A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
Transcript of A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 1/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 2/455
@ Hgojdsd ktmZ `t i`vuj ej tgd are`i _`jbtzd^o`jb
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 3/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 4/455
YGD
IQ@BEJXYOQX@J OJYOM@YD XLDYHG-AEEL
EF HGOJ@"X LTEMOJY@JB QDVENTYOEJ
0?12-1?
Dy
GDJQ_ FQ@JHOX MOXXDNROY[
JDR _EQL; G@QAOJBDQ GETXD
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 5/455
Hepyrobgt 0?90 ay Gdjry Fr`jhos Mossdnwotz
robjts rdsdrvdi* rdpreiuhtoej oj wjend er
oj p`rt feraoiidj. dxhdpt fer snNert dxhdrpts
quetdi. ay rdvodwdrs*
FOQXY DIOYOEJ
SQOJYDI DJY YGD! YKJYYDoI XY@*YD8X EF0
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 6/455
HEJYDJYX
SQDF@HD
0 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX 00
1 RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 07
8 YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 81
9 RG_ RD @QD OJ HGOJ@ 41
4 OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 64
6 QDI QTND @Y G@JLER 72
2 TS YE YGD FQEJY 038
7 YGD QDI FN@MD F@IDX 010
? JOJBSE MEQD F@Q 081
03 @ JDR ID@N FEQ HGOJ@ 099
00 HGO@JB L@O-XGDL"X QDYTQJ 042
01 QDI QDADNNOEJ 062
08 HGQOXY EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I 029
09 YGD M@QOJDX BDY BEOJB 076
04 YGD DJI EF HG@JB YXE-NOJ 0?0
06 YEL_E"X IONDMM@ 131
02 @ IQD@M YG@Y QOV@NX BDJBGOX LG@J 136
07 XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD 104
0? YGD IQ@BEJ ND@QJX YE FN_ 11?
13 ATQO@N EF XTJ _@Y-XDJ 18?
10 SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_ 197
11 YGD Ae_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 161
18 YGD QE@I @GD@I 126
OJIDW 172
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 7/455
SQDF@HD
Ygd Hgojdsd `rd ujotdi tei`y tdmper`rony* Ygdy wdrd foj`nny
`reusdi. `nejb wotg muhg ef tgd rdst ef tgd werni. ay K`p`j"s oj-
v`soej ef Hgoj`* Xmeunidrojb he`ns ef iddp g`trdi `b`ojst tgd K`p`jdsd
aurst ojte qudjhgndss fn`mds* Ojtdrj`n strofd w`s ferbettdj oj tgd
wgotd gd`t ef ` jdw mdj`hd frem eutsoid tgdor Moiind Lojbiem. `ji
tgd Hgojdsd m`id pd`hd `t gemd fer tgd memdjt tgdrd oj tgd tojidr-
aex ef @so` `b`ojst ` hemmej fed* Ygd ojtendr`and gd`t ef tgdor
g`trdi ef tgd ojv`idrs frem tojy. ojsun`r K`p`j wdnidi `nn Hgoj` ojte
ejd v`st ne`tgojb. ojhegdrdjt m`ss*
Ejd idfojotd `ji sobjofoh`jt rdsunt w`s tgd forst f`ojt sobj ef rd`n
ujoty `mejb tgd m`jy tet`nny ioffdrdjt typds ef @so`toh pdepnds oj tg`t
are`i. onnotdr`td n`ji* K`p`j"s ojv`soej ef Hgoj` ioi merd te ujotd
tgesd pdepnds tgesd rdstndss sejs ef G`j tg`j `jy etgdr ejd tgojb
er `jy etgdr nd`idr g`i iejd sojhd tgd rdvenutoej oj 0?00. wgohg
evdrtgrdw tgd hr`vdj. dffdtd `ji hromoj`nny herrupt eni M`jhgu Iy-
j`sty oj Sdlojb. tgd `jhodjt H`pot`n*
Ot os tgd aortg ef ` jdw Hgoj`. `s tgd Ir`bej stors `ji `w`lds.
wotg wgohg wd`rd hejhdrjdi oj tgd
fennewojb p`bds.r`tgdr tg`j
`jetgdr aeel ej K`p`j"s s`jbuoj`ry ujidhn`rdi w`r wotg `j uj-
wodniy jdobgaer oj tgd hg`etoh Erodjt* Gdrd os ` storrojb hress-sdhtoej
ef tgesd vot`n i`ys ` fdw yd`rs `be. wgdj Hgoj` adb`j fumanojb fer
` j`toej`n hejshoeusjdss `ji teel tgd forst f`ntdrojb stdps upw`ri
tew`ri ujoty*
Ygd Hgojdsd wdrd f`r frem ujotdi wgdj O forst rd`hgdi Xg`jbg`o.
d`rny oj 0?12* @ iddp-reetdi uprosojb g`i adbuj f`r oj tgd iddp
Xeutg ef Hgoj`. `t H`jtej. `ji w`s hejvunsojb `nn d`st @so`* Ot w`s
tgd Luemojt`jb. er Sdepnd"s S`rty. `b`ojst tgd w`r neris `t Sdlojb.
oj tgd Jertg* Ygd rdadns frem Hgoj`"s f`r Xeutg wdrd ndi ay Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl. tgdj ` yeutgfun hemm`jidr wge w`s te adhemd tgdor Bdjdr`n-
ossome* Ygdy swdpt swoftny jertgw`ri. tgreubg tgd _`jbtzd V`nndy.
sdozojb prevojhd `ftdr prevojhd oj tgdor rdndjtndss `iv`jhd. `ji sgeut-
ojb ; Iewj wotg tgd Sdlojb w`r neris ! `ji Iewj wotg tgd Ferdobj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 8/455
Idvons 0 oj tgdor rutgndss fury* Ferdobjdrs frem tgd Rdst wdrd id-
jeujhdi te tgd pdepnd ef Hgoj` `s tgdor djdmods tgdj. `s jew. ay nd`idrs
oj tgd Luemojt`jb*
Ot os tgos tdjsd pdroei. tgd i`wj ef tgd hurrdjt dr` oj tgd dxetoh
Erodjt. wgohg os ioshussdi oj tgos venumd* Je dffert w`s m`id te
wrotd ` step prdss stery ef Hgoj`. wotg aunndtoj-nold `hheujts ef gdr
frdjzodi. gdreoh `ttdmpts te w`ri eff tgd n`ji-gujbry K`p`jdsd wotg
eur foj`jho`n `ji m`tdro`n `oi* Q`tgdr. O g`vd hejhdjtr`tdi dssdjto`nny
ej tgd adbojjojbs ef Hgoj`"s strubbnd tew`ri ujoty `s ` j`toej. se vdry
rdhdjtny. wgond gdr seun-a`rojb Sdepnd"s Qdvenutoej swdpt te vohtery
`reuji md*
My j`md `ji ` aot ef pdrsej`n gostery m`y ad ef ojtdrdst* Mossdn-
wotz os `j eni Bdrm`j j`md. frem X`xejy ej tgd aeridr ef Sen`ji*
O w`s aerj oj Nd`vdjwertg. L`js`s. oj 0?33. `t tgd turj ef tgd
hdjtury* My f`tgdr w`s aerj oj Jdw _erl dobgty-twe yd`rs `be. `ji
gd `ji my metgdr stonn novd oj Mosseuro* Gos f`tgdr w`s aerj oj
X`xejy. `ji fdnn oj nevd wotg ` Bdrm`j born wge g`i novdi nejb oj Fr`jhd*
Ygdy fndi Bdrm`jy oj tgd moiind ef tgd n`st hdjtury `ji sdttndi forst oj
Jdw _erl* Xgertny `ftdr my f`tgdr w`s aerj tgdrd. tgd f`mony mevdi te
Sgon`idnpgo` wgdrd gd w`s rd`rdi* Gd. Gdrm`j Fr`jhos Mossdnwotz.
adh`md ` Sgon`idnpgo` n`wydr< `ji `aeut tgd tomd wgdj Ger`hd Brddndy
w`s tdnnojb yeujb mdj oj tgd brewojb j`toej. rdujotdi fennewojb eur
Hovon R`r. te be wdst. gd wdjt wdst*
Ygdrd oj Nd`vdjwertg. tgdj ` tgrovojb tr`iojb pest `ji kumpojb
eff pn`hd fer tgd stonn jejd tee s`fd
keurjdy`hress tgd hejtojdjt te tgd
Rdst He`st `ji H`noferjo`. gd gujb eut gos sgojbnd* @ji tgdrd tgos
s`jiy g`ordi. anud-dydi X`xej frem M`jg`tt`j mdt my metgdr* Xgd
w`s ` tojy yeujb n`iy. jet nejb frem tgd anud br`ss heujtry ef gdr
j`tovd Ldjtuhly* Xgy i`rl dyds. nold h`vds ef sujnobgt. sgejd frem
gdr idnoh`td fd`turds adjd`tg ` hneui efkdt
an`hl g`or pondi gobg oj `
pemp`ieur. tgdj f`sgoej`and* Frem tgdm. O bdt my nobgt arewj g`or
`jii`rl
arewj dyds*Metgdr
w`s aut 9fddt 00
ojhgdst`nn*
Gdrj`md tgdj w`s Br`hd Dnn` Fodnis* Xgd h`md ef ` moxturd ef Djbnosg-
Jerm`j Frdjhg ej gdr f`tgdr"s soid gd w`s Gdjoy Hn`y Fodnis. ef
eur Tjotdi Xt`tds pest`n sdrvohd `ji ef Xhethg `ji Iuthg ej gdr
metgdr"s soid* Qdr metgdr w`s N`ur` Adnnd Dmary. ef Ldjtuhly. wge
adh`md `j `ridjt tdmpdr`jhd nd`idr ef tgd pest-w`r 'Hovon R`r/ dr`
`ji ejd ef tgd vdry d`rny mdmadrs ef tgd Remdj"s Hgrosto`j Ydrj-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 9/455
pdr`jhd Tjoej gd`idi ay gdr frodji `ji `sseho`td. tgd iyj`moh Fr`jhds
Ronn`ri. oj Rohgot`. L`js`s*
O w`s aerj `s tgd twdjtodtg hdjtury adb`j. jd`r tgd vdry gd`rt
ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds* O `sldi ` frodji oj Adrnoj ` fdw yd`rs `be
te neel ojte tgd f`mony j`md Mossdnwotz. `ji idtdrmojd of O wdrdj"t `t
nd`st p`rtny Kdwosg se tg`t. `s O put ot oj ` ndttdr te gom. O heunij"t ad
` bdjous. tee%" nold se m`jy Kdws `rd oj musoh `ji tgd etgdr `rts. te
s`y jetgojb ef tgdor suhhdss `s a`jldrs `ji oj `nmest `jy loji ef
hemmdrhd er ausojdss My frodji. ` ferdobj herrdspejidjt eroboj`nny
frem Jdw Ernd`js. N`*. g`i tgd j`md Mossdnwotz neeldi up <`ji `ftdr
`j dxtdjsovd sd`rhg oj tgd Qdohgst`b noar`ry oj Adrnoj `ji tgreubg `
prefdssoej`n bdjd`nebosttgdrd. gd wretd a`hl te tgd dffdht tg`t ""a`hl-
te tgd yd`r 733 @ I* yeu"rd 033 pdr hdjt @ry`j. `ji heuni dvdj suot
Gotndr ej tg`t sherd *** se O"m vdry muhg `fr`oi yeu h`j"t adhemd `
bdjous oj tg`t w`y er O mobgt `ii. oj `jy etgdr !
Oj rdhebjotoej ef tgdor gdnpfun sdrvohds. wgohg pn`ydi ` n`rbd p`rt
oj m`lojb tgos aeel pessoand. tg`jls `rd iud te sdvdr`n pdrsejs `ji
erb`joz`toejs. ojhnuiojb A* R Fndosgdr. puanosgdr ef Ygd K`p`j @ivdr-
tosdr. `j @mdroh`j i`ony merjojb jdwsp`pdr projtdi oj Djbnosg oj
Yelye. fer wgem O forst wdjt te tgd F`r D`st oj 0?19* Ygd @ivdrtosdr
sojhd g`s addj seni te tgd K`p`jdsd bevdrjmdjt*
Yg`jls `ji my `pprdho`toej noldwosd `rd iud te tgd Tjotdi Srdss.
fer bovojb md `j `ssobjmdjt oj Xg`jbg`o. d`rny oj 0?12< te Ygd Jdw
_erl Yomds. fer `ppeojtojb md tgdor hgodf herrdspejidjt oj Hgoj`.
n`tdr oj tgd s`md yd`r< te @rtgur G`ys Xunzadrbdr. puanosgdr ef Ygd
Jdw _erl Yomds. fer tdnnojb md O heuni usd m`tdro`n b`tgdrdi fer
tgd p`pdr wgond O w`s oj Hgoj`. `s tgd a`sos fer muhg ef tgos aeel<
`ji te H`rrenn Ldjwertgy. oj R`sgojbtej. IH*. wge `s `j dxpdrt
ej tgd Erodjt. ioi muhg te `jswdr my qudrods er te bdt tgdm `jswdrdi
`t tgd Hgojdsd `ji K`p`jdsd dma`ssods wgond tgos w`s adojb wrottdj*
G* F* M*
Fdaru`ry. 0?90
X`jt` Mejoh`. H`nof*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 10/455
Ye
M_ MEYGDQ
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 11/455
YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
YGDHgojdsd g`i tgd forst nd`bud ef j`toejs ej d`rtg* Ygd oid`
werldi smeetgny fer jd`rny tgrdd hdjturods. ujton tgd Ir`bej
Ygrejd oj Sdlojb w`s evdrtgrewj oj 0?0 0* Ygd m`hgojdry fer
tgos ojoto`n `ttdmpt `t ` nd`bud `mejb mdj w`s sdt up wgdj tgd
M`jhgus sw`rmdi seutg evdr tgd Brd`t R`nn ef Hgoj` `ji hejqudrdi
g`nf ` hejtojdjt* Ygdy teel evdr tgd Moiind Lojbiem. `s tgd Hgojdsd
tgdmsdnvds ojv`ro`any h`nn tgdor heujtry. `ji oj 0699 oj`ubur`tdi tgdor
`utehr`toh rund evdr `nn tgd prevojhds* Ygd M`jhgu rdbomd g`i ots
h`pot`n `t Sdlojb. jew Sdopojb*
Nold tgd Y`rt`rs. Mejbens `ji etgdrs wge g`vd hemd ojte hnesd
hejt`ht wotg tgd Hgojdsd r`hds `ji tgdrd `rd m`jy woidny v`rodi
pdepnds oj tg`t n`ji tgd M`jhgus oj tomd wdrd `aseradi* Ygd pre-
hdss w`s p`ssovd. sh`rhdny jetohd`and frem bdjdr`toej te bdjdr`toej*
Jejd frem eutsoid tgd Brd`t R`nn dvdr g`s addj h`p`and ef wotg-
st`jiojb tgd untom`td `ji sddmojbny ojdvot`and iemoj`jhd ef tgd
Hgojdsd* Sessoany K`p`j m`y hejtren tgd n`ji wd ljew `s Hgoj`*
Ygd n`tdst pessoand suakub`toej ef tgesd pdepnds m`y n`st fer bdjdr-
`toejs. dvdj hdjturods* Ot mobgt wdnn prevd *`Zbrd`t* hovonozojb Zapej+"
*te- tgd Hgojdsd arojbojb tgdm meidrj nofd `ji ots `ttdji`jt adjd-
f`htoejs suhg `s tgd r`ioe. `orpn`jds. `ji dvdj tgd n`st weri oj*
pnumaojb `ji gd`tojb jew se s`iny n`hlojb oj heujtndss monnoejs ef
Hgojdsd gemds* Aut `t n`st tgd idshdji`jts ef tgdsd twdjtodtg hdj-
tury monot`rosts m`y ad `aseradi*
Ygd M`jhgus rundi tgdor forst
nd`bud
ef j`toejs
ay a`jiojb
tgd
v`roeus Hgojdsd prevojhds tebdtgdr ojte wg`t tgdy h`nndi tgd Moiind
Lojbiem* Ygdy adnodvdi tg`t tgd n`ji wd h`nn Hgoj`. `ji quotd
drrejdeusny hejsoidr ejd j`toej. w`s notdr`nny tgd hdjtdr ef tgd d`rtg
`ji tg`t Sdlojb w`s tgd id`i hdjtdr ef tgd Tjovdrsd* Ejd i`y jet
nejb `be O steei ej ` stejd `t tgd brd`t Ydmpnd ef Gd`vdj oj tgd
drstwgond Feraoiidj Hoty wotgoj Sdlojb* O sgeutdi fer tgd dhge.
00
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 12/455
01 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
gejerojb hustem* Ygd veohd `htu`nny ioi seuji semdwg`t gennew.
`s ot usu`nny ieds oj ` tdndpgejd aeetg `jywgdrd r`tgdr `j eii
dxpdrodjhd. oj`smuhg `s tgd id`i hdjtdr os robgt eut oj tgd epdj*
Gew tgd fexy eni `rhgotdhts `rr`jbdi tg`t stujt. wgohg w`s hejvojhojb
te m`jy fer se nejb. os stonn ` roiind*
@ monot`ry bevdrjer w`s pn`hdi oj `utgeroty oj d`hg Srevojhd ujidr
tgd rund ef tgd Xej ef Gd`vdj `ji gos heurt `ivosdrs oj Sdlojb. D`hg
monot`ry bevdrjer swerd `nndbo`jhd te tgd M`jhgu Dmpdrer* Gd p`oi
t`xds. er troautd. `t stopun`tdi ojtdrv`ns `ji rundi gos tdrrotery oj
pd`hd* @s nejb `s tgd rdvdjud fnewdi oj rdbun`rny. Sdlojb m`id je
dffert te ojtdrfdrd* Ygd Srevojhds djkeydi `j dxtdjidi pdroei ef
tr`jquonnoty ujidr tgos h`nm. tgeubg pdrg`ps stuntofyojb. `rr`jbdmdjt*
Ygdrd w`s je qudstoej ef st`tds" robgts fer tgd sompnd rd`sej tg`t
d`hg st`td. prevojhd. j`toej er wg`tdvdr yeu h`rd te h`nn ot g`i
funn frddiem ef `htoej* Ygdy mdrdny p`oi t`xds te tgd hdjtr`n
Bevdrjmdjt. `ji wdjt tgdor ewj w`y*
Ot m`id jet tgd snobgtdst ioffdrdjhd oj tgd werni te ` sompnd
pd`s`jt frem tgd Xg`jbg`o `rd` tg`t gd heuni jet spd`l wotg ` m`j
frem Sdlojb er `jyejd frem etgdr rdmetd hotods `ji iost`jt `rd`s oj
tg`t v`st n`ji* Dvdj tei`y. ` hotozdj ef tgd Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh wge
g`ons frem Sdlojb h`jjet t`nl wotg ` m`j er wem`j frem. s`y. H`j-
tej* @ji ` G`jlew-m`j heuni jet. `ji h`jjet jew. t`nl wotg `jy-
ejd ef jerm`n. pd`s`jt mdjt`noty frem `jy ef tgd etgdr hotods* Ygdy
sompny ie jet t`nl tgd s`md n`jbu`bd*
@s ` rdsunt. `j effoho`n er m`ji`roj+" n`jbu`bd brdw up* Ygd
weri m`ji`roj md`js effoho`n* Fer ojst`jhd. wgdj ejd spd`ls
ef ` m`ji`roj he`t semdwg`t pepun`r oj tgd Rdst. tgd notdr`n
rdfdrdjhd os te ` b`rmdjt ejhd werj ay `j effoho`n ef tgd eni M`jhgu
rdbomd* Mdj ^vd weuni h`nn bevdrjers. m`yers. kuibds`ji tgd nold
werd tgdsd a`ibds ef effohd. `ji usu`nny tgdy wdrd rdspndjidjt. te
omprdss tgd hemmej pdepnd* Ygdsd effoho`n+. `nn evdr tgd Moiind Lojb-
iem hejvdrsdi oj tgd M`ji`roj n`jbu`bd. `ji dvdjtu`nny shgen`rs oj
dvdry prevojhd nd`rjdi ot oj `iiotoej te tgdor ewj tejbud* Ot adh`md
woidsprd`i oj n`tdr yd`rs `ji shgen`rs ujidr tgd M`jhnuus wdrd gobgny
rdspdhtdi* Ygdy prevdi ojv`nu`and te tgd mdj rujjojb tgd m`hgojdry
ef tgd bevdrjmdjt wgohg rundi muhg ef @so`*
Aut tgd m`j oj tgd strddt rdm`ojs uj`and te hejvdrsd wotg mdj
frem etgdr p`rts ef Hgoj`* Ygesd wge h`j rd`i `ji wrotd. gewdvdr.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 13/455
YYOD IQ@BEJ XYOQX 08
h`j bdt tgdor tgeubgts evdr ay wrotojb tgdm fer etgdrs of aetg ljew
djeubg ef tgd heujtndss godrebnypgs. er hg`r`htdrs. wgohg tgd Hgojdsd
pdrsost oj usojb oj prdfdrdjhd te tgd Qem`j `npg`adt. Fdw ef tgd
933.333.333 Hgojdsd ` budss. fer je `hhur`td hdjsus os `v`on`and
g`vd m`stdrdi tg`t fermoi`and t`sl* Ygdrd os `j dffert jew mddtojb
wotg semd md`surd ef suhhdss te td`hg tgdm tgd tgeus`ji hg`r`htdrs
systdm ef sompnofodi wrotojb `ji rd`iojb. `ji r`ioe prebr`ms gdnp te
aoe`ih`st ljewndibd te tgd m`ssds* Oj tgd m`oj. tgd Hgojdsd rdm`oj
`j ojdrt m`ss ef onnotdr`td pdepnds wge iostrust jet ejny mdj frem
`jy ferdobj n`ji. aut d`hgetgdr*
@ m`j frem tgd jdxt prevojhdos
` ferdobjdr%" te monnoejs ef tgd hemmej pd`s`jtry. `ji heenods*
Ygos os ejd fuji`mdjt`n rd`sej wgy tgd Hgojdsd stonn n`hl ujoty
Ygdy `rd ujotdi `t tgd memdjt `b`ojst tgd K`p`jdsd ojv`idrs* Ygd
wgotd-get gd`t ef tgdor g`trdi fer tgd sturiy nottnd mdj frem K`p`j
m`y wdni tgdm tebdtgdr pdrm`jdjtny* Of se. tgd sejs ef H`tg`y
wonn jet g`vd iodi oj v`oj*
Z
Aut `s ` m`ttdr ef f`ht. ` H`jtej-m`j `ji ` Sdlojb-m`j jew
k`rd je merd `nold tg`j `j Ot`no`j er ` Xp`jo`ri. `ji `j Orosgm`j* Ygd
H`jtejdsd os usu`nny sgert. sw`rtgy er i`rl ydnnew. get-gd`idi. `ji
-` be-bdttdr oj ausojdss* Ygdy `rd tgd Hgojdsd ejd erioj`rony fojis
`are`i* Oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. tgeus`jis `rd n`ujirymdj* Ygdor
spddhg seujis soaon`jt. merd sojb-sejb oj tejd tg`j etgdr Hgojdsd
n`jbu`bds* Ygdy `rd tgd rdvenutoej`rods. tgd rdstndss seuns ef @so`*
ft w`s frem H`jtej tg`t tgd n`tdst hovon w`r adb`j. wgdj tgd forst
sddis ef j`toej`n ujoty wdrd pn`jtdi*
Ygd mdj frem tgd jertg `rd t`nndr tg`j tgesd ef tgd H`jtej `rd`*
.Ygdy spd`l ` ioffdrdjt tejbud* Ot os adttdr meiun`tdi. `ji merd
pnd`sojb te gd`r* Ygdsd mdj `rd ndss venh`joh* Ygdy `rd merd eftdj
tgd shgen`rs. a`jldrs. seniodrs* Xemd be ojte ausojdss er tgd pre-
fdssoejs Ygdy r`rdny tr`vdn. `s ie tgd H`jtejdsd*
Ygd eroboj`n Hgojdsd rdvenutoej`rods wge evdrtgrdw tgd M`jhgu
iyj`sty oj 0?00 mevdi tee r`poiny fer tgdor ewj beei* Ygdy id-
streydi `utgeroty. aut g`i jejd wotg wgohg te rdpn`hd ot* Ygd eustdi
Xej ef Gd`vdj w`s ferhdi te w`thg a`jiots `ji w`r neris shr`mand
fer pewdr oj gos rettojb rd`nm*
Ygd upre`r wotgoj Hgoj` ldpt tgd werni budssojb fer yd`rs* Fdw
pdepnd oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds er dnsdwgdrd ujidrst`ji wgy tgd Hgojdsd
`nw`ys g`vd feubgt `mejb tgdmsdnvds*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 14/455
09 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Oj tgd forst pn`hd. ot sgeuni ad ujidrsteei tg`t tgd h`usds ef w`r
oj tgd v`st `ji tddmojb Srevojhds ef Hgoj` `rd oidjtoh`n wotg tgd
h`usds ef w`r `jywgdrd* Oj etgdr weris. tgdy `rd dhejemoh `ji
penotoh`n of tgd twe h`j ad sdp`r`tdi* Ygd ioffdrdjhd os tg`t tgdsd
h`usds `ffdht tgd ojiovoiu`ns ojvenvdi merd iordhtny tg`j tgdy usu`nny
ie dnsdwgdrd* @ m`j keojs `j `rmy oj Hgoj` adh`usd gd jddis tgd
mejdy effdrdi* Gd os eut ef werl. gd h`jjet foji `ke//*
@j oj-
hrd`sojb jumadr jew keojte fobgt K`p`j. `ji `rd sojhdrdny p`troetoh
hgodfny adh`usd tgd K`p`jdsd tgrd`tdj tgd dhejemoh dxostdjhd ef tgd
Hgojdsd*
Ygd m`keroty sdd oj tgd ujoferm ` nohdjsd te neet< oj tgd rofnd. `
hg`jhd te b`oj ` wd`ntg ef serts< oj tgd revojb nofd ef ` seniodr. wg`t
nottnd rem`jhd tgdrd os te ad g`i eut ef `j dxostdjhd tg`t os `t adst
a`rrdj*
Hejsdrv`tovd dstom`tds pn`hd Hgoj`"s `rmdi ferhds `t frem 0.433.-
333 te 1.333.333 mdj. aut jejd h`j heujt `hhur`tdny tgd gerids oj
tgd `rmods `ji a`jiot a`jis tg`t re`m tgdor s`jbuoj`ry w`y `aeut
tgd w`rterj f`hd ef ` tordi H`tg`y* F`mojd g`s `iidi te tgd gerrer
ef hovon w`rs fer idh`ids `ji ef K`p`jdsd ojv`soejs oj n`ttdr yd`rs<
`ji tgeus`jis ef mdj `rd rd`iy te be ojte `j `rmy er keoj ` idspdr`td
a`jiot a`ji te lddp frem st`rvojb* Ygdor ojhrd`sdi jumadrs `ii te
tgd vot`n seho`n preandms tgdy weuni dsh`pd< aut tgdor ompunsd os hdr-
t`ojny j`tur`n ujidr tgd horhumst`jhds*
Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `ji etgdr nd`idrs oj tgd eni
J`jlojb rdbomd. jew ej ` w`rtomd a`sos `t Hgujblojb. `rd g`mpdrdi
ay n`hl ef hemmujoh`toejs `ji ay tgd j`tur`n meujt`oj n`ors te ad
feuji oj m`jy prevojhds* Dfferts te m`ojt`oj n`w `ji eridr `rd
fddand dvdj oj jerm`n tomds* @jy bevdrjmdjt. `s Yelye wonn jew
foji eut `t J`jlojb. wonn g`vd ioffohunty ojadttdrojb tgd sotu`toej
r`poiny* Dvdj ` aej` foid Hgojdsd Hdjtr`n bevdrjmdjt weuni g`vd
ioffohunty oj m`ojt`ojojb eridr evdr `nn Hgoj` ujton suhg tomd `s r`on-
re`is `ji gobgw`ys h`j ad auont. tgd pd`s`jtry diuh`tdi `ji ` strejb
j`toej`n `rmy dvenvdi frem tgd prdsdjt stonn neesdny fdidr`tdi ferhds*
A`jiots g`vd addj ` tr`iotoej`n sheurbd ef Hgoj` fer hdjturods*
Ygdsd revojb reaadrs `rd hejsoidrdi `s hdrt`oj tgdrd `s id`tg `ji
t`xds* Ygd a`jiot-supprdssoej bdjdr`ns ehh`soej`nny feuji ot dxpdiodjt
te ojherper`td a`jiot b`jbs ojte tgdor `rmods r`tgdr tg`j try tefobgt
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 15/455
YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX OX
ot eut wotg tgd eutn`ws* A`jiot ejd i`y. seniodr tgd jdxt os `
truosm oj Hgoj`*
Ygdrd os ` hn`ssoh stery teni `nejb tgd Hgoj` he`st ef gew tgd
forst penohd ferhd oj tgd werni h`md te ad fermdi tgdrd* O eutnojd ot
gdrd. te idmejstr`td tgd tgereubgny rdsobjdi `ttotuid tew`ri tgdsd
Kdssd K`mds mdj ef @so`*
@ pewdrfun a`jiot hgodft`oj oj enidj tomds. ot os s`oi. fdnn oj nevd
wotg tgd i`ubgtdr ef ` wd`ntgy mdrhg`jt oj tgd `rd` oj wgohg tgd
a`jiot `ji gos mdj gdni sw`y* Gd w`s nejb uj`and te woj gdr* Aut
ejd i`y gd tgeubgt ef ` shgdmd* Gd eridrdi gos mdj te r`oi tgd
mdrhg`jt"s p`n`to`n w`rdgeusd `ji wgdj tgdy iovoidi tgd neet. `nn
gd teel w`s `j overy mojo`turd ef tgd mdrhg`jt"s i`ubgtdr*
Iosbuosojb gomsdnf `s ` tr`vdndr. tgd a`jiot Hgodf teel tgd mojo-
`turd te tgd mdrhg`jt"s gemd ` fdw i`ys n`tdr*
O adb yeu. sor. gd s`oi. te pdrmot md te rdturj tgos overy
mojo`turd wgohg O hg`jhdi upej oj ` sgep oj tgd vonn`bd* O nd`rjdi
ef yeur ness. `ji `m pnd`sdi te rdturj ot te yeu*
Ygd mdrhg`jt w`s jet feendi* Gd teni tgd a`jiot tg`t gd rdheb-
jozdi gom `ji `sldi wg`t gd w`jtdi* Ygd a`jiot rdpnodi `mo`any*
Jew tg`t tgdy ujidrsteei ejd `jetgdr. gd s`oi. gd w`jtdi mdrdny te
m`rry tgd mdrhg`jt"s i`ubgtdr* Ygd mdrhg`jt rdfusdi* Gd idhn`rdi
ojiobj`jtny ot w`s ompessoand tg`t ` i`ubgtdr ef gos sgeuni wdi `
tgodf. `ji tgdy t`nldi ef etgdr tgojbs
Foj`nny ` heujtdr-prepes`n w`s m`id ay tgd mdrhg`jt* Gd hem-
pn`ojdi ef tgd gd`vy ndvods wgohg tgd a`jiot"s r`ois wdrd m`lojb ej
gos prepdrtods `ji effdrdi te p`y tgd hgodft`oj ` hdrt`oj jumadr ef
podhds ef sonvdr d`hg yd`r of tgd a`jiot weuni ejny quot reaaojb gom.
`ji weuni `ssurd gom ef ommujoty te ness tgreubg tgodvdry ay etgdrs*
Ygdy m`id ` id`n `ftdr tgd g`aotu`n penotd g`bbnojb `ji swerd `j
e`tg te tgd p`ht*
@ wddl er se n`tdr tgd a`jiot h`nndi gos prespdreus a`ji tebdtgdr*
Gd g`i addj quotd ausy oj tgd md`jtomd* Rgdj tgdy g`i `nn hemd
tebdtgdr gd `iirdssdi tgdm wotg gos prepes`n* Gd g`i sddj mest ef
tgd mdrhg`jts oj gos tdrrotery `ji gd g`i bet tgd etgdrs te `brdd
te p`y sdt sums ` yd`r fer ommujoty*
Ygd tet`n. my ardtgrdj%" gd s`oi. ay f`r dxhddis tgd `meujt wd
g`vd `vdr`bdi ay werlojb g`ri `s a`jiots oj rdhdjt yd`rs* Gdjhd.
wd m`y rdtord `ji ydt ad `ssurdi ef ojhemds brd`tdr tg`j of wd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 16/455
06 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
hejtojud te pny eur `jhodjt `ji gejer`and prefdssoej `mejb tgd
wertgy bdjtry ef tgdsd jeand gonns*
Ygdrd w`s je nottnd iossdjsoej `t forst* Ygd a`jiots gdsot`tdi te
bovd up tgd `jhodjt prefdssoej wgohg tgdy `ji tgdor `jhdsters g`i
fennewdi fer bdjdr`toejs* Aut oj tgd dji. `nn `brddi te tgdor hgodf"s
pn`js* Ygdy weuni hd`sd te pnujidr < noldwosd. tgdy `brddi te prdvdjt
nov`n a`jis frem reaaojb tgdor bdjdreus p`trejs* Oj ` weri. tgd forst
penohd ferhd ej d`rtg w`s feujidi*
Ygd a`jiot nd`idr. jew ` rdspdht`and hgodf-ef-penohd. p`oi heurt te
tgd mdrhg`jt"s i`ubgtdr* Oj iud heursd. tgd stery rujs. tgdy wdrd
m`rrodi `ji novdi g`ppony dvdr `ftdr*
Yrud er jet. tgos bovds `j ojsobgt ojte tgd `vdr`bd Hgojdsd psy-
hgeneby ej a`jiotry* A`jiots hejtojud te pn`y `j ompert`jt p`rt oj
tgd monot`ry nofd ef tgd n`ji* Iurojb K`p`j"s ujidhn`rdi w`r `ji
fer yd`rs `ftdrw`ris. a`jiots m`y ad dxpdhtdi te re`m frem ujoferm
te ujoferm `ji a`hl `b`oj wotg `stejosgojb `a`jiej*
Oj Yelye. tgdrd os ` strejb `ji r`poiny brewojb sdjtomdjt `mejb
tgd ney`n suakdhts ef Dmpdrer Goregote fer ` brd`tdr. `ji dvdr merd
pewdrfun K`p`j* Ygdor jdw hry os. @so` fer tgd @so`tohs! Ygdy
gepd te `hgodvd Ttepo` oj tgd Erodjt`n gdmospgdrd* @ji mest om-
pert`jt te us. tgd K`p`jdsd weuni dvoht tgd hdjtury-eni iemoj`tojb
ojfnudjhd ef tgd wgotd m`j frem `nn tgd F`r D`st `ji rund tgdm-
sdnvds*
Dvdj `mejb tgd Hgojdsd. ef n`ttdr i`ys. tgd K`p`jdsd g`vd semd
suppertdrs oj tgd surbd tew`ri rdjdwdi vober `ji `utgeroty fer tgd
ydnnew r`hds ef tgd werni* Etgdrs wge ehh`soej`nny keoj tgd K`p`jdsd
oj tgos pg`sd ef tgdor irovd fer pewdr `rd tgd pdepnds ef Ojio`. tgd
Fonopoje r`hds Mere. Y`b`neb `ji etgdrs tgd Xo`mdsd. Yoadt`js.
Mejbens. @r`as `ji dvdj tgd Yurls `ji revojb Mesndm troads ef
Jertg @froh`*
S`ssoej`tdny. `nw`ys oj tgd buosd ef gobg p`troetosm. tgd K`p`jdsd
gepd tg`t ejd i`y tgdy wonn `hgodvd hejtren ef tgd djtord F`r D`st* M`jyef tgdsd zd`nets weuni dvdj ojhnuid @ustr`no` oj tgdor f`r-fnujb
shgdmd* Joppej"s st`tdsmdj djvos`bd K`p`j `s tgd spd`rgd`i ef tgos
mevdmdjt. dmdrbojb ejd i`y `s tgd brd`tdst pewdr oj gostery* Oj
tgd n`st hdjtury `jetgdr osn`ji lojbiem Djbn`ji. oj tgd Ehhoidjt
resd te suhg gdobgts tgreubg tgd ird`ms `ji dxpneots ef Neri Hnovd
ef Ojio`< ef Bn`istejd. Iosr`dno `ji tgdor ompdro`nostoh mdj-ef-tgd-pdj.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 17/455
YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX 02
suhg `s tgd n`td Quiy`ri Lopnojb* Ygus ot os jet tee f`r-fdthgdi `
ird`m jew fer ydnnew mdj wge pejidr ej tg`t. te `spord te somon`r
bnery `ji `hgodvdmdjts
Ygdrd `rd easdrvdrs `t tgd dma`ssods. ndb`toejs `ji hejsun`tds oj
tgd Erodjt wge adnodvd tg`t f`or-slojjdi pdepnds oj tgd rdst ef tgd
werni weuni ad wosd kust jew te objerd K`p`j"s idtdrmojdi nottnd
monot`ry mdj `ji tgdor `jtohs. rdb`rindss ef wg`t tgdy ie* Gewdvdr.
tg`t os jet eur hgodf hejhdrj gdrd Ot os ` f`shoj`tojb stuiy. `ji
tgd K`p`jdsd ojv`soej ef Hgoj` ujieuatdiny wonn ad tgd suakdht ef
m`jy aeels. otsdnf* Aut O sg`nn ioshuss gdrd tgd rubbdi mdj `ji
swoft dvdjts tg`t g`vd ldpt tgd F`r D`st oj mystoh turmeon fer merdtg`j ` qu`rtdr ef ` hdjtury*
Ygd idh`id 0?12-82 adb`j wotg tgd st`rt ef tgd voendjt Luemojt`jb
Qdvenutoej `t H`jtej* O sg`nn idshroad tgd rdadns" sdozurd ef Xg`jbg`o
`ji tgd turaundjt dvdjts wgohg fennewdi wgond O w`s novojb eut tgdrd
oj tgd tgohl ef ot*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 18/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN
YGDeffohdr frem tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojd Herps `aruptny nd`jdi
`hress eur iojojb t`and `t tgd @mdroh`j Hnua oj Xg`jbg`o `ji
surprosdi md wotg ` suiidj qudstoej*9
"H`j yeu lddp ` sdhrdt5 gd `sldi*
Gos veohd g`i adhemd new `ji eiiny ojtdjsd* Ot w`s f`r frem `p-
prepro`td te tgd gddindss `tmespgdrd `reuji us. O teni gom O heuni.
of jdhdss`ry. aut s`oi tg`t adojb ` w`r herrdspejidjt `t tgd gdobgt ef
tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej hejvunsojb `nn Hgoj` md`jt hut-tgre`t hem-
pdtotoej. p`rtohun`rny oj sdhrdts* Ygdrd wdrd notdr`nny sherds ef etgdr
prdss mdj wge g`i addj sdjt eut D`st ay tgd syjioh`tdi prdss sdrvohds
`s wdnn `s heujtndss ojiovoiu`n jdwsp`pdrs `ji m`b`zojds oj pr`htoh`nny
dvdry hovonozdi heujtry ej d`rtg*
O h`j%" O s`oi. *aut yeu h`j"t m`ld md nold ot* Rgy5Gd tgeubgt fer ` memdjt* Ygdj ;
_eu"nn ljew tgos ay merjojb `jyw`y< O mobgt `s wdnn tdnn yeujew* Aut wonn yeu lddp yeur seurhd. `t nd`st. `asenutdny ` sdhrdt
adtwddj us5
Sesotovdny*
El`y. gd `jswdrdi. aut iej"t quetd md* O"nn idjy ot! Jewnostdj. tgos os str`obgt iepd* Ot"s effoho`n. er wonn ad ay merjojb. `jy-
w`y* O mobgt ossud eur hemmujoqud mysdnf* Xe bdt tgos;
Ygd H`jtejdsd `rd ej tgd m`rhg* Ygdor treeps `rd hnesojb oj tgos
mojutd* Xg`jbg`o wonn f`nn oj tgd jdxtferty-dobgt
geurs* @ji tg`t"s
` f`ht*
O wej"t quetd yeu. O premosdi. aut ndt"s bdt eut ef gdrd. jew!
Of tg`t"s frem yeur M`rojd Ojtdnnobdjhd rdperts. ot beds te Jdw _erl
tejobgt* O"m h`anojb ot urbdjt* @ji wotgeut qu`nofoh`toej*
_eu"i adttdr ad robgt er r`tgdr. O g`i! Hemd ej*
Rd gurrodi evdr te tgd bneemy-neelojb r`msg`hlnd Tjotdi Srdss
07
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 19/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 0?
effohds. twe anehls iewj Feehgew Qe`i tew`ri tgd Auji. er w`tdr-
frejt* Ygd effohdr `ji O stumandi iewj ` an`hl. heaand-stejdi anoji
`nndy te
myidsl* O wretd `j urbdjt h`and te tgd Tjotdi Srdss oj
Nejiej. tgdj my rdn`y peojt te tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds* Ot rd`i;
H@JYEJDXD YQEESX M@QHGOJB* F@NN XG@JBG@O
TJN@YDQJ MEJI@_ OJDVOY@AND*
Yg`t w`s `nn* Aut ot w`s djeubg*
Aey%0
O sgeutdi* ""Hgep hgep! Bdt beojb !
@ heenod h`md rujjojb* Gd br`aadi tgd iosp`thg. geppdi ej gos
aohyhnd `ji w`s eff fer tgd Ydndbr`pg Auoniojb. twe anehls `w`y ej
@vdjud Diw`ri VOO* @ fdw mojutds `ftdr tgd M`rojd effohdr"s quodt
`jjeujhdmdjt `t tgd @mdroh`j Hnua. weri w`s ej ots w`y* Ot b`vd
` sm`sgojb nd`i fer my X`turi`y `ftdrjeej p`pdrs `nn evdr tgd Tjotdi
Xt`tds `ji Xeutg @mdroh`. `ji tgd dvdjojb diotoejs oj Durepd* Ygd
werni g`i w`otdi wddls. wgond Hgoj`"s rdvenutoej w`s `t st`ndm`td*
M`jy ferdobjdrs wdrd tgereubgny hejvojhdi tgd Jertg Hgoj` w`r
neris g`i wej* Xemd tg`t dvdjtfun jobgt dvdj h`andi tgdor frodjis er
jdwsp`pdrs a`hl gemd tg`t Xg`jbg`o w`s stonn ojvojhoand* F`td prevdi
tgd hejtr`ry. `ji `nse w`s loji te md*
Ygd ioffdrdjhd oj tomd m`id my fertujd pessoandstg`t. `ji ojvotojb
` M`rojd effohdr te iojjdr wotg md `t tgd @mdroh`j Hnua. oj ` purdny
h`su`n memdjt* Jojd e"hnehl `t jobgt oj Xg`jbg`o os dobgt e"hnehl
tgd merjojb ef tgd s`md i`y oj Jdw _erl. fer Jdw _erl os tgortddj
geurs adgoji Xg`jbg`o* Yomd w`s wotg md< `nse tgd M`rojd* Rdg`i addj werlojb tebdtgdr dvdr sojhd gos `rrov`n ej tgd treep tr`js-
pert sgop Hg`umejt sdvdr`n wddls adferd tgos jobgt* Rd g`i sw`ppdi
tops `ji mutu`n hejfoidjhds. `ji jew gd b`vd md tgd topej wg`t wd g`i
addj w`otojb fer `nn tgesd frdjzodi i`ys oj tg`t mest a`ffnojb ef hotods.
Xg`jbg`o*
Ygos ojhoidjt ehhurrdi ej M`rhg 0?. 0?12* Hgoj` w`s oj `
trdmdjieus upgd`v`n* Gdr sejs wdrd djb`bdi oj rdvenutoej* Xemdh`nndi ot hovon w`r* Gdr mdj frem tgd Jertg `ji tgesd frem tgd
Xeutg wdrd fobgtojb oj ` idspdr`td strubbnd fer m`stdry* Aretgdrs
feubgt aretgdrs. `s oj eur R`r adtwddj tgd Xt`tds* Ygd Xevodt
Tjoej w`s '`ji rdm`ojs/ merd tg`j `j ojtdrdstdi easdrvdr* Ygd
rdadnnoej g`i ` Qusso`j @ivoser`td sdjt eut frem Meshew* Ot w`s
gd`idi ay Mol`n Aereioj* Yei`y. gd rujs `j Djbnosg-n`jbu`bd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 20/455
13 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
jdwsp`pdr oj Meshew soh tr`jsot bnero` mujio* K`p`j noldwosd w`s
f`r frem oind* Xgd g`i je `ivoser`td ej dotgdr soid effoho`nny*
Aut gdr monot`rosts. dvdr
djhg`jhojb
tgdor pewdr `are`i. g`i `j `hd
oj tgd gend oj tgd pdrsej ef tgd Aey Dmpdrer. ` shgen`rny aut gdnp-
ndss yeujb m`j ef tgd eni M`jhgu Iyj`sty oj Sdlojb wge g`i
hg`jbdi gos j`md te pn`oj Mr* Gdjry Su-yo*
Ygd Qusso`js fndi n`tdr oj 0?12* K`p`j tdj`hoeusny gujb ej*
Dvdjtu`nny. oj 0?80. sgd sdozdi M`jhguro`. rdj`mdi ot M`jhgulue `ji
put tgd Aey Dmpdrer ej tgd tgrejd ef gos `jhdsters* Gd os ` M`j-
hgu* Xemd i`y. tgd K`p`jdsd monot`rosts oj tgdor nust fer bnery `ji
pewdr 'er p`troetosm. `s tgdy `rd funny hejvojhdi/ m`y ad dxpdhtdi
te pn`hd tgdor puppdt `b`oj ej gos Ir`bej Ygrejd oj Sdopojb* Ot
heuni g`ppdj aut tg`t os `jetgdr stery* @nn Hgoj`. md`jwgond. rd-
m`ojs oj hg`es. `ji prea`any wonn. fer yd`rs*
O fennewdi up tgd iosp`thg wotg ` arodf idshroptoej ef tgd `iv`jhd
`s idshroadi ay tgd M`rojd* Gd s`oi gos Ojtdnnobdjhd Herps nodutdj`jts
g`i addj eut tew`ri tgd rdadn H`jtejdsd nojds `nn tg`t X`turi`y. `ji
g`i t`nldi wotg tgd `iv`jhd bu`ris*
Ygd irovd os ej. je qudstoej. gd s`oi* Ygdrd"nn ad ` beei sgew
ej ay merjojb. er Meji`y `t tgd n`tdst*
Rd bet eff tgesd iosp`thgds `ji tgdj m`id ` reuji ef tgd Xg`jbg`o
idfdjsds aetg oj tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt `ji oj tgd Frdjhg
Hejhdssoej* Mest ef tgd @mdroh`js novojb oj Xg`jbg`o wdrd neh`tdi
oj tgd n`ttdr `rd`. hgodfny wotgoj sm`nn h`jjej r`jbd ef tgd j`tovd hoty*
Oj f`ht. semd ef tgdor gemds tg`t turaundjt. ujferbdtt`and sprojb. wdrd
i`m`bdi ay sgdnns*
Ej tgd strddts. p`trens ef ferdobj treeps frem g`nf ` iezdj j`toejs
`reuji tgd werni ldpt tgd hurfdw* Eur prdss `ji monot`ry p`ssds.
gewdvdr. m`id us ommujd te tgd strohtny djferhdi eridrs tg`t `nn
hovono`js ad eff tgd strddts ay 03 p*m*
Xg`jbg`o. oj tg`t dvdjtfun sprojb ef 0?12 wgdj tgd J`toej`nost
'Luemojt`jb/ `rmods frem tgd Xeutg h`md re`rojb ojte tgd V`nndy
ef tgd _`jbtzd. w`s dvdj merd tg`j usu`n tgd dxetoh andji ef D`st `ji
Rdst* Ot sprd`i ots b`odty `ji wohldijdss ots ojjehdjhd `mejb tgd
mossoej`rods. `ji ots fontg `mejb tgd newdst iovds `nejb tgd new a`jls
ef tgd Rg`jbpee Qovdr. ` fdw monds upstrd`m frem tgd pn`hd wgdrd
tgd are`i. ydnnew _`jbtzd mddts tgd sd`
Rgond treeps ef f`r j`toejs hejhdjtr`tdi oj m`rto`n `rr`y adgoji
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 21/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 10
a`radi word `ji s`jia`b dmpn`hdmdjts. tgd pepun`hd Hgojdsd `s
wdnn `s ferdobj i`jhdi `j `m`zojb wgorn oj ` w`rtomd `tmespgdrd
ef tgereubg `a`jiej* _eujb Hgojdsd m`ois fextrettdi te @mdroh`j
n`zz oj sw`jl jobgt hnuas `s nuxuroeus `s `jy oj S`ros. Adrnoj er
Jdw _erl* Ygdy i`jhdi wotg Hgojdsd yeutgs diuh`tdi oj tgd ujo-
vdrsotods ef Durepd `ji tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds* Eni Hgojdsd. sw`tgdi oj
tgd he`rsd anud hnetgojb ef tgd heujtry-soid. mojbndi wotg tgd yeujbdr
bdjdr`toej* Ferdobjdrs frem tgd feur herjdrs ef tgd d`rtg h`md `ji
wdjt ej djindss mossoejs* Xemd wdrd spods werlojb fer tgd Xeutg.
tgd Jertg. tgd K`p`jdsd `jyaeiy wge weuni p`y tgdm* Aut mest
30 tgdm wdrd ausojdssmdj wotg dyd te ` quohl prefot* @ji ef heursd.
tgdrd wdrd tgd sherds ef prdss herrdspejidjts tgdrd te hevdr tgd
stery fer rd`idrs te wgem tgd hoty w`s aut ` j`md*
Aut oj tgd m`oj tgdy wdrd tr`idrs idshdji`jts ef mdj wge wdjt
eut oj tgd rem`jtoh hnoppdr sgop i`ys ef tgd n`st hdjtury. `ji wge jew
ewjdi sp`hoeus dst`tds ej tgd f`sgoej`and eutslorts ef tgd mdtrepenos*
Etgdrs `ppd`rdi wotg bdt-rohg-quohl shgdmds oj wgohg gobg ojtrobud
merd eftdj tg`j jet pn`ydi ` sojostdr p`rt* Y`nn Xolgs frem Ojio`.
rofnds snujb oj rd`iojdss evdr tgdor tewdrojb sgeunidrs. penohdi tgd Oj-
tdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt. tgdor arobgt tura`js. an`hl ad`ris `ji fn`sgojb
dyds `nn p`rt ef tgd pohturdsqud sdttojb* Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojds. sm`rt
oj tgdor ujoferms. Arotosg Yemmods. Frdjhg s`oners `ji tgdor
sw`rtgy @j`motds frem Ojie-Hgoj`. K`p`jdsd treeps `ji m`rojds.
Ot`no`js. `ji Sertubudsd sw`rmdi oj `ji `reuji tgd hoty tgd mdj
oj tgd @nnodi @rmy ef Idfdjsd wge tgrdw ` rojb ef a`yejdts `reuji
Xg`jbg`o `ji ldpt ot s`fd frem tgd Hgojdsd `rmods strubbnojb fer
pessdssoej ef tgd j`tovd p`rt ef tg`t rovdr pert*
Ferdobj mdj-ef-w`r n`y `jhgerdi eff tgd Auji. rd`iy te pretdht
tgd novds `ji prepdrty ef j`toej`ns frem evdrsd`s* Ygdrd wdrd ferty-
sox ferdobj w`rsgops strujb eut `nejb tgd j`rrew w`tdrw`y `t tgd
gdobgt ef tgd rdvenutoej* Oj tgd ferdobj `rd`s. sox monds `nejb tgd
rovdr frejt `ji wotgoj ` pdromdtdr ef jd`rny tgorty monds. g`jisemd
meidrj m`jsoejs. a`jls. getdns `s fojd `s `jy ej d`rtg. `ji ad`uto-
funny `ppeojtdi hnuas. `nn fneurosgdi* Y`xoh`as. ausds. tr`hlndss trenndy-
h`rs r`j ej tgd are`i `vdjuds. hnuttdrdi wotg rohlsg`ws `ji `jhodjt.
hrd`lojb Hgojdsd wgddna`rrews* Evdrgd`i. hemmdrho`n pn`jds frem
Gujbk`e @orpert eutsoid tgd hoty. er dnsdwgdrd. irejdi geurny idspotd
tgd w`r adjd`tg tgdm.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 22/455
11 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
Ej tgd Auji steei tgd Xg`jbg`o Hnua wotg ots nejbdst a`r oj
tgd werni p`hldi tgrdd iddp `t jeej `ji jobgt fer g`nf ` anehl `nejb
ots aurjosgdi i`rl weeidj ndjbtg* Ot os kust adnew @vdjud Diw`ri
VOO. aeuji`ry adtwddj tgd Frdjhg Hejhdssoej `ji tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n
Xdttndmdjt* @ fdw anehls `w`y. iewj Feehgew Qe`i. tgd @mdroh`j
Hnua f`hdi tgd Mujohop`n Auoniojb otsdnf ` m`bjofohdjt stejd struhturd
hevdrojb ` hoty anehl* Ygd @mdroh`j Hnua. `j dobgt-stery auoniojb ef
rdi arohl. meidrj oj dvdry idt`on. w`s p`hldi i`y `ji jobgt. ots dvdry
reem fonndi wotg mdj areubgt tgdrd ay tgd w`r. @ sherd er merd
Arotosg effohdrs teel qu`rtdrs tgdrd. fojiojb ot merd hgddry tg`j `
getdn er `jetgdr hnua*
Jobgt hnuas r`j ujton i`wj* S`trejs ojsoid `ftdr 03 p*m* wdrd
uj`and te be gemd ujton tgd hurfdw w`s noftdi `t i`wj. `aeut 9 `*m*
Ygd penohd wdrd hejtrenndi ay tgd Arotosg oj tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttnd-
mdjt* Ygd Hemmossoejdr w`s Arotosg. `s wdrd tgd Ojspdhters `ji
etgdr effohdrs* Tjidr tgdm wdrd tgd Xolgs. semd Hgojdsd `ji ` fdw
Qusso`j p`trenmdj `ji tr`ffoh effohdrs*
Ygd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt w`s se j`mdi adh`usd ot os hempesdi
ef tgd eni Arotosg `ji K`p`jdsd `ji wg`t w`s te g`vd addj tgd
@mdroh`j Hejhdssoejs* Ygd @mdroh`j Hejhdssoej w`s te g`vd addj
adtwddj tgd Arotosg `ji K`p`jdsd* Aut tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds oj tgd n`st
hdjtury. wgdj tgos `rr`jbdmdjt w`s adojb m`id ej tgd muifn`ts ef
tgd mesquote-ojfdstdi Rg`jbpee Qovdr. `t tgd dxprdss eridrs ef tgd
Hgojdsd wge w`jtdi a`iny te sdbrdb`td tgd ferdobj a`ra`ro`j
tr`idrs tg`t pdstdrdi tgdm wotg beeis rdfusdi te t`ld ` hejhdssoej
oj Xg`jbg`o er `jywgdrd oj Hgoj`*
Ygd Arotosg `ji K`p`jdsd `s ` rdsunt prepesdi ` hemaoj`toej. `ji
tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt w`s aer`* Ygd Frdjhg teel tgdor hej-
hdssoej. wgohg adh`md ` sdp`r`td p`rt ef Xg`jbg`o. bevdrjdi ay `
Frdjhg Mujohop`n Heujhon. ujidr tgd Frdjhg Hejsun-Bdjdr`n* Xg`jb-
g`o w`s ` tropny iovoidi hoty. tgdj. ef semd 8.143.333 ojg`aot`jts
prdiemoj`jtny. ef heursd. Hgojdsd*
Ef tgd tet`n pepun`toej. pessoany 43.333 wdrd ferdobjdrs* Ygdrd
wdrd `aeut 4.333 @mdroh`js. 7.333 Arotosg. `ji pessoany 1.333 etgdr
Durepd`js. mest ef tgdm dotgdr Frdjhg er Bdrm`j* Ygdrd wdrd `nse
semd 04.333 er merd Qusso`js. hgodfny dmobrds ferhdi te nd`vd gemd
ay tgd rosd ef tgd Aensgdvol rdbomd* Ygdsd fndi te Hgoj` tgreubg
Xoadro` ay w`y ef G`raoj. oj wg`t w`s M`jhguro`* Ygdrd wdrd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 23/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 18
13.333 er se K`p`jdsd er etgdr @so`tohs. `s wdnn* Ygd K`p`jdsd ewjdi
mest ef tgd epundjt hettej-tdxtond monns oj Xg`jbg`o*
Ot w`s oj tgos sdttojb `ji `t ` mestdxhotojb pdroei
oj
Xg`jbg`o"smeidrj gostery tg`t tgd M`rojd H`pt`oj `ji O m`id eur w`y `reuji
tgd eutnyojb idfdjsds tg`t X`turi`y jobgt* Rd `htu`nny feuji jetgojb
dxtr`erioj`ry. `ntgeubg tgd Frdjhg `pp`rdjtny g`i g`i weri ef tgd
`iv`jhd `ji wdrd merd tg`j usu`nny `ndrt* Oj f`ht. tgdy g`i addj
hrotohozdi semdwg`t ay tgd etgdr bdjdr`n effohdrs ef tgd ferdobj
Xg`jbg`o Idfdjsd Ferhd. `ji `t ejd tomd oj tgd prehddiojbs tgd Ojtdr-
j`toej`n Xdttndmdjt hejtojbdjt put up a`radi-word djt`jbndmdjts fer
` mond er merd iewj @vdjud Diw`ri VOO. sdp`r`tojb tgd Frdjhg
Hejhdssoej ej tgd etgdr soid. wgohg f`hdi tgd Hgojdsd j`tovd hoty
ef J`jt`e*
Aut wgond tgd Idfdjsd Ferhd effohdrs m`y g`vd ljewj. hdrt`ojny
fdw `mejb tgd hovono`j pepun`toej wdrd `w`rd tg`t tgd J`toej`nosts
frem H`jtej wdrd iosrdb`riojb eridrs frem tgd tdmper`ry Qdi-hej-
trenndi rdadn bevdrjmdjt up tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr `t G`jlew. `ji wdrd
mevojb ej Xg`jbg`o* Ot g`i eroboj`nny addj pn`jjdi te prehddi te
Sdlojb evdrn`ji. ay tgd a`hl ieer. nd`vojb Xg`jbg`o te f`nn ejhd
tgd rdvenutoej g`i h`pturdi tgd `jhodjt H`pot`n* Aut nd`idrs oj tgd
J`toej`nost @rmy. ojhnuiojb Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. areld wotg
G`jlew `ji ots Qusso`j @ivoser`td. h`pturdi Xg`jbg`o `ji sdt up
tgd sdmo-hejsdrv`tovd rdbomd oj 0?12 `t J`jlojb*
Ygd H`jtejdsd. er J`toej`nosts `s tgdy ojsostdi ej adojb h`nndi
'adh`usd tgd mevdmdjt w`s jet purdny H`jtejdsd/. g`i addj iub oj
`aeut dobgtddj monds seutg ef Xg`jbg`o fer ` mejtg. w`otojb fer weri
te `tt`hl* Ygdor prdsdjhd `t forst st`rtndi tgd hempn`hdjt Xg`jbg`o
pepun`hd. ojhnuiojb tgd @mdroh`js. aut wgdj jetgojb g`ppdjdi wddl
`ftdr wddl. tgdor kottdrs adb`j te suasoid `s muhg `s tgdy heuni oj
tg`t `tmespgdrd ef ujhdrt`ojty `ji monot`ry iospn`y* Ygd ferdobjdrs
prehddidi wotg pn`js fer tgdor dv`hu`toej te tgd Auji `ji tgdjhd. of
jdhdss`ry. te w`rsgops oj tgd rovdr*
Ygdhoty
w`s `stor wotg ojtdjsd dxhotdmdjt* _dt ejny ` g`jifun
ljdw tgd hnom`x w`s iud tg`t wddl dji*
Ygd jdxt i`y. M`rhg 13. w`s ` hnd`r. w`rm. sprojb X`aa`tg* O
g`i nujhgdej wotg K* A* Sewdnn. puanosgdr ef ` neh`n wddlny oj Djbnosg
`ji spdho`n herrdspejidjt fer tgd Hgoh`be Yroaujd* Gd `ji O `ji
` budst irevd eutsoid tgd nojds tg`t Xuji`y `ftdrjeej. `b`ojst tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 24/455
19 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
eridrs ef eur Hejsun`r `ji J`v`n `utgerotods `ji r`j ojte `iv`jhojb
H`jtejdsd! Rd g`i p`ssdi jumdreus h`rs ej tgd irovd. fonndi wotg
herrdspejidjts `ji pgetebr`pgdrs eut fer tgd jdws `ji tgd tgronn* Rd
`nn bet pndjty ef aetg* Ygd rdtrd`tojb Jertgdrj treeps wdrd puttojb
up ` g`nf-gd`rtdi rdsost`jhd te tgd J`toej`nost irovd* Rd r`j ojte
gujirdis ef tgdm ej tgd tdj-mond irovd tgreubg wg`t. dvdj tgdj.
sddmdi ` pd`hdfun. p`ster`n shdjd
Rd ndft Xg`jbg`o. `ji meterdi r`poiny p`st f`rmdrs beojb `aeut
tgdor nottnd truhl-f`rmojb hgerds `s usu`n* Ygd re`i tew`ri Mojbgejb.
` jd`ray vonn`bd. w`s iettdi wotg merd `ji merd Jertgdrj seniodrs
oj nottnd breups er `nejd. str`bbnojb jet frem aut tew`ri tgd frejt
nojds* Furtgdr `nejb. semd h`rrodi aexds swujb hnumsony ej a`maee
pends* Ygdsd wd ioshevdrdi wdrd tgd `mmujotoej ad`rdrs* Ygdy oj-
hrd`sdi oj jumadr `s wd prehddidi. ujton tgdrd w`s ` std`iy strd`m
ef tgdsd heenod treeps tr`jspertojb aunndts te tgdor hemr`ids oj tgos
promotovd f`sgoej* Ygd w`r. ot w`s `pp`rdjt. w`s muhg hnesdr te
Xg`jbg`o tg`j mest pdepnd oj tgd Xdttndmdjt ljdw*
Ygd idfd`tdi treeps neeldi `t us oj surprosd* Xemd sddmdi jejd
tee hgddrfun. aut wd g`i je ioffohuntods ujton wd reujidi ` adji `ji
h`md ojte vodw ef ` tojy aroibd. nottnd merd tg`j ` hunvdrt. `aeut `
qu`rtdr ef ` mond `w`y* Ot w`s bu`ridi ay `aeut ` gujirdi mdj*
Rd idhoidi te irovd iewj te tgos aroibd. ojquord `aeut tgojbs `ji tgdj
rdturj te Xg`jbg`o* @s wd irevd up ejd ef tgd seniodrs. dvoidjtny
`j effohdr. i`sgdi tew`ri us w`vojb gos `rms `ji sgeutojb* Ygd hg`uf-
fdur. vosoany frobgtdjdi. ojtdrprdtdi;
Kust jew sgeetojb%" gd sputtdrdi*+ 9
Gd s`y je h`j be* Must
be a`hl-soid. pndjty hgep-hgep!
Ot w`s trud* Rd wdrd oj tgd frejt nojds* Ej dotgdr soid ef tgd
aroibd mdj oj br`y ujoferms. strdthgdi eut `s slormosgdrs. fermdi `j
orrdbun`r nojd `s f`r `s wd heuni sdd* Ygdy n`y adgoji `j dma`jl-
mdjt ay tgd h`j`n er hrddl wgohg tgd aroibd sp`jjdi* Frem tomd te
tomd. `pp`rdjtny wotgeut eridrs. tgdy teel ` pet-sget `t tgd djdmy*
Etgdrs bnoidi `reuji a`rjs. tgd trdds gdrd `ji tgdrd. er r`osdi Hgoj-
dsd br`vds `jywgdrd tgdy heuni foji sgdntdr `ji ldpt up `sh`ttdrojb
ford `t tgd djdmy* Ygd H`jtejdsd nojd w`s br`iu`nny pusgojb `hress
tgd ojtdrvdjojb newn`jis* Ygdy wdrd. O sgeuni s`y. `aeut ` qu`rtdr
ef ` mond `w`y* Ygdor f`ojt rofnd sgets ojioh`tdi tgdy wdrd h`rryojb
ej ` somon`r got-`ji-moss mdtgei ef w`rf`rd @s f`r `s ejd heuni
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 25/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 14
tdnn. tgdrd wdrd je h`su`ntods ej tgd Jertgdrj soid. `ji hdrt`ojny tgd
ejny gepd tgdsd `nndbdi idfdjidrs ef Xg`jbg`o g`i ef gottojb tgd djdmy
n`y oj hg`jhd*
Aut tgdrd w`s ` hg`jhd tg`t tgd djdmy mobgt sgeet oj eur iordhtoej*
Ygd hg`uffdur jddidi je eridrs te wgosl tg`t nottnd m`hgojd `reuji.
`ntgeubg gd lonndi tgd meter twohd oj ieojb se ej tgd j`rrew heujtry
n`jd* Rd strd`ldi `w`y frem tgd frejt `t ` mond ` mojutd. a`hl te
s`fdty wotgoj Xg`jbg`o"s nojds ef mdj `ji stddn `ji te tgd h`and words*
Xg`jbg`o fdnn tgd jdxt i`y. ej M`rhg 10. 0?12. te tgd m`rhgojb
mdj frem H`jtej* @nn tgreubg ` meejnot Xuji`y jobgt tgd anud-br`y
nojds swdpt oj w`vds `hress tgd seft md`iews* G`riny ` sget w`s
fordi oj `htu`n idfdjsd ef tgd pert* Ygd Jertgdrj treeps. iosporotdi.
vortu`nny nd`idrndss. fndi oj reut. idsdrtojb tgd hoty* Xemd wdrd tr`ppdi
`nejb tgd r`onre`i `ji `t Jertg Xt`toej. kust eutsoid tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n
Xdttndmdjt* @ rdobj ef tdrrer adb`j tg`t Meji`y merjojb* @rmdi
n`aerdrs oj an`hl bewjs shurrodi tgreubg tgd j`rrew strddts oj tgd
j`tovd `rd`s. forojb ojioshromoj`tdny* Hgojdsd hotozdjs peurdi ojte tgd
ferdobj-pretdhtdi `rd`s ay tgd tgeus`jis. ` mosdr`and strd`m ef ids-
totutd f`monods*
Ot w`s ej tgos arobgt sprojb merjojb tg`t tgd 9tg Qdbomdjt ef tgd
Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojds `nse teel Xg`jbg`o* Ygd mdj g`i addj
qu`rtdrdi ej ae`ri tgd tr`jspert Hg`umejt. todi up iewjstrd`m fer
twe wddls `w`otojb weri tgdy wdrd jddidi* Ygdrd w`s semd t`nl
dvdj ef sdjiojb tgdm ej te M`jon` of tgd sgew f`ondi te ard`l. er
of tgd Jertgdrj ferhds `tt`hldi. pusgojb tgd rdadns a`hl ojte tgd seutg*
Ygd M`rojds wdrd rdstndss* Ygdy h`md `sgerd bn`iny. rd`iy fer `
fobgt er ` frenoh. aut ommdjsdny bn`i te bdt tgdor fddt ej J`jlojb Qe`i.
m`rhgojb te aonndts oj tgd Rdstdrj Iostroht wgdrd ` fdw i`ys n`tdr
tgdy steei sgeunidr te sgeunidr wotg tgd f`mdi Henistrd`m Bu`ris
frem Nejiej* Yebdtgdr tgdy feubgt eff ` g`nf-m`iidjdi Hgojdsd
r`aand sddlojb te peur tgreubg a`radi word djt`jbndmdjts ojte tgd
Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt*
Rotg a`jis pn`yojb. tgd M`rojds g`i n`jidi* Ygdor toj g`ts"+
`ji soid-`rms bnostdjdioj tgd sujsgojd* Ferdobjdrs. ojhnuiojb guj-
irdis ef neh`n @mdroh`j rdsoidjts. hgddrdi* Aut tgd Hgojdsd neeldi
ej stenoiny. g`tojb tgos iospn`y ef ferdobj ferhd dvdj tgeubg tgdy ljdw
ot md`jt furtgdr pretdhtoej fer tgdm* Ygd 6tg Qdbomdjt n`jidi semd
wddls n`tdr* Fer mest ef tgd sprojb `ji summdr ef 0?12. tgd Tjotdi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 26/455
16 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Xt`tds g`i evdr 9.333 fobgtojb mdj oj Xg`jbg`o. Tjhnd X`m"s p`rt ef
`j `nnodi ferdobj idfdjsd ferhd tg`t `t ejd tomd tet`ndi merd tg`j
14.333 mdj* Ygos w`s dxhnusovd ef tgd j`v`n ferhds* Ygd M`rojds
bet pndjty ef `htoej tgd mojutd tgdy stdppdi `sgerd* Ygdy teel up
tgdor pests oj tgd frejt nojds `reuji tgd wdstdrj rom ef tgd Ojtdr-
j`toej`n Xdttndmdjt `ji stuhl tgdrd fer wddls. ujton tgd hoty h`nmdi
iewj ejhd merd ujidr tgd smub. vohteroeus ferhds ef tgd H`jtejdsd-
ojspordi Luemojt`jb `rmods*
Xg`jbg`o fdnn pr`htoh`nny wotgeut ` strubbnd. dxhdpt fer ejd er twe
hn`sgds wgohg wdrd sg`rp `ji aneeiy* Ejd ehhurrdi wgdj ` herps ef
Rgotd Qusso`js 'idspdr`td dmobrds djnostdi oj tgd Jertgdrj @rmy te
lddp frem st`rvojb oj ` str`jbd n`ji/ wdrd tr`ppdi `ji trodi te fobgt
tgdor w`y eut frem adgoji tgd H`jtejdsd nojds* Ygdy m`jjdi `j
`rmerdi tr`oj ej tgd J`jlojb Q`onw`y wotg ots tdrmoj`n `t tgd Xg`jb-
g`o Jertg Xt`toej. `ji foj`nny surrdjidrdi*
Ygd Jertgdrj Hgojdsd seniodrs. gewdvdr. p`joh-strohldj ej tg`t
Meji`y wgdj tgd H`jtejdsd `tt`hldi oj ferhd. tgrdw iewj tgdor bujs*
Ygdy stermdi tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt. adbbojb fer pretdhtoej*
Ejd ojhoidjt ef tgos loji ehhurrdi `aeut iusl `t tgd Jertg Gej`j
Qe`i b`tds. adtwddj tgd j`tovd hoty `ji tgd Xdttndmdjt* @ s`jia`b
anehlgeusd tgdrd ojsoid tgd t`nn orej b`tds w`s m`jjdi ay ` squ`i
ef vdry yeujb Arotosg treeps* @ yeutg g`riny eut ef gos "tddjs w`s
oj hemm`ji* Ygd Jertgdrj r`aand stermdi tgdb`tds. `ji oj tgdor
p`joh fordi ej tgd mdj wgem tgdy seubgt `s pretdhters* Ygdy wdrd
mdt wotg ` rdturj ford* Ygd forst r`jls prdssojb `b`ojst tgd orej a`rs
wdrd sget iewj `pp`rdjtny wotgeut mdrhy* Ygdrd w`s je gdnp fer ot*
Xjopdrs `nejb Q`jbd Qe`i. wgohg hressds Jertg Gej`j Qe`i `t
tgd Xdttndmdjt nomots. fordi ojioshromoj`tdny ej aetg soids* O bet te
tgos sdhter kust `ftdr tgd hn`sg adtwddj tgd Arotosg `ji Hgojdsd. oj
tomd te bdt oj ej tgd ojtdrprdtdi ojstruhtoejs te tgd Hgojdsd te n`y
iewj tgdor bujs of tgdy weuni djtdr* Ot w`s `nmest i`rl* Yebdtgdr
wotg feur er fovd etgdr ferdobj herrdspejidjts. O g`i meterdi eut
Xzdhgu`j Qe`i frem tgd gd`rt ef Xg`jbg`o* Rd ndft eur h`r semd
anehls adgoji* Hnojbojb hnesd te ` tdj-feet-gobg arohl w`nn bu`riojb
tgd frejt y`ris ef mest geusds f`hojb Q`jbd Qe`i. wd hrdpt `nejb
tew`ri tgd Jertg Xt`toej anehlgeusd. tgrdd anehls `w`y* O heujtdi
tgrdd er feur id`i Hgojdsd. ejd oj Jertgdrj ujoferm. nyojb oj tgdor
ewj aneei oj tgd strddt* Rd shurrodi `nejb ujidr tgd pretdhtoej ef
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 27/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 12
tg`t frodjiny w`nn* Rd g`i te ruj fer ot oj hressojb tgd twe ojtdr-
sdhtojb strddts. m`lojb ot ejd m`j `t ` tomd* Xe f`r `s O ljew. je
ejd teel ` sget `t us* Xtonn. tgd f`ht tg`t tgdy mobgt. sjopojb frem
sguttdrdi wojiews `ji frem i`rl reefs. w`s ` tgeubgt tg`t ioi jet
h`nm tgd jdrvds. jejd tee beei ay tg`t tomd. `jyw`y*
Ygd Hgojdsd ferhds. hewdi. foj`nny n`oi iewj tgdor rofnds `ji adb`j
te strd`m ojte tgd Xdttndmdjt. adferd kuaon`jt Xeutgdrj ferhds heuni
h`thg up wotg tgdm `ji m`ld tgdm prosejdrs* Ygd vohters `htu`nny
ioi sdozd tgeus`jis. aut O w`thgdi `aeut 1.333 a`iny a`ttdrdi mdj
sg`mand te hemp`r`tovd. of tdmper`ry. s`fdty tgreubg tgd b`tds `ji
a`radi word*
Ygdy wdrd tgd mest idsen`td. iosporotdi aeiy ef mdj O dvdr s`w
oj my nofd* Ygdor ujoferms wdrd r`bbdi `ji terj < sherds wdrd weujidi
`ji peerny a`ji`bdi* @ fdw wdrd fertuj`td djeubg te bdt rohlsg`ws.
punndi ay ` hemr`id<aut oj tgd m`oj. weujidi `ji wdnn. tgdy geaandi
`nejb* Ygdor br`ss s`ji`ns `ji fn`ppojb wr`p-puttdds wdrd oj t`ttdrs.
`ji iosojtdbr`toej sddmdi te pessdss tgd vdry seuns ef tgdsd mdj.
serry neelojb mdmadrs ef `jetgdr nest a`tt`noej*
Ygdy wdrd ojtdrjdi fer sdvdr`n wddls aut foj`nny wdrd rdp`tro`tdi
te Xg`jtujb Srevojhd. te tgd jertg. ej ferdobj sgops s`vdi te fobgt
semd etgdr i`y ay tgd s`md ferdobj idvons tg`t tgdy tgdmsdnvds `ji
tgd Xeutgdrj J`toej`nosts wdrd ejd oj i`mjojb* @nn Hgojdsd. rdb`rindss
ef tgdor ojhdss`jt kumand ef penotohe-monot`ry f`otgs. `t nd`st g`i tg`t
aottdr g`trdi `b`ojst eutsoid ojtdrfdrdjhd wotgoj tgdor treuandi Moiind
Lojbiem* Ej ujoty ojsoid tgdor `jhodjt Brd`t R`nn. tgdsd ydnnew
mdj tgdmsdnvds wdrd f`t`nny iovoidi* Ygdy stonn `rd*
Md`jwgond. wgotd mdj `ji wemdj up-heujtry. ojhnuiojb sherds ef
@mdroh`js. wdrd oj vdry rd`n i`jbdr ef tgdor novds frem tgd vohteroeus
Xeutgdrj gerids wge swdpt dvdrytgojb adferd tgdm up te tgd seutgdrj
a`jl ef tgd _`jbtzd* Ygdy wdrd urbdi te dv`hu`td `s r`poiny `s
pessoand* Oj f`ht. tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds hejsun`r `utgerotods g`i addj
tryojb fer mejtgs te omprdss upej mossoej`rods `ji ausojdss mdj tgd
jdhdssoty ef gurryojb a`hl te tgd ndss i`jbdreus trd`ty perts* M`jy
ioi*
Ejd herrdspejidjt. `j @ustr`no`j. w`s ndss fertuj`td* Gd w`s
lonndi up-heujtry. jd`r ` sm`nn tewj h`nndi Hgdjbhgew. jertg ef G`j-
lew. oj Gej`j Srevojhd* @t nd`st. gd w`s djbunfdi wgond w`nlojb
iewj tgd r`onre`i tr`hls te ojspdht ` meidn vonn`bd ` mond `w`y
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 28/455
17 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
frem Hgdjbhgew* Gos gest. tgd Adnbo`j Hejsun-Bdjdr`n st`toejdi up
tgd _`jbtzd `t G`jlew. rdpertdi gom mossojb wgdj gd gurrodi a`hl
te tgd rovdr pert `nejd* @ sd`rhg w`s eridrdi ay tgd Hgrosto`j
Bdjdr`n%" Fdjb _u-gso`jb* M`rsg`n Fdjb g`i kust rdturjdi frem
dxond oj Meshew* Gos gd`iqu`rtdrs wdrd tdmper`rony `t Hgdjbhgew*
Ygd herrdspejidjt. ` w`r vdtdr`j frem Durepd"s a`ttndfodnis. g`i ojtdr-
vodwdi tgd ompdjdtr`and Fdjb* Ot w`s jet quotd tgd sdjsoand tgojb
te ie `ji w`s ujidrt`ldj `b`ojst tgd `ivohd ef frodjis. effoho`n `ji
etgdrwosd* Aut Fdjb"s rdturj te Hgoj` w`s jdws* O jd`rny wdjt
up frem G`jlew mysdnf* Ejny tgd f`ht tg`t O g`i kust sddj Fdjb
evdr `t Gsuhgew-fu. jd`r Xg`jtujb. `ji gd`ri frem gos ewj gps ef
gos idsdrtoej ef tgd Qusso`j @ivoser`td `ji gos id`n'ot prevdi
tr`jsodjt/ wotg Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. tgd rdvenutoej`ry hgodf.
prdvdjtdi suhg ` pessoany f`t`n dxhursoej*
Fdjb"s sd`rhg w`s fruotndss* Ygd mystdry ef tgd ios`ppd`r`jhd
rdm`ojs ` sdhrdt* Xemd tgeubgt tgd m`j lonndi ay seniodrs er a`jiots*
Etgdrs an`mdi tgd prdv`ndjt `jto-ferdobjosm wgohg prep`b`jiosts ef
tgd rdvenutoej sprd`i tgreubgeut tgd ndjbtg `ji ard`itg ef Hgoj`*
Dvdj tgd sompndst pd`s`jt w`s ojfdhtdi* Xhgeen hgonirdj s`jb `jto-
ferdobj a`nn`is* Ygdy sgeutdi Iewj wotg tgd Ferdobj Idvons O `ji
Iewj wotg Ompdro`nosm! `nejb wotg tgd muntotuid* Oj `jy h`sd.
tgd aeiy w`s jdvdr feuji* Rgdtgdr tgd m`j w`s loij`pdi er wgdtgdr
gd iodi ` suiidj id`tg. O h`jjet s`y*
Ygd j`md ef tgos m`rtyr tekeurj`nosm w`s Fr`jl Qondy. tgd sej
ef ` aosgep oj @ustr`no`* Qondy s`oi tg`t gd g`i dsh`pdi frem ` Bdr-
m`j prosej h`mp iurojb tgd forst Rerni R`r* @ftdr tg`t gd g`i novdi
oj v`roeus heujtrods. ojhnuiojb Mdsepet`mo`* Gd w`s ` idnobgtfun
hemp`joej. ` hg`p `aeut tgorty-fovd yd`rs ef `bd. t`nn. wotg an`hl g`or
`ji ojtdnnobdjt dyds* Gos iosp`thgds wdjt te Ygd Nejiej Yomds* O
`nw`ys suspdhtdi gd g`i semd sert ef hejjdhtoej wotg tgd Arotosg
Ferdobj Effohd* O jdvdr ljdw* Gd w`s tgd sert ef m`j wge g`i
tgd nejb vodw. ojstojhtovdny* Gd s`w pdepnds `ji preandms oj pdr-
spdhtovd. `j dssdjto`n te beei rdpertojb `jywgdrd*
Xherds ef ferdobjdrs. gewdvdr. teel soids* Oj tgd m`oj. tgdsd wdrd
mossoej`rods* Ygdy fdnt tgdy ljdw tgd Hgojdsd r`hds tgereubgny. `ji
ojsostdi tgdy wdrd s`fd* M`jy m`ojt`ojdi tg`t of tgdy w`jtdi te rd-
m`oj. tg`t w`s tgdor ausojdss* @ji tgdsd rdfusdi te auibd* @ jumadr
ef tgdm `ji ` sherd er merd ef @mdroh`j ausojdss mdj. `s wdnn `s tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 29/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 1?
hejsun`r effoho`ns wge stuhl ay tgdor pests. wdrd oj J`jlojb wgdj tgd
vohteroeus treeps bet eut ef g`ji ej Ygursi`y ef tgd wddl tg`t Xg`jb-
g`o fdnn
O g`i `j urbdjt h`nn frem H`pt`oj 'jew Qd`r-@imor`n/ R`nn`hd
Vdrjeu. hgodf-ef-st`ff ej tgd eni fn`bsgop T* X* X* Sottsaurbg. tg`t
Ygursi`y.
@nn gdnn"s austdi neesd `t J`jlojb. tgd H`pt`oj s`oi evdr tgd
sgop-te-sgerd tdndpgejd* Rd n`oi iewj ` a`rr`bd te arojb eut @mdr-
oh`js `ji etgdr ferdobjdrs* Ygd Arotosg g`vdkeojdi
us* O tgojl
tgdrd wdrd je ferdobj h`su`ntods* O"nn ndt yeu ljew merd wgdj wd
gd`r frem eur mdj ej tgd Je`
Ygd T* X* X* Je` w`s ` idstreydr ej tgd _`jbtzd S`tren Nodut*
Hemm`jidr Qey H* Xmotg w`s oj hemm`ji* Ygd Arotosg idstreydr
G* M* X* Dmdr`ni keojdi tgd Je` oj s`vojb merd tg`jfofty ferdobj
mdj. wemdj `ji hgonirdj `ji sddojb tg`t tgdy bet s`fdny iewjstrd`m
te Xg`jbg`o*
Ygd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt ehhurrdi ej M`rhg 19* Ygd Xeutgdrj
ferhds wdrd eut ef hejtren* Ygdy neetdi tgd hoty* Irujl wotg vohtery.
tgd mdj lonndi `ji r`pdi ferdobjdrs `s wdnn `s Hgojdsd oj tgd tgdj
jdw h`pot`n* Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds `ji Arotosg idstreydrs nyojb eff J`j-
lojb oj tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr epdjdi ford wgdj h`nndi ej ay tgd rdfubdds
`sgerd. oj ommojdjt i`jbdr ef tgdor novds* Ygd Je` fordi forst. `ntgeubg
tgd Arotosg sloppdr w`s tgd supdroer j`v`n effohdr prdsdjt* Hemm`jidr
Xmotg g`i `sldi tgd Djbnosg h`pt`oj fer gos `pprev`n* Gd bet ot*
Aetg vdssdns n`oi iewj ` gd`vy a`rr`bd `reuji Xehejy Gonn. tgd
Xt`ji`ri Eon Hemp`jy ef Jdw _erl"s gd`iqu`rtdrs oj J`jlojb. hej-
hdjtr`toej peojt "fer tgd rdfubdds* Ot s`vdi tgd novds ef `nn prdsdjt*
Xmotg g`i sdjt ` n`jiojb p`rty `sgerd. hemm`jidi ay tgd n`td
Djsobj Reeiw`ri Sgdnps* 'Sgdnps suasdqudjtny sget gomsdnf oj Jdw
_erl*/ Sgdnps. `j effohdr aerj te tgd tr`iotoej ef tgd sd`. ndi gos
squ`i te Xehejy Gonn* Gd `ji gos mdj rdshudi mdmadrs ef tgd
Tjotdi Xt`tds Hejsun`td-Bdjdr`n st`ff. `s wdnn `s semd rdfubdds wgeg`i b`tgdrdi tgdrd* Ygd gerids swdpt ej tew`ri tgd gonn* Sgdnps
eridrdi ` sobj`nm`j te st`ji ej tgd reef* Tjidr ford. tgd @mdroh`j
s`oner sobj`ndi tgd sgop* A`hl ej tgd Je`. Hemm`jidr Xmotg w`thgdi
fer tgd sobj`n* Gd iosrdb`ridi ferm`n j`v`n rdbun`toejs* H`nnojb te
gos bujjdry effohdr. tgd n`td Nodut* Adj Xt`uid 'wge `ftdrw`ris hem-
mottdi suohoid oj Xeutg`mptej. Djbn`ji/. gd sgeutdi;
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 30/455
83 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
O iej"t ljew wgdtgdr wd"nn bdt ` heurt-m`rto`n er ` idher`toej
fer tgos aut ndt "dr be. Adjjy!
Adjjy eadydi* Jet ` novojb seun heuni g`vd pdjdtr`tdi tgd tguj-
idreus a`rr`bd wgohg tgd Je` `ji Dmdr`ni n`oi iewj* Ygd ferdobjdrs.
ljettojb sgddts tebdtgdr. shr`mandi iewj tgd `jhodjt soxty-feet w`nn
wgohg surreujis J`jlojb* Ygdy shuttndi `hress tgd newn`jis aeridrojb
tgd rovdr `ji wdrd quohlny t`ldj eff oj sm`nn ae`ts te tgd idstreydrs*
Ygd Je` areubgt sdvdr`n rdfubdds iewj tgd rovdr* Mest ef tgd
etgdrs h`md ej frodjiny Hgojdsd rovdr std`mdrs* Hemm`jidr Xmotg
bet je heurt-m`rto`n!
Ojsoid tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt `ji Frdjhg Hejhdssoej tgd b`y
reutojd wdjt ej `ji ej* Ygd ojg`aot`jts wdrd iosturadi nottnd. of `t
`nn. ay tgd w`r beojb ej `nn `reuji tgdm* Ygd eni fovd-a`rrdi fn`b ef
tgd eroboj`n Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh w`s rdpn`hdi ay tgd sh`rndt Luemojt`jb
dmandm ef tgd J`toej`nosts ` rdi fn`b. wotg ` wgotd st`r oj tgd anud
fodni oj tgd uppdr ndft g`ji herjdr* Ot fnuttdrdi dvdrywgdrd oj tgd
arddzd. ` fn`ppojb dmandm ef tgd jdw id`n oj Hgoj`*
@mdroh`j s`oners `ji Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojds nejb wdrd ` f`mono`r
sobgt ej tgd strddts tgdrd* Rd ldpt ` pdrm`jdjt Hgoj` S`tren ef
w`rsgops ej iuty `nejb tgd he`st. `ji up tgd _`jbtzd fer merd tg`j
` tgeus`ji monds* Ygd 9tg Qdbomdjt. T* X* M`rojd Herps. rdm`ojs
st`toejdi oj Xg`jbg`o* Tjton tgd heujtry os ndss hg`etoh tgdsd ferhds
wonn st`y te pretdht eur ojtdrdsts tgdrd* Ygd mdj frdqudjt tgd s`md
i`jhd g`nns `ji etgdr `musdmdjt spets oj tgd adbuonojb S`ros ef tgd
D`st. wgohg mdmadrs ef tgd etgdr sdrvohds p`trejozd*
Ehh`soej`nny frem ` herjdr. wgdj mdj ef tgd Je` `ji Dmdr`ni
bet tebdtgdr yeu weuni gd`r tgos iotty ` p`r`pgr`sd ay tgd n`td Nodut*
Xt`uid ef `j eni M`rojd a`nn`i. Ygd G`nns ef Mejtdsum`. hemmdm-
er`tojb tgdJ`jlojb Ojhoidjt* Ot beds ;
Frem tgd i`jhd g`nns ef eni Xg`jbg`o
Ye tgd w`nns ef eni J`jlojb.
Rd g`vd mdt `nn lojis ek wemdj.@ji wd"vd feubgt `nn lojis ef mdj*
Hgerus
%% tgd Je` `ji tgd Dmdr`ni
Dvdr keoj oj fobgt `b`oj.
Ofnn ad beei-ayd te Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl
@ji te Gdnn wotg Dubdjd Hgdj!
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 31/455
RGDJ XG@JBG@O FDNN 80
Dubdjd Hgdj w`s ferdobj mojostdr oj tgd jew idfujht Qdi-hej-
trenndi rdbomd `t G`jlew. oj Hdjtr`n Hgoj`. semd sox gujirdi monds
up tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr*
Ygd ferdobjdrs. wotgoj tdj i`ys `ftdr tgd hoty"s f`nn. rdturjdi te
tgdor jerm`n reutojd ef hnua nofd. reundttd. jobgt hnuas. benf. tdjjos.
iebs `ji gersd r`hojb* Xg`jbg`o ujidr tgd Luemojt`jb rdvenu-
toejosts `ji ferdobj `nnodi @rmy ef Ehhup`toej `ppd`rdi te g`vd
hg`jbdi aut nottnd frem Xg`jbg`o ujidr tgd Jertg Hgoj` w`r neris
`ji tgd Arotosg*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 32/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY
YGD
J`jlojb Ojhoidjt%+ `s ot adh`md ljewj `reuji tgd st`rtndi.
ujhemprdgdjiojb werni. g`ppdjdi ej Ygursi`y ef tgd wddlwgohg adb`j wotg Xg`jbg`o"s f`nn* Ygd m`rhgojb mdj frem H`j-
tej sdozdi Xg`jbg`o ej Meji`y `ji teel J`jlojb. 024 monds ojn`ji
ej tgd _`jbtzd. ej Ygursi`y* Ygd f`nn ef Xg`jbg`o w`s ` pd`hdfun
dvdjt hemp`rdi te tgd gerrers wgohg `hhemp`jodi tgd sdozurd ef pewdr
oj tgd pnd`s`jt hoty ef J`jlojb* Ygd Luemojt`jb treeps. swddpojb
dvdr jertgw`ri tew`ri Sdlojb. tgdor be`n. bet eut ef g`ji hempndtdny
Ygdor effohdrs heuni ie jetgojb wotg tgdor woni-dydi mdj frem Xeutg
Hgoj`*
Mdj oj ujoferms. rofnds oj g`ji. ponn`bdi tgd tewj* Ygdy neetdi
`ji s`hldi tg`t tewj `s ` hoty g`s r`rdny addj neetdi. dvdj oj Hgoj`*
Ygd werst p`rt ef tg`t ojhoidjt w`s tg`t tgdrd wdrd twe sherd er
merd ferdobjdrs rdsoiojb tgdrd wge rdfusdi `nn `ivohd te hnd`r eut*
Ygdsd eni Hgoj`-g`jis tgeubgt tgdy ljdw tgd Hgojdsd* Ygdy
adnodvdi tgdy heuni trust tgdm. seniodrs er je seniodrs* Ygdy feuji
eut tgdy wdrd wrejb tgesd wge novdi*
Rg`t tgdsd mdj `ji sturiy wemdj ioi jet ljew w`s tg`t `jy
m`j wotg ` buj. roiojb tgd gobg hrdst ef vohtery. os jet rdspejsoand
fer gos `htoejs* Gd m`y ie `jytgojb. `ji usu`nny ieds* Yg`t os `j
`xoem ef w`r*
Ygd vohteroeus seniodrs re`mdi tgreubg tgd hoty. idstreyojb. pon-
n`bojb. r`pojb tgd wemdj. lonnojb tgd mdj* M`jy gerroand dvdjts
ehhurrdi. aut fdw wdrd se heni-aneeidi `s tgd w`jtej muridr ef Ir*
K* D* Ronno`ms. ` mossoej`ry* Gd g`i novdi fer yd`rs`mejb
tgd Hgoj-
dsd `ji heuni t`nl te tgdm oj tgdor n`jbu`bd* Gd `nse tgeubgt tg`t
rdm`ojojb oj J`jlojb w`s s`fd* M`jy etgdrs. tee. prdfdrrdi te rd-
m`oj `ji s`vd f`hd wotg tgdor trustdi Hgojdsd frodjis* Aut m`jywge s`vdi f`hd nest tgdor novds* Ir* Ronno`ms. ` lojiny. dnidrny
m`j ef Bei. w`s ejd* Gd w`s tgd gd`i ef J`jlojb Tjovdrsoty* Ye be
`nejb wotg tgd trdji ef tgd tomds. gd g`i `brddi te m`ld ` Hgojdsd
81
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 33/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 88
jemoj`nny tgd Srdsoidjt ef tgd Tjovdrsoty Gd adh`md Vohd-Srdso-
idjt. aut stonn bevdrjdi tg`t mossoej`ry ojstotutoej
Ygdhg`jbd
w`s iud te tgd w`vd ef `jto-f
erdobjosm`ji j`toej`nosm
wgohg swdpt evdr @so`* Ir* Ronno`ms nest gos nofd wgdj ` yeutg oj
ujoferm. adjt ej reaadry. neet `ji r`pd. sget tgd mossoej`ry id`i*
Ygd bujm`j ieuatndss g`i jet tgd f`ojtdst ojlnojb ef Ir* Ronno`m"s
oidjtoty er tgd beei gd w`s ieojb heujtndss Hgojdsd oj tgd J`jlojb
`rd`* Ot ioi jet m`ttdr te tgd yeutg* Gd lonndi gom. ndosurdny reaadi
tgd herpsd `ji wdjt ej gos h`rdfrdd w`y rdkeohojb oj gos sg`rd ef tgd
speons ef w`r* Ygdsd ojhnuidi tgd id`i m`j"s w`thg* Ot os ieuatfun
wgdtgdr tgd b`y yeujb m`j wotg tgd buj heuni rd`i tgd tomdpodhd
aut tomd md`jt jetgojb te gom tgdj* Ygd tohlojb m`y g`vd `musdi
gos ojf`jtond moji. er tgdbnojt
ef tgd beni m`y g`vd `ttr`htdi gos dyd*
Ygd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt os ` an`hl spet ej tgd dshuthgdej ef tgd
Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej* Ygd Hgojdsd `imot tg`t* Fer ejd tgojb.
ferdobjdrs wdrd ojvenvdi* Yg`t md`jt ojtdrj`toej`n hempnoh`toejs*
Ygd Hgojdsd rdvenutoej`rods wdrd jet
rd`iyfer suhg
hempnoh`toejsYgdy g`i ` w`r ef tgdor ewj ej tgdor g`jis* @nse. tgd mdj tgdj `t
G`jlew prdfdrrdi `veoiojb Xg`jbg`o `ji J`jlojb. iewj jd`r tgd
he`st. ujton Sdlojb w`s t`ldj* Ygdy w`jtdi te be ej up tgd Loj-g`j
Q`onw`y te tgd `jhodjt H`pot`n* Ygdy fd`rdi suhg ojhoidjts%" ojvenvojb
jet ejny tgd usu`nny d`sy beojb Tjotdi Xt`tds Bevdrjmdjt. aut teubgdr
hustemdrs te id`n wotg wgdj pretdhtoej ef tgdor j`toej`ns os hejhdrjdi.
suhg `s Brd`t Arot`oj*
Aut mdj wotgoj tgd Luemojt`jb iosnoldi tgd brewojb ojfnudjhd ef
Meshew `ji Hemmujosm* Ygos breup ojhnuidi Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl. tgd jdw Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf ef tgd Qdvenutoej`ry @jjods*
Ygdy tgdrdferd teel Xg`jbg`o `ji J`jlojb oj ` suiidj swoft aot ef
str`tdby. `ji spnot idfojotdny wotg tgd r`ioh`n aneh oj hejtren ef tgd
bevdrjmdjt sdt up `t G`jlew. oj tgd hdjtdr ef Hgoj`* @ji tgd
J`jlojbaneh
dvdjtu`nny wejeut* Bdjdr`n
Hgo`jb erb`jozditgd J`-
toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb oj @pron 0?12. ndss tg`j ` mejtg `ftdr
tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt* Gd hejtrens Hgujblojb tei`y `s Srdsoidjt
ef tgd Dxdhutovd _u`j. er Heujhon Gos M`j Froi`y. Noj Xdj. g`s
tgd jemoj`n totnd ef Srdsoidjt ef tgd Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh* Aut Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl runds Frdd Hgoj` wotg ioht`tero`n pewdrs* Ygd ejny vdstobd
ef tgd Hemmujost ojfnudjhd oj Hgoj` os tgd Hemmottdd ferm ef bevdrj-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 34/455
89 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
mdjt. `ji sper`ioh eutard`ls ef Hemmujost a`jis oj tgd ojtdroer
Xeutg-Hdjtr`n sdhtoejs*
Ygd effoho`n rdpert ej tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt w`s m`id tg`t dx-
hotojb wddl ay tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Hejsun tgdrd. Mr* Kegj L* I`vos*
Gos i`t` w`s m`id `v`on`and te md `ji O adnodvd g`s jdvdr adferd
addj projtdi bdjdr`nny. oj funn* Hejsun I`vos. ` m`j tgdj oj gos fertods.
wgesd wofd wdjt tgreubg tgd Ojhoidjt%" wretd gos rdpert ujidr iof-
fohunty* Gd rdm`rldi `s gd djidi ot ej ae`ri ` Tjotdi Xt`tds w`r-
sgop ef eur _`jbtzd Qovdr S`tren. tg`t tgd t`sl ef ir`ftojb ot ay
nejbg`ji wgdj wotgeut my bn`ssds. ef wgohg O w`s reaadi ay J`-
toej`nost seniodrs. `ji ay `rtofoho`n nobgt. g`s addj p`ojfunny n`aeroeus
`ji snew*
Jdvdrtgdndss. tgd werl os `j ojtdrdstojb. prdhosd rdsumd ef wg`t
g`ppdjdi tg`t wddl `t J`jlojb. dspdho`nny ojsef`r `s tgd dvdjts `f-
fdhtdi tgd ferdobjdrs tgdrd* Mr* I`vos h`nndi gos rdpert ; @jto-Ferdobj
Eutr`bds `t J`jlojb ej M`rhg 19. 0?12* Je ejd oj tgd ferdobj hem-
mujoty w`s hejhdrjdi vdry iddpny `aeut wg`t g`ppdjdi te tgd Hgo-
jdsd. aut ot m`y ad `ssumdi tgdsd ehhurrdjhds wdrd `t nd`st `s brud-
semd* Ygd Hejsun"s rdpert trd`ts wotgeut mojhojb weris ef wg`t
g`ppdjdi te @mdroh`j wemdj wge rdfusdi te gddi `ivohd `ji bdt
eut wgond tgd bdttojb w`s beei*
Mr* I`vos w`s ferhdi te fndd frem tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Hejsun`td Oj
J`jlojb wotg gos wofd `ji twe sm`nn hgonirdj tgd merjojb ef M`rhg
19. fojiojb rdfubd oj tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon Hemp`jy"s geusd ej Xehejy
Gonn* Gdrd gd. tebdtgdr wotg D* Y* Gea`rt. ` Xt`ji`ri Eon dxdhutovd.
`ji mdmadrs ef tgd Hejsun`r st`ff. ldpt tgd Hgojdsd eff fer geurs
adferd ferhdi te eridr tgd sobj`n fer rdnodf frem idstreydrs oj tgd
rovdr* Mr* I`vos" rdpert. tgdrdferd. os a`sdi ej gos ewj dydwotjdss
dxpdrodjhds oj `iiotoej te hejvdrs`toejs wotg etgdrs wge wdjt tgreubg
tgd `ff`or*
Gd idshroadi gew tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Hejsun`td w`s neetdi. `ji
areubgt eut vovoiny tgd m`jjdr oj wgohg tgd @mdroh`j fn`b w`s ojtdj-
toej`nny idsdhr`tdi ay Hgojdsd seniodrs* Gd s`oi. oj ` p`r`br`pg ej
tgdfn`b
ojhoidjt;
Ygdfn`b w`s forst g`undi iewj `ji tgdj r`osdi upsoid iewj.
dvoidjtny `s `j ojsunt< ot w`s tgdj g`undi iewj. terj `ji tgd
g`ny`ri hut `ji t`ldj `w`y*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 35/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 84
Ygos `ji tgd neetojb. Mr* I`vos `iidi. wdrd iejd ay J`toej`nost
treeps oj ujoferm* Ot w`s tgos peojt tg`t mdj oj tgd G`jlew bev-
drjmdjt idsordi te `rbud. hejtdjiojb tg`t `j Ojtdrj`toej`n Hem-
mossoej te ojquord ojte tgd J`jlojb `ff`or w`s tgd ejny hovonozdi
w`y te be `aeut dst`anosgojb wgdtgdr er jet J`toej`nost seniodrs wdrd
buonty< `ji. sdhejiny. of se. wgdtgdr tgd G`jlew bevdrjmdjt heuni
ad gdni rdspejsoand* Ye tgos Jetd. wrottdj ay Dubdjd Hgdj G`j-
lew"s Mojostdr fer Ferdobj @ff`ors `ji jetd-wrotdr p`r dxhdnndjhd
jejd ef tgd Sewdrs ojvenvdi puanohny rdpnodi*
Hejsun I`vos" effoho`n rdpert ej tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt. prdp`rdi
`t J`jlojb wgond gd w`s tdmper`rony ` rdfubdd ej ae`ri tgd T* X* X*
Os`adn. O rdpreiuhd gdrd oj funn*
YGD @JYO-FEQDOBJ ETYQ@BDX @Y J@JLOJB
EJ M@QHG YRDJY_-FETQYG. 0?12
Frem Kegj L* I`vos. Hejsun*
J`jlojb. Hgoj`*
I`td ef prdp`r`toej; @pron 1. 0?12*
I`td ef m`onojb; @pron 8. 0?12*
Fond Je* 733%833*
Ygd eutr`bds `b`ojst ferdobj novds `ji prepdrty pdrpdtr`tdi ay
seniodrs ef tgd J`toej`nost `rmy ej M`rhg 19 `ffdhtdi se m`jy
@mdroh`j hotozdjs neh`tdi oj woidny sdp`r`tdi p`rts ef tgd hoty
`ji ojvenvdi se muhg prepdrty. tg`t ot os ompessoand dvdj jew
te bovd ` hemprdgdjsovd pohturd ef @mdroh`j ojkurods `ji nessds*
Oj tgos rdpert. gewdvdr. `j dffert wonn ad m`id te bovd ` bdjdr`n
pohturd `ji te suppny suhg pdrtojdjt ojferm`toej `s os suppertdi
ay my ewj pdrsej`n easdrv`toej. swerj `ffoi`vots ay @mdroh`j
hotozdjs `ji ay st`tdmdjts ef tgereubgny rdno`and Hgojdsd mdmadrs
ef tgd J`jlojb Hejsun`r st`ff*
NOJKTQODX
@JI NEXXDX XTFFDQDI A_ @MDQOH@JX;
`* Ye Sdrsejs;
Ygd mest sdroeus sojbnd ojhoidjt tg`t ehhurrdi w`s tgd heni-
aneeidi muridr ef Ir* K* D* Ronno`ms. Vohd-Srdsoidjt ef J`j-
lojb Tjovdrsoty. ay ` ujofermdi J`toej`nost seniodr `t 7 `*m* ej
tgd twdjty-feurtg* Frem tgd swerj st`tdmdjts ef Ir* Aewdj.
Mr* Xpddrs `ji Mr. Newidrmonl. djhnesurds Jes* 0. 1 `ji 8
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 36/455
86 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
te tgos rdpert. ot wonn ad sddj tg`t je preveh`toej wg`tsedvdr w`s
bovdj ay tgd vohtom `ji tg`t tgd muridr w`s djtordny w`jtej*
Furtgdr. `ftdr lonnojb Ir* Ronno`ms. tgd seniodr h`nneusny reaadi
gos aeiy*
@s wonn ad sddj ay tgd `ffoi`vot ef Moss Mojjod V`utroj `ji
fovd etgdr mdmadrs ef tgd Bojnojb Henndbd fer Remdj. djhnesurd
Je* 00. ` hemp`r`tovdny sgert tomd `ftdr tgd muridr ef Ir*
Ronno`ms. tgd J`toej`nost seniodrs neetojb tgd Bojnojb Henndbd
rdhebjozdi `ji eadydi ` J`toej`nost effohdr. tgus hejhnusovdny
prevojb tg`t tgdy wdrd jet `bdjts ef tgd Hgogno-Xg`jtujb
`rmy* Xojhd tgd Bojnojb Henndbd os tgd forst ferdobj hempeuji
wdst ef tgd Tjovdrsoty ef J`jlojb wgdrd Ir* Ronno`ms w`s
muridrdi `ji os ndss tg`j g`nf ` mond frem ot. wotg je etgdr
geusds ojtdrvdjojb. ot os dvoidjt tg`t tgd muridrdr w`s ejd ef
` n`rbd breup. tgd mdmadrs ef wgohg wdrd hnd`rny prevdj te ad
J`toej`nost seniodrs*
Jdxt oj sdroeusjdss `ftdr tgd muridr ef Ir* Ronno`ms w`s tgd
sgeetojb `ji weujiojb ay ` ujofermdi J`toej`nost seniodr ef
Moss @jj` D* Meffdtt. Xdhrdt`ry ef tgd @mdroh`j Jertgdrj
Srdsaytdro`j Mossoej* Frem tgd `ffoi`vot ef Moss Moro`m D*
Gunn. djhnesurd Je* 9. ot wonn ad sddj tg`t tgos hromd w`s djtordny
ujpreveldi. idnoadr`td `ji pdhuno`rny arut`n Ygd swerj st`td-
mdjt ef Ronno`m K`modsej. djhnesurd Je* 4. `nse bovds ` bdjdr`n
oid` ef tgd `ttotuid ef tgd seniodrs `t tgos tomd. wgesd m`oj ea-
kdht w`s tgd std`nojb ef prepdrty. `ji wge wdrd ujofermny arut`n
oj tgd md`js dmpneydi te ferhd tgdor vohtoms te ioshnesd tgd
wgdrd`aeuts ef tgdor v`nu`ands*
Ygdrd ehhurrdi twe ljewj h`sds ef `ttdmptdi voen`toej ef
@mdroh`j wemdj ay ujofermdi J`toej`nost seniodrs. `ji ot os
adnodvdi tg`t etgdr somon`r h`sds ehhurrdi ef wgohg O g`vd jet
ydt addj ojfermdi* Fer eavoeus rd`sejs ef meidsty. tgd twe
vohtoms ie jet wosg tgdor j`mds bovdj `ji wdrd ujwonnojb te
m`ld wrottdj swerj st`tdmdjts* Gewdvdr. aetg wemdj `rd
ljewj te md `ji `rd tgereubgny trutgfun `ji jet bovdj te gys-
tdro` er dx`bbdr`toej* Oj ejd h`sd tgd wem`j w`s gdni ay ejd
er merd seniodrs wgond tgd weuni-ad r`post punndi up gdr hnetgojb
`ji w`s ejny steppdi ay tgd fertuj`td rusgojb oj ef ` hovono`j
r`and adjt ej neet oj tgd w`ld ef tgd seniodrs*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 37/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 82
Arut`noty w`s se ojv`ro`any tgd rund tg`t te ojhnuid `nn ljewj
h`sds weuni rdquord ` f`r nejbdr rdpert tg`t ot os pessoand jew
te prdp`rd ujidr
myprdsdjt nomot`toejs ef st`ff `ji effohd dquop-
mdjt*
Frem my pdrsej`n easdrv`toej O h`j veuhg fer tgd reubg
g`jinojb `ji reaaojb ef Mr* D* Y* Gea`rt. Vohd-Hejsun S`xtej
`ji mysdnf `t tgd rdsoidjhd ef Mr* Gea`rt* Rd wdrd rdpd`tdiny
mdj`hdi wotg ne`idi postens `ji rofnds `ji ay a`yejdts* Ejd
seniodr st`rtdi te sgeet Mr* Gea`rt oj eridr tg`t gd mobgt bdt
eff ` tobgtny fottojb fojbdr rojb. `ji ejny idsostdi wgdj O premosdi
tg`t ot weuni ad premptny t`ldj eff. `ji peojtdi eut tg`t tgdy
weuni bdt merd mejdy of wd wdrd jet lonndi*
Remdj wdrd trd`tdi wotg `s muhg arut`noty `s mdj `ji tgd
`asdjhd ef ` n`rbdr jumadr ef rdpertdi ojst`jhds ef dxtrdmd
arut`noty te tgdm ^v`s iud '0/ te tgd f`ht tg`t tgd brd`tdr p`rt
ef tgd @mdroh`j wemdj `ji hgonirdj g`i gddidi my `ivohd `ji
`nrd`iy addj dv`hu`tdi< `ji '1/ adh`usd ef tgesd wge wdrd oj
tgd hoty. m`jy wdrd dotgdr `ssdmandi oj tgd pn`hds ef brd`tdst
s`fdty er wdrd goiidj `w`y sojbny er oj sm`nn breups oj tgd
geusds ef frodjiny Hgojdsd*
Mrs* A`tds. wgesd gusa`ji"s st`tdmdjt `ppd`rs `s djhnesurd
Je* 6. w`s vdry reubgny g`jindi `ji p`rtny stroppdi ay J`-
toej`nost seniodrs* Mrs* Ardjtej. `j @mdroh`j n`iy ef 63 er
merd wge n`y sdroeusny onn oj ` hg`or. g`i gdr adiiojb terj eff
gdr `ji w`s sd`rhgdi `ji reaadi< `ji ` yeujb @mdroh`j jursd
w`s m`id te sgew gdr b`rtdrs 'sdd `ffoi`vot ef Mr* @nspdhg.
djhnesurd Je* 2/* Ejd yeujb @mdroh`j wem`j. wge frem
fddnojbs ef meidsty rdfusdi te m`ld ` swerj st`tdmdjt oj wrot-
ojb. g`i gdr s`jot`ry j`ploj terj eff gdr ay ` J`toej`nost sen-
iodr* Mrs* Monns 'djhnesurd Je* 6/ rdperts tgd tgrd`tdjojb ef
`j eni n`iy adh`usd sgd heuni jet bdt eff gdr
wdiiojb rojbquohlny djeubg*
Oj Mr* N* K* Ewdj"s `ffoi`vot 'djhnesurd Je* 03/. gd st`tds
tg`t gos wofd. wgem O ljew te ad prdbj`jt. g`i ` a`yejdt prdssdi
te gdr `aiemdj `ji gdr irdss roppdi `ji gdr ujidrhnetgojb
sd`rhgdi* Ygdor twe nottnd borns wdrd `nse reubgny g`jindi*
Moss V`j Vnodt 'sdd djhnesurd Je* 0/ w`s reaadi. p`rto-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 38/455
87 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
`nny stroppdi `ji tgdj sd`rhgdi. tgd seniodrs fddnojb gdr b`rtdr
hn`sp `ji ojtdjiojb te rdmevd ot ujton hejvojhdi ef ots n`hl ef
ojtrojsoh v`nud* Dvdj hgonirdj ef tdjidr `bd wdrd jet dxdmpt*
Mr* Newidrmonl 'djhnesurd Je* 8/ st`tds tgdy wdrd sd`rhgdi.
wgond Mr* Xpddrs 'djhnesurd Je* 1/ tdnns ef tgd idnoadr`td forojb
`t ` hgoni ef sdvdj*
Ygd brd`tdst arut`noty w`s sgewj tgd m`keroty ef tgd @mdr-
oh`j mdj* Ygdy wdrd ad`tdj. rdpd`tdiny tgrd`tdjdi wotg ne`idi
ford `rms. sget `t `ji m`jy g`i tgdor eutdr hnetgojb stroppdi
eff tgdor a`hls* Ir* Kejds oj gos st`tdmdjt 'djhnesurd Je* ?/
idshroadi gew Mr* @* @* Y`yner 'Arotosg/ w`s ir`bbdi `nejb
wotg ` repd `reuji gos jdhl `ji w`s sget `t. `ji m`jy etgdr
ojst`jhds wonn ad feuji idshroadi oj tgd djhnesdi swerj st`td-
mdjts*
a* Qeaaojb `ji Idstruhtoej ef @mdroh`j Srepdrty;
Ejny sdheji oj ompert`jhd te tgd t`lojb ef @mdroh`j nofd
`ji ndssdr voendjhd te @mdroh`j pdrsejs wdrd tgd wgends`nd
reaadry `ji idstruhtoej ef @mdroh`j prepdrty*
Sr`htoh`nny `nn @mdroh`js oj tgd hoty wdrd reaadi ef `nn tgdor
adnejbojbs ej tgdor pdrsejs `ji oj tgdor gemds. `ji usu`nny wotg
brd`t voendjhd `ji arut`noty* Idt`ons ef tgd horhumst`jhds wonn ad
feuji oj tgd djhnesdi swerj st`tdmdjts* Dvdj st`orw`ys. woj-
iew fr`mds. ieers `ji oj sgert dvdrytgojb wgohg heuni ad terj
eut. wdrd t`ldj `w`y* Jet hejtdjt wotg tgos idstruhtoej. tgrdd
ojstotutoej`n auoniojbs. tgd Gonnhrdst Xhgeen fer @mdroh`j hgon-
irdj. tgd J`jlojb Ygdeneboh`n Xdmoj`ry `ji ejd auoniojb ef
tgd Frodjis+ 'Pu`ldr/ Mossoej Gespot`n wdrd aurjdi* @pprexo-
m`tdny tdj @mdroh`j rdsoidjhds suffdrdi ` somon`r f`td*
Xemd @mdroh`j ausojdss effohds `ji tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon Hem-
p`jy"s ojst`nn`toejs oj Sulew `ji tgd rovdrojd suaura ef Gso`-
lw`j `rd adnodvdi up te jew te ad ojt`ht. `j ommujoty brewojb
eut ef tgdor neh`toej `ji tgd f`ht tg`t tgd j`v`n a`rr`bd steppdi
tgd werst voendjhd adferd tgd J`toej`nost seniodrs g`i bet iewj
te tgd rovdr*
h* @tt`hl Tpej @mdroh`j Hejsun`td;
Ygd mest eutr`bdeus idstruhtoej ef @mdroh`j prepdrty frem
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 39/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 8?
`j ojtdrj`toej`n st`jipeojt. gewdvdr. w`s tgd `tt`hl upej `ji
tgd tgereubg neetojb ef tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td sgertny adferd
jeej ej M`rhg 19 ay J`toej`nost seniodrs* Djtry w`s b`ojdi
tgreubg tgd rd`r djtr`jhd upej wgohg oj n`rbd Hgojdsd hg`r-
`htdrs w`s ` sobj @mdroh`j Hejsun`td. se tg`t tgd `tt`hl heuni
jet g`vd addj tgreubg mosujidrst`jiojb%+ Merdevdr. tgd fn`b
ej tgd fn`b st`ff w`s funny vosoand frem `nn `reuji*
Ygd seniodrs h`md oj geniojb tgdor rofnds rd`iy te sgeet `ji
h`nnojb eut lonn tgd ferdobjdrs. sgew us wgdrd tgd ferdobjdrs
`rd se tg`t wdm`y
lonn tgdm `ji somon`r tgrd`ts*
Tpej adojbteni ay tgd Hgojdsd st`ff `ji tgd sdrv`jts tg`t tgos w`s tgd
@mdroh`j Hejsun`td `ji tg`t @mdroh`js wdrd frodjiny te tgd
Hgojdsd. tgd seniodrs rdpnodi tg`t `nn ferdobjdrs wdrd `nold `ji
wdrd te ad lonndi*
Rgdj s`tosfodi tg`t je @mdroh`js wdrd tgdrd. tgd seniodrs
prehddidi te std`n dvdrytgojb oj tgd effohd `ji rdsoidjhd `ji te
ard`l up wg`t tgdy heuni jet h`rry `w`y* Ygdy p`oi spdho`n
`ttdjtoej te tgd s`fds `ji mdt`n fonojb h`aojdts `ji djid`verdi
ay tgrd`ts `ji ferhd te hempdn tgd Hgojdsd dmpneyds te epdj
tgd fermdr* Tsojb v`roeus ompndmdjts. tgdy tgdj `tt`hldi tgd
s`fds `ji m`j`bdi te m`ld ` beei sozdi gend oj tgd a`hl ef ejd*
Fertuj`tdny. tgd hemp`rtmdjt rd`hgdi ejny hejt`ojdi st`toejdry.
upej tgd ioshevdry ef wgohg tgdy idhoidi tg`t tgos s`fd w`s jet
wertg furtgdr dffert*
Ygd seniodrs dvdj teel eff mdt`n adis. mdt`n fond h`aojdts `ji
somon`r n`rbd podhds ef furjoturd* Rgdj tgdy g`i `nn tgdy w`jtdi.
tgd ne`fdrs `ji hemmej pdepnd wdrd urbdi ay tgdm te hemd oj
`ji t`ld wg`t w`s ndft @s ` rdsunt. tgd Hgojdsd st`ff rdpert
tg`t tgd auoniojb os neetdi hnd`j wotg tgd dxhdptoej ef tgd s`fds.
twe stevds. sh`ttdrdi aeels `ji p`pdrs `ji semd idsls. tgd
n`ttdr. gewdvdr. adojb sdroeusny i`m`bdi*
Ygd fn`b w`s forst g`undi iewj `ji tgdj r`osdi upsoid iewj.
dvoidjtny `s `j ojsunt< ot w`s tgdj g`undi iewj. terj `ji tgd
g`ny`ri hut `ji t`ldj `w`y*
Ygus. tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td w`s reaadi ef vortu`nny `nn
ots furjoturd `ji dquopmdjt `ji tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun stroppdi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 40/455
93 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
ef `nn gos geusdgeni furjosgojbs. hnetgojb `ji pdrsej`n prepdrty
`nn ay tgd J`toej`nost treeps oj ujoferm*
Je dffert w`s m`id te step tgos erby ujton suasdqudjt te tgd
j`v`n a`rr`bd. `ji `ftdr `nn tgd i`m`bd g`i addj iejd*
1. OJKTQODX YE EYGDQ J@YOEJ@NX-
Oj ` m`jjdr somon`r te tg`t usdi `b`ojst @mdroh`js. `nn etgdr
ferdobjdrs. ojhnuiojb K`p`jdsd. wdrd `ss`untdi `ji reaadi. aut
ot os sobjofoh`jt tg`t wgond semd 08 @mdroh`j auoniojbs wdrd aurjdi.
je auoniojbs ewjdi ay etgdr j`toej`ns wdrd se trd`tdi*
Ygd K`p`jdsd Hejsun`td w`s tgd forst bevdrjmdjt hdjtdr
`tt`hldi* Ygd n`rbd jumadr ef K`p`jdsd `ssdmandi tgdrd wdrd
reaadi `ji arut`nny mostrd`tdi* @hheriojb te tgd st`tdmdjt ef
tgd K`p`jdsd j`v`n effohdr tgdj oj hg`rbd gdrd. sgets wdrd id-
noadr`tdny`ji sdvdr`n tomds fordi `t tgd K`p`jdsd Hejsun wge
w`s onn oj adi* Ygrdd K`p`jdsd mdmadrs ef tgd hejsun`r st`ff
wdrd `tt`hldi `ji weujidi ay J`toej`nost seniodrs. wgond tgd
hejsun`r effohds `ji rdsoidjhds wdrd tgereubgny reaadi `jineetdi* K`p`jdsd getdns. gespot`ns. pn`hds ef ausojdss `ji rdso-
idjhds `nn suffdrdi somon`r f`tds* Ejd K`p`jdsd s`oner w`s `nse
sget `ji lonndi*
@ Frdjhg H`tgenoh f`tgdr w`s muridrdi* Ygd hemm`jidr
ef tgd @ndrtd st`tdi tg`t ` J`toej`nost effohdr fennewdi ay gos
mdj djtdrdi tgd shgeen wgdrd tgd prodst w`s `ji. wotgeut `jy
w`rjojb wg`tsedvdr. gomsdnf sget gom*@j Ot`no`j H`tgenoh prodst w`s `nse sget `ji lonndi ay J`-
toej`nost seniodrs `ji wotgeut preveh`toej*
J`toej`nost seniodrs `rd rdpertdi te g`vd peurdi ldresdjd ej
p`rts ef tgd H`tgenoh hgurhg. aut wdrd prdvdjtdi frem `htu`nny
sdttojb ford te ot ay Hgojdsd jdobgaers wge fd`rdi fer tgd s`fdty
ef tgdor ewj prepdrty*
Ygd Arotosg suffdrdi tgd gd`vodst ness ef nofd. g`vojb twe mdjlonndi. Ir* N* X* Xmotg. ` muhg rdspdhtdi `ji gejerdi neh`n
pr`htotoejdr. `ji Mr* Guadr. tgd G`raerm`stdr ef tgd Hgojdsd
M`rotomd Hustems* Aetg wdrd muridrdi `t tgd Arotosg Hej-
sun`td Bdjdr`n wgdrd tgdy g`i addj t`lojb rdfubd* Mr* Adrtr`m
Bonds `ji H`pt`oj Xpd`r wdrd `nse sget `ji weujidi `t tgd
Hejsun`td Bdjdr`n* Aetg tgd muridrs `ji weujiojb wdrd iejd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 41/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 90
ay J`toej`nost seniodrs wge ljdw wgdrd tgdy wdrd `ji. oj Mr*
Bonds+ h`sd. wge tgdor vohtom w`s*
Ygd Arotosg Hejsun`td Bdjdr`n w`stgereubgny
neetdi
aysuh-
hdssovd w`vds ef J`toej`nost seniodrs `ji tgd twe weujidi mdj
`hhemp`jodi ay Mrs* Bonds `ji ` Moss An`ld wdrd fer 80 geurs
oj tgd a`hl reem ef tgd b`td geusd* @ntgeubg tgd eutr`bds `t
tgd Hejsun`td Bdjdr`n. ojhnuiojb tgd weujiojb ef Mr* Bonds.
wdrd m`ttdrs ef hemmej ljewndibd tgreubgeut tgd hoty. jetgojb
wg`tsedvdr w`s iejd tew`ris `fferiojb `idqu`td pretdhtoej `ji
rdnodf ujton tgd `ftdrjeej ef M`rhg 14*
Arotosg hotozdjs wgdrdvdr feuji wdrd reaadi `ji `ausdi oj
tgd s`md m`jjdr `s @mdroh`js. `ji tgdor rdsoidjhds. pn`hds ef
ausojdss `ji tgd gunls. `nejbsoid ef wgohg sgops ne`i `ji ios-
hg`rbd. wdrd `nn tgereubgny neetdi* @ntgeubg jejd ef tgdor
auoniojbs wdrd aurjdi. oj m`jy h`sds tgd ieer `ji wojiew
fr`mds wdrd terj eut. `ji oj ejd h`sd. dvdj tgd fneers wdrd iub
up*
8* HGOJDXD EFFOHDQX @JI YQEESX QDXSEJXOAND;
Bdjdr`n Hgdjb Hgodj. Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf ef tgd 6tg J`-
toej`nost @rmy `ji Iordhter ef tgd Qobgt 'Xeutg/ A`jl ef tgd
Qovdr. os tgd gobg Hemm`jiojb Effohdr wgesd treeps `rd rd-
spejsoand fer tgd eutr`bds* Ot wonn prea`any ad usdndss te dj-
id`ver te fox tgd rdspejsoaonoty upej `jy p`rtohun`r iovosoej. `s
`t nd`st p`rts ef aetg tgd 1ji `ji 6tg J`toej`nost @rmods wdrd
oj tgdhoty
`t tgd tomd ef tgd ojhoidjts* Ygd Qdi Xw`stol`
Xehodty"s effohdrs ojfermdi us. gewdvdr. tg`t tgd Hemm`jidr ef
tgd 9tg Iovosoej '1ji J`toej`nost @rmy/ w`s `htu`nny oj tgd
hoty ej tgd 19tg< ot g`s `nse addj suasdqudjtny nd`rjdi tg`t
Bdjdr`n Gu _`e-t`u. Hemm`jidr ef tgd 1ji Ojidpdjidjt
Iovosoej. w`s `nse tgdj oj tgd hoty*
My Hgojdsd st`ff ojferm md tg`t tgd treeps wgohg `tt`hldi
`ji neetdi tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td adnejbdi te tgd 1ji Ojid-
pdjidjt Iovosoej* Gewdvdr. tgos f`ht sgeuni jet ad mdjtoejdi
`s ot mobgt rdsunt oj tgd pdrsdhutoej ef eur vdry ney`n dmpneyds
wge g`vd `nrd`iy suffdrdi aetg ness `ji g`risgop adh`usd ef
tgdor hejjdhtoej wotg eur effohd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 42/455
91 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
9 SQEEFX EF EQB@JO[@YOEJ @JI SQDMDIOY@YOEJ;
@s wonn ad jetdi frem `j dx`moj`toej ef tgd hdrtofodi hepods
ef swerj `ffoi`vots ef semd 83 @mdroh`j hotozdjs wgohg `rd `p-
pdjidi te tgos rdpert `s djhnesurds er dxgoaots. ` jumadr ef tgd
merd ndvdn gd`idi ef tgd @mdroh`js g`vd st`tdi ot `s tgdor form
adnodf tg`t tgd eutr`bds ef M`rhg 19 wdrd jet ejny hemmottdi
wotg tgd ljewndibd `ji hejsdjt ef tgd gobgdr J`toej`nost effohdrs.
aut wdrd p`rt ef ` prdmdiot`tdi `ji h`rdfunny `rr`jbdi pn`j te
irovd @mdroh`js `ji etgdr ferdobjdrs eut ef Hgoj`* Frem tgdor
wrottdj `ji vdra`nst`tdmdjts.
`s wdnn `s frem tgd sdrods ef
dvdjts tg`t h`md ujidr my pdrsej`n easdrv`toej `ji tgd st`td-
mdjts m`id te md ay ujofermdi J`toej`nost seniodrs `ji pdtty
effohdrs. O `m funny hejvojhdi aetg '0/ ef tgd buonty ljewndibd
ef. `ji tgd hejsdjt te. tgd eutr`bds ej tgd p`rt ef tgd gobgdr
effohdrs. ojhnuiojb Bdjdr`n Hgdjb Hgodj. `ji '1/ tg`t tgd J`j-
lojb Ojhoidjt w`s h`rdfunny pn`jjdi oj `iv`jhd ay `t nd`st `
p`rtef tgd
hejtrennojbnd`idrs ef tgd se-h`nndi J`toej`nost mevd-
mdjt* Ygos os ` sdroeus st`tdmdjt. aut O adnodvd tg`t `ftdr h`rd-
funny dx`mojojb tgd djhnesdi `ffoi`vots `ji jetojb tgd fennewojb
peojts. tgd Idp`rtmdjt `ji Ndb`toej wonn funny hejhur oj myhejhnusoejs ;
`* Yomd Rotgoj Rgohg Eutr`bds Ehhurrdi;
Ot g`s addj hn`omdi oj ` puanoh st`tdmdjt ay Mr* Dubdjd
Hgdj tg`t tgd J`jlojb ojhoidjts wdrd tgd werl ef iosbuosdi
`bdjts ef tgd Hgogno-Xg`jtujb @rmy `ji wdrd pn`jjdi wotg `
vodw te arojb ioshrdiot upej tgd J`toej`nost bevdrjmdjt* Ygdrd `rd
m`jy preefs tg`t tgos w`s jet `ji heuni jet g`vd addj tgd h`sd*
Ygd sojbnd otdm ef tgd tomd wotgoj wgohg tgd eutr`bds ehhurrdi
`nmest somunt`jdeusny `ji tgreubgeut tgd hoty. os suffohodjt
`nejd te prevd tg`t tgdy heuni jet g`vd ehhurrdi wotgeut tgd
ljewndibd `ji hejsdjt ef tgd gobgdr J`toej`nost hemm`jidrs*
Hemmdjhojb `t `aeut 7 oj tgd merjojb. tgdy hejtojudi wotg
dvdr ojhrd`sojb voendjhd ujton `ftdr tgd j`v`n a`rr`bd wgohg adb`j
`t 8;14 oj tgd `ftdrjeej* Jet ejny se. aut tgd tgrdd hejsun`tds
`rd `nn neh`tdi ej tgd projhop`n strddt ef tgdhoty. `ji wg`tdvdr
teel pn`hd tgdrd must g`vd addj premptny `jifunny ljewj te
tgd gobgdr effohdrs*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 43/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 98
Furtgdr. `ntgeubg Bdjdr`n Hgdjb Hgodj. Hemm`jidr ef tgd
6tg @rmy. ossudi `j eridr fer tgd pretdhtoej ef ferdobj novds
`ji prepdrty. `hheriojb te gos ewj wrottdj st`tdmdjt. `ftdr gd`r-
ojb tgd j`v`n a`rr`bd. tgos w`s jet djferhdi* Fer wgond tgd
a`rr`bd steppdi voendjhd te pdrsejs. ferdobj auoniojbs wdrd neetdi
ej tgd 14tg `ji 16tg. `hheriojb te tgd st`tdmdjts ef sdrv`jts
wge weuni g`vd je rd`sej te nod oj tgos rdb`ri* Merdevdr.
pdtty neetojb `t tgd Arotosg Hejsun`td Bdjdr`n ay seniodrs hej-
tojudi ej tgd 17tg `ji tgd rdsoidjhds ef tgd Arotosg dmpneyds
ef tgd Yodjtsoj-Sulew
Q`onw`y`t Suhgdj. tgrdd monds `aevd
Sulew. wdrd rdpertdi `s neetdi ej tgd forst ef @pron* G`i ot
addj trud tg`t tgd eutr`bds wdrd tgd werl ef Jertgdrj seniodrs.
tgdy heuni jet pessoany g`vd addj hejtojudi ujidr tgd jesds ef
tgd J`toej`nosts fer se nejb*
Oj tgd `ffoi`vot ef Moss Mojjd V`utroj 'djhnesurd Je* 00/.
sgd st`tds tg`t `t `aeut 03 oj tgd merjojb ef M`rhg 19 `j effohdr.
tgd aretgdr ef `Bojnojb Henndbd
stuidjt. h`md te tgdhenndbd
`ji rdjidrdi `ssost`jhd oj pretdhtojb tgd @mdroh`j td`hgdrs*
@s `t tg`t tomd gd must g`vd sddj `ji gd`ri ef m`jy ef tgd
eutr`bds `b`ojst @mdroh`js. ojhnuiojb tgd muridr ef Ir* Ron-
no`ms. `ji hdrt`ojny weuni g`vd rdpertdi tgdm< tgd ujojtdr-
ruptdi hejtoju`jhd ef tgd werst ojhoidjts fer )y geurs tgdrd-
`ftdr heuni jet g`vd ehhurrdi wotgeut tgd funn ljewndibd `ji
hejsdjt ef tgdgobgdr
effohdrs*
a* Xomon`roty ef Ojhoidjts Ygreubgeut Hoty;
Ygd `jto-ferdobj eutr`bds wgohg wdrd pdrpdtr`tdi oj ` n`rbd
jumadr ef sdp`r`td prdmosds neh`tdi. oj semd ojst`jhds. `s muhg
`s fovd monds `p`rt wdrd `nn hg`r`htdrozdi ay se strolojb ` somo-
n`roty `s te ojioh`td tg`t tgdy wdrd h`rrodi eut oj tgd dxdhutoej
ef ` prd`rr`jbdi pn`j* Oj pr`htoh`nny d`hg h`sd tgd seniodrs dj-
tdrdi tgd ferdobj prdmosds tgrd`tdjojb tgd ehhup`jts wotg rofnds
er postens `ji h`nnojb fer tgd ferdobjdrs wgem tgdy st`tdi tgdy
weuni lonn* Rgdj ferdobjdrs wdrd feuji. tgdy wdrd forst reaadi
`ji tgdj ferhdi `t tgd peojt ef ne`idi ford `rms te ioshnesd tgd
wgdrd`aeuts ef hejhd`ndi v`nu`ands* @ftdr `nn tgdsd g`i addj
bovdj up. tgd seniodrs prehddidi te lonn er etgdrwosd mostrd`t
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 44/455
99 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgdor vohtoms. oj m`jy h`sds stroppojb tgdm ef tgdor eutdr
hnetgojb*
Ot w`s jetdiay
Mr* Gea`rt `jimysdnf
`ji `nse rdpertdiay
mossoej`rods wge `t tgd tomd wdrd m`jy monds frem us. tg`t tgd
seniodrs aerd dvdry dvoidjhd ef g`vojb addj werldi up ay h`rd-
fun prep`b`ji` te pdrferm iddis wgohg tgdy j`tur`nny fd`rdi te
hemmot* Ot w`s jetdi tg`t wgdj ejd seniodr b`vd dvoidjhd ef
adojb semdwg`t rdstr`ojdi ay eur `ttotuid `ji `rbumdjts. ejd
ef gos fdnnews weuni rdmoji gom tg`t gd adnejbdi te tgd rdve-
nutoej`ry `rmywgohg ioi jet fd`r
ferdobjdrs`ji
purpesdnylonndi tgdm `nn*
Oj tgd m`keroty ef h`sds. `ji jet`any `t tgd @mdroh`j `ji
K`p`jdsd Hejsun`tds. `ftdr tgd seniodrs g`i t`ldj wg`t tgdy heuni
h`rry. tgdy ferhdi tgd neh`n pdepnd `t tgd peojt ef tgd buj te
hemd oj `ji neet `nse Ygos w`s p`np`any iejd oj eridr te hrd`td
`j `noao oj `iv`jhd tg`t tgd objer`jt `ji stupoi"+
pdepnd mobgt
n`tdr ad an`mdi*
Ygd neetdrs prehddidi oj breups ef 9. 6 er merd. wgohg mevdi
ej wgdj iordhtdi ay ejd ef tgdor jumadr. dvoidjtny ` pdtty
effohdr. te ie se* Ygos pn`j w`s jetohdi aetg `t tgd Xt`ji`ri
Eon rdsoidjhd `ji `t tgd @mdroh`j mossoejs m`jy monds `w`y*
Xdd tgd `ffoi`vot ef Ir* Aewdj 'djhnesurd Je* 0/*
h* Ndssdr Effohdrs Rdrd Eftdj Rotg Neetdrs @ji Heuni
Hejtren Ygdm Rgdj Ygdy Idsordi;
G`i tgd neetdrs addj Jertgdrj `bdjts. tgdy weuni jet g`vd
addj `hhemp`jodi oj semd h`sds ay J`toej`nost effohdrs. jer
weuni tgdy g`vd addj rdhebjozdi `s J`toej`nost seniodrs ay. er
g`vd eadydi tgd eridrs ef. suhg effohdrs* _dt oj tgd swerj
st`tdmdjts ef Moss Mojjod V`utroj `ji etgdr Bojnojb Henndbd
f`huntymdmadrs
'djhnesurd Je* 00/ otos
iostojhtny sgewj tg`t
jet ejny w`s ` J`toej`nost effohdr ej tgd shdjd ef neetojb. aut
tg`t gd w`s `and. wgdj gd hgesd. te dxdrhosd hejtren evdr tgd
seniodrs* @s tgos `htoej teel pn`hd `t `aeut 03 oj tgd merjojb.
ot hnd`rny prevds tg`t tgd J`toej`nost hemm`jiojb effohdrs must
g`vd ljewj `t `pprexom`tdny 03-83 kust wg`t eutr`bds wdrd
adojb pdrpdtr`tdi ay tgdor mdj* Ygdor f`onurd te t`ld `jy rd-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 45/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 94
str`ojojb `htoej ujton `ftdr tgd j`v`n a`rr`bd. wgohg ioi jet ehhur
ujton fovd geurs n`tdr. os ` hnd`r ojioh`toej ef tgdor buonty ljewn-
dibd
ef `ji `hquodshdjhd oj tgd eutr`bds* Oj vodw ef tgd hejtren
dxdrhosdi evdr tgd J`toej`nost seniodrs dnsdwgdrd. tgd pdrmottojb
ef tgd `jto-ferdobj erby `t J`jlojb `nse ojioh`tds prdmdiot`toej*
Ot os ojhejhdov`and tg`t tgd gobgdr hemm`jiojb effohdrs wdrd uj-
`and te hejtren tgdor mdj fer pr`htoh`nny dobgt geurs `ji tgdj.
upej tgd a`rr`bd frem tgd @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg j`v`n vdssdns.
suiidjny adh`md `and te dxdrhosd suhg hejtren* Ygd uj`veoi`and
hejhnusoej os tg`t hejtren w`s dxdrhosdi`hheriojb
te tgd idsords
ef tgd gobgdr hemm`jiojb effohdrs. `ji tg`t sojhd `t `pprexo-
m`tdny 9 p* m* tgd treeps wdrd suiidjny `ji premptny h`nndi
tebdtgdr. tgdy g`i fer tgd prdhdiojb dobgt geurs addj fujhtoejojb
ujidr eridrs
Ygd f`ht tg`t tgd neetojb ay tgdor seniodrs w`s sddj ay `ji
`hquodshdi oj ay v`roeus J`toej`nost effohdrs os hnd`rny areubgt
eut oj tgd swerj st`tdmdjt ef Ir* @* K* Aewdj. Srdsoidjt ef tgd
J`jlojb Tjovdrsoty 'djhnesurd Je* 0/ `ji ay sdvdr`n etgdr
st`tdmdjts oj tgd djhnesdi `ffoi`vots*
i* Neetojb Xeniodrs Iordhtdi ay Rgostnds @ji @ssdmandi ay
Aubnd H`nns;
Qdvdrdji R`ntdr Q* Ronno`ms 'djhnesurd Je* 01/ st`tds tg`t
tgd suhhdssovd a`jis ef neetojb seniodrs wdrd mevdi ej ay sgronn
wgostnds dvoidjtny anewj ay nd`idrs* @s Mr* Ronno`ms w`s `t
tg`t tomd oj goiojb `ji jet tgdj adojb mendstdi. gd w`s oj `
pdhuno`rny `iv`jt`bdeus pesotoej h`rdfunny te jetd wg`t teel pn`hd.
`j `aonoty jet djkeydi ay tgesd wgesd easdrv`toejs wdrd m`id
wgond `htu`nny ujidrbeojb voendjhd `t tgd g`jis ef J`toej`nost
seniodrs* Fer tgos rd`sej. `ji adh`usd gd os ` pdhuno`rny hej-
sdrv`tovd `ji trutgfun ojiovoiu`n. gos st`tdmdjt oj tgos rdb`ri
sgeuni ad bovdj spdho`n wdobgt*
@hheriojb te tgd st`tdmdjts ef Qdvdrdji R`ntdr Q* Ronno`ms.
Mr* K`mds M* Xpddrs. Ir* G`rry F* Qewd. `ji Ir* Iej`ni R*
Qohg`risej 'djhnesurds Jes* 01. 1. 08. `ji 09. rdspdhtovdny/.
ommdio`tdny `ftdr tgd j`v`n a`rr`bd aubnds seujidi tgd seniodrs
wdrd dvoidjtny `ssdmandi er h`nndi eff ujidr eridrs* @s je
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 46/455
96 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
aubnds g`i addj prdvoeusny jetdi. ot `ppd`rs tg`t tgd hemm`jiojb
effohdrs ioi jetgojb te h`nn eff tgdor mdj ujton frobgtdjdi ay tgd
j`v`n buj ford. aut wdrd `and `t wonn `nmest ojst`jtny te arojb
tgdor mdj ujidr bdjdr`n hejtren*
d* Neetojb Rdnn Erb`josdi `ji oj Xemd H`sds Iordhtdi ay
Hovono`js Rge Ljew J`jlojb;
Frem my ewj easdrv`toej ej tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon gonn `ji frem
tgd swerj st`tdmdjts m`id ay mossoej`rods. jet`any ay Ir*
Aewdj. Mr* Ewdj `ji Mrs* H* G* Fneppdr 'djhnesurds Jes*
0. 03. `ji 04/. ot w`s hnd`r tg`t tgd neetojb w`s jet g`pg`z`ri
aut w`s h`rrodi eut oj ` bdjdr`nny erb`jozdi m`jjdr* Ygd sm`nn
breups sddmojbny g`i ljewj eakdhtovds `ji `nn fennewdi"tgd s`md
prehdiurd ef reaaojb. sdhurojb ef hejhd`ndi v`nu`ands ay ojtomo-
i`toej `ji voendjhd te @mdroh`js*
@hheriojb te st`tdmdjts ef Mdssrs* Xpddrs. Kejds. Xmotg `ji
Mrs* Monns 'djhnesurds Jes* 1. ?. 06 `ji 7. rdspdhtovdny/. neetojb
breups ef J`toej`nost seniodrs wdrd ndi. oj sdvdr`n h`sds. ay Hgo-
jdsd hovono`js wge. adojb f`mono`r wotg J`jlojb. buoidi tgd
neetdrs te ljewj eakdhtovds* Ygos peojt os ef brd`t ompert`jhd
`s ot ojioh`tds tg`t tgd eutr`bds wdrd pn`jjdi oj `iv`jhd `ji tg`t
J`toej`nost hovono`js wdrd utonozdi oj iordhtojb `ji buoiojb tgd
seniodrs oj tgdor h`mp`obj ef eutr`bd `ji tdrreroz`toej*
f* @nn Hovono`j
NeetojbEridrdi er Ndi
ayJ`toej`nost Xen-
iodrs ;
@s ot g`s addj `ssdrtdi tg`t `nn neetojb w`s iejd ay Jertgdrj
seniodrs er ay tgd neh`n pdepnd. ot sgeuni ad h`rdfunny jetdi tg`t
frem djhnesurds Jes* 02. 1. 9. 07. 08. 0?. 13. 04. 2. `ji 16. ot os
iostojhtny dst`anosgdi ay swerj st`tdmdjts ay tgereubgny rdno`and
@mdroh`j hotozdjs tg`t `ntgeubg hejsoidr`and neetojb w`s iejd
ay neh`n pdepnd. ot w`s ejny hemmottdi wgdj eridrdi er ndi aytgd seniodrs* Oj etgdr weris. `ntgeubg semd hovono`j neetojb ioi
ehhur. ot w`s jdvdr ojoto`tdi ay tgd pdepnd wge mdrdny fennewdi
tgd seniodrs" nd`i*
@t tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td wgdj tgd penohd djid`verdi te
step semd n`td neetdrs frem t`lojb eut aujinds ef `rtohnds wgohg
tgdy g`i pohldi up. tgdy 'tgd penohd/ wdrd hevdrdi ay tgd bujs
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 47/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 92
ef p`ssojb seniodrs wge s`oi tg`t tgd pdepnd sgeuni ad `nnewdi
te neet ferdobj prepdrty `t wonn @t tgos tomd tgd prehn`m`toej
eridrojb
tgd
pretdhtoej
ef
ferdobj
novds `jiprepdrty
g`i`nrd`iy
addj pestdi `t tgd hejsun`r djtr`jhd b`td*
b* Dxdmptoej ef Hgojdsd Geusds Ojioh`tds Metoud Ojkury te
Ferdobjdrs `ji Jet Mdrd Neet;
Frem sdvdr`n ef tgd djhnesdi st`tdmdjts ot wonn ad sddj tg`t
Hgojdsd geusds wdrd dxdmpt frem neetojb* Oj tgd `ffoi`vot ef
Mr* Genreyi 'djhnesurd Je* 11/ ot os peojtdi eut tg`t tgd rdso-
idjhd ef Mr* Op.` H`jtejdsd mdmadr ef tgd Tjovdrsoty ef J`j-
lojb. dsh`pdi neetojb `ntgeubg neh`tdi oj tgd moist ef ` breup
ef @mdroh`j rdsoidjhds* G`i mdrd neetojb addj tgd eakdht ef
tgd treeps. er g`i tgdy addj `htu`nny eut ef hejtren. tgos auoniojb
weuni `nse g`vd addj reaadi* Ygus tgd promd `htu`tojb metovd
ef tgd eutr`bds os sddj te ad ojkury te ferdobjdrs `ji jet neet
`nejd*
g* Dvoidjhds ef Sn`jjojb ;
Frem tgd st`tdmdjts ef Qdvdrdji R* Q* Ronno`ms 'djhnesurd
Je* 01/ `ji ef Qdvdrdji R* S* Qeadrts 'djhnesurd Je* 18/
ot `ppd`rs tg`t hdrt`oj stdps wdrd idfojotdny pn`jjdi oj `iv`jhd*
Mr* Ronno`ms gd`ri seniodrs st`tojb tg`t ferdobjdrs wdrd te
ad stroppdi te tgdor ujidrwd`r `ji tg`t te lonn ` ferdobjdr weuni
ad te b`oj prdstobd* @s tgos w`s dx`htny tgd prehdiurd fennewdi
oj sdvdr`n h`sds oj ioffdrdjt p`rts ef tgd hoty. ot os dvoidjt tg`t
tgos w`s ` prd`rr`jbdi pn`j. tgd dvdjtu`n dxdhutoej ef wgohg
w`s ejny frustr`tdi ay tgd uj`jtohop`tdi j`v`n a`rr`bd*
Mr* Qeadrts w`s teni ay ` J`toej`nost effohdr tg`t tgd `jto-
Arotosg g`trdi w`s h`usdi ay tgd fojiojb ef ` id`i Djbnosgm`j
`mejb tgd id`i wgotd Qusso`j seniodrs `ji tg`t tgos ioshevdry
g`i se ojfn`mdi tgd mojis ef tgd J`toej`nost seniodrs tg`t tgdy
g`i idtdrmojdi te lonn `nn Qusso`js `ji Djbnosgmdj wgem tgdy
feuji* Mr* Qeadrts adnodvds tg`t tgos os dvoidjhd ef prep`-
b`ji` purpesdny usdi te stor up tgd seniodrs tg`t tgdy weuni jet
gdsot`td te lonn* Ot `ppd`rs prea`and tg`t tgos hejhnusoej w`s
funny w`rr`jtdi*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 48/455
97 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
o* Qdfus`n ek Qdspejsoand Effohdrs te Xdd Ferdobj Hejsuns;
Dfferts te bdt ojte teuhg wotg tgd gobgdr J`toej`nost effohdrs
wdrd m`id ay md tgreubgeut tgd djtord i`yef
M`rhg 19tg.
tgreubg tgd penohd effoho`ns. ay bovojb my h`ri te seniodrs `ji
tgreubg tgd sdnf-styndi Senotoh`n Aurd`u oj tgd Gso`lw`j suraura*
Xomon`r dfferts wdrd m`id ay etgdr ferdobj effoho`ns* Rgond ot os
ujidrst`ji`and tg`t semd mdss`bds mosh`rrodi ot os ompessoand
tg`t `nn ioi se. `ji ot os ejny tee pn`oj tg`t tgd gobgdr effohdrs
ioi jet idsord er ojtdji te ad sddj ay ferdobj effoho`ns* Ygdor
metovd fer tgos rdfus`n os eavoeus <
wdrd tgdy te sdd suhg effoho`ns
`ji ad effoho`nny ojfermdi ef tgd eutr`bds. tgdy heuni jet ioshn`om
ljewndibd er rdspejsoaonoty*
Dvdj oj tgd dvdjojb wgdj Bdjdr`n Hgdjb Hgodj sdjt weri
tgreubg tgd Qdi Xw`stol` Xehodty `slojb tg`t tgd a`rr`bd jet
ad rdpd`tdi. gd rdfusdi te sdji `jy rdspejsoand gobg effohdr te
ioshuss tgd sotu`toej wotg Qd`r @imor`n G* G* Geubg. H`pt`oj
Djbn`ji ef tgd Dmdr`ni `ji mysdnf* Ygos rdfus`n w`s hejtojudi
ej tgd 14tg. wgdj `j ompuidjt `ji dv`sovd rdpny w`s rdhdovdi
frem gom*
k* Jdbndht te Y`ld @iv`jhd Srdh`utoejs;
G`i tgd J`toej`nosts idsordi te pretdht ferdobj novds `ji prep-
drty. `s w`s hn`omdi ay Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb Hgodg-sgog 'Hgo`jb L`o-
sgdl/ oj gos st`tdmdjt te prdss rdprdsdjt`tovds oj Xg`jbg`o. `i-
v`jhd stdps weuni g`vd addj t`ldj oj vodw ef tgd ljewj prds-
djhd oj J`jlojb ef tgrdd ferdobj hejsun`tds `ji ` n`rbd ferdobj
pepun`toej* Ygd f`ht tg`t je suhg stdps wdrd t`ldj. hnd`rny prevds
tg`t tgd Hdjtr`n Hemmottdd g`i je idsord fer tgd pretdhtoej ef
ferdobjdrs. aut ej tgd hejtr`ry. `ji fer ots ewj purpesds. idsordi
tg`t `jto-ferdobj eutr`bds sgeuni ehhur* Ot os adnodvdi. gewdvdr.
tg`t pdrsej`nny Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb Hgodg-sgog prea`any g`i je `i-
v`jhd ljewndibd ef tgos pn`j `ji pdrg`ps rdbrdts tgd ehhur-
rdjhd* Gewdvdr. Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb ieds jet hejtren tgd J`toej`nost
bevdrjmdjt `ji gos ewj pdrsej`n sddmojbny merd rd`sej`and
`ttotuid h`jjet ad hejsoidrdi `s rdprdsdjtojb tg`t ef tgd hej-
trennojb dndmdjt oj gos p`rty*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 49/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 9?
l* Yreeps Hemmottojb Eutr`bds Rdrd Xeutgdrj Hgojdsd ;
Ygd treeps wgohg hemmottdi tgd eutr`bds wdrd frem tgdor
spddhg ujqudstoej`anyXeutgdrjdrs*
Ygd n`rbd jumadrwotg
wgemO w`s ferhdi te p`rndy fer evdr twe geurs `t Mr* Gea`rt"s rdso-
idjhd `ji tgd sdvdr`n wotg wgem O speld adferd nd`vojb tgd
@mdroh`j Hejsun`td wdrd dotgdr Guj`jdsd er frem Lo`jbso `ji
fdw wdrd dvoidjtny frem Lw`jbtujb. `s tgdy heuni jet spd`l
M`ji`roj* Ygdy werd str`w s`ji`ns `ji m`jy g`i tgd typoh`n
H`jtejdsd. n`rbd reuji a`maee g`ts str`ppdi te tgdor a`hls*
4* DFFDHY EF YGD A@QQ@BD;
Ygd j`v`n a`rr`bd wgohg w`s put iewj ay tgd T* X* X* Je`.
tgd T* X* X* Srdstej `ji G* M* X* Dmdr`ni oj eridr te s`vd
tgd 41 ferdobjdrs adsdobdi oj tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon geusd. ujqudstoej-
`any s`vdi tgd novds jet ejny ef tgos p`rty. aut ef ` sm`nndr "breup
`t tgd Arotosg Hejsun`td Bdjdr`n. ef tgd n`rbd breup ef K`p`jdsd
`t tgdK`p`jdsd
Hejsun`td `ji ef semd 013 @mdroh`jsm`ojny
`s-
sdmandi `t tgd Tjovdrsoty ef J`jlojb* Ot w`s iordhtdi `t tgd
epdj gonn heujtry ommdio`tdny `reuji tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon rdsoidjhds
`ji wgond ` fdw sgdnns wdjt adyeji. tgd i`m`bd iejd te Hgojdsd
nofd. etgdr tg`j te tgd `tt`hldrs ef tgd rdsoidjhds oj qudstoej. w`s
ojfojotdsom`n<tgd i`m`bd te Hgojdsd prepdrty w`s `nse jdbnoboand*
Jet ejny os tgd heujtry `reuji tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon gonn epdj `ji
wotg ejny ehh`soej`n breups ef f`rm geusds. aut tgd s`md st`td-
mdjt os trud ef tgd heujtry adyeji `ji oj nojd wotg tgd ford* Ygd
Hoty ef J`jlojb w`s jet aema`ridi `ji `nn ef tgd st`tdmdjts te
tgd hejtr`ry ay Mr* Dubdjd Hgdj `rd p`np`any mdji`hoeus `ji
ojtdjidi te idhdovd tgd Rdstdrj werni*
Ygd st`tdmdjts ef @mdroh`js oj tgdor swerj `ffoi`vots `s te
tgd adjdfoho`n dffdht ef tgd j`v`n a`rr`bd `rd tee jumdreus te ad
quetdi gdrd aut sgeuni ad h`rdfunny jetdi* Oj bdjdr`n tgdsd
st`tdmdjts `brdd tg`t tgd j`v`n buj ford s`vdi tgd novds ef `nn
ferdobjdrs tgdj wotgoj tgd hoty w`nns< tg`t ot ojst`jtny steppdi
tgd forojb eff ef rofnds `ji postens ay neetojb J`toej`nost seniodrs<
tg`t ot m`id pessoand tgd dv`hu`toej ef ferdobjdrs ej M`rhg 14tg<
tg`t ot h`usdi tgd anewojb ef aubnds te h`nn eff tgd neetdrs< tg`t
tgd werst voendjhd `ji neetojb w`s ojst`jtny steppdi ay ot< tg`t
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 50/455
43 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
hovono`j neetdrs wdrd `wdi `ji rdstr`ojdi< `ji. oj arodf. tg`t ot
preiuhdi `nn ef tgd rdsunts idsordi aetg dffdhtovdny `ji premptny*
6* HEJHNTXOEJ*
Frem tgd f`hts `s areubgt eut `aevd. `ji frem tgd `auji`jt
m`tdro`n hejt`ojdi oj tgd djhnesdi `ffoi`vots. ot os sgewj tg`t ej
M`rhg 19tg tgdrd ehhurrdi ` idnoadr`td `ji dvoidjtny prd`rr`jbdi
h`mp`obj ef ujp`r`nndndi voendjhd `ji eutr`bd `b`ojst `nn fer-
dobjdrs oj J`jlojb ay pertoejs ef tgd 1ji `ji 6tg J`toej`nost
`rmods* Adsoids ieojb jetgojb te rdstr`oj gos treeps ujton ferhdi
te ie se ay tgd j`v`n a`rr`bd. tgd J`toej`nost hemm`jiojb effohdr
hejsostdjtny rdfusdi te sdji `jy gobg r`jlojb effohdr te ioshuss
tgd ojhoidjts `ji `rr`jbd fer tgd rdnodf ef tgd ferdobjdrs ndft oj
tgd hoty. wgesd `htu`n dv`hu`toej `s idshroadi oj my idsp`thg
ef M`rhg 17tg. w`s ejny m`id pessoand ay ` strejb tgrd`t te
aema`ri tgd hoty* Furtgdr. `ftdr tgd eutr`bd gd g`s sgewj je
hejtrotoej `ji g`s iejd jetgojb wg`tsedvdr tew`ris m`lojb
`mdjis er pujosgojb tgesd buonty < ej tgd hejtr`ry. gd g`s m`oj-
t`ojdi `j `ttotuid ef truhundjhd `ji ompuidjhd. `ji g`s nobgtny
iosmossdi tgd ojhoidjts `s tgd werl ef neh`n a`i hg`r`htdrs
ojstob`tdi ay Jertgdrj `bdjts*
Ot g`s addj ompessoand te hevdr `nn peojts `ji ot os gepdi.
tgdrdferd. tg`t tgd Idp`rtmdjt `ji Ndb`toej wonn jet hejfojd tgdor
`ttdjtoej te tgesd dnuhoi`tdi oj gos rdpert. aut wonn h`rdfunny dx-
`mojd tgd m`ss ef v`nu`and m`tdro`n hejt`ojdi oj tgd djhnesdi
hepods ef swerj st`tdmdjts ay @mdroh`j hotozdjs*
2* YGOX QDSEQY SQDS@QDI TJIDQ IOFFOHTNYODX;
Oj spotd ef tgd vdry bdjdreus `ssost`jhd ef Nodutdj`jt-
Hemm`jidr Fr`jl G* Nuhldn `ji tgd effohdrs ef tgd T* X* X*
Kegj I* Feri. tgd prdp`r`toej ef tgos rdpert g`s addj `ttdjidi
wotg muhg ioffohunty* Ygd t`sl ef ir`ftojb ot ay nejbg`ji wgdjwotgeut my bn`ssds. ef wgohg O w`s reaadi ay J`toej`nost sen-
iodrs. `ji ay `rtofoho`n nobgt. g`s addj p`ojfunny n`aeroeus `ji
snew* @ sgert`bd ef typdwrotdrs ej ae`ri `ji nomot`toejs ef
sp`hd g`vd `nse idn`ydi ots hempndtoej* Ygdsd hejiotoejs `rd
`hheujt`and fer tgd m`jy eavoeus ompdrfdhtoejs oj stynd `ji
`ppd`r`jhd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 51/455
YGD J@JLOJB OJHOIDJY 40
Oj m`lojb tgd djhnesdi hepods ef `ffoi`vots. ot g`s addj om-
pessoand te ie beei typojb `ji m`jy herrdhtoejs oj ojl g`vd addj
rdquordi te m`ld tgdm dx`ht*
Foj`nny hrdiot os iud Vohd-Hejsun S`xtej fer gos hejst`jt
`ssost`jhd `ji te Hndrl @* G* [dd wge g`s hemd ej ae`ri `ji
werldi f`r ojte tgd jobgt oj eridr tg`t tgos rdpert mobgt ad
hempndtdi `ji put upej ` iewj rovdr std`mdr*
Kegj L* I`vos
@mdroh`j Hejsun
I`vos+ rdpert weuni sddm sdnf-suffohodjt* Ot rdm`ojs ej fond oj
R`sgojbtej `s tgd effoho`n vdrsoej ef tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt. oj wgohg
se m`jy ferdobjdrs 'ojhnuiojb @mdroh`j mdj. wemdj `ji semd hgon-
irdj/ wdrd ojvenvdi*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 52/455
RG_ RD @QD OJ HGOJ@
FDR.of
`jy. ef tgd mdjoj
tgd TjotdiXt`tds
J`vy`ji M`rojd
Herps effohdrs `s wdnn `s djnostdi pdrsejjdn g`i ` vdry hnd`r
oid` ef wgy tgdy wdrd sdjt te Hgoj` oj suhg jumadrs ay tgd
@mdroh`j Bevdrjmdjt iurojb tgd hg`es wgohg adb`j wotg tgd Lue-
mojt`jb Qdveutoej*
Xemd dvdjtu`nny b`ojdi ` ruiomdjt`ry ljewndibd '0/ ef tgd a`soh
h`usds ef tgd treuand tg`t w`s dji`jbdrojb `nn nofd `ji prepdrty oj
@so`. j`tovd `s wdnn `s ferdobj< `ji '1/ tg`t tgdy. fer tgos vdry fuji`-
mdjt`n rd`sej. wdrd sdjt D`st te pretdht @mdroh`j novds `ji prepdrty
oj tg`t pdrsostdjtny druptojb `rd` oj tgd Erodjt* Ygdor t`sl w`s jet te
ojtdrfdrd wotg iemdstoh ioffohuntods ef tgd Hgojdsd. aut te prdvdjt tgdsd
frdqudjt eutard`ls frem ojtdrfdrojb tee brd`tny wotg tgd `htovotods ef
@mdroh`j f`monods wge hgesd er wdrd eanobdi te rdsoid oj tg`t `nmest
hejst`jt i`jbdr zejd oj tgd F`r D`st*
Ygos pretdhtoej ef ferdobj novds `ji prepdrty adh`md ` h`thg-
pgr`sd `mejb tgd ojg`aot`jts ef Hgoj` iurojb tgd H`jtej-ojspordi
rdvenutoej wgohg swdpt jertgw`ri evdr tgd djtord heujtry adjd`tg
tgd Brd`t R`nn. frem 0?16 te 0?17* Rotg semd easdrvdrs. tgos erio-
j`rony sdroeus ausojdss ef eur mdj oj ujoferm adh`md ljewj `s tgd
pretdhtoej ef 0* & p* er novds `ji prepdrty `s usu`n. iej"t yeuljew*
Ygd fobgtojb mdj fdnn oj wotg tgd pepun`r `ttotuid ef tgd tr`idrs
tew`ri tgd Hgojdsd omarebnoe `ji tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds ojvenvdi oj
tg`t surbd* Ygdy r`rdny ljdw tgd h`usds ef tgd turmeon wgohgareubgttgdm ej tgd nejb vey`bd te tgd Erodjt. ndt `nejd ujidrsteei tgd r`hds
ef ydnnew-slojjdi. sn`jt-dydi pdepnds `reuji tgdm* Ygdrd os jetgojb
eii oj tg`t n`hl ef hemprdgdjsoej ay mdj oj tgd J`vy er M`rojd
Herps* Oj tgd forst pn`hd. tgdors w`s hdrt`ojny jet te rd`sej wgy*
Ygdor e`tg te tgd fn`b `ji tgdor ewj heujtry w`s aut te ie er iod*
Ygdsd mdj g`i jet tgd snobgdst ojtdrdst oj tgd h`usd ef Hgoj`"s treu-
41
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 53/455
X8
ands* Ygd m`keroty wdrd ` g`ppy-be-nuhly net ef mdj. wotgeut ` h`rd
oj tgd werni* Ygd teur ef iuty eut Hgoj`-w`y w`skust
`jetgdr
`ssobjmdjt wgohg m`id tgd nofd ef ` seniodr. s`oner er M`rojd se
`p-pd`nojb te mdj wge wdrd rem`jtoh. sdjtomdjt`n er j`ovd djeubg te
neel fer ` tgronn ay keojojb up* Ygdy wdrd n`rbdny ojtdjt ej t`lojb
tgdor fuj wgdrd tgdy feuji ot h`usds ad i`mjdi* Ygdy wdrd
str`jbdrs oj ` str`jbd n`ji. `ji tg`t w`s djeubg*
Ye hema`t tgos ljew-jetgojb ndtg`rby `mejb tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds
J`vy oj tgd F`r D`st iurojb tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej. `j effohdr
`ae`ri tgd T* X* X* Hojhojj`to ossudi `
momdebr`pgdiMdmer`jium
te fdnnew-effohdrs `ji djnostdi mdj oj eur fnddt ej tgd ""Hgoj` Xt`toej%0
Ygd Hojhojj`to w`s fn`bsgop ef ` hruosdr squ`irej rusgdi te Hgoj`
iurojb tgd gdobgt ef tgd treuand oj tgd sprojb ef 0?12* Ygd sostdr
sgops wdrd hruosdrs T* X* X* Qohgmeji `ji tgd T X* X* Mdmpgos*
Ygdy wdrd sdjt eut te rdojferhd tgd jerm`n strdjbtg ef eur @so`toh
fnddt oj tgesd `ajerm`n tomds*
Oj `iiotoej. tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds g`i twe aeiods ef M`rojds `t
Xg`jb-g`o tgdj tgd 9tg `ji 6tg Qdbomdjts* Ygdor objer`jhd ef wgy tgd
Hgojdsd feubgt. dji`jbdrojb ferdobj novds `ji prepdrty. w`s `aysm`n
aut. ad ot dmpg`sozdi. je merd `akdht tg`j tg`t ef tgd `vdr`bd tr`idr
wge mevdi ojte ` str`jbd n`ji fer tgd usu`n rd`sej. j`mdny. te m`ld
mejdy*
Ygd Mdmer`jium w`s ossudi ay Nodut* Xt`jndy @* Kejds. ` buj-
jdry effohdr ef dxhdptoej`n ojtdnnobdjhd* Kejds resd frem tgd r`jls*
Gd w`s ` j`tur`n stuidjt. `ji p`ssdi ej gos ewj ojferm`toej te tgd
etgdrs wotg gom oj tgd Hgoj` `ivdjturd* Ygd eutnojd ef gostery
wgohg tgd Nodutdj`jt b`vd w`s ` hemprdgdjsovd stuiy ef tgd sotu-
`toej oj tgd Erodjt* Gd b`vd ` tguma-j`on sldthg ef tgd rd`sejs fer
eur bevdrjmdjt"s ojtdjsd ojtdrdst oj 0?12 oj idvdnepmdjts `mejb
tgd Hgojdsd r`hds* Gd h`nndi ot. Eur Mossoej te Hgoj`. `ji oj `
fdw weris teni wg`t tg`t mossoej w`s* Ygd ujoqud Mdmer`jium
fennews. oj ots djtordty;
ETQ MOXXOEJ YE HGOJ@
Ye tgd hrdw ef tgd T* X* X* Hojhojj`to;
Ot os `pprepro`td `t tgos tomd te `hqu`ojt yeu `nn wotg tgd
eakdht ef eur hruosd te Hgoj`* Eur mossoej os te pretdht tgd novds
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 54/455
49 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`ji prepdrty ef @mdroh`j hotozdjs. `ji ay rdhoprehoty. wd pretdht
tgd novds ef etgdr ferdobjdrs*
_eumobgt
`sl;-
0* Rg`t `rd @mdroh`j hotozdjs ieojb oj Hgoj`5
1* Rgy iej"t tgdy nd`vd Hgoj` of tgdor novds `rd oj i`jbdr5
8* Rg`t brodv`jhd g`vd tgd Hgojdsd `b`ojst ferdobjdrs5
9* Rg`t heujtrods `rd p`rtohun`rny ojvenvdi. `ji wg`t wonn
ad eur rdn`toejs wotg tgdm ujidr tgd prdsdjt ioffohuntods5
4* Rg`t heujtrods `rd oj symp`tgy wotg tgd Hgojdsd oj tgdor
prdsdjtst`ji5
6* H`jjet tgd Hgojdsd bevdrjmdjt g`jind tgdor ewj `ff`ors5
Ygdsd sddm te ad tgd neboh`n qudstoejs noldny te `rosd oj
tgd mojis ef tgesd wge `rd jet `hqu`ojtdi wotg tgd sotu`toej
oj tgd F`r D`st* Oj rdpny tgdrdte. tgd fennewojb dxtr`hts frem
v`roeus seurhds. heupndi wotg forst g`ji ljewndibd ef tgd Hgojdsd
qudstoej b`tgdrdi iurojb sdvdj yd`rs ef iuty ej tgd Hgoj` st`-
toej. sgeuni djnobgtdj yeu `s te wgy tgd ferdobjdr os pdrsostdjt
oj gos ojtdrdst te bdt Hgoj` ej gdr fddt*
@s ` rdsunt ef tgd dxpdrodjhd ef ejd Kegj Ndiy`ri ef Hej-
jdhtohut wotg tgd H`pt`oj Heel Dxpdiotoej te tgd S`hofoh. tgd
forst sgop te s`on frem @mdroh` te djb`bd oj tr`id wotg @so` w`s
tgd Dmprdss ef Hgoj` Ndiy`ri rdturjdi frem tgd jertgwdst
he`st ef @mdroh` wotg sterods ef tgd fur tr`id adojb h`rrodi ej
wotg H`jtej* Gd teni ef tr`idrs auyojb furs fer soxpdjhd wgohgseni oj H`jtej fer )033* Ygdsd t`nds ojtdrdstdi mdrhg`jts ef
Aestej `ji Jdw _erl se tgd Dmprdss ef Hgoj` w`s fottdi eut
`ji s`ondi fer H`jtej ej Fdaru`ry 11. 0279* Xgd rdturjdi M`y
01. 0274*
Ygd rdturj ef tgd Dmprdss ef Hgoj` hrd`tdi semdwg`t ef `
sdjs`toej* @ rdpert ef tgd hruosd te eur Srdsoidjt hejt`ojdi tgd
st`tdmdjts tg`t tgd @mdroh`js wdrd trd`tdi `s a`ra`ro`js* Dvdjtei`y. `mejb tgd onnotdr`td Hgojdsd. wd `rd rdfdrrdi te `s ferdobj
idvons* @mdroh`js `ji Durepd`js g`vd `nw`ys addj ujwdnhemd
prespdhters oj Hgoj`* Tjton tgd yd`r 0791 H`jtej w`s tgd ejny
pert ef Hgoj` epdj te ferdobj tr`id< `ji tgd mdrhg`jts wge
`ttdmptdi te ie ausojdss wotg tgd Hgojdsd suffdrdi m`jy oj-
kustohds* Ygd ferdobjdrs m`id dvdry dffert te hemd te frodjiny
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 55/455
RG_ RD @QD OJ HGOJ@ 44
tdrms wotg tgd Hgojdsd. yodniojb te Hgojdsd `utgeroty `s hor-
humst`jhds idm`jidi*
Oj 0710 `sd`m`j.
Fr`jhos Ydrr`jev`. frem `j @mdroh`j
sgop eut ef A`ntomerd. w`s turjdi evdr te tgd Hgojdsd fer puj-
osgmdjt fer tgd lonnojb ef ` Hgojdsd aumae`t wem`j* Ygd
pujosgmdjt fer sn`ubgtdr ujidr Hgojdsd n`w w`s ejny ` sm`nn fojd*
@s `j ojioh`toej ef tgd prdkuiohd `b`ojst ferdobjdrs. Ydrr`jev`
w`s str`jbndi wotgeut dvdj ` gd`rojb*
Tjton 0793. tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Bevdrjmdjt effdrdi nottnd er
jepretdhtoej
te eur hotozdjs oj Hgoj`* Xojhd tgdj. gewdvdr. wd
g`vd djtdrdi ojte trd`tods wotg tgd Hgojdsd `ji adhemd ojtdrdstdi
`ji ojvenvdi oj F`r D`stdrj `ff`ors. `nejb wotg etgdr Sewdrs
wge `rd hempdtoters oj tgd hemmdrho`n fodni*
Kegj Puojhy @i`ms. oj ` ndhturd oj 0790. adferd tgd M`ss-
`hgusdtts Gosteroh`n Xehodty. s`oi ; Ygd fuji`mdjt`n projhopnds ef
tgd Hgojdsd Dmpord `rd `jto-hemmdrho`n* Ot `imots je eanob`toej
te geni hemmdrho`n ojtdrheursd wotg etgdrs. Otuttdrny
idjods
tgd dqu`noty ef etgdr j`toejs wotg otsdnf. `ji dvdj os ojidpdjidjt
Ot genis otsdnf te ad tgd hdjtdr ef tgd tdrr`qudeus bnead. dqu`n te
tgd gd`vdjny gest. `ji `nn etgdr j`toejs wotg wgem ot g`s `jy
rdn`toejs. penotoh`n er hemmdrho`n. `s eutsoid. troa`n a`ra`ro`js.
rdvdrdjtny suamossovd te tgd wonn ef ots idspetoh hgodf* Ot os upej
tgos projhopnd. epdjny `vewdi `ji ojfndxoany m`ojt`ojdi. tg`t tgd
projhop`n
m`rotomd j`toejs efDurepd
fer sdvdr`n hdjturods. `ji
tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds ef @mdroh` frem tgd tomd ef tgdor `hljewn-
dibdi ojidpdjidjhd. g`vd addj hejtdjt te geni hemmdrho`n ojtdr-
heursd wotg tgd Dmpord ef Hgoj`* Ot os tomd tKo`t tgos djermeus
eutr`bd upej tgd robgts ef gum`j j`turd. `ji upej tgd forst
projhopnds ef tgd robgts ef j`toejs sgeuni hd`sd*
Ygd h`us ef tgd w`r os tgd lewtew. tgd `rreb`jt `ji
ujsuppert`and prdtdjsoejs ef Hgoj`tg`t sgd wonn geni
hemmdrho`nojtdrheursd wotg tgd rdst ef m`jloji. jet upej tgd tdrms ef dqu`n
rdhoprehoty. aut upej tgd ojsuntojb `ji idbr`iojb ferms ef rd-
n`toej adtwddj neri `ji v`ss`n*
@i`ms w`s Xdhrdt`ry ef Xt`td `t tgd tomd ef Ydrr`jev`"s
dxdhutoej. `ji wdnn ujidrsteei tgd Hgojdsd `ttotuid tew`ri
ferdobjdrs*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 56/455
46 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Oj 0791. tgd Yrd`ty ef J`jlojb 'Arotosg/ prevoidi fer tgd
epdjojb ef tgd perts ef Feehgew. Jojbpe. @mey `ji Xg`jbg`o
fer tgd
purpesds
ef tr`id*
Ygd forst @mdroh`j Hemmossoejdr. rdsoidjt oj Hgoj`. w`s
H`nda Busgojb* Gd ndft tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds wotg idt`ondi ojstruh-
toejs `ji wotg tgd `utgeroty te m`ld ` trd`ty te rdbun`td tr`id*
@ftdr tgd sobjojb ef tgd Yrd`ty ef J`jlojb. Djbn`ji adnodvdi
tg`t Husgojb"s mossoej weuni ad fruotndss* Gewdvdr. gd prevdi
gomsdnf `j `and iopnem`t `ji wej sdvdr`n hejhdssoejs frem Hgoj`
wotgeutojtomoi`toej*
Husgojb"s trd`ty.ljewj `s tgd
Yrd`tyef
R`jbg`o. hejt`ojs tgd iehtrojd ef dxtr`tdrrotero`noty. evdr wgohg
tgdrd g`s rdhdjtny addj muhg ioshussoej* Ygd tdxt ef tgd `r-
tohnds wotg rdfdrdjhd te dxtr`-tdrrotero`n robgts os `s fennews ; Xua-
kdhts ef Hgoj` wge m`y ad buonty ef `jy hromoj`n `ht tew`ri
hotozdjs ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds sg`nn ad `rrdstdi `ji pujosgdi ay
tgd Hgojdsd `utgerotods `hheriojb te tgd n`ws ef Hgoj`. `ji hoto-
zdjs ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds wgem`y
hemmot`jy
hromd oj Hgoj`
sg`nn ad trodi `ji pujosgdi ejny ay tgd hejsun er etgdr puanoh
effoho`n ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds tgdrdte `utgerozdi `hheriojb te tgd
n`ws ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. @ji. `nn `rtohnds oj rdb`ri te robgts.
wgdtgdr ef prepdrty er pdrsej. `rosojb adtwddj hotozdjs ef tgd
Tjotdi Xt`tds `ji Hgoj` sg`nn ad suakdht te tgd *kurosiohtoej ef.
`ji rdbun`tdi ay. tgd `utgerotods ef tgdor ewj bevdrjmdjt* @ji
tgos `rtohnd `nse `iis;u`ji `nn hejtrevdrsods
ehhurrojboj Hgoj`
adtwddj tgd hotozdjs ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds `ji tgd suakdhts ef
`jy etgdr bevdrjmdjt sg`nn ad rdbun`tdi ay tgd trd`tods dxostojb
adtwddj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds `ji suhg bevdrjmdjts. rdspdhtovdny.
wotgeut ojtdrfdrdjhd ej tgd p`rt ef Hgoj`* Yg`t ujton tgd Hgo-
jdsd n`ws `rd iostojhtny m`id ljewj `ji rdhebjozdi. tgd pujosg-
mdjt fer wrejbs hemmottdi ay ferdobjdrs upej tgd Hgojdsd er
etgdrs sg`nn jet adbrd`tdr
tg`j tgdor`ppnoh`aonoty
te tgd nold
effdjsd ay tgd n`ws ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds er Djbn`ji< jer sg`nn
`jy pujosgmdjt ad ojfnohtdi ay tgd Hgojdsd `utgerotods upej `jy
ferdobjdr ujton tgd buont ef tgd p`rty sg`nn g`vd addj f`orny `ji
id`rny prevdj*
Oj ir`ftojb tgos trd`ty. Busgojb dvoidjtny g`i oj moji tgd
f`meus Ydrr`jev` h`sd* Etgdr Sewdrs jew g`vd tgd s`md
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 57/455
^V G _ R D @ Q D O J H G O W @
42
`brddmdjt wotg Hgoj`* Ygd Yrd`ty ef R`jbg`o prevoidi `nse
fer tgd robgt ef @mdroh`j hotozdjs te dst`anosg rdsoidjhds oj trd`ty
perts* Ygus. tgd
Yrd`tyef
R`jbg`om`rldi tgd djtr`jhd ef
tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds ojte F`r D`stdrj penotohs*
Oj `nn eur id`nojbs wotg Hgoj` wd g`vd djid`verdi te fennew
iopnem`toh hg`jjdns r`tgdr tg`j monot`ry* Ygd prdsdjt ujrdst
os ay je md`js eur forst dxpdrodjhd wotg tgd `jto-ferdobj fddnojb
oj Hgoj`* Iurojb tgd Y`opojb Qdadnnoej oj 0748 tgd w`nndi hoty
ef Xg`jbg`o h`md ojte tgd pessdssoej ef tgd rdadns* Ygd hustems
geusd w`s neetdi `ji tgdOmpdro`n
Hgojdsd Bevdrjmdjtseubgt
`ssost`jhd oj tgd supprdssoej ef tgd rdadns* Rgond ot g`s `nw`ys
addj tgd penohy ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds jet te ojtdrfdrd wotg tgd
ojtdrj`n penotohs ef ` j`toej. wd hejsdjtdi te hejhdrtdi `htoej ef
tgd trd`ty Sewdrs oj rdjidrojb `ssost`jhd te tgd Ompdro`n Bev-
drjmdjt ef Hgoj`* Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds teel je p`rt oj tgd `ff`or
adh`usd ef eur ewj hovon w`r `t gemd* Ygd Y`opojb Qdadnnoej
djidioj
0768oj f`ver ef tgd
Ompdro`nBevdrjmdjt*
Ej `hheujt ef tgd herruptjdss ef Hgojdsd effoho`ns `ji `s `
bu`r`jtdd fer ne`js m`id ay tgd trd`ty Sewdrs. `nn rdvdjud os
henndhtdi `t tgd trd`ty perts ay tgd Hgojdsd M`rotomd Hustems.
wgohg os effohdrdi ay tgd Sewdrs*
Oj 0?18. Xuj _`t-sdj. wge w`s tgdj tgd nd`idr ef tgd H`j-
tejdsd. tgrd`tdjdi te sdozd tgd hustems geusd `t H`jtej `ji
henndht
t
gos ewj+" rdvdjud* Ygd Sewdrs s`wte ot
tg`t gos oj-
tdjtoejs ioi jet m`tdro`nozd* Ygd wrotdr w`s prdsdjt `t H`jtej
ej tgos ehh`soej* Xuj ossudi ` st`tdmdjt te tgd dffdht tg`t. wgond
tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd mobgt dxpdht ` sdheji N`f`ydttd. tgd Sewdrs
hejhdjtr`tdi mdj-ef-w`r `t H`jtej te prdvdjt gom frem t`lojb
evdr wg`t gd adnodvdi wrdrd gos kust robgts* Ygd Sewdrs heuni
jet yodni te Xuj _`t-sdj"s idm`ji wotgeut voen`tojb tgdor trd`ty
wotgtgd
Sdlojb Bevdrjmdjt* Xuj w`sjet
rdhebjozdi`s oj
`jyw`y hejjdhtdi wotg tgd Hgojdsd Bevdrjmdjt*
Ygd H`jtejdsd. wotg tgdor rdhdjt suhhdssds. `rd jew oj hejtren
ef `nn tgd trd`ty perts seutg ef `ji `nejb tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr*
Dvdj tgeubg tgdy `rd oj hejtren tgdy h`jjet henndht tgd rdvdjud.
iud te tgd trd`tods wgohg dxost adtwddj tgd Sewdrs `ji tgd rdh-
ebjozdi Sdlojb Bevdrjmdjt* Ygos prevelds tgd `jto-ferdobj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 58/455
YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
fddnojb* Xgeuni tgd H`jtejdsd evdrtgrew tgd Sdlojb Bevdrj-
mdjt. tgdy wonn je ieuat jdbeto`td fer tgd meiofoh`toej ef dxostojb
trd`tods* Ot os tgd epojej ef m`jy herrdspejidjts tg`t tgd
Sewdrs wonn jet hejsdjt te tgd `areb`toej ef dxtr`-tdrrotero`noty
robgts* @nse. tg`t tgd adst senutoej te tgd Hgojdsd qudstoej os
tgd `ppeojtmdjt ef ` heujhon er hemmossoej. dxpdrt oj bevdrj-
mdjt`n erb`joz`toej. te str`obgtdj eut tgd bevdrjmdjt oj Hgoj`*
@jetgdr `jto-ferdobj idmejstr`toej teel pn`hd oj 0?33 wgdj
` sdhrdt sehodty. ljewj `s tgd Aexdrs%" s`oi te g`vd addj oj
hennusoej wotg tgd M`jhgu Bevdrjmdjt. `tt`hldi tgd ferdobj ndb`-
toejs `t Sdlojb `ji m`ss`hrdi j`tovd Hgrosto`js `ji ferdobj mos-
soej`rods* Ygd Ndb`toej bu`ris wdrd uj`and te g`jind tgd sotu-
`toej. se ` ferhd ef 0?.333 treeps hempesdi ef Arotosg. @mdroh`j.
Qusso`j. Frdjhg `ji Bdrm`js. `iv`jhdi ej Sdlojb* Ygos `ff`or
hest tgd Hgojdsd Bevdrjmdjt )882.433.333* Ygd oidmjoty ndvodi
ay tgd Sewdrs w`s )243.333.333. aut tgreubg tgd beei effohds
ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. ot w`s rdiuhdi*
Ygd id`tg ef tgd Dmpdrer oj 0?37 g`stdjdi tgd evdrtgrew ef
tgd M`jhgu Iyj`sty* Xuj _`t-sdj erb`jozdi ` rdvenutoej`ry
p`rty oj 0?03 `ji adh`md tgd nd`idr ef ` mevdmdjt fer ` bev-
drjmdjt ay tgd pdepnd* Ygos mevd w`s suhhdssfun. `ji Ir* Xuj
`aioh`tdi gos nd`idrsgop oj 0?00 oj f`ver ef _u`j Xgo-l`o. wge
suasdqudjtny adh`md tgd forst Srdsoidjt ef tgd Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh*
_u`j w`s hejfrejtdi wotg ` vdry ioffohunt t`sl. fer jdotgdr gd
jer gos `sseho`tds g`i tgd dxpdrodjhd jdhdss`ry fer tgd dst`anosg-
mdjt ef ` st`and fdidr`n bevdrjmdjt* Iurojb tgd erb`joz`toej ef
tgd H`aojdt semd iossdjsoej idvdnepdi rdb`riojb tgd rdprdsdjt`-
tovds ef tgd prevojhds* Oj 0?06. ` mevdmdjt w`s st`rtdi te
`aenosg tgd Qdpuanoh `ji rdturj te ` mej`rhgy* _u`j Xgo-l`o
w`s te adhemd Dmpdrer* Ygos stdp mdt wotg woid eppesotoej
tgreubgeut tgd heujtry* Xuj _`t-sdj sdt
up
` Srevojho`n Bev-
drjmdjt oj H`jtej `ji st`rtdi `jetgdr rdvenutoej`ry h`mp`obj
tg`t g`s addj `htovd dvdr sojhd*
Xuj _`t-sdj w`s tordndss oj gos dfferts te b`oj ferdobj rdheb-
jotoej. aut w`s ujsuhhdssfun* @ftdr tgd Sewdrs anehldi gos pn`js
te t`ld evdr tgd H`jtej Hustems oj 0?18. gd `hhdptdi tgd `oi `ji
heujsdn ef Xevodt Qusso`* Ygd prep`b`ji` `ji `htovoty ef Qdi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 59/455
RG_ RD @QD OJ HGOJ@ 4?
Qusso` g`s prdv`ondi `mejb tgd H`jtejdsd ferhds fer tgd p`st
tgrdd yd`rs* Qusso`. `j euth`st se f`r `s werni penotohs os hej-
hdrjdi. os tgd
ejny heujtry`nnodi te tgd H`jtejdsd `ji os
`bot`-
tojb tgd `jto-ferdobj fddnojb oj Hgoj`*
@ stuiy ef @mdroh`j p`rtohop`toej oj Hgojdsd `ff`ors hnd`rny
ojioh`tds tg`t wdrd ot jet fer tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. Hgoj` weuni
jet ad djkeyojb tgd sevdrdobj robgts sgd g`s tei`y*
Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds Bevdrjmdjt `ji etgdr Durepd`j Sewdrs.
g`vojb iud rdb`ri fer tgd rdhebjotoej ef trd`tods m`id `hheriojb
te tgd n`ws ef j`toejs. `rd
rdprdsdjtdi`t
Xg`jbg`o rd`iyte usd
ferhd. of jdhdss`ry. te djferhd eur trd`ty robgts* Ygd ferhds ef
tgd v`roeus prevojho`n w`r neris. voz* Hg`j L`o-sgdl 'Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl/ ef tgd H`jtejdsd. Ru Sdo-fu. ef tgd Hdjtr`n Bevdrj-
mdjt< Hg`jb Yse-noj. ef tgd M`jhguro`js. `ji Fdjb _u-gso`jb.
tgd se-h`nndi Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n%" `rd `nn mdrhdj`ry* Ygdy `rd
eftdj iosney`n `ji wonn fobgt fer `jyejd wge os `and te p`y tgdm
`ji fddi tgdm* Merd eftdj tgdy rdhdovd tgdor p`y tgreubg tgd
provondbd ef neetojb*
Ygd j`toej`n sporot ef tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd g`s addj idvdn-
epdi. wrotds Ir. Rdnnojbtej Lee te tgd Arotosg Ndb`toej `t
Sdlojb* Sdrg`ps se. aut ot weuni ad f`r adttdr tg`t tgos j`-
toej`n sporot ad iordhtdi `b`ojst tgd t`htohs ef tgd Hgojdsd w`r
neris wge `rd. `ji h`j ad dxpdhtdi te prevd ` furtgdr mdj`hd
te tgd
erb`joz`toej
ef tgd Hgojdsd Bevdrjmdjt. tg`j tew`ri tgd
ferdobjdrs wge `rd `jxoeus te sdd ` st`and bevdrjmdjt `t Sdlojb*
Ygd Arotosg `ji @mdroh`j Bevdrjmdjts g`vd aetg dxprdssdi
` idsord fer tgd meiofoh`toej ef dxostojb trd`tods* Rd h`jjet
id`n wotg rdadns*
Xummojb up tgd ojferm`toej hejt`ojdi oj tgos tgdsos. tgd
`jswdrs te tgd epdjojb qudstoejs `rd;
0* @mdroh`j hotozdjs `rd oj Hgoj` djb`bdi oj ndbotom`td tr`id
ay robgt ef trd`ty*
1* Rgond trd`tods h`nn fer tgd pretdhtoej ef novds ef eur j`-
toej`ns. wd tendr`td tgd `htoejs ef tgd Hgojdsd rdadns* Eur
hotozdjs neel te us fer pretdhtoej* Xemd dxprdssoejs ef
epojoej weuni g`vd us adnodvd tg`t oj eridr te idm`ji
eur robgts `s @mdroh`js hotozdjs. wd sgeuni rdm`oj wotgoj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 60/455
YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
tgd aeuji`rods ef eur heujtry* Ygd prespdroty ef eur
j`toej os feujidi ej eur hemmdrho`n rdn`toejs wotg tgd
rdst ef tgd werni* Oj eridr te m`ojt`oj eur j`toej`n
prdstobd. hemmdrho`n ojtdrdsts rdquord tgdor rdprdsdjt`tovds
te dst`anosg rdsoidjhds oj ferdobj heujtrods* Ygdy sgeuni
`t nd`st ad pretdhtdi `b`ojst r`ho`n `ji rdnoboeus prdkuiohd.
`ji pretdhtdi `b`ojst tgd n`ws ef ` heujtry wgdrd tgd ness
ef ` gum`j nofd os eftdj jet rdheridi*
8* Meidrj Hgoj` adnodvds tgd dxostojb trd`tods te ad ujdqu`n
`ji ujkust*
Ygdy ferbdt
tgd f`ht tg`t tgd j`toej`n ojidatdi-
jdss ef Hgoj` os oj tgd jdobgaergeei ef ejd aonnoej ienn`rs*
9 @nn ef tgd Sewdrs ef Durepd. tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds `ji K`p`j.
`rd hejhdrjdi oj tgd prdsdjt sotu`toej oj Hgoj`* Ygdy `rd
`nnodi oj tgd idtdrmoj`toej tg`t tgd ferdobj Xdttndmdjt `t
Xg`jbg`o sg`nn jet ad iosturadi*
4* Jejd aut Qdi Qusso`* Xgd os tryojb te ir`b Hgoj` iewj
te gdr ndvdn
6* Hgoj` g`s jet prevdj gdrsdnf `and te g`jind gdr ewj iof-
fohuntods* Ygd Bevdrjmdjt os a`jlrupt*
'XOBJDI/ Xt`jndy @* Kejds.
Nodut*. T* X* J*
Ygos iehumdjt tdnns ots ewj stery `ji `jswdrs tgd qudstoejs oj
any t`aun`tdi ferm. wgohg `nn heuni rd`i. bovdj tgd idsord* Fdw g`i
vdj tg`t. ef heursd< prefdssoej`n fobgtdrs r`rdny h`rd te bdt se iddpny
otdrdstdi oj tgd suakdht jd`rdst tgdm* Ygd Nodutdj`jt"s Mdmer`jium.
ndrdferd. ioi aut nottnd beei etgdr tg`j te sgew `j dxhdptoej`nny hnd`r
ohturd ef tgd a`soh rdn`toejs adtwddj tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds `ji tgd
`hds frem `are`i
+ + +
Xemdtomds tgd `ftdrjeej suj sgejd tgreubg tgd br`y ef Fdaru`ry"s
neuis tg`t newdrdi mest i`ys oj tgd wojtdr ef 0?12-17 evdr tgd
Vg`jbpee Qovdr fn`ts* Rgdj ot ioi. tgd r`ys sdt `bnew tgd aur-
osgdi hurvds ef ` sonvdr hup ej ` idsl oj ` heni stejd auoniojb oj tgd
s`rt ef Xg`jbg`o Ygdj sp`ttdrdi sujnobgt. areldj ojte myro`i tojy
n`fts. arobgtdjdi tgd dyds ef tgd m`j oj ujoferm `t tgd idsl. `ji gd
oeldi `t tgd nevojb-hup wotg `imor`toej `ji proid* Ygd m`j w`s
30 G* H* I`vos. hemm`jiojb effohdr ef tgd Feurtg Qdbomdjt. Tjotdi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 61/455
R G _ R D @ Q D O J H G O J @
60
Xt`tds M`rojd Herps. st`toejdi oj Xg`jbg`o* Ygd auoniojb w`s gos
gd`iqu`rtdrs* Ygd hup aerd tgos ojshroptoej ;
Srdsdjtdi te tgd FeurtgQdbomdjt. Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojd
Herps. ay M`ker-Bdjdr`n K* Iujh`j. Hemm`jiojb Arotosg Xg`jb-
g`o Idfdjsd Ferhd. `s ` mdmdjte ef eur frodjiny heepdr`toej oj
Xg`jbg`o. 0?12-17*
Ygd Iujh`j Hup w`s prdsdjtdi te tgd Feurtg Qdbomdjt ej
K`ju`ry 02. 0?17. `t Henejdn I`vos" gd`iqu`rtdrs* Bdjdr`n Iujh`j.
wge n`tdr adh`md M`ker-Bdjdr`n Xor Kegj Iujh`j `ji wge rdturjdi
te Djbn`ji `ftdr jd`rny ` yd`r"s sdrvohd oj Hgoj`. prdsdjtdi ot gomsdnf
`s ` pdrsej`n teldj ef `pprdho`toej ef tgd frodjisgop `ji heepdr`toej
wgohg dxostdi adtwddj tgd @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg idfdjsd ferhds oj tgd
F`r D`st* Ygd Bdjdr`n g`i `ppd`rdi ej tgd merjojb ef tgd prdsdj-
t`toej `t tgd @mdroh`j M`rojd gd`iqu`rtdrs. uj`hhemp`jodi ay `jy ef
gos st`ff* Oj gejer ef tg`t dvdjt. ` funn hemp`jy ef M`rojds g`i addj
prdsdjt wotg rofnds. stddn gdnmdts `ji nobgt m`rhgojb dquopmdjt* Ygd
rdbomdjt`n a`ji `jitgd
M`rojdfofd
`ji irum herps g`i t`ldj p`rt*
Bdjdr`n Iujh`j g`i addj bovdj twe ruffnds `ji fneurosgds wgohg gd
r`tdi `s ` M`ker-Bdjdr`n*
Kust `hress tgd reem. f`hojb Henejdn I`vos" idsl. `jetgdr trepgy
steei. `nse wej oj frodjisgop* Ot w`s ` fn`bst`ji ad`rojb ` sonvdr
pn`qud. `ji ej ot w`s tgd ojshroptoej ;
Srdsdjtdi te tgd Feurtg Qdbomdjt. Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojd
Herps ay tgd Forst A`tt`noej. tgd Brddj Gew`ris. te Hemmdm-er`td Ygdor Xdrvohd Yebdtgdr oj Xg`jbg`o. 0?12*
Ygd hrdst ef tgd Brddj Gew`ris. ` Arotosg rdbomdjt. w`s `t tgd
aettem ef tgd pn`qud. `ji tgd M`rojd hrdst. wotg ots mette. Xdmpdr
foidnos. w`s djbr`vdi `t tgd tep* Ygd @mdroh`j fn`b `ji tgd Feurtg
Qdbomdjt"s heners wdrd hressdi. oj tgd st`ji*
Ygreubgeut tgesd d`rnodr mejtgs tgd @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg `ji
etgdr idfdjsd ferhds heepdr`tdi oj ` rdm`rl`and sporot ef frodjisgop*
Ygd J`toejs `nnodi oj tgd Brd`t R`r oj Durepd `b`oj g`i te pn`hd
fobgtojb ferhds oj tgd fodni. tgos tomd oj Hgoj`* @ji tgd m`jjdr oj
wgohg tgdy werldi tebdtgdr `ji fermdi n`stojb frodjisgops w`s tgd
suakdht ef muhg f`ver`and hemmdjt eut D`st* Rgdj tgd Brddj
Gew`ris ndft fer Djbn`ji. tgd effohdrs ef tgd @mdroh`j M`rojds oj
Xg`jbg`o b`vd tgdor effohdrs ` f`rdwdnn iojjdr oj tgd @mdroh`j Hnua.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 62/455
61 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgd jobgt ef Idhdmadr 17* 0?12 @s tgdy idp`rtdi ej ae`ri ` tr`js-
pert ej K`ju`ry 6. 0?17. tgdrd w`s ` hemp`jy ef @mdroh`j M`rojds
iewj te sdd tgdm eff. `ji tgd M`rojd A`ji turjdi eut fer tgd ehh`-
soej* Ygd Yemmods"+ `ji tgd _`jls wdrd auiiods*
Ygd s`md sert ef sporot w`s jetohd`and oj tgd twe j`vods iurojb
tgd djtord yd`r oj Hgoj`* Rgond tgdrd w`s je ferm`n `rr`jbdmdjt
hevdrojb tgd suakdht. @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg. `ji etgdrs tee. oj hem-
m`ji ef j`v`n vdssdns up tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr. teel ot upej tgdmsdnvds
oe pretdht tgd novds `ji prepdrty jet ejny ef tgdor ewj j`toej`ns. aut
ef etgdr ferdobjdrs `s wdnn* Ygd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt w`s ` strolojb
dx`mpnd ef tgd sporot ef heepdr`toej tg`t w`s `pp`rdjt tgreubgeut*
Ot wonn ad rdh`nndi tg`t @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg idstreydrs `t J`jlojb
fordi wgdj h`nndi upej ay rdfubdds `sgerd oj i`jbdr ef tgdor novds tg`t
sprojb ef 0?12* Dvdry i`y tgd @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg hemm`jiojb
effohdrs hejfdrrdi tebdtgdr* Ygd K`p`jdsd `nse `ttdjidi* @ntgeubg `
Arotosg effohdr. H`pt`oj Djbn`ji. w`s tgd supdroer j`v`n effohdr prdsdjt
`t tgd tomd. wgdj Nodut -Hemir Qey H Xmotg. Kr*. hemm`jiojb tgd
T X* X* Je`. rdqudstdi gos pdrmossoej te ford forst of jdhdss`ry. H`p-
t`oj Djbn`ji rd`iony br`jtdi ot*
@ji jew. oj tgd w`rireem ef tgd T* X* X* Je` tgdrd os ` ad`u-
tofun sonvdr hob`rdttd aex. suot`any djbr`vdi. prdsdjtdi te tgd idstreydr
jet te tgd hemm`jiojb effohdr. gos effohdrs er `jy etgdr ojiovoiu`n.
aut te tgd Je` ay tgd Arotosg w`rsgop. G* M* X* Dmdr`ni* Oj
tgd w`rireem ef tgd Dmdr`ni st`jis ` n`rbd sonvdr hehlt`on sg`ldr*
Ot w`s tgd boft te tgd Arotosg sgop frem tgd Je`* @nrd`iy ` tr`iotoej
g`s `rosdj ; tgd sg`ldr jdvdr os te ad usdi dxhdpt wgdj `j effohdr frem
tgd T* X* X* Je` hemds ej ae`ri tgd G* M* X* Dmdr`ni*
Ygdsd `rd aut ` fdw ef tgd ojhoidjts sgewojb tgd heepdr`toej `ji
sporot ef frodjisgop wgohg m`rldi tgd rdn`toejs ef tgd @mdroh`j `ji
Arotosg ferhds oj Hgoj`* Ygd f`ht tg`t Bdjdr`n Iujh`j `ji tgd n`td
@imor`n M`rl N* Arosten. hemm`jiojb tgd @mdroh`j j`v`n ferhds
oj tgd Erodjt. wdrd `nse hnesd pdrsej`n frodjis sgeuni ad rdm`rldi*
Fennewojb tgdor effoho`n h`nns. tgd Arotosg Bdjdr`n `ji tgd @mdroh`j
@imor`n wdrd eftdj tebdtgdr `t seho`n fujhtoejs. `ji Bdjdr`n Iujh`j
w`s frdqudjtny ` budst `t tgd Xg`jbg`o rdsoidjhd ef @imor`n `ji Mrs.
Arosten* Ygos pdrsej`n iopnem`hy. tgosbdttojb te ljew tgd mdj ef
etgdr j`toejs oj hg`rbd ef tgd `ff`ors ef tgdor pdepnds. prdvoeusny id-
mejstr`tdi oj Yurldy. `b`oj m`rldi @imor`n Arosten `s `j ujusu`n
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 63/455
R G _ R D @ Q D O J H G O J @
68
`ji eutst`jiojb j`v`n m`j wge. ot w`s woidny `brddi. fottdi oj pdr-
fdhtny wotg gos kea oj tgd Erodjt oj tgesd tryojb i`ys*
Ojrdn`tojb tgdsd ojhoidjts O g`vd ioshussdi
ejny
tgd Tjotdi
Xt`tds `ji Arot`oj adh`usd tgdsd twe j`toejs g`i tgd n`rbdst idfdjsd
ferhds oj Hgoj` iurojb 0?12* Ot must jet ad tgeubgt tg`t tgd etgdr
Sewdrs rdprdsdjtdi wdrd jet `nmest `s frodjiny* Gewdvdr. spd`lojb
etgdr n`jbu`bds. tgdor mdj ioi jet adhemd `s wdnn `hqu`ojtdi `s ioi
tgd Arotosg `ji @mdroh`js* @ji. `b`oj. g`vojb sm`nndr ferhds. tgdrd
w`s nottnd ehh`soej fer tgd ojiovoiu`n ujots ef tgd Frdjhg. fer dx`mpnd.
er tgd Ot`no`js er etgdrs te werl tebdtgdr ojtom`tdny
@ stuiy ef tgd @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg ferhds oj 0?12-17 ioshnesds
tg`t `ntebdtgdr tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds g`i. `hheriojb te effoho`n foburds.
9.8?? effohdrs `ji mdj oj tgd M`rojd Herps oj Hgoj`. 0.333 @rmy
effohdrs `ji mdj. `ji tgd usu`n hempndmdjt ef Tjotdi Xt`tds J`vy
bujae`ts. idstreydrs `ji etgdr mdj-ef-w`r oj tgd Hgoj` Xt`toej.
tebdtgdr wotg tgrdd hruosdrs sdjt eut te `ubmdjt jerm`n j`v`n strdjbtg*
Ygdsd wdrd tgd nobgt hruosdrs Hojhojj`to. Qohgmeji `ji M`randgd`i.
ujidr hemm`ji ef Qd`r-@imor`n K* Q* _* An`ldny* Ygd Arotosg
idfdjsd ferhd oj Xg`jbg`o w`s hut te 9.433 effohdrs `ji mdj*
Ygd @mdroh`j strdjbtg oj Hgoj` ef jd`rny 9.433 M`rojds oj 0?12-
17 w`s tgd brd`tdst oj tgd gostery ef eur rdn`toejs wotg tgd D`st* Ygd
Feurtg Qdbomdjt. ndss tgd Xdheji A`tt`noej. dma`rldi fer Hgoj` `t
X`j Iodbe ej Fdaru`ry 8. 0?12. `ae`ri tgd T* X* X* Hg`otmejt* Ygdy
`rrovdi oj Xg`jbg`o ej Fdaru`ry 19 ef tg`t yd`r* Ygd rdbomdjt
rdm`ojdi `ae`ri tgd sgop ujton M`rhg 10. tgd i`y tgd J`toej`nosts
h`pturdi Xg`jbg`o. wgdj tgd mdj wdrd eridrdi `sgerd te pretdht
@mdroh`j novds `ji prepdrty* Ygd Xoxtg Qdbomdjt 'mojus tgd Ygori
A`tt`noej/. tgd Ygori Arob`id Gd`iqu`rtdrs `ji Gd`iqu`rtdrs Hem-
p`jy. `ji tgd Ygori Arob`id Xdrvohd Hemp`jy. ejd a`ttdry ef tgd
Ydjtg @rtonndry `ji ` M`rojd @vo`toej squ`irej s`ondi frem X`j
Iodbe ej ae`ri tgd tr`jspert Gdjidrsej ej @pron 2. 0?12. fennewojb
` rdqudst fer rdojferhdmdjts* Oj tgd md`jtomd. Arob*-Bdj* Xmdindy I*
Autndr `rrovdi. n`jiojb tgd i`y `ftdr tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt*
Etgdr `iiotoejs wdrd m`id sgertny `ftdr tgd Gdjidrsej s`ondi*
Ygd p`ssdjbdr nojdr Srdsoidjt Br`jt w`s hg`rtdrdi fer usd `s ` tr`js-
pert `ji s`ondi @pron 02 fer tgd Sgonoppojds wotg tgd Ygori A`tt`noej
ef tgd Xoxtg Qdbomdjt `ji tgd Xdheji A`tt`noej ef tgd Feurtg Qdbo-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 64/455
69 YGD IQ@ BEJ XYOQX
mdjt. tebdtgdr wotg tgd Forst A`tt`noej ef tgd Ydjtg @rtonndry 'ndss
ejda`ttdry/. ejd nobgt t`jl pn`teej. tgd Foftg Hemp`jy Djbojddrs.
`ji p`rt ef `jetgdr M`rojd `vo`toej squ`irej* Ygd rdst ef tgos `vo`-
toej squ`irej w`s pohldi up `t Bu`m `ji tgd vdssdn prehddidi te
Enejb`pe. jd`r M`jon`* Ygd mdj wdrd gdni tgdrd oj rdsdrvd `ji
suasdqudjtny areubgt te Xg`jbg`o* Ygd Feurtg M`rojds g`vd rd-
m`ojdi tgdrd dvdr sojhd* Ygd rdst ef tgd Ygori Arob`id w`s sgoftdi
te Yodjtsoj oj Kujd. wgdrd ot w`s st`toejdi ujton wotgir`wj* Bdjdr`n
Autndr. wge os jew id`i. m`id Yodjtsoj gos gd`iqu`rtdrs*
Ygd M`rojds fdnn ojte rdbun`r djh`mpmdjt reutojd muhg `s tgeubg
tgdy wdrd oj X`j Iodbe er `jywgdrd dnsd. `soid. ef heursd. frem tgd
ojoto`n jevdnty ef tgdor surreujiojbs* Ygd mdj wdrd bovdj dvdry
eppertujoty te bdt `nn tgdy heuni oj tgd w`y ef `j diuh`toej eut ef tgdor
teur ef iuty+" oj Hgoj` ay sobgt-sddojb* @ji tgdy g`i tgdor sperts
`ji `musdmdjts tgdrd `s oj @mdroh`* Ygd M`rojd ir`m`toh hnua b`vd
ehh`soej`n pn`ys oj tgd J`vy _* M* H* @* Ygd mdj g`i a`sldta`nn
td`ms. pn`ydi feeta`nn `ji etgdr sperts `ji wdjt oj fer aexojb m`thgds
wgohg wdrd `ttdjidi ay hovono`js `ji mdj oj ujoferm. `nold* YgdM`rojd A`ji pn`ydi fer v`roeus ferm`n `ji seho`n `ff`ors. `ji semd
ef tgd musoho`js fermdi ` i`jhd erhgdstr` tg`t w`s pepun`r `ji eftdj
pn`ydi `t tgd Henumao` Heujtry Hnua td`-i`jhds* Oj tgd summdr
Xg`jbg`o g`i ` a`sda`nn nd`bud. `ji tgd M`rojds" td`m `nw`ys w`s
`mejb tgd adst*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 65/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D
XGEQYN_`ftdr Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl h`pturdi J`jl-
lojb `ji sdt tg`t `jhodjt hoty up `s tgd jdw H`pot`n ef Hgoj`. O
wdjt up tgd _`jbtzd-lo`jb te G`jlew. oj tgd gd`rt ef tg`t w`r-
rojb n`ji* Ygd lo`jb p`rt ef tgd j`md md`js rovdr. `ntgeubg tgos
rd`nny os vdry nottnd nold tgd w`y tgd Hgojdsd tgdmsdnvds prejeujhd ot
tgd weri seujis merd nold bo`jb. wotg ` g`ri B. wgdj speldj ay `
Hgojdsd* Rgy wd spdnn ot wotg ` L os `jetgdr Hgojdsd puzznd*
Ygd _`jbtzd os ejd ef tgd nejbdst. woidst. iddpdst `ji mest
trd`hgdreus strd`ms ej d`rtg* Ot frdqudjtny evdrfnews. fneeiojb tgd
pn`hoi heujtrysoid fer monds ujton tgd v`nndy rdsdmands `j ojn`ji sd`.
sterm-tessdi `ji `jbry* Ygd Hgojdsd t`ld suhg dvoidjhd ef tgd
ujf`tgem`and h`prohds ef tgd rovdr bei oj rdsobjdi er pgonesepgoh`n
m`jjdr; `s ` wgom ef tgd dndmdjts. evdr wgohg tgdy g`vd je hejtren*
Xe tgdy `hhdpt ot wotg ` sgrub. aury tgdor id`i. `ji rdauoni tgdor
iosm`jtndi gemds `ji tewjs wgohg tgdy rd`nozd must ad idstreydi
`b`oj `jetgdr i`y* Ygdrd `rd fneei hejtren mevdmdjts. aut tgdy g`vd
f`ondi te `hhempnosg muhg* Tjton rdhdjt yd`rs tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds
heuni jet ad pdrsu`idi dvdj te try te st`ji oj tgd w`y ef `j ojdxer`and
bei. adjt ej moshgodf* Ygdy fdnt. `ji stonn fddn. tg`t te ie se os te
rosl `j dvdj brd`tdr vdjbd`jhd*
Ygd _`jbtzd rdm`ojs ujaroibdi te tgos i`y* Frem tgd seurhd
te ots are`i meutg `t tgd sd`. tgdrd os je aroibd `hress ots ompdtueus
hurrdjt* Hejstruhtoej ef ejd os jet ejny pregoaotovd adh`usd ef tgd
h`sgeutn`y ojvenvdi.
aut ot os stonn teei`jbdreus
`kea
oj struhtur`n
djbojddrojb*
Ygd sozd `ji pewdr ef tgd _`jbtzd m`y ad br`spdi wgdj ot os
ljewj tg`t mdj-ef-w`r `s n`rbd `s tgd 03.333-tej T* X* X* Hojhojj`to.
` sd`-beojb nobgt hruosdr. jet ejny h`j aut ie hruosd robgt up tgd
hdjtdr ef Hgoj` `nejb tgos rovdr"s iddp hg`jjdn* Ygd Hojhojj`to spdjt
tgd summdr ef 0?12 `t G`jlew. gdr bujs `iiojb tgdor pretdhtoej te
64
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 66/455
66 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgesd ef bujae`ts ej tgd hustem`ry T* X* _`jbtzd S`tren oj adg`nf ef
@mdroh`j novds `ji prepdrty up tgd rovdr* Ygd hruosdr w`s prd-
vdjtdi fremrdturjojb
te tgd sd` ay new w`tdr iurojb tg`t get. fdtoi
summdr oj tgd G`jlew `rd`* O w`s tgdrd iurojb tgd dxhotojb i`ys `t
tgd dji ef tgd Qusso`j @ivoser`td oj tgd sd`t ef tgd rdvenutoej wgdj
Mol`n Aereioj `ji gos hemr`ids fndi*
My forst trop up tgd _`jbtzd w`s m`id oj tgd n`ttdr p`rt ef tgd
sprojb ef 0?12*+ @ nottnd rovdr std`mdr. tgd X* X* Neejbwe. epdr`tdi
ay ` Arotosg j`vob`tojb `ji tr`iojb hejhdrj. m`id tgd trop wotg ` hej-
vey ef ferdobj w`r-hr`ft. ojhnuiojb @mdroh`j idstreydrs*
Ygd _`jbtzd `t tg`t pdroei oj Hgoj`"s w`rrojb gostery w`s tgd
iovoiojb nojd adtwddj treeps ef tgd Luemojt`jb `ji tgesd ef tgd
Jertgdrj w`r neris* Frem tgd strd`m"s fn`t a`jls tgdy teel pet-sgets
`t d`hg etgdr `ji `t us f @ Hgojdsd hewpr`ierd. er hndrl. g`i addj
lonndi ay ` str`y sget ej tgd prdvoeus trop. `ji tgos areubgt tgd w`r
gemd te tgd hrdw `ji te us* Je ejd w`s gurt ej eur trop. `ntgeubg
wd wdrd ehh`soej`nny ujidr ford*
My fonds sgew jetds `ji hepods ef iosp`thgds wgohg O sdjt a`hl
wgond ej tg`t hruosd ojte tgd gd`rt ef Hgoj` `ji gdr rdvenutoej* Ygdy
`rd rdpreiuhdi gdrd te bovd `j oid` ef wg`t tgd vey`bd w`s nold te `
broffoj 'ndss tg`j ` yd`r oj Hgoj`. `ji `jyejd os ` broffoj te `j eni
Hgoj`-g`ji/. nold mysdnf* Oj ` sdjsd ot w`s nold ` Frdjhgm`j"s
hruosojb up tgd Mossossoppo ej ` Frdjhg ae`t. hejveydi ay Frdjhg
w`r-hr`ft fer mest ef us `mejb tg`t sgop"s hemp`jy hdrt`ojny wdrd
jet Hgojdsd.
Omprdssoejs te my dioter fennew;
_`jbtzd Qovdr X.drohs Je 0*
EJ AE@QI YGD XYD@MDQ NEEJBRE. @pron 13*
F`r `w`y. gobg `moi tgd meujt`ojs ef Yoadt. tg`t eni f`tgdr ef
por`tds. tgd _`jbtzd. adbojs ots rennohlojb. ponn`bojb heursd tgreubg
+O g`i addj ^votg Ygd Tjotdi Srdss @sseho`toejs ej ` rdt`ojdr a`sos* Ygdy
idhoidi oj Jdw _erl te lddp tgd pest tgdrd tgdj ` p`rt-tomd `ssobjmdjt* Ot
w`s n`tdr m`id ` rdbun`r Aurd`u* Frdidrohl Meerd. hgodf ef Ygd Jdw _erlYomds st`ff oj tgd F`r D`st. g`i `nrd`iy effdrdi ` aonndt `s funn tomd herrd-
spejidjt wotg tgdm. `ji ujidr tgd horhumst`jhds O w`s ferhdi te `hhdpt* R`ntdr
Iur`jty h`md `hress Xoadro` frem Meshew `ji w`s st`toejdi tg`t summdr oj
Sdlojb* Frdidrohl Meerd rdm`ojdi `s hgodf `t Xg`jbg`o< `ji O hempndtdi tgos
tgrdd-w`y hevdr`bd sdt-up ay beojb te G`jlew `ji rdpertojb tgd idhnojd ef tgd
Qdis tgdrd* N`tdr. wgdj Mr Meerd `ji Mr Iur`jty ndft. O adh`md tgd hgodf
herrdspejidjt oj Hgoj` fer Ygd Jdw _erl Yomds. rdm`ojojb ujton n`td oj 0?1?*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 67/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 62
Hgoj` te wgdrd. ydnnew wotg neetdi seon. ots are`i meutg. jd`r
Xg`jbg`o. dtdrj`nny fnojbs ots sebby a`jiot"s auridj ojte tgd sd`*
Nd`pojb meujt`oj strd`ms. ndosurdny troaut`rods oj nejb v`nndys
`ji. oj tgd fn`t newn`jis. hrddls `ji tojy rovundts sddpojb te tgdor
ndvdn. hemaojd te `adt `ji strdjbtgdj tgd are`i-hgdstdi eni aro-
b`ji tg`t dx`hts troautd frem g`nf ef @so`*
@ m`jtnd ef rem`jhd. tgohl `s tgd sonldj fenis ef `j epundjt
M`ji`roj"s he`t. goids tgd he`rsd foburd ef tgos reaadr rovdr* Ot
h`jjet ad sddj `s ot os* Ygd _`jbtzd must dvdr ad vdondi oj
tr`iotoej* Xtd`mojb `nejb ots muiiy heursd adtwddj ots fn`t.
hemmejpn`hd a`jls. ejd h`jjet aut rdmdmadr tgd t`nds ef ots
gostery< tg`t tgos rovdr g`s. tgdy s`y. ruj rdi wotg tgd aneei ef
`jhodjt w`rroers `nmest `s eftdj `s ots benidj fneei g`s swdpt
`jbrony evdr tgd newn`jis oj tgd sprojb< tg`t oj tgd pnd`s`jt nofd
ef Hgoj`"s d`rny hunturd. berbdeus prehdssoejs. rohg oj spndjier
wotg tgd areh`id `ji ydnnew beni ef petdjt`tds `ji projhdssds.
aeaadi `nejb tgos gobgw`y< tg`t oj tomds ef hejqudst. stdrj w`r-
hr`ft. m`jjdi ay s`v`bd mdj frem adyeji tgd gonns te tgd wdst.
h`md iewj te r`v`bd `ji hejqudr `ji tgd ojv`idrs t`rrodi.
`ji wdrd `aseradi*
Ygd _`jbtzd. prdiemoj`jtny hrudn. prevds loji te semd*
Xwddpojb `hress tgd newn`jis oj fneei tomds. tgd rovdr. sprd`iojb
g`veh oj ots p`tg. nd`vds ` h`rpdt ef fdrtond sont. `ji tgesd wge
survovd `rd bn`i* Ygdy prespdr*
Srespdrojb. tgdy seubgt m`rldts fer tgdor preiuhts* Oj turj.
tgdy fermdi ` m`rldt fer etgdr preiuhts. tgdsd `brohuntur`n mon-
noejs oj tgd _`jbtzd V`nndy. `ji oj ndss tg`j ` hdjtury tr`idrs
frem tgd Rdst g`vd auont up ` sturiy hemmdrhd wotg tgdsd
pdepnd*
R`r g`s `b`oj terj `t tgd gd`rt ef tg`t hemmdrhd* Qdvenu-
toej adbojjojb oj H`jtej g`s swdpt jertgw`ri. `ji tgd _`jbtzd
tei`y os ` nojd ef idm`rh`toej adtwddj tgd jertg `ji tgd seutg*
Qovdr p`hldts stonn pny ` i`jbdreus tr`id up tgd _`jbtzd* Ygd
jumadr ef rovdr std`mdrs os brewojb std`iony ndss* Ygd m`rldts
up-heujtry `rd iunn `ji st`bj`jt Ygd Hgojdsd `rd `fr`oi te auy*
Ygd `rmods. forst ejd `ji tgdj `jetgdr. hejfosh`td wg`tdvdr tgdy
idsord* Ygd rdvenutoej os hestny*
M`jy mdj-ef-w`r frem j`toejs `are`i `rd pnyojb tgd _`jb-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 68/455
67 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tzd tei`y. oj dvdr ojhrd`sojb jumadrs* Mdrhg`jtmdj g`vd bovdj
w`y. oj tgd m`oj. te w`rsgops ejhd merd* Xtdrj br`y hr`ft
dshert rovdr std`mdrs
up
`ji iewj tgd _`jbtzd. fer seniodrs ef
tgd jertg `ji ef tgd seutg ford ojioshromoj`tdny ej `nn sgoppojb*
Ot os jet. tgdrdferd. wotgeut ` fddnojb ef `ivdjturd tg`t ejd
ae`ris ` rovdr std`mdr tgdsd i`ys `ji dma`rls fer G`jlew. `s O
ioi n`st jobgt* Xg`jbg`o. tg`t wohldidst hoty. tgdy s`y. oj Hgoj`.
os s`fd adgoji tgd nojds ef mdj `ji a`radi word djt`jbndmdjts
`s s`fd `s Jdw _erl otsdnf heuni ad. se f`r `s `tt`hl frem tgd
Hgojdsd os hejhdrjdi* Xg`jbg`o. aunbojb wotg pdepnd. rdfubdds
frem dvdrywgdrd oj tgd ojtdroer. os wdnn bu`ridi* Ygd ferdobjdr
oj Hgoj` `t prdsdjt os. estrohg-nold. goiojb gos gd`i oj tgd s`ji*
Ygd pdepnd ef Xg`jbg`o `rd roiohundi ay tgd ferdobjdr wge novds
ojn`ji* Ygdsd mdj peojt eut tgd futonoty ef dxostdjhd. hemmdr-
ho`nny. oj Hgoj` of ejny ` hoty nold Xg`jbg`o os gdni* Ot"s tgd aeiy
ef tr`id tgdy weuni s`vd*
Mdj nold tgdsd ojn`ji tr`idrs lddp tgd rovdr std`mdrs ruj-
jojb* Soejddrs oj hemmdrhd. tgdy be ojte tgd heujtry `ji sdnn
tgd Hgojdsd beeis `nw`ys ej ` h`sg a`sos oj tgdsd treuandi
tomds. te ad surd. aut tgd peojt os tg`t tgdy sdnn preiuhts frem
`are`i `ji prdvdjt tr`id frem iyojb* Ygdrd `rd twe ef tgdsd
mdj ej ae`ri. tea`hhe mdrhg`jts ej tgdor w`y te Rugu te
str`obgtdj eut tgdor effohd tgdrd `ji te sddl te h`rry ej idspotd
tgd rdvenutoej* Ejd os `j @mdroh`j. tgd iostroht m`j`bdr frem
J`jlojb< tgd etgdr os Arotosg* Ygd n`ttdr g`s addj oj Hgoj` eff
`ji ej fer soxtddj yd`rs* Gd os typoh`n ef tgdsd tr`idrs. spd`ls
tgd n`jbu`bd oj g`nf ` iezdj io`ndhts. g`riy. ` aob fdnnew. `fr`oi
ef jetgojb* Gd g`s kust hemd eut ef Sdjbpu. gd s`oi. beojb
jertg ay tr`oj te Yodjtsoj `ji tgdjhd seutg te Xg`jbg`o ay ae`t*
@ji tgdj. str`obgt `w`y a`hl ojte tgd tgohl ef ot* Gos dxpdro-
djhds weuni fonn ` n`rbd venumd*
Ygd Neejbwe. shgdiundi te s`on `t moijobgt n`st jobgt.
foj`nny bet ujidr w`y `t `aeut tgrdd e"hnehl tgos merjojb* Ygd
Arotosg s`oners ej bu`ri frem tgd fn`bsgop G`wlojs p`trennojb
tgd iehl `ji tgd std`mdr. wgond ojsprojb ` fddnojb ef hemp`r`tovd
s`fdty. `nse wdrd hejst`jt rdmojidrs tg`t tgos trop up-rovdr w`s
jet dx`htny tgd s`fdst tgojb oj tgd werni kust `t prdsdjt* O w`s
surprosdi te foji tgd std`mdr jd`rny funn* @ str`jbd pdrsej oj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 69/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 6?
my h`aoj wotg md spd`ls ejny Qusso`j `ji ` fdw. ` vdry fdw.
weris ef Bdrm`j* Ygdrd `rd. `s ` m`ttdr ef f`ht. `aeut ` iezdj
Qusso`js ejae`ri.
`nn aeuji fer
G`jlew<feur er fovd Hgojdsd
oj forst h`aoj< my twe tea`hhe mdrhg`jt frodjis. ` Hemm`jidr
R`ri hemojb eut frem Djbn`ji te t`ld ` pest ej tgd Arotosg
hruosdr Vojiohtovd jew `t G`jlew< `ji ` H`tgenoh prodst*
Hn`madrojb ojte my aujl sgertny `ftdr moijobgt. O w`s seej
`snddp. idspotd tgd sgronn hrods ef tgd wg`rf heenods `ji tgdor
st`hh`te sojb-sejb hg`jt `s tgdy ne`idi h`rbe ojte tgd geni* Ygd
ge`rsdan`st ef tgd
feb gerj `w`ldjdi md sdvdr`n geursn`tdr* O
pddrdi eut ojte tgd mosts* Ygd i`wj w`s ird`r* Sg`jtem sgops
iroftdi snewny p`st oj tgd sdmo-twonobgt ef tgd jdw i`y* O sndpt
ujton moimerjojb `ji tgdj. iezojb. nostdjdi te tgd str`jbd jeosds
`reuji md ; tgd swosg ef swornojb w`tdr `b`ojst tgd sgop"s soids<
tgd new gum ef tgd djbojds< semdejd oj tgd s`neej pn`yojb
Ygdrd"s ` Nejb. Nejb Yr`on @-wojiojb< veohds ej tgd premdj`id
idhleutsoid<
sj`thgds ef hejvdrs`toej; neelsprdtty a`i.*
* *
H`jtejdsd g`vd addj.* * * ausojdss * * * tdrroand * * * i`jbdreus
* * * bn`i tgdsd w`rsgops `rd8
+* * * *
O wdjt eut ej idhl* Rd wdrd stuhl oj tgd mui* Ygd toid
w`s beojb eut* Ywe etgdr sgops `ji ` rovdr bujae`t wdrd
sobgtdi eff eur stdrj. sddj iomny tgreubg tgd most* Ygd woji
andw ` b`nd* Ywe geurs n`tdr wd bet eff semdgew. `ftdr djindss
m`jduvdrojb* Ygdetgdr vdssdns g`i
bejd`gd`i ` nottnd `ji
w`otdi fer us* O. fer ejd. w`s bn`i te g`vd tg`t @mdroh`j buj-
ae`t `nejb* Eur breup ef feur sgops 'wd pohldi up `jetgdr
iurojb tgd `ftdrjeej/ m`id snew spddi* Ejd sgop heuni ejny ie
dobgt ljets. `ji tg`t gdni a`hl tgd wgend prehdssoej*
Ygd i`y werd ej* Hemm`jidr R`ri. tgd twe tea`hhe
mdrhg`jts `ji mysdnf. `ji. oj ` w`y. tgd S`ird%" tgrewj merd
er ndss tebdtgdr ay eur hemmej ojtdrdsts `ji n`jbu`bd. fermdi` aot ef ` hnoqud* Ygd S`ird. ` nottnd hg`p wotg gerj-rommdi
spdht`hnds. w`s ferdvdr pddrojb `t tgd sgerd tgreubg ` p`or ef
aojehun`rs* Gd `jjeujhdi `aeut tgrdd e"hnehl tgd sobgtojb ef
` breup ef Hgojdsd w`rsgops*
Ygdrd wdrd feur ef tgdm oj `nn* Ygd @mdroh`j bujae`t
Sd`ry. wgohg g`i addj kust `nejbsoid tgd Neejbwe. sgevdi `gd`i
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 70/455
23 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
` nottnd `s wd irdw jd`r* Ygd Hgojdsd. fnyojb tgd H`jtejdsd fn`b.
wdrd nojdi up oj ` rew* Ygd pn`hd os ljewj `s tgd Hressre`is.
ot adojb `t tgd meutg ef ` troaut`ry te tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr* D`hg
ioppdi gdr fn`b oj rdpny te eur s`nutd ef ` somon`r j`turd `s wd
p`ssdi* Ygos w`s tgd ejny dvoidjhd ef w`r tgd wgend i`y nejb*
@soid frem eur hejvey `ji tgdsd sgops. `ji tgd f`ht tg`t eur
std`mdr g`s qu`rtdr-ojhg orej pn`tds nojdi up `nn `reuji tgd idhl
`s `rmer `b`ojst ford frem dotgdr sgerd. wd mobgt `s wdnn g`vd
addj std`mojb up tgd Mossossoppo Qovdr* Jet ` seniodr ioi wd
sobgt `nn tgd forst i`y up tgd rovdr*
_`jbtzd Qovdr Xdrods Je* 1*
EJ AE@QI YGD X* X* NEEJBRE. _`jbtzd Qovdr.
@pron 10* @ m`j j`mdi G* H* Fdnnojb wge g`s addj. gd s`ys.
oj Hgoj` fer merd tg`j soxtddj yd`rs. eff `ji ej. s`t `t iojjdr
ej tgos std`mdr n`st jobgt `ji p`ojtdi `s iosm`n ` pohturd ef tgd
Hgojdsd pdepnd `s ejd heuni wdnn om`bojd*
Ygd m`j. ` tea`hhe mdrhg`jt aerj oj Nejiej `ji oj tgd
dmpney ef `j @mdroh`j erb`joz`toej. speld ef hrudnty ioffohunt
te hejhdovd* Gd teni t`nds ef tgd gdnn tgd Rgotd Qusso`j seniodrs
g`vd addj tgreubg < ef Hgojdsd seniodrs wge. t`lojb etgdr Hgojdsd
`ji Qusso`js prosejdrs. g`vd sdt tgdor h`ptovds `fn`md `ftdr
peurojb ldresdjd evdr tgdor hnetgojb*
Ejd pepun`r mdtgei ef terturd. gd s`oi. os ljewj `s
bovojb tgd vohtom "tgd tgeus`ji huts*" Mdj `rd hut `nn evdr tgdor
aeiods. d`hg hut tee sm`nn te ad f`t`n aut djeubg te ad dxhddi-
ojbny p`ojfun* Ygd vohtoms novd fer i`ys < semdtomds. adferd tgdy
foj`nny foji rdnodf oj id`tg*
O g`vd `nse sddj wemdj terturdi gerroany. tgdor ard`sts
hut eff. semd vohtoms aurjdi. ejd slojjdi `novd* _eu g`vd je
oid` wg`t os beojb ej oj tgd ojtdroer iurojb tgdsd w`rs* Ot os
frobgtfun*
Rg`t tgd wemdj ef Hgoj` g`vd suffdrdi. gd s`ys. tgd werni
wonn jdvdr ljew* Ygdy must suffdr wotgeut pretdst. tgdsd Hgo-
jdsd metgdrs ef tgd mdj wge ponn`bd tgdor ewj pdepnd frem ejd
yd`r"s dji te tgd jdxt*
Ygdy kump oj tgd wdnns oj fr`jtoh dfferts te dsh`pd tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 71/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 20
seniodrs. Fdnnojb s`oi* Eftdj. wd g`vd addj uj`and te bdt w`tdr
adh`usd tgd wdnns g`vd addj funn ef id`i wemdj `ji hgonirdj*
Ygd mdrhg`jts jdvdr ljew wgdj tgdy m`y jdxt nesd tgdor
djtord stehl* O ljew ef ejd m`j. `ji gos h`sd os typoh`n. wge
nest dvdrytgojb gd g`i ejhd ` yd`r tgrdd yd`rs rujjojb* _dt
gd st`rtdi up `b`oj d`hg tomd* Ot os m`rvdneus tgd w`y tgdy
stohl te ot* _dt wg`t h`j tgd peer idvons ie5
Fdnnojb idshroadi gew tgdy bdt tgdor `rmods. tgdsd Hgojdsd
w`r neris wge g`vd addj tgd hursd ef tgd j`toej sojhd tgd 0?00
rdvenutoej*
Xuppesd. gd s`oi. ""Bdjdr`n Hg`jb Hgujb-hg`jb w`jts 93.-
333 mdj eut ef Xg`jtujb prevojhd* Gd sdjis eut `j eridr fer
tg`t m`jy treeps* Ygd prevojhd os iovoidi ojte iostrohts* D`hg
iostroht g`s ` gd`im`j* Ygd gd`im`j ef tgd iostroht `ivosds tgd
gd`imdj ef tgd v`roeus hotods `ji tewjs `ji vonn`bds oj gos `rd`
tg`t tgdy must preiuhd se m`jy seniodrs ay ` hdrt`oj i`td*
Ygd vonn`bd er hoty gd`im`j h`nns ` mddtojb ef tgd gd`is
ef `nn tgd f`monods oj gos tewj* Gd tdnns tgdm gew m`jy mdj
tgd hoty must preiuhd* Ygdj tgdy pre-r`td tgd tgojb* @ f`mony
wotg tgrdd aeys sdjis twe. ejd wotg feur sdjis tgrdd. `ji se ej*
Ygdy jdvdr t`ld ` sej of gd os tgd ejny aey oj tgd f`mony* Ygd
Hgojdsd `rd vdry stroht ej tgd f`mony systdm* Ygdrd must ad
`j gdor*
Oj ` fdw i`ys yeu g`vd yeur "`rmy" ef 93.333 mdj* Ygdy
`rd tr`ojdi ` vdry sgert wgond `ji tgdj sdjt ojte a`ttnd* Yg`t
os gew yeu bdt yeur "venujtddr `rmods" oj Hgoj`* Ygd seniodrs
`rd. oj tgd m`oj. ojdxpdrodjhdi `ji tgdy h`j"t fobgt* Oj ` a`ttnd.
tgdy `rd `s noldny `s jet te turj `ji ruj fer ot `jy tomd tgdy
tgojl tgdy `rd bdttojb tgd werst ef ot* Ygdy g`vd je stem`hg fer
fobgtojb* Ygdy `rd `fr`oi* Ygdy `rd dvdj `fr`oi te quot tgd
`rmy* Tp `b`ojst `jy rd`n eppesotoej tgdy ruj nold r`aaots.
tgesd fdnnews*
Ot sddms te ad trud tg`t tgdy ie. tee* Ot os sobjofoh`jt te jetd
tg`t tgd J`toej`nost rdvenutoej g`s hemd te tgd _`jbtzd `nmest
wotgeut eppesotoej* Ygdy teel Xg`jbg`o wotgeut ` strubbnd*
J`jlojb w`s dxpdhtdi te ad ` a`ttnd* Ot w`s ` Jertgdrj reut*
Ejd wejidrs wg`t weuni g`ppdj of tgd Jertgdrjdrs wdrd te fobgt
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 72/455
21 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`ji woj ` vohtery* Fdnnojb adnodvds tgd Xeutgdrjdrs weuni ruj
kust `s quohlny*
Ef heursd. gd s`oi. tgd J`toej`nosts `rd ` aot ioffdrdjt*
Ygdy"vd bet ` h`usd te fobgt fer* Ygdy sddm te g`vd ` nottnd merd
sporot tg`j tgd Jertgdrj seniodrs*
Fdnnojb g`skust hemd eut ef Sdjbpu. jertg ef J`jlojb ej tgd
Sulew-Yodjtsoj r`onw`y nojd* Gd s`oi tgd Jertgdrjdrs g`vd
neetdi tg`t hoty tgereubgny* Ygd nessds `rd djermeus te Hgo-
jdsd `s wdnn `s te ferdobj forms. gd s`oi*
_`jbtzd Qovdr Xdrods Je* 8
EJ AE@QI YGD X* X* NEEJBRE. _`jbtzd Qovdr.
@pron 10* O ojtdrvodwdi tgd n`st wgotd wem`j oj Hgojlo`jb te-
i`y* Xgd os Mrs* A* M* Xmotg. `j @mdroh`j. tgd wofd ef `
Xt`ji`ri Eon Hemp`jy m`j wge os h`rryojb ej oj Hgojlo`jb*
Mrs* Xmotg ioij"t g`vd muhg te s`y* Xgd s`oi ot os jet
i`jbdreus oj Hgojlo`jb* Jet `s muhg `s ejd mobgt tgojl.
`jyw`y* Xgd `ji Mr* XmotgAdtty `ji Aruhd. tgdy `rd. `
g`ppy yeujb p`or m`rrodi jet vdry nejb novd ej ` n`ujhg kust
`nejbsoid tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon ojst`nn`toej oj Hgojlo`jb* Ygdrd osj"t
` wgotd m`j. wem`j er hgoni ej sgerd*
Rd iej"t g`vd suhg ` a`i tomd. Mrs* Xmotg s`oi* Rd
ljew `nn tgd J`vy mdj gdrd. `ji wd usu`nny iojd ej ae`ri tgd
@mdroh`j bujae`t* Ot rd`nny osj"t `s a`i `s yeu mobgt tgojl*
Jet se beei. dotgdr. `t tg`t. `ji sgd n`ubgdi ` aot* Fer `
yeujb bornnold Mrs* Xmotg. Hgojlo`jb effdrs vdry fdw `ttr`h-
toejs `t prdsdjt* Ot os r`tgdr iunn jet adojb `and te be `sgerd*
@ji tgd horhnd ef ferdobjdrs os. dvdj wotg tgd J`vy. aetg Arotosg
`ji @mdroh`j 'tgdrd w`s ejd bujae`t ef d`hg gdrd tei`y/.
r`tgdr sm`nn*
Mrs* Xmotg w`s hgodfny ojtdrdstdi oj gdr m`on* Ygd tr`ojs
te Xg`jbg`o ruj jew `ji tgdj `ji tgd rovdr ae`ts arojb m`on
twohd ` wddl. se tgdy `rd jet se eut ef teuhg wotg tgd werni*
Xgd os frem Aojbg`mtej. Jdw _erl `ji `imots tg`t `t tomds
sgd weunij"t moji adojb a`hl tgdrd* Ot sddmdi mest ojhejbrueus
te foji tgos born. aeaadi g`or. johd dyds `ji wd`rojb tgd n`tdst
tgojb oj ` snddvdndss spert irdss. ar`vdny stohlojb ot eut wotg
gdr gusa`ji. novojb ej ` nottnd n`ujhg*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 73/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 28
Ygd Neejbwe `rrovdi `t Hgojlo`jb sgertny `ftdr jeej tei`y*
Ygd i`y w`s pdrfdht. w`rm. tgd suj sgojojb oj ` sly idveoi
ef hneuis* @aeut 00;83 `* m* wd s`w eur forst seniodrs. ` fdw
gdrd `ji tgdrd ej tgd jertg a`jl* Ygdy wdrd M`rsg`n Xuj
Hgu`j-f`jb"s mdj. `s ejd heuni tdnn ay tgdor br`y ujoferms `ji
tgd nottnd g`ts tgdy wd`r* Ygdy `rd nold Qeaoj Geei g`ts. pd`ldi
`ji wotg sn`jtojb aonns* @nn tgdy n`hl os ` hehly nottnd fd`tgdr*
Aut tgdy ie jet neel vdry hehly. tgdsd fdnnews* Ygdy g`vd vdry
nottnd sporot. te s`y tgd nd`st* Jejd ef tgdm fordi* Fertrdssds
ej tgd seutg a`jl neeldi emojeus. tgdor bujs tr`ojdi ej tgd
rovdr. aut jetgojb g`ppdjdi*
Hgojlo`jb os jet ` vdry n`rbd hoty* Ot nods sh`ttdrdi `nejb
tgd w`tdrfrejt. ` geibd-peibd ef geusds evdrsg`iewdi `t tgd d`st
dji ef tgd hoty ay tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon pn`jt* Rd h`md `nejbsoid
tgd K`rimd-M`tgdsej Hemp`jy"s gunl wgdrd `j eni rdsoidjt. `
Arotosg rdprdsdjt`tovd ef tgd sgoppojb hemp`jy. teni us jeaeiy
os ndft ej sgerd `t `nn* Gd. nold tgd rdst ef tgd nottnd hemmujoty.
os novojb ej ae`ri tgd gunl* @nn novd oj ae`ts*
Ywe tea`hhe mdrhg`jts ej ae`ri tgd Neejbwe ljdw tgd eon
mdrhg`jt. se O keojdi tgdm `ji reid evdr oj tgdor n`ujhg te h`nn*
Xmotg. tgd eon m`j. s`oi tg`t gd os stonn ieojb ` nottnd ausojdss*
Rd idm`ji h`sg ej idnovdry. gewdvdr%" gd s`oi* Ejny w`y
wd h`j ie ot* Gd s`oi tgdrd w`sj"t muhg te ie. aut ojsostdi
tg`t ""ausojdss os rd`nny r`tgdr beei. idspotd tgd w`r `ji eur h`sg
rdquordmdjts*
Ot sddms tg`t @mdroh`js `rd bdttojb tgd Arotosg tr`id* Ygd
fddnojb `b`ojst tgd Arotosg os r`tgdr gobg dvdrywgdrd. `ji tgdrd
`rd pdrsostdjt dfferts te aeyhett `nn Arotosg beeis*
Fer semd rd`sej. wd spdjt tgd jobgt oj Hgojlo`jb g`raer*
N`st jobgt wd spdjt `jhgerdi oj moistrd`m* Ygd rovdr ae`ts ie
jet. ot sddms. tr`vdn `t jobgt jew* Ot os ejny ` fdw geurs" ruj
up te J`jlojb frem gdrd aut wd wdrd uj`and te bdt ujidr w`^
d`rny djeubg oj tgd `ftdrjeej. iud te ejd tgojb `ji `jetgdr wotg
tgd bujae`ts `ji eur h`rbe< se tgd sloppdr idhoidi te rdm`oj
`nn jobgt* @b`oj O wdjt fer ` roid `reuji tgd g`raer wotg tgd
tea`hhe mdrhg`jts. tgos adojb `pp`rdjtny quotd s`fd idspotd tgd
w`rnold `ttotuid ef tgd J`toej`nost treeps `nejb tgd Auji* @t
iusl. wd h`nli ej tgd Xmotgs ejhd merd `ji tgdrd mdt `j
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 74/455
29 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
effohdr frem tgd @mdroh`j bujae`t S`un Kejds. st`toejdi gdrd*
Gd s`oi dvdrytgojb g`i addj r`tgdr quodt rdhdjtny* Gos hgodf
hempn`ojt. wgdj gd feuji eut wge O w`s. w`s tg`t Ygd Jdw
_erl Yomds w`s jet adojb idnovdrdi ujton `t nd`st twe mejtgs
`ftdr i`td ef puanoh`toej*
M`rto`n n`w beds ojte dffdht `t sox e"hnehl. aut wd wdrd pdr-
mottdi te st`y eut `ftdr tg`t tomd* Ygd suj s`jl `ji `ftdr `
twonobgt jet tdj mojutds nejb. i`rljdss fdnn evdr tgd g`raer*
Rd teel tgd S`un Kejds effohdr a`hl te gos sgop `ji tgdj hgubbdi
a`hl te tgd Neejbwe fer tgd jobgt
_`jbtzd Qovdr Xdrods Je* 9*
EJ AE@QI YGD X* X* NEEJBRE. J@JLOJB. @pron
11* Rd g`i eur a`ptosm ef ford tgos merjojb* Xeniodrs ej tgd
seutg a`jl `ji. ` nottnd furtgdr ej. ej tgd jertg jet f`r frem
J`jlojb. ndtfny `t us ojioshromoj`tdny* Ygdor `om. fertuj`tdny.
w`s a`i* Jejd ef us w`s got. je aunndts. `s f`r `s O g`vd
nd`rjdi. strolojb `jy ef tgd std`mdrs oj eur `ivdjtureus qu`rtdt
ef feur rovdr ae`ts* Eur hejvey. tgd @mdroh`j bujae`t S`un
Kejds. `nse w`s ujteuhgdi*
Ygd S`un Kejds rdturjdi tgd ford frem tgd seutg a`jl wotg
` arodf spurt ef m`hgojd buj ford* Ygdrd w`s je furtgdr sgeetojb*
Ej ae`ri. jejd w`s dxhotdi. `ntgeubg tgd Hgojdsd aeys wdrd
ojhnojdi te ad ` aot frobgtdjdi* Ygdy n`y fn`t ej tgd idhl wgdr-
dvdr tgdy g`ppdjdi te ad* Ejd ydstdri`y. oj f`ht. wgdj wd
wdrd p`ssojb tgd ferts adnew Hgojlo`jb. ireppdi tgd iosgds gd
w`s sdrvojb `t t`and `ji r`j fer tgd b`nndy. tgdrd te keoj gos
fdnnews prejd ej tgd idhl* Gd dxpn`ojdi tg`t tg`t w`s eridrs.
sojhd tgd Hgojdsd hempr`ierd g`i addj sget id`i ej tgd prd-
voeus trop*
Ygd p`ssdjbdrs wdrd pdrmottdi te ie `s tgdy pnd`sdi* O rd-
m`ojdi. fer tgd mest p`rt. ojsoid my h`aoj iurojb tgd forojb* Xe
ioi mest ef us* @ fdw ar`vdny feenosg seuns teel ` turj `aeut tgd
premdj`id idhl* Ygdy ieibdi `ftdr d`hg sget. ojvenujt`rony* Rd
wdrd. gewdvdr. prdtty s`fd ojsoid eur w`nn ef `rmer pn`td*
J`jlojb. hrewj kdwdn ef tgd _`jbtzd. n`y bnostdjojb `t jeej
oj tgd w`rm sprojb sujsgojd* Ygd g`raer. tgd Auji. Gso`-lw`j.
` suaura. `nn wdrd idsdrtdi. jet ` seun ojsobgt*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 75/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 24
Rd std`mdi r`poiny p`st oj moistrd`m* Ej tgd jertgdrj
a`jl. tgd tewj ef Sulew strdthgdi ots r`msg`hlnd `hrd`bd gdrd
`ji tgdrd `nejb tgd rovdr* @t tg`t peojt yejidr. ` std`mdr n`y
sujl* Ot w`s tgd vdssdn. O `m teni. ej wgohg M`i`md M* Aer-
eioj. wofd ef tgd Qusso`j `ivosdr te tgd J`toej`nosts `t G`jlew.
w`s rdhdjtny t`ldj h`ptovd* Ots st`rl m`sts stuhl top ojte tgd
anud `t ` hr`zy `jbnd* Rd foj`nny adrtgdi ` mond er merd adyeji
J`jlojb oj moistrd`m* Rd wdrd eppesotd tgd Arotosg w`rsgop
Dmdr`ni. nyojb eff adtwddj us `ji tgd jertg a`jl* Ygd Tjotdi
Xt`tds bujae`t S`un Kejds. st`toejdi `t Hgojlo`jb. rdturjdi tgdrd*
Ygd Feri punndi ojte ` adrtg kust `aevd tgd Dmdr`ni* Furtgdr
ej. ` K`p`jdsd bujae`t n`y tgrdd w`rsgops oj `nn*
Ygd rd`sej wd ioi jet tod up `t J`jlojb w`s tg`t ojtdrmottdjt
forojb adtwddj J`jlojb `ji Sulew w`s beojb ej `ji ot w`s
hejsoidrdi tee i`jbdreus te rdm`oj oj tgd nojd ef ford* Ygd
Jertgdrjdrs. se s`oi effohdrs frem tgd Dmdr`ni wge h`md `ae`ri
te sdd `aeut bdttojb prevosoejs. g`vd ` beei net ef gd`vy `rton-
ndry* D`hg merjojb tgdy str`fd tgd Xeutgdrjdrs oj J`jlojb.
`ji tgd Xeutgdrjdrs rdpny* Ygd aeem ef `rtonndry heuni ad gd`ri
frem tomd te tomd `s wd nujhgdi. `ji `j ehh`soej`n r`ttnd ef
rofnd ford `iidi te tgd w`r jeosds oj tgd g`raer* Ot os ieuatfun
wgdtgdr dotgdr soid ioi muhg i`m`bd oj tgdor forojb*
J`jlojb frem tgd std`mdr w`s ujh`jjy oj ots idsdrtoej `ji
quodt* Rg`t must usu`nny ad ` ausy g`raer w`s swdpt hnd`j
dvdj ef ots s`mp`js* Ygdsd n`st sw`rmdi `reuji us `ji tgd
etgdr rovdr std`mdrs oj irevds. s`fd oj eur hemp`jy. tgd mosdr`and
heenods sddlojb ` f`rd. `nms. `jytgojb te d`rj ` fdw heppdrs*
Ygdors os ` serry pnobgt*
Sulew. ots a`hl te ` nejb. new r`jbd ef meujt`ojs. w`s tee
f`r `w`y te ad sddj hnd`rny. dvdj wotg fodni bn`ssds* J`jlojb
wd heuni vodw quotd pn`ojny* Ywe J`toej`nost bujae`ts. tojy fdn-
news. std`mdi snewny up tgd hrddl eutsoid tgd hoty"s w`nn* Ygdtea`hhe mdrhg`jt. wge g`s novdi oj J`jlojb. peojtdi eut tgd
pn`hds ef ojtdrdst*
Xdd tg`t geusd ej tgd gonn. `w`y a`hl tgdrd. oj nojd wotg
tg`t smeld st`hl5 Rdnn. gd s`oi. tg`t"s Xehejy Geusd* Yg`t
os wgdrd tgd ferdobjdrs b`tgdrdi `ji tgd @mdroh`j `ji Arotosg
bujae`ts aema`ridi tgd pn`hd se tgdy heuni dsh`pd* Qobgt `nejb
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 76/455
26 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
tgdrd ej tgd jdxt gonn os tgd A@Y* geusd 'Arotosg-`ji-@mdr-
oh`j Yea`hhe Hemp`jy/. `ji furtgdr `nejb`ji gd teni md ef
pn`hds ef ojtdrdst* @nn tgdsd geusds. twe monds er merd `w`y
`hress tgd fn`t newn`jis. wdrd oj pn`oj vodw frem tgd rovdr*
Ygd an`hl nojd ef J`jlojb"s hoty w`nn rujs `j ujhdrt`oj heursd
fer monds `nejb tgd rovdr. pdrg`ps ` mond er se a`hl frem tgd
Auji* J`jlojb frem tgd rovdr ieds jet bovd `j omprdssoej ef
sozd er ef p`rtohun`r ad`uty* Ots meidrj auoniojbs oj tgd auso-
jdss sdhtoej ndji ` hdrt`oj spohl-`ji-sp`j-jdss te tgd pn`hd. `ji
ots w`nn rdh`nns tgd spndjier ef `jetgdr i`y Aut dvdj se. my
omprdssoej w`s ef `jytgojb aut `wd* J`jlojb `s ` tgojb ef
ad`uty. sddj frem moistrd`m. wonn jet n`st ferdvdr*
Ywe yeujb Arotosg effohdrs frem tgd Dmdr`ni h`md ej ae`ri.
ejd te bdt tgd prevosoejs. tgd etgdr `ftdr tgd m`on Aetg wdrd
n`is ydt oj tgdor tddjs. resy-hgddldi aeys wotg ` sdroeus `or. johd
yeujb fdnnews. str`jbdny yeutgfun fer tgdor hgdvrejs* Ygd mdj.
eni djeubg te ad tgdor f`tgdrs. `jswdrdi wotg ` sor. te d`hg
qudry `ji wdrd hempndtdny rdspdhtfun*
Ot w`s twe e"hnehl adferd wd bet ujidr w`y `b`oj. tgos tomd
`nejd* Ygd etgdr tgrdd std`mdrs g`i bejd `gd`i wotg eur hej-
vey* Ot sddms tgdrd os nottnd te fd`r `nejb tgd reutd adtwddj gdrd
`ji Rugu* Ygreubgeut tgd `ftdrjeej tgd seutg a`jl w`s iet-
tdi frem tomd te tomd wotg seniodrs w`nlojb `aeut `moi tgdor
iojby nottnd mui-gut a`rr`hls. tg`thgdi reefs ydnnew `b`ojst tgd
brddj fodnis ef br`oj* Rd s`w je Jertgdrjdrs tgd wgend `ftdr-
jeej. aut tgd Jertg genis dvdrytgojb robgt up te tgd _`jbtzd.
frem `nn rdperts* Ygdy hemd te tgd rovdr wgdjdvdr tgdy pnd`sd.
t`ld ` fdw pet-sgets 'aetg soids ford ej ferdobj vdssdns wotgeut
ioshromoj`toej/ `ji be tgdor w`y `b`oj*
I`rljdss g`i sdttndi evdr tgd rovdr wgdj wd rd`hgdi Rugu.
ej tgd seutg a`jl. `aeut dobgt e"hnehl* Eur drstwgond hem-
p`joejs g`i rd`hgdi pert adferd us `ji tgdrd wdrd je adrtgs
ndft* Rd `jhgerdi oj moistrd`m `b`oj fer tgd jobgt* Ygd Rugu
g`raer w`s ` ausy pn`hd wotg feur rovdr std`mdrs `rrovojb* Xob-
j`ns fn`sgdi frem tgd bujae`ts `ji tgd hruosdr H`r`ieh. j`v`n
meterae`ts peppdi `aeut. twe h`nnojb te ojquord `s te eur wdn-
f`rd `ji tgd Arotosg te nd`vd `j `rmdi bu`ri ej ae`ri wotg
ojstruhtoejs te lddp `nn seniodrs eff tgos sgop
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 77/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 22
Ygd fdw rdm`ojojb ferdobjdrs. O nd`rjdi frem tgd effohdrs ef
tgdsd meterae`ts. `rd novojboj sgops oj tgd g`raer* Ygdy be
`sgerd iurojb tgd i`y aut rdturj `t jobgt te tgdor fne`tojb gemds*
Ygd Hgojdsd g`vd iejd ` nottnd neetojb. aut ot sddms tg`t tgdy g`vd
rdturjdi tgd Qdhrd`toej Hnua te tgd ferdobjdrs. mevojb tgd
treeps a`rr`hldi tgdrd te etgdr aonndts* @soid frem `j ehh`soej`n
dffert te ae`ri rovdr std`mdrs `ji be dnsdwgdrd. tgd J`toej`nost
treeps g`vd `pp`rdjtny h`usdi nottnd treuand* Ygrdd trodi te ie
tg`t ydstdri`y. tgd yeujb Arotosg effohdr rdm`rldi* Ygdy wdrd
snobgtny weujidi wotg a`yejdts wgond tgd s`oners ojsostdi tg`t
tgdy rdm`oj `sgerd*
Nobgts iewj. `jhgerdi oj moistrd`m wotg `j `rmdi bu`ri
ej ae`ri te pretdht us. eur sgop"s hemp`jy turjdi oj tejobgt
wotg ` fddnojb ef hemp`r`tovd sdhuroty* Rg`t heuni 13.333 H`j-
tejdsd seniodrs ie oj ` h`sd nold tg`t5 Jetgojb* Oj f`ht. eur
hgodf hempn`ojt os n`hl ef jdws frem tgd eutsoid werni* @soid
frem ` weri gdrd `ji tgdrd frem tgdsd yeutgfun effohdrs wge
bdt ot frem tgdor j`v`n r`ioe iosp`thgds `ji tgdsd jet `nw`ys
`hhur`td `ji jdvdr wotg `jy idt`on wd `rd hempndtdny hut eff*
Ygd bdjdr`n omprdssoej sddms te ad tg`t tgd Jertg hejtrens dvdry-
tgojb robgt up te tgd _`jbtzd ejhd merd `ji tg`t tgd J`toej`nosts
`rd geniojb ej te tgdor pesotoejs ej tgd seutg a`jl* Ygd Hem-
mujosts `pp`rdjtny hejtojud te geni tgd iemoj`jt pesotoej oj
G`jlew*
_`jbtzd Qovdr Xhrods Je* 4*
EJ AE@QI YGD X* X* NEEJBRE. RTGT. @pron 18*
Ygos g`s addj `j oind i`y ej ae`ri tgd Nehjbwe* Ygd heenods
g`vd addj ausy djeubg ujne`iojb h`rbe `ji ne`iojb etgdr stuff
fer up-rovdr wotg ` tdrrofoh sgeutojb `ji ioj tgd wgend i`y nejb*
Ygd p`ssdjbdrs. ferhdi te rdm`oj `ae`ri. oindi `aeut tgd idhl.
rd`iojb `ji frdttojb `t tgd idn`y*
Ygd twe tea`hhe mdrhg`jts ndft us gdrd* Ejd. G* H* Fdnnojb.
os rdm`ojojb oj Rugu* Ygd etgdr. ` hg`p frem Aestej j`mdi
Fendy. os rdturjojb te Xg`jbg`o ej tgd jdxt ae`t. tgd Yuhlwe.
wgohg os iud te s`on iewjstrd`m temerrew. Xuji`y* Fendy os
t`lojb my iosp`thgds te Xg`jbg`o wgdrd tgdy `rd te ad rdn`ydi*
Ygdrd os je etgdr w`y ef bdttojb tgdm eut frem up gdrd `t
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 78/455
27 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
prdsdjt* Hemmujoh`toejs `rd ompessoand* Dvdj of ejd heuni
bdt te tgd tdndbr`pg effohd s`fdny. ot os ieuatfun wgdtgdr tgd mds-
s`bd weuni bdt tgreubg wotgoj tgrdd er feur i`ys* @ji tgdj
ot weuni ieuatndss adsuakdhtdi
te tgd strohtdst hdjsersgop*
Ygd forst jdws ef wg`t os beojb ej `reuji us h`md tgreubg
tei`y oj tgd ferm ef ` h`raej hepy ef tgd @mdroh`j Sr.dss word-
ndss lojiny bovdj us ay tgd h`pt`oj ef tgd Arotosg hruosdr gdrd.
tgd H`r`ieh* Gd `nse teni us tgd jdws ef tgd untom`tum ef tgd
Sewdrs wgohg. ot sddms. g`s addj g`jidi G`jlew* Gd w`s jet
surd wgdtgdr er jet ` somon`r iehumdjt g`i addj g`jidi Bdjdr`n
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `t J`jlojb* Furtgdrmerd. wd gd`ri tg`t tgd
`nnods g`vd bovdj eridrs te tgdor h`pt`ojs ef tgd _`jbtzd p`tren
te rdpny wotg `nn tgdy"vd bet te `jy furtgdr forojb frem dotgdr
sgerd* Ot sddms tgdy jew ojtdji te step tgos pn`yfun g`not ef tgd
Hgojdsd seniodrs*
Ygd Neejbwe iehldi `nejbsoid tgd gunl `aeut i`wj. `ji wd
wdrd `w`ldjdi te tgd `m`zojb turmeon tg`t ejny ` sm`nn a`ji
ef Hgojdsd heenods h`j m`ld* Ygd g`ridr tgdy werl tgd merd
tgdy sgeut. tgdsd fdnnews* Adbb`rs oj s`mp`js `ji ejd `htu`nny
oj `j eanejb weeidj tua wotg weeidj sgevdns fer e`rs sw`rmdi
`reuji tgd std`mdr. `iiojb tgdor sgronn hrods te tgd guaaua*
@aevd ot `nn w`s `j ehh`soej`n sgeutojb fer `nn tgd werni nold
tgd jeosd gd`ri ej `ppre`hgojb ` feeta`nn st`ioum `t gemd wgdj
ejd os. gewdvdr. stonn semd anehls `w`y frem tgd b`md*
Ygos. ot turjdi eut. w`s ` seuji m`id ay hemp`jods ef H`j-
tejdsd seniodrs ironnojbej tgd Auji. jet ` gujirdi y`ris frem
eur sgop* Ygd seniodrs. wgend hemp`jods ef tgdm. sgeutdi tgdor
effohdr"s hemm`ji oj ujosej `s tgdy seubgt te dxdhutd tgd eridr*
Feur er fovd hemp`jods wdrd m`rhgojb `aeut ironnojb. `ji vdry
a`iny. tee* Gdrd `ji tgdrd ej tgd brddj p`r`id-breuji etgdrs
sojbny. er oj squ`is ef feur er sox. st`nldi `aeut ieojb tgd beesd-
stdp
Er r`tgdr. ` H`jtejdsd vdrsoej ef tg`t Bdrm`j dxdrhosd
fer treeps wgohg w`s str`jbd te easdrvd* Mest ef tgdm adjt tgd
ljdd se tg`t tgdy b`vd tgd omprdssoej ef ` horhus gersd tgd ejd
tg`t tgd rojbm`stdr tdnns tgd neh`n yeldns wonn jew dxdhutd tgd
w`ntz*
Ygd i`y g`s addj pdrfdht. hnd`r. w`rm. jet get. wotg ` heen
arddzd anewojb* Rugu. nold mest ef tgdsd rovdr tewjs. nods
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 79/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 2?
strdthgdi eut `nn `nejb tgd w`tdrfrejt* Gonns rosd `aruptny ad-
goji tgd hoty. `ji ej tgdor teps fojd ferdobj gemds g`vd addj
auont* Ygdsd. O `m teni. `rd jew ehhupodi ay J`toej`nost treeps*
Ferdobjdrs ie jet novd `sgerd `ji jew dvdj iurojb tgd i`ytomd
r`rdny be `s f`r `s tgd Auji* Ygdrd `rd ndss tg`j ` iezdj stonn
gdrd* Ygdy novd ej n`ujhgds er gunls `nejbsoid tgd Auji* @j
`rmdi bu`ri pretdhts tgdm*
Rugu os. oj ` w`y. ` r`tgdr prdtty nottnd hoty* Ot g`s `
Hgojdsd pepun`toej ef `aeut 033.333 pdrsejs* Oj jerm`n tomds.
tgdrd `rd pdrg`ps 033 ferdobjdrs novojb gdrd* Ygd hustems geusd.
jew vortu`nny oind. st`jis oj tgd hdjtdr ef tgojbs ej tgd Auji. `
hnehl ej ots tewdr tennojb tgd geurs* Adnew tgd hnehl jew os `
brd`t pohturd ef tgd n`td Dg-* Xuj _`t-sdj. feujidr ef tgd Lue-
mojt`jb* Ygd Auji `ji ejd ef tgd `vdjuds nd`iojb a`hl tew`ri
tgd gonns `rd p`rto`nny sg`idi ay rews ef trdds. `j ujusu`n tgojb
oj tgos p`rt ef tgd werni* Ejd sdniem sdds ` trdd `jywgdrd `nejb
tgd _`jbtzd te G`jlew*
@ftdr toffoj 'nujhg/ O wdjt evdr te tgd gunl `nejbsoid wgohg
wd wdrd iehldi `ji t`nldi wotg tgd sgoppojb hemp`jy `bdjt
tgdrd Gos j`md os H* A* Rertndy* Gd os ` Arotosgdr. `s mest ef
tgdsd mdj `rd up gdrd* K* H`jom. ef tgd Xt`ji`ri Eon. os stonn
gdrd. `ji G* N* Mdhlndjaurbg. ` tea`hhe m`j. `nse `j @mdroh`j.
os h`rryojb ej fer tgd prdsdjt* Ygd Hemmossoejdr ef Hustems
os ` Adnbo`j. A`rej id H`rtodr*
Rertndy s`oi tg`t tgdrd g`s addj je dxhotdmdjt gdrd fer semd
tomd* Gd s`oi. gewdvdr. tg`t ` fdw i`ys `be ` jumadr ef sen-
iodrs `ji stuidjts h`md iewj frem G`jlew `ji st`rtdi treuand*
Eridrs h`md frem J`jlojb. frem Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. O"m teni.
te ruj tgdsd stuidjts eut ef gdrd. Rertndy s`oi* Ygdy g`vd
addj nd`vojb `s f`st `s pessoand dvdr sojhd* O stonn sdd ` fdw ef
tgdm `reuji. `bot`ters fer tgd "Aensgods% _eu"rd t`lojb semd ef
tgdm ej tgd Neejbwe a`hl te G`jlew*@ji se wd `rd* Ygdrd `rd ` jumadr ef tgdsd se-h`nndi stu-
idjts wge h`md ej ae`ri `t Rugu. iewj adnew* Ygd h`pt`oj
s`oi tgdy h`j"t ad prdvdjtdi frem hemojb `ae`ri oj wg`t `rd"
stonn. estdjsoany `t nd`st. pd`hd tomds* Of tgdy h`usd je treuand
tgdy wej"t ad mendstdi. gd s`oi*
Xhgdiundi te bdt ujidr w`y `t twdnvd jeej `ji tgdj `t twe
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 80/455
73 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
e"hnehl. tgd Neejbwe foj`nny punndi eut `t fovd e"hnehl* @t tgd
wdstdrj dxtrdmoty ef Rugu. twe Hgojdsd bujae`ts n`y `t `jhger.
std`m up. fnyojb tgd H`jtejdsd fn`b* Rd ioi jet iop eur fn`b
tgos tomd. jer. te ad surd. ioi tgdy* Ygd jdxt step os Loulo`jb*
Rotgeut mosg`p. wd sgeuni `rrovd n`td Xuji`y `ftdrjeej te-
merrew. tg`t os ay std`mojb `nn jobgt* Rd `rd `nejd. wotgeut
hejvey er `hhemp`jyojb mdrhg`jtmdj* Tp te i`rl wd s`w je
seniodrs* @ fdw monds `aevd Rugu. ej tgd seutg a`jl. wd
p`ssdi ` nottnd vonn`bd tg`t g`s addj tgereubgny neetdi* Ygd arohl
hustems geusd. v`h`jt. st`rdi `t us wotg an`jl dyds* D`hg
wojiew `ji ieer fr`md g`i addj terj eut `ji h`rtdi `w`y.
nd`vojb ` k`bbdi eutnojd ef arohl*
_`jbtzd Qovdr Xdrods Je* 6*
EJ AE@QI YGD X* X NEEJBRE. LOTLO@JB. @pron
19* Ejd ef tgd p`r`iexds ef tgos rdvenutoej oj Hgoj` ehhurrdi
gdrd tei`y* Ygd Hgojdsd Luemmt`jb ferdobj hemmossoejdr. `
m`j j`mdi Mr* _* [* Nodu. fnddojb fer gos nofd frem Loulo`jb.
h`md ej ae`ri tgd Neejbove `ji os adojb bovdj tgd s`fd p`ss`bd
`ji s`jhtu`ry wgohg gd idsords Oj etgdr weris. tgd ferdobjdrs
tgd Arotosg. @mdroh`j. K`p`jdsd `ji etgdr w`rsgops up-rovdr
`rd bovojb pretdhtoej te `j effoho`n ef tgd bevdrjmdjt wgesd sen-
iodrs. rdspejsoand er jet. g`vd m`id ot dssdjto`n fer tgd wgotd m`j
te dv`hu`td muhg ef Hgoj`*
Gd os tgereubgny `pprdho`tovd @ji gd idhn`rds tg`t gos p`rty.
tgd Luemojt`jb meidr`tds. w`jt tgd ferdobjdrs te st`y oj Hgoj`.
`ji gd `iis tg`t tgd J`toej`nosts `rd ieojb dvdrytgojb oj tgdor
pewdr te m`ld ot s`fd fer dvdryaeiy ojhnuiojb gomsdnf* Gd os
beojb te G`jlew ej tgd Neejbove adh`usd gd h`jjet be `jy-
wgdrd dnsd* Gd must fndd frem Loulo`jb. fer tgd r`ioh`n `i-
gdrdjts `rd sdjiojb tgdor treeps tgdrd Ygdy `rd dxpdhtdi `jy
memdjt* Ygd tdndbr`pg os usdndss. Mr* Nodu s`ys. `t nd`st te gom*
Gd g`s nottnd er je jdws ef dvdjts eutsoid tgosvohojoty*
Ygd Neejbwe rd`hgdi Loulo`jb `aeut feur e"hnehl tgos `ftdr-
jeej `ftdr `j ujdvdjtfun i`y* Ygd hustems n`ujhg h`md `nejb-
soid* Rd `jhgerdi oj moistrd`m adh`usd tgdrd w`s je reem `t
tgd gunl* Ygd Arotosg `ji @mdroh`j idstreydrs `rd `nejbsoid. ejd
ef d`hg* Ygdrd `nse os ` K`p`jdsd hruosdr gdrd `ji `j @mdroh`j
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 81/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 70
`ji ` Arotosg bujae`t Ygd h`pt`oj ef tgd Arotosg w`rsgop Roni
Xw`j h`md ej ae`ri wotg `j `rmdi bu`ri* Gd shrutojozdi tgd
p`ssperts ef tgd Qusso`js wd `rd tr`jspertojb te G`jlew `ji
tgdj ndft*
Ausojdssmdj wge h`md ej ae`ri fer ` arodf vosot s`oi tg`t
tgd Hgojdsd ej sgerd `rd jejpnusdi* Ygdy iej"t ljew wgohg
w`y te turj. ot sddms. fer Loulo`jb os kust ej tgd aeridr adtwddj
tgd Qdi `ji tgd Meidr`td ojfnudjhds oj tgd Luemojt`jb* Bdj-
dr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl"s mdj wdrd stonn gdrd wgdj wd ndft* Aut
tgdy m`y jet st`y* Ygd Qdis `rd dxpdhtdi memdjt`rony. `ji
tgd etgdrs wonn prea`any rdtrd`t iewj-rovdr ujton tgdy foji rd-
djferhdmdjts* Ygd iezdj er se ferdobjdrs `rd novojb oj geusds
`nejb tgd Auji* D`hg. O `m teni. g`s ` a`b p`hldi `ji os rd`iy
te m`ld ` ruj fer ` w`rsgop `nejbsoid `t ` memdjt"s jetohd* Auso-
jdss os vortu`nny jon. tgd rdprdsdjt`tovds ef tgd v`roeus hemp`jods
rdm`ojojb te hnd`j up a`hl `hheujts `ji te lddp oj teuhg ujton
tgd i`y. of `jy. wgdj tgdy m`y dxpdht te foji hejiotoejs merd
jd`rny jerm`n*
Ygdrd g`s addj nottnd er je fobgtojb gdrd oj tgd n`st fdw i`ys*
Rd bet ujidr w`y `t fovd e"hnehl. eff fer G`jlew. eur jdxt step*
Mr* Nodu. ujton tgos `ftdrjeej Ferdobj Hemmossoejdr oj Lou-
lo`jb. os adojb bovdj dvdry heurtdsy ej ae`ri* Gd g`s addj pn`hdi
`t tgd h`pt`oj"s t`and oj tgd iojojb s`neej. wgdrd oj gos g`ntojb
Djbnosg tgos dvdjojb gd d`bdrny teni us ef gos idsord te ad frodjiny
tew`ri ferdobjdrs. `ji tgd idsord ef tgd Luemojt`jb te ad tgd
s`md* Gos os ` r`tgdr potofun t`nd. aut gd hnojbs te tgd sonvdr
nojojb wgohg gd adnodvds. gd s`ys. os adgoji tgd prdsdjt i`rl >Zeui
ef iossdjsoej oj tgd J`toej`nost S`rty*
Rd must put eut tgd Hemmujosts.+" Mr* Nodu teni us* Ygos
spnot g`i te hemd* Ygdy g`vd je treeps* Rd wonn woj eut `ji
tgdj wd h`j hejtojud eur irovd ej tgd Jertg* Aut%" gd rd-
pd`tdi. wd g`i te ard`l wotg tgd Hemmujosts oj eur p`rty* Ot
g`i te hemd* Ygdrd w`s oj gos `ttotuid ` Iej"t yeu sdd5
pnd`*
N`tdr. gd h`md `nejb te my h`aoj wgdrd O heuni t`nl `t ndjbtg
wotg gom `aeut gos pn`js `ji tgesd ef gos p`rty. `ji wd t`nldi
fer `j geur `aeut tgd sotu`toej. wgohg. gd idhn`rds. ieds jet
md`j tgd ard`liewj ef tgd J`toej`nost mevdmdjt. aut wgohg. ot
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 82/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 83/455
OJ YGD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 78
@s wd t`nldi. tgd hr`zy quont pohturd ef Hgoj` snewny `p-
pd`rdi* Ygd J`toej`nosts. spnot `mejb tgdmsdnvds. fobgtojb fer
hejtren ef tgdor ewj p`rty `b`ojst tgd Hemmujosts" ojfnudjhd. `rd
ejd p`rt ef tgd pohturd* Ygdrd `rd djeubg p`thgds oj tg`t g`nf
te m`ld tgd t`sl ef ljottojb tgdm tebdtgdr oj `jytgojb nold ` he-
erioj`td p`ttdrj `nmest futond `ji hdrt`ojny iosheur`bojb* @ji
ej tgd Jertg ef tgos _`jbtzd `rd etgdr f`htoejs. ujotdi fer tgd
memdjt `b`ojst tgd J`toej`nost mevdmdjt* M`rsg`n Hg`jb
Hgujb-hg`jb `ji gos `nny. M`rsg`n Xuj Hgu`j-f`jb ef Xg`jbg`o.
`rd s`oi te ad semdwgdrd oj tgd jd`r vohojoty ef J`jlojb `ji
G`jlew* M`rsg`n Xuj g`s jet gdni ` vdry gobg gd`i sojhd gos
objemojoeus idfd`t `ji hry fer `ssost`jhd oj Hgdlo`jb Srevojhd.
`ji `t Xg`jbg`o* Gd h`j g`riny ad dxpdhtdi te fddn tgereubgny
s`fd wotg M`rsg`n Hg`jb. `j djermeus eni a`jiot frem Xg`j-
tujb* Hg`jb"s gostery rd`is nold ` Roni Rdst t`nd. er ` ydnnew-
a`hl tg`t mobgt ad djtotndi Frem Heenod te M`rsg`n tgd Y`nd ef
` Xuhhdsskun R`rroer* Gd hdrt`ojny werldi gos w`y up oj gos
hgesdj prefdssoej. frem ` wg`rf heenod tgreubg tgd dssdjto`n
st`bds ef a`jiotry te tgd monot`ry hejtren ef Xg`jtujb `ji jew
tgd tdmper`ry `nny ef M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj. ef Mulidj `ji
Sdlojb*
M`rsg`n Ru Sdo-fu. ejhd pewdrfun. os eni `ji f`idi. ` vdry
sm`nn aot ef tgd pohturd robgt jew. `ji ejd. dvdryaeiy sddms te
adnodvd. wge wonn jet rdturj te gos drstwgond aronno`jhd `ji pewdr*
Gd os hejtdjt wotg tgd quodt nofd ef ` pedt `ji shgen`r* Gd g`s
b`ojdi ` rdput`toej fer shgen`rsgop `ji `s ` pedt. hgodfny. gos
hrotohs `fform. adh`usd gd os ejd ef tgd fdw monot`rosts ef tgd eni
shgeen wge heuni dvdj rd`i er wrotd* Gd os semdwgdrd oj jertg-
drj Gej`j. ot sddms. hejtdjt te ndt gos suhhdssers oj monot`rosm
h`rry ej tgd `jhodjt fdui`n p`stomd ef tgd Hgojdsd*
M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb oj Xgdjso wotg pdrg`ps 033.333 mdj.
os dxpdhtdi te rdm`oj wotg Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl* Hemmos-soejdr Nodu fdrvoiny `vdrrdi tg`t tgd woidny ljewj Hgrosto`j
Bdjdr`n wonn jdvdr be a`hl ej Hgo`jb* Gd g`s sdjt ` idndb`td
te tgd J`jlojb Hejfdrdjhd. Mr* Nodu peojtdi eut. `ji gos `rmy
os te ad ` vot`n f`hter oj tgd t`lojb ef Sdlojb semd i`y* Mr*
Nodu w`s jet surd wgdj tg`t vohtery heuni ad dxpdhtdi te ehhur*
Ygojbs `rd tee ujsdttndi*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 84/455
79 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygd Hemmossoejdr w`s aottdr `b`ojst Qusso`* Gd s`oi tgd
Xevodt os tryojb te bdt `t tgd Sewdrs tgreubg Hgoj`. usojb tgos
j`toej `s ` h`tsp`w* Ygdy iej"t w`jt ` w`r oj tgdor ewj
heujtry%" gd s`oi* Ygdy idsord te stor up ejd gdrd. te g`vd tgd
fodni ef tgdor a`ttnd wotg tgd h`pot`nostoh Sewdrs. `s tgdy h`nn tgdm.
oj Hgoj`* Ygus. Qusso` os jet g`rmdi* O iej"t tgojl tgdy wonn
sdji `j `rmy te Hgoj`. gd `iidi oj rdspejsd te ` qudry*
Gd s`oi gd g`i `ivosdi Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl te `hhdpt `oi
frem K`p`j. `ji te heepdr`td wotg K`p`j* Yg`t areubgt oj
`jetgdr p`rt ef tgd pohturd ef iosojtdbr`tdi Hgoj`. j`mdny. M`r-
sg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj* O s`oi tg`t of Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl werldi wotg
K`p`j gd weuni g`vd te werl wotg M`rsg`n Hg`jb. tee* Aut
tgd Hemmossoejdr. ` trud H`jtejdsd. s`oi tg`t weuni jdvdr hemd
te p`ss*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl wonn jdvdr sg`ld g`jis wotg M`r-
sg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj.0 "
gd s`oi* Rgy5 Rdnn. adh`usd tgdy g`vd
addj djdmods tee nejb* Ygdy h`j"t werl tebdtgdr oj Hgoj`
Aut K`p`j must werl wotg Hgoj`< `ji of wd t`ld `nn ef Hgoj`.
wd wonn g`vd te werl wotg K`p`j* Yg`t os j`tur`n* K`p`j os se
hnesd. ot os jdhdss`ry te gdr dxostdjhd* @mdroh` `ji Arot`oj `rd
tee f`r `w`y* Rd weuni ad frodjiny. ef heursd. te dvdryaeiy*
Xe tg`t p`rt ef tgd pohturd. er tgd hr`zy quont 'te stohl te
tgd foburd/. wonn jet fot oj wotg tgd rdst* Gdjhd. tgd ujoty ef
Hgoj` m`y g`vd te w`ot `b`oj fer ` wgond. Mr* Nodu `imottdi*
Ygdj tgdrd os _ujj`j. tg`t v`st prevojhd ej tgd aeridr ef
Aurm` wgdrd arob`jis `ji epoum smubbndrs `aeuji* Yg`t os `
fr`ydi dibd ef tgd quont wgohg h`usds je nottnd treuand te tgd
teondrs* _ujj`j. ot wonn ad rdh`nndi. ` fdw mejtgs `be g`i `
rdvenutoej `nn ej ots ewj. `ji jew ojstd`i ef tgd monot`ry bev-
drjer oj hg`rbd. tgdrd os ` Hotozdjs" Hemmottdd ef Fovd rujjojb
tgojbs* Ygdy s`y ot osj"t Hemmujostoh. dx`htny* Yg`t ot os `
""hemmossoej ferm ef bevdrjmdjt* _dt ot g`s ` hdrt`oj hromsej
tojbd te ot wgohg wej"t w`sg `w`y Furtgdrmerd. _ujj`j os `
woni heujtry. sp`rsdny sdttndi `ji ojfdstdi wotg a`jiots* Ot os
`jetgdr preandm wgohg tgdsd teondrs must f`hd wge weuni ujotd
tgos Hgoj` ef tei`y ` fdui`n st`td wgesd pdepnd `rd `imottdiny
hdjturods adgoji tgd tomds oj tgeubgt. hunturd. diuh`toej `ji oj
tgdor id`nojbs wotg ejd `jetgdr* Ygdor w`rnerisstonn. ejd must
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 85/455
OJ YYOD V@NND_ EF YGD _@JBY[D 74
fd`r. `rd somon`r te tgd fdui`n a`rejs ef Durepd oj tgd Moiind
@bds wgesd ney`nty w`s. `s tgd Hgojdsd os tei`y. jejd tee
hdrt`oj `j `ff`or* Ot heuni ad aeubgt ay tgd gobgdst aoiidr* Xe
h`j tg`t ef tgd `vdr`bd Hgojdsd monot`ry hgodft`oj* Ygdsd
tgojbs O s`oi er ompnodi* _dt tgd Hemmossoejdr rdm`ojdi
eptomostoh*
Rd ioshussdi j`mds `ji pn`hds* Ygd Hemmossoejdr s`oi tg`t
Guj`j Srevojhd os tgd getadi ef Hemmujosm* Gd s`oi tg`t tgdrd
tgdy idm`ji tg`t dvdryaeiy wge g`s merd tg`j )133 must iovoid
ot wotg gos fdnnew-mdj* Ygos sddms te ad tgd usu`n rdpert ej
Guj`j* O gd`ri rdhdjtny tg`t tgdy g`vd trodi eut iovoiojb up
tgd n`ji `ji ojstotutojb `nn tgd Hemmujostoh fer Hemmuj`n/
f"Zrms ef bevdrjmdjt*
Bdjdr`n Hgdj Hgodj. oj hemm`ji ef tgd Xoxtg @rmy. g`s bejd
te G`jlew* Gd w`s oj J`jlojb* Gd hemm`jidi tgd `rmods tg`t
h`pturdi `ji neetdi tg`t onn-f`tdi hoty ej M`rhg 19* Hemmossoejdr
Nodu tgojls Bdjdr`n Hgdj wonn st`y oj G`jlew* Hgodj Ysu-moj.
n`td hemm`jidr ef tgd Lwdohgew `rmy. os id`i* Gd w`s dxd-
hutdi `t Hg`jtdg. oj wdstdrj Guj`j. `t tgd eridr ef Bdjdr`n Y`jb
Xgdj-tsd. jew `t G`jlew* Ygd Hemmossoejdr tgeubgt. tgdrdferd.
tg`t Bdjdr`n Hgodj"s mdj. semd 84.333. weuni ad ney`n te Bdjdr`n
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. swerj djdmy ef tgd m`j wge lonndi tgdor hgodf*
Bdjdr`n Ydjb _dj-t`g os ` vdry a`i m`j%" tgd Hemmossoejdr
idhn`rdi* Gd os tgd rdhebjozdi Qdiidst ef tgd Qdis `t G`jlew;
gd `ji Bderbd Gsu-hgodj. Mojostdr ef Kustohd*
Dubdjd Hgdj5 Ygd Hemmossoejdr w`s jet surd wgdrd gd
st`jis aut sddmdi ojhnojdi te tgojl Hgdj mobgt nold te bdt a`hl
wotg tgd Meidr`tds* Gd g`i gd`ri tg`t Hgdj. tgd G`jlew Fer-
dobj Mojostdr. w`jts te bdt te Xg`jbg`o. aut tgd Q`ioh`ns `rd geni-
ojb gom vortu`nny ` prosejdr* Gd tgojls tg`t Hgdj mobgt ad `nn
robgt. aut ot osj"t hdrt`oj*
Iej"t tdnn Dubdjd Hgdj%" tgd Hemmossoejdr s`oi `s wd s`oi
beeijobgt. tg`t O `m ej tgd Neejbwe O premosdi O weuni jet
ard`tgd ` weri ef gos prdsdjhd oj G`jlew* Ot weuni jet ad
gd`ntgy* Rd `rd iud adferd jeej temerrew. @pron 14*
Ygos dxhotojb trop up-rovdr te G`jlew djidi ej @pron 14. 0?12. `s
shgdiundi* O n`jidi oj semd trdpoi`toej aut w`s jet mendstdi* Ygd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 86/455
76 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
mest `jbuosg wgohg O suffdrdi w`s iurojb ` mond w`nl `nejb tgd Auji
te tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Hejsun`td-Bdjdr`n. te mddt Hen* Fr`jl S* Nehlg`rt.
eur bdjo`n Hejsun-Bdjdr`n tgdrd* Gd put md up `t tgd Hejsun`td-
Bdjdr`n fer my st`y. wgohg n`stdi sdvdr`n wddls* Ygd ""`jbuosg+" w`s
iud te tgd gd`t jet te a`jis ef ojsuntojb Hgojdsd ej muridr adjt*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 87/455
QDI QTND @Y G@JLER
QDIiust. fojd. get. tgohl `s ` rub. n`y gd`vony evdr tgd m`h`i-
`mozdi sdhtoejs ef tgd Auji `t G`jlew* Ygd strddt. p`vdi
ejny oj ` fdw spets. strdthgdi ots sndjidr ndjbtg twe monds `ji
merd `nejb tgd _`jbtzd* Je arddzd storrdi. aut `j ehh`soej`n gurtnojb
meterh`r spurtdi g`jifuns ef iort evdr pdidstro`js `ji ios`ppd`rdi oj
` iunn rdi hneui* Ygdsd r`rd `utemeaonds usu`nny aerd ej tgdor geeis
tgd J`toej`nost fn`b. `nse prdiemoj`jtny rdi. wotg ots wgotd st`r oj `
herjdr ef anud*
Ygd iunn rdi hneuis wdrd stofnojb* Merjojb w`s suntry dvdj ej tgd
twdjty-foftg ef @pron* G`jlew w`s get* Ygd gd`t w`vd w`s prdm`turd*
Aut G`jlew"s hnom`td os somon`r te tgd moiind-seutg ef tgd Tjotdi
Xt`tds* Ots summdrs `rd nejb `ji stohly `ji fdtoi* Ygd hoty os strol-
ojbny somon`r te `jy rovdr pert `nejb tgd Mossossoppo Qovdr. adnew Xt*
Neuos* Of yeu heuni dxhg`jbd tgd Hgojdsd heenods fer Jdbreds. tgd
tewjs weuni `nmest `ppd`r oidjtoh`n* Ygd heenods sgeut `ji gdd-g`w
`s tgdy h`rry tgdor auridjs ej a`maee pends er pondi gobg ej tgdor
sturiy are`i sgeunidrs `ji jdhls. kust `s Jdbreds sgeut `ji sojb `s
tgdy werl* G`jlew. te ad surd. os ` nottnd merd hesmepenot`j* Aut
tgdrd os ` strolojb somon`roty dxhdpt fer ejd tgojb; rdhurrdjt w`rs*
Dvdj tg`t w`s jet jetohd`and `s ejd iosdma`rldi frem ` rovdr
std`mdr `ji w`nldi `nejb tgd Auji* Ot w`s jetohd`and. te ad surd. tg`t
`j `ajerm`n sotu`toej prdv`ondi oj 0?12* Ygd hgodf rd`sej w`s tgd prds-
djhd ef semd tgorty er merd ferdobj w`rsgops oj tgd rovdr tgdrd* Ej tgd
_`jbtzd"s rosojb. rumpndiw`tdrs fne`tdi ` rdm`rl`and henndhtoej ef
fobgt-
ojb hr`ft ef g`nf ` iezdj j`toejs tgdrd te sdd tg`t ferdobj novds `ji prep-
drty wdrd pretdhtdi. rdb`rindss ef wg`t Hgojdsd f`htoej gdni tgd ndrro-
tery wgohg ojhnuids Rug`j*
Rug`j os tgd j`md bovdj tgd tgrdd hotods tg`t g`vd addj auont up
`reuji tgd keojojb ef tgd G`j `ji _`jbtzd Qovdrs `t tgos peojt* Ej tgd
seutgdrj a`jl ef tgd _`jbtzd os Ruhg`jb< ommdio`tdny eppesotd os
72
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 88/455
77 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
G`jlew<`ji kust te tgd wdst ef G`jlew os G`jy`jb* Ygd tgrdd hotods
g`vd ` tet`n pepun`toej ef pdrg`ps twe monnoej* Rug`j os tgd b`td-
w`y te tgd Rdst ef Hgoj`* Ot hejtrens tgd ojtdroer m`rldts ay vor-
tud ef ots pesotoej ej tgd _`jbtzd* Ygdrd `rd stonn `nmest je r`on-
re`is oj tgd rohg hdjtr`n `ji wdstdrj prevojhds. `ji beeis must fnew
`nejb tgd rovdr reutds* Ygd _`jbtzd oj meidrj tomds os wg`t tgd
Mossossoppo w`s fofty te sdvdjty-fovd yd`rs `be* Fertujds g`vd addj
m`id `ji `rd stonn adojb m`id oj tgd rovdr tr`jspert ausojdss oj tgd
_`jbtzd v`nndy*
G`jlew os tgd projhop`n pert ef tgd tgrdd hotods* Ygdrd ferdobj
ojtdrdsts `rd hdjtdrdi* Ygd Auji os nojdi wotg n`rbd meidrj auoni-
ojbs wgohg geusd ferdobj hemmdrho`n forms. ojhnuiojb m`bjofohdjt
struhturds fer tgd a`jls* Ygd ferdobj hejsun`tds-bdjdr`n `rd `nejb
tgd Auji* Ygdsd auoniojbs `nn f`hd tgd rovdr* Ygd rovdr soid ef tgd
strddt os bovdj evdr te ` p`rlw`y nojdi wotg trdds `ji adjhgds. aer-
idrojb ` are`i soidw`nl wgdrd ejd m`y premdj`id oj sd`rhg ef `or
ej gumoi jobgts*
Ygdrd os ejd aob ioffdrdjhd adtwddj tgd prdsdjt `ji tgd beei
eni i`ys. tgdy s`y* Fermdrny tgd Auji"s p`rlw`y w`s rdsdrvdi dj-
tordny fer tgd usd ef ferdobjdrs* Jew ot os `novd wotg Hgojdsd. hgodfny
heenods. nennojboj tgd sg`id ef ots brddj trdds* Ygd Auji w`s auont ay
tgd ferdobjdrs. d`hg j`toej wotg ` hejhdssoej ieojb ots sg`rd* Ygd
Arotosg Hejhdssoej os `t tgd f`r dji ef tgd Auji tg`t os. f`rtgdst up-
strd`m< tgd eni Qusso`j Hejhdssoej os jdxt< tgd Frdjhg `ftdr tg`t<
tgdj. tgd eni Bdrm`j Hejhdssoej < `ji `t tgd newdr dji. tgd K`p`jdsd
Hejhdssoej* Ygos n`st usu`nny os hut eff ay a`radi word a`rroh`ids
`ji s`jia`bs se tg`t ot rdm`ojs frdd frem Hgojdsd ne`fdrs*
Ej nd`vojb tgd Neejbwe. O w`s `ivosdi ay tgd H`pt`oj `ji etgdrs
jet te t`ld ` rohlsg`w* Ygdrd g`i addj rdperts ef treuand wotg tgd
heenods. wge. ot w`s s`oi. g`i addj m`lojb dxeraot`jt hg`rbds `ji g`i
addj ojsuntojbej `nn ehh`soejs* Gdjhd O pneiidi `nejb tgd Auji te
tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td-Bdjdr`n. ` mond er se frem wgdrd eur std`mdr
iehldi* N`tdr. O feuji tg`t tgdrd w`s nottnd er je rd`sej fer djiur-
ojb tgos ioshemfert* Ygd heenods wdrd jet tgdj oj tgd nd`st eastrdp-
dreus* Ygdy hg`rbdi tgd usu`n new prohds `ji wdrd ojhnojdi te `ssost
`jy ferdobjdr hgddrfunny* Ygd hg`jbd frem ` wddl proer te my `r-
rov`n w`s idshroadi `s rdm`rl`and*
Ygos. oj f`ht. w`s tgd suakdht wgohg `nn ferdobjdrs wdrd ioshussojb
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 89/455
QDI QTND @Y G@JLER 7?
tg`t @pron 14. 0?12* Ygd @mdroh`j Hejsun-Bdjdr`n. Hen* Fr`jl Nehl-
g`rt. w`s tgd forst te mdjtoej ot* O `sldi wgdtgdr ot wdrd s`fd te roid
oj rohlsg`ws `ji gd s`oi tg`t gdtgeubgt
ot
w`s `iiojbtg`t
tgd
hg`jbd wgohg g`i hemd evdr tgd heenods w`s `m`zojb* Gd w`s `t `
ness te dxpn`oj ot te gomsdnf s`tosf`hterony. aut w`s ojhnojdi te adnodvd.
`s mest ferdobjdrs wdrd. tg`t tgd hg`jbd w`s h`usdi ay tgd prdsdjhd
ef tgd jumdreus ferdobj w`rsgops oj tgd rovdr* Ygd `ttotuid ef tgd
heenods `pp`rdjtny hg`jbdi hgodfny adh`usd ef bevdrjmdjt eridrs te
tgdm te ad loji te ferdobjdrs* Ygd bevdrjmdjt werldi tgreubg tgd
N`aer Tjoejs `ji sddmdi te ad oj hempndtd hejtren. `s f`r `s tgd
werldrs wdrd hejhdrjdi*
Mest ef tgd @mdroh`js stonn oj G`jlew wdrd rdsoiojb oj tgd @mdr-
oh`j Hejsun`td. usojb hets oj tgd reems* Ygd Hejsun-Bdjdr`n effdrdi
md gos gespot`noty* O `hhdptdi* Ot sddmdi tgd adttdr p`rt ef v`ner
tgd getdns oj G`jlew. nold getdns oj m`jy ` rovdr tewj. wdrd f`r frem
nuxuroeus* @ji `t tg`t tomd tgdrd w`s je `ssur`jhd tg`t tgdy weuni
ad tee s`fd*
Frem tgd Hejsun`td. O prehddidi te tgd @mdroh`j fn`bsgop Os`adn
te h`nn ej Qd`r-@imor`n G* G* Geubg. tgdj oj hg`rbd ef tgd @mdro-
h`j J`vy p`tren oj tgd _`jbtzd* @ftdr p`yojb my rdspdhts. O wotg-
irdw `ji mdt tgd h`pt`oj `ji effohdrs ef tgd fn`bsgop* O w`s bovdj usd
ef tgd Os`adn"s n`ujhg te bdt my nubb`bd eff tgd Neejbwe `ji tr`js-
pert ot te tgd iehl* O g`i semd snobgt ioffohunty oj bdttojb tgd a`bs
tr`jspertdi frem tgd iehl te tgd Hejsun`td* Je wg`rf heenod w`s oj
sobgt. `ji ejd ef tgd s`oners g`jidi tgd a`bs evdr te ` he`nojb heenod*
Ojjehdjt ef `jy ard`hg ef heenod dtoqudttd. O prehddidi `gd`i ef tgd
fdnnew tew`ri tgd Auji. `hress tgd weeidj podr tg`t dxtdjis eut evdr
tgd ferdsgerd* Neelojb `reuji `t gos suiidj euthry. O ioshevdrdi ad-
ferd wd g`i bejd fofty y`ris tg`t gd g`i addj adsdt ay tgrdd er feur
reubg neelojb hg`r`htdrs wge sddmdi te ad ojsostojb tg`t gd rdnd`sd
my a`bb`bd* @nejd. uj`and te spd`l tgd n`jbu`bd `ji. fer tgd me-
mdjt. uj`and te ujidrst`ji tgd h`usd ef tgd `rbumdjt. O heuni ie
jetgojb* Frem tgd sterods O g`i gd`ri. O w`s rd`iy te adnodvd wd
wdrd adojb reaadi ej tgd sgerd oj are`i i`ynobgt*
O sgevdi ejd ef tgd `tt`hldrs `soid. foj`nny. `ftdr gd g`i struhl
my heenod frdqudjtny ej tgd f`hd `ji gd`i wotg tgd fn`t ef gos g`ji.
`ji teni tgd fdnnew te hejtojud. ar`jiosgojb my stohl tgd wgond* Ot
f`ondi te werl* Ygdy rdturjdi te tgd fr`y. `ji ejd metoejdi tg`t gd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 90/455
?3 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
w`jtdi te h`rry tgd a`bs. peojtojb te my heenod `ji tgdj te tgd he`n-
ojb kujl* Ygd fdnnew O g`i w`s smorhgdi wotg he`n iust `ji `pp`r-
djtny
g`i addj ujne`iojb tgd
kujl*
Ot sddmdi tg`t tg`t w`s gos kea
gos pobdej `s tgdy s`y oj tgd vdrj`hun`r tgdrd `ji gd heuni jet ie
`jytgojb dnsd dvdj of gd sgeuni w`jt te ad djtdrprosojb* Of gd ioi. gd
hut semd etgdr heenod eut ef ` aewn ef rohd* O p`oi tgd forst hg`p
twdjty hdjts Mdx* 'er `aeut dobgt hdjts oj T* X* hurrdjhy `t tgd
tomd/* Rgdj twe etgdrs br`aadi my twe a`bs. d`hg t`lojb ejd. O
idhoidi. r`tgdr tg`j subbdst tg`t ejd t`ld aetg ef tgdm. te ndt tgdm
g`vd tgdor w`y* @t tgd Hejsun`td ` anehl `w`y O b`vd tgdm ` Mdxo-
h`j ienn`r te fobgt evdr `ji tgdy brojjdi tgdor w`y a`hl ojte eanovoej*
Ot w`s prea`any tgrdd er feur tomds tgdor usu`n w`bd fer tg`t sert ef
kea. aut bdttojb roi ef tgd p`or ef tgdm wotgeut `j ojhoidjt w`s
wertg tgd ferty hdjts ot hest md* O w`s teni n`tdr tg`t gottojb er
sgevojb ejd ef tgdsd fdnnews ` wddl d`rnodr weuni g`vd addj `nmest
nold sobjojb ejd"s ewj id`tg w`rr`jt*
Ygdrd wdrd ejny twe er tgrdd pn`hds te d`t oj G`jlew `t tg`t
tomd* Ygd mest pepun`r w`s tgd T* X* J`vy _* M* H* @*. ` anehl
frem tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td `ji kust eff tgd Auji* Ygd getdns
tgdrd wdrd twe ef tgdm wdrd sdrvojb feei `b`oj. `ji tgd G`jlew
Hnua w`s rujjojb ots iojojb-reem fer mdmadrs `ji budsts* O g`i
toffoj wotg ` m`j frem tgd Hejsun`td `ji twe Xt`ji`ri Eon mdj `t
tgd _* M* H* @* Ygd `ftdrjeej w`s spdjt oj m`lojb `ppeojtmdjts
wotg G`jlew"s effoho`ns. ojhnuiojb tgd Mojostdr fer Ferdobj @ff`ors.
Mr* Dubdjd Hgdj. `ji tg`t rdm`rl`and `ivosdr. Hemr`id Mol`n Aere-
ioj* Gd w`s tgd m`j adgoji mest ef tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej
tgd ar`ojs ef tgd wgend sgew*
Ygd wgend i`y w`s dxtr`erioj`rony quodt se f`r `s w`rf`rd er uj-
rdst w`s hejhdrjdi. `ji tgd woni rdperts `aeut G`jlew"s tdjsdjdss
wdrd `asuri* Ygd hoty. `soid frem tgd w`rsgops `ji tgd ehh`soej`n
J`toej`nost seniodr sddj ej tgd strddts. w`s `s quodt tgdj `s Idtreot*
Yd` `t tgd G`jlew Q`hd Hnua w`s `jetgdr surprosd* Gdrd. `s tgd
suj wdjt iewj. O s`t wotg Aruje Xhgw`rtz. ef Jdw _erl. tgdj pua-
nosgdr ef tgd G`jlew Gdr`ni. `ji nostdjdi te musoh ay tgd hnua a`ji*
Ygdrd wdrd sherds ef pdrsejs sottojb ej tgd are`i n`wj adferd tgd
hnuageusd. hg`ttojb `s oj dvdryi`y nofd `jywgdrd. w`r tgd f`rtgdst
tgojb frem tgdor mojis* @ jumadr ef wemdj. tee. wdrd prdsdjt.
mestny Bdrm`js. `ji ` fdw Frdjhg* O w`s stonn omprdssdi tgdj wotg
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 91/455
QDI QTND @Y G@JLER ?0
tgd oid` tg`t G`jlew w`s i`jbdreus. `ji ojhnojdi te adnodvd tg`t
tgdsd pdepnd wge rdfusdi te t`ld ot sdroeusny wdrd sottojb ej tgd dibd
ef ` venh`je* Aut Mr* Xhgw`rtz ios`ausdi my moji ef suhg onnusoejs*
Ygd etgdr wemdj oj G`jlew wdrd tgd Qusso`js. ojhnuiojb tgd
i`jhojb bornsef tgd h`a`rdts* Ygd h`a`rdt systdm ef G`jlew w`s `
ujoqud tgojb* Jet tg`t ot osj"t stonn te ad feuji `jywgdrd oj Hgoj`"s
n`rbd hotods aut te foji ot tgdrd `t ` tomd nold tg`t w`s uttdrny eii*
Ot w`s tgd hnom`x te ` bretdsqud i`y jet `t `nn nold tgd ejd O g`i
dxpdhtdi te foji* @ftdr iojjdr. wotg twe seuji `ji rdspdht`and auso-
jdss mdj wge wdrd jet `t `nn ef tgd tordi"" typd. O reujidi eut tgd
forst i`y"s diuh`toej oj tgd w`ys ef tg`t hoty ay ` vosot te tgd h`a`rdts*
Ygdrd wdrd prea`any g`nf ` iezdj oj ejd anehl* Ygd erhgdstr`s
peujidi eut musoh wgohg oj tgd b`uiony nobgtdi strddt andjidi ojte
ejd r`uheus gewn ef k`zz* Ygd h`a`rdts wdrd. `ftdr `nn. mdrdny i`jhd
g`nns. tgeubg oj p`nmodr i`ys tgdy g`i g`i djtdrt`ojdrs* Ygd adst
idshroptoej. O tgojl. ef tgd strddt `ji tgd i`jhd g`nns oj 0?12 os te ad
feuji oj ` hemp`rosej wotg tgd typoh`n metoej pohturd sdt idpohtojb
tgd i`jhd g`nns ef @mdroh`"s Roni Rdst oj tgd i`ys ef "9?* Ygdrd
w`s je prdtdjsd ef fojdry* Ejny ejd pn`hd g`i dvdj `j `ttdmpt `t ot.
`ji gdrd ejd feuji v`ro-henerdi dndhtroh nobgts stuhl oj ` nojd `reuji
tgd w`nns `aeut tdj fddt `aevd tgd fneer* Ot b`vd ` wdori dffdht. b`uiy.
` aurndsqud ej tgd Hgrostm`s sporot*
Ygd borns. Qusso`js `nn. wdrd ` hndvdr net* Ygdy i`jhdi wotg
s`oners oj tgd `ftdrjeej. `ji `t jobgt wotg mdj ef `nn r`jls `ji peso-
toejs `ji j`toej`notods wge fer ejd rd`sej er `jetgdr g`i hemd te
tgesd pn`hds* My buoids peojtdi eut te md iopnem`ts. h`pt`ojs ef
sgops. gd`is ef n`rbd ferdobj forms. n`wydrs. iehters. a`jldrs. Hgojdsd
effoho`ns* Ot w`s ejd ef tgd mest aoz`rrd sobgts te ad sddj `jywgdrd
oj tgd werni* Effoho`ns ef ferdobj bevdrjmdjts mojbndi wotg effo-
ho`ns ef tgd G`jlew bevdrjmdjt oj tgesd iovds< Hemmujosts frem
Meshew i`jhdi soid ay soid wotg tgd mdj tgdy wdrd sddlojb te ferhd
eut ef Hgoj`< yeujb borns. `nw`ys Qusso`js. n`ubgdi `t tgdm `ji
i`jhdi wotg tgdm `nn. idm`jiojb frdqudjtny. _eu auy md ` sm`nn
aettnd wojd. pnoss5
Ygd wojd w`s usu`nny ` pojt ef vond omot`toej hg`mp`bjd wgohg
w`s seni te tgd mdj `t )7 ` aettnd. Mdx*. tgd born bdttojb )0 `s gdr
hemmossoej* Of sgd i`jhdi. sgd w`s bovdj ` tohldt wertg ferty hdjts.
Mdx* Dvdrytgojb oj Hgoj` os stonn ej tgos sonvdr a`sos. eroboj`nny
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 92/455
?1 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
ompertdi frem Mdxohe te `oi tr`id* Ygd borns ioi jet adhemd wd`ntgy
aut tgdy d`rjdi ` novojb oj tgos f`sgoej* Xemd ef tgdm. O w`s teni.
nd`rjdi
m`jytgojbs wgohg dj`andi tgdm te djg`jhd tgdor usu`n oj-
hemd*
Xemd. tgd wgospdrojbs s`oi. wdrd spods* Oj tgdsd h`fds wgohg
fermdi se muhg ` p`rt ef G`jlew"s nofd iurojb tgesd str`jbd i`ys.
tgdy wdrd suppesdi te nd`rj muhg frem ferdobjdrs `ji te rdt`on tgdor
ljewndibd te hdrt`oj hg`jjdns wgdrd ot heuni prevd usdfun* Ygd uj-
wottojb vohtom eftdj ndt semdtgojb irep tg`t g`i v`nud oj tgd muiindi
shgdmd ef hress-purpesds oj tgd Erodjt* Rgdtgdr tgdor spy sh`rd w`s
trud. O ie jet ljew* Ot w`s gobgny pessoand. `t nd`st* Aut hdrt`ojny
tgdrd wdrd sejbs ef Meshew sujb eftdj oj tgesd i`jhd g`nns ef G`j-
lew< `ji tgd rdi iust tg`t n`yoj tgd j`rrew. rohlsg`w-hnuttdrdi
Xtrddt ef tgd H`a`rdts w`s eftdj sworndi ojte `jbry diiods ay tgd
gurtnojb meter h`rs ef tgd Aensgdvolo*
O ojtdrvodwdi Dubdjd Hgdj tgd jdxt i`y* Dvdryaeiy ojtdrvodwdi
Mr* Hgdj tgdj* Gd w`s Ferdobj Mojostdr oj tgd r`ioh`n G`jlew
Bevdrjmdjt `ji w`s. tgdrdferd. ` m`ker seurhd ef ojferm`toej `aeut
Hgoj`"s `htoejs. idsords `ji rd`htoejs* Gd w`s tgd effoho`n spelds-
m`j+" ef tgd G`jlew J`toej`nost @imojostr`toej* @nn p`tgs. tgdrd-
ferd. fer tgd gerid ef mdj wge fnehldi frem `nn evdr tgd werni ojte
G`jlew `ji eut `b`oj. ndi te gos ausy ieer*
Ygd Ferdobj Mojostdr w`s ehhupodi wotg tgd mdhg`johs ef ` rdvenu-
toej* Gd seubgt `s ` mdmadr ef tgd H`aojdt te ruj tg`t sdhtoej ef
Hgoj` tgdj ujidr G`jlew"s hejtren< `ji Hgdj w`s werrodi `t tg`t
tomd ay ` hrosos wotgoj tgd Luemojt`jb. tgd spnot wgohg. fer ` wgond.
iovoidi tgd J`toej`nost ferhds* Gewdvdr. ehhupodi wotg tgdsd tgojbs
`ji tgd pessoand jdhdssoty ef rdpnyojb te `jetgdr Jetd frem tgd Sewdrs
ej tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt. Mr* Hgdj s`t fer `j geur `ji teni ef gos
hejhdptoej ef tgd `oms `ji `spor`toejs ef tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej*
Gd pnd`idi fer s`joty `mejb tgd pewdrs oj tgdor `ttotuid tew`ri
Hgoj`* Gd gepdi tg`t tgd Sewdrs weuni jet anehl`id tgd _`jbtzd*
Gd ioi jet idjy tg`t tgdy heuni. aut s`oi tg`t Hgoj` gepdi tgd Sewdrs
weuni rdfr`oj frem tg`t sert ef `htoej*t'
O iej"t tgojl tg`t tgos "wonn
g`ppdj. gd s`oi. ujndss tgd werni g`s bejd m`i* _dt. gd wej-
idrdi `aeut tgd tgorty er merd ferdobj w`rsgops oj G`jlew tgdj*
Of tgdy anehl`id tgd _`jbtzd. gd s`oi. wd stonn g`vd rohd `ji
pd`jut eon* Rd sg`nn hejtojud te d`t `ji te g`vd n`mps* @ji. `ftdr
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 93/455
Q D I Q T N D @ Y G @ W L R ?8
`nn. wd ie jet sot up jobgts `ji rd`i vdry muhg* Gd smondi* Rd
wonn. O tgojl. bdt `nejb* Aut O gepd mest sojhdrdny tg`t tg`t ieds jet
g`ppdj*
Dubdjd Hgdj. ` m`j jdrveusny djdrbdtoh. s`jl a`hl ojte gos anud
pnusg hg`or `ji rdb`ridi md. `w`otojb tgd jdxt qudry* Gd w`s `
r`tgdr snobgt m`j. pdrg`ps fofty yd`rs eni tgdj. gos an`hl g`or sget
wotg br`y. gos tgoj g`jis bdstohun`tojb oj dmpg`sos er dxpn`j`toej ef
gos rdm`rls* Keurj`nost `ji tdmper`ry st`tdsm`j ef tgd jdw Hgoj`.
gos w`s ` pnd`s`jt pdrsej`noty* Ejd mobgt jet `brdd wotg gos epoj-
oejs. gos vodws. tgd `htovotods ef tgd mdj wotg wgem gd w`s `nnodi oj
sddlojb te ujotd Hgoj` ujidr J`toej`nosm<aut gos pdrsej`noty ej forst
`hqu`ojt`jhd w`s hdrt`ojny jet `b`ojst gom*
Ygd J`toej`nost rdvenutoej wonn hejtojud `s pn`jjdi%" gd s`oi oj
rdpny te my jdxt qudstoej* ""Rd wonn jet pdrmot tgd idfdhtoej ef
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl te step us* Rd wonn id`n wotg gom n`tdr* Oj tgd
md`jtomd wd pn`j te prehddi wotg eur irovd te tgd jertg* O tgojl
yeu wonn foji semdtgojb ojtdrdstojb g`ppdjojb oj tgd jdxt fdw wddls*
O ie jet s`y mejtgs. aut wddls* Rd `nrd`iy g`vd tgd newdr g`nf. er
merd. ef Gej`j Srevojhd* Hg`jb Yse-noj"s `rmods geni aut ` sh`jt
sdhtoej ej tgd jertg* Rd wonn seej hejtren `nn ef Gej`j*
M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb os wotg us* Gd wonn jet st`y wotg
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl* Gd os jew oj Xgdjso* Eur ferhds wonn hemaojd
`ji irovd Hg`jb Yse-noj a`hl ojte M`jhguro`* Ot wonn jet ad nejb*
@ fdw wddls* Ojtdrdstojb idvdnepmdjts `rd `t g`ji* Rd eroboj`nny
pn`jjdi te prehddi ej Sdlojb vo` G`jlew* Ygd spnotoj tgd p`rty g`s
h`usdi ` tdmper`ry idn`y* Jew. wd `rd ej tgd m`rhg*
UHgdj s`oi tg`t tgd ard`hg wotg Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl g`i addj nejb
dxpdhtdi* Ygd pn`j ef tgd rdvenutoej. gd s`oi. jdvdr g`i addj te t`ld
+4fo`jbg`o er J`jlojb oj 0?12* Forst. gd s`oi. tgdy w`jtdi te bdt te
Sdlojb ojn`ji* J`jlojb oj p`rtohun`r g`i. tgd Mojostdr s`oi d`rjdst-
ny. ferdvdr addj. ` Jdmdsos. ` hoty ef onn emdj te rdvenutoejs* Aut
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl turjdi `b`ojst `ivohds frem tgd Bevdrjmdjt* Gdh`nndi Hgo`jb ` rdadn `ji ` monot`rost ef tgd eni shgeen. eut fer
pdrsej`n b`oj `ji bnery* Ygd spnot. Hgdj ojsostdi. os foj`n. tgdrd
os je ieuat ef ot* Rd wonn id`n wotg Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl wgdj ejhd wd
bdt Sdlojb* Gd g`s ejny 83.333 mdj `t tgd mest. `ji tgdy wonn ad
ldpt ausy wotg tgd Jertgdrj treeps* Rd iej"t fd`r tgdor `tt`hlojb
G`jlew%"
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 94/455
?9 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygdsd foburds. ef heursd. v`rodi dxtr`erioj`rony frem foburds bovdj
d`rnodr tg`t sprojb ay Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl"s `igdrdjts* Ygd
J`jlojb
anehl `ssdrtdi tg`t G`jlew g`i fdw mdj* Ot w`s ompes-
soand te heujt tgdm. se O h`j aut rdn`td wg`t d`hg soid idhn`rdi tgdj*
Oj 0?12 ejd heuni ejny `w`ot idvdnepmdjts te idtdrmojd wgohg soid
w`s herrdht* Hgdj. ef heursd. nest eut. `ji g`i te fndd n`tdr tg`t s`md
yd`r aut gd heuni jet ferdsdd tgesd dvdjts tgdj*
Ejd rd`sej tgd Mojostdr s`oi tgd Bevdrjmdjt g`i eppesdi t`lojb
Xg`jbg`o ujton n`tdr w`s tgd i`jbdr ef hejfnoht wotg ferdobj treeps
tgdrd* Gd s`oi tg`t tgd geniojb ef Xg`jbg`o ay tgd Sewdrs wotg
ferhd w`s `b`ojst tgd projhopnds ef J`toej`nosm"2
oj Hgoj`< tg`t ot
w`s `j ojtendr`and sotu`toej. `ji ` hg`nndjbd te Hgoj`"s sev-
drdobjty* Gdjhd. tgd treeps must be. Hgdj s`oi. `ji wotg tgd
J`toej`nosts oj hejtren tgdy must. te ad trud te tgdor h`usd. idm`ji
tg`t tgd treeps idp`rt* Ygdy ioi m`ld tgdor idm`ji. aut tgd treeps
rdm`ojdi*
Gd s`oi Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl g`i ioseadydi eridrs oj t`lojb Xg`jb-
g`o. `ji gos Bevdrjmdjt oj G`jlew w`s jet rdspejsoand fer wg`t
mobgt ehhur jdxt* Ygd m`ttdr ef tgd ferdobj Xdttndmdjt `ji tgd
Frdjhg Hejhdssoej tgdrd gd fdnt weuni g`vd te `w`ot tgd tomd wgdj
G`jlew hejtrens tg`t p`rt ef Hgoj`. `s wdnn `s Sdlojb*
Ygd ferdobj Sewdrs idfd`t tgdor ewj dji oj sdjiojb treeps te
Hgoj`. Hgdj `iidi* Ygd prdsdjhd ef tgesd treeps g`s iejd merd
te `reusd tgd pdepnd ef Hgoj` `b`ojst ferdobj ompdro`nosm tg`j `nn eur
prep`b`ji` dvdr heuni g`vd gepdi te ie* Ot md`js Hgoj` os jet frdd*
Je j`toej tg`t g`s ots heujtry vortu`nny ruj ay ferdobjdrs os frdd*
Ygd supdr-bevdrjmdjt ef Hgoj` g`s addj tgd Iopnem`toh Herps `t
Sdlojb* Oj Xg`jbg`o. ef heursd. tgdrd os tgd neh`n bevdrjmdjt oj
tgd Xdttndmdjt* Ots iuty os te penohd tgdhoty* O h`nn ot ` sh`vdjbdr
bevdrjmdjt ot lddps tgojbs hnd`j*
Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds. Hgdj s`oi. w`s m`lojb ` brd`t most`ld oj
adojb. `s gd s`w ot. mosndi ay tgd Arotosg ojte fennewojb tgdor nd`i oj
Hgoj`* Tjton @mdroh` sdjt treeps eut te Xg`jbg`o. gd s`oi. tgd
Hgojdsd g`i neeldi upej tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds `s ` frodji* Gewdvdr.
jew tg`t sgd g`i keojdi Arot`oj oj usojb ferhd. gd s`oi ot w`s ioffo-
hunt te hejtojud te m`ojt`oj eur tr`iotoej`nfrodjisgop wotg tgd @mdr-
oh`j pdepnd* Hgdj w`s aerj oj Yrojoi`i. `ji w`s ` Arotosg suakdht
aut gd idjeujhdi Brd`t Arot`oj*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 95/455
QDI QTND @Y G@JLER ?4
Hgdj s`oi dmpg`toh`nny tg`t tgd G`jlew Bevdrjmdjt w`s jet
Hemmujostoh* Gd idjodi rdperts wgohg wdrd hemmej oj Xg`jbg`o.
tg`t tgd projhopnds ef tgd Luemojt`jb oj G`jlew wdrd adojb henerdi
rdi*
Rd `rd kust jew t`hlnojb oj tgd G`jlew Bevdrjmdjt tgd dhe-
jemoh qudstoejs f`hojb us. tgd Ferdobj Mojostdr s`oi* Rd `rd
`ivosojb tgd werldrs tg`t ot os adst te adttdr tgdor pesotoej br`iu`nny
`ji jet sddl te eat`oj `t ejhd ` 033 pdr hdjt ojhrd`sd oj w`bds* Eurs
os ` werldrs" `ji pd`s`jts" rdvenutoej* Ygdy g`vd werldi fer m`jy
bdjdr`toejs `t w`bds tee new `nmest te pdrmot tgdm te dxost* Of `
m`j bdts sohl `ji os eut ef werl. gd `ji gos wgend f`mony must st`rvd*
Yg`t os jet robgt* Rd w`jt te hg`jbd tg`t. `ji wd tgojl tgd werldrs
`rd djtotndi te adttdr trd`tmdjt*
Ygd n`aer ujoejs tgdmsdnvds `rd t`lojb rdspejsoaonoty ef hejtren-
nojb tgd werldrs* N`aer nd`idrs `rd oj hejtren ef tgd sotu`toej* Ygdy
`rd `ivosojb tgd werldrs te be snew `ji t`ld br`iu`n ojhrd`sds*
Ej tgd f`rms. tgojbs `rd ioffdrdjt* Oj Guj`j. ot os trud wd g`vd
trodi tgd dxpdromdjt ef iovoiojb up n`ji* @ m`j wonn ad ` adttdr
hotozdj of gd os ` n`ji ewjdr* Gd wonn fobgt fer gos n`ji* Gdjhd. wd
`rd tryojb ot eut te sdd gew ot werls* Yg`t. je ieuat. os wgdrd tgdsd
rumers `aeut eur Hemmujostoh projhopnds eroboj`td* Hgoj` jdvdr wonn
ad Hemmujostoh* Rd wonn jet ie `w`y wotg prov`td ewjdrsgop ef
prepdrty* Ygd f`ht tg`t tgd pd`s`jt ewjs n`ji wonn. wd adnodvd. m`ld
gom ` adttdr hotozdj*
Hgdj s`oi tg`t ferdobjdrs oj Hgoj` wdrd hemp`r`tovdny s`fd* Gds`oi tg`t tgdy wdrd `s s`fd oj G`jlew `s oj Jdw _erl* Gdjhd. gd
w`s aottdr `b`ojst w`rsgops adojb sdjt tgdrd* Ygdy ejny `bbr`v`td tgd
Hgojdsd%" gd s`oi* Gd `iidi tg`t tgdy wdrd jet jddidi* Ygos
areubgt up tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt. `ji tgd pesotoej ef ferdobjdrs oj
Hgoj` oj bdjdr`n*
Ferdobjdrs oj Hgoj` `rd. `s ` rund. s`fd frem `jy g`rm. Hgdj
`vewdi* Oj tgd h`sd ef
J`jlojb.wd ie jet
`hhdpt buontfer wg`t-
dvdr g`ppdjdi iurojb tgd t`lojb ef tg`t hoty* Rd wonn. ef heursd. p`y
fer `jy i`m`bd iejd te tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td `t J`jlojb*
Aut tgd hg`rbd tg`t wd idnoadr`tdny erb`jozdi tgd `tt`hl ej fer-
dobjdrs tgdrd wd ie mest hdrt`ojny idjy* Ygd ejny w`y te sdttnd tgd
m`ttdr. `s wd sdd ot. os te g`vd `j ojvdstob`toej* Yg`t os tgd w`y
tgdsd tgojbs `rd iejd oj `jy etgdr heujtry* Rgy jet oj Hgoj`5
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 96/455
?6 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Hgdj `b`oj rdfdrrdi te st`tdmdjts. m`id ay tgd J`t"ej`nosts. tg`t
m`jy tgeus`jis ef Jertgdrj treeps wdrd stonn oj J`jlojb wgdj tgd
H`jtejdsd
h`pturdi
tgd hoty* Gd ompnodi tg`t tgdsd mdj wdrd merd
noldny tgd ejds buonty ef tgd neetojb* Ot w`s peojtdi eut tg`t @mdro-
h`js `ji Arotosg hemojb frem J`jlojb g`i swerj tgd `tt`hl w`s ay
mdj oj J`toej`nost ujoferms. hgodfny frem Guj`j Srevojhd* Hgdj
tgdj s`oi tgd ejny w`y te sdttnd tgd `ff`or w`s te g`vd `j ojtdrj`toej`n
hemmottdd neel ojte ot* Ygd Mojostdr s`oi Hgoj` w`jtdi ferdobjdrs
te rdm`oj* Gd s`oi `nse. gewdvdr. tg`t tgdrd w`s ` rdvenutoej oj
Hgoj` `ji tg`t ot mobgt `t tomds ad i`jbdreus* Of ferdobjdrs tgeubgt
ot tee i`jbdreus. tgdy sgeuni nd`vd. gd s`oi< aut gd dmpg`sozdi tg`t
tgd Hgojdsd wdrd9>
jet `jto-ferdobj `ji ie jet w`jt tgd ferdobjdrs
te idp`rt*
Rd w`jt tgdm te rdm`oj. Hgdj `iidi* Rd `rd jet fobgtojb
tgd ferdobjdrs* Rd `rd idtdrmojdi. gewdvdr. te ie `w`y wotg tgd
Ompdro`nostoh penohods ef ferdobj bevdrjmdjts tew`ri eur heujtry* Rd
w`jt eur heujtry a`hl* Rd w`jt tgd ujdqu`n trd`tods `aenosgdi. `nejb
wotg dxtr`-tdrrotero`noty* Rd `rd rd`iy te prevd eursdnvds `and te
g`jind eur j`toej jew* Rd"i nold tgd hg`jhd%"
Hemr`id Mol`n Aereioj w`s tgd iemoj`tojb foburd oj tgd G`jlew
Bevdrjmdjt iurojb ots rehldt-nold h`rddr* Gd w`s iyj`moh gd`i ef
tgd Qusso`j @ivoser`td `ji iordhtdi tgd merd r`ioh`n ar`jhg ef tgd
Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej* Gd hejtrenndi G`jlew"s rdbomd fer ` tomd
oj tgd i`ys wgdj ot w`s `t ots pd`l. `ji tgd Qdis rundi oj Hgoj`*
Gos weri w`s n`w. `ji gd w`s f`r frem sondjt* Gd m`id fdw spddhgds
er puanoh `ppd`r`jhds <aut gd w`s tgd pewdr adgoji tgd tgrejd*
Ot w`s tee beei te n`st< `ji wgdj tgd wgddn ef fertujd turjdi
`aruptny `b`ojst gom. Aereioj aewdi te tgd ojdvot`and `ji fndi evdr-
n`ji tgreubg Mejbeno` te Xoadro` `ji m`id tgd nejb trdl te Meshew*
Gos h`rddr ef pewdr oj @so` w`s arodf aut spdht`hun`r `ji oj `nn w`ys
`asenutd* Ot w`s tgos n`st f`ht tg`t h`usdi gos f`nn Hgojdsd ndi ay
Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl s`w tgd emjopetdjhd ef Meshew `s
dxdmpnofodi ay Aereioj. ots `bdjt < se tgdy tgrdw gom eut* Gd adh`md
`j dioter oj Meshew*
@t tgd gdobgt ef gos mossoej oj G`jlew. Aereioj w`s ` werni
foburd* Gd w`s ` rdvenutoej`ry frem gos yeutg. `ji dvdj adferd tgd
KO?02Qdvenutoej oj Qusso`. g`i addj ferhdi te fndd gos j`tovd n`ji*
Gd wdjt te tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds adferd tgd Rerni R`r `ji `ttdjidi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 97/455
QDI QTND @Y G@JLER ?2
shgeen `t V`np`r`ose Tjovdrsoty oj Ojio`j`* Gd mdt gos wofd. `
shgeen td`hgdr. oj Hgoh`be. `ji `ftdr tgdor m`rro`bd gd hejiuhtdi `
Xhgeen ef Senotoh`n Dhejemy* Gos j`md os Adrb. O adnodvd. `ji gd
`ji gos wofd r`j tgd shgeen ujidr tg`t j`md* Gd rdturjdi te Qusso`
`t tgd tomd ef tgd 0?02 rdvenutoej* Dvdjtu`nny. gd teel tgd j`md
Aereioj 'er w`s Adrb `ssumdi 5/ `ji w`s bovdj tgd mossoej oj Hgoj`*
J`tur`nny. O w`jtdi te sdd gom oj G`jlew* Ygd `ppeojtmdjt w`s
`rr`jbdi ay Q`yj` Sregmd. ` iyj`moh yeujb wem`j frem Hgoh`be.
tgdj diotojb Ygd Sdepnd"s Yroaujd. erb`j ef tgd Qdi rund* Xgd w`s
tgd wofd ef Ronno`m Sregmd. `jetgdr keurj`nost ef r`rd
ojtdnnobdjhdwge `t tg`t tomd w`s gd`i ef tgd J`toej`nost Jdws @bdjhy ` prep`-
b`ji` erb`joz`toej oj Xg`jbg`o* Aetg `rd jew id`i* Q`yj` '`s
dvdryejd h`md te ljew tgos quotd `m`zojb bornwotg gdr sgehl ef
fn`mojb rdi g`or/ iodi semd yd`rs `be oj Meshew ef evdrwerl `ji
ar`oj fdvdr< Aonn iodi oj 0?84 oj Gejenunu. `ftdr suffdrojb fer yd`rs
frem ` punmej`ry onnjdss* Idspotd penotoh`n ioffdrdjhds. `nn wge mdt
Q`yj` `ji Aonn wdrd ojfnudjhdi ay tgdor pdrsej`notods `ji tgdor hn`roty
ef vosoej*
Oj G`jlew. Q`yj` w`s vdry muhg `novd `ji `rr`jbdi my djtrdd
te tgd brd`t m`j"s s`jhtum tg`t wddl oj n`td @pron wotg je `pp`rdjt
treuand* Xgd s`oi; ""_eu w`jt te sdd Aereioj5 El`y. O"nn sdd wg`t
h`j ad iejd* O bet ` jetd tgd tgori i`y O w`s oj G`jlew. tdnnojb
md tg`t tgd mddtojb g`i addj `rr`jbdi* Aereioj g`i effohds ej tgd
sdheji fneer ef ` auoniojb oj tgd eni Bdrm`j Hejhdssoej 'sdozdi ay
tgd Hgojdsd oj tgd Rerni R`r/* @ftdr w`otojb g`nf `j geur. O w`s
usgdrdi ojte gos prdsdjhd Gd w`s `aeut fofty. t`nn. gd`vy aut wdnn
auont. wotg ` tgohl m`jd ef an`hl g`or* Gd g`i ` fnewojb an`hl mus-
t`hgd. sdttojb eff ` f`hd m`rldi ay `j `quonojd jesd `ji h`jioi i`rl
dyds* Rgond O w`s tgdrd. Aereioj streid rdstndssny `aeut. suhlojb `
popd* Gd speld venuany. `ji oj pdrfdht Djbnosg* Gd w`s `j ompesojb
foburd.novojb up
te gos rdput`toej fer s`b`hoty `s wdnn `s fd`rndssjdss*
O `sldi Aereioj gew gd g`ppdjdi te keoj tgd Hgojdsd rdvenutoej`ry
mevdmdjt*
"Ygd n`td Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj ojvotdi md te hemd te Hgoj` feur yd`rs
`be. gd s`oi* O `m oj tgdor rdvenutoej `s `j ojiovoiu`n tgeubg
j`tur`nny O g`vd my ewj oid`s fer hejiuhtojb ot fer tgd beei ef tgdor
pdepnd* O g`vd je hejjdhtoej wotg Meshew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 98/455
?7 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Aereioj s`oi tg`t tgdrd heuni ad je truny Hemmujost Xt`td oj
Hgoj` `t tg`t tomd*
Of tgd Hemmujost S`rty ef Hgoj` wdrd adojb j`mdi tei`y. gd
s`oi. ot heuni jet ad h`nndi Hemmujost* O g`vd feuji ot os ompessoand
te hemmujozd tgd Hgojdsd sompny adh`usd ot os jet pessoand te hem-
mujozd pevdrty* Ygd Hgojdsd pdepnds `rd ioffdrdjt frem tgd Qusso`js
er tgd @mdroh`js* Ot mobgt ad pessoand te hemmujozd tgd Tjotdi
Xt`tds. wgdrd yeu g`vd v`st wd`ntg `ji prepdrty h`j ad hemmuj`n.
er ewjdi ay tgd hemmujoty* KKutHgoj` os pevdrty-strohldj* Hem-
mujosm 'oj ots purd sdjsd/ os ompessoand* Gdjhd. eur tgderods `rd
hg`jbdi* Rd sddl. ef heursd. te `oi tgd pnobgt ef n`aerdrs `ji tgd
f`jjdr. er pd`s`jt. hn`ssds*
Ygd spnot wgohg w`s te evdrtgrew gom se swoftny w`s dxpn`ojdi
frem gos peojt ef vodw*
>9Rd areld wotg J`jlojb. er Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. fer twe
m`ker rd`sejs. gd s`oi* Forst. Hgo`jb adb`j tgd Jertgdrj Dxpdio-
toej frem H`jtej oj 0?16 wotg 43.333 mdj* Gd rd`hgdi tgd _`jbtzd
V`nndy wotg 933.333 treeps* Oj tg`t v`st `rmy tgdrd wdrd sherds ef
r`aand wge keojdi te s`vd tgdor jdhls* Ygdor effohdrs wdrd jet oj-
spordi wotg tgd purpesds ef tgos rdvenutoej tgdy ojfnudjhdi Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl te sdozd Xg`jbg`o. sendny te fonn tgdor ewj pehldts wotg beni*
Xdheji. Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl h`md ujidr tgd ojfnudjhd ef
tgd mdrhg`jts `ji hempr`ierd hn`ss oj Xg`jbg`o* Gd bet ` fdw mon-
noej ienn`rs frem tgdm `ji `brddi te geni iewj n`aer se tgd brddiy
mobgt hejtojud te w`x f`t `ji wd`ntgodr* Hgo`jb w`s `nse sw`ydi ay
tgd ferdobj a`jls `ji os nest oj tgd sg`iews ef tgesd ojoquoteus
tdmpnds ef tgd mejdy-hg`jbdrs oj Xg`jbg`o* Gdjhd. `s f`r `s tgd
Hgojdsd mevdmdjt. er rdvenutoej. os hejhdrjdi. gd os ieemdi*
Aut fer ejhd. Aereioj drrdi* Gd. jet Hgo`jb. w`s tgd ieemdi
m`j. `s ` rdvenutoej`ry oj Hgoj`*
Gd dxpn`ojdi gos `ttotuid tew`ri tgd ferdobj Sewdrs*
Of tgd Sewdrs sdd oj Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl ` sdheji M`rsg`n Hg`jbYse-noj tgdy wonn try te tgrew Hgoj` a`hl ojte hg`es. `ji `jto-ferdobj-
osm wonn hejtojud ojidfojotdny* Ygos rdvenutoej wonn jet dji tgdrd*
Ygdsd pdepnds `rd `reusdi* Memdjt`rony steppdi. tgdy wonn hejtojud
tew`ri tgdor idstojy anojiny `t tomds. yds< aut tgdy wonn hejtojud
tew`ri tgd be`n wd jew idsord* Ot os ojdvot`and* Ye `oi tgdm `ji
us. tgd Sewdrs sgeuni jew rdhebjozd tgd J`toej`nost Bevdrjmdjt
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 99/455
QDI QTND @Y G@JLER ??
gdrd oj G`jlew* Ot os fer yeur bevdrjmdjt oj R`sgojbtej. fer `jy
ferdobj bevdrjmdjt. te m`ld up ots moji wgohg os Hgoj`"s trud bev-
drjmdjt. adst dquoppdi te nd`i tgdsd pdepnds tew`ri `hgodvdmdjt ef
tgdor be`n* Of tgdy h`jjet m`ld up tgdor mojis. turmeon wonn pdrsost
`ji prdsdjt hejiotoejs oj Hgoj` wonn rdm`oj ojidfojotdny*
Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds sddms te ad brewojb `s ompdro`nostoh `s Brd`t
Arot`oj g`s addj fer tgd p`st hdjtury* Rgy a`hl `jy f`htoejs5 Rdnn.
wgy ie yeu a`hl ejd soid oj Joh`r`bu` `ji jet tgd etgdr5 _eu
suppert f`htoejs tgdrd sompny adh`usd yeu g`vd spdho`n ojtdrdsts oj
Hdjtr`n @mdroh`. `ji `nn N`toj @mdroh`* _eu `rd `j ompdro`nostoh
j`toej*
*Ygd m`j ojsostdi tg`t tgd purpesd ef tgd Hgojdsd rdvenutoej w`s
prom`rony te `oi n`aerdrs `ji mdj `ji wemdj ej tgd f`rms* Ygdsd
seho`n preandms must ad senvdi. gd s`oi. adferd tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds
heuni adhemd ujotdi* Ygd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej. `s vodwdi ay gom.
w`s ` f`rm rdnodf prebr`m ` keojt F`rmdr-N`aer Mevdmdjt. oj ots
gobgdst sdjsd* Gos idsord sddmdi te ad te `oi tgd Hgojdsd oj tgdor
ojiustro`n rdvenutoej. somon`r te tgd ejd oj Djbn`ji `ji @mdroh` ef
tgd p`st gujirdi yd`rs< te `oi tgdm te adhemd `j ojiustro`n j`toej.
`ji tgus effdr ` brd`tdr m`rldt fer f`rm preiuhts ef dvdry sert*
Ygus tgd ydnnew m`j heuni dmdrbd `s ` pewdr ej d`rtg*
Aereioj ojvotdi md te nujhg `t gos `p`rtmdjt ` i`y er se n`tdr*
@t tg`t tomd gd put eut ` fddndr tew`ri `j @mdroh`j ne`j te tgd
G`jlew Bevdrjmdjt. dmpg`sozojb `ji rdotdr`tojb tg`t Hgoj` w`s
bdttojb je mejdy frem Meshew `t tg`t tomd* O g`i `sldi of Meshew
weuni jet ad ` adttdr prespdht. er of tgdy wdrd jet bdttojb rdvdjud
tgdrd*
Jet ejd hdjt. Aereioj s`oi. `asenutdny jet ` hdjt* Ygd Xevodt
Tjoej os `nw`ys r`tgdr dhejemoh`n* Rd `rd spdjiojb `reuji )133.-
333.333 Mdx* ` yd`r gdrd oj tgos rdvenutoej* Rd h`j bdt tgos frem
v`roeus t`xds. ef heursd. oj tomd* Gd ojsostdi G`jlew w`s beei
fer tgd gord ef tgd mejdy. `ji hdrt`ojny weuni mddt gdr ferdobj
idats* Rd idsord te st`aonozd eur hrdiot `are`i. gd s`oi* Rd g`vd
je oid` ef rdjeujhojb eur idats. er tgesd wd m`y ojhur*
Furtgdrmerd. yeu wdrd jet steppdi ay tgd aebdy ef "sdhuroty" oj
tgd h`sd ef Durepd iurojb tgd Rerni R`r* Rg`t sdhuroty ioi @mdr-
oh` g`vd tgdj5 Jejd! Rotg ` ne`j. wd heuni rdfuji Hgoj`"s j`-
toej`n idat< `ji wd weuni p`y ot eff oj ` hdrt`oj pdroei ef tomd. s`y
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 100/455
033 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
g`nf ` hdjtury tgd s`md `s Fr`jhd. er `jy etgdr j`toej* @mdroh`
jddi g`vd je fd`r ef n`hl ef sdhuroty gdrd*
Frem n`tdr gostery hejhdrjojb ojtdrj`toej`n eanob`toejs. ot weuni
`ppd`r tg`t Aereioj"s epojoejs wdrd jet se f`r-fdthgdi `s tgdy sddmdi
oj G`jlew tgdj* Aut jetgojb dvdr h`md ef tg`t vosoej`ry shgdmd oj
Hgoj`< `t nd`st. jet fer tgd Hemmujost-hejtrenndi rdbomd f`r up tgd
_`jbtzd*
@s ejd vot`n rdsunt ef tgd merd ndjodjt `ttotuid tew`ri ferdobj-
drs. tgd tojy henejy ef ferdobjdrs h`rrodi ej nofd oj G`jlew vortu`nny
tgd s`md `s adferd tgd Hgojdsd strubbnd* @soid frem tgd f`ht tg`t
ausojdss steei `nmest oind. tgd mdj `ji tgd fdw wemdj wdjt `aeut
tgdor i`ony nofd ujmendstdi* V`roeus hnuas wdrd epdj* A`rs wdrd `n-
w`ys jd`rny funn* @t jeej `ji oj tgd dvdjojb tgd Frdjhg Hnua `ji
tgd G`jlew Hnua wdrd tgd mest pepun`r* Ygd ad`utofun G`jlew
Q`hd Hnua g`i ots usu`n td`-i`jhds. wotg ` ferdobj erhgdstr` d`hg
dvdjojb* Ygd benf heursd w`s oj usd `ji tgd tdjjos heurts ehhupodi
aut tgd wgend tgojb rdmojidi md ef ` sldndtej struttojb `aeut* Oj
jerm`n tomds tg`t v`st hnua os tgd mddtojb-pn`hd ef 133 er 833 pdrsejs
d`hg `ftdrjeej* Oj tgesd i`ys. pdrg`ps ` sherd er se b`tgdrdi tgdrd.
tgd ejny wemdj adojb Bdrm`js* Ygdrd wdrd 23 @mdroh`js stonn oj
G`jlew. 033 Arotosg. `aeut 433 K`p`jdsd `ji 143 Bdrm`js* K`p`jdsd
ausojdss rdepdjdi ` fdw i`ys n`tdr*
Ygd K`p`jdsd m`id tgd formdst st`ji `ji rdfusdi G`jlew"s id-
m`ji fer tgd rdmev`n ef tgdor `rmdi bu`ris `s wdnn `s tgdor a`radi
word `ji s`jia`bs* Ygd K`p`jdsd Hejhdssoej w`s rdmojoshdjt ef
Xg`jbg`o. `ji p`ssds wdrd rdquordi te djtdr* Ygd rdst ef G`jlew.
gewdvdr. w`s woid epdj* J`toej`nost seniodrs `ji effohdrs struttdi
`aeut tgd strddts dvdrywgdrd* Ygeus`jis ef ferdobj s`oners `ae`ri
w`rsgops oj tgd g`raer wdrd jet pdrmottdi sgerd nd`vd fer wddls ad-
h`usd ef `j ojhoidjt oj tgd K`p`jdsd Hejhdssoej* A`jls rdm`ojdi
hnesdi. aut dvdjtu`nny tgd mdj oj tgd G`jlew Bevdrjmdjt feuji `
w`y te pdrmot tgdm te epdr`td `t ` prefot. idspotd tgd tdmper`ry sonvdr
dma`rbe*
Ygd ejny ferdobj jdwsp`pdr tgdrd tgdj w`s Ygd Sdepnd"s Yroaujd.
puanosgdi ay tgd bevdrjmdjt* Gewdvdr. Ygd G`jlew Gdr`ni rd-
epdjdi wotg ots forst jdw ossud tgd jdxt Froi`y merjojb `ftdr my`rrov`n* Ygdrd w`s je steppojb Aruje Xhgw`rtz. tgd dioter `ji pua-
nosgdr ef tgos woid-`w`ld @mdroh`j i`ony* Ygd rdepdjojb ef tgd a`jls.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 101/455
QDI QTND @Y G@J QER 030
`s wdnn `s tgd rdturj ef m`jy K`p`jdsd. ojioh`tdi ` bdjdr`n ndssdjojb
ef tgd tdjsoej. `t nd`st tdmper`rony* Xeej ot w`s je nejbdr i`jbdreus
te w`nl `aeut `t jobgt `jywgdrd. dxhdpt oj tgd j`tovd hoty* Ygd
Frdjhg Hejhdssoej w`s jet teuhgdi. @jj`motds penohojb tgd strddts `s
tgdy ioi oj Xg`jbg`o* Ygd mevods wdrd rujjojb jobgtny* Ferdobjdrs.
dspdho`nny @mdroh`js. mevdi a`hl ojte tgdor gemds* Ygd @mdroh`j
Hejsun`td jew g`i ejny mysdnf `s budst oj ` a`rr`hls-stynd qu`rtdrs
ej tgd tgori fneer* O sndpt ej `j orej het sgoppdi tgdrd frem Ldjesg`.
Roshejsoj*
Ygdbevdrjmdjt-ewjdi tdndbr`pg
nojds wdrdepdr`tojb.
aut tgdor
fujhtoejojb w`s ujs`tosf`htery* Srovondbds te w`r herrdspejidjts te
sdji tgdor mdss`bds henndht wdrd h`jhdnndi. fer tgd G`jlew effohd ioi
jet heepdr`td wotg J`jlojb `ji Xg`jbg`o iurojb tgd spnot wotg tgd
Luemojt`jb nd`idrs iewj tgd _`jbtzd* Iosp`thgds g`i te be eut ay
mdssdjbdr ej ae`ri `j ehh`soej`n Arotosg rovdr std`mdr. er tgreubg `
ferdobj idstreydr beojb eut te tgd he`st* Ygdy wdrd rdn`ydi `are`i
ay h`and frem Xg`jbg`o. aut wdrd ojv`ro`any sdvdr`n i`ys er dvdj `
fertjobgt n`td. of idnovdrdi `t `nn*
Get `ji p`jtojb heenods. `nrd`iy jeosy `ji iorty djeubg adjd`tg
n`ydrs ef pdjdtr`tojb rdi iust wgohg resd frem hn`y ef tgd rovdr
a`jls. sw`rmdi tgd strddts oj v`roeus st`bds ef ujirdss* Ygdy peppdi
tgd ojdvot`and Hgojdsd fordhr`hldrs dvdrywgdrd i`y `ji jobgt. `iiojb
te tgd ioj ef G`jlew `t tgd st`rt ef tg`t jobgtm`rosg summdr* Ygdor
hejtroautoej te tgd hejfusoej ef i`ony dxostdjhd '`ji tgd w`y tgdy b`vd
tgd nod te tgd pepun`r Rdstdrj adnodf oj tgd ojshrut`aonoty ef tgd so-
ndjt Erodjt`n"+ w`s ` tgojb te adgeni!/ w`s je `oi te tgd jdrvds. `nrd`iy
kumpy `ji fr`ydi ay dvdjts oj rdhdjt wddls*
Ygd _`jbtzd w`s ` rdm`rl`and sobgt tgdj. ujnold `jytgojb adferd
er sojhd* Ygd are`i strd`m w`s notdr`nny hr`mmdi wotg w`rsgops ef
m`jy j`toejs* Ygdor omprdssovdjdss h`jjet ad dx`bbdr`tdi* Frem
mywojiew oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds
Hejsun`td.ot sddmdi
`bnew`t
jobgt*
Nobgts frem m`jy hr`ft bnd`mdi tgreubg tgd i`rljdss. `ji tgd mdj
ej ae`ri sdjt frdqudjt sobj`ns te ejd `jetgdr* Eftdj tgdsd j`v`n
sobj`ns wdrd mdrdny semd sgop"s effohdrojvotojb `jetgdr te toffoj tgd
jdxt i`y. aut ot ioij"t m`ttdr tgdrd w`s mystdry `ji `wd oj tgd sobgt*
Sewdrfun sd`rhgnobgts pddrdi evdr tgd strd`m"s surf`hd fer str`jbd
eakdhts wgohg wdrd eftdj `fne`t ej tg`t i`rl rovdr"s sojostdr hurrdjt
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 102/455
031 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygdsd `iidi tgdor fojbdrs ef an`zd te tgd wgend ` teuhg ef tgd
Jertgdrj nobgts oj dffdht*
Oj ` sgert tomd O w`s te rdturj te Xg`jbg`o `ji tgd trustwertgo-
jdss ef ` ferdobj-ruj h`and-gd`i tgdrd* Kujd g`i kust ir`wj tgd hur-
t`oj ej gdr dvdjtfun wddls wgdj O gd`idi a`hl iewj tgd _`jbtzd.
jet wotgeut ` sobg ef rdnodf*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 103/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY
YGDHgrosto`j Bdjdr`n%" M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb. w`s a`hl
frem ` sekeurj oj Meshew* Ygdrd wdrd rumers tg`t gd mobgt
hejfdr wotg Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl semdwgdrd jd`r tgd
Frejt oj tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej"s `iv`jhd tew`ri tgd jertg* Gos
pesotoej oj tgd J`jlojb-G`jlew spnot w`s vot`n te Hgoj`"s rdvent*
My t`sl w`s te ioshevdr wg`t ot w`s frem tgd `stutd M`rsg`n oj pdr-
sej. of pessoand* Oj ndss tg`j twe wddls. gd h`md d`st te mddt Bdj-
dr`n Hgo`jb `t Gsuhgew-fu. oj Lo`jbsu Srevojhd. jd`r tgd Xg`jtujb
aeridr*
Xe O wdjt tgdrd `nse*
Mystdry survovds aut f`ojtny oj tgd gd`rt ef Hgoj`* Oj Kujd 0?12.
wotg twe etgdr ferdobj herrdspejidjts O spdjt ` fertjobgt oj tgd ojtd-
roer* Rd vosotdi tgd w`r frejt `ji wd tr`vdndi gujirdis ef monds
tgreubg ` n`ji ef f`rmdrs* Sd`s`jts `t werl oj pd`hdfun v`nndys `rd
jet bn`mereus< `ji t`nds ef i`ys wgdj `jhodjt tyr`jts rundi `ji
w`rrdi. `ji tgos n`ji ef tgd Ir`bej w`s ujljewj te ` wejidrojb
Rdst. f`idi oj tgd w`rm sujsgojd ef Kujd"s meidrj i`ys*
Eni tdmpnds stonn dxostdi `ji tewdrojb p`bei`s rd`rdi tgdor sterodi
fojbdrs ojte tgd anud< aut tgd tdmpnds rettdi go idh`y. sldndtejs ef `j
enidr bnery. ehhupodi ay treeps wge. nold br`y r`ts. shuttndi oj `ji eut
ef v`h`jt ieers* Ygd p`bei`s. ejd fdnt. must g`vd addj usdi `s sones
fer tgd br`oj Hgoj`"s benidj g`rvdst wgohg. nold gdr beni oj `jetgdr
i`y. w`s s`ppdi frem ots seurhd te prevoid tgd dvdr-iomojosgojb sojdws
ef w`r se tg`t tgd
Luemojt`jbQdvenutoej
mobgt beej*
Hgoj`. oj adojb aerj `b`oj. idstreydi dvdry vdstobd ef gdr fermdr
sdnf* Ygd ir`bej sguffndi eff ots `jhodjt heon* Ygd prehdss os tr`boh.
ydt ` vodw ef ot `t hnesd r`jbd oj 0?12 g`i ots mdrots oj ` sdrods ef
quddr dxpdrodjhds oj tgd D`st*
Rd wdrd tgrdd ej tg`t dxpdiotoej te qu`ojt Gsuhgew-fu. oj tgd
dxtrdmd jertgdrj top ef Lo`jbsu Srevojhd. jd`r tgd Xg`jtujb Srevojhd
038
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 104/455
039 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
aeridr. wgdrd tgd J`jlojb J`toej`nost nojd g`i addj pusgojb br`iu-
`nny jertgw`ri `ji d`stw`ri te tgd S`hofoh* Iurojb tgd djtord trop wd
jetohdi jet tgd snobgtdst `jto-ferdobjosm `mejb tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd.
idspotd tgd tgereubg-beojb prep`b`ji` ef tgd J`jlojb `utgerotods
`b`ojst wg`t tgdy tdrmdi ""ompdro`nosts%" wgohg tgd `vdr`bd Hgojdsd
j`tur`nny dxpdhtdi te ojhnuid `nn ferdobjdrs* Ygd prep`b`ji` pestdrs
wdrd dvdrywgdrd* Mest ef tgdm wdrd onnustr`tdi. oj eridr tg`t tgd
onnotdr`td Hgojdsd 'tgd v`st m`keroty ef tgd pdepnd/ mobgt bdt semd
f`ojt oid` ef wg`t ot w`s `nn `aeut* @ji tgd ompdro`nost w`s oj-
dvot`any. ef heursd. ` wgotd ferdobjdr* Rd `nse s`w ` jumadr ef `jto-
K`p`jdsd pestdrs iurojb tgos trop. wgohg wdrd hg`r`htdrozdi ay foburds
ef K`p`jdsd treeps idspeonojb tgd Hgojdsd*
O st`rtdi fer tgd dxhotojb trop up te tgd frejt ej Xuji`y. Kujd 01.
0?12. beojb `s f`r `s J`jlojb wotg fermdr Xdj`ter Gor`m Aojbg`m.
ef Hejjdhtohut. wge. wotg gos sej. Reeiaroibd Aojbg`m. g`i addj
m`lojb ` tgereubg teur ef Hgoj`. aetg Jertg `ji Xeutg* Oj J`jlojb.
O mdt Qeadrt X* Sohldjs. ` spdho`n herrdspejidjt fer tgd Hgoh`be
Yroaujd. `ji ` I`josg herrdspejidjt j`mdi Ir* @`bd L``rup Jodnsdj*
Ir* Jodnsdj w`s ` Xeutg Sen`r dxpnerdr. `mejb etgdr tgojbs. `ji fer
sox er sdvdj yd`rs g`i addj tr`vdnojb fer tgrdd Xh`jioj`vo`j jdws-
p`pdrs. rdturjojb te Durepd te ndhturd `ji wrotd aeels ej wg`t gd
g`i sddj* O gordi ` heel. teel feei `ji aettndi irojlojb w`tdr. `ji
wotg ` tr`jsn`ter st`rtdi fer J`jlojb `ji tgd frejt*
O ndft Xg`jbg`o `t ?;03 `*m*. beojb te J`jlojb oj ` prov`td h`r
wotg tgd Aojbg`ms `ji Mr* Kund`j @rjeni. tgd @mdroh`j Hemmdrho`n
@tt`hgd oj Xg`jbg`o* Rd `rrovdi `aeut feur e"hnehl oj tgd `ftdrjeej*
@j ujidr-sdhrdt`ry frem tgd J`jlojb Ferdobj Effohd mdt us. tebdtgdr
wotg twe effohdrs frem tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds idstreydr Sd`ry. st`toejdi
tgdrd. `ji wd prehddidi te tgd B`ridj Getdn* @ftdrbdttojb sdttndi.
Mr* @rjeni `ji O. wotg tgd Ferdobj Effohd sdhrdt`ry '` hg`p j`mdi
Hg`jb/. h`nndi ej tgd n`td Ir* H* H* Ru. tgd J`jlojb Ferdobj Moj-
ostdr* Ir* Ru teni us arodfny ef tgd idsord ef gos Bevdrjmdjt te g`vdtgd ferdobjdrs rdturj te J`jlojb. `ssurojb us tg`t jdotgdr gd jer gos
hennd`buds wdrd `jto-ferdobj* Rd hemp`rdi J`jlojb"s Bevdrjmdjt
wotg tgd G`jlew J`toej`nost breup. `ji Ir* Ru s`oi tgd ejny iof-
fdrdjhd w`s tg`t J`jlojb w`s `jto-Qdi* Ygd bdjdr`n mdhg`josm ef
tgd twe bevdrjmdjts w`s tgd s`md* Ygdsd pdepnd. gewdvdr. ioi jet
fddn tg`t n`aer sgeuni ad pn`hdi ydt oj suhg `j dx`ntdi pesotoej*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 105/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 034
Mr* @rjeni `ji O. wotg Hg`jb. idp`rtdi fer ` teur ef J`jlojb*
Rd vosotdi J`jlojb Tjovdrsoty `ji irevd tgreubg tgd breuji ef
Bojnojb Henndbd fer borns* Aetg wdrd fujhtoejojb `ji dxpdhtdi te
br`iu`td hn`ssds tg`t wddl* Ygd mossoejs suppertojb tgdm. mdj oj
hg`rbd teni md. wdrd pn`jjojb te hejtojud te ie se. idspotd tgd f`ht
tg`t je ferdobj td`hgdrs rdm`ojdi*
Ygd getdn `t J`jlojb wgdrd O st`ydi. wgond jet tgd mest meidrj
oj tgd werni. w`s ` surprosd* Ygd reems wdrd n`rbd `ji hemfert`and*
Ygd pn`hd w`s funn tgdj. `ji O teel evdr ` reem adnejbojb te Sohldjs.
wge g`i bejd te Xg`jbg`o evdr tgd wddl dji* J`jlojb w`s quodtdr
tg`j O g`i addj ndi te adnodvd. `ji jejd ef us. ot sddmdi. w`s oj tgd
snobgtdst i`jbdr* Gewdvdr. tgd jdxt i`y O jetohdi ` fdw osen`tdi dvo-
idjhds tg`t `nn w`s jet wdnn oj tgd rdn`toejs adtwddj ferdobjdrs `ji
tgd Hgojdsd*
Jdxt merjojb wd wdjt ej `jetgdr teur ef J`jlojb* Ygd Xt`ji-
`ri Eon geusd. wgdrd fofty-eii ferdobjdrs g`i b`tgdrdi iurojb tgd
J`jlojb Ojhoidjt. w`s ` wrdhl* Ot w`s ` stoff hnoma up tgd gonn ej
tgd eutslorts ef J`jlojb te wgdrd ot steei evdrneelojb tgd hoty `ji
tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr* Ygdrd w`s `j eni toj hup feur fddt gobg. ` trepgy
m`id ef Xt`ji`ri Eon fovd-b`nnej tojs. st`jiojb oj tgd y`ri. a`ttdrdi
`ji adjt* Ej ots idf`hdi surf`hd ejd heuni stonn m`ld eut tgd weris
p`ojtdi oj an`hl ej tgd trepgy* Ygdy rd`i; @mdroh`j Yd`m. Oj-
tdrj`toej`n Sene. `ji adjd`tg tgos. ejd ujidr tgd etgdr. wdrd tgd
j`mds ef mdmadrs ef tgd td`m* Adnew tgos nost w`s tgd i`td. 0?10 <
`ji `t tgd aettem. ` ruidny sldthgdi foburd ef ` gersd* Ygd Hgojdsd
r`aand hejsoidrdi tgos sdjtomdjt`n trepgy tee trovo`n te aetgdr std`nojb*
Ygdy ndft nottnd dnsd* Ygd a`tg tuas wdrd bejd. `nn nobgt `ji w`tdr
foxturds g`i addj roppdi eut. wojiews areldj. a`sdae`ris stroppdi eff.
dvdrytgojb ndft oj hempndtd hejfusoej*
Ndttdrs `ji p`rts ef djvdnepds n`y dvdrywgdrd. tebdtgdr wotg eni
jdwsp`pdrs `ji m`b`zojds* @ terj p`bd frem Ygd Jdw _erl Yomds
n`y oj ` g`nnw`y wotg shr`ps ef pdrsej`n ndttdrs te tgd mdj frem tgdor
metgdrs. wovds. frodjis* Idsen`toej gujb nold ` sgreui `reuji tgos
ejhd novdny geusd wgesd d`vds jew iroppdi r`oj* An`jl. sobgtndss
wojiews b`zdi ujsddojb `hress tgd vdri`jt n`jish`pd. evdr tgd v`nndy
`ji rovdr fn`ts adnew te wgdrd tgd ydnnew _`jbtzd swddps br`hdfunny
eut ef sobgt p`st Noej Gonn te tgd wdst*
Kund`j @rjeni `ji O h`nndi `b`oj `t J`jlojb Tjovdrsoty. wgdrd wd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 106/455
036 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
mdt tgd @htojb Id`j* Gd `ji `jetgdr prefdsser. aetg @mdroh`j hen-
ndbd br`iu`tds. teel us te vosot tgd gemd ef `j @mdroh`j prefdsser
wge g`i dv`hu`tdi. Kegj Qdosjdr. Ot w`s ehhupodi ay J`toej`nost
treeps wge seubgt te eastruht eur djtr`jhd* Rd pusgdi ay `ji wdjt
ojsoid* Furtgdr idsen`toej* Je furjoturd w`s ndft etgdr tg`j ` a`t-
tdrdi po`je. ots overy ldys stroppdi frem tgd ae`ri. ots strojbs sj`ppdi.
usdndss* Rd wdrd eridrdi eut adferd wd heuni be f`rtgdr. tgd sen-
iodrs. ubny `ji mdj`hojb. spd`lojb oj buttur`n tejds te eur Hgojdsd
frodjis* My tr`jsn`ter teni md tgdy g`i h`nndi tgd prefdssers ""ruj-
jojb iebs ef ompdro`nosm.
0 "
` tgdj pepun`r Hgojdsd sneb`j*
Ot w`s eur forst sobj ef `jytgojb nold `jto-ferdobjosm. `ntgeubg tgd
Xdj`ter"s sej g`i teni us ef `j ehhurrdjhd tgd jobgt adferd tg`t w`s
wersd* Gd w`s te spdji tgd jobgt ej tgd T* X* X Sd`ry. `ji `aeut
7 e"hnehl wdjt iewj te tgd iehl te mddt ` n`ujhg gd g`i addj teni
weuni `w`ot gom* Gd feuji je n`ujhg. se teel ` s`mp`j* Ygd j`vy
mdj teni gom tgd n`ujhg g`i w`otdi fer gom. aut tg`t wgond w`otojb
`t iusl ` Hgojdsd mea b`tgdrdi `ji idm`jidi tg`t tgdy ad `nnewdi
`ae`ri te ojspdht tgd ae`t* Ygd s`oners rdfusdi `ji wdrd brddtdi ay
` sgewdr ef stejds* Q`tgdr tg`j hrd`td ` iostura`jhd. tgd @mdroh`js
idhoidi te wotgir`w Ot hest yeujb Aojbg`m )1. gd s`oi. te gord `
s`mp`j te tgd Sd`ry Ygd usu`n prohd os 13 er 83 hdjts fer tgos tdj-
mojutds" rewojb te moistrd`m*
Mr @rjeni ndft `t jeej @ftdr toffoj. tgd Ferdobj Effohd sdhrdt`ry
areubgt us ojvot`toejs te ` iojjdr adojb bovdj fer Xdj`ter Aojbg`m*
Iurojb tgd `ftdrjeej. wd vosotdi tgd @mdroh`j Hejsun`td* Gdrd `b`oj
wd feuji ` wrdhl ; s`fds a`ttdrdi. p`pdrs sh`ttdrdi dvdrywgdrd. trujls
dmptodi. twe er tgrdd adistd`is mojus adi hnetgojb er m`ttrdssds*
Eutsoid. ` penohdm`j steei bu`ri* Ygdrd w`s nottnd te bu`ri* @ J`-
toej`nost sd`n g`i addj pn`hdi evdr tgd ieers ef tgd gubd effohd s`fd*
Ot w`s jet epdjdi. aut dvoidjhds wdrd m`jy ef ` a`ttnd wotg tgd a`y-
ejdts ef seniodrs* Frem tgdrd. wd vosotdi tgd gemd ef tgd n`td Ir*
Kegj Ronno`ms. tgd J`jlojb Tjovdrsoty m`j wge w`s muridrdi* Ot
w`s ehhupodi ay treeps*
O s`t jdxt te Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `t iojjdr tg`t dvdjojb* Ot
w`s tgd forst tomd O g`i sddj gom sojhd n`td @pron. oj Xg`jbg`o. `ji
wd t`nldi ef gos vohterods `ji wg`t gd pn`jjdi te ie jdxt* Gd s`oi
gd w`jtdi tgd @mdroh`js te hemd a`hl te J`jlojb. `ji tg`t gd weuni
sdd tg`t tgdy wdrd s`fd* Gd `nse s`oi gd weuni eridr tgd treeps eut
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 107/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 032
ef ferdobj prepdrt} of semdaeiy weuni suamot te gom ` nost ef tgd
geusds se ehhupodi. `ji tgdor ewjdrs*
O m`id `rr`jbdmdjts ej Yudsi`y te be jertg te tgd Gsuhgew-fu
frejt. tgd J`jlojb eutpest `t tgd top ef Lo`jbsu Srevojhd. jd`r Xg`j-
tujb* Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl effdrdi md ` bu`ri wgdj O t`nldi wotg gom oj
tgd `ftdrjeej. `ji tgos O bn`iny `hhdptdi* Gd `nse wretd twe ndttdrs
te gos bdjdr`ns `t tgd frejt. ojtreiuhojb md `ji `slojb tg`t tgdy dx-
tdji heurtdsods* My neh`n p`sspert w`s ` quddr fnomsy iehumdjt. ad-
ojb rd`nny ` monot`ry p`ss. aut Hg`jb 'my ojtdrprdtdr/ s`oi ot weuni
bdt md ay `jywgdrd oj J`jlojb-hejtrenndi tdrrotery*
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl b`vd md gos `utebr`pgdi pgetebr`pg* Gd `b`oj
strdssdi gos idsord te g`vd @mdroh`js rdturj te J`jlojb* O subbdstdi
tg`t tgd `jto-ompdro`nostoh pestdrs tgdy g`i up `nn `reuji wdrd g`riny
hejiuhovd te tgd rdturj ef ferdobjdrs tgdy sgeuni ad hg`jbdi `ji
pestdrs f`ver`and te tgd wgotd m`j put up* Ygd Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf
s`oi tgos mobgt ad iejd* Gd s`oi `nse tg`t gd `ji M`rsg`n Fdjb
_u-gso`jb wdrd oj hempndtd `hheri. `ji tg`t M`rsg`n _dj Gso-s`j oj
Xg`jso Srevojhd wdst ef Sdlojb w`s werlojb wotg gom oj tgd J`toej-
`nost rdvenutoej* Aut ejd h`jjet tdnn* Ot w`s f`t`n te rdny ej suhg oj-
ferm`toej. dvdj wgdj bovdj ay mdj oj gobg pn`hds* Ygdy `nn g`i
tgdor ewj ojtdrdsts te pretdht*
Ir* Jodnsdj. tgd I`josg herrdspejidjt. `rrovdi `t tgd B`ridj Getdn
tg`t dvdjojb* Gd `ji Sohldjs. wge g`i rdturjdi. `ji O pn`jjdi te
bdt ujidr w`y tgd jdxt merjojb ay tr`oj* Ygdrd w`s je w`y ef
tdnnojb wg`t sert ef tr`oj ot weuni ad. gewdvdr. fer mest ef tgd rennojb
stehl g`i bejd jertgw`ri wotg tgd rdtrd`tojb Xg`jtujb seniodrs*
Ygd tgrdd ef us `ji Xdhrdt`ry Hg`jb g`i Hgojdsd hgew++ tg`t
jobgt ej ` pohturdsqud h`j`n ae`t* Arewj-aeiodi ae`tmdj shunndi us
`nejb< Hgojdsd n`jtdrjs aeaadi ej `nn soids< tgdrd w`s tgd seuji ef
sgronn Hgojdsd musoh `ji tgoj veohds ef tgd sojb-sejb borns.tgd hg`ttdr
ef M`g Kejbb tonds `s wd fne`tdi `nejb* @ shdjd ef hener `ji n`ubg-
tdr `ji p`pdr n`jtdrjs. rdfndhtdi oj tgd i`rl w`tdr* Je w`rs er
rumers ef w`rs gdrd* Ygd Hgojdsd `rd nold tg`t*
Gewdvdr. O feuji ej Rdijdsi`y tg`t bdttojb `w`y frem J`jlojb
w`s jet `s d`sy `s ejd mobgt tgojl* Ygd tr`oj ndft `t sdvdj ojstd`i
ef jojd. `s wd g`i addj teni. `ji tgd Hgojdsd hg`p wge teni us wrejb
w`s vdry serry* Ejd os ompetdjt oj tgd f`hd ef tg`t vdry serry dx-
prdssoej ef tgd D`st* Eur monot`ry bu`ri%" ` r`tgdr ojhejsdqudjto`n
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 108/455
037 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
yeujb effohdr. teni us tg`t `jetgdr ndft `t twe e"hnehl. `ji wd pn`jjdi
te t`ld tg`t* Aut wd g`ij"t foburdiej tgd heel* Ygos rdm`rl`and
pdrsej ndft d`rny oj tgd merjojb te auy prevosoejs fer tgd keurjdy<
`ji gd rdturjdi kust `t twe e"hnehl. premptny* Rd g`i teni gom tgd
tr`oj ndft `t twe. gdjhd gd must bdt a`hl oj tomd* Gd `rrovdi ej tgd
iet. `t twe. `ji wgdj ot w`s dxpn`ojdi oj idt`on `ji jet wotgeut `
aon ef ferhd tg`t ot w`s omprea`and wd heuni bdt te tgd fdrry `ji `hress
tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr `nn oj `j ojst`jt te h`thg tgd tr`oj. hemprdgdjsoej
`ji serrew sprd`i evdr gos idmurd fd`turds* Gd. tee. ot turjdi eut.
w`s vdry serry* Oj tgd md`jtomd. wd g`i te w`ot ujton `jetgdr
merjojb te be*
Rd foj`nny bet ujidr w`y tew`ri tgd frejt ej Ygursi`y* Ot teel
ttd frem feur-tgorty tg`t r`ojy merjojb ujton tdj `t jobgt te bdt st`rtdi
frem Sulew. aut `t n`st wd wdrd ej tgd tr`oj. `ji tg`t w`s semd-
tgojb*
Qosojb oj tgd br`y i`wj. wd rusgdi te bdt tgd Sulew fdrry `t fovd
e"hnehl* Eur spdho`n effohdr f`ondi te `ppd`r. nold ` i`jiy nottnd fdnnew.
nd`vojb us te werry `aeut eur ewj futurd* Ygd heel wd g`i sdjt
`gd`i. `ji gd w`s w`otojb ej tgd st`toej pn`tferm fer us adsoid `
heenod tr`oj k`mmdi wotg seniodrs* Gd s`oi tg`t ot w`s pessoand tg`t
tr`oj mobgt punn eut `t sdvdj e"hnehl. aut g`i gos ieuats*
O s`oi ot mobgt punn eut `t sdvdj er `jy etgdr e"hnehl fer `nn wd
h`rdi wd heunij"t roid ej ot* Ygdrd w`sj"t ` squ`rd ojhg ef sp`hd
`jywgdrd ej `jy ejd ef tgesd frdobgt h`rs< `ji of tgdrd g`i addj. wd
heuni jdvdr g`vd p`hldi eur heel `ji gos tgrdd p`hlojb h`sds ef
prevosoejs `ae`ri* Ot w`s gepdndss* Eur effohdr g`i f`ondi te `ppd`r
`jywgdrd `nejb tgd reutd. aut jew `s wd wdrd b`zojb `aeut gd andw
oj `ji s`oi tgdrd weunij"t ad ` tr`oj ujton `t nd`st twe e"hnehl tg`t
`ftdrjeej*
Aut wd mevdi eur heel `ji gos nubb`bd `ji eursdnvds `nejbsoid
`jetgdr `ji ` f`r adttdr tr`oj wgohg. O ioshevdrdi ay `slojb ejd ef
tgd seniodrs wge speld Djbnosg. w`s w`otojb fer Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-
sgdl* Ygd Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf w`s dxpdhtdi te be up te tgd frejt
tg`t i`y. gd s`oi* Ygdrd wdrd twe forst-hn`ss hemp`rtmdjt h`rs wgohg
subbdstdi preioboeus pessoaonotods!
O `sldi eur ojtdrprdtdr te bdt ot `hress te tgd Nottnd Henejdn wotg
us tg`t wd idsordi te djtdr ejd ef tgdsd h`rs `ji rdst ujton tgd Bdj-
dr`n `rrovdi* Gd w`s sgehldi `ji surprosdi. `ji dshertdi us te tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 109/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 03?
w`otojb reem ojstd`i* @ftdr g`nf `j geur. `s wd s`t ej g`ri hg`ors
oj tgos fdtoi pn`hd `ji w`thgdi tgd Hgojdsd buzznd seup. gd peujhdi
oj ej us `ji `jjeujhdi ` tr`oj w`s nd`vojb oj ` fdw mojutds `ji tg`t
wd g`i adttdr t`ld ot*
Dn`tdi. wd i`sgdi eut `nn rd`iy fer Aob Ygojbs* Gd ndi us a`hl
te tgd woid epdj sp`hds ef tg`t heenod tr`oj* Gd sloppdi jomany
`gd`i tgreubg ` nobgt irozznd `ji wd. eur `rier i`mpdjdi ay m`jy
tgojbs wgdj wd b`zdi ej tgos f`mono`r sobgt. fennewdi w`rony* Dvdj
tgd dshert w`s ` aot hrdstf`nndj* Gd g`i dvoidjtny t`ldj semdaeiy"s
weri fer ot tg`t tg`t tr`oj effdrdi dxhdnndjt `hhemmei`toejs fer `
troe ef w`r herrdspejidjts `ji tgdor frodjis. `nn g`riy `ji usdi te
reubgojb ot! Rd neeldi `t tgd tr`oj wgdrd seniodrs `ji heenods s`t
ej truhls. fonndi epdj he`n h`rs. dxuidi frem br`oj h`rs `ji s`t
pdrhgdi dvdrywgdrd `tep `jytgojb. wotg tgdor umardnn`s* ^Vd neeldi
serrewfunny `t eur w`yw`ri dshert `ji tgdj wd w`nldi `w`y* Ot
sompny heuni jet ad iejd*
@s wd strenndi `nejb oj tgd nobgt irozznd. O tgeubgt merd `ji merd
ef husgoejs `ji tg`t forst hn`ss h`rro`bd O teni eur ojtdrprdtdr tg`t
wd wdrd jew beojb te epdj tgd h`r `ji sot tgdrdoj ujton furtgdr je-
tohd* Gd ieuatdi ot* Aut my hemp`joejs. iosbustdi `ji rd`iy te
try ot. fer wd heunij"t ad wersd eff. `ssdjtdi* O trodi tgd ieer te tgd
h`r* Ot w`s nehldi* @ yeujb effohdr stdppdi eut ef tgd jdxt h`r. `ji
O `ppd`ndi te gom* Ot turjdi eut tg`t gd w`s ` mdmadr ef tgd Srep`-
b`ji` Herps `ji ` fermdr jdwsp`pdr m`j frem Xg`jbg`o `ji"Sdlojb
wge usdi te werl ej ` p`pdr tg`t Dubdjd Hgdj g`i diotdi* Gos
j`md w`s S`un Hgu. gd s`oi. `ji gd w`s ` br`iu`td ef `j @mdroh`j
mossoej henndbd oj Hgoj`* O teni gom tgd Bdjdr`n g`i ojvotdi us te
be te Gsuhgew-fu. tg`t wd wdrd bdttojb je `ttdjtoej `t `nn. `ji tg`t
`nn oj `nn. tgd trop se f`r g`i addj je gewnojb suhhdss*
Gd peojtdi eut tg`t tgd h`r wgohg wd w`jtdi te djtdr w`s nehldi*
O `imottdi tgos. aut subbdstdi wd p`y ` nottnd seho`n h`nn ej tgd Xt`toej
M`stdr `ji sdd wg`t gd weuni ie* Rd ioi* Ygd Xt`toej M`stdr
nd`rjdi wd wdrd budsts ef tgd Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf. wgohg. oj ` w`y.
w`s trud* Gd w`s `penebdtoh* @ji wg`t os merd te tgd peojt. gd
epdjdi tg`t h`r! Rd p`rldi oj ` hemp`rtmdjt fer tgd rdst ef eur
keurjdy te Gsuhgew-fu. fer idspotd dfferts ej tgd p`rt ef eur nottnd
effohdr-dshert. wd rdfusdi te auibd frem eur hemfert`and hemp`rtmdjt.
wgdrd ejd mobgt nod strdthgdi eut ej ` nd`tgdr upgenstdrdi sd`t `ji
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 110/455
003 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
snddp* Aea Sohldjs preiuhdi `j ompert`jt neelojb iehumdjt wgohg
^vd g`i g`i `t tgd getdn oj J`jlojb. bovdj us ay tgd Ferdobj Effohd*
Ot `htu`nny ioi idhn`rd. ujidr tgd Bevdrjmdjt Xd`n. tg`t wd wdrd
budsts ef tgd Ferdobj Effohd `ji wdrd jet te ad iosturadi* Rd wdrd
ndft `nejd gdjhdfertg `ji g`i ` beei roid*
Ygd heel. a`hl oj tgd a`bb`bd h`r. w`s `fr`oi te epdj gos pre-
vosoej aexds fer fd`r tgd pn`yfun seniodrs qu`rtdrdi wotg gom mobgt
ojsost ej tgdor sg`rd* Xe wd `td rohd oj n`rbd aewns `ji w`sgdi ot hnewj
wotg ndmej`id* Ygd i`y p`ssdi snewny* Rd pgetebr`pgdi tgd heenod
tr`oj wotg ots `hhemp`jyojb h`rs ne`idi wotg sox meter truhls tg`t.
wotg wgotd-`rhgdi a`hls. neeldi nold hevdrdi w`bejs* Ygdy wdrd fer
usd `t tgd frejt oj tr`jspert sdrvohd `ji `s `maun`jhds. wd wdrd teni*
Ygd Srep`b`ji` aeys wdrd ausy tgd wgend i`y nejb p`ojtojb pohturds
ef tgd n`td Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj ej tgd tr`oj `ji hepods ef tgd Luemoj-
t`jb dmandm dvdrywgdrd. `s wdnn `s puttojb up jdw `ji adttdr pestdrs*
Eur+
"bu`ri keojdi us wotgeut iospn`y n`td oj tgd `ftdrjeej. bn`i
te `imot idfd`t `ji idsdrt gos a`bb`bd h`r qu`rtdrs jew k`mmdi wotg
treeps p`rt. O prdsumd. ef Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb"s bu`ri* Gd s`oi Hgo`jb"s
idp`rturd w`s stonn ojidfojotd. aut ^vd g`i idhoidi te stohl ay eur
hemp`rtmdjts 'wd jew g`i t`ldj twe `ikeojojb ejds `ji ldpt tgdm/.
of ot teel ` wddl* Ygd Hgojdsd wdrd mest frodjiny. `ji O feuji ejd
ef tgd aeys ej tgd tr`oj speld Djbnosg wotg `j @mdroh`j `hhdjt*
Ot sddms gd werldi oj Vn`iovestel wgdj wd g`i treeps oj Xoadro`
iurojb tgd Rerni R`r*
@aeut sox e"hnehl. wd wdjt ejte tgd pn`tferm fer ` strenn Ot w`s
` nuhly gujhg* Rd mdt tgd m`j`bojb iordhter ef tgd r`onw`y `ji gd
w`s bn`i te t`nl te ferdobjdrs `ji pr`htosd gos Djbnosg* Gos j`md
w`s Reei pdrvdrsoej ef semd Hgojdsd j`md. ef heursd `ji gd w`s
` br`iu`td ef `j @mdroh`j ujovdrsoty* Gd w`s muhg ojtdrdstdi oj
eur trop< `ji gd subbdstdi wd mobgt g`vd treuand bdttojb tr`oj `h-
hemmei`toejs frem Gsuhgew-fu a`hl te Sulew* O g`i tgeubgt ef
tgd s`md tgojb* Xe Mr* Reei wretd ` jetd te gos m`j `t Gsuhgew-
fu `ji eridrdi gom te bovd us ` prov`td h`r wgdj wd w`jtdi ot*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `rrovdi `t ?;93. `ji fovd mojutds n`tdr
wd wdrd eff fer Gsuhgew-fu* Gd h`ubgt sobgt ef us `s gd m`rhgdi
p`st. `ji rdturjdi eur s`nutd* Rotg ` brd`t anewojb ef m`jy aubnds.
wd punndi eut fer tgd jertg `t ?;94 p*m*
Rg`t spottdrs tgd Hgojdsd `rd t Eur h`r. oj tgd j`rrew `osnd eut-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 111/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 000
soid eur hemp`rtmdjts. w`s `novd wotg jeosds ay i`yard`l. `ji tgd
neuidst ef tgdsd w`s tgd spottojb ay dvdj-aeiy. dvdrywgdrd. prdfdr-
`any. ot sddmdi. ej tgd fneer* Ot w`s ` b`md ef gehl. spot `ji kump%"
wotg us ieojb tgd kumpojb* Ejd ef tgesd tgojbs yeu g`vd te bdt usdi
te oj Hgoj`. `ji dnsdwgdrd oj tgd D`st* Ot os ` j`toej`n hustem*
Rd g`i te snddp oj eur hnetgojb iurojb tgd jobgt. We adi hnetgds*
O usdi my arodf-h`sd 'wgohg w`s `nn my nubb`bd. ojhoidjt`nny. ej tg`t
teur/ `s ` ponnew* Ot w`s ` ad`utofun jobgt wotg meejnobgt `hress
tgd md`iews `ji frdqudjt n`lds `ji quotd hgonny* @s wd steppdi `t
d`hg tewj. tgd Senotoh`n Aurd`u pestdr prep`b`ji` aeys wdjt `aeut
puttojb up jdw `ji sgojy pestdrs ej dvdrytgojb* Eur tr`oj w`s not-
tdrdi wotg sobjs* Ej tgd Bdjdr`n"s h`r ` aob an`hl-`ji-wgotd pestdr
oj Hgojdsd rd`i; Ye HEJBQ@YTN@YD BDJDQ@N HGO@JB L@O-XGDL EJ
GOX JEQYGDQJ DWSDIOYOEJ 03.333 _D@QX! Ygos n`st w`s ` typoh`n
Hgojdsd dxprdssoej md`jojb nejb nofd `ji g`ppojdss* Ir* Xuj"s pgete-
br`pg w`s p`ojtdi ej tgd h`r. `ji tgdrd wdrd tgd usu`n sneb`js. `s
IERJ ROYG OMSDQO@NOXM! IERJ ROYG YGD HEMMTJOXY S@QY_!
`ji HND@J TS YGD MONOY@QOXYX!
Ygd heel. nold ` beei fdnnew. turjdi up `t sox e"hnehl oj tgd merj-
ojb wotg tojjdi feei `ji fruot. `ji tgd aey areubgt td` `ji get w`tdr*
Ygd tr`oj"s pdrsejjdn. `soid frem tgd m`jy treeps. ojhnuidi jum-
dreus pdepnd ef ompert`jhd. `mejb tgdm rdprdsdjt`tovds ef M`rsg`n
Fdjb _u-gso`jb* Ywe ef tgdm. vdry beei fdnnews. h`md oj fer ` hg`t*
Ygdy swerd tg`t Fdjb w`s `nn fer Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb. `ji tgdy s`oi gd
w`s `nrd`iy g`nf-w`y te Gsuhgew-fu ej tgd Nujbg`o Q`onw`y Nojd
Ejd hg`p `nse swerd Fdjb w`s id`i `b`ojst tgd Hemmujost S`rty oj
Hgoj`* Ygos sddmdi te md r`tgdr str`jbd. `ftdr tgd gdnp Fdjb _u-
gso`jb. tgd `nndbdi Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n. bet frem Meshew `ftdr gos
idfd`t oj Sdlojb oj 0?14* Ygd ieuatfun m`j sddmdi r`tgdr te ad _dj
Gso-s`j. oj Xg`jso. Aut. tgdy s`oi. gd w`s aeuji te hemd evdr te tgd
Xeutg* Ejd ef tgd mdj. Yojb Yu`j-so`e. ` fermdr iordhter ef tgd
Sdlojb-Mulidj Q`onw`y. s`oi gd tgeubgt Hg`jb Yse-noj weuni geni
Sdlojb te tgd n`st iothg* Aetg wdrd aottdr `b`ojst K`p`j fer sdjiojb
treeps te Xg`jtujb* Xe w`s dvdryaeiy. ot sddmdi* Ygdy rdh`nndi
K`p`j"s `oiojb Hg`jb Yse-noj `b`ojst Lue Xujb-noj oj M`jhguro` oj
Idhdmadr `ji K`ju`ry. 0?14-16. wgdj Yelye idhn`rdi ` ""jdutr`n
zejd `t Mulidj `ji st`vdi eff wg`t sddmdi te ad hdrt`oj idfd`t fer
Hg`jb*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 112/455
001 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Rd p`ssdi jumdreus st`toejs* Dvdrywgdrd hrewis turjdi eut te
brddt tgdor Bdjdr`n* Ygd heujtry w`s `s fn`t `s L`js`s ad`utofun
f`rm heujtry. strdthgojb `w`y fer monds oj `nn iordhtoejs `s f`r `s ejd
heuni sdd* Rd st`rtdi frem Sulew tgreubg ` new r`jbd ef meuj-
t`ojs. `ji gobg gonns. arewj oj tgd a`hlbreuji. wdrd stonn vosoand
`b`ojst tgd anud sly* Rd p`ssdi tgreubg Fu No Hgo `t 03 `*m* Ot
w`s ejd ef tgd prdttodst purdny Hgojdsd g`mndts O dvdr s`w* Mui
geusds wotg wgotd tond reefs. hurnojb up `t tgd d`vds *** ` w`nndi
tdmpnd gobg ej ` f`r gonn * * * adbb`rs. semd eni `ji adjt. etgdrs
yeujb `ji j`ldi* O tessdi tgdm heppdrs. `ji `s tgd tr`oj punndi eut
` aob aey br`aadi ejd heoj ef tgrdd O"i tgrewj ` j`ldi nottnd hg`p jet
evdr tgrdd yd`rs ef `bd* Ygd a`ay gewndi. `ji O sgeutdi neuiny `ji
wotgeut iobjoty `t tgd r`sh`n* Gd ireppdi tgd heoj `ji fndi*
Rd rd`hgdi Gsuhgew-fu `t jeej* @ monnojb. a`jjdr-w`vojb rd-
hdptoej `w`otdi Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl* Gsuhgew-fu dj fdtd. `
genoi`y idhn`rdi. brddtdi eur p`rty* Rd bet rohlsg`ws te tgd B`ridj
Getdn wgdrd O mdt Bdjdr`n Sdo Hgujb-gso. h`pturdr ef Xg`jbg`o. t`nl-
ojb wotg Mdrnd N`vey. `kevo`n
S`tgd jdwsrddn vdtdr`j wge g`i addj
evdr te tgd frejt oj Xg`jtujb* Ygd pn`hd w`s funn ef seniodrs. fer
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb m`id gos BGP tgdrd* Rd mdt m`jy effohdrs. ojhnui-
ojb tgd Senohd Hemmossoejdr. wge tgeubgt ` heni irojl weuni be beei
`ftdr eur get roid* Ot ioi*
@jetgdr effohdr `rr`jbdi fer reems fer us tgreubg tgd Hgojdsd
Hg`madr ef Hemmdrhd* Rd g`i toffoj `t tgd getdn `ji tgdj mevdi te
eur qu`rtdrs* Ygdy wdrd oj ` sp`hoeus reem ojsoid `j eni Hgojdsd
tdmpnd. wotg a`maee `ji m`jy fnewdrs brewojb oj tgd y`ri* M`ker-
Bdjdr`n M` Ge-hgew. oj hg`rbd ef tgd `rtonndry ujot wotg tgd Ydjtg
@rmy. qu`rtdrdi gdrd. h`nndi ej us* Gd areubgt Bdjdr`n S`jb Ysodj-
ts`o. `nse ef tgd Ydjtg @rmy. `nejb. ` smonojb Auiig` ef ` m`j. beei
j`turdi `ji fujjy. ` are`i. r`tgdr sdnf-hejshoeus broj `nw`ys ad`mojb
`hress gos f`t. pnd`s`jt. arewj. reuji f`hd* Xgertdjojb gos j`md.
S`jb. wd iuaadi gom S`. te be wotg Bdjdr`n M`. eur gest* Ygdn`ttdr speld f`orny beei Djbnosg* Gd w`s ` sporotdi fdnnew wgesd mdj
must g`vd nevdi gom*
Rd ndft `t feur e"hnehl. `ftdr td`. `ji ojtdrvodwdi Bdjdr`n No
Hgujb-kdj `t gos y`m`j* Gd `brddi te t`ld us up te tgd frejt wotg
gom oj ` fdw i`ys* Ot w`s `aeut 033 no. er ` nottnd evdr 83 monds te
tgd nojds wgdrd gd w`s `ssobjdi. wgohg wotg treeps weuni ad ` twe
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 113/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 008
i`ys" m`rhg* @aeut sox wd teel eur idp`rturd. te sddl adi hnetgds
oj tgd m`rldt-pn`hd* Tjton wd bet ` penohdm`j `t BGP te gdnp us.
wd bet jewgdrd* Ygd mdrhg`jts. ej genoi`y. rdfusdi te epdj up* Rdioij"t bdt eur mesquote jdttojb. ujfertuj`tdny. `ji `nn ef us g`i `
g`ri fobgt iurojb tgd jobgt wotg tgdsd pdsts. `ji wotg fnods `t suj-up*
N`vey `ji gos h`mdr`m`j. Hgdj. wdrd w`otojb fer us wgdj wd bet
a`hl te eur tdmpnd-gemd `aeut sdvdj* Ygdy g`i addj te tgd D`stdrj
frejt oj Xg`jtujb wotg Bdjdr`n Sdo Hgujb-gso. `ji N`vey teni us ef
dxpdrodjhds tgdrd* Gd w`s `kenny aob fdnnew wge g`i addj `nn evdr
tgd werni wotg gos h`mdr`. oj w`rs dvdrywgdrd. `ji ej `nn frejts oj
Durepd iurojb tgd Rerni R`r* Gd heuni tdnn ` mdrry t`nd wdnn* Gd
`jtohop`tdi ` ard`l-up oj tgd Jertgdrj ferhds tg`t summdr ef 0?12
`ji ` m`rhg te Sdlojb ay tgd J`toej`nosts adferd m`jy mejtgs*
Rgond wd wdrd hg`ttojb. Bdjdr`n M` keojdi us `ji `s gos hejtroautoej
te tgd p`rty s`jb ` pepun`r @mdroh`j sejb. % w`jt te sdd my gemd
oj Ioxod! Gd w`s t`nn. wotg ` fodrhd an`hl must`hgd. loji dyds `ji `
revojb sporot tg`t w`s `nw`ys gottojb ej semdtgojb jdw te s`y er ie*
Gd w`s ` j`tur`n seniodr `ji wdnn-fottdi te ad ` nd`idr ef gos r`bbdi
`ji jejd tee sporotdi treeps*
Gd areubgt oj g`nf ` iezdj effohdrs tdj mojutds n`tdr `ji ojsostdi
wd `nn be ojte gos qu`rtdrs `ji iojd Hgojdsd-hgew stynd* N`vey
g`i te rdfusd aut wd `hhdptdi. `ntgeubg tgd heel g`i `nrd`iy prd-
p`rdi iojjdr* Rd iojdi ay h`jindnobgt `reuji ` ae`ri t`and. wotg
feei oj tgd hdjtdr oj djermeus qu`jtotods wgohg wd `td wotg hgep-
stohls* Ywe ef tgd effohdrs speld K`p`jdsd aut je etgdr ferdobj n`j-
bu`bd* Bdjdr`n M` foj`nny fdnt hejstr`ojdi te sojb ejhd merd `ji ioi.
oj ` ge`rsd. kevo`n veohd* Gd tgdj ojsostdi tg`t gos budsts sojb. `ji
Aea Sohldjs `ji O eanobdi wotg semd ef tgd henndbd sejbs wd aetg
ljdw. djiojb up wotg G`on. G`on tgd B`jb"s @nn Gdrd. te wgohg eur
iobjofodi Bdjdr`ns tgdrd wdrd fovd Bdjdr`ns `ji sdvdr`n ndssdr effohdrs
prdsdjt tgumpdi tgd t`and rdseujiojbny!
Ygd vohd-hg`orm`j ef tgd m`ss mddtojb te wdnhemd Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl jdxt i`y w`s prdsdjt `t tgd iojjdr. `ji gd ojvotdi us `nse
te m`ld ` spddhg* Rd gdni ` hejfdrdjhd ej tgossuakdht. `ji ot w`s
foj`nny `brddi tg`t O w`s te m`ld ` arodf `hljewndibmdjt ef tgd
gejer iejd us oj Gsuhgew-fu. tgd tgrdd ef us te ad ojtreiuhdi `t ejd
tomd `ji O te s`y tgd podhd*
Ygd jdxt i`y w`s X`turi`y. Kujd 07. `ji tgd gubd Hgojdsd m`ss
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 114/455
009 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
mddtojb w`s `j omprdssovd suhhdss `ntgeubg wd ioi jet spd`l* Ygd
Hgojdsd wdrd nejb ej `iirdssds. `ji wgdj ot w`s tomd fer eur idaut
tgd pdepnd wdrd
wd`ry
ef
st`jiojb
m tgd get suj `ji ot w`s p`st
jeej `ji dvdryaeiy w`s gujbry. ojhnuiojbus* Xe wd ndft* Bdjdr`n
Hgo`jb m`id ` beei spddhg. `s usu`n. `ji gd idjodi tg`t tgd Lue-
mojt`jb mdmadrs wdrd `b`ojst Hgrosto`joty er Hejfuho`josm er `jy-
tgojb dnsd oj tgd w`y ef rdnoboej er frddiem ef spddhg `ji tgeubgt*
Ygd mddtojb w`s gdni ej ` are`i pn`oj `t tgd dibd ef tgd hoty.
adyeji tgd w`nn Ygd suj w`s areonojb get aut wd ioij"t moji tg`t
se muhg. adojb budsts ej ` sg`iy pn`tferm* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb `rrovdi
`aeut tdj e"hnehl* Gd s`nutdi us `ji h`md evdr te `sl of wd"i bet
hemfert`and qu`rtdrs* Ygd mddtojb areld up `aeut 01 ;83* Ygd strd`m
ef gum`joty up tgd gonn `ji a`hl te tewj w`s ` brd`t sobgt* Ygd Ieh
oj ` rohlsg`w hevdrdi `nn evdr nold ` hevdrdi-w`bej w`s ` f`jt`stoh
sobgt oj gos wrgotd gdnmdt. roiojb arddhgds. lg`lo he`t `ji h`mdr`*
Rd g`i ` sodst` `ftdr toffoj. tgd i`y adojb get `ji je ejd storrojb
O `weld `t tgrdd e"hnehl te foji tgd reem fonndi wotg seniodrs* Ygdy
wdrd `j ojquosotovd net. `nn Guj`jdsd. `ji vdry frdsg. aut tgdy ndft
quohlny wgdj `j `ssdmany adnn r`jb* Ot s`vdi us semd dma`rr`ssmdjt.
fer wd weuni g`vd g`i te dvoht tgdm* Ygdy g`i addj idm`jiojb
hob`rdttds `ji td`. semd fofty er merd ef tgdm. `ji tg`t weuni g`vd
t`ldj ` net ef hob`rdttds `ji td`* Aut wd wdrd roi ef tgdm. tg`jls te
tgd adnn wgohg h`nndi tgdm te ferm`toej* O iej"t ljew gew tgdy bet
oj. aut wd hempn`ojdi te eur Bdjdr`n M`. `ji gd pestdi ` bu`ri
wgohg prdvdjtdi furtgdr treuand ef tgos loji*
Eur jdxt h`nndr w`s ` stuidjt-td`hgdr ef `rt wge h`nndi fer je
beei rd`sej dxhdpt te t`nl wotg tgdsd ferdobj idvons* Gd w`s pnd`s-
`jt djeubg. `ntgeubg ` f`tueus-f`hdi b`neet. `ji gd premosdi te p`ojt
us ` f`j `podhd* Gd s`oi gd tgeubgt tgd pdepnd weuni nold tgd J`toej-
`nosts ejhd tgdy bet `hqu`ojtdi adttdr. fer. gd s`oi. m`jy ef tgd effo-
hdrs wdrd wdnn diuh`tdi* "Ygdsd J`toej`nosts%" gd hejfoidi. g`vd
ojtdrdsts oj `rt `ji notdr`turd. wgond tgd Jertgdrjdrs `rd reubg fdn-
news. ujdiuh`tdi* O tgojl tgd J`toej`nosts wonn ad pepun`r. tgdrdferd*
Jew. tg`t w`s ` jdw `jbnd ej tgd rdvenutoej*
Ygd tewj w`s prdp`rojb fer tgd wdnhemd ef M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-
gso`jb. wge w`s iud oj tgd merjojb* Sestdrs fndw dvdrywgdrd* Rd
aeubgt mesquote jdts. neeldi `t k`id. `ji `ftdr foxojb eur qu`rtdrs `ji
jdttojb fer tgd jobgt. wdjt te Bdjdr`n R`jb Yodj-pdo"s -qu`rtdrs fer
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 115/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 004
iojjdr* Ygdrd wd nd`rjdi wd g`i te mevd `t ejhd. fer Fdjb w`s te
ad bovdj eur reems oj tgd tdmpnd ! Xe wd mevdi adferd iojjdr oj `
brd`t h`r`v`j ef rohlsg`ws tgreubg tgd j`rrew. reubgny heaandi strddts
ef Gsuhgew-fu. `ji iojdi n`td `t dndvdj e"hnehl wotg tgd effohdrs ef
Bdjdr`n R`jb"s mdss* Ygd Bdjdr`n g`i te nd`vd te `ttdji ` wdnhemd
hemmottdd mddtojb te prdp`rd fer Fdjb"s `rrov`n `t i`wj tgd jdxt i`y*
Gd w`s hemm`jidr ef tgd Ydjtg @rmy `ji `j eni Ru Sdo-fu m`j<
` herio`n gest `ji pnd`s`jt. `s mest ef tgdsd pdepnd wdrd te us* Rd
wdrd trd`tdi nold projhds ej `nn g`jis. `ji dvdj `mejb tgd pdepnd
tgdrd w`s jet ` tr`hd ef `jto-ferdobjosm*
Eur jdw qu`rtdrs wdrd oj ` idsdrtdi borns" shgeen `t tgd dibd ef
Gsuhgew-fu. ehhupodi ay Bdjdr`n R`jb `ji gos bu`ri `ji tgd prep`-
b`ji` aurd`u hg`ps* Ot w`s ` a`rj-nold pn`hd. aut pohturdsqud ` fojd
vodw w`s te ad g`i ef tgd djtord hoty* @ftdr iojjdr. sdvdr`n ef tgd
effohdrs `hhemp`jodi us te eur reems* Ywe ef tgdm g`i stuiodi dj-
bojddrojb oj Fr`jhd `ji Bdrm`jy. `ji wd bet `nejb jeany oj areldj
Frdjhg. ioshevdrojb ` hemmej ljewndibd ef sdvdr`n Frdjhg a`nn`is*
Ejd yeujb M`ker w`s p`rtohun`rny preui ef gos Ydrpsohgerd`j `hhem-
pnosgmdjts `ji prevdi gos st`tdmdjts ay dss`yojb tgd Hg`rndstej ej
tgd reubg ae`ris ef tg`t `ttoh hg`madr* Ygdy ndft us sgertny `ftdr
moijobgt* Rd rdm`id eur aonndts ej ieers robbdi up `s adis tgd
g`ridst weei O g`vd ydt ioshevdrdi*
Rd wdrd ojvotdi te nujhg wotg Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `ji Fdjb _u-
gso`jb ej Xuji`y merjojb. aut mossdi ot* Feenosgny prdsumojb tgd
p`rty weuni ad `t jeej er n`tdr. wd wdjt `aeut h`nnojb ej gd`i-
qu`rtdrs. `ji reid te tgd r`onw`y st`toej te sdd tgd m`j te wgem O g`i
` jetd `aeut ` prov`td h`r. of `ji wgdj wd weuni w`jt ot* Rd bet te
tgd Hg`madr ef Hemmdrhd wgdrd Fdjb w`s bovojb tgd nujhgdej `t
jeej `ji tgd p`rty w`s evdr* Ot g`i adbuj `t dndvdj* Rg`t `j geur
te d`t nujhg t Rd `rr`jbdi te ojtdrvodw Fdjb `t gos qu`rtdrs `t feur
e"hnehl*
Fdjb _u-gso`jb prevdi te ad fexy* Gd b`vd us je iordht `jswdrs
ej `jytgojb* O `sldi gom wg`t gd dxpdhtdi te ie oj Gsuhgew-fu*
Gd s`oi gd dxpdhtdi te hejfdr wotg Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl* Rd `sldi gom
wgy. `ji gd s`oi gd g`i gd`ri muhg `aeut Hgo`jb `ji tg`t gd. Fdjb.
w`s ` mdmadr ef tgd Luemojt`jb `ji w`jtdi te m`ld Hgo`jb"s `h-
qu`ojt`jhd* @sldi of gd g`i hemd te effdr funn heepdr`toej wotg
Hgo`jb. gd s`oi tg`t gd g`i addj heepdr`tojb wotg Hgo`jb fer m`jy
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 116/455
006 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
mejtgs. `jyw`y. `ji weuni hejtojud te ie se* Gd s`oi Aereioj w`s
`j `hqu`ojt`jhd ef gos. aut tg`t gd noldi Hgo`jb adttdr* Gd s`oi gd
ioi jet ojtdji te suppert sdp`r`tdny dotgdr J`jlojb er G`jlew. ad-
h`usd gd idhn`rdi tgdy weuni seej mdrbd ojte ejd bevdrjmdjt `b`oj*
@s te tgd Hemmujost S`rty oj Hgoj`. Fdjb s`oi gd heuni s`y
jetgojb. tg`t qudstoejs hejhdrjojb penotohs wdrd sdttndi ay tgd Hdjtr`n
Dxdhutovd Hemmottdd ef tgd Luemojt`jb* Oj tg`t f`sgoej gd soid-
stdppdi `nn m`ker qudstoejs*
@s wd wdrd nd`vojb. O s`oi; ""Rdnn. Bdjdr`n. `rd yeu stonn ` Hgros-
to`j5 Gd brojjdi `ji rdpnodi. Ie yeu tgojl O neel nold ejd5
@ji tg`t w`s tg`t* Gd pesdi fer pohturds `ji. stonn brojjojb adgoji
gos tgrdd-i`ys" ad`ri. aoi us ` herio`n ` nottnd tee herio`n. O tgeubgt
f`rdwdnn*
Rd wdjt te ` iojjdr tg`t jobgt bovdj ay Hgo`jb fer Fdjb `t tgd
B`ridj Getdn Aetg tgd Bdjdr`ns m`id sgert spddhgds. r`tgdr md`j-
ojbndss. rdfdrrojb te tgd jeand projhopnds ef tgd J`toej`nost H`usd `ji
h`nnojb ej dvdryaeiy te stohl tebdtgdr* Hgo`jb dxtenndi Fdjb `ji
wdnhemdi gom ojte tgd feni< `ji Fdjb dxtenndi Hgo`jb fer gos voh-
terods oj gos m`rhg jertg frem H`jtej* @ftdr ot w`s evdr O speld
arodfny te Hgo`jb `aeut bdttojb ` pgetebr`pg ef tgd twe ef tgdm te-
bdtgdr. `ji gd premosdi te `rr`jbd ot* Xe. gemd te eur shgeengeusd
reems oj rohldty rohlsg`ws. tgreubg tgd tumany eni w`nndihoty*
Ygd Hgo`jb-Fdjb hejfdrdjhd w`s iud te dji tgd jdxt i`y. `ji wd
idhoidi tg`t sojhd tgdrd w`s je w`y te bdt jdws eut aut ay mdssdjbdr.
ot w`s tomd te bdt a`hl te Xg`jbg`o* Rd `sldi Mr* _u. tgd Xt`toej
M`stdr. te fox us up* Gd b`vd us ` prov`td frdobgt h`r. `ji put ot ej
` soiojb fer eur usd ! Ygdrd w`s jetgojb dnsd `v`on`and* Ygdj. wgond
w`otojb te sdd Hgo`jb `t tgd getdn. wd mdt ` yeujb M`ker-Bdjdr`n.
I`voi Neg. hgodf ef hemmujoh`toejs `t tgd frejt. wge effdrdi us hets
`ji ` bu`ri* Xe wd wdrd `nn rd`iy te idp`rt wgdj tgd hejfdrdjhd
djidi*
Bdjdr`n R`jb sdjt gos sobjdi pgetebr`pg evdr te us tg`t Meji`y`ftdrjeej `ji n`tdr. wotg gos st`ff. p`oi us ` ferm`n h`nn* Ot w`s `
tdrrofoh str`oj ej eur heel `ji gos td` sdrvohd. wgohg hejsostdi ef
tgrdd hups `ji s`uhdrs. feur bn`ssds `ji semd tojs ef h`lds `ji
hr`hldrs* Aut wd m`id ot. p`rlojb tgd Bdjdr`n `ji gos effohdrs `reuji
ej weeidj adjhgds `ji eur ieer-adis* R`jb hejformdi my omprds-
soejs ef Fdjb* @ji ot neeldi `s tgeubg J`jlojb heuni jet mevd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 117/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 002
jertg ujton tgd G`jlew spnot w`s sdttndi* Ygdy wdrd stonn `fr`oi ef
Fdjb tgdrd* Rd g`i ` quodt dvdjojb `t gemd `ji idhoidi te mevd
ojte eur aex-h`r forst tgojb oj tgd merjojb*
Rd wdjt `ae`ri `t 03 `*m* Ygd tr`oj w`s iud te be `t jeej*
Bdjdr`n Neg w`s `s beei `s gos weri. `ji gos `rmy hets wdrd ej
g`ji* Rd feuji `aeut g`nf ` iezdj etgdrs oj eur h`r `nse
mdj. wd nd`rjdi. bovdj spdho`n provondbd te roid wotg us. semd `s
bu`ris. etgdrs `s effoho`ns wge g`i ompert`jt ausojdss oj J`jlojb `ji
g`i je etgdr md`js ef tr`jspert`toej* Rd wdrdj"t hrewidi. se ot w`s
`nn robgt* O ireppdi9YSH" h`ris ef f`rdwdnn `t BGP `ji rdturjdi
te tgd tr`oj `t 00;83 `nn sdt te bdt `w`y* Rd g`i bet eur pgete-
br`pg ef Fdjb `ji Hgo`jb tebdtgdr. `ji wdrd `ssurdi tg`t Fdjb w`s
nd`vojb `t jeej `nse. wgohg gd ioi* Hgo`jb s`oi je st`tdmdjt ej tgd
hejfdrdjhd weuni ad ossudi ujton gd bet a`hl te J`jlojb*
Eur heenod tr`oj bet ujidr w`y `t 1;94 p*m* Ot hr`wndi ` sh`jt
tdj monds oj twe geurs. `ji steppdi oj tgd r`oj* Rd st`ydi tgdrd `j
geur `rbuojb wotg tgd st`toej m`j `ji ` monot`ry tr`oj ojspdhter te
hut tgd tr`oj oj g`nf `ji ndt p`rt ef us be ej* Yg`t adir`bbndi djbojd
heuni ie jetgojb wotg tgd twdjty-feur h`rs ot w`s dxpdhtdi te punn*
Rd djidi ay a`hlojb `nn tgd w`y te Gsuhgew-fu ejhd merd. wgdrd
wd spdjt tgd jobgt* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb w`s nd`vojb d`rny Rdijdsi`y
merjojb. `ji O `sldi Mr* _u te `tt`hg eur h`r te gos tr`oj* Gd s`oi
ejd weuni nd`vd `t tdj e$
hnehl tg`t jobgt `ji wd g`i adttdr bdt ot
`tt`hgdi te tg`t* Rd `brddi. `ji O wdjt a`hl te tgd soiojb. renndi
up oj ` an`jldt `ji ireppdi eff te snddp. gepojb aut jet dxpdhtojb te
bdt ujidr w`y tg`t jobgt*
Bdjdr`n Neg h`md te sdd us `aeut jojd e"hnehl `ji t`nldi fer `j
geur `aeut gos werl `ji gew tgd J`toej`nosts `ji Jertgdrjdrs fobgt.
`ji `aeut tgd Qdi Hress werl oj Hgoj`* Gd s`oi tgd iehters rdfusd
te aetgdr wotg weujidi prov`tds oj mest h`sds*
"Of prov`tds `rd sget tgreubg tgd ndb er sgeunidr. aut heuni bdt
wdnn. ot m`lds je ioffdrdjhd* Ygdy eridr tgd auro`n squ`i te tess
tgdm ojte tgd "id`i+ gd`p `ji tgdy `rd aurodi `novd* Ygdy `rd teni
tgdy `rd ef je usd. tg`t tgdrd os je pn`hd te tdji te tgdm. `ji tg`t
tgdy g`i adttdr iod fer tgdor heujtry jew `ji s`vd furtgdr suffdrojb.
Neg s`oi* Ot os tdrroand* Effohdrs `rd semdtomds sp`rdi*
@ memdjt n`tdr. gd ndft `ji O turjdi oj fer tgd jobgt*
Eur ojtdrprdtdr `w`ldjdi md `aeut 6;83 `*m* tgd jdxtmerjojb.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 118/455
007 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`ji s`oi; Ygdy_d w`otojb fer Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb `ji gd os beojb te
nd`vd `jy mojutd jew* Rg`t sg`nn wd ie5 O r`j evdr te tgd
Gsuhgew-fu st`toej te foji seniodrs nojdi up. aubnds pn`yojb `ji eur
Xt`toej M`stdr ef `asenutdny je usd* Gd w`s vdry serry tg`t je
tr`oj G`i ndft iurojb tgd jobgt< aut gd g`i je tomd tgdj*
Ygd Senohd Hemmossoejdr w`s ej g`ji* Gd trodi te bdt us `hhem-
mei`toejs ej `jetgdr h`r ej tgd Bdjdr`n"s tr`oj. aut ot w`s p`hldi*
O w`s fr`jtoh `ji furoeus. `ji idm`jidi tg`t eur h`r ad swothgdi ej
adgoji* Ygd Xt`toej M`stdr terd gos g`or `ji s`oi ot w`s tee n`td*
Rd feubgt ot eut fer ` qu`rtdr ef `j geur. aut jetgojb g`ppdjdi*
Ejd yeujb fdnnew s`oi; Rgy werry `aeut tgdsd hr`zy ferdobjdrs
`jyw`y5 Ygd Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf os iud `jy memdjt* Ndt tgdm
genndr aut iej"t aetgdr `aeut tgdm*0 "
My ojtdrprdtdr tr`jsn`tdi `nn
tgos*
Ot w`s mostojb `ji tgd Bdjdr`n irevd up `ji tgd tr`oj w`s `aeut
te nd`vd* Aea `ji tgd Ieh wdrd stonn evdr oj tgd aex-h`r ej tgd
soiojb. ` anehl `w`y* Ygd Bdjdr`n w`s ej tgd h`r stdp* Hgddrs `ji
aubnds* O br`aadi tgd ojtdrprdtdr. pusgdi tgreubg tgd m`ss robgt up
te tgd Bdjdr`n `ji p`usdi. spd`lojb r`poiny te tgd ojtdrprdtdr `ji
neelojb `t Hgo`jb* O teni gom te tdnn tgd Bdjdr`n eur treuands `ji
tg`t wd w`jtdi te t`ld tg`t tr`oj te J`jlojb* Rgdj tgos w`s dx-
pn`ojdi. Hgo`jb smondi `ji s`oi. Rdnn. hemd ej oj my h`r* O teni
gom oj my ar`ji ef K`p`jdsd 'gd stuiodi oj K`p`j. `ji O w`s ej `j
@mdroh`j jdwsp`pdr oj Yelye tgrdd yd`rs/ tg`t tgdrd wdrd tgrdd ef
us* Gd s`oi te bdt tgd etgdrs* O r`j. wgond tgd tr`oj w`otdi. `ji bet
Aea `ji tgd Ieh. teni tgd heel te p`hl gos tgojbs `ji h`thg tgd jdxt
tr`oj te Sulew `ji W`jlojb. `ji wotg my h`mdr` `ji arodf h`sd. r`j
a`hl te tgd tr`oj* Rd m`id ot* @j ojst`jt n`tdr tgd tr`oj sgevdi eff.
wgond tgd hrewi re`rdi*
Ejhd wd g`i eur ard`tg. ` aey `ppd`rdi `ji `sldi us of wd
w`jtdi ard`lf`st* Rd g`i areubgt je feei `ji g`i g`i je hg`jhd
te d`t* Rd bn`iny `hhdptdi. `ji gd areubgt us g`m `ji dbbs. te`st
`ji k`m. `ji tgd adst heffdd oj mejtgs* Rgond wd `td. Hgo`jb ioh-
t`tdi te gos sdhrdt`rods* Gd neeldi evdr `ji `sldi `j geur n`tdr of
wd g`i g`i hgew* Gd `ji gos st`ff tgdj iojdi. kust `s wd g`i*
Ygd tgrdd md`ns wd g`i wdrd `nn ferdobj-stynd. tgd Bdjdr`n `ji gos
mdj d`tojb wotg ljovds. ferls `ji speejs. `ji d`tojb feei tg`t fer-
dobjdrs d`t je rohd er etgdr Hgojdsd iosgds*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 119/455
TS YE YGD FQEJY 00?
@ftdr toffoj tgd hgodf sdhrdt`ry. ` yeujb H`pt`oj wge w`s ` br`i-
u`td ef tgd Tjovdrsoty ef Sdjjsynv`jo`. s`oi tg`t gd g`i ` mdss`bd
wgohg wdmobgt
nold te sdd* Ot w`s ` tdndbr`m wgohg
Fdjb_u-gso`jb
g`i sdjt te G`jlew idm`jiojb tgd dvohtoej ef Aereioj `ji tgd etgdr
Hemmujosts tgdrd. `ji tgd mdrbojb ef tgd G`jlew pdepnd wotg J`j-
lojb fertgwotg!
Ygd sdhrdt`ry rd`i ot eff oj f`orny beei Djbnosg. `ji Sohldjs `ji
O h`andi eur p`pdrs `ftdr rd`hgojb Xg`jbg`o* Ygd Fdjb mdss`bd
neeldi `s tgeubg gd rd`nny md`jt te stohl ay Hgo`jb. `t nd`st fer tgd
memdjt* Rg`t gos b`md w`s te ad n`tdr w`s stonn ` mystdry* Dvdj
tgd st`ff effohdrs ioi jet trust gom muhg* O `sldi Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb
wg`t gd tgeubgt ef Fdjb `ji wgdtgdr gd adnodvdi Fdjb weuni stohl
ay J`jlojb. `ji gd. ef heursd. s`oi tg`t gd trustdi Fdjb `ji w`s
hejvojhdi tgd ""Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n weuni hejtojud te suppert J`jlojb*
Aut O ieuatdi ot*
Of ot g`ij"t addj fer Aea Sohldjs wd weuni jet g`vd rd`hgdi J`j-
lojb tg`t jobgt* Gd usdi te werl summdrs oj ` reuji-geusd iewj
oj H`renoj` Ygd weaany djbojd areld iewj twohd Aut Aea bet eut
`ji foxdi ot aetg tomds. huttojb ` fordm`j"s sgevdn g`jind oj twe te bdt
` poj fer ` irovojb rei* Ygdj gd sgewdi tgdm gew te fox tgd s`md
poj wgdj ot werldi neesd `ji tgd tgrd`is ej tgd juts wdrd werj
smeetg `s ` wgostnd `j geur `ftdr tgd forst ard`liewj*
Rd rd`hgdi Sulew `aeut dndvdj e"hnehl `ji fdrrodi `hress te J`j-
lojb. bdttojb ` getdn reem ejny `ftdr ` Hgojdsd mevdi eut. pdrmottojb
us te usd ot* Ygd getdn w`s p`hldi. ejd budst adojb Fu`i Ady.
fermdr Yurlosg Mojostdr `t Yelye. wge w`s tgdrd t`nlojb wotg Ir*
H* H* Ru `aeut ` jdw hemmdrho`n trd`ty* Rd teel tgd merjojb
tr`oj te Xg`jbg`o. tr`vdnojb oj ` h`r prevoidi fer Bdjdr`n Gu`jb.
tgdj M`yer ef Xg`jbg`o. wge w`s `nse rdturjojb `ftdr ` vosot te tgd
frejt*
@nn tgrdd ef us g`i ejny pr`osd fer tgd w`y oj wgohg wd wdrd
trd`tdi oj ` heujtry wgdrd enidr rdsoidjts w`rjdi us tg`t eur gd`is
weuni jet ad wertg tgdor hgdmoh`n hejtdjt of wd wdrd te vdjturd ojte
tg`t woni ojtdroer oj suhg treuaneus tomds* Ot w`s ` n`rl fer us.
`jyw`y `ji O bet i`t` ej tgd Hgo`jb-Fdjb hemaojd `t forst g`ji*
Ot rdsuntdi oj tgd r`poi idhnojd ef tgd Qdi Qusso`j rund oj G`jlew*
O h`ubgt tgd forst rovdr std`mdr a`hl up tgd _`jbtzd ej Kuny 1 te
ard`l tgd idt`ons te Hemr`id Aereioj `ji gos Qusso`j @ivoser`td. `ji
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 120/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 121/455
8 YGD QDI FN@MD F@IDX
YGDrovdr std`mdr up tgd _`jbtzd-lo`jb ndft `j geur d`rnodr
tg`j O g`i addj teni ot weuni fer tgd jdrvd-tojbnojb vey`bd te
G`jlew. `ji wd jd`rny mossdi tgd ae`t* Fr`jl Qondy ef Ygd
Nejiej Yomds 'Ygd Ygujidrdr/ `ji O tdndpgejdi te hgdhl tgd
tomd ef idp`rturd `b`oj. fer std`mdrs `nejb tg`t w`tdr gobgw`y oj tgd
muiindi i`ys ef 0?12-17 ndft `jy pert wgdj tgd nd`vojb w`s beei*
O g`i addj teni `t tgd podr tg`t tgd X* X* Yuhlwe weuni s`on `t
jeej se Qondy `ji O g`i ` ndosurdny ard`lf`st `t tgd wdnn-`ppeojtdi
@mdroh`j Hnua tg`t oind
merjojbef
Kuny 1.wgdj wd wdjt
uptgd
rovdr* Gd w`s m`lojb ot fer wg`t `pp`rdjtny turjdi eut te ad gos
n`st trop* Rd p`hldi ejd a`b d`hg. g`i tgd Hnua"s ieerm`j h`nn `
meter h`r. irevd te tgd iehl `t 0 0 ;83 `*m*. oj wg`t wd adnodvdi w`s
`mpnd tomd `ji s`w tgd dnusovd nottnd Yuhlwe kust ard`lojb `w`y
fer gdr vey`bd. `ji eurs* Rd irevd ej te tgd podr* Sohldjs ef tgd
Hgoh`be Yroaujd. w`s bdstohun`tojb woniny te us* Qondy `ji O kumpdi
frem tgd h`r* Ygd Yuhlwe w`s `nrd`iy twe y`ris frem tgd weeidj
podr. `ji tgd `jbry w`tdrs ef tgd ydnnew _`jbtzd wdrd adnew us*
H`thg tgos. O ydnndi `t Aea `ji tgrdw gom my pert`and typd-
wrotdr* @ji tgos* Gd bet my a`b. `nse* Aea `ji etgdrs ej ae`ri
ldpt sgeutojb te us te h`thg ` s`mp`j te moistrd`m `ji hemd `ae`ri
tgdrd* Aut ojstd`i. Qondy. ` sox-feetdr `ji nejb ef noma. m`id ` nd`p
fer ot evdr tgd dvdr woidjojb b`p* O g`i je tomd te tgojl* O r`j `
fdw p`hds. m`id ` fnyojb nd`p oj turj `ji tgdy y`jldi md ej ae`ri*
Rd g`i m`id ot ay tgd j`rrewdst ef m`rbojs. aut wd aetg wdrd ej
ae`ri. `ji s`fd*
@mejb eur `ridjt hgddrdrs `s wd m`id tg`t uj`oidi fnobgt tgreubg
sp`hd wdrd twe yeujb @mdroh`j wemdj* Ejd w`s beojb up-rovdr
te ad m`rrodi te ` Tjotdi Xt`tds J`vy djsobj ej ae`ri tgd T* X* X*
Hojhojj`to. ` hruosdr tgdj st`jiojb ay `t G`jlew* Ygd etgdr w`s gdr
aroidsm`oi* Ygdy g`i hemd frem tgd Xt`tds. `ji `ftdr mddtojb gdr
010
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 122/455
011 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
foj`jhd oj Gejenunu. tgd aroid idhoidi te keoj tgd J`vy `ji m`rry
gdr s`oner* Xgd w`s h`nndi Hgros. `ji gdr aroidsm`oi w`s Moss
Myrtnd Kegjsej. frem Mohgob`j* Ygd wdiiojb teel pn`hd oj G`j-
lew. tgd fo`jhd prevojb te ad ` J`vy effohdr j`mdi Ronno`m Diiy*
Ygdsd wemdj djnovdjdi tgd trop upstrd`m hejsoidr`any* Ygd w`r
w`s `t nd`st supdrfoho`nny quodshdjt oj tgd ujad`r`and gd`t ef moi-
summdr* Ygd vey`bd w`s ndss tdjsd tg`j tgd ejd ej tgd Neejbwe
oj @pron. `ji wd g`i ` b`n` tomd `mejb ` merd rdspejsovd sgop"s
hemp`jy* My pdrsej`n rdhenndhtoejs ef tg`t Feurtg ef Kuny eff Rugu
rdm`oj dspdho`nny idnobgtfun* Ygd wdiiojb `t G`jlew ` fdw i`ys
n`tdr `iidi ` teuhg ef rem`jhd te tgd brom ausojdss ef w`rf`rd* Aetg
Qondy `ji O `ttdjidi oj tgd quodt hempeuji ef mdmadrs ef tgd Nu-
tgdr`j Hgurhg tgdrd. m`jy ef wgem wdrd Xwdiosg*
Ejd jet uj`ttr`htovd yeujb pdrsej seubgt te td`hg md ` fdw ruio-
mdjt`ry dxprdssoejs oj tg`t tejbud* Ygd ejny ejd wgohg O stonn rd-
h`nn frem tg`t rem`jtoh ojtdrnuid oj tgd wgotd gd`t ef Hgoj`"s rdvenu-
toej os; K`b dnsl`r iob! Ye ` Xh`jioj`vo`j. tgesd seujis md`j O
nevd yeu* Ygd wdiiojb w`s tgd ejny aot ef rem`jhd wgohg wd wdrd
te djheujtdr oj G`jlew `moi tgd rdvenutoej`ry dvdjts wgohg sworndi
`aeut us* Ef heursd. tgdrd wdrd stonn tgd i`jhojb borns `t tgd h`a`rdts*
Oj tgd `wfun gd`t. dvdj tgdy f`idi `ji tgdor hgd`p tojsdn nest `nn prd-
tdjsd ef bn`meur*
Ejd dvdjojb O g`i iojjdr oj tgd effohdrs" mdss ej ae`ri tgd
T* X* X* Hojhojj`to Ygd hruosdr w`s `jhgerdi oj moistrd`m Ygd
_`jbtzd os ` mond er merd woid `t Rug`j. `ji tgd hn`y a`jls `rd
new `ji fn`t* Of ` arddzd wdrdstorrojb `jywgdrd `hress tg`t stofnojb
evdj. ot sgeuni w`ft evdr tg`t strd`m"s hdjtdr* Ygdrd os jetgojb wg`t-
dvdr te step ot. je wojiard`l er a`rroh`id ef `jy idshroptoej* _dt
`t sdvdj e"hnehl tg`t dvdjojb ` tgdrmemdtdr adnew idhls. wotg `nn pert-
gends epdj. rdbostdrdi 032 idbrdds F`grdjgdot* @ji tg`t w`s tgd
heen ef tgd dvdjojb oj G`jlew oj moi-Kuny* Eni-tomdrs novojb
tgdrd tgesd wge sdd tg`t tgd n`mps ef Hgoj` g`vd eon. tgd a`jldrs.
tgd Ferdobj Xdrvohd effoho`ns ef tgd Hejsun`tds. `ji tgd mossoej`rods
`ji puanosgdrs wdrd `brddi tg`t ot w`s tgd s`md oj `jy moi-summdr.
`ji tg`t tgd Kuny ef 0?12 dxpdrodjhdi je ujgd`ri-ef gd`t w`vd*
Ygd G`jlew bevdrjmdjt wotgdrdi `ji iodi oj tg`t gd`t. `ji
andw `w`y* Mol`n Aereioj `ji gos hemr`ids. roiojb tgd hrdst ef tgd
rdvenutoej"s jertgw`ri toid wgdj O w`s `mejb tgdm ` fdw wddls
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 123/455
YGD QDI FN@MD F@IDX 018
adferd. fndi g`pg`z`riny jertgwdst ay meter h`r`v`j tew`ri Eutdr
Mejbeno`. ` frodjiny tgeubg stonn jemoj`nny ojidpdjidjt Xevodt Qd-
puanoh* Dvdjtu`nny tgdy `nn rd`hgdi Xoadro` `ji prehddidi te Meshew*
Ygd gd`t wgohg h`usdi tgos swoft pgdjemdjej oj Hgoj`"s strubbnd
tew`ri gdr idstojy w`s ef ` ioffdrdjt j`turd frem tg`t wgohg h`usdi
us se muhg aeiony ioshemfert* Oj tgd m`oj. ot w`s `ppnodi ay Bdj-
dr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `ji gos jdw rdbomd `t J`jlojb* Gos hej-
fdrdjhd wotg tgd ujprdioht`and Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n%" M`rsg`n Fdjb
_u-gso`jb. g`i swujb tg`t pewdrfun dx-tr`oter ojte nojd `ji areubgt
`
puanohprejeujhdmdjt ay
Fdjb
te tg`t dffdht*
Fdjbquot gos Hem-
mujost frodjis `t G`jlew wotgeut ` quovdr* Gd g`i kust hemd a`hl
te Hgoj` frem Meshew. m`lojb tgd keurjdy evdrn`ji tgreubg Xoadro`
`ji Mejbeno` Gos epdj ieer w`s tgreubg Xgdjso Srevojhd. jd`r
Yoadt. te tgd tewj ef Hgdjbhgew. oj Gej`j Srevojhd `tgw`rt tgd
r`onw`y nojlojb G`jlew `ji Sdlojb* Gd sdozdi hejtren ef Hgdjb-
hgew. premosdi `oi te gos hemr`ids oj G`jlew. sdhrdtny wdjt te
Gsuhgew-fu. hejfdrrdi tgdrd wotg Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb `ji turjdi
gos a`hl ej Hemmujosm `ji G`jlew* Fdjb sdjt ` tdndbr`m te tgd
mdj oj tgd G`jlew bevdrjmdjt. rdfdrrojb te Aireioj `ji gos Qusso`j
@ivoser`td tgdrd. `ji penotdny aut formny tdnnojb tgdm te bdt eut* Ygdy
ioi* Ygdrd w`s jetgojb dnsd te ie*
@t forst. Aereioj rdfusdi te adnodvd oj Fdjb"s pdrfoiy* O teni gom
tg`t O g`i sddj ` hepy ef Fdjb"s tdndbr`m. wgohg g`i addj m`id
`v`on`and te md wgond rdturjojb wotg Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl
frem gos mddtojb wotg Fdjb* Ygd Qusso`j"s p`nd f`hd turjdi novoi*
Ygdj gd s`oi; M`rsg`n Fdjb os eur frodji* Gd os my frodji. je
m`ttdr* Gd os stonn wotg us* O `m surd gd st`ys trud te G`jlew*
Aut Fdjb ioi jet st`y trud te `jyaeiy er `jytgojb fer vdry Znejb*
Q`yj` Sregmd. tgd rdi-gd`idi yeujb wem`j wge g`i se `any
diotdi Ygd Sdepnd"s Yroaujd. `nse g`i te fndd* Xgd m`id gdr w`y te
Sdlojb `ji `ftdr ` fdw wddls wdjt `hress Xoadro` te Meshew* Ygdrd.
gd`rt-areldj aut stonn fobgtojb fer tgd sprd`i ef ` trud hejhdptoej ef
tgd hemmuj`n tgdery ef nofd. sgd iodi*
Ygd tdndbr`m frem Fdjb te G`jlew w`s ` sdnf-pertr`ot ef tgd
Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n* Ygd mdss`bd w`s `iirdssdi te R`jb Hgojb-
wdo `ji etgdr r`ioh`n Hgojdsd nd`idrs `t G`jlew* Ot fennews;
Rgdj O mdt yeu bdjtndmdj oj Hgdjbhgew. wd t`nldi ef tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 124/455
019 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
epprdssoej ef tgd mdrhg`jts `ji etgdr mdmadrs ef tgd bdjtry. ef
n`aer epprdssojb tgd f`htery ewjdrs `ji ef tgd epprdssoej ef
f`jjdrs ay n`jiewjdrs*
Ygd pdepnd wosg te supprdss tgos ferm ef idspetosm* M`jy
seniodrs wge fobgt `t tgd frejt suffdr adh`usd tgdor f`monods `rd
mostrd`tdi oj Gej`j `ji dnsdwgdrd oj Hdjtr`n Hgoj`* Oj tgd
j`md ef tgd J`toej`nost S`rty. m`jy tgojbs `rd adojb iejd
wgohg `rd wrejb* Ygdrd os `j dffert adojb m`id te tgrew eur
heujtry ojte furtgdr hejfusoej mdrdny fer tgd pdrsej`n adjdfot
ef ` fdw ojiovoiu`ns* M`jy ef tgd r`ioh`n dndmdjt wermdi tgdor
w`y ojte eur S`rty Erb`joz`toej oj `j dffert te hejtren tgd dj-
tord Luemojt`jb Mevdmdjt* Ygdy g`vd iejd `nn tgd ujn`wfun
tgojbs tgdy h`j te tgos dji* Gobgdr mdmadrs oj eur S`rty Er-
b`joz`toej g`vd seubgt te step tgos hrd`toej ef ujrdst wotgoj eur
S`rty. aut tgd r`ioh`ns g`vd rdfusdi te eady eridrs*
Rd `nse t`nldi ef rdmdiods fer tgos sotu`toej*
Ygd ejny senutoej 'wgohg wd `nse ioshussdi/ os. `s O sdd ot.
`s fennews; 0/ Mol`n Aereioj. wge `nrd`iy g`s rdsobjdi. sgeuni
rdturj te gos ewj heujtry ommdio`tdny< 1/ Ygesd mdmadrs ef
tgd Hdjtr`n Dxdhutovd Hemmottdd oj tgd G`jlew Bevdrjmdjt
wge wosg te be `are`i fer ` rdst sgeuni ad `nnewdi te ie se*
Ygd etgdrs m`y keoj wotg tgd J`jlojb Bevdrjmdjt. of tgdy
idsord*
Oj Gsuhgew-fu. O ioshussdi tgos preandm wotg tgd J`jlojb
Bevdrjmdjt effoho`ns* Rgdj tgdy g`i gd`ri tgd rdsunts ef eur
hejvdrs`toejs oj Hgdjbhgew. tgdy wdrd aetg keyeus `ji s`i*
Ygdy g`vd wdnhemdi tgd `aevd subbdstoejs* Aetg J`jlojb `ji
G`jlew. O adnodvd. ujidrst`ji tgdsd mutu`n preandms*
O jddi jet rdmoji yeu bdjtndmdj. ef heursd. tg`t eur heujtry
os f`hojb ` sdvdrd hrosos< aut oj vodw ef tgos. O fddn hejstr`ojdi
te ojsost tg`t tgd prdsdjt os ` beei tomd te ujotd tgd J`toej`nost
f`htoejs fer tgd fobgt `b`ojst eur hemmej djdmods* Ot os myidsord tg`t yeu `hhdpt tgd `aevd senutoej `ji rd`hg ` hejhnusoej
ommdio`tdny* Ojiovoiu`n hejfnohts must ad evdrhemd se tg`t eur
rdvenutoej m`y suhhddi oj tgd sgertdst pessoand tomd. `ji Ir*
Xuj _`t-sdj"s Ygrdd Srojhopnds ad put ojte dffdht* Ygos os tgd
ejny s`nv`toej ef eur heujtry* Rd must rdvdrd tgd mdmery ef
Ir* Xuj. `ji wd must rdmdmadr tgesd ar`vd seniodrs wge g`vd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 125/455
YGDQDIFN@MDF@IDX 014
bovdj tgdor novds oj tgd h`usd* Eur weujis g`vd jet addj
gd`ndi* Ygeus`jis oj tgd jertg `rd stonn ujidr tgd wonn ef tgd
monot`rosts* Ygdy `rd `jxoeus fer eur gdnp* Rd must ujotd
fertgwotg*
Bdjdr`n Y`jb Xgdj-tsd os p`troetoh `ji stonn ` trud rdvenu-
toejost. se gd sgeuni sdji treeps te Hgdjbhgew ommdio`tdny `ji
heepdr`td wotg md oj eridr te h`pturd Sdlojb `ji hempndtd tgd
t`sl ef eur Jertgdrj Dxpdiotoej*
O m`ld tgdsd subbdstoejs sojhdrdny. `ji dxpdht yeu te `hhdpt
tgdm*
Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. hemmdjtojb ej tgd `aevd. s`oi;
O `m mest g`ppy `t tgos form st`ji t`ldj ay M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-
gso`jb* Rd `rd pn`jjojb te hejtojud eur jertgdrj h`mp`obj vdry
seej jew. je nejbdr fd`rojb tg`t eur rd`r m`y ad hut eff `t Gsuhgew-
fu frem tgd wdst* Oj ndss tg`j ` mejtg tgd Qdis g`i bejd frem
Hgoj` `ji Aereioj w`s oj tgd v`j ef tg`t idfd`tdi a`ji ej tgd nejb
evdrn`ji trdl. a`hl te Meshew*
D`rnodr. Aereioj w`s tgd forst m`j oj tgd idhnojojb G`jlew bev-
drjmdjt wgem O s`w wgdj wd rd`hgdi Rug`j d`rny oj Kuny. 0?12*
O w`jtdi te bdt gos rd`htoej te tg`t tdndbr`m frem tgd ""Hgrosto`j
Bdjdr`n* Rgdtgdr Aereioj s`w tg`t gos Qusso`j @ivoser`td"s p`rt
oj tg`t r`poiny sgoftojb rdvent w`s evdr rdm`ojs hejkdhtur`n. aut gobgny
prea`and* Gos quohl dyds jerm`nny jet ejny s`w tgd preandms hej-
st`jtny `rosojb `nn `aeut gom. aut `nse s`w `nn `reuji tgdm `s wdnn
`ji semdtomds ej p`st tgdm te tgdor ojdvot`and hejhnusoejs*
Rgdj O t`nldi wotg gom tgos tomd. Aereioj neeldi tordi* Gos `tto-
tuid w`s stonn ejd ef idfo`jhd te tgesd 'te gom/ ndssdr mdj wge weuni
ojtdrrupt gom `s gd feubgt tew`ri gos be`n ef arojbojb `nn Hgoj` ojte
tgd werni rdvenutoej ndi ay Meshew* Ot w`s oj gos sp`hoeus effohds
`b`oj tg`t O s`w gom n`st* Idspotd brewojb `bot`toej gdrd `ji dnsd-
wgdrd `b`ojst gom `ji gos Hemmujost `ssost`jts. gd ojsostdi tg`t gd
w`s jet rd`iy te quot* Gd fdnt tg`t gos werl oj Hgoj` w`s jet ydt
fojosgdi* Gd rdotdr`tdi semdwg`t gd`tdiny tg`t gd w`s fennewojb tgd
projhopnds eutnojdi ay tgd n`td Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj. wge g`i ojvotdi
Aereioj te p`rtohop`td oj tgd H`jtejdsd-ojspordi Qdvenutoej `b`ojst
Sdlojb. `ji `ssdrtdi tg`t tgd @br`ro`j Qdvenutoej ef Hgoj` must
be ej*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 126/455
016 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Gd rdhdovdi md herio`nny djeubg. dvojhojb brd`t ojtdrdst oj `nn
g`ppdjojbs oj J`jlojb `ji Xg`jbg`o. p`rtohun`rnysojhd G`jlew w`s
`b`oj osen`tdi* Ygd tdndbr`pg words wdrd iewj `ji tgdrd w`s je
weri dxhdpt fer arodf wordndss iosp`thgds tg`t rd`hgdi tgd H`pot`n* Gd
w`jtdi te ljew gew Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl"s bevdrjmdjt w`s pre-
hddiojb. `ji gew Fdjb `ji Hgo`jb wdrd `brddojb*
Aereioj. nold tgd rdst ef tgd G`jlewotds. prefdssdi te adnodvd tg`t
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl rundi J`jlojb wotg `j orej g`ji* Ygd hgodf eakdh-
toejs te Hgo`jb wdrd gos `nndbdi monot`rosm `ji gos idsord fer pdr-
sej`n b`oj. `s G`jlew s`w ot* Aereioj ojsostdi tg`t Fdjb"s tdndbr`m
idm`jiojb gos rdsobj`toej w`s ` f`ld*
Yg`t os jet Fdjb"s stynd. gd s`oi* Gd ioij"t wrotd tg`t tdnd-
br`m. O `m surd* Gos pdrsej`n tdndbr`ms te G`jlew g`vd addj dj-
tordny ioffdrdjt* Gos ndttdrs te md `rd jet nold tg`t* Puddr tgojbs
g`ppdj oj tgd monot`ry `ji penotoh`n nojd-ups oj Hgoj`. gewdvdr* Ejd
must ujidrst`ji gew te t`ld tgdsd tgojbs* Fdjb os hejtojuojb te
heepdr`td wotg us* Gd g`s rdprdsdjt`tovds gdrd jew* Gew ie
yeutgojl gd h`j suppert suhg ` tdndbr`m5 O iej"t adnodvd Fdjb wretd
ot `ntgeubg gd mobgt g`vd addj ojfnudjhdi te sobj semd suhg iehu-
mdjt*
Rd rdturjdi te tgos suakdht n`tdr. `ji Aereioj `imottdi oj m`jjdr
merd tg`j oj spddhg gos aottdrjdss `t Fdjb"s `htoej. idspotd gos dx-
prdssdi adnodf tg`t Fdjb rdm`ojdi ` ney`n suppertdr ef tgdor Rug`j
f`htoej* Aereioj tgdj rdfusdi te t`nl furtgdr ej tgos suakdht.s`yojb;
""Fdjb os my frodji* O h`jjet ioshuss gos `htoejs*
Aereioj rd`iony ioshussdi etgdr tgojbs*
Eur hgodf preandm robgt gdrd os `j d`rny sdttndmdjt ef tgdspnot
wotg J`jlojb. gd s`oi* @pp`rdjtny wd must ie tgos ay ferhd*
Gdjhd. wd `rd sdjiojb ` monot`ry dxpdiotoej tew`ri J`jlojb ommd-
io`tdny* Rd wonn h`pturd J`jlojb wotgeut ` ieuat* Eur mdj `rd
f`r adttdrfobgtdrs
tg`jHgo`jb
L`o-sgdl"streeps. wge. furtgdrmerd.
`rdj"t vdry ney`n* Ygdy `rd rd`iy te hemd evdr te eur soid. ejhd
bovdj tgd eppertujoty* Ejhd tgos spnot os sdttndi. eur Sdlojb h`m-
p`obj wonn prehddi* Ygd Qusso`j `nse ojsostdi gd w`s jet werrodi
`aeut foj`jhds. idspotd wg`t gd tdrmdi prep`b`ji` hejhdrjojb `
a`i dhejemoh sotu`toej tgdrd* Gd `imottdi tg`t ausojdss w`s a`i `t
tg`t tomd. aut `iidi tg`t tgd rdvenutoej weuni hejtojud idspotd tgos.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 127/455
YGDQDIFN@MDF@IDX 012
`t nd`st `s nejb `s rohd os `v`on`and. wgohg ot stonn os oj brd`t qu`j-
totods*
Aereioj dxprdssdi gobg ojtdrdst oj ` J`jlojb Ojhoidjt sdttnd-
mdjt< gd idhn`rdi tgd Ojhoidjt must ad sdttndi `ji jet `nnewdi te
iod eut* Gd s`oi ; Rd h`jjet jew prevd tgd buontfer tgos ojhoidjt.
aut gostery wonn sgew wgdrd tgd trud buont nods* Rd hejtojud ujidr
tgd stobm` ef tgd werni fer tgos `ff`or jew* Gdjhd. wd must sdd tg`t
ot os sdttndi* Ygd rd`sej Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl ios`rmdi tgd Xoxtg @rmy`t J`jlojb w`sj"t te pujosg tgdm fer tgd J`jlojb @ff`or. aut ad-
h`usd tgdy g`i h`pturdi J`jlojb. `ji gd eridrdi tgdm te h`pturd
Sulew `ji mevd jertgw`ri wotgeut tgd rdst. gd gomsdnf mevojb ojte
J`jlojb oj s`fdty wotg gos ewj `rmods* Ygd Xoxtg @rmy effohdrs
rdfusdi. `ji eppesdi gom* Gdjhd gd ios`rmdi tgdm. sgeetojb iewj
m`jy seniodrs* O wosg tg`t @mdroh` weuni t`ld tgd nd`i `ji sdttnd
J`jlojb* Ot must ad hnd`rdi up*
Aereioj pdrsostdi oj tgd oid` tg`t tgd r`aand `ji orrdspejsoand
h`mp fennewdrs ioi tgd `jto-ferdobj neetojb* Gd a`rldi eut ` idjo`n
tg`t mdj `t G`jlew g`i erb`jozdi tg`t jeteroeus `ff`or*
Aereioj n`ubgdi `t tgd hejst`jt rdperts tg`t gd g`i `nrd`iy fndi
G`jlew* Gd dvdj sheutdi tgd oid` tg`t gos iosmoss`n w`s ommojdjt
aut `iidi tg`t. `ftdr `nn. gd w`s mdrdny `j dmpneyd ef tgd bevdrj-
mdjt `ji `s suhg weuni `nw`ys suamot te ots m`ji`tds*
Ygos sddmojbny oind hemmdjt w`s prepgdtoh* Oj ndss tg`j ` fert-
jobgt. Aereioj w`s bejd*
Ygd jdxt step oj my otojdr`ry w`s `t tgd ieer ef Dubdjd Hgdj.
`hress tgd strddt* Hgdj str`obgtw`y uttdrdi sgronn hrotohosm ef ` sub-
bdstoej ay Xdj`ter Aojbg`m tg`t @mdroh` sdji effoho`n gobg hemmos-
soejdrs te d`hg ef Hgoj`"s v`roeus id f`hte bevdrjmdjts* Gd s`oi tg`t
suhg `htoej weuni idfd`t ots ewj djis. h`usojb `j ojidfojotd hejtoju`-
toej ef Hgoj`"s iosujoty. `ji weuni werl `b`ojst tgd hemmej h`usd
wgohg Hgdj idhn`rdi gos bevdrjmdjt. tgreubg rdvenutoejs. seubgt te
prep`b`td*
Hgdj s`oi; Ygd G`jlew Bevdrjmdjt wonn jdvdr `brdd te suhg `
subbdstoej `s Xdj`ter Aojbg`m"s ef sdjiojb hemmossoejdrs te d`hg
breup oj Hgoj`* O subbdst `s ` heujtdr-prepes`n tg`t R`sgojbtej
sdji ` hempdtdjt effoho`n rdprdsdjt`tovd te Hgoj` wgesd rdpert weuni
dj`and @mdroh` hnd`rny te ujidrst`ji eur mevdmdjt* Of suhg `j ef-
foho`n rdprdsdjtdi tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds oj Sdlojb tei`y tgojbs mobgt ad
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 128/455
017 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
ioffdrdjt% aut tg`t rdprdsdjt`tovd ef tgd Arotosg Dmpord gd`iojb yeur
Ndb`toej g`s jdvdr addj f`or te us* Rd ie jet w`jt `jetgdr m`j
sdjt frem er te Sdlojb* Rg`t os jdhdss`ry os ` jdw moji bovojb `
jdw `ji ydt dxpdrt rdpert ej wg`t gd sdds gdrd jet ` m`j wotg tgd
`aonoty ef ` hndrl!
Gd must g`vd vosoej `ji ojsobgt. ` frdsg moji tg`t h`j br`sp
wg`t wd `rd tryojb te ie gdrd* Yg`t weuni ie merd te hn`rofy@mdr-
oh`"s ujidrst`jiojb ef eur rdvenutoej tg`j `jytgojb dnsd O h`j tgojl
ef* Aut of yeu sdji rdprdsdjt`tovds gdrd `ji te J`jlojb `ji Sdlojb.
yeu tdji te hejtojud tgd sdp`r`toej ef tgdsd f`htoejs ojidfojotdny*
Xuhg qu`so-rdhebjotoej weuni g`vd tgd werst dffdht om`boj`and* O
ieuat tg`t tgd Xdj`ter"s oind oid`s wonn rdhdovd muhg `ttdjtoej oj
R`sgojbtej*+"
Hgdj. nold tgd etgdr effoho`ns. hejtojudi estdjsoany i`ppdr `ji ep-
tomostoh hejhdrjojb G`jlew"s futurd* Gd idjodi tg`t tgd sotu`toej
w`s `jy merd sdroeus tg`t ot g`i addj oj M`y. idhn`rojb; Rd wonn
t`ld J`jlojb wotgoj ferty i`ys. wotgeut ` qudstoej*Hgo`jb
L`o-
sgdl"s mdj `rd rd`iy jew te hemd te G`jlew `s seej `s wd mevd oj
tg`t iordhtoej* Gos effohdrs `rd jet ney`n* Gd os p`jidrojb te Xg`jb-
g`o"s mdrhg`jts `ji `s ` rdvenutoej`ry gd os fojosgdi*
Hgdj `nse. gewdvdr. aottdrny idjeujhdi M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb.
iuaaojb gom tgd Ndep`ri ef Hgoj`* Gd `iidi. Aut Fdjb wonn
jdvdr `tt`hl G`jlew< gos g`jis `rd funn g`jinojb Gej`j Srevojhd
wgohg gd os `and te usd jew `s ` rdsunt ef eur`ppeojtmdjt*
Aut wd
stonn hejtren Gej`j*
Hgdj `imottdi tg`t G`jlew w`s hejsoidrojb tgd pesotoej ef eur
Qusso`j `ivosdrs. p`rtohun`rny Aereioj* Gd s`oi. gewdvdr. tg`t tgdy
weuni ad rdt`ojdi `s nejb `s tgdy wdrd usdfun* Hgdj s`w je rd`sej
te ioshg`rbd tgdm `s ydt. `iiojb gewdvdr tg`t gd tgeubgt Aereioj
rd`nny idsdrvdi ` v`h`toej*
Gdg`s
werldioj
eur rdvenutoej fer tgd n`st feur yd`rs. Hgdjs`oi. `ji g`s iejd rdm`rl`any wdnn. werlojb g`ri i`y `ji jobgt*
Gdjhd. nold `jy m`j. gd jddis `ji idsdrvds ` v`h`toej* Ygos ieds
jet md`j tg`t wd hejsoidr subbdstojb tg`t gd `htu`nny t`ld ejd jer
tg`t gos werl os ujs`tosf`htery* O `m mdrdny t`nlojb fr`jlny ef tgd
pgysoh`n sotu`toej ef `jy m`j*
Ot w`s ioffohunt te tdnnkust wg`t Hgdj md`jt ay tgos. aut O `m
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 129/455
YGD QDI FN@MD F@IDX 01?
ojhnojdi te adnodvd tg`t gd `htu`nny md`jt tg`t `jy m`j wge werls
feur yd`rs wotgeut ` rdst jddis ` nottnd tomd `w`y frem tgd kea*
Hgdj `nse `vdrrdi;
Dvdrytgojb os beojb smeetgny gdrd oj G`j-
lew* Rd `rd jet werrodi* Ej tgd hejtr`ry. wd rdm`oj mest hej-
foidjt ef tgd futurd* Hgdj"s st`tdmdjt w`s g`riny hemp`toand wotg
i`ony dvdjts tg`t summdr oj tgd str`jbd rdvenutoej`ry rdbomd* Hgdj.
nold Aereioj. ojsostdi tg`t tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt+" sgeuni ad sdttndi
adh`usd tgd werni tgeubgt tg`t G`jlew w`s buonty* Rd wonn t`ld ot
te tgd Nd`bud ef J`toejs of jdhdss`ry. gd s`oi* O m`id tgd prepe-
sotoej fer `j Ojtdrj`toej`n Ojvdstob`toej Hemmossoej* Rgy iej"t yeu
rdpny5 Rd st`ji rd`iy te f`hd tgd f`hts. aut wd `rd jet rd`iy te
`hhdpt g`sty `ffoi`vots frem ao`sdi rdfubdds*
Hgdj w`s `nse bejd wotgoj tgd mejtg*
Hejsun-Bdjdr`n Fr`jl Nehlg`rt s`oi n`tdr tg`t i`y tg`t gd pdr-
sej`nny adnodvdi tgojbs weuni hejtojud te werry `nejb oj G`jlew
ojidfojotdny* Ygd Henejdn tgeubgt tg`t tgd stupdjieus hg`jbds oj tgd
n`st twe mejtgs g`i addj supdrfoho`n* Ferdobjdrs bdjdr`nny wdrd oj-
tdrdstdi oj ljewojb wgdj @mdroh` weuni rdturj ` Hejsun te J`jlojb*
Ygd tr`idrs `ji a`jldrs wdrd wejidrojb wgdtgdr `jy penotoh`n rd`-
sejs n`y adgoji tgd idn`y* Ygdy w`jtdi tgojbs rdturjdi te jerm`nhy*
Ygd f`iojb bnew ef tgd rdi st`r ef Hemmujosm nobgtdi G`jlew
aut iomny oj tgd fdw suhhddiojb wddls ef tg`t iosm`n. f`tdfun moi-
summdr* @nn Hgoj`. frem tgd ujwodniy. ujhemprdgdjiojb m`ssds oj
_ujj`j Srevojhd ej Aurm`"s aeridr te tgd stdppds ef tgd stonn
treuandi Xoadro`j frejtodr te tgd jertg w`s ojfdhtdi ay tgd vorus ef `
jdw oid`* Ygd i`y ef tgd eni-tomd. sdnf-hdjtdrdi monot`rost wge g`i
gdni sw`y se nejb. iovoiojb tgd hejtojdjt podhd-md`n. `nse w`s hnesojb.
tgeubg merd snewny tg`j tgd ojfnudjhd ef Hemmuj`n tgderods frem
`are`i* Ygd n`st i`ys ef G`jlew"s Qdi rdbomd sddm b`rosg. aoz`rrd
oj tgd nobgt ef prdsdjt-i`y pdrspdhtovd* @t tgd tomd tgdy sddmdi vdry
rd`n ojiddi `ji d`hg i`y ef tg`t sujsdt dr` w`s p`hldi wotg `htoej*
Fr`jl Qondy h`md rusgojb ojte my reem ` i`y er se `ftdr Hgros
g`i m`rrodi gdr j`v`n effohdr* Gd w`jtdi md te keoj gom oj ` trop
semd 133 monds jertg ojte Gej`j Srevojhd. te sdd M`rsg`n Fdjb
_u-gso`jb `t tgd tewj ef Hgdjbhgew* Oj tgd forst pn`hd. O g`i sddj
Fdjb. `ji oj tgd sdheji. Hgdjbhgew w`s tee f`r frem `jytgojb nold
rdno`and tdndbr`pg words* Yee muhg w`s beojb ej. `ji O g`i te w`thg
ot g`ppdj tgdrd oj G`jlew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 130/455
083 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ot w`s fertuj`td fer md tg`t O ioij"t be* Qondy jdvdr h`md a`hl*
Gd ios`ppd`rdi quotd mystdroeusny ejd i`y. wgdj `aeut te st`rt tgd
rdturj keurjdy* Gd sompny w`nldi iewj tgd r`onre`i tew`ri ` meidn
vonn`bd wgohg Fdjb w`s hejstruhtojb ` mond eut frem Hgdjbhgew
`ji w`s sw`nnewdi ay tgd ir`bej* Ojquorods prevdi jetgojb. dxhdpt
tg`t gd w`s nest. wotgeut vosoand tr`hd* Gd stonn os*
@mejb tgd herrdspejidjts fnehlojbte G`jlew tgdj w`s Vojhdjt
Xgdd`j* Kommy w`s diuh`tdi `t tgd Tjovdrsoty ef Hgoh`be `ji feuji
muhg oj hemmej wotg Q`yj` Sregmd. te wgem O ojtreiuhdi gom. fer
sgd tee h`md frem Hgoh`be* Gos funn j`md os K`mds Vojhdjt Xgdd`j.
`ji dvdry ejd h`md te ljew tgos sdjtomdjt`n aut hempndtdny nev`and
sox-feet Orosg-@mdroh`j `s Kommy*
Kommy `ji O g`i ojjumdr`and djheujtdrs aetg seho`nny `ji m rd-
pertojb tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej `t G`jlew* M`jy ef tgdsd wdrd
`musojb* Ejd O rdh`nn w`s eur g`onojb twe Hgojdsd heenods sgertny
adferd i`wj* Ygd heenods wdrd djb`bdi oj h`rryojb tgd ojdvot`and
jobgt seon te tgd hoty"s sdw`bd iump* @s w`s hustem`ry. tgdy g`i
tgdor a`rrdn ef tgos vond-smdnnojb hejhehtoej. er gejdy-auhldt `s ot os
bdjdr`nny ljewj. snujb adtwddj tgdm ej ` sox-feet a`maee pend*
Ygd aeys wdrd sgeutojb nustony `s tgdy h`rdfunny m`id tgdor surd-
feetdi w`y `nejb tgd j`rrew strddt* Ygd ejd prdhdiojb tgd auhldt
ydnndi G`o-ge! `ji tgd etgdr sgeutdi.>9
G`o-ge oj vobereus tejds.
`nadot oj ndssdr venumd* Ygus. lddpojb tgdor tr`iotoej`n sojb-sejb. iue-
synn`aoh rgytgm. tgd heenods wdjidi tgdor w`y `aeut tgdor ausojdss
sdroeusny. of jet oj pdrfdht quodtuid*
@ji tgdj wd mdt tgdm* Xuiidjny. O feuji mysdnf geniojb tgd
rd`r dji ef tg`t a`maee pend `ji m`rhgojb `nejb wotg Mr* Xgdd`j*
Gd ndi tgd prehdssoej* Ygd heenods. g`ppy wotg `j orej Hgojdsd
ienn`r `podhd 'merd tg`j ` i`y"s funn p`y/ hgddrdi us ej `s wd pre-
hddidi `nejb tgd i`rldjdi strddt. sgeutojb oj rgytgm* Rd m`id dx-
hdnndjt prebrdss `t tgd eutsdt ef tgos roiohuneus `ivdjturd* Aut Kommy
stuaadi gos ted* Ygd auhldt kestndi. `ji tgd a`rrdn. pend `ji `nn.
fdnn wotg ` hn`ttdr `ji spn`sg te tgd p`vdmdjt* @ pend-h`t weuni g`vd
ruj `t eur `ppre`hg wgdj wd foj`nny rd`hgdi tgd getdn* @ji se te
adi!
Ygdrd wdrd nuiohreus ojhoidjts suhg `s tgos. aut eur werl oj tgd
m`oj w`s sdroeus i`y oj `ji i`y eut*
Aottdrjdss `ji ` hdrt`oj sdjsd ef idspdr`toej tdmpdrdi ay tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 131/455
YGD QDI FN@MD F@IDX 080
brommdst idtdrmoj`toej prdiemoj`tdi oj G`jlew"s hneuidi `tme-
spgdrd* Ygd strubbnd `b`ojst wg`t prevdi te ad tgd ojdvot`and hej-
tojudi* Effoho`ns wdrd eptomostoh. eutw`riny `t nd`st. `ji G`jlew
supdrfoho`nny `ppd`rdi ujhg`jbdi* Ygd _`jbtzd w`s stonn fonndi wotg
ferdobj w`rsgops* @nn w`s h`nm* Ot w`s tgd h`nm adferd tgd sterm*
Ygdj Aereioj fndi suiidjny ej Kuny OX* Yg`t w`s tgd dji*
@nn tgd Qdis wdrd seej bejd frem Hgoj`* @s f`r `s tgd dyd
heuni sdd tgdrd w`s jet ` Hemmujost Qusso`j `jywgdrd vosoand**
Ygd Qusso`js g`i bejd. G`jlew w`s quodt `b`oj. tgd fobgtojb te
tgd jertg `reuji Hgdjbhgew wotg pohldi Fdjbtodj Srevojhd treeps
frem M`jhguro` w`s djidi* Jdws ef `jy sert iwojindi. `ji ot w`s
`nmest ujadnodv`any get. se O wdjt a`hl iewj tgd _`jbtzd `b`oj te
Xg`jbg`o*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb sddmdi te ad ej tep ef tgd werni `t tg`t memdjt
idspotd G`jlew"s neui tgrd`ts `ji idjujho`toejs. aut oj ndss tg`j
`jetgdr mejtg gd. tee. w`sueut* @j `pp`rdjt s`hrofohd te `ppd`sd
G`jlew fer tgd memdjt. gd wdjt seutg te ` idnobgtfun. h`nm `ji
dxtr`erioj`rony pohturdsqud eni tdmpnd oj Hgdlo`jb Srevojhd. jd`r gos
aortgpn`hd*
@ftdr ` fdw summdr i`ys ef oindjdss oj Xg`jbg`o. O wdjt tgdrd te
sdd gom `ji foji eut wgy*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 132/455
JOJBSE MEQD F@Q
BDJDQ@NOXXOME
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl rdsobjdi frem tgd Lue-
mojt`jb Qdvenutoej `t tgd gdobgt ef ots `pp`rdjtny r`poi stroids
tew`ri suhhdss oj @ubust ef 0?12* Ojtdrj`n iossdjsoej areld
eut `mejb gos hemm`jiojb bdjdr`ns. ndi oj tgd m`oj ay tgd fodry
yeujb nd`idrs frem tgd Lw`jbso Hnoqud wge wdrd te prevd ` tgerj
oj tgd soid ef Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb `b`oj n`tdr Gd trodi hempremosd.
f`ondi. `ji quot tgd rdvenutoej*
@ mejtg d`rnodr. `nnodi wotg tgd Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n. Hgo`jb g`iruj tgd Qdis eut ef `nn Hgoj`* Jew gd w`s eut gomsdnf*
Ygd moisummdr rdsobj`toej w`s p`rtny iud te K`p`j"s djtr`jhd
ojte tgd pohturd* Ygdsd pdrsostdjt jdobgaers fnehldi ojte Xg`jtujb
Srevojhd. anehlojb `j d`sy w`y ef prebrdss up tew`ri Sdlojb*
Hgo`jb fdnt ot w`s adst te objerd K`p`j fer tgd memdjt. t`ld Sdlojb
frem tgd a`hl ieer reutd up tgd Lojg`j Q`onre`i. `s eroboj`nny
pn`jjdi. `ji tgdj id`n wotg Yelye* Gd w`jtdi forst te dnomoj`td
M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-gj. tgdj idhnojojb oj bnery `ji pewdr `t Sdlojb*
Iossdjsoej `resd `s te tgd jdxt mevd oj tgd Qdvenutoej. `ji Hgo`jb
bet eut te ndt tgd etgdrs try tgdor g`jis `t rujjojb tgd `iv`jhd*
Gd wdjt seutg te `j eni tdmpnd oj Hgdlo`jb Srevojhd. vo` Jojbpe
merd f`r oj tg`t stery-aeel n`ji. te pejidr* O fennewdi gom ojte
tgos p`ster`n h`nm te nd`rj wgy*
Ot os jet f`r `s monds be frem Xg`jbg`o seutgd`st ojte Hgdlo`jb
Srevojhd te tgd meujt`oj vonn`bd ef Hgo-le. jdstnojb oj tgd brddj
weeidi gonns wgdrd Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl w`s aerj* _dt te rd`hg tgos
spet ndss tg`j 043 monds `w`y ejd must tr`vdn tgd adttdr p`rt ef `
i`y `ji ` jobgt. `ji oj tgd gd`rt ef tg`t gonn heujtry ejd m`y foji
eni Hgoj`. ujhg`jbdi ay tgd p`r`id ef tgd yd`rs. `s `jhodjt `ji oj-
tdrdstojb `s ` p`bd frem tgd aeel ef M`rhe Sene* Eni mdj `ji
sm`nn aeys tdji sgddp oj tgd vdri`jt v`nndys adjd`tg t`nn pd`ls wgesd
081
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 133/455
J O JBSE MEQD F @ Q
088
sndjidr. idjsd dvdrbrddjs teuhg wgotd fuzzy tufts ef hneuis frem tgd
aewn ef anud sly `aevd*
R`tdr auff`neds. pujhgdi wotg stohls ay g`nf-j`ldi arewj-slojjdi
nottnd fdnnews. w`nl ojtdrmoj`any oj ` horhnd ujidr tg`thgdi reuji reefs
`ji tgus renn ` gd`vy stejd evdr br`oj. pewidrojb ot ojte ` fneur wotg
wgohg tgdsd fenl m`ld tgesd fn`t p`jh`lds ejd sdds oj aob tr`ys `t
dvdry g`mndt* Mdj `ji wemdj ujidr fneppy str`w suj g`ts werl
nejb i`ys oj tgd areonojb summdr suj huntov`tojb djindss fodnis ef rohd
oj dx`htny tgd s`md f`sgoej `s tgdor ferdf`tgdrs. jew nyojb oj eni
r`osdi stejd br`vds. semd hdjturods eni*
Ot w`s jet nejb `be `s tgojbs oj Hgoj` be tg`t L`o-sgdl. sej ef
Hgo`jb. tgd wojd mdrhg`jt. w`s rujjojb `aeut tgd j`rrew iorty strddts
ef Hgo-le. ` novdny yeujbstdr wge dvdj tgdj. tgdy s`y. w`s `nw`ys tgd
nd`idr oj aeyosg b`mds oj tgd vonn`bd* Gd noldi te pn`y seniodr. `ji
wgdjdvdr ` hemp`jy ef seniodrs h`md tg`t w`y L`o-sgdl w`s tgronndi
fer i`ys* Gos f`tgdr w`jtdi tgd aey te adhemd preprodter ef gos hem-
fert`and ausojdss oj tgd nottnd wojd sgep `ji h`rry ej tgd f`mony j`md
oj Fdjbgw` Heujty `s gd `ji gos `jhdsters g`i iejd fer bdjdr`toejs*
Aut tgd aey brdw ojte m`jgeei wotg je tgeubgt aut ef adhemojb `
seniodr* Gos `maotoej irdw gom ojte monot`ry shgeen. `ji ay tgd tomd
gd w`s twdjty gd g`i b`ojdi p`rdjt`n pdrmossoej te be te K`p`j te
stuiy monot`ry shodjhd `ji t`htohs* Ot os s`oi tg`t tgdrd gd `tt`ojdi
beei m`rls `ji semd nottnd f`md fer gos aronno`jhd `s ` str`tdbost `ji
pr`htoh`n seniodr* Gd rdturjdi te Hgoj` te keoj tgd rdvenutoej `b`ojst
tgd Sdlojb monot`ry rdbomd `ji w`s dvdjtu`nny `ppeojtdi te gos gobg
pest tgreubg tgd ojfnudjhd `ji frodjisgop gd g`i wotg tgd feujidr ef
tgd Luemojt`jb mevdmdjt. Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj* Gd g`i nd`rjdi semd-
tgojb ef penotohs oj tgd yd`rs tg`t gd stuiodi seniodrojb. `ji tgos hem-
aoj`toej `oidi tgd `maotoeus yeutg oj gos hnoma te f`md*
@ g`nf iezdj yd`rs g`i p`ssdi sojhd L`o-sgdl vosotdi gos j`tovd
vonn`bd* Gos p`rdjts. tgdy s`oi oj Hgo-le. g`i nejb sojhd iodi* Ygd
eni j`md ef Hgo`jb os je nejbdr f`meus fer fojd vojt`bds ef Hgojdsd
nobgt wojds* Ot g`s ` jdw sobjofoh`jhd* @ j`tovd sej ef Hgo-le g`i
adhemd tgd mest eutst`jiojb foburd oj tgd rdvenutoej oj tgesd g`nf
iezdj yd`rs ef gos `asdjhd* Ygd vonn`bdrs ioi jet an`md gom fer
rdm`ojojb `w`y*
Ygd n`i. tgdy s`oi. g`s addj ausy* @ji tgdy w`bbdi preui
gd`is `t wg`t yeujb L`o-sgdl g`i `hhempnosgdi* Fer tgd Hgojdsd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 134/455
089 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
fddn `nmest `s preui evdr tgd `hhempnosgmdjts ef ejd ef tgdor ewj
vonn`bd `s tgdy ie ef ejd ef tgdor ewj f`mony* Ygd n`i wge g`i addj
ausy rdturjdi te gos j`tovd vonn`bd* Yg`t gd rdturjdi ` idpesdi
nd`idr m`id jet tgd snobgtdst ioffdrdjhd te gos fdnnew tewjsmdj* Oj-
iddi. ot w`s ieuatfun tg`t tgdy ljdw wgy gd g`i hemd*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb gurrodi tgreubg Xg`jbg`o frem J`jlojb ej gos
w`y gemd* Gd ndft gos m`jofdste ef rdsobj`toej wotg tgd hovon ef-
foho`ns `ji wdjt `w`y* O fennewdi gom ojte tgd quodtuid ef gos rdtrd`t.
aut O w`s jet `nejd oj my qudst* Ygd Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf m`id ot
ioffohunt te rd`hg gom aut `nn p`tgs ndi te gos ieer `ji i`y `ji jobgt
sherds ef pdepnd m`id tgd tdioeus ponbrom`bd te gos tdmpnd wgdrd gd
seubgt pd`hd `ji rdst* Ot w`s idjodi gom. fer gos i`y w`s `s funn `s
dvdr ef hejfdrdjhds `ji h`nns* Gos v`h`toej neibd w`s jet oj gos eni
gemd oj Hgo-le* Ot w`s str`obgt up tg`t t`nn eni meujt`oj. ` hnoma
ef `aeut fovd monds. te wgdrd. kust evdr tgd roibd. ` tdmpnd spr`wndi oj
` vorboj wonidrjdss `ji heen arddzds m`id nofd pnd`s`jt oj tgd moist
ef ` terroi @ubust Ygd tdmpnd w`s eni `ji nottnd usdi* @ sherd ef
mejls novdi tgdrd. stuiyojb tgd weri ef Auiig` `ji m`ojt`ojojb tgd
`jhodjt pn`hd oj ` idbrdd ef eridr* Ot w`s quodt `ji rdstfun. `j oid`n
pn`hd fer ejd sddlojb surhd`sd frem tgd turmeon tg`t `bot`tdi tgd v`nndy
adnew*
Ot w`s gdrd tg`t wd feuji Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb `ftdr keurjdyojb ` jobgt
`ji ` i`y* Ygdrd wdrd feur oj eur p`rty mysdnf `ji Mr* G* V*
L`ntdjaerj. `t tg`t tomd @sseho`td Dioter ef tgd Areelnyj D`bnd.
b`tgdrojb m`tdro`n fer ndhturds `ji `rtohnds< `ji twe Hgojdsd wge`htdi `s buoids `ji ojtdrprdtdrs* Jetgojb aut Hgojdsd. `ji tgd io`-
ndht ef tgd iostroht `t tg`t. w`s ujidrsteei tgdrd* Rd wdrd tgd forst
ferdobjdrs te vosot tg`t vonn`bd oj feur er fovd yd`rs. ` huroeus eni
p`rhgmdjt-slojjdi hg`p teni us oj Hgo-le* Eur h`r`v`j hrd`tdi hej-
soidr`and ojtdrdst `ji semd nottnd `musdmdjt. p`rtohun`rny `t md`n tomd
Ljovds `ji ferls wdrd teens ef tgd idvon oj tgos n`ji wgdrd hgepstohls
wdrd stonn tgd ejny utdjsons ef tg`t sert oj usd*
Rd ndft Xg`jbg`o `t sox e"hnehl oj tgd dvdjojb. Rdijdsi`y. @ubust
02. ej ae`ri tgd std`mdr Jojbsg`e. aeuji fer Jojbpe `s eur forst
pert ef h`nn* Frem tgdrd wd bet ojte tgd iostroht ef Fdjbgw`* Rd
dxpdhtdi te ad r`tgdr osen`tdi ej tgos Hgojdsd std`mdr. g`vojb gd`ri
t`nds ef tgd i`jbdr ef tr`vdnojb `jywgdrd eff tgd ad`tdj tr`hl oj tgesd
i`ys. aut te eur surprosd wd mdt `jetgdr ferdobjdr ej ae`ri. ` Ir*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 135/455
084
Ygem`s ef tgd A`ptost Mossoej oj Jojbpe. rdturjojb te gos pest `ftdr
` vosot te Xg`jbg`o* @ji wd `nse ioshevdrdi ` frodji oj Ir* Fejb
Xdh. gd`i ef tgd Djbnosg sdhtoej ef ` n`rbd puanosgojb geusd oj
Xg`jb-g`o* Ir* Fejb. wotg gos wofd `ji f`mony. w`s beojb te tgd geny osn`ji
ef Su-te 'prejeujhdi pee-iee/ fer ` fertjobgt* Gos twe i`ubgtdrs.
aeaadi-g`ordi `ji wd`rojb meidrj spert irdssds. `ji Mrs* Fejb
speld pdrfdht Djbnosg. Mrs* Fejb g`vojb addj aerj oj X`j Fr`jhoshe
Rd keojdi ferhds. eur twe p`rtods fddnojb `t gemd tebdtgdr* Rd ios-
hevdrdi tg`t ` p`rty ef g`nf ` iezdj er se J`toej`nost effohdrs wdrd
beojb te sdd Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb. `nse. se tg`t eur keurjdy. ot sddmdi.
weuni jet ad nejdsemd `jywgdrd `nejb tgd reutd*
Ir* Ygem`s s`oi `t iojjdr tg`t tgdrd wdrd ejny `aeut ` iezdj
ferdobjdrs oj Jfjbpe tgdj. `s hemp`rdi te 014 er se oj erioj`ry
tomds* Gewdvdr. gd mojomozdi tgd i`jbdr ef novojb tgdrd. `s mest
pdepnd ie wge pdrsost oj rdfusojb te dv`hu`td* @ji se f`r `s O s`w
`jywgdrd oj tgd _`jbtzd V`nndy `ji ots vohojoty. tgd Hgojdsd ej tgd
wgend wdrd jet gestond* Ygd seniodrs `t tomds adh`md aetgdrsemd. aut
ejny r`rdny*
@ quddr hustemdr `ae`ri w`s ` nottnd H`jtejdsd hg`p wge h`nndi
gomsdnf Srefdsser _eujb* Gd speld Djbnosg fnudjtny. `s wdnn `s
Bdrm`j `ji Frdjhg `ji ` nottnd Qusso`j. `s gd peojtdi eut oj gos pdr-
sostdjt hejvdrs`toej `ji O must s`y gd weuni prea`any m`ld ` beei
rdpertdr. wotg gos ojs`to`and qudst fer ojferm`toej `aeut dvdryejd gd
mdt* Gd ljdw `nn `aeut md oj tdj mojutds. `ji idspotd gos v`hueus.
smonojb meej f`hd `ji gos g`or. nejb `s `j eni-f`sgoejdi born"s `ji
hurndi up oj semd mejstreus f`sgoej tg`t m`id ot `ppd`r aeaadi. tgos
fdnnew w`s je iumaadnn*
Gd neeldi `t my h`ri `ji idm`jidi te ljew wge feujidi Ygd
Jdw _erl Yomds `ji oj wg`t yd`r O g`i te hejfdss objer`jhd `s te
tgd `jswdrs te aetg qudrods. `ji sg`nn jdvdr ferbovd tgd fdnnew fer tg`t
a`i memdjt* Ygd Srefdsser g`i addj te @mdroh` ejhd. gd hejfoidi.
`ji w`s d`bdr te be `b`oj* Gd h`jioiny `imottdi gd tr`vdndi `s `
budst ef tgd puanoh. tg`t gd g`i je hejjdhtoejs `jywgdrd `ji tg`t
gd pohldi up ` nottnd mejdy jew `ji tgdj ay sdnnojb pgetebr`pgs ef
ojtdrdstojb pdepnd `ji str`jbd pn`hds* Gos `naum w`s fonndi wotg
pgetebr`pgs ef premojdjt pdrsejs oj Hgoj`. wotg `utebr`pgs ef mest*
Gd hrotohozdi Bg`jio. speld ojtdnnobdjtny ef @mdroh`j keurj`nosm `ji
ots gostery `ji tgd feujidrs ef hdrt`oj brd`t i`onods. ioshussdi nofd oj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 136/455
086 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
S`ros. Adrnoj `ji mest etgdr hotods oj Durepd. `ji hejfdssdi gd g`i
jet addj oj Hgoj` fer twdjty yd`rs*
Gd w`s tgdj. gd `imottdi. wrotojb ` gostery ef Hgoj`. wgohg gd
`nse `imottdi w`s te ad ` v`nu`and venumd* Gd g`i je oid` gew gd
weuni bdt frem Jojbpe te Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb. `ji O b`vd gom je ojfer-
m`toej* Gd w`jtdi te dxhg`jbd Hgojdsd pgetebr`pgs fer semd ef
K`p`j tg`t O g`i oj my henndhtoej*
Jojbpe os twe geurs ay std`mdr up tgd _u-y`e Qovdr. adojb oj-
n`ji. `s os dvdry hgodf pert `nejb tgd Hgoj` he`st* Rd iehldi tgdrd
ej Ygursi`y. @ubust 07* Hgojdsd heenods h`j m`ld jeosd oj merd
w`ys tg`j `jyejd dnsd* Rd `rrovdi `t i`wj `ji wd ljdw ot `t ejhd*
Heujtndss adnns ef tgd tojy sdrv`jt-h`nnojb typd wdrd k`jbnojb tgd me-
mdjt wd wdrd oj sobgt ef tgd iehl* Ygdy seujidi nold `nn adin`m
turjdi neesd* O ioshevdrdi tg`t tgdy adnejbdi te tgd rohlsg`w heenods
wge r`jb tgdm hejst`jtny wgond sddlojb hustemdrs `ji `b`oj wgond
trettojb tgreubg tgd j`rrew wojiojb strddts*
Rd g`i tgrdd geurs te w`ot wgond eur Hgojdsd bet ` geusdae`t
`ji n`ujhg `ji prevosoejs fer tgd uprovdr trop. se O teel ` rohlsg`w
`ji `j ojtdrprdtdr `ji irevd eut te tgd etgdr soid ef tgd hoty te h`nn
ej Ir* A`rnew. `nse ef tgd A`ptost Mossoej* O feuji tgd beei Iehter
up te gos `rmpots oj tgd strd`m tg`t fnews `nejbsoid gos geusd. rdp`or-
ojb gos nottnd ae`t* Gd g`ikust `hquordi `j djbojd `ji w`s ausony
foxojb ` pn`hd fer ot `t tgd rd`r ef tgd fn`tae`t* Rd hg`ttdi `wgond
`aeut tgd jdw A`ptost gespot`n. wgohg w`s g`nf Hgojdsd. g`nf ferdobj
oj `rhgotdhturd. `ji `aeut gos werl Ygdrd w`s nottnd djeubg te ie
kust tgdj. ot sddmdi* Gos f`mony g`i bejd gemd `ji gd w`s `nejd
ej tgd kea. wotg Ir* Ygem`s `ji tgd g`jifun ef etgdr ferdobjdrs.
mestny mdrhg`jts `ji hustems pdepnd. oj Jojbpe* Gd w`s ojtdrdstdi
oj jdws ef Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `ji dspdho`nnyoj tgd rumers ef gos hem-
ojb m`oro`bd te Moss Mdo-nojb Xeejb*
Ygd Arotosg-@mdroh`j Yea`hhe m`j`bdr oj Jojbpe. ` m`j j`mdi
V`rgen. w`s `ae`ri wgdj O bet a`hl* Gd `ssostdi us oj dvdry w`yte bdt tgojbs nojdi up fer ` hemfert`and keurjdy. furjosgojb gos geusd-
ae`t `ji n`ujhg. wotg h`mp adis `ji hg`ors `ji `nn tgd rdst ef ot*
Ygdsd ferdobjdrs oj tgd eut perts `rd mest gespot`and. `ji Mr* V`rgen
w`s je dxhdptoej* Rotgeut gom. wd weuni g`vd g`i je dji ef idn`y
`ji treuand* Rd bet ujidr w`y foj`nny `t `aeut 03;83. tgd tojy n`ujhg
tubbojb us uprovdr* Rd st`rtdi up tgd Fdjbgw` Qovdr. wgohg keojs
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 137/455
JOJBSE MEQD F@Q 082
tgd _u-y`e `t Jojbpe* Xnewny. fer tgd geusdae`t w`s ` n`rbd `ff`or.
wd mevdi ojte tgd rovdr `ji upstrd`m p`st sherds ef pohturdsqud eni
kujls `ji myro`is ef
shuttnojbs`mp`js.
`nejb
tgd j`rrew.iojby
eni
Jojbpe Auji. `ji se ojte tgd epdj heujtry adyeji*
Rd g`i toffoj `ae`ri. `j dxhdnndjt md`n sdrvdi ay tgd heel-aey wd
g`i `hquordi `t Jojbpe* Ygd keurjdy se f`r g`i addj id nuxd* Q`oj
squ`nns idn`ydi eur prebrdss frem tomd te tomd. tgd woji adojb `b`ojst
us. `ji `t ejd e"hnehl wd feuji wd wdrd ndss tg`j g`nf w`y te tgd pn`hd
wgdrd wd weuni t`ld sdi`j hg`ors er rohlsg`ws `hress heujtry* @t tg`t
r`td wd weuni jet m`ld Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb"s tdmpnd ay jobgt* Rd hej-
fdrrdi. `ji Mr* L`ntdjaerj subbdstdi huttojb `w`y frem tgd geusdae`t
`ji beojb `gd`i oj tgd n`ujhg* Rd ioi tgos. t`lojb `s muhg feei `s
pessoand oj twe a`sldts. tebdtgdr wotg h`mp hets `ji teondt `rtohnds* @ftdr
`j geur er se tgd r`oj quot `ji wd bet ejny ` nottnd wdt. usojb umardnn`s
te sgodni tgd feei `ji eursdnvds*
Eur prebrdss w`s ojtdrruptdi `t twe-tgorty. wgdj ` kujl mevdi ojte
tgd strd`m `gd`i ef us `ji ` seniodr sobj`ndi us te step* Gd w`jtdi te
ljew of wd heuni t`ld gom `ji gos eridrny uprovdr wotg us* @nrd`iy
gd`vony ne`idi wotg fovd ef us oj tgd tojy n`ujhg. ojhnuiojb tgd ae`t-
m`j. wd wdrd ojhnojdi te rdfusd gos rdqudst. aut tgd Hgojdsd `ivosdi
`b`ojst tgos* Xe tgd twe hn`madrdi `ae`ri `ji wd sdt eff `b`oj.
snewdr tg`j dvdr*
@ fdw monds ej. `s wd bet ojte tgd feet gonns. tgd strd`m iwojindi
ujton eur prepdnndr w`s iobbojb up mui g`nf tgd tomd `ji wd wdrd
a`rdny mevojb* Rd muiindi tgreubg ujton `nmest feur e"hnehl wgdj
tgd ae`tm`j brujtdi `ji wd wdjt `breuji* Rd heuni be je furtgdr*
Ygd strd`m g`i adhemd nottnd adttdr tg`j ` meujt`oj ronn ` fdw y`ris
woid* Rd bet eut `ji w`nldi te ` nottnd vonn`bd ` qu`rtdr ef ` mond
adyeji. wgdrd wd bet rohlsg`ws te tgd pn`hd wgdjhd wd teel hg`ors*
Ygd n`ujhg. nobgtdjdi ef `nn ef us aut tgd ae`tm`j. h`md ej te tgd
vonn`bd. wgdrd wd ndft ot `ftdr ojstruhtojb tgd ae`tm`j te w`ot fer eur
rdturj tgd jdxt i`y*
Ygdrd wdrd semd 833 seniodrs ef Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb"s bu`ris oj tgos
vonn`bd ef Lo`jblew* Rd wdrd brddtdi mest herio`nny `ji g`i je
treuand oj bdttojb rohlsg`ws fer tgd geur"s roid te Xg`ew`jbrjo`e. `r-
rovojb tgdrd `t fovd e"hnehl `ftdr `j ojtdrdstojb roid tgreubg p`iiy
fodnis oj tgd sg`iew ef brddj meujt`ojs* Ygd suj s`jl new adgoji
tgd gonns* Oj tgorty mojutds wd g`i prehurdi feur hg`ors `ji ` h`rry
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 138/455
087 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
heenod fer eur nubb`bd* Rotg tdj hg`or heenods wd wdrd eff fer Hgo-le.
twdjty Hgojdsd no iost`jt* @ no os `aeut ` tgori ef ` mond*
Qoiojb oj ` hg`or os jet ujhemfert`and. aut `ftdr ` wgond ot adhemds
tdioeus. `ji Mr* L`ntdjaerj `ji O feuji rdnodf oj w`nlojb `t ojtdrv`ns*
Hgojdsd pd`s`jts turjdi te st`rd `t eur p`rty `s wd swujb `nejb oj
tgd twonobgt* Rd mdt m`jy f`rmdrs rdturjojb gemd. wd`ry `ftdr `
i`y ujidr tg`t suj. `ji dvdry ejd ef tgdm w`s pnd`s`jt. neelojb
iehond `ji lojiny `ji jet `t `nn `s tgeubg wd wdrd tgd g`tdi ferdobj
idvons tgdy wdrd suppesdi te tgojl us*
Rd rd`hgdi Hgo-le `t sdvdj-tgorty. kust `s tgd forst st`rs wdrd
`ppd`rojb* Ygd tewj w`s dj fdtd. sherds ef hgonirdj rujjojb `aeut
wotg pohturdsqud n`jtdrjs ef `nn sg`pds `ji sozds. frem aob rdi fosg te
` meidn `orpn`jd* Ot w`s ` p`r`id oj gejer ef tgdor rdturjdi Bdjdr`n*
Rd wdjt ojsoid Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb"s geusd* Ot w`s r`tgdr n`rbd fer
Hgo-le. ojioh`tojb tg`t tgd Hgo`jb f`mony g`i djkeydi ` hdrt`oj idbrdd
ef prespdroty* Xeniodrs. `pp`rdjtny effohdrs ef gos bu`ri. wdrd iojojb
oj tgd eutdr reem* Eur ojtdrprdtdr teni us wd wdrd mest wdn-
hemd. `ji tgd effohdrs aewdi `ji smondi bdjo`nny* Rd ioshevdrdi
wd wdrd dxpdhtdi Mr* Y* V* Xeejb. fermdr Mojostdr ef Foj`jhd
oj tgd G`jlew rdbomd `ji ` aretgdr-oj-n`w ef Hgo`jb"s. g`vojb
wordi `gd`i*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb g`i g`i ` prov`td tdndbr`pg nojd strujb up
frem Jojbpe te gos gd`iqu`rtdrs up oj tgesd gonns* Rd areubgt
eut eur feei `ji iojdi `t ` t`and bovdj us fer tg`t purpesd* O
g`i jdvdr addj quotd se muhg tgd hdjtdr ef `nn dyds adferd* Ygdlois" p`r`id areld up fer tgd memdjt `ji tgd wgend tewj. ot
sddmdi. hr`mmdi oj `t tgd ieers `ji hnomadi up te pddr oj `t
tgd wojiews `s wd `td* Ygdy s`oi wd wdrd tgd forst ferdobjdrs
te hemd tg`t w`y oj feur er fovd yd`rs* M`jy ef tgd hgonirdj
heuni jet rdmdmadr dvdr g`vojb sddj ` w`o-be-kdj 'ferdobjdr/
adferd* Ygdy `sldi of wd wdrd @mdroh`js. `ji wgdj wd s`oi wd
wdrd. tgdy sddmdi pnd`sdi. brojjojb are`iny*
Rd g`i te Yourry ej. fer Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb w`s oj gos tdmpnd
gobg `aevd us ej tgd gonn* Nd`vojb Hgo-le `aeut dobgt e"hnehl.
wd pusgdi ej `hress tgd j`rrew strop ef v`nndy adtwddj us `ji
tgd meujt`oj* @t tgd dibd ef tgd vonn`bd wd r`j ojte tgd n`jtdrj
prehdssoej* Eur hg`or heenods. ujiosm`ydi. st`nldi robgt iewj
tgd s`md j`rrew strddt tgd p`r`id w`s hemojb up. `ji wd wdrd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 139/455
JOJBSE MEQD F@Q 08?
oj tgd moist ef aeaaojb n`jtdrjs `ji hn`sgojb hyma`ns `ji `
a`aanojb ef m`jy veohds* Ot w`s ` brd`t sobgt. tgesd p`pdr fosg.
`jom`ns. n`jtdrjs ef `nn sozds `ji ferms h`rrodi
ayhgonirdj. semd
ojf`jts oj `rms geniojb sw`yojb n`jtdrjs ej tgoj rddis* Rgy tgd
hgonirdj wdrd bovojb tgd idmejstr`toej wd jdvdr ioshevdrdi*
Sdrg`ps ot w`s tgdor i`y*
Ygreubg tgd jobgt wd kebbdi. eur ewj hg`ors fermojb ` sert
ef n`jtdrj prehdssoej* Fordfnods oj brd`t gerids sp`rlndi `moi
tgd t`nn br`ss `ji sh`ttdrdi a`maee trdds* Oj `j geur wd jetohdi
etgdr hg`or prehdssoejs* Tp tgd wojiojb meujt`oj p`tg wd
hnomadi. w`nlojb p`rt ef tgd w`y. roiojb wgdj wd bet tordi*
Ygesd sturiy Hgojdsd heenods wdrd m`rvdns* Rotg eur ne`i. twe
ef tgdm heuni be robgt `gd`i `t ` brd`t p`hd up tgd stddpdst oj-
hnojds* Ygdor ndbs `rd gd`vony mushndi. g`ri `s stddn* Adnew ejd
heuni neel a`hl ojte tgd v`nndy `ji sdd etgdr ponbroms tr`vdrsojb
tgd nejb p`tg te tgd meujt`oj tep te sdd tgd rdtordi nd`idr* Gos
sdhnusoej w`s ` mytg*
@t n`st tgd tdmpnd! Rd `rrovdi adferd tgd m`ssovd weeidj
b`tds `t tdj e"hnehl* Ygdrd wdrd `t nd`st tdj hg`ors `ji semd
tgorty heenods* @j eridrny teel eur h`ris `ji ` ndttdr L`ntdjaerj
g`i frem Y* V* Xeejb te Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb `ji wotg ` brujt ios-
`ppd`rdi tgreubg tgd heurty`ri ojte tgd i`rl auoniojb adyeji*
Rd w`otdi* Gd rdturjdi `ji epdjdi tgd b`tds* @ sgeut wdjt
up `s tgd heenods areubgt oj tgdor hg`ors* Ygd bu`ri g`rsgny
eridrdi sondjhd* Ygd Bdjdr`n g`i rdtordi*
Rd wdrd ndi ojte `j ojjdr hg`madr `ji effdrdi feei `ji td`*
Rd heuni jet sdd tgd Bdjdr`n tg`t jobgt. aut `ftdr nejb p`rndys
wotg gos sdhrdt`ry wd m`id ot hnd`r wd w`jtdi te sdd gom d`rny
tgd jdxt merjojb oj eridr te bdt ujidr w`y te h`thg tgd feur
e"hnehl Jojbpe ae`t fer Xg`jbg`o* Rd wdrd tgdj sgewj te `j-
etgdr reem oj tgd r`manojb eni tdmpnd. wgdrd wd feuji m`ts ej
weeidj heuhgds rd`iy fer eur usd* Rd wdrd bovdj dvdry heur-
tdsy* Rd bet eur adi hnetgojb. n`oi ot evdr tgd m`ts. `ji adferd
dndvdj e"hnehl wdrd `snddp. fer tgd sondjhd oj tgesd weeis w`s
gd`vy*
Aeemojb tdmpnd adnns `w`ldjdi us `t fovd e"hnehl tgd jdxt
merjojb* Ygdor rdsej`jt tejds seujidi tgreubg tgd weeis `ji
fonndi tgd `or* Ygd sujnobgt strd`mdi oj `t eur wojiew* Rd `resd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 140/455
093 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`ji feuji ` heenod g`i areubgt get w`tdr `ji tewdns *** `nn tgd
hemferts ef gemd* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb"s v`ndt. ` yeujb m`j O rd-
mdmadrdi frem eur Gsuhgew-fu trop oj Kujd. seej `ppd`rdi+ `ji
areubgt us er`jbds 'Xujlost er`jbds frem H`noferjo`/ `ji ard`l-
f`st. ojhnuiojb get monl. h`lds. ard`i `ji ` sert ef hgehen`td
w`fdr* Rgond wd wdrd d`tojb. tgd v`ndt rdturjdi `ji `jjeujhdi
tg`t Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb w`s w`otojb te rdhdovd us*
Rd feuji gom ej tgd are`i vdr`ji`g eutsoid tgd m`oj auoni-
ojb ef tgd tdmpnd* Rd g`i hg`ors `rr`jbdi `reuji ` sm`nn t`and
ej wgohg get brddj td` w`s pn`hdi. tebdtgdr wotg tgd ojdvot`and
nottnd idnoh`hods suhg `s juts. h`jiods. dth* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb w`s
irdssdi oj ` sonl suot t`onerdi nold tg`t ef ` ferdobjdr dxhdpt tg`t
tgd he`t auttejdi up `reuji tgd jdhl oj sdmo-monot`ry f`sgoej*
Ot w`s tgd ujoferm ef tgd Luemojt`jb. idsobjdi ay tgd n`td Ir*
Xuj _`t-sdj* Gd werd sonl sehls `ji p`tdjt nd`tgdr pumps* Gd
neeldi heen `ji r`tgdr ndss werj `ji ir`wj tg`j wgdj O g`i n`st
sddj gom ej tgd w`y a`hl frem tgd Gsuhgew-fu frejt*
Gd brddtdi us herio`nny `ji sgeel g`jis wotg md. dxprdssojb
gos `pprdho`toej ef tgd g`risgops ejd g`s te be tgreubg te bdt te
tgos eut ef tgd w`y pn`hd `ji ojvotojb us te rdm`oj evdr tgd i`y
se tg`t gd mobgt t`ld us ej ` gold `reuji tgd gonns `ji sgew us `
p`rtohun`rny ad`utofun w`tdrf`nn jet f`r `w`y* Gd w`s sojhdrdny
ios`ppeojtdi wgdj wd teni gom wd must rusg tgreubg tgd ojtdr-
vodw `ji bdt a`hl te Xg`jbg`o wgdrd tgojbs wdrd g`ppdjojb* Gd
subbdstdi wd mobgt be te tgd w`tdrf`nn `jyw`y. `ji eridrdi `j
dshert fer tgd keurjdy* Aut wd heuni jet m`ld ot*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb w`s aottdr `b`ojst tgd K`p`jdsd* Gd s`oi gd
adnodvdi tgdm rdspejsoand fer gos idfd`t oj tgd jertg `ji tgd
f`onurd ef tgd J`toej`nosts" jertgdrj dxpdiotoej oj Kuny*
Ygdor ehhup`toej ef Ysoj`j `ji tgd r`onw`y anehldi us. gd
s`oi* Eur suhhdss w`s `ssurdi ujton K`p`j stdppdi oj*
Hgo`jb s`oi gd ioi jet w`jt te t`nl `jy merd `aeut tgos. jerweuni gd be ojte idt`on `aeut gos quottojb `s Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf*
Gd s`oi. My rd`sejs `rd oj my m`jofdste bovdj eut oj Xg`jbg`o*
Ygdrd `rd je etgdr rd`sejs*
Gd teel gos pesotoej pgonesepgoh`nny* Ygdrd w`s ` aot ef tgd
dbetost oj tgd Bdjdr`n. p`riej`and je ieuat oj vodw ef gos `hgodvd-
mdjts* Gd w`s `sldi of gd ioij"t tgojl gos nd`vojb tgd rdvenu-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 141/455
090
toej `t tgos tomd ef hruho`n g`ppdjojbs w`s aeuji te wd`ldj tgd
h`usd. `ji gd s`oi; _ds. O tgojl se* Hryptoh djeubg* Aut gd
s`oi gd g`i te quot oj vodw ef wg`t g`i
bejd
adferd `ji rdfdrrdi
`b`oj te gos nejb mdss`bd ef rdsobj`toej* Oj tgos gd s`oi tg`t
tgdrd g`i addj tee muhg eppesotoej te gom pdrsej`nny `ji tg`t
gd tgeubgt ujton hejfoidjhd oj gom w`s rdsterdi gd g`i adttdr bdt
eut* Gd aewdi te tgd hrotohosm ef G`jlew `ji te tgd penotoh`n
dxobdjhods ef tgd memdjt*
Ygd Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf s`oi gd mobgt rdturj te tgd rdvenu-
toej* O `m tee muhg ` p`rt ef ot. ot os tee muhg `
p`rt
ef md.
fer md te bdt eut fer `nn tomd* O dxpdht te rdturj te tgd mevd-
mdjt. aut O ie jet ljew wgdj* O weuni nold te be `are`i*
Rgdrd5 O `sldi*
"Ye @mdroh` forst. Hgo`jb rdpnodi* _eu tdnn md tgdy `rd
symp`tgdtoh tgdrd* Rdnn. O weuni nold te be `ji sdd* @ftdr tg`t.
te Durepd `ji dnsdwgdrd* Ot os `nn ojidfojotd. ef heursd* Aut O
jddi ` rd`n rdst*
Gd ojtom`tdi tg`t evdrturds wdrd adojb m`id te bdt gom a`hl
ojte tgd S`rty* Gd w`s ujidhoidi aut gd ojtdjidi te rdm`oj oj
gos tdmpnd rdtrd`t fer ` tomd. oj `jy h`sd* Gd smondi wgdj wd
rdfdrrdi te tgd m`jy vosoters gd w`s g`vojb. dvdj up gdrd* _ds.
gd s`oi. ejd"s rd`n frodjis t`ld tgd treuand te keurjdy dvdj ojte
` pn`hd nold tgos* Gd s`oi Y* V* Xeejb w`s dxpdhtdi oj ` fdw
i`ys* Xeejbw`jtdi te
urbd Hgo`jb"srdturj*
Rd t`nldi fer jd`rny `j geur `ji tgdj. `ftdr pgetebr`pgojb
tgd Bdjdr`n ej gos frejt perhg wotg gos dndvdj-yd`r eni sej.
Hgo`jb Hgojb-p`jb. wd ndft oj eur hg`ors `t dobgt e"hnehl*
Xwojbojb evdr tgd roibd `ji iewj ojte tgd v`nndy adnew. wd
g`i ` g`nf geur ef ejd ef tgd mest m`rvdneus vodws O g`vd dvdr
sddj* Rd heuni sdd fer monds `hress tgd pn`ojs te wgdrd meuj-
t`ojs resd `b`oj ej tgd f`r soid. `ji adnew us ` meujt`oj strd`mwoidjdi ojte ` sonvdry n`ld wgesd stonn w`tdrs bnostdjdi oj tgd
d`rny merjojb sujsgojd*
Ygd keurjdy iewj te eur ae`t `t Lo`jblew teel frem dobgt
ujton ejd* Rd bet te Lo`jblew `t jeej. aut tgd ae`tm`j. rd-
mdmadrojb tgd mui `ji tgd sg`nnew strd`m. g`i ndft gos n`ujhg
tdj no `w`y! Rd g`i te w`nl ot tgreubg tgd moii`y furj`hd ef
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 142/455
091 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tg`t v`nndy `ji wd `rrovdi `j geur n`tdr ej feet tgreubg tgd
gumoi. sw`mpy rohd fodnis. iroppojb wotg pdrspor`toej*
Ygd std`mdr ndft Jojbpe fer Xg`jbg`o `t feur e"hnehl* Rd id-
hoidi `b`oj jet te usd tgd geusdae`t. wgohg g`i rd`hgdi tgos peojt
iurojb tgd `ftdrjeej `ji jobgt. aut te gurry `nejb oj tgd n`ujhg* @t
twe ferty-fovd wd wdrd ejny `aeut g`nf w`y te Jojbpe. `ji tgd pres-
pdhts ef h`thgojb tgd ae`t wdrd iom* Ygdj ` n`rbd n`ujhg ej tgd
rdbun`r uprovdr ruj gevd oj sobgt `ji wd g`ondi ot* Hn`madrojb
`ae`ri. wd feuji ot k`mmdi funn ef Hgojdsd ef tgd pd`s`jt er heenod
hn`ss* Ygdy wdrd mest frodjiny. n`ubgojb `ji k`aadrojb `w`y `t eur
`rrov`n* Ejd rdm`rldi oj Hgojdsd;
>l
Rdnn. O must s`y O g`vd sddj wgotdr ferdobjdrs tg`j tgdsd*
Gd w`s ieuatndss robgt* Eur f`hds wdrd ` arobgt rdi. `ji tgd
sujaurj sm`rtdi fer i`ys. idspotd eur are`iarommdi str`w g`ts*
Ygd n`ujhg bet te Jojbpe kust`t feur e"hnehl* Rd r`hdi `nejb
tgd Auji ` g`nf mond te wgdrd eur std`mdr w`s te idp`rt* Ot g`i
bejd* Rd heuni sdd ot ` qu`rtdr ef ` mond iewj strd`m aut f`r frem
eur gepds ef h`thgojb ot* Gewdvdr. eur Hgojdsd ioshevdrdi ` std`mdr
`nejbsoid tg`t w`s nd`vojb `t feur-tgorty* Rd sobgdi wotg rdnodf* Ye
spdji ` jobgt `ji ` i`y oj Jojbpe weuni g`vd addj torojb*
Rd bet ujidr w`y `t feur-tgorty. `ftdr p`yojb eff eur aonns `ji
bovojb eur Hgojdsd frodjis m`jy tg`jls fer ` mest iovdrtojb trop*
Ygd vey`bd w`s ujdvdjtfun iurojb tgd dvdjojb* Rd p`ssdi tgd etgdr
sgop. ojhoidjt`nny. `t `aeut dobgt e"hnehl. muhg te eur ujgeny bndd*
@ftdr iojjdr. wgohg wd `td oj senot`ry spndjier. tgd Hgojdsd iojojb
ej rohd `t sox e"hnehl `ji wd g`vojb ferdobj hgew `t sdvdj. wd
turjdi oj*
Ot w`s tgrdd-twdjty-fovd `*m*. @ubust 13. wgdj wd wdrd `w`ldjdi
ay ` sdrods ef tdrrofoh dxpnesoejs* Nd`jojb eut ef my aujl. O pddrdi
ojte tgd jobgt* @ hr`sg. `ji ` fn`sg ef ford h`md frem ` i`rl sgop jet
933 y`ris `w`y* @b`oj tgos w`s rdpd`tdi* Xgronn hrods h`md frem
tgd wemdj `ae`ri. `ji mdj rusgdi `aeut*
O wdjt ej idhl oj lomeje te ioshevdr tgd treuand* Ot `ppd`rdi
tg`t ` Hgojdsd w`rsgop w`s forojb`t us* Xox sgets h`md re`rojb evdr
eur gd`i. ejd n`jiojb kust `gd`i ef tgd aew `ji slottdrojb `hress tgd
w`tdr* Ot w`s je fuj. tg`t ausojdss. `ji O rdturjdi te sd`rhg tgd
h`aoj fer ` nofd adnt* Ygdrd w`s jejd*
Ygd Hgojdsd h`aoj aey. wge heuni spd`l Djbnosg. s`oi tgd sgop w`s
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 143/455
JOJBSE MEQD F@Q 098
` bujae`t sdjt ay Hg`jb Yse-noj te aema`ri tgd Reesujb ferts `ji
g`r`ss sgoppojb* Ygos. `ftdr gd g`i s`oi tgd bujs wdrd ` sobj`n te
n`y te `ji `jhger fer tgd jobgt* O teni gom tg`t stery adnejb je
beei%" `ji gd `imottdi gd w`s tryojb te prdvdjt eur adojb werrodi*
Ygd w`rsgop `pp`rdjtny b`vd ot up `s ` a`i kea `ftdr sox sgets `ji
hd`sdi forojb* Rgy tgdy ioij"t hg`sd us os stonn ` mystdry* Aut tgdy
turjdi tgdor are`isoid `w`y. te my v`st rdnodf. `ji ios`ppd`rdi ojte
tgd jobgt* @jetgdr vdrsoej ef tgd stery w`s tg`t tgdy wdrd aema`ri-
ojb tgd Reesujb ferts* Aut wd wdrd jet ydt jd`r Reesujb. `ji
adsoids tgd ferts ioi jet rdpny*
O foj`nny wdjt a`hl te snddp te ird`m ef a`ttnds ujton i`wj. `ji
w`s bn`i te bdt ` rohlsg`w `t sox-tgorty `s wd h`md `nejbsoid tgd
Auji oj Xg`jbg`o ejhd merd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 144/455
03 @ JDR ID@N FEQ HGOJ@
BDJDQ@NOXXOME
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl g`i erb`jozdi tgd J`-
toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb ndss tg`j ` mejtg `ftdr tg`t
hoty w`s h`pturdi ay tgd rdvenutoej`ry ferhds frem tgd Xeutg*
Ygd i`td w`s @pron 07. 0?12*
Ojhoidjt`nny. oj tgd M`ji`roj io`ndht tgd weri er weris. J`j-
Lojb%" md`j. Xeutgdrj H`pot`n*+" Ygd forst hg`r`htdr. J`j. md`js
Xeutgdrj< `ji Lojb. 'Hgojb. er Kojb. `s ot os prejeujhdi ay tgd
Hgojdsd/ md`js H`pot`n* Yg`t os wgy tgd j`md Sdlojb w`s `ntdrdi
te Sdopojb fer'o
Sd-Lojb md`jt Jertgdrj H`pot`n Ygd jdwny
djrohgdi mdj ef tgd Luemojt`jb hnujb te tgd tgdery tg`t tgdrd heuni
ad je jertgdrj h`pot`n* Ygdrd jddi ad aut ejd. tgdy gdni. `ji tg`t
sgeuni ad J`jlojb* Gdjhd. tgdy ossudi ` idhrdd oj 0?17. `ji tgd
hoty tg`t g`i addj ljewj `s Sdlojb fer `bds adh`md ljewj oj ` sur-
prosojbny sgert tomd `s Sdopojb. er Jertgdrj Sd`hd.
Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl spnot wotg gos eni hemr`ids oj hej-
tren `t G`jlew tg`t turaundjt sprojb ef 0?12. `ji gos mdj h`pturdi
Xg`jbg`o `ji tgdj J`jlojb. `s idshroadi* Hgo`jb iosnoldi tgd Hem-
mujost ojfnudjhd oj G`jlew* Ot w`s brewojb oj brd`t stroids* Gd
w`jtdi te hgdhl tgos ojtdrfdrdjhd frem Meshew* Gd iostrustdi tgd
Qusso`j @ivoser`td. gd`idi ay Mol`n Aereioj* Ygd Qusso`j @ivo-
ser`td g`i werldi smeetgny `ji wotg r`rd prdhosoej tg`t h`jjet ad
qudstoejdi* Ot werldi fer tgd mest p`rt ujidr hevdr* Aereioj r`rdny
`ppd`rdi oj puanoh er m`id ` spddhg* Gd s`w te ot tg`t ot w`s `
purdnyHgojdsd
mevdmdjt.ej tgd surf`hd gd `ji gos mdj aerdi
frem wotgoj. `ji wdnn*
Hgo`jb g`i rd`nozdi wg`t w`s ehhurrojb* Gd s`w tgd Hgojdsd
nesojb hejtren ef `nn tgdor pn`js `t gemd te ` jdw `ji ojsoioeus ferdobj
a`ra`ro`j aneh* Hgo`jb djvosoejdi tgdm usojb tgd Luemojt`jb
mdrdny `s ` teen wotg wgohg te b`oj dvdjtu`n m`stdry ef @so`. oj tgd
Qusso`j hejhdptoej ef tgdor be`n tgd werni rdvenutoej* Frem tgd
099
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 145/455
FEQ HGOJ@ 094
st`rt. tgd Bdjdr`n g`i `ivosdi `b`ojst tgd `hhdpt`jhd ef `oi frem
Meshew* Gd w`s evdrrundi* Aut Xuj _`t-sdj. F`tgdr ef tgd Que-
mojt`jb. wgem monnoejs oj Hgoj`tei`y
rdvdrd. g`i iodi oj
Sdlojboj 0?16*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb. tgd jdw Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf ef tgd Luemojhguj
'Ygd Sdepnds+ @rmy/ `s wdnn `s tgd Luemojt`jb 'Ygd Sdepnds"
S`rty/. w`s frdd te eady gos ewj ioht`tds* Gd hgesd te spnot wotg
G`jlew wgdj tgd mdj tgdrd rdfusdi te fennew gos hemm`jis*
Gd struhl swoftny* Ejhd oj hejtren ef Xg`jbg`o `ji J`jlojb.
Hgo`jb seubgt ` jdw id`n fer tgd wdnf`rd ef`nn
Hgojdsd* Gd seubgtot `ftdr tgd ioht`tds ef gos ewj idsords. jet tgesd ef tgd Qusso`j @ivos-
er`td* Ygd Bdjdr`n w`s frdd* Gd heuni ie beei oj gos ewj m`jjdr.
`ji jejd heuni s`y gom j`y*
Ygd Bdjdr`n. wgdj gd seubgt ` jdw id`n fer tgd Hgojdsd pde-
pnds. forst sdt up gos J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb* Gd w`s id-
jeujhdi `s ` jde-monot`rost ay tgd venuand Dubdjd Hgdj `t G`jlew*
Ygd ojf`jt bevdrjmdjt g`i ots hrotohs. Hgojdsd `s wdnn `s ferdobj. fremtgd st`rt* Ots p`tg w`s ` rehly re`i tew`ri ujoty `ji ` merd `auj-
i`jt nofd fer tgd iewjtreiidj mdj. wemdj `ji hgonirdj ojg`aotojb `nn
Hgoj`*
Hgo`jb w`s ejd ef tgd r`rd mdj oj Hgoj` wge adnodvdi tg`t ot
w`s tomd te ndt tgd Hgojdsd oj ej tgd adttdr tgojbs ef tgos dxostdjhd*
Gd w`s. `ji rdm`ojs. ` m`j wge g`s tgd oid` tg`t tgd v`roeus trd`tods
wgohg ferdobj j`toejs sobjdi wotg tgd jew idfujht Ir`bej Ygrejd oj
tgd i`ys ef tgd M`jhgu Iyj`sty `t Sdlojb sgeuni ad rdvosdi. of jet
shr`ppdi* Gos sneb`j os stonn; Iewj wotg tgd ujdqu`n trd`tods!
Fer ejd tgojb. tgd Bdjdr`n fdnt tg`t Hgoj` sgeuni ad `nnewdi te ruj
gdr ewj Hustems @imojostr`toej ojstd`i ef g`vojb ` ferdobjdr 'usu-
`nny Arotosg/ `t tgd gd`i ef ot* Ejd rdsunt w`s tg`t tgd eni fovd pdr
hdjt `i v`nerdm t`roff ej dvdrytgojb ompertdi ojte `jy trd`ty pert oj
Hgoj` w`sshr`ppdi*
Ygd jdw J`toej`nBevdrjmdjt. jd`rny
tweyd`rs
`ftdr ots ojhdptoej. sdt up ots ewj forst Y`roff Xhgdiund ej Fdaru`ry 0.
0?1?* Xemd ferdobj tr`idrs `ji etgdrs eakdhtdi. aut tgd t`roff
rdm`ojdi*
Ygd `aenotoej ef dxtr`-tdrrotero`noty w`s `jetgdr be`n tew`ri wgohg
tgd mdj `t J`jlojb wdrd werlojb* Ot md`js tgd dji ef hejsun`r
heurts fer tgd tro`n ef ferdobjdrs 'ojhnuiojb @mdroh`js/ oj Hgoj`. `ji
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 146/455
096 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgd dji ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Fdidr`n Heurt fer Hgoj`. wotg gd`i-
qu`rtdrs oj Xg`jbg`o*
@ M`jofdste te tgd Sdepnd w`s ossudi sgertny `ftdr tgos Hgojdsd
oid` ef ` jdw id`n w`s put ojte dffdht wotg tgd feuji`toej ef tgd
J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb* Ygos gosteroh m`jofdste w`s m`id
`v`on`and te md oj Hgoj` `t tgd tomd ot w`s ossudi* O prdsdjt tgos
storrojb `ji vot`n iehumdjt gdrd fer ots v`nud `s ` m`ttdr ef rdheri `ji
ojferm`toej `ji fer ots ojtdrdst `s Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb"s hejhdptoej oj
tgesd ujsdttndi i`ys ef tgd mdtgeis fer `tt`ojojb pr`htoh`n wdnf`rd
feo `nn* Gos tdxt;
M@JOFDXYE YE YGD SDESND
0* Ygd J`toej`nost rdvenutoej `b`ojst tgd ompdro`nosts `ji mono-
t`rosts*
1* Ygd pepun`roty ef tgd Hgojdsd J`toej`nost @rmy*
8* Ygd hromds ef tgd Hgojdsd Hemmujosts*
9* Ygd tgrdd peojts ef fuji`mdjt`n ioffdrdjhd adtwddj tgd Lue-
mojt`jb `ji tgd Hemmujost S`rty*
4* Ygd mosnd`iojb tdrm. Jdw Monot`rost*
6* Hgoj`"s tgrdd p`tgs;
`* Monot`ry rund*
a* Hemmujost rdbomd*
` Ygd p`rty bevdrjmdjt ef tgd Luemojt`jb*
Ygd purpesd ef tgd Luemojt`jb. sojhd ot os feujidi ej tgd
X`j-moj projhopnds. os te premetd tgd wdnf`rd ef tgd Hgojdsd
pdepnd. te frdd tgd djtord r`hd `ji te strovd fer tgd dqu`noty ef
`nn tgd j`toejs ef tgd werni*
Ots t`sl. tgdrdferd. os te evdrtgrew monot`rosm `ji ompdro`n-
osm. te dnomoj`td `nn wohldi `ji voendjt ferhds aetg wotgoj `ji
wotgeut tgd heujtry `ji te eat`oj Hgoj`"s ojidpdjidjhd. noadrty
`ji dqu`noty* Ygos os `nse ` p`rt ef tgd t`sl ef tgd werni rdve-
nutoej*
Fer m`jy yd`rs eur heujtry g`s addj epprdssdi hejtojueusny
ay ompdro`nosm wgohg g`s ojv`idi eur tdrrotery. ojfrojbdi upejeur sevdrdobjty. djhre`hgdi upej eur m`rotomd hustems. hej-
trenndi eur penotoh`n `ji dhejemoh nofd `ji dvdj lonndi eur yeutgs
'upej suhg `j ehh`soej. fer ojst`jhd. `s tgd m`ss`hrd ef M`y83. 0?14*/ Ompdro`nosm g`s `nse ompesdi ujdqu`n trd`tods upej
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 147/455
@` J D w ID@N"+ FEQ HGOJ@ 092
us `ji trd`tdi us `s ` sdmo-henejo`n pessdssoej* Heuni Hgoj`
stonn ad rdb`ridi `s `j ojidpdjidjt `ji frdd st`td5
Oj `iiotoej te tgos tgd ferdobj ompdro`nostoh
pewdrs
utonozd tgd
objer`jhd `ji tgd rutgndssjdss ef tgd Hgojdsd monot`rosts oj eridr
te rund Hgoj`. `ji tgdy `nnew tgd n`ttdr"s `jom`n ojstojhts te
idvdnep te suhg ` idbrdd tg`t tgdy h`jjet ad hgdhldi* @t forst
tgdsd monot`rosts w`bdi w`r dvdry fdw yd`rs fer sdnfosg djis.
tgdj tgdy w`bdi w`r ejhd ` yd`r. `ji tgdj sdvdr`n w`rs dvdry
yd`r fer m`jy yd`rs. tgdrday ard`lojb up seho`n erb`joz`toejs
`ji ojhrd`sojb tgd suffdrojbs ef tgd pdepnd* Rotg tgd j`toej`n
`ff`ors djtrustdi te tgd g`jis ef tgdsd ojhempdtdjt. objer`jt `ji
ojgum`j hrd`turds. h`j eur pdepnd g`vd `jy gepd ef dxostdjhd5
Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj. tgd nd`idr ef tgd Luemojt`jb. w`s tgd
feujidr ef tgd Qdpuanoh ef Hgoj`* @htu`tdi ay ` idsord te s`vd
Hgoj` frem tgd pdron ef dxtojhtoej `ji te bovd tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd
` merd s`tosf`htery nofd. gd feujidi tgd X`j-mnj projhopnds. wgohg
`rd; j`toej`nosm. idmehr`hy `ji seho`noz`toej ef dhejemoh erb`jo-
z`toej* Tjfertuj`tdny. gewdvdr. `ftdr ferty yd`rs ef gdreoh
dffert. gd iodi fer tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd `ji djtrustdi. oj gos wonn.
tgd ney`n mdmadrs ef tgd Luemojt`jb `ji tgd trud adnodvdrs ef
tgd Xhm-wooj projhopnds. wotg tgd t`sl ef tgd hejtoju`toej. te-
bdtgdr wotg tgd m`ssds ef tgd pdepnd. ef gos uj`hhempnosgdi werl
ef j`toej`nost rdvenutoej* Xojhd O teel tgd e`tg te hemm`ji tgd
jertgdrj dxpdiotoej`ry `rmy. O g`vd `nw`ys ldpt Ir* Xuj"s
oid`ns `s my buoid oj tgd strubbnd wotg tgd jertgdrj monot`rosts*
Xojhd ot `oms fer tgd wdnf`rd ef tgd heujtry. tgd j`toej`nost
rdvenutoej`ry `rmy os jet mdrdny fer tgd pdepnd. ot os `nse ef tgd
pdepnd* Qdnyojb upej puanoh suppert. eur `rmy g`s suhhddidi
`t dvdry st`bd< `t forst ehhupyojb Guj`j `ji Gupdg `ji evdr-
tgrewojb tgd rd`htoej`ry monot`rost. Ru Sdo-fu< tgdj sdozojb
Lo`jbso. Fulodj. Hgdlo`jb. `ji @jgwdo. tgdrday dnomoj`tojb tgd
hujjojb monot`rost. Xuj Hgu`jb-f`jb. `ji tgdj h`pturojb Xg`jbg`o
`ji J`jlojb. irovojb `w`y tgd arut`n monot`rost. Hg`jb Hgujb-
hg`jb*
Xojhd Xzdhgw`j. Lwdohgew. _ujj`j. Xgdjso. `ji L`jsu `rd
jew ujidr tgd bneroeus fn`b ef tgd rdvenutoej`ry `rmy. tgd pewdr
ef tgd hrudn jertgdrj monot`rosts g`s se f`r idhrd`sdi tg`t furtgdr
strejb rdsost`jhd sddms ompessoand* Rgdrdvdr eur seniodrs g`vd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 148/455
097 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
bejd tgdy g`vd mdt wotg tgd heepdr`toej ef tgd pdepnd* Ygd
seniodrs jet ejny h`usd je treuand `mejb tgd pdepnd aut `nse
hejsoidr tgdm `s ardtgrdj< wgond tgd pdepnd wgend-gd`rtdiny `ji
venujt`rony wdnhemd tgd seniodrs wotg feei `ji lojijdss* Ygos
sgews tgd pepun`roty ef tgd Luemojt`jb seniodrs `mejb tgd
pdepnd*
Ygd Hgojdsd Hemmujosts. g`vojb sdhurdi mdmadrsgop oj tgd
Luemojt`jb wotg m`nohoeus ojtdjt. m`sldi ay eur p`rty `ji
wotg tgd pretdhtoej ef eur `rmy. ujdxpdhtdiny dxtdjidi tgdor
ojfnudjhd dvdrywgdrd `ji hrd`tdi ` rdobj ef tdrrer tgreubg tgd
`bdjhy ef tgdor sdhrdt `ji trd`hgdreus pnets*
Ygdy ljdw tg`t tgd Luemojt`jb g`i ots ewj systdm`toh `ji
hejhrdtd prebr`m fer j`toej`n `ji penotoh`n rdhejstruhtoej. se
tgdy purpesdny utonozdi jeteroeus penotoho`js. ruffo`js. roetdrs
`ji rdhlndss yeutgs `ji `ausdi bevdrjmdjt pewdr oj eridr te
prdvdjt tgd prebr`m ef tgd Luemojt`jb frem adojb h`rrodi eut*
Ygdy ljdw tg`t tgd Luemojt`jb supperts tgd pd`s`jts" `ji
n`aerdrs" mevdmdjt `ji p`ys ` brd`t id`n ef `ttdjtoej te tgdor
seho`n `ji dhejemoh hejiotoej `ji ydt tgd Hemmujosts dmpneydi
tgdsd trd`hgdreus pdrsejs mdjtoejdi `aevd te g`r`ss `ji epprdss
tgd rd`n pd`s`jts `ji n`aerdrs*
Ej tgd ejd g`ji tgdy dxhnuidi tgd mdmadrs ef tgd Lue-
mojt`jb frem p`rtohop`toej oj tgd pd`s`jts" `ji n`aerdrs" mevd-
mdjts. `ji ej tgd etgdr tgdy ruojdi tgd pepun`roty ef tgd Lue-
mojt`jb `mejb tgd teonojb m`ssds. se tg`t tgd wdnf`rd ef tgd
pd`s`jts `ji n`aerdrs g`s addj hempndtdny jdbndhtdi `ji tgdor
suffdrojbs g`vd ojhrd`sdi brd`tny i`y ay i`y*
Oj tgos w`y `rd tgd t`htohs ef tgd Hgojdsd Hemmujosts werl-
ojb tew`ris tgd idstruhtoej `ji hempndtd a`jlrupthy ef tgd
Hgojdsd seho`n `ji dhejemoh st`td*
Rotg rdb`ri te diuh`toej. tgd `iv`jhdmdjt `ji `hquosotoej ef
ljewndibd `rd gojir`jhds te tgd m`jopun`toej ef tgd m`ssds* Oj
Gupdg. tgdrdferd. tgdy `ieptdi tgd sneb`js; Ye be te shgeen
os jet rdvenutoej`ry `ji tgdrdferd ot osheujtdr-rdvenutoej`ry*
Tjidr tgdor rund oj Guj`j `ji Gupdg diuh`toej ospr`htoh`nny
jdbndhtdi*
Rotg rdb`ri te ferdobj penohy. tgdy g`vd rdkdhtdi tgd penohy
ef tgd Luemojt`jb. wgohg os te id`n wotg ` sojbnd pewdr forst.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 149/455
@ JDR ID@N"+ FEQ HGOJ@ 09?
`ji tgdy g`vd ferhdi tgd ompdro`nostoh pewdrs ojte ` strejb `ji
ujotdi frejt se tg`t Hgoj` mobgt f`hd djdmods dvdrywgdrd `ji
ad ferhdi. oj hejsdqudjhd. te hemd ujidr tgd brop ef ` spdho`n
ferdobj erb`joz`toej*
Rotg rdb`ri te p`rty `ff`ors. tgdy ljdw tg`t wd g`vd m`oj-
t`ojdi tgd penohy ef S`rty bevdrjmdjt `s Hgoj`"s ejny gepd ef
s`nv`toej. `ji se tgdy g`vd sjd`ldi ojte tgd Luemojt`jb oj
eridr te upsdt eur systdm `ji. ay usojb tr`oters. te `nodj`td eur
hemr`ids* Ej tgd ejd g`ji tgdy iemoj`tdi tgd hdjtr`n erb`jo-
z`toej%" `ji ej tgd etgdr tgdy hejtrenndi tgd newdr ar`jhgds ef
tgd p`rty `ji dxhnuidi tgd rd`n `ji ney`n mdmadrs ef tgd Lue-
mojt`jb frem p`rty `ff`ors* Ygus g`vd tgdy trodi te m`ld tgd
p`rty Luemojt`jb oj j`md aut Hemmujost oj f`ht*
Oj monot`ry `ff`ors. tgdy s`w tgd r`poi `iv`jhd m`id ay eur
`rmy `ji fd`rdi `j d`rny suhhdss fer tgd j`toej`nost rdvenutoej
wgohg weuni `nnew je tomd fer tgd Hemmujost prep`b`ji` werl
wgdj tgd prebr`m ef rdhejstruhtoej hemmdjhdi. `ji se tgdy
`nodj`tdi eur `rmy hemr`ids. ojtdrruptdi monot`ry mevdmdjts.
gdni up prevosoejs `ji `mmujotoej `ji ioi dvdry etgdr dma`r-
r`ssojb tgojb oj tgdor pewdr*
Ygdsd hejiotoejs g`vd `nn addj idt`ondi oj my Idhn`r`toej te
tgd Luemojt`jb Mdmadrs%" wgohg `nn pdrsejs m`y rd`i*
Oj sgert. tgdy g`vd idhdotfunny `ssumdi eur j`md oj eridr te
hemmot dvdry pessoand hromd `ji tgdy. adojb tgd teens ef ` spd-
ho`n ferdobj erb`joz`toej. g`vd m`id usd ef meas `ji ruffo`js
`ji g`vd put ojte pr`htohd tgdor gerroand penotohs* Yg`t os tgd
rd`sej wgy tgdrd os tgd hry `nn `nejb tgd _`jbtzd V`nndy. Iewj
wotg tgd S`rty mdj!
O idsord tg`t eur pdepnd g`vd ` hnd`r hejhdptoej ef tgd
S`rty mdj* O h`jjet s`y tg`t ef eur monnoej Luemojt`jb
hemr`ids dvdry ejd os pdrfdht. aut tgd trud ejds fennew eur p`rty
projhopnds `ji h`jjet pdrmot tgdmsdnvds te ad mosndi ay tgd
idhdotfun Hemmujost S`rty* Ygesd wge ie jet hejferm te tgd
X`j-moj projhopnds. dvdj tgeubg tgdy geni mdmadrsgop oj tgd
Luemojt`jb. `rd p`rty tr`oters `ji wonn ad pujosgdi sdvdrdny*
O gepd tg`t tgd pdepnd wonn jet rdhebjozd oj tgdm tgd rd`n Lue-
mojt`jb mdmadrs*
Rotg rdb`ri te tgd prdsdjt rdvenutoej`ry mevdmdjt. tgd Lue-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 150/455
043 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
mojt`jb ioffdrs fuji`mdjt`nny frem tgd Hemmujost S`rty oj tgd
tgrdd fennewojb eutst`jiojb peojts;
Oj tgd forst pn`hd. wd `om `t tgd frddiem ef tgd djtord Hgojdsd
pdepnd. gdjhd wd rdquord tgd heepdr`toej ef `nn hn`ssds* Ygd
ioht`tersgop ef ejd hn`ss weuni nd`vd tgd etgdr hn`ssds ujdm`j-
hop`tdi `ji hrd`td `jetgdr tyr`jjoh`n `ji gobg-g`jidi rund* Eur
sojhdrd idsord os te g`vd ` br`ji ujoej ef f`rmdrs. n`aerdrs. mdr-
hg`jts. stuidjts `ji seniodrs* Rd formny adnodvd tg`t Hgoj` ieds
jet jddi tgd ioht`tersgop ef tgd prendt`ro`t*Furtgdrmerd wd
adnodvd tg`t of tgd ioht`tersgop ef tgd prendt`ro`t wdrd pr`htosdi
oj Hgoj` ot weuni jet ad ` trud ejd aut weuni ad ` mea rund*
Adsoids. wd st`rtdi tgd rdvenutoej fer tgd pdepnd `s ` wgend.
wgdrd`s tgd Hemmujosts ie ot ejny fer tgd hrd`toej ef ` ioht`ter-
sgop ef tgd prendt`ro`t wotg tgd eakdht ef idstreyojb seho`n `ji
dhejemoh feuji`toejs wgends`nd*
Xdhejiny. wd rdhebjozd tg`t tgd pdepnd ef Hgoj` sgeuni g`vd
tgd robgt ef sdnf-idtdrmoj`toej fer wd ujidrst`ji tg`t ejny wd
eursdnvds ljew pdrfdhtny eur ewj ojtdrdsts `ji tgd w`ys `ji
md`js ef id`nojb wotg tgdm* Ygd supdr-bevdrjmdjt ef tgd
Ndb`toej Pu`rtdr oj Sdlojb sgeuni jet ad rdpn`hdi ay ` supdr-
bevdrjmdjt ef Aereioj oj G`jlew*
@ftdr eur ewj noadr`toej wd eubgt te gdnp noadr`td tgd etgdr
epprdssdi `ji wd`l r`hds. fer wd hgdrosg tgd gepd `ji bnery ef
fobgtojb tgd a`ttnd ef gum`joty* @s tgd rdvenutoej oj Hgoj` os
p`rt ef tgd werni mevdmdjt wd sgeuni g`stdj tgd hempndtoej
ef ot* Ygdj wd sgeuni. ojidpdjidjtny `ji venujt`rony. keojoj
tgd werni rdvenutoej `ji jet ad ir`bbdi ojte ot*
Foj`nny. wd must ndssdj tgd suffdrojbs ef eur pdepnd iurojb
tgd tr`jsotoej pdroei `ji. `s seej `s eur monot`ry suhhdss os hem-
pndtd. wd must st`rt tgd werl ef rdhejstruhtoej se tg`t sehodty
sg`nn g`vd `idqu`td f`honotods fer idvdnepmdjt* Aut tgd Hem-
mujosts try te idstrey dvdry seho`n eridr `ji usurp tgd penotoh`n
pewdr tgreubg mea voendjhd. jet heujtojb suhg ` hest `s
8?3.333.333 novds fer tgd purpesd ef hrd`tojb ` st`td ef 03.333.-
333 Hemmujosts te ad tgd teen ef ` spdho`n ferdobj erb`joz`toej
Ot os trud tg`t Ir* Xuj hejsdjtdi te `imot tgd Hemmujosts
ojte tgd Luemojt`jb `s ojiovoiu`ns. aut jet `s ` ujot* Xe.
spd`lojb ef ot `s tgd `nno`jhd ef tgd twe p`rtods os ` mosojtdr-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 151/455
@ JDR ID@N FEQ HGOJ@ 040
prdt`toej ef tgd f`hts ay tgd Hemmujosts* Oj gos hejsdjt. Ir*
Xuj g`i twe ojtdjtoejs< forst te prdvdjt tgdm frem pr`htosojb
tgd Hemmujost oid`ns oj Hgoj` `ji te hejvdrt tgdm ojtdnndhtu`nny
te ` adnodf oj tgd X`j-moj projhopnds. `ji sdheji. te `fferi tgdm
`j eppertujoty te p`rtohop`td oj tgd j`toej`nost rdvenutoej* Aut
tgos w`s jet iejd se tg`t tgdy mobgt usurp tgd p`rty pewdr `ji
ioht`td tgd p`rty penohy. iosrdb`riojb tgd X`j-woj projhopnds*
Ir* Xuj"s penohy ef heepdr`toej wotg Qusso` w`s m`id pes-
soand ejny ay tgd Xevodt"s dqu`n trd`tmdjt ef eur pdepnd* Ot
w`s jet te ojvotd Hemr`id Aereioj purpesdny te gojidr eur
rdvenutoej`ry prebrdss* Ygd idtdrmojojb f`hter ef wgdtgdr er
jet tgd penohy ef heepdr`toej wotg Xevodt Qusso` os te ad m`oj-
t`ojdi ieds jet nod wotg Hgoj`. aut tgd tdst os wgdtgdr er jet
Xevodt Qusso` h`j trd`t us `s dqu`ns* Of Xevodt Qusso` g`i jet
hg`jbdi gdr penohy wd heuni g`vd stonn heepdr`tdi wotg gdr* Oj
tgd werni ejny projhopnds ioht`td penohods. penohods jdvdr ioht`td
projhopnds*
Ygd ojsoioeus ojtrobuds ef tgd Hemmujost S`rty. wgdrday
tgdy try te idstrey tgd rdvenutoej`ry `rmy. tgd Luemojt`jb `ji
tgd j`toej. g`vd addj dxpesdi* @t tgd vdry eutsdt tgdy fr`uiu-
ndjtny pn`hdi tgdor mdmadrs oj dvdry herjdr ef eur p`rty `ji
tgdj bet hejtren ef tgd se-h`nndi Rug`j hdjtr`n dxdhutovd hem-
mottdd. wgohg dj`andi tgdm te idhdovd `ji tgrd`tdj eur Lue-
mojt`jb hemr`ids `ji tgd puanoh* Eur Hdjtr`n Luemojt`jb
hdjser hemmottdd heuni jet djiurd tgdor iemoj`toej `ji
tyr`jjy. wgohg w`s nd`iojb tew`ri tgd dji ef eur p`rty. `ji
rdsenutdny dxpesdi tgd onndb`n `ji tr`otereus `htoejs ef tgd se-
h`nndi Rug`j hdjtr`n dxdhutovd hemmottdd. `ji `t tgd s`md
tomd urbdi eur J`toej`nost Bevdrjmdjt hemmottddmdj te `ssumd
effohd `t J`jlojb `ji wotg J`jlojb `s tgd h`pot`n*
Gosteroh`nny. J`jlojb w`s tgd h`pot`n* Ot g`i f`nndj ejhd
`ji w`s n`tdr rddst`anosgdi `s suhg ay tgd strubbnd ef eur pdepnd
fer ojidpdjidjhd `ji noadrty*
Ygesd wge `rd `t tgd gdnm aetg ef tgd S`rty `ji ef tgd
Xt`td `rd mestny mdj ef dxpdrodjhd `ji ef tgd gobgdst vortud.
wge `iveh`tdi tgd rdvenutoej fer yd`rs `ji g`vd addj rdspdhtdi
`s ojtdnndhtu`n poejddrs ay tgd wgend heujtry*
@s tgd p`rty pewdr g`s jew addj rdsterdi O sg`nn nd`i f`otg-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 152/455
041 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
funny `nn eur rdvenutoej`ry `rmods jertgw`ri* O t`ld tgd e`tg te
suppert tgd Luemojt`jb te tgd n`st `ji eady ots hemm`jis. te
`hhempnosg
tgd rdvenutoej`ry werl. te dnomoj`td tgd suffdrojbs
ef tgd pdepnd `ji te premetd tgd wdnf`rd ef tgd heujtry* O trust
tg`t `nn eur pdepnd. ujwonnojb te sdd Hgoj` adojb ruojdi ay tgd
monot`rosts er ay tgd Hemmujosts. wonn hemd `ji bovd us tgdor
uj`jomeus `ji funn suppert*
Ygd mevdmdjt te Xuppert tgd S`rty `ji te X`vd Hgoj`
os `t prdsdjt `t ots gdobgt wotgoj tgd Luemojt`jb. `ji tgos prevds
tgd rd`noty ef tgd Luemojt`jb `ji tgd strejb wonn ef ots mdmadrs*
Jew O h`nn upej tgd pdepnd te keoj us oj tgd strubbnd fer tgd
s`md h`usd wotgeut tgd snobgtdst gdsot`toej*
Ejhd merd O must ojferm tgd wgend j`toej tg`t. hejsoidrojb
tgd prdsdjt ojtdrj`toej`n sotu`toej `ji eur hg`jbojb ojtdrj`n
hejiotoejs. dvdry hn`ss oj Hgoj` must `w`ld ommdio`tdny `ji
erb`jozd tgereubgny fer pesotovd rd`ikustmdjts* Fer yd`rs. fer-
dobjdrs g`vd adnodvdi tg`t Hgojdsd. nold s`ji. n`hl tgd h`p`hoty
fer erb`joz`toej* Ye s`vd tgd j`toej os ` gobg `ji vot`n mossoej
`ji se wd must erb`jozd eursdnvds `htovdny `ji systdm`toh`nny*
_eu. pd`s`jts `ji n`aerdrs. must jet ad idhdovdi ay tgd
Hemmujosts. aut must erb`jozd yeursdnvds te `ssost oj tgd rdve-
nutoej`ry werl* Oj `hheri`jhd wotg Ir* Xuj"s prebr`m ef dhe-
jemoh survov`n yeu m`y pn`j fer yeur ewj pdrm`jdjt wdnf`rd*
_eu. mdrhg`jts. sgeuni ie tgd s`md wotg `nn yeur pewdr `ji
rdseurhds. fer yeu must jet ad se sgert-sobgtdi `s te rdb`ri tgd
prdsdjt `s of ot wdrd tgd p`st. tg`t yeu jddi jet aetgdr wotg tgd
hejiotoej ef tgd bevdrjmdjt `ji sehodty `ji tg`t yeu h`j ie
ausojdss adgoji hnesdi ieers `ji iosrdb`ri hejiotoejs* _eu
sgeuni jet tgojl tg`t tgd werldrs" g`risgops jddi jet ad yeur
hejhdrj* Of tgd hejiotoejs ef n`aer ad jet omprevdi. gew h`j
pd`hd ad nejb prdsdrvdi5 Snd`sd `ssost tgdm venujt`rony te adttdr
tgdor novojb hejiotoejs*
_eu. tgd se-h`nndi ojtdnndhtu`n hn`ss. sgeuni bovd up yeur
d`sy-hg`or nofd* Snd`sd buoid tgd tgeubgt ef yeutg `nejb tgd
prepdr nojds. premetd m`ss diuh`toej `ji `ppny yeur spdho`n
ljewndibd `ji tdhgjoh`n slonn oj tgd hejstruhtovd werl*
Oj eridr te bdt roi ef psyhgeneboh`n wd`ljdss. p`ssovdjdss `ji
terpoioty `nn must hemaojd tebdtgdr `ji werl fer tgd rdvenutoej*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 153/455
@ JDR ID@N FEQ HGOJ@ 048
Erb`joz`toej os yeur strdjbtg. werl os yeur s`nv`toej* Rotg
yeur sporot `ji djdrby tgd rdvenutoej oj Hgoj` wonn ad hrewjdi
wotg brd`t suhhdss*
Ygd Hgojdsd pdepnd sgeuni jet hejsoidr tgd spnot adtwddj tgd
Hemmujosts `ji tgd Luemojt`jb mdrdny `s ` preandm wotgoj tgd
p`rty* Ot os ` vot`n preandm wgohg hejhdrjs `nn ef us*
@ frodji ef mojd. sohldjdi wotg tgd trdji ef hurrdjt `ff`ors.
s`oi tg`t ot w`s stonn tee d`rny te st`rt tgd mevdmdjt ef eppesojb
tgd Hemmujost rdobj ef tdrrer< jet adh`usd tgd Hemmujost hromds
g`vd jet addj dxpesdi. aut adh`usd eur pdepnd `rd jet ydt funny
hejshoeus ef tgdor suffdrojbs* Os tg`t rd`nny se5 O adnodvd jet*
Oj Guj`j `ji Gupdg tgd Hemmujosts g`vd ejny kust adbuj tgd
epdr`toej ef tgdor penohy `ji ydt dvdry ejd fddns tg`t nofd os uj-
djiur`and* Oj G`jbhgew `ji Xg`jbg`o tgdy g`vd ejny kust
m`id ` st`rt `ji ydt `nn `rd oj tdrrer* Oj Lw`jtujb. Fulodj `ji
dnsdwgdrd. tgd pd`s`jts `ji n`aerdrs g`vd dxprdssdi tgdor brodv-
`jhds oj jumdreus ndttdrs `ji tdndbr`ms* Rd must jet w`ot
ujton tgd sweri os pn`hdi evdr eur jdhls adferd wd hry eut*
Adsoids. tgd prdsdjt ojtdrj`toej`n sotu`toej os jet suhg tg`t
ot h`j pdrmot Hgoj` te ad tgd dxpdromdjt`n fodni fer Hemmujosm
wotgeut tgd i`jbdr ef suffdrojb br`vd hejsdqudjhds* Etgdr
pdepnd ie jet h`rd wgdtgdr er jet tgd novds `ji wdnf`rd ef eur
pdepnd `rd `t st`ld. aut wd ie* My adnevdi fdnnew heujtrymdj.
jew os tgd tomd te w`ld up*
Xuppesd tg`t O sgeuni ndt yeu ad epprdssdi hejtojueusny ay
tgd monot`rosts. dxpneotdi ay tgd ompdro`nosts `ji iospesdi ef
ujidr tgd rdobj ef tdrrer ef tgd Hemmujosts. ot weuni md`j tg`t
O g`i idsdrtdi my s`hrdi iuty `s ` rdvenutoej`ry seniodr `ji
g`i adhemd tgd `rhg hromoj`n ef tgd `bd*
Of. gewdvdr. tgd Luemojt`jb hemr`ids `ji seniodrs s`hrofohd
tgdmsdnvds fer tgd j`toej`n h`usd `ji stonn yeu rdjidr us je `oi.
yeu jet ejny f`on te ioshg`rbd yeur iuty ef hotozdjsgop aut yeu`nse `ht `b`ojst yeur ewj hejshodjhd*
Ye bu`r`jtdd eur frdd `ji prepdr idvdnepmdjt. wd g`vd eur
`rmy. te nd`i yeu te erb`jozd `ji te `ssurd yeu s`tosf`htery hej-
iotoejs fer d`rjojb ` novojb. wd g`vd eur p`rty ef X`j-moj proj-
hopnds. `ji wotg rdb`ri te yeur untom`td `w`ldjojb `ji d`rjdst
p`rtohop`toej oj tgd j`toej`n `ff`ors. tg`t os djtordny up te yeu*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 154/455
049 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygd Hemmujost S`rty g`s addj sprd`iojb `are`i `nn serts ef
rumers suhg `s epprdssoej ef tgd teonojbm`ssds ay Luemoj-
t`jb. `ji Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. tgd jdw monot`rost. Ygdsd `rd
iud te my eppesotoej te ots gerroand penohods*_eu must jet ad
idhdovdi `ji wd sgeuni ojvdstob`td tgd rumers oj idt`on* Ygd
tdmper`ry survdonn`jhd ef tgd Hemmujosts w`s eridrdi adh`usd
tgdy wdrd g`mpdrojb monot`ry epdr`toejs. tgos f`ht adojb dxpesdi
ay tgd Luemojt`jb hdjtr`n hdjser hemmottdd* Fer tgd s`fdty
ef eur seniodrs `ji ef tgd pdepnd ot w`s ompdr`tovd tg`t tgdor
`htovotods sgeuni ad semdwg`t rdstrohtdi iurojb tgd tomd ef w`r*
Ygos os ` monot`ry jdhdssoty* Rd idt`oj tgdm ejny ujton monot`ry
epdr`toejs `rd hempndtdi. aut wd g`vd je wosg te dji`jbdr tgdor
novds* Ygos b`vd rosd te tgd se-h`nndi S`rty Omprosejmdjt*
Rotg rdb`ri te rderb`jozojb tgd pd`s`jt `ji n`aer ujoejs hej-
trenndi ay tgd Hemmujosts. tgos os a`sdi ej tgd s`md oid`. `ji
`t tgd s`md tomd wd sgeuni bovd tgd rd`n pd`s`jts `ji n`aerdrs
tgd eppertujoty fer frdd erb`joz`toej*
Rd ios`rmdi tgd Xg`jbg`o N`aer Tjoej Herps adh`usd ot
`tt`hldi eur `rmy wotg rofnds `ji m`hgojd bujs* Ej @pron 08.
0?12. tgd N`aer Herps surreujidi `ji `tt`hldi tgd gd`iqu`rtdrs
ef tgd 1ji Iovosoej ef tgd 16tg @rmy aut tgdy wdrd rdpunsdi. `ji
`s ` rdsunt wd h`pturdi ?3 h`ptovds. ef wgohg 93 wdrd prevdi te
ad seniodrs ef Hg`jb Hgujb-hg`jb ujidr tgd eridrs ef tgd Hem-
mujost S`rty* Ygos prevds tg`t tgd Hemmujosts wonn ie `jy-
tgojb pessoand te ruoj tgd h`usd ef tgd rdvenutoej. dvdj tgeubg
tgdy hejspord wotg tgd jertgdrj monot`rosts*
Ot w`s frem iehumdjts ef `nn serts ioshevdrdi oj sd`rhgojb
tgd Xg`jbg`o N`aer Tjoej tg`t wd `shdrt`ojdi tgdor sdhrdt `ji
i`jbdreus pnets* Ygd t`nl ef epprdssoej ef tgd teonojb m`ssds ay
tgd Luemojt`jb os djtordny f`nsd* Of tg`t os trud ef us wd `rd
wonnojb te ad adgd`idi* Ot os ` f`ht tg`t tgd Luemojt`jb"s ep-
pesotoej te Hemmujosm os jet eppesotoej te pd`s`jts `ji n`aer-
drs* Jew os tgd adst eppertujoty fer tgd rd`nteonojb m`ssds te
`rosd `ji erb`jozd* Fer yeur ewj ojtdrdsts yeur erb`joz`toej
must jet ad jdbndhtdi* Of yeu ie jet erb`jozd yeursdnvds etgdrs
wonn ie ot ay `ssumojb f`nsdny yeur j`md* Frdd frem tgd Hem-
mujost S`rty"s mejepenozdi hejtren `nn ef yeu g`vd tgd epper-
tujoty ef m`lojb yeur ewj erb`joz`toejs* Rotgoj tgd kurosioh-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 155/455
@ JDR ID@N FEQ HGOJ@ 044
toej ef eur J`toej`nost Bevdrjmdjt tgd dmdrbdjhy md`surds
t`ldj `b`ojst tgd Hemmujost S`rty weuni ie yeu. tgd rd`n pd`-
s`jts `ji n`aerdrs. je g`rm*
@s te tgdor m`nohoeus hg`rbd `b`ojst md `s ` ""jdw monot`rost
ot os quotd roiohuneus* Os tgdrd ` monot`rost `jywgdrd oj tgd
werni wge fobgts fer projhopnds5 Rg`t tgd monot`rosts w`jt os
tdrrotero`n `hquosotoej* Rgdrdvdr eur `rmy g`s rd`hgdi. tgd
pdepnd g`vd g`i tgdor ewj sdnf-bevdrjmdjt* Rg`t tgd monot`rosts
idsord os wd`ntg* O g`vd feubgt idvetdiny fer yd`rs `ji ef my
pdrsej`n wd`ntg tgdrd os jetgojb s`vdi* Rg`t tgd monot`rosts
h`rd fer os tgdor ewj sloj `ji wg`t tgdy sp`rd os tgdor seniodrs"
novds* Frem tgd tomd wgdj O pdrsej`nny ujidrteel tgd jertgdrj
dxpdiotoej O ndi tgd `rmy `t tgd frejt `ji teel je tgeubgt ef
pdrsej`n i`jbdr*
Ygd Hgojdsd monot`rosts bdt tgdor m`tdro`n `ji foj`jho`n sup-
pert frem tgd ompdro`nostoh pewdrs. wgond O ie jet* Ygd idvetdi
fobgtojb ef eur mdj evdr tgeus`jis ef monds ef tdrrotery g`s addj
` s`hrofohd fer projhopnd. aut jet ` s`hrofohd fer md pdrsej`nny* Oj
suhg ` w`y g`vd O djheur`bdi my effohdrs `ji mdj< oj suhg
` w`y g`vd tgdy stomun`tdi md* Xe tgd idf`m`toej m`nobjs jet
ejny md aut `nse tgd 83.333 gdreoh id`i ef eur `rmy* Of O `m
buonty ef `jy moshejiuht O `m rd`iy te suamot mysdnf fer tro`n
`ji sdvdrd pujosgmdjt ay eur Luemojt`jb `ji ay eur pdepnd*
O nd`vd tgd kuibmdjt ef my hg`r`htdr te tgd futurd*
Ygd Luemojt`jb os ` rdspejsoand penotoh`n p`rty `ji wd h`j-
jet `nnew tgd Hemmujosts te wrdhl ot* Rd adnodvd sojhdrdny tg`t
Hgoj` eubgt te ad rundi ay S`rty Bevdrjmdjt* Ygd bevdrj-
mdjt`n systdm sgeuni jet ad suakdhtdi te suhg r`poi hg`jbds ef
penotoh`n tgeubgts* Oj eridr te `hgodvd ` beei rdsunt penotoh`nny
tgdrd must ad ` hn`ss ef wosd `ji uprobgt mdj wotg idfojotd `i-
mojostr`tovd `aonoty. wge wonn upgeni ` seuji `ji suot`and proj-
hopnd* Ygd rdprdsdjt`tovd ferm ef bevdrjmdjt g`s addj trodi oj
Hgoj` `ji g`s f`ondi adh`usd eur pdepnd n`hldi penotoh`n hej-
shoeusjdss. `ji tgdrd os je usd te try ot `b`oj*
Rd prepesd te rund Hgoj` tgreubg tgd S`rty `ji tgdj wd
sg`nn g`vd tgd systdm ef hgdhl `ji a`n`jhd oj tgd bevdrjmdjt ay
tgd S`rty `ji tgd pdepnd* Adojb suotdi te Hgojdsd hejiotoejs.
tgd X`j-moj projhopnds ef tgd p`rty hejstotutd tgd ejny hg`jjdn
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 156/455
046 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
ef j`toej`n s`nv`toej* Ygdy `rd ujot`ry `ji erb`joh `ji sgeuni
ad put ojte epdr`toej somunt`jdeusny* Ompertdi tgderods h`jjet
ad hemp`rdi wotg tgdm* Merdevdr. tgdy `rd f`ver`any `hhdptdi
ay tgd f`r-sobgtdi penotoh`n tgojldrs*
@t prdsdjt tgd Luemojt`jb os Hgoj`"s ejny penotoh`n S`rty*
Ot w`s erb`jozdi nejb adferd tgd aortg ef tgd Qdpuanoh ef Hgoj`.
Ot g`s 0.333.333 mdmadrs. `and. idtdrmojdi. `ji hemp`r`tovdny
wdnn tr`ojdi* Of g`s tgd gdreoh nd`idr. Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj. wge
ndi tgd pdepnd oj tgd J`toej`nost h`usd fer yd`rs*
Ye rund Hgoj` tgreubg tgd S`rty ieds jet md`j tg`t `nn
bevdrjmdjt`n `ff`ors must ad g`jindi ay tgd Luemojt`jb. aut
ejny tg`t tgdy must ad g`jindi oj `hheri`jhd wotg ots projhopnds.
penohods `jiioshopnojd*
Rd `rd jet nold tgd Hemmujosts wge
`rd sdnfosg `ji j`rrew-mojidi* Rd idsord te heepdr`td `nse
wotg tgesd wge `rd jet Luemojt`jb mdmadrs* Adsoids. Lue-
mojt`jbos `
puanoh penotoh`n S`rty.`imossoej ojte wgohg os `t
`nn tomds frdd* Ygesd wge t`ld ojtdrdst oj j`toej`n p`rty `ff`ors.
wotg tgd dxhdptoej ef tgd eppertujosts. wonn ad wdnhemdi dvdry-
wgdrd* Rotg tgd rdmev`n ef tgd Hemmujosts. tgd Luemojt`jb"s
trud f`hd os hnd`r te dvdryejd* Hemd `ji keoj us `ji ferm `
ujotdi a`ttnd frejt*
Ejny tgrdd p`tgs `rd jew epdj fer tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd* Ejd
os te rdturj te tgd rund ef monot`rosm `s tgd teen ef ferdobj om-
pdro`nostoh pewdrs `ji te fobgt yd`r `ftdr yd`r fer sdnfosg djis*
Ygd etgdr os te fennew tgd feetstdps ef tgd Hemmujosts ujidr
tgd iordhtoej ef ` spdho`n ferdobj erb`joz`toej wotg tgd eakdht ef
hrd`tojb ` rdobj ef Qdi tdrrer `ji wgends`nd idstruhtoej. wotg-
eut hejsoidr`toej ef horhumst`jhds*
@jetgdr w`y os te fennew tgd X`j-woj projhopnds wgdrday tgd
pdepnd noadr`td tgdmsdnvds tgreubg idnoadr`td prehdss efpenotohs.
sdnf-idtdrmoj`toej `ji sdnf-suppert* Of tgd pdepnd `rd jet wonnojb
te suakdht Hgoj` te monot`ry rund. `j ompdro`nostoh rdbomd er tgd
rdobj ef Qdi tdrrer. ndt tgdm jew keoj tgd Luemojt`jb oj
eridr te `hhempnosg tgd J`toej`nost Qdvenutoej. te dm`jhop`td tgd
Hgojdsd pdepnd `ji te p`rtohop`td oj tgd werni rdvenutoej*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 157/455
HGO@JB L@O-XGDL"X QDYTQJ
F YGD std`iy strd`m ef mdj wotg mossoejs urbojb Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl
0Zte rdturj te gos pesotoej `s Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodf ef tgd Luemoj-
t`jb strubbnd rdsuntdi oj gos rdturj te tgd rdvenutoej wotg dj-
g`jhdi prdstobd* Ygd eppesotoej f`idi `ji tgd Bdjdr`n rd`ssumdi
hempndtd hejtren `t J`jlojb oj tgd f`nn ef 0?12* Gd pusgdi gos pn`j
fer t`lojb tgd `jhodjt h`pot`n `t Sdlojb. `veoiojb treuand `s f`r `s
pessoand wotg K`p`j aut beojb ferw`ri tgreubg Xg`jtujb Srevojhd.
`s wdnn `s vo` tgd Loj-g`j
Q`onw`y
te tgd wdst*
Gd p`usdi d`rny tg`t wojtdr fer ` teuhg ef rem`jhd wgdj gd m`r-
rodi Moss Mdo-nojb Xeejb* Xgd w`s diuh`tdi oj ` rdnoboeus shgeen oj
tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds `ji os ` idvetdi mdmadr ef tgd eni Mdtgeiost
Dposhep`n Hgurhg 'Xeutg/* Xgd os ` sostdr ef Mmd* Xuj _`t-sdj `ji
ef Mmd* G* G* Lujb. wofd ef tgd Foj`jhd Mojostdr ef Hgoj`* Gdr
aretgdr os Y* V* Xeejb. ` G`rv`ri br`iu`td `ji gomsdnf nejb Foj`jhd
Mojostdr oj tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb oj d`rnodr yd`rs*
Ygos aneh ferms wg`t os ljewj oj Hgoj` `s tgd
Xeejb Iyj`sty.`j
ujusu`nny ojfnudjto`n f`mony breup oj tgd F`r D`st* Ygd m`rro`bd teel
pn`hd oj Xg`jbg`o ej Idhdmadr 0. 0?12*
Ygd Hgrosto`j hdrdmejy w`s gdni `t tgd Xeejb rdsoidjhd oj tgd
Frdjhg Hejhdssoej. aut oj idfdrdjhd te Hgojdsd hustem. ` j`tovd hdrd-
mejy teel pn`hd oj tgd erj`td a`nnreem ef tgd eni M`kdstoh Getdn*
Ygd Bdjdr`n gomsdnf g`s rdhdjtny dmar`hdi Hgrosto`joty tgreubg tgd
Mdtgeiost Dposhep`n Hgurhg `ji g`s nd`rjdi quotd ` aot ef tgd Djbnosg
n`jbu`bd* Ygd M`kdstoh Getdng`s
addjterj
iewj. aut tg`t m`rro`bdhdrdmejy os ejd wgohg O rdh`nn `s ` wdnhemd rem`jtoh ojtdrnuid oj
Hgoj`"s w`rs*
D`rny oj 0?17 Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb rdturjdi te gos tg`jlndss t`sl ef
nd`iojb Hgoj`* Gd ossudi ` sg`rp mdss`bd te tgd Ygori J`toej`n
Hejbrdss. pnd`iojb fer penotoh`n ujoty wotgoj tgd rdvenutoej* Gd dx-
prdssdi gos adnodf tg`t ` S`rty Ioht`tersgop os tgd adst ferm ef bevdrj-
042
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 158/455
047 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
mdjt fer tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds ujidr prdsdjt hejiotoejs `ji stdrjny
rdauldi yeujbdr. merd r`ioh`n mdmadrs ef tgd Sdepnd"s S`rty wge.
gd fd`rdi. mobgt h`usd ` jdw spnotoj tgd J`jlojb J`toej`n Bevdrj-
mdjt*
Eur Bevdrjmdjt os jet nold tgd penotoh`n erb`joz`toej ef `jy etgdr
heujtry oj tgd werni%" Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl"s mdss`bd s`oi* @ penotoh`n
idfd`t suffdrdi ay tgd Bevdrjmdjt ef `jy etgdr heujtry ieds jet md`j
`s muhg `s ot weuni te tgd Luemojt`jb ef Hgoj`* Of eur S`rty f`ondi
te h`rry eut ots prebr`m tgd wgend hejtojdjt weuni `b`oj ad pnujbdi
ojte ` st`td ef penotoh`n hg`es `ji ujhdrt`ojty* R`r mobgt `b`oj rd-
sunt* Ygos must jet ehhur* Ygd feuji`toejs ef ` jdw idvdnepmdjt.
penotoh`nny`ji dvdry etgdr w`y. g`vd addj n`oi* Ot tgdrdferd jew ad-
hemds tgd projhop`n eakdht ef tgd Ygori J`toej`n Hejbrdss te idvosd
md`js wgdrday tgd penotoh`n erb`joz`toej ef eur S`rty m`y ad pn`hdi
ej `j dvdj formdr feuji`toej*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb rdh`nndi tg`t fer twe yd`rs `ji merd tgd hgodf
t`sls adferd tgd Qdvenutoej`ry S`rty g`i addj tgd suhhdssfun hejhnu-
soej ef tgd dxpdiotoej `b`ojst tgd Jertg `ji tgd supprdssoej ef a`jio-
try `ji Hemmujostoh uprosojbs* Gd s`oi tg`t tgd forst ef tgdsd t`sls
g`i addj `hhempnosgdi `ji tg`t prebrdss w`s adojb m`id ej tgd sdh-
eji* Ygd Qdis wdrd dvohtdi oj Idhdmadr. 0?12. `ji wgond r`ioh`n
uprosojbs stonn hejtojudi tgdy wdrd jet `s ompert`jt `s oj tgd treuandi
p`st*
Ygd pdroei ef penotoh`n tutdn`bd jew g`s adbuj. tgd Bdjdr`n id-
hn`rdi. Rd g`vd erb`jozdi ` jdw J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt* Rd h`j-
jet turj A`hl jer h`j wd sdd eur n`aers be fer j`ubgt* Rd must
g`vd ujoty `ji tgd suppert ef tgd Luemojt`jb%"
@aeut tgd m`jofdst`toejs ay yeujbdr mdmadrs oj tgd S`rty ef
tgdor p`tdjt idsord te `ssumd nd`idrsgop. tgd Bdjdr`n adh`md h`ustoh*
Ygd yeujbdr mdmadrs%" gd s`oi. sgeuni ad s`tosfodi wotg `htovotods
ef ` suaerioj`td j`turd* Ygdy sgeuni w`ot ujton tgdy g`vd `hquordi
merd dxpdrodjhd `ji g`vd adhemd adttdr tr`ojdi oj S`rty `ff`ors* Ot
os idpner`and te gd`r tg`t sm`nn hnoquds g`vd addj fermdi wotgoj eur
S`rty* Xuhg pdrsej`n erb`joz`toejs `rd aut teens ef ndssdr nd`idrs
wge `rd ujiuny `maotoeus*
@ strejb tdjidjhy tew`ri meidr`toej oj rdb`ri te n`aer preandms
g`i nejb addj jetohd`and oj Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl"s `ttotuid te-
w`ri werldrs `ji f`jjdrs* Ygos `ttotuid w`s ejd ef tgd rd`sejs fer
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 159/455
HGO@JB L@O-XGDL"X QDYTQJ 04?
gos epdj ard`l wotg tgd Xevodt @ivoser`td ujidr Mol`n Aereioj* Oj
gos mdss`bd ej Bevdrjmdjt penohy Hgo`jb h`md eut oj eppesotoej te
hn`ss w`rf`rd. `ssdrtojb tg`t wgond tgd Bevdrjmdjt w`s idsoreus ef
`oiojb tgd f`rmdrs `ji werldrs ot weuni jet `nnew tgdor uprosojbs
`b`ojst dmpneydrs*
Ygd `om ef tgd Luemojt`jb. gos mdss`bd dxpn`ojdi. os te oj-
hrd`sd tgd m`tdro`n hemfert `ji prespdroty ef tgd pd`s`jts `ji
werldrs ef eur heujtry* Jet ejny must wd pretdht tgdor ojtdrdsts aut
wd must `nse iordht `ji buoid tgdm oj tgdor `htovotods se tg`t tgdy m`y
jet f`nn vohtoms te tgd sojostdr shgdmds ef tgd Hemmujosts* Rd wosg
tgdor `iv`jhdmdjt te ad ef ` pdrm`jdjt j`turd< `ji fer tgos vdry
rd`sej wd dxdrhosd fer tgd memdjt tgdor penotoh`n pewdr fer tgdm*
Ygd Luemojt`jb"s penohy.oj tgdery `t nd`st. os tg`t tgd prdsdjt
pdroei ef wg`t os tdrmdi penotoh`n tutdn`bd os te dji wgdj tgd pdepnd
ef Hgoj` g`vd addj diuh`tdi up te tgd provondbds `ji iutods ef hotozdj-
sgop oj ` idmehr`hy* Oj tgd md`jtomd. '`ji ferdvdr. tgd sg`rp-
tejbudi hrotohs ef tgd S`rty ioht`tersgop `vdr/. tgd Luemojt`jb
nd`idrs ojtdji te lddp hejtren ef tgd heujtry `s nejb `s tgdy pessoany
h`j* Hgo`jb rdfdrrdi te tgd f`ht tg`t d`rnodr oj tgd rdvenutoej tgd
Luemojt`jb djheur`bdi tgd werldrs `ji pd`s`jts oj tgdor eppesotoej
`b`ojst tgd epprdssoej ef tgdor dmpneydrs `ji n`jineris*
Aut. gd hejtojudi. tomds g`vd hg`jbdi* @ntgeubg wd g`vd id-
hn`rdi `b`ojst epprdssoej ef werldrs `ji pd`s`jts. wd must `t tgd
s`md tomd sdd te ot tg`t tgd werldrs `ji pd`s`jts tgdmsdnvds ie jet
adhemd tgd epprdssers tg`t tgdy ie jet t`ld `iv`jt`bd ef tgdor dm-
pneydrs `ji n`jineris `s tgdy `rd ojhnojdi te ie `t prdsdjt* Ot must
ad m`id hnd`r te tgd n`aerdrs `ji f`rmdrs tg`t `jy ness sust`ojdi ay
tgdor dmpneydrs `ji n`jineris md`js ness te tgdmsdnvds* Ygd Bevdrj-
mdjt h`jjet ioshromoj`td `b`ojst ejd hn`ss oj f`ver ef `jy etgdr hn`ss.
er hn`ssds*
Ygd Hemmujosts prd`hg hn`ss w`rf`rd* Rd ie jet*
Fdjb _u-gso`jb. tgd Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n. fdnt etgdrwosd* Gd w`stgd hg`mpoej ef @so`"s ferbettdj m`j. `ji rdm`ojdi hejvojhdi tg`t
bevdrjmdjt `jy bevdrjmdjt fer tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds sgeuni a`sd
ots tgdsos ef pr`htoh`n penotoh`n dhejemy ej ommdio`td `oi fer tgd
f`rmdr `ji heenod. er n`aerdr. hn`ssds oj sehodty*
Gos net oj n`ttdr yd`rs g`s addj tgd s`i ejd ef ` m`j prefdssojb
sdjtomdjts `htu`tdi pessoany ay sojhdrd metovds aut tgw`rtdi ej dvdry
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 160/455
063 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
g`ji ay hejiotoejs adyeji gos hejtren* Fdjb rdm`ojs tgd vohtom ef `
h`prohoeus f`td. ` ird`mdr uj`and te put gos vosoejs fer tgd wdnf`rd ef
gum`joty ojte pr`htohd* Ejd rdsunt g`s addj tgd idvdnepmdjt oj gom
ef ` hr`fty j`turd wgohg gd usds `s ` sert ef idfdjsd mdhg`josm
`b`ojst tgd idfd`t ef gos `oms. oid`ns `ji `maotoejs fer `j dm`jhop`tdi
Hgoj`<wotgeut tgos. gd fd`rs eanovoej `s ` nd`idr. f`onurd oj gos mossoej
te sprd`i nobgt evdr @so`* Gdjhd gos mdtgeis g`vd adhemd ojdx-
pnoh`and. oj n`rbd md`surd*
Fdw rd`nny ljew tgd m`j wge os Fdjb* Gos hrotohs `rd ndboej `ji
gos idvoeus `htoejs rdm`oj eashurd* Gd dmar`hds wg`tdvdr hemds te
g`ji. prevoidi ot wonn `oi gom tew`ri gos be`n tgd adttdrmdjt ef `nn
Hgojdsd pdepnds* Fdjb tgus os ljewj pepun`rny `s ` tr`oter. ` ieuand-
hressdr. adh`usd. te gom. tgd dji fer se nejb g`s g`i tekustofy
tgd
md`js*
@ntgeubg pdrsej`nny `asdjt frem tgd Ygori J`toej`n Hejbrdss
h`nndi ay Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl oj J`jlojb oj M`rhg. 0?17. M`r-
sg`n Fdjb ojstruhtdi gos idndb`tds te suppert tgd J`toej`n Bevdrj-
mdjt"s penohods dj aneh. oj Hgo`jb"s str`tdby fer tgd r`poi `ji suhhdss-
fun m`rhg ej Sdlojb* Xemd mejtgs n`tdr `ftdr Sdlojb w`s t`ldj `ji
tgd j`md hg`jbdi te Sdopojb. Fdjb teel up tdmper`ry rdsoidjhd `t
J`jlojb. tgd jdw H`pot`n* Gd w`s Mojostdr ef R`r fer ` tomd. `ji
O w`jtdi `jetgdr ojtdrvodw wotg tgos `stutd penotohe-monot`ry m`j
Eur sdheji mddtojb w`s `t J`jlojb. wgdrd gd teni ef gos pgonesepgy
ef gew mdj `ji wemdj `ji tgdor hgonirdj mobgt foji ` ndss g`rsg
dxostdjhd oj tgd Erodjt tg`j tgd ejd tgdy g`i*
M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb s`oi tg`t gd prdfdrrdi jet te t`nlpenotohs*
Gd w`s. gewdvdr. quotd rd`iy te t`nl `aeut wg`t gd tgeubgt w`s
wrejb wotg Hgoj` `ji te dxpeuji gos oid`s ef gew tgd Hgojdsd heuni
adst omprevd tgdor st`td* Xe fer jd`rny `j geur O s`t oj tgd rdhdptoej
reem ef gos ferdobj-stynd rdsoidjhd oj ` gespot`n hempeuji oj J`jlojb
`ji wotg ejny ehh`soej`n ojtdrkdhtoejs te tgd ojtdrprdtdr nostdjdi te
M`rsg`n Fdjb"s prebr`m fer tgd dhejemoh rdg`aonot`toej ef tgd Hgojdsd
pdepnds*
Ygdrd wdrd sox mdj prdsdjt `t tg`t ojtdrvodw. tgrdd @mdroh`js
`ji tgrdd Hgojdsd* Ef tgd @mdroh`js. twe wdrd herrdspejidjts fer
@mdroh`j p`pdrs `ji tgd etgdr ` ausojdss m`j frem Xg`jbg`o wge
w`jtdi te be `nejb `ji mddt tgd m`j wge. m`jy adnodvdi. wodnidi
tgd brd`tdst sojbnd ojfnudjhd oj `nn tgd jdw. sdmo-ujotdi Hgoj`* Ygd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 161/455
HGO@JB L@O-XGDL"X QDYTQJ 060
Hgojdsd prdsdjt wdrd eur twe ojtdrprdtdrs `ji M`rsg`n Fdjb gomsdnf*
Ygd n`ttdr s`t ej ` wohldr neujbd. gos gubd fr`md sneuhgojb `t d`sd.
heen tg`t get merjojb oj tgd p`k`m`-nold wgotd hestumd ef tgd Hgojdsd.
gos fddt djh`sdi oj ` hruid p`or ef hemmej ojf`jtry aeets* Gd werd
je gesd* Gos bdjo`n reuji f`hd w`s brozzndi. tgd f`tkewns. str`jbdny
pojl oj hempndxoej fer ` Hgojdsd. p`rto`nny goiidj adjd`tg ` stuaany
ad`ri ef sdvdr`n i`ys" brewtg*
Ygd M`rsg`n novdi ` sompnd nofd* Gd stonn adnodvds. ot g`s addj
rdm`rldi. oj Kdffdrsejo`j sompnohoty. `ji gd pr`htosds wg`t gd
prd`hgds oj tg`t rdb`ri* Gd wd`rs tgd ujoferm wgohg gos hemmejdst
seniodrs wd`r* Ay je ojsobjo` m`y ejd ljew gom `s tgd m`j wgesd
pdrsej`n nd`idrsgop auont up `j `rmy tg`t w`s ney`n te gom `ji tg`t
m`id gom prea`any ejd ef tgd mest ompert`jt sojbnd foburds oj Hgoj`*
Ot m`y ad jetdi oj p`ssojb tg`t. adnodvojb tgd nd`idrs ef tgd Lue-
mojt`jb Qdvenutoej sgeuni jet squ`jidr tgd pdepnd"s mejdy. M`rsg`n
Fdjb spejserdi ` penohy ef stroht dhejemy wgdrdvdr gd wdjt oj 0?17*
Oj J`jlojb. wgohg gd vosotdi te `ttdji tgd Foftg Sndj`ry Xdssoej ef tgd
Hdjtr`n Dxdhutovd Hemmottdd ef tgd Luemojt`jb d`rny oj @ubust. tgd
Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n ioshevdrdi tgd penotoho`js nd`iojb novds ef d`sd*
Gd feuji tgdm `ji. `s ot `ppd`rdi te gom. dvdryaeiy dnsd b`manojb
`ji bovojb a`jqudts `ji djtdrt`ojojb oj ` f`sgoej tg`t. gd idhn`rdi.
w`s tr`otereus* Ot w`s ejny ` fdw i`ys n`tdr tg`t tgd Mojostdr fer
tgd Ojtdroer. ` Fdjb `ppeojtdd. ossudi `j eridr pregoaotojb `nn b`m-
anojb `ji idhrddojb tg`t je nejbdr heuni Hgoj`"s tr`iotoej`n sojb-
sejb borns djtdrt`oj `t fd`sts `nejb tgd h`j`ns `ji tojy strd`ms oj `ji
`aeut J`jlojb*
Ygd pepun`hd w`s or`td `ji tgd Hg`madr ef Hemmdrhd bet up
pdtotoejs te ferhd ` rdpd`n ef tgd Bevdrjmdjt"s eridr* Ygd eridr. tgdy
s`oi. tgrdw `t nd`st 03.333 pdrsejs eut ef werl* Qdst`ur`jts n`j-
buosgdi `ji tgd pohturdsqud h`j`n ae`ts n`y oind fer w`jt ef hustemdrs*
Ygdy wonn seej foji werl dnsdwgdrd. s`oi M`rsg`n Fdjb* Ygdy
h`j put tgdor g`jis te semdtgojb merd prefot`and te tgd hemmujoty*
Aut tgd borns `ji tgd ae`tmdj s`oi. Rd sg`nn aoid eur tomd*
Ygos sonny eridr h`jjet prdv`on* Rgdj tgos m`j beds a`hl ojte gos
gemd heujtry oj Gej`j yeu wonn sdd tg`t tgojbs wonn ad `s adferd* Ot
h`jjet n`st. tgos eridr `b`ojst eur tr`iotoejs*
Ygdy wdrd robgt* Dvdj wgond M`rsg`n Fdjb rdm`ojdi oj pewdr
tgdrd w`s ` aot ef sojb-sejb born aeetndbbojb jetohd`and* Gdrd `ji
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 162/455
061 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgdrd tgd sgronn veohd ef ejd ef tgdsd ienn-nold nottnd djtdrt`ojdrs r`osdi
oj tgd soaon`jt. mejetejeus w`on ef tgd Hgojdsd mobgt ad gd`ri ej
semd jobgts `t pn`hds `nejb tgd tojy strd`ms wgdrd tgd penohd. ejd
nd`rjdi. wdrd merd symp`tgdtoh tg`j vobon`jt*
Ot w`s jet d`sy te sdd tgd M`rsg`n* Gewdvdr. tgreubg tgd sdhrd-
t`ry te Ir* G* G* Lujb. Mojostdr ef Foj`jhd. eur `ppeojtmdjt w`s
m`id* Ygd M`rsg`n weuni ad bn`i te sdd yeu `t sdvdj e"hnehl te-
merrew merjojb%" Gd g`i jet addj fddnojb wdnn. etgdrwosd tgd `p-
peojtmdjt weuni g`vd addj `j geur d`rnodr* M`rsg`n Fdjb"s h`nnojb
geurs wdrd erioj`rony frem 4 te 2 `*m* Gos oid` w`s tg`t oj tgos w`y
gd heuni bdt h`nndrs eut ef tgd w`y `ji tgdj bdt iewj te ` funn i`y"s
ujojtdrruptdi werl*
@rd yeu beojb te `ttdji tgd Luemojt`jb"s Foftg Sndj`ry Xds-
soej5 O `sldi wgdj wd wdrd sd`tdi. td` g`i addj sdrvdi ot ojv`ro-
`any os. `ji tg`t i`y. bdttojb `j d`rny st`rt. wd wdrd sdrvdi td` dx-
`htny twdjty-sdvdj tomds `ji tgd usu`n s`nut`toejs p`ssdi*
_ds%" M`rsg`n Fdjb rdpnodi* Je ujjdhdss`ry weris* Kust ` jei
te tgd ojtdrprdtdr `ji tgd Hgojdsd weri fer yds. wgohg seujis nold
soio* Ygd M`rsg`n w`s jet ` rdbun`r mdmadr ef tgd Hdjtr`n Dxdhu-
tovd Hemmottdd aut gd g`i addj ojvotdi te sot oj ej tgd mddtojbs tg`t
summdr `ji w`s bovdj `nn pewdrs gdni ay rdbun`r mdmadrs* Gos
prdsdjhd tgdj. `s ` m`ttdr ef f`ht. areubgt hejsoidr`and rdnodf te m`jy*
Rg`t ie yeu tgojl `rd tgd hgodf preandms f`hojb tgd jdw Bevdrj-
mdjt5 semdaeiy `sldi*
Idmeaonoz`toej ef eur gubd `rmods O tgojl hdrt`ojny hemds forst.
`t gemd%" M`rsg`n Fdjb s`oi* Ygos wonn t`ld semd tomd* Aut `n-
rd`iy pn`js `rd ujidr w`y* Foj`n `htoej os up te tgd monot`ry heujhon*
Rg`t ie yeu tgojl ef K`p`j"s `ttotuid oj M`jhguro` `ji wg`t
weuni yeu rdhemmdji tg`t tgd J`toej`nost Bevdrjmdjt ie `aeut ot5
w`s my jdxt qudry*
O h`j"t `jswdr tg`t%" M`rsg`n Fdjb s`oi* O prdfdr. r`tgdr. jet
te `jswdr tgd qudstoej* O g`vd my ewj oid`s. te ad surd. aut yeumust t`ld tg`t up wotg tgd Ferdobj Effohd* O `m kust ` seniodr `ji
jet suppesdi te t`nl `aeut ferdobj iopnem`toh `ff`ors*
Ygdj h`md tgd suakdht wgohg irdw gom ojte `j dxtdjsovd `ji
`jom`tdi ioshussoej ef Hgoj`"s iemdstoh onns `ji gew gd weuni senvd
tgdm* Gos prebr`m `s eutnojdi adnew w`s suamottdi oj ` hemprd-
gdjsovd mdmer`jium pn`hdi adferd tgd Bevdrjmdjt `t ots Foftg Sndj-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 163/455
HGO@JB L@O-XGDL"X QDYTQJ 068
`ry Xdssoej. `ji sojhd g`s addj hejsoidrdi ay dxpdrts fer yd`rs oj tgd
v`roeus Mojostrods wgohg ot `ffdhts* M`rsg`n Fdjb"s prebr`m w`s
a`sdi ej diuh`toej `ji dhejemoh rdferm* Gd adnodvdi tg`t Hgoj`"s
onns wdrd iud hgodfny te objer`jhd `ji ots ojdvot`and heerioj`tds. rdvenv-
ojb `reuji ojdqu`noty ef dhejemoh eppertujoty* Arodfny. gd g`i feur
m`ker prekdhts;
0* @ Bevdrjmdjt prebr`m ef ommdio`td `htoej wotg jumdreus
pr`htoh`n mevds te `oi tgd f`rmdrs ef Hgoj`*
1* Adttdr geusojb f`honotods*
8* Bevdrjmdjt suppert fer ojf`jt ojiustrods*
9* Hejstruhtoej ef `t nd`st 033.333 monds ef r`onw`ys `ji ` hem-
pndtd gobgw`y systdm tgreubg Hgoj`*
O `m hejvojhdi. M`rsg`n Fdjb s`oi dmpg`toh`nny. tg`t tgd Bev-
drjmdjt sgeuni `pprepro`td `t nd`st )43.333.333 `t ejhd fer f`rm
rdnodf*
F`rm rdnodf os p`rtohun`rny jddidi oj Hdjtr`n `ji Jertgwdst
Hgoj`* Ygd pdepnd ef Lo`jbsu Srevojhd 'oj wgohg Xg`jbg`o os ne-
h`tdi/. ewojb te adttdr md`js ef hemmujoh`toej `ji m`rldtojb f`hono-
tods. `rd ommdjsdny wd`ntgy `s hemp`rdi wotg tgd pevdrty-strohldj
pdepnd ef ojtdroer Hgoj`. dspdho`nny Gej`j. Xgdjso `ji L`jsu* Ygdsd
prevojhds hejstotutdi tgd `rd` oj wgohg tgd M`rsg`n g`i addj mest oj
hejtren oj rdhdjt yd`rs* Rd must omprevd tgd net ef tgd f`rmdrs
wge ferm tgd a`sos ef eur j`toej* Hgoj` os dssdjto`nny ` f`rmojb
heujtry* Gdjhd. prespdreus f`rmdrs md`j ` g`ppy. prespdreus j`-
toej*
M`rsg`n Fdjb s`oi muhg ef tgd mejdy te ad `pprepro`tdi heuni ad
usdi oj orrob`toej prekdhts oj Hdjtr`n `ji Jertgwdst Hgoj` `ji oj
prevoiojb hemmujoh`toejs se tg`t. ejhd ` f`rmdr r`osds gos hrep. gd
h`j sdnn ot `t ` prefot*
Etgdr pg`sds ef f`rm rdnodf wgohg gd teuhgdi ej ojhnuidi tgd
dst`anosgmdjt ef shgeens `ji f`rm a`jls wgohg heuni ndji mejdy te
tgd f`jjdrs `t new r`tds ef ojtdrdst te dj`and tgdm te meidrjozd tgdor
dquopmdjt* Oj tgd shgeens. gd s`oi. gd weuni td`hg meidrj f`rmojb
mdtgeis `i`ptdi te hejiotoejs oj tgd p`rtohun`r iostrohts* Gd urbdi
tgd usd ef iosa`jidi treeps oj orrob`toej `ji rdhn`m`toejprekdhts* Oj
Gej`j Srevojhd. ot os sobjofoh`jt te jetd tg`t M`rsg`n Fdjb oj 0?12-17
ioi muhg oj tgd w`y ef puttojb tgdsd oid`s ojte dffdht* Gd g`s addj
pr`osdi fer tgd hejstruhtoej ef re`is `ji geusds oj tg`t prevojhd dvdj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 164/455
069 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`t ` tomd wgdj gd w`s ausony djb`bdi oj pusgojb tgd jertgdrj h`m-
p`obj tew`ri Sdlojb*
Rd must sdd tg`t eur pdepnd g`vd adttdr geusds te novd oj. M`r-
sg`n Fdjb prehddidi* Ygdrd `rd tdjs ef tgeus`jis ef pdepnd oj tgd
ojtdroer ef Hgoj` oj f`ht. dvdrywgdrd oj eur heujtry wge- g`vd je
pn`hd te novd* Xemd wge g`vd dxost oj tgd md`jdst ef mui gevdns tg`t
mdnt oj `jy loji ef ` r`oj sterm* Fer tgos rd`sej. O g`vd subbdstdi
tg`t tgd Bevdrjmdjt `pprepro`td `jetgdr )43.333.333 fer puanoh wdn-
f`rd werl* S`rt ef tgos mejdy heuni ad ` iordht `pprepro`toej. tgd
rdst heuni ad r`osdi tgreubg ` iemdstoh aeji ossud* Oj tgd p`st yd`r
oj Gej`j O g`vd auont 0.733 geusds `ji turjdi tgdm evdr te jddiy
f`monods* Ygos. ef heursd. os g`riny ` st`rt* Aut ot os ` pr`htoh`n dx-
`mpnd ef wg`t O gepd te ie `ji wg`t O tgojl tgd Bevdrjmdjt sgeuni
ie* Rd g`vd addj prd`hgojb tgd adjdfots ef eur rdvenutoej te tgd
iewjtreiidj m`ssds* Ot os. O tgojl. tomd te bovd tgdm semd hejhrdtd
dx`mpnd ef wg`t tgd Xt`td h`j ie te gdnp ots hotozdjs*
Ygdsd geusds ef tgd typd tg`t O g`vd oj moji h`j ad auont wotg
idmeaonozdi treep n`aer fer `s new `s )23 te )033 ` geusd* Ygdy `rd
sm`nn. aut tgdy `rd wdnn auont `ji sdrvohd`and* Ygdy `rd ojfojotdny
adttdr tg`j tgd mui `ji m`t gevdns tg`t tgd m`ssds `rd jew ferhdi te
h`nn gemd* O weuni rdjt tgdm eut `t tdj hdjts ej tgd ienn`r ef prdsdjt
rdjt`ns* Of ` f`mony h`jjet `fferi dvdj tg`t. O weuni turj tgd geusd
evdr te tgdm wotgeut hg`rbd ujton suhg tomd `s tgdy heuni adboj te
p`y*
@ji `jetgdr tgojb; tgdsd geusds. tgeus`jis ef tgdm. weuni ad
auont djtordny ef m`tdro`n preiuhdi oj Hgoj`* Ygdy weuni ad "m`id-
oj-Hgoj`4
geusds* Ygus. wd weuni `oi `nn hn`ssds* Rd weuni auy
m`tdro`n frem tgd mdrhg`jts. tgd numadrmdj `ji se ej. `ji gord mdj
kust eut ef tgd `rmy te ie tgd werl. tgus. oj p`rt. senvojb eur ujdm-
pneymdjt preandm* @ji tgd fojosgdi preiuht weuni r`osd tgd st`ji`ri
ef novojb ef eur pdepnd*
O rdm`rldi tg`t tgos w`s `j oid`n pn`j aut tg`t ot w`s noldny te
pn`hd ` prdmoum ej n`zojdss* Ygd tgeubgt subbdstdi otsdnf tg`t tgdrd
weuni ad ` n`rbd pdrhdjt`bd ef pdepnd wge weuni ehhupy ` geusd frdd
`ji weuni jdvdr try te d`rj `jy mejdy `soid frem ` fdw heppdrs `
i`y fer feei* Ot mobgt tdji te m`ld tgd Xt`td p`tdrj`n `ji s`p tgd
ojoto`tovd ef tgd pdepnd*
Jet `t `nn. s`oi M`rsg`n Fdjb* Ygd Hgojdsd `rd jet n`zy*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 165/455
HGO@JB L@O-XGDL"X QDYTQJ 064
Bovdj ` hg`jhd te adttdr tgdmsdnvds. tgdy wonn prebrdss* Ejhd `
f`mony sdds etgdr f`monods w`xojb prespdreus `ji novojb ej ` gobgdr
sh`nd. tgd tejd ef tgd wgend hemmujoty wonn ad r`osdi* Ygdrd m`y
ad ` fdw sn`hldrs aut wd wonn idvosd w`ys te id`n wotg tgdm wgdj tgd
tomd hemds*
Ot seujidi str`jbdny nold tgd `ttdmpts ef Djbnosg henejosts oj Vor-
bojo` te dst`anosg ` hemmuj`n vonn`bd wgdrd. gostery rdn`tds. `nn g`i
`hhdss te tgd tewj preiuhts `ji d`hg w`s suppesdi te preiuhd semd-
tgojb fer tgd beei ef tgd wgend* Yg`t d`rny `ttdmpt `t ` hemmujostoh
st`td f`ondi*
Fdjb `iidi tg`t `t nd`st 033.333 suhg geusds wdrd jddidi oj
Gej`j Srevojhd `nejd* Ygos iedsj"t md`j tg`t O tgojl tgd Bevdrj-
mdjt sgeuni adhemd p`tdrj`n%" gd s`oi* Ygd pdepnd. `ftdr `nn. `rd tgd
rd`n m`stdrs ef ` heujtry* Aut tgd m`stdrs g`vdj"t g`i ` hg`jhd te
`ssdrt tgdmsdnvds. `ji tgdor sdrv`jts. eur nd`idrs. g`vd novdi oj tgd
m`stdrs" geusds eff tgd mejdy t`ldj frem tgd rd`n m`stdrs ef tgd
Xt`td* Rd must rdvdrsd tgos*
Ygdrd `rd semd wge wonn sdd oj tgos ` tdjidjhy tew`ri Hem-
mujosm* Ot m`y ad. aut `s ` m`ttdr ef f`ht wgond Fdjb"s dhejemohs
m`y ad `nn wrejb `hheriojb te tgdery. ot h`jjet ad idjodi tg`t gd
w`jtdi te gdnp tgd pdepnd oj ` pr`htoh`n w`y* Gd os ` beei ioshopno-
j`ro`j `ji ` beei `imojostr`ter. `s gos etgdrwosd iuaoeus rdheri wonn
sgew*
Bevdrjmdjt suppert te ojf`jt ojiustrods irdw gos `ttdjtoej jdxt*
Gd s`oi;
Ygd Bevdrjmdjt sgeuni r`osd )63.333.333 te gdnp eur ojiustrods
jew kust bdttojb st`rtdi `ji tgesd jet ydt ujidr w`y. wgohg wd jddi*
Rd sgeuni g`vd merd `ji aobbdr `ji adttdr hettej monns. t`jjdrods
`ji f`hterods ef `nn serts* Hgoj` g`s tgd r`w m`tdro`ns* Ygdrd os je
jddi fer us te dxpert tgdm `nn* Of wd `oi eur f`rmdrs wd h`j lddp
eur dxperts up `nmest te tgdor prdsdjt ndvdn `ji stonn preiuhd djeubg
te suppny eur monns. t`jjdrods. `ji f`hterods wotg Hgojdsd brewj.
Hgojdsd mojdi. Hgojdsd preiuhdi r`w m`tdro`ns* Eur j`tur`n rd-
seurhds `rd ommdjsd* Rd must m`ld usd ef tgdm*
M`rsg`n Fdjb"s `maotoeus prebr`m ef dhejemoh rdferm h`nndi fer `
tet`n dxpdjioturd ef )833.333.333. Hgojdsd hurrdjhy* Ot w`s jet pes-
soand fer J`jlojb te spdji tg`t muhg mejdy ej gos er `jy etgdr
idvdnepmdjt prebr`m* Aut ` st`rt w`s m`id*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 166/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 167/455
01 QDI QDADNNOEJ
DVDJYX
mevdi wotg `m`zojb swoftjdss tgd wddl dji ef Idhdm-
adr 03-01. 0?12. wgdj Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl rdturjdi te tgd Lue-
mojt`jb rdvenutoej* Gd w`s effoho`nny rdojst`tdi ej ` Froi`y<
ej X`turi`y gd b`vd gos puanoh vodws ef wg`t sgeuni ad iejd jdxt
`ji ujidr hevdr tgd Hemmujosts te tgd Xeutg wdrd `htovd oj rdadnnoej
`t H`jtej<ej Xuji`y. tgd dndvdjtg. `nn H`jtej w`s epdjny oj tgd brop
ef ` Qdi Qdadnnoej. 733 monds er merd seutg ef J`jlojb< `ji ej
Meji`y. tgd Hgojdsd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt. ndi ay Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb.
idhoidi ferm`nny te ard`l eff rdn`toejs wotg Meshew wotgoj `nn tgdor
rdvenutoej`ry J`toej`nost-hejtrenndi tdrrotery. `ji te eridr Xevodt
Qusso`"s iopnem`toh sdrvohd mdj eut ef tgd heujtry*
Ygd Qdi Qdadnnoej oj tgd iddp seutg ef Hgoj` areld ujdxpdhtdiny.
dvdj te tgd Hemmujost nd`idrs tgdmsdnvds* Ygdor g`ji g`i addj
ferhdi. `ji tgdy struhl `aruptny `ji wotg r`rd arut`noty dvdj fer
Hgoj`* Ygd Hgojdsd neetdi. r`pdi. muridrdi. aurjdi `ji s`hldi tgdor
ewj hoty dvdj merd rutgndssny tg`j tgdy hemmottdi somon`r `trehotods
ej ferdobj novds `ji prepdrty*
Ygdor sw`y w`s arodf* Oj turj. wgdj tgdy wdrd evdrtgrewj ay
ney`n Hgojdsd seniodry. tgd i`ys ef gerrer wdrd `nse arodf aut dvdj
merd nuroi. of pessoand* Sgetebr`pgs O s`w ef tg`t wrdhl`bd. gum`j
`s wdnn `s m`tdro`n. teni tgd j`usd`tojb. serioi t`nd merd br`pgoh`nny
tg`j heuni ` weri pohturd* M`jy ef tgd pohturds heuni jet ad pua-
nosgdi* Ygd ndjbtgs oj terturd te wgohg tgd Hgojdsd be `rd ujadnodv-
`and aut tdrroany trud. ad tgd vohtom ` Hgojdsd m`j er wem`j er `
nest seun wotg wgotd sloj frem ferdobj sgerds* Ygd Hgojdsd tgreubg
tgd hdjturods g`vd `hgodvdi. `mejb etgdr tgojbs. `j `pebdd oj w`ys ef
terturd*
H`jtej w`s oj tgd brop ef tgd Qdis ej Xuji`y. Idhdmadr 01.
0?12* Xg`jbg`o w`s ujidr spdho`n p`tren. wotg @mdroh`j m`rojds
ieojb jobgt ojstruhtoej iuty* Ygd Arotosg `ji K`p`jdsd idfdjsd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 168/455
067 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
ferhds `ssostdi tgd mujohop`n penohd oj m`ojt`ojojb eridr `s tgd rosojb
toid ef pd`s`jt-n`aer ujrdst swdpt Xeutg Hgoj`* Ygd f`td ef @mdro-
h`js oj tgd H`jtej `rd` w`s ujhdrt`oj fer i`ys Rordndss iosp`thgds
s`oi tg`t tgd @mdroh`j j`v`n `utgerotods wdrd sddlojb te dst`anosg hej-
t`ht wotg tgd rdfubdds ej n`ji*
Rgond tgd Qdi rdvent oj H`jtej rdsuntdi oj sdttojb tgd hoty `ford
oj m`jy pn`hds `s wdnn `s oj neetojb. tgd mea w`s jet `jto-ferdobj
Ygdsd mdj wdrd sddlojb r`tgdr te evdrtgrew Hgoj`"s monot`ry rdbomd
`ji dst`anosg Hemmujost rund*
Xtrolojb iurojb tgd i`rl geurs proer te tg`t Xuji`y"s i`wj tgd
Qdi uprosojb suhhddidi iurojb tgd i`y oj ios`rmojb tgd penohd. reut-
ojb Bdjdr`n Hg`jb F`-lwdo"s md`bdr b`rrosej `ji b`ojojb hempndtd
hejtren ef tgd hoty. wgohg tgd r`aand prehddidi te neet* Xper`ioh
fords rdsuntdi `t tgd f`jhy ef tgd pewdr-m`i pd`s`jtry* Jet ejny
H`jtej w`s oj tgd hejtren ef tgd r`aand aut `t nd`st sdvdj etgdr hotods
oj tgd Lw`jtujb `rd`* Ygd @mdroh`j bujae`ts X`hr`mdjte `ji
S`mp`jb` steei ay `t H`jtej* Ygd T* X* X* @sgdvonndkeojdi tgdm
tgdrd*
Ygd vohteroeus mea"s nd`idrs ossudi ` st`tdmdjt fennewojb tgd
rdster`toej ef hemp`r`tovd quodt. idhn`rojb oj p`rt;
Ygd hemaojdi ferhds ef pd`s`jts `ji werlmdj g`vd foj`nny t`ldj
evdr hejtren ef H`jtej* Ygd m`keroty ef tgdsd p`rtohop`tojb oj tgd
rdvent `rd treeps oj tgd Gemd Idfdjsd Xdrvohd `t H`jtej* Eur werl-
mdj"s Qdi Herps ujidr tgd iordhtoej ef Qdi treeps g`vd h`pturdi tgd
Sd`hd Aurd`u `ji ios`rmdi tgd bu`ris*
Sd`s`jts horhun`tdi g`jiaonns ad`rojb suhg ojshroptoejs `s; IERJ
ROYG HGO@JB L@O-XGDL. BDJDQ@N HG@JB F@-LRDO. R@JB HGOJB-
RDO. RGE @QD YGD DJDM_ EF SD@X@JYX @JI REQLMDJ! QDI
SD@X@JYX @JI XENIODQX @QD YGD EJN_ EJDX RGE H@J SQEYDHY YGD
M@XXDX! @nn sgeps wdrd hnesdi* Ygd eutslorts ef H`jtej sw`rmdi
wotg `rmdi pd`s`jts `ji werlmdj wd`rojb rdi ar`ss`ris `ji `pp`r-
djtny wotg nottnd er je nd`idrsgop* M`ss mddtojbs wdrd gdni. te
hgeesd nd`idrs fer tgd ferm`toej ef ` Qdi Bevdrjmdjt*
Ygd d`sd wotg wgohg H`jtej fdnn os dxpn`ojdi ay tgd f`ht tg`t mest
ef tgd rdbun`r treeps tgdrd g`i addj h`nndi fer iuty oj Gej`j* Gdjhd
tgd h`pturd w`s d`sy. m`jy ef tgd rdm`ojojb treeps beojb Qdi* Gew-
dvdr. tgd Hgojdsd J`vy rdm`ojdi ney`n te Hg`jb F`-lwdo* Gd a`rdny
dsh`pdi wotg gos nofd `ae`ri ` bujae`t* Ygd b`tds te tgd hoty wdrd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 169/455
QDI QDADNNOEJ 06?
hnesdi. aut dfferts te rdt`ld tgd hoty seej m`id prebrdss. `ntgeubg
j`vob`toej adtwddj H`jtej `ji Gejblejb w`s ompessoand*
Ojferm`toej `s te gew tgd uprosojb st`rtdi os stonn v`bud. aut O
w`s teni tg`t n`td ej tgd prdvoeus X`turi`y Bdjdr`n R`jb Hgo-gsojb"s
treeps suiidjny `ttdmptdi te ios`rm tgd 9tg rdbomdjt ef tgd jdw
1ji Iovosoej. jumadrojb 0.333 mdj* Fobgtojb djsudi. pd`s`jts `ji
werlmdj t`lojb tgdor hud frem tgd seniodrs `ji keojojb oj tgd roets*
Ygd Qdi Qdadnnoej fennewdi*
Ejd rdsunt w`s J`jlojb"s idfojotd idhosoej te ard`l wotg Xevodt
Qusso`* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `jjeujhdi tg`t tgd Luemojt`jb
nd`idrs g`i ojstruhtdi Ir* H* H* Ru. tgdj J`jlojb"s ferdobj mojostdr.
te prehddi wotg tgd jdhdss`ry stdps fer tgd wotgir`w`n ef `nn Xevodt
hejsun`tds oj J`toej`nost tdrroterods* 'Ir* Ru os jew id`i*/ Ygd
nd`idr idhn`rdi tg`t tgd p`rty"s ojstruhtoejs wdrd oj tgd ferm ef `
pdrdmptery eridr. prdhnuiojb tgd pessoaonoty ef tgd Mojostdr"s f`onurd
te `ht* Ir* Ru fertgwotg idm`jidi tgd wotgir`w`n ef `nn tgd Xevodt
Tjoej"s hejsun`tds oj Hgoj`* Ygd Xevodt Hejsun-Bdjdr`n w`s A*
Lesnevsly oj Xg`jbg`o* Gd teni md `t forst tg`t gd g`i jet addj
ojfermdi* Gd `iidi tg`t gd must `w`ot Ir* Ru"s ferm`n `htoej
`s wdnn `s Meshew"s rdpny* Gd bet tgdm `ji ndft*
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl s`oi ; Ygd p`rty"s `htoej w`s ldpt sdhrdt gdrdte-
ferd. pdjiojb tgd Ferdobj Mojostdr"s ferm`n `htoej* Gewdvdr. O fddn
tgd `jjeujhdmdjt os kustofodi jew oj vodw ef tgd H`jtej eutaurst.
wgohg ujieuatdiny w`s tgd rdsunt ef Xevodt `bot`toej* Ygdrd os je
ieuat aut tg`t Ir* Ru wonn `ht vdry quohlny* Gd g`s jet ydt g`i
tomd te t`ld tgd usu`n ferm`n stdps fennewojb tgos ompert`jt idhosoej
`s f`r `s ` ferm`n jetd te Meshew os hejhdrjdi aut O `m surd gd wonn
prehddi fertgwotg* Xevodt `bot`ters `rd rdspejsoand fer mest ef eur
treuands oj tgos H`jtej `rd`. `s wdnn `s G`jlew. J`jlojb `ji dnsd-
wgdrd. Gdjhd `j `asenutd ard`l ommdio`tdny os jdhdss`ry fer tgd
rdster`toej ef pd`hd wotgoj eur tdrroterods*
Ygd n`tdst `jto-Qdi `jjeujhdmdjt hn`rofodi tgd H`jtej idvdnep-
mdjts* Ot w`s idhn`rdi tg`t tgd pd`s`jtry"s heup i"dt`t Xuji`y rd-
suntdi frem tgd Luemojt`jb"s sdjiojb ` tdndbr`m te H`jtej eridrojb
Bdjdr`n Hg`jb F`-lwdo te r`oi H`jtej"s Xevodt Hejsun`td `ji sdozd
iehumdjts sgewojb tg`t Meshew w`s adgoji tgd pd`s`jt-n`aer up-
rosojbs oj v`roeus sdhtoejs ef Hgoj`* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. `s wdnn
`s Y* V* Xeejb `ji Ir* G. G* Lujb. wdrd hejvojhdi tg`t tgdsd oj-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 170/455
023 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
struhtoejs nd`ldi eut `t H`jtej. rdsuntojb oj tgd Qdi rdvent `ji pn`h-
ojb meas oj hejtren ef tgdhoty* Ygos dxpn`ojdi tgd eutaurst `t tg`t
tomd. `ntgeubg fer ` fertjobgt tgdrd g`i addj sobjs tg`t treuand w`s
ardwojb*
H`jtej hejtojudi oj turmeon*
Ney`n Luemojt`jb treeps seubgt te evdrpewdr tgd `rmdi pd`s`j-
try. wotg swoft suhhdss* Foftddj @mdroh`js `ji twe Arotosg dv`hu-
`tdi H`jtej. wgond `rmerdi n`ujhgds frem tgd T* X* X* S`mp`jb` `s
wdnn `s tgd Xehejy Ojst`nn`toej `ssostdi oj arojbojb eut rdfubdds frem
tgd suauras* Qdfubdds hejhdjtr`tdi ej tgd osn`ji ef Xg`mddj* Xg`-
mddj os aut ` kdw y`ris eff sgerd. oj Sd`rn Qovdr* Furtgdr prdh`u-
toejs wdrd t`ldj ej sgerd. tgd T* X* X* X`hr`mdjte n`jiojb fodni-podhds
`ji ojst`nnojb tgdm ej tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Hejsun`td breujis. wgohg os
ej Xg`mddj Osn`ji*
Ygd sgert-novdi Qdi rdvent oj H`jtej djidi ej Idhdmadr 09* Ygd
r`aand w`s reutdi. `ji ney`n Luemojt`jb treeps rdb`ojdi hejtren* Ygd
H`jtej eutard`l h`usdi tgd merd meidr`td rdvenutoej`rods te ojvdobg
merd tg`j dvdr `b`ojst Meshew"s ojtdrfdrdjhd* Ygd dffdht ef tgd tdr-
rerosts" `htovotods w`s te turj tgd J`jlojb nd`idrs merd tg`j dvdr
`b`ojst r`ioh`nosm*
Tttdr`jhds ay Mr* Pue Y`o-hgo. tgdj Vohd-Mojostdr fer Ferdobj
@ff`ors `t J`jlojb. `t `j @mdroh`j Tjovdrsoty Hnua iojjdr oj Xg`jb-
g`o. wdrd ojioh`tovd ef `j `arupt turj tew`ri tgd Qobgt* Pue Y`o-
hgo. n`tdr Hgoj`"s @ma`ss`ier oj Nejiej. teni ` n`rbd b`tgdrojb ef
premojdjt Hgojdsd `ji @mdroh`js; 9>Ygd Luemojt`jb os tgereubgny
fdi up wotg tgd `htovotods ef `nn Hemmujosts* Gd `iidi ;
Hgoj` os `t tgd hressre`is* Rd `rd f`hojb ` idhosoej adtwddj tgd
Xevodt `ji wg`t m`y ad tdrmdi tgd @jbne-X`xej ferm ef bevdrjmdjt*
Aottdr dxpdrodjhd g`s prevdi tg`t tgd Xevodts `rd f`nsd beis* Gdjhd.
tgeubgtfun nd`idrs oj tgd Luemojt`jb `rd jew rd`iy te hg`jbd* Aut
wd jddi yeur suppert. `ji tgd suppert ef `nn tgd Rdstdrj Sewdrs
etgdr tg`j Xevodt Qusso` of eur hg`jbd os te prevd pr`htoh`n* Rd `rd
idhoidiny jet `jto-ferdobj. `ntgeubg hdrt`oj ef eur penohods g`vd addj
se idshroadi*
Ygd Hgojdsd ef tgd d`rny i`ys hejsoidrdi `nn ferdobjdrs `s a`r-
a`ro`js `ji adjd`tg tgdm* Ygdj tgd ferdobjdrs g`i tgdor i`y* Rdst-
drj mdhg`joh`n hovonoz`toej idvdnepdi. `ji ferdobjdrs hemojb te
Hgoj` hejsoidrdi tgd Hgojdsd a`hlw`ri `ji ujhovonozdi* Ot os jew
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 171/455
QDI QDADNNOEJ 020
gobg tomd tg`t aetg Hgojdsd `ji ferdobjdrs iosh`ri tgdsd `jhodjt prdk-
uiohds `ji sddl te heepdr`td tew`ri tgd adst ojtdrdsts ef tgd werni%"
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl m`id furtgdr `tt`hls ej Meshew `ji `nn
tgd Xevodts oj tgd Hgojdsd prdss* Gd idhn`rdi; Ygd Xevodt hej-
sun`tds dvdrywgdrd oj Hgoj` `rd sdrvojb `s hdjtdrs fer tgd prep`b`-
toej ef Hemmujosm* O f`ver ard`lojb eff eur rdn`toejs; etgdrwosd.
tgd sprd`i ef Hemmujosm m`y g`jioh`p eur rdvenutoej* Of tgos g`i
addj iejd semd tomd `be ot os pessoand tg`t tgd H`jtej treuand mobgt
g`vd addj `veoidi* Rd `rd idfojotdny `b`ojst hejtojuojb iopnem`toh
rdn`toejs wotg Xevodt Qusso`. `ji h`jjet furtgdr heepdr`td wotg Qusso`
`s oj tgd p`st* O `nse adnodvd wd sgeuni heepdr`td wotg etgdr j`toejs
oj prdvdjtojb tgd sprd`i ef Hemmujosm*
Ygd J`jlojb Jetd eridrdi `nn Xevodt iopnem`toh effoho`ns eut ef
Hgoj` oj sdvdj i`ys* Ygd tdxt ef tgd Jetd fennews;
Ygd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt g`s fer semd tomd addj ojfermdi
ay v`roeus rdperts tg`t tgd Xevodt hejsun`tds `ji tgd Xevodt
Xt`td"s hemmdrho`n `bdjhods oj `rd`s wotgoj tgd kurosiohtoej ef
tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt g`vd addj usdi `s gd`iqu`rtdrs ef Qdi
prep`b`ji` `ji `j `synum fer `nn Hemmujosts* Dxpesurd ef
tgdsd f`hts g`s addj wotggdni. oj vodw ef ojtdrj`toej`n rdn`toejs
adtwddj Hgoj` `ji Qusso`*
Ej tgd dndvdjtg ef tgd prdsdjt mejtg `j uprosojb ehhurrdi
oj tgd hoty ef H`jtej hunmoj`tojb oj tgd ferhoand ehhup`toej ef
tg`t hoty ay Hemmujosts wge hut hemmujoh`toejs. aurjdi. pnuj-
idrdi `ji m`ss`hrdi tgreubgeut tgd hoty* Ygos st`rtnojb dvdjt
wotg `nn ots ios`streus hejsdqudjhds m`y ad `ttroautdi m`ojny te
tgd f`ht tg`t tgd Hgojdsd Hemmujosts `v`ondi tgdmsdnvds ef tgd
Xevodt hejsun`td `ji Xevodt Xt`td hemmdrho`n `bdjhods `s ` a`sd
fer iordht epdr`toejs* Fd`rs wdrd djtdrt`ojdi tg`t ehhurrdjhds
ef ` nold j`turd m`y ehhur dnsdwgdrd*
Rotg ` vodw te m`ojt`ojojb pd`hd `ji eridr `ji te prdvdjt-
ojb tgd furtgdr sprd`i ef suhg ios`stdrs eur Bevdrjmdjt fddns
tg`t suhg ` st`td ef tgojbs os fr`ubgt wotg ojh`nhun`and i`jbdrs
te eur S`rty `ji tgd Xt`td* Ot h`j je nejbdr ad tendr`tdi*
Ygdrdferd. ot os gdrday eridrdi tg`t eur rdhebjotoej `hheridi te
hejsuns ef tgd T* X* X* Q* st`toejdi oj tgd v`roeus Srevojhds
sg`nn ad suspdjidi oj eridr tg`t tgd reet ef tgos dvon ojfnudjhd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 172/455
021 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
sg`nn ad dr`ioh`tdi `ji ` tgereubg ojquory ojstotutdi* Ygd Moj-
ostry fer Ferdobj @ff`ors os jew ojstruhtdi te supdrojtdji ots sua-
erioj`td
erb`js
`ji `ht oj
hejkujhtoej
wotg tgd etgdr Bevdrj-
mdjt `utgerotods hejhdrjdi te put ojte dxdhutoej tgos m`ji`td
wotg `nn iud h`rd. `ji rdpert tgdrdej*
Ygd iopnem`toh. hejsun`r `ji `nn tr`id `ji etgdr Qusso`j effoho`ns
ndft wotgoj ` wddl* Adferd tgd hemojb ef tgd Jdw _d`r ef 0?17 jet
` rdhebjozdi Qusso`j effoho`n rdm`ojdi oj `nn Hgoj`*
Hgoj` w`s hemp`r`tovdny quodshdjt adferd tgd st`rt ef tgd sterm
tew`ri tgd Jertg `b`oj tg`t sprojb* Hen Gdjry N* Xtomsej. jew
Xdhrdt`ry ef R`r. w`s j`mdi Bevdrjer-Bdjdr`n ef tgd jew sdmo-
ojidpdjidjt Sgonoppojd Osn`jis* Ygd Henejdn p`ssdi tgreubg Xg`jbg`o
oj Fdaru`ry ej gos w`y te gos pest `t M`jon`. `ji O bet ej tgd
std`mdr `ji wdjt te tgd Sgonoppojds wotg gom*
Ej tg`t dxhursoej te vodw eur preandms `ji prebrdss oj tgesd
osn`jis `t tgd ojhdptoej ef tgd Xtomsej rund. O `nse bet ` vodw ef tgd
dffdht ef tgd Qdi turmeon `t H`jtej* Ot w`s @pron. 0?17. wgdj O vosotdi
Xeutg Hgoj` `ji feuji tg`t H`jtej. oj tgd gd`rt ef ejd ef tgd rohgdst
prevojhds oj `nn Hgoj`. tgd a`sd ef hovon w`rs fer ` qu`rtdr ef ` hdj-
tury `ji merd. w`s r`poiny beojb `aeut tgd ausojdss ef rdauoniojb
woid `rd`s idstreydi iurojb tgd Qdi Qdadnnoej tgd prdvoeus Idhdmadr*
Ygd wojtdr wddls `ji d`rny sprojb g`i jet sddj `j `pprdho`and
hg`jbd oj tgd idv`st`tdi `rd`. ot w`s trud< ydt pn`js wdrd ujidr w`y
fer rdhejstruhtoej* Oj tgd md`jtomd. tgd tgrofty Hgojdsd auont tgdm-
sdnvds sgeps oj tgd b`ujt arohl w`nns ef aurjdi auoniojbs `ji wdrd
beojb `aeut nofd muhg `s usu`n*
Anehls `ji anehls wdrd buttdi ay tgd fn`mds tg`t g`i terj `t tgd
gd`rt ef tgd Xeutgdrj h`pot`n wgdj tgd Qdis. ojfuro`tdi `t tgd ios-
hevdry ef tgdor pnet te evdrtgrew tgd H`jtej bevdrjmdjt. wdrd ferhdi
te `tt`hl prdm`turdny* Ygd i`m`bd r`j ojte tdjs ef monnoejs ef ien-
n`rs* Ygd dstom`tds v`rodi frem )04.333.333 te )93.333.333. tgos n`st
foburd t`lojb ojte hejsoidr`toej. ot weuni `ppd`r. tgd hest ef rdhej-
struhtoej* Ygd dstom`td os a`sdi. `s usu`n. ej Hgoj`"s sonvdr hurrdjhy*
Qdpn`hdmdjt ef aurjdi er aemadi auoniojbs hest `s muhg er merd
tg`j tgd eroboj`n struhturd `ji tg`t. ot w`s foburdi. must ad hej-
soidrdi oj tgd dstom`tds ef tgd tet`n ness*
Ot w`s idprdssojb te w`nl `nejb tgd are`i strddts ef H`jtej. auont
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 173/455
QDI QDADNNOEJ 028
`hheriojb te meidrj pn`js m`id ujidr tgd rdbomd ef tgd n`td Ir* H*
H* Ru. wge `nse nejb w`s M`yer ef H`jtej* Ygd are`i strddts. uj-
usu`n oj ` Hgojdsd hoty. wdjt tgreubg anehl `ftdr anehl ef a`rrdj auoni-
ojbs wgesd w`nns. sh`rrdi `ji an`hldjdi. wdrd terj iewj te m`ld w`y
fer rdhejstruhtoej* Ygdy tdstofodi te tgd fury ef tgd mea
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 174/455
08 HGQOXY EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I
A@JIOYQ_
oj @so` os stonn ` prefot`and ausojdss wgohg tgeu-
s`jis ef revojb jem`is hejtojud te pursud. aut wgond tgd idvon
rdobjs evdr woid `rd`s. ndt us p`usd gdrd te neel `t tgd werl
wgohg tgd Hgrosto`j mossoej`rods `rd ieojb oj ` v`no`jt of se f`r futond
dffert te sgew tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds tgd nobgt* Xemd yd`rs `be mymetgdr b`vd md ` nottnd aeel djtotndi. HGQOXY EF YGD OJIO@J QE@I*
Ot w`s ay ` mossoej`ry wge g`i spdjt mest ef gos `iunt nofd `mejb
tgd pdepnds ef Ojio`. sddlojb te sgew tgdm tgd R`y* Ot sddms te
md tg`t O mobgt ie wersd oj sdndhtojb ` totnd fer tgos ojtdrdstojb pg`sd
ef m`j"s strubbnd fer dxostdjhd oj tgd Erodjt tg`j ay hgeesojb HGQOXY
EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I*
Ygd mdj `ji wemdj oj eur Hgrosto`j mossoejs g`vd g`i `jytgojb
aut `j d`sy tomd ef ot oj tgdor dfferts te hejvdrt tgd gd`tgdj Hgojdsd*
Ygd Hgojdsd `hhdpt tgdbofts
ef tgd mossoej`rods. dspdho`nny tgesd ef `
m`tdro`n j`turd*
Ygdy`nnew tgdsd mdj `ji wemdj frem
ferdobjn`jis te hemd ojte tgdor n`ji `ji try te sprd`i tgdor bespdn* Aut oj
merd tg`j ` hdjtury tgd trud hejvdrts te Hgrosto`joty `mejb tgd
Hgojdsd g`vd addj fdw* Fer hdjturods tgdy g`vd g`i tgdor ewj w`y
ef tgojlojb `aeut ojfojoty `ji tgd w`y ef tgos nofd `ji gew adst te novd
or* Ygdy rdt`oj tgdor `jhodjt f`otg oj Auiigosm. wgohg os tgd m`oj
rdnoboej ef @so`*
Ygdrd `rd tdjs ef tgeus`jis. wge g`vd dmar`hdi Hgrost"s td`hgojbs
`s tgdor
ewj.`ji fennew Gom
tgreubgGos mossoej`rods* Aut
tgdsd.
tgeubg tgdy jumadr semd tgrdd monnoej seuns. `rd stonn aut ` irep oj
tgd auhldt* Ygdrd `rd stonn jd`rny 933.333.333 etgdr Hgojdsd. wge rd-
m`oj ujmevdi ay tgdsd td`hgojbs* Ygd s`md os trud oj K`p`j wgdrd
Xgojteosm. ` vdrsoej ef Auiigosm. os tgd Xt`td rdnoboej*
Ygd werl ef tgd mossoej`rods. tgdrdferd. os g`ri oj tgd D`st* _dt
tgdy pdrsost. `ji wgdrd tgdy h`j tgdy ie ` beei werl. ot must ad
029
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 175/455
HGQOXY EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I+" 024
`imottdi dvdj ay tgd Hgojdsd* Mest ef tgd hejvdrts `rd mdrdny eut
fer tgd roid%" eut. oj etgdr weris. fer wg`t os oj ot fer tgdm* Ygdsd
`rd ljewj te tgd g`ri-aottdj tr`idrs wge ojg`aot tgd he`st`n hotods `s
tgd i`mjdi rohd-Hgrosto`js* Ygdrd os trutg oj tg`t dpotgdt fer tg`t
os dx`htny wg`t m`jy ef tgdm `rd* Ygdor ejny rd`sej fer `ttdjiojb `
Mossoej Xhgeen oj Hgoj` os se tg`t tgdy m`y adjdfot ay tgd ojstruhtoej
effdrdi te stuidjts. `j dxhdnndjt hg`jhd te nd`rj ` ferdobj n`jbu`bd.
usu`nny Djbnosg. wgohg tgdy m`y usd n`tdr wgdj tgdy djtdr tr`id.
a`jlojb. ` prefdssoej er bevdrjmdjt sdrvohd*
Ljewndibd suhg `s tg`t os vdry usdfun. tgd Hgojdsd ljew. `ji tgdy
h`j bdt ot `t ` mojomum ef dxpdjsd* Rg`t tgdy ie `ftdr br`iu`toej
os hejkdhtur`n* Mest ef tgdm rdturj te tgdor eni f`otg. t`ld ` jdw
vew oj tgdor sdt fermun` ef `jhdster wersgop `ji tgd f`otg ef tgdor
ferdad`rs. `ji be `aeut tgdor ausojdss hejtdjtdi* Ygdy tgojl tgdy
g`vd snoppdi ejd evdr ej tgdsd ferdobj a`ra`ro`js. `b`oj*
Ot os trud. ef heursd. tg`t semd rd`nny adhemd hejvdrtdi te Hgros-
to`joty `ji novd up te tgd td`hgojbs te wgohg tgdy g`vd addj suakdhtdi*
Gewdvdr. tgdy `rd fdw*
Ygd hgodf werl ef tgd Hgrosto`j mossoej`rods oj Hgoj` tgdrdferd os
hejfojdi te twe fodnis ef gum`j djid`ver. j`mdny. diuh`toej `ji s`jo-
t`toej. wotg tgd n`ttdr fodni hevdrojb mdioh`n mossoejs bdjdr`nny oj @so`*
Ygd dv`jbdnoh`n werl os ompert`jt. ef heursd aut tgd Hgojdsd `rd `
pr`htoh`n net `ji `htoejs spd`l neuidr tg`j weris*
@ prd`hgdr h`j st`ji up `ji spddhg `t tgdm `nn i`y dvdry i`y
oj tgd wddl. aut ujndss gd ieds semdtgojb wgohg h`j prevd adyeji
tgd sg`iew ef ` ieuat tg`t tgd w`y ef tgd ferdobj. wgotd-slojjdi Hgros-
to`js wonn m`ld tgos nofd merd novd`and. gd mobgt kust `s wdnn s`vd gos
ard`tg* Fer tgos rd`sej tgd Hgrosto`j werldrs `rd d`rjdstny tryojb te
prevd te tgd Hgojdsd tg`t ` Hgrosto`j hemmujoty os hnd`jdr. tgd oj-
g`aot`jts `htu`nny novd oj johdr gemds ej johdr strddts `ji oj johdr
tewjs. tgdy `rd tgdrdferd g`ppodr `ji `nse merd prespdreus. `ji tgd
Hgrosto`js `rd adttdr diuh`tdi adh`usd tgdy g`vd merd `ji adttdr
shgeens oj tgdor tewjs*
Ygd hgoninold m`ssds ef Hgojdsd 'er `jy etgdr pdepnd. fer tg`t
m`ttdr/ h`j ujidrst`ji ` w`y ef nofd nold tg`t. `ji tgdy `rd dmar`hojb
Hgrosto`joty fer tg`t rd`sej oj n`rbdr jumadrs tg`j gdrdteferd. te tgd
pnd`s`jt surprosd ef tgd Hgrosto`j werldrs*
J`tur`nny. m`tdro`n adjdfots gdrd `ji jew hemd forst te promotovd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 176/455
026 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
seuns dxostojb oj ` hrudn. a`rrdj werni* Ygdy h`j sdd ejny gew tgdy
`rd te ad noftdi up aeiony ay ` jdw `ji str`jbd hrddi< tgdy h`jjet ad
dxpdhtdi te g`vd tgd are`idr vosoej wgohg djhemp`ssds tgd sporotu`n
er mdjt`n bnerods te fennew* Aut ejhd `oidi tew`ri ` merd pnd`s`jt
nofd wotg seho`n sdhuroty fer `nn. `ji ejd oj wgohg tgdy h`j ad diuh`tdi
up te `j `pprdho`toej ef tgd fojdr tgojbs ef dxostdjhd. tgd trud hej-
vdrsoej te tg`t meid ef novojb wonn hemd te p`ss*
Ygd mdioh`n mossoejs `ji tgd diuh`toej`n werl tgreubg shgeens
sh`ttdrdi `nn evdr Hgoj` frem _djhgojb Tjovdrsoty `t Sdopojb te tgd
H`jtej Hgrosto`j Henndbd oj tgd iddp Xeutg `rd bovojb tgos pr`htoh`n
breujiwerl tei`y oj dxhdnndjt f`sgoej*
@jetgdr beei tgojb wgohg tgd mossoej`rods ioi eut oj Hgoj` `t tgd
st`rt ef tgos idh`id w`s te dnomoj`td 'se f`r `s tgd Hgojdsd `rd hej-
hdrjdi/ tgd ojhemprdgdjsoand idjemoj`toejs tgreubg wgohg tgd Ehho-
idjt`n werni vodws Bei* Ygd sompnd-mojidi aut neboh`n Hgojdsd f`ondi
te br`sp wgy. wgdj wd wersgoppdi aut ejd Gd`vdjny F`tgdr. wd `nse
must g`vd H`tgenohs `ji Sretdst`jts* Er wgy tgdsd. tee. `rd iovoidi
`ji sua-iovoidi nold ` rd`n dst`td idvdnepmdjt tgd Mdtgeiosts 'Jertg
`ji Xeutg/. tgd A`ptosts. tgd Hgrosto`js. tgd Nutgdr`js. Srdsaytdro`js.
`ji se ej* Ygd idjemoj`toejs ef tgd Sretdst`jt Hgurhg ioi `w`y
wotg hrddis `ji iovosoej`n a`rrodrs oj 0?12. `aeut tgd tomd tg`t Bdj-
dr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl w`s bdttojb m`rrodi `hheriojb te tgd wdiiojb
rotu`n ef tgd Mdtgeiost Dposhep`n Hgurhg 'Xeutg/ te ` idveut Mdtgei-
ost Hgurhg 'Xeutg/ Hgojdsd bornoj Xg`jbg`o* Ygd H`tgenohs stonn `rd
iovoidi ojte Brddl Ertgeiex. Qem`j. dth*
Ygos O tgojl os ` beei pn`hd te rdvodw tgd mossoej`ry `htovotods `s
tgdy ehhurrdi oj Hgoj` `t tg`t tomd*
@t G`jlew oj M`y ef 0?12. Aosgep N* G* Qeets. gd`i ef tgd
@mdroh`j Hgurhg Mossoej. wge g`i rdfusdi te dv`hu`td idspotd Hej-
sun-Bdjdr`n Fr`jl Nehlg`rt"s urbdjt rdqudst. teni md gd adnodvdi tg`t
ejd rdsunt ef tgd hrosos weuni ad tgd djtord rderb`joz`toej ef mossoej-
`ry werl tgdrd* Aosgep Qeets `ivosdi gos Hgurhg te sdji ` hemmos-
soej te Hgoj` te ojvdstob`td hejiotoejs `ji idhoid ej tgd adst stdps te
t`ld oj vodw ef tgd rdvenutoej`ry `htovotods wgohg g`i tdmper`rony
eustdi Hgrosto`j mdj `ji wemdj frem Hgoj`*
Ygd Aosgep rdhdovdi md oj gos effohds oj `j eni rdi arohl auoniojb
jd`r tgd Auji. `ji herio`nny wdnhemdi fr`jl ioshussoej ef hurrdjt
preandms hejjdhtdi wotg gos werl* Gd `imottdi tg`t `ivdrsd hejio-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 177/455
HGQOXY EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I 022
toejs wdrd `ffdhtojb tgd djtord futurd ef Hgrosto`joty oj @so` `ji
t`nldi d`rjdstny ej tgos suakdht*
Aosgep Qeets rdspejidi semdwg`t sg`rpny te
myqudry `s te gos
rd`sejs fer rdfusojb te idp`rt frem tgd i`jbdreus _`jbtzd Qovdr
sgerds* Gd s`oi; O adnodvd tg`t my werl os `s ompert`jt `s tg`t ef
tgrdd sherd ausojdss mdj rdm`ojojb gdrd jew er `s yeurs. fer tg`t
m`ttdr* Rgy sgeuni O idsdrt ujton ferhdi te ie se. `jy merd tg`j
tgdsd ausojdss mdj sgeuni nd`vd tgd kea er `jyejd dnsd stonn gdrd5
Ygd Aosgep s`oi tg`t ejny feur ferdobjdrs tgdj rdm`ojdi oj gos
mossoej. ieojb werl fermdrny iejd ay ejd gujirdi mossoej`rods* Ygdy
wdrd gomsdnf. Y*K* Genn`jidr. Ir S`un R`ldfodni `ji Kegj Nottdnn*
Oj tgos hrosos O foji wd `rd ioshevdrojb tgd trud v`nud ef eur
Hgojdsd Hgrosto`js. tgd Aosgep s`oi* Ygdy `rd h`rryojb ej tgd werl
wgohg wd g`vd adbuj* Eur gespot`n. ujovdrsoty `ji moiind shgeen `rd
stonn rujjojb gdrd. ujidr tgd iordhtoej ef tgd Hgojdsd ejny* Rd `rd
stonn suppertojb eur ojstotutoejs tgd s`md `s adferd. `ji tgdy rdprdsdjt
`j ojvdstmdjt ef `t nd`st ` monnoej ienn`rs. beni. `ji pessoany merd*
Eur `jju`n m`ojtdj`jhd hest rujs `pprexom`tdny )933.333. Mdx* Ygd
Hgojdsd `rd oj hempndtd hejtren*
O `m uj`and te s`y ydt wg`t eur pesotoej wonn ad oj tgd futurd.
aut O `m ojhnojdi te adnodvd tg`t tgos tdst ef tgd Hgojdsd Hgrosto`js os
` beei tgojb* Rgdtgdr wd wonn jddi `s m`jy ferdobjdrs oj tgd futurd
rdm`ojs te ad sddj* Sdrsej`nny. O tgojl wd wonn ad ferhdi te rderb`j-
ozd eur djtord mossoej werl ej ` jdw a`sos. nd`vojb tgd Hgojdsd Hgros-
to`js dssdjto`nny oj hejtren* Ygd pesotoej ef tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt
os `jetgdr hejsoidr`toej* Ygdy g`vd idjodi adojb `jto-rdnoboeus er
`jto-Hgrosto`j. aut jumdreus h`mp`objs `b`ojst Hgrosto`joty g`vd addj
gdni oj rdhdjt mejtgs wotg tgdor hejsdjt* Eur rdn`toejs wotg tgd bev-
drjmdjt must ad rdhejsoidrdi* Ygd eni trd`tods wgond jemoj`nny stonn
oj ferhd `htu`nny `rd jet* Rd must tgdrdferd idtdrmojd eur st`tus wotg
tgd J`toej`nosts of tgdy `rd vohteroeus. `s sddms prea`and*
Ygd Hgojdsd tei`y `rd jet nold tgd Hgojdsd ef tgorty yd`rs `be*
Ygdy `rd `reusdi jew* Ef heursd. ejny ` fdw `htu`nny `rd `rtohun`td
`ji ot os tgdsd tg`t wd gd`r `ji sdd tgd mest. aut tgd m`ssds `nse `rd
hg`jbdi* O g`vd `ivosdi eur Mossoej te w`ot ujton tgdsd rdvenutoej`ry
hejiotoejs hnd`r up adferd idhoiojb ej ` idfojotd penohy oj Hgoj`* Ygdy
`rd sdjiojb ` hemmossoej te Hgoj` te `ssost tgd mossoej`rods `nrd`iy
gdrd `ji te `brdd ej futurd pn`js* Oj tgd md`jtomd. wd g`vd dv`hu-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 178/455
027 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`tdi `nmest `nn eur st`toejs oj tgd _`jbtzd V`nndy* Eur mossoej
werldrs `rd rdm`ojojb hgodfny `t Xg`jbg`o tdmper`rony. pdjiojb ` id-
hosoej ej gew te
prehddiwotg eur werl*
O adnodvd tg`t sdjtomdjt `mejb tgd J`toej`nosts f`vers rdnoboeus
frddiem oj Hgoj` `s ` wgend* Bdjdr`n Y`jb Xgdj-tsd oj hg`rbd gdrd
os ` Auiigost. etgdrs oj `utgeroty `rd Hejfuho`js. `ji se ej< Bdjdr`n
Y`jb sdjt ` ndttdr te us rdhdjtny wrottdj ej p`pdr ad`rojb ` w`tdrm`rl
sgewojb `j eni Auiigost s`yojb. Mest mdrhofun hemp`ssoej`td ejd wge
s`vds ojiovoiu`ns `ji s`vds tgd werni* O adnodvd tg`t tgd bevdrjmdjt
wonn m`ld semdprevosoej
ferrdnoboeus
frddiem dvdjtu`nny. oj ` ferm`n
w`y* Ygos prdsdjt w`r gystdro` h`jjet n`st ferdvdr*
Aosgep Qeets s`oi tg`t Guj`j Srevojhd w`s tgd werst spet oj
Hgoj` `s f`r `s mossoej`ry werl w`s hejhdrjdi `ji tg`t `nn tgd fer-
dobjdrs tgdrd seutg ef G`jlew g`i addj dv`hu`tdi* Gd s`oi tg`t tgd
Hgojdsd Hgrosto`js wge wdrd ndft tgdj wdrd uj`and te hejtojud wotg
tgdor rdnoboeus werl `ji je sdrvohds ef `jy loji wdrd adojb gdni* Gos
mossoej tgdrd w`s hnesdi `s wdrd
m`jyef tgd etgdrs* Xdvdr`n wdrd
hejfosh`tdi ay tgd Hgojdsd Hemmujosts*
Ygd Tjoejs ef tgd pd`s`jts `rd hgodfny rdspejsoand fer tgdsd `hts%"
Aosgep Qeets s`oi*9f
Ygd sotu`toej tgdrd os aeridrojb ej `j`rhgy*
Hemmujosm os tee beei ` tdrm fer ot* Mea rund dxosts oj Guj`j.
wgdrd tgdy jew g`vd ` rund ef tgd ujruny* @nn mossoejs `rd hnesdi
`ji. `s O s`y. hgurhg sdrvohds `rd jet pessoand `t tgd memdjt*
Aosgep Qeets ojtom`tdi tg`t gd `ji tgd etgdr mossoej`rods weunit`ld up tgd djtord qudstoej dvdjtu`nny wotg tgd J`jlojb rdvenutoej`ry
`utgerotods. of `ji wgdj tgd bevdrjmdjt w`s `and te bovd `ttdjtoej te
preandms hejhdrjojb ojtdrj`n erb`joz`toej ef tgd hejtojdjt*
Iossdjsoej oj tgd g`rrodi r`jls ef @mdroh`j mossoej`rods areld eut
oj Xg`jbg`o tg`t summdr* Xg`jbg`o w`s tgd rdnoboeus h`pot`n fer `
tomd. wgdrd werldrs frem sh`ttdrdi ojtdroer pests wdrd hejbrdb`tdi
`w`otojb tgd ieuatfun futurd ef Hgrosto`joty oj tg`t n`ji* @ breup ef
Fuji`mdjt`nosts gdni ` mddtojb `ji `ftdraottdrny idjeujhojb tgd
Meidrjosts oj tgd mossoej fodni sdt tgdor sobj`turds te ` mdss`bd wgohg
w`s sdjt te v`roeus hgurhg erb`joz`toejs `ji jdwsp`pdrs oj @mdroh`*
Ygd Fuji`mdjt`nosts h`rrodi tgd fobgt `b`ojst tgdor aottdr feds. tgd
Meidrjosts. te tgd @mdroh`j puanoh. `ji tgdor mdss`bd idfojotdny
seubgt te ojfnudjhd hgurhg nd`idrs a`hl gemd* Ygd mdss`bd `ssdrtdi ;
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 179/455
HGQOXY EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I+" 02?
Ygd prdsdjt dv`hu`toej ef tgd mossoej`rods g`s addj pdrmottdi ay Bei
`s ` md`js ef purofyojb tgd mossoej`ry djtdrprosd oj Hgoj`*
Ygd Meidrjosts wdrd iuaadi dhhndso`stoh`n Aensgdvosts. tgd `tt`hl
adojb p`rtohun`rny aottdr `b`ojst tgd J`toej`n Hgrosto`j Heujhon* Ygd
Qdv* Ir* Gubg R* Rgotd ef tgd Xeutgdrj Srdsaytdro`j Mossoej. wge
prdsoidi. adn`aerdi gos Meidrjost hennd`buds oj tgd fennewojb votroenoh
f`sgoej oj gos `iirdss; X`t`j"s `i`pt`toej ef Kdrus`ndm Hgrosto`joty
g`s put ojte tgd nd`i ef tgd Meidrjost mevdmdjt ` a`ji ef dhhndso`s-
toh`n Aensgdvosts wge werl ej tgd projhopnd ef "aerojb frem wotgoj%
fddiojb ej Hgrosto`joty te idstrey ot* Meidrjosm os prom`rony penotoh`n
`ji os `omdi `t eur Hgrosto`j werls bevdrjmdjt. `s wdnn `s tgd ojsto-
tutoej ef m`rro`bd ej wgohg tgd Hgrosto`j seho`n systdm os a`sdi*
Ygd mdss`bd te @mdroh` idjeujhdi tgd J`toej`n Hgrosto`j Heujhon
`s ` idstruhtovd `bdjhy `ji idm`jidi tg`t wgdj mossoej`rods `b`oj
rdturjdi te Hgoj` tgdy ad sdjt te hejiuht wg`t tgd Fuji`mdjt`nosts
tdrmdi ertgeiex werl*
Ygd Qdv* D* D* Xtretgdr. Xdhrdt`ry ef tgd Hgrosto`j Djid`ver
Tjoej. s`oi; Rd `rd f`hojb ` tgereubgny erb`jozdi Meidrjosts" m`-
hgojd wgohg os nold ` brd`t `rmy ruj ay wdnn tr`ojdi effohdrs `ji `
m`rvdneus ojtdnnobdjhd idp`rtmdjt wotg sdhrdt heids. wordndss hemmu-
joh`toejs `ji wdnn dquoppdi tr`ojojb h`mps* Ygos `rmy g`s ` v`st
jumadr ef seniodrs wonnojb te fennew anojiny tgdor ewj trustdi nd`idrs.
dvdj te id`tg* Ygos pewdrfun `rmy os noadr`nny foj`jhdi `ji sdhrdtny
`nnodi wotg etgdr brd`t suavdrsovd erb`joz`toejs wotg `auji`jt fujis*
Ygdor prep`b`jiosts `rd semd ef tgd mest hndvdr mdj oj tgd werni.
`ji ay tgdor str`tdby tgdy g`vd suhhddidi oj punnojb tgd ween evdr
tgd dyds ef ` jumadr ef pdepnd oj n`rbd heujtrods*
Xtretgdr b`vd ` summ`ry ef tgd ioffdrdjhds adtwddj tgd Meidrj-
ost `ji Fuji`mdjt`nost adnodfs. `tt`hlojb dvenutoej `ji quetojb tgd
n`td Ronno`m Kdjjojbs Ary`j* Fddnojbs oj tgos aottdr fobgt rd`hgdi `
hnom`x oj Xg`jbg`o. wgohg os tgd jdrvd hdjtdr ef `nn Hgoj` fer tgd
mossoej`rods*
Ygdsd squ`aands iurojb ` tomd wgdj mossoej`ry preandms wdrd
ehhupyojb ` premojdjt pn`hd oj tgd `htovotods ef ferdobjdrs bdjdr`nny
h`usdi je nottnd `ivdrsd hemmdjt tgdrd* @mejb tgd sobjofoh`jt puanoh
rdm`rls w`s ` nd`iojb `rtohnd projtdi oj tgd Xg`jbg`o Yomds. ` noadr`n
Arotosg-ewjdi i`ony diotdi ay `j @mdroh`j* Ygd `rtohnd b`vd foburds
sgewojb tgdrd wdrd ejny `aeut fovd gujirdi mossoej`rods rdm`ojojb oj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 180/455
073 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgd ojtdroer st`toejs `s hemp`rdi wotg dobgt tgeus`ji oj jerm`n tomds*
Fovd tgeus`ji g`i addj rdturjdi te tgdor gemdn`jis dotgdr ej furneubg
er ej spdho`n nd`vds ef `asdjhd<foftddj gujirdi wdrd oj Xg`jbg`o. `ji
`jetgdr tgeus`ji wdrd tdmper`rony tr`jsfdrrdi te st`toejs oj K`p`j
`ji Lerd`*
Ygd diotero`n hemmdjtdi ; Ot os jet tee muhg te s`y tg`t tgd hnehl
ef mossoej`ry prebrdss oj Hgoj` g`s addj sdt a`hl m`jy bdjdr`toejs*
Ot `iidi. gewdvdr. Hejiotoejs `rd aeuji te omprevd. `t nd`st `s f`r
`s tgd mossoej`rods `rd hejhdrjdi. ojsef`r `s Hgoj` wonn hejtojud te
jddi fer m`jy yd`rs te hemd tgdor gd`nojb ojstotutoejs suhg `s gespo-
t`ns. shgeens. `ji etgdr suhg erb`joz`toejs wgohg be tew`ri auoniojb
` merd s`jd `ji n`stojb st`td ef sehodty*
Ygd diotero`n. `ftdr eutnojojb tgd pr`htoh`n adjdfots adojb b`ojdi
tgreubg Hgrosto`j Ojstotutoejs wgohg `rd dssdjto`n te tgd m`tdro`n
wdnf`rd ef tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds `ppd`ndi fer tgd rdturj ef tgd mossoej-
`rods oj brd`tdr jumadrs* Gewdvdr. wgond pr`osojb tgd wdnf`rd werl
ef tgd v`roeus mossoejs. ot gepdi tg`t wgdj ferdobj mossoej`rods ioi
rdturj tgdy weuni ad tgesd wgesd dyds g`vd jet addj iommdi ay
penotoh`n hejsoidr`toejs er ay tgd br`voty ef tgdor ewj iondmm`s*
+ + +
Of yeu wdrd te t`ld ` tr`oj `t tgd Jertg Xt`toej oj Xg`jbg`o ej
tgd J`jlojb nojd `ji tr`vdn tgd fofty-tgrdd monds tg`t sdp`r`td tgd
pohturdsqud eni w`nndi hoty ef Xeehgew frem tgd sd`. yeu mobgt foji
f`r ej tgd eutslorts. `ppre`hgdi tgreubg tgd j`rrewdst ef wojiojb
sgep-p`hldi n`jds. ` meidrj @mdroh`j ujovdrsoty* _eu weuni jddi
` buoid te foji ot tgd forst tomd ujndss yeu heuni dxpn`oj te ` rohlsg`w
heenod wgdrd yeu w`jtdi te be fer mest ef tgdm ljew tgos mossoej`ry
shgeen `ji tgd J`jhds%"
Ygd J`jhds g`vd addj novojb oj Xeehgew fer tgd p`st qu`rtdr hdj-
tury er merd `ji dvdryaeiy tgdrd ljews wge tgdy `rd* Ygdy `rd
gespot`and fenl frem tgd seutg oj @mdroh` `ji tgdy wdrd sdjt eut te
Hgoj` wgdj tgdy wdrd yeujb te td`hg oj Xeehgew Tjovdrsoty* Ir*
R`ntdr Auhljdr J`jhd. ` j`tovd ef M`rsg`nn Heujty. Ydjj*. adh`md
Srdsoidjt ef tgd shgeen oj 0?11* Ygd ujovdrsoty os ` mejumdjt te
gos werl* Ot w`s feujidi `ji os suppertdi ay tgd Mdtgeiost Dpos-
hep`n Hgurhg 'Xeutg/*
Of Ir. J`jhd ojvotdi yeu te spdji ` wddl dji wotg tgdm `ji g`i
rohlsg`ws `w`otojb `t tgd st`toej yeu weuni jet jddi te werry `aeut
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 181/455
HGQOXY EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I+" 070
`jytgojb. fer gd os ` Xeehgew m`j. `s gd puts ot* _eu weuni prea-
`any nd`rj merd `aeut Xeehgew"s str`jbd gostery oj ` wddl dji tg`j
mest pdepnd weuni oj ` muhg nejbdr tomd* Furtgdrmerd. yeu weuni
ioshevdr tg`t Mrs* J`jhd os ` hg`rmojb gestdss wge g`s areubgt ` aot
ef tgd eni seutg ojte tgd gd`rt ef Hgoj`<`ji tg`t gdr heel. wgem sgd
t`ubgt dvdrytgojb gd ljews. os ` hempesdr ef sympgejods oj Xeutgdrj
idnoh`hods*
Ejd wddl dji oj tgd n`td summdr ef 0?12. Ir* J`jhd sgewdi md
Xeehgew"s tdmpnds. ` f`meus b`ridj `ji tgd Xeehgew p`bei`* Gd
w`s ` yeujbosg nottnd m`j idspotd gos yd`rs `ji gos sonvdry wgotd g`or.
`ji gos dyds sp`rlndi wotg pdrpdtu`n gumer adgoji romndss bn`ssds*
Gd w`s tordndss oj hejiuhtojb eur teur ef Xeehgew. `ji gd w`s forst
te tgd tep wgdj wd sh`ndi tgd p`bei`"s iozzy gdobgt* Xt`jiojb ej ots
j`rrew tepmest a`nhejy wd b`zdi eut evdr Xeehgew a`aanojb oj tgd
iusl `t eur fddt. ots tondi reefs `ji nottnd wgotdw`sgdi auoniojbs. typo-
h`nny Hgojdsd. spnethgojb tgd shr`bbny n`jish`pd fer monds `reuji* Oj
tgd iost`jhd. tgd an`hl w`nn md`jidrdi pretdhtojbny `reuji tgd geusds*
Xeehgew. ` hoty ef `aeut ` monnoej. nods hgodfny wotgoj tgos w`nn. wgohg
os merd tg`j tdj monds oj horhumfdrdjhd*
@ tdmpnd `ik`hdjttgd eni Xeehgew p`bei`. idstreydi `t semd
tomd er etgdr iurojb tgd w`rs tg`t swddp evdr tgos `rd` `nn tee frd-
qudjtny. w`s ujidr hejstruhtoej* Rotgoj. ejd feuji beis oj tgd m`lojb.
sturiy werlmdj djdrbdtoh`nny gdwojb brd`t Auiig`s frem nejb nebs
`ji `rtos`js slonndi oj tgdor n`aer ausony f`sgoejojb tgd `rms. aeiods
`ji stdrj. pdjsovd f`hds ef tgdsd oiens te wgem tgdy `ji etgdrs seej
weuni pr`y*
Xeehgew g`s hg`jbdi nottnd sojhd tgd Moiind @bds* Ot os. oj tgos.
nold mest ef Hgoj`"s hotods* Idstreydi frem tomd te tomd ay w`r er
ford er f`mojd er semd etgdr j`tur`n ios`stdr. tgd hoty os rdauont `ji
tgd survovers h`rry ej* Frem eur p`bei`. wd heuni sdd ej `nn soids
huroeus meujis evdrbrewj wotg br`ss wgohg Ir* J`jhd dxpn`ojdi
wdrd tgd gd`ps ojte wgohg tgd hg`rrdi `sgds ef Xeehgew wdrd r`ldi
ay tgd survovers `ftdr tgd hoty w`s n`oi w`std oj tgd Y`opojb Qdadnnoej
ef tgd n`st hdjtury* Xemd ef tgdsd meujis `rd tgorty er ferty fddt
gobg. neemojb up `aevd tgd geusds reuji `aeut* Nottnd of `jytgojb ef
v`nud os. tgdy s`y. aurodi wotgoj* Jetgojb aut arohls `ji stejds.
hg`rrdi r`ftdrs `ji tgd nold g`vd dvdr addj ioshevdrdi ay tgesd wotg
djtdrprosd `ji huroesoty djeubg te iob ojte tgdm*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 182/455
071 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Rotg Mrs* J`jhd. wd vosotdi tgd sgeps `ji aeubgt huroes podhds
ef overy `ji f`js* @ji oj ` tdmpnd wd feuji yeujb mejls tr`hojb
`jhodjt shrenns.
rdpreiuhojbtgd
strolojb pohturds
ir`wj ay prodsts
wgdj Hgoj` w`s hrd`tojb `rt* Ygd tr`hojbs m`y ad aeubgt fer ` pot-
t`jhd. `ji wd `iidi sdvdr`n te eur henndhtoej ef tgojbs Hgojdsd*
@t jobgt `ftdr iojjdr eur p`rty strenndi `aeut tgd h`mpus oj tgd
meejnobgt `ji Mrs* J`jhd sgewdi us gdr b`ridj ef m`jy fnewdrs.
ojhnuiojb ` rdm`rl`and iospn`y ef hgrys`jtgdmums* Ygd h`mpus qu`i-
r`jbnd os `s typoh`n `j @mdroh`j h`mpus `s ejd mobgt foji oj ` sm`nn
henndbdtewj
`jywgdrdoj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. ots
auoniojbs tgereubgnymeidrj* Ygd ujovdrsoty g`s ots ewj nobgt `ji pewdr systdm* Y`nn
sg`id trdds ferm `j `rhgw`y `nejb tgd are`i w`nl tg`t aeujis tgd
h`mpus* Dvdrytgojb `aeut tgd ujovdrsoty rdh`nns ots @mdroh`j heujtdr-
p`rt* @nejb tgd h`mpus dibd tgd Xeehgew me`t rujs. aeujidi ej ots
f`r soid ay tgd hoty"s w`nn* Ygd hejtr`st os pewdrfun*
Ir* J`jhd teni ef tgd hg`jbds tg`t wdrd t`lojb pn`hd oj tgd ujovdr-
sotyujidr jdw
rdbun`toejs bevdrjojbsuhg ojstotutoejs* Ygd J`toej`n-
ost J`jlojb Bevdrjmdjt g`i eridrdi tg`t `nn ferdobj shgeens must
ad rdbostdrdi wotg tgd Bevdrjmdjt `ji tg`t jejd aut ` Hgojdsd m`y
ad tgd gd`i ef ` shgeen oj Hgoj`* @ ae`ri ef hejtren ef foftddj mdm-
adrs. dobgt ef wgem `rd Hgojdsd. w`s j`mdi* @ Hgojdsd w`s hgesdj
`s Srdsoidjt te suhhddi Ir* J`jhd* Ygd jdw gd`i ef tgd shgeen w`s
`j `numjus ef tgd ujovdrsoty. Sref* _* H _`jb* Ir* J`jhd hejtojudi
oj gos jdw h`p`hoty `s tgd se-h`nndi @mdroh`j @ivosdr*
Rotg tgdsd hg`jbds. suakdht te tgd pdrm`jdjt `pprev`n ef tgd
Ae`ri ef Mossoejs. Xeehgew Tjovdrsoty hejtojudi te epdr`td. `ji `n-
rd`iy g`i epdjdi ots f`nn sdmdstdr tg`t @ubust wotg `j djrennmdjt
`ppre`hgojb jerm`n. tgdrd adojb 070 henndbd stuidjts `ji 198 oj tgd
prdp`r`tery shgeen* Ygd hg`jbds wdrd jet rdvenutoej`ry. adh`usd Ir*
J`jhd `s `ivosdr hejtojudi `s vortu`n gd`i ef tgd shgeen*
Ojhdptoejef ` mevdmdjt
sddlojbte `aenosg `nn
sdht`ro`j nojds oj
ferdobj mossoej werl oj Hgoj` rdsuntdi. oj Xg`jbg`o oj Ehteadr 0?12.
oj ` hejfdrdjhd `mejb jojdty-feur Hgojdsd idndb`tds frem `nn p`rts ef
tgd hejtojdjt* Ygdsd idndb`tds. rdprdsdjtojb soxtddj idjemoj`toejs.
vetdi te iossenvd tgdor eni st`tus `ji erb`jozd tgd Hgurhg ef Hgrost oj
Hgoj`* Ygdor idhosoej wretd fojos te tgd werl ef tgd Srdsaytdro`j.
Hejbrdb`toej`n `ji etgdr idjemoj`toej`n ojstotutoejs `s suhg. `nn nesojb
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 183/455
HGQOXY EF YGD HGOJ@ QE@I 078
tgdor oidjtoty oj tgd jdw jej-sdht`ro`j erb`joz`toej* Ygd mevd. O
adnodvd. g`i tgd funn suppert ef tgd gemd effohds ef tgesd mossoejs oj
tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds `ji Brd`t Arot`oj*
Ygd Qdv* Ir* D* H* Neadjstmd. Srdsaytdro`j nd`idr wge g`i kust
rdturjdi frem tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. teni md tg`t gos erb`joz`toej w`s
vortu`nny spejserojb suhg ` stdp* Ygos `htoej. nejb `jtohop`tdi. hrys-
t`nnozdi dfferts te dst`anosg `j djtordny Hgojdsd Hgrosto`j Hgurhg wotg
`ffono`toejs `are`i aut jet hejtrenndi oj futurd ay `jy ejd jet Hgojdsd*
Jdvdrtgdndss. tgd mevdmdjt hejtojudi te rdhdovd ferdobj suppert
foj`jho`nny `s wdnn `s tgd `ssost`jhd ef ferdobj mossoej`ry `ivosdrs*
Ygd ferdobjdrs wge g`i addj hejiuhtojb tgd mossoej`ry werl ujton
tgdj idhn`rdi tg`t tgdor dnomoj`toej `s tgd hejtrennojb gd`is ef tgd
v`roeus mossoejs g`i nejb addj dxpdhtdi `ji f`verdi* M`jy ef tgdsd
s`oi tg`t tgdy f`verdi g`vojb tgd Hgojdsd `imojostdr tgdor ewj Hgros-
to`j ojstotutoejs. `ji tgd seejdr tgd adttdr* Ygd A`ptosts `ji tgd fdw
Mdtgeiosts wge `ttdjidi tgd hejfdrdjhd ojsostdi tg`t tgdy wdrd prdsdjt
mdrdny `s easdrvdrs. `ji tg`t tgdor idjemoj`toejs wdrd jet ydt funny
prdp`rdi te mdrbd wotg tgd etgdrs ojte tgd jdw `ji ujofodi `sseho`-
toej oj tgd Erodjt*
M`jy mossoej`rods. gewdvdr. peojtdi eut tg`t `iv`jt`bds ef tgd
jej-sdht`ro`j erb`joz`toej ojhnuidi tgd rdmev`n ef tgd v`rodi idjemo-
j`toej`n td`hgojbs wgohg g`i `nw`ys addj mystofyojb te tgd Hgojdsd
wgem tgdy seubgt te hejvdrt* Ygd hejfdrdjhds ojvenvdi merd tg`j
0.333 hgurhgds oj 06 prevojhds oj Hgoj`. rdprdsdjtojb `pprexom`tdny
ejd-tgori ef tgd Sretdst`jt mossoej`rods tgdrd* Ygdsd adh`md `i-
vosdrs. aut tgd he`notoej md`jt nottnd ir`stoh hg`jbd ommdio`tdny dxhdpt
oj tgdor totnds* @ Hgojdsd Meidr`ter. tgd Qdv* Mr* Hg`jb Hgdjb-yo.
w`s dndhtdi ay tgd idndb`tds*
Ygd hejfdrdjhd ossudi ` summ`ry ef ots werl. s`yojb ; Ygd hgurhg
`t prdsdjt stonn jddis ferdobj `oi+ Aut tgd mdmadrs sgeuni ujidrt`ld
tgd rdspejsoaonotyef iosmossojb idjemoj`toej`nosm `ji hrdi`n strofd
`ji sdt je nomots te tgd `htovoty ef tgd sporot ef Bei oj tgd woid
spgdrd ef gum`j `htovoty* Ot os jet tg`t tgd hgurhg sgeuni djtdr
penotohs.aut ojiovoiu`ns oj ot must f`hd tgdsd jdw rdspejsoaonotods* Fer-
dobjdrs `rd urbdi te ad p`todjt `ji te hejtojud wotg dvdj brd`tdr
djdrby oj tgdor werl*
Yg`t Idhdmadr `jetgdr breup ef ferdobj mossoej ojstotutoejs keojdi
tgd jdw Hgurhg ef Hgrost oj Hgoj`* Ir* Neadjstojd. Xdhrdt`ry ef tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 184/455
079 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
J`toej`n Hgurhg Heujhon oj Hgoj`. `jjeujhdi tg`t tgd Djbnosg A`ptost
Mossoej oj Xg`jtujb Srevojhd g`i vetdi tekeoj
tgd jdw jej-sdht`ro`j
Hgojdsd Hgrosto`j Hgurhg*
Ygd `jjeujhdmdjt s`oi; Ygos os tgd forst h`sd oj tgd gostery ef
tgd hgurhg wgdrd ` breup ef A`ptost hgurhgds g`s ferm`nny ujotdi wotg
tgd Hejbrdb`toej`n. Srdsaytdro`j `ji Qdferm Hgurhgds* @ fdw yd`rs
`be oj H`j`i` tgd Mdtgeiost Hgurhg keojdi wotg tgd Hejbrdb`toej`n.
osts `ji tgd Srdsaytdro`js. `ji tgd Tjotdi Hgurhg ef H`j`i` Mossoej
oj Hgoj` os jew keojojb wotg eur Hgurhg ef Hgrost. tgus hemaojojb
oj tgos ejd hgurhg tgd Hejbrdb`toej`nosts. Srdsaytdro`j `ji tgesd wge
wdrd fermdrny Mdtgeiosts `ji A`ptosts*
Ygd `jjeujhdmdjt `nse peojtdi eut tg`t tgd Xg`jtujb A`ptosts
`rd ` ar`jhg ef tgd Djbnosg Hgurhg `ji sgeuni jet ad hejfusdi wotg
tgd Xeutgdrj A`ptost Mossoej frem tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds* O nd`rjdi.
gewdvdr. tg`t tgd @mdroh`j Jertgdrj A`ptosts g`i `ppeojtdi ` hem-
mottdd te hejfdr wotg tgd Hgojdsd hejhdrjojb tgdor keojojb tgd jdw
`ji ujofodi hgurhg* Mdmadrs s`oi tg`t foj`n `htoej w`s tgdj n`rbdny
idpdjidjt upej tgd gd`i effohds ef tgdor idjemoj`toejs `t gemd* Ygd
H`j`io`j Mdtgeiosts oj Xzdhgu`j Srevojhd wdrd hejsoidrojb ` somon`r
mevd*
Ygd mevdmdjt g`s tgd suppert ef tgd m`keroty ef ferdobj mossoej-
`rods ej tgd fodni ef a`ttnd oj @so`* Ygd Hgojdsd Hgrosto`j nd`idrs stonn
dmpg`sozd tgd f`ht tg`t tgdy g`vd je idsord tespnot wotg tgd wdstdrj
Hgrosto`js. aut mdrdny idsord te hemaojd tgdor m`jy ioshejhdrtojb
hrddis ojte ejd Hgrosto`j hgurhg iordhtdi ay Hgojdsd wge fer tgd tomd
adojb wonn g`vd jumdreus wdstdrj `ivosdrs*
Ygd `iiotoej ef etgdr ferdobj mossoejs w`s rdb`ridi `s `j ojioh`-
toej tg`t tgd j`toej-woid h`mp`obj fer ujoty `mejb tgd mossoej`rods
w`s r`poiny fruhtofyojb*
Xemd nottnd ojtdrdst w`s hrd`tdi ay tgd vosot ef @rhgaosgep Hej-
st`jtojo. rdprdsdjt`tovd ef Sepd Sous WO. wge wdjt te Hgoj` ej teur
d`rny oj 0?1? `ji w`s fdtdi ay tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt oj J`jlojb*
@rhgaosgep Hejst`jtojo h`nndieffoho`nny
ej Srdsoidjt Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl
`t J`jlojb `ji w`s `nse brddtdi ay etgdr gobg mdmadrs ef tgd Bev-
drjmdjt* Gd s`oi gd g`i hemd te hejvdy pdrsej`nny tgd beei wosgds
ef tgd Sepd*
@rhgaosgep Hejst`jtojo s`oi ef gos mossoej te Srdsoidjt Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl ;
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 185/455
HGQOXY EF YGD H G O J @ QE@O: 074
O iddm ot ` brd`t gejer te ad gdrd `s tgd rdprdsdjt`tovd ef Gos
Genojdss. Sepd Sous WO. tgd gobgdst `utgeroty ef tgd H`tgenoh F`otg
oj tgd werni* Rg`t gepd tgd Sepd djtdrt`ojs tew`ri Hgoj` g`s addj
st`tdi hnd`rny oj gos horhun`r tdndbr`m ef @ubust 0. 0?17* O `m gdrd
te hejvdy pdrsej`nny tgd wosgds ef tgd Sepd*
Ot os ` brd`t pnd`surd te sdd pd`hd rdsterdi `ji ujofoh`toej dffdhtdi
oj tgos heujtry* Ot os my sojhdrd gepd tg`t tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt
mobgt gd`i tew`ri tgd w`y ef rdferm `ji rdhejstruhtoej. tgus dst`a-
nosgojb tgd pdrm`jdjt feuji`toej ef tgd j`toej*
@ntgeubg H`tgenoh prodsts wge `rd jew prd`hgojb oj Hgoj` adnejb
te ioffdrdjt j`toej`notods. tgdor `om os ejd. tg`t os. te hejvdy te tgd
Hgojdsd m`ssds tgd Bespdn ef Hgrost wgohg os ejd ef fr`tdrj`n nevd `ji
dqu`noty* Ygd H`tgenoh rdnoboej ljews je j`toej`n er r`ho`n ioshromoj`-
toej `ji ot os ` rdnoboej upgeniojb tgd dqu`noty ef m`jloji*
Rd. `s prodsts. g`vd je ojtdjtoej ef ojtdrfdrojb oj tgd penotohs `ji
iopnem`hy ef `jy j`toej `ji eur `ttotuid os ejd ef `asenutd omp`r-
to`noty* Rd `rd rd`iy te effdr eur dvdry `ssost`jhd te jdwaerj Hgoj`
oj gdr jumdreus rdferms `ji t`sls ef rdhejstruhtoej* Rd pr`y fer
Bei"s andssojb upej tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd oj eridr te dj`and tgdm te
djkey pdrm`jdjt pd`hd `ji eridr* Rd `nse pr`y tg`t Hgoj` m`y ad
dst`anosgdi ej `j dqu`n feetojb wotg etgdr Sewdrs. tgus djsurojb pd`hd
oj tgd wgend werni*
Ygd mossoej`ry shdjd g`s hg`jbdi wotg tgd tomds. ef heursd* Ejd
dvoidjhd ef tgd ojiuhtoej ef Hgojdsd Hgrosto`js ojte sdrvohd fer tgd
f`otg ef eur f`tgdrs ehhurrdi jet nejb `be* O s`w ` arodf otdm `aeut
ot oj ` i`ony jdwsp`pdr oj Mo`mo. Fneroi`* Ygd iosp`thg w`s frem
V`toh`j Hoty `ji rdn`tdi gew Sepd Sous WO g`i sdt ` jdw prdhdidjt
fer tgd Geny Xdd wotg tgd ferm`n `ppeojtmdjt ef ` Hgojdsd H`tgenoh te
`j effohd gobg oj S`p`n horhnds* Ygd m`j w`s Mr* Ne S` Gejb. `
hotozdj ef semd wd`ntg oj Xg`jbg`o*
Gd w`s hrd`tdi tgd Sepd"s Srov`td V`ndt ef tgd Xweri `ji H`pd*
Ygd `hheujt ojioh`tdi tg`t tgos w`s tgd forst tomd tg`t ` jej-wgotd
g`s dvdr addj `hheridi tg`t gejer ay ` Sepd* Ot sddms tg`t Mr*
Gejb. `s tgd rdpert h`nndi gom. w`s Srdsoidjt ef tgd H`tgenoh @htoej
Xehodty ef Hgoj` `ji ` frdqudjt `ji n`rbd hejtroauter te tgd foj`j-
ho`n suppert ef tgd H`tgenoh mossoejs oj Hgoj`*
Aetg H`tgenoh `ji Sretdst`jt Hgojdsd `rd snewny mevojb merd `ji
merd ojte premojdjhd aut dvdj se. tgdor rdnoboeus fdrver os jet ydt
wg`t tgd mossoej`rods heuni wosg ot* Yg`t wonn rdquord muhg tomd.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 186/455
09 YGD M@QOJDX BDY BEOJB
YGDLuemojt`jb Qdvenutoej djbunfdi Sdlojb d`rny oj Kujd. 0?17*
Ygd `jhodjt h`pot`n fdnn ej Kujd 7 ef tg`t memdjteus yd`r* Ygd
K`p`jdsd `t ejhd adh`md sdroeus* Ygdy djtdrdi tgd pohturd ej
tgd @so`toh m`ojn`ji oj ` idtdrmojdi w`y. dspdho`nny `reuji Sdlojb
`ji Yodjtsoj `ji jertg ef tgd Brd`t R`nn oj tgd Ygrdd D`stdrj Srev-
.jhds ljewj `s M`jhguro`* Ygdy g`vd sojhd. `s `nn ljew. `jjdxdi
tgos p`rtohun`rfht
spgdrd ef ojfnudjhd `ji rdj`mdi ot M`jhgulue*
Ygd wddls ef Kujd wdrd hr`mmdi wotg dxhotdmdjt `ji dvdjts ef
gosteroh sobjofoh`jhd* Eni Sdlojb fdnn. tgeubg jet wotgeut ` jeand
strubbnd. `ji tgd Xeutgdrj ferhds rdpndjosgdi frem prevojhds `nn `nejb
tgd nejb trdl frem tgd Sd`rn Qovdr `t H`jtej keyeusny m`rhgdi ay
tgd tgeus`jis tgreubg tgesd stdrj eni b`tds. sw`rmojb dvdrywgdrd oj
prefusd djkeymdjt ef tgdor g`ri feubgt vohtery*
Ygd mdj wdrd g`ppy `t b`ojojb tgdor be`n. `ji ef neetojb er ef
prepdrty i`m`bd tgdrd w`s nottnd oj tgesd wojiojb eni `vdjuds se
str`jbd te tgd jdw a`tt`noejs notdr`nny frem `jetgdr heujtry oj tgd iddpseutg ef Hgoj`* Ferdobjdrs wdrd ujg`rmdi* Xemd wdrd snobgtny ios-
hemmeidi fer ` i`y er twe aut jejd. `s f`r `s O ljew. w`s ojkurdi
er nest `j `pprdho`and `meujt ef prepdrty. of `jy* @ji tg`t. oj tomd
ef w`r. os jet usu`n* Aut tgd treeps. vohteroeus `ji ojhnojdi te ad
r`mp`jt. wdrd b`y* G`rm te tgesd wge g`i rdm`ojdi w`s f`r frem
tgdor tgeubgts oj tgd wddl tg`t Sdlojb fdnn*
Eni M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj. tgd idfd`tdi w`r neri frem M`j-
hguro`. s`w tgd fobgt w`s v`oj* Gd fndi a`hl tew`ri gos ewj h`pot`nef Mulidj. `aevd tgd Brd`t R`nn ef tg`t Hgoj` wgohg tgd eni arob`jig`i gepdi te rund `s ydt `jetgdr M`jhgu dmpdrer ej tgd Ir`bejYgrejd oj Sdlojb* Aut M`rsg`n Hg`jb jdvdr novdi te sdd gos ewj
h`pot`n `b`oj. `ji tgdrd `rd m`jy wge stonn s`y ot w`s a`i kess 'onn
nuhl/ fer gom dvdr te g`vd ndft tgd pd`hdfun pn`ojs ef M`jhguro` wgdrd
gd w`s ioht`ter*
0X6
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 187/455
YGD M@QOJDX BDY BEOJB 072
Ygd he`hg ej wgohg tgd M`rsg`n w`s fnddojb tew`ri gemd w`s
mystdroeusny an`stdi te aots ej tgd eutslorts ef Mulidj kust `s tgd
tr`oj w`s `aeut te djtdr tgd hoty* M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj w`s lonndi.
`s ir`m`toh`nny `ji mystdroeusny `s gd g`i novdi te rosd frem a`jiot
oj M`jhguro` te tgd m`j wge weuni ad lojb evdr tgd Hgojdsd. tgdor
rundr `ji dmpdrer oj Sdlojb ` meidrj9f
Xej ef Gd`vdj*"+ Ojstd`i.
gd iodi* Ygd dxpnesoej w`s `t i`wj ej tgd merjojb ef Kujd 9*
Ygd ferdobj treeps oj Hgoj` adh`md ojtdrdstdi oj tgd r`poi idvdn-
epmdjts `reuji Sdlojb tg`t wddl< `ji se ioi O* Rgdj weri h`md
tg`t eni M`rsg`n Hg`jb g`i t`ldj ` prov`td tr`oj `ji fndi. wd rd`nozdi
tg`t tgojbs wdrd idhoidiny pohlojb up oj tgd jertg* @ji wgdj wd
gd`ri oj Xg`jbg`o. jd`rny 0333 monds te tgd seutg. tg`t oj gos fnobgt
frem Sdlojb tgd eni seniodr-arob`ji-ioht`ter g`i addj `ss`ssoj`tdi.
tgdrd w`s aut ejd tgojb fer md te ie* Nold tgd M`rojds `ji tgd J`vy.
O wdjt te tgd shdjd forst te Yodjtsoj `ji tgdj `hress Sdohgogno A`y
te M`jhguro`. n`jiojb oj tgd K`p`jdsd-ewjdi pert ef I`ordj jd`r Sert
@rtgur*
O bet `w`y ej ` hrewidi std`mdr `ji sndpt oj tgd noar`ry er ej
idhl hg`ors* Ot os fojd wd`tgdr oj d`rny Kujd `nejb tgd Hgoj` He`st*
Kust adferd wd ndft. O m`y dxpn`oj tgd jertgdrj irovd ay tgd Luemoj-
t`jb `rmods `nejb twe m`ker s`nodjts w`s rdsumdi tew`ri Sdlojb*
O `nse w`jt te strdss gdrd tgd `ttotuid ef eur ewj. tgd Arotosg `ji tgd
K`p`jdsd ferhds eut tgdrd `t tg`t ompert`jt kujhturd oj tgd rdvenutoej
Ygd pessoaonoty ef @mdroh`"s keojojb wotg tgd Arotosg oj sdjiojb
`t nd`st p`rt ef tgd treeps idfdjiojb Xg`jbg`o jertgw`ri w`s ojhrd`s-
ojb i`ony. `ji tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojds wdrd seej eridrdi te Yodjt-
soj* Ygd tgd`tdr ef tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej r`poiny sgoftdi jertg-
w`ri `ji aetg tgd Arotosg `ji tgd @mdroh`j j`v`n `ji monot`ry `utger-
otods wdrd ojhnojdi te vodw tgd sotu`toej oj tgd Sdlojb-Yodjtsoj `rd`
wotg gdobgtdjdi ojtdrdst of jet `htu`n `pprdgdjsoej fer tgd s`fdty ef
tgd m`jy ferdobjdrs hejhdjtr`tdi tgdrd*
Ygd Arotosg sdjt twe a`tt`noejs jertgw`ri* Ejd prehddidi te
tgdor jertgdrj a`sd `t tgd tewj ef Rdo-G`o-Rdo. `ji tgd sdheji wdjt
te Yodjtsoj* M`ker-Bdjdr`n Kegj Iujh`j. hgodf oj hemm`ji ef tgdor
ferhds oj Hgoj`. s`ondi fer Yodjtsoj `hhemp`jodi ay Vosheujt Bert. gos
hgodf-ef-st`ff. `ji `j `vo`toej rdhejj`os`jhd effohdr* Ygd i`jbdr oj
tgd jertg w`s adnodvdi te ad somon`r te tg`t wgohg g`i mdj`hdi Xg`jb-
g`o ` yd`r er se adferd. wgdj tgd rdvenutoej swdpt evdr tgd _`jbtzd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 188/455
077 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
V`nndy `ji djbunfdi tg`t hoty* @ n`rbd ferhd. tgdrdferd. w`s sdjt te
tgd Sdlojb-Yodjtsoj `rd`* Brd`t Arot`oj. `ji Tjotdi Xt`tds. Fr`jhd
`ji K`p`j heepdr`tdi oj tgos mevdmdjt ef treeps `ji m`rojds*
Oj tgdsd mevdmdjts tgd T* X* M`rojds sdjt ejd rdbomdjt te Yodj-
tsoj* Ot w`s tgd 6tg rdbomdjt. tgd mdj s`onojb ej ae`ri tgd tr`jspert
Gdjidrsej* Bdjdr`n Xmdindy Autndr. oj hemm`ji ef tgd T* X*
M`rojds oj Hgoj`. rdturjdi frem tgd jertg `ji `rr`jbdi idt`ons ef tgd
sgoft* @htojb Hejsun-Bdjdr`n Hn`rdjhd B`uss w`s tr`jsfdrrdi te Yodj-
tsoj oj moi-Kujd. fermdr Hejsun-Bdjdr`n Diwoj X* Hujjojbg`m. wge
g`i gdni tgd Xg`jbg`o pest fer yd`rs. rdturjojb frem ` nd`vd ef
`asdjhd*
@nse. sox Tjotdi Xt`tds idstreydrs wdrd hejhdjtr`tdi `t Hgdfee.
tgdor jertgdrj summdr a`sd adnew Yodjtsoj* Ygdsd ojhnuidi tgd T* X*
X* Gurnadrt. wgohg w`s `nrd`iy tgdrd. `ji fovd etgdrs* Ygdy wdrd tgd
f`meus T* X* X* Je`. wgohg fordi iurojb tgd J`jlojb Ojhoidjt merd
tg`j ` yd`r adferd< tgd S`un Kejds. tgd Srdand. tgd Srdstej `ji tgd
Sruott*
Ygd djtord eutneel ef tgd Hgojdsd rdvenutoej turjdi jertgw`ri. `s
` rdsunt ef eptomostoh rdperts frem aetg J`jlojb `ji G`jlew* Mdj
`t aetg rdvenutoej`ry hdjtdrs hn`omdi vohterods `nn `nejb tgd nojds ef
tgd twe reutds ef `tt`hl tew`ri Sdlojb. tgd be`n fer se m`jy yd`rs oj
tgos surbd tew`ri pewdr evdr `nn Hgoj`* Ejd nojd ef m`rhg w`s jertg
frem G`jlew `nejb tgd ojn`ji r`onre`i te Sdlojb; tgd etgdr w`s up
frem J`jlojb. tgreubg Xg`jtujb Srevojhd. `nejb tgd sd` he`st ojte
Yodjtsoj `ji tgdjhd te Sdlojb. ndss tg`j 033 monds `w`y* M`rsg`n
Fdjb _u-gso`jb"s irovd `reuji Hgdjbhgew oj tgd hdjtr`n-Hgoj` reutd.
w`s `pp`rdjtny prebrdssojb f`ver`any `ji tgd M`jhgu treeps rdoj-
ferhojb tgd Jertgdrjdrs wdrd aettndi up adyeji Lujb-gsodj ej tg`t
s`nodjt*
Ygd Luemojt`jb mdj `ppd`rdi `nse te g`vd aurodi tgd g`thgdt `t
n`st `ji te ad idtdrmojdi te be `gd`i wotg tgd a`ttnd fer Sdlojb wotg-
eut furtgdr ojtdrj`n squ`aands* J`jlojb `ji G`jlew sddmdi te ad
oj `hheri `s f`r `s tgd jertgdrj dxpdiotoej w`s hejhdrjdi*
@ prejeujhdmdjt w`s ossudi ay tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`j-
lojb sddlojb te hnd`r up ejhd `ji fer `nn tgd J`jlojb eutr`bds ef
tgd prdvoeus yd`r* Ygd Arotosg `utgerotods hejiuhtdi ujeffoho`n hej-
vdrs`toejs wotg tgdm `ji ` puanoh st`tdmdjt ej tg`t treuandsemd oj-
hoidjt oj tgd rdvenutoej w`s tgd rdsunt* @ sdttndmdjt. `t nd`st `s f`r
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 189/455
YGD M@QOJDX BDY BEOJB 07?
`s tgd Arotosg wdrd hejhdrjdi. w`s foj`nny `rr`jbdi* @ Xdttndmdjt
Hemmossoej ef Hgojdsd `ji ferdobjdrs w`s dvdjtu`nny `ppeojtdi te
`rr`jbd tgd h`sg p`ymdjts te ad m`id*
Ot w`s bdjdr`nny adnodvdi tgdj oj effoho`n horhnds oj Hgoj` tg`t tgd
rd`sej fer tgd hejhdjtr`toej ef ` n`rbd ferdobj idfdjsd ferhd oj er jd`r
Yodjtsoj w`s tgd pretdhtoej ef ferdobj novds `ji prepdrty oj tgd dvdjt
ef ` Jertgdrj treep ida`hnd* Ygd wgend mevd w`s `s muhg `b`ojst
i`jbdr frem Jertgdrj Hgojdsd treeps wge g`i te fndd. `s `b`ojst tgd
vohteroeus `ji `iv`jhojb Xeutgdrjdrs oj tgd Luemojt`jb @rmy*
Gobgojtdrdst
w`s dvojhdioj
Xg`jbg`oevdr
Srdsoidjt Heenoibd"s
`pprev`n ef tgd Xt`td Idp`rtmdjt"s pn`j oj 0?17 te rdmevd eur Ndb`-
toej frem Sdlojb te semd peojt ej tgd he`st. ieuatndss Yodjtsoj* Ygd
neh`n rd`htoej w`s v`rodi oj tgd dxtrdmd. gewdvdr. `ji O feuji tg`t
hdrt`oj @mdroh`js `s wdnn `s Arotosg wdrd ojhnojdi te hrotohozd wg`t
tgdy rdb`ridi `s ` furtgdr ojioh`toej ef R`sgojbtej"s rdfus`n te t`ld
` form st`ji fer tgd pretdhtoej ef @mdroh`j ojtdrdsts oj Hgoj`* Xtonn
etgdrs tdjidi te tgd vodw tg`t
R`sgojbtejw`s
dmojdjtnyherrdht. dvdj
ejd gobg Arotosg effoho`n `imottojb tg`t tgdrd sddmdi te ad vdry nottnd
usd oj m`ojt`ojojb tgd Ndb`toejs oj Sdlojb wgdj tgdrd w`s `pp`rdjtny
je dffert m`id ay tgd Hgojdsd oj pewdr tgdrd tew`ri tgd m`ojtdj`jhd
ef ` hovon ferm ef bevdrjmdjt*
Qd`r-@imor`n K* Q* _* An`ldny. oj hemm`ji ef eur nobgt hruosdr
squ`irej ej tgd Hgoj` he`st. s`ondi `ae`ri tgd hruosdr Qohgmeji. `ji
`s tgd
r`jlojbj`v`n effohdr w`s oj hemm`ji ef tgd j`v`n `ji m`rojd
ferhds `t Yodjtsoj* Qdperts pdrsostdi tg`t tgd Arotosg weuni sdji `t
nd`st feur a`tt`noejs jertg* Ygdor gd`iqu`rtdrs. gewdvdr. ojsostdi ejny
twe weuni ad iosp`thgdi* Ygos w`s iejd*
Md`jwgond. ` K`p`jdsd ferhd ef 1333 mdj `rrovdi `t tgd pert ef
Ysojbt`e oj Xg`jtujb Srevojhd* Qdperts ojioh`tdi tg`t fddnojb w`s
rujjojb gobg `b`ojst K`p`j"s rdturjojb te Xg`jtujb. `ji idmejstr`-
toejs
`mejbtgd Hgojdsd sgewdi ` rdjdwdi
pepun`r `jtop`tgytew`ri
tgos suiidj mevd*
Ygd ojtdroer sdhters `ppd`rdi quodt* Ejd iosp`thg frem G`jlew+.
gd`iqu`rtdrs fer tg`t s`nodjt. `ssdrtdi tg`t M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb
g`i rdpertdi gos h`pturd ef Ney`jb. wgohg sddmdi prea`and oj vodw ef
tgd stoff fobgtojb oj tg`t `rd` fer i`ys* @jetgdr tdndbr`m frem tgdrd
`ivosdi tg`t Hgojdsd Hemmujosts oj tgd tewjs ef Hg`jbsg`. Xojbt`j.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 190/455
0?3 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
_oy`jb. Sojb-lo`jb. Hg`jbtdg `ji Nojy`jb g`i addj eustdi ay tgd
H`jtejdsd treeps. wge tgdj prehddidi te ferm ujoejs*
Eur he`st`n p`hldt jesdi p`st Y`jblu A`r tgrdd i`ys `ftdr wd
ndft Xg`jbg`o. oj d`rny Kujd `ji wd todi up `nejbsoid Y`jblu. pert ef
Yodjtsoj semd dobgtddj monds iewj tgd G`o-ge Qovdr ej tgd sd` Ygdrd
w`s stonn hejsoidr`and fobgtojb beojb ej adtwddj tgd he`st `ji Yodjtsoj
`s tgd Luemojt`jb ferhds pusgdi ej `ftdr tgd r`poiny fnddojb Jertgdrj
treeps. wge wdrd nd`vojb oj ` iosporotdi reut* @s ` rdsunt. tgdrd w`s
je `pp`rdjt w`y te bdt up rovdr te Yodjtsoj. `ji ejhd tgdrd. tgdrd w`s
je w`y te bdt ej evdr te Sdlojb. `aeut jojdty monds furtgdr ojn`ji oj
wg`t w`s tgdj Hgogno Srevojhd. jew h`nndi Gepdo*@ yeujb Iuthgm`j. Qohg`ri Ardotdjstdoj. `ji O wdjt `sgerd te
rdhejjeotdr. tgdrd adojb jetgojb dnsd te ie Yr`oj sdrvohd `t tgd st`-
toej w`s iosgdi fer tgd memdjt jejd ljdw wgdj er of ` tr`oj weuni
ruj* Xemd Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojds wdrd iewj fer tgd m`on. gewdvdr.
`ji tgdy gd`ri ef eur pnobgt* Ejd teni md tg`t tgdrd w`s ` T* X*
M`rojd `vo`toej a`sd jd`ray. st`toejdi eppesotd tgd neh`n Xt`ji`ri Eon
pn`jt ej tgd sd`he`st*
Rotgeut idn`y wd w`nldi evdr tgdrd. ` sgert iost`jhd* Ygdrd wdrd
` iezdj er merd M`rojd `orpn`jds `t tg`t pest tgdj. `ji tgdy prevdi
` nofds`vdr* Rd `rr`jbdi te fny te Yodjtsoj ` fnobgt wgohg teel `aeut
twdjty mojutds. iordhtny `hress tgd hn`sgojb nojds forojb `t ejd `jetgdr
adnew* Rd fndw oj `j epdj sgop. semd 1.433 fddt up. `ji `ntgeubg wd
bet ` beei vodw ef tg`t sdhter oj `htoej. tgd M`rojd fnodr `ji O wdrd
gobg djeubg te ad eut ef bujsget r`jbd `ji pdrfdhtny s`fd* Rd s`w
` K`p`jdsd idstreydr oj tgd G`o-ge rdpnyojb te sgets frem tgd a`jls
Ygd pn`jd m`id `v`on`and te md w`s `j `mpgoao`j wgohg g`i te
be up te gd`iqu`rtdrs `jyw`y. `ji O w`s oj nuhl* Rd teel eff frem
tgd G`o-ge 'ge md`js rovdr oj Jertg Hgoj`/ `t Y`jblu `ji ndss
tg`j ` g`nf geur n`tdr n`jidi ej tgd Q`hd Heursd eutsoid Yodjtsoj*
O tg`jldi tgd M`rojd fnodr. ` H`pt`oj. `ji bet ` t`xo oj te tewj*
Ygdrd. O feuji O heuni jet bdt up te Sdlojb fer sdvdr`n i`ys* Xe O
rdbostdrdi `t tgd @ster Getdn. a`tgdi `ji turjdi oj. bn`i ef ` adi
`ftdr snddpojb fotfunny `ji funny hnetgdi ej idhl hg`ors sojhd nd`vojb
Xg`jbg`o*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 191/455
04 YGD DJI EF HG@JB YXE-NOJ
M_`rrov`n oj Yodjtsoj w`s ej Kujd 03 ef tg`t str`jbd mejtg
oj 0?17. twe i`ys `ftdr Sdlojb g`i addj t`ldj evdr ay Bdj-
dr`n _dj Gso-s`j. gomsdnf ` Jertgdrj bevdrjer oj Xg`jso
Srevojhd jd`ray. aut `nnodi wotg tgd Luemojt`jb* Ygd dx-heenod wge
adh`md Bevdrjer ef Xg`jtujb. M`rsg`n Hg`jb Hgujb-hg`jb. w`s stonn
geniojb Yodjtsoj. aut gd. tee. g`i te fndd wotgoj tgd wddl. `ji gos
treeps wdjt evdr te tgd vohters* Xemd fndi. aut oj tgd m`oj tgdy
mdrdny rdhebjozdi ` jdw hgodft`oj*
Ygd m`j wge ehhupodi Yodjtsoj w`s Bdjdr`n Fu Yse-yo. ` meej-
f`hdi aut stdrj monot`ry m`j wgesd treeps wdrd ney`n te gom `ji tgd
Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej* Bdjdr`n Fu w`s j`mdi tgd jdw Idfdjsd
Hemmossoejdr. `ji O wdjt eut oj tgd j`tovd hoty `reuji tgd ferdobj
hejhdssoejs ef Yodjtsoj te sdd gom tgd jdxt i`y* Gos `oms wdrd jet
`jto-ferdobj. gd s`oi. `ji gos treeps wdrd teni te rdspdht ferdobj prep-
drty tgdrd* Hdrt`ojny je ejd seubgt te g`rm md oj tgd trop te tgd
Bdjdr`n"s y`mdj. er gd`iqu`rtdrs. tgreubg tgd j`rrew j`tovd
`vdjuds*
Ygd Hemmossoejdr ioi jet ljew wgdtgdr tgd vohteroeus m`rhg
weuni hejtojud tgdj te prdss ej p`st tgd Brd`t R`nn `ji ojte M`j-
hguro`. wgdrd eni M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj g`i kust addj lonndi* Jejd
oj Yodjtsoj tgdj ljdw er weuni hemmdjt ej tgos p`rt ef tgd rdvenu-
toej< tgdy sddmdi te fddn. gewdvdr. tg`t geniojb Sdlojb `ji Yodjtsoj
weuni lddp tgdor treeps ehhupodi fer tgd jdxt fdw mejtgs* Ygdrd w`s
stonn semd nottnd fobgtojb beojb ej oj tgd eutslorts ef Yodjtsoj. `ji tgd
seuji ef sgeetojb heuni eftdj ad gd`ri*
O rdh`nn teurojb tgd ferdobj idfdjsds n`td ejd jobgt. er kust adferd
i`wj. wgond iost`jt rofnd ford w`s `uioand aut jetgojb ef ompert`jhd
ehhurrdi wotgoj tgd hejhdssoej `rd`* Jetgojb aut tgd usu`n reuji ef
ujaroindi b`odty wotg wgohg tgd ferdobjdrs @mdroh`js. Arotosg.
Frdjhg. Bdrm`js. `ji Qusso`js seubgt `j eutndt frem tgd oindjdss
0?0
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 192/455
0?1 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`nw`ys ferhdi ej hemmdrhd ay w`rf`rd* Ygdy i`jhdi gdrd `ji tgdrd
oj tgd g`nns r`tgdr t`wiry wgdj hemp`rdi te tgd merd nuxuroeus
pn`hds fer wgohg
Xg`jbg`o
g`s adhemd ljewj `ji mest ef tgdm spdjt
geurs `t jumdreus Hgojdsd b`manojb geusds. er tgd ejd ruj ay `j
@mdroh`j pdrexoid anejid ef ujhdrt`oj vojt`bd `ji vortud oj wg`t
g`i addj tgd eni Bdrm`j Hejhdssoej tgdrd* Ot r`j woid epdj. `ji O
w`s ndi `str`y ejd jobgt nejb djeubg te try ` fnojbwotg tgd `nw`ys
f`shoj`tojb nottnd overy a`nn oj reundttd. wgdrd O wej )133 Mdx*. er
`aeut )?4 oj T* X* hurrdjhy `t tg`t tomd*
Ot w`s stonn ompessoand te bdt tgreubg te Sdlojb `t tgd dji ef `
wddl. se O ndft fer M`jhguro`* Ygd neh`n herrdspejidjt fer Ygd Jdw
_erl Yomds tgdj h`rrodi ej frem Yodjtsoj. `ji gos hgodf. G`nndtt
@adji. tgdj ` p`rt-tomd m`j oj Jertg Hgoj` wge wotgoj ` fdw mejtgs
w`s te suhhddi md oj `nn @so` wotg gd`iqu`rtdrs `t Xg`jbg`o. w`s
bdttojb tgd Sdlojb `jbnd eut frem tgdrd* Ygd str`jbd m`jjdr oj
wgohg M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj g`i iodi ojtrobudi md. oj `jy h`sd. se
O wdjt te Mulidj te sdd wg`t w`s ehhurrojb `hress Sdohgogno A`y
tgdrd* My hemp`joej. Ardotdjstdoj. wdjt `nejb `ji oj moi-Kujd wd
n`jidi frem ` K`p`jdsd vdssdn `t tgd K`p`jdsd-hejtrenndi hoty ef I`ordj
`r tgd top ef tgd M`jhguro`j pdjojsun`*
I`ordj w`s ` meidrj hoty. h`nm. quodt `ji pd`hdfun `ftdr tgd hg`es
ef Hgoj`* Ygd K`p`jdsd auont ot up frem nottnd er jetgojb `ji g`vd
tgdor pewdrfun Xeutg M`jhguro` Q`onw`y gd`iqu`rtdrs tgdrd* Ygdy
wdrd preui ef tgdor werl jet ejny oj I`ordj aut oj `nn Xeutgdrj M`j-
hguro` wgohg tgdy tgdj hejtrenndi `ji oj `nn f`orjdss. O must s`y gdrd
tg`t tgdy g`i. `ji g`vd. ` robgt te ad preui* Ygd `tmespgdrd ef
ojiustry `ji hustem`ry pd`hdtomd pursuots w`s `nn aut evdrwgdnmojb
te ejd kust frdsg frem tgd w`rs ef Hgoj`*
Ye foji eut wg`t w`s a`hl ef `nn tgos `ji wg`t tgd K`p`jdsd oj-
tdjidi te ie of tgd mdj oj tgd Hgojdsd Luemojt`jb trodi te pusg ej
ojte M`jhguro`. O seubgt eut `j eni frodji* Gd w`s Gdjry R*
Lojjdy. `j `ivosdr te tgd Xeutg M`jhguro` Q`onw`y. wgem O g`iljewj yd`rs adferd oj Yelye* Lojjdy. ` wrotdr. tr`vdnndr. dioter `ji
drstwgond `sseho`td ef tgd n`td K`hl Nejiej wgdj tgd twe wdrd rdso-
idjts ef Gejenunu d`rnodr oj tgos hdjtury. ljdw `nn tgd `jswdrs* Aut
gd ljdw `nse tg`t tgdy weuni seuji adttdr oj @mdroh` of tgdy h`md
frem ` K`p`jdsd* Xe gd ojtreiuhdi md te Mr* _esuld M`tsuel`. tgdj
vohd-prdsoidjt ef tgd X* M* Q* oj I`ordj. ` K`p`jdsd iopnem`t diuh`tdi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 193/455
YGD DJI EF HG@JB YXE-NOJ 0?8
oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds* M`tsuel`-X`j suasdqudjtny adh`md werni
f`meus `s tgd gd`i ef tgd K`p`jdsd idndb`toej te tgd Nd`bud ef J`-
toejs wgohg w`nldi eut ef tg`t `ubust `ssdmany semd yd`rs `be* Oj
tgd summdr ef 0?93 gd adh`md Ferdobj Mojostdr oj Yelye*
@ gobg idbrdd ef ojtdrdst `ppre`hgojb `jxodty m`rldi tgd K`p`jdsd
`ttotuid `s ojioh`toejs ojhrd`sdi tg`t tgd vohteroeus J`toej`nosts ioi
jet ojtdji te step wotg tgd h`pturd ef Sdlojb. aut wdrd `nrd`iy n`yojb
pn`js fer `j ejw`ri pusg ojte Hgoj`"s Ygrdd D`stdrj Srevojhds. er
M`jhguro`* Qdperts puanosgdi woidny oj tgd K`p`jdsd prdss oj I`ordj
oj 0?17 eutnojdi tgd Xeutgdrjdrs" hejtdmpn`tdi effdjsovd. `ji O feuji
ot `pp`rdjt tg`t prdp`r`toejs wdrd ujidr w`y `t `nn str`tdboh peojts te
mddt tgd hrosos wgohg w`s fd`rdi te ad ommojdjt* Ef heursd. ot f`ondi
te m`tdro`nozd*
K`p`j g`i idfojotdny idtdrmojdi jet te pdrmot `jytgojb te iosrupt
tgd pd`hd `ji eridr ef M`jhguro`. idtdrmoj`toej m`id hnd`r ay ` fr`jl
idhn`r`toej te md ay M`tsuel`* Ygd epojoej prdv`ondi tg`t K`p`j w`s
f`hojb tgd mest hrotoh`n sotu`toej oj gdr
ehhup`toej
ef M`jhguro` sojhd
tgd Qusse-K`p`jdsd R`r oj 0?P9--34. aut effoho`ns prehddidi ej wg`t
w`s bdjdr`nny rdb`ridi `s ` s`jd prebr`m te effsdt tgd pessoaonotods ef
hovon w`r djtdrojb tgd Ygrdd D`stdrj Srevojhds*
Eur penohy. fr`jlny. os pd`hd `t `jy prohd. s`oi M`tsuel`* Rd
ojtdji te rdotdr`td. of jdhdss`ry. eur idhn`r`toej jet te pdrmot dotgdr
Mulidj er J`jlojb te h`rry tgd fobgtojb ojte M`jhguro`. Of tgdy
`rd `and te
bdt tebdtgdr`ji sdttnd tgdor
penotoh`n
ioffdrdjhds
pd`hdfunny.`nn robgt of jet. wd sg`nn hnesd tgd ieer `t Xg`jg`olw`j '`t tgd d`st-
drj dji ef tgd Brd`t R`nn/ `ji jet pdrmot tgd Xeutgdrj `rmods te
p`ss*
M`tsuel` g`i addj nejb oj tgd Ferdobj Effohd oj Yelye `ji w`s
`mejb tgesd hnesdst te tgd n`td A`rej Y`j`l`. tgd Srdmodr. `ntgeubg
gd tgdj gdni je penotoh`n pest*
Osj"t tg`t vortu`nny ` pretdhter`td evdr wgedvdr os oj pewdr oj
Mulidj5 O `sldi M`tsuel`*
H`nn ot ` pretdhter`td of yeu wonn%" gd rdpnodi* Rd wonn jet pdr-
mot w`r te iostura M`jhguro`. wgdrd tgd pdepnd `rd pd`hdfun `ji pres-
pdreus* Rd ojtdji te `ssurd pd`hd `t `jy prohd oj M`jhguro`. wgohg
os eur eni `ji nejb dst`anosgdi penohy*
O `imot tg`t tgos os no`and te put us oj `j dma`rr`ssojb pesotoej*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 194/455
0?9 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Rd hdrt`ojny ie jet idsord te ojtdrfdrd oj Hgojdsd penotohs.`nn tgd
hrotohosm te tgd hejtr`ry jetwotgst`jiojb*
M`tsuel` s`oi gd adnodvdi tg`t gd w`s dxprdssojb Yelye"s penohy
wgdj gd idhn`rdi tg`t je Xeutgdrj treeps weuni ad pdrmottdi te p`ss
Xg`jg`olw`j of tgdrd w`s `jy fobgtojb oj tgd effojb*
J`jlojb"s prebr`m tgdj te pusg ej oj furtgdr hejqudsts adyeji
Sdlojb. `s puanosgdi oj tgd K`p`jdsd prdss. w`s te fennew tgos pn`j;
Oj tgd forst nojd ef `tt`hl ujidr Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. gos treeps
weuni `iv`jhd te Xg`jg`olw`j `nejb tgd Sdlojb-Mulidj Q`onw`y vo`
Yodjtsoj* @ sdheji breup ujidr M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb weuni
st`rt fer tgd s`md idstoj`toej vo` Yujbhgew. _utodj `ji Fdjbkuj.
Fdjb adojb oj tgd moiind sdhter adtwddj Hgo`jb"s mdj `ji tgesd ef
Bdjdr`n _dj Gso-s`j. Bevdrjer ef Xg`jso Srevojhd `ji Sdlojb"s jdw
rundr. wge w`s iordhtojbtgd tgori `iv`jhd vo` Kdgen Srevojhd. jertg
ef tgd R`nn @jetgdr sobjofoh`jt fd`turd w`s sddj oj tgd p`rtohop`toej
ef Bdjdr`n Sdo Hgujb-gso. tgd m`j wge h`pturdi Xg`jbg`o. n`tdr fdnn
eut wotg Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. wdjt te Rug`j `ji w`s tgdj oj Sdlojb*
Ygos nd`idr ef tgd Lw`jbso breup g`i nejb addj ` iosturaojb dndmdjt
wotgoj tgd Luemojt`jb* Bdjdr`n Sdo w`s s`oi te ad nd`iojb ` feurtg
dxpdiotoej`ry ferhd `b`ojst tgd jertg oj tgd bdjdr`n iordhtoej ef Hgod-
fdjhgew. tgd str`tdby `pp`rdjtny adojb te g`vd gos `rmy rd`iy te rd-
ojferhd `jy etgdrs oj tgd dvdjt tg`t tg`t sgeuni ad jdhdss`ry*
Of tgdy bdtoj tgd vohojoty ef Xg`jg`olw`j `ji Mulidj rdfusds
te surrdjidr. s`oi M`tsuel`. ot wonn md`j hovon w`r oj M`jhguro` `ji
tgos wd sg`nn `asenutdny jet pdrmot* Rd sg`nn step tgdm `t tgd ieer*
Ygdrd `rd tomds wgdj ` form `ttotuid os dssdjto`n. `ji tgos os ejd ef
tgdm* Rd ie jet w`jt te gdnp `jy f`htoej wotgoj Hgoj`. aut wd g`vd
bet te pretdht tgd pd`hd ef M`jhguro`*
M`tsuel` w`s ujusu`nny fr`jl `ji eutspeldj `s gd rdpnodi te my
qudrods* @sldi wgy gd w`s se dmpg`toh. gd rdotdr`tdi;
Rd must pretdht eur ojtdrdsts oj M`jhguro`*
Ygdj gd prehddidi wotg gos fr`jl `ji sobjofoh`jt st`tdmdjt*
J`tur`nny wd hejsoidr eur ojtdrdsts djeubg rd`sej fer eur `htoej
gdrd. gd s`oi* Gewdvdr. wd mobgt `s wdnn `imot tg`t M`jhguro` os
str`tdboh`nny vot`n te K`p`j ot os eur forst nojd ef idfdjsd* Bdebr`pgo-
h`nny. tgos os trud* Ygdsd `rd tgd f`hts wgohg pdrg`ps wonn h`usd us
dma`rr`ssmdjt. aut wd must f`hd tgd sotu`toej `ji `imot tg`t tgojbs
`rd `s tgdy `rd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 195/455
YGD DJI EF HG@JB YXE-NnL 0?4
Aut ndt md `ii tg`t wd ie jet w`jt turmeon* Rd ie jet w`jt te
ad mosujidrsteei* Rd w`jt pd`hd oj M`jhguro`* Yg`t os `nn*
@jetgdr tgojb wgohg gd fd`rdi mobgt iostura tg`t pd`hd w`s tgd
prea`aonoty tg`t Hg`jb Yse-noj. w`rneri ef M`jhguro` `ji drstwgond
Jertgdrj Ioht`ter. w`s id`i* @asenutdny jeaeiy wotg `utgeroty oj
I`ordj weuni s`y ydt wgdtgdr gd w`s id`i er `novd* Dvdj M`tsuel`
ojsostdi tg`t gd heuni jet `shdrt`oj tgd trutg*
Gdjhd. tgd omprdssoej w`s brewojb geurny `s je jdws h`md frem
Mulidj etgdr tg`j rumers ejd w`y `ji tgd etgdr hejhdrjojb tgd w`r-
neri"s hejiotoej. tg`t gd g`i suhhumadi te tgd weujis gd suffdrdi
wgdj gos tr`oj w`s aemadi sdvdr`n i`ys d`rnodr `s gd w`s fnddojb frem
Sdlojb te Mulidj* Ygd wgend aemaojb `ff`or w`s surreujidi ay tgd
iddpdst mystdry* Ygesd wge sgeuni g`vd ljewj `nn `aeut ot prefdssdi
tgd mest hempndtd objer`jhd. tgd Hgojdsd an`mojb tgd K`p`jdsd `ji
tgd K`p`jdsd adojb ojhnojdi te ojtom`td tg`t Hgojdsd andw up Hg`jb
Yse-noj"s tr`oj* Aut jeaeiy w`s m`lojb `jy idfojotd st`tdmdjt* Ygd
jdw `nobjmdjt oj M`jhguro`j penotoh`n `ff`ors g`i ` sobjofoh`jt dffdht
ej tgd K`p`jdsd pesotoej tgdrd* Gdjhd tgd tdjsdjdss surreujiojb tgd
aemaojb ef tgd eni M`rsg`n. wgohg hejt`ojdi tgd sddis ef f`r-rd`hgojb
ojtdrj`toej`n idvdnepmdjts*
O wdjt ej up te Mulidj. wgdrd O feuji tg`t yeujb Bdjdr`n Hg`jb
Gsudg-no`jb. ` h`p`and yeutg tgdj stonn oj gos twdjtods. g`i suhhddidi
gos pohturdsqud f`tgdr `s Bevdrjer ef Fdjbtodj `ji Ioht`ter ef M`j-
hguro`* Mulidj tg`t moi-Kujd w`s arobgt wotg fovd-a`rrdi fn`bs.dm-
andms ef Hgoj`"s forst rdpuanoh ay tg`t tomd fnyojb ejny oj tgd h`pot`ns
ef tgesd Ygrdd D`stdrj Srevojhds hdndar`tojb tgd ferm`n `jjeujhd-
mdjt ef tgd `ivdjt ef ` jdw rundr*
Ygdrd w`s ` semadr jetd oj tgd surf`hd b`odty. gewdvdr. aerj ef
hdrt`ojty tg`t tgd eni M`rsg`n w`s id`i idspotd tgd effoho`n prejeujhd-
mdjt tg`t gos sej w`s `ssumojb tgd ioht`tersgop adh`usd ef gos f`tgdr"s
hrotoh`n hejiotoej* Ygdrd w`s ` furtgdr rd`sej fer tgd str`oj ef `jxodty
adjd`tg tgd pepun`hd"s penohd-`ikurdi kennoty* Ygd penotoh`n pnets `ji
heujtdrpnets pdrv`iojb M`jhguro`"s pd`hdfun pn`ojs tgrd`tdjdi te up-
reet `utgeroty. `ji Hgojdsd `ji K`p`jdsd `nold rdb`ridi tgd sotu`toej
wotg hejhdrj* Mystdry djvdnepdi Mulidj*
Ywe vot`n qudstoejs tg`t effoho`nny rdm`ojdi uj`jswdrdi wdrd ; wge
wrdhldi Hg`jb Yse-noj"s tr`oj `ji gew5 `ji w`s tgd M`rsg`n id`i5
Hg`jb Yse-noj"s id`tg g`i jet addj effoho`nny `jjeujhdi ay Kujd 0?*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 196/455
0?6 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Gewdvdr. tgd sej g`i toffoj oj tgd j`tovd hoty tg`t i`y wotg ` breup ef
ojiustro`n Hgojdsd. ojhnuiojb pdrsejs hnesdst te tgd yeujb Bdjdr`n. `ji
ot w`s ujidrsteei tg`t ` st`tdmdjt ef gos f`tgdr"s id`tg w`s ossudi
sgertny tgdrd`ftdr*
Ygd Hgojdsd wdrd `nw`ys tgereubgny hejvojhdi tg`t K`p`j w`s
rdspejsoand* Ygd usu`n metovd `iv`jhdi w`s tg`t K`p`j w`jtdi te
h`usd treuand oj M`jhguro` se tg`t ot weuni ad pessoand fer gdr te
`jjdx tgd heujtry wotgeut tee muhg eppesotoej `are`i* Ygos sgd ioi
feur yd`rs n`tdr*
Ygd K`p`jdsd `utgerotods. ej tgd etgdr g`ji. st`jhgny idjodi un-
tdroer metovds oj M`jhguro`. tgd hejsun`r `s wdnn `s monot`ry effohdrs
pdrsostojb oj tgd hejtdjtoej tg`t tgd send ojtdrdst ef K`p`j w`s te m`oj-
t`oj pd`hd `ji te `ssost tgd Hgojdsd te adhemd prespdreus* Ygd K`p`-
jdsd Hejsun-Bdjdr`n. Mr* G`y`sgo. seubgt te bdt tgd Hgojdsd te `brdd
te ossud ` keojt st`tdmdjt ej tgd aemaojb. aut tgd Hgojdsd rdfusdi*
Ygd ojioh`toej w`s tg`t tgdy ioi jet idsord ` keojt ojquory fer. hej-
vojhdi tg`t tgd K`p`jdsd ioi ot `jyw`y. tgdy weuni rdkdht dfferts te
prevd etgdrwosd*
Ygd Hgojdsd teel je `htoej. tgdor nd`idrs peojtojb eut tg`t tgd
K`p`jdsd w`jtdi tgdm te st`rt semdtgojb te dj`and K`p`j te be `gd`i
`ji t`ld M`jhguro`* Gdjhd tgdy sgeel puzzndi gd`is. `imottdi strejb
`jto-K`p`jdsd fddnojb w`s ojhrd`sojb. `ji ydt idhn`rdi tg`t tgdy must
aoid tgdor tomd `ji g`jind tgd `ff`or wgdj tomds wdrd ndss treuaneus
`t gemd*
K`p`j g`i ` b`rrosej ef jd`rny 03.333 mdj oj Mulidj tgdj. `ji
gdr tet`n ferhd oj M`jhguro` w`s dstom`tdi `t jd`rny 14.333. wgohg
w`s djeubg te djferhd pd`hd* Hgojdsd Jertgdrj treeps hejtojudi
te `rrovd frem tgd seutg ej tgd Sdlojb-Mulidj Q`onw`y nojd. k`mmdiwotg treep tr`ojs* Hg`jb Yse-noj ndft nottnd rennojb stehl adgoji gom*
Xherds ef tgd f`meus Anud Dxprdss h`rs ef tgd Yodjtsoj-Sulew nojd
wdrd ej tgd soiojbs `t Mulidj. `s wdnn `s h`rs m`rldi Sdlojb. G`j-
lew. dth* Gos idjuiojb tgd r`onw`ys ef `nn h`rs g`mpdrdi hemmujoh`-toejs tgreubgeut Hgoj` fer mejtgs* Ygd wgdrd`aeuts ef M`rsg`ns Xuj
Hgu`j-f`jb `ji Hg`jb Hgujb-hg`jb. Mulidj"s `nnodi hemm`jidrs.
w`s h`usojb spdhun`toej* Ot w`s adnodvdi tg`t tgdy wdrd oj tgd vohojoty
ef Xg`jg`olw`j. `ji tgdy wdrd dxpdhtdi te rdtord s`fdny te I`ordj*
Hg`jb Gsudg-no`jb g`i jet ferm`nny `ssumdi tgd m`jtnd oj suh-
hddiojb gos f`tgdr `s Bevdrjer ef Fdjbtodj Srevojhd. `ntgeubg oj dffdht
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 197/455
YGD DJI EF HG@JB YXE-NOJ 0?2
gos pesotoej w`s tgd s`md `s tg`t ef gos f`tgdr* K`p`j w`s `pp`rdjtny
hejtdjt te pdrmot tgd yeujb Bdjdr`n te `ssumd gos f`tgdr"s pest. `n-
tgeubg ot sddmdi quotd p`tdjt tg`t tgd K`p`jdsd. tgereubgny ojhdjsdi
evdr Hg`jb Yse-noj"s `ttotuid oj rdhdjt mejtgs. w`jtdi ` jdw nojd-up*
Ygos. ojhoidjt`nny. w`s `mejb tgd rd`sejs fer tgd Hgojdsd adnodf tg`t
tgd K`p`jdsd wdrd adgoji Hg`jb Yse-noj"s `ss`ssoj`toej* Ygdy s`oi
tg`t K`p`j nejb seubgt te dvoht tgd eni M`rsg`n. wge w`s ujwonnojb
te m`ld hdrt`oj hejhdssoejs K`p`j w`s s`oi te idsord*
Ferdobj dxpdrts wge vosotdi tgd shdjd ef tgd ios`stdr seej `ftdr
ots ehhurrdjhd `brddi tg`t tgdrd must g`vd addj `t nd`st OXE peujis
ef dxpnesovd oj tgd mojd n`oi oj tgd podr ef tgd aroibd ef tgd Xeutg
M`jhguro` Q`onw`y. `ji tg`t ot must g`vd t`ldj sdvdr`n geurs te n`y
ot* Gdjhd. tgd K`p`jdsd seniodrs wge wdrd bu`riojb tgd sotd wdrd
iddmdi te g`vd addj `t nd`st str`jbdny jdbnobdjt* Ygd K`p`jdsd rd-
pnodi tg`t tgd Hgojdsd bu`ridi tgdor ewj nojd adnew tgd aroibd. wgdrd
tgd K`p`jdsd wdrd st`toejdi* Aut tgd Hgojdsd `ssdrtdi tg`t tgdy wdrd
jet pdrmottdi te sdji bu`ris wotgoj tgd K`p`jdsd r`onw`y zejd `ji
g`i jejd tgdrd* @ m`j ej tgd tr`oj s`oi tg`t gd s`w je Hgojdsd
bu`ris `ji tg`t tgd K`p`jdsd ioi jet `ppd`r ujton `aeut twdjty
mojutds `ftdr tgd dxpnesoej*
Ej Kujd 13. O t`nldi fer tgd forst tomd wotg yeujb M`rsg`n Hg`jb
Gsudg-no`jb* Gd s`oi gd ojtdjidi te pursud ` penohy g`vojb `mejb
ots hgodf be`ns tgd dr`ioh`toej ef tgd sheurbd ef w`r oj tgdsd tgrdd
treuandi d`stdrj prevojhds ef Hgoj`*
Fennewojb tgd d`rny ojstotutoej ef `j dr` ef dhejemoh idvdnepmdjt.
gd gepdi te djheur`bd tgd ojvdstmdjt ef @mdroh`j h`pot`n oj M`j-
hguro`*
O weuni wdnhemd foj`jho`n `oi frem `are`i ej tgd a`sos ef dqu`n-
oty%" s`oi tgd yeujb M`rsg`n* O weuni ad adst pnd`sdi of @mdroh`j
h`pot`n wdrd ojvdstdi oj M`jhguro`* Gewdvdr. O ie jet ojtdji te
br`jt furtgdr spdho`n provondbds* Ferdobj herper`toejs hemojb ojte eur
heujtry must ad wonnojb te `brdd te dqu`noty ef hejtren tg`t os. g`nf
Hgojdsd `ji g`nf j`toej`ns ef wg`tdvdr ferdobj heujtrods erb`jozd
hemp`jods gdrd*
Ygos w`s somon`r te tgd eni `rr`jbdmdjt fer tgd Hgojdsd D`stdrj
Q`onw`y. wgohg w`s dssdjto`nny Qusso`j ujton aeubgt ay K`p`j*
Ygd yeutgfun suhhdsser te Hg`jb Yse-noj. twdjty-sdvdj yd`rs eni
ej Kujd 9. 0?17. tgd i`y gos f`tgdr"s tr`oj w`s iyj`motdi. ossudi `
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 198/455
0?7 YGDIQ@BEJXYOQX
ferm`n prehn`m`toej tgd jdxt i`y bovojb tgd idt`ons ef gos penohods. aut
oj tgos forst ojtdrvodw gd eutnojdi oj `iv`jhd te Ygd Jdw _erl Yomds
herrdspejidjt tgd hgodf penohods ef gos Bevdrjmdjt*
Gd idhnojdi te ioshuss tgd `ttotuid ef K`p`j aut fdnt Yelye"s sgew
ef ferhd ioi jet rdprdsdjt tgd `ttotuid ef tgd pdepnd* Gd adnodvdi ot
w`s tgd rdsunt ef tgd tdmper`ry `shdjidjhy ef ` hdrt`oj hnoqud oj tgd
Bevdrjmdjt. wgohg gd gepdi w`s ` p`ssojb pg`sd. `ji tg`t dvdjtu`nny
gd weuni ad `and te trd`t wotg K`p`j ej ` a`sos ef dqu`noty ujg`mpdrdi
ay spdho`n robgts* Gd w`s dvohtdi ay K`p`j oj 0?80. gewdvdr. fnddojb
te J`jlojb*
Ygd }eujb M`rsg`n00
rdhdovdi md `t gos monot`ry gd`iqu`rtdrs*
Gd w`s sndjidr `ji p`nd. ydt djdrbdtoh* Gos tgohl. an`hl must`hgd
`ji sdroeus modj `iidi iobjoty te gos fr`on yeutg*
O sg`nn ossud ` prehn`m`toej bovojb my `spor`toejs fer bevdrjmdjt
oj idt`on. gd s`oi* Ygdy. arodfny. `rd tgos ; O sg`nn sddl te dji w`r*
O g`vd addj tdj yd`rs oj w`r `ji ljew ots gerrers* O w`jt. forst ef
`nn. te noft tgos sheurbd frem eur pdepnd* O gepd O sg`nn jet ad ferhdi
te `ht etgdrwosd oj my ferdobj penohy* O sg`nn idm`ji dqu`n trd`tmdjt
fer Hgoj`* Dvdjtu`nny. wd must `aenosg tgd ujdqu`n trd`tods*
@t gemd. wd must rderb`jozd eur eutneel* O w`jt eur pdepnd te
hejhdjtr`td ej tgd idvdnepmdjt ef M`jhguro` `ji neel te eursdnvds.
jet eutw`ri. fer idvdnepmdjt* Ygdrd os je jddi ef eur sddlojb te
dxp`ji jew er djhre`hg ej etgdr p`rts ef Hgoj`* Rd must auoni
frem wotgoj*
fht
n `m p`rtohun`rny ojtdrdstdi oj tgd idvdnepmdjt ef diuh`toej.
wgohg os `jetgdr vot`n peojt* My f`tgdr ndft md )03.333.333* Oj my
prehn`m`toej yeu wonn sdd md iej`td dvdry hdjt te `j diuh`toej`n
aurd`u te ad `imojostdrdi wosdny. tgd adbojjojb ef ujovdrs`n diuh`toej
tgreubgeut eur prevojhds* Ygos os gobgny dssdjto`n te tgd futurd pd`hd-
fun idvdnepmdjt ef eur heujtry*
Qdb`riojb tgd J`toej`nosts. wd `rd rd`iy te trd`t wotg tgdm ej
` a`sos efdqu`noty*
Ojf`ht. wd
`rd`nrd`iy hejiuhtojb jdbeto`toejs.
aut tgdy `rd `t ` st`jistonn fer tgd prdsdjt. iud te tgd n`hl ef ujoty
wotgoj tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt* Rgdj tgdy `rd rd`iy te ioshuss `
jdw `nobjmdjt wotg us. wd sg`nn ie se. aut t`nl pd`hd ejny `s dqu`ns*
Of tgdy sddl te dxhnuid us `ji m`ld pd`hd ej tgdor ewj tdrms j`tu-
r`nny wd wonn jet g`vd `jytgojb te ie wotg tgdm* O gepd tg`t wonn jet
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 199/455
YGD DJI EF HG@JB YXE-NOJ 0??
ehhur `ji tg`t tgd J`toej`nosts wonn dst`anosg ujoty `ji dj`and us te
m`ld tdrms*
lo
Md`jtomd. tgdy`rd ujrdno`and* Fer
dx`mpnd.Bdjdr`n _dj Gso-
s`j h`md te Sdlojb `ji teni us gew gd weuni bu`r`jtdd tgd s`fd
idp`rturd ef eur b`rrosej* Ygd Hemm`jidr ndft oj hg`rbd ` sm`nn
`rmy te m`ojt`oj pd`hd oj Sdlojb ujton tgd turj-evdr* Rgdj eur
Bdjdr`n idp`rtdi. gos mdj mdt M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb"s treeps ad-
twddj Sdlojb `ji Yodjtsoj `ji wdrd ios`rmdi* Ygos iosbr`hdfun
ard`hg ef f`otg nd`vds us ieuatojb tg`t tgdy trust d`hg etgdr*
"Ygdsdtgojbs
O wonn strovd te`hhempnosg* _eu
must rd`nozd tgd
prebr`m os ejny tdjt`tovd `ji suakdht te suasdqudjt dvdjts* O gepd
jetgojb eastruhts ots `hgodvdmdjt. aut oj tgd dvdjt tg`t semdtgojb
ujferdsddj ehhurs O ie jet w`jt yej te tgojl md jet fr`jl* O h`j
ejny strovd fer tgdsd be`ns* Ygd m`oj eakdht os te dst`anosg f`otg oj my
rdbomd*
O fr`jlny `imot tgd preandm* Aut tgos eutnojds my nofd"s `om*
Ygd M`rsg`ns`oi tg`t M`rsg`ns
Hg`jb Hgujb-hg`jb `ji XujHgu`j-f`jb wdrd stonn wotg gom. Xuj hemm`jiojb tgd treeps bovdj gom
ay yeujb Hg`jb< `ji Hg`jb Hgujb-hg`jb wotg tgd rdmj`jts ef gos
Xg`jtujb `rmy*
@ fdw i`ys n`tdr O wdjt jertg te G`raoj* Jertgdrj M`jhguro`
w`s `stor wotg `jxodty `s tgd pdepnd oj tgd Ygrdd D`stdrj Srevojhds
`w`otdi tgd senutoej ef tgd sgoftojb penotoh`n sotu`toej h`usdi ay tgd
h`pturd ef Sdlojb ay tgd J`toej`nosts `ji tgd ir`m`toh id`tgef
M`r-sg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj*
Hejvdrs`toejs wotg wdnn-ojfermdi pdrsejs ojioh`tdi `t nd`st twe
tgojbs. j`mdny. tg`t tgd prevojhds ef Loroj `ji G`onujlo`jb wdrd
idtdrmojdi te dji hejtren ay ` ioht`tersgop oj Mulidj je m`ttdr
ujidr wgem. aut p`rtohun`rny ujidr yeujb M`rsg`n Hg`jb Gsudg-
no`jb< `ji tg`t ot w`s adnodvdi tg`t M`jhguro` seej weuni keoj `
J`toej`n Fdidr`toej ef Hgoj` ujidr ` M`jhguro`j Hdjtr`n DxdhutovdHemmottdd ferm ef bevdrjmdjt wotg tgd h`pot`n rdm`ojojb `t Mulidj*
Ygd `ttotuid ef Loroj w`s p`rtohun`rny `i`m`jt `b`ojst hej-
toju`toej ef tgd eni eridr ef tgojbs `s f`r `s m`ojtdj`jhd ef ` ioht`ter-
sgop ujidr tgd y ujb M`rsg`n w`s hejhdrjdi. tgd pesotoej ef Loroj
adojb tg`t of Hg`jb Gsudg-no`jb wdrd ` suot`and rundr fer gos ewj
pdepnd ef Fdjbtodj Srevojhd ot w`s s`tosf`htery te Loroj tg`t gd rund
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 200/455
133 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgdrd. aut tgdy weuni jet `imot gos robgt te ioht`td `ff`ors eutsoid ef
Fdjbtodj*
Easdrvdrs oj hnesd teuhg wotg `ff`ors wdrd ojtdjtny w`thgojb tgd
hejvdrs`toejs wotg tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb. `ji tgd om-
prdssoej w`s brewojb tg`t ` tdjt`tovd `brddmdjt g`i `nrd`iy addj
rd`hgdi ujidr wgohg M`jhguro` weuni rdt`oj muhg ef ots eni `utejemy
aut weuni keoj tgd J`toej`nosts `s p`rt ef ` fdidr`toej `brddmdjt*
Ygos tgdy ioi. ujidr tgd yeujb M`rsg`n* Rgond puanoh epojoej
rdb`ridi ` hg`jbd te tgos systdm wotg ieuat. ots `ieptoej w`s bdjdr-
`nny sddj `s ` prebrdssovd mevd tew`ri dvdjtu`n ujoty `ji tgd djiojb
ef ojtdrj`n penotoh`n strofd wgohg etgdrwosd. ot w`s fd`rdi. mobgt hej-
tojud ojidfojotdny*
Ygd `ttotuid ef K`p`j tew`ri suhg `brddmdjts w`s rdb`ridi `s `
prea`and eastruhtoej. gewdvdr* K`p`jdsd oj `utgeroty idjodi tg`t tgdy
ojtdjidi te ojtdrfdrd `s nejb `s tgd Hgojdsd sdttndi tgdor penotoh`n
`ff`ors pd`hdfunny* Ygd K`p`jdsd monot`ry gobg hemm`ji `t Mulidj
w`s stonn uj`jomeus oj idhn`rojb ot ioi jet ojtdji te dxhddi trd`ty
robgts. gdjhd tgd epojoej w`s b`ojojb breuji tg`t K`p`j w`s wonnojb
te pdrmot M`jhguro` te try tgd J`toej`nost dxpdromdjt `s nejb `s gdr
robgts wdrd ujomp`ordi `ji pd`hd w`s prdsdrvdi*
Oj f`ht. kust adferd nd`vojb Mulidj. O rdhdovdi ` hemmujoh`toej
frem _esuld M`tsuel`. s`yojb tg`t gd idsordi te hnd`r up gos `ttotuid
ej ` ""pretdhter`td tgdrd* Gd hejsoidrdi tgd usd ef tgd weri ujfer-
tuj`td. `iiojb; O wosg te dmpg`sozd tg`t jdotgdr O jer `jy etgdr
rdspejsoand K`p`jdsd idsords jer hejtdmpn`tds ` K`p`jdsd pretdhter`td
evdr M`jhguro`* M`tsuel`"s oid` w`s te m`ojt`oj pd`hd oj M`j-
hguro` ay prdvdjtojb tgd `rmods ef dotgdr soid frem fobgtojb `ji of tgos
wdrd hejstrudi `s pretdhtojb `jy ojtdrdsts ot heuni jet ad gdnpdi <aut
`s f`r `s tgd Yelye Bevdrjmdjt ferm`nny `jjeujhojb `jy ojtdjtoej
ef sdttojb up ` pretdhter`td oj tgd Nd`bud ef J`toejs sdjsd. gd s`oi
ot w`s sompny ujtrud*
Ygd Hgojdsd. jdvdrtgdndss. rdb`ridi K`p`j"s mevds wotg `pprd-
gdjsoej* @utgerotods oj `nn qu`rtdrs heujsdnndi ` penohy ef h`nmjdss
`ppre`hgojb suamossovdjdss ujton iemdstoh penotoh`n `ff`ors suasoidi*
Ygdrd g`i addj wg`t w`s rdb`ridi `s ` str`jbd `jto-Xevodt h`m-
p`obj oj tgd j`tovd hoty oj G`raoj* Xtuidjts wdrd horhun`tojb p`mpgndts
oj wgohg twe tgderods wdrd `iv`jhdi ejd. tg`t tgd K`p`jdsd. wgem
tgd Hgojdsd wdrd `nn rd`iy te an`md fer `jytgojb. wdrd tryojb te `reusd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 201/455
YGD DJI EF HG@JB YXE-NOL 130
treuand. `ji tgd etgdr. tg`t tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb w`s
a`hlojb tgd mevdmdjt* Xevodt `igdrdjts oj Jertg M`jhguro` wdrd
lddpojb quodt `jijet
djtdrojbtgd
penotoh`nfodni ej ejd soid er tgd
etgdr. `ntgeubg O feuji tgdm lddpojb oj p`rtohun`rny hnesd teuhg wotg
` K`p`jdsd M`jhguro`j henejoz`toej pn`j*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 202/455
06 YEL_E"X IONDMM@
A@HL`b`oj oj Mulidj tew`ri tgd dji ef tg`t Kujd. O h`md te
tgd hejhnusoej tg`t K`p`j w`s fobgtojb wotg gdr a`hl te tgd
Brd`t R`nn ef Hgoj`*
Rgond ej tgd surf`hd `nn w`s h`nm `ji tgd Hgojdsd effoho`nny dx-
prdssdi tgdor `pprdho`toej ef tgd m`jjdr oj wgohg K`p`j"s form penohy
oj M`jhguro` g`i m`ojt`ojdi pd`hd wgond tgd rdst ef Hgoj` suffdrdi
tgd `bejods ef sddmojbny ojtdrmoj`and hovon w`r. ot w`s ojhrd`sojbny
`pp`rdjtte
md dvdjtgdj tg`t
brd`tferhds wdrd
mevojbwgohg dvdj-
tu`nny weuni tdji te ferhd tgd K`p`jdsd dotgdr te ehhupy M`jhguro`
`ji put `j dji te ieuat. er wotgir`w gdr hn`oms te hejtren `ji
spdho`n provondbds* Ot w`s ieuatfun oj tgd dxtrdmd tg`t Yelye weuni
nostdj `t `nn te tgos n`ttdr `ntdrj`tovd* Ygdrdferd. tgd j`tur`n tdjidjhy
ej tgd p`rt ef tgd Hgojdsd w`s te `jtohop`td tg`t K`p`j ojtdjidi te ie
dvdrytgojb oj gdr pewdr merd formny te ompn`jt gdr hejtren tgdrd*
Rgdtgdr tg`t `ttdmpt w`s te t`ld tgd ferm ef ` pretdhter`td er
wgdtgdrot
w`s tgd ojtdjtoejef
tgd R`r Effohd h`aojdtoj
Yelyete
prehddi wotg ` aeni prebr`m ef `jjdx`toej wdrd `mejb tgd hejtoj-
bdjhods sdhrdtny ioshussdi oj tgd M`jhguro`j h`pot`n oj 0?17* Ygd
K`p`jdsd oj pesotoejs ef `utgeroty wdrd fr`jlny rd`iy te `imot. ieuat-
ndss wotg tgd `pprev`n ef tgdor Srdmodr. A`rej Y`j`l`. tg`t K`p`j
ojtdjidi te pretdht tgdsd prevojhds frem `tt`hl* Ygd K`p`jdsd sneb`j
rdm`ojdi Sd`hd `t `jy prohd. oj M`jhguro`. `ji tgdy wdrd rd`iy te
st`ji adgoji tg`t penohy te tgd nomot*
Rgdtgdr tg`t hejstotutdi dst`anosgojb ` pretdhter`td oj dffdht evdrwgedvdr g`ppdjdi te ad oj pewdr oj Mulidj w`s jet. tgd K`p`jdsd
dxpn`ojdi te md. tgdor ausojdss* Ot w`s tgdor `vewdi ojtdjtoej te
m`ojt`oj pd`hd `ji eridr oj M`jhguro`. hemd wg`t mobgt* Dvdj tgd
Hgojdsd heuni jet aut sdd tgd wosiem ef suhg ` penohy. `ntgeubg oj
Mulidj O gd`ri jew `ji tgdj semd Hgojdsd rdm`rl tg`t tgos puanoh
dxprdssoej ej tgd p`rt ef K`p`j w`s `j ojsunt te tgd ojtdbroty `ji
131
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 203/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 204/455
139 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Aut eur Hejsun g`i g`i ` sgehl sojhd tgdj* @ yeujb hg`p sh`rhdny
eut ef gos tddjs g`i addj sdozdi ay tgd K`p`jdsd `utgerotods wotgoj
tgdor Q`onw`y [ejd `t Mulidj*
Ygd yeutg. irdssdi oj tr`mp-nold hovono`j hnetgds. g`i je p`sspert
er etgdr oidjtofyojb p`pdrs aut hn`omdi tg`t gd w`s `j @mdroh`j* Gos
forst stery w`s tg`t gd w`s eff ` frdobgtdr tgdj oj I`ordj `ji. bovdj
evdrjobgt sgerd-nd`vd. g`i t`ldj ` tr`oj roid te Mulidj* Gd s`oi
gd weuni ad ej gos w`y a`hl tgdj aut fer tgd f`ht tg`t gd w`s `aruptny
`rrdstdi* Dvdjtu`nny. tgd K`p`jdsd er eur Hejsun O jdvdr ioi ios-
hevdr wgohg wermdi eut ef tgd frobgtdjdiyeujbstdr
gos trud oidjtoty*
Gd tgdj quohlny teni gos stery. ef gew gd g`i hemd te idsdrt tgd ON X*
M`rojd Herps `t Yodjtsoj. oj tomd ef ` w`r oj Jertg Hgoj` oj wgohg
tgdy mobgt g`vd addj ojvenvdi*
Ygd loi. `s wd h`md te ljew eur M`rojd -fer gd w`s jet muhg
evdr dobgtddj yd`rs eni. of tg`t s`oi gd w`s frem tgd Moiind Rdst*
Gd keojdi tgd M`rojds te sdd tgd werni. aut g`i feuji h`mp reutojd
`t Yodjtsojprdtty
iunn `ftdr se
nejb
` tomd* Ygdj gd mdt ` Qusso`j.
gd rdn`tdi. wge teni gom gd sgeuni jet eady eridrs ef `nn tgesd buys.
tgd effohdrs* Ygdy g`i ` fdw irojls. ot sddms. `ji tgd M`rojd quot"K
tgd sdrvohd. keojdi wotg gos p`n. br`aadi ` tr`oj. `ji n`jidi oj k`on `t
Mulidj ` sgert tomd n`tdr* Rg`t g`ppdjdi te gos Qusso`j frodji. O
jdvdr nd`rjdi*
Aut my preandm os gew te bdt gom a`hl te gos rdbomdjt oj Yodj-
tsoj. s`oi tgd Hejsun* Rd g`vd je fujis fer
rdturjojbidsdrtdrs*
Xe Fm puttojb ot up te yeu yeu `rd nd`vojb fer Yodjtsoj `t jeej.
wonn be te I`ordj tejobgt. `ji s`on a`hl te Hgoj` temerrew* O h`j"t
p`y yeu jew. aut of yeu wonn `iv`jhd tgos idsdrtdr"s f`rd `ji md`ns.
yeu"nn bdt semd loji ef ` rdw`ri er p`y frem tgd Herps oj Yodjtsoj*
Gew `aeut ot5
Ygdrd w`s je peojt oj rdfusojb. se O s`oi; El`y. aut ejd tgojb
must ad ujidrsteei jew* O"nn
p`ygos
w`y`ji
hg`pdrejdtgos
n`i.aut
O wej"t snddp wotg gom g`jihuffdi te my `rm! Of gd w`jts te iuhl
`b`oj tejobgt wgdj O bdt gom ` reem oj I`ordj tg`t os strohtny jejd
ef my `ff`or* Of gd rd`nny os rd`iy te f`hd tgd musoh `ji w`jts te be.
ndt"s be* Gew `aeut tg`t5
Ygd Hejsun `brddi* Gd s`oi tgdrd weuni ad je an`md `tt`hgdi te
md of tgd M`rojd fndi `b`oj `ftdr adojb pn`hdi oj my husteiy*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 205/455
YEL_E"X IONDMM@ 134
G`vd gom gdrd `t jeej fer tgd Dxprdss iewj te I`ordj. O s`oi*
@ji ay tgd w`y. wg`t"s tgos idsdrtdr"s j`md5
Auizojslo%" eur `ff`and Hejsun rdpnodi. `ji n`ubgdi* Ot rd`nny os*
Gd"s `j @mdroh`j. `nn robgt aut tg`t"s gos robgt j`md. adnodvd ot
er jet%"
"
Rotg `j ujusu`n j`md ef my ewj O g`i je treuand oj adnodvojb ot.
er tg`t tgd n`i w`s `j @mdroh`j* Rd `nrd`iy g`i pohldi up `jetgdr
n`i kust eut ef _`nd `ji m`lojb ` werni teur `s ` br`iu`toej prdsdjt.
wgem wd mdt `t G`raoj* Gos j`md w`s Gdrm`jj* Ygd jdxt i`y.
wgdj O aeubgt tgd feur std`msgop tohldts fer eur squ`irej treepojb
`hress Hgoj` dvdj tgd K`p`jdsd m`j `t tgd heujtdr g`i te smond* Rgeweunij"t. `t feur hg`ps tr`vdnnojb tebdtgdr `ji j`mdi Gdrm`jj.
Ardotdjstdoj. Mossdnwotz `ji Auizojslo! @ji wd wdrd `nn Bdjtonds.
dxhdpt Gdrm`jj. wge w`s ` Kdw frem Jdw _erl*
Ej tgd tr`oj iewj te I`ordj O t`nldi wotg tgd aeyosg M`rojd `ji
wd g`i je treuand oj tg`t qu`rtdr*
Ot"s el`y wotg md. O teni gom. of yeu idsdrt `b`oj wgdj wd got
I`ordj tejobgt* O"m beojb te bovd yeu fovd ydj '`aeut )1*43 tgdj/
fer ` md`n er twe `ji ` reem fer tgd jobgt. `ji ot"s up te yeu te ad
ej tgd ae`t wgdj wd s`on* Of yeu"rd jet. O wej"t nold ot.aut wg`t ie
yeu h`rd5 _eu"nn ad frdd. frdd `s `jy gujtdi m`j h`j ad* @ji yeu
m`y ad frdd. se te spd`l. fer fovd. tdj er twdjty yd`rs aut semd ejd
ef tgdsd i`ys tgd nejb `rm ef Tjhnd X`m"s n`w wonn br`a yeu `b`oj*
_eu iej"t w`jt te be tgreubg nofd `s ` idsdrtdr. ` gujtdi m`j. ie
yeu5 M`ld up yeur moji* Gdrd"s tgd mejdy O"nn neel fer yeu
wgdj wd s`on fer Hgoj` temerrew*
@ji gd w`s tgdrd. bn`i te ad s`onojb a`hl te gos eutfot Ygdrd w`s
je g`rm oj tg`t M`rojd. `ji O gepd gd bet eff nobgt `t gd`iqu`rtdrs*
@nn wd heuni bdt ej tgd K`p`jdsd vdssdn a`hl w`s idhl sp`hd `b`oj*
O g`i g`i my fonn ef idhl sp`hd tr`vdn. aut O g`i te bdt te Sdlojb. se
wd wdjt* @ntgeubg ot w`s jd`rny Kuny. tg`t jobgt `t sd` eff Jertg
Hgoj` w`s ejd ef tgd mest hgonnojb O dvdr spdjt `jywgdrd* Ygd jdxt
i`y ej sgerd `t Yodjtsoj ot w`s stofnojb. aut wd `nn jd`rny frezd te
id`tg ej tg`t tojy sgop sh`jt sgdntdr frem tgesd ohy an`sts tew`ri tgd
M`jhguro` pn`ojs wgohg wd wdrd nd`vojb*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 206/455
02 @ IQD@M YG@Y QOV@NX BDJBGOX LG@J
M_ERJ jertgdrj dxpdiotoej ojte tgd woni p`sturds ef
M`jhguro` djidi ej ` Xuji`y. wgdj eur std`mdr iehldi `t
Yodjtsoj* O `b`oj seubgt eut tgd @ster Geusd Getdn* O g`i
forst te idnovdr tgd M`rojd te tgd a`sd tgdj `t Yodjtsoj* Ygd etgdrs
wdjt `nejb te tgd getdn wgond O seubgt eut tgd BGP te turj Auizojslo.
peer idvon. evdr te tgd M`rojd `utgerotods
Ot w`s get. ujad`r`any get. tg`t forst i`y ef Kuny oj Jertg Hgoj`.
jet tee f`r frem tgd evdj ljewj `s tgd Beao Idsdrt* Auizojslo w`s
wonnojb djeubg te be `nejb. `s gd g`i addj dvdr sojhd gd w`s turjdi
evdr te md. `ji fer ` an`hl sgddp. er idsdrtdr. O must bovd gom hrdiot
fer m`lojb je iostura`jhd wg`tdvdr* Oj f`ht. gd w`s bn`i te ad a`hl
wgdrd gd heuni sdd gos fermdr auiiods. wge `t nd`st t`nldi gos n`j-
bu`bd. `ji gd w`s quotd prdp`rdi te t`ld gos mdiohojd
Aut tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojd Herps b`vd us eur ioffohuntods ej
tg`t get X`aa`tg* Yg`t w`s kust tgd treuand ot w`s Xuji`y* Je ejd
ef `utgeroty w`s `reuji* Ygd djnostdi m`j ej iuty `t tgd idsl g`ijdvdr gd`ri ef Auizojslo. `ji heuni jet ad aetgdrdi* Dvdjtu`nny `
jej-hemmossoejdi effohdr gd`ri tgd w`nn`-w`nn`. er t`nl. oj tgd eutdr
effohd `ji put oj `j `ppd`r`jhd* Gd g`i gd`ri ef ` idsdrtdr semd
wddls `be aut jdvdr g`i gd`ri ef Auizojslo. `ji w`s stumpdi fer `
memdjt* Ygdj tgd aronno`jt jej-hem g`i `j ojspor`toej* Gd s`oi;
R`ot ` mojutd. `ji h`nndi ` H`pt`oj ej tgd rdbomdjt`n tdndpgejd*
Ygd H`pt`oj w`s jet oj* Ot w`s Xuji`y* Oid` jumadr twe; Ygd
sdrbd`jt tdndpgejdi tgd effohdr `t gos qu`rtdrs* Gd"nn ad tgdrd. `nn
robgt. gd s`oi* N`st jobgt w`s X`turi`y jobgt. yeu ljew*
Ygd H`pt`oj w`s tgdrd oj adi* Xdji tgdm evdr. Xdrbd`jt. gos
veohd seujidi tgreubg tgd rdhdovdr* Rdnn. wd wdjt evdr* Ygd H`pt`oj
s`oi gd ioij"t ljew. aut gd suppesdi gd heuni put Auizojslo oj tgd
bu`rigeusd ujton Meji`y wgdj tgd Herps weuni st`rt fujhtoejojb
`b`oj* Yg`t sddmdi f`or djeubg* Ot w`s `nn wd heuni ie. oj `jy h`sd.
136
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 207/455
@ IQD@M YG@Y QOV@NX BDJBGOX LG@J 132
`ji O tg`jldi tgd H`pt`oj. ` nol`and yeujb hg`p. `ji wdjt ej te tgd
getdn*
Rgdj tgd jdxt i`y O bet eur tohldts fer tgd g`pg`z`ri tr`oj roid
te Sdlojb ` M`rojd teni md `t tgd st`toej tg`t O weuni ad rdp`oi fer
Auizojslo"s f`rd te Yodjtsoj frem Mulidj `ji gos jobgt"s neibojb oj
I`ordj. ay tgd rdw`ri iud md fer s`fdny hejiuhtojb ` idsdrtdr a`hl
te gos rdbomdjt gdrd* Dvdjtu`nny `jetgdr M`rojd w`s sdjt `nn tgd
w`y te Sdlojb sendny te idnovdr tgos rdw`ri te md* O feuji ot w`s
merd tg`j ieuand tgd hest ef Srov`td Auizojslo"s rdturj `ji O stonn
fddn O ewd tg`t yeujb m`j semd ef tgd )43 O bet*
Oj Sdlojb. tgd gd`t ef d`rny Kuny w`s dvdj wersd tg`j oj Yodjtsoj*
Ot rdmojidi md ef G`jlew f`r te tgd seutg. wgdrd ejd mobgt dxpdht
gd`t* Dvdj se. tgd `jhodjt h`pot`n. vosotdi fer tgd forst tomd. w`s rd`nny
` trd`t* Ygdrd w`s djeubg beojb ej te m`ld us ferbdt tgd hnom`td*
Fer ejd tgojb. tgd nd`idrs ef tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej b`tgdrdi tgdrd
tg`t summdr fer tgd Aob Feur Hejfdrdjhd* Ygdy wdrd Bdjdr`nossome
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb. Bdjdr`n _dj Gso-s`j.
Bevdrjer ef Xg`jso Srevojhd. `ji Bdjdr`n No Hgujb-kdj. ` seutgdrjdr
frem Lw`jbso Srevojhd wge g`i addj ejd ef tgd ferdmest Bdjdr`ns oj
tgd fodni iurojb tgd h`pturd ef Sdlojb*
Sdlojb fdnn te tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej ej Kujd 7. 0?17. wgdj
treeps ney`n te Bdjdr`n _dj Gso-s`j ehhupodi tgd hoty* Ygdor djtr`jhd
w`s pd`hdfun. fer tgd Jertgdrj treeps g`i fndi*
Ygd hejfdrdjhd ioi nottnd aut `brdd tg`t tgd jdxt mevd w`s te
idmeaonozd Hgoj`"s v`st `rmdi ferhds* Ygd nd`idrs idhoidi tg`t `
M`jhguro`j dxpdiotoej w`s ujjdhdss`ry* Ygd yeujb M`rsg`n. sej
ef tgd n`td M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj. w`s `nn fer tgd Luemojt`jb Qdve-
nutoej `ji tgd Ygrdd Sdepnd"s Srojhopnds. `ji tgd rdi dmandm ef tgd
Luemojt`jb wotg ots wgotd suj ej ` fodni ef nobgt anud oj tgd
uppdr ndft g`ji herjdr fndw `nn evdr M`jhguro` adferd tgd yd`r djidi*
@nn w`s wdnn wotg tgd werni. `s tgdsd Aob Feur s`w ot tgdj `ji
tgdy hejfdrrdi fer `wgond `ji wdjt gemd* Idmeaonoz`toej `ji tgd werlef rdhejstruhtoej wdrd tgd tgojbs te `hgodvd jdxt. tgdy idhoidi* Ygdy
wdrd robgt aut tgesd twe tgojbs g`vd ydt te ad `hhempnosgdi* Jdotgdr
w`s pessoand tgdj er jew fer m`jy rd`sejs. ojhnuiojb ojhdss`jt strofd
wotgoj tgd Luemojt`jb forst. fennewdi ay tgd ojv`soej ef w`rrojb K`p`j*
Ygd dma`nmdi aeiy ef tgd n`td Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj w`s djtemadi `t
tg`t tomd oj ` tdmpnd sgrojd eutsoid Sdlojb. `w`otojb tgd i`y wgdj ot
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 208/455
137 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
sgeuni ad aurodi pdrm`jdjtny ay gos adnevdi Luemojt`jb fennewdrs oj
` M`usendum wgohg tgdy g`i hejstruhtdi ej Surpnd Meujt`oj eutsoid
tgd h`pot`n ef tgd jdw Hgoj` wgohg gd djvos`bdi. `t J`jlojb* @t
Sdlojb tg`t fdtoi Kuny tgd i`ony tdmpdr`turd `t tgd getdn w`s `reuji
003 idbrdds `t jeej O teel ` rohlsg`w eut te tgd tdmper`ry rdstojb
pn`hd te sdd wgdrd tgd Jertgdrjdrs ldpt Ir* Xuj"s aeiy* Ot w`s `
ad`utofun spet* Ygd sgrojd w`s gobg up `t tgd tep ef `j eni tdmpnd*
Xeniodrs ef tgd Luemojt`jb wdrd ej bu`ri tgdrd* Gewdvdr. treeps
p`oi je `pprdho`and `ttdjtoej te md `s O w`nldi `nejd `hress tgd fn`bbdi
heurty`ris te tgd nejb fnobgt ef stejd stdps nd`iojb upw`ri te tgd v`unt*
@ pertr`ot ef Ir* Xuj w`s vosoand wotgoj tgd iomny nobgtdi v`unt. `aevd
tgd brd`t m`j"s h`sldt* Ygd h`sldt w`s ef mdt`n. sdjt `s ` boft ay tgd
Meshew Bevdrjmdjt< Ir* Xuj w`s tgdor frodji `ji `sseho`td* Ygd
twe seniodrs ej bu`ri weuni jet pdrmot md te djtdr tgd geny ef
genods%" aut tgdy wdrd beei-j`turdi `ji g`i je eakdhtoejs te my
pddrojb ojte tgd bneem wotgoj. i`rl `s ` h`vdrj `ftdr tgd sujnobgt eut-
soid* Ygd jdxt tomd. `ji tgd n`st. tg`t O w`s te sdd Ir* Xuj"s h`sldt
w`s wgdj O s`w tgd i`rl. dma`nmdi aeiy ef tgd Ysujb-no. er nd`idr.
tgd i`y adferd tgd Xt`td fujdr`n `ji djtemamdjt oj ` foj`n rdstojb-
pn`hd eutsoid J`jlojb ` yd`r n`tdr*
Yg`t Feurtg ef Kuny tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Mojostdr. Kegj V`j @*
M`hMurr`y. b`vd tgd hustem`ry Ojidpdjidjhd I`y rdhdptoej `ji hehl-
t`on p`rty* Nold `nn Sdlojb seho`n `ff`ors. ot w`s ` b`n` fujhtoej* Ygd
budsts ef `nn j`toejs. ojhnuiojb eur heusojs tgd Arotosg '`t wgem wd
wdrd `jbry wgdj tg`t i`y adh`md ` i`y te rdmdmadr oj @mdroh`j
gostery/. monndi `aeut oj bdjo`n h`m`r`idrod `ji tgd p`rty w`s `s b`y
`s tgd Hgojdsd rdvenutoej`ry vohters `nn `reuji tgd Ndb`toej Hempeuji*
Oj f`ht. ot w`s hdndar`tojb`jetgdr rdvenutoej fer frddiem*
Ygd p`rty w`s aut ejd ef tgd soidnobgts ef tgd rdvenutoej oj Hgoj`*
Ygd wgorn ef Sdlojb wdjt ej `p`hd* Ygd jobgt hnuas. semdwg`t
t`wiry `ff`ors `t adst. `ji tgd getdn reef i`jhds wdjt ej `ji ej `ji
ej* Rotgoj ` wddl O g`i sddj djeubg ef tgos. ef tdmpnds. ef qu`ojt eni
Sdlojb-stynd gemds wotg meej-b`td `pdrturds oj dvdry b`ridj w`nn.
ef tgd +"Aob Feur Hejfdrdjhd ef ot `nn* O ndft* @ tr`oj te G`jlew
w`s ` pessoaonoty fer ` wgond. aut tg`t oid` fdnn tgreubg `ji O teel `
he`st`n std`mdr a`hl te Xg`jbg`o*
Ygd summdr ef 0?17 feuji tgd mdj `t J`jlojb funn ef vohtery oj
tgdor Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej `ji ef pn`js fer ` ydt brd`tdr Hgoj`*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 209/455
@ IQD@M YG@Y QOV@NX BDJBGOX LG@J 13?
Ygdy g`i bet usdi te tr`vdnojb `t rdvenutoej`ry spddi `ji ird`mdi ef
` ujoty tg`t weuni djhemp`ss `nn @so`* Ygd ird`ms wdrd fojd `ji tgd
hejhdptoej rdm`ojs ` br`ji oid`. aut tgd J`jlojb vohters ferbet tgd
`p`tgy wotg wgohg tgd m`ss ef gum`joty vodws ` jdw tgeubgt*
Ot w`s ` ird`m. gewdvdr. tg`t rov`ndi tgd iddis ef Bdjbgos Lg`j*
Ygd ird`m w`s ef ` brd`t j`toej tg`t. strdthgojb f`r `hress `nmest `nn
@so`. heujts wotgoj ots aeridrs jet ejny wg`t os ljewj `s Hgoj`
Srepdr '` v`st `rd` oj otsdnf/ aut tgd prevojhds oj M`jhguro`. Ojjdr
`ji Eutdr Mejbeno`. `ji Yoadt* Oj tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt tgdrd
w`s fermdi ` Hemmottdd ej Mejbeno`j `ji Yoadt`j @ff`ors* Ot ojhnuidi
mdj wge `rd wdnn `hqu`ojtdi wotg tgd heujtrods aeridrojb Hgoj`
Srepdr `ji wge g`vd vosotdi tgdsd woni gojtdrn`jis ef @so`. dvdj semd
wge g`vd novdi `mejb tgd jem`ioh pdepnds wge pepun`td tgd pn`ojs
`ji pn`td`ux adyeji tgd Brd`t R`nn `ji eut te tgd Rdst wgdrd tgd
_`jbtzd Qovdr adbojs*
Ef heursd tgdsd mdj g`vd m`id nottnd prebrdss oj tgd rd`noz`toej ef
tgdor ird`m* Hemmujoh`toejs ojte tgdsd a`hln`jis `rd `s promotovd
tei`y. oj tgd m`oj. `s oj tgd tomd sdvdj hdjturods `be wgdj Bdjbgos
Lg`j"s gerids swdpt `hress @so` `ji st`rtdi tgd forst pejy dxprdss*
Ygdrd osj"t dvdj ` vdstobd ef tg`t pejy dxprdss oj dxostdjhd* Ehh`-
soej`nny h`r`v`js ir`w eut ef Sdlojb. tgreubg tgd meujt`oj p`ssds `ji
up ojte tgd pn`td`ux adyeji. t`lojb beeis te tgd `aeroboj`n troads tg`t
novd `s tgdor `jhdsters novdi* Ehh`soej`nny gersd tr`idrs be a`hl ojte
tgdsd pn`hds `ji arojb eut irevds ef Mejbeno`j pejods er gersds frem
Yoadt* Aut hemmdrhd os n`x. `ji tgd t`sl ef ujotojb tgdsd f`r pn`hds
ujidr ejd bevdrjmdjt rdm`ojs dxtrdmdny ioffohunt*
Ygd east`hnds `rd jet `nn j`tur`n* Ot m`y ad rdh`nndi tg`t Eutdr
Mejbeno` w`s fer ` tomd ` mdmadr ef tgd Xevodt Tjoej* Ygd ojfnudjhd
ef Qusso` g`s nejb addj strejb oj tgos heujtry. `ik`hdjt te Xoadro` `ji
fermojb ` sdheji of jet forst nojd ef idfdjsd oj h`sd ef `jetgdr w`r wotg
K`p`j* Gdjhd. tgd J`toej`nosts" pn`js oj tgos iordhtoej wonn g`vd te
rdhebjozd tgd Qusso`j preandms adferd muhg prebrdss h`j ad dxpdhtdi*
Ygd Mejbens `rd jet djtordny `vdrsd te hemojb ojte ` fdidr`toej wotg `
strejb Hgojdsd bevdrjmdjt* Aut tgdy `rd ujidr strejb prdssurd frem
tgdor Qusso`j jdobgaers*
Xdvdr`n yd`rs `be tgd Mejbens st`bdi `j uprosojb `ji idhn`rdi
tgdmsdnvds ` idmehr`toh st`td. `ji tgd bevdrjmdjt `t ejhd idhn`rdi
tgd Mejbeno`j projhds" totnds veoi* @ idndb`toej frem Hg`rg`r. jertg-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 210/455
103 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
wdst ef Sdlojb. w`s sdjt te J`jlojb `ji tgd qudstoej ef ujotojb wotg
tgd J`toej`nosts w`s ioshussdi* Ygd Mejbeno`js prdsdjtdi ` ndjbtgy
pdtotoejtr`hojb
tgd
idvdnepmdjtef tgdor easendtd aut `pp`rdjtny stonn
dffdhtovd ferm ef bevdrjmdjt* Oj ot. tgdy `ppd`ndi fer `utejemeus rund
ujidr ` Ar`jhg Senotoh`n Heujhon frem J`jlojb* Ygd `ppd`n w`s
rdfdrrdi te tgd Hemmottdd ej Mejbeno`j `ji Yoadt`j @ff`ors* Aut tgd
sobjofoh`jt peojt os tg`t tgd Mejbens. te `nn ojtdjts `ji purpesds. g`vd
addj rd`iy te ujotd wotg J`jlojb* Gew pr`htoh`n suhg ` ujoej mobgt
prevd os ` qudstoej. aut ot os ` mevd tew`ri tgd be`n ef wgohg tgd mdj
ujidr Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl ejhd ird`mdi
Gdrd `rd tgd dssdjto`n prepes`ns subbdstdi ay tgd Mejben idnd-
b`toej ;
0* Ygd Mejben hn`js pndibd `nndbo`jhd te tgd J`toej`nost
Bevdrjmdjt `ji pn`hd tgdmsdnvds ujidr tgd kurosiohtoej ef tgd
Luemojt`jb*
1* Oj nodu ef tgd prdsdjt tottujb `ji gsodj 'iostroht/ systdm
ef bevdrjmdjt tgd hn`js sg`nn adhemd tgd `imojostr`tovd ujot.
d`hg hn`j dndhtojb ots ewj rdprdsdjt`tovd te ` Ar`jhg Senotoh`n
Heujhon* Ygd Heujhon sg`nn ad ujidr tgd iordht hejtren ef tgd
Hdjtr`n Senotoh`n Heujhon oj J`jlojb aut sg`nn jet ad rdspejsoand
te `jy ojtdrmdio`ry erb`j*
8* N`jis onndb`nny sdozdi frem tgd hn`js ay tgd monot`ry sg`nn
ad rdturjdi te tgd eroboj`n ewjdrs*
9* Ygd hn`js sg`nn adbr`jtdi
tgdrobgt
tepenohd
tgdor ewj
tdrrotery*
Ygdsd prepes`ns seujidi. oj ` w`y. nold ` suot fer pd`hd r`tgdr
tg`j `j effdr tgdj te keoj J`jlojb* Gewdvdr. dotgdr w`y. ejhd
`hhdptdi `ji werlojb. Ojjdr Mejbeno` weuni `t nd`st `hljewndibd tgd
rund ef tg`t bevdrjmdjt* Ygd nd`idrs ef Hgoj` stonn pn`j te arojb
Yoadt `ji Mejbeno` ujidr tgdor fn`b. pessoany `s st`tds `igdrojb te tgd
J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt. aut `t nd`st p`rt ef ` Tjotdi Hgoj`*
Ygd Mejbeno`j idndb`toej idhn`rdi tgdy wdrd rd`iy te fny tgd
J`toej`nost fn`b `ji p`rtohop`td oj tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt tgdj `t
J`jlojb* @s ` rdsunt ef tgos `ji ef tgd prebr`m oj tgd mojis ef tgd
jdj oj J`jlojb `j dffert w`s m`id te m`ld semd sert ef ferm`n st`rt
;:j arojbojb Yoadt `ji tgd Mejbeno`js ojte nojd* Ygd J`jlojb Bevdrj-
mdjt `jjeujhdi ` sdrods ef rdbun`toejs bevdrjojb tgd erb`joz`toej `ji
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 211/455
@ IQD@M YG@Y QOV@NX BDJBGOX LT@J 100
fujhtoejs ef tgd Mejbeno`j `ji Yoadt`j @ff`ors Hemmottdd oj tgd
J`toej`n rdbomd* 'Ygd J`jlojb Bevdrjmdjt jew fujhtoejs `t
Hgujblojb*/
Ygos hemmottdd. O `m teni. os semdtgojb `loj te tgd Ojio`j @ff`ors
Hemmottdd oj R`sgojbtej* Ygdrd os ` ioffdrdjhd. te ad surd. `t tgd
vdry st`rt. fer Yoadt `ji Ojjdr `ji Eutdr Mejbeno` `rd f`r frem
adojb ujidr tgd hejtren ef J`jlojb* Aut tgd iutods ef tgd jdw hem-
mottdd g`vd te ie wotg tgd ferm`toej ef ` systdm wgdrday tgd hem-
mottdd. `htojb ujidr `ji wotg tgd `pprev`n ef tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt.
dvdjtu`nny h`j sdt up ` hovon `imojostr`toej tgreubgeut Yoadt `ji
Mejbeno`. suaerioj`td te J`jlojb ydt fujhtoejojb wotg ` n`rbd idbrdd
ef `utejemy `s f`r `s st`td robgts `rd hejhdrjdi* Ygd rdbun`toejs
sdt fertg tg`t tgd hemmottdd"s kurosiohtoej ""sg`nn dxtdji evdr Mejbeno`
`ji Yoadt ejny. `ji oj tgd sdheji `rtohnd prevoid tg`t. `soid frem `
hg`orm`j `ji vohd-hg`orm`j. tgd hemmottdd sg`nn ojhnuid frem jojd
te dndvdj mdmadrs. `ppeojtdi ay tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt ej tgd
rdhemmdji`toej ef tgd Hg`orm`j ef tgd Dxdhutovd _u`j*
Ygd Dxdhutovd _u`j w`s ejd ef tgd fovd yu`j. er Heujhons. wgohg
g`jindi tgd ausojdss ef Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb* Ygd Hemmottdd. oj
tgd Bevdrjmdjt"s `jjeujhdmdjt ef ots ferm`toej. w`s `imejosgdi te
adboj `t ejhd ej std`iy werl neelojb te tgd funfonmdjt ef tgd v`st
prebr`m ef dxp`jsoej tgd nd`idrs oj J`jlojb gepdi te sdd rd`nozdi*
Ygd aeiy mdt `t nd`st ejhd ` wddl oj ferm`n sdssoej `ji oj tgd md`j-
tomd tgd sua-iovosoejs. suhg `s tgd Xdhrdt`ro`t ef tgd Hemmottdd. tgd
Mejbeno`j @ff`ors Effohd `ji tgd Yoadt`j @ff`ors Effohd. h`rrodi ej
tgd i`ony reutojd ef h`rryojb eut tgd oid`s `ji prekdhts ef tgd hem-
mottdd `s ` wgend*
Tjton 0?80 M`jhguro` fndw tgd Luemojt`jb. er J`toej`n S`rty.
dmandm idspotd eppesotoej tgdrd `mejb tgd nd`idrs se sdvdrd `s te
rdsunt oj tgd dxdhutoej ef twe ef tgdm* Ygd yeujb bevdrjer. M`rsg`n
Hg`jb Gsdug-no`jb. oj ` puanoh st`tdmdjt dxpn`ojojb tgdor summ`ry
dxdhutoej. idhn`rdi tgdy eppesdi keojojb wotg J`jlojb* Ygdrd wdrd
etgdr hejsoidr`toejs. ojhnuiojb tgd ojtom`toej tgdy g`i pnettdi te evdr-
tgrew tgd Mulidj rdbomd `ji dxtdji brd`tdr provondbds te K`p`j oj
M`jhguro`. `ji tgd `nndb`toej tg`t ejd ef tgdm mos`pprepro`tdi mejdy
oj hejjdhtoej wotg gos iutods `s gd`i ef tgd Mulidj `rsdj`n*
Srevojhds oj ojtdroer Hgoj` `nse `rd ydt te ad areubgt ojte nojd
idfojotdny* Ygdsd ojhnuid _ujj`j ej tgd aeridr ef Aurm`. Xzdhgu`j
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 212/455
101 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
kust wdst ef G`jlew. L`jsu `ji Xojlo`jb oj tgd jertgwdst* Ygdrd
wonn ieuatndss ad nejb yd`rs ef aeridr w`rf`rd. iurojb wgohg ujsua-
kdhtdi a`jis ef keandssmdj.
drstwgond seniodrs
pdrg`ps
oj tgd `rmods
ef Hgoj`. Jertg er Xeutg. wonn prdy ej tgd heujtrysoid* Ygdrd wonn.
ot os `imottdi. ad yd`rs ef budrronn` fobgtojb ef ` idsuntery aut orrot`tojb
sert. wgohg n`hl ef r`onw`ys `ji meter re`is `ji hemmujoh`toejs
bdjdr`nny wonn m`ld ioffohunt ef supprdssoej* Ygdrd wonn ad tgd Kdssd
K`mdsds `ji tgd Hend _eujbdrs ef tgd aeridr n`jis te tgd Rdst ef
Hgoj` fer m`jy ` tdioeus yd`r tg`t os br`jtdi* Rg`t tgd mdj oj
hg`rbd ef tgos g`i oj moji forst w`s bdttojb ` st`rt ej tgdor nejb `ji.
fer tgdm. pdrg`ps. jdvdr-djiojb pn`j*
Ygd hrotohosm tg`t tgos os g`riny tgd tomd te tgojl ef sddlojb furtgdr
dxp`jsoej os pdrg`ps wdnn breujidi* Aut ot os ioffohunt te hejvojhd tgd
J`jlojb Hgojdsd. jew oj Hgujblojb ef tg`t f`ht* Ygdy s`w tgd
rdvenutoej brew oj tdj yd`rs frem ` tojy uprosojb `reuji H`jtej te `
j`toejwoid mevdmdjt Ygd `rmods frem H`jtej. Qusso`j buoidi. wotg
prep`b`ji` `ji ` sohl Jertg `s tgdor `nnods. m`rhgdi wotg hemp`r`tovd
d`sd `hress tgd djtord f`hd ef Hgoj` oj ndss tg`j twe yd`rs `ji. oj `
md`surd. ujofodi tgd j`toej* Ot os jet ioffohunt. tgdj. fer tgdm te ird`m
ef `hhempnosgojb semdtgojb somon`r oj tgdor nofdtomd fer `nmest `nn @so`*
Ygdrd os je tdnnojb tgd euthemd ef tgdor n`aers. tg`t os hdrt`oj* Aut
ot must ad `imottdi tg`t tgd shepd ef tgdor shgdmd `nejd os semdtgojb
te `imord. te poqud tgd om`boj`toej* Ot os `j ojtdrdstojb of jet `
hurrdjtny ompert`jt pg`sd ef tgd `htovotods ef tgd Hgujblojb Bevdrj-
mdjt.
Iovdrbdjhd oj tgd speldj n`jbu`bd os ejd ef tgd aobbdst east`hnds
te ujoty oj tgd @so`toh heujtrods. `s oj Durepd* Ygd Mojostry ef
Diuh`toej oj tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt g`s ` prebr`m te pepun`rozd
tgd usd ef M`ji`roj `s tgd effoho`n `ji. dvdjtu`nny. tgd ejny n`jbu`bd
ef `nn Hgoj`* Ygd weri m`ji`roj md`js effoho`n. oj Hgojdsd* @M`ji`roj oj tgd eni i`ys w`s ` m`bostr`td* Gdjhd. tgd M`ji`roj
n`jbu`bd w`s tgd effoho`n heurt n`jbu`bd*
Rgdjdvdr ` m`j ef premojdjhd oj Hgoj` m`lds `j `iirdss gd
prdfdrs te spd`l oj M`ji`roj Etgdrwosd gos `uiodjhd mobgt tgojl
gom ujdiuh`tdi `ji ujwertgy ef gos gobg effohd* Dvdj stuidjts oj
gobg shgeens `ji henndbds oj Xg`jbg`o `ji tgd seutg ef Hgoj` ie jet
`nn spd`l M`ji`roj. `ntgeubg tgd m`keroty ef tgdm ieuatndss h`j
ujidrst`ji oj ` bdjdr`n w`y wgdj speldj te oj tgd effoho`n tejbud*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 213/455
@ IQD@M YG@Y QOV@NX BDJBGOX LG@J 108
Ot os `nse ` f`ht tg`t m`jy stuidjts rdturjojb te Hgoj` frem @mdroh`j
ujovdrsotods wgdj spd`lojb te etgdr stuidjts frem ` ioffdrdjt sdhtoej
ef Hgoj` t`nl oj Djbnosg* Jew `ji tgdj tgdy m`y n`psd ojte tgdor
ewj tejbud er spd`l M`ji`roj of tgdy `rd `and. aut ot os ojtdrdstojb
te jetd tg`t wgdj tgdy ie tgos tgdy `nmest ojv`ro`any `hhemp`jy tgdor
weris wotg ` ir`wojb ef tgd Hgojdsd hg`r`htdr oj tgd `or er ej semd
hejvdjodjt surf`hd*
Ygd wrottdj n`jbu`bd. ef heursd. os tgd s`md tgreubgeut Hgoj`*
Ygd hg`r`htdrs. tg`t os. `rd tgd s`md* Ygdrd m`y ad semd sg`ids ef
md`jojb oj v`roeus sdhtoejs ef tgd heujtry tg`t ioffdr frem etgdrs.
aut tgdsd `rd hemp`r`tovdny fdw*
Ygd usd ef poiboj Djbnosg os wdnn jobg ujovdrs`n `mejb tgd
newdr hn`ssds* Fer dx`mpnd. m`jy ef tgd sdrv`jts ej ae`ri tgd tr`js-
S`hofoh nojdrs `rd Hgojdsd* Ygdsd Hgojdsd aeys m`y hemd frem `jy
sdhtoej ef Hgoj`* @ji wgdj. `s eftdj ehhurs. ` Xg`jbg`o aey w`jts
te be ej `j drr`ji wgond gos sgop os oj pert oj Gejblejb. gd spd`ls
oj poiboj Djbnosg* Ygos pdhuno`r `ji pohturdsqud k`rbej g`s brewj
up `nejb tgd Hgoj` he`st oj tgd p`st hdjtury*
Ot os jet. `s os bdjdr`nny suppesdi. ` rdsunt ejny ef tgd Hgojdsd
dfferts te nd`rj ` usdfun ar`ji ef Djbnosg* Ot g`s brewj eut ef dfferts
ej d`hg soid te rd`hg semd speldj mdtgei ef dxprdssoej rd`iony hem-
prdgdjsoand te tgd etgdr* Ygd dxprdssoejs `rd m`id ay tgd usd ef
Djbnosg weris er pdrvdrsoejs ef Djbnosg weris. trud* Aut tgd ferm
oj tgd m`oj os ` iordht tr`jsn`toej ef tgd Hgojdsd dxprdssoej fer tgd
s`md md`jojb* Fer dx`mpnd. of ejd w`jts ` rohlsg`w gd tdnns tgd
Hgojdsd aey semdtgojb nold tgos; My w`jthgdd ejd podhod rohlsg`w*
Jew tg`t os jet `s f`r frem wg`t tgd Hgojdsd weuni s`y oj gos ewj
n`jbu`bd `s ejd mobgt tgojl* Ygos n`jbu`bd g`s usdi Djbnosg `s
ots a`sos ej ` suastruhturd ef Hgojdsd br`mm`toh`n hejstruhtoej*
Ygd preandm ef td`hgojb tgd Hgojdsd m`ssds te spd`l ` jdw n`j-
bu`bd `ji tg`t os wg`t M`ji`roj os te tgdm os ` aob ejd* Ygdrd
`rd prea`any `s m`jy n`jbu`bds. er io`ndhts. oj Hgoj` `s tgdrd `rd
n`jbu`bds oj Durepd* Ot os `nmest nold tryojb te td`hg dvdry m`j.
wem`j `ji hgoni oj Durepd te spd`l Djbnosg. er `jy etgdr ejd
n`jbu`bd* Yg`t mobgt dvdj ad d`sodr adh`usd tgd st`ji`ri ef diu-
h`toej tgdrd os ojfojotdny gobgdr. tgdrd `rd puanoh shgeen systdms `nrd`iy
oj epdr`toej `ji tgd puanoh bdjdr`nny g`s nd`rjdi te rd`i `ji wrotd*
Ay f`r tgd brd`tdr p`rt ef tgd Hgojdsd pdepnd h`jjet dvdj rd`i `ji
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 214/455
109 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
wrotd* @ st`rt must ad m`id. gewdvdr. `utgerotods oj tgd Mojostry ef
Diuh`toej fdnt* Gdjhd. ` J`toej`n N`jbu`bd Tjofoh`toej Srdp`r`tery
Hemmottdd g`s addj `ppeojtdi*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 215/455
07 XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD
JE QDHEQI ef tgdsd storrojb yd`rs wgohg wd `rd ioshussojb
weuni ad hempndtd wotgeut ` hg`ptdr idvetdi te tgd stery ef
ef tgd @mdroh`js `ji Djbnosgmdj wge wdrd tgdj oj pesotoejs
ef `utgeroty oj Hgoj`*
Ygos rdsumd ef tgd `htovotods ef tgesd nd`idrs ef mdj h`rrods us
a`hl fer ` arodf memdjt te tgd semadr p`ssojb ef ` M`rojd effohdr.
wge iodi ay gos ewj g`ji* Ygd tr`boh id`tg oj Xg`jbg`o ef Henejdn
Hg`rnds X`jidrsej Gonn. hemm`jiojb effohdr ef tgd 9tg Qdbomdjt ef
tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojds. rdmevdi ejd ef tgd mest aronno`jt foburds
oj tgos ar`jhg ef tgd @mdroh`j sdrvohd* Henejdn Gonn w`s feuji id`i
oj gos adireem `t Qdbomdjt`n Gd`iqu`rtdrs Mdss oj tgd Frdjhg Hej-
hdssoej. `t 7;17 ej tgd merjojb ef Meji`y. Xdptdmadr 4. 0?12* Oj
gos robgt g`ji w`s `j `utem`toh posten @ aunndt tgreubg tgd ar`oj
g`i h`usdi id`tg* @pp`rdjtny tgd a`rrdn ef tgd sdrvohd wd`pej g`i
addj pn`hdi oj gos meutg `ji tgd posten ioshg`rbdi*
Henejdn Gonn g`i jet addj oj beei gd`ntg sojhd gos `rrov`n tgd
prdhdiojb Fdaru`ry oj hemm`ji ef tgd forst hejtojbdjt ef @mdroh`jM`rojds te hemd eut te Hgoj` oj tgd dmdrbdjhy* Idspejidjhy aer-
idrojb ej mdn`jhgeno`. ojiuhdi ay gos hejst`jt ojiospesotoej. w`s. tgd
effoho`n rdpert s`oi. tgd `pp`rdjt metovd fer gos suohoid*
Gos id`tg w`s ` iostojht sgehl te Xg`jbg`o. wgdrd tgd hemm`jidr
g`i adhemd mest pepun`r iurojb gos hemp`r`tovdny sgert rdsoidjhd*
Gd g`i addj `htovd oj tgd nofd ef tgd ferdobj hemmujoty `ji gos kevo`n
beei j`turd `t tgd hnuas `ji dnsdwgdrd g`i wej gom ` gest ef rd`n
frodjis* Idspotd gos onnjdss. Henejdn Gonn rdfusdi te hd`sd werl. `jigd `ppd`rdi tgreubg tgd gd`t ef @ubust `t gos effohd `t M`rojd gd`i-
qu`rtdrs dvdry i`y up te tgd n`st*
Ygd Meji`y merjojb ef gos id`tg Henejdn Gonn `resd `s usu`n. g`i
ard`lf`st wotg tgd @mdroh`j j`v`n mdioh`n effohdr `tt`hgdi te tgd 9tg
Qdbomdjt. `ji wdjt a`hl upst`ors* Oj funn ujoferm. st`jiojb adsoid
gos adi. gd pn`hdi gos posten oj gos meutg `ji fordi* Ygd iehter gd`ri
104
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 216/455
106 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
gos aeiy f`nn `ji rusgdi ojte tgd reem te foji tgd hemm`jidr nyojb
ej tgd fneer id`i* Nodut*-Henejdn F* I* Lonberd. wge suhhddidi
Henejdn Gonn `s hemm`jiojb effohdr. tdndpgejdi md sgertny `ftdr dndvdj
e"hnehl tg`t merjojb* O wosg yeu weuni hemd eut te Gd`iqu`rtdrs
`s seej `s pessoand. gd s`oi* Henejdn Gonn iodi tgos merjojb%"
Henejdn Hg`rnds X`jidrsej Gonn w`s ` br`iu`td aetg ef @jj`penos
`ji Rdst Seojt. `ji w`s rdb`ridi `s ejd ef tgd adst shgeendi effohdrs
oj tgd sdrvohd* Gos h`rddr w`s eutst`jiojb oj m`jy w`ys. `ji ot w`s
rumerdi tg`t gd w`s sgertny te g`vd addj r`osdi te tgd r`jl ef
Arob`iodr-Bdjdr`n Iurojb gos nejb sdrvohd oj tgd M`rojd Herps.
Henejdn Gonn teel `j `htovd p`rt oj v`roeus h`mp`objs. ojhnuiojb
sdrvohd oj Hgoj` iurojb tgd Aexdr Qdadnnoej. oj tgd Sgonoppojds. oj tgd
Xp`josg-@mdroh`j R`r. `ji evdrsd`s iuty iurojb tgd Rerni R`r*
Sroer te tgd Xp`josg-@mdroh`j R`r. gd g`i sdrvdi `s ` j`v`n h`idt*
Oj @pron. 07??. gd `hhdptdi ` hemmossoej oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds M`rojd
Herps*
Iurojb tgd Aexdr Qdadnnoej. Henejdn Gonn sdrvdi `ae`ri sgop oj
Hgojdsd w`tdrs @ftdr sdrvohd oj tgd Sgonoppojds gd adh`md M`rojd
Fnddt Effohdr oj tgd S`hofoh Fnddt. t`lojb `j `htovd p`rt oj tgd h`mp`obj
oj Joh`r`bu` oj 0?01* Iurojb tgd Rerni R`r Henejdn Gonn w`s
`tt`hgdi te tgd @nnodi `rmods `s `j easdrvdr oj Fr`jhd. ` pest `t wgohg
gd wej pr`osd* @ftdr tgd w`r. gd w`s Hemm`jiojb Effohdr ef tgd
M`rojd A`rr`hls. J`vy _`ri. Sgon`idnpgo`. frem 0?18 te 0?16* Gd
w`s tr`jsfdrrdi te X`j Iodbe `s Hemm`jidr ef tgd 9tg Qdbomdjt. `ji
h`md te Hgoj` wotg tgdm*
+ + +
Rotg tgd `ppeojtmdjt d`rny oj 0?1? ef Mr* F* R* M`zd. fermdrny
Hemmossoejdr ef Hustems `t Xg`jbg`o. `s Ojspdhter-Bdjdr`n ef Hus-
tems. tgd Ojspdhter`td-Bdjdr`n w`s rdmevdi frem Sdlojb te J`jlojb*
Ygd X`nt B`adnnd effohds wdrd hnesdi oj Sdlojb semd mejtgs adferd
`ji j`tur`nny tgd Hgojdsd Bevdrjmdjt `imojostr`tovd effohds oj Sdlojb
ujidr tgd eni rdbomds wdrd hnesdi wgdj Sdlojb fdnn* Ygd J`jlojbBevdrjmdjt idtdrmojdi te m`ld tgd jdw h`pot`n tgd h`pot`n oj f`ht `s
wdnn `s oj j`md wotg tgd sgertdst pessoand idn`y*
Ygd `ppeojtmdjt ef Mr* M`zd. wge os Arotosg `ji jew Xor
Frdidrohl M`zd. ioi jet hemd `s ` surprosd. `ntgeubg ot w`s jet
bdjdr`nny ljewj tg`t gos suhhdssoej te Mr* @. G* F. Diw`rids. `nse
Arotosg. weuni hemd se quohlny. Ygdrd g`i addj semdtgojb ef ` fobgt
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 217/455
XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD 102
ej adtwddj wg`t adh`md ljewj `s tgd M`zd `ji tgd Diw`rids f`h-
toejs oj tgd Hustems @imojostr`toej* Diw`rids w`s `ppeojtdi @htojb
Ojspdhter-Bdjdr`n oj Fdaru`ry ef 0?12.
suhhddiojb
Xor Fr`jhos
@bndjwge w`s eustdi ay tgd n`td M`rsg`n Hg`jb Yse-noj. tgdj oj pewdr oj
Sdlojb* Gos `ppeojtmdjt w`s fer ejd yd`r* Ot g`i dxpordi. aut gd
hejtojudi adh`usd ef tgd hejtoju`jhd ef tgd hovon w`r `ji ots `ttdji`jt
iosturadi hejiotoejs tgreubgeut tgd heujtry*
Fennewojb tgd f`nn ef Sdlojb. tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt turjdi ots
`ttdjtoej te `ff`ors ef st`td* Ejd ef tgd preandms w`s tgd st`tus ef
Mr* Diw`rids `ji tgd pessoand `ppeojtmdjt ef ` suhhdsser* Mr* M`zd.
ot w`s ljewj. w`s frodjiny tew`ri tgd jdw Bevdrjmdjt wgond tgdrd
wdrd semd wge fdnt. pdrg`ps. tg`t Mr* Diw`rids. wgond ieuatndss
dffohodjt. mobgt jet werl se wdnn wotg tgd Mojostry ef Foj`jhd oj
J`jlojb*
Rg`tdvdr tgd epojoejs wdrd tg`t h`usdi tgd preandm te adhemd
merd er ndss `hutd. tgd f`ht rdm`ojs tg`t Mr* Diw`rids" rd-`ppeojtmdjt
er iosmoss`n w`s gdni up fer mejtgs pdjiojb ` idfojotd idhosoej* Ygdj
oj tgd `utumj ef 0?17 h`md `jjeujhdmdjt ef tgd Mojostry ef Foj`jhd
ef gos `ppeojtmdjt `s effoho`tojb Ojspdhter-Bdjdr`n* Mr* M`zd w`s
bovdj `j `sseho`td pesotoej oj tgd Hustems `t tgd s`md tomd. wgond
hejtojuojb `s Hemmossoejdr oj Xg`jbg`o* Ot w`s aruotdi `aeut tgdj
tg`t tgos w`s mdrdny ` f`hd-s`vojb prepesotoej fer Mr* Diw`rids.
`ji tg`t gd weuni seej g`vd te rdsobj* Gd ioi. `ji oj gos jetd ef
rdsobj`toej ossudikust
adferd tgd dji ef tgd yd`r. gd idpnerdi tgd iu`n
hejtren*
Mr* M`zd w`s `ppeojtdi `nmest `t ejhd. `s g`i addj dxpdhtdi. `ji.
prea`any `htojb ej ojstruhtoejs frem Foj`jhd Mojostdr Y* V* Xeejb.
eridrdi tgd rdmev`n ef tgd @imojostr`toej effohds te J`jlojb* Ygdy
fujhtoejdi oj Xg`jbg`o pdjiojb tgd hejstruhtoej ef `idqu`td effohd
auoniojbs oj tgd jdw h`pot`n Effohd sp`hd w`s `t ` prdmoum `ji tgd
Ojspdhter`td-Bdjdr`n nold m`jy etgdr iovosoejs ef tgd Bevdrjmdjt
fujhtoejdi `s adst ot heuni tgdrd `ji oj J`jlojb*
Mr* M`zd g`i addj oj tgd Hustems sdrvohd fer merd tg`j ` qu`rtdr
ef ` hdjtury `ji gos `ppeojtmdjt w`s rdb`ridi wotg s`tosf`htoej oj
mest horhnds* Ygdrd w`s semd ojioh`toej `t tgd tomd ef gos dndv`toej
te hgodf ef tgd sdrvohd tg`t. oj`smuhg `s gd mobgt ad dxpdhtdi te rdtord
oj twe yd`rs er se. gd w`s bovdj tgd effohd `s ` tdmper`ry hempremosd*
Ygos w`s effoho`nny idjodi*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 218/455
107 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ot w`s ljewj. gewdvdr. tg`t tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt `spordi te
rdb`oj hempndtd hejtren ef tgd Hustems @imojostr`toej* Gdjhd. tgd
rumer pdrsostdi tg`t dfferts te tgos dji weuni ad fertghemojb `t je
iost`jt i`td* Ygd @imojostr`toej w`s dst`anosgdi eroboj`nny semd
soxty yd`rs `be `s ` md`js ef s`fdbu`riojb tgd brd`t ferdobj idats
sdhurdi ej tgd Hustems* Ygd Sewdrs ojtdrdstdi. hgodfny Arot`oj.
K`p`j `ji Fr`jhd. h`j g`riny ad dxpdhtdi te bovd up tgos ferm ef
supdrvosoej `s nejb `s tgdrd `rd eutst`jiojb ne`js sdhurdi ej tgd
t`roffs* Gewdvdr. ot weuni jet ad surprosojb te sdd tgd Hustems
Ojspdhter`td-Bdjdr`nsgop be te ` Hgojdsd oj tgd jdxt fdw yd`rs
+ + +
@ jdw dr` w`s n`ujhgdi oj Fdaru`ry. 0?1?. oj Hgoj`"s nejb ios-
turadi foj`jho`n sotu`toej wotg tgd `rrov`n ef ` hemmossoej ef soxtddj
@mdroh`j dhejemoh dxpdrts gd`idi ay Sref* Diwoj R`ntdr Ldmmdrdr.
tgd mejdy-iehter. te sddl te st`aonozd tgd v`rodi hurrdjhy ef tgd
j`toej `ji pessoany te hg`jbd tgd sonvdr st`ji`ri te beni* Ygd hem-
mossoej ojhnuidi jumdreus premojdjt @mdroh`js jetdi fer tgdor ljewn-
dibd ef a`jlojb. auibdtojb. hurrdjhy. fosh`n `ji foj`jhojb preandms*
Ygd breup w`s `mejb m`jy somon`r hemmossoejs wgohg wdrd tgdj
wotg @mdroh`j djdrby `oiojb tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt te prehddi
s`jdny wotg ots `maotoeus shgdmds te rdjev`td tgd w`r-terj `ji a`hl-
w`ri heujtry ej meidrj nojds*
Srefdsser Ldmmdrdr g`i jet muhg te s`y upej n`jiojb etgdr tg`j
te rdm`rl. @ iehter os uj`and te io`bjesd tgd p`todjt proer te `j
dx`moj`toej. aut gd `iidi tg`t gd ojtdjidi te bdt te werl ommd-
io`tdny* Gd hejfdrrdi wotg tgd Foj`jhd Mojostdr. Y* V* Xeejb. mest
ef tg`t i`y `ji `nse wotg tgd Q`onw`ys Mojostdr. Xuj-Fe* Ygd moni-
m`jjdrdi aut djdrbdtoh prefdsser oj gos d`rny foftods. wge g`s rdvovdi
tgd iyojb foj`jhds ef jumdreus j`toejs iurojb gos rdm`rl`and h`rddr.
w`s jejhemmott`n hejhdrjojb tgd `oms ef tgd hemmossoej aut gd
sddmdi mest d`bdr te st`rt werl ej tgd t`sl fer wgohg Srojhdtej
Tjovdrsoty `nnewdi gom te ad `asdjt fer ` yd`r frem tgd hg`or ef
dhejemohs*
Ygd hgodf `ssobjmdjt w`s tgdhdjtr`nozojb ef Fdidr`n hejtren ef
Hgoj`"s rdvdjuds. te ad fennewdi ay dst`anosgojb ` ujoferm hurrdjhy
ef tgd s`md dxhg`jbd v`nud tgreubgeut tgd heujtry* Ygd tgori t`sl
w`s te `aenosg tgd t`dn systdm. wgohg os tgd hustem ef usojb ejd eujhd
ef purd sonvdr. ljewj `s tgd t`dn. `s tgd a`sos ef dxhg`jbd. h`usojb `
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 219/455
XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD 10?
ieuand tr`js`htoej wgdj hg`jbojb ferdobj hurrdjhy ojte `jy Hgojdsd
mejdy er vohd vdrs`* Ygd Hemmossoej eutnojdi ` auibdt ej tgd pr`h-
toh`n a`sos ef hurrdjt rdvdjuds wgohg hevdrdi hejstruhtoej prekdhts ef
v`st shepd `ji wgohg w`s idsobjdi te rdp`y tgd jumdreus ferdobj
ne`js te Hgoj` oj tgd sgertdst pessoand pdroei*
Sremojdjt mdmadrs ef tgd hemmossoej wdrd Ir* @rtgur Johgens
_eujb. dxpdrt oj puanoh hrdiot. wge rdsobjdi `s dhejemoh `ivosdr te
tgd Xt`td Idp`rtmdjt< Ir* Enovdr H* Nehlg`rt. Herjdnn `ji Auff`ne
Tjovdrsotods. t`x dxpdrt< R* A Sen`ji. Rdst Seojt. J* _*. dxpdrt oj
r`onw`y foj`jhd< Ir* Adjk`moj A* R`nn`hd. fer semd yd`rs spdho`n
dxpdrt te tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Y`roff Hemmossoej< Ir* Frdidrohl @*
Hndvdn`ji. Aestej Tjovdrsoty. auibdt dxpdrt< F* A* Nyjhg ef tgd
J`toej`n Hoty A`jl. dxpdrt ej a`jlojb mdtgeis< Ronno`m R`tsej.
fermdrny ef tgd f`hunty ef Xyr`husd Tjovdrsoty. spdho`nost oj fosh`n hej-
tren< Qohg`ri R* Aejjdvonnd. fermdrny ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Hem-
mdrhd Idp`rtmdjt. dxpdrt oj fosh`n hejtren< Diw`ri F* Fddny ef Jdw
_erl. hejsunt`jt ej dxpert tr`id foj`jhojb 8 bdjdr`n sdhrdt`ry ef tgd
hemmossoej. `ji Ir* Fr`jl R* Fdttdr. br`iu`td ef Srojhdtej `ji
G`rv`ri `ji prefdsser ef dhejemohs `t Srojhdtej. ujidrsdhrdt`ry*
Etgdr mdmadrs ojhnuidi tgd st`ff `ji tgdor f`monods. `ji semd rdm`ojdi
nejbdr tg`j ` yd`r*
Ygd ojfnux ef @mdroh`j `ivosdrs. er dxpdrts. omprdssdi ferdobjdrs
`s wdnn `s tgd Hgojdsd wotg tgd idtdrmoj`toej ef J`jlojb te prehddi
ej wg`t. ndss tg`j ` yd`r d`rnodr. wdrd hejsoidrdi tgd ompr`htoh`n
vosoejs ef ird`mdrs `ji oid`nosts* Ygd prdiemoj`jt p`rt @mdroh`js
pn`ydi oj tgd rdauoniojb ef Hgoj` h`usdi ojhrd`sojb hemmdjt* Ir*
Ldmmdrdr strdssdi tgd f`ht tg`t `nn mdmadrs ef tgd hemmossoej fer-
mdrny hejjdhtdi wotg tgd R`sgojbtej Bevdrjmdjt g`i sdvdrdi tgdor
effoho`n hejjdhtoejs proer te hemojb te Hgoj`< gdjhd. tgd hemmossoej
w`s ujeffoho`n* Ygdrd w`s je sdman`jhd ef @mdroh`j bevdrjmdjt`n
suppert wg`tsedvdr* + + +
Henejdn Gdjry N Xtomsej `ji Kegj V`j @* M`hMurr`y. tgdj
@mdroh`j Mojostdr. wdrd budsts ef Ir* H* Y* R`jb. fermdr Ferdobj
Mojostdr ef tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt. `ji Ir* G* G* Lujb. n`tdr
Mojostdr ef Foj`jhd. `t `j ojferm`n prov`td iojjdr oj Xg`jbg`o oj tgd
sprojb ef 0?1?* @mejb tgd etgdr budsts. `soid frem @mdroh`j ef-
foho`ns. wdrd etgdr H`aojdt mdmadrs `ji semd ef Henejdn Xtomsej"s
Hgojdsd frodjis oj gobg effoho`n pesotoejs*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 220/455
113 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygd fujhtoej w`s djtordny ujeffoho`n* Mrs* Xtomsej `ji tgd wovds
ef tgd etgdrs wdrd prdsdjt `ji tgdrd wdrd je spddhgds. tgd Bevdrjer-
Bdjdr`n ef tgd Sgonoppojds idhnojojb effoho`nnyte ioshuss gos futurd er
`jy etgdr preandms iurojb gos semdwg`t gurrodi keurjdy te R`sgojb-
tej te adhemd Xdhrdt`ry ef Xt`td* Gd hejfdrrdi wotg Mr* M`hMurr`y
adferd tgd iojjdr. aut aetg effoho`ns ojsostdi tg`t tgdor mddtojb w`s
purdny pdrsej`n `ji w`s jet rdn`tdi te Henejdn Xtomsej"s prea`and
iordhtoej ef @mdroh`"s penohy tew`ri Hgoj` frem R`sgojbtej. tgd
Henejdn dxpn`ojojb tg`t gd w`s j`tur`nny ojtdrdstdi oj Hgojdsd `ff`ors
aut. fer tgd prdsdjt `t nd`st. purdny `s Bevdrjer-Bdjdr`n ef tgd Sgonop-
pojds `ji `j @mdroh`j hotozdj*
_eu `rd mddtojb md `s tgd Bevdrjer-Bdjdr`n ef tgd Sgonoppojds.
Henejdn Xtomsej teni md* O `m pesotovdny uj`and te `fform tgd rumers
ef my `ppeojtmdjt te tgd H`aojdt oj `jy pest wg`tdvdr* Xe f`r `s tgd
Sgonoppojds `rd hejhdrjdi. tgd p`st yd`r os bdjdr`nny hejsoidrdi te g`vd
m`id gostery oj eur rdn`toejs wotg tgd osn`jis. wgohg os gobgny br`to-
fyojb te md `ji te etgdrs oj my `imojostr`toej* O adnodvd tg`t tgd
dxprdssdi `ttotuid ef tgd Fonopoje nd`idrs. tgd idsord te heepdr`td wotg
tgd @mdroh`j `imojostr`toej ef tgd osn`jis os djtordny sojhdrd* Iurojb
tgd yd`r wd g`vd auont tgd fr`mdwerl ef tgos penohy wgohg O gepd wonn
nejb rdm`oj `ji brew* Yg`t tgd eni eppesotoej os f`iojb `w`y os
rd`sej`any hnd`r oj tgd brd`t idvdnepmdjts `nejb tgdsd nojds*
Mr* M`hMurr`y s`oi tg`t gos vosot te J`jlojb `ji Xg`jbg`o g`i
je penotoh`n ompert`jhd*
Ots ejny pessoand rdn`toej te puanoh `ff`ors. gd s`oi. w`s my
ojquory ojte hdrt`oj pg`sds ef J`jlojb"s jdw tr`idm`rl rdbostr`toej
n`w. wgohg O wosg te hn`rofy* O ioi jet ioshuss penotohs wotg Ir* R`jber `jy ejd dnsd ydstdri`y `t J`jlojb. `ji ioi jet ojtdji te* Ygd
purpesd ef my vosot w`s prom`rony te `hqu`ojt mysdnf pdrsej`nny wotg
tgd prebrdss ef `ff`ors `t J`jlojb* Mest ef tgd etgdr Mojostdrs g`vd
vosotdi J`jlojb rdhdjtny. `ji O g`i addj pn`jjojb ` somon`r keurjdy
fer semd tomd aut w`s uj`and te nd`vd Sdlojb ujton jew*+ + +
Rgdj tgd n`td @imor`n M`rl N* Arosten. hemm`jidr-oj-hgodf ef tgd
@mdroh`j J`v`n `ji M`rojd ferhds oj tgd F`r D`st fer twe yd`rs.
idp`rtdi fer R`sgojbtej `t tgd dji ef summdr ef 0?1?. gd ndft adgoji
` rdm`rl`any n`rbd `ji strolojbny sojhdrd horhnd ef frodjis jet ejny
`mejb tgd ferdobjdrs tgreubgeut tgd Erodjt. aut Hgojdsd ef `nn w`nls
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 221/455
XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD 110
ef nofd* Ygd j`v`n effohdr-iopnem`t h`md te Hgoj` frem Yurldy.
`rrovojb n`td oj @ubust. 0?12. `ji t`lojb evdr hemm`ji ef tgd @so`toh
Xt`toej ej Xdptdmadr ? ef tg`t yd`r frem @imor`n H* X* Ronno`ms*
Ygdrd g`vd. te ad surd. addj je ujpepun`r mdj wge g`vd gdni tgos
gobg pest oj tgd @mdroh`j J`vy. aut ot os pdrg`ps jet ojherrdht te s`y
tg`t wotg tgd `ivdjt ef @imor`n Arosten"s `ssumptoej ef hemm`ji `
stonn merd herio`n rdn`toejsgop dxostdi adtwddj tgd gd`i ef eur pre-
tdhtovd ferhds tgdrd `ji tgd ausojdss mdj. @mdroh`j mossoej`rods `ji
etgdrs wge wdjt eut te tgd d`st te are`idj tgd shepd ef eur hemmdrhd
`ji hovonoz`toej oj tgd werni* Frem tgd vdry adbojjojb. @imor`n
Arosten m`id ot `pp`rdjt gd w`jtdi te mddt tgd ausojdss mdj. te bdt
tgdor vodws. te ljew tgdor preandms* Gd noldwosd w`jtdi te mddt tgd
Hgojdsd wge wdrd iordhtojb tgd idstojods ef tgdor heujtry* Gd mdt
tgd mdj hejiuhtojb tgd J`toej`nost rdvenutoej oj Xg`jbg`o. `ji n`tdr
gd wdjt jertg `ji oj Sdlojb `ji dnsdwgdrd mdt tgd mdj wge wdrd
tgdj hema`tojb tgd Xeutgdrj ferhds*
Gd w`jtdi te bdt `t `nn soids ef tgd sotu`toej* @ji gd ljdw gew
te be `aeut ot* Ygd sekeurj ef tgd @imor`n oj @so`toh w`tdrs w`s jet
gos forst* Gd wdjt eut te Hgoj` `s `j djsobj jd`rny fofty yd`rs `be
`ji n`tdr sdrvdi ej tgd _`jbtzd S`tren `ji w`s oj Hgoj` `t tgd eut-
ard`l ef tgd forst rdvenutoej oj 0?00. wgdj tgd M`jhgu Iyj`sty w`s
evdrtgrewj `ji tgd forst `ttdmpts `t ` Qdpuanoh wdrd ojdffdhtovdny aut
pdrsostdjtny m`id* Furtgdrmerd. gos dxpdrodjhd `s tgd @mdroh`j Gobg
Hemmossoejdr oj Yurldy. iurojb ` strolojbny somon`r pdroei wgdj tg`t
heujtry `ftdr tgd Brd`t R`r wdjt tgreubg ` pdroei ef j`toej`n rdg`-
aonot`toej `ji bevdrjmdjt`n rdferm. steei tgd @imor`n oj beei std`i
oj Hgoj`*
Buoidi ay gos dxpdrodjhds oj tgd Jd`r D`st fennewojb ` h`rdfun
stuiy ef `ff`ors `s tgdy wdrd wgdj gd `rrovdi oj Hgoj`. @imor`n
Arosten fermdi tgd hejvohtoej tg`t tgd J`toej`nost ferhds oj Hgoj`
weuni dmdrbd vohteroeus* Gd j`tur`nny heuni t`ld je soids dotgdr oj
weri er `ht. aut tgdrd w`s ` tdjidjhy oj gos `ttotuid te nd`j tew`ri
tgd J`toej`nosts `s tgd adttdr ferhd tew`ri prebrdss fer tgd pdepnd ef
tgd heujtry* Gd m`id ot ` peojt jdvdr te prepgdsy* Jdvdrtgdndss.
gos sdjsojb ef tgd trdji ef dvdjts w`s `s `hhur`td ` a`remdtdr `s
heuni ad idsordi. `s tgojbs turjdi eut* @ji gd w`s `and te kuibd
r`tgdr adttdr tg`j etgdr easdrvdrs adh`usd ef gos herio`n `ttotuid
tew`ri tgd Hgojdsd wge heuni bovd gom ojferm`toej hejhdrjojb wg`t
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 222/455
111 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
w`s g`ppdjojb oj tgos er tg`t f`htoej oj tgd rdvenutoej er oj tgd Jertg*
@imor`n Arosten sdrvdi oj tgd @so`toh Xt`toej `t ` tomd wgdj ot
w`s gobgny ompert`jt te lddp pestdi* Xe `mejb tgd forst tgojbs gd
ioi w`s te bdt `hqu`ojtdi pdrsej`nny wotg suhg mdj `s tgd n`td Ir*
H* H* Ru. tgdj Ferdobj Mojostdr oj tgd J`jlojb Bevdrjmdjt. Ir*
H* Y* R`jb. tgdj jet effoho`nny oj penotohsaut n`tdr Ferdobj Mojostdr
`t J`jlojb `ji ejhd @ma`ss`ier oj R`sgojbtej. Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl. `ji etgdrs*
Gd mdt tgdsd mdj. t`nldi wotg tgdm. `ji nd`rjdi muhg frem tgos
pdrsej`n hejt`ht* Ygd mddtojbs `nw`ys wdrd purdny ujeffoho`n. te ad
surd* R`sgojbtej g`i jet tgdj rdhebjozdi J`jlojb* Ygd n`ji w`s
iovoidi ay hovon w`r* Ot w`s ` tomd rdquorojb iopnem`toh prehdiurd
ojiddi te mddt tgd mdj ej aetg soids wotg dqu`n t`ht `ji ojtdrdstdi
frodjisgop* Ygdrd w`s jdvdr tgdj jer g`s tgdrd dvdr addj `jy rd`sej
te tgojl @imor`n Arosten. ay mddtojb mdj oj tgd forst J`jlojb Bevdrj-
mdjt. ndjt dvdj mer`n `oi te tg`t h`usd* Jer ay ioshussojb `ff`ors
wotg tgd mdj oj Sdlojb ioi gd g`vd `jy jetoej ef ojfnudjhojb tgdm
ejd w`y er tgd etgdr* Gd w`s mdrdny sddlojb ojferm`toej. `ji gd
bet ot*
@ji gd bet semd hrotohosm. `s wdnn* Ygdrd w`s fer ` wgond semd-
tgojb ef ` fddnojb tg`t tgd @imor`n w`s jet djtordny ioshrddt oj mddtojb
tgd mdj nd`iojb ` rdvenutoej`ry h`usd* Ot w`s s`oi oj v`roeus horhnds
tg`t pdrg`ps gd weuni h`usd treuand ay suhg `htoejs Gos frodjisgop
tew`ri tgd Hgojdsd. wg`tdvdr tgdor penotohs. `reusdi ` hdrt`oj `jtop`tgy
`mejb tgesd ferdobjdrs wge wdrd jet `and te sdd tgd snobgtdst hg`jbd
oj Hgoj`* Gos `ivohd jdvdr bovdj `s `ivohd aut mdrdny `s epojoej
oj frodjiny hejvdrs`toejs wotg @mdroh`j rdsoidjts tg`t tgd ferdobjdrs
sgeuni bdt adttdr `hqu`ojtdi wotg tgd Hgojdsd. `hhdptojb tgdm seho`nny
te ` brd`tdr idbrdd `ji trd`tojb tgdm `s dqu`ns. areubgt gd`tdi `rbu-
mdjts* Aut tgdrd os ` hg`jbdi `ttotuid jew. `ji tgesd wge hrotohozdi
h`md te `imot tgd @imor`n"s ferdsobgtdi penohy w`s herrdht*
Ygd @imor`n s`t oj tgd @mdroh`j Hnua oj Xg`jbg`o ejd dvdjojb O
rdh`nn `ji ioshussdi tgojbs wotg ` breup ef @mdroh`j easdrvdrs wdnn
vdrsdi oj Hgojdsd `ff`ors* Jew ot w`s vdry a`i ferm te quetd tgd
@imor`n* Gd idhn`rdi tgd i`y gd `rrovdi tg`t gd weuni jet ad
quetdi tgdj er `jy etgdr tomd ej `jy suakdht. `ji gd `nse s`oi of gd
wdrd quetdi gd weuni idjy `jytgojb oj projt `s hemojb frem gom*
Gd weuni ioshuss `jy suakdht `t ndjbtg. bdt tgd vodws ef tgesd gd w`s
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 223/455
XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD 118
t`nlojb wotg. bovd gos ewj epojoejs `ji tgdj. of ` jdwsp`pdrm`j ad
prdsdjt. gd weuni s`y oj p`rtojb; Tsd `jytgojb yeu"vd bet frem md
`s ` a`hlbreuji of yeu w`jt. aut yeu h`j"t quetd md* Ygdsd t`nls
`rd kust fer eur ewj ojferm`toej* Ygdy werl aetg w`ys* O m`y bdt
semdtgojb frem yeu `ji yeu m`y bdt semdtgojb frem md. `ji wd m`y
aetg ujidrst`ji tgd sotu`toej adttdr* Aut iej"t quetd md*
Xe je ejd dvdr ioi* Aut jew pdrg`ps ` weri er twe tgd @imor`n
s`oi tgdj mobgt jet ad hejsoidrdi ndsd m`kdstd* Ygd easdrvdrs
rdfdrrdi te `aevd ojhnuidi twe w`r herrdspejidjts. ejd m`j tr`vdnnojb
oj Hgoj` b`tgdrojb m`tdro`n fer ` aeel. tgd @mdroh`j puanosgdr ef ejd
ef tgd n`rbdst Hgojdsd jdwsp`pdrs oj tgd j`toej. tgd @imor`n"s Hgodf-
ef-Xt`ff. H`pt* Ldjjdtg H`stndm`j. ` a`jldr. `ji twe er tgrdd mdj
iordhtojb n`rbd @mdroh`j hemmdrho`n ojtdrdsts. wge ldpt up ej penotoh`n
dvdjts merd tg`j w`s hustem`ry*
Ygd hejvdrs`toej w`s bdjdr`n fer tgd mest p`rt* Xemdejd areubgt
up tgd monot`ry pg`sd ef tgd rdvenutoej< tgd h`pturd ef Xg`jbg`o w`s
mdjtoejdi. `ji tgd dffdht ef tgos str`tdboh mevd ej tgd rdbomd `t
G`jlew* Ejd m`j. tgd wrotdr ef aeels. rdn`tdi gos dxpdrodjhds `
fdw wddls prdvoeusny wotg a`jiots ej tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr* Gd nest gos
w`nndt `ji `nn gos rd`iy h`sg. `ji gos wofd nest gdr kdwdnry. aut tgd
a`jiots. er por`tds. wge ae`ridi tgd rovdr std`mdr. ioi tgdm je aeiony
g`rm* Ygdy lonndi ejd er twe Hgojdsd oj tgdor dxhotdmdjt. gewdvdr.
`ji sget `j @mdroh`j frem G`jlew tgreubg tgd ndb fer je `pp`rdjt
rd`sej*
Ygd rdn`toejs ef ferdobjdrs wotg tgd Hgojdsd w`s mdjtoejdi* Xemd-
ejd wejidrdi wgdtgdr wd sgeuni `imot tgdm te eur hnuas* Ygos g`s
addj iejd jew `nn evdr Hgoj`. ` rdvenutoej`ry hg`jbd* Ygd @imor`n
s`oi;
O tgojl ot ` spndjioi oid`* Rd sgeuni `imot tgdm te tgd hnuas.
ay `nn md`js* Of wd trd`t tgdsd pdepnd `s dqu`ns. tgdy wonn jet f`on te
rd`ht te eur frodjisgop* Ygos hejhdptoej ef eur supdroeroty g`s bet te
ad iospdnndi* Ygdrd `rd Hgojdsd bdjtndmdj oj tgd Bevdrjmdjt ef tgos
j`toej tei`y wge `rd ay je md`js eur ojfdroers* Ot os trud. O br`jt.
tg`t wd sdd heujtndss tgeus`jis ef ojfdroer Hgojdsd oj eur i`ony novds*
Ygd heenods. tgd newdr hn`ssds. `rd eur ojfdroers* Ygd Hgojdsd r`hd
g`s preiuhdi semd brd`t shgen`rs `ji st`tdsmdj* Ygdrd os ` brd`t
hg`jbd beojb ej oj Hgoj` tei`y. `ji tgd w`vd ef j`toej`nosm swddpojb
tgd heujtry os beojb te rdsunt oj dvdj brd`tdr hg`jbds*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 224/455
119 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ot m`y t`ld semd tomd. ot os trud* Ygdrd `rd preandms tg`t wd
h`jjet dvdj `pprdho`td f`hojb tgd nd`idrs wge w`jt te ujofy tgd
Hgojdsd pdepnd* Rd `nn rd`nozd tgd
n`jbu`bdioffohunty. tgd n`hl ef
diuh`toej `mejb tgd m`ss ef Hgojdsd. tgd n`hl ef rd`iy hemmujoh`toejs
wgohg lddp tgd Hgojdsd `p`rt jet ejny frem tgd werni aut frem tgdm-
sdnvds* Ygdsd `rd v`st east`hnds. aut ot os pessoand fer tgd nd`idrs ef
tgd Hgojdsd dvdjtu`nny te evdrhemd tgdm*
O tgojl ` brd`t stdp g`s addj t`ldj oj tgos heujtry oj tgd p`st
twe yd`rs tew`ri `w`ldjojb ` brd`t j`toej* Ot os wrejb te idjy tg`t
hg`jbd os ehhurrojb* Of wd ujidrst`ji tg`t `ji `imot tgd Hgojdsd
te eur hnuas `ji trd`t tgdm seho`nny `s dqu`ns tgesd wge `rd diuh`tdi
Hgojdsd bdjtndmdj `ji bdjtndwemdj wd wonn g`vd nd`rjdi ` ndssej
jew tg`t wd must nd`rj seejdr er n`tdr*
Ygos sporot ef j`toej`n hejshoeusjdss os ay je md`js ` jdw
pgdjemdjej* Ot swdpt Durepd `ftdr tgd w`r `ji O g`i ` pdrsej`n
dxpdrodjhd wotg ot oj Yurldy adferd hemojb gdrd* Ygd hg`jbds oj
Hgoj` `rd vdry. vdry somon`r te tgd hg`jbds tg`t teel pn`hd oj Yurldy*
Ygd `aenotoej ef hejsun`rkurosiohtoej.
ef `nn spdho`n robgts ef ferdobjdrs.
tgd rosojb ojfnudjhd ef ` r`hd hejshoeusjdss `rd `nn somon`r te tgd dvdjts
`ji sdjtomdjt oj Hgoj` `ji `mejb tgd Hgojdsd* Rd heuni nd`rj muhg
ay stuiyojb tgd gostery ef Yurldy"s idvdnepmdjt sojhd tgd Brd`t R`r*
Ot os futond te idjy somon`r hg`jbds `rd ehhurrojb oj tgos heujtry
tei`y*
Yg`t. arodfny. w`s @imor`n Arosten"s hrdie ej Hgoj`* Ot w`s. O
mobgt `ii. tgd epojoej ef mest wdnn ojfermdi pdrsejs novojb oj tgd d`st
tgdj* Jdotgdr gd jer tgdy idjodi tg`t tgd hg`jbd te rd`n ujoty wonn
stonn rdquord tomd* Sdrg`ps tgos ujoty wonn dvdjtu`nny ad oj tgd ferm
ef ` fdidr`toej ef st`tds d`hg dvdj merd jd`rny `utejemeus tg`j `t
forst pn`jjdi somon`r oj ` w`y te tgd Fdidr`toej ef Bdrm`j Xt`tds
wdnidi ojte ` j`toej ndss tg`j ` hdjtury `be ay Aosm`rhl*
Ygd Hgojdsd tg`t novd oj tgd gojtdrn`jis ef @so` `ji monnoejs ef
tgd onnotdr`td novojb `nejb tgd S`hofoh he`st ljew `nn tee nottnd ef tgd
md`jojb ef tgd prebr`ms ef tgdor nd`idrs* Ygdy `rd hejtdjt te hej-
soidr tgdor f`mony `s tgd ujot. tgdor vonn`bd `s tgdor gemd. tgdor prev-
ojhd `s tgdor ujovdrsd* Ygdy wonn ad ney`n te tgdor f`mony `ji p`troetoh
oj ` v`ryojb idbrdd te tgdor j`tovd pn`hd `ji tgdor prevojhd* Aut tgd
oid` ef ` j`toej wonn t`ld tomd te sojl oj* Ot w`s tgos hejhdptoej tg`t
@imor`n Arosten g`i b`ojdi ej gos n`st sekeurj oj tgd d`st* Gos kuib-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 225/455
XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD 114
mdjt. ot os jew bdjdr`nny `brddi. w`s herrdht* Gd ujidrsteei tgd
preandms aut formny adnodvdi tgd tr`iotoej`n @mdroh`j penohy ef `ntruosm
`ji frodjisgop weuni hejtojud te prevd adst `ji tg`t tgd Hgojdsd
weuni dvdjtu`nny prevd tgdmsdnvds jet ujwertgy ef tg`t penohy*
Ygd seho`n `ff`ors ej ae`ri tgd fn`bsgop T* X* X* Sottsaurbg bovdj
ay tgd @imor`n `ji Mrs* Arosten. wge os `j djtordny hg`rmojb gestdss.
st`ji eut `s p`rtohun`rny mdmer`and fd`turds ef `jetgdr soid ef tgd
Hemm`jidr-oj-Hgodfs rdsoidjhd tgdrd* Hgojdsd `s wdnn `s @mdroh`js
`ji m`jy pdrsejs ef etgdr j`toej`notods oj tg`t hesmepenot`j pert
`ttdjidi tgd td` i`jhds ujidr tgd v`ro-henerdi `wjojb `ft ej tgd
hruosdr `ji tgd ehh`soej`n ferm`n dvdjojb a`nns ej tgd sp`hoeus fn`b-
sgop"s `ftdr idhl* Gos herio`n bdjo`noty `ji Mrs* Arosten"s br`hoeusjdss
woidjdi tgdor horhnd ef frodjis d`hg vosot*
@imor`n Arosten"s hnesd teuhg wotg tgd Hgojdsd w`s dxtdjidi te tgd
hemm`jidrs ef etgdr idfdjsd ferhds oj Xg`jbg`o* Gd w`s p`rtohun`rny
frodjiny wotg M`ker-Bdjdr`n Xor Kegj Iujh`j. fermdrny gd`i ef tgd
Arotosg Xg`jbg`o Idfdjsd Ferhd* Ygd Bdjdr`n w`s ` frdqudjt vosoter
`t tgd Arosten rdsoidjhd oj Xg`jbg`o `ji tgos hnesd seho`n hejt`ht
areubgt `aeut ` mutu`n ujidrst`jiojb tg`t m`id tgd senutoej ef
idfdjsd preandms d`sodr tg`j `jy ferm`n ioshussoej ef somon`r qudstoejs
heuni g`vd iejd* + + +
Kund`j @rjeni. tgd @mdroh`j hemmdrho`n `tt`hgd oj Sdopojb. wge
rdturjdi oj M`y 0?1? frem `j dxtdjsovd teur tgreubg Lw`jbso Srev-
ojhd `ji seutg ojte _ujj`j. s`oi upej gos `rrov`n oj Xg`jbg`o tg`t
idspotd ` w`r wotg Lw`jbtujb Srevojhd `reuji H`jtej. tgd pdepnd
ef Lw`jbso wdrd jet suffdrojb `pprdho`any `ji tg`t beei re`is wdrd
adojb auont oj m`jy sdhtoejs ef tgd prevojhd*
O tr`vdnndi merd tg`j ` tgeus`ji monds ay meter h`r tgreubg
Lw`jbso. Mr* @rjeni s`oi. evdr dxhdnndjt re`is* Ygdy `rd auoniojb
jdw gobgw`ys `nn tgd tomd. `ji wgond ot m`y ad semd yd`rs adferd
r`onre`is g`vd epdjdi up tgos prevojhd. tgd gobgw`ys `ji rovdrs wonn
h`rry `j ojhrd`sojb `meujt ef tgd f`rmdrs" beeis te tgd d`st he`st
m`rldts*
Mr* @rjeni s`oi gd tr`vdnndi vortu`nny `nejd. wotgeut ` bu`ri ef
`jy loji. `ji g`i je treuand `jywgdrd `nejb tgd reutd* Gd h`rrodi je
ferdobj feei `nejb jer `jy w`tdr a`bs er aettnds ef iostonndi w`tdr
te irojl* Gd `td Hgojdsd feei tgd wgend tomd. `ji wgond gd `imottdi
gd bet ` aot fdi up wotg ot.+" gd s`oi gd g`i jet werrodi `aeut gos
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 226/455
116 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
gd`ntg ej tgos `hheujt* Fdw of `jy ferdobjdrs oj tgd S`hofoh he`st
hotods `ji dnsdwgdrd oj Hgoj` d`t Hgojdsd feei ujndss tgdy ljew wgdrd
ot os prdp`rdi `ji gew* Yypgeoi fdvdr `ji iysdjtdry `rd `nn tee
prdv`ndjt te t`ld m`jy hg`jhds ej tgd s`jot`toej ef ` Hgojdsd rds-
t`ur`jt dvdj oj tgd ferdobj hejhdssoej `rd`s* Ot os p`rtohun`rny i`j-
bdreus `t hdrt`oj sd`sejs ef tgd yd`r te d`t brddj vdbdt`ands brewj
oj Hgoj` adh`usd tgd Hgojdsd fdrtonozd tgdor truhl b`ridjs wotg gum`j
jobgt seon%" ` hustem tgreubgeut tgd F`r D`st* O `td `jytgojb `ji
dvdrytgojb `s wd wdjt `nejb. Mr* @rjeni `imottdi* Bdt teubg. O
budss. `ftdr tgorty yd`rs eut oj tgos heujtry* O"vd g`i je onn dffdhts
kdt
Mr* @rjeni s`oi gd jetohdi nottnd treuand tgreubgeut tgd prevojhd*
Ot w`s `s pd`hdfun fer mond `ftdr mond ef fdrtond f`rm n`ji `s tgd
moiind wdst `t gemd%" gd s`oi* Ejd bdts tgd fddnojb ef adojb tdrroany
eut ef teuhg a`hl oj tgd gojtdrn`jis ef Hgoj`* Je jdws ef tgd
idvdnepmdjts oj J`jlojb er `are`i rd`hgdi us fer i`ys `t ` tomd*
Q`tgdr ` beei tgojb. `t tg`t. te bdt `w`y frem tgd jdws ef turmeon
fer `wgond. O tgojl* Ygd pdepnd iewj tgdrd ioij"t sddm te moji wg`t
g`ppdjdi oj J`jlojb er Xg`jbg`o er `jywgdrd dnsd `s nejb `s tgdy
g`i beei hreps `ji wdrd jet mendstdi*
A`jiots oj Lw`jbso wdrd fdw. Mr* @rjeni s`oi* Gd s`oi tgdy
wdrd jet ujljewj. aut `iidi tg`t ejny ehh`soej`nny wdrd tgdor r`ois
gd`ri ef* Gd p`ojtdi `nn oj `nn ` mest eptomostoh pohturd ef `ff`ors oj
tg`t sdhtoej ef Hgoj`. frem wgohg g`i `rosdj oj rdhdjt mejtgs ` breup
ef penotoho`js ljewj `s tgd Lw`jbso hnoqud wge wdrd mdj`hojb
H`jtej `ji wdrd s`oi te ad pn`jjojb te evdrtgrew tgd J`jlojb
Bevdrjmdjt. fermojb ` hemaojd wotg tgd Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n*
Ygd re`is systdm os jetgojb sgert ef dxhdnndjt. Mr* @rjeni `iidi*
Ygdy g`vd gobgw`ys hressojb tgd prevojhd tg`t ojtdrsdht wotg gobg-
w`ys rujjojb jertg `ji seutg. `ji ejd h`j irovd te `nmest `jy om-
pert`jt spet oj tgd prevojhd ay meter*
@jetgdr fd`turd ef tgd jdw tr`jspert`toej systdm os tgd erb`jo-
z`toej ef jumdreus aus nojds tg`t ruj dvdry iordhtoej* Ygdy `rd
auyojb merd ausds `nn tgd tomd. mest ef tgdm frem tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds*
Ygos os trud oj etgdr prevojhds. te ad surd. aut tgd idvdnepmdjt oj
Lw`jbso osp`rtohun`rny sobjofoh`jt `t tgos tomd* Ejd m`y roid frem
ejd dji te tgd etgdr ef tgd prevojhd ej tgdsd nojds oj s`fdty*
Ydndpgejd nojds g`vd addj n`oi eut `ji put ojte epdr`toej. Mr*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 227/455
XEMD @MDQOH@JX RGE RDQD YGDQD 112
@rjeni s`oi* Ygd nejb iost`jhd tdndpgejd sdrvohd oj Lw`jbso os
truny rdm`rl`and%" gd hemmdjtdi* _eu h`j step `jywgdrd `nejb tgd
m`oj gobgw`y `ji tdndpgejd `gd`i te ` tewj twe er tgrdd gujirdi
monds `w`y `ji rdsdrvd ` reem fer tgd jobgt `t `j ojj* Ygd sdrvohd
os pdrfdht* O w`s mest pnd`s`jtny surprosdi te foji tgos prebrdss oj
wg`t g`s addj hejsoidrdi ` w`rnold. a`hlw`ri iostroht ef Hgoj`%"
+ + +
X`fdny a`hl frem str`jbd dxpdrodjhds `mejb tgd jem`ioh troads
ef Hdjtr`n @so`. Ldrmot Qeesdvdnt p`ssdi tgreubg Xg`jbg`o n`td oj
M`y. 0?1?* Xuhhdss hrewjdi wg`t fer ` tomd sddmdi te ad ` futond
gujtojb trop fer tgd bo`jt p`ji`. ujidr tgd `uspohds ef tgd Fodni
Musdum oj Hgoh`be. ujidrt`ldj ay Ldrmot `ji gos aretgdr Ygdeierd
oj `jetgdr hg`ptdr ef tgdor dxpner`toejs ef nottnd-vosotdi herjdrs ef tgd
d`rtg*
Keurjdyojb evdrn`ji frem Q`jbeej tgreubg Aurm` `ji tgdjhd
`hress tgd seutgwdstdrj tep ef Hgoj` ojte Yoadt. sheurojb meujt`ojs.
v`nndys `ji sjew-hn`i gobgn`jis oj qudst ef tgd ad`st wgohg nurdi tgdm
ej tgdor i`jbdreus spertojb mossoej. tgd Qeesdvdnt p`rty `ftdr wddls
ef fruotndss tr`hlojb idsp`ordi ef sobgtojb. muhg ndss sgeetojb. ` bo`jt
p`ji`* Ygdy turjdi tew`ri Hgoj` ejhd merd frem Yoadt `ji oj wg`t
os ljewj `s tgd Ojidpdjidjt Nen` heujtry. ` tojy st`td aeridrojb ej
Yoadt `ji Hgoj` `ik`hdjt te Xzdhgu`j Srevojhd. tgdy feuji tgdor
qu`rry*
Jd`rny sox mejtgs frem tgd tomd tgdy idp`rtdi wotg L`sgmor
buoids `ji h`rrodrs frem tgd f`mono`r gonn heujtry. Ldrmot. wotg tgd
speons ef tgd hg`sd. w`s dj reutd te @mdroh`. wgond Henejdn Qeesdvdnt
rdm`ojdi `t X`obej fer sdvdr`n wddls te hejtojud tgd gujtojb dx-
pdiotoej oj ndss sdqudstdrdi tr`hts*
O weuni ad wotg gom ydt of my p`rtjdr g`i jet bet geni ef md
`ji ir`bbdi md a`hl te werl%" Ldrmot teni md `t toffoj* My aretgdr
os rdm`ojojb `t X`obej wotg Xuyi`m Huttojb* Ygd etgdr ferdobj mdm-
adr ef tgd p`rty. Gdradrt Xtdvdjs. ` aori spdho`nost. os hemojb eut vo`
Xzdhgu`j `ji tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr* Gd os jew `aeut `t Hgdjbtu `ji
sgeuni rd`hg gdrd oj ` fdw wddls*
Ioshussojb gos trop. Mr* Qeesdvdnt s`oi; Rd ndft Xg`me Vonn`bd.
Aurm`. ej tgd aeridr ef Hgoj` ej Idhdmadr 13* My aretgdr. Huttojb
`ji mysdnf. tebdtgdr wotg tgd L`sgmor h`rrodrs. wdjt ay mund tr`oj
evdrn`ji te _ujj`j. tgdjhd ojte Yoadt. wgdrd fer wddls wd w`jidrdi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 228/455
117 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
oj sd`rhg ef tgd bo`jt p`ji`* Aut wd wdrd ujsuhhdssfun. i`ys ef
tr`hlojb bdttojb us jewgdrd* Foj`nny wd turjdi wdst `ji seutgw`ri
`b`oj. rd`hgojb tgd aeridr ef Hgoj` oj Xzdhgu`j Srevojhd. `ji tgdjhd
wdjt seutg tgreubg tgd Ojidpdjidjt Nen` heujtry* Gdrd. ejd merjojb
fennewojb ` r`tgdr gd`vy sjewf`nn. wd feuji p`ji` tr`hls*
Rd wdrd dxtrdmdny nuhly. `s ` m`ttdr ef f`ht. fer `ftdr ejny feur
geurs ef tr`hlojb wd ioshevdrdi tgd ad`st t`lojb ots jeeji`y sodst`*
My aretgdr `ji O `ppre`hgdi h`rdfunny. fordi somunt`jdeusny `ji bet
gom* Ygd Nen` rujjdrs wotg us rdfusdi te arojb tgd `jom`n ojte tgdor
vonn`bd* Ot sddms tgd bo`jt p`ji` os ` sert ef mojer idoty `mejb
tgdm* Ot w`s `musojb n`tdr te foji tgdy g`i h`nndi oj ` prodst wge
hejiuhtdi rotds te purofy tgd troad `ji irovd eff `vdjbojb sporots* Ygd
Nen` pdepnd jdvdr g`rm tgd p`ji`* Mest ef tgesd wd mdt g`i jdvdr
sddj ejd*
Ygd ad`st w`s ` ad`utofun spdhomdj. wdobgojb merd tg`j 133
peujis `ji md`surojb jd`rny sdvdj fddt oj ndjbtg* Ot g`i ` tgohl he`t
ef fur wotg an`hl `ji wgotd spnethgds `ji ` wgotd gd`i wotg an`hl
dydbn`ssds. ` an`hl frojbd ef g`or `reuji tgd dyds* Ygd `jom`n os
adnodvdi te adnejb te tgd ad`r f`mony. aut. ujnold ad`rs. jdvdr goadr-
j`td `ji. furtgdrmerd. g`s ferty-twe tddtg ojstd`i ef ferty* Etgdrwosd.
ot os somon`r te tgd ad`r spdhods*
"Ygd p`ji` novds dxhnusovdnyej a`maee sgeets. wgohg `rd `mpny
prevoidi oj ots j`tovd g`ujts. wgohg `rd tgd gobg `ntotuids. r`jbojb
frem 7.333 te 09.333 fddt* Ot `nw`ys st`ys `mejb tgohl a`maee ferdsts
`ji os vdry feji ef gejdy* Ots g`aots `rd ad`rnold. aut shodjtosts h`j
idtdrmojd frem tgos spdhomdj tg`t ot g`s ` idfojotd hn`ssofoh`toej*
Gd idshroadi tgd Nen`s `s `mo`and pdepnd. somon`r te tgd @mdroh`j
Ojio`js oj m`jy w`ys* @ntgeubg tgd heujtry tgreubg wgohg tgd p`rty
w`nldi fer gujirdis ef monds os ejd ef tgd wonidst p`rts ef @so` `ji
os ojfdstdi wotg a`jiots. Mr* Qeesdvdnt s`oi gd g`i jet mdt treuand ef
`jy loji `ji tg`t tgd pdepnd dvdrywgdrd wdrd mest frodjiny `ji
herio`n*
Rgdj wd djtdrdi tgd Nen` heujtry. gd s`oi. tgd hgodf ef tgd
forst vonn`bd djtdrt`ojdi us. `ji wgdj wd ndft gd sdjt gos sej `nejb te
`ssurd us s`fd hejiuht `s f`r `s tgd jdxt vonn`bd* Oj tgos m`jjdr wd
wdrd h`rrodi tgreubg tgos tojy frodjiny st`td. muhg te tgd `m`zdmdjt
et tgd Hgojdsd wgdj wd teni tgd t`nd ef eur dxpdrodjhds ej rdturjojb
te tgos heujtry*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 229/455
0? YGD IQ@BEJ ND@QJX YE FN_
r + YGD ir`bej ef Hgoj`. snewny `w`ldjojb frem ` nejb snumadr
0Zse nejb tg`t ot m`lds Qop v`j Rojlnd"s snddp sddm nold ` j`p-sgeel gomsdnf `ji trodi gos wojbs* Oj tgd p`st fdw yd`rs tgd
ir`bej g`s nd`rjdi te fny* Gd g`i d`rnodr m`id iovdrs v`oj `ttdmpts
aut jew tgd ad`st teel te tgd `or wotg ` brd`t wgorrojb `ji re`r*
Ygd Hgojdsd pdepnd. oj etgdr weris. bovdj ` ard`tgojb spdnn fer pd`hd-
tomd pursuots oj 0?17-1? nd`rjdi tgd Ehhoidjt"s usd ef tgd `or `s `
mdioum fer tr`vdn* Ygos w`s ejd ef tgd mest rdvenutoej`ry pd`hdtomdrdferms ydt te strold @so`. `ji tgd Hgojdsd teel te tgd `or wotg
`m`zojb `voioty* Ygdrd g`i addj fnobgts ay Hgojdsd ponets oj tgd p`st.
te ad surd< aut ot w`s jet ujton tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej swdpt
jertg ej Sdopojb tg`t ot adh`md `jytgojb nold tgd vot`n f`hter oj Hgojdsd
i`ony nofd tg`t ot g`s sojhd adhemd*
@mdroh`j `vo`toej ojtdrdsts wdrd oj tgd v`j ef tgd ferdobj idvons
wge t`ubgt tgd Hgojdsd tgd usd ef tgd `orpn`jd oj rdhdjt yd`rs* Ygdy
wdrd tgd poejddrs oj ` pr`htoh`n w`y. `ji tgd @mdroh`j-ewjdi Hnoppdr
fnyojb ae`ts ndi tgd w`y oj an`zojb tgos brd`t tr`on fer Hgoj`* Ygdor
brd`t `orsgops forst fndw oj 0?84-86 `t rdbun`r ojtdrv`ns ej tgd reutd
`hress tgd are`i S`hofoh te M`jon`. `ji tgdy bet pdrmossoej frem tgd
Sertubudsd Bevdrjmdjt `t Nosaej te `nobgt oj w`tdrs eff tgd Ser-
tubudsd hejhdssoej ef M`h`e. oj seutg Hgoj`* Ygd Arotosg oj tgd
adbojjojb rdfusdi pdrmossoej te `nobgt eff tgdor Hrewj Henejy ef Gejb-
lejb. aut tg`t `nse w`s br`jtdi* Hejjdhtoejs `rd m`id frem M`h`e
`ji Gejblejb wotg `or nojds jew hross-hressojb Hgoj`* Yr`js-S`hofoh
p`ssdjbdrs n`ji tgdrd `ji h`j t`ld ` Hgojdsd-hejtrenndi hemmdrho`n
p`ssdjbdr pn`jd jertg*
Ygos `or sdrvohd adtwddj H`noferjo` `ji Hgoj` os ejd ef tgd mest
ojsporojb `dro`n stdps te `jjogon`td sp`hd `ji tomd oj tgd gostery ef
m`jloji* Ygd forst fnobgt. h`rryojb ejny `or m`on `ji hrdw. w`s m`id
frem @n`mdi`. H`noferjo`. te M`jon` ej Jevdmadr 11. 0?84. tgd Hnoppdr
11?
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 230/455
183 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
rdturjojb Idhdmadr 1 ef tg`t yd`r te gdr gemd a`sd `t tgd dji ef `j
`wd ojsporojb reuji trop `hress tgd v`st strdthgds ef epdj w`tdr* Ygdrd
wdrd steps `t G`w`oo. Moiw`y. R`ld Osn`ji `ji Bu`m. wgdrd meidrj
getdns g`vd addj hempndtdi fer tgd teurost"s evdrjobgt step* Ot os ejny
233 monds f`rtgdr te Hgoj` frem M`jon` ` sgert fnobgt. hemp`rdi te
tgd iost`jhd `nrd`iy hevdrdi*
Oj Hgoj` otsdnf ot os jew pessoand te fny `nmest `jywgdrd* Dvdj
tgd heenods `rd je nejbdr surprosdi `t tgd sobgt er tgd seuji ef `
pn`jd evdrgd`i `ji tg`t. oj otsdnf. os `j ojioh`toej ef tgd brd`t rdve-
nutoej`ry stroids wgohg tgd pdepnds ef tgd Ir`bej g`vd m`id oj rdhdjt
yd`rs* Tjton vdry rdhdjtny ` Hgojdsd kujl+" er s`onae`t w`s tgd
erioj`ry meid ef tr`vdn oj @so`* Yei`y tgdrd `rd rdbun`r `or nojds
hejjdhtojb `nn tgd m`ker hotods ef Hgoj`* Ejd h`j fny frem Xg`jbg`o
te Sdopojb oj sox geurs ! Fermdrny ot teel twe i`ys oj beei tomds ej
`j dxprdss tgd f`mdi Anud Dxprdss. tgdj tgd hr`hl r`onw`y tr`oj*
Er ejd h`jfny te G`jlew oj feur geurs wgdrd`s ot teel md fovd
i`ys ay std`mdr up-rovdr `ji tgrdd i`ys iewj oj 0?12*
Hgdjb-tu w`s fermdrny `j eutpest oj Xzdhgu`j Srevojhd `nmest uj-
rd`hg`and evdr tgd berbds ef tgd _`jbtzd. r`poi `ji i`jbdreus `t `jy
tomd `aevd G`jlew* Jew tgd fnobgt frem Xg`jbg`o os m`id oj dobgt
geurs* Ot os m`id sdvdr`n tomds ` wddl jew `s eftdj `s tgd oj-
hrd`sojb tr`ffoh wonn `nnew* Ygd heenod stonn g`s te usd tgd eni stynd
kujl ej tgd rovdrs ef gos `jhdsters er `t r`rd ojtdrv`ns. gd t`lds `
tr`oj* Ygd prohds fer fnyojb `rd `aevd gos rd`hg. nold tgd `orpn`jds
tgdmsdnvds* Aut tgdrd os brd`t prebrdss oj tgos fodni*
@t tgos peojt. O w`jt te sldthg tgd d`rny i`ys ef `vo`toej. wgdj tgd
Hgojdsd forst st`rtdi tefny
oj `jytgojb nold ` pr`htoh`n. sdroeus w`y*
Ygd @mdroh`js g`i muhg te ie wotg `vo`toej oj Hgoj` frem tgd st`rt*
Sepun`r ojtdrdst w`s poqudi d`rny ay ` fnobgt jd`rny `reuji tgd werni
ay twe dxtr`erioj`rony i`rojb `ji h`p`and fnodrs frem Mohgob`j oj tgdor
pn`jd. tgd Sroid ek Idtreot* Ygdy wdrd Mdssrs* Arehl `ji Xhgndd.
`ji O sg`nn jdvdr ferbdt tgd Xdptdmadr dvdjojb oj 0?17 wgdj tgdy
`ppd`rdi eut ef tgd seutg frem Gejblejb. `ji n`jidi eutsoid Xg`jb-
g`o* @nn w`s prdp`rdi fer ` rdhdptoej `t tgd Q`hd Heursd oj tgd hdjtdr
ef Xg`jbg`o ej Auaanojb Rdnn Qe`i aut tgdy tgeubgt tgd ev`n tee
sm`nn fer ` t`ld-eff `ji n`jidi `t Gujk`e @orpert `t tgd hoty nomots
ojstd`i. lddpojb us rujjojb a`hl `ji fertg nold w`tdr-aubs fer `j geur*
Xg`jbg`o. ` hoty ef tgronns ojurdi te w`r"s gystdro`. tojbndi wotg
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 231/455
YGD IQ@BEJ ND@QJX YE FN_ 180
dxhotdmdjt `t tgd arodf vosot ef @mdroh`"s i`rojb `vo`ters wgesd werni
fnobgt teel tgdm tgdrd fer ` sojbnd jobgt"s w`y-st`toej p`usd d`rny oj
Xdptdmadr 0?17* Reri ef tgd s`fd `rrov`n ef Xhgndd `ji Arehl `t
Emur` Vonn`bd. jd`r J`b`s`lo. rd`hgdi Xg`jbg`o n`td tgd jobgt ef
Xdptdmadr 00. `ji w`s rdhdovdi wotg ` rd`n sdjsd ef rdnodf* Ydndpgejds
ef `nn jdwsp`pdrs `ji jdws `bdjhods r`jb hejst`jtny n`td tg`t `ftdrjeej
`ji dvdjojb. wotg tgeus`jis ojquorojb `ftdr tgd s`fdty ef tgd `vo`ters
wgesd dffohodjhy `ji i`rojb h`pturdi pepun`r om`boj`toej* Ygdor s`fd
`rrov`n oj K`p`j idspotd tgdor f`onurd te rd`hg Yelye. tgdor be`n. w`s
woidny `ppn`uidi*
@j `ftdrm`tg ef djtguso`sm fennewdi Xhgndd `ji Arehl `s tgd puanoh
`w`ldjdi te tgd sobjofoh`jhd ef tgd ujusu`n fnobgt* Rgond pepun`r
`hhn`om w`s ojtdrdstdi hgodfnyoj tgdor gdreohs. ` sobjofoh`jt pg`sd ef
tgd ujovdrs`n pn`uiots w`s tgd gd`rty pr`osd frem `vo`toej effohdrs oj
tgd Xg`jbg`o idfdjsd ferhd ef m`jy j`toejs* Ygd Arotosg Qey`n @or
Ferhd effohdrs wdrd iddpny omprdssdi `ji ioi jet gdsot`td te idhn`rd
tgdor proid oj tgd `hgodvdmdjt* Ygdy ujstojtojbny pr`osdi tgd fnodrs"
i`rojb `ji slonn frem ` prefdssoej`n vodwpeojt `s ojioh`tojb tgd prebrdss
ef `vo`toej* Ygd Arotosg `orpn`jd h`rrodr effohdrs sdjt hejbr`tun`toejs.
`slojb tgd T* X* X* Sottsaurbg; Snd`sd hejvdy te tgd ponets ef tgd
Sroid ef Idtreot tgd hejbr`tun`toejs ef tgd @rbus ej tgdor vdry fojd
pdrferm`jhd*
Sepun`r sdjtomdjt w`s summdi up oj prdss hemmdjt wgohg n`uidi
tgd @mdroh`js gobgny* Ygd Xg`jbg`o Yomds. ` Arotosg-ewjdi i`ony.
projtdi `j diotero`n `hhn`omojb tgd fnobgt `s ` m`bjofohdjt `hgodvd-
mdjt%" `ji hg`r`htdrozojb ot `s tgd mest suhhdssfun ydt ujidrt`ldj.
ojioh`tojb tfod prebrdss ef `vo`toej* Ygd Jertg Hgoj` I`ony Jdws.
Arotosg. peojtdi te tgd ompert`jhd ef tgdor jej-step fnobgt frem Gejb-
lejb te Xg`jbg`o. st`tojb; Ygd Sroid ef Idtreot g`s sgewj tg`t ot
os pessoand te `hhempnosg tgos oj tgd sp`hd ef ejd i`y* Rg`t `nn rd`nozd
oj tgos pdrferm`jhd os tgd brd`t prebrdss wgohg `orpn`jds `ji djbojds
g`vd m`id oj rdhdjt yd`rs* Ejd `pprdho`tds merd `ji merd tgd
spndjioi h`noard ef tgd mdj wge h`rry eut tgdsd fnobgts* Rd m`y wdnn
effdr eur hejbr`tun`toejs te tgd Sroid ef Idtreot `ji gdr j`vob`ters
ej tgdor pdrferm`jhd oj rd`hgojb Xg`jbg`o. fer ot jet ejny hrd`tds `
rdheri frem Jdw _erl te Hgoj`. aut of wd `rd jet most`ldj ot dst`a-
nosgds ` jdw neh`n nejb iost`jhd `hgodvdmdjt* Ygd n`st rdfdrrdi te
tgd jej-step fnobgtfrem Gejblejb*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 232/455
181 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygd Hgoj` Srdss. 'tgdj @mdroh`j/ peojtdi eut tg`t Xhgndd `ji
Arehl fndw vortu`nny wotgeut `ssost`jhd. rdm`rlojb; Meujt`ojs. ferdsts
`ji ehd`js wdrd feuji te ad je a`r te tgos fnobgt `reuji tgd werni.
hejtojuojb tg`t tgus f`r. tgdy g`vd g`i je bevdrjmdjt`n `oi dotgdr
frem eur @rmy er J`vy* Aut tgd mest ioffohunt strdthg os te hemd
tgdy must hress tgd S`hofoh Ehd`j* Sr`ydrs ef monnoejs `nn evdr tgd
werni be wotg tgdm `s tgdy t`ld eff frem K`p`j ej tgos n`st `ji mest
`wdsemd pertoej ef tgdor fnobgt* Rd wosg tgdm Beispddi*
Ygos p`pdr peojtdi eut tg`t ot g`i je idsord te iosheur`bd Xhgndd
`ji Arehl. aut `iidi tg`t oj tgd dvdjt tg`t tgdy rdturjdi s`fdny te
Idtreot. kuibojb frem tgd m`jy ios`stdrs. ehd`j fnyojb mobgt wdnn ad
hurt`ondi fer ` wgond dxhdpt wgdj semd brd`t shodjtofoh eakdht m`y ad
`tt`ojdi* Dvdry heujtry g`s `maotoejs jer ieds `jy n`hl ar`vd
`vo`ters te h`rry tgdm eut. aut ujndss tgd st`ld os gobgdr tg`j mdrdny
tgd bnery ef adojb tgd forst te ie tgos er tg`t stujt. wg`t os b`ojdi5
Ygd `rtohnd `iidi ` subbdstoej fer shodjtofoh rdsd`rhg ojte `vo`toej
preandms ef tgd uppdr `or. djiojb; "Ygdj try fer werni rdheris. aut
jetkust ydt* Ygd re`is `rd tee fdw `ji tgd mondstejds tee m`jy.
mest ef tgdm ydt ujm`rldi br`vds*
Ay Jevdmadr 0?17. pepun`r ojtdrdst oj `vo`toej oj Hgoj` g`i oj-
hrd`sdi ay nd`ps `ji aeujis* Ejd ef tgd mest pewdrfun ojfnudjhds w`s
tgd ujprdhdidjtdi fnobgt ef tgd H`jtej. ` Qy`j-M`gejdy mejepn`jd
somon`r te tg`t oj wgohg Nojiadrbg fndw tgd @tn`jtoh* Sonetdi ay
H`pt`oj Hg`jb Guo-hg`jb ef tgd Hgojdsd @or Ferhd. tgd H`jtej ndft
H`jtej d`rny tg`t f`nn `ji m`id ` jej-step fnobgt te G`jlew. jd`rny
` tgeus`ji monds* H`pt`oj Hg`jb ndft tgdrd `ji geppdi eff te J`j-
lojb. v`ryojb gos eroboj`n ojtdjtoej te prehddi iordhtny te Sdlojb* @t
tgd h`pot`n gd w`s bovdj ` trdmdjieus ev`toej* Ygd ferdobj `s wdnn `s
tgd Hgojdsd prdss b`vd gos fnobgt woid puanohoty*
H`pt`oj Hg`jb jdxt fndw te Sdlojb @b`oj gd w`s bovdj ` brd`t
ev`toej. `ji iojjdrs `ji rdhdptoejs somon`r te tgesd ef `or gdreds oj
tgd Ehhoidjt wdrd tdjidrdi gom `ji gos twe hemp`joejs ay tgd Hgojdsd
iobjot`rods* Bdjdr`n _dj Gso-s`j. bevdrjer ef Xg`jso tgdj oj hg`rbd
ef tgd Sdlojb-Yodjtsoj `rd`. b`vd gom ` iojjdr p`rty* Ygd `vo`ters
wdrd fdtdi ay tgd pepun`hd. `ji Bdjdr`n Sdo Hgujb-gso `nse b`vd Hg`jb` iojjdr* Gd w`s tgd gdre ef tgd geur oj Sdlojb* H`pt`oj Hg`jbfndw te Mulidj. tgdj h`pot`n ef M`jhguro`. proer te rdturjojb iewj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 233/455
YGD IQ@BEJ ND@QJX YE FN_ 188
tgd he`st te Xg`jbg`o `ji tgdjhd te H`jtej* @nn `nejb tgd w`y gd
w`s gdr`nidi wotg djtguso`sm `ji gobg `hhn`om*
Ygd fnobgt otsdnf weuni jet g`vd addj se dxtr`erioj`ry `jywgdrd
aut oj tgd Erodjt* Aut ot w`s `j `hgodvdmdjt oj Hgoj`. wgdrd `vo`toej
g`i ujton tgdj pn`ydi se sm`nn ` p`rt oj w`r er pd`hd* Ot os trud tgdrd
w`s dvdj tgdj ` Fnyojb Herps ujidr tgd R`r Effohd* Aut tgdrd wdrd
stonn fdw pn`jds oj usd `ji `soid frem r`rd ehh`soejs wgdj tgdy wdrd
usdi te easdrvd djdmy pesotoejs. jdotgdr ferhd oj tgd Luemojt`jb
Qdvenutoej rdsertdi te `jy sert ef `dro`n w`rf`rd* Mulidj pessoany
g`i tgd adst `vo`toej idp`rtmdjt tgdj oj Hgoj`* Ygdrd wdrd merd
tg`j 033 `orsgops `t tgd Mulidj `oriremd `ji O s`w tgdor `rsdj`n
ar`jhg tgdrd. hejst`jtny turjojb eut jdw m`hgojds fer wgohg djbojds
wdrd purhg`sdi `are`i* @orpn`jds heuni ad sddj fnyojb evdr Mulidj
`nmest `jy i`y oj summdr< aut dvdj tgdrd tgdy g`i addj usdi aut
sdniem oj w`r. `ji je hemmdrho`n nojds g`i ydt addj `ttdmptdi* Yei`y
ot os v`stny hg`jbdi `ji meidrjozdi*
Ejd ef tgd `dro`n idvdnepmdjts `t J`jlojb w`s tgd `jjeujhdmdjt
tg`t tgd Bevdrjmdjt w`s hejsoidrojb erb`joz`toej ef ` Xoje-Bdrm`j
`vo`toej herper`toej* Effoho`ns oj tgd Mojostrods ef R`r. Ojtdroer. Oj-
iustry. Hemmdrhd `ji N`aer. `ji Foj`jhd hejfdrrdi ej tgd suakdht*
@or nojds te Durepd wdrd ioshussdi `s wdnn `s hemmdrho`n reutds oj
Hgoj`* Ygd Bevdrjmdjt w`s `nse idsoreus ef oj`ubur`tojb ` nojd hej-
jdhtojb tgd h`pot`n `ji L`nb`j* Ygdrd w`s semd qudstoej wgdtgdr.
ujidr tgd `brddmdjt pregoaotojb tgd s`nd ef `rms `ji `mmujotoej ay
@mdroh`js te Hgoj`. `orpn`jds heuni ad seni oj tg`t heujtry* @s `
rdsunt. mest ef tgd pn`jds forst oj usd wdrd purhg`sdi oj Durepd* Gew-
dvdr. tgd H`jtej w`s ` Qy`j-M`gejdy areubg`m mejepn`jd wotg `
Rrobgt wgornwoji meter*
Ot os my epojoej tg`t @mdroh`j `orpn`jd meters `rd f`r supdroer
te `nn etgdrs%0
H`pt`oj Hg`jb s`oi. kust proer test`rtojb ej gos gos-
teroh hress-heujtry fnobgt* Ygdy `rd "feen-preef fer ejd tgojb* @ji
tgdy st`ji up adttdr oj ` nejb ruj* O weuni nold te sdd `j `ssdmany
pn`jt st`rtdi oj H`jtej. a`hldi ay @mdroh`j h`pot`n* Ygdrd wonn ad
`j ojhrd`sojb idm`ji fer `orpn`jds oj tgd jd`r futurd `s wd dst`anosg
`or m`on `ji p`ssdjbdr sdrvohds adtwddj eur n`rbdr hotods. `ji ot hests
tee muhg te sgop ` pn`jd `nn sdt up* @j `ssdmany pn`jt wonn ad jddidi.
`ji O weuni nold te sdd `j @mdroh`j `vo`toej hemp`jy a`hl ef ot*
@mdroh`j `vo`toej ojtdrdsts geppdi `hress tgd S`hofoh. `ji ` jdw
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 234/455
189 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
dr` w`s oj`ubur`tdi oj Hgoj`"s hemmujoh`toejs ej @pron 0?. 0?1?.
wgdj Mojostdr Xuj Fe. `htojb oj gos h`p`hoty `s prdsoidjt ef tgd Hgoj`
J`toej`n @vo`toej Herper`toej. sobjdi ` hejtr`ht wotg @vo`toej Dx-
pner`toej. Ojh*. ` suasoio`ry ef tgd Hurtoss breup* Ygd n`ttdr ujidr tgd
`brddmdjt `brddi te h`rry m`on fer tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt ej tgrdd
trujl nojds*
Dxpdrts s`oi tg`t tgd sobjojb ef tgos ompert`jt `brddmdjt epdjdi
ejd ef tgd brd`tdst fodnis ef hemmdrho`n fnyojb oj tgd werni* Ygd
sobjojb teel pn`hd oj J`jlojb. fennewojb ` Xt`td Heujhon mddtojb
iurojb tgd `ftdrjeej te hejsoidr tgd prepes`ns suamottdi semd wddls
d`rnodr* Xemd eakdhtoejs wdrd djheujtdrdi `t tgd eutsdt ef tgd jdbe-
to`toejs `b`ojst pdrmottojb ferdobj ojtdrdsts te g`jind ` Bevdrjmdjt
m`on hejtr`ht* Ygdsd wdrd evdrhemd. gewdvdr. ay J`jlojb"s semd-
wg`t j`ovd erb`joz`toej ef tgd herper`toej wgohg estdjsoany g`jindi
tgd m`on otsdnf aut wgohg suandt tgd hejtr`ht te tgd @vo`toej Dx-
pner`toej pdepnd. se tg`t tgd dffdht w`s prdhosdny tgd s`md*
Ygrdd trujl nojds wdrd prepesdi ommdio`tdny. ejd hejjdhtojb J`j-
lojb `ji Sdopojb. tgd sdheji nojlojb H`jtej te G`jlew. `ji tgd tgori
nojlojb Xg`jbg`o `ji G`jlew vo` J`jlojb tgus `nn ojtdrnehlojb* Ot
w`s `jjeujhdi tg`t shgeens weuni ad dst`anosgdi ommdio`tdny ay tgd
@mdroh`js te tr`oj Hgojdsd ponets `ji etgdr pdrsejjdn. tgd oid` adojb
te dmpney Hgojdsd wgdrdvdr pessoand `s seej `s tgdy wdrd h`p`and ef
fnyojb* Ygd @mdroh`j ponets wdrd te ad ldpt ejny `s nejb `s tgdy
wdrd dssdjto`n*
M`ker Ronno`m A* Qeadrtsej rdprdsdjtojb tgd @mdroh`j form. m`id
tgos ferm`n `jjeujhdmdjt;
Ygos wonn ad ` Hgojdsd sdrvohd ujidr hejtren ef tgd J`toej`n
Bevdrjmdjt aut wotg @mdroh`j m`j`bdmdjt `ji epdr`toej fer
tgd tomd adojb* Ygd `orpn`jds wonn iospn`y Hgojdsd hg`r`htdrs fer
tgd j`md ef tgd Hgojdsd Herper`toej `ji tgd ojsobjo` ef tgd
J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt
@vo`toej Dxpner`toej furtgdr rdhdovds tgd provondbd ef djb`bojb
oj tgd `or tr`jspert`toej ef p`ssdjbdrs `ji frdobgt ej ots ewj
`hheujt. `ji te m`juf`hturd pn`jds `ji dquopmdjt oj Hgoj`* Ot
os pn`jjdi te ferm ` jdw @mdroh`j hemp`jy wotg ` h`pot`noz`toej
ef sdvdr`n monnoej ienn`rs 'beni/. oj wgohg tgd Hgojdsd wonn ad
ojvotdi te p`rtohop`td* Q`poi hemmujoh`toejs `rd tgd urbdjt jddi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 235/455
YGD IQ@BEJ ND@QJX YE FN_ 184
ef tgd memdjt gdrd* Ot wonn t`ld yd`rs te mddt tgos idm`ji ay
r`on er meter re`is<aut ay `vo`toej ot os gepdi tg`t Hgoj` wotgoj
` fdw mejtgs wonn ad ej ` p`roty wotg tgd etgdr j`toejs oj `or
hemmujoh`toejs*
Durepd`j hempdtotoej w`s mdt iurojb tgd wddls ef strdjueus
jdbeto`toejs. `s wdnn `s tg`t frem etgdr @mdroh`j ojtdrdsts oj Hgoj`*
Xg`jbg`o w`s `novd wotg `vo`ters frem `are`i sddlojb te dst`anosg
nojds oj `nn iordhtoejs* M`ker Qeadrtsej areubgt feur pn`jds te Hgoj`
wgond tryojb te sdnn J`jlojb gos m`on hejtr`ht oid`* Ygdor idmej-
str`toejs omprdssdi tgd Hgojdsd effoho`ns. p`rtohun`rny Mr* Xuj Fe*
Ygd Mojostdr ef Q`onw`ys w`s djtguso`stoh `ftdr fnyojb oj ejd ef tgdsd
pn`jds te J`jlojb frem Xg`jbg`o* Gd s`oi m`jy effoho`ns mobgt seej
hemmutd te J`jlojb ay `or frem Xg`jbg`o*
Oj foj`jhojb trod jdw nojds. ot w`s dxpn`ojdi tg`t tgd @mdroh`j
hemp`jy g`i ` bu`r`jtdd frem tgd Hgojdsd bevdrjmdjt ujidr tgd hej-
tr`ht stopun`tojb ` snoiojb sh`nd ef p`y te tgdm ef )0*43 'beni/ `
peuji te )9*43 'beni/ ` peuji. idpdjiojb ej tgd sozd ef tgd ne`i
h`rrodi* Ygd Hgojdsd `nse `brddi te auy `nn `dro`n dquopmdjt frem tgd
@vo`toej Dxpner`toej breup* Ywe @mdroh`jponets. D* N* Xnejobdr
`ji @n H`pdrtej. wdrd wotg M`ker Qeadrtsej `ji `oidi oj tr`ojojb
Hgojdsd ponets* Roidsprd`i eppesotoej idvdnepdi `mejb Hgojdsd `vo`-
toej erb`joz`toejs `b`ojst tgd @mdroh`j hejtr`ht* Gewdvdr. effoho`ns
ef tgd @mdroh`j breup oj Xg`jbg`o wdrd eptomostoh `aeut tgd dvdjtu`n
h`rryojb eut ef tgd tdrms ef tgdor `brddmdjt*
Ot prevoidi tg`t tgd sdrvohd w`s te adboj oj sox mejtgs. tg`t tgd
@mdroh`js wdrd te prevoid tgd `orpn`jds. ponets. `ji `nn etgdr dquop-
mdjt `ji pdrsejjdn. `ji tg`t tgd Hgojdsd wdrd te prevoid g`jb`rs
`ji suot`and n`jiojb fodnis `nejb tgd reutds prepesdi* Ot w`s furtgdr
prevoidi tg`t oj tgd dvdjt tgd rdvdjuds frem `or m`on ej tgd nojds w`s
ojsuffohodjt te mddt tgd r`tds `brddi ej. tgd @mdroh`j hemp`jy weuni
epdr`td `t ` ness `ji t`ld tgd Hgojdsd hemp`jy"s premossery jetds upte )1.333.333* Ot w`s `brddi tgdrd w`s te ad ` mojomum ef 8.333
fnyojb monds ` i`y wgdj tgd nojds hemmdjhdi*
Ygd Qeadrtsej breup `nse effdrdi te ndji tgd Hgojdsd Hemp`jy
`jetgdr )0.333.333 beni oj h`sg fer usd oj tgd sdhurojb ef `or fodnis.
hejstruhtoej ef g`jb`rs `ji etgdr dxpdjsds ojhoidjt`n te bdttojb st`rtdi*
M`ker Qeadrtsej rdturjdi te Jdw _erl te `rr`jbd furtgdr idt`ons*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 236/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 237/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 238/455
187 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygd Hgojdsd `rd r`poiny adhemojb `or mojidi* Ygdy `rd f`t`nosts
`t aettem `ji b`mandrs oj `jy h`sd* Xe tgdy fny wotg ujaroindi
djtguso`sm*
Ygd `orsgop tee g`s jet ejny areubgt Hgoj` ojte ` merd hemp`ht
m`ss oj @so`. aut g`s areubgt @so` `ji tgd Erodjt hnesdr te @mdroh`
`ji Durepd+ Hnoppdr sgops arojb Hgoj` hnesdr te gemd wd oj tgd
Tjotdi Xt`tds wonn hemd te ljew `ji ujidrst`ji tgd ojshrut`and
Erodjt`n adferd nejb* Eur br`jihgonirdj. of jet wd eursdnvds. wonn
tgojl jetgojb ef fnyojb evdr te Xg`jbg`o frem Jdw _erl fer tgd
wddl dji*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 239/455
13 ATQO@N EF XTJ _@Y-XDJ
Q@QDN_of dvdr oj gdr gdhtoh
gosteryg`s Hgoj`
p`oi
merd
idveut gem`bd te `jy m`j tg`j sgd ioi te Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj
tgd i`wj ef Kujd 0. 0?1?*
Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj w`s tgd vosoej`ry m`j wge feujidi tgd Lue-
mojt`jb Ygd Sdepnd"s S`rty oj Hgoj`* Gd brdw up oj G`w`oo.
wgdrd gos arusgojb `b`ojst tgd Ehhoidjt`n hejhdptoejs ef idmehr`hy
`ji dqu`noty b`vd aortg te gos rdvenutoej`ry oid`ns fer tgd pdepnds ef
Hgoj`. nejb epprdssdi jet ejny ay ferdobjdrs aut ay tgdor ewj r`p`hoeus
bevdrjojbhn`ss `ji
aytgd w`r neris* Ygdsd oid`s oj `
mej`rhgysuhg
`s Hgoj` `t tgd st`rt ef tgos hdjtury. ujidr ` idh`idjt `ji tgereubgny
herrupt oM`jhgu iyj`sty tgdj runojb frem tgd Ir`bej Ygrejd `t
Sdlojb wdrd rdvenutoej`ry ojiddi* Je ejd g`i gd`ri ef suhg ` tgojb
oj tgd gojtdrn`ji ef Hgoj` je ejd w`jtdi te gd`r ef suhg ` hejhdpt
`t tgd M`jhgu Heurt oj tgd i`ys adferd tgd forst rdvenutoej. Aut Ir*
Xuj _`t-sdj gd`ri*
Gd rdturjdi te H`jtej `ji snewny adb`j te td`hg tgos ojsoioeus
iehtrojd oj gos j`tovdn`ji ef Xeutg Hgoj`* Ygd oid` sprd`i vdry
br`iu`nny. aut ot w`s ejd ef tgd ujidrnyojb h`usds ef tgd evdrtgrew
ef tgd M`jhgu Iyj`sty oj tgd eroboj`n rdvenutoej `b`ojst tgd Sdlojb
tgrejd oj 0?00* Ygdsd mdj fobgtojb fer frddiem `ji idmehr`toh rund
suhhddidi. `ji tgd rdvent w`s effoho`nny prehn`omdi te g`vd evdrtgrewj
tgd Ir`bej Ygrejd ej Fdaru`ry 2. 0?01*
Ygd idsposdi M`jhgu Aey Dmpdrer. wgesd j`md w`s tgdj
Gsu`j-Y"ojb. `aioh`tdi gos robgt te pewdr `s tgd Xej ef Gd`vdj
ej tg`t i`td. er r`tgdr. tgd eni Iew`bdr Dmprdss ioi ot fer gom. fertgd rundr w`s aut sdvdj yd`rs eni `ji dvdj merd ompetdjt `s
dmpdrer tgdj tg`j jew* Fer gd runds"+ `b`oj ej tgd tgrejd ef gos
`jhdsters oj Gsojlojb 'fermdrny Hg`jb-hgujb/ . er Jdw H`pot`n. oj
K`p`j"s ojidpdjidjt Xt`td ef M`jhgulue* Ygos yeutg os tgd n`st ef
tgd eni M`jhgu nojd. sdt up wgdj tgd M`jhgu gerids sw`rmdi evdr
tgd Brd`t R`nn oj 0699 `ji hejqudrdi tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds*
18?
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 240/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 241/455
ATQO@N EF XTJ _@Y-XDJ 190
eni frodji Mol`n Aereioj. fneurosgdi fer ` tomd* Ygd jertgdrj dx-
pdiotoej rdsuntdi wotg rdvenutoej`ry r`poioty* Ygd Luemojt`jb
Qdvenutoej ndft tgd Sd`rn Qovdr `t H`jtej oj tgd n`td sprojb ef 0?16.
`ji `ftdr mevojb te tgd _`jbtzd V`nndy oj 0?12. h`pturdi Sdlojb oj
Kujd. 0?17. twe yd`rs `ftdr ots ojhdptoej* Yg`t os ` rdheri. oj `
rdvenutoej ef suhg m`bjotuid*
Aut Ir* Xuj g`i iodi* Ygd feujidr ef tgd Qdvenutoej w`s ejny
soxty yd`rs eni. aut ` vdry tordi m`j wgdj gd wdjt te Sdlojb oj `
n`st dffert te prdvdjt tgd jdhdssoty ef ` w`r te `hgodvd gos djis* Ygdrd.
oj tgd hot`idn ef tgd jertg wgohg w`s tgd hr`ind ef tgd herrupt pewdr
wgohg gd idsposdi. gd iodi. ej M`rhg 01. 0?14*
Gos dma`nmdi aeiy n`y djtemadi fer ` tomd oj ` sgrojd `tep `j
eni tdmpnd eutsoid Sdopojb* @ spdho`n prehdss w`s usdi te dma`nm tgd
Iehter"s fr`on aeiy. `ji O s`w ot oj tgd Xt`td fujdr`n rotds feur yd`rs
`ftdr gos id`tg. oj tgd h`sldt oj wgohg ot jew nods djtemadi. eutsoid
J`jlojb* Ygd Xt`td fujdr`n rotds adb`j oj tgd i`rljdss adferd i`wj
ef tgd forst i`y ef Kujd 0?1?* Ygd hoty ef J`jlojb. onn-dquoppdi te
sgdntdr se m`jy vosoters. w`s hr`mmdi wotg gum`joty* M`jy fer-
dobjdrs wdrd tgdrd. `ji prdss "herrdspejidjts fnehldi te tgd h`pot`n ej
tg`t gosteroh i`y*
Fdw bet `jy snddp tgd jobgt ef tg`t M`y 80 oj J`jlojb* Ygd
rotu`n adb`j `t tgrdd e"hnehl oj tgd merjojb* N`iy G`y Irummeji
G`y. `j Djbnosg wem`j wrotojb gdr omprdssoejs ef tgd dvdjt. L`rn vej
Rodb`ji. vdtdr`j @mdroh`j herrdspejidjt. `ji O steei `reuji oj `
a`rr`hls-nold auoniojb mest ef tgd jobgt `ftdr twdnvd e"hnehl w`otojb fer
semdtgojb te g`ppdj* Ygdj wd wdjt evdr te tgd pn`hd wgdrd tgd
sdrvohds wdrd adbojjojb* Ejny S`rty mdmadrs wdrd `nnewdi ojsoid*
Ygd rdst ef us steei eutsoid w`otojb fer tgd nejb prehdssoej te st`rt te
tgd jdwny hempndtdi m`usendum ej Surpnd Meujt`oj. p`st tgd `jhodjt
Mojb temas. tdj monds eutsoid tgd hoty w`nns*
Ygd fujdr`n prehdssoej st`rtdi kust `s nobgt adb`j te sgew oj tgd
d`st* Ot w`s id`iny snew `ji teel geurs te rd`hg tgd sgrojd. wgdrd
djtemamdjt teel pn`hd `t gobg jeej* Ir* Xuj"s aeiy w`s pn`hdi oj `
gd`rsd `t tgd dji ef tgd nejb nojd ef idveut fennewdrs* @nejb ` jdw
gobgw`y dspdho`nny hejstruhtdi fer tgd purpesd. tgd hertdbd mevdi
tgreubg tgd v`nndy ef tgd _`jbtzd.
Ygd fujdr`n prehddidi `t se snew ` p`hd tg`t O idhoidi te be a`hl
te tgd getdn `ji wrotd ` h`and te tgd Yomds `aeut ots st`rt. tgdj pohl
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 242/455
191 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
ot up `b`oj ay meter h`r `t tgd a`sd ef tgd m`usendum* Ygos O ioi.
`ji O `m beojb te bovd yeu tgesd p`r`br`pgs `s wrottdj tgdrd oj tgd
d`rny merjojbgusg ef
Kujd0. 0?1?*
Gobg ej tgd soid ef Surpnd Meujt`oj. f`r frem tgd ausy rusg
ef ` jdw j`toej er tgd seuji ef bujs oj rdhurrdjt rdvenutoej. tgd
aeiy ef Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj nods djsgrojdi tejobgt oj ots foj`n rdst-
ojb pn`hd `t tgd spet wgdrd tgd id`i Nd`idr eftdj. oj nofd. dx-
prdssdi gos hgdrosgdi idsord te ad aurodi*
Ygd foj`n rotds adb`j oj sendmj hdrdmejy adferd i`wj oj tgd
Hdjtr`n S`rty Gd`iqu`rtdrs `uioteroum wgdrd tgd aeiy g`s n`oj
oj st`td fer tgd p`st tgrdd i`ys* Ygd fujdr`n hnesdi sgertny `ftdr
jeej wotg tgd ferm`n newdrojb ef tgd brd`t arejzd h`sldt ojte ots
sujldj hrypt* Eutsoid. tgd suj m`id arobgt tgd anud `ji wgotd
br`jotd `ji m`rand m`usendum wgohg steei spndjioi `aevd tgd
_`jbtzd fdrtond newn`jis*
Ojsoid. adyeji tgd gobg-reefdi Mdmero`n G`nn `ji p`st tgd
gubd arejzd ieers tgd Ysotjb-no"s aeiy nods pd`hdfunny adnew
iemdi w`nns oj ` seft twonobgt wgohg oj i`ytomd fontdrs bdjtny oj
tgreubg tojy st`ojdi bn`ss wojiews* Gdrd ejny ` hgesdj fdw
b`tgdrdi wotg aewdi gd`is `t tgd djtemamdjt ef tgd Nd`idr"s
fr`on fr`md `s ot p`ssdi ferdvdr frem gum`j sobgt* Ygdsd wdrd
tgd mdmadrs ef Ir* Xuj"s ommdio`td f`mony `ji gos hnesdst fen-
newdrs. wge g`i addj `nnewdi te ad jd`r gom iurojb tgd mdme-
ro`n meurjojb hdrdmejy `t i`wj wotgoj tgd iom-not `uioteroum
adferd i`y areld evdr tgd h`pot`n* Ygdy ojhnuidi tgd woiew.
Mmd* Xuj _`t-sdj<tgd ejny sej ef tgd feujidr ef tgd Luemoj-
t`jb. Mr* Xuj Fe< Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. gos drstwgond
`oid<`ji ` hemp`r`tovdny fdw etgdrs hnesd tgreubg aneei rdn`toej-
sgops er penotoh`n `sseho`toej*
@ fdw memdjts n`tdr tgos nottnd breup snewny rdtr`hdi tgdor
stdps iewj tgd nejb. swddpojb br`jotd st`orh`sd `ji idp`rtdi
`nejb tgd are`i gobgw`y wgohg nold ` roaaej. wgdj vodwdi frem
tgd gdobgts ef tgd meujt`ojsoid tema. hejjdhts tgd sgrojd tgreubg
tgd eni J`jlojb hoty w`nns wotg tgd iost`jt jdw h`pot`n ef Hgoj`*
@nn tgreubg tgd jobgt prdp`r`toejs g`i hejtojudi fer tgd
truny strolojb prebr`m* Ot w`s tgd hnom`x ef yd`rs ef pn`jjojb*
Ygd wgend ef J`toej`nost Hgoj` g`i spdjt ` wddl oj effoho`n
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 243/455
ATQO@N EF XTJ _@Y-XDJ 198
meurjojb* Ygd w`rs fer tgd memdjt wdrd ferbettdj `ji tgd
hejtojdjt g`s addj `t pd`hd sojhd tgd fujdr`n tr`oj idp`rtdi frem
Sdlojb n`st Meji`y h`rryojb tgd
aeiy
ef Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj frem
ots tdmper`ry tema eutsoid tgd `jhodjt h`pot`n seutgw`ri g`nf
w`y `hress Hgoj` te J`jlojb* Fer i`ys. `nn J`jlojb ojhemojb
tr`ojs `ji rovdr std`mdrs g`vd addj hrewidi wotg pdrsejs frem
`nn herjdrs ef tgd n`ji* Iopnem`toh mossoejs ef vortu`nny dvdry
j`toej ej frodjiny rdn`toejs wotg tgd jdw Hgoj` `rrovdi te `ttdji
tgd Xt`td djtemamdjt*
Nejb adferd i`wj. seniodrs. s`oners. Aey Xheuts. Born Buoids.
bdji`rmds `ji rdbun`r penohd keojdi oj sddlojb te g`jind quodtny
tgd brd`t tgrejbs wgohg fonndi tgd h`pot`n fer tgos dvdjt* Ygd
pdepnd oj ` brd`t. nejb prehdssoej m`rhgdi `feet tgd monds ad-
twddj tgd `uioteroum oj tgd gd`rt ef J`jlojb `ji tgd m`use-
ndum `nejb tgd jdw Hgujbsg`j gobgw`y evdr wgohg tgd hertdbd
mevdi `t ` sj`on-nold p`hd* Ygos prehdssoej adb`j kust `t i`wj
`s tgd gd`rsd mevdi ojte pn`hd tew`ri tgd dji ef tgd nojd ef tgd
novojb strdthgojb jd`rny twe monds `gd`i.
M`i`md Xuj _`t-sdj 'tgd sdheji/. kust a`hl frem Durepd
te `ttdji tgd fujdr`n sdrvohds fer gdr id`i gusa`ji. steei `nejd
`ji ujsuppertdi* Irdssdi oj `ustdrd an`hl. sgd w`nldi ay tgd
soid ef gdr gusa`ji"s sej. Mr* Xuj Fe gomsdnf `aeut gdr ewj
`bd `ji w`s sddj te ad wddpojb sondjtny `t tgos rdjdw`n ef f`otg
oj gdr gusa`ji* Rotg gdr `nse wdrd gdr twe sostdrs. Mmd*
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl `ji Mmd* G* G* Qujb* Ygdsd `ji etgdr
mdmadrs ef tgd ommdio`td f`mony wdrd goiidj adgoji ` an`hl-
sgddtdi sgodni wgond tgdy w`nldi frem tgd `uioteroum oj ` pn`hd
sdt `soid fer tgdm kust a`hl ef tgd gd`rsd oj wgohg tgd h`sldt
rdstdi* Ot w`s ir`pdi oj ` fn`b ef tgd jdw rdpuanoh ujidr tgd
Luemojt`jb*
Ygreubg tgd w`rm sprojb sujsgojd ef tgd d`rny Kujd merjojb.
mdmadrs ef tgd H`aojdt. gobg Hgojdsd effoho`ns. ferdobj djveys.
seniodrs `ji etgdrs m`rhgdi oj tgd nejb trdl tew`ri tgd m`use-
ndum Hgojdsd a`jis pn`ydi tgd iorbd* Bujs oj ferts `tep Noej
Gonn eutsoid tgd w`nns aeemdi ejd gujirdi `ji ejd tomds oj `
j`toej`n s`nutd ef f`rdwdnn* Nold ` bo`jt ir`bej `t n`st `w`ld.
tgd fujdr`n prehdssoej weuji tgreubg tgd hoty"s sondjt m`ssdi
tgrejbs ojte tgd epdj heujtrysoid*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 244/455
199 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Ygd prehdssoej rd`hgdi tgd a`sd ef tgd m`usendum `t tdj
e"hnehl oj tgd merjojb. `t tgd dji ef ` sox geur m`rhg* Gdrd tgd
h`sldt w`s ujne`idi `ji pn`hdi ej ` arobgt anud h`t`f`nqud wgohg
m`jy sondjt heenods h`rrodi upw`ri te tgd sgrojd wotgoj tgd
djermeus auoniojb `aevd* @t tgd tema. fennewojb dn`aer`td `ji
idveut rotds. tgesd pdrsejs dspdho`nny ojvotdi te `ttdji tgd fujdr`n
hdrdmejy fondi p`st tgd hrypt*
Ygd hoty ef J`jlojb easdrvdi tgrdd mojutds ef sondjhd dx`htny
`t gobg jeej. `ji tgd rotds wdrd djidi*
Ommdio`tdny `ftdr Ir* Xuj"s fujdr`n. tgd mdj `t J`jlojb turjdi
tew`ri ad`utofyojb tgdor jdw h`pot`n* Ot jddidi ot* Sn`js wdrd ir`wj
up ay Gdjry L* Murpgy `ji Drjdst S* Beeirohg ef Jdw _erl. fer
m`lojb J`jlojb ejd ef tgd mest ad`utofun h`pot`ns oj tgd werni* Ygd
eni w`nn rujjojb ots zobz`b w`y `hress tgd gonns `nejb tgd _`jbtzd w`s
te ad turjdi ojte ` meidrj aeundv`ri djhorhnojb tgd hoty*
@t forst ot w`s suppesdi tg`t tgd w`nn weuni g`vd te be* Ot w`s
fdnt dvdj ay tgd Hgojdsd tg`t ots prdsdjhd weuni rdt`ri tgd hoty"s
idvdnepmdjt* Gdjhd ot w`s prepesdi tgdj tg`t tgd w`nn ad r`zdi `ji
tgd arohls usdi te p`vd jdw strddts* Rgdj Mr* Murpgy. tgd `rhgotdht
oj tgd hoty pn`jjojb prebr`m. `rrovdi oj Hgoj` d`rny tg`t Fdaru`ry.
gd wdjt `t ejhd te J`jlojb* Ejd ef tgd forst tgojbs gd ioi w`s te
`jjeujhd tg`t gd tgeubgt purdny Hgojdsd `rhgotdhturd sgeuni ad usdi
tgreubgeut oj idsobjojb tgd H`pot`n"s jdw puanoh auoniojbs `ji tg`t
tgd a`ttdrdi eni br`y w`nn sgeuni ad m`ojt`ojdi `t `nn hests*
Ot os typoh`n ef Hgoj`%" Mr* Murpgy s`oi* Ot weuni ad ` brd`t
most`ld te td`r ot iewj* Nd`vd ot `ji wd wonn m`ld ` are`i aeundv`ri
ej ots tep. ` mest v`nu`and `ssdt oj dvdry w`y te tgd jdw hoty* Ygd
w`nn wonn tgus ad usdfun `ji `t tgd s`md tomd mest `ttr`htovd* Ay je
md`js iostura ot* Of jdhdss`ry. put b`tds tgreubg ot `t dvdry strddt.
aut lddp tgd w`nn*
Xe tgdy ldpt tgd eni w`nn `t J`jlojb*
Ygd h`pot`n. sotu`tdi ej tgd seutg a`jl ef tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr. w`s
` typoh`n eni Hgojdsd hoty ef ndss tg`j ` monnoej pepun`toej* Ot r`mandi
`nn `nejb tgd heujtrysoid fer monds. wotg v`st epdj sp`hds wotgoj tgd
w`nn* Dnsdwgdrd. ots j`rrew strddts tr`vdrsd tgohlny pepun`tdi sdhtoejs
wgdrd tgd hotozdjs novd p`hldi `ji k`mmdi tebdtgdr oj typoh`n Hgojdsd
f`sgoej* Ot os stonn jet ` prdtty hoty tei`y. aut tgd neh`toej fer `
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 245/455
ATQO@N EF XTJ _@Y-XDJ 194
ad`utofun meidrj mdtrepenos os oid`n* Ygd new gonns adgoji tgd hoty
rosd reujiny `b`ojst tgd sly. `ji frem tgd v`jt`bd ef tgd _`jbtzd `s
ejd bnoids p`st ej ` std`mdr tgd hoty os jet wotgeut hg`rm*
Mr* Beeirohg. tgd djbojddr. eroboj`nny wdjt te Hgoj` te werl ej
tgrdd t`sls oj hejjdhtoej wotg tgd J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt"s rdhej-
struhtoej prebr`m Ygdsd wdrd tgd J`jlojb hoty pn`jjojb prekdht.
tgd hejstruhtoej ef J`jlojb"s pert `ji tgd idvdnepmdjt ef ` pert `t
H`jtej fer ehd`j-beojb nojdrs*
O h`md eut te Hgoj` te `ssost oj tgd pn`jjojb ef tgd jdw J`j-
lojb%" Mr* Beeirohg s`oi oj t`nlojb ef gos werl tgdrd. `ji te bovd
tgdm ` pr`htoh`n pn`j fer tgd hejstruhtoej ef perts fer ehd`j nojdrs `t
H`jtej `ji pessoany `t J`jlojb* Mr* Murpgy `ji mysdnf `rd beojb
`gd`i forst ej tgd J`jlojb hoty pn`jjojb prebr`m* Rd `rd m`lojb
gd`iw`y. `s gd wonn tdnn yeu* Gd ljews merd `aeut tg`t dji ef ot
tg`j O ie*
@s te tgd perts `t H`jtej `ji J`jlojb. O h`jjet s`y ydt gew
muhg tgdy wonn hest. aut pessoany ot wonn ruj ojte monnoejs ef ienn`rs*
Gew tgdy ojtdji te foj`jhd tgos werl os jejd ef eur hejhdrj* Rd `rd
ojtdrdstdi. te ad surd. oj tgd suhhdss ef tgd djtdrprosd. aut O ujidrst`ji
`t Yodjtsoj tgdy `rd stonn werlojb ej g`raer omprevdmdjts subbdstdi oj
` pn`j n`oi iewj tdj er twdjty yd`rs `be*
Eur oid` os te survdy tgd sotu`toej `s pr`htoh`n djbojddrs. `ji
ejhd wd g`vd tgd survdy hempndtdi te n`y iewj ` nojd ef werl wgohg
wonn. wgdj h`rrodi eut. bovd H`jtej `ji J`jlojb tgd mest up-te-i`td
perts pessoand* Rd wonn. O prdsumd. prehddi wotg tgos werl ef prd-
sdjtojb tgd Hgojdsd Bevdrjmdjt wotg ` pr`htoh`n djbojddrojb prebr`m
fer tgdsd perts `s seej `s tgdhoty pn`jjojb prebr`m `t J`jlojb os
s`tosf`hterony ir`wj up* Ygd `htu`n hejstruhtoej werl ef tgd perts
wonn ad iejd. O adnodvd. ay hejstruhtoej djbojddrojb forms wge `rd
`sldi te aoi ej tgd prekdhts `s spdhofodi oj tgd pert pn`js O suamot
te tgd Bevdrjmdjt*
Ot w`s dstom`tdi tgd hejstruhtoej ef tgd pert `t H`jtej weuni hest
`t nd`st )03.333.333* Ygd pert `t J`jlojb weuni hest tg`t muhg `ji
pessoany merd* Mojostdr Xuj Fe. wge w`s forst oj hg`rbd ef tgos werl
`ji wge rdt`ojdi Mr* Murpgy `ji Mr* Beeirohg oj @mdroh`. s`oi tgd
foj`jhojb shgdmds hevdrojb tgdsd prekdhts weuni ad a`hldi ay tgd
J`toej`n Bevdrjmdjt rdvdjuds* Mr* Murpgy. `j eni vosoter te Hgoj`.
w`s strejbny oj f`ver ef `igdrojb `s hnesdny `s pessoand te tgd eni
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 246/455
196 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Hgojdsd stynd ef `rhgotdhturd* Gd hrotohozdi dfferts te hemaojd tgd eni
wotg tgd jdw wdstdrj oid`s. jet adh`usd tg`t sert ef hemaoj`toej w`s
jet `
beei
oid` aut adh`usd. gd s`oi te md ej tgos suakdht. tgd `rhgo-
tdhts g`i bejd `aeut tgd hemaoj`toej oj tgd wrejb w`y*
O adh`md hejvojhdi. Mr* Murpgy s`oi. tg`t tgd hgodf ioffohunty
wotg tgd `i`pt`toejs `nrd`iy m`id n`y oj tgd f`ht tg`t tgdor idsobjdrs
g`i st`rtdi eut wotg ferdobj dxtdroers ojte wgohg tgdy g`i ojtreiuhdi
te ` brd`tdr er ndss dxtdjt Hgojdsd fd`turds. wotg tgd ojdvot`and rdsunt
tg`t tgd hempndtdi auoniojbs rdm`ojdi dssdjto`nny ferdobj*
O idhoidi wd must st`rt eut wotg Hgojdsd dxtdroers ojte wgohg wd
weuni ojtreiuhd ejny suhg ferdobj fd`turds `s wdrd jddidi te mddt
semd idfojotd rdquordmdjts* Ef tgd auoniojbs jew hempndtdi oj tgd
Bojnojb Henndbd breup `t J`jlojb `ji ef tgd twdjty er merd jew
ehhupodi ay _djhgojb Tjovdrsoty '`t Sdopojb/ my Hgojdsd frodjis s`y
tgdy `rd rd`nny Hgojdsd*
Oj ots j`tur`n fd`turds `ji surreujiojbs J`jlojb g`s `iv`jt`bds
djkeydi ay fdw h`pot`ns oj tgd werni%" gd `iidi* Oj wg`t etgdr
h`pot`n h`j wd foji p`r`nndns fer tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr ej ejd soid ad`rojb
tgd hemmdrhd ef twe gujirdi monnoej pdepnd. fer tgd Netus N`ld ej
tgd etgdr wotg ots pohturdsqudny weeidi osn`jis `ji ots pessoaonotods
`s tgd p`rl hdjtdr ef ` suaura`j rdsoidjto`n idvdnepmdjt. fer tgd
rennojbtdrr`oj wgohg `iis se muhg te tgd `rhgotdhtur`n pessoaonotods
ef tgd futurd tgohlny auont pertoejs ef tgd hoty prepdr. fer tgd new gonns
aeridrojb J`jlojb ej tgd jertg `ji seutg. `ji fer tgd hunmoj`toej
ef tgdsd gonns `t tgd wdst oj Surpnd Meujt`oj. rosojb 0933 fddt oj `
songeudttd ef ojiovoiu`noty `ji hg`r`htdr5 @ji wgdj yeu hejsoidr
tg`t evdr g`nf ef tgd sdvdjtddj te dobgtddj squ`rd monds wotgoj tgd
w`nns ef J`jlojb hejsosts ef fodnis jd`rny dmpty ef auoniojbs ef `jy
loji yeu wonn rd`nozd gew ujusu`n `j eppertujoty os gdrd `fferidi te
`hgodvd ` hoty pn`j n`oi eut `nmest ej oid`n nojds*
Mr* Murpgy h`md eut te Hgoj` `hress Durepd `ji Xoadro`. vosotojb
semd twdjty hotods dj reutd te J`jlojb* Gd stuiodi tgdor hoty pn`js
wotg `j dyd te gew te `i`pt tgd adst fd`turds ef d`hg te tgd hoty gd
w`s pn`jjojb* @ji gd feuji oj tgd hoty w`nn ` brd`t tr`ffoh `rtdry
`nrd`iy te g`ji*
Ef tgd m`j-m`id fd`turds ef J`jlojb. gd s`oi. tgd mest
strolojb os tgd wejidrfundjhorhnojb hoty w`nn r`manojb fer twdjty-twe
monds. ujiun`tojb bdjtny `hress tgd feetgonns ef Surpnd Meujt`oj.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 247/455
ATQO@N EF XTJ _@Y-XDJ 192
ehh`soej`nny ireppojb te twdjty fddt oj gdobgt. `vdr`bojb ferty er
merd. `ji fer nejb strdthgds rosojb te ` m`kdstoh gdobgt ef evdr soxty
fddt* M`jy gujirdis ef yd`rs eni. sturiony auont ef gobg arohls `aevd
` senoi br`jotd a`sd. tgd shdjd ef heujtndss a`ttnds fer tgd hoty. tgd
w`nns ef J`jlojb `rd ` prohdndss gdrot`bd ef m`kdsty `ji ad`uty <`ji
my forst strejb fddnojb wgdj O `rrovdi w`s tgd hejvohtoej tg`t tgdsd
w`nns must jet ad nest `s tgd prohd te ad p`oi ay J`jlojb fer ots
meidrjoz`toej*
Rgdj O feuji tgd w`nn w`s jewgdrd ndss tg`j tdj fddt woid `t
tgd tep `ji md`surdi evdr twdjty-fovd fddt woid fer `nn aut ` sgert
strdthg. wotg sdvdr`n monds ef w`nn evdr ferty fddt woid `ji `nrd`iy
p`vdi wotg stejd. O hnojhgdi m`ttdrs ay prepesojb tgd usd ef tgd djtord
w`nn fer `j dndv`tdi meter aeundv`ri twdjty-twe monds nejb wotg
r`mps nd`iojb up `t frdqudjt ojtdrv`ns `ji wotg p`rlojb sp`hds `ji
rdfrdsgmdjt st`toejs wgdrd tgd w`nn woidjs eut `t d`hg b`td ojte `
sp`hoeus pn`td`u* Ygd `hhempnosgmdjt ef tgos prekdht wonn bovd J`j-
lojb ejd ef tgd fojdst p`jer`moh irovds oj tgd werni*
Fennewojb tgd eroboj`n f`ht-fojiojb survdy. Mr* Murpgy adb`jwerl ej tgd hoty pn`j otsdnf. `ji J`jlojb snewny os adhemojb meidrj*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 248/455
10 SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_
@Ytgd dji ef tg`t summdr O ndft tgd F`r D`st `ji h`md gemd*
Ot w`s `aeut tomd. fer pdrg`ps O `nrd`iy g`i mossdi tee m`jy
ae`ts. `s tgd eni s`yojb os `mejb ferdobjdrs `nejb tgd Hgoj`
He`st* @ftdr merd tg`j fovd yd`rs spdjt oj K`p`j. Hgoj`. tgd Sgonop-
pojds `ji M`jhguro` O ndft tgd Erodjt ej Xdptdmadr 0. 0?1? er
r`tgdr. ot w`s ej tg`t X`aa`tg i`y tg`t O st`rtdi te nd`vd*
Aut adferd nd`vojb Hgoj` ndt us neel ejhd merd `t tgd shdjd tgdrd*
Ot w`s ` geibd-peibd ef penotohe-monot`ry purpesds `ji hress-purpesds*
Ygd pdroei ef tr`jsotoej oj se n`rbd ` n`ji pdepndi ay se m`jy woidny
sh`ttdrdi r`hds must n`st ` bdjdr`toej er merd* Yg`t os wgy O g`vd
j`mdi tgos venumd Ygd Ir`bej Xtors* Ygd ir`bej ef Hgoj` os jet
funny `w`ld dvdj jew aut gd os storrojb oj gos snddp* Gd os p`rtny
`w`ld `ji wgdj gos djtord sojueus aeiy hemds te nofd. i`wj wonn ad
evdr*
Yg`t Kujd. oj 0?1?. tgd mdj `t J`jlojb wdrd djb`bdi oj sup-
prdssojb
tgd
orrdprdssoand
Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n. M`rsg`n
Fdjb_u-
Gso`jb. `b`oj* Gd `ji tgd yeujbdr Bdjdr`ns oj tgd treuandsemd
Lw`jbso Srevojhd hnoqud wdrd r`osojb ` rumpus up-heujtry `t G`j-
lew* Ygd jdwdst ard`hg wotgoj tgd Luemojt`jb g`i st`rtdi oj M`y.
adferd Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj"s djtemamdjt `t J`jlojb* Oj neelojb tgreubg
my fonds ef iosp`thgds te Ygd Jdw _erl Yomds. O foji tgos gd`inojd
ej M`y 14; J@JLOJB NOJLX FDJB YE QDI SNEY* Etgdrs iurojb
tgesd etgdrwosd pnd`s`jt sprojb i`ys rdn`tdi gew Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb
L`o-sgdl `t
J`jlojb pnd`idiwotg M`rsg`n
Fdjbte `aoid
ay pd`hd <
gew tgd f`td ef Hgoj` gujb ej Fdjb"s jdxt stdp. `ji se ej* Ygos
rdadnnoej w`s smetgdrdi. `ji ay Kuny. `nn sddmdi quodt ej tgd Hgojdsd
frejt* Aut treuand wotg Xevodt Qusso` w`s te ehhur `b`oj sgertny.
m`rrojb my keurjdy a`hl te tgd Xt`tds* Ygos w`s jet `pp`rdjt `t
tg`t tomd. se O wdjt iewj te tgd Sgonoppojds*
Ygdrd wdrd sdvdr`n rd`sejs fer tgos* Ejd w`s tg`t O g`i addj
197
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 249/455
SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_
fonojb my h`andi iosp`thgds te Jdw _erl vo` M`jon`. bovojb ` irep-
hepy tgdrd te ` Fonopoje syjioh`td ef j`tovd n`jbu`bd jdwsp`pdrs
'hgodfny oj Y`b`neb/* Ygdy wdrd te p`y tgd h`and hests `s f`r `s
M`jon`. Ygd Jdw _erl Yomds te p`y tgdm frem tgdrd ej te Jdw
_erl* Aut tgd Fonopoje p`pdrs ioi jet p`y tgdor sg`rd. jdvdr g`i
sojhd wd adb`j tgos `rr`jbdmdjt mejtgs adferd* Ot w`s up te md te
henndht. se O wdjt te M`jon` `ji ioi*
@jetgdr rd`sej fer beojb kust `t tg`t tomd w`s my mddtojb wotg
Iwobgt F* I`vos. ef Xt* Neuos. wge g`i rdhdjtny addj `ppeojtdi te
suhhddi Henejdn Gdjry N* Xtomsej `s Bevdrjer-Bdjdr`n ef tgd Sgonop-
pojd Osn`jis* Mr* I`vos w`s p`ssojb tgreubg Xg`jbg`o ej gos w`y
te M`jon`. se O bet ej tgd s`md sgop `ji wdjt `nejb* Ygd bdjo`n
iejer ef tgd I`vos Hup fer ojtdrj`toej`n tdjjos hempdtotoej ` spndjioi
symaen ef beei wonn ojiuhdi tgreubg sperts w`s ` kevo`n sgop"s hem-
p`joej `ji wd adh`md r`tgdr wdnn `hqu`ojtdi fer suhg ` sgert mddtojb
`s tg`t feur-i`y ae`t roid*
O henndhtdi tgd )1.333 er se iud my p`pdr oj M`jon`. a`id Bevdrjer
I`vos `ji Xdj`ter M`judn Pudzej 'jew Srdsoidjt Pudzej/ f`rdwdnn
`t M`n`h`j`j S`n`hd `ji wdjt a`hl te Xg`jbg`o. `rrovojb oj moi-Kuny"s
gd`t* O idtdrmojdi tgdj te rdturj te @mdroh`*
Oj tgd fdw i`ys wgohg O spdjt oj p`hlojb my tgojbs prdp`r`tery te
tgd aob pusg%" treuand w`s ardwojb adtwddj Meshew `ji J`jlojb*
Ygd Hgojdsd r`oidi tgd Hgojdsd D`stdrj Q`onw`y `t G`raoj. oj Jertg
M`jhguro`. `aeut tg`t tomd* Ygd Qusso`js hejtrenndi tg`t nojd. wgohg
w`s hejjdhtdi wotg tgdor tr`js-Xoadro`j r`onre`i frem Vn`iovestel te
Meshew. `ji tgdy ioij"t nold tgos r`oi ` aot* Ygdy tgrd`tdjdi te
ojv`id M`jhguro` '`s tgd K`p`jdsd ioi n`tdr/ `ji tgdrd brdw up `
w`rnold tdjsoej adtwddj tgd twe j`toejs*
My treuands g`ikust adbuj* O g`i jet addj a`hl oj Xg`jbg`o `
wddl wgdj O bet iysdjtdry. wgohg idn`ydi my idp`rturd* Ay tgd
tomd O bet eut ef tgd gespot`n `ji ej my fddt `b`oj. ot w`s jd`rny tgd
dji ef @ubust. 0?1?* O h`jhdnndi ` tdjt`tovd p`ss`bd ej tgd E* X* L*Nojd vo` Xeutg @froh`. `ji seubgt ojstd`i te bdt te Durepd `hress
Xoadro`* Aut ` st`td `ppre`hgojb w`r dxostdi oj M`jhguro` ay tgdj*
Ot w`s jdhdss`ry te be vo` Vn`iovestel `ji tgdrd wdrd je Qusso`j
hejsun`r effoho`ns oj `nn Hgoj`. jet dvdj oj M`jhguro`. te prevoid md
wotg tgd vdry muhg jddidi p`sspert vos`* O idtdrmojdi. jdvdrtgdndss.
te be ej up te Vn`iovestel. tgdjhd tgreubg tgd @mur V`nndy evdr tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 250/455
143 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
nep ef M`jhguro` `ji iewj `b`oj. keojojb tgd tr`js-Xoadro`j nojd
prepdr `t tgd tewj ef Hgot`* Ot w`s tgos reutd O teel. wotgeut `
Qusso`j vos`* Jejd heuni ad eat`ojdi oj Hgoj`. aut O rdnodi ej tgd
`ivohd ef ` Xevodt prdss hennd`bud* Yg`t turjdi eut te ad ` most`ld.
aut gd heuni jet gdnp ot*
Ot w`s ` beei tgojb te ad bdttojb `w`y rd`nny `w`y `t n`st. `ftdr
se m`jy yd`rs fonndi wotg se m`jy r`poiny ehhurrojb dxpdrodjhds*
Ygdsd kust g`ppdjdi. `ji tgdy ehhurrdi te `jyejd wge w`s oj tgd F`r
D`st tgdj< aut O must s`y dvdjts sddmdi te hrewi ej d`hg etgdr"s
gddns oj tgesd yd`rs*
Ejd etgdr rd`sej tg`t O g`i te be w`s tg`t adferd O wdjt te tgd
gespot`n ejd neh`n Xg`jbg`o p`pdr r`j `j otdm tg`t O w`s nd`vojb ej
` ae`t vo` Xeutg @froh` tgd jdxt i`y* O wdjt te tgd gespot`n ojstd`i !
Rgdj O bet eut `nmest ` mejtg n`tdr. `t tgd @mdroh`j Hnua `ji tgd
Henumao` Heujtry Hnua wgdrd O wdjt wotg frodjis `b`oj te s`y f`rd-
wdnn semdejd ojv`ro`any s`oi; _eu stonn gdrd5 Ejd p`pdr r`j `
pohturd ef ` adspdht`hndi mossoej`ry `aeut tg`t tomd wotg my j`md
ujidr ot. `ji tgd h`ptoej tg`t O w`s nd`vojb tgd Erodjt* _eu m`y
om`bojd tgd hemmdjt. wgohg ojhnuidi; My. my. suhg ` hg`jbd `ji
onn ndss tg`j ` mejtg. tee!"+ Ef heursd tgdrd wdrd m`jy etgdr soids
te my idp`rturd. aut tgojbs nold tg`t aeridrojb ej tgd roiohuneus `ji
tgd nobgtdr soid ndft md wotg rdnosg fer tgd jdw `ivdjturd*
My io`ry ef tgd w`y oj wgohg O ndft Hgoj` os tgd adst w`y te bovd
yeu tgd hempndtd pohturd ef tgd rdturj ef tgd j`tovd te Jdw _erl*
XTJI@_. Xdptdmadr 0. 0?1?;
@AE@QI YGD X* X* MEIDXY@. @t Xd`; O ndft Hgoj`
tei`y * * * `ftdr twe yd`rs. sdvdj mejtgs* * * * @rrovdi oj Xg`jb-
g`o frem Yelye ej Xuji`y. Fda* 6. 0?12. fer tgd T* S* Yei`y.
oj ` R`nn`-w`nn` n`ujhg wotg H`renyj Hejvdrsd `ji Vohter
Lddj ef tgd Jdw _erl Gdr`ni-Yroaujd. O h`md `ae`ri tgd X* X*
Meidst`. `j @jbne-I`josg std`mdr aeuji fer Vn`iovestel- `ji
`hress Xoadro` `ji Durepd. `ji tgd @tn`jtoh * * * gemd ! Fovd
yd`rs gdrd `ji oj K`p`j os djeubg* O"m bn`i te ad ej my w`y*
G`i ` f`rdwdnn iojjdr `t tgd M`kdstoh Getdn n`st jobgt. Voh adojb
gest * * * kust ` quodt nottnd `ff`or Voh `ji Moss Hg`pnoj. "Boj`
`ji Aruje Xhgw`rtz `ji H`renyj `ji mysdnf* Gemd `t i`wj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 251/455
SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_ 140
* * * gurrodi foj`n p`hlojb `ji se te tgd sgop * * * Merros G`rros
'@*S*/ h`md te tgd Hustems Kdtty wotg us*
Ygdrd `rd sox etgdr
p`ssdjbdrs.
`nn Qusso`js* Ejd ojtreiuhdi
gomsdnf `s ` m`j wge. Qevdr ef Y`ss `bdjhy s`oi. weuni gdnp
md bdt ` vos` `t Vn`iovestel* Yeel ` hg`jhd `ji h`md ej tgos
trop wotgeut ` vos`. worojb R`ntdr Iur`jty `t Meshew* Eur
H`pt`oj os ` Jerwdbo`j kust eut frem Durepd wotg `j `rms
sgopmdjt * * * nejb oj Xeutg @mdroh`. `ji sojbs tgd pr`osds ef
Qoe id K`jdore* *** Ye adi d`rny `ji vdry tordi. `ftdr t`nlojb
wotg tgd H`pt`oj `aeut tgd ujf`or jdw T* X* @%s sgoppojb sua-
soiy. tgd ad`utods ef Qoe. dth* *** O `rrovdi `ji ndft Hgoj` ej `
Xuji`y* * * *
MEJI@_. Xdptdmadr 1;
Tp `t jeej `ji `ftdr td` `ji te`st oj my h`aoj. ej idhl te
w`nl ` aot `ji rd`i* * * * Xgop"s vortu`nny idsdrtdi* Ygd Meidste.
os ` f`r hry frem tgd Srds* Sodrhd wgohg O h`md eut ej oj 0?19*
Yd` `t feur `ji fddnojb ` aotonn
*** rennojb quotd ` aot. aut sef`r jet se a`i* My Qusso`j sgopm`tds `ssurd md O"nn g`vd je
treuand n`jiojb `t Vn`iovestel* Ygdy pn`ydi M` Kejbb `ftdr
iojjdr tejobgt `ji n`tdr wd s`t `ji g`i ` b`y tomd oj tgd
smelojb reem* Ye adi r`tgdr n`td `ftdr muhg R`nn`-w`nn`.
ojhnuiojb `j `rbumdjt wotg eur H`pt`oj `s te tgd mdrots ef tgd
Djbnosg n`jbu`bd Gd ojsostdi ot w`s tgd adst. mest dxprdssovd
spddhgoj tgd
werni.wgond O s`oi ot w`s ejd ef tgd
werst. n`hlojbtgd dx`htjdss ef tgd Frdjhg er dvdj semd Hgojdsd n`jbu`bds* * * *
YTDXI@_. Xdptdmadr 8;
Rd `rd g`nfw`y te V*. std`mojb pd`hdfunny `hress tgd K`p`j
Xd` wotg Lerd` pn`ojny vosoand eff eur pert aew. new. br`y.
mosty* * * * Nottnd fosgojb ae`ts iet tgd fn`t surf`hd ef eur ehd`j.
tgdor tojy s`ons adnnodi te tgd snobgt arddzd `ppd`rojb nold tgd
projts ay K`p`jdsd `rtosts* Ygd w`tdr os ` br`y-brddj `b`oj `ftdr
ydstdri`y"s pdhuno`rny iddp anud hg`r`htdrostoh ef tgd trepohs* * * *
@ji str`jbdny djeubg. wd r`j ojte heujtndss shgeens ef tojy fnyojb
fosg ! Jdvdr s`w tgesd aut oj tgd trepohs adferd* Ej idhl tei`y
`ftdr toffoj oj my h`aoj. te rd`i Meidrj Hgojdsd Hovonos`toej. ay
Ir* @* F* Ndbdjird. tr`jsn`tdi ay Dnsod M`rtoj Kejds oj Yelye*
Ot os ` vdry bdjdr`n pnd` fer ojtdrvdjtoej oj Hgoj` ay tgd Sewdrs <
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 252/455
141 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
aut gd. nold etgdrs wge"rd suppesdi te ljew `ji g`vd subbdstdi
tgos. effdrs je prebr`m* * * *
Musoh ej tgd Vohtren` oj tgd H`pt`oj"s h`aoj `ftdr iojjdr*
Gd prevoidi `nse G* B* Rdnns0
Mr* Arotnojb Xdds Ot Ygreubg.
` aeel ej Arot`oj"s beojb ojte tgd Brd`t R`r wgohg O rd`i ujton
tgd Hgoj`-aey dvohtdi md frem tgd iojojb reem `t tdj e"hnehl*
Ej idhl fer ` ard`tg ef `or* M`jy st`rs. aut ` vdry heen. an`hl
jobgt* * * * Ygd Aob Ioppdr eff eur pert aew. vdry new oj tgd
sd`* Ye my aujl vdry nejdny. semdgew*
RDIJDXI@_. Xdpt* 9;
Mr* Arotnojb `ji O g`i ` heen. pnd`s`jt i`y ef ot* O nold
Rdnns mest ef tgd tomd* Gd`vodr hnetgojb w`s hemfert`and ej
idhl* Bdttojb r`tgdr rdstndss `ji d`bdr te bdt `sgerd. @ mejet-
ejeus trop. tgos* Rdnn. Vn`iovestel d`rny temerrew os ejd hej-
sen`toej* Xtonn wejidrojb `aeut my vos`* My Qusso`j sgopm`tds
`rd hejfoidjt* * * surd je treuand. tgdy s`y*
YGTQXI@_. Xdpt* 4;
Rd `rd jew oj Vn`iovestel fer tgd forst tomd* Kust `s seej
ot"s my n`st. tee* Rg`t ` r`msg`hlnd tewj! Aut ` ad`utofun. `
truny ad`utofun j`tur`n g`raer. n`jinehldi. ots gonns rosojb nobgt
brddj `aevd tgd pn`hoi w`tdr* Ot g`s m`rvdneus pessoaonotods. aut
jetgojb"s addj iejd te ad`utofy ot er tgd tewj* Ygd g`raer
frddzds senoi oj Jevdmadr `ji osj"t ohd-frdd. tgdy s`y. ujton n`td
sprojb* G`ri te rd`nozd Vn`i* os `aeut tgd s`md n`totuid `s
Qemd! @ji wd g`vd je vos` tei`y! @ji tg`t"s je keldoj
tgos h`sd* Adh`usd tgd `utgerotods hovonny aut kust `s idfojotdny
s`oi ; _eu must jet hemd `sgerd wotgeut ` vos`* H`and Meshew
`b`oj of yeu nold* Rd"vd gd`ri jetgojb* Aut oj tgd md`jtomd.
ot"s tgd Meidste. fer yeu* Xe gdrd O sot `nejd wotg my tgeubgts.
` vortu`n prosejdr ej wg`t os jew my prov`td y`hgt* O sgeuni
g`vd `j `jswdr ejd w`y er tgd etgdr ay X`turi`y te ` h`and O
sdjt Meshew `b`oj tei`y tgreubg tgd h`p`and Mr* Venhgdl ef
tgd Qusso`j I`na`jl. wge `hhemp`jodi md te tgd Ferdobj @bdjt"s
effohd `ji tgd Senohd Idp`rtmdjt ef S`ssperts* Er r`tgdr. O
`hhemp`jodi gom* Gd teni my t`nd ef wed `ji jdbeto`tdi `ji
foj`nny teni md tgd rdsunt Gd hdrt`ojny w`s eanobojb. aut O h`j"t
gdnp fddnojb tg`t O"i g`vd iejd f`r adttdr ej my ewj. wotg `
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 253/455
SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_ 148
purd aut sompnd ojtdrprdtdr r`tgdr tg`j ` bu`rio`j* Xtonn. ot w`s
vdry loji ef gom* * * * Rd irevd te tgd F* @*"s effohd oj `j
`jhodjt
iresgly
evdr `reubg.
heaandstejdi `vdjuda`iny
oj jddi
ef rdp`or `ji up ` suaura`j-nold n`jd iewj wgohg sm`nn frdsgdts
r`j iobbojb trd`hgdreus gends oj tgd iort re`i wgohg h`usdi us
te pothg `aeut nold ` sgop oj ` b`nd. `ji mest pdroneusny tee*
M`id ot `ji a`hl wotgeut ` mosg`p * * * i`mjdi hndvdr. tgdsd
Quslods. irovojb* @ji se a`hl te tgd sgop fer ` n`td toffoj `nejd*
@ji ` j`p. fer O bet up d`rny te be `sgerd. `ji tgd kenny eni
Hustems kegjjods `ppd`rdi `t 03 `*m*. ojstd`i ef tgd `ivdrtosdi
fovd e"hnehl ej tgd aunndtoj ae`ri! Ygdy `nw`ys ie* ***
Ygdy el`ydi my nubb`bd wotgeut ioffohunty. aut ojsostdi ej
nehlojb up my fonds oj ejd ef my sm`nn tr`vdnnojb a`bs * * * Bei
ljews wgdrd tgdy"vd bet ot jew< semdwgdrd oj Vn`i* *** O
gepd ot hemds a`hl* Ygdy m`y ad rd`iojb `nn my h`ands. m`on
sterods. dt `n. fer yd`rs te tgd Yomds* * * * My H`pt`oj `ji O
g`i iojjdr oj st`td tejobgt< tgdj gd `ji tgd forst effohdr. Mr*
Orwoj G`jsdj. quotd ` rdm`rl`and fdnnew. wdjt `sgerd fer wg`t
turjdi eut te ad ` aot ef ` jobgt eut. rennojb oj wotg tgd i`wj*
@ji se te adi* * * *
FQOI@_. Xdpt* 6;
Rgy O dvdr. `s O ioi ej Rdijdsi`y. tgeubgt Vn`iovestel
weuni ad ` hejsen`toej Bei ejny ljews* Ot"s ad`stny. `ji of O
iej"tbdt
eff tgos
sgop
adferd
nejbO"nn
bem`i*
Ne`iojb`ji ujne`iojb ojtdrmoj`and brd`t aexds ef td` `nn i`y `ji jobgt!
Je snddp *** je JEYGOJB* Fer ndss tg`j tg`t O"i hguhl tgos
Durepd`j teur `ji be robgt gemd. vdry `jbry* * * * Fujjy te
neel a`hl ej. el`y * * * aut tgdsd ujdjiojb i`ys `ji jobgts `rd
tgd werst O"vd ljewj*
X@YTQI@_. Xdpt* 2;
@sgerd tei`y* Neels `s tgeubg semdtgojb g`s g`ppdjdi* @fnujly h`md `ae`ri `aeut feur p*m* `ji `ftdr semd treuand bdttojb
`j ojtdrprdtdr s`oi tg`t gd g`i ` p`ss pdrmottojb md te n`ji `t
ejhd `ji be `jywgdrd O noldi* Fojd* @nse. gd g`i ` mdss`bd
rdquorojb tg`t O h`nn `t tgd se-h`nndi Hdjtr`n Hejtren Seojt%"
S`sspert Iovosoej. `t jojd `*m* ej Meji`y* My budss os tg`t
tgdy bet weri tgd vos` os el`y `ji tg`t O bdt ot Meji`y* Fojd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 254/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 255/455
SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_ 144
heni md`ts. tojjdi `ji etgdrwosd. `ji veil`. wotg std`mojb get
Qusso`j td` oj t`nn bn`ssds `ftdr wgohg O"m bdttojb te nold om-
mdjsdny* Ot w`shgonny
wgdj wd ndft te h`thg tgd 2;86 p*m*
tr`oj a`hl te Vn`iovestel* Rd wdjt te ` Qusso`j mevod tejobgt
`nn Xevodt prep`b`ji` `ji g`i merd td` `ji md`t a`nns `ji
` swddt fer iojjdr n`tdr* Xe a`hl te tgd getdn. `ji te adi wgohg
O g`i te m`ld* Ot g`i jet addj teuhgdi sojhd O ndft tg`t merjojb*
MEJI@_. Xdpt* ?;
Kuibd @nnm`j g`s hemd `ji bejd* Bet oj tewj tei`y ej `
K`p`jdsd std`mdr frem Ysurub` `jiO mossdi gom `t forst * * *
t`lojb my a`tg* * * * Gd h`md `b`oj te tgd getdn `aeut sox p*m*.
g`vojb bet gos tohldt fer tejobgt"s tr`oj* * * tee n`td jew te
h`jhdn ot `ji gd wdjt ej te Meshew* @ji O stonn g`vd je vos`*
* * * X`w tgd S`sspert Iovosoej hg`p* Je weri. aut w`jtdi md
te fonn eut `j `ppnoh`toej an`jl* O ioi. `ji gd"nn pgejd md of `ji
wgdj `jytgojb g`ppdjs* Ygos ujhdrt`ojty os bdttojb mobgty eni*
YTDXI@_. Xdpt* 03;
My ojtdrprdtdr. ` yeujb @mdroh`j hg`p. str`jbd te s`y. ef
Qusso`j p`rdjts. str`jidi `nejd gdrd. h`md `nejb `aeut tgrdd
`ji wd wdjt oj sd`rhko ef B`tdsm`j. tgd Ferdobj @bdjt * * * tgdj
te tgd K`p`jdsd Hejsun`td te sdd `aeut beojb te K`p`j temerrew
te bdt ` vos` `t Ysurub`. `ji rdturj gdrd wotg tgd Arostens `ji
t`ld tgd s`md tr`oj* * * * Je h`j ie* *** Bet B`tdsm`j ej tgd
pgejd `ji foj`nny m`id `j `ppeojtmdjt fer tdj `*m* temerrew*Xdjt Iur`jty `jetgdr urbdjt h`and* Gepd semdtgojb g`ppdjs
seej! R`r rumers tgohl `s fnods `t tgd heffdd sgeps `ji dnsd-
wgdrd oj tewj tei`y* * * * Hgojdsd m`y fobgt* * * * A`ttnd beojb
ej `nejb tgd M`jhguro`j aeridr sojhd tgd dobgtg. tgdy s`y * * *
`nse `reuji G`a`revsl* * * * Fddn eut ef teuhg wotg dvdrytgojb
oj tgos pn`hd. fer tgd forst tomd oj yd`rs* * * * Eii fddnojb. tgos
oindjdss ef mojdrobgt
jew* * * *
Qdhruotojb gurrodiny beojbej
gdrd jew* Xeniodrs dvdrywgdrd sojbojb. m`rhgojb tgreubg tgd
strddts* Neels emojeus* Gepd ot iedsj"t geni up tgd tr`oj
sdrvohd * * * jet adferd O bdt `hress of O dvdr ie bdt tg`t vos`*
RDIJDXI@_. Xdpt* 00;
Bet `htoej tei`y! Mdt B`tdsm`j `t tgd effohd `t tdj `*m*
wotg Hgrostdjsdj ef tgd Brd`t Jertgdrj. `ji B`tdsm`j g`i bet
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 256/455
146 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
` tdndbr`m frem Meshew tdnnojb gom te fox md up* Gd ioi `
net ef tdndpgejojb `ji wd wdjt te tgd S`sspert Effohd `ji `nn w`s
`pp`rdjtnyel`y*
Fondi `jetgdr `ppnoh`toej.wgohg Mr* H* wretd
eut oj Qusso`j. `ji p`oi twdjty ruands `ji b`vd tgdm ` pgete*
Bdt my p`sspert a`hl wotg tgd vos` ej Froi`y* * * * Yejbud oj
hgddl ujton tgdj. aut adnodvd ot"s foj`nny foxdi* Rotg Ojtdrprdtdr
S`un te Ygd Qdi A`jjdr. ` Hemmujost sgddt * * * tgdj evdr te
tgd Meidst`* Jdvdr w`nldi se muhg er se f`r oj ejd i`y oj
`nn my nofd *** `nn evdr tewj ej muntof`roeus drr`jis* *** Je
weri frem Iur`jty* Ye ` hojdm` wotg Mrs* M* tejobgt * * *
ndft `t g`nf-tomd* Xgd teni md tejobgt sgd w`s ` seniodr oj tgd
Hz`r"s `rmy oj 0?04 weujidi jojdtddj tomds iurojb tgd Rerni
R`r* * * * Qdm`rl`and wem`j* Ye adi d`rny. vdry tordi*
YGTQXI@_. Xdpt* 01;
Merd a`i jdws* @ iendfun h`and frem Iur`jty oj Meshew
ojtom`tojb F* E* tgdrd rdfusds p`sspert vos` ej wg`t breujis
Beiejny
ljews* * * * @ftdr B`tdsm`j"s `ttotuid ydstdri`y `ji
gos urbdjt ojsostdjhd `t tgd S`sspert Effohd gdrd tg`t tgdy bovd
md ejd `t ejhd. dnsd gd bdts ojte treuand oj Meshew. djtordny oj-
dxpnoh`and* * * * Hgrostdjsdj"s fer iojjdr tejobgt. `ji gd `ji
Gerriej wdrd stonn eptomostoh* @m suppesdi te bdt my vos` `t
jeej temerrew* Ej tgd strdjbtg ef `nn tgdsd tgojbs. mevdi
trujls oj frem tgd Meidst` tei`y* M`y g`vd te mevd tgdm robgt
a`hl temerrew! Xpndjioi hgew `t H"s. `ji n`tdr aroibd fer `
heupnd ef geurs* Dvdryejd os hdrt`ojny `mo`and `ji `hhem-
mei`tojb*
FQOI@_ tgd 08tg!<
Bet tgd vos` tei`y! Rotg Mr* H* te tgd S`sspert Effohd `t
jeej `ji dvdrytgojb w`s el`y* Bet my T* X* hurrdjhy hg`jbdi
ojte ruands `t tgd Hgesdj A`jl* Ye tgd Bdrm`j Hejsun`td wgdrd
O bet ` vos` fer
Bdrm`jy beeifer ejd
yd`r*O"m tr`js-Xoadro`
aeuji ej Meji`y wg`t ` ne`i eff my moji*
YTDXI@_. Xdpt* 02;
Rd"rd ej tgd w`y te Meshew. `ji `t tgd memdjt `rd st`nndi
`t ` nottnd pn`hd h`nndi Qdi Qovdr Xt`toej. kust ` fdw monds frem
G`a`revsl. `ftdr moijobgt ej ` heni. meejnot pn`oj* G`i toffoj
Xuji`y wotg @imor`n `ji Mrs* Arosten. kust oj frem K`p`j * * *
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 257/455
SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_ 142
`nse iojjdr `ji te tgd tr`oj `t dndvdj p*m* Mdt H`pt`oj K* ej
tgd w`y tgdrd* Feuji twe trujls hest md 066*43 ruands a`bb`bd
f`rd! YeMeshew.
`nejd * * * `nmest `s muhg `s
myewj r`on-
re`i tohldt `ji snddpojb h`r. hemaojdi. te Adrnoj! Yg`t w`s `
anew* * * * Foj`nny `nn `ae`ri `t twdnvd moijobgt `ji rd`iy te
be *** Hgrostdjsdj `ji Gerriej `nse iewj te sdd us eff. `ji
twe er tgrdd merd* O"m `nejd oj my hemp`rtmdjt se f`r* Bdt
` p`rtjdr `t G`a`revsl* Gepd gd"s jet bet muhg a`bb`bd <tgdsd
hemp`rtmdjts `rd sm`nn* * * * Ejd nol`and hg`p ej ae`ri os `
Xwdiosg djbojddr. nejb ` rdsoidjt ef Hgoj`. beojb gemd*
FQOI@_. Xdpt* 13;
Eubgt te lddp tgos up dvdry i`y * * * aut jet muhg ef oj-
tdrdst* Geur `ftdr geur ef rennojb pr`orod * * * reutojd ef d`tojb.
rdstojb. w`nlojb. dth*. bdttojb ` aot ef dxdrhosd `t tgd v`roeus
st`toej steps. `ji hg`ts wotg tgd etgdr rdstndss p`ssdjbdrs*
S`ssdi Hgot` tei`y *** r`j ojte Johl. hg`p wge a`radrdi `t
tgd @mdroh`j Hnua oj Xg`jbg`o* Xtr`jidi up gdrd `ji h`j"t bdta`hl jew. iud te tgd w`r* Heujtry os ioffdrdjt jew* Rd"rd oj
Xoadro` prepdr* Merd vonn`bds tg`j tgreubg tgd @mur V`nndy.
tgd rohg ydnnew n`ji huntov`tdi. `ji fdjhds `nn `nejb* Adferd tgdrd
w`s jetgojb. gujirdis ef monds ef gonns. ferdsts. je huntov`toej*
Ird`ry `ji heni* G`i eur forst sjew ydstdri`y* Yrdds turjojb
ydnnew `ji rdi oj ` prefusoej ef f`nn heners `nejb tgd Xoadro`j
heujtrysoid<muhg nold tgd moiindwdst `t gemd* Ygd meejnot
jobgts up gdrd `rd wejidrfun. hnd`r* @ funn ydnnew g`rvdst meej
hemds up `t i`rl. `s wd hg`sd tgd rdiidjojb. sdttojb suj ojte
tgd Rdst tew`ri Durepd. `ji fonns eur ydnnew werni wotg ` seft
nobgt* Ygd ferdst trdds jd`ray `nejb tgd tr`hls. er tr`hl ot os
sojbnd. se f`r. `hress mest ef Xoadro` m`rhg ay nold an`hl
sg`iews* Xox merd i`ys te Meshew. `ji O"nn ad bn`i wgdj
wd"rd tgdrd* Rd sdt tgd hnehl a`hl `j geur ` i`y jew. Meshew
adojb sox geurs adgoji Hgot`*
MEJI@_. Xdpt* 18;
Tjdvdjtfun wddldji. wotg eur trop merd tg`j g`nf evdr*
Omprevojb my Qusso`j tgd wgond. of `jy. wotg `j dx-Henejdn ef
tgd Hz`r"s `rmy. ` semdwg`t `ttr`htovd `ji vdry anejid a`nndt
i`jhdr frem Ndjojbr`i. `ji ` Qusso`j-Kdw wge spd`ls Bdrm`j
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 258/455
147 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`ji `hts `s ojtdrprdtdr fer md* Nd`rjdi QEM M`rod oj Qusso`j.
wgohg os je sm`nn fd`t. dvdrytgojb hejsoidrdi* Rd p`ss ` jumadr
ef
vonn`bds
`ji semd sozd`and hotods jew `ji tgdj* Y`ld dxdrhosd
`t dvdry step. `ji auy hgddsd. seur hrd`m `ji auttdr< semd re`st
hgohldjs. tee* Ygd @imor`n os `j ojidf`tobu`and ojvdstob`ter ef
tgd st`toej rdst`ur`jts `ji ojv`ro`any hemds a`hl n`idj wotg neet
tgd preiuhd ef tgd g`mndt* Rd bdt te Meshew ej Ygursi`y*
G`ppy tgeubgt; ` a`tg!
RDIJDXI@_. Xdpt* 14;
Ygreubg tgd Tr`ns n`st jobgt `ji ojte Durepd tei`y* Meshewtemerrew merjojb* Xdjt Iur`jty ` word `slojb gom te bdt
rdsdrv`toejs fer md `ji tgd Arostens `t tgd Br`ji Getdn tgdrd oj
Meshew * * * tgdrd"s `nw`ys ` Br`ji Getdn oj dvdry tewj. ot
sddms! Aeubgt ` heupnd ef trojldts * * * sdmo-prdhoeus stejds
`ji tgd nold. `t ` tewj h`nndi Xvdrinevsl n`st jobgt* Yei`y bet
` weeidj hob`rdttd h`sd `t `jetgdr st`toej oj ` iostroht f`meus
ferots
weeiwerl* H`j"t rd`nozd tejobgt"sn`st
jobgt ej tr`oj*
Ygd heujtrysoid jew os rd`nny ad`utofun * * * wdnn ldpt up `ji
huntov`tdi * * * jet nold tgd woni stdppds ef Xoadro`"s pn`ojs * * *
monnoejs ef for trdds* Ygd werni os stonn s`fd fer X`jt` Hn`us!
Ygd trop `hress g`s addj idnobgtfun `nn tgd tdj i`ys *** bet ojte
` reutojd. wotg toffoj i`ony `t tgrdd p*m* Ygd jobgts h`md ej
`m`zojbny f`st * * * tgd i`ys fndi ay oj je tomd* * * * Meshew
oj tgd
merjojb.
wotgpnd`surd
aut ot"s addj `quohl
`jidjkey
0
`and trop te Durepd frem tgd F`r D`st* Oj ` w`y. O"m serry ot"s
djiojb*
YGTQXI@_. Xdpt* 16;
Rd bet te Meshew `aeut tdj tgorty tgos merjojb `ji of ot
g`ij"t addj fer Dubdjd Nyejs ef tgd T* S* wd"i ad `t tgd st`toej
ydt! Gd w`s tgdrd `ji foxdi dvdrytgojb `aeut nubb`bd. dth*
Ndft my trujls `t tgd st`toej. `ji wotg Mrs* A* `ji nets ef a`bs
'tgdy wdrd wosd `ji teel je trujls/ teel ` t`xo te tgd getdn*
O"vd jet tee a`i ` reem. tgeubg wotg je a`tg `tt`hgdi. fer tdj
ruands ` i`y* Mrs* Audrboj. wofd ef tgd Bdjdr`n Meters hgodf
`t S`ros. dj reutd tgdrd. heunij"t bdt ` reem. jet g`vojb wordi
`gd`i `s wd ioi. `ji `s sgd w`jtdi te t`ld ` a`tg O ndt gdr usd
my reem wgond O a`tgdi oj tgd reems ef H`rrenn Aojidr. ef tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 259/455
SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_ 14?
Hgoh`be I`ony Jdws. wge hemaojds gos effohd `ji reems `t tgd
getdn oj ejd suotd* @ji wgond tgd trop w`s jet a`i. `ftdr tg`t
a`tg O fdnt nold ` jdw m`j `b`oj! Ygd i`y w`s hnd`r. aut heni
`s gdnn. `t nd`st `ftdr Xg`jbg`o"s moni hnom`td jd`r tgd trepohs*
G`i toffoj wotg Aojidr. Iduss ef O* J* X*. `ji etgdrs* Sn`jjdi
te teur `aeut tewj wotg tgd A"s `ftdr toffoj. aut mossdi tgdm
wgond tryojb te gdnp Mrs* Audrboj auy ` tohldt frem tgd aeridr
te S`ros* Yejobgt te tgd Meshew epdr` wotg tgd Arostens `ji
Aojidr* Adb`j `t sdvdj tgorty `ji n`stdi ujton twdnvd tgorty `*m* !
Bet eur mejdy"s wertg tgdrd* Epdr` Geusd os ` m`ssovd auoni-
ojb * * * epdr` sojbojb dxhdnndjt. dspdho`nny hgerusds* * * * X`w
Aeros Beiujev. Meusserbsly"s epdr` ef eni Qusso`j heurt oj-
trobud* Ygd A"s `ji O g`i suppdr `t ejd `*m*. `ji `ftdr ` i`jhd
wotg M` Arosten. te adi n`td `ji vdry tordi* * * * Iur`jty w`s
oj Adrnoj. rdturjojb frem S`ros* A`hl ej Xuji`y* Ygd A"s be
te Ndjojbr`i X`turi`y p*m* O"vd idhoidi te be ej te Bdrm`jy
ej Xuji`y dvdjojb*
X@YTQI@_. Xdpt* 17;
Ygos os ` f`shoj`tojb aut fd`rfunny idprdssojb spet* Ygos wddl
dji wd g`vd addj sddojb tgd sobgts oj merd er ndss teurost f`sgoej.
dxhdpt wd g`vd jet g`i tomd te be ojte tgd musdums. hgurhgds.
f`hterods. `ji tgd rdst ej tgd ad`tdj teurost tr`hl* Rd"vd irovdj
`aeut tewj. gewdvdr. `ji sddj tgdsd pn`hds `t. se te spd`l. `rm"s
ndjbtg* Ygd Lrdmnoj eff tgd Qdi Xqu`rd wd ioi oj `aeut twe
geurs. er ` nottnd ujidr Ygos os f`r frem tgd rdheri. wgohg tgd
teurosts `rd huttojb iewj `nn tgd tomd* Xeej tgdy"nn ad rujjojb
sobgt-sddojb ausds tgreubg ot oj tdj mojutds f Ejd must g`vd `
p`ss te bdt oj gdrd fer tgd Lrdmnoj os tgd sd`t ef bevdrjmdjt*
Oj gdrd ejd m`y vodw tgd wojiews ef Ndjoj"s stuiy oj tgd
Bevdrjmdjt auoniojb ej tgd ndft. wgond ej yeur robgt. n`iods
`ji bdjtndmdj. os `j eni h`jjej. tgd hgonn veohd ef tgd pre-
fdssoej`n buoid irejds ej wgond `j `nn-@mdroh`j p`rty ef `t nd`st
tgorty r`tgdr aerdi hotozdjs b`zds `aeut tgd h`mpus-nold squ`rd
fermdi ay `jhodjt auoniojbs. hgurhgds. Sdtdr tgd Brd`t"s pn`y-
geusd. dth*. `ji y`wjs* Ygd Lrdmnoj. wgond jet se get. must
g`vd addj rd`nny m`bjofohdjt oj ots i`y; ot stonn os ` m`ssovdny
omprdssovd pn`hd. wotg ots beni-hevdrdi. mesqud-nold hgurhg
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 260/455
163 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tewdrs. tgd squ`rd wgdrd tgd dmpdrers ef eni wdrd hgrostdjdi
wgdj Meshew w`s tgd h`pot`n. tgd pn`hd wgdrd tgd Hz`rs wdrd
hrewjdi. rundi `ji n`y aurodi jew bu`ridi ay Qdi Xevodt
treeps `ji m`hgojd bujs* * * *
MEJI@_. Xdpt* 83;
Eut ef Xevodt Qusso` `t n`st* Rd hressdi tgd aeridr ojte
Sen`ji `t Xtenphd `t tdj `*m*
Mdt Iur`jty ` memdjt ej gos rdturj frem eutsoid. `s tgd
herrdspejidjts er `jyejd dnsd st`toejdi oj Meshew tdrms ` vosot
te `jy heujtry oj tgd rdst ef Durepd* Ygdj O g`i te i`sg fer
my tr`oj te Adrnoj. beojb vo` R`rs`w fer ` arodf g`nt adtwddj
tr`ojs tgdrd. wgdrd O g`i ` bnompsd ef tgdor Tjljewj Xeniodr"s
tema wotg ots pdrdjjo`n ujqudjhgdi fn`md `ji tgd ojdvot`and
wrd`tg ef gejer* My tr`oj hemp`joejs. ejd `j Djbnosgm`j `ji
tgd etgdr ` yeujb @mdroh`j djbojddr. `brddi tg`t ot w`s brd`t
jet te g`vd te t`nl oj wgospdrs `jy merd. jew tg`t wd wdrd eut
ef Qusso`* Ot os* @ji te sdd mdj `ji wemdj wotg smonojb f`hds
`ji sonl stehlojbs `ftdr tgd hettej-hnetgdi. hgddrndss `ppd`rojb
Qusso`j borns se ird`r oj tgdor j`tovd sdttojb*
Gdrd O sg`nn slop my io`ry"s ndjbtgy `hheujt ef my ieojbs oj
Adrnoj `ji my ujdxpdhtdi trop iewj te S`ros wgdj O g`i pn`jjdi te
st`y nejbdr oj Bdrm`jy `ji pdrg`ps wrotd semdtgojb tgdj `aeut tgd
Erodjt `ji ots `ff`ors* O
pn`jjdite s`on frem
Ardmdrg`vdjej
tgdJertg Bdrm`j Nneyi nojdr Xtuttb`rt fer ` ndosurdny hressojb te Jdw
_erl. aut dvdjts wgohg O ioi jet hejtrenjer h`rdi te p`rtohun`rny
`ftdr ` fovd-yd`r sekeurj eut D`st `w`y frem nofd `s wd ljew ot oj tgd
Ehhoidjt h`usdi md te spdji tgrdd wddls oj S`ros* Ygdy wdrd
idnobgtfun wddls. aut O s`ondi `t n`st frem Aeunebjd fer gemd. `ji
wretd;
FQOI@_. Jevdmadr7;
@AE@QI YGD X*X* XYTYYB@QY. @t Xd`; Rd"rd twe
i`ys frem Jdw _erl. adojb iud ej Xuji`y. tgd 03tg. X`w `nn
O h`rd te ef Durepd fer jew oj tgd p`st tgrdd wddls oj S`ros.
`ji `ftdr ` wddl ej ae`ri tgos snew p`hldt O sg`nn ad rd`iy te
bdt a`hl gemd* Mdt `jojtdrdstojb Bdrm`j-@mdroh`j hg`p ej
ae`ri j`mdi G* S* 'Gdojod/ Negm`jj. fermdrny wotg tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 261/455
SDQXEJ@N STANOHOY_ 160
Xt`ji`ri Eon oj Xg`jbg`o. ` stehl areldr oj X`j Fr`jhoshe*
Ljdw m`jy ef my frodjis oj Hgoj`. `ji wd t`nldi ef eni tomds
eut D`st* Rd`tgdr se f`r dxhdnndjt ej tgd Jertg @tn`jtoh fer
tgos tomd ef yd`r* * * * Jet ` i`y ef sd`-sohljdss fer md ***
aut wd"vd renndi quotd ` aot sdvdr`n tomds * * * must ad ` adttdr
er wosdr s`oner*
Ej ae`ri tgd X* X* Xtuttb`rt `rd ` Mr* Nulds `ji gos twe
yeujb i`ubgtdrs. X`r`g `ji Xus`j. ef Puojhy. 000* * * * Ygdsd
borns wdrd `t Hgrosto`j Henndbd oj Mosseuro wgdj O wdjt te tgd
Xt`td Tjovdrsoty `t Henumao` tgdrd yd`rs `be * * * tgdy ljdw
Yobd Arewj. Tjh Adjsej. dth*. vdry wdnn* *** Rd `nse
g`i hejsoidr`and te hg`t `aeut frem tgesd i`ys vdry iost`jt te
us `nn *** fujjy heojhoidjhd* * * *
My io`ry djis `aruptny wotg tg`t rdm`rl. fujjy heojhoidjhd*
Rd iehldi oj Jdw _erl ` i`y er se n`tdr ej Jevdmadr 03. 0?1?*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 262/455
11 YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ
f|+GD K`p`jdsd sdozdi M`jhguro`"s pd`hdfun Ygrdd D`stdrj Srev-
O ojhds ef Hgoj` oj tgd f`nn `ji wojtdr ef 0?80-81 `ji rdsterdi tgd
Aey Dmpdrer te tgd tgrejd ef gos M`jhgu `jhdsters ej M`rhg
0 `j gosteroh`n i`td oj m`rlojb tgd M`jhgu ojv`soej ef Hgoj` adnew
tgd Brd`t R`nn* Ot w`s ej tgos i`td oj 0699 tg`t tgdy adb`j tgdor
Hgojb Iyj`sty er Surd rund oj Sdlojb*
Ygd Aey Dmpdrer g`i addj novojb oj pd`hdfun sdhnusoej `s `
budst ef tgd K`p`jdsd oj tgdor Hejhdssoej `t Yodjtsoj fer sdvdr`n
yd`rs. sojhd gos prdhopoteus fnobgt frem Sdlojb"s ujhdrt`ojtods* Gd w`s
oj aeiony i`jbdr tgdrd dvdj adferd tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej. `ji
wotg tgd `oi ef tgd K`p`jdsd gd bet `w`y* Xtonn. ot w`s semdtgojb ef
` h`sd ef eut ef tgd fryojb-p`j `ji ojte tgd ford fer gd g`s jdvdr
addj frdd sojhd*
Gd w`s ` vortu`n prosejdr `t Yodjtsoj* Ygdj wgdj K`p`j p`hofodi
M`jhguro` `ji rd`nny adh`md id`iny sdroeus oj gdr pn`j tgdrd. gd w`s
djtgrejdi `t Hg`jb-hgujb. jew h`nndi Gsojlojb. tgd jdw h`pot`n oj
jertgd`stdrj @so`*
Ygd Aey Dmpdrer g`i je merd te s`y `aeut gos adojb wgosldi
`w`y frem tgd h`nm ef Yodjtsoj te tgd m`dnstrem ef M`jhguro` oj
0?81 tg`j yeu ioi* Ot w`s fer tgd st`td. `j Erodjt`n hejhdptoej ef
purd p`troetosm. tg`t tgd yeutg. wge g`i addj ljewj fer ` tomd adferd
gos evdrtgrew oj tgd eroboj`n rdvent `b`ojst gos Ir`bej Ygrejd `s
Dmpdrer Gsu`j Y"ojb. adh`md Dmpdrer L`jb-Ydg* Gomsdnf. gd
prdfdrrdi te ad ljewj `s pn`oj Mr Gdjry Su-yo. `ji iurojb gos
rdtordmdjt oj Sdlojb `ji n`tdr oj Yodjtsoj tg`t w`s tgd hebjemdj
gd usdi* Aut ejd aerj `s tgd Xej ef Gd`vdj. h`jjet ad pn`oj Mr*
`jytgojb fer vdry nejb* Ygd Erodjt`ns `rd fujjy tg`t w`y* Of yeu
`rd tgd Xej ef Gd`vdj. yeu"vd bet te ad tgd Xej ef Gd`vdj se tg`t
tgd hemmej pdepnd m`y g`vd semdtgojb te lew-tew te iewj gdrd ej
d`rtg*
161
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 263/455
YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 168
Yg`t os tgd hgodf rd`sej tgdrd w`s je m`ker hempn`ojt veohdi ay
tgd M`jhgus er tgd Hgojdsd pdepnds wgdj Gdjry adh`md tgdor jdw
rundr*
Ygdynoldi ot* Ygd
Dmpdreroj tgd Erodjt os
wersgoppdi`s wdnn `s rdvdrdi* Ygd K`p`jdsd g`vd tgd s`md hejhdptoej oj tgdor
idveut aewojb te tgd Dmpdrer Goregote. wgem tgdy adnodvd ` iordht
idshdji`jt ef tgd Xuj Beiidss* Ygd Ehhoidjt`n r`hds g`vd `j `f-
fono`tdi rdnoboeus adnodf eftdj dxprdssdi oj tgd iovojd robgt ef lojbs*
Oj tgd rdster`toej oj M`jhguro` M`rhg 0. 0?81. K`p`j br`aadi
M`jhguro` `s sgd g`i se nejb h`rdfunny pn`jjdi te ie* @aeut tg`t
tomd. O w`s kust bdttojb sdttndi oj R`sgojbtej* Ygd treuand g`i
st`rtdi adferd O bet tgdrd* K`p`j rdpertdi tgd jew gosteroh Mulidj
Ojhoidjt. wgdj gdr Xeutg M`jhguro` Q`onw`y tr`hl ej tgd aeridr
ef tg`t hoty w`s s`oi te g`vd addj terj up ay Hgojdsd* Yreeps wdrd
rusgdi te tgd spet frem `nn qu`rtdrs. rd`hgojb tgdrd oj ` surprosojbny
sgert tomd frem tgd hgodf M`jhguro`j a`sd `t I`ordj*
Ygd ojhoidjt ehhurrdi ej Xdptdmadr 07. 0?80* Oj ` fdw geurs
tgd K`p`jdsd sdozdi hejtren ef Mulidj wotg gdr r`onw`y bu`ris st`-
toejdi tgdrd `ji rdojferhdmdjts* Ygdrd w`s gd`vy fobgtojb`nn tg`t
f`nn `ji f`r ojte tgd wojtdr. aut ay sprojb tgd K`p`jdsd g`i dvdrytgojb
ujidr hejtren* Ygdor @ma`ss`ier te tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. Mr* Ldj-
lohgo Idauhgo. i`ony `ssurdi eur Xdhrdt`ry ef Xt`td tgdy g`i je
ojtdjtoej ef `jjdxojb M`jhguro`* Henejdn Gdjry N Xtomsej pre-
fdssdi te adnodvd gos an`ji. dvdr-smonojb `ssur`jhds
Oj ` w`y. tgd Gejer`and Mr* Idauhgo sgert. retuji. smonojb. `ji
` beei sheut w`s robgt* Ygd mdj `t Yelye ioi jet `jjdx
M`jhguro` oj se m`jy weris* Ygdy sompny s`w te ot tg`t tgd
pdepnd oj M`jhguro` w`jtdi ojidpdjidjhd frem Hgoj` ` pgr`sd
dvdj tgd `vdr`bd @mdroh`j heuni ujidrst`ji* Rd w`jtdi eur ojid-
pdjidjhd ejhd jet se nejb `be. tee. `ji bet ot* Ygus wd foji tg`t
9
"tgd pdepnd hg`jbdi tgd j`md te M`jhgulue `ji tgdmsdnvds pre-
hn`omdi tgdor jdw ojidpdjidjt Xt`td tgd i`y tg`t tgd Aey Dmpdrer
`shdjidi gos jdw tgrejd oj Gsojlojb* Yelye g`i jetgojb te ie
wotg ot effoho`nny*Aut ujeffoho`nny wdnn. wg`t ie yeu tgojl5
Yg`t i`y tgdy 'tgd pdepnd/ .wotg K`p`jdsd `ivosdrs. b`vd yeujb
Mr* Gdjry Su-yo `j Ompdro`n `jjeujhdmdjt. er Qdshropt. te rd`i
wgond gd prdp`rdi te sot iewj ej gos jdw tgrejd* Ot rd`i tg`t gd
'wd/ w`s `shdjiojb tgd tgrejd oj hejfermoty wotg tgd wosgds ef
tgd pdepnd. `ji hempnyojb wotg tgd wonn ef Gd`vdj* @ji tgd jdw
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 264/455
169 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Xt`td w`s aerj. K`p`j dxtdjidi id kurd rdhebjotoej effoho`nny sdvdr`n
mejtgs n`tdr. oj tgd Sretehen ef Xdptdmadr 04. 0?81. kust ` yd`r `ftdr
tgd Mulidj ojhoidjt wgohg w`s r`tgdr f`st mevojb oj suhg `
b`md ef penotohs*
D`rny oj K`ju`ry ef 0?81. tgd K`p`jdsd bet ojte treuand iewj oj
Xg`jbg`o* Ygos forst Xg`jbg`o R`r h`usdi wddls ef st`rtnojb
jdws `b`oj `ji ot teel K`p`j"s treeps r`tgdr nejbdr tg`j tgdy g`i
`jtohop`tdi te qudnn tgd stuaaerj Hgojdsd rdsost`jhd ndi ay tgd jew
f`meus Jojdtddjtg Qeutd @rmy `t tgd meutg ef tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr
jd`rXg`jbg`o*
Yg`t eutard`l
adb`j
wgdj ` Hgojdsd mea ej
K`ju`ry 07. 0?81. `tt`hldi fovd K`p`jdsd oj Xg`jbg`o. ojhnuiojb twe
Auiigost prodsts* Ygd K`p`jdsd sdjt ` M`rojd p`tren `sgerd te
p`hofy tgd sotu`toej. `ji tgd w`r w`s ej* Herrdspejidjts frem
`nn evdr tgd werni fnehldi tgdrd `b`oj. ojhnuiojb Ronn Qebdrs. Fneyi
Boaaejs `ji sherds ef etgdrs* @ji O w`s rdh`nndi frem R`sgojbtej
te g`jind tgd trdmdjieus venumd ef h`andi iosp`thgds peurojb oj frem
tgd herrdspejidjts eut tgdrd fer Ygd Tjotdi Srdss @sseho`toejs*
Ygdy ldpt md sw`mpdi i`y oj. i`y eut iurojb tg`t sgew oj
K`ju`ry `ji Fdaru`ry ef 0?81* Ygd jdws peurdi oj `t `nn geurs ef
tgd i`y `ji jobgt* Ej K`ju`ry 13. tgd Xg`jbg`o Mujohop`n Heujhon
oj tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt prehn`omdi ` st`td ef dmdrbdjhy oj
tgd ferdobj `rd`* Mest ef tgd fobgtojb ehhurrdi oj Hg`pdo. tgd j`tovd
Hgojdsd hoty tew`ri Reesujb `ji tgd S`hofoh* Ygd Nd`bud ef J`-
toejs w`s ojfermdi ef tgd vortu`n st`td ef w`r tgdj dxostojb* Ygdrd
w`s jetgojb vortu`n `aeut ot te tgd mdj oj tgdforojb nojds! Ygd
Reesujb-Hg`pdo a`ttnd eutsoid tgd Xdttndmdjt n`stdi frem Fdaru`ry
13 te M`rhg 0. aut tgd `rmostohd djiojb tg`t aneeiy `ff`or w`s jet
sobjdi ujton M`y 4. 0?81*
Ygd fobgtojb g`i nejb addj evdr ay tg`t tomd. gewdvdr. `ji O
wdjt a`hl te tgd Rgotd Geusd oj R`sgojbtej. I* b. tgd M`rhg
prdvoeuste tgd
Xg`jbg`o`rmostohd*
'O
g`ikeojdi
tgd Tjotdi Srdss
ej my rdturj te @mdroh`. `ji oj 0?80 w`s `ssobjdi te tgd Rgotd
Geusd te hevdr tgd Geevdr @imojostr`toej*/ Ygd rdster`toej
ir`m` ef tgd Aey Dmpdrer oj M`jhguro` ojtrobudi md. `ji wg`t
ot md`jt te Hgoj` `ji tgd futurd ef tgd Erodjt* Ot stonn os ` str`jbd
podhd oj tgd t`jbndi p`ttdrj ef eur tomds. `ji O w`jt te be ojte tgd
nofd stery gdrd ef tgos g`pndss p`wj oj tgd sgoftojb p`jer`m` ef tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 265/455
YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 164
F`r D`st *** tgd ujadnodv`and gostery ef tgd m`j wge"i jet ad lojb.
of gd heuni gdnp ot*
Ygos sndjidr. fr`on yeutg. gos ydnnew f`hd tgoj `ji p`nd adgoji
spdht`hnds. steei oj tgd Ygrejd Qeem ef gos M`jhgu `jhdsters `t
gosteroh Hg`jb-hgujb. `jhodjt h`pot`n ef M`jhguro`. tg`t sprojb i`y oj
0?81. `ji teel tgd e`tg ef effohd `s jemoj`n rundr ef `jetgdr sg`iewy
rd`nm* Ygos w`s tgd jdw `ji syjtgdtoh M`jhguro`j-Mejbeno`j st`td
ef wg`t w`s forst h`nndi fer ` arodf tomd @jlue. N`ji ef Sd`hd
spejserdi ay K`p`j. vobereusny rdkdhtdi ay Hgoj`. `ji jet rdhebjozdi
iopnem`toh`nny ay tgd rdst ef tgd werni*
Bejbs seujidi tgreubg tgd p`n`hd `t ejd tomd b`y wotg p`bd`jtry
ef `jetgdr `ji merd henerfun i`y* Ygdor sejereus. iddp aeemojb
wdnndi tgreubg tgd wojtry strddts ef Hg`jb-hgujb oj tgd gd`rt ef
M`jhguro`. h`nnojb ej `nn te wotjdss tg`t ` jdw rundr g`i addj pre-
hn`omdi* Ygd i`td w`s M`rhg ?. 0?81* Ygos yeutg. tgd n`st te sot
ej tgd Ir`bej Ygrejd ef Hgoj` oj Sdlojb. w`s rdhdjtny rdturjdi
ujidr K`p`jdsd bu`ri te tgd fdrtond prevojhds ef M`jhguro` `ji oj-
`ubur`tdi ay tgd K`p`jdsd `s rundr ef tg`t n`ji ef gos f`tgdrs*
Srosejdr te `nn ojtdjts `ji purpesds tgdsd p`st twe idh`ids oj tgd
g`jis ef tgd K`p`jdsd. Gdjry os jew tgdor ujwonnojb puppdt oj M`j-
hguro`. ferhdi te ` pesotoej ef jemoj`n pewdr. te wgohg gd jdvdr
`spordi*
Ygd K`p`jdsd ay ` aeni monot`ry `ivdjturd g`i dkdhtdi ejd yeujb
m`j `s ` rundr ef M`jhguro` `ji pn`hdi `jetgdr oj gos std`i* Ay `
p`r`iex ef fertujd. tgd yeutg wge w`s dnomoj`tdi os tgd sej ef tgd
m`j wge. `t tgd adbojjojb ef tgos hdjtury. pn`ydi ` m`ker rend oj tgd
evdrtgrew ef tgd M`jhgus wge jew rdobj `b`oj* Ot w`s pedtoh kustohd
tg`t tgd K`p`jdsd rdturjdi Gdjry Su-yo te ` sdman`jhd ef pewdr*
Ygus. f`jt`stoh`nny. `t tgd turj ef tgd wgddn wgohg put tgdm tgdrd.
Gdjry `roi gos wofd. Dnoz`adtg 'aoz`rrd j`mds wgohg tgd Xej ef
Gd`vdj hgesd fer gomsdnf `ji gos aroid/ jew pn`y `t runojb oj tgd
M`jhguro`j prevojhds. muhg. ad ot rdpd`tdi. `b`ojst tgdor wonn* Ygdor
rd`n j`mds `rd Gsu`j Y"ojb. tgd Aey Dmpdrer. `ji gos Jumadr
Ejd wofd. tgd fermdr Srojhdss Lue Hgo` Xo. i`ubgtdr ef ` m`ker-
bdjdr`n ujidr tgd eni rdbomd oj Sdopojb* Gd sdndhtdi gdr. eiiny
djeubg `ji nottnd oj gos nofd os jet eii tgreubg ` ad`uty hejtdst*
Aut merd ef tg`t n`tdr*
Aetg Gdjry `ji gos prdtty wofd weuni f`r r`tgdr be `are`i.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 266/455
166 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
prdfdr`any te tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. te novd quodtny `s stuidjts tg`j rund
tgd M`jhgus ujidr tgd tguma ef tgd K`p`jdsd* Gdjry os tgorty-sdvdj <
gos tojy. ad`utofunny `rostehr`toh hejsert os g`riny merd tg`j tgorty*
Ygdy `rd meidrjozdi rundrs ef tgd Erodjt. spd`l Djbnosg. be te
tgd mevods. `ji g`vd `s tgdor forst wosg oj nofd ` idsord te ad ndft
`nejd* Ygdy g`vd feuji ejhd merd. gewdvdr. tg`t nofd fer ` m`j
ujfertuj`td djeubg te g`vd addj rundr ef tgd `jhodjt Hdndsto`n Dmpord
ef Hgoj` os jet tg`t sompnd* @ji tgd p`n`hd `t Hg`jb-hgujb os jew
tgd prdsoidjto`n `aeid ef Gdjry `ji Dnoz`adtg tgd Rgotd Geusd ef
` jdw st`td. gewdvdr ujst`and* Ots heurty`ris `rd ujldmpt hemp`rdi
wotg tgdor pemp `ji hdrdmejy ef ydstdri`y* Ygdrd os nottnd te rdh`nn
tgd spndjier ef arobgtdr i`ys adferd tgd M`jhgus m`rhgdi seutgw`ri.
sw`rmdi evdr tgd Brd`t R`nn `ji hejqudrdi Hgoj` ejny te ad
`aseradi tgdmsdnvds*
Ygd tgrejd reem ef tgdor jdw rdsoidjhd w`s tgd shdjd ef tgd
oj`ubur`toej* Ywe brd`t benidj sd`ns wdrd prdsdjtdi te Gdjry tgd
sd`n ef Xt`td `ji tgd Qdbdjt"s sd`n* @ sm`nn breup ef Hgojdsd `ji
` fdw Mejbeno`j projhds b`tgdrdi fer tgd ujrd`n hdrdmejods* Ygdsd
mdj. wotg tgd `oi ef K`p`jdsd `ivosdrs. `nse prdsdjt. wdrd rdspej-
soand fer tgd wgend sgew* Ygd hdrdmejy w`s arodf* Ygd yeutg
brddtdi tgd `uiodjhd `ji speld ` fdw weris prdp`rdi fer gom* Gd
swerd te upgeni tgd jdw Xt`td* Ygd Xej ef Gd`vdj g`i adhemd
'`b`oj eiiny djeubg te stor gos gejer`and `jhdsters oj tgdor `jhodjt
temas/ gd`i ef ` idmehr`hy ef serts ` ioht`tersgop. `htu`nny. gdni
tebdtgdr ay a`yejdts aut a`sdi ej tgd tgdery ef dvdjtu`nny m`lojb
@jlue ` idmehr`hy*
@nn gos nofd. Gdjry Su-yo g`s addjfnottojb
frem tgrejd te senotuid
`ji a`hl `b`oj* Dvdjts ef brd`t memdjt ehhurrdi te gom wgdj gd
w`s tee yeujb te ujidrst`ji wg`t ot w`s `nn `aeut* Gd w`s ejny
tgrdd yd`rs eni wgdj gd `shdjidi tgd Ir`bej Ygrejd oj Sdlojb* Gd
w`s aerj mdrdny tgd gdor te ejd ef Hgoj`"s projhop`notods aut w`s
hgesdj ay tgd eni Iew`bdr Dmprdss te suhhddi gdr jdpgdw. tgd Dm-pdrer Lu`jb Gsu* Ygd tgrdd-yd`r eni ojf`jt ljdw jetgojb ef tgd
brd`t p`bd`jts `ji tgd `hhn`om tg`t w`s `hheridi gom `ji nottnd ef
tgd rdst ef tgd hdrdmejy wgohg w`s ` pohturdsqud p`rt ef gos here-
j`toej `s `j Erodjt`n petdjt`td*
Gd w`s stonn ` vdry sm`nn aey wgdj gd w`s forst rdmevdi frem tgd
tettdrojb Ir`bej Ygrejd* Ygd rdvent `b`ojst tgd M`jhgus suhhddidi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 267/455
YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 162
oj 0?00. `ji ejny feur yd`rs `ftdr gos djtgrejdmdjt tgd Aey Dm-
pdrer rdsobjdi* Gos `aioh`toej md`jt jetgojb te gom `t tgd tomd.
`ji gd heuni g`vd ljewj jetgojb `t tgd `bd ef sdvdj ef tgd sobjofoh`jhd
tg`t gos sobjojb `w`y `j dmpord g`i oj tgd m`rhg ef werni `ff`ors*
Tpej `aioh`toej. Gsu`j Y"mb adh`md pn`oj Gdjry Su-yo `ji rdtordi
ojte tgd me`tdi Feraoiidj Hoty. Ygdrd oj tgd gd`rt ef tgd Y`rt`r
Hoty ef eni Sdlojb. surreujidi ay bnd`mojb ydnnew reefs. m`rand
tdrr`hds `ji st`tdny p`n`hds wotg tgdor sendmj Mojb iyj`sty m`sejry.
gd stuiodi `ji h`rrodi ej*
Md`jwgond tgd wofd ef Lu`jb Gsu. tgd ujhnd wgem Gdjry suh-
hddidi `s dmpdrer. g`i hemd ojte tgd totnd ef Iew`bdr Dmprdss* Xgd
gdni tgos pest `t tgd tomd ef tgd `aioh`toej. aut sgertny tgdrd`ftdr
iodi* @t gdr id`tg. hr`fty Hgoj Fdo. Lu`jb Gsu"s benidj hejhuaojd%"
w`s ndft `s gd`i ef tgd wemdj oj tgd Ompdro`n geusdgeni* Xgd w`s
vortu`nny suprdmd oj idhoiojb tgd nofd ef tgd yeutg iurojb tgd yd`rs
gd novdi oj tgd Feraoiidj Hoty. wgdrd dvdj gos ewj f`tgdr `ji metgdr.
tgd Srojhd `ji Srojhdss Hguj. wdrd jet pdrmottdi* Ygd ojfnudjhd ef
tgos hejhuaojd henerdi gos d`rny i`ys `ji fermdi `jetgdr p`rt ef tgd
wdori p`ttdrj ef gos nofd*
Ygd tdrms ef Gdjry"s `aioh`toej wdrd jet djtordny ujpnd`s`jt*
Gd rdt`ojdi gos totnd ef Dmpdrer `ji w`s bu`r`jtddi ay tgd Qdpuanoh
tgd s`md rdspdht `s w`s iud ` ferdobj sevdrdobj* Gd w`s te rdhdovd
)9.333.333 'sonvdr/` yd`r. wgohg `t tgd tomd w`s `pprexom`tdny
)1.333.333 oj Tjotdi Xt`tds hurrdjhy. `s hempdjs`toej frem tgd Qd-
puanoh fer hejfosh`tojb gos robgts `ji hrewj* Aut gd r`rdny of dvdr
bet `jytgojb frem tgd sgoftojb h`aojdts `t Sdlojb. `ji g`i ` ioffohunt
tomd foj`jho`nny*
Gdjry `nse rdt`ojdi gos prov`td prepdrty ujidr tgd `aioh`toej
tdrms* Ygos ldpt gos heurt oj tgd Feraoiidj Hoty beojb* Gd g`i te
sdnn ` brd`t id`n ef tgd tomadr `ji etgdr v`nu`and tgojbs te hejtojud*
Ygd tgrejd `nse rdhdovdi boftsfrem ney`nosts. `ji gd m`j`bdi te sua-
sost* Ygdrd w`s dvdj ` semdwg`t p`tgdtoh `ttdmpt `t rdh`pturojb tgd
spndjier ef tgd eni heurt nofd aut tgd n`mp ef gos fertujds fnohldrdi
`ji wdjt eut*
Ygd aey novdi quodtny oj tgd Feraoiidj Hoty fer semd yd`rs.
ljewojb jetgojb wg`tdvdr ef tgd sojostdr ojtrobud beojb ej `nn `aeut
gom `ftdr tgd rdvenutoej* Ot `ppre`hgdi tgd surf`hd ojjumdr`and
tomds. `ji tgd eutard`l oj 0?02 wgohg rdsterdi gom te tgd tgrejd ej
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 268/455
167 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
tgd arodf hrdst ef ots toid w`s ojdvot`and aut. te gom. ` hempndtd
surprosd*
Ygdmej`rhgy
w`s rddst`anosgdi fer ` fnddtojb memdjt. `ji Srdso-
idjt Fdjb Lue-hg`jb g`i te ruj fer gos nofd* Gd hgesd tgd Iuthg
Ndb`toej `s ` rdfubd* Gos ojsdhuroty w`s sgert* Ygd treeps ef tgd
jdw Qdpuanoh reutdi tgd Ompdro`n ferhds tgrdd i`ys n`tdr `ji tgd Aey
Dmpdrer w`s `b`oj rdndb`tdi fertgwotg te tgd ojjdr hejfojds ef tgd
Feraoiidj Hoty* Nottnd ioi gd tgojl. pdrg`ps. gew feraoiidj tg`t hoty
w`s semd i`y te ad te gom* Gd w`s ejny tgortddj yd`rs eni tgdj. `ji
ieuatndss ujfdttdrdi ay f`jhods ef br`jidur*
Frem 0?02 ujton tgd f`nn ef 0?19. Gdjry novdi oj `j `tmespgdrd
ef gobg ojtrobud. ydt `nn `aeut gom w`s `pp`rdjtny h`nm* Iurojb tgdsd
sdvdj yd`rs gd jdvdr ndft tgd Feraoiidj Hoty se f`r `s os ljewj. aut
spdjt gos i`ys oj stuiy `ji oj dxdrhosd ef tgd sert pessoand ojsoid tgd
p`n`hd breujis* Ygd prdtdjsd ef gos heurt w`s m`ojt`ojdi `ji gd
w`s f`wjdi upej ay tgd heurtodrs* Jew `ji `b`oj gd reid gersd-
a`hl. rdperts frem wotgoj s`oi* Etgdr rdperts s`oi tgd dxtdjt ef tgos
dxdrhosd hejsostdi ef tgd aey"s adojb sdt ej ` sm`nn Mejbeno`j pejy
wgohg w`s tgdj ndi snewny tgreubg tgd stejd-fn`bbdi breujis ay twe
h`rdfun `ttdji`jts*
Rotg gos meidrj tdjidjhods. Gdjry must g`vd adhemd merd tg`j
fdi up wotg gos sdqudstdrdi nofd* Aut ot w`s dssdjto`n `ji p`rt ef
gos f`td. fer ot must ad rdmdmadrdi tg`t wotgoj tgd erj`td w`nns ef
tgd Feraoiidj Hoty gd w`s stonn te `nn ojtdjts `ji purpesds tgd ehhu-
p`jt ef tgd Ir`bej Ygrejd `ji rundr ef tgd Hdndsto`n Dmpord* Ygd
ney`n `ttdji`jts. tgd n`iods `ji bdjtndmdj ef tgd pg`jtem heurt. tgd
dujuhgs `ji tgd m`oidjs heuni jet arojb tgdmsdnvds te tgojl ef gom
etgdrwosd*
Ojtrobud. semd pdtty `ji semd sojhdrd. w`s tgdor nofd aneei* Ygdrd
w`s. fer dx`mpnd. ` trdmdjieus `rbumdjt evdr wgdtgdr tgd yeutg
sgeuni wd`r spdht`hnds* Ejd f`htoej oj gos heurt gdni tg`t spdht`hnds
g`i jdvdr addj werj ay `jy etgdr dmpdrer ef tgd iyj`sty `ji tg`t
tgd idvohd hdrt`ojny heuni jet ad jdhdss`ry `t tgos n`td i`td* Ygd
fermdr Iew`bdr Dmprdss w`s mest strdjueus oj gdr eppesotoej te
tgd ojjev`toej* Aut Gdjry. jdvdr strejb. g`i adhemd ` hejst`jt
stuidjt* Gd usdi gos dyds i`y `ji jobgt. rd`iojb* @ heurt pgysoho`j
rundi tg`t of tgd aey"s sobgt wdrd te ad s`vdi Gdjry g`i te usd
spdht`hnds wgdjdvdr rd`iojb* Ygd pgysoho`j sdttndi tgd hejtrevdrsy.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 269/455
YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 16?
aut gos idhosoej h`usdi je nottnd g`ri fddnojb oj tgd Ompdro`n geusdgeni*
Ot w`s tgdor aobbdst preandm oj mejtgs*
Ygus. ir`m`. tr`bdiy `ji tr`boh-hemdiy fonndi tgd nofd ef Gdjry
Su-yo. `nn wotgeut tgd snobgtdst venotoej ej gos p`rt* Gd g`s jdvdr
wonndi gomsdnf ojte ` ir`m`toh. tr`boh er hemoh sotu`toej* Gd weuni
ruj f`r frem ejd er `nn tgrdd* _dt `nw`ys tgos yeutg g`s p`oi tgd
pdj`nty ef adojb tgd n`st Xej ef Gd`vdj*
Ejd teuhg ef tr`bdiy wgohg gd rdmdmadrs ehhurrdi oj Ehteadr
0?10* @j effoho`n heurt st`tdmdjt rdpertdi tgd suiidj id`tg ef
Srojhdss Hguj. gos yeujb `ji stonn prdtty metgdr* Xgd iodi ef epoum
peosejojb* Ygd Srojhdss. tgd arodf rdpert sdt fertg. g`i hemmottdi
suohoid* Gewdvdr tg`t m`y ad. gdr id`tg h`md `s ` rdsunt ef ` qu`rrdn
wotg Hgoj Fdo. tgd benidj hejhuaojd `ji. `s O g`vd s`oi. vortu`n
Dmprdss Iew`bdr* Ygd rdperts ef tgd qu`rrdn wdrd jet hnd`r `s tgdy
sddpdi frem tgd kd`neusny m`sldi novds ef tgd heurt oj tgd gd`rt ef
tgd Feraoiidj Hoty*
Ygd treuand. ot `ppd`rdi. w`s evdr tgd sdndhtoej ef ` aroid* Hgoj
Fdo neeldi wotg f`ver upej ` m`tromejo`n `nno`jhd adtwddj Gdjry `ji
` i`ubgtdr ef tgd jdw Srdsoidjt ef Hgoj`. hdrt`ojny ` str`jbd hem-
aoj`toej te mest w`ys ef tgojlojb* Ygd yeutg"s metgdr. gewdvdr.
prdfdrrdi gdr sej te wdi tgd i`ubgtdr ef _uj No`jb. gdr jdpgdw*
Ygd aey gomsdnf. ot `ppd`rs. `nse g`i oid`s `aeut gos m`rro`bd* Gd
w`jtdi te wdi gos ewj metgdr"s yeujbdr sostdr. oj etgdr weris. gos
`ujt* Xtonn. adojb ` p`todjt yeutg. gd s`oi gd weuni `aoid ay gos
metgdr"s hgeohd*
Hgoj Fdo w`s jet ` nottnd ojhdjsdi `t tgd turj ef dvdjts wgohg oj
tgd dji upsdt gdr shgdmds* Aottdr weris fennewdi* Srojhd `ji Sroj-
hdss Hguj steei ay tgdor sej* Ygd qu`rrdn hejtojudi fer tgrdd novoi
i`ys* Ygdj Srojhdss Hguj iodi suiidjny* Ygdy s`oi sgd g`i hem-
mottdi suohoid* Ygd Aey Dmpdrer ndft gos sdhnusoej fer tgd forst
tomd te `ttdji gos metgdr"s fujdr`n ej Ehteadr 80. 0?10* Gd w`s
vdry p`nd tg`t i`y `ji sddmdi fr`on `ji sh`rhdny tdj yd`rs eni ojstd`i
ef soxtddj* @s tgd h`t`f`nqud ef gos metgdr w`s noftdi. gd ljdnt ej `
rub ef n`masloj `ji aewdi tgrohd tew`ri tgd heffoj* Gd w`s frobgt-
djdi. aut m`ojt`ojdi `j `or ef utmest iobjoty*
Yomd p`ssdi `ji adferd nejb Gdjry Su-yo w`s `b`oj sd`rhgojb fer
` wofd* Gd g`i gos w`y tgos tomd* Ygdrd w`s je mddtojb wotg tgd
born. je heurtsgop suhg `s os ljewj oj tgd Rdstdrj Rerni* Aut `
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 270/455
123 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
idp`rturd tg`t w`s dvdj merd st`rtnojb w`s m`id oj gos sdndhtoej ef
` aroid*
Gdjry
gdni ` ad`uty hejtdst! Gd eridrdi tgd twdnvd mest ad`u-
tofun M`jhgu projhdssds oj Hgoj` te g`vd tgdor pgetebr`pgs t`ldj `ji
sdjt te gom* Ygd yeutg. Ompdro`n kuibd ef tgos rdm`rl`and `rr`y ef
Erodjt`n punhgrotuid. `t n`st djidi tgd suspdjsd ay hgeesojb Srojhdss
Lue Hgo`-so* Gdr f`mony w`s eashurd aut ef projhdny M`jhgu aneei*
Ygd m`thg w`s rdb`ridi `s ` nevd `ff`or* Idshroptoejs ef tgd Srojhdss
s`oi sgd w`s tgd mest ad`utofun M`jhgu born oj tgd werni* Xgd os
sm`nn `ji sndjidr* Adojb ` M`jhgu sgd ieds jet aoji gdr fddt wgohg.
gewdvdr. `rd j`tur`nny sm`nn* Ygd Born Dmprdss. os quotd meidrj
oj ejd rdspdht fer '`ji tgos os `nse adh`usd sgd os ` M`jhgu/ sgd
usds hesmdtohs. ojhnuiojb reubd. frddny*
Ygd n`w ef tgd Hgojb iyj`sty runds tg`t ejny ` M`jhgu m`y
adhemd tgd wofd ef `j Dmpdrer*
Ygd Dmprdss g`s g`or ef tgdkdt-an`hl sert se prozdi oj tgd Erodjt*
Ot os nejb `ji nuxuro`jt. rd`hgojb te gdr ljdds* Ot os ieuatfun tg`t
sgd weuni aea ot dvdj wdrd sgd te hemd te @mdroh` semd i`y. `s sgd
w`jts te ie* Gdr fd`turds `rd wdnn fermdi. tgd jesd adojb `nmest
`quonojd* Gdr dyds `rd n`rbd `ji arewj. b`zojb eut frem adjd`tg
sgdntdrojb gd`vy n`sgds* Ygdy `rd jet sn`jtojb. `t nd`st jet ej tgd
dx`bbdr`tdi `jbnd hemmej te Erodjt`ns* Gdr f`hd os ev`n. wotg seftny
reujidi hgoj* Xgd weuni ad hg`rmojb `jywgdrd. `ji kuibdi ay
Erodjt`n st`ji`ris os merd tg`j ad`utofun*
Oj tgd d`rny geurs adferd i`wj ef Idhdmadr 0. 0?11. tgdy wdrd
m`rrodi* Xuhg pemp `ji spndjier `rd sdniem sddj `jywgdrd* Ygd
projhdss h`md te gdr nevdr h`rrodi evdr tgd ydnnew-s`jidi. j`rrew
strddts ef Sdlojb tgreubg tgd Brd`t D`st B`td ojte tgd Feraoiidj
Hoty* _dnnew n`jtdrjs fnohldrdi oj tgd i`rljdss `ji ` ydnnew meej
ej tgd w`jd pddrdi iewj wotg g`nf `j dyd `t tgd dxetoh prehddiojbs*
Frem `tep tgd ir`bej hg`or ef ydnnew sonl oj wgohg sgd reid ` Benidj
Sgedjox. symaen ef tgd Dmprdss ef Hgoj`. sprd`i ots brd`t wojbs*
Xgd s`t adgoji ir`wj hurt`ojs tg`t gdr f`hd mobgt ad vdondi idmurdny
frem tgd puanoh b`zd*
Ygorty-twe sturiy mdj h`rrodi gdr frem gdr f`tgdr"s geusd te tgd
Ompdro`n p`n`hd* Benidj s`ji `nejb tgd w`y. ydnnew sonl dvdrywgdrd
ydnnew os tgd rey`n purpnd ef Hgoj` `j dvdjt ef suhg m`bjofohdjhd
heuni t`ld pn`hd ejny oj `jhodjt Sdlojb* @ fdw anehls `w`y. tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 271/455
YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 120
ferdobj henejy stonn rdvdndi te tgd str`ojs ef ` meidrj i`jhd erhgdstr`
oj easdrv`jhd ef tgd Xt* @jirdw"s a`nn*
Ygd m`rro`bd rotds tgdmsdnvds wdrd sompnd* Ygd Srojhdss `ji gdr
Aey Dmpdrer s`t soid ay soid ej tgd Ir`bej Adi. gd ej tgd ndft
`ji sgd ej tgd robgt* Ygdy dxhg`jbdi benidj hups hejt`ojojb wojd
`ji podhds ef seft wgd`t ard`i* Ygd rotu`n os symaenoh ef nejb nofd `ji
` andssojb ej pestdroty* Ygdor gejdymeej w`s spdjt oj tgd hejfojds
ef tgd Feraoiidj Hoty. tgd dxtdjt tgdj ef gos nest dmpord*
Gdjry Su-yo os tgd j`md gd teel `s ` rdsunt ef gos stuiy ef
Djbnosg gostery* Gd g`i ` Arotosg tuter. `ji ejd i`y ej ompunsd
Gdjry idhrddi tg`t gos j`md sgeuni je nejbdr ad Gsu`j Y"ojb* Gd
teel tgd j`md ef Gdjry `ftdr ejd ef gos f`verotd Djbnosg lojbs* Gd
b`vd gos wofd tgd j`md ef Dnoz`adtg `ji Gdjry `ji Dnoz`adtg.
str`jbdny djeubg. rundi oj tgd Feraoiidj Hoty `s nejb `s tgd nd`idrs
ef tgd Qdpuanoh pdrmottdi*
Gdjry sddms te suot tgos ioffoidjt yeutg muhg adttdr tg`j gos
Ompdro`n j`md `ji totnd. Gd os ` sdroeus yeujb m`j. r`tgdr johd
neelojb. `nw`ys sgy wotg str`jbdrs< gd g`s gos g`or hut wdstdrj stynd.
arusgdi a`hl oj ` stoff pemp`ieur. `ji g`s `j `or ef `nw`ys strovojb
te ad dxtrdmdny frodjiny wotg dvdryejd Gdjry `ji gos aroid novdi
g`ppony fer jd`rny twe yd`rs adferd tgd t`jbndi sldoj ef tgdor quddr
novds h`ubgt tgdm up `b`oj `ji wgosldi tgdm eff ej jdw `ivdjourds*
Ot w`s oj tgd `utumj e 0?19 tg`t M`rsg`n Fdjb _u-gso`jb. tgd
se-h`nndi Hgrosto`j Bdjdr`n. turjdi ej gos ewj hgodft`oj `ji wotg
hg`r`htdrostoh bdsturd h`pturdi Sdlojb* Oj gos robereus pgonesepgy
tgdrd w`s je pn`hd fer dmpdrers ef `jy sert* Gomsdnf ` pd`s`jt punndi
up ay gos ewj aeetstr`ps. M`rsg`n Fdjb sdt eut te dnomoj`td tgd Aey
Dmpdrer `ji gos aroid ejhd `ji fer `nn Gdjry `ji Dnoz`adtg fndi
ojte tgd K`p`jdsd Ndb`toej* Dvdj tgos `synum w`s jejd tee sdhurd*
Ygd K`p`jdsd. gewdvdr. ay tg`t tomd s`w oj Gdjry ` v`nu`and
p`wj fer tgdor ewj m`jduvdrojbs oj tgd penotoh`n ojtrobud oj tgd D`st*
Ygdy idhoidi te bdt gom eut ef Sdlojb.
Ygd sgoftojb ef tgd p`wj adb`j wgdj tgd K`p`jdsd sporotdi Gdjry
eut ef tgd Ndb`toej Pu`rtdr oj Sdlojb ej Fdaru`ry 19. 0?14. `ji
gurrodi gom adferd i`wj ej tgd re`i te Yodjtsoj. Ot w`s i`rl wgdj
tgdy st`rtdi* Sdlojb sndpt* @ nobgt fnohldrdi `ji w`s bejd `s ` m`j
oj ujoferm sjuffdi gos tojy n`jtdrj `ji snoppdi h`utoeusny `hress tgd
tdrr`hd te ` w`otojb meter h`r* @nn rd`iy. gd wgospdrdi oj K`p`-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 272/455
121 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
jdsd* Ygd m`j `t tgd wgddn jeiidi* Ygd etgdr rdtr`hdi gos stdps
`ji. epdjojb tgd ieer wgdjhd gd g`i hemd. speld oj new tejds te
semdejd ojsoid*
@ memdjt n`tdr ` breup ef tgrdd er feur fondi sondjtny eut `ji
fennewdi tgdor buoid te tgd m`hgojd* Ygreubg tgd b`tdw`y `ji iewj
tgd strddt. tgd h`r prehddidi snewny tgreubg tgd Ndb`toej Pu`rtdr. ej
tgreubg tgd an`hl jobgt wgohg sddms an`hldr kust adferd i`wj* Ygdy
b`tgdrdi spddi `s tgdy fndi oj tg`t d`rny merjojb senotuid. gurtnojb ej
tgreubg tgd Y`rt`r Hoty `ji. merd snewny jew. ej ujton tgd b`tds ef
Sdlojb wdrd rd`hgdi*
Ygdy g`i je treuand tgdrd* Ygd b`tds epdjdi fer tgd i`y tgdy
`rd nehldi dvdry jobgt. dvdj jew `ji tgd m`hgojd fndi p`st `ji ej
te tgd epdj gobgw`y* @j ujdvdjtfun trop evdr semd dobgty monds ef
wrdthgdi re`is. `ji tgd Aey Dmpdrer g`i `rrovdi `t Yodjtsoj `ji
s`fdty*
Ygd Aey Dmpdrer w`s bu`ridi hnesdny `ji gos nofd ldpt ` iddp
sdhrdt `t Yodjtsoj* Ot w`s dvdj semdwg`t prdsumptueus te ojsost tg`t
gd `htu`nny w`s tgdrd* Xemd ieuatdi ot. `ji gd w`s ` pg`jtem foburd
`ftdr gos mystdroeus fnobgt frem tgd eni h`pot`n Dvdj pdrsejs wge
wdrd novojb oj Yodjtsoj tgdj sddmdi jet te g`vd `jy hnd`r jetoej `s
te kust wgdrd gd w`s* @j @mdroh`j `rmy h`pt`oj. jew a`hl oj tgd
Tjotdi Xt`tds. wge g`i addj ej iuty oj Yodjtsoj wotg tgd 04tg Oj-
f`jtry. rdprdsdjtdi tgd typoh`n ferdobjdrs" `ttotuid tew`ri Gdjry Su-yo*
@j @mdroh`j tr`jspert oj tgd Erodjt`n sdrvohd g`i kust rd`hgdi
J`b`s`lo. oj seutgdrj K`p`j. `ji tgd effohdr w`s ejd ef twe oj hg`rbd
ef tgd sgerd-nd`vd w`thg* Xemd ef tgd mdj mobgt bdt nest oj J`b`-
s`lo* Ot os ` adbuonojb hoty. `ntgeubg jd`rny idsdrtdi jew `s f`r `s
ferdobjdrs `rd hejhdrjdi* O w`s tgdrd ej ` genoi`y `t tgd tomd*
@t tgd J`b`s`lo Hnua. dssdjto`nny Arotosg. wd wdrd budsts ef tgd
Tjotdi Xt`tds `rmy qu`rtdrm`stdr st`toejdi tgdrd* Ygd effohdrs wdrd
usojb tgi Hnua `s tgdor gd`iqu`rtdrs*
Gew os tgd Aey Dmpdrer5 O `sldi*
Ygd h`pt`oj g`i gd`ri ef Gdjry* Gd w`s quotd surd tgd yeutg
w`s oj beei gd`ntg* Aut tgdj. jeaeiy dvdr s`w gom muhg* Gd irevd
`aeut tgd hoty. tg`t os oj tgd ferdobj hejhdssoejs. aut tgd effohdr rd`nny
ioi jet ljew kust wg`t p`rt ef tewj tgd idpesdi rundr novdi oj*
Arotosg Hejhdssoej. gd tgeubgt* Aut `ftdr `nn. jeaeiy p`oi muhg
`ttdjtoej te Gdjry*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 273/455
YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 128
Gd iedsj"t `meujt te muhg. tgd H`pt`oj hemmdjtdi. `ji gd
`ppd`rdi aerdi wotg tgdsuakdht*
Rdnn. tgdrd w`s nottnd te s`y furtgdr `aeut tg`t*
Gdjry
`t tgd
tomd. `t nd`st ej tgd emojeusny h`nm surf`hd ef tgojbs. ioi jet `ppd`r
te `meujt te muhg
Ygd lojb w`s id`i. ot sddmdi* _dt vdry muhg
`novd. `s idvdnepmdjts sgewdi* Ygd K`p`jdsd w`jtdi gom fer gobg
shgdmds `ji gd w`s swdpt `nejb tew`ri gos str`jbd idstojy*
Ot w`s `aeut tgos tomd tg`t nd`idrs oj tgd jdw rdbomd `t Sdlojb
idm`jidi Gdjry"s dxdhutoej `s ` mdj`hd te tgd jdw Xt`td* Ot sddmdi
str`jbd tg`t tgdy sgeuni fd`r tgos stuioeus yeutg `ji sdd oj gom `
pewdrfun djdmy< ydt tgdy m`y g`vd g`i ojlnojbs ef tgd ird`ms ef tgd
mej`rhgosts wgohg hdjtdrdi `reuji gos fr`on foburd* Ygd Qdpuanoh"s
er`ters idjeujhdi Gdjry `s ` shgdmdr `ji ` tr`oter `ji idm`jidi
gos surrdjidr* Gdjry. fer gos sm`nn p`rt. rdotdr`tdi tg`t gd jdvdr
w`jtdi te ad dmpdrer `b`oj* Aut tgd r`ioh`ns idhn`rdi tg`t gd w`s `j
ojbr`td `ji tg`t gd g`i `ttdmptdi te `ssumd tgd tgrejd* Ot g`riny
sddmdi pn`usoand. tgos `vewdi fd`r ef gos petdjto`n pewdr* _dt gdrd os
tgd tdndbr`m horhun`tdi ay tgd Sdlojb bevdrjmdjt `t tgd tomd. oj tgd
sprojb ef 0?16;
RGDQD@X ST-_O. IOXX@YOXFODI ROYG YGD DXSDHO@NN_ NDJODJY
YQD@YMDJY MDYDI ETY YE GOM A_ YGD HGOJDXD BEVDQJMDJY. IOI
EJHD @YYDMSY YE QDXYEQD YGD OMSDQO@N QDBOMD @JI OX JER YQ_OJB
YE @YY@OJ GOX @OM @X OX XGERJ A_ GOX XDHQDY IDS@QYTQD FQEM
SDLOJB @JI A_ jos @XXTMSYOEJ EF YGD YOYND EF
"DMSDQEQ%@JI
OJ VODR EF @NN YGD DVOIDJHD YG@Y GD OX HEJXSOQOJB @B@OJXY
YGD DWOXYOJB QDBOMD.
YGDQDFEQD. YGD BEVDQJMDJY XGETNI Y@LD XYDSX FEQ YGD
OMMDIO@YD H@JHDNN@YOEJ EF GOX DXSDHO@NN_ F@VEQ@AND YQD@YMDJY
@JI. OJ EQIDQ YE JOS OMSDQO@NOXYOH OJYQOBTD OJ YGD ATI. IDM@JI
YGD XTQQDJIDQ EF YGD "DMSDQEQ" ROYG @ VODR YE GOX DWDHTYOEJ.
YEBDYGDQ ROYG YG@Y EF GOX FENNEROJB. EJ YGD HG@QBD EF GOBG
YQD@XEJ*
Ygdrd w`s semd trutg oj tgd hg`rbds oj tgd tdndbr`m* Ygd Aey
Dmpdrer. `s O g`vd s`oi. w`s `htu`nny rdturjdi te tgd Ir`bej Ygrejd
oj 0?02. aut ejny fer tgrdd i`ys* @ji gd g`i jetgojb te ie wotg tg`t
Furtgdrmerd. gd `htu`nny os h`nndi Dmpdrer. `s oj tgos `rtohnd* Ot
os ieuatfun. gewdvdr. tg`t gd tgojls ef gomsdnf oj tg`t w`y* Ot mdrdny
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 274/455
129 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
os ` tdrm. r`tgdr tg`j ` totnd. wgohg prdsdjts otsdnf mest rd`iony wgdj
idshroaojb gom. aut etgdrwosd os md`jojbndss*
Md`jwgond. tgd K`p`jdsd gdni gom pr`htoh`nny ojhemmujoh`ie*O
trodi te sdd gom oj Yodjtsoj oj tgd summdr ef 0?17* @ sdhrdt`ry `t tgd
eni rdi arohl. wdstdrj-stynd geusd oj wgohg gd w`s novojb ojsostdi
penotdny aut formny tg`t ot w`s jet pessoand* Gdjry novdi ` sdhnuidi
nofd. pretdhtdi kd`neusny frem `nn eutsoidrs ay gos jdw m`stdrs*
Ygd yd`rs ir`bbdi ej wgond Gdjry `ji Dnoz`adtg auont `or-h`stnds
ay tgd sd` `ji gepdi fer ` hg`jhd te be `are`i* Ygdor mejdy
iwojindi* Bofts frem ney`n M`jhgus `ji etgdrs ejhd`ffnudjt `t tgd
pempeus heurt ef `jhodjt H`tg`y wdrd f`r sm`nndr `ji ndss frdqudjt*
Ygd heurtodrs tgdmsdnvds feuji tgd jdw eridr g`ri `ji f`hdi pdrsej`n
prov`toej* Oj tgd dji. tgdsd bofts pr`htoh`nny hd`sdi `ji Gdjry w`s
`nn aut idpdjidjt ej `j `nodj gest wgdj mevdi te M`jhguro`* Ygd
bont werd eff gos h`bd wotg tgd p`ssojb yd`rs*
Ygd K`p`jdsd aoidi tgdor tomd* Xemd fdnt tg`t Gdjry w`s ad-
hemojb tee muhg ef ` auridj* Ygdy hejtojudi. jdvdrtgdndss. te genigom prosejdr* Ygdy trd`tdi gom wdnn. aut tgdor rdspdht fer gom daadi
r`poiny* Ygd Erodjt`n spots ej ` f`nndj oien* Ygdy rdm`ojdi herio`n
aut jet tee penotd te tgdor f`nndj Ompdro`n gest`bd*
@ fdw yd`rs `be. fer dx`mpnd. Gdjry ndt ot ad ljewj tg`t gd oj-
tdjidi te vosot K`p`j* Jetohd w`s premptny bovdj tg`t gd weuni ad
rdhdovdi ejny `s `j erioj`ry hotozdj. `ji tg`t gd weuni g`vd te step `t
getdns wgdrdvdr gd wdjt* Gdjry g`i dxpdhtdi adttdr trd`tmdjt wotg`t nd`st semd prdtdjsd oj K`p`j tg`t gd w`s ` pdrsej ef rey`n nojd`bd*
Er of gd pdrsej`nny ioi jet fddn se strejbny ej tgd peojt. pdrsejs hnesd
te gom ioi* Yelye. gewdvdr. w`s `t pd`hd wotg tgd jdw Sdopojb
rdbomd `ji Gdjry h`jhdnndi tgd trop*
Hovon w`r sworndi `reuji `aeut gom oj tgd n`st fdw yd`rs wgond gd
neeldi ej. gdnpndss. `s usu`n* Hgojdsd w`r neris. mdj ef tgd r`hd gd
`ji gos M`jhgu `jhdsters g`i rundi. terd `t d`hg etgdr"s tgre`ts*
Ygdor `rmods a`ttndi up `ji iewj Hgoj`* Ygdsd mdj. semd ef tgdm
p`troetoh oj ` sdjsd aut tgd m`keroty ef tgdm eut fer neet `ji bnery.
`rd tgd s`jbuojd `ftdrm`tg ef tgd bdjdr`toej tg`t evdrtgrdw tgd Ir`bej
Ygrejd* Ygdy iosruptdi ` ferm ef bevdrjmdjt `ji sdjt tgd Aey
Dmpdrer0 "
shuttnojb fer hevdr* Ygdy h`md ojte pewdr adferd tgdy g`i
` m`j er ` systdm suffohodjtny strejb te rdpn`hd tgd Xej ef Gd`vdj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 275/455
YGD AE_ DMSDQEQ QTNDX @B@OJ 124
`j ojf`jt. ydt ` symaen. dvdj ` rdnoboej tg`t gdni tgd v`st. neesdny
ljot Hdndsto`n Dmpord tebdtgdr wotg semd sdman`jhd ef ujoty*
Gdjryfndi fer gos nofd* Ygd
K`p`jdsds`vdi
gom.gdni gom ujton
tgdy wdrd rd`iy. `ji jew g`vd pn`hdi gom `t tgd gd`i ef tgd jdw
st`td oj M`jhguro` wgohg Yelye hejtrens* @ji jet ejhd oj tgdsd
`m`zojb yd`rs g`s Gdjry g`i ` weri te s`y `aeut ot*
Rg`t ef tgd futurd5 Ygd `jhodjt bnery ef Sdopojb f`nns r`poiny
ojte idh`y* Ygd austnojb hemmdrho`n pert ef Xg`jbg`o nods w`stdi ay
w`r* Hgoj` os ` a`jlrupt j`toej oj merd w`ys tg`j ejd* Ygd f`htoejs
g`ntdi oj tgdor
m`i hnuthgojbfer
pewdr nejb djeubgte
prdsdjt` sdmo-
ujotdi frejt tew`ri tgd K`p`jdsd `t Xg`jbg`o aut tgdor aottdr djmotods
stonn smeunidr. rd`iy `s tgos os wrottdj te aurst `b`oj ojte fn`md `ji
sdt Hgojdsd `rmods ejhd merd ej tgd m`rhg*
Ygd Hgojdsd pdepnds `rd torojb ef tgd ojdffdhtu`n `ttdmpts yd`r `ftdr
yd`r te ad rundi ay Rdstdrj hovonoz`toej"s hejhdptoej ef dqu`noty `ji `
rdpuanoh`j ferm ef bevdrjmdjt* Ygdy `rd adbojjojb te fddn tg`t ot os
nold
m`jy etgdr jevdntods ojvdjtdi aytgd
ferdobj a`ra`ro`js eutsoid
tgd Brd`t R`nn* Jejd h`j ferdtdnn wg`t tgdy wonn ie. tgdsd Hgojdsd*
Jdvdrtgdndss. ot os `s hdrt`oj `s Losmdt tg`t tgdy `rd beojb te sdttnd
tgos ausojdss ejd w`y er `jetgdr ejd i`y*
Ygd Hgojdsd w`ot ` nejb tomd* Ygdy suffdr ujteni mosdrods* Aut
oj tgd dji tgdy usu`nny sdp`r`td tgd wgd`t frem tgd hg`ff r`tgdr wdnn*
Ygd Hgojdsd. p`hofoh pdepnds rd`nny. w`jt pd`hd* Ygdy g`i hdjturods
ef pd`hd ujton tgd rdvenutoej ef 0?00 evdrtgrdw tgd M`jhgus* @jitg`t os ` tgeubgt wgohg hemds te tgd heujtndss monnoejs jew hrusgdi
ujidr tgd p`ojfun `ji hestny gddn ef monot`rosm*
Ygd K`p`jdsd sdozdi `iv`jt`bd ef tgosrosojb toid ef g`trdi fer
tgd w`r neri typd ef rundr ef Hgoj`* Ygd mevd oj M`jhguro` w`s aut
tgd ferdrujjdr ef ` brd`tdr pn`j* K`p`j g`s puppdts oj drstwgond pep-
un`r f`htoejs `mejb tgd Hgojdsd te auoni ` st`and bevdrjmdjt ejhd merd
adnew tgd Brd`t R`nn ef Hgoj`* Ygd mej`rhgosts `nse `rd `htovd `b`oj*
Ygdy `ji tgd K`p`jdsd. v`bud rumers ef ojtrobud rdn`td. m`y keoj
ferhds te pn`hd Gdjry Su-yo ejhd merd ej tgd Ir`bej Ygrejd oj
Sdopojb* Yum-t`-t`-tum-tum. tum-t`-t`-tum ad`t tgd irums ef gos
huroeus idstojy* _dt jejd jew h`j `jswdr tgd qudry ;
Ronn tgd twostdi ompunsds ef tgd D`st rdsterd tgd Aey Dmpdrer
te gos Sdlojb tgrejd `s ` m`j5
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 276/455
18 YGD QE@I @GD@I
YGDsturiy nottnd mdj ef K`p`j. sojhd tgdor hemp`r`tovdny d`sy
sdozurd ef M`jhguro` oj 0?80-81. prehddidi wotg dvdr ojhrd`sojb
spddi `ji `m`zojb suhhdss tew`ri `hgodvojb tgdor `bd-eni `m-
aotoej te hejqudr `ji m`ojt`oj hempndtd hejtren evdr `nn Hgoj`* Ygd
h`mp`obj w`s pn`jjdi oj Yelye fer yd`rs*
Ygdrd w`s jetgojb jdw. tgdj. wgdj tgd sdheji ujidhn`rdi w`r
oj tgd Xg`jbg`o `rd` areld eut oj tgd summdr ef 0?82. `ji K`p`j
mevdi oj*
Ygd ejny tgojb rd`nny ujdxpdhtdiw`s tgd `htu`n i`td
fer tgd Hgojdsd nd`idrs `t J`jlojb `ji dnsdwgdrd g`i nejb dxpdhtdi
tgd K`p`jdsd te `tt`hl oj tgdor jdxt mevd ef `bbrdssoej ej tgd hej-
tojdjt ef @so`* Jejd. ef heursd. ljdw kust wgdj er wgdrd tgd `tt`hl
weuni ehhur* Jer ioi tgd K`p`jdsd tgdmsdnvds ljew tgdsd spdhofoh
idt`ons wgond tgdy wdrd pn`yojb tgdor wony w`otojb b`md* O must. gew-
dvdr. br`jt oj `nn f`orjdss. tg`t tgd `maotoej ef tgd K`p`jdsd os ejny
gum`j tee gum`j* @imottdi. tgd idt`ons ef tgdor `rmdi `htoej `rd
tee eftdj
merd ojgum`j `ji gerroand tg`j etgdrwosd aut `rmdi mdjhemmot dxhdssds ej `jy p`rt ef tgos bnead"s surf`hd. `ji tgd K`p`jdsd
`rd je dxhdptoej* @ m`j oj a`ttnd os notdr`nny m`i rdb`rindss ef r`hd*
J`tur`nny. O ie jet hejtdji tg`t tgd ujidhn`rdi w`r os f`or te
Hgoj`* Oj f`ht. dvdr sojhd O forst sdt feet ej Hgojdsd seon merd tg`j
` idh`id `be O g`vd addj hejsoidrdi pre-Hgojdsd* O `m g`riny tg`t.
dotgdr* O `m pre- jetgojb* O pnd`i buonty ejny te adojb ` rd`nost*
Frem tgos purdny eakdhtovd peojt ef vodw. O must `imot tg`t tgd
Hgojdsd tgdmsdnvds `rd n`rbdnyte
an`md fer tgdor ewj pnobgt* Ygdysompny h`jjet sddm te adhemd ujotdi `ji st`y tg`t w`y* @t tgd
memdjt. yds. tgdy `rd ujotdi* Aut ejny `b`ojst ` hemmej fed. K`p`j.
tgd idsposdi nottnd osn`ji jdobgaer eff tgdor nejb `ji rohg he`stnojd
tgdrd oj tgd S`hofoh* Ygdy fobgt sgeunidr-te-sgeunidr `b`ojst tgos oj-
v`idr. wge mews iewj tgd stuaaerj seniodrs ef Frdd Hgoj` `ji
g`s sdt up ` puppdt rdbomd hejtrenndi frem Yelye* Ygos rdbomd weuni.
126
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 277/455
YGD QE@I @GD@I 122
tgd K`p`jdsd ojsost. djferhd pd`hd oj tgd Erodjt. wotg K`p`j `s hgodf-
ef-penohd*
Aut ndt K`p`j ad idfd`tdi. ndt K`p`j fer `jy rd`sej ej d`rtg wotg-
ir`w gdr pdrsostdjt `ji f`j`toh seniodry frem Hgoj`. `ji tgd Hgojdsd
oj ndss tomd tg`j ot t`lds te bdt tgos ojte projt.wonn ad `t d`hg etgdr"s
tgre`ts `b`oj wotg `j dvdj merd aottdr vdjbd`jhd tg`j tgdy g`vd
feubgt tgd treeps frem I`o Joppej. My Hgojdsd frodjis `ji tgdy
`rd ndboej gdrd `ji `are`i wonn s`y tg`t oj tgos vodw O `m ujf`or.
ao`sdi. pessoany dvdj pre-K`p`jdsd* Rgdj ejd os jet djtordny ej ejd
soid er tgd etgdr. gd os noldny te foji gomsdnf suiidjny rdb`ridi `s
pre- tgd etgdr soid oj `jy h`usd. penotohs er w`r. nevd er g`td yeu
j`md ot ! O sompny st`td `b`oj tg`t O `m ` frodji ef Hgoj`. sddojb gdr
f`unts `s wdnn `s gdr vortuds*
O mysdnf w`jt Hgoj` te ad ujotdi* O w`jt. fer tg`t m`ttdr. tgd
wgend ef eur ujsdttndi werni te ad ujotdi aut `s nejb `s gum`j
j`turd os hejstotutdi `s ot os. gd`vdj gdnp us of wd iej"t g`vd penohd oj
eur hotods te hgdhl hromd. `ji seniodrs ej `nn frejtodrs te `vdrt oj-
v`soej*
Ygd sdheji ujidhn`rdi w`r ej tgd Xg`jbg`o frejt adb`j @ubust
?. 0?82* Ygd K`p`jdsd wdrd jet neelojb fer ot `t tg`t memdjt. aut
tgdy wdrd rd`iy* Rg`t K`p`j w`jtdi mest `t tg`t tomd w`s pd`hd
adnew tgd _dnnew Qovdr. oj Jertg-Hdjtr`n Hgoj`. te pdrmot gdr te bdt
ej wotg gdr prebr`m ef sdttojb up ydt `jetgdr ojidpdjidjt `ji
`utejemeus st`td oj tgd fovd prevojhds dxtdjiojb adnew tgd Brd`t
R`nn Xg`jtujb. Gepdo. Xg`jso. Xuoyu`j `ji Hg`g`r* Aut `jetgdr
ojhoidjt ehhurrdi oj tgd Xg`jbg`o `rd` `ji tgd sdheji a`ttnd ef
Xg`jbg`o. tgd sgewiewj. w`s ujidr w`y* Ygd forst Xg`jbg`o w`r w`s
wej ay K`p`j `ji sdttndi ay ` truhd oj 0?81. wgdj tgd Jojdtddjtg
Qeutd @rmy w`s foj`nny reutdi ay tgd K`p`jdsd `ji fndi seutg* Oj-
hoidjt`nny. tgdsd ar`vd Hgojdsd fobgtdrs wge wdrd g`ondi fer ` tomd `s
tgd s`voers ef Xg`jbg`o. ` yd`r n`tdr wdrd tgdmsdnvds tgrd`tdjojb
te st`rt ` hovon w`r `b`ojst tgd Hdjtr`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb* Ejny
gurrodi hejfdrdjhds `ji prea`any tgd usd ef sonvdr aunndts 'mejdy/.
`s os hustem`ry tgdrd. prdvdjtdi tg`t nottnd aretgdrny qu`rrdn frem ad-
hemojb hrotoh`n wotgoj Hgoj`"s v`st iem`oj*
K`p`j sddms jew te g`vd bejd f`r tew`ri pdrm`jdjtny `hgodvojb
gdr be`n tgd hejtren ef `nn Hgoj`. wotg tgd idstruhtoej ef Bdjdr`nossome
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. feujidr ef tgd Hdjtr`n Bevdrjmdjt `t J`jlojb oj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 278/455
127 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
0?12* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb w`s `nn `nejb fer hejhono`toej. je m`ttdr gew
f`r Yelye wdjt oj gdr idm`jis. `ji tgdrdferd w`s idjeujhdi `s `
spojdndss puppdt ef Yelye. ` tr`oter te gos trust `s nd`idr ef tgd Jdw
Hgoj`*
Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb mdrdny ljdw tg`t Hgoj` heuni jet fobgt ` wojjojb
fobgt `b`ojst tgd adttdr dquoppdi `ji adttdr tr`ojdi K`p`jdsd treeps ej
n`ji `ji sd` `ji oj tgd `or* Ygd Bdjdr`n f`verdi ndttojb tgdm t`ld
tgd fovd jertgdrj prevojhds. nd`vojb J`jlojb `ji Xg`jbg`o ujteuhgdi*
O adnodvd gd fdnt tg`t oj ` hemp`r`tovdny fdw yd`rs tgdrd mobgt ad `
hg`jhd te st`rt ` rdvenutoej oj tgd jertg `b`ojst tgd K`p`jdsd `ji woj
a`hl Hgoj`"s nest tdrroterods* Aut gos getgd`idi ujidrnojbs w`jtdi te
fobgt*
Ygd K`p`jdsd `hhemmei`tdi tgdm `ji tgd rdsunt w`s `s tgd
Bdjdr`n prdiohtdi. gd`vy nessds fer Hgoj`* K`p`j hressdi m`jy
ferdobj ojtdrdsts oj Xg`jbg`o `ji dnsdwgdrd* @s ` rdsunt. tgd K`p`jdsd
`rd jet pepun`r jew* Ygdy `rd tgd adtd jeor ef tgd prdsdjt*
Ndt md m`ld ejd prdiohtoej; O ie jet tgojl tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds.
er `jy etgdr pewdr ej d`rtg os beojb te be te w`r te step K`p`j
oj gdr m`rhg ej tgd Hgojdsd. `t gemd er `jywgdrd dnsd* Ygdrd wonn
ad aeyhetts `ji merd aeyhetts. yds* Ygdrd wonn ad gobg ojiobj`toej.
onn-fddnojb.sdjtomdjt`n uprosojbs ef `j eutr`bdi Rdstdrj werni gdrd
`ji tgdrd* Aut Tjhnd X`m os jet beojb te sdji yeujb mdj ojte tgd
F`r D`st te iod fer tgd tdmper`ry pretdhtoej ef eur hemmdrho`n
ojtdrdsts eut tgdrd*
Ef heursd. Qemd `ji Adrnoj wdrd oj symp`tgy wotg Yelye frem
tgd adbojjojb oj tgd Xdheji R`r* Ygdy rdb`ridi K`p`j `s tgd
strejbgeni oj tgd F`r D`st ef tgd tdjdts ef F`shosm ` aunw`rl
`b`ojst Hemmujosm oj tgd Erodjt. `s tgdy tgdmsdnvds `rd oj Durepd*
Ygd Hgojdsd. tgdj. g`i ` nest h`usd `s f`r `s werni `htoej w`s hej-
hdrjdi* Ygd Nd`bud ef J`toejs w`s ompetdjt* Ot nestprdstobd oj
tgd Ot`no`j hejqudst ef Dtgoepo`. adferd tg`t. wgdj K`p`j `jjdxdi
M`jhguro`* Oj f`ht. ot w`s tgd Nd`bud"s f`onurd te a`hl up Hgoj`
tgdj tg`t b`vd Srdmodr Mussenojo muhg ef gosfddnojb ef
sdhuroty wgdj
gd idhoidi te `hquord Dtgoepo`*
Rerni sdjtomdjt os `jetgdr stery* Oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds. fer dx-
`mpnd. sdjtomdjt w`s `nn fer tgd Hgojdsd* Xdjtomdjt oj @mdroh` os
erioj`rony fer tgd ujidr-ieb. `ji ot w`s dvdj merd se tg`j usu`n oj
tgd K`p`j-Hgoj` w`r* Aut werni `htoej jon*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 279/455
YGD QE@I @GD@I 12?
K`p`j w`s vdry serry fer stdppojb ej ferdobj teds. ojhnuiojb
Tjhnd X`m"s. `reuji Xg`jbg`o* Aut jetgojb w`s iejd. `soid frem
K`p`j"sp`yojb
` sm`nn ojidmjoty fer ferdobjdrs lonndi oj tgd w`r zejd*
K`p`j adb`j gdr nejb-hejhdovdi prebr`m ef `bbrdssoej `t tgd
dxpdjsd ef Hgoj` tew`ri tgd dji ef tgd n`st hdjtury* Ygd forst w`r
adtwddj K`p`j `ji Hgoj` ehhurrdi oj 07?9-?4* K`p`j teel evdr tgd
osn`ji ef Fermes` 'h`nndi Y`ow`j. oj K`p`jdsd. jew/* Ot os ` sdmo-
trepoh`n osnd adnew K`p`j. tew`ri tgd Sgonoppojds `ji w`s ojg`aotdi
n`rbdny ay s`v`bd gd`igujtdrs oj tgd ojtdroer* Ygdj Yelye ferhdi
tgd Hgojdsd te m`ld Lerd` ` tdmper`rony `utejemeus j`toej wgohg
K`p`j teel evdr tdj yd`rs er se n`tdr. j`mojb ` K`p`jdsd bevdrjer-
bdjdr`n `t tgd Lerd`j h`pot`n ef Xdeun* Ygd jdxt stdp w`s tgd Qusse-
K`p`jdsd R`r ef 0?39-34. wgohg K`p`j `nse wej `b`oj prea`any ay
tgd n`vosg usd ef sonvdr aunndts `mejb tgd Qusso`j treeps ef tgd eni
Hz`rost rdbomd. fobgtojb ej tgd M`jhguro`j pn`ojs f`r frem Enb` `ji
gemd* K`p`j sdozdi hejtren ef Xeutg M`jhguro` `ji teel ots Q`onw`y
[ejd jertg `s f`r `s tgd g`nfw`y m`rl `t Hg`jb-hgujb. jew ljewj
`s Gsojlojb. `ji m`id h`pot`n ef M`jhgulue oj 0?81*
Ydj yd`rs `ftdr tg`t Qusse-K`p`jdsd R`r djidi. wgond tgd werni
w`s ausy wotg tgd Brd`t R`r oj Durepd. Yelye m`id gdr jew
jeteroeus Ywdjty-ejd Idm`jis ej ` supojd Hgoj`. pewdrndss te rdsost*
Ygd idm`jis"" wdrd ioshevdrdi ay `j `ndrt Tjotdi Xt`tds prdss sdrvohd
herrdspejidjt oj Sdlojb. Frdidrohl Meerd* Gd b`vd tgdor tdxt te tgd
`steujidi werni* Ygd upre`r w`s se tdrrofoh dvdj iurojb tgd Durepd`j
w`r tg`t K`p`j a`hldi iewj `ji aoidi gdr tomd*
Xgd dvdj sobjdi tgd Jojd-Sewdr Yrd`ty oj 0?10-11 `t tgd R`sg-
ojbtej Hejfdrdjhd h`nndi ay Hg`rnds Dv`js Gubgds. tgdj Xdhrdt`ry ef
Xt`td* Ygd p`ht bu`r`jtddi tgd tdrrotero`n ojtdbroty ef Hgoj` `ji
tgd f`meus Epdj Ieer penohy ef dqu`n dhejemoh eppertujoty tgdrd*
K`p`j wotgirdw gdr ferhds frem Xg`jtujb Srevojhd. ehhupodi `s gdr
speons ef w`r wgdj sgd stdppdi ojte tgd Bdrm`j-hejtrenndi pert ef
Ysojbt`e* Aut jet fer nejb* K`p`j wdjt a`hl ojte Xg`jtujb `b`oj
wgdj tgd Luemojt`jb Qdvenutoej ndi ay Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-
sgdl `ji ojspordi ay tgd n`td Ir* Xuj _`t-sdj. swdpt jertg `hress
Hgoj` frem H`jtej oj 0?12-17* Bdjdr`n Hgo`jb ejhd teni md tg`t
K`p`j"s ehhup`toej oj 0?12 ef Ysoj`j-fu. h`pot`n ef Xg`jtujb Srevojhd.
g`i gdni a`hl tgd Hgojdsd rdvenutoej`ry `rmods `ji idn`ydi tgdor
h`pturd ef Sdlojb fer ` yd`r* Ygd K`p`jdsd suasdqudjtny wotgirdw
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 280/455
173 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
`b`oj aut oj tgd prdsdjt w`r te ` fojosg sgd rdjdwdi gdr h`mp`obj oj
Xg`jtujb. dspdho`nny `t Ysojbt`e `ji Ysoj`j-fu*
Aut Hgoj` gdrsdnf. `ftdr tgd Luemojt`jb 'Sdepnd"s S`rty/ Qdvenu-
toej g`i h`pturdi Sdlojb frem tgd jertgdrj w`r neris. w`s seej
iovoidi `mejb gdr ewj f`htoejs `b`oj. `s `nw`ys* Ygdrd wdrd rd-
hurrdjt ojsurrdhtoejs wotgoj tgd S`rty. adbojjojb wotg tgd Rug`j
Qdadnnoej up tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr sgertny `ftdr tgd f`nn ef Sdlojb oj 0?17*
Ygd rdvent w`s qudnndi. ejny fer J`jlojb te foji etgdr f`htoejs
sprojbojb up `ji t`lojb `rms `b`ojst tgd jdwny fermdi Hdjtr`n
Bevdrjmdjt tgdrd* Ygd Hgojdsd Hemmujosts hejtojudi ` tgerj oj
tgd soid ef Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl. `s wdnn. dvdj te tgd prdsdjt* Tjoty w`s
f`r frem `hgodvdi*
Ygd K`p`jdsd teel hebjoz`jhd ef tgos `ji ef tgd werni dhejemoh
idprdssoej sprd`iojb `mejb tgd wdstdrj j`toejs `ji oj tgd f`nn ef
0?80 adb`j tgd sdozurd ef M`jhguro`* Xgd rdsterdi tgd Aey Dm-
pdrer te tgd tgrejd ef gos `jhdsters `t Gsojlojb oj tgd Xprojb ef
0?81. `ji hrewjdi gom Dmpdrer L`jb-Ydg tgdrd ej M`rhg 0. 0?89*
Ygdj. ej ejd prdtdxt er `jetgdr. sgd mevdi ojte Kdgen Srevojhd. jertg
ef tgd Brd`t R`nn* Ygd hejqudst tgdrd w`s dqu`nny sompnd. wotg nottnd
er je eppesotoej ay tgd Hgojdsd* Kdgen w`s `iidi te M`jhgulue `s
`jetgdr prevojhd oj tg`t jdw auffdr Xt`td*
K`p`j"s jdxt mevd w`s te sdt up tgd Gepdo-Hg`g`r `utejemeus
rdbomd oj tgdsd twe prevojhds evdrn`ppojb tgd Brd`t R`nn ojte Ojjdr
Mejbeno`. oj 0?84* Ygos `rd` w`s idmonot`rozdi. Hgoj` lddpojb ` se-
h`nndi Sd`hd Srdsdrv`toej Herps ef seniodr-penohd oj tgd vohojoty< `ji
K`p`j g`i tgd m`lojbs ef ydt `jetgdr ojidpdjidjt Xt`td oj Jertg
Hgoj` `ik`hdjt te gdr puppdt st`td ef M`jhgulue. ` auffdr `b`ojst
pessoand `tt`hl frem Xevodt Qusso`* K`p`j fd`rdi Meshew merd tg`j
tgd Hgojdsd. `ji ieds jew*
Ygd Yelye h`mp`obj oj 0?84 `ji ujton tgd st`rt effobgtojb
jd`r
Sdopojb- te usd tgd rdvosdi spdnnojb ef tgd `jhodjt h`pot`n w`s m`id
te bdt hejtren ef `j `utejemeus Xt`td hempesdi ef tgd fovd prevojhds
iewj te tgd _dnnew Qovdr* @j ojhoidjt w`s tgd ommdio`td h`usd
ef tgd eutard`l effobgtojb* H`usojb ojhoidjts g`s addj ejd ef
K`p`j"s mest frdqudjt mdtgeis ef prevoiojb ` prdtdxt fer w`rf`rd oj
@so`* Ygd ojhoidjt ehhurrdi ej Kuny 2. 0?82. iurojb `ji `ftdr jobgt
m`jduvdrs ay K`p`jdsd treeps oj tgd idmonot`rozdi zejd oj Gepdo*
Ygdy hn`sgdi wotg Hgojdsd oj tgd Sd`hd Srdsdrv`toej Herps oj tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 281/455
YGD QE@I @GD@I 170
vohojoty ef tgd M`rhe Sene Aroibd `aeut jojd monds eutsoid tgd w`nns
ef Sdopojb `ji tgd w`r w`s ej. tgeubg jet idhn`rdi*
K`p`j w`jtdi te lddp tgd fobgtojb neh`nozdi oj Jertg Hgoj` `ji
`hgodvd gdr jdw ojidpdjidjt Xt`td tgdrd aut `jetgdr tgos tomd O
adnodvd ujdxpdhtdi ojhoidjt ehhurrdi oj tgd Xg`jbg`o zejd `aeut
` mejtg n`tdr. `ji tgd sdheji A`ttnd ef Xg`jbg`o adb`j @ubust ?.
0?82* @ K`p`jdsd j`v`n effohdr oj tgdor _`jbtzd S`tren ndi ` n`jiojb
p`rty jd`r tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt. estdjsoany sd`rhgojb fer `
mossojb K`p`jdsd* Ygd n`jiojb p`rty trodi te ferhd `j djtr`jhd ojte
Gujbk`e Monot`ry @oriremd eutsoid Xg`jbg`o* @ hn`sg ehhurrdi wotg
Hgojdsd idfdjsd treeps tgdrd. tgd effohdr ef K`p`j w`s lonndi. `ji etgdr
treeps weujidi* @ji tgd sdheji Xg`jbg`o w`r adb`j*
Ygd fobgtojb oj Jertg Hgoj` oj tgd Sdopojb-Yodjtsoj `rd` w`s seej
evdrsg`iewdi ay tgd Xg`jbg`o w`rf`rd* Ferdobjdrs. ojhnuiojb guj-
irdis ef @mdroh`j wemdj `ji hgonirdj. wdrd dv`hu`tdi frem Xg`jbg`o*
Xemd wdrd lonndi. m`jy suffdrdi weujis oj tgd `or r`ois `ji aema`ri-
mdjts ay aetg soids `t tgd st`rt ef tgd hn`sg* Ygd @mdroh`j std`msgop
Srdsoidjt Geevdr w`s aema`ridi. aut jet a`iny i`m`bdi. oj tgd
fobgtojb* 'Xgd n`tdr wdjt ej tgd rehls eff Fermes`. wgdj @mdroh`j
mdrh`jtond sgoppojb adb`j ` venujt`ry aeyhett ef Xg`jbg`o `s ` pert
ef h`nn iurojb tgd gdobgt ef tgd fobgtojb. `ji w`s peujidi te podhds*
Gdr p`ssdjbdrs `ji hrdw wdrd s`vdi*/ Ygd K`p`jdsd rusgdi rdoj-
ferhdmdjts te tgdor j`v`n `ji `rmy ferhds `nrd`iy `t Xg`jbg`o* @ftdr
wddls ef sdvdrd `rtonndry aema`rimdjt `ji `or `tt`hls ej tgd hoty.
ojhnuiojb tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt `ji tgd Frdjhg Hejhdssoej. tgd
Hgojdsd treeps wotgirdw* Xg`jbg`o w`s ` prozd ef w`r fer tgd K`p`-
jdsd gdr brd`tdst vohtery oj tgd bdjdr`toej-eni h`mp`obj oj Hgoj`*
Ygd K`p`jdsd ommdio`tdny m`rhgdi wdstw`ri up tgd _`jbtzd Qovdr
tew`ri J`jlojb `ji. `ftdr nottnd er je eppesotoej `t Xeehgew ej tgd
w`y. h`pturdi tgd H`pot`n* Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl fndi oj `j
`orpn`jd wotg gos wofd. tgd fermdr Mdo-nojb Xeejb ad`utofun `ji mest
ojfnudjto`n wem`j oj Hgoj`* Ygd Bevdrjmdjt wgohg Hgo`jb g`i
fermdi oj @pron ef 0?12 g`i `nrd`iy dv`hu`tdi J`jlojb. sh`ttdrojb te
tgd wdst* @ fodni-gd`iqu`rtdrs typd ef w`rtomd Bevdrjmdjt w`s sdt
up tdmper`rony `t G`jlew. 633 monds up tgd _`jbtzd oj tgd ojtdroer ef
Hgoj` wotg tgd merd pdrm`jdjt h`pot`n dst`anosgdi `t Hgujblojb.
oj Xzdhgu`j Srevojhd. ej tgd aeridr ef Yoadt*
K`p`j hejtojudi gdr rutgndss h`mp`obj te suakub`td `nn Hgoj`*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 282/455
171 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Yreeps sdozdi H`jtej f`r te tgd seutg* Oj Xg`jtujb. tgdy h`pturdi
Ysojbt`e. hgodf pert ef tgdor eni strejbgeni tgdrd. `ji Ysoj`j-fu. tgd
h`pot`n* @ meppojb-up irovd fennewdi. wotg G`jlew ejd m`ker
eakdhtovd* Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds Dma`ssy `t J`jlojb. gd`idi ay @ma`s-
s`ier Jdnsej Y* Kegjsej. mevdi te G`jlew `ji tgdj te Hgujblojb
wotg tgd Hdjtr`n Bevdrjmdjt.
Oj Xg`jbg`o. fobgtojb hd`sdi `ji tgd hoty adb`j te neel te rdp`orojb
tgd ojhrdioand i`m`bd iejd ay wddls ef `rtonndry `ji `dro`n aema`ri-
mdjts* Ygd ness ef novds `ji prepdrty w`s trdmdjieus*
Ygd ieem ef tgd wgotd m`j `s ` nottnd toj bei oj tgd F`r D`st
w`s seujidi ay tgd K`p`jdsd `htoej oj Hgoj`* Ygd prdstobd ef tgd
mdj frem tgd Ehhoidjt`n werni g`i nejb addj f`iojb* Ygd vohtery ef
K`p`j oj `ji `reuji Xg`jbg`o w`s tgd fojosgojb teuhg ` jdw mond-
stejd oj tgdor `iv`jhd upej tgd nejb-seubgt eakdhtovd; @so` fer tgd
@so`tohs! @t tgd gdobgt ef tgd Xg`jbg`o hejfnoht ejd Bevdrjmdjt
mdmadr oj Yelye veohdi tgd bdjdr`n fddnojb `mejb nd`idrs ef I`o
Joppej* Gd w`s tgd Gemd Mojostdr. @imor`n Jeaum`s` Xuydtsubu*
Gd fr`jlny `ssdrtdi oj ` puanoh st`tdmdjt oj tgd prdss ef K`p`j tg`t
tgd wgotd r`hds sgeuni jet h`rry ej tr`id oj tgd Erodjt a`sdi sendny
ej tgdor ewj sdnf-ojtdrdst* Gd ojsostdi tg`t werni pd`hd idpdjidi
upej wg`t gd h`nndi tgd noadr`toej ef tgd henerdi r`hds ef tgd d`rtg
frem wgotd suprdm`hy*
Oj Xg`jbg`o. ejd ef tgd forst pr`htoh`n `ppnoh`toejs ef tgos `ttdmpt
te dr`ioh`td tgd wgotd m`j"s ojfnudjhd oj tgd Erodjt w`s tgd ommdio`td
idm`ji tg`t K`p`j ad br`jtdi hejtren ef tgd Mujohop`n Heujhon runojb
tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt tgdrd* Ygd Heujhon g`i addj hejtrenndi
sojhd ots ojhdptoej oj tgd p`st hdjtury. ay tgd Arotosg wotg @mdroh`j
`ji K`p`jdsd mdmadrs< `ji. oj tgd n`st idh`id. wotg Hgojdsd `t n`st
`imottdi te sot `s rdbun`r vetojb mdmadrs ef tgos aeiy* Ygd K`p`jdsd
m`ojt`ojdi. oj prdssojb tgdsd idm`jis. tg`t`pp`rdjtny tgd Heujhon
dotgdr w`s jet sdroeus oj ots idsord te pretdht K`p`jdsd novds `ji
prepdrty wotgoj tgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt frem `hts ef eutr`bd
ay tgd Hgojdsd. w`s uj`and te bovd `idqu`td pretdhtoej te tgd K`p`jdsd
rdsoidjts. jumadrojb tgeus`jis tgdrd*
Herjdnn X* Fr`jlnoj. `j @mdroh`j. w`s Hg`orm`j ef tgd Heujhon
iurojb tgd treuandi yd`rs ef 0?82-87* Gd seubgt te mdio`td. t`lojb
tgd K`p`jdsd idm`jis fer hejtren ujidr hejsoidr`toej*
Ygd pd`hd tdrms wgohg Yelye wonn n`y iewj `ftdr tgd ujidhn`rdi
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 283/455
YGDQE@I@GD@I 178
w`r oj Hgoj` `rd stonn jdauneus* Ygdy wonn ieuatndss ad ljewj seej
djeubg* Ejd woidny horhun`tdi rdpert s`oi tgd tdrms weuni ad suhg
`s weuni m`ld Hgoj` hempndtdny suasdrvodjt te K`p`j wotgeut tdhg-
joh`nny voen`tojb tgd K`p`jdsd effoho`n `ssdrtoej tg`t K`p`j g`s JEtdrrotero`n `maotoejs oj Hgoj`* @jetgdr hurrdjt rdpert `t tgd gdobgt
ef tgd fobgtojb s`oi tgd K`p`jdsd dxtrdmosts idm`jidi;
0 Qdhebjotoej ef M`jhgulue `ji ferm`toej ef `j dhejemoh
aneh `mejb Hgoj`. K`p`j `ji M`jhgulue*
1 Ferm`toej ef `utejemeus. `jto-Hemmujost `imojostr`toejs
oj Jertg Hgoj` `ji Ojjdr Mejbeno`. aetg ujidr K`p`jdsd pre-
tdhtoej aut hejtrennojb `nn tgdor ewj t`xds `ji hustems rdvdjuds*
8 @ppeojtmdjt ef ` K`p`jdsd Ojspdhter-Bdjdr`n ef Hustems
oj Hgoj`. `ji ef K`p`jdsd `ivosdrs oj `nn j`toej`n `ji prevojho`n
idp`rtmdjts< `ji rdvosoej ef Hgojdsd t`roffs te premetd `j dx-
hg`jbd ef K`p`jdsd m`jf`hturds `b`ojst Hgojdsd r`w m`tdro`ns.
9 Bdjdr`nossome Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl te stdp `soid fer ` pre-
K`p`jdsdSrdsoidjt ef
Hgoj`.`ji Hgoj` te
keojtgd `jto-
Hemmujost aneh hemprosojb K`p`j. Bdrm`jy `ji Ot`ny*
4 Hgoj` te rdfr`oj frem pessdssojb `j `rmy er `or ferhd ef
w`rpn`jds< ` spdho`n Sd`hd Srdsdrv`toej Herps te ad fermdi fer
ojtdrj`n penohd fujhtoejs< `ji `nn hemmdrho`n `or sdrvohds te ad
m`j`bdi ay K`p`j. tgd Hgojdsd `ornojds te bdt tgdor pn`jds frem
K`p`jdsd pn`jts*
Xemd ef tgdsd fovd peojts seuji str`jbdny nold tgesd ojhnuidi oj tgd
eroboj`n Ywdjty-ejd Idm`jis mdjtoejdi `aevd* @quodshdjhd ay Hgoj`
hdrt`ojny weuni bovd Yelye hempndtd hejtren ef tg`t heujtry. `s tgd
K`p`jdsd g`vd nejb idsordi* @ji tgd Epdj Ieer ef dqu`n dhejemoh
eppertujoty. nejb ` m`ker pn`jl oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds penohy tew`ri tgd
Erodjt. weuni swojb sgut wotg ` a`jb*
Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds adh`md ojvenvdi oj tgd Xg`jbg`o w`rf`rd wgdj
tgd K`p`jdsd sujl tgd T* X* X* S`j`y. ` bujae`t ej eur _`jbtzd Qovdr
p`tren* Xgd w`s dv`hu`tojb mdj. wemdj `ji hgonirdj frem J`jlojb
ej Xuji`y. Idhdmadr 01. 0?82* K`p`jdsd w`rpn`jds rdpd`tdiny
ireppdi `dro`n aemas ej tgd ieemdi w`rsgop. `ji sgd wdjt te tgd
aettem* @t nd`st tgrdd pdepnd wdrd lonndi oj tg`t ojhoidjt twe
@mdroh`js `ji ejd Ot`no`j* Ygrdd Xt`ji`ri Eon t`jldrs jd`ray nold-
wosd wdrd aemadi oj tgd `or r`oi `ji sujl oj tgd iddp _`jbtzd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 284/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 285/455
YGD QE@I @GD@I 174
fremfontdrojb ojte Hgoj`. `ji tgdjhd `hress tgd a`y te tgdor osn`ji
dmpord feujidi. tgdy s`y. ay tgd Xuj Beiidss gdrsdnf* Fer tgdrd
g`snejb
addj ujrdst wotgoj tgd aeuji`rods ef
Joppej*Ygd n`aer
mevdmdjt. `s ydt `nmest oj`rtohun`td. os jejdtgdndss tgdrd. Ygd oj-
iustro`n rdvenutoej oj K`p`j g`s addj tee rdhdjt fer n`aer te bdt wdnn
erb`jozdi* Aut tgd monot`ry hgodft`ojs. fd`rojb kust suhg `j `w`l-
djojb `ji pessoand dvdjtu`n sprd`i ef Hemmujost iehtrojds `t gemd
`ji ojtdrj`n rdvenutoej. fobgt tgd Xevodt Tjoej `ji ots projhopnds
wotg tgdor a`hls te tgd Brd`t R`nn ef Hgoj`*
Hryst`n-b`zojb iewj tgd twostojb `vdjud ef tgd yd`rs te hemd oj
`j `iindi werni os i`jbdreus ausojdss `t adst. p`rtohun`rny of wd
sddl te pdjdtr`td `nejb tg`t n`jd wgohg os idvetdi te tgojbs ef tgd
Erodjt* Rgdtgdr tgd Aey Dmpdrer wonn ad rdsterdi te gos Ir`bej
Ygrejd j`tur`nny os hejkdhtur`n `t tgos wrotojb* Ot os ieuatfun
wgdtgdr tgd K`p`jdsd wge `rd stonn punnojb tgd puppdt-strojbs oj
tg`t sgew m tgdor sdhtoej ef tgd werni"s surf`hd tgdmsdnvds ljew*
Ot os my hejvohtoej tg`t suhg ` mevd os jet f`r iewj tgd penotoh`n
gerozej oj Jertg Hgoj`* Ygd mevd `ppd`rs neboh`n wgdj tgd p`ttdrj
te i`td os tr`hdi `hhur`tdny `ji tgd metovds adgoji K`p`j"s idsord
fer suprdm`hy ej tgd m`ojn`ji ef @so` ojdvot`any `t Hgoj`"s dxpdjsd
forst. `ji `t Xevodt Qusso`"s sdheji `rd hemprdgdjidi* Oj tgos
venumd. O g`vd trodi te prdsdjt tgdm oj hnd`r fehus wotg `j ujao`sdi
pdrspdhtovd* @ji oj hempndtojb tgos ojtom`tdny teni t`nd ef gew ot
g`ppdjdi eut tgdrd. O adnodvd O sg`nn s`y gdrd jew tg`t tgd Aey
Dmpdrer os beojb te tewj ej tgd a`hls ef tgd sturiy. ompn`h`and
nottnd mdj frem I`o Joppej `ji tgd tewj te wgohg gd os beojb os
0 "dlojb* Ygd i`td5 Xemd M`rhg 0 adferd tee nejb `j gosteroh i`y
oj tgd novds ef tgd M`jhgu dmpdrers. `s wd jew ljew*
Ygdrd `rd Hgojdsd `nse wge fddn tg`t tgdor n`ji heuni ie wersd
tg`j rdturj te tgd w`ys ef tgdor `jhdsters `ji try `b`oj te rund `nn
Hgoj` frem ` strejb hdjtr`n bevdrjmdjt `t Sdlojb* Ygd idmehr`toh
w`y ef nofd se f`r g`s f`ondi oj tgd Erodjt* Ot wonn jddi merd tomd
adferd ots untom`td vohtery tgdrd. `ji dvdrywgdrd dnsd oj eur werni*
"Kgos vohtery os ojdvot`and* Ot os `j ommut`and f`ht oj tgd p`ojfun
prebrdss ef m`jloji*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 286/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 287/455
OJIDW
ADJI.G`nndtt 0?1
i`ms. Kegj Puojhy 44
bndj. Xor Fr`jhos 102
Vbr`ro`j Qdvenutoej 014
Godi @rmy ef Idfdjsd 10.18
mdroh`. @mdroh`j 13. 11. 18. 14.
17-83. 89. 84. 82-92. 9?-41. 49-4?.
60-69. 66. 67-23. 21-24. 2?. 73. 79.
77-?0.?9-?6. ?7-030. 039-032. 03?. 003.
008. 007. 010. 012-083. 084. 087. 090.
094. 063. 062. 067. 023. 027-073. 071.
079. 072. 07?. 0?0. 0?1. 0?2. 139. 134.
137. 108. 104. 107-118. 114. 112. 117-187. 193. 190. 194. 19?. 144. 14?. 163.
168. 169. 123. 121. 127. 170-179
mdroh`j Hgurhg Mossoej 026. 022
mdroh`j Hnua 07. 0?. 11. 60. 010. 111.
143. 142
mdroh`j Jertgdrj Srdsgyndro`j Mos-
soej 86
mdroh`j Tjovdrsoty Hnua 023
mey 46
jgwdo 092
jj`penos 106
r`as 06rozej` 71
meni. Kund`j -039-036. 114. 116
so` 01. 09. 04. 88. 41. 49. 62. ?6.
099. 04?. 063. 066. 029. 024. 022. 079.
076. 0?1. 13?. 101. 110. 111. 119.
112-183. 182. 187. 161. 126. 173. 171.
174
sseho`tdi Srdss 140
tn`jtoh Ehd`j 143. 160
usnr`g`. @ustr`no`j 12. 17
@NYOMEQD 44`ptost Hgurhg 084. 086. 026. 078. 079
drb 'sdd `nse Aereioj. Mol`n/ ?2
drnm 086. 142. 14?. 163. 127
ojidr. H`rrenn 147. 14?
ojbg`m. Xdj`ter Gor`m 039. 036.
012. 017
ojbg`m. Reeiaroibd 039. 036
ojbg`mptej. J _* 21
n`ldny. Qd`r-@im K* Q _*-Z68. 07?
Aensgdvol11. 2?.
?1
Aejjdyonnd.Qohg`ri R* 10?
Aereioj. M`i`md M* 24
Aereioj. Mol`n 0?. 66. ?3. ?6-033.
004. 00?. 011-01?. 080. 099. 043. 040.
04?. 190
Aestej 49. 22
Aestej Tjovdrsoty -13?
Aewdj. Ir* @* K* 94. 96
Aexdr Qdadnnoej 47. 106
Aey Dmpdrer 13. 18?. 193. 161-164.
162. 167. 120-124. 173. 174
Ardotdjstdoj. Qohg`ri 0?3. 0?1. 134Arosten. @hnm M`rl N* 61. 113-114.
149-146. 147. 14?
Arosten. Mrs M`rl N 114. 146. 147.
14?
Arot`oj. Arotosg 10. 11. 16. 17. 1?. 80.
88. 87. 93. 90. 98. 94. 92. 9?. 46. 47.
4?. 60-68. 66. 67. 6?. 21. 28. 24-70.
79. 77. ?9. ?6. ??-030. 017. 094. 062.
023. 02?. 078. 072-07?. 0?0. 137. 106.
107. 114. 11?. 180. 141. 120. 121.
171. 179
Arotosg `ji @mdroh`j Yea`hhe Hem-p`jy 26. 086
Areelnyj D`bnd :089
Ary`j. Ronno`m Kdjjojbs 02?
Auiig`. Auiigosm 001. 089. 029. 027.
070. 169
Auff`ne Tjovdrsoty 10?
Aurm` 79. 01?. 100. 112
Autndr. Arob*-Bhj* Xmdindy I* 68. 69.
077
H@NOFEQJO@ 093. 11?
H`mm. K* 2?H`j`i` 079
H`jtej. H`jtejdsd 08. 02-16. 81. 92.
9?. 41. 49. 42-4?. 62. 6?. 23. 22. 27.
73. 71. 79. ?6. ?7. 006. 014. 084.
066-028. 076. 0?3. 101< 114. 116. 181-
189. 18?-190. 194. 12?. 171
H`jtej Hgrosto`j Henndbd 026
H`stndm`j. H`pt* Ldjjdtg 118
H`tgenoh 026. 074
172
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 288/455
177 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Hdjtr`n @mdroh` ??
Hg`jb Hgdjb-yo. Qdv 078
Hg`jb-hgujb 18?. 161. 164. 166. 12?
Hg`jb Hgujb-hg`jb. M`rsg`n 20. 78.
092. 049. 0?0. 0?6. 0??
Hg`jb F`-lwdo. Bdj* 067. 06?
Hg`jb Gsudg-g`jb. Bdj 0?4-0??. 100
Hg`jb Guo-hg`jb. H`pt 181. 188
Hg`jbsg` 07?
Hg`jb Xgdj-tsd. Bdj 74
Hg`jb Yse-nm 4?. 78. 79. ?8. ?7. 000.
081. 098. 076. 072. 0?0. 0?1. 0?4-0?2.
0??. 132. 102
Hg`pdo169
tgdlo`jb Srevmh>Z-78. 080. 081. 092
Hgdj. Dubdjd-83. 80. 84. 91. 9?. 74.
?3. ?1-?6. 03?. 012-01?. 094
Hgdjb Hgodj. Bdj -90-98. 97. 74
Hgdjbhgew-12. 17. 018-014. 01?-080.
077
Hgdjbtu 112. 183
Hgo`jb Hgmb-p`jb 090
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl 09. 18. 17. 83. 88.
97. 4?. 64. 27. 2?. 70-74. ?8. ?9. ?6.
?7. 038. 036-037. 003-00?. 018. 014-
017. 080-090. 099-096. 041. 049. 042-
063. 062-06?. 020. 026. 079. 0?9. 132.
103. 111. 191. 197. 122-170. 178
Hgoh`be ?2. 083
Hgoh`be I`ony Jdws 14?
Hgoh`be Yroaujh-~18. 039. 010
Hgoh`be. Tjovdrsoty ef 083
Hgodfdjhgew 0?9
Hgodj Ysu-moj 74
Hgogno 0?3
Hgogno-Xg`jtujb @rmy 86. 91
Hgo-le 081-089. 087
Hgoj`. Hgojdsd-00-06. 07-11. 19-84.
82. 8?. 90. 91. 96. 92. 9?. 41-21. 29.
22-77. ?0-030. 038-032. 03?-009. 006-
00?. 011-012. 01?-08?. .091. 099-048.
044-07?. 0?1-0?7. 133. 131-108. 104.
106. 107-193. 191-196. 197-141. 149.
144. 142. 160-166. 123. 128-174
Hgoj` Srdss 181
Hgojdsd Hdjtr`n Bevdrjmdjt 09. 4?.
173. 171
Hgojdsd D`stdrj Q`onw`y 072. 19?
Hgojdsd J`toej`n @vo`tej Herper`toej
189-182
Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh 47. 092. 046. 162.
167. 120. 128
Hgojdsd Yurldst`j 066
Hgoj Fdo 162. 167
Hgmlo`jb 21-24
Hgrosto`j. Hgrosto`joty 0 09. 006. 042.
029-073. 071-074
Hgrost ef tgd Ojio`j Qe`i 029
Hgujblojb 09. 88. 100. 101. 170. 171
Hgu. S`un 03?
Hndvdn`ji. Ir* Frdidrohl @ 10?
Hemmujost. Hemmujosm 88. 89. 22.
70-74. ?0. ?4. ?7. 033. 000. 006. 00?.
018. 014. 01?. 080. 099. 096. 097-046.
047. 04?. 064. 062. 067. 023. 020. 027.
07?. 146. 127. 173. 178-174
Hejfuhous. Hejfuho`josm 009. 029. 027
Hejbrdb`toej`n Hgurhg 071. 079
Hejst`jtojo. @rhgaosgep079
Hejvdrsd. H`renyj 143
Heenoibh. H`nvoj 07?
Herjdnn Tjovdrsoty 10?
Hujjojbg`m. Diwoj X 077
Huttojb. Xuyi`m 112
I@OQDJ 072. 0?1. 0?8. 0?4. 0?6. 138-
134. 132. 168
I`vos. Iwobgt F 19?
I`vos. Hen G* H 63. 60
I`vos. KegjL 89. 84. 40
Idauhgo. Ldjlohgo 168
Idtreot ?3. 183-181
Iosr`dno 06
Iujh`j. M`k*-Bdj* Xor Kegj 60. 61.
072. 114
Iur`jty. R`ntdr 66. 140. 144. 146.
147-863
DII_. Ronno`m 011
Diw`rids. @ G* L 106. 102
Dtgoepo` 127
Durepd. Durepd`j 49. 44. 4?-60. 74.
039. 008. 086. 090. 066. 101. 108. 119.
188. 184. 187. 193. 198. 196. 19?-140.
148. 142. 147. 163. 127. 12?
Dxtr`-Yhrrotero`noty. Iehtrojd ef 46.
47. ?6. 094
F@XHOXM 127
Fddny. Diw`ri F* 10?
Fdjbgw` 088. 089Fdjbgw` Qovdr 086
Fdjbkuj 0?9
Fdjb Lue-hg`jb 167
Fdjbtodj Srevojhd 080. 0?4. 0?6. 0??.
133. 138
Fdjb _u-gso`jb 17. 4?. 78. ?8. 038.
032. 000. 009-002. 00?. 018. 014. 016.
017-083. 04?-066. 077. 07?. 0?9. 0??.
132. 197. 120
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 289/455
OJIDW 17?
Fdttdr. Ir Fr`jl R 10?
Fodni Musdum 112
Feraoiidj Hoty 00. 193. 162-120
Fejb Xdh. Ir* 084
Fermes` 12?. 170
Feehgew 46
Fr`jhd. Frdjhg 13. 11. 18. 83. 93. 47.
68. 66. 77. ?3. ?9. 033. 030. 004. 084.
042. 077. 0?0. 104. 106. 107. 140. 170
Fr`jlnoj. Herjdnn X 171
Fu`i Ady 00?
Fulodj 71. 092. 048
Fu No Hgo 001
Fu Yse-yo. Bdj 0?0
B@TXX. Hn`rdjhd 077
Bdjbgos Lg`j 13?
Bdrm`jy. Bdrm`j 11. 17. 47. 6?. 27.
77. ?3. ?2. 033. 004. 084. 0?0. 0?1.
119. 188. 146. 14?. 163. 12?. 178
Boaaejs. Fneyi 169
Bojnojb Henndbd fer Remdj -86. 98.
99. 034. 196
Bn`istejd 06
Beeirohg.Drjdst S 199. 194
Bert. Vosheujt 072
Brd`t R`nn ef Hgm`-00. 12. 41. 076.
0?0. 0?8. 0?9. 131. 13?. 18?. 161. 166.
124. 122. 173. 174
Bu`m 69. 183
G@A@QEVXL 144-142
G`o-ge Qovdr 0?3
G`onujlo`jb 0??
G`jbhgew 048
G`jlew-01. 18. 17. 80. 88. 84. 64. 66.67. 6?. 24. 22-78. 74. 72-?2. ??-030.
038. 039. 006. 00?-080. 087. 090. 099.
094. 043. 066. 06?. 026. 027. 077. 07?.
0?6. 132. 137. 100. 118. 183. 181.
189. 197. 170. 171
G`jlew Hnua ?3. 033
G`jlew Tdrii-R. 033
G`jlew Q`hd Hnua ?3. 033
G`j Qovdr 72
G`jsdj. Orwm 148
G`jy`jb 77
G`raoj 11. 0??. 133. 134. 19?
G`riojb. R`rrdj B* 193
G`rros. Merros 140
G`rv`ri Tjovdrsoty 10?
G`w`oo 183. 18?
G`y. N`iy G`y Irummeji 190
Gdjry Su-yo 'sdd `nse Gsu`j-Yojb`ji tgd Aey Dmpdrer/ 13. 161.
168. 164-124
Gonn. Hen Hg`rnds X`jidrsej 104. 106
Goregote-06. 168. 179
Gea`rt. D* Y -89. 82. 99. 9?
Genn`jidr. Y K* 022
Gej`j Srevojhd-Z. 78. ?8. 018. 019.
017. 01?. 060. 068-064. 067
Gejblejb 06?. 108. 11?-180
Gejenunu ?2. 011. 0?1
Geevdr. GdradrtZ169
Gepdo 0?3. 122. 173
Geubg. Qd`r-@im* Q G -97< 7?
Gso`lw`j 87. 97. 29
Gsmlojb 18?. 161. 168. 12?. 173
Gsu`jY"mb 18?. 161. 164. 162.
120
Gsu-hgodj. Bderbd 74
G&uhgew-fu 17. 038. 032. 03?-008.
004. 002. 007. 018-014. 093
Gubgds. Hg`rnds Dv`js 12?
Gunn. Heridnn 179
Guj`j 74. ?4. ?6. 009. 092. 097. 048.
027
Gupdg 092. 097. 048
Gu _`e-t`u 90
0JKIO@-96. 10. 029Ojio`j` ?2
Ojtdrj`toej`n Jdws Xdrvohd 14?
Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt 13. 11. 18. 14.
16. 83. 168. 170. 171. 179
Ot`ny. Ot`no`j-93. 68. 127. 178
K@S@J. K`p`jdsd 00. 08. 06-18. 93.
99. 97. 63. 61. 24. 73. 79. 77. 033.
039. 000. 008. 007. 081. 088. 086. 093.
042. 061. 062. 029. 073. 076-0?3. 0?1-
0?7. 133-134. 132. 13?. 100. 107. 180.
181. 18?. 193. 197-140. 144. 146. 161-
166. 120-174
Kdgen 0?9. 173
Kdrus`ndm 02?
Kegjsej. @ma`ss`ier Jdnsej Y. 171
Kejds. Dnsod M`rtoj 140
Kejds. Nodut* Xt`jndy @* 48. 63
L@NYDJAEQJ. G* V*-089. 082-08?
L`jb-Ydg 161. 173
L`js`s 001
L`jsu-068. 066. 0?2. 101
L`sgmor 112
Lddj. Vohter 143
Ldmmdrdr. Sref* Diwoj R`ntdr 107.
10?
Lo`jblew 082. 090
Lo`jbso-9?. 092
Lo`jbsu 038. 032. 068
Lonberd. Nodut-Hen* F* I* 104
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 290/455
1?3 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
Lm-g`j Q`onw`y 88. 081. 042
Lojlo`jb 73. 70
Lojjdy. G* R* 0?1
Lopnojb. Quiy`ri 02
Loroj-0??. 138
Lee. Ir* Rdnnojbtej 4?
Lerd` 073. 140. 12?
Lesnevsly. A* 06?
Lrdmnoj 14?
Lu`jb Gsu 166. 162
Lujb. Ir* G* G* 061. 06?. 10?
Lujb. Mmd G G 042. 198
Lujb-gsodj 077
Lue Hgo` Xo 164. 123
Luemojhguj 094
Luermjt`jb02. 07. 13. 83-88. 41. 48.
66. 2?-71. ?3. ?1. ?4. ?6. ??. 030. 038.
003. 009-006. 00?. 019. 083. 081. 088.
093. 099-04?. 060. 061. 062. 06?. 023.
076-0?1. 0?9. 138. 132. 137. 103. 100.
11?. 188. 18?-198. 197. 161. 12?. 173
Lue Xujb-noj 000
Lw`jbso-081. 0?9. 132. 114. 116. 197
Lw`jbtujb-Z0. 71. 114
Lw`jtujb 048. 067Lwdohgew 71. 74. 092
N@VE_. Mdrnd 001. 008
Nd`bud ef J`toejs 01?. 0?8. 133. 169.
127
Ndbdjird. Ir* @* F* 140
Ndjoj 14?
Ndjojbr`i 14?
No Hgujb-kdj. Bdj 001. 132
Nodu. _ [ -73-78. 74
Nojhenj. @ar`g`m 193Nojiadrbg. Hg`rnds 181
Noj Xdj~-88
Nojy`jb 0?3
Nosaej 11?
Nottdnn. Kegj 022
Nehlg`rt. Hen Q S* 76. 7?. 01?. 026
Nehlg`rt. Ir* 3* H 10?
Neg. M`k*-Bdj I`voi 006. 002
Negm`jj. G* S* 163
Nen` 112. 117
Nejiej 23. 023
Nejiej. K`hl 0?1
Nejiej Yomds 17. 010
Ne S` Gejb 074
Ney`jb 07?
Nulds. X`r`g 160
Nulds. Xus`j 160
Nujbg`o Q`onw`y 000. 066
Nutgdr`j Hgurhg 011. 026
Nyjhg. F* A* 10?
Nyejs. Dubdjd 147
M@H@E 11?
M`hMurr`y. Kegj V`j @* 137. 10?.
113
M` Ge-hgew. M`k*-Bdj 001
M`jhgu 00. 13. 47. 094. 076. 077. 138.
110. 18?. 161. 168. 164. 166. 123.
129. 124. 174
M`jhgulue 13. 076. 138. 18?. 193.
168. 12?. 173. 178. 179
M`jhguro` 13. 11. 4?. ?8. 000. 080. 061.
076. 072. 0?0-138. 134-132. 13?. 100.
181. 197-143. 144. 161-164. 129-126.
127-173. 179
M`ji`roj 01. 9?. 62. 099. 101. 108
M`jon`-69. 021. 11?. 183. 182. 19?
M`rhe Sene 081
M`tsuel`. _esuld 0?1-0?4. 133
M`zd. Xor Frdidrohl 106. 102
Mdhlndjaurbg. G* N 2?
Mdtgeiost Dposhep`n Hgurhg 042. 026.
073. 078. 079
Mdxohe. Mdxoh`j ?3-?1. ??. 0?1. 149
Mo`mo.Fn`* 074
Mohgob`j->71. 011. 183
Moiind Lojbiem-! 0. 12
Moiw`y Osn`ji 183
Mossossoppo Qovdr 66. 23. 72. 77
Mosseuro 160
Mosseuro. Tjovdrsoty ef 160
Meidrj Hgojdsd Hovonoz`toej 140
Mejbeno` ?6. 018. 13?-100. 164. 166.
167. 173. 178. 179
Meerd. Frdidrohl F*-66. 12?
Meshew 13. 17. 88. 66. ?0. ?1. ?6. ?2.
??. 038. 000. 00?. 018. 014. 099. 094.
062. 06?-020. 137. 193. 19?-141. 149-
163. 173. 179
Meusserbsly 14?
Ar* ArotTjb Xdds Ot Ygreubg 1)1
Mulidj 78. 000. 076. 072. 0?1-0?6.
0??. 133. 131-139. 132. 100. 181. 188.
168. 169
Mussenojo 127
J@JHD. Ir* R`ntdr Auhljdr 073-
071
J`jhd. Mrs* R`ntdr Auhljdr *070. 071
J`jlojb-09. 18. 14. 1?. 83. 81-84. 91.
94. 96. 97-43. 61. 64. 67. 20-26. 27. 2?.
78. 74. ?8-?6. ?7. 030. 038-032. 003.
006-00?. 018. 019. 016-01?. 089. 099-
092. 040. 042. 047. 063. 060. 064-062.
06?-020. 027. 073. 071. 079. 077. 0?8.
0?9. 0?7. 133. 130. 137-101. 106. 102.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 291/455
OJIDW 1?0
10?. 113. 111. 116. 181-182. 190-
19?. 126-127. 173-179
J`jlojb Ojhoidjt 1?. 80-84. 91. 40.
61. 68. ?1. ?4. 034. 012. 01?. 077
J`jlojb Ygdeneboh`n Xdmoj`ry 87
J`jlojb. Yrd`ty ef 46
J`jlojb Tjovdrsoty 81. 84. 86. 94. 92.
9?. 034. 036
J`toej`n Hoty A`jl 10?
J`toej`n Hgrosto`j Heujhon 02?
J`toej`nost 13. 18. 19. 12. 83. 89-43.
68. 20-28. 24. 22. 2?-70. 78. 72. ?3.
?1-?9. ?6. ?7. 033. 039. 036. 032. 008.
009. 006. 002. 019. 084. 093. 096.
040. 044. 046. 061. 062. 06?. 022. 027.
071. 0?8. 0?7-133. 13?. 103. 110. 191
J`toej`nost Jdws @bdjhy ?2
Jdw _erl-0?. 10. 1?. 49. 66. 67. ?3.
?4. 10?. 180. 184. 187. 199. 19?. 143.
163. 160
Jdw _erl Gdr`ni Yroaujd--143
Jdw _erl 2w~66. 29. 034. 084.
0?1. 0?7. 190. 197. 19?. 148
Joh`r`bu` -??. 106
Jodnsdj. Ir* @`bd L``rup 039. 032Jojd-Sewdr Yrd`ty 12?
Jojbpe-46. 081. 089-08?. 091
Jertgdrj @rmy 0?. 10. 19-16. 98. 99.
66. 20. 21. 24-22. ?8. ?6. ?7. 008. 009.
002. 014. 092. 077-0?3. 0?6. 132
ENEJB@SE-69Epdj Ieer Senohy 12?. 178
Eutdr Mejbeno` 018. 13?. 100. 179
S@HOFOH Ehd`j-o49. 039. 108. 106.119. 114. 11?. 181. 188. 169. 126
S`jb Ysodj-ts`o. Bdj 001-009
S`ros 086. 147-163
Sd`rn Qovdr 023. 076. 190
Sdohgogno A`y 072. 0?1. 138
Sdo Hgujb-gso. Bdj* 001. 008. 0?9.
181
Sdopojb 'sdd `nse Sdlojb/ 00. 13. 099.
063. 026. 114. 11?. 183. 189. 190.
196. 164. 129. 124. 173. 170. 174
Sdlojb 'sdd `nse Sdopojb/ 00. 81. 88.
42-4?. 66. 78. ?8. ?9. 032. 03?. 000.
008. 018. 014-017. 081. 088. 099. 094.
043. 042. 063. 069. 066. 076-0?6. 0??.
138. 134. 132-103. 106. 102. 113-111.
181. 18?-190. 198. 161. 164-162. 123-
128. 124. 12?. 173. 174
Sdlojb-Mulidj Q`onw`y 000. 0?9. 0?6
Fdnnojb. G* H*-23-21. 22
Sdjbpu 67. 21
Sdjjsynv`jo`. Tjovdrsoty ef 00?
Sdepnd"s Yroaujd. Y%t>5 ?2. 033. 018
Sdtdr tgd Brd`t 14?
Sgon`idnpgo` 106Sgonoppojd Osn`jis-8. 021. 106. 113.
197. 19?. 12?
Sohldjs. Qeadrt X* 039. 034. 032. 003.
008. 007. 00?. 010
Sojb-lo`jb 0?3
Sen`ji 163
Sen`ji. R* A-10?
Sepd Sous WO 079. 074
Sert @rtgur 072
Sertub`n 11?
Sewdnn. K* A*-18
Srdsaytdro`j Hgurhg 026. 071-079
Srojhdtej Tjovdrsoty 107. 10?
Sregmd. Q`yj` ?2. 018. 083
Sregmd. Ronno`m ?2
Sretdst`jt 026. 078. 074
Suhgdj-98
Sulew 87. 98. 21. 24. 037. 003. 001.
007. 00?. 012. 0?6
PTD[EJ.M`judn 19?
Puojhy. OOO 160
Pue Y`o-hgo 023
Q@IOE Herper`toej ef @mdroh` 182
Q`jbeej 12
Qdi A`jjdr. Ygd -146
Qdi Xw`stol` Xehodty-90. 97
Qdosjdr. Kegj 036
Qohg`risej. Ir* Iej`ni R* 94
Qondy. Fr`jl-17. 010. 011. 01?. 083
Qoe id K`jdore 140Qeadrts. Qdv* R* S*-92
Qeadrtsej. M`k* Ronno`m A* 189. 184
Qehly Meujt`ojs 71
Qebdrs. Ronn 169
Qemd 141. 127
Qeesdvdnt. Fr`jlnoj I 179
Qeesdvdnt. Ldrmot 112. 117
Qeesdvdnt. Ygdeierd 112
Qeets. Aosgep N* G 026-027
Qewd. Ir* G`rry F 94
Qusso`. Qusso`j 0?. 13. 11. 18. 17. 92.
47-63. 66. 6?. 23. 24. 70. 79. 77. ?0.
?6-?7. 00?. 018. 014. 016. 017. 080.
084. 099. 094. 040. 062. 06?-021. 0?0.
0?2. 138. 139. 13?. 101. 193. 197-141.
149-163. 12?. 173. 179. 174
Qusse-K`p`jdsd R`r 0?8
X@OBEJ 112
Xt* Neuos 72. 19?
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 292/455
1?1 YGD IQ@BEJ XYOQX
X`j Iodbe 68. 69. 106
X`j Fr`jhoshe 084. 160
Xtewjw 096-048. 044. 046
Xhgw`rtz. Aruje ?3. ?0. 033. 143
Xg`jbg`o 01. 02-16. 1?-88. 97. 48. 46.
42. 4?-69. 66-67. 20. 21. 22. 71. 78.
74. ?8-?4. ?2. ?7. 033-031. 039-036.
03?. 001. 006. 00?. 016. 017. 080.
081. 089. 084. 08?. 093. 091-092. 048.
042. 063. 068. 066. 062. 06?. 023. 021.
026. 027-073. 071. 074. 072-0?3. 0?1.
0?9. 137. 101. 108. 104-102. 10?-118.
114-112. 183. 180. 188-184. 182. 187.
19?. 143. 142. 14?. 160. 169. 124-12?.
170-179
Xg`jbg`o Hnua 11
Xg`jbg`o N`aer Tjoej Herps 049
Xg`jbg`o Yomds 02?. 180
Xg`jg`olw`j 0?8. 0?9. 0?6
Xg`jso 032. 000. 0?0. 0?9. 132. 181.
122
Xg`jtujb 12. 17. 20. 78. 038. 032. 000-
008. 081. 042. 079. 077. 07?. 0?0. 0??.
122. 12?. 173. 171
Xg`ew`jbmo`e082
Xgdd`j. Vojhdjt 083
Xgdjso 78. 018. 092. 068. 066
Xgojteosm 029
Xo`m 06
Xoadro` 11. 66. ?6. 003. 018. 01?. 066.
13?. 196. 19?. 143. 149. 146-147. 179
Xojbt`j 07?
Xojlo`jb 101
Xmotg. Nodut-Hemm* Qey H 1?. 83.
61
Xmotg. A M* 21. 28Xmotg. Mrs A. M* 21
Xehejy Geusd 24
Xeehgew 073-071. 170
Xeehgew Tjovdrsoty 073. 071
Xeejb Iyj`sty 042
Xeejb. Mdo-nmb 086. 042. 198. 170
Xeejb. Y* V*-087. 08?. 090. 042. 06?.
102. 107
Xeutgdrj @rmy 0?. 10. 12. 1?. 9?. 21.
24. 076. 07?. 0?8. 0?9. 110
Xeutgdrj Srdsaytdro`j Mossoej 02?
Xeutg M`jhguro` Q`onw`y 0?1. 0?2.
168. 12?
Xpddrs. Ir* K`mds M* 94. 96
Xt`ji`ri Eon Hemp`jy 1?. 89. 87. 99.
96. 9?. 21. 28. 2?. ?3. 034. 0?3. 160
178
Xt`uid. Nodut Adj 1?. 83
Xtdvdjs. Gdradrt 112
Xtomsej. Hen* Gdjry N* 021. 10?. 113.
19?. 168
Xtomsej. Mrs Gdjry N 10?
Xtretgdr. Qdv* D* D 02?
Xuoyu`j 122
Xuj Hgu`j-f`jb. M`rsg`n 28. 78. 092.
0?6. 0??
Xuj Fe-107. 189. 184. 182. 191. 198.
194
Xuj _`t-sdj. Ir 42. 47. 2?. 71. ?2.
003. 000. 019. 014. 088. 093. 094. 092.
043-041. 046. 132. 137. 18?-199. 197.
12?
Xuj V`t-sdj. Mmh 042. 191. 198
Xuydtsubu. Jeaum`s` 171
Xwdidj. Xwdiosg 011. 142
Xyr`husd Tjovdrsoty 10?
Xzdhgu`j 092. 079. 100. 112. 117. 183.
170
Y@OSOJB Qdadnnoej 42. 070
Y`ow`j 12?
Y`j`l`. A`rej 0?8. 131
Y`jblu 0?3
Y`jb Xgdj-tsd.Bdj
71. 014.027
Y`eost 029
Y`rt`r 00. 162. 121
Y`ss @bdjhy 140
Y`yner. @* @ 87
Yhjb _dj-t`g. Bdj* 71. 74
Ydjjdssdd 073
Ydrr`jev`. Fr`jhos 44. 46
Ygem`s. Ir 084. 086
Yoadt 06. 66. 018. 13?-100. 112. 170
Yodjtsoj 98. 69. 67. 21. 076-0?1. 0?9.
0?6. 0??. 138-132. 181. 193. 194. 131.
120. 121. 129. 170
Yojb Yu`j-s`oe 000
Yelye 09. 000. 007. 00?. 081. 0?1-
0?9. 0?7. 133. 131. 180. 143. 140. 168.
129-126. 127-173. 171-174
Yrojoi`i ?9
Ysoj`j 093
Ysojbt`e 07?. 12?. 173. 171
Yujbhaew 0?9
Yurldy 06. 61. 113. 110. 119
Ywdjty-ejd Idm`jis- 12?. 178
TJOYDI Srdss-07. 0?. 66. 143. 147.
169
Tjotdi Xt`tds 08. 0?. 10. 11. 14. 12. 1?.
83. 88. 89. 41. 48. 44-63. 68. 24. 76.
72. ?3. ?9. ?6. ?7. ??. 030. 039. 010.
012. 096. 042. 023. 071-079. 072. 077.
0?3. 0?1. 0?8. 138. 139. 136. 137. 104.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 293/455
OJIDW 1?8
106. 10?. 116. 182. 187. 140. 166. 162.
121. 127. 12?. 171-179
V@YOH@J Hoty 074
V`utroj. Mojjod 86. 98. 99
Vdrjeu. H`pt* R`nn`hd 1?
Vorbojo` 064
Vn`iovestel 003. 19?-148. 144
R@LDFODNI. Ir* S`un 022
R`ld Osn`ji 183
R`nn`hd. Ir* Adjk`moj A 10?
R`j Hgo-gsojb 06?
R`jb Hgojb-wdo 018. 067
R`jb. Ir* H* Y 10?. 113. 111
R`jbg`o. Yrd`ty ef 46. 42
R`jb Yodj-pdo. Bdj* 009-006
R`ri. Hemm`jidr 6?
R`rs`w 163
R`sgojbtej. I* H* ??. 012. 017. 07?.
100. 10?. 113. 111. 182. 193. 168.
169. 12?. 179
R`tsej. Ronno`m 10?
vej Rdob`ji. L`rn 190
Rdo-G`o-Rdo 072
Rdnns.G* B* 141
Rdst Seojt 106. 10?
Rg`jbpee Qovdr 13. 11. 63
Rgotd. Qdv* Ir* Gubg R 02?
Rgotd Qusso`j 16. 92. 23
Ronno`ms. @imor`n H* X 110
Ronno`ms. Ir* K* D-81. 88. 84. 86. 98.
036
Ronno`ms. Qdv R`ntdr Q 94. 92
Reesujb 098. 169Rerni R`r ?6. ??. 008. 106. 110. 119.
193. 141. 146. 12?
Rertndy. H. A. 2?
Ru. Ir* H H* 039. 00?. 06?. 028. 111
Ruhg`jb 72
Rug`j-72. 011. 014. 016. 040. 0?9. 173
Rugu 67. 26-73. 011
Ru Sdo-fu. M`rsg`n 4?. 78. 004. 092
o
_@JB. Sref* _* H 071
_`jbtzd-lo`jb-Z13. 18. 12-81. 89. 42.
61. 64-67. 23-21. 29. 26-73. 78. 72-7?.
?1. ?7. 033-031. 034. 037. 00?. 010.
011. 080. 084. 09?. 022. 027. 072.
13?. 110. 118. 112. 183. 190. 191.
199-196. 169. 173. 170. 178
_djhgojb Tjovdrsoty 026. 196
_dj Gso-s`j. M`rsg`n 032. 000. 0?0.
0?9. 0??. 132. 181
_oy`jb 0?3
_eujb.Ir @rtgur Johgens 10?
_u`j Xgo-l`o 47
_uj No`jb 16?
_ujj`j~X9. 01?. 092. 100. 114. 112
_utodj 0?9
_u-y`e Qovdr 086. 082
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 294/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 295/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 296/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 297/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 298/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 299/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 300/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 301/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 302/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 303/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 304/455
@ XYTI_
GOXYEQ_
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 305/455
Ygd Qey`n Ojstotutd+ ef OrftXrj`toej`n sof`oj os`j t9toeftoG`& `ji jej-petotoh`n aeiy. feujidi ojrpZe*%x5 tf&dptdr`bd `ji f`honot`td tgd shodjtofohstuiy ef ojtdrj`toej`n qudstoejs+
Ygd Ojstotutd. us suhg. ts prdhnuidi ay +%
rundsfrem dsdprhssotqr foj epojoej ej >my `spdht efojtdrj`toej`n `ff`ors< epojoej5 dxprdssdi oj tgosgeel `rd. tgdrdferd. purdny
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 306/455
@ XYTIf 6F
GOXY EQ _A_
@QJENI K* YE_JADDIordhter ef Xtuiods oj tgd Qey`n Ojstotutd
ef Ojtdrj`toej`n @ff`ors
Qdsd`rhg Srefdsser ef Ojtdrj`toej`n Gosteryoj tgd Tjovdrsoty ef Nejiej
'aetg ej tgd Xor I`jodn Xtdvdjsej Feuji`toej/
"Rerl * * * wgond ot os i`y * * *"
KEGJ ox* 9
+ Jex ruot. @djh` * * *
"
@DJDOI VO. 48?
+
Ygeubgt sg`nn ad tgd g`ridr.
Gd`rt tgd lddjdr.
Meei sg`nn ad tgd merd.@s eur mobgt ndssdjs*"
YGD N@_ EF YGD A@YYND EF M@NIEJ
VENTMD OO
EWFEQI TJOVDQXOY_ SQDXX
NEJIEJ ; GTMSGQD_ MONFEQIOssudi ujidr tgd `uspohds ef tgd Qey`n Ojstotutd
ef Ojtdrj`toej`n @ff`ors
+?89
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 307/455
; EWFEQI
TJOVDQXOY_ SQDXX@MLJ GETXD. L*HY 9
O-ejhoej Limaurtfg Bn`sbewNdopzob Jdw _erl Yerejte
Mdnaeurjd H`pdtewj noema`yH`nhutt` M`ir`s Xg`jbg`o
GTMSGQD_ MONLELISTINOXWOFT YE YGL
TJOVK LXOY_
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 308/455
HEJYDJYX
VENTMD OO
OO* I* YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD * o
O* W`^drri ri Le@` **** o
Ygd Qdturj ef J`turd **** o
Oj Hdjtr`n @mdroh` * * 8
Oj Hdynej *** *** 4
Oj tgd Jertg @r`ao`j Idsdrt * -?Ej D`stdr Osn`ji
*****01
Oj Jdw Djbn`ji
*****04
Ej tgd Qem`j H`mp`bj` * * * . * *06Sdrfoi` H`pu` * * * * * * *07Ygd Ydmpt`toejs ef Eiyssdus * * * *11Ygd Fndsg Sets ef Dbypt * * * * * 19
Ygd Ie`syeunolds * * * * * * *14OO* ROD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX * * * 80
@ Sn`j ef Epdr`toejs * * * * * 80
Ygd _dnnew Qovdr `ji tgd _`jbtsd * * * * 80
Hgomu `ji V`np`r`ose * * * * * -88Newn`jis `ji Gobgn`jis oj Bu`tdm`n` * * * 89
Ygd @dbd`j He`sts `ji tgdor Hejtojdjt`n Gojtdrn`jis * -86@ttoh` `ji Aedeto` * * + * * -82Hg`nhoiohX `ji Aedeto` * * * * * *91Ayz`jtoum `ji H`nhgdiej * * -98@dboj` `ji @rbes * * * * * *97Osr`dnotds. Sgedjoho`js. `ji Sgonostojds * * * - 9?
Nda`jej `ji K`a`n @js`roy`g * * -44Ar`jidjaurb `ji tgd Qgojdn`ji
* * *
-42@ustro` `ji Nema`riy * 47
+Ygd An`hl Heujtry" `ji "Ygd Gemd Heujtods" * * 63
Ygd Xtrubbnd fer Jertg @mdroh` * * * * -64
OG* YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI * * - - -28Ygd Ydstomejy ef Sgonesepgy. Mytgeneby. `ji Qdnoboej * 28
Ygd Ydstomejy ef tgd "Qdn`tdi+ Hovonoz`toejs * * -29Ygd Xpdho`n Xtomunus ef Mobr`toej Evdrsd`s * * *79
OV* YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX * . * - - * OEE
V* YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX * - - *001
"M`rhgds" `ji "Ojtdroers0
* * * - *-001
Oj tgd Dbypto`h Rerni * * "* * * *001
Oj tgd Xojoh Rerni * * * * X
Oj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni * * - *00?Oj tgd Gojiu Rerni * * * * * x2Oj tgd Xumdroh `ji A`aynejoh Rernis * * * +88
Oj tgd Xyro`h Rerni * * * * * - +82
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 309/455
vo HEJYDJYXOj tgd Or`joh Rerni evdr `b`ojst Dur`so` * 099
Oj tgd Or`joh Rerni evdr `b`ojst Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem 0 43
Oj Qusso`j Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem * * * * 049
Oj K`p`j
***** 047
Oj tgd Moje`j `ji Gdnndjoh Rernis * * 04?
Oj tgd Rdstdrj Rerni evdr `b`ojst tgd Hejtojdjt`n Durepd`jA`ra`ro`js * * * 066
Oj tgd Rdstdrj Rerni evdr `b`ojst Mushevy * * * 029
Oj tgd Rdstdrj Rerni evdr `b`ojst tgd Ettem`j Dmpord . 022
Oj tgd Rdstdrj Rerni evdr `b`ojst tgd F`r Rdstdrj Hgrostdjiem o be
Oj tgd Rdstdrj Rerni evdr `b`ojst Xh`jioj`vo` * * +?9
Oj tgd Rdstdrj Rerni evdr `b`ojst tgd Xyro`d Rerni oj tgd Oghj`j
Sdjojsun` ***** 131
Oj tgd @jid`j `ji Hdjtr`n @mdroh`j Rernis * * 136
VO* YGD XYOMTNTX EF SDJ@NO[@YOEJX
*****1e7
Ygd J`turd ef tgd Xtomunus * * * * *137
Mobr`toej * . * * * * * *101
Xn`vdry ****** * 108
H`std ******** 106
Qdnoboeus Ioshromoj`toej ****** 113
Ygd Sg`j`roets . * * * * v 111
YgdP`zfojnos * * * * * * *117Ygd Ndv`jtojds
*******183
Ygd Kdws. S`rsdds. Jdstej`js. Mejepgysotds. `ji Mejeogdnhtds * 189
Ygd @sgldj`zom. Xhpg`riom. Itfjmd. `ji Mjrr`jes * 193
J`aeas `ji X`goas ****** 197
Dm`jhop`tdi Jejhejfermosts ***** 143
Dm`jhop`tdi Q`"nydg * * * . * *140@ssomon`toejosts `ji [oejosts * * * * *141Osm`"onos `ji Om`mns * * * * * *149Fessons oj F`stjdssds * * * * . -144
VOO* YOOD BENIDJ MD@J * * * * + 14?
Ygd N`w ef Hempdjs`toejs * * * * 14?
Gew os ` Hg`nndjbd prevdi Dxhdssovd 5 * * 129
Hemp`rosejs oj Ygrdd Ydrms * * * * *133Jerw`y Ohdn`ji Brddjn`ji * * * . 1?0
Ioxod M`ss`hgusdtts M`ojd * * * * * 1?8
Ar`zon N` Sn`t` S`t`bejo` ***** 1?6
Ygd S`hofoh Xd`ae`ri ef Xeutg @mdroh` * . . * 1?2
Vety`ls M`by`rs N`pps * + * * * 833
Qd`htoejs te Hg`jbds ef Hnom`td * . * . . 83+
Xhetn`ji Tnstdr @pp`n`hgo` * * * * . 83?Qd`htoejs te tgd Q`v`bds ef R`r * * * * . 808
Hgojdsd Qd`htoejs te tgd Hg`nndjbd ef Dmobr`toej * . * 8x4
Xn`vs @hg`d`js Ydutejs Hdnts * * * * 804
Ygd @aertovd F`r Rdstdrj Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej * * + 811
Ygd @aertovd Xh`jioj`vo`j Hovonoz`toej * * . *893Ygd Omp`ht ef Osn`m upej tgd Hgrostdjiems . * * 863
Ygd @aertovd F`r D`stdrj Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej * * + 86?
Mosh`rro`bds `ji Aortgs ef Hovonoz`toejs oj Xyro` * * -8Z4
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 310/455
HEJYDJYX voo
OO* I onn @jjdx; Os "Eni Breuji+ ndss fdrtond tg`j "Jdw Breuji"
Ojtrojsoh`nny er ay @hhoidjt5 * * * 8?4
v @jjdx; Gosteroh Xodbds `ji tgdor @ftdr-dffdhts * * 933
vo @jjdx< Kdws oj F`stjdssds
*****931
vj @jjdx O; Ir* Dnnswertg Gujtojbtej"s @ppnoh`toej ef gos
Hgm`td-`ji-Hovogz`toej Ygdery te tgd Gosterods
ef tgd M`y`j `ji _uh`tdh Hovonoz`toejs oj Hdjtr`n
@mdroh`. `ji te tgd Gostery ef tgd Xyj`h Hovonoz`-
toej oj tgd E`sds ef tgd Jertg @r`ao`j Xtdppd * 908
@jjdx OO; Ygd Ygrdd-Herjdrdi Qdn`toej adtwddj tgd Qem`j
Hgurhg. Djbn`ji. `ji Ordn`ji * * *910
@jjdx OOO; Ygd Dxtojhtoej ef tgd F`r Rdstdrj Hgrosto`j Hunturd
oj Ordn`ji
******919
@jjdx OV; Ygd Ferfdotdi Aortgrobgt ef tgd @aertovd F`r Rdstdrj
Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej **** 912
@jjdx V; Ygd Qdsdman`jhd adtwddj tgd @aertovd Xh`jioj`vo`j
Hovonoz`toej `ji tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej * * 989
@jjdx VO; Ygd Ferfdotdi Aortgrobgt ef tgd @aertovd Xh`jioj`vo`j
Hovonoz`toej * * * * *987
@jjdx VOO; Ygd Nest Eppertujotods ef tgd Xh`jioj`vo`js `ji tgd
"Esm`jnos
******999
@jjdx VOOO; Ygd Ferfdotdi Aortgrobgt ef tgd @aertovd F`r D`stdrj
Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej + 996
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 311/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 312/455
I* YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
O* W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@
Ygd Qdturj ef J`turd
RDg`vd jew stuiodi tgd `htoej ef Hg`nndjbd-`ji-Qdspejsd
`ji g`vd `ttdmptdi te survdy tgd rend wgohg hg`nndjbds `ji
rdspejsds g`vd pn`ydi oj tgd bdjdsds ef hovonoz`toejs* Oj dma`rlojb
upej tgos survdy. wd g`vd ompnohotny rdkdhtdi tgd vodw tg`t hovonoz`-
toejs `rd `pt te ad bdjdr`tdi oj djvorejmdjts pgysoh`n er gum`j
wgohg effdr ujusu`nny d`sy hejiotoejs ef nofd te M`j* Ygos vodw
os pepun`rny gdni. er `t `jy r`td woidny `ordi. oj tgd meidrj
Rdstdrj Rerni. tgeubg ot os hejtr`iohtdi ay tgd tgdery ef eur
meidrj Rdstdrj Sgysoh`n Xhodjhd `s wdnn `s ay tgd iddpdr ojtuotoej
ef M`jloji wgohg g`s feuji dxprdssoej oj tgd Mytgeneby efv`roeus
sehodtods oj v`roeus `bds*0 Oj tgd heursd ef tgd survdy wgohg wd
g`vd kust hejhnuidi. wd g`vd objerdi tgos f`nsd vodw< aut wd m`yfoji tg`t. adsoids ompnohotny rdkdhtojb ot. wd g`vd `nse ojiordhtny
rdfutdi ot ay dxpesojb tgd f`nn`hy ej wgohg ot os feujidi*
Ygos f`nn`hy sprojbs frem ` f`onurd te hejhdovd tgd bdjdsos ef `
hovonoz`toej `s "`j `ht ef hrd`toej
ojvenvojb
`prehdss
ef
hg`jbd
oj
Yomd* Ygd foj`n `ppd`r`jhd ef tgd shdjd. `s ot neels wgdj tgd
ir`m` ef bdjdsos g`s addj pn`ydi te tgd fojosg. os tgeubgtndssny
dqu`tdi wotg tgd promotovd `ppd`r`jhd ef tgd s`md shdjd oj tgd
prdgosteroh `bd adferd tgd sotd w`s t`ldj oj g`ji ay M`j te sdrvd
`s tgd st`bd fer ` brd`t gum`j `htoej* Fer dx`mpnd.
"wd `rd `hhustemdi te rdb`ri Dbypt `s ` p`r`iosd. `s tgd mest fdrtond
heujtry oj tgd Rerni. wgdrd. of wd aut shr`thg tgd seon `ji sh`ttdr sddi.
wd g`vd ejny te `w`ot `ji b`tgdr tgd g`rvdst* Ygd Brddls speld ef
Dbypt `s tgd mest fot pn`hd fer tgd forst bdjdr`toejs ef mdj. fer tgdrd.
tgdy s`oi. feei w`s `nw`ys rd`iy `t g`ji. `ji ot teel je n`aeur te sdhurd
`j `auji`jt suppny* +^
Ygd f`nn`hy ef tgos vodw os peojtdi eut ay tgd iostojbuosgdi `rhg`de-
nebost wge g`s fermun`tdi ot oj tgdsd sdjtdjhds oj eridr te rdfutd ot*
Gos rdfut`toej os prdsdjtdi oj tgd n`ttdr p`rt ef ` p`ss`bd wgohg g`s
`nrd`iyaddj
quetdi.oj tgd
prdhdiojb hg`ptdr
ef tgos
Xtuiy.
`t
brd`tdr ndjbtg*
"Ygdrd h`j ad je ieuat". gd beds ej te s`y. "tg`t tgd Dbypt ef te-i`y
os ` vdry ioffdrdjt pn`hd frem tgd Dbypt ef prd-`brohuntur`ntomds* * * *
+ Fer tgos hejtr`ry shodjtofoh `ji mytgeneboh`n Rdnt`jshg`uujbZ sdd `aevd. ON H 'u/ 'a/
o. ven* o. p`ssom.+Jdwadrry. ep. hot* oj OO* H 'oo/ 'a/ 1. `aevd. ven*
o. p* 836*
OO A
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 313/455
1 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Ygd `brohuntur`n Dbypt ef meidrj tomds os `s muhg ` boft ef M`j `s ot os
ef tgd Jond*"0
Oj f`ht. tgd f`nn`hoeus pepun`rvodw djtordny evdrneelstgd stupdjieus
gum`j dffert ojvenvdi. jet ejny oj ejhd tr`jsfermojb tgd prdgosteroh
kujbnd-sw`mp ef tgd Newdr Jond V`nndy ojte tgd gosteroh`n N`ji ef
Dbypt. aut `nse oj pdrpdtu`nny prdvdjtojb tgos m`bjofohdjt aut
prdh`roeus werl ef mdj"s g`jis frem rdvdrtojb te ots promdv`n
st`td ef J`turd.
Rg`t tgos st`td ef J`turd w`s. wd g`vd ojioh`tdi. oj tgd twe
ojst`jhds ef tgd N`ji ef Dbypt `ji tgd N`ji ef Xgoj`r. ay hotojb1
forst-g`ji idshroptoejs ef tgd prdsdjt st`td ef hdrt`oj etgdr sdhtoejs
ef tgd Jond V`nndy `ji tgd Yobros-Dupgr`tds V`nndy wgohg g`vdrdm`ojdi. iewj te tgos i`y. oj tgd promotovd hejiotoej eut ef wgohg
Dbypt w`s hejkurdi up oj tgd Newdr Jond V`nndy ay tgd f`tgdrs ef
tgd Dbypto`h Hovonoz`toej `ji Xgoj`r ay tgd f`tgdrs ef tgd Xumdroh
Hovonoz`toej oj wg`t usdi te ad tgd Newdr Yobros-Dupgr`tds V`nndy
adferd tgd prdsdjt prevojhds ef A`sr`g `jif
@r`aost`j wdrd auont
eut ojte tgd Sdrso`j Bunf ay tgd prebrdssovd idpesot ef `nnuvoum
iurojb tgd n`st fovd er sox tgeus`ji yd`rs* Ygd prdsdjt st`td ef tgd
A`gr-`n-K`a`n sdhtoej ef tgd Jond V`nndy8 `ji ef tgd "@m`r`g-
J`soroy`g-A`sr`g tro`jbnd oj tgd Yobros-Dupgr`tds V`nndy9tdstofods
te tgd fd`t wgohg w`s pdrfermdi ay tgd poejddrs wge. semd fovd er
sox tgeus`ji yd`rs `be. suhhddidi oj tr`jsfermojb somon`r tr`hts ef
ojgespot`and kujbnd-sw`mp. eut ef `nn rdhebjotoej. ojte `j eridrdi
jdtwerl ef iylds `ji fodnis. wgdrd seon `ji w`tdr `rh suakdht te
gum`j hejtren fer tgd sdrvohd ef gum`j purpesds* Ygd vodw tg`t
hovonoz`toejs `rd adbettdj oj djvorejmdjts wgdrd tgd hejiotoejs `rd
ujusu`nny d`sy os hnd`rny sgewj te ad ujtdj`and wgdj wd hemp`rdtgesd gewnojb wonidrjdssds. wgohg rdpreiuhd. oj tgdor vorboj st`td
te-i`y. tgd promdv`n st`td ef Dbypt `ji Xgoj`r. wotg tgd `htu`n
st`td ef Dbypt `ji Xgoj`r `s wd sdd ot te-i`y soid ay soid wotg
tgd A`gr-`n-K`a`n `ji wotg tgd sw`mps oj wgohg tgd Yobros `ji
Dupgr`tds nesd tgdmsdnvds adnew "@m`r`g `ji J`soroy`g* @t tgd
s`md tomd. kust adh`usd tgd werls ef M`j wgohg g`vd dff`hdi tgd
promdv`n st`td ef J`turd oj tgd Newdr Jond V`nndy `ji oj tgd Newdr
Yobros-Dupgr`tds V`nndy `rd stonn "beojb hejhdrjs". wd h`jjet
easdrvd tgd promdv`n st`td ef J`turd gdrd iordhtny* Rd g`vd te adhejtdjt wotg tgd rdfndhtoejs ef ot wgohg wd h`j ioshdrj oj tgd
w`tdry morrers ef tgd A`gr-`n-K`a`n `ji tgdh
@m`r`g~J`soroy`g~A`sr`g tro`jbnd <
`ji tgeubg tgd shodjtofoh stuidjt m`y fddn mer`nny
+Jdwadrry. ep* hot*. quetdi oj ven* o. pp* 836 `ji 837. `aevd* Fer tgd hdndar`tdi
`pgerosm ef Gdreietus. te wgohg Srefdsser Jdwadrry t`lds dxhdptoej oj tgd sdhejisdjtdjhd gdrd
quetdi. sdd feetjetd 1 ej p* 141 oj OO* H'oo/ '`/ 1. oj ven* o. `aevd.
z Oj OO* H 'u/ '6/ 1. ven* o. pp* 83?-01 `ji 806-07. `aevd*8 Xdd ven* k. pp* 83?-01. `aevd* 9 Xdd ven*
o. pp* 806-07. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 314/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@ 8
hdrt`oj. oj gos ewj moji. tg`t tgdsd survovojb rdfndhtoejs bovd ` f`or
pohturd ef tgd nejb-eanotdr`tdi eroboj`ns. gd must ad prdp`rdi te
foji tgd n`ym`j idhn`rojb. nold ieuatojb Ygem`s. tg`t ejny iordht
easdrv`toej wonn hejvojhd gom*
@rd tgdrd tgd`trds ef hovonoz`toej. etgdr tg`j Dbypt `ji Xgoj`r.wgohg h`j prevoid tgd n`ym`j wotg tgd iordht dvoidjhd wgohg gdidm`jis `ji wgohg Dbypt `ji Xgoj`r h`jjet bovd gom 5 _ds. tgdrd
`rd. fer tgd gum`j fd`t ef m`ojt`ojojb Dbypt `ji Xgoj`r `s "beojbhejhdrjs" ` fd`t ejny ndss rdm`rl`and tg`j tgd eroboj`n fd`t ef
hrd`tojb tgdm os semdtgojb dxhdptoej`n* Oj bdjdr`n ot os trud tg`t
"j`tur`m dxphnn`s furh`. t`mdj usqud rdhurrdt"*0 @t v`roeus tomds
`ji pn`hds. rdh`nhotr`jt J`turd. ejhd areldj oj ay gum`j gdreosm.g`s areldj neesd `b`oj adh`usd n`tdr bdjdr`toejs g`vd hd`sdi fer
semd rd`sej te lddp up tgd hejst`jt dxdrtoejs rdquordi ef tgdm oj
eridr te m`ojt`oj tgd m`stdry wgohg g`i addj wej fer tgdm `ji
tr`jsmottdi te tgdm ay tgd poejddrs* Oj suhg h`sds ef rdvdrsoej.
tgd promdv`n st`td ef J`turd. `s ot w`s adferd M`j dvdr teel ot oj
g`ji. h`j ad sddj te-i`y jet mdrdny oj tgd morrer ef semd somon`r
podhd ef J`turd wgohg g`s g`ppdjdi te rdm`oj oj ots vorboj st`td
aut ay iordht easdrv`toej ej tgd vdry spet wgohg g`s tdmper`rony
addj tgd shdjd ef ` sobj`n gum`j `hgodvdmdjt* Xuhg spdht`hnds. oj
wgohg tgd promdv`n st`td ef J`turd `ji tgd suasdqudjt werls ef
M`j `ji tgd dvdjtu`n rdvdrsoej ef J`turd te gdr promdv`n st`td
`rd `nn iospn`ydi tebdtgdr ej ejd spet nold bdeneboh`n str`t`. `rd
hdrt`ojny merd strolojb. `s vosu`n idmejstr`toejs. tg`j tgd spdht`hnd
strolojb tgeubg tgos os ef tgd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd prdsdjt st`td
ef Dbypt `ji tgd prdsdjt st`td ef tgd A`gr-`n-K`a`n. oj wgohg tgd
twe eakdhts tg`t g`vd te ad areubgt ojte somunt`jdeus fehus nod
` tgeus`ji monds `p`rt* Rgdrd J`turd g`s `htu`nny rd`ssdrtdi gdr`shdji`jhy evdr semd spet tg`t g`s ejhd addj tgd aortg-pn`hd ef `
hovonoz`toej er tgd shdjd ef semd etgdr sobj`n gum`j `hgodvdmdjt.
ot os ompessoand te adgeni J`turd fn`ujtojb gdr untom`td troumpgevdr tgdsd werls ef M`j `ji stonn te ieuat tg`t gdrd. `t `jy r`td.
tgd hejiotoejs oj wgohg tgesd gum`j werls wdrd pdrfermdi wdrd
jet ujusu`nny d`sy aut ujusu`nny ioffohunt* Rd wonn tgdrdferd try-
te hnojhg eur `rbumdjt ay p`ssojb ` fdw ojst`jhds efsuhg rdvdrsoejs
ujidr rdvodw*
Oj Hdjtr`n @mdroh`
Ejd rdm`rl`and ojst`jhd os tgd prdsdjt st`td ef tgd aortg-pn`hd ef
tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej* F`r ioffdrdjt frem tgd iylds `ji fodnis ef
Dbypt `ji Xgoj`r. wgohg `rd stonn adojb ldpt oj eridr ay M`j `ji
+Ger`hd. Dpostnds. Aeel O. Dp* x. 0* 19*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 315/455
9 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
stonn iuny sdrvojb gos purpesd oj yodniojb gom ` novdnogeei. tgd
werls ef tgd M`y`s `rd je nejbdr "beojb hejhdrjs" te-i`y* Ygdor
send survovojb mejumdjts `rd tgd ruojs ef tgd ommdjsd `ji
m`bjofohdjtny idher`tdi puanoh auoniojbs wgohg jew st`ji. f`r`w`yfrem `jy prdsdjt gum`j g`aot`toejs. oj tgd idptgs ef tgd trepoh`n
ferdst* Ygd ferdst. nold semd synv`j ae`-hejstrohter. g`s notdr`nny
sw`nnewdi tgdm up. `ji jew ot os iosmdmadrojb tgdm `t ots
ndosurd; prosojb tgdor fojd-gdwj. hnesd-n`oi stejds `p`rt wotg ots
wrotgojb reets `ji tdjirons* Ygd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd prdsdjt
`spdht ef tgd heujtry `ji tgd `spdht wgohg ot must g`vd werj wgdj
tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej w`s oj adojb os se brd`t tg`t ot os `nmest
adyeji om`boj`toej*
0 Ygdrd must g`vd addj ` tomd wgdj tgdsd
ommdjsd puanoh auoniojbs steei oj tgd gd`rt ef n`rbd `ji pepuneus
hotods. `ji wgdj tgesd hotods n`y oj tgd moist ef v`st strdthgds ef
huntov`tdi n`ji wgohg furjosgdi tgdm wotg tgdor feei-suppnods*
Ygd m`stdrpodhds ef M`y`j `rhgotdhturd wgohg `rd jew adojb
str`jbndi ay tgd ferdst must g`vd addj auont `s werls ef supdr-
dreb`toej wotg tgd surpnus ef `j djdrby wgohg. fer nd`buds `reuji.
g`i `nrd`iy tr`jsfermdi tgd ferdst ojte fruotfun fodnis* Ygdy wdrd
trepgods ef M`j"s vohtery evdr J`turd< `ji. `t tgd memdjt wgdj
tgdy wdrd r`osdi. tgd rdtrd`tojb frojbd ef tgd v`jquosgdi `ji reutdi
synv`j djdmy w`s pdrg`ps a`rdny vosoand ej tgd gerozej. dvdj frem
tgd gobgdst pn`tferms ef tgd p`n`hds er frem tgd summots ef tgd
tdmpnd-pyr`mois* Ye tgd gum`j adojbs wge neeldi eut evdr tgd
Rerni frem tgesd v`jt`bd-peojts tgdj. tgd vohtery ef M`j evdr
J`turd must g`vd sddmdi uttdrny sdhurd<`ji tgd tr`jsoterojhss ef
gum`j `hgodvdmdjts `ji tgd v`joty efgum`jwosgds `rd peobj`jtny
dxpesdi ay tgd untom`td rdturj ef tgd ferdst. djbunfojb forst tgd
fodnis `ji tgdj tgd geusds. `ji foj`nny tgd p`n`hds `ji tgd tdmpndstgdmsdnvds* _dt tg`t os jet tgd mest sobjofoh`jt er dvdj tgd mest
eavoeus ndssej te ad nd`rjt frem tgd prdsdjt st`td ef Hep`j er
Yol`n er S`ndjqud* Ygd ruojs spd`l stonn merd dnequdjtny ef tgd
ojtdjsoty ef tgd strubbnd wotg tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt wgohg tgd
hrd`ters ef tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej must g`vd w`bdi vohteroeusny oj
tgdor i`y* Oj gdr vdry rdvdjbd. wgohg rdvd`ns gdr oj `nn gdr brud-semd pewdr. Yrepoh`n J`turd tdstofods ujwonnojbny te tgd heur`bd
`ji tgd vobeur eftgd mdj wge ejhd. of ejny fer ` sd`sej. suhhddidioj puttojb gdr te
fnobgt `ji lddpojb gdr `t a`y*+
Mr. Quiy`ri Lopnojb oj gos idshroptoej ef "tgd Heni N`ors" ; ` fohtotoeus Gojiu hoty wgohgtgd Ojio`j Kujbnd g`s sw`nnewdi up* 'Qd`i tgd stery h`nndi "L``"s Gujtojb+ oj YgdKujbnd Aeel*/
+
.Sr- Dnnswertg Gujtojbtej subbdsts tg`t tgd J`turd wgem tgd f`tgdrs ef tgd M`y`j
Hovonoz`toej ejhd put te fnobgt w`s ` ioffdrdjt '`ji ndss fermoi`and/ `jt`bejost frem tgdJ`turd wge g`s sojhd bet tgd adttdr ef tgdsd mdj"s idshdji`jts oj tgd sdnfs`md rdboej.Fer Ir* Gujtojbtej"s gypetgdsos ef ` pdroeioh sgoftojb ef hnom`toh zejds. sdd OO* I 'voo/.@jjdx o. adnew+
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 316/455
W@@DOO@ Y@ L@@@4
Oj Hdynej
Rotg tgd s`md iuma dnequdjhd. tgd hrddpdr-hevdrdi ruojs ef
@jbler R`t tdstofy te tgd prewdss ef tgd mdj wge ejhd prep`b`tdi
tgd Gojiu Hovonoz`toej ej seon hejqudrdi frem tgd trepoh`n ferdst ef
H`maeio`< `ji tgd dqu`nny `riueus fd`t ef hejqudrojb tgd p`rhgdi
pn`ojs ef Hdynej fer `brohunturd os hemmdmer`tdi oj tgd ard`hgdi
aujis `ji evdrbrewj fneers ef tgd t`jls wgohg wdrd ejhd hej-
struhtdi ej tgd wdt soid ef tgd gonn-heujtry. ej ` heness`n sh`nd. aytgd Xojg`ndsd hejvdrts te tgd Ojiod rdnoboej ef tgd Goj`y`j`*
+Ye rd`nosd gew suhg t`jls h`md ojte adojb ejd must ljew semdtgojbef tgd gostery ef N`jl`* Ygd oid` ujidrnyojb tgd systdm w`s sompnd aut
vdry brd`t* Ot w`s ojtdjidi ay tgd t`jl-auoniojb lojbs tg`t jejd ef tgdr`oj wgohg fdnn oj suhg `auji`jhd oj tgd meujt`ojs sgeuni rd`hg tgd
sd` wotgeut p`yojb troautd te M`j ej tgd w`y*"Oj tgd moiind ef tgd seutgdrj g`nf ef Hdynej os ` woid meujt`oj
ssejd. aut te tgd d`st `ji jertg iry pn`ojs hevdr tgeus`jis ef squ`rd
monds. `ji `t prdsdjt `rd vdry sp`rsdny pepun`tdi* Oj tgd gdobgt ef tgd
mejseej. wgdj `rmods ef sterm-swdpt hneuis rusg ej i`y `ftdr i`y te
m`thg tgdor strdjbtg `b`ojst tgd gonns. tgdrd os ` nojd ir`wj ay J`turd
tg`t tgd r`ojs `rd uj`and te p`ss* * . * Ygdrd `rd peojts wgdrd tgd nojd ef
idm`rh`toej ef tgd twe zejds. tgd wdt `ji tgd iry. os se j`rrew tg`twotgoj ` mond ejd sddms te p`ss ojte ` jdw heujtry< fer tgd wgend
hg`r`htdr ef tgd ferdst `ntdrs. `ji oj sozd `ji loji `ji iostroautoej tgd
trdds ioffdr hempndtdny frem tgesd ejd h`j stonn sdd adgoji ejd* Ygd woni
fnewdrs t`ld jdw ferms `ji heneurs< ioffdrdjt aoris sojb oj tgd ausgds<
huntov`toej hg`jbds `aruptny< `ji wd`ntg djis* Ygd nojd hurvds frem
sd` te sd` `ji `ppd`rs te ad st`and `ji uj`ffdhtdi ay tgd epdr`toejs ef
M`j. suhg `s fdnnojb ferdsts%0
_dt tgd mossoej`rods ef tgd Ojiod Hovonoz`toej oj Hdynej ejhd
`hgodvdi tgd teur idferhd ef hempdnnojb tgd mejseej-smottdj gobg-
n`jis wgdrd "r`oj peurs iewj `t ` gobgdr r`td fer tgd mejtg tg`j
tgd r`ojf`nn ef Nejiej fer tgd wgend ef ` vdry wdt yd`r"1
te bovd
w`tdr `ji nofd `ji wd`ntg te tgd pn`ojs wgohg J`turd g`i hej-
idmjdi te nod p`rhgdi `ji idsen`td*
"Gonn strd`ms wdrd t`ppdi `ji tgdor w`tdr buoidi ojte tgd bo`jt
ster`bd-t`jls adnew. semd ef tgdm feur tgeus`ji `hrds oj dxtdjt< `ji.
frem tgesd. hg`jjdns r`j ej te etgdr n`rbd t`jls f`rtgdr frem tgd gonns.
`ji frem tgdm te etgdrs stonn merd rdmetd* @ji adnew d`hg brd`t t`jl`ji d`hg brd`t hg`jjdn wdrd gujirdis ef nottnd t`jls. d`hg tgd juhndus
ef ` vonn`bd< `nn. oj tgd nejb-ruj. fdi frem tgd wdt meujt`oj-zejd* Xe
br`iu`nny tgd `jhodjt Xojg`ndsd hejqudrdi `nn. er jd`rny `nn. ef tgd
pn`ojs tg`t `rd jew se dmpty ef mdj*"8
Ygd `riueusjdss ef tgd n`aeur ef forst hejqudrojb `ji tgdj
+Xtonn. Kegj; Ygd Kujbnd Yoid 'Diojaurbg 0?83. An`hlweei/. pp* 29-)*
+Xtonn. ep* hot*. p* 29-
8 Xtonn: S- hnt - SS"
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 317/455
6 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
geniojb fer ` m`j-m`id hovonoz`toej tgdsd j`tur`nny a`rrdj `ji idse-
n`td pn`ojs os idmejstr`tdi ay tgd twe eutst`jiojb fd`turds oj tgd
n`jish`pd ef Hdynej `t tgd prdsdjt i`y* Ygd forst fd`turd os tgd
rdn`psd ef tg`t ejhd orrob`tdi `ji huntov`tdi `ji pepun`tdi heujtry-soid ojte ots promdv`n a`rrdjjdss `ji idsen`toej upej tgd stepp`bd
ef tgd hejtojueus gum`j dxdrtoejs wgohg g`i addj rdquordi oj
eridr te preiuhd `ji m`ojt`oj tgos mor`huneus tr`jsferm`toej ef
tgd f`hd ef J`turd*0 Ygd sdheji fd`turd os tgd `veoi`jhd ef tgdsd
idrdnoht pn`ojs. wgohg wdrd ejhd tgd sd`t ef ` hovonoz`toej. ay eur
meidrj Rdstdrj heffdd `ji td` `ji ruaadr pn`jtdrs wge g`vd
hemd te Hdynej te m`ld tgdor fertujds tgdrd oj tgdsd n`ttdr i`ys*
Ej tgd forst ef tgdsd twepeojts.
tgdfennewojb tdstomejy
os
aerjd ay tgd meidrj Rdstdrj dydwotjdss wgem wd g`vd quetdi
`nrd`iy;
+Ygd t`jl `bd djiurdi fer merd tg`j foftddj hdjturods. `ji tgdj tgd
kujbnd toid resd evdr ot `ji `nn sobjs er mdmery ef ot adh`md nest* *** Oj
tgd ferdst wgohg hevdrs tgd `jhodjt lojbiem. f`r frem tgd seujis efmdj.
ejd hemds upej tgd aujis ef t`jls. jew uttdrny ferbettdj. wgdrd tgd
a`jls g`vd bovdj w`y `ji tgd adis adhemd nold j`tur`n bn`ids fer iddr
te br`zd oj. ***
"O ljew \`] hoty * * * \wgohg] nods adnew tgd auji ef `j djermeus t`jlwgesd `rd` m`y wdnn g`vd addj tgeus`jis ef `hrds. fer tgd auji os monds
nejb* Aut jew tgd vdry j`md ef tgd t`jl os nest. fer tgd auji aurst
gujirdis ef yd`rs `be `ji ots adi os aut ` new-nyojb rdboej oj tgd
ujareldj ferdst. ` iddpdr `rd` `moi tgd sd` ef trdds* Ygd ejny j`md ot
jew ad`rs os ` Y`mon ejd md`jojb Y`jl ef tgd Brd`t Ard`hg* @t `
w`tdrgend oj ` rehl oj tgd adi ef tg`t t`jl O s`w ` ad`r steep `ji irojl.`ji ot w`s huroeus te tgojl gew gd seubgt fer tg`t sm`nn gend ef st`bj`jt
w`tdr. `s fer ` r`rd trd`surd. oj ` pn`hd tg`t fer m`jy hdjturods w`s `t
tgd aettem ef `j ojn`ji sd` wgdrd w`vds areld `ji pdnoh`js s`ondi ojfnddts* Merd tg`j `jytgojb dnsd. ot areubgt gemd te md mest vovoinygew arodf g`i addj tgd `bd ef t`jls oj tgd nejb gostery ef tgd kujbnd*Fer ` monnoej yd`rs `jom`ns ir`jl frem tg`t j`rrew gend< tgdj. fer `tgeus`ji yd`rs. tgd rehl. gend `ji `nn. w`s ujidrjd`tg tgd w`vds< `jijew tgd kujbnd irojls `b`oj wgdrd `jom`ns ir`jl wgdj M`j usdi stejd
`rrewgd`is. `ji adferd gd ojvdjtdi tgdm. `ji adferd J`turd ojvdjtdigom*"1
Ygd sdheji fd`turd oj tgd prdsdjt n`jish`pd ef Hdynej wgohg
idmejstr`tds tgd `riueusjdss ef tgd fd`t wgohg tgd `jhodjt+ Ygd h`usd eftgd ard`liewj ef tgd `jhodjt Xojg`ndsd orrob`toej systdm w`s `j ojhdftQ-
ZKYo -yZYZVY07 w` i+5
in4j mdrhdj`rods frem Xeutgdrj Ojio`* Ygdsd
mdrhdj`rods idnoadr`tdny hut tgd h`j`ns `ji ard`hgdi tgd aujis `s ` sgert hut te monot`ryidhosoejs< `ji dvdjtu`nny tgos wonn te idstrey evdrh`md tgd wonn te rdp`or* Ygdrdwotg tgdpn`ojs jet ejnywdjt;eut;ef huntov`toejtgreubgtgdstepp`bdef tgd w`tdr-suppny. aut gdyZse
adh`md get-adis ef m`n`ro` wgdj tgd rujjojb w`tdrs iwojindi ojte st`bj`jt peenjwgohg wdrd tee sg`nnew te g`raeur tgd fosg tg`t novd ay
ES- hot*. pp* 22 `ji 2? `ji 0 00-08*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 318/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@ 2
Xojg`ndsd auji-auonidrs tdmper`rony `hhempnosgdi os tgd `veoi`jhd
ef tgd idrdnoht pn`ojs ay eur meidrj Rdstdrj pn`jtdrs wge g`vd
ojtdrdstdi tgdmsdnvds oj Hdynej jet oj eridr te prep`b`td ` hovonoz`-
toej tgdrd aut oj eridr tebdt
rohgquohl*
"Ot os ` huroeus f`ht tg`t *** tgd aunl ef tgd pepun`toej `ji mest ef tgd
wd`ntg g`vd addj feuji ej tgd wdt soid ef tgd nojd iurojb tgd feur
hdjturods ef Durepd`j rund+ *** Ye m`ld mejdy. ejd st`ys `s ` rund ejtgd wdt soid. aut te sdd tgd ruojs ef tdmpnds er mej`stdrods. ef p`n`hds er
djbojddrojb werls. ejd must be te tgd iry soid ef tgd nojd*0
* * * Fer tgd
gonns wgdrd wd brew td` `ji ruaadr \tgd `jhodjt Xojg`ndsd] ioi jet h`rd*
Fdw `jhodjt rdm`ojs `rd te ad feuji `mejb tgdm. `ji tgd ferdsts wdfeuji tgdrd. `ji idstreydi. wdrd ef ommdjsd `bd `ji prea`any ef trud
vorboj brewtg* * * *
Must ejd ad r`jldi `s eppesdi te hovonoz`toej of ejdprdfdrs tgd iry `ji tgojny pepun`tdi soid ef tgd mejseej"s frejtodr te
tgd prespdreus `ji wdt ejd5 Yg`t os ` qudstoej O foji ot ompessoand te
`jswdr wotgeut forst sdttnojb wg`t tgd weri hovonoz`toej md`js*"1
Ygd orrdfut`and tdstomejy ef tgd rdturj ef J`turd os rdpd`tdidvdj wgdrd tgdrd `rd je stupdjieus ruojs te werl upej eur
om`boj`toej* Rd m`y pdrhdovd ot oj tgd n`st `bejods ef tgd peer
vonn`bd oj tgd kujbnd `s wotjdss tgd fennewojb p`ss`bd frem `
meidrj Rdstdrj werl ef fohtoej oj wgohg tgd shdjd ef `htoej os
noldwosd Hdynej;
+Ygh yd`rs g`i areubgt merd dvon. id`tg `ji idh`y upej tgd vonn`bd*
* * * Iosd`sd `ji gujbdr vosotdi ot yd`r `ftdr yd`r* Ot sddmdi. `s tgd
gd`im`j s`oi. te g`vd addj ferbettdj ay beis `ji mdj* _d`r `ftdr yd`r.
tgd r`ojs frem tgd jertg-d`st p`ssdi ot ay< ejny tgd suj ad`t iewj merd
potondssny. `ji tgd woji re`rdi evdr ot `hress tgdkujbnd <tgd nottnd p`thgds
ef hgdj` hrep wgohg tgd vonn`bdrs trodi te huntov`td wotgdrdi `s seej `s
tgd yeujb sgeets sgewdi `aevd tgd breuji* Je m`j. tr`vdnndr er
gd`im`j er tr`idr. dvdr h`md te tgd vonn`bd jew* Je ejd treuandi `jy
nejbdr te hnd`r tgd tr`hl wgohg ndi te ot<tgdkujbnd hevdrdi ot `ji hut tgd
vonn`bd eff* * * *
"Ygdy strubbndi g`ri `b`ojst tgd f`td tg`t gujb evdr tgdm. hnojbojb
te tgd pn`hd wgdrd tgdy g`i addj aerj `ji novdi. tgd hempeuji tgdy
ljdw. `ji tgd stdrond hgdj`s wgohg tgdy g`i sewj* Je hgonirdj wdrd
aerj te tgdm jew oj tgdor gut. tgdor wemdj wdrd `s stdrond `s tgd d`rtg <
tgd hgonirdj tg`t g`i addj aerj te tgdm iodi ef w`jt `ji fdvdr* @t n`st
+ Ygos bdebr`pgoh`n sdbrdb`toej ef tgd fodnis ef tgd `jhodjt ojiobdjeus `ji tgd meidrj
Durepd`j djtdrprosd oj Hdynej g`s ots `j`nebud oj Hdjtr`n @mdroh`. wgdrd tgd meidrjXp`josg henejosts g`vd somon`rny ldpt hnd`r ef tgd pn`ojs wgohg wdrd ejhd tgd sd`t ef
tgd M`y`j hunturd. `ji g`vd dst`anosgdi tgdmsdnvds oj tgd gobgn`jis wgohg wdrd ndft
ujehhupodi ay aetg tgd f`tgdrs `ji tgd hgonirdj ef tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej* 'Xdd
ON H 'oo/ '`/ 1. ven* o. p* 862. `aevd. `ji OO* I'u/. pp* 89-Z6. adnew*/ Oj tgos hejjdxoej.
ot os omm`tdro`n tg`t. oj hejtr`st te tgd hnom`toh hejiotoejs oj Hdynej. tgd Hdjtr`n
@mdroh`j pn`ojs `rd rdn`tovdny wdt `ji tgd Hdjtr`n @mdroh`j gobgn`jis rdn`tovdny iry<
fer wgdrd`s. oj Hdynej. `j `auji`jhd ef r`oj `fferis dhejemoh d`sd wgond ` sh`rhoty
idm`jis dhejemoh dffert. oj Hdjtr`n @mdroh` tgd rdn`toejs ef dhejemoh dffdht te hnom`toh
h`usd `rd kust tgd ojvdrsd. ewojb te tgd ojvdrsd herrdn`toej adtwddj hnom`td `ji
n`jish`pd*@*O*Y*
+Xtonn. ep* `t*. pp* 24-6 `ji 22 `ji ?1.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 319/455
7 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tgdy yodnidi te tgd kujbnd* Ygdy p`hldi up tgdor fdw pessdssoejs `ji
ndft tgd vonn`bd fer dvdr* * * *
"Ygdy trodi te ojiuhd Sujhgo Mdjol` te be wotg tgdm. aut sgd rdfusdi*
* * * Ygd ejny tgojb ndft te gdr w`s tgd hempeuji `ji tgd kujbnd wgohg
sgd ljdw* Xgd hnujb te ot p`ssoej`tdny. anojiny* * * *
"Ygd kujbnd surbdi ferw`ri evdr `ji anettdi eut tgdvonn`bd up te tgd
vdry w`nns ef gdr gut* Xgd je nejbdr hnd`rdi tgd hempeuji er mdjiditgd fdjhd. tgd kujbnd hnesdi evdr tgdm `s ot g`i hnesdi evdr tgd etgdr
guts `ji hempeujis. evdr tgd p`tgs `ji tr`hls* Ots ard`tg w`s get `ji
gd`vy oj tgd gut otsdnf. wgohg ot omprosejdi oj ots w`nn. strdthgojb `w`yujareldj fer monds* Dvdrytgojb dxhdpt tgd nottnd gut wotg rettojb w`nns
`ji areldj t`ttdrdi reef g`i bejd iewj adferd ot* Ot hnesdi wotg ots
sgruas `ji ausgds `ji trdds. wotg tgd ompdjdtr`and ioseridr ef ots tgerjs
`ji hrddpdrs. evdr tgd rohd-fodnis `ji tgd t`jls* Ejny ` nottnd gennewojbef tgd breuji wgdrd tgd trdds steei oj w`tdr wgdj r`oj fdnn. `ji ` nejbnottnd meuji wgohg tgd r`ojs w`sgdi eut `ji tgd dndpg`jts tr`mpndiiewj. m`rldi tgd pn`hd wgdrd adferd g`i n`oj tgd t`jl `ji ots n`ji*
Ygd vonn`bd w`s ferbettdj. ot ios`ppd`rdi ojte tgd kujbnd frem wgohg ot
g`i sprujb. `ji wotg ot sgd w`s hut eff. ferbettdj* Ot w`s `s of sgd w`stgd n`st pdrsej ndft oj tgd Rerni. ` werni ef ujdjiojb trdds `aevd wgohgtgd woji re`rdi `nw`ys `ji tgd Xuj an`zdi* * * *
"Aut nofd os vdry sgert oj tgd kujbnd* Sujhgo Mdjol` w`s `
vdryeni
wem`j adferd sgd w`s ferty* Xgd je nejbdr sewdi br`oj. sgd novdi ejnyej tgd reets `ji nd`vds tg`t sgd b`tgdrdi* Ygd pdrpdtu`n gujbdr w`stdigdr snewny. `ji wgdj tgd r`ojs h`md sgd n`y sgovdrojb wotg fdvdr oj tgdgut* @t n`st tgd tomd h`md wgdj gdr strdjbtg f`ondi gdr< sgd n`y oj tgdgut uj`and te ir`b gdrsdnf eut te sd`rhg fer feei* Ygd ford oj tgd herjdrtg`t g`i smeunidrdi se nejb adtwddj tgd tgrdd brd`t stejds w`s eut*Oj tgd i`y tgd get `or diiodi tgreubg tgd gut. get wotg tgd ard`tg ef tgdwoji anewojb evdr tgd v`st p`rhgdi kujbnd <
`t jobgt sgd sgovdrdi oj tgdhgonn idw* Xgd w`s iyojb. `ji tgd kujbnd ljdw ot< ot os
`nw`ys w`otojb<h`j sh`rhdny w`ot fer id`tg* Rgdj tgd dji w`s hnesd upej gdr ` brd`tan`hl
sg`iew< bnoidi ojte tgd ieerw`y* Ywe nottnd dyds twojlndi `t gdr
std`iony. twe ommdjsd wgotd tusls hurndi up bnd`mojb `b`ojst tgd i`rl-jdss* Xgd s`t up. fd`r h`md upej gdr. tgd fd`r ef tgdkujbnd. anoji `bejos-
ojb fd`r*ft
@ppehghgo. @ppehghgo! sgd shrd`mdi* Gd g`s hemd. tgd idvonfrem tgd ausg* Gd g`s hemd fer md `s yeu s`oi* @oye! s`vd md. s`vd md!@ppehghgo!
"@s sgd fdT a`hl. tgd brd`t ae`r brujtdi seftny. `jibnoidi
nold `sg`iew tew`ris gdr ojte tgd gut* 5O
@s tgd rd`idr hnesds tgd aeel. gd spdhun`tds ej tgd md`jojb eftgd t`nd wgohg g`s tgos
djiojb* Ygreubgeut tgdstery. tgd wrotdr
g`s ir`wj oj fer us. streld ay streld. gos pohturd ef tgd kujbnd `s` sojostdr ad`st ef prdy wgohg ejny novds ots ewj nofd oj eridr te
" X " ; Ygd Vonn`7d oj ++ ZjbT 'Nejiej "8* Aiw`ri
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 320/455
W@@DT@ Y@ L@@@ ?
arojb gum`j nofd te idstruhtoej ` synv`j heujtdrp`rt te tgd
`jom`tdi sldndtej wgohg os eur om`bd ef Id`tg*
G`ui obotur ndto pr`dhnus` dst o`mo` h`dne
jdd seno tdrr`dqud jdqud `ntos `dqueros ujios.sdi p`tdt omm`jd dt v`ste rdspdht`t go`tu* 0
Tjidr tgd sg`iew ef tgos ojgum`j mejstdr. dvdr w`thgojb `ji
w`otojb wotg ` nddr ej ots eashdjd heujtdj`jhd tonn ot fojis ots
eppertujoty te hnesd oj upej ots vohtom. tgd gum`j nofd ef tgd peer
vonn`bdrs sddms ujad`r`any wrdthgdi* * Ygd eiis `b`ojst tgdm `rd
se gd`vy <tgd prdssurd upej tgdm os se brojiojb <
weuni ot jet g`vd
addj adttdr fer tgdm jdvdr te g`vd addj aerj 5 @ji ydt tgd stery ef
tgdor novds. `s ot os teni ay tgd `utger oj tgos p`ojfun sdttojb. os
ujieuatdiny wertg tgdtdnnojb* Rd rd`i tgd t`nd te tgd dji `ji
fddn tg`t tgdsd novds g`vd jet addj novdi fer jetgojb. dvdj tgeubg`t n`st tgd kujbnd evdrwgdnms tgdm* Rg`t os tgd sobjofoh`jhd `ji
tgd ojtdrdst ef tgdm5 Sdrg`ps ot os tg`t tgd hrudn `ji ujhd`sojb
strubbnd wotg tgd kujbnd. wgohg `t forst sobgt sddms `nmest te iovdst
tgdm ef tgdor gum`joty te idbr`id tgdm te tgd ndvdn ef tgd ad`sts
tg`t pdrosg1er ef tgd hrddpojb tgojbs tg`t hrddp upej tgd d`rtg8
suatny
rdvd`ns tgdm oj `jetgdrnobgt
te tgd ojw`ridyd*
Of tgdkujbnd
os ` m`ndvendjt ad`st ef prdy. tgdj tgd vonn`bdrs wge g`vd feubgt ot
wotg tgdor a`rd g`jis `rd gdreds wgesd stery os `j dpoh* Rotgeut
tgd kujbnd tgd vonn`bd heuni g`riny g`vd rosdj te ad ` tgdmd fer
notdr`turd* @ji wgdj tgd kujbnd sw`nnews tgd vonn`bd up. wd rd`nozd
oj rdtrespdht tg`t wd g`vd addj rd`iojb ` t`nd ef gum`j prewdsswgohg surp`ssds tgd t`nd teni ay tgd ruojs ef @jbler R`t*
Oj tgd Jertg @r`ao`j Idsdrt
@ hdndar`tdi `ji ojiddi `nmest g`hljdydi onnustr`toej ef eur
tgdmd os tgd prdsdjt st`td ef Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr` ` spdht`hnd wgohg
g`s ojspordi ` wgend sdrods ef meidrj Rdstdrj dss`ys oj tgd
pgonesepgy ef gostery. frem Nds Quojds+ ejw`ris* Ye-i`y. tgdsd
fermdr gemds ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej `rd oj tgd s`md st`td `s tgd
fermdr gemds ef tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej `t Hep`j `ji Yol`n. `ji
tgdor mejumdjts `stejosg `ji hejfeuji tgd spdht`ter fer tgd s`md
rd`sej* Ygd p`r`nndn os ojiddi dx`ht. dxhdpt tg`t gestond J`turd os
+Nuhrdtous. Id Qdrum J`tur`. Aeel V. 00* 828-4*
+ Ss`nm xnox. w* 01 `ji 13*
8 Ndvotohus xo* 1?*9 Venjdy. H* F*. Hemtd id; Nds Qoijds. eu Mdiot`toej sur nds Qdvenutoejs ids Dmpords
'xst diotoej. S`ros 02?0/* Fer `j `ttr`htovd bdjdr`n `heujt ef tgd h`r`v`j hotods wgohg
os a`sdi upej forst-g`ji `ji rdhdjt `rhg`deneboh`n rdsd`rhg. dspdho`nny `t Iur`. sdd
Qestevtzdtt. M*; H`r`v`jZHottdsZ 'Exferi 0?81. Hn`rdjiej Srdss/* FerZSdtr` sdd `nse
`nmyrd
'S`ros 0?80. Vroj/ `ji S`rtshg. K*; S>
Xotzujbsadjhgtd @l* Ndopzob. aeiv '0?11/*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 321/455
03 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
rdprdsdjtdi gdrd ay tgd @fr`so`j Xtdppd ojstd`i ef tgd trepoh`n
ferdst*0
Gdrd. tee. wd sdd tgd ruojs ef gubd `ji spndjioi puanoh
auoniojbs wgohg `rd noldwosd idsen`td `ji noldwosd osen`tdi frem tgdjd`rdst prdsdjt gum`j g`aot`toejs ay m`jy nd`buds ef surreujiojb
wonidrjdss tgd @fr`so`j wonidrjdss ef iry rehl `ji br`vdn `ji
s`ji wgohg os jet ndss feraoiiojb tg`j tgd trepoh`n wonidrjdss ef
seiidj `ji m`ttdi vdbdt`toej* Ygd idsdrt g`s sw`nnewdi up Sdtr`
`ji S`nmyr`. `s tgd ferdst g`s sw`nnewdi up Yol`n `ji Hep`j <`ji
gdrd. `b`oj. tgd ruojs survovd te peojt ` hejtr`st adtwddj prdsdjt`ji p`st wgohg os se brd`t `s te ad `nmest ujom`boj`and*Ygd ruojs tdnn us tg`t tgdsd dn`aer`td tdmpnds `ji pertoheds `ji
temas. `t tgd tomd wgdj tgdy steei ojt`ht. must g`vd addj erj`-
mdjts ef hotods wgohg rov`nndi tgd M`y`j hotods oj wd`ntg `ji
pepun`toej <`ji gdrd tgd idiuhtoejs frem tgd dvoidjhd ef @rhg`de-
neby. wgohg `rd eur send md`js ef hempesojb ` pohturd ef tgd
M`y`j Hovonoz`toej. `rd rdojferhdi ay tgd wrottdj tdstomejy ef
gosteroh`n rdheris* Ygd dhejemoh feuji`toejs ej wgohg tgd wd`ntg
`ji pepun`toej ef Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr` wdrd suppertdi `rh jet
m`ttdrs ef hejkdhturd* Rd ljew tg`t tgd gosteroh`n poejddrs ef tgd
Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej wge hejkurdi tgdsd hotods up eut ef tgd idsdrtwdrd m`stdrs ef tgd m`boh wgohg tgd Xyro`h Mytgeneby `ttroautds
te Mesds*
Ygdsd m`boho`js ljdw gew te arojb w`tdr eut eftgd iry rehl `jigew te foji tgdor w`y `hress tgd ujtreiidj wonidrjdss* Oj tgdor
promd. Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr` steei oj tgd moist ef orrob`tdi b`ridjsnold tgesd wgohg stonn surreuji I`m`shus te-i`y er tgesd wgohg tgd
Srepgdt Mug`mm`i idpohts oj tgd Pur"`j wgdjdvdr gd wosgds te
dveld oj tgd mojis ef tgd f`otgfun `j om`bd ef S`r`iosd< aut Sdtr`
`ji S`nmyr` ioi jet novd tgdj. `jy merd tg`j I`m`shus novds
te-i`y. dxhnusovdny er dvdj projhop`nny ej tgd fruots ef tgdor j`rrew-
vdrbdi e`sds*1 Ygdor rohg mdj wdrd jet tgdor m`rldt-b`ridjdrs aut
tgdor mdrhg`jts. wge ldpt e`sos oj hemmujoej wotg e`sos. `jihejtojdjt wotg hejtojdjt. ay ` ausy h`r`v`j-tr`ffoh frem peojt te
peojt `hress tgd ojtdrvdjojb tr`hts ef stdppd `ji idsdrt ; br`vdnnyg`m`i `ji s`jiy j`fui* Ygd J`a`t`d`js ef Sdtr`. epdr`tojb tgdtr`js-idsdrt reutd frem tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j perts ef Xyro` te tgd
Ehd`j perts ef tgd _`m`j. hempdtdi wotg tgd Brddl sd`mdj ef@ndx`jiro` fer tgd tr`id adtwddj tgd Qem`j Dmpord `ji Ojio`<
4
Gno 1+ 4455+ZoX7+300 sddls te dxpn`oj tgd rosd `ji f`nn ef Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr`*
onZkv o Z -f +
Zr2Z" ay
.gos Ztgdsos ef ` pdroeioh sgoftojb eo"hgm`toh zejds* Fer gos `ppnoh`toej ef tgd gypetgdsos te tgd h`sd ef S`nmyr`. sdh S`n`tojd
Ir w 0ZZZ`fte0
tejiej%?oo. Hejst`and/. hg* xv* Fer ` bdjdr`n ioshowuoej ef
Af"IZXZXX O5XeZj gySetg ++ +: tgd gosterods ef
hovonoz`toejs. `hd
1 Ygd s`md peojt os m`id `prepes ef Kdr`sg 'Bdr`s`/ ay QestevtzhfF oj ep* dot ejpp: 62~7 " 8 Xdd Qestevtzdff. ep* it. pp* )6-2*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 322/455
W@@DY0@ Y@ L@@@ jtgd S`nmyrhjds. epdr`tojb tgd tr`js-idsdrt reutd frem Xyro` te
"Or`q. vortu`nny mejepenozdi tgd tr`id adtwddj tgd Qem`j Dmpord`ji tgesd rdboejs nyojb d`st ef ot wgohg wdrd rundi suhhdssovdny
aytgd @rs`hois `ji tgd
X`s`jois*
0
Ygd dhejemoh hejtren ef tr`id-reutds areubgt penotoh`n pewdr oj ots tr`oj< `ji tgd J`a`t`d`j
Lojbiem. dxtdjiojb frem Xoj`o te I`m`shus `ji frem Y`ym` te
Addrsgda`. r`jldi `s ejd ef tgd projhop`n hnodjt-st`tds ef Qemdadferd ots `jjdx`toej ay Yr`k`j*
1 @s fer S`nmyr`.8
iurojb tgesd
idh`ids ef tgd tgori hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr` wgdj tgd Qem`j
Dmpord w`s prestr`tdi ay ` p`r`nytoh streld prdmejotery ef ots
hemojb iossenutoej. Puddj [djeao` suhhddidi memdjt`rony. adferd
@urdno`j h`rrodi gdr h`ptovd. oj
runojb
frem tgd
S`nmyrdjde`sos
` prdm`turd `ji `aertovd "suhhdsser-st`td" wgohg `jtohop`tdi. ayfeur hdjturods. tgd projhop`noty ef tgd H`nopg Mu"`wny`g*
9
Xuhg wdrd tgd `hgodvdmdjts ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej ujidr tgd
stomunus ef tgd idsdrt* @ji tgd ruojs ef Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr`. oj
tdstofyojb. `s tgdy st`ji. te tgd foj`n vohtery ef tgd idsdrt evdr M`j.`nse tdstofy. ay tgd sdnfs`md pesturd. te tgd prdvoeus vohtery ef
M`j evdr tgd idsdrt* Xojhd tgd i`y wgdj tgd Xyro`h Xehodtyevdrhemd ay tgd prdssurd ef tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt oj tgd sg`pdef tgd Qem`j Dmpord
4 rdn`xdi ots brop upej tgd pgysoh`n djvorej-
mdjt `t tgdsd twe peojts `ji `nnewdi tgd idsdrt te g`vd ots w`ywotg Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr` `b`oj. je etgdr sehodty g`s dvdr `ttdmptdite rdpd`t tgd `hgodvdmdjt ef tgd Xyro`h poejddrs ay rdh`nnojb dotgdr
ef tgdsd id`i hotods te nofd* Ygd `ttdmpt g`s jet dvdj addj m`id upte tgd prdsdjt ay Rdstdrj djtdrprosd. tgeubg oj eur i`y wd iospesd
+ Xdh QestevtshfF. ep* hot.. pp* 031-9*" ` Ygd J`a`t`d`j rdbomd oj tgos rdboej n`stdi `ntebdtgdr fer jd`rny tgrdd hdjturods.
adbojjojb horh` 069 A*H* 'Qesteytzdff. ep* hot*. p* 43/*8 S`nmyr` os rust gd`ri ef oj 90 A*H* 'QestevtzdfY. ep* hot*. p* 010/* Ygd d`rnodst
dxt`jt S`nmyrhjh ojshroptoej w`s hut oj 7 A h* 'FdVrodr. ep* hot*. p* 6/*, Xdh ven* o. p* 29. `aevd. feetjetd 9* Ot m`y ad jetdi tg`t wgond tgd J`a`t`d`j
hnodjt-sn`td ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord w`s a`sdi ej tgd sojbnd e`sos ef Sdtr` `ji [djeao`"s
`aeotovh "suhhdsser-st`td" ej tgd sojbnd e`sos ef S`nmyr`. tgd suhhdssoun "suhhdsser-st`td"
wgohg w`s dst`anosgdi er usurpdi ay Mu"`woy`g w`s a`sdi ej ` p`or ef e`sds; tgesd
ef Mdioj` `ji Mdhh`* Ygd penotoh`n ujoej ef tgdsd twe e`sds w`s tgd suprdmd penotoh`n
`hgodvdmdjt ef Mug`mm`i* Oj `hgodvojb ot. gd n`oi tgd feuji`toejs ef ` st`td wgohg
brdw. forst ojte ` "suhhdsser-st`td" ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord oj ots Xyro`h prevojhds. `ji tgdj
mte ` rdojthbr`toej er rdsumptoej ef tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td wgohg g`i addj auont
ay tgd @hg`dmdjois `ji evdrtgrewj ay @ndx`jidr tgd Brd`t* 'Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o.
pp* 28-2. `aevd*/
4 Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr` d`hg resd oj turj te brd`tjdss ay fojiojb pn`hds fer tgdmsdnvdsoj tgd ojtdrstohds adtwddj tgd iemojoejs ef mutu`nny gestond Brd`t Sewdrs wgesd
gestonoty w`s tee brd`t te `imot ef tgdor hemojb te ` iordht ujidrst`jiojb wotg d`hg
etgdr. wgond ot w`s jet brd`t djeubg te irovd tgdm ojte ferbeojb tgd `iv`jt`bd ef ieojbausojdss wotg ejd `jetgdr ojiordhtny tgreubg tgd `bdjhy ef hemmdrho`n be-adtwddjswge weuni `nse sdrvd `s penotoh`n auffdrs* Sdtr` resd oj tgos w`y oj `j ojtdrstohd adtwddj
tgd Xdnhuhoi `ji tgd Stendm`oh "suhhdsser-st`td+ ef tgd @hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord< S`nmyr`
resd oj `j ojtdrstohd adtwddj tgd Qem`j Dmpord `ji tgd @rs`hoi Sewdr* Sdtr` w`s
ieemdi wgdj tgd Qem`j Dmpord suppn`jtdi aetg tgd Xdnduhoi `ji tgd Stendm`oh Sewdr
`nold< S`nmyr` w`s ieemdi wgdj tgd idh`y ef tgd @rs`hoi`d ndft Qemd memdjt`rony
wotgeut ` rov`n oj tgos qu`rtdr noldwosd pdjiojb tgd rosd ef tgd X`s`joi`d* 'Xdd furtgdr
Qestevtzdff. ep* hot*. pp* 16-84*/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 323/455
01 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
ef tdhgjoh`n f`honotods wgohg tgd J`a`t`d`js `ji tgd @r`m`d`js
jdvdr ird`mdi ef; `rtdso`j wdnns tg`t h`j t`p suatdrr`jd`j w`tdr-
suppnods quotd adyeji tgd rd`hg efpohls er tgd ldj efiovojojb-reis <
`ji pdtren-irovdj sox-wgddndi meter-h`rs wgohg h`j tr`vdrsdoj `
i`y ` tr`ht ef idsdrt wgohg os ` wddl"s keurjdy fer ` h`mdn* 0 Ygus
tgd ruojdi mejumdjts `ji tgd irodi-up e`sds `ji tgd `a`jiejdi
h`r`v`j-reutds ef Sdtr` `ji S`nmyr` idhn`rd ujmost`l`any. te tgd
easdrvdr wge hejsoidrs tgdm te-i`y. ` f`ht wgohg os jet rdvd`ndi oj
tgesd nevdny b`ridjs tg`t `rd stonn w`tdrdi ay tgd rovdrs ef I`m`s-
hus ; tgd f`ht tg`t tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt oj wgohg tgd Xyro`h
Hovonoz`toej h`md te aortg w`s jet ujusu`nny d`sy aut. ej tgd
hejtr`ry.
w`sujusu`nny
ioffohunt fer M`j te m`stdr*
Ej D`stdr Osn`ji
Oj ` ioffdrdjt djvorejmdjt `b`oj. wd m`y ir`w ` herrdspejiojb
hejhnusoej hejhdrjojb tgd erobojs ef tgd Senyjdso`j Hovonoz`toej1
frem tgd prdsdjt st`td ef D`stdr Osn`ji* 8 @t tgd tomd ef ots ioshevdry
ay meidrj Rdstdrj dxpnerdrs. D`stdr Osn`ji w`s ojg`aotdi ay twe
r`hds ; ` r`hd ef fndsg-`ji-aneei `ji ` r`hd ef stejd<`j `pp`rdjtny
promotovd gum`j pepun`toej ef Senyjdso`j pgysoqud. `ji ` gobgny
`hhempnosgdi pepun`toej ef st`tuds* Ygd novojb ojg`aot`jts oj tg`t
bdjdr`toej pessdssdi jdotgdr tgd `rt ef h`rvojb st`tuds suhg `s tgdsd
jer tgd shodjhd ef j`vob`tojb tgd tgeus`ji monds ef epdj sd` tg`t
sdp`r`td D`stdr Osn`ji frem tgd jd`rdst sostdr-osn`ji ef tgd Seny-jdso`j @rhgopdn`be* Adferd ots ioshevdry ay tgd sd`mdj eftgd Rdst.D`stdr Osn`ji g`i addj osen`tdi frem tgd rdst ef tgd Rerni fer `j
ujljewj ndjbtg ef tomd* _dt ots iu`n pepun`toej ef fndsg `ji stejd
tdstofods. kust `s hnd`rny `s tgd ruojs ef S`nmyr` er Hep`j. te `
v`josgdi p`st wgohg must g`vd addj uttdrny ioffdrdjt frem tgdvosoand prdsdjt*
Ygesd gum`j adojbs must g`vd addj adbettdj. `ji tgesd foburdsmust g`vd addj h`rvdi. ay Senyjdso`j j`vob`ters wge ejhd feujitgdor w`y `hress tgd S`hofoh te D`stdr Osn`ji oj fnomsy epdj h`jeds.
0 Oj tgd yd`r 0?83 ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. tgd meter-h`r `ji tgd `rth`wm wdnn wdrd adojbusdi ay ejd brd`t m`j wge w`s jet ` Rdstdrjdr aut `j @r`a LojL "@ai-`n-"@zfh @Oa` ui ef tgd J`ki-Gok`zoj eridr te rd`ssdrt M`j"s `shdji`jhy evdr J`turd oj ejd ef
@ Zrrferaniin
5Xted++ ef tgd @fr`so`j Xtdppd. j`mdny Hdjtr`n @r`ao`* Rotg tgd
`oi enRdstdrj tdhgjoqud. Oaj X` ui w`s dvelojb. oj ` rdboej wgohg g`i prdvoeusny addjutonozdi fer jetgojb adttdr tg`j tgd r`jbds ef p`ster`n Jem`is. ` jdw werni ef orrob`tdi
e`sds. nojldi tebdtgdr ay tr`js-idsdrt reutds wgohg sdrvdi tgd iu`n purpe`h ef hemmdrhd`ji bevdrjmdjt* Ygd dmpord rundi ay tgd R`gg`ao Lojb frem Qoy`i premosdi. of ot
djiurdi. te rdpreiuhd `t n`st. oj tgd twdjtodtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgmto`j Dr`. `j om`bd eftgd dmpurds wgohg g`i ejhd addj rundi ay Lojb ft`rotg frem Sdtr` `ji ay Puddj[djeao` frem S`nmyr`* 'Xdd Qog`jo @mddj; Oaj X`"eui ef @r`ao`; Got Sdepf+ `ji gotN`ji 'Nejiej 0?17
Hejst`and/<Sgnnay. G* Xt* K* A*; @r`ao` ef tgd R`gg`ao+ 'Nejiej
0?17. Hejst`and/. `ji @r`ao` 'Nejiej 0?83. Adjj/*/
8 fr)dZ7tdi SenZN
dso`j Hovonoz`toej. sdd furtgdr S`rt OOO* @. adnew*
+jG YZ 50 76"
X.V
YgZM&Z +f D+t+r Osn`ji 'Nejiej O ?+?. Xoftej Sr`hi/<`ji Arewj. K* M`hmonn`j; Ygd Qoiind ef tgd S`hofoh 'Nejiej 0?19. Fo`gdr Tjwoj/.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 324/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@08
wotgeut hg`rt er hemp`ss `ji wotg je etgdr meter-pewdr tg`j tgd
woji adgoji tgdor tojy s`ons `ji tgd gum`j mushun`r ferhd tg`t
pnodi tgdor p`iinds* @ji tgos vey`bd h`j g`riny g`vd addj `j
osen`tdi `ivdjturdwgohg areubgt ejd ae`t-ne`i ef Senyjdso`j
poejddrs te D`stdr Osn`ji ay ` streld ef nuhl tg`t w`s jet rdpd`tdi<fer ej tg`t suppesotoej ot weuni rd`nny ad ompessoand te `hheujt
aetg fer tgd prdsdjhd ef tgd pepun`toej ef st`tuds `ji fer tgd
oj`aonoty ef tgd n`ttdr-i`y pepun`toej ef gum`j adojbs te h`rvd
tgdm* Ygd `rt ef shunpturd must g`vd addj areubgt te D`stdr
Ksn`ji ay tgd poejddrs. `ji nest ej D`stdr Osn`ji ay tgdor idshdj-
i`jts. tebdtgdr wotg tgd `rt ef j`vob`toej* Ygd rdn`psd ef tgdsd
iost`jt henejosts frem tgd huntur`n ndvdn ef tgd
Senyjdso`j Xehodtydnsdwgdrd must g`vd addj iud te tgd ard`lojb ef tgdor hejt`ht wotg
tgd rdst ef Senyjdso`* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. tgd pepun`toej ef st`tuds
os se jumdreus tg`t ot must g`vd t`ldj m`jy bdjdr`toejs te pre-
iuhd< `ji iurojb tgesd bdjdr`toejs tgd `rt ef shunpturd. wgohg g`s
addj nest oj tgos n`ttdr-i`y `bd ef osen`toej. must g`vd addj ldpt`novd ej D`stdr Osn`ji ay hejtoju`n tr`jsm`rojd ojtdrheursd* Y`ldj
tebdtgdr. tgdsd hejsoidr`toejs peojt te ` prdvoeus st`td ef `ff`ors oj
wgohg tgd j`vob`toej `hress tgesd tgeus`ji monds ef epdj sd` w`s
h`rrodi ej rdbun`rny evdr ` nejb pdroei ef tomd* Dvdjtu`nny. fer
semd rd`sej wgohg stonn rdm`ojs ` mystdry te us. tgd sd`. ejhd
tr`vdrsdi vohteroeusny ay M`j. hnesdi oj reuji D`stdr Osn`ji. `s tgd
idsdrt hnesdi oj reuji S`nmyr` `ji tgd ferdst reuji Hep`j* _dt.
gdrd `b`oj. J`turd"s rd`ssdrtoej ef gdr pewdr ad`rs tdstomejy te tgd
prewdss ef M`j oj ejhd evdrhemojb gdr `ji tgus ojioh`tds tg`t
tgdrd wdrd hdrt`oj fd`turds ef ujusu`n ioffohunty oj tgd pgysoh`n
djvorejmdjt oj wgohg tgd Senyjdso`j Hovonoz`toej h`md te aortg*
Ygd trutg tgus prehn`omdi oj ujosej ay S`st `ji Srdsdjt ejD`stdr Osn`ji os. ef heursd. oj fn`t hejtr`iohtoej te tgd pepun`r
Rdstdrj vodw tg`t tgd Xeutg Xd` Osn`jis `rd `j d`rtgny p`r`iosd
`ji tgdor ojg`aot`jts hgonirdj ef J`turd oj tgd ndbdji`ry st`td ef
@i`m `ji Dvd adferd tgd F`nn* Sdrg`ps tgos vodw `rosds frem `
most`ldj `ssumptoej tg`t ejd pertoej ef tgd Senyjdso`j djvorej-
mdjt hejstotutds tgd wgend ef ot* Ygd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt ef tgd
Senyjdso`j Xehodty hejsosts. oj rd`noty. ef w`tdr `s wdnn `s n`ji;
w`tdr wgohg prdsdjts ` fermoi`and hg`nndjbd te `jy gum`j adojbswge prepesd te hress ot wotgeut pessdssojb `jy adttdr md`js ef
j`vob`toej tg`j tgesd. idshroadi `aevd. wgohg wdrd `htu`nny tgd
ejny md`js `t tgd Senyjdso`j j`vob`ters" hemm`ji* Ot w`s ay
rdspejiojb aeniny `ji suhhdssfunny te tgos hg`nndjbd ef tgd dstr`jb-
ojb sd` ay `hgodvojb. wotg tgdor ruiomdjt`ry md`js ef j`vob`toej.
tgd teur id ferhd ef dst`anosgojb ` rdbun`r m`rotomd tr`ffoh `hress
tgd epdj w`tdrs adtwddj osn`ji `ji osn`ji tg`t tgd Senyjdso`j
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 325/455
o9 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
poejddrs wej tgdor feetojb ej tgd spdhls ef iry n`ji wgohg `rd
sh`ttdrdi tgreubg tgd v`st w`tdry wonidrjdss ef tgd S`hofoh Ehd`j
`nmest `s r`rdny `s tgd st`rs `rd sh`ttdrdi tgreubg tgd idptgs ef
Xp`hd* Dvdj br`jtojb tg`t tgdsd ad`hgojb-pn`hds wgohg hejstotutdsuhg `j ojfojotdsom`nny sm`nn fr`htoej ef tgd Senyjdso`j djvorej-
mdjt ie effdr `j d`rtgny p`r`iosd te `jy gum`j adojbs wge m`ysuhhddi oj rd`hgojb tgdm. ot must ad aerjd oj moji tg`t tgd
Senyjdso`js rd`hgdi tgdm ay tgdor ewj dxdrtoejs. `ftdr g`z`riojb
tgdor novds upej tgd w`tdrs. wgdrd`s tgd @i`m `ji Dvd ef tgd
Xyro`h Mytgeneby wdrd pn`hdi oj tgd B`ridj ef Didj ay tgd `ht
ef tgdor hrd`ter. `ji ioi jet adboj dotgdr te dxdrt tgdor mojis `ji
aeiods er te g`z`ri tgdor novds ujton
tgdyg`i addj irovdj eut ef tgd
B`ridj. `ji ldpt eut ef ot. ay tgd `jbdn wotg tgd fn`mojb sweri* 0
Ot os pessoand tg`t. oj tgd djvorejmdjt wgdrd tgd Senyjdso`j
Hovonoz`toej h`md te aortg. tgdrd w`s `j ujtew`ri idbrdd ef sg`rp-
jdss oj tgd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd ioffohunty ef tgd forst erid`n wgohg
g`i te ad p`ssdi `ji tgd d`sd ef tgd hejiotoejs ef nofd wotg wgohg tgd
suhhdssfun rdspejsd te tgos forst hg`nndjbd w`s rdw`ridi* Ygd teons
`ji i`jbdrs ef Senyjdso`j j`vob`toej ej tgd S`hofoh wdrd se fer-
moi`and `ji tgd swddts ef rdpesd ej tgd osn`jis wdrd se `nnurojb
tg`t tgd hgonirdj m`y wdnn g`vd addj tdmptdi te `a`jiej tg`t
brd`t Ehd`joh werni ef n`ji `ji w`tdr wgohg tgdor f`tgdrs g`i
epdjdi up fer tgdm. oj eridr te sojl a`hl d`hg ej tgd osn`ji
wgohg gd g`i ojgdrotdi oj vortud ef gos f`tgdr"s dfferts ojte ` nofd
ef promotovd d`sd `ji osen`toej* Yg`t sddms te g`vd addj tgd
gostery ef tgd idhnojd `ji f`nn ef tgd Senyjdso`j Hovonoz`toej ej
D`stdr Osn`ji ; tgd osn`ji wgohg g`i te ad wej `ji gdni `t tgd prohd
ef tgd nejbdst sd`-p`ss`bd ef `nn* Ygd henejosts ef D`stdr Osn`ji
must g`vd addj tgd fnewdr ef tgd Senyjdso`j poejddrs < `ji tgd
vortud tg`t w`s oj tgdm jet ejny h`rrodi tgdm `hress ` tgeus`ji
monds ef epdj sd`1 aut `v`ondi tgdm adferd ot wdjt eut ef tgdm
te hemmdmer`td tgdor `hgodvdmdjt fer dvdr ay hrd`tojb. `t tgdor
iost`jt keurjdy"s dji. semd ef tgd fojdst m`stdrpodhds dvdr pre-iuhdi ay Senyjdso`j `rt* Ygd gostery ef tgd Senyjdso`j Hovonoz`toej
ej D`stdr Osn`ji m`y suppny tgd hnud te tgd gostery ef tgd Seny-jdso`j Hovonoz`toej `s ` wgend* Yg`t os ` preandm wgohg wonn
idm`ji eur jetohd `b`oj gdrd`ftdr*8
Oj tgos pn`hd wd `rd sompnyhejhdrjdi te peojt eut tg`t tgd pepun`r Rdstdrj vodw ef tgd Seny-
+ Fer tgd sobjofoh`jhd ef tgos mytg ef tgd B`ridj `ji tgd F`M. sdh `aevd. OO. H 'oo/ '/o. ven*o.pp 1?3-8*
U
1 Ygd jd`rdst n`ji te D`stdr jew ojg`aotdi. wotg tgd dxhdptoej ef Soth`orj Ojn`ji.os oj tgd B`mao` Osn`jis. `aeut 0.133 monds te tgd wdstw`ri< tgd nottnd her`n p`thg efIuhod Osn`ji. wgohg nods adtwddj tgd twe. os jd`rny ?33 monds frem D`stdr. `ji gj jeiwdnndrs*" 'Qeutndibd. X*; Ygd Mystdry ef D`stdr Osn`ji 'Nejiej 0?0?. Xoftej Sr`di/.p* 1?1*/
s Ot os teuhgdi upej `b`oj oj S`rt OOO* @. ven* ou. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 326/455
W@@DOO@ Y@ L@@@ 04
jdso`j djvorejmdjt os most`ldj `ji te dxpn`oj gew ot g`s `rosdj<
`ji tgd dxpn`j`toej turjs eut te ad vdry sompnd* Ygd Rdstdrj
easdrvdrs wge g`vd bovdj ot hurrdjhy g`vd ejny g`i dyds fer tgd
n`ji `ji g`vd objerditgd sd`
wgohg hevdrs`nn
aut ` fr`htoej ef tgd`rd` evdr wgohg tgd Senyjdso`j Hovonoz`toej ejhd r`jbdi* Srd-
sum`any tgdy weuni jet g`vd objerdi ot of tgdy g`i g`i te tr`vdrsd
ot tgdmsdnvds oj tgd hr`ft ef tgd Senyjdso`j j`vob`ters. ojstd`i ef
tr`vdnnojb. `s tgdy g`vd iejd. `s p`ssdjbdrs oj meidrj Rdstdrj
ehd`j-beojb nojdrs. nd`vojb tgd rdspejsoaonoty ef j`vob`toej te ad
aerjd ay prefdssoej`n Rdstdrj j`vob`ters wotg tgd `ssost`jhd ef
hemp`ss `ji hg`rt*
Oj Jdw Djbn`ji
Adferd hnesojb tgos rdvodw ef rdvdrsoejs te ` st`td ef J`turd. tgd
wrotdr m`y pdrmot gomsdnf te hotd twe ojst`jhds ejd semdwg`t
eut ef tgd w`y `ji tgd etgdr dxhddiojbny eavoeus wgohg g`ppdjte g`vd hemd wotgoj gos ewj pdrsej`n easdrv`toej*
O w`s ejhd tr`vdnnojb oj ` rur`n p`rt ef tgd Xt`td ef Hejjdhtohut
oj Jdw Djbn`ji. wgdj O h`md `hress ` idsdrtdi vonn`bd ` jet
ujhemmej spdht`hnd. se O w`s teni. oj tgos sdhtoej ef tgd Tjotdi
Xt`tds. ydt ` spdht`hnd. jdvdrtgdndss. wgohg os ojdvot`any surprosojb
`ji dvdj ioshejhdrtojb te ` Durepd`j oj @mdroh`* Ygos p`rtohun`r
vonn`bd ot w`s h`nndi Yewj Gonn g`i dvoidjtny addj n`oi eutmuhg
nold etgdr Jdw Djbn`ji vonn`bds. stonn ojg`aotdi. oj semd eftgd merd
fdrtond iostrohts ef tgd s`md st`td tgreubg wgohg O g`i `nrd`iy p`ssdi
ej my keurjdy tg`t vdry i`y* Fer semd twe hdjturods. pdrg`ps.
Yewj Gonn g`i steei wotg ots pn`jl-auont Bderbo`j Hgurhg oj tgd
moiind ef tgd vonn`bd brddj. `ji wotg tgd geusds reuji tgd hgurhg.
`ji wotg tgd erhg`ris adyeji tgd geusds. `ji wotg tgd herj-fodnis .
strdthgojb `w`y adyeji tgd fruot-trdds* Oj 0?14 tgd hgurhg stonn
steei'ot
w`s adojb ldpt oj rdp`or ay tgd Xt`td @rhg`deneboh`n
Xehodty `s `j `jhodjt mejumdjt/ <tgd geusds g`i v`josgdi 'tgeubg
tgdor fermdr pesotoejs heuni stonn ad tr`hdi ay tgd rdmj`jts ef tgdor
feuji`toejs/ <tgd fruot-trdds g`i bejd woni `ji g`i addj sw`nnewdi
up oj tgd rdsurbdjt ujidrbrewtg* @s fer tgd fodnis. tgdy g`i f`idi
`w`y `ntebdtgdr ojte tgd rehls `ji shrua ef tgd a`rrdj gonn-soid*
Nojbdrojb ej tgd spet `ji `nnewojb my tgeubgts te pn`y `aeuttgd str`jbd sobgts gdrd prdsdjtdi te md. O m`rvdnndi forst `t `j
`pp`rdjt p`r`iex* Rotgoj tgd gujirdi yd`rs djiojb oj tgos yd`r
0?14. tgesd v`josgdi Jdw Djbn`jidrs g`i wrdstdi frem J`turd tgd
wgend ard`itg ef ` hejtojdjt* Oj tgdsd fdw bdjdr`toejs tgdy g`i
sprd`i frem tgd spet wgdrd O w`s st`jiojb. ej tgd @tn`jtoh snepd.
te tgd sgerds ef tgd S`hofoh* _dt `t tgd s`md tomd tgdy g`i suffdrdi
J`turd te rdh`pturd frem tgdm tgos vonn`bd oj tgd gd`rt ef tgdor
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 327/455
06 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
gemdn`ji ` vonn`bd wgohg tgdor ferdf`tgdrs g`i feujidi `nmest `s
seej `s tgdy g`i sdt feet ej @mdroh`j seon<` vonn`bd wgdrd. fer
pdrg`ps twe gujirdi yd`rs adferd "tgd Rojjojb ef tgd Rdst". tgd
`shdji`jhy ef M`j evdr J`turd g`i sddmdi te ad dst`anosgdi `s
sdhurdny `s oj `jy vonn`bd oj Durepd* Ygdsd wdrd my forst tgeubgts <
aut ej sdheji tgeubgts O adb`j te ujidrst`ji tgd sobjofoh`jhdef
wg`t O w`s neelojb `t* Ygd r`poioty. tgd tgereubgjdss. tgd `a`jiej
wotg wgohg J`turd g`i rd`ssdrtdi gdr iemojoej evdr tgd sotd ef
Yewj Gonn `s seej `s M`j g`i rdn`xdi gos brop. surdny b`vd tgd
md`surd ef tgd dxdrtoejs wgohg M`j g`i fermdrny m`id. forst te
h`pturd tgos pesotoej frem J`turd `ji tgdj te geni ot* Ygesd
dxdrtoejs mustg`vd addj dxtrdmd
< `ji.wgdj ejd h`md te tgojl ef
ot. ejny `j djdrby `s ojtdjsd `s tgd djdrby wgohg tgd ard`lojb-oj ef
Jdw Djbn`ji g`i h`nndi ojte pn`y heuni g`vd addj suffohodjt fer
tgd Gdrhund`j n`aeur ef ard`lojb-oj ` wgend hejtojdjt* Ygus. se
f`r frem "tgd Rojjojb ef tgd Rdst" m`lojb tgd ness ef Yewj Gonn
ojdxpnoh`and. tgd trutg w`s tg`t. oj tgd ness ef Yewj Gonn. tgd sdhrdt
ef "tgd Rojjojb ef tgd Rdst+ w`s n`oi a`rd* Ygd pertdjt ef tgos
vonn`bd oj Hejjdhtohut. idsdrtdi te-i`y. dxpn`ojdi tgd mor`hnd ef
tgesd brd`t hotods oj Egoe `ji Onnojeos `ji Hener`ie `ji H`noferjo`
wgohg g`i sprujb ojte dxostdjhd evdrjobgt* Oj tgos g`ri djvorej-
mdjt ef Jdw Djbn`ji. `j `pprdjtohdsgop g`i addj sdrvdi fer tgd
g`ri t`sl ef auoniojb tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds* Rgdj tgd `pprdjtohd
g`i fdnt gomsdnf funny tr`ojdi oj jdrvd `ji mushnd `ji slonn. gd g`i
sompny ndft tgd pn`hd wgohg g`i addj gos tr`ojojb-breuji `ji g`i
bejd te tgd pn`hd wgdrd gd w`s te ie gos werl oj nofd* Ygd idsdrtoej
ef Yewj Gonn w`s jet ` p`r`iex `ftdr `nn<ot w`s ef ejd podhd wotg
tgd brd`t gum`j djtdrprosd wgohg g`i feujidi `ji pdepndi Hoj-
hojj`to `ji Hgoh`be `ji Idjvdr `ji X`j Fr`jhoshe*
Ej tgd Qem`j H`mp`bj`
Xomon`r hejsoidr`toejs rdsenvd tgd `pp`rdjt p`r`iex oj tgd
prdsdjt st`td ef tgd Qem`j H`mp`bj`* Ot os adsoid tgd peojt te
m`rvdn. wotg Novy. tg`t `j ojjumdr`and muntotuid ef ydem`j-w`rroers sgeuni fermdrny g`vd suasostdi oj ` rdboej wgohg oj gos
i`y. `s oj eurs.0 w`s ` wonidrjdss ef a`rrdj br`y fdnn `ji fdvdrosg
f
+
Oj 0?80. wgdj tgd wrotdr ef tgos Xtuiy rdvosotdi tgd Qem`j H`mp`bj` `ftdr `jojtdrv`n ef twdjty yd`rs. gd feuji tg`t tgos st`tdmdjt rdquordi qu`nofoh`toej* Oj xe*j tgdstuidjtwge m`id tgd ponbrom`bd ef tgd Vo` @ppo` @jtoh` feuji gomsdnf w`nlojb tgreubg` wonidrjdss `nmest frem tgd memdjt wgdj gd p`ssdi adyeji tgd Hoty w`nns tgreubgtgd Sert` X`j Xda`sto`je tonn tgd memdjt wgdj gd `ppre`hgdi tgd eutfnlort` ef @naoje*Rgdj gd rdpd`tdi tgd ponbrom`bd oj 0?80. gd feuji tg`t. oj tgd ojtdrv`n. M`j g`i amoausony rd`ssdrtojb gos m`stdry evdr tgd wgend strdthg ef heujtry tg`t nods adtwddj Qemd`ji tgd H`stdTo Qem`jo* Ygd Vo` @ppo` @jtoh` otsdnf w`s ujhg`jbdi 'adojb h`rdfunnyprdsdrvdi. nold tgd hgurhg `t Yewj Gonn. ay `rhg`deneboh`npodty/ < aut tgdrd w`d jew jepeojt `nejb ots heursd wgdrd tgd w`yf`rdr w`s eut ef sobgt ef meidrj meter-re`iG.`dreiremds. wordndss-m`sts `ji merd omprdssovd tg`j `nn tgdsdjdwny huntov`tdijdnis* Ygd tdjsoej ef gum`j djdrby ej tgd Qem`j H`mp`bj` os jew adbojjojb te j+d
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 328/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@ 02
brddj sw`mp wgdrd tgd ejny survovojb vdstobds ef gum`j g`aot`-
toej wdrd tgd fr`on str`w guts ef ` fdw mosdr`and sgdpgdris*0
Ot os
merd `ppesotd te rdfndht tg`t tgos n`ttdr-i`y wonidrjdss g`s rdpre-iuhdi tgd
prostojdst`td ef tgd
feraoiiojb n`jish`pd wgohg w`s ejhdtr`jsfermdi ay N`toj er Vensho`j poejddrs ojte ` huntov`tdi `ji
pepuneus heujtrysoid <`ji tg`t tgd djdrby bdjdr`tdi oj tgd prehdss
ef ard`lojb-oj tgos j`rrew pnet ef ieur Ot`no`j seon w`s tgd djdrbywgohg `ftdrw`ris hejqudrdi tgd Rerni oj ` r`ious dxtdjiojb frem
tgd H`mp`bj` te Arot`oj `ji Dbypt. `ji frem tgd @na`j Gonns te
tgd @tn`s `ji tgd H`uh`sus*1 Of `j djdrby wgohg suffohdi. oj ots
ioffusoej. te auoni tgd Qem`j Dmpord w`s forst bdjdr`tdi `ji hej-
hdjtr`tdi wotgoj tgd nomots ef tgd H`mp`bj`. tgos ojioh`tds tgd
idbrdd ef gum`j dffert ojvenvdi oj forst hejqudrojb tgd H`mp`bj`frem tgd wonidrjdss `ji tgdj m`ojt`ojojb ot `b`ojst rdvdrsoej* Os
ot `jy wejidr tg`t tgd hr`ind ef tgd Qem`j Hemmejwd`ntg ioi
rdvdrt te ots prostojd st`td wgdj tgd aeiy penotoh wgohg tgos hr`ind
g`i jurturdi dvdjtu`nny turjdi ots djdrbods eutw`ris evdr `nn tgd
lojbiems ef tgd D`rtg 5 Xurdny ot weuni g`vd addj merd surprosojbof tgd H`mp`bj` g`i stonn hejtojudi te yodni ojhrd`sd te tgd Qem`jgusa`jim`j `ji rdhruots te tgd Qem`j ironn-sdrbd`jt oj tgesd
n`ttdr i`ys wgdj tgd Qem`j @rmy w`s bu`riojb tgd frejtodrs ef tgd
Dmpord. `ji tonnojb tgdpr`n` ndboejum. f`r `w`y ej tgd frojbd ef tgd
@fr`so`j Xtdppd `ji ej tgd a`jls ef tgd Qgojd `ji tgd I`juad 5
Rd g`vd jew p`ssdi ujidr rdvodw ` jumadr ef sotds oj tgd
@mdroh`j `ji @so`toh Yrepohs. oj tgd @fr`so`j Xtdppd. oj tgd
S`hofoh @rhgopdn`be. oj Jertg @mdroh`. oj tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j
wgohg g`vd rdvdrtdi te tgdor prostojd st`td ef J`turd `ftdr g`vojbaddj tgd shdjd ef sobj`n gum`j `hgodvdmdjts tg`t `rd jew hem-
mdmer`tdiay
idsdrtdi ruojs* Oj tgos
`rr`y.
tgdrd os tgd utmest
iovdrsoty aetg oj tgd hg`r`htdr ef tgd neh`n pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt
`ji oj tgd sg`pd ef tgd yeld wgohg M`j g`s ejhd n`oi upej ot< ydt
`nn tgdsd sotds `brdd oj ad`rojb uj`jomeus wotjdss te ejd dssdjto`n
hejiotoej ef suhhdssfun gum`j `htovoty ;
Jur idr vdriodjt sohg Frdogdot wod i`s Ndadj
Idr t`bnohg sod dreadrj muss*8
Dvdj wgdj tgd dfferts ef tgd poejddrs g`vd suhhddidi oj hejqudr-
ojb
semdpesotoej
frem J`turd. tgd
hejqudrdi breuji
g`s te ad
`b`oj fer tgd forst tomd sojhd tgd dji ef tgd tgori hdjtury A*H*. wgdj. iurojb tgd R`r ef
G`jjoa`n. ot adb`j ots brd`t idhnojd tew`ris tgd zdre peojt `t wgohg ot g`s steei tgreubg-eut tgd forst jojdtddj hdjturods ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`*
+ "Ojjumdr`aondm muntotuiojdm noadrerum h`potum oj dos fuossd nehos qu`d mojd. vox
sdmoj`roe monotum dxobue rdghte. sdrvoto` Qem`j` `a senotuiojd vojioh`jt+ 'Novy.
Aeel VO. hg* 01/* Hemp`rd tgd `nnusoejs ojGer`hd. Dpostnds. Aeel O. Dp* xo. 00* 2-7 `ji 83*` Ygos os tgd tgdmd ef Srefdsser Ydjjdy Fr`jl oj Ygd Dhejemoh KDQstery ef tgd Qem`j
Qdpuanoh '`ji diotoej. A`ntomerd 0?12. Kegjs Geplojs Tjovdrsoty Srdss/*8F`ust. 00* 00424-6. quetdi `aevd oj ven* o ej p* 122*
OO H
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 329/455
0 7 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
gdni. ay ujrdmottojb dfferts ej tgd p`rt ef tgd poejddrs" suhhdssers.
`b`ojst J`turd"s ujrdmottojb heujtdr-`tt`hls* Ygd fodnis ef Dbypt
er tgd b`ridjs ef I`m`shus. wgohg sddm `t forst sobgt te yodni tgdor
fruots `utem`toh`nny te `jy ejd wge shr`thgds tgd seon.
0
`rd rd`nny
ejny m`ojt`ojdi `s "beojb hejhdrjs" ay hejst`jt `ji strdjueus
n`aeur* Gew muhg brd`tdr. tgdj. must g`vd addj tgd n`aeur wgohg
ot hest tgd f`tgdrs ef tgd Dbypto`h `ji tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej
te arojb tgd N`ji ef Dbypt `ji tgd Bgut`g ef I`m`shus ojte
dxostdjhd eut ef tgd promdv`n kujbnd-sw`mp `ji tgd promdv`n
idsdrt5 Sdrg`ps wd m`y jew hejsoidr tg`t wd g`vd prevdi tgd
prepesotoej wgohg wd forst teel fer br`jtdi* Ot sddms dvoidjt tg`t
tgd hejiotoejs effdrdi te M`jay
tgd djvorejmdjts tg`t g`vd addj
tgd aortg-pn`hds ef hovonoz`toejs g`vd addj jet ujusu`nny d`sy aut
ujusu`nny ioffohunt*
Sdrfoi` H`pu`
G`vojb stuiodi tgd hg`r`htdr ef hdrt`oj djvorejmdjts wgohg g`vd
`htu`nny addj tgd shdjd ef tgd bdjdsds ef hovonoz`toejs er ef etgdr
sobj`n gum`j `hgodvdmdjts. `ji g`vojb feuji dmporoh`nny tg`t tgd
hejiotoejs wgohg tgdy g`vd effdrdi te M`j g`vd addj jet d`sy aut
r`tgdr tgd hejtr`ry. ndt us p`ss ej te ` hempndmdjt`ry stuiy* Ndt
us dx`mojd hdrt`oj etgdr djvorejmdjts oj wgohg tgd hejiotoejs
effdrdi te M`j g`vd oj f`ht addj d`sy. `ji stuiy tgd dffdht ej
gum`j nofd wgohg suhg djvorejmdjts g`vd preiuhdi* Kj `ttdmpt-
ojb tgos stuiy. wd must iostojbuosg adtwddj twe ioffdrdjt sotu`toejs*
Ygd forst os ejd oj wgohg pdepnd `rd ojtreiuhdi ojte `jd`fhy
djvorejmdjt `ftdr g`vojb novdi oj semd ioffohunt djvorejmdjt ef ejdef tgd lojis tg`t wd g`vd dx`mojdi `aevd* Ygd sdheji sotu`toej os
tg`t ef pdepnd oj `j d`sy djvorejmdjt wge g`vd jdvdr. se f`r `s
os ljewj. addj dxpesdi te `jy etgdr djvorejmdjt sojhd tgdor
prd-gum`j `jhdsters adh`md mdj* Oj etgdr weris. wd g`vd te
iostojbuosg adtwddj tgd rdspdhtovd dffdhts ef dxpesurd te `j d`sydjvorejmdjt upej M`jloji oj prehdss ef hovonoz`toej `ji upejSromotovd M`j* Ndt us id`n wotg tgd twe sotu`toejs sdp`r`tdny. oj
tgos eridr. `ji ndt us ejhd merd fennew tgd dmporoh`n mdtgei ef
ojquory wgohg wd g`vd dmpneydi se f`r*
Ndt us adboj wotg ` hn`ssoh dx`mpnd ef `j d`sy djvorejmdjtwgohg os subbdstdi ay tgd n`st dx`mpnd ef ` ioffohunt djvorejmdjttg`t g`s ehhupodi eur `ttdjtoej* Oj Hn`ssoh`n
Ot`ny. Qemd feuji gdr`jtotgdsos oj H`pu` `jetgdr brd`t `ji f`meus hoty wgesd idstojods
wdrd `s ioffdrdjt frem tgesd ef Qemd `s gdr surreujiojbs* Ygdo Ygos sddms te ad tgd pgonesepgy ef Ar`zon. te kuibd ay tgd fennewojb `mo`and s`yojbwgohg os rdpertdi te ad hurrdjt `mejb tgd Ar`zono`js ; "Fer twdnvd geurs oj tgd i`y wd ie
eur werst wotg tgd heujtry< aut fer tgd etgdr twdnvd geurs wd snddp. `ji tgdj Bei `jitgd heujtry put tgojbs robgt `b`oj!"
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 330/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@ 0?
H`pu`j H`mp`bj` w`s `s lojiny te M`j `s tgd Qem`j H`mp`bj`w`s ieur
<
x `ji wgond tgd Qem`js wdjt fertg frem tgdorferaoiiojb
heujtry te hejqudr ejd jdobgaeur `ftdr `jetgdr. tgd H`mp`jo`jss`t oj tgdor
smonojb heujtry `ji `nnewdi ejd jdobgaeur `ftdr`jetgdr te hejqudr tgdm* Frem gdr n`st hejqudrers. tgd X`mjotds
ef tgd @aruzzo. H`pu` w`s idnovdrdi. `t gdr ewj ojvot`toej. ay tgd
ojtdrvdjtoej ef Qemd gdrsdnf< `ji tgdj. `t tgd mest hrotoh`n memdjtef tgd mest hrotoh`n w`r oj Qem`j gostery. ej tgd merrew ef tgd
A`ttnd ef H`jj`d. H`pu` rdp`oi Qemd ay epdjojb gdr b`tds te
G`jjoa`n. oj tgd gepd ef rdhevdrojb gdr frddiem ay dxhg`jbojb ejd
p`trej fer `jetgdr. z @s f`r `s H`pu` w`s hejhdrjdi. tgdfutonoty ef
tgos
gepd
w`s wrottdjn`rbd
oj gdr
prdvoeus gostery<aut fer G`jjo-
a`n. oj gos w`r `b`ojst tgd forst hoty ef Ot`ny. tgd idfdhtoej ef tgd
sdheji hoty ef Ot`ny frem Qemd"s soid te gos neeldi nold ` b`oj wgohg
w`s quotd adyeji qudstoej* Oj f`ht. G`jjoa`n `ji gos Qem`j
eppejdjts wdrd ef ejd moji oj rdb`riojb H`pu`"s hg`jbd ef soids
`s adojb tgd projhop`n ommdio`td hejsdqudjhd ef tgd A`ttnd ef
H`jj`d `ji pdrg`ps tgd idhosovd dvdjt oj tgd w`r* G`jjoa`n
rdspejidi te tgd H`mp`jo`js" evdrturds ay rdp`orojb te H`pu` `ji
t`lojb up gos wojtdr-qu`rtdrs tgdrd wgdrdupej semdtgojb g`p-
pdjdi wgohg f`nsofodi dvdryaeiy"s dxpdht`toejs* @ wojtdr spdjt oj
H`pu` idmer`nozdi tgd treeps wge g`i kust `jjogon`tdi tgd brd`tdst
Qem`j `rmy tg`t g`i dvdr t`ldj tgd fodni*
"Ygd H`rtg`bojo`j `rmy. wgohg \G`jjoa`n] ldpt ujidr hevdr tgdrd \oj
H`pu`] fer tgd brd`tdr p`rt ef tgd wojtdr. g`i addj nejb `ji tgereubgnyg`ridjdi `b`ojst `nn tgd onns tg`t h`j `ffnoht M`jloji
<aut wgdj ot h`md
te tgd beei tgojbs ef tgos nofd. tgd treeps n`hldi aetg f`mono`roty `ji
dxpdrodjhd* @hheriojbny tgdsd gdreds wge g`i rdsostdi tgd utmest
`ss`unts ef `ivdrsoty wdrd ujiejd ay `j dxhdss ef prespdroty `ji djkey-mdjt< `ji tgdy fdnn gd`inejb. adh`usd tgdor nejb `astojdjhd m`id tgdm
pnujbd oj gd`i-evdr-d`rs* Ygd reuji ef snddpojb. irojlojb. d`tojb.
wgerojb. a`tgojb `ji t`lojb tgdor d`sd adh`md swddtdr te tgdm `s d`hg
p`ssojb i`y hejformdi tgd g`aot. ujton tgdy adh`md se djdrv`tdi ay ot.
aeiy `ji seun. tg`t tgdor s`fdty h`md te rdst oj tgd prdstobd ef tgdor p`st
vohterods r`tgdr tg`j oj tgd prdsdjt strdjbtg ef tgdor robgt `rms* Ot w`s
0 Ygd j`md H`mp`bj`. wgohg hnojbs te-i`y te tgd hr`ind ef tgd Qem`j Hemmej-wd`ntg oj tgd newn`jis adtwddj tgd ndft a`jl ef tgd Yoadr `ji tgd @na`j Gonns. eroboj`nny
adnejbdi 'oj ots N`toj spdnnojb "H`mp`jo`"/ te tgd newn`jis surreujiojb H`pu`. tgreubgwgohg tgd Venturjus fnews ej ots w`y frem tgd @aruzzo te tgd sd`. kust jertg ef J`pnds*Ygd j`md w`s dxtdjidi frem tgd b`tds ef J`pnds te tgd b`tds ef Qemd ay @ubustus. te
idsobj`tdejd ef tgd "rdboejs+ ojte wgohg gd rd-m`ppdi Qem`j Ot`ny< `ji tgd j`md g`s
pdrsostdi oj ` tdrrotery te wgohg ot w`s tgus `rtofoho`nny `ppnodi. `ftdr g`vojb iodi eut oj
tgd tdrrotery wgdrd ot w`s ojiobdjeus*1 Ot os jetdwertgy tg`t wgond H`pu`. `ftdr H`jj`d. adtr`ydi Qemd wge g`i feubgt
tgd X`mjotds ej gdr `hheujt. tgd X`mjotds. wge g`i addj feubgt `ji hejqudrdi ayQemd ej `hheujt ef H`pu`. rdm`ojdi ney`n te Qemd. wotg tgd sojbnd dxhdptoej
ef tgd
seutg-d`stdrjmest h`jtej ef tgd fermdr X`mjotd Hejfdidr`toej. tgd Gorpojo* Ygd
ney`nty ef tgd X`mjotds te tgd Qem`js iurojb tgd G`jjoa`noh R`r w`s `s rdm`rl`and `s
tg`t ef tgd Xolgs te tgd Arotosg iurojb tgd Ojio`j Mutojy*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 331/455
13 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tgd epojoej ef monot`ry dxpdrts tg`t. oj `nnewojb tgdm te hemd te tgos
p`ss. tgdor hemm`jidr hemmottdi ` stonn brd`tdr f`unt tg`j oj f`onojb te
m`rhg ej Qemd ommdio`tdny `ftdr tgd A`ttnd ef H`jj`d* Ot mobgt ad
`rbuditg`t gos ion`terojdss `ftdr H`jj`d g`i mdrdny pestpejdi tgd geur
ef foj`n vohtery. wgdrd`s gos drrer `t H`pu` g`i idprovdi gom ef tgd
strdjbtg te woj tgd w`r `t `nn*"0
G`jjoa`n"s f`t`n drrer w`s jdvdr hemmottdi ay tgd Qem`j
Bevdrjmdjt te tgd dji ef ots i`ys* Rgdj Qemd b`vd up tgd hej-
shropt `rmy dxdrhosdi ay tgd n`aeroeus gusa`jiry ef gdr H`m-
p`bj` wotg wgohg sgd g`i hejqudrdi tgd Rerni. oj eridr te
pn`hd gdr hejqudsts ujidr tgd bu`ri ef `j `rmy ef prefdssoej`ns.
sgd ioi jet m`ld tgd most`ld ef st`toejojb tgos jdw meidn `rmy oj
H`pu` er dvdj oj `jy ef tgesd idndht`and pn`hds `nejb tgd Qovodr`1
wgdrd tgd speonthgonirdj ef eur meidrj Rdstdrj Xehodty t`ld up
tgdor wojtdr-qu`rtdrs jew`i`ys* Xgd teel h`rd tg`t tgd seniodrs ef
tgd Dmpord sgeuni ad tdmpdrdi ay `j djvorejmdjt wgohg w`s jet
ndss sdvdrd tg`j tg`t wgohg g`i preiuhdi tgd rdieuat`and seniodrs
eftgd Qdpuanoh* Ygd ndboej`rods wge wdrd je nejbdr te ad dxdrhosdi
`s ydemdj oj tgd H`mp`bj`ay lddpojb ots m`rsgds oj ir`oj`bd `ji
ots fdnns ujidr tgd pneubg wdrd jew st`toejdi `nejb tgd Qgojd `ji
tgd I`juad `mejb tgd Yr`js`npojd ferdsts `ji r`ojs `ji frests.
te ad dxdrhosdi ay tgos jdw hg`nndjbd frem Sgysoh`n J`turd fer
tgdor aeridr w`rf`rd wotg tgd Jertg-Durepd`j a`ra`ro`js* Ygd
`veoi`jhd ef G`jjoa`n"s drrer ay @ubustus prenejbdi tgd nofd ef tgd
Qem`j Dmpord ay semd feur gujirdi yd`rs*8
@ubustus hnd`rny iovojdi tgd ojhemp`toaonoty adtwddj monot`ry
dffohodjhy `ji `j d`sy djvorejmdjt. `ji gd sdt gomsdnf te rdferm
tgd speont `ji ojsuaerioj`td seniodry wgohg gd ojgdrotdi frem tgd
hovon w`rs ay a`josgojb ot te bu`ri tgd frejtodrs ej tgd and`ldr soid
ef tgd @nps* Rgond tgd brd`t Qem`j st`tdsm`j w`s h`rryojb tgos
ioffohunt penohy tgreubg..w`s gd dvdr hejformdi oj gos rdsenutoej ay
`jy rdmojoshdjhds ef tgd Brddl notdr`turd oj wgohg gd g`i addj
diuh`tdi5
Ygd projhopnd wgohg bevdrjdi tgd monot`ry penohy ef @ubustusg`i addj m`id tgd suakdht ef ` f`and ay tgd Brddl gostero`j Gdre-
ietus feur hdjturods d`rnodr* Ygd f`and w`s hdndar`tdi. sojhd tgd
brd`t Brddl wrotdr g`i bovdj ot premojdjhd ay tdnnojb ot `s tgd t`on-
podhd ef gos werl<9 `ji tgd f`and w`s `nse
`pt. sojhd ot w`s teni ayoNovy. Aeel WWOOO. hg* 07*
` Ygd Qovodr`hejstotutojb. `s ot ioi `t tgd tomd. tgd projhop`n evdrn`ji reutdadtwddj Ot`ny `ji Yr`js`npojd Durepd weuni g`vd effdrdi + hejvdjodjt st`toej fertgd Ompdro`n ferhds frem ` purdny bdebr`pgohe-str`thboh`n peojt ef vodw*
8 Ef heursd dvdj ted st`tdsm`jsgop ef `j @ubustus w`s ejny `and te idn`y tgd ieemefQemd wotgeut adojb `and pdrm`jdjtny te `vdrt ot* Fer tgd dvdjtu`n tr`jsfdrdjhd ef tgdmonot`ry `ji penotoh`n pewdr oj tgd Qem`j Dmpord frem tgd g`jis ef tgd Qem`js tgdm-sdnvds te tgd g`jis ef tgd Yr`js`npojd a`ra`ro`js. sdd ON I 'v/. pp* 069-4. adnew*
9Gdreietus. Aeel OW. hg* 011*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 332/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 333/455
11 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Ygd Ydmpt`toejs ef Eiyssdus
Ygos f`and ef tgd Sdrso`js" Hgeohd. nold tgd trud stery ef G`jjo-
a`n"s @rmy `t H`pu`. sobjofods tg`t wgdj gum`j adojbs wge g`vd
addj novojb ujidr prdssurd `rd sdt `t d`sd. tgdor djdrbods `rd jet
rdnd`sdi aut `rd r`tgdr rdn`xdi ay tgos pnd`sur`and hg`jbd oj tgdor
hejiotoejs ef nofd* Ygd s`md hejhdptoej `ppd`rs oj ` werl ef
hn`ssoh`n notdr`turd tg`t os enidr `ji merd f`meus tg`j tgd gosterods
ef Gdreietus `ji Novy* Ot os tgd tgdmd ef tgesd feur aeels ef tgd
Eiyssdy0 oj wgohg tgd gdre tdnns @nhojeus tgd stery ef gos w`jidrojbs
frem tgd i`y wgdj gd s`ondi wotg gos hemp`joejs frem Yrey te
tgd i`y wgdj gd w`s w`sgdi up. tgd send survover. ej tgd sgerds ef
H`nypse"s osn`ji*
Oj tg`t nejb sdrods ef `ivdjturds. ot os jet wgdj gd os djheujtdr-
ojb gos ioffohuntods `ji i`jbdrs rujjojb tgd b`ujtndt ef tgd
N`dstrybejs er hejfrejtojb tgd Hyhneps er m`lojb tgd p`ss`bd
adtwddj Xhynn` `ji Hg`ryaios tg`t Eiyssdus hemds jd`rdst te
f`onurd oj gos strubbnd te m`ld gos w`y gemd te Otg`h`* Q`tgdr.
tgdsd erid`ns spddi gom ej gos heursd tew`ris tgd be`n ef gos
djid`veurs ay h`nnojb gos f`huntods ef `ui`hoty `ji jomanhjhss ef
wot `ji djiur`jhd `ji ojbdjuoty ojte `htoej*1
Gd hemds jd`rdst tef`onurd wgdj tgd rdsenutoej te pdrsdvdrd ej tgd ioffohunt `ji i`jbdr-
eus heursd tew`ris tgd keurjdy"s dji g`s te hempdtd wotg tgd
`ttr`htoejs ef `j `ssurdi `ji ommdio`td d`sd*
Ygus. wgdj tgd tgrdd hemp`joejs wgem gd sdjt eut ej ` rdhej-
j`oss`jhd ojte tgd n`ji eftgd netus-d`tdrs fdnn oj wotg tgd ojg`aot`jts.
"tgd netus-d`tdrs ioi jet adtgojl tgdm te ie eur hemp`joejs te id`tg.
aut b`vd tgdm ef tgd netus te t`std* @ji wgohg sedvdr ef tgdm ioi d`t
tg`t gejdy-swddt fruot. gd je nejbdr g`i tgd wonn te arojb a`hl toiojbsjer oj `jy wosd te rdturj< aut tgdor wonn w`s te rdm`oj tgdrd wotg tgd
netus-d`tdrs. fddiojb ej netus. `ji te tgojl je merd ef tgd gemdw`ri
vey`bd* Xe O teel tgdm te tgd sgops wddpojb. ujidr iurdss. `ji oj tgd
gennew sgops O ir`bbdi tgdm ujidr tgd adjhgds `ji aeuji tgdm tgdrd*
@ji tgdj O a`id tgd rdst efmy hemp`joejs hemd `ae`ri tgd swoft sgops
bnery ay aurjojb tgd Brd`t Lojb"s p`n`hd `t Sdrsdpenos* Ygd `tejy fodnis `ji and`l
p`sturds `moi wgohg tgd ruojdi p`n`hd steei'`ji st`jis te-i`y/ ioi jet dd`jd te arddi
w`rroers* @ndx`jidr gomsdnf w`s se iddpny omprdssdi ay tgd monot`ry vortud+ ef tgd
Ompdro`n Sdepndwgem gd g`i
kust evdrtgrewj tg`t gd djnostdi tgd idfd`tdi O"hm`joo ojgos ewj `rmy ej dqu`n tdrms wotg gos vohteroeus M`hdiejo`js. O n`i O nereietoM novdi` hdjtury n`tdr tg`j gd ioi. `ji h`rrodi gos j`rr`tovd ef tgd sdhun`r hejfnoht adtwddj tgdXyj`h `ji Gdnndjoh wernis iewj te tgd hnesd ef @ndx`jidr"s ir`m`toh hejtroautoej tetgd stery. gd mobgt g`vd h`ppdi gos f`and wotg ` prepgdhy 'oj go` orejoh vdoj/ tg`t tgdreubg heujtry wgohg g`i ardi seniodrs fer Hyrus `ji seniodrs fer @ndx`jidr weunihejtojud te ad`r tgdsd fermoi`and hreps se nejb `s tgd Sdrso`j pd`s`jt rdm`ojdi ej go+gemdstd`i te sew tgd ir`bej"s-teetg sddi.
+Eiyssdy
lAeels OW-WOO*
8+DvP`: Xt Yrer`/ o
.
3`wrete. >%:&evs eMv`vrds r`tpev)*
'Eiyssdy. OW. 00. 61-8 `ji 464-6*/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 334/455
W@@DOK@ Y@ L@@@ 18
wotg `nn spddi. ndst `jy m`j sgeuni nesd tgeubgt ef tgd vey`bd gemd ayd`tojb ef tgd netus*"
0
@b`oj. wgdj g`nf gos sgop"s hemp`jy `hhdptdi Horhd"s ojvot`toej
te hemd ojte gdr p`rneur.
"sgd ndi tgdm oj `ji b`vd tgdm adjhgds `ji hg`ors te sot ej `ji moxdi
fer tgdm hgddsd `ji a`rndy `ji ydnnew gejdy oj Sr`mjd`j wojd< `ji
`mejb tgd feei sgd sprojlndi a`jdfun irubs. te m`ld tgdm uttdrny
ferbdt tgdor j`tovd n`ji* @ji tgdj wgdj sgd g`i bovdj ot te tgdm `ji
tgdy g`i irujl ot up. str`obgtw`y sgd smetd tgdm wotg gdr st`ff `ji
pdjjdi tgdm oj pob-styds* @ji. ne. tgdy g`i tgd gd`is ef swojd `ji tgd
veohd `ji tgd arostnds. yd` `ji tgd aeiy tgdrdef.1`nadot tgdor ujidr-
st`jiojb w`s std`if`st `s `ferdtomd*" 8
Ot jddidi jet ejny Eiyssdus"s gum`j sweri aut Gdrmds" iovojd
gdra te rdshud tgd peer feens frem Horhd"s an`hl m`boh*
Ygdrd`ftdr. Eiyssdus gomsdnf weuni g`vd bejd idnoadr`tdny te
gos id`tg. oj tgd Xordjs" hnuthgds. wgdj tgd djhg`jtmdjt ef tgdor
sojbojb fdnn upej gos d`rs. g`i gd jet adferdg`ji steppdi gos hem-
p`joejs" d`rs wotg w`x `ji m`id tgdm aoji gom g`ji `ji feet te
tgd m`st `ji djkeojdi upej tgdm ejny te muntopny gos aejis of gd
adseubgt tgdm te rdnd`sd gom*9
Sdrg`ps tgd gdre os nd`st gdreoh wgdj. sgopwrdhldi `ji `nejd.
gd os w`sgdi up ej H`nypse"s osn`ji `ji os lojiny djtrd`tdi ay tgd
Beiidss4 ` f`ordr tg`j Sdjdnepd6 wge t`lds gom te iwdnn wotg
gdr oj gdr d`rtgny p`r`iosd2`ji premosds gom `j ommert`notyef pdr-
pdtu`n yeutg*7 Gd fojis s`nv`toej wgdj tgd jympg hd`sds te pnd`sd
gom wgdj gd adbojs te p`ss gos jobgts `s `j ujwonnojb nevdr oj gdr
wonnojb `rms `ji gos i`ys sottojb ej tgd sd`-sgerd '`s gd os sgewj
`t gos forst `ppd`r`jhd oj tgd pedm/ wotg gos dyds jdvdr iry ef td`rs
`ji gos nofd daaojb `w`y oj gos nejbojb fer gemd*? Ygos rdvent. oj
tgd dobgtg yd`r ef ` p`ssovd h`ptovoty.03`b`ojst ` st`td ef mdn`jhgeny
d`sd oj wgohg gd mobgt g`vd hejtojudi fer dvdrmerd. os tgd ojw`ri
rdnd`sd wgohg g`s ots dxtdrj`n heujtdrp`rt oj tgd ojtdrhdssoej ef
@tgdjd adferd tgd tgrejd ef [dus `ji oj tgd noadr`tojb mossoej
ef Gdrmds* 00 Rgdj H`nypse pnd`is wotg gom. `t tgd n`st memdjt.
te rdm`oj. Eiyssdus `jswdrs ;
0
N`iy Beiidss. ad jet wretg wotg md fer tgos* O. dvdj O. ljew ot `nn ;
O ljew tg`t tgd pruidjt Sdjdnepd os jet te ad hemp`rdi wotg tgdd. oj
r Ei* OW. 00* ?1-031* @j gosteroh`n `j`nebud te tgos ndbdji`ry ojhoidjt os tgd seperofoh
dffdht upej tgd Senyjdso`j j`vob`ters ef tgd swddts ef rdpesd ej tgd Xeutg Xd` Osn`jis*
'Xdd pp* 08-04. `aevd/+ Hemp`rd Sn`te"s idshroptoej ef "tgd Hoty ef Xwojd+ m Ygd Qdpuanoh. 86?8-8213.
wgohg os hotdi `aevd m S`rt OO* A. ven* o. p* 0?8. feetjetd o*
8 Ei* W* T* 188-93*> Ei* WOO. 00* 8?-49 `ji 048-133*
+ Ei* Vg. 00* 144-2*+ Ei* V. 00* 100-07*
2 Xdd tgd ad`utofun idshroptoej ef ot. `s Gdrmds s`w ot. oj Ei* V. 00* 68-29.7 Ei* V. 0* 13?. `ji VOO. 0* 142* Ei* V. 00* 040-7*03 Ei* VOO. 00* 14?-60* Ei* V. T* 0-097*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 335/455
19 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
foburd jer oj st`turd. f`hd te f`hd* Xgd os ` mert`n wem`j. wgond tgeu `rt
id`tgndss `ji `bdndss*_dt jejd tgd ndss O nejb `ji pr`y i`ony te rd`hg
my gemd `ji te adgeni tgd i`y efmy rdturjojb* _d`. `ji of semd Bei
sg`nn wrdhl md oj tgd wojd-f`hdi sd`. O wonn djiurd ot* Fer O g`vd oj
my ard`st ` sporotwdnn shgeendi oj djiurojb serrews* @nrd`iy g`vd O
suffdrdi funn m`jy. `ji g`vd aerjd tgd auffdrojbs ef w`vd `ji w`r*
O h`rd jet of tgos etgdr anew ad `iidi ujte tgesd* :x
Rgdj Eiyssdus spd`ls tgdsd weris. gd os gos hnd`r-sobgtdi `ji
ojiemot`and sdnf `b`oj< `ji jetgojb jet dvdj Sesdoiej"s foj`n
streld ef m`nohd. wgohg tgd gdre ferdsdds h`j prdvdjt gom frem
rd`hgojb Otg`h` jew* Merdevdr. `s gd ljews `nrd`iy frem tgd
meutg ef Ydordso`s" bgest. gd wonn jet rdst ej gos e`rs. dvdj wgdj
gd g`s rdb`ojdi gos gemd `ji sn`oj Sdjdnepd"s suoters* @jetgdr
keurjdy `w`ots gom. oj wgohg gd must ad`r gos e`r ej gos sgeunidr
`ji dxhg`jbd tgd teons `ji pdronsef tgd sd` fer tgesd ef tgd n`ji* 1
Ygd Fndsg Sets ef Dbypt
Ygos metofoj tgd Gdnndjoh stery ef Eiyssdus" rdturj frem Yrey te
Otg`h` `ppd`rs. oj ` v`ro`jt ferm. oj tgd Xyro`h stery ef tgd Hgesdj
Sdepnd"s dxeius frem Dbypt te tgd Sremosdi N`ji* Ygd `ttr`htoej
wgohg ujidrmojds tgd rdsenutoej ef tgd Osr`dnotds iurojb tgdor
w`jidrojbs oj tgd wonidrjdss os jet tgd prdsdjt idnobgt ef ` Netus
N`ji er ` H`nypse"s Osnd. aut ` g`jldrojb `ftdr tgd fndsg pets ef
Dbypt.8 wgohg m`y pdrg`ps ad tgdors `b`oj te-merrew of ejny tgdy
turj a`hl jew* Ygdy g`vd je seejdr hressdi tgd sd` iry-sgei. `ji
sddj Sg`r`eg `ji gos gest pdrosg oj tgd rdturjojb w`tdrs. tg`j tgdy
adboj te murmur oj tgd wonidrjdss `b`ojst Mesds `ji @`rej ;
"Reuni te Bei wd g`i iodi ay tgd g`ji ef tgd Neri oj tgd N`ji ef
Dbypt. wgdj wd s`t ay tgd fndsg pets `ji wgdj wd ioi h`t ard`i te tgdfunn< fer yd g`vd areubgt us fertg ojte tgos wonidrjdss te lonn tgos wgend
`ssdmany wotg gujbdr*9
* * *
"Rgdrdferd os tgos tg`t tgeu g`st areubgt us up eut ef Dbypt. te lonn
us `ji eur hgonirdj `ji eur h`ttnd wotg tgorst5 4* * .
"Rge sg`nn bovd us fndsg te d`t5 Rd rdmdmadr tgd fosg wgohg wd ioi
d`t oj Dbypt frddny tgd huhumadrs `ji tgd mdnejs `ji tgd nddls `ji tgd
ejoejs `ji tgd b`rnoh aut jew eur seun os irodi `w`y; tgdrd os jetgojb`t `nn adsoid tgos m`jj` adferd eur dyds*"
6
Dvdj wgdj tgdy g`vd hressdi tgd wonidrjdss `s sX`fdny `s tgdy g`ihressdi tgd sd`. `ji st`ji `t n`st ej tgd tgrdsgeni ef H`j``j. tgdor
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 336/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@ 14
tgeubgts fny a`hl te Dbypt `s tgdy nostdj te tgd dvon rdpert ef tgdor
spods tgdor sobgt ef tgd Xejs ef @j`l. tgd hgonirdj ef tgd bo`jts.
oj wgesd prdsdjhd tgd spods g`i sddmdi `ji fdnt nold br`ssgeppdrs*
"@ji `nn tgd hejbrdb`toej noftdi up tgdor veohd `ji hrodi< `ji tgd
pdepnd wdpt tg`t jobgt* @ji `nn tgd hgonirdj ef Osr`dn murmurdi
`b`ojst Mesds `ji `b`ojst @`rej. `ji tgd wgend hejbrdb`toej s`oi ujte
tgdm; Reuni Bei tg`t wd g`i iodi oj tgd n`ji ef Dbypt! Er weuni
Bei wd g`i iodi oj tgos wonidrjdss! @ji wgdrdferd g`tg tgd Neri
areubgt us ujte tgos n`ji. te f`nn ay tgd sweri. tg`t eur wovds `ji eur
hgonirdj sgeuni ad ` prdy5 Rdrd ot jet adttdr fer us te rdturj ojte
Dbypt5 @ji tgdy s`oi ejd te `jetgdr; Ndt us m`ld ` h`pt`oj `ji
ndt us rdturj ojte Dbypt*K0
Ygd Hgesdj Sdepnd `rd uj`and te djtdr ojte tgdor ojgdrot`jhd ujton
tgos g`ujtojb `ji djdrv`tojb rdhenndhtoej ef tgd fndsg pets g`s addj
dff`hdi< `ji ot os jet dff`hdi ujton ferty yd`rs ef purb`tery spdjtoj w`jidrojb evdr tgd f`hd ef tgd wonidrjdss wgohg tgdy g`vd kust
put adgoji tgdm oj ejd str`obgt `ji r`poi trdl g`vd areubgttgd enidr bdjdr`toej te tgd br`vd `ji tgd yeujbdr bdjdr`toej te
m`jgeei* 1
YgdIe`syeunolds
Ygdsd p`ss`bds frem mytg `ji gostery surdny idmejstr`td.
adtwddj tgdm. tg`t wgdj pdepnd `rd tr`jsn`tdi wgdtgdr oj "rd`n
nofd+ er oj om`boj`toej frem hejiotoejs ef prdssurd ojte hejiotoejs
ef d`sd. tgd dffdht upej tgdor adg`voeur os idmer`nozojb* Ot m`y
pdrg`ps ad rdtertdi tg`t tgos os ` truosm. `ji tg`t wd mobgt g`vd
sp`rdi eursdnvds tgd treuand ef idmejstr`tojb tgd f`ht `ji jet
g`vd evdrneeldi tgd eavoeus dxpn`j`toej* Ygd onn dffdht. ot m`y
ad `rbudi.os
` hejsdqudjhd ef tgd prehdss ef tr`jsotoej `ji jet `
hejsdqudjhd ef tgd hejiotoej oj wgohg tgd tr`jsotoej rdsunts. "_eu
ojfdr. frem tgd onnustr`toejs wgohg yeu g`vd put adferd us. tg`t
hejiotoejs ef d`sd `rd ojomoh`n te hovonoz`toej oj tgdmsdnvds* _eu
mobgt `s wdnn `rbud tg`t ` funn stem`hg os ojomoh`n te gd`ntg ej tgd
breuji tg`t ` gd`vy md`n g`s addj ljewj te prevd f`t`n te `
st`rvojb m`j* _eu ljew vdry wdnn tg`t tgd prepdr trd`tmdjt fer
st`rv`toej os jdotgdr te fonn tgd p`todjt"s dmpty stem`hg `t ejd
sottojb
jer te
lddp
gom `t st`rv`toej
peojt
oj
pdrpdtuoty.
aut te
rd-`hhustem gom te t`lojb ` jerm`n `meujt ef jeurosgmdjt ay
ojhrd`sojb gos r`toej br`iu`nny* Ygd ios`streus dffdht ef tgd gd`vy
md`n upej tgd gd`ntg eftgd st`rvojbm`jw`s iud jette `jyojgdrdjt
f`unt oj tgd qu`jtoty ef tgd funn r`toej. aut sendny te tgd r`sg `arupt-
jdss wotg wgohg ot w`s `imojostdrdi*" Oj eridr te mddt tgos
+ Jumadrs xvo* 0-9*+ Jumadrs xov* `6-8X- Ej tgos peojt. sdd `nse OO* H 'oo/ 'a/ 1. ven* o. pp* 889-4o
`aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 337/455
16 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
hrotohosm. wd must turj te tgd sdheji ef tgd twe sotu`toejs wgohg
wd g`vd iostojbuosgdi `aevd tgd sotu`toej ef pdepnd oj `j d`sy
djvorejmdjt wge g`vd jdvdr. se f`r `s os ljewj. addj dxpesdi te
`jy etgdr djvorejmdjt sojhd tgdor prd-gum`j `jhdsters adh`md
mdj* Oj tgos h`sd. tgd f`hter ef tr`jsotoej os dnomoj`tdi `ji wd `rd
dj`andi te stuiy tgd dffdht ef d`sy hejiotoejs oj tgd `asenutd*
Gdrd os `j `utgdjtoh pohturd ef ot frem Jy`s`n`ji. `s sddj ay `
Rdstdrj easdrvdr. jd`rny g`nf ` hdjtury `be. oj tgd d`rny i`ys ef
"tgd epdjojb-up ef @froh`";
"Goiidj `w`y oj tgdsd djindss ferdsts. nold aoris" jdsts oj ` weei. oj
tdrrer ef ejd `jetgdr. `ji ef tgdor hemmej fed. tgd sn`vdr. `rd sm`nnj`tovd vonn`bds< `ji gdrd oj gos vorboj sompnohoty iwdnns Srom`dv`n M`j.wotgeut hnetgds. wotgeut hovonos`toej. wotgeut nd`rjojb. wotgeut rdnoboej
tgd bdjuojd hgoni ef J`turd. tgeubgtndss. h`rdndss. `ji hejtdjtdi*
Ygos m`j os `pp`rdjtny quotd g`ppy< gd g`s pr`htoh`nny je w`jts* Ejd
stohl. peojtdi. m`lds gom ` spd`r< twe stohls ruaadi tebdtgdr m`ld gom
` ford< fofty stohls todi tebdtgdr m`ld gom ` geusd* Ygd a`rl gd pddns
frem tgdm m`lds gos hnetgds< tgd fruots wgohg g`jb ej tgdm ferm gos
feei* Ot os pdrfdhtny `stejosgojb. wgdj ejd tgojls ef ot. wg`t J`turd h`j
ie fer tgd `jom`n-m`j. te sdd wotg wg`t sm`nn h`pot`n `ftdr `nn ` gum`j
adojb h`j bdt tgreubg tgd Rerni* O ejhd s`w `j @froh`j aurodi* @hheri-
ojb te tgd hustem ef gos troad. gos djtord d`rtgny pessdssoejs `ji gd w`s
`j `vdr`bd hemmejdr wdrd aurodi wotg gom* Ojte tgd br`vd. `ftdr tgd
aeiy. w`s newdrdi tgd id`i m`j"s popd. tgdj ` reubg ljofd. tgdj `
mui aewn. `ji n`st gos aew `ji `rrews tgd aewstrojb hut tgreubg tgd
moiind. ` teuhgojb symaen tg`t ots werl w`s iejd* Yg`t w`s `nn* Feur
otdms. `s `j `uhtoejddr weuni s`y. wdrd tgd wgend adnejbojbs fer g`nf `
hdjtury ef tgos gum`j adojb* Je m`j ljews wg`t ` m`j os tonn gd g`s
sddj wg`t ` m`j h`j ad wotgeut. `ji ad wotg`n ` m`j* Yg`t os te s`y. je
m`j ljews gew brd`tM`j os tonn gd g`s sddj gew sm`nn gd g`s addj ejhd*"Ygd @froh`j os eftdj an`mdi fer adojb n`zy. aut ot os ` mosusd efweris*
Gd ieds jet jddi te werl< wotg se aeujtofun ` J`turd reuji gom ot
weuni ad br`tuoteus te werl* @ji gos ojiendjhd. tgdrdferd. `s ot os
h`nndi. os kust `s muhg ` p`rt ef gomsdnf `s gos fn`t jesd. `ji `s nottnd
an`mdwertgy `s snewjdss oj ` terteosd* Ygd f`ht os. @froh` os ` j`toej ef
tgd ujdmpneydi*"Ygos hempndtdjdss. gewdvdr. wonn ad ` s`i ir`wa`hl te idvdnepmdjt*
@nrd`iy ot os feuji ioffohunt te hrd`td jdw w`jts<`ji wgdj n`aeur os
rdquordi. `ji yeu g`vd `nrd`iy p`oi yeur m`j ` y`ri ef h`nohe `ji `strojb ef ad`is. yeu g`vd jetgojb oj yeur pessdssoej te aroad gom te
`jetgdr g`ji"s turj* Jetgojb `nmest tg`t yeu g`vd weuni ad tgd
snobgtdst usd te gom* * * *
+@ fojd-neelojb pdepnd. quodt `ji iemdstoh. tgdor nofd-gostery frem tgdhr`ind te tgd br`vd os ef tgd utmest
sompnohoty* Yee onn `rmdi te gujt.tgdy novd `nn aut dxhnusovdny ej ` vdbdt`and iodt* @ sm`nn p`rt ef tgd yd`rtgdy idpdji. nold tgd mejldys. upej woni fruots `ji gdras< aut tgd
st`pnd feei os ` sm`nn t`stdndss monndt-sddi wgohg tgdy brew oj b`ridjs.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 338/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@ 12
hrusg oj ` mert`r. `ji stor wotg w`tdr ojte ` tgohl perroibd* Ywohd `
i`y. jd`rny `nn tgd yd`r reuji. d`hg m`j stuffs gomsdnf wotg tgos he`rsd
`ji t`stdndss ieubg. sgevdnnojb ot ojte gos meutg oj g`jifuns. `ji hej-
sumojb `t ` sottojb ` pond tgd sozd ef `j `jt-gd`p* Gos ejd ehhup`toej os te
brew tgos monndt. `ji gos b`ridjojb os ` huroesoty* Xdndhtojb ` spet oj tgd
ferdst. gd hnomas ` trdd. `ji wotg ` sm`nn gemd-m`id `xd neps eff tgd
ar`jhgds ejd ay ejd* Gd tgdj w`ids tgreubg tgd nottdr te tgd jdxt trdd.
`ji g`hls ot te podhds `nse. nd`vojb tgd trujl st`jiojb drdht* Tpej `nn
tgd trdds wotgoj ` horhnd ef tgorty er ferty y`ris" io`mdtdr gos `xd werls
somon`r g`veh. tonn tgd breuji st`jis ard`st-gobg oj nd`vds `ji ar`jhgds*
Jdxt. tgd wgend os sdt ej ford `ji aurjt te `sgds* Ygdj. wgdj tgd forst
r`ojs meostdj tgd g`ri breuji `ji w`sg tgd fdrtond hgdmoh`n hejstotudjts
ef tgd `sg ojte tgd seon. gd `tt`hls ot wotg gos ged. ireps oj ` fdw g`ji-
funs ef monndt. `ji tgd yd`r"s werl os evdr* Aut ` fdw wddls eff `ji ej`rd rdquordi fer tgdsd epdr`toejs. `ji gd m`y be te snddp tonn tgd r`ojs `rd
evdr. `ssurdi ef ` hrep wgohg jdvdr f`ons. wgohg os jdvdr peer. `ji wgohg
wonn n`st gom tonn tgd r`ojs rdturj `b`oj*
"Adtwddj tgd `hts gd ieds jetgojb aut neujbd `ji snddp <gos wofd. er
wovds. `rd tgd monndrs `ji a`ldrs< tgdy werl g`ri te prdp`rd gos feei.
`ji `rd rdw`ridi ay g`vojb te t`ld tgdor ewj md`ns `p`rt. fer je @froh`j
weuni dvdr idmd`j gomsdnf ay d`tojb wotg ` wem`j* O g`vd trodi te
tgojl ef semdtgojb dnsd tg`t tgdsd pdepnd g`aotu`nny ie. aut tgdor
v`hueus nofd nd`vds jetgojb merd te tdnn*"0
Ygos podhd ef forst-g`ji tdstomejy te tgd Xtges `ji adg`voeur ef
M`rx oj `j d`sy djvorejmdjt g`s addj hgesdj fer quet`toej gdrd
adh`usd ef tgd rdm`rl`and sg`rpjdss ef vosoej `ji idptg ef ojsobgt
wgohg tgd wotjdss iospn`ys <aut ef heursd gos dvoidjhd ieds jet
st`ji `nejd* Ot heuni ad suppertdi. of tg`t wdrd jdhdss`ry. ay etgdr
meidrj Rdstdrj dvoidjhd. r`jbojb oj Yomd evdr tgd feur hdjturods
tg`t g`vd dn`psdi sojhd Rdstdrj M`j forst adb`j te t`ld tgd wgend
Rerni fer gos fodni. `ji r`jbojb oj Xp`hd evdr `nn p`rts ef tgd
Rerni wgdrd gd g`s feuji promotovd sehodtods stonn survovojb*1
Frem tgd eppesotd dxtrdmoty ef Yrepoh`n @froh`. wd heuni hotd
somon`r idshroptoejs ef tgd nofd ef tgd Iojl` `ji tgd Xgonnul ` nofd
wgohg dxgoaots te-i`y. nold semd spdhomdj oj "` novojb musdum". tgd
horhumst`jhds oj wgohg tgd f`tgdrs ef tgd Dbypto`h Hovonoz`toej
wdrd novojb adferd tgdy rdspejidi te tgd hg`nndjbd ef idsohh`toej
`ji pnujbdi ojte tgd kujbnd-sw`mp ef tgd Newdr Jond V`nndy*8
+Irummejhn. G*; Yrepoh`n @froh` 'Nejiej 0777. Geiidr `ji Xteubgtej/. pp* 44-6
`ji 47-?*` kfer ` survdy `ji hn`ssofoh`toej ef promotovd sehodtods tg`t g`vd hemd ujidr tgd iordht
easdrv`toej ef eur meidrj Rdstdrj dxpnerdrs `ji `jtgrepenebosts. sdd Ygd M`tdro`n
Hunturd `ji Xeho`n Ojstotutoejs ef tgd Xompndr Sdepnds; `j dss`y oj herrdn`toej. ay Gea-
geusd. N* Y*. Rgddndr. B* H** `ji Bojsadrb. M* 'Nejiej 0?04. Hg`pm`j `ji G`nn.
rdprojtdi oj 0?83/. wgohg g`s addj hotdi `aevd oj O* H 'm/ '`^ ven* o. p* 092. feetjetd `
8 Xdh tgd idshroptoej ef tgd seho`n ojstotutoejs ef tgd Iojl` `ji tgd Xgonnul wgohg g`s
addj quetdi `aevd oj OO* H 'oo/ '6/ 1. ven*o.ej p* 808. frem Hgonid. V* B*; Ygd Mest
@jhodjt D`st 'Nejiej 0?17. Ldb`j S`un/. pp* 03-0 0* Fer ` funndr `hheujt. sdd Xdnobm`j.
H* B* `ji A* [*; S`b`j Yroads ef tgd Jonetoh Xui`j 'Nejiej 0?81. Qeutndibd/*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 339/455
17 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
@b`oj. tgos Yrepoh`n @froh`j dvoidjhd heuni ad rdojferhdi ay
rdheris ef promotovd trepoh`n nofd oj iost`jt nejbotuids ; oj @m`zejo` 0
er oj Mdn`jdso`*1 @nn tgos meidrj Rdstdrj dvoidjhd os rd`iony
`hhdssoand< `ji fer tgos rd`sej wd wonn geni ot oj rdsdrvd `jiwonn
hnesd eur rdvodw ef tgd dffdht ef d`sy hejiotoejs oj tgd `asenutd '`s
iostojht frem tgd dffdht ef d`sy hejiotoejs suhhddiojb te ioffohunt
hejiotoejs. wgohg wd g`vd dx`mojdi `nrd`iy/ ay hotojb ` idshrop-
toej ef Gdnndjoh `utgersgop. `nadot tgos idshroptoej os ejny bovdj `t
sdheji g`ji `ji g`s m`jofdstny addj djrohgdi ay hdrt`oj ndbdji`ry
teuhgds* Gdrd os Gdreietus"s `hheujt ef ` pdepnd h`nndi tgd @rbop-
p`do wge wdrd te ad feuji `t tgd f`rtgdst dxtrdmoty. `s ot steei oj
gos
i`y.
ef tgd tr`id-reutdnd`iojb
frem tgd Brddl sdttndmdjts ej
tgd jertg he`st ef tgd An`hl Xd` jertg-d`stw`ri ojte tgd ojtdroer ef
tgd brd`t Dur`so`j Xtdppd ;8
"Tp te tgos peojt. tgd wgend ef tgd heujtry tg`t O g`vd idshroadi os
pn`oj-n`ji wotg ` iddp seon. aut frem tgos peojt ejw`ris ot os areldj
heujtry `ji tgd seon os stejy* Of yeu hress tgos areldj heujtry `ji
tgdrd os ` brd`t strdthg ef ot yeu hemd te tgd feetgonns ef nefty meuj-
t`ojs<`ji tgdsd feetgonns `rd ojg`aotdi ay pdepnd wge `rd `nn a`ni frem
aortg. mdj `ji wemdj `nold* Ygdy `nse g`vd sjua jesds `ji ausgy
ad`ris. `ji ` n`jbu`bd ef tgdor ewj. tgeubg tgdy wd`r Xhytgo`j hnetgds<`ji tgdy novd eff trdds* Ygd trdd effwgohg tgdy novd os h`nndi tgd Sejtohum*
Ot os kust `aeut tgd sozd ef ` fob-trdd. `ji ot ad`rs ` fruot tgd sozd ef ` ad`j.
wotg ` stejd oj ot* Rgdj tgd fruot ropdjs. tgdy a`b ot oj hnetgs. `ji tgdj
ot dxuids ` tgohl an`hl suast`jhd wgohg os h`nndi `shgy* Ygos tgdy dotgdr
suhl er irojl moxdi wotg monl. wgond frem tgd tgohl irdbs tgdy m`ldh`lds `ji usd tgdsd fer senoi feei* Ygdy g`vd jet muhg novdstehl
adh`usd tgdrd os jet `jy beei p`sturdn`ji tgdrd<aut dvdry m`j novds
ujidr gos trdd* Oj tgd wojtdr gd hevdrs oj tgd trdd wotg ` tdjt ef hnesd
wgotd fdnt< oj tgd summdr gd novds ujidr tgd trdd oj tgd epdj* Ygdsdpdepnd `rd jet onn-trd`tdi ay `jyaeiy* Ygdy `rd ndft oj pd`hd adh`usd
tgdy `rd rdb`ridi `s geny. `ji tgdy pessdss je `rms* Ygdor jdobgaeurs
arojb tgdor iosputds te tgdm fer `raotr`toej. `ji `jyejd wge t`lds
`synum wotg tgdm os s`fd frem ojkury*"9
Ygos Gdnndjoh idshroptoej ef promotovd nofd oj Hdjtr`n @so` `ji
tgd ferdbeojb Rdstdrj idshroptoej ef promotovd nofd oj Hdjtr`n
@froh` bovd. adtwddj tgdm. ` hnd`r pohturd ef gew M`j ieds novd
wgdrd gd g`s jdvdr addjdxpesdi
te `hg`nndjbd
dotgdr frem tgd
0 Fer tgd `asdjhd ef rdspejsd te `jy stomunus frem tgd djvorejmdjt oj tgd @m`zejA`soj 'dxhdpt. ef heursd. ej ots @jid`j rom/. sdd tgd `nnusoejs oj Md`js. S* @ ; @jhodjtHovonos`toejs ef tgd @jids 'Jdw _erl 0?80. Xhroajdr/. p* 1). qu`nofodi ay Jeridjslotfni"`easdrv`toejs wgohg g`vd addj hotdi oj OO* H 'oo/ '`/ 1. ven* o. ej p* 14?. feetjetd o. `aevd*
1 Xdd M`nojewslo. A*; @rbej`uts ef tgd S`hofoh 'Nejiej 0?11. Qeutndibd/*8 Ygd pessoaonoty tg`t. ` hdjtury er se adferd Gdreietus"s i`y. tgos tr`id-reutd m`y
g`vd dxtdjidi robgt `hress tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd. frem tgd jertg-d`stdrj dxtrdmoty ef tgdGdnndjoh Rerni te tgd jertg-wdstdrj dxtrdmoty ef tgd Xojoh Rerni. os dx`mojdi ayGuisej. B* F*. m Durepd `ji Hgoj`; @ Xurvdy ef tgdor Qdn`toejsfrem tgd D`rnodst Yomdste 0733 'Nejiej 0?80. Diw`ri @rjeni/. hg* o * "Adyeji tgd Jertg Roji"*
+Gdreietus. Aeel OV. hg* 18* Xdd `nse hgs* 19 `ji 14*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 340/455
W@@DG@ Y@ L@@@ 1?
pgysoh`ner frem tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt* Gd vdbdt`tds. quotd
hemfert`any `ji g`ppony. oj ` st`td ef ndtg`rby< `ji. te `nn `ppd`r-
`jhd. gd mobgt hejtojud te vdbdt`td ojpdrpdtuoty. wdrd gd jet ej
tgdpeojt
efadojb dxpesdi
te `fermoi`and hg`nndjbd frem tgd
gum`j djvorejmdjt `t n`st*
Ygos ommojdjt hg`nndjbd os pertdjidi oj tgd vdry f`ht tg`t gos
m`jjdr ef nofd g`s hemd ujidr tgd easdrv`toej ef ejd ef tgesd
djdrbdtoh sehodtods tg`t `rd oj prehdss ef hovonoz`toej< fer gos
djheujtdr wotg tgdsd ompertuj`td str`jbdrs wonn jet dji oj `
mdrd pn`tejoh `hqu`ojt`jhd* Ygdy easdrvd oj eridr te t`ld `htoej<
`ji. wgdj ejhd tgd dxpnerdr g`s hressdi tgd promotovd"s tgrdsgeni.
tgd tr`idr `ji tgd mossoej`ry `ji tgd seniodr `rd surd te fennew oj
quohl suhhdssoej `t tgd dxpnerdr"s gddns* Ygd promotovd"s osen`toej
os tdrmoj`tdi. gos pd`hd os areldj. gos hemfert `ji g`ppojdss `rd
rdpn`hdi ay ` hejshoeusjdss ef prdssurd `ji ` fddnojb ef `jxodty*
Oj f`ht. gd os hejfrejtdi ay ` hg`nndjbd ujidr wgohg ot os ompessoand
fer gos ndtg`rby te pdrsost* Ygd ndtg`rby m`y p`ss ojte id`tg er ot
m`y p`ss ojte `htoej. aut ej dotgdr `ntdrj`tovd ot wonn p`ss `w`y*Ygd pessoand `ntdrj`tovd euthemds ef hennosoejs adtwddj promotovd
sehodtods `ji sehodtods oj prehdss ef hovonoz`toej `rd dx`mojdi oj
n`tdr p`rts ef tgos Xtuiy*0 Oj tgos pn`hd wd `rd hejhdrjdi sendny wotg
tgd st`td oj wgohg tgd promotovd sehodtods `rd feuji dxostojb `t tgd
memdjt wgdj tgd forst hejt`ht t`lds pn`hd* Ygos st`td m`lds ` pre-
feuji omprdssoej upej tgd ojtruidrs adh`usd tgdrd os `j dxtrdmd
hejtr`st adtwddj tgd twe hennoiojb w`ys ef nofd adtwddj tgd Xtges
ef pdepnd wge g`vd addj sgdntdrdi frem hg`nndjbds gotgdrte ay `j
d`sy djvorejmdjt `ji tgd fdtges ef pdepnd wge g`vd addj hg`nndjbdi
`ji g`vd rdspejidi vohteroeusny* Ygos omprdssoej werls se pewdr-
funny upej tgd ojtruidrs" dmetoejs `ji om`boj`toej tg`t ot ossuds oj
mytgeneby*
Ygd hn`ssoh Gdnndjoh dxpesotoej ef tgd mytg os tgd f`and ef tgd
Netus D`tdrs. wgohg wd g`vd quetdi `nrd`iy `prepes ef tgd dffdht
ef tgd netus fruot upej Eiyssdus" hemp`joejs*1 @ hn`ssoh Rdstdrj
dxpesotoej os "Ygd Gostery ef tgd Brd`t `ji F`meus J`toej ef tgd
Ie`syeunolds. wge h`md `w`y frem tgd Heujtry ef G`riwerl
adh`usd tgdy w`jtdi te pn`y ej tgd Kdws" G`rp `nn i`y nejb"* Oj
Hg`rnds Lojbsndy"s f`and. `j omprevoidjt pdepnd wge pdrsost oj
novojb ` nofd ef promotovd d`sd oj `j d`rtgny p`r`iosd evdrsg`iewdi
ay tgd druptovd hr`tdr ef Dtj`. p`y tgd pdj`nty ay idbdjdr`tojb
ojte Yrepoh`n @froh`j beronn`s*Ygos os tgd hempndmdjt te `jetgdr
Rdstdrj f`and wgohg wd g`vd id`nt wotg oj `j d`rnodr hg`ptdr;8
+ Oj ` bdjdr`n w`y tgdy `rd dx`mojdi oj S`rt VOOO< tgd spdho`n h`sd ef tgd hennosoejs
adtwddj promotovd sehodtods `ji eur Rdstdrj Hovonoz`toej os furtgdr dx`mojdi ojoj
k*VYY
` Xdd pp* 11-8. `aevd* 8 Xdd OO. H 'oo/ '`/ O. ven*o. pp* 106-10. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 341/455
83 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
"Ygd Gostery ef tg`t Vortueus `ji Srevoidjt Hrd`turd Jerioh
M`j. wge fennewdi tgd rdtrd`tojb Ohd H`p adh`usd gd w`jtdi te
g`ridj gos Mer`n Foard*" Oj tgd Rdstdrj vdrsoej ef tgd mytg.
wgohg tgdsd twe f`ands hejvdy adtwddj tgdm. tgd hnd`r vosoej ef tgd
promotovd dtges oj `j d`sy djvorejmdjt. wgohg wd foji oj tgd vdrsd
ef Gemdr `ji tgd presd ef Gdreietus. os eashurdi ay tgd mosts ef
sdnf-robgtdeusjdss `ji sdnf-ojtdrdst* _dt tgdsd andmosgds `rd orrdnd-
v`jt te eur prdsdjt purpesd < `ji. of wd hejsdjt fer tgd memdjt te
objerd tgdm. wd m`y pdrhdovd. ujidrnyojb tgdm. tgd pgonesepgoh
trutg wgohg wd g`vd stuiodi oj tgd Xyro`h f`and ef tgd B`ridj ef
Didj* 0 Ygd s`md pgonesepgoh trutg os morrerdi oj tgd f`and ef tgd
Netus D`tdrs* Oj f`ht. tgdeakdhtovd
vodw ef tgdpromotovd
dtges oj
d`sy horhumst`jhds os feuji. wgdj wd `astr`ht ot.1 te ad suast`j-
to`nny tgd s`md oj tgd mojis ef tgd Rdstdrj `ji tgd Gdnndjoh
easdrvdr* @nold. tgdy sdd tg`t tgd promotovd djvorejmdjt prdsdjts
tgd sg`rpdst hejtr`st te tgdor ewj< tgdy sdd tg`t tgdrd os ` herrd-
spejiojb hejtr`st adtwddj tgd Xtges wgohg g`s addj ojiuhdi oj tgd
0 Xdd OO* H 'no/ '/ o. ven* o. pp* 1?3-8. `aevd. fer ` ioshussoej ef tgd f`and ef tgd
B`ridj ef Didj `ji fer tgd rdndv`jt quet`toejs frem Gdsoei. Sn`te. Vorbon. Erobdj.
Venjdy. Gujtojbtej. `ji Myrds* Ot wonn ad jetohdi tg`t tgd tgrdd p`ss`bds quetdi fremtgd werls ef Rdstdrj shgen`rs `rd sompny dxpurb`tdi vdrsoejs ef tgd mytg wgohg tgd
f`and ef Jerioh M`j rdjidrs se hruidny*z Oj `nn vdrsoejs ef tgd mytg. tgd eakdhtovd vodw tgd purdny ojtdnndhtu`n pdrhdptoej ef
tgd f`hts g`s te ad iosdjt`jbndi frem hdrt`oj `dstgdtoh `ji dmetoej`n hejhemot`jts*
Ygd ioffdrdjhd adtwddj tgd turjs wgohg tgdsd hejhemot`jts t`ld oj tgd Rdstdrj `jiGdnndjoh vdrsoejs tgrews semd ojtdrdstojb soid-nobgts upej tgd ioffdrdjhd ef eutneel
wgohg iostojbuosgds tgd Gdnndjoh frem eur Rdstdrj Hovonoz`toej* Oj tgd f`and eftgd Netus
D`tdrs. tgd ojjehdjhd `ji g`ppojdss ef tgd promotovd fotges oj d`sy horhumst`jhds `rd
`pprdho`tdi `t tgdor funn `dstgdtoh v`nud `pprdho`tdi se lddjny tg`t tgd Gdnndjoh easdrvdr
fddns ` novdny fd`r ef adojb h`ptov`tdi ay tgos hg`rmojb w`y ef nofd `ji suhhumaojb te ots
ndtg`rby `ji se adojb adbuondi ojte `a`jiejojb tgesd pr`htoh`n djis ej tgd pursuot ef
wgohg gos ewj hovonoz`toej idpdjis* Ygd Gdnndjd ieds jet w`jt te rdm`ld tgd NetusD`tdr m gos ewj om`bd* Ojiddi. tgd oid` jdvdr ehhurs te gom* Gd os hejtdjt te `veoi
turjojb ojte ` Netus D`tdr gomsdnf. `ji dvdj ej tgos peojt gd os oj twe mojis* @s gd
s`ons `w`y. gd neels a`hl ej Netus N`ji wotg ` hdrt`oj wostfun rdbrdt* "Sdrg`ps". gdtgojls. +O mobgt g`vd addj g`ppodr `s ` Netus D`tdr `ftdr `nnn" Ygd Rdstdrj easdrvdr"s
`ttotuid os `musojbny ioffdrdjt* @s ` rund. gd os anoji te tgd ad`uty ef tgd nofd wgohg gdos easdrvojb* @ M`nojewslo"s `pprdho`toej ef tgd `rtostoh `ji rotu`n `ji seho`n rdfojd-
mdjts wotg wgohg "tgd @rbej`uts ef tgd S`hofoh" ehhupy tgdor v`st ndosurd os tgd dxhdptoejwgohg prevds tgd rund* Ygd typoh`n Rdstdrj easdrvdr iosmossds suhg promotovd ehhup`-toejs `s hgoni"s-pn`y `ji trovo`noty `ji w`std ef tomd* Gd os quotd ommujd frem tgd
pessoaonoty ef adojb h`ptov`tdi ay tgdrj gomsdnf. `ji tgdrd os je sg`iew ef tgos fd`r ejgos moji* Ygd dmetoej wgohg gd fddns os iosbust iosbust tg`t tgd Ie`syeunolds sgeunig`vd pn`ydi tru`jt frem tgd Heujtry ef G`riwerl< iosbust tg`t tgd Xgonnul `ji tgd
Iojl` sgeuni g`vd dv`idi tgd hg`nndjbd ef idsohh`toej te wgohg tgd vortueus Dbypto`jg`s rdspejidi ay adhemojb ` f`nn`g* Oj tgd Rdstdrjdr"s vodw. tgos wd`l-mojidi
m`nojbdrojb os se hejtdmptoand tg`t ot must arojb tgd wrdthgds wge ojiunbd oj ot te `
a`i dji* @ Ie`syeunold. ndft te gomsdnf. os aeuji te idbdjdr`td ojte ` beronn`* Ot fennewstg`t ot os tgd iuty ef Jerioh M`j te ojtdrvdjd. m eridr te s`vd tgd Ie`syeunold. oj spotdef gomsdnf. frem gos j`tur`n `ji wdnn-idsdrvdi f`td* Fertuj`tdny. iuty<
`ji sdnf-ojtdrdst
heojhoid. fer tgd Ie`syeunold h`j ejny ad s`vdi ay adojb rdm`id oj Jerioh M`j"som`bd. `ji tgd forst stdp oj tgos tr`jsfobur`toej os te m`ld gom sdrvd `j `pprdjtohdsgop ``
Jerioh M`j"s gdwdr efweei `ji ir`wdr ef w`tdr* Jerioh M`j h`j ie wotg `jy `meujtef hgd`p n`aeur* +@ji wd ljew tg`t `nn tgojbs werl tebdtgdr fer beei te tgdm tg`t nevd
Bei. te tgdm wge `rd tgd h`nndi `hheriojb te Gos purpesd+ 'Qem`js vooo* 17/* Fertofodioj gos rdsenutoej ay tgos er`hnd frem tgd Xertds Aoanoh`d. Jerioh M`j t`lds tgd peerIe`syeunold formny oj g`ji `ji oj tgd v`roeus rends ef t`slm`stdr. s`ndsm`j. `ji
dv`jbdnost `reusds gom frem gos ndtg`rby. wotg untom`td hejsdqudjhds wgohg `rd jet ydt`pp`rdjt aut wgohg m`y prevd te ad surprosojb*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 342/455
W@@DOO@ Y@ L@@@ 80
promotovd ay gos d`sy horhumst`jhds `ji tgd dtges wgohg g`s addj
ojiuhdi ay ` strdjueus nofd oj tgdmsdnvds< tgdy sdd tg`t tgd promo-
tovd wonn jet `ji h`jjet dvdr keoj tgdm oj rujjojb tgd r`hd ef
hovonoz`toej0 se
nejb`s `j
d`sy djvorejmdjt hejtojuds te sgodnigom frem tgd jdhdssoty< `ji
foj`nny tgdy sdd tg`t tgdy tgdmsdnvds.
of tgdy suhhuma te tgos ojsoioeus djvorejmdjt. wonn hd`sd te ruj
wotg p`todjhd tgd r`hd tg`t os sdt adferd tgdm*
OO* YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX
@ Sn`j ef Epdr`toejs
Rd g`vd jew pdrg`ps dst`anosgdi idhosovdny tgd trutg tg`t d`sd
os ojomoh`n te hovonoz`toej* Ygd rdsunts ef eur ojvdstob`toej up tetgos peojt `ppd`r te w`rr`jt tgd prepesotoej tg`t. tgd brd`tdr tgd
d`sd ef tgd djvorejmdjt. tgd wd`ldr tgd stomunus tew`ris hovonoz`-
toej wgohg tg`t djvorejmdjt `imojostdrs te M`j* H`j wd jew
prehddi ejd stdp f`rtgdr5 @rd wd w`rr`jtdi oj fermun`tojb. oj
dqu`nny sompnd `ji `astr`ht tdrms. tgd ojvdrsd prepesotoej tg`t tgd
stomunus tew`ris hovonoz`toej brews strejbdr oj prepertoej `s tgd
djvorejmdjt brews merd ioffohunt5 Ndt us put tgos sdheji pre-
pesotoejte tgd tdst
ayeur
jewwdnn-trodi
dmporoh`nmdtgei* Ndt us
rdvodw forst tgd dvoidjhd oj f`veur ef tgd prepesotoej `ji tgdj tgd
dvoidjhd `b`ojst ot. `ji sdd wg`t ojfdrdjhd dmdrbds* Dvoidjhd
ojioh`tojb tg`t tgd ioffohunty `ji tgd stomunus ef`j djvorejmdjt `rd
`pt te ojhrd`sdZ`rop`ssu os jet g`ri te n`y g`jis upej* Q`tgdr. wd
`rd noldny te ad dma`rr`ssdi ay tgd wd`ntg ef onnustr`toejs tg`t nd`p
te tgd moji* Mest ef tgdsd onnustr`toejs prdsdjt tgdmsdnvds oj tgd
ferm ef hemp`rosejs* Ndt us adboj ay sertojb eut eur onnustr`toejs
ojte twe breups oj wgohg tgd peojts ef hemp`rosej rdn`td te tgd
pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt `ji te tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt rdspdhtovdny<
`ji ndt us forst hejsoidr tgd pgysoh`n breup* Ot suaiovoids otsdnf ojte
twe h`tdberods; hemp`rosejs adtwddj tgd rdspdhtovd stomun`tojb
dffdhts ef pgysoh`n djvorejmdjts wgohg prdsdjt ioffdrdjt idbrdds ef
ioffohunty< `ji hemp`rosejs adtwddj tgd rdspdhtovd stomun`tojb
dffdhts ef eni breuji `ji jdw breuji. `p`rt frem tgd ojtrojsoh
j`turd ef tgd tdrr`oj*
Ygd _dnnew Qovdr `ji tgd _`jbtsdNdt us hemp`rd. fer dx`mpnd. tgd ioffdrdjt idbrdds ef ioffohunty
wgohg `rd prdsdjtdi rdspdhtovdny ay tgd newdr v`nndys ef tgd _dnnew
Qovdr `ji tgd _`jbtsd st`rtojb oj dotgdr h`sd frem tgd peojt
wgdrd tgd rovdr ossuds frem ots n`st berbd oj eridr te fnew tgd rdst ef
ots w`y tgreubg epdj heujtry te tgd he`st*
Ygd promdv`n st`td ef tgd newdr sdhtoej ef tgd _dnnew Qovdr
+ Fer tgos mdt`pger. sdd OO* H 'oo/ '`/ r. ven* o. pp* 888~9: `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 343/455
81 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
V`nndy os vovoiny idshroadi oj ` p`ss`bd frem tgd werl ef ` ios-
tojbuosgdi Xojenebost wgohg g`s addj quetdi oj `j d`rnodr hg`ptdr*0
Rgdj M`j forst teel tgos w`tdry hg`es oj g`ji. tgd rovdr w`s jet
j`vob`and `t `jy sd`sej< oj tgd wojtdr ot w`s dotgdr frezdj erhgeldi wotg fne`tojb ohd
<tgd mdntojb ef tgos ohd oj tgd sprojb pre-
iuhdi idv`st`tojb `jju`n fneeis wgohg rdpd`tdiny hg`jbdi tgd
rovdr"s heursd ay h`rvojb eut jdw hg`jjdns. wgond tgd eni hg`jjdns
turjdi ojte kujbnd-hevdrdi sw`mps* Ygos w`s tgd st`td ef tgd
rovdr `s M`j forst feuji ot<`ji te-i`y. wgdj semd tgrdd er feur
tgeus`ji yd`rs ef gum`j dffert g`vd ir`ojdi tgd sw`mps `ji g`vd
hejfojdi tgd m`oj hg`jjdn ef tgd rovdr adtwddj dma`jlmdjts. tgd
idv`st`tojb`htoej ef tgd fneeis g`s jet addj dnomoj`tdi* Ygd
vosot`toejs g`vd mdrdny addj rdiuhdi oj frdqudjhy ejny te r`v`bd
tgd werls ef M`j wotg brd`tdr voendjhd `ji evdr ` woidr r`jbd
wgdj tgdy ie ehhur*
Ygd fneei-w`tdrs ef tgd _dnnew Qovdr wgohg. oj tgd st`td ef
J`turd. usdi te sprd`i tgdmsdnvds `jju`nny evdr tgd pn`ojs.jew oj
jerm`n yd`rs tr`vdn g`rmndssny adtwddj dma`jlmdjts frem tgd
dxot ef tgd berbds te tgd sd`< aut. nold Beis rdstr`ojdi ay gum`j
ompodty frem s`tosfyojb tgdor nust te idstrey. tgdsd fneeis. oj
p`ssojb. prdp`rd fer ` futurd rdvdjbd* Ygdy pond up treuand fer
M`j oj tgd notdr`n sdjsd ay idpesotojb tgd sont wgohg tgdy g`vd
areubgt iewj frem tgd meujt`ojs `s tgdy sn`hldj spddi `ji mevd
ej snubbosgny evdr tgd fn`t rovdr-adi te wgohg. oj tgdor newdr heursd.
tgd dma`jlmdjts jew hejfojd tgdm* _d`r ay yd`r. `s tgd idpesots
`hhumun`td. tgd ndvdn ef tgos rovdr-adi rosds `aevd tgd ndvdn ef tgd
fodnis ej dotgdr soid< yd`r ay yd`r. tgd pdepnd r`osd tgd gdobgt ef
tgd dma`jlmdjts. te prdvdjt tgd fneei-w`tdrs frem sponnojb evdr*
_dt `t n`st tgdrd hemds ` peojt `t wgohg tgd ndvdn ef tgd rovdr-adi os
se gobg `aevd tgd ndvdn ef tgd surreujiojb heujtry tg`t je gdobgtdj-
ojb er tgohldjojb ef tgd dma`jlmdjts `v`ons `jy nejbdr te ndji
tgdm tgd rdquosotd rdsostojb pewdr< `ji tgdj. oj semd yd`r ef gobg
fneei. tgd omprosejdi rovdr s`v`bdny aursts ots a`jls `ji djbunfs` wgend heujtrysoid. eanotdr`tojb tgd fodnis `ji swddpojb `w`y tgd
auoniojbs `ji irewjojb tgd novd stehl `ji tgd pepun`toej* Xojhd
tgd gostery ef tgd rdboej adb`j te ad rdheridi. tgdsd pdroeioh
ojuji`toejs g`vd ehhurrdi ojjumdr`and tomds< `ji ej sdvdr`nehh`soejs tgd rovdr g`s hg`jbdi ots heursd hempndtdny* @t tgd
prdsdjt memdjt ot idaeuhgds ojte tgd Bunf ef Hgogno jd`r tgd moi-
peojt ef ots seutg-wdstdrj he`st. `nmest eppesotd tgd top ef tgd
No`etujb Sdjojsun`< oj tgd prdgosteroh `bd ot idaeuhgdi `t tgd
jertg-wdst herjdr ef tgd Bunf tgreubg tgd adi oj wgohg tgd S`oge
Qovdr fnews te-i`y <+ aut iurojb tgd ojtdrvdjojb tgrdd er feur
+ Xdd OO* H '`/ 'a/ 1. ven* o. pp* 807-13. `aevd* 1Ep* hot. neh* hot*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 344/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 88
monndjjo` ot g`s pn`ydi brd`tdr v`b`rods tg`j tgos* Ndss tg`j `
hdjtury `be ot w`s jet idaeuhgojb ojte tgd Bunf ef Hgogno `t `nn*
Ot w`s ejny tgd ojuji`toej ef 0741 tg`t iovdrtdi tgd rovdr a`hl ojte
tgd Bunf frem `hg`jjdn idaeuhgojb. seutg ef tgd Xg`jtujb
Sdjojsun`. iordht ojte tgd _dnnew Xd`< `ji tgos w`s jet tgd forst
tomd ej rdheri tg`t tgd _dnnew Qovdr g`i swothgdi ots heursd fremejd soid ef tgd Xg`jtujb Sdjojsun` te tgd etgdr*
@ rdm`rl`and hejtr`st te tgos os prdsdjtdi ay tgd newdr v`nndy ef
tgd _`jbtsd* Ygd Newdr _`jbtsd ir`ojs ` a`soj wgdrd tgd n`ji os
petdjto`nny je ndss fdrtond tg`j tgd jertgdrj pn`ojs `ji wgdrd
`brohunturd g`s jet te n`aeur. `s ot n`aeurs tgdrd. ujidr tgd twefeni
sheurbd ef fneei `ji ireubgt* Ygd _`jbtsd semdtomds dmun`tds gos
jertgdrj aretgdr oj ojuji`tojb gos gum`j jdobgaeurs" fodnis.0 aut
gd jdvdr rdfusds te ad`r tgdor hr`ft upej gos w`tdrs*1
Xuhg `rd tgd rdspdhtovd hg`r`htdrs eftgd twe brd`t rovdrs. `s tgdywdrd oj tgd adbojjojb `ji `s tgdy `rd te-i`y* @ji wgdrd ioi tgd
Xojoh Hovonoz`toej hemd te aortg 5 Ej tgd a`jls ef tgd br`hoeus
_`jbtsd Lo`jb er ej tgesd ef tgd idmejoh Gw`jb Ge 5 Rd ljewtg`t ot h`md te aortg ej tgd a`jls ef tgd Gw`jb Ge. `ji tg`t tgd
Newdr _`jbtsd V`nndy w`s jet areubgt wotgoj tgd `maot ef tgd
Xojoh Xehodty ujton `ftdr tgd Xojoh Hovonoz`toej g`i areldj iewj`ji g`i djtdrdi upej ` Yomd ef Yreuands wgohg w`s tgd forst
pg`sd ef ots idhnojd*
Hgomu `ji V`np`r`ose
@b`oj. ej wg`t sdhtoej ef tgd S`hofoh He`st ef Xeutg @mdroh`
ioi tgd @jid`j Hovonoz`toej hemd te aortg 5 Jet ej tg`t Hdjtr`n
O @ wddl `ftdr tgdsd sdjtdjhds g`i addj wrottdj oj tgd summdr ef tgd yd`r 0?80. tgd
_`jbtsd preiuhdi. oj tgd rdboej ef G`jlew. ` fneei wgohg<oj sh`nd `ji oj idstruhtovd-
jdss. os pdrg`ps ujsurp`ssdi oj tgd `jj`ns ef tgd _dnnew Qovdr otsdnf* Jdvdrtgdndss. tgdwrotdr adnodvds tg`t ej ` nejb vodw. dxtdjiojb a`hl te tgd neh`n adbojjojbs ef rdheridi
gostery oj tgd moiind ef tgd n`st monndjjoum A h*. tgd hejtr`st gdrd ir`wj adtwddj tgd
hg`r`htdrs iospn`ydi ay tgd _`jbtsd `ji tgd _dnnew Qovdr oj tgdor rdspdhtovd rdn`toejs te
M`j os aerjd eut ej tgd wgend ay tgd f`hts*
+ Oj tgd yd`r 0?16 ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. "tgd _`jbtsd w`s j`vob`and+ oj +tgd summdr
mejtgs. wgdj tgd ioshg`rbd ef tgd rovdr w`s `ubmdjtdi ay tgd summdr r`ojf`nn `ji aytgd mdntojb ef tgd sjews oj Yoadt *** `s f`r up `s G`jlew '`aeut 423 monds frem ots
meutg/ * * * fer n`rbd ehd`j-beojb std`mdrs" <`ji tgos peojt g`i addj ljewj te ad rd`hgdi
ay "` ferdobj a`ttndsgop ef `s muhg `s 01.333 tejs iospn`hdmdjt* * * * Tjidr tgd s`md
hejiotoejs. std`mdrs ef erioj`ry hejstruhtoej. tgeubg jet ef gd`vy tejj`bd. heuni
j`vob`td noldwosd tgd jdxt sdhtoej ef 862 j`utoh`n monds frem G`jlew te Ohg`jb* Ygdsdhtoej ef 933 j`utoh`n monds `aevd tgos. adtwddj Ohg`jb `ji Hgujblojb. g`i addj
epdjdi sojhd 0?0? te std`m-j`vob`toej ay spdho`nny hejstruhtdi rovdr-std`mdrs ef nobgtir`ft `ji wotg djbojds suffohodjtny pewdrfun te meujt tgd r`pois* Ygos `hgodvdmdjt g`i
areubgt std`m-j`vob`toej ojte Xzdhgu`j tgd mest pepuneus Hgojdsd prevojhd 'wotg `j
dstom`tdi pepun`toej ef 43.333.333/* Fer j`tovd kujls. tgd p`ss`bd ef tgd r`pois oj tgd
Ohg`jb-Hgujblojb sdhtoej w`s ` snew. n`aeroeus. `ji i`jbdreus epdr`toej* Ej tgd
etgdr g`ji. tgdy wdrd `and te `shdji tgd rovdr `s f`r `s Xuofu. wgohg w`s `aeut 0.497
j`utoh`n monds frem tgd meutg. er dvdj `s f`r `s Sojbsg`j. `aeut 88 monds furtgdr.
wgdrd`s Hgujblojb. tgd nomot ef rovdr-std`mdr j`vob`toej. w`s `aeut 0.882 monds frem
tgd meutg. `ji Ohg`jb. tgd nomot ef j`vob`toej fer sm`nn std`mdrs ef erioj`ry auoni.
`aeut 382*" 'Yeyjadd. @* K*; Xurvdy ef Ojtdrj`toej`n @ff`ors. 0?16 'Nejiej 0?17.
Monferi/. pp* 831-8*/
OO I
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 345/455
89 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Hgond`j sdhtoej wgohg djkeys suhg ` bdjdreus r`ojf`nn tg`t tgd
Xp`josg dxpnerdrs s`nutdi `j d`rtgny p`r`iosd V`np`r`ose oj tgd
forst ef tgdsd brddj v`nndys wgohg rdkeohdi tgdor dyds `ftdr tgdor nejb
keurjdy iewj tgd p`rhgdi arewj he`st wgohg tgdy g`i te tr`vdrsdf`rtgdr jertg* Ygd @jid`j Hovonoz`toej h`md te aortg ej tgd Jertg
Sdruvo`j sdhtoej ef tgd he`st idshroadi oj ` p`ss`bd wgohg g`s
addj quetdi `aevd0 wgdrd M`j g`s te fobgt ` pdrpdtu`n a`ttnd
wotg tgd idsdrt `ji must w`tdr gos fodnis. wgohg tgd sly wonn jet
w`tdr fer gom. ay gos ewj g`ri n`aeur ; tgd sp`id-werl ef iobbojb
`ji m`ojt`ojojb ojjumdr`and orrob`toej-hg`jjdns* Hgond w`s jet
areubgt wotgoj tgd `maot ef tgd @jid`j Xehodty ujton tgd @jid`j
Hovonoz`toej g`i rd`hgdi `j `iv`jhdist`bd
oj ots idhnojd* Hgond
w`s ejd ef tgd n`st hejqudsts ef tgd Dmpord ef tgd Ojh`s tgd
@jid`j ujovdrs`n st`td `ji dvdj tgdj tgd Ojh`s wdrd hejtdjt te
nd`vd tgd brd`tdr p`rt ef fdrtond Hgond adyeji tgdor seutgdrj frej-
todr. wgohg tgdy irdw `nejb tgd nojd ef tgd Qovdr M`und* Ygd Ojh`s
wdrd `t gemd ej tgd @jid`j Sn`td`u. te wgohg tgd he`st`n hovonoz`-
toej g`i sprd`i `t `j d`rny i`td oj ots brewtg* @ji ej wg`t sdhtoej
ef tgd pn`td`u ioi tgos hovonoz`toej sdhurd ots forst feetgeni 5 Jdotgdr
ej tgd sdhtoej wgohg w`s jd`rdst te ots prom`ry gemd oj tgd he`st`n
v`nndys ef Hgomu. jer ydt ej tgd jertgdrny sdhtoej 'oj tgd tdrrotery
ef tgd meidrj N`toj Qdpuanoh ef Henemao`/ wgdrd tgd `ntotuids `rh
hemp`r`tovdny new `ji tgd v`nndys epdj `ji tgd hnom`td bdjo`n*
Ygd ruojs ef Yo`gu`j`he tdstofy tg`t tgd forst feetgeni ef hovonoz`-
toej ej tgd pn`td`u w`s oj tgd upn`ji a`soj ef N`ld Yotoh`h` `
rdboej wgohg w`s g`riny jd`rdr te tgd prom`ry gemd ef tgd @jid`j
Hovonoz`toej oj ejd iordhtoej tg`j tgd uppdr a`soj ef tgd M`bi`ndj`Qovdr w`s oj tgd etgdr. wgond oj seon `ji hnom`td ot w`s m`jofdstny
ndss ojvotojb*1
Newn`jis `ji Gobgn`jis oj Bu`tdm`n`
@b`oj. wgohg f`hd ef Hdjtr`n @mdroh` w`s ot tg`t s`w tgd aortg
ef tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej5 Jet tgd S`hofoh f`hd. wgdrd ` rdn`tovdny
gobg `ntotuid he-epdr`tds wotg ` rdn`tovdny new r`ojf`nn te noadr`td
`strop ef heujtry frem tgd p`nn ef trepoh`n ferdst wgohg smetgdrs
tgd @tn`jtoh newn`jis* 8
0 Xdd OO* H 'oo/ 'a/ 1. ven*o. pp* 811-8. `aevd*
1 Xdd tgd idshroptoej ef tgd Yotoh`h` A`soj wgohg g`s addj quetdi oj ven* o. p* 811.`aevd* Fer tgd aortg-pn`hds ef tgd @jid`j Hovonoz`toej. `ji tgd heursd ef ots dxp`jsoejiurojb ots brewtg. sdd OO* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* 013-8. `aevd*
8 Fer tgd hejtr`st oj hnom`td `ji vdbdt`toej adtwddj tgd S`hofoh Gobgn`jis `ji tgd@tn`jtoh Newn`jis ef Hdjtr`n @mdroh`. sdd Gujtojbtej. D*; Ygd Hnom`toh F`hter `t
onnustr`tdi oj @ji @mdroh`'R`sgojbtej 0?09. H`rjdbod Ojstotutoej ef R`sgojbtej.
Suanoh`toej Je* 0?1/. hgs* xvoo `ji xvooo* Fer tgd `nmest dx`ht ojvdrsoej ef tgd rdn`tovd
idbrdds ef hovonoz`toej tg`t g`vd addj prdv`ndjt rdspdhtovdny oj tgd sdvdr`n ioffdrdjt
bdebr`pgoh`n zejds ef Hdjtr`n @mdroh` oj pest-Henumao`j tomds. `s hejtr`stdi wotg tgdsotu`toejm tgd `bd oj wgohg tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej h`md te aortg `ji brdw te m`turoty.sdd ep* hot*. pp* 107-0?* Fer Ir* Gujtojbtej"s gypetgdsos tg`t tgos sgoft ef seho`n zejdsos te ad `hheujtdi fer ay ` sgoft ef hnom`toh zejds. sdd OO* I 'voo/. @jjdx O. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 346/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 84
Rgdj tgd Xp`jo`ris `rrovdi. tgdy teel te tgdsd epdj gd`ntgyHdjtr`n @mdroh`j upn`jis evdrneelojb tgd S`hofoh `j
d`rtgny
p`r`iosd oj tgd Yrepohs `s idhoidiny `s tgdy teel te Hgond`j
V`np`r`ose `t tgd f`r dxtrdmoty ef tgdor hejqudsts oj tgdJdw Rerni*Ot w`s gdrd tg`t tgdy pn`jtdi tgdor Hdjtr`n @mdroh`j sdttndmdjts.
werlojb tgdor w`y up tgd S`hofoh he`st frem tgd peojt wgdrd tgdyadstreid tgd Ostgmus ef S`j`m` `s f`r `s tgd prdsdjt frejtodr
adtwddj Bu`tdm`n` `ji Mdxohe* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. tgdy m`id jesdroeus `ttdmpt te ehhupy tgd @tn`jtoh he`st ef Hdjtr`n @mdroh`
adtwddj tgdor sdttndmdjts ej tgd Ostgmus `ji tgdor sdttndmdjts oj
_uh`t`j* Ygd trepoh`n ferdst oj tgd gojtdrn`ji idtdrrdi tgdm.
tgeubgtgos he`st
n`y
`nmest wotgojsobgt
ef tgdor osn`jipessdssoejsoj tgd @jtonnds `ji tgeubg tgd epdjojb up ef he`st `ji gojtdrn`ji
weuni g`vd sgertdjdi `pprdho`any tgd ndjbtg eftgdkeurjdyadtwddj
tgd Xp`josg sdttndmdjts ej tgd S`hofoh f`hd ef Hdjtr`n @mdroh` `ji
tgd metgdr heujtry* Oj spotd ef tg`t. tgd Xp`jo`ris `a`jiejdi
tgos @tn`jtoh he`st te ojiobdjeus Ojio`js `ji te Djbnosg ojtdrnepdrs.K
`ji wdrd hejtdjt te nd`vd tgd hemmujoh`toejs adtwddj Xp`oj `ji
tgd Xp`josg sdttndmdjts ej tgd S`hofoh he`st te fennew tgd reuji-
`aeut reutd `hress tgd Ostgmus* Ygd sotu`toej g`s jet hg`jbdi
suast`jto`nny sojhd tgd Xp`josg Dmpord oj tgd Jdw Rerni g`s ios-
`ppd`rdi* Ygeubg fovd eut ef tgd sox rdpuanohs wgohg `rd ots "suh-
hdsser-st`tds" oj Hdjtr`n @mdroh` pessdss @tn`jtoh sd`ae`ris. tgd
adst-idvdnepdi iostrohts `ji tgd projhop`n hdjtrds ef pepun`toej `rd
stonn te ad feuji ej tgd upn`jis evdrneelojb tgd S`hofoh wgdrd tgd
Xp`jo`ris forst m`id tgdmsdnvds `t gemd* Oj 0?88. tgdrd wdrd stonn
je merd tg`j twe nojds ef r`onw`y sp`jjojb Hdjtr`n @mdroh` frem
he`st te he`st adtwddj tgd Ostgmus ef S`j`m` `ji tgd Ostgmus ef
Ydgu`jtdpdh< `ji oj 0?12 tgd h`pot`n hoty ef `t nd`st ejd rdpuanoh
w`s stonn hut eff frem ots @tn`jtoh notter`n ay ` a`rrodr ef vorboj `ji
vortu`nny omp`ss`and kujbnd*1
Ygd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd d`bdrjdss `ji premptjdss wotg wgohg
tgd Xp`jo`ris teel te tgd epdj gobgn`jis evdrneelojb tgd S`hofoh
he`st ef Hdjtr`n @mdroh` `ji tgd `nmest hempndtd f`onurd ef tgd
henejosts `ji tgdor suhhdssers. evdr ` pdroei ef merd tg`j feur
0 @j ujsuhhdssfun `ttdmpt te feuji ` Surot`j henejy ej tgd osndt ef X`jt` H`t`noj` er
Srevoidjhd. eff "tgd Mesquote He`st". w`s m`id oj @*I* 0683 'sdd Jdwtej. @* S*; YgdHenejosojb @htovotods ef tgd Djbnosg Surot`js 'Jdw G`vdj 0?09. _`nd Tjovdrsoty Srdss//.
`ji tgd Arotosg Bevdrjmdjt hejtojudi te hn`om ` pretdhter`td evdr tgd Mesquote Ojio`js
tonn 0744* @ftdr tgd `hquosotoej ef K`m`oh`. tgd Djbnosg sdhurdi ` feetojb ej `jetgdr
sdhtoej ef tgos he`st wgohg g`s jew adhemd tgd Hrewj Henejy ef Arotosg Gejiur`s*z Ygd Jertg @mdroh`j st`tdsm`j. Mr* Gdjry N* Xtomsej. wgdj gd w`s `t M`j`bu`.
tgd h`pot`n ef Joh`r`bu`. oj 0?12. feuji tg`th
tgd @tn`jtoh he`st ef Joh`r`bu` w`s
iost`jt frem us muhg ndss tg`j 133 monds `s tgd hrew fnods. aut ot t`lds nejbdr te bdt tgdrd
tg`j te be frem Jdw _erl te X`j Fr`jhoshe. `ji tgd ejny w`y ef beojb w`s ay sd`- +
vonnojb te tr`vdn ej feet tgreubg tgd kujbndgreubg tgd S`j`m` H`j`n. ujndss ejd w`s Z* U
er te fennew iewj ` trepoh`n rovdr m ` h`jed+* 'Xtomsej. G* N*; @mdroh`j Senohy oj
Joh`r`bu` 'Jdw _erl 0?12. Xhroajdr/. p* 92*/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 347/455
86 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
hdjturods. te epdj up tgd @tn`jtoh he`st wotg ots gojtdrn`ji ef
trepoh`n ferdst. bovds semd md`surd ef tgd ioffdrdjhd oj tgd idbrdd
ef tgd ioffohunty wgohg tgdsd twe jdobgaeurojb aut vdry iovdrsd
rdboejs eppesd rdspdhtovdny te M`j wgdj gd `ttdmpts te ard`ltgdm oj* Rgdrd w`s ot. tgdj. tg`t tgd enidst ojiobdjeus hovonoz`toej
ef tgd Jdw Rerni h`md te aortg5 Ej tgd Hdjtr`n @mdroh`j
upn`jis er oj tgd Hdjtr`n @mdroh`j ferdsts 5 Rd ljew tg`t tgd
M`y`j Hovonoz`toej h`md te aortg oj tgd ferdsts `ji tg`t. dvdj wgdj
ot sprd`i. ots nojd ef dxp`jsoej w`s jet seutgw`ris ojte tgd `ikeoj-
ojb upn`jis aut jertgw`ris ojte tgd _uh`t`j Sdjojsun` `ji ej te
tgd Mdxoh`j Sn`td`u* Ot w`s oj tgesd qu`rtdrs. `ji jet ej tgd
seutgdrjupn`jis.
tg`t tgd twe n`tdr hovonoz`toejs wgohg wdrd
rdn`tdi te tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej `resd oj tgdor turj* @pp`rdjtny
tgd d`sony `hhdssoand Hdjtr`n @mdroh`j upn`jis wdrd jdvdr ehhupodi
ay `jy hovonoz`toej ujton tgd Xp`jo`ris h`md te t`ld pessdssoej ef
tgdm frem tgd etgdr soid ef tgd @tn`jtoh* Ygd ojiobdjeus hovonoz`-
toejs wdrd `s pdrsostdjt oj sgujjojb tgd upn`jis `s tgd ojtrusovd
hovonoz`toej g`s addj oj sgujjojb tgd ferdsts* Ygdj wdrd tgd M`y`sanoji `ji tgd Xp`jo`ris sg`rp-sobgtdi 5 Rd g`vd ejny te hemp`rdtgd rdspdhtovd `hgodvdmdjts oj Hdjtr`n @mdroh` ef tgd M`y`jHovonoz`toej ej tgd ejd g`ji `ji ef tgd Xp`josg vdrsoej ef eur
Rdstdrj Hovonoz`toej ej tgd etgdr oj eridr te rd`nozd tg`t tgd ferdsts
oj wgohg tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej h`md te aortg surp`ss oj twe
rdspdhts tgd upn`jis ej wgohg eur Rdstdrj Hovonoz`toej g`s addj
prep`b`tdi* Ygdy jet ejny surp`ss tgdm oj tgd idbrdd ef tgd
ioffohunty wgohg tgdy eppesd te gum`j dfferts< tgdy surp`ss tgdm
je ndss oj tgd idbrdd ef tgd rdspejsd wgohg tgdy g`vd dveldi frem
gum`j adojbs wge g`vd m`id tgd dffert te br`ppnd wotg tgdm* 0
Ygd @dbd`j He`sts `ji tgdor Hejtojdjt`n Gojtdrn`jis
@b`oj. tgd ujusu`n ioffohunty prdsdjtdi ay tgd @dbd`j `rd`. oj
wgohg tgd Moje`j `ji tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej suhhdssovdny h`md
te aortg. adhemds funny `pp`rdjt ejny wgdj tgd `rd` os vodwdi oj
ots bdebr`pgoh`n sdttojb. `b`ojst tgd feon prevoidi ay tgd rdboejsreuji `aeut* O h`j tdstofy te tgos frem pdrsej`n dxpdrodjhd* Ej
my forst vosot te tgd @dbd`j. O h`md `ji wdjt ay sd`< `ji. `s
`nw`ys. tgd sd`-
vey`bd
g`i tgd
psyhgeneboh`ndffdht ef
foxojb`brd`tmdjt`n bunf adtwddj ots tdrmojo* Ygd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd pgysoh`n
fd`turds ef Brddhd `ji tgesd ef Djbn`ji w`s ef heursd eavoeus<
aut ej aetg tgd keurjdy eut `ji tgdkeurjdy a`hl tgd `arupt tr`jso-
toej frem tgd ejd heujtry te tgd etgdr m`id ot ompessoand te0 Ygos `veoi`jhd ef tgd fermdr tgd`trd ef tgd M`y`j Hovonoz`toej ay tgd Xp`josg
henejosts oj Hdjtr`n @mdroh` m`y ad hemp`rdi wotg tgd `veoi`jhd ef tgd fermdr tgd`trdef tgd Ojiod Hovonoz`toej oj Hdynej ay tgd Xhettosg `ji Djbnosg pn`jtdrs* 'Xdd OO* I 'o/.
o pp* 6-2. `aevd*/ Oj aetg ojst`jhds. tgd n`ttdr-i`y Rdstdrj ojtruidrs hgesd tgd seftdr
^`ji ndss stomun`tojb eptoej*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 348/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 82
`pprdho`td tgos eavoeus m`ttdr ef f`ht om`boj`tovdny* Ej my sdheji
vosot te tgd @dbd`j. O `b`oj `rrovdi ay sd`< aut tgos tomd O areld
my st`y oj @tgdjs ay m`lojb tgrdd rdhejj`oss`jhds ojte rdboejs
kust eutsoid tgd @dbd`j `rd`* Forst O wdjt te Xmyrj` `ji m`iddxpdiotoejs frem tgdrd ay r`on up heujtry ojte tgd ojtdroer ef
@j`teno`< jdxt O wdjt te Hejst`jtojepnd `ji m`id etgdr dxpdio-
toejs ojte @j`teno` frem tg`t qu`rtdr< `ji tgdj. adferd hemojbgemd. O wdjt te X`nejoh` `ji m`id `j dxpdiotoej frem tgdrd ojte
tgd ojtdroer ef M`hdiejo`* Foj`nny. O rdturjdi te Djbn`ji ay tgd
evdrn`ji reutd. tr`vdnnojb oj tgd s`md r`onw`y-h`rro`bd. wotgeut `
hg`jbd. frem Hejst`jtojepnd te H`n`os* Ygus. oj tgd heursd ef tgos
vosot. O tr`vdnndi
evdrn`ji.eut ef tgd
@dbd`j`rd` ojte tgd
rdboejsreuji `aeut. oj feur ioffdrdjt iordhtoejs<`ji d`hg tomd. oj dvdry
iordhtoej. O feuji mysdnf tr`vdnnojb eut ef heujtry tg`t w`s a`rd.
a`rrdj. rehly. meujt`ojeus. `ji areldj ojte fr`bmdjts ay tgd
dstr`jbojb sd`. ojte heujtry tg`t w`s brddjdr `ji rohgdr `ji
seftdr heujtry oj wgohg meujt`oj-r`jbds wdrd rdpn`hdi ay
rennojb gonns. `ji sd`-fonndi bunfs `ji str`ots ay are`i huntov`and
rovdr-v`nndys* Ygd humun`tovd dffdht ef tgdsd hejtr`sts upej tgd
easdrvdr"s om`boj`toej w`s vdry pewdrfun* Ej tgos hemp`r`tovd
vodw. tgd @dbd`j `rd` sgewdi otsdnf oj ots trud heneurs `s ` rdboej
ef ujusu`n ioffohunty. jet ejny ay hejtr`st wotg Djbn`ji er wotg tgd
etgdr Yr`js`npojd heujtrods ef Durepd. aut ay hejtr`st wotg dvdry
rdboej `ikeojojb ot* Oj tgos nobgt. O rd`nozdi tgd iddp md`jojb ef tgd
weris wgohg Gdreietus puts ojte tgd meutg ef tgd Xp`rt`j dxond
I`m`rXtus oj ` hennequy wotg tgd Brd`t Lojb Wdrxds ; "Gdnn`s g`s `
festdr-sostdr Sevdrty wge jdvdr nd`vds gdr< aut sgd g`s areubgt oj
` budst oj tgd sg`pd ef Vortud. tgd hgoni efRosiem `ji N`w< `ji
ay Vortud"s `oi Gdnn`s lddps Sevdrty `t a`y`ji Xdrvotuid noldwosd*" 0
@ttoh` `ji Aedeto`
Xomon`r hejtr`sts oj tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt. h`ppdi ay herrd-
spejiojb hejtr`sts oj tgd neh`n v`rodty ef hovonoz`toej. m`y ad
easdrvdi oj tgd ojtdroer ef tgd @dbd`j `rd` otsdnf* Fer ojst`jhd. of
ejd tr`vdns ay tr`oj frem @tgdjs `nejb tgd r`onw`y wgohg dvdjtu`nny
nd`is. tgreubg X`nejoh`. eut ef tgd @dbd`j `rd` ojte tgd gd`rt ef
Durepd.ejd
p`ssds.
ej tgd forst
st`bd
ef tgd keurjdy. tgreubg `
strdthg ef heujtry wgohg bovds te Hdjtr`n er Rdstdrj Durepd`j
dyds `j `jtohop`tery bnompsd ef f`mono`r shdjdry* @ftdr tgd tr`oj g`s
addj hnomaojb snewny fer geurs reuji tgd d`stdrj fn`jls ef Meujt
S`rjds tgreubg ` typoh`n @dbd`j n`jish`pd ef stujtdi pojds `ji
k`bbdi nomdstejd hr`bs. tgd tr`vdnndr os `stejosgdi te foji gomsdnf
o Gdreietus. Aeel VOO. hg* 031* Ygd Brddl tdxt os; Yfn "KD@@`Xt Yrm"ok %odv `odo kherd
>rtovrpe>t:6) &m. ipdj/ Ad HYr`%ere"s tero. `ve rd ee>%:fys L`rdpy`hrpdvrk %h`t v6pev ohrxypev+ YYK
< 0} "DW^`) rtfv rd Yrdvgkv hwr`%jRr`o
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 349/455
87 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
adojb r`ttndi iewj ojte ` newn`ji heujtry ef bdjtny ujiun`tojb
iddp-seondi pneubgn`jis* Gd mobgt om`bojd tg`t gd g`i kust
hressdi tgd @ustre-Bdrm`j frejtodr ej tgd r`onw`y adtwddj Ojjs-
aruhl `ji Mujohg< tgd jertgdrj `spdht ef S`rjds `ji Hotg`drej.wgohg gd jew vodws `t ` iost`jhd `hress tgos newn`ji ferdbreuji.
mobgt ad tgd jertgdrjmest r`jbd ef tgd Yyrendsd @nps* Ef heursd
tgos n`jish`pd os `"spert"* Gd wonn jet sdd tgd nold `b`oj ujton gd
g`s put Josg adgoji gom semd tgorty-sox geurs n`tdr `ji os
idshdjiojb tgd Newdr V`nndy ef tgd Mer`v` tew`ris tgd Moiind
I`juad< `ji tg`t m`lds tgos `jtohop`tery p`thg ef A`v`ro`-oj-
Brddhd se muhg tgd merd strolojb*
Rg`t w`s tgos eiipodhd
efheujtry
h`nndi
iurojbtgd nofdtomd ef
tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej5 Ot w`s h`nndi Aedeto`< `ji oj Gdnndjoh
mojis tgd weri "Aedeto`j" g`i ` quotd iostojhtovd hejjet`toej* Ot
steei fer `j fdtges wgohg w`s rustoh. stenoi. ujom`boj`tovd. arut`n
`j dtges eut ef g`rmejy wotg tgd prdv`onojb bdjous ef tgd Gdnndjoh
hunturd* Ygos iosheri adtwddj tgd Aedeto`j tges `ji Gdnndjosm
w`s `hhdjtu`tdi ay tgd f`ht tg`tkust adgoji tgd r`jbd ef Hotg`drej.
`ji kust reuji tgd herjdr ef S`rjds wgdrd tgd r`onw`y wojis ots w`y
jew`i`ys. n`y @ttoh` "tgd Gdnn`s ef Gdnn`s"; tgd heujtry wgesd
dtges w`s tgd quojtdssdjhd ef Gdnndjosm nyojb hgddl ay kewn wotg
tgd heujtry wgesd Xtges `ffdhtdi jerm`n Gdnndjoh sdjsoaonotods nold
` k`rrojb jetd* Ygd hejtr`st w`s summdi up oj poqu`jt pgr`sds ;
"Aedeto`j Xwojd" `ji "@ttoh X`nt"*
Ygd peojt ef ojtdrdst. fer tgd purpesd ef eur prdsdjt stuiy. os
tg`t tgos huntur`n hejtr`st. wgohg omprdssdi otsdnf se vovoiny ej tgd
`jhodjt Gdnndjoh hejshoeusjdss. w`s bdebr`pgoh`nny heojhoidjt wotg
`j dqu`nny strolojb hejtr`st oj tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt wgohg
`nrd`iy dxostdi tgdj `ji wgohg stonn survovds te-i`y te omprdsstgd p`ssojb Rdstdrj r`onw`y-tr`vdnndr* Fer @ttoh` os "tgd Gdnn`s ef
Gdnn`s" jet ejny oj gdr seun aut oj gdr pgysoqud* Xgd st`jis te
tgd etgdr heujtrods ef tgd @dbd`j `s tgesd @dbd`j heujtrods st`ji
te tgd rdboejs `reuji* Of yeu `ppre`hg Brddhd ay sd` frem tgd
wdst `ji djtdr tgreubg tgd `vdjud ef tgd Herojtgo`j Bunf. yeu m`yfn`ttdr yeursdnf tg`t yeur dyd g`s brewj `hhustemdi te tgd Brddl
n`jish`pd ad`utofun `ji feraoiiojb `t ejhd adferd tgd vodw os
sgut eut ay tgd a`jls ef tgd Herojtg H`j`n* _dt wgdj yeurstd`mdr dmdrbds frem tgd huttojb tgreubg tgd Ostgmus te pneubg
@dbd`j w`tdrs `t n`st. yeu wonn stonn ad sgehldi. oj tgd X`rejoh Bunf.
ay `j `ustdroty ef n`jish`pd fer wgohg tgd shdjdry ej tgd etgdr
soid ef tgd Ostgmus g`s jet funny prdp`rdi yeu< `ji tgos `ustdroty`tt`ojs ots hnom`x wgdj yeu reuji tgd herjdr ef X`n`mos `ji sdd tgd
n`ji ef @ttoh` sprd`i eut adferd yeur dyds up te tgd summots ef
Sdjtdnohus `ji Gymdttus*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 350/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 8?
Oj @ttoh`. wotg gdr `ajerm`nny nobgt `ji stejy seon. tgd prehdssh`nndi idjui`toej. wgohg Aedeto` g`s dsh`pdi iewj te tgos i`y.
w`s `nrd`iy hempndtd oj Sn`te"s tomd. `s wotjdss tgd @ttoh pgone-
sepgdr"s ewj br`pgoh `hheujt ef ot*
"Hejtdmper`ry @ttoh` m`y `hhur`tdny ad idshroadi `s ` mdrd rdnoh ef
tgd eroboj`n heujtry. `s O sg`nn prehddi te dxpn`oj* Oj hejfobur`toej.@ttoh` hejsosts djtordny ef ` nejb pdjojsun` pretruiojb frem tgd m`ss ef
tgd hejtojdjt ojte tgd sd`. `ji tgd surreujiojb m`rojd a`soj os ljewjte sgdnvd stddpny reuji tgd wgend he`stnojd* Oj hejsdqudjhd ef tgd
suhhdssovd voendjt idnubds wgohg g`vd ehhurrdi wotgoj tgd p`st ?.333
yd`rs 'tgd ojtdrv`n wgohg sdp`r`tds eur ewj tomds frem tgd pdroei wotg
wgohg wd `rd id`nojb/. tgdrd g`s addj ` hejst`jt mevdmdjt ef seon `w`yfrem tgd gobg `ntotuids< `ji. ewojb te tgd sgdnvojb rdnodf ef tgd he`st.
tgos seon. ojstd`i ef n`yojb iewj `nnuvoum. `s ot ieds dnsdwgdrd. te `jy
`pprdho`and dxtdjt. g`s addj pdrpdtu`nny idpesotdi oj tgd iddp sd`
reuji tgd pdropgdry ef tgd heujtry er. oj etgdr weris. nest< se tg`t
@ttoh` g`s ujidrbejd tgd prehdss easdrv`and oj sm`nn osn`jis. `ji wg`t
rdm`ojs ef gdr suast`jhd os nold tgd sldndtej ef ` aeiy dm`ho`tdi ay
iosd`sd. `s hemp`rdi wotg gdr eroboj`n rdnodf* @nn tgd rohg. seft seon g`s
meuntdi `w`y. nd`vojb ` heujtry ef sloj `ji aejds* @t tgd pdroei.
gewdvdr. wotg wgohg wd `rd id`nojb. wgdj @ttoh` w`s stonn ojt`ht. wg`t
`rd jew gdr meujt`ojs wdrd nefty. seon-hn`i gonns<gdr se-h`nndi sgojbnd-
pn`ojs ef tgd prdsdjt i`y wdrd funn ef rohg seon< `ji gdr meujt`ojs wdrd
gd`vony `fferdstdi ` f`ht ef wgohg tgdrd `rd stonn vosoand tr`hds* Ygdrd
`rd meujt`ojs oj @ttoh` wgohg h`j jew lddp jetgojb aut adds. aut wgohg
wdrd hnetgdi. jet se vdry nejb `be. wotg fojd trdds preiuhojb tomadr
suot`and fer reefojb tgd n`rbdst auoniojbs< tgd reefs gdwj frem tgos
tomadr `rd stonn oj dxostdjhd* Ygdrd wdrd `nse m`jy nefty huntov`tdi
trdds. wgond tgd heujtry preiuhdi aeujindss p`sturd fer h`ttnd* Ygd
`jju`n suppny ef r`ojf`nn w`s jet nest. `s ot os `t prdsdjt. tgreubg adojb
`nnewdi te fnew evdr tgd idjuidi surf`hd ojte tgd sd`. aut w`s rdhdovdi
ay tgd heujtry. oj `nn ots `auji`jhd. ojte gdr aesem. wgdrd sgd sterdi ot
oj gdr ompdrvoeus pettdr"s d`rtg `ji se w`s `and te ioshg`rbd tgd ir`oj`bd
ef tgd gdobgts ojte tgd gennews oj tgd ferm ef sprojbs `ji rovdrs wotg `j
`auji`jt venumd `ji ` woid tdrrotero`n iostroautoej* Ygd sgrojds tg`t
survovd te tgd prdsdjt i`y ej tgd sotds ef dxtojht w`tdr-suppnods `rd
dvoidjhd fer tgd herrdhtjdss ef my prdsdjt gypetgdsos*"0
Rg`t ioi tgd @tgdjo`js ie wotg tgdor peer heujtry wgdj sgd
nest tgd auxemjdss ef gdr Aedeto`j yeutg 5 Rd ljew tg`t tgdy ioi
tgd tgojbs wgohg m`id @tgdjs "tgd diuh`toej ef Gdnn`s"*1 Rgdj
tgd p`sturds ef @ttoh` irodi up `ji gdr pneubgn`jis w`stdi `w`y.
gdr pdepnd turjdi frem tgd hemmej pursuots ef stehl-arddiojb `ji
br`oj-brewojb te idvohds tg`t wdrd `nn tgdor ewj ; enovd-huntov`toej
+Sn`te. Hroto`s. oj @-I*
` Ygd @tgdjo`j rdspejsd te tgd hg`nndjbd ef tgd @ttoh djvorejmdjt g`s addj teuhgdi
upej. ay `jtohop`toej. oj O* A 'u/. ven* o. pp* 19-4. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 351/455
93 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
`ji tgd dxpneot`toej ef tgd suaseon* Ygd br`hoeus trdd ef @tgdj`
jet ejny lddps `novd aut fneurosgds ej tgd a`rd rehl* _dt M`j
h`jjet novd ay enovd-eon `nejd* Ye m`ld ` novojb frem gos enovd-
brevds. tgd @tgdjo`j must dxhg`jbd @ttoh eon fer Xhytgo`j br`oj*
Ye pn`hd gos eon ej tgd Xhytgo`j m`rldt. gd must p`hl ot oj k`rs
`ji sgop ot evdrsd`s jdhdssotods wgohg h`nndi ojte dxostdjhd tgd
@ttoh pettdrods`ji tgd @ttoh mdrhg`jt-m`rojd.
0 `ji `nse tgd @ttoh
sonvdr-mojds. sojhd ojtdrj`toej`n tr`id idm`jis ` mejdy dhejemy`ji tgus stomun`tds `j dxpner`toej ef tgd suaseon fer prdhoeus
mdt`ns `s wdnn `s fer pettdr"s d`rtg* Foj`nny. `nn tgdsd tgojbs te-
bdtgdr dxperts.ojiustrods. mdrhg`jt sgops. `ji mejdy rdquordi
tgd pretdhtoej `ji idfr`ydi tgd uplddp ef ` j`vy* Ygus tgd
idjui`toej ef tgdor seon oj @ttoh` stomun`tdi tgd @tgdjo`js te
`hquord tgd hemm`ji ef tgd sd` frem ejd dji ef tgd @dbd`j te tgd
etgdr. `ji adyeji <`ji tgdrdwotg tgd rohgds wgohg tgdy g`i nest
wdrd rdhevdrdi ` gujirdifeni* Ygos dffdht ef @tgdjo`j sd`-pewdr
0 Oj tgd yd`r 0?10. tgd wrotdr ef tgos Xtuiy vosotdi ` meidrj Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j
hemmujoty oj tgd @dbd`j `rd` oj wgesd nofd tgd enovd w`s tgdjZpn`yojb tgd s`md p`rt`s ot g`i ejhd pn`ydi oj Gdnndjoh @ttoh`* Ygos meidrj Brddl hoty-st`td ef @yv`nyq '`
Yurlosg weri md`jojb "Puojhd Erhg`ri"/ er Lyigejod"s 'tgd dquov`ndjt oj meidrjBrddl/ w`s sotu`tdi ej ` nottnd pdjojsun` prekdhtojb ojte tgd @dbd`j frem tgd wdst he`st
ef @j`teno` eppesotd tgd Brddl osn`ji ef Motyndjd 'tgd `jhodjt Ndsaes/* Ygd seon ef tgos
pdjojsun` wgohg w`s `s tgoj `ji stejy `ji rehl-roaadi `s tgd seon ef @ttoh` otsdnf
m`id ` strolojb omprdssoej ef a`rrdjjdss upej tgd tr`vdnndr wge h`md te @yv`nyq evdr-
n`ji frem tgd fdrtond v`nndy ef tgd H`ohus `ji tr`vdnndi ej te Motyndjd wotg ots smonojb
b`ridjs `ji vojdy`ris kust `hress tgd w`tdr* Frem tgd hot`idn ef Sdob`mum. wgohghemm`jis tgd H`ohus V`nndy. M`hdiejo`j @tt`nois `ji Yurlosg P`r` "Esm`jebgnusg`i semdtomds dxtdjidi tgdor iemojoejs evdr g`nf @so` Mojer* _dt a`jdj @yv`nyq g`i
`hquordi `j dmpord tee ; `j evdrsd`s dmpord dxtr`htdi frem tgd enovd* Ygd Brddl sdttndrs
frem `nn p`rts ef tgd @dbd`j wge g`i feujidi @yv`nyq iurojb tgd n`st qu`rtdr ef tgd
dobgtddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr` g`i turjdi tgd a`rrdj seon. ej wgohg tgdor net w`s
h`st. ojte ` beeiny gdrot`bd ay pn`jtojb ot wotg twe monnoej pgvh tohds< `ji. & hdjtury `ji` g`nf
n`tdr.tgdsd
pn`jt`toejs wdrd suppertojb`hemmujoty
eftgorty
erferty tgeus`ji
pdepnd oj ` gobg idbrdd ef hovonoz`toej* @t @yv`nyq. tgd enovd w`s `t tgd aettem ef dvdry-
tgojb* Ygd hemmujoty purhg`sdi ots feei suppnods `ji etgdr jdhdssotods ef nofd aydxpertojb tgd preiuhd ef tgd enovd oj v`roeus feoms ; `s fruot. `s eon. `ji `s se`p 'wgohgtgdy m`juf`hturdi eut ef tgd eon oj tgdor ewj f`hterods/* Ygd w`std preiuht ef tgd eon-
prdssds slojs `ji stejds `ji irdbs w`s usdi `s fudn fer irovojb tgd eon-prdssds `jitgd se`p-f`hterods oj @yv`nyq tewj. `ji `nse fer irovojb tgd std`mdrs 'ewjdi ay neh`n
h`pot`nosts `ji m`jjdi ay neh`n hrdws/ wgohg h`rrodi tgd preiuhd ef tgd enovd-brevdsfrem @yv`nyhk pert `s f`r `fodni `s Qusso` `ji @mdroh`. oj eridr te fdthg tgd hemmujoty"sferdobj rdquordmdjts `s rdturj h`rbeds* Ygos enovd-dhejemy dj`andi @yv`nyq jet ejnyte novd aut te novd wdnn* Ygos hemmujoty ef fruot-brewdrs `ji m`juf`hturdrs `ji mdr-hg`jts `ji sgoppdrs ioi jet jdbndht tgd tgojbs ef tgd sporot* Ots hgodf
bnery w`s `j`h`idmy wgohg w`s ejd ef tgd forst pn`hds oj wgohg tgd notdr`turd ef `jhodjt Gdnn`s `jitgd shodjhd ef tgd meidrj Rdst g`i addj stuiodi `ji t`ubgt tebdtgdr oj tgd meidrjBrddl tejbud*Ygos rdm`rl`and hemmujoty `t @yv`nyq w`s aetg areubgt ojte dxostdjhd `ji wopdi
eut ef dxostdjhd ay tgd prehdss ef Rdstdrjoz`toej. `s tgosrdmersdndssny werldi otsdnf
eut oj tgd Jd`r D`st* @ftdr adojb twohd idstreydi `ji twohd rdfeujidi oj tgd strubbndfer tgd gdrot`bd eftgd eni Ettem`j Dmpord ` strubbnd wgohg tgd fdrmdjt efRdstdrjoz`-toej sdt ej feet adtwddj tgd Brddls `ji tgd Yurls `ji tgd etgdr Jd`r D`stdrj pdepndsBrddl @yv`nyq w`s foj`nny dv`hu`tdi. tgos tomd prdsum`any fer beei. oj tgd brd`t Brddldxeius frem @j`teno` `ftdr tgd i&ihnd ef tgd Brddl @rmy oj obzz* Ye-i`y. meidrjBrddl @yv`nyq adnejbs te tgd p`st je ndss tg`j `jhodjt Brddl @tgdjs* Ygd prdsdjtwrotdr"s bnompsd ef tgd
pn`hdoj 0?10. ej tgd dvd ef ots dxtojhtoej. g`s dj`andi gom te
ujidrst`ji ay `j`neby tgd p`rt pn`ydi oj `jhodjt @ttoh nofd ay tgd mor`huneus trdd wgohgw`s vdjdr`tdi `ji nevdi `s tgd boft ef @ttoh`"s tutdn`ry Beiidss*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 352/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 90
g`s addj vovoiny p`ojtdi ay `j `jejymeus @tgdjo`j wrotdr ef tgd
bdjdr`toej adferd Sn`te"s ;
"A`i g`rvdsts iud te `tmespgdroh hejiotoejs f`nn wotg hrusgojb wdobgt
upej dvdj tgd strejbdst n`ji-pewdrs. wgond sd`-pewdrs surmeujt tgdmd`sony* A`i g`rvdsts `rd jdvdr ef werni-woid ojhoidjhd. `ji tgdrdferd
tgd m`stdrs ef tgd sd` `rd `nw`ys `and te ir`w upej rdboejs oj wgohg tgd
g`rvdst g`s addj `auji`jt* Of O m`yvdjturd te idshdji te mojer idt`ons.
O m`y `ii tg`t tgd hemm`ji ef tgd sd` g`s dj`andi tgd @tgdjo`js * * *
te ioshevdr rdfojdmdjts ef nuxury tgreubg tgdor dxtdjsovd ferdobjrdn`toejs* Dvdry idnoh`hy ef Xohony. Ot`ny. Hyprus. Dbypt. Nyio`. tgd
An`hl Xd`. tgd Sdnepejjdsd er `jy etgdr heujtry g`s addj `hhumun`tdi
ej ` sojbnd spet oj vortud ef tgd hemm`ji ef tgd sd`* * * * Merdevdr. tgd
@tgdjo`js `rdtgd
ejny j`toej. Gdnndjoh er jej-Gdnndjoh. tg`t os oj `pesotoej te `hhumun`td wd`ntg* Of ` heujtry g`ppdjs te ad rohg oj sgop-
tomadr. wg`t m`rldt os tgdrd fer ot. of ot f`ons te hejhono`td tgd m`stdrs ef
tgd sd`5 Xomon`rny. of ` heujtry g`ppdjs te ad rohg oj orej. heppdr er
fn`x. wg`t m`rldt os tgdrd fer ot. of ot f`ons te foji f`veur oj tgd s`md
qu`rtdr5 Aut tgdsd `rd prdhosdny tgd r`w m`tdro`ns eut ef wgohg O hej-
struht my sgops tomadr hemojb frem ejd seurhd. orej frem ` sdheji.
heppdr frem ` tgori. gdmp frem ` feurtg. fn`x frem ` foftg* Oj `iiotoej.
tgdy wonn rdfusd te nohdjhd tgd dxpert ef tgdsd hemmeiotods te etgdr
m`rldts er tgesd
wgehgeesd te
eppesd eur wosgdssg`nn
ad dxhnuidifrem tgd sd`! Ygus O. wge preiuhd jet ejd ef tgdsd hemmeiotods ojmygemd tdrrotery. pessdss tgdm `nn ay w`y ef tgd sd`. wgond je etgdr
heujtry pessdssds `jy twe ef tgdm somunt`jdeusny*"0
Aut tgdsd rohgds ef tgd sd` rohgds adyeji tgd ird`m ef tgd
Aedeto`j pneubgm`j wgesd iddp-seondi fodnis g`i jdvdr f`ondi gom
wdrd mdrdny tgd dhejemoh feuji`toej fer ` penotoh`n `ji `rtostoh
`ji ojtdnndhtu`n hunturd wgohg m`id @tgdjs "tgd diuh`toej ef
Gdnn`s" `ji "@ttoh X`nt" tgd `jtotgdsos ef Aedeto`j `jom`noty* Ejtgd penotoh`n pn`jd. tgd @tgdjo`j ojiustro`n `ji sd`-f`rojb pepun`-
toej hejstotutdi tgd dndhter`td ef tgd @tgdjo`j idmehr`hy. wgond
@ttoh tr`id `ji sd`-pewdr prevoidi tgd fr`mdwerl fer tg`t ojtdr-
j`toej`n `sseho`toej ef @dbd`j hoty-st`tds wgohg teel sg`pd oj tgd
Idno`j Nd`bud ujidr @tgdjo`j `uspohds* Ej tgd `rtostoh pn`jd.
tgd prespdroty ef tgd @ttoh pettdrods b`vd tgd @ttoh v`sd-p`ojtdr tgd
eppertujoty wgohg gd usdi fer hrd`tojb ` jdw ferm ef ad`uty< `ji
tgd dxtojhtoej ef tgd @ttoh ferdsts hempdnndi @tgdjo`j `rhgotdhts te
tr`jsn`td tgdor werl frem tgd mdioum ef tomadr ojte tgd mdioumef stejd `ji se ndi tgdm ej te hrd`td tgd S`rtgdjej ojstd`i ef
rdstojb hejtdjt wotg tgd hemmejpn`hd neb-geusd wgohg M`j
g`s `nw`ys auont oj dvdry pn`hd wgdrd t`nn trdds brew*1 Ej tgd
0Ssduie-Wdjepgej; @tfodj`oXj Segtdo` '"@tgdjo`j Ojstotutoejs"/. diotdi ay L`nojl`.
D* 'Ndopzob 0?08. Yduajdr/. hg* 1*
1 Ygd tr`jsn`toej ef ` hemmejpn`hd `rhgotdhturd oj tomadr ojte ` ujprdhdidjtdiny`ji ujsurp`ssdiny jeand `rhgotdhturd oj stejd -w`s ef heursd jet `j dxhnusovdny @ttoh
`hgodvdmdjt* Ot w`s tgd bdjdr`n hejsdqudjhd ef ` bdjdr`n dxg`ustoej ef tomadr-suppnods
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 353/455
91 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@OWDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
ojtdnndhtu`n pn`jd.te quetd eur `jejymeus @tgdjo`j easdrvdr
ejhd `b`oj.
"tgdor f`mono`roty * * * wotg dvdry n`jbu`bd speldj ujidr tgd Xuj g`s
dj`andi tgd @tgdjo`js te sdndht tgos dxprdssoej frem tg`t n`jbu`bd `jitgos frem tgd etgdr. wotg tgd rdsunt tg`t oj hejtr`st te etgdr Gdnndjds.
wge. `s ` bdjdr`n rund. prdsdrvd tgdor neh`n io`ndht. nofd `ji hestumd
tgd @tgdjo`js rdkeohd oj ` hesmepenot`j hovonoz`toej fer wgohg tgd djtord
Gdnndjoh `ji jej-Gdnndjoh wernis g`vd addj n`oi ujidr hejtroautoej*0
Ygos @ttoh hunturd ioi. ojiddi. b`tgdr tgd wgend eftgd hejtdmper`ry
Gdnndjoh hunturd ojte otsdnf. oj eridr te tr`jsmot ot te pestdroty
sd`sejdi wotg tgd "@ttoh X`nt" `ji djjeandi ay tgd @ttoh omprdss*
Hg`nhoiohX `ji Aedeto`
Ygd hejtr`st adtwddj Aedeto` `ji @ttoh` os jet tgd ejny onnustr`-
toej ef eur tgdmd wgohg tgd @dbd`j `rd` g`s adqud`tgdi frem tgd
`bdwgdj otw`s tgd tgd`trd ef Gdnndjoh gostery* Aedeto` g`i `jetgdr
jdobgaeur. Hg`nhos ; ` hnesdr jdobgaeurtg`j @tgdjs. tgeubg iovoidi
frem Aedeto` ay tgd sd`* Ygd hoty ef Hg`nhos steei ej tgd Duaed`j
sgerd eftgd Xtr`ots se j`rrew tg`t `ttomds tgdy g`vd addj sp`jjdi
ay ` aroibd wgohg ruj adtwddj tgd Osn`ji ef Duaed` `ji tgd
Aedeto`j m`ojn`ji* Oj tgd Duaed`j gojtdrn`ji ef Hg`nhos Hoty.
`ji wotgoj tgd frejtodrs ef tgd Hg`nhoio`j Xt`td. n`y tgd Ndn`jtojd
Sn`oj* @ji tgos Hg`nhoio`j h`mp`bj` w`s jet nold tgd "a`i n`jis"
ef N`toum er @ttoh`* Ot w`s `s beei ` pneubgn`ji `s Aedeto` otsdnf<
aut. ujfertuj`tdny er fertuj`tdny fer tgd Hg`nhoio`js. tgd Ndn`j-
tojd Sn`oj w`s j`rrew<`ji gdjhd. wgond tgd Aedeto`j f`rmdrs wdrd
stonn fojiojb n`ji fer tgd pneubg. djeubg `ji te sp`rd. wotgeut
neelojb adyeji tgdor aeridrs. tgd Hg`nhoio`j f`rmdrs areubgt up
sgert. ejtgdor
osn`ji. aytgd
prdhopoteusfn`jls ef tgd
tewdrojbpd`l ef Iorpgys wdrd stomun`tdi te sd`rhg fer frdsg pneubgn`jis
`are`i* Ygd s`nt w`tdrs ef tgd Duropus Xtr`ots. wgohg w`sgdi tgd
feet ef tgdor hoty w`nns. effdrdi tgd Hg`nhoio`js ` sd`-p`ss`bd fer
tgdor vey`bds ef dxpner`toej* X`onojb eut ojte tgd @dbd`j `ji
adyeji ot. tgdy teel te tgd n`ji `b`oj wgdrdvdr tgdy feuji `jetgdr
Ndn`jtojd Sn`oj `w`otojb tgd Hg`nhoio`j pneubg wotg ` j`tovd pepu-n`toej ojhempdtdjt te geni ots ewj `b`ojst tgd Hg`nhoio`j henejost*
X`onojb jertg `ji d`st. tgdy feujidi ` jdw Hg`nhoiohh ej tgd
he`sts ef Ygr`hd< s`onojb seutg `ji wdst. tgdy feujidi `jetgdr oj
Xohony*
tgreubgeut tgd @dbd`j `rd`* Ot w`s. gewdvdr. ej @tgdjo`j sotds `ji oj @tgdjo`j g`jistg`t tgd Gdnndjoh `rhgotdhturd preiuhdi ots m`stdrpodhds* Rd m`y jetd oj p`ssojb tg`t
tgd `asdjhd ef auoniojb tomadr g`i ` prefeujiny stomun`tojb dffdht jet ejny upej tgd
Gdnndjoh `rhgotdhturd aut upej tgd Xumdjh* Gdrd. gewdvdr. tgd dffdht w`s ef ` ioffdrdjt
loji* Rgond tgd Gdnndjoh `rhgotdht. oj tr`jsn`tojb frem tomadr ojte stejd. w`s stomun`tdi
te hrd`td ` jdw ad`uty. tgd Xumdroh `rhgotdht. oj tr`jsn`tojb frem tomadr ojte arohl. w`sstomun`tdi te ojvdjt ` jdw tdhgjoqud* Gd ioshevdrdi tgd projhopnds ef tgd `rhg `ji tgd
v`unt* x 3p* hot. neh* hot*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 354/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 98
Ef heursd. tgos fd`t wgohg tgd Hg`nhoio`js pdrfermdi ujidr tgd
stomunus ef n`ji-sgert`bd oj Duaed` os jet te ad hemp`rdi wotg tgd
fd`ts te wgohg tgd idjui`toej ef @ttoh` stomun`tdi tgd @tgdjo`js*
Rgond tgd @tgdjo`js rdspejidi te tgd @ttoh hg`nndjbd ay ` qu`not`-tovd hg`jbd oj tgdor dhejemy. tgd Hg`nhoio`js" rdspejsd te tgd
Duaed`j hg`nndjbd w`s qu`jtot`tovd* Ygdy mdrdny `iidi fodni te
fodni. ojstd`i ef tr`jsfermojb fodnis ojte mojds `ji enovd-brevds*
Ygd `brohuntur`n nofd ef tgd Hg`nhoio`j henejods. d`hg sdt oj ots
`r`and pn`oj ` Ygr`ho`j Yerejd er ` Xohono`j Ndejtojo w`s `
rdpnoh` ef tgd nofd wgohg g`i addj novdi oj tgd Ndn`jtojd Sn`oj aytgd henejosts" ferdf`tgdrs `ji wgohg w`s stonn adojb novdi tgdrd aytgdor heusojs wgesd ferdf`tgdrs g`i suhhddidi oj
st`yojb`t gemd*
Oj etgdr weris. tgd dxp`jsoej ef Hg`nhos ioffdrdi fremtgd dxp`jsoejef @tgdjs oj adojb dxtdjsovd `ji jet ojtdjsovd*
0Jdvdrtgdndss.
Hg`nhos tee. oj rdspejsd te ` ndss fermoi`and hg`nndjbd. m`id `
m`rl `nadot ` f`ojtdr m`rl tg`j tgd @tgdjo`j upej Gdnndjoh
gostery* Ot w`s tgreubg tgesd Hg`nhoio`j f`rmdr-sdttndrs evdrsd`s
tg`t tgd a`ra`ro`js ef M`hdiejo` `ji ef N`toum wdrd ir`wj ojte
tgd eraot ef tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej `ji wdrd bovdj tgdor forst
tojhturd ef tgd Gdnndjoh hunturd*1 Ygd Hg`nhoio`js rd`htdi. oj tgdor
idbrdd. te tgd prohl ef Jdhdssoty"s spur. wgond hemfert`and Aedeto`
h`rdi fer jejd ef tgdsd tgojbs*
Ayz`jtoum `ji H`nhgdiej
Ygd djn`rbdmdjt ef tgd `rd` ef tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni irh` 214-
414 A*H*. oj wgohg tgd Hg`nhoio`js pn`ydi tgos premojdjt p`rt.
effdrs us semd furtgdr Gdnndjoh onnustr`toejs ef eur tgdmd* @mejbtgd a`ra`ro`js wge h`md wotgoj r`jbd ef tgd mevdmdjt `ji wge
rd`htdi te ot ay adhemojb hejvdrts te Gdnndjosm ojstd`i ef adojb
suppn`jtdi ay Brddl sdttndrs. tgd ioffdrdjhd. oj stomun`tojb dffdht.
adtwddj ` g`ri `ji `j d`sy djvorejmdjt os onnustr`tdi ay tgd hej-
tr`st adtwddj tgd h`rddrs ef tgd twe Ot`no`j hoty-st`tds wgohg `resd
rdspdhtovdny oj tgd Qem`j `ji oj tgd H`pu`j h`mp`bj`* Ygos
hejtr`st jddis je merd tg`j ` a`rd mdjtoej gdrd. sojhd wd g`vd
dx`mojdi ot oj `jetgdr hejjdxoej `nrd`iy <
8 `ji wd m`y p`ss ej te
tgd hdndar`tdi onnustr`toej wgohg os `fferidi ay tgd hejtr`st adtwddj
tgd twe Brddl henejods ef H`nhgdiej `ji Ayz`jtoum wgohg wdrd
pn`jtdi rdspdhtovdny ej tgd @so`toh `ji ej tgd Durepd`j soid ef tgd
djtr`jhd te tgd Aespgerus frem tgd Xd` ef M`rm`r`*
@ hdjtury er se `ftdr tgd feuji`toej ef tgd twe hotods. tgd Sdrso`j
0 Ygos peojt g`s addj jetdi. ay `jtohop`toej. oj O* A 'oo/. ven* o. pp* 19-4. `aevd. `ji os
t`ldj up `b`oj oj S`rt OOO* A. ven* ooo. pp* 013-1. adnew*1 Xdd furtgdr OOO* H 'u/ '6/. @jjdx OV. ven* noo*
8 Xdd pp* 07-1 0. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 355/455
99 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
st`tdsm`j Mdb`a`zus. wge g`i addj pn`hdi oj hg`rbd ef tgd
Durepd`j gojtdrn`ji ef tgd Xtr`ots ay I`rous.
"m`id ` met wgohgwej gom ommert`n hdndaroty `mejb tgd Gdnndspejtojd
Brddls* @t Ayz`jtoum gd gd`ri tg`t tgd H`nhgdiejo`js g`i pn`jtditgdor hoty sdvdjtddj yd`rs d`rnodr tg`j tgd Ayz`jtojds g`i pn`jtdi tgdors
<
`ji gd g`i je seejdr gd`ri ot tg`j gd rdm`rldi; Ygdj tgd H`nhgd-
iejo`js must g`vd addj anoji mdj `nn tg`t tomd* Gd md`jt tg`t tgdy
must g`vd addj anoji te hgeesd tgd wersd sotd wgdj tgd adttdr w`s `t
tgdor iospes`n*"0
Mdb`a`zus"s f`meus easdrv`toej w`s dpobr`mm`toh r`tgdr tg`j
`hutd< fer ot os jet se ioffohunt te ad wosd `ftdr tgd dvdjt. `ji oj
Mdb`a`zus+s
i`ytgd
rdspdhtovd
idstojods ef H`nhgdiej `jiAyz`j-toum wdrd `nrd`iy m`jofdst* H`nhgdiej w`s stonn wg`t sgd g`i addj
te adboj wotg ; `j erioj`ry Brddl tr`jsm`rojd `brohuntur`n sdttnd-
mdjt ef tgd loji wgohg Hg`nhos `ji Mdb`r` `ji g`nf ` iezdj etgdr
`brohuntur`n hemmujotods oj Eni Brddhd g`i pn`jtdi ay tgd sherd
reuji tgd he`sts ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j `ji ots a`hlw`tdrs* Md`j-
wgond. Ayz`jtoum w`s `nrd`iy brewojb ojte ejd ef tgd ausodst perts
ef tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni `ji w`s f`orny n`ujhgdi ej tgd h`rddr wgohg
w`s te hunmoj`td oj gdr adhemojb tgd untom`td h`pot`n ef ` Gdnndjoh
ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd n`st pg`sd ef Gdnndjoh gostery* Ygus. ay
Mdb`a`zus"s tomd. `jy hemp`rosej adtwddj tgd rdspdhtovd `iv`j-
t`bds ef tgd sotds ef Ayz`jtoum `ji H`nhgdiej weuni j`tur`nny
turj upej tgdor rdspdhtovd f`honotods `s perts <`ji ej tgos tdst tgd
dnoboaonoty ef Ayz`jtoum w`s je ieuat ojhemp`r`any brd`tdr tg`j
tg`t ef gdr jdobgaeur evdr tgd w`tdr* Ayz`jtoum jet ejny pessdssditgd j`tur`n g`raeur ef tgd Benidj Gerj wgohg g`i je heujtdrp`rt
ej tgd dxpesdi `ji fd`turdndss sdhtoej ef tgd eppesotd @so`toh
he`stnojd wgdrd H`nhgdiej steei* Merd tg`j tg`t. tgd sdt ef tgd
hurrdjt wgohg hemds iewj tgd Aespgerus frem tgd An`hl Xd` ojte
tgd Xd` ef M`rm`r` os oj f`veur ef `jy vdssdn tryojb te m`ld tgd
Benidj Gerj frem dotgdr iordhtoej." wgond ot os `ivdrsd te `jyvdssdn gd`iojb fer tgd epdj ad`hg ef H`nhgdiej* 1 Ygus dvdry sgoptg`t pnods adtwddj tgd An`hl Xd` `ji tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j g`s `
ieuand ojhdjtovd fer p`ssojb ay ej tgd etgdr soid frem H`nhgdiej
`ji m`lojb Ayz`jtoum ots pert ef h`nn* Ygd feujidrs ef H`nhgdiej
weuni g`vd addj anoji mdj ojiddi of. oj f`hd ef tgos eavoeus f`ht.
tgdy g`i idnoadr`tdny hgesdj H`nhgdiej oj prdfdrdjhd te Ayz`jtoum`s tgd sotd fer ` pert*
Oj rd`noty. ef heursd. tgd feujidrs ef H`nhgdiej m`id tgdor
gosteroh hgeohd ej quotd ` ioffdrdjt hejsoidr`toej* @s tgdy `p-
pre`hgdi tgd seutgdrj djtr`jhd te tgd Aespgerus ej tgdor vey`bd
0Gdreietus. Aeel OV. hg* 099*
1 Xdd tgd idt`ondi `hheujt ef tgos wgohg os bovdj ay Senyaous. Aeel OV. hgs* 98 `ji 99*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 356/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 94
ef dxpner`toej. tgdy neeldi `t tgd n`jish`pd `ji hgesd tgdor sotd
wotg dyds tg`t wdrd jet anoji `t `nn. aut wdrd sompny f`jjdrs+ dyds`ji jet m`rojdrs"< `ji frem tgd f`rmdr"s st`jipeojt tgdor hgeohd
w`s `imor`and* Ygdy pn`jtdi tgdor hoty ej tgd Aotgyjo`j Qovodr`;` sgdntdrdi strop ef fdrtond he`st wgohg sddms nold `j djhn`vd ef
Mdiotdrr`jd`j shdjdry oj ` merd jertgdrny hnomd* Ej tgos f`veurdi
spet. tgd Brddl f`rmdr-prespdhterswge feujidi H`nhgdiej sdttndi
iewj te r`osd tgd hreps `ji pn`jt tgd fruot-trdds wgohg tgdy g`i
`nw`ys r`osdi `ji pn`jtdi `t gemd* Fer tgdor purpesd. tgdy heuni
jet g`vd hgesdj adttdr< `ji wd m`y ad surd tg`t tgos w`s tgd
kuibdmdjt ef tgd jdxt hemp`jy ef Brddl dxpnerdrs. oj sd`rhg ef
frdsg n`ji fer tgdor
pneubgs.wge h`md tgos
w`ysdvdjtddj
yd`rsn`tdr* Rd m`y pohturd tgd feujidrs ef Ayz`jtoum hursojb tgd
H`nhgdiejo`js fer tgdor pdrspoh`hoty `ji tgdmsdnvds fer tgdor
t`riojdss `s tgdy turjdi tgdor sgops" prews `w`y frem tgd smonojb
Aotgyjo`j Qovodr`. jew hrewjdi ay H`nhgdiej"s w`nns. tew`ris tgd
muhg ndss ojvotojb eppesotd he`st ef Ygr`hd* Xemd Gdsoeioh
dquov`ndjt ef tgd prevdra tg`t "Ot os tgd d`rny aori tg`t bdts tgd
forst werm" must g`vd eftdj addj oj tgd Ayz`jtojds" meutgs wgdj
tgdy tonndi tgd seon ef tgdor nottnd Ygr`ho`j pdjojsun` ejny te sdd
tgdor hreps h`rrodi eff systdm`toh`nny. yd`r `ftdr yd`r. ay tgd a`r-
a`ro`js ef tgd gojtdrn`ji*
"Ygd Ayz`jtojd tdrrotery os `j djhn`vd oj Ygr`hd. wgohg m`rhgds wotg
tgd djtord Ayz`jtojd n`ji-frejtodr `ji hemds iewj te tgd sd` ej dotgdr
soid* Oj hejsdqudjhd. tgd Ayz`jtojds `rd `ffnohtdi wotg `j ojtdrmoj`and
`ji ojsenuand w`r `b`ojst tgd Ygr`ho`js* Dvdj wgdj tgdy m`ld `
monot`ry dffert `ji bdt tgd adttdr ef tgd Ygr`ho`js fer tgd memdjt. tgdyh`j jdvdr bdt roi ef tgd Ygr`ho`j w`r ewojb te tgd muntotuid ef tgd
Ygr`ho`j gerids `ji Ygr`ho`j projhdnojbs* Of tgdy evdrtgrew ejdprojhdnojb. tgos sompny hnd`rs tgd w`y fer tgrdd etgdrs merd fermoi`and
tg`j tgd forst* Dvdj of tgd Ayz`jtojds bovd oj `ji hemd te tdrms fer
p`yojb ` stopun`tdi troautd. tgdy foji tgdmsdnvds je adttdr eff* Fer `jyhejhdssoej wgohg tgdy m`ld te ejd djdmy g`s tgd iordht dffdht ef
arojbojb fovd jdw djdmods iewj upej tgdm* Xe tgdy `rd oj tgd teons ef
tgos ojtdrmoj`and `ji ojsenuand w`r. oj wgohg tgdy `rd dxpesdi te `nn
tgd i`jbdr ef adojb `t hnesd qu`rtdrs wotg ` a`i jdobgaeur `ji `nn tgd
gerrer ef w`rf`rd `b`ojst ` a`ra`ro`j `ivdrs`ry* Ygdsd. oj ` bdjdr`n
w`y.`rd tgd dvons
`b`ojst wgohg tgdyg`vd te
strubbndej
n`ji< `ji.adsoids tgd erioj`ry dvons `ttdji`jt ej w`r. tgdy g`vd te djiurd tgd
ndbdji`ry pujosgmdjt ef Y`jt`nus* Ygdy pessdss ` forst-r`td seon< tgdy
huntov`td ot ojtdjsovdny< tgdy r`osd fojd aob hreps `ji tgdj tgd a`r-
a`ro`js `rrovd ej tgd shdjd te b`tgdr oj `ji h`rry eff tgd hreps `ji
idstrey wg`t tgdy ie jet t`ld `w`y! Ot os jet ejny tgd ness ef n`aeur `ji
mejdy `ji tgd spdht`hnd ef idv`st`toej aut tgd fojdjdss ef tgd hreps tg`t
m`lds tgd ausojdss gd`rtard`lojb*"0
+Senyaous. Aeel OV. hg* 94*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 357/455
96 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Ygus Ayz`jtoum w`s suakdht. `s ` m`ttdr ef heursd. tgreubgeut
gdr gostery. te ` rdhurrdjt h`n`moty wgohg @tgdjs ejny dxpdrodjhdi
iurojb foftddj eut ef tgd twdjty-dobgt yd`rs ef tgd Sdnepejjdso`j
R`r0
`ji Mondtus ejny iurojb gdr dndvdj yd`rs" w`r wotg Nyio`oj tgd rdobjs ef Lojbs X`iy`ttds `ji @ny`ttds*
1 Gdr `brohunturd
w`s `t tgd mdrhy ef `j ojv`idr wgem sgd w`s jet strejb djeubg te
mddt oj tgd fodni `ji wge tgdrdferd g`i ` frdd g`ji te h`rry eff er
idstrey gdr hreps* @ftdr `nn. tgdj. tgd Brddl f`rmdr-henejosts wge
feujidi H`nhgdiej wdrd jet anoji mdj wgdj. wotg aetg sgerds ef
tgd Aespgerus te hgeesd adtwddj. tgdy sdttndi ej tgd Aotgyjo`j
Qovodr` `ji sgujjdi tgd ojgespot`and Ygr`ho`j sgerd< jer wdrd
tgd feujidrs ef
Ayz`jtoummdj ef vosoej*
Ygdy sompnyfennewdi oj
tgd d`rnodr prespdhters" w`ld `ji teel tgdor nd`vojbs* Gewdvdr. `
vojioh`toej ef tgd H`nhgdiejo`js" pdrspoh`hoty os jet tgd trud mer`n
ef tgos stery* Ygd trud mer`n os tg`t wgdj tgd Ayz`jtojds feuji
tgdmsdnvds pdrpdtu`nny suakdht. ej n`ji. te ` pregoaotovd g`jioh`p
wgohg tgd @tgdjo`js `ji tgd Mondso`js suffdrdi ejny fer ` fdw
hrotoh`n yd`rs oj tgd wgend heursd ef tgdor rdspdhtovd gosterods. tgd
Ayz`jtojds wdrd tgdrday stomun`tdi. dvdj merd pewdrfunny tg`j
tgd @tgdjo`js `ji tgd Mondso`js wdrd stomun`tdi oj tgdor ndss
idspdr`td horhumst`jhds. te turj tgdor `ttdjtoej frem tgd n`ji te
tgd sd` `ji te ojidmjofy tgdmsdnvds fer tgdor ruojeus nessds `s
f`rmdrs ay m`lojb g`jisemd prefots `s mdrhg`jts `ji m`rojdrs*
Tjidr tgos pewdrfun stomunus. te wgohg tgd pruidjt H`nhghiejo`j
f`rmdrs ej tgd eppesotd sgerd wdrd jdvdr dxpesdi. tgd Ayz`jtojds
m`id tgd mest ef tgdor str`ots `ji ioshevdrdi je ieuat te tgdor
ewj surprosd `s wdnn `s te tgdor jdobgaeurs" tg`t +tgd Benidj
Gerj" w`s ` herjuhepo`* Ygd wd`ntg `ji ojfnudjhd wgohg Ayz`j-
toum w`s t`ubgt ay Jdhdssoty te idrovd frem gdr hemm`ji ef tgd
Aespgerus `rd idshroadi oj tgd sdheji hdjtury A*H* ay Senyaous oj
tdrms wgohg rdh`nn tgd p`ss`bd `nrd`iy hotdi8 frem `j `jejymeus@tgdjo`j wrotdr ef tgd foftg hdjtury wge os idshroaojb tgd dffdhts ef
gos ewj heujtry"s woidr aut ndss iur`and sd`-pewdr*
"Ygd Ayz`jtojds ehhupy ` sotd wgohg. frem tgd twoj st`jipeojts ef
sdhuroty `ji prespdroty. os tgd mest f`veur`and ef `nn sotds oj tgd Gdnndjoh
Rerni te sd`w`ri `ji tgd mest ujprdpessdssojb ef `nn te n`jiw`ri* Ye
0 Iurojb tgd forst p`rt ef tgd R`r. tgd Sdnepejjdso`js ojv`idi @ttoh` oj tgd yd`rs
980. 983. 917. 912. `ji 914 A*H* Iurojb tgd sdheji p`rt. tgdy wdrd oj pdrm`jdjtehhup`toej ef ` fertofodi pesotoej ej @ttoh seon. `t Idhdnd`. iurojb tgd yd`rs 908-939 A*H*
ojhnusovd*1 Xdd tgd `hheujt ef tgos w`r oj Gdreietus. Aeel O. hgs* 02-11* Ygd Nyio`j ojv`idrs
ef Mondso` pr`htosdi tgd s`md ferm ef dhejemoh w`rf`rd `s tgd Ygr`ho`j ojv`idrs ef tgd
Ayz`jtojd tdrrotery `ji tgd Sdnepejjdso`j ojv`idrs ef @ttoh`* Ygdy idstreydi erh`rrodi eff tgd `jju`n hreps* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. tgd Nyio`js sgewdi ndss a`ra`roty
+
er `t `jy r`td merd djnobgtdjdi sdnf-ojtdrdst tg`j dotgdr tgd Ygr`ho`js er tgd Sdne-
pejjdso`js oj nd`vojb tgd f`rm-auoniojbs. eut oj tgd heujtrysoid. ojt`ht.8 Ej pp* 90-1. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 358/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 92
sd`w`ri. Ayz`jtoum hemm`jis tgd meutg ef tgd An`hl Xd` se `ase-
nutdny tg`t ot os ompessoand fer `jy mdrhg`jtm`j te p`ss dotgdr oj er eut
`b`ojst tgd Ayz`jtojds" wonn< `ji tgus tgd Ayz`jtojds hejtren `nn tgd
jumdreus hemmeiotods eroboj`tojb oj tgd An`hl Xd` wgohg `rd oj bdjdr`nidm`ji* Ygdsd hemmeiotods ojhnuid aetg jdhdssotods nold tgd h`ttnd
`ji sn`vds fer wgohg tgd gojtdrn`ji ef tgd An`hl Xd` os jeteroeusny `
promd seurhd ef suppny. aetg fer qu`jtoty `ji fer qu`noty `ji nuxurods
nold gejdy. w`x `ji h`vo`r. wgohg tgd s`md rdboej prevoids oj `auj-
i`jhd* Merdevdr. tgd An`hl Xd` gojtdrn`ji effdrs ` m`rldt fer tgd
surpnus ef eur Mdiotdrr`jd`j preiuhts. suhg `s enovd eon `ji wojds ef
dvdry vojt`bd br`oj adojb tgd mdioum ef dxhg`jbd oj wgohg tgd
a`n`jhd eftr`id os `ikustdi pdroeioh`nny oj dotgdr iordhtoej* Ygd Gdnndjoh
Rerni weuni jdhdss`rony ad ida`rrdi frem `nn tgos tr`id hempndtdny. er
`t `jy r`td weuni nesd `nn pessoaonoty ef m`lojb ` prefot ej ot. of tgd
Ayz`jtojds hgesd te bovd up pn`yojb tgd b`md `ji wdjt ojte p`rtjdr-
sgop wotg tgd Hdnts 'er. jerm`nny. wotg tgd Ygr`ho`js/. er `b`oj of
Ayz`jtoum otsdnf wdrd sompny jet ej tgd m`p* Ygd Xtr`ots `rd se j`rrew
`ji tgd `ikeojojb gerids ef a`ra`ro`js se fermoi`and tg`t oj tgesd hor-
humst`jhds tgd An`hl Xd` weuni ujqudstoej`any ad hnesdi te Gdnndjoh
j`vob`toej* @s ` m`ttdr ef f`ht. tgd Ayz`jtojds tgdmsdnvds prea`anyir`w tgd brd`tdst dhejemoh prefot ef `nn frem tgdor ujoqud pesotoej.
wgohg dj`ands tgdm te dxpert `nn tgdor surpnus preiuhts. `ji ompert`nn tg`t tgdy jddi. aetg d`sony `ji prefot`any. wotgeut `jy dxdrtoej er
i`jbdr* @t tgd s`md tomd. m`jy hemmeiotods wgohg `rd oj bdjdr`nidm`ji rd`hg tgdor idstoj`toej tgreubg tgd Ayz`jtojds" `bdjhy. `s g`s
addj easdrvdi `nrd`iy* Ye tgos idbrdd. tgd Ayz`jtojds `rd adjdf`hters
ef Xehodty wge f`orny idsdrvd jet ejny br`totuid aut pesotovd monot`ry
`ssost`jhd. ej `j ojtdrj`toej`n a`sos. frem tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni `b`ojst tgd
st`jiojb mdj`hd ef tgd a`ra`ro`js*"0
Ygd Ayz`jtojds wdrd hejtdjt te pdrferm tgdor sdrvohd te Gdnndjoh
Xehodty wotgeut rdhempdjsd se nejb `s. ej tgd n`jiw`ri soid. tgdy
ejny g`i te id`n wotg tgdor rdbun`r termdjters. tgd Ygr`ho`js*1
Rgdj. gewdvdr. oj tgd heursd ef tgd tgori hdjtury A*H*. tgd neh`n
Ygr`ho`js wdrd tdmper`rony suakub`tdi ay ` mobr`tery gerid ef
Hdnts. tgd Ayz`jtojds suffdrdi gd`vony frem tgos hg`jbd ef m`stdrs
oj tgdor gojtdrn`ji* Rgdrd tgd Ygr`ho`js g`i hg`stosdi tgdm wotg
wgops. tgd Hdnts jew hg`stosdi tgdm wotg sherpoejs* Ygdy r`osdi
tgd `jju`n r`jsem fer tgd Ayz`jtojd hreps te `j dxeraot`jt foburd <
`ji oj tgos dxtrdmoty tgd Ayz`jtojds mdt wotg g`riny `jy rdspejsd
wgdj tgdy `ppd`ndi fer foj`jho`n `ssost`jhd te tgd rdst ef tgd Gdn-
ndjoh Rerni* @hheriojbny. tgd Ayz`jtojds wdrd irovdj te r`osd
fujis fqk r`jsemojb tgdor fodnis frem tgd Hdnts ay ndvyojb ` tenn
ej `nn sgops p`ssojb tgreubg tgd Aespgerus< `ji tgdor `htoej se
upsdt tgd Gdnndjoh h`rryojb-tr`id tg`t tgd hejsdqudjhd w`s ` w`r
oSenyaous. Aeel OV. hg* 87*
+Senyaous. Aeel OV. hg* 94-
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 359/455
97 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
adtwddj Ayz`jtoum `ji Qgeids. tgd nd`iojb m`rotomd hemmujoty
oj tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni ef tgd i`y*0
Ygus tgd v`st iovdrbdjhd adtwddj tgd idstojods ef Ayz`jtoum
`ji H`nhgdiej os jet dxpn`ojdi ay Mdb`a`zus"s dpobr`m* Ot w`sjet tgd anojijdss ef tgd H`nhgdiejo`js aut tgd a`ra`roty ef tgd
Ygr`ho`js `ji tgd Hdnts tg`t m`id Ayz`jtoum"s fertujd* Of tgd
`htu`n feujidrs ef Ayz`jtoum g`i `rrovdi forst ej tgd shdjd. tgdy
weuni hdrt`ojny g`vd m`id tgd H`nhgdiejo`js" hgeohd<`ji of tgd
`htu`n feujidrs ef H`nhgdiej g`i `rrovdi sdheji `ji g`i addj ndft
je hgeohd aut te feuji Ayz`jtoum. tgdy. fer tgdor p`rt. weuni
ojdvot`any g`vd addj hejfrejtdi ay tgd hg`nndjbd ef `j ojtendr`and
sotu`toej ejn`ji.
wotg tgdAyz`jtojds"
gosteroh hgeohd adtwddj
st`rvojb `s n`jismdj er m`lojb ` fertujd eut ef tgd sd`*
@dboj` `ji @rbes
@jetgdr onnustr`toej ef eur tgdmd frem Gdnndjoh gostery os tgd
hejtr`st adtwddj tgd h`rddrs ef twe hoty-st`tds ef tgd @rbenoi;
@rbes gdrsdnf `ji @dboj`* Ygd @rbovds. adojb ewjdrs ef ejd ef tgd
fojdst `r`and pn`ojs oj tgd Sdnepejjdsd. g`i ejny ejd oid` wgdj tgdy
adb`jte foji tgdor
@rbovd pn`ojtee sm`nn fer tgdm*
Ygdysdt
eut.nold tgd Hg`nhoio`js. te t`ld pessdssoej ef `iiotoej`n `r`and n`ji
adyeji tgdor aeridrs< aut. ujfertuj`tdny fer tgdmsdnvds. tgdy ioi
jet neel eut te sd` aut noftdi up tgdor dyds ujte tgd gonns `ji hevdtdi
wg`t n`y adyeji tgdm* Y`lojb up tgd spd`r adferd n`aeurojb `t
tgd e`r. tgdy seubgt tgdor jdw fodnis oj tgd qu`rtdr wgdrd ot w`s
g`ridst te `hquord tgdm ; oj tgd tdrrotery ef tgdor Gdnndjoh jdobg-
aeurs. wge wdrd spd`rmdj tee* Ygd Hg`nhoio`js g`i ljewj adttdr
tg`j te try hejhnusoejs wotg tgd sturiy Aedeto`js < tgdy g`i rdsdrvdi
tgdor stddn fer d`sy vohterods evdr onn-`rmdi `ji onn-ioshopnojdi
Ygr`ho`js `ji Xohdns* Ygd @rbovds wdrd ndss pruidjt* Fobgtojbfer tgd m`stdry ef tgd Sdnepejjdsd. tgdy hennoidi wotg tgd Xp`rt`js.wge g`i rdspejidi te tgd s`md hg`nndjbd oj tgd s`md w`y. aut g`i
f`hdi tgd ompnoh`toejs ef tgdor rdspejsd ay monot`rozojb tgdor nofd
frem tep te aettem*1 Fer spd`rmdj suhg `s tgdsd. tgd @rbovds wdrd
je m`thg<`ji tgos w`s tgd dji ef tgdor hoty"s h`rddr* Xgd jdvdr
dxtroh`tdi gdrsdnf frem tgd rend ef adojb Xp`rt`"s ioshemfotdi rov`n
ujton Gdnndjoh gostery h`md te `j dji*
Md`jwgond. tgd nottnd @rbenoh osn`ji ef @dboj` g`i addj pn`yojb`j uttdrny ioffdrdjt gosteroh`n rend. oj hejfermoty wotg tgd v`stny
peerdr pgysoh`n djiewmdjt wgohg sgd g`i rdhdovdi frem J`turd*
@dboj`. r`osojb gdr gerj ` a`rd. senot`ry meujt`oj-pd`l `aevd
0Senyaous. Aeel OV. hgs* 96 `ji 92*
1 Fer Xp`rt`j monot`rosm. sdd O* A 'j/. ven. o. pp* 19-6. `aevd. `ji OOO. @. ven* j"o.
SS* 43-2?+ adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 360/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 9?
tgd w`tdrs ef tgd X`rejoh Bunf wotgoj funn vodw ef @tgdjs.0 w`s je
ieuat ejd ef tgesd "sm`nn osn`jis" wgohg wdrd oj tgd @tgdjo`j
pgonesepgdr"s moji1 `s sobj`n dx`mpnds ef idjui`toej `t ots werst*
@dboj` w`s.oj
f`ht.`j @ttoh` oj mojo`turd
< `ji. ujidr` stonn
merdsdvdrd prdssurd frem tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt tg`j tg`t te wgohg
tgd @tgdjo`js wdrd dxpesdi. tgd @dbojdt`js `jtohop`tdi. ej ` sm`nn
sh`nd. tgd @tgdjo`js" `hgodvdmdjts* @dbojdt`j mdrhg`jts wdrd
t`lojb tgd nd`i oj tgd `htovotods ef tgd Gdnndjoh sdttndmdjt `t
J`uhr`tos oj Dbypt `t ` tomd wgdj @tgdjo`j mdrhg`jts wdrd stonn
r`rd vosoters tgdrd<
8 `ji @dbojdt`j shunpters wdrd h`rvojb st`tuds
te st`ji oj tgd pdiomdjts ef tgd tdmpnd wgohg @dbojdt`j `rhgo-
tdhts g`i auont fer tgd neh`n beiidss @pg`o`. g`nf ` hdjtury adferd
tgd @tgdjo`j Sgdoio`s h`rvdi gos m`stdrpodhds fer tgd S`rtgdjej*
Osr`dnotds. Sgedjoho`js. `ji Sgonostojds
Of wd turj jew frem Gdnndjoh gostery te Xyro`h. wd sg`nn foji
tg`t tgd v`roeus dndmdjts ef pepun`toej tg`t djtdrdi Xyro`. er gdni
tgdor ewj tgdrd. `t tgd tomd ef tgd pest-Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujb.
iostojbuosgdi tgdmsdnvds rdn`tovdny tgdrd`ftdr oj hnesd prepertoej te
tgd rdn`tovd ioffohunty ef tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt oj tgd ioffdrdjt
iostrohts oj wgohg tgdy g`ppdjdi te g`vd m`id tgdmsdnvds `t gemd*Oj `j d`rnodr p`ss`bd.
9 wd g`vd t`ldj jetd ef tgd ioffohunty wgohg
`j ommobr`jt pepun`toej must g`vd feuji oj `hquorojb tgd `rt ef
orrob`tojb tgd b`ridjs ef I`m`shus* _dt tgd Bgut`g tgeubg `
g`ri heujtry hemp`rdi wotg tgd f`auneus B`ridj ef Didj w`s
tgd hgeohdst prozd tg`t effdrdi otsdnf oj Xyro` te tgd ojhemojb a`r-
a`ro`js<`ji ot os tgdrdferd rdm`rl`and tg`t. oj tgd suasdqudjt pre-
brdss ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej. ot w`s jet tgd @r`m`d`j ehhup`jts
ef I`m`shus tg`t teel tgd nd`i* Jer w`s tgd nd`i t`ldj
aytgesd
etgdr @r`m`d`js wge sdttndi iewj `t G`m`tg te orrob`td tgd fdrtond
a`jls ef tgd Erejtds wotg tgdor w`tdr-wgddns<jer `b`oj ay tgesd
troads ef Osr`dn wge g`ntdi d`st ef Keri`j oj eridr te f`ttdj tgdor
h`ttnd ej tgd fojd p`sturd-n`jis ef Bond`i*4 Mest rdm`rl`and ef `nn.
tgd prom`hy oj tgd Xyro`h Rerni w`s jet rdt`ojdi ay tgesd rdfubdds
0 @dboj` w`s dxdhr`tdi te `j @tgdjo`j `uiodjhd `s @oK%xYk [fhtp`t&e< "tgd dyd-serd
ef tgd Sdor`dus+ ay tgd @tgdjo`j st`tdsm`j Sdrohnds wgdj gd w`s dxgertojb gos heujtry-
mdj te id`n tgd m`rotomd rov`n ef @ttoh` tgd ljehl-eut anew `t tgd hunmoj`toej ef ` nejb`ji aottdr strubbnd fer tgd hemm`ji ef ` sd` wgohg w`s tee j`rrew te ad sg`rdi adtwddj
tgd a`rrdj osn`ji `ji tgd a`rrdj pdjojsun`*1 Xdd tgd quet`toej frem Sn`te ej p* 8?. `aevd*
8 Oj tgd tomd ef Lojb @m`sos ef Dbypt 'rdbj`a`t horh` 46?-414 A*H*/ tgd @dbojdt`jswdrd ejd ef tgrdd Gdnndjoh hemmujotods tgd etgdr twe adojb tgd X`mo`js `ji tgd
Mondso`js tg`t pessdssdi sdp`r`td rdnoboeus prdhojhts `t J`uhr`tos idioh`tdi te tgdor
rdspdhtovd tutdn`ry Beis* Ygd etgdr jojd Gdnndjoh hemmujotods wgohg g`i ` feetojb `t
J`uhr`tos wdrd hejtdjt te sg`rd ` hemmej prdhojht; tgd Gdnndjoej* @t tgos tomd. @tgdjs
jet ejny g`i je sdttndmdjt ef gdr ewj `t J`uhr`tos. aut w`s jet dvdj ejd ef tgd jojd
hoty-st`tds tg`t sg`rdi oj tgd `imojostr`toej eftgd Ojtdrj`toej`n Xdttndmdjt* 'Gdreietus.Aeel OO. hg* 027*/
> Oj OO* H 'oo/ '6/ 1. ej pp* 889-X+ `aevd* s Jumadrs. hg* ;
OO D
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 361/455
Xe YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
frem tgd @dbd`j wge h`md te Xyro` jet `s a`ra`ro`js aut `s tgd
gdors ef tgd Moje`j Hovonoz`toej `ji wge teel pessdssoej ef tgd
perts `ji hotods `ji fodnis ef tgd Xgdpgdn`g ; tgd m`rotomd pn`oj
tg`t dxtdjis frem tgd seutg-wdstdrj f`hd ef Meujt H`rmdnte
tgd jertg-d`stdrj frejtodr ef Dbypt*
Oj tgd hejjet`toej wgohg tgdor j`md g`s `hquordi. tgd Sgonos-
tojds g`vd f`rdi stonn wersd tg`j tgd Aedeto`js* Oj eur meidrj
Rdstdrj veh`aun`ry. wotg ots dhgeds ef Xyro`h `ji Gdnndjoh
tr`iotoej. tgd weri "Aedeto`j" sobjofods jetgojb wersd tg`j ` hej-
bdjot`n eatusdjdss ef vosoej. wgond "Sgonostojd+ sobjofods` wonfun
anojijdss `ji ` monot`jt gestonoty tew`ris "tgd Hgesdj Sdepnd" wge
sdd tgdnobgt* Sessoany.
jdotgdr Sgonostojds jer Aedeto`js funny
idsdrvd tgdor a`i j`md- Ot os prea`and. ej tgd wgend. tg`t tgdy
g`vd addj mosrdprdsdjtdi. hejsoidrojb tg`t tgdor rdput`toej g`s
addj `t tgd mdrhy ef gestond jdobgaeurs* _dt tgos hejsoidr`toej oj
otsdnf tdnns ` t`nd* Rgy os ot tg`t tgd pohturd ef tgdsd j`toejs wgohg
g`s hemd iewj te us os ` pohturd p`ojtdi ay tgdor jdobgaeurs" g`jis
`ji jet ay tgdor ewj5 Ot os adh`usd tgdsd jdobgaeurs `ji hej-
tdmper`rods ef tgdors wdrd merd `htovd. merd veh`n. `ji merd
suhhdssfun tg`j tgdy wdrd. `ji gdjhd wdrd adttdr `and tg`j tgdy
wdrd te omprdss tgdor ewj wonn `ji tgdor ewj vodw upej tgd futurd*
Ygd @tgdjo`js `ji Hg`nhoio`js. wge wdrd tgd Aedeto`js" jdobg-
aeurs. g`vd ehhupodi eur `ttdjtoej `nrd`iy* Rd g`vd t`ldj jetd
ef tgd fd`ts `hhempnosgdi ay tgdm wgohg tgd Aedeto`js jdvdr
`ttdmptdi* Ndt us neel jew `t tgd jdobgaeurs ef tgd Sgonostojds.
`ji hemp`rd tgd Sgonostojds" rdheri wotg tgdors*
Ygd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej g`s tgrdd brd`t fd`ts te ots hrdiot*0
Ot
ojvdjtdi `j `npg`adtoh systdm ef wrotojb <ot ioshevdrdi tgd @tn`jtoh
Ehd`j< `ji ot `rrovdi `t ` p`rtohun`r hejhdptoej ef Bei wgohg os
hemmej te Kui`osm. [ere`stro`josm. Hgrosto`joty. `ji Osn`m. aut
`nodj `nold frem tgd Dbypto`h. Xumdroh. Ojiod. `ji Gdnndjoh vdojs ef
rdnoboeus tgeubgt `ji fddnojb*1 Rgohg wdrd tgd Xyro`h hemmujotods
ay wgem tgdsd `hgodvdmdjts wdrd sdvdr`nny hejtroautdi5 Ygd
Sgonostojds m`y prevd te g`vd addj tgd tr`jsmottdrs. of jet tgd
ojvdjters. ef tgd dndmdjts ef tgd @npg`adt. of tgd hejkdhturdi
idrov`toej ef tgd @npg`adt frem semd Moje`j shropt8 os sua-
st`jto`tdi oj tgd futurd ojvdstob`toejs efeurRdstdrj `rhg`denebosts*
Sdjiojb furtgdr `rhg`deneboh`n rdsd`rhg. tgd hrdiot fer tgd ojvdj-
0 Xdd O* H 'o/ '/. ven* o. pp* 71 `ji 031. `aevd*z @ji dqu`nny `nodj. ot weuni `ppd`r. frem tgd Moje`j `ji Gottnth vdojs. `s f`r `s
tgdsd `rd ljewj te us* Oj tgos h`t`nebud. tgd dxhdptoej wgohg prevds tgd rund os tgd
hejhdptoej ef Bei wgohg w`s `tt`ojdi ay Olgj`tej 'sdh O* H 'oo/. ven* o. pp* 094-6.`aevd. `ji S`rt VOO. adnew/* Ygd `aertovd sen`r mejetgdosm ef Olgj`tej g`s ` ios-
tojhtny Xyro`h teuhg< aut tgos fn`sg ef onnumoj`toej oj tgd seun ef ` sojbnd ojiovoiu`n. wgew`s rdpuio`tdi ay tgd sehodty oj wgohg gd g`ppdjdi te ad aerj. h`j g`riny ad pn`hdite tgd hrdiot ef tgd Dbypto`h Hovonoz`toej*
8 Xdd O* H 'o/ '/. ven* o. p* 031. feetjetd 8. `aevd. `ji OO* I 'voo/. p* 876. feetjetd 1. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 362/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 40
toej ef tgd @npg`adt must `t prdsdjt ad ndft uj`nneh`tdi* Rgdj wd
hemd. gewdvdr. te tgd etgdr twe Xyro`h `hgodvdmdjts. tgd gostery
ef wgohg os ` m`ttdr ef hemmej ljewndibd. wd foji tg`t tgd
Sgonostojds g`vd je p`rt er net oj tgdm*Rge wdrd tgesd Xyro`h sd`f`rdrs wge vdjturdi te s`on tgd wgend
ndjbtg ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j te tgd Sonn`rs ef Gdrhunds `ji eut
adyeji5 Jet tgd Sgonostojds. wgesd Moje`j `jhdsters g`i addj
tgd poejddrs ef nejb-iost`jhd sd`m`jsgop oj tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j* 0
Oj tgd Sgonostojd hemmujotods ef tgd m`rotomd pn`oj. tgd `jhdstr`n
sd`f`rojb tr`iotoej w`s aurodi. wotg tgd sewojb-herj. oj tgd furrews
ef tgd are`i pneubgn`jis <`ji se. wgdj tgd Sgonostojds h`md te fddn
tgd jddi te
dxp`ji. tgdyteel tgd s`md
wrejb turjojb`s tgd
@rbovds teel oj tgd Sdnepejjdsd* Yurjojb tgdor a`hls ej tgd sd`.
tgd Sgonostojds teel up `rms te hejqudr tgd `roi newn`jis ef Addr-
sgda` `ji tgd wdnn-w`tdrdi v`nndys ef Dsir`dnej `ji Kdzrddn <`ji
tgdy mdt tgd @rbovds" f`td wgdj. oj fobgtojb fer tgd m`stdry ef
S`ndstojd. tgdy h`md ojte hejfnoht wotg stonn adttdr fobgtdrs; tgd
troadsmdj oj tgd gonn-heujtry ef Osr`dn `ji Kui`g* Ygd ioshevdry
ef tgd @tn`jtoh w`s `hgodvdi jet ay tgd Sgonostojd Neris ef tgd
Xgdpgdn`g. aut ay tgd Sgedjoho`j tdj`jts ef tgd rubbdi moiind
sdhtoej ef tgd Xyro`j he`st*
Ygdsd Sgedjoho`js wdrd ` rdmj`jt eftgd H`j``jotds tgd pepu-n`toej wgohg g`i addj oj ehhup`toej ef Xyro` adferd tgd pest-
Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujb idshdjidi nold ` gum`j fneei upej tgd
Heujtry* Rgdj tgd jdobgaeurs `ji lojsmdj ef tgd Sgedjoho`js
g`i addj evdrwgdnmdi ay tgd ojhemojb Sgonostojds `ji Yduhro`js
frem tgd sd` `ji Osr`dnotds `ji @r`m`d`js frem tgd idsdrt. tgd
Sgedjoho`js g`i survovdi adh`usd tgdor gemds `nejb tgd moiind
sdhtoej ef tgd Xyro`j he`st wdrd jet suffohodjtny ojvotojb te `ttr`ht
tgd ojv`idrs*
Sgedjoho`. wgohg tgd Sgonostojds ndft `nejd. prdsdjts ` rdm`rl`and
pgysoh`n hejtr`st te tgd Xgdpgdn`g. oj wgohg tgd Sgonostojds sdttndi*
Ej tgos sdhtoej ef tgd he`st. tgdrd os je are`i pn`oj `ji je br`i`-
toej adtwddj pn`oj `ji gonn-heujtry* Ojstd`i. tgd meujt`oj-r`jbdef Nda`jej rosds `nmest sgddr eut ef tgd sd` bruibojb tgd he`st-
iwdnndrs `jy pn`oj ef tgdor ewj `ji huttojb tgdm eff frem tgd
pn`ojs ef tgd ojtdroer* Nda`jej `ji Mdiotdrr`jd`j nod oj suhg `hnesd dmar`hd tg`t tgdy ie jet dvdj nd`vd reem adtwddj tgdm fer
re`i er r`onw`y*1 Ygd Sgedjoho`js hemmujoh`tdi wotg d`hg etgdr
+ Xdd O* H 'o/ '/. ven* o. p* 031. feetjetd 9. `aevd*` Oj tgd yd`r 0?88 tgdrd w`s ` hejtojueus nojd ef st`ji`ri-b`ubd r`onw`y frem G`yi`r
S`sg`. tgd @so`toh r`onw`y-tdrmojus `t Hejst`jtojepnd. `nn tgd w`y te Y`r`aunus `t tgd
jertgdrj dji ef tgd Sgedjoho`j sdhtoej ef tgd Xyro`j he`st< tgdrd w`s `nse ` hejtojueus
nojd ef st`ji`ri-b`ubd r`onw`y frem G`of`. `t tgd seutgdrj dji ef tgos sdhtoej ef he`st. te
H`ore< aut tgd b`p adtwddj Y`r`aunus `ji G`of` rdm`ojdi ujaroibdi ewojb te tgd
dxpdjsd ojvenvdi oj tgd ioffohunt djbojddrojb fd`t ef auoniojb ` st`ji`ri-b`ubd he`st`n
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 363/455
41 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
`ji wotg tgd eutdr werni ay w`tdr. he`stwosd <`ji ef tgd tgrdd
nd`iojb Sgedjoho`j hotods Yyrd. @r`ius. `ji Xoiej tgd twe
forst-mdjtoejdi wdrd jet dvdj sotu`tdi ej tgd m`ojn`ji aut wdrd
pdrhgdi. nold bunns" jdsts. ej rehly eff-sgerd osn`jis* Rgdj tgd@r`m`d`js iroftdi ojte Xyro` eut ef tgd idsdrt. tgdy sontdi up
`b`ojst tgd d`stdrj f`hd ef Nda`jej wotgeut pdjdtr`tojb adyeji ot<
`ji wgdj tgd Sgonostojd Venldrw`jidrujb p`ssdi tg`t w`y dj
reutd frem @j`teno` tew`ris Dbypt. wd m`y prdsumd tg`t tgd sgops
s`ondi seutgw`ri str`obgt p`st tgd feraoiiojb Sgedjoho`j he`st te
tgd f`rtgdr soid ef "tgd N`iidr ef Yyrd". wgond tgd ex-h`rts teel
tgd ojn`ji re`i. te tgd d`st ef Nda`jej. `nejb wgohg tgd meidrj
r`onw`y-tr`vdnndrfrem
Yurldyte
Dbyptfojis gomsdnf
tr`jspertdite-i`y* Dvdj wgdj tgd Sgonostojds `ji Yduhro`js wdrd fnujb a`hl
frem tgd frejtodr ef Dbypt.0
tgdy ioi jet f`nn upej Sgedjoho` oj
tgdor rdheon* Ygdy f`stdjdi upej tgd Xgdpgdn`g `ji m`id je
pdrm`jdjt sdttndmdjts jertg ef Meujt H`rmdn* Ygus. tg`jls te
Nda`jej. tgd Sgedjoho`js survovdi tgd Sgonostojds" p`ss`bd< `ji.
`b`oj tg`jls te Nda`jej. tgdy `htu`nny teel evdr frem tgdor jdw
jdobgaeurs tg`t Moje`j tr`iotoej efnejb-iost`jhdj`vob`toejwgohg
tgd Sgonostojds tgdmsdnvds jew iosh`ridi* Rgond tgd Sgonostojds
wdrd arewsojb ej tgd Xgdpgdn`g nold sgddp oj hnevdr `ji wdrd
mevojb ojn`ji. `t tgdor pdron. oj sd`rhg ef p`sturds jdw. tgd
Sgedjoho`js. wgesd m`rotomd gerozej g`i gotgdrte addj rdstrohtdi
te tgd sgert r`jbd ef tgd he`stwosd tr`ffoh adtwddj Ayanes `ji tgd
Idnt` ef tgd Jond.1 jew n`ujhgdi eut. Moje`j-f`sgoej. ojte tgd
epdj sd` `ji wej ` sdheji gemd fer tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej oj
tgd wdstdrj a`soj ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j `ji ej tgd he`sts ef tgd
Ehd`j adyeji*
Ygus tgd m`rotomd `hgodvdmdjt ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej w`shejtroautdi jet ay tgd Sgonostojds aut ay tgd Sgedjoho`js* Ygd
pgysoh`n ioshevdry ef tgd @tn`jtoh. gewdvdr. os surp`ssdi. `s ` fd`t
ef gum`j prewdss. ay tgd sporotu`n ioshevdry ef Mejetgdosm<`ji
tgos `hgodvdmdjt w`s hejtroautdi ay ` Xyro`h hemmujoty tg`t g`i
addj str`jidi ay tgd Venldrw`jidrujb oj ` pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt
wgohg w`s stonn ndss ojvotojb tg`j tgd Sgedjoho`j he`st ; j`mdny. tgd
r`onw`y te nojl Y`r`aunus `ji G`of` tebdtgdr* Ygus tgd r`onw`y-tr`vdnndr wge. adtwddj
Nejiej `ji @ndppe. g`i ejny addj rdquordi te hg`jbd h`rro`bds twohd `t tgd Xtr`ots efIevdr `ji `t tgd Aespgerus g`i te hg`jbd feur tomds merd oj eridr te hempndtd gos
r`onw`y-keurjdy te H`ore* @t Gerjs gd g`i te nd`vd gos tgreubg-h`rro`bd. aeuji fer
r`ongd`i `t Y`r`aunus. oj eridr te prehddi `nejb tgd ar`jhg nojd nd`iojb te tgd ojn`ji
kujhtoej ef Q`y`q* @t Q`y`q gd g`i te hg`jbd tr`ojs frem tgd st`ji`ri-b`ubd r`onw`yej te ` j`rrew-b`ubd r`onw`y wgohg d`rjdi gom 'ay r`hl-`ji-pojoej evdr @jto-Nda`jej/te I`m`shus* @t I`m`shus gd g`i te hg`jbd `b`oj ej te `jetgdr j`rrew-b`ubd r`onw`y*@ji foj`nny gd g`i te hg`jbd ` feurtg tomd oj eridr te ae`ri ` tr`oj rujjojb ej tgd
st`ji`ri-b`ubd r`onw`y adtwddj G`of` `ji H`ore* Ygdsd idt`ons ef meidrj r`onw`ybdebr`pgy arojb eut. oj ` strolojb w`y. tgd ioffohunty ef n`ji-tr`ffoh `nejb tgd Sgedjoho`jhe`st* o Xdd O* H 'o/ '&/. ven* o. pp* ?8 `ji 033-0. `aevd*
1 Xdd O* H 'o/ '/. ven* o. p* 031. feetjetd 9. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 364/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 48
gonn-heujtry ef Dpgr`om `ji Kui`g* Ygos heujtry w`s ojiddi se
dxtrdmdny ujojvotojb tg`t oj spotd ef ots pesotoej oj tgd gd`rt ef
Xyro`. evdrneelojb tgd gobg re`i adtwddj Dbypt `ji Xgoj`r ot
`ppd`rs te g`vd rdm`ojdi 'nold tgd roft-v`nndy ef tgd Keri`j/0
`vorboj wonidrjdss tgreubgeut tgd tgeus`ji yd`rs `ji merd iurojbwgohg tgd rdst ef Xyro` g`i addj ojherper`tdi suhhdssovdny forst
oj tgd Dmpord ef Xumdr `ji @ll`i. wgohg w`s tgd Xumdroh
ujovdrs`n st`td. `ji tgdj oj tgd Gylses "suhhdsser-st`td+ ef tg`t
dmpord. `ji tgdj oj "tgd Jdw Dmpord" ef Dbypt* @pp`rdjtny. tgos
p`thg ef tgoj-seondi.ferdst-hevdrdi gonn-heujtry rdm`ojdi notdr`nny `
je-m`j"s-n`ji ujton "tgd Jdw Dmpord" adb`j te nesd ots brop upej
Xyro`
`ji tgd
pest-Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujbsdt
oj<`ji tgdj. `t
n`st. ot w`s pepun`tdi ay tgd `ivdjtureus v`jbu`ri ef tgd Gdardw
Jem`is wge g`i iroftdi ojte tgd frojbds ef Xyro` eut ef tgd Jertg
@r`ao`j Xtdppd*1 Ygdsd Gdardws wdrd hejtdjt. fer tgd mest p`rt.
te g`nt oj tgd p`sturd-n`jis d`st ef Keri`j `ji seutg ef Gdarej*
Ygd gonn-heujtry adyeji w`s tgd f`rtgdst aeurjd ef tgdor mobr`-toej
<`ji gdrd tgd Osr`dnotd poejddrs tr`jsfermdi tgdmsdnvds frem
Jem`ioh stehl-arddidrs ojte sdidjt`ry tonndrs ef ` stejy breujiwgohg tgdy n`aeroeusny hnd`rdi ef ots ferdsts8
ejny te sdd tgd seon
wgohg tgdy g`i wej frem tgd trdds w`sgdi `w`y ay tgd r`ojs te
iddpdj tgd Sgonostojd pneubgn`jis ej tgd Xgdpgdn`g* Ygd g`ri-
jdss ef tgd nofd wgohg g`s te ad novdi ay tgd gusa`jim`j wgesd
net os h`st oj tgos gonn-heujtry ef Dpgr`om `ji Kui`g os hejvdydi oj
tgd fennewojb p`ss`bds frem tgd rdpert ef `j dxpdrodjhdi Arotosg
ojvdstob`ter wge. oj tgd yd`r 0?83. easdrvdi ej tgd spet tgd nofd ef
tgd Osr`dnotd gusa`jimdj"s meidrj @r`a suhhdssers*9
"Ygd huntov`tdi n`ji oj tgd Gonns v`rods vdry n`rbdny aetg oj idptg `ji
qu`noty ef tgd seon* Oj tgd v`nndys tgdrd `rd strdthgds ef fdrtond n`ji. wgohgwonn brew sds`md `s ` summdr hrep* Ej tgd gonnsoids tgd seon os sg`nnew
`ji ojfdrtond. `ji tgd dxtdjt ef n`ji-gujbdr os dvoidjt frem tgd f`ht tg`t
dvdry `v`on`and pnet ef seon os huntov`tdi. dvdj wgdj ot os se sm`nn tg`t tgd
pneubg h`jjet ad dmpneydi* Ygdrd huntov`toej os h`rrodi ej wotg tgd
m`ttehl `ji tgd ged* Ygd g`rvdst ef suhg pnets. dvdj oj ` f`veur`and
yd`r. os dxhddiojbny sm`nn oj bdjdr`n ot sddms ieuatfun wgdtgdr suhg
0 Xdd tgd quet`toej frem Diu`ri Mdydr oj OO* H 'oo/ '`/ 1. ven* o. p* 142. `aevd*
1 Ygdsd st`tdmdjts noldwosd `rd m`id ej tgd`utgeroty
ef Diu`ri Mdydr; Bdshgohgtd
ids @ntdrtums. ven* oo 'o/. 1ji diotoej 'Xtuttb`rt `ji Adrnoj 0?17. Hptt`/. p* ?6*8 Xdd Kesgu` xvoo* 09-07. fer tgd m`rl m`id upej tgd Osr`dnotds" fenl-mdmery ay
tgd n`aeur ef idferdstojb tgos gonn-heujtry oj eridr te foji reem fer `j dx-Jem`ioh
pdepnd tg`t g`i addj irovdj eff tgd Jertg @r`ao`j Xtdppd ydt w`s idtdrrdi ay ots fd`r
ef tgd orej hg`roets ef tgd H`j``jotds frem idshdjiojb ojte tgd fdrtond v`nndy ef Kdzrddn*
9 Ygd meidrj @r`a pd`s`jtry ef S`ndstojd. nold tgdor Osr`dnotd prdidhdssers. `rd
idshdjidi p`rtny frem Jem`ioh ojtruidrs eff tgd Jertg @r`ao`j Xtdppd. wge ojpgysoh`n
r`hd wdrd @fr`so`j "nejb-gd`is+. `ji p`rtny frem "are`i-gd`idi" idjozdjs eftgd gobgn`ji
zejd ef fenidi meujt`ojs 'sdd ven* o. p* 817. `aevd/. wge werldi tgdor w`y iewj te tgd
S`ndstojo`j gobgn`jis frem tgd @j`teno`j Sn`td`u* @jtgrepemdtroh stuiods ef tgd meidrj
pepun`toej ef S`ndstojd ojioh`td tg`t. oj tgd rdpd`tdi moxturd eftwe r`hds wgohg g`s gdrd
t`ldj pn`hd. tgd "@npojd" str`oj g`s prdv`ondi evdr tgd "Mdiotdrr`jd`j"*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 365/455
49 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
huntov`toej h`j p`y* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. dvdj tgd mest rehly gonnsoids
suppert trdds. dspdho`nny enovds< `ji. of h`pot`n wdrd `v`on`and. m`jy ef
tgd huntov`ters ef tgdsd dxobueus `ji ojfdrtond pnets weuni ad `and te b`oj
` novdnogeei
ay
huntov`toej ef fruot trdds `ji ef enovds* Ygdsd huntov`ters
g`vd. gewdvdr. je h`pot`n.`ji h`jjet `fferi te ferbe dvdj tgd md`brd
hreps eat`ojdi. fer tgd feur er fovd yd`rs wgohg `rd rdquordi adferd fruot-
trdds rdjidr ` rdturj* Oj tgd h`sd ef tgd enovd. tgd pdroei adferd ` rdturj
m`y ad dxpdhtdi os muhg nejbdr*
Ygdrd os nottnd orrob`toej oj tgd Gonn Heujtry* Gdrd `ji tgdrd `rd
sprojbs wgohg `fferi ` suppny fer tgd orrob`toej ef ` sm`nn `rd`< aut.
t`ldj `s ` wgend. tgd heujtry os `roi `ji tgd hreps idpdji ej r`oj* * * *
"Oj tgd adst h`sd *** ot os ompessoand tg`t tgd bdjdr`n hg`r`htdr ef tgd
huntov`toej oj tgd Gonn Heujtry h`j ad r`ioh`nny hg`jbdi. dxhdpt oj se
f`r `s fruot h`j ad m`id te rdpn`hd br`oj* * * * Frem tgd peojt ef vodw
ef `brohunturd. tgd Gonn Heujtry wonn `nw`ys rdm`oj `j ujs`tosf`htery
prepesotoej* * * *
"Ygd nofd ef tgd f`nn`g os ejd ef brd`t strubbnd `ji prov`toej* * * .
"Ot os ` hemmej omprdssoej tg`t tgd f`nn`g"s huntov`toej os djtordny
oj`idqu`td. `ji ` beei id`n ef roiohund g`s addj `ji os peurdi upej tgd
j`on-pneubg wgohg gd usds* Oj tgd stejy heujtry ef tgd Gonns. je etgdr
pneubg weuni ad `and te ie tgd werl `t `nn* Rotg rdb`ri te tgd usd ef
tg`t pneubg. Ir* Ronl`jsly \`meidrj [oejost `brohuntur`n dxpdrt]
wrotds; Ygd @r`a pneubg os nold tgd `jhodjt Gdardw pneubg* *** Ot
pdrferms vdry snewny. ot os trud. aut vdry tgereubgny `nn tgd fujhtoejs
fer wgohg ` hemaoj`toej ef meidrj m`hgojds os rdquordi* * * * Ygd
pneubgojb eftgd f`nn`g os `aevd rdpre`hg* Gos fodni. prdp`rdi fer sewojb.
os jdvdr ojfdroer te tg`t prdp`rdi ay tgd mest pdrfdht ompndmdjts. `ji
semdtomds ot dvdj surp`ssds `nn etgdrs*j
Oj suhg ` heujtry. `ji ujidr suhg hejiotoejs. tgd Osr`dnotds hej-
tojudi te novd oj eashuroty ujton tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej g`i p`ssdi
ots zdjotg* @s n`td `s tgd foftg hdjtury adferd Hgrost. `t ` i`td wgdj`nn tgd brd`t prepgdts ef Osr`dn g`i `nrd`iy s`oi tgdor s`y. tgd j`mdef Osr`dn w`s stonn ujljewj te tgd brd`t Brddl gostero`j Gdreietus
`ji tgd N`ji ef Osr`dn w`s stonn m`sldi ay tgd N`ji ef tgd Sgonos-
tojds oj tgd Gdreietd`j p`jer`m` ef tgd Xyro`h Rerni* RgdjGdreietus wosgds te idsobj`td tgd pdepnds ef Xyro` `s ` wgend. gd
h`nns tgdm "tgd Sgedjoho`js `ji tgd Xyro`js oj tgd N`ji ef tgd
Sgonostojds"<
1 `ji "tgd N`ji ef tgd Sgonostojds" Fon`stoj er S`ndstojd
os tgd
j`md ay wgohg Drdz Osr`dn g`s hejtojudi te ad ljewj`mejb tgd Bdjtonds iewj te tgos i`y*
8 _dt oj tgdsd a`rrdj n`ji-
nehldi gobgn`jis. wgohg wdrd jet ef suffohodjt werniny ompert`jhdte `hquord dvdj ` rdhebjozdi j`md eftgdor ewj. tgdrdw`somm`jdjt
0Xompsej. Xor K* G*; S`ndstojd; Qdpert ej Ommobr`toej. N`ji Xdttndmdjt `ji Idvdnep-
mdjt 'Arotosg S`rno`mdjt`ry S`pdr Hmi* 8676 ef 0?83; Nejiej 0?83. G*M* Xt`toejdryEffohd/. p* 09. 64. `ji 66*
1d*b* oj Aeel OO. hg* 039. `ji oj Aeel VOO. hg* 7?*
8Yn`@`ohmvYk ks tgd @jhodjt Brddl `ji KN5 tgd meidrj @r`aoh fer Sgonosto`*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 366/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 44
'te p`r`pgr`sd Sn`te"s n`jbu`bd/0 ` iovojd ojspor`toej wgohg m`id
tgos ujojvotojb heujtry ` md`js ef br`hd te tgesd wge h`md te
sdttnd tgdrd* @ Xyro`h f`and tdnns gew tgos iovojoty ejhd tdstdi `
lojb ef Osr`dn wotg tgd mest sd`rhgojb tdst tg`t ` Bei h`j `ppny te` mert`n*
"Ygd Neri `ppd`rdi te Xenemej oj ` ird`m ay jobgt< `ji Beis`oi; @sl wg`t O sg`nn bovd tgdd* @ji Xenemej s`oi; *** Bovd * * *
tgy sdrv`jt `j ujidrst`jiojb gd`rt* * * * @ji tgd spddhg pnd`sdi tgd
Neri. tg`t Xenemej g`i `sldi tgos tgojb* @ji Bei s`oi ujte gom;
Adh`usd tgeu g`st `sldi tgos tgojb. `ji g`st jet `sldi fer tgysdnf nejb
nofd< jdotgdr g`st `sldi rohgds fer tgysdnf. jer g`st `sldi tgd nofd ef
tgojd djdmods< aut g`st `sldi fer tgysdnf ujidrst`jiojb te ioshdrj
kuibmdjt < adgeni. O g`vd iejd `hheriojb te tgy weris ; ne. O g`vd bovdjtgdd ` wosd `ji `j ujidrst`jiojb gd`rt. se tg`t tgdrd w`s jejd nold tgdd
adferd tgdd. jdotgdr `ftdr tgdd sg`nn `jy `rosd nold ujte tgdd* @ji O g`vd
`nse bovdj tgdd tg`t wgohg tgeu g`st jet `sldi.aetg rohgds `ji gejeur. se
tg`t tgdrd sg`nn jet ad `jy `mejb tgd lojbs nold ujte tgdd `nn tgy i`ys*"1
Ygos f`and ef Xenemej"s Hgeohd os ` p`r`and ef tgd gostery ef tgd
Hgesdj Sdepnd* Oj tgd pewdr ef tgdor sporotu`n ujidrst`jiojb. tgd
Osr`dnotds surp`ssdi tgd monot`ry prewdss ef tgd Sgonostojds `ji
tgd m`rotomd prewdss ef tgd Sgedjoho`js* Ygdy g`i jet seubgt`ftdr tgesd tgojbs wgohg tgd Bdjtonds sddl. aut g`i seubgt forst tgd
lojbiem ef Bei<`ji tgdrdferd `nn tgesd tgojbs wdrd `iidi ujte
tgdm* 8 @s fer tgd nofd ef tgdor djdmods. tgd mobgty mdj ef tgd
Sgonostojds wdrd idnovdrdi ojte Osr`dn"s g`jis te ad smottdj wotg tgd
dibd ef tgd sweri* @s fer rohgds. Kdwry djtdrdi ojte tgd ojgdro-
t`jhd ef Yyrd `ji H`rtg`bd te hejiuht tr`js`htoejs ej ` sh`nd
adyeji Sgedjoho`j ird`ms oj hejtojdjts adyeji Sgedjoho`j
ljewndibd* @sfer
nejb nofd.tgd
Kdwsnovd ej tgd s`md
pdhuno`rpdepnd te-i`y. nejb `bds `ftdr tgd Sgedjoho`js `ji tgd Sgonostojds
g`vd nest tgdor oidjtoty nold `nn tgd j`toejs* Ygd `jhodjt Xyro`h
jdobgaeurs ef Osr`dn g`vd f`nndj ojte tgd mdntojb-pet `ji g`vd addj
rd-mojtdi. oj tgd funnjdss ef tomd. wotg jdw om`bds `ji supdrshrop-
toejs. wgond Osr`dn g`s prevdi ompdrvoeus te tgos `nhgdmy pdr-
fermdi ay Gostery oj tgd hruhoands ef ujovdrs`n st`tds `ji ujovdrs`n
hgurhgds `ji w`jidrojbs ef tgd j`toejs te wgohg wd Bdjtonds `nn
oj turj suhhuma*9
Nda`jej `ji kf`a`n @js`rty`g
Ygd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd rends ef tgd Sgedjoho`js `ji tgd
Sgonostojds oj tgd gostery ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej os rdpreiuhdi. oj
0 Xdd tgd p`ss`bd quetdi `aevd oj OO* H 'oo/ '`/ 1. ven* o. ej p 141. oj feetjetd 1*
+ o Lojbs ooo* 4-08*8 M`tt* vo* 80-8< Nuld xoo* 1?-80*
9 Frem tgd Bdjtond st`jipeojt. meidrjKdwry os tgd "fesson" rdmj`jt ef ` sehodty tg`t os
dxtojht* Fer tgos pgdjemdjej ef "fessonoz`toej". sdd O* A 'uo/. ven* o. p. 84. `ji O* H 'o/
'6/. pp* ?3-1. `aevd< `ji OO* I 'vo/ `ji S`rt OW. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 367/455
46 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tgd gostery ef tgd `ffono`tdi @r`aoh Hovonoz`toej. oj ` herrdspejiojb
hejtr`st wgohg h`j ad stuiodi oj tgd nofd `t tgd prdsdjt i`yadtwddj tgd djtdrprosd ef tgd Nda`jdsd gobgn`jidrs. oj tgd gojtdr-
n`ji ef tgd fermdr Sgedjoho`j perts ef Xoiej `ji Yyrd `ji Ayanus.`ji tgd st`bj`toej ef tgd Jus`yro gobgn`jidrs wge novd ej tgd
jertgdrj soid ef tgd J`gr-`n-L`aor oj tgd gojtdrn`ji ef @r`ius*
Oj meidrj tomds tgd gobgn`jidrs ef tgd Nda`jej g`vd dmu-
n`tdi tgd gosteroh dxpneots ef tgd Sgedjoho`j osn`jidrs ef Yyrd `ji
@r`ius ay sddlojb tgdor fertujds `are`i `ji m`lojb ` novdnogeei
`s tr`idrs `ji sgeplddpdrs f`r `ji woid oj Dbypt `ji oj Rdst
@froh` `ji oj tgd Jdw Rerni* 0 Ygd Jus`yro gobgn`jidrs. ej tgd
etgdr g`ji. g`vd addj `s
st`y-`t-gemd
`s tgd Sgonostojd hej-
tdmper`rods ef tgd Sgedjoho`js*
Ygd dxtrdmd idbrdd `ji nejb hejtoju`jhd ef tgd Jus`yros"
st`bj`toej oj tgdor gobgn`ji gemds os `ttdstdi ay tgd `jtoqud `spdht
ef tgdor rdnoboej* Ygd Nda`jej. oj ots ewj idbrdd. os ` musdum ef
rdnoboeus survov`ns* Ygd dx-Mejetgdndtd1 M`rejotds `ji tgdMeje-
pgysotd K`heaotds `ji tgd Om`mo Xgo"Os ef tgd K`a`n "@mon `ji tgd
Irusds `rd se m`jy "fesson" rdmj`jts ef ioffdrdjt pg`sds oj tgd nejbhejt`ht adtwddj tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej `ji tgd Gdnndjoh* 8 Ygd
Jus`yros. tee. g`vd `hquordi semd tojhturd ef Xyro`h rdnoboej oj
ots n`tdst pg`sd* Ygdy g`vd tr`vdstodi tgd Osm`"nno Xgo"osm wgohg
ferhdi `j djtry ojte tgdor meujt`oj f`stjdss oj tgd `bd ef tgd
Hrus`ids9 ay idofyojb tgd H`nopg "@nn `au Y`noa<aut tgos wersgop
ef "@nn os ejny `j `hhrdtoej<4 `ji tgd herd ef tgdor rdnoboej `ppd`rs
te ad semd neh`n wersgop wgohg os merd `jhodjt tg`j dotgdr Osn`m er
Hgrosto`joty `ji os pdrg`ps dvdj proer te tg`t omp`ht ef Gdnndjosm
ej tgd Xyro`h Rerni oj wgohg aetg Hgrosto`joty `ji Osn`m g`vd
eroboj`tdi* Ygd sg`rpjdss ef tgd hejtr`st. oj dvdry `spdht efseho`n nofd. adtwddj tgd Jus`yros `ji tgd Nda`jdsd os vdry strolojb <
`ji tgdrd os `nse ` strolojb hejtr`st adtwddj tgd twe pdepnds"
rdspdhtovd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjts*
Rgond tgd j`tovd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt ef tgd Nda`jdsd os pdr-
g`ps jet quotd se stomun`tojb `s tgd rehly osndt ef Yyrd. wgohg
h`jjet ad huntov`tdi `t `nn. ot prdsdjts ` sdvdrdr hg`nndjbd te tgd
gusa`jim`j tg`j tgd gonn-heujtry ef Dpgr`om `ji Kui`g* Ej tgd
stejy fn`jls ef Nda`jej tgdrd os ` roboi nomot te tgd g`rvdsts tg`th`j ad wrujb eut ef ` sh`jty seon. `ji tgos seon otsdnf h`j ejny ad
0 Xdd OO* I 'vo/. p* 887. adnew*8*Dfh-Mejetgdndtd. adh`usd tgd M`rejotds g`vd addj oj funn hemmujoej wotg tgd
Qem`j H`tgenoh Hgurhg sojhd @*I* 0994. tgeubg tgdy g`vd rdt`ojdi tgdor ewj Xyro`d
noturby `ji tgdor ewj dhhndso`stoh`n ioshopnojd*8 Xdd OO* I
'vo/. pp* 189-6. `ji OO* I 'voo/. pp* 174-7. adnew*9 Xdd OO* I
'vo/.p* 147. adnew*
Ej tgd so
K 'vo/. p* 147. adnew*
ktrdjbtg ef ot. tgd Frdjhg m`ji`tery `utgerotods g`vd iuaadi tgd Jus`yros'@r`aoh pnur`n "@js`roy`g"/ "@neuotds". wgohg os ` B`nnohosm fer tgd @r`aoh "@n`woym*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 368/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 42
hejsdrvdi `ji ldpt ujidr huntov`toej ay n`aeroeus tdrr`hojb*0
Ayhejtr`st. tgd K`a`n @js`jy`g. tgeubg ot "g`s addj idshroadi `s `
a`rrdj rdboej". os oj rd`noty "`j dxtrdmdny `brdd`and `ji fdrtond
tr`ht* Adojb newdr `ji ndss rehly. ot os j`tur`nny muhg merd fdrtondtg`j tgd Nda`jej"*1 Oj tgd nobgt ef tgd neh`n prdhdidjts. ot neels `s
tgeubg tgd Nda`jdsdg`iaddj stomun`tdi te dmun`tdtgd Sgedjoho`js
ay tgd a`rrdjjdss ef tgdor j`tovd meujt`oj. wgond tgd `brdd`and-jdss ef tgd K`a`n @js`roy`g g`s ojvdobndi tgd Jus`yros ojte
vdbdt`tojb oj ` Sgonostojd snetg*
Ar`jidjaurb `ji tgd Qgojdn`ji
Rgdj wd turj frem tgd @dbd`j `ji frem Xyro`8
te tgd shdjds efeur ewj Rdstdrj gostery. somon`r hejtr`sts strold tgd dyd*
Xuppesd. fer dx`mpnd. tg`t ejd fojis ejdsdnf oj tgd h`pot`n hoty ef
dotgdr ef tgd twe brd`t Hdjtr`n Durepd`j Dmpords ef tgd meidrj
`bd ; tgd Gegdjzenndrj Dmpord ef Ar`jidjaurb-Srusso`-Bdrm`jy`ji tgd I`juao`j G`psaurb Mej`rhgy* Ejd g`s ejny te ae`ri `j
eutbeojb tr`oj `t `jy r`onw`y tdrmojus oj dotgdr Adrnoj er Vodjj` oj
eridr te rdhdovd tgd s`md omprdssoej tg`t ` tr`vdnndr rdhdovds wgdj
gdbeds ay
tr`oj frem tgd
@dbd`j`rd` ojte tgd ojtdroer ef @j`teno`
er ojte tgd ojtdroer ef Durepd*9 Oj wgohgdvdr iordhtoej yeu m`y
g`ppdj te ad tr`vdnnojb eutw`ris frem tgd juhndus ef tgd Gegdj-
zenndrj er ef tgd G`psaurb Dmpord ojte ots frojbds `ji eutslorts.
yeu foji yeursdnf p`ssojb eut ef `j ujusu`nny ioffohunt pgysoh`n
. djvorejmdjt ojte djvorejmdjts wgdrd tgd ioffohuntods `rd ndss
fermoi`and*
0 Xdh OO* I'vo/. p* 147. adnew*
+ Arotosg @imor`nty; @ G`jiaeel ef Xyro` 'Nejiej 0?13. G*M* Xt`toejdry Effohd/.
S- 88?-8 Rd h`jjet t`ld nd`vd ef tgd Xyro`h Rerni wotgeut easdrvojb tg`t. oj tgd pdjuntom`td
pg`sd ef Xyro`h gostery. tgd hejtr`st wgohg wd g`vd areubgt eut adtwddj Sgedjoho` `jiSgonosto` w`s rdpreiuhdi. oj
t
tgd Gok`z '` rdboej wgohg os ` seutgw`ri dxtdjsoej ef
Xyro` ojte @r`ao`/. oj tgd somon`r hejtr`st adtwddj tgd twe e`sds ef Mdhh` `ji Mdioj`*
Ygd hemmujoty wgohg g`i sdttndi oj tgd v`nndy ef Mdhh` * * * h`jjet. wgdj tgdy sdndhtdi
tgos spet. g`vd gepdi te novd ay ots preiuhd< fer tg`t tgd seon os ojh`p`and ef preiuhojb
`jytgojb os `ttdstdi ay `nn wge ljew ot. frem tgd `utger ef tgd Pur"`j te tgd prdsdjt
i`y* * * * Tjnold Mdhh`. _`tgroa \Mdioj`] nods oj ` fruotfun pn`oj* R`nndi g`aot`toejs.
brddj fodnis. rujjojb w`tdr. dvdry andssojb tgd D`stdrj moji h`j idsord. `rd tgdrd*
@ji ojiddi tgd rohgjdss ef tgd seon fojis dxprdssoej oj tgd j`md Y`"oa`g. tgd pnd`sojb*"
'M`rbenoeutg. I* X*; Meg`mmdi. 8ri diotoej 'Nejiej 0?34. Sutj`m/. pp* 27 `ji
074*/ Oj hejsdqudjhd. wd foji tg`t tgd _`tgroaos. nold tgd Sgonostojds. wdrd hejtdjt te
huntov`td tgdor b`ridj wotgeut turjojb tgdor g`jis er mojis te etgdr tgojbs er adt`lojb
tgdmsdnvds adyeji tgdor ewj aeridrs. wgdrd`s tgd Mdhh`js wdrd stomun`tdi ay tgd
hg`nndjbd ef ` a`rrdj gemd te t`ld te tgd Xtdppd `s tgd Sgedjoho`js. oj somon`r horhum-
st`jhds. g`i t`ldj te tgd sd`. `ji te d`rj tgdor novojbs `s h`mdn-h`r`v`jdrs* Ot os sobjofo-
h`jt tg`t Mdhh`. `ji jet Mdioj`. w`s tgd e`sos oj wgohg tgd Gok`zo Srepgdt Mug`mm`iw`s aerj `ji areubgt up* Ot w`s tgd stomunus ef gos hejt`ht wotg tgd brd`t werni oj gos
h`r`v`j dxpdiotoejs te tgd Xyro`j idsdrt-perts ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord. horh` @*I* 4?9 sdqq*.
tg`t b`vd Mug`mm`i tgd mdjt`n stomunus wgohg ompdnndi gom te dma`rl upej tgd
h`rddr ef ` rdnoboeus rdvenutoej`ry* 'Fer tgd h`rddr ef Mug`mm`i. sdd OOO* H 'u/ '6/.
ven* ooo. pp* 126-7. wotg @jjdx OO. adnew*/9 Fer tgos omprdssoej. `s dxpdrodjhdi ay tgd wrotdr ef tgos Xtuiy. sdd pp* 86-2.
`aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 369/455
47 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Y`ld tgd juhndus ef tgd Gegdjzenndrj iemojoejs ; tgd tdrroterods
wgohg Frdidrohl tgd Brd`t ojgdrotdi frem gos f`tgdr wgdj gd h`md
te tgd Srusso`j tgrejd ; Ar`jidjaurb. Semdr`jo`. D`st Srusso`* @s
yeu tr`vdn tgreubg tgos ujprdpessdssojb heujtry adtwddj tgd G`vdn`ji tgd M`suro`j N`lds. wotg ots st`rvdnojb pojd-pn`jt`toejs `ji
ots s`jiy fodnis. yeu mobgt f`jhy tg`t yeu wdrd tr`vdrsojb semd
eutnyojb herjdr ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd. wgdrd tgd `bbrdssovd idsdrt
w`s tgrustojb ots iry aejds up `ji eut tgreubg tgd sloj ef tgd
Durepd`j n`jish`pd* Ygdj tr`vdn ej wdstw`ri frem Ar`jidjaurb
ojte tgd Qgojdn`ji er d`stw`ri frem Srusso` ojte Notgu`jo` er
jertgw`ri frem Semdr`jo` ojte Xh`jioj`vo`; wgohgdvdr w`y yeu
be. yeuwonn
dxpdrodjhd` jdw sdjs`toej* @s tgd
p`sturds
`ji addhg-
weeis ef Idjm`rl er tgd an`hl d`rtg ef Notgu`jo` er tgd vojdy`ris
ef tgd Qgojdn`ji brddt yeur dyds. yeu wonn ard`tgd ` sobg ef rdnodf
`t yeur p`ss`bd ojte ` jerm`n Durepd`j n`jish`pd eut ef ` n`ji-
sh`pd wgohg w`s `j effdjhd te yeur `dstgdtoh sdjsoaonotods* "Xe tgos
rdpunsovd Estdnaoshgds N`ji os. `ftdr `nn. semdtgojb dxhdptoej`n oj
tgd Durepd`j pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt!" Yrud djeubg< ydt ot os je
ndss trud tg`t tgd idshdji`jts ef tgd mdiodv`n Rdstdrj henejosts
wgesd net w`s h`st oj tgdsd "a`i n`jis" g`vd pn`ydi `j dxhdptoej`n
rend oj tgd meidrj gostery ef tgd Rdstdrj Rerni* Ygd ndbdji`ry
"Srusso`j" m`y ad `s ujprdpessdssojb `s gos gemdn`ji* 'Ygdrd os
`nw`ys ` fnohldr ef fn`md adgoji ` shrddj ef smeld `ji `nw`ys `
br`oj ef trutg adjd`tg tgd mest gestond h`roh`turd*/ Ad tg`t `s ot
m`y. gd g`s m`j`bdi te m`ld gos ujpremosojb lojbiem "tgd
diuh`toej ef Durepd" oj hdrt`oj m`ttdrs wgohg je beei Durepd`jh`j `ffdht te idsposd* Ygd Srusso`j g`s t`ubgt gos jdobgaeurs gew
te m`ld s`ji preiuhd hdrd`ns ay djrohgojb ot wotg `rtofoho`n
m`jurds< `ji gd g`s t`ubgt us gew te r`osd ` wgend pepun`toej
te `j ujprdhdidjtdi st`ji`ri ef seho`n dffohodjhy ay ` systdm ef
ujovdrs`n hempunsery st`td diuh`toej `ji te `j ujprdhdidjtdist`ji`ri ef seho`n sdhuroty ay ` somon`r systdm ef gd`ntg `ji
ujdmpneymdjt ojsur`jhd* Ojtgdsdrdspejsds te gos pgysoh`n djvorej-
mdjt. tgd Srusso`j g`s pdrfermdi ` brd`tdr sdrvohd te M`jloji`ji g`s dst`anosgdi ` merd n`stojb mdmero`n fer gomsdnf tg`j oj
gos merd jeteroeus `hgodvdmdjts; tgd tr`ojojb ef tgd Srusso`j
@rmy `ji tgd auoniojb ef tgd Bdrm`j Qdohg*
@ustro` `ji Nema`riy
Y`ld. `b`oj. tgd juhndus ef tgd I`juao`j G`psaurb iemojoejs ;
tgesd I`juao`j tdrroterods wgohg tgd Dmpdrer Hg`rnds V ojgdrotdi
frem tgd Dmpdrer M`xomono`j adferd tgd I`juao`j Mej`rhgyteel sg`pd oj tgd soxtddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. `ji wgohg
tgd @ustro`j Qdpuanoh ojgdrotdi `b`oj frem tgd n`st @ustro`j
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 370/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 4?
Dmpdrer Hg`rnds wgdj tgd Mej`rhgy areld up oj 0?07* Ej tgd
`dstgdtoh sh`nd ef v`nuds. tgd gd`rt ef @ustro` `ji tgd gd`rt ef
Srusso` `rd ef heursd `t eppesotd dxtrdmds* Ygd @nps oj tgd Yyren
`ji tgd X`nzl`mmdrbut. `ji tgd I`juad oj Tppdr `ji Newdr@ustro`. `rd `s ad`utofun `s tgd s`jis `ji pojd weeis ef Ar`jidj-
aurb `ji Semdr`jo` `rd ubny* _dt. of tgd easdrv`jt tr`vdnndr os jet
`j `rtost aut `j dhejemost. gos pres`oh dyd wonn rdbostdr tgd s`md
omprdssoej wgdj gd tr`vdns eutw`ris frem Vodjj` `s wgdj gd
tr`vdns eutw`ris frem Adrnoj* Rgdtgdr gos keurjdy h`rrods gom eut
ef tgd Yyrendsd er Xtyro`j meujt`ojs ojte tgd pn`ojs ef A`v`ro` er
Nema`riy er Hre`to` er Gujb`ry. erfrem tgda`jls ef tgd @ustro`j
I`juad te tgd a`jls ef tgd Aegdmo`jDnad.
tgddhejemost.
`s gd
easdrvds tgd hg`jbds oj tgd n`jish`pd. wonn objerd tgd tr`jsotoej
frem v`rodty te mejetejy wgohg tgd `rtost pdrhdovds. `ji wonn t`ld
jetd tg`t gd g`s ndft ` nd`j n`ji. fnewojb wotg jetgojb adttdr tg`j
monl `ji gejdy. `ji g`s djtdrdi f`t n`jis wgdrd tgd pn`ojs `rd
hevdrdi wotg gep-fodnis er vojdy`ris er wgd`t-fodnis er addt-fodnis.
`ji wgdrd tgd meujt`ojs `rd ne`idi wotg mojdr`n erds* _dt tg`t
nd`j n`ji ef @ustro` ardi tgd iyj`sty0 wgohg b`tgdrdi tebdtgdr tgd
f`t n`jis reuji `aeut `ji gdni tgdm ujotdi fer feur hdjturods
`b`ojst ` gest ef djdmods wotgeut `ji wotgoj*
Ygd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd rdn`tovd pevdrty ef tgd juhndus ef tgd
G`psaurb Mej`rhgy `ji tgd rdn`tovd rohgds eftgd `ppdjidi hrewj-
n`jis bovds tgd pgysoh`n dxpn`j`toej ef tgd bdjdsos eftgd I`juao`j
Mej`rhgy*1 @ iyj`sty ardi oj ` ioffohunt djvorejmdjt suppn`jtdi
tgd merd seftny jurturdi iyj`stods reuji `aeut* Ygd s`md hej-
tr`st dxpn`ojs tgd dhejemoh str`ots te wgohg tgd Hoty ef Vodjj` g`s
addj rdiuhdi sojhd tgd I`juao`j Mej`rhgy"s iossenutoej* @str`jbdr. vosotojb Vodjj` `ftdr 0?07 wotgeut `jy ljewndibd ef
meidrj Rdstdrj gostery `ji wotjdssojb Vodjj`"s pnobgt te-i`y.
weuni ad `t ` ness te ujidrst`ji gew ` m`bjofohdjt hoty ef semd
twe monnoej seuns heuni dvdr g`vd hemd ojte dxostdjhd oj ` peerny
djiewdi heujtry ef semd sox monnoej seuns `nn teni* @htu`nny. ef
heursd. tgd prdsdjt sozd `ji m`bjofohdjhd ef Vodjj` `rd dxpn`ojdi
ay tgd hoty"s ho-idv`jt st`tus `s tgd h`pot`n ef `j dmpord wotg fofty
monnoej ojg`aot`jts `ji wotg `auji`jt j`tur`n rdseurhds. wgond tgd
neh`toej ef Vodjj` os dxpn`ojdi ay tgd I`juao`j Dmpord"s eroboj*Ygd h`pot`n ef tgd G`psaurb Mej`rhgy w`s jdvdr mevdi frem tgd
0 @s ` m`ttdr ef stroht gosteroh`n `hhur`hy. tgd G`psaurb Iyj`sty w`s ardi oj tgd
h`stnd ef G`psaurb. oj tgd prdsdjt Xwoss H`jtej ef @`rb`u. adferd ot h`md te rund evdr
@ustro`* Ygos. gewdvdr. ejny bovds `iiotoej`n peojt te eur prdsdjt `rbumdjt< fer. hem-
p`rdi wotg tgd @`rb`u. dvdj @ustro` os ` n`ji ef pndjty*+ Fer tgd gum`j dxpn`j`toej. sdd OO* I 'v/. pp* 022-?3. adnew* Oj p`rtohun`r. sdd
p* 070. feetjetd O. wgdrd ` iostojhtoej os ir`wj adtwddj tgd 6tges ef tgd Yyrendsd
Gobgn`jidr. wgohg ejhd m`id @ustro` `j Ompdro`n Sewdr. `ji tgd dtges ef tgd Vodjjdsd
aeurbdeos. wgohg rdfndhts tgd idmer`nozojb ojfnudjhd ef `j dmpord upej tgd ojg`aot`jts
ef ots h`pot`n hoty*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 371/455
63 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
@ustro`j gemdn`ji ef tgd G`psaurb Iyj`sty ` n`ji wgohg w`s
tgd mest vdjdr`and aut nd`st v`nu`andkdwdn oj tgd G`psaurb Hrewj*
"Ygd An`hlHeujtry"
`ji "Ygd Gemd Heujtods"
Rgdj wd turj frem Hdjtr`n Durepd te Brd`t Arot`oj. tgd `p-
p`rdjtn`wefherrdspejidjhdadtwddj tgd ioffohunty `ji tgd stomunus
ef ` pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt tgd n`w onnustr`tdi ay tgd bdebr`pgoh`n
sotu`toejs ef Vodjj` `ji Adrnoj sddms `t forst sobgt te ad put oj
qudstoej ay tgd bdebr`pgoh`n sotu`toej ef Nejiej* Rgond tgd
h`pot`nsef tgd ho-idv`jt G`psaurb `ji Gegdjzenndrj Dmpords nod
oj tgd nd`jdst iostrohts ef Hdjtr`n Durepd. tgd Yg`mds V`nndy. oj
wgohg Nejiej nods. os ejd ef tgd mest wdnn-f`veurdi iostrohts ef tgd
Tjotdi Lojbiem* Ygos supdrfoho`n `jem`ny ios`ppd`rs. gewdvdr.
`s seej `s wd neel iddpdr* Fer ejd tgojb. wd sg`nn foji tg`t.
`ntgeubg tgd se-h`nndi "gemd heujtods" hdrt`ojny wdrd tgd hgeohdst
pertoej ef tgd Djbnosg pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt oj tgd `bd wgdj tgd
h`pot`n ef Djbn`ji h`md te ad dst`anosgdi `t Nejiej. ot os `nse trud
tg`t Nejiej ioi jet woj gdr pesotoej wotgeut g`vojb te rdspeji
te `jy hg`nndjbd `t `nn* Oj tg`t vdry `bd. sgd rdspejidi vohteroeusny
te ` hg`nndjbd frem tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt wgohg wd sg`nn
dx`mojd furtgdr ej oj tgos S`rt* 0Ygos. gewdvdr. os ay tgd w`y*
Fer eur prdsdjt purpesd. ot os merd te tgd peojt te jetohd tg`t. oj
tgd meidrj seho`n bdebr`pgy ef tgd Tjotdi Lojbiem. Nejiej g`s
jet rdm`ojdi tgd h`pot`n ef tgd heujtry oj dvdry sdjsd*
Rgond Nejiej g`s rdt`ojdi gdr st`tus oj tgd Lojbiem `s tgd
fehus ef penotohs `ji foj`jhd. tgd dhejemoh hdjtrd ef br`voty
sgoftdi. iurojb tgd Ojiustro`n Qdvenutoej. frem tgd seutg-d`st
tew`ris tgd jertg-wdst. ujton. ej tgd dvd ef tgd Bdjdr`n R`r ef
0?09-07. ot g`i hemd te rdst ej tgd f`rtgdr soid ef ` nojd ir`wj
io`bej`nny `hress tgd osn`ji frem tgd dstu`ry ef tgd Xdvdrj tgreubg
Hevdjtry `ji Ndohdstdr te tgd dstu`ry ef tgd Gumadr* Of wd jewfox eur `ttdjtoej upej tgd rdboej jertg-wdst ef tgos nojd `ji pohl
eut tgd iostrohts wgohg sg`rdi adtwddj tgdm tgd ojiustro`n prom`hyoj "prd-w`r" Brd`t Arot`oj. wd sg`nn sdd `t ejhd tg`t tgdy hejferm
te eur n`w hejspohueusny* Ygd moin`ji m`juf`hturojb hotods
Aormojbg`m `ji Hevdjtry. Ndohdstdr `ji Jertg`mptej wgohg
`nmest adstroid eur iovoiojb nojd `rd tgd ejny breup sotu`tdi oj
beei `r`and er br`zojb heujtry< `ji tgos os tgd dxhdptoej tg`t
prevds tgd rund* Oj d`hg ef tgd etgdr ojiustro`n iostrohts ef "prd-
w`r" Brd`t Arot`oj. tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt os ejd wgohg. kuibdi
ay tgd `vdr`bd st`ji`ri ef tgd osn`ji. effdrs ujusu`nny ioffohunt
hejiotoejs te M`j* Ygos os trud `nold ef tgd v`nndys ef Xeutg R`nds<
ef Yyjdsoid `ji Yddssoid< `ji ef tgd jdhl ef Xhetn`ji wgdrd
0 Xdd OO* I 'v/. p* 0??. wotg tgd @jjdx. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 372/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 60
Hnyidsoid jew g`raeurs. oj Bn`sbew. tgd sdheji n`rbdst hoty ef
Brd`t Arot`oj `ftdr Nejiej gdrsdnf* Ygd mest strolojb onnustr`toej
ef `nn os tgd bob`jtoh ojiustro`nzejdwgohg dmar`hds tgd seutgdrjdji
ef tgd Sdjjojds oj tgd sg`pd ef ` m`bjdt wotg ots tops `t Srdstej `jiNddis `ji ots hurvd slortojb tgd uppdr heursd ef tgd Yrdjt ` zejd
wgohg ojhnuids tgd N`jh`sgord hettej-monns `ji tgd Xt`fferisgord
pettdrods `ji hennodrods `ji tgd muntopnd ojiustrods ef Jettojbg`m`ji tgd stddn-werls ef Xgdffodni `ji tgd ween-monns ef tgd Jertg
Qoiojb*
Ygd feraoiiojb hg`r`htdr ef tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt oj wgohg
tgos Sdjjojd ojiustro`n zejd os sdt w`s areubgt gemd te tgd wrotdr
ef tgos
Xtuiyejhd wgdj gd g`i ehh`soej te tr`vdn
ayre`i frem
tgd rur`n spet oj tgd d`st ef _erlsgord. oj wgohg gd os wrotojb tgdsd
nojds `t tgos memdjt. te ` pn`hd oj Xgrepsgord wotgoj sobgt ef tgd
Rrdloj* @ftdr tr`vdrsojb _erl ` hoty jet ndss rdmojoshdjt tg`j
H`jtdraury ef mdiodv`n Djbn`ji wd irevd ej seutg-wdstw`ris
`hress ` fdrtond pn`oj stonn ojjehdjt ef etgdr preiuhts tg`j hreps `ji
h`ttnd. tonn wd rd`hgdi tgd frejtodr ef tgd ojiustro`n zejd `t ` vonn`bd
wgohg os hdndar`tdi fer ` ndbdji* Ygd ndbdji os tg`t. ` hdjtury `be.
` hdrt`oj @jbnoh`j prdn`td wgesd ioehdsd dxtdjidi evdr tgd Rdst
Qoiojb usdi te `ppeojt tgd hgurhg ef tgos vonn`bd `s gos trystojb-
pn`hd wotg Rdst Qoiojb h`jioi`tds fer hejform`toej. adh`usd. gd
idhn`rdi. tgos w`s tgd f`rtgdst peojt wdst. tew`ris tgd jdw tdrr`
ojhebjot` ef ojiustro`n squ`ner. te wgohg `jy bdjtndm`j oj eridrs
er eut ef tgdm heuni ad dxpdhtdi te roid! @ji ojiddi. wgdj wd
p`ssdi tg`t prdn`td"s ndbdji`ry aeurjd jew tg`t tgd squ`ner adyeji
ot. ej wgohg gd g`i rdfusdi dvdr te sdt dyds. g`i g`i ` gujirdi
yd`rs nejbdr te brew. tgd `dstgdtoh soid ef eur j`turd pretdstdi oj
symp`tgy wotg tgd prdn`td"s sh`ji`neus untom`tum te tgd nest seuns
oj gos ojiustro`n hurd* Adyeji tgos vonn`bd. tgd fdrtond newn`jis
h`md te `j dji `ji `t tgd s`md peojt tgd fdnns `ji tgd f`hterods
adb`j*
Oj tgdor eutw`ri `spdht.tgd "i`rl s`t`joh monns" sddmdi ` fottojb
m`thg fer tgd and`l brdy n`jish`pd <`ji `t tgd s`md tomd tgd teur
idferhd ef tgdsd mejstreus werls ef M`j. drdhtdi oj idfo`jhd ef
tgd wonidrjdss. g`i `nn tgd mer`n ojhejbruoty ef `j `aemoj`toej
ef idsen`toej st`jiojb oj tgd pn`hd wgdrd ot eubgt jet* Oj tgos
punnun`tojb. tgreaaojb. squ`noi nofd oj ` feraoiiojb n`jish`pd. tgdrd
w`s semdtgojb pertdjteusny ujj`tur`n <`ji tgd `hmd ef ujj`tur`n-
jdss w`s rd`hgdi wgdj wd p`usdi ej tgd summot ef tgd Sdjjojd
Q`jbd otsdnf ` g`ji"s-ard`itg ef fdnn-heujtry tg`t g`i addj ndft
stonn ojvoen`td oj ots st`td ef J`turd `ji neeldi iewj. tgos w`y`ji tg`t. tew`ris Nddis kust adgoji us `ji M`jhgdstdr kust
`gd`i* Rgdj. `t jobgtf`nn.wd feuji eursdnvds p`ssojb tgreubg
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 373/455
61 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Xgrdwsaury suhg `jetgdr mdnnew hoty `s _erl oj suhg `jetgdr
pnd`s`jt heujtrysoid eur bnompsd ef tgd Rdst Qoiojb `ji Xeutg
N`jh`sgord `nrd`iy adb`j te f`id ojte tgd ujrd`noty ef `j dvon ird`m*
_dt tgos ojiustro`n teur idferhd tg`t g`s addj `hhempnosgdi oj tgdSdjjojd [ejd os ef heursd jet kust ` goideus andmosg ej tgd n`ji-
sh`pd* Ygd pertdjt g`s `nse `j ompert wgohg tgd ndbdji`ry prdn`td
wge idpnerdi ots `ppd`r`jhd jdvdr iovojdi* Ygd Sdjjojd [ejd os
ojiddi ` m`bjdt. jet ejny oj ` f`jhofun bdebr`pgoh`n hejhdot. aut oj
seadr dhejemoh rd`noty* Ot os ` m`bjdt wgohg g`s ir`wj te otsdnf tgd
preiuhtovoty `ji tgd pepun`toej ef ` brd`t heujtry se petdjtny tg`t
ot g`s `htu`nny suhhddidi oj sgoftojb tg`t heujtry"s dhejemoh hdjtrd
efbr`voty sgoftojb
ot frem tgd fdrtond a`soj ef tgd Yg`mds te tgd
a`rrdj slorts ef tgd Sdjjojd fdnns* Ygd ujhempremosojb prdn`td
gomsdnf. of gd heuni rdturj te nofd te-i`y. weuni `nmest ad hej-
str`ojdi ay huroesoty te roid ej ojte gos tdrr` ojhebjot` oj eridr te
dxpnerd tgd ubny wejidrn`ji ojte wgohg tgd ubny wonidrjdss g`s
addj tr`jsfermdi* @ji wg`t os tgd `bdjhy wgohg g`s preiuhdi
tgdsd `stejosgojb dffdhts 5 Rgdj wd neel ojte ot. wd foji eursdnvds.
gdrd `b`oj. oj prdsdjhd ef ` jew f`mono`r seho`n pgdjemdjej ; tgd
strejbdr stomunus ef ` merd ioffohunt djvorejmdjt prdv`onojb evdr
tgd wd`ldr stomunus ef `j djvorejmdjt oj wgohg tgd ioffohunty
os ndss*
Oj tgos psyhgeneboh`n `spdht. tgd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd rur`n
seutg-d`st `ji tgd ojiustro`n jertg-wdst ef meidrj Arot`oj sojhd
tgd Ojiustro`n Qdvenutoej rdpreiuhds tg`t hejtr`st adtwddj Aedeto`
`ji @ttoh`. oj `jhodjt Brddhd. wgohg struhl tgd om`boj`toej ef Gdn-
ndjoh easdrvdrs `ftdr tgd brd`t @tgdjo`j st`tdsmdj `ji dhejemosts
` Xenej `ji ` Sdosostr`tus `ji ` Hndostgdjds `ji ` Ygdmostehnds
g`i iejd tgdor werl* Oj eur se-h`nndi Moiind @bds. tgd ojg`ao-
t`jts ef "tgd gemd heujtods" ef Djbn`ji. seutg-d`st ef eur nojd. gdni
dhejemoh `ssdts hemp`r`and te tgesd wgohg tgd Aedeto`js gdni oj
tgd forst `bd ef Gdnndjoh gostery* Ojiddi. tgdy jet ejny pessdssdi
tgd adst `r`and `ji p`sturd n`jis oj tgd Lojbiem. aut oj Xurrdy`ji Xussdx tgdy `nse g`i hemm`ji ef d`sony werl`and orej erds.
wotg tgd weeis ef tgd Rd`ni te suppny fudn fer tgdor ferbds `ji wotg
wotg tgdsd rohg aut w`stojb `ssdts. tgd Xeutgdrjdrs. nold tgd Feenosg
Vorbojs oj tgd p`r`and. omprevoidjtny aurjt up tgdor fudn tonn ot w`s
`nn hejsumdi `w`y* Ygd orej r`onojbs reuji Xt* S`un"s `rd s`oi te
ad tgd n`st suast`jto`n podhd ef werl tg`t w`s preiuhdi ay tgd
Xeutgdrj orej-m`stdrs* Ay tgd tomd wgdj tgdsd r`onojbs wdrd
ferbdi. tgd Rd`ni w`s a`rd. `ji tgdrdupej tgd Xeutgdrj orej
ojiustry h`md te ` id`i g`nt* Ygd st`bj`jt rddi-hgeldi g`mmdr-
pejis upej wgohg tgd n`ttdr-i`y "goldr" stumands oj tgd moiind ef
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 374/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 68
tgd Xurrdy gd`tgs `rd je merd te-i`y tg`j tgos id`i ojiustry"sfujdr`n mejumdjt* 0
Md`jwgond. tgd mdiodv`n ojg`aot`jts ef tgd
Rdnsg `ji Xhettosg `ji Jertgdrj Djbnosg "a`i n`jis" g`i addj
stomun`tdi ay tgd pevdrty ef tgdor djvorejmdjt te dxdrhosd tgdor
ojbdjuoty oj m`lojb tgd mest ef ot* Oj Xeutg R`nds `ji oj Iurg`m.tgdy preadi tgd sua-seon. oj tgd sporot ef tgd `jhodjt ojg`aot`jts
ef @ttoh`. te sdd wgdtgdr J`turd mobgt prevd te ad ndss jobb`rinyadnew tg`j sgd w`s ej tgd surf`hd
<`ji tgdor ojquosotovdjdss w`s
rdw`ridi ay tgd ioshevdry ef ` jdw loji ef fudn* Oj tgd Sdjjojd
[ejd. tgdy teel te suppndmdjtojb tgd md`brd novdnogeei eat`oj`and
frem fdnn-f`rms ay spojjojb `ji wd`vojb <`jitgdyturjdi tegum`j
prefot
fdnn-soids tg`t wdrd teestddp
`ji a`rrdj fer tgdpneubg ay
g`rjdssojb tgd w`tdr-pewdr ef tgd f`nnojb adhl* @ji se. ujidr tgd
hejst`jt prohl ef Jdhdssoty. tgdy dquoppdi tgdmsdnvds. ujwottojbny.fer dxhg`jbojb rends wotg tgdor Xeutgdrj jdobgaeurs `s seej `s
tgdor jdobgaeurs" omprevoidjhd b`vd tgdm tgdor eppertujoty* Rgdjtgd eon oj tgdsd Feenosg Vorbojs" n`mps b`vd eut. tgd Rosd Vorbojsef tgd Jertg wdrd rd`iy te stdp ojte tgdor pn`hds `ji te `stejosg
tgd Rerni wotg tgd mobgty tgeubg s`iny vunb`r onnumoj`toej
wgohg tgdy wdrd `and te preiuhd* Oj tgd Ojiustro`n Qdvenutoej. tgd
Jertgdrj he`n-fudn wotg ots ujgd`ri-ef petdjhy `ji tgd Jertgdrj
mdhg`joh`n prehdssds wotg tgdor ujgd`ri-ef preiuhtovoty rdpn`hdi`ji dhnopsdi tgd hemmejpn`hd weei-fudn `ji tgd tr`iotoej`n g`ji-
werl ef tgd Xeutg*1 Ygd meidrj ojiustro`n Arot`oj wgohg `resd.
nold ` kojj ef tgd idsdrt. eut ef tgd "a`i n`jis" adyeji tgd Xdvdrj-
Gumadr nojd. surp`ssdi tgd mdiodv`n `br`ro`j Arot`oj ef "tgd gemd
heujtods" `s Xenemej tgd lojb ef tgd gonn-heujtry ef Dpgr`om `ji
Kui`g surp`ssdi oj `nn gos bnery tgd e`sos-quddj ef Xgda`* 8
+ Fer tgd gostery ef tgd Xeutgdrj orej ojiustry. sdd Xtr`ldr. D* ; Rd`nidj Orej 'Nejiej0?80. Adnn/*
z Ot os `musojb te jetohd tg`t tgd id`rtg ef weei. wgohg stomun`tdi tgd `jhodjt
Brddls ojte hrd`tojb tgd ad`utods ef Gdnndjoh `rhgotdhturd. `ji tgd `jhodjt Xumdro`jsojte ojvdjtojb tgd `rhg `ji tgd v`unt 'sdd feetjetd 1 ej p* 90. `aevd/. g`s stomun`tdi tgd
meidrj Arotosg ojte aurjojb he`n*8 Ygd sgoftojb ef tgd dhejemoh hdjtrd ef br`voty ef Brd`t Arot`oj `t tgd tomd ef tgd
Ojiustro`n Qdvenutoej os semdtomds `ttroautdi oj n`rbd md`surd te tgd hg`jbd oj tgd fnew
ef ojtdrj`toej`n tr`id wgohg fennewdi tgd ioshevdry ef tgd Jdw Rerni* Xojhd tgd
Rdstdrj dxpnerdrs wge m`id tgos ioshevdry wdrd jet j`tovds ef tgd Arotosg Osnds. tgd
dffdht ef tgdor ioshevdry upej tgd dhejemoh nofd ef Brd`t Arot`oj must ad rdb`ridi. fremtgd Arotosg st`jipeojt. `s tgd `hhoidjt`n dffdht ef `j dxtr`jdeus h`usd* Xe f`r. tgdrdferd.
`s tgos dxtr`jdeus h`usd hejtjautdi te tgd sgoft oj tgd dhejemoh hdjtrd ef br`voty ef
Arot`oj. ot tdnns `b`ojst eur dxpn`j`toej ef tgd sgoft `s `j ojhoidjt oj tgd ojtdrj`n gostery
ef Arot`oj `ji `s ` hejsdqudjhd ef tgd ioffdrdjt rdn`toejs adtwddj M`j `ji gos pgysoh`n
djvorejmdjt wgohgrdspdhtovdny eat`ojdi. iurojb tgd Moiind @bds. oj tgd Xeutg `ji oj
tgd perts ej tgd wdst he`st `ji ef tgdor dhejemoh gojtdrn`jis. `ji te tgd prdkuiohd ef tgd
perts ej tgd d`st he`st* Ygos iovoiojb nojd adtwddj tgd d`stdrj `ji tgd wdstdrj f`hds ef
Brd`t Arot`oj ay je md`js heojhoids. gewdvdr. wotg tgd nojd. rujjojb io`bej`nny `hress
tgd heujtry frem Xdvdrj te Gumadr. wgohg h`mddvdjtu`nny
semd twe er tgrdd
hdjtomds `ftdr tgd ioshevdry ef @mdroh` g`i t`ldj pn`hd te iovoid tgd `br`ro`j sdhtoej
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 375/455
69 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Oj tgd prdsdjt "pest-w`r" `bd. tgos bnery os pdrg`ps idp`rtojb*
Xojhd `aeut tgd yd`r 0?13 tgdrd g`vd addj ojioh`toejs tg`t tgd
dhejemoh hdjtrd ef br`voty ef Brd`t Arot`oj os tdjiojb te sgoft a`hl
`b`oj. seutg-d`stw`ri.tew`ris ots mdiodv`n nehus.
K
`ji somunt`jdeusojioh`toejs tg`t tgd dhejemoh hdjtrd ef br`voty ef tgd Rerni os
sgoftojb `w`y frem tgd Arotosg Osnds. `ji ojiddi frem Durepd.
`ntebdtgdr. `ji os p`ssojb evdr te Jertg @mdroh`* Ot m`y ad tg`t.
of tgdsd symptems adhemd merd sg`rpny prejeujhdi. tgd ho-idv`jt
ojiustro`n fehus ef Arot`oj. m`reejdi `mejb tgd a`rrdj Sdjjojd
fdnns. wonn hemd te prdsdjt `s mdn`jhgeny ` spdht`hnd `s tgd ho-
idv`jt penotoh`n h`pot`n ef tgd I`juao`j Mej`rhgy. omprosejdi
wotgoj tgd frejtodrs ef tgd nottnd
@npojd Qdpuanohef @ustro`* Ygd
ir`m` ef Ojiustro`n Arot`oj. wgohg epdjdi oj ` ausy squ`ner `ji
hunmoj`tdi oj ` brom m`bjofohdjhd. m`y ad tr`jsfoburdi oj ots tgori
`ht ojte `j `ustdrd tr`bdiy wotg ` hrudn dji*1
Ygd dhejemoh hejtr`st adtwddj tgd twe sdhtoejs ojte wgohg
Brd`t Arot`oj os iovoidi ay tgd Xdvdrj-Gumadr nojd os jet tgd ejny
onnustr`toej ef eur tgdmd wgohg tgd osn`ji prevoids* Xtonn merd
f`mono`r os tgd huntur`n hejtr`st adtwddj Djbn`ji `ji Xhetn`ji.
wgohg g`s survovdi tgd ujoej ef tgd twe lojbiems `ji wgohg stonn
ndjis rd`noty te ` Aeridr wgohg g`s nest ots penotoh`n `ji g`s jdvdr
pessdssdi `jy dhejemoh sobjofoh`jhd* Ygd jeteroeus ioffdrdjhd ef
tdmpdr`mdjt `ji g`aotadtwddj tgd ndbdji`ry Xhethgm`j sendmj.
p`rsomejoeus. prdhosd. pdrsostdjt. h`utoeus. hejshodjtoeus. `ji
tgereubgny wdnn diuh`tdi `ji tgd ndbdji`ry Djbnosgm`j frove-
neus. dxtr`v`b`jt. v`bud. sp`smeioh. h`rdndss. frdd-`ji-d`sy. `ji
onn-breujidi oj aeel-nd`rjojb fennews tgd s`md nojds. `ji herrd-
ef Brd`t Arot`oj frem tgd ojiustro`n* Fer ojst`jhd. tgd ioshevdry ef @mdroh`. `s w`s te ad
dxpdhtdi. areubgt prespdroty oj tgd soxtddjtg hdjtury te tgd sd`mdj ef Idvejsgord `jite tgd mdrhg`jts ef Arosten; tgd wdstdrj m`rotomd iostrohts wgohg wdrd nd`st iost`jt frem"tgd gemd heujtods" `ji frem Nejiej* _dt ot g`s stonn te ad dxpn`ojdi wgy Arosten `ftdr-@-
w`ris nest tgd prom`hy oj tgd @mdroh`j tr`id te Novdrpeen `ji Bn`sbew; wdst-he`st
perts wgohg wdrd bdebr`pgoh`nny g`jioh`ppdi. oj hempdtotoej wotg Arosten. ay adojb
sdp`r`tdi frem tgd epdj @tn`jtoh ay ` nejbdr strdthg ef j`rrew i`jbdreus w`tdrs* Ot g`s
`nse te ad dxpn`ojdi wgy. oj tgd Ojiustro`n Qdvenutoej. tgd jdw nofd sgewdi otsdnf jet ejnyoj tgd N`jh`sgord `ji N`j`rlsgord gojtdrn`jis ef Mdrsdysoid `ji Hnyidsoid aut dqu`nnyoj Yyjdsoid `ji Yddssoid `ji oj tgd Rdst Qoiojb ef _erlsgord. wgohg w`s sdrvdi ay tgd
pert ef Gunn* Jdwh`stnd `ji Moiindsareubg `jiGunn. nold tgd dxtojht gd`rtgs efmdiodv`n
Djbnosg tr`id `ji ojiustry oj D`st @jbg`. `nn f`hd `w`y frem tgd @tn`jtoh `ji frem@mdroh`* Of tgd `hhdssoaonoty ef tgd @mdroh`j m`rldt `ji ef tgd @mdroh`j seurhd ef
suppny w`s rd`nny tgd idtdrmojojb f`hter oj tgd sgoft ef tgd dhejemoh hdjtrd ef br`voty ef
Brd`t Arot`oj `t tgd tomd ef tgd Ojiustro`n Qdvenutoej. ot weuni ad ompessoand te dxpn`oj
wgy `t tgos vdry tomd Arosten idh`ydi`ji Jdwh`stnd adb`j te fneurosg* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji.tgd pgdjemdj` `rd `nn dxpnoh`and of ot os hejhdidi tg`t tgd bdebr`pgoh`n rdn`toej te @mdroh`w`s je merd tg`j ` sdheji`ry f`hter `ji tg`t tgd bevdrjojb f`hter oj tgd sgoft w`s tgd
ioffdrdjhd. dx`mojdi `aevd. oj tgd idbrdd ef tgd rdspdhtovd stomuno wgohg wdrd `imojos-tdrdi te gum`j `htovotods ay tgd twe sdhtoejs ef tgd osn`ji. `s idm`rh`tdi ay eur io`bej`niovoiojb nojd*
0 Ygdsd symptems `rd ioshussdi. oj `jetgdr hejjdxoej. oj OOO* H 'o/ 'i/. ven* ooo. p* 132.adnew*
` Ygdsd nojds wdrd wrottdj ` fdw wddls adferd tgd 1ost Xdptdmadr. 0?80. wgohg. `t
tgd tomd ef rdvosoej. sddmdi noldny te ad ` memdjteus i`td oj Djbnosg dhejemoh `jifoj`jho`n gostery*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 376/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 64
spdjis te tgd s`md hejtr`st oj tgd neh`n pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt. `s
tgd somon`r ioffdrdjhd. wgohg g`s noldwosd addj dn`aer`tdi `ji
h`roh`turdi ej aetg soids. adtwddj tgd ndbdji`ry Srusso`j `ji tgd
ndbdji`ryA`v`ro`j*
+
Ygd Xtrubbnd fer Jertg @mdroh`
Ygd hn`ssoh onnustr`toej ef eur prdsdjt tgdmd oj eur Rdstdrj
gostery os tgd euthemd ef tgd hempdtotoej adtwddj g`nf ` iezdj
ioffdrdjt breups ef Rdstdrj henejosts fer tgd m`stdry ef Jertg
@mdroh`* Ygd vohters oj tgos hejtdst wdrd tgd Jdw Djbn`jidrs<`ji `t `j d`rnodr peojt oj tgos hg`ptdr. `prepes ef tgd rdvdrsoej ef
Yewj Gonn. Hejjdhtohut. te ots prostojd st`td ef J`turd. wd g`vd
t`ldj jetd ef tgd ujusu`n ioffohunty ef tgd neh`n @mdroh`j djvorej-
mdjt wgohg forst fdnn te tgd net ef tgd untom`td m`stdrs ef tgd wgend
hejtojdjt* Ndt us jew hemp`rd tgos Jdw Djbn`ji djvorejmdjt. ef
wgohg tgd sotd ef Yewj Gonn os ` spdhomdj. wotg tgd d`rnodst
@mdroh`j djvorejmdjts ef tgd Jdw Djbn`jidrs" ujsuhhdssfun
hempdtoters ; tgd Iuthg. tgd Frdjhg. tgd Xp`jo`ris. `ji tgd Jdw
Djbn`jidrs" ewj lojsmdj `ji jdobgaeurs frem Djbn`ji wgedst`anosgdi tgdmsdnvds `nejb tgd seutgdrj sdhtoej ef tgd @tn`jtoh
sd`ae`ri*Oj tgd moiind ef tgd sdvdjtddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`.
wgdj `nn tgdsd sdttndrs g`i `nrd`iy feuji tgdor forst feetojb ej tgd
frojbds ef tgd Jertg @mdroh`j m`ojn`ji. ot weuni g`vd addj quotd
d`sy te prdioht tgd hemojb hejfnoht adtwddj tgdm fer tgd pessdssoej
ef tgd ojtdroer< aut tgd mest `hutd `ji f`r-sobgtdi easdrvdr tgdj
`novd weuni g`riny g`vd addj noldny te got tgd m`rl of gd g`i addj
`sldi. `t tgd tomd. te idsobj`td tgd untom`td vohter* Gd mobgt hej-
hdov`anyg`vd g`i tgd `humdj te rund eut tgd
Xp`jo`risoj
spotd
ef
tgdor twe eavoeus `ssdts ; tgdor ewjdrsgop. oj Mdxohe. ef tgd ejny
rdboej oj er `ikeojojb Jertg @mdroh` wgohg g`i addj areldj-oj
`ji idvdnepdi dhejemoh`nny. adferd tgd Durepd`j henejosts" `rrov`n.
ay `j ojiobdjeus hovonoz`toej< `ji tgd prom`hy ef Xp`oj. oj eur
gypetgdtoh`n easdrvdr"s ewj i`y. `mejb tgd Brd`t Sewdrs ef tgd
Rdstdrj Rerni* Eur easdrvdr mobgt g`vd iosheujtdi tgd gobg
idvdnepmdjt ef Mdxohe oj vodw ef ots eutnyojb pesotoej hut eff.
`s ot w`s. frem tgd m`oj aeiy ef Jertg @mdroh` ay ` are`i adnt ef
ojgespot`and pn`td`u `ji idsdrt< `ji g`vd iosheujtdi tgd penotoh`n
strdjbtg ef Xp`oj ay rd`iojb tgd penotoh`n sobjs ef tgd tomds `s tgdy
wdrd wrottdj adtwddj tgd nojds ef tgd Yrd`ty ef Rdstpg`no`*
"Ygd Xp`josg Dmpord". gd mobgt g`vd prejeujhdi. "os `nrd`iy `
h`rh`ss reuji wgohg tgd vunturds `rd b`tgdrojb* Fr`jhd wonn
suhhddi te tgd monot`ry gdbdmejy ef Xp`oj oj Durepd. Genn`ji `ji
Djbn`ji wonn suhhddi te gdr j`v`n `ji hemmdrho`n suprdm`hy ej
j F
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 377/455
66 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tgd sd`s* Ygd hempdtotoej fer Jertg @mdroh` nods jew adtwddj
tgdsd tgrdd heujtrods* Ndt us dstom`td tgdor rdspdhtovd hg`jhds oj
tgd ieuand nobgt ef tgdor bdjdr`n pesotoejs oj tgd Rerni `ji ef tgdor
neh`ngeniojbs oj @mdroh`* Ej ` sgert vodw. Genn`ji"s hg`jhds mobgt`ppd`r te ad tgd mest premosojb* Xgd os mostrdss ef tgd sd`s 'Djb-
n`ji adojb je m`thg fer gdr ej tgos dndmdjt. `ji Fr`jhd jet
sdroeusny hempdtojb/ <`ji oj @mdroh` sgd genis ` spndjioi w`tdr-
b`td epdjojb ojte tgd ojtdroer; tgd v`nndy ef tgd Guisej* Ej `
nejbdr vodw. gewdvdr. Fr`jhd sddms merd noldny te ad tgd wojjdr<
fer tgd Frdjhg Xt* N`wrdjhd effdrs stonn adttdr md`js ef `hhdss te
tgd ojtdroer ef Jertg @mdroh` tg`j tgd Iuthg Guisej. wgond ot os
oj tgd
pewdreftgd Frdjhg te ommeaonozd `ji dxg`ust tgd Iuthg
ayarojbojb te ad`r `b`ojst tgdmtgd evdrwgdnmojb monot`ry supdroeroty
ef Fr`jhd ej tgd Hejtojdjt ef Durepd* @nn tgd s`md. `s adtwddj
Frdjhg `ji Iuthg prespdhts. O gdsot`td" 'wd gd`r gom s`yojb/ "te
idhoid* Ygd ejd prepgdhy tg`t O m`ld wotg hejfoidjhd os tg`t tgd
Djbnosg `rd jet oj tgd rujjojb* Sessoany tgd merd seutgdrny ef tgd
Djbnosg henejods. wotg tgdor rdn`tovdny bdjo`n seon `ji hnom`td. wonn
m`j`bd te survovd tgeubg `t adst tgdy wonn foji tgdmsdnvds
gdmmdi oj adtwddj tgd Iuthg `nejb tgd Guisej oj tgd jertg `ji
tgd Xp`jo`ris oj Fneroi` ej tgd seutg `ji tgd Iuthg er tgd Frdjhg.
wgohgdvdr ot m`y ad tg`t huts eff tgdor gojtdrn`ji ej tgd wdst ay
sdhurojb tgd hejtren ef tgd Mossossoppo* Ejd tgojb. gewdvdr. os
hdrt`oj* Ygd nottnd breup ef sdttndmdjts oj tgd and`l `ji a`rrdj
heujtry wgohg tgd henejosts g`vd hgrostdjdi Jdw Djbn`ji os
aeuji te ios`ppd`r* Ygdy `rd hut eff frem tgd etgdr Djbnosg
sdttndmdjts ay tgd Iuthg oj tgd Guisej V`nndy. wgond tgd Frdjhg
oj tgd Xt* N`wrdjhd V`nndy prdss tgdm hnesd ej tgd eppesotd fn`jl*
Ygd idstojods ef tgdsd Jdw Djbn`jidrs. `t `jy r`td. `rd jet oj
ieuat!"
Ndt us jew suppesd tg`t eur gypetgdtoh`n easdrvdr novds te sdd
tgd turj ef tgd hdjtury* Ay tgd yd`r 0230 gd wonn ad hejbr`tun`tojb
gomsdnf ej gos ioshdrjmdjt. fofty yd`rs d`rnodr. oj r`tojb Frdjhg
prespdhts gobgdr tg`j Iuthg< fer oj tgd heursd ef tgdsd n`st fofty
yd`rs tgd Xt* N`wrdjhd g`s v`jquosgdi tgd Guisej* Ygd Frdjhg
dxpnerdrs g`vd pusgdi up tgd Xt* N`wrdjhd ej te tgd Brd`t N`lds.
`ji evdr tgd pert`bd ojte tgd A`soj ef tgd Mossossoppo. `ji iewjtgdsd Rdstdrj R`tdrs te tgd idnt` ef tgd brd`t rovdr. wgdrd tgdy g`vd
dst`anosgdi tgd jdw Frdjhg henejy ef Neuoso`j` te m`thg tgd enidr
Frdjhg henejy ef H`j`i` `t tgd etgdr dji ef tgd tr`js-hejtojdjt`n
w`tdrw`y* @s fer tgd Iuthg. eur easdrvdr must `imot tg`t gd g`i
r`tdi tgdor prespdhts muhg tee gobg* Ygdy mobgt g`vd m`idtgdmsdnvds m`stdrs ef tgd Brd`t N`lds adferd tgd Frdjhg `rrovdi
tgdrd* Ojiddi. fer tgd ehd`j-beojb vdssdns ef tgd hdjtury. tgd gd`i
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 378/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 62
ef j`vob`toej w`s r`tgdr ndss iost`jt up tgd Guisej tg`j ot w`s
up tgd Xt* N`wrdjhd frem tgd sgerds ef N`ld Ejt`roe* _dt. f`r
frem tg`t. tgd Iuthg g`vd t`mdny `nnewdi tgd Guisej V`nndy otsdnf
te ad t`ldj frem tgdm ay tgdor wd`ldr m`rotomd rov`ns tgd Djbnosg*Rdnn. tgd Iuthg `rd eut ef tgd rujjojb jew oj Jertg @mdroh`. `ji
tgd Frdjhg `ji tgd Djbnosg `rd ndft tgdrd tdtd ` tXtd<aut tgd Djbnosg
h`j g`riny ad rdb`ridi `s sdroeus hempdtoters* Ygd dvdjts ef tgd
n`st g`nf-hdjtury `ssurdiny ie jet h`nn fer `jy rdvosoej ef ferdh`sts
ej tgos gd`i jetwotgst`jiojb tgd ujneeldi-fer suhhdss wgohg tgd
Djbnosg g`vd b`ojdi oj tgd Guisej V`nndy* Hdrt`ojny tgd Jdw
Djbn`jidrs `rd m`lojb tgd mest ef tgos wojif`nn* @nrd`iy tgdy `rd
henejozojbtgd
a`hl-heujtryef tgd Iuthg
prevojhd`ji `rd
nojlojbJdw Djbn`ji up wotg tgd rdst ef tgd Djbnosg sdttndmdjts ej tgd
@tn`jtoh he`st* Sessoany tgd Jdw Djbn`jidrs g`vd addj s`vdi
frem dxtojhtoej aut tgos ejny te sg`rd tgd meidst prespdhts ef
tgdor seutgdrj lojsfenl* Fer tgd Djbnosg fd`t ef hejqudrojb tgd
Guisej V`nndy frem tgd f`hond Iuthg g`s addj uttdrny surp`ssdi
ay tgd somunt`jdeus Frdjhg fd`t ef hejqudrojb frem tgd fermoi`and
vorboj wonidrjdss tgd wgend dxtdjt ef tgd m`bjofohdjt ojn`ji w`tdr-
w`y adtwddj Pudadh `ji Jdw Ernd`js* Rgond tgd Djbnosg henejods
g`vd addj hejsenoi`tdi. tgd Frdjhg henejods g`vd dffdhtovdny
gdmmdi tgdm oj* Ygd futurd ef tgd Hejtojdjt os idhoidi! Ygd
vohters `rd tgd Frdjhg!
Xg`nn wd djiew eur easdrvdr wotg supdrgum`j ndjbtg ef nofd. oj
eridr tg`t gd m`y rdvodw tgd sotu`toej ejhd merd oj tgd yd`r 0738 5
Of wd ie prdsdrvd gom `novd tonn tgdj. gd wonn ad ferhdi te hejfdss
tg`t gos wots g`vd jet addj wertgy ef gos nejbdvoty* Ay tgd dji ef
0738. tgd Frdjhg fn`b g`s `htu`nny ios`ppd`rdi eff tgd penotoh`n m`pef Jertg @mdroh` `ntebdtgdr* Fer ferty yd`rs p`st. H`j`i` g`s
addj ` pessdssoej ef tgd Arotosg Hrewj. wgond Neuoso`j`. `ftdr
adojb hdidi ay Fr`jhd te Xp`oj `ji rdtrehdidi `b`oj. g`s kust addj
seni ej tgd setg Idhdmadr. 0738. ay J`pendej te tgd Tjotdi
Xt`tds tgd jdw Brd`t Sewdr wgohg g`s dmdrbdi eut ef tgd tgor-
tddj Djbnosg henejods ay ` mest dxtr`erioj`ry mdt`merpgesos*
"Ygd Tjotdi Xt`tds ef @mdroh`!" Rge weuni g`vd prepgdsodi
ot5 _dt tgd `maotoeus totnd os kustofodi ay tgd `hhempnosgdi f`hts*
Oj tgos yd`r 0738. tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds g`vd tgd hejtojdjt oj tgdor
pehldts. `ji tgd shepd fer prepgdhy os rdiuhdi* Ot ejny rdm`ojs te
ferdh`st wgohg sdhtoej ef tgdsd Tjotdi Xt`tds os beojb te pehldt tgd
n`rbdr sg`rd ef tgos v`st dst`td tgd ard`itg ef ` hejtojdjt tg`t
g`s hemd ojte tgdor keojt pessdssoej*@ji surdny tgos tomd tgdrd
h`j ad je most`ld 5 Ygd Xeutgdrj Xt`tds `rd tgd m`jofdst m`stdrs
ef tgd Tjoej `ji rdsoiu`ry ndb`tdds oj Jertg @mdroh` ef Brd`t
Arot`oj `ji Fr`jhd* Neel gew tgd Xeutgdrjdrs `rd nd`iojb oj tgos
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 379/455
67 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
foj`n reuji ef tgd hempdtotoej oj tgos ojtdr-@mdroh`j r`hd fer tgd
Rojjojb ef tgd Rdst* Ot os tgd a`hlweeismdj ef Vorbojo` wge
g`vd feujidi Ldjtuhly tgd forst jdw st`td te ad dst`anosgdi wdst
ef tgesd meujt`ojs wgohg g`vd se nejb hejspordi wotg tgd Frdjhgte lddp tgd Djbnosg-spd`lojb sdttndrs ej tgd @tn`jtoh he`st frem
pdjdtr`tojb ojte tgd ojtdroer* @ji t`ld jetd ef tgd ldy-pesotoej
wgohg Ldjtuhly ehhupods. dxtdjiojb robgt iewj tgd ndft a`jl ef
tgd Egoe te tgd hejfnudjhd ef tgd Mossossoppo"s projhop`n troaut`ry
wotg tgd Mossossoppo gomsdnf* Ygd Rdst os oj tgd Xeutgdrjdrs"
br`sp. `ji m`rl gew `nn tgojbs werl tebdtgdr fer tgdor beei* Ygd
st`tdsm`jsgop ef `j Djbnosg Hg`tg`m `ji ` Sdjjsynv`jo`j Fr`jlnoj
`ji ` Hersoh`jAuej`p`rtd
g`s djiewditgdm wotg `j ommd`sur`and
suppny ef n`ji< `ji. `s f`st `s tgdy h`j put tgos jdw n`ji ujidr
tgd ged. tgd jdw-f`jbndi monns ef iost`jt N`jh`sgord `rd effdrojb
tgdm `j dvdr-dxp`jiojb m`rldt fer tgd hettej-hrep wgohg tgd seon
`ji hnom`td ef tgd Xeutg dj`and tgdm te r`osd* Ygd Jdbre pre-
voids tgd n`aeur `ji tgd Mossossoppo tgd md`js ef tr`jspertojb tgd
preiuhd te tgd qu`ys ef Jdw Ernd`js. wgdrd tgd sgops frem Novdr-
peen `rd w`otojb te ad`r ot `w`y* Dvdj tgd Jdw Djbn`jidr os `
usdfun `uxono`ry. `s tgd Xeutgdrjdr supdrhonoeusny peojts eut*
+Eur _`jldd heusoj". tgd Xeutgdrjdr easdrvds oj 0732. "g`s kust
ojvdjtdi ` std`m-ae`t wgohg wonn j`vob`td eur Mossossoppo up-strd`m
<`ji gd g`s m`id ` pr`htoh`n suhhdss ef ` m`hgojd fer h`riojb
`ji hnd`jojb eur hettej-aenns* Ygesd ujnev`and. ujfertuj`td
fdnnew-hotozdjs ef eurs oj tg`t eut-ef-tgd-w`y herjdr. iewj d`st!
Ygdor _`jldd jetoejs `rd merd prefot`and te us tg`j tgdy `rd te
tgd ojbdjoeus ojvdjters! Fer wg`t `rd Jdw Djbn`ji"s prespdhts5
Gdr prespdhts `rd je adttdr oj tgos yd`r 0732 tg`j tgdy wdrd `
hdjtury sojhd* Ye-i`y. wgdj tgd woid Rdst g`s addj tgrewj epdjte Xeutgdrj djtdrprosd `t n`st. ot stonn rdm`ojs hnesdi te tgd Jdw
Djbn`jidr* Jdw Djbn`ji os stonn a`rrdi oj ej tgd n`jiw`ri soid aytgd a`rrodr ef H`j`i`. wgohg g`s jet hd`sdi te ad ` ferdobj heujtryoj p`ssojb frem tgd Frdjhg te tgd Arotosg Hrewj* Xe tgdrd eur
peer rdn`toej stonn sots oj gos eut-ef-tgd-w`y herjdr. heepdi up ej
tgd a`i n`jis ef Yewj Gonn< `ji tgdrd. prdsum`any. gd wonn beej sottojb tonn Ieemsi`y! Xdidt. `dtdrjumqud sdidaot!
"+
Of eur ujnuhly prepgdt t`lds Xeutgdrj prespdhts ej tgd merrewef tgd Neuoso`j` Surhg`sd `t tgd Xeutgdrjdr"s ewj v`nu`toej. gd
must ojiddi ad oj gos iet`bd <fer oj tgd n`st reuji ef tgd twe-
hdjturods-nejb hejtdst fer tgd m`stdry ef tgd Jertg @mdroh`j
Hejtojdjt. tgd Xeutgdrjdr os idstojdi te mddt ` swoftdr `ji merd
hrusgojb idfd`t tg`j tgesd tg`t g`vd addj mdt gdrdteferd ay tgd
Xp`jo`ri `ji tgd Iuthgm`j `ji tgd Frdjhgm`j* Ye wotjdss gos
+Vorbon; @djdti. Aeel VO. 0* 602*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 380/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 6?
ioshemfoturd. wd sg`nn jet g`vd te w`ot `s nejb `s ` hdjtury* Rdsg`nn sdd tgd rdn`tovd pesotoejs ef Xeutg `ji Jertg rdvdrsdi oj ndss
tg`j ` nofdtomd*
Oj tgd yd`r 0764. tgd sotu`toej os `nrd`iy tr`jsfermdi. eut ef `nn
rdhebjotoej. frem wg`t ot w`s oj 0732* Oj tgd Rojjojb eftgd Rdst.tgd Xeutgdrj poejddr g`i addj eutstroppdi `ji eutfn`jldi ay gos
Jertgdrj rov`n* @ftdr `nmest wojjojb gos w`y te tgd Brd`t N`lds
tgreubg Ojio`j` `ji `ftdr bdttojb tgd adst ef tgd a`rb`oj oj
Mosseuro. tgd Xeutgdrjdr g`s addj idhosovdny idfd`tdi oj L`js`s.`ji gd g`s jdvdr rd`hgdi tgd S`hofoh* Ygd idshdji`jts ef tgd mdjwge m`stdrdi tgd ioffohuntods ef Yewj Gonn. Hejjdhtohut. g`vd jewadhemd m`stdrs ef tgd S`hofoh he`st
`nejbtgd wgend frejt frem
Xd`ttnd te Nes @jbdnds* Jer g`s tgd Xeutgdrjdr"s hemm`ji ef tgd
Mossossoppo muhg `v`ondi gom* Gd g`i heujtdi ej tgd jdtwerl ef
tgd Rdstdrj R`tdrs te ir`w tgd wgend ef tgd Rdst ojte ` Xeutgdrj
systdm ef dhejemoh `jipenotoh`n rdn`toejs< `ji wgdj tgd _`jldd
prdsdjtdi gom wotg std`m-ae`ts te pny ej tgd Rdstdrj R`tdrs. gd
om`bojdi tg`t tgd _`jldd g`i idnovdrdi tgd Rdst ojte gos g`jis*
Aut"
_`jldd jetoejs" g`vd jet hd`sdi* Ygd ojvdjter ef tgd std`mdr
g`s bejd ej te ojvdjt tgd nehemetovd< `ji tgd nehemetovd g`s
t`ldj `w`y merd frem tgd Xeutgdrjdr tg`j tgd std`mdr dvdr b`vd
gom<fer tgd petdjto`n fujhtoej ef tgd Guisej V`nndy oj tgd gum`j
bdebr`pgy ef Jertg @mdroh` `s tgd m`oj b`tdw`y frem tgd @tn`jtoh
te tgd Rdst ` petdjto`noty wgohg tgd Iuthg g`i f`ondi te turj te
`hheujt oj hempdtotoej wotg tgd Frdjhg g`s addj `htu`nozdi `t
n`st oj tgd r`onw`y `bd* Ygd r`onw`y-tr`ffoh wgohg jew p`ssds uptgd v`nndy ef tgd Guisej `ji tgd v`nndy ef tgd Meg`wl `ji tgdj
`nejb tgd n`ld-soid te nojl Jdw _erl wotg Hgoh`be g`s supdrsdidi
tgd rovdr-tr`ffoh ej tgd Mossossoppo adtwddj Jdw Ernd`js `ji Xt*
Neuos* Ygdrdwotg. tgd ojtdrj`n nojds ef hemmujoh`toej ef tgd
Jertg @mdroh`j Hejtojdjt g`vd addj turjdi `t robgt `jbnds frem
seutg `ji jertg te d`st `ji wdst<`ji tgd Jertg-Rdst g`s addj
idt`hgdi frem tgd Xeutg. te ad wdnidi ej te tgd Jertg-D`st oj
ojtdrdst `ji oj sdjtomdjt* Ojiddi. tgd D`stdrjdr. wge ejhd m`id
tgd Xeutg-Rdst ` prdsdjt ef tgd rovdr-std`mdr. g`s jew wej tgd
gd`rt ef tgd Jertg-Rdst wotg ` ieuand boft; gd g`s hemd te tgd
Jertg-Rdstdrj f`rmdr wotg tgd nehemetovd oj ejd g`ji `ji wotgtgd rd`pdr-`ji-aojidr oj tgd etgdr. `ji se g`s prevoidi gom wotg
senutoejs fer aetg tgd preandms wotg wgohg tgd Rdst os hejfrejtdi*
Oj eridr te idvdnep ots petdjto`n dhejemoh h`p`hotods.tgd wgend
Rdst g`s jddi ef twe tgojbs ; tr`jspert `ji n`aeur <aut tgd Xeutg-
wdstdrj pn`jtdr adnodvojbtg`t gos n`aeur-preandmg`s addj senvdi
fer dvdr ay tgd ojstotutoej ef jdbre sn`vdry g`s seubgt ` senutoej
fer gos tr`jspert-preandm. `ji fer tgos ejny. frem tgd _`jldd"s
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 381/455
23 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
"mdhg`joh`n ojbdjuoty* Ygd Jertg-Rdstdrj f`rmdr os oj ` ioffdrdjt
h`sd* Gd iospesds ef je sdrvond m`j-pewdr. `ji gos frdd-n`aeur
ferhd os rdhruotdi ay tgd h`su`n prehdss ef ommobr`toej frem Durepd
`nn tee snewny te tonn gos f`st-dxp`jiojb fodnis* Xe gdfojis
tgd
`brohuntur`n m`hgojdry wgohg os turjdi eut ay tgd D`stdrj f`hterods
`s brd`t ` beisdji `s tgd D`stdrj r`onw`ys* Ay tgdsd twe "_`jldd
jetoejs". tebdtgdr. tgd `nndbo`jhd ef tgd Jertg-Rdst g`s addj
idhoidi<`ji tgus tgd Hovon R`r g`s addj nest ay tgd Xeutg adferd
ot g`s addj feubgt* Oj t`lojb up `rms oj tgd gepd ef rdirdssojb
gdr dhejemoh rdvdrsds ay ` monot`ry heujtdrstreld. tgd Xeutg g`s
mdrdny prdhopot`tdi `ji hejsumm`tdi ` iiaihnd tg`t w`s `nrd`iy
ojdvot`and*
Ygos untom`td vohtery ef tgd Jdw Djbn`jidrs. oj ` hempdtotoej
fer tgd m`stdry ef Jertg @mdroh` oj wgohg tgdor Xp`josg. Iuthg.
Frdjhg. `ji Xeutgdrj hempdtoters wdrd suhhdssovdny ioshemfotdi. os
onnumoj`tojb fer tgd stuiy ef tgd qudstoej wotg wgohg wd `rd hej-
hdrjdi `t tgd memdjt; tgd qudstoej ef tgd rdn`tovd stomun`tojb
dffdhts ef ioffdrdjt idbrdds ef ioffohunty oj tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt
efgum`j nofd* Fer. ujusu`nny ioffohunt tgeubg tgd Jdw Djbn`jidrs"
djvorejmdjt w`s. ot os m`jofdst tg`t tgd rov`n henejosts" djvorej-
mdjts wdrd jejd ef tgdm d`sy* Ye adboj wotg. `nn `nold g`i ujidr-
bejd tgd ojoto`n erid`n ef pnuhlojb up tgdor seho`n reets oj Durepd`ji hressojb tgd @tn`jtoh `ji strolojb frdsg reets oj tgd seon ef `
Jdw Rerni<0
`ji. wgdj tgdy g`i suhhddidi oj rd-dst`anosgojb
tgdmsdnvds. ot w`s jet ejny tgd Jdw Djbn`jidrs wge feuji
pdrm`jdjt ioffohuntods te hejtdji wotg oj tgdor jdw @mdroh`j
gemd* Ygd Frdjhg sdttndrs oj H`j`i` g`i te hejtdji wotg `j
`nmest `rhtoh heni< `ji tgd Frdjhg sdttndrs oj Neuoso`j` g`i te
ard`l oj ` brd`t rovdr* Ygd Mossossoppo w`s `s w`yw`ri oj hg`jbojbgos heursd. `ji `s idv`st`tojb oj gos ojuji`toejs. `s tgd _dnnew
Qovdr er tgd Jond er tgd Yobros< `ji tgd ndvods wotg wgohg tgd
Hrdends pretdhtdi tgdor g`ri-wej fodnis `ji vonn`bds hest je ndss
gum`j dffert te auoni `ji m`ojt`oj tg`j tgd d`rtgdj aunw`rls ef
tgd Dbypto`h `ji tgd Xumdroh `ji tgd Xojoh Hovonoz`toej* Oj f`ht.
tgd ioffohuntods prdsdjtdi ay tgd pgysoh`n djvorejmdjt oj H`j`i`
`ji oj Neuoso`j` wdrd ejny ndss fermoi`and tg`j tgesd wgohg tgd
Jdw Djbn`jidrs djheujtdrdi ej Yewj Gonn otsdnf* Ygus tgosJertg @mdroh`j onnustr`toej. `s f`r `s ot beds. tdnns oj f`veur ef tgd
prepesotoej tg`t tgd ioffohunty `ji tgd stomunus ef `j djvorejmdjt
`rd `pt te ojhrd`sd p`rop`ssu* Ot wonn tdnn tgd s`md t`nd of wd pusgot dvdj f`rtgdr*
H`j wd pusg ot f`rtgdr5 H`j wd vdjturd. oj 0?88. te prepgdsy
0 Ygd stomunus ef tr`jsm`rojd henejoz`toej `ji mobr`toej os dx`mojdi furtgdr ej
pp* 79-033. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 382/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 20
oj wgesd g`jis tgd m`stdry ef Jertg @mdroh` wonn nod ` hdjturygdjhd 5 H`j wd gepd te hemd `jy jd`rdr te tgd m`rl eursdnvds
tg`j eur om`boj`ry prepgdt oj 0643 `ji 0230 `ji 0738 5 H`j wd
ie merd tg`j rojb iewj tgd hurt`oj ej tgd prdsdjt shdjd. oj wgohgtgd effsprojb ef tgd Jdw Djbn`jidrs iemoj`tds tgd st`bd 5 Ioffo-
hunt tgeubg iovoj`toej m`y ad. tgdrd `rd `nrd`iy hdrt`oj sobjs tg`t
tgd ir`m` os jet ydt pn`ydi eut `ji tgd foj`n vohtery oj tgd strubbndjet ydt idhoidi* Ejd sm`nn sobj ejhd h`md te tgd jetohd ef tgd
`utger ef tgos Xtuiy*
@ fdw i`ys `ftdr tgd ehh`soej. mdjtoejdi `aevd.0 wgdj O p`ssdi
ay tgd idsdrtdi sotd efYewj Gonn. Hejjdhtohut. O feuji mysdnf wotg
`j geur te spdji adtwddj tr`ojs oj ejd ef tgd sm`nn
a`hl-heujtrym`juf`hturojb tewjs ef Jdw Djbn`ji. ej tgd M`ss`hgusdtts soid
ef tgd Hejjdhtohut-M`ss`hgusdtts st`td-nojd* Xojhd tgd Bdjdr`n
R`r ef 0?09-07. tgd ojiustro`n iostrohts efJdw Djbn`ji g`vd f`rdi
`s a`iny `s tgesd ef tgd metgdr heujtry* Ygdy g`vd f`nndj ej dvon
i`ys. `ji tgdy sgew ot oj tgdor `spdht* Oj tgos tewj. gewdvdr. ej
tgos i`y. tgd `tmespgdrd w`s jet `t `nn fernerj er nofdndss* Ygd tewjw`s oj fdtd. `ji tgd wgend pepun`toej w`s `are`i oj tgd strddts*
Ygrd`iojb my w`y tgreubg tgd hrewis O jetohdi tg`t ejd pdrsej
eut ef dvdry twe w`s wd`rojb ` spdho`n a`ibd. `ji O ojquordi wg`ttgd heneurs sobjofodi* O w`s teni tg`t tgdywdrd tgd heneurs eftgd neh`n
Frdjhg H`j`io`j hnua<`ji O `shdrt`ojdi tg`t my reubg omprdssoej
ef tgdor frdqudjhy oj tgd strddts w`s aerjd eut ay st`tostohs* Oj tg`t
yd`r 0?14. oj tg`t Jdw Djbn`ji m`juf`hturojb tewj. tgd Frdjhg
H`j`io`js wdrd ay f`r tgd strejbdst hejtojbdjt oj tgd neh`n n`aemv
ferhd* Ygd ojiobdjeus Jdw Djbn`jidrs g`i ndft tgdsd f`hterods. `s
tgdy g`i ndft tgd fodnis ef Yewj Gonn. te foji tgdor fertujds oj tgd
Rdst< aut tgd tewj. ujnold tgd vonn`bd. g`i jet addj idsdrtdi* @sf`st `s tgd ojiobdjeus pepun`toej g`i daadi eut. ` toid ef Frdjhg
H`j`io`j ommobr`jts g`i fneeidi oj* Hejiotoejs ef werl `ji nofd
wgohg g`i hd`sdi te ad `ttr`htovd te tgd idshdji`jts ef tgd Sonbrom
F`tgdrs sddmdi nuxuroeus te tgdsd Jerm`j pd`s`jts" hgonirdj frem
tgd sua-`rhtoh gojtdrn`ji ef Pudadh* Merdevdr. O w`s teni. tgd
Frdjhg H`j`io`j ommobr`jts wdrd sprd`iojb frem tgd tewjs ef
Jdw Djbn`ji ej te tgd n`ji. wgdrd. `s pd`s`jts. tgdy feuji tgdm-
sdnvdstruny
`t gemd* Ej tgdor
frub`n
st`ji`ri efnovojb.
@mdroh`j
r`tds ef ojiustro`n w`bds ndft tgdm wotg ` surpnus wgohg quohlny
meujtdi up te tgd purhg`sd-prohd ef ` idrdnoht Jdw Djbn`ji f`rm*
Ygd ommobr`jts wdrd `htu`nny rd-pepun`tojb tgd idsdrtdi heujtry-
soid* Sdrg`ps. ej my jdxt vosot. O sgeuni foji Yewj Gonn otsdnf je
nejbdr idsen`td* _dt of. ej tg`t feraoiiojb spet. tgd werls ef M`j
evdrh`md tgd wonidrjdss fer tgd sdheji tomd. ot heuni ad ferdsddj
0 Xdd pp* 04-06. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 383/455
21 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tg`t gostery weuni rdpd`t otsdnf wotg ` ioffdrdjhd* Ygd fodnis `ji
erhg`ris `ji dvdj tgd geusds mobgt wd`r `b`oj oj 0?43 tgd `spdht
wgohg tgdy g`i werj twe hdjturods adferd< aut tgos tomd tgd
aneei oj tgd vdojs ef tgd f`rmdrs weuni ad Frdjhg `ji jet Djbnosg .
`ji iovojd wersgop oj tgd `jtoqud weeidj hgurhg weuni ad hej-
iuhtdi je nejbdr ay ` Srdsaytdro`j mojostdr aut ay ` H`tgenoh
prodst!
Ygus ot sddms pessoand tg`t tgd hejtdst adtwddj tgd Frdjhg
H`j`io`j `ji tgd Jdw Djbn`jidr fer tgd m`stdry ef Jertg
@mdroh` m`y jet. `ftdr `nn. g`vd addj hejhnuidi `ji iospesdi ef
foj`nny ay tgd euthemd ef tgd Xdvdj _d`rs" R`r* Fer. wgdj tgd
Frdjhg fn`b w`s g`undi iewj. tgd Frdjhg pd`s`jt ioi jet ios`ppd`rwotg tgd dmandm ef tgd Frdjhg Bevdrjmdjt"s sevdrdobjty* Tjidr
tgd tutdn`bd ef tgd Qem`j H`tgenoh Hgurhg. tgos pd`s`jtry hej-
tojudi. ujiosturadi. te ad fruotfun `ji muntopny `ji rdpndjosg tgd
D`rtg< `ji jew oj tgd funnjdss ef tomd tgd Frdjhg H`j`io`j os
m`lojb ` heujtdr-effdjsovd ojte tgd gd`rt ef gos eni rov`n"s gemd-
n`ji* Gd os hejqudrojb Jdw Djbn`ji oj tgd pd`s`jt"s w`y aysnewdr aut surdr mdtgeis tg`j tgesd wgohg Bevdrjmdjts g`vd `t
tgdor
hemm`ji* Gdos
hejiuhtojbgos
epdr`toejswotg tgd
pneubg-sg`rd `ji jet wotg tgd sweri. `ji gd os `ssdrtojb gos ewjdrsgop aytgd pesotovd `ht ef henejozojb tgd heujtrysoid `ji jet ay tgd
h`rtebr`pgoh`n hejhdot ef p`ojtojb heneurs `ji ir`wojb nojds ej `
shr`p ef p`pdr* Md`jwgond. n`w `ji rdnoboej `ji djvorejmdjt `rd
hemaojojb te `ssost gom* Ygd djvorejmdjt ef ` g`rsg heujtrysoid
lddps gom dxpesdi te ` stomunus wgohg je nejbdr ojvober`tds gos
rov`n oj tgd seftdr `tmespgdrd ef tgd iost`jt Rdstdrj hotods* Gos
rdnoboej feraois gom te rdstroht tgd sozd ef gos f`mony ay hejtr`-
hdptovd mdtgeis ef aortg-hejtren* @ji Tjotdi Xt`tds ndbosn`toej.
wgohg g`s rdstrohtdi ommobr`toej frem heujtrods evdrsd`s aut jet
frem heujtrods ej tgd @mdroh`j Hejtojdjt. g`s ndft tgd Frdjhg
H`j`io`j ommobr`jt oj ` provondbdi pesotoej wgohg os sg`rdi wotg
gom ay jejd aut tgd Mdxoh`j* 0
Sdrg`ps tgd prdsdjt `ht oj tgd
ir`m` ef Jertg @mdroh`j gostery m`y dji. `ftdr ` hdjtury ef
pd`hdfun pdjdtr`toej. oj ` troumpg`n mddtojb adtwddj tgd twe
rdsurbdjt N`toj pd`s`jtrods oj tgd jdobgaeurgeei ef tgd Fdidr`n
H`pot`n ef tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds! Os tgos tgd idjeudmdjt tg`t eur
brd`t-br`jihgonirdj `rd idstojdi te wotjdss oj @*I* 1388 5 Ygdrd
0 YgosQdstrohtoej
ef ommobr`toej ojte tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds g`s addj dffdhtdi ay tgd
Ommobr`toej 'Qdstrohtoej/ @hts ef 0?10 `ji 0?19* Ot sgeuni ad jetdi tg`t tgd woid ieerndft epdj fer ommobr`toej ojte tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds `hress tgd n`ji-frejtodrs os ejny epdjfer j`tovd-aerj ojg`aot`jts ef tgd `ikeojojb @mdroh`j heujtrods* @ Durepd`j er @so`toh
wge `ttdmpts te djtdr tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds tgreubg H`j`i` er Mdxohe. wotgeut g`vojbsdhurdi ` pn`hd oj tgd `jju`n quet` ef ommobr`jts `ssobjdi te gos ewj heujtry ef eroboj.fojis gomsdnf dxhnuidi* Oj tgos m`ttdr. tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds Aurd`u ef Ommobr`toej g`s
`ieptdi tgd Arotosg @imor`nty"s iehtrojd ef "hejtojueus vey`bd+*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 384/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF G@QI HETJYQODX 28
g`vd addj rdvdrs`ns ef fertujd dvdry aot `s str`jbd `s tgos oj Jertg@mdroh`j gostery adferd*
OOO* YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJIYgd Ydstomejy ef Sgonesepgy. Mytgeneby. `ji Qdnoboej
Xe muhg fer hemp`rosejs adtwddj tgd rdspdhtovd stomun`tojbdffdhts ef pgysoh`n djvorejmdjts wgohg prdsdjt ioffdrdjt idbrdds ef
ioffohunty* Ndt us jew `ppre`hg tgd s`md qudstoej frem ` ioffdrdjt
`jbnd ay hemp`rojb tgd rdspdhtovd stomun`tojb dffdhts ef eni breuji`ji jdw breuji. `p`rt frem tgd ojtrojsoh j`turd ef tgd tdrr`oj*
Ieds tgd dffert efard`lojb
jdwbreuji
`ht `s ` stomunus oj otsdnf 5
Ygd qudstoej os `jswdrdi oj tgd `fform`tovd ay tgd hrotoh`n dmporo-hosm ef `j dobgtddjtg-hdjtury Rdstdrj pgonesepgdr `s wdnn `s aytgd
woidr spejt`jdeus gum`j dxpdrodjhd wgohg g`s feuji ` humun`-
tovd dxprdssoej oj Mytgeneby* I`voi Gumd hejhnuids gos dss`y
Ef tgd Qosd `ji Srebrdss ef tgd @rts `ji Xhodjhds wotg tgd easdrv`-
toej tg`t "tgd `rts `ji shodjhds. nold semd pn`jts. rdquord ` frdsg
seon< `ji. gewdvdr rohg tgd n`ji m`y ad. `ji gewdvdr yeu m`yrdhruot ot ay `rt er h`rd. ot wonn jdvdr. wgdj ejhd dxg`ustdi. pre-iuhd `jytgojb tg`t os pdrfdht er fojosgdi oj tgd loji"* Ygd s`md
`fform`tovd `jswdr os hejvdydi oj tgd mytg ef tgd Dxpunsoej frem
Didj `ji oj tgd mytg ef tgd Dxeius frem Dbypt* Oj tgdor rdmev`n
eut ef tgd m`boh b`ridj ojte tgd werl`i`y werni. @i`m `ji Dvd
tr`jshdji tgd feei-b`tgdrojb dhejemy ef Sromotovd M`jloji `ji
bovd aortg te tgd f`tgdrs ef `j `brohuntur`n `ji ` p`ster`n hovonoz`-
toej*0 Oj tgdor dxeius frem Dbypt. tgd Hgonirdj ef Osr`dn tgeubg
tgdy g`jldr oj tgd wonidrjdss `ftdr tgd fndsg pets ef tgd geusd ef
aeji`bd1 bovd aortg te ` bdjdr`toej wgohg gdnps te n`y tgd
feuji`toejs ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej oj t`lojb pessdssoej ef
tgd Sremosdi N`ji*8 Rgdj wd turj frem mytgs te rdheris. wd
foji tgdsd ojtuotoejs hejformdi ay tgd dvoidjhd ef dmporoh`n
easdrv`toej*
Oj tgd gosterods ef rdnoboejs. wd foji tg`t te tgd hejstdrj`toej ef
tgesd wge `sl tgd sherjfun qudstoej; "H`j `jy beei tgojb hemd
eut ef J`z`rdtg 5"9 tgd Mdsso`g ef Kdwry ieds hemd eut ef tg`t
eashurd vonn`bd oj "B`nondd ef tgd Bdjtonds";4
`j eutnyojb podhd efjdw breuji wgohg g`i addj h`pturdi fer Kdwry ay tgd M`hh`-
adds r`tgdr ndss tg`j ` hdjtury adferd tgd i`td ef Kdsus"s aortg*6
@ji wgdj tgd ojiemot`and brewtg ef tgos B`non`d`j br`oj ef
o Xdd OO* H 'oo/ 'a/ O. ven o. p* 1?3. `aevd* 1 Xdd pp* 19-4. `aevd*
8 Xdd tgd p`ss`bd quetdi oj OO* A. ven* o. p 0?7. `aevd*
+ Kegj 0*96* Hemp`rdKegj vj* 90 `ji 41. `ji M`tt ov* 09-0 6. wgohg os ` rdmojoshdjhd
ef Os`o`g ox* 0-1*
s M`tt* ov* 04*6Qdbj`jtd @ndx`jir` K`jj`de. 038-26 A*H*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 385/455
29 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
must`ri-sddi turjs tgd hejstdrj`toej ef Ertgeiex Kdwry ojte
`htovd gestonoty. `ji tgos jet ejny oj Kui`d` otsdnf aut `mejb tgd
Kdwosg io`spero. tgdj tgd prep`b`ters ef tgd jdw f`otg idnoadr`tdnyh
turj te tgd Bdjtonds"
0
`ji prehddi te hejqudr jdw wernis fer
Hgrosto`joty ej breuji wgohg g`i n`oj wgenny adyeji tgd r`jbd ef
tgd strejb robgt `rm ef `j @ndx`jidr K`jj`dus* Oj tgd gostery ef
Auiigosm ot os tgd s`md stery. fer tgd idhosovd vohterods ef tgos
Ojiod f`otg `rd jet wej ej tgd eni breuji ef tgd Ojiod Rerni* Ygd
Goj`y`j` forst fojis `j epdj re`i oj Hdynej. wgohg w`s ` henejo`n
`jjdx ef tgd Ojiod Hovonoz`toej* @ji tgd M`g`y`j` st`rts ots
nejb `ji reuji`aeut keurjdy tew`ris ots futurd iem`oj oj tgd
F`r D`st
ay h`pturojbtgd
Xyro`hozdi
`ji Gdnndjozdi Ojiod
prevojhdef tgd S`jk`a* Ot os ej tgd jdw breuji ef tgdsd `nodj wernis tg`t tgd
gobgdst dxprdssoejs ef tgd Ojiod `ji tgd Xyro`h rdnoboeus bdjous
dvdjtu`nny ad`r tgdor fruot oj wotjdss te tgd trutg tg`t "` prepgdt
os jet wotgeut gejeur s`vd oj gos ewj heujtry `ji oj gos ewj
geusd"*1
Ygd Ydstomejy ef tgd "Qdn`tdi" Hovonoz`toejs
@ hejvdjodjt dmporoh`n tdst ef tgos seho`n "n`w" os effdrdi ay tgesd
hovonoz`toejs ef tgd "rdn`tdi" hn`ss tg`t g`vd `rosdj p`rtny ej breuji
`nrd`iy ehhupodi ay tgd rdspdhtovd `jtdhdidjt hovonoz`toej `ji
p`rtny ej breuji wgohg tgd "rdn`tdi" hovonoz`toej g`s t`ldj evdr
dotgdr frem promotovd sehodtods er frem etgdr hovonoz`toejs ej ots
ewj `hheujt. wotgeut tgd `jtdhdidjt hovonoz`toej g`vojb gdrd prd-
hdidi ot `ji prdp`rdi tgd w`y* Rd h`j tdst tgd rdspdhtovd stomu-
n`tojb dffdhts ef eni breuji `ji jdw breuji ay survdyojb tgd
h`rddr ef `jy ejd ef tgdsd "rdn`tdi" hovonoz`toejs. m`rlojb tgd peojt
er peojts wotgoj ots iem`oj `t wgohg ots `hgodvdmdjts oj `jy nojd
ef seho`n `htovoty g`vd addj mest sobj`n. `ji tgdj easdrvojb
wgdtgdr tgd breuji ej wgohg suhg peojts `rd neh`tdi os jdw
breuji er eni*
Ndt us adboj wotg tgd dxtrdmd h`sd ef tgd A`aynejoh Hovonoz`toej.
wgesd eroboj`n gemd g`s addj feuji te ad wgenny heojhoidjt wotg
tg`t ef tgd "`pp`rdjtdi" hovonoz`toej ; tgd Xumdroh* 8 Oj wgohg ef ots
tgrdd feho A`aynejo`. Dn`m. @ssyro`9 ioi tgd A`aynejoh Hovonoz`-
toej mest iostojbuosg otsdnf5 Tjieuatdiny oj @ssyro`* Rgdtgdrwd kuibd ay prewdss oj `rms er ay hejstruhtovd `aonoty oj penotohs
er ay hrd`tovd bdjous oj `rt. wd must prejeujhd tg`t tgd A`aynejohHovonoz`toej rd`hgdi ` gobgdr ndvdn oj @ssyro` tg`j oj dotgdr ef tgd
etgdr twe A`aynejoh heujtrods* @ji w`s @ssyro` eni breuji er
0@htp xoj* 96*
1 M`ttgdw xooo* 42* Hemp`rd M`rl vo* 9< Nuld ov* 19< Kegj ov* 99*8 Xdd tgd t`and `ji tgd feetjetd oj ven o. p* 081. `aevd*9 Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* 006-02. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 386/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 24
jdw 5 Ot turjs eut. ej furtgdr dx`moj`toej. tg`t @ssyro` w`s tgd
ejd pertoej ef tgd eroboj`n gemd ef tgd `jtdhdidjt Xumdroh Hovono-
z`toej wgohg pessoany mobgt ad rdb`ridi `s jdw breuji `t `jy
r`td ay hemp`rosej wotg Xumdr `ji @ll`i `ji Dn`m< fer wgdj wd
pread tgd neh`n gostery ef @ssyro` `s iddp `s tgd prdsdjt st`td ef eur
`rhg`deneboh`n ljewndibd `nnews us te pdjdtr`td. wd foji semd
rd`sej fer suppesojb tg`t @ssyro` w`s jet ejd ef tgd eroboj`n hem-
mujotods ojte wgohg tgd Xumdroh Xehodty `rtohun`tdi otsdnf `ftdr ots
aortg. aut w`s oj semd sdjsd ` henejy `nadot ` henejy tg`t w`s
`nmest hedv`n wotg tgd metgdr heujtry* Sdrg`ps ot os jet `ntebdtgdr
f`jt`stoh te surmosd tg`t tgd stomunus idrovdi frem tgos ard`lojb ef
jdwbreuji
oj
@ssyro``t semd
d`rny st`bdoj tgd
brewtgef tgd
Xumdroh Hovonoz`toej m`y `hheujt oj p`rt fer tgd spdho`n vobeur
wgohg w`s `ftdrw`ris iospn`ydi ay tgd "`ffono`tdi" A`aynejoh Hovono-
z`toej ej tgos @ssyro`j breuji*0
Yurjojb jdxt te tgd Gojiu Hovonoz`toej. ndt us m`rl tgd neh`n
seurhds ef tgd jdw hrd`tovd dndmdjts oj Gojiu nofd p`rtohun`rny oj
rdnoboej. wgohg g`s `nw`ys addj tgd hdjtr`n `ji suprdmd `htovoty ef
tgd Gojiu Xehodty* Rd foji tgdsd seurhds oj tgd Xeutg* Ot w`s
gdrd tg`t `nn tgd iostojhtovd fd`turds ef Gojiuosm teel sg`pd ;1 tgd
hunt ef Beis rdprdsdjtdi ay m`tdro`n eakdhts er om`bds `ji geusdi
oj tdmpnds <tgd dmetoej`n pdrsej`n rdn`toej adtwddj tgd wersgoppdr
`ji tgd p`rtohun`r Bei te wgesd wersgop gd g`s idvetdi gomsdnf<
tgd mdt`pgysoh`n suanom`toej ef om`bd-wersgop `ji dmetoej`nosm
oj `j ojtdnndhtu`nny sepgostoh`tdi tgdeneby 'X`jl`r`. tgd f`tgdr ef
Gojiu Ygdeneby. w`s aerj. horh` @*I* 277. oj Xeutgdrj M`n`a`r/*8
@nn tgdsd fd`turds ef Gojiuosm ad`r ` Xeutgdrj st`mp* @ji w`s
tgd Xeutg efOjio` eni breuji erjdw 5 Ot w`sjdw breuji. oj`smuhg
`s ot g`i jet addj ojherper`tdi ojte tgd iem`oj ef tgd "`pp`rdjtdi"
Ojiod Hovonoz`toej ujton tgd tomd ef tgd M`ury` Dmpord 'horh`
818-074 A*H*/.9 wgdj tgd Ojiod Xehodty. `ftdr g`vojb forst areldj
iewj `ji tgdj p`ssdi tgreubg ` Yomd ef Yreuands. `t ndjbtg
djtdrdi upej tg`t `iv`jhdi st`bd oj tgd iosojtdbr`toej ef ` hovonoz`-
toej wgohg wd g`vd nd`rjt te rdhebjozd `s ` "ujovdrs`n st`td"*
Ndt us neel jew `t tgd twe hovonoz`toejs tg`t `rd "`ffono`tdi+ te tgd
Xyro`h. j`mdny tgd @r`aoh `ji tgd Or`joh*4
Rgdrd. iurojb tgd sgert nofd ef tgd @r`aoh Xehodty. ioi ots r`tgdrfddand punsd ad`t nd`st fddany5 @ssurdiny oj Dbypt. wgdrd ` bgest
ef tgdh
@aa`soi H`nopg`td '` bgest. tg`t os te s`y. eftgd "rdojtdbr`tdi"
Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td/ w`s dveldi oj tgd tgortddjtg hdjtury ef tgd
+ Fer `jetgdr dxpn`j`toej ef @ssyro`"s rosd `s ` rd`htoej te tgd stomunus ef prdssurd
frem tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt. sdd tgd prdsdjt venumd. pp* o88~2: adnew*
` Xdd Dnoet. Xor Hg`rnds; Gojiuosm `ji Auiigosm 'Nejiej 0?10. @rjeni. 8 vens*/.
ven* o. Ojtreiuhtoej. p* xno*
8 Xdd Dnoet. ep* hot.ven* oo. p* 132*
+ Xdd O* H 'o/ 'o/. ven* o. pp* 76-2. `aevd*
s Xdd o* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* 62-21. wotg @jjdx O. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 387/455
26 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Hgrosto`j Dr` ay tgd M`mnuls* 0 Ot w`s oj Dbypt tg`t tgd @r`aoh
notdr`turd `ji tgd @r`aoh `rhgotdhturd ldpt tgdmsdnvds `novd iurojb
tgd qu`rtdr ef ` monndjjoum tg`t dn`psdi adtwddj tgd oj`ubur`toej
ef tgd H`ordjd H`nopg`td `ji tgd Ettem`j hejqudst* @ji w`sDbypt eni breuji er jdw5 Ot w`s jdw breuji oj`smuhg `s ot g`i
jet adbuj te ad ojherper`tdi ojte tgd iem`oj ef tgd Xyro`h Hovono-
z`toej. te wgohg tgd @r`aoh Hovonoz`toej w`s "`ffono`tdi". adferd tgd
djtry ef tgos Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej ojte ots ujovdrs`n st`td<`ji dvdj
tgdj tgd "id`i trujl" ef tgd ojiobdjeus Dbypto`h Hovonoz`toej.
wgohg stonn humadrdi tgd breuji oj Dbypt. w`s ejny `aseradi ojte
tgd tossuds ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej snewny `ji `riueusny*
Ygdhejqudst
ef
Dbypt aytgd @hg`dmdjo`j
Dmpord.wgohg w`s
tgd eroboj`n Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td.1 w`s ` mdrd dxtdrj`n `jjdx`toej*
Ygd Dbypto`js wdrd sompny suaiudi penotoh`nny ay ferhd ef `rms
`ji dvdj tgos ejny ojtdrmottdjtny* Ygd @hg`dmdjo`j rdbomdm`id je prebrdss wg`tdvdr tew`ris hejvdrtojb tgdor seuns
< `ji.
wgdj tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td w`s ojtdrruptdi ay tgd ojtrusoej
ef Gdnndjosm. "Gdnndjoz`toej" sddmdi ` merd noldny idstojy fer tgd
rdsoiud ef tgd Dbypto`h Xehodty tg`j ` mdrbdr wotg tgd Xyro`h
Xehodty wgohg g`i addj suamdrbdi. quotd `s iddpny `s tgd
Dbypto`h Xehodty otsdnf. ujidr tgd Gdnndjoh fneei* Ot w`s jet ujton
aetg tgd Gdnndjoh `ji tgd Dbypto`h Xehodty wdrd oj dxtrdmos tg`t.
oj tgd hempdtotoej fer sporotu`n iemojoej evdr Dbypt. tgd Gdnndjoh
Xehodty nest `ji tgd Xyro`h Xehodty b`ojdi tgd uppdr g`ji* Ygduntom`td vohtery ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej oj Dbypt w`s forst ferd-
sg`iewdi wgdj Dbypt w`s h`ptov`tdi ay Mejepgysotosm `
vdrsoej ef Hgrosto`joty oj wgohg tgd Xyro`h rd`htoej `b`ojst Gdn-
ndjosm dxprdssdi otsdnf adferd tgd iossenutoej ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord
`ji tgd rd-ojtdbr`toej ef tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd "@aa`soi
H`nopg`td*8 Ygd vohtery ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej oj Dbyptw`s ejny
hejsumm`tdi wgdj tgd pepun`toej ef Dbypt `ftdr g`vojb suh-
hdssovdny `a`jiejdi tgdor `jhodjt Dbypto`h rdnoboej fer Sromotovd
Hgrosto`joty `ji Sromotovd Hgrosto`joty fer Mejepgysotosm wdrd
hejvdrtdi dj m`ssd frem Mejepgysotosm te Osn`m< `ji tgos ioi jet
g`ppdj ujton tgd "@aa`soi H`nopg`td otsdnf g`i iossenvdi ojte tgd
ojtdrrdbjum 'horh` @*I* ?24-0124/+ eut efwgohg tgd @r`aoh Hovonoz`-
toej `ftdrw`ris dmdrbdi* Ygus. oj Dbypt. tgd @r`aoh Hovonoz`toejw`s ehhupyojb breuji wgohg tgd "`pp`rdjtdi" Xyro`h hovonoz`toej
g`i jet hempndtdny m`id ots ewj ujton tgd @r`aoh Hovonoz`toej w`sej tgd peojt ef hemojb te aortg* _dt ot w`s ej tgos jdw breuji oj
0 Xdd ven* o. p* 23. `aevd* ` Xdd ven* o. pp* 24-?. `aevd*8 Ygd rd`htoej ef tgd Xyro`j Hovonoz`toej `b`ojst tgd ojtrusoej ef Gdnndjosm. ef wgohg
tgos Mejepgysotd vdrsoej ef Hgrosto`joty w`s ejd symptem oj ejd pg`sd. os ioshussdifurtgdr oj OO* 8I 'vo/. ej p* 186. `ji OO* I 'vj/. ej pp* 876-2. `s wdnn `s oj S`on OW. adnew*
+ Xdd ven* o. pp. 62-7. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 388/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 22
Dbypt tg`t tgd @r`aoh Hovonoz`toej iospn`ydi suhg vobeur `s ot ioi
iospn`y adferd ots h`rddr w`s prdm`turdny hnesdi ay ojherper`toejojte tgd aeiy seho`n ef ots nustodr Or`joh sostdr* Ygos os jetdwertgy.
hejsoidrojb tg`t tgd eroboj`n gemd ef tgd @r`aoh Hovonoz`toejojhnuidi jet ejny tgd jdw breuji ef Dbypt aut `nse tgd eni breujief Xyro` tgd vdry rdboej oj wgohg tgd "`pp`rdjtdi
8
Xyro`h Hovono-
z`toej g`i t`ldj ots rosd* _dt. oj tgd gostery ef tgd "`ffono`tdi+
@r`aoh Hovonoz`toej. Xyro` `nw`ys pn`ydi tgd suaerioj`td `ji Dbypttgd nd`iojb p`rt*
@b`oj. oj wg`t `rd`s ioi tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej tgd sostdr ef tgd
Xyro`h mest hejspohueusny fneurosg 5 @nmest `nn tgd brd`t `hgodvd-
mdjts ef tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej oj tgdprojhop`n spgdrds
ef seho`n
`htovoty jet ejny oj w`r `ji oj penotohs. aut dvdj oj `rhgotdhturd
`ji oj notdr`turd0 wdrd `hhempnosgdi `t ejd er etgdr ef tgd twe
dxtrdmotods ef tgd Or`joh Rerni ; dotgdr oj Gojiust`j. `t ejd dji. er
oj @j`teno`. `t tgd etgdr<1 `ji tgdy hunmoj`tdi rdspdhtovdny. oj
tgdsd twe `rd`s. oj tgd Mubg`n `ji oj tgd Ettem`j Dmpord* Rdrdtgdsd twe Or`joh dmpords drdhtdi ej eni breuji er ej jdw breuji 5
Ygd breuji w`s jdw oj aetg h`sds* Ygd Ettem`j Dmpord w`s
drdhtdi ej tgd iem`oj ef tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej< `ji
ojiddi ot ehhupodi tgos iem`oj se dffdhtovdny tg`t ot `htu`nny pdr-
fermdi. fer tgd m`oj aeiy ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem. tgd fujhtoej
ef ` ujovdrs`n st`td*8Xomon`rny. tgd Mubg`n Dmpord w`s drdhtdi ej
tgd iem`oj eftgd Gojiu Hovonoz`toej `ji pdrfermdi tgd fujhtoej ef
` ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd Gojiu Rerni*9 Ygus tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej
0 Sdrso`j notdr`turd wgohg oj tgd d`rny `bd ef Or`joh gostery hejtojudi te fneurosg. `jitgos oj tgd gd`rt ef tgd Or`joh Rerni. oj Or`j otsdnf os ` hejspohueus `pp`rdjt dxhdptoejte tgd bdjdr`n rund gdrd fermun`tdi* Ygos Sdrso`j notdr`turd. gewdvdr. os te ad rdb`ridi`s ` hrd`toej jet ef tgd Or`joh aut ef tgd "`pp`rdjtdi" Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej '`s N`toj
notdr`turd os ` hrd`toej ef tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej `ji jet ef tgd "`ffono`tdi+ Rdstdrj erN`toj Hgrostdjiem/* Ygd bdjdsos ef Sdrso`j notdr`turd w`s `j dvdjt ef tgd "@aa`soi `bd.wgdj tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej w`s djkeyojb ` loji ef "Ojio`j Xummdr+ `ftdr tgd rdojtdbr`-noej ef ots ujovdrs`n st`td* Ot os te tgos `bd ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej tg`t Sdrso`j notdr`turd
bdjdtoh`nny adnejbs. `ntgeubg hgrejeneboh`nny tgd nofdtomd ef ejd ef ots brd`t m`stdrs.X`+io ef Xgor`z 'vovda`t `rd` @ I* 0 079-01?x4. f`nns wotgoj tgd pest-Xyj`h ojtdrrdbjum.`ji tgd nofdtomds ef twe etgdrs G`foz ef Xgor`z `ji K`m! ef Lgur`s`j f`nn rdspdhtovdnywotgoj tgd feurtddjtg `ji tgd foftddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`; tg`t os te s`y.
wotgoj ` tomd wgdj tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej g`i `nrd`iy dmdrbdi G`foz `ji tgd etgdr
Sdrso`j pedts ef gos bdjdr`toej fneurosgdi ujidr seho`n hejiotoejs huroeusny rdsdmanojbtgesd wgohg preiuhdi aetg tgd Xh`jioj`vo`j sl`nis `ji tgd Oejo`j Gemdji`d* +Ot
weuni sddm tg`t tgd dxostdjhd ef jumdreus sm`nn heurts. rov`ns te ejd `jetgdr. `ji d`hg
strovojb te eutsgojd tgd etgdrs. w`s sojbun`rny f`veur`and te tgd djheur`bdmdjt ef pedts
`ji etgdr mdj ef ndttdrs. wge. of ios`ppeojtdi er snobgtdi oj ejd hoty. heuni bdjdr`nnyfoji oj `jetgdr ` merd f`veur`and rdhdptoej*" 'Arewjd. D B*; @ Notdr`ry Gostery ef
Sdrso`. ven* m 'H`maroibd 0?17. Tjovdrsoty Srdss/. pp 063-0 / Ygdrd`ftdr. gewdvdr.frem tgd adbojjojb ef tgd soxtddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. Sdrso`j notdr`turd
wontdi oj Oo`j ujidr tgd rdbomd ef tgd X`f`wos* 'Fer ` ioshussoej ef tgos n`st-mdjtoejdi
pgdjemdjej. sdd Arewjd. D. B ; @ Notdr`ry Gostery ef Sdrso`. ven ov 'H`maroibd 0?17.
Tjovdrsoty Srdss/. pp* 19-80< `ji tgd prdsdjt Xtuiy. O* H 'o/ '6/. @jjdx O. oj veno.
`aevd*/` Fer tgd `rd` hevdrdi ay tgd eroboj`n iem`oj ef tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej. sdd O* H 'o/
'6/. ven* o. pp* 67-?. `aevd*8 Fer tgos rend ef tgd Ettem`j Dmpord. sdd furtgdr S`rt OOO* @. ven* ooo. pp* 16-2. `ji
S`rt VO. adnew* 9 Xdd S`rt VO. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 389/455
27 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
iospn`ydi. `t twe peojts wgohg wdrd rdmetd frem ejd `jetgdr. tgd
oidjtoh`n oioesyjhr`sy ef fneurosgojb adst ej ferdobj seon* Merd-
evdr. ot os te ad jetdi tg`t. oj aetg h`sds. tgd `hquosotoej ef tgos
ferdobj seon g`i jet st`rtdi ujton `ftdr tgd adbojjojb ef tgd ojtdr-
rdbjum 'horh` @*I* ?24-0124/ ojte wgohg tgd ujovdrs`n st`td ef tgd
"`pp`rdjtdi" Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej iossenvdi `ji eut ef wgohg tgd
"`ffono`tdi" Or`joh Hovonoz`toej otsdnf dmdrbdi* Ygd forst pdrm`jdjt
hejqudsts ef Gojiu tdrrotery oj tgd L`aun V`nndy `ji oj tgd S`jk`a
wdrd m`id 'horh` @*I* ?24-O314/0
ay Xdaultdboj `ji gos merd
hdndar`tdi suhhdsser M`gmui ef Bg`zj`g< tgd forst pdrm`jdjt
hejqudsts ef Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j tdrrotery wdrd m`id 'horh` @*I*
0323-4/ aytgd
X`nkuqs*@hheriojbny. ot w`s ej sotds `hquordi podhdmd`n frem `nodj
hovonoz`toejs `t rdhdjt i`tds tg`t tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej dvdjtu`nny
drdhtdi ots mest ompesojb mejumdjts* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. tgd
sdheji gemd wgohg tgd "`pp`rdjtdi" Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej g`i ejhd
feuji ej tgd Or`jo`j Sn`td`u `ji oj tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj1
jdvdr adh`md tgd mest `htovd fehus ef tgd "`ffono`tdi" Or`joh Hovono-
z`toej. oj spotd ef tgd f`ht tg`t tgdsd twe rdboejs n`y oj tgd gd`rt
ef tgd zejd oj wgohg tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej eroboj`nny dmdrbdi*
Iurojb tgd `bd wgdj. oj tgd jdw tdrroterods hejqudrdi frem
Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem `ji Gojiuosm. tgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej w`s
beojb frem strdjbtg te strdjbtg. ot suhhumadi oj Or`j `ji oj
Yr`jsex`jo` te ` sdrods ef neh`n mosidvdnepmdjts*8 Oj tgd forst
pn`hd. iurojb tgd pest-Xyro`h ojtdrrdbjum. tgdsd rdboejs aerd tgd
arujt ef tgd Mejben ojv`soej tgd n`st `ji mest idstruhtovd
`v`n`jhgd ef tgd pest-Xyro`h Venldrw`jidrujb* Ygdrd`ftdr. tgdy
n`y terpoi ujidr tgd id`iwdobgt ef tgd twe neh`n Mejben "suhhdsser-
st`tds" ef tgd "@aa`soi H`nopg`td tgd `pp`j`bd ef tgd On-Lg`js `jitgd `pp`j`bd ef tgd Geusd ef Hg`bg`t`y <
`ji tgdsd ioseridrny `ji
snubbosg rdbomds ejny ios`ppd`rdi te m`ld w`y fer tgd idveurojbmonot`rosm ef Yomur* Ygd foj`n anews. ay wgohg tgd twe rdboejs
wdrd prestr`tdi somunt`jdeusny `t tgd adbojjojb ef tgd soxtddjtg
hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. wdrd tgd dst`anosgmdjt ef tgd Xgo"o
Sewdr oj Or`j `ji tgd hejqudst ef tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj ay tgd
Tzadb a`ra`ro`js eff tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd ; twe voendjt penotoh`n
tr`jsferm`toejs wgohg g`i tgd oidjtoh dffdht ef foxojb ` brd`t
rdnoboeus `ji huntur`n bunf adtwddj tgd bdebr`pgoh`n gd`rt ef tgd
0Xdaultdboj dst`anosgdi gos suzdr`ojty evdr tgd L`aun V`nndy oj @*I* 324< `ji
M`gmui hejqudrdi ot `ji ferhoany hejvdrtdi tgd pepun`toej te Osn`m oj @*I* 0310.
'V`oiy`. H* V*- @ Gostery ef Mdio`dv`n Ojio` 'Seej` 0?10-9. Erodjt`n Aeel-Xuppnyojb@bdjhy. 1 vens*/. ven* o. p* 0?8 / Xdaultdbm"s r`ois ej tgd S`jk`a adb`j oj @*I* ?76-2<M`gmui r`oidi L`j`uk oj @*I* 030? 'Xmotg. V*; Ygd D`rny Gostery ef Ojio`. 8ri diotoej
'Exferi 0?09. Hn`rdjiej Srdss/. p* 871/*1 Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* 73-1. `aevd*
` Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. @jjdx O. oj ven* o. OO* I 'v/. pp* 099-7 ef tgd prdsdjt venumd ; `jiS`rt OV*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 390/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 2?
Or`joh Rerni `ji dotgdr ef ots dxtrdmotods* Ygus ot w`s oj tgd
dxtrdmotods `ji jet `t tgd gd`rt ef tgd Or`joh aeiy seho`n tg`t tgd
aneei puns`tdi mest vobereusny< er. oj tdrms ef eur eroboj`n mdt`-
pger.ot
w`s ej jdw breuji `ji jet ej eni breuji tg`t tgd sddi eftgd Or`joh hunturd preiuhdi ots fojdst g`rvdsts*
Oj wg`t rdboejs g`s tgd brd`tdst vobeur addj iospn`ydi ay tgd
Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej5 @ bn`jhd `t ots gostery sgews
tg`t ots seho`n hdjtrd ef br`voty g`s n`oj oj ioffdrdjt rdboejs `t
ioffdrdjt tomds* Oj tgd forst `bd `ftdr ots dmdrbdjhd eut ef tgd pest-
Gdnndjoh ojtdrrdbjum. tgd nofd ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem w`s mest
vobereus ej tgd @so`toh soid ef tgd Aespgerus `ji I`ri`jdnnds
oj tgd hdjtr`n `ji jertg-d`stdrjp`rts
ef tgd @j`teno`j Sn`td`u
er. oj tgd `imojostr`tovd tdrmojeneby ef tgd i`y. oj tgd @j`tenoh
`ji @rmdjo`h `rmy herps iostrohts 'tgdm`t`/ ef tgd D`st Qem`j
Dmpord* Ygdrd`ftdr. oj tgd heursd ef tgd twe hdjturods wgohg
dn`psdi adtwddj tgd hejvdrsoej ef Aunb`ro` te Ertgeiex Hgrosto-
`joty oj @*I* 764-23 `ji tgd ehhup`toej ef tgd ojtdroer ef @j`teno`
ay tgd X`nkuq Yurlosg hejvdrts te Osn`m oj @*I* 0323-4. tgd hdjtrd
ef br`voty ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem sgoftdi frem tgd @so`toh te tgd
Durepd`j soid ef tgd Xtr`ots< `ji. `s f`r `s tgd m`oj aeiy ef
Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Xehodty os hejhdrjdi. ot g`s rdm`ojdi oj tgd
A`nl`j Sdjojsun` dvdr sojhd* Oj meidrj tomds. gewdvdr. tg`t
pertoej ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem wgohg hejstotutds tgd m`oj aeiyef tgd sehodty frem `j gosteroh`n st`jipeojt g`s addj f`r eutstroppdi
oj brewtg `ji evdrsg`iewdi oj ompert`jhd ay tgd mobgty effsgeet
ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem oj Qusso`* 0
@rd tgdsd tgrdd `rd`s oj wgohg tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`-
toej g`s suhhdssovdny r`osdi ots gd`i te ad rdb`ridi `s eni breuji
er `s jdw 5 Hdjtr`n `ji Jertg-D`stdrj @j`teno` w`s hdrt`ojny jdw
breuji `s f`r `s tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej w`s hejhdrjdi*
Ot w`s tgd fermdr iem`oj ef tgd Gottotd Hovonoz`toej< `ji `ntgeubg
tgd Gottotd Hovonoz`toej g`i iodi ` prdm`turd id`tg ay voendjhd
iurojb tgd Venldrw`jidrujb oj wgohg tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej
w`s areubgt te aortg.1
ots @j`teno`j gemdn`ji w`s jet pdjdtr`tdi
ay Gdnndjosm ujton `ftdr tgd idstruhtoej ef tgd @hg`dmdjo`j
Dmpord ay @ndx`jidr tgd Brd`t* Dvdj tgdj. tgos rdboej rdm`ojdi
ujgdnndjozdi muhg nejbdr tg`j m`jy pn`hds tg`t wdrd f`r merdiost`jt frem tgd @dbd`j* Ygd prehdss ioi jet sdt oj vobereusny
gdrd ujton `ftdr tgd n`st ef tgd neh`n "suhhdsser-st`tds" ef tgd
@hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord g`i addj hejvdrtdi ojte Qem`j prevojhds<
`ji tgd forst pesotovd neh`n hejtroautoejs te tgd Gdnndjoh hunturd
+ @j effsgeet wgohg g`s jdotgdr nest ots ompert`jhd jer hd`sdi te ad rdhebjoz`and
tgreubg adojb ir`pdi twohd evdr forst ay Sdtdr tgd Brd`t `ji tgdj ay Ndjoj m `j
dxetoh f`jhy irdss ef tgd memdjt`rony f`sgoej`and Rdstdrj hut*
1 Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* ?8 `ji 033-0. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 391/455
7e YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
wdrd m`id `s n`td `s tgd feurtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr` ay tgd
H`pp`ieho`j F`tgdrs ef tgd Hgurhg* Ygus tgd d`rnodst hdjtrd ef
br`voty ef tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej oj tgd ojtdroer ef
@j`teno` n`y oj ` rdboej wgohg g`i jet addj hempndtdny ojherper`tdiojte tgd iem`oj ef tgd "`pp`rdjtdi" Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej ujton
Gdnndjosm w`s oj `rtohune mertos*
Ygd sdheji hdjtrd ef br`voty oj tgd ojtdroer ef tgd A`nl`j
Sdjojsun` w`s dst`anosgdi ej jdw breuji noldwosd* Fer tgd vdjddr
ef Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej oj ` N`toj mdioum. wotg wgohg tgos rdboej
g`i addj tgojny evdrn`oi. oj tgd nofdtomd ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord.
iurojb ` sp`j ef semd fovd hdjturods. g`i addj idstreydi wotgeut
nd`vojb` tr`hd0
iurojbtgd
ojtdrrdbjumojte wgohg tgd
Dmpordg`i
dvdjtu`nny iossenvdi* Ygd idstruhtoej w`s merd tgereubgbeojbgdrd tg`j ot w`s oj `jy ef tgd wdstdrj prevojhds wotg tgd sojbnd
dxhdptoej ef Arot`oj* Oj tgd A`nl`j Sdjojsun`. `s oj Arot`oj. tgd
supdrfoho`n hg`jbd ef rdbomd w`s `hhemp`jodi ay ` r`ioh`n hg`jbdefpepun`toej `ji rdnoboej* Ygd Hgrosto`j Qem`j prevojho`ns wdrd
jet sompny hejqudrdi aut wdrd pr`htoh`nny dxtdrmoj`tdi ay tgd
p`b`j a`ra`ro`j ojv`idrs< `ji tgdsd a`ra`ro`js dr`ioh`tdi `nn
dndmdjts ef neh`n hunturd se dffdhtovdny tg`t wgdj tgdor idshdji`jts
rdpdjtdi ef tgd dvon wgohg tgdor f`tgdrs g`i iejd tgdy g`i te eat`oj
frdsg sddi frem eutsoid oj eridr te st`rt huntov`toej `b`oj* Ay tgd
tomd wgdj Ertgeiex Hgrosto`joty w`s rd-sewj oj tgd A`nl`j
Sdjojsun` oj tgd jojtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. tgd seon g`i
addj nyojb f`nnew fer merd tg`j tgrdd hdjturods ; tg`t os te s`y. fer
`aeut twohd `s nejb `s tgd seon ef Arot`oj g`i addj nyojb f`nnew `t
tgd tomd wgdj @ubustojd w`s sdjt ej gos mossoej ay Brdbery tgd
Brd`t* Ygus tgd rdboej oj wgohg tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`-
toej dst`anosgdi ots sdheji hdjtrd ef br`voty w`s breuji wgohg g`irdhdjtny addj rdhn`omdi id jeve frem tgd wonidrjdss*
@s fer tgd tgori hdjtrd ef br`voty oj Qusso`. tgdrd os je jddi te
n`aeur tgd peojt* Ygd effsgeet ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem wgohg
w`s tr`jspn`jtdi te Qusso` oj tgd tdjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j
Dr` w`s prep`b`tdi tgdrd oj vorboj seon ej wgohg je hovonoz`toej g`i
dvdr brewj adferd< `ji tgos jdw Qusso`j effsgeet ef Ertgeiex
Hgrostdjiem w`s sdp`r`tdi frem tgd m`oj aeiy ay ` ieuand
a`rrodr ef sd` `ji stdppd*1
Qusso` w`s jdw breuji wotg `
0 Ygd survov`n ef ` Qem`jhd n`jbu`bd `mejb tgd meujt`ojs ef Xeutg-D`stdrj
Durepd. frem tgd H`rp`tgo`js te tgd Sojius. h`jjet prepdrny ad rdb`ridi `s ` tr`hd ef tgdN`toj vdrsoej ef tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej m tgd A`nl`j Sdjojsun`< fer tgd survov`n ef tgd
n`jbu`bd ioi jet h`rry wotg ot `jy survov`n ef tgd hunturd ef wgohg tgos n`jbu`bd g`i ejhdaddj tgd vdgohnd* Ygd stonn N`toj-spd`lojb `ji stonn jemoj`nny Hgrosto`j Vn`hgs `jiQum`js g`i te ad hejvdrtdi. oj "tgd Moiind @bds". te tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`-
toej id jeve. kust nold tgd hejtdmper`ry Aunb`rs `ji Kubesn`vs. wge wdrd p`b`j a`r-a`ro`js spd`lojb eutn`jiosg tejbuds*
1 @t tgd prdsdjt tomd. tgd iem`oj ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem oj Qusso` `ji ots iem`ojoj tgd A`nl`j Sdjojsun` `rd bdebr`pgoh`nny osen`tdi frem ejd `jetgdr je nejbdr* Ygd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 392/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 70
vdjbd`jhd< `ji ot os jetdwertgy tg`t. oj Qusso`. tgd Ertgeiex
Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej g`s fneurosgdi wotg `j dxuadr`jhd wgohg
st`jis eut oj hejtr`st te ots str`ojdi `ji stujtdi brewtg dnsd-
wgdrd*
Ot os stonn merd rdm`rl`and te easdrvd tg`t wgond tgd hdjtrd ef
br`voty ef tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej g`s sgoftdi twohd oj
tgd heursd ef Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j gostery. ot g`s jdvdr n`oj oj tgd
gemdn`ji ef tgd "`pp`rdjtdi" Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej oj tgd @dbd`j
`rd`. `ntgeubg tgos `rd` g`s addj ojhnuidi oj tgd iem`oj ef Ertge-
iex Hgrostdjiem frem forst te n`st* Oj tgd d`rny `bd eftgd Ertgeiex
Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej. wgdj ots hdjtrd ef br`voty n`y ej tgd
@j`teno`j Sn`td`u. tgd @dbd`j frejt`bd ef @j`teno`. wgohg g`i
pn`ydi ` nd`iojb rend oj tgd d`rny `bd ef tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej.
w`s pdrg`ps tgd nd`st ompert`jt iostroht oj tgd @so`toh pdjojsun`*0
@b`oj. sojhd tgd hdjtrd ef br`voty ef tgd m`oj aeiy ef Ertgeiex
Hgrostdjiem g`s sgoftdi te tgd Durepd`j soid ef tgd Xtr`ots. ot g`s
jerm`nny n`oj ej tgd n`jiw`ri `ji jet ej tgd sd`w`ri soid ef
X`nejoh`* Oj f`ht. pdjojsun`r Brddhd. wgohg w`s tgd gua ef tgd
Gdnndjoh ujovdrsd `ftdr tgd prom`hy g`i ejhd p`ssdi frem Oejo`. g`s
jdvdr pn`ydi ` premojdjt p`rt oj Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j gostery dxhdpt
ej twe ehh`soejs ejd oj tgd "mdiodv`n" `ji tgd etgdr oj tgd"meidrj" `bd ef Rdstdrj gostery wgdj Brddhd g`s sdrvdi `s `
Qum`jo`j Ertgeiex Hgrosto`js ef tgd A`nl`j `rd` jew m`rhg wotg tgdor Tlr`ojo`j he-
rdnoboejosts ef tgd Qusso`j `rd` `nejb ` nojd dxtdjiojb frem tgd Hdjtr`n H`rp`tgo`js
tgreubg tgd Aulevoj` `ji Adss`r`ao` te tgd An`hl Xd` he`st* Ygos bdebr`pgoh`n hej-
tojuoty adtwddj tgd Qusso`j `ji tgd A`nl`j iem`ojs ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem ieds jet.
gewdvdr. i`td a`hl f`rtgdr tg`j tgddobgtddjtg hdjtury*
Ygd twe iem`ojs wdrd sdp`r`tdifrem ejd `jetgdr ay `j eutnyojb strop ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd ujton `ftdr tgd Qusse-
Yurlosg R`r ef @*I* 0267-29 Ot w`s ejny oj tgd sdqudn te tgos w`r. wgdj tgd jertg
he`st ef tgd An`hl Xd` `ji ots wgend gojtdrn`ji wdrd `jjdxdi te tgd Qusso`j Dmpord.tg`t tgos ojsun`tojb strop ef stdppd w`s hnd`rdi ef tgd n`st ef ots Jem`ioh p`ster`n tdj`jts
`ji w`s henejozdi wotg `j `brohuntur`n pepun`toej ef Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j pd`s`jts*Ygos w`s tgd foj`n st`bd oj ` br`iu`n hejvdrbojb djhre`hgmdjt ef tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j
pd`s`jt"s pneubgn`ji upej tgd Musnom er p`b`j gdrism`j"s h`ttnd-r`jbd wgohg g`i
addj oj prebrdss sojhd tgd Qum`j poejddrs g`i idshdjidi oj tgd feurtddjtg hdjturyfrem tgd Yr`jsynv`jo`j gobgn`jis ojte tgd pn`ojs ef R`nn`hgo` `ji Meni`vo`. `ji sojhd
tgd [`perebo`j Hess`hls g`i dst`anosgdi tgdmsdnvds `s tgdy ioi `t `aeut tgd s`md i`td
ej tgdor osn`ji-fertrdss oj tgd Qovdr Imdpr* 'Xdd OO* I 'v/. pp* 049-2. adnew*/ Oj
tgd tdjtg hdjtury. gewdvdr. tgos djhre`hgmdjt g`i jet ydt adbuj* @t tg`t tomd. tgd
p`b`j Yurlosg Sdhgdjdbs wdrd p`sturojb tgdor fnehls ej vorboj stdppd-n`ji frem tgd
a`jls ef tgd Iej te tgd Orej B`tds ef tgd I`juad wotgeut ojtdrruptoej Ygd Ertgeiex
Hgrosto`j mossoej`rods wge h`rrodi tgd sddis ef tgdor hovonoz`toej te Qusso` heuni ejny
oh`hg tgos jdw fodni ay f`hojb tgd pdrons ef sd` `ji stdppd oj suhhdssoej* Ygdy g`i forst te
tr`vdn ay sgop frem Hejst`jtojepnd te tgd Hromd`. `ji tgdjhd te pohl tgdor w`y `hress
tgd epdj pr`orod. wgdrd tgdy wdrd `t tgd mdrhy ef tgd Sdhgdjdbs ujton tgdy feuji s`fdty`t n`st oj tgd seutgdrj eutslorts ef tgd Qusso`j ferdsts*
+ Rgdj tgd D`st Qem`j @rmy w`s hejhdjtr`tdi oj @j`teno` iurojb tgd monot`ry hrosos
preiuhdi ay tgd Sdoso`j `ji @r`a ojv`soejs oj tgd sdvdjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j
Dr`. tgos iostroht w`s `ssobjdi te tgd Ygr`hdjso`j @rmy Herps. wgohg w`s pdrm`jdjtnywotgir`wj frem tgd Durepd`j iostroht frem wgohg ot idrovdi ots j`md `ji w`s st`toejdi
gdrd oj Rdstdrj @j`teno` oj eridr te suppert tgd @j`tenoh @rmy Herps. wgohg g`i addj
wotgir`wj frem Xyro` ej te tgd @j`teno`j Sn`td`u* Ygd @j`tenoho wdrd tgd frejt-nojd
treeps< tgd Ygr`hdjsds wdrd mdrd rdsdrvds* @hheriojbny. tgd Ygr`hdjso`j iostroht w`s
gttnd `hheujtdi ef. wgdrd`s tgd @j`tenoh iostroht. oj hejkujhtoej wotg tgd @rmdjo`h.
sw`ydi tgd idstojods ef tgd D`st Qem`j Dmpord*
OO B
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 393/455
71 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
R`tdrb`td tgreubg wgohg Rdstdrj ojfnudjhd g`s ferhdi `j djtry
ojte tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Rerni* 0
Yurjojb jew te Gdnndjoh gostery. ndt us `sl eur qudstoej `prepes
ef tgd twe rdboejs wgohg '`s wd g`vd kust easdrvdi oj p`ssojb/
suhhdssovdny gdni tgd prom`hy oj tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni* Rgdj tgd
Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej fnewdrdi ej tgd @j`teno`j he`st ef tgd @dbd`j`ji `ftdrw`ris ej tgd Durepd`j Brddl pdjojsun`. w`s ot ej jdw
breuji er ej eni breuji tg`t tgos fnewdrojb teel pn`hd 5 Ot w`s ej
jdw breuji. gdrd `b`oj <fer jdotgdr ef tgdsd rdboejs g`i n`oj wotgoj
tgd eroboj`n gemd ef tgd `jtdhdidjt Moje`j Hovonoz`toej. te wgohg
tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej w`s rdn`tdi* Ej tgd Durepd`j Brddl
pdjojsun`.tgd Moje`j
Hovonoz`toej.dvdj `t ots woidst dxtdjsoej oj
ots n`tdst `bd. g`i gdni je merd tg`j ` hg`oj ef fertofodi pesotoejs
`nejb tgd seutgdrj `ji d`stdrj he`st-nojds*8 Ej tgd @j`teno`j he`st
ef tgd @dbd`j. tgd f`onurd ef eur meidrj Rdstdrj `rhg`denebosts
te foji tr`hds ef tgd prdsdjhd. er dvdj ojfnudjhd. ef tgd Moje`j
Hovonoz`toej g`s addj se sobj`n tg`t ot h`j g`riny ad `ttroautdi te
hg`jhd. aut sddms r`tgdr te ojioh`td tg`t fer semd rd`sej tgos
he`st `htu`nny ioi jet hemd wotgoj tgd Moje`js" r`jbd*8 @s f`r `s
wd ljew. tgd forst sdttndrs frem tgd @dbd`j te ehhupy tgd wdst
he`st ef @j`teno` dffdhtovdny wdrd tgesd rdfubdds ef Moje`j hunturd
`ji Brddl spddhg wge wdrd irovdj tgotgdr. `s n`td `s tgd twdnftg
hdjtury A*H*. oj tgd s`md foj`n hejvunsoej ef tgd pest-Moje`j
Venldrw`jidrujb tg`t irevd tgd Sgonostojds ej te tgd he`st ef
Xyro`*9 Ygdsd wdrd tgd feujidrs ef @denos `ji Oejo`< `ji tgus
Gdnndjosm fnewdrdi forst ej seon wgohg tgd `jtdhdidjt hovonoz`toej
g`i jdvdr sdroeusny huntov`tdi* Merdevdr. wgdj tgd sddis wdrd
sh`ttdrdi `are`i frem Oejo` ojte etgdr p`rts ef tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni.
tgd Oejoh seon ej wgohg tgdy fnewdrdi jdxt w`s tgd stejy breuji ef
@ttoh` ej tgd eppesotd soid ef tgd @dbd`j* Ygdy ioi jet bdrmoj`tdoj tgd Hyhn`ids ; tgd Oejoh osn`jis wgohg steei. nold stdppojb-stejds.adtwddj tgd Oejoh m`ojn`jis oj @so` `ji oj Durepd* Ygreubg tgd
wgend heursd ef Gdnndjoh gostery tgd Hyhn`ioh osn`jidrs pn`ydi `
suaerioj`td rend `s gumand sdrv`jts ef tgd suhhdssovd m`stdrs ef tgd
sd`* Ygos os rdm`rl`and. sojhd tgd Hyhn`ids g`i addj ejd ef tgd
twe feho ef tgd `jtdhdidjt Moje`j Hovonoz`toej* Ygd etgdr Moje`j
fehus. ef heursd. w`s Hrdtd< `ji tgd rend pn`ydi oj Gdnndjoh gostery
ay Hrdtd os dvdj merd surprosojb*
+ Ygd forst ef tgdsd twe ferhoand djtrods w`s tgd monot`ry hejqudst ef pdjojsun`r Brddhd
ay tgd N`tojs. iurojb `ji `ftdr tgd se-h`nndi "Feurtg Hrus`id"* Ygd sdheji w`s tgdojfontr`toej ef meidrj Rdstdrj oid`s wgohg adb`j tew`ris tgd dji ef tgd sdvdjtddjtg
hdjtury `ji h`md te ` gd`i penotoh`nny. semd gujirdi `ji fofty yd`rs n`tdr. oj tgd BrddlR`r ef Ojidpdjidjhd wgohg areld eut oj @*I* 0710*
` Xdd O* H 'o/ '/. @jjdx OO. ven o. `aevd*8 Ej tgos peojt. sdd O* H 'o/ 'a/. ven* o. p* ?4. `aevd*+ Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* 033-1. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 394/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 78
Hrdtd mobgt g`vd addj dxpdhtdi te rdt`oj ots seho`n ompert`jhdjet ejny fer gosteroh`n rd`sejs. `s tgd pn`hd oj wgohg tgd Moje`jHovonoz`toej g`i `tt`ojdi ots hunmoj`toej. aut fer bdebr`pgoh`n
rd`sejs `s wdnn* Hrdtd w`s ay f`r tgd n`rbdst osn`ji oj tgd @dbd`j@rhgopdn`be. `ji ot n`y `tgw`rt twe ef tgd mest ompert`jt sd`-
reutds oj tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni* Dvdry sgop tg`t s`ondi frem tgd
Sdor`dus fer Xohony g`i te p`ss adtwddj tgd wdstdrj dji ef Hrdtd
`ji N`hejo`< dvdry sgop tg`t s`ondi frem tgd Sdor`dus fer Dbyptg`i te p`ss adtwddj tgd d`stdrj dji ef Hrdtd `ji Qgeids* _dt.
wgdrd`s N`hejo` `ji Qgeids d`hg pn`ydi ` nd`iojb p`rt oj Gdnndjoh
gostery. Hrdtd rdm`ojdi `neef. eashurd `ji adjobgtdi frem forst
te n`st* Rgond Gdnn`s `nn `reuji w`sbovojb
aortg te st`tdsmdj
`ji pedts `ji `rtosts `ji pgonesepgdrs. tgd osn`ji wgohg g`i ejhd
addj tgd gemd ef tgd Moje`j Hovonoz`toej jew ardi jetgojb merd
rdput`and tg`j mdiohojd-mdj `ji mdrhdj`rods `ji por`tds< `ji
tgeubg tgd brd`tjdss ef Moje`j Hrdtd g`i ndft ots omprdss upej tgd
Gdnndjoh Mytgeneby oj tgd f`ands ef Mojes tgd tg`n`ssehr`t `ji gos
aretgdr Qg`i`m`jtgys. tgd kuibd ef tgd id`i. tgos ioi jet s`vd tgd
n`ttdr-i`y Hrdt`j sh`pdbr`hd frem adhemojb ` Gdnndjoh ayweri*
Ojiddi. gd g`s p`ssdi kuibdmdjt ej gomsdnf oj tgd sejb ef Gyaro`s0
`ji oj ` gdx`mdtdr wgohg g`s addj dmadiidi. nold ` fny oj `madr.
oj tgd h`jej ef Hgrosto`j Xhropturd* "Ejd ef tgdmsdnvds. dvdj `
prepgdt ef tgdor ewj. s`oi; Ygd Hrdto`js `rd `nw`ys no`rs. dvon
ad`sts. snew adnnods* :1 Ygus dvdj tgd @pestnd ef tgd Bdjtonds
dxhdptdi tgd Gdnndjds ef Hrdtd frem tgd hg`roty wgohg gd adstewdi
upej Gdnndjds oj bdjdr`n*8
Ndt us `sl eur qudstoej ejhd `b`oj tgos tomd oj rdb`ri te tgd
F`r D`stdrj Hovonoz`toej wgohg os "`ffono`tdi" te tgd Xojoh Hovonoz`toej*
@t wg`t peojts oj ots iem`oj g`s tgos F`r D`stdrj Hovonoz`toej
sgewj tgd brd`tdst vobeur 5 Ygd K`p`jdsd `ji tgd H`jtejdsd st`ji
eut ujmost`l`any `s ots mest vobereus rdprdsdjt`tovds te-i`y< `ji
aetg tgdsd pdepnds g`vd sprujb frem seon wgohg os jdw breuji `ji
jet eni breuji frem tgd st`jipeojt ef F`r D`stdrj gostery* @s
rdb`ris tgd seutg-d`stdrj sd`ae`ri ef Hgoj`. wd g`vd jetohdi oj `j
d`rnodr hg`ptdr+ tg`t ot w`s jet ojherper`tdi ojte tgd iem`oj ef tgd
+ @j Djbnosg tr`jsn`toej ef tgd Xejb ef Gyaro`s. ay Bonadrt Murr`y. wonn ad feuji
adnew
mS`rt OOO*
@.ven*
oj. ej p 72.feetjetd o*
1 Ygd Dpostnd ef S`un te Yotus. hg* o. v* 01* Ygd gdx`mdtdr gdrd quetdi rujs oj Brddl ;
Lp-fkrds `ht 3h5`r>u. LHNLE* Aypn`.. y``rdpds `pyet*
Fer tgd eroboj`n hejtdxt ef tgos vdrsd oj tgd pedm h`nndi "Mojes" wgohg w`s `ttroautdi
te tgd Hrdt`j "prepgdt" Dpomdjoids. sdd O H 'o/ '/. ven* o. p ??. feetjetd 1*
8 Ygd Hrdt`js g`vd jet ferbovdj Xt* S`un fer ommert`nozojb tgdor onn rdputd. `ji tgdyg`vd r`hldi tgdor ar`ojs te turj tgd p`ss`bd ef Xhropturd oj wgohg tgdy `rd ponnerodi te tgd
@pestnd"s ewj ioshrdiot* Rgdj tgd prdsdjt wrotdr w`s tr`vdnnojb oj Hrdtd oj tgd yd`r
0?01. ` Hrdt`j pd`s`jt `ikurdi gom oj `nn sdroeusjdss te iosheujt S`un"s tdstomejy ej tgd
breuji tg`t S`un w`s ` ao`sdi wotjdss* Ej adojb `sldi wg`t g`i bovdj S`un gos `jto-
Hrdt`j ao`s. tgd pd`s`jt dxpn`ojdi tg`t ` Hodt`j g`i ejhd bet tgd adttdr ef S`un oj `
ausojdss tr`js`htoej! , Oj O* H 'o/ '4/. ven* o. p* ?3. feetjetd 1*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 395/455
79 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
"`pp`rdjtdhY Xojoh Xehodty ujton tgd n`st pg`sd ef Xojoh gostery. `ji
dvdj tgdj ejny ej tgd supdrfoho`n pn`jd ef penotohs. `s ` frejtodr
prevojhd ef tgd Dmpord ef tgd G`j. wgohg w`s tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n
st`td* Ots ojg`aot`jts rdm`ojdia`ra`ro`js<
`ji tgdor suhhdssers
oj tgd feur meidrj Hgojdsd prevojhds ef Lw`jbtujb. Lw`jbso.
Fulodj. `ji Hgdlo`jb tdstofy. oj tgd jemdjhn`turd wgohg tgdy
dmpney. tg`t tgdy hn`om je p`rt er net oj tgd hg`ptdr ef gostery
wgohg tgd G`j Iyj`sty areubgt te ` hnesd* Ygdy rdsobj tgd
bneroeus j`md ef "G`j pdepnd" te tgdor jdobgaeurs oj tgd a`sojs ef
tgd _`jbtsd `ji tgd _dnnew Qovdr. `ji usd tgd j`md ef "Y"`jb
pdepnd" te idsobj`td tgdmsdnvds* Oj tgos idsobj`toej tgdy sobjofy
tg`t tgdor ewj gostery ioi jet adboj ujton tgd F`r D`stdrj Hovonoz`-
toej g`i `nrd`iy dmdrbdi frem tgd pest-Xojoh ojtdrrdbjum < fer tgd
nojd`mdjts ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Hovonoz`toej g`i t`ldj sg`pd adferd
tgd hnesd ef tgd foftg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. wgdrd`s tgd Y"`jb
Iyj`sty w`s jet feujidi ujton @*I* 607* Ygus tgd feur prevojhds
ef Hgoj` Srepdr wgohg `rd jew tgd mest vobereus `ji prebrdssovd`rd tgd feur oj wgohg tgd F`r D`stdrj Hovonoz`toej g`s areldj jdw
breuji* @s fer tgd K`p`jdsd @rhgopdn`be. tgd effsgeet ef tgd F`r
D`stdrj Hovonoz`toej wgohg w`s tr`jspn`jtdi tgotgdr. ay w`y ef
Lerd`. oj tgd soxtg `ji sdvdjtg hdjturods ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr` w`sprep`b`tdi tgdrd ej breuji wgdrd tgdrd w`s je tr`hd ef `jy prd-voeus hunturd* Ygd strejb brewtg ef tgos effsgeet ef tgd F`r D`stdrj
Hovonoz`toej ej tgd vorboj seon ef K`p`j os hemp`r`and te tgd brewtgef tgd effsgeet ef tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`toej wgohg w`s
tr`jspn`jtdi frem tgd @j`teno`j Sn`td`u te tgdvorboj seon ef Qusso`* 0
Ygd Xpdho`n Xtomunus ef Mobr`toej Evdrsd`s
Ygos survdy ef tgd rdn`tovd fdrtonoty ef eni breuji `ji jdw
breuji. `s dxdmpnofodi oj tgd gosterods ef sdvdj "rdn`tdi" hovonoz`-
toejs. g`s bovdj us ` hdrt`oj dmporoh`n suppert1 fer tgd iehtrojd
wgohg os ompnohot oj tgd mytgs ef tgd Dxeius `ji tgd Dxpunsoej ;
tgd iehtrojd tg`t tgd erid`n ef ard`lojb jdw breuji g`s `j ojtrojsoh
stomun`tojb dffdht* Adferd p`ssojb ej frem tgd pgysoh`n te tgd
gum`j djvorejmdjt. ndt us p`usd te bn`jhd `t hdrt`oj onnustr`toejs
ay wgohg tgd ferdbeojb dmporoh`n dvoidjhd m`y ad rdojferhdi*
Ygdsd `iiotoej`n onnustr`toejs hejform tgd vodw wgohg os sub-
bdstdi aytgd ujusu`n
vot`notyef tgd
Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j Hovonoz`-toej oj Qusso` `ji ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Hovonoz`toej oj K`p`j tg`t
tgd stomun`tojb dffdht ef ard`lojb jdw breuji os brd`tdst ef `nn wgdjtgd jdw breuji h`j ejny ad rd`hgdi ay hressojb tgd sd`*
Ygd spdho`n stomunus ojgdrdjt oj tr`jsm`rojd henejoz`toej `ppd`rs0 Xdd pp* 7e-r. `aevd*z Fer ` idfdjhd ef tgos dmporoh`n dvoidjhd `b`ojst ` pessoand hrotohosm. sdd OO* I 'm/.
@jjdx. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 396/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 74
vdry hnd`rny oj tgd gostery ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j iurojb tgd forst g`nf
ef tgd n`st monndjjoum A*H*. wgdj tgd Rdstdrj A`soj ef tgd Mdiotdr-
r`jd`j w`s adojb henejozdihempdtotovdny ay m`rotomd poejddrs
rdprdsdjtojb tgrdd ioffdrdjt hovonoz`toejs oj tgd Ndv`jt* Ot `ppd`rs.fer ojst`jhd. oj tgd idbrdd te wgohg tgd twe brd`tdst ef tgdsd
henejo`n feuji`toejs Xyro`h H`rtg`bd `ji Gdnndjoh Xyr`husd-d`hg eutstroppdi ots
p`rdjt-hoty*0
H`rtg`bd iw`rfdi Yyrd oj tgd
venumd `ji v`nud ef gdr hemmdrhd. `ji ej tgos dhejemoh a`sos sgd
auont up ` penotoh`n dmpord te wgohg tgd p`rdjt-hoty ioi jet `ji
heuni jet `spord* Xyr`husd noldwosd iw`rfdi gdr p`rdjt Herojtg oj
penotoh`n pewdr. `ji pdrg`ps dvdj merd sobj`nny oj tgd hejtroautoej
wgohg sgd m`id te Gdnndjoh hunturd*@b`oj.
tgd@hg`d`j
henejods
oj M`bj` Br`dho` adh`md ausy sd`ts ef Gdnndjoh hemmdrhd `ji
ojiustry. `ji aronno`jt hdjtrds ef Gdnndjoh tgeubgt. `s d`rny `s tgd
soxtg hdjtury A*H*. wgdrd`s tgd p`rdjt @hg`d`j hemmujotods `nejbtgd jertgdrj he`st ef tgd Sdnepejjdsd rdm`ojdi oj ` a`hlw`tdr
eutsoid tgd m`oj strd`m ef Gdnndjoh gostery fer tgrdd merd
hdjturods. `ji ejny dmdrbdi frem tgos nejb eashuroty `ftdr tgd
Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej g`i p`ssdi ots zdjotg* @s fer tgd Nehro`js.
wge wdrd tgd @hg`d`js" jdobgaeurs ej aetg soids ef tgd Oejo`j
Xd`. ot w`s ejny tgd Dpozdpgyro`j Nehro`js. oj tgdor tr`jsm`rojd
sdttndmdjt oj Ot`ny. wge dvdr iostojbuosgdi tgdmsdnvds `t `nn* YgdNehro`js ef Hejtojdjt`n Brddhd rdm`ojdi eashurd frem forst te n`st*
Ygd mest strolojb h`sd ef `nn os tg`t ef tgd Dtrush`js.1 wge wdrd
tgd tgori p`rty hempdtojb wotg tgd Brddls `ji tgd Sgedjoho`js
fer tgd henejoz`toej ef tgdRdstdrj Mdiotdrr`jd`j* Oj tgos hempdto-
toej. tgd Dtrush`js dffdhtovdny gdni tgdor ewj* Ygdor henejods ej
tgd wdst he`st ef Ot`ny wdrd hemp`r`and. oj sozd `ji jumadr. te tgd
Brddl henejods oj M`bj` Br`dho` `ji Xohony `ji te tgd Sgedjoho`j
henejods oj @froh` `ji Xp`oj< `ji tgd Dtrush`j henejosts. ujnold
dotgdr tgd Sgedjoho`js er tgd Brddls. wdrd jet hejtdjt te rdm`oj
wotgoj sobgt ef tgd sd` `hress wgohg tgdy g`i hemd* Ygdy pusgdiferw`ri frem tgd wdst he`st ef Ot`ny ojte tgd ojtdroer wotg `j in`j
wgohg h`rrodi tgdm ej `hress tgd @ppdjjojds `ji `hress tgd Se.
ujton tgdor eutpests g`ntdi `t n`st `t tgd feet ef tgd @nps* @t tgd
s`md tomd. tgdsd henejo`n Dtrush`js rdm`ojdi oj hnesd hejt`ht wotg
tgdor Brddl `ji Sgedjoho`j rov`ns < `ji tgeubg tgos hejt`ht br`iu-
`nny irdw tgdm ojte tgd `maot eftgd Gdnndjoh Xehodty `ji dvdjtu`nny
rdsuntdi oj tgdor adojb ojherper`tdi ojte tgd Gdnndjoh aeiy seho`n.
tgos huntur`n "hejvdrsoej" ojhrd`sdi r`tgdr tg`j iomojosgdi tgd
ompert`jhd ef tgdor pesotoej oj tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j Rerni* Ygus
0@s. oj tgd meidrj Durepd`j henejoz`toej ef Jertg @mdroh`. Aestej oj M`ss`hgu-
sdtts g`s eutstroppdi ots p`rdjt-tewj oj Nojhenjsgord. `ji Jdw _erl `ji Jdw Ernd`js
g`vd eutstroppdi tgd twe hotods oj Djbn`ji `ji Fr`jhd `ftdr wgohg tgdy `rd rdspdhtovdny
j`mdi. ` Xdd O* H'o/ '6/. ven* o. p* 009. feetjetd 8. wotg @jjdx OO. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 397/455
76 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tgd Dtrush`j henejods oj Ot`ny `rd onnumoj`tdi ay tgd funn nobgt ef
gostery< `ji wd `rd `nse jet wotgeut dvoidjhd ef `j `aertovd
Dtrush`j henejo`n djtdrprosd oj `jetgdr qu`rtdr ; ` i`rojb aut ujsuh-
hdssfun `ttdmpt te hempdtd wotg tgd Brddls. oj Brddl gemd w`tdrs.fer tgd m`stdry ef tgd I`ri`jdnnds `ji fer tgd hemm`ji ef tgd
An`hl Xd`* 0Ot os tgd merd rdm`rl`and tg`t tgd Dtrush`j gemdn`ji
oj tgd Ndv`jt. wgohg sdjt eut evdrsd`s tgd Dtrush`j henejosts ef
Ot`ny `ji tgd Dtrush`j henejosts ef Ndmjes. sgeuni ad `j gosteroh`n
tdrr` ojhebjot`* Je gosteroh`n rdheri ef ots dx`ht neh`toej survovds<
`ji jetgojb h`j ad auont ej tgd Gdnndjoh ndbdji tg`t tgd Dtrush`js
h`md frem Nyio`*1 Rd g`vd te ad hejtdjt wotg tgd ljewndibd.
suppnodi aytgd rdheris ef "tgd Jdw
Dmpord"ef
Dbypt.tg`t tgd
`jhdsters ef tgd Dtrush`js. nold tgd `jhdsters ef tgd @hg`d`js. teel
p`rt oj tgd pest-Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujb <`ji oj tgd prdsumptoej
tg`t tgd perts frem wgohg tgd idshdji`jts ef tgesd enidr Dtrush`j
sd`-r`oidrs `ftdrw`ris sdt s`on te m`ld tgdor fertujds oj tgd wdst n`y
semdwgdrd ej tgd @so`toh he`st ef tgd Ndv`jt oj tgd je-m`j"s-n`ji
adtwddj Brddl Xoid `ji Sgedjoho`j @r`ius* Ygos surprosojb b`poj tgd gosteroh`n rdheri h`j ejny md`j ejd tgojb;
8j`mdny. tg`t tgd
Dtrush`js wge st`ydi `t gemd jdvdr ioi `jytgojb wertg rdheriojb*
Ygd `stejosgojb hejtr`st adtwddj tgd jejdjtoty ef tgd Dtrush`js `t
gemd `ji tgdor dmojdjhd evdrsd`s bovds tgd md`surd eftgd stomunus
wgohg tgdy must g`vd rdhdovdi oj tgd prehdss ef tr`jsm`rojd
henejoz`toej*
Ygd stomun`tojb dffdht ef hressojb tgd sd` os pdrg`ps brd`tdst ef
`nn oj ` tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej wgohg ehhurs oj tgd heursd ef `
Venldrw`jidrujb*Xuhg ehhurrdjhds sddm te ad ujhemmej* Ygd ejny ojst`jhds
wgohg tgd wrotdr ef tgos Xtuiy h`j h`nn te moji `rd tgd mobr`toej ef
tgd Yduhro`js. @deno`js. nejo`js. `ji Iero`js `hress tgd @dbd`j te
tgd wdst he`st ef @j`teno` `ji tgd mobr`toej ef tgd Yduhro`js `ji
Sgonostojds reuji tgd d`stdrj dji ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j te tgd he`st
ef Xyro` oj tgd heursd ef tgd pest-Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujb< tgd
mobr`toej ef tgd @jbnds `ji Kutds `hress tgd Jertg Xd` te Arot`oj oj
tgd heursd ef tgd pest-Gdnndjoh Venldrw`jidrujb <tgd hejsdqudjt
mobr`toej ef tgd Herj`voo `ji etgdr Arotejs `hress tgd Hg`jjdn te
tgd @rmeroh`j Sdjojsun` ef B`un < tgd hejtdmper`ry mobr`toej eftgd Orosg Xhets `hress tgd Jertg Hg`jjdn te tgd herjdr ef Jertg
Arot`oj tg`t os jew h`nndi @rbynn<9 `ji tgd mobr`toejs ef tgd
0 Xdd O* H 'o/ '/. @jjdx OO. oj ven o. `aevd*+ Ygos ndbdji m`y g`vd je adttdr a`sos tg`j tgd jet vdry hnesd rdsdman`jhd adtwddj
twe prepdr j`mds ; Yyrrgdjeo `ji Yerrgdaeo*8 S`hd tgesd meidrj Rdstdrj shgen`rs wge t`ld tgos te md`j tg`t tgd Dtrush`js ef
Ot`ny wdrd dotgdr+
`utehgtgejeus+
Ot`no`js er dnsd ommobr`jts. ay `j evdrn`ji reutd.frem tgd ojtdroer ef tgd Durepd`j Hejtojdjt*
9 Xdd OO* I 'v/. p 0?9. `ji OO* I 'voo/. pp* 818-9. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 398/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 72
Xh`jioj`vo`js oj tgd heursd eftgd Venldrw`jidrujbwgohg fennewdi
tgd `aertovd dveh`toej ef ` bgest ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord ay tgd
H`renojbo`js*0 Ygos Xh`jioj`vo`j Venldrw`jidrujb teel pn`hd
`nmest djtordny ay sd`. `ji tgos oj sdvdr`n iordhtoejs ;
frem Jerw`y`hress tgd Jertg @tn`jtoh te tgd Xgdtn`jis `ji Erljdys `ji tgdjhd
ay w`y ef tgd Gdaroids te Ordn`ji `ji ay w`y ef tgd F`reds te
Ohdn`ji< frem Idjm`rl `hress tgd Jertg Xd` te Djbn`ji< frem
dotgdr Jerw`y er Idjm`rl iewj tgd Djbnosg Hg`jjdn te Jer-
m`jiy< `ji frem Xwdidj `hress tgd A`ntoh te Qusso`*
Ygd Sgonostojd mobr`toej. `s wd g`vd easdrvdi `t `j d`rnodr peojtoj tgos hg`ptdr.
1 h`md te ` st`jistonn oj `j d`sy djvorejmdjt wgohg
preiuhdi`
seperofoh
dffdht
upejtgd
ommobr`jts`ftdr
tgdyg`i
sdttndi iewj<`ji tgos sdqudn weuni `ppd`r te g`vd jdutr`nozdi `jy
stomun`tojb dffdht tg`t m`y g`vd addj preiuhdi ay tgd prdvoeus
sd`-p`ss`bd*8 Ygd Arotosg mobr`toej. noldwosd. `ppd`rs te g`vd
preiuhdi je `pprdho`and stomun`tojb dffdht te kuibd ay tgd r`tgdr
ujiostojbuosgdi suasdqudjt gostery ef tgd Ardtejs `ji tgos oj
spotd ef tgd f`hts tg`t tgd jdw Hejtojdjt`n Arott`jy w`s idhoidiny
` g`ri heujtry. `ji tg`t tgd jdw-hemdrs frem evdrsd`s ioi jet
dst`anosg tgdor feetojb tgdrd wotgeut g`vojb te djheujtdr `ji evdr-
hemd ` hejsoidr`and rdsost`jhd. aetg frem tgd Qem`j Hgurhg `ji
frem tgd Sr`jlosg "suhhdsser-st`td+ ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord*9 Oj tgd
etgdr feur ojst`jhds. gewdvdr tg`t os te s`y. oj tgd tr`jsm`rojd
mobr`toejs ef tgd nejo`js. tgd @jbnds. tgd Xhets. `ji tgd Xh`jio-
j`vo`js wd h`j ioshdrj hdrt`oj strolojb pgdjemdj` wgohg g`vd `j
ojjdr hejjdxoej wotg ejd `jetgdr `ji wgohg `ppd`r oj hejkujh-
toej. oj d`hg ojst`jhd. wotg sojbun`r ujofermoty. wgond tgdy `rd jet
te ad feuji oj tgd f`r merd jumdreus ojst`jhds ef mobr`toej evdr-
n`ji* Hejsoidrojb tg`t tgd feur mobr`toejs oj qudstoej g`vdehhurrdi quotd ojidpdjidjtny ef ejd `jetgdr `t woid ojtdrv`ns ef
tomd `ji pn`hd.4 wd m`y vdjturd. pdrg`ps. te bdjdr`nozd frem tgdm
+ Fer tgd `aertovd Xh`jioj`vo`j Hovonoz`toej. sdd OO I 'voo/. pp* 893-63. adnew* Fer
tgd Xh`jioj`vo`j Gdreoh @bd. eut ef wgohg tgd `aertovd Xh`jioj`vo`j Hovonoz`toej f`ondi
te hemd te aortg. sdd S`rt VOOO. adnew* Fer tgd `aertovd H`renmbo`j bgest ef tgd Qem`j
Dmpord. sdd S`rt W. adnew*+ Xdd pp* 9?-40. `aevd*8 Merdevdr. tgd Sgonostojd mobr`toej w`s ejny m`rotomd oj p`rt Ygd fnetonn` wgohg
slortdi tgd @so`toh he`st w`s `hhemp`jodi ay ` tr`oj ef ex-h`rts oj wgohg tgd wemdj `ji
hgonirdj `ji beeis ef tgd mobr`jt gerid wdrd tr`jspertdi evdrn`ji*
9 Ygd f`onurd ef tgd Ardtejs te iostojbuosg tgdmsdnvds os tgd merd rdm`rl`and wgdjwd hejsoidr tg`t tgdor mobr`toej `hress tgd Hg`jjdn oj tgd pest-Gdnndjoh Venldr-
w`jihrujb os tgd dx`ht `j`nebud ef tgd mobr`toej ef tgd @deg`js `ji nejo`js `hress tgd
@dbd`j oj tgd pest-Moje`j Venlhow`jidrujb* Ygd Hejtojdjt`n Ardtejs. nold tgd @so`toh
@heno`js `ji nejo`js. `rd tgd evdrsd`s idshdji`jts ef rdfubdd rdprdsdjt`tovds ef tgd
`jtdhdidjt hovonoz`toej wge g`vd addj iosneibdi ay tgd ojhemojb a`ra`ro`js* Ygdy `rd
jet tgd evdrsd`s idshdji`jts ef tgd a`ra`ro`js tgdmsdnvds. nold tgd @jbnds `ji tgd
Iero`js* Oj tgd gostery ef tgd @deg`js `ji nejo`js. tgd hemaoj`toej ef tgd stomunus ef
tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej wotg tgd `ssdt ef `j ojgdrotdi hunturd g`s. ef heursd. sgewj otsdnf
p`rtohun`rny petdjts Rotg tgd dxhdptoej ef tgd Djbnosg `ji tgd Xhettosg mobr`toejs. wgohg wdrd hej-
tdmper`ry oj i`td tgeubg bdebr`pgoh`nny osen`tdi frem ejd `jetgdr*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 399/455
77 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
te tgd dxtdjt ef rdb`riojb tgesd pgdjemdj` wgohg `rd hemmej te
`nn feur `s adojb ojgdrdjt fd`turds ef ` Venldrw`jidrujb wgdj tgos
t`lds pn`hd jet oj tgd usu`n f`sgoej evdrn`ji aut oj tgos dxhdptoej`n
f`sgoej evdr tgd w`tdr*Ygd iostojhtovdjdss ef tgdsd pgdjemdj` `ji tgdor ojjdr hej-
jdxoej wotg ejd `jetgdr `rd aetg dxpn`ojdi ay ejd `ji tgd s`md
sompnd f`ht ; Oj tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej. tgd seho`n `pp`r`tus ef tgd
mobr`jts g`s te ad p`hldi ej ae`ri sgop adferd tgdy h`j nd`vd
tgd sgerds ef tgd eni heujtry `ji tgdj ujp`hldi `b`oj `t tgd dji ef
tgd vey`bd adferd tgdy h`jm`ld tgdmsdnvds `tgemd ej jdw breuji*@nn lojis ef `pp`r`tus pdrsejs `ji prepdrty. tdhgjoquds `ji
ojstotutoejs `ji oid`s `rd
dqu`nny suakdht
te tgos n`w*
@jytgojbtg`t h`jjet st`ji tgd sd` vey`bd `t `nn g`s sompny te ad ndft adgoji <
`ji m`jy tgojbs `ji tgdsd jet ejny m`tdro`n eakdhts wgohg tgd
mobr`jts ie m`j`bd te t`ld wotg tgdm h`j ejny ad sgoppdi `ftdr
tgdy g`vd addj t`ldj te podhds jdvdr. pdrg`ps. te ad rd`ssdmandi
oj tgdor eroboj`n ferm*
Ygos n`w bevdrjs `nn tr`jsm`rojd mevdmdjts wg`tsedvdr* Ot g`s
bevdrjdi. fer dx`mpnd. tgd `jhodjt Brddl `ji Sgedjoho`j `ji
Dtrush`j henejoz`toej ef tgd Rdstdrj A`soj ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j
`ji tgd meidrj Durepd`j henejoz`toej ef @mdroh`< `ji tgd hg`n-
ndjbd wgohg. oj vortud ef tgos n`w. os ojgdrdjt oj ` sd`-p`ss`bd`hheujts fer tgd ojtrojsoh stomunus ef hressojb tgd sd` wgohgwd g`vd
easdrvdi `nrd`iy oj tgdsd twe h`sds* Oj tgdsd p`rtohun`r h`sds.
gewdvdr. tgd henejosts g`ppdj te g`vd adnejbdi te sehodtods wgohgwdrd `nrd`iy oj prehdss ef hovonoz`toej `t tgd tomd wgdj tgd sd` w`s
hressdi* Rgdj ` tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej ehhurs oj tgd heursd ef
` Venldrw`jidrujb. tgd hg`nndjbd os muhg merd fermoi`and `ji
tgd stomunus prepertoej`tdny merd ojtdjsd adh`usd tgd omp`ht gdrdf`nns upej ` sehodty wgohg os jet seho`nny prebrdssovd `t tgd tomd autos evdrt`ldj ay tgd hg`nndjbd wgond ot os stonn oj tg`t st`toh hejiotoej
wgohg os tgd n`st st`td ef Sromotovd M`j* 0 Ygd tr`jsotoej. oj tgd
Venldrw`jidrujb. frem tgos p`ssovoty te ` suiidj p`rexysm ef
sterm `ji strdss preiuhds ` iyj`moh dffdht upej tgd nofd ef `jyhemmujoty wgohg ujidrbeds tgd dxpdrodjhd<
1 aut tgos dffdht os
j`tur`nny merd ojtdjsd wgdj tgd mobr`jts t`ld sgop tg`j wgdj tgdy+
lddp tgdor fddt ej senoi breuji tgreubgeut tgdor trdl* Ygd irovdref `j ex-h`rt g`s ` brd`tdr hemm`ji tg`j tgd m`stdr ef ` sgop evdrtgd horhumst`jhds ef gos keurjdy* Gd h`j m`ojt`oj `j ujareldj
0 Fer tgd _m-st`td oj wgohg wd foji Sromotovd M`j `s wd ljew gom. sdd Y H 'm/ 'd/.ven* o. pp 02?-73. `ji OO* A. ven* o. pp* 0?1-4* Oj dssdjto`ns. dvdry sehodty wgohg t`ldsp`rt m ` Vpnldrw`jidoujb os stonn m tg`t st`toh hejiotoej dvdj tgeubg. dx gypetgdsoot g`s addj orr`io`tdi ay hdrt`oj dndmdjts ef tgd hovonoz`toej ojte wgesd `maot ot g`s addj`ttr`htdi `ji oj wgesd "dxtdrj`n prendt`ro`t" ot g`s addj djrenndi `ji wgesd fermdriem`oj ot os jew ojv`iojb* 'Xdd S`rt OO* @. ven* o. pp* 072-7. `aevd. `ji S`rt VOOOadnew
-/ 1 Xdd furtgdr S`rt VOOO. adnew*"
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 400/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI 7?
hejt`ht wotg gos a`sd ef epdr`toejs <gd h`j pothg h`mp `ji strold
h`mp wgdrd `ji wgdj gd hgeesds< gd h`j sdt gos ewj p`hd< `ji
oj tgdsd horhumst`jhds gd h`j h`rry wotg gom muhg ef tgd seho`n
`pp`r`tus wgohg g`s te ad iosh`ridi ay gos sd`f`rojb hemr`id*Ygus wd h`j md`surd tgd stomun`tojb dffdht ef tr`jsm`rojd mobr`-toej oj tgd heursd ef ` Venldrw`jidrujb ay hemp`rojb tgd pgdje-mdj` wotg tgd dffdht ef mobr`toej evdrn`ji. `ji `fertoero wotg tgd
dffdht ef st`yojb `t gemd `ji ndttojb tgd p`rexysm p`ss wotgeut
adojb mevdi te fennew dotgdr tgd sw`j-p`tg er tgd h`rt-tr`hl*
+
Rgdj tgd Xh`jioj`vo`js wdjt adyeji tgd sd`. tgdor mobr`toej md`jt
merd tg`j ` hg`jbd ef pn`hd* @t gemd. tgd Rerni. n`rbd `s ot w`s. heuni
adsurvdydi
frem tgd gemdstd`i wotg tgddyds
ef tgd moji<
aut.`s ejd
gerozej aurst ej tgd vodw `ji `jetgdr hnesdi oj *** tgd `jhodjt Moiind-
b`rtg nest ots idfojotdjdss `ji m`id w`y fer semdtgojb merd `loj te eur
Tjovdrsd* Ygos hg`jbd ef eutneel b`vd aortg te ` jdw hejhdptoej ef beis`ji mdj* Ygd neh`n idotods wgesd pewdr w`s hedxtdjsovd wotg tgd
tdrrotery ef tgdor wersgoppdrs wdrd rdpn`hdi ay ` herper`td aeiy ef beis
runojb tgd Rerni* Ygd geny pn`hd wotg ots anet-geusd wgohg g`i fermdi
tgd hdjtrd ef Moiindb`rtg w`s r`osdi ej gobg `ji turjdi ojte ` iovojd
m`jsoej* Yomd-gejeurdi mytgs sdttojb fertg tgd ieojbs ef mutu`nny
ojidpdjidjtidotods wdrd werldi
upojte `
pedtoh`n mytgeneby.` iovojd
s`b`. ej tgd s`md nojds tg`t g`i addj fennewdi ay `j d`rnodr r`hd ef
Volojbs. tgd Gemdroh Brddls* Ygos rdnoboej areubgt ` jdw bei te aortg ;
Eioj. tgd nd`idr ef mdj. tgd neri ef tgd a`ttndfodni*"0
Oj semdwg`t somon`r f`sgoej. tgd evdrsd`s mobr`toej ef tgd Xhets
frem Ordn`ji te Jertg Arot`oj prdp`rdi tgd w`y fer tgd djtry ef
` jdw rdnoboej* Ot os je `hhoidjt tg`t tgd tr`jsm`rojd I`nro`i`
adh`md tgd gd`i-qu`rtdrs ef Xt* Henuma`"s mossoej`ry mevdmdjt
wgohg jet ejny `hgodvdi tgd hejvdrsoej ef tgd Sohts `ji tgd
Jertgumaro`js aut `nse dxdrhosdi ` prefeuji rdtre`htovd ojfnudjhd
upej Hgrosto`joty oj Ordn`ji otsdnf tgreubg tgd F`mono` Henuma`d ;
` hnustdr ef fdidr`tdi mej`stdrods. mestny sotu`tdi ej Orosg seon.
wgohg `nn rdhebjozdi tgd suprdm`hy ef nej`*1
Ejd iostojhtovd pgdjemdjej ef tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej os tgd
ojtdrmojbnojb `ji ojtdrarddiojb ef iovdrsd r`ho`n str`ojs< fer tgd
forst podhd ef seho`n `pp`r`tus tg`t g`s te ad `a`jiejdi os tgd promo-
tovd troad er gerid* Je sgop wonn geni merd tg`j ejd sgop"s
hemp`jy. `ji tgd promotovd sgop os sm`nn* @t tgd s`md tomd. tgd
promotovd sgop os rdn`tovdny meaond hemp`rdi wotg tgd ex-h`rt er
etgdr promotovd md`js ef tr`jspert ej n`ji* Merdevdr. oj tr`js-
m`rojd mobr`toej. je ndss tg`j oj evdrn`ji mobr`toej. tgdrd os
s`fdty oj jumadrs* Fer tgdsd rd`sejs. ` jdw hemmujoty feujidi
0 Brajadhg. V* ; Ygd Hunturd ef tgd Ydutejs 'Nejiej 0?80. Monferi. 8 p`rts oj 1 vens*/.
ort OO. pp* 836-2*` Fer tgd F`mono` Henuma`d. sdd furtgdr OO* I 'vj/. p* 814. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 401/455
?3 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
ay mobr`jts `hress tgd sd` os `pt te ad dst`anosgdi ay tgd hejhdrtdi
dfferts ef ` jumadr ef hrdws wgohg g`vd keojdi ferhds frem ioffdrdjt
qu`rtdrs oj hejtr`st te tgd erioj`ry prehdss ef mobr`toej evdrn`ji.
oj wgohg ` wgend troad os `pt te p`hl ots wemdj `ji hgonirdj `jisddi-herj `ji geusdgeni beis `ji geusdgeni utdjsons ojte ots ex-
h`rts `ji mevd eff dj m`ssd. `t ` feet"s p`hd. evdr tgd f`hd ef tgd
D`rtg* Rd h`thg ` bnompsd ef tgos pgdjemdjej ef m`rotomd r`hd-
moxturd oj tgd feuji`toej-ndbdjis ef Gdnndjoh @denos `ji Oejo`
wg`tdvdr tgdsd ndbdjis m`y ad wertg oj tgd ferm oj wgohg tgdy
g`vd addj tr`jsmottdi ay Gdreietus `ji S`us`jo`s* Oj `nmest
dvdry Brddl hoty-st`td `nejb tgd wdst he`st ef @j`teno`. tgd n`ttdr-
i`yojg`aot`jts tr`hdi tgdor
`jhdstrya`hl te merd
pn`hds
tg`j ejd
oj tgd Durepd`j Brddl pdjojsun` jet te spd`l ef tgd str`ojs
ojtreiuhdi ay ojtdrm`rro`bd wotg tgd j`tovd wemdj wgem tgd
poejddrs teel h`ptovd* Rd `rd ej surdr breuji wgdj wd turj frem
tgd h`sd ef Oejo` te tg`t ef Ohdn`ji. wgdrd `j dx`ht `ji idt`ondi er`n
rdheri survovdi te ad pdrpdtu`tdi oj tgd N`jij`m`ael*
"@mejb tgd pdhuno`rny f`veur`and hejiotoejs fer mdjt`n idvdnepmdjtoj Ohdn`ji. tgd mest ompert`jt w`s tgd sdndhtoej ef tgd gum`j stehl tg`t
sdttndi tgd osn`ji* Ot ojhnuidi `nn tgesd f`monods ef pdtty lojbs `ji
pd`s`jt hgodft`ojs frem Rdstdrj Jerw`y wge rdfusdi te yodni te tgd
`utehr`toh rund ef G`reni F`org`or. prdfdrrojb te sddl ` jdw gemd ej tgd
iost`jt osn`ji wgohg g`i rdhdjtny addj ioshevdrdi* @t tgd s`md tomd ot
w`s ompessoand fer tgd sehodty ef Ohdn`ji te adhemd ` mdrd rdpdtotoej ef
tgd eni Jerwdbo`j hemmujoty< tgd r`ho`n moxturd w`s tee prejeujhdifer tg`t* Ygdrd h`md Jerwdbo`js frem v`roeus p`rts ef tgd heujtry.
str`bbndrs frem Xwdidj. volojbs frem tgd Rdst. ojhnuiojb dvdj semd
sdmo-Hdntoh dndmdjts*"0
Ygos iostojhtovd pgdjemdjej ef ujusu`nny f`r-beojb r`ho`n mox-turd os hnesdny hejjdhtdi wotg `jetgdr; tgd ujusu`nny r`poi ios-
ojtdbr`toej ef tgd loj-breup wgohg os tgd a`sos ef seho`n erb`joz`toej
oj ` promotovd sehodty* Ygd hemp`r`tovd dffoh`hy ef tr`jsm`rojd
mobr`toej `ji ef evdrn`ji mobr`toej `s senvdjts ef tgd loj-breup os
`ppr`osdi `s fennews. `t tgd hejhnusoej ef `j dxg`ustovd ojquory. ay` iostojbuosgdi meidrj stuidjt ef Xh`jioj`vo`j `jtoquotods ;
"Ygd `j`neby ef tgd Ohdn`jioh sdttndrs wonn ojhnojd us te `hhdpt tgd oid`
tg`t `mobr`toej ojvenvojb tr`jspert ay
sd`
w`s dspdho`nnyno`and te
omp`ortgd sdjsd ef loj-senoi`roty `mejb tgesd wge vdjturd ej ot. tgeubg tgd
erb`joz`toej ef tgesd wge rdm`ojdi adgoji mobgt jet ad `pprdho`any`ffdhtdi* Ot os dxtrdmdny ujnoldny tg`t d`hg breup ef lojirdi weuni auoni
` vdssdn `ji m`j ot dxhnusovdny. er dvdj m`ojny. wotg tgdor ewj lojsmdj<
ej tgd hejtr`ry. `nn `j`nebods sgew us tg`t `jy ojiovoiu`ns wosgojb te
keoj`j dxpdiotoej weuni r`nny te tgd forst sgop tg`t w`s s`onojb `ji
0Enrol. @*; Volojb Hovonos`toej 'Djbnosg tr`jsn`toej- Nejiej 0?83. @nndj `ji Tjwoj/.
pp. 024-6* Hp* p* 001*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 402/455
YGD XYOMTNTX0EF JDR BQETJI ?0
prea`any rdm`oj pdrm`jdjtny `sseho`tdi wotg ots hrdw oj tgd jdw
heujtry9@ hn`ssoh dx`mpnd os `fferidi ay tgd sejs ef D`rn Grenn`ub ef Jerw`y.
ejd ef wgem. Bejbu-Grenf. os idhn`rdi ay Xjerro te g`vd feujidi tgd
Iuhgy ef Jerm`jiy< ejd nest gos nofd oj tgd Rdstdrj Osnds ef Xhetn`ji
ej `j dxpdiotoej wotg G`r`ni G`orf`or< `jetgdr adh`md D`rn ef tgd
Erljdys. wgond ydt `jetgdr sdttndi oj Ohdn`ji* Ot sddms merd tg`j
prea`and tg`t tgd pdepnds ef Xhgndswob-Genstdoj novdi ujidr somon`r
hejiotoejs oj tgd 4tg hdjtury. wotg volojb dxpdiotoejs. `ji foj`nny tgd
pdrm`jdjt hejqudst ef Djbn`ji. `s tgd rdsunt* Ygd sdttndrs oj Djbn`ji
mobgt tgdrdferd ad `nmest `s n`hlojb oj funn lojirdis `s tgd sdttndrs oj
Ohdn`ji ` fdw hdjturods n`tdr* Adferd wd m`ld hdrt`oj tg`t tgd ojv`idrs
must g`vd hemd evdr dj m`ssd. oj funn lojirdis. oj eridr te `hgodvd suhg
` v`st rdsunt `s tgd hejqudst ef Djbn`ji. wd sg`nn ie wdnn te rdmoji
eursdnvds tg`t tgd fd`t w`s `nn aut p`r`nndndi. oj ` muhg sgertdr tomd `ji
oj tgd tddtg ef ` rdsost`jhd `t nd`st dqu`nny eastoj`td. ay tgd volojbs ef `
n`tdr pdroei< ydt tg`t je ejd tgojls ot jdhdss`ry te `ssumd ` wgends`nd
dmobr`toej ef lojirdis oj tgos h`sd. er te pestun`td tg`t tgd erb`joz`toej
ef tgd Volojbs. wgdj tgdy `rrovdi oj Djbn`ji. w`s ej ` a`sos ef lojirdis*
"Of wd `rd te `iept tgd I`josg tgdery tg`t tgd Jerm`js `rd m`ojny ef
I`josg `ji jet Jerwdbo`j eroboj. wd h`j peojt te Jerm`jiy `nse `s
`fferiojb herreaer`tovd dvoidjhd fer tgd iosojtdbr`tojb ojfnudjhd ej tgd
lojirdi ef ` sdttndmdjt ay sd`* @hheriojb te tgos tgdery tgd ojv`idrs ef
Jerm`jiy h`md frem tgd gobgny hegdsovd lojirdis ef Idjm`rl* _dt
tgd tr`hds ef lojsgop-senoi`roty oj tgortddjtg-hdjtury Jerm`jiy `rd f`r
f`ojtdr tg`j oj etgdr iostrohts ef Jertgdrj Fr`jhd. wgohg tgd Ydutejs
rd`hgdi ay n`ji*
"Xe f`r `s ot beds. tee. tgd dvoidjhd `v`on`and fer tgd d`stdrjmest `ji
wdstdrjmest ef Ydutejoh sdttndmdjts ad`rs eut eur hejtdjtoej* Ygd
n`ws ef tgd Xwdiosg lojbiem oj Qusso`. wej ay j`v`n dxpdiotoejs. sgew
aut ` fddand hejhdptoej ef lojsgop; tgd sn`ydr `nejd p`ys fer gos iddi.
`ji tgd robgt ef vdjbd`jhd os nomotdi te aretgdr. f`tgdr. sej `ji jdpgdw*
Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. Rdst Betgoh hustum`ns oj Xp`oj sgew iovosoej ef
wdrboni adtwddj lojsmdj. idfojotdny erb`jozdi aneei-fduis adtwddj
lojirdis. `ji e`tg-gdnpdrs ef tgd lojirdi Ygd Rdst Betgs tr`vdnndi
` nejb w`y. aut tgdy tr`vdnndi ay n`ji*
"Ygus wd `rd irovdj te tgd hejhnusoej tg`t tgd m`oj iosojtdbr`tojb
f`hter oj tgd h`sd ef tgd Ydutejoh lojirdis w`s mobr`toej. `ji dspdho`nny
mobr`toej ay sd`* Idjm`rl `ji Xhgndswob `rd tgd strejbgenis ef tgd
lojirdis; tgesd ef Frodsn`ji. tgd Jdtgdrn`jis `ji Jertgdrj Fr`jhd
g`i vot`noty djeubg te wotgst`ji hdjturods ef gobgny `ivdrsd ojfnudjhds.
wgdrd`s tgd Ohdn`jidr steei `nejd frem tgd memdjt gd sdt feet ej
Ohdn`jioh seon< `ji ot m`y ad qudstoejdi wgdtgdr tgd @jbne-X`xej
sdttndr w`s oj muhg adttdr h`sd oj tgos rdspdht* Gdrd. tee. wd sgeuni foji
`j dxpn`j`toej ef tgd wd`ljdss ef tgd lojirdis oj Jerw`y. fer muhg ef
tgd sdttndmdjt ef tg`t heujtry must g`vd addj `hhempnosgdi ay sd`. `ji
`t ` vdry n`td pdroei*+0
oSgonnpetts. A* X* ; Lojirdi `ji Hn`j 'H`maroibd 0?08. Tjovdrsoty Srdss/. pp. 142-64*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 403/455
?1 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
@jetgdr iostojhtovd pgdjemdjej ef tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej os tgd
`trepgy ef ` promotovd ojstotutoej wgohg os pdrg`ps tgd suprdmd
dxprdssoej ef ujioffdrdjto`tdi seho`n nofd adferd tgos os rdfr`htdi.
ay ` hn`rofyojb seho`n hejshoeusjdss. ej te tgd sdp`r`td pn`jdsef
dhejemohs `ji penotohs `ji rdnoboej `ji `rt ; tgd ojstotutoej ef tgd
w`vre) X`tkothev`ji gos hyhnd*
0 Ej tgos peojt wd m`y quetd `jetgdr
werl ay tgd s`md `utgeroty ;
"Oj Ohdn`ji tgd M`y I`y b`md. tgd rotu`n wdiiojb. `ji tgd weeojb
shdjd sddm g`riny te g`vd survovdi tgd sdttndmdjt. p`rtny. je ieuat.
adh`usd tgd sdttndrs wdrd m`ojny ef ` tr`vdnndi `ji djnobgtdjdi hn`ss. `ji
p`rtny adh`usd tgdsd rur`n easdrv`jhds `rd hejjdhtdi wotg `brohunturd.
wgohg heuni jet ad `j ompert`jt ar`jhg ef `htovoty oj Ohdn`ji*"1
Of wd wosg te sdd tgd rotu`n ef tgd dvo`ures X`f`hw oj ots bnery oj
tgd Xh`jioj`vo`j Rerni. wd must stuiy ots idvdnepmdjt `mejbXh`jioj`vo`j pdepnds wge ioi jet nd`vd tgdor gemds ;
"Ot sddms tg`t `t Ndkrd `ji X`ng`ub`r oj Xk`dnn`ji. `t Tps`n` oj
Xwdidj. `ji pessoany `t tgd eni Xlorojbss`n oj Xeutg Jerw`y. tgd
fdrtonoty-ir`m` w`s prdsdjtdi oj `jhodjt s`jhtu`rods hejsdhr`tdi ay tgd
temas ef lojbs er beis* Ygdrd os semd rd`sej fer adnodvojb tg`t ot w`s
tgd hdjtr`n rotd ef ` rdnoboeus hejfdidr`hy* Ygos ir`m` w`s `pp`rdjtny
pdrfermdi ejny ejhd dvdry jojd yd`rs. ay `hters ef rey`n aortg. `ji tgdrd
w`s ` tr`iotoej ef `j `htu`n sn`yojb* Xuhg st`tdny ir`m` `s tgos w`s
aeuji ay ommdmero`n tr`iotoej te ejd neh`noty* Ygd s`jhtu`ry. tgd
beiidss. tgd prodst-lojb8 heuni jet mobr`td wotg tgd mdmadrs ef tgd
hejfdidr`td troads* Ygdrd os tgdrdferd je tr`hd ef wg`t wd m`y h`nn
notdr`ry ir`m`. er ef suhg gobgny idvdnepdi tr`boh ir`m`. eutsoid
Xeutgdrj Xh`jioj`vo`. wgdrd Ydutejoh pdepnds g`i addj sdttndi fer
sdvdr`n tgeus`ji yd`rs*"9
Ygd tgdsos ef tgd werl frem wgohg tgdsd twe n`st
p`ss`bds`rd
quetdi os tg`t tgd Xh`jioj`vo`j pedms wgohg g`vd addj prdsdrvdi
ay Ohdn`jioh tr`iotoej `ji hemmottdi te wrotojb oj tgd Ohdn`jioh
hempon`toej h`nndi tgd Dnidr Dii` `rd idrovdi frem tgd speldjweris ef tgd promotovd Xh`jioj`vo`j fdrtonoty-ir`m` tgd ejnydndmdjt oj tgd tr`iotoej`n rotu`n wgohg tgd mobr`jts wdrd `and te
hut `w`y frem ots iddpny-dmadiidi neh`n reets `ji te t`ld ej
ae`ri sgop wotg tgdm* @hheriojb te tgos tgdery. tgd idvdnepmdjtef ` promotovd rotu`n ojte ` Xh`jioj`vo`j ir`m` w`s `rrdstdi `mejb
0 Xdd S`rt OO* A. ven* o. p* 07?* Ygd ujioffdrdjto`tdi ujoty ef @rt `ji Qdnoboej `jiNofd otsdnf oj ` promotovd gum`j sehodty os peojtdi eut. `prepes ef tgd Xh`jioj`vo`j h`sd.
ay Brejadhg. V*; Ygd Hunturd ef tgd Ydutejs 'Nejiej 0?80. Monferi. 8 p`rts oj 1 vens*/.S`rt OO. pp* 18?-90 `ji 16?*
1Sgonnpetts. A* X*; Ygd Dnidr Dii` `ji @jhodjt Xh`jioj`vo`j Ir`m` 'H`maroibd
0?13. Tjovdrsoty Srdss/. p* 139* Ej tgd s`md suakdht. sdd furtgdr Brajadhg. V* ; Ygd
tgd mobr`toejs ef tgd Fr`jls ioi jet n`st nejb `ji `ffdhtdi tgdor hustems vdry nottnd*"
9Sgonnpetts. ep* hot*. p* 132*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 404/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI ?8
tgesd Xh`jioj`vo`js wge mobr`tdi `hress tgd sd`<`ji tgd tgdery os
suppertdi ay `j `j`neby frem Gdnndjoh gostery* Fer ot os ` wdnn-
dst`anosgdi f`ht tg`t. `ntgeubg tgd Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej h`md te
fnewdr oj tr`jsm`rojd Oejo` forst. tgd Gdnndjoh ir`m`. wgohg w`s
"
ejd ef tgd gobgdst hrd`toejs ef Gdnndjoh hunturd. spr`jb frem tgd
hejtojdjt`n seon ef tgd Durepd`j Brddl pdjojsun`* Ygd heujtdr-
p`rt. oj Gdnn`s. ef tgd s`jhtu`ry `t Tps`n` w`s tgd tgd`trd ef
Ioejysus `t @tgdjs* Jdotgdr Oejo` jer Ohdn`ji heuni sgew tgd nold*
Ygd iostojhtovd pgdjemdj` ef tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej wgohg wdg`vd jetohdi se f`r `rd `nn jdb`tovd <
aut tgd hg`nndjbd ompnohot oj
tgdsd jdb`tovd pgdjemdj` g`s dveldi ` rdm`rl`and pesotovd rd-
spejsdwgohg must jew
djb`bdeur `ttdjtoej*
@t `j d`rnodr peojt oj tgos Xtuiy wd g`vd feuji rd`sej te adnodvd
tg`t r`hd-moxturd. ay sdttojb up ` pgysoh`n iostura`jhd. `imojostdrs
` stomunus te tgd psyhgd wgohg os hejiuhovd te tgd bdjdsos ef ` -
hovonoz`toej se muhg se. tg`t tgd bdjdsds ef hovonoz`toejs m`y`htu`nny prevd te rdquord hejtroautoejs frem merd r`hds tg`j ejd* 0 "
Ygos ojiordht pgysoh`n stomunus m`y ad `ssumdi te rdojferhd tgd
iordht psyhgoh stomunus wgohg os `imojostdrdi ay "` sd` hg`jbd+ <
`ji tgd twe f`hters oj hemaoj`toej sg`ttdr tgd "h`ld ef hustem"
oj wgohg promotovd sehodtods. `s wd ljew tgdm. `rd f`st aeuji*1 +-
Ygdrdupej. oj nejb-omprosejdi `ji suiidjny noadr`tdi seuns tgdrd
dmdrbds ` ruiomdjt`ry seho`n hejshoeusjdss wgohg rdvd`ns otsdnf oj
twe hnesdny hejjdhtdi ferms; `j `w`rdjdss ef strejb ojiovoiu`n -
pdrsej`notods `ji `j `w`rdjdss ef memdjteus puanoh dvdjts* Ygd
horhumst`jhds `ji sporotef tgos mdjt`n `w`ldjojb `rd ferhoany hej-
vdydi oj tgd fennewojb idshroptoej ef ot. `s ot h`md te p`ss oj
Ohdn`ji. frem tgd pdj ef ejd ef tgd tgrdd meidrj Rdstdrj shgen`rs
wgem wd g`vd quetdi `nrd`iy*
"Ygd n`rbdst p`rt ef tgd pepun`toej h`md frem tgd iostrohts ef Geri`-
n`ji `ji Qeb`n`ji oj Rdstdrj Jerw`y. \`ji] ot w`s tgdsd rdboejs tg`t
g`i hejtroautdi mest te tgd brd`t Volojb @bd `ji tgd pdroei ef ios-
hevdrods* M`jy f`monods g`i spdjt yd`rs oj tgd wdstdrj henejods* Ygdyg`i `hquordi ` woid gerozej `ji `j ojsobgt ojte penotoh`n hejiotoejs oj
jd`r `ji iost`jt pn`hds< fer `nn tgdsd sh`ttdrdi g`aot`toejs wdrd hnesdny
hejjdhtdi wotg d`hg etgdr ay f`mony tods `ji hemmej djtdrprosds* Ygd
jumdreus mdrhg`jt-sgops hejst`jtny areubgt jdws. wgohg w`s rdhdovdi.
shrutojosdi `ji kuibdi* Ygd dxpdrodjhds ef hejtdmper`rods j`tur`nny
adh`md tr`jsfermdi ojte s`b`s*
"Ygdsd `rostehr`toh `ji t`ndjtdi pdrsejs sdttndi oj Ohdn`ji ujidr merd
sdvdrd hejiotoejs ef nofd tg`j tgdy g`i fermdrny ljewj* Ojstd`i ef adojb
` pdtty lojb. tgd pd`s`jt g`i `t mest ` vdry nomotdi hgodft`oj `utgeroty
`s tgsbeio 's`hrofoho`n prodst `ji tgojb nd`idr/ ef gos iostroht< m`jy ` m`j
+ Xdd OO* H 'oo/ '`/ o. ven* o. pp* 18?-198. `ji OO* H 'oo/ '6/ o. ven* o. p* 127. `aevd*+
1 Fer tgos "h`ld ef hustem" sdd S`rt OO* A. ven* o. p* 0?1. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 405/455
?9 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
ef jeand eroboj g`i te sdttnd `s ` pd`s`jt oj tgd beieri 'beio iostroht/ ef
`jetgdr m`j* Ojstd`i ef preui r`ftdrdi g`nns. tgdy auont geusds wotg
w`nns ef d`rtg sdvdr`n y`ris tgohl. ` hejtojueus rew er breup ef suhg
geusds hejstotutojb tgd f`rm auoniojbs* H`ttnd-arddiojb. aori-gujtojb.
fosgojb rdquordi `j dxtrdmd idbrdd ef `ttdjtoej of tgdy wdrd te yodni
feeistuffs fer `nn tgd geusdh`rns `ji sdrv`jts< ` m`j wge ejhd g`i
tr`idi oj tgd mest prdhoeus hemmeiotods ef ferdobj heujtrods g`i jew
ejny tgd gemd-wevdj frodzd te dxpert* Ygd dxtdrj`n horhumst`jhds ef
nofd wdrd j`rrewojb iewj* Ygd ejny d`rm`rl ef jeaonoty tg`t w`s stonn
rdt`ojdi frem tgd ferdf`tgdrs w`s tgd mdjt`n hunturd. tgd `aonoty te p`ss oj
rdvodw ` suhhdssoej ef dvdjts. te ferm ` kuiohoeus dstom`td ef sotu`toejs*"0
Oj tgd strdjueus `ji stomun`tojb mdjt`n `tmespgdrd gdrd idshroadi.
tgd veoi rdsuntojb frem tgd `asdjhd eftgd promotovd seho`n `pp`r`tustg`t g`s addj ndft adgoji oj hressojb tgd sd` os fonndi ay jdw `hts ef
seho`n hrd`toej* Ygd djdrbods rdnd`sdi ay tgd ard`lojb ef tgd "h`ld
ef hustem" hryst`nnozd. oj tgd jdw tr`jsm`rojd djvorejmdjt. ojte
jdw `htovotods wgohg `rd idfojotd oj tgdor ferms `ji `rd nomotdi oj
tgdor shepd. oj d`hg h`sd. te semd sojbnd pn`jd ef seho`n nofd* Oj tgd
fodni ndft hnd`r ay tgd `trepgy ef tgd fdrtonoty-rotu`n tgdrd `rosds `
j`rr`tovd ferm ef notdr`ry `rt; tgd X`b` er tgd Dpoh* Oj tgd fodni
ndft hnd`r ay tgd iosojtdbr`toejef
tgd loj-breuptgdrd `rosds `
penoty oj tgd noldjdss ef ` sgop"s hemp`jy ej `j djn`rbdi sh`nd `ji
ej ` pdrm`jdjt a`sos; ` hemmejwd`ntg oj wgohg tgd aojiojb
dndmdjt os jet hemmujoty ef aneei aut tg`t hemmej eadiodjhd te
` frddny hgesdj nd`idr `ji hemmej rdspdht fer ` frddny `hhdptdi
n`w wgohg g`s addj h`nndi "tgd seho`n hejtr`ht" oj tgd fobur`tovd
n`jbu`bd ef eur meidrj Rdstdrj Senotoh`n Mytgeneby*
Ygd X`b` `ji tgd Dpoh aetg `nold `rosd oj rdspejsd te tgd s`md
jdw mdjt`n jddi* Oj aetg. tgd jdw `w`rdjdss ef strejb ojiovoiu`n
pdrsej`notods `ji ef memdjteus puanoh dvdjts. wgohg tgd sterm
`ji strdss ef tgd Venldrw`jidrujb g`s areubgt ojte hejshoeusjdss.
fojis `j dxprdssoej tgreubg `rt*1
+Ygd Ohdn`jioh X`b` * * * brdw eut ef rdperts ef hejtdmper`ry g`ppdj-
ojbs* @ m`j wge g`i rdhdjtny rdturjdi gemd weuni sot `t tgd @ntgojb
0Enrol. ep* hot
. pp* 026-21 Ygd ioffdrdjhd adtwddj tgd X`b` `ji tgd Dpoh nods jet oj tgd j`turd eftgd stomunus
ay wgohg tgdy `rd dveldi jer oj tgd j`turd ef tgd ojtdrdsts `ji fddnojbs `ji oid`s wgohg`rd dxprdssdi oj tgdm. aut mdrdny oj tgd mdtgei `ji eroboj eftgdor rdspdhtovd tdhgjoquds*
Oj tgd Ohdn`jioh X`b`. tgd jdw ojtdrdst oj pdrsej`notods `ji dvdjts fojis dxprdssoej oj `tdhgjoqud wgohg os jdw noldwosd* Ygd ferm `ji m`ttdr ef tgd io`nebuds `ji senonequodstg`t brdw eut ef tgd hejtojdjt`n Xh`jioj`vo`j fdrtonoty-rotu`n `rd rdnoboeusny prdsdrvdi oj
tgd Dnidr Dii`< aut. g`vojb ejhd addj terj `w`y frem tgdor reets oj Enidr te gd tr`js-
pertdi `hress tgd sd`. tgdy `rd jet put te jdw usds oj tgd jdw heujtry jer idvdnepdi `jyfurtgdr* Ygdy `rd prdsdrvdi. `s ot wdrd. `s fessons< `ji wgdj tgd Ohdn`jidrs f`sgoej "tgd
X`b`. tgd trud Ohdn`jioh heujtdrp`rt ef tgd Dpoh. eut eftgd sterods hurrdjt oj tgd heujtry-soid". tgdy hrd`td. te hejvdy ot. "` jdw presd ferm+ oj wgohg tgdy `rd "g`mpdrdi ay jefessonosdi tr`iotoej+ 'Sgonnpetts- Ygd Dnidr Dii`. p 134/* Ygd s`b`s ejny ojiordhtnyrdvd`n tgd dxostdjhd ef `j enidr ir`m`toh tdhgjoqud oj ` hdrt`oj ir`m`toh sdjsd `jiir`m`toh idt`hgmdjt wgohg `rd hg`r`htdrostoh ef tgdor stynd 'ep* hot.. neh* hot*/ Ej tgdetgdr g`ji. tgd m`ldrs ef tgd Dpoh oj Oejo` er oj Djbn`ji senvd tgd s`md preandm ef
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 406/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI ?4
`ji tdnn gos stery ` hejjdhtdi `hheujt ef `nn tg`t g`i t`ldj pn`hd
iurojb tgd yd`r `t wdnn-ljewj shdjds ef `htoej Srea`any m`jy ` s`b`
eroboj`tdi oj tgos w`y* Ygd stery w`s rdn`tdi te `j `ttdjtovdny nostdjojb
horhnd ef gd`rdrs ay ejd wge g`i gomsdnf addj t`lojb p`rt oj tgd dvdjts<
`ji wgond tgd forst shdjd os adojb tgus rdpertdi. Nofd otsdnf hejtojuds tgd
idstojods ef tgd `htojb pdrsejs*"0
Ygus. ejd i`y `t tgd @ntgojb. Ygermei nostdjs te ` s`b` tg`t os
adojb teni ay Ygerbrom `ji sn`ys tgd tdnndr `ftdr tgd t`nd os iejd
adh`usd `j ojhoidjt oj tgd stery g`s addj tgd sn`yojb. ay Ygerbrom
gomsdnf. ef Ygermei"s ewj festdr-aretgdr*1 Ygus. noldwosd. iurojbtgd sodbd ef Yrey. wgdj @hgonnds os sunlojb oj gos tdjt. gd os tgdrd
feuji djtdrt`ojojb gomsdnf ay sojbojb +tgd t`nds ef w`rroers"8 suhg
t`nds `s "tgd wr`tg ef @hgonnds" otsdnf os idstojdi te adhemd oj tgd
meutgs ef Gemdroh mojstrdns* @nrd`iy. oj tgd tdjtg yd`r `ftdr tgd
f`nn ef Yrey. tgd t`nds ef tgd sodbd `ji ef tgd vohters" gemdw`ri
vey`bds `rd dvdr oj tgd meutgs ef tgd mojstrdn Sgdmous oj Otg`h`
`ji tgd mojstrdn Idmeiehus oj tgd n`ji ef tgd Sg`d`ho`js*9
"Yg`t n`y os pr`osdi ef mdj tgd mest wgohg rojbdtg jdwdst oj
tgdor d`rs*"4 _dt tgdrd os ejd tgojb oj `j dpoh n`y tg`t os stonn merd
gobgny prozdi tg`j ots jevdnty ay tgd gd`rdrs. `ji tg`t os tgd
ojtrojsoh gum`j ojtdrdst ef tgd stery* Ygd ojtdrdst oj tgd prdsdjt
prdiemoj`tds kust se nejb `s tgd sterm `ji strdss ef tgd Gdreoh @bd
hejtojuds< aut tgos seho`n p`rexysm os dssdjto`nny tr`jsotery< `ji.
fojiojb `j `rtostoh dxprdssoej fer tgd jdw ojtdrdst oj pdrsej`notods `ji dvdjts ay "m`lojbevdr+ aetg tgd ferm `ji tgd m`ttdr ef tgd hejtojdjt`n fdrtonoty-rotu`n te fot tgd jdwidm`ji* Ygus. oj tgd Brddl `ji Djbnosg Dpoh wd foji tgd t`nd ef Yrey"s f`nn er @hgonnds"
wr`tg er Eiyssdus" w`jidrojbs er Adewunf"s dxpneots br`ftdi ej te mytgs oj wgohg tgd
stuff ef promotovd rotu`n g`s addj rdsg`pdi `ji prekdhtdi ojte gdreoh j`rr`tovd* Ygd
`m`nb`m`toej ef tgdsd twe dndmdjts oj tgd Dpoh os se tgereubg. `ji tgd `rtostoh pdrfdhtoej
ef tgd fojosgdi preiuht os se hempndtd. tg`t ot jddis `nn tgd p`r`pgdrj`no` ef "tgd GobgdrHrotohosm" te
`j`nysdtgd
prehdsswgohg g`s t`ldj pn`hd* Jdvdotgdndss. suhg `j`nysos
rdvd`ns jet ejny tgd prdsdjhd ef tgdsd twe ejhd sdp`r`td dndmdjts oj tgd Dpoh aut `nse
tgd dxtrdmd iovdrsoty ef tgdor j`turd `ji eroboj* Ygd Dpoh. ujnold tgd X`b`. g`s ` rotu`n
reet. `ji ot sg`rds tgos reet wotg tgd Ir`m`* Ygd hejtojdjt`n Oejoh Ir`m` ef @ttoh` `ji
tgd tr`jsm`rojd Oejoh Dpoh ef Oejo` `rd twe fnewdrs ef `rt wgohg g`vd sprujb frem `
sojbnd rdnoboeus stdm* Ay hejtr`st. tgd pedtry ef tgd Dnidr Dii` `ji tgd presd ef tgd
X`b`s `rd twe fnewdrs tg`t g`vd sprujb frem ioffdrdjt stdms eut ef reets adiidi oj
ioffdrdjt seons* Ygd Dnidr Dii` os ` fnewdr wgohg g`s wontdi. adferd ot g`s addj `and
te ujfeni otsdnf m ots funn pdrfdhtoej. adh`usd ots reet g`s addj hut oj eridr te tr`jspert ot
`hress tgd sd`* Ygd X`b` os ` fnewdr wgohg g`s anessemdi adh`usd ot g`s brewj up frem
jdw reets oj tgd jdw breuji*0
Enrol. ep* hot. pp* 022-7*` Ygos onnusto`toej os hotdi `t brd`tdr ndjbtg oj ep hot*. neh hot*. oj tgd p`ss`bd gdrd
emottdi oj tgdfeodbemb quet`toej*8 YPV 7+ )pev >f:pv` Ydpore%xdvev Zep%xtyyt WtydHfk* * * *
rj e y+ iv`ev [rdpYYtv. idoXd 7+ `p` jWd` `v)p:v*
'Og`i. OW. 00* 076-?*/+ Ef tgd feur n`ys sujb ay Sgdmous `ji Idmeiehus oj tgd Eiyssdy. je ndss tg`j tgrdd
`rd t`ldj frem tgd Yrek`j Hyhnd. wgond ejny ejd os ` t`nd ef tgd Beis* Sgdmous sojbs
ef tgd gemdw`ri vey`bd ef tgd @hg`d`js 'Ei* O. 00* 814-2/. Idmeiehus ef ` qu`rrdn
adtwddj Eiyssdus `ji @hgonnds 'Ei* VOOO. 00* 28-71/. `ji ef tgd Reeidj Gersd 'Ei*
VOOO. 00* 9??-413/*4
rZv y`p `etXZv %t`@@ev HYrt%ht`tevhr" hovPpworeo.
j Yt5 ifhet<6VY>r>ro vdhuY`rj iuZYd@o5Y`o*
'Ei* 0. 00* 840-1*/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 407/455
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 408/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI ?2
Ygd etgdr pesotovd hrd`toej tg`t dmdrbds frem tgd erid`n ef
tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej oj tgd heursd ef ` Venldrw`jidrujb os jet
`rtostoh. nold tgd Dpoh `ji tgd X`b`. aut penotoh`n* Ygos jdw loji ef
penotyos ` hemmejwd`ntg oj
wgohgtgd
aojiojb dndmdjtos
hejtr`ht`ji jet lojsgop* Rd g`vd jetdi ots j`turd `nrd`iy ay `jtohop`toej.`ji dx`mpnds ef ot nd`p te tgd moji*
Ygd mest f`meus dx`mpnds. pdrg`ps. `rd tgesd hoty-st`tds wgohgwdrd feujidi ay sd`f`rojb Brddl mobr`jts oj tgd n`st hejvunsoej ef
tgd pest-Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujb `nejb tgd wdst he`st ef@j`teno`.oj tgd iostrohts wgohg suasdqudjtny h`md te ad ljewj `s @denos `ji
Oejo` `ji Ieros* Ygd sh`jty survovojb rdheris ef Gdnndjoh hejsto-
tutoej`n gostery sddm te ojioh`td tg`t tgd projhopnd ef penotoh`n
erb`joz`toej ay n`w `ji neh`noty ojstd`i ef ay hustem `ji lojsgop`ssdrtdi otsdnf forst oj tgdsd Brddl sdttndmdjts evdrsd`s `ji w`s
`ftdrw`ris `ieptdi oj tgd Durepd`j Brddl pdjojsun` ay momdsos.
Oj tgd `ht ef dst`anosgojb tgdor feetgeni ej tgd @j`teno`j he`st oj
tgd f`hd ef eppesotoej frem tgd prdvoeus ehhup`jts ef tgd heujtry.tgd Brddl sd`f`rdrs weuni prehddi upej tgd jdw projhopnd spej-
t`jdeusny* @ jumadr ef sgop"s hemp`jods d`hg g`onojb frem `
ioffdrdjt iostroht `ji rdhruotdi frem mdmadrs ef m`jy ioffdrdjt
loj-breups weuni keoj ferhds te hejqudr ` jdw gemd fer tgdm-sdnvds evdrsd`s `ji te sdhurd tgdor hemmej hejqudst ay auoniojb `
hemmej hot`idn* Oj tgd hoty-st`td tgus feujidi. tgd "hdnns" ef tgd
jdw penotoh`n erb`joz`toej weuni ad. jet lojirdis gdni tebdtgdr aytgd tod ef hemmej idshdjt. aut "troads"
0
rdprdsdjtojb sgop"s hem-
p`jods< `ji tgdsd sgop"s-hemp`jods. oj t`lojb te tgd n`ji. weuni
stonn ad gdni tebdtgdr ay tgd tods wgohg g`i gdni tgdm ej sgop-
ae`ri* G`vojb he-epdr`tdi `t sd` `s mdj ie he-epdr`td wgdj tgdy`rd "`nn oj tgd s`md ae`t" oj tgd moist ef tgd
pdronsef tgd
iddp.tgdy weuni hejtojud te fddn `ji `ht oj tgd s`md w`y `sgerd wgdj
tgdy g`i te geni ` strop ef g`riny-wej he`st `b`ojst tgd mdj`hd ef `
gestond gojtdrn`ji* Ej sgerd. `s `t sd`. hemr`idsgop weuni heujt
fer merd tg`j loj. `ji tgd eridrs ef ` hgesdj `ji trustdi nd`idr
weuni evdrroid tgd premptojbs ef g`aot `ji hustem* Oj f`ht. ` advyef sgop"s-hemp`jods keojojb ferhds te hejqudr ` jdw gemd fer
tgdmsdnvds evdrsd`s oj ` str`jbd n`ji weuni turj spejt`jdeusnyojte ` hoty-st`td `rtohun`tdi ojte neh`n "troads" `ji bevdrjdi ay `j
dndhtovd m`bostr`hy*
Ygdrd `rd je herrdspejiojb horhumst`jhds te `hheujt fer tgd
dvenutoej ef tgd Gdnndjoh hoty-st`td oj Durepd`j Brddhd<`ji ojiddi
eur sh`jty rdheris ojioh`td tg`t tgd Brddls wge g`i st`ydi `t
gemd oj Durepd h`md ojte nojd penotoh`nny wotg tgd Brddls wgeg`i mobr`tdi `hress tgd sd` te @so` ay omot`tojb. `rtofoho`nny `ji
0 Ygd hejvdjtoej`n Djbnosg tr`jsn`toej ef tgd Brddl weri Zu@`t*
OO G
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 409/455
?7 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
adn`tdiny. `j `ht wgohg. oj tgd sdttndmdjt ef @denos `ji Oejo` `ji
Ieros. g`i addj semdtgojb ommdio`td `ji spejt`jdeus* Ej tgd
he`st ef @j`teno`. tgd hoty-st`td w`s ` jdw hrd`toej dveldi ay tgd
stomunus ef tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej* Oj Durepd`j Brddhdot
w`stgd sdheji-g`ji preiuht ef ` idnoadr`td "syjedhosm" ` rdvenutoej-
`ry `bbrdb`toej ef vonn`bd-hemmujotods ojte hoty-st`tds. wgohg w`s
`hhemp`jodi erfennewdi ay tgd suastotutoej ef neh`noty fer loj `s tgd
a`sos efpenotoh`n erb`joz`toej* Ygdrd os je rd`sejte suppesd tg`t `jy
suhg "syjedhosm" weuni dvdr g`vd addj h`rrodi eut er dvdj tgeubgt
ef oj "tgd eni heujtry" of tgd spejt`jdeus bdjdr`toej ef tgd hoty-st`td
oj "tgd jdw heujtry" evdrsd`s g`i jet prevoidi tgd Gdnndjoh Xehodty
wotg ` meidnpenoty
` meidnwgohg w`s hemmdjidi jetejny ay
ots
ewj eavoeus ojtrojsoh mdrots aut `nse ay tgd prdstobd ef ots hrd`ters.
tgd Gdnndjds ef @denos `ji Oejo`. wge wdrd oj tgd ferdfrejt ef tgd
Gdnndjoh Hovonoz`toej oj tgos forst `bd ef Gdnndjoh gostery*0
Rgdj wd turj frem tgd pest-Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujb te tgd
Xh`jioj`vo`j. wd h`j ioshdrj tgd ruiomdjts ef ` somon`r penotoh`n
idvdnepmdjt oj hdrt`oj jdw Xh`jioj`vo`j hemmujotods wgohg `resd
eut ef tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toejs noldwosd*1 Of tgd `aertovd Xh`jio-
j`vo`j Hovonoz`toej g`i `htu`nny hemd te aortg. tgd p`rt ejhd pn`ydi
oj Gdnndjoh gostery ay tgd hoty-st`tds ef @denos `ji Oejo` mobgt g`vd
addj pn`ydi oj Xh`jioj`vo`j gostery ay tgd fovd hoty-st`tds ef tgd
Estmdj `nejb tgd Orosg he`st8 er ay tgd fovd aereubgs wgohg wdrd
erb`jozdi ay tgd I`jds te bu`ri tgd n`jiw`ri aeridr ef tgdor hej-
qudsts oj Mdrho`*9 Dvdj `s ot w`s. tgd stomunus ef tr`jsm`rojd
0 Ygd `rtofoho`n hg`r`htdr ef tgd prehdss ef "syjedhosm+ oj Hejtojdjt`n Brddhd. `s `*
idnoadr`td omot`toej ef `j evdrsd`s p`ttdrj. os ojioh`tdi ay tgd f`ht tg`t tgd feur "Oejoh"
>f/vW`o. ojte wgohg tgd @tgdjo`j aeiy penotoh w`s `rtohun`tdi adferd tgd Hnhostgdjoh
rderb`joz`toej ef 437 A h*. wdrd ` sdndhtoej frem ` n`rbdr jumadr ef >k:v^`o ojte wgohg wdljew tg`t tgd aeiy penotoh w`s `rtohun`tdi `t Mondtus* 'Xdd Ron`mewotz-MednnhjierrY.T* vej; @rostetdnds uji @tgdj 'Adrnoj 07?8. Rdoim`jj. 1 vens*/. ven*
00. pp* 087-91*/ Ejtgos `j`neby. wd m`y hejkdhturd tg`t tgd tgrdd "Ieroh+ >%:vW`o noldwosd eroboj`tdi spej-
t`jdeusny oj semd hoty-st`td ef tgd evdrsd`s Ieros `ji wdrd rdpreiuhdi `rtofoho`nny oj
semd ef tgd "Iero`j+ hoty-st`tds ef Hejtojdjt`n Brddhd 'tgdrd os je dvoidjhd fer tgdor
rdpreiuhtoej oj Xp`rt`/* Xe muhg fer tgd evdrsd`s eroboj ef tgd "Oejoh+ `ji "Ieroh">f:y^`t
oj tgd hoty-st`tds ef Hejtojdjt`n Brddhd* Rdm`y `ttroautd tgd s`md eroboj te tgd "Iero`j+.
"Oejo`j+. `ji "@deno`j+ r`hds ojte wgohg tgd Brddl-spd`lojb Rerni `s ` wgend w`s
hejvdjtoej`nny `rtohun`tdi* Ygd Brddl tr`jsm`rojd sdttndmdjts ej tgd @j`teno`j he`st
fdnn ojte tgrdd iostojht bdebr`pgoh`n breups spd`lojb tgrdd ioffdrdjt io`ndhts ef tgd Brddl
n`jbu`bd* Ygd neh`n j`mds ef tgdsd breups wdrd @denos. Oejo`. `ji Ieros< `ji wd m`yhejkdhturd tg`t tgd s`md j`mds wdrd suasdqudjtny `ppnodi te hemmujotods oj etgdr p`rts
ef tgd Brddl-spd`lojb Rerni ej breujis ef nojbuostoh `ffojoty er ef `hhoidjt`n somon`rotyef j`md* 'Xdd Adnehg. L* K* ; Bjdhgoshgd Bdshgohgtd. 1ji diotoej. ven* o 'o/ 'Xtr`ssaurb0?01. Yr`ajdr/. pp* 08?-91 /
1 Xdd Enrol. @*; Volojb Hovonos`toej 'Nejiej 0?83. @nndj `ji Tjwm/. pp* ?7-?*8 Ygdsd hoty-st`tds wdrd Iuanoj. Rdxferi. R`tdrferi. Herl. `ji Nomdrohl* 'Fer
tgdor gostery. sdd Ldjirohl. Y* I*; @ Gostery ef tgd Volojbs 'Nejiej 0?83. Mdtgudj/.pp* 122 `ji 1??*/
+ Ygdsd fovd aereubgs wdrd Nojhenj. Xt`mferi. Ndohdstdr. Idray. `ji Jettojbg`m'sdd Ldjirohl. ep* hot*. p* 186/* Hemp`rd tgd feur somon`r aereubgs wgohg wdrd
dst`anosgdi. `ftdr tgd hejhnusoej ef tgd Yrd`ty ef Rdimeod. `t Jertg`mptej. Gujtojb-iej. H`maroibd. `ji Adiferi. oj eridr te bu`ri tgd n`jiw`ri aeridrs ef I`josg D`st
@jbno` 'Ldjirohl. ep* hot*. p* 193/*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 410/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF JDR BQETJI ??
mobr`toej preiuhdi sdvdr`n Xh`jioj`vo`j penotods tg`t ioi `tt`oj `
gobg idbrdd ef idvdnepmdjt* Ej tgd seutg he`st ef tgd A`ntoh. oj
Rdjin`ji. tgd sgert-novdi fr`tdrjoty ef tgd Kemsvolojbs idvdnepdi
` st`ji`ri ef `shdtohosm. ioshopnojd. `ji prewdss wgohg wej fer
Kemsaerb. oj ots i`y. tgd s`md rdput`toej oj tgd Xh`jioj`vo`j
Rerni tg`t Xp`rt` g`i ejhd djkeydi oj Gdnn`s* 0 Ygd enidr Xh`jio-
j`vo`j sdttndmdjt ef@nidobkuaerb dst`anosgdi ay volojbs wge g`i
hressdi tgd A`ntoh frem wdst te d`st `ji g`i pusgdi ej up tgd Bunf
ef Fojn`ji `ji up tgd Qovdr Jdv` ojte N`ld N`ieb` m`id `j
omprdssoej ef penotoh`n dffohodjhy upej tgd mojis ef tgd Jertgdrj
Xn`vs wgohg os rdfndhtdi oj tgd feuji`toej-ndbdji ef tgd Xh`jio-
j`vo`j
dmpord
oj Qusso`* Ygdndbdji
rdn`tds tg`t tgd Xn`vs wge g`i
f`nndj ujidr tgd yeld ef tgdsd ojtruidrs frem adyeji tgd sd`
suhhddidi oj irovojb tgdor jdw m`stdrs eut<aut tg`t. g`vojb ejhd
dxpdrodjhdi. ujidr iurdss. tgd adjdfots ef Xh`jioj`vo`j rund. tgdyfeuji tgd rdvdrsoej te tgdor j`tovd `j`rhgy se ojtendr`and tg`t
tgdy ojvotdi tgd Xh`jioj`vo`js te rdturj `ji rdhdovd tgdor wonnojb
eadiodjhd* Ygos ndbdji`ry "seho`n hejtr`ht" adtwddj ` promotovd
Xn`vejoh pepun`toej `ji ` Xh`jioj`vo`j runojb hn`ss wgohg g`i
`hquordi ots penotoh`n diuh`toej oj hressojb tgd sd` os tgd tr`iotoej`n
dxpn`j`toej ef tgd eroboj ef tgd Qusso`j Xt`td* _dt tgd hrd`toej ef
Qusso` w`s jet tgd brd`tdst penotoh`n fd`t tg`t w`s `hgodvdi ayXh`jioj`vo`js wge mobr`tdi evdrsd`s* Ot w`s surp`ssdi ay tgd
hrd`toej ef tgd Qdpuanoh ef Ohdn`ji ` Xh`jioj`vo`j penoty wgesd
feuji`toej os jet vdondi oj ndbdji aut os onnumoj`tdi ay tgd funn nobgt
ef gostery* Ej tgd `pp`rdjtny ujpremosojb seon ef tgos a`rrdj
`rhtoh osn`ji. wgohg heuni ejny ad rd`hgdi frem tgd jd`rdst Xh`jio-
j`vo`j peojt i"`ppuo oj tgd F`reds ay hressojb semd fovd gujirdi
monds ef epdj @tn`jtoh. tgd penotoh`n `s wdnn `s tgd notdr`ry bdjous ef
tgd Xh`jioj`vo`j Hovonoz`toej preiuhdi ots fojdst fnewdr*
@s fer tgd penotoh`n hejsdqudjhds ef tgd tr`jsm`rojd mobr`toej ef
tgd @jbnds `ji Kutds te Arot`oj oj tgd heursd ef tgd pest-Gdnndjoh
Venldrw`jidrujb. ot os pdrg`ps semdtgojb merd tg`j ` heojhoidjhd
tg`t `j osn`ji wgohg w`s ehhupodi `t tgd i`wj ef Rdstdrj gostery
ay ommobr`jts wge g`i sg`ldj eff tgd sg`hlnds ef tgd promotovd
loj-breup oj hressojb tgd sd` sgeuni `ftdrw`ris g`vd addj tgd
0"Kejosaerb * * * w`s ojg`aotdi ay ` *** volojb b`rrosej< `ji ndbdji tdnns tg`t tgos
sehodty wotgoj tgd fertrdss w`s bevdrjdi ay stroht runds* Ygdrd wdrd je wemdj `t `nn
`nnewdi ojsoid. `ji d`hg ejd ef tgd mdj w`s ` w`rroer ef tdstdi v`neur. jet enidr tg`j
fofty yd`rs ef `bd jer yeujbdr tg`j dobgtddj* Heur`bd. `ji heur`bd `nejd. wej `imossoej
te tgdor hemp`jy.`ji m tg`t hemp`jy ` sdnf-s`hrofohojb ney`nty te d`hg `ji `nn ejd"s
fdnnews w`s idm`jidi ef tgd Kemsvolojbs. sn`jidr ef `jy loji w`s pregoaotdi. `ji tgd
prov`td rdtdjtoej ef aeety feraoiidj* Monot`ry dffohodjhy w`s tgd send eakdht ef tgdor
erb`joz`toej `ji rdbun`toejs. `ji tgeubg je sojbnd m`j mobgt ad `w`y frejZtgdfertrdss fer merd tg`j tgrdd i`ys wotgeut spdho`n nohdjhd. d`hg summdr tgd Kemsvolojbswdrd `are`i tebdtgdr fobgtojb. `ji se woidsprd`i ioi tgdor f`md adhemd tg`t seej tgdywdrd heujtdi `s tgd brd`tdst w`rooers ef tgd Jertg% 'Ldjirohl. ep* hot*. pp* 070-1*/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 411/455
oee YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
heujtry oj wgohg eur Rdstdrj Hovonoz`toej `hgodvdi semd ef tgd
mest ompert`jt stdps oj ots penotoh`n prebrdss* Ygd I`josg `ji
Jerm`j ojv`idrs wge fennewdi ej tgd gddns ef tgd @jbnds. `ji wge
sg`rd tgd hrdiot fer suasdqudjt Djbnosg penotoh`n `hgodvdmdjts.noldwosd h`md evdr tgd dndmdjt tg`t g`s te ad tr`vdrsdi ay `nn wge
sdt feet ej tgd sgerds ef `j osn`ji< `ji tgd sd`-p`ss`bd g`i tgd
s`md noadr`tojb dffdht upej tgdor seho`n erb`joz`toej `s upej tg`t ef
tgdor sd`f`rojb prdidhdssers* @ pdepnd tgus fruotfunny iovdrsofodi
oj ots r`ho`n hempesotoej. `ji `t tgd s`md tomd ujofermny frddi frem
tgd djhumar`jhd ef ` g`mpdrojb promotovd ojstotutoej. effdrdi `j
ujusu`nny f`veur`and fodni fer penotoh`n huntov`toej* Ot os jet sur-
prosojbtg`t eur Rdstdrj Hovonoz`toej sgeuni g`vd
suhhddidi.oj
Djbn`ji. oj hrd`tojb forst "tgd Lojb"s Sd`hd" `ji tgdrd`ftdr "S`rno`-
mdjt`ry Bevdrjmdjt". wgond. ej tgd Hejtojdjt. eur Rdstdrj
penotoh`n idvdnepmdjt w`s rdt`ridi ay tgd survov`n ef tgd loj-
breup `mejb tgd idshdji`jts ef Fr`jls `ji Nema`ris wge g`i
jet addj rdnodvdi ef tg`t seho`n ojhuaus `t tgd eutsdt ay ` noadr`tojb
tr`jsot ef tgd sd`*
Foj`nny. wd m`y easdrvd. oj tgos penotoh`n hejjdxoej. tgd huroeus
f`ht tg`t ejd ef tgd twe djiurojb penotoh`n djtotods tg`t g`vd
dvdjtu`nny dmdrbdi eut ef tgd strubbnd fer dxostdjhd adtwddj tgd
dpgdmdr`n a`ra`ro`j "suhhdsser-st`tds" ef tgd Qem`j Dmpord oj
Arot`oj g`s addj tgd Lojbiem ef Xhetn`ji<0 `ji tg`t tgd feujidrs
`ji dpejyms ef tgos Xhetn`ji oj Arot`oj wdrd `j evdrsd`s effsgeet
ef tgesd eroboj`n Xhets ef Ordn`ji wge. oj tgdor j`tovd osn`ji. `rd `
ayweri fer tgdor prenejbdi f`onurd te hrd`td `j dffdhtovd ujotdi
Orosg st`td dvdj ujidr tgd prdssurd ef tgd mest fermoi`and
ferdobj `bbrdssoej frem tgd Xh`jioj`vo`js `ji tgdrd`ftdr frem tgd
Djbnosg*1
OV* YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX
G`vojb jew dx`mojdi tgd rdn`tovd stomun`tojb dffdhts ef ` ndss
`ji ` merd ioffohunt djvorejmdjt oj h`sds oj wgohg tgd djvorej-
mdjts `rd pgysoh`n. wd m`y hempndtd tgos p`rt ef eur stuiy ay
survdyojb tgd fodni ef gum`j djvorejmdjts ej tgd s`md hemp`r`-tovd mdtgei*
Fer hejvdjodjhd. wd m`y iovoid tgos fodni ojte sdhtoejs* Rd m`yiostojbuosg. forst. adtwddj tgesd gum`j djvorejmdjts tg`t `rd
bdebr`pgoh`nny dxtdrj`n te tgd sehodtods upej wgohg tgdy `ht. `ji
0 Fer tgd hrd`toej ef tgd Lojbiem ef Xhetn`ji. sdd furtgdr OO* I 'v/. pp* 0?3-1 `ji
0?9-4. adnew*8 Ot os ejd eftgd huroesotods ef gostery tg`t dvdj oj tgdsd n`ttdr i`ys. wgdj tgd Orosgg`vd
te semd dxtdjt rdtrodvdi tgdor penotoh`n rdput`toej ay tgdor suhhdss oj dst`anosgojb `jOrosg Frdd Xt`td. tgos penotoh`n `hgodvdmdjt oj Ordn`ji otsdnf g`s addj ferdst`nndi ay tgdsuhhdss ef tgd Orosg dmobr`jts `hress tgd @tn`jtoh m pn`yojb tgd b`md ef "m`hgojd
penotods" oj tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds!
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 412/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX 030
tgesd tg`t `rd bdebr`pgoh`nny ojtdrmojbndi wotg tgdm* Ygd fermdr
h`tdbery wonn hevdr tgd `htoej ef sehodtods. pdepnds. st`tds. hotods. `ji
etgdr seho`n erb`joz`toejs tg`t `rd oj dxhnusovd ehhup`toej. `t `jy
bovdj tomd. ef p`rtohun`r pertoejs ef tgd g`aot`and werni. upejjdobgaeurojb seho`n erb`joz`toejs ef tgd s`md loji* Frem tgd
st`jipeojt ef tgd erb`joz`toejs wgohg pn`y tgd p`ssovd rend oj suhg
seho`n ojtdrheursd. tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt wotg wgohg tgdy `rd
hejfrejtdi gdrd os "dxtdrj`n" er "ferdobj"* Ygd sdheji ef eur twe
h`tdberods wonn hevdr tgd `htoej ef ejd seho`n "hn`ss" upej `jetgdr.
wgdrd tgd twe "hn`ssds" `rd oj keojt ehhup`toej ef tgd s`md bde-
br`pgoh`n `rd`. `ji wgdrd tgd tdrm "hn`ss" os dmpneydi oj ots woidst
md`jojb*Frem tgd
st`jipeojt
ef ` "hn`ss" wgohgpn`ys
tgdp`ssovd
rend. tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt hejstotutdi ay tgd etgdr "hn`ssds" tg`t
`rd `htojb upej ot os "ojtdrj`n" er "iemdstoh"* Nd`vojb tgos "ojtdrj`n
gum`j djvorejmdjt" fer n`tdr dx`moj`toej. `ji st`rtojb wotg tgd
"dxtdrj`n gum`j djvorejmdjt". wd m`y adboj ay m`lojb ` furtgdr
suaiovosoej adtwddj tgd omp`ht ef tgd "dxtdrj`n gum`j djvorej-
mdjt8
wgdj ot t`lds tgd ferm ef ` suiidj anew `ji ots omp`ht oj tgd
ferm ef ` hejtojueus prdssurd*
Rg`t os tgd dffdht ef suiidj anews frem tgd dxtdrj`n gum`j
djvorejmdjt 5 Ieds eur prepesotoej "Ygd brd`tdr tgd hg`nndjbd tgd
brd`tdr tgd stomunus" geni beei gdrd 5 Ndt us sddl nobgt. ejhd merd.
frem eur wdnn-trodi dmporoh`n mdtgei ef ojquory*
Ygd forst tdst h`sds tg`t j`tur`nny ehhur te eur mojis `rd hdrt`oj
sdjs`toej`n ojst`jhds oj wgohg ` monot`ry `ji monot`jt Sewdr g`s
forst addj stomun`tdi ay suhhdssovd hejtdsts wotg ots jdobgaeurs. `ji
g`s tgdj suiidjny addj prestr`tdi oj `j djheujtdr wotg semd
`ivdrs`ry `b`ojst wgem ot g`s jdvdr md`surdi ots strdjbtg adferd*
Rg`t usu`nny g`ppdjs wgdj ojhopodjt dmpord-auonidrs `rd tgus
ir`m`toh`nny evdrtgrewj oj moi-h`rddr5 Ie tgdy usu`nny rdm`oj
nyojb. nold Xosdr`. wgdrd tgdy g`vd f`nndj. wgond tgdor g`nf-auont
dmpord henn`psds nold ` geusd ef h`ris 5 Er. ej tgd hejtr`ry. ie
tgdy rosd `b`oj frem tgdor Metgdr D`rtg. nold tgd bo`jt @jt`dus ef
tgd Gdnndjoh Mytgeneby.0 wotg tgdor strdjbtg `ji vobeur `ji mer`n
rdieuandi 5 Ie tgdy suhhuma 5 Er ie tgdy rd`ht te `j ujprdhd-
idjtdiny gd`vy anew ay `j ujprdhdidjtdi eutaurst ef purpesdfun
djdrby 5 Ygd gosteroh dx`mpnds ojioh`td tg`t tgd sdheji `ji jet tgdfermdr `ntdrj`tovd rd`htoej os tgd jerm`n euthemd*
Rg`t. fer dx`mpnd. w`s tgd dffdht ef tgd Bn`ids @nnodjsos upej tgd
fertujds ef Qemd 5 Ygd h`t`strepgd evdrteel gdr ejny fovd yd`rs
`ftdr gdr vohtery oj gdr nejb `ji `riueus iudn wotg Vdoo g`i pn`hdi
gdr. `t n`st. oj ` pesturd te `ssdrt gdr gdbdmejy evdr N`toum* Ygd
evdrtgrew ef tgd Qem`j @rmy `t tgd @nno` `ji tgd ehhup`toej ef
0 Fer tgd mytg ef @jt`dus. sdd furtgdr S`rt W. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 413/455
031 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Qemd gdrsdnf ay a`ra`ro`js frem tgd a`hl ef adyeji mobgt g`vd
addj dxpdhtdi te wopd eut. `t ejd streld. ejhd `ji fer `nn. tgd pewdr`ji prdstobd wgohg Qemd g`i wej. kust adferd. ay tgd evdrtgrew
`ji `jjdx`toej ef gdr Dtrush`j jdobgaeur* Ojstd`i. Qemd rd-hevdrdi frem tgd B`nnoh ios`stdr se r`poiny tg`t. wotgoj ndss tg`j
g`nf ` hdjtury `ftdr tgd B`uns g`i addj objemojoeusny aeubgt eff.
tgd Qem`j Xt`td w`s `and te djb`bd oj ` nejbdr `ji merd `riueus
iudn wotg ` mobgtodr jdobgaeur tg`j Vdoo fer gobgdr st`lds* Ygd
Qem`j Xt`td w`s `and te fobgt tgd X`mjotd Hejfdidr`hy fer tgd
prozd ef ` gdbdmejy evdr `nn Ot`ny. `ji dvdjtu`nny te dmdrbd voh-
teroeus frem ` fofty-yd`rs" w`r wgohg f`r surp`ssdi. oj sh`nd `ji
sdvdroty. `jy prdvoeusw`r wgohg Qemd g`i dvdr vdjturdi te
w`bd*
0
Rg`t. `b`oj. w`s tgd dffdht ej tgd fertujds ef tgd "Esm`jnos
wgdj Yomur Ndjl teel A`ydzoi _onidrom h`ptovd ej tgd fodni ef
@jber` 5 Ygos h`t`strepgd evdrteel tgd"
Esm`jnos kust wgdj tgdy
wdrd ej tgd peojt ef hempndtojb tgdor hejqudst ef tgd m`oj aeiyef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem oj tgd A`nl`j Sdjojsun`* Ygd
f
Esm`jnos
g`i pn`jtdi tgdor monot`ry henejods oj Ygr`hd `ji M`hdiejo`< tgdy
g`i evdrtgrewj tgd n`tdst m`stdrs ef tgd ojtdroer tgd Xdras ej
tgd fodni ef Leseve< `ji tgdy wdrd adnd`budrojb tgd n`st rdmj`jt
ef tgd D`st Qem`j Dmpord oj Hejst`jtojepnd* @t tgd memdjtwgdj tgdy wdrd tgus ej tgd vdrbd ef hejsenoi`tojb tgd rdsunts ef
fofty yd`rs" n`aeurs oj Durepd. tgdy wdrd prestr`tdi. ej tgd @so`toh
soid ef tgd Xtr`ots. ay ` tgujidraent frem Yr`jsex`jo`* @ hen-
n`psd ef tgd Ettem`j Dmpord oj tgd A`nl`js mobgt g`vd addj
dxpdhtdi te fennew tgd ios`stdr `t @jber` tgd merd se. oj`smuhg
`s Yomur. adojb r`tgdrmerd prevoidjt ofjetmuhg merd pdrsdvdrojb
tg`j Ardjjus. g`i t`ldj stdps te p`r`nysd tgd Ettem`j Sewdr oj
ots @j`teno`j gemdn`ji ay noadr`tojb `ji rd-dst`anosgojb tgd rov`n
@j`teno`j Yurlosg projhop`notods* Xe f`r frem tg`t. gewdvdr.
Mdgmdi tgd Hejqudrdr. wge suhhddidi te tgd Ettem`j tgrejd
kust g`nf ` hdjtury `ftdr gos `jhdster A`ydzoi g`i addj h`rrodi `w`y
h`ptovd te X`m`rq`ji. w`s `and te pn`hd tgd hepojb-stejd ej
A`ydzoi"s auoniojb ay t`lojb pessdssoej ef Hejst`jtojepnd `ji
reujiojb eff tgd Ettem`j Dmpord ujton. frem Yrdaozeji te tgd
b`tds ef Adnbr`id `ji frem tgd Hromd` te tgd Merd`. ot hemprosdi
tgd wgend iem`oj ef Ertgeiex Hgrostdjiem dxhdpt ots tr`jsm`rojd`jjdx oj Qusso`*1
Oj tgd tgori pn`hd. wd m`y t`ld jetohd ef tgd fertujds ef tgd Ojh`s
`ftdr tgdor p`ss`bd ef `rms wotg tgd Hg`jh`s tew`ris tgd moiind ef
tgd feurtddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`* Rgdj tgd Hg`jh`s
0 Ygd tr`iotoej`n ojoto`n `ji tdrmoj`n i`tds ef tgd forst tgrdd Qem`je-X`mmtd R`rs`rd 898-1?3 A*H*
<tgd tr`iotoej`n i`td ef tgd A`ttnd ef tgd @nno` os 8?3 A h*
8 Mdgmdi F`tog ompdria`t @*I* 0940-70< tgd A`ttnd ef @jber` g`i addj feubgt m@*I* 0931*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 414/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX 038
m`rhgdi ej Huzhe `ji tgd rdobjojb Ojh`_`gu`rGu`hh`h dv`hu`tdi
gos h`pot`n oj ` p`joh. ot neeldi `s tgeubg tgd Ojh`s g`i nest tgd
dmpord wgohg g`i addj feujidi ` gujirdi yd`rs adferd wgdj tgdor
`jhdsters g`i hejqudrdi tgd Henn`e `ji J`zh`*
0
Ygd a`ttnd ej tgdpn`oj ef X`hs`gu`j`. oj wgohg Srojhd G`tuj Yup`h tgd futurd
Ojh` Vor`hehg` kust suhhddidi oj st`yojb tgd Hg`jh`s" ejsn`ubgt`ji s`vojb Huzhe frem ford `ji sweri. w`s tgd g`ridst a`ttnd tg`t
tgd Ojh`s g`i ydt g`i te fobgt* Jdvdrtgdndss. tgd brd`t werl ef
dxp`jiojb `ji dndv`tojb tgd Dmpord ojte `j @jid`j ujovdrs`n
st`td w`s t`ldj up `ji hempndtdi ay Vor`hehg`+s sej `ji suhhdsser
tgd Ojh` S`hg`hutdh. wge h`md te tgd tgrejd `t Huzhe semd fofty
yd`rs
`ftdr tgd A`ttnd ef X`hs`gu`j` g`i addjfeubgt*
1
Etgdr onnustr`toejs ef tgd s`md "n`w" tgd strejbdr stomunus ef
tgd gd`vodr anew wonn mddt eur dyds of wd rdepdj tgd aeel ef
Qem`j gostery `t ` n`tdr p`bd `ji stuiy tgd heursd ef tgesd w`rs
adtwddj Qemd `ji tgd rov`n Brd`t Sewdrs ef tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni
wgohg hnd`rdi tgd breuji fer tgd dvdjtu`n hejvdrsoej ef tgd Qem`j
Dmpord ojte ` Gdnndjoh ujovdrs`n st`td* Oj tgos pg`sd ef Qem`j `ji
Gdnndjoh gostery wgohg adb`j wotg tgd eutard`l ef tgd forst
Qem`je-Sujoh R`r oj 169 A*H* `ji djidi wotg tgd somunt`jdeus
idstruhtoej ef H`rtg`bd `ji `jjdx`toej ef M`hdiejo` oj tgd yd`r
096 Qemd g`i te fobgt tgrdd reujis wotg H`rtg`bd `ji feur wotg
M`hdiejo` adferd sgd w`s `and te idnovdr twe "ljehl-eut anews"
wgohg areubgt tgd tot`joh strubbnd te ` hnesd* Je ieuat. tgd pedt
Vorbon g`i tgdsd twe sdrods ef w`rs oj moji wgdj gd a`id gos
heujtrymdj dvdr rdmdmadr "te a`ttnd iewj tgd stoff-jdhldi";
idadnn`rd supdraes*8 _dt tgd gosteroh`n f`hts surdny ojioh`td tg`t tgd
mdtgei ef `ttrotoej w`s jet ` m`stdrny hgeohd aut ` hestny `ji
i`jbdreus jdhdssoty< fer. tgeubg tgd Qem`js m`j`bdi te ad`t tgd
H`rtg`bojo`js `ji tgd M`hdiejo`js oj dvdry w`r tg`t tgdy feubgt
wotg dotgdr Sewdr. jdvdrtgdndss. `t d`hg suhhdssovd rdjdw`n ef tgd
hema`t. tgd prewdss iospn`ydi ay tgd v`jquosgdi `ji tgd dxdrtoejs
rdquordi ef tgd vohters wdrd aetg hejspohueusny brd`tdr tg`j tgdy
g`i addj d`hg tomd adferd*
Ygd idfd`t ef H`rtg`bd oj tgd forst Qem`je-Sujoh R`r stomu-
n`tdi G`monh`r A`rh` te hejqudr fer gos heujtry `j dmpord oj Xp`oj
wgohg f`r surp`ssdi gdr nest dmpord oj Xohony. `ji G`monh`r"s sejG`jjoa`n te strold `t tgd gd`rt ef tgd Qem`j Sewdr oj Ot`ny* Dvdj
`ftdr tgd G`jjoa`noh R`r g`i djidi oj tgd idfd`t ef G`jjoa`n"s
0 Fer tgd feuji`toej eftgdZOjh` Dmpord. sdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven o. pp* 010-1. `aevd*
1 Ygd dndv`toej ef tgd Dmpord ef tgd Ojh`s ojte `j @jid`j ujovdrs`n st`td m`y ad s`oi
te g`vd addj `hhempnosgdi tgreubg tgd ojherper`toej ef tgd st`tds `nejb tgd sd`ae`ri ef
tgd S`hofoh. frem nd` te Hgomu ojhnusovd. wgohg hevdrdi. adtwddj tgdm. tgd eroboj`n
gemd ef tgd @jid`j Xehodty* Ygd Ojh` S`hg`hutdh. wge `hgodvdi tgos. ompdr`a`t horh`
@*I* 0933-97< tgd A`ttnd ef X`hs`gu`j` g`i addj feubgt horh` @*I* 0892*8@djdoi: Aeel VO. 0* 748*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 415/455
039 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
n`st `rmy `t [`m`. oj tgd gemd tdrrotery ef H`rtg`bd. tgd H`r-
tg`bojo`js twohd `stejosgdi tgd Rerni iurojb tgd g`nf hdjtury tg`t
w`s stonn te ruj adferd tgdor j`md w`s anettdi eut ef tgd Aeel ef
Nofd* Tjidr tgd stomunus ef tgos `pp`nnojb sotu`toej. wgdj tgdy n`y`t tgd mdrhy ef `j ompn`h`and djdmy. wotg tgdor ompdjiojb ieem
dvdr prdsdjt te tgdor mojis. tgdy iospn`ydi `j djdrby `ji ` ferto-
tuid wgohg g`i jet iostojbuosgdi tgdm oj tgd i`ys ef tgdor pewdr`ji tgdor sdhuroty* Ygdy sgewdi tgdor mdttnd forst oj tgd r`poioty
wotg wgohg tgdy p`oi eff tgdor w`r ojidmjoty te Qemd `ji rd-
hevdrdi tgdor hemmdrho`n prespdroty<0 `ji tgdy sgewdi ot `b`oj oj
tgd gdreosm wotg wgohg tgd wgend pepun`toej ef tgd ieemdi hoty
mdj. wemdj.`ji hgonirdj
feubgt`ji iodi oj tgd n`st
strubbnd.wgdj tgd Qem`js wdrd `vewdiny adjt upej idstreyojb tgdm
uttdrny. `ji wgdj ot w`s hdrt`oj tg`t jetgojb jew heuni s`vd tgdm
frem tgdor f`td*
@b`oj. Lojb Sgonop V ef M`hdiej g`i addj hejtdjt iurojb tgd
G`jjoa`noh R`r. wgdj gd mobgt g`vd s`vdi gos heujtry ay keojojb
ferhds wotg G`jjoa`n gomsdnf oj Ot`ny. te djb`bd oj idsuntery `ji
ojdffdhtovd "soid-sgews" ej gos ewj soid ef tgd @iro`toh* Ot w`s tgd
anew ef Hyjeshdpg`n`d. wgohg hest gom gos gdbdmejy oj Brddhd.
tg`t stomun`tdi gom te sgew tg`t "gos n`st suj g`i jet ydt sdt"1 `ji
te tr`jsferm M`hdiejo` ojte se fermoi`and ` pewdr tg`t. ` qu`rtdr
ef ` hdjtury `ftdr Hyjeshdpg`n`d g`i addj feubgt. Sgonop"s sej
Sdrsdus w`s `and te hg`nndjbd Qemd sojbnd-g`jidi `ji `nmest te
idfd`t gdr utmest dfferts te evdrhemd gom* Dvdj wgdj Sdrsdus"
stuaaerj rdsost`jhd w`s foj`nny areldj `t Syij`. tgd M`hdiejo`j
pdepnd wdrd se f`r frem nesojb tgdor sporot tg`t. semd twdjty yd`rs
n`tdr. ot ejny jddidi tgd `ppd`r`jhd ef `j `ivdjturdr ompdrsej`tojb
Sdrsdus" sej Sgonop te m`ld tgd j`toej rosd oj `rms `b`oj oj ` n`st
strubbnd fer noadrty wgohg w`s ` fernerj gepd frem tgd st`rt*
Oj eur ewj Rdstdrj gostery. somon`r rd`htoejs wdrd dveldi ay
J`pendej O"s prdm`turd `ji `aertovd `ttdmpt. iurojb tgd Bdjdr`n
R`r ef 02?1-0704. te dst`anosg ` Rdstdrj ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd
ferm ef ` Frdjhg Dmpord*8
Fer dx`mpnd. tgd @ustro`js. wge g`i `nnewdi tgdmsdnvds oj
02?1 te ad turjdi a`hl ay ` h`jjej`id `t V`nmy frem `j ojv`soej
0 @s d`rny `s 0?0 A*H*. ejny tdj yd`rs `ftdr tgd rdster`toej ef pd`hd. tgd H`rtg`bojo`jseffdrdi te p`y eff tgd wgend eutst`jiojb `meujt ef tgd ojidmjoty fertgwotg oj ` sojbnd
nump sum. oj `jtohop`toej ef tgd stopun`tdi suhhdssoej ef ojst`nmdjts* Ygos effdr w`sjet `hhdptdi ay tgd Qem`js* 'Novy. Aeel WWWVO. hg* 9*/
1 Xdd tgd `hheujt bovdj ay Novy 'Aeel WWWOW. hg* 16/ ef `j ojtdrvodw oj tgd yd`r
074 A h* 'tgd dndvdjtg yd`r `ftdr Hyjeshdpg`n`d/ adtwddj Sgonop `ji ` Qem`j hem-mossoejdr* @ftdr st`tojb gos h`sd. Sgonop "dn`tus idmid or` `iodhot jejium emjoumiodrum sendm ehhoiossd"*
ZYgdM`hdiejo`j lojb"s eutaurst w`s ` rdmojoshdjhd ef ` nojd
ef Ygdehrotus; GXok y&p fei`fyo orivi+ e@tev `ppo XdXwhdtv< 'Ygdehrotus; Ygyrsts*0* 031/
8 Ygos `spdht ef tgd J`pendejoh Dmpord os dx`mojdi furtgdr oj S`rt VO. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 416/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX 034
ef Fr`jhd wgohg mobgt g`vd joppdi tgd Qdvenutoej oj tgd aui. `ji
g`i `nnewdi tgdmsdnvds tgdrd`ftdr te ad dkdhtdi ay tgd Frdjhg
twohd evdr frem Ot`ny. wdrd `reusdi `t n`st ay tgd anew ef 0734.
wgdj oj ` sojbnd h`mp`obj J`pendej h`pturdi g`nf tgd @ustro`j@rmy `t Tnm `ji ehhupodi Vodjj` `ji idstreydi tgd rdst ef tgd
@ustro`j @rmy `t @ustdrnotz* @ustro` `ftdr @ustdrnotz prdp`rdi fer
` rdjdw`n ef tgd hejtdst wotg tgd s`md brom djdrby tg`t M`hdiejo`
g`i iospn`ydi `ftdr Hyjeshdpg`n`d <`ji oj 073?. wgdj sgd trodi
hejhnusoejs wotg tgd hejqudrer `b`oj. `ji tgos tomd sojbnd-g`jidi.wotgeut `j `nny. sgd m`id gom p`y `s muhg merd id`rny fer `
sdheji vohtery `s M`hdiejo` m`id tgd Qem`js p`y oj 020-067 A*H*
Of @ustdrnotz w`s @ustro`"s
Hyjeshdpg`n`d. R`br`mw`s gdr
Syij`*Merdevdr. tgd @ustro`js. nold tgd M`hdiejo`js. stonn g`i tgd
sporot.
`ftdr suffdrojb twe sobj`n idfd`ts. te t`ld up `rms ejhd `b`oj< `ji.
merd fertuj`td tg`j tgd M`hdiejo`js. tgdy m`rhgdi tgos tomd te
vohtery* Ygd ojtdrvdjtoej ef @ustro` ej tgd soid ef Qusso` `ji
Srusso` oj 0708 w`s tgd idhosovd `ht wgohg m`id tgd evdrtgrew ef
J`pendej ojdvot`and `ji areubgt gos dpgdmdr`n dmpord te tgd
breuji*
@b`oj. tgd Srusso`js pn`ydi tgd s`md ojdffdhtovd p`rt oj 0734 `s
tgd M`hdiejo`js pn`ydi iurojb tgd G`jjoa`noh R`r. `ji tgdy p`oitgd pdj`nty ay mddtojb tgdor Hyjeshdpg`n`d `t Kdj`< aut tgd dffdhts
ef Kdj` upej Srusso` wdrd iyj`moh* Ygd rdmj`jt ef tgd Srusso`j
@rmy wgohg g`i m`rhgdi eut se ojbneroeusny oj tgd `utumj te `j
objemojoeus idfd`t g`i tgd g`riogeei te fobgt ` wojtdr h`mp`obj`ji te dx`ht ` Syrrgoh vohtery frem J`pendej `t Dyn`u `ji `ftdr tg`t
te be ej fobgtojb stonn. oj tgd f`rtgdst herjdr ef Srusso`j tdrrotery
adyeji tgd Mdmdn* Oj tgd yd`r `ftdr Kdj`. tgd Srusso`js ejny
`hhdptdi tgd Frdjhg hejqudrer"s tdrms adh`usd tgdy wdrd vortu`nny
hedrhdi ojte surrdjidr ay tgdor ewj Qusso`j `nnods<`ji tgd sdvdroty
ef tgd tdrms ejny `iidi te tgd stomunus wgohg tgd sgehl ef Kdj`
g`i forst `imojostdrdi* Ygd djdrby dveldi oj Srusso` ay tgos
stomunus w`s dxtr`erioj`ry* Ot jet ejny rdbdjdr`tdi tgd Srusso`j
@rmy '`ji tgos tgreubg tgd ojstrumdjt`noty ef tgd vdry rdstroh-
toejs wgohg J`pendej g`i ompesdi upej tgd Srusso`j @rmy oj
eridr te rdiuhd ot te ompetdjhd/ <ot rdbdjdr`tdi. ojte tgd a`rb`oj.
tgd Srusso`j @imojostr`tovd Xdrvohd `ji tgd Srusso`j Diuh`toej
Xystdm* Oj f`ht. tgos jdw-feuji djdrby tr`jsfermdi tgd Srusso`j
Xt`td ojte ` hgesdj vdssdn fer geniojb tgd jdw wojd ef Bdrm`j
J`toej`nosm<`ji somunt`jdeusny ot pdrfermdi tgd mor`hnd ef hej-
kurojb tgos strejb Bdrm`j wojd eut ef ` w`tdry hesmepenot`josm*
Ygd forst-fruots ef tgos tot`joh Srusso`j rdspejsd te tgd hg`nndjbd ef
Kdj` wdrd tgd `hts ef f`otg wgohg idhoidi tgd ossud ef tgd Adfrdo-
ujbslrodb< tgd foj`n g`rvdst w`s b`tgdrdi oj ay Aosm`rhl oj tg`t
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 417/455
oe6 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
h`nhun`tdi hemaoj`toej ef iopnem`hy `ji w`r wgohg preiuhdi ots
ojtdjidi rdsunt oj tgd dst`anosgmdjt ef ` jdw penoty; Srusso`-
Bdrm`jy*
@s fer tgd rend ef tgd Qusso`js oj tgd Bdjdr`n R`r ef 02?1-0704.ot os jeteroeus tg`t tgdy feubgt ojioffdrdjtny se nejb `s tgdy wdrd
fobgtojb tgd Frdjhg ej ferdobj breuji* Oj 0701 tgd j`toej`n
djdrbods ef tgd Qusso`j pdepnd wdrd dveldi. oj suhhdssovdny gobgdr
idbrdds. `s tgd Frdjhg ojv`idrs hressdi tgd penotoh`nfrejtodr `ji
`s tgdy p`ssdi. `t Xmendjsl. eut ef tgd ojsdjsotovd frojbd ef `nodj
tdrroterods. rdhdjtny ojherper`tdi oj tgd Qusso`j Dmpord. ojte tgd
quohl ef Geny Qusso`* @t n`st. oj tgd aurjojb ef Meshew. Qusso`
feujigdrsdnf<
`ji tgdj sgd turjdi
upejgdr ojv`idr oj ` heujtdr-
`tt`hl tg`t ioi jet hemd te ` st`jistonn ujton tgd toid ef w`r g`i
daadi a`hl robgt `hress tgd Hejtojdjt frem Meshew te S`ros*
Rgdj wd turj te tgd jdxt hg`ptdr ef Rdstdrj gostery. oj wgohg
tgd rends ef Fr`jhd `ji Bdrm`jy `rd rdvdrsdi. dx`htny tgd s`md
pgdjemdj` prdsdjt tgdmsdnvds mut`tos mut`jios* Oj 0 723.wgdj tgd
Frdjhg. oj tgdor turj. pn`ydi tgd v`ojbneroeus `ji objemojoeusrend ef tgd Srusso`js oj 0736. tgd Srusso`j Bdjdr`n Xt`ff. wge tgos
tomd g`i h`nhun`tdi `ji prevoidi fer dvdrytgojb iewj te tgd
n`st auttej. wdrd g`nf-surprosdi `t tgd d`sd wotg wgohg tgdy wdrd
`and te ojv`id Fr`jhd `ji idstrey tgd Frdjhg `rmods oj tgd fodni
`ji n`y sodbd te S`ros*0 Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. oj 0?09 tgd Srusso`j
Bdjdr`n Xt`ff ef tgd i`y. wge wdrd easdssdi ay tgd mdmery ef
wg`t g`i g`ppdjdi ferty-feur yd`rs adferd. wdrd `stejosgdi `t
wg`t g`ppdjdi tgos tomd wgdj tgdy rdpd`tdi tgd ojv`soej ef
Fr`jhd wotg `pp`rdjtny brd`tdr eiis oj tgdor f`veur tg`j tgdor
prdidhdssers g`i addj `and te heujt upej oj 0723* Oj 0?09 tgd
Bdrm`js djheujtdrdi ` Frdjhg rdsost`jhd fer wgohg tgd h`mp`objef 0723 effdrdi je prdhdidjt< `ji tgdor ujidr-dstom`td ef Frdjhg
mer`n oj 0?09 w`s ejd ef sdvdr`n psyhgeneboh`n mosh`nhun`toejs
wgohg. humun`tovdny. wdrd rdspejsoand oj n`rbd md`surd fer Bdr-
m`jy"s foj`n idfd`t oj tgd R`r ef 0?09-07* Ygd Bdrm`js fdnn ojte
tgos p`rtohun`r drrer ef kuibdmdjt adh`usd tgdy jdbndhtdi te t`ld
ojte `hheujt tgd memdjteus dffdht ef tgd stomunus wgohg tgdor ewjf`tgdrs g`i `imojostdrdi te Fr`jhd oj id`nojb gdr tgd anew ef
0723* Ygos stomunus g`i rdvd`ndi otsdnf `nrd`iy. adferd tgd R`r ef0723 w`s evdr. oj tgd hejtr`st adtwddj tgd iiaihls `t Xdi`j `ji
0 Ot w`s tgd bn`meur ef J`pendej O"s vohterods tg`t anojidi tgd Frdjhg te rd`notods oj
0723. kust `s. oj 0736. tgd Srusso`js g`i addj anojidi te rd`notods ay tgd bn`meur ef tgdvohterods ef Frdidrohl tgd Brd`t* @mejb jdutr`n spdht`ters. tgd dxpdht`toej ef ` Frdjhgvohtery oj 0723 w`s woidsprd`i wgdj w`r areld eut* Ygd wjtdr ef tgos Xtuiy pessdssds` m`p. puanosgdi `t tg`t memdjt ay Ygd Onnustr`tdi Nejiej Jdws. oj wgohg tgd sdhtoejhevdrdi ay tgd Bdrm`j Qgojdn`ji os projtdi oj rdi oj eridr te pohl ot eut ej tgd `ssump-toej tg`t ot os idstojdi te ad tgd w`r-zejd Ygd Frdjhg @rmy otsdnf os s`oi te g`vd addjsuppnodi wotg m`ps ef Bdrm`jy aut jet wotg m`ps ef Fr`jhd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 418/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX 032
Mdtz `ji tgd stuaaerj rdsost`jhd ef tgd pdepnd ef S`ros oj ` sodbdfrem wgohg tgdy g`i je gepd ef adojb idnovdrdi* Ygd s`md stomu-
nus rdvd`ndi otsdnf `b`oj `t ` n`tdr i`td `ji oj ` suanom`tdi ferm oj
tgd @ff`ord Irdyfus. wgdj ` mer`n ossud storrdi tgd wgend Frdjhgj`toej te tgd idptgs* Fer tgesd wge g`i dyds te sdd. ot w`s dvoidjt
tg`t tgos w`s tgd turjojb-peojt `t wgohg tgd sgehl ef idfd`t. stonn
werlojb oj Frdjhg seuns. g`i tr`jsn`tdi otsdnf ojte tgd storrojbs ef
rdbdjdr`toej <`ji se. te prepdrny ojstruhtdi easdrvdrs. tgd dxtrdmd
ioffdrdjhd adtwddj tgd suhhdssovd Frdjhg rd`htoejs te suhhdssovd
Bdrm`j ojv`soejs oj 0723 `ji oj 0?09 ioi jet hemd `ntebdtgdr `s
` surprosd*
Ygdtdj`hoty
ef tgd Frdjhg rdsost`jhd
iurojbtgd
R`ref
0?09-07 ` tdj`hoty wgohg w`s symaenozdi ay tgd idfdjhd ef Vdriujw`s ejd ef tgd projhop`n f`hters oj tgd vohtery ef tgd @nnodi `ji
@sseho`tdi Sewdrs* Sdrg`ps tgd mest omprdssovd fd`turd oj tgd
adg`voeur ef tgd Frdjhg iurojb tgesd w`r-yd`rs w`s tgd fertotuid
wotg wgohg tgdy djiurdi tgd idv`st`toej ef semd ef tgd wd`ntgodst
`ji mest v`nu`and p`rts ef tgdor j`toej`n tdrrotery <`ji tgd sdqudn os
stonn merd rdm`rl`and* @ symp`tgdtoh `ji `imorojb wotjdss ef
Frdjhg j`toej`n gdreosm iurojb tgos w`r mobgt g`vd om`bojdi. `t
tgd tomd. tg`t gd w`s wotjdssojb tgd id`tg ef ` j`toej ej tgd fodni ef
gejeur* "Fr`jhd". gd mobgt g`vd prepgdsodi. "m`y pessoany dmdrbd
vohteroeus. aut gdr vohtery wonn hdrt`ojny ad tgd id`tg ef gdr* Ygos
nejb-ir`wj-eut idv`st`toej ef tgd w`r-zejd must g`vd ojfnohtdi `
mert`n weuji upej tgd Frdjhg j`toej`n dhejemy* Ygdsd tdrroand
h`su`ntods must g`vd ieemdi tgd pepun`toej ef Fr`jhd te `j
orrdtrodv`and idhnojd* @ m`bjofohdjt dutg`j`so`! _dt id`tg os stonn
id`tg ef tgd aeiy. dvdj wgdj ot g`s addj reaadi ef ots sporotu`n
stojb*" Xuhg prepgdts jdvdr ird`mdi tg`t tgd bg`stny weujiwgohg w`s adojb ojfnohtdi ej Fr`jhd weuni `htu`nny rdkuvdj`td gdr*
_dt se ot g`s turjdi eut* Oj tgd rdhejstruhtoej ef tgd idv`st`tdi
`rd`s. tgd wgend m`tdro`n `pp`r`tus ef nofd g`s g`i te ad rdjdwdi*
Ygd idaros ef tgd eni dquopmdjt g`s j`tur`nny addj rdpn`hdi ayjdw dquopmdjt ef tgd n`tdst p`ttdrj < `ji. `s tgd werl ef rdjev`toej
g`s prehddidi. tgd Frdjhg g`vd hemd te hejbr`tun`td tgdmsdnvds
ej tgd `hhoidjt wgohg tgdy n`mdjtdi se aottdrny wgond tgd idv`st`-
toej w`s t`lojb pn`hd tg`t tgd w`r-zejd g`ppdjdi te ojhnuid tgd
m`keroty ef tgdor ojiustro`n iostrohts* Rgdtgdr tgd hest ef rdhej-
struhtoej `htu`nny g`s addj. er dvdr wonn ad. idfr`ydi ay Bdrm`j
Qdp`r`toejs p`ymdjts os ` sdheji`ry qudstoej* Oj tgd foftddjtg
yd`r `ftdr tgd @rmostohd. ot os `nrd`iy dvoidjt tg`t ot g`s prefotdi
Fr`jhd g`jisemdny te g`vd g`i gdr g`ji ferhdi ay idv`st`toej.
dvdj of tgd hejsdqudjt rdhejstruhtoej g`s g`i te ad h`rrodi eut
`nmest djtordny `t Frdjhg dxpdjsd* Oj tgos hempunsery rdjev`toej
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 419/455
oe7 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
ef gdr ojiustro`n pn`jt. Fr`jhd g`s addj hempdnndi te m`ld `j
ojdstom`any v`nu`and h`pot`n ojvdstmdjt* Merdevdr. gdr b`oj os jet
te ad md`surdi oj hruid tdrms ef orej `ji stddn `ji arohls `ji
mert`r* @ jdw `pp`r`tus ojvenvds ` jdw tdhgjoqud< `ji ` jdwtdhgjoqud ojvenvds ` jdw sporot*
Ot os je p`r`iex te s`y tg`t. oj
tgd rdhejstruhtoej ef tgd idv`st`tdi `rd`s. Fr`jhd gdrsdnf g`s
rdjdwdi gdr yeutg*0
@s fer Bdrm`jy. tgd mor`hnd wgohg ` monot`ry idv`st`toej g`s
`hhempnosgdi oj ejd f`sgoej fer vohteroeus Fr`jhd g`s addj
`hhempnosgdi oj `jetgdr f`sgoej fer tgd idfd`tdi rov`n ef Fr`jhd ay` foj`jho`n ojfn`toej* Ot os `nrd`iy dvoidjt tg`t tgd anews wgohg g`vd
addj r`ojdi
upej Bdrm`jysojhd tgd @rmostohd ef
0?07`rd
g`vojbtgd s`md stomun`tojb dffdht `s tgd anews ojfnohtdi ej Srusso` `
hdjtury `be oj 0736-2 *1 Oj f`ht. tgd ujfrodjiny sdrvohd wgohg tgd
Bdrm`js ioi te tgd Frdjhg adferd tgd @rmostohd g`s addj iejd aytgd Frdjhg te tgd Bdrm`js iurojb tgdsd pest-w`r yd`rs <
se tg`t `j
easdrvdr wge pdrhdovdi ejny tgd eutw`ri `htoejs `ji tgdor dffdhts.
wotgeut adojb `w`rd ef tgd metovds adgoji tgdm er tgd tdmpdr
ojfermojb tgdm. mobgt `nmest om`bojd tg`t Fr`jhd `ji Bdrm`jywdrd twe fn`bdnn`jts wge g`i bejd ojte ` p`rtjdrsgop oj `shdtohosm
ujidr ` mutu`n vew te wodni tgd n`sg fer ejd `jetgdr oj turj*
"Ygdsd `rd tgdy wgohg h`md eut ef brd`t troaun`toej"<8 `ji hdr-
t`ojny. oj tgd `utumj ef 0?80. wgdj tgd forst ir`ft ef tgos hg`ptdr
w`s wrottdj. aetg Fr`jhd `ji Bdrm`jy sddmdi te ad ndss f`r frem
s`nv`toej tg`j Brd`t Arot`oj; tgd ejd Brd`t Sewdr oj Durepdwgohg g`i suhhddidi fer merd tg`j sdvdjtddj yd`rs `ftdr tgd eut-
ard`l ef tgd Brd`t R`r oj turjojb tgd anews ef Fertujd `soid `ji
`veoiojb aetg tgd twe h`n`motods ef ojv`soej `ji ojfn`toej* @j
Djbnosgm`j. hemmujojb wotg gos ewj seun oj tgd `utumj ef tgd
yd`r 0?80 `ftdr tgd henn`psd ef tgd Seuji Xtdrnojb ej tgd 1ost
Xdptdmadr. mobgt wdnn `sl gomsdnf wgdtgdr tgos Arotosg teur id
ferhd g`i jet rd`nny addj ` pdrvdrsd dv`soej ef "tgojbs tg`t `hhem-
p`jy s`nv`toej"9 ` pdrvdrsoty wgdrday Brd`t Arot`oj g`i sompnyhejidmjdi gdrsdnf te "werl eut" gdr "ewj s`nv`toej" adn`tdiny "wotg
0 Oj tgd `utumj ef 0?80. semd tgortddj yd`rs `ftdr tgd @rmostohd. ej tgd merrew eftgd f`nn ef tgd Seuji Xtdrnojb frem tgd Beni Xt`ji`ri. Fr`jhd memdjt`rony feujigdrsdnf `j ` pesotoejm tgd Rerni wgohg. dvdj `t tgd tomd ef tgd Sd`hd Hejfdrdjhd. ot g`i
sddmdi ojhejhdov`and tg`t sgd sgeuni dvdr ehhupy `b`oj* @t tg`t memdjt. sgd pessdssdi`ji dxdrhosdi `j dffdhtovd monot`ry suprdm`hy `ji penotoh`n gdbdmejy ej tgd Durepd`jHejtojdjt. sgd w`s prdiemoj`jt evdr tgd wgend et Durepd oj tgd `or< sgd w`s sdheji
ejny te tgd Tjotdi Xt`tds oj gdr geniojb ef beni. `ji sgd w`s oj ` hejspohueusny adttdr
dhejemoh pesotoej tg`j `jy etgdr brd`t heujtry oj tgd Rerni oj vortud et gdr rdn`tovd
ommujoty. fer tgd tomd adojb. frem tgd ojhoidjhd eftgd werni-woid dhejemoh idprdssoej*Ot w`s `s of. wgdj [dus gurndi tgd tgujidr-aent wgohg w`s te `jjogon`td Xdmdnd. gos
idfdjhdndss vohtom g`i addj tr`jsfoburdi. `t tgd streld. ojte @tgdjd r`io`jt oj gdr
sgojojb `rmeur*1 Ygos p`ss`bd w`s wrottdj oj tgd summdr ef 0?80. `ji ot stonn genis beei `t tgd
memdjt ef rdvosoej oj tgd sprojb ef 0?888 Qdvdn`toej voo* 09* 9 Gdardws vo* ?*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 420/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX 03?
fd`r `ji trdmanojb".0 ojstd`i ef g`vojb s`nv`toej tgrust upej gdr
adtomds* "Fer wgesedvdr wonn s`vd gos nofd sg`nn nesd ot*"1
Ygd hn`ssoh dx`mpnd ef tgd stomun`tojb dffdht ef ` anew os tgd
rd`htoej ef Gdnn`s oj bdjdr`n. `ji @tgdjs oj p`rtohun`r. te tgdejsn`ubgt ef tgd @hg`dmdjo`j Sewdr tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td
oj 973-92? A*H*
"Ygd v`stjdss ef tgd ferhds dmpneydi oj tgd dxpdiotoej ef Wdrxds Lojbef Sdrso` `b`ojst Gdnn`s h`st tgd sg`iew ef ` tdrroand i`jbdr evdr tgd
Gdnndjoh Xehodty* Ygd st`lds fer wgohg tgd Gdnndjds wdrd h`nndi upej te
fobgt wdrd sn`vdry er frddiem. wgond tgd f`ht tg`t tgd Gdnndjoh hem-
mujotods oj @so` g`i `nrd`iy addj djsn`vdi hrd`tdi ` prdsumptoej oj
dvdry moji tg`t tgd hemmujotods oj Gdnn`s otsdnf weuni dxpdrodjhd tgd
s`md f`td* Rgdj. gewdvdr. tgd w`r rdsuntdi. hejtr`ry te dxpdht`toej.
oj ots `m`zojb ossud. tgd ojg`aot`jts ef Gdnn`s feuji tgdmsdnvds jet ejny
rdnodvdi frem tgd i`jbdrs wgohg g`i tgrd`tdjdi tgdm aut pessdssdi. oj
`iiotoej. ef gejeur `ji bnery. wgond dvdry Gdnndjoh hemmujoty w`s
fonndi wotg suhg `ffnudjhd tg`t tgd wgend Rerni w`s `stejosgdi `t tgd
hempndtdjdss wotg wgohg tgd sotu`toej g`i addj rdvdrsdi*"
Iurojb tgd g`nf hdjtury tg`t fennewdi tgos dpehg. Gdnn`s m`id v`st
stroids oj prespdroty* Iurojb tgos pdroei. tgd dffdhts ef tgd jdw `ffnudjhd
sgewdi tgdmsdnvds oj tgd prebrdss ef tgd `rts<`ji `rtosts `s brd`t `s `jy
rdheridi oj gostery. ojhnuiojb tgd shunpter Sgdoio`s. fneurosgdi `t tgd
tomd* Ygdrd w`s `j dqu`nny sobj`n `iv`jhd oj tgd ojtdnndhtu`n fodni. oj
wgohg pgonesepgy `ji puanoh-spd`lojb wdrd sojbndi eut fer spdho`n
gejeur tgreubgeut tgd Gdnndjoh Rerni `ji p`rtohun`rny `t @tgdjs* Oj
pgonesepgy tgdrd w`s tgd shgeen ef Xehr`tds. Sn`te. `ji @rostetnd< oj
puanoh-spd`lojb tgdrd wdrd suhg foburds `s Sdrohnds. Osehr`tds `ji Ose-
hr`tds+ pupons< `ji tgdsd wdrd a`n`jhdi ay mdj ef `htoej wotg brd`t
monot`ry rdput`toejs nold Monto`ids. Ygdmostehnds. @rostoids. Homej.
Myrejoids `ji ` nejb `rr`y ef etgdr j`mds tee jumdreus te mdjtoej*
"Oj tgd ferdfrejt ef `nn. @tgdjs `hgodvdi suhg troumpgs ef bnery `ji
prewdss tg`t gdr j`md wej `nmest werni-woid rdjewj* Xgd ojhrd`sdi
gdr `shdji`jhy te suhg ` peojt tg`t. wotg gdr ewj rdseurhds. ujsup-
pertdi ay tgd N`hdi`dmejo`js `ji Sdnepejjdso`js. sgd areld tgd
rdsost`jhd ef pewdrfun Sdrso`j ferhds ej n`ji `ji sd` `ji se gumandi
tgd proid ef tgd f`meus Sdrso`j Dmpord tg`t sgd hempdnndi ot te noadr`td
ay trd`ty `nn tgd Gdnndjoh hemmujotods oj @so`*"8
Ygd prd-dmojdjhd ef @tgdjo`j vot`noty oj tgos eutaurst ef Gdn-
ndjoh nofd wgohg fennewdi tgd rdpunsd ef Wdrxds" ejsn`ubgt os hem-p`r`and wotg tgd rdkuvdj`toej ef Fr`jhd `ftdr tgd R`r ef 0?09-07 <
fer @tgdjs ej tg`t ehh`soej. nold Fr`jhd ej tgos. aerd tgd arujt ef
tgd stomun`tojb anew* Rgond tgd fdrtond fodnis ef Aedeto` wdrd s`vdi
frem idv`st`toej ay tgd trd`hgdry ef tgdor ewjdrs te tgd Gdnndjoh
h`usd. `ji tgd fdrtond fodnis ef N`hdi`dmej ay tgd prdsdjhd `ji tgd
0Sgogppo`js 00* 01*
1 M`ttgdw xvo* 14*
8 Ioeierus ef @byjum; @ Noar`ry ef Tjovdrs`n Gostery. Aeel WOO. hgs* o-` 0*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 421/455
je YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
prewdss ef tgd @tgdjo`j fnddt `t X`n`mos. tgd peer n`ji ef @ttoh`
w`s idv`st`tdi systdm`toh`nny ay tgd ojv`idrs oj twe suhhdssovd
sd`sejs* Ojiddi. @ttoh` suffdrdi merd oj 973-92? A*H* tg`j Fr`jhd
oj @K:* 0?09-07 < fer tgd Bdrm`js ejny suhhddidi oj ehhupyojb `fr`htoej. `nadot `j dspdho`nny v`nu`and fr`htoej. ef tgd Frdjhg
j`toej`n tdrrotery. wgdrd`s tgd Sdrso`js ehhupodi `ji idv`st`tdi
tgd wgend ef @ttoh`. ojhnuiojb @tgdjs otsdnf `ji tgd @hrepenos `ji
tgd tdmpnd ef @tgdjd. ej tgd summot ef tgd rehl. wgohg w`s tgd
@ttoh geny ef genods* Ygd wgend pepun`toej ef @ttoh` mdj.
wemdj. `ji hgonirdj g`i te dv`hu`td tgd heujtry `ji hress tgd
sd` te tgd Sdnepejjdsd `s rdfubdds <`ji ot w`s oj tgos sotu`toej tg`t
tgd @tgdjo`j fnddt
feubgt`ji wej tgd A`ttnd ef X`n`mos. wotgoj
sobgt ef tgd vohters" `a`jiejdi fodnis `ji ruojdi gemds `ji `nt`rs*
Ot os je wejidr tg`t ` anew wgohg `reusdi tgos ojiemot`and sporot
oj tgd @tgdjo`j pdepnd sgeuni g`vd addj tgd prdnuid te `hgodvd-
mdjts wgohg `rd pdrg`ps ujoqud oj tgd gostery ef M`jloji fer
tgdor aronno`jhd `ji muntotuid `ji v`rodty* Oj tgd m`tdro`n rdhej-
struhtoej ef @ttoh`. tgd jdw dquopmdjt ef tgd f`rmstd`is surp`ssdi
tgd eni `s hejspohueusny `s tgd jdw dquopmdjt ef tgd Frdjhg
f`hterods g`s surp`ssdi tgd pn`jt idstreydi ay Bdrm`j sgdnn-ford*
G`nf ` hdjtury n`tdr. tgos jdw `pp`r`tus ef `brohunturd oj @ttoh` w`s
stonn se f`r supdroer te `jytgojb tg`t w`s te ad feuji oj etgdr p`rts
ef Gdnn`s tg`t wgdj @tgdjs adtr`ydi ojte fenny ay dxhdss ef beeifertujd `t n`st hejkurdi up `b`ojst gdrsdnf `j evdrwgdnmojbheujtdr-he`notoej ef etgdr Sewdrs. tgd Aedeto`j hejtojbdjt oj tgd
@nnodi `ji @sseho`tdi @rmods feuji ot wertg wgond te h`rry eff tgd
weeiwerl ef tgd @ttoh f`rm-auoniojbs aeiony `hress tgd meuj-
t`ojs*0
_dt. oj tgd rdhejstruhtoej ef @ttoh`. tgos ompesojb rd-
dquopmdjt ef tgd f`rmstd`is w`s jetgojb `hheujtdi ef* Ygd werl"
wgohg w`s rdb`ridi `s truny symaenoh ef tgd heujtry"s bneroeus
rdsurrdhtoej w`s tgd rdauoniojb ef tgd tdmpnds <`ji oj tgos werl
Sdrohnd`j @tgdjs iospn`ydi ` vot`noty f`r supdroer te tg`t ef pest-w`rFr`jhd* Rgdj tgd Frdjhg rdhevdrdi tgd a`ttdrdi sgdnn ef Qghoms
H`tgdir`n. tgdy pdrfermdi ` poeus rdster`toej ef d`hg sg`ttdrdi
stejd `ji spnojtdrdi st`tud* Rgdj tgd @tgdjo`js feuji tgd Gdl`-
0 Ygos f`ht os rdheridi oj tgd fr`bmdjt ef ` gostery ef Gdnndjoh `ff`ors. ef ujljewj
`utgersgop. wgohg g`s hemd te nobgt ej tgd Exyrgyjhgus S`pyrus* Ygd rdndv`jt p`ss`bdrujs `s fennews ;
"Ygdads g`i djkeydi ` brd`t ojhrd`sd oj bdjdr`n prespdroty `s `j ommdio`td rdsunt eftgd eutard`l ef tgd @tgdje-Sdnepejjdso`j R`r * * sgd prespdrdi stonn merd `ftdr tgd
keojt Ygda`je-N`hdi`dmejo`j ehhup`toej ef Idhdnd`* Rgond tgd ehhup`toej n`stdi.tgd Ygda`js aeubgt up hgd`p tgd sn`vds `ji etgdr prozd ef w`r< `ji tgd t`ht tg`t tgdywdrd tgd @tgdjo`js" jdxt-ieer jdobgaeurs dj`andi tgdm te tr`jspeot te tgd Ygda`oi`nn tgd
h`pot`n dquopmdjt ef @ttoh`. ojhnuiojb tgd vdry tomadr `ji tonojb ef tgd auoniojbs*@t tg`t tomd tgd @ttoh heujtrysoid w`s merd n`vosgny dquoppdi tg`j `jy etgdr oj Gdnn`s*Ot g`i suffdrdi vdry nottnd oj tgd prdvoeus N`hdi`dmejo`j ojv`soejs. `ji `j ommdjsd`meujt ef slonn `ji n`aeur g`i addj ojvdstdi oj ot ay tgd @tgdjo`js* * *" 'Gdnnhjoh`
Exyrgyjhgo` 'Exferi 0?3?. Tjovdrsoty Srdss/. xoo* 8-9*/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 422/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF ANERX oj
tempdiej aurjt iewj te tgd feuji`toejs. tgdy ndt tgd feuji`toejs
nod `ji prehddidi. ej ` jdw sotd. te hrd`td tgd S`rtgdjej*
@s fer Xp`rt`. sgd g`i te w`ot fer tgd stomunus wgohg sgd g`i
addj sp`rdi er idjodi ay Idstojy oj 973-92? A*H* ujton ot w`s`hheridi te gdr semd foftddj yd`rs n`tdr ay `j `ht ef Bei* Ot w`s
tgd brd`t d`rtgqu`ld ef 969 A*H* ` h`t`strepgd wgohg n`oi tgd Hotyef Xp`rt` oj ruojs `ji r`osdi `nn tgd Gdnets ef N`hejo` oj rdvent
`b`ojst tgdor strohldj m`stdrs tg`t put tgd Xp`rt`js ej tgdor mdttnd
`b`oj `ji jdrvdi tgdm forst te hgdhl tgd dxp`jsoej ef tgd @tgdjo`j
Dmpord `ji n`tdr te put `j dji te ots dxostdjhd* @s fer Ygdads. sgd
ioi jet hempndtdny rdhevdr frem tgd idmer`noz`toej efgdr "Mdiosm"
oj
973A*H*. jer
wgenny
dff`hd ots
stobm`.
ujton `nmest `
hdjturyn`tdr
wgdj. oj tgd yd`r 871. tgd Beis `t n`st g`i mdrhy ej gdr `ji
ojspordi tgd Xp`rt`js te sdozd ay fr`ui `ji geni ay ferhd tgd Ygda`j
hot`idn. tgd H`imd`* Tjidr tgd stomunus ef tgos gd`vdj-sdjt anew.
Ygdads `hgodvdi. fer ` sd`sej. tgd mor`hnd ef `iiojb ` huaot te gdr
st`turd* Ygd noadr`toej ef tgd H`imd` oj 827 A*H* w`s fennewdi aytgd vohtery ef Nduhtr` oj 820 `ji tgd ojv`soej ef N`hejo` oj 823*
Ygdads g`i jet ejny funfonndi gdr `jhodjt `maotoej ef dst`anosgojb
`j ujiosputdi `utgeroty evdr tgd etgdr hoty-st`tds ef Aedeto`<sgd
g`i `htu`nny idfd`tdi tgd ojvojhoand Xp`rt`js `ji r`oidi tgdor
ojvoen`and tdrrotery `ji wrdstdi frem tgdm tgd gdbdmejy ef tgd
Gdnndjoh Rerni*
Oj tgos sdrods ef dx`mpnds frem tgd monot`ry `ji penotoh`n gosterods
ef sevdrdobj st`tds. tgd stomunus ef anews os m`jofdst* _dt of tgdsd
dx`mpnds w`rr`jt tgd ojfdrdjhd tg`t "tgd gd`vodr tgd anew tgd
strejbdr tgd stomunus" os ` bdjuojd seho`n n`w. wd must adw`rd ef
m`lojb tgd furtgdr ojfdrdjhd tg`t Monot`rosm oj otsdnf os ` seurhd ef
hrd`tovd djdrby < fer tgd gosteroh dx`mpnds ef eur prdsdjt n`w `rd
jet hejfojdi te tgd a`ttnd-fodni.0 `ji tgdrd `rd etgdr mdioums
adsoids tgesd ef w`r `ji penotohs oj wgohg tgdsd stomun`tojb anews
`rd id`nt `ji rdhdovdi*
Ygd hn`ssoh dx`mpnd. wgohg wd g`vd rdsdrvdi ujton tgd dji ef
tgos hg`ptdr. os prdsdjtdi ej tgd fodni ef rdnoboej oj tgd @hts ef tgd
@pestnds* Ygdsd iyj`moh `hts. wgohg wdrd te woj tgd wgend
Gdnndjoh Rerni fer Hgrosto`joty `s tgdy werldi tgdmsdnvds eut oj
tgd funnjdss ef tomd. wdrd hejhdovdi `t tgd memdjt wgdj tgd
@pestndswdrd neelojb std`if`stny tew`ri Gd`vdj `s tgdor Neri wdjt
o Ejd ef tgd jeteroeus iddis ef Monot`rosm m rdhdjt Rdstdrj gostery tgd aurjojbef tgd hoty ef @tn`jt`. Bderbo`. ay Bdjdr`n Xgdrm`j oj @ I* 0769 g`s stomun`tdi tgd
strohldj hoty te r`osd gdrsdnf te `j dmojdjhd oj tgd `rts ef pd`hd wgohg sgd g`i jdvdr
`tt`ojdi oj gdr `jtd-adnnum ojf`jhy Xgdrm`j hg`nndjbdi @tn`jt` te sgew gdr idstreydr
tg`t sgd w`s jet ` Sdrsdpenos aut ` pgedjox < `ji gd t`ubgt gdr tgd w`y ay epdjojbZgdr
dyds te tgd ojidstruhtoand ompert`jhd ef gdr bdebr`pgoh`n pesotoej `s ` r`onw`y kujhtoej*
Ej tgd merrew efgdr ios`stdr. @tn`jt`teel fer gdr hovoh mette tgd N`toj weri Qdsurbdjs.
`ji turjdi gdr str`tdboh pesotoej te hemmdrho`n `hheujt ay m`lojb gdrsdnf ojte ` iostro-
autojb hdjtrd fer tgd wgend ef tgd seutg-d`stdrj Tjotdi Xt`tds.
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 423/455
us YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
up eut ef tgdor sobgt*0 @t tgd memdjt. ot w`s ` hrusgojb anew fer
tgdm te nesd `b`oj tgd pdrsej`n prdsdjhd ef` M`stdrwge g`i se n`tdny
rdturjdi te tgdm frem tgd id`i* _dt tgd vdry gd`vojdss ef tgd anew
dveldi. oj tgdor seuns. ` prepertoej`tdny pewdrfun psyhgeneboh`nrd`htoej wgohg os hejvdydi mytgeneboh`nny oj tgd mdss`bd ef tgd
twe mdj oj wgotd `pp`rdn1 `ji oj tgd idshdjt ef tgd Sdjtdhest`n
tejbuds ef ford*8 Oj tgd pewdr ef tgd Geny Bgest. tgdy prd`hgdi
tgd iovojoty ef tgd hruhofodi `ji v`josgdi Kdsus jet ejny te tgd
Kdwosg pepun`hd aut te tgd X`jgdiroj<
9`ji. wotgoj tgrdd hdjturods.
tgd Qem`j Bevdrjmdjt otsdnf h`potun`tdi te tgd Hgurhg wgohg tgd
@pestnds g`i feujidi `t ` memdjt ef dxtrdmd sporotu`n prestr`toej*
V* YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX
"M`rhgds" `ji "Ojtdroers"
Xe muhg fer tgd stomunus ef tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt wgdj ots
omp`ht t`lds tgd ferm ef ` suiidj dxtdrj`n anew* Rd g`vd jdxt te
dx`mojd tgd h`sds oj wgohg tgd omp`ht t`lds tgd ioffdrdjt ferm ef `
hejtojueus dxtdrj`n prdssurd*
Oj tdrms ef penotoh`n bdebr`pgy. tgd pdepnds. st`tds. er hotods
wgohg `rd dxpesdi te suhg prdssurd f`nn. fer tgd mest p`rt. wotgojtgd bdjdr`n h`tdbery ef "m`rhgds"
<`ji tgd adst w`y te stuiy tgd
dffdhts ef tgos p`rtohun`r loji ef prdssurd dmporoh`nny os te m`ld
semd survdy ef tgd p`rts pn`ydi ay m`rhgds. oj tgd gosterods ef tgd
sehodtods er hemmujotods te wgohg tgdy adnejb. oj hemp`rosej wotg
tgd p`rts pn`ydi ay etgdr tdrroterods tg`t adnejb rdspdhtovdny te tgd
s`md sehodtods er hemmujotods aut `rd sotu`tdi bdebr`pgoh`nny oj
tgdor "ojtdroers"*4
Oj tgd Dbypto`h Rerni
Oj tgd gostery ef tgd Dbypto`h Hovonoz`toej. fer dx`mpnd. wd g`vd
jetohdi `nrd`iy. oj `jetgdr hejjdxoej.6tg`t. ej je ndss tg`j tgrdd
memdjteus ehh`soejs. tgd heursd ef Dbypto`h gostery w`s iordhtdi
ay Sewdrs eroboj`tojb oj tgd seutg ef Tppdr Dbypt* Ygd feuji`-
toej ef tgd Tjotdi Lojbiem horh` 8133 A*H*. tgd feuji`toej ef
tgd ujovdrs`n st`td horh` 1323%1363 A*H*. `ji tgd rdster`toej ef tgd
ujovdrs`n st`td horh`
0473A*H*. wdrd `nn
`hhempnosgdi aySewdrs
tg`t eroboj`tdi wotgoj tgos j`rrewnyhorhumshroadi iostroht* Rd m`yeasdrvd jew. `prepes ef eur prdsdjt ojquory. tg`t tgos iostroht os
0 @hts o* ?-03*+ @hts o* ne-oo* 8 @hts oo* 0-9*
9 @hts oo-v*
4 Oj S`rt OV. adnew. wd sg`nn g`vd ehh`soej te rdhur te tgos survdy ef tgd p`rts pn`ydiay m`rhgds. `prepes ef tgd p`tgeneboh`n pgdjemdjej ef `j dxhdssovd hejhdjtr`toej ef
djdrby upej hdrt`oj p`rtohun`r `htovotods wgohg `od tgd rdspejsds te p`rtohun`r hg`nndjbds*@j dx`mpnd ef tgos pgdjemdjej wgohg os hejspohueus oj tgd gosterods ef m`rhgds os tgdseho`n m`n`iy h`nndi Monot`rosm
6 Xdd O* H 'j/. ven* o. p* 093. feetjetd 1. `aevd. fennewojb Mdydr. D* * Bdshgugtd f`s
@ntdrtums. ven* 00 'o/. 1ji diotoej. pp* 63-0*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 424/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 008
heojhoidjt wotg tgd Xeutgdrj M`rhg ef tgd Dbypto`h Rerni wgohgw`s dxpesdi te prdssurd frem tgd a`ra`ro`js ef Juao`* @ji of wdneel furtgdr ojte Dbypto`h gostery frem eur prdsdjt `jbnd ef vosoej.
wd sg`nn foji etgdr m`rhgdspn`yojb dquov`ndjt p`rts oj rd`htoej te
prdssurds frem a`ra`ro`js er frem `nodj hovonoz`toejs wgohg om-
pojbdi upej tgd Dbypto`h Rerni frem etgdr qu`rtdrs* Oj p`rtohu-
n`r. ` prdssurd frem Jertg-Rdstdrj @froh` er frem Xeutg-Rdstdrj
@so` w`s `pt te h`nn ojte dxostdjhd. oj tgd Dbypto`h Rerni. `
p`r`meujt Sewdr wotg ots sd`t oj tgd herrdspejiojb m`rhgds ej
tgos er tg`t frojbd ef tgd Idnt`* 0
Ygd pen`roz`toej ef penotoh`n pewdr `t tgd twe dxtrdmotods ef tgd
Dbypto`h iem`oj w`s `j d`rny `s wdnn `s ` pdrsostdjt pgdjemdjejef Dbypto`h gostery* @ hejsenoi`toej ef tgd twdjty er tgorty ejhd
ojidpdjidjt neh`n st`tds ef tgd Newdr Jond V`nndy1 ojte twe dmpords
wotg tgd Jertgdrj `ji tgd Xeutgdrj M`rhg `s tgdor rdspdhtovdjuhndo w`s tgd prdnuid te tgd feuji`toej ef tgd Tjotdi Lojbiem<`ji `ftdr tgos iu`nosm g`i addj hejvdrtdi ojte ujoty tgreubg tgd
troumpg ef tgd Xeutgdrj evdr tgd Jertgdrj Sewdr. tgd mdmery ef
ot w`s stonn ldpt `novd oj tgd symaenosm ef tgd Ieuand Hrewj. ujton
`t n`st. `ftdr tgd p`ss`bd ef semd twe tgeus`ji yd`rs. tgd Jertgdrj
M`rhg suhhddidi oj h`pturojb oj ots turj. `ji tgdjhdfertg rdt`ojojb.tgd prom`hy* Oj tgd tgortddjtg hdjtury A*H*. jdw prdssurds frem
tgd Gottotd Sewdr ej tgd @so`toh m`ojn`ji `ji frem tgd pest-Moje`j Venldrw`jidrujb oj tgd Ndv`jt h`usdi tgd shdptrd te p`ssfrem Ygdads. tgd gosteroh mdtrepenos ef tgd Xeutgdrj M`rhg. te
tgd Hoty ef Q`msds ; tgd jdw frejtodr-fertrdss ej tgd d`stdrj frojbd
ef tgd Idnt` wgohg jew bu`ridi tgos dxpesdi dxtrdmoty ef tgd
Dbypto`h Rerni `s Ygdads g`i bu`ridi tgd frejtodr evdr `b`ojst
Juao`*8
Ygdrd`ftdr. iurojbtgd soxtddj hdjturods ef
twonobgtwgohg
dn`psdi adtwddj tgd idhnojd ef "tgd Jdw Dmpord" `ji tgd untom`td
dxtojhtoej ef tgd Dbypto`h Xehodty oj tgd foftg hdjtury ef tgd
Hgrosto`j Dr`. penotoh`n pewdr rdvdrtdi te tgd Idnt` `s pdrsostdjtny
`s ot g`i addj `pt te rdvdrt te tgd Xeutgdrj M`rhg iurojb tgd prd-
hdiojb twe tgeus`ji yd`rs* @ftdr adojb bevdrjdi oj tgd tgortddjtg
`ji twdnftg hdjturods A*H* frem Idnt`oh Q`msds. tgd Dbypto`h
0 d b* `t tgd Hoty ef Q`msds `ji `t Y`jos `ji `t Aua`stos ej tgd d`stdrj frojbd ef tgd
Idnt`< `t X`os ej tgd wdstdrj frojbd 'sdd adnew/*
1 Ygd gosteroh`n "jemds". o*d* prevojhds. `s tgdy wdrd h`nndi `ftdr tgdor +mdio`toz`toej"*8 Fer tgos tr`jsfdr ef tgd h`pot`n frem Ygdads te tgd Hoty ef Q`msds. sdd Mdydr. D* ;
Bdshgohgtd ids @ntdrtums. ven* oo 'o/. 1ji diotoej. pp* 948-9. 972-7. `ji 9?9-4* Ygd Hotyef Q`msds w`s tgd forst Idnt`oh h`pot`n ef `j edhumdjoh`n Dbypto`h Xt`td wotg tgd dxhdptoejef @v`js
<`ji @v`js os tgd dxhdptoej wgohg prevds tgd rund
<fer @v`ros w`s tgd h`pot`n ef
tgd Gylses <`ji tgd Gylses wdrd `nodj ojtdrnepdrs oj tgd Dbypto`h Rerni wge jdvdr
fdnt tgdmsdnvds `t gemd tgdrd* Fer tgos rd`sej. tgd Gylses ioi jet `ttdmpt te dst`anosg
tgdmsdnvds `j tgd ojtdroer. aut rdm`ojdi djh`mpdi `t@v`js. ej tgd dibd ef tgdor Dbypto`jiemojoejs. oj eridr te lddp epdj tgdor nojd ef rdtrd`t te tgdor eroboj`n sdttndmdjts oj Xyro`*Ygus @v`ros. ujidr tgd Gylses rdbomd. w`s jet rd`nny tgd h`pot`n ef `j Dbypto`h Xt`td
aut r`tgdr tgd gd`i-qu`rtdrs ef `j `nodj monot`ry ehhup`toej*
OO O
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 425/455
oo9 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Rerni w`s bevdrjdi oj tgd dndvdjtg hdjtury frem Idnt`oh Y`jos
`ji oj tgd tdjtg `ji jojtg hdjturods frem Idnt`oh Aua`stos<`ji
tgd hn`ssoh ojst`jhd ef Idnt`oh p`r`meujthy os tgd rosd ef tgd
Ywdjty-Xoxtg Iyj`sty. wgohg eroboj`tdi oj tgd Idnt` oj rdspejsdte tgd hg`nndjbd ef tgd @ssyro`j ehhup`toej oj tgd sdvdjtg hdjtury
A*H* `ji h`md. `ftdr suppn`jtojb tgd ojtruidrs. te rund `nn Dbypt.
`s f`r seutg `s Dndpg`jtojd. frem X`os* Ygd X`otd Sewdr. tgus
feujidi. djiurdi ujton ot f`ondi te rdspeji te `jetgdr hg`nndjbd
frem @so` oj f`onojb te s`vd Dbypt frem penotoh`n ojherper`toej ojte
tgd @hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord* Ygd suasdqudjt suhhdssovd `ttdmpts
semd `aertovd `ji etgdrs tdmper`rony suhhdssfun te tgrew eff tgd
@hg`dmdjo`j yeld`nn dm`j`tdi frem tgd Idnt` noldwosd*
Iurojbtgdsd hdjturods wgdj tgd Idnt` w`s penotoh`nny
oj tgd `shdji`jt. tgd
Ygda`oi w`s penotoh`nny oj dhnopsd* Ygd pesotoej ef pest-Ompdro`n
Ygdads oj tgd n`ttdr-i`y Dbypto`h Rerni rdsdmandi tg`t ef pest-
Ompdro`n Qemd iurojb tgd pest-Gdnndjoh ojtdrrdbjum `ji tgd
d`rny `bd ef Rdstdrj Hgrostdjiem* Ygd ho-idv`jt Ompdro`n Hoty
w`s pdrfujhterony hempdjs`tdi `ji hejsendi fer tgd ness ef ots
penotoh`n pewdr ay tgd djkeymdjt ef `j dhhndso`stoh`n prom`hywgohg w`s ` ndb`hy frem ots
prdvoeusbrd`tjdss `ji ` troautd te ots
djiurojb prdstobd*0
H`j wd ioshdrj wgy ot w`s tg`t. oj tgd hempdtotoej fer penotoh`n
p`r`meujthy adtwddj tgd Ygda`oi `ji tgd Idnt`. tgd Ygda`oi
g`i tgd uppdr g`ji frem tgd feuji`toej ef tgd Tjotdi Lojbiemujton tgd idhnojd ef "tgd Jdw Dmpord". wgond tgd Idnt` g`i tgd
uppdr g`ji tgdrd`ftdr 5 Ygos pdrm`jdjt hg`jbd oj tgd a`n`jhd ef
pewdr os te ad dxpn`ojdi ay hdrt`oj pdrm`jdjt hg`jbds oj tgd
ojhoidjhd ef dxtdrj`n prdssurd upej tgd Dbypto`h Rerni* Frem tgd
feurtddjtg `ji tgortddjtg hdjturods A*H* ejw`ris. tgd prdssurds
frem Jertg-Rdstdrj @froh` `jifrem Xeutg-Rdstdrj @so` idhoidiny
eutwdobgdi tgd prdssurds frem etgdr qu`rtdrs< `ji `hheriojbny.
iurojb tgdsd n`ttdr i`ys. tgd stomunus idrovdi frem dxtdrj`n prds-
surd w`s fdnt oj brd`tdst md`surd ay tgd Jertgdrj M`rhgds oj tgd
Idnt`* Hejhurrdjtny. tgd prdssurd frem tgd Tppdr Jond V`nndy
rdn`xdi< `ji tgd hn`ssoh Xeutgdrj M`rhg. oj tgd sdhtoej ef tgd
v`nndy ommdio`tdny adnew tgd Forst H`t`r`ht. w`s rdndb`tdi te tgd
ojtdroer ef tgd Dbypto`h Rerni ay `j dxtdjsoej ef tgd Dbypto`hiem`oj up-rovdr*
Ygd hn`ssoh Xeutgdrj M`rhg w`s ejny ` m`rhg se nejb `s tgd
Forst H`t`r`ht m`rldi ` sg`rp nojd ef huntur`n iovosoej adtwddj tgd
Dbypto`h Hovonoz`toej `ji ` Juao`j a`ra`rosm<`ji tgos hejiotoej
0 Xdd Mdydr. D* ; Bettdsst``t. Monot`rgdrrshg`ft uji Xtijidwdsdj oj @dbyptdj =
Adrohgtdj Adrn* @l`i* 0?17. pp* 9?4 sdqq*< dujidm; BdshYjhgtdids@ntdrtums. ven* oo 'oo/.
`ji diotoej 'Xtuttb`rt `ji Adrnoj 0?80. Bett`/. pp* 6-63*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 426/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 004
ioi jet prdv`on dotgdr oj tgd dvdjojb er `t tgd i`wj ef Dbypto`h
gostery* Oj tgd se-h`nndi prd-iyj`stoh `bd. tgdrd g`i addj je
suast`jto`n ioffdrdjhd oj hunturd adtwddj tgd sdhtoejs ef tgd Jond
V`nndy adnew tgd Forst H`t`r`ht `ji `aevd ot* Ygd ioffdrdjto`toej ef` iyj`moh hovonoz`toej oj Dbypt frem ` st`toh promotovd hunturd oj
Juao` idhn`rdi otsdnf ej tgd dvd ef tgd feuji`toej ef tgd Tjotdi
Lojbiem< `ji tgd stomunus ef a`ra`ro`j prdssurd upej tgd
Dbypto`h frejtodrsmdj `t tgd jdw iovoiojb nojd pdrg`ps `hheujts
fer tgd feuji`toej ef tgd Tjotdi Lojbiem ay ` iyj`sty wgesd sd`t
w`s `t @n L`a* Ygd jdw ioffdrdjhd oj huntur`n ndvdn adtwddj Dbypt`ji Juao` w`s `hhdjtu`tdi iurojb tgd rdbomd ef tgd Dbypto`hTjotdi
Lojbiem.`s tgd
Dbypto`hHovonoz`toej se`rdi te ots
zdjotg<`ji tgos huntur`n bunf rdm`ojdi foxdi iurojb tgd suasdqudjt "Yomd
ef Yreuands" wgdj Juao` `ppd`rs te g`vd addj ehhupodi ay@fr`so`j Jem`is frem tgd Jertg-Rdst `ji `nse iurojb tgd
rdbomd ef tgd Dbypto`h ujovdrs`n st`td. wgohg w`s feujidi `ji
m`ojt`ojdi ay tgd Ygda`j dmpdrers ef tgd Dndvdjtg `ji Ywdnftg
Iyj`stods* Ygeubg Juao` w`s `jjdxdi te tgd Dbypto`h ujovdrs`n
st`td penotoh`nny. ots ojherper`toej ojte tgd Dbypto`h Rerni rdm`ojdi
supdrfoho`n. nold tgd ojherper`toej ef tgd seutgdrj sd`ae`ri ef
Hgoj` ojte tgd Xojoh Rerni ujidr tgd G`j* 0 Ygd Dbypto`h Hovonoz`-
toej w`s stonn dxetoh oj Juao`< `ji suhg neh`n ojtdr`htoej adtwddj
tgd twe hunturds `s teel pn`hd oj tg`t `bd rdsuntdi oj tgd a`ra`rozojbef tgd Dbypto`j b`rrosej `ji jet oj tgd hovonozojb ef tgd Juao`j
prendt`ro`t* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. Juao` w`s jet ejny penotoh`nny
`jjdxdi aut w`s `nsehuntur`nny `ssomon`tdi ay tgd rdsterdi Dbypto`h
ujovdrs`n st`td "tgd Jdw Dmpord" `ji `ftdr tgd erb`joz`toej ef
tgd jdw iemojoej ay Ygetgmds O 'ompdr`a`t horh` 0442-0434 A*H*/
tgd seutgdrj aeuji`ry ef tgd Dbypto`h Rerni steei jd`r tgd feet
ef tgd Feurtg H`t`r`ht. `t tgd jdw frejtodr-fertrdss ef J`p`t`.ojstd`i ef st`jiojb `t tgd gd`i ef tgd Forst H`t`r`ht `t tgd eni
frejtodr-fertrdss ef Dndpg`jtojd* Oj tgus idfojotovdny ojherper`tojb
Juao` ojte tgd Dbypto`h Rerni. tgd Ygda`j dmpdrers ef tgd
Dobgtddjtg Iyj`sty hut tgd reets ef tgdor ewj heujtry"s brd`tjdss*
Ygdy tr`jsfdrrdi frem tgd Ygda`oi te J`p`t` tgd monot`ry aur-
idj. `ji wotg ot tgd penotoh`n stomunus. ef sdrvojb `s tgd Xeutgdrj
M`rhg< `ji ej tgd ejd ehh`soej. iurojb tgd n`st soxtddj hdjturodsef Dbypto`h gostery. ej wgohg tgd jew prdv`ndjt penotoh`n p`r`-
meujthy ef tgd Jertgdrj M`rhgds w`s hejtdstdi ay tgd Xeutg. tgd
Xeutgdrj Sewdr wgohg `spordi te edhumdjoh`n `utgeroty g`i ots
reets oj tgd jdw Xeutgdrj M`rhg ef J`p`t` `ji jet oj tgd ho-
idv`jt Xeutgdrj M`rhg ef tgd Ygda`oi*
Rgdj tgd ard`l-up ef "tgd Jdw Dmpord" ojte suhhdsser-st`tds.
0 Xdd pp* 78-9. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 427/455
j6 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
ujidr tgd rund ef neh`n projhdnojbs idshdjidi frem Noay`j mdr-
hdj`rods. w`s fennewdi ay ` rd-pen`roz`toej ef penotoh`n pewdr `t tgd
twe dxtrdmotods ef tgd Dbypto`h Rerni. tgd twe pends oj tgd jdw
tdjsoej wdrd jet aetg heojhoidjt wotg tgesd `t wgohg pewdr g`iaddj hejhdjtr`tdi ej tgd dvd ef tgd feuji`toej ef tgd Tjotdi
Lojbiem. semd twe tgeus`ji fovd gujirdi yd`rs d`rnodr* Oj tgd
pest-Ompdro`n `bd. tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Jertgdrj Sewdr w`s iuny
pn`jtdi oj tgd Idnt`. tgos tomd `t Aua`stos. ay tgd Noay`j projhds ef
Gdr`hndepenos <wgond tgdsd n`ttdr-i`yNoay`j Gdr`hndepenotds" J`p`-
t`j lojsmdj 0 `ji hejtdmper`rods. wge dst`anosgdi tgd Xeutgdrj
Sewdr. rdt`ojdi tgdor h`pot`n `t J`p`t`. wgohgw`s jewtgd Xeutgdrj
peojtef
prdssurd`ji
stomunus.`ji ioi jet tr`jsfdr ot dotgdr te tgd
Ygda`oi er te `jy etgdr peojt oj tgd ojtdroer* Oj tgd funnjdss ef
tomd. tgos J`p`t`j Sewdr `ttdmptdi te dmun`td tgd tgrohd-rdpd`tdi
fd`t ef tgd Ygda`oi; tgd penotoh`nujofoh`toej ef tgd wgend Dbypto`h
Rerni ujidr ` sojbnd sevdrdobjty* Ygd jdw Xeutgdrj M`rhg.
gewdvdr. jew f`ondi te `hhempnosg wg`t tgd eni Xeutgdrj M`rhg
g`i `hgodvdi tgrohd evdr* Ygd J`p`t`j `ttdmpt te b`oj edhumdjo-
h`n pewdr. wgohg w`s ojoto`tdi ay L`sgt` wgdj gd `jjdxdi tgd
Ygda`oi horh` 243 A*H* `ji w`s `nmest h`rrodi te hempndtoej aySo`jlgowgdj gdm`id gos dxpdiotoej iewj-Jond ojte tgd Idnt` horh`
214. w`s frustr`tdi forst ay tgd `nodj @ssyro`j ojv`idrs `ji foj`nny
ay tgd ojiobdjeus Idnt`oh Sewdr ef tgd X`otds. wge adb`j `s tgd
@ssyro`js"hrd`turds `ji djidi`stgdorneh`n rdsoiu`ry ndb`tdds* Horh`
660-644 A*H*. tgd frejtodr adtwddj tgd X`otd `ji tgd J`p`t`j Sewdr
h`md te rdst `t Dndpg`jtojd< `ji tgdrd`ftdr tgos easendtd aeuji`ryadtwddj `j Dbypto`h Hovonoz`toej `ji ` Juao`j a`ra`rosm `hquordi` jdw fujhtoej `s tgd ojtdrj`n nojd ef idm`rh`toej adtwddj tgd twe
penotoh`n ujots ojte wgohg tgd djn`rbdi Dbypto`h Rerni w`s tgdjhd-
fertg pdrm`jdjtny iovoidi*
Ygus. oj tgd pest-Ompdro`n `bd. tgd eni Jertgdrj `ji tgd jdwXeutgdrj M`rhg aetg f`ondi te `tt`oj edhumdjoh`n pewdr oj tgd dji
<
`ji tgd rdsunt`jt penotoh`niu`nosm pdrsostdi iurojb tgd rdm`ojidr
ef Dbypto`h gostery* _dt tgeubg J`p`t` fdnn sgert. oj `hgodvdmdjt.
ef @n L`a `ji Ygdads. sgd w`s jet `ntebdtgdr ujrdspejsovd te tgd
stomunus ef dxtdrj`n prdssurd te wgohg. `s tgd n`ttdr-i`y Xeutgdrj
M`rhg ef tgd Dbypto`h Rerni. sgd g`i hemd te ad dxpesdi oj gdrturj* Ygd fermdr frejtodr-fertrdss ef "tgd Jdw Dmpord" ej tgd
Tppdr Jond adh`md tgd h`pot`n ef` "suhhdsser-st`td" wgohgdmar`hdi
g`nf. `nadot tgd merd a`hlw`ri g`nf. ef tgd n`ttdr-i`y dxp`jidi
Dbypto`h Rerni < `ji. ujnold tgd X`otds `ji tgdor suhhdssers oj tgd
0 Qdosjdr"s vodw tg`t tgdsd projhds ef J`p`t` wdrd Noay`js os jet `hhdptdi ay Diu`ri
Mdydr. wge subbdsts tg`t tgdy wdrd idshdjidi frem Gjger. tgd Gobg Srodst ef @mejwge dst`anosgdi tgd Ygda`j tgdehr`hy htrh` 0324 A*H* 'Bdshgohgtd ids @ntdrtums. ven* oo 'oo/.
`ji diotoej. p* 41/*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 428/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 002
Idnt`. tgd J`p`t`js ioi jet suhhuma te `nodj hejqudrers* Iurojbtgd nejb hdjturods wgdj Dbypt jertg ef Dndpg`jtojd w`s suh-
hdssovdny suakdht te tgd @hg`dmdjois `ji tgd Stendmods `ji tgd
Qem`js. Dtgoepo` seutg ef Dndpg`jtojd rdm`ojdi `j ojidpdjidjtDbypto`h Sewdr* Ojiddi. iurojb tgdsd hdjturods tgd iem`oj ef tgd
Dbypto`h Hunturd w`s dxtdjidi stonn f`rtgdr up-rovdr ujidr tgos
Dtgoepo`j rdbomd. ujton J`p`t` gdrsdnf. wge g`i st`rtdi gdr h`rddr
`s ` frejtodr-fertrdss. w`s rdndb`tdi te tgd ojtdroer `s Ygdads g`i
addj adferd gdr* Ygdrd`ftdr. horh` 833 A*H*. J`p`t` w`s suppn`jtdi.`s tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Dtgoepo`j st`td. ay Mdred `t tgd feet ef tgd
Xoxtg H`t`r`ht. moiw`y adtwddj tgdkujhtoejs eftgd @ta`r``ji tgd
Anud Jond wotg tgd m`ojrovdr<
`ji tgos Mdreotoh Sewdr novdiej.`s ` penotoh`nny ojidpdjidjt dmaeiomdjt ef tgd Dbypto`h Xehodty.
ujton tgd tgori hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. wgdj tgd Dbypto`hHunturd suffdrdi ` voendjt id`tg oj Dtgoepo` `t tgd g`jis ef a`r-
a`ro`j ojv`idrs. semd twe hdjturods adferd ot iodi pd`hdfunny oj
ots snddp oj Dbypt otsdnf*
Ygus tgd penotoh`n gostery ef tgd Dbypto`h Rerni. frem adbojjojbte dji. m`y ad rd`i `s ` tdjsoej adtwddj twe pends ef penotoh`n
pewdr wgohg. oj dvdry `bd. wdrd neh`tdi rdspdhtovdny oj tgd
Xeutgdrj `ji oj tgd Jertgdrj M`rhg ef tgd i`y* Ejd er etgdr
ef tgdsd m`rhgds w`s tgd hr`ind ef dvdry suhhdssfun er `aertovd
edhumdjoh`n iyj`sty* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. tgdrd `rd je dx`mpnds ef
edhumdjoh`n iyj`stods wgohg eroboj`tdi `t peojts oj tgd ojtdroer ef
tgd Dbypto`h Rerni* Ygd penotoh`n hrd`toejs ef tgd ojtdroer wdrd
sdniem merd tg`j p`rehgo`n <`ji dvdj wgdj edhumdjoh`n iyj`stods
wgesd reets n`y oj ejd ef tgd m`rhgds oj tgd Idnt` er oj tgd
Ygda`oi tr`jsfdrrdi tgdor h`pot`ns te pn`hds oj Moiind Dbypt fer
`imojostr`tovd hejvdjodjhd. penotoh`n pewdr w`s `pt te daa a`hl te
tgd m`rhgds `s seej `s tomds ejhd merd adh`md hrotoh`n* Fer
ojst`jhd. `ftdr tgd feuji`toej ef tgd Tjotdi Lojbiem. tgd h`pot`n
w`s tr`jsfdrrdi frem @n L`a. oj tgd Xeutgdrj M`rhg. wgohg g`i
addj tgd eroboj`n sd`t ef tgd feujidrs. te Mdmpgos ej tgd aeridr-
nojd adtwddj tgd twe n`jis ef tgd Ieuand Hrewj< ydt tgd jdw t`sl
ef feujiojb tgd Dbypto`h ujovdrs`n st`td `ftdr ` tomd ef treuands
w`s `hhempnosgdi ay ` iyj`sty frem Ygdads* @b`oj. `ftdr tgd
feuji`toej ef tgd ujovdrs`n st`td. tgd h`pot`n w`s tr`jsfdrrdi ejhd
merd. tgos tomd frem Ygdads te ` jdw hdjtr`n sotd kust `aevd Mdm-
pgos <
K
ydt tgd jdw t`sl ef rdsterojb tgd ujovdrs`n st`td `ftdr tgd
ojtrusoej ef tgd Gylses w`s `hhempnosgdi ay ` iyj`sty frem
Ygdads. wge tgus `ssdrtdi gdr penotoh`n petdjhy fer tgd sdheji
0 Ygos jdw hdjtr`n sotd. te wgohg tgd h`pot`n w`s tr`jsfdrrdi ay @mdjdmg`t O frem
Ygdads. w`s h`nndi Oz-Y`uo. wgohg md`jt "Hejqudrer ef aetg N`jis" 'Mdydr. D**
Bdshgohgtd ids @ntdrtumsZ ven* o'00/. 8ri diotoej. p* 162/*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 429/455
j7 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tomd* Foj`nny. `ftdr tgd rdster`toej ef tgd ujovdrs`n st`td. tgd
h`pot`n w`s tr`jsfdrrdi frem Ygdads ay Olgj`tej te gos jdw ompdro`n
hoty `t Ydnn-dn-@m`rj`. moi-w`y adtwddj Ygdads `ji Mdmpgos <
ydt tgos tr`jsfdr w`s `s dpgdmdr`n `s tgd rdnoboeus `ji `rtostoh
ojjev`toejs wotg wgohg ot w`s aeuji up*0
Tpej tgd id`tg ef tgd
ompdro`n rdvenutoej`ry. tgd h`pot`n rdvdrtdi te Ygdads `ji rdm`ojdi
tgdrd ujton tgd Ygda`oi p`oi tgd ojdvot`and pdj`nty fer g`vojb
hd`sdi te ad ` m`rhg ay ferfdotojb. ejhd fer `nn. ots `jhodjt `ji
nejb-djiurojb penotoh`n p`r`meujthy* Dvdj tgdj. tgd penotoh`n
gdrot`bd ef tgd Ygda`oi ioi jet f`nn te `jy iostroht oj tgd ojtdroer.
aut w`s iovoidi. `s wd g`vd sddj. adtwddj tgd eni Jertgdrj M`rhg
oj tgd Idnt` `ji tgd jdw Xeutgdrj M`rhg ef Juao`jJ`p`t`*
Oj tgd Xojoh Rerni
Ygd p`rt pn`ydi oj tgd hn`ssoh`n pdroei ef Dbypto`h gostery ay tgd
Ygda`oi tgd m`rhg wgohg rdnodvdi tgd ojtdroer ef tgd Dbypto`hRerni frem tgd prdssurd ef tgd a`ra`ro`js ef Juao` w`s pn`ydioj Xojoh gostery ay tgd v`nndys ef tgd Rdo-ge `ji tgd Fdj-ge. wgohg
wdrd tgd m`rhgds ef tgd Xojoh Rerni `b`ojst tgd a`ra`ro`j gobg-
n`jidrs ef Xgdjso `ji Xg`jso* Ygd Hgeu Iyj`sty. wgohg feujidi
tgd Xojoh dquov`ndjt ef tgd Dbypto`h Tjotdi Lojbiem tew`ris tgd
hnesd ef tgd sdheji monndjjoum A*H*. `ji tgd Ys"oj Iyj`sty. wgohg
feujidi tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd yd`r 110 A*H*. aetg eroboj`tdi
oj tgd Rdo V`nndy. wgond tgd Fdj V`nndy w`s tgd sd`t ef tgd Ysoj
Iyj`sty. wgohg w`s tgd rov`n ef tgd Ys"oj iurojb tgd forst pg`sdef tgd Xojoh Yomd ef Yreuands* Oj Xojoh. `s oj Dbypto`h. gostery.
tgdrd w`s ` tdjidjhy fer Sewdrs wgohg eroboj`tdi oj tgd m`rhgds
`ji `ftdrw`ris `tt`ojdi `j edhumdjoh`n iemojoej te tr`jsfdr tgdor
h`pot`ns frem tgd pdropgdry te tgd ojtdroer* Ygd sotd oj tgd Xojoh
Rerni wgohg herrdspejidi te tgd Dbypto`h Mdmpgos w`s Ney`jb
'tgd meidrj Gej`j-fu/* Ot n`y ej tgd aeridrnojd adtwddj tgd
wdstdrj v`nndys `ji tgd d`stdrj pn`oj.1 tr`vdrsdi ay tgd _dnnew
Qovdr oj ots newdr heursd. wgohg w`s tgd bdebr`pgoh`n gd`rt ef tgd
Xojoh Rerni*8 Ygd h`pot`n ef tgd Hg6u w`s tr`jsfdrrdi te tgd
jdobgaeurgeei ef Ney`jb frem tgd Rdo V`nndy `ftdr tgd iyj`sty
0 Fer ` ioshussoej ef Olgj`tej"s rend oj Dbypto`h gostery. sdd O* H 'oo/. ven o. pp* 094-6.
`aevd*1 Ygd dx`ht neh`toej ef Ney`jb w`s oj tgd v`nndy ef tgd Ne-ge. ` mojer robgt-a`jl
troaut`ry ef tgd _dnnew Qovdr wgohg idaeuhgds ojte tgd m`m strd`m kust adnew tgd_dnnew Qovdr"s dxot frem tgd berbds tg`t ojtdrvdjd adtwddj ots Newdr A`soj oj tgd d`stdrj
pn`oj `ji ots Tppdr A`soj oj tgd gobgn`jis wgdrd ot rdhdovds tgd w`tdrs ef tgd Rdo `jitgd Fdj*
8 Ygd totnd ef "Moiind Lojbiem+ 'Hgujb Lwe/. wgohg w`s dvdjtu`nny t`ldj evdr ay tgdXojoh ujovdrs`n st`td `s `j `ntdrj`tovd te "@nn tg`t os ujidr Gd`vdj+ 'Y"odj-gt`/: `ppd`rste g`vd addj aerjd eroboj`nny ay tgd nottnd projhop`noty ef Hgu. oj tgd moiind ef tgd
d`stdrj pn`oj. ej tgd aeridrnojd adtwddj tgd meidrj prevojhds ef Gej`j `ji Xg`jtujb*'Xdd Heriodr. G* ; Gostegd B6j6r`nd id n` Hgojd 'S`js 0?13-0. Bdutgjdr. 9 vens*/. ven* o.
p* 809/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 430/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 00?
g`i f`nndj ojte idh`idjhd<`ji oj ` n`tdr `bd tgd h`pot`n ef tgd
Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td. wgohg g`i addj neh`tdi eroboj`nny `t Hg"`jb
Jb`j oj tgd Rdo V`nndy ujidr tgd Sroer G`j. w`s tr`jsfdrrdi nold-
wosd te Ney`jb wgdj tgd Sestdroer G`j b`vd tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`nst`td ` sdheji nd`sd ef nofd* Ot os tgd merd sobjofoh`jt tg`t. jet-
wotgst`jiojb tgos rdpd`tdi `ttr`htoej ef tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Xojoh
Rerni frem tgd pdropgdry ojte tgd ojtdroer. tgd twe Sewdrs wgohg
m`id Xojoh gostery aetg eroboj`tdi oj tgd Rdstdrj M`rhg* Ygd
ejny Sewdr tg`t os hrdiotdi wotg `j eroboj`n sd`t oj tgd d`stdrj pn`ojos tgd sdmo-ndbdji`ry _oj er Xg`jb Iyj`sty. wgohg w`s tr`io-
toej`nny suppesdi te g`vd addj p`r`meujt adferd tgd Hgeu ujotdi
tgd d`stdrjpn`oj
wotg tgd Rdstdrj M`rhg ujidr tgdor
ewj shdptrd*
Oj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni
Rgdj wd turj te tgd gostery ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Hovonoz`toej
wgohg os "`ffono`tdi" te tgd Xojoh Hovonoz`toej. wd foji tg`t tgd
eshonn`toej adtwddj ` wdstdrj h`pot`n `ji `j d`stdrj h`pot`n. wgohg
g`i addj hg`r`htdrostoh ef tgd penotoh`n gostery ef tgd"`pp`rdjtdi"
hovonoz`toej. os rdpreiuhdi. wotg ` ioffdrdjhd. oj ` jdw eshonn`toej
adtwddj ` seutgdrj h`pot`n `ji ` jertgdrj*
Oj tgd Xojoh Rerni. tgdrd g`i addj ` tdjidjhy fer edhumdjoh`n
Sewdrs te eroboj`td oj tgd Rdstdrj M`rhg. ujidr stomunus frem
tgd prdssurd ef tgd surreujiojb a`ra`ro`j gobgn`jidrs. `ji te
tr`jsfdr tgdor h`pot`ns te sotds oj tgd ojtdroer ej tgd d`stdrj pn`oj*
Oj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni. tgd gd`vodst dxtdrj`n prdssurd h`md
frem ` ioffdrdjt seurhd `ji ` ioffdrdjt qu`rtdr* Ygd a`ra`ro`j
gobgn`jidrs ef Xgdjso `ji Xg`jso g`i addj suaiudi `ji `ssomon`tdi
ay tgd brewojb Sewdrs ef Ys"oj `ji Ysoj adferd tgd hnesd ef tgd
Xojoh Yomd ef Yreuands< aut tgos dnomoj`toej ef tgd a`ra`ro`js ef
tgd wdstdrj gobgn`jis g`i mdrdny rdmevdi ` auffdr wgohg g`i
prdvoeusny ojtdrvdjdi adtwddj tgd Xojoh Rerni `ji tgd f`r merd
fermoi`and Jem`ioh pdepnds ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd< `ji tgd
somunt`jdeus dxp`jsoej ef tgd twe Xojoh projhop`notods ef Hg`e `ji
_dj. `t tgd jertgdrj dji ef tgd d`stdrj pn`oj. ieuandi tgd ndjbtg ef
tgd jdw frejt adtwddj tgd Xojoh Rerni `ji Dur`so`* Ygos frejt
jew dxtdjidi frem tgd jertg-wdstdrj he`st ef tgd Bunf ef No`etujb
te tgd jertg-d`stdrj dsh`rpmdjt ef tgd Yoadt`j Sn`td`u* Ygd nojds
ef idfdjhd `b`ojst Jem`i ojre`is. wgohg g`i addj tgrewj up
podhdmd`n ay tgd hejtdjiojb st`tds ef tgd Xojoh Rerni. wotg suhg
djdrbods `s tgdy heuni sp`rd frem tgd n`st reuji oj tgdor ewj ojtdr-
jdhojd strubbnd. wdrd hejsenoi`tdi. `ftdr tgd "ljehl-eut anew" g`i
addj idnovdrdi `ji tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td feujidi ay Ys"oj Xgd
Gw`jb-to. ojte tgd Brd`t R`nn ef Hgoj`* 0 Ot w`s `hress tgd nojd ef
0 Xdd Heriodr. ep* hot*. ven* o. pp* 136-2*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 431/455
013 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
tgd R`nn. frem jertg te seutg. tg`t. semd fovd hdjturods n`tdr.
iurojb tgd ojtdrrdbjum 'horh` @*I* 024-924/ wgohg fennewdi tgd
ard`l-up eftgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td. tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is h`md oj.
`s a`ra`ro`j ojv`idrs. oj tgd pest-Xojoh Venldrw`jidrujb< `ji tgdprdssurd frem tgd jertg ioi jet hd`sd wgdj tgd jdw F`r D`stdrj
Hovonoz`toej dmdrbdi* Gdjhd. oj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni. tgdrd w`s
` tdjidjhy. frem tgd adbojjojb. fer edhumdjoh`n Sewdrs dotgdr te
eroboj`td oj tgd Jertgdrj M`rhgds er te tr`jsfdr tgdor h`pot`ns te
tgd Jertgdrj M`rhgds of tgdy g`i eroboj`tdi oj tgd seutgdrj
ojtdroer*
Fer ojst`jhd. tgd Sewdr wgohg dveldi. oj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni.`
bgestef tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td
0 oj tgd forst
`bdef F`r D`stdrj
gostery. eroboj`tdi. nold tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td otsdnf. oj tgd Rdo
V`nndy< `ji oj tgd jdw erodjt`toej ef penotoh`n bdebr`pgy tgd Rdo
V`nndy hejstotutdi tgd wdstdrj sdhtoej ef tgesd Jertgdrj M`rhgds
oj wgohg tgd prdssurd frem tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is w`s jew m`lojbotsdnf fdnt* Ot w`s gdrd tg`t tgd Xuo Iyj`sty. wgohg rd-dj`htdi tgd
p`rt ef Ys"oj Xgd Gw`jb-to ay ujotojb tgd wgend ef Xehodty ujidr
` sojbnd rund. dst`anosgdi ` jdw edhumdjoh`n h`pot`n `t Xo Jb`j 'tgd
meidrj Xo`j-fu/ oj tgd jdobgaeurgeei ef tgd `jhodjt
Hg"`jbJb`j*1 Xo Jb`j. ujidr tgd Xuo. irdw te otsdnf tgd pewdr tg`t g`i
prdvoeusny rdsoidi oj J`jlojb. tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Xeutg.8 wgohg tgd
Xuo g`i `jjdxdi te tgdor iemojoejs<`ji wgdj tgd Y"`jb Iyj`sty
rd`pdi tgd fruots ef tgd Xuo Iyj`sty"s n`aeurs. `s tgdor pretetypdstgd G`j g`i ejhd djtdrdi ojte tgd gdrot`bd ef Ys"oj Xgd Gw`jb-to.tgd Y"`jb ldpt tgd sd`t ef edhumdjoh`n pewdr `t Xo Jb`j. wgdrd
tgdy g`i feuji ot*
Xo Jb`j. gewdvdr. ioi jet rdt`oj ots prom`hy oj pdrpdtuoty <fer
tgd ojhoidjhd ef tgd prdssurd frem tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is tdjidi. oj
tgd heursd ef F`r D`stdrj gostery. te sgoft frem tgd wdstdrj sdhter
ef tgd Jertgdrj M`rhgds te tgd d`st. `ji tgd sd`t ef penotoh`n pewdroj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni sgoftdi d`stw`ris herrdspejiojbny* Ygos
sgoft w`s `pprexom`tdny hejtdmper`jdeus wotg tgd memdjt`ryard`liewj ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Edhumdjoh`n Sewdr iurojb tgd
ojtdrv`n adtwddj tgd dxtojhtoej ef tgd Y"`jb Iyj`sty oj @*I* ?32`ji tgd feuji`toej ef tgd Xujb Iyj`sty oj @*I* ?63*
Iurojb tgd Xujb @bd. F`r D`stdrj gostery hejsostdi. fer tgd m`ojaeiy ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Xehodty ej tgd Hejtojdjt.
9 oj ` snew `ji0 Xdd furtgdr tgd hemp`r`tovd stuiy. oj S`rt W. adnew. eftgd noldjdssds `ji ioffdrdjhds
adtwddj tgd dveh`toej ef tgd bgest ef tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni`ji tgd dveh`toej ef bgests ef tgd Gdnndjoh ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd Ertgeiex Hgrosto`j `jiRdstdrj wernis*
+ Fer Hg"`jb Jb`j. tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td ujidr tgd Sroer G`j. sdd
p* u ?. `aevd* 8 Xdd p* 011. feetjetd o. adnew*+ Ygd ioffdrdjt heursd t`ldj ay tgd gostery ef tgd effsgeet ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Xehodty
evdrsd`s. oj K`p`j. os dx`mojdi adnew oj tgd prdsdjt sdhtoej. ej pp* 047-?. `s wdnn `s ojS`rts VO `ji VOOO*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 432/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 010
stuaaerj rdtrd`t ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Edhumdjoh`n Sewdr frem jertg
te Xeutg ujidr `j dvdr ojhrd`sojb prdssurd frem ` suhhdssoej ef
Jem`i Sewdrs epdr`tojb frem M`jhguro`* Ygd Lgot`j g`i
dxtertdi tgd hdssoej ef soxtddj iostrohts `nejb tgd jertgdrj aeridrhorh` @*I* ?12-82. adferd tgd edhumdjoh`n `utgeroty ef tgd Xujb g`i
addj dst`anosgdi< tgd Lgot`js+ suhhdssers. tgd Loj. hejqudrdifrem tgd Xujb. horh` @*I* 0014-91. tgd wgend ef Jertgdrj Hgoj`
iewj te tgd w`tdrsgdi adtwddj tgd _dnnew Qovdr `ji tgd _`jbtsd<
`ji. wgdj tgd Loj g`i addj suppn`jtdi oj tgdor turj ay tgd Mej-
bens. tgd Mejben Brd`t Lg`j Puaon`y 'ompdr`a`t @*I* 014?-?9/
hempndtdi tgd werl ef gos Loj `ji Lgot`j prdidhdssers ay dxtoj-
buosgojb
tgd
Xujb `ntebdtgdr
`jirdujotojb
tgd wgend ef tgd m`oj
aeiy ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni ujidr ` a`ra`ro`j iemojoej* Ygdtoid ef a`ra`ro`j hejqudst. gewdvdr. g`i je seejdr djbunfdi tgd n`st
rdmj`jt ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Xehodty ej tgd m`ojn`ji tg`j ot adb`jte rdhdid <
`ji tgd peojt ef ojtdrdst. fer eur prdsdjt purpesd. nods oj
tgd sdqudn wgohg fennewdi tgd dvohtoej ef tgd Mejbens frem Hgoj`
oj @*I* 08670
ay ` jdw tgereubgardi Hgojdsd Sewdr; tgd Mojb*Ygos jdw tgereubgardi Hgojdsd iyj`sty `resd oj tgd s`md
qu`rtdr oj wgohg tgdor n`st tgereubgardi prdidhdssers. tgd Xujb.g`i gdni eut nejbdst. tg`t os te s`y oj tgd Xeutg< `ji tgd feujidr
ef tgd Mojb. Gujb Ru. sobj`nozdi tgd dxpunsoej ef tgd a`ra`ro`js
frem Hgoj` `ji tgd rdster`toej ef ` bdjuojd Hgojdsd rdbomd ay `
sendmj tr`jsfdr ef tgd h`pot`n*
Rgdj tgd Loj g`i hejqudrdi Jertgdrj Hgoj`. tgdy g`i dst`a-
nosgdi tgdor h`pot`n ej tgd sotd ef tgd meidrj Sdlojb '+tgd Jertgdrj
H`pot`n"/. ej tgd aeridrnojd adtwddj tgd a`ra`ro`j pertoej ef tgdor
iemojoejs te tgd jertg ef tgd Brd`t R`nn `ji tgd Hgojdsd pertoej
te tgd seutg ef ot*1 Ygd s`md sotd hemmdjidi otsdnf. fer tgd s`md
bdebr`pgoh`n rd`sej. te Puaon`y<8 `ji oj gos rdobj Sdlojb adh`md
tgd h`pot`n jet mdrdny ef ` rdujotdi Hgoj` aut ef ` ujovdrs`n st`td
wgohg dxtdjidi frem tgd S`hofoh he`sts ef @so` robgt `hress tgd
hejtojdjt `s f`r `s tgd Sdrso`j Bunf `ji tgd Dupgr`tds `ji tgd
H`rp`tgo`js `ji tgd A`ntoh `ji tgus dmar`hdi tgd wgend horhum-
fdrdjhd ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd* Ygos Loj `ji Mejben h`pot`n w`s
j`tur`nny eajexoeus te tgd Hgojdsd `s ` rdmojidr ef tgd a`ra`ro`j
+ Ygd ojsurrdhtoej `b`ojst tgd Mejbens wgohg djidi oj tgdor dvohtoej adb`j `aeuttgd yd`r 0840*
+Hemp`rd tgd neh`toej ef tgd Gylses+ h`pot`n. Y`jos. ej tgd
aeridrnojdZadtwddj tgd
jej-Dbypto`h pertoej ef tgdor iemojoejs oj Xyro` `ji tgd Dbypto`h pertoej oj tgd Newdr
Jond V`nndy* 'Xdd p* 008. feetjetd 8. `aevd*/8 Puaon`y adb`j te rdhejiotoej Sdlojb oj @I* 0169 `ji tr`jsfdrrdi gos h`pot`n
tgotgdr oj 0162 frem P`r`qerum. wgohg w`s gos `jhdstr`n h`pot`n oj tgd A`soj ef tgd
Erlgej. oj tgd gd`rt ef Dur`so`* @t tgd s`md tomd gd ldpt `feetojb
ej tgd Xtdppd ay
auoniojb gomsdnf ` suasoio`ry rdsoidjhd. wotgoj d`sy rd`hg ef Sdlojb. `t Hgujb-Yu
'Hendroibd"s W`j`iu/ kust eutsoid tgd Brd`t R`nn*
"Oj W`j`iu ioi Luan` Lg`j@ st`tdny pnd`surd-iemd idhrdd* * * *"
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 433/455
011 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
yeld wgohg tgdy g`i aerjd se nejb `ji g`i ejny kust suhhddidi oj
tgrewojb eff* @hheriojbny. Gujb Ru g`i je seejdr irovdj tgd
Jem`is eut `b`oj ojte tgdor j`tovd stdppds `ji rd-dst`anosgdi tgd
frejtodr ef ` noadr`tdi Hgoj` `nejb tgd nojd ef tgd Brd`t R`nn. tg`jgd tr`jsfdrrdi tgd h`pot`n frem Puaon`y"s hoty te J`jlojb. wgohg
g`i addj tgd "H`pot`n ef tgd Xeutg" `t tgd i`wj ef F`r D`stdrj
gostery*0
Gujb Ru n`oi eut gos jdw hoty `t J`jlojb ej ` sh`nd
hemmdjsur`td wotg tgd sozd ef tgd brd`tdr dmpord ef wgohg ot w`s
idsobjdi te ad tgd h`pot`n gdjhdferw`ri* _dt jdotgdr gosteroh`n
sdjtomdjt jer huntur`n `meur preprd jer `imojostr`tovd hej-
vdjodjhd jer ` n`vosg eutn`y ej puanoh auoniojbs `v`ondi te rdt`oj
tgdh`pot`n
ef tgd
Mojb Dmpordej tgos sotd oj tgd ojtdroer* Fer
tgeubg tgd Jem`is g`i addj dxpdnndi frem Hgoj` fer tgd memdjt
ay Gujb Ru"s prewdss. gd heuni jet dxerhozd tgd i`jbdr ef tgdor
pessoand rdturj * Ej tgd merrew ef tgdor dxpunsoej. `s tgdy adb`j te
rdhevdr frem tgdor memdjt`ry prestr`toej `ji te r`nny tgdor ferhds
nold X`t`j `ji gos `jbdns oj tgd dxerioum ef S`r`iosd Nest. tgdor
prdssurd adh`md pdrhdptoand ejhd merd `t tgd peojt wgdrd ot g`i
addj m`lojb otsdnf fdnt fer tgd p`st fovd hdjturods tg`t os. oj tgd
d`stdrj sdhter ef tgd Jertgdrj M`rhg `ji. ejhd `b`oj. tgd peojt
wgohg w`s ad`rojb tgd arujt ef tgd penotoh`n prdssurd irdw te otsdnf
tgd prom`hy oj penotoh`n pewdr* Oj @*I* 0910. Gujb Ru"s sej `ji
sdheji suhhdsser. _ujb Ne 'rdbj`a`t @*I* 0938-14/. rdtr`jsfdrrdi
tgd h`pot`n ef Hgoj` frem gos ewj f`tgdr"s hgesdj hoty ef J`jlojbte tgd vdry hoty ef Sdlojb wgohg g`i forst addj r`osdi te gejeur aytgd gdrdiot`ry a`ra`ro`j djdmy*
_ujb Ne"s rdvdrsoej fremh
tgd Xeutgdrj H`pot`n" oj tgd ojtdroer
te "tgd Jertgdrj H`pot`n" oj tgd M`rhgds w`s kustofodi ay tgd dvdjt*
Ojiddi. tgd rdjdwdi prdssurd frem tgd jertg adh`md se strejb
tg`t. tgeubg tgd rdtr`jsfdrdjhd ef tgd h`pot`n te tgd i`jbdr-peojt
pestpejdi tgd i`y ef frdsg ios`stdr fer Hgoj`. ot heuni jet fer dvdr
`vdrt ot* Oj @*I* 060?-99. r`tgdr merd tg`j twe hdjturods `ftdr
_ujb Ne"s st`tdsm`jnold mevd. tgd Brd`t R`nn w`s areldj tgreubg`ji Sdlojb h`pturdi `ji `nn Hgoj` evdrruj ay ` jdw Sewdr frem
tgd jertg-d`stdrj je-m`j"s-n`ji oj tgd sg`pd ef tgd M`jhgus<
1 `ji
0J`jlojb g`i addj hejtojueusny tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Xeutg. ujidr fovd suhhdssovd
iyj`stods. frem @ I* 802 'tgd i`td wgohg s`w tgd dji ef tgd dpgdmdr`n rdster`toej eftgd Xojoh ujovdrs`n st`td ujidr tgd se-h`nndi "Tjotdi Ysoj"/ iewj te @ I* 47? 'tgd i`td
wgohg s`w tgd dveh`toej ef ` bgest ef tgd Xmoh ujovdrs`n st`td ay tgd Xuo/* Oj @ I* 47?tgd Xuo `jjdxdi tgd Xeutg te tgdor ewj Jertgdrj iemojoejs `ji tgdrday ujotdi tgd
wgend F`r D`stdrj Rerni ef tgd i`y ujidr ` sojbnd rund 'Xdd p* 013. `aevd /1 Tjnold tgd Mejbens. tgd M`jhgus wdrd jet stehl-arddiojb Jem`is aut promotovd
gujtdrs wge wdrd `t gemd. jet ej tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd. aut m tgd gobgn`jis hn`i
oj vorboj ferdst wgohg aeuji. ej tgd d`st. tgd d`stdrjmest djhn`vd ef tgd Dur`so`j
Xtdppd oj tgd hemmej a`soj ef tgd Qovdrs No`e `ji Xujb`ro* Ygd p`rtohun`r M`jhguhemmujoty wgohg hejqudrdi Hgoj` oj tgd sdvdjtddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`h`md frem tgd sdhtoej ef tgos gobgn`ji-ferdst heujtry tg`t nods adtwddj Lorm `ji tgdS`hofoh he`st* Ygdsd M`jhgu hejqudrers ef Hgoj`. adojb stonn ej tgd promotovd ndvdn `t
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 434/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 018
oj tgd dobgtddjtg hdjtury eftgd Hgrosto`jDr` tgd M`jhgu sevdrdobjHg"odj Nujb rundi frem Sdlojb
0 `j dmpord ujotojb `nn Hgoj` `ji
g`nf Dur`so` ujidr ` hemmej iemojoej wgohg heuni ad`r hem-
p`rosej wotg tgd dmpord tg`t g`i ejhd addj rundi frem Sdlojbay tgd Mejben Brd`t Lg`j Puaon`y gomsdnf* Frem @*I* 0910iewj te @*I* 0?17. Sdlojb rdm`ojdi tgd h`pot`n ef Hgoj` tgreubg`nn vohossotuids* Ygd `ttdmpt ef tgd Y"`op"ojb ojsurbdjts. oj tgd
moiind ef tgd jojdtddjtg hdjtury.1 te arojb a`hl tgd h`pot`n te
J`jlojb henn`psdi wotg tgd f`onurd ef tgdor djid`veur. ef wgohg ot
w`s ` p`rt. te id`n wotg tgd M`jhgus `s tgd Mojb g`i id`nt wotg tgd
Mejbens* Oj 0?17. gewdvdr. tgd Dmpdrer _ujb Ne"s gosteroh `ht
w`s rdvdrsdi. `t n`st.
aySrdsoidjt
Hgo`jb L`o-sgdl<`ji `t tgd
tomd ef wrotojb J`jlojb os tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh.wgond Sdlojb g`s addj idbr`idi te tgd r`jl ef ` prevojho`n hdjtrd
ujidr tgd adnottnojb totnd ef Sdpojb*Os tgos hg`jbd noldny te ad pdrm`jdjt5 @ji. of ot os. wonn ot
monot`td `b`ojst tgd v`noioty ef eur seho`n "n`w" tg`t m`rhgds `rd
`pt te ad stomun`tdi. ay tgd dxtdrj`n prdssurd te wgohg tgdy `rd
dxpesdi. ojte idvdnepojb ` penotoh`n pewdr wgohg bovds tgdm `
prdiemoj`jhd evdr tgd ojtdroer5 Oj tgd wrotdr"s adnodf. tgd rdhdjt
tr`jsfdr ef tgd Hgojdsd h`pot`n frem Sdlojb te J`jlojb os noldny
te ad pdrpdtu`tdi. `ji tgos kust adh`usd. se f`r frem ojv`noi`tojb eur
"n`w". ot `htu`nny onnustr`tds `ji hejforms ot*
Gew `rd wd te `hheujt fer tgd suhhdss ef tgd Luemojt`jb oj rd-
tr`jsfdrrojb tgd h`pot`n ef Hgoj` frem Sdlojb te J`jlojb semd
tgrdd-qu`rtdrs ef ` hdjtury `ftdr tgd Y"`op"ojb"s f`onurd oj tgdor
`ttdmpt te ie tgos vdry tgojb5 Ygd dxpn`j`toej os te ad feuji oj
hdrt`oj f`r-rd`hgojb tr`jsferm`toejs ef Hgoj`"s gum`j djvorej-
mdjt wgohg g`vd t`ldj pn`hd iurojb tgd ojtdrv`n*
Oj "tgd dobgtddj-foftods" ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. tgd qu`rtdr frem
wgohg Hgoj` w`s suakdht te tgd gd`vodst dxtdrj`n prdssurd w`s stonn
tgd jertg. `s ot g`i addj sojhd tgd adbojjojb ef F`r D`stdrj gostery*
@t tg`t memdjt. Hgoj` w`s ujidr iod rund ef ` iyj`sty ef jertg-
a`ra`ro`j eroboj wgesd feujidr g`i ferhdi gos djtry ay ard`lojb
tgreubg tgd Brd`t R`nn. oj ots d`stdrj sdhter. frem jertg te seutg<
tgd tomd ef tgd hejqudst. wdrd muhg merd rd`iony `ssomon`tdi te tgd F`r D`stdrj hunturd.
`ji `aseradi ojte tgd F`r D`stdrj aeiy seho`n. tg`j tgdor Mejben prdidhdssers. wge g`idjtdrdi Hgoj` `s funn-fndibdi Dur`so`j Jem`is wotg ` tojhturd ef tgd `aertovd F`r
D`stdrj Hgrosto`j hunturd ef tgd Jdstero`j Io`sper` 'sdd OO* I 'vo/. pp* 182-7. adnew/*
Fer tgd promotovd hunturd ef tgd M`jhgus. sdd N`ttujerd. Ewdj; M`jhguro` Hr`ind ef
Hejfnoht 'Jdw _erl 0 ?8 1. M`hmonn`j/. pp* 99-4 * Ot wonn ad sddj tg`t tgd M`jhgu hejqudst
ef Hgoj` ioffdrdi frem tgd Mejben hejqudst aetg oj j`turd `ji oj euthemd. `ji aerd `
brd`tdr rdsdman`jhd te tgd Hgohgomdh hejqudst ef Mdxohe*0 Ygd M`jhgu rundrs ef Hgoj` fennewdi Puaon`y"s dx`mpnd ay suppndmdjtojb tgdor
h`pot`n `t Sdlojb. ej Hgojdsd seon. wotg ` sdheji`ry rdsoidjhd ` bnerofodi gujtojb neibd
`ji summdr rdtrd`t eutsoid tgd Brd`t R`nn* Ygos M`jhgu heujtdrp`rt ef Puaon`y"s
W`j`iu+ w`s Kdgen oj D`stdrj Ojjdr Mejbeno`*` Ygd Y"`op"ojb ojsurrdhtoej n`stdi frem @*I* 0743 te @*I* 0769*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 435/455
019 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
`ji. `hheriojb te eur "n`w". ot w`s te ad dxpdhtdi tg`t tgd h`pot`n ef
Hgoj` weuni rdm`oj oj tgd zejd ef prdssurd tg`t os te s`y. `t
Sdlojb. oj tgd d`stdrj sdhter ef tgd Jertgdrj M`rhgds se nejb `s
tgos st`td ef `ff`ors hejtojudi* Ay 0?17. gewdvdr. ` gosteroh sotu`-
toej wgohg g`i stonn addj ojt`ht oj "tgd dobgtddj-foftods" g`i adhemd
djtordny easendtd< `ji tgd Hgojdsd Senotoh`n Qdvenutoej ef 0?00.
wgohg evdrtgrdw tgd M`jhgu Iyj`sty `ji put `j dji te tgd
M`jhgu `shdji`jhy oj Hgoj` Srepdr. w`s ay je md`js tgd mest
rdvenutoej`ry dvdjt oj tgos r`ioh`n hg`jbd* Ygd M`jhgu Iyj`sty`ji tgd M`jhgu A`jjdrmdj wge g`i tr`jsfdrrdi tgdor rdsoidjhd
frem M`jhguro` te Hgoj` `t tgd tomd ef tgd hejqudst g`i addj hej-
vdrtdi te Hgojdsd hunturd
m`jy bdjdr`toejsadferd
tgdywdrd
putiewj frem tgdor sd`tay Hgojdsd J`toej`nosm* 0 Ygd rd`nny memdjt-
eus hg`jbd oj tgd sotu`toej sojhd tgd f`onurd ef tgd Y"`op"ojb g`s
addj jet penotoh`n aut dhejemoh. `ji g`s hejsostdi oj ` heujtdr-
effdjsovd ef tgd Hgojdsd huntov`ter `b`ojst tgd Jem`i gdrism`j*1
Ygos Hgojdsd henejoz`toej ef tgd stdppd heujtry. wgohg w`s wdnn
ujidr w`y adferd 0?00. g`s addj f`honot`tdi ay tgd n`psd ef tgd
M`jhgu rdbomd"s mobr`toej-rdstrohtoejs `ji g`s addj stomun`tdi
aytgd
suasdqudjt r`v`bds
ef hovon w`r `jia`jiotry
`ji f`mojd `ji
fneei oj tgd gd`rt ef Hgoj` otsdnf; ` feurfeni sheurbd wgohg g`s addj
irovojb tgd Hgojdsd pd`s`jtry ef Xg`jtujb `ji Gej`j `ji Hgogno
te dmobr`td oj tgdor gujirdis ef tgeus`jis te tgd dmpty `ji
ujg`r`ssdi vorboj n`jis ef M`jhguro` `ji Ojjdr Mejbeno`* Ygus.
te-i`y. tgd Brd`t R`nn je nejbdr m`rls tgd aeuji`ry adtwddj
Hgojdsd pd`s`jt `ji a`ra`ro`j Jem`i* Ygd nojd `hress wgohg tgd
Jem`i ojv`idr g`s trdsp`ssdi se m`jy tomds iurojb tgd n`st twe
tgeus`ji yd`rs g`s addj ndft f`r adgoji oj tgd Hgojdsd pd`s`jt"s
pd`hdfun aut petdjt heujtdr-effdjsovd. ujton jew ` are`i zejd ef
tgd stdppd-n`ji wgohg tgd Mejben gdrism`j usdi te r`jbd g`s
0Ojiddi. ot weuni g`riny ad `j dx`bbdr`toej te s`y tg`t tgd M`jhgu Iyj`sty
`ji Jeaonoty. `t `jy r`td. g`i addj Xojofodi adferd tgdy hressdi tgd Brd`t R`nn oj@I* 060?* Fer tgdor prdvoeus dxtr`-mur`n iemojoejs g`i ojhnuidi jet ejny tgdor ewjeroboj`n gemdn`ji oj tgd ferdst-hn`i gobgn`jis d`st ef Loroj aut `nse tgd rdn`tovdny wdnn-
w`tdrdi pertoej ef tgd newn`jis oj tgd No`e Qovdr a`soj wgohg g`i addj areubgt ujidrtgd pneubg ay Hgojdsd pd`s`jt-henejosts `ji g`i addj sgodnidi frem Jem`i ojhursoejs
ay tgd hejstruhtoej ef tgd Ronnew S`nos`id; ` jertg-d`stdrj prenejb`toej ef tgd Brd`tR`nn wgohg t`lds eff frem tgd R`nn kust `aevd Xg`jg`olw`j `ji rujs iewj tgd d`stdrj
dsh`rpmdjt ef tgd Hdjtr`n @so`j Sn`td`u `ji tgdj `hress tgd Xeutg M`jhguj`j pn`ojs
ujton ot strolds tgd ndft a`jl ef tgd Tppdr Xujb`j `ftdr tr`vdrsojb tgd feet-gonns ef tgdd`stdrj meujt`ojs adtwddj Hg`jbhguj `ji Lorm* Ay tgd tomd wgdj tgd M`jhgusidshdjidi frem tgdor gobgn`jis. tgdsd wdnn-w`tdrdi `ji henejozdi `ji huntov`tdi `jipretdhtdi newn`jis g`i adhemd ` Hgojdsd heujtry< `ji ot w`s `t Mulidj. oj tgos
Hgojdsd monodu. tg`t tgd M`jhgus gdni tgdor heurt adferd tgdy hressdi tgd R`nn `jimevdi te Sdlojb* Ygos rdsoidjhd `t Mulidj Xojofodi tgd M`jhgu projhds `s dffdhtovdny`s
tgdZXhettosg lojbs wdrd @jbnohozdi ay tr`jsfdrrojb tgdor rdsoidjhd frem tgd Gobgn`jiste Diojaurbg. `ji tgd @hg`dmdmi`d A`aynejohozdi ay tr`jsfdrrojb tgdors frem Sdrsoste Xus`* G`nf tgd A`jjdrmdj wge hejqudrdi ojtr`-mur`n Hgoj` fer tgd M`jhguIyj`sty wdrd jet M`jhgus `t `nn. aut Xeutg-M`jhguro`j Hgojdsd< `ji tgd se-h`nndiM`jhgu hejqudst ef Hgoj` w`s. oj dffdht. ` Hgojdsd hovon w`r* 'Xdd N`ttomerd. ep* hot*.
SS- 9X-2O-/8 Fer tgos. sdd furtgdr S`rt OOO* @. ven
ooo. pp* 06-11. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 436/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 014
addj areubgt ujidr tgd Hgojdsd pneubg* Tjidr tgd heujtdr-
`tt`hl ef tgdsd dvdr `iv`jhojb furrews. tgd Mejbens g`vd `nmest
dv`hu`tdi tgdor fermdr p`sturdn`jis seutg ef tgd Beao Idsdrt.wgond
tgd M`jhgus g`vd adhemd `nmest dxtojht oj "tgd Ygrdd D`stdrjSrevojhds" ef tgd Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh wgohg `rd stonn pepun`rny ljewj`s M`jhguro`* Oj etgdr weris. tgd djvorejs ef Sdlojb g`vd hd`sdi
te ad ` m`rhg `ji g`vd adhemd `ssomon`tdi te tgd ojtdroer fer tgd
forst tomd oj F`r D`stdrj gostery< `ji ot os oj `hheri`jhd wotg
eur n`w tg`t oj tgdsd jdw horhumst`jhds Sdlojb otsdnf sgeuni fer-
fdot ots nejb-m`ojt`ojdi st`tus ef adojb tgdh`pot`n ef Hgoj`* 0
Aut g`s J`jlojb ujidrbejd `jy hejvdrsd hg`jbd ef horhum-
st`jhds wgohg djtotnds ot te
rd-`hquord
tgd st`tus wgohgSdlojb
g`s
jew nest 5 Of eur n`w os te ad vojioh`tdi hempndtdny. wd must ad
`and te idmejstr`td tg`t. hejhurrdjtny. tgd djvorejs ef J`jlojbg`vd hd`sdi te ad p`rt ef tgd ojtdroer. `s tgdy g`vd addj gotgdrte
sojhd tgd adbojjojb ef F`r D`stdrj gostery. `ji g`vd adhemd `
m`rhg< `ji. `s seej `s wd st`td tgd preandm oj tgdsd tdrms. wd
pdrhdovd tg`t. oj tgos qu`rtdr. tgdrd g`s oj f`ht addj ` tr`jsferm`-
toej ef Hgoj`"s gum`j djvorejmdjt wgohg os jet ndss f`r-rd`hgojb
tg`j tgd hg`jbd oj tgd jertg* Rgond. `nejb tgd jertgdrj n`ji-
frejtodrs ef Hgoj`. tgd eni prdssurd frem tgd Jem`is ef tgd
Dur`so`j Xtdppd g`s br`iu`nny addj rdiuhdi te v`josgojb peojt `ji
g`s n`ttdrny bovdj pn`hd te ` heujtdr-prdssurd upej tgd Jem`is
frem tgd Hgojdsd. Hgoj` g`s addj dxpesdi hejtdmper`jdeusny te `
jdw prdssurd. ef std`iony ojhrd`sojb ojtdjsoty. `nejb gdr d`stdrj
frejt`bd. wgdrd sgd f`hds tgd sd`* Oj d`rnodr `bds ef F`r D`stdrj
gostery. tgd he`st-nojd ef Hgoj` w`s tgd qu`rtdr ej wgohg tgd
prdssurd upej gdr w`s nd`st sdvdrd* X`vd fer tgd idsuntery vosots ef
@r`a `ji Sdrso`j Musnom mdrhg`jt-sgops oj tgd Y"`jb pdroei `jitgd idsuntery r`ois ef K`p`jdsd por`tds oj tgd Mojb pdroei. tgd sd`
rdm`ojdi. frem tgd Hgojdsd st`jipeojt. "` pdrfdht `ji `asenutd
an`jl". ujton. semd feur hdjturods `be. ot adh`md tgd vdgohnd ef tgd
omp`ht ef eur Rdstdrj Hovonoz`toej upej tgd F`r D`st+
Ygos omp`ht ef ` gum`j ferhd frem tgd eppesotd soid ef tgd bnead
w`s fddand `t forst<`ji ot os ndss tg`j ` hdjtury `be tg`t ot adb`j te
`hquord ots prdsdjt fermoi`and memdjtum* @t tgd i`td. fer ojst`jhd.
wgdj tgd Y"`op"ojb m`id tgdor ujsuhhdssfun `ttdmpt te rdtr`jsfdrtgd h`pot`n ef Hgoj` te J`jlojb. tgd Rdstdrj ojtdrj`toej`n sdttnd-
mdjt ef Xg`jbg`o w`s stonn oj ots pujy ojf`jhy; `j ujrdb`ridi
aujhg ef "beiewjs" pn`jtdi ej ` mui-a`jl up ` a`hlw`tdr ef
tgd_`jbtsd dstu`ry* Ye-i`y Xg`jbg`o os jet ejny tgd brd`tdst ef tgd
trd`ty-perts tg`t stui tgd he`st ef Hgoj` frem H`jtej `t ejd dji
0 Hemp`rd tgd diopsd ef Ygdads `ftdr ot g`i addj rdndb`tdi te tgd ojtdroer ef tgd
Dbypto`hRerni tgreubg tgd ojherper`toej ef Juao` 'sdd tgd prdsdjt hg`ptdr. pp 0 09-07.
`aevd/*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 437/455
016 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
te Yodjtsoj `t tgd etgdr* Xgd os `nse ejd ef tgd brd`tdst perts `ji
brd`tdst hotods oj tgd Rerni. `ji. te `nn `ppd`r`jhd. sgd hemm`jis
` futurd tg`t wonn quotd dhnopsd gdr ompesojb prdsdjt* Oj etgdr
weris. `s Hgoj`"s jertgdrj n`jiw`ri m`rhgds g`vd f`nndj ojte
`trepgy wotg tgd hdss`toej ef prdssurd frem tgd Jem`is. ` jdw
d`stdrj m`rotomd m`rhg g`s addj areubgt ojte dxostdjhd ay ` jdw
prdssurd frem evdrsd`s wgohg os adojb dxdrtdi upej Hgoj` ay tgd
Rdstdrjdrs* Ygos jdw m`rotomd m`rhg g`s t`ldj tgd pn`hd ef tgd
eni n`jiw`ri m`rhg `s tgd qu`rtdr frem wgohg tgd ojhoidjhd ef
dxtdrj`n prdssurd upej Hgoj` os gd`vodst< `ji tgd sdhter oj wgohg
ot os jew gd`vodst ef `nn os tgd hdjtr`n sdhter hejt`ojojb Xg`jbg`o*
Xg`jbg`oos tgd
peojtef tgd
spd`rwgohg tgd Rdst os
tgrustojbojte
Hgoj`"s soid<`ji `hheriojbny. oj tgd penotoh`n bdebr`pgy ef Hgoj`.
`s ot g`s hemd te ad rd-erodjt`tdi iurojb tgd n`st tgrdd-qu`rtdrs ef
` hdjtury. tgd prevojhd ef Lo`jbsu. ojwgohg Xg`jbg`o os dmadiidi.
g`s suhhddidi te tgd gosteroh pesotoej ef tgd prevojhd ef Hgogno.
wgohg usdi te nod `tgw`rt tgd w`r-p`tgs ef Jem`i ojv`idrs frem
Mejbeno` `ji M`jhguro`* 0
Jew J`jlojb ehhupods oj Lo`jbsu ` pesotoej herrdspejiojb te
0
Ygd rd`idr ef tgos p`ss`bd m`y idmur te tgos ompnodi rdndb`toej ef M`jhguj` te `sdheji`ry rend< fer gd h`j peojt eut tg`t M`jhguro` g`s jdvdr hd`sdi te ad ` zejd mwgohg dxtdrj`n prdssurd os adojb areubgt te ad`r upej Hgoj` `ji tg`t. sojhd tgd o7tg-
obtg Xdptdmadr. 0?80. tgd prdssurd upej Hgoj` frem tgos qu`rtdr g`s adhemd se ojtdjsd
tg`tZotg`s hemd te ad rdb`ridi `s ` m`ttdr ef werni-woid hejhdrj* Ygos os quotd trud<
aut ot sgeuni `nse ad easdrvdi tg`t. sojhd tgd n`st idh`id ef tgd jojdtddjtg hdjtury ef tgd
Hgrosto`j Dr`. tgd prdssurd wgohg g`s addj dxdrtdi upej Hgoj` tgreubg M`jhguro`g`s jet addj tgd prdssurd dotgdr ef Mejben Jem`iosm er ef M`jhgu A`ra`rosm Oj
tgdsd n`ttdr i`ys. tgd prdssurd tgreubg M`jhguro` g`s addj dxdrtdi ay Qusso` `ji
K`p`j< `ji ot g`s addj dxdrtdi ay tgdsd twe Sewdrs `s ` hejsdqudjhd ef tgd prehdss ef
Rdstdrjoz`toej wgohg d`hg eftgdm g`s prdvoeusny ujidrbejd Oj f`ht. Qusso` `ji K`p`joj M`jhguro` `rd `htojb `s rdprdsdjt`tovds ef tgd Rdst< `ji. oj vortud ef tgos. tgd
ompert`jhd ef M`jhguro` `s ` hg`jjdn hejiuhtojb tew`ris Hgoj` tgd `bbrdssoej ef tgd
Rdst os `t nd`st `s brd`t+ `t tgd prdsdjt i`y "`s ots ompert`jhd oj arojbojb tgd dxp`jsovdpewdrs ef Hgoj` te ad`r ej tgd frejtodr"* 'N`ttomerd. ep hot*. p* 14?*/ Tjidr tgd sg`iewef tgd Xoje-Qusso`j hejfnoht oj M`jhguro` oj 0?1? `ji tgd merd fermoi`and Xoje-
K`p`jdsd hejfnoht oj M`jhguro` wgohg h`md te ` gd`i oj 0?80. `j easdrvdr mobgt adojhnojdi tekuibd tg`t. wgond tgd pdrsej`noty ef tgd `bbrdsser oj M`jhguro` g`s hg`jbditgd K`p`jdsd `ji tgd Qusso`j g`vojb rdpn`hdi tgd Mejben `ji tgd M`jhgu M`jhguro`otsdnf g`s jet ferfdotdi ots gosteroh rend `s tgd qu`rtdr frem wgohg tgd gd`vodst dxtdrj`n
prdssurd upej Hgoj` os dxdrtdi* _dt ej hnesdr ojspdhtoej ot wonn ad feuji tg`t. oj spotd ef
supdrfoho`n `ppd`r`jhds. tgd M`jhguro`j frejtodr. `s ` zejd ef djtry fer tgd Rdstdrj
omp`ht upej Hgoj`. os rd`nny sdheji`ry te tgd m`rotomd frejtodr reuji tgd dstu`ry ef tgd
_`jbtsd* Ygos trutg os aerjd eut aytgd gostery eftgd Xme-K`p`jdsd hejfnohtwgohg areldeut oj M`jhguro` oj 0?80< fer tgd hejfn`br`toej wgohg g`i forst fn`rdi up `t Mulidjsprd`i te Xg`jbg`o fertgwotg*
"Ygdrd heuni g`vd addj je merd hejhnusovd idmejstr`toej tg`j tgos ef tgd trutg tg`ttgd hdjtrd ef br`voty ef Hgoj` g`i ojiddi dffdhtovdny sgoftdi frem tgd Srevojhd ef Hgogno`ji tgd A`soj ef tgd Sdoge Qovdr `ji tgd pert ef Yodjtsoj `ji tgd fermdr penotoh`n h`pot`n`t Sdlojb te tgd Srevojhd ef Lo`jbsu `ji tgd a`soj ef tgd _`jbtsd Qovdr `ji tgd pert ef
Xg`jbg`o `ji tgd jdw penotoh`n h`pot`n `t J`jlojb Oj dffdht. tgd jdw hdjtrd ef djdrbywotg wgohg Rdstdrj djtdrprosd g`i djiewdi er djhumadrdi Hgoj` `t Xg`jbg`o g`iadhemd se petdjt tg`t. ay tgd yd`rs 0?80-1. ot w`s vortu`nny ompessoand feo `jytgojb ef
m`ker ompert`jhd te g`ppdj te Hgoj` `t n`rbd wotgeut Xg`jbg`o adhemojb tgd projhop`nshdjd ef `htoej* Oj tgos pg`sd ef Hgojdsd gostery. Xg`jbg`o w`s ` iemoj`jt m`bjdtohpeojt< `ji tgd m`bjdtoh pewdr ef tgos Rdstdrj-m`id fehus ef meidrj Hgojdsd dhejemohnofd prevdi strejbdr tg`j K`p`jdsd monot`ry iospesotoejs% 'Yeyjadd. @* K*; Xurvdy efOjtdrj`toej`n @ff`oos 0?80 'Nejiej 0?81. Monferi/. p* 960*/
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 438/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 012
tg`t ef Sdlojb oj Hgogno* Sdlojb hemm`jis tgd Mejbeno`j w`r-p`tgiewj tgd J`jlew idfond `ji tgd M`jhguro`j w`r-p`tg tgreubgtgd p`ss`bd ef Xg`j-g`o-lw`j. wgdrd tgd Brd`t R`nn idshdjis
frem tgd meujt`ojs te tgd sd`* Xomon`rny. J`jlojb hemm`jis tgdp`tg ay wgohg Rdstdrj mdj-e"-w`r pdjdtr`td ojte tgd gd`rt ef
Hgoj` up tgd w`tdrw`y ef tgd _`jbtsd* @ Hgojdsd Bevdrjmdjt
dst`anosgdi `t J`jlojb h`j idfdji Hgoj` `b`ojst tgd mest fer-
moi`and ef tgd dxtdrj`n prdssurds te wgohg sgd os suakdht te-i`y`t tgd peojt wgdrd tgd prdssurd os tgd mest ojtdjsd
< `ji. oj lddpojbtgd ojtruidr ujidr survdonn`jhd `ji geniojb gom oj hgdhl frem tgos
pest ef v`jt`bd. tgd rundrs ef Hgoj` h`j nd`rj gos `rts `s wdnn* F`s
dst dt `a gestdiehdro".
0 `jiJ`jlojb
os
ejnyejd sgert
jobgt"s r`onw`y-keurjdy iost`jt frem Xg`jbg`o; tgd idj `ji shgeen ef tgodvds
wgohg Rdstdrj djtdrprosd g`s pn`jtdi `t Hgoj`"s d`stdrj ieer*
"Monot`ry idfd`t frem tgd sd`w`ri soid. oj spotd ef tgd gostery ef tgd
jojdtddjtg hdjtury. os stonn jevdn `ji tdrrofyojb te tgd hejshoeusjdss ef
tgd \Hgojdsd] pdepnd `t n`rbd* Ygdrd os je auffdr tdrrotery adtwddj tgd
sd` `ji tgd gd`rt ef Hgoj`< tgdrd `rd je jej-Hgojdsd rdsdrveor troads
te br`iu`td tgd sgehl< `ji tgd tr`iotoej ef tgd sd`-beojb pepun`toejotsdnf os ejd ef dxpneotojb. jet efadojb dxpneotdi* Ygd omp`ht ef Rdstdrj
j`toejs. tgd `nodj st`ji`ris ef tgd Rdst. trd`tods ioht`tdi ay tgd Rdst.g`vd `nw`ys `reusdi ` rd`htoej ef tdrrer `ji g`td f`r brd`tdr tg`j `jyidfd`t oj tgd v`bud auffdr tdrroterods ef tgd Jertg* Ygdrd os je ujidr-
nyojb tr`iotoej te prdshroad ` mdtgei ef id`nojb wotg `bbrdssoej frem
evdr tgd sd`* Ygd mdtgeis `ppnodi oj tgd dobgtddjtg `ji jojdtddjtg
hdjturods wdrd. bdjdr`nny spd`lojb. heneurdi ay tgd tr`iotoejs `ppnyojb
te tgd jertgdrj n`ji-frejtodr a`ra`ro`js* Ygdy ioi jet werl wdnn< oj
f`ht. tgdy tdjidi te arojb ej ios`stdrs* Gdjhd ` fddnojb. wgohg g`s jew
pdjdtr`tdi vdry iddp. tg`t tgd Rdstdrj j`toejs `rd ojh`nhun`and. tg`t tgdy
`rd `nw`ys noldny te sprojb ` frdsg surprosd. semdtgojb quotd eutsoid ef
dxpdrodjhd `ji tgd runds ef tgd b`md*"1
Ot w`s oj eridr te nd`rj tgd eutn`jiosg runds ef tgd jdw Rdstdrj
b`md efw`r `ji iopnem`hy `ji tr`id `ji ojiustry `ji foj`jhd tg`t
tgd h`pot`n ef Hgoj` w`s tr`jsfdrrdi frem Sdlojb te J`jlojb oj
@*I* 0?17* Ot wonn ad sddj tg`t tgos tr`jsfdr os ` pdrfdht onnustr`toej
ef eur n`w tg`t tgd dxtdrj`n prdssurd ef tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt
upej ` m`rhg `imojostdrs ` stomunus wgohg bovds tgd m`rhg prd-
iemoj`jhd evdr tgd ojtdroer*
Oj tgd Gojiu Rerni
Of wd turj jdxt frem F`r D`stdrj gostery te Gojiu. wd sg`nn
rdhebjozd hdrt`oj herrdspejiojb pgdjemdj`* Rd sg`nn jetohd. fer
ojst`jhd. tg`t oj Ojio`. `s oj Hgoj`. te-i`y tgd m`rhg wgohg os
oEvoi. Mdt`merpgesds. Aeel OV. 0* 917*
`N`ttomerd. Ewdj; M`jhguro` Hr`ind ef Hejfnoht 'Jdw _erl 0?81. M`hmonn`j/.
pp* 1?2-7*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 439/455
017 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
suakdht te tgd gd`vodst prdssurd os tgd sd`ae`ri. `ji tg`t tgd
prdssurd frem evdrsd`s os adojb `ppnodi ay tgd s`md Rdstdrj ferhd*
Oj Aema`y. "tgd B`td ef Ojio`". wd sg`nn oidjtofy tgd Ojio`j
`j`nebud ef Xg`jbg`o< `ji wd sg`nn easdrvd tg`t kust `s tgd vot`ndndmdjts ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Xehodty oj Hgoj` g`vd addj hejhdj-
tr`tojb tgdmsdnvds n`ttdrny oj tgd ommdio`td gojtdrn`ji ef Xg`jbg`o.
se tgd vot`n dndmdjts ef tgd Gojiu Xehodty oj Ojio` sddm te ad
hejhdjtr`tojb tgdmsdnvds jew oj tgd ommdio`td gojtdrn`ji ef Aem-
a`y* Ot os tgd Aema`y Srdsoidjhy. frem Seej` te @gm`i`a`i. tg`t
os preiuhojb tgd ferdmest penotoho`js `ji ojiustro`nosts `ji s`ojts
`ji tgojldrs oj Ojio` oj eur bdjdr`toej*
Rd sg`nn
jetohd. `b`oj. tg`t.oj Ojio` `s oj
Hgoj`.tgos hejhdjtr`-
toej ef prdssurd `ji stomunus `ji rdspejsd oj tgd m`rotomd m`rhg
os ef rdhdjt i`td<`ji ojiddi oj Ojio` ot os stonn f`r frem adojb hem-
pndtd* Of wd p`ss. fer ojst`jhd. frem tgd ojtdnndhtu`n `ji dhejemoh
ojiohds ef seho`n vot`noty te tgd monot`ry. `ji ojquord ojte tgd hem-
p`r`tovd hejtroautoejs ef tgd v`roeus suaiovosoejs ef hejtdmper`ryOjio` te tgd Ojio`j @rmy. wd sg`nn foji tg`t jd`rny 47 pdr hdjt.
ef tgd pdrsejjdn os suppnodi ay tgd S`jk`a `ji ay tgd `ikeojojbJertg-Rdst Frejtodr Srevojhd. `ji tg`t. ej tgos hrotdroej. tgd
Aema`y Srdsoidjhy os `ntebdtgdr eutm`thgdi ay tgd S`jk`a oj
vot`noty. dvdj tgeubg ot genis ots ewj oj tgd monot`ry fodni. `s oj tgd
hovon. `b`ojst `nn etgdr prevojhds ef Arotosg Ojio`* 0
Merdevdr. tgd
h`pot`n ef tgd Ojio`j Dmpord. tgeubg ot w`s tr`jsfdrrdi te ` jdw sotd
oj @*I* 0?01. `s tgd h`pot`n ef tgd Hgojdsd Qdpuanoh w`s tr`jsfdrrdi
oj 0?17. g`s jet addj tr`jspn`jtdi te tgd Aema`y"Srdsoidjhy* Ot g`s
addj neh`tdi `t Idngo<`ji Idngo.tgeubg jet `pprdho`any jd`rdr tg`j
tgdprdvoeus h`pot`n. H`nhutt`.teAema`y. osejtgdfrojbdeftgdS`jk`a *
Oj f`ht. tgd spdho`n djhn`vd hejt`ojojb tgd jdw ompdro`n h`pot`n g`s
addj h`rvdi eut ef tdrroterywgohg prdvoeusny adnejbdi te tgd S`jk`a`s idnomotdi oj Arotosg Ojio`j `imojostr`tovd bdebr`pgy*
0 Oj tgd yd`r 0?83. tgd tet`n hema`t`jt strdjbtg ef tgd Arotosg Ojio`j Qdbun`r @rmyw`s 047.133* Ef tgdsd treeps. ?0.633 g`i addj rdhruotdi frem tgd S`jk`a `ji tgdJertg-Rdst Frejtodr Srevojhd. semd 84.433 frem tgd Gom`n`y`j Gobgn`jis 'B`rgw`n.Lum`ej. Jdp`n/< semd 80.033 frem tgd rdst ef Ojio`. ojhnuiojb tgd Aema`y Srdsoidjhy<`ji 2.333 frem tgd Aema`y Srdsoidjhy otsdnf 'Xdd tgd Qdpert ef tgd Ojio`j Xt`tuteryHemmossoej = Arotosg S`rno`mdjt`ry S`pdr Hmi* 8467 ef 0?83 'Nejiej 0?83. G M*Xt`toejdry Effohd/. ven* o. pp* ?6-7* Oj tgd foburds dxtr`htdi frem tgos seurhd oj tgdprdsdjt feetjetd. tgd 06.433 treeps rdhruotdi frem tgd Tjotdi Srevojhds g`vd addj
hrdiotdi te tgd Gom`n`y`j Gobgn`jis ej tgd `ssumptoej tg`t tgd m`keroty ef tgdm h`mdfrem tgd gobgn`ji iostrohts ef B`rgw`n `ji Lum`ej*/ Ygd `aevd foburds ojhnuidrdhruotmdjts eutsoid `s wdnn `s ojsoid tgd nomots ef tdrrotery ujidr Arotosg `imojostr`toejer hejtren* Oj tgd yd`r 0?83. `aeut ejd-sdvdjtg ef tgd Ojio`j Qdbun`r @rmy w`srdhruotdi frem tdrroterods adyeji tgd nomots ef Arotosg `imojostr`toej er hejtren; p`rtny`mejb tgd gobgn`jidrs ef tgd Jertg-Rdst Frejtodr oj iostrohts wgohg wdrd jet ujidrdffdhtovd Arotosg rund tgeubg tgdy wdrd ej tgd Ojio`j soid ef tgd Ojie-@fbg`j Frejtodr-`ji
p`rtnyZtetgd strdjbtg ef 0?.333/ `mejb tgd gobgn`jidrs ef Jdp`n; `j ojidpdjidjt
st`td g`jbojb ej tgd seutgdrj fn`jls ef tgd Gom`n`y`s* Fer tgd tdjidjhy ef hovonoz`-
toejs. wgdj tgdy foji tgdmsdnvds hejfrejtojb a`ra`ro`js `nejb st`toej`ry `rtofoho`n
frejtodrs. te rdhruot tgdor frejtodr idfdjhd-ferhds frem `mejb tgd tr`js-frejtodr a`r-a`ro`js tgdmsdnvds. sdd S`rt VOOO. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 440/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 01?
Rgy g`s tgd h`pot`n ef Ojio` mevdi te Idngo `ji jet te tgd
gojtdrn`ji ef Aema`y 5 @jiwgy ie tgdS`jk`a `ji tgd Jertg-Rdst
Frejtodr Srevojhd suppny. adtwddj tgdm. merd rdhruots tg`j `nn tgd
rdst ef Ojio`tebdtgdr
te tgd Ojio`j
@rmy5Ygd `jswdr te tgd sdheji qudstoej os. ef heursd. tg`t. oj tgd S`j-
k`a `ji oj tgd Jertg-Rdst Frejtodr Srevojhd. oj hejtr`st te tgd
M`rotomd M`rhg `ji tgd ojtdroer `nold. Ojio`j vot`noty g`s addj
stomun`tdi te dxprdss otsdnf oj monot`ry prewdss ay dxpesurd te
dxtdrj`n monot`ry prdssurd* Ygos prdssurd os adojb `ppnodijew`i`ys
ay tgd w`rnold gobgn`jidrs wge stonn prdsdrvd tgdor ojidpdjidjhd id
f`hte ej tgd dxtrdmd dibd ef tgd Or`jo`j Sn`td`u. wgdrd ots seutg-
d`stdrj dsh`rpmdjt idshdjis upej tgd jertg-wdstdrj fn`jl ef tgd
Ojius V`nndy* Ygd prexomoty ef tgdsd a`ra`ro`j gonn-mdj g`s tgd
s`md stomun`tojb dffdht upej tgd frejtodrsmdj ef tgd Gojiu Rerni.
`nejb tgd a`jls ef "tgd Fovd Qovdrs". tg`t tgd prexomoty ef somon`r
a`ra`ro`js oj tgd gobgn`jis ef Xgdjso `ji Xg`jso ejhd g`i upejtgd frejtodrsmdj ef tgd Xojoh Rerni oj tgd v`nndys ef tgd Rdo `ji
tgd Fdj* 0 @ji tgd p`r`nndn beds furtgdr* Ej tgd jertgdrj m`rhgds
ef Hgoj`. tgd gobgn`ji zejd ejhd ehhupodi ay a`ra`ro`j gonn-mdj
dvdjtu`nny adh`md. `s wd g`vd easdrvdi.1 ` p`ss`bd tgreubg wgohg
Hgoj` w`s ojv`idi ay tgd merd fermoi`and Jem`ioh pdepnds fremtgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd oj tgd gojtdrn`ji* Xomon`rny. ej tgd jertg-
wdstdrj m`rhgds ef Ojio`. tgd prdssurd wgohg os adojb dxdrtdi aytgd neh`n gobgn`jidrs `t tgd prdsdjt i`y w`s fermdrny f`r surp`ssdi
oj sdvdroty ay ` prdssurd frem tgd Jem`is ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd.
wge feuji ` p`ss`bd ojte Ojio` `hress tgd gobgn`jis ef@fbg`jost`j.
`s tgdor heujtdrp`rts feuji ` p`ss`bd ojte Hgoj` `hress tgd gobg-
n`jis ef Xgdjso `ji Xg`jso `ji Kdgen*
Oj Gojiugostery.
`s oj F`r D`stdrj. ot os tgos
prdssurd
frem
Dur`so`j Jem`is `hress `j ojn`ji frejtodr tg`t g`s addj tgd
gd`vodst dxtdrj`n prdssurd ujton rdhdjtny. `ji tgos dvdr sojhd tgd
tomd wgdj Gojiu gostery adb`j* Ygd Jem`is" prdssurd w`s fdnt
oj funn ferhd iurojb tgd ojtdrrdbjum. fennewojb tgd iosojtdbr`toej
ef tgd "`pp`rdjtdi" Ojiod Hovonoz`toej. eut ef wgohg tgd Gojiu
Hovonoz`toej eroboj`nnydmdrbdi * Ojtgdpest-OjiodVenldrw`jidrujb
`ftdr tgd ard`l-up ef tgd Bupt` Dmpord tgd Ojiod Sewdr tg`t g`i
rdsumdi `ji funfonndi tgd seho`n fujhtoejs ef `j Ojiod ujovdrs`n
st`td8 Ojio` w`s ojv`idi. `hress tgos jertg-wdst frejtodr. ay tgd
0 Xdd tgd prdsdjt sdhtoej. pp* 007-0?. `aevd. `ji hemp`rd tgd rdn`toejs adtwddj tgd
Hgojdsd frejtodrsmdj `ji tgd M`jhgu a`ra`ro`j gonn-mdj oj M`jhguro`. ej tgd dvd ef
tgdor keojt hejqudst ef ojtr`-mur`n Hgoj`* 'Xdd p* 019. feetjetd o. `aevd*/1Xddp* 00?. `aevd*
*
8 Fer tgd rend ef tgd Bupt` Dmpord oj Ojiod gostery. `s ` rdsumptoej ef tgd Ojiod
ujovdrs`n st`td wgohg g`i addj forst dmaeiodi oj tgd M`ury` Dmpord `ji g`i tgdj addj
ojtdrruptdi prdm`turdny ay ` Gdnndjoh ojtrusoej upej tgd Ojiod Rerni. sdd O. H 'o/ '4/.
ven* o. pp* 74-6. `aevd*
OO L
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 441/455
083 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Jem`i Burk`r`s `ji Gujs* Ygd ojv`idrs sw`mpdi tgd Ojius
V`nndy. m`id tgdmsdnvds `t gemd oj tgd Ojio`j Idsdrt adyeji ot.
`ji swdpt ej tgreubg Q`kput`j` ojte tgd Idhh`j* 0 Ygd gosteroh
ossud
w`s wgdtgdr tgdsd a`ra`ro`js sgeuni er sgeuni jet ferdst`nntgd dmdrbdjhd ef ` jdw hovonoz`toej. "`ffono`tdi+ te tgd idfujht Ojiod
Hovonoz`toej. ay djbunfojb tgd B`jbds V`nndy `s wdnn< `ji tgos
qudstoej w`s idhoidi oj tgd jdb`tovd adh`usd. `nejb tgd nojd ef tgd
Qovdr Kumj`. ` st`ji `b`ojst tgdor ejsn`ubgts w`s m`id wotg
suhhdss* Oj tgd gosteroh`n bdebr`pgy eftgd Gojiu Rerni. tgd hress-
sdhtoej ef tgd brd`t pn`oj ef Gojiust`j wgohg hejt`ojs tgd heursd
ef tgd Kumj`. frem tgd seutgdrj feet-gonns ef tgd Gom`n`y`s te tgd
jertgdrj feet-gonns ef tgd Hdjtr`n Ojio`jgobgn`jis.
g`s g`i tgd
s`md str`tdboh ompert`jhd `s tgd p`ssds frem M`jhguro` `ji Mej-
beno` ojte tgd Hgojdsd prevojhd ef Hgogno oj tgd gosteroh`n bdebr`pgyef tgd F`r D`st* Gdrd w`s tgd b`p tgreubg wgohg tgd Jem`iojv`idrs must p`ss of tgdy wdrd te pdjdtr`td f`rtgdr
<`ji gdrd w`s
tgd peojt wgdrd tgdy mdt wotg sdroeus rdsost`jhd* Ye tgos jdobg-
aeurgeei. `hheriojbny. tgd h`pot`n ef Ojio` g`s br`vot`tdi gotgdrte
tgreubgeut tgd gostery ef tgd Gojiu Hovonoz`toej*
@nrd`iy. iurojb tgd pest-Ojiod ojtdrrdbjum. wgdj G`rsg`
'ompdr`a`t @*I* 636-92/ memdjt`rony rdsterdi tgd Ojiod ujovdrs`n
st`td. gd foxdi gosh`pot`n oj tgos jdw jertg-wdstdrj m`rhg `t
Xtg`jdsv`r`. hevdrojb tgd `ppre`hg frem tgd S`jk`a te tgd Kumj`.`ji jet oj tgd ojtdroer ef M`b`ig` tgd j`tur`n `imojostr`tovd
hdjtrd ef tgd B`jbds A`soj. `t tgd kujhtoej ef tgd B`jbds wotg tgd
Kumj` `ji wotg twe etgdr troaut`rods. wgohg g`i addj tgd h`pot`nef aetg tgd Bupt`s `ji tgd M`ury`s* @b`oj. semd twe hdjturods
n`tdr. wgdj tgd jdw Gojiu Hovonoz`toej. wgohg g`i dmdrbdi oj
tgd md`jwgond. w`s tgrd`tdjdi oj ots ojf`jhy ay prdssurd frem tgd
@r`as. wge g`i rd`hgdi tgd idnt` ef tgd Ojius frem tgd sd` `jiwdrd pusgojb tgdor w`y ojn`ji up-rovdr.
1 tgd @r`as" `iv`jhd w`s`rrdstdi ay tgd rosd ef ` Gojiu Sewdr. tgd Sr`tog`r` Q`kputs. wgerundi frem Bukdr`t te tgd Kumj`-B`jbds Iu`a `ji foxdi tgdor
h`pot`n oj tgd Iu`a. ej tgd wdst a`jl ef tgd B`jbds. `t L`j`uk*8
f
+ OjVojhdjt Xmotg"s epojoej. tgd Hg`nuly`s. wge feujidi ` projhop`notyoj tgd Idhh`jhorh` @*I* 443. wdrd prea`any Burk`r` ojv`idrs frem Q`kpun`j`* 'Xmotg. Vojhdjt; YgdD`rny Gostery ef Ojio`. 8ri diotoej 'Exferi 0?09. Hn`rdjiej Srdss/. p* 919 /
+
Fer tgd prevojhd ef tgd @r`a H`nopg`td oj tgd Ojius V`nndy. sdd O* H 'o/ 'a/. ven* o
pp* 034-6. `aevd*
8ZYgd Sr`tog`r`s wdrd Burk`r` hejvdrts te Gojiuosm wge idfdjidi tgd sehodty ef
tgdor `ieptoej `b`ojst tgd `bbrdssoej ef tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td 'jew rdsumdi. `ftdrtgd Gdnndjoh ojtrusoej. oj tgd @r`a H`nopg`td/. kust `s. ej tgd eppesotd dibd ef tgdXyro`h Rerni. `jetgdr j`shdjt sehodty oj tgos h`sd. Rdstdrj Hgrostdjiemw`sidfdjidi `b`ojst tgd s`md @r`a `bbrdssers ay tgd Sr`jlosg hejvdrts te Hgrosto`joty*Ygd Dur`so`j Jem`i eroboj ef tgd Sr`tog`r`s os `ttdstdi ay tgdor monot`ry tdhgjoqud*Ygdy wdrd gersd-`rhgdrs `ji h`mdn-mdj. jet dndpg`jt-roidrs* 'Xdd V`oiy`* H* V* ; YgdGostery ef Mdio`dv`n Ojio` 'Seej` 0?19. Erodjt`n Aeel Xuppnyojb @bdjhy/. ven* oo.
p* 034 / Ygd Sr`tog`r`s m`id tgdmsdnvds m`stdrs ef tgd Kumj`-B`jbds Iu`a idfojo-
tovdny horh` @*I* 703-06* Ot os rdm`rl`and tg`t tgdy foxdi tgdor h`pot`n `t L`j`uk. oj tgos
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 442/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 080
Aetg L`j`uk `ji Xtg`jdsv`r`. gewdvdr. wdrd te ad dhnopsdi ay `
n`tdr feuji`toej oj tgd s`md rdboej* Idngo w`s auont ej tgd wdst
a`jl ef tgd Kumj`. ej ` sotd ojtdrmdio`td adtwddj tgd sotds ef tgd
twed`rnodr
h`pot`ns. oj @*I* ??8-9+ ay Gojiu g`jis< aut Idngo. nold
Sdlojb.w`s forst r`osdi te gejeuray rundrswge wdrd `nodj ojtruidrs*
@t tgos vdry kujhturd. tgd Jem`is ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd areld
tgdor aeujis `b`oj `ji adb`j te m`ld tgdorw`y ojte Ojio` ay tgd eni
reutd `hress tgd jertg-wdst frejtodr<aut tgos tomdtgdy `ppd`rdi oj `
jdw buosd* Ygd Guj `ji Burk`r` ojv`idrs eftgd pest-Ojiod Venldr-
w`jidrujb 'horh` @*I* 924-224/ g`i hemd oj `s ujioffdrdjto`tdi
a`ra`ro`js wge wdrd jet ommujd frem hejvdrsoej te Gojiuosm*
Ygdor Yurlosg lojsmdj wge teel tgd s`md re`i twe hdjturods
n`tdr `rrovdi oj Ojio` `s hejvdrts te Osn`m tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n
hgurhg `ji `s `pestnds ef ` jdw Or`joh Hovonoz`toej te wgohg tgd
dxporojb Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej w`s "`pp`rdjtdi"* Ay ferhd ef `rms
tgdsd n`ttdr-i`y Yurlosg ojv`idrs h`rrodi tgdor `nodj rdnoboej `ji
hunturd ojte tgd B`jbds V`nndy. wgdrd tgdor Burk`r` prdidhdssers
g`i jet sdhurdi ` feetojb ujton `ftdr tgdy g`i adhemd Gojius*
Ygd Yurls areld tgreubg tgd Kumj` M`rhg. `ji hejqudrdi tgd
B`jbds V`nndy iewj te tgd he`st ef Adjb`n. oj @*I* 0 0?0-0139< tgdy
hejqudrdi tgd Idhh`j oj @*I* 01?9-083?< `ji dvdjtu`nny ` brd`t
Yurlosg st`tdsm`j. @la`r tgd Yomuroi 'ompdria`t @*I* 0446-0634/.
rdujotdi tgd Gojiu Rerni ujidr `j `nodj rund. `s tgd Mejben
Puaon`y rdujotdi tgd m`oj aeiy ef tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni.1ay
arojbojb tebdtgdr ots metndy fr`bmdjts Gojiu `ji Musnom projho-
p`notods `nold ojte `j `nn-dmar`hojb dmpord wgohg pdrfermdi tgd
fujhtoejs ef ` Gojiu ujovdrs`n st`td* Fer tgd Dur`so`j ojv`idrs ef
Ojio`. Idngo w`s tgd j`tur`n sotd fer ` h`pot`n sotu`tdi. `s ot w`s.
ej tgd aeridrnojd adtwddj tgd Ojius V`nndy `ji tgd B`jbds V`nndy.
adtwddj tgd rdboej oj wgohg Osn`moh rdnoboej `ji Or`joh hunturd `ji
Dur`so`j aneei g`i adhemd prdiemoj`jt `ji tgd rdboej wgdrd
Gojiuosmw`s stonn geniojb otsewjujidr `j `nodjyeld* @hheriojbny.
Idngo w`s tgd jerm`n sd`t ef Yurlosg Musnom rund oj Ojio` frem
tgd tgortddjtg hdjtury ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`. wgdj tgd "Xn`vd Lojbs"
foxdi tgdor h`pot`n tgdrd. iewj te tgd dobgtddjtg. wgdj tgd idshdj-
i`jts ef @la`r. tgd m`ldr ef tgd Gojiu ujovdrs`n st`td. wdrd m`oj-
t`ojojb ` sg`iew heurt `t Idngo `s pretdbds `ji pdjsoejdrs ef tgdArotosg D`st Ojio` Hemp`jy*
8
jdwny `hquordi prevojhd `t tgd dxtrdmoty ef tgdor iemojoejs. ojstd`i ef rdt`ojojb otZ`t
semd sotd oj Q`kput`j`. tgd heujtry oj wgohg tgdy g`i addj `t gemd fer sdvdr`n hdjturods
`ji wgohg w`s stonn tgd bdebr`pgoh`n hdjtrd ef tgdor dmpord* Oj eridr te dxpn`oj tgdor
hgeohd. wd must suppesd tg`t tgd str`tdboh ompert`jhd ef tgd Kumj`-B`jbds Iu`a w`s
`nrd`iy wdnn rdhebjozdi*oXmotg. V*. ep* hot*. p* 879
1 Xdd p* 010. `aevd*
8 Rgond Idngo w`s jerm`nny tgd h`pot`n ef Ojio` iurojb tgd fovd er sox hdjtomds
ef Musnom Yurlosg rund. gdr djkeymdjt ef tgos st`tus w`s jet ujojtdrruptdi* Oj tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 443/455
o81 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Merdevdr. Idngo. nold Sdlojb. g`s suhhddidi oj rdhevdrojb gdr
st`tus `ftdr tgd iewjf`nn ef tgd Sewdr ay wgohg tgos st`tus w`s forst
hejfdrrdi upej gdr* Ygd rdpn`hdmdjt ef tgd Mubg`n Q`k oj Ojio`
ay tgd Arotosg Q`k. nold tgd dxpunsoej ef tgd Mejbens frem Hgoj`ay tgd Mojb. w`s `hhemp`jodi `t tgd memdjt ay ` tr`jsfdr ef
tgd h`pot`n frem tgd projhop`n n`jiw`ri m`rhg te ` jdw sotd oj tgd
ojtdroer wgdrd tgd jdw rundrs fdnt tgdmsdnvds `t gemd `ji wdrd
surd ef tgdor `utgeroty* Oj tgd jojdtddjtg hdjtury. Idngo g`i te
yodni gdr prom`hy te H`nhutt`. `s. oj tgd feurtddjtg hdjtury. Sdlojb
g`i te yodni gdrs te J`jlojb* _dt oj Ojio`. `s oj Hgoj`. tgd eni
h`pot`n oj tgd m`rhg dvdjtu`nny wej a`hl. frem tgd jdw h`pot`n oj
tgdojtdroer.
tgd st`tus wgohg ot g`itdmper`rony
ferfdotdi* Oj @*I*
0?01. fofty-fovd yd`rs `ftdr tgd idfojotovd dxtojhtoej ef tgd Mubg`n
Q`k `ji hejform`toej ef tgd Arotosg Q`k oj tgd supprdssoej ef
tgd Ojio`j Mutojy. tgd Arotosg Bevdrjmdjt otsdnf rdtr`jsfdrrdi
tgd h`pot`n ef Ojio` te Idngo. `s tgd Mojb Dmpdrer _ujb Ne rd-
tr`jsfdrrdi tgd h`pot`n ef Hgoj` te Sdlojb fofty-tgrdd yd`rs `ftdr tgd
dxpunsoej ef tgd Mejbens frem Hgoj` ay _ujb Ne"s ewj f`tgdr
Gujb Ru*Ot os jetdwertgy tg`t. wgond tgd h`pot`n ef Ojio` g`s pdrpdtu`nny
br`vot`tdi te tgd djvorejs ef Idngo sojhd tgd bdjdsos ef tgd Gojiu
Hovonoz`toej. ot g`s jdvdr dst`anosgdi otsdnf pdrm`jdjtny `jywgdrdoj tgd Moiind er Newdr B`jbds V`nndy. oj Aog`r er oj Adjb`n*Adferd tgd `ivdjt ef tgd Arotosg. ot jdvdr dst`anosgdi otsdnf tgdrd-
`aeuts `t `nn<`ji je pdrm`jdjt hg`jbd oj tgd penotoh`n bdebr`pgy
ef tgd Gojiu Rerni g`s addj preiuhdi ay tgd gosteroh`n `hhoidjt
tg`t tgd Arotosg rund adb`j oj Adjb`n ` hdjtury adferd ot w`s funny
hejformdi tgreubgeut Ojio`* Ygos `hhoidjt b`vd Adjb`n ` ieuand
tdmper`ry `iv`jt`bd evdr etgdr Ojio`j prevojhds ; sgd adh`md tgd
a`sd ef epdr`toejs `ji sd`t ef bevdrjmdjt ef tgd jdw @nn-Ojio` r`k
wgohg w`s t`lojb tgd pn`hd ef tgd areldj-iewj r`k ef tgd Mubg`ns <
`ji gdr pdepnd wdrd dxpesdi te tgd prehdss efojtdjsovd Rdstdrjoz`-
toej sdvdr`n bdjdr`toejs d`rnodr tg`j tgdor jdobgaeurs* _dt tgdsd
`hhoidjt`n `iv`jt`bds. hejsoidr`and tgeubg tgdy `rd. g`vd jet
`v`ondi `b`ojst tgd pdrm`jdjt g`jioh`p te wgohg Adjb`n os suakdht ;
tgd n`hl ef stomunus wgohg os tgd pdj`nty ef gdr sotu`toej oj tgd
ojtdroer* Dvdj ujidr tgd Arotosg Q`k. wgohg g`s ots seurhd oj sd`-
pewdr. tgd h`pot`n ef Ojio` g`s idp`rtdi frem H`nhutt` ` pert
d`rny i`ys ef tgd dmpord ef tgd Brd`t Mubg`ns. tgd h`pot`n w`s `t @br`; `ji @la`r.wge ujljewojbny fennewdi oj Olgj`tej"s feetstdps oj `ttdmptojb te turj gos `utehr`toh
penotoh`n `utgeroty te `hheujt fer tgd `rtofoho`n hrd`toej `ji ompesotoej ef ` jdw ujovdrs`nhgurhg 'sdd S`rt VOOO. adnew/. noldwosd fennewdi Olgj`tej oj auoniojb gomsdnf ` ar`ji-jdw h`pot`n hoty* @ftdr tgd feujidr"s id`tg. gewdvdr. F`togpur Xolro g`i tgd s`md f`td`s Ydnn-dn-@m`rj`< tgd h`pot`n rdvdrtdi te @br` `ji tgdjhd. ujidr Xg`g K`g`j. te Idngo<`ji se. oj tgd n`ttdr i`ys ef tgd Mubg`n Dmpord. tgd Yurlosg Musnom rund oj Ojio`djidi `t Idngo. wgdrd ot g`i adbuj
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 444/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 088
`hhdssoand te ehd`j-beojb vdssdns `ji g`s sgoftdi a`hl te Idngo.
wgdrd tgd Dur`so`j gersdm`j os `t gemd `ji tgd Rdstdrj sd`-
f`rdr os ` str`jbdr* @s fer tgd stomunus ef tgd omp`ht ef eur Rdstdrj
Hovonoz`toej frem `hress tgd sd` `j omp`ht wgohg g`s bovdj Adjb`ntgd hg`r`htdr ef ` m`rhg fer tgd forst tomd oj Gojiu gostery tgd
Adjb`no rdspejsd te tgos hg`nndjbd sddms te n`hl vot`noty `ji
eroboj`noty* Oj Adjb`no seuns. tgd fdrmdjt ef Rdstdrjoz`toej os `ptte idtdroer`td ojte "tgd nd`vdj ef tgd Xhroads"* "Rgdrd tgdrd os je
vosoej. tgd pdepnd pdrosg" <
x
`ji. oj tgd Ojio`j J`toej`n Mevdmdjt.wgohg tgd hg`nndjbd ef tgd Rdst g`s dveldi. tgd ojspor`toej `ji tgd
nd`idrsgop g`vd addj p`ssojb. `s wd g`vd easdrvdi `nrd`iy. frem
Adjb`nte tgd
Aema`y Srdsoidjhy*Rd
m`yeasdrvd furtgdr tg`t
tgos gojtdrn`ji ef Aema`y. wgohg g`s tgus adhemd tgd projhop`nm`rhg ef Ojio` vos-`-vos tgd Rdst. g`s jet jew `hquordi tgd
hg`r`htdr ef ` m`rhg fer tgd forst tomd oj Gojiu gostery* Frem tgd
adbojjojb. ot g`s addj dxpesdi te dxtdrj`n prdssurd ef v`roeus lojis
frem v`roeus qu`rtdrs ; monot`ry prdssurd frem Burk`r`s `ji @r`as
ay n`ji< dhejemoh prdssurd frem @r`as `ji S`rsdds ay sd`* "Ygd
brd`tdr tgd prdssurd tgd brd`tdr tgd stomunus" os ` m`xom wgohg os
aerjd eut ay tgd pgdjemdj` ef seho`n bdebr`pgy oj tgd Gojiu
Rerni. `s wdnn `s oj tgd F`r D`stdrj Rerni `ji oj tgd Xojoh `ji oj
tgd Dbypto`h*
Oj tgd Xumdroh `ji A`aynejoh Rernis
Oj tgd Xumdroh Rerni. wd foji tgd s`md n`w onnustr`tdi oj tgd
gostery ef tgd Xumdroh ujovdrs`n st`td*1 Ygd Dmpord ef Xumdr `ji
@ll`i w`s feujidi ay ` Xumdro`j iyj`sty wgesd h`pot`n w`s `t
Tr. oj tgd gd`rt ef tgd gemdn`ji ef tgd Xumdroh Hovonoz`toej* Ygd
Dmpord w`s rdsterdi. `ftdr ` tdmper`ry ard`liewj. ay `j @merotd
iyj`sty wgesd h`pot`n w`s `t A`aynej; "tgd B`td ef tgd Beis"
wgohg w`s `nse tgd b`td tgreubg wgohg tgd @merotd Jem`is ef
tgd Jertg @r`ao`j Xtdppd g`i ferhdi `j djtry ojte tgd N`ji ef
Xgoj`r* Ygus. oj tgd Xumdroh ujovdrs`n st`td. penotoh`npewdrp`ssdifrem tgd ojtdroer te tgd m`rhg ej wgohg tgd gd`vodst dxtdrj`n
prdssurd w`s adojb dxdrtdi*
Ygd s`md pgdjemdj` rd`ppd`r oj tgd gostery ef tgd A`aynejoh
Hovonoz`toej wgohg w`s "`ffono`tdi" te tgd Xumdroh* Rd g`vd sddj
tg`t. oj A`aynejoh gostery. A`aynejo` w`s surp`ssdi. oj `rms `ji
`rts `nold. ay @ssyro`< `ji wd g`vd `ttroautdi @ssyro`"s supdroeroty
te tgd f`ht tg`t. `s hemp`rdi wotg A`aynejo`. sgd w`s oj ` hdrt`oj
sdjsd "jdw breuji"*8 Rd sg`nn jew foji ` sdheji `ji pessoany merd
petdjt h`usd ef A`aynejo`"s f`onurd te geni gdr ewj `b`ojst @ssyro`
0 Srevdras xxox* 07*
` Xdd O* H 'o/ '/. ven*o. pp* 038 `ji 036. `aevd* 8 Xdd pp* 29-4. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 445/455
089 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
oj tgd f`ht tg`t A`aynejo` ehhupodi ` sgdntdrdi pesotoej oj tgd
ojtdroer ef tgd A`aynejoh Rerni. wgdrd`s @ssyro` w`s ` m`rhg
wgohg aerd tgd arujt ef suhhdssovd dxtdrj`n prdssurds* Oj tgd pest-
Xumdroh Venldrw`jidrujb. A`aynejo` g`i suffdrdi `ji suh-humadi te `j ojv`soej ef a`ra`ro`j L`ssotds `t tgd tomd wgdj
@ssyro` w`s suffdrojb `ji rdpdnnojb `j ojv`soej ef a`ra`ro`j
Mot`jjo`js<`ji tgdrd`ftdr tgd @ssyro`js dxpdrodjhdi `ji rdsostdi
furtgdr prdssurds frem wgohg tgd A`aynejo`js wdrd dxdmpt*
@ftdr adojb noadr`tdi. oj tgd feurtddjtg hdjtury A*H*. frem tgd
Mot`jjo`j prdssurd ay tgd voh`roeus dxdrtoejs ef tgd Gottotd Sewdr.0
@ssyro` w`s ojvenvdi. tgreubgeut tgd dndvdjtg `ji tdjtg hdjturods.
oj ` jdwstrubbnd
fer dxostdjhd`b`ojst
` merd fermoi`and`ivdrs`rytg`j Mot`jjo oj tgd sg`pd ef @r`m* Ygd @r`m`d`js wdrd Jem`is
wge g`i ossudi eut ef tgd @r`ao`j Sdjojsun`. oj hemp`jy wotg tgd
Gdardws. iurojb tgd Venldrw`jidrujb wgohg prdhdidi tgd aortg
ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej<`ji wgond tgd Gdardws g`i iroftdi ojte
Xeutgdrj Xyro`. tgd @kr`m`d`js g`i iroftdi jertgw`ris oj tgd
`jhodjt tr`hl ef tgd @merotds* Ejd wojb ef tgd mobr`jt @r`m`d`j
gerid g`i sdttndi oj tgd e`sds ef d`st-hdjtr`n Xyro`. frem I`m`shus
te G`m`g< `jetgdr wojb g`i n`ppdi evdr tgd Moiind Dupgr`tds`ji g`i ehhupodi tgd p`sturd-n`jis ef Jertgdrj Mdsepet`mo`<`ji ot w`s tgos d`stdrj wojb tg`t h`md ojte hennosoej wotg @ssyro`*
Ygd sotu`toej. gewdvdr. w`s jet oj `nn rdspdhts tgd s`md `s wgdj
tgd @r`m`d`js" @merotd prdidhdssers g`i ferhdi `j djtry ojte tgd
Xumdroh Rerni `nejb tgos vdry tr`hl semd twdnvd gujirdi yd`rs
adferd*
Ygd @merotds wgdj tgdy djtdrdi @ll`i. nold tgd Gujs `ji
Burk`r`s wgdj tgdy djtdrdi Ojio`. g`i hemd oj `s ujioffdrdjto`tdi
a`ra`ro`js `ji. `s suhg. tgdy g`i addj hejvdrtdi d`sony `ji r`poinyte tgd hunturd wgohg tgdy feuji oj ehhup`toej ef tgd breuji ej
wgohg tgdy wdrd trdsp`ssojb* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. tgd @r`m`d`js.wgdj tgdy adb`j te djhre`hg upej tgd wdstdrj aeridrs ef @ssyro`.g`i `nrd`iy hemd wotgoj tgd `maot ef tgd j`shdjt Xyro`h Hovonoz`-
toej. kust `s tgd Yurls wge ojv`idi Ojio` oj tgd feetstdps ef tgd
Gujs g`i prdvoeusny hemd wotgoj tgd `maot ef tgd j`shdjt Or`joh
Hovonoz`toej `ji g`i addj rdjidrdi ommujd te Gojiuosm ay `j
`jtohop`tery ojehun`toej wotg Osn`m* Ygus tgd @r`m`d`j Xyro`h
prdssurd upej tgd A`aynejoh Rerni w`s `s fermoi`and ` i`jbdr te
tgd dxostdjhd ef tgd tgrd`tdjdi hovonoz`toej `s tgd Yurlosg Musnom
prdssurd upej tgd Gojiu Rerni< aut. wgdrd`s tgd Q`kputs f`ondi
te s`vd Ojio` frem adojb evdrruj ay tgd Yurls. tgd @ssyro`js jet
ejny hgdhldi tgd @r`m`d`js" d`stw`ri `iv`jhd oj twe hdjturods ef
idfdjsovd w`rf`rd aut p`ssdi evdr tgdrd`ftdr. oj tgd jojtg hdjtury+ Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. p* 008. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 446/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 084
A*H*. ojte ` heujtdr-effdjsovd wgohg h`rrodi tgd @ssyro`j `rms te
tgd sgerds ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j `ji breuji `nn Xyro` ujidr tgd
@ssyro`j gddn* Ygus. oj tgos forst reuji ef tgd nejb `ji `riueus
strubbnd adtwddj tgd Xyro`h `ji A`aynejoh hovonoz`toejs. @ssyro`aerd tgd arujt `ji b`ojdi tgd vohtery fer tgd A`aynejoh Rerni* Oj
tgd md`jtomd A`aynejo` g`i tgd d`sy t`sl ef `ssomon`tojb tgd Hg`n-
i`d`js ` Jem`ioh pdepnd wge g`i ossudi eut ef tgd @r`ao`j
Sdjojsun` somunt`jdeusny wotg tgd @r`m`d`js `ji tgd Gdardws.aut wgesd nojd ef mobr`toej n`y se f`r te tgd seutg-d`st tg`t tgd
ojfnudjhd ef tgd j`shdjt Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej ioi jet rd`hg tgdm*
Ygus tgd Hg`ni`d`js nold tgd @merotds `ji ujnold tgd @r`m`d`js
h`md oj `s ujioffdrdjto`tdi a`ra`ro`js wge wdrdepdj
te `ssomo-
n`toej< `ji tgdor ojfontr`toej ojte A`aynejo`. iurojb tgd hdjturods
wgdj @ssyro` w`s fobgtojb tgd @r`m`d`js fer gdr nofd. w`s ` pd`hd-fun pdjdtr`toej ojstd`i ef adojb ` fermoi`and erid`n*
Merdevdr. tgd @r`m`d`j frejt w`s ejny ejd ef tgd frejts ej
wgohg @ssyro` g`i te fobgt* Rgond sgd w`s rdsostojb tgd prdssurd
frem tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej ej tgd seutg-wdst. sgd g`i te idfdji
gdr rd`r `b`ojst tgd gobgn`jidrs ef tgd Or`jo`j `ji @j`teno`j
pn`td`ux ej tgd d`st `ji tgd jertg* Oj tgos qu`rtdr. `b`oj. @ssyro`
pdrfermdi tgd fujhtoej ef ` m`rhg hevdrojb tgd ojtdroer ef tgd
A`aynejoh Rerni < `ji. wgond sgd dvdjtu`nny b`ojdi tgd uppdr g`ji
evdr gdr Xyro`h `ivdrs`rods. tgd gobgn`jidrs ldpt gdr pdrpdtu`nny ej
tgd idfdjsovd* Ojiddi. wgdj. tgreubg tgos w`rnold ojtdrheursd. tgd
gobgn`ji projhop`noty ef Tr`rtu. oj tgd a`soj ef N`ld V`j. dvdj-
tu`nny adh`md hejvdrtdi te tgd A`aynejoh Hovonoz`toej. tgd strubbnd
ejny adh`md tgd merd ojtdjsd nold tgd strubbnd adtwddj tgd D`st
Qem`j Dmpord `ji Aunb`ro` `ftdr tgd hejvdrsoej ef tgd Aunb`ro`js
te Ertgeiex Hgrosto`joty*
Jdvdrtgdndss @ssyro`. ujidr tgos pdrpdtu`n prdssurd frem dvdry
qu`rtdr. idvdnepdi ` vot`noty wgohg A`aynejo` heuni jet m`thg se
nejb `s @ssyro`"s prewdss b`vd gdr sgdntdr* Ej tgd etgdr g`ji. tgd
pesotoejs wdrd rdvdrsdi wgdj @ssyro` turjdi gdr `rms `b`ojst tgd
ojtdroer ef tgd A`aynejoh Rerni `ji hd`sdi te idfdji ots frejtodrs*0
Iurojb tgd sdvdjtg hdjtury A*H* sgd `ppnodi te gdr sostdr-heujtry
A`aynejo` tgd brojiojb prdssurd wgohg sgd g`i `ppnodi oj tgd jojtg
`ji dobgtg hdjturods te `nodj Xyro` < `ji tgos fd`rfun hg`nndjbd stomu-n`tdi tgd A`aynejo`js `s petdjtny `s ot stomun`tdi tgd Xyro`js. tgeubg
oj ` ioffdrdjt w`y* Oj Xyro`j seuns. ot dveldi tgd rdnoboeus ojspor`-
toej wgohg feuji dxprdssoej tgreubg tgd meutgs ef tgd Srepgdts
ef Osr`dn< oj A`aynejo`j seuns ot dveldi ` iebbdi j`toej`nosm
0 Ygos hg`jbd oj tgd iordhtoej ef @ssyro`j djdrbods os dx`mojdi furtgdr oj S`rt OV.
adnew. `prepes ef tgd p`tgeneboh`n pgdjemdjej ef Monot`rosm `s ` spdhofoh m`n`iy ef
tgd m`rhgds*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 447/455
o 86 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
wgohg prevdi merd tg`j ` m`thg fer tgd furer @ssyro`hus* Ygd
A`aynejo`js fertofodi ay Hg`ni`d`j ojfusoejs `ji stddndi ay
@ssyro`j `trehotods wdrd oj `t tgd id`tg wgdj. `t tgd hnesd ef tgd
sdvdjtg hdjtury A*H*. tgd gobgn`jidrs ef tgd Or`jo`j Sn`td`u evdr-wgdnmdi @ssyro` `t n`st
<`ji tgdsd Mdio`j `nnods ef A`aynej oj tgd
w`r ef `jjogon`toej `b`ojst @ssyro` wdrd `and jew te `hgodvd tgd
idstruhtoej ef tgd Sewdr wgohg g`i suhhdssfunny rdsostdi tgd prds-
surd ef Tr`rtu `ji tgd d`rnodr prdssurd ef Mot`jjo adh`usd @ssyro`.
ay tgd tomd wgdj sgd g`i te id`n wotg tgd Mdids. g`i hd`sdi te
pdrferm gdr gosteroh fujhtoej `s ` m`rhg*
Oj tgd sdvdjtg hdjtury A*H*. ` w`vd ef Dur`so`j Jem`is tgd
Hommdro`js `ji tgdXhytgs
areld evdr tgd jertg-wdstdrj dx-
trdmoty ef tgd Or`jo`j Sn`td`u `ji idshdjidi upej tgd A`aynejoh
`ji Xyro`h wernis. `s tgd Gujs `ji Burk`r`s areld evdr tgd jertg-
d`stdrj dxtrdmoty ef tgd s`md pn`td`u `ji idshdjidi upej tgd
Ojiod Rerni oj tgd foftg `ji soxtg hdjturods ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`*
Ygdrdwotg. tgd hg`nndjbd ef Jem`ioh ojv`soej w`s prdsdjtdi oj
Xeutg-Rdstdrj @so` fer tgd forst tomd sojhd tgd ehh`soej wgdj.merd tg`j ` tgeus`jiyd`rs d`rnodr. iurojb tgd pest-XumdrohVenldr-
w`jidrujb. tgd Gylses g`i areldj eut ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd `ji
g`i swdpt `hress tgd idrdnoht iem`oj ef tgd Dmpord ef Xumdr `ji
@ll`i te sdttnd oj Xyro`.0 Ygos tomd. @ssyro` w`s tgd Xeutg-Rdst
@so`j Sewdr wgesd prepdr t`sl ot w`s te t`ld tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is"
hg`nndjbd up < aut. tgos tomd. @ssyro` f`ondi te rosd te tgd ehh`soej
fer tgd forst tomd oj gdr gostery* Rgdtgdr frem ompetdjhd er frem
ompenohy. sgd `nnewdi tgd Jem`is te r`oi Xeutg-Rdstdrj @so`
ujhg`stosdi< `ji sgd dvdj djnostdi tgdor sdrvohds `s mdrhdj`rods
te fobgt fer gdr oj gdr Mdio`j `ji A`aynejo`j w`rs* Ygdrday. sgd
rdpuio`tdi tgd fujhtoej wgohg sgd g`i m`id gdr ewj fer tgd n`st
fovd hdjturods<`ji tgd Mdids sdozdi tgd eppertujoty tgus effdrdi
te tgdm* Ygdy stdppdi ojte tgd ard`hg< ehhupodi tgd v`h`jt pestef i`jbdr `ji gejeur< dxtdrmoj`tdi er suaiudi er dxpdnndi tgd
Xhytgo`j ojtruidrs< `ji ojgdrotdi. `s tgdor rdw`ri. tgd gdbdmejy
prdvoeusny dxdrhosdi ay @ssyro` evdr Xeutg-Rdstdrj @so`.1 Fer
0 Xdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven*o. pp* 039-4. `aevd* Oj tgd sdvdjtg hdjtury A*H*. tgd Xhytgo`js
pdjdtr`tdi te Xyro`. nold tgd Gylses adferd tgdm `ji tgd Yurls `ftdr tgdm< `ji tgdj`md Xhytgepegs. ay wgohg tgd Brddls `ftdrw`ris ljdw tgd Aoanoh`n hoty ef Adtgsgd`j
'tgd meidrj A`os`j/ oj tgd V`nndy ef Kdzrddn. `ttdsts tg`t `t nd`st ejd Xhytgo`j w`r-a`jim`id ` pdrm`jdjt sdttndmdjt oj S`ndstojd*
1Dxhdpt oj tgd wdstdrj dxtrdmoty<
ef tgd @j`teno`j Sdjojsun`. adyeji tgd Qovdr G`nys.wgdrd tgd neh`n t`sl ef dxtdrmoj`tojb er suaiuojb er dxpdnnojb tgd ojtrusovd Jem`isw`s t`ldj oj g`ji. jet ay tgd Mdids. aut ay tgd Nyio`js; ` neh`n pdepnd wge wdrdujidr tgd ojfnudjhd ef tgd Gdnndjoh `ji jet tgd A`aynejoh er tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej*Ygd neh`n rdspejsd ef Nyio` te tgd hg`nndjbd frem tgd Jem`is wej gdr ` ieuand rdw`ri*Ej tgd n`jiw`ri soid. sgd sg`rdi wotg Mdio`. A`aynejo`. `ji Dbypt tgd iemojoejprdvoeusny dxdrhosdi ay @ssyro` evdr Xeutg-Rdstdrj @so`* Ej tgd sd`w`ri soid. tew`ristgd @dbd`j. sgd ompesdi gdr suzdr`ojty upej tgd Brddl hoty-st`tds `nejb tgd sd`ae`ri.wge g`i f`ondi te s`vd tgdmsdnvds frem tgd Jem`is `ji tgdodferd ferfdotdi tgdor
penotoh`n ojidpdjidjhd te tgd Sewdr oj tgd gojtdrn`ji wgohg g`i pdrfermdi tgd werl ef
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 448/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 082
@ssyro` w`s ` m`rhg er jetgojb* @s seej `s sgd f`ondi te rdspejite tgd hg`nndjbd ef dxtdrj`n prdssurd frem tgd gum`j djvorejmdjt.sgd fdnn< `ji Mdio`. wge g`i t`ldj up tgd Xhytgo`j hg`nndjbd. w`s
tgd Sewdr tg`t id`nt @ssyro` gdr id`tg-anew*
Oj tgd Xyro`h Rerni
Rgond tgd ommdio`td hejsdqudjhd ef tgd prdsdjt`toej ef tgd
Xhytgo`j hg`nndjbd w`s tgd rdpn`hdmdjt ef @ssyro` ay Mdio`. `j
untom`td hejsdqudjhd wgohg w`s ef muhg brd`tdr gosteroh`n om-
pert`jhd w`s tgd dvdjtu`n vohtery ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej oj ots
nejb iudn wotg tgd A`aynejoh tgd iudn wgohg g`i adbuj oj tgd
dndvdjtg
hdjturyA*H* wotg tgd hennosoej adtwddj
@ssyro``ji @r`m*
@ftdr tgd forst reuji g`i addj idhoidi oj f`veur ef tgd A`aynejohHovonoz`toej ay tgd vohteroeus @ssyro`j heujtdr-effdjsovd `b`ojst
Xyro` oj tgd jojtg `ji dobgtg hdjturods A*H*. tgd strubbnd g`i sgoftdi
frem tgd monot`ry te tgd huntur`n pn`jd `ji g`i rdsenvdi otsdnf ojte `
hempdtotoej adtwddj tgd twe rov`n hovonoz`toejs fer tgd hejvdrsoej
ef tgd gobgn`jidrs ej tgd @j`teno`j `ji Or`jo`j pn`td`ux* Oj tgos
hempdtotoej. tgd A`aynejoh Hovonoz`toej b`ojdi `j ojoto`n suhhdss.
wgohg g`s addj mdjtoejdi `aevd. oj tgd hejvdrsoej ef Tr`rtu<aut
tgos huntur`n "A`aynejohoz`toej+ ef ejd gobgn`ji heujtry ej tgd
jertg wgohg ioi jet suhhuma te @ssyro`j `rms w`s heujtdr-
a`n`jhdi ay tgd "Xyro`hoz`toej" ef `jetgdr gobgn`ji heujtry ej tgd
d`st wgohg tgd @ssyro`js tdmper`rony suhhddidi oj suakub`tojb<
`ji gdrd. oj Mdio`. tgd @ssyro`js oj `ppnyojb tgdor rutgndss
penohy ef ard`lojb tgdor vohtoms" sporot ay upreetojb tgdm frem
tgdor gemds `ji h`rryojb tgdm `w`y h`ptovd `htu`nny sdrvdi `s
"h`rrodrs" fer tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej wgohg tgdy g`i tr`mpndi
ujidr feet*
Rgdj tgd @ssyro`js foj`nny areld tgd rdsost`jhd ef tgd Xyro`h
pdepnds oj tgd n`ttdr g`nf ef tgd dobgtg hdjtury A*H*. tgdy idpertdi
p`rt ef tgd hejqudrdi pepun`toej te "tgd hotods ef tgd Mdids"<+ aut
tgos dxtrdmd `ppnoh`toej ef tgd m`xom "Iovoid `ji rund+ g`i `j
ujojtdjidi hejsdqudjhd* Ay tgd ferhoand ojtreiuhtoej ef Xyro`h
idpertdds. tgd Mdids wdrd ojehun`tdi wotg tgd bdrms ef tgd
Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej adferd tgdy wdrd stomun`tdi. ay tgd hg`nndjbd
ef Xhytgo`j prdssurd. te stdp ojte @ssyro`"s pn`hd* @t tgd s`mdtomd. tgd Xhytgo`j hg`nndjbd. wgohg h`nndi eut tgos "Xyro`hozdi"
Mdio`"s djdrbods. areld tgd "A`aynejohozdi" Tr`rtu"s a`hl< `ji
tgus tgd fovdfeni ojtdr`htoej adtwddj Xyro` `ji @ssyro` `ji Mdio`
`ji tgd Xhytgs `ji Tr`rtu werldi tebdtgdr fer tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`-
s`nv`toej fer tgdm* Ygd penotoh`n suakdhtoej ef tgd @so`toh Brddls te Nyio` j`tur`nny
dxpdiotdi tgd huntur`n hejvdrsoej ef tgd Nyio`js te Gdnndjosm* Ojiddi. tgos w`s pdrg`ps
tgd forst ef m`jy ojst`jhds oj wgohg "Br`dho` h`pt` fdrum vohterdm hdpot+* 'Ger`hd;
Dposten`d. Aeel OO. Dp* o. 0* 046*/+ 1 Lojbs xvj* 6 `ji xvuo* j*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 449/455
087 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
toej"s beei* @ftdr tgd f`nn ef @ssyro`. tgd rdmj`jt ef tgd A`aynejoh
Rerni jew b`tgdrdi tebdtgdr ojte "tgd Jde-A`aynejo`j Dmpord"
ef J`aepen`ss`r `ji Jdauhg`ijdzz`r feuji otsdnf gdmmdi oj
`ji prdssdi upej ay tgd Xyro`h Rerni ej aetgfn`jls;
jet ejnyfrem tgd rov`n hovonoz`toej"s gemdn`ji oj Xyro` otsdnf aut frem tgd
brd`t jdw iem`oj wgohg tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej g`i jew `hquordi
fer otsdnf oj Or`j* Frem tgos djhorhnojb mevdmdjt. tgd A`aynejoh
Hovonoz`toej g`i je merd hg`jhd ef dsh`pd tg`j `j `jtdnepd g`s
frem tgd teons ef ` ae`-hejstrohter* Ygd hejstrohtoej `ji m`stoh`-
toej ef tgd A`aynejoh Hovonoz`toej ay ots vohteroeus rov`n w`s ejny `
m`ttdr eftomd<`ji tgd prehdss w`s hempndtdi adferd tgd adbojjojb
ef tgd Hgrosto`j Dr`*0
Of wd jew turj eur `ttdjtoej te tgd suasdqudjt gostery ef tgd
Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej. wd sg`nn foji eur n`w onnustr`tdi gdrd `b`oj*
Ygd djn`rbdi Xyro`hRerniwgohg g`i addj areubgt ojte dxostdjhd
ay tgd "Xyro`hoz`toej" ef Or`j rdm`ojdi. frem tgd sdvdjtg hdjtury
A*H* ejw`ris. oj iordht hejt`ht wotg tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd< `ji ot
w`s frem tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is tg`t ot hejtojudi te rdhdovd tgd
gd`vodst dxtdrj`n prdssurd* Oj hejsej`jhd wotg tgos. wd foji tg`t.
tgdjhdferw`ri. tgd prom`hy oj tgd Xyro`h Rerni p`ssdi. oj suh-
hdssoej. te tgd pdepnds wge suhhdssovdny teel evdr tgd auridj ef
lddpojb tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is `t a`y. `ji te tgd rdboejs wgohg
suhhdssovdny sdrvdi `s `jto-Jem`i m`rhgds* Ygd Mdio`j gdbd-
mejy. fer dx`mpnd. n`stdi kust se nejb `s tgd Mdids gdni tgd frejt
nojd oj tgd idfdjsovd w`rf`rd `b`ojst Jem`i `bbrdssoej* Ygd gdbd-
mejy w`s ferfdotdi ay tgd Mdids te tgd Sdrso`js adh`usd tgd projhdsef Sdrsos g`i suhhddidi oj sj`thgojb frem tgdor Mdio`j jdobgaeurstgd w`ridjsgop ef tgd Dur`so`j M`rhgds `ji tgdrday rdndb`tojb
Mdio` te `j ujdxpesdi `ji ujstomun`tojb pesotoej oj tgd ojtdroer
ef tgd Xyro`h Rerni* Ygd Mdids g`i addj hejtdjt te a`r tgd
p`ss`bd ef tgd Jem`is `t ots j`rrewdst peojt. wgdrd tgd Dnaruz
Q`jbd ej ejd soid `ji tgd Hdjtr`n Idsdrt ef Or`j ej tgd etgdr
soid a`rdny nd`vd epdj. adtwddj tgdm. tgd H`spo`j B`tds"* Ygd@hg`dmdjoi`d m`sldi tgos Mdio`j frejt nojd. `ji rdiddmdi frem
Jem`i ehhup`toej ` v`st `iiotoej`n zejd ef Or`jo`j tdrrotery. ay
dxtdjiojb tgdor ewj iemojoejs jertg-d`stw`ris frem tgdor gemd
tdrrotery ef Sdrsos robgt up te tgd nojd ef tgd Exus < `ji ot w`s tgdor
dxp`jsoej oj tgos iordhtoej tg`t m`id tgdor fertujd ay puttojbtgdm oj ` pesotoej te supdrsdid tgd Mdids `s tgd Mdids g`i supdr-sdidi tgd @ssyro`js*
1
+ Fer tgd `ttr`htoej ef Or`j ojte tgd eraot ef tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej. `ji tgd `aserp-toej ef tgd id`i aeiy ef tgd A`aynejoh Hovonoz`toej ojte tgd Xyj`h Hovonoz`toej"s novojbtossuds. sdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* 2?-70. `aevd*
1 Ot m`y ad jetdi tg`t tgd Nyio`js `s wdnn `s tgd Mdids suhhumadi te tgd @hg`dmdjo-i`d. `ji tg`t Nyio`. nold Mdio`. g`i prdvoeusny addj "rdndb`tdi te tgd ojtdroer" ay tgd@hg`dmdmis+ `ssumptoej ef tgd w`ridjsgop ef tgd Dur`so`j m`rhgds*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 450/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 08?
Ygos @hg`dmdjo`j djtdrprosd oj tgd jertg-d`st. wgohg w`s tgd
prdnomoj`ry te tgd evdrtgrew ef tgd Mdio`j @sty`bds `ji te tgd
feuji`toej ef ` Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td oj tgd ferm ef`j @hg`dmdjo`j
Dmpord. wdjt `nmest ujm`rldi `mejb Gdnndjoh easdrvdrs. wgesdvosoej ioi jet ydt dxtdji te suhg iost`jt gerozejs* _dt tgd `hquoso-toej ef A`htro` w`s ` merd ompert`jt stdp oj tgd rosd ef tgd @hg`d-
mdjo`j Sewdr tg`j tgd `hquosotoej ef Dn`m< `ji ot w`s jet fer
jetgojb tg`t Hyrus mdt gos id`tg oj fobgtojb tgdJem`i M`ss`bdt`d
adyeji tgd K`x`rtds*0 Tjidr Hyrus"s suhhdssers. tgd @hg`dmdjo`j
Dmpord gdni `b`ojst tgd Jem`is. wotg ` strejb g`ji. dvdry e`sos
tg`t heuni ad hrd`tdi ay orrob`toej `nejb tgd heursds ef tgesd rovdrs
Gdro Qui `jiMurbg`a.
Exus `jiK`x`rtds
wgohg fnew eut
frem tgd jertgdrj feet ef tgd Or`jo`j Sn`td`u `ji frem tgd wdstdrj
feet ef tgd S`mors te rd`hg tgd H`spo`j er tgd Xd` ef @r`n er dnsd
te nesd tgdmsdnvds oj tgd idsdrt* Rd m`y hejkdhturd tg`t tgd
prdssurd ef tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is upej tgos Jertg-D`stdrj M`rhgef tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td `nw`ys wdobgdi merd gd`vony ej tgd
mojis ef @hg`dmdjo`j st`tdsmdj tg`j tgd prdssurd ef tgd Gdnndjds
upej tgd eppesotd dxtrdmoty ef tgdor iemojoejs `ji tgos dvdj
iurojb tgd @tgdjo`j heujtdr-effdjsovd tg`t w`s ldpt up ojtdr-
mottdjtny fer tgorty yd`rs `ftdr tgd f`onurd ef Wdrxds" dxpdiotoej
`b`ojst Brddhd* Ot w`s `ssurdiny jet ujton @ndx`jidr g`i hressdi
tgd I`ri`jdnnds. `ji pdrg`ps jet ujton gd g`i hressdi tgd Dupgr`tds.tg`t tgd Gdnndjoh pdron adh`md ` brd`tdr `jxodty tg`j tgd Jem`i
pdron te tgd n`st I`rous*
Merdevdr. @ndx`jidr"s ewj dxpdrodjhd oj tgdprehdss efhejqudr-
ojb tgd @hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord ojioh`tds tg`t. gdrd `s dnsdwgdrd. tgd
m`rhg wgohg w`s dxpesdi te tgd gd`vodst dxtdrj`n prdssurd g`i
addj stomun`tdi ojte ` brd`tdr vot`noty tg`j `jy etgdr rdboej* Ot
teel @ndx`jidr jet merd tg`j fovd yd`rs te hejqudr eutrobgt. wotg-
eut p`rndy er hempremosd. tgd v`st m`ss ef tgd @hg`dmdjo`j
iemojoejs. frem tgd I`ri`jdnnds `ji tgd Noay`j e`sds up te "tgd
H`spo`j B`tds". wgdrd tgd Mdids g`i g`ntdi oj tgdor pursuot ef tgd
reutdi Xhytgs `ji wgdrd @ndx`jidr evdrteel tgd iyojb I`rous*
Sdrsos otsdnf tgd gemd tdrrotery ef tgd ompdro`n iyj`sty `ji tgd
j`tovd n`ji ef tgd ompdro`n pdepnd quodtny `hhdptdi tgd vdrioht
ef tgd A`ttnd ef @radn`. jetwotgst`jiojb tgd stomunus wgohg tgdSdrso`js g`vojb "dndhtdi te novd `s `j ompdro`n pdepnd oj ` reubg
heujtry r`tgdr tg`j te huntov`td tgd newn`jis `s semd etgdr j`toej"s
0 Xdd tgd pohturdsqud `hheujt ef Hyrus"s n`st h`mp`obj oj Gdreietus. Aeel O. hgs*
131-04* Gdreietus"s `hhur`td ljewndibd ef bdebr`pgy ioi jet dxtdji muhg f`rtgdr
d`stw`ris tg`j ` nojd ir`wj frem Yrdaozeji te Xus` 'o*d* ` nojd reubgny heojhoidjt wotg
tgd prdsdjt d`stdrj frejtodrs ef Yurldy `ji "Or`q/< `ji gos "Qovdr @r`xds+ ej tgd
hressojb ef wgohg gos stery turjs `ppd`rs te ad ` hejfn`toej ef tgd `htu`n rovdr. stonn
ad`rojb tg`t j`md. wgohg fnews frem @rmdjo` tgreubg @zdra`ok`j ojte tgd H`spo`j.
wotg tgd `htu`n Exus `ji K`x`rtds. ojte ` sojbnd mobgty `ji f`auneus strd`m*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 451/455
093 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
sn`vds"0 g`i jdvdr hd`sdi te idrovd frem tgdor pgysoh`n djvorej-
mdjt* Jdvdrtgdndss. oj tgos ojst`jhd. tgd pgysoh`n stomunus ef `
reubg heujtry upej tgd Sdrso`js sgewdi otsdnf ndss petdjt tg`j tgd
gum`j stomunus ef Jem`i prdssurd upej tgdor lojsmdj oj tgdjertg-d`stdrj m`rhgds< fer. wgdrd`s ot g`i t`ldj @ndx`jidr je
merd tg`j fovd yd`rs te hejqudr tgd ojtdroer ef tgd @hg`dmdjo`j
Dmpord up te "tgd H`spo`j B`tds". ot teel gom twe wgend yd`rs
merd te hempndtd gos t`sl ay hejqudrojb tgd m`rhgds oj tgd Exus-
K`x`rtds A`soj*
@s seej `s @ndx`jidr p`ssdi adyeji tgd H`spo`j B`tds. gd
dxpdrodjhdi `j djtord hg`jbd oj tgd j`turd ef tgd rdsost`jhd wgohg
gd djheujtdrdi*
Tpte tg`t
peojt.gd g`i sdhurdi tgd suamossoej
ef v`st prevojhds `t tgd prohd ef ` fdw pothgdi a`ttnds `b`ojst
gdtdrebdjdeus ompdro`n fodni `rmods wgohg sgewdi nottnd djtguso`sm
fer idfdjiojb tdrroterods wgdrd tgdy fdnt tgdmsdnvds g`riny merd `t
gemd tg`j tgd ojv`idr* Tpej sdttojb feet. gewdvdr. oj tgd Exus-
K`x`rtds A`soj `ftdr tgd n`st ef tgd @hg`dmdjo`j `rmods g`i addj
sh`ttdrdi te tgd wojis. tgd M`hdiejo`j hejqudrer mdt wotg ` spej-
t`jdeus rdsost`jhd frem ` fdui`n `rostehr`hy wotg neh`n reets* Ygd
aeridr a`rejs ef A`htro` `ji Xebio`j` idfdjidi tgdmsdnvds `b`ojst
tgd M`hdiejo`js `s tgdy wdrd `hhustemdi te idfdji tgdmsdnvds
`b`ojst tgd M`ss`bdt`d* Ygdor rdsost`jhd w`s jet ejny spejt`jdeus
aut djdrbdtoh `ji pretr`htdi* Dvdry h`stnd steei ` sodbd< `ji dvdj
wgdj ` a`rej g`i addj areubgt te gos ljdds gd resd oj rdvent `b`oj
tgd memdjt tgd hejqudrer"s a`hl w`s turjdi* @t tgd dji ef twe
strdjueus h`mp`objs. @ndx`jidr g`i te woj tgd `nndbo`jhd wgohg
ferhd heuni jet dx`ht ay ` penohy ef hejhono`toej*
Ygus. iurojb tgd twe hdjturods tg`t g`i dn`psdi adtwddj tgd i`y
wgdj Hyrus mdt gos id`tg `t tgd g`jis ef tgd M`ss`bdt`d ej tgd f`r
soid ef tgd K`x`rtds `ji tgd i`y wgdj @ndx`jidr b`vd tgd Jem`is` ndssej ay aema`riojb tgdm wotg gos h`t`punts wotgeut hressojb
tgd frejtodr rovdr. tgd vot`noty ef tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td wgohg
w`s dmaeiodi oj tgd @hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord g`i hemd te ad hejhdj-
tr`tdi oj tgdsd jertg-d`stdrj m`rhgds. wgdrd tgd Xyro`h Rerni
w`s dxpesdi te tgd sdvdrdst dxtdrj`n prdssurd* Ot os rdm`rl`and te
foji tgos pgdjemdjej rd`ppd`rojb wgdj tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td.
wgohg g`i addj prdm`turdny hut sgert ay tgd idstruhtoej ef tgd@hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord tgreubg @ndx`jidr"s `htoej. w`s rdojtdbr`tdi`ji rdsumdi. `ftdr ` Gdnndjoh ojtrusoej wgohg g`i n`stdi `tgeus`ji
yd`rs. oj tgd "@aa`soi H`nopg`td*1
Ygeubg tgdh
@aa`soih`pot`n w`s foxdi. ej hejsoidr`toejs ef bde-
0 Xdd tgd p`ss`bd quetdi frem Gdreietus oj OO* I fo/. ej p* 80. `aevd*1 Fer tgd gosteroh`n rdn`toej adtwddj tgd "@aa`soi H`nopg`td `ji tgd @hg`dmdjo`j
Dmpord. sdd O* H 'o/ '6/. ven* o. pp* 28-7. `aevd*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 452/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 090
br`pgoh`n `ji `imojostr`tovd hejvdjodjhd. `t A`bgi`i.0 oj tgd
`jhodjt gemdn`ji ef tgd A`aynejoh Hovonoz`toej wgohg g`i nejbsojhd addj `aseradi ojte tgd Xyro`h Rerni. tgd penotoh`n `ji monot`ry
mevdmdjt wgohg hempndtdi tgd rd-dst`anosgmdjt ef tgd Xyro`hujovdrs`n st`td ay sdttojb up tgd "@aa`sois oj tgd pn`hd ef tgd
Tm`yy`is eroboj`tdi oj Lgur`s`j; tgd prevojhd nyojb adtwddj
"tgd H`spo`j B`tds" `ji tgd Murbg`a. wgohg w`s tgd jertg-d`stdrj
m`rhg ef tgd Xyro`h Rerni oj tg`t `bd*1 Ygd stomunus wgohg
jdrvdi @au Musnom `ji gos Lgur`s`jos te evdrtgrew tgd Tm`y-y`is w`s tgd sdnfs`md stomunus tg`t. oj d`rnodr `bds ef Xyro`h
gostery. g`i jdrvdi Hyrus `ji gos F`rsos te evdrtgrew@sty`bds `ji
tgd
Mdids.`ji g`i jdrvdi tgd iogl`js ef A`nlg `ji
Xubgite
md`surd tgdmsdnvds `b`ojst tgd ojvojhoand Osl`ji`r Igu"n-P`rj`yj*Ygd hg`nndjbd ef prdssurd frem tgd Jem`is ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppdw`s `s stomun`tojb te tgd n`ttdr-i`y Xyro`h frejtodrsmdj wge wdrd
hejfrejtdi ay tgd Dpgtg`notds `ji tgd Yurls `ji tgd Yoorbdsg `s
ot g`i addj te tgdor prdidhdssers wge g`i g`i te id`n wotg tgd
Xhytgs `ji tgd M`ss`bdt`d< `ji tgd Lgur`s`jos" gosteroh fd`t ef
rd-dst`anosgojb tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td oj @*I* 240 w`s ndi up te.
iurojb tgd yd`rs 234-90. ay tgd merd `riueus. of ndss memdjteus.fd`t ef rdojherper`tojb tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj ojte tgd Xyro`h
Rerni `ftdr ` sdp`r`toej tg`t g`i n`stdi semd dobgt er jojd
hdjturods*8
0 Ygd "@aa`sois foxdi tgdor h`pot`n `t A`bgi`i ej tgd s`md hejsoidr`toejs tg`t g`iejhd ndi tgd @hg`dmdjois te geni tgdor heurt `t A`aynej fer feur mejtgs oj tgd yd`r
'Gdreietus. Aeel O. hg* 0?1/* Ot n`y oj tgdmest rdmujdr`tovd prevojhd oj tgdor iemojoejs`ji `t tgd moi-peojt adtwddj tgd Xyro`j `ji tgd Or`jo`j g`nf ef tgd Dmpord*
z Ygd idstruhtoej ef tgd @hg`dmdm`j Dmpord g`i addj fennewdi. wotgoj twe hdj-
turods. ay tgd suamdrbdjhd ef tgd fermdr Jerm-D`stdrj M`rhgds oj tgd Exus-K`x`rtdsA`soj ujidr ` fneei efJem`i ojv`soej< fer tgd Xdnduhoi Dmpord. wgohg w`s tgd Gdnndjoh
"suhhdsser-st`td+ ef tgd @hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord oj @so`. w`s tee dx`htojbny prdehhupodiay tgd t`sl ef geniojb ots ewj `b`ojst rov`n Gdnndjoh Sewdrs oj tgd Ndv`jt te ioshg`rbd
dffohodjtny tgesd rdspejsoaonotods ej tgd iost`jt aeridrs ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd wgohg ot
g`i ojgdrotdi frem ots @hg`dmdjo`j prdidhdsser* 'Xdd pp* 0989. adnew*/ Ygus. fremtgd n`ttdr p`rt ef tgd sdheji hdjtury A*H* te tgd adbojjojb ef tgd dobgtg hdjtury ef tgd
Hgrosto`j Dr`. tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj g`i addj nest te tgd Xyro`h Rerni `ji g`i addj
novojb ` sdp`r`td nofd ef ots ewj ujidr tgd iemojoej ef suhhdssovd Jem`i ojtruidrs
M`ss`bdt`d '= X`l`s/ `ji _udhgo `ji Dpgtg`gtds `ji Yurls* Tjidr tgos iospdjs`toej.tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj g`i eftdj addj oj hnesdr rdn toejs wotg Ojio` tg`j wotg* Or`j<
`ji oj tgdsd hejiotoejs ot g`i idvdnepdi symptems ef ` iostojhtovd seho`n ojiovoiu`noty
wgohg premosdi. fer ` tomd. te t`ld idfojotd sg`pd oj tgd bdjdsos ef ` jdw "F`r D`stdrj
Hgrosto`j+ Hovonoz`toej* 'Xdd OO* I 'voo/. pp* 86?-74. adnew*/ Iurojb tgos nejb sdhdssoej* *v- - & + * +
** -o`h Rerni. Y
"
`ji dstr`jbdmdjt ef tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj frem tgd Xyro`h Rerni. tgd rend ef `jto-
Jem`i m`rhg idvenvdi upej tgd prevojhd ef Lgur`s`j. wgohg w`s s`vdi fer tgd Xyro`hRerni ay tgd @rs`hoi pjjhd Motgr`i`tds tgd Brd`t 'rdbj`a`t 018-77 A*H*/ `ftdr ` strubbnd
adtwddj tgd @rs`hoi Sewdr `ji tgd ojv`iojb X`l`s er M`ss`bdt`d wgohg g`i n`stdi fer
jd`rny g`nf ` hdjtury*8 Lgur`s`j tgd frejtodr prevojhd evdr `b`ojst tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is wgohg tgd
Tm`yy`is teel evdr frem tgd X`s`m`j suhhdssers ef tgd @rs`hoi`d w`s tgd a`sd ef
epdr`toejs frem wgohg. ujidr tgd Tm`yy`i rdbomd. tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj w`s
dvdjtu`nny rdojherper`tdi ojte tgd Xyro`h Rerni. ay ferhd ef `rms. oj @*I* 234-90* 'Xdd
Boaa. G* @* Q*; Ygd @r`a Hejqudsts oj Hdjtr`n @so` 'Nejiej 0?18. Qey`n @so`toh
Xehodty/*/ Ygd werl w`s `hhempnosgdi ay tgd hemaojdi dfferts ef @r`a b`rrosejs wgohg
g`i addj h`jtejdi oj Lgur`s`j `ftdr tgd @r`a hejqudst ef tgd X`s`m`j Dmpord. g`nf
` hdjtury adferd. `ji neh`n ndvods wgohg wdrd r`osdi. ay tgd @r`a `utgerotods. frem tgd
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 453/455
091 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Ygdrday. tgd Jertg-D`stdrj M`rhgds ef tgd Xyro`h Rerni. evdr
`b`ojst tgd Jem`is ef Dur`so`. wdrd rdsterdi. ej tgd dvd ef tgd
rdojtdbr`toej ef tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td ujidr tgdh
@aa`sois. te
tgd nomots up te wgohg tgdy g`i addj h`rrodi eroboj`nny ej tgd dvdef tgd forst dst`anosgmdjt ef tgd ujovdrs`n st`td ujidr tgd @hg`d-
mdjois* @ji tgdrd`ftdr gostery rdpd`tdi otsdnf ydt `b`oj <fer ujidr
tgd "@aa`soi. `s ujidr tgd @hg`dmdjoi. rdbomd tgd vot`noty ef tgd
Dmpord hejhdjtr`tdi otsdnf oj tgd Jertg-D`stdrj M`rhgds `s ot
daadi `w`y frem tgd ojtdroer* Ygos adh`md `pp`rdjt `t tgd ard`l-
up ef tgd "@aa`soi H`nopg`td. `s ot g`i adhemd `pp`rdjt. ejhd
adferd. `t tgd idstruhtoej eftgd @hg`dmdjo`jDmpord ay @ndx`jidr <
fer tgd mestpewdrfun
`ji dffdhtovd `jiseho`nny
adjdfohdjt ef tgd
H`nopg`td"s "suhhdsser-st`tds" `resd ejd `ftdr `jetgdr oj tgos rdboej*
Ygd X`m`joi rdbomd `t A`nlg `ji Aulg`r` '@*I* 70?-???/ festdrdi
Sdrso`j notdr`turd oj ots ojf`jhy `ji `hhempnosgdi semdtgojb wgohg
tgd H`nopg`td g`i jdvdr `hgodvdi oj prep`b`tojb Osn`m `mejb tgd
Jem`is ef tgd Xtdppd <+ `ji ot w`s ejny `s hejvdrts tg`t ot suffdrdi
tgdm `t n`st te trdsp`ss frem tgd idsdrt ej te tgd sewj* Ygdrd`ftdr.
ejd gerid ef tgdsd trdsp`ssdrs. tgd X`nkuqs. wgdj tgdy g`i pdjd-tr`tdi te A`bgi`i oj eridr te rdshud tgd "@aa`soi H`nopgs frem tgd
tyr`jjy ef tgd sdht`ro`j Auw`ygois. turjdi a`hl te suppn`jt tgdor
fdnnew-hejvdrts. tgd Ondl Lg`js. `s w`ridjs ef tgd Jertg-D`stdrj
M`rhgds `b`ojst tgdor ujhejvdrtdi Jem`ioh lojsmdj wge stonn
rdm`ojdi ej tgd Xtdppd* Tjidr tgos X`nkuq rdbomd `t Mdrv '@*I*
037?-0090/ tgd frejtodr ef I`r-`n-Osn`m w`s ejhd merd bu`ridi `s
f`otgfunny `s ot g`i addj bu`ridi ay tgd X`m`jois <`ji dvdj tgd
Xg`gs ef Lgw`rozm. wge forst resd te pewdr ay adtr`yojb tgdor
rdnoboej `ji `nndbo`jhd wgdj tgdy keojdi ferhds 'oj @*I* 0090/ wotg
tgd p`b`j Jem`i P`r` Pot`ys oj eridr te dxpdn tgd X`nkuq Xunt`j
X`jk`r frem tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj. dvdjtu`nny rdiddmdi tgdor
gejeur wgdj 'frem @*I* 0113 te 0180/ tgdy aerd tgd arujt ef tgd
Mejben `v`n`jhgd wgohg foj`nny evdrwgdnmdi I`r-`n-Osn`m oj tgd
n`st hejvunsoej ef tgd pest-Xyro`h Venldrw`jidrujb*1
ojiobdjeus Or`jo`j Lgur`s`jos* Ot os jetdwertgy tg`t ot w`s gdrd. oj tgd Jertg-D`stdrj
M`rhgds. ujidr tgd ferm`tovd ojfnudjhd ef ` hemmej prdssurd frem adyeji tgd frejtodr.tg`t tgd v`jquosgdi Or`jo`js `ji tgd vohteroeus @r`as forst fr`tdrjozdi wotg ejd `jetgdr*
@ji ot w`s tgos @r`a-Or`jo`j frejtodr-ferhd tg`t hempndtdi tgd rd-dst`anosgmdjt ef tgd
Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td. ay puttojb iewj tgd Tm`yy`is `ji sdttojb up tgdh
@aa`sois. tdjyd`rs `ftdr ot g`i prevdi ots mdttnd `ji `hquordi ots dsprot id herps ay hempndtojb tgd
rd-hejqudst ef Yr`jsex`jo` ej tgd Xyro`h Xehodty"s `hheujt*0 Ygd X`nkuqs. wge `t tg`t tomd wdrd r`jbojb evdr tgd stdppd-heujtry oj tgd Exus-
K`x`rtds A`soj. wdrd hejvdrtdi `aeut @*I* ?46< tgd fennewdrs ef tgd Ondl Lg`js. wgewdrd r`jbojb evdr tgd stdppds `ikeojojb tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj ej tgd jertg-d`st. oj
tgd b`p adtwddj tgd Yodj Xg`j `ji tgd @nt`o Meujt`ojs 'oj tgd feurtddjtg-hdjtury"Mubg`nost`j" `ji tgd meidrj "[ujb`ro`"/. wdrd hejvdrtdi `aeut @*I ?63*
1 Oj @*I* 013?%0103. tdj yd`rs adferd tgd Mejben `v`n`jhgd idshdjidi upej tgdm.tgd Lgw`rozm Xg`gs g`i p`rto`nny heujtdr`htdi tgd dffdhts ef tgdor eroboj`n `ht ef
trd`hgdry `b`ojst tgd X`nkuqs ay somon`rny adtr`yojb tgd P`r` Pot`ys* Ygdy p`rtotoejditgd iemojoejs ef tgd P`r` Pot`ys oj hejkujhtoej wotg Busgnul tgd J`om`j. `jetgdr
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 454/455
YGD XYOMTNTX EF SQDXXTQDX 098
Ygus. evdr tgd heursd ef semd jojdtddj hdjturods ef Xyro`h gos-
tery. frem tgd sdvdjtg hdjtury A*H* te tgd tgortddjtg hdjtury ef tgd
Hgrosto`j Dr`. wd h`j easdrvd ejd hejst`jt pgdjemdjej* Rd foji
tgdprdssurd frem tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is jerm`nny dxhddiojb oj
sdvdroty tgd prdssurds frem etgdr jdobgaeurs ef tgd Xyro`h Rerni.`ji hejhurrdjtny wd foji tgd Jertg-D`stdrj M`rhgds. upej wgohg
tgd arujt ef tgos prdssurd fdnn. jerm`nny surp`ssojb oj vot`noty `nn
tgd etgdr m`rhgds `s wdnn `s tgd ojtdroer*
Ygd dxhdptoej wgohg prevds tgd rund os tgd sotu`toej wgohg prd-
v`ondi. fer semd twe hdjturods eut ef tgdsd jojdtddj. ujidr tgd
Xdnduhoi Dmpord. wgohg w`s tgd @hg`dmdjo`j Dmpord"s Gdnndjoh
"suhhdsser-st`td" oj @so`* 0 Tjidr tgd Xdnduhoirdbomd.
`s ujidr
tgd @hg`dmdjoi `ji tgdh
@aa`soi. vot`noty `ji pewdr tdjidi te
p`ss frem tgd ojtdroer ef tgd Dmpord te tgd pdropgdry <aut wgdrd`s
tgdy p`ssdi ujidr tgd @hg`dmdjois frem Sdrsdpenos `ji Xus` `ji
A`aynej `ji Dha`t`j` te A`htro` `ji Xebio`j`. `ji ujidr tgd
"@aa`sois frem A`bgi`i te Lgur`s`j `ji te Yr`jsex`jo`. tgdyfnewdi eut. ujidr tgd Xdnduhois. oj tgd io`mdtroh`nny eppesotdiordhtoej ; tg`t os. frem Xdnduho`-ej-Yobros jet te "@ndx`jiro` ej
tgd Vdrbd" ef tgd Dur`so`j Xtdppd aut te @jtoehg-ej-Erejtds*
Ygos br`vot`toej ef tgd Xdnduhoi h`pot`n te ` sotd wgohg n`y `nmest oj
vodw ef tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j ojioh`tdi tg`t tgd Xdnduhoi st`tdsmdj.
ujnold tgdor @hg`dmdjoi prdidhdssers. fdnt tgd prdssurd frem tgd
Gdnndjoh Rerni merd `hutdny tg`j tgd prdssurd frem tgd Dur`so`j
Jem`is* Ygd euthemd. gewdvdr. w`s te prevd tg`t tgd Xdnduhois"
penohy w`s onn-`ivosdi `ji tgd sotd ef @jtoehg dhhdjtroh< fer. jet-
wotgst`jiojb tgd hndvdr neh`toej ef @jtoehg `tgw`rt tgd sgertdst
pert`bd adtwddj tgd Mdiotdrr`jd`j `ji tgd Dupgr`tds. tgd tr`js-
fdr ef tgd h`pot`n frem Xdnduho` te @jtoehg hest tgd Xdnduhoi`d tgdor
Dmpord `ji tgd Xyro`h Rerni ots Jertg-D`stdrj M`rhgds* Ygd
forst hejsdqudjhd w`s tg`t tgd Brddl b`rrosejs oj tgd Exus-K`x`rtds
A`soj. fojiojb tgdmsdnvds ndft te tgdor ewj rdseurhds. sdhdidi frem
tgd Xdnduhoi Dmpord `ji hejstotutdi tgdmsdnvds ojte `j ojidpdj-
idjt Sewdr; tgd Gdnndjoh Lojbiem ef A`htro`* Ygd sdheji hejsd-
qudjhd w`s tg`t tgos Gdnndjoh A`htro`. wgohg g`i rdspejidi wotg
suhg sporot te tgd hg`nndjbd ef idsdrtoej ay rdsertojb te sdnf-gdnp.
feuji gdrsdnf ujdqu`n oj tgd nejb ruj te tgd t`sl ef geniojb tgd
p`b`j Jem`i Sewdr. wge teel tgd P`r` Pot`ys oj tgd rd`r* Oj tgos ujgdreoh m`jjdr.tgd wgend ef tgd Exus-K`x`rtds A`soj w`s memdjt`rony rdhevdrdi `b`oj fer I`r-`n-
Osn`m< aut rdtroautoej quohlny evdrteel tgd speondrs* Ygd J`om`j `ji tgd Lgw`rozmXg`g wdrd evdrwgdnmdi oj turj ay tgd Mejben Hgojbos Lg`j< `ji ot w`s oj rdspejsdte tgos tdrrofoh Mejben hg`nndjbd tg`t tgd n`st ef tgd Lgw`rozm Xg`gs. K`n`n-`i-Ioj
M`jleaorjO. rdiddmdi tgd trd`hgdrods ef gos `jhdsters ay tgd gdreoh rd`r-bu`ri `htoej
oj wgohg gd hevdrdi tgd ojtdroer ef I`r-`n-Osn`m frem Mejben `ss`unt `ji a`ttdry fer `
wgend idh`id `ftdr tgd Mejbens g`i evdrruj gos ewj gemd-tdrroterods ej tgd a`jls ef
tgd Newdr Exus*0 Xdd tgd sdheji feetjetd ej p* 090. `aevd. `ji. furtgdr. S`rt VO. adnew*
7/27/2019 A Study of History : Volume 2 (Arnold J. Toynbee)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-study-of-history-volume-2-arnold-j-toynbee 455/455
099 YGD Q@JBD EF HG@NNDJBD-@JI-QDXSEJXD
Jertg-D`stdrj M`rhgds `b`ojst tgd Jem`is wotgeut suppert frem
tgd ojtdroer* Oj tgd sdheji hdjtury A*H*. A`htro` suhhumadi te `
Jem`i ojv`soej <+`ji tgd breuji tgdj nest te tgd Jem`is ay tgd
Brddls w`s ejny rdhevdrdi frem tgd Jem`is ay tgd @r`as semddobgt er jojd hdjturods n`tdr*
1
Oj tgd Orejoh Rerni evdr `b`ojst Dur`so`
Ygd Jertg-D`stdrj M`rhgds evdr `b`ojst tgd Dur`so`j Jem`is.
wgohg wdrd tgus rdojherper`tdi ojte tgd Xyro`h Rerni ej tgd dvd ef
tgd rdojtdbr`toej ef tgd Xyro`h ujovdrs`n st`td. `ji wgohg pn`ydi `
p`rt ef std`iony ojhrd`sojb ompert`jhd ujidr tgdh
@aa`soi rdbomd.8
preiuhdi tgdor gosteroh seho`n dffdht ejhd merd oj tgd forst `bd eftgd Or`joh Hovonoz`toej. "`ffono`tdi" te tgd Xyro`h Hovonoz`toej. wgohg
dmdrbdi. `ftdr tgd ojtdrrdbjum fennewojb tgd ard`l-up ef tgd "@a-
a`soi H`nopg`td. wgdj tgd w`tdrs ef tgd Mejben h`t`hnysm adb`jte suasoid*
Rd h`j ioshdrj tgos dffdht oj tgd iovdrsoty adtwddj tgd rdspdhtovd
gosteroh`n rends ef tgd twe Mejben "suhhdsser-st`tds" wgohg wdrd
idpesotdi gdrd ejd oj tgd aeridrn`ji `ji tgd etgdr oj tgd ojtdroer*
@s adtwddj tgdsd twe`pp`j`bds
ef tgd
Mejben Dmpordoj I`r-`n-
Osn`m. jetgojb h`md ef tgd projhop`noty ef tgd Geusd ef Gun`bu.tgd se-h`nndi On-Lg`js. oj Or`j `ji Or`q* "Ygd nojds" wdrd "f`nndj
ujte" tgdsd a`ra`ro`js "oj pnd`s`jt pn`hds < yd`". tgdy g`i "` beeiny
gdrot`bd"*9 @ji ydt. "`s tgd hneui os hejsumdi `ji v`josgdtg `w`y".
se tgd On-Lg`js wdjt iewj te tgd br`vd `ji h`md up je merd* 4