A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning...

47
A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton

Transcript of A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning...

Page 1: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

A Personal Recollection

by

Roger A.Dorton

Page 2: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Expo ‘67 Bridge Design Competition, 1967

A. Murray MacKay Suspension Bridge , 1970

Lions’ Gate Bridge Renovation, 1976

Conestogo River Test Bridge , 1976

Ontario Highway Bridge Design Code, 1979

Twinning the Burlington Skyway, 1985

Confederation Bridge, N.B. to P.E.I., 1997

Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997

Page 3: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 4: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 5: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 6: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 7: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 8: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Angus L. Macdonald

Bridge, 1956, by

P.L. Pratley.

Through Truss Design

Page 9: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Suspended Deck

Details, MacKay

Bridge

Cross Section of Deck, B-B

Page 10: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 11: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Full Aeroelastic Model, Tested by Alan Davenport

Page 12: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Suspended Span

Weights for Medium

Span Bridges

A. Murray MacKay Bridge the lightest suspension bridge with spans over 1,000 feet in 1970.

Page 13: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 14: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Modification to the North Cable Bent, 1976

Replacement of the Suspended Structure, 2002

Lions’ Gate Bridge

Renovation, 1976,

2002

Page 15: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 16: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 17: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

North Cable Bent

Page 18: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Cable Slippage

Page 19: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Deformed Shape

from 125mm Cable

Slippage and

Footing Rotation

Page 20: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Sequence of

Operations

For rotation of the north cable bent footings

Page 21: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 22: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 23: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 24: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 25: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 26: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 27: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 28: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 29: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 30: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 31: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 32: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

1979,1983,1991

Page 33: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

1. Limit States Design Replaced Working Stress

2. Load Factors Calibrated to 3.5 Safety Index

3. Deck Slab Arching Action, Only 0.3% Steel

4. Allowed Increase in Legal Truck Loads

5. New Dynamic Load Allowance

6. Full Commentary for the Code

7. Paid Consultants

8. Not a Consensus Code

9. Full MTO Management Support

Page 34: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 35: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 36: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 37: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 38: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through

Load and Resistance Factors Calibrated to a Safety Index of 4.0

Page 39: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 40: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 41: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 42: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 43: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 44: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 45: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 46: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through
Page 47: A Personal Recollection by Roger A.Dorton - ogra Roger Dorton_Innovation in Bridge... · Twinning the Blue Water Bridge, 1997 . Angus L. Macdonald Bridge, 1956, by P.L. Pratley. Through