Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1)...

16
Gorm Bruun Andresen Ph.d., industrial postdoc Energy System Engineering Department of Engineering Aarhus University 1

Transcript of Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1)...

Page 1: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

Gorm Bruun Andresen Ph.d., industrial postdoc Energy System Engineering Department of Engineering Aarhus University 1

Page 2: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

Renewable Energy Systems Group Aarhus University

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

2

Uffe Poulsen

Emil Hedevang

(Jochen Cleve)

Group leader:

Martin Greiner (T) +45 8942 3472 Professor, System Engineering (E) [email protected]

Main research topics:

(1) Large-scale renewable energy systems

(2) Wind farm modeling

(3) Turbulence modeling

(4) The physics of complex networks

Page 3: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

About this talk…

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

3

Further reading:

• R.A. Rodriguez et al., ArXiv 1306.1079 (submitted to Renewable Energy).

• S. Becker et al., ArXiv 1307.1723 (submitted to Energy).

• D. Heide et al., Renewable Energy 35 (2010).

• D. Heide et al., Renewable Energy 36 (2011).

• M. G. Rasmussen et al., Energy Policy 51 (2012).

• Very short introduction to weather-driven modeling.

• Sharing surplus in a renewable Europe. - How large are the benefits? - What is required to realize

the benefits?

• Final remarks

Funding:

Page 4: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

WEATHER-DRIVEN MODELING We cannot control when the wind blows or the sun shines

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

4

Page 5: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

“Let the weather decide!”

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

5

High-resolution weather data (70,128 h): 50 x 50 km2, 1 hour weather data covering the 8-year period 2000-2007 for 27 European countries on and offshore.

High-resolution wind and solar PV power generation.

Regional electricity demand: Hourly electricity demand for 50 individual regions.

Page 6: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

6

The European wind and solar resource

Seasonal optimal mix

Resource maps

Most important time scales

and correlations

Page 7: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

7

Energy system model:

Balancing system:

Variable renewable power

Dispatchable power

Electricity demand

Round trip electricity storage

Surplus

Page 8: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

High shares of wind and solar leads to large surplus production

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

8

Page 9: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

TRANSMISSION OF WIND AND SOLAR SURPLUS

Solar and in particular wind power is smoothed over large distances

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

9

Wind power, January 2001 Solar power, June 2001

Page 10: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1)

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

10

Availability of Renewable Energy

Quantifying the benefit of

transmission is done through the

total need for balancing

Bi = ( ∆ i − (KF) i )−

Which is a result of

Mismatch

Net Exports

Rolando Rodriguez Power t ransmission in a highly renewable Europe 5/ 12

Maximum benefit of transmission

The MAXIMUM BENEFIT OF TRANSMISSION quantifies how much balancing/surplus can be reduced by sharing local surplus wind and solar power in an unconstrained pan-European transmission network.

Page 11: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1)

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

11

We calculate the optimal physical flow of surplus wind and solar power to derive minimal transmission capacity requirements. A total of 70.000 hours are used in the analysis.

• As of winter 2010, the actual transmission capacity was about 70 GW.

• In our case study, 830 GW are required to achieve the maximum benefit.

• However, only 390 GW can achieve 99% of the maximum benefit.

Page 12: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

Building a pan-European transmission grid to share renewable surplus (1)

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

12

Key assumptions: • 90% of maximum benefit of

transmission. • Official 2020 targets for wind

and solar. • 100% gross share in 2050. • Optimized wind-solar mix in

2050.

Page 13: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

Building a pan-European transmission grid to share renewable surplus (2)

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

13

Investments:

Achieved benefit of transmission:

• To realize 70 – 90% of the maximum benefit of transmission, 2x – 3.5x todays capacity is required in the endpoint scenario (2050).

• Most of the build-up should happen in the period 2020 – 2040. • The achieved benefit is near elimination of VRE surplus in the

period 2025 – 2032. • In 2032, the benefit corresponds to about 5% of the annual

electricity demand of Europe. In 2050, it is about 10%.

Page 14: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

An optimal wind-solar mix (2050/endpoint scenario)

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

14

• For a pan-European power system, the optimal wind-solar energy mix depends on the strength of the transmission network.

• A typical benefit of optimizing the wind-solar mix is 5% of the annual electricity demand in Europe.

No transmission, 70/30 wind-solar mix

Unconstrained transmission, 80/20 wind-solar mix

Page 15: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

15

Thank you for listening!

Final remarks

• Main growth of renewables and transmission lines happens between 2020 and 2040.

• Between 2 to 4 times the transmission capacity of today yields the largest benefit per GW installed.

• An optimal wind-solar mix has a potential similar to that of transmission. • Beyond 2030, additional measures such as storage, power2heat or power2gas are

likely required to make use of all renewable surplus.

Page 16: Aarhus University 1 - energirike.no€¦ · Case study: All countries have 100% wind + solar (1) G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 gba@ase.au.dk 11 We calculate the optimal physical

Storage in a renewable pan-European power system

G.B. Andresen, Haugesund, 7/8 – 2013 [email protected]

16

A completely renewable electricity supply can be achieved with: • A strong pan-European transmission

grid. • 150 TWh/yr balancing, e.g. from hydro

storage lakes. • 2 TWh high-efficiency storage. • 25 TWh of hydrogen storage. • Annual wind + solar energy

corresponding to 103% of the annual European consumption of about 3000 TWh/yr.