8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 1/63

 

I @bkh}bsr }o|h}s sh ahkfo}okao =<9=

Sh Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq f}h` Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq- I aidd fh} `h}id bkvoksh}r ikc doico}qjb| bk I+I+

Ahksoksq \igo

Bks}hcuasbhk……………………………………………………………………………………+++9

Qoasbhk 9Ikidrqbq hf |iqs ikc au}}oks ovoksq$ _QI$ Aikici$ _E………………………+ ……………++++9

Qoasbhk =Muqbkoqq jiq kh muqbkoqq bk I+I………………………………………………………………+9:

Qoasbhk 1Sjo iksbsjoqbq hf Mbg Mhhe Q|hkqh}qjb|> Ozi`|doq hf I+I+ q|hkqh}qjb|$uqbkg yuhsisbhkq f}h` I+I+ |umdbqjoc dbso}isu}o…………+……………………………………+=2

Qoasbhk 3Ikidrqbq hf I+I+ S}icbsbhkq ikc Ahkao|sq i||dboc sh |iqs ikc au}}oks ovoksq$ozi`bkbkg sjo cbffo}okao moswook iqqo}sbvo ikc |ukbsbvo mojivbhu}…………………………+++1=

Qoasbhk ? Kh \hdbao fh}ao bk I+I+8 Ik ikidrqbq hf |iqqbvo mojivbhu}……………………………………+3<

Qoasbhk 6Ozi`bkisbhk hf sjo cbffo}okao moswook `bkh}bsr g}hu|q$ `bkh}bsr h|bkbhkq$i sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd `bkh}bsboq++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++3?

Qoasbhk 7Bkvoksh}r………………………………………………………………………………………+++36

Qoasbhk :I+I+‒q Fusu}o> Ici|sisbhk h} Ovhdusbhk8 ………………………………………………………+?<

Qoasbhk 2I}o wo ah``ukbaisbkg sjo I+I+ `oqqigo bk sjo }bgjs wir8 ……………………………………?3

Qoasbhk 9<Ahkaduqbhk………………………………………………………………………………………+6=

 

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 2/63

I @bkh}bsr }o|h}s sh ahkfo}okao =<9=

Sh Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq f}h` Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq- I aidd fh} `h}id bkvoksh}r ikc doico}qjb| bk I+I+

Sjbq chau`oks ah`|}bqoq ik ikidrsbaid ikc a}bsbaid qu}vor hf sjo Foddhwqjb| bk =<99$cbqauqqbkg sjo ah`|doz crki`baq qu}}hukcbkg au}}oks ovoksq haau}}bkg bk sjo _QI$_E ikc Aikici ikc }odisbkg sjoqo sh |iqs ovoksq ikc sh II S}icbsbhkq ikc Ahkao|sq+Sjo cbqauqqbhk mogbkq wbsj swh ozi`|doq hf iasbvo doico}qjb|$ hko mr Mbdd W+ bk sjo923<q$ sjo hsjo} mr i ah``bssoo bk Qiksi @hkbai Aidbfh}kbi _QI$ bk 92?:5 bs sjok`hvoq hk sh bkaduco au}}oks ovoksq+ Sjo husah`o oz|hqoq i ji~i}chuq co|i}su}o f}h`S}icbsbhk$ qo}bhuq ikc g}hwbkg bkso}kid cbvbqbhkq ikc |umdba ahkao}kq+ Bs idqh oz|hqoqi wbcoq|}oic ikc ji~i}chuq `bqahkao|sbhk bk sjo i||dbaisbhk hf I+I+ S}icbsbhkq+ Ikci qbsuisbhk wjo}o kobsjo} I+I+ S}icbsbhk$ kh} Goko}id Wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao i}owbsjqsikcbkg bk shcir‒q foddhwqjb|+ Sjbq aiuqoq uq sh food cusr mhukc sh |diao sjbq iq i`bkh}bsr }o|h}s mofh}o sjo _E Goko}id Qo}vbao Ahkfo}okao =<9=+

QOASBHK 9

Ikidrqbq hf |iqs ikc au}}oks ovoksq$ _QI$ Aikici$ _E 

Sjo fhddhwbkg bq ik ozs}ias f}h` I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo+ Mbdd W‒q }oq|hkqo sh |}hsoasI+I+‒q |umdba }odisbhkq mr sjwi}sbkg sjo |dikq hf i |hsoksbid fbgu}ojoic wbsj i—whkco}fud vbqbhk‐ ikc jbq —`oqqigo‐+ Shcir hko hkdr jiq sh }o|diao sjo wh}c—}icbh‐ wbsj —womqbso+‐ Ik ozi`|do hf S}icbsbhk Swh ikc Ahkao|s BZ bk iasbhk>

—Ik hdc qsh}r$ }ovoidbkg qovo}id iq|oasq hf I+I+‒q |umdba }odisbhkq |}hmdo`$ ah`oq sh `bkc> Hko hf hu} |bhkoo} `o`mo}q ahkaobvoc sjo bcoi hf qsi}sbkg i g}hu| bk jbq absr mr }icbh…++ Qh hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc ahkqs}uasoc i qo}boqhf ‚Swodvo Doasu}oq hk Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+‒ Sjoqo wo}o i qs}ikgo `bzsu}o hf I+I+ ikc jbq hwk }odbgbhuqbcoiq+ Jo qhhk |us sjo` hk ib} wbsj idd sjo vbghu} hf i Ajiusiuyui h}ish}+ Ahks}i}r sh hu} oz|oasisbhkq$ jo ghs i`hcoqs }oquds+ Bkyub}boq ai`o bk ikc jo qsi}soc i g}hu|+ Khw fduqjoc wbsj quaaoqq$ jo wiq q`bssok wbsj i

whkco}fud vbqbhk+++++++++ Wo icvbqoc jb` sjis sjo s}uqsooq fods jbq `oqqigo bki||}h|}biso fh} kisbhkid ahkqu`|sbhk+Qh jo w}hso i jhs dosso} sh sjbq offoas> ‚Sh jodd wbsj sjo s}uqsooq$ sjo wh}dc bq wibsbkg fh} `r `oqqigo+ B‒vo ghs sjo}bgjs sh f}oo q|ooaj ikc B‒` ghbkg hk ib} wjosjo} rhu dbeo bs h} khs+‒ Sjbq udsb`isu` wiq ik idi}`bkg |hqo}+ Bsdhheoc dbeo |}h`hsbhk$ |}hfoqqbhkidbq`$ ikc ikhkr`bsr-m}oiebkg idd bk hko |iaeigo…+ ovo}r ic `ik ikc qidoq`ikbk Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq whudc qhhk mo qoddbkg I+I+‒q wi}oq$ wbddr-kbddr+ Wo whudc dhhqo ahks}hd hf hu} |umdba}odisbhkq+…………+ Wo iqqu}oc hu} wodd-`oikbkg f}bokc sjis wo whudc ao}sibkdr u|jhdc jbq }bgjs sh f}oo q|ooaj+Mus wo iccoc sjis jo hugjs sh u|jhdc hu}q$ shh+ Wo iqqu}oc jb` sjis bf jbq ‚doasu}oq‒ woks hk ib}$ wo whudc icvbqoovo}r I+I+ g}hu| hf sjo ab}au`qsikaoq ikc iqe sjo` sh w}bso qs}hkg dosso}q sh sjo q|hkqh}bkg dbfo iqqu}ikaoah`|ikr$ dosso}q hf i ebkc sjo q|hkqh} `bgjs khs dbeo sh }oaobvo+ Sjo m}hicaiqs kovo} woks hk ib}+‐ *II ah`oq hf Igo |igoq 91<-919"

9

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 3/63

Sjo fhddhwbkg bq ikhsjo} ozi`|do hf S}icbsbhk Swh ikc Ahkao|s BZ bk iasbhk5 ikI+I+ ah``bssoo siebkg ik ukah`|}h`bqbkg qsikc igibkqs i |hwo} c}bvbkg doico} bk92?:+ Sjbq iasbhk q|dbs sjo I+I+ g}hu|$ sjuq |}hsoasbkg I+I+ f}h` wbco} cbqukbsr ikcqumqoyuoks mic |}oqq+ S}uo sh S}icbsbhk Swh$ sjo |}ocbasbhk sjis sjo —i}aj coiahk‐whudc obsjo} iaao|s sjo g}hu| ahkqabokao h} wbkc u| c}uke ai`o ovoksuiddr$ mus hkdrifso} =< roi}q+ Sjo qumqoyuoks jbqsh}r hf Qrkikhk qjhwq sjis i auds }uk mr ikidahjhdba aik mo vo}r quaaoqqfud wbsj dhkg-so}` vbimbdbsr+ Sjo g}hu|‒q doico}  Ajuae C*wjh bkabcoksiddr wiq sh qh`o roi}q diso} i||hbks jb`qodf \h|o$ ikc jbq wbfo$ Jbgj\}boqsoqq hf sjo auds Aju}aj hf Qrkikhk"$ }oaiddoc jbq 92?: khs qh q|b}bsuid mi|sbq`wbsj ahkao|s BZ$ whkco}fuddr ozoausoc mr I+I+ s}uqsoc qo}viksq+

- Sjor bksubsbvodr ekow jhw jikcdo qbsuisbhkq wjbaj qoo` sh miffdo uq shcir+ 

—Bs ji||okoc }bgjs bk sjo `bccdo hf ik I+I+ `oosbkg+ Hu} wjhdo gikg jic sieok hvo} sjo Qisu}cir kbgjs `oosbkghf sjo Qiksi @hkbai I+I+ g}hu| is Swoksr Qbzsj ikc M}hicwir ikc mubds bs u| f}h` bsq issokcikao hf sok |oh|do shik issokcikao hf imhus fh}sr fbvo h} fbfsr+ Sjo}o wiq qh`o hmnoasbhk hk qh`o bqquo mr sjo `o`mo}q hf sjo Mhi}c hf Cb}oash}q hf sjo I+I+ adum+ B }oaidd sjo doico} qsh||bkg sjo `oosbkg+ Sjor cbck‒s dbeo uq+ Sjo ideboq cbck‒s dbeo sjoiccbasq$ ikc sjor cbck‒s dbeo `o bk |i}sbaudi}…ikc sjor cbck‒s dbeo `r gikg moaiuqo sjor wo}o `hqsdr iccbasq+Sjor `ico sjbkgq cbffbauds fh} uq+ B }o`o`mo} gossbkg u| bk sjo `oosbkg ikc qirbkg$ ‚Idd }bgjs$ dos‒q gh jh`o-sjojodd wbsj sjbq+‒ Qh sjo wjhdo `oosbkg ghs u|$ ikc wo idd ghs bksh hu} iush`hmbdoq ikc ai`o chwk sh sjo adum$ ikcwo kovo} woks miae sh I+I+ igibk+‐ *F}h` sjo Coqe hf Nuik Doqokco> Jhw C}ug Imuqo S}ois`oks Su}kq bksh@bqs}ois`oks Mr Nuik O+ Doqokco - Qo|so`mo} 9:sj =<<2"jss|>((www+s}ois`oksqhdusbhkqkoswh}e+ah`(mdhg(bkcoz+|j|(=<<2(<2(9:(f}h`-sjo-coqe-hf-nuik-doqokco-jhw-c}ug-imuqo-s}ois`oks-su}kq-bksh-`bqs}ois`oks( 

Wjo}o cbc bs ah`o f}h`8 Qrkikhk Aju}aj ikc sjo `ocbaid miqbq fh} sjo #s}ibgjsq>jss|>((sjoqs}ibgjsq+ah`(sjo|}hg}i`(qrkikhk-qsh}r=+js` Wbeb|ocbi ‑ Qrkikhk> jss|>((ok+wbeb|ocbi+h}g(wbeb(QrkikhkAjuae Coco}baj Qsbdd ]udoq Qrkikhk$ mus Khw Jo Jiq 9$1<< Qumnoasq ikc i #== @bddbhk O`|b}o -- Mr Mi}mi}iWbdebkq --\OH\DO `igi~bko'q i}ajbvo> Hashmo} 99$ 9276$ Vhd+ 6$ Kh+ 9?>jss|>((www+|oh|do+ah`(|oh|do(i}ajbvo(i}sbado(<$$=<<662:?$<<+js`d Coco}bae Aji}doq O> *Sjo dbke `ir qjhw —kh sozs ivibdimdo‐$ bf qh adbae mduo dbke —qoi}aj fh} sjbq |igo sbsdo‐+Qoi}aj }oqudsq `ir qjhw —Kh |igo sbsdo `isajoq‐$ Bf qh adbae hk sjo mduo —Coco}bae Aji}doq O dbke$ imhus jidfwirchwk sjo |igo+"> jss|>((www+iqs}h+ah`(iqs}h-cisimike(Coco}bae/=AXAji}doqXO+ Fbkcbkg Ibc fh} sjo @bsajodd-Qrkikhk Dbsbgisbhk \i|o}q$ 9272-92:2 _kbvo}qbsr hf Sokkoqqoo Q|oabid AhddoasbhkqDbm}i}r$ Ekhzvbddo$ SK> jss|>((cda+dbm+use+ocu(f(fi(fuddsozs(9799+js`d

Wo whkco} jhw I+I+ whudc jivo }oq|hkcoc$ bf Ajuae jic coabcoc sh h|o}iso jbq

f}ikajbqo iq ik iushkh`huq g}hu| hf I+I+$ fh} ozi`|do —sjo Qrkikhk g}hu| hf I+I+‐bkqsoic hf ghbkg bs idhko+ H} bf sjo I+I+ `o`mo}q jic dofs sjo I+I+ g}hu| idd sh Ajuae 

 mr qirbkg —Oiaj g}hu| bq iushkh`huq)‐ —Dbvo ikc dos dbvo)‐ —Vhso wbsj rhu} foos)‐bkqsoic hf jivbkg sjo miaemhko sh qsikc ikc cofokc I+I+ S}icbsbhk+ Whudc sjobkso}g}hu|q ikc GQH hf sjo 926<q jivo ahksbkuoc sh }ogbqso} jbq g}hu|q ikc jhw`uaj ci`igo whudc sjo ozs}ih}cbki}r imuqoq sjis wo}o sh haau} bk jbq auds jivo chkosh I+I+‒q |umdba }odisbhkq$ wo}o jbq auds sh jivo }o`ibkoc bk I+I+8

=

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 4/63

Hko aik hkdr sieo ik bkfh}`oc guoqq f}h` sjo wh}cq hf Mbdd W+ bk sjo i}sbado imhus

—Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐ wjh su}koc —idi}`bkg |hqo}‐ *II ah`oq hf Igo |igo 91<-919"$ jhw jo ikc sjhqo s}uqsooq whudc jivo }oq|hkcoc sh sjo }bqo hf sjo fbgu}ojoicNho @aY5 wjh odovisoc jb`qodf sh soiajo} ikc iusjh} hf sjo mhhe —Ai}}r Sjbq@oqqigo ‑ gubco sh Mbg Mhhe Q|hkqh}qjb|5‐ wjbaj ai}}boq jbq —`oqqigo+‐ - i —qs}ikgo`bzsu}o hf II ikc jbq hwk }odbgbhuq bcoiq‐ *II ah`oq hf Igo |igo 91<" ikc jbqs}ois`oks aoks}o ]oahvo}r Crki`baq |}hg}i`+

Sjo fhddhwbkg i}o ozs}iasq f}h` —Ai}}r Sjbq @oqqigo ‑ i gubco sh Mbg Mhhe Q|hkqh}qjb|‐$ mr Nho @aY>—Iq q|hkqh}q wo ekhw$ sjo}o i}o ao}sibk sjbkgq wo }oyub}o hf i q|hkqh}oo UqbaP… … … jo jiq sh ai}}r hus jbqiqqbgk`oksq ikc ch sjo sjbkgq rhu iqe jb` sh ch‐ *|igo =?"+—… … wo i}o wh}ebkg wbsj ik ukcbqab|dbkoc |o}qhk+ Iqqbgk`oksq qjhudc mo gbvok$ ikc sjo q|hkqh} qjhudc `ieo bsadoi} sh sjo |o}qhk sjis iqqbgk`oksq jivo sh mo chko mr i q|oabfba sb`o…++sjo}o i}o ao}sibk sjbkgq wo }oyub}o hf iq|hkqh}oo UqbaP… … Jo jiq sh ai}}r hus jbq iqqbgk`oksq ikc ch sjo sjbkgq rhu iqe jb` sh ch … … C}+ Mhm qibc‚Gos chwk hk rhu} ekooq+‒ Ikc sjor shhe qso| 1… … Mus ik idahjhdba aik ch nuqs imhus ikrsjbkg rhu `ieo jo} ch+ Bf rhu bkqbqs sjis qjo ch ao}sibk sjbkgq$ qjo‒dd gos sjo` chko+ Qjo jiq sh gh f}h` sjo ukcbqab|dbkoc sh sjocbqab|dbkoc… … Is hu} s}ois`oks aoks}o$ Qo}okbsr \i}e$ wo }oyub}o idd sjo adboksq gos i q|hkqh} wbsjbk sjo sjb}cwooe… Sjo q|hkqh} soiajoq cbqab|dbko… … ovo}rsjbkg bq wh}ebkg hk sjbq ukcbqab|dbkoc |o}qhk… …+ Ikukcbqab|dbkoc |o}qhk `ir fbgjs cbqab|dbko$ mus bs jiq sh mo okfh}aoc sh jod| sjo |o}qhk…+‐ *\igoq$ =6$ =7"Rhu aik‒s nuqs qir sh sjo q|hkqh}oo UqbaP ‚gh qsi}s hk rhu} bkvoksh}r‒ moaiuqo bs `bgjs sieo jb` i `hksj$ `irmoswh+ A}oiso i qajocudo mr qirbkg qh`osjbkg dbeo$ ‚Wo i}o ghbkg sh wh}e hk }oqoks`oksq fh} swh cirq‒ sjok ch sjohsjo} bkvoksh}boq qb`bdi}dr$ wbsj i qajocudo fh} oiaj hko wjbaj choqk‒s iddhw sjo q|hkqh}oo UqbaP sh qeb`|$ mus`hvoq jb` h} jo} idhkg is i ghhc |iao…+*Qso| Fhu} iqqbgk`oks"+Rhu kooc sh `hvo rhu} q|hkqh}oo UqbaP idhkg |}ossr fiqs…+ mus rhu kooc sh eoo| sjo q|hkqh}oo UqbaP muqr ikc eoo|jo} `hvbkg… rhu qjhudc nuqs `hvo jb` }bgjs hk sj}hugj sjo` mi`$ mi`$ mi`$ mi`+ Eoo| sjo `h`oksu`…++‐*\igo 6?"

—]o`o`mo} sjis idd sjo |oh|do bk hu} foddhwqjb| g}hu|q i}o khs }oiddr idahjhdbaq… … … Sjor i}ok‒s }oiddridahjhdbaq ‑ moaiuqo ik idahjhdba aik‒s ch sjis+ Sjor chk‒s uquiddr qsir5 sjor nuqs ah`o bk ik hus hf hu} foddhwqjb|+Mus sjor chk‒s jivo i `oqqigo sh qji}o…++‐ *\igo 6?"

Sjo Hkdbko Hzfh}c cbasbhki}r cofbkbsbhk hf m}ibk wiqj>vo}m Uwbsj hmnoas P

|}oqqu}b~o *qh`ohko" bksh ich|sbkg }icbaiddr cbffo}oks modbofq mr uqbkg qrqso`isba ikc hfsok

fh}abmdo `oikq> |oh|do i}o m}ibkwiqjoc bksh modbovbkg fi`bdr dbfo bq sjo moqs *iq khuk m}ibkwiqjbkg"

vbasb`q hf m}ibkwiqjbkg  jss|>((hzfh}ccbasbhki}boq+ah`(cofbkbsbhk(m}ibkwiqj

Ozs}iasq f}h` —Sjo Qso|q wo shhe‐$ Nho @aY+ hf sjo ‚Mbg Mhhe Qsucr Si|oq‒>

—Sjo}o bq i qsh}r bk sjo Mbmdo jhw idd sjbq ahkfdbas mogik+ Sjo Gi}cok hf Ocok qsh}r… … sjo Mbmdo qirq ‚wo i}oGhc-dbeo‒… … Qh jo a}oisoc Ici` ikc Ovo ikc |us sjo` bk Qo}okbsr \i}e…+ Hko cir i qkieo ai`o u| sh Ovoikc jo qibc… … ‚Jor Ovo rhu‒vo ghs qodf wbdd‒… … Ovo jic kovo} joi}c quaj i sjbkg qh qjo qibc ‚Wjis‒qsjis8‒… … Qh sjo qkieo }ik bs chwk sh jo}+ Jo qibc ‚Rhu aik ch wjisovo} rhu wiks sh)‒ Qjo ahudck‒s wibs$ qjo }iksh sodd Ici`$ ‚Ici`$ Ici` wo‒vo ghs qodf ‑wbdd+‒ Jo |}hmimdr qibc ‚Wjis bk sjo wh}dc bq sjis8‒ Qh qjo oz|dibkocbs sh jb`… …‐ *\igo 3<$ 39"—B sjbke hko hf sjo `bqsieoq `ikr |oh|do i}o `iebkg shcir bq sjbq> khs hkdr iq bkcbvbcuidq$ mus g}hu|q hf |oh|do$gos shgosjo} ikc side imhus sjob} |}hmdo`q+ Sjor kovo} qoo` sh side imhus wjis sh ch imhus sjo`… … … Sjo}o bqkh g}hwsj bk sjbq wir hf chbkg5 bk fias sjor nuqs `igkbfr sjob} |}hmdo`q+ B aidd sjbq ‚g}hu| qbaekoqq…‒ *\igo 9=:"—B sjbke Noquq `ir jivo mook soiajbkg sjo |}bkab|do hf sjo fb}qs qso| wjok jo qibc ‚cokr sjrqodf+‐ *\igo 92"—Qso| 9 h|okq sjo chh} sh Qso| =+ B dbeo sh uqo sjo |i}imdo hf sjo |}hcbgid qhk *Dueo 9?>99-1=" *\igo =3"

1

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 5/63

—Sjo Mbmdo qirq$ ‚…ro qjidd ekhw sjo s}usj ikc sjo s}usj qjidd `ieo rhu f}oo+‒*Nhjk :>1="+‐ *\igo =?"—Civbc qibc bk sjo =1}c |qid`$ ‚Sjo Dh}c bq `r qjo|jo}c+‒ *\igo ?1"—Bs‒q dbeo bk sjo Mbmdo$ wjo}o bs qirq sjo}o bq sb`o fh} ovo}rsjbkg+ *Oaadoqbiqsoq 1>9"+‐ *\igo 63"—Noquq qibc$ ‚Sjhu qjids dhvo sjo Dh}c sjr Ghc wbsj idd sjr joi}s+‐ *\igo 9=3"—B dhvo sjo |iqqigo bk sjo Mbmdo sjis qirq$ ‚ Sjhu qjids khs mo if}ibc hf sjo so}}h} mr kbgjs5 kh} fh} sjo i}}hw sjisfdbosj mr cir5 kh} fh} sjo |oqsbdokao sjis wideosj bk sjo ci}ekoqq5 kh} fh} sjo coqs}uasbhk sjis wiqsosj iskhhkcir+‒*\qid`q 29>?-6"—B idqh dbeo sjo qsh}r hf Civbc sjo dbssdo qjo|jo}c mhr ikc sjo gbiks Ghdbisj+‐ *\igo 936"—++Sjis sjor `bgjs jivo dbfo$ ikc sjis sjor `bgjs jivo bs `h}o imukciksdr *Nhjk 9<>9<" *|igo 9??"

—Wjok wo fbkbqj qso| 2 wo gos sjo |}h`bqoq+‐ *\igo 9=1"

—Qbkao Mbdd cbck‒s jivo sjo ai|iabsr sh w}bso dbeo i g}ois oz|o}s bk q|b}bsuid sjbkgq$ jo dibc hus i moiusbfud$ qb`|docibdr ozo}abqo+‐ *|igo 917"

Sjbq |}hg}i` `ir wodd jivo wh}eoc bk jbq s}ois`oks aoks}oq+ Mus mr `bzbkg sjbqhusqbco okso}|}bqo bkqbco I+I+ ikc mr |diabkg sjo mhheq bk sjo jikcq hf sjo qsbddo`hsbhkiddr quffo}bkg idahjhdba q|hkqh}q wjh mi}odr ukco}qsikc jhw b}}isbhkid sjori}o$ sjo cbasish}bid$ nucg`oksid ikc cbqab|dbki}bik so}`bkhdhgr jo uqoc sjo}obk$ jiqkhw dofs I+I+ wbsj sjo dogiar hf i auds fhddhwbkg ikc ik imuqbvo qsrdo hf aho}abvoq|hkqh}qjb| f}h` wjbaj bs wbdd sieo i dhs hf offh}s sh }oahvo}+ - I dogiar hf sjovbhdisbhk hf S}icbsbhkq fhu} *dhkg fh}`" qbz ikc swodvo+

I cbqiffoasoc idahjhdba soddq jbq qsh}r>

—Sjikeq fh} sjbq fh}u` gurq ikc gidq+ B i` jivbkg g}ivo cbffbaudsboq wbsj II$ iq `r oz|o}bokaoq wbsj bs i}o khsghhc$ ikc B jivo mook dhhebkg fh} i qbso sh ahkfb}` `r |}onucbaoq+ B sjhugjs B jic fhukc bs bk sjo H}ikgo \i|o}q$ mus `osjbkeq sjis sjo iusjh} chsj |}hsoqs shh `uaj$ ikc B i` mobkg su}koc hff sjbq qbso+ B jivo mook qumnoasoc sh sjo |}b`i}r |u}|hqo g}hu| mr `r q|hkqh} wjbdqs bk s}ois`oks$ ikc sjbq wiq sjo sb||bkg |hbks fh} `o+ Jhwovo}$ B wiq nucgbkg II - idd II mr sjo }iksbkgq hf Aj}bq ]+ Khw B qoo sjis sjo}o I]O `hco}isoq bk II$ |oh|do dbeorhu}qodvoq$ moaiuqo wjbdqs B }oidbqo sjis II bq khs fh} `o$ B ch }oq|oas sjo i}gu`oks sjis bs BQ ghhc fh} qh`o |oh|do$ ikc B dhhe fh}wi}c sh }oicbkg sjo |hqsq bk sjbq fh}u`‐+ *iiaudswisaj fh}u` qumnoas oksbsdoc —II auds+‐"jss|>((iiaudswisaj+ah+ue(cofiuds+iq|z

Bk 9239 sjo ghhc kowq wiq w}bssok bk sjo |}oqq ikc I+I+ mogik sh sieo hff>

—Moaiuqo hf sjo imqokao hf fbgu}ojoicq ikc sjo fias sjo}o bq kh fh}`id mhcr hf modbof sh |}h`hso$ sjor jivo khfoi}q sjis Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq wbdd cogoko}iso bksh i auds+‐ *Sjo Niae Idozikco} i}sbado imhus II$ |igo =1"jss|>((www+ii+h}g(|cf(|}hcuasq(|-9=XsjoNiaeIdozI}sbado+|cf 

Wo whkco} bf sjo ah-fhukco}q hf II whudc qir sjo qi`o sjbkg bf sjor wo}o i}hukcshcir+ Shcir hu} |umdba b`igo bq khs qh ghhc>

3

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 6/63

922:> Sjo Bkco|okcoks> Auds h} au}o> sjo II miaediqj ---- Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq bq ukco} issiae+ Sjhqo wjhjivo mook sj}hugj bsq `bdd adib` bs bq liusjh}bsi}bik' ikc lfiqabqsba'$ o`|dhrq m}ibkwiqjbkg soajkbyuoq ikc bq auds-dbeo bk bsq issbsuco sh `o`mo}q+ _}qudi Eokkr sideq sh sjo cbqiffoasoc wjh jivo }onoasoc bsq }hic sh }oahvo}r++++jss|>((www+bkco|okcoks+ah+ue(dbfo-qsrdo(auds-h}-au}o-sjo-ii-miaediqj-996<991+js`d=<<2> Sjo Bkco|okcoks> Sh` Qjhko sieoq hk sjo idd |hwo}fud auds hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huqjss|>((www+bkco|okcoks+ah+ue(i}sq-okso}sibk`oks(mhheq(foisu}oq(shmr-rhukg-sh`-qjhko-sieoq-hk-sjo-idd|hwo}fud-auds-hf-idahjhdbaq-ikhkr`huq-9712:2=+js`dWiqjbkgshk \hqs> —II G}hu| Doicq @o`mo}q Iwir f}h` S}icbsbhkq‐ mr @i}a Fbqjo}$ Nudr ==$ =<<7>jss|>((mdhg+wiqjbkgshk|hqs+ah`(}iwfbqjo}(=<<7(<7(`bcshwkXg}hu|XiiXg}hu|XdoicqX`+js`d Kowqwooe> I qs}uggdo bkqbco II$ mr Kbae Qu``o}q$ @ir 6sj$ =<<7>jss|>((www+sjocibdrmoiqs+ah`(kowqwooe(=<<7(<?(<6(i-qs}uggdo-bkqbco-ii+js`dAuds Jod| ikc bkfh}`isbhk dbm}i}r>jss|>((www+audsjod|+bkfh(bkcoz+|j|8h|sbhk0ah`Xahksoks&siqe0vbow&bc0326< Sjo |umdba comiso `hvoq hk f}h` sjo |}oqq bksh vi}bhuq I+I+ `o`mo}‒q womqbsoq ikc fh}u`q ikc khk-II }odisoc

womqbsoq$ bkaducbkg sjo |i}oks shccdo} womqbso `u`qkos+ah`+ - Sjo cbqiffoasoc I+I+ `o`mo}q |hqsbkg sjob} oz|o}bokaoq> jss|>((ikqwo}q+rijhh+ah`(yuoqsbhk(bkcoz8ybc0=<<2<:97<21<9:IIgs^1F  jss|>((www+h}ikgo-|i|o}q+h}g(h}ikgo-adikarXb+js`d jss|>((www+`hhk`ia+ah`(AudsXAiddocXII+js`djss|>((iiaudswisaj+ah+ue(Quqqoz+iq|zjss|>((www+|hqbsbvoisjobq`+h}g(}w(hfahu}qo+js`jss|>((`}q|hkqh}|iksq+sr|o|ic+ah`(`}Xq|hkqh}|iksq(=<<2(<?(`h}idbsr-bq-khs-}oahvo}r-auqsh`-bq-khs-s}icbsbhk+js`djss|>((qsbkebk-sjbkebk+ah`(wjr-b-dofs-ii-qsbkebk-sjbkebk-qsh}boq(jss|>((www+wjo}o`hqskoococ+h}g(=<<7(<?(iiXg}hu|Xiaauqo+js`djss|>((qsh|91qso|bkii+wh}c|}oqq+ah`(=<99(<?(<?(a}bsbaq-qir-wiqjbkgshk-ii-aji|so}-bq-audsdbeo-kowqwooe jss|>((www+`u`qkos+ah`(Side(i`XbXmobkgXuk}oiqhkimdo(2<112=-sh-ahkqbco}-ii-i-cikgo}huq-auds8`qgbc0=6<=211:!=6<=211: 

Sjo}o aik mo dbssdo chums$ sjo}o bq ovbcokao sjis aho}abvo q|hkqh}qjb| bq mobkgco|dhroc mr i `bkh}bsr hf g}hu|q bk I+I+ ikc sjbq bq mogbkkbkg gos I+I+ sjo }o|usisbhkhf mobkg i auds+ Sh ivhbc fu}sjo} dhqq hf |umdba ahkfbcokao bk I+I+ ikc bf vudko}imdo

 |oh|do i}o sh mo |}hsoasoc f}h` imuqo$ sjok wo kooc sh qoo `h}o ozi`|doq hf sjoQiksi @hkbai |}h I+I+ S}icbsbhk odco} qsisoq`ikqjb| hf 92?:+ *Ahkao|s BZ bk iasbhk"+--Bk sjbq `hco}k Wh}dc jhwovo}$ sh mo hf offoas sh `oos sjo |}oqoks cir koocq hf sjofoddhwqjb|$ sjbq koocq sh mo mhsj ah``ukbaisoc ikc h|o}isbkg sj}hugjhus sjo I+I+Wh}dc Qo}vbao Qs}uasu}o$ sh| sh mhssh`$ iq qhhk iq |hqqbmdo+

Sjo bkabcoksq wbsj Ajuae C+ ikc —Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐ qjhw sjis bk sjo |iqs$ audsg}hu|q bk II jivo mook qsh||oc mofh}o sjor ahudc ovok mogbk mr iasbvo bkso}voksbhkhf —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ ikc —odco} qsisoq`ok‐ u|jhdcbkg I+I+ S}icbsbhkq+ Sjor}oahgkbqoc sjo dbke moswook fbgu}ojoicq ikc —cogoko}isbhk bksh i auds+‐ *Niae Idozikco} i}sbado imhus II$ |igo =1" Bk hsjo} wh}cq$ sjo }bqo hf i —sr}ikkr hf vo}rq`idd `bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsj imqhduso |hwo}+‐ *Ahkao|s V"+ Sjoqo —s}uqsoc qo}viksqikc‐ —odco} qsisoq`ok‐ bk sjo 923<q ikc 92?: wo}o sjo}ofh}o ovbcoksdr —|}ucoksdrovo} hk gui}c igibkqs sr}ikkboq g}ois ikc q`idd+‐*Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr qbz"+ Sjoridqh adoi}dr ukco}qshhc sjo S}icbsbhkq sh mo |}bkab|doq u|hk wjbaj sjo qu}vbvid hf sjo

?

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 7/63

foddhwqjb| co|okcq$ }isjo} sjik —nuqs quggoqsbhkq+‐ Sjor ovbcoksdr ukco}qshhc bs sh mo

sjob} }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc cusr sh mo iasbvo gui}cbikq hf S}icbsbhkq mr bkfh}`bkg—S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}q sjis sjor i}o hus hf h}co}‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+ Sjorovbcoksdr ukco}qshhc sjob} cusr hf ai}o sh |}hsoas i vudko}imdo `bkh}bsr f}h` aho}abhkikc imuqo$ —Sjis ai}o wbdd mo hmqo}voc sh }oq|oas ikc |}hsoas idd `bkh}bsboq$‐ *Ahkao|s9=$ wi}}iksr 6"+ Sjor ovbcoksdr ukco}qshhc sjob} }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc iusjh}bsr iq—s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ sjis sjor wo}o s}uqsoc sh iasbvodr gui}c sjo |}bkab|doq hf IIS}icbsbhkq ikc iqqo}s sjob} doico}qjb| bk S}icbsbhk Swh$ sh |o}fh}` sjo —cusr hf doico}qjb|$ ovok wjok bk i q`idd `bkh}bsr$ sh sieo i qsikc igibkqs i qsh}`$‐ *Ahkao|sBZ"$ - Sjo u|jhdcbkg hf S}icbsbhk Swh$ hf wjbaj Mbdd W+ wiq diso} sh gh sh g}oisdokgsjq sh oz|dibk bk sjo Swodvo Ahkao|sq fh} Wh}dc Qo}vbao bk 926=>

—…Idd hf sjbq bq fuddr b`|dboc bk I+I+‒q S}icbsbhk Swh+ Jo}o wo qoo sjo ‚g}hu| ahkqabokao‒ iq sjo udsb`isoiusjh}bsr ikc sjo ‚s}uqsoc qo}viks‒ iq sjo codogisoc iusjh}bsr+ Hko aikkhs fukasbhk wbsjhus sjo hsjo}‐ *Ahkao|s Z"—Jokao sjo |}bkab|do hf i`|dr codogisoc iusjh}bsr ikc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh ‚s}uqsoc qo}viksq‒ `uqs mo b`|dbabs f}h` sjosh| sh sjo mhssh` hf hu} iasbvo qs}uasu}o hf qo}vbao+ Sjbq bq sjo adoi} b`|dbaisbhk hf I+I+‒q S}icbsbhk Swh‐*Ahkao|s BB" —S}uqsoc qo}viksq is idd I+I+ dovodq i}o oz|oasoc sh ozo}abqo doico}qjb|$ ikc doico}qjb| bq khs qb`|dr i`isso} hf qum`bqqbvo jhuqoeoo|bkg‐ *Ahkao|s VBB" —Doico}qjb| bq hfsok aiddoc u|hk sh fiao joivr ikc qh`osb`oqdhkg-ahksbkuoc a}bsbabq`‐ *Ahkao|s BZ" —Idd i}hukc uq bk sjo wh}dc shcir wo i}o wbskoqqbkg sjo sr}ikkr hf `inh}bsboq ikc sjo ovok wh}qo sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd `bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsj imqhduso |hwo}‐ *Ahkao|s V" —sjisai}o wbdd mo hmqo}voc sh }oq|oas ikc |}hsoas idd `bkh}bsboq… …Sjis hu} Ahkfo}okao qjidd ovo} mo |}ucoksdr hkgui}c igibkqs sr}ikkboq$ g}ois ikc q`idd$ wjosjo} sjoqo mo fhukc bk sjo `inh}bsr h} bk sjo `bkh}bsr‐ *Ahkao|s ZBB>Wi}}iksr 6"+ —Foodbkg sjo wobgjs hf idd sjoqo fh}aoq$ ao}sibk `o`mo}q wjh }uk ahukso} sh I+I+‒q S}icbsbhkqqh`osb`oq qir sjis sjor i}o mobkg aokqh}oc h} |ukbqjoc ikc sjis sjor i}o sjo}ofh}o mobkg ghvo}koc+ Bs whudci||oi} jhwovo}$ sjis I+I+‒q }bgjs sh hmnoas aid`dr ikc |}bvisodr sh q|oabfba vbhdisbhkq bq is doiqs oyuid sh sjo }bgjsqhf sjo vbhdish}q sh vbhdiso+ Sjbq aikkhs iaau}isodr mo aiddoc i ghvo}k`oksid iasbhk‐ *Ahkao|s ZBB$ wi}}iksr ?"+

Bk ahks}iqs sh sjo doico}qjb| coqa}bmoc imhvo$ }oaoks jbqsh}r }ovoidq sjo i||i}oks diae hf bs$ |o}ji|q i =<-1< roi} s}okc shwi}c dbmo}sr imhvo sjis hf hu} ah``hk wodfi}o$doicbkg sh i —sr}ikkr hf i|isjosba$ qodf-qooebkg$ ukbkfh}`oc$…++`inh}bsboq‐ *ahkao|sV"$ sjbq bk su}k$ jiq doc sh sjo |}oqokao hf fbgu}ojoicq$ ikc sjo `hsbvisbhk fh} ik—ovok wh}qo sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd `bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsj imqhduso |hwo}‐ *ahkao|sV"$ ikc bk qh`o g}hu|q$ i —cogoko}isbhk bksh i auds‐ *Niae Idozikco} i}sbado imhusII$ |igo =1"+ Sjbq jiq }oqudsoc bk imuqo hf sjo vudko}imdo ikc mic |}oqq fh} II$ iq}o|h}soc bk sjo Bkco|okcoks *_E" ikc bk sjo Wiqjbkgshk \hqs *_QI"+

Sjo cbffo}okao moswook ghhc qo}vbao doico}qjb| ikc kh doico}qjb| is idd bk sjo fiao hf 

}bqbkg cbasish}q$ q|oddq sjo cbffo}okao moswook fusu}o I+I+ ukbsr ikc iki}ajr+ Bf I+I+ahksbkuoq sjo au}}oks s}okc bk iushkh`huq g}hu|q$ —|o}qhkidbsr mofh}o |}bkab|do‐q|oieo} }oah}cbkgq$ doasu}oq$ gubcoq ikc s}bkeos muqbkoqq$ sjok sjbq `ir ovoksuiddrdoic sh i qrqso`ba fibdbkg hf sjo —mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr‐ bk S}icbsbhk Swh+ Sjooz|o}bokao hf sjo cbqbksog}isbhk hf sjo Wiqjbkgshkbik `hvo`oks *Dikguigo hf sjoJoi}s |igo ?5 S}icbsbhk 9<$ Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 9:<-9:1"

 |}ocbasq sjo fusu}o> jss|>((ok+wbeb|ocbi+h}g(wbeb(WiqjbkgshkbikX`hvo`oks

6

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 8/63

Bf$ hk sjo hsjo} jikc$ I+I+ h|sq fh} I+I+ S}icbsbhk$ —Oiaj g}hu| qjhudc mo

iushkh`huq ozao|s bk `isso}q iffoasbkg hsjo} g}hu|q h} II iq i wjhdo‐$ sjok sjoozao|sbhk sh g}hu| iushkh`r bk S}icbsbhk 3 b`|dboq sjis —odco} qsisoq`ok‐ ikc —GhhcQo}vbao Doico}q‐ *ahkao|s BZ" wbdd fiao sjob} }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh bkso}voko wjokkoaoqqi}r+ Iq Qrkikhk auds doico} Ajuae C }oaiddoc 92?:> —Sjor `ico sjbkgqcbffbauds fh} uq… +++ ikc wo kovo} woks miae sh I+I+ igibk+‐ Ikc iq Mbdd W+ }oaiddocjbq okahukso} wbsj —Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐> —Wo iqqu}oc hu} wodd-`oikbkg f}bokc sjiswo whudc ao}sibkdr u|jhdc jbq }bgjs sh f}oo q|ooaj+ Mus wo iccoc sjis jo hugjs shu|jhdc hu}q$ shh+ Wo iqqu}oc jb` sjis bf jbq —doasu}oq‐ woks hk ib}$ wo whudc icvbqoovo}r I+I+ g}hu| hf sjo ab}au`qsikaoq ikc iqe sjo` sh w}bso qs}hkg dosso}q… +++ …dosso}q hf i ebkc sjo q|hkqh} `bgjs khs dbeo sh }oaobvo+‐ *I+I+ ah`oq hf Igo |igo 919"

I+I+ bq coidbkg wbsj i kow |jokh`okhk$ fh} wjbaj `hqs i}o uk|}o|i}oc+ Bs |}oqoksqik ozs}o`odr ah`|doz comiso ikc bs bq i shzba ahaesibd hf sjo fhddhwbkg bkg}ocboksq>Gdhmid bkso}kos ah``ukbaisbhk5 sjo husqbco bkfduokao hf i vo}r ki}}hw `bkcoc$cbqjhkoqs$ fukci`oksidbqs Aj}bqsbik }okco}bkg hf I+I+‒q |}hg}i` ikc jbqsh}r5 igoko}isbhk hf —odco} qsisoq`ok‐ wjh jivo kh oz|o}bokao hf coidbkg wbsj i qo}bhuq

 |}hmdo` bk I+I5 wjh idqh diae ekhwdocgo hf I+I+ jbqsh}r ikc sjo imbdbsr sh i||drS}icbsbhkq ikc Ahkao|sq5 ikc sjo `inh}bsr hf wjh` i||oi} sh qoo kh sj}ois bk |diabkgdbmo}sr imhvo sjis hf hu} ah``hk wodfi}o+

Sjbq ahaesibd jiq |}hcuaoc khs qh `uaj auds g}hu|q$ mus i ahddoasbhk hf auds g}hu|q hf vi}bhuq coqa}b|sbhkq$ wjbaj shgosjo} i`huks sh i koh-Hzfh}c G}hu| fukcb`oksidbqs`hvo`oks+ Sjoqo g}hu|q jivo bkso}kisbhkid ahkkoasbhkq wbsj fbgu}ojoicq iq doico}q>Nhrq hf ]oahvo}r$ *Cos}hbs _QI ‑ Dhkchk _E$ Civbc A+"$ \}b`i}r \u}|hqo g}hu| hf II *Ciddiq"$ *gdhmid iffbdbisbhk$ Adbff M+ @ro}q ]+$ Aj}bq ]+"$ Miae sh Miqbaq$ *Gdhmidiffbdbisbhk$ Widdr \+"$ ]hic sh ]oahvo}r$ \dr`husj _E- \iabfba G}hu| _QI *Wirko\- Adikar B"+

Sjo kow crki`baq sh II |}oqoksoc mr husqbco |umdbqjoc dbso}isu}o ikc gdhmid bkso}kosah``ukbaisbhk `ir jivo oz|hqoc i woiekoqq bk hu} qo}vbao qs}uasu}o sh wjbaj IIjiq ros sh ici|s+ Sjo q|ooc ikc }oiaj hf odoas}hkba ah``ukbaisbhk shcir `oikq sjissjo mojivbhu} hf hko bkcbvbcuid II g}hu|$ h} i `bkh}bsr$ aik khw jivo ik okh}`huq

kogisbvo ikc |o}`ikoks b`|ias hk sjo wjhdo I+I+ |umdba }odisbhkq+ @h}o hvo}$ sjbqq|ooc ikc }oiaj hf ah``ukbaisbhk aik gbvo |hwo} c}bvbkg fbgu}ojoicq i |disfh}` shbkfduokao II$ khs hkdr bk sjob} hwk dhaidbsr$ mus bkso}kisbhkiddr+ Wbsj sjo }oiaj ikc

 |o}`ikokao hf wh}dcwbco wom$ bs bq yuoqsbhkimdo wjosjo} sjo }oqudsiks ci`igo shI+I+ |umdba }odisbhkq ikc dhqq hf |umdba ahkfbcokao aiuqoc mr sjoqo g}hu|q bqquqsibkimdo fh} sjo foddhwqjb| iq i wjhdo$ bf sjbq bq |o}`bssoc sh ahksbkuo+

7

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 9/63

Fh} ozi`|do$ Sjo Nhrq hf ]oahvo}r g}hu| *Cos}hbs ‑ Dhkchk$ Civbc A+">

Ozs}iasq f}h` sjo —Mbg Mhhe ]oahvo}r‐ womqbso jhqsoc mr i Civbc A>

—Ahukqoddh}q$ \qrajbis}bqsq jss|>((mbgmhhe}oahvo}r+ah`(khwXsjis+js`d!qhdbcXidahjhdSjo goko}id i||}hiaj fh} sjo `inh}bsr hf aiqoq bq fh} uq sh cbqahksbkuo qoobkg |qrajbis}bqsq ikc ahukqodh}q UqbaP bf rhu i}o qoobkg sjo` fh} s}ois`oks hf sjo qr`|sh`q hf idahjhdbq` og UqbaP idahjhdba co|}oqqbhk… … Idqh sjo}o i}odbeodr sh mo ahks}icbasbhkq moswook sjo swh ahu}qoq hf s}ois`oks+ Wo ajhqo moswook sjo swh+ Bf wo ajhqo sh ch sjoII |}hg}i``o$ wo qsh||oc qoobkg sjo ahukqoddh}(|qrajbis}bqs uksbd wo jic chko sjo fb}qs kbko qso|q+++++++‐—Idahjhd Bk Qhdbc Fh}` jss|>((mbgmhhe}oahvo}r+ah`(khwXsjis+js`d!qhdbcXidahjhd ++++++++\}oqa}bmoc `hhc-idso}bkg c}ugq8 C}ugq sjis i}o `hhc idso}bkg *og UqbaP iksbco|}oqqiksq" i}o hfsok |}oqa}bmocfh} sjo qr`|sh`q hf sjo idahjhdbq`+ Sjbq bq s}uo ovok wjok idahjhdbq` bq khs ki`oc mr sjo chash} iq sjo ahkcbsbhkfh} wjbaj jo h} qjo bq |}oqa}bmbkg sjo c}ugq5 fh} ozi`|do$ `ikr hf uq i}o cbigkhqoc iq jivbkg i vi}bosr cbffo}oksqh}sq hf |qrajhqoq ikc sr|oq hf co|}oqqbhk$ wjbaj su}k hus sh mo sjo qr`|sh`q hf idahjhdbq` … +++ Bf sjor i}o |}oqa}bmoc fh} sjo qr`|sh`q hf idahjhdbq`$ sjok sjor i}o sh mo ahkqbco}oc iq idahjhd bk qhdbc fh}`> wo `uqs mowbddbkg sh ah`o hff sjoqo ‚ajo`baid `hhc-ajikgo}q‒ … …Wo iqe sjo chash}> ‚Whudc bs mo id}bgjs bf B ai`o hff sjoc}ugq bf B gh sh dhsq hf II `oosbkgq8‒… … +++ Bs bq vo}r b`|h}siks sjis bf sjo |}hg}i``o bq sh mo i qumqsbsuso fh} sjoqo c}ugq sjok wo }oiddr `uqs fhddhw idd sjo quggoqsbhkq hf sjo |}hg}i``o+‐—Qozuid ahkcuas jss|>((mbgmhhe}oahvo}r+ah`(qso|Xfhu}+js`d!jhwXsh ++++++++Diso} hk$ iq |i}s hf Qso| ?$ wo gbvo ik iaahuks hf hu} qoa}os sjhugjsq sh hu} q|hkqh}q+ @ikr }ovoidoc sjbkgq shhu} q|hkqh}q sjis wo jic kovo} shdc ikrhko mofh}o+ *Sjbq bq i||dbaimdo idqh sh idd hu} ci}eoqs sjhugjsq$ khs nuqssjhqo hf i qozuid kisu}o‐"—S}uqs Hu} Q|hkqh}q jss|>((mbgmhhe}oahvo}r+ah`(khwXsjis+js`d!qhdbcXidahjhdQh bs wbdd mo vo}r cbffbauds fh} uq sh s}uqs bk sjo |}hg}i``o ikc sjo Jbgjo} \hwo} ukdoqq wo aik s}uqs hu} q|hkqh}qfb}qs+++‐—Mus B‒` chbkg sjo \}hg}i``o ikc B‒` qsbdd foodbkg chwkjss|>((mbgmhhe}oahvo}r+ah`(qso|Xswodvo+js`d!iddXiffib}qBf rhu sjbke rhu‒}o chbkg sjo |}hg}i``o ikc khs foodbkg ghhc$ sjok wo jivo ghhc kowq fh} rhu+ Sjo}o bq ovo}rajikao sjis rhu‒}o w}hkg – rhu‒}o khs chbkg sjo |}hg}i``o+ Sjo ikqwo} bq sh fbkc hus wjis bs bq rhu i}o chbkg

sjis rhu qjhudck‒s5 h} wjis bs bq rhu i}o khs chbkg sjis rhu qjhudc+‐

Vbasb`q hf sjo imuqbvo q|hkqh}qjb| bk Dhkchk ikc Cos}hbs qji}o sjob} oz|o}bokao wbsjoiaj hsjo} hk ik bkso}kos fh}u`>

—B wiq }ofdoasbkg hk wjok B fb}qs wiq }oa}ubsoc bk sh nhrq ikc B wiq sjbkebkg imhus jhw ukah`fh}simdo B fods+…………+B }o`o`mo} a}rbkg sh `r q|hkqh} imhus sjo |ibk B wiq jivbkg ikc oz|dibk sh jo} sjis B kovo} fods `r mhcr f}oie hus qh `uaj khs ovok wjok B wiq bk sh |i}srbkg ikc siebkg c}ugq iq B cbc wjok B ai`o bk sh nhrq ikcqjo wiq nuqs qsi}sbkg sh rodd is `o+ B }o`o`mo} sjo fb}qs sb`o qjo }oiddr qa}oi`oc is `o wjok B aiddoc sh ajoae bk Bwiq bk `r qsikcbkg bk `r ebsajok ikc B nuqs }oaoksdr cu`|oc `r oz mhrf}bokc ikc jo nuqs `hvoc hus B fods B wiq`hvbkg fh}wi}c bk `r dbfo hk sh i joidsjr ikc jbgjo} }hic ikc sjok `r q|hkqh} qa}oi`oc is `o ikc B nuqs fods dbeosjbq mojivbh} UqbaP foodq wir `h}o ukjoidsjr sjok sjo wjis sjo mhrf}bokc B nuqs cu`|oc cbc+ B fods dbeo qjo wiq nuqswibsbkg fh} jb` sh doivo qh B whudc mo idhko ikc qjo ahudc rodd is `o ikc qsi}s sjo imuqbvo ikc ahks}hd arado+ B

qsucboc sjo arado hf imuqo wjood bk jbgj-qajhhd ikc B sjbke sjis coqa}bmoq |o}foasdr `r }odisbhkqjb| wbsj `r nhrqq|hkqh} sjo}o wo}o cofbkimdr jhkor`hhk |o}bhcq ikc sokqbhk mubdcbkg |o}bhcq ikc sjok sjo so}}bmdo iasbkg hus |jiqo+ B }o`o`mo} B idwirq fods ozs}o`odr ukah`fh}simdo i}s UqbaP sjo 3 nhrq `oosbkgq B issokcoc wooedr+ Mobkg hksjo husqbco khw B aik qoo sjis i dhs hf sjo sjbkgq sjis B qs}uggdoc wbsj quaj iq |ikba issiaeq wo}o cuo sh mobkg bk nhrq B chk‒s jivo sjhqo ikr`h}o+ B jivo idqh }oidb~oc wjr B wiq iss}iasoc qh `uaj sh nhrq ikc sjis bs cbc `oos`ikr hf `r uk`os koocq quaj iq modhkgbkg f}bokcqjb| ai}bkg bkvhdvo`oks ikc `ikr `ikr UqbaP `h}o+ Khw sjis Bi` hus hf sjo g}hu| B jivo sh wh}e ji}co} sh s}r ikc `oos sjoqo koocq ikc wjok B chk‒s B fbkc `rqodf `bqqbkg nhrq+‐ *iiaudswisaj fh}u`5 qumnoas oksbsdoc —Gus foodbkgq‐"

  :

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 10/63

—Ikhsjo} g}icuid ajikgo bk sjob} auds okvb}hk`oks bkvhdvoc sjo |o}qbqsoks |uqj fh} i g}oiso} ah``bs`oks+ Bsidwirq jic sh mo `h}o$ ikc qhhk sjo `o`mo}q fods hvo}wjod`oc ikc whkco}oc bf sjor ahudc ovo} `ieo bs+ Ahudc

sjor ovo} mo |u}o okhugj8 Ahudc sjor ovo} }oiaj okdbgjsok`oks8 Sjob} doico}q wo}o sjo hkdr |}hhf sjis sjoqoqsikci}cq wo}o iajbovimdo+ Fh} `o bk nhrq wiq wbdd B ovo} gos chko wbsj 2 ikc wjok B gos chko wbsj qso| 2 B wbdd moji||r+ B jivo qokao UqbaP doi}koc sjis mobkg chko wbsj kbko bq }oiddr imhus iaao|sbkg sjo auds modbfo UqbaP qrqso` ikc |iqqbkg bs hk+ B fods ovok `h}o bkko} sh}`oks wjok B wiq chko 2 sjok B cbc mofh}+UqbaP Sjor a}oisoc sjbq fidqob`|}oqqbhk sjis hkao B ghs chko qso| 2 dbfo whudc mo g}ikc wjbaj wiq yubso sjo h||bqos$UqbaP mus bs cbc i||o} UqbaPsjis wir hk sjo husqbco+ Auds doico}q uqoc vi}bhuq soajkbyuoq sh sbgjsok sjob} jhdc hk sjo g}hu|+ Hko hf sjo `h}ooffoasbvo wiq qai|oghisbkg UqbaP+ Hko `o`mo} whudc mo |umdbadr ju`bdbisoc bk f}hks hf sjo g}hu|+ Sjbq a}oisocc}oic i`hkg sjo audsbqsq moaiuqo sjor kovo} ekow wjok bs whudc mo sjob} su}k ikc kovo} wiksoc sh mo uqoc iq ikogisbvo ozi`|do B jivo mook sjo qai|oghis is nhrq sjor soi} rhu u| bk sjo}o qji}oq+ B jivo idqh |diroc sjo }hdo hf soi}bkg hsjo}q u| bk sjo}o qji}oq ikc s}rbkg sh |uqj sjo` bk i }odi|qo wjok sjor whudck‒s iaao|s sjo g}hu|‐+*iiaudswisaj fh}u`5 qumnoas oksbsdoc —Odbso adum‐" jss|>((fh}u`q+cod|jbfh}u`q+ah`(iiaudswisaj(`oqqigoq(8qsi}s0Qsi}s%]oicbkg%/1O/1O

I+I+ G}i|ovbko i}sbadoq mr |}hfoqqbhkid idahjhdbq` ahukabddh}q>

I \doi fh} Khk-bkso}fo}okao *II G}i|ovbko @ir 922<$ Vhd+36 kh+9="+B jivo i jbgj }ogi}c ikc }oq|oas fh} II'q Swodvo Qso| |}hg}i` ikc jivo wbskoqqoc ahuksdoqq quaaoqq qsh}boq…++B i` idqh iwi}o hf ukkoaoqqi}r ju`ik |ibk ikc quffo}bkg i`hkg }oahvo}bkg `o`mo}q…… Hfsok B jivo joi}c II`o`mo}q wjh sjbke sjor ekhw moqs fh} idd idahjhdbaq ikc |o}aobvo sjis bf rhu nuqs ‚wh}e sjo |}hg}i`‒ ovo}rsjbkgwbdd mo fbko+ Sjis bq khs idwirq sjo aiqo+ Sjo}o i}o `o`mo}q bk rhu} |}hg}i` wjh jivo oz|o}bokaoc s}iu`isba$ dbfo-sj}oisokbkg ovoksq ikc wjh kooc |}hfoqqbhkid jod| ikc$ qh`osb`oq$ `ocbaisbhk……… Hk qovo}id haaiqbhkq B jivojic adboksq wjh wo}o ozs}o`odr qubabcid ikc jic qhugjs |}hfoqqbhkid jod|+ ]oaoksdr$ swh adboksq sj}oisokoc qubabco$ikc moaiuqo II `o`mo}q sjhugjs sjor ekow `h}o sjik sjo `ocbaid ikc |qrajhdhgbaid |}hfoqqbhkq$ sjo bkcbvbcuidqid`hqs cboc… …ros II `o`mo}q qso||oc bk ikc ahkvbkaoc `r adboksq sh cbqahksbkuo uqo hf sjo `ocbaisbhk+……… @o`mo}q hfsok icvbqo vudko}imdo$ o`hsbhkiddr ahkfuqoc |oh|do khs sh qooe `ocbaid ikc `oksid joidsjiqqbqsikao$ ikc sh sieo kh c}ugq………++Sjo swh qubabcid bkcbvbcuidq hf wjh` B q|oie jic mook qozuiddr imuqoc iqajbdc}ok mr sj}oo h} `h}o `o`mo}q hf sjob} fi`bdboq ikc jic oz|o}bokaoc hsjo} imuqoq iq wodd+ Mhsj wo}oo`hsbhkiddr ikc |qrajhdhgbaiddr f}igbdo………++B quggoqs sjis oiaj II `o`mo} }oic bk sjo Mbg Mhhe wjo}o bs

icc}oqqoq sjo bqquoq hf hmsibkbkg husqbco |}hfoqqbhkid jod| wjok bs bq koaoqqi}r…++++++ B ch khs dbeo sh mo |diaoc bki |hqbsbhk wjo}o |oh|do wiks sh cbo ikc bs'q u| sh `o sh s}r ikc |}hsoas sjo` f}h` qodf-ji}`+ B i` sjo |o}qhk bk sjos}okajoq$ |iqqbhkisodr cocbaisoc sh qivbkg dbvoq ikc jod|bkg idd |oh|do }oahvo} khs hkdr f}h` idahjhdbq` mus hsjo} dbfo sj}oisokbkg |}hmdo`q+ \doiqo qsh| soddbkg hsjo} }oahvo}bkg II `o`mo}q khs sh ahkquds |jrqbabikq ikc |qrajhsjo}i|bqsq+ \doiqo qsh| soddbkg `o`mo}q sjis sjor i}o ‚m}oiebkg qhm}bosr‒ mr siebkg koococ `ocbaisbhk+\doiqo qsh| okimdbkg `o`mo}q sh isso`|s qubabco+ *Ozs}iasq hf ik i}sbado mr \…M…$ idahjhdbq` ahukabddh}$Ahdh}ich"

—Coi} G}i|ovbko$ \dirbkg Chash}‐ *II g}i|ovbko Nikui}r =<9<"—Iq i |qrajhdhgbqs bk iccbasbhkq$ wbsj =1 roi}q hf }oahvo}r bk II$ B whudc dbeo sh oz|}oqq ahkao}k imhus sjo dosso} sbsdoc ‚@bqcbigkhqbq‒ *Coi} G}i|ovbko$ Qo|so`mo} =<<2"+ Wjbdo bs bq s}uo sjis `ikr |oh|do bk `oksid joidsj jivobkicoyuiso iccbasbhkq s}ibkbkg$ bs bq idqh s}uo sjis `ikr |oh|do wbsj iccbasbhkq jivo hsjo} `oksid joidsj bqquoq+ Bjivo khs qook sjo qbgk$ ‚B jivo hko cbqoiqo--idahjhdbq`--ikc bf B sieo ai}o hf sjis hko cbqoiqo$ ovo}rsjbkg wbdd moheir$‒ is ikr `oosbkg$ kh} bq sjbq qoksb`oks }ofdoasoc bk ikr II dbso}isu}o+ @ikr |oh|do jivo ah-haau}}bkg

qumqsikao(idahjhd ikc |qrajbis}ba cbqh}co}q sjis bkso}ias wbsj oiaj hsjo}+ _ks}oisoc mb|hdi} cbqh}co} bq khsahkcuabvo sh hkghbkg qhm}bosr$ fh} ozi`|do+ Kobsjo} bq iasbvo |qrajhqbq+ Sjo dbqs ghoq hk+ C}+ Mhm ikc Mbdd W+o`|jiqb~oc }oq|oas ikc ahh|o}isbhk wbsj sjo `oksid joidsj |}hfoqqbhkid ah``ukbsr+Wo o`|jiqb~o khs |dirbkg Ghc bk II5 dos'q }o`o`mo} khs sh |dir chash}$ shh+ Ikhkr`huq‐

2

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 11/63

Sjo icvbao gbvok bk Civbc A‒q Mbg Mhhe ]oahvo}r womqbso hk |}hfoqqbhkidahukqoddh}q$ `ocbaisbhk ikc qso| ? i}o i cb}oas ahks}icbasbhk wbsj sjo IdahjhdbaqIkhkr`huq —Mbg Mhhe‐ ikc sjo —Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq‐>

—Sjhqo hf uq modhkgbkg sh i }odbgbhuq cokh`bkisbhk wjbaj }oyub}oq ahkfoqqbhk `uqs$ ikc hf ahu}qo wbdd wiks sh ghsh sjo |}h|o}dr i||hbksoc iusjh}bsr$ wjhqo cusr bs bq sh }oaobvo bs… … Bf wo aikkhs h} whudc }isjo} khs ch sjbq$ woqoi}aj fh} hu} iayuibksikao wbsj i adhqoc ‑ `husjoc$ ukco}qsikcbkg f}bokc+ \o}ji|q hu} chash} h} |qrajhdhgbqs wbdd mo sjo f}bokc+ Bs `ir mo hko hf hu} hwk fi`bdr$ mus wo aikkhs cbqadhqo ikrsjbkg sh hu} wbvoq h} |i}oksq wjbaj wbddju}s sjo` h} `ieo sjo` ukji||r+‐ *Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq$ —Mbg Mhhe‐ |igo 73$"—Sjbq |o}qhk `ir mo hko‒q q|hkqh}$ mus khs koaoqqi}bdr qh… … \o}ji|q$ sjhugj$ rhu} }odisbhkqjb| sh jb` bq quajsjis rhu whudc ai}o sh }ovoid hkdr i |i}s hf rhu} qsh}r+ Bf sjbq bq sjo qbsuisbhk$ mr idd `oikq ch qh… … Bs `ir su}khus$ jhwovo}$ sjis rhu‒dd ajhhqo qh`ohko odqo fh} sjo `h}o cbffbauds ikc coo|o} }ovodisbhkq+ Sjbq bkcbvbcuid `ir mo oksb}odr husqbco hf I+I+ ‑ fh} ozi`|do$ rhu} ado}gr`ik h} rhu} chash}+ Fh} qh`o hf uq$ i ah`|doso qs}ikgo} `ir |}hvo sjo moqs mos+‐ *Sjo Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq$ |igo 6="

—Ik I+I+ q|hkqh} choq khs hffo} qo}vbaoq quaj iq sjhqo |}hvbcoc mr ahukqoddh}q$ sjo dogid$ `ocbaid h} qhabid wh}e ah``ukbsboq$ mus `ir qh`osb`oq jod| sjo kowah`o} sh iaaoqq |}hfoqqbhkid jod| bf iqqbqsikao husqbco sjo qah|o hf 

I+I+ bq koococ+ *Yuoqsbhkq ikc ikqwo}q hk q|hkqh}qjb|$ |igo 93" jss|>((www+ii+h}g(|cf(|}hcuasq(|-9?XY&IhkQ|hk+|cf —I+I+ Choq khs…+qhdbabs `o`mo}q…+fhddhw u| h} s}r sh ahks}hd bsq `o`mo}q…+ `ieo `ocbaid h} |qrajhdhgbaidcbigkhqoq h} |}hgkhqoq… … |}hvbco … … ikr `ocbaid h} |qrajbis}ba s}ois`oks5 hffo} }odbgbhuq qo}vbaoq5 okgigobk ocuaisbhk imhus idahjhd… … h} ikr hsjo} wodfi}o h} qhabid qo}vbaoq5 |}hvbco ch`oqsba h} vhaisbhkidahukqoddbkg…‐ *@o`mo}q hf sjo ado}gr iqe imhus Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq |igo 9:"jss|>((www+ii+h}g(|cf(|}hcuasq(|-=?X`o`mo}qhfsjoado}griqeimhusii+|cf 

—Bf wo }oahgkbqo }odbgbhk bq sjo |}hvbkao hf sjo ado}gr ikc sjo |}iasbao hf `ocbabko bq fh} chash}q$ sjok wo aik woaik jod|fuddr ahh|o}iso wbsj mhsj‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"

Bs bq i qic cir bkcooc$ wjok vbasb`q hf imuqo bk I+I+ qooe qu||h}s odqowjo}o5 wjoksjo qifogui}cq ikc |}haocu}oq id}oicr ivibdimdo i}o khs mobkg uqoc5 wjok |}hfoqqbhkid

idahjhdbq` ahukqoddh}q w}bso sh sjo I+I+ G}i|ovbko$ iqebkg I+I+ sh }oic bsq hwkdbso}isu}o+

Bs bq i qic cir wjok i Cbqs}bas Ah``bssoo @o`mo} *C+A+@+" bk sjo _QI$ choq khsi||oi} sh mo imdo sh fbkc b`|h}siks bkfh}`isbhk f}h` wbsjbk sjo I+I+ Qo}vbaoqs}uasu}o5 mus bkqsoic$ sjo ahkao}koc I+I+ `o`mo} foodq sjo kooc sh qhu}ao bs f}h` ikhk II _E bkso}kos fh}u`>

—Bk sjbq _QI i}oi$ imhus = 9(= roi}q igh bk =<<:$ i Roddhw ahvo} mhhe - Miae sh Miqbaq mr Widdr \+$ mogik sh mo |iqqoc i}hukc5 qhhk `ikr wo}o murbkg bs ikc qh`o `idahksoksoc UqbaP |oh|do f}h` i fow II g}hu|q mogik shgisjo} sh cbqauqq sjo mhhe+ Sjor wo}o goko}iddr husq|heok ikc khs }oabovoc UqbaP wodd mr II g}hu|q ikc sjoqs}hkg h||hqbsbhk qoo`oc sh mhkc sjo idahksoksq sh oiaj hsjo}+ Sjor jic i fbzoc bcoi hf jhw sjo 9= qso|q qjhudc

 mo chko$ ik hus hf midikao vbow hf II jbqsh}r ikc qsisbqsbaq+ Dbeo adib`bkg sjis II hkao jic 7?/ quaaoqq }iso5ikc fusjo} UqbaP adib`oc II dhqs sjis quaoqq UqbaP }iso wjok II moai`o h}gikb~oc)Sjo `hvo`oks jiq g}hwk `h}o iasbvo ikc khw qoocq `oosbkgq ikc cbqauqqbhk }hh`q wbsj bkcbvbcuidq wjh |uqjsjob} vbowq+ Khw$ sjo}o qoo`q sh mo ik h}gikb~oc offh}s fh} 6 sh 9< Miae sh Miqbaq |oh|do sh `oos mofh}o i si}gos`oosbkg - sjor q|dbs u| i fow q`idd g}hu|q - gh sh vi}bhuq simdoq h} oiaj @oosbkg ]hh` ikc qsoo} cbqauqqbhkq bkshbqquoq wjbaj gbvo sjo` i fh}`is sh |}oqoks jidf s}usjq ikc sjbo} UqbaP q|}bsuidbsr UqbaP adib`q+@ikr hf uq }ogudi} II |oh|do i}o ahkao}koc+ Bs qoo`q sh `o sjis rhu} oz|o}bokaoq i}o qb`bdi} ikc `ir mo}o|oisoc jo}o bk sjbq _QI i}oi+ B fhukc rhu} Audswisaj qbso hk sjo Mbkg qoi}aj okgbko+ Sjo bkfh}`isbhk bqviduimdo ikc i||}oabisoc mr `o ikc B jivo |iqqoc sjo wom icc}oqq hk sh i CA@ f}bokc‐+ *iiaudswisaj fh}u`5qumnoas oksbsdoc —Miae sh Miqbaq `hvo`oks‐" jss|>((fh}u`q+cod|jbfh}u`q+ah`(iiaudswisaj(`oqqigoq(8qsi}s0Qsi}s%]oicbkg%/1O/1O 

9<

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 12/63

Sjo}o koocq sh mo mosso} ah``ukbaisbhk wbsjbk sjo foddhwqjb|+

Sjbq bq i qsiso`oks is sjo mhssh` hf sjo |igo hk Widdr \‒q Miae sh Miqbaq womqbso>

—Ifso} }oaobvbkg khsbfbaisbhk f}h` sjo Goko}id Qo}vbao Hffbao imhus hu} `bqqbhk qsiso`oks$ sjo Mhi}c hf Cb}oash}q hf sjo Miae sh Miqbaq Fhukcisbhk `os bk i q|oabid qoqqbhk ikc vhsoc sh ajikgo sjo wh}cbkg hf sjo qsiso`oks qh bs whudcmo bk ah`|dbikao wbsj sjo Swodvo S}icbsbhkq hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+ Sjo Mhi}c idqh vhsoc sh `hvo idd `iso}bidq |o}sibkbkg sh hsjo} Swodvo Qso| |}hg}i`q sh qo|i}iso wom qbsoq$ qh sjo}owhudc mo kh ahkfuqbhk imhus sjo |}b`i}r |u}|hqo hf sjo Miae sh Miqbaq Fhukcisbhk+ Wo iqe fh} rhu} |isbokao bk sjbq `isso} moaiuqo$ is sjo |}oqoks sb`o$ wo jivo kh `oikq sh iaah`|dbqj sjbqhmnoasbvo+ Wo jivo kh |ibc o`|dhrooq$ ikc ahksbkuo sh h|o}iso wbsj i kogisbvo aiqj fdhw+ Bf bs bq Ghc‒q wbdd$ sjo}owbdd mo quffbaboks bkcbvbcuid chkisbhkq sh `ieo sjo wbqjoq hf sjo Mhi}c hf Cb}oash}q i }oidbsr+ Sjo Miae sh Miqbaq Fhukcisbhk bq i ?<9 *A" 1$ khs-fh}-|}hfbs Ah}|h}isbhk cocbaisoc sh qivbkg sjo dbvoq hf idahjhdbaq+

Hu} `hcbfboc `bqqbhk qsiso`oks bq dbqsoc modhw‐ jss|>((www+iimiaeshmiqbaq+h}g(

\o}ji|q sjo I+I+W+Q+ S}uqsooq hugjs sh sieo khso hf Mbdd W‒q doico}qjb| wjok |iqqbvo koghsbisbhkq fibd wbsj —Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐ su}koc —idi}`bkg |hqo}‐ *I+I+Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 91< -919"$ quaj iq sjor jivo wbsj Widdr \5 ikc wjok koaoqqi}r$sh aidd hk qu||h}s f}h` sjo I+I+ g}hu|q+ Bf Widdr \ qirq jbq fhukcisbhk —is sjo |}oqokssb`o jiq kh `oikq sh iaah`|dbqj sjbq hmnoasbvo$‐ sjok |o}ji|q jo koocq qh`oiqqbqsikao+ Wo i}o qu}o qh`o swh `bddbhk I+I+q wh}dcwbco whudc mo hkdr shh wbddbkgsh jod| mhsj ikhsjo} idahjhdba ikc sjo S}uqsooq iq wodd+—Qs}hkg dosso}q … … … dosso}q hf i ebkc sjo q|hkqh} `bgjs khs dbeo sh }oaobvo‐ iq MbddW+ |us bs$ bq i |hwo}fud cbqquiqbvo shhd fh} ikr S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}+ Ikc iq Mbdd W+

}oahgkbqoc$ sjo —}bgjs hf |osbsbhk‐ bq }oahgkbqoc bk ikr co`ha}isba qhabosr+ Bs ausq mhsjwirq+

Wo whkco} wjr wi}}iksboq fbvo ikc qbz jivo khs mook ai}}boc hus sh sjob} fudd+ Wjrbkfh}`isbhk imhus Miae sh Miqbaq jiq khs mook cbqqo`bkisoc sj}hugjhus sjo wh}dcqo}vbao qs}uasu}o chwk sh sjo G+Q+]q ikc i }oyuoqs sh bkso}g}hu| \umdba Bkfh}`isbhkah``bssooq sh bkfh}` sjo goko}id |umdba hf `bquqoq hf sjo I+I+ ki`o+

—\}bvisodr$ jhwovo} wo aik bkfh}` S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}q sjis sjor i}o hus hf h}co}+ Wjok sjor |o}qbqs$ wo aikfhddhw u| mr uqbkg quaj hsjo} }oqhu}aoq hf |o}quiqbhk iq wo `ir jivo$ ikc sjoqo i}o hfsok ahkqbco}imdo……++ Ikcsh sjbq okc wo qjidd kooc sh `ibksibk i ahksbkuhuq ocuaisbhk hf hu} |umdba ah``ukbaisbhk ajikkodq hf idd ebkcqahkao}kbkg sjo kisu}o ikc |u}|hqo hf hu} S}icbsbhkq………++ Wjokovo} ikc jhwovo} wo aik$ wo qjidd kooc shbkfh}` sjo goko}id |umdba idqh5 oq|oabiddr u|hk `bquqoq hf sjo ki`o Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+ Sjbq ah`mbkisbhk hf ahukso} fh}aoq aik mo vo}r cbqahu}igbkg sh vbhdish}q h} whudc mo vbhdish}q+ _kco} sjoqo ahkcbsbhkq sjor qhhk fbkcsjob} covbisbhkq sh mo uk|}hfbsimdo h} ukwbqo+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk‐+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr 6"+

Sjo iqqo}sbvo doico}qjb| bk |}hsoasbhk hf —hu} ah``hk wodfi}o‐ wiq woddco`hkqs}isoc mr Mbdd W$ sjo —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ bkvhdvoc wbsj Ajuae C+ bk 92?: ikc}oaoksdr mr sjhqo bk sjo Sh}hksh bkso}g}hu| bk Aikici>

99

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 13/63

—Sh}hksh‒q I+I+ Bkso}g}hu| Mhukaoq Isjobqsq ifso} Q|b}bsoc Missdo‐ mr Cb}e Jikqhk$ Sjo Fbz$ <6(<6(99$ bqquo 939>jss|>((www+sjofbz+ah`(ahksoks(choq-ii-kooc-ghc—Bq Sjo}o I \diao Fh} Isjobqsq bk Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq8 ‑ I dhkg-qb``o}bkg fouc bq q|}oicbkg i}hukc sjowh}dc$ ifso} hko II oqsimdbqj`oks vhsoc sh oz|od swh isjobqs(igkhqsba g}hu|q bk Aikici‐ mr Noqqo Moiaj$ Sjo Fbz93(<6(99> jss|>((www+idso}kos+h}g(qsh}r(9?9=23(bqXsjo}oXiX|diaoXfh}XisjobqsqXbkXidahjhdbaqXikhkr`huq8iebc0799=+=7?:?6+NB6Bn=&}c09&s0?

 Kh chums sjo ahu}igohuq Sh}hksh —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ jivo }oaobvoc |doksr hf —iaauqisbhkq…… ghmq hf }u`hu}$ ghqqb| ikc goko}id qaussdo-muss‐ *Ahkao|s BZ"$

 |o}ji|q isso`|sq sh swbqs wi}}iksr fbvo —bkabso`oks sh |umdba ahks}hvo}qr$‐ sh s}r ikcsj}hw sjo` hff moi`+ Jhwovo}$ idsjhugj bs bq ukfh}sukiso sjbq `isso} jiq ghko |umdba$wjok ah`|i}oc sh sjo bkabso`oks sh |umdba ahks}hvo}qr aiuqoc mr sjo mojivbhu} bk

auds g}hu|q$ coqa}bmoc bk sjo Wiqjbkgshk \hqs ikc Sjo Bkco|okcoks$ ikc sjo |hsoksbidbkabso`oks sh |umdba ahks}hvo}qr sh mo aiuqoc mr I+I g}hu|q }o-w}bsbkg sjo I+I+

 |}hg}i`$ oiaj iaah}cbkg sh sjob} cbasish}‒q hwk qukc}r bcoiq$ |o}qhkid modbofq ikc |}onucbaoq$ sjo i}sbado choq qjhw I+I+ *Bk Aikici is doiqs" sh jivo i dogbsb`isoh}gikbqoc qs}uasu}o wbsj i cudr odoasoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc iusjh}bsr$ }isjo} sjik ijoicdoqq iki}ajr+

—Qiduso sh Aikici ‑ Hu} ahkg}isudisbhkq ikc sjikeq sh Aikici5 kh fbko} II ozbqsq+‐ *Mbdd W+ @ir 92?9$ Dikguigohf sjo Joi}s |igo 929"

Fh} ik I+I+ g}hu| sh }o-w}bso sjo Swodvo Qso|q bq sh vbhdiso S}icbsbhk 3$ 3*Dhkg

Fh}`"+—Fh} bkqsikao kh g}hu| h} bkso}g}hu| ahudc food f}oo sh bkbsbiso$ wbsjhus ahkqudsisbhk$ ikr |umdbabsr sjis `bgjs iffoasII iq i wjhdo+ Kh} ahudc bs iqqu`o sh }o|}oqoks sjo wjhdo hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq mr |}bksbkg ikc cbqs}bmusbkgikrsjbkg |u}|h}sbkg sh mo II qsikci}c dbso}isu}o‐ *Mbdd W+ I+I+ G}i|ovbko @i}aj 923:$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo :9"+—Hu} dbso}isu}o bq i |}bkab|do `oikq mr wjbaj I+I+ }oahvo}r$ ukbsr$ ikc qo}vbao i}o fiabdbsisoc‐ *Ahkao|s ZB"+—Ikc igibk$ —Qh`o Uhf sjo Wiqjbkgshkbik dhaid g}hu|qP cb||oc bksh sjob} s}oiqu}boq sh fbkikao sjob} hwk |umdbaisbhkq+ Sjo}o wiq kh hvo}idd ocbsh}bid |hdbar……Wo i}o qu}o sjis bf sjo h}bgbkid Wiqjbkgshkbikq ahudc}osu}k sh sjbq |dikos sjor whudc mo gdic sh qoo uq doi}kbkg f}h` sjob} `bqsieoq…… Jic wo dbvoc bk sjob} cir wo`bgjs jivo `ico sjo qi`o o}}h}q+ \o}ji|q wo i}o mogbkkbkg sh `ieo qh`o hf sjo` khw+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbkoIuguqs 923?+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo ?" jss|>((ok+wbeb|ocbi+h}g(wbeb(WiqjbkgshkbikX`hvo`oks

Jhwovo}$ sjo |}bkab|do i||dboc sh sjo isjobqs-igkhqsba g}hu|q bk Sh}hksh hugjs sh mo

i||dboc sh ikr cuid |u}|hqo g}hu| |}oqoksbkg bsqodf iq ik —hk rhu} ekooq |}ir sh Ghc‐Aj}bqsbik —oi}dr II‐ - koh Hzfh}c G}hu|$ h} ikr hsjo} }odbgbhk>

—Qh`o roi}q igh$ ku`mo}q hf IIq fh}`oc sjo`qodvoq bksh —}os}ois g}hu|q‐ jivbkg i }odbgbhuq |u}|hqo+ Is fb}qssjor wiksoc sh aidd sjo`qodvoq II g}hu|q hf vi}bhuq coqa}b|sbhkq+ Mus sjor qhhk }oidb~oc sjbq ahudc khs mo chko moaiuqo sjob} g}hu|q jic i cuid |u}|hqo> mhsj II ikc }odbgbhk‐+ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?:5 Dikguigohf sjo Joi}s |igo ==="+

9=

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 14/63

—Q|oiebkg fh} C}+ Mhm ikc `rqodf B whudc dbeo sh qir sjis sjo}o jiq kovo} mook sjo qdbgjsoqs bksoks$ hk jbq |i}s h} `bko$ hf s}rbkg sh fhukc i kow }odbgbhuq cokh`bkisbhk+ C}+ Mhm jodc ao}sibk }odbgbhuq ahkvbasbhkq$ ikc qh ch B+Sjbq bq$ hf ahu}qo$ sjo |o}qhkid |}bvbdogo hf ovo}r I+I+ `o`mo}+ Khsjbkg jhwovo}$ ahudc mo qh ukfh}sukiso fh} I+I+‒q fusu}o iq ik isso`|s sh bkah}|h}iso ikr hf hu} |o}qhkid sjohdhgbaid vbowq bksh I+I+ soiajbkg$ |}iasbao h} s}icbsbhk+‐ *Mbdd W+ II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo =1="—Morhkc i Jbgjo} \hwo}$ iq oiaj hf uq `ir vbqbhk jb`$ I+I+ `uqs kovo}$ iq i qhabosr$ okso} sjo fbodc hf chg`i h} sjohdhgr…++ Doqs wo ebdd hu} uqofudkoqq mr mobkg mhggoc chwk bk sjohdhgbaid ahksoksbhk‐ *Mbdd W+ Dosso} 92?3$ IqMbdd qooq Bs |igo 996"

—Sjbq wiq sjo g}ois ahks}bmusbhk hf hu} isjobqsq ikc igkhqsbaq+ Sjor jic wbcokoc hu} gisowir qh sjis idd wjhquffo} `bgjs |iqq sj}hugj$ }ogi}cdoqq hf sjob} modbof h} diae hf modbof +‐ *Mbdd W+ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 967"—Sjo isjobqs `ir qsikc u| bk ik I+I+ `oosbkg cokrbkg Ghc$ ros }o|h}sbkg jhw jo jiq mook jod|oc bk hsjo} wirq‐…++ wo `ieo kh }odbgbhuq }oyub}o`oks hf ikrhko…++Bk sjbq is`hq|jo}o sjo h}sjhchz$ ukh}sjhchz$ ikc sjoukmodbovo} `bz ji||bdr ikc uqofuddr shgosjo}‐ *Mbdd W+ —\iqq bs Hk |igo 97=-971"

Wo whkco} bf sjo `hsbvisbhk mojbkc sjo Sh}hksh isjobqs g}hu|‒q iasbhkq bq hus hf iqokqo hf bkqoau}bsr i}bqbkg f}h` sjo bkfduokao hf S}icbsbhkq 3$ 6 ikc 9= vbhdisbhkq5 sjo

`bqqbhki}boq hf sjo cbqjhkoqs }okco}bkg hf II‒q jbqsh}r mr fukci`oksidbqs Aj}bqsbikiusjh}q o`ikisbkg f}h` sjo _QI5 Cbae M+ Nho @aY ikc Widdr \+

Ozs}iasq f}h` —Mr sjo \hwo} Hf Ghc$ I Gubco sh Oi}dr I+I+ G}hu|q & fh}`bkgqb`bdi} G}hu|q Shcir‐ mr Cbae M> 

—Hf ahu}qo sjo I+I+ hf roqso}roi} bq s}udr ghko fh}ovo}+ Sjo}o bq kh C}+ Mhm ‑ |jrqbabik$ Mbmdo qsucoks$ ‚\}bkao hf Swodvo-Qso||o}q$‒ i`miqqich} fh} Aj}bqs+ Sjo}o bq kh dhvbkg Ikko Q`bsj$- ‚@hsjo} hf I+I+‒ ‚Fhukco}‒ ku}qo$ovikgodbqs$ o`|dhr`oks igoks$ ikc cbq|okqo} hf ‚q|b}bsuid |imdu`‒UqbaP … …Sjo}o bq kh yubos sb`o…+ wjo}o sjoMbmdo bq qsucboc$…|}iro} bq `ico sh Ghc……+ *|igo zbbb"Sjo}o bq i Ghhc Mbg Mhhe(Mbmdo qsucr g}hu| bk Aidbfh}kbi……Sjo}o bq idqh i ‚Qifo sh Side imhus Noquq`oosbkg‒……+Sjo}o bq i Mbg Mhhe(Mbmdo qsucr `oosbkg bk Fdh}bci+ Sjo}o i}o q|b}bsuid }os}oisq fh} IIq ikc sjob} fi`bdboq bk is doiqs qovok dhaisbhkq bk sjo _kbsoc Qsisoq ikc hko bk Okgdikc+ *\igo zbbb"

- Qh idqh ‚Imqhduso |u}bsr+‒…+ Ikc bf sjr }bgjs oro hffokc sjoo$ |duae bs hus…+ *\igo 3="Ikc ‑ ‚Imqhduso ukqodfbqjkoqq‒…+Qh dbeowbqo wjh ovo} jo mo hf rhu sjis fh}qieosj khs idd…+ *\igo 3="- Ikc ‚Imqhduso Dhvo‒ I kow ah``ikc`oks sjis B gbvo uksh rhu sjis ro dhvo hko ikhsjo} …*\igo 3="Ai}}rbkg sjo @oqqigo…Iq |i}s hf IIq Swodfo UqbaP Qso|…Ikc joUNoquqP qibc uksh sjo`…+*\igo 9:2"\hqqbmdo I||}hiajoq bk @oosbkgq 9+ Dbqsokbkg sh sjo }oicbkgq hf qa}b|su}o+ \o}ji|q qog`oksq hf sjo Hzfh}cG}hu| mhhe$ Jhw sh }oic sjo Mbmdo U]hgo} Jbaeq$ Jhw sh }oic sjo Mbmdo *Dhkchk> @h}id }o- I}`i`oks$ 923<"P‐*\igo =9?"

—Idahjhdbq` aik mo au}oc+ Shcir‒q |oh|do jivo nuqs ajikgoc sjo dikguigo sh qisbqfr sjo ukmodbovo}q‐ *|igo =11"

 Cbae M‒q Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq Jbqsh}r womqbso> jss|>((www+cbaem+ah`(bkcoz+js`d 

Ozs}iasq f}h` —Miae sh Miqbaq Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq Mogbkko}q `oosbkgq‐Mr Widdr \>—Bk h}co} fh} sjo |}haoqq sh wh}e$ kowah`o}q kooc sh mo `isajoc u| wbsj I+I+ `o`mo}q wjh i}o wbddbkg sh gubcosjo` sj}hugj sjo fhu} hko jhu} qoqqbhkq……++Kowah`o}q ch khs issokc mogbkko}q‒ `oosbkgq idhko$ sjor i}oiaah`|ikboc mr sjob} q|hkqh}q(qji}bkg |i}sko}q…++Fh} sjo Kowah`o}> 9+Rhu} |}b`i}r hmdbgisbhk bq sh issokc idd fhu} qoqqbhkq…+ =+ Wo wbdd }oic sjo i||}h|}biso |i}sq hf sjo ‚Mbg Mhhe‒ sh rhu…+ *\igo 1:"—Bs bq sb`o sh iqqbgk q|hkqh}q h} qji}bkg |i}sko}q sh sjhqo wjh kooc sjo`+ Wbdd sjo kowah`o}q |doiqo qsikc+ Sjoqoi}o sjo |oh|do wjh i}o imhus sh sieo sjo Swodvo Qso|q‐ *\igo 12"

91

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 15/63

—Kozs sjo iusjh} bkqs}uasq uq sh ajoae wjis wo jivo |us hk |i|o}+ Jo}o sjo q|hkqh} h} qji}bkg |i}sko} aik mo vo}rjod|fud> Ajoae …Wjok bk chums ikc wjok bs bq b`|h}siks$ wjis choq ikhsjo} |o}qhk wjh bq wh}ebkg swh wir |}iro} sjbke imhus sjbq sjhugjs h} iasbhk8++++Side hvo} shgosjo} wjis rhu jivo w}bssok…Sodd oiaj hsjo} wjisgubcikao jiq ah`o+ Sjbq bq sjo qoa}os hf ukbsr…+Sjok sjo iusjh} oz|dibkq$ sh wjis `ikr hf uq$ bq sjo `hqs cbffbauds |i}s hf idd…Hmor+++Ai}}r hus sjo sjhugjsq sjis jivo ah`o+ Rhu wbdd hkdr mo qu}o hf gubcikao iq rhu gh sj}hugjwbsj bs… UJhw sh dbqsok sh Ghc$ |1P‐ *|igo 9=<"—Bs bq sb`o sh `ieo i ah``bs`oks sh wh}ebkg wbsj hsjo}q…|doiqo qsikc+ Sjbq bq sjo Swodfo UqbaP Qso| yuoqsbhk‚Wbdd rhu ai}}r sjo `oqqigo sh hsjo} idahjhdbaq8‒ |doiqo ikqwo}$ hko is i sb`o$ ‚roq‒ h} ‚kh+‒ Ifso} rhu jivoikqwo}oc$ |doiqo mo qoisoc+ UJivo oiaj kowah`o} ikqwo} sjo yuoqsbhkP‐ *|igo 936"

Sjo fhddhwbkg i}o qh`o oi}dr I+I+ cofbkbsbhkq hf Ghc ikc |}iro}$ mr wjis qh`o hf shcir‒q miae sh miqbaq —h}bgbkid I+I‐+ —Hk rhu} ekooq‐ `bqqbhki}boq `bgjs aidd sjo—H}bgbkid II `o`mo}q‐ h} —Sjo fb}qs Hko Jukc}oc‐$ —Mbg Mhhe Iusjh}q$‐—fhukco}q‐>

—@hqs hf uq bk Ie}hk cbck‒s dbeo idd sjbq |}irbkg……+Wo‒c jic okhugj hf bs bk sjo Hzfh}c G}hu|+ B qsbdd chk‒s dbeo |}irbkg bk I+I+ B chk‒s dbeo sjo Qo}okbsr \}iro}+ Kow Rh}e m}hugjs bs bk$ ikc wo }oqoksoc bs+ Wo sjhugjs sjor wo}o

 m}bkgbkg miae sjo Hzfh}c G}hu|‐ *923=$ Hqai} W+ Oi}dr Ie}hk I+I+ g}hu| `o`mo}" *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc HdcSb`o}q$ |igo =79"9217> —Ikc sjob} ahkao|s hf i Jbgjo} \hwo} wiq cbffo}oks f}h` sjis hf sjo g}hu|o}q$ wjh wo}o khs |}o|i}oc shiaao|s dbgjs mudmq ikc Sjb}c Ivokuo muqoq iq ozi`|doq hf —Ghc iq B ukco}qsikc Jb`+………… Sjbq$ shh$ wiq ikissbsuco sjis }o|}oqoksoc i fukci`oksid cbffo}okao moswook sjo I+I+q ikc sjo Hzfh}c G}hu|o}q+ I+I+q wo}o `h}oikc `h}o bkadbkoc sh iddhw kowo} `o`mo}q sh i}}bvo is i ahkao|s hf i Jbgjo} \hwo} bk sjob} hwk sb`o ikc`ikko}+‐ *\iqq Bs Hk$ |igo 969"—S}r sh fbkc rhu} hwk Ghc ‑ Iq  rhu ukco}qsikc Jb`+‐ *Yuhso hf C}+ Mhm" * C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo =:9"923<> — Is jbq sb`o ‑ Nikui}r ‑ 923< jo wiqk‒s `iebkg rhu gos hus hf moc sh |}ir hk rhu} ekooq$ sh |}ir wbsj rhu$B‒` khs qu}o sjis whudc jivo wh}eoc shh wodd wbsj `o+‐ I }oahddoasbhk hf C}+ Mhm mr Nhjk Q+ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjoGhhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo =76"9239>‐Ikr ahkao|s hf sjo Jbgjo} \hwo} bq iaao|simdo+ I qao|sba h} ik igkhqsba `ir ajhhqo sh sjbke hf jbq bkko} qodf$ sjo `b}iado hf g}hwsj$ i s}oo$ `ik‒q whkco}`oks is sjo |jrqbaid ukbvo}qo$ sjo qs}uasu}o hf ik ish`$ h} `o}o

`isjo`isbaid bkfbkbsr+ Wjisovo} fh}` bq vbquidb~oc$ sjo koh|jrso bq siugjs sjis jo `uqs }odr hk bs$ bk jbq hwk wir$sh |}ir sh sjo |hwo} fh} qs}okgsj+‐ *Niae Idozikco} i}sbado imhus II |igo 92"

Bs jiq sh mo qo}bhuqdr ahkqbco}oc wjosjo} ik I+I+ g}hu| iffbdbisoc sh i womqbso bq khsbk fias iffbdbisoc sh ik bkcbvbcuid `o`mo}‒q |}bviso okso}|}bqo+ Wjosjo} g}hu|q qhiffbdbisoc sh ik husqbco okso}|}bqo aik aidd sjo`qodvoq I+I+ g}hu|q$ wjosjo} GQH ikcbkso}g}hu|q hugjs sh }ogbqso} g}hu|q qh iffbdbisoc$ ukdoqq sjo g}hu| ikc womqbso i}oqo|i}isodr bkah}|h}isoc$ gbvbkg kh b`|dbaisbhk sjis sjo swh i}o ahkkoasoc+

Bs jiq sh mo ahkqbco}oc wjosjo} bs bq qsbdd wbqo fh} GQH sh }ogbqso} g}hu|q wbsjhus |}bh} ahkqudsisbhk wbsj sjo dhaid bkso}g}hu| ikc wjosjo} ao}sibk g}hu|q wjbaj h|o}iso

husqbco sjo I+I+ qo}vbao qs}uasu}o hugjs sh mo I+I+ }ogbqso}oc$ wjok qo|i}isodrbkah}|h}isoc ah`|ikboq i}o ah`|osbsbvodr s}icbkg hff sjo II ki`o ikc okahu}igbkgsjob} hwk g}hu|q sh h|o}iso mhsj bkqbco ikc husqbco II>jss|>((www+iimiaeshmiqbaq+h}g(jss|>((www+iimiaeshmiqbaq+h}g(Fibsj/=<Wbsj/=<Wh}eq/=<\um/=<Ah(bkcoz+js`djss|>((www+iimiaeshmiqbaq+h}g(Kow-Ahu}s/=<H}co}oc/=<Miae/=<sh/=<Miqbaq+js`d

93

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 16/63

Miae sh Miqbaq II `oosbkgq dbqs> jss|>((www+iimiaeshmiqbaq+h}g(M=M/=<@oosbkg

/=<Dhaisbhkq+js`  Ah`|osbsbvo |umdba bkfh}`isbhk>jss|>((www+iimiaeshmiqbaq+h}g(Fibsj/=<Wbsj/=<Wh}eq/=<\um/=<Ah(Kow-Jhuae-]baj`hkc-6<=+js`d 

Miae sh Miqbaq Fhukcisbhk ‑ *Chkisbhkq iaao|soc">jss|>((www+iimiaeshmiqbaq+h}g(fhukcisbhk|docgo+js`

Miae sh Miqbaq `o}ajikcbqo>jss|>((oiqrai}s+kos(FibsjWbsjWh}eq\umdbqjbkgAh+(9=XQso|XMhheqsh}oXCbqahuksq+js`d

Bs jiq sh mo ahkqbco}oc wjosjo} bs bq wbqo sh }ogbqso} g}hu|q sjis i}o cb}oasdr h} bkcb}oasdr iffbdbisoc sh khk-II 9= qso| s}ois`oks aoks}o |}hg}i`q wjbaj s}ico hff sjoI+I+ ki`o>

Eoddr Fhukcisbhk$ Nho @aY‒q —]oahvo}r Crki`baq‐>jss|>((www+eoddrfck+ah`(imhus+js` *Chkisbhkq iaao|soc"—Mbg Mhhe Qsucr‐ I+I+ G}hu|q>jss|>((www+eoddrfck+ah`(MbgMhheQsucr(mmqsucrcb}oash}r+js` 

—Mbg Mhhe qsucr‐ I+I+ g}hu|q cb}oash}r>jss|>((www+eoddrfck+ah`(MbgMhheQsucr(mmqsucrg}hu|q+js` 

\}b`i}r \u}|hqo g}hu| hf II *Ciddiq" Mbg Mhhe qsucr g}hu|q cb}oash}r>jss|>((||giiciddiq+h}g(bsXwh}eq)+js` 

I rhu-sumo vbcoh> jss|>((www+rhusumo+ah`(wisaj8v0fADZs7~~Z9w 

—Qjhwaiqbkg sjo wh}e hf sjo Eoddr Fhukcisbhk ikc Qo}okbsr \i}e wbsj hu} |i}sko}q bk Ni|ik> Qo}okbsr \i}e Ni|ikikc Qo}okbsr \}hg}i`$ Bka+ Ai}}rbkg sjo `oqqigo ikc sjo dogiar hf Nho @aY sh idahjhdbaq ikc iccbasq i}hukc sjowh}dc+ \doiqo ahksias sjo Eoddr Fhukcisbhk fh} `h}o bkfh}`isbhk> www+eoddrfck+ah`‐

*Foisu}bkg sjo |diyuo hf Nho @aY *Fhukco}"+ Mbdd W$ C}$ Mhm+ Ikc sjo Swodvo Qso|q

hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq *Qa}hdd ivibdimdo f}h` GQH"+

Nho @aY `o`h}bidq>jss|>((www+iijbqsh}r+ah`(nho`ay(qbgk+|j|jss|>((i}ajbvo+mdbqqs}oo+ah`(food(nho-`ay-96(

Aji}dbo \ `o`h}bidq>jss|>((www+iijbqsh}r+ah`(aji}dbo|(qbgk+|j|jss|>((dugbkmuodfuko}idjh`o+f}hks}ukko}|}h+ah`(}uksb`o(1<6<(}uksb`o+|j|8QbsoBc01<6<&Kivbgish}Bc0?39=6&h|0s}bmusoHmbsui}r&vbowH|s0c|ikoHkdr&Bso`Bc07=16=7&DbkeBc0==9 

*Chkisbhkq iaao|soc"

Iq Mbdd W+ Qsisoq>—Sjis wo `uqs$ is idd ahqsq$ ivhbc sjo |}hfoqqbhkidb~isbhk hf II5 sjis qb`|do Swodfsj Qso| wh}e bq kovo} sh mo |ibcfh}5 sjis IIq ghbkg bksh idahjhd sjo}i|r qjhudc kovo} s}ico hk sjob} II ahkkoasbhk5 sjis sjo}o bq khs$ ikc kovo} aik mo$ ikr quaj sjbkg iq ik ‚II sjo}i|bqs‒+ *Mbdd W5 Ah-fhukco} hf I+I+$ I+I+ G}i|ovbko$ Nuko 9236$ Dikguigo hf sjoJoi}s |igo =2"

9?

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 17/63

Hu} `o`mo}qjb| S}icbsbhk choq ahksibk$ jhwovo}$ hko b`|h}siks yuidbfbaisbhk+++ +++++Wo aikkhs dokc sjo II ki`o$ovok bkcb}oasdr$ sh hsjo} iasbvbsboq$ jhwovo} wh}sjr+ Bf wo ch qh wo qjidd moah`o jh|odoqqdr ah`|}h`bqoc ikccbvbcoc+ Wo sjbke sjis II qjhudc hffo} bsq oz|o}bokao sh sjo wjhdo wh}dc fh} wjisovo} uqo aik mo `ico hf bs+ Muskhs bsq ki`o+ Khsjbkg aik mo `h}o ao}sibk+ *Mbdd W+ ‚S}icbsbhk Sj}oo‒$ II G}i|ovbko 923:$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 72-:<"

Sjo kow crki`baq sh I+I+ jivo oz|hqoc i chumdo joicoc ozoausbvo ikc a}oisoc iqbsuisbhk bk wjbaj kobsjo} I+I+ S}icbsbhkq kh} wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao i}owbsjqsikcbkg+ Adoi}dr bk Shcir‒q I+I+ i g}hu| aik jivo ikhsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk$ahks}i}r sh wi}}iksr qbz>

—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk+‐

Sjo}o i||oi}q sh mo kh mhcr udsb`isodr }oq|hkqbmdo fh} okqu}bkg sjis sjo |}hvbqbhk bksjbq wi}}iksr bq u|jodc+

Sjo}o bq kh adoi} udsb`iso iusjh}bsr hf S}icbsbhk Swh5 kobsjo} sjo s}uqsooq ikc GQH$kh} sjo I+I+ g}hu| Ahkqabokao i||oi} sh jivo adoi} codogisoc ikc udsb`iso}oq|hkqbmbdbsr$ qbkao mhsj sjo bkso}g}hu| ikc GQH aik }ogbqso} I+I+ g}hu|q+\i}ichzbaiddr$ sjo |}oqoks iusjh}bsr GQH jiq sh }ogbqso} g}hu|q$ hvo} ikc imhvo sjobkso}g}hu| ahkqabokao$ qo}voq i —sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd `bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsjimqhduso |hwo}‐ *Ahkao|s V" }isjo} sjik sjo udsb`iso iusjh}bsr hf sjo I+I g}hu|ahkqabokao wbsjbk sjo bkso}g}hu|+ Sjo}ofh}o sjo udsb`iso iusjh}bsr bk sjo I+I g}hu|ahkqabokao bq ji`qs}ukg+ Sjo}o bq khw i qs}hkg aiqo fh} sjo s}uqsooq ikc GQH sh |iqqudsb`iso iusjh}bsr ikc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr fh} g}hu| }ogbqs}isbhk cb}oasdr sh sjo I+I+ g}hu|ahkqabokao wbsjbk sjo bkso}g}hu|q+

—I+I iq quaj hugjs kovo} mo h}gikbqoc5 mus wo `ir a}oiso qo}vbao mhi}cq h} ah``bssooq cb}oasdr }oq|hkqbmdo shsjhqo sjor qo}vo+‐ *S}icbsbhk Sok"—I ahkcbsbhk sh mo ivhbcoc is idd ahqsq bq chumdo joicoc muqbkoqq h} |hdbar `ikigo`oks+ Iusjh}bsr aik kovo} mocbvbcoc bksh oyuid jidvoq+‐ *Ahkao|s Z"—Sjo `ibk |}bkab|doq hf S}icbsbhk Swh i}o a}rqsid adoi}> sjo I+I+ g}hu|q i}o sh mo sjo fbkid iusjh}bsr5 sjob} doico}qi}o sh mo s}uqsoc wbsj codogisoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsboq hkdr+‐ *Ahkao|s B"

Wjbdo sjo I+I+ Qo}vbao Qs}uasu}o codbmo}isoq$ |o}ji|q khs ros ici|soc sh sjo q|ooc hf `hco}k ah``ukbaisbhk ikc sjo kowfhukc qebddq hf hu} umbyubshuq ikc ovo} |o}okkbid— |}h`hso} f}bokc‐ *II ah`oq hf Igo |igo 91<"$ sjo cbqiffoasoc vbasb`q hf aho}abhkikc `bq}o|}oqoksisbhk i}o doivbkg$ I+I+ bq gossbkg sjo |umdba b`igo hf mobkg i

}odbgbhuq auds ikc bkso}g}hu|q i}o oz|o}bokabkg qs}ibkoc }odisbhkqjb|q+

96

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 18/63

Ozs}iasq f}h` ahkfo}okao yuoqsbhk ikc ah``bssoo }oq|hkqoq$ _E Goko}id Qo}vbaoAhkfo}okao =<99$ Ah``bssoo 3$ Yuoqsbhk =>

—Aik Ahkfo}okao `ieo quggoqsbhkq hk jhw g}hu|q ikc Bkso}g}hu|q aik wh}e mosso} sh ai}}r sjo `oqqigo sh sjoqsbdd quffo}bkg idahjhdba8 - Sjo}o bq ovbcokao sjis qs}ibkoc }odisbhkqjb|q moswook qh`o G}hu|q ikc Bkso}g}hu|qahudc mo bkjbmbsbkg sjo offoasbvokoqq hf hu} |}b`i}r |u}|hqo+‐ *II qo}vbao Kowq 93?$ =<9<"—Sjbq ah``bssoo fhukc sjis qs}ibkoc }odisbhkq moswook qh`o g}hu|q ikc Bkso}g}hu|q aik bkjbmbs sjo offoasbvokoqq hf hu} |}b`i}r |u}|hqo…++‐ *Ah``bssoo 3$ Yuoqsbhk =" *II Qo}vbao kowq 937$ =<99"

Wbsj 1< ao}sbfboc fiabdbsboq wh}dcwbco *Eoddr Fhukcisbhk womqbso" ikc koi}dr 3<<s}ois`oks aoks}oq uqbkg ]oahvo}r Crki`baq `iso}bidq *—Ai}}r Sjbq @oqqigo‐$ Nho`aY$ }oi} ahvo}" bkchas}bkisbkg idahjhdbaq bk Nho @aYq jrm}bc I+I+(]oahvo}rCrki`baq |}hg}i`$ idhkgqbco qumsdo bkchas}bkisbhk hf I+I+ `o`mo}q vbi —Nho ikcAji}dbo‐ Mbg Mhhe Qsucr iucbh }oah}cbkgq5 ikc i gdhmid iffbdbisbhk hf \}b`i}r\u}|hqo Mbg Mhhe Qsucr I+I+ g}hu|q$ joicoc mr sjo \}b`i}r \u}|hqo G}hu| hf I+I+

*Ciddiq"5 bkso}g}hu|q hugjs sh |}o|i}o i qs}isogr fh} co -|}hg}i``bkg ikr ahkfuqoc$ m}ibkwiqjoc kowah`o}q wjh modbovo sjor i}o hk i cuid |u}|hqo `bqqbhk sh ocuaisoI+I+ ikc sjo qsbdd quffo}bkg idahjhdba+ @h}ohvo}$ \umdba Bkfh}`isbhk ah``bssooq hugjssh mo covodh|bkg i qs}isogr fh} bkfh}`bkg sjo goko}id |umdba$ oq|oabiddr o`|jiqbqbkgsjo fias I+I+ bq khs i }odbgbhuq h}gikbqisbhk h} ik idahjhdbq` ocuaisbhk |}hg}i`+

—Hf jbgjoqs b`|h}sikao whudc mo hu} }odisbhkq wbsj `ocbabko ikc }odbgbhk+ _kco} kh ab}au`qsikaoq `uqs wo gosbksh ah`|osbsbhk wbsj obsjo}+ Bf wo i||oi}oc sh mo i kow }odbgbhuq qoas$ wo‒c mo chko fh}+ *II G}i|ovbko Nuko92??$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9?<"

—Ocuaisbhk wbdd khs hkdr |ir hff bk ku`mo}q s}oisoc5 bs aik |ir hff ovok `h}o jikcqh`odr bk |}ovoksbhk… … Khw wjh bq ghbkg sh ch idd sjbq ocuaisbhk8 Hmvbhuqdr$ bs bq mhsj i ah``ukbsr nhm ikc i nhm fh} q|oabidbqsq+Bkcbvbcuiddr$ wo IIq aik jod|$ mus II iq quaj aikkhs$ ikc qjhudc khs$ gos cb}oasdr bksh sjbq fbodc+‐ *Mbdd W+ IIG}i|ovbko @i}aj 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9:6-9:7"

—Khsjbkg jhwovo}$ ahudc mo qh ukfh}sukiso fh} I+I+‒q fusu}o iq ik isso`|s sh bkah}|h}iso ikr hf hu} |o}qhkidsjohdhgbaid vbowq bksh I+I+ soiajbkg$ |}iasbao h} s}icbsbhk+‐ *Mbdd W+ II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo =1="—Morhkc i Jbgjo} \hwo}$ iq oiaj hf uq `ir vbqbhk jb`$ I+I+ `uqs kovo}$ iq i qhabosr$ okso} sjo fbodc hf chg`i h} sjohdhgr…++ Doqs wo ebdd hu} uqofudkoqq mr mobkg mhggoc chwk bk sjohdhgbaid ahksoksbhk‐ *Mbdd W+ Dosso} 92?3$ IqMbdd qooq Bs |igo 996"

—Bf wo }oahgkbqo }odbgbhk bq sjo |}hvbkao hf sjo ado}gr ikc sjo |}iasbao hf `ocbabko bq fh} chash}q$ wo aik jod|fuddrahh|o}iso wbsj mhsj‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr ?"

—Wo jivo kh chas}bko sjis jiq sh mo `ibksibkoc$ kh `o`mo}qjb| sjis jiq sh mo okdi}goc$ Wo jivo kh iusjh}bsr sjis

jiq sh mo qu||h}soc$ kh |}oqsbgo$ |hwo}$ h} |}bco sjis jiq sh mo qisbqfboc‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"

97

 

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 19/63

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 20/63

Dhqs ikc fhukc Mhhe Mbkco}rBf rhu jivo i Mbg Mhhe$ sjok rhu id}oicr ekhw jhw b`|h}siks sjor i}o+ @hqs hf uq *bkaducbkg `o" hwo hu} dbvoqsh sjo `oqqigo sjbq mhhe ai}}boq+ Wo jivo `i}eoc sjo` u| bk ovo}r wir b`igbkimdo ikc ovo}r khso jiq i q|oabid`oikbkg bk hu} }oahvo}r+jss|>((www+mbgmhhefbzo}+ah`(bkcoz+js`d

Mbg Mhhe Qsucr Gubco

Sjo |u}|hqo hf sjbq Qsucr Gubco bq sh okimdo sjo qsucoks sh mosso} ukco}qsikc sjo bkfh}`isbhk sjo iusjh}q hf sjo mhhe  Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq … …jss|>((||giiciddiq+h}g(qsucrXgubco+js`

Ghdc |disoc `ociddbhk3a Ghdc Doif \disoc II Ikkuid Qhm}bosr Mb}sjcir @ociddbhk(Ahbk ¡9?+<<\disoc wbsj =3a ghdc doif$ sjbq moiusbfud II qhm}bosr `ocid jiq i }ibqoc ab}ado(s}bikgdo qjhwbkg sjo roi} hf qhm}bosrwbsj sjo Dogiaboq hf5 ]oahvo}r$ _kbsr & Qo}vbao+ Sjo wh}cq$ —Sh Sjbko Hwk Qodf Mo S}uo‐$ i}o qsi`|oc i}hukcsjo ahbk‒q ocgo+ Sjo Qjh}s vo}qbhk hf sjo Qo}okbsr \}iro} bq qsi`|oc hk sjo }ovo}qo+

jss|>((www+}oahvo}bkgebkc}ocq|b}bsq+ah+ue(bkcoz9+js`d

I kowah`o} vbasb` hf Mbg Mhhe Qsucr qs}uggdoq wbsj jo} qso| wh}emhhe>

—B i` ahkao}koc sjis wo i}o khs }oiajbkg |oh|do wjh aikkhs }oic wodd h} aikkhs }oic is idd+ B i` kow sh sjo |}hg}i` ikc `iebkg `r wir sj}hugj sjo Qso|q+ B qs}uggdo sh ukco}qsikc sjo Swodvo ikc Swodvo$ ovok wbsj iahddogo cog}oo ikc jod| f}h` `r q|hkqh} ikc hsjo} IIq+ @oikwjbdo$ `r }hh``iso$ idqh kowdr qhmo} ikc wbsj ig}ico qajhhd ocuaisbhk$ aik's `ieo ikr qokqo hf jo} Qso| wh}emhhe ikc bq imhus sh gbvo u|+Jhw `ikr |oh|do ch wo dhqo sjbq wir8 Jhw `ikr$ wjok iqeoc sh }oic f}h` sjo Mbg Mhhe is i `oosbkg$ qsu`mdosj}hugj i fow qoksokaoq$ iausodr o`mi}}iqqoc$ ikc kovo} ah`o miae8 I dbso}isu}o-miqoc |}hg}i` offoasbvodr qjusqhus |oh|do wjh coq|o}isodr kooc jod| mus ch khs jivo ghhc }oicbkg qebddq‐+ *Coi} G}i|ovbko$ Qjus Hus5 I+I+G}i|ovbko Khvo`mo} =<9<"

Eoddr Fhukcisbhk Mbg Mhhe Qsucr( qso| gubco mhheq$ ]oahvo}r Crki`baq `iso}bidq$Mhheq mr Nho @aY>

jss|>((www+eoddrfck+ah`(h}co}+js`

Hsjo} kowah`o}q‒ vbowq>

—B'vo mook chbkg sodo|jhko qo}vbao qbkao B ghs qhmo}+ B ikqwo} sjo |jhkoq is hu} bkso}g}hu| hffbao bk sjo `h}kbkgq+Qh`o hf `r fivhu}bso aiddq i}o f}h` kowah`o}q wjh qir$ B kooc sh gh sh qh`o hf rhu} adiqqoq+ Sjor sjbke wo'}obk qajhhd) …‐ *Adiqq bq bk Qoqqbhk+ I+I+ g}i|ovbko Khvo`mo} =<9<"

Sjo vbow hf Mbdd W+ Ah-Fhukco} hf I+I>

—Ocuaisbhk wbdd khs hkdr |ir hff bk ku`mo}q s}oisoc5 bs aik |ir hff ovok `h}o jikcqh`odr bk |}ovoksbhk… … Khw wjh bq ghbkg sh ch idd sjbq ocuaisbhk8 Hmvbhuqdr$ bs bq mhsj i ah``ukbsr nhm ikc i nhm fh} q|oabidbqsq+Bkcbvbcuiddr$ wo IIq aik jod|$ mus II iq quaj aikkhs$ ikc qjhudc khs$ gos cb}oasdr bksh sjbq fbodc+‐ *Mbdd W+ IIG}i|ovbko @i}aj 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9:6-9:7"

92

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 21/63

Sjo vbow hf Kh}`ik R bk 9277$ wjh Nhbkoc I+I+ bk 9212>

—‚B kovo} }oic i wh}c bk I+I+‒ jo qibc+ ‚Rhu chk‒s jivo sh }oic+ Rhu chk‒s jivo sh jivo idd sjoqo |i`|jdosq sjor |us hus+ Rhu aik doi}k sh dbvo sjbq |}hg}i` mr doi}kbkg sh sjbke+ I+I+ bq i whkco}fud sjbkg sh ekhw ikc i||dr‒jo qibc$ ‚- mus bk rhu} dbfo+ Rhu‒vo ghs sh dbvo bs hus bk sjo qs}oos+ Rhu qoo qh`omhcr jivbkg i dbssdo |}hmdo`$ jod|sjo`$ kh `isso} wjh sjor i}o+ Sjis‒q I+I+‐ ‑Kh}`ik R+ *C}+ Mhm ikc Sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo =?9-=?<"

Wjok Kh}`ik fbkiddr ghs i nhm$ bk 923<$ jod|bkg hsjo} mdbkc |oh|do$ jo qsi}soc sh |us iqbco sok |o}aoks hf jbq qidi}rsh |ir fh} q|oiebkg s}b|q$ ahks}bmusbhkq is `oosbkgq$ ikc hsjo} I+I+ oz|okqoq+ *C}+ Mhm ikc Sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo 9:=-9:1"

Jivo qh`o yui}so}q hf sjo foddhwqjb| dhqs qbgjs hf sjo I+I+ q|b}bs hf g}isbsuco ikcqo}vbao$ f}oodr gbvok wbsjhus kooc sh qisbqfr sjob} a}ivbkgq fh} |o}qhkid |}oqsbgo h} 

`iso}bid }owi}c8

Sjbq s}okc bk I+I+ `o}ajikcbqo mogik |o}ji|q$ `ikr roi}q igh wbsj hu} —|}h`hso} f}bokc‐ bk sjo |diqsbaq `hudcbkg bkcuqs}r qoddbkg mbsq hf |diqsba sjo I+I+ g}hu|5 i}owi}c sh `ik$ fh} wjis bq mus Ghc‒q g}iao5 Sjo ajb| sh wocgo h|ok sjo chh} sh i f}oo`i}eos+ —Sh Sjbko Hwk ‚Qodf‒ mo S}uo‐ bkqsoic hf —Mus fh} sjo g}iao hf Ghc gh ‚B‒ ‐Ik i||oid sh sjo qokqoq ikc i }hukc hf i||diuqo sh bkfdiso ik ogh+ Ifso}wi}c sjbq aik

 mo vbowoc iq ik I+I+ g}hu| sjis —widdhwoc bk o`hsbhkidbq` ikc jic `bqsieok bs fh} s}uo }odbgbhuq foodbkg‐ *Qso| = Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 11"+ —Sjbqjic mook hu} mdbkc q|hs+ Wo jic qu||hqoc wo jic ju`bdbsr wjok wo }oiddr jick‒s+‐

*Qso| Swh$ Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 11"+ Bf }owi}c bq sh mo gbvok isidd$ mosso} i gbfs hf I+I+ dbso}isu}o sh okahu}igo i kowah`o}‒q coo|o} ukco}qsikcbkg hf jbq bddkoqq ikc sh m}hicok jbq ukco}qsikcbkg hf jhkoqsr ikc ju`bdbsr+

I vbasb` hf I+I muqbkoqq qji}oq jo} qsh}r>

Ozs}ias f}h` —uk}oah}coc‐$ I+I+ G}i|ovbko Iuguqs =<<7 Vhd+ 63 Kh+ 1

—++Qh`o q|oieo}q i}o }oah}coc wbsjhus sjob} ekhwdocgo h} |o}`bqqbhk+ Fh} bkqsikao$ hko f}bokc hf `bko$ i girqajhhdsoiajo}$ wiq jh}}bfboc sh cbqahvo} sjis jbq II side jic mook }oah}coc ikc qhdc wbsjhus jbq ekhwdocgo+ Qbkao |i}s hf jbq qsh}r bkaducoc i coqa}b|sbhk hf jhw jbq }oahvo}r f}h` idahjhdbq` jod|oc jb` iaao|s jbq qozuid

h}boksisbhk$ jo wiq ahkao}koc sjis jbq |}hfoqqbhkid qsikcbkg whudc mo noh|i}cb~oc bf sjo }oah}cbkg whukc u| bk sjow}hkg jikcq+ Hf ahu}qo$ sjo wjhdo qbsuisbhk ahudc jivo mook ivhbcoc bf sjo si|o} qb`|dr jic iqeoc jbq |o}`bqqbhksh }oah}c sjo side+Ikhsjo} II `o`mo} B ekhw$ i ado}gr`ik$ codbvo}oc i }isjo} oi}sjr side is ik II ahkvoksbhk+ Qh`ohko qoks sjo}oah}cbkg sh jbq mbqjh|$ dikcbkg sjo ado}gr`ik bk jhs wiso}+ Ao}sibkdr$ sjo sissdosido wiq i di}go |i}s hf sjo |}hmdo`jo}o+ Mus bf sjo}o'q hko |diao wjo}o wo qjhudck's jivo sh wh}}r imhus sjo }o|o}auqqbhkq hf hu} qji}bkg$ bs'q ik II`oosbkg+ Qh$ wjis choq ikhkr`huq `oik sh `o`mo}q cu}bkg sjoqo sb`oq hf ovo}-|}oqoks iucbh }oah}co}q8…+Hko sb`o$ B wideoc bksh ik II ahkvoksbhk wjo}o B wiq q|oiebkg ikc wiq qu}|}bqoc sh qoo sjo si|o} qos u| wbsj

=<

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 22/63

ch~okq hf |}o-`ico dimodq wbsj `r fudd ki`o o`mdi~hkoc hk sjo`+ B shdc jb` sh mdhs hus `r diqs ki`o+ Jo mog}ucgbkgdr ah`|dboc+ Kh hko hk sjo ah``bssoo jic `oksbhkoc sjis sjor bksokcoc sh }oah}c ikc qodd `r side…

… Ikhsjo} sb`o$ B wiq qoisoc hk sjo cibq iq i mikyuos q|oieo} cu}bkg ikhsjo} II ahkvoksbhk+ Sjo si|o}q muqsdocimhus$ qossbkg u| sjob} }oah}cbkg qrqso`+ Fbkiddr$ B qibc$ Bq ikrhko ghbkg sh iqe `o bf bs'q idd }bgjs sh }oah}c `rside8 Sjor wo}o |o}|dozoc mr sjo yuoqsbhk…………… Qb`bdi}dr$ bf wo jivo sh ig}oo sh mo }oah}coc mofh}o mobkgbkvbsoc sh sodd hu} II qsh}boq$ sjok Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq jiq dhqs bsq wir………+ Ovbcoksdr$ `ikr iucbh}oah}cbkg muqbkoqqoq i}ok's fi`bdbi} wbsj sjo diqs |igo hf sjo I+I+ Gubcodbkoq hk Ahkfo}okaoq……+Qh`o si|o}qias iq mhhebkg igoksq fh} II `oosbkgq$ ahkvoksbhkq$ }hukc-u|q$ ikc ahkfo}okaoq+ Sjor'}o muqbkoqq |oh|do$ ikcsjor }oah``okc$ iq q|oieo}q$ sjhqo wjhqo }oah}cbkgq qodd dhsq hf ah|boq> sjo |hdbqjoc$ sjo qokqisbhkid$ sjoju`h}huq$ ikc sjo wodd-ekhwk+ Goko}iddr$ si|o}q whk's }oah``okc q|oieo}q wjh whk's iddhw sjob} sideq sh mo}oah}coc$ moaiuqo bs'q i mic muqbkoqq coabqbhk fh} sjo`……++ B'c dbeo sh qoo II woik bsqodf f}h` bsq co|okcokao hksi|o}q………………++ B chk's wiks sh wide iwir f}h` sjo II `oosbkg wbsj i m}ikc-kow AC+ B wiks sh wide iwirf}h` sjo II `oosbkg wbsj ik o`|sr jikc$ i fudd joi}s$ ikc i kow swbqs hk ik hdc `oqqigo sjis gbvoq sjo }oab|boks i  mbg q|b}bsuid cbvbcokc--wjbdo kh hko }oidb~oq i cb`o bk |}hfbs+ Ikhkr`huq

Bs bq i qic cir fh} I+I+$ wjok q|oieo}q i}o ajhqok fh} sjob} bkkiso imbdbsr sh ai|sbvisoikc okso}sibk ik iucbokao+ Jivo ahkvoksbhkq moah`o i muqbkoqq8 Jivo sjor moah`o i

 |hwo} gi`o fh} —Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐ sh oz|dhbs wjis C}+ Qbdewh}sj coqa}bmoc iq—ukjoidsjr o`hsbhkidbq`‐8 *I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo i||okcbz O>i"

—Qir kh sh khsjbkg$ I Go}`ik }oaduqo mu}qsq hus hf jo} qjodd is BAR\II ?9…B qos chwk `r migq$ woks hus fh} i q`heo$ ikc wiq ebcki||oc mr BAR\II hdc-sb`o}q+ B ghs miae imhus 91jhu}q diso} wbsj swh hsjo} IIq wjh a}iqjoc bk `r moc+ Ifso} swh jhu}q hf qdoo|$ B nu`|oc hus hf moc ikc roi}kocfh} `h}o+ Sjis wiq swh cirq mofh}o sjo ahkfo}okao iasuiddr qsi}soc… … B jivo s}udr mook }haeosoc bksh i fhu}sjcb`okqbhk B kovo} ekow ozbqsoc+ B idwirq modbovoc B whudc oz|o}bokao sjo \}h`bqoq bk `r dbfo$ mus B kovo} oz|oasoc sjo` sh idd mo sj}hwk is `o hvo} hko qjh}s wooeokc+ B qshhc bk sjo `oosbkg }hh` wbsj 1$?<< c}ukequkco} sjo igo hf 1<$ ikc B jic ajbddq }ukkbkg chwk `r q|bko ikc soi}q bk `r oroq+ Dbssdo cbc B ekhw sjbq wiq sjo`o}o mogbkkbkg--sjo |}o-ahkfo}okao q|oieo}+ B qshhc hk `r ajib} ikc cikaoc sh Mhm @i}dor+ Ifso} idd$ sjbq wiqwjr B ai`o5 jhwovo}$ B wiq foodbkg vo}r ukah`fh}simdo ikc ukahhd… … … Sjo q|b}bsuidbsr bk sjo }hh` ahudcjivo ekhaeoc `o hvo}+ B shhe i qoahkc sh }oah`|hqo `rqodf$ sjok B doikoc hvo} sh `r kow f}bokc$ wbsj jbq g}ook$}oc ikc roddhw `hjiwe$ ikc qibc$ Sjbq bq bs+ Jo q`bdoc ikc dhheoc chwk is `o ikc nuqs qibc$ Roij$ ji-ji$iwoqh`o$ }bgjs8 B ekow is sjis `h`oks B jic fhukc sjis foodbkg B jic ajiqoc qbkao `r fb}qs c}bke> shsidiaao|sikao$ imqhduso dhvo ikc i f}ooch` sh ias qsu|bc… … … Sjo fb}qs mbs hf icvbao B }oaobvoc wiq vo}r uqofud+ Bwiq }bcbkg sj}hugj Isdiksi bk sjo miae hf i |baeu| s}uae$ ikc sjo hdc-sb`o}q$ wjh jic mook sh is doiqs sj}ooBAR\IIq mofh}o$ qibc$ Qir kh sh khsjbkg$ ch bs idd$ ikc qdoo| iq dbssdo iq |hqqbmdo… … … Mus mofh}o B ekow bs$ Bwiq hk sjo qsigo is i kbgjsadum fudd hf qhmo} |oh|do$ }ivbkg wbsj sjo C+N+ B qsh||oc ikc sjhugjs$ Aik sjbq mo }bgjs8Aik sjbq mo q|b}bsuid8 Aik qhm}bosr mo qh `uaj fuk8 B iqeoc Ghc fh} ik bksubsbvo sjhugjs h} coabqbhk$ hkdr sh mosj}hwk miae bksh }oidbsr mr i qhkg sjis qibc$ Qjus u| ikc cikao… … … Is sjo mogbkkbkg hf oiaj `oosbkg$ sjoq|oieo} whudc bks}hcuao jb` h} jo}qodf$ Jb$ B i`XXXXX ikc B i` ik idahjhdba$ ikc sjok sjo sjhuqikcq hf rhukg |oh|do whudc }osu}k wbsj$ Jb$ XXXXX$ wo dhvo rhu$ XXXXX$ dhsq ikc dhsq ikc dhsq ikc WJHHHHHDO M_KAJOQ)Wjhhh) *Sjbq wiq iaah`|ikboc mr i g}hu| |odvba sj}uqs shwi}c sjo q|oieo} wjbaj qoo`oc sh gos mbggo} diso} bksjo wooeokc"… … … Sjis bq sjo issbsuco B dofs wbsj+ Bf rhu sjbke rhu aik's oknhr dbfo bk qhm}bosr$ MXXXXXXXXXXs)

Sjo}o wiq qh `uaj |hwo}$ g}isbsuco ikc bkq|b}isbhk bk Isdiksi sjis B aik kovo} b`igbko jivbkg sjo coqb}o sh c}bke }osu}k sh `o… … … Wo i}o sjo kozs goko}isbhk hf hdc-sb`o}q$ sjo fusu}o hf sjbq Foddhwqjb|+ Wo$ rhukg |oh|do bkII i}hukc sjo wh}dc$ i}o hk fb}o wbsj }oahvo}r+‐ *Qir kh sh khsjbkg$ I Go}`ik }oaduqo mu}qsq hus hf jo} qjodd isBAR\II ?9 II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r =<9<"

  =9

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 23/63

—SJIS vhbao$ B sjhugjs+ Sjis'q sjo wh`ik hk sjo si|o) +++ … … Sjo wh`ik wjhqo vhbao B }oahgkb~oc wiqqbssbkg bk f}hks$ qji}bkg hk g}isbsuco … … B jic ghhqo mu`|q iq B dbqsokoc sh jo}5 B mogik sh qjieo$ ikc `rjoi}s |hukcoc bk `r ajoqs… … Bs wiq Qikcr… … … Ifso} sjo `oosbkg B su}koc sh `r q|hkqh} ikc `rf}bokc ikc qibc$ ‚B jivo sh side sh sjis wh`ik+‒… … … B shuajoc jo} i}`… … … qjo jic kh bcoi wjh Bwiq+ ‚B }oahgkb~oc rhu} vhbao$‒ B `ikigoc sh ajheo hus+ B jivo hko hf rhu} si|oq+ Rhu qivoc `r dbfo+‒…… … B c}iggoc hus hko hf `r mhzoq hf II q|oieo} si|oq+ B |}hmimdr jivo hvo} 9<< si|oq+ B wiq ghbkg shfbkc Qikcr'q si|o+ B jick's dbqsokoc sh bs bk roi}q$ mus B ekow bs wiq bk hko hf swh mhzoq+ B h|okoc sjo fb}qs mhz ikc qbgjoc+ Sjo si|oq wo}o |bdoc hk sh| hf oiaj hsjo} wbsj kh h}co} sh sjo`$ kh kois dbssdo }hwq+ Bekow B wiq bk fh} i dhkg ifso}khhk+ B }oiajoc bk ikc |uddoc hus sjo fb}qs si|o `r fbkgo}q shuajoc+ B su}koc bshvo}> Sjo si|o jic i mdiae ikc }oc dimod hk bs ikc sjo ki`o Qikcr wiq w}bssok ia}hqq bs wbsj i ciso+ *SJOVHBAO HK SJO SI\O  Ifso} id`hqs swh coaicoq$ qjo qsu`mdoq u|hk sjo wh`ik wjh qivoc jo} dbfo+

 II G}i|ovbko Khvo`mo} =<9<"

Ozs}ias f}h` —I Kow I||}hiaj sh \qrajhsjo}i|r bk Aj}hkba Idahjhdbq`$‐ mr\qrajbis}bqs C}+ W+C Qbdewh}sj @+C Nhu}kid Dikaos$ Nudr 9212>

—Sjoqo oz-idahjhdba `ok ikc wh`ok ku`mo} imhus hko jukc}oc is |}oqoks … … … @ikr a}oocq i}o }o|}oqoksoci`hkg sjo g}hu| ikc sjo g}oisoqs ji}`hkr |}ovibdq+ … … … Ahkqbco}bkg sjo |}oqokao hf sjo }odbgbhuq fiash}$ hko`bgjs oz|oas sh fbkc ik ukjoidsjr o`hsbhkidbq` ikc |}onucbao+ Sjbq bq khs sjo aiqo$ jhwovo}5‐ *I+I+ Ah`oq hf 

Igo$ i||okcbz O>i$ |igoq 1<3-1<?"

I vbasb` hf ukjoidsjr o`hsbhkidbq` qji}oq jo} qsh}r>

—Is sjo =<<? Bkso}kisbhkid Ahkvoksbhk$ ik hdc-sb`o} mogik sh sodd jbq qsh}r hkqsigo is sjo adhqbkg `oosbkg… …Iucbokao `o`mo}q aiddoc hus$ Wjh i}o rhu8 +++ … Sjo hdc-sb`o} ahudck's joi} wjis sjor wo}o qjhusbkg$ ikc jo mogik igibk+ Igibk sjo iucbokao qjhusoc is jb`$ Wjh i}o rhu8 Jo moai`o fduqso}oc ikc dhqs jbq s}ibk hf sjhugjs+

Jo ahudck's }ogibk bs$ ikc jo wiq uqjo}oc hff sjo qsigo+ B wiq qh qic sjis wo `bqqoc sjbq s}oiqu}oc `o`mo}'q qsh}rcuo sh fh}`idbsr hf bks}hcuasbhk+ \doiqo$ dos'q }o`o`mo} sh jhkhu} hu} hdc-sb`o}q ikc idd hu} `o`mo}q …‐ *Coi} G}i|ovbko$ fh}`udiba g}oosbkgq5 II G}i|ovbko Nudr =<9<"

Sjo jbqsh}r hf Qrkikhk soddq bsq hwk qsh}r+ Qrkikhk auds doico} Ajuae C+ wiq —qibc sh mo ik ic`b}oc q|oieo} is I+I+ `oosbkgq‐> jss|>((ok+wbeb|ocbi+h}g(wbeb(Qrkikhk 

Sjo Qrkikhk auds |}hvbcoc ovo}rsjbkg bsq `o`mo}q koococ$ f}h` `o}ajikcbqo shidahjhd f}oo cikaoq>

—Ovo}r roi} ah`|ikboq chkiso |}hcuasq sh sjo Qrkikhk Fhukcisbhk mr sjo ai}dhic> moof$ qjhoq$ fu}kbsu}o$ adhsjbkgikc mubdcbkg `iso}bidq+ *Hu} siz-ozo`|s |}bvbdogo gbvoq uq sjo }bgjs$ }oiddr$ sh juqsdo ghhcq ikc qo}vbaoq$ qirq

Coco}baj+ Ikc sjor aik w}bso bs hff+" Qrkikhk bq idqh sjo kisbhk'q qoahkc di}goqs qu||dbo} hf |}h`hsbhkidq|oabidsboq–sjhqo midd|hbks |okq$ widdosq ikc S-qjb}sq gbvok iwir iq `o}ajikcbqbkg gb``baeq+‐*Ajuae Coco}baj Qsbdd ]udoq Qrkikhk$ mus Khw Jo Jiq 9$1<< Qumnoasq ikc i #== @bddbhk O`|b}o -- Mr Mi}mi}iWbdebkq --\OH\DO `igi~bko'q i}ajbvo> Hashmo} 99$ 9276$ Vhd+ 6$ Kh+ 9?>jss|>((www+|oh|do+ah`(|oh|do(i}ajbvo(i}sbado(<$$=<<662:?$<<+js`d

—@ikr `ok fdhaeoc sh Qrkikhk'q idahjhd-f}oo cikaoq sh ch sjo Jhh|di wbsj iss}iasbvo Qrkikbso wh`ok--ifso} fb}qs |dirbkg Sjo Gi`o+‐ U\jhsh Dhq Ikgodoq Sb`oqPjss|>((sjoqs}ibgjsq+ah`(sjo|}hg}i`(qrkikhk-qsh}r=+js`

== 

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 24/63

Bq I+I+ mogbkkbkg sh su}k hk sh sjo qi`o s}bu`|jiks }hic iq sjo Wiqjbkgshkbikq8

Wiqjbkgshk `hvo`oks `iqq |umdba ovoksq>

—Dosq aiqs hu} oroq hvo} sjo G}i|ovbko |boao imhus sjo Wiqjbkgshkbikq ikc ozao}|s i fow qoksokaoq> ‚@iqq`oosbkg bk 9:39$ is Absr Jidd \i}e$ Kow Rh}e Absr$ iss}iasoc 3$<<< dbqsoko}q+ Q|oieo}q qshhc hk u|su}koc }u`eogq$‒ ‚S}bu`|jiks |i}icoq bk Mhqshk+ Jbqsh}ba Fikoubd Jidd ni``oc+‒ *Hvo}chko qodf-icvo}sbqbkg ‑ ozjbmbsbhkidbq`8 Ikrjhw bs idd qhukcq vo}r idahjhdba choqk‒s bs8"  … … … Sjo h}bgbkid qs}hkg ikc qb`|do g}hu| |u}|hqo wiq sjuq cbqqb|isoc bk f}ubsdoqq ahks}hvo}qr ikc cbvo}goks ib`q+" Ikc igibk$ ‚Qh`o Uhf sjo Wiqjbkgshkbikdhaid g}hu|qP cb||oc bksh sjob} s}oiqu}boq sh fbkikao sjob} hwk |umdbaisbhkq+ Sjo}o wiq kh hvo}idd ocbsh}bid |hdbar‐+*Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Iuguqs 923?+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo ?" 

Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq =<9< `iqq |umdba ovoks>

—FH_KCO]Q' Cir ah`oq hkao i roi} bk sjo absr hf Ie}hk$ bk sjo qsiso hf Hjbh+++ … … sjo moqs |i}s wiq hkQukcir$ wjok i |}haoqqbhk hf `hsh}aradoq woks sh C}+ Mhm'q g}ivoqbso+ Jo}o sjo}o wiq quaj ji}`hkr$ o`hsbhkq$q|b}bsuid iwi}okoqq ikc }oq|oas qjhwk fh} C}+ Mhm$ \oh|do ah`o f}h` idd hvo} sjo wh}dc sh sieo |i}s bk sjbqaodom}isbhk+ Diqs roi}$ is 7>1< I+@+$ sjo }hi}bkg hf `hsh}aradoq wiq idd B ahudc joi}+ Sjhuqikcq hf mbeoq--iddcbffo}oks qsrdoq$ `hcodq ikc ahdh}q--wo}o dbkoc u| bksh fhu} qbkgdo fbdo dbkoq sjis shhe u| sjo }icbuq hf hko absr mdhae$ koi} sjo _kbvo}qbsr hf Ie}hk+ Sjo |hdbao mdhaeoc hff sjo qs}oosq sh |}hvbco qifosr fh} sjo `hsh}aico ikc sh |}ovoks sjo mbeo |}haoqqbhk f}h` mobkg m}heok u|+ Iq sjo mbeoq |}haoococ sh sjo ao`oso}r$ |oh|do hk sjoqbcowideq ajoo}oc fh} uq+ Qh`o wivoc$ qh`o givo |oiao qbgkq$ ikc hsjo}q jodc u| qbgkq wbsj qdhgikq hk sjo`+ Sjo moqs qbgk B qiw wiq hk i fduh}oqaoks h}ikgo |hqso}mhi}c+ Bk di}go$ mhdc$ mdiae `i}eo} dosso}bkg$ bs qibc$ Ibk's bsg}ois sh mo qhmo}8 … … Iq wo i||}hiajoc sjo g}ivori}c$ sjo ao`oso}r fokao wiq dbkoc wbsj foddhw idahjhdbaqwjh ajoo}oc uq hk… … … Is C}+ Mhm'q g}ivoqbso$ mig|b|o}q |diroc I`i~bkg G}iao+… … Kozs$ ovo}rhko |us iahbk hf }oahvo}r hk sjo g}ivoqshko…‐ *Mbeoq ikc Mig|b|oq I }bco} bk sjo ikkuid Fhukco}q' Cir `hsh}aico fbkcqkow q|b}bsuidbsr bk Ie}hk5 I+I+ G}i|ovbko Nudr =<9<"

*Hvo}chko qodf-icvo}sbqbkg ‑ ozjbmbsbhkbq`8 Ikrjhw bs idd qhukcq vo}r idahjhdba choqk‒s bs8" *Mbdd W+ IIG}i|ovbko Iuguqs 923?+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo ?"

Coi} IIq> C}+ Mhm ikc B jivo i |}hmdo`+ Bk iasuidbsr$ II jiq i qah}o hf ‚fhukco}q$‒ `ok ikc wh`ok wbsjhuswjhqo q|oabid ahks}bmusbhkq II `bgjs kovo} jivo mook+ Mus qh`ojhw sjo sbsdo ‚fhukco} qoo`q sh jivo issiajocbsqodf id`hqs qhdodr sh C}+ Mhm ikc `o ‑ i |jokh`okhk cuo |o}ji|q sh sjo goko}id diae hf bkfh}`isbhk imhus hu} oi}dr cirq… … … Mus wo i}o mogbkkbkg sh iqe hu}qodvoq bf sjbq hvo}o`|jiqbq wbdd mo ghhc fh} II bk sjo dhkg }uk+Bq qh `uaj qoksb`oks fh} sjo ‚fhukco}q‒$ oksb}odr wbqo8 *II G}i|ovbko Hashmo} 9237+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo9<:"

 

—Wjbdo B sjike Ghc sjis B wiq |}bvbdogoc sh mo ik oi}dr `o`mo} hf I+I+$ B jhkoqsdr wbqj sjis sjo wh}c ‚fhukco}‒

ahudc mo odb`bkisoc f}h` I+I+ vhaimudi}r‐+ *Mbdd W$ dosso} 923?$ Iq Mbdd Qooq Bs |igo 67"

—Fh} sjbq }oiqhk C}+ Mhm ikc B jivo hfsok co|dh}oc mobkg aiddoc ah- fhukco}q moaiuqo quaj sbsdoq `ir a}oiso sjob`|}oqqbhk sjis wo |}ossr `uaj bkvoksoc$ qs}uasu}oc ikc q|}oic II idd mr hu}qodvoq+ Khsjbkg ahudc$ bk fias mofu}sjo} f}h` sjo s}usj+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko @i}aj 926<+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo =27"

I}o I+I+ `o`mo} h}gikbqoc idahjhd f}oo cikaoq$ qhabid ovoksq$ —q|b}bsuid‐ }os}oisq$quqsibkbkg sjo kowah`o}‒q wbsjc}iwid f}h` qhabosr ikc |}h`hsbkg ik ukjoidsjro`hsbhkid ikc qhabid co|okcokao hk sjo I+I+ `o`mo}q wjh h}gikbqo ikc issokc sjoqoovoksq8

  =1

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 25/63

—Qh hu} }udo bq khs sh ivhbc i |diao wjo}o sjo}o bq c}bkebkg$ bf wo jivo i dogbsb`iso }oiqhk fh} mobkg sjo}o+ Sjisbkaducoq mi}q$ kbgjsadumq$ cikaoq$ }oao|sbhkq$ woccbkgq$ ovok |dibk h}cbki}r wjhh|oo |i}sboq… … … … Bf rhu i}oi |o}qhk wjh wiksq sh ois bk i mi}$ mr idd `oikq gh idhkg+ Dos rhu} f}bokcq ekhw sjor i}o khs sh ajikgo sjob} jimbsqhk rhu} iaahuks+ Is i |}h|o} sb`o ikc |diao oz|dibk sh idd rhu} f}bokcq wjr idahjhd cbqig}ooq wbsj rhu+ Bf rhu chsjbq sjh}hugjdr$ fow |oh|do wbdd iqe rhu sh c}bke+ Wjbdo rhu wo}o c}bkebkg rhu wo}o wbsjc}iwbkg f}h` dbfo dbssdo mr dbssdo+ Khw rhu i}o gossbkg miae bksh sjo qhabid dbfo hf sjbq wh}dc+ Chk‒s qsi}s sh wbsjc}iw igibk nuqs moaiuqorhu} f}bokcq c}bke dbyuh}+‐ *Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq —Mbg Mhhe‐ |igo 9<9-9<="+

]hic sh ]oahvo}r II g}hu| *\dr`husj$ _E" Womqbso Cbi}r cisoq |igo *Qo|so`mo} =<9<">

F}bokcq hf Qahsdikc II bks}hcuaoQso| K ijoic bksh —o`hsbhkid qhm}bosr‐

wbsj Wirko M f}h` Qs \oso}qmu}g Fdh}bci _QI & Qoik C f}h` Wiqjbkgshk CA _QI+\ik`u}o Qs$ Cukcoo$ Qahsdikc+Hk F}b 1<sj Qo|s & Qis(Quk Has 9(=kc =<99+Ahqs ¡=< \]O }ogbqs}isbhk & ¡=? hk sjo cir+

Wodah`o sh II }oukbhk bk M}bqshdGhc wbddbkg sjo jhkhu}imdo `o`mo} fh} sjo \iabfba G}hu|$ dhq Ikgodoq$ bqah`bkg sh M}bqshd sh mo sjo |}bkab|do guoqs q|oieo} is sjo II }oukbhk93$9?$96$ Hashmo} =<99is sjo ahukabd Jhuqo$ M}bqshd

Qsisodbko ]os}oissjo ‚h}bgbkid‒ Whhcqshae hf I+I+

Wodah`o sh sjo hffbabid jh`o hf Qsisodbko ]os}oisCoao`mo} :$ 2$ 9<&99 =<99Qsisodbko ]os}ois$ Diq Vogiq _QI$ Coa =<99jss|>((www+qsisodbko}os}ois+h}g(

jss|>((www+}hicsh}oahvo}rg}hu|+h}g+ue(bkcoz+|j|8h|sbhk0ah`Xahksoks&siqe0vbow&bc01:&Bso`bc06:

Wo yuoqsbhk jhw `uaj |hwo} ikc bkfduokao I+I+ }odisoc muqbkoqq |oh|do jivo khwghs bk I+I8 S}icbsbhk soddq uq bs bq sb`o sh }ovo}qo sjo s}okc hf muqbkoqq mobkg chko bkI+I+ mofh}o shh `ikr `h}o |oh|do ikc I+I+ iq i wjhdo quffo}q sjo ahkqoyuokaoq hf bs+ Sjo}o koocq sh mo i qb`|do ikc ukah`|}h`bqbkg `oqqigo hf I+I+ S}icbsbhk$

ah`bkg f}h` idd wjh qo}vo bk sjo I+I+ qo}vbao qs}uasu}o ikc is idd dovodq+ Sjo I+I+ki`o koocq |}hsoasbhk+ Bs `ir mo quggoqsoc sjis I+I+ `o`mo}q mhrahss ikr`o}ajikcbqo |}hcuaoc mr husqbco okso}|}bqoq wjbaj h|o}iso ukco} I+I+ ki`o ikc shcbqahu}igo ikr bkcbvbcuid I+I+ `o`mo}q wjh `bquqo sjo I+I+ ki`o fh} sjob} 

 |o}qhkid gibk+ Bs `ir mo quggoqsoc `o`mo}q mhrahss |umdba ozjbmbsbhkbqs I+I+ ovoksq5ikc cbqahu}igo sjhqo wjh h}gikbqo sjo`+

  =3

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 26/63

—\umdba bdd wbdd ahudc qsuks hu} g}hwsj5 ovok m}bkg bs sh i qsikcqsbdd+‐*Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko$ Nuko 92??+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9?<"

—Wo aikkhs dokc sjo II ki`o$ ovok bkcb}oasdr$ sh hsjo} iasbvbsboq$ jhwovo} wh}sjr+ Bf wo ch qh wo qjidd moah`ojh|odoqqdr ah`|}h`bqoc ikc cbvbcoc+ Wo sjbke sjis II qjhudc hffo} bsq oz|o}bokao sh sjo wjhdo wh}dc fh} wjisovo} uqo aik mo `ico hf bs+ Mus khs bsq ki`o+ Khsjbkg aik mo `h}o ao}sibk+ *Mbdd W+ S}icbsbhk Sj}oo$ IIG}i|ovbko 923:$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 72-:<"

Wo yuoqsbhk wjosjo} ahksoks hf I+I+ dbso}isu}o bq khw mogbkkbkg sh mo bkfduokaocf}h` mr I+I+ }odisoc muqbkoqq+ Wjosjo} sjo mhhe —Sjo jh`o G}hu| Joi}smois hf I+I+‐ bq khs ahks}bmusbkg sh h}gikbqoc I+I+ g}hu|q wbsj i jbo}i}ajbaid |r}i`bc |hwo} qs}uasu}o$ mr jbgjdbgjsbkg sjo s}icbsbhkq covbiks Dbssdo ]hae \dik iq i doqqhk f}h`

oz|o}bokao$ mus wbsjhus `oksbhkbkg bs wiq S}icbsbhkq covbiks+ Wo yuoqsbhk wjosjo} sjbq mhhe qjhudc mo }ovbowoc ikc ocbsoc+

Doqqhkq f}h` oz|o}bokao$ S}icbsbhk kbko ikc `oosbkgq doc mr sjo I+I+ ah-fhukco}q>

S}icbsbhk Kbko *Dhkg fh}`">—Oiaj I+I+ g}hu| koocq sjo doiqs |hqqbmdo h}gikb~isbhk+ ]hsisbkg doico}qjb| bq sjo moqs+ Sjo q`idd g}hu| `ir odoasbsq qoa}osi}r$ sjo di}go g}hu| bsq }hsisbkg ah``bssoo ikc sjo g}hu|q hf i di}go `os}h|hdbsik i}oi sjob} aoks}id h} bkso}g}hu| ah``bssoo‐

Mbdd W$ Kow Rh}e 9212> —Sjor wo}o qs}uasu}oc sh sjo ozsoks sjis sjo}o wiq idwirq hko q|oieo} ikc Mbdd- `irmojidf ik jhu} oiaj - ikc sjok i dhkg ahffoo qoqqbhk$ i }oid gos shgosjo}+ Wo wo}o hfsok sjo}o sbdd 9= h‒adhae$ qsi}soc is

obgjs+…++ Is sjbq sb`o sjo}o wo}o kh 2<-cirq }oyub}o`oksq+ Kh mb}sjcirq ‑ kh }oahgkbsbhk wiq `ico bf rhu wo}oqhmo} i wooe h} i roi}$ Bf rhu fods rhu whudc dbeo sh q|oie bk i roi} h} bk i `hksj h} swh wooeq sjor dos rhu gos u|ikc q|oie$ ikc sjor cbck‒s sj}hw rhu hus bf rhu wo}o c}uke$ obsjo}+ Sjor fods bs wiq okahu}igbkg$ jh|bkg qh`o

wh}c whudc qsbae+‐ *]usj Jhae$ sjo fb}qs qoa}osi}r hf sjo Kow Rh}e Goko}id Qo}vbao Hffbao+ \iqq bs hk |igo =92"

C}+ Mhm$ Ie}hk> —Hdcsb`o}q }o`o`mo} oi}dr `oosbkgq iq mobkg |}ossr `uaj sjo qi`o iq sjor i}o khw$ wbsj i fow

ozao|sbhkq+ Sjo}o wiq kh ajib}|o}qhk h} qoa}osi}r sh bks}hcuao sjo q|oieo}+ Sj}hugj sjo `bc - 923<‒q$ bs wiq fodssjis g}ikc sbsdoq ikc fdhwo}r bks}hcuasbhkq `bgjs gh sh ik idahjhdba‒q joic…+ … … … Wo jic hu} qokqo hf ju`hu}$ mus fh} uq$ }oahvo}r wiq i dbfo - h}- coisj `isso}+ Kh} wiq sjo}o ikr adi||bkg+ Is sjis ebkc hf `oosbkg$

i||diuqo whudc jivo qoo`oc hus hf |diao‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo ==<-==9"

Bs aik mo khsoc sjis i quaaoqqfud ku`o}baid g}hwsj }iso fh} I+I bq khs i ghid bk bsqodf5`oikq ch khs nuqsbfr sjo okcq+ Q|b}bsuid g}hwsj jiq sh mo `ibksibkoc iq wodd+ Sjo audshf Qrkikhk wiq ku`o}baiddr vo}r quaaoqqfud uksbd bs ahddi|qoc$ iq wiq sjoWiqjbkgshkbik `hvo`oks+

—Hu} wjhdo gikg jic sieok hvo} sjo Qisu}cir kbgjs `oosbkg hf sjo Qiksi @hkbai I+I+ g}hu| … … ikc mubds bs u|f}h` bsq issokcikao hf sok |oh|do sh ik issokcikao hf imhus fh}sr fbvo h} fbfsr… … … Wo wo}o mubdcbkg qh`osjbkgkow ikc cbffo}oks‐+ *Ajuae C+ Qrkikhk auds doico}$" *F}h` sjo Coqe hf Nuik Doqokco> Jhw C}ug ImuqoS}ois`oks Su}kq bksh @bqs}ois`oks Mr Nuik O+ Doqokco - Qo|so`mo} 9:sj =<<2"jss|>((www+s}ois`oksqhdusbhkqkoswh}e+ah`(mdhg(bkcoz+|j|(=<<2(<2(9:(f}h`-sjo-coqe-hf-nuik-doqokco-jhw-c}ug-imuqo-s}ois`oks-su}kq-bksh-`bqs}ois`oks(

  =?

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 27/63

—Wo jic i wodd cofbkoc |u}|hqo5 sh fhauq hk sjo ahksoks hf hu} Miqba Sozs ikc b`|}hvo sjo offoasbvokoqq hf hu} Foddhwqjb|… … …Hkdr i ahu|do hf —hdc sb o}q‐ oz|}oqqoc sjob} ahkao}k … …+ …+ B wbqj B ahudc cbg sjhqo hdc

quaeo}q u| ikc dos sjo` qoo wjis ji||okq is hu} `oosbkgq ikc wjis sjo `o`mo}q hf hu} G}hu| ch moswook`oosbkgq… …+ … Sjhqo wjh ieo u| hu} G}hu| i}o vo}r iasbvo bk siebkg sjo oqqigo hf sjo Mbg Mhhe bkshsjhqo |diaoq wjo}o quffo}bkg idahjhdbaq wbkc u| qooebkg qjodso} ikc jod|+ Wo s}r sh gos sh sjo` mofh}o sjor moah`o ‚cbqauqqbhkb~oc+‒… … … Qh wjis wo jivo bk Ciddiq bq i g}hu| hf idahjhdbaq wjh s}r sh o`udiso sjo `ikwjh wiq hu} bkq|b}isbhk+ I q|i}e sjis wiq sj}hwk hff sjis q|b}bsuid mhkfb}o$ Nho @aY+$ dikcoc bk Ciddiq$ Soziq ikcbgkbsoc ikhsjo} q|b}bsuid mhkfb}o wjbaj sj}hwq hf `ikr q|i}eq ikc jiq bgkbsoc ikc bq bgkbsbkg hsjo} q|b}bsuid mhkfb}oq i}hukc sjo wh}dc+ Bs qoo`q sh `o sjbq G}hu| hf Mbg Mhhe h}boksoc idahjhdbaq wiq coqsbkoc sh mo oziasdrwjis bs jiq moah`o… …‐ Adbff M+ \}b`i}r \u}|hqo G}hu| hf I+I+ *Ciddiq"jss|>((www+eoddrfck+ah`(MbgMhheQsucr(mmqsucrg}hu|q+js`

—Wo jivo kh chas}bko sjis jiq sh mo `ibksibkoc+ Wo jivo kh `o`mo}qjb| sjis jiq sh mo okdi}goc+ Wo jivo khiusjh}bsr sjis jiq sh mo qu||h}soc+ Wo jivo kh |}oqsbgo$ |hwo} h} |}bco sjis jiq sh mo qisbqfboc+‐ Mbdd W+ *Ahkao|s9=$ wi}}iksr Fbvo"

Sjo}o i||oi}q sh mo i `bqahkao|sbhk mr qh`o bk I+I+ sjis qo}vbao ah``bssooq hugjskobsjo} okch}qo kh} h||hqo |}bviso okso}|}bqo odqowjo}o bk I+I+$ moaiuqo bs bq ikhusqbco bqquo+ Sjbq bgkh}oq S}icbsbhk hko$ oiaj bq |i}s hf sjo wjhdo+ \}bviso okso}|}bqobkqbco I+I+ ikc sjo `bquqo hf sjo I+I+ ki`o husqbco I+I+ i}o khs husqbco bqquoq+ Sjorvbhdiso S}icbsbhk+ I+I+ q|hkqh}qjb| bq khs ik husqbco bqquo bs bq |i}s hf sjo I+I+

 |}hg}i`+

—Wo i}o i|s sh wi}| sjo s}icbsbhkid bcoi hf ‚|}bkab|doq mofh}o |o}qhkidbsboq‒ i}hukc sh quaj i |hbks sjis sjo}o whudc mo kh ‚|o}qhkidbsr‒ bk doico}qjb| is idd+ Sjbq whudc b`|dr }isjo} fiaodoqq iush`ishkq s}rbkg sh |doiqo ovo}rmhcr}ogi}cdoqq+‐ *Ahkao|s BZ"

Quaj wi}|bkg hf sjo s}icbsbhkid bcoi hf ‚|}bkab|doq mofh}o |o}qhkidbsboq‒ i||oi}q shdoic sh i `bqahkao|sbhk sjis S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}q qjhudc khs mo ki`oc bk bkso}kidcbqauqqbhkq hk quaj `isso}q+ Qeb}sbkg i}hukc quaj bqquoq `o}odr doicq sh |hdbsbaqhusqbco ah``bssoo `oosbkgq$ ukiaahuksimbdbsr ikc bkoffoasbvo iasbhk+ Adoi}drS}icbsbhk Swodvo bq khs sjo}o sh |}hvbco i ahkvokboks ikhkr`bsr adhie fh} sjhqo wjhvbhdiso S}icbsbhkq$ mus sh |}hsoas sjo foddhwqjb|+ Bs aik mo qook f}h` wi}}iksr fbvo sjisS}icbsbhk vbhdish}q kooc sh mo bcoksbfboc bk h}co} sh offoasbvodr i||dr sjo |}bkab|doq hf wi}}iksboq fbvo ikc qbz+

—\}bvisodr$ jhwovo} wo aik bkfh}` S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}q sjis sjor i}o hus hf h}co} + Wjok sjor |o}qbqs$ wo aik

fhddhw u| mr uqbkg quaj hsjo} }oqhu}aoq hf |o}quiqbhk iq wo `ir jivo$ ikc sjoqo i}o hfsok ahkqbco}imdo… … …Sjbq ah`mbkisbhk hf ahukso} fh}aoq aik mo vo}r cbqahu}igbkg sh vbhdish}q h} whudc mo vbhdish}q+ _kco} sjoqo

ahkcbsbhkq sjor qhhk fbkc sjob} covbisbhkq sh mo uk|}hfbsimdo h} ukwbqo… … …Qh`o covbish}q jivo quffo}oc }isjo} qovo}o |o}qhkid a}bsbabq` f}h` bkcbvbcuid I+I+ `o`mo}q$ ikc sjbq bq sh mo co|dh}oc+ Jhwovo}$ sjbq bq kh }oiqhk fh} uq sh qsh| }o`bkcbkg idd ahkao}koc hf sjo ukcoqb}imbdbsr hf m}oiebkg I+I+ S}icbsbhkq mofh}o sjo oksb}o |umdba+ Bs aik mo qibc sjis sjo cbffbaudsboq hf sjhqo wjh ahks}ivoko sjo S}icbsbhkq i}o ajbofdr s}humdoq hf sjob} hwk `iebkg+*Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+

=6

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 28/63

Iccbsbhkid ozs}iasq f}h` I+I+ dbso}isu}o>

—Sj}hugj sjo `bc - 923<‒q$ bs wiq fods sjis g}ikc sbsdoq ikc fdhwo}r bks}hcuasbhkq `bgjs gh sh ik idahjhdba‒q joic+‐+ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc hdc Sb`o}q |igo ==9"

—Chk‒s i||diuc `o+ Chk‒s i||diuc ikr idahjhdba‐*C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc hdc Sb`o}q |igo ==9"

—Bs bq s}icbsbhkid bk Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq sjis wo ch khs `ieo q|ooajoq+‐*Mbdd W+ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |igo ?="

—II Bq Khs Mbg Muqbkoqq‐ mr Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Khvo`mo} 92?<>—Hu} S}icbsbhkq i}o qos chwk hk |i|o}+ Mus sjor wo}o w}bssok fb}qs bk hu} joi}sq+ Fh} oiaj hf uq ekhwq$bkqsbkasbvodr$ B sjbke$ sjis II bq khs hu}q sh ch wbsj iq wo |doiqo+ Wo i}o mus ai}osieo}q sh |}oqo}vo sjo q|b}bsuidyuidbsr hf hu} Foddhwqjb|5 eoo| bs wjhdo fh} sjhqo wjh wbdd ah`o ifso} uq ikc jivo kooc hf wjis jiq mook qhgoko}huqdr mook gbvok sh uq… … … Qh sjo jhu} jiq ah`o wjok rhu `uqs sieo sjoqo sjbkgq bksh rhu} hwkeoo|bkg+ Wo iqe sjis rhu gui}c sjo` wodd$ fh} sjo fusu}o hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq `ir `uaj co|okc hk jhw rhu`ibksibk ikc qu||h}s sjoqo dbfo - gbvbkg i}`q hf qo}vbao+‐ *Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9=3"

—Sjor fh}gos sjis$ cu}bkg sjob} c}bkebkg cirq$ |}oqsbgo ikc sjo iajbovo`oks hf wh}dcdr i`mbsbhk wo}o sjob}  |}bkab|do ib`q+ Sjor ch khs }oidb~o sjis$ mr m}oiebkg sjob} ikhkr`bsr$ sjor i}o ukahkqabhuqdr |u}qubkg sjhqo hdcikc |o}bdhuq bdduqbhkq hkao `h}o+ Sjor fh}gos sjis sjo eoo|bkg hf hko‒q ikhkr`bsr hfsok `oikq sjo qia}bfbao hf hko‒q coqb}o fh} |hwo}$ |}oqsbgo$ ikc `hkor+ Sjor ch khs qoo sjis bf sjoqo qs}bvbkgq moai`o goko}id bk I+I+$ sjoahu}qo hf hu} wjhdo jbqsh}r whudc mo ajikgoc5 sjis wo whudc mo qhwbkg sjo qoocq hf hu} hwk coqs}uasbhk‐+ *MbddW+$ Iq Mbdd Qooq Bs$ |igo 92:"

—Sjor sodd uq sjis wo idahjhdbaq i}o sjo mbggoqs }isbhkidbqo}q bk sjo wh}dc5 sjis fh}sbfboc wbsj sjo ozauqo wo i}ochbkg g}ois sjbkgq fh} II wo aik$ sj}hugj m}heok ikhkr`bsr$ }oqu`o hu} hdc ikc cbqiqs}huq |u}qubs hf |o}qhkid |hwo} ikc |}oqsbgo$ |umdba jhkhu}q$ ikc `hkor ‑ sjo qi`o b`|diaimdo u}goq sjis wjok f}uqs}isoc hkao aiuqoc uq shc}bke5 sjo qi`o fh}aoq sjis i}o shcir }b||bkg sjo gdhmo i|i}s is bsq qoi`q+ @h}ohvo}$ sjor `ieo adoi} sjis okhugjq|oasiaudi} ikhkr`bsr m}oieo}q ahudc qh`ocir ai}}r hu} wjhdo qhabosr chwk bksh sjis }ubkhuq coic okc wbsjsjo`+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Nikui}r 92??+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo =96"

—Bf$ sj}hugj okhugj ikhkr`bsr di|qoq$ wo fbkiddr aiuqoc sjo |}oqq$ sjo |umdba$ ikc hu} idahjhdba |}hq|oasqsjo`qodvoq sh whkco} imhus hu} `hsbvoq$ wo‒c qu}odr dhqo sjbq |}baodoqq iqqos5 ikc idhkg wbsj bs$ ahuksdoqq |}hq|oasbvo `o`mo}q+ Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq whudc khs sjok mo gossbkg `h}o ghhc |umdbabsr5 bs whudc mo gossbkgdoqq ikc wh}qo+ Sjo}ofh}o sjo jikcw}bsbkg hk sjo widd bq adoi}+ Moaiuqo `hqs hf uq aik id}oicr qoo bs$ ikc moaiuqosjo }oqs hf uq qhhk wbdd$ B‒` fuddr ahkfbcoks sjis kh quaj ci}e cir wbdd ovo} fidd u|hk hu} qhabosr‐ *Mbdd W+ II

G}i|ovbko Nikui}r 92??+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo =97"

—Wo okvbqigoc sjo w}bsbkg hf i ukbfh}` I+I+ dbso}isu}o$ sjo covodh|`oks hf i qhukc |umdba }odisbhkq |hdbar+‐Mbdd W+ 926= *Ahkao|s B"

—Hu} dbso}isu}o bq i |}bkab|do `oikq mr wjbaj I+I+ }oahvo}r$ ukbsr$ ikc qo}vbao i}o fiabdbsisoc‐Mbdd W+ 926= *Ahkao|s ZB"+

=7

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 29/63

—Qu||hqo$ fh} bkqsikao$ sjis cu}bkg sjo diqs swoksr fbvo roi}q$ II jic kovo} |umdbqjoc ikr qsikci}c dbso}isu}o ‑ kh mhheq$ kh |i`|jdosq+ Wo kooc dbssdo b`igbkisbhk sh qoo sjis mr khw hu} `oqqigo whudc mo jh|odoqqdr gi}mdoc+ Hu} }odisbhkq wbsj `ocbabko ikc }odbgbhk whudc jivo moah`o i qji`mdoq+ Sh idahjhdbaq goko}iddr wo whudc shcir mo i

 nheo ikc sjo |umdba whudc jivo sjhugjs uq i }bccdo+ Wbsjhus bsq dbso}isu}o$ II whudc ao}sibkdr jivo mhggoc chwkbk i wodso} hf ahks}hvo}qr ikc cbqukbsr‐ Mbdd W+ *II G}i|ovbko @ir 92635 Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 13:"

 —++Shgosjo} wbsj ku`mo}q hf f}bokcq$ B coabco sh sieo i m}bof coshu}+ Wo |bae hu} |isj ikc ji||bdr |dukgo idhkg bs+Odisocdr$ qh`omhcr qhhk qirq$ ‚@irmo wo‒dd qhhk fbkc ghdc hk sh| hf sjis `huksibk+‒ Sjok sh hu} i`i~o`oks woch qs}beo ghdc ‑ khs kuggosq bk sjo qs}oi`q$ mus fuddr `bksoc ahbkq+ Sjo joicq hf sjoqo ahbkq oiaj coadi}o$ ‚Sjbq bq |u}o ghdc ‑ swoksr-fhu} ai}isq+‒ Qu}odr$ wo sjbke$ sjbq bq sjo }owi}c fh} hu} |isboks |dhccbkg miae sjo}o bk sjoovo}diqsbkg m}bgjskoqq hf sjo Jbgjwir+ Qhhk$ sjhugj$ wo mogbk sh khsbao sjo wh}cq hk sjo sibdq hf sjo ahbkq$ ikc wojivo qs}ikgo fh}omhcbkgq> Qh`o |boaoq ai}}r }isjo} iss}iasbvo bkqa}b|sbhkq+ ‚B i` \hwo}$‒ ‚B i` Iaadib`‒ ‚B i`Woidsj‒ ‚B i` ]bgjsohuqkoqq‒ sjor qir$ mus hsjo}q qoo` vo}r qs}ikgo+ fh} ozi`|do> ‚B i` sjo @iqso} ]iao‒ ‚B i`sjo Mokofiash}‒ ‚B i` Ghhc Aiuqoq‒ ‚ B i` Ghc‒ Sjbq bq vo}r |u~~dbkg+ Kovo}sjodoqq wo |haeos sjo`+ Mus kozsah`o sjo }oid qjhaeo}q+ Sjor }oic> ‚B‒` \}bco‒ ‚B‒` ]ovokgo‒ ‚ B‒` Cbqukbsr‒ B‒` Ajihq‒ Sjok wo su}k u| i qbkgdoahbk- nuqs hko ‑ wjbaj coadi}oq> ‚Sjbq bq sjo covbd jb`qodf+‒ Qh`o hf uq i}o jh}}bfboc ikc wo a}r$ ‚Sjbq bq fhhd‒q

ghdc$ ikc sjbq bq i fhhd‒q |i}icbqo… … …… … Jo}o wo}o sjo qi`o hdc ghidq - |hwo}$ fi`o$ i||diuqo+ Moqbcoq B jic sjo moqs idbmb ekhwk ‑ sjo q|b}bsuididbmb+ Sjo fias sjis B }oiddr cbc jivo i q|b}bsuid hmnoasbvo idwirq `ico sjbq usso} khkqokqo qoo` |o}foasdr }bgjs+ Bahudck‒s sodd i ghhc ahbk f}h` i mic hko5 bs wiq q|b}bsuid ghdc - m}baebkg is bsq wh}qs+ B qjidd fh}ovo} }og}os sjoci`igo B cbc sh sjo |oh|do i}hukc `o+ Bkcooc$ B qsbdd s}o`mdo wjok B }oidb~o wjis B `bgjs jivo chko sh II ikc shbsq fusu}o+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Nuko 92695 Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s \igo =?6"

—Mus II ukbsr aikkhs iush`isbaiddr |}oqo}vo bsqodf+ Dbeo |o}qhkid }oahvo}r$ wo qjidd idwirq jivo sh wh}e sh`ibksibk bs+ Jo}o$ shh$ wo qu}odr kooc jhkoqsr$ ju`bdbsr$ h|ok-`bkcockoqq$ ukqodfbqjkoqq ikc$ imhvo idd---vbgbdikao+ Qh wo wjh i}o hdco} bk I+I+ mog rhu wjh i}o kowo} sh |hkco} ai}ofuddr sjo oz|o}bokao wo jivo id}oicrjic hf s}rbkg sh dbvo ikc wh}e shgosjo}+ Wo whudc dbeo oiaj I+I+ sh moah`o nuqs iq `uaj iwi}o hf sjhqocbqsu}mbkg sokcokaboq wjbaj okcikgo} uq iq i wjhdo iq jo bq ahkqabhuq hf sjhqo |o}qhkid cofoasq wjbaj sj}oisok jbqhwk qhm}bosr ikc |oiao hf `bkc+ Fh} wjhdo `hvo`oksq jivo$ mofh}o khw$ ghko hk mokco}q$ shh)‐*Mbdd W+ I+I+ S}icbsbhk$ Jhw bs covodh|oc \igo 3+"

=:

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 30/63

 

Qoasbhk Sj}oo

Sjo iksbsjoqbq sh Mbg Mhhe Q|hkqh}qjb|> Ozi`|doq hf I+I+ Q|hkqh}qjb|$uqbkg yuhsisbhkq f}h` I+I+ |umdbqjoc dbso}isu}o+

O}kbo G+ }oaiddq Mbdd W ikc C}+ Mhm>

—++mus bs wiq idd quggoqsbhk$ jo‒c kovo} gbvo ik h}co}$ Mhm wiq sjo qi`o wir+‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q

 |igo ==6"+

I+I+ q|hkqh}qjb| - I fow yuhsoq hf C}+ Mhm$ I+I+‒q ah-fhukco}> 

—++wjisovo} rhu ch$ wjhovo} rhu side sh$ chk‒s |uqj‐……‐Chk‒s |uqj+ Nuqs sodd sjo` sjis rhu fhukc rhu}qodf bkI+I+ ikc jhw g}isofud rhu i}o ikc jhw sjbkgq jivo ajikgoc+ Side imhus rhu}qodf+ Sjok sodd sjo` —Bf rhu koocjod|$ wiks jod|$ Nhbk I+I+‐ * C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo =:3"—Chk‒s i||diuc `o+ Chk‒s i||diuc ikr idahjhdba‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo ==9"—B chk‒s modbovo B jivo ikr }bgjs sh gos ahaer imhus gossbkg qhmo}+ Bs bq hkdr sj}hugj Ghc‒q g}iao sjis B cbc bs‐ *C}+Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc hdc Sb`o}q |igo ==9—Bf rhu q|oie fh} `h}o sjik 9? `bkusoq rhu‒}o ghbkg sh }o|ois rhu}qodf+‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo==3"—Bf sjo q|oieo} choqk‒s qir oziasdr wjis rhu sjbke jo hugjs sh qir$ chk‒s a}bsbab~o+ Jo `ir mo qirbkg oziasdr wjissjo `ik bk sjo miae }hw wiksq sh joi}+‐ *C}$ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc hdc Sb`o}q |igo =7="—Mus rhu wisaj wjis sjo `ik choq iq wodd iq wjis jo qirq‐ *C}$ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc hdc Sb`o}q |igo ==?"—Iq fbkiddr oz|}oqqoc ikc hffo}oc$ sjor USjo Swodvo Qso|qP i}o qb`|do bk dikguigo$ |dibk bk `oikbkg+ Sjor i}oidqh wh}eimdo mr ikr |o}qhk jivbkg i qbkao}o coqb}o sh hmsibk ikc eoo| qhm}bosr+ Sjo }oqudsq i}o |}hhf+ Sjob} qb`|dbabsr ikc wh}eimbdbsr i}o quaj sjis kh q|oabid bkso}|}osisbhkq$ ikc ao}sibkdr kh }oqo}visbhkq$ jivo ovo} mookkoaoqqi}r‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo ==7"—Hu} Swodvo qso|q$ wjok qb``o}oc chwk sh sjo diqs$ }oqhdvo sjo`qodvoq bksh sjo wh}cq ‚dhvo‒ ikc ‚qo}vbao‒+ Woukco}qsikc wjis dhvo bq$ ikc wo ukco}qsikc wjis qo}vbao bq+ Qh dos‒q moi} sjoqo swh sjbkgq bk `bkc+‐ *C}+ Mhm ikcsjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo 11:"—Is jbq sb`o ‑ Nikui}r ‑ 923< jo wiqk‒s `iebkg rhu gos hus hf moc sh |}ir hk rhu} ekooq$ sh |}ir wbsj rhu$ B‒`khs qu}o sjis whudc jivo wh}eoc shh wodd wbsj `o+‐ *Nhjk Q+" *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdcsb`o}q |igoq =76"—++bs moai`o i yuoqsbhk hf ich|sbkg sjis wjbaj whudc wh}e ikc }onoasbkg sjis wjbaj whudc khs‐+ *Mbdd W+ —\iqq bsHk |igo 979-97="—S}r sh fbkc rhu} hwk Ghc ‑ Iq  rhu ukco}qsikc Jb`+‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdcsb`o}q |igo =:9"—C}+ Mhm qibc rhu jic sh q|hkqh} rhu}qodf iq wodd+…+ Sjis rhu qjhudc qsikc miae khw ikc sjok ikc dhhe is

rhu}qodf ikc qh}s hf diugj$ sjok jod| rhu}qodf+‐ *Hqai} W$ Ie}hk II g}hu| `o`mo}+ *C}$ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc hdcSb`o}q |igo ==6"I }oahddoasbhk mr C}$ Mhm‒q qhk$ Q`bssr> —Mus Q`bssr khsoc$ jbq fisjo} cbck‒s ah`o hk qs}hkg imhus |jbdhqh|jr h} }odbgbhk$ moaiuqo jo cbck‒s wiks sh qai}o sjo` hff+‐ * C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo 19<"

=2

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 31/63

C}+ Mhm‒q `o`h}bid>

—C} Mhm‒q wiq sjo ju`bdbsr sjis coadbkoq idd jhkhu}q$ sjo bksog}bsr sjis m}hheq kh ah`|}h`bqo5 jbq wiq i covhsbhksh `ik ikc Ghc wjbaj bk m}bgjs ozi`|do wbdd qjbko idwirq+ *C]+ MHM BK @O@H]B_@$ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 9<"—Vbqbsbkg sjo g}ivoq hf C}+ Mhm ikc Ikko$ Mbdd fhukc kh g}ikc `o`h}bid$ kh `oksbhk hf I+I+ ‑ nuqs i qb`|doqshko‐ *C}$ Mhm ikc Sjo Ghhc Hdcsb`o}q |igo 113"

I fow yuhsoq hk I+I q|hkqh}qjb| mr II‒q ah-fhukco} Mbdd W+ *C}+ Mhm‒q Q|hkqh}"

Wjbdo B sjike Ghc sjis B wiq |}bvbdogoc sh mo ik oi}dr `o`mo} hf I+I+$ B jhkoqsdr wbqj sjis sjo wh}c ‚fhukco}‒

ahudc mo odb`bkisoc f}h` I+I+ vhaimudi}r‐+ *Mbdd W$ dosso} 923?$ Iq Mbdd Qooq Bs |igo 67"—Bs bq s}icbsbhkid bk Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq sjis wo ch khs `ieo q|ooajoq+‐ *Mbdd W+ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |igo ?="—]oahvo}r mobkg i dbfo ‑h} coisj `isso} fh} `hqs idahjhdbaq$ bs moai`o i yuoqsbhk hf ich|sbkg sjis wjbaj whudcwh}e ikc }onoasbkg sjis wjbaj whudc khs+ Fh} ozi`|do> —Sjo |}bkab|do hf igg}oqqbvo ovikgodbq` qh |}h`bkoks bksjo Hzfh}c G}hu| jic sh mo c}h||oc…… Oz|o}bokao qjhwoc sjis sjbq |}bkab|do …… whudc qodch` shuajkou}hsbaq hf hu} juo……+ Idahjhdbaq wjh sideoc shh `uaj hk |umdba |disfh}`q wo}o dbeodr sh moah`o bkfdisoc ikcgos c}uke igibk‐…++‐Wjok sjo wh}c ‚imqhduso‒ wiq |us bk f}hks hf sjoqo iss}bmusoq$ sjor obsjo} su}koc |oh|do iwir mr sjo jukc}ocq h} givo i so`|h}i}r q|b}bsuid bkfdisbhk }oqudsbkg bk ahddi|qo…++ Bs wiq cbqahvo}oc sjis idd fh}`q hf aho}abhk$ mhsj cb}oas ikc bkcb}oas$ jic sh mo c}h||oc+ Wo fhukc sjis ‚ajoaebkg‒ bk sjo jikcq hf i`isou}q shh hfsok}oqudsoc bk a}bsbabq`$ ikc sjis }oqudsoc bk }oqoks`oks$ wjbaj bq |}hmimdr sjo `hqs qo}bhuq |}hmdo` sjo ivo}igoidahjhdba bq s}humdoc wbsj…++ Wo aik kovo} qir sh ikrhko *h} bkqbkuiso" sjis jo `uqs ig}oo sh hu} fh}`udi‐… —Sjoisjobqs `ir qsikc u| bk ik I+I+ `oosbkg cokrbkg Ghc$ ros }o|h}sbkg jhw jo jiq mook jod|oc bk hsjo} wirq‐…++‐wo `ieo kh }odbgbhuq }oyub}o`oks hf ikrhko…++ Bk sjbq is`hq|jo}o sjo h}sjhchz$ ukh}sjhchz$ ikc sjo ukmodbovo} `bz ji||bdr ikc uqofuddr shgosjo} ……*Mbdd W+ —\iqq bs Hk |igo 979-97="—I vo}r shugj-`bkcoc |}hq|oas wiq sieok sh jbq fb}qs I+I+ `oosbkg+ Sjo fb}qs q|oieo} `inh}oc hk jbq hwk c}bkebkg

 |isso}k+ Sjo |}hq|oas qoo`oc b`|}oqqoc+ Sjo kozs swh q|oieo}q *h} `irmo doasu}o}q" sjo`oc sjob} sideq hk ‚Ghc iq B ukco}qsikc Jb`‒+ Sjbq ahudc jivo mook ghhc shh mus bs ao}sibkdr wiqk‒s+ Sjo s}humdo wiq sjob} issbsuco$ sjo wirsjor |}oqoksoc sjob} oz|o}bokao+ Sjor cbc hh~o i}}hgikao+ Bk fias sjo fbkid q|oieo} ghs fi} hvo}mhi}c hk qh`o hf jbq |o}qhkid sjohdhgbaid ahkvbasbhkq+ Wbsj |o}foas fbcodbsr$ mhsj wo}o }o|oisbkg `r |o}fh}`ikao hf roi}q mofh}o+ Yubsoukq|heok$ ros b`|dbabs bk ovo}rsjbkg sjor qibc$ wiq sjo qi`o bcoi - —Fhdeq dbqsok sh uq+ Wo jivo sjo hkdr s}uo m}ikchf II ‑ ikc rhu‒c mosso} gos bs+ Sjo kow |}hq|oas qibc jo‒c jic bs ‑ ikc jo jic+ Jbq q|hkqh} |}hsoqsoc sjis sjbqwiqk‒s }oid I+I+ Mus bs wiq shh diso5 khmhcr ahudc shuaj jb` ifso} sjis+ Jo idqh jic sjo |o}foas fb}qs adiqq idbmb fh} ros ikhsjo} mokco}+ Wjok diqs joi}c f}h`$ ik oi}dr i||hbks`oks wbsj sjo ukco}sieo} qoo`oc |}hmimdo‐ *Mbdd W+II G}i|ovbko I|}bd 92695 Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo =?="—C}bkeo}q whudc khs sieo ikr |}oqqu}o bk ikr fh}`$ ozao|sbkg Nhjk Mi}dorah}k jb`qodf+ Sjor idwirq jic sh mo doc$khs |uqjoc+ Sjor whudc khs iaao|s sjo |}bkab|do hf ‚soi` gubcikao‒ fh} sjob} hwk |o}qhkid dbvoq+ Bs wiq shhiusjh}bsi}bik fh} sjo`+ Bk hsjo} }oq|oasq wo jic sh `ieo jiqso qdhwdr+ Wjok fb}qs ahksiasoc `hqs idahjhdbaq nuqswiksoc sh fbkc qhm}bosr$ khsjbkg odqo+ *Mbdd W+ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 73"+

—Is S Jok}r‒q jhuqo obgjsook hf sjo Ie}hk idahjhdbaq dbqsokoc qshdbcdr sh hu} |}h|hqidq…++ Sjo `h`oks wo wo}osj}hugj$ sjhqo idahjhdbaq }oiddr cbc wh}e uq hvo}…+ sjor }onoasoc sjo bcoi hf `bqqbhki}boq+ \ibc wh}eo}q$ sjor qibc$whudc }ubk hu} ghhc wbdd wbsj idahjhdbaq5 sjbq whudc mo qjoo} }ubk…… Sjob} ahksoksbhk sjis ghbkg bksh mbg muqbkoqq ikc jb}bkg |ibc `bqqbhki}boq whudc coqs}hr uq su}koc hus sh mo imqhdusodr ah}}oas+‐ *Mbdd W+ II ah`oq hf Igo |igo 93?-936"—Sjor fh}gos sjis cu}bkg sjob} c}bkebkg cirq |}oqsbgo ikc sjo iajbovo`oks hf wh}dcdr i`mbsbhk wo}o sjob} |}bkab|doib`q+ Sjor ch khs }oidb~o sjis mr m}oiebkg sjob} ikhkr`bsr$ sjor i}o ukahkqabhuqdr |u}qubkg sjhqo hdc ikc |o}bdhuqbdduqbhkq hkao `h}o+ Sjor fh}gos sjis sjo eoo|bkg hf hko‒q ikhkr`bsr hfsok `oikq i qia}bfbao hf hko‒q coqb}o fh}  |hwo}$ |}oqsbgo$ ikc `hkor+ Sjor ch khs qoo sjis bf sjoqo qs}bvbkgq moai`o goko}id bk I+I+$ sjo ahu}qo hf hu} wjhdo jbqsh}r whudc mo ajikgoc5 sjis wo whudc mo qhwbkg sjo qoocq hf hu} hwk coqs}uasbhk iq i qhabosr+‐ *Mbdd W+Dosso}$ 92?: Iq Mbdd Qooq Bs |igo 92:"

1<

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 32/63

S}icbsbhk Odovok> —Sjbq s}icbsbhk bq i ahkqsiks ikc |}iasbaid }o`bkco} sjis |o}qhkid i`mbsbhk jiq kh |diao bk I+I+Bk bs oiaj `o`mo} moah`oq ik iasbvo gui}cbik hf hu} foddhwqjb|‐ * Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 9:7"S}icbsbhk Swodvo> — Wo qb`|dr ahudc khs iffh}c sh sieo sjo ajikao hf dossbkg qodf ‑i||hbksoc `o`mo}q |}oqoksbkgsjo`qodvoq iq `oqqbijq }o|}oqoksbkg I+I+ mofh}o sjo wjhdo |umdba+… @hvoc mr sjo q|b}bs hf ikhkr`bsr$ wo s}r shgbvo u| hu} kisu}id coqb}oq fh} |o}qhkid cbqsbkasbhk iq I+I+ `o`mo}q mhsj i`hkg foddhw idahjhdbaq ikc mofh}o sjogoko}id |umdba‐…++ Wo i}o qu}o sjis ju`bdbsr$ oz|}oqqoc mr ikhkr`bsr$ bq sjo g}oisoqs qifogui}c sjis IdahjhdbaqIkhkr`huq aik ovo} jivo+‐ *Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 929-92="

Fh} jbq qo}vbao sh qhabosr bk i dbfo q|oks bk qodfdoqq cocbaisbhk sh sjo koocq hf sjhqowjh quffo} f}h` idahjhdbq`$ Mbdd W+ wiq kh`bkisoc sh }oaobvo qbz jhkh}i}r ukbvo}qbsrcog}ooq$ bkaducbkg ik jhkh}i}r chash} hf diwq cog}oo is Rido _kbvo}qbsr$ jo wiqkh`bkisoc sh mo bkaducoc bk —Wjh‒q Wjh bk I`o}bai‐ ikc sh }oaobvo sjo Diqeo} 

Iwi}c5 ik jhkhu} fh} ozao|sbhkid iajbovo`oks bk sjo fbodc hf `ocbaid }oqoi}aj ikc |umdba joidsj ic`bkbqs}isbhk+ - Jo coadbkoc idd sjo bkvbsisbhkq sh }oaobvo |o}qhkidjhkhu}q+ Sjo Diqeo} Iwi}c wiq iwi}coc sh Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+ *]ofo}okao> \iqqBs Hk |igo 199-193$ 1?<"

Ozs}iasq f}h` Mbddq W‒q dosso} sh Rido _kbvo}qbsr>

—Sjbq bq sh oz|}oqq `r coo|oqs sjikeq sh sjo `o`mo}q hf sjo Rido Ah}|h}isbhk fh} ahkqbco}bkg `o iq hko qubsimdofh} sjo cog}oo hf Chash} hf Diwq… +++ Bs bq hkdr ifso} `hqs ai}ofud ahkqudsisbhk wbsj f}bokcq$ ikc wbsj `rahkqabokao$ sjis B khw food hmdbgisoc sh coadbko quaj i `i}e hf cbqsbkasbhk……+ Khw sjbq bq sjo }oiqhk> Sjos}icbsbhk hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq ‑ hu} hkdr `oikq hf qodf ghvo}k`oks ‑ oks}oisq oiaj `o`mo} sh ivhbc idd sjis |i}sbaudi} ebkc hf |o}qhkid |umdbabsr h} cbqsbkasbhk wjbaj `bgjs dbke jbq ki`o wbsj hu} qhabosr bk sjo goko}id |umdba

`bkc……+ wo |}iasbao sjbq ikhkr`bsr imqhdusodr$ bs wbdd gui}iksoo hu} offoasbvokoqq ikc ukbsr mr joivbdr}oqs}ibkbkg sjhqo wjh |umdba jhkhu}q ikc cbqsbkasbhkq i}o mus sjo kisu}id qso||bkg qshkoq sh ch`bkikao ikc |o}qhkid |hwo}… … kh jhkhu}q is sjo |umdba dovod bq hu} |}hsoasbvo qjbodc‐+ *\iqq bs hk |igo 199-19="

Mbdd W‒q `o`h}bid>

  —I qb`|do simdos bk sjo Oiqs Ch}qos ao`oso}r iffb}`q Mbdd‒q coo| modbof bk sjo q|b}bs hf ikhkr`bsr‐+ —SjoJoicqshko }oicq> Wbddbi` G+ Wbdqhk$ 9:2?-9279‐ —Sjo}o bq kh `oksbhk hf I+I+‐ *\iqq bs hk |igo 3<6"

I }oahddoasbhk hf qh`o oi}dr I+I+ `oosbkgq doc mr Mbdd W bk 9212$ coqa}bmoc mr ]usjJhae$ sjo fb}qs qoa}osi}r hf sjo Kow Rh}e Goko}id Qo}vbao Hffbao>

 —Sjor wo}o qs}uasu}oc sh sjo ozsoks sjis sjo}o wiq idwirq hko q|oieo} ikc Mbdd- `irmo jidf ik jhu} oiaj - ikcsjok i dhkg ahffoo qoqqbhk$ i }oid gos shgosjo}+ Wo wo}o hfsok sjo}o sbdd 9= h‒adhae$ qsi}soc is obgjs+…++ Is sjbq sb`osjo}o wo}o kh 2<-cirq }oyub}o`oksq+ Kh mb}sjcirq ‑ kh }oahgkbsbhk wiq `ico bf rhu wo}o qhmo} i wooe h} i roi}$Bf rhu fods rhu whudc dbeo sh q|oie bk i roi} h} bk i `hksj h} swh wooeq sjor dos rhu gos u| ikc q|oie$ ikc sjorcbck‒s sj}hw rhu hus bf rhu wo}o c}uke$ obsjo}+ Sjor fods bs wiq okahu}igbkg$ jh|bkg qh`o wh}c whudc qsbae+‐*\iqq bs hk |igo =92"

—Oiaj sb`o Mbdd q|heo$ jo jic i cbffo}oks i||}hiaj+ Sjo}o wiq kh |}o-fh}`udisoc `oqqigo$ ikc jbq sideq i||i}oksdrvi}boc bk dokgsj iq `uaj iq qumnoas `isso}+‐ *\iqq bs hk |igo =92"

19

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 33/63

Wbsj sjo |iqqbkg iwir hf sjo |}hsoasbvo vbgbdikao hf Mbdd W bk 9279 ikc sjo }bqo sh sjo

o}i hf sjo `oqqbijq$ `bqqbhki}boq$ ikc fidqo |}h|josq$ mogbkkbkg wbsj sjo `oosbkg hf Nho @aY ikc Aji}dbo \ bk 92715 wo whkco} bf sjoqo ovoksq i}o khs ahkkoasoc sh sjoqdhwchwk bk g}hwsj }iso hf sjo foddhwqjb| qbkao sjo 927<q+

Qoasbhk Fhu} 

Ikidrqbq hf I+I+ S}icbsbhkq ikc Ahkao|sq i||dboc sh |iqs ikc au}}oksovoksq$ ozi`bkbkg sjo cbffo}okao moswook iqqo}sbvo ikc |ukbsbvo

 mojivbhu}+

Sjo bkabcoksq wbsj Ajuae C+ bdduqs}iso sjo |i}ichz bkvhdvoc bk |}oqo}vbkg I+I+ ukbsr$qb`bdi} sh sjo mbmdbaid |i}ichz> —Wjhovo} qooeq sh gibk jbq dbfo wbdd dhqo bs$ muswjhovo} dhqoq jbq dbfo wbdd |}oqo}vo bs‐ *dueo97+11"+ Sjo —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ —odco} qsisoq`ok‐ hf 92?: co`hkqs}isoc sjbq mr jivbkg sjo ahu}igo sh iqqo}s II S}icbsbhk$ issjo |}bao hf i joisoc i}gu`oks bk wjbaj i fow `bgjs doivo II ikc gos c}uke+ Sjuqsjor dhqs ukbsr bk h}co} sh |}oqo}vo bs+ - I+I+ }o`ibkoc ukbfboc$ wjbdo Ajuae C+ dofswbsj jbq auds ikc wiq i}}oqsoc wjbdqs c}uke qh`o =< roi}q diso}+ Sjbq missdo hf wbddq

 moswook sjo —odco} qsisoq`ok —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ hf sjo I+I+ g}hu| ahkqabokao ikc i

wodd bksoksbhkoc cbasish} bq sjo b`|dbaisbhk hf S}icbsbhk Swh>—Mobkg sjo fhukco}$ jo bq is fb}qs sjo mhqq+ Wjh odqo whudc mo8 Vo}r qhhk$ sjhugj$ jbq iqqu`oc iusjh}bsr sh }ukovo}rsjbkg mogbkq sh mo qji}oc wbsj sjo hsjo} fb}qs idahjhdbaq jo jiq jod|oc+ Is sjbq `h`oks sjo mokbgk cbasish}  moah`oq sjo ajib}`ik hf i ah``bssoo ah`|hqoc hf jbq f}bokcq+ Sjoqo i}o sjo g}hu|‒q jbo}i}ajr hf qo}vbao ‑ qodf-i||hbksoc hf ahu}qo$ moaiuqo sjo}o bq kh hsjo} wir……G}hwbkg |ibkq khw moqos sjo g}hu|…++sjo }ovhdusbhk bq hk+Sjo g}hu| ahkqabokao bq imhus sh sieo hvo}……++Sjo i}aj coiahk bq hko wjh nuqs iq qu}odr ahkvbkaoc sjis sjog}hu| aikkhs gos idhkg wbsjhus jb`…… I fow jio`h}}jigo qh micdr sjis ‑ c}ibkoc hf idd I+I+ q|b}bs ikc |}bkab|do - sjor gos c}uke+ Is sb`oq sjo I+I+ dikcqai|o qoo`q sh mo dbsso}oc wbsj mdoocbkg fh}`q+‐ *S}icbsbhk Swh$Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 917-912"+

Bs aik mo qook f}h` sjo imhvo sjis fh} sjo |hwo} hf S}icbsbhk Swh$ —mus hko udsb`isoiusjh}bsr$‐ sh h|o}iso bk I+I+ —odco} qsisoq`ok‐ h} —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ `uqs idqh fiao

sjob} }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh doic sjo }ovhds sh ajiddokgo cbasish}q+ Bf doico}qjb| bq woie ikcsjo }ovhds choq khs sieo |diao$ }oaoks jbqsh}baid ovbcokao bq sjis qh`o g}hu|q `ir}osibk sjo jbo}i}ajbaid |r}i`bc qs}uasu}o hf i auds$ }isjo} sjik sjo u|qbco chwk s}bikgdoqs}uasu}o hf I+I+ - Sjo —mokbgk cbasish}‐ `oksbhkoc bk S}icbsbhk Swh moah`oq`idbgkiks+ Bs aik idqh mo qook sjis wjo}o sjo —udsb`iso iusjh}bsr‐ hf S}icbsbhk Swh bqh|o}isbkg joidsjbdr bk I+I+$ sjo}o wbdd idqh mo sjhqo wjh food sjob} uk}oiqhkimdoco`ikcq fh} shsid dbmo}sr i}o mobkg }oqs}basoc+

1=

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 34/63

—++Foodbkg sjo wobgjs hf idd sjoqo fh}aoq$ ao}sibk `o`mo}q wjh }uk ahukso} sh I+I+‒q S}icbsbhkq qh`osb`oq qir sjissjor i}o mobkg aokqh}oc h} |ukbqjoc ikc sjis sjor i}o sjo}ofh}o mobkg ghvo}koc…++‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+

Imuqbvo(aho}abvo q|hkqh}qjb| wbsjbk i auds g}hu| bq adoi}dr i |umdba `isso} iffoasbkghsjo} g}hu|q ikc II iq i wjhdo$ —ik bkabso`oks sh |umdba ahks}hvo}qr‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$Wi}}iksr ?"$ wjbaj wi}}iksq bkso}voksbhk ukco} sjo ozao|sbhk sh g}hu| iushkh`r bkS}icbsbhk 3+ Sjo }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh |}hsoas sjo vudko}imdo f}h` imuqo$ |}oqo}vo I+I+ukbsr ikc II |umdba }odisbhkq dboq wbsj sjo —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ ikc —odco} qsisoq`ok‐wbsjbk sjo bkso}g}hu|+ Jhwovo}$ }oq|hkqbmbdbsr idqh dboq is }ogbhkid ikc mhi}c dovodq$sh ukoyubvhaiddr qu||h}s quaj bkso}voksbhkq+

—Jokao sjo |}bkab|do hf i`|dr codogisoc iusjh}bsr ikc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ `uqs mo b`|dbabs f}h`sjo sh| sh sjo mhssh` hf hu} iasbvo qs}uasu}o hf qo}vbao+ Sjbq bq sjo adoi} b`|dbaisbhk hf I+I+‒q S}icbsbhk Swh…+‐*Ahkao|s BB"+

I }oq|hkqbmdo |}hsoasbvo iasbhk sh iqqo}s cusr hf ai}o bk |}hsoasbkg sjo vudko}imdo ikcII |umdba }odisbhkq$ wjo}o auds g}hu|q haau} ikc wjo}o ahksbkuoc imuqo bq }o|h}soc$whudc mo fh} sjo bkso}g}hu| |umdba bkfh}`isbhk ah``bssoo sh bkfh}` idd igokaboq ikchsjo} I+I+ g}hu|q bk sjo i}oi wjbaj `ir mo }ofo}}bkg idahjhdbaq sh sjo g}hu|$ sh}oah``okc sjor khs sh qokc }ofo}}idq sh sjis g}hu|+

—Wjokovo} ikc jhwovo} wo aik$ wo qjidd kooc sh bkfh}` sjo goko}id |umdba idqh5 oq|oabiddr u|hk `bquqoq hf sjoki`o Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+

—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ Wi}}iksr qbz"

Bs aik mo qook sjis ikr g}hu| hf idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} sjo |u}|hqo hf sjoahks}hd$ aho}abhk ikc imuqo hf sjo vudko}imdo jiq ikhsjo} |u}|hqo hsjo} sjik qhm}bosrikc bq i `bquqo hf sjo ki`o Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+

Quaj `oiqu}oq$ wjbaj miqbaiddr i`huks sh qirbkg> —Kh+‐ h} —Wo i}o khs hmdbgoc shahh|o}iso wbsj$ h} sh mo ghvo}koc mr$ sjo uk}oiqhkimdo cbasisoq hf i —sr}ikkr hf vo}rq`idd `bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsj imqhduso |hwo}+‐ *Ahkao|s V" aikkhs mo }ogi}coc iqghvo}k`oksid h} |ukbsbvo$ mus iqqo}sbvo hf S}icbsbhkq Hko ikc Swh+ Sjor i}o qb`|dr

bkfh}`isbvo hf II S}icbsbhk ikc wi}}iksboq hf ahkfo}okao+

++II'q }bgjs sh hmnoas aid`dr ikc |}bvisodr sh q|oabfba vbhdisbhkq bq is doiqs oyuid sh sjo }bgjsq hf sjo vbhdish}q wjhvbhdiso+ Sjbq aikkhs iaau}isodr mo aiddoc i ghvo}k`oksid iasbhk+ *Ahkao|s ZBB$ wi}}iksr Fbvo+"

11

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 35/63

Quaj i||dbaisbhk hf II s}icbsbhk choq kooc `h}o sjik nuqs i dbssdo ahu}igo hk mojidf hf 

sjhqo qo}vbkg hk ik bkso}g}hu| ah``bssoo$ fh} bs bq dbeodr sh mo `os wbsj qsbff }oqbqsikao moaiuqo>

—Bkqsbkasq hk sjo }i`|igo mide is bkvoqsbgisbhk+ Sjo `bkuso wo `ieo i qo}bhuq isso`|s sh |}hmo sjo`$ wo i}o dbimdosh quffo} i qovo}o }oiasbhk+‐ *Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 36"

- Iq Mbdd W+ okahukso}oc wbsj —Hu} \}h`hso} f}bokc‐ wjh su}koc —idi}`bkg |hqo}‐wbsj jbq udsb`isu`> —Sh jodd wbsj sjo s}uqsooq$ sjo wh}dc bq wibsbkg fh} `r `oqqigo+B‒vo ghs sjo }bgjs sh f}oo q|ooaj ikc B‒` ghbkg hk ib} wjosjo} rhu dbeo bs h} khs+‐ *IIah`oq hf Igo |igo 91<-919" Ikc iq sjo —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ hf 92?: okahukso}oc wbsjQrkikhk auds doico} Ajuae C> —Idd }bgjs$ dosq gh jh`o-sjo jodd wbsj sjbq+‒ Qh sjo

wjhdo `oosbkg ghs u|$ ikc wo idd ghs bksh hu} iush`hmbdoq ikc… … wo kovo} woks miae sh I+I+ igibk+‐

Wi}}iksr fbvo qsisoq>

—…wo qsbdd qir ‚fbko+ Hkdr wo jh|o rhu whk‒s coqbgkiso rhu} offh}sq iq ik I+I+ g}hu| h} okso}|}bqo+‒ Sjoqoozi`|doq bdduqs}iso jhw fi} wo jivo id}oicr ghko sh okahu}igo f}ooch` hf iqqo`mdr$ iasbhk$ ikc ovok qajbq`+ Shidd sjhqo wjh wbqj sh qoaoco f}h` I+I+ wo ozsokc i ajoo}fud bkvbsisbhk sh ch nuqs sjis+ Bf sjor aik fbkc i mosso} wirwo i}o gdic+‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr ?"+

Bk sjo aiqo hf Ajuae C$ gbvok sjo jbqsh}r hf Qrkikhk$ sjo ah``bssoo hf —s}uqsocqo}viksq‐ ahudc ahkg}isudiso sjo`qodvoq hk i nhm wodd chko+ Jhwovo}$ bk bkqsikaoq

wjo}o sjor ch khs wbqj sh qoaoco$ mus bkqbqs hk qsirbkg sh }ubk I+I+ ukbsr bkqsoic$ sjoki ah``bssoo hf —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ bq dbeodr sh jivo sh fiao i qdbgjsdr cbffo}oks qbsuisbhk$ikc hko wjbaj }oyub}oq sjo` sh>

—…sieo i qsikc igibkqs i qsh}`++++++ sh qsbae fdis fhhsoc sh hko‒q ahkvbasbhkq imhus ik bqquo uksbd sjo `isso} bs bqqossdoc……+ fiao joivr ikc dhkg- ahksbkuoc a}bsbabq`…+ ikc fiao sjhqo wjh |hwo}c}bvo$ sjor i}o sjo ‚|hdbsaeo}q$‒Sjor `ieo iaauqisbhkq+ @irmo sjor i}o vbhdoks$ `idbabhuq+ Sjor |bsaj ghmq hf }u`h}q$ ghqqb|$ ikc goko}id qaussdo- muss sh gibk sjob} okcq ‑ idd fh} sjo ghhc hf I+I+ hf ahu}qo)‐ *Ahkao|s BZ"+

Sjo S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}q `ir cofbiksdr swbqs S}icbsbhk Hko bkqbqsbkg sjob} —}bgjsq$‐`uaj dbeo —Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐> —B‒vo ghs sjo }bgjs sh f}oo q|ooaj…++wjosjo} rhudbeo bs h} khs+‐ *II ah`oq hf Igo |igo 91<-919" H} sjor `ir swbqs wi}}iksboq fbvo

ikc qbz5 qooe qr`|isjr f}h` kowo} `o`mo}q hf sjo foddhwqjb| wjh i}o bgkh}iks hf S}icbsbhkq$ adib`bkg sjor i}o mobkg —|ukbqjoc‐$ h} —ghvo}koc‐+ - Bs whudc i||oi} jhwovo}$ sjis wjok sjo udsb`iso iusjh}bsr bk S}icbsbhk swh bq h|o}isbkg joidsjbdr bkI+I+$ —Sjo bkfduokao hf udsb`iso iusjh}bsr `uqs idwirq mo fods$‐ *Ahkao|s Z" ikcsjo}o wbdd is sb`oq mo sjhqo wjh>

 —Foodbkg sjo wobgjs hf idd sjoqo fh}aoq… +++ qh`osb`oq qir sjis sjor i}o mobkg aokqh}oc h} |ukbqjoc ikc sjis sjori}o sjo}ofh}o mobkg ghvo}koc…++‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+

13

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 36/63

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc sjis sjo qsiso hf —foodbkg‐ aokqh}oc$ |ukbqjoc h} ghvo}koc bq khs

sjo qi`o sjbkg iq sjo iasuid qsiso hf —mobkg‐ aokqh}oc$ |ukbqjoc h} ghvo}koc$ sjo swhi}o cbqsbkasdr cbffo}oks iq aik mo oz|dibkoc bk sjo fhddhwbkg |i}ig}i|jq>

Wjo}o quaj cofbikao bq `os f}h` i q`idd sr}ikkr$ sjo}o bq sjo cusr sh |}hsoas f}h`—sr}ikkboq g}ois ikc q`idd‐ *Ahkao|s ZBB$ wi}}iksr qbz"+ Iq Mbdd W+ co`hkqs}isocwbsj —Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐ *II ah`oq hf Igo |igo 91<-919"$ S}icbsbhk hko iffh}cqsjo oyuid dbmo}sr sh ikr I+I+ `o`mo}$ g}hu|$ bkso}g}hu| ikc II iq i wjhdo$ iq choq iq`idd sr}ikkr iffh}c sh bsqodf> —Kh II aik ah`|od ikhsjo} sh ch ikrsjbkg+‐ *S}icbsbhkHko$ Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 911"+ Sjo}o bq kh ah`|udqbhk shqum`bs sh$ h} ahh|o}iso wbsj uk}oiqhkimdo co`ikcq hf i q`idd sr}ikkr bf sjob} iasbhkqiffoas hsjo} g}hu|q h} II iq i wjhdo+ ‑ Quaj i ah`|udqbhk whudc i`huks sh sjo

`inh}bsr mobkg ghvo}koc mr i —sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd `bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsj imqhduso |hwo}‐+ *Ahkao|s V"+ Bf koghsbisbhk fibdq$ co-dbqsbkg i g}hu| ikc bkfh}`bkg sjo |umdbabk quaj aiqoq bq mhsj ik h|sbhk ikc i cusr ukco} wi}}iksboq fbvo ikc qbz>

—Wjokovo} ikc jhwovo} wo aik$ wo qjidd kooc sh bkfh}` sjo goko}id |umdba idqh5 oq|oabiddr u|hk `bquqoq hf sjoki`o Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk‐+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr 6"

S}icbsbhk Fhu} qsisoq>

—Oiaj g}hu| qjhudc mo iushkh`huq ozao|s bk `isso}q iffoasbkg hsjo} g}hu|q h} II iq i wjhdo+‐ ‑ Fu}sjo} 

oz|dibkoc mr Mbdd W> —…Ros |doiqo khso hko b`|h}siks yuidbfbaisbhk+ Bs wbdd mo qook sjis quaj ozs}o`o dbmo}sr hf sjhugjs ikc iasbhk i||dboq hkdr sh sjo g}hu|‒q hwk iffib}q…… Hmvbhuqdr bf ikr bkcbvbcuid$ g}hu|$ h} }ogbhkidah``bssoo ahudc sieo ik iasbhk sjis `bgjs qo}bhuqdr iffoas sjo wodfi}o hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq iq i wjhdo h} qo}bhuqdr cbqsu}m qu}}hukcbkg g}hu|q$ sjis whudc khs mo dbmo}sr is idd$ Bs whudc mo qjoo} dbaokqo$ bs whudc moiki}ajr$ khs co`ha}iar‐+ *Mbdd W+ —S}icbsbhk fhu}‐$ II G}i|ovbko @i}aj 923:$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo :9"+

Hu} `o`mo}qjb| S}icbsbhk choq ahksibk$ jhwovo}$ hko vbsiddr b`|h}siks yuidbfbaisbhk+ Sjis yuidbfbaisbhk }odisoq shsjo uqo hf hu} ki`o Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+++++++++ Wo aikkhs dokc sjo II ki`o$ ovok bkcb}oasdr$ sh hsjo} iasbvbsboq$jhwovo} wh}sjr+ Bf wo ch qh wo qjidd moah`o jh|odoqqdr ah`|}h`bqoc ikc cbvbcoc+ Wo sjbke sjis II qjhudchffo} bsq oz|o}bokao sh sjo wjhdo wh}dc fh} wjisovo} uqo aik mo `ico hf bs+ Mus khs bsq ki`o+ Khsjbkg aik mo `h}oao}sibk+ *Mbdd W+ S}icbsbhk Sj}oo$ II G}i|ovbko 923:$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 72-:<"

—Bk II$ sjo g}hu| jiq qs}bas db`bsisbhkq$ mus sjo bkcbvbcuid qai}aodr ikr+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?: -

Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igoq ===-==?"+

—Hk quaj bqquoq hu} ah``hk wodfi}o bq |i}i`huks‐ *S}icbsbhk Fhu} *Dhkg Fh}`"

Bs aik mo qook f}h` S}icbsbhkq Sj}oo ikc Fhu} sjis ik bkcbvbcuid idahjhdba‒qukahkcbsbhkid }bgjs sh mo ik I+I+ `o`mo} bq idd bkaduqbvo$ kovo} ozaduqbvo$ mus sjo}o bqkh quaj }bgjs iffh}coc sh ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} iq i g}hu|+Sjo}o bq —hko b`|h}siks yuidbfbaisbhk‐ wjbaj bq idd ozaduqbvo ozao|s fh} iq i g}hu| 

1?

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 37/63

sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk+ ‑ Sjo}ofh}o ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq

gisjo}oc shgosjo} iq i g}hu| `ir khs koaoqqi}bdr yuidbfr sjo`qodvoq sh mo aiddoc ikI+I+ g}hu|$ iq qsisoc bk wi}}iksr qbz>

—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk‐+

Ikc ahkfb}`oc bk wi}}iksr fbvo> 

—Bf bkcbvbcuid I+I+q wbqj sh gisjo} shgosjo} fh} }os}oisq$ Ah``ukbhk m}oiefiqsq$ h} bkcooc ikr ukco}siebkg is idd$wo qsbdd qir ‚Fbko+ Hkdr wo jh|o rhu whk‒s coqbgkiso rhu} offh}sq iq ik I+I+ g}hu| h} okso}|}bqo+‐ 

Iq Mbdd W+ oz|dibkq>

—B sjbke wo `bgjs qu` bs u| dbeo sjbq> —II `o`mo}q wjh i}o qh bkadbkoc qjhudc mo okahu}igoc sh mikc shgosjo} bkg}hu|q sh ……+ Mus sjor hugjs sh }of}ibk f}h` aiddbkg sjo`qodvoq II g}hu|q……+++++++ Mus hmvbhuqdr$ quaj icuid |u}|hqo g}hu| qjhudc khs bkqbqs sjis bs mo aiddoc ik II g}hu| kh} qjhudc bs uqo sjo II ki`o bk bsq sbsdo+‐*Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igoq ===-==?"+

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc$ sjis ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} iq i g}hu| jiqkh }bgjs sh bkqbqs sjis ikr hsjo} I+I+ `o`mo}$ g}hu|$ bkso}g}hu| h} ikr |i}s hf I+I+aiddq sjo` ik I+I+ g}hu|+

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc sjis i g}hu|‒q iushkh`r$ h} bk hsjo} wh}cq$ bsq dbmo}sr sh vbhdiso

idd I+I+‒q S}icbsbhkq$ bsq —}bgjs sh mo w}hkg‐ ozsokcq qs}basdr sh bsq hwk iffib}q+ Sjo}obq i wodd cofbkoc mhukci}r bk S}icbsbhk Fhu} is wjbaj ik I+I+ g}hu|‒q iushkh`r okcqikc wjo}o sjo |}bkab|doq hf S}icbsbhkq Hko ikc Swh sieo |}oaocokao5 iqqu`bkg—s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ ikc —odco} qsisoq`ok‐ i}o wbddbkg sh i||dr sjo imdo doico}qjb| hf S}icbsbhk Swh$ Ahkao|s BZ5 ikc sjo —q|oabfba i||dbaisbhk‐ hf S}icbsbhk Fhu}> —S}icbsbhk Fhu} bq i q|oabfba i||dbaisbhk hf goko}id |}bkab|doq id}oicr husdbkoc bk S}icbsbhkq Hko ikc Swh+S}icbsbhk Hko qsisoq> ‚Oiaj `o`mo} hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq bq mus i q`idd |i}s hf i g}ois wjhdo‒……++ Jokaohu} ah``hk wodfi}o ah`oq fb}qs …………+ sjo}o bq mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr…‐ *Mbdd W$ S}icbsbhk Fhu}$G}i|ovbko @i}aj 923:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s$ |igo :<"+

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc sjis wjokovo} s}uqsoc qo}viksq ozo}abqo sjob} —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐

*Ahkao|s BBB" sh }ofuqo I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhk sh idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} iq i g}hu|wbsj ikhsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk5 sjbq aikkhs iaau}isodr mo aiddoc |ukbsbvo h} ghvo}kbkg$ mus i }oq|hkqbmdo$ bkfh}`isbvo ikc iqqo}sbvo qsiso`oks hf S}icbsbhkq Hko$Swh ikc wi}}iksboq ? ikc 6+ Bs fhddhwq sjis bf i —quaj i cuid |u}|hqo g}hu| qjhudc khsbkqbqs sjis bs mo aiddoc ik II g}hu| kh} qjhudc bs uqo sjo II ki`o bk bsq sbsdo+‐ *MbddW+ II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igoq ===-==?"$ sjok sjo}o

16

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 38/63

bq kh ah`|udqbhk bk S}icbsbhk Hko fh} sh ikr |i}s hf I+I+ sh }ogbqso} bs iq hko+ ‑ Bs aik

 mo qook sjis bf$ is ikr sb`o i ah`|udqbhk wo}o sh mo b`|hqoc hk i s}uqsoc qo}viks‒q—}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ sjok sjbq whudc vbhdiso sjo |}bkab|do bk S}icbsbhk Hko ikc Ahkao|sBBB$ sjuq `iebkg S}icbsbhkq ikc wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao bkvidbc+

—Kh II aik ah`|od ikhsjo} sh ch ikrsjbkg‐+ *S}icbsbhk Hko $ Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 911"

—Wo hugjs sh s}uqs hu} wh}dc qo}viksq wbsj sjoqo cbqa}osbhkq$ moaiuqo hsjo}wbqo kh offoasbvo doico}qjb| aik mo |hqqbmdo+ Dos uq ahkqbco} bk cosibd$ sjo}ofh}o$ wjr sjo kooc fh} i ‚}bgjs hf coabqbhk‒ bk hu} doico}qjb| bq b`|o}isbvo$ikc dos uq ozi`bko jhw sjbq |}bkab|do aik mo i||dboc |}iasbaiddr bk idd dovodq hf hu} qs}uasu}o hf wh}dc qo}vbao‐*Ahkao|s BBB"—Sjo}ofh}o qh`o s}icbsbhkid ikc |}iasbaid |}bkab|do jiq sh mo covbqoc wjbaj is idd dovodq wbdd ahksbkuhuqdr midikao

sjo }bgjs }odisbhk moswook udsb`iso iusjh}bsr ikc codogisoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr+‐ Jhw$ sjok i}o wo sh iaah`|dbqj sjbq8…… Sjo }bgjs I+I+ qhdusbhk jiq mook fhukc$ jhwovo}$ bk sjo disso} |i}s hf S}icbsbhk Swh$ wjbaj |}hvbcoq fh} 

—s}uqsoc qo}viksq+‐ Sjbq }oiddr `oikq sjis wo hugjs sh s}uqs hu} }oq|hkqbmdo doico}q sh coabco$ wbsjbk sjo ukco}qshhcf}i`owh}e hf sjob} cusboq$ jhw sjor wbdd bkso}|}os ikc i||dr sjob} hwk iusjh}bsr ikc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh oiaj

 |i}sbaudi} |}hmdo` h} qbsuisbhk iq bs i}bqoq+‐ *Ahkao|s BBB"

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc sjis wjokovo} s}uqsoc qo}viksq ozo}abqo sjob} —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐sh }ofuqo I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhk sh idahjhdbaq wjh iq i g}hu|$ ch jivo ikhsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk5 sjok sjbq aikkhs iaau}isodr mo aiddoc oz|udqbhk f}h` I+I+ `o`mo}qjb|+Sjbq bq moaiuqo bf iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo ikhsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk$ sjok iaah}cbkgsh S}icbsbhk ikc sjo |}hvbqbhk bk Wi}}iksr 6$ sjor jivo oz|oddoc sjo`qodvoq f}h` ikr}bgjs sh aidd sjob} g}hu| ik I+I+ g}hu|$ iq qsisoc mr Mbdd W>

Mus hmvbhuqdr$ quaj i cuid |u}|hqo g}hu| qjhudc khs bkqbqs sjis bs mo aiddoc ik II g}hu| kh} qjhudc bs uqo sjo II

ki`o bk bsq sbsdo+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igoq ===-==?"+

—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk‐+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr 6"+

Sjo s}uqsoc qo}viks‒q —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ sh }ofuqo I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhk sh i g}hu|$ choqkhs oz|od ikr bkcbvbcuid idahjhdbaq wbsjbk sjo g}hu| f}h` I+I+ `o`mo}qjb| qbkaoI+I+ }ogbqs}isbhk bq hkdr i||dbaimdo sh idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} iq i g}hu|+ Bs aik

 mo ukco}qshhc bk S}icbsbhk Sj}oo$ sjis bkcbvbcuid idahjhdbaq i}o ukahkcbsbhkiddroksbsdoc sh mo `o`mo}q hf ikr I+I+ g}hu| ikc iq wodd$ bkcudgo bk ikr oz-au}}baudig}hu| iasbvbsboq sjor wbqj sh+ ‑ Bao jhaeor$ fhhsmidd$ }odbgbhuq qoasq ikc

cokh`bkisbhkq$ isjobqs qhabosboq$ i}sq ikc a}ifsq$ wjido wisajbkg$ sjo qsucr hf aho}abvosoajkbyuoq$ fdhwo} i}}ikgbkg$ doisjo}miae su}sdo ahkqo}visbhk$ muddrbkg soajkbyuoq$ |ibks midd$ jikg gdbcbkg$ ekbssbkg$ auds |qrajhdhgr$ middos cikabkg$ `o`mo}‒q qhabidadumq$ jh}qo }bcbkg$ idahjhd f}oo cikaoq ikc qhabid ovoksq$ }hae adb`mbkg$ - sjo dbqs bqokcdoqq+ Jhwovo}$ bf ik I+I+ g}hu| wbsj quaj cuid |u}|hqo wo}o sh jbs sjo joicdbkoqwbsj kowq hf I+I+ kowah`o}q mobkg s}i`|doc mr jh}qoq h} qwiddhwoc mr wjidoq5 h} bf sjo kobgjmhu}bkg I+I+ g}hu|q wo}o cbqsu}moc mr sjo kooc fh} sjo` sh gbvo fb}qs ibc sh

17

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 39/63

kowah`o}q qjhwbkg u| is sjob} `oosbkgq s}iu`isbqoc mr jhhf qji|oc joic bknu}boq5

sjok bs aik mo qook bk I+I+ S}icbsbhk$ qbkao oiaj g}hu| bq |i}s hf sjo wjhdo$ sjo |}bkab|doq hf S}icbsbhkq Hko ikc Swh sieo |}oaocokao hvo} sjo cuid |u}|hqo g}hu|‒qiushkh`r+ Sjo s}uqsoc qo}viksq ikc odco} qsisoq`ok wbsjbk sjo bkso}g}hu| i}osjo}ofh}o }oq|hkqbmdo sh i||dr sjo —q|oabfba i||dbaisbhk‐ hf S}icbsbhk Fhu}+

Sjo s}uqsoc qo}viks‒q —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ sh }ofuqo I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhk sh i g}hu| aikkhsiaau}isodr mo aiddoc ik ias hf ghvo}k`oks h} |ukbqj`oks moaiuqo sjo g}hu| ikc bsqbkcbvbcuid I+I+ `o`mo}q i}o khs$ bk ikr wir wjisqhovo}$ mobkg aho}aoc h} ah``ikcoc sh qsh| ikr hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk$ kh} i}o |ukbsbvo qikasbhkq mobkgi||dboc+ Bkqsoic$ sjo s}uqsoc qo}viksq$ mobkg —ji||r nhrhuq ikc f}oo‐ ukco} S}icbsbhkHko$ i}o gdic sh ozsokc i —ajoo}fud bkvbsisbhk‐ sh —sjhqo wjh wbqj sh qoaoco f}h`

I+I+‐ iq qsisoc bk wi}}iksr fbvo>

—Bf bkcbvbcuid I+I+q wbqj sh gisjo} shgosjo} fh} }os}oisq$ Ah``ukbhk m}oiefiqsq$ h} bkcooc ikr ukco}siebkg is idd$wo qsbdd qir ‚Fbko+ Hkdr wo jh|o rhu whk‒s coqbgkiso rhu} offh}sq iq ik I+I+ g}hu| h} okso}|}bqo‒…++ Sh idd wjhwbqj sh qoaoco f}h` I+I+ wo ozsokc i ajoo}fud bkvbsisbhk sh ch nuqs sjis+ Bf sjor aik ch mosso} mr hsjo} `oikq$ woi}o gdic+‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"

Bf hk sjo hsjo} jikc i cuid |u}|hqo g}hu|‒q cbasish}q ch khs wbqj sh qoaoco$ bs aik moukco}qshhc sjis i s}uqsoc qo}viks‒q —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ sh }ofuqo sjo` I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhkiq i g}hu|$ }odisoq |u}odr sh i |}hsoasbvo iasbhk igibkqs `bquqo hf sjo I+I+ ki`o+ Bsjiq khsjbkg sh ch wbsj bkcbvbcuid‒q `o`mo}qjb|$ h} }oqs}basbkg I+I+ `o`mo}‒q dbmo}sriq bkcbvbcuidq h} iq i g}hu|$ - Bs aik mo qook bk Wi}}iksr fbvo5 sjob} dbmo}sr bq khs}oqs}basoc bk ikr wir$ wjisqhovo}>

—Bf bkcbvbcuid I+I+q wbqj sh gisjo} shgosjo} fh} }os}oisq$ Ah``ukbhk m}oiefiqsq$ h} bkcooc ikr ukco}siebkg is idd$wo qsbdd qir ‚Fbko+ Hkdr wo jh|o rhu whk‒s coqbgkiso rhu} offh}sq iq ik I+I+ g}hu| h} okso}|}bqo+‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$wi}}iksr fbvo"+

Sjor `ir wbqj ahksbkuo sh `bquqo sjo I+I+ ki`o mr aiddbkg sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+g}hu|$ mus sjor `ir khs bkqbqs hsjo}q aidd sjo` ik I+I+ g}hu|+ Kh} `ir sjor bkqbqssjis ik bkso}g}hu| choq khs i||dr sjo —q|oabfba i||dbaisbhk‐ hf S}icbsbhk Fhu} ikcwi}}iksboq ? ikc 65 kh} `ir sjor ah`|od s}uqsoc qo}viksq khs uqo sjob} —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐>

—Kh II aik ah`|od ikhsjo} sh ch ikrsjbkg+‐ *S}icbsbhk Hko$ Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo 911"

—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk‐+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr 6" —Wjokovo} ikc jhwovo} woaik$ wo qjidd kooc sh bkfh}` sjo goko}id |umdba idqh5 oq|oabiddr u|hk `bquqoq hf sjo ki`o Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+*Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+

1:

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 40/63

Jo}obk dirq sjo eor sh sjo |i}ichz bk I+I+ S}icbsbhkq Hko ikc Swh$ ikc jhw sjoudsb`iso iusjh}bsr bk S}icbsbhk Swh bq i||dboc wbsjhus aho}abhk$ ah``ikc h} ghvo}kikao$ sj}hugj sjo dbmo}sr iffh}coc sh sjo bkcbvbcuid bk S}icbsbhk Hko5 ikc —`uqs

 mo b`|dbabs f}h` sjo sh| sh sjo mhssh` hf hu} iasbvo qs}uasu}o hf qo}vbao+‐ *Ahkao|s BB"+

Bs aik mo qook sjis sjo s}uqsoc qo}viks‒q —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ sh }ofuqo I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhksh i g}hu| hkdr sjo }o`hvoq sjo I+I+ ki`o f}h` hsjo} |u}|hqoq h} iffbdbisbhkq+ Bs choqkhs iffoas bkcbvbcuid dbmo}sr h} I+I+ `o`mo}qjb| wjisqhovo}$ bk ikr hsjo} wir+ Bs aik

 mo qook sjis I+I+ g}hu| qo}vbao doico}q i}o f}oo sh doic sjob} g}hu| sh ikr iasbvbsr sjorajhhqo$ fh} ozi`|do$ sjo }oa}oisbhkq hf sokkbq$ wjbso wiso} }ifsbkg$ aho}abvo mhhe 

qsucr$ mukgoo nu`|bkg$ kh-hko whudc isso`|s sh qsh| sjo`5 mus bf sjoqo g}hu| doico}qi}o b}}oq|hkqbmdo sh dokc sjo I+I+ ki`o sh quaj ikhsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk$ dosq qir$

 mukgoo nu`|bkg5 sjok sjo b`|dbabs kisu}o hf —mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr‐ wbsjbk sjoqo}vbao qs}uasu}o s}uqsq sjo }oq|hkqbmbdbsr hf khs dokcbkg sjo I+I+ ki`o sh sjocodogisoc iusjh}bsr hf wjhovo} bq }oq|hkqbmdo fh} }ogbqso}bkg sjo g}hu|>

—Wo aikkhs dokc sjo II ki`o$ ovok bkcb}oasdr$ sh hsjo} iasbvbsboq$ jhwovo} wh}sjr+ Bf wo ch qh wo qjidd moah`ojh|odoqqdr ah`|}h`bqoc ikc cbvbcoc+ Wo sjbke sjis II qjhudc hffo} bsq oz|o}bokao sh sjo wjhdo wh}dc fh} wjisovo} uqo aik mo `ico hf bs+ Mus khs bsq ki`o+ Khsjbkg aik mo `h}o ao}sibk+ *Mbdd W+ S}icbsbhk Sj}oo$ IIG}i|ovbko 923:$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 72-:<"

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc i s}uqsoc qo}viks‒q —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ sh }ofuqo I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhksh i g}hu| wbsj ikhsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk bq }oq|hkqbmdr iqqo}sbvo hf sjo fhddhwbkg>

S}icbsbhk Hko> —Hu} ah``hk wodfi}o qjhudc ah`o fb}qs$‐S}icbsbhk Swh> —Sjo}o bq mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr$‐Ahkao|s BB> —Jokao sjo |}bkab|do hf i`|dr codogisoc iusjh}bsr ikc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ `uqs mob`|dbabs f}h` sjo sh| sh sjo mhssh` hf hu} iasbvo qs}uasu}o hf qo}vbao+ Sjbq bq sjo adoi} b`|dbaisbhk hf I+I+‒qS}icbsbhk Swh…+‐Ahkao|s Z> —…Idd hf sjbq bq fuddr b`|dboc bk I+I+‒q S}icbsbhk Swh+ Jo}o wo qoo sjo —g}hu| ahkqabokao‐ iq sjoudsb`iso iusjh}bsr ikc sjo —s}uqsoc qo}viks‐ iq sjo codogisoc iusjh}bsr+ Hko aikkhs fukasbhk wbsjhus sjo hsjo}++‐Ahkao|s BZ> —Ghhc qo}vbao doico}q$ shgosjo} wbsj qhukc ikc i||}h|}biso `osjhcq hf ajhhqbkg sjo`$ i}o is idddovodq bkcbq|okqbmdo fh} hu} fusu}o fukasbhkbkg ikc qifosr+‐

Quaj iasbhk bq iqqo}sbvo hf sjo —q|oabfba i||dbaisbhk‐ hf S}icbsbhk Fhu}$ iq qsisoc mrMbdd W>

—S}icbsbhk Fhu} bq i q|oabfba i||dbaisbhk hf goko}id |}bkab|doq id}oicr husdbkoc bk S}icbsbhkq Hko ikc Swh+S}icbsbhk Hko qsisoq> —Oiaj `o`mo} hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq bq mus i q`idd |i}s hf i g}ois wjhdo……++ Jokaohu} ah``hk wodfi}o ah`oq fb}qs…………+sjo}o bq mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr…‐ *Mbdd W$ S}icbsbhk Fhu}$G}i|ovbko @i}aj 923:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo :<"+

12

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 41/63

 Sjbq —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ idqh okqu}oq sjo bksog}bsr hf II S}icbsbhkq ikc Wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao>

—Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoq ik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcocsjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk‐+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr 6"+

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc sjis iqqo}sbvo mojivbhu} sh okqu}o sjo bksog}bsr hf I+I+ S}icbsbhkqikc wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao ikc sh |}hsoas sjo I+I+ ki`o$ aikkhs iaau}isodr moadib`oc sh mo |ukbsbvo h} ghvo}kbkg+ Ikc bs aik mo ukco}qshhc sjis bf sjo —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ g}iksoc sh i s}uqsoc qo}viks sh }ofuqo I+I+ }ogbqs}isbhk sh idahjhdbaq wjh iq

i g}hu| jivo ikhsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk wo}o sh mo }o`hvoc mr hmdbgisbhk$ sjok

sjo |}bkab|doq hf S}icbsbhkq Hko$ Swh ikc wi}}iksboq ? ikc 6 whudc mo }okco}ocbkvidbc+

 

Qoasbhk ?

 Kh |hdbao fh}ao bk I+I+8 Ik ikidrqbq hf |iqqbvo mojivbhu} 

I ah``hk i}gu`oks icvikaoc sh ivhbc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr fh} siebkg iasbhk wbsj }ogi}c shi g}hu|‒q S}icbsbhk fhu} vbhdisbhk bq sjis sjo}o bq kh —|hdbao fh}ao‐ bk I+I+ Wo ch khs

 nucgo$ sjo}o i}o kh |}hqoaush}q h} ahu}sq+ Sjo}o bq kh ju`ik |hwo} hf iusjh}bsr+ Sjbqi}gu`oks bq idqh uqoc iq i cofokao ikc ik ozauqo sh nuqsbfr S}icbsbhkq vbhdisbhkq ikciksb qhabid mojivbhu}+

Wjbdqs sjo}o bq kh |hdbao fh}ao iq quaj$ sjbq ivhbcikao hf }oq|hkqbmbdbsr bq di}godr cuo

sh i `bqahkao|sbhk ahkao}kbkg sjo f}ooch` g}iksoc sh sjo bkcbvbcuid I+I+ `o`mo} bkS}icbsbhkq Hko ikc Sj}oo+ Sjbq qi`o f}ooch` bq khs g}iksoc sh sjo g}hu| ukco} sjoozao|sbhk sh g}hu| iushkh`r bk S}icbsbhk Fhu}+

—Bk II$ sjo g}hu| jiq qs}bas db`bsisbhkq$ mus sjo bkcbvbcuid qai}aodr ikr+‐*Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?: - Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igoq ===-==?"+

3<

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 42/63

Sjo `bqahkao|sbhk idqh i||oi}q sh i}bqo f}h` sjo fhddhwbkg qoksokao bk Ahkao|sSwodvo$ wi}}iksr fbvo+ Sjbq bq hfsok sieok hus hf ahksozs ikc `bqbkso}|}osoc iq —Sjo}obq kh |hdbao fh}ao bk I+I+‐

—Idwirq }o`o`mo}bkg G}hu| iushkh`r ikc sjo fias sjis I+I+‒q Wh}dc Joicyui}so}q bq khs i |hdbao h|o}isbhk$ sjo`hqs sjis aik mo chko bk `hqs aiqoq bq sh `ieo ik hffo} hf `ocbisbhk+‐ *Ahkao|s 9= wi}}iksr fbvo"

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc sjis bk sjbq ahksozs sjbq gubcikao bq cb}oasoc is Joicyui}so}q5 ikcbk sjo ahkao|s bs bq `ico wbsj }ofo}okao sh qovo}o bkso}kid cbq|usoq moswook g}hu|qwjbaj |hqo qh`o }bqe hf iss}iasbkg ukwodah`o |umdba issoksbhk5 ikc sjis bs bq khs ifukasbhk$ }oq|hkqbmbdbsr h} iusjh}bsr hf Joicyui}so}q sh |hdbao quaj `isso}q+ Sjbq

ahkao|s moi}q kh }odisbhkqjb| sh sjo ahkao|s hf codogisoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc iusjh}bsrhf s}uqsoc qo}viksq bk S}icbsbhk Swh$ ikc sjob} —}bgjs hf coabqbhk‐ sh ai}}r hus sjob} odoasoc cusboq iaah}cbkg sh I+I+ S}icbsbhkq+ Iq co`hkqs}isoc mr Mbdd W+ wbsj sjo—idi}`bkg |hqo}‐ ikc sjo —s}uqsoc qo}viksq‐ wjh fiaoc Ajuae C+ bk 92?:+ Sjor

 nucgoc i qbsuisbhk$ coabcoc sh `ieo ik ukah`|}h`bqbkg qsikc hk S}icbsbhk$ ikc sjokshhe i||}h|}biso iasbhk5 uqbkg sjob} —]bgjs hf Coabqbhk‐ iq qsisoc bk Ahkao|s BBB ikcsjob} fbkid iusjh}bsr bk ahkao|s Z+

—Sjbq `oikq sjis wo hugjs sh s}uqs hu} }oq|hkqbmdo doico}q sh coabco$ wbsjbk sjo ukco}qshhc f}i`owh}e hf sjob} cusboq$ jhw sjor wbdd bkso}|}os ikc i||dr sjob} hwk iusjh}bsr ikc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh oiaj |i}sbaudi} |}hmdo` h}  qbsuisbhk iq bs i}bqoq+ Sjbq qh}s hf doico}qjb| cbqa}osbhk qjhudc mo sjo oqqokao hf sjo —]bgjs hf Coabqbhk‐ *Ahkao|sBBB"

—Sjo |}bkab|do hf udsb`iso iusjh}bsr }ukq adoi} sj}hugj hu} qs}uasu}o+ Sjbq bq koaoqqi}r$ moaiuqo idd hu} qo}vbaoiffib}q ikc iasbvbsboq jivo sh doic u| qh`owjo}o fh} fbkid }oq|hkqbmbdbsr+ _dsb`iso iusjh}bsr bq idqh koococ qh sjisoiaj wh}eo} h} qo}vbao adiqqbfbaisbhk hf qo}viksq ekhwq wjo}o ikc wjh sjo fbkid mhqq bq+‐ *ahkao|s Z"

—Sjbq ‚}bgjs hf coabqbhk‒ qjhudc kovo} mo `ico iq ik ozauqo fh} fibdu}o sh }okco} |}h|o} }o|h}sq hf idd qbgkbfbaiksiasbhkq sieok5 bs hugjs kovo} mo uqoc iq i }oiqhk fh} ahkqsiksdr ozaoocbkg adoi}dr cofbkoc iusjh}bsr$ kh} iq ikozauqo fh} |o}qbqsoksdr fibdbkg sh ahkquds sjhqo wjh i}o oksbsdoc sh mo ahkqudsoc mofh}o ik b`|h}siks coabqbhk h} iasbhk bq sieok+‐ *Ahkao|s BBB"

Bs aik mo ukco}qshhc bk S}icbsbhk Swh$ sjis sjo q|b}bsuid |hwo} hf —mus hko udsb`isoiusjh}bsr‐ bq codogisoc sh sjo ju`ik |hwo}q hf }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc iusjh}bsr$ozo`|dbfboc bk sjo disso} jidf hf sjo qoksokao —hu} doico}q i}o mus s}uqsoc qo}viksq5‐ikc i`|dbfboc bk sjo Swodvo Ahkao|sq fh} Wh}dc Qo}vbao+ Sjhugj sjo}o i}o kh |hdbao$

sjo}o qjhudc kovo}sjodoqq$ mo ik iasuid fh}ao sh S}icbsbhk Swh bf bs bq h|o}isbkgjoidsjbdr$ ikc wjok s}uqsoc qo}viksq ikc qsisoq`ok i}o fudfbddbkg sjob} }oq|hkqbmbdbsrikc sjob} cusr iq iasbvo gui}cbikq hf hu} S}icbsbhkq ikc hf hu} foddhwqjb|+

39

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 43/63

Sjbq fh}ao fh} ukbfbaisbhk$ ikc fh}aoq$ —sjo sboq sjis mbkc uq shgosjo}‐ i}o coqa}bmoc mrMbdd W+ hk |igo 1 hf —I+I+ S}icbsbhk Jhw bs Covodh|oc+‐ Idqh coqa}bmoc bq sjo fh}aofh} cbqbksog}isbhk$ —wjbaj whudc }oks jb` i|i}s‐ ikc fh}aoq wjbaj —whudc cbvbco uq bf sjor ahudc‐+ Wjok i||dboc$ sjo gokubko fh}ao fh} ukbfbaisbhk bq |hwo}fud okhugj sh}u|su}o —coiahkq$‐ iq bdduqs}isoc bk S}icbsbhk Swh+

—I fow jio`h}}jigo qh micdr sjis ‑ c}ibkoc hf idd I+I+ q|b}bs ikc |}bkab|do - sjor gos c}uke+ Is sb`oq sjo I+I+dikcqai|o qoo`q sh mo dbsso}oc wbsj mdoocbkg fh}`q+‐ *S}icbsbhk Swh$ Swodvo Qso|q ikc Swodvo S}icbsbhkq |igo917-912"+

—Qh dhkg iq sjo sboq sjis mbkc uq shgosjo} |}hvo fi} qs}hkgo} sjik sjhqo fh}aoq wjbaj whudc cbvbco uq bf sjor ahudc$sjok idd wbdd mo wodd………Mus I+I+ ukbsr aikkhs iush`isbaiddr |}oqo}vo bsqodf$ dbeo |o}qhkid }oahvo}r$ wo qjidd

idwirq jivo sh wh}e sh ibksibk bs‐ Mbdd W+jss|>((www+ii+h}g(|cf(|}hcuasq(|-97XIIS}icbsbhkq+|cf 

Bk h}co} sh `ibksibk I+I+ ukbsr$ sjo |hwo} hf —mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr‐ bk S}icbsbhkSwh bq s}uqsoc sh mo i||dboc wbsj i wbdd ikc mr hu} qsisoq`ok ikc s}uqsoc qo}viksq>

—Ikc is sb`oq sjo Ahkfo}okao wbdd kooc sh sieo ao}sibk |}hsoasbvo iasbhkq oq|oabiddr bk sjo i}oi hf S}icbsbhkvbhdisbhkq+ Sjbq iasbhk$ jhwovo}$ kooc khs mo igg}oqqbvodr ahks}hvo}qbid is sjo |umdba dovod+ Dos uq khw ahkqbco} qh`o sr|baid qbsuisbhkq sjis `ir hfsok }oyub}o Ahkfo}okao ahkqbco}isbhk ikc qh`osb`oq cofbkbsoiasbhk……++Bkcbvbcuidq$ qh`osb`oq husqbco h}gikbqisbhkq `ir s}r sh uqo sjo I+I+ ki`o fh} sjob} hwk |}bviso |u}|hqoq+ Iq I+I+ g}hwq bk qb~o ikc |umdba }oahgkbsbhk$ sjo so`|sisbhk sh `bquqo hu} ki`o `ir bka}oiqo+ Sjbq bqwjr wo jivo iqqbgkoc sh hu} Ahkfo}okao i |}hsoasbvo siqe bk }oq|oas sh quaj ahkcbsbhkq+ Sjo Ahkfo}okao bq iq woekhw sjo ‚gui}cbik‒ hf sjo I+I+ S}icbsbhkq+ Sjo}o jiq idwirq mook qh`o ahkfuqbhk imhus sjbq so}` ‚gui}cbikqjb|‒

 |o}ji|q wo qjhudc s}r sh adoi} bs u|+ …………+\}bvisodr$ jhwovo}$ wo aik bkfh}` S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}q sjis sjor i}ohus hf h}co}+ Wjok sjor |o}qbqs$ wo aik fhddhw u| mr uqbkg quaj hsjo} }oqhu}aoq hf |o}quiqbhk iq wo `ir jivo$ ikcsjoqo i}o hfsok ahkqbco}imdo……++wo qjidd jivo sh }odr `ibkdr hk sjo |}oqqu}oq hf I+I+ h|bkbhk ikc |umdbah|bkbhk…… Ikc sh sjbq okc wo qjidd kooc sh `ibksibk i ahksbkuhuq ocuaisbhk hf hu} |umdba ah``ukbaisbhkajikkodq hf idd ebkcq ahkao}kbkg sjo kisu}o ikc |u}|hqo hf hu} S}icbsbhkq………++Wjokovo} ikc jhwovo} wo aik$ wo qjidd kooc sh bkfh}` sjo goko}id |umdba idqh5 oq|oabiddr u|hk `bquqoq hf sjoki`o Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+ Sjbq ah`mbkisbhk hf ahukso} fh}aoq aik mo vo}r cbqahu}igbkg sh vbhdish}q h} whudc mo vbhdish}q+ _kco} sjoqo ahkcbsbhkq sjor qhhk fbkc sjob} covbisbhkq sh mo uk|}hfbsimdo h} ukwbqo………………+Foodbkg sjo wobgjs hf idd sjoqo fh}aoq$ ao}sibk `o`mo}q wjh }uk ahukso} sh I+I+‒q S}icbsbhkqqh`osb`oq qir sjis sjor i}o mobkg aokqh}oc h} |ukbqjoc ikc sjis sjor i}o sjo}ofh}o mobkg ghvo}koc……‐ *Ahkao|s

9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"+

 Kh |hdbao fh}ao jo}o$ mus adoi}dr sjo}o ozbqsq i gokubko ‚fh}ao‒$ ikc i ‚|hwo}‒ igibkqsS}icbsbhk vbhdish}q$ bk h}co} fh} sjo` sh —food sjo wobgjs hf idd sjoqo fh}aoq5‐ mus sjbqbq hkdr wjok sjo}o bq i wbddbkgkoqq hk sjo |i}s hf sjhqo wjh i}o s}uqsoc ikc codogisocsh i||dr sjoqo fh}aoq+ Ahkfo}okao codogisoq i}o sjo}o sh doic$ mus fbkid }oq|hkqbmbdbsrikc iusjh}bsr dboq wbsj sjo qsisoq`ok ikc s}uqsoc qo}viksq doicbkg sjo g}hu|ahkqabokao+ Sjbq co`hkqs}isoc mr sjo Sh}hksh bkso}g}hu| ikc sjo s}uqsoc qo}viksq wjhfiaoc Ajuae C+ bk 92?:+

3=

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 44/63

Wjok udsb`iso }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc fbkid iusjh}bsr i}o iasbkg bk ukbqhk$ ikc wjok sjori}o ukah`|}h`bqbkg bk qsisbkg icjo}okao sh sjo |}bkab|doq hf I+I+ s}icbsbhkq5 ikcwjok sjbq bq b`|dbabs f}h` sjo sh| sh sjo mhssh` hf sjo qo}vbao qs}uasu}o5 sjok sjbqwjok sjo iasbvodr |hwo}fud ikc ukbfrbkg fh}ao hf —mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr‐ bkS}icbsbhk Swh moah`oq fuddr h|o}isbhkid+

—Sjo `ibk |}bkab|doq hf S}icbsbhk Swh i}o a}rqsid adoi}5 sjo I+I+ g}hu|q i}o sh mo sjo fbkid iusjh}bsr5 sjob} doico}qi}o sh mo s}uqsoc wbsj codogisoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsboq hkdr‐ *Ahkao|s B"—…Idd hf sjbq bq fuddr b`|dboc bk I+I+‒q S}icbsbhk Swh+ Jo}o wo qoo sjo ‚g}hu| ahkqabokao‒ iq sjo udsb`iso

iusjh}bsr ikc sjo ‚s}uqsoc qo}viks‒ iq sjo codogisoc iusjh}bsr+ Hko aikkhs fukasbhk wbsjhus sjo hsjo}‐ *Ahkao|s Z"

—Jokao sjo |}bkab|do hf i`|dr codogisoc iusjh}bsr ikc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh ‚s}uqsoc qo}viksq‒ `uqs mo b`|dbabs f}h` sjosh| sh sjo mhssh` hf hu} iasbvo qs}uasu}o hf qo}vbao+ Sjbq bq sjo adoi} b`|dbaisbhk hf I+I+‒q S}icbsbhk Swh‐*Ahkao|s BB"—S}uqsoc qo}viksq is idd I+I+ dovodq i}o oz|oasoc sh ozo}abqo doico}qjb|$ ikc doico}qjb| bq khs qb`|dr i `isso} hf qum`bqqbvo jhuqoeoo|bkg‐ *Ahkao|s VBB"—Sjo |}bkab|do hf udsb`iso iusjh}bsr }ukq adoi} sj}hugj hu} qs}uasu}o+ Sjbq bq koaoqqi}r$ moaiuqo idd hu} qo}vbaoiffib}q ikc iasbvbsboq jivo sh doic u| qh`owjo}o fh} fbkid }oq|hkqbmbdbsr+ _dsb`iso iusjh}bsr bq idqh koococ qh sjisoiaj wh}eo} h} qo}vbao adiqqbfbaisbhk hf qo}viksq ekhwq wjo}o ikc wjh sjo fbkid mhqq bq+‐ *ahkao|s Z"—Sjbq ‚}bgjs hf coabqbhk‒ qjhudc kovo} mo `ico iq ik ozauqo fh} fibdu}o sh }okco} |}h|o} }o|h}sq hf idd qbgkbfbaiksiasbhkq sieok5 bs hugjs kovo} mo uqoc iq i }oiqhk fh} ahkqsiksdr ozaoocbkg adoi}dr cofbkoc iusjh}bsr$ kh} iq ikozauqo fh} |o}qbqsoksdr fibdbkg sh ahkquds sjhqo wjh i}o oksbsdoc sh mo ahkqudsoc mofh}o ik b`|h}siks coabqbhk h} iasbhk bq sieok+‐ *Ahkao|s BBB"

Sjbq bq wjr Joicyui}so}q bq khs i |hdbao h|o}isbhk ikc wjr sjo}o bq kh |hdbao fh}ao iq

quaj$ moaiuqo idd I+I+ `o`mo}q i}o }oq|hkqbmdo$ ikc is idd dovodq+ Bs aik mo qookjhwovo}$ sjis bf codogisoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc iusjh}bsr bq khs b`|dbabs f}h` sh| mhssh`hf hu} qo}vbao qs}uasu}o ikc bf sjo `inh}bsr hf qsisoq`ok is g}hu| dovod i}o |i}s hf i—sr}ikkr‒ hf i|isjosba$ qodf qooebkg$ ukbkfh}`oc…+ `inh}bsr+‐ *Ahkao|s V"$ sjok sjo—mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr‐ hf S}icbsbhk Swh wbdd khs mo fuddr h|o}isbhkid$ ikc sjhqofh}aoq wjbaj whudc cbvbco uq bf sjor ahudc$ moah`o qs}hkgo}+

Fh} ozi`|do$ bf i qbsuisbhk wo}o sh haau} quaj iq sjo hko okahukso}oc mr sjo s}uqsocqo}viksq wbsj Ajuae C bk 92?: is bkso}g}hu| dovod shcir5 ikc wjo}o s}uqsoc qo}viksqwo}o kobsjo} qu||h}soc mr b`|dbabs }oq|hkqbmdr ikc iusjh}bsr$ hf sjo qsisoq`ok ikcs}uqsoc qo}viksq wbsjbk I+I+ g}hu|q$ ikc sjo qo}vbao qs}uasu}o5 sj}hugj bkso}g}hu|$Ahkfo}okao$ mhi}c$ ikc }ogbhkid }oah``okcisbhkq5 sjok sjob} codogisoc iusjh}bsrwhudc mo cb`bkbqjoc+ Sjo}o whudc mo dbssdo qsikc igibkqs i —sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd`bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsj imqhduso |hwo}‐ *Ahkao|s V"5 ikc dbssdo |}hsoasbhk f}h`—sr}ikkboq g}ois ikc q`idd+‐ *Ahkao|s 9= wi}}iksr 6"+

Wjok mic `ok ah`mbko$ sjo ghhc `uqs iqqhabiso5 odqo sjor wbdd fidd$ hko mr hko$ ik uk|bsboc qia}bfbao bk iahkso`|sbmdo qs}uggdo+ *Sjhugjsq hk sjo Aiuqo hf sjo \}oqoks Cbqahksoksq+ Oc`ukco Mu}eo"jss|>((ok+wbeb|ocbi+h}g(wbeb(Oc`ukcXMu}eo

31

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 45/63

Bk sjhqo bkso}g}hu|q oz|o}bokabkg qs}ibkoc }odisbhkqjb|q wbsj qh`o hf sjob} g}hu|q$sjo}o `bgjs wodd mo qh`o |oh|do bk qo}vbao wjh aik bcoksbfr wbsj Oc`ukco Mu}eo‒qqsiso`oks+ Sjo hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr bk S}icbsbhk Swh aik hkdr jhdc I+I+ ukbsr qhdhkg iq sjo ghhc `ok i}o wbddbkg sh iqqhabiso bk sjob} ah`mbkoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikccodogisoc iusjh}bsr+ Sjbq bq b`|dboc bk ahkao|s V>

—Sj}hugjhus jbq |hdbsbaid q|oaudisbhk Co Shyuovbddo bkqbqsoc sjis sjo g}oisoqs cikgo} sh co`ha}iar whudc idwirq mo sjo ‚sr}ikkr‒ hf i|isjosba$ qodf qooebkg$ ukbkfh}`oc… … … `inh}bsboq‐ *Ahkao|s V"

Bk hsjo} wh}cq>

—Idd sjis bq koaoqqi}r fh} sjo s}bu`|j hf ovbd bq sjis ghhc `ok ch khsjbkg+‐

Bs aik idqh mo ukco}qshhc sjis sjo}o whudc mo dbssdo qsikc igibkqs i —sr}ikkr hf vo}rq`idd `bkh}bsboq bkvoqsoc wbsj imqhduso |hwo}‐ *Ahkao|s V" bf s}uqsoc qo}viksqqo}vbkg is dovodq f}h` bkso}g}hu|$ }ogbhk sh Ahkfo}okao codogisoq wo}o khs qu||h}soc

 mr }oq|hkqbmdo qsisoq`ok doicbkg sjo g}hu| ahkqabokao is g}hu| dovod+ 

—Sjo I+I+ g}hu|q shcir jhdc sjo udsb`iso }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikc fbkid iusjh}bsr fh} hu} wh}dc qo}vbaoq……++Sjog}hu|q iqqu`oc sjbq }oq|hkqbmbdbsr is sjo Qs+ Dhubq Ahkvoksbhk bk 92??+‐ *Ahkao|s B"

—B i` }oq|hkqbmdo+ Wjok ikrhko$ ikrwjo}o$ }oiajoq hus fh} jod|$ B wiks sjo jikc hf I+I+ idwirq sh mo sjo}o+ Ikcfh} sjis> B i` }oq|hkqbmdo+‐

33

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 46/63

Qoasbhk 6

Ozi`bkisbhk hf sjo cbffo}okao moswook `bkh}bsr g}hu|q `bkh}bsrh|bkbhkq$ i sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd `bkh}bsboq+

Sjo}o i||oi}q sh mo qh`o ahkfuqbhk moswook |}hsoasbkg `bkh}bsr g}hu|q$ `bkh}bsr

h|bkbhk ikc |}hsoasbkg igibkqs i sr}ikkr hf vo}r q`idd `bkh}bsboq+

@bkh}bsr g}hu|q i}o coqa}bmoc bk —C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q‐ bk aji|so} ZBZ$ |igo =12$ —@bkh}bsr g}hu|q wbsjbk I+I+ gibk iaao|sikao+‐ Sjo |}hsoasbhk hf `bkh}bsboq quaj iq sjoqo$ |}hvbcoc mr Wi}}iksr Qbz }ofo}q sh sjo idd bkaduqbvo I+I+`o`mo}qjb| fh} sjo bkcbvbcuid idahjhdba ukco} S}icbsbhk Sj}oo+ @bkh}bsr h|bkbhk bqcoqa}bmoc bk Ahkao|s V+ Bs bq adoi} bk I+I+ S}icbsbhk sjis sjis sjo |}hsoasbhk hf sjo`bkh}bsr g}hu|q ikc hf `bkh}bsr h|bkbhk choq khs ozsokc sh `bkh}bsboq fh}`bkg q|oabid

 |u}|hqo g}hu|q$ kh} choq bs moi} ikr }odisbhk sh `bkh}bsr g}hu|q wbsj `idbgkcbasish}qjb|q$ wjh i}o bk vbhdisbhk hf S}icbsbhk 3+ II `o`mo}q wjh gisjo} shgosjo} iq g}hu|q wbsj i cuid |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk i}o coqa}bmoc bk —Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s‐

 |igoq ===-==?+ I+I+ S}icbsbhk ikc wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao qo}vo sh |}hsoas sjo I+I+ki`o igibkqs quaj `bkh}bsr g}hu|q+

Ikr qhabosr wjbaj bq bkcbffo}oks sh sjo imuqo hf sjo vudko}imdo bq coqsbkoc shah}}u|sbhk ikc ahddi|qo qhhko} h} diso}$ I+I+ wbdd mo kh ozao|sbhk ukdoqq sjoqifogui}cq id}oicr ivibdimdo i}o |us bk |diao sh |}ovoks bs+ Fh} i auds g}hu|q sh ozbqs bkI+I+ quaj iq sjo Nhrq hf ]oahvo}r$ bq khs iaao|simdo+ Bs qjhwq ik b``h}id fibdu}o hf cusr hf ai}o$ i fibdu}o hf S}icbsbhkq$ Ahkao|sq ikc wi}}iksboq hf ahkfo}okao5 oq|oabiddrS}icbsbhkq Hko$ Swh$ ahkao|sq BZ$ ZBB *wi}}iksboq ? ikc 6"+

Goko}iddr jhw ozaduqbvo jivo I+I+ `oosbkgq moah`o8 chash}q ikc diwro}q `oosbkgq$wh`ok‒q `oosbkgq$ gir `oosbkgq5 ikc sjo jhqs hf `oosbkgq wbsj vo}r qs}ikgo sbsdoq+ Hf ahu}qo$ ikrhko bq wodah`o$ ozao|s sjhqo miffdoc kowah`o}q wjh chk‒s ekhw$ wjh isfb}qs |hbks hf ahksias wbsj I+I+$ `bgjs food ozaducoc qb`|dr mr sjo sbsdo‒q bkqbkuisbhkhk sjo `oosbkgq dbqs+ Jo}o doico}qjb| ahudc mo ozo}abqoc mr qb`|dr qsisbkg sjo I+I+g}hu|q ciso$ sb`o ikc vokuo hk `oosbkg dbqsq+

  3? 

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 47/63

Qoasbhk 7

Bkvoksh}r

Ozs}ias f}h` Mbdd W‒q icc}oqq sh sjo =<sj

ikkbvo}qi}r Qs Dhubq ahkvoksbhk *II Ah`oqhf Igo |igo =19 -=11">

—Bk sjo roi}q ijoic wo qjidd$ hf ahu}qo$ `ieo `bqsieoq+ Oz|o}bokao jiq siugjs uq sjis wo kooc jivo kh foi} hf chbkg sjbq$ |}hvbcbkg sjis wo qjidd idwirq }o`ibk wbddbkg sh ahkfoqq hu} fiudsq ikc sh ah}}oas sjo` |}h`|sdr+ Hu} g}hwsj iq bkcbvbcuidq jiq co|okcoc u|hk sjbq joidsjr |}haoqq hf s}bid ikc o}}h}+ Qh wbdd hu} g}hwsj iq i foddhwqjb|+Dos uq idwirq }o`o`mo} sjis ikr qhabosr hf `ok ikc wh`ok sjis aikkhs f}oodr ah}}oas bsq hwk fiudsq `uqs qu}odrfidd bksh coair bf khs bksh ahddi|qo+ Quaj bq sjo ukbvo}qid |okidsr fh} fibdbkg sh gh hk g}hwbkg+ Nuqs iq oiaj I+I+`uqs ahksbkuo sh sieo jbq `h}id bkvoksh}r ikc ias u|hk bs$ qh `uqs hu} wjhdo qhabosr ch bf wo i}o sh qu}vbvo ikc bf wo i}o sh qo}vo uqofuddr ikc wodd+

B jivo g}ois fibsj sjis wo qjidd kovo} o`m}iao ikc |o}qbqs bk i fisid o}}h}5 ikc ros wo  qsbdd `bgjs ch qh$ fiddbmdoju`ik mobkgq sjis wo i}o+ Sjbq bq sjo i}oi bk sjo fusu}o dbfo hf I+I+ wjo}o wo aik kovo} mo shh |}ucoks h} shhvbgbdiks+ Dos uq khs qu||hqo$ nuqs moaiuqo I+I+ iq i wjhdo jiq kovo} jic i g}bovhuq |}hmdo`$ sjis bs kovo} 

wbdd……++Wbsjbk I+I$ B qu||hqo wo qjidd idwirq yui}}od i ghhc mbs……+ Wo qjidd jivo hu} ajbdcbqj q|isq ikc qkbsq……+++Ikr mukaj hf g}hwbkg ajbdc}ok *ikc sjis bq wjis wo }oiddr i}o" whudc ji}cdr mo bk aji}iaso} bf sjor cbc doqq+ Sjoqoi}o sjo g}hwbkg |ibkq hf bkfikar$ ikc wo iasuiddr sj}bvo hk sjo`+ ……

Mus sjo}o i}o kovo}sjodoqq ao}sibk i}oiq wjo}o ikgo} ikc ahksoksbhk ahudc |}hvo sh mo hu} ukchbkg+ Wo ekhw sjbq moaiuqo qs}hkgo} qhabosboq sjik hu} hwk jivo mook ukchko+ Sjo wjhdo `hco}k wh}dc bq bk fias ah`bkg i|i}s iqkovo} mofh}o moaiuqo hf |hdbsbaid ikc }odbgbhuq qs}bfo5 moaiuqo `ok mdbkcdr |u}quo woidsj$ fi`o$ ikc |o}qhkid |hwo}$ }ogi}cdoqq hf sjo ahkqoyuokaoq sh ikrhko$ ovok sjo`qodvoq+ Sjoqo i}o sjo coqs}uasbvo c}bvoq sjis i}obkovbsimdr q|u}}oc hk mr qodf ‑ nuqsbfbaisbhk$ ikc bk idd sjob} cbqiqs}huq ahddbqbhkq sjor i}o |hwo}oc mr }bgjsohuqbkcbgkisbhk$ sjok mr uk}oiqhkbkg ikgo}$ ikc fbkiddr mdbkc fu}r+ Wbsj sjo `hqs joi}s fods g}isbsuco B aik }o|h}s sjiswo jivo kovo} ros jic sh okcu}o ikr quaj s}bidq mr fb}o bk I+I+ Bk idd sjoqo swoksr `i}voddhuq roi}q kh quaj sjbkgiq }odbgbhuq h} |hdbsbaid cbqqokqbhk jiq shuajoc uq+ Vo}r fow jivo s}boc sh oz|dhbs I+I+ fh} woidsj h} fi`o h}  |o}qhkid |hwo}……++‐

Sjbq roi}$ =<99 `i}eoc ikhsjo} I+I+ ikkbvo}qi}r$ wjbaj i fow `bgjs jivoiaekhwdocgoc+ Sjbq$ sjo 3<sj ikkbvo}qi}r bk wjbaj I+I+ jiq qshhc wbsjhus Mbdd W‒qovo} |}ucoks$ ovo} vbgbdiks —Qsh| Dhhe Dbqsok‐ *Ahkao|s 9" doico}qjb|+ Sjbq |iqqociwir wbsj jb` hk Nikui}r =6 sj 9279+ Iq wo aik qu}vor sjo foddhwqjb| shcir$ |o}ji|qbs bq khw sb`o sh —Qsh| Dhhe Dbqsok+‐ \o}ji|q wo jivo sieok hu} oroq hff sjo midd wbsj—Hu} |}h`hso} f}bokc‐+ \o}ji|q bs bq sb`o sh dhhe vo}r qo}bhuqdr is hu} S}icbsbhkq$ khsiq quggoqsbhkq$ mus sjo vo}r |}bkab|doq u|hk wjbaj sjo qu}vbvid hf hu} foddhwqjb|co|okcq+ Nuqs sh sjo cog}oo sjis wo covbiso f}h` sjoqo |}bkab|doq bq |}oabqodr sjocog}oo sh wjbaj sjo foddhwqjb| cbqbksog}isoq+

36

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 48/63

\o}ji|q bs bq khw sb`o sh dhhe vo}r adhqodr is ahkao|s BZ+ Ikc iqe hu}qodvoq$ sh wjbaj |i}sr ch B modhkg sh$ sjo |hdbsbabik‒q h} sjo qsisoq`ik‒q8

I ‚qsisoq`ik‒ bq ik bkcbvbcuid wjh aik |us sjo |}bkab|do hf I+I+ S}icbsbhk mofh}o sjob} hwk |o}qhkidbsr5 qodf qia}bfbabkg$ ovo} vbgbdiks$ |}ucoksdr hk gui}c$ wbsj ik bksog}bsrsjis m}hheq kh ah`|}h`bqo5 dbeo sjo Qsisoq`ok wjh okahukso}oc Ajuae C+ bk 92?:+

—I qsisoq`ik bq ik bkcbvbcuid wjh aik……++ovok bk i q`idd `bkh}bsr sieo i qsikc igibkqs i qsh}`……+qsbae fdisfhhsoc sh hkoq ahkvbasbhkq imhus ik bqquo uksbd bs bq qossdoc……+fiao joivr ikc qh`osb`oq dhkg-ahksbkuoca}bsbabq`………ghmq hf }u`hu}q$ ghqqb|$ ikc goko}id qaussdomuss…‐ *Ahkao|s BZ"

Ozi`|doq hf khk idahjhdba Qsisoq`ok bk I+I+ jbqsh}r>

—@uaj diso} wo }oidbqoc wjis @}+ ]haeo}foddo} jic }oiddr chko fh} uq+ Is }bqe hf |o}qhkid }bcbaudo$ jo jic qshhc u| mofh}o sjo wjhdo wh}dc sh |us bk i |dug fh} i sbkr Qhabosr hf qs}uggdbkg idahjhdbaq‐ *Mbdd W+ }ofo}}bkg sh sjo jod|gbvok sh I+I+ mr Nhjk C+ ]haeo}foddo} N}+" *I+I+ G}i|ovbko @ir 92??+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 937"

—C}+ Qbdewh}sj dos `o wh}e wbsj i fow |oh|do bk sjo jhq|bsid is sjo }bqe hf jbq }o|usisbhk+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko

Nudr 926:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo =:?"

—Is vo}r ahkqbco}imdo }bqe sh jbq |}hfoqqbhkid qsikcbkg Ji}}r Sbomus ovo} qbkao ahksbkuoc sh okch}qo I+I+ ikc bsqwh}e sh sjo |qrajbis}ba |}hfoqqbhk+‐ *Mbdd W+ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 3"

Sjo fhddhwbkg |i}ig}i|j bq ik ozi`|do hf sjo vhbao hf hko hf shcir‒q Qsisoq`ok5sjhugj bs bq ukfh}sukiso sjo }ovbow ah``bssoo ahudc khs ah`o hus wbsj i ukbfboc vhbaohk sjbq |}bkab|do>

—Fbkiddr S}icbsbhk Swh soddq `o wo jivo mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr ‑ i dhvbkg Ghc iq Jo oz|}oqqoq jb`qodf bk hu} g}hu| ahkqabokao+ Bs qoo`q sh `o bf wo iddhw bkso}|}osisbhkq hf sjo Mbg Mhhe sj}hugj qsucr gubcoq wo wbdd idqhukco}`bko hu} udsb`iso iusjh}bsr+‐ *F}h` I+I+ Wh}dc Qo}vbaoq —Mbg Mhhe Qsucr Gubcoq> ]ovbowbkg i |hqbsbhk |i|o} ‑ II Qo}vbao Kowq$ Kh+9=7 Qu``o} =<<6 ( Mhz 3?2$ vhd+?9$ Kh+6+ Coao`mo} =<<?"

I ‚|hdbsbah‒ bq ik bkcbvbcuid wjh ai}}boq i |}bkab|do hkdr qh fi} iq fh} bs khs mo hf  |o}qhkid ahqs sh jb`qodf5 jo imqhdvoq jb`qodf hf jbq codogisoc }oq|hkqbmbdbsr ikciusjh}bsr mr s}rbkg sh eoo| sjo |oiao$ s}rbkg sh |doiqo sjo |oh|do$ hko —wjh bq fh}ovo} s}rbkg sh ‚gos sjo |oh|do wjis sjor wiks‐ *Ahkao|s BZ"$ mr swbqsbkg qirbkgq dbeo —Bjivo kh h|bkbhk+ B kobsjo} okch}qo kh} h||hqo‐ —Dbvo ikc dos dbvo)‐ —Sjo}o‒q khsjbkgwo aik ch$ oiaj g}hu| bq iushkh`huq+‐ —Eoo| rhu} qbco hf sjo qs}oos adoik+‐ —Jikc bshvo}‐ —Ghc wbdd qh}s bs hus‐$ —Bsq Ghc‒q wbdd)‐ —Vhso wbsj rhu} foos)‐\hdbsbabikq$ |doiqo mo iwi}o$ sjo cbqiffoasoc i}o —vhsbkg wbsj sjob} foos+‐

  37

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 49/63

—Kh qhabosr aik fukasbhk wodd wbsjhus imdo doico}qjb| is bk idd bsq dovodq$ ikc I+I+ aik mo kh ozao|sbhk……muswjok jo shh `ooedr moah`oq ik h}co}- sieo} ikc ozo}abqoq kh nucgo`oks hf jbq hwk ‑ wodd$ jo bqk‒s i doico} isidd…+ I ‚|hdbsbah‒ bq ik bkcbvbcuid wjh bq ‚fh}ovo} s}rbkg sh gos sjo |oh|do wjis sjor wiks‒…… Ghhc doico}qjb|kovo} |iqqoq sjo muae‐…… —Iq bkcbvbcuidq ikc iq i foddhwqjb|$ wo qjidd qu}odr quffo} bf wo aiqs sjo wjhdo nhm hf  |dikkbkg fh} sh`h}}hw hksh i fisuhuq bcoi hf |}hvbcokao+ Ghc‒q }oid \}hvbcokao jiq okchwoc uq ju`ik mobkgqwbsj i ahkqbco}imdo ai|iabsr fh} fh}oqbgjs ikc Jo ovbcoksdr oz|oasq uq sh uqo bs‐+ *Mbdd W$ Ahkao|s BZ"+

Ozs}ias f}h` sjo Ahkfo}okao Aji}so} - G}ois M}bsibk>

I}sbado 1+ Ahkfo}okao bk }odisbhk sh I+I+

—Sjo Ahkfo}okao wbdd ias fh} I+I+ bk G}ois M}bsibk bk sjo |o}|osuisbhk ikc gubcikao hf bsq qo}vbaoq ikc bs wbdd idqh mo sjo vojbado mr wjbaj I+I+ bk G}ois M}bsibk aik oz|}oqq bsq vbowq hk idd `isso}q hf vbsid I+I+ |hdbar ikc iddji~i}chuq covbisbhkq f}h` I+I+ S}icbsbhk……+‐ *I+I+ Qo}vbao jikcmhhe fh} G}ois M}bsibk qoasbhk 2+9"

Sjo Goko}id Qo}vbao Mhi}c

—Sjo Goko}id Qo}vbao Mhi}c bq sjo auqshcbik hf sjo Swodvo S}icbsbhkq hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq bk G}ois M}bsibk+Iq quaj bs jiq sjo }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sh okqu}o sjis sjo S}icbsbhkq i}o |}oqo}voc bksias ikc sjis sjo foddhwqjb| hf I+I+ bkG}ois M}bsibk iasq bk iaah}cikao wbsj sjo S}icbsbhkq+‐ *I+I+ Qo}vbao jikcmhhe fh} G}ois M}bsibk qoasbhk 2+9"

\o}ji|q bs bq sb`o sh }ofdoas hk idd |}ovbhuq Ahkfo}okao }oah``okcisbhkq }ogi}cbkgsjo uqo ikc cbq|dir hf khk I+I+ |umdbqjoc dbso}isu}o ikc s}bkeos muqbkoqq bkI+I+ `oosbkgq ikc bk I+I+ ahkvoksbhkq$ ovoksq5 ikc idqh$ }oah``okcisbhkq hk q|oabid

 |u}|hqo g}hu|q+ Jivo |}ovbhuq }oah``okcisbhkq qsuae fb}`dr sh sjo |}bkab|do hf I+I+ S}icbsbhk h} jivo sjor covbisoc8 Aik sjo foddhwqjb| iffh}c Ahkfo}okao sh `ieoah`|}h`bqoq hk S}icbsbhkq8 Bq sjo foddhwqjb| quffo}bkg sjo ahkqoyuokaoq8

—Sjo Ahkfo}okao$ iq wo ekhw$ bq sjo ‚gui}cbik‒ hf sjo I+I+ S}icbsbhkq‐ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo"

Bq sjo m}hicqbco hf I+I+ S}icbsbhk mobkg codbvo}oc bk Ahkfo}okao }oah``okcisbhkq$ h} bq bs sjo ki}}hw qbco —Sh gos sjo |oh|do wjis sjor wiks‐8

_E Goko}id Qo}vbao Ahkfo}okao =<99>Ozs}iasq f}h` ahkfo}okao yuoqsbhk ikc ah``bssoo }oq|hkqo>

—Aik Ahkfo}okao `ieo quggoqsbhkq hk jhw g}hu|q ikc Bkso}g}hu|q aik wh}e mosso} sh ai}}r sjo `oqqigo sh sjoqsbdd quffo}bkg idahjhdba8 - Sjo}o bq ovbcokao sjis qs}ibkoc }odisbhkqjb|q moswook qh`o G}hu|q ikc Bkso}g}hu|qahudc mo bkjbmbsbkg sjo offoasbvokoqq hf hu} |}b`i}r |u}|hqo+‐ *II qo}vbao Kowq 93?$ =<9<"—Idd qo}vbao mhcboq i}o }o`bkcoc sjis II bq ik bkaduqbvo foddhwqjb|+ Icjo}okao sh II S}icbsbhkq$ ahkao|sq ikcwi}}iksboq okqu}oq bkaduqbvbsr+ Sjbq ah``bssoo fhukc sjis qs}ibkoc }odisbhkq moswook qh`o g}hu|q ikc Bkso}g}hu|qaik bkjbmbs sjo offoasbvokoqq hf hu} |}b`i}r |u}|hqo+ Sjo |}bkab|doq hf _kbsr$ }bgjs hf |i}sbab|isbhk$ sjis `bkh}bsrh|bkbhk `uqs mo joi}c ikc sjis kh qo}vbao mhcr jiq sjo iusjh}bsr sh sieo |ukbsbvo iasbhk wo}o o`|jiqbqoc sh jod|}oqhdvo qh`o hf sjo cbffbaudsboq okahukso}oc+‐*Ah``bssoo 3$ Yuoqsbhk =" *II Qo}vbao kowq 937$ =<99"+

3:

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 50/63

Ikhsjo} qbco sh I+I+ S}icbsbhk>

—Bk II$ sjo g}hu| jiq qs}bas db`bsisbhkq$ mus sjo bkcbvbcuid qai}aodr ikr+‐*Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?: - Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igoq ===-==?"+

S}icsbsbhk Hko> —Hu} ah``hk wodfi}o qjhudc ah`o fb}qs…‐S}icbsbhk Swh —Sjo}o bq mus hko udsb`iso iusjh}bsr…‐Ahkao|s 9= wi}}iksr qbz> —Sjis hu} ahkfo}okao wbdd mo ovo} |}ucoksdr mo hk gui}c igibkqs sr}ikkboq g}ois ikcq`idd$ wjosjo} sjoqo mo fhukc bk sjo `inh}bsr h} bk sjo `bkh}bsr+‐

Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo —Foodbkg sjo wobgjs hf idd sjoqo fh}aoq$ ao}sibk `o`mo}q wjh }uk ahukso} sh I+I+‒qS}icbsbhkq qh`osb`oq qir sjis sjor i}o mobkg aokqh}oc h} |ukbqjoc ikc sjis sjor i}o sjo}ofh}o mobkg ghvo}koc…++‐S}icbsbhk Swh> —I fow jio`h}}jigo qh micdr sjis ‑ c}ibkoc hf idd I+I+ q|b}bs ikc |}bkab|do - sjor gos c}uke+ Issb`oq sjo I+I+ dikcqai|o qoo`q sh mo dbsso}oc wbsj mdoocbkg fh}`q+‐ *S}icbsbhk Swh5 Swodvo Qso|q ikc SwodvoS}icbsbhkq |igo 917-912"+Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr 6> —Fbkiddr$ ikr swh h} sj}oo idahjhdbaq gisjo}oc shgosjo} fh} qhm}bosr `ir aidd sjo`qodvoqik I+I+ g}hu| |}hvbcoc sjis$ iq i g}hu|$ sjor jivo kh hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk‐+ *Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr 6"Ahkao|s 9=$ wi}}iksr fbvo> —Sjoqo ozi`|doq bdduqs}iso jhw fi} wo jivo id}oicr ghko sh okahu}igo f}ooch` hf iqqo`mdr$ iasbhk$ ovok qajbq`……+Bf sjor aik ch mosso} mr hsjo} `oikq$ wo i}o gdic+‐

—I+I+ qsi}soc bk i }bhs+ Bs g}hwq bk }bhsq‐ *Wi}}ok A+ ‚Ghhc Hdc sb`o}‒$ nhbkoc I+I+ 9212"*C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q$ |igo =<2"

Sjo}o aik mo kh |oiao wbsjhus nuqsbao$ kh qo}okbsr bk iki}ajr$ kh ukbsr wbsjhus

icjo}okao sh S}icbsbhk+ Hu} jbqsh}r ikc S}icbsbhkq sodd uq sjis wo kooc kovo} foi} bkso}kid ahks}hvo}qr$ i}gu`oks$ q|dbs ikc qajbq`+ Mus wjis wo ch kooc sh foi} bq ifidqo ukbsr is sjo |}bao hf S}icbsbhkq ikc fidqo |}bco is sjo oz|okqo hf ju`bdbsr+ Wo chkooc sh foi} |umdba ahks}hvo}qr aiuqoc mr sjo ah``ukbaisbhk hf i gi}mdoc `oqqigoikc covbikao f}h` S}icbsbhkq+ Sjo bksog}bsr hf I+I+ S}icbsbhkq ikc wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao `uqs mo |}oqo}voc bk sjob} iasbvo |}bkab|doq$ moaiuqo bf sjor i}oah`|}h`bqoc bs wbdd doic sh hu} cbqbksog}isbhk+

I yuhso hf C}+ Mhm hk ju`bdbsr>—+++i sjbkg wjbaj khs shh `ikr hf uq i}o mdoqqoc+‐ Sjbq wiq khs sjo —fieo ju`bdbsr hf Cbaeokq‒q _}bij Joo|‐ Kh} wiq bs —sjo chh}`is vi}bosr+‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc hdc sb`o}q |igo ==="+

32

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 51/63

Qoasbhk :

I+I+‒q Fusu}o> Ici|sisbhk h} Ovhdusbhk8

 

Mbdd W$ - Ozs}iasq f}h` —Dosq Eoo| Bs Qb`|do Mus Jhw8‐ II G}i|ovbko Nudr 926<5Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 1<1 - 1<7">

—Wo qjidd mo qso||bkg hvo} i kow sj}oqjhdc bksh hu} fusu}o+ Wo qjidd }onhbao iq wo sjbke hf sjo gbfsq ikc sjowhkco}q hf roqso}cir+ Ikc$ iq wo }o-cocbaiso hu}qodvoq sh fudfbddbkg sjo b``okqo |}h`bqo hf II‒q sh`h}}hw$ woqjidd ao}sibkdr qu}vor jhw wo qsikc shcir+ Jivo wo ‚eo|s I+I+ qb`|do‒8 H}$ ukwbssbkgdr$ jivo wo mdukco}oc8 ++++++++++++ Sjo}ofh}o wo iqe$ jiq I+I+ eo|s fibsj wbsj C}+ Mhm‒q wi}kbkg$ ‚dosq eoo| bs qb`|do‒8 Jhw aikwo |hqqbmdr qyui}o shcir‒q Swodvo Qso|q$ Swodvo S}icbsbhkq$ Goko}id Qo}vbao Ahkfo}okaoq ikc Bkso}kisbhkidAhkvoksbhkq wbsj hu} h}bgbkid ahffoo-ikc-aieo II8 …… Gokubko qb`|dbabsr fh} shcir bq sh mo fhukc$ B sjbke$ bkwjisovo} |}bkab|doq$ |}iasbaoq$ ikc qo}vbaoq aik |o}`ikoksdr okqu}o hu} wbcoq|}oic ji}`hkr ikc offoasbvokoqq+Sjo}ofh}o bs jiq mook mosso} sh qsiso hu} |}bkab|doq sjik sh doivo sjo` viguo5 mosso} sh adi}bfr sjob} i||dbaisbhkq sjiksh doivo sjoqo ukadoi}5 mosso} sh h}gikb~o hu} qo}vbaoq sjik sh doivo sjo` sh jbs-h}- `bqq `osjhcq$ h} sh khko is idd+@hqs ao}sibkdr bkcooc$ i }osu}k sh sjo ebsajok simdo o}i whudc m}bkg kh-jh|oc fh} qb`|dbabsr+ Bs whudc hkdr `oik

wjhdoqido b}}oq|hkqbmbdbsr$ cbqji}`hkr$ ikc bkoffoasbvokoqq ………… I fh}`doqq II iki}ajr$ ikb`isoc hkdr mrsjo ‚dosq gos shgosjo}‒ q|b}bs$ nuqs bqk‒s okhugj fh} IIq jo}o ikc khw+ Wjis wh}eoc fbko fh} swh qah}o `o`mo}q bk921: whk‒s wh}e is idd fh} `h}o sjik =<<$<<< hf sjo` bk 926<+ Hu} iccoc qb~o ikc sjo}ofh}o g}oiso} }oq|hkqbmbdbsrqb`|dr q|oddq sjo cbffo}okao moswook II‒q ajbdcjhhc ikc bsq ah`bkg hf igo+ Wo jivo qook sjo fhddr hf isso`|sbkgsh }oai|su}o sjo ajbdcjhhc vi}bosr hf qb`|dbabsr bk h}co} sh qbcoqso| sjo ebkc hf }oq|hkqbmbdbsr sjis `uqs mo fiaoc sh‚eoo| bs qb`|do fh} shcir‒+ Wo aikkhs |hqqbmdr su}k miae sjo adhae ikc qjhudck‒s s}r+‐

926= Mbdd W

—Wo i}o qu}o sjis oiaj g}hu| hf wh}eo}q bk wh}dc qo}vbao wbdd mo so`|soc sh s}r idd qh}sq hf bkkhvisbhkq sjis `irhfsok |}hcuao dbssdo `h}o sjik |ibkfud }o|osbsbhk oi}dbo} `bqsieoq+ Sjo}ofh}o bs wbdd mo ik b`|h}siks hmnoasbvo hf sjoqo Ahkao|sq sh fh}oqsidd quaj }o|osbsbhkq mr jhdcbkg sjo oz|o}bokaoq hf sjo |iqs adoi}dr mofh}o uq+ Ikc bf `bqsieok co|i}su}oq i}o kovo}sjodoqq `ico$ sjoqo Ahkao|sq `ir sjok |}hvbco i }oicr `oikq hf qifo }osu}k sh ik

h|o}isbkg midikao sjis `bgjs hsjo}wbqo sieo roi}q hf fdhukco}bkg sh }ocbqahvo}+‐ *Bks}hcuasbhk sh sjo SwodvoAhkao|sq fh} Wh}dc Qo}vbao+"

92?:$ Fom}ui}r$ Mbdd W+

—Khw sjo}o i}o ao}sibk sjbkgq sjis II aikkhs ch fh} ikrmhcr$ }ogi}cdoqq hf wjis hu} qovo}id coqb}oq h} qr`|isjboq`ir mo+Hu} fb}qs cusr$ iq i qhabosr bq sh okqu}o$ hu} hwk qu}vbvid+ Sjo}ofh}o wo jivo sh ivhbc cbqs}iasbhkq ikc`udsb|u}|hqo iasbvbsr+ Ik II g}hu| iq quaj$ aikkhs sieo hk idd sjo |o}qhkid |}hmdo`q hf bsq `o`mo}q$ dos idhko sjo |}hmdo`q hf sjo wjhdo wh}dc+ Qhm}bosr ‑ f}ooch` f}h` idahjhd ‑ sjhugj sjo soiajbkg ikc |}iasbao hf II‒q swodvoqso|q$ bq sjo qhdo |u}|hqo hf ik II g}hu|+ G}hu|q jivo }o|oisoc s}boc hsjo} iasbvbsboq sjor jivo idwirq fibdoc+ Wojivo sh ahkfbko hu} `o`mo}qjb| sh idahjhdbaq ikc wo jivo sh ahkfbko hu} II g}hu|q sh i qbkgdo |u}|hqo+ Bf wochk‒s qsbae sh sjoqo |}bkab|doq$ wo qjidd id`hqs ao}sibkdr ahddi|qo+ Ikc bf wo ahddi|qo$ wo aikkhs jod| ikrhko … …

?<

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 52/63

… … Sjo}ofh}o B qoo kh wir hf `iebkg khkidahjhdba UqbaP iccbasq bksh II `o`mo}q$ Oz|o}bokao qirq dhucdr sjiswo aik ic`bs kh ozao|sbhkq$ ovok sjhugj c}ug uqo}q ikc idahjhdbaq ji||ok sh mo fb}qs ahuqbkq hf i qh}s+ Bf wo |o}qbqs bk s}rbkg sjbq$ B‒` if}ibc bs wbdd mo ji}c hk sjo c}ug uqo} jb`qodf$ iq wodd iq hk II+ Wo `uqs iaao|s sjo fiassjis kh khkidahjhdba$ UqbaP wjisovo} jbq iffdbasbhk$ aik mo ahkvo}soc bksh ik idahjhdba II `o`mo}+‐ *I+I+G}i|ovbko Fom}ui}r 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo ==1"

92?:$ Nikui}r - Iuguqs$ Qiksi @hkbai

Qrkikhk mogik wbsj Aji}doq O+ Coco}bae+ Jo jic mook ik idahjhdba fh} swoksr roi}q$ ikc i `o`mo} hf Idahjhdbaq

Ikhkr`huq+ Bk Nikui}r hf 92?:$ jo —jic kh nhm$ swh aoksq bk `r |haeos$ ikc wiq dbvbkg hff uko`|dhr`oks mokofbsq$ bk i q`idd i|i}s`oks koi} sjo moiaj bk Haoik \i}e$ Aidbfh}kbi+‐ *Rimdhkqer$ D+ 926?+ Qrkikhk sjo sukkod miae " Jo$ ikc hsjo} f}bokcq f}h` II$ qsi}soc i }ogudi} wooedr `oosbkg+ Bk sjbq `oosbkg$ `ibkdr moaiuqo hf Aji}doq$ h} —Ajuae‐ Coco}bae$ iq jo moai`o ekhwk$ sjo cbqauqqbhkq moai`o joisoc…+ …+ … Sjbq II g}hu| `osuksbd i c}i`isba m}oie sjis qhdbcbfboc sjo cbffo}okao moswook Qrkikhk$ ikc I+I+ Sjbq bq sjo qsh}r iq shdc mr Ajuae>

 

—Sjo m}oie wbsj Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq haau}}oc imhus sjo `bccdo hf Iuguqs *92?:"Bs ji||okoc }bgjs bk sjo `bccdo hf ik I+I+ `oosbkg+ Hu} wjhdo gikg jic sieok hvo} sjo Qisu}cir kbgjs `oosbkg hf sjo Qiksi @hkbai I+I+ g}hu| is Swoksr Qbzsj ikc M}hicwir ikc mubds bs u| f}h` bsq issokcikao hf sok |oh|do sh ikissokcikao hf imhus fh}sr fbvo h} fbfsr+ Sjo}o wiq qh`o hmnoasbhk hk qh`o bqquo mr sjo `o`mo}q hf sjo Mhi}c hf Cb}oash}q hf sjo I+I+ adum+ B }oaidd sjo doico} qsh||bkg sjo `oosbkg+ Sjor cbck‒s dbeo uq+ Sjo ideboq cbck‒s dbeo sjoiccbasq$ ikc sjor cbck‒s dbeo `o bk |i}sbaudi}… … ikc sjor cbck‒s dbeo `r gikg moaiuqo sjor wo}o `hqsdr iccbasq+Sjor `ico sjbkgq cbffbauds fh} uq+ B }o`o`mo} gossbkg u| bk sjo `oosbkg ikc qirbkg$ ‚Idd }bgjs$ dos‒q gh jh`o-sjojodd wbsj sjbq+‒ Qh sjo wjhdo `oosbkg ghs u|$ ikc wo idd ghs bksh hu} iush`hmbdoq ikc ai`o chwk sh sjo adum$ ikc

wo kovo} woks miae sh I+I+ igibk…+ … … Wo wo}o mubdcbkg qh`osjbkg kow ikc cbffo}oks… … … Wo jivo idbvo-bk qbsuisbhk$ wbsj fi`bdr aji}iaso}bqsbaq+ Wo o`|jiqb~o qodf-}odbikao }isjo} sjik co|okcokao hk i jbgjo} mobkg+Wo iqqu`oc i }oq|hkqbmbdbsr5 wo jic sh gos u| sjo }oks$ wo jic sh fooc sjo |oh|do wjok sjor ai`o bk$ ikc qh hk+Sjbq wiq sjo |hbks is wjbaj sjo fow idahjhdbaq bk sjo adum mogik sh fidd hus+ Sjor cbck‒s wiks ikr }oq|hkqbmbdbsr+ Bkfias$ bs wiq ovok vo}midb~oc+ ‚Wo chk‒s wiks sh ch sjbq5 wo wiks sh jivo i dhs hf fuk5 wo wiks sh jivo i adum iq iadum+‒ Sjo ideboq mogik sh qir$ ‚Wodd$ bs‒q hu} adum$‒ ikc B qibc$ ‚Kh$ bs‒q `r adum+‒ B moai`o sjo aji`|bhk hf sjoiccbasq$ ajuaeoc sjo idahjhdbaq hus$ ikc Qrkikhk wiq sjok fuddr diukajoc fh} iccbasq+‐*Rimdhkqer$ D+ 926?"*F}h` sjo Coqe hf Nuik Doqokco> Jhw C}ug Imuqo S}ois`oks Su}kq bksh @bqs}ois`oks Mr Nuik O+ Doqokco -Qo|so`mo} 9:sj =<<2"jss|>((www+s}ois`oksqhdusbhkqkoswh}e+ah`(mdhg(bkcoz+|j|(=<<2(<2(9:(f}h`-sjo-coqe-hf-nuik-doqokco-jhw-c}ug-imuqo-s}ois`oks-su}kq-bksh-`bqs}ois`oks(

Sjo Wiqjbkgshkbik `hvo`oks ovhdvoc bksh `udsb |u}|hqo iasbvbsr ikc ahddi|qoc+ SjoHzfh}c G}hu| ovhdvoc }oki`bkg bsqodf @h}id ]oi}`i`oks bk 921:+ Sjo auds hf Qrkikhk ovhdvoc bksh `udsb |u}|hqo iasbvbsr ikc ahddi|qoc+

II jiq qshhc sjo soqs hf sb`o moaiuqo bs aikkhs ovhdvo dbeo hsjo} h}gikbqisbhkq$S}icbsbhkq ikc Ahkao|sq |}ovoks sjbq+ Sjo cb}oasbhk hf II ovhdusbhk wiq f}h`cbvo}qbsr sh qb`|dbabsr+ II aikkhs ovhdvo sh gos ikr qb`|do} sjik g}hu|q wbsj `oosbkg}hh`q$ qbkgdo |u}|hqo$ qbkgdo iffbdbisbhk$ ikc i qo}vbao qs}uasu}o sh qu||h}s sjo`+

?9

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 53/63

Bs bq b`|h}siks sh cbqsbkgubqj moswook ici|sisbhk ikc ovhdusbhk+ Sjo qo}vbao qs}uasu}o`uqs h}gikbqo ikc ici|s sh ajikgoq bk qhabosr$ mus sjo I+I+ g}hu| bq mhukc mr I+I+S}icbsbhk$ bsq soiajbkg hf sjo swodvo qso|q sj}hugj doiqs |hqqbmdo h}gikbqisbhk+

S}icbsbhk Kbko *Dhkg fh}`">—Oiaj I+I+ g}hu| koocq sjo doiqs |hqqbmdo h}gikb~isbhk+ ]hsisbkg doico}qjb| bq sjo moqs+ Sjo q`idd g}hu| `ir odoasbsq qoa}osi}r$ sjo di}go g}hu| bsq }hsisbkg ah``bssoo ikc sjo g}hu|q hf i di}go `os}h|hdbsik i}oi sjob} aoks}id h} bkso}g}hu| ah``bssoo‐

Mbdd W$ Kow Rh}e 9212> —Sjor wo}o qs}uasu}oc sh sjo ozsoks sjis sjo}o wiq idwirq hko q|oieo} ikc Mbdd- `irmojidf ik jhu} oiaj - ikc sjok i dhkg ahffoo qoqqbhk$ i }oid gos shgosjo}+ Wo wo}o hfsok sjo}o sbdd 9= h‒adhae$ qsi}soc isobgjs+…++ Is sjbq sb`o sjo}o wo}o kh 2<-cirq }oyub}o`oksq+ Kh mb}sjcirq ‑ kh }oahgkbsbhk wiq `ico bf rhu wo}oqhmo} i wooe h} i roi}$ Bf rhu fods rhu whudc dbeo sh q|oie bk i roi} h} bk i `hksj h} swh wooeq sjor dos rhu gos u|ikc q|oie$ ikc sjor cbck‒s sj}hw rhu hus bf rhu wo}o c}uke$ obsjo}+ Sjor fods bs wiq okahu}igbkg$ jh|bkg qh`o

wh}c whudc qsbae+‐ *]usj Jhae$ sjo fb}qs qoa}osi}r hf sjo Kow Rh}e Goko}id Qo}vbao Hffbao+ \iqq bs hk |igo =92"

II+ G}i|ovbko =<9<B qs}uggdo sh ukco}qsikc sjo Swodvo ikc Swodvo$ ovok wbsj i ahddogo cog}oo ikc jod| f}h` `r q|hkqh} ikc hsjo} IIq+ @oikwjbdo$ `r }hh``iso$ idqh kowdr qhmo} ikc wbsj i g}ico qajhhd ocuaisbhk$ aik's `ieo ikr qokqo hf jo} Qso| wh}emhhe ikc bq imhus sh gbvo u|+ Jhw `ikr |oh|do ch wo dhqo sjbq wir8 Jhw `ikr$ wjok iqeoc sh }oic

f}h` sjo Mbg Mhhe is i `oosbkg$ qsu`mdo sj}hugj i fow qoksokaoq$ iausodr o`mi}}iqqoc$ ikc kovo} ah`o miae8 Idbso}isu}o-miqoc |}hg}i` offoasbvodr qjusq hus |oh|do wjh coq|o}isodr kooc jod| mus ch khs jivo ghhc }oicbkgqebddq‐+ *Coi} G}i|ovbko$ Qjus Hus5 I+I+ G}i|ovbko Khvo`mo} =<9<"

—Ocuaisbhk wbdd khs hkdr |ir hff bk ku`mo}q s}oisoc5 bs aik |ir hff ovok `h}o jikcqh`odr bk |}ovoksbhk… … bs bq mhsj i ah``ukbsr nhm ikc i nhm fh} q|oabidbqsq… … mus II iq quaj aikkhs$ ikc qjhudc khs$ gos cb}oasdr bksh sjbqfbodc+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko @i}aj 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9:6-9:7"

 Kh}`ik R$ 9277$ nhbkoc II bk 9212—‚B kovo} }oic i wh}c bk I+I+‒ jo qibc+ ‚Rhu chk‒s jivo sh }oic+ Rhu chk‒s jivo sh jivo idd sjoqo |i`|jdosq sjor |us hus+ Rhu aik doi}k sh dbvo sjbq |}hg}i` mr doi}kbkg sh sjbke+ I+I+ bq i whkco}fud sjbkg sh ekhw ikc i||dr‒jo qibc$ ‚- mus bk rhu} dbfo+ Rhu‒vo ghs sh dbvo bs hus bk sjo qs}oos+ Rhu qoo qh`omhcr jivbkg i dbssdo |}hmdo`$ jod|sjo`$ kh `isso} wjh sjor i}o+ Sjis‒q I+I+‐ ‑Kh}`ik R+ *C}+ Mhm ikc Sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo =?9-=?<"

—Wo jivo kh chas}bko sjis jiq sh mo `ibksibkoc+ Wo jivo kh `o`mo}qjb| sjis jiq sh mo okdi}goc+ Wo jivo kh

iusjh}bsr sjis jiq sh mo qu||h}soc+ Wo jivo kh |}oqsbgo$ |hwo} h} |}bco sjis jiq sh mo qisbqfboc+‐ Mbdd W+ *Ahkao|s9=$ wi}}iksr Fbvo"

Wjis wh}eoc qs}uasu}iddr bk 921: whudck‒s wh}e bk 926<$ wjis wh}eoc bk 926<choqk‒s i||oi} sh mo wh}ebkg vo}r wodd bk =<99+ \o}ji|q sjo}o koocq sh mo iwbddbkgkoqq sh mo h|ok sh ajikgo+

Sjo}o i}o sjo kow crki`baq hf khk-II |umdbqjoc dbso}isu}o$ gdhmid bkso}kosah``ukbaisbhk5 sjo foddhwqjb| bq `uaj di}go} ikc ros sjo kow ah``ukbaisbhkajikkodq `ieo bs `h}o bksb`iso+

?=

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 54/63

Bf sjo foddhwqjb| jiq g}hwk shh mbg fh} sjo S}uqsooq bk sjo _E ikc _QI sh ah|o wbsjsjo ku`mo}q hf sjhqo wjh oz|dhbs sjo foddhwqjb|$ |o}ji|q qh`o hf sjbq }oq|hkqbmbdbsrahudc mo |iqqoc sh sjo g}hu|q vbi ah``ukbaisbhk sh sjo`+

Sjo}o koocq sh mo kow sjbkebkg sh qubs kow qbsuisbhkq+ Sjo wir bk wjbaj g}hu|q i}o}ogbqso}oc ahudc mo ahkqbco}oc+ Sjo |iqqbkg hf }oq|hkqbmbdbsr hf g}hu| }ogbqs}isbhkf}h` GQH sh sjo bkso}g}hu| whudc f}oo sjo I+I+ g}hu| ahkqabokao sh cbqao}k wjosjo} i |i}sbaudi} g}hu| sjis bq h|o}isbkg husqbco sjo qo}vbao qs}uasu}o bq h|o}isbkg iaah}cbkg

sh S}icbsbhk ikc wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao5 wjosjo} bs bq hko sjis bq qb`|dr ozo}abqbkgbsq }bgjs sh g}hu| iushkh`r mr khs mobkg |i}s hf sjo bkso}g}hu|5 h} wjosjo} sjo g}hu|bq `bquqbkg sjo II ki`o mr hsjo} |u}|hqo h} iffbdbisbhk+ Sjoqo `isso}q ahudc moqossdoc dhaiddr mr bkso}g}hu| ahkqabokao+

B`|}hvoc ah``ukbaisbhk bk sjo foddhwqjb| ahudc mo okahu}igoc+Wjo}o bkso}kisbhkiddr iffbdbisoc auds g}hu|q ozbqs$ II g}hu|q ikc bkso}g}hu|q ahudc mookahu}igoc sh ah``ukbaiso wbsj oiaj hsjo} cb}oasdr ia}hqq }ogbhkid ikc bkso}kisbhkid

 mhukci}boq bkqsoic hf mobkg bqhdisoc$ gbvbkg bkfh}`isbhk ozajikgo ikc ahh|o}isbhk+

Iq }oq|hkqbmdo bkcbvbcuidq ikr I+I+ `o`mo} bq fuddr oksbsdoc sh ias f}oodr iaah}cbkg shjbq h} jo} hwk ahkqabokao+ Dosso}q h} o`ibdq ahudc mo qoks sh ikr S}icbsbhkq vbhdish}$g}hu|$ h} ah`|ikr sjis bq `bquqbkg sjo I+I+ ki`o+

—B i` }oq|hkqbmdo+ Wjok ikrhko$ ikrwjo}o$ }oiajoq hus fh} jod|$ B wiks sjo jikc hf I+I+ idwirq sh mo sjo}o+ Ikcfh} sjis> B i` }oq|hkqbmdo+‐

 

?1

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 55/63

Qoasbhk 2I}o wo ah``ukbaisbkg sjo I+I+ `oqqigo

bk sjo }bgjs wir8@hqs I+I+ `o`mo}q i}o |}hmimdr iwi}o sjo ku`o}baid g}hwsj bk II jiq qsigkisoc bk}oaoks roi}q+ Wjbdo sjo}o `ir mo `ikr ahks}bmusbkg fiash}q$ wo yuoqsbhk hkdr hkoiq|oas jo}o$ wjosjo} I+I‒q }hhsq bk mhsj `ocbabko ikc }odbgbhk i}o mobkgah``ukbaisoc s}usjfuddr ikc jhdbqsbaiddr bk |}oqoks cir I+I+ |umdba ikc kowah`o} }odisbhkq+ H} jiq sjo}o mook shh fi} i qjbfs shwi}c |}h`hsbkg I+I+ iq i q|b}bsuid(}odbgbhuq |}hg}i`$ iwir f}h` sjis wjbaj bq oqqoksbiddr i |}ig`isba |}hg}i` hf ah|bkg

wbsj idahjhdbq` iq ik bddkoqq8

Bs whudc i||oi} f}h` sjo oi}dboqs cirq sh sjo |}oqoks$ sjo |}oqoksisbhk hf I+I+ iq iq|b}bsuid |}hg}i` bq `bqukco}qshhc ikc i g}ois mi}}bo} sh hvo}ah`o fh} `ikr bf khs`hqs kowah`o}q+ Fh} `ikr |oh|do bk qhabosr$ sjo wh}cq —q|b}bsuid‐ ikc —}odbgbhuq‐i}o bkso}ajikgoimdo$ fh} hsjo}q sjor `oik sjo qi`o sjbkg+ I yuoqsbhk sh iqe bq> Ch

 |oh|do khw sjbke I+I+ bq }odbgbhuq8 Ch sjo uqo hf sjo wh}c Ghc ikc sjo qo}okbsr |}iro} bk |umdba }odisbhkq( kowah`o} dbso}isu}o gbvo i }odbgbhuq b`|}oqqbhk ikc |usku`mo}q hf idahjhdbaq hff f}h` `iebkg bkbsbid ahksias8 Whudc sjo }o`hvid hf sjowh}c Ghc ikc sjo qo}okbsr |}iro} f}h` |umdba }odisbhkq( kowah`o} dbso}isu}o ikc}o|diabkg sjo` wbsj so}`q quaj iq —qh`o |hwo} morhkc sjo`qodvoq‐ mo `h}ooffoasbvo bk iss}iasbkg ikc }osibkbkg qao|sbaid kowah`o}q8

—Nuqs mofh}o doivbkg fh} Ie}hk$ C}+ Qbdewh}sj jic gbvok `o i g}ois |boao hf icvbao+ Wbsjhus bs I+I+ `bgjs kovo} jivo mook mh}k+ ‚Dhhe$ Mbdd$‒ jo jic qibc ‚rhu‒}o jivbkg khsjbkg mus fibdu}o moaiuqo rhu i}o |}oiajbkg is sjoqoidahjhdbaq… …sidebkg sh sjo` imhus sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| |}oao|sq… … sjok rhu sh| bs hff mr ji}|bkg hk imhus sjbq`rqso}bhuq q|b}bsuid oz|o}bokao hf rhu}q… … …wjr chk‒s rhu su}k rhu} qs}isogr sjo hsjo} wir }hukc8 … …I}ok‒s rhu sjo foddhw wjh hkao qjhwoc `o sjis mhhe mr sjo |qrajhdhgbqs Wbddbi` Ni`oq8 … … … Jivo rhufh}ghssok C}+ Ai}d Rukg bk ^u}baj… …Mbdd rhu jivo ghs sjo ai}s mofh}o sjo jh}qo… … Rhu‒vo ghs sh cofdisosjoqo |oh|do fb}qs… … Qh gbvo sjo` sjo `ocbaid muqbkoqq$ ikc gbvo bs sh sjo` ji}c+ \hu} bs }bgjs bksh sjo` imhussjo hmqoqqbhk sjis ahkco`kq sjo` sh c}bke ikc sjo |jrqbaid qokqbsbvbsr h} iddo}gr hf sjo mhcr sjis ahkco`kq sjo`sh gh `ic h} cbo bf sjor eoo| hk c}bkebkg… … @irmo sjis wbdd a}iae sjob} oghq coo| chwk…+ … Hkdr sjok aikrhu s}r rhu} hsjo} `ocbabko$ sjo osjbaid |}bkab|doq… ++‐ *Mbdd W+ II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 6:"

  ?3

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 56/63

—Sjo wh}c Ghc qsbdd i}huqoc qh`o iksb|isjr+ Wjok sjo sjhugjs wiq oz|}oqqoc sjis sjo}o `bgjs mo i Ghc |o}qhkidsh `o sjbq foodbkg bksokqbfboc+ B cbck‒s dbeo sjo bcoi+ B ahudc gh fh} quaj ahkao|sbhkq iq A}oisbvo Bksoddbgokao$_kbvo}qid @bkc h} Q|b}bs hf Kisu}o mus B }oqbqsoc sjo bcoi hf i A~i} hf sjo Joivokq… … @r f}bokc quggoqsoc wjissjok qoo`oc i khvod bcoi —Wjr chk‒s rhu ajhhqo rhu} hwk ahkao|s hf Ghc8‐ ‑ Mbdd W+ *Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq—Mbg Mhhe‐ |igo 9="

—Fbs~ fodd is hkao bksh i jhs i}gu`oks wbsj Jok}r imhus sjo }odbgbhuq ahksoks hf sjo ah`bkg vhdu`o+ I kowah`o} Nb``r M+$ wjh dbeo Jok}r wiq ik oz qidoq`ik ikc i fh}`o} isjobqs idqh ghs bksh sjo jiqqdoq+ Fbs~ wiksoc i |hwo}fuddr }odbgbhuq chau`oks5 Jok}r ikc Nb``r whudc jivo khko hf bs+ Sjor wiksoc i |qrajhdhgbaid mhhe wjbaj

whudc du}o sjo }oico} bk5 wjok jo fbkiddr i}}bvoc i`hkg uq$ sjo}o whudc sjok mo okhugj sb`o sh sb| jb` hff imhussjo q|b}bsuid aji}iaso} hf hu} qhabosr+‐ *I+I+ ah`oq hf Igo |igo 97"

—C}+ Jhwi}c i |qrajbis}bqs… … `ico ik b`|h}siks ahks}bmusbhk… … Mbdd qibc sjo |qrajbis}bqs‒q ‚bcoi wiq sh}o`hvo idd fh}`q hf aho}abhk$ sh |us hu} foddhwqjb| hk i ‚wo hugjs‒ miqbq bkqsoic hf ‚rhu `uqs‒ miqbq… … …‚C}+ Jhwi}c }oic Usjo `ikuqa}b|sP ikc m}hugjs bs miae sjo kozs cir‒… ‚Rhu jivo sh sieo hus sjo `uqs+ Rhu jivosh sieo hus sjo Ghc ‑ sjo ah`|doso Ghc+‒ ‐ *\iqq Bs Hk |igo =<3"

 —++ C}+ Ji}}r Sbomus$ sjo fb}qs |qrajbis}bqs ovo} sh jhdc u| sjo jikcq hf hu} foddhwqjb| fh} idd sh qoo… … … Sjoroi} wiq 9212$ ikc sjo mhhe  Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq wiq imhus sh jbs sjo |}oqq… …wo jic `ico |}o|umdbaisbhkah|boq bk `udsbg}i|j UqbaP … … Hko hf sjo` fodd bksh Ji}}r‒q jikcq… …jo is hkao }oqhdvoc sh qjhw sjo kowvhdu`o sh i ahu|do hf |isboksq$ qbkao ekhwk sh uq iq @i}sr ikc G}okkr … …Is fb}qs sjo mhhe `ico dbssdob`|}oqqbhk … … bsq joivr di}cbkg wbsj sjo wh}c Ghc qh ikgo}oc @i}sr sjis qjo sj}ow bs hus hf sjo wbkchw$

fdhukaoc hff sjo g}hukcq… … ikc |}haoococ… hk i mbg mokco}… … Miae bk jo} yui}so}q$ @i}sr fbkiddr m}hugjsjo}qodf sh doif sj}hugj bsq |igoq hkao `h}o+ I qbkgdo |j}iqo aiugjs jo} oro ikc bs }oic ‚Wo aikkhs dbvo wbsj}oqoks`oks‒… … Fh}sjwbsj qjo issokcoc i `oosbkg… … ]osu}kbkg … … qjo fhukc G}okkr bksokqodr au}bhuq…… Jo} fb}qs wh}cq sh jb` wo}o ‚G}okkr wo i}o khs idhko ikr `h}o)‒ ‐ *Mbdd W+ I+I+ G}i|ovbko Nudr 9266+Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 162"

—Sjo ukmodbovo}‐ *fb}qs ocbsbhk —Mbg Mhhe$‐ Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq"—B iqeoc sjo chash} sh sodd `o sjo s}usj+‐ *Oz|o}bokao Qs}okgsj ikc Jh|o |igo ?"—@ieo bs nuqs i |hwo} sjis wbdd jod|+‐ *Oz|o}bokao Qs}okgsj ikc Jh|o |igo ?"

—Ocuaisoc Igkhqsba‐ *fb}qs ocbsbhk —Mbg Mhhe$‐ Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq"—Jo shdc `o hf hsjo} `ok wjh jic fhukc qhm}bosr sj}hugj sjo }oahgkbsbhk hf qh`o |hwo} morhkc sjo`qodvoq+ Bf Bai}oc sh B wiq sh ahkqbco} `rqodf bkvbsoc sh i gisjo}bkg sjo fhddhwbkg Suoqcir wjo}o B ahudc `oos hsjo} idahjhdbaqwjh jic qsh||oc+‐ *Oz|o}bokao Qs}okgsj ikc Jh|o |igo 9<3"

—Hf jbgjoqs b`|h}sikao whudc mo hu} }odisbhkq wbsj `ocbabko ikc }odbgbhk+ _kco} kh ab}au`qsikaoq `uqs wo gosbksh ah`|osbsbhk wbsj obsjo}+ Bf wo i||oi}oc sh mo i kow }odbgbhuq qoas$ wo‒c mo chko fh}+ Ikc bf wo `hvoc bksh sjo`ocbaid fbodc$ iq quaj$ sjo }oquds whudc mo sjo qi`o+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko Nuko 92??$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9?<"

—I KOW I\\]HIAJ SH \QRAJHSJO]I\R BK AJ]HKBA IDAHJHDBQ@‐ C}+ W+C Qbdewh}sj @+C+$ Nhu}kid Dikaos$ Nudr 9212+—Sjoqo oz-idahjhdba `ok ikc wh`ok ku`mo} imhus hko jukc}oc is |}oqoks+ Hko G}hu| bq qaisso}oc idhkg sjoIsdiksba qoimhi}c wbsj Kow Rh}e iq i aokso}+ UqbaP Ikhsjo} ikc qh`owjis di}go} mhcr bq dhaisoc bk sjo @bccdoWoqs… … … Sjo foddhwqjb| bq oksb}odr bkcbffo}oks ahkao}kbkg sjo bkcbvbcuid `ikko} hf q|b}bsuid i||}hiaj qh dhkgiq sjo |isboks bq wbddbkg sh su}k jbq dbfo ikc jbq |}hmdo`q hvo} sh sjo ai}o ikc cb}oasbhk hf jbq a}oish}+ Sjo |isboks

??

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 57/63

`ir |basu}o sjo Cobsr bk ikr wir jo dbeoq+ Kh offh}s bq wjisovo} bq `ico sh ahkvo}s jb` sh qh`o |i}sbaudi} fibsj h} a}ooc+ @ikr a}oocq i}o }o|}oqoksoc i`hkg sjo g}hu| ikc sjo g}oisoqs ji}`hkr |}ovibdq+ Bs bq o`|jiqb~oc sjis sjofoddhwqjb| bq khk-qoasi}bik ikc sjis sjo |isboks bq oksb}odr f}oo sh fhddhw jbq hwk bkadbkisbhk+ Khs i s}iao hf igg}oqqbvo ovikgodbq` bq ozjbmbsoc……Ahkqbco}bkg sjo |}oqokao hf sjo }odbgbhuq fiash}$ hko `bgjs oz|oas sh fbkcik ukjoidsjr o`hsbhkidbq` ikc |}onucbao+ Sjbq bq khs sjo aiqo jhwovo}5 hk sjo ahks}i}r sjo}o bq ik bkqsiks}oicbkoqq sh cbqai}c hdc `osjhcq fh} kow hkoq wjbaj |}hcuao mosso} }oqudsq+‐ *I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo$ i||okcbz O>i$ |igoq 1<3-1<?"

Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko I|}bd 9269

—Wo `uaj }og}os sjis sjoqo fiasq hf I+I+ dbfo i}o khs ukco}qshhc mr sjo dogbhk hf idahjhdbaq bk sjo wh}dc i}hukcuq+ Ikr ku`mo} hf sjo` i}o mocovbddoc mr sjo cb}o ahkvbasbhk sjis bf sjor ovo} gh koi} II sjor wbdd mo |}oqqu}ocsh ahkfh}` sh qh`o |i}sbaudi} m}ikc hf fibsj h} sjohdhgr+ Sjor nuqs chk‒s }oidbqo sjis fibsj bq kovo} i koaoqqbsr fh} II `o`mo}qjb|5 sjis qhm}bosr aik mo iajbovoc wbsj ik oiqbdr iaao|simdo `bkb`u` hf bs5 ikc hu} ahkao|sq hf ijbgjo} |hwo} ikc Ghc iq wo ukco}qsikc jb` iffh}c ovo}rhko i koi}dr ukdb`bsoc ajhbao hf q|b}bsuid modbof ikciasbhk‐ … … … Jhw sh s}ikq`bs sjbq ghhc kowq bq hko hf hu} `hqs ajiddokgbkg |}hmdo`q bk ah``ukbaisbhk$ fh} wjbaj sjo}o `ir mo kh fiqs h} qwoo|bkg ikqwo}+ \o}ji|q hu} |umdba bkfh}`isbhk qo}vbaoq ahudc mogbk sh o`|jiqb~osjbq idd-b`|h}siks iq|oas hf II `h}o joivbdr+ Ikc wbsjbk hu} hwk }ikeq wo `bgjs wodd covodh| i `h}oqr`|isjosba iwi}okoqq hf sjo iauso |dbgjs hf sjoqo }oiddr bqhdisoc ikc coq|o}iso quffo}o}q … … +++ … Sjhugj sj}oojukc}oc sjhuqikc cbc }oahvo} bk sjo diqs swoksr-fbvo roi}q$ `irmo jidf i `bddbhk `h}o jivo wideoc bksh hu} `bcqs$ikc sjok hus igibk… … Ros wo aik‒s wodd ahksoks hu}qodvoq wbsj sjo vbow sjis idd sjoqo }oahvo}r fibdu}oq wo}ooksb}odr sjo fiuds hf sjo kowah`o}q sjo`qodvoq … … Wo cbck‒s ah``ukbaiso wjok wo `bgjs jivo chko qh+ Qh woIIq fibdoc sjo`+ \o}ji|q `h}o hfsok sjik wo sjbke$ wo qsbdd `ieo kh ahksias wbsj sjhqo quffo}bkg sjo cbdo``i hf kh fibsj+‐ *Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo =?9 -=?="

 

Bs bq adoi} sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| bkfduokao bk sjo fh}`isbvo roi}q hf I+I+ wiq iq `uajkogisbvo iq |hqbsbvo+ Wjok ah`|i}oc sh sjo ah`mbkoc bkfduokao hf hsjo}q bk h}gikbqoc}odbgbhk ikc sjo `ocbaid |}hfoqqbhk$ wjh eo|s II hk ahu}qo iq i khk }odbgbhuqh}gikbqisbhk$ sjo sb`o q|ik hf Hzfh}c G}hu| bkfduokao wiq vo}r q`idd5 swh roi}q bk

 Kow Rh}e ikc fbvo roi}q bk Ie}hk+ Sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| ahkkoasbhk wiq idqh i |umdba}odisbhkq dbimbdbsr+ Bk vbow hf sjo bkfduokao bk I+I+ shcir hf fukci`oksidbqs Aj}bqsbikkhk I+I+ |umdbqjoc dbso}isu}o wjbaj icvhaisoq oi}dr I+I+ `oosbkgq iq Hzfh}c G}hu|`oosbkgq$ wo yuoqsbhk wjosjo} sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| ahkkoasbhk hugjs khw mo ahkfbkoc

sh sjo I+I+ jbqsh}r mhheq$ ikc khs mo `oksbhkoc is idd bk ikr |umdba bkfh}`isbhk ikckowah`o} dbso}isu}o+

—Sjo Hzfh}c G}hu|o}q jic adoi}dr qjhwk uq wjis sh ch+ Ikc$ nuqs iq b`|h}siksdr$ wo jic doi}koc f}h` sjo` wjis khs sh ch iq fi} iq idahjhdbaq wo}o ahkao}koc+ Wo jic fhukc sjis ao}sibk hf sjob} bcoiq ikc issbsucoq ahudc khs moqhdc sh idahjhdbaq+ Fh} ozi`|do$ c}bkeo}q whudc khs sieo |}oqqu}o bk ikr fh}`$ ozao|sbkg f}h` Nhjk Mi}dorah}kjb`qodf+ Sjor idwirq jic sh mo doc$ khs |uqjoc+ Sjor whudc khs qsikc fh} sjo }isjo} igg}oqqbvo ovikgodbq` hf sjoHzfh}c G}hu|q+ Ikc sjor whudc khs iaao|s sjo |}bkab|do hf ‚soi` gubcikao‒ fh} sjob} hwk |o}qhkid dbvoq+‐ *I+I+Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 73"

  ?6

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 58/63

—Jo qibc jo wiq ik idahjhdba shh… … i ajo`bqs}r |}hfoqqh} wjh wiq mi}odr `ikigbkg sh jhdc hk sh jbq soiajbkg |hqs+ Jo jic ah`o sh sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| is jbq wbfo‒q u}gbkg$ mus jo ahudc khs qsikc sjob} ‚khk- qokqbaid‒ UqbaP side imhus Ghc$ kh} cbc jo dbeo idd sjoqo ‚igg}oqqbvo |oh|do‒ wjh wo}o s}rbkg sh qivo jbq qhud+ Ikc wjbdo jo ahudc khsiaao|s Mbdd‒q ‚wob}c‒ }odbgbhuq oz|o}bokao$ jo ao}sibkdr cbc ig}oo wbsj wjis Mbdd qibc imhus idahjhdbq`… …joqsiroc c}uke hk ikc hff fh} 99 roi}q mofh}o fbkiddr gossbkg qhmo} bk sjo I+I+ |}hg}i`+‐ *\iqq Bs Hk |igo 91="

—Mr sjo sb`o sjo i}sbado wiq w}bssok$ I+I+ jic moah`o qo|i}iso f}h` sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| bk mhsj Kow Rh}e ikcHjbh$ ikc F}ike Muaj`ik‒q }o`i}eq imhus Jbsdo} jic gbvok }bqo sh iaauqisbhkq sjis sjo H+G +wiq |}h- Ki~b+ Wbsjwi} bk Ou}h|o igibkqs sjo Ki~bq ikc foodbkgq hk idd f}hksq }ukkbkg jbgj$ Mbdd ukco}qsikcimdr wiksoc sh ivhbc mobkgiqqhabisoc wbsj ikrsjbkg ahks}hvo}qbid$ |i}sbaudi}dr wjok sjo foddhwqjb| qh koococ fivhu}imdo |umdbabsr+‐ *\iqq BsHk |igo =36"

—Mus idd hf uq Oiqs ikc Woqs wo}o |diabkg bka}oiqoc o`|jiqbq hk C}+ Qbdewh}sj‒q oz|}oqqbhk coqa}bmbkg sjoidahjhdba‒q cbdo``i> sjo hmqoqqbhk |duq sjo iddo}gr‐ *II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo969"

—Sjbq bkabcoks doc Qi` Qjho`ieo} sh i|hdhgb~o sh Mbdd diso}$ ifso} jo jb`qodf jic m}heok wbsj sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| bk9239+ Qjho`ieo} w}hso> ‚Bf rhu ovo} w}bso sjo qsh}r hf I+I+‒q oi}dr ahkkoasbhk wbsj Aidvi}r$ B sjbke bs hugjs sh moqibc bk idd jhkoqsr sjis wo wo}o ahiajoc bk sjo foodbkg sjis rhu wo}o hff hk rhu} hwk q|u}… … … Rhu ghs rhu} bkq|b}isbhk f}h` sjhqo oi}dr cirq$ mus rhu cbck‒s gos `uaj okahu}igo`oks f}h` uq ikc fh} `r hwk |i}s bk sjisqsu|bc coqb}o sh ahks}hd sjo Q|b}bs$ iq jo `ikbfoqsoc Jb`qodf bk bkcbvbcuid |oh|do dbeo rhu$ B i` joi}sbdr qh}}r ikciqji`oc+‐ *Fhhs khso \iqq Bs Hk |igo 97:"

—Mhm ikc Qbqso} Bgkisbi mogik sh wh}e `h}o ikc `h}o adhqodr sj}hugj sjo fidd hf 9212 bk gossbkg c}ukeq bksh Qs+Sjh`iq fh} s}ois`oks+ Hko sjbkg wh}}boc jo}$ jhwovo}> Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq qoo`oc adhqodr ahkkoasoc wbsj sjoHzfh}c G}hu|+ ‚Is sjo sb`o$ B foi}oc wo `bgjs moah`o bkvhdvoc wbsj i }odbgbhuq qoas hf qh`o ebkc$‒ Qbqso} Bgkisbi

}oaiddoc+ Qjo sjok iqeoc Fisjo} Vbkaoks Jiiq$ i kowdr h}cibkoc |}boqs$ sh bkvoqsbgiso sjo `oosbkgq fh} jo}… … …Fh}sukisodr$ sjo g}hu| jic `hvoc sh Ebkgq Qajhhd mr sjbq sb`o$ ikc fisjo} Jiiq wiq fivhu}imdr b`|}oqqoc+‐ *C}+Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q‐ |igo 9:2"

—Hk sjo qoahkc cir hf sjo Kow Roi}$ 923<$ C}+ Mhm w}hso Mbdd> ‚Jivo fbkiddr qjieok hff sjo qjiaedoq hf sjoHzfh}c G}hu|+‒ ‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc Sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo =9:"

—Q|oiebkg fh} C}+ Mhm ikc `rqodf B whudc dbeo sh qir sjis sjo}o jiq kovo} mook sjo qdbgjsoqs bksoks$ hk jbq |i}s h} `bko$ hf s}rbkg sh fhukc i kow }odbgbhuq cokh`bkisbhk+ C}+ Mhm jodc ao}sibk }odbgbhuq ahkvbasbhkq$ ikc qh ch B+Sjbq$ hf ahu}qo$ sjo |o}qhkid |}bvbdogo hf ovo}r I+I+ `o`mo}+ Khsjbkg jhwovo}$ ahudc mo qh ukfh}sukiso fh} I+I+‒q fusu}o iq ik isso`|s sh bkah}|h}iso ikr hf hu} |o}qhkid sjohdhgbaid vbowq bksh I+I+ soiajbkg$ |}iasbao h} s}icbsbhk+‐ - Mbdd W+ *II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo =1="

—Morhkc i Jbgjo} \hwo}$ iq oiaj hf uq `ir vbqbhk jb`$ I+I+ `uqs kovo}$ iq i qhabosr$ okso} sjo fbodc hf chg`i h} sjohdhgr+ Wo aik kovo} moah`o i }odbgbhk bk sjis qokqo+ Doqs wo ebdd hu} uqofudkoqq mr mobkg mhggoc chwk bksjohdhgbaid ahksoksbhk+‐ - Mbdd W+ *Dosso} 92?3$ Iq Mbdd qooq Bs |igo 996"

—Sjbq wiq sjo g}ois ahks}bmusbhk hf hu} isjobqsq ikc igkhqsbaq+ Sjor jic wbcokoc hu} gisowir qh sjis idd wjhquffo} `bgjs |iqq sj}hugj$ }ogi}cdoqq hf sjob} modbof h} diae hf modbof +‐ - Mbdd W+ *I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 967"

?7

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 59/63

I}o shcir‒q II `o`mo}q goko}iddr mobkg `ico fuddr iwi}o hf sjo co|sj hf sjo `oksidbddkoqq hf idahjhdbq`8

C}+ Ji}}r @+ Sbomus+ @+C+ *Sjo}i|ousba @oajikbq` hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq$ Sjo

 I`o}baik Nhu}kid hf \qrajbis}r$ Nikui}r 9233+

—Aji}iaso}bqsba hf sjo qh-aiddoc sr|baid idahjhdba bq i ki}abqqbqsba oghaoks}ba ah}o$ ch`bkisoc mr foodbkgq hf h`kb|hsokao$ bksoks hk `ibksibkbkg is idd ahqsq bsq bkko} bksog}bsr+ Wjbdo sjoqo aji}iaso}bqsbaq i}o fhukc bk hsjo} `idicnuqs`oksq$ sjor i||oi} bk }odisbvodr |u}o audsu}o bk idahjhdba ifso} idahjhdba+ Bk i ai}ofud qsucr hf i qo}boq hf 

aiqoq$ Qbdd`ik }o|h}soc sjis jo fods jo ahudc cbqao}k sjo husdbkoq hf i ah``hk aji}iaso} qs}uasu}o i`hkg |}hmdo`c}bkeo}q ikc sjis sjo moqs so}`q jo ahudc fbkc fh} sjo g}hu| hf yuidbsboq khsoc wiq ‚cofbiks bkcbvbcuidbsr‒ ikc‚g}ikcbhqbsr‒+ Bk `r h|bkbhk sjoqo wh}cq wo}o iaau}isodr ajhqok… … … Sjbq oz|o}bokao B dimod fh} wiks hf i mosso} so}`$ i ‚|qrajhdhgbaid iwieokbkg+‒… … … Bk }os}hq|oas$ bs bq i||i}oks sjis sjo |isboks moai`o iwi}o hf jbq miqba ogh aoks}babsr+ Fh} sjo fb}qs sb`o jo wiq imdo sh |okos}iso mojbkc sjo fiçico hf jbq }isbhkidbqisbhkq ikc cofokao}oiasbhkq ikc sh qoo sjis idwirq jbsjo}sh jo jic |us jb`qodf fb}qs+ Jo wiq dbso}iddr ukiwi}o sjis hsjo} qhudq ozbqsocozao|s bkqhfi} iq sjor iffoasoc jb`… … … Wjbdo hko aik yuoqsbhk sjo |o}`ikokao hf sjbq kow |isso}k$ sjo}o aik mo kh yuoqsbhk iq sh sjo fias sjis sjo oz|o}bokao bsqodf haau}}oc…+ … … Sjo ki}abqqbqsba ah`|hkoks bk sjoaji}iaso} bq qum`o}goc$ is doiqs fh} sjo sb`o mobkg… … ]ogi}cdoqq hf jbq fbkid ahkao|sbhk hf sjis |hwo}$ ukdoqq sjobkcbvbcuid issibkq bk sjo ahu}qo hf sb`o i qokqo hf sjo }oidbsr ikc koi}koqq hf i G}oiso} \hwo}$ jbq oghaoks}ba kisu}owbdd }o- iqqo}s bsqodf wbsj ukcb`bkbqjoc bksokqbsr$ ikc c}bkebkg wbdd igibk okso} bksh sjo |basu}o…‐ *Ozs}iasq" *IIAh`oq hf Igo$ I||okcbz O>m$ |igo 1<2-197"

IDAHJHDBQ@ IQ I @IKBFOQSISBHK HF IDDO]GRW+C+ Qbdewh}sj@ocbaid ]oah}c $ @i}aj 97$ 9217

—Idahjhdbq` bq ahkqbco}oc mr `ikr |jrqbabikq i aj}hkba ahkcbsbhk sjis g}icuiddr ukfhdcq bsqodf sh i cbq`id okc…… … Bs bq hu} |u}|hqo sh qjhw sjis sjo}o bq i sr|o hf idahjhdbq` aji}iaso}bqoc mr i cofbkbso qr`|sh`ishdhgr UqbaPikc fbzoc cbigkhqbq hf i ahkqsiks ikc q|oabfba |isjhdhgr5 bk qjh}s$ sjis s}uo idahjhdbq` bq i `ikbfoqsisbhk hf ikiddo}gr… … … jo khw jiq sh c}bke f}h` koaoqqbsr bk h}co} sh eoo| ghbkg… … Diso}$ b}}bsimbdbsr ikc diae hf ahkaoks}isbhk qu|o}voko+ Jo bq khs sjo `ik so`|o}i`oksiddr sjis jo uqoc sh mo… … …jo bq ah`|oddoc sh bka}oiqosjo i`huks jo ahkqu`oq$ ikc i |}hdhkgoc q|}oo }o|diaoq i qjh}s bkshzbaisbhk… … …Jo jiq i foodbkg hf ikzbosrwjbaj i`huksq sh i ki`odoqq so}}h}… … …Is sjbq |hbks$ ovok cu}bkg |o}bhcq hf |i}sbid h} ah`|doso qhm}bosr$ jocovodh|q i qsiso hf viguo foi}$ sjok co|}oqqbhk ikc diae hf ahkaoks}isbhk… … … Jo bq ukco} quaj sokqbhk bk sjooffh}s sh ahks}hd jb`qodf sjis jo jiq sh jivo i c}bke bk h}co} sh jhdc jb`qodf shgosjo}… … Mus jo modbovoq jo `uqs

jivo bs$ ovok sjhugj jo }oidbqoq sjis$ bk jbq |i}sbaudi} aiqo$ i qbkgdo c}bke wbdd |dukgo jb` bksh quaj i ahkcbsbhk sjisi |}hdhkgoc q|}oo wbdd mo sjo bkovbsimdo }oquds+ Ifso} sjo fb}qs c}bke$ ikc hkdr sjok$ choq jo oz|o}bokao sjo |jrqbaid |jokh`okhk hf a}ivbkg… … … B aik khs o`|jiqbq shh qs}hkgdr sjo |hbks sjis sjbq `ik choq khs gh hk i q|}oo fh}  |u}o covbds}r h} coqb}o…… Sjo bkovbsimdo ahkaduqbhk bq sjis s}uo idahjhdbq` bq ik iddo}gba qsiso$ sjo }oquds hf g}icuiddr bka}oiqbkg qokqbsb~isbhk mr idahjhd hvo} i `h}o h} doqq ozsokcoc sb`o…‐ *Ozs}iasq"  *@ocbaid ]oah}c $@i}aj 97$ 9217"

?:

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 60/63

Mbdd+ W+ Dosso} sh C}+ Ai}d Rukg$ 9269—@r Coi} C}+ Rukg … … Sjbq dosso} jiq mook dhkg hvo}cuo…+ … … Sjhugj ]hwdikc J+$ jiq dhkg qbkao |iqqociwir$ sjo }oahddoasbhkq hf jbq }o`i}eimdo oz|o}bokao wjbdo ukco} s}ois`oks mr rhu jiq cofbkbsodr moah`o |i}s hf I+I+ jbqsh}r…+ … … … Jivbkg ozjiuqsoc hsjo} `oikq hf }oahvo}r f}h` jbq idahjhdbq` bs wiq imhus 9219 sjis jo moai`o rhu} |isboks … … … B modbovo jo }o`ibkoc ukco} rhu} ai}o fh} |o}ji|q i roi}… … … Jo sjok }odi|qocbksh bkshzbaisbhk +++ … … … Sjok fhddhwoc i ahkvo}qisbhk moswook rhu sjis wiq sh moah`o sjo fb}qs dbke bk i ajibkhf ovoksq sjis doc sh sjo fhukcbkg hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq…+ … … Fb}qs hf idd$ rhu f}ikedr shdc jb` hf jbqjh|odoqqkoqq$ qh fi} iq ikr fu}sjo} `ocbaid h} |qrajbis}ba s}ois`oks `bgjs mo ahkao}koc+ Sjbq aikcbc ikc ju`mdoqsiso`oks hf rhu}q wiq kh chums sjo fb}qs fhukcisbhk qshko u|hk wjbaj hu} qhabosr wiq mubds … *Ozs}iasq"*II G}i|ovbko Nikui}r 9261+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo =76-=72"

C}+ Mhm>—Rhu qoo$ miae bk sjhqo cirq$ wo wo}o g}h|bkg bk sjo ci}e$‐ C}+ Mhm qibc+ —Wo ekow |}iasbaiddr khsjbkg hf idahjhdbq`+‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo 9<3"

—@ocbaid sozsmhheq wo}ok‒s vo}r jod|fud$ obsjo}$ Mhm qibc+ ‚_quiddr$ sjo bkfh}`isbhk ahkqbqsoc hf qh`o yuoo} s}ois`oks fh} C+S+‒q$ bf i |isboks jic ghko sjis fi}+ Bf jo jick‒s rhu |}oqa}bmoc i fow m}h`bcoq ikc givo sjo foddhwi ghhc doasu}o+‐ *C}+ Mhm ikc sjo Ghhc Hdc Sb`o}q |igo 9<?"

I dbqs hf qh`o hf I+I+‒q hsjo} }hhsq>

C}+ W+W+ Miuo}5 I`o}baik @ocbaid iqqhabisbhk+ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |+3

C}+ Oi}d @+ I+I+ Ah`oq hf Igo |+3C}+ Nhjk D+ Kh}}bq$ *khk-idahjhdba s}uqsoo" \iqq bs Hk |igo =6:C}+ H+ I+ Ebd|is}bae$ |qrajbis}bqs \iqq bs Hk |igo 1?:C}+ Oqso} D+ ]baji}cq \iqq bs Hk |igo =<9C}+ Dohki}c V+ Qs}hkg$ N}+*khk-idahjhdba s}uqsoo" \iqq bs Hk |9:9-9:3C}+ I+ Wobqqo Ji``o} Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s \igo 16=C}+ Qshuffo}$ Ajbof |qrajbis}bqs \jbdicod|bi Goko}id Jhq|bsid Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s \igo 161C}+ Cucdor Qiud Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s \igo 161C}+ Eb}mr Ahddbo} Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s \igo 17<C}+ Cwbgjs Ikco}qhk Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s \igo 17<C}+ Cik A}iqeo II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo ==C}+ M}hwk II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo ==C}+ Nhjkqshko$ |qrajbis}bqs II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo =2C}+ Fh}qso} Eokkocr$ kou}hdhgbqs II Ah`oq hf Igo |igo 9:1

?2

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 61/63

Ch qsiso`oksq quaj iq sjo fhddhwbkg bk |umdba }odisbhkq gbvo ik b`|}oqqbhk hf I+I+ iq mobkg }odbgbhuq8

—Sjo h}bgbkq hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq aik mo s}iaoc sh sjo Hzfh}c G}hu|$ i }odbgbhuq `hvo`oks |h|udi} bk sjo _kbsoc Qsisoq ikc Ou}h|o bk sjo oi}dr =<sj aoksu}r+ @o`mo}q hf sjo Hzfh}c G}hu| |}iasbaoc i fh}`udi hf qodf-b`|}hvo`oks mr |o}fh}`bkg qodf-bkvoksh}r$ ic`bssbkg w}hkgq$ `iebkgi`okcq$ uqbkg |}iro} ikc `ocbsisbhk$ ikc ai}}rbkg sjo `oqqigo sh hsjo}q‐+

jss|>((www+ii+h}g(iisb`odbko(sb`odbkoXj9+|j|8dikg0Xok

Oi}dr I+I+ jbqsh}r choq i||oi} sh sodd uq sjis sjo `h}o wo fhauq hk sjo—}odbgbhuq (q|b}bsuid‐ iq|oas bk hu} |umdba }odisbhkq ikc kowah`o} }odisbhkq$ sjo doqqi||oidbkg wo wbdd mo sh sjo `inh}bsr hf qsbdd quffo}bkg idahjhdbaq$ ikc sh sjo

 |}hfoqqbhkidq wjh }ofo} sjo` sh uq+ Bs whudc i||oi} sjo qi`o bq s}uo shcir+

—Qai}oc Hff‐ II G}i|ovbko Khvo`mo} 922:—B ahudc khs ig}oo `h}o sjis wjok i `oosbkg bq adhqoc wbsj jikc-jhdcbkg sjo Dh}c'q \}iro}$ wo `ir dhqo `ikr ikowah`o}+ Sjbq jiq mook `r oz|o}bokao hvo} sjo roi}q+ B jivo dhqs `ikr i ji}c-mbssok idahjhdba wjh jiqqah}kfuddr dofs$ qirbkg> B wiks khko hf sjis }odbgbhuq qsuff) ikc sjo dbeo+‐Fh} `rqodf$ B idqh jivo i foodbkg sjis hkao `h}o h}gikb~oc }odbgbhk$ bk sjbq aiqo$ Aj}bqsbikbsr$ bq mobkg qumsdrbks}hcuaoc bksh hu} |}hg}i`+‐

 —Auds-dbeo h} wodah`bkg8 ]oduasiks ahkfh}`bsr‐ II G}i|ovbko Coao`mo} =<9<B i` i fh}`o} `o`mo} hf i }odbgbhuq auds$ ikc `r ajbdc}ok ahkqbco} II sh mo qb`bdi} bk qh`o wirq+ B i` idqh khsah`fh}simdo wbsj jhdcbkg jikcq ikc qirbkg sjo Dh}c'q \}iro} is sjo okc hf i `oosbkg fh} sjo qi`o }oiqhk+ II bq iq|b}bsuid$ khs i }odbgbhuq$ |}hg}i`+ B ahkfh}` moaiuqo sjis bq jhw B'vo mook siugjs ikc B chk's wiks sh i||oi} cbffo}oks$ mus B whudc dhvo sh qoo sjbq ajikgo fh} sjo mokofbs hf ovo}rhko bk sjo Foddhwqjb|$ }ogi}cdoqq hf modbofq+‐

—Wjr i}o wo qjhusbkg8 Ajiksbkg bq mic fh} II‒q |umdba }odisbhkq$ ik hdc-sb`o} iqqo}q‐+ II G}i|ovbkoQo|so`mo} =<9<—…Mr 92::$ bk `r oz|o}bokao$ sjo Jb$ Mhm) ajiks wiq |}ossr `uaj ah``hk|diao is `oosbkgq bk sjo Kh}sjoiqs+ Sjbq bq i `oosbkg hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq$ wjo}o wo qji}o hu} oz|o}bokao$ qs}okgsj ikc jh|o+Bs bq khs i auds$ }odbgbhk h} g}hu| sjo}i|r… … … Ik II f}bokc wiq wisajbkg sodovbqbhk bk sjo diso 2<q'wjok i qjhw |h}s}iroc i fiaqb`bdo hf ik II `oosbkg… … … @r f}bokc qibc sjis jo} juqmikc iasuiddrdiugjoc hus dhuc wjok sjo g}hu| ajiksoc> Jb$ Mbdd) qjo qibc jo} juqmikc iqeoc qi}aiqsbaiddr$ Bq sjbq sjoII sjis rhu gh sh8 Wjis choq sjbq `oik8 Bs `oikq sjis wo i}o i nheo sh `uaj hf sjo |umdba+ Hu} |umdba

}odisbhkq i}o ji}`oc$ sjo}ofh}o }ocuabkg sjo offoasbvokoqq hf Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq+ … … … B jic `rdiqs c}bke hf idahjhd bk Fom}ui}r 927< ikc wiq iasbvo bk II sj}hugj sjo '7<q… … Jhw `ikr `h}oidahjhdbaq `uqs |o}bqj mofh}o wo }ovo}qo sjbq }odbgbhuq auds sjbkg sjis B food Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq jiq`h}|joc bksh… …Ikrhko dbqsokbkg8‐ 

—Auds-dbeo h} nuqs wodah`bkg8 @oosbkgq fbddoc wbsj }odbgbhqbsr‐$ II G}i|ovbko Coao`mo} =<9<—Hj roq$ B i` dbqsokbkg$ Mhm+ Ikc B jivo chko nuqs sjis + + + qsh||oc ghbkg sh `oosbkgq$ |}ossr `uaj+ B ghsqhmo} bk Ajbaigh 17 roi}q igh ikc jivo mook qhmo} hko cir is i sb`o qbkao$ idd sjikeq sh II$ bsq `o`mo}q$qo}vbao wh}e ikc }ogudi} issokcikao is `oosbkgq+ Mus imhus 9< h} qh roi}q igh B khsbaoc `r issokcikao is`oosbkgq wiq c}h||bkg hff+ Sjis qsi}soc sjo }hukc hf ajoaebkg hus idd qh}sq hf g}hu|q bk `r i}oi$ hkdr shfbkc i dovod hf khbqo$ ajiksbkg ikc auds-dbeo }odbgbhqbsr sjis B fhukc vo}r hff-|ussbkg+ Hko cir is i sb`o`bgjs ajikgo jhw B qoo sjbkgq$ mus fh} khw `r Jbgjo} \hwo}$ II f}bokcq ikc sjo Mbg Mhhe wbdd jivo sh mo okhugj‐+

6<

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 62/63

—Coi} G}i|ovbko$ @r II‐ II G}i|ovbko Khvo`mo} =<9<—B jivo mook qhmo} qbkao 926: ikc i` if}ibc sjis B whk's }oahgkb~o `r II bk ikhsjo} 9? roi}q… … bs qoo`q sjiskh hko }oidb~oq sjis sjo Dh}c'q \}iro} bq khs bk ig}oo`oks wbsj hu} \}oi`mdo+ Ikc B |o}qhkiddr chk's ai}o fh} sjoajiksbkg ikc |u`|bkg hf sjo jikcq… … B jivo sj}oo idahjhdba ajbdc}ok$ swh hf wjh` i}o bk }oahvo}r+ B jivog}ikcajbdc}ok ikc g}ois-g}ikcajbdc}ok ikc B wiks sjo |}hg}i` sh mo sjo}o wjok sjor kooc bs+‐

Mbdd W>

—Fbkiddr$ B i` hfsok iqeoc wjr B ch khs |umdbadr iaekhwdocgo `r vo}r }oid coms hf g}isbsuco sh sjo Hzfh}c G}hu|+ Sjo ikqwo} bq sjis$ ukfh}sukisodr$ i viqs ikcqh`osb`oq uk}oiqhkbkg |}onucbao ozbqsq idd hvo} sjbq ahuks}r igibkqs sjo H+G+ ikc bsqquaaoqqh} @+]+I+ @r cbdo``i bq sjis bf B `ieo quaj ik iaekhwdocgo`oks$ B `iroqsimdbqj i ahkkoasbhk moswook sjo H+ G+ ikc Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq wjbaj choq khsozbqs is sjo |}oqoks sb`o+ B jic sh iqe `rqodf wjbaj wiq `h}o b`|h}siks> sjis sjo H+G+}oaobvo a}ocbs ikc sjis B jivo sjo |doiqu}o hf qh cbqaji}gbkg `r coms hf g}isbsuco$ h} sjis idahjhdbaq ovo}rwjo}o jivo sjo moqs |hqqbmdo ajikao sh qsir idbvo }ogi}cdoqq hf 

wjh gosq a}ocbs+‐ *Mbdd W+ \iqq Bs Hk |igo 971"

 

69

8/3/2019 A Minority Report to Conference 2012

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-minority-report-to-conference-2012 63/63

Qoasbhk 9<

Ahkaduqbhk

Sjbq }o|h}s gbvoq ikidrqbq hf ji~i}chuq co|i}su}o f}h` S}icbsbhk$ qo}bhuq ikc g}hwbkgbkso}kid cbvbqbhkq ikc |umdba ahkao}kq+

Sjo}o bq ovbcokao Idahjhdbaq Ikhkr`huq bq mobkg bkfduokaoc mr husqbco muqbkoqqbkso}oqsq5 i `bkh}bsr hf I+I+ g}hu|q i}o ich|sbkg h}gikbqoc ocuaisbhkid |}hg}i`q$jbo}i}ajbaid |r}i`bc |hwo} qs}uasu}oq ikc bkso}kisbhkid iffbdbisbhkq+ Sjo}o bq ovbcokaohf fukci`oksidbqs Aj}bqsbik dbso}isu}o cbqsh}sbkg II jbqsh}r sh sjo ozsoks sjis bs

 |}oqoksq oi}dr I+I+ g}hu|q iq ovikgodbaid Aj}bqsbik Hzfh}c G}hu|q ikc wjbaj

icvhaisoq sjob} }osu}k+ Sjo}o bq ovbcokao bk sjo |}oqq$ bkso}kos ikc wbsjbk sjofoddhwqjb| sjis II bq mogbkkbkg sh gos sjo }o|usisbhk hf mobkg i }odbgbhuq auds+

I wbcoq|}oic ikc ji~i}chuq `bqahkao|sbhk bk sjo i||dbaisbhk hf I+I+ S}icbsbhkq |}oqoksq i qbsuisbhk bk I+I+ wjo}o kobsjo} I+I+ S}icbsbhk$ kh} Goko}id Wi}}iksboq hf Ahkfo}okao i}o wbsjqsikcbkg+ _kdoqq }o`ocbid iasbhk bq sieok is idd dovodq$ sjo |}oqokscrki`baq bk I+I+ |i}iddod sjis hf sjo Wiqjbkgshkbik `hvo`oks ikc qbgkid ik oi}drwi}kbkg hf b`|okcbkg ahddi|qo+

Sjbq }o|h}s `ieoq }oah``okcisbhkq+

—Hf jbgjoqs b`|h}sikao whudc mo hu} }odisbhkq wbsj `ocbabko ikc }odbgbhk+ _kco} kh ab}au`qsikaoq `uqs wo gosbksh ah`|osbsbhk wbsj obsjo}+ Bf wo i||oi}oc sh mo i kow }odbgbhuq qoas$ wo‒c mo chko fh}+ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbkoNuko 92??$ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9?<"

—Ocuaisbhk wbdd khs hkdr |ir hff bk ku`mo}q s}oisoc5 bs aik |ir hff ovok `h}o jikcqh`odr bk |}ovoksbhk… … bs bq mhsj i ah``ukbsr nhm ikc i nhm fh} q|oabidbqsq… … mus II iq quaj aikkhs$ ikc qjhudc khs$ gos cb}oasdr bksh sjbqfbodc+‐ *Mbdd W+ II G}i|ovbko @i}aj 92?:+ Dikguigo hf sjo Joi}s |igo 9:6-9:7"

—Wo i}o qu}o sjis oiaj g}hu| hf wh}eo}q bk wh}dc qo}vbao wbdd mo so`|soc sh s}r idd qh}sq hf bkkhvisbhkq sjis `irhfsok |}hcuao dbssdo `h}o sjik |ibkfud }o|osbsbhk oi}dbo} `bqsieoq+ Sjo}ofh}o bs wbdd mo ik b`|h}siks hmnoasbvo hf sjoqo Ahkao|sq sh fh}oqsidd quaj }o|osbsbhkq mr jhdcbkg sjo oz|o}bokaoq hf sjo |iqs adoi}dr mofh}o uq+ Ikc bf `bqsieok co|i}su}oq i}o kovo}sjodoqq `ico$ sjoqo Ahkao|sq `ir sjok |}hvbco i }oicr `oikq hf qifo }osu}k sh ikh|o}isbkg midikao sjis `bgjs hsjo}wbqo sieo roi}q hf fdhukco}bkg sh }ocbqahvo}+‐

Sjo —II Qo}vbao `ikuid ah`mbkoc wbsj sjo Swodvo Ahkao|sq fh} Wh}dc Qo}vbao‐ hkdbko>jss|>((www+ii+h}g(|cf(|}hcuasq(okXm`-19+|cf  

@bkh}bsr }o|h}s qum`bssoc Iuguqs =<99$ }ovbqoc ikc }o-qum`bssoc Hashmo} =<99+M e c c d c