ F 36H DBN bc@G/ M N O DGF <_5Y/ D / � 3 DGF�� , 3JUfH?9

� �

�%������� ��. J 9 .=3Z/�bcU N H D 3JQ �i3J< � d F�N � 36U�b%.0/ D / /�U�5 � M /�bc<0.=36H D @L3 , K D 3 N U 9

R F <:W�@B<IW�@ N Q?<IHBH N @ 3JH /�A6H N /=5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5)WY/�@G/ AJAJ<IAeWf@ N bc@B/ M � 3 DGF /=HLK�W[<I@L143JH N @ � N @!� <?@N @Lb�/�U�3� / D 3 N U 9 � D_F /�H0HB3 � H D /�bc<IH � < /�Q F HL<?WY/�@B/ D <I5 ,�- /X5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 , /�@L@B3J<I@?9Td - U�Q F @ N��U�3� / D 3 N U , < D � <?<IU�H D /�b�<?H W�@L<I1c<IU D H8`4Kf3JQ,� � N @%��<?@LH O\@ N M N , D /�3JU�36U�b�36U�Q N M W�A6< D <�5Y/ D /O\@ N M HBA N � <I@ � N @!� <?@LH?9

� d D /�bc<+>(d D /�@ D K�W � R F <aHBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @ HLWY/ � U�H � N @!� <?@BH /�U�5)b�361c<IH DGF < M DBF <a@G/ � 5Y/ D /]YA6<+UY/ M < � DGF <)5Y/ D / D - W[< � DGF <)5f<?W DBF N O DBF < M /�Q?@ N QI<?AJA F 3J<I@G/�@LQ F - /�U�5 DBF <)AJ< 1c<IADBF @B<I< , @B3JQ,� HB3�I<�9

� d D /�bc< h $ @L3JQ,�&/�U�5 ��3JH DGN b�@G/ M � R F < � N @!� <?@LH�Q?@L< / D <�/�U�< M W D - 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5M < M N @ - HBW�/�Q?< /�U�5X@L< /�5 DGF <?3J@ N � U85Y/ D /T1�/ AJK�<IHa3JU DGN 3 D 9 7 /�Q F ]YAJ<=@L< /�5 D / ��<IH�36U/ h . HLAJ3JQI< N O 5Y/ D /f9^R F < � N @!��<I@BHi]�U�5 DBF < , @L3JQ,� <?5�A N Q?/ D 3 N U#O N @(< /�Q F 1 /�A6K�< � , K DN UfA - Q N W - DBF <?36@ N � U81 /�A6K�<?H 3JU DGN+DBF <?36@ N � U8@L<?HL3J5�<IU D HL< D H?9 R F <0]Y@BH D � N @!��<I@(/�AJH N, 36U�H DGF < 5�/ D /)1 /�AJK�<IHa3JU DGN)DBF < F 3JH DGN bc@B/ M ]�AJ<03JU DBF 3JHaH D /�bc< 9

� �

� d D /�bc< k ( @B3 D < $ @L3JQ,� ) 3JAJ< � R F < ]Y@LH D � N @!� <?@ N , D / 3JU�H+<?/�Q F , @B36Q,� N 1c<I@%H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - 3JU D K�@BU DGN Q?@L< / D < DBF < , @B36Q,� ]YA6<�9

� d D /�bc<+F g @L< / D <_>�/�QI@ N Q?<?A6AJH � 7 /�Q F � N @%��<I@(Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB<IH�/+5f3 � <?@B<IU D HB< D:N O DGN W � AJ< 1c<?AM /�Q?@ N QI<?A6AJH?9 R F < - @B<IQ?K�@LHB3 1c<?A - N , D / 3JU M 3JUf3 M K M /�U�5 M / �e3 M K M 1 /�AJKf<?H O\@ N M DGF <A N � <?@ A6<I1c<IAJH N O DBF < F 3J<I@G/�@LQ F - DGN Q N M W�AJ< D <:< / Q F M /�Q?@ N QI<?AJA 9 C^D DGF < , N�DLDGN M A6<I1�<?A �/ M < DGF�N 5 3JU DGF <i. $ @L3JQ,� C @L@G/ - k QIAZ/�HLH ]YU�5�H DGF < M 3JU�3 M K M /�U�5 M / �f3 M K M 1�/ AJK�<IH36U /�U�/�@ , 3 D @B/�@B36A - HB3�?<?5 QIK , < N O 5Y/ D /f9 & 3�� < DGF <)@B/ - Q N UfH N A63J5Y/ D 3 N U�W�@ N Q?<IHBH � DGF <M 3JU " M / �%]YUf5�<?@(Q N UfH N A63J5Y/ D <?HaH F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH�O N @^OP/�H D <I@(Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB36U�b�9

� d D /�bc<QB g N M W�36AJ< >�/�QI@ N Q?<?A6A��(3J<?@B/�@BQ F - � R F < � N @!� <?@BHXHL<?U�5 DGF <?3J@ Q N M W�A6< D <I5M /�Q?@ N QI<?A6AJH DGNXDGF <%]Y@LH D � N @%��<I@?9 R F <%]Y@BH D � N @!� <?@ @B<?QI<?3 1c<?H M /�QI@ N Q?<IAJAJH05f3J@B<IQ D A -36U DBN 3 D H N � U8WY/�@ D 3Z/ A M /�Q?@ N QI<?AJA F 3J<I@G/�@LQ F - 9

� d D /�bc< D(�@L3 D <:>�/�Q?@ N QI<?A6A�) 3JA6< � R F <:]Y@BH D � N @%��<I@ HB/21�<?H DGF <:Q N M W�A6< D <?5 M / Q?@ N Q?<IAJAF 36<?@B/�@BQ F - DBN 5�36H!�;9

R / , AJ< Be9?>ibc3 1c<?H DGF < M < /�HLK�@B<I5 D 3 M <aO N @ k > � N @%��<I@BH DGN W�@L<?W�@ N QI<?HBH^/ H - U DGF < D 36Q=H F <?AJA5Y/ D /�HL< D 9 � U DGF < D / , AJ< � DGF < , @L3JQ,��Q N AJK M U Q N U D / 3JU�H DGF <8<?AJ/�W�HL<?5 D 3 M <#O N @%H D / bc<?H,>DGF @ N K�b F�k /�U�5 M /�QI@ N Q?<?A6A Q N AJK M U Q N U D /�36U�H DGF < <?AJ/�W�HB<I5 D 3 M <=O N @�H D /�b�<?H F DBF @ N Kfb F Df9R F <�5Y/ D / D - W[<�3JH K�U�HL3JbcUf<?5 H F�N @ D � � 3 DGF / O N K�@ AJ<I1�<?A F 3J<I@G/�@LQ F - /�U�5 h H � $ , @B3JQ,��HI9 R F <]Y@LH D:D � N Q N AJK M U�HaH FfN � DGF <_HB3�?< N O DGF <01 N AJK M <_/�U�5 DGF < M /�QI@ N Q?<?A6A[]YA6<�9

��� ��� � �".#- 9 �� � & 3JU�<� N A6K M <� @B<?Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB36U�b�9

.=3 M <IU�HB3 N U .0/ D / de3�?< C Q?QI<?A de3�?< $ @B36Q,�4H > g <?A6A� 1 N �e<?A6H � � + $ � � > $ � � HB<IQ � � HB<?Q �B=> h 9 h B H 9 B=> hch 9VB >�Df9 kD FUD 9 B j > k 9 j F e9 j h Df9 �> k >�9 j > h 9 E >I> kUH 9 j> j�h F h 9 j hch 9GF k B E H Df9 F> h E�> Ff9 j k e9 D BIB E > h F

� �

� @B<?Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB36U�b�Q N K�A65 , < /�QIQ?<IAJ<?@B/ D <I5 O\Kf@ DGF <?@ ,�- @L< /�5�36U�baAZ/ @Bbc<I@ HBAJ/ , H N O4@G/ � 5Y/ D / � ,�-K�HL3JU�b M K�A D 3JW�A6< DGF @B< / 5�H 5�Kf@B3JUfb M /�Q?@ N QI<?A6A�Q?@B<?/ D 3 N U � /�U�5 ,�- WY/ @G/�A6AJ<?A63�I3JU�b DGF < F 3JH DGN bc@B/ MN W <?@B/ D 3 N U 9

$ <?Q?/�K�HL< DGF < 5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5 W�@ N bc@B/ M A N / 5�H DGF < , @L3JQ,��<I5�5Y/ D /%36U W�/�@G/�A6AJ<IA � 3 D Q /�U A N / 5AZ/ @Bbc<+1 N AJK M <?H0OP/�H D <I@ DBF /�U*� � �(/ - 5 N <?HI9 7 /�Q F � N @!��<I@ N U�A - Uf<?<?5fH DBN A N /�5 / O\@G/�Q D 3 N UN O DGF < , @L3JQ,��H � /�U�5 DGF < WY/ @G/�A6AJ<?A ]YAJ< H - H D < M 36H0AJ<IHBH N Oa/ , N�DBD AJ<IU�<?Q,�;9 R F <%5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5W�@ N bc@G/ M A N /�5�Hi/�U + $�1 N AJK M <+36U N U�< M 3JU�K D < � / U�5 � � �(/ - A N /�5�H DGF <+HB/ M <+1 N A6K M <3JUXU�36U�< M 3JU�K D <IH?9

��� � � � � � � �de<I1�<?@B/�A OP/�Q DGN @LH 3JU��YK�<?UfQ?< DBF <=W <?@LO N @ M /�U�Q?< N O DBF <i@L<?U�5�<I@B<I@ � 3 DGF 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 5�/ D /f9

� U DGF 36HaHB<?Q D 3 N U � � < 36U�1�<?H D 3Jbc/ D < DBF <0O N AJA N � 36U�bTOP/�Q DGN @LH��

� Q N U�H N AJ3J5�/ D 36U�b)/�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH DGN DGF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@ �

� Q F / U�bc3JUfb DBF < / M N K�U D:N O M < M N @ - /�A6A N Q / D <?5 O N @aH F /�@L<?5 5Y/ D / N U8< / Q F U N 5�< �

� K�HL3JU�b H D / D 3JQ D / H!� /�HLHB36bcU M <?U D:DGN 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB<_5Y/ D /)Q NcF <I@B<IU�Q?< �

� Q F / U�bc3JUfb DBF <_bc@G/ U4KfAZ/�@L3 D - N O 5�/ D / H F / @B3JUfb �

� K�HL3JU�b�/ W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N U&Q N U D @ N A6AJ<I5 5�< M /�U�5EW�/�bc3JUfb3JU�H D <?/�5 N O 5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5EH F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - � /�Uf5

� 36U�Q?@L< /�HL3JU�b%/�HLH N Q?3Z/ D 36143 D - 36U DBF <_A N Q /�A[Q /�Q F <�9

� D 3JH / AJH N 3 M W N @ D /�U D DGN <��f/ M 3JUf< F�N � DBF < @B<IU�5�<I@B<?@XW <?@ O N @ M H N 1c<I@ D 3 M < � � F / DDGF <)<�� D @B/8Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ D 3 N U�Q N H D H � /�U�5 F�N � � <IAJA DBF < W�@ N bc@G/ M HBQ?/�AJ<IH?9+R F <+]Y@BH D W N 36U D3JU�1 N A61�<?H^A NeN ��36U�bT/ D DGF <=5 - UY/ M 3JQ , < F / 143 N @ N O DGF <i@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@a/�H 1e36< � W N 3JU D /�U�5#36H N 1 /�AJK�<Q F /�Ufbc<?H+Q?/�K�HL<#1�/ @B3Z/ D 3 N U�36U DBF < 1 N AJK M < N O:5Y/ D / D @G/ � Q 9�R F < HB<?Q N U�5�W N 3JU D 3JU�1 N A61c<IHK�HL3JU�b)5�< D /�36AJ<I5#5�3Z/ bcU N H D 3JQIH DGN M < / HBK�@L< F�N � M KfQ FXD 3 M < DBF <=W�@ N bc@G/ M HLW[<IU�5�H:Q N M%M K �U�36Q / D 3JU�b /�U�5 Q N M WfK D 36U�b @L<?HLW[<IQ D 3 1c<IA - 9iR F < DGF 3J@B5�W N 36U D 36U�1 N A61�<?H=<��f/ M 36U�3JUfb F�N � DGF <H - H D < M W <?@ O N @ M H:/�H M N @B<0W�@ N QI<?HLH N @LHi/�@L< /�W�W�A63J<?5 9

� �

R N <��f/ M 3JU�< DBF <?HL<i36HBHBKf<?H � � <�5 N /_HB<?@L3J<IH N O D <IH D HI9 C A6A D <?H D H � <I@B<�Q N U�5fK�Q D <?5 N U DGF <HG/ M <+QIAJK�H D <I@ DGF / D � /�H_5�<IHBQI@B3 , <?5 36U HB<?Q D 3 N U k 9 k 9TS(U�AJ<IHBH N�DBF <?@ � 3JHB<)U N�D <I5 � DGF <)b�361c<IU@B<IHBK�A D H /�@L<+O N @=3JH N HBKf@LOP/�QI<%@L<?U�5f<?@B36U�b � /�Uf5 k > � N @%��<?@ U N 5�<?H � < /�Q F�F / 143JU�b D � N @L<?U�5�<I@DGF @B< / 5�H � /�@B< K�HB<I5 9_d F / 5�3JU�b 3JH(HB36U�bcAJ< HB365�<?5 � 3 DGFfN K D H F /�5 N � HI9=R F <+3 M / bc<_@B<?H N AJK D 3 N U3JH5B=> h ��B=> h Wf3 �e<?A6H � /�U�5 DBF <)3 M /�bc<IH0/�@B<)Q N M W N HL<?5 O\@ N M >�D � > DXWf3 �e<?A D 3JA6<?H � � F 3JQ F /�@L<5 - UY/ M 3JQ?/�AJA - /�HBHL3JbcU�<I5 9

(�< D <?H D � 3 DBF O N K�@#H - U DBF < D 3JQ�1 N AJK M <?H � /�Uf5�HB<I1�<?U D 3 M < H D <IW�H#O\@ N M / HLQ?3J<IU D 36]�Q5Y/ D /)HB< D 9�) 3JbcKf@B<MBe9 B+H F�N � H DGF <_H - U DGF < D 36Q 1 N AJK M <IH?9�� U DGF <_H F <?AJA[1 N A6K M < � <I1�<?@ - W N 36U DQ N U D /�3JUfH DBF <:5�3JH D /�UfQ?< DGN0DGF <(QI<?U D <I@ N O DBF <a1 N A6K M < 9 R F <(3JH N HBKf@LOP/�QI<?H /�@B<(/�A6AfQ N U�Q?<IU D @B36QH F <?AJA6H?9�R F < M K�A D 3JH F <?A6A 1 N A6K M < Q N U�HB36H D H N O h jcj @B/�U�5 N M A - HB3�I<?5 /�U�5W�AJ/�Q?<I5 H F <?A6AJH �� 3 DBF W <?@ D K�@ , <?5 1�/ AJK�<IH DGF / D M / ��<�3J@L@B<?b�K�AZ/�@ HLK�@LOP/�QI<?HI9 R F <� <I@BAJ36U 1 N AJK M <(3JH^/ 1 N A6K M <5�< ]YU�<?5 ,�- DGF < � <I@BAJ36UTU N 3JHB< � h � O\K�U�Q D 3 N U � 3 DBF > jiF /�@ M N U�36Q?H?9 R F < � F 3 D < U N 36HB< 1 N A6K M <Q N U�HB36H D H N O:Q N M W�A6< D <IA - @G/ U�5 N M 1 /�AJKf<?H?9�R F < � F 3 D < U N 3JHB< 1 N A6K M < A N4N ��H A63�� <#/�H N AJ365

�%������� ��. � 9Vd - U DGF < D 3JQ�� N AJK M <IH�� d F <IAJA � >�K�A D 3ed F <IAJA6H � � <?@LAJ36U S N 3JHB< � / U�5 ( F 3 D < S N 36HB<�9

� �

Q?K , <=O\@ N M / 5�3JH D /�U�QI< , <IQ /�KfHB<03 D Q N U D /�3JU�H^/ F Kfbc<0U�K M+, <?@ N O HB/ M WfAJ<?HI9 R F <0H - U DGF < D 36Q1 N AJK M <?H_/�@L<)Q N M W N HB<I5 N O > D � , 3 D K�UfHB3Jb�U�<?5 3JU D <?bc<I@BH /�U�5�/�@L<�> j�h F 1 N �f<IAJH � N @ h + $ �K�U�A6<?HLH N�DBF <?@ � 3JHL<%U N�D <I5 9 R <?H D H N U DGF <%H - U DGF < D 36Q%1 N AJK M <?H M < /�HLK�@B< DBF < D 3 M <TO N @ DGF <]Y@LH D > jcj O\@G/ M <IH N OV/)H D / D 3JQ_HB<IHBHB3 N U 9

) 3Jb�K�@B<MBe9GD+H FfN � H D 3 M <iH D <IW�H(bc<?U�<I@G/ D <?583JU8/ �(36Q F�D MT- <?@ � >�<?H F � N 183JUfH D / , 3JA63 D - HB3 M �K�AJ/ D 3 N U 9�R F 36H g N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A ) A6K�3J5 . - UY/ M 3JQIH'� g )V. � 5Y/ D / HB< D � / H#W�@ N 5�K�QI<?5�/ D& / � @B<?UfQ?<& 3 1c<?@ M N @B< Si/ D 3 N U�/�A & / , H � h > � 9 R F <(1 N AJK M <:3JH Q N M W N HB<I5 N O K�U�HL3JbcU�<I5 � , 3 D3JU D <?bc<I@BH � / U�5�< /�Q F D 3 M <8H D <IW�3JH,>�E h�j � h j F � h�j F� 1 N �e<IAJH N @ H 9 B + $�9 R F < D <IH D H N UDGF < g )V.�5Y/ D / , <?U�Q F M /�@%� / @B<?Q N @B5f<?5X3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1c<iHL<?HLHB3 N U � 3 DGF O\@B<?`�K�<IU D 3JH N 1 /�A6K�<i/ U�5143J< � W N 36U D Q F /�U�bc<IH?9

�%����� � �". 9 �:3JQ F�D MT- <?@ � >�<IH F � N 1 Ra3 M <_d D <?W�H j � F B � > j � hIH�j 9

� �

��.A3".#- ����"$ ���#� ! �(������ �'� � ��$)$$ <?Q?/�K�HL<T5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 M < M N @ - / Q?Q?<IHBH=36H:HBA N � Q N M WY/�@L<?5�A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - /�Q?QI<?HBH�3 D 36H

3 M W N @ D /�U D^DGN @B<I5�K�Q?< DGF < DBN�D / A U4K M+, <I@ N O M < M N @ - /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH?9 ( < F /21�< <��eW[<I@B3 M <?U D <?5

� 3 DBF�DGF @L<?< Q?<IAJA^36U D <?@LHB<IQ D 3 N U @ N K D 3JUf<?H+O N @)>'� � /�U�5 3JH N HBKf@LOP/�QI< @B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b�9�R F <#]Y@BH D@ N K D 36U�<�/�QI`�K�3J@L<?HX/�U�5�@L<?A6< /�HL<?H DGF <�<?36b F�D Q N @LU�<?@LH N O < /�Q F QI<?AJA(3JUf5�<?W <?U�5f<?U D A - 9 R F <HB<IQ N Uf5 @ N K D 36U�<0H N @ D H DBF <_<?36b F�D Q N @LU�<?@LH:H N DGF / D 3 D 5 N <?H:U N D U�<?<I5 DBN /�Q?`�K�36@B< DGF <0HB/ M <, A N Q,� M N @L< DGF /�U N UfQ?<(3JU N U�<aQI<?AJA 9 � O /_QI<?A6AYH D @B/�5�5�A6<?H / , @B36Q,�+Q N @BU�<I@ � 3 D � 36AJA�U�<I<?5%<?36b F�D/�QI`4Kf3J@B<IH / U - � / - /�Uf5 DBF <�H N @ D 3JU�b�/�5�5fH N 1c<I@ F <?/�5 9 g <?A6AJH N U , @B36Q,��HB365�<?H /�U�5 <?5�bc<IH/�@L<T/�U�/�A N b N K�H?9 R F < 1 /�H D M / � N @L3 D - N OVQ?<IAJA6H�/ @B< 3JU D <I@B3 N @ DBN%DBF < , @B3JQ,��H � H N DGN D /�A /�QIQ?<IHBHD 3 M <X36H QIA N HL< DGN N U�< <?3Jb F�DBF DBF / D N O03JUf5�<?W <?U�5f<?U D /�QIQ?<?HLH?9�R F < DGF 3J@B5 @ N K D 36U�< H N @ D H/�A6A N O DBF < /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH � 3 DGF 36U DGF < ]Y@BH D AJ<I1�<?A M /�QI@ N Q?<IAJAJHI9�R / , AJ<�Be9 h H F�N � H DGF <X/ 1�<?@G/ bc<U�K M+, <?@ N O:/�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH)W[<I@ � N @!� <?@+W <?@_O\@G/ M < /�U�5 DGF < /21�<?@B/�bc< O\@B/ M < @B/ D <%K�HB36U�b DBF @B<I</�QIQ?<?HLH WY/ DBD <I@BU�H O N @ DBF < g ) .&5Y/ D /_HB< D 9 R / , AJ< Be9 k AJ3JH D H DBF < M < / HBK�@L<?5 O\@G/ M <a@G/ D <:K�HB36U�bDGF < DGF @L<?< / W�W�@ N /�Q F <?H O N @#>�� � /�U�5 3JH N HBK�@ OP/�Q?<IH#@B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b�H N O DBF < h + $ H - U DGF < D 36Q� <I@BA63JU 1 N AJK M <�9 � U <?/�Q F D <?H D � DGF <#O\@B/ M <#@G/ D < 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB<X3JHT3JU�1c<I@BHB<IA - Wf@ N W N @ D 3 N U�/�A DBNDGF <85f<?Q?@L< /�HL< 36U DGF <XU�K M+, <?@ N O=/�Q?QI<?HBHL<?H � M 36U�K�H DGF < N 1c<I@ F <?/�5 N O DGF < , @B3JQ,��H N @ D 3JUfb/�A6b N @B3 DGF M 9 g N U�H N AJ365Y/ D 3 N U�5 N <?HXU N D @L<?5�K�QI< DBF <�U4K M+, <I@ N O M 3JHLHB<?H � H N 3 D 3JH M N H D< � <?Q D 3 1c< � F <?U F 3 D H:5 N M 3JUY/ D < DGF < @L<?U�5f<?@ D 3 M < 9

��.A3".A3 � ��� ��� � � � �� � � � � � � � � � �.=K�@B36U�b 3JUf3 D 3J/�AJ3� / D 3 N U � DGF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@BH /�A6A N Q / D < A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - DBN K�HB<)O N @=H F /�@L<?5

5Y/ D /f9 R F < .� � R > C �=._df>�>�7 > <?U�143J@ N U M <IU D 1�/ @B3Z/ , AJ<VQ N U D @ N AJH DBF < / M N K�U D N OeA N Q /�AM < M N @ - 9 (�3 DBF S�U N 5�<IH � < /�Q F U N 5�< M K�H D /�A6A N Q / D <^/ D A6< /�H D � � ��� � ������� �� ,�- D <?HI9 R F <

��� ��� � �".A3 9 g N U�H N AJ365Y/ D <I5 C QIQ?<?HLH DBN d F /�@B<I5�>�< M N @ - N U DBF < g )V. .0/ D / de< D 9

�V/ DLD <I@BU C Q?Q?<IHBHL<?H )Y@G/ M < �(/ D <� O " H �

C Q?QI<?HBH�> k�hIH E jcjcj 9?>I> FUEC Q?QI<?HBH FUB k F jcj 9 H�j E j

C QIQ?<?HLHi>�/�U - B k�h E j >c9GD�ID

�H�

��� � ��� ��.A< 9 g N U�H N AJ3J5�/ D <I5 C Q?QI<?HBH DGN d F / @B<?5 >�< M N @ - N U DGF < � <?@BA63JU � N A6K M <�9

�(<IU�5�<I@�> < DGFfN 5 �V/ DBD <I@BU C Q?Q?<IHBHL<?H )Y@G/ M < �(/ D <� O " H �

>'� � C Q?QI<?HBHM> >�E IE jcjcj 9 H F�>� d � FUB hIH�jcj h 9 kcj>'� � C Q?QI<?HBH h k UB jcj h 9A>CB� d � D F kUH�j B49 E�>'� � C Q?QI<?HBH M / U - IE F kcj h 9 Hch� d � >CB k�h�j De9 HIH

U N 5�<?H Q /�UX/�A6A N Q / D <:U N M N @B< DGF /�U DGF <=HLK M N O DGF <i3JU�H D /�A6AJ<?5%W F - HB36Q /�A M < M N @ - /�U�5 DGF <Q N Uf]YbcK�@L<?5 H � /�W�HBWY/ Q?< � M 3JU�K�H DGF <+O N4N�D Wf@B3JU DiN O /�AJA /�Q D 361�<)W�@ N Q?<IHBHB<IH?9 � U N K�@0Q?A6K�H D <?@ �< / Q F U N 5�< F /�HM> + $ N OVW F - HL3JQ / A M < M N @ - /�U�5 > + $ N O H � /�W�HLWY/�Q?< � /�U�5�36U N U�< D @L3Z/�A> j�j >�$ � /�H DGF <_K�WfW[<I@(A63 M 3 D 9

(�3 DBF�DGN4N A63 DBD AJ< M < M N @ - � DGF <#A N Q /�A Q?/�Q F < Q?/�U�U N�DTF�N A65 DGF < � N @!��3JU�b�HB< D /�U�5 DGF <Q / Q F < � 36AJA DGF @B/�H F 9 $ @L3JQ,��H Q N M W[< D <�O N @ HLWY/�Q?< 3JU DBF < Q /�Q F < /�U�5 Q / K�HB<�O\@B<I`�K�<?U DM 3JHBHL<?HI9 R N ]�U�5 N K D FfN � M KfQ FEN O%/ 1 N AJK M <�U�<I<?5�H DBN , <�Q /�Q F <I5 � � < 1 /�@ - DGF <.� � R > C �0._df>�>�7 > W�/�@G/ M < D <?@ /�U�5 M < /�HLK�@B< DGF <8O\@G/ M <�@B/ D <8O N @ DGF <�O N K�@ H - U �DGF < D 36Q+1 N A6K M <?H?9 R / , AJ<�B49GF Q N U D /�36U�H05�< D /�3JA6<?5�5f3Z/�bcU N H D 3JQ?H�O N @ DGF < M K�A D 3JH F <?AJA 1 N AJK M <�9) 36bcK�@B<MB49 H bc@B/�W F H DGF < @L<?HLK�A D H N OV/�A6A[O N Kf@aH - U DGF < D 3JQ_1 N AJK M <?HI9R F < 3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1e3 D - 3JH�W NeN @ � 3 DBF @B<IH D @L3JQ D <?5 M < M N @ -�, <?Q / K�HB< DGF < M 36HBH�W <?U�/�A D -

5 N M 3JU�/ D <IH DBF <�O\@G/ M < D 3 M < 9 � U�3 D 3Z/ AJA - � DBF <�O\@G/ M <�@G/ D < 3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<IH /�H DGF <�/ AJA N Q / D <?5M < M N @ - 36U�Q?@L< /�HL<?HI9�(�3 DGF M < M N @ - / D @ N K�b F A - > h � N O DGF <:1 N A6K M <�HL3�?< � F 3 D H 5 N M 36UY/ D <

��� ����� ��.?J 9�& N Q?/�A >�< M N @ - C AJA N D M <?U D .=< D /�36A O N @ DGF < > K�A D 3 d F <IAJA � N AJK M <�9

C AJA N Q?/ D 3 N U & N Q?/�A g /�Q F < ��3 D �(/ D < )Y@G/ M < �(/ D <� > $ � � > $ � � � � � O " H �H�j 9VB j F�9 F k B IDf9 IE 9GEID k BH Ff9 jcj H 9GE k B EIDf9 j�h h 9 H > j>I> h 9 j F Be9GE F E H 9GDUB Ff9A> kIHB=> h 9 j FIF B49 E EIEf9 h > H 9 DUB >CB k D > F H�j EIEf9 F k e9GFIFID

� �

0

2

4

6

8

10

0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Per Node Memory [MB]

Multi ShellShell

Perlin NoiseWhite Noise

�%� ��� �� ��. � 9�& N Q?/�A >�< M N @ - C AJA N D M <?U D /�U�5 )Y@G/ M < �(/ D < 9

DGF <+O\@G/ M < D 3 M < � /�Uf5 DBF <+O\@G/ M < @G/ D <)3JU�QI@B< / HB<)AJ< 1c<IAJH N K D 9�S N�D < DBF / D < 1c<IU�/ , N 1c< DGF <3JUfH D / AJAJ<I5 W F - HL3JQ?/�A M < M N @ - N O5> + $ DBF < 36U D <?@B/�Q D 36143 D - H D 36AJAV3 M W�@ N 1c<?H HBA63Jb F�D A - 9 ��<I@B< �143J@ D KY/�A M < M N @ - /�AJA N � HT< /�Q F U N 5�< DGN ��<I<?W /�AZ/�@Lbc<?@+U�K MT, <I@ N O , A N Q,�4H)A N Q?/�AJA - � / U�5N U�A - DBF < /�Q D 361c< N Uf<?H:U�<?<I5 D / ��<_K�W8HBWY/ Q?< 3JUXW F - HB3JQ?/�A M < M N @ - 9

��.A3".A< � � � ��� �)�'$)$ ����� ��� � �(�3 DBF 5 - U�/ M 36Q HBQ F <?5�K�A63JU�b � DGF < D 3JAJ<�/�HBHL3JbcU M <IU D H Q F /�U�bc<�O\@L<?`�K�<?U D A - /�Uf5 <?/�Q F

� N @!� <?@ M KfH D @L<?U�5f<?@ M N H D#N O DBF <�3 M / bc< N 1�<?@ D 3 M <�9 (�3 DGF H D / D 3JQ8HBQ F <I5�K�A63JU�b � <?/�Q F

� N @!� <?@X@B<IU�5�<?@LH DGF < HB/ M < HL< DXN O D 3JAJ<IH#@B<IW[<?/ D <I5�A - 9 .0/ D / Q NcF <?@B<IU�Q?< 36H , < DBD <?@ � 3 DBFH D / D 36QT/ HBHB36bcU M <?U D , <?Q?/�K�HL<+< /�Q F � N @%��<?@iQ N U�H D /�U D A - /�Q?QI<?HBHL<?H DBF <THB/ M < H M /�AJA W N @ D 3 N UN O DGF <_5Y/ D /f9 R F < 5�@G/ � , / Q,� 3JH DGF / D(N U�A - @B<?Uf5�<?@ DGF @B< / 5�H N U DBF < HB/ M <0U N 5f<T/�@L< / , AJ<DGN Q NeN W <?@B/ D < DBN @L<?U�5f<?@:5�3��%QIK�A D W N @ D 3 N UfH N O DBF <_3 M /�bc< 9R / , AJ<,Be9 B�Q N M WY/�@L<?H)5 - UY/ M 36QX/�U�5 H D / D 36Q D /�H%��/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D O N @)HB< 1c<?U D 3 M <#H D <IW�H

O\@ N M DBF < �(36Q F�D MT- <?@ � >�<?H F � N 1X5Y/ D /THL< D 9�) N @ DBF <i]Y@LH DaD 3 M <iH D <?W�H � DGF <i5Y/ D /+Q NcF <I@B<?UfQ?<

� �

��� � ��� ��. � 9 . - UY/ M 3JQi1�<?@BHL<)d D / D 36Q C HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D O N @ g )V. Ra3 M <0d D <IW�H?9

. - UY/ M 3JQ d D / D 3JQRa3 M <0d D <IW C Q?QI<?HLHB<?H �(3 D �(/ D < )Y@G/ M < �(/ D < ��3 D ��/ D < )Y@G/ M < �(/ D <

� � � � O " H � � � � � O " H �j hchch jcj EIEe9 E F Df9GDIE�> EIEf9GEUB Ff9� H HF B k > h H�j EIEe9� k F�9 hch F EIEf9GE h k 9 D� kE j k �> D j EIEe9 HIH k 9 k B h EIEf9GE h k 9A>�D=>> k B F�>�E F j EIEe9 D� h 9 H B E EIEf9GE j h 9 DUB E> j B=> H D j EIEe9 D�> h 9 j EUB EIEf9 IE h 9 h F Fhch B B D j E j EIEe9VB D >c9 H F EIEf9 � h 9A> j >hIH�j B k B j EIEe9GF >c9GD�ID EIEf9 F h 9 j

b�/�36U�H05 N U N�D_N K D � <I3Jb F DGF <%A N /�5 3 M+, /�AJ/�U�Q?<TW[<IUY/�A D 3J<IH?9 ) N @ DBF < Q N M W�AJ<�� D 3 M <+H D <?W�H �DGF < <�� D @G/ F 3 D HaQ N M W <?U�HB/ D <0O N @ DBF <_K�U�< 1c<?U � N @%��A N /�5 9

��.A3". J 2 � � � � #��� � � � � � �g F /�U�b�3JU�b DGF <�5Y/ D / b�@G/�U�K�AJ/�@B3 D - 5�< M N UfH D @B/ D <IH�/�U N�DGF <I@ D @G/ 5�< N � 9 d M /�A6A , @L3JQ,��H

D /���< AJ<IHBH D 3 M < DGN�D @B/�U�H M 3 D � � / H D < A6<?HBH HLWY/�QI< ,�-�, < DLD <I@ Q N UfO N @ M 3JU�b DBN /�HBK�@ OP/�Q?< �/�U�5�5�<?QI@B< / HB< Q N M W < D 3 D 3 N U O N @TA N Q?/�A Q /�Q F < HLWY/�QI<�9 � U DGF < N�DGF <?@ F /�U�5 � AJ/�@Bbc< , @L3JQ,��H, < DBD <?@(/ M N @ D 3�I< DGF < D @B/�U�H O\<?@:3JU�3 D 3J/ D 3 N U AJ/ D <IU�Q - / U�5 D <?U�5 DGN 3 M W�@ N 1�< DGF < F 3 D @G/ D < ,�-HB<I@L143JQI3JU�b M KfA D 36W�AJ< /�QIQ?<?HLHB<IH � 3 DBF /0HB3JUfbcAJ< D @G/�UfHLO\<?@I9VR F < , <?H D bc@B/�U�K�AZ/ @B3 D - , / AZ/�U�QI<?H DGF <Q N M W < D 3JU�b0OP/�Q DGN @LH � /�U�5 36H AJ3�� <?A - DGN , <(5Y/ D / 5�<IW[<IU�5�<IU D 9 R N D <?H D DBF 3JH � < , @L3JQ,� /�> + $H F <?AJA 5Y/ D / HL< D / U�5 DGF < H 9 B + $ �:3JQ F�D M - <?@ � >�<IH F � N 1#5Y/ D / HL< D /�Uf5 1 /�@ - DBF <iA6<I1c<IA DBF @B<I<, @L3JQ,�#HL<?AJ<IQ D 3 N U DGN Q F / U�bc< DGF <_U�< D � N @%� D @B/�U�HLO\<I@:5Y/ D /)bc@B/�U�K�AZ/ @B3 D - 9R / , AJ< Be9 D H F�N � H DBF <�@B<IHBK�A D HI9 (�3 DBF , N�DGF 5Y/ D / HB< D H � DGF < F 3 D @B/ D <�/�U�5 DBF < M 3JHBH

W <?UY/�A D - Q?A63 M+, � 3 DGF 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB<I5 bc@B/�U�K�AZ/ @B3 D - 9 � U DBF <?HL< D <?H D H � <?3Jb F�D W�/�bc< , @B36Q,��H DBN N Uf<DGN W � A6<I1c<IA , @B36Q,� 36H:OP/ H D <IH D 9

��.A3". � 2 � � ����! * � � ��! � � ��� �(�<%Q / U�K�HL< /8.0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@ M M /�W Q?AJ/�HBH DGN @B<IU�5�<I@ ,�- 5�< M /�Uf5 WY/ bc3JU�bX5Y/ D / O\@ N M

5�36H!�#@B/ DGF <I@ DGF /�UXO\@ N M DGF <_U�< D � N @!�;9 R F < M%M /�W � � H - H D < M Q?/�AJA @B<?`�K�36@B<IH�WY/ bc< � /�AJ36bcU�<?5/�5�5f@B<?HLHB<IH?9 R N K�HL<03 D � DBF <05�3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 1 N AJK M <=QIAZ/�HLHB<IHaQ /�U @ N K�U�5 DBF <=AJ< 1c<IA DGF @L<?< , @L3JQ,�

� �

��� ����� ��. 9�)Y@G/ M < �(/ D <_/�U�5 .0/ D / + @G/�U�K�AJ/�@B3 D - 9

& < 1c<IA k de< DBD 3JU�b $ A N Q,� de3�?< �(3 D �(/ D < >�36HBH � <IUY/�A D - )Y@G/ M < �(/ D <� � $ � � � � � � H � � O " H �> + $ � >�D � , 3 D d F <?A6A

> k 9 k E f9 H > k E j 9 H > >c9 D Eh hIH 9 j E Ef9 D j > jIHIH > F�9VB Hk E�>�9A> E Ef9� j h E j B > k 9 kIHF h >�D E Ef9� DIE hch > >c9A> >H 9VB + $ � � , 3 D �:3JQ F�D M - <?@ � >�<IH F � N 1

> F E f9 H�h B H 9 j >�9 D jIHh k�h E Ef9GF� > F�>I> >�9 D� Dk > j E Ef9 D F k E Hch >�9 kcj E

HB3�?< K�W /�U�5�W�/�5 DBN%DBF < U�< /�@L<?H D F � $ � 9 �V/�5�5f3JU�b , A N / D H DBF < , @B3JQ,�#]�AJ<?H(/�Uf5�3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<IH, A N Q,� D @G/ U�HLO\<I@ D 3 M <0H N 3 D 36HaU N�D U N @ M /�AJA - K�HL<?5 9

(�<_@L< , @L3JQ,� DBF <_H - U DGF < D 36Q H F <?A6A 1 N AJK M <_/�U�5XQ N M WY/ @B< DGF <_.0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@ 5f3J@B<IQ D QIAZ/�HLH

� 3 DBF8DBF <+.0/ D /�de<I@L1�<?@ M%M /�WXQ?AZ/ HBH?9aR / , A6<�Be9 H H FfN � H DGF / D M < M N @ -#M /�WfW�3JU�b 36H(OP/�H D <I@O N @(H M /�AJA 1 N AJK M <?H , K D HBA N � <?@�O N @�AJ/�@Bb�< 1 N AJK M <?HI9�R F 3JH=/ bc@B<I<?H � 3 DGF8DGF <+@L<?HLK�A D�N O DGF <@G/ U�5 N M /�QIQ?<?HLH).0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@TQ N M WY/ @B3JH N U�3JU�HLK , HL<?Q D 3 N U k 9 k 9 h / U�5 DBF < <��fWfAZ/�UY/ D 3 N U 36HDGF <=HG/ M < � N U�QI< DGF < N W[<I@G/ D 3JU�b H - H D < M 36H O N @LQ?<?5 DBN WY/�bc<�5Y/ D / DGN 5�36H!� � Uf< D � N @!� M 3JHLHB<IH/�@L< OP/�H D <?@I9 >�< M N @ -�M /�WfW�3JU�b M / -�, < OP/�H D <?@ O N @TH M /�A6A 1 N A6K M <IH � , K D @L<?W�A63JQ / D 3 N U 36HOP/�H D <?@:H D 3JA6A 9

��� �|�-9�� ,4 �L�" |� ;��g�2B@BC�"! ,","!:,E�[�"!p��E�E� /&,���E ��2;@!:B� �(%� ��r� �-9���,��[�"! ;(.2 ;(.[�+1���E E /�'��CB(B�! B��

��� ����� ��. � 9�S(< D � N @!�8/�Uf5 .=< M / U�5 �V/�bc<I5�> < M N @ - g N M WY/ @B3JH N U 9

.0/ D / de3�?< S(< D � N @!� )Y@B/ M < ��/ D < >�< M N @ - >�/ W�)Y@G/ M < �(/ D <� + $ � � O " H � � O " H �9 h B >�Ef9 hch h�h 9 k�j9VB > H 9?> k h >c9 E F> > F�9 B E h j 9 h h > h 9?> B49 jck�jF Ef9 H�h E >�9 H j

� �

��.A3". �'$)$ ���I���(�����"� � �R F <^5�36@B<IQ D M /�WfW[<I5+.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@ F /�H DGF < /�5f1 /�U D / bc< N O�A N � N 1c<I@ F <?/�5)3JU Q N M WY/�@L3JH N U

� 3 DBF DBF <+/�HLH N Q?3J/ D 3 1c< .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@ � , K D 3 D(F / H DGF <TW N�D <IU D 3Z/�A DBN DGF @G/�H F � F <?U�/ � N @!� <?@U�<I<?5�H�HB<I1�<?@B/�A , @L3JQ,��H DGF / D(F / W�W[<IU DGN /�A63JbcU DBN DGF < HB/ M <_HLA N�D 9 C HLH N Q?3J/ D 3 1e3 D - 3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<IHDGF < F 3 D @G/ D < ,�- Wf@ N 143J5�36U�b/�A D <I@BUY/ D <�W�AJ/�Q?< M <IU D H�O N @ < /�Q F O\< D Q F <I5 , @B36Q,� 9 � D /�AJH N3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<IH DBF < F 3 D)D 3 M < , <?Q / K�HB<83 D U�<I<?5�H DGN HB<?/�@BQ F HB< 1c<?@B/�A(A N Q / D 3 N U�HT/�U�5 3 D F / H DBN��<I<?W D 3 M <�H D / M WfH?9 R / , AJ<+Be9 +H F�N � H DGF < M <?/�HBKf@B<?5 F 3 D @B/ D < � F 3 D D 3 M < � /�U�5#O\@G/ M <�@G/ D <O N @ 5�36@B<?Q D M / W�W[<I5 / U�5�F � � > h � /�U�5,>�D � / - /�HBH N QI3Z/ D 361�<aQ /�Q F <IH N U DGF < g )V.�5Y/ D / HL< D 9( <%]YUf5 DGF / D < 1c<?U DGF 36H AJ/�@Bbc<)1 N AJK M < F /�HT/ � N @!��36U�b�HL< DTDBF / D ] D H � 3 DBF 3JU DGF < Q / Q F <

� 3 DBF�N K DaDBF @G/ H F 36U�b�9( F <?U DGF <=1 N AJK M <0bc@ N � H DBN)DGF <_W N 3JU D � F <I@B< DGF < � N @!��36U�b HB< D 36H DGN4N AZ/�@Lbc<=O N @ DGF <

A N Q / A M < M N @ - N U DBF < U N 5f<?H � DGF @G/�H F 3JU�b , <?Q N M <IH M N @L< N Oa/ W�@ N , AJ< M 9 C HBH N Q?3J/ D 3 143 D -Q / U 3JU�QI@B< / HB< DBF <iO\@G/ M <(@G/ D < F <I@B< ,�- 3JU�QI@B< / HB3JUfb DGF <iU4K M+, <I@ N O F 3 D HI9 R N <��f/ M 3JU�< DGF 36HW N HBHL3 , 36AJ3 D - � < D <?H D:DGF < M KfA D 36H F <IAJA;1 N A6K M <_/�U�5 1 /�@ - DGF <_/�A6A N Q / D <?5 M < M N @ - W <?@aU N 5�<�9R / , AJ<�Be9GEXAJ3JH D H DBF < M < / HBK�@L<?5 O\@B/ M <%@B/ D <)O N @0]�1�< 5f3 � <?@B<IU D /�HLH N Q?3J/ D 3 1c< HB< D HL3�?<IHT/ U�5]�1�< A N Q?/�AJA - / AJA N Q / D <?5 M < M N @ - HL3�?<IH?9R F <a@B<IHBK�A D H H F�N � DBF / D � 3 DGF AJ3 M 3 D <I5 M < M N @ - � /�HLH N Q?3Z/ D 36143 D - 3 M W�@ N 1c<IH 3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1e3 D - 9

(�3 DBF B=> h > $�W[<I@:U N 5f< � /�U�58/)HB3 � � / - /�HBH N QI3Z/ D 361c<0Q?/�Q F < � N U�A - F � N O DGF < F 3 D HaQ N M <O\@ N M DGF < <�� D @B/�HBA N�D HI9 R F < /�HBH N QI3Z/ D 361�< HLA N�D H+/�@L< K�HL<?5 M N @B< F <?/21436A - � F <IU DGF < A N Q /�AM < M N @ - HLWY/�Q?< 36H H M / AJA 9 (�3 DBF H�j 9VB�>�$ W[<I@+U N 5�< => � N O DGF < F 3 D HTQ N M <%O\@ N M DGF <<�� D @G/ HBA N D H?9�� U DGF 3JHaQ / HB< � O\< � <I@ M 3JHLHB<?HaW�/ - O N @ DGF <_A N U�bc<?@ F 3 DaD 3 M <�9

��� ����� ��. ; 9 C HBH N Q?3J/ D 3 143 D - R <?H DiN U DBF < g )V. .0/ D /f9

.0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@ �(3 D �(/ D < R �(3 D );@B/ M < ��/ D <� � � � � H � � O " H �

.=3J@L<?Q D EIEf9 F Df9 UB H >c9GD�IDC HLH N Q � F�� EIEf9GD j >I>c9 BIB >c9 B h >C HLH N Q � � EIEf9GD k > k 9?> H >c9 FIF kC HLH N Q � > h � EIEf9GD k > F�9 j > >c9 k D�>C HLH N Q � >�D � EIEf9GDUB >CBe9 F >c9 h ID

� �

��� ��� � �". � 9�)Y@G/ M < �(/ D <=14H?9 C HLH N Q?3J/ D 3 1e3 D - / U�5 C AJA N Q?/ D <I5X>�< M N @ - 9

.0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@ C AJA N Q / D <?5X> < M N @ - � > $ �H�j 9 B H F >I> h B > h >CB k D

.=36@B<IQ D 9 EID HIH h 9 H D F F�9 h >�D H 9 DIB D f9 FUE hC HBH N Q � > � 9 E F H D h 9 H�j > F�9 j H H 9 h jck H 9GEUB C HBH N Q � h � >c9GF�� k 9 h�kch F�9 h F H 9 E h f9?>�D�>C HBH N Q � F�� >c9VB D h k 9 h E F F�9?> FUD f9 j D h f9 j B jC HBH N Q � D � >c9VB E� k 9 hch k F�9 j F H f9A> F H f9?> H�k

��.A3". � 2 � �"��� � � � � �"�U�"��� R F <:O\@G/ M <a@G/ D < N O DBF <:@B<IU�5�<?@L<?@ 3JH 36U�1�<?@LHB<?A - @B<IAZ/ D <?5 DGN0DGF <i/ M N K�U D N O[@B< M N D <a5Y/ D /

O\< D Q F <?5 ,�- DGF <:@B<IU�5�<I@ DBF @B<?/�5�H?9 > < /�HLK�@B36U�b DBF <aO\@G/ M <a@G/ D <(/�U�5 DGF <(5Y/ D / D @G/ � Q M / ��<IHDGF < @L<?AZ/ D 3 N U�H F 36WXQ?AJ<?/�@B<I@?9 ) 3JbcKf@B<�Be9 %H F�N � H DGF < @L<?Q N @B5�<I5�5Y/ D / D @G/��%Q /�U�5XO\@G/ M <_@G/ D <N 1c<I@i/�UX36U D <?@B/�Q D 361c<0HL<?HLHB3 N U N U DGF < g ) . 5Y/ D /)HB< D KfHB3JUfb N U�<_@B<?Uf5�<?@ DGF @B< / 5 W <?@:U N 5�<�9R F < , N�DBDBN M WY/�Uf<?A H F�N � H DGF <T@B<IU�5�<I@B<?5 3 M / bc< / D ]f1c<TO\@B/ M <IH�5fK�@B36U�b DBF <THL<?HBHL3 N U 9

R F <^Uf<�� D DBN , N�DBDBN M WY/�U�<IAe@L<?W�@ N 5�KfQ?<?H DGF < 3JH N 1 /�A6K�< /�U�5T143J< � W N 3JU D Q F /�U�bc<IH DGF / DVN Q?Q?Kf@N 1c<I@ DGF <THB<?HLHB3 N U 9=R F <T<?U D 36@B< 1 N AJK M < 3JH(3JU�143J< � O N @ DBF < ]�@BH D=F /�A6O N O DGF < D <IH D � /�U�5 36UDGF < AJ/�H D F /�A O N O DGF < D <?H D DBF < 1436< � 36H NeN M <?5�3JU N U�/ H M /�A6A W N @ D 3 N U N O DGF <%1 N AJK M <�9R F < HB<?Q N U�5�W�/�U�<?A O\@ N M DGF < DBN W�H F�N � H DGF <T/ M N K�U D(N O 5Y/ D / DGF / D <?/�Q F U N 5�< /�QI`4Kf3J@B<IHN 1c<I@ DGF <+Uf< D � N @!� / D < /�Q F O\@B/ M < 9 (�3 DBF�DGF <T<?U D 36@B<T1 N AJK M <+36U�143J< � � <I1c<I@ - Q F /�U�bc<)36U143J< � W N 36U DaN @^36H N HLK�@LOP/�QI<0Q /�KfHB<?H DBF <05Y/ D / D @G/ � Q DBN HBW�3���< /�U�5 DBF <?U85�<IQ / - 9�( F <IU N U�A -/)H M /�AJA W N @ D 3 N U 3JHa36UX1436< � � DGF < 5�/ D / D @B/�U�H O\<?@:3JH M 3JU�3 M / A 9R F < DBN W8WY/�U�<IA Q N U D /�36U�H D � N bc@G/ W F H � N Uf< H F�N � 3JU�b DGF < M < /�HLK�@B<I5 O\@G/ M <0@B/ D < � / U�5

DGF < N�DGF <I@ H F�N � 3JUfb DBF <^O\@G/ M <a@B/ D < DBF / D � N K�A65 N Q?QIK�@ 36O U N0D 3 M < � / H HLW[<IU D D @G/�U�H O\<?@L@B3JUfb5Y/ D /f9 S N�D < DGF / D 3JU DGF < M < /�HLK�@B<I5 O\@G/ M <(@G/ D <�W�A N�D � O N @ DGF <�]Y@LH D^F /�A6O N O DGF < D <IH D � <I1�<?@ -HBWf3���< 36U�5�/ D / D @B/��%Q%Q?/�K�HL<?H /XH F /�@LW 5�@ N W�3JU DGF <)O\@B/ M <)@B/ D < � O N AJA N � <?5 ,�- / bc@B/�5�KY/�A3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB< 9 ��<?@L< � <?/�Q F Q F /�U�bc<_@L<?`�K�3J@L<?H DBF <_.0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@ DBN Q /�Q F < /+5�3 � <I@B<IU D W N @ D 3 N U N ODGF < 5Y/ D / � /�U�5 N , D /�36U�3JUfb DBF <%5Y/ D / N 1c<?@ DGF <%U�< D � N @%� @L<?5�KfQ?<?H DGF < O\@G/ M < @G/ D <�9 � 1c<I@HB< 1c<I@G/�A4O\@G/ M <?H � DGF < � N @!� <?@BH N , D / 3JU DBF < <IU D 3J@L< � N @%�436U�b=HL< D � /�U�5 DBF < O\@B/ M < @B/ D < @B< D K�@LU�HDGN U N @ M /�A 9 ( F <?U DGF <)143J< � 3JH NeN M <I5�36U � DGF < � N @%��<?@LH Q?/�U�< /�HL3JA - Q / Q F < DBF <)143JHB3 , AJ<

� �

0

1

2

3

4

[f/s]

Loaded Frame RateFrame Rate

0

4

8

12

16

[MB

/nod

e]

Data Traffic

0

64

128182

256

Isov

alue

No

Uni

ts

Isovalue

0

64

128182

256

100 200 300 400 500

Isov

alue

No

Uni

ts

Frame Number

View Point

�%����� � �". ; 9 .0/ D /+R @G/ � Q /�Uf5�)Y@G/ M < �(/ D <�9

5Y/ D / � /�U�5 DGF < HLW[<I<?5 N O DBF <_@B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b%<?U�b�3JU�< � 3JU�QIAJK�5�36U�b F 3 DaD 3 M < DBN%DBF < .0/ D /�d4<?@L1�<?@ �5�< D <?@ M 36U�<?H DBF <0O\@G/ M <=@G/ D < � @B/ DGF <?@ DGF / U DBF <_Q /�Q F < , < F / 143 N @?9R F < A N /�5�<I50O\@G/ M < @G/ D < b�@G/�W F � /�H @L<?Q N @B5�<I5 ,�- @B<IW[<?/ D 36U�b:< /�Q F O\@B/ M < D � <IU D - D 3 M <IH �

/�U�5 DGF <IUW�A N�DBD 3JU�b <I1�<?@ - D � <?U D 36< DGF O\@G/ M <�9�R F 36H WfA N�D 5�< M N UfH D @B/ D <IH DBF <�@L<?U�5�<I@B36U�bHBW <?<I5�/ HBHBK M 36U�b)/+W <?@LO\<IQ D Q?/�Q F <�9�� U DGF 3JH D <?H DaDBF <_/ 1c<I@G/�bc<=O\@B/ M <=@G/ D <=3JH >c9 k E h O\@G/ M <IHW <?@0HB<IQ N Uf5 � 3 DGF ]YA6AJ<?5 Q?/�Q F <IH / U�5 >c9 h F�>+O\@G/ M <?HiW[<I@0HB<?Q N U�5 � 3 DBF�N K D 9TR F < 5 - UY/ M 3JQ, < F / 143 N @ DBF <?U 5�<IW[<IU�5�H K�W N U DGF <:5�<Ibc@B<I< DGN � F 36Q F DBF <:Q /�Q F <?H /�@B<^]�AJAJ<I5 � � F 36Q F 36U D K�@LU5�<IW[<IU�5�H F <?/21436A - K�W N U DBF < @B/ D < /�U�5 WY/ DBD <I@BU N O:K�HB<I@+3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 N U 9 � U DGF 3JH D <?H DTD 3 M <HBW <?U D�N , D /�3JU�36U�b+5Y/ D / N 1c<?@ DGF < Uf< D � N @!� HLA N � <I5 DBF <_@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@ ,�- > j 9 UB � 9

� �

��.A3". ; ��� ���#����( F <?U�A N Q /�A M < M N @ - Q N U D /�3JU�H DGF < � N @!��36U�b�HL< D � U�< D � N @%� W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI<%36H_U N�D /�U

3JHLHBK�< � /�U�5 DBF <_@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@:<�� F 3 , 3 D H DGF <0HB/ M <0HBQ / AJ3JUfb DGF / D 3 D 5 N <?H � 3 DGF @L<?W�A63JQ / D <?5 5�/ D /f9S�< D � N @!�XAZ/ D <?U�Q - /�U�5 DGF < U�K M+, <?@ N O W�3 �e<?A D /�H!��H(5�< D <?@ M 3JUf< DBF < H F /�W < N O DBF < HBQ / AJ3JUfbQ?Kf@L1c< 9 ��3 D+D 3 M <IH DGN 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5�H F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - /�@B< HBA N � <?@ DGF /�U�U N @ M /�A M < M N @ -/�QIQ?<?HLH)H N 5f3JH D @B3 , K D 36U�b DBF < 5�/ D /�HLA N � H DBF <#@B<IU�5�<I@B<?@T5 N � U 9 � U H M /�AJA 1 N AJK M <?H DGF / DQ / U , <8@B<IW�AJ36Q / D <?5 � � < F / 1c< M < / HBK�@L<?5 DBF / D K�HB36U�b DBF <�5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5 H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ -HBA N � H DBF <i@L<?U�5�<I@B<I@ 5 N � U ,�- /�H M K�Q F /�HND j � 9VR F <?@L<IO N @L< � 3 D D / � <?H M N @L<:W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @BH DBN@B<?/�Q F DGF < O\@G/ M <T@B/ D < AJ3 M 3 D 9 ) 3JbcK�@L< B49 E#bc@B/�W F H DGF <+@B/ - D @G/�QI<?@ � H0W <?@LO N @ M /�U�Q?< N U DGF <h + $ M KfA D 36H F <IAJA 1 N A6K M <_/ H DBF <_U�K M+, <?@ N O W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @BH(3JHa3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<I5 9

( F <?U DGF < � N @!��3JUfb HB< D 36H DGN4N AJ/�@Bb�<=O N @:A N Q /�A M < M N @ - � /�5f5�3JU�b � N @!� <?@BH�Q /�U H N M < �D 3 M <IH - 36<?AJ5 HBK�W <?@LAJ36U�< /�@ HBQ?/�AJ36U�b�9 ) N @ 3JU�H D /�U�QI< � � 3 DGF /�U + $ 5Y/ D / HL< D � 3 D D / � <?H)/ DAJ<?/�H D <?3Jb F�D QIAJK�H D <I@)U N 5f<?H DGN @L<?U�5�<I@ DGF < 5Y/ D / � K�U�A6<?HLH � < D /���< DGF < W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< F 3 DN O M < M N @ -#M /�W�Wf3JU�b+O\@ N M 5�36H!�;9 C 5�5f3JU�b U N 5�<?H(5�3 1e365�<?H DBF <_5Y/ D /%36U DBN H M /�AJA6<?@^Wf3J<?QI<?H �� F 36Q F AJ< / 1�<?H M N @B<^HLWY/�QI<^O N @ DBF <^A N Q / AeQ?/�Q F <�9 & /�@Lbc<?@ Q /�Q F <?H F�N A65 M N @B< N O DBF < � N @!��36U�b

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Number of Nodes

1 Thread per node2 Threads per node

�%����� � �". � 9 deQ?/�AJ36U�b � 3 DBF .=36H D @L3 , K D <?5 � N AJK M <0.0/ D /f9

� �

HB< D � `�K�3JQ,��A - 36U�Q?@L< /�HL3JU�b DBF < F 3 D @G/ D < /�U�5 DBF <_O\@G/ M <_@G/ D <�9 � U�QI< DBF < A N Q /�A Q?/�Q F < F�N AJ5fHDGF < � N @%�436U�b%HB< D � HBQ?/�AJ36U�b)@B< D K�@LU�H DBN HBK , A63JU�<?/�@B3 D - 9

� U#Q N U D @G/�H D DBN DGF < , <?U�< ]YQ?3J/�A[< � <IQ D N O 3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB36U�b DBF <iU�K MT, <I@ N O U N 5�<IH � 3JU�QI@B< / HB3JUfbDGF <8U�K MT, <I@ N Oi@L<?U�5�<I@ DGF @L< /�5�H W <?@ U N 5�< 3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB<IH Q N U D <IU D 3 N U�O N @ DBF <X5Y/ D /f9 (�3 DBFAJ3 M 3 D <I58A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - � DBF 3JH(Q / U�Q /�KfHB< DBF @G/�H F 3JUfb�9:R � N DBF @B<?/�5�H=W <?@(U N 5�<TQ?/�U�@L<?U�5�<I@/ h + $ H F <?A6AY1 N A6K M <:K�HL3JU�b H�j 9 B_> $ N O /�AJA N Q?/ D <I5 M < M N @ - / D j 9 �0O\@G/ M <?H W <?@ HB<IQ N U�5 9$ <IQ /�K�HL<8/�HB3JUfbcAJ< DGF @L< /�5 @B<I5�K�QI<?H Q N U D <?U D 3 N U � N U�< DBF @B<?/�5 W[<I@+U N 5�< � 36AJA @B<?Uf5�<?@ DGF <HG/ M < HBQ?<IU�< / D >c9GF O\@G/ M <?H%W[<I@#HB<IQ N Uf5 9 g N U D <IU D 3 N U�3JH A6<?HLH N O /�U 3JHBHLK�< � 3 DGF M N @B<M < M N @ - � H N)DGF < HL<?Q N U�5 DBF @B<?/�58U N @ M /�A6A - 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB<IH DBF <0O\@G/ M <0@G/ D <�9

��.A3". � ������ �"� � � �(������� �(��! ����� ��� � ����� � �����"� � $ ���) N @X/ M N @L<�Q N U�Q?@L< D <�K�U�5f<?@BH D /�Uf5�3JU�b N O DGF <�3 M W�/�Q D N O D @G/�UfH M 3 DBD 3JU�b�5Y/ D / N 1c<I@

DGF <)U�< D � N @!� � � < M <?/�HBK�@L< DGF < D 3 M <THLW[<IU D ,�- DGF <TW�@ N b�@G/ M W[<I@LO N @ M 36U�b Q N M W�K D / D 3 N U/�U�5�Q N M%M K�U�36Q / D 3 N U 5�K D 36<?H � 3 DGF /�5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5�1 N A6K M <�9 ) N @ DBF 3JH D <?H D � < KfHB< D 3 M <H D <?W hch B N O DGF < �:3JQ F�D MT- <I@ � > <?H F � N 1 5Y/ D /f9 � U DGF 36H=WY/�@ D 3JQIK�AZ/ @ D <?H D <?/�Q F O\@G/ M < D / ��<IH� K�H D K�Uf5�<?@ N U�<%HB<?Q N U�5 DBN @L<?U�5�<I@?9XR F < @B<?Uf5�<?@ DGF @L< /�5�H HBW <?Uf5 N U / 1�<?@G/ bc<DIEe9A>CB M H

� /�3 D 3JU�bXO N @ /�HBHL3JbcU M <?U D H O\@ N M DGF < HBK�W <?@ 1e36H N @ � E h�j 9 D M H @G/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b � /�U�5 D�e9 h > M HQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ D 36U�b Q N U D @ N A 5Y/ D / � 3 DBF8DBF <THLK�W <?@L1436H N @I9 � U N�DGF <?@ � N @L5�H � H � N O DGF < D 3 M <3JH HBW <?U D @L<?U�5f<?@B36U�b � De9VB � N O DGF < D 3 M <%3JH HBW <?U D Q N M M K�U�3JQ?/ D 36U�b � 3 DBF DGF < HBKfW[<I@L143JH N @/�U�58@ N K�b F A - DGF < HB/ M <_/ M N K�U D:N O D 3 M <=3JHaHLW[<IU D � /�3 D 3JU�b+O N @ � N @%�;9R F <+@B/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b D 3 M < 36H M KfQ F F 3Jb F <?@ DGF /�U DBF / D HBW <?U D 3JU DGF <THBW F <I@B<��;/ ��< D <?H DiN O

HBK , HB<IQ D 3 N UF�9 h 9 k W�/�@ D 3Z/�A6A - , <IQ /�K�HL< N O DGF <(<�� D @G/ D 3 M <aHBW <?U D M /�UY/�b�3JU�b DBF <�5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - 9�� U#OP/�Q D FUD � N O DBF <0@B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b D 3 M <�36H^HBW <?U D /�QIQ?<IHBHB36U�b DGF <i5Y/ D / � F /�A ON O � F 3JQ F 36H D 3 M < HBW <?U D 36U Q?/�Q F < F 3 D H /�Uf5 F /�A O�36U Q?/�Q F < M 3JHLHB<IH?9 � UT/21�<?@B/�bc< <?/�Q FTDBF @B<?/�5HBW <?Uf5�H h > Df9 D M H /�Q?QI<?HBHL3JU�b Q /�Q F <?5 5Y/ D / � /�U�5 h > j 9GD M H0O\< D Q F 3JUfb @L< M N�D < 5Y/ D /f9%R F <M 3JHBH D 3 M <03JH:5�<?W <?Uf5�<?U D K�W N U DGF < U�< D � N @%� , /�U�5 � 365 DGF � DBF < @ N K�Uf5 D @L3JW D 3 M <_/�Uf5 DGF <HB<I@L143JQI< D 3 M < N U DBF <0@B< M N�D < , A N Q,� HL<?@ 1e36U�b U N 5�<?HI9 R F < F 3 D^D 3 M < M /���<?H:/)WY/ @ D 36Q?K�AJ/�@BA -/ DLD @G/ Q D 3 1c<:Q F�N 36Q?<aO N @ N W D 3 M 3�?/ D 3 N U , <?Q / K�HB<(3 D 36H <IU D 3J@L<?A - 3JU�5f<?W <?U�5�<IU D N O DGF <:U�< D � N @!� �/�U�5 M 3Jb F�D , <_3 M W�@ N 1c<I5 � 3 DGF H M /�A6A W�@ N bc@B/ M M N 5�3 ]YQ / D 3 N U�H?9

� �

��.A3".#- R � � � � � ����� � ��Q �����"� � $ ���) 3JU�/�AJA - � � <TQ N M WY/�@L< DGF <T5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5�@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@ DBN � � �(/ - N U D 3 M < H D <?W hIH j N O DGF <

�:3JQ F�D MT- <?@ � >�<IH F � N 1�5Y/ D / HB< D 9 � U DBF < Q?AJKfH D <I@ � � <%HL<?A6<?Q D_DBF < WY/�@G/ M < D <?@LH DGF / D � <?@L<O N K�Uf5 DGN - 3J<IAJ5 DBF < F 3Jb F <?H D 3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1e3 D - O N @ DBF 3JH 1 N AJK M < � M /�Q?@ N QI<?A6A�Q N U�H N AJ3J5�/ D <I5/�QIQ?<?HLH DBN , A N Q,��H � 5f3J@B<IQ D M /�W�W <?5EQ?/�Q F 3JUfb � /�U�5 k�h � $ , A N Q,��H?9 C A DGF�N Kfb F H D / D 36Q/�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D 36H#OP/�H D <?@ N U DGF 36H 5Y/ D / HB< D � � < KfHB<�5 - UY/ M 3JQ D 36AJ< / HBHB36bcU M <?U D8N U , N�DBFM /�Q F 3JUf<?H_/�U�5 F�N A65�/�AJA /�5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A @L<?U�5f<?@_HB< DBD 36U�bcH_Q N U�H D /�U D 9 ) 3Jb�K�@B<�Be9?> j H F�N � H DGF <@B<IQ N @L5�<?5XO\@G/ M <=@B/ D <IH N U DGF <_Q?A6K�H D <?@ � 3 DGFXN U�<_/�Uf5 D � N%DBF @B<?/�5�H:W <?@aU N 5�<_/�U�5 N U DGF <d + � 9 R F < / 1�<?@G/ bc<+O\@G/ M <T@B/ D <IH N 1c<I@ DGF <)HL<?HBHL3 N U / @B<>c9 j � >c9 D E � /�Uf5 F�9 D E O\@G/ M <?HiW[<I@HB<IQ N Uf5 O N @ DGF <8HB36U�bcA6< DBF @B<?/�5 � 5fKY/�A DGF @L< /�5 /�U�5 HBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D <?@ D <?H D H � @B<?HLW[<IQ D 361c<IA - 9(�3 DBF <?`�KY/�A U4K M+, <I@ N O W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @BH DBF <?U DGF <0Q?AJKfH D <I@a3JH^@ N K�b F A - N U�<0`�KY/�@ D <I@ DGF <0HLW[<I<?5N O DGF <Td + � � / U�5 � 3 DGFXD � N Wf@ N Q?<?HLH N @LHiW <?@(U N 5�< � DGF < QIAJK�H D <?@(3JH(@ N K�b F A - N U�< � DGF 3J@B5 DGF <HBW <?<I5 9> N @L< <���/ Q D A - � DGF < @L<?AZ/ D 361�< W[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?< 1 /�@B36<?H � 3 DGF�DGF < 5�<Ibc@B<I< DBN � F 36Q F�DGF <

Q?A6K�H D <?@ Q / U ��<I<?W#3 D H Q?/�Q F <?H ]YAJA6<?5 9 � U DBF <a]Y@BH D F / A6O N O DBF < D <?H D � � 3 DBF%DBF <:<?U D 36@B<:1 N A6K M <

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

0 100 200 300 400 500 600

Fra

me

Rat

e [fr

ames

/sec

]

Frame Number

SGICluster 2 Threads per nodeCluster 1 Thread per node

�%����� � �".#- R 9 g AJK�H D <?@a1�<?@BHLK�HideK�W <?@BQ N M W�K D <I@?9

� �

3JU0143J< � � DBF < 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5_@B<IU�5�<?@L<?@ H D @BK�bcb�AJ<?H DBN � <?<IW DGF < Q?/�Q F < A N /�5f<?5 � /�U�5 Q N U�HB36H D <IU D A -WY/ - H DGF < M 36HBH W[<IUY/�A D - 9VR F <i< � <?Q D 3JH W�/�@ D 3JQ?KfAZ/�@LA - 5f<?AJ< D <I@B3 N K�H^/�@ N K�U�5 O\@G/ M <?H h�jcj / U�5h B j � F <?@L< DGF < 143J< � W N 36U D 3JH `�K�3JQ,��A - @ N�D / D 3JU�b /�@ N K�U�5 DBF < 1 N AJK M < 9 C^D DGF <IHB<#W N 3JU D HDGF <03JH N HBK�@ OP/�Q?<036H^HB<I<?U N UX/�UX<?5�b�< � /�Uf5 M N H DaN O DGF <03 M / bc<i36H^< M W D - 9 R F <05f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5Q / Q F <?H0/ @B<TU N�D / , AJ< DGN ]YAJA `�K�36Q,�4A - <?U N Kfb F�DGN%D / � <+/�5e1�/ U D /�bc< N O DGF 3JH(HB3 D KY/ D 3 N U 9 R F <d + �i5 N <?H_U N D HLK � <?@_O\@ N M DBF 3JH0Wf@ N , A6< M 9 (�3 DGF DBF < <?U D 36@B<)1 N A6K M <%36U 1e36< � � DGF < d + �/ 1c<I@G/�bc<IH B49 H >)O\@B/ M <IH0W[<I@0HB<IQ N U�5 � /�Uf5 DBF < Q?AJKfH D <I@_/ 1c<?@B/�bc<IH�>c9 FUD#O\@G/ M <IH0W[<I@ HL<?Q N U�5

� 3 DBF8D � N DBF @B<?/�5�H(W[<I@:U N 5f<�9 � U DGF 36H:W N @ D 3 N U N O DBF < D <?H D � DGF <_QIAJK�H D <?@(3JH:QIA N HL<?H D(DGN DGF <d + �^/ D O\@B/ M < >CB � � F <?@L<T3 D AZ/�bcH ,�- k O\@G/ M <?H:W <?@(HB<?Q N U�5 9 � D AJ/�bcH DGF < M N H D / D O\@B/ M <> � � � F <?@L< 3 D 36H9> j O\@G/ M <?HiW[<I@0HB<?Q N U�5 HBA N � <?@I9 ( F <?U DBF < <?U D 36@B<+1 N AJK M <+3JHi3JU 143J< � �Q / Q F <XA N /�5f3JU�b M / � <?H DGF < 5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 @B<?Uf5�<?@L<?@ @BK�U / D , < D � <?<IU N Uf< D <?U DGF /�U�5 N Uf<DGF 3J@B5 DBF <_HBW <?<?5 N O DGF < d + � 9

( F <?U DGF <:143J< � W N 36U D 36H NeN M <?5%3JU N U / H M /�A6A�W N @ D 3 N U N O DBF <(5Y/ D / � DBF <:O\@G/ M <:@G/ D <3JH)Q N M W�K D < , N K�Uf5 / U�5 DBF < Q?A6K�H D <?@ W�@ N bc@G/ M Q?A N HB<IA - O N AJA N � H � � �(/ - 9 � U DGF <8HL<?Q N U�5F /�A O N O DGF < D <?H D � DGF <Td + �^/ 1c<I@G/�b�<?H F�9A> H O\@B/ M <IHaW[<I@�HL<?Q N U�5 � /�U�5 DGF <_QIAJK�H D <?@(/ 1c<I@G/�b�<?Hh 9 B �O\@G/ M <?H)W <?@)HL<?Q N U�5 � 3 DGF�D � N�DBF @B<?/�5�H W[<I@)U N 5�<�9 R F <X@B<IAZ/ D 361�<#W[<I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< 36HM N @B<�Q N U�HL3JH D <?U D � 3 DBF /�O N Q?KfHB<?5�143J< � 9 ��<I@B< DGF < QIAJK�H D <I@ H D / - H , < D � <I<?U�>�9�IE�/ U�5>c9 hIH O\@B/ M <?H W[<I@ HB<IQ N Uf5 HBA N � <?@ DGF /�U DGF <=d + � 9 ( F <IU DGF <�Q /�Q F <?H:/�@L<(]YA6AJ<I5 � DBF <iQIAJK�H D <I@@BKfU�H:Q N U�HL3JH D <?U D A - / D D j � N O DGF < d + �,� H:O\@B/ M <0@G/ D <�9

������� ����� �

� " � ��$ � �:� " � � ���E� ! � � ����� � " ���

(�< F / 1�< H F�N � U DBF / D 3 D 3JH W N HLHB3 , AJ< DBN 1436HBKY/�A63�I< M K�A D 3 ��+ 36b�/ ,�- D < 1 N AJK M < D @B3JQ 5Y/ D / HB< D H3JU D <?@G/ Q D 3 1c<IA - K�HB36U�b)Q?A6K�H D <?@LH?9�( <0K�HB< DBF <=@B/ - D @B/�Q?36U�b)/�A6b N @L3 DGF M � � F 36Q F 3JH � <?A6A ��U N � UO N @�W�@ N 5�K�QI3JU�b / Q?Q?Kf@G/ D < � F 36b F `�KY/�A63 D - 3 M /�bc<IH?9=R F <)/�AJb N @B3 DGF M 36Hi3JU F <?@L<?U D A - WY/ @G/�A6AJ<?A �� F 36Q F M / � <?H 3 D /=UY/ D Kf@G/�AeQ F�N 3JQI<^O N @VAJ/�@Bbc< WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A4Q N M W�K D <?@ H - H D < M H?9 R F <(/�5f1 /�U D /�b�<b�/�36U�<?5 3JU K�HB36U�b / QIAJK�H D <I@T3JH W�@B3 M / @B3JA - / U <?Q N U N M 3JQ N U�< 9 C QIAJK�H D <I@T3JH HB36bcU�3 ]YQ /�U D A -AJ<IHBHa<��fW <?UfHB361�< DBF /�U8/�U <I`4Kf361 /�AJ<IU DaD 3Jb F�D A - Q N K�W�AJ<I5XWY/�@G/ AJAJ<IA M /�Q F 36U�< � /�U�5XH N)DGF <0U�< �W�@ N bc@G/ M H FfN K�AJ5 M / ��<036U D <?@B/�Q D 361c<0143JHLKY/�A63� / D 3 N U N O AZ/�@Lbc<=5Y/ D /�HB< D H M N @B<_/ 1 /�3JAJ/ , AJ< 9

( F <?U W�@ N bc@G/ M%M 3JU�b O N @ /:Q?A6K�H D <?@ <?U�143J@ N U M <?U D DGF < 3 M%M <?5�3J/ D < W�@ N , AJ< M 3JH DGN ]YU�5 /

� / - DGN � N 36U DBF <aHB<IWY/�@G/ D <^W�@ N QI<?HLHB<?H DBF / D M / ��< K�W DGF < WY/�@G/ AJAJ<IAeWf@ N bc@B/ M 9 � K�@ W�@ N b�@G/ MK�HL<?H�& <Ibc3 N U � / M 36U�3 M /�AJ36H D Q N M%M K�Uf3JQ / D 3 N U�H AJ3 , @G/�@ -=, Kf3JA D N U DGN W N OYR g � 9 R F < AJ3 , @G/ @ - � HQ / WY/ , 36AJ3 D 3J<IHa/�@B< M N 5�KfAZ/�@ - < D <��%Q?3J<IU D � < /�Q F O\<?/ D Kf@B< 3JH N W D 3 N UY/ A � /�Uf5�Q / U , < N M 3 DLD <I5DGN @B<I5�K�Q?< N 1�<?@ F < /�5 9 � U F < /�5 � DGN�� F < / 5 D <IH D H & <?bc3 N U 36H H N M < � F / D HBA N � <?@ DGF / U@G/ �H N Q,��< D Q /�A6AJH � OP/ H D <I@ DBF /�U >�� � g � � /�U�5 @ N K�b F A - <?`�KY/ A DGN & C > � >�� � 9 & <?bc3 N U HLK�W�W N @ D HM K�A D 3 DGF @L< /�5�<I5+Q?A6K�H D <?@ / W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N UfH DBF / D / @B< W�/�@G/�A6AJ<IA , N�DBF � 3 DGF 3JU)/�Uf5 , < D � <I<?U%U N 5�<?HI9C H - U�Q F @ N U N K�H M <?HBHB/�bc< F /�U�5�A63JU�b�3JU & <?b�3 N U F <?AJWfH DGN O\@L<?<^Q N M WfK D / D 3 N U�/�A DGF @L< /�5�H O\@ N MQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ D 3 N U#5�<IAZ/ - H?9R F <:@G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�biW�@ N b�@G/ M � / H 5�<?@L361c<I5%O\@ N M � � �(/ - � � F 36Q F @BK�U�H N U%H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ -

WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A M /�Q F 3JU�<IH?9VR N QI@B<?/ D < DGF <:U�< � W�@ N bc@G/ M � � <�365�<?U D 36]Y<I5 / AJA N O DGF <:5�<IW[<IU�5�<IU�Q?36<?H, < D � <?<?U&O\K�U�Q D 3 N UY/�A=K�Uf3 D H 36U � � �(/ - � /�U�5&K�HB<I5 & <Ibc3 N U DBN�D @G/ U�H M 3 D DGF < M N 1c<?@ DGF <U�< D � N @%�;9 R F < 5�3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 Wf@ N bc@B/ M 3JH Q /�WY/ , AJ< N O 3JU D <I@G/�Q D 3 1c<?A - @B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b�HLQ?<?Uf<?HQ N U D /�3JUf3JU�b D � N M 3JAJA63 N U W N A - b N U�H(/ D:D � N O\@B/ M <IH:W[<I@(HL<?Q N U�5 ,�- @B<IW�AJ36Q / D 3JU�b DBF < HBQ?<IU�<5Y/ D / , /�HL< 36U <?/�Q F U N 5�< � H M < M N @ - 9 R <IH D H H F�N � DGF / D 3 D 36H U N�D KfU�Q N M%M N U O N @ j � N O DGF <@B<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb D 3 M < DBN , < HLW[<IU D 3JU8Q N M W�K D / D 3 N U 9 ( F <IU DGF < W�@ N bc@G/ M 3JH:Q N M W�K D < � , N KfU�5

� �

DGF < O\@G/ M < @G/ D <�3JH�@ N K�b F A - <?`�KY/�A DBNDGF / D N O � � �(/ - 9 ) N @�AJ<?HLH 5�< M /�U�5f3JU�b�HLQ?<?Uf<?HDGF < U�< D � N @!�&W[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?< , <IQ N M <?H DGF < , N DBD A6<?U�<IQ,� � /�U�5 DBF < < 1c<IU D KY/�A O\@G/ M < @G/ D <AJ3 M 3 D / D 3 N U 5�<?W <?U�5fH�K�W N U DBF <�U�K M+, <?@ N O D 3JA6<?H83JU DGF < 3 M /�bc<�9 C H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ -HBKfW[<I@BQ N M W�K D <?@ 5 N <IHVU N�D HBK � <?@ O\@ N M DGF < HG/ M < AJ3 M 3 D / D 3 N U � , K D � 3 DBFTD <IU�H N O;Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB36U�b<?A6< M <?U D H 36U�H D < /�5 N O F K�Uf5�@B<I5�H � , N�DBF Wf@ N bc@B/ M H W�@ N 5�K�QI<�HL3 M 3JAZ/ @ O\@G/ M <a@B/ D <IH?9 ( < F /21�<N , HL<?@ 1c<?5 HLK�H D /�3JUf<?5 O\@B/ M < @B/ D <IH N OVK�W DGN D j O\@B/ M <?H:W[<I@�HL<?Q N U�5 � N U)B=> h ��B=> h 3 M /�bc<IH �, K D M N @B< D - W�36Q /�A6A - N , D /�3JU , < D � <?<?U > /�U�5 h�j O\@G/ M <?HaW <?@:HB<IQ N Uf5 9deQ?36<?U D 3 ]YQ=5Y/ D /THL< D H:/ @B<=bc@ N � 3JU�b � 3 DGF DBF <0/ , 3JAJ3 D - N O Q N M W�K D <?@LH DGN b�<?U�<I@G/ D < DGF < M 9

g AJKfH D <I@ � , /�HB<I5 143JHLKY/�A63� / D 3 N U N O AJ/�@Bbc<^1 N AJK M <IH 36H W�@ N , AJ< M / D 3JQ O N @ DBF @B<I<�@L< /�H N U�H?9 ) 3J@BH D �k�h � , 3 D � g � HVQ /�UfU N�D / Q?Q?<IHBH M N @B< DGF /�U F + 3Jbc/ ,�- D <?H N O M < M N @ - � H N H N M < AJ/�@Bb�< HLQ?3J<IU D 36]�Q5Y/ D /�HL< D H Q / U U N�D , < @L<?W�A63JQ?/ D <I5 N U DBN A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - 9de<IQ N Uf5 � W�@ N QI<?HBH N @BH F / 1c< U N/�K DBN M / D 36Q M < /�UfH DGN /�QIQ?<IHBH DGF < M < M N @ - � 3 DGF 36U�@B< M N D <+U N 5�<IH?9 R F 3J@L5 � DGF <+U�< D � N @%�Q N U�U�<?Q D 3 N U , < D � <I<?U U N 5f<?H 3JH HB36bcU�36]�Q /�U D A - HBA N � <?@ DBF /�U M < M N @ - /�Q?QI<?HLH � 3 DGF 36U)/=U N 5�<�9( <TK�HL< & <?bc3 N U � Hi5�36H D @B3 , K D <I5�H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - DGN M /���< DGF <T/�bcbc@L<?b�/ D < M < M N @ - HBWY/�QI</ 1 /�3JAJ/ , AJ< DGN <I1c<I@ - @L<?U�5f<?@B36U�b DGF @B< / 5 9 R F 3JH+36H)/�U N , � <IQ D � , /�HL<?5 ._df> � � F 3JQ F M / ��<IHDGF < k�h � , 3 D /�5�5�@L<?HBH%AJ3 M 3 D 36@B@B<IAJ< 1�/ U D 9 R F <�AZ/ @Bbc<IH D 5Y/ D / , /�HL< DBF / D � < F / 1c< D <IH D <I5 36H/�U + 3Jb�/ ,�- D <85Y/ D / HL< D � F 3JQ F @L<?U�5f<?@BH#/ D , < D � <?<IU j 9 B /�U�5 �O\@B/ M <IH W <?@ HB<IQ N U�5 9g /�Q F 36U�b 3JH DGF < � < - DBN N 1c<?@LQ N M 3JUfb DGF <)HLA N � <?@=U�< D � N @!� /�QIQ?<IHBH D 3 M < 9 $ - <IAJ3 M 36UY/ D 36U�bK�U�Uf<?Q?<IHBHB/�@ - /�U�5 @L<?5�K�Uf5Y/�U D /�Q?QI<?HBHL<?H DGN0DGF <a5�/ D / � � < N , D /�3JU F 3 D @G/ D <?H N O[bc@L< / D <?@ DGF /�UEUB � M N H D:N O DGF < D 3 M < 9�� U DBF <_]YUY/�A Q N M W�/�@B36H N U � DGF <_Q?A6K�H D <?@:@B<IU�5�<I@BH M K�A D 3 ��+ 36b�/ ,�- D <5Y/ D /%HL< D Hi/ D @ N K�b F A - N Uf< DBF 3J@L5 DBF < @G/ D < N OV/ HBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D <?@ DGF / D Q N H D H D <?U D 3 M <?H:/ HM K�Q F 9R F <XQ?A6K�H D <?@ � , /�HL<?5 @B<IU�5�<?@L<?@ 5 N <?H F / 1�<83 M W N @ D /�U D 5f3JHG/ 5f1 /�U D /�bc<IH?9 R F < U�< D � N @%�

5�< D <?@ M 36U�<?5 O\@B/ M < @G/ D < A63 M 3 D / D 3 N U�H F / 1c< , <?<IU�5�3JHLQ?K�HLHB<I5 36U 5�< D /�3JA 9 C U N�DGF <I@+5�36HG/�5 �1 /�U D /�b�< 3JH DGF / DTDGF <#HBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D <?@ � H+H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - F /�@L5 � /�@B< M / � <?H+3 D <?/�HB36<?@ DBNM N 5�3 O - DBF < Wf@ N bc@B/ M 9 ) N @_3JUfH D / U�Q?< � 3JU DGF < U�< � W�@ N bc@G/ M /�K��e3JA63Z/�@ - 5�36HBW�AJ/ - H � � F 3JQ FAJ< D+DGF < K�HB<I@)Q N U D @ N A^WY/ @ D 36Q?K�AJ/�@ N , � <?Q D H � 3 DBF 3JU DBF < HBQI<?U�< � Uf<?<?5 DGN F /21�< DGF <I3J@+H D / D <Q F /�Ufbc<?H_<?UfQ N 5�<?5�3JU DGN#DBF < )Y@G/ M <2d D / D <+H D @BK�Q D K�@L<�9 � U DGF < N @B3Jb�3JUY/�A W�@ N bc@B/ M DBF <)K�HB<I@3JU D <?@LOP/ Q?<aQ?AJ/�HBHL<?H /�Uf5 DBF < N , � <IQ D Q?AJ/�HBHL<?H Q N K�AJ5)HL3 M W�A - @B< O\<?@ DBN <?/�Q F)DGF @ N K�b F /=W N 3JU D <?@?9R F < HG/ M <)36H D @BKf< N O^/ U - Q F /�U�bc<IH DBN DGF <)K�HL<?@_3JU D <?@LOP/ Q?< N O DGF < W�@ N bc@B/ M /�H_/ � F�N AJ<�9

� �

R F < K�HB<I@�5�36@B<IQ D A - 3JU D <I@G/�Q D H � 3 DBF8DBF < HLK�W <?@L1436H N @�U N 5f<T/�Uf5 DBF < M <?Q F / U�3JH M ,�- � F 3JQ FDGF <iHBKfW[<I@L143JH N @ 36U D <?@B/�Q D H � 3 DGF DBF < � N @%��<?@LH F /�H DGN , <�W�@ N bc@G/ M%M <?5 9 C U N�DBF <?@ <��f/ M W�A6<3JH DBF / D%N K�@ N , � <IQ D � , /�HL<?5�._de> @L<?`�K�3J@L<?H DGF / D H F /�@B<I5 5Y/ D / 3 D < M H / @B<83JU�5�<��e<?5 � / U�5DGF / D /�Q?QI<?HLHB<?H DGN�DBF <X5Y/ D / F / 1c< DGN , < bcKY/�@L5�<?5 ,�- /�QI`4Kf3J@B<X/ U�5 @B<?A6< /�HL< N W <?@G/ D 3 N U�H?9R F <IHB< /�Q?QI<?HBH HL< M /�U D 3JQIH M / � < 3 D U N U D @B3 143Z/�A O N @ /�U /�W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U�Wf@ N bc@B/ M%M <I@ DGN K�HL<DGF <)5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 H F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - 9 R F 36H_3JH=36U Q N U D @B/�H D_DBN#DGF < d + �,� H F /�@B5 � /�@L<%H F /�@L<?5M < M N @ - H - H D < M � � F 3JQ F AJ< D H DBF <%W�@ N b�@G/ M%M <I@ D @L< / D DGF <%H F /�@B<I5 N , � <IQ D H <��f/�Q D A - A63���<DGF <)@B<?H D_N O DGF <)Q N U D <IU D H N O DBF < M < M N @ - 9 R F <%Q N U�HL<?`�K�<?UfQ?<%3JH DBF / D @B<IU�5�<I@B<?5�H F /�W[<IHF / 1c< DBN , < M /�5�<^._df> � / � /�@B< DBN , <aH F /�@L<?5 � /�Uf5%H N OP/�@ N UfA - 1 N A6K M < D @L3JQ 5�/ D / F / H , <I<?UM N 5�3 ]Y<?5 DBN � N @%�#3JU DGF 3JHaH - H D < M 9R F < D @B<IU�5�H DBF / D M N�D 3 1�/ D <?5 DBF 3JH8@B<IHB< / @BQ F /�@L< A63�� <?A - DGN Q N U D 36U�K�<�9 g N M W�K D <?@LH

/�@L< , <?Q N M 3JU�b�Q F <?/�W <?@ /�U�5EOP/�H D <?@ � /�U�5 DGF < Q N U�U�<?Q D 3 N U�H , < D � <I<?U Q N M W�K D <I@BH�/�@L<bc< DBD 36U�b `�K�36Q,��<I@?9 � N � < 1c<?@ � W�@ N QI<?HBH N @�HLW[<I<?5�H / @B<�3 M Wf@ N 143JU�b�OP/�H D <?@ DGF / U U�< D � N @%�@G/ D <?H /�@L<�9 & NeN HB<?A - Q N K�W�AJ<I5�WY/ @G/�A6AJ<?A M /�Q F 36U�<?H � 3JU�QIAJK�5f3JU�b Q?A6K�H D <?@LH � DGF <�bc@L3J5 � / U�5@B<IAZ/ D <?5 D <IQ F U N A N bc36<?H � /�@B< , <?Q N M 36U�b M N @B< Wf@B<I1 /�A6<?U D /�H�/�@B<IHBK�A D N O DGF <IHB< D @B<IU�5�HI9( < F / 1�< H F�N � U DGF / D U�< D � N @!� HLW[<I<?5 36H_/�AJ@L< /�5 - HBK �%Q?36<?U D O N @_3JU D <I@G/�Q D 361�< @B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b�9deK , HB<?Q D 3 N U�H Ff9 h 9 k /�U�5 B49 h 9GE H F�N � DGF / D Uf< D � N @!�8/�QIQ?<?HLH D 3 M <036H N U�A - /%H M /�AJA[O\@G/�Q D 3 N UN O N K�@ W�@ N b�@G/ M � H @LK�U�U�36U�b D 3 M <�9 $ <?Q?/�K�HL< DGF <�U�< D � N @!� 3JH U N�D DGF <�W�@L3 M /�@ -T, N DBD A6<?U�<IQ,� �DGF <_OP/ H D <I@:bc@ N � DGF8N O Q N M W�K D 3JU�b D <?Q F U N A N b - � 3JA6A U N�D M / � < N K�@ D <?Q F U�3J`�K�<IH�36@B@B<IAJ< 1�/ U DO N @ H N M < - <?/�@BH DBN Q N M <�9 � U DBF <0Q N U D @G/�@ - � � < , <IAJ36<I1c< DGF / D 3 D � 3JAJA , <?Q N M <=< 1c<IU M N @B<3 M W N @ D /�U D DGN ]YU�5 � / - H DGN K�HL<iA N4N HL<?A - ��U�3 D H - H D < M H <��%Q?3J<IU D A - 9�� U DBF <(HG/ M < � / - DGF / DM N 5�<I@BU M < M N @ - F 36<?@B/�@BQ F 36<?H , @B3J5fbc< DGF <)b�/�W , < D � <?<?U�W�@ N QI<?HBH N @0HBW <?<I5�/ U�5 M < M N @ -/�QIQ?<?HLH D 3 M < � D <?Q F U�3J`�K�<IH%A63�� < N K�@)KfHB< N O(/�H - U�Q F @ N U N K�H M <IHBHB/�bc< F / U�5�AJ36U�b /�Uf5�A N Q /�A5Y/ D /)Q /�Q F 36U�b � 3JAJA , <IQ N M < M N @B<=3 M W N @ D /�U D 3JU DBF <0O\K D K�@L<�9

);/�H D <?@)U�< D � N @%��H � OP/ H D <I@)W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @BH � /�Uf5 AJ/�@Bb�<?@+A N Q?/�A M < M N @ - HLWY/�Q?<IH � 3JAJA /�AJA N �M N @B<+Q N M W�AJ<���HLQ?<?Uf<?H DGN , <)@B<?Uf5�<?@L<?5 M N @L<+@B<?/�AJ36H D 3JQ / AJA - / D_F 3Jb F <?@=@B/ D <IH03JU DBF <)U�< / @O\K D K�@B< 9 � D M / -�, <XW N HLHB3 , AJ< DGN 3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB< DGF < W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< N O DGF <8Wf@ N bc@B/ M � 3 DGF�N K D

� /�3 D 3JU�b O N @ OP/�H D <I@ F /�@B5 � /�@L< � DGF @ N K�b F 1 /�@L3 N KfH N W D 3 M 3� / D 3 N U�HI9 C OP/�H D <?@X@L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b<?Ufbc3JU�<T3JH=5�<IHB36@G/ , A6<+U N�D_N U�A - , <IQ /�KfHB<)3 D Q /�U , <+K�HB<I5 DBN 3 M W�@ N 1�<+3 M /�bc< `4K�/�AJ3 D - � , K D

� �

/�A6H N , <?Q?/�K�HB< 3 D � 3JA6A D / ��<+O\< � <I@_U N 5f<?H DBN / DBD /�3JU DBF <)HG/ M <TO\@B/ M <T@G/ D <?H � A N � <?@B36U�b DGF <Q N H D(N O 3JU D <I@G/�Q D 361�<_@B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b�9R F 3JH DGF <IHB36H F / H W�@L<?HL<?U D <I5 / U#/�UY/ A - HB36H N O DGF <(W�@ N bc@G/ M � N , D /�3JUf<?5 O\@ N M W <?@ O N @ M 3JU�b

/#HB<I@B36<?H N O , <?U�Q F M /�@%��H?9 C 5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A D <IH D H0Q /�U , < DLD <?@i5�< D <?@ M 3JUf<+<��f/�Q D A - � F / D W�/�@ D HU�<I<?5 DBN , <X3 M W�@ N 1c<I5 9 ) N @ 36U�H D /�U�Q?< � N K�@ W�@ N bc@B/ M K�HL<?H R g � 36U�H D < /�5 N O DBF < S�HB<[email protected]/ D /�bc@G/ M � @ N�DGN Q N A � Si.� �0, <?Q?/�K�HB< R g � <?U�HLK�@B<IH)@B<IAJ3Z/ , AJ< D @B/�U�HLW N @ D 9 C U /�UY/�A - HB3JHN O DBF <+U�K M+, <?@ N O 5�@ N WfW[<I5 WY/�Q,��< D H N U DBF <+U�< D � N @!� � N K�A65�H FfN � DGN � F / D <�� D <?U D0DGF <@B<IAJ3J/ , 3JA63 D - <?UfO N @LQ?< M <IU DXN 1�<?@ F < /�5�3JH U�<?QI<?HLHG/�@ - 9 C AJH N � DGF <�@B<IU�5�<?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H HLW[<IU�5�/HB36bcU�3 ]YQ /�U D / M N KfU D^N O D 3 M < � /�3 D 3JU�b+O N @ D /�H%��H�/ U�5X5Y/ D /e9 C M N @L<=<��f/�Q D /�Q?Q N K�U D 36U�b N ODGF < W�@ N bc@B/ M H F�N K�AJ5 W N 36U D N K DTFfN � , <IH DTDBN M 3JUf3 M 3�?< DGF < � / 3 D D 3 M <�9 & /�H D A - � g � SH D / D 36H D 3JQ?H0Q N K�A65 , < N , D /�36U�<?5 DGN 5�< D <I@ M 3JU�< FfN � < �%Q?36<?U D A - DBF < W�@ N b�@G/ M 3JH0/�QIQ?<IHBHB36U�bDGF < M < M N @ - F 3J<?@B/�@BQ F - � � F 36Q F M 3Jb F�D AJ<?/�5 DBN DGF <T5�< 1c<?A N W M <?U D=N O OP/�H D <?@i/�Q?QI<?A6<?@G/ D 3 N UH D @BK�Q D K�@L<?HI9

$ <?Q?/�K�HL< DGF <+Uf< D � N @!�8AZ/ - <I@=3JH:O\K�U�5�/ M <IU D /�A DGN DBF <TO\K�UfQ D 3 N U�36U�b N O DGF <+@B/ - D @G/�QI<?@ �3 D M / � <?H(HB<?UfHB< DGN%N W D 3 M 3�?<=3 D <I1�<?U DBF�N K�b F 3 D 36HaU N�D:DGF < W�@L3 M /�@ - , N�DBD AJ<?Uf<?Q,�;9ad N Q,��< DN W <?@B/ D 3 N U�H 36U�1 N A 1c< Q N U D <�� D H � 3 D Q F�N 1c<I@ F <?/�5 � F <?U DGF <�Uf< D � N @!�H - H D < M Q / AJAJH D @B/�WDGN H - H D < M HLWY/�QI<�9 C K�HB<I@ HLWY/�Q?<XU�< D � N @!� AZ/ - <I@)AJ3���< �� C � D � M 3Jb F�D - 3J<IAJ5 H N M < 3 M �W�@ N 1�< M <?U D 9 g N M W�@L<?HBHL3 N U8Q N K�AJ5 3 M W�@ N 1c< , / U�5 � 3J5 DGF K D 3JA63�?/ D 3 N U � <IHBW <?QI3Z/�A6A - O N @:AJ/�@Bbc<H F /�@B<I5%5�/ D / , @B3JQ,��HI9 C OP/�H D Q N M W�@L<?HBHL3 N UT@ N K D 3JU�< � 3 DBF / F 3Jb F Q N M W�@L<?HBHL3 N U)@B/ D 3 N � Q N K�A65HB36bcU�3 ]YQ /�U D A - @B<I5�K�Q?< DBF < , @L3JQ,� M 36HBH D 3 M < � / H=A N Ufb /�H DBF <)5�<?Q N M W�@B<IHBHB3 N U D 3 M < 3JH=A6<?HLHDGF /�U DGF < D 3 M < HB/21�<?5 D @B/�U�H M 3 DBD 36U�b(/iH M /�A6AJ<?@ H D @B<?/ M 9 � U�< /�W�W�@ N /�Q F � N K�AJ5 , < DGN M / � <DGF <i.0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@ � <?<?W Q N M W�@B<IHBHL<?5 Q N W�3J<IH N O DGF <�@B<IHB3J5f<?U D , A N Q,��H � /�Uf5#/�A6A N � @L<?`�K�<IH D 36U�b.0/ D /�de<?@ 1c<I@BH DGN 5�<?Q N M W�@B<IHBH , A N Q,��H N U DBF < � - 9C H�D F � , 3 D � g H , <?Q N M < / 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6<+3 D M / - M / � < HB<?UfHB< DBN @L<?W�AJ/�Q?< DGF < .0/ D /�de<I@L1c<I@

� 3 DBF /_W�/�bc< � , /�HL<?5%5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 H F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - 9 C D F � , 3 D W�/�bc< � , /�HL<?5%H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ -

� 3JA6A U N�D , <#AJ3 M 3 D <?5 DGN F + 3Jbc/ ,�- D <?H � / U�5 , @B36Q,� F 3 DTD 3 M < M / - , <#@B<I5�K�Q?<I5 ,�- K�HB36U�bDGF <T143J@ D KY/�A M < M N @ - F /�@B5 � /�@L< DGN 5�< D <IQ D H F /�@B<I5 M < M N @ - / Q?Q?<IHBHI9T> N @B< DGF /�U F /�A O N ON K�@ , @L3JQ,�8/�Q?QI<?HLH D 3 M <_3JH:HLW[<IU D 3JU85�< D <?Q D 3JU�b DGF <IHB< F 3 D H � H N DBF 3JH F /�Hi/ bc@L< / D W N D <?U D 3Z/�AO N @:3JUfQ?@B<?/�HB36U�b DBF < N 1�<?@B/�AJA O\@G/ M <_@G/ D <�9 C WY/�b�< � , /�HB<I5�H F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - � 3JA6A /�AJH N M / � <DGF < / W�W�AJ36Q / D 3 N U W�@ N b�@G/ M%M <I@BH � N , <?/�HB36<?@ � , <IQ /�K�HL< DBF < /�Q?`�K�36@B< /�U�58@B<IAJ<?/�HB<_HB< M / U D 3JQIH

� �

� 3JA6A , <(@B< M N 1�<?5 � /�U�5#H N 5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5 H F / W[<IH � 3JA6AYU N�D F / 1c< DBN , < M /�5�<�._df> � / � /�@L<i36UN @L5�<?@ DGN � N @!�;9C H � <=36U�Q?@L< /�HL< DBF <i@L< /�A63JH M N O N Kf@ 3 M /�b�<?H ,�- D @G/�QI3JU�b M N @B<:@G/ - H � � < � 36AJAYQI<?@ D /�3JUfA -

U�<I<?5 /�5�5�3 D 3 N UY/�A N W D 3 M 3�?/ D 3 N U 9 g N M W�K D / D 3 N U D 3 M < 36H N Kf@+W�@B3 M / @ -�, N DBD A6<?U�<IQ,� � / U�5/�5�5f3 D 3 N UY/�A AJ< 1c<IAJH N O(WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A63JH M M / - - 36<?AJ5 , < DLD <I@)W[<I@LO N @ M /�UfQ?<�9 $ - <��eW�A N 3 D 36U�b DGF <HB3 M K�A D /�U�< N K�H M KfA D 3 DGF @L< /�5f3JU�b0/ U�5 36U�H D @BK�Q D 3 N U � A6<I1c<IA�WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A63JH M W�@ N 1e365�<?5 ,�- DGF < � U D <IA�=< N U W�@ N Q?<IHBH N @BH N O N K�@=QIAJK�H D <?@ � � < F�N W < DGN /�QIQ?<IAJ<?@B/ D < DBF < Q N M W�K D / D 3 N UY/�A W F / HB< N O@G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b�9 R F <I@B< 3JH(/ b NeN 5XQ F /�U�QI< DBF / D � < M 3Jb F�D /�A6H N 3 M W�@ N 1�< DBF <_O\@G/ M <0@G/ D < ,�-K�HL3JU�b%/ M N @B< F 36b F A - HLW[<IQ?3J/�AJ3�?<?5 Q N M W�3JA6<?@?9 � U�3 D 3Z/�A 3JU�5f3JQ / D 3 N U�H N U � F < DGF <I@ DGF <_UY/ D 361�<� U D <IA0Q N M W�3JA6<?@ � 3JAJA�W�@ N 5�K�QI< OP/�H D <?@ Q N 5�< DGF /�U DGF < bcU�K&Q N M W�36AJ<?@ /�@B< 36U�Q N U�Q?A6K�HB3 1c<�9� U&/�U N�DBF <?@ 5f3J@B<IQ D 3 N U � � < Q N K�A65 D @ - DGN <��eW�A N 3 D DBF < bc@G/�W F 3JQIH#Q /�@L5�H 3JU N K�@ Q?A6K�H D <?@ �H D /�@ D 3JU�b � 3 DBF�DGF <T/�AJb N @B3 DGF M Wf@ N W N HB<I5 ,�- � K�@LQ?<IAJA < D /�A 9 � kcj�� 9(R F <+5�3 �%Q?K�A D WY/ @ D � 36AJA, <8<��%Q?3J<IU D A - Q N U D @ N AJA63JU�b DGF < � N � N O=5Y/ D / DGF @ N K�b F�N K D)DGF <8Q?A6K�H D <?@ , < D � <?<IUU N 5�<?H �W�@ N QI<?HBH N @BH � M < M N @ - � / U�5 DGF <_bc@B/�W F 36Q?H F /�@L5 � / @B<�9

(�<+O N K�U�5 DGF / D=DGF <)@B<?Uf5�<?@ DBF @B<?/�5�H0HBW <?Uf5 /#HL3JbcUf36]YQ?/�U D W N @ D 3 N U N O DGF <)@L<?U�5�<I@B36U�bD 3 M < � /�3 D 36U�b�9 � D � 36AJA , <:W�@ N 5�K�Q D 3 1c< DGN 3JU�1c<IH D 3Jb�/ D < D <IQ F U�3J`�K�<IH DBN � <?<IW DGF <:@B/ - D @G/ Q?3JUfbDGF @B< / 5�H , KfH - /�H N O D <?U/�H W N HLHB3 , AJ<�9 � U/�5�5�3 D 3 N U DBN D @ - 3JU�b / M N @B< /�5f1 /�UfQ?<?5 A N Q /�AD / H!� `�K�<IK�< � � <XW�AZ/ U DBN <��eW[<I@B3 M <IU D � 3 DGF W�@B< O\<?@L@B<?5 , 3Z/ H D /�H%��/�AJA N Q?/ D 3 N U�H D @B/ D <Ibc3J<IHDGF / D Q N M+, 36U�< DBF < , <?U�< ] D H N O H D / D 36Q+/�U�5�5 - UY/ M 3JQ D /�H!� /�HLHB3Jb�U M <IU D H D @G/ D <?bc36<?HI9=.0/ D /5�36H D @L3 , K D 3 N U�Q /�KfHB<?H /�5f5�3 D 3 N UY/ A � /�3 DiD 3 M <�9 �(/ - @B< N @B5�<I@B36U�b M / - HB3Jb�U�36]YQ?/�U D A - @L<?5�K�QI<DGF < M 3JHBH W <?UY/ A D - 9�� @L<IO\< D Q F 3JUfb D <IQ F U�36`4Kf<?H � � F 3JQ F / 3 M DBN @B<I`�K�<?H D M 36HBHL3JU�b 5Y/ D / , <IO N @L<3 D 3JH U�<?<I5�<?5 � Q N K�A65 , <=Q N MT, 3JU�<I5 � 3 DBF @G/ - D @G/ 1�<?@BHB/�A @L< N @L5�<?@L3JU�b � � F 36Q F M / � <?H DBF <=@G/ -W�@ N QI<?HBH Q / Q F <?5%5Y/ D /0]�@BH D 9�$ N�DBF N O DBF <?HL<�Q N K�A65 , <aQ N M+, 3JUf<?5 � 3 DBF DBF <(/ , 36AJ3 D - DBN WfAZ/�QI<H D /�AJA6<?5 @B/ - H N U F�N A65836U OP/21 N @ N O @G/ - H DBF / D /�@L<0@B< / 5 - DGN , < Wf@ N Q?<?HLHB<I5 9R F < U�<?<I5 O N @:/�5f5�3 D 3 N UY/ A[O\< / D K�@L<?H�/�U�5 , < DBD <I@:@B<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b%`�KY/�AJ3 D - 36H D /�U D / M N KfU DaDBN

DGF < U�<I<?5 O N @ OP/�H D <?@ @B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�bf9 C H DBF < Wf@ N bc@B/ M H D /�U�5fH 3 D 3JH / D @G/�5f3 D 3 N UY/�A ( F 3 DLD <I5 H D - A6<@G/ - D @G/�QI<?@?9 ) / H D bcA N , /�A 36AJAJK M 36UY/ D 3 N U /�U�5 g N4N � < � <IQ D H M / - , < /�5�5�<I5 9 C 5f5�3 D 3 N UY/ AJA - �@B<?/�AJ36H D 3JQ HBQ?<IU�<?H0@L<?`�K�36@B<+AJ/�@Bbc<I@iHLQ?<?Uf<)5Y/ D / , /�HB<IH � /�Uf5 / D=DBF < M N M <IU DiN UfA - >�� � / U�53JH N HBKf@LOP/�QI<^1 N A6K M < @B<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b_Q?/�U)K D 36AJ3�?< DBF <a5�36H D @L3 , K D <?5)H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - 9-� U DGF <aH F�N @ DD <I@ M � <�WfAZ/�U DGN <�� D <?U�5 DBF <(@G/ - D @B/�Q?<I@ DBN F /�U�5�A6< D 3 M <^1 /�@ - 36U�b 1 N AJK M <a5Y/ D /_HB< D H?9�( <

� �

/�U D 36Q?36WY/ D <#/ M 3JU N @T<�� D <?U�HL3 N U DGN DGF <XH N O D � / @B< DGN M / ��<X3 D K�HB<8HB< 1c<?@B/�A(.0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@LH3JU / HB36U�bcAJ<XW�@ N bc@B/ M 9 7 /�Q F D 3 M <#H D <?W � 3JAJA , <8bc3 1c<?U 3 D H N � U .0/ D /cde<?@ 1c<?@ � /�Uf5 DGF <W�@ N bc@G/ M � 36AJA;H � 3 D Q F , < D � <?<IU D 3 M <�H D <?WfHa<I1c<I@ - O\< � O\@G/ M <?HI9 ( <0/�AJH N W�AJ/�U DBN , @B36U�b+36U5�36@B<?Q D 1 N AJK M <T@L<?U�5�<I@B36U�b M N 5�KfAJ<?H(O\@ N M � � ��/ - 9iR F 3JH � 36AJA 3JU�QI@B<?/�HB< , N�DBF�DGF < / M N KfU DN O W�@ N Q?<IHBHB36U�b N U / U�5 DBF <(U4K M+, <I@ N O /�QIQ?<IHBHB<IH DGN_DGF <(5�/ D /f9�) 3JUY/ AJA - � � <�WfAZ/�U DGN <�� D <?U�5DGF < Wf@ N bc@B/ M DBN 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <0AZ/�@Lbc<0W N A - b N UY/ A 5Y/ D /)HB< D H?9

� U�Q N U�Q?A6K�HB3 N U � � < F / 1�<%O N KfU�5 DBF / D A N � <?@_Q N H D Q?AJKfH D <I@BH N O � g H /�@L<%HLK �%Q?36<?U D O N @3JU D <?@G/ Q D 3 1c<IA - @G/ - D @G/�QI3JU�b M K�A D 3 � + 3Jbc/ ,�- D <X5Y/ D / HB< D H?9 R F < 5�<?b�@B<?< DBN � F 3JQ F / M N @B<<��eW <?U�HL361�<#H F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - HBK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D 3JU�b W�AZ/ D O N @ M W[<I@LO N @ M H , < DLD <?@ N U DBF < HB/ M <D / H!� F / H , <?<IU H D K�5f3J<?5 9 R F < @L<?HBKfA D H N O DGF 3JH H D K�5 - H F�N K�A65 , < K�HB< O\K�A DGN /�U - N U�</ DLD < M W D 3JU�b DBN O\KfAJA - <��eW�A N 3 DaDBF <_W[<I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< N O <?3 DGF <I@:Q?AZ/ HBH N O WY/�@B/�AJA6<?A M /�Q F 36U�<�9

� � �����E�&��� �

$ � ��� " � � � ��$)����� � � " � ��������� ! ��� �

) 3JA6<iA N bcbc<I@?9 F Q N U D @ N A6H & <?bc3 N U � H^H D / D 36H D 36Q?H^bc/ DGF <I@B36U�b)/�U�5 A N bT]YA6<=Q?@L< / D 3 N U K D 3JA63 D 3J<?HI9

����������� ��������������������������� �!���"�����!#���$�$%�������%�&�!#�� �������'$����(���$����*)+���"&� ��,-� �������. $���� ���0/1#2����3��# 4�,657�2���!������8657�9��������� ��� � ����,���:�� .�;�<�= .�>�?�@�A�<�B&CDFE"&� ��,-#�$�������. $���� ���0/GDFE

���H� $���I����(���H��������� $J� K��� ���L��� ���$��&�������� ���!��(�����!��K�K�$ ��#����L�����M)N������PO����-�2�!4L�2���'Q�R�R-� ��� �����3� �L��$��JS�TVU9� $���W/YX�X�UG?�� $�$��HZ����$�,FU9X�X�����,$ DFE2U[)7�������Q��������9� \UG]���(_^`Ua�&�IUG]�� (cb U7��� ���������'� $�$���(�����!� $���-#���$�$��*)+���]�� (_^

]�, ��(��2��J� $���W/d�Le2��ALD!fg fK���� � ����, .���� ����h . $���# 80/diL����$���#�8LDjEkf�2��l�����&���Le2��A6EmfK���� � ����, .���� ����h .�����$���# 86/di�����$���#�8LDjEmfn

] � $ ���]�, ��(��2��J� $���W/d�Le2��ALDHg�n

] ����,�� (���H� $����.��c���P(���H�L�����&� $*5o��������������p(���2�_����!��K�K�$���#����L��� �rqm����� � ����,��*)a���]�, ��(��9��J� $��� .��0/dh65s�Le2��ALD*)�)�)

���H� $���I����(���_��t��������&� $������&���H�&�������� ���*)a�������>������!�2������$�,�������t����� �����,-��(�(r)u���

� �

]�, ��(��9��J� $���W/ �Le2��ALD )�)�)]�, ��(��9��J� $��� .��0/dh65s�Le2��ALD*)�)�)

���!$�$���I����(���H��������� $J� K��� ���L��� ���$��&�������� ���_�9�L����, �H����H� ��������M)����>������!�2������$�,��L�2���$�$�l�t����� �����,-��(�(r)u���]�, ��(��9��'$�$���W/ �Le2��ALD )�)�)]�, ��(��9��'$�$��� .��0/dh65s�Le2��ALD*)�)�)

���PO��L#�� ���&�������9� UG]�,���(��9���B � C�>�<�>C�UN�&��8��������&�_#�� ����������#����&���-��� ,H����J������p, �����������"����_� ��#�����,!,��������$���,I� �����L��� �L��#���,�� ���9� !���&�������r5s��� ,'������%K ���9� �����&���c� ���V�9�!����J$����(L��$����%4�����_���&��K �&���� ���'�������`�9��������*)a������p]�, ��(L�9��HB � C�> <�>�C]�� (�, ��(!B � C�> <�>�C

���P>��&�����J��� ���&��#��&����4�����#2�V#����Jt���L����,!�&�!#���$�$���# �c� �������*)u���

����Q����������H��� ,I�9�L#�� ���&��� � )a���]�, ��(��2��-#�� �������2�0/Y�DHg���R�RWE n]�, ��(��2��-#�� ��������r/Y� 5d,�DHg���R�:�,0E n

���pC�������-���L�9�&��� ������KM)a���]�, ��(��2��H�L� �&����������KL�j/ ��^D )�)�)�������2�����2� ���L� �&����������KM)a���]�, ��(��2��H�L� �&����������K� / ��^ 5u��D )�)�)

] � $ ���]�, ��(��2��-#�� �������2�0/Y�DHg�n]�, ��(��2��-#�� ��������r/Y� 5u,LD%g�n]�, ��(��2��H�L� �&����������KL�j/ ��^D�g�n]�, ��(��2��H�L� �&����������K� / ��^ 5u��D�g�n

] ����,�� (

� �

) 3JA6<VQ N M M KfU�3JQ?/ DGN @I9 F 5f<I]YU�<IH�& <?b�3 N U � H Q?<IU D @G/ A�Q N M%M K�U�36Q / DBN @ QIAZ/�HLH � � F 3JQ F Q N U D @ N A6H/�A6A U�< D � N @%� D @G/ U�H M 3JHLHB3 N U�H , < D � <?<?U�U N 5f<?H?9

����Q�$�����������������I#�� � ����9� ���&�������� ������ ,$��9� H�&�����L��,I�2��tL#�$������p�������*)s���#�$�����J#�� $�$�����gK���t�$ ��# �"L� �����&� $'�9�������� ,$����&�������� �*/G�2��� ��� # 8657�9��� �������������, � 5 �2���H;&C��&e2BLDp:J^ E

n E

���%;�������� ������ ,&$ �9� H�&��������,&�H��� ,J(����L# �L�����J���8��!�_��� # 8����c� ,05u�!������J����� ,L�9� �����, �-� ,05u��� ,_���&�������� �H��l�K�-� ,05 ������JK �&��#����������&��, �����J������J� ��� ����� 5+��� ,!� ��������� �J�2�L#�#������'�9��,���#�������� �M)a�����l�K&��, ��( f�9� � /1#�� $�$���� ��� �'#�� $�$�����.�����������,LD /G�9���V��� # 8657�9��� �������������, � 5 �2���H;&C��&e2BLDjE

��l�K&��, ��( f�9� � /1#�� $�$�����.�(����L#��L��� ��D /G�9���I����#�865 �9��� �������������, � 5 �2���H;&C��&e2BLDjE

����>���'#��2��� ������#����&���V#�$�����p,�� � ��#����%�����4&����8J��� ��(�(L��#*)a���#�$�����J#��2����������#�������� � K���t�$ ��#%@��������t�$��_gK �L�2"������ �

]�� (�, ��(!B � C�> <�>�C,� ��t�$��_����$���# ��� E,� ��t�$��_����� ,&�jE,� ��t�$���� �# "��jE,� ��t�$���t l�������.��������6E,� ��t�$���t l�������.�����# "�,0E,� ��t�$��_#�� ���&.��L�9�&� E,� ��t�$���� $�.��L� �&�WE

] ����,�� (

�-�

K���t�$ ��# ����P>��&�_#����L� ������# �&���_���8���� � $ ����� ��(�����, ���j5 � ����8I��(�������� ����, � 5a������ ������t��� ��(H����, ��%��� �L���W5u��� ,H>�Q��HKL�����!�&�!#�� �����#��!��� )s���#��2����������#��������W/1#2�&���V� ����, � $ ������(���$��W5

�9���H��l�� ����865�9�����������L��, ���j5�9����K�������:�� � @�>�DFE

���P>��&��, �� �����L#��&���!K ���2�����J� �����L�%���%���&�J$����(���$������ ,-#�$������L�%��K )s���"L� �����&� $

�#��2��� ������#����&���W/GDjE

����Q���$�$p�������%�&�J#�� ����# �J�������!#��2��� ������#����&���&�pt&��(��� �-#���$�$ �9� J�����M)s����9���V�9���2��4��t6/GDFE����Q���$�$p�������%�&�%t����9�-����l��L#2� ������ �L�p�&��� ,$ �2� ��( �2��t�� ����,!,������0)+���"L� �����&� $p"&� � ,!�����6/ DFE

���pC�K&��4�� �J#�� ���&��� ,J������I#����V#�� ������!���'��K�K�$ ��#����L��� �'4L� ���'�_�������#�� ����������#����&���c� �!���������� � ��(H������L��, ���J�9�J����'#�$ �L� ����r)a����9���J�&�2K��4��6/1#2����I��# 4�,05

#2�&��� ��#��2������� ,05#2�&��� ������&� 5#2�&��� � ����, ��$ ��� � : ^ 5�9� ��KL����� :�SLb`5�9� ������������,�����:�S�b[5�9� ������� ��� ������,&��: ^DFE

���P�����&���H����H�&�2K��4��c�2��K�K�$�����,I#��2������� , $ �9��J����&�p��� ,�������� ��� �J������ K����9�������!�&�H��h �#2������tL$�� qm�!����&�*)u���� �����L��#!�9� �HK���&����.�����&�F/G�2���c������&#j57#2���� �����������"r5

#2����-����.�# 4�,65#2����-����.�����,�� $ ��� �r5 �9��� ��.�K������65

� �

�9��� ��.�����������,����j5 �9� �-��.���l�� ��� 865�9��� ��.������ ��� ������,&��DjE

����Q�$����������J#���$�$p�������%�&�p� ������������!�������H�&��� ,$����&�*)a����9���J� ������������ .��`��&�F/G�2���_;C���e2B657#�� $�$����'��i&#j5N#�� $�$�����.��&��������,!�[DFE�9���J� ������������ .��`��&�F/G�2���_;C���e2B657#�� $�$�����.�(����L# �L����� ��(�DjE

���P>���� ����,I����(��'����� ,&����� ,!� ��#��&�2"����J��('� ��_�����L��� ��, �����t���(�( ���&� )u����9���I����� , .����� /1#�� ��� �c�9����;C��&e2Br5N#�� �L� �V�9��� ���������� ����8r5

#�� ��� �V��� � ��.��I� � � ��b2: ^ 5 "&� � ,-�2�&�������� ��b :�^ 5#�� ��� �V��� � ��.��I� � � ����: ^ 5 "&� � ,-�2�&�������� ����:�^DFE

�9���J� ��# "�.�t�� (�( /1#����L� �c�9���I����# 8r5 "�� � ,-� t�� (�(����05 #�� ��� � � � � ��.��V��� � �DFE�9���I����� , .�t�� (�(&�j/G�9���3����# 865N� ������# �c����"���#!��"��# �65 �9���I#�� �����LDFE�9���J� ��# "�.�t�� (�(&�j/G�9���3����# 865N� ������# �c����"���#!��"��# �65 �9���I#�� �����LDFE

���%<&#�#����������&�*)a����9��$ �9�&�'�9� �H; l�� ����80/ DJ#�� �L� �'g�� ����� ���J��l�� ����86EYn�9��$ �9�&�'�9� ������������, ��F/GDJ#�� ��� �-g�� ���������J����������, ���jE n�9���I����# 80/G#�� �L� �3�2���I��D�#�� ��� �6EN��� �����I����# 8����J(&�����L��, �-� )s���

����Q�����������,����������9t�� ����,!t�����������&� )a���$���������.�t������������!� ������������ .�t&�����������W/G�9���-t�����L����� .��,05

�9�����������L��, ���j5 �2���-������, �������LDFE����Q�����������,����������9t�� ����,V�2���� ��,H�&���L����lI�2K��#��6)u���, ������������"����&�H� ������������ .�,�������������"����W/ �9��� t�$�8���� � � 5

���L��� ����,V�9���_�&��.��� � � 5���L��� ����,V�9���I$�#�.��� � � 5�9���'��������#�:Lb`5 �9���J,���l�K��:Lb`5�9���'� $ � ��:Lb�DFE

n E

� �

) 3JA6<a5Y/ D /�HB<I@L1c<I@?9 F 5�< ]YU�<IH DGF <�36U D <?@ OP/�Q?< DGN_DGF <(5f3JH D @B3 , K D <I5 H F /�@L<?5 M < M N @ - Q?AJ/�HBHL<?HI9

#�$�����p, ������������"���� � K���t�$���#J#�� $�$����!gK �&������# ���, �����Q����������$J��(�����'�2���� ��,�t�$���#�8��*)+���, �������V����#���#2�� E�9����t�$�8���� � � E�9���J�&��.���� � � E�9��� $�#�.���� � � E

]�� (�, ��(!B � C�> <�>�C,� ��t�$�����#�#���������jE,� ��t�$������ ���jE,� ��t�$����L����, .���������#jE,� ��t�$���(���$�$�.���������#jE,� ��t�$��%�`���������jE,� ��t�$���� ����������� E,� ��t�$��%�&�WE,� ��t�$��J��������0E,� ��t�$��%��l�.��L� �&�WE,� ��t�$������"���.��L�9�&� E,� ��t�$��%�`������.��L�9�&� E

] ����,�� (

K���t�$ ��# �����#�� ����������#����&��� ��� � ��L��� ������.�,�����������"���W/ D #�� $�$����������*)s���, ������������"����0/1#��2��� ������#����&��� ��#��2���M5

�9� �Ht�$�8���� � �W5 �9���J�&��.���� � � 5 �9��� $�#�.�� � � � 5�9� �_��������#�:Lb[57����<�������#������L�2"L� ��lr)N����9� �_� $�� ���:�^&DFE7����A����t�$��'���������L�2� '��,�,�� ����H� $ � ����&����� )a���

� �

���P>��&��, �� �����L#��&���!K ���2�����J� �����L�%���%���&�J$����(���$������ ,-#�$������L�%��K )s����, �����������"����W/GDFE

���P@������� �����J�������%4L�2���J����'#��2����������#����&���r)7���"L� �����&� $'�9�������� ,$����&�������� �*/G�2��� ��� # 8657�9��� �������������, � 5 �2���H;&C��&e2BLD�:�^ E

���%<�,�,&�p, �������&������H� ����� ,������V�����!4L�2���L� ���V��l��L# � �� ��� � ���L�����M)7����9���'��,�, .�,������*/ "�� � ,I����,�,�� ����� 5 �9���!8���l�DFE

���%<&# � ��� � �J����,!��� $��������H������,-� ��$�l!, �����6)u���"L� �����&� $p"&� � ,�p ���.�, ����� /G�9���c����8���l��� 5 �9���Ji������������� ���L��� D�g�nWE"L� �����&� $p"&� � ,!� � $���������.�,������*/G�2���3����8���l���*57�2���-������� ����� ��������D�g�n E

���%<&# � ��� � �J����,!��� $���������4 ���2����tL$���, �����0)+���"L� �����&� $p"&� � ,�p ���.�, ������.��&��.�4 ���2���*/ �9���I8���l057�9���_i ��������� ���`D�g

� ����� ���' ����.�, �����*/d8���l05 ��� ����� ����DFEn E"L� �����&� $p"&� � ,!� � $���������.�4 ���2�������.�, ����*/G�9���V8���l05N�2���_��� ����� ����D�g

� � $���������.�, �����*/d8���l05 ��� ����� ����DjEn E

���P?&��4��&��� l���� �I$���#�� $%t�$�� # 8��J#����ceH#���#2����J����9��$ �9�&�'�9� �!��Q .���� � � /GDJ#�� �L���'g�� ����� ���I$ #�.���� � � E n E���P?&��4��&��� l $���#�� $%t�$�� # 8��p,�_e ���"����!����9��$ �9�&�'�9� ��@�C�.���� � � /GDJ#�� �L���'g�� ����� ���_����.���� � � E n E���P?&��4��&��� l�t�$���# 8L����� �'�2������J��� �L� � �'�2�������,H�&���L����l��J����9��$ �9�&�'�9� ���$���# 8��F/ DJ#�� �L� �'gH� ����� ���_����.���� � �_�%����� ����, ��� EunWE

n E

� � � � �E�����

� ���&��� � ��� �E�������� � ��� � ���

#�$�����HC�#������C��������_gK���t�$ ��# ��9�����L����.�t "6E ������l�K�'��(J��#�#���$ )a� �����L#���� � ��9���J���� ,&#�� $�$���� � � E ������K&��� ���&�������J(���J�����,J��#�#�� $��������L��� �,� ��t�$��J$ �������.�����,��9�L� E ����,��������������I��(J��� ���'$ ������I��� � �&#����,� ��t�$���t�"L��#�� $��WE ��������(��V�2�&��,��4I��#�� $��H(���# �&���t�����$%����.���� E ������#�#2������$�������� �'t���(�( ���'��������� $ ������9� t�����$%t���L# �rE ��� t���L# ���&����8_����_��#�����t�����$!$����(�� ���&��� E ����� ��#�����,I����������� ��9������4&����8���&�jE ��� ������t&��� ��(��L��, ����9��������� � ����,&�jE ��� ������t&��� ��(������ , ���!����� ����,&�%K��������, �,� ��t�$�� � � ������� .�"�� $����1b ^�^�^��6E ������(�(&�������p(���_�����L��� $ ����� �9� ,� ��t�$�� � � ������� .�"�� $��2t��mb ^�^�^��0E

n E

#�$����� ��� ���&��C��������_gK���t�$ ��# ��&� �9���'��l �WE ����#����&��� ��&� �9��� $�����8����6E� ��# �&������K E,� ��t�$���(��"6E,� ��t�$���h��(�(&�����rE ����(���_� $ K��&�pt�� (�( ���'��� �L��� $ �������9� ,� ��t�$���l��(�(&�����rE

� �

,� ��t�$������`� � �L� ��� E �����L� �&�-� �����K_(���_����� �&������,I� t � ��# ����9���Jh�� ���jE ������#�� �����'� ������$����L��� ��9���Jl�� ���jE�9���Jh��L��$����� � � E ��� K�� h ��$�����$��H,�� �&��������� �L��9���Jl��L��$����� � � E�9���I�2���,��4�.��L��,�� E ��������'��� $��# ����,V�2�&��,��4-� $�&�����2������9���H�&��h�, ��K����rE ����������&��h��9�����-� ��lJ, ��K ����9��������� �&$������B�K�l&�jE ��� ������t&��� ��(J��� hr) K�$������,����2K�$���l���9��������� � ��$ ���&��B�K l&�jE ��� ������t&��� ��(J��� hr)o"&��$ �����H,L���2K�$���l&�($�������t������.���� �����2����$�,0E ����������(�� ��#��L��� �3#�����(�(���# �������t�����$p,��. � �2�������6E ���������tL$�� � �2������� ��,-��������� $ ������9� t�����$J� ������� � E ���������tL$��-� ����� ���p����� , ���L�9� t�����$H����� ������� E ���������tL$��J����� �&������,I� t � ��# ���t�����$%������� K������jE ���������tL$����������2KL���_,�������L��� �L��#p"�����4t�����$H����t���������.��&��# 86E ���������tL$��J�J$ ������L�9�������, �t�����$p� ���L����.�������8��jE ���������tL$��-� �����L��#%���� 8'������� ����&�����t�����$J�2����4.������ 8L�jE ���������tL$��-�2����4!����� 8L�t�����$J�2����4. ��4�����0E ���������tL$��-�2����4I�2�������,!"&��$ ) , ����

<���� ��l`b X��&$������B�K l � � $�����T!K�B�K�l&�jEN�����2K&��#���(���_��� hr) ,����2K�$���lJ, �����<���� ��l`b X � ��$����&��B�K�l � � $�����T_"�B�K l&�jE

n E

��� ! ����� � � � �

� > � � h�j�jck � ��/�U 9 � & C > "�>�� � � / @G/�A6AJ<?A g N M W�K D 3JU�b . N � U�A N /�5�HI9 � � U�AJ36U�< � 9 C 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6< �F�DBD W � " " � � � 9 AJ/ M � M W�3 9 N @Bb " 5 N � U�A N /�5

� h�� � h�j�jck � ��/�U 9 � >�� � g � � C � N @ D / , A6< � M W�A6< M <?U D / D 3 N U N OV>�� � 9 C @Lb N U�U�<MS�/ D 3 N UY/�A& / , N @G/ DBN @ - 9�� � U�AJ36U�< � 9 C 1 /�36AZ/ , A6< � F�DLD W � " " � � � � K�U�3 �[9 M Q?HI9 /�UfA 9 b N 1 " M W�3 " M W�3JQ F "3JU�5f<��[9 F�D M A

� k ��� ����� � � � � � ���� � � � � � � � C R � g N @BW N @B/ D 3 N U � h�jcjck 9 � � U�AJ36U�< � 9 C 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6< �F�DBD W � " " � � � 9 / D 3 9 Q N M

� F � $i9 S 9 $ <?@LH F /�5 / U�5 >�9 ��9 � < � / K�H!� /�H � � >�365 � / - �id F /�@L<?5 > < M N @ - �V/�@B/�AJA6<?A�� @ N �bc@G/ M M 3JU�b � 3 DGF 7 U D @ - g N U�HL3JH D <?U�Q - O N @i.=36H D @L3 , K D <?5 >�< M N @ - >�K�A D 3JWf@ N Q?<?HLH N @LH � �g /�@BUf<?bc36<_>�<?A6A N UXS(U�361�<?@BHL3 D - � R <?Q F 9 �:<?W 9 g >�S � g d � E�> � > H�j � >�EIE=>c9

� B � + 9 $ K�@LU�H � � 9 .0/ N K�5 � /�U�5 ��9 � /�3JbcA � � & C > � C U � W[<IU g A6K�H D <?@ 7 U�143J@ N U M <IU DO N @�>�� � � � � F 3 N deK�W <?@LQ N M W�K D 3JU�b g <IU D <?@ � > EIE F�9 � � U�A63JU�< � 9 C 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6< � F�DBD W �" " � � � 9 AZ/ M � M W�3 9 N @Bb " 5 N � UfA N /�5

� D � � � � � � ����� � � � � � �� � � � �� ��� � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � g N M WY/ ` � � U D <IA � > 3JQ?@ N H N O D � .=<?Q�9>�EIE H 9 � � UfAJ3JUf< � 9 C 1 /�36AZ/ , A6< � F�DLD W � " " � � � 9 143J5fO 9 N @Lb " 3JUeO N " j FcH D /�Uf5Y/�@B5fH?9 F�D M A

� H�� � 9 & 9 g NeN � � R09 � N @ D <?@ � /�U�5 & 9 g /�@LW[<IU D <?@ � � .=3JH D @L3 , K D <?5 ��/ - Ra@G/ Q?3JUfb � � 3JU � ������ � � ����� � � � � � � ��� � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � �� � � � � � � �� � ��� � � � 9 R F <C HLH N Q?3Z/ D 3 N U#O N @ g N M W�K D 36U�b >�/�Q F 3JU�<I@ - � � U�Q 9 � > E� F � WfW 9"> kUH�� > F Be9

� � $i9 g N @L@B36< /�U�5 � 9 >�/ Q,��<?@L@G/�H � � � /�@B/�AJA6<?A � N A6K M < �(<IU�5�<?@L3JU�b(/�Uf5 .0/ D / g NcF <I@B<IU�Q?< � �3JU�� ����� � � � � ��� � � �! � � ��� � � �"� � � � � � � �$# 9 R F < C HBH N Q?3J/ D 3 N U�O N @ g N M W�K D 3JUfb>�/�Q F 36U�<?@ - � � U�Q 9 � >�E E k � WfW 9 h�k��fh Df9

� E � >�9 g N � /�U�5 .+9 7 AJA6H � N @ DBF � �LC W�WfAJ3JQ?/ D 3 N U � g N U D @ N AJAJ<I5�.=< M /�Uf5 � /�b�3JU�b O N @ � K D �N O � g N @B<�=36HBKY/ AJ3�?/ D 3 N U � � 36U%�'&(&)& � � � � ��� ��� � � � � � � >�E E H � WfW 9 h�k B �eh FIF�9� > j � C 9 )YK � 3 M N�DGN � R09iR /�UY/ � / � /�Uf5 �)9 � � / D / � �LC � R(d � C Q?QI<?A6<?@G/ D <?5 �(/ - R @G/ Q?3JUfbd - H D < M � � �*&(&(& � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � U N 9KD � W�W 9 > D �fh D � C W�@?9>�E�IDe9

� >I> � C 9 + / @BQ?3J/ / U�5 � 9 � (�9 d F <IU � �LC U � U D <?@LAJ<?/21�<?5 � /�@G/ AJAJ<IA�� N A6K M < �:<?U�5f<?@B<I@ � 3 DBF� g � Q?A6K�H D <?@LH � � 36U � �� � � � � �$# � � � � � �,+ � �-& � � � # � ��� � � �/. � � � � � �0� � �1 � � ��� � � �� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � ��� ��� � � � � � � de<IW D 9 h�jcjch 9

� > h�� C 9 + <I3JH D � � ���32 � 4� �65 � � ��� � � � � � � � � ���7� ���� � � � �98 � � �;: �<� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ���� � � � � �>= � � ��� � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � �$# 9 >�� R � @L<?HBH � >�EIE F�9

� �

� > k � C 9 d[9 + AZ/ HBHBUf<?@ � � deWY/�QI<8deK , 5�36143JHL3 N U�O N @ ) /�H D �(/ - Ra@B/�Q?36U�b � � �*&(&(& � � � � � � �� � ��� � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � U N 9�F � W�W 9">CB �fhch � � Q D 9 >�E� F�9

� > F � (�9 + @ N W�W � 7(9�& K�H!� � S 9f. N HBH � /�U�5 C 9fd�� � <?AJA6K M � � C�F 36b F�� W <?@ O N @ M /�U�QI< � W N @ D / , AJ<3 M W�AJ< M <IU D / D 3 N U N O DBF <>�� � M <IHBHB/�bc<WY/ HBHB36U�b 36U D <?@ OP/�Q?< H D / U�5Y/�@L5 � �� � � ��� � � �� � � � � � �$# � 1 N A 9 h�h � U N 9�D � W�W 9 H E � h � de<IW D 9">�E EIDf9

� >CB � � 9 ��< M W <?A � � R F < >'���0d D /�Uf5Y/�@B5 O N @_>�<IHBHB/�bc< � / HBHB36U�b � � 36U � �� � � � � �$# � � � � � �� � # ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � �$# � � ��� � ��= � � ��� �$#�� � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � �&���� ������� � � � � >�EIE F � W�W 9 h F H �fh B h 9

� >�D � >�9 �_9 �_/�W�AJ/�U � � deW�/�Q?< R @G/�QI3JU�b � C g N U�H D /�U D Ra3 M < ��/ - Ra@B/�Q?<I@ � � 3JU�� � � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � ��� ��� � � ��� � � � � � � � �,� � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � �� � �� � ��� � � � 9 R F < C HBH N Q?3J/ D 3 N U#O N @ g N M W�K D 3JU�b%>�/ Q F 3JU�<I@ - � � U�Q�9 � >�E�UBe9

� > H�� � 9 �0<?AJ< F <?@I9�� >�EIEID � S N 1 9 � g �0> �[R F < g NcF <I@B<IU D �i3J@ D KY/�A >�/ Q F 3JU�< 9 S(U�361�<?@BHL3 D - N O>�/�@ - AJ/�U�5 9 � � U�A63JU�< � 9 C 1 /�3JAJ/ , AJ< � F�DBD W � " " � � � 9 Q?H?9 K M 5 9 <?5�K " W�@ N � <IQ D H," Q 1 M "

� > � �)9 & 3 � � � ��� � C d F /�@B<I5 �=36@ D K�/�A >�< M N @ - d - H D < M O N @ � /�@G/�A6AJ<IA g N M W�K D 36U�b � � 36U � �� � � � � �$# � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � � �$# � >�E � � W�W 9E F � > j >c9

� >�E � (�9�& 3Jb N UX/�U�5 � 9 � N HBH � � C U � 1c<?@ 143J< � N O DGF < � /�@B/�AJA6<?A �i3J@ D KY/�A ) 3JA6<0d - H D < M � � 36U&�� � � � � � � � ��� . � � � � � �0� � >�E EIEf9� h�j � �)9 >�/ � ��9 d[9 �V/�36U D <?@ � g 9 .+9 �i/�UfHB<?U � /�U�5 >�9 ) 9��0@ N b F � � C .0/ D /#.=3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 ��V/�@B/�AJA6<?A C A6b N @L3 DGF M O N @ ��/ - � Ra@B/�Q?<I5 � N AJK M < �:<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b � � 3JU � �� � � � � �$# � � �

� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � �$# � � � � ��� � � >�EIE k � W�W 9">�B �fhch 9� h > � C 9 C 9;>�3J@L3JU � � ���32 � � � <?@ - �(3Jb F �:<?H N AJK D 3 N U de3 M K�AJ/ D 3 N U N O g N M Wf@B<?HLHB3 , AJ<_R K�@ , K �AJ<IU�Q?< N U DBF < ��$^> � d�� d - H D < M � � 36U�� � # � � � � � � � � � � � �>= � � ��� �$# � � ��� � � � � �

� �$# � � � � � � � � � � >�E EIEf9� hch�� S 9US(<I143JU � � R F < � <I@LO N @ M / U�Q?< N O & C > Df9 j /�Uf5 >'��� g �!>c9 j 9?> h=N U%/ ( N @!��H D / D 3 N Ug AJK�H D <I@ � � � F 3 N deK�W <?@BQ N M W�K D <I@ g <IU D <?@ � R <IQ F 9 �:<?W 9 � d g � R�� � >�EIEID � F � >�/�@I9=> EIEIDf9

� h�k � � � � � �� � � ��� � ��� � � � � � ��= � S �� .� C g N @BW N @G/ D 3 N U � h�j�jck 9 � � U�A63JU�< � 9C 1 /�36AZ/ , A6< � F�DLD W � " " � � � 9 U�143J5�3J/f9 Q N M

� h F � � h�j�j�h � S N 1 9 � � �=> � /�@B/�AJA6<?A �i3J@ D KY/�A >�/�Q F 36U�< (�< , � /�bc<�9 � / � �(365�bc<9S�/ D 3 N UY/�A& / , N @G/ DBN @ - 9 � � UfAJ3JUf< � 9 C 1 /�36AZ/ , A6< � F�DLD W � " " � � � 9 Q?H M 9 N @LU�A 9 b N 1 " W�1 M "

� h B � >�9 7:9 � /�A M <?@ � d[9 R / - A N @ � / U�5 $i9 R N�DBD - � � 7��fWfA N 3 D 3JUfb .=<I<?W � / @G/�A6AJ<?A:> < M N @ -��36<?@G/ @BQ F 36<?H:O N @ ��/ - g /�H D 3JU�b � N A6K M < �:<?Uf5�<?@L3JU�b � � 36U6�'&)&(& � � ��� � � � � � � � � � � �$#� � � � ��� � � > EIE H � WfW 9">CB �fh�h 9� h D � d[9 �V/�@%��<?@ � (�9f>�/�@ D 3JU � � 9�deA N /�U � � 9fd F 36@BA6< - � $i9ed M 3 D H � /�U�5 g 9 �i/�UfHB<?U � � � U D <I@G/�Q �D 3 1c< �(/ - R @B/�Q?36U�b � � � � � � � �� � � � � ��� � � ��� � � ��� � ����� � W�W 9">I>�E � > h D � C W�@?9"> EIEIEf9

� �

� hIH�� d[9 �V/�@%��<I@ � >�9 �V/�@%��<?@ � �)9 & 3614UY/ D � � 9#deA N /�U � g 9 ��/�U�HL<?U � /�Uf5 � 9 d F 36@BAJ< - �� � U D <I@G/�Q D 361�< �(/ - R @G/ Q?3JUfb�O N @ � N A6K M < �=36HBKY/ AJ3�?/ D 3 N U � � �'&)&(& � � � � � �� � � � � � � �� � � � ��� ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � 1 N A 9/B � U N 9 k � W�W 9 h�k �fh B j � > EIEIEf9

� h � �)9�� <?@BA63JU /�Uf5)7(9�>�9 � N � <I@ D � � � - W <?@ D <�� D K�@B< � � 3JU � �� � � � � �$# � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � # � ��� � � � � � � � � � � � �� � � � ��� � �� � ��� � � � � >�E�IE � WfW 9 h B k��h D h 9

� h E � .+9 � 9 � N @ D <?@?9 � h�jcjch � �cK�Uf< � � N AJK M < �i3JHLKY/�AJ3� / D 3 N U N O �(3Jb F �:<?H N AJK D 3 N U.0/ D / S(HB36U�b � g � g AJK�H D <I@BH?9&S(U�361�<?@BHL3 D - N O >�36U�U�<?H N�D /e9 � � U�A63JU�< � 9 C 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6< �F�DBD W � " " � � � 9 A6Q?HB< 9 K M U 9 <?5fK " F 14@," W QI1 N AJ@L<?U�5�> F � K�U�< h�jcj�h 9 W 5fO

� kcj � R09 ��9 � K�@LQ?<IAJA � � 9 $ K�Q,� � (�9 �_9=>�/�@!� � /�Uf5 � 9 �i/ U�@G/ F /�U � � ��/ - R @G/ Q?3JUfb N U� @ N bc@B/ M%M / , AJ< + @B/�W F 36Q?H ��/�@B5 � /�@L< � � 36U � ��� ��� � � ���;� � � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � � �� � � � � � � ��� � � � � � �<� � � � � �� � � � � � � �� � ��� � � � 9 R F < C HLH N Q?3Z/ D 3 N U�O N @ g N M W�K D 3JUfb>�/�Q F 36U�<?@ - � � U�Q 9 � h�j�j�h � WfW 9 H�jck��=H > h 9

� k > � d[9��:K , 3JU�/�U�5�R09 ( F 3 DLD <?5 � �LC R F @B<I< .=3 M <?UfHB3 N UY/�A �:<?W�@L<?HL<?U D / D 3 N U&O N @ )V/�H D�(<IU�5�<I@B3JUfb N O g N M W�A6<�� d4Q?<?Uf<?H � � � � � � � � � � � ��� � � � � 1 N A 9 > F � U N 9 k � W�W 9I>I> j�� >I>�D ��cK�A - >�E� j 9

� k�h�� � � � � � � # � � ��� � de3JA63JQ N U + @G/ W F 3JQIH � UfQ�9 � h�j�j�h 9 � � UfAJ3JUf< � 9 C 1 /�3JAJ/ , A6< �F�DBD W � " " � � � 9 HLbc3 9 Q N M " N @L3Jbc36U " kcj�jcj " 5Y/ D /�H F <?< D 9 F�D M

� kck � $i9 R /�U�b�U�< - � � ���32 � � � 1�<?@ 1e36< � N O 5�3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 H F / @B<?5 M < M N @ - � � .=<IWY/�@ D M <IU D0N Og N M W�K D <I@(deQ?36<?U�QI< � R @B3JUf3 D - g N AJAJ<Ibc< � R <IQ F 9 �(<IW 9YR g . � g d � >�EIE � h F � � Q D 9">�EIE�f9

� k F � � 9 ( /�A65 � R09 � N A6AJ3Jb � g 9 $ <?U DGF 36U � C 9 �0<IAJAJ<I@ � /�U�5 � 9TdeAJK�HB/�AJA6< � � � � U D <I@G/�Q D 361�<+ A N , /�A � AJA6K M 3JUY/ D 3 N U K�HL3JU�b );/�H D ��/ - R @G/�QI3JU�b � � 3JU � �� � � � � �$# � � � � � � � � � �& 8 � � � � � ��� � � . � � � � � �0� � � � � � � � � � �$# � h�j�j�h 9

� k B � � 9 (�/�A65�/�U�5 � 9 d4AJK�HB/�AJA6< � � � d D / D < � N O � DBF < � /�@ D 3JU'� U D <?@B/�Q D 361�< ��/ - � Ra@B/�Q?36U�b � � � � � � �� � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � & 8 � � � � � � � � ��� � � � W�W 9 h > � F h � de<IW D 9 h�jcj >c9

� k D � � 9 ( /�A65 � � 9fdeAJKfHG/�A6AJ< � � /�U�5 g 9 $ <IU DGF 36U � � � U D <?@B/�Q D 361c<i.=3JH D @B3 , K D <?5 �(/ - Ra@G/�QI3JU�b N O��36b F A - g N M WfAJ<�� > N 5�<IAJH � � 36U�� � � � � � � �$# � � �� � ��� � � � � � ��5,��� � �6& � � � # � ��� � � �. � � � � � �0� � � � � � � � � � �$# � �cKfU�< h�jcj > � W�W 9 hIHIH �fh �f9