A Hegel Bibliography

A HEGEL BIBLIOGRAPHY This selective bibliography is mainly of English-language material, although some items in French and German are also listed. Printed out, the bibliography is about 40 pages long. Navigation: The bibliography is all on one page. After the list of contents, it is divided into 8 main sections, each with up to 20 headings. Each heading is preceded by ‘@’ plus a space. To find a heading, use the ‘find’ facility on your browser, entering ‘@’ + space + the first words of the heading. To return to the top of the page, press Ctrl-Home. [ ] = date of writing or original publication * = recommended + = introductory Please e-mail suggestions for additions or improvements to Andrew Chitty, University of Sussex, England (home page) Last updated 13 Nov 2012 –––––––– Contents GENERALIntroductions to Hegel’s work as a whole, by HegelIntroductions to Hegel’s work as a wholeCommentaries on Hegel’s work as a wholeCollections on Hegel’s work as a wholeHistorically influential views of HegelTerminology and languageBibliographiesSurveys of Hegel literatureJournals of Hegel studiesHegel links TEXTSTranslations of Hegel’s major worksTranslations of some of Hegel’s short pieces PRECURSORS: UP TO HERDERIndian and Eastern Philosophy and HegelGreek philosophy in general and HegelForms and categories in Plato, Aristotle, Kant and HegelPlato, Socrates and HegelPlato and Hegel: political philosophiesAristotle and HegelAristotle and Hegel: political philosophyChristian theology in general and HegelNeo-Platonism, Pseudo-Dionysianism and HegelPaul, John, Marcion and HegelGnosticism and HegelAquinas and HegelHermeticism, German mysticism and Hegel: generalEckhart and HegelBoehme and HegelHobbes and HegelSpinoza and neo-Spinozism as influences on HegelSpinoza and pantheism: Hegel’s critiqueMaimon and HegelRousseau and HegelPolitical economists and Hegel

PRECURSORS: GERMAN IDEALISMGerman idealism and HegelKant and Hegel: generalKant and the PhenomenologyKant’s epistemology and metaphysics: Hegel’s critiqueIntellectual intuition from Kant to HegelKant on self-consciousness, apperception and the transcendental deduction: Hegel’s critiqueKant’s dialectic and antinomies: Hegel’s critiqueKant’s ethics and theory of will and freedom: Hegel’s critique of it in generalKant’s ethics: Hegel’s critique of its formalismSchiller and HegelFichte: generalFichte: metaphysics and relation to Kant’s first critiqueFichte on consciousness and self-consciousnessFichte’s ethicsFichte’s philosophy of right (general)Fichte’s distinction between right and ethicsFichte on recognition and intersubjecivityFichte on propertyFichte and Hegel: generalFichte and Hegel: recognitionRomanticism and Hegel (Novalis, Schlegel)SchellingSchelling’s Philosophy of NatureSchelling’s early systems and HegelHölderlin and Hegel DEVELOPMENT OF HEGEL’S THOUGHTBiographies (intellectual)Early development as a whole (Stuttgart, Tübingen, Berne, Frankfurt, Jena)Stuttgart and Tübingen writings (1777-93)Berne and Frankfurt writings (1793-1800)Natural theology and the young HegelCivil religion and the young HegelProgressive theories of history and the young HegelJena writings (1801-06): generalJena writings: logic and metaphysicsJena writings: politics, ethics and religionEssay on Natural Law (1802-03)Natural law and HegelDifferenzschrift and Faith and Knowledge RECOGNITION AND INTERSUBJECTIVITYRecognition: the conceptRecognition and intersubjectivity: historiesRecognition in Plato and AristotleRecognition in FichteLife and love in Frankfurt, Jena and the PhenomenologyLove in Hegel’s mature writingsRecognition in Hegel’s work as a wholeRecognition in the Jena writings (1801-1806)Recognition in the Phenomenology, master-servant relationRecognition in the Philosophy of Spirit (= Philosophy of Mind), universal self-consciousnessRecognition in the Philosophy of RightRecognition in the LogicSlavery in HegelRecognition and selfhood in HegelRecognition and freedom in HegelMarx on recognitionKojève (on recognition and in general)

Merleau-Ponty on recognitionSartre on recognitionHeidegger on intersubjectivy, recognition and MitseinAlthusser on recognitionHabermas on recognitionHonneth on HegelFukuyama (on recognition and on end of history)Nancy on intersubjectivity and recognitionRecognition in other 20th century writersRecognition and workRecognition and colonialism, FanonColonialism, racism and HegelRecognition and feminismRecognition in international relationsHonour vs. dignityKohlberg, Mead and Dewey on recognitionStrawson on recognitionHonneth’s theory of recognitionPolitics of recognition, recognition of identitiesRecognition and redistribution (Honneth-Fraser debate)Recognition, work and classSelf-esteem, self-respect, dignityRecognition as ontologicalRecognition as ethicalRecognition theory: collections PHENOMENOLOGY OF SPIRITPhenomenology: short introductionsPhenomenology: introductory commentariesPhenomenology: advanced commentariesPhenomenology: commentaries on particular topicsPhenomenology: collectionsPhenomenology: PrefacePhenomenology: IntroductionMethod of the PhenomenologyTranscendental argument and transcendental deduction in the PhenomenologyScepticism and Hegel, assumptions and foundations of the Phenomenology and LogicImmediate knowledgeStructure of the PhenomenologyPhenomenology: chs. 1-3 in generalSense-certainty, ch. 1Sense-certainty: possible parallels to Hegel’s argumentPerception, ch. 2Force and understanding, ch. 3Infinity in HegelInverted worldSelf-consciousness in the PhenomenologyDesire and the body in the PhenomenologyRecognition in the PhenomenologyMaster-servant relationDeath in HegelLabour in HegelStoicism, scepticism and the unhappy consciousness, ch. 4BSocial epistemology in ch. 4Observing reasonTransition to spiritSpirit: textsSpirit: metaphysical interpretationsSpirit: intersubjective and collective-subject interpretationsPhenomenology: ch. 6 in general

Coherence of the Phenomenology, phenomenology and historyGreek world and its inadequacyAntigoneTragedy in HegelLegal status (Rechtszustand), Roman world, person and property in the PhenomenologyAlienation in HegelEnlightenment vs. faithModernity and HegelFrench RevolutionTotalitarianism, authoritarianism, nationalism and Prussianism in HegelMoral and political stance of the PhenomenologyPhenomenology: ch. 7Art in the PhenomenologyAbsolute knowing and the metaphysics of the Phenomenology, ch. 8Phenomenology and logic, phenomenology and system LOGIC AND METAPHYSICSLogic: short introductionsLogic: commentariesLogic: collectionsLogic: surveys of the secondary literatureDialectical methodLogic: method and structure, dialectic, contradiction, speculation, form and contentLogic: formalisations of dialectical logicReason, understanding and intuitionSociality of reasonProposition (judgment), speculative proposition, languageBeing, nothing, becomingEssenceSubjective logicConcept, theConcrete and abstract universalityIdentity and difference in HegelConcrete universal in British idealismMetaphysics of Hegel, his account of the absolute: textsMetaphysics of Hegel: surveysMetaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations - generalMetaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations: orthodoxMetaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations: spirit-monist, emanationist and panentheistMetaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations: kenotic and christomorphicMetaphysics of Hegel: immanentist and pantheist theological interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: conceptualist and panlogist interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: dialogical interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: non-metaphysical interpretations in generalMetaphysics of Hegel: empiricist-realist interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: positivist and category theory interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: implicitly anti-realist interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: hermeneutical interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: Kantian interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: transformed-Kantian interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: epistemist-realist interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: social-Kantian interpretationsMetaphysics of Hegel: historical-relativist interpretations NATURE AND SUBJECTIVE SPIRIT (REALPHILOSOPHIE)Relation of Logic to RealphilosophieNature and the natural sciences: generalMathematics and geometry in HegelEcology, environmentalism and HegelNature and the natural sciences: particular topics

TimeLife in Hegel’s mature system, plant and animal subjectivitySubjective spirit: generalSoul and feeling, anthropologyConsciousness, self-consciousness and the I in the Philosophy of SpiritUniversal self-consciousness in the the Philosophy of SpiritTheoretical spirit, intentionality, imaginationPractical spiritMadness and Hegel POLITICS, ETHICS AND HISTORYPolitics and ethics: textsPolitics and ethics: introductionsPolitics and ethics: guidesPolitics and ethics: fuller commentariesPolitics and ethics: collectionsPolitics and ethics: early developmentNormative stance, the Doppelsatz (the rational is real), positive right vs. natural right, ethics and reasonPhilosophy of Right: method and structurePhilosophy of Right and LogicHartmann on the Philosophy of RightPippin on Hegel’s social philosophyFreedom in Hegel: generalFreedom and recognition in HegelFreedom and determinismFreedom and free will as the basis of the Philosophy of Right, constructivism in HegelAction in HegelReasons for action in HegelWill: its logical structureSavigny (and the historical school of law) and HegelDuty, desire and feelings in HegelAbstract rightProperty and contract (general)Property and contract: recognition-centred accountsHuman rights in HegelCrime and punishmentMorality (Moralität)Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom, individuality, autonomy, liberalism and HegelBifurcationConscience and virtueEthical life, i.e. SittlichkeitCommunity and individual, sociality of the self in HegelSocial role and sense of self (Selbstgefühl) in HegelEthical substance: substantialist vs. intersubjective interpretationsSocial contract theory: Hegel’s critiqueSubstantial will, objective will, universal will, substantial or objective freedomFamilyFeminism and HegelCivil society: generalSystem of needs, the economyClass in HegelLaw (Gesetz), legal theory, Roman lawBildung and educationContradictions of civil societyState and constitutionDemocracy and monarchy in HegelWar and international relations in HegelCivic humanism and other forms of republicanism in HegelHistory (philosophy of): textsHistory (philosophy of): short introductions

History (philosophy of): commentaries and collectionsHistory as progressive, the cunning of reasonHistory of philosophyHistorical role of Hegel’s philosophyEnd of history in Hegel RELIGION AND ARTPhilosophy of religion in generalKant and Fichte’s theology and HegelReligion in the PhenomenologyNatural religionJudaism and HegelChristianity and Hegel, Hegel’s christologyTrinitarianism in HegelReligion and philosophy in generalReligion and the stateArt and aesthetics SUBSEQUENT PHILOSOPHERS AND HEGELSchellingian critiques of HegelMarx and HegelKierkegaard and HegelNietzsche and HegelBritish Idealism (or British Hegelians)British idealism: ethical and political thoughtWhitehead and HegelFreud, Lacan and HegelHeidegger and HegelFrench philosophers and HegelBataille and HegelKojève and HegelSartre and HegelDe Beauvoir and HegelLevinas and HegelMarxists on HegelWittgenstein and HegelAdorno and HegelGadamer and HegelNancy and HegelIrigaray and HegelHabermas on Hegel, and on philosophy after HegelLyotard, postmodernism and HegelDerrida and HegelAnalytic philosophy and HegelMcDowell on HegelBrandom on Hegel –––––––– @ GENERAL @ Introductions to Hegel’s work as a whole, by Hegel Hegel [1820s] Introduction to the Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Knox and Miller, pp. 15-52 ‘Berlin

Introduction’ Hegel [1830] The Encyclopaedia Logic, tr. Geraets et al., §§1-25 @ Introductions to Hegel’s work as a whole Soll, I. (1969) An Introduction to Hegel’s Metaphysics Singer, P. (2001) Hegel: A Very Short Introduction, originally published 1983 as Hegel, Past Masters Rockmore, T. (1993) Before and After Hegel: A Historical Introduction to Hegel’s Thought

Maker, W. (1994) Philosophy without Foundations: Rethinking Hegel Plant, R. (1997) Hegel: On Religion and Philosophy, The Great Philosophers Stern, R. (1998) ‘G.W.F. Hegel’ in J. Teichman and G. White (eds.) An Introduction to Modern European

Philosophy, 2nd. ed* Beiser, F.C. (2005) Hegel* Houlgate, S. (2005) An Introduction to Hegel: Freedom, Truth and History (2nd ed. of his Freedom, Truth and

History, 1991) Schroeder , W.R. (2005) Continental Philosophy: A Critical Approach, ch. 1 ‘Hegel’ James, D. (2007) Hegel: A Guide for the Perplexed @ Commentaries on Hegel’s work as a whole Findlay, J.N. (1958) Hegel: A Re-examination Mure, G.R. (1965) The Philosophy of Hegel Lauer, Q. (1971) Hegel’s Idea of Philosophy Rosen, S. (1974) G.W.F. Hegel: An Introduction to the Science of Wisdom Rotenstreich, N. (1974) From Substance to Subject: Studies in Hegel Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, 5th (ed.) 1987 Hamacher, W. [1978] Pleroma: Reading in Hegel: The Genesis and Structure of a Dialectical Hermeneutics in

Hegel, tr. 1998 Inwood, M. (1983) Hegel, Arguments of the Philosophers Rockmore, T. (1984) Hegel’s Circular Epistemology Hösle, V. (1987) Hegels System. Der Idealismus der Subjectivität und das Problem der Intersubjectivität [Hegel’s

System: The Idealism of Subjectivity and the Problem of Intersubjectivity], 2 vols Pinkard, T. (1988) Hegel’s Dialectic: The Explanation of Possibility Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism: The Satisfactions of Self-Consciousness Berthold-Bond, D. (1989) Hegel’s Grand Synthesis: A Study of Being, Thought and History Stern, R. (1990) Hegel, Kant and the Structure of the Object Kainz, H.P. (1996) G.W.F. Hegel: The Philosophical System Redding, P. (1996) Hegel’s Hermeneutics Wallace, R.M. (2005) Hegel’s Philosophy of Reality, Freedom, and God @ Collections on Hegel’s work as a whole (Collections on specific subjects are under the relevant headings) Steinkraus, W.E. (1971) New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel* MacIntyre, A. (ed.) (1972) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays* Inwood, M. (ed.) (1985) Hegel, Oxford Readings in Philosophy Lamb, D. (ed.) (1987) Hegel and Modern Philosophy Desmond, W. (ed.) (1989) Hegel and his Critics Hospers, J. (ed.) (1991) ‘Hegel today’, The Monist 74(3)* Stern, R. (ed.) (1993) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, 4 volumes* Beiser, F.C. (ed.) (1993) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Stewart, J. (ed.) (1996) The Hegel Myths and Legends Lamb, D. (ed.) (1998) Hegel, 2 vols Deligiorgi, K. (ed.) (2006) Hegel: New Directions Ashton, P. et al (2008) The Spirit of the Age: Hegel and the Fate of Thinking @ Historically influential views of Hegel Caird, E. (1883) Hegel, reprinted 2002, also available online McTaggart, G. (1901) Studies in Hegelian Cosmology Royce, J. (1919) Lectures on Modern Idealism Rosenzweig, F. [1920] Hegel und der Staat Mure, G.R. (1940) An Introduction to Hegel Popper, K. (1945) The Open Society and Its Enemies, 5th (ed.) 1966, vol. 2, ch. 12 @ Terminology and language (For Hegel’s own theory of language see ‘Proposition (judgment), speculative proposition, language’) Royce, J. (1901) ‘Hegel’s terminology’, Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology, vol. 1 (ed.) J.M. Baldwin Koyré, A. (1961) ‘Note sur la langue et la terminologie hégéliennes’ in his Études d’Histoire de la Pensée

Philosophique

Adorno, T.W. [1963] Hegel: Three Studies, ch. 3 Petry, M.J. (1981) ‘Introduction’ to Hegel The Berlin Phenomenology, (ed.) Petry, sec. i ‘The language’ Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 4a Geraets, T.F. et al (1991) The Encyclopaedia Logic* Inwood, M. (1992) A Hegel Dictionary Burbidge, J.W. (2001) Historical Dictionary of Hegelian Philosophy @ Bibliographies Weiss, F.G. (1973) ‘Hegel: a bibliography of books in English arranged chronologically’, in J.J. O’ Malley et

al. The Legacy of Hegel Steinhauer, K. (1980, 1998) Hegel Bibliography, Parts 1 and 2 (Utterly comprehensive listing of works on and by

Hegel published up to 1990, over 1000 pages long) The Encyclopaedia Logic (1991), tr. T.F. Geraets et al. (Has an annotated bibliography on the Logic) Houlgate, S. (1991) Freedom Truth and History (Has an annotated bibliography)* Inwood, M. (1992) A Hegel Dictionary (Has a bibliography covering the main areas of Hegel’s thought)* Beiser, F.C. (ed.) (1993) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel (Has another good bibliography) Harris, H.S. (1997) Hegel’s Ladder, vol. 2 (Has a 70-page bibliography on the Phenomenology) Stewart, J. (ed.) (1998) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader (Has a bibliography on the Phenomenology) @ Surveys of Hegel literature Avineri, S. (1968) ‘Hegel revisited’, Journal of Contemporary History 3(2), reprinted in MacIntyre

(ed.) Hegel 1972 (survey of interpretations of Hegel’s political philosophy from his death onwards) Schmidt, J. (1980-81) ‘Recent Hegel literature: general surveys and the young Hegel’, Telos 46 Schmidt, J. (1981) ‘Recent Hegel literature: the Jena period and the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Telos 48 Lewis, C. (1981) ‘Recent literature on Hegel’s Logic’, Philosophische Rundschau 28 Bienenstock, M. (1985) ‘Hegel’s Jena writings; recent trends in research’. Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great

Britain 11 Ameriks, K. (1986?) ‘Recent work on Hegel: the rehabilitation of an epistemologist?’, Philosophy and

Phenomenological Research 46 Harris, H.S. (1987) ‘Hegel’s science of experience’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 15 @ Journals of Hegel studies The Owl of Minerva (US) Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain (Britain) Hegel-Studien (Germany) Hegel-Jahrbuch (Germany) Jahrbuch für Hegelforschung (Germany) @ Hegel links Hegel.Net (maintained by Kai Frobe, Munich) Hegel Society of Great Britain Hegel Society of America @ TEXTS @ Translations of Hegel’s major works (The Hegel.net e-texts page gives a list of Hegel texts available online. The best sources for English translations

are Hegel by hypertext and Carl Mickelson’s Hegel text collection and GWFHegel.org. These also have secondary literature)

Three Essays 1793-95 [Tübingen, Berne 1793-95], tr. J. Dobbins and P. Fuss 1984 Early Theological Writings [Berne, Frankfurt 1795-1800], tr. T.M. Knox 1948, reprinted 1971 The Difference Between Fichte’s and Schelling’s System of Philosophy (the ‘Differenzschrift’) [Jena 1801], tr.

H.S. Harris and W. Cerf 1977. Available online: German text Natural Law [Jena 1802], tr. T.M. Knox 1975 Faith and Knowledge [Jena 1802], tr. W. Cerf and H.S. Harris 1977 System of Ethical Life and First Philosophy of Spirit [Jena 1802, 1803-4], tr. H.S. Harris and T.M. Knox 1979.

Available online: System of Ethical Life The Jena System 1804-5: Logic and Metaphysics [Jena 1804-5], tr. J. Burbidge and G. di Giovanni 1986. Second

Jena system

Hegel and the Human Spirit [Jena 1805-6], tr. L. Rauch 1983. Third Jena system. Available online: English text (in part)

Phenomenology of Spirit [Jena 1807], tr. A.V. Miller 1977, or in a looser but more readable translation, as The Phenomenology of Mind, tr. J.B. Baillie 1910, revised 1931. Available online: German text, German text on a single page, Baillie translation, Baillie translation (alternative source)

Spirit: Book Six of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, (ed.) D.E. Shannon, 2001 The Philosophical Propaedeutic [Nürnberg 1808-11], tr. A.V. Miller, 1986. Available online: Section on

Phenomenology, Section on Logic Science of Logic [Nürnberg 1812-16, rev. Berlin 1831], tr. A.V. Miller 1969 pb, or in 2 volumes, tr. W.H.

Johnston and L.G. Struthers 1929. Available online: German text part 1, part 2, Miller translation (extracts) Encyclopaedia of the Philosophical Sciences in Outline [Heidelberg 1817], tr. S.H. Taubeneck 1990. This

includes the Encyclopaedia Logic, Philosophy of Nature and Philosophy of Mind Encyclopaedia Logic (also known as ‘Shorter Logic’) [Heidelberg 1817, rev. Berlin 1827, 1830], tr. T.F. Geraets

et al. 1991 pb, or in a much worse translation, as Hegel’s Logic or The Logic of Hegel, tr. W. Wallace 1873, reprinted 1975, Available online: German text, Wallace translation

Lectures on Logic, tr. C. Butler, 2008 Encyclopaedia Philosophy of Nature [Heidelberg 1817, rev. Berlin 1827, 1830] as The Philosophy of Nature, tr.

A.V. Miller 1970, or, in a better translation with the German on opposite pages, in 3 volumes, tr. M.J. Petry 1970. Available online: German text, Taubeneck translation of 1817 edition

Encyclopaedia Philosophy of Spirit [Heidelberg 1817, rev. Berlin 1827, 1830] as Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind, tr. W. Wallace 1894, republished with additions, tr. A.V. Miller 1971 pb. Also, with the German on opposite pages and an 1825 set of students lecture notes as an appendix, as Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit, 3 volumes, tr. M.J. Petry 1978. Petry republished the section on Phenomenology, with the 1825 lecture notes interpolated between the paragraphs of Hegel’s text instead of the usual additions, as The Berlin Phenomenology 1981. Available online: German text, Wallace translation

Lectures on the Philosophy of Spirit 1827-8, ed. R.R. Williams, OUP 2007 Lectures on Natural Right and Political Science [Heidelberg, 1817-18], tr. J.M. Stewart and P.C. Hodgson 1995 Philosophy of Right [Berlin, 1821] as Elements of the Philosophy of Right, tr. H.B. Nisbet 1991 pb or as Outlines

of the Philosophy of Right tr. Knox and Houlgate 2008, preferable to the older translations as Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, tr. T. Knox 1952 pb, and, tr. Dyde 1897. Available online: Knox translation

Lectures on the Philosophy of History [Berlin 1820s] as The Philosophy of History, tr. J. Sibree 1858, revised 1899, reprinted 1956 pb. The introduction is published separately, in much better translations than Sibree’s, as Reason in History, tr. R.S. Hartman 1953, and as Introduction to the Philosophy of History, tr. L. Rauch 1988 pb; and also in a much fuller version as Lectures on the Philosophy of World History, Introduction: Reason in History, tr. H.B. Nisbet 1975 pb. Available online: Sibree translation of introduction

Lectures on Aesthetics [Berlin 1820s], as Hegel’s Aesthetics, 2 volumes, tr. T.M. Knox 1979. The introduction is published separately as Introductory Lectures on Aesthetics, tr. B. Bosanquet 1886, reissued 1993 pb, and also as Hegel’s Introduction to Aesthetics, tr. T.M. Knox 9179. Available online: Knox translation of whole text

Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion [Berlin 1821-31], 3 volumes, tr. P.C. Hodgson et al. 1984-87. Preferable to the older version, tr. E.B. Speirs and J.B. Sanderson 1895, reprinted 1968. Available online: Speirs and Sanderson translation (introduction)

Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion: One-volume Edition, The Lectures of 1827 [Berlin 1827], tr. P.C. Hodgson et al. 1988. The 1827 version of the lectures extracted from the 3-volume edition

Lectures on the Proofs of the Existence of God, tr. P.C. Hodgson 2007 Lectures on the History of Philosophy [Berlin 1820’s], 3 volumes, tr. E.S. Haldane and F. Simson 1892-96,

reprinted 1995 pb. A more accurate version of volume 3 is published as Lectures on the History of Philosophy: The Lectures of 1825-26. Volume 3: Medieval and Modern Philosophy, tr. R.F. Brown and J.M. Stewart 1990. The various introductions are translated separately as Introduction to the Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. T.M. Knox and A.V. Miller 1985 pb. Available online: Haldane and Simson translation (selections), (alternative source)

Hegel: The Letters, tr. C. Butler and C. Seiler 1984 A reasonably complete edition of Hegel’s works in German is published by Suhrkamp as Hegel: Werke, 20

volumes pb. For online and CD versions, see www.hegel.de @ Translations of some of Hegel’s short pieces ‘Two fragments of 1797 on love’ [1797], Clio 8(2), 1979 ‘Two fragments on the ideal of social life’ [1799-1800], Clio 10(4), 1981 ‘The relationship of skepticism to philosophy’ [1801], in G. di Giovanni and H.S. Harris, tr. Between Kant and

Hegel: Texts in the Development of Post-Kantian Idealism, 1985

‘On the nature of philosophical critique’ (1802), partly translated in M.N. Forster, Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit, 1998, pp. 605-607

‘Aphorisms from the wastebook’ [1803-1806], Independent Journal of Philosophy 3, 1979 ‘Who thinks abstractly?’ [1807-1808], in Kaufmann Hegel: Reinterpretation, Texts and Commentary, pp. 461-

465. Available online: German text, English text ‘Reason and religious truth’ [1821], foreword to H. Hinrich Religion in its Inner Relation to Science, in F. Weiss

(ed.) Beyond Epistemology: New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, pp. 227-244. Available online: German text

Hegel, G.W.F. (2000) Miscellaneous Writings of G.W.F. Hegel, (ed.) J. Stewart @ PRECURSORS: UP TO HERDER @ Indian and Eastern Philosophy and Hegel Dubey, V.K. (2002) Absolutism: East and West: A Comparative Study of Sri Aurobindo and Hegel Herling, B.L. (2006) The German Gītā: Hermeneutics and Discipline in the German Reception of Indian thought,

1778-1831 @ Greek philosophy in general and Hegel (See also ‘Greek world and its inadequacy’ and ‘Natural law and Hegel’) Gray, J. (1958) Hegel and Greek Thought Heidegger, M. [1958] ‘Hegel and the Greeks’ in W. McNeill (ed.) Pathmarks 1998 (Another English translation

is available online) Riedel, M. [1967] ‘Criticism of natural law theory’, as ch. 4 of his Between Tradition and Revolution, tr. W.

Wright 1984 Taminiaux, J. [1982] ‘Hegel and Hobbes’, in his Dialectic and Difference: Modern Thought and the Sense of

Human Limits 1985 Taminiaux, J. (1984) Naissance de la Philosophie Hégélienne de l’Etat: Commentaire et Traduction de la

Realphilosophie d’Iéna (1805-1806), Introduction (Paris: Payot) De Laurentiis, A. (2000) ‘Silenced subjecvity: remarks on Hegel’s view of Plato’s world’, Studies in Practical

Philosophy 2(1), p. 64-79 De Laurentiis, A. (2005) Subjects in the Ancient and Modern World: On Hegel’s Theory of Subjectivity @ Forms and categories in Plato, Aristotle, Kant and Hegel Mure, G.R.G. (1940) An Introduction to Hegel (Oxford), pp. 82-113 Wilson, J.C. (1968) ‘Categories in Aristotle and Kant’, in J. Moravcsik (ed.) Aristotle: A Collection of Critical

Essays Rosen, M. (1982) Hegel’s Dialectic and its Criticism Jaeschke, W. (1981) ‘Absolute Idee – Absolute Subjektivität. Zum Problem der Persönlichkeit Gottes in der

Logik und in der Religionsphilosophie’ , Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung 35, pp. 385-416 @ Plato, Socrates and Hegel (See also ‘Plato, Aristotle, Kant and Hegel on the forms and categories’) Lectures on the History of Philosophy, section on Plato Philosophy of Right, references to Plato Plato, Timaeus Rosen, S. (1974) ‘Self-consciousness and self-knowledge in Plato and Hegel’, Hegel-Studien 9 Rose, R.E. (1978) ‘Hegel, the Plato of the modern world’, Southwestern Philosophical Studies Griswold, C. (1982) ‘Reflections on ‘dialectic’ in Plato and Hegel’, International Philosophical Quarterly 22(3) Wartenberg, T.E. (1991) ‘Hegel’s use of Socratic Method in the Phenomenology’, Hegel-Jahrbuch Vieillard-Baron, J.-L. (1997) Platon et l’ idéalisme allemand Ferrari, G.R.F. (1999) ‘Platonic love’ in R. Kraut (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Plato Ware, RB (2000) ‘Freedom as justice: Hegel’s interpretation of Plato’s ‘Republic’’, Metaphilosophy 31(3) Sembou, E. (2006) ‘The young Hegel on ‘life’ and ‘love’’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 53-54 @ Plato and Hegel: political philosophies Lectures on the History of Philosophy, section on Plato’s political philosophy Foster, M.B. (1935) The Political Philosophies of Plato and Hegel Inwood, M. (1984) ‘Hegel, Plato and Greek “Sittlichkeit”‘, in Z. Pelczynski (ed.) The State and Civil Society @ Aristotle and Hegel

(With thanks to Vicky Roupa) (See also ‘Plato, Aristotle, Kant and Hegel on the forms and categories’) Lectures on the history of Philosophy, section on Aristotle Mure, G.R. (1940) An Introduction to Hegel Weiss, F.G. (1969) Hegel’s Critique of Aristotle’s Philosophy of Mind Findlay, J.N. (1971) ‘Hegel’s use of teleology’, in Steinkraus, W.E. (ed.) New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel Aubenque, P. (1974) ‘Hegel et Aristote’, in J. d’ Hondt (ed.) Hegel et la pensée grecque Santoro-Brienza, L. (1992) ‘Aristotle and Hegel on nature: some similarities’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of

Great Britain 26 Wolff, M. (1992) Das Körper-Seele Problem. Kommentar zu Hegel Enzyklopädie(1830), #389 [The Body-Soul

Problem: Commentary on Hegel’s 1830 Encyclopaedia, §389] Koninck, T. de and Planty-Bonjour, G. (eds.) (1992) La question de Dieu selon Aristote et Hegel, esp. essays

by P. Aubenque, V. Décarie and L. Ponton Ferrarin, A. (2001) Hegel and Aristotle Pendlebury, G. (2006) Action and Ethics in Aristotle and Hegel: Escaping the Malign Influence of Kant @ Aristotle and Hegel: political philosophy (See also ‘Slavery in Hegel’) Ilting, K.-H. (1963-4) ‘Hegels Auseinandersetzung mit der aristotelischen Politik’, Philosophisches Jahrbuch 71 Pinson, J.-C. (1988) ‘Hegel et l’empirisme dans l’ecrit sur le droit naturel de 1802-1803’, Archives de

Philosophie 51 Depew, D.J. (1992) ‘The polis transfigured: Aristotle’s Politics and Marx’s Critique of Hegel’s “Philosophy of

Right”‘, in G.E. McCarthy (ed.) Marx and Aristotle: Nineteenth Century German Social Theory and Classical Antiquity

Fawes, H. (1995) ‘L’esclave, le travail et l’action: Aristote et Hegel’, Archives de Philosophie 58(1) Bull, M. (1998) ‘Slavery and the multiple self’, New Left Review 231 @ Christian theology in general and Hegel (See also ‘Christianity, Hegel’s christology’ and ‘Hegel’s metaphysics: theological interpretations’) Sontag, F. (1962) Divine Perfection: Possible Ideas of God Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit 1770-1807 @ Neo-Platonism, Pseudo-Dionysianism and Hegel (Plotinus, Proclus, Pseudo-Dionysius, John Scotus Eriugena) (Also in their relation to Schelling) Hegel, Lectures on the History of Philosophy, section on neo-Platonism Plotinus, Enneads Proclus, The Elements of Theology Rist, J.M. (1967) Plotinus: The Road to Reality (Cambridge), pp. 38-54 Findlay, J.N. (1970) ‘Towards a neo-neo-platonism’, in his Ascent to the Absolute: Metaphysical Papers and

Lectures Beierwaltes, W. (1973) ‘The revaluation of John Scottus Eriugena in German Idealism’ in J.J. O’Meara and L.

Bieler (eds.) The Mind of Eriugena Vater, M.G. (1976) ‘Schelling’s neo-Platonic system-notation, “Ineinsbildung” and temporal unfolding’ in R.B.

Harris (ed.) The Significance of Neoplatonism+ Kolakowski, L. (1978) Main Currents of Marxism, Vol. 1: The Founders, ch. 1 Gottfried, P.E. (1981) ‘Hegel and Proclus: remarks on a problematic relationship’, Thought: Fordham University

Quarterly 56, pp. 263-271 O’Regan, C. (1994) The Heterodox Hegel, ch. 2 ‘The first narrative epoch: the immanent trinity’ Beierwaltes, W. (2002) ‘The legacy of Neoplatonism in F. W. J. Schelling’s thought’, International Journal of

Philosophical Studies 10(4) @ Paul, John, Marcion and Hegel Souche-Dagues, D. (2000) ‘Thinking Logos in Hegelianism’, Philosophical Forum 31(3-4) @ Gnosticism and Hegel (See also ‘Boehme and Hegel’) Hanratty, G. (1984) ‘Hegel and the Gnostic tradition: I’, Philosophical Studies 30 Hanratty, G. (1986-87) ‘Hegel and the Gnostic tradition: II’, Philosophical Studies 31 O’Regan, C. (2001) Gnostic Return in Modernity

Burbidge, J. (2002) ‘The word became flesh or the orthodox Hegel’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 45-46

Mitscherling, J. (1997) ‘The identity of the human and the divine in the logic of speculative philosophy’, in M. Bauer (ed.) Hegel and the Tradition: Essays in Honour of H.S. Harris

Hanratty, G. (1997) Studies in Gnosticism and in the Philosophy of Religion @ Aquinas and Hegel Lakebrink, B. (1955) Hegels dialektische Ontologie und die thomistische Analektik Maritain, J. (1964) Moral Philosophy, an Historical and Critical Survey of the Great Systems, section on Hegel Lakebrink, B. (1984) Perfectio omnium perfectionum. Studien zur Seinskonzeption bei Thomas von Aquin und

Hegel Brito, E. (1991) Dieu et l’Etre d’après Thomas d’Aquin et Hegel Vieillard-Baron , J.-L. (1994) De Saint Thomas à Hegel @ Hermeticism, German mysticism and Hegel: general (Hermes Trismegistus, Eckhart, Cusa, Bruno, Paracelsus, Boehme) Benz, E. [1968] The Mystical Sources of German Romantic Philosophy, tr. 1983+ Kolakowski, L. (1978) Main Currents of Marxism, Vol. 1: The Founders, ch. 1 Weeks, A. (1993) German Mysticism: From Hildegard of Bingen to Ludwig Wittgenstein, ch. 9 Magee, G.A. (2001) Hegel and the Hermetic Tradition, introduction available online @ Eckhart and Hegel Ekhart, Meister Eckhart: Selected Treatises and Sermons, (eds.) J.M. Clark and J.V. Skinner 1963 Lichtenstein, E. (1966) Zur Entwicklung des Bildungsbegriffs von Meister Eckhart bis Hegel Beriaschwili, M. (2001) ‘Das einfache Eins-Werden des Menschen und Gottes bei Meister Eckhart und

Hegel’, Bochumer Philosophisches Jahrbuch fur Antike und Mittelalter 5(1), pp. 71-95 @ Boehme and Hegel Lectures on the History of Philosophy, vol. 3, section on Jacob Boehme Haldane, E. S. (1897) ‘Jacob Boehme in his relation to Hegel’, Philosophical Review 6 Benz, E. [1968] The Mystical Sources of German Romantic Philosophy, tr. B. Reynolds and Eunice Paul 1983 Vieillard-Baron, J-L. [1971] ‘Natural religion: an investigation of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, tr. J. Stewart

in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader 1998 Walsh, D. (1994) ‘The historical dialectic of spirit: Jacob Boehme’s influence on Hegel’, in R.L. Perkins

(ed.) History and System: Hegel’s Philosophy of History (with ‘Comment’ by E. von der Luft)) O’Regan, C. (2002) Gnostic Apocalypse: Jacob Boehme’s Haunted Narrative @ Hobbes and Hegel Natural Law, tr. Knox, pp. 59-70 Lectures on the History of Philosophy, The Lectures of 1825-1826, Volume 3, tr. Brown and Stewart, pp. 180-182 Strauss, L. (1936) The Political Philosophy of Hobbes (see end of ch. 4) Riedel, M. (1971) ‘Nature and freedom in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s Political

Philosophy, reprinted as ‘Laws of nature and laws of right’, ch. 3 of Riedel’s Between Tradition and Revolution 1984

Siep, L. [1974] ‘The struggle for recognition: Hegel’s dispute with Hobbes in the Jena writings’, in J. O’Neill (ed.) Hegel’s Dialectic of Desire and Recognition 1996 (originally in German in Hegel-Studien 9)

* Taminiaux, J. [1981] ‘Hegel and Hobbes’, in his Dialectic and Difference: Modern Thought and the Sense of Human Limits 1985 (originally in French in Taminiaux’s Philosophie et Politique)

Peperzak, A.T. (1995) ‘Hegel and Hobbes revisited’, in A. Collins (ed.) Hegel on the Modern World Buchwalter, A. (1995) ‘Hegel, Hobbes, Kant and the scientization of practical philosophy’, in A. Collins

(ed.) Hegel on the Modern World @ Spinoza and neo-Spinozism as influences on Hegel (‘Neo-Spinozism’ refers to the revival of Spinozistic thought by Herder, Goethe and Lessing in the 1780s) Spinoza [1677] Ethics Herder [1787] God: Some Conversations, Bobbs-Merrill, 1940 (esp. the third conversation; see also the

introduction by F.H Burkhardt) Beck, L.W. (1969) Early German Philosophy: Kant and his Predecessors Bell, D. (1984) Spinoza in Germany from 1670 to the Age of Goethe Beiser, F.C. (1987) The Fate of Reason: German Philosophy From Kant to Fichte

Walther, M. (ed.) (1992) Spinoza und der deutsche Idealimus @ Spinoza and pantheism: Hegel’s critique (Including Hegel’s debates with those who accused him of atheism and pantheism) Phenomenology of Spirit §17 Science of Logic, tr. Miller¸ pp. 536-40 (‘The philosophy of Spinoza and Leibniz’), 580-1 Encyclopaedia Logic §151A Philosophy of Spirit §573 Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Haldane and Simson, vol. 3 pp. 256-290 (on Spinoza) Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, vol. 1, the section ‘Of God’ Whittemore, R.C. (1960) ‘Hegel as panentheist’, Tulane Studies in Philosophy 9 Parkinson, G.H.R. (1977) ‘Hegel, pantheism and Spinoza’, Journal of the History of Ideas 38(3) Lauer, Q. (1982) Hegels’ Concept of God, ch. 6 ‘The question of pantheism’ Yovel, Y. (1989) The Adventures of Immanence, ch. 2 Byrne, L. (1990) ‘Hegel’s criticism of Spinoza’s concept of the attribute’, in G. di Giovanni (ed.) Essays

on Hegel’s Logic Solomon, R.C. (1978) ‘The secret of Hegel (Kierkegaard’s complaint): a study in Hegel’s philosophy of

religion’, The Philosophical Forum 9(4) @ Maimon and Hegel Atlas, S. (1964) From Critical to Speuclative Idealism: The Philosophy of Salomon Maimon Beiser, F.C. (1987) The Fate of Reason: German Philosophy from Kant to Fichte, ch. 10 @ Rousseau and Hegel (See also ‘Substantial will’) (See also ‘French Revolution’) (See also ‘Social contract theory: Hegel’s critique’) (See also ‘Freedom in Hegel’) Phenomenology ch. 6B 3 ‘Absolute freedom and terror’ Encyclopaedia Logic §163A Philosophy of Right §§29R, 258R Philosophy of Spirit §435, 435A Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Haldane and Simpson, vol. 1vol. 2 p. 115, vol. 3 pp. 400-402 Kelly, G.A. (1969) Idealism Politics and History: Sources of Hegelian Thought, pp. 336-342 Méthais, P. (1974) ‘Contrat et volonté genérale selon Hegel et Rousseau’ in d’Hondt, J. (ed.) Hegel et le Siècle

des Lumières Riley, P. (1982) Will and Political Legitimacy, chs. on Rousseau and Hegel Fulda, H.F. and Horstmann (eds.) (1991) Rousseau, die Revolution und der junge Hegel Philonenko, A. (1991) ‘Rousseau et Hegel: droit et histoire’, in Fulda and Horstmann (eds.) Rousseau, die

Revolution und der junge Hegel Fulda, H.F. (1991) ‘Rousseausche Probleme in Hegels Entwicklung’, in Fulda and Horstmann

(eds.) Rousseau, die Revolution und der junge Hegel Wokler, R. (1993) ‘Hegel’s Rousseau: the general will and civil society’, Arachne 8, Göteborg; reprinted in

Wokler’s Rousseau’s Enlightenment: The Historical Contexts of his Social Thought, 1998 Ripstein, A. (1994) ‘Universal and general wills: Hegel and Rousseau’, Political Theory 22(3) Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom, chs. 1-2 De Laurentiis, A. (2003) ‘The place of Rousseau in Hegel’s system’, in D.A. Duquette (ed.) Hegel’s History of

Philosophy: New Interpretations @ Political economists and Hegel (See also ‘Civil society’) Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel Chamley, P. (1963) Économie politique chez Stuart et Hegel Chamley, P. (1965) ‘Les origines de la pensée économique de Hegel’, Hegel-Studien 3 Avineri, S. (1972) Hegel’s Theory of the Modern State, first chs Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983 Plant, R. (1977) ‘Hegel and political economy, parts 1 and 2’, New Left Review 103-4, revised and extended as

‘Hegel on political economy’, in Maker 1987 Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983 Cullen, B. (1979) Hegel’s Social and Political Thought

Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit, 1770-180, ch. 5 Waszek, N. (1988) The Scottish Enlightenment and Hegel’s Account of ‘Civil Society’ Henderson, J. and Davis, J.B. (1991) ‘Adam Smith’s influence on Hegel’s philosophical writings’, Journal of the

History of Economic Thought 13 @ PRECURSORS: GERMAN IDEALISM @ German idealism and Hegel Seth Pringle-Pattison, A. (1882) The Development from Kant to Hegel, reprinted 2002, available online Henrich, D. [1973] Between Kant and Hegel: Lectures on German Idealism, tr. 2003 Ameriks, K. and Sturma, D. (eds.) (1995) The Modern Subject: Conceptions of the Self in Classical German

Philosophy Kelm, D. and Zöller, G. (eds.) (1997) Figuring the Self: Subject, Absolute and Others in in Classical German

Philosophy Sedgwick, S. (ed.) (2000) The Reception of Kant’s Critical Philosophy: Fichte, Schelling, and Hegel Beiser, F.C. (2002) German Idealism: The Struggle Against Subjectivism, 1781-1801 Pinkard, T. (2002) German Philosophy 1760-1860: The Legacy of Idealism Beiser, F. (2005) Hegel @ Kant and Hegel: general (See also ‘Bifurcation’) (For specific areas see ‘Kant’s epistemology and metaphysics: Hegel’s critique’, ‘Kant’s ethics and theory of will

and freedom: Hegel’s critique’ and ‘Kant and Fichte’s theology and Hegel’) Priest, S. (ed.) (1987) Hegel’s Critique of Kant Zimmerman, R.L. (2005) The Kantianism of Hegel and Nietzsche: Renovation in 19th-Century German

Philosophy @ Kant and the Phenomenology Solomon, R.C. (1974) ‘Hegel’s epistemology’, American Philosophical Quarterly 11, reprinted in Inwood

(ed.) Hegel Redding, P. (1996) Hegel’s Hermeneutics Kain, P.J. (2005) Hegel and the Other: A Study of the Phenomenology of Spirit Bristow, W.F. (2007) Hegel and the Transformation of Philosophical Critique @ Kant’s epistemology and metaphysics: Hegel’s critique (Also on the contrast between Hegel’s idealism and Kant’s in general) (See also specific sections) (See also ‘Plato, Aristotle, Kant and Hegel on the forms and categories’) (See also ‘Kant and Fichte’s theology and Hegel’) (See also ‘Proposition (judgment), speculative proposition, language’) (See also ‘Metaphysics of Hegel: Kantian interpretations’) (See also ‘McDowell on Hegel’) (For Hegel’s general critique of the Kantian standpoint see ‘Bifurcation and the standpoint of modern thought,

Kant’s standpoint as a whole’) Faith and Knowledge, A. ‘Kantian Philosophy’, esp. c. pp. 63-78 Phenomenology §235 Science of Logic, tr. Miller, pp. 35-36, 44-47, 56, 62-3, 489-490, 577-595, 789 Encyclopaedia Logic §§40-60 Philosophy of Spirit §§413-425 Lectures on the History of Philosophy, volume 3, section on Kant Maier, J. (1966) Hegel’s Critique of Kant Soll, I. (1969) An Introduction to Hegel’s Metaphysics, ch. 2 Smith, J.E. (1973) ‘Hegel’s critique of Kant’, Review of Metaphysics 26, reprinted in J.J. O’Malley et al. Hegel

and the History of Philosophy 1974 Solomon, R.C. (1970) ‘Hegel’s concept of “Geist”‘, Review of Metaphysics 23, reprinted in MacIntyre

(ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays Sayers, S. (1985) Reality and Reason: Dialectic and the Theory of Knowledge, chs. 2-3 Ameriks, K. (1985) ‘Hegel’s critique of Kant’s theoretical philosophy’ Philosophy and Phenomenological

Research 46(1) Priest, S. (ed.) (1987) Hegel’s Critique of Kant, first six essays

Hartnack, J. (1987) ‘Categories and things-in-themselves’ in Priest (ed.) Hegel’s Critique of Kant Pippin, R.B. (1987) ‘Kant on the spontaneity of mind’, Canadian Journal of Philosophy 17(2), reprinted in

Pippin’s Idealism as Modernism: Hegelian Variations Rosen, M. (1988) ‘From Vorstellung to thought: is a ‘non-metaphysical’ view of Hegel possible?’, in Henrich, D.

and Horstmann, R.-P. (eds.) Metaphysik nach Kant?, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3

* Bird, G. (1987) ‘Hegel’s account of Kant’s epistemology in the Lectures on the History of Philosophy’, in S. Priest (ed.) Hegel’s Critique of Kant

Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, chs. 1, 2, and part 3 Stern, R. (1990) Hegel, Kant and the Structure of the Object* Guyer, P. (1993) ‘Thought and being: Hegel’s critique of Kant’s theoretical philosophy’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The

Cambridge Companion to Hegel McDowell, J. (1996) Mind and World McDowell, J. [2001] ‘L’Idealismo di Hegel come Radicalizazzione di Kant’, in L. Ruggiu and L. Testa

(eds.) Hegel contemporaneo: La ricezione americana di Hegel a confronto con la tradizione europe, 2003 @ Intellectual intuition from Kant to Hegel (Also called ‘intuitive understanding’) Kant, Critique of Judgment, §§76-77 Schelling, F.W.J. [1802] ‘Further presentations from the system of philosophy’, tr. M. Vater, Philosophical

Forum 31(4), 2001 (in ‘Schelling) Hegel, Faith and Knowledge, pp. 88-90Walsh, W. (1946) ‘Hegel and intellectual intuition’, Mind 55Gram, M.S. (1981) ‘Intellectual intuition: the continuity thesis’, Journal of the History of Ideas 42 Walsh , W. (1982) ‘Kant as seen by Hegel’, in Vesey, G. (ed.) Idealism Past and Present Snow, D.E. (1987) ‘F.H. Jacobi and the development of German Idealism’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 25 Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, ch. 4 Velkley, R.L. (1997) ‘Realizing nature in the self: Schelling on art and intellectual intuition’, in G. Zöller

(ed.) Figuring the Self: Subject, Absolute, and Others in Classical German Philosophy Westphal, K.R. (2000) ‘Kant, Hegel, and the fate of ‘the’ intuitive intellect’, in S. Sedgwick (ed.) The Reception

of Kant’s Critical Philosophy: Fichte, Schelling, and Hegel Vater, M. (2000) ‘Intellectual intuition in Schelling’s philosophy of identity 1801-1804’, in C. Asmuth

(ed.) Schelling: Zwischen Fichte und Hegel Kreines, J. (2007) ‘Between the bounds of experience and divine intuition: Kant’s epistemic limits and Hegel’s

ambitions’, Inquiry 53 @ Kant on self-consciousness, apperception and the transcendental deduction: Hegel’s critique (See also ‘McDowell on Hegel’, ‘Hegel’s metaphysics: Kantian interpretations’) (For Hegel’s own positive account, see ‘‘Self-consciousness in the Phenomenology’) Faith and Knowledge, A. ‘Kantian Philosophy’ Science of Logic, pp. 577-595 Guyer, P. (1980) ‘Kant on apperception and a priori synthesis’, American Philosophical Quarterly 17 Düsing, K. (1983) ‘Constitution and structure of self-identity: Kant’s theory of apperception and Hegel’s

criticism’, Midwest Studies in Philosophy 8, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Priest, S. (1987) ‘Subjectivity and objectivity in Kant and Hegel’ in Priest (ed.) Hegel’s Critique of Kant* Pippin, R.B. (1989) ‘Apperception and the difference between Kantian and Hegelian idealism’, in G. Funke and

T.M. Seebohm (eds.) Proceedings of the Sixth International Kant Congress, vol. II/2, 535-550, revised as ch. 2 of Pippin’sHegel’s Idealism

Sedgwick, S. (1992) ‘Hegel’s treatment of transcendental apperception in Kant’, The Owl of Minerva 23(2) Sedgwick, S.S. (1993) ‘Pippin on Hegel’s critique of Kant’, International Philosophical Quarterly 33(3) De Nys, M.J. (1995) ‘Self-consciousness and the concept in Hegel’s appropriation of Kant’ in A.B. Collins

(ed.) Hegel on the Modern World Stern, D.S. (1995) ‘Transcendental apperception and subjective logic: Kant and Hegel on the role of the subject’,

in A.B. Collins (ed.) Hegel on the Modern World McDowell, J. (2003) “‘The apperceptive I and the empirical self”: towards a heterodox reading of “lordship and

bondage” in Hegel’s Phenomenology’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 47-48, reprinted in K. Deligiorgi (ed.)Hegel: New Directions, 2006

Schulting, D. (2005) ‘Hegel on Kant’s ‘synthetic a priori’’ in ‘Glauben und Wissen’, in A. Arndt (ed.) Glauben und Wissen, Dritter Teil (Hegel-Jahrbuch 2005)

@ Kant’s dialectic and antinomies: Hegel’s critique Encyclopaedia Logic §48 Science of Logic ‘Pure Quantity’, remark 2 (pp. 190-199), ‘Quantitative infinity’ remark 2 (pp. 234-238) Sedgwick, S. (1991) ‘Hegel on Kant’s antinomies and the distinction between general and transcendental

logic’, The Monist 74(3) Priest, G. (1995) Beyond the Limits of Thought @ Kant’s ethics and theory of will and freedom: Hegel’s critique of it in general (Including material focusing exclusively on ch. 5C and ch. 6C of the Phenomenology) (Also of Kant’s theory of freedom, will and morality; of Moralität) (For Hegel on form and content, and critique of Kant’s formalism, see) (See also bibliography in Wood 1990 p273) (See also ‘Action and will’ and ‘Duty, desire and feelings in Hegel’) Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 5Cb, 5Cc, 6C Philosophy of Right §§129-141 ‘Good and conscience’ Bradley, F.H. (1927) Ethical Studies, 2nd ed., essay 4 ‘Duty for duty’s sake’ Reyburn, H.A. (1921) The Ethical Theory of Hegel, chs. 8-10 Ritter, J. [1956] ‘Morality and ethical life: Hegel’s controversy with Kantian ethics’ in Hegel and the French

Revolution: Essays on the Philosophy of Right Knox, T.M. (1957-58) ‘Hegel’s attitude to Kant’s ethics’, Kant-Studien 49, pp. 76-81 Maier, J. (1966) On Hegel’s Critique of Kant, relevant chapters Walsh, W.H. (1969) Hegelian Ethics, chs. 1-9 Shklar, J. N. (1974) ‘The Phenomenology: beyond morality’, Western Philosophical Quarterly 27, reprinted

in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, vol. 4 Gram, M. S. (1978) ‘Moral and literary ideals in Hegel’s critique of “the moral world-view”‘, Clio 7: pp. 375-

402, reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader Petry, M.J. (1983) ‘Hegel’s criticism of the ethics of Kant and Fichte’, in L. Stepelevich and D. Lamb

(eds.) Hegel’s Philosophy of Action Priest, S. (ed.) (1987) Hegel’s Critique of Kant, relevant essays O’Hagan, T. (1987) ‘On Hegel’s critique of Kant’s moral and political philosophy’, in Priest (ed.) Hegel’s

Critique of Kant Sedgwick, S.S. (1988) ‘Hegel’s critique of the subjective idealism of Kant’s ethics’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 26 Rawls, J. (1989) ‘Themes in Kant’s moral philosophy’, in E. Förster (ed.) Kant’s Transcendental Deductions Hoy, D.C. (1989) ‘Hegel’s critique of Kantian morality’, History of Philosophy Quarterly 6 Stern, P. (1989) ‘On rational autonomy and ethical community: Hegel’s critique of Kantian morality’, Praxis

International 9(3)* Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, chs. 8-9 Allison, H.E. (1990) Kant’s Theory of Freedom, ch. 10 sec. 2 Westphal, K.R. (1992?) ‘Hegel’s critique of Kant’s moral world view’, Philosophical Topics 19(2), pp. 133-17+ Wood, A. (1993) ‘Hegel’s ethics’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Pippin, R.B. (1995) ‘Hegel on the rationality and priority of ethical life’, Neue Hefte für Philosophie 35, pp. 95-

126, reprinted as ‘Hegel’s ethical rationalism’ in Pippin’s Idealism as Modernism: Hegelian Variations 1997 @ Kant’s ethics: Hegel’s critique of its formalism (Including Hegels’ critique of Kant’s divorce of morality and feeling - see also ‘Duty, desire and feelings in

Hegel’) (Including Hegel on form generating content in ethics) Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 5C sec. c Natural Law, tr. T.M. Knox 1975, pp. 70-92, esp. 75-83 Philosophy of Right §§135R ‘Good and conscience’ Walsh, W.H. (1969) Hegelian Ethics, ch. 4 ‘Ethical formalism’ Ameriks, K. (1987) ‘The Hegelian critique of Kantian morality’, in B. den Ouden (ed.) New Essays on Kant Sedgwick, S.S. (1988) ‘On the relation of pure reason to content: a reply to Hegel’s critique of formalism in

Kant’s ethics’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 49(1) Wood, A. (1989) ‘The emptiness of the moral will’, The Monist 72(3), reprinted in R. Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel:

Critical Assessments, vol. 4* Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, ch. 9 ‘The emptiness of the moral law’ Pippin, R.C. (1991) ‘Idealism and agency in Kant and Hegel’, Journal of Philosophy 88

Pippin, R.C. (1991) ‘Hegel, ethical reasons, Kantian rejoinders’, Philosophical Topics 19(2), reprinted in Pippin’s Idealism as Modernism: Hegelian Variations

Sedgwick, S. (1998) ‘On the relation of pure reason to content: a reply to Hegel’s critique of formalism in Kant’s ethics’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 49

Wood, A. (1999) Kant’s Ethical Thought, ch. 3 sec. 7 ‘Problems with FUL’ @ Schiller and Hegel Beiser, F.C. (2005) Schiller as Philosopher: A Re-examination @ Fichte: general (See also D. Breazeale, ‘English Fichte bibliography’ in D. Breazeale and T. Rockmore (eds.) Fichte: Historical

Contexts / Contemporary Controversies, 1994) (Each issue of the North American’s Fichtean Society’s newletter Fichteana has a bibliography of recent work on

Fichte. See also the society’s bibliography of Fichte’s works in English translation) Fichte [1790-99] Early Philosophical Writings, tr. D. Breazeale 1988, especially ‘Some lectures concerning the

scholar’s vocation’ Fichte, Introductions to the Wissenschaftslehre and Other Writings, tr. D. Breazeale 1994 Fichte [1794-95] The Science of Knowledge [‘Foundation of the Entire Wissenschaftslehre’], trs. Heath and

Lachs, §§1-3 Fichte [1796-97] The Foundations of Transcendental Philosophy (Wissenschaftslehre) Nova Methodo, tr.

Breazeale 1992 Fichte [1800] The Vocation of Man, sec. 2 ‘Knowledge’ Fichte [1810] ‘Outlines of the doctrine of knowledge’, in The Popular Works of Johann Gottlieb Fichte, tr. W.

Smith, 1889, available online Fichte, The Popular Works of Johann Gottlieb Fichte, tr. W. Smith, (ed.) D. Breazeale 1999.

Introduction available online Copleston, F. (1963) A History of Philosophy. Vol. 7: Fichte to Nietzsche, section on Fichte Henrich, D. [1973] Between Kant and Hegel: Lectures on German Idealism, 2003, section 3 ‘Fichte’ ‘New studies in the philosophy of Fichte’ (1976) Idealistic Studies 6(2) (special issue on Fichte) Tabor, J. (1983) Transformative Philosophy: A Study of Sankara, Fichte and Heidegger Beiser, F.C. (1987) The Fate of Reason: German Philosophy from Kant to Fichte Jalloch, C.M. (1988) Fichte’s Kant Interpretation and the Doctrine of Science ‘Fichte and contemporary philosophy’ (1988) Philosophical Forum 19(2-3) (special issue on Fichte)+ Wood, A. (1991) ‘Fichte’s philosophical revolution’, Philosophical Topics 19 Breazeale, D. and Rockmore, T. (eds.) (1994) Fichte: Historical Contexts / Contemporary Controversies Breazale, D. (1993) ‘Fichte and Schelling: The Jena period’, in R.C.. Solomon and K.M. Higgins (eds.)

(1993) Routledge History of Philosophy. Volume 6: The Age of German Idealism Seidel, G.J. (1993) Fichte’s Wissenschaftslehre of 1794: A Commentary on Part 1 @ Fichte: metaphysics and relation to Kant’s first critique Lachs, J. (1972) ‘Fichte’s Idealism’, American Philosophical Quarterly 91 Mandt, A.J. (1984) ‘Fichte’s idealism in theory and practice’, Idealistic Studies 14 Taber, J. (1984) ‘Fichte’s emendation of Kant’, Kant-Studien 75* Philonenko, A. (1988) ‘Fichte and the critique of metaphysics’, Philosophical Forum 19(2-3) Reid, J.D. (2003) ‘On the unity of theoretical subjectivity in Kant and Fichte’, Review of Metaphysics 57 @ Fichte on consciousness and self-consciousness* Henrich, D. [1966] ‘Fichte’s original insight’ in D.E. Christensen et al. (ed.) Contemporary German Philosophy Vol. 1,

1982 Henrich, D. [1970] ‘Self-consciousness: a critical introduction to a theory’, Man and World 4(1), 1971 Pippin, R. (1988) ‘Fichte’s contribution’ in Philosophical Forum 19(2-3), revised as ch. 3 of his Hegel’s

Idealism: The Satisfactions of Self-Consciousness, 1989 Neuhouser, F. (1990) Fichte’s Theory of Subjectivity La Vopa, A. (2001) Fichte: The Self and the Calling of Philosophy Breazeale, D. (2005) ‘Check or checkmate? On the finitude of the Fichtean self’, in K. Ameriks and D. Sturma

(eds.) The Modern Subject @ Fichte’s ethics Fichte, J.G. (1798) The System of Ethics, trans. G. Zöller and D. Breazeale 2005

+ Wood, A. (1999) ‘The ‘I’ as principle of practical philosophy’, in S. Sedgwick (ed.) The Reception of Kant’s Critical Philosophy: Fichte Schelling and Hegel, also available online

Darwall, S. (2005), ‘Fichte and the second person standpoint’, International Yearbook of German Idealism, vol. 3 Breazeale, D. (2008), ‘The first-person standpoint of Fichte’s ethics’, Philosophy Today 52(3-4) @ Fichte’s philosophy of right (general) (Including the relation between ethics and right) Fichte, J.G. [1796-97] Foundations of Natural Right [Grundlage des Naturrechts nach Prinzipien der

Wissenschaftslehre] part 1, §§1-4 Fichte, J.G. [1798] System of Ethics in accordance with the Principles of the Wissenschaftslehre, tr. 2005 Philonenko, A. (1968) Théorie et praxis dans la pensée morale et politique de Kant et de Fichte en 1793, 2nd ed.

1988 Renaut, A. (1986) Le système du droit. Philosophie et droit dans la pensée de Fichte Hösle, V. (1992) ‘Zur Interpretation von Fichtes Theorie der Intersubjectivität’, in Fichtes Lehre von

Rechstverhältnisse: Die Deduktion der §§1-4 der Grundlage des Naturrechts und ihre Stellung in der Rechtsphilosophie

Shell, S. (1992) ‘“A determined stand”: freedom and security in Fichte’s Science of Right’, Polity 25 Williams, R.R. (1992) Recognition: Fichte and Hegel on the Other Ferry, L. [198?] Political Philosophy, vol. 2: The System of Philosophies of History, tr. F. Philip 1992 Radrizzani, I. (1993) Vers la fondation de l’intersubjectivité chez Fichte. Des Principes à la Nova Methodo Williams, R.R. (1994) ‘The question of the other in the thought of Fichte’, in D. Breazeale & T. Rockmore

(eds.) Fichte: Historical Contexts/Contemporary Controversies* Martin, W.M. (1997) Idealism and Objectivity: Understanding Fichte’s Jena Project Zoeller, G. (1998) Fichte’s transcendental philosophy: The Original Duplicity of Intelligence and Will+ Neuhouser, F. (2000) ‘Introduction’ to Fichte, Foundations of Natural Right, tr. M. Baur Breazeale, D. and Rockmore, T. (2006) Rights, Bodies and Recognition: New Essays on Fichte’s Foundations of

Natural Right Beck, G. (2008) Fichte and Kant on Freedom, Rights, and Law James, D. (2010) ‘Fichte’s reappraisal of Kant’s theory of cosmopolitan right’, History of European Ideas 36 James, D. (2011) Fichte’s Social and Political Philosophy, ch. 1 (second entry) Nakhimovsky, I. (2011) The Closed Commercial State: Perpetual Peace and Commercial Society from Rousseau

to Fichte @ Fichte’s distinction between right and ethics Ferry, L. (1988) ‘The distinction between law and ethics in the early philosophy of Fichte’, Philosophical

Forum 19(2-3) Neuhouser, F. (1994) ‘Fichte and the relationship between right and morality’, in D. Breazeale and T. Rockmore

(eds.) Fichte: Historical Contexts/ Contemporary Controversies James, D. (2009), ‘The relation of right to morality in Fichte’s Jena theory of the state and society’, History of

European Ideas 35 @ Fichte on recognition and intersubjecivity Philonenko, A. (1966) La Liberté Humaine dans la Philosophie de Fichte, 2nd ed. 1980+ Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, ch. 4 Wolff, E.A. and Zaczyk, R. (1992) Fichtes Lehre vom Rechtsverhältnis: Die Deduktion der §§1-4 der

“Grundlage des Naturrechts” und ihre Stellung in der Rechtsphilosophie Shell, S. (1992) ‘“A determined stand”: freedom and security in Fichte’s Science of Right’, section 1, Polity 25(1) Williams, R.R. (1995) ‘The other: F.H. Jacobi and German idealism’, in A.B. Collins (ed.) Hegel on the Modern

World Franks, P. (1996) ‘The discovery of the other: Cavell, Fichte and scepticism’, Common Knowledge 5 Redding (1996) Hegel’s Hermeneutics, ch. 5 ‘Hegel’s recognitive theory of spirit’+ Chitty, A. (1998) ‘Recognition and social relations of production’, section 1, Historical Materialism 2 Herbert, G.B. (1998) ‘Fichte’s deduction of rights from self-consciousness’, Interpretation: A Journal of Political

Philosophy 25(2) Fischbach, F. (1999) Fichte et Hegel: la reconnaissance, section on Fichte Moggach, D. (1999) ‘Reciprocity, elicitation, recognition: the thematics of intersubjectivity in the early

Fichte’, Dialogue 38(2) Giassi, L. (2000) ‘De la déduction fichtéene à la phénoménologie hégélienne: le concept d’intersubjectivité’, in

M. Beinenstock and M. Crampe-Casnabet (eds.) Dans quelle mesure la philosophie est pratique. Fichte, Hegel

Honneth, A. (2001) ‘Die transzendentalen Notwendigkeit von Intersubjectivität’ in J-C. Merle (ed.) Johann Gottlieb Fichte: Grundlage des Naturrechts

Brinkmann, K. (2002) ‘The deduction of intersubjectivity in Fichte’s Grundlage des Naturrechts’, in D. Breazeale and T. Rockmore (eds.) New Essays on Fichte’s Later Jena Wissenschaftslehre

Scribner, F.S. (2002) “The ‘subtle matter’ of intersubjectivity in the Grundlage des Naturrechts’, in D.Breazeale and T. Rockmore (eds.) New Essays on Fichte’s Later Jena Wissenschaftslehre

Siemek, M.J. (2003) ‘Fichtes und Hegels Konzept der Intersubjektivität’, Fichte-Studien 23 Nowak-Juchacz, E. (2003) ‘Das Anerkennungsprinzip bei Kant, Fichte und Hegel’, Fichte-Studien 23 Mather, R. (2003) ‘On the concepts of recognition’, Fichte-Studien 23 Gardner, S. (2005) ‘Sartre, intersubjectivity, and German Idealism’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 43 (see

pp. 337-40) Wood, A. (2006) ‘Fichte’s intersubjective I’, Inquiry 49(1) Ware, O. (2010), ‘Fichte’s voluntarism’, European Journal of Philosophy 18 Nomer, F. (2010), ‘Fichte and the relationship between self-positing and rights’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 48(4) @ Fichte on property Neuhouser, F. (1994) ‘Fichte and the relationship between right and morality’, in D. Breazeale and T. Rockmore

(eds.) Fichte: Historical Contexts/ Contemporary Controversies Perru, O. (1998) ‘Rapports de droit et propriete selon Fichte’, Revue Philosophique de Louvain 96(3), pp. 489-495 Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom ch. 5 sec. 4 James, D. (2010) ‘Fichte’s theory of property’, European Journal of Political Theory 9(2) James, D. (2011) Fichte’s Social and Political Philosophy, ch. 1 @ Fichte and Hegel: general Science of Logic, tr. Miller pp. 77, 709 Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Haldane and Simson vol. 3 pp. 479-506 ‘Fichte’ Siep, L. (1970) Hegels Fichtekritik und die Wissenschaftslehre von 1804 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 1 Seidel, G.J. (1976) Activity and Ground: Fichte, Schelling and Hegel Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, chs. 1-2 Kelly, G. (1969) Idealism, Politics and History: The Sources of Hegelian Thought Seidel, G.J. (1976) Activity and Ground: Fichte, Schelling and Hegel+ Beiser, F.C. (1993) ‘Introduction: Hegel and the problem of metaphysics’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge

Companion to Hegel Houlgate, S. (1994) ‘Hegel and Fichte: recognition, otherness and absolute knowing’, The Owl of Minerva 26(1) @ Fichte and Hegel: recognition (See ‘Recognition in the Jena writings’) @ Romanticism and Hegel (Novalis, Schlegel) (For Schelling see ‘Schelling’) (For Hölderlin see ‘Hölderlin and Hegel’) Werner, A.S. (1980) Spirit and Politics in German Idealism and Romanticism: G.W.F. Hegel and Friedrich

Schlegel Beiser, F.C. (1992) Enlightenment, Revolution and Romanticism: The Genesis of Modern German Political

Thought 1790-1800 Beiser, F.C. (ed.) (1996) The Early Political Writings of The German Romantics Beiser, F.C. (2004) The Romantic Imperative: The Concept of Early German Romanticism Frank, M. (2003) The Philosophical Foundations of Early German Romanticism @ Schelling (Including Schelling on recognition) (See also ‘Schellingian critiques of Hegel’) Schelling, F.W.J. [1795] ‘Of the I as the principle of philosophy’, in The Unconditional in Human Knowledge:

Four Early Essays (1794-96), tr. F. Marti 1980 Schelling, F.W.J. [1795] ‘Philosophical letters on dogmatism and criticism’, in The Unconditional in Human

Knowledge: Four Early Essays (1794-96), tr. F. Marti 1980

Schelling, F.W.J. [1800] System of Transcendental Idealism, tr. P. Heath 1978, introduction and part 1 available online (Williams 1997: see esp. pp. 160-174, the first exposition of freedom as intersubjective, following Fichte’s hints in GNR)

+ Schelling, F.W.J. [1801] ‘Presentation of my system of philosophy’, tr. M. Vater, Philosophical Forum 31(4), 2001

Schelling, F.W.J. [1802] ‘Further presentations from the system of philosophy’, tr. M. Vater, Philosophical Forum 31(4), 2001 (co-authored by Hegel)

Schelling, F.W.J. [1809] Philosophical Investigations into the Nature of Human Freedom, tr. 2002; also as Of Human Freedom, tr. J. Gutmann 1936

Schelling, F.W.J. [1833-34] On the History of Modern Philosophy, tr. A. Bowie 1994 Feuerbach, L. [1839] ‘Towards a critique of Hegel’s philosophy’ in L.S. Stepelevich (ed.) The Young

Hegelians 1983, pp. 116-120, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 1, c. pp. 118-122 Heidegger [19?] Schelling’s Treatise on the Essence of Human Freedom, Ohio University Press, c. p. 163+ Cerf, W. (1977) ‘Speculative philosophy and intellectual intuition’, secs 1-3, in Harris and Cerf (eds.) The

Difference Between Fichte’s and Schelling’s System of Philosophy Marx, W. (1984) The Philosophy of F.W.J. Schelling: History, System, Freedom White, A. (1983) Schelling: An Introduction to the System of Freedom Bowie, A. (1990) Aesthetics and Subjectivity: from Kant to Nietzsche, 2nd ed. 2002, ch. on Schelling Bowie, A. (1993) Schelling and Modern European Philosophy: An Introduction Snow, D.E. (1996) Schelling and the End of Idealism Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, ch. 2 ‘Recognition in Fichte and Schelling’ (Better on

Schelling than Fichte) [1]+ Horstmann, R.-P. (2000) ‘The early philosophy of Fichte and Schelling’, in K. Ameriks (ed.) The Cambridge

Companion to German Idealism Beierwaltes W. (2002) ‘The legacy of Neoplatonism in F. W. J. Schelling’s thought’, International Journal of

Philosophical Studies 10(4) Lawrence, J.P. (2003) ‘Spinoza in Schelling: appropriation through critique’, Idealistic Studies 33(2-3) @ Schelling’s Philosophy of Nature Schelling, F.W.J. [1797] Ideas for a Philosophy of Nature, tr. E. Harris and P. Heath 1988 Schelling, F.W.J. [1799] First Outline of a System of the Philosophy of Nature, tr. K.R. Peterson 2004 Schelling, F.W.J. [1800] System of Transcendental Idealism, tr. P. Heath 1978, pp. 83-133 @ Schelling’s early systems and Hegel (See also ‘Schellingian critique of Hegel’) Nauen, F. G. (1971) Revolution, Idealism and Human Freedom: Schelling, Holderlin and Hegel and the Crisis of

Early German Idealism Seidel, G.J. (1976) Activity and Ground: Fichte, Schelling and Hegel Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, chs. 1-2 @ Hölderlin and Hegel@ Hoelderlin and Hegel Hölderlin, F., Friedrich Hölderlin. Essays and Letters on Theory, ed. T. Pfau, 1988 Henrich, D. [1965-66] ‘Hölderlin on judgment and being’, in his The Course of Remembrance and Other Essays on

Hölderlin, 1997 Henrich, D. [1967] ‘Hegel and Hölderlin’, in his The Course of Remembrance and Other Essays on Hölderlin,

1997 Henrich, D. (1970) ‘Some historical presuppositions of Hegel’s system’, in D.E. Christensen (ed.) Hegel and the

Philosophy of Religion:The Wofford Symposium Nauen, F. G. (1971) Revolution, Idealism and Human Freedom: Schelling, Holderlin and Hegel and the Crisis of

Early German Idealism Henrich, D. [1973] ‘The place of Hölderlin’s “Judgment and Being”‘, in his Between Kant and Hegel: Lectures

on German Idealism, 2003 Olson, A.M. (1982) ‘Renunciation and metaphysics: an examination of dialectic in Hölderlin and Hegel during

their Frankfurt period’, Man and World 15(2) Förster, E. (1995) ‘To lend wings to physics once again: Hölderlin and the Oldest System Programme of German

Idealism’, European Journal of Philosophy 3 Henrich, D. (1997) ‘Hölderlin in Jena’, in his The Course of Remembrance and Other Essays on Hölderlin @ DEVELOPMENT OF HEGEL’S THOUGHT

@ Biographies (intellectual) Rosenkranz, K. [1844] Georg Wilhem Friedrich Hegels Leben, reprinted 1969 Haym, R. [1852] Hegel und seine Zeit, reprinted 1962 Kaufmann, W. (1965) Hegel: Reinterpretation, Texts and Commentary Althaus, H. [1992] Hegel: An Intellectual Biography, tr. 2000 Pinkard, T. (2000) Hegel: A Biography @ Early development as a whole (Stuttgart, Tübingen, Berne, Frankfurt, Jena) Haering, T. (1929) Hegel, sein Wollen und sein Werk Hyppolite, J. [1948] Introduction to Hegel’s Philosophy of History, tr. 1996 Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel Asveld, P. (1953) La Pensée Religieuse du jeune Hegel* Harris, H.E. (1972) Hegel’s Development I: Towards the Sunlight (1770-1801) Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983* Harris, H.E. (1983) Hegel’s Development II: Night Thoughts (Jena 1801-1806) Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit, 1770-1807 Wylleman, A. (ed.) (1989) Hegel on the Ethical Life, Religion and Philosophy (1793-1807)+ Harris, H.S. (1993) ‘Hegel’s intellectual development to 1807’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion

to Hegel Crites, S. (1998) Dialectic and Gospel in the Development of Hegel’s Thinking @ Stuttgart and Tübingen writings (1777-93) Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel, ch. 1 Lacorte, C. (1959) Il Primo Hegel* Harris, H.E. (1972) Hegel’s Development I: Towards the Sunlight (1770-1801), chs. 1-2 Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983, ch. 1 Althaus, H. [1992] Hegel: An Intellectual Biography, tr. M. Tarsh 2000, ch. 2 Pinkard (2000) Hegel: A Biography, chs. 1-2 @ Berne and Frankfurt writings (1793-1800) Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel, chs. 2-8 Wahl, J. (1929) Le malheur de la conscience dans la philosophie de Hegel Kaufmann, W. (1954) ‘Hegel’s antitheological phase’, Philosophical Review 63 Kaufmann, W. (1960) ‘The young Hegel and religion’ in his The Owl and the Nightingale: From Shakespeare to

Existentialism, reprinted in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays Walsh, W.H. (1963) Metaphysics, ch. 9, reprinted in Inwood (ed.) Hegel Kaufmann, W. (1965) Hegel: Reinterpretation, Texts and Commentary, ch. 1* Harris, H.E. (1972) Hegel’s Development I: Towards the Sunlight (1770-1801), chs. 3-5 Young, W. (1972) Hegel’s Dialectical Method Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983, chs. 2-3 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 2 Schmidt, J. (1980-81) ‘Recent Hegel literature: general surveys and the young Hegel’, Telos 46, Winter 1980-81+ Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 3 Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit, 1770-180, introduction, chs. 1-4 Althaus, H. [1992] Hegel: An Intellectual Biography, tr. M. Tarsh 2000, chs. 2-4 Bondeli, M. (ed.) (1999) Hegels Denkenentwicklung in der Berner und Frankfurter Zeit+ Pinkard (2000) Hegel: A Biography, chs. 3-4 Adams, G.P. (1910) The Mystical Element in Hegel’s Early Theological Writings, reprinted 2005 @ Natural theology and the young Hegel (This is the attempt to establish the existence and properties of God and the essential doctrines of religion on the

basis of reason) (See also ‘Kant and Fichte’s theology and Hegel’) Rousseau, J.J. [1762] Emile, book 4 Reimarus [1774-77] Fragments (originally published as Fragmente des Wolfenbuttelschen ungenannten) Lessing, G.E. [1779] Nathan the Wise Lessing, G.E. [1780] The Education of the Human Race Herder [1787] God: Some Conversations

Pfleiderer, O. [18?] The Development of Theology in Germany since Kant @ Civil religion and the young Hegel Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit, 1770-1807, introduction Shanks, A. (1991) Hegel’s Political Theology @ Progressive theories of history and the young Hegel Löwith, K. (1949) Meaning in History Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit, 1770-180, chs. 1-2 @ Jena writings (1801-06): general (‘Jena systems’ refers to the logic and metaphysics of 1801-2 (largely lost), JS1 (1st Jena System, 1803-4:

philosophy of nature, spirit), JS2 (2nd Jena System, 1804-5: logic, metaphysics, philosophy of nature), JS3 (3rd Jena System, 1805-6: philosophy of nature, spirit))

Schmidt, J. (1981) ‘Recent Hegel literature: the Jena period and the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Telos 48 Harris, H.E. (1983) Hegel’s Development II: Night Thoughts (Jena 1801-1806) @ Jena writings: logic and metaphysics The Jena System 1804-5: Logic and Metaphysics (second Jena system) Hyppolite, J. [1938] ‘The concept of life and consciousness of life in Hegel’s Jena philosophy’, in his Studies in

Hegel and Marx, tr. 1969 Düsing, K. (1980) ‘Idealistische Substanzmetaphysik. Problem der Systementwicklung bei Schelling und Hegel in

Jena’, Hegel-Studien Beiheft 20: Hegel in Jena Harris, H.E. (1983) Hegel’s Development II: Night Thoughts (Jena 1801-1806), ch. 1 ‘The new logic and the old

metaphysics’ @ Jena writings: politics, ethics and religion (For the ‘Essay on natural law’ see ‘Essay on natural law’) (For recognition in these works see ‘Recognition in the Jena writings’) (For politics and ethics of the Phenomenology see ‘Moral and political stance of the Phenomenology’) Essay on Natural Law System of Ethical Life First Philosophy of Spirit (first Jena system) Hegel and the Human Spirit (third Jena system) Ilting, K.-H. (1963-64) ‘Hegels Auseinandersetzung mit der aristotelischen Politik’, Philosophisches Jahrbuch 71 Habermas, J. [1966] ‘On Hegel’s political writings’, in his Theory and Practice Kimmerle, H. (1970) Das Problem der Abgeschlossenheit des Denkens: Hegels System der Philosophie in den

Jahren 1800-1804 Riedel, M. [1967] ‘Criticism of natural law theory’, as ch. 3 of his Between Tradition and Revolution, tr. W.

Wright 1984 Horstmann, R.-P. (1972) ‘Probleme der Wandlung in Hegels Jenaer Systemkonzeption’, Philosophische

Rundschau 19 Harris, H.S. (1979) ‘Introduction to the System of Ethical Life’, in System of Ethical Life and First Philosophy of

Spirit, tr. H.S. Harris and T.M. Knox Kimmerle, H. (1980) ‘Hegel’s lectures on natural law’, in D.P. Verene (ed.) Hegel’s Social and Political Thought Rose, G. (1981) Hegel Contra Sociology* Harris, H.E. (1983) Hegel’s Development ll: Night Thoughts (Jena 1801-1806) Taminiaux, J. (1984) Naissance de la Philosophie Hégélienne de l’Etat: Commentaire et Traduction de la

Realphilosophie d’Iéna (1805-1806), Introduction (Paris: Payot) Bienenstock, M. (1985) ‘Hegel’s Jena writings; recent trends in research’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great

Britain 11 Gerard, G. (1986) ‘La fin du droit naturel Hegelien d’Iena selon les comptes rendus de Karl Rosenkranz et de

Rudolf Haym’, Revue Philosophique de Louvain 84:64 Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit, 1770-1807 Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, ch. 7 Bienenstock, M. (1992) Politique du Jeune Hegel: Iéna 1801-1806 @ Essay on Natural Law (1802-03) Essay on Natural Law

Riedel, M. [1967] ‘Criticism of natural law theory’, as ch. 3 of his Between Tradition and Revolution, tr. W. Wright 1984

Pinson, J.-C. (1988) ‘Hegel et l’empirisme dans l’ecrit sur le droit naturel de 1802-1803’, Archives de Philosophie 51

Cruysberghis, P. (1989) ‘Hegel’s critique of modern natural law’, in A. Wylleman (ed.) Hegel on the Ethical Life, Religion and Philosophy (1793-1807)

Bourgeois, B. (1986) Le droit naturel de Hegel (1802-03): Commentaire @ Natural law and Hegel (In his early and later political philosophy, and both classical natural law based on the idea of nature and modern

natural law based on the ideas of freedom, will and reason; for the former see also ‘Greek philosophy in general and Hegel’, for the latter see also ‘Freedom and free will as the basis of the Philosophy of Right ‘)

(For Essay on Natural Law see ‘Essay on Natural Law’) (For Aquinas, see ‘Aquinas and Hegel’) Bobbio, N. [1966] ‘Hegel e il giusnaturalismo’, Rivista di Filosofia 57, pp. 379-407, tr. into German as ‘Hegel

und die Naturrechtslehre’ in M. Riedel (ed.) Materialien zu Hegels Rechtsphilosophie vol. 1, 1974 Ilting, K.-H. (1971) ‘The structure of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, in Z. Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s Political

Philosophy Mitias, M.H. (1982) ‘Hegel’s conception of law’, Rivista Internazionale di Filosofia del Diritto 59 Burns, T. (1996) Natural Law and Political Ideology in the Philosophy of Hegel Fonnesu, L. and Henry, B. (eds.) (2000) Diritto naturale e filosofia classica tedesca @ Differenzschrift and Faith and Knowledge Wright, K. (1983) ‘The identity of identity and non-identity’, Idealistic Studies 13 @ RECOGNITION AND INTERSUBJECTIVITY (Recognition is ‘acknowledging someone as something’; intersubjectivity is the constitution of subjectivity or

selfhood, or of a certain sort of self, or of a certain self-conception, through relations between subjects) (Constitutive recognition recognition that gives rise to intersubjectivity – recognition that constitutes the

recognised as a self or a certain sort of self . For this see headings with that phrase in them) (For Hegel’s concept of spirit and the sociality of the self see respectively ‘Spirit’ and ‘Community and

individual, sociality of the self in Hegel’) (For recognition in Hegel’s work as a whole, and for Fichte-Hegel comparisons on recognition, see ‘Recognition

in the Jena writings’) (See also A social and political philosophy bibliography: ‘Recognition’) @ Recognition: the concept Cavell, S. (1976) ‘Knowing and acknowledging’, In Must We Mean What We Say: A Book of Essays Darwall, S.L. (1977) ‘Two kinds of respect’, Ethics 88(1)+ Inwood, M. (1992) A Hegel Dictionary, entry on recognition Brandom, R.B. (2007) ‘The structure of desire and recognition: self-consciousness and self-

constitution’, Philosophy and Social Criticism 33(1), reprinted in H. Ikäheimo and A. Laitinen (eds) Recognition and Social Ontology, 2011

Honneth, A. (2001) ‘Recognition I: Invisibility: on the epistemology of “recognition’”, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 75

Ikäheimo, H. (2002) ‘On the genus and species of recognition’, Inquiry 45(4)* Ikäheimo, H. and Laitinen, A. (2007) ‘Analysing recognition: identification, acknowledgement and recognitive

attitudes between persons’, in B. van den Brink and D. Owen (eds.) Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical Social Theory

@ Recognition and intersubjectivity: histories Theunissen, M. [1965] The Other: Studies in the Social Ontology of Husserl, Heidegger, Sartre and Buber, 2nd

German ed. 1977, trans. 1984 Buber, M. (1965) ‘The history of the dialogical principle’, in Between Man and Man Trilling, L. (1969) Sincerity and Authenticity Roth, M.S. (1988) Knowing and History: Appropriations of Hegel in Twentieth Century France Taylor, C. (1989) Sources of the Self Honneth, A. [1992] The Struggle for Recognition, tr. 1995 Crossley, N.B. (1996) Intersubjectivity Todorov, T. (2001) Life in Common. An Essay in General Anthropology

Ricoeur, P. (2005) The Course of Recognition, part 3 @ Recognition in Plato and Aristotle Plato, Phaedrus, esp. 255d Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 1166a31, 1170b6 Irwin, T.H. (1988) Aristotle’s First Principles, ch. 18 Karavakou, V. (2003) ‘Friendship and recognition in Aristotle and Hegel’, Philosophical Inquiry 25(3-4) @ Recognition in Fichte (See ‘Fichte on recognition and intersubjectivity’) @ Life and love in Frankfurt, Jena and the Phenomenology (See also ‘Life in Hegel’s mature system’) Hegel, ‘The Spirit of Christianity and its Fate’, ‘Love’ , and ‘Fragment of a System’ in Early Theological

Writings Hegel, ‘Two fragments of 1797 on love’, Clio 8(2), 1979 Hegel, Phenomenology of Spirit, §§169-172 Marcuse, H. [1932] Hegel’s Ontology and the Theory of Historicity, chs. 18-25 Hyppolite, J. [1936] ‘The concept of life and consciousness of life in Hegel’s Jena philosophy’, in his Studies in

Hegel and Marx, tr. 1969 Pöggeler, O. (1966) ‘Die Komposition des Phänomenologie des Geistes’, Hegel-Studien, Beiheft 3, reprinted in

Fulda and Henrich (eds.) Materialien zu Hegels Phänomenologie des Geistes 1973, pp. 329-390 Gadamer, H.-G. [1973] ‘Hegel’s dialectic of self-consciousness’, in Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Hermeneutical

Studies Harris, H.S. (1980) ‘The concept of recognition in Hegel’s Jena manuscripts’, Hegel-Studien, Beiheft 20,

reprinted in J. O’Neill (ed.) Hegel’s Dialectic of Desire and Recognition, 1996 Wright, K. (1983) ‘Hegel: The identity of identity and non-identity’, Idealistic Studies 13 Düsing, E. (1990) ‘Genesis des Selbstbewußtseins durch Anerkennung und Liebe: Untersuchungen zu Hegels

Theorie der konkreten Subjektivität’, in L. Eley (ed.) Hegels Theorie des Subjektiven Geistes Freiberger, E.D. (1997) The Genesis of Hegel’s Concept of Life: A Translation of the 1803 and 1805 Jena

Lectures on the Organic with an Historical Introduction and Commentary, dissertation, abstract available online

Ormiston A. (2004) Love and Politics: Re-Interpreting Hegel Sembou, E. (2006) ‘The young Hegel on ‘life’ and ‘love’’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 53-54 @ Love in Hegel’s mature writings Ikäheimo, H. (2010) ‘Making the best of what we are: recognition as an ontological and ethical concept’, in H.-C.

Schmidt am Busch and C. Zurn (eds) The Philosophy of Recognition: Historical and Critical Perspectives Ikäheimo, H. (2011) ‘Holism and normative essentialism in Hegel’s social ontology’, in H. Ikäheimo and A.

Laitinen (eds) Recognition and Social Ontology @ Recognition in Hegel’s work as a whole Williams, R.R. (1992) Recognition: Fichte and Hegel on the Other Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition Pippin, R. (2008) Hegel’s Practical Philosophy: Rational Agency as Ethical Life , ch. 7 ‘Hegelian sociality:

recognitive status’ Anderson, S.S.C. (2009) Hegel’s Theory of Recognition: From Oppression to Ethical Liberal Modernity Sorensen, A. (ed.) (2009) Dialectics, Self-Consciousness, and Recognition: The Hegelian Legacy @ Recognition in the Jena writings (1801-1806) (Including discussions of how Hegel absorbed Fichte’s practical philosophy, and specifically his conception of

mutual recognition, from SEL through to PhG) (For ethics and politics in general in the Jena works see ‘Jena writings (politics, ethics and religion)’) (For recognition specifically in Phenomenology see ‘Recognition and the master-servant relation in

the Phenomenology’) (For labour see ‘Labour in Hegel’) Hegel [1801] The Difference Between Fichte’s and Schelling’s System of Philosophy, tr. H.S. Harris and W. Cerf

1977, pp. 142-9 Hegel [1802] Natural Law, second part Hegel [1802] ‘System of Ethical Life’, in System of Ethical Life and First Philosophy of Spirit, pp. 110-152

Hegel [1803-04] First Jena System (= First Philosophy of Spirit), in System of Ethical Life and First Philosophy of Spirit section B ‘The negative’, pp. 235-244 (also section C ‘Real existence of the people’, pp. 242-250, on social division of labour and property)

Hegel [1805-06] Third Jena System, tr. as Hegel and the Human Spirit, pp. 110-120 (also pp. 120-127 on social division of labour, property and contract)

Hegel [1820s] Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Haladane and Simson, vol. 3 pp. 503-4* Habermas, J. [1967] ‘Labour and interaction: remarks on Hegel’s Jena Philosophy of Mind’, in his Theory and

Practice, tr. J. Viertel 1973 Theunissen, M. (1973) ‘Die Verwirklichung der Vernunft. zur Theorie-Praxis Diskussion im Anschluss an

Hegel’, Philosophische Rundschau Beiheft 6 Siep, L. [1974] ‘The struggle for recognition. Hegel’s dispute with Hobbes in the Jena writings’, in J.

O’Neill , Hegel’s Dialectic of Desire and Recognition: Texts and Commentary, 1996 Siep, L. (1979) Anerkennung als Prinzip der Praktischen Philosophie: Untersuchungen zu Hegels Jenaer

Philosophie des Geistes Harris, H.S. (1980) ‘The concept of recognition in Hegel’s Jena manuscripts’, Hegel-Studien, Beiheft 20,

reprinted in J. O’Neill (ed.) Hegel’s Dialectic of Desire and Recognition, 1996 Wildt, A. (1982) Autonomie und Anerkennung: Hegels Moralitätskritik im Lichte seiner Fichte-

Rezeption [Autonomy and Recognition: Hegel’s Critique of Morality in the Light of his Reception of Fichte] Mercier-Josa, S. (1982) ‘Combat pour la reconnaissance et criminalité’, in D. Henrich and R.-P. Horstmann

(eds.) Hegels Philosophie des Rechts Habermas, J. [1985] The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, tr. 1990, lecture 2 Düsing, E. (1986) Intersubjektivität und Selbstbewusstsein: behavioristische, phänomenologische und idealitische

Begrundungstheorien bei Mead, Schutz, Fichte und Hegel Jurist, E.L. (1987) ‘Hegel’s concept of recognition’, The Owl of Minerva 19(1) Siep, L. (1992) ‘Der Freheitsbegriff der praktischen Philosophie Hegels in Jena’, in Siep’s Praktische Philosophie

im Deutschen Idealismus Honneth, A. (1992) ‘Moral development and social struggle: Hegel’s early social doctrines’, in A. Honneth et al.

(eds.) Cultural-Political Interventions in the Unfinished Project of Enlightenment Williams, R.R. (1992) Recognition: Fichte and Hegel on the Other, ch. 4 ‘The early Hegel and Fichte’* Honneth, A. [1992] The Struggle for Recognition, trans. 1995, chs. 1-3 Beck, G. (1996) ‘From Kant to Hegel: Johann Gottlieb Fichte’s theory of self-consciousness’, History of

European Ideas 22(4) Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, ch. 5 ‘Recognition and right in the Jena manuscripts’ Fischbach, F. (1999) Fichte et Hegel: la reconnaissance Decker, K. (2001) ‘Right and recognition: criminal action and intersubjectivity in Hegel’s early ethics’, History of

Political Thought 22(2) Redding, P. (2005) ‘Fichte’s role in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, Chapter 4’ (paper to APA, Pacific

Division, Annual Conference, San Francisco, March 25, 2005) , available online Clarke, J. (2009) ‘Fichte and Hegel on recognition’, British Journal for the History of Philosophy 17(2) Testa, I. (2012, forthcoming) ‘How does recognition emerge from nature? The genesis of consciousness in

Hegel’s Jena writings’, Critical Horizons @ Recognition in the Phenomenology, master-servant relation (Including the section ‘Evil and forgiveness’) (See also ‘Slavery in Hegel’, and ‘Labour in Hegel’) (See also ‘Recognition in the Philosophy of Spirit (= Philosophy of Mind)’) (For relation to Aristotle see ‘Aristotle and Hegel: political philosophies and slavery’) Kojève, A. [1947] Introduction to the Reading of Hegel ‘In place of an introduction’ Hyppolite, J. [19?] ‘Le phénomène de la “reconnaissance universelle” dans l’expérience humaine’, in his Figures

de la pensée philosophique, 1991 Kelly, G.A. (1966) ‘Notes on Hegel’s “Lordship and bondage”‘, Review of Metaphysics 19, reprinted in

MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays, in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3, and in Stewart (ed.)The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader

Soll, I. (1969) An Introduction to Hegel’s Metaphysics, ch. 1* Gadamer, H.-G. [1973] ‘Hegel’s dialectic of self-consciousness’, in Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Hermeneutical

Studies+ Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 5 sec. 1 Siep, L. (1992) ‘Zur Dialektik der Anerkennung bei Hegel’, in his Praktische Philosophie im Deutschen

Idealismus Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 3

Preuss, P. (1982) ‘Selfhood and battle: the second beginning of the Phenomenology’ in M. Westphal (ed.) Method and Speculation in Hegel’s Phenomenology

+ Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 8 Flay, J. (1984) Hegel’s Quest for Certainty, ch. 4 and notes pp. 331-341 Neuhouser, F. (1986) ‘Deducing desire and recognition in the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 24(2) Jarczyk, G. and Labarrière, P.-J. (1987) Les premiers combats de la reconnaisance. Maitrîse et servitude dans

la Phénomenologie de l’esprit de Hegel Gunn, R. (1988) ‘“Recognition” in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, Common Sense 4 Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, ch. 7+ Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, ch. 4 Williams, R.R. (1992) Recognition: Fichte and Hegel on the Other, chs. 7-8 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 3 Duquette, D. (1994) ‘The political significance of Hegel’s concept of recognition in the Phenomenology’, Bulletin

of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 29 Osborne, P. (1995) The Politics of Time, ch. 3 O’Neill, J. (ed.) (1996) Hegel’s Dialectic of Desire and Recognition: Texts and Commentary Kain, P.J. (1998) ‘Self-consciousness, the other and Hegel’s dialectic of recognition’, Philosophy and Social

Criticism Siep, L. (1998) ‘Die Bewegung des Anerkennens in der Phänomenologie des Geistes’, in D. Köhler and O.

Pöggeler (eds.) G.W.F. Hegel: Phänomenologie des Geistes, Klassiker Auslegen, 2nd ed. 2006 Rauch, L. and Sherman, D. (1999) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Self-Consciousness: Text and Commentary, part 2 Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, ch. 3 ‘Recognition in the Phenomenology’ Sembou, E. (2003) ‘Hegel’s idea of a struggle for recognition: the Phenomenology of Spirit’, History of Political

Thought 24(2) Williams, R.R. (2003) ‘The concept of recognition in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’ in A. Denker and M.

Vater (eds.) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: New Critical Essays* Houlgate, S. (2003) ‘G. W. F. Hegel: The Phenomenology of Spirit’, in R. Solomon and D. Sherman (eds.) The

Blackwell Guide to Continental Philosophy, available online Pippin, R. (2004) ‘Recognition and reconciliation: actualized agency in Hegel’s Phenomenology, in K. Ameriks

and J. Stolzenberg (eds.) Internationales Jahrbuch des Deutschen Idealismus, vol. 2, reprinted in K. Deligiorgi (ed.) Hegel: New Directions, 2006, also in B. van den Brink and D. Owen (eds.) Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical Social Theory, 2007

Burke, V. (2005) ‘Hegel’s concept of mutual recognition: the limits of self-determination’, The Philosophical Forum 36(2)

Beiser, F. (2005) Hegel, ch. 8 ‘Solipsism and intersubjectivity’ Brandom, R.B. (2007) ‘The structure of desire and recognition: self-consciousness and self-

constitution’, Philosophy and Social Criticism 33(1), reprinted in H. Ikäheimo and A. Laitinen (eds) Recognition and Social Ontology, 2011

Neuhouser, F. (2009) ‘Desire, recognition, and the relation between bondsman and lord’, in K. Westphal (ed.) The Blackwell Guide to Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit

Houlgate, S. (2009) ‘Why does the development of self-consciousness in Hegel’s Phenomenology make recognition necessary?’, Archivio di Filosofia 77(2-3)

* Quante, M. (2010) ‘“The pure notion of recognition”: reflections on the grammar of the relation of recognition in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, in H.-C. Schmidt am Busch, H.-C. and C. Zurn (eds) The Philosophy of Recognition: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives

Stern, R. (2012, forthcoming) ‘Is Hegel’s master-slave dialectic a refutation of solipsism?’, British Journal of the Histgory of Philosophy

@ Recognition in the Philosophy of Spirit (= Philosophy of Mind), universal self-consciousness (For comparisons with the earlier writings see ‘Recognition in Hegel’s work as a whole’) Philosophy of Spirit §§424-439 (in Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind, or in Philosophy of Subjective Spirit or The

Berlin Phenomenology with accompanying lecture notes) Chitty, A. (1996) ‘On Hegel, the subject and political justification’, sections 2-4, Res Publica 2(2) Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, ch. 4 ‘Recognition in the Encyclopedia Philosophy of Spirit Chitty, A. (1998) ‘Recognition and social relations of production’, section 3, Historical Materialism 2 Ikäheimo, H. (2000) Self-Consciousness and Intersubjectivity: A Study on Hegel’s Encyclopedia Philosophy of

Subjective Spirit (1830), also available online Ikäheimo, H. (2004) ‘On the Role of Intersubjectivity in Hegel’s Encyclopaedic Phenomenology and

Psychology’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain, 49/50, pp. 73-95

@ Recognition in the Philosophy of Right (For recognition as a particular being in the Philosophy of Right see ‘Social role and sense of self (Selbstgefühl) in

Hegel’) (For other specific areas see ‘Recognition in abstract right’, ‘Freedom as social, freedom and recognition’) (For Honneth’s view see ‘Honneth on Hegel’) Theunissen, M. [1982] ‘The repressed intersubjectivity in Hegel’s philosophy of right’, in D. Cornell et al.

(eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory 1991 Tunick, M. (1992) Hegel’s Political Philosophy: Reinterpreting the Practice of Legal Punishment Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, part 2 ‘Recognition in the Philosophy of Right’ Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Theory of Freedom, chs. 4-6* Patten, A. (2001) ‘Social contract theory and the politics of recognition in Hegel’s political philosophy’, in

R.R. Williams (ed.) Beyond Liberalism and Communitarianism: Studies in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right* Pippin, R. (2008) Hegel’s Practical Philosophy: Rational Agency as Ethical Life Moyar, D. (2011) Hegel’s Conscience, ch. 5 ‘Mutual recognition’ @ Recognition in the Logic (See also ‘Metaphysics of Hegel: social-Kantian interpretations’) (See also ‘Concept and universal in Hegel, identity and difference’) Westphal, M. (1980) ‘Hegel’s theory of the concept’, in W.E. Steinkraus and K.I. Schmidt (eds.) Art and Logic in

Hegel’s Philosophy, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Hösle, V. (1987) Hegels System. Der Idealismus der Subjectivität und das Problem der Intersubjectivität [Hegel’s

System: The Idealism of Subjectivity and the Problem of Intersubjectivity], 2 vols @ Slavery in Hegel (see also ‘Aristotle and Hegel: political philosophy’) Philosophy of Right §§ 21R, 57, 66-7 Philosophy of Spirit §§ 433A, 482 ‘Hegel and American Slavery’ (1989) Special issue of Cardozo Law Review 10(5-6) Davis, D.B. (1975) The Problem of Slavery in the Age of Revolution, epilogue Patterson, O. (1982) Slavery and Social Death Smith, S.S. (1992) ‘Hegel on slavery and domination’, Review of Metaphysics 46 Bull, M. (1998) ‘Slavery and the multiple self’, New Left Review 231 Buck-Morss, S. (2000) ‘Hegel and Haiti’, Critical Inquiry 26(4) @ Recognition and selfhood in Hegel (Recognition by others as a necessary condition of self-consciousness or subjectivity) (See ‘Self-consciousness in the Phenomenology’) @ Recognition and freedom in Hegel (See ‘Freedom as social, freedom and recognition’) @ Marx on recognition (See A Marx bibliography: ‘Recognition in Marx’) @ Kojève (on recognition and in general) (See also ‘End of history’) Kojève, A. [1946] ‘Hegel, Marx and Christianity’, Interpretation: A Journal of Political Philosophy 1¸1970 Kojève, A. [1947] Introduction to the Reading of Hegel, tr. J.H. Nichols 1969, esp. pp. 88-99 Kojève, A. and Strauss, L. (1991) On Tyranny, expanded edition Poster, M. (1975) Existential Marxism in Postwar France Descombes, V. [1979] Modern French Philosophy, ch. 1 Riley, P. (1981) ‘Introduction to the reading of Alexandre Kojève’, Political Theory 9(1) Goldford, D.J. (1982) ‘Kojève’s reading of Hegel’, International Philosophical Quarterly 22 Roth, M.S. (1983) ‘A note on Kojève’s phenomenology of right’, Political Theory 11(3) Roth, M.S. (1985) ‘A problem of recognition: Alexandre Kojève and the end of history’, History and Theory 24 Butler, J. (1987) Subjects of Desire: Hegelian Reflections in 20th Century France, ch. 1 and c. pp. 63-87 Roth, M.S. (1988) Knowing and History: Appropriations of Hegel in Twentieth Century France, ch. 5 Lynch, R.A. (2001) Mutual recognition and the dialectic of master and slave: reading Hegel against

Kojève’, International Philosophical Quarterly 41(1)

@ Merleau-Ponty on recognition Merleau-Ponty [1946] ‘Hegel’s Existentialism’, in his Sense and Non-Sense, tr. 1992 Schmidt, J. (1979) ‘Lordship and bondage in Merleau-Ponty and Sartre’, Political Theory 7(2) @ Sartre on recognition (See also ‘Sartre and Hegel’) Sartre [1943] Being and Nothingness, tr. H.E. Barnes 1956, pt. 3 ch. 1 sec. 4 ‘The Look’ (pp. 252-302) (cf. the

preceding commentary on Hegel, pp. 233-252), pt. 3 ch. 3 ‘Concrete Relations with Others’ (pp. 361-433), pt. 4 ch. 2 sec. 3 ‘Quality as a Revelation of Being’ (pp. 600-615)

Sartre [1946] Anti-Semite and Jew Sartre [1946] Existentialism and Humanism Sartre [1947-48] Notebooks for an Ethics, tr. 1992, pp. 10-60, 470-560 Sartre [1961] Introduction to F. Fanon Wretched of the Earth Greene, N. (1960) Jean-Paul Sartre: The Existentialist Ethic+ Warnock, M. (1967) Existentialist Ethics ch. 4 Theunissen, M. [1965] The Other: Studies in the Social Ontology of Husserl, Heidegger, Sartre and Buber, 2nd

German (ed.) 1977, trans. 1984, ch. 6 Barnes, H. (1967) An Existentialist Ethics Schmidt, J. (1979) ‘Lordship and bondage in Merleau-Ponty and Sartre’, Political Theory 7(2) Anderson, T.C. (1979) The Foundation and Structure of Sartrean Ethics Jeanson, F. (1980) Sartre and the Problem of Morality Butler, J. (1987) Subjects of Desire: Hegelian Reflections in 20th Century France, ch. 2 Honneth, A. [1992] The Struggle for Recognition, trans. 1995, ch. 7, section on Sartre Anderson, T.C. (1993) Sartre’s Two Ethics Catalano, J.S. (1996) Good Faith and Other Essays: Perspectives on a Sartrean Ethics Gardner, S. (2005) ‘Sartre, intersubjectivity, and German Idealism’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 43 (3) @ Heidegger on intersubjectivy, recognition and Mitsein (See also ‘Heidegger and Hegel’) Gadamer, H.G. [1975] ‘Subject and intersubjectivity, subject and person’, Continental Philosophy Review 33(3),

2000 Dallmayr, F.R. (1980) ‘Heidegger on intersubjectivity’, Human Studies 3 Mazis, G.A. (1985) ‘Co-being [Mitsein] and meaningful interpersonal relationship in Being And Time’, Journal of

the British Society For Phenomenology 16(3) Williams, R.R. (1989) ‘Hegel and Heidegger’, in W. Desmond (ed.) Hegel and his Critics Olafson, F.A. (1998) Heidegger and the Ground of Ethics: A Study of Mitsein Salem-Wiseman, J. (2003) ‘Heidegger’s Dasein and the liberal conception of the self’, Political Theory 31(4) Lewis, M. (2005) Heidegger and the Place of Ethics: Being-With in the Crossing of Heidegger’s Thought [1] @ Althusser on recognition (See A Marx bibliography: ‘Althusser: on ideology, recognition and selfhood, interpellation’) @ Habermas on recognition (See also ‘Recognition in the Jena writings’) Baynes, K. (2002) ‘Freedom and recognition in Hegel and Habermas’, Philosophy & Social Criticism 28(1) @ Honneth on Hegel Honneth, A. [1992] The Struggle for Recognition, tr. 1995, chs. 2-3 Honneth, A. (2000) Suffering from Indeterminacy: An Attempt at a Reactualisation of Hegel’s Philosophy of

Right Honneth, A. [2001] The Pathologies of Individual Freedom: Hegel’s Social Theory, tr. 2010 Honneth, A. [2006] ‘Das Reich der verwirklichten Freiheit. Hegels Idee einer Rechtsphilosophie’,

in Honneth, Das Ich im Wir, 2010 Honneth, A. (2008) ‘From desire to recognition: Hegel’s account of human sociality’, in D. Moyar and M. Quante

(eds) (2008) Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’: A Critical Guide Honneth, A. (2009) ‘Justice as institutionalized freedom: A Hegelian perspective’, A. Sorenson (ed.) Dialectics,

Self-Consciousness, and Recognition: The Hegelian Legacy Honneth, A. (2011) Das Recht der Freiheit

@ Fukuyama (on recognition and on end of history) Fukuyama, F. (1989) ‘The end of history?’, The National Interest 16, Summer 1989 Hirst, P. (1989) ‘Endism’, London Review of Books 11(22), 23 November 1989 Roth, M.S. (1991) ‘Natural right and the end of history: Leo Strauss and Alexandre Kojève’, Revue de

Metaphysique et de Morale 3 Redding, P. (1991) ‘Hermeneutic or metaphysical Hegelianism? Kojève’s dilemma’, The Owl of Minerva 22(2) Fukuyama, F. (1992) The End of History and the Last Man Anderson, P. (1992) ‘The ends of history’ in his A Zone of Engagement Miliband, R (1992) ‘Fukuyama and the socialist alternative’, New Left Review 192 Bertram, C. and Chitty, A. (eds.) (1994) Has History Ended?: Fukuyama, Marx, Modernity Burns, T. (ed.) (1994) After History? Francis Fukuyama and his Critics, esp. essay by Susan Shell Williams, H., Sullivan, D. and Matthews, G. (eds) (1997) Francis Fukuyama and the End of History O’Neill, J. (1997) ‘Hegel against Fukuyama: associations, markets and recognition’, Politics 17(3) Anderson, P. (2006) ‘Inside man’, The Nation Elliott, G. (2008) Ends in Sight: Marx, Fukuyama, Hobsbawm, Anderson @ Nancy on intersubjectivity and recognition (And more generally on ‘community’) (See also ‘Nancy and Hegel’)* Nancy, J.-L. [1983] The Inoperative Community, tr. P. Connor et al 1991, ch. 1 Nancy, J.-L. [1988] The Experience of Freedom, tr. B. McDonald 1993 Nancy, LJ.-L. (1991) ‘“La comparution”/the compearance: from the existence of “communism” to the community

of “existence”‘ 20(3)* Nancy, J.-L. [1996] ‘Being Singular Plural’ in Being Singular Plural, tr. R. Richardson and A. O’Byrne 2000 Nancy, J.-L. (1993) The Birth to Presence Bernasconi R., ‘On deconstructing nostalgia for community within the West: the debate between Nancy and

Blanchot’, Research in Phenomenology 23 Ingram, D. (1988) ‘The retreat of the political in the modern age: Jean-Luc Nancy on totalitarianism and

community’, Research in Phenomenology 18 Devisch I. (2000) ‘A trembling voice in the desert: Jean-Luc Nancy’s re-thinking of the space of the

political’, Cultural Values 4(2) Norris, A. (2000) ‘Jean-Luc Nancy and the myth of the common’, Constellations 7(2) George, T.D. (2003) ‘The myth of the West interrupted: community and cultural difference in Nancy’s “literary

communism”‘, International Studies in Philosophy 35(1) Rehberg, A. (2004) ‘Exposures: Nancy and Heidegger on community’, Journal of the British Society for

Phenomenology 35(3) @ Recognition in other 20th century writers Weber, M. [19?] ‘Classes, status groups and power’ in W.G. Runciman (ed.) Weber: Selections in Translation,

1978 Bakhtin, M.M. [19?] Problems of Dostoyevsky’s Poetics Sorel, G. (19?) ‘The ethics of socialism’, in J.L. Stanley (ed.) From Georges Sorel: Essays in Socialism and

Philosophy Buber, M. [1928] I and Thou Ricoeur, P. [19?] Oneself as Another, tr. 1992 Mead, G.H. (1934) Mind, Self and Society Mead, G.H. (1964) Selected Writings (ed.) A.J. Reck Frie, R. (1977) Subjectivity and Intersubjectivity in Modern Philosophy and Psychoanalysis Frank, M. (1991) ‘Wider den apriorischen Intersubjektivismus: Gegenvorschläge aus Sartrescher Inspiration’, in

his Selbsbewußtsein und Selbsterkenntnis: Essays zur analytischen Philosophie der Subjektivität Dews, P. (1995) ‘Modernity, self-consciousness and the scope of philosophy’, in his The Limits of

Disenchantment: Essays on Contemporary European Philosophy @ Recognition and work Recognition and Work, conference at MacQuarrie University, 2007 (audio links) @ Recognition and colonialism, Fanon Sartre, J.-P. [1946] Anti-Semite and Jew (original title: Réflexions sur la question juive) Fanon, F. [1961] The Wretched of the Earth, with introduction by Sartre Fanon, F. [1952] Black Skin, White Masks

Turner, L. (1996) ‘On the difference between the Hegelian and Fanonian dialectic of lordship and bondage’, in L.R. Gordon et al. (eds.) Fanon: A Critical Reader

Liberman, K. (1999) ‘The dialectics of oppression: a phenomenological perspective’, Philosophy Today 43(3) Gibson, N. (2002) ‘Dialectical impasses: turning the table on Hegel and the black’, Parallax 8(2), 30-45 Chari, A. (2003) ‘The limits of recognition: Fanon and Hegel’, available online Oliver, K. (2003) ‘Alienation and its double; or, the secretion of race’ in R. Bernasconi (ed.) Race and Racism in

Continental Philosophy Chari, A. (2004) ‘Exceeding recognition’, Sartre Studies International 10(2) @ Colonialism, racism and Hegel McCarney, J. (2003) ‘Hegel’s racism? a response to Bernasconi’, Radical Philosophy 119 @ Recognition and feminism (See also ‘Feminism and Hegel’) (For de Beauvoir see ‘De Beauvoir and Hegel’) Benhabib, S. (1992) Situating the Self: Gender, Community and Postmodernism in Contemporary Ethics Meehan, J. (ed.) (1995) Feminists Read Habermas Fraser, N. (1995) ‘From redistribution to recognition? Dilemmas of justice in a “post-socialist” age’, secs. 1

and 2, New Left Review 212 Dean, J. (1996) Solidarity of Strangers: Feminism after Identity Politics Fraser, N. (2001) ‘Recognition without ethics?’, Theory Culture and Society 18(2-3) Yar, M. (2002) ‘Beyond Nancy Fraser’s “perspectival dualism’, Economy and Society 30(3) Gauthier, J.A. (2006) Hegel and Feminist Social Criticism: Justice, Recognition and the Feminine @ Recognition in international relations Williams, R.R. (2000) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, ch. 14 Kochi, T. (2009) The Other’s War: Recognition and the Violence of Ethics @ Honour vs. dignity Berger, P. (1983) ‘On the obsolescence of the concept of honour’, in S. Hauerwas and A. MacIntyre

(eds.) Revisions: Changing Perspectives in Moral Philosophy @ Kohlberg, Mead and Dewey on recognition Kohlberg (1969) ‘Stage and sequence: the cognitive-developmental approach to socialisation’, in D.A. Goslin

(ed.) The Handbook of Socialisation Theory and Research, pp. 347-380 Joas, H. (1998?) Die Entstehung der Werte (last chapter is on Dewey and Mead vs. Habermas on the recognitive

foundations of morality) @ Strawson on recognition Strawson, P. (1959) Individuals, ch. 3 ‘Persons’ Strawson, P.F. (1962) ‘Freedom and resentment’ Proceedings of the British Academy 48, reprinted in Freedom

and Resentment and Other Essays, also in G. Watson (ed.) Free Will, and as a pamphlet Strauss, M. (2003) ‘The role of recognition in the formation of self-understanding’, in R.N. Fiore and H.L. Nelson

(eds.) Recognition, Responsibility, and Rights @ Honneth’s theory of recognition (For Honneth and Marx see A Marx bibliography: ‘Recognition in Marx’) (For Honneth on Hegel see A Hegel bibliography: ‘Honneth on Hegel’) Honneth, A. (1979) ‘Communication and reconciliation: Habermas’s critique of Adorno’, Telos 39 Honneth, A. [1980] ‘Work and instrumental action: on the normative basis of critical theory’, New German

Critique 26, 1982, reprinted in C. Wright (ed.) The Fragmented World of the Social: Essays in Social and Political Philosophy1994

Honneth, A. (19?) ‘Diskursethik und implizites Gerechtigkeitskonzept’, ? Honneth, A. and Joas, H. [1980] Social Action and Human Nature, tr. 1988 Honneth, A. [198?] The Critique of Power: Reflective Stages in a Critical Social Theory, tr. 1990 Honneth, A. (1990) Die zerrissene Welt des Sozialen Honneth, A. (1990) ‘Morale Bewußtsein und Klassenherrschaft’ (?), in Die zerrissene Welt des Sozialen Honneth, A. [1990] ‘Integrity and disrespect: principles of a conception of morality based on the theory of

recognition’, Political Theory 20(2), 1992; reprinted in C. Wright (ed.) The Fragmented World of the Social:

Essays in Social and Political Philosophy, 1994 (Overview of the theory developed in The Struggle for Recognition)

Honneth, A. (1992) ‘Moral development and social struggle: Hegel’s early social doctrines’, in A. Honneth et al. (eds.) Cultural-Political Interventions in the Unfinished Project of Enlightenment

* Honneth, A. [1992] The Struggle for Recognition, tr. 1995 Honneth, A. (1994) ‘The social dynamics of disrespect: on the location of critical theory today’, Constellations 1,

255-269 Honneth, A. (1994) ‘Introduction’ to Honneth (ed.) Pathologien des Sozialen Honneth, A. (1995) ‘The other of justice: Habermas and the ethical challenge of postmodernism’, in White, S.K.

(ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Habermas Alexander, J. and Pia Lara, M. (1996) ‘Honneth’s new critical theory of of recognition’, New Left Review 220 Honneth, A. (1997) ‘Anerkennung und moralische Verpflichtung’, Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung 51+ Honneth, A. and Critchley, S. (1998) ‘Philosophy in Germany’, Radical Philosophy 89+ Foster, R. (1999) ‘Recognition and resistance: Axel Honneth’s critical social theory’, Radical Philosophy 94 Honneth, A. (2000) ‘The possibility of a disclosing critique of society: The Dialectic of Englightenment in the

light of current debates in social criticism’, Constellations 7(1) Honneth, A. (2001), ‘Invisibility: On the epistemology of ‘recognition”, Aristotelian Society Supplementary

Volume 75(1) Honneth A. et al (2002) ‘Symposium on Honneth’s theory of recognition’, Inquiry 45(4) Heidegren, C.-G. (2002) ‘Anthropology, social theory and politics: Axel Honneth’s theory of

recognition’, Inquiry 45(4) Honneth, A. (2002) ‘Grounding recognition: a rejoinder to critical questions’, Inquiry 45(4) Kauppinen, A. (2002) ‘Reason, recognition and internal critique’, Inquiry 45(4) Honneth, A. (2002): ‘The role of sociology in the theory of recognition’, Interview by A. Petersen and R.

Willig, European Journal of Social Theory 5(2)* Fraser, N. and Honneth, A. (2003) Redistribution or Recognition? A Political-Philosophical Exchange Honneth, A. (2003) Anxiety and Politics Honneth, A. (2004) ‘Recognition and justice: outline of a plural theory of justice’, Acta Sociologica 47(4) Markell, P. (2003) Bound by Recognition Honneth, A. (2006) ‘Reification: a recognition-theoretical view’, The Tanner Lectures on Human

Values, also available online Thompson, S. (2006) The Political Theory of Recognition: A Critical Introduction Deranty, J.-P. and Renault, E. (2007) ‘Politicizing Honneth’s ethics of recognition’, Thesis Eleven 88(1) Honneth, A. (2007) ‘Work and recognition, a redefinition’, conference paper (audio link) Honneth, A. (2007) Disrespect: The Normative Foundations of Critical Theory van den Brink, B. and Owen, D. (eds.) (2007) Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical

Social Theory Deranty, J.-P. (2009) Beyond Communication: A Critical Study of Axel Honneth’s Social Philosophy @ Politics of recognition, recognition of identities (Including the relation between recognition and multiculturalism) Adorno, T. [19?] ‘Society’, in F. Jameson et al. (eds) Critical Theory and Society Althusser, L. [1968] ‘Ideology and the ideological state apparatuses’, in Lenin and Philosophy, and Other

Essays Siep, L. (1979) Anerkennung als Prinzip der Praktischen Philosophie: Untersuchungen zu Hegels Jenaer

Philosophie des Geistes, last part Gutmann, A. (ed.) (1992) Multiculturalism and the ‘Politics of Recognition, enlarged edition

as Multiculturalism: Examining the Politics of Recognition, 1994* Taylor, C. (1992) ‘The politics of recognition’ in A. Gutmann (ed.) Multiculturalism and the ‘Politics of

Recognition Taylor, C. (1992) ‘The need for recognition’, in his The Ethics of Authenticity Cornell, D. (1993) Transformations: Recollective Imagination and Sexual Difference Brown, W. (1995) States of Injury: Power and Freedom in Late Modernity, chs. 2-3 Butler, J. (1997) Excitable Speech Butler, J. (1997) ‘Merely cultural’, Social Text 52-53, reprinted in New Left Review 227, 1998 Düttmann, A.G. [1997] Between Cultures: Tensions in the Struggle for Recognition, tr. 2000 Wynne, E. (2000) ‘Reflections on recognition: a matter of self-realization or a matter of justice?’, in Thinking

Fundamentals, IWM Junior Visiting Fellows Conferences, Vol. 9: Vienna 2000, available online Yar, M. (2001) Recognition and the politics of human(e) desire, Theory, Culture and Society, 18 (2-3)

Markell, P. (2003) Bound by Recognition Lazzeri, C. and Christian, A. (2006) ‘Recognition today: the theoretical, ethical and political stakes of the

concept’, Critical Horizons 7(1) McNay, L. (2008) Against Recognition @ Recognition and redistribution (Honneth-Fraser debate)* Fraser, N. (1995) ‘From redistribution to recognition? dilemmas of justice in a “post-socialist” age’, New Left

Review 212* Fraser, N. (1997) Justice Interruptus: Critical Reflections on the ‘Post-Socialist’ Condition Tully, J. (2000) ‘Struggles over recognition and distribution’, Constellations 7(4) Fraser, N. (2000) ‘Rethinking recognition’, New Left Review II/3 Fraser, N. (2001) ‘Recognition without ethics?’, Theory Culture and Society 18(2-3) Yar, M. (2001) ‘Beyond Nancy Fraser’s “perspectival dualism’, Economy and Society 30(3)* Fraser, N. and Honneth, A. (2003) Redistribution or Recognition? A Political-Philosophical Exchange Zurn, C.F. (2003) ‘Identity or status? Struggles over recognition in Fraser, Honneth and

Taylor’, Constellations 10(4) Thompson, S. (2005) ‘Is redistribution a form of recognition? Comments on the Fraser-Honneth

debate’, Critical Review of International Social and Political Philosophy 8(1) @ Recognition, work and class (See also see A Marx bibliography: ‘Recognition and Marx’)) Honneth, A. [1980] ‘Work and instrumental action: on the normative basis of critical theory’, New German

Critique 26, 1982, reprinted in C. Wright (ed.) The Fragmented World of the Social: Essays in Social and Political Philosophy 1994

Deranty, J.-P. (2006) ‘Repressed materiality: retrieving the materialism in Axel Honneth’s theory of recognition’, Critical Horizons 7(1)

Honneth, A. (2007) ‘Work and recognition, a redefinition’, conference paper (audio link) Honneth, A. (2007) Disrespect: The Normative Foundations of Critical Theory Smith, N.H. (2009) ‘Work and the struggle for recognition’, European Journal of Political Theory 8(1) Deranty, J.-P. and Smith, N. (2010) Applying the Ethics of Recognition: Work and the Social Bond @ Self-esteem, self-respect, dignity (For Rawls and self-respect see that) Kant, Lectures on Ethics, tr. Infield, 120-127 Sachs, D. (1981) ‘How to distinguish self-respect from self-esteem’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 10(4) Bay, ? (1982) ‘Self-respect as a human right: thoughts on the dialectic of wants and needs in the struggle for

human community’, Human Rights Quarterly 4, 53-75 Hill, T.E. Jr. (1991) ‘Servility and self-respect’, in Autonomy and Self-Respect Honneth, A. [1990] ‘Integrity and disrespect: principles of a conception of morality based on the theory of

recognition’, Political Theory 20(2), reprinted in C. Wright (ed.) The Fragmented World of the Social: Essays in Social and Political Philosophy, 1994; originally published as ‘Integrität und Mißachtung’, Merkur 44

Bertram, C. and Chitty, A. (eds) (1994) Has History Ended?, essays by McCarney, Bertram Margalit, A. [19?] The Decent Society Raz, J. (1994) ‘Duties of wellbeing’ in his Ethics in the Public Domain @ Recognition as ontological (Recognition by others as constituting individuals as self-conscious or subjects or person) (For recognition as making individuals free in Hegel see ‘Freedom and recognition in Hegel’) (See also ‘Brandom on Hegel’, ‘Pippin on Hegel’s social philosophy’) Baynes, K. (2001) ‘Practical reason, the “space of reason”, and public reason’, in J. Bohman and W. Rehg

(eds) Pluralism and the Pragmatic Turn Strauss, M. (2003) ‘The role of recognition in the formation of self-understanding’, in R.N. Fiore and H.L. Nelson

(eds.) Recognition, Responsibility, and Rights Winfield, R.D. (2006) ‘Self-Consciousness and intersubjectivity’, Review of Metaphysics 59(4) Ikäheimo, H. (2007) ‘Recognizing persons’ in H. Ikäheimo and A. Laitinen (eds), Dimensions of Personhood,

special issue of Journal of Consciousness Studies 14(5-6), also issued separately as a book Ikäheimo, H. (2010) ‘Making the best of what we are: recognition as an ontological and ethical concept’, in H.-C.

Schmidt am Busch and C. Zurn (eds) The Philosophy of Recognition Ikäheimo, H. and Laitinen, A. (eds) (2011) Recognition and Social Ontology

Testa, I. (2011) ‘Social space and the ontology of recognition’, in H. Ikäheimo and A. Laitinen (eds) Recognition and Social Ontology

@ Recognition as ethical (Recognition by others as a condition of a good life) (See also ‘Honneth’s theory of recognition’) Laitinen, A. (2002) ‘Interpersonal recognition: a response to value or a precondition of

personhood’, Inquiry 45(4) Laitinen, A. (2007) ‘Sorting out aspects of personhoon: capacities, normativitiy and recogntion’, in H. Ikäheimo

and A. Laitinen (eds), Dimensions of Personhood, special issue of Journal of Consciousness Studies 14(5-6), also issued separately as a book

@ Recognition theory: collections van den Brink, B. and Owen, D. (eds.) (2007) Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical

Social Theory Schmidt am Busch, H.-C. and Zurn, C. (eds) (2010) The Philosophy of Recognition Seymour, M. (ed.) (2010) The Plural States of Recognition Ikäheimo, H. & Laitinen, A. (eds) (2011) Recognition and Social Ontology Sorenson, A @ PHENOMENOLOGY OF SPIRIT (Including corresponding parts of Philosophy of Spirit) (For ch. 7 see ‘Religion in the Phenomenology’) @ Phenomenology: short introductions Baillie, J.B. (1910) ‘Translator’s Introduction’ to Hegel, The Phenomenology of Mind, tr, Baillie* Findlay, J.N. (1958) Hegel, chs. 4-5* Kaufmann, W. (1965) Hegel: Reinterpretation, Texts and Commentary, ch. 3 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 4 sec. 1* Singer, P. (1983) Hegel, ch. 4 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 4b Findlay, J.N. (1977) ‘Foreword’ to Miller’s translation of the Phenomenology Harris, H.S. (1987) ‘Hegel’s science of experience’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 15 (survey of

interpretations of the Phenomenology since the 60s) Solomon, R. (1993) ‘Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, in R. Solomon and K.M. Higgins (eds.) The Age of

German Idealism, Routledge History of Philosophy Vol. 6 Pinkard, T. (1999) ‘History and philosophy: Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, in S. Glendinning (ed.) The

Edinburgh Encyclopedia of Continental Philosophy @ Phenomenology: introductory commentaries Marx, W. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: Its Point and Purpose Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology Rockmore, T. (1997) Cognition: An Introduction to Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’ Stern, R. (2002) Hegel and the Phenomenology of Spirit, Routledge Philosophy Guidebook Verene, D.P. (2007) Hegel’s Absolute: An Introduction to Reading the Phenomenology of Spirit @ Phenomenology: advanced commentaries Heidegger, M. [1930-31] Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit* Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, tr. S. Cherniak and J. Heckman

1974 Kojève, A. [1947] Introduction to the Reading of Hegel, tr. J.H. Nichols 1969 Loewenberg, J. (1965) Hegel’s Phenomenology: Dialogues of the Life of the Mind Gadamer, H.-G. [1966] Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Hermeneutical Studies, tr. 1976 Pöggeler, O. (1973) Hegels Idee einer Phenomenoloige des Geistes Kainz, H.P. (1976,1983) Hegel’s Phenomenology, 2 volumes Lauer, Q. (1976) A Reading of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, 2nd ed. 1993 Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, 3rd (ed.) 1998 Lamb, D. (1980) Hegel: From Foundation to System Dudeck, C.V. (1981) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Mind: Analysis and Commentary Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel: A Study of G.W.F. Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit

Flay, J. (1984) Hegel’s Quest for Certainty Westphal, K. (1989) Hegel’s Epistemological Realism: A Study of the Aim and Method of Hegel’s

Phenomenology of Spirit Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology: The Sociality of Reason Harris, H.S. (1995) Hegel: Phenomenology and System Reed, E.D. (1996) A Theological Reading of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, with Particular Reference to its

Themes of Identity, Alienation, and Community: Salvation in a Social Context Harris, H.S. (1997) Hegel’s Ladder, 2 volumes* Forster, M.N. (1998) Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit Simpson, P. (1998) Hegel’s Transcendental Induction Siep, L. (2000) Der Weg der Phenomenologie des Geistes Stewart, J. (2000) The Unity of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: A Systematic Interpretation Westphal, K. (2003) Hegel’s Epistemology: A Philosophical Introduction to the Phenomenology of Spirit. Russon, J.E. (2004) Reading Hegel’s Phenomenology Kain, P.J. (2005) Hegel and the Other: A Study of the Phenomenology of Spirit Bristow, W.F. (2007) Hegel and the Transformation of Philosophical Critique Jameson, F. (2010) The Hegel Variations: On the Phenomenology of Spirit @ Phenomenology: commentaries on particular topics Verene, D.P. (1985) Hegel’s Recollection: A Study of Images in the ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’ Parry, D.M. (1988) Hegel’s Phenomenology of the ‘We’ Russon, J.E. (1997) The Self and Its Body in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit @ Phenomenology: collections Fulda, H.F. and Henrich, D. (eds.) (1973) Materialien zu Hegels Phänomenologie des Geistes Westphal, M. (ed.) (1982) Method and Speculation in Hegel’s Phenomenology Stern, R. (ed.) (1993) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, volume 3 Browning, G.K. (ed.) (1997) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: A Reappraisal* Stewart, J. (ed.) (1998) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader: Critical and Interpretive Essays Denker, A. and Vater, M. (eds) (2003) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: New Critical Essays Moyar, D. and Quante, M. (eds) (2008) Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’: A Critical Guide Vieweg, K. and Welsch, W. (eds) (2008) Hegels Phänomenologie des Geistes: Ein kooperativer Kommentar zu

einem Schlüsselwerk der Moderne Westphal, K. (ed.) (2009) The Blackwell Guide to Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit @ Phenomenology: Preface Phenomenology of Spirit, Preface §§1-47* Kaufmann, W. (1965) Hegel: Reinterpretation, Texts and Commentary, ch. 8 Schacht, R. (1972) ‘A commentary on the Preface to Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, Philosophical Studies 23,

reprinted in his Hegel and After: Studies in Continental Philosophy Between Kant and Sartre 1975 Marx, W. (1975) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: Its Point and Purpose Sallis, J. (1977) ‘Hegel’s concept of presentation: its determination in the Preface to the Phenomenology of

Spirit’, Hegel-Studien 12, reprinted in Sallis’s Delimitations: Phenomenology and the End of Metaphysics, and in Stewart (ed.)The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader

Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 2 Adelman, H. (1984) ‘Hegel’s Phenomenology: facing the Preface’, Idealistic Studies 14 Stepelevich, L. S. (ed.) (1990) G. W. F. Hegel: Preface and Introduction to the ‘Phenomenology of Mind’ Yovel, Y. (2005) Hegel’s Preface to the Phenomenology of Spirit: Translation and Running Commentary @ Phenomenology: Introduction (For specific issues see ‘Method of the Phenomenology’ and ‘Scepticism and Hegel’ below) Phenomenology of Spirit, introduction Heidegger, M. [1950] Hegel’s Concept of Experience* Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 1 Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 1 Bahti, T. (1981) ‘The indifferent reader: the performance of Hegel’s introduction to

the Phenomenology’, Diacritics 11 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 6 Gillespie, M.A. (1984) Hegel, Heidegger and the Ground of History, ch. on the introduction Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, chs. 2, 5

Stepelevich, L. S. (ed.) (1990) G. W. F. Hegel: Preface and Introduction to the ‘Phenomenology of Mind’ @ Method of the Phenomenology (Including role of the phenomenologist (‘for us’), immanent critique, determinate negation) (For dialectical method in the Logic see ‘Logic: method and structure, dialectic, contradiction, speculation, form

and content’) (For relation of Phenomenology and logic see ‘Phenomenology and system, phenomenology and logic’) Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, part 1 ch. 1 ‘Meaning and

method of the Phenomenology’ Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 8 Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, ch. 5, see pp. 94-99 Dove, K. (1970) ‘Hegel’s phenomenological method’, Review of Metaphysics 23(4), reprinted in Steinkraus

(ed.) New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3, and in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader 1998

Pippin, R. (1975) Hegel’s phenomenological criticism’, Man and World 8, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3

Marx, W. (1975) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: Its Point and Purpose, pp. 91-92 Rosen, M (1979) ‘The spirit of Hegel’ in Radical Philosophy 22 Marx, W. (1979) ‘Dialectic and the role of the phenomenologist’, The Owl of Minerva 11(2), reprinted in Stern

(ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Flay, J.C. (1982) ‘Pragmatic presuppositions and the dialectics of Hegel’s Phenomenology’, in Westphal

(ed.) Method and Speculation in Hegel’s Phenomenology Rosen, M. (1982) Hegel’s Dialectic and its Criticism, ch. 2 ‘Determinate negation and immanent critique’ Westphal, K. (1988) ‘Hegel’s solution to the dilemma of the criterion’, History of Philosophy Quarterly 5,

reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader 1998 Houlgate, S. (2003) ‘G.W.F. Hegel: Phenomenology of Spirit (1807): thinking philosophically without begging

the question’, in J.J.E. Garcia et al. The Classics of Western Philosophy: A Reader’s Guide+ Houlgate, S. (2005) An Introduction to Hegel: Freedom, Truth and History (2nd ed. of his Freedom, Truth and

History, 1991), ch. 3 ‘Phenomenology and natural consciousness’ @ Transcendental argument and transcendental deduction in the Phenomenology (See also ‘Scepticism and Hegel, assumptions and foundations of the Phenomenology and Logic’)* Taylor, C. (1972) ‘The opening arguments of the Phenomenology’, sec. 2, in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection

of Critical Essays Neuhouser, F. (1986) ‘Deducing desire and recognition in the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 24(2) Westphal, K. (1989) Hegel’s Epistemological Realism: A Study of the Aim and Method of Hegel’s

Phenomenology of Spirit , pp. 154-188 Forster, M.N. (1998) Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit , ch. 3 ‘Justifying Hegelian science’ pp. 161-165

(critique of Taylor) Stewart, J. (2000) The Unity of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: A Systematic Interpretation , pp. 21-25 ‘Kant

and Hegel on transcendental philosophy’ Horstmann, R.-P. (2006) ‘Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit as an argument for a monistic

ontology’, Inquiry 49(1) @ Scepticism and Hegel, assumptions and foundations of the Phenomenology and Logic (Including the idea that Hegel’s philosophy is anti-dogmatic, presuppositionless or anti-foundationalist) (See also ‘Phenomenology: Introduction’) (See also ‘Transcendental argument and transcendental deduction in the Phenomenology’) (For Hegel’s critique of Kantian scepticism in particular, see ‘Kant’s epistemology and metaphysics: Hegels

critique’) ‘Relationship of skepticism to philosophy, exposition of its different modifications and comparison of the latest

form with the ancient one’ [1801], in G. di Giovanni and H.S. Harris (eds.) Between Kant and Hegel: Texts in the Development of Post-Kantian Idealism 1985

Lectures on the History of Philosophy, Part 1, Section 2, D ‘Scepticism’ Introduction to Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Knox and Miller, pp. 181-182 Encyclopaedia Logic §§ 32A, 71-72, 81A Heidegger, M. [1930-31] Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, §5 ‘The presupposition of the Phenomenology: its

abolute beginning with the absolute’

Dove, K. (1970) ‘Hegel’s phenomenological method’, Review of Metaphysics 23(4), reprinted in Steinkraus (ed.) New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3, and in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader 1998

Rosen, M. (1982) Hegel’s Dialectic and its Criticism Flay, J.C. (1982) ‘Pragmatic presuppositions and the dialectics of Hegel’s Phenomenology’, in Westphal

(ed.) Method and Speculation in Hegel’s Phenomenology Rockmore, T. (1984) Hegel’s Circular Epistemology Harris, H.S. (1985) ‘Skepticism, dogmatism and speculation in the critical journal’, in G. di Giovanni and H.S.

Harris (eds.) Between Kant and Hegel: Texts in the Development of Post-Kantian Idealism Westphal, K. (1988) ‘Hegel’s solution to the dilemma of the criterion’, History of Philosophy Quarterly 5,

reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader 1998 Westphal, K. (1989) Hegel’s Epistemological Realism: A Study of the Aim and Method of Hegel’s

Phenomenology of Spirit Forster, M.N. (1989) Hegel and Skepticism Maker, W. (1994) Philosophy without Foundations: Rethinking Hegel* Forster, M.N. (1998) Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit , ch. 3 ‘Justifying Hegelian science’ Clark, W.L. and Fritzman, J.M. (2003) ‘The nonfoundational Hegelianism of Dove, Maker, and Winfield’, The

Philosophical Forum 34(1) Westphal, K.R. (2003) ‘Hegel’s manifold response to scepticism in The Phenomenology of Spirit’, Proceedings of

the Aristotelian Society 103(1)+ Beiser, F. (2005) Hegel, ch. 1 ‘The cultural context’ Houlgate, S. (2005) An Introduction to Hegel: Freedom, Truth and History (2nd ed. of his Freedom, Truth and

History, 1991), ch. 2 ‘Thinking without presuppositions’ and sec. 1 of ch. 3 ‘Phenomenology and natural consciousness’

@ Immediate knowledge (This is a cogito-like knowledge in which one knows the object with the same indubitability that one knows

oneself; sometimes Hegel uses ‘witness of one’s spirit’ for it) Phenomenology §§26, 554 Philosophy of Right §147 ‘Reason and religious truth’ p. 43 Vorlesungen uber Philosophie des Rechts vol. 1 pp. 285-286 @ Structure of the Phenomenology (See also ‘Coherence of the Phenomenology, phenomenology and history’) Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit, part 1 ch. 3 Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel, sec. 4 ch. 3 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 4c (pp. 211-236)* Stewart, J. (1993) ‘The architectonic of Hegel’s Phenomenology’, Philosophy and Phenomenological

Research 55(4), reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader Forster, M.N. (1998) Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit @ Phenomenology: chs. 1-3 in general Philosophy of Spirit (as Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind or Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit, or The Berlin

Phenomenology) §§413-423 Encyclopaedia Logic §§125-130, 135-137 Science of Logic, 2.2.1.A ‘The thing and its properties’, 2.2.3 ‘The essential relation’ Purpus, W. (1908) Zur Dialektik des Bewußtseins nach Hegel Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 4 sec. 2 Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 2 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 7 secs. a-e Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, ch. 6 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 2 Chitty, A. (1996) ‘On Hegel, the subject and political justification’, section 1, Res Publica 2(2) @ Sense-certainty, ch. 1 Phenomenology ch. 1, §558 Encyclopaedia Logic §§20R, 61-78* Feuerbach, L. [1839] ‘Towards a critique of Hegel’s philosophy’ in L.S. Stepelevich (ed.) The Young

Hegelians 1983, pp. 113-116, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 1, pp. 116-118

Loewenberg, J. (1935) ‘The comedy of immediacy in Hegel’s Phenomenology’, Mind 44, pp. 21-38 Hamlyn, D. (1961) Sensation and Perception: A History of the Philosophy of Perception, chapter on Hegel Wiehl, R. (1966) ‘Über den Sinn der sinnlichen Gewißheit in Hegels Phänomenologie des Geistes’ Hegel-

Studien Beiheft 3 Soll, I. (1969) An Introduction to Hegel’s Metaphysics, ch. 3 Löwith, K. (1971) ‘Mediation and immediacy in Hegel, Marx and Feuerbach’ in Steinkraus, W.E. (ed.) New

Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel 1971 Heinrichs, J. (1974) Die Logik der Phänomenologie des Geistes+ Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 3* Taylor, C. (1972) ‘The opening arguments of the Phenomenology’, sec. 2, in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection

of Critical Essays, reprinted without the references to Wittgenstein as ch. 4 sec. 2 of Taylor’s Hegel, 1975 Solomon, R.C. (1974) ‘Hegel’s epistemology’, American Philosophical Quarterly 11, reprinted in Inwood

(ed.) Hegel Soll, I. (1976) ‘Charles Taylor’s Hegel’, Journal of Philosophy 73(19), reprinted in Inwood (ed.) Hegel Taylor, C Lamb, D. (1978) ‘Hegel and Wittgenstein on language and sense-certainty’, Clio 7, pp. 285-301 De Nys, M.J. (1978) ‘“Sense certainty” and universality: Hegel’s entrance into the Phenomenology’, International

Philosophical Quarterly 18(4), reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Plumer, G. (1980) ‘Hegel on singular demonstrative reference’, Philosophical Topics 11, pp. 71-94 Warminski, A. (1981) ‘Reading for example: sense-certainty in Hegel’, Diacritics 11(2), pp. 83-94 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel ch. 7 sec. a Dulckheit, K. (1986) ‘Can Hegel refer to particulars?’, The Owl of Minerva 17, reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The

Phenomenology of Spirit Reader Craig, E. J. (1987, pb. 1996) The Mind of God and the Works of Man, ch. 4 ‘One way to read Hegel’ [oso] De Vries, W. (1988) ‘Hegel on reference and knowledge’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 26* Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism ch. 6 sec. 1 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 2 sec. 1 Westphal, K.R. (2000) ‘Hegel’s internal critique of naive realism’, Journal of Philosophical Research 15, pp.

173-229 @ Sense-certainty: possible parallels to Hegel’s argument Plato, Theaetetus, 151d–186e Fichte [1800] The Vocation of Man, first third Wittgenstein, L. (195?) Philosophical Investigations Quine, W. (19?) Word and Object, ch. 4 McDowell, J. (1996) Mind and World @ Perception, ch. 2 Taylor, C. (1972) ‘The opening arguments of the Phenomenology’, section 3, in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A

Collection of Critical Essays Westphal, M. (1973) ‘Hegel’s phenomenology of perception’, in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit

Reader Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel ch. 7 secs. b-c Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism ch. 6 sec. 2 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 2 sec. 2 Westphal, K.R. (1998) ‘Hegel and Hume on perception and concept-empiricism’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 33 @ Force and understanding, ch. 3 De Nys, M.J. (1982) ‘Force and understanding: the unity of the object of consciousness’, in M. Westphal

(ed.) Method and Speculation in Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology’ Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel ch. 7 sec. d @ Infinity in Hegel (See also ‘Levinas and Hegel’) Encylopaedia Logic §§92-95 Hyppolite, J. [1936] ‘The concept of life and consciousness of life in Hegel’s Jena philosophy’, in his Studies in

Hegel and Marx, tr. 1969 Lacroix, A. (2000) ‘The mathematical infinite in Hegel’, Philosophical Forum 31(3-4)

Horstmann, R.-P. [2003] ‘Substance, subject and infinity: A case study of the role of logic in Hegel’s system’, in K. Deligiorgi (ed.) Hegel: New Directions, 2006

@ Inverted world (For the soul, see ‘Soul and feeling, anthropology’) Phenomenology of Spirit ch. 3 §§157-165 (Baillie pp. 203-213), ch. 4 §166 (Baillie pp. 218-9) Philosophy of Spirit §§413-417, 422-424 (in Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind, or in Philosophy of Subjective

Spirit or The Berlin Phenomenology with accompanying lecture notes) Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, section on the inverted world Gadamer, H.G. [1966] ‘Hegel’s inverted world’, in Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Hermeneutical Studies, reprinted in

Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Flay, J.C. (1970) ‘Hegel’s “inverted world”‘, Review of Metaphysics 23(4), reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel:

Critical Assessments vol. 3, and in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader, and in D. Köhler and O. Pöggeler (eds.) G.W.F. Hegel: Phänomenologie des Geistes, Klassiker Auslegen

Murray, D. (1970-71) ‘Force and understanding’, in Reason and Reality, Royal Institute of Philosophy Lectures vol. 5, (ed.) G. Vesey

Bossart, W.H. (1982) ‘Hegel on the inverted world’, Philosophical Forum 13(4) Zimmerman, R. (1982) ‘Hegel’s “inverted world” revisited’, Philosophical Forum 13(4) Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 7 sec. e Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism: The Satisfactions of Self-Consciousness, section on the inverted world @ Self-consciousness in the Phenomenology (See also ‘Fichte on consciousness and self-consciousness’, ‘Consciousness, self-consciousness and the I in

the Philosophy of Spirit’) (Including the idea of recognition or intersubjectivity as a necessary condition of self-consciousness) (For Hegel’s critique of Kant’s conceptions of apperception and of the I, see ‘Kant on self-consciousness,

apperception and the transcendental deduction: Hegel’s critique’) (For the connection between the concept and the I see ‘Representation vs. concept, concrete universal,

intentionality’) Phenomenology §§26, 36, 82, 84, chapter 4 section A Cramer, K. [1973] ‘Bewußtsein und Selbstbewußtsein: Vorschläge zur Rekonstruktion der systematischen

Bedeutung einer Behauptung Hegels in §424 der Berliner Encyclopädie der Philosophischen Wissenschaften’ in D. Henrich (ed.)Hegels philosophische Psychologie, Hegel-Studien Beiheft 19, 1979

Cramer, K. (1974) ‘Erlebnis: These zu Hegels Theorie des Selbstbewußtseins mit Rucksicht auf die Aporien eines Grundbegriffs nach Hegelscher Philosophie’, Hegel-Studien Beiheft 11

Cramer, K. (1976) ‘Bemerkungen zu Hegels Begriff vom Bewußtsein’, in Guzzoni, U. et al. (eds.) Der Idealismus und seine Gegenwart

Tugendhat, E. [1979] Self-Consciousness and Self-Determination, tr. 1986, lectures 13-14 de Vries, W.A. (1988) Hegel’s Theory of Mental Activity: An Introduction to Theoretical Spirit, chs. 2,6,

also available online Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, ch. 6 sec. 3 Frank, M. (1991) ‘Subjektivität und Intersubjektivität’, in his Selbstbewußtsein und Selbsterkenntnis Hespe, F. (1991): ‘System und Funktion der Philosophie des Subjektiven Geistes’, in Hespe and Tuschling

(eds.) Psychologie und Anthropologie oder Philosophie des Geistes Ikäheimo, H. (2007) ‘Recognizing persons’, Journal of Consciousness Studies, 14(5-6), pp. 224-247 Pippin, R. (2011) Hegel on Self-Consciousness: Desire and Death in the Phenomenology of Spirit @ Desire and the body in the Phenomenology (see also ‘Self-consciousness in the Phenomenology’) (For desire as pragmatisation of knowledge, see ‘Social epistemology or pragmatism in ch. 4’) Neuhouser, F. (1986) ‘Deducing desire and recognition in the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 24(2) Butler, J. (1987) Subjects of Desire: Hegelian Reflections in 20th Century France, ch. 1 ‘Desire, rhetoric and

recognition in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’ Russon, J.E. (1997) The Self and Its Body in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit Jenkins, S. (2009) ‘Hegel’s concept of desire’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 47(1) @ Recognition in the Phenomenology (See this heading above)

@ Master-servant relation (see ‘Recognition in the Phenomenology’ above) @ Death in Hegel Hyppolite, J. [1955] ‘The concept of existence in the Hegelian phenomenology’, in his Essays on Hegel and Marx @ Labour in Hegel (In all writings, but Phenomenology is central) (Also: the praxis/poesis relation) (For the economy see ‘Civil society and the economy’) (See also ‘Contradictions of civil society’) Philosophy of Right, sec. on ‘The kind of work’ under system of needs Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel Arendt, H. (1959) The Human Condition, ch. 5 Dubsky, I. (1961) Hegels Arbeitsbegriff und die idealistische Dialektik Lakebrink, B. (1962-63) ‘Geist und Arbeit im Denken Hegels’, Philosophisches Jahrbuch 70 Lim, S.-Z. [1963] Der Begriff der Arbeit bei Hegel: Versuch einer Interpretation der Phänomenologie des

Geistes, 2nd German (ed.) 1966* Habermas, J. [1967] ‘Labour and interaction: remarks on Hegel’s Jena Philosophy of Mind’, in his Theory and

Practice Lobkowicz, N. (1967) Theory and Practice: History of a Concept from Aristotle to Marx, ch. 22 Mercier-Josa, S. (1976) ‘Après Aristote et Adam Smith, que dit Hegel de l’agir?’, Les Etudes Philosophiques 3 Blanchette, O. (1979) ‘Praxis and labor in Hegel’, Studies in Soviet Thought 20 Lange, E.M. (1980) Das Prinzip Arbeit, esp. ch. 1 Adelman, H. (1980) ‘Of human bondage: labour, bondage, and freedom in the Phenomenology’, in Verene

(ed.) Hegel’s Social and Political Thought , reprinted in O’Neill (ed.) Hegel’s Dialectic of Desire and Recognition: Texts and Commentary, also in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader

Planty-Bonjour, G. (1983) ‘Hegel’s concept of action as unity of poesis and praxis’, in Stepelevich and Lamb eds Bernstein, J. (1984) ‘From self-consciousness to community: act and recognition in the master-slave relationship’,

sec. 4 (pp. 32-38), in Pelczynski (ed.) The State and Civil Society Arthur, C. (1988) ‘Hegel’s theory of value’ in M. Williams (ed.) Value, Social Form and the State Avineri, S. (1996) ‘Labor, alienation, and social classes in Hegel’s Realphilosophie’, in J. O’Neill (ed.) Hegel’s

Dialectic of Desire and Recognition Sayers, S.P. (2003) ‘Creative activity and alienation in Hegel and Marx’, Historical Materialism 11(1) Sayers, S.P. (2005) ‘Why work? Marxism and human nature’, Science and Society 69(4) Sayers, S.P. (2007) ‘The concept of labour: Marx and his critics’, Science and Society 71(4) @ Stoicism, scepticism and the unhappy consciousness, ch. 4B (See also ‘Legal status (Rechtzustand), person and property in the Phenomenology’) Hegel [1795] ‘How Christianity conquered paganism’, in ‘The Positivity of the Christian Religion’, in his Early

Theological Writings, also available online Phenomenology ch. 4B, §340 Wahl, J. (1929) Le malheur de la conscience dans la philosophie de Hegel, 2nd ed. 1951, Presses Universitaires

de France, pp. 119-147, trans. R. Northey in R. Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, vol. 2 Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, part 3, chs. 2-3 Greene, M. (1970) ‘Hegel’s notion of inversion’, International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 1(3) Hyppolite, J. (1971) ‘Hegel’s phenomenology and psychoanalysis’, in Steinkraus (ed.) New Studies in the

Philosophy of Hegel Rosen, S. (1974) G.W.F. Hegel: An Introduction to the Science of Wisdom, ch. 7 Burbidge, J.W. (1978) ‘Unhappy consciousness in Hegel: an analysis of medieval Catholicism?’, Mosaic 11,

reprinted in Burbidge’s Hegel on Logic and Religion: The Reasonableness of Christianity, and in J. Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader

Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 8 pp. 455-471 Butler, J. (1997) The Psychic Life of Power, ch. 1 ‘Stubborn attachment, bodily subjection: rereading Hegel on the

unhappy consciousness’ @ Social epistemology in ch. 4 Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 5A Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 4 secs. e-f, i.e. pp. 376-401

Solomon, R.C. (1974) ‘Hegel’s epistemology’, American Philosophical Quarterly 11, reprinted in Inwood (ed.) Hegel

Pippin, R. (1993) ‘You can’t get from there to here: transition problems in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, secs. 2-4, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel

@ Observing reason Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 5A Acton, H. B. (1971) ‘Hegel’s conception of the study of human nature’, in ? (ed.) Royal Institute of Philosophy

Lectures, Vol. 4: 1969-70: The Proper Study; reprinted in Inwood (ed.) Hegel MacIntyre, A. (1972) ‘Hegel on faces and skulls’, in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays,

reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 4 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 7g Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 4 sec. 1 @ Transition to spirit Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 5B-C Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 4 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 9 secs. a-b Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 4 sec. 2 @ Spirit: texts Phenomenology, §177, introduction to ch. 6 Philosophy of Spirit §§381-384, and the students’ notes to §377 (published in M. Petry (ed.) Hegel’s Philosophy

of Subjective Spirit, vol. 1) @ Spirit: metaphysical interpretations (For the parallel discussions about the nature of ethical substance, see ‘Ethical substance’) (For relationship between spirit and nature, see ‘Freedom and determinism’) Findlay, J.N. (1958) Hegel, ch. 2 Habermas, J. [1967] ‘Labour and interaction: remarks on Hegel’s Jena Philosophy of Mind’, in his Theory and

Practice, tr. J. Viertel 1973* Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, chs. 3, 14 Taylor, C. (197?) ‘Hegel’s philosophy of mind’, reprinted in Human Agency and Language: Philosophical Papers

1 1985 Habermas, J. [1985] The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, tr. 1990 lecture 2+ Inwood, M. (1991) A Hegel Dictionary, entry on ‘Spirit’ Honneth, A. [1992] The Struggle for Recognition, tr. 1995, chs. 1-3, esp. pp. 58-62* Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 2 sec. 1 @ Spirit: intersubjective and collective-subject interpretations Solomon, R.C. (1970) ‘Hegel’s concept of “Geist”‘, Review of Metaphysics 23(4), reprinted in MacIntyre

(ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays Theunissen, M. (1970) Hegels Lehre vom Absoluten Geist also theologisch-politischer Traktat Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 5 Williams, R.R. (1987) ‘Hegel’s concept of Geist’, in P.G. Stillman (ed.) Hegel’s Philosophy of Spirit, reprinted in

Stern, R. (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, vol. 3 Williams, R.R. (1992) Recognition: Fichte and Hegel on the Other Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology: The Sociality of Reason Pippin, R.B. (2000) ‘What is the question for which Hegel’s theory of recognition is the answer?’, European

Journal of Philosophy 8(2) Sembou, E. (2003) ‘Hegel’s idea of a struggle for recognition: the Phenomenology of Spirit’, History of Political

Thought 24(2) Pippin, R. (2008) Hegel’s Practical Philosophy: Rational Agency as Ethical Life , ch. 7 ‘Hegelian sociality:

recognitive status’ @ Phenomenology: ch. 6 in general (For mature theory of history see ‘History (philosophy of)’) Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 6 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 6

Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 5 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 9 pp. 534-579 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 5 @ Coherence of the Phenomenology, phenomenology and history (And the transition from chs. 1-5 to ch. 6) (See also ‘Phenomenology: structure’) Phenomenology of Spirit, Preface §§27-29 Encyclopaedia Logic, §25 Haering, T. (1934) ‘Die Entstehungsgeschichte der Phänomenologie des Geistes’, Verhandlung des 3.

Hegelkongresses, (ed.) B. Wigersma Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, part 1 ch. 2 ‘History and

phenomenology’ Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel, sec. 4 ch. 3 Pöggeler, O. [1961] ‘Zur Deutung der Phänomenologie des Geistes’, in his Hegels Idee einer Phänomenologie

des Geistes, 1973* Marx, W. (1975) Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit: Its Point and Purpose Pöggeler, O. (1966) ‘Die Komposition des Phänomenologie des Geistes’, Hegel-Studien, Beiheft 3, reprinted in

Fulda and Henrich (eds.) Materialien zu Hegels Phänomenologie des Geistes 1973 Petry, M.J. (1978) ‘Introduction’ to Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit, (ed.) M.J. Petry Schmidt, J. (1981) ‘Recent Hegel literature: the Jena period and the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Telos 48 (pp. 125-

130) Pippin, R. (1993) ‘You can’t get from there to here: transition problems in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, in

F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Forster, M. (1998) Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit, chs. 8-12 @ Greek world and its inadequacy (For the figure of Antigone and feminist interpretations of the Antigone story, see ‘Antigone’) (See also ‘Enlightenment vs. faith’ and ‘Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom, individuality, autonomy’) (For Hegel’s relations to Greek philosophy see ‘Plato and Hegel’, ‘Aristotle and Hegel’, ‘Greek philosophy in

general and Hegel’) Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 6A Philosophy of History, part 2 secs. 1 and 3; part 3 introduction Philosophy of Right, Preface (CUP edition) pp. 20-21, §§117A, 124R, 185R,A, 206R, 262A Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, part 5, introduction (pp. 321-

333) Shklar, J. (1971) ‘Hegel’s Phenomenology: an elegy for Hellas’, in Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s Political Philosophy,

reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983 Shklar, J.N. (1976) Freedom and Independence: A Study of The Political Ideas in Hegel’s Phenomenology of

Mind Kelly, G.E. (1978) Hegel’s Retreat from Eleusis Schmidt, J. (1981) ‘Recent Hegel literature: the Jena period and the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Telos 48, pp. 136-

141 Inwood, M. (1984) ‘Hegel, Plato and Greek “Sittlichkeit”‘, in Pelczynski (ed.) The State and Civil Society+ Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 5 sec. 1 De Laurentiis, A. (2005) Subjects in the Ancient and Modern World: On Hegel’s Theory of Subjectivity De Boer, K. (2009) ‘The eternal irony of the community: Aristophanian echoes in Hegel’s Phenomenology of

Spirit’, Inquiry 52(4) @ Antigone (For feminists on Hegel in general see ‘Feminism and Hegel’) (For Irigaray’s interpretation in particular see ‘Irigaray and Hegel’) Irigaray L. [1974] Speculum of the Other Woman, ‘The eternal irony of the community’ Steiner, G. (1984) Antigones, the section on Antigone in Hegel, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical

Assessments, vol. 3 Mills, P.J. (1986) ‘Hegel’s Antigone’, The Owl of Minerva 17(2), revised version in Mills (ed.) Feminist

Interpretations of G.W.F. Hegel 1996, reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader Benhabib, S. (1991) ‘On Hegel, women and irony’, in Shanley and Pateman (eds.) Feminist Interpretations and

Political Theory

Kelly, O. (1996) ‘Antigone’s ghost: undoing Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, Hypatia 11(1) Walsh, L. (1999) ‘Her mother her self: the ethics of the Antigone family romance’, Hypatia 14(3) Hutchings, K. (2000) ‘Antigone: towards a Hegelian feminist philosophy’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great

Britain, 41/42, pp. 120-131 Butler, J. (2000) Antigone’s Claim: Kinship Between Life and Death @ Tragedy in Hegel Bradley, A.C. (1903-04) ‘Hegel’s theory of tragedy’, The Hibbert Journal 11, reprinted in A. and H. Paolucci

(eds.) Hegel on Tragedy Hegel, G.W.F., Hegel on Tragedy, eds. A. and H. Paolucci, 1962 Kaufmann, W. (1968) Tragedy and Philosophy, section on Hegel Roche, M.W. (1998) Tragedy and Comedy: A Systematic Study and a Critique of Hegel Finlayson, G. (2000) ‘Conflict and reconcilation in Hegel’s theory of tragedy’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 37(3) George, T.D. (2006) Tragedies of Spirit: Tracing Finitude in Hegel’s Phenomenology @ Legal status (Rechtszustand), Roman world, person and property in the Phenomenology (See also ‘Stoicism, scepticism and the unhappy consciousness’) Phenomenology, ch. 6Ac ‘Legal status’, §§748-753 Seth Pringle-Pattison, A. (1887) Hegelianism and Personality, reprinted 1971, available online Hyppolite, J. (1966) ‘L’état du droit (la condition juridique)’, Hegel-Studien 3, pp. 181-185 Kervegan, J.-F. (1987) ‘Hegel et l’état du droit’, Archives de Philosophie 50, pp. 55-56 Bernasconi, R. (1989) ‘Persons and masks: the Phenomenology of Spirit and its laws’, Cardozo Law Review 10,

pp. 1695-1711, reprinted in D. Cornell et al (eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory 1991 Hoffheimer, M.H. (1992) ‘The idea of law (Recht) in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, Clio 21(4), pp. 345-367 @ Alienation in Hegel (Entfremdung and Entäusserung) (Including comparisons between Hegel’s and Marx’s usages) (For Marx on these alienation see A Marx bibliography: ‘Alienation’) (For Entässerung and kenosis in Hegel’s work as a whole see ‘Metaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations:

kenotic and christomorphic’) Marx, K. [1844] Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts, final section: ‘Critique of Hegel’s dialectic’ Marx, ‘Hegel’s construction of the Phenomenology’ [1844], Marx and Engels, Collected Works, vol. 4, p. 665* Lukacs, G. [1948] The Young Hegel tr. R. Livingstone 1975, part 4, ch. 4 ‘Entausserung as the central

philosophical concept of the Phenomenology of Mind’ Hyppolite, J. [1955] Studies on Hegel and Marx , ch. 4 ‘Alienation and objectification’ Gauvin, F. (1962) ‘Entfremdung et Entäusserung dans la Phénomenologie de Hegel’, Archives de Philosophie,

555-571 Lobkowicz, N. (1967) Theory and Practice: History of a Concept from Aristotle to Marx, chs. 20-22 Schacht, R. (1971) Alienation, ch. 2* Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 5 Robinson, J. (1977) Duty and hypocrisy in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Mind: An Essay in the Real and the Ideal,

pp. 23-26 Kain, P.J. (1979) ‘Alienation and estrangement in the thought of Hegel and the young Marx’, The

Philosophical Forum 11(2) Arthur, C.J. (1986) Dialectics of Labour: Marx and his Relation to Hegel, chs. 4-6+ Inwood, M. (1992) A Hegel Dictionary, entry on ‘alienation and estrangement’ Duquette, D.A. (1993) ‘C. J. Arthur on Marx and Hegel on alienation’, Auslegung 19(1) Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, introduction, pp. 95-122,

conclusion Sayers, S. (2003) ‘Creative activity and alienation in Hegel and Marx’, Historical Materialism 11(1) @ Enlightenment vs. faith (See also ‘Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom’) (See also ‘Greek world and its inadequacy’) (See also ‘Historical role of Hegel’s philosophy’) (See also ‘Bifurcation, and the standpoint of modern thought, Kant’s standpoint as a whole’ ) ‘Relationship of skepticism to philosophy’ [1801], in G. di Giovanni and H.S. Harris, tr. Between Kant and

Hegel: Texts in the Development of Post-Kantian Idealism 1985

Phenomenology §§6-10, 26, and ch. 6B2 ‘The Enlightenment’ ‘Reason and religious truth’, foreword to H. Hinrich Religion in its Inner Relation to Science, in F. Weiss

(ed.) Beyond Epistemology: New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, pp. 227-244 Lectures on the History of Philosophy, part 3 introduction and section on ‘French Philosophy’ Rosen, S. (1974) G. W. F. Hegel: An Introduction to the Science of Wisdom, Yale University Press, pp. 183-228+ Solomon (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel pp. 552-559 Hinchman, L.P. (1984) Hegel’s Critique of the Enlightenment Stern, R. (1993) ‘General introduction’, to Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, vol. 1 pp. 1-20 Pippin, R. (1997) ‘Hegel on historical meaning: for example, the Enlightenment’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of

Great Britain 35 @ Modernity and Hegel (See also ‘Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom, individuality, autonomy’) Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel and Modern Society (= Hegel chs. 3,1 4, 15, 20)* Habermas, J. [1985] The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, lecture 2 Kolb, D. (1986) The Critique of Pure Modernity: Hegel, Heidegger and After Westphal, M. (1992) Hegel, Freedom, and Modernity Brod, H. (1992) Hegel’s Philosophy of Politics: Idealism, Identity and Modernity Dallmayr, F. (1993) G.W.F. Hegel, Modernity and Politics, new ed. 2002 Collins, A.B. (ed.) (1995) Hegel on the Modern World Luther, T. (2009) Hegel’s Critique of Modernity: Reconciling Individual Freedom and the Community @ French Revolution (including material on the relation of Enlightenment to French Revolution) (See also ‘Will and action’ ) (See also ‘Rousseau and Hegel’) Phenomenology ch. 6B2c ‘Absolute freedom and terror’ Philosophy of History, part 4 sec. 3, ‘The modern time’ Hyppolite, J. [1952] ‘The significance of the French Revolution in Hegel’s Phenomenology’, in his Studies on

Hegel and Marx Ritter, J. [1956] ‘Hegel and the French Revolution’, in his Hegel and the French Revolution, tr. R. Winfield 1982 Habermas, J. [1963] ‘Hegel’s critique of the French Revolution’, in his Theory and Practice, tr. J. Viertel 1973 Nusser, K. [1970] ‘The French Revolution in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit, in Stewart (ed.) The

Phenomenology of Spirit Reader Suter, J.-F. (1971) ‘Burke, Hegel, and the French Revolution’, in Pelczynksi (ed.) Hegel’s Political Philosophy* Avineri, S. (1972) Hegel’s Theory of the Modern State+ Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel pp. 403-421 Beck, L. W. (1976) ‘The Reformation, the Revolution, and the Restoration in Hegel’s political

philosophy’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 14 Harris, H.S. (1977) ‘Hegel and the French Revolution’, Clio 7, pp. 5-18 d’Hondt, J. (197?) Hegel in his Time: Berlin 1818-1831, tr. J. Burbidge 1981+ Solomon (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, pp. 559-564 Smith, S.B. (1990) ‘Hegel and the French Revolution: an epitaph for republicanism’, in F. Fehér (ed.) The French

Revolution and the Birth of Modernity, also available online May, H. (1990) ‘The French Revolution and the problem of German modernity: Hegel, Heine, and Marx’, New

German Critique 50 O’Regan, C. (1995) ‘The religious and theological relevance of the French Revolution’, in A.B. Collins

(ed.) Hegel on the Modern World Wokler, R. (1996) ‘The Enlightenment and the French revolutionary birth pangs of modernity’, Sociology of the

Sciences Yearbook 20 Wokler, R. (1997) ‘The French Revolutionary roots of political modernity in Hegel’s philosophy, or the

Enlightenment at dusk’ Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 35 Wokler, R. (1998) ‘Contextualizing Hegel’s phenomenology of the French Revolution and Terror’, Political

Theory 26(1) @ Totalitarianism, authoritarianism, nationalism and Prussianism in Hegel (I.e. in Hegel’s own politics) Haym, R. (1857) Hegel und seine Zeit, ch. 15 Popper, K. (1945) The Open Society and Its Enemies, 5th (ed.) 1966, vol. 2, ch. 12

Kaufmann, W. (1951) ‘The Hegel myth and its method’, Philosophical Review 60, also in Kaufmann’s The Owl and the Nightingale, also in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays

Berlin, I. (1958) Two Concepts of Liberty (pamphlet), reprinted in Four Essays on Liberty 1969 Ritter, J. [1962] ‘Person and property: on Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, paragraphs 34-81’, in Hegel and the

French Revolution: Essays on the Philosophy of Right Knox, T.M. (1970) ‘Hegel and Prussianism’ in W. Kaufmann (ed.) Hegel’s Political Philosophy* Avineri, S. (1972) Hegel’s Theory of the Modern State, chs. 6-9 Stewart, J. (ed.) (1996) The Hegel Myths and Legends, part 2 Tugendhat, E. [1979] Self-Consciousness and Self-Determination, tr. 1986, pp. 312-23 Cristi, R. (2005) Hegel on Freedom and Authority @ Moral and political stance of the Phenomenology (Considered separately from that of the Philosophy of Right) (For material on ch. 6Ac see ‘Legal status (Rechtzustand), person and property in the Phenomenology’) (For material on ch. 5C and 6C see ‘Kant’s ethics and theory of will and freedom: Hegel’s critique of it in

general’) (See also ‘Recognition in the Jena writings’) Marcuse, H. (1941) Reason and Revolution, ch. 4 ‘The Phenomenology of Mind’ Plamenatz, J. (1963) Man and Society, vol. 2, pp. 146-202 Shklar, J.N. (1976) Freedom and Independence: A Study of The Political Ideas in Hegel’s Phenomenology of

Mind Franco, P. (2000) Hegel’s Philosophy of Freedom, ch. 3 ‘The moral and political ideas of the Phenomenology of

Spirit’ Pippin, R. (2004) ‘Recognition and reconciliation: actualized agency in Hegel’s Phenomenology, in K. Ameriks

and J. Stolzenberg (eds.) Internationales Jahrbuch des Deutschen Idealismus, vol. 2, reprinted in K. Deligiorgi (ed.) Hegel: New Directions, 2006, also in B. van den Brink and D. Owen (eds.) Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical Social Theory, 2007

@ Phenomenology: ch. 7 (See ‘Religion in the Phenomenology’) @ Art in the Phenomenology (See ‘Art’) @ Absolute knowing and the metaphysics of the Phenomenology, ch. 8 (Commentaries on ch. 8 and references to it by Hegel elsewhere) (For Hegel’s standpoint in general see ‘Hegel’s standpoint (his idealism) and the Logic: texts’ below and the

sections following it) Phenomenology §§ 26, 37, 797-808 Science of Logic, tr. Miller, pp. 28 (on ‘pure knowing’), 49 (on ‘absolute knowing’), 60 (on ‘pure knowing’), 69

(on ‘pure knowing’)+ Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, pp. 107-109* Miller, M.H., Jr. (1978) ‘The attainment of the absolute standpoint in Hegel’s Phenomenology, Graduate Faculty

Philosophy Journal 7, reprinted in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, conclusion Houlgate, S. (1998) ‘Absolute knowing revisited’, The Owl of Minerva 30(1), 51-67 Horstmann, R.-P. (2006) ‘Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit as an argument for a monistic

ontology’, Inquiry 49(1) @ Phenomenology and logic, phenomenology and system (Including logicist interpretations of the Phenomenology)* Phenomenology, Preface §§35-47 (Baillie pp. 95-106), esp. §37, ch. 8 §805 (Baillie pp. 804-806) Science of Logic, Preface to first edition Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, Conclusion pt. 3 Hyppolite, J. [1952] Logic and Existence: Essays on Hegel’s Logic, tr. 1997 Hartmann, K. (1966) ‘On taking the transcendental turn’, Review of Metaphysics 20(2), reprinted in

Hartmann’s Studies in Foundational Philosophy, 1988 Pöggeler, O. (1966) ‘Die Komposition des Phänomenologie des Geistes’, Hegel-Studien, Beiheft 3, reprinted in

Fulda and Henrich (eds.) Materialien zu Hegels Phänomenologie des Geistes 1973

Fulda, H.F. (1966) ‘Zur Logik der Phänomenologie von 1807’, Hegel-Studien, Beiheft 3, reprinted in Fulda and Henrich (eds.) Materialien zu Hegels Phänomenologie des Geistes 1973

Léonard, A. (1971) ‘La structure du système hégélian’, Revue philosophique de Louvain 69, pp. 495-524 Puntel, L.B. (1971) Darstellung, Methode, und Struktur, in Hegel- Studien, Beiheft 10 Heinrichs, J. (1974) Die Logik der Phänomenologie des Geistes Trede, J.H. (1975) ‘Phänomenologie und Logik: Zu den Grundlagen einer Diskussion’, Hegel-Studien 10 Léonard, A. (1976) ‘Pour une exégèse renouvelée de la Phénoménologie de l’esprit de Hegel’, Revue

philosophique de Louvain 74, pp. 572-593+ Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, pp. 116-132 Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 8C Schmidt, J. (1981) ‘Recent Hegel literature: the Jena period and the Phenomenology of Spirit’, Telos 48 Dove, K. (1982) ‘Phenomenology and systematic philosophy’, in Westphal, M. (ed.) Method and Speculation in

Hegel’s Phenomenology Hösle, V. (1987) Hegels System. Der Idealismus der Subjectivität und das Problem der Intersubjectivität [Hegel’s

System: The Idealism of Subjectivity and the Problem of Intersubjectivity], 2 vols Forster, M.N. (1998) Hegel’s Idea of a Phenomenology of Spirit , chs. 13-17 Cobben, P.G. (2003) ‘The logical structure of self-consciousness’, in A. Denker and M. Vater (eds.) Hegel’s

Phenomenology of Spirit: New Critical Essays @ LOGIC AND METAPHYSICS @ Logic: short introductions Marcuse, H. (1941) Reason and Revolution, part 1 ch. 5 Hyppolite, J. [1952] ‘On the Logic of Hegel’, in his Studies on Hegel and Marx Hyppolite, J. [1952] Logic and Existence: Essays on Hegel’s Logic, tr. 1997, final chapter, ‘The organisation of

the Logic’, available online Kaufmann, W. (1965) Hegel: Reinterpretation, Texts and Commentary, ch. 4 Mure, G.R. (1965) The Philosophy of Hegel chs. 1,5* Gadamer, H.-G. [1973] ‘The idea of Hegel’s Logic’, in Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Phenomenological Studies,

reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 9 Pinkard,T. (1979) ‘The logic of Hegel’s Logic’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 17, reprinted in Inwood

(ed.) Hegel Inwood, M. (1983) Hegel, Arguments of the Philosophers, ch. 8 deVries, W.A. (1993) ‘Hegel’s logic and philosophy of mind’, in R.C. Solomon and K.M. Higgins

(eds.) Routledge History of Philosophy. Volume 6: The Age of German Idealism* Houlgate, S. (2005) An Introduction to Hegel: Freedom, Truth and History (2nd ed. of his Freedom, Truth and

History, 1991), ch. 2 ‘Thinking without presuppositions’ Burbidge, J. (1992) ‘On Hegel’s Logic’, in Burbidge (ed.) Hegel on Logic and Religion Burbidge, J. (1993) ‘Hegel’s conception of logic’ in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Burbidge, J. (2006) The Logic of Hegel’s Logic: An Introduction @ Logic: commentaries (Unclassified as to interpretation) Harris, W.T. (1890) Hegel’s Logic: A Book on the Genesis of the Categories of the Mind: A Critical Exposition,

reprinted 2011 McTaggart, J.M. (1896) Studies in the Hegelian Dialectic, available online, 2nd ed. 1922 available online Baillie, J.B. (1901) The Origin and Significance of Hegel’s Logic: A General Introduction to Hegel’s System Macran. H.S. (1929) Hegel’s Logic of World and Idea Mure, G.R. (1950) A Study of Hegel’s Logic Findlay, J.N. (1954) Hegel: A Re-examination, chs. 6-8 Rosen, S. (1974) G.W.F. Hegel: An Introduction to the Science of Wisdom, chs. 3-5* Burbidge, J. (1981) On Hegel’s Logic: Fragments of a Commentary Longuenesse, B. [1981] Hegel’s Critique of Metaphysics, tr. 2007 Harris, E.E. (1983) An Interpretation of the Logic of Hegel Johnson, P.E. (1989) The Critique of Thought: A Re-examination of Hegel’s ‘Science of Logic’ Hartnack. J. (tr. 1998) An Introduction to Hegel’s Logic Carlson, D.G. (2007) A Commentary to Hegel’s Science of Logic @ Logic: collections

Weiss, F. (ed.) (1974) Beyond Epistemology: New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel Steinkraus, W.E. and Schmitz, K.L. (eds.) (1980) Art and Logic in Hegel’s Philosophy Vesey, G. (ed.) (1982) Idealism Past and Present di Giovanni, G. (ed.) (1990) Essays on Hegel’s Logic* Stern, R. (ed.) (1993) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, volume 3 @ Logic: surveys of the secondary literature Lewis, C. (1981) ‘Recent literature on Hegel’s Logic’, Philosophische Rundschau 28 The Encyclopaedia Logic (1991), tr. T. Geraets et al. (aas annotated bibliography of works on the Logic) @ Dialectical method See ‘Logic: method and structure’, ‘Logic: formalisations of dialectical logic’, ‘Method of the Phenomenology’ @ Logic: method and structure, dialectic, contradiction, speculation, form and content (Including materials on dialectic in general in Hegel; for dialectic specifically in the Phenomenology’s see

‘Method of the Phenomenology’) (Form and content in the sense that the Logic generates content from form; for form and content in Hegel’s ethics

see ‘Kant’s ethics: Hegel’s critique of its formalism’) (See also ‘Reason, understanding and intuition’) (For critique of Kant’s antinomies see ‘Kant’s dialectic and antinomies: Hegel’s critique’) (For Phenomenology and Logic see ‘Phenomenology and system, phenomenology and logic’) Science of Logic, Prefaces, Introduction, ‘With what must the science begin?’* Encyclopaedia Logic, Prefaces, §§19-25, 79-82 Philosophy of Nature Philosophy of Spirit §§377-387, 413-439, 440, 445-456, 451, 465, 469, 481-6 (in Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind) Popper, K. (1940) ‘What is dialectic?’, Mind 49, reprinted in Popper’s Conjectures and Refutations, 5th (ed.)

1989 Findlay, J.N. (1958) Hegel, ch. 3 Mueller, G.E. (1958) ‘The Hegel legend of “thesis-antithesis-synthesis”‘, Journal of the History of Ideas 19 di Giovanni, J. (1973) ‘Reflection and contradiction: a commentary on some passages of Hegel’s Science of

Logic’, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Pinkard,T. (1979) ‘The logic of Hegel’s Logic’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 17, reprinted in Inwood

(ed.) Hegel Pippin, R.B. (1978) ‘Hegel’s metaphysics and the problem of contradiction’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 16, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Wolff, M. (1979) ‘ Über das Verhältnis zwischen logischem und dialektischem Widerspruch’, Hegel Jahrbuch Sherman, N. (1980) ‘Hegel’s two dialectics’, Kant-Studien 71, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical

Assessments vol. 3 Burbidge, J. (1982) ‘Transition or reflection’, Revue Internationale de Philosophie 36, reprinted in Stern

(ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Rosen, M. (1982) Hegel’s Dialectic and its Criticism, chs. 2-3 Forster, M.N. (1993) ‘Hegel’s dialectical method’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Bencivenga, E. (2000) Hegel’s Dialectical Logic+ Beiser, F.C. (2005) Hegel, ch. 7 ‘The dialectic’ Hahn, S.S. (2007) Contradiction in Motion: Hegel’s Organic Concept of Life and Value @ Logic: formalisations of dialectical logic Kosok, M. (1972) ‘The formalisation of Hegel’s dialectical logic’, in A. MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of

Critical Essays Lachertman, D. (1987) ‘Hegel and the formalisation of logic’, Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal 12, 153-236 Priest, G, (1989) ‘Dialectic and dialethic’, Science and Society 53 @ Reason, understanding and intuition (As methods of thinking) (Also Hegel’s critique of ordinary logic) (See also ‘Representation vs. concept, concrete universal, intentionality’) Phenomenology, transition to ch. 5 Encyclopaedia Logic §§60, 80-82 ‘Reason and religious truth’, foreword to H. Hinrich Religion in its Inner Relation to Science, in F. Weiss

(ed.) Beyond Epistemology: New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, pp. 227-244

Hanna, R. (1986) ‘From an ontological point of view: Hegel’s critique of the common logic’, Review of Metaphysics 40

@ Sociality of reason Escobar, J.A.R. (2008) ‘Hegel’s Science of Logic and the ‘sociality of reason’’, in P. Ashton et al. The Spirit of

the Age: Hegel and the Fate of Thinking @ Proposition (judgment), speculative proposition, language (See also ‘Reason, understanding and intuition’) (For Hegel’s own use of language see ‘Terminology and language’ above’) Phenomenology of Spirit, Preface §§60-66 Science of Logic 577-595, tr. Miller Encyclopaedia Logic §§1-5, 20, 28-29, 163, 166 Cook, D.J. (1972) ‘Language and consciousness in Hegel’s Jena writings’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 10, reprinted in R. Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, vol. 4 Cook, D. (1973) Language in the Philosophy of Hegel Surber, J.P. (1975) ‘Hegel’s speculative sentence’, Hegel-Studien 10, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel:

Critical Assessments vol. 3 Theunissen, M. (1978) Sein und Schein: Die kritische Funktion der Hegelschen Logik Gasche, R. (1986) The Tain of the Mirror: Derrida and the Philosophy of Reflection, c. pp. 45-49 deVries, W.A. (1988) Hegel’s Theory of Mental Activity: An Introduction to Theoretical Spirit (part 3 is on

Hegel’s theory of language)* Rosen, M. (1988) ‘From Vorstellung to thought: is a ‘non-metaphysical’ view of Hegel possible?’, in Henrich, D.


Surber, J.O. (2006) Hegel and Language Vernon, J. (2007) Hegel’s Philosophy of Language Reid, J. (2007) Real Words: Language and System in Hegel @ Being, nothing, becoming Encyclopaedia Logic, §§84-88 Burbidge, J. (1981) On Hegel’s Logic: Fragments of a Commentary, pp. 38-45 Harris, E.E. (1983) An Interpretation of the Logic of Hegel, pp. 93-100 Pippin, R. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism pp. 182-188 Houlgate S. (2004) The Opening of Hegel’s Logic: From Being to Infinity @ Essence Henrich, D. [19?] ‘Logik der Reflexion’ in his Hegel im Kontext Houlgate, S. (1999) ‘Hegel’s critique of foundationalism in the “Doctrine of Essence”‘, in A. O’Hear

(ed.) German Philosophy Since Kant Cirulli, F. (2006) Hegel’s Critique of Essence: A Reading of the Wesenslogik @ Subjective logic Winfield, R.D. (2005) From Concept to Objectivity: Thinking Through Hegel’s Subjective Logic Carlson, D.G. (ed.) (2005) Hegel’s Theory of the Subject @ Concept, the (Including the connection between the concept and the ‘I’) (See also ‘Infinity in Hegel’) Pinkard,T. (1979) ‘The logic of Hegel’s Logic’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 17, reprinted in Inwood

(ed.) Hegel Westphal, M. (1980) ‘Hegel’s theory of the concept’, in W.E. Steinkraus and K.I. Schmidt (eds.) Art and Logic in

Hegel’s Philosophy, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 De Nys, M.J. (1986) ‘Self-consciousness and the concept in Hegel’s appropriation of Kant’ in A.B. Collins

(ed.) Hegel on the Modern World Iber, C. (2003) ‘Übergang zum Begriff. Rekonstruktion der Überführung von Substantialität, Kausalität und

Wechselwirkung in die Verhältnisweise des Begriffs’, Anton Friedrich Koch (ed.) Der Begriff als die Wahrheit. Zum Anspruch der Hegelschen ‘Subjektiven Logik’

De Boer, K. (2004) ‘The dissolving force of the concept: Hegel’s ontological logic’, Review of Metaphysics 57(4)

@ Concrete and abstract universality (For the universality of the will see ‘Substantial will’)* Royce, J. (1892) ‘Appendix C: The Hegelian theory of universals’, in his The Spirit of Modern Philosophy,

pp. 492-506., also available online (the whole book is available here) Grier, P.T. (1990) ‘Abstract and concrete in Hegel’s Logic’, in G. di Giovanni (ed.) Essays on Hegel’s Logic Harris, E.E. (1990) ‘A Reply to Philip Grier’s “Abstract and concrete in Hegel’s Logic”‘, in G. di Giovanni

(ed.) Essays on Hegel’s Logic Ilyenkov, E.V. [19?] ‘The universal’, in F.J. Adelmann (ed.) Philosophical Investigations in the USSR, 1975 (an

alternative version of this article exists as ch. 11 of Dialectical Logic), available online Stern, R. (2007) ‘Hegel, British Idealism, and the curious case of the concrete universal’, British Journal for the

History of Philosophy 15(1), sections 2-4 Kisner, W. (2008) ‘The concrete universal in Žižek and Hegel’, International Journal of Zizek

Studies 2(2), available online @ Identity and difference in Hegel Haas, A. (2000) Hegel and the Problem of Multiplicity Grier, P.T. (2007) Identity and Difference: Studies in Hegel’s Logic, Philosophy of Spirit, and Politics, part 1 @ Concrete universal in British idealism (See also ‘British idealism’) Bosanquet, B. (1912) The Principle Of Individuality And Value, The Gifford Lectures for 1911, lecture 2 ‘The

concrete universal’, available online Sabine, G.H. (1912) ‘Professor Bosanquet’s Logic and the concrete universal’, The Philosophical Review 21(5) Mander, J. (2005) Life and finite individuality: The Bosanquet/Pringle-Pattison debate’, British Journal for the

History of Philosophy 13(1) Stern, R. (2007) ‘Hegel, British Idealism, and the curious case of the concrete universal’, British Journal for the

History of Philosophy 15(1) @ Metaphysics of Hegel, his account of the absolute: texts Phenomenology, Preface, §§17-23 (substance as subject), §37 (‘being is self-like or the concept’); ch. 1; §759

(substance reflected into itself in its accidents is subject); ch. 8 esp. §797 (knowledge of self as substance and of substance as knowledge of self’s act)

Science of Logic, Prefaces, Introduction, ‘With what must science begin?’ Encyclopaedia Logic (also as Hegel’s Logic or The Logic of Hegel), §§1-18, esp. §§7-12 and 18 (NB this is

Hegel’s introduction to the Encyclopaedia as a whole, not just to the Encyclopaedia Logic), §§26-78 Philosophy of Nature, Introduction from start up to and including §247 (Miller translation pp. 1-16) Philosophy of Spirit, Introduction, section on ‘what mind [Geist] is’, §§381-384 (in Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind,

tr. Wallace pp. 8-20; or in vol. 1 of Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit, (ed.) M. Petry) Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, vol. 1, the section ‘Of God’ Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion (one volume edition), c. pp. 473, 489 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: surveys Kreines, J. (2006) ‘Hegel’s metaphysics: changing the debate’, Philosophy Compass 1(5) (NB The following interpretations of Hegel’s metaphysics are from the most realist to the most idealist) @ Metaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations - general (Theological interpretations are the only ones to attribute to Hegel the claim that he can know objects beyond the

range of sensory experience) (For Hegel’s philosophy of religion see ‘Philosophy of religion’) (See also ‘Kant and Fichte’s theology and Hegel’) Collins, J. (1967) The Emergence of Philosophy of Religion, ch. 7 ‘Religion and Hegelian metaphysics’ Jaeschke, W. (1981) ‘Absolute Idee – Absolute Subjektivität. Zum Problem der Persönlichkeit Gottes in der

Logik und in der Religionsphilosophie’ , Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung 35, pp. 385-416 Ferrini, C. (1999) ‘God and nature in Hegel’s Science of Logic’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great

Britain, 39/40 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations: orthodox (The basic distinction between these and emanationist and kenotic and immanentist interpretations is that God or

the absolute is self-conscious independently of creation, rather than only through human beings)

(See also ‘Religion in Hegel’s work as a whole’) (See also ‘Trinitarianism in Hegel’) Yerkes, J. (1978) The Christology of Hegel Lauer, Q. (1982) Hegel’s Concept of God, esp. introduction and ch. 1 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations: spirit-monist, emanationist and panentheist (Also the idea of the absolute as substance and subject) (Neo-Platonist. The Logic is realist and a priori; its determinations pre-exist us, and more or less literally

externalise themselves in nature in order to then become self-conscious in human spirit, thereby realising God, whether this realisation is thought of as achieved in the first or second of these steps. Hence ‘substance as subject’.)

(See also ‘Spinoza and pantheism: Hegel’s critique’) (For Feuerbach’s view of Hegel see ‘Feuerbach and Hegel’ in A Marx bibliography) Phenomenology §§17-19, 36-37, 755-61, 802 Whittemore, R.C. (1960) ‘Hegel as panentheist’, Tulane Studies in Philosophy 9* Taylor (1975) ch. 3 secs. 2,3,5 (reprinted as Taylor’s Hegel and Modern Society, ch. 1 secs. 2,3,5 ), esp. pp. 87-90, and

ch. 18 secs. 1-2+ Plant, R. (1997) Hegel: On Religion and Philosophy, The Great Philosophers, esp. pp. 30-49 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations: kenotic and christomorphic (This is a version of emanationism in which the emphasis is on the necessity for absolute to ‘empty itself’,

become finite, and subject itself to suffering, as Christ does in Christianity) (For Hegel on the historical Jesus and on Christianity, see ‘Christianity’) Phenomenology §§ 760-784 Küng, H. [1970] The Incarnation of God: An Introduction to Hegel’s Theological Thought as a Prolegomena to a

Future Christology, tr. 1987 Hallman, J. (1991) The Descent of God: Divine Suffering in History and Theology, last chapter Altizer, T.J.J. (1991) ‘Hegel and the Christian God’, Journal of the American Academy of Religion 59(1) Altizer, T.J. J. (1993) The Genesis of God: A Theological Genealogy, ch. 2 O’Regan, C. (1994) The Heterodox Hegel McGrath, A.E. (1994) The Making of Modern German Christology, 1750-1990 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: immanentist and pantheist theological interpretations (Spinozist. The Logic is realist and a priori; its determinations are the determinations of an immanent rational

subjectivity which emerges progressively within not prior to nature and then in the human mind) (See also ‘Spinoza and pantheism: Hegel’s critique’) Butler, C. (1985) ‘Hermeneutic Hegelianism’, Idealistic Studies 15 Houlgate, S. (2005) An Introduction to Hegel: Freedom, Truth and History (2nd ed. of his Freedom, Truth and

History, 1991), ch. 2 ‘Thinking without presuppositions’ Houlgate, S. (1991) ‘Thought and being in Kant and Hegel’, The Owl of Minerva 22(2) Houlgate, S. (1993) ‘A reply to Joseph C. Flay’s “Hegel’s metaphysics”‘, The Owl of Minerva 24(2) Houlgate, S. (1994) ‘Hegel and Fichte: recognition, otherness and absolute knowing’, The Owl of Minerva 26(1) @ Metaphysics of Hegel: conceptualist and panlogist interpretations (Aristotelian. The Logic is realist and a priori; its determinations pre-exist us and are immanent in nature. The

difference from pantheist interpretations is that subjectivity is not mentioned here) Horstmann, R.-P. (1974) Ontologie und Relationen Buchdahl, G. (1973) ‘Hegel’s philosophy of nature and the structure of science’, Ratio 15(1), reprinted in Inwood

ed., and in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 4 Rosen, M. (1982) Hegel’s Dialectic and its Criticism Inwood, M. (1983) Hegel, Arguments of the Philosophers, chs. 8-10 Eisenberg, P. (1990) ‘Was Hegel a panlogicist?’, Nous 24 Stern, R. (1990) Hegel, Kant and the Structure of the Object* Wartenberg, T. (1993) ‘Hegel’s idealism: the logic of conceptuality’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge

Companion to Hegel @ Metaphysics of Hegel: dialogical interpretations (Flay, Williams. The Logic is a priori but cannot be categorised as either realist or anti-realist because it

thematises the relationship between subject and object (Flay), in which the object is neither just distinct from nor just identical to the subject (Williams))

Flay, J.C. (1993) ‘Hegel’s metaphysics’, The Owl of Minerva 24(2), 145-152 Flay, J. (1998) ‘Absolute knowing and the absolute other’, The Owl of Minerva 30(1), 69-82 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: non-metaphysical interpretations in general Lumsden, S. (2008) ‘The rise of the non-metaphysical Hegel’, Philosophical Compass 3(1), available online @ Metaphysics of Hegel: empiricist-realist interpretations (Findlay. The Logic is realist and a posteriori, ordering our empirical knowledge at the highest level of

abstraction. This interpretation is called ‘non-metaphysical’ because it is a posteriori) Findlay, J.N. (1958) Hegel, ch. 1 sec. 1, chs. 6-9, ch. 12 sec. 5* Findlay, J.N. (1971) ‘Hegel’s use of teleology’, in Steinkraus, W.E. (ed.) New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel Rosen, M. (1988) ‘From Vorstellung to thought: is a ‘non-metaphysical’ view of Hegel possible?’, in Henrich, D.


@ Metaphysics of Hegel: positivist and category theory interpretations (Hartmann and followers. The Logic is anti-realist and a posteriori; the Logic is a derivation of the categories of

ordinary experience and empirical science, without existential commitments, and justified by its explanation of those categories. All of Hartmann is here, although he seems to waver between a positivist and a Kantian interpretation: Pippin sees him as positivist and Beiser as Kantian)

Hartmann, K. (1966) ‘On taking the transcendental turn’, Review of Metaphysics 20(2), reprinted in Hartmann’s Studies in Foundational Philosophy, 1988

* Hartmann, K. (1972) ‘Hegel: a non-metaphysical view’, in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3

Hartmann, K. (1972) ‘The “analogies” and after’, in Beck, L.W. (ed.) Proceedings of the Third International Kant Congress

+ Bole, T. (1974) ‘The dialectic of Hegel’s Logic as the logic of ontology’, Hegel-Jahrbuch Hartmann, K. (1976) ‘Die ontologische Option’, in his Die ontologische Option Pinkard, T. (1979) ‘Hegel’s idealism and Hegel’s Logic’, Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung 33, reprinted

in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Pinkard, T. (1987) Hegel’s Dialectic: The Explanation of Possibility Pinkard, T. (1989) ‘The categorial satisfaction of self-reflexive reason’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great

Britain 19 Smith, T. (1990) The Logic of Marx’s Capital ch. 1 Pippin, R. (1990) ‘Hegel and category theory’, Review of Metaphysics 43 Englehardt, H.T. and Pinkard, T. (eds.) (1994) Hegel Reconsidered: Beyond Metaphysics and the Authoritarian

State Khushf, G. (1994) ‘The meta-ontological option’, in Englehardt, H.T. and Pinkard, T. (eds.) Hegel Reconsidered* Beiser, F.C. (1995) ‘Hegel, a non-metaphysician? A polemic’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 32 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: implicitly anti-realist interpretations (The Logic is a theory of thought-categories, so is implicitly anti-realist, but these writers remain agnostic about

its possible metaphysical implications) Henrich, D. (1971) Hegel im Kontext Fulda, H. (1978) ‘Unzulängliche Bermerkungen zur Dialektik’, in Horstmann, R.-P. (ed.) Seminar: Dialektic in

der Philosophie Hegels @ Metaphysics of Hegel: hermeneutical interpretations (Gadamer. The Logic is anti-realist and a posteriori, as in positivist interpretations, but the method of elucidating

these is hermeneutic rather than hypothetico-deductive; the Logic is a hermeneutic of contemporary spirit) Gadamer, H.-G. [1973] Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Phenomenological Studies Redding, P. (1996) Hegel’s Hermeneutics @ Metaphysics of Hegel: Kantian interpretations (Pippin, early Solomon. The Logic is anti-realist but a priori; it elaborates, a priori, the categories which are the

necessary conditions of thought or intelligible experience) (See also ‘Kant’s epistemology and metaphysics: Hegel’s critique’) (See also ‘McDowell on Hegel’)

(For discussions focusing on apperception see ‘Kant on self-consciousness, apperception and the transcendental deduction: Hegel’s critique’)

Solomon, R.C. (1970) ‘Hegel’s concept of “Geist”‘, Review of Metaphysics 23, reprinted in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays

Longuenesse, B. [1981] Hegel’s Critique of Metaphysics, tr. 2007 White, A. (1983) Absolute Knowledge: Hegel and the Problem of Metaphysics Pinkard, T. (1988) Hegel’s Dialectic: The Explanation of Possibility, chs. 1-5* Pippin, R (1989) Hegel’s Idealism, esp. ch. 1, ch. 5, ch. 8 sec. 1 Various authors (1989) ‘Pippin’s Hegel’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 19 Pinkard, T. (1990) ‘How Kantian was Hegel?’, Review of Metaphysics 43 Pippin, R. (1990) ‘Hegel and category theory’, Review of Metaphysics 43 Ameriks, K. (1991) ‘Hegel and idealism’, Monist 74(3) reprinted in Stern vol. 3 Westphal, K. (1993) ‘Hegel, idealism, and Robert Pippin’, International Philosophical Quarterly 33(3) @ Metaphysics of Hegel: transformed-Kantian interpretations (Akin to Kantian interpretations but attributing to Hegel a more radical transformation of Kant in a metaphysical

direction) Fulda, H.F. (1988) ‘Ontologie nach Kant und Hegel’, in his Metaphysik nach Kant De Boer, K. (2004) ‘The dissolving force of the concept: Hegel’s ontological logic’, Review of Metaphysics 57(4) Bristow, W.F. (2007) Hegel and the Transformation of Philosophical Critique @ Metaphysics of Hegel: epistemist-realist interpretations (Beiser, Fulda. The Logic is realist and a priori, but it deduces the nature of reality from the successive necessary

ways in which consciousness must conceive it in order for it to be able to think of itself as knowing it. Akin to Kantian interpretations except that the result is a realist Logic)

(See also ‘Phenomenology and system, phenomenology and logic’) (See also ‘Schellingian critiques of Hegel’) Beiser, F.C. (1993) ‘Introduction: Hegel and the problem of metaphysics’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge

Companion to Hegel @ Metaphysics of Hegel: social-Kantian interpretations (Including Metaphysics and ethics) (Theunissen. The Logic is anti-realist but a priori, as for Kantian interpretation, but it elaborates, a priori, the

categories which correspond to a free or true social order) (See also ‘Philosophy of Right and Logic’) (Also, material on the relation between Hegel’s ethics / politics / theory of freedom and his logic/metaphysics) Reyburn, H.A. (1921) The Ethical Theory of Hegel: A Study of the Philosophy of Right Habermas, J. (1968) Knowledge and Human Interests, ch. 1 Berki, R.N. (1968) ‘Political freedom and Hegelian metaphysics’, Political Studies 16 Soll, I. (1969) An Introduction to Hegel’s Metaphysics+ Norman, R. (1976) Hegel’s Phenomenology, pp. 109-116 Theunissen, M. (1978) Sein und Schein: Zur kritische Funktion der Hegelschen Logik Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology Pippin, R. (1979) ‘The rose and the owl: some remarks on the theory-practice problem in Hegel’, Independent

Journal of Philosophy 3 Pippin, R. (1981) ‘Hegel’s political argument and the problem of Verwirklichung’, Political Theory 9 Fulda, H., Horstmann, R.-P. and Theunissen, M. (1980) Kritische Darstellung der Metaphysik. Eine Diskussion

der Hegels Logik Rose, G. (1981) Hegel Contra Sociology Kolb, D. (1986) The Critique of Pure Modernity: Hegel, Heidegger and After, chs. 3-5 @ Metaphysics of Hegel: historical-relativist interpretations (Later Solomon and later Pinkard. The Logic is anti-realist but a priori; it elaborates, a priori for those of us who

belong to the contemporary form of spirit, the categories of that spirit’s thought, in terms of the rationality intrinsic to it)

Solomon, R.C. (1974) ‘Hegel’s epistemology’, American Philosophical Quarterly 11 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, conclusion Pinkard, T. (1991) ‘The successor to metaphysics: absolute idea and absolute spirit’, Monist 74(3), July 1991,

parts 1-2 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 6 sec. 2

@ NATURE AND SUBJECTIVE SPIRIT (REALPHILOSOPHIE) @ Relation of Logic to Realphilosophie Halper, E.C. (2002) ‘The idealism of Hegel’s system’, The Owl of Minerva 34(1) @ Nature and the natural sciences: general (For particular topics see ‘Nature and the natural sciences: particular topics’) (See also above ‘metaphysics of Hegel’) (See also ‘Aristotle and Hegel’) Encyclopaedia Logic §§6-12 Philosophy of Nature, Introduction (§245-252), pp. 191-201 Philosophy of Spirit §379A Alexander, S. (1886) ‘Hegel’s conception of nature’, Mind 11 Harris, E.E. (1949-50) ‘The philosophy of nature in Hegel’s system’, Review of Metaphysics 3 Kimmerle, H. (1967) ‘Hegels Naturphilosophie in Jena, Hegel-Studien 4 McMullin, E. (1969) ‘Philosophies of nature’, The New Scholasticism 43 Petry, M.J. (1970) ‘Introduction’ to his translation of The Philosophy of Nature Buchdahl, G. (1973) ‘Hegel’s philosophy of nature and the structure of science’, Ratio 15(1), reprinted in Inwood

(ed.) Hegel and in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 4 Sambursky, S. (1974) ‘Hegel’s philosophy of nature’, in Elkana, Y. (ed.) The Interaction Between Science and

Philosophy* Petry, M.J. (1975) ‘Hegel’s dialectic and the natural sciences’, Hegel Jahrbuch 19 Webb, T. (1980) ‘The problem of knowledge in Hegel’s philosophy of nature’, Hegel-Studien 15 Buchdahl, G. (1983) ‘Conceptual analysis and scientific theory in Hegel’s philosophy of nature (with special

reference to Hegel’s optics)’ in Cohen and Wartofsky (eds.) Hegel and the Sciences Cohen, R.S. and Wartofsky, M.W. (eds.) (1983) Hegel and the Sciences Lucas, G.R. (1984) ‘A reinterpretation of Hegel’s philosophy of nature’, Journal of the History of

Philosophy 22(1), reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 4 Horstmann, R.-P. and Petry, M.J. (eds.) (1986) Hegels Philosophie der Natur Richter, ? (1985) Hegels begreifende Naturbetrachtung Stern, R. (1990) Hegel, Kant and the Structure of the Object Kalenberg (1997) Die Befreiung der Natur Houlgate, S. (ed.) (1998) Hegel and the Philosophy of Nature Beiser, F. (2003) ‘Hegel and Naturphilosophie’, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A 34(1) Stone, A. (2005) Petrified Intelligence: Nature in Hegel’s Philosophy @ Mathematics and geometry in Hegel (With thanks to Dirk Damsma) (For infinity see ‘infinity in Hegel’) Baer, R. (1932) ‘Hegel und die Mathematik’, in Veröffentlichungen des Internationalen Hegelbundes,

Verhandlungen des Zweiten Hegelkongresses vom18. bis 21. Oktober 1931 Tóth, I. (1972) Die nicht-euklidische Geometrie in der Phänomenologie des Geistes; Wissenschaftstheoretische

Betrachtungen zur Entwicklungsgeschichte der Mathematik Paterson, A.L.T. (1997) ‘Towards a Hegelian philosophy of mathematics’, Idealistic Studies 27 (this and other

articles by Paterson on Hegel and mathematics are available online) Paterson, A.L.T. (2002) ‘Does Hegel have anything to say to modern mathematical philosophy?’ Idealistic

Studies 32(2) Paterson, A.L.T. (2004-05) ‘Hegel’s early geometry’, Hegel-Studien 39/40 @ Ecology, environmentalism and Hegel (With thanks to Alison Stone) Passmore, J. (1995) ‘Attitudes to nature’, in R. Elliott (ed.) Environmental Ethics (includes a section on Hegel) Petersen, M.C. E. (1996): ‘The role of practical and theoretical approaches in Hegel’s philosophy of nature’, The

Owl of Minerva 27(2) Berthold-Bond, D. (1997) ‘Hegel and Marx on nature and ecology’, Journal for Philosophical Research 22 Miller, E.P. (1997) ‘The figure of self-sacrifice in Hegel’s Naturphilosophie’, Philosophy Today 41, Supplement Stone, A. (2002) ‘Ethical implications of Hegel’s philosophy of nature’, British Journal for the History of

Philosophy 10(2)

@ Nature and the natural sciences: particular topics Wandschneider, ? (1982) Raum, Zeit, Relativität Ferrini, C. (1991) ‘Features of irony and alleged errors in Hegel’s De orbitis planetarum’, Hegel-Jahrbuch 1991,

pp. 459-477 Petry, M.J. (ed.) (1993) Hegel and Newtonianism Reusswig, ? (1993) Natur und Geist Ferrini, C. (1994) ‘On Newton’s demonstration of Kepler’s second law in Hegel’s De orbitis

planetarum (1801)’, Philosophia Naturalis 31(1), pp. 150-170 Burbidge, J.W. (1997) Real Process: How Logic and Chemistry Combine in Hegel’s Philosophy of Nature @ Time McTaggart, ‘Unreality of time’, Mind 17, pp. 457-74 Malabou, C. [1996] The Future of Hegel: Plasticity, Temporality and Dialectic, tr. 2005 @ Life in Hegel’s mature system, plant and animal subjectivity Greene, M. (1987) ‘Natural life and subjectivity’, in P.G. Stillman (ed.) Hegel’s Philosophy of Spirit Malabou, C. [1996] The Future of Hegel: Plasticity, Temporality and Dialectic, tr. 2005 @ Subjective spirit: general (with thanks to Heikki Ikäheimo) Fetcher, I. (1970) Hegels Lehre vom Menschen Petry, M.J. (1978) Introduction to Petry (ed.) Hegel’s Philosophy of Subjective Spirit Stillman, P.G. (ed.) (1987) Hegel’s Philosophy of Spirit deVries, W.A. (1988) Hegel’s Theory of Mental Activity: An Introduction to Theoretical Spirit Eley, L. (ed.) (1990) Hegels Theorie des subjektiven Geistes Hespe, F. and Tuschling, B. (eds.) (1991) Psychologie und Anthropologie oder Philosophie des Geistes Wolff, M. (1992) Das Körper-Seele-Problem Stederoth, D. (2001) Hegels Philosophie des Subjektiven Geistes Halbig, C. (2002) Objektives Denken Henrich, D. (ed.) (1979) Hegels philosophische Psychologie (Hegel-Studien Beiheft 19) @ Soul and feeling, anthropology (On I and self, see ‘Self-consciousness in the Phenomenology’) (On sociality of the self, see ‘Community and individual, sociality of the self in Hegel,’) Greene, M. (1972) Hegel on the Soul: A Speculative Anthropology @ Consciousness, self-consciousness and the I in the Philosophy of Spirit (See also ‘Self-consciousness in the Phenomenology’) Schalhorn, C. (2000) Hegels enzyklopädischer Begriff von Selbstbewusstsein Ikäheimo, H. (2000) Self-Consciousness and Intersubjectivity: A Study on Hegel’s Encyclopedia Philosophy of

Subjective Spirit (1830), also available online @ Universal self-consciousness in the the Philosophy of Spirit (See ‘Recognition and univeral self-consciousness in the the Philosophy of Spirit) @ Theoretical spirit, intentionality, imagination Greene, M. (1972) ‘Hegel’s triadic doctrine of cognitive mind’, Idealistic Studies 2, reprinted in R. Stern

(ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, vol. 4 deVries, W.A. (1988) Hegel’s Theory of Mental Activity: An Introduction to Theoretical Spirit Bates J.A. (2004) Hegel’s Theory of Imagination @ Practical spirit (see ‘Action and will in Hegel’) @ Madness and Hegel (See also ‘Freud, Lacan and Hegel’) @ POLITICS, ETHICS AND HISTORY @ Politics and ethics: texts

Philosophy of Right Preface, §§1, 4-21, 27-33, 36, 41-45, 54, 59, 65, 71-75, 81-82, 102-108, 114, 129-139, 141-157, 158, 181-198, 209, 229-231, 249-250, 256-262, 272-273, 279, 302-303, 324, 330-334 and the remarks and additions (these passages cover all the key points and transitions) (up to §157 incl. is to end of introduction to ethical life)

@ Politics and ethics: introductions (Including Hegel’s substantive political views, and discussions of whether he is a conservative or liberal) Avineri, S. (1968) ‘Hegel revisited’, Journal of Contemporary History 3(2), reprinted in MacIntyre

(ed.) Hegel 1972 (survey of interpretations of Hegel’s political philosophy from his death onwards) Inwood, M. (1983) Hegel, Arguments of the Philosophers, ch. 11 Singer, P. (1983) Hegel Past Masters, ch. 3 (with ch. 2 on philosophy of history) Ottman, H. (1984) ‘Hegel’s Philosophy of Right: changing paradigms for its interpretation’, Clio 13(4) Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, introduction Houlgate, S. (1991) Freedom, Truth and History, ch. 3 Hardimon, M.O. (1992) ‘The project of reconciliation: Hegel’s social philosophy’, Philosophy and Public

Affairs 21(2) Dallmayr, F.R. (1993) G.W.F. Hegel: Modernity and Politics Wood, A. (1993) ‘Hegel’s ethics’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Westphal, K. (1993) ‘The basic context and structure of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The

Cambridge Companion to Hegel Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 1 @ Politics and ethics: guides Avineri, S. (1972) Hegel’s Theory of the Modern State, esp. chs. 5-9 Kainz, H.P. (1974) Hegel’s Philosophy of Right: A Handbook for Students Knowles, D. (2002) Hegel and the Philosophy of Right, Routledge Philosophy Guidebook Rose, D. (2007) Hegel’s Philosophy of Right: A Reader’s Guide @ Politics and ethics: fuller commentaries Bradley, F.H. (1876) Ethical Studies Bosanquet, B. (1899) The Philosophical Theory of the State, available online Reyburn, H.A. (1921) The Ethical Theory of Hegel: A Study of the Philosophy of Right Forster, M. (1935) The Political Philosophies of Plato and Hegel Walsh, W.H. (1969) Hegelian Ethics Avineri, S. (1972) Hegel’s Theory of the Modern State, esp. chs. 5-9 Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983 Weil, E. [1950] Hegel and the State, tr. 1998 Weil, E. (1979) Hegel et la Philosophie de Droit* Riedel, M. (1984) Between Tradition and Revolution: The Hegelian Transformation of Political

Philosophy (translation of Studien zu Hegels Rechtsphilosophie) Steinberger, P.J. (1988) Logic and Politics: Hegel’s Philosophy of Right* Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought Peperzak, A.T. (1991) Hegels praktische philosophie Tunick, M. (1992) Hegel’s Political Philosophy: Reinterpreting the Practice of Legal Punishment Brod, H. (1992) Hegel’s Philosophy of Politics: Idealism, Identity and Modernity* Hardimon, M. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom Franco, P. (2000) Hegel’s Philosophy of Freedom Honneth, A. (2000) Suffering from Indeterminacy: An Attempt at a Reactualization of Hegel’s Philosophy of

Right Peperzak, A.T. (2001) Modern Freedom: Hegel’s Legal, Moral, and Political Philosophy Ormiston A. (2004) Love and Politics: Re-Interpreting Hegel Goldstein, J.D. (2006) Hegel’s Idea of the Good Life: From Virtue to Freedom, Early Writings and Mature

Political Philosophy James, D. (2007) Hegel’s Philosophy of Right: Subjectivity and Ethical Life Brooks, T. (2007) Hegel’s Political Philosophy: A Systematic Reading of the Philosophy of Right* Pippin, R. (2008) Hegel’s Practical Philosophy: Rational Agency as Ethical Life Luther, T. (2009) Hegel’s Critique of Modernity: Reconciling Individual Freedom and the Community Moyar, D. (2011) Hegel’s Conscience

@ Politics and ethics: collections Kaufmann, W. (ed.) (1970) Hegel’s Political Philosophy Pelczynski, Z.A. (ed.) (1971) Hegel’s Political Philosophy (See esp. piece by Ilting) Riedel, M. (ed.) (1974-75) Materialien zu Hegels Rechtsphilosophie, 2 vols Verene, D.P. (ed.) (1980) Hegel’s Social and Political Thought Henrich, D. and Horstmann, R.-P. (eds.) (1982) Hegels Philosophie des Rechts: Die Theorie der Rechtsformen

und ihre Logik Pelczynski, Z.A. (ed.) (1984) The State and Civil Society (See esp. pieces by Pelczynski, Hartmann) Cornell, D. et al. (eds.) (1991) Hegel and Legal Theory Stern, R. (ed.) (1993) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments, volume 4, section on political philosophy Kotkavirta, J. (ed.) (1997) Right, Morality, Ethical Life: Studies in G.W.F. Hegel’s Philosophy of Right Siep, L. (ed.) (1997) Hegel: Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts Williams, R.R. (ed.) (2001) Beyond Liberalism and Communitarianism: Studies in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right Pippin R. and Höffe O. (eds.) (2004) Hegel on Ethics and Politics @ Politics and ethics: early development (See ‘Jena writings (politics, ethics and religion)’) @ Normative stance, the Doppelsatz (the rational is real), positive right vs. natural right, ethics and reason (The underlying basis for Hegel’s ethics: whether it is Aristotelian, legal-positivist (Machtstaat-ist),

communitarian, historical-movement-based, or freedom-and-rationality based (Rechtstaat-ist)) (Including discussions of and the Preface to the Philosophy of Right as a whole) (However for freedom-based accounts see ‘Freedom and free will as the basis of the Philosophy of Right ‘) (See also ‘Ethical substance’ and ‘Ethical life’) (For ‘Religion and the state’ see that) (For Hegel’s substantive political views see ‘Politics and ethics: introductions’) The German Constitution, introduction Encyclopaedia Logic §§6, 142 Lectures on Natural Right §1, pp. 319-321 Philosophy of Right preface (esp. footnote on laws of nature and right, and last four pages), §§ 3, 211-214, 258A,

270R (see Nisbet (ed.) p. 294), 273R Reason in History p. 53 Lectures on the History of Philosophy, section on Plato’s political philosophy Reyburn, H.A. (1921) The Ethical Theory of Hegel Löwith, K. [1941] From Hegel to Nietzsche, tr. D. Green, 1964, pp. 135-50 Weil, E. (1951) Hegel et l’Etat Ritter, J. [1956] ‘Morality and ethical life: Hegel’s controversy with Kantian ethics’ in Hegel and the French

Revolution: Essays on the Philosophy of Right Plamenatz, J. (1963) Man and Society vol. 2 pp. 216-241 Ilting, K.-H. (1963-64) ‘Hegels Auseinandersetzung mit der aristotelischen Politik’, Philosophisches Jahrbuch 71 Pelczynski , Z.A. (1964) ‘Introduction’ to Hegel’s Political Writings (V.Roupa: clear statement of Rechtstaatist

view) Walsh, W.H. (1969) Hegelian Ethics Marini, G. (1977) ‘La polemica con la scuola storica nell “Filosifia del diritto” hegeliana’, Rivista di Filosofia 7-

8-9, pp. 169-204 (see section 2) Tugendhat, E. [1979] Self-Consciousness and Self-Determination, tr. 1986 Peperzak, A.T. (1983) ‘The foundations of ethics according to Hegel’, International Philosophical Quarterly 23 Stillman, P.G. (1986) ‘A critique of ideal worlds: Hegel and Marx on modern utopian thought’ in G.S. del Buffa

and A.O. Lewis (eds.) Utopie per Gli Anni Ottanta: Studi Interdisciplinari sui temi, la storia, i progetti (Rome: Gangemi)

Peperzak, A.T. (1987) Philosophy and Politics: A Commentary on the Preface to Hegel’s ‘Philosophy of Right’ Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, introduction, chs. 11-12 Lucas, H.-C. (1993) ‘The identification of Vernunft with Wirklichkeit in Hegel’, Owl of Minerva 25(1)* Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 2 sec. 2 ‘The Doppelsatz’ Chitty, A. (1996) ‘On Hegel, the subject and political justification’, Res Publica 2(2) Kaufman, A. (1997) ‘Hegel and the ontological critique of liberalism’, American Political Science Review 91(4) Brod, H. (1992) Hegel’s Philosophy of Politics, ch. 2 O’Neill, O. (1988) ‘Ethical reasoning and ideological pluralism’, Ethics 98 Tunick, M. (1994) ‘Hegel’s nonfoundationalism’, History of Philosophy Quarterly 11(3) Jackson, M.W. (1996) ‘Hegel: the rational and the real’, in J. Stewart (ed.) The Hegel Myths and Legends

Sayers, S. (1998) Marxism and Human Nature, chs 6-9 Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, ch. 1 Stern, R. (2006) ‘Hegel’s Doppelsatz: a neutral reading’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 44(2) @ Philosophy of Right: method and structure (For relations between Philosophy of Right and Logic see ‘metaphysics of Hegel: social-Kantian interpretations’) Ilting, K.-H. (1971) ‘The structure of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, in Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s Political

Philosophy Ilting, K.-H. (1982) ‘Rechtsphilosophie als Phänomenologie des Bewußtseins der Freiheit’, in Henrich and

Horstmann eds Mitias, M.H. (1984) The Moral Foundation of the State in Hegel’s ‘Philosophy of Right’: Anatomy of an

Argument Markus, G. (1997) ‘Political philosophy as phenomenology: on the method of Hegel’s Philosophy of

Right’, Thesis Eleven 48 @ Philosophy of Right and Logic (With thanks to Charlotte Daub) (See also ‘Will: its logical structure’, ‘Metaphysics of Hegel: social-Kantian interpretations’) Fulda, H.F. (1968) Recht der Philosophie in Hegels Philosophie des Rechts Ilting, K.-H. (1975) ‘Zur Dialektik in der Rechtsphilosophie’, Hegel-Jahrbuch 1975 Gottfried, P. (1980) ‘On the social implications and context of dialectics’, Journal of the History of Ideas 41 Henrich, D. and Horstmann, R.-P. (eds.) (1982) Hegels Philosophie des Rechts. Die Theorie der Rechtsformen

und ihre Logik Steinberger, P.J. (1988) Logic and Politics: Hegel’s Philosophy of Right Richardson, H.S. (1989) ‘The logical structure of Sittlichkeit: a reading of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’,

in Idealistic Studies 19 Such, J. (2000) ‘Hegel’s category of totality and his concept of the state’, in Hegel-Jahrbuch 2000 Peperzak, A.T. (2001) Modern Freedom: Hegel’s Legal, Moral, and Political Philosophy, ch. 1 Henrich, D. (2004) ‘Logical form and real totality: the authentic conceptual form of Hegel’s concept of the state’,

in R. Pippin and O. Höffe (eds.) Hegel on Ethics and Politics, 2004 @ Hartmann on the Philosophy of Right (And work on Philosophy of Right as social theory) Hartmann, K. (1971) ‘What is a social category?’ Idealistic Studies 1(1) Hartmann, K. (1984) ‘Towards a new systematic reading of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in Pelczynski (ed.) The

State and Civil Society, also in Hartmann’s Studies in Foundational Philosophy 1988 Bubner, R. [1984] ‘Hegel’s significance for the social sciences’, in R.S. Cohen and M.W. Wartofsky (eds.) Hegel

and the Sciences Pinkard, T. (1986) ‘Freedom and social categories in Hegel’s ethics’, Philosophy and Phenomenological

Research 47(2), reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 7 @ Pippin on Hegel’s social philosophy (Including his account of freedom in Hegel) Pippin, R. (1979) ‘The rose and the owl: some remarks on the theory-practice problem in Hegel’, Independent

Journal of Philosophy 3 Pippin, R. (1981) ‘Hegel’s political argument and the problem of Verwirklichung’, Political Theory 9 Pippin, R.B. (1989) Hegel’s Idealism: The Satisfactions of Self-Consciousness* Pippin, R.B. (1991) Modernity as a Philosophical Problem, ch. 3 Pippin, R.B. (1991) ‘Hegel, ethical reasons, Kantian rejoinders’, Philosophical Topics 19(2), reprinted in

Pippin’s Idealism as Modernism: Hegelian Variations Pippin, R. (1991) ‘Hegel, modernity and Habermas’, The Monist, 74(3), reprinted in his Idealism as Modernism:

Hegelian Variations, 1997 Pippin, R.C. (1991) ‘Idealism and agency in Kant and Hegel’, Journal of Philosophy 88 Pippin, R. (1993) ‘You can’t get from there to here: transition problems in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, in

F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Pippin, R.B. (1995) ‘Hegel on the rationality and priority of ethical life’, Neue Hefte für Philosophie 35, reprinted

as ‘Hegel’s ethical rationalism’ in Pippin’s Idealism as Modernism: Hegelian Variations, 1997 Pippin, R.B. (1997) ‘Hegel, freedom, the will: the Philosophy of Right §§1-33’, in L. Siep (ed.) Hegel:

Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts

Pippin, R.B. (1999) ‘Naturalness and mindedness: Hegels compatibilism’, with a comment by Richard Rorty, European Journal of Philosophy 7(2)

Pippin, R.B. (2000) ‘What is the question for which Hegel’s theory of recognition is the answer?’, European Journal of Philosophy 8(2)

Pippin, R. (2004) ‘Recognition and reconciliation: actualized agency in Hegel’s Phenomenology, in K. Ameriks and J. Stolzenberg (eds.) Internationales Jahrbuch des Deutschen Idealismus, vol. 2, reprinted in K. Deligiorgi (ed.) Hegel: New Directions, 2006, reprinted in B. van den Brink and D. Owen (eds.) Recognition and Power: Axel Honneth and the Tradition of Critical Social Theory, 2007

* Pippin, R. (2008) Hegel’s Practical Philosophy: Rational Agency as Ethical Life Pippin, R. (2011) Hegel on Self-Consciousness: Desire and Death in the Phenomenology of Spirit, partly

reprinted in H. Ikäheimo and A. Laitinen (eds) Recognition and Social Ontology, 2011 Deranty, J.P. (2011) ‘Rationality, autonomy and the social bond: models of Hegelian recognition and their

implications for social and political theory’, Philosophy Today, Spring 2011 O’Connor, B. (2012) ‘The Neo-Hegelian theory of freedom and the limits of emancipation’, European Journal of

Philosophy (pre-publication) @ Freedom in Hegel: general (See also ‘Freedom as social’, ‘Action and will in Hegel’) (For freedom as the normative foundation for Hegel’s political philosophy see ‘Freedom and free will as the basis

of the Philosophy of Right ‘) Philosophy of Right, Introduction (especially §§10-22), §260 Lectures on the Philosophy of World History: Introduction, tr. Nisbet, pp. 93-101, 145-9 Philosophy of History, tr. Sibree, pp. 37-43, 442-449 Philosophy of Spirit §§483-486 (in Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind) Dyde, S.W. (1894) ‘Hegel’s conception of freedom’, Philosophical Review 3(6) Berlin, I. (1958) Two Concepts of Liberty (pamphlet), reprinted in Four Essays on Liberty 1969 Riedel, M. (1971) ‘Nature and freedom in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s Political

Philosophy, reprinted as ‘Laws of nature and laws of right’, ch. 3 of Riedel’s Between Tradition and Revolution 1984

Schacht, R. (1972) ‘Hegel on freedom’, in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays Tugendhat, E. [1979] Self-Consciousness and Self-Determination, tr. 1986, lectures 13-14 Siep, L. (1992) ‘Der Freifeitsbegriff der praktischen Philosophie Hegels in Jena’, in his Praktische Philosophie im

Deutschen Idealismus Houlgate, S. (1995) ‘The unity of theoretical and practical spirit in Hegel’s concept of freedom’, Review of

Metaphysics 48 (4)* Franco, P. (2000) Hegel’s Philosophy of Freedom* Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom Dudley, W. (2002) Hegel, Nietzsche, and Philosophy: Thinking Freedom+Houlgate, S. (2005) An Introduction to Hegel: Freedom, Truth and History (2nd ed. of his Freedom, Truth and

History, 1991), ch. 8 Beiser, F.C. (2005) Hegel, ch. 9+ Matarrese, C. (2007) ‘Hegel’s theory of freedom’, Philosophical Compass 2(2) Yeomans, C. (2012) Freedom and Reflection: Hegel and the Logic of Agency @ Freedom and recognition in Hegel (The idea that individuals become free through mutual recognition) (For Pippin’s version of this claim see ‘Pippin on Hegel’s social philosophy’) (For Brandom’s version see ‘Brandom on Hegel’) (For Honneth’s version see ‘Honneth on Hegel’) (For other contemporary versions of the idea that freedom is the result of recogntion see ‘Recognition as

ontological’) (See also ‘Recognition in the Philosophy of Right’, ‘Ethical substance’) Westphal, M. (1980) ‘Hegel’s theory of the concept’, in W.E. Steinkraus and K.I. Schmidt (eds.) Art and

Logic in Hegel’s Philosophy, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Winfield, R.D. (1983) ‘Freedom as interaction: Hegel’s resolution to the dilemma of liberal theory’, in

Stepelevich and Lamb (eds.) Hegel’s Philosophy of Action, reprinted in Winfield’s Freedom and Modernity Gadacz, T. (1987) ‘Freedom as reconciliation: the essence of the individual’s freedom in the philosophy of

Hegel’, International Philosophical Quarterly 27 Smith, S. (1989) Hegel’s Critique of Liberalism: Rights in Context

Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, ch. 2 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology: The Sociality of Reason, ch. 5 Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, pp. 80-88, 122-32* Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Theory of Freedom, esp. chs. 2-4, 6* Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom, esp. chs. 1 and 3-5 McCarney, J. (2000) Hegel on History, Routledge Philosophy Guidebook, ch. 5 ‘Freedom’ Baynes, K. (2002) ‘Freedom and recognition in Hegel and Habermas’, Philosophy & Social Criticism 28(1),

section 1 Sinnerbrink, R. (2004) ‘Recognitive freedom: Hegel and the problem of recognition’, Critical Horizons 5(1) Ikäheimo, H. (2010) ‘Making the best of what we are: recognition as an ontological and ethical concept’, in H.-C.

Schmidt am Busch and C. Zurn (eds) The Philosophy of Recognition: Historical and Critical Perspectives Ikäheimo, H. (2011) ‘Holism and normative essentialism in Hegel’s social ontology’, in H. Ikäheimo and A.

Laitinen (eds) Recognition and Social Ontology @ Freedom and determinism (Also, freedom and inclinations, relation of spirit to nature, Hegel on the mind-body problem) Philosophy of Spirit §§381, 388-9* Parkinson, G.H.R. (1970-71) ‘Hegel’s concept of freedom’, Royal Institute of Philosophy Lectures, Vol. 5: 1970-

71: Reason and Reality, reprinted in M. Inwood (ed.) Hegel* Schacht, R. (1972) ‘Hegel on freedom’, in MacIntyre (ed.) Hegel: A Collection of Critical Essays Pippin, R.B. (1997) ‘Hegel, freedom, the will: The Philosophy of Right §§1-33’, in L. Siep (ed.) Hegel:

Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts Pippin, R.B. (1999) ‘Naturalness and mindedness: Hegels compatibilism’, with a comment by Richard

Rorty, European Journal of Philosophy 7(2) Yeomans, C. (2012) Freedom and Reflection: Hegel and the Logic of Agency @ Freedom and free will as the basis of the Philosophy of Right, constructivism in Hegel (For recognitive constructivism in Hegel see ‘Recognition in the Philosophy of Right’) (See also ‘Rousseau and Hegel’, ‘Substantial will’, ‘Will: its logical structure’) (Hegel can be seen as a constructivist either in that he derives right ‘regressively’ as the necessary condition of

agency or will or freedom (e.g. Westphal) or ‘expressively’ in that he derives it as the necessary expression of agency or will or freedom (e.g. Maletz))

(For discusssions limited to property, see ‘Property’) (For principle of subjective freedom, see ‘Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom, individuality,

autonomy’) (For critique of Hegel as a totalitarian see ‘ Totalitarianism, authoritarianism, nationalism and Prussianism in

Hegel’) Bosanquet, B. (1899) The Philosophical Theory of the State, ch. 8 sec. 4 ‘Freedom in Hegel’s Philosophy of

Right’ (pp. 247-52), ch. 9 sec. 8 ‘The state proper’ and following two sections (pp. 280-95) Weil, E. [1950] Hegel and the State, tr. 1998 (in ‘Politics and ethics: commentaries’) Riley, P. (1975) ‘Hegel on consent and social contract theory: how does he ‘cancel and preserve’ the

will?’, Western Political Quarterly 26(1) Pippin, R.B. (1981) ‘Hegel’s political argument and the problem of Verwirklichung’, Political Theory 9(4) Riley, P. (1982) Will and Political Legitimacy, ch. on Hegel Winfield, R.D. (1983) ‘Freedom as interaction: Hegel’s resolution to the dilemma of liberal theory’, in

Stepelevich and Lamb (eds.) Hegel’s Philosophy of Action, reprinted in Winfield’s Freedom and Modernity Maletz, D.J. (1985) ‘An introduction to Hegel’s “Introduction” to the “Philosophy of

Right”‘, Interpretation 13, reprinted in D. Lamb (ed.) Hegel, 1988 Westphal, K. (1993) ‘The basic context and structure of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The

Cambridge Companion to Hegel+ Maletz, D.J. (1989) ‘Hegel on right as actualized will’, Political Theory 17(1) Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 3 Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, chs. 2-4, 6* Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom* Franco, P. (2000) Hegel’s Philosophy of Freedom, esp. ch. 5 Peperzak, A.T. (2001) Modern Freedom: Hegel’s Legal, Moral, and Political Philosophy Cristi, R. (2005) Hegel on Freedom and Authority @ Action in Hegel

(See also ‘Freedom in Hegel’, ‘Freedom and determinism’ and ‘Duty, desire and feelings’, ‘Freedom as social’, ‘Slavery in Hegel’, ‘Will: its logical structure’)

Philosophy of Spirit §§471-478 (in Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind) Philosophy of Right, introduction, §§105-125 Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals, beginning of section 3 (Kant’s account of negative and positive

freedom) Wiehl, R. (1971) ‘Über den Handlungsbegriff als Kategorie der Hegelschen Ästhetik’ Derbolav, J. (1975) ‘Hegels Begriff der Handlung’ Mercier-Josa, S. (1976) ‘Après Aristote et Adam Smith que dit Hegel de l’agir?’, Les Études Philosophiques 3 Taylor, C. (197?) ‘Hegel’s philosophy of mind’, reprinted in Human Agency and Language: Philosophical Papers

1, 1985 Inwood, M. (1982) ‘Hegel on action’, in G. Vesey (ed.) Idealism Past and Present Stepelevich, L. and Lamb, D. (eds.) (1983) Hegel’s Philosophy of Action Taylor, C. (1983) ‘Hegel and the philosophy of action’, in Stepelevich, L.S. and Lamb, D. (eds.) Hegel’s

Philosophy of Action (eds.) Pelczynski, Z.A. (1984) ‘Freedom in Hegel’, in Z.A. Pelczynski and J. Gray (eds.) Conceptions of Freedom in

Political Philosophy Murray, P.T. (1991) Hegel’s Philosophy of Mind and Will Quante, M. [1993] Hegel’s Concept of Action, tr. 2004 Pendlebury, G. (2006) Action and Ethics in Aristotle and Hegel: Escaping the Malign Influence of Kant Pippin, R. (2008) Hegel’s Practical Philosophy: Rational Agency as Ethical Life Yeomans, C. (2012) Freedom and Reflection: Hegel and the Logic of Agency @ Reasons for action in Hegel Laden, A.S. (2005), “Evaluating social reasons: Hobbes vs. Hegel”, Journal of Philosophy 102(7) @ Will: its logical structure (For the universality of the will see ‘Substantial will, objective will, universal will’) Westphal, M. (1980) ‘Hegel’s theory of the concept’, in W.E. Steinkraus and K.I. Schmidt (eds.) Art and Logic in

Hegel’s Philosophy, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 3 Maletz, D.J. (1985) ‘The meaning of ‘will’ in Hegel’s “Philosophy of Right”‘, Interpretation 13, reprinted in D.

Lamb (ed.) Hegel, 1988 Quante, M. (1997) ‘Personal autonomy and the structure of the will’, in J. Kotkavirta (ed.) Right, Morality,

Ethical Life: Studies in G.W.F. Hegel’s Philosophy of Right Pippin, R.B. (1997) ‘Hegel, freedom, the will: the Philosophy of Right §§1-33’, in L. Siep (ed.) Hegel:

Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts Quante, M. [1997] ‘The personality of the will as the principle of abstract right: an analysis of §§ 34-40 of

Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, in terms of the logical structure of the concept’, in R. Pippin and O. Höffe (eds) Hegel on Ethics and Politics, 2004

Dudley, W. (2000) ‘A limited kind of freedom: Hegel’s logical analysis of the finitude of the will’, Owl of Minerva, 31(2)

@ Savigny (and the historical school of law) and Hegel (For Savigny and Hegel on possession, see ‘Possession’) (For Savigny in general see A Marx bibliography: ‘Savigny’) Philosophy of Right, Preface pp. 16-17 (CUP edition), §§ 3R, 211R, 212R, 215R, 216R Jaeger, H. (1967) ‘Savigny et Marx’, Archives de Philosophie du Droit 12, pp. 65-89; see pp. 82-83 Marini, G. (1977) ‘La polemica con la scuola storica nell “Filosifia del diritto” hegeliana’, Rivista di Filosofia 7-

8-9, pp. 169-204 Marini, G. (1980) ‘Il rapporto Savigny-Hegel nella storiografia recente’, Quaderni fiorentini per la storia del

pensiero giuridico moderno 9, pp. 113ff Schild, W. (1978-79) ‘Savigny und Hegel’, Anales de la Catedra Francisco Suarez 18-19, pp. 321-340 Schiavone, A. (1984) Alle Origini del Diritto Borghese: Hegel Contro Savigny Becchi, P. (1984) ‘Hegel e Savigny’, Materiali per una storia della cultura giuidica 14(2), pp. 463-470 @ Duty, desire and feelings in Hegel (For this in relation to Kant specifically, see ‘Kant’s ethics: Hegel’s critique of its formalism’) Lectures on the Philosophy of World History: Introduction, tr. Nisbet, pp. 68-93 Philosophy of Mind §478 Philosophy of Right §149

Butler, J. (1987) Subjects of Desire, ch. 1 Pippin, R.B. (1997) ‘Hegel, freedom, the will: The Philosophy of Right §§1-33’, in Hegel: Grundlinien der

Philosophie des Rechts (ed.) L. Siep Wildt, A. (1982) Autonomie und Anerkennung: Hegels Moralitätskritik im Lichte seiner Fichte-Rezeption, part 1 Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, ch. 2 esp. secs. 1-3 @ Abstract right Brudner, A. (1991) ‘Hegel and the crisis of private law’ in D. Cornell et al. (eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory Weinrib, E.J. (1991) ‘Right and advantage in private law’, in D. Cornell et al. (eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory @ Property and contract (general) (See also ‘Social contract theory: Hegel’s critique’) (See also ‘Property and contract: recogintion-centred accounts’) (For Kant on property see A social and political philosophy bibliography: ‘Kant on possession and property’) (For Savigny on possession see A Marx bibliography: ‘Savigny on possession’) Reyburn, H.A. (1921) The Ethical Theory of Hegel, ch. 6 Marcuse, H. (1941) Reason and Revolution, 2nd ed., part 1 ch. 6* Ritter, J. [1962] ‘Person and property: on Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, paragraphs 34-81’, in Hegel and the

French Revolution: Essays on the Philosophy of Right Teichgraeber, R. (1977) ‘Hegel on property and poverty’, Journal of the History of Ideas 38 Stillman, P.G. (1980) ‘Person, property and civil society in the Philosophy of Right’, in Verene (ed.) Hegel’s

Social and Political Thought Stillman, P.G. (1980) ‘Property, freedom and individuality in Hegel’s and Marx’s political thought’, in J.R.

Pennock and J.W. Chapman (eds.) NOMOS XXII: Property Piper, A. (1980) ‘Property and the limits of the self’, Political Theory 8, also Stillman, P.G. (1980) ‘Property, freedom and individuality in Hegel’s and Marx’s political thought’, in J.R.

Pennock (ed.) Property Berry, C.J. (1980) ‘Property and possession: two replies to Locke—Hume and Hegel’, in J.R. Pennock and J.W.

Chapman (eds.) Nomos XXII: Property Ilting, K.-H. (1982) ‘Rechtsphilosophie al Phänomenologie des Bewußtseins der Freiheit’ in D. Henrich and R.-P.

Horstmann (eds.) Hegels Philosophie des Rechts Radin, M.J. (1981-82) ‘Property and personhood’, Stanford Law Review 34 Knowles, D. (1983) ‘Hegel on property and personality’, Philosophical Quarterly 33:130 Ryan, A. (1984) Property and Political Theory, ch. 5 Ryan, A. (1984) ‘Hegel on work, ownership and citizenship’, in Pelczynski (ed.) The State and Civil Society Davis, R.A. (1987) ‘Property and labor in Hegel’s concept of freedom’, in W. Maker (ed.) Hegel on Economics

and Freedom Waldron, J. (1988) The Right to Private Property, ch. 10 (but see also the review of Waldron by A.

Carter, Philosophical Books 31, 1990, pp. 129-136) Davis, R.A. (1989) ‘The conjunction of property and freedom in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, Zeitschrift fur

philosophische Forshung 43(1), pp. 111-123 Benson, P. (1991) ‘The priority of abstract right and constructivism in Hegel’s legal philosophy’, in D. Cornell et

al. (eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory Stillman, P.G. (1991) ‘Property, contract and ethical life in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in D. Cornell et al.

(eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory Becchi, P (1991) ‘Ein Fragment Hegels über Savigny. Zur Geschichte der Besitzlehre am Anfang des 19.

Jahrhunderts’, Zeitschrift für neuere Rechtsgeschichte 13 Patten, A. (1995) ‘Hegel’s justification of private property’, History of Political Thought 16(4), revised as ch. 5 of

his Hegel’s Idea of Freedom 1999 Lampert, J. (1997) ‘Locke, Fichte, and Hegel on the right to property’, in M. Bauer and J. Russon (eds.) Hegel

and the Tradition: Essays in Honor of H.S. Harris Knowles, D. (2002) Hegel and the Philosophy of Right, Routledge Philosophy Guidebook, ch. 5 Quante, M. (2004) ‘The personality of the will as the principle of abstract right: an analysis of §§ 34-40 of

Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, in terms of the logical structure of the concept’, in R. Pippin and O. Höffe (eds) Hegel on Ethics and Politics, 2004

@ Property and contract: recognition-centred accounts (Including the problem of the apparent individualism in Hegel’s account of property) Ilting, K.-H. (1971) ‘The structure of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, in Z. Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s Political

Philosophy

Landau, P. (1975) ‘Hegels Begrundung des Vertragsrechts’, in M. Riedel (ed.) Materialien zu Hegels Rechtsphilosophie, vol. 2

Ilting, K.-H. (1982) ‘Rechtsphilosophie als Phänomenologie des Bewußtseins der Freiheit’, in D. Henrich and R.-P. Horstmann (eds.) Hegels Philosophie des Rechts

Siep, L. (1982) ‘Intersubjektivität, Recht und Staat in Hegels ‘“Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts”‘, in D. Henrich and R.-P. Horstmann (eds.) Hegels Philosophie des Rechts

Siep, L. (1984) ‘Person and law in Kant and Hegel’, Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal 10 Benhabib, S. (1984) ‘Obligation, contract and exchange: on the significance of Hegel’s abstract right’, in Z.A.

Pelczynski (ed.) The State and Civil Society Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, chs. 4-5* Patten, A. (1995) ‘Hegel’s justification of private property’, History of Political Thought 16(4), revised as ch. 5 of

his Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, 1999 (see especially section 5) Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, ch. 7 ‘Persons, property and contract’ Skorupski, J. (1999) ‘Freedom, morality and recognition: Some theses of Kant and Hegel’ in his Ethical

Explorations Knowles, D. (2002) Hegel and the Philosophy of Right, Routledge Philosophy Guidebook, ch. 4 Schmidt am Busch, H.-C. (2008) ‘Personal respect, private property, and market economy: what critical theory

can learn from Hegel’, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 11(5) @ Human rights in Hegel (With thanks to Neil Stammers) Hinchman, L.P. (1984) ‘The origins of human rights: a Hegelian perspective’, Western Political Quarterly 37(1) Douzinas, C. (2000) The End of Human Rights: Critical Legal Thought at the Turn of the Century Cannon, B. (2001) Rethinking the Normative Content of Critical Theory: Marx, Habermas and Beyond @ Crime and punishment (With thanks to Chris Bennett) MacTaggart, J.M.E. [1899] ‘Hegel’s theory of punishment’, in G. Ezorsky (ed.) Philosophical Perspectives on

Punishment 1972, revised and extended as ch. 5 of MacTaggart’s Studies in Hegelian Cosmology 1901 Stillman, P.G. (1975) ‘Hegel’s idea of punishment’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 14(2) Nicholson, P.P. (1982) ‘Hegel on crime’, Journal of the History of Political Thought 3(2) Hinchman, L.P. (1982) ‘Hegel’s theory of crime and punishment’, Review of Politics 44(4) Steinberger, P.J. (1983) ‘Hegel on crime and punishment’, American Political Science Review 77(4) Primoratz, I. (1989) Justifying Legal Punishment, ch. 4 Tunick, M. (1992) Hegel’s Political Philosophy: Reinterpreting the Practice of Legal Punishment Vogel, U. (1997) ‘Loss of recognition and self-subsumation - Hegel’s theories of punishment’, Hegel-Studien 32

(in German) Skorupski, J. (1999) ‘Freedom, morality and recognition: Some theses of Kant and Hegel’ in his Ethical

Explorations @ Morality (Moralität) Ritter, J. [1956] ‘Morality and ethical life: Hegel’s controversy with Kantian ethics’ in Hegel and the French

Revolution: Essays on the Philosophy of Right Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, chs. 7-8 Wood, A. (1997) ‘Hegel’s critique of morality’, in L. Siep (ed.) Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts.

Klassiker Auslegen Moyar, D. (2011) Hegel’s Conscience @ Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom, individuality, autonomy, liberalism and Hegel (Including reconciliation of this with membership of state and citizenship) (See also ‘Enlightenment vs. faith’, ‘Modernity and Hegel’, ‘Community and individual, sociality of the self in

Hegel’) Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Haldane and Simpson, vol. 2 pp. 114-5 Philosophy of Right, Preface (CUP edition) p. 20, §§117, 118A, 120, 124R, 132, 185R,A, 206, 258R (CUP

edition p. 277), 260, 261R,A, 262A, 316A, 355R Pippin, R.C. (1991) ‘Hegel, ethical reasons, Kantian rejoinders’, Philosophical Topics 19(2), reprinted in

Pippin’s Idealism as Modernism: Hegelian Variations Losurdo, D. [1992] Hegel and The Freedom of Moderns, tr. 2004 Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 1 sec. 4 part 3 (pp. 32-37)

and ch. 5 ‘Individuality and social membership’

Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom, chs. 3, 7 Taylor, M.C. (1981) Journeys to Selfhood: Hegel and Kierkegaard Chitty, A. (1996) ‘On Hegel, the subject and political justification’, Res Publica 2(2) Franco, P. (1997) ‘Hegel and liberalism’, Review of Politics 59(4) Cristi, R. (2006) ‘Marx’s critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right: a critique’, in D. Moggach (ed.) The New

Hegelians: Politics and Philosophy in the Hegelian School James, D. (2007) Hegel’s Philosophy of Right: Subjectivity and Ethical Life Quante, M. and Schweikard, D.P. (2009) ‘Leading a universal life’: the systematic relevance of Hegel’s social

philosophy’, History of the Human Sciences 22(1) @ Bifurcation (See also ‘Kant and Hegel: general’, ‘Modernity and Hegel’) (See also ‘History (philosophy of)’) (This is the theme of the feeling/thinking and subject/object divisions in general) (See also ‘Duty, desire and feelings in Hegel’) (See also ‘Reason, understanding and intuition’) (See also ‘Kant’s ethics: Hegel’s critique of it in general’ and ‘Kant’s epistemology and metaphysics: Hegel’s

critique’) (See also ‘Enlightenment vs. faith’) (For the public/private bifurcation see ‘state and the value of community’) The Difference Between Fichte’s and Schelling’s System of Philosophy c. pp. 83-89+ Introductory Lectures on Aesthetics, Penguin, pp. 58-60 ‘Reason and religious truth’, foreword to H. Hinrich Religion in its Inner Relation to Science, in F. Weiss

(ed.) Beyond Epistemology: New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, pp. 227-244 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 1+ Plant, R. (1997) Hegel, The Great Philosophers, pp. 11-29 @ Conscience and virtue (Including conscience in the Phenomenology) Buchwalter, A. (1992) ‘Hegel’s concept of virtue’, Political Theory 20* Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, ch. 10 Bernstein, J.M. (1996) ‘Confession and forgiveness: Hegel’s poetics of action’, in R. Eldridge (ed.) Beyond

Representation Sembou, E. (2003) ‘Hegel’s idea of a struggle for recognition: the Phenomenology of Spirit’, History of Political

Thought 24(2) (in ‘Spirit: intersubjective and collective-subject interpretations’) @ Ethical life, i.e. Sittlichkeit (Discussions specifically of the role of ethical life (Sittlichkeit) in the Philosophy of Right, and its contrast

with Moralität) (See also ‘Bildung and education’) (For general discussions of Hegel’s synthesis of community and individualism see ‘Community and individual,

sociality of the self in Hegel’) (For the will that underlies ethical life see ‘Substantial will’) (For discussions of whether Hegel grounds his ethics in existing community practices, i.e. is a

‘nonfoundationalist’, see ‘Normative stance, the rational is real, ethics and reason’) Phenomenology §§347-350 Philosophy of Right, introduction to ‘Ethical life’ Philosophy of Mindt §§513-516 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 14 ‘Ethical substance’ Habermas, J. [1976] ‘The development of normative structures’ in Communication and the Evolution of Society Siep, L. (1983) ‘The Aufhebung of morality in ethical life’ in L. Stepelevich and D. Lamb (eds.) Hegel’s

Philosophy of Action Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, chs. 11-12 Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, chs. 5-6 Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom, chs. 3-5 @ Community and individual, sociality of the self in Hegel (This is the general issue of the relation between the social whole and individuals, and of priority of the former to

the latter) (Including romantic and organicist political thought and Hegel)

(See also ‘Social contract theory: Hegel’s critique’) (See also ‘Ethical life’) (See also ‘Self-consciousness in the Phenomenology’) (See also ‘Soul and feeling, anthropology’) (See also ‘Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom’) (See also ‘Freedom as social’) Philosophy of Right §§142-157 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 14 ‘Ethical substance’ Thomas, P. (1980) Karl Marx and the Anarchists, ch. 1 ‘Hegelian roots’* Pelczynski, Z.A. (1984) ‘Political community and individual freedom in Hegel’, in Pelczynski (ed.) The State and

Civil Society Ilting, K.-H. (1984) ‘Hegel’s concept of the state and Marx’s early critique’, in Z.A. Pelczynski (ed.) The State

and Civil Society Beiser, F.C. (1992) Enlightenment, Revolution and Romanticism: The Genesis of Modern German Political

Thought 1790-1800, chs. 8-11+ Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 5 Larmore, C. (1996) The Romantic Legacy Chitty, A. (1996) ‘On Hegel, the subject and political justification’, Res Publica 2(2) Williams, R.R. (ed.) (2001) Beyond Liberalism and Communitarianism: Studies in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right Tunick, M. (2001) ‘Hegel on political identity and the ties that bind’, in R.R. Williams (ed.) Beyond Liberalism

and Communitarianism: Studies in Hegel’s ‘Philosophy of Right’ Luther, T. (2009) Hegel’s Critique of Modernity: Reconciling Individual Freedom and the Community @ Social role and sense of self (Selbstgefühl) in Hegel (Including recognition of oneself as a particular being) Philosophy of Right §§158, 162, 261R Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 6 Hardimon, M.O. (1994) ‘Role obligations’, Journal of Philosophy 91 Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom, ch. 3 sec. 2 (pp. 93-102) @ Ethical substance: substantialist vs. intersubjective interpretations (For the parallel discussions about the nature of spirit, see ‘Spirit’) (See also ‘Recognition in the Philosophy of Right’) Bosanquet, B. (1899) The Philosophical Theory of the State, MacMillan, pp.192-199 Theunissen, M. [1965] The Other: Studies in the Social Ontology of Husserl, Heidegger, Sartre and Buber, 2nd

German (ed.) 1977, trans. 1984, see pp. 88ff, 150ff Theunissen, M. (1975) ‘Begriff und Realität’, in Denken im Schatten des Nihilismus Siep, L. (1979) Anerkennung als Prinzip der Praktischen Philosophie: Untersuchungen zu Hegels Jenaer

Philosophie des Geistes, pp. 285 ff Theunissen, M. [1982] ‘The repressed intersubjectivity in Hegel’s philosophy of right’, in D. Cornell et al.

(eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory 1991 Hösle, V. (1987) Hegels System. Der Idealismus der Subjectivität und das Problem der Intersubjectivität [Hegel’s

System: The Idealism of Subjectivity and the Problem of Intersubjectivity], 2 vols @ Social contract theory: Hegel’s critique (Including the question of ‘methodological atomism’, whether for Hegel the good or end of the social whole can

be reduced to the good of individuals prior to their membership of it) (See also ‘Ethical life’ and ‘Rousseau and Hegel’) (See also ‘Principle of subjectivity or subjective freedom’) Encyclopaedia Logic §98A Ritter, J. [1962] ‘Person and property: on Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, paragraphs 34-81’, in Hegel and the

French Revolution: Essays on the Philosophy of Right Stillman, P.G. (1974) ‘Hegel’s critique of liberal theories of right’, American Political Science Review 68(3) Losurdo, D. [19?] Hegel et les libéraux, tr. into French 1992 Smith, S. (1989) Hegel’s Critique of Liberalism: Rights in Context Williams, R.R. (1997) Hegel’s Ethics of Recognition, ch. 12 ‘Recognition and the social contract theory of the

state’ Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, ch. 4, secs. 1-2 Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom, pp. 37-52, ch. 6

* Patten, A. (2001) ‘Social contract theory and the concept of recognition in Hegel’s political philosophy’, in R.R. Williams (ed.) Beyond Liberalism and Communitarianism: Studies in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right (shortened version of Patten 2000 ch. 4)

Westphal, K.R. (2003) ‘Objektive Gültigkeit zwischen Gegebenem und Gematchtem: Hegels kantischer Konstruktivismus in der praktischen Philosophie’, Jahrbuch für Recht und Ethik 11, pp. 177-198, see sec. 5

@ Substantial will, objective will, universal will, substantial or objective freedom (The ‘will that is rational in and for itself’; this is the will that underlies ethical life) (For material specifically on the contrast between Hegel’s universal will and Rousseau’s general will see

‘Rousseau and Hegel’) Philosophy of Right §§24, 26, 142-147, 257-258 Philosophy of Spirit §435A, 486 Philosophy of History, tr. Sibree p. 456 Brudner, A. (1991) ‘Hegel and the crisis of private law’, in D. Cornell et al. (eds.) Hegel and Legal Theory Neuhouser, F. (2000) Foundations of Hegel’s Social Theory: Actualizing Freedom, pp. 52-54, 78-81, chs. 4-5 Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, ch. 3 sec. 4 ‘Towards a resolution: the concrete universal’ Baum, M. [19?] ‘Common welfare and universal will in Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in R. Pippin and O.

Höffe (eds.) Hegel on Ethics and Politics, 2004 Stern, R. (2007) ‘Hegel, British Idealism, and the curious case of the concrete universal’, British Journal for the

History of Philosophy 15(1), sections 2-4 @ Family Phenomenology, ch. 6A Philosophy of Right, ‘the family’ Stillman, P.G. (1981) ‘Hegel’s idea of the modern family,’ Thought 56:22, September 1981, pp. 342-52 Siebert, R.J. (1998) Hegel’s Concept of Marriage and Family: The Origin of Subjective Freedom @ Feminism and Hegel (For feminist interpretations of the Antigone story, see ‘Antigone’) (For feminism and Hegel see ‘Feminism and Hegel’)’) (For de Beauvoir ‘De Beauvoir and Hegel’) (For Irigaray see ‘Irigaray and Hegel’) Phenomenology of Spirit, §§446-463 ‘The ethical world. Human and divine law: man and woman’ de Beauvoir, S. (19?) The Second SexMills, P.J. (1978) ‘Hegel and “the woman question”: recognition and intersubjectivity’ in L.M.G. Clark and L.

Lange (eds.) The Sexism of Social and Political Theory: Women and Reproduction From Plato to Nietzsche Benjamin, J. (1980) ‘The bonds of love: rational violence and erotic domination’, Feminist Studies 6(1) Lloyd, G. (1983) ‘Masters, slaves and others’, Radical Philosophy 34 Lloyd, G. (1984) The Man of Reason, 2nd ed. 1993, chs 4-6 Arthur, C. (1988) ‘Hegel as lord and master’, Radical Philosophy 50, revised version in S. Sayers and P. Osborne

(eds.) Socialism, Feminism and Philosophy: A Radical Philosophy Reader 1990 Ravven, H.M. (1988) ‘Has Hegel anything to say to feminists?’, The Owl of Minerva 19(2) Benjamin, J. (1988) Bonds of Love: Psychoanalysis, Feminism and the Problem of Domination Chodorow, N. (1989) Feminism and Psychoanalytic Theory Butler, J. (1989) ‘Gendering the body: Beauvoir’s philosophical contribution’, in A. Garry and M. Pearsall

(eds.) Women, Knowledge and Reality: Exploration in Feminist Philosophy Young, I.M. (1990) Justice and the Politics of Difference Bambey, A. (1991) Das Geschechterverhältnis als Annerkennungstruktur Benhabib, S. (1991) ‘On Hegel, women and irony’, in Shanley and Pateman eds., Feminist Interpretations and

Political Theory Gatens, M. (1991) Feminism and Philosophy: Perspectives on Difference and Equality Mills, P.J. (ed.) (1996) Feminist Interpretations of G.W.F. Hegel Gauthier, J.A. (1997) Hegel and Feminist Social Criticism: Justice, Recognition and the Feminine Hutchings, K. (2002) Hegel: A Feminist Revision Hutchings, K. (2003) Hegel and Feminist Philosophy Kerruish, V. (2002) ‘Persons and available identities: gender in Hegel’s philosophy of law’, in M. Salter

(ed.) Hegel and Law Stone, A. (2004) ‘Going beyond oppositional thinking? The possibility of a Hegelian feminist philosophy’, Res

Publica 10(3) Gauthier, J.A. (2006) Hegel and Feminist Social Criticism: Justice, Recognition and the Feminine

MacDonald, S. (2008) Finding Freedom: Hegel’s Philosophy and the Emancipation of Women @ Civil society: general (For contrasts between Marx and Hegel on civil society see A Marx bibliography: ‘Critique of Hegel’s Doctrine

of the State’)* Riedel, M. [1962] ‘State and civil society: linguistic context and historical origin’, as ch. 6 of his Between

Tradition and Revolution, tr. W. Wright 1984 Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983, ch. 9* Arato, A. (1991) ‘A reconstruction of Hegel’s theory of civil society’, in Cornell et al (eds.) Hegel and Legal

Theory, slightly revised as J.L. Cohen and A. Arato, Civil Society and Political Theory, 1992, ch. 2 ‘ Conceptual history and theoretical synthesis’

Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 6 Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, ch. 6, sec. 2 @ System of needs, the economy (For these themes in the young Hegel see ‘Political economy and the young Hegel’) (For the civil society / state distinction see ‘Contradictions of civil society’) (For recognition and work, see ‘Labour in Hegel’) Philosophy of Right, ‘Civil society’ Phenomenology of Spirit, introductions to chs. 5B and 6, ‘virtue and the way of the world’, ‘the animal kingdom

of spirit’ Avineri, S. (1971) ‘Labor, alienation and social classes in Hegel’s Realphilosophie’, Philosophy and Public

Affairs 1(1) Horstmann, R.-P. (1974) ‘The role of civil society in Hegel’s political philosophy’, in R. Pippin and O. Höffe

(eds.) Hegel on Ethics and Politics, 2004 Stillman, P.G. (1980) ‘Hegel’s civil society: a locus of freedom’, Polity 12(4), Summer 1980, pp. 622-46 Stillman, P.G. (1983) ‘Scarcity, sufficiency, and abundance: Hegel and Marx on material needs and

satisfaction,’ International Political Science Review 4(3), Summer 1983, pp. 295-310 Walton, A.S. (1984) ‘Economy, utility and community in Hegel’s theory of civil society’, in Z.A. Pelczynksi

(ed.) The State and Civil Society Dickey, L. (1987) Hegel: Religion, Economics and the Politics of Spirit, 1770-1807, ch. 5 Maker, W. (ed.) (1987) Hegel on Economics and Freedom Stillman, P.G. (1987) ‘Partiality and wholeness: economic freedom, individual development, and ethical

institutions in Hegel’s political thought,’ in W. Maker (ed.) Hegel on Economics and Freedom Winfield, R.D. (1987) ‘Hegel’s challenge to the modern economy’, in W. Maker (ed.) Hegel on Economics and

Freedom Arthur, C.J. (1987) ‘Hegel on political economy’, in D. Lamb (ed.) Hegel and Modern Philosophy Arthur, C.J. (1988) ‘Hegel’s theory of value’, in M. Williams (ed.) Value, Social Form and State Waszek, N. (1988) The Scottish Enlightenment and Hegel’s Account of ‘Civil Society’ Inwood, M. (1992) A Hegel Dictionary, entry on ‘thing and subject matter’ Wallace, R.M. (1999) ‘How Hegel reconciles private freedom with citizenship’, Journal of Political

Philosophy 7(4) @ Class in Hegel Ruda, F. (2011) Hegel’s Rabble: An Investigation into Hegel’s Philosophy of Right @ Law (Gesetz), legal theory, Roman law (See also ‘Natural law and Hegel’) Bogdandy, A. von (1966) Hegels Theorie des Gesetzes Villey, M. (1974) ‘Le Droit Romain dan la “Philosophie des Rechts” de Hegel’, Hegel-Studien Beiheft 11 Cornell, D. et al. (eds.) (1990) Hegel and Legal Theory Salter, M. (ed.) (2002) Hegel and Law @ Bildung and education (See also ‘Community and individual, sociality of the self in Hegel) Phenomenology §§28-29 Philosophy of Right §187, §187R+ Inwood, A Hegel Dictionary, entry on ‘culture and education’ Luqueer, F.L. (1896) Hegel as Educator Mackenzie, M. (1909) Hegel’s Educational Theory and Practice

Gadamer, H.-G. [19?] Truth and Method, tr. 1975, pp. 9-19 Trilling, L. (1974) Sincerity and Authenticity, 2nd ed Kelly, G. (1969) Idealism, Politics and History: The Sources of Hegelian Thought, esp. pp. 341-8 Soll, I. (1972) ‘Hegel as a philosopher of education’, Educational Theory 22 Soll, I. (1972) ‘Bildung, Geschichte und Notwendigkeit bei Hegel’, Hegel Jahrbuch 1972 Dooren, W. (1973) ‘Der Begriff der Bildung in der Phänomenologie des Geistes’, Hegel Jahrbuch Bruford, W.H. (1975) The German Tradition of Self-Cultivation Bourgeois, B. (1978) ‘La pedagogie de Hegel’, in G.W.F. Hegel: Textes Pedagogiques Pöggeler, O. (1980) ‘Hegels Bildungsconzeption in geschichtlicher Zusammenhang’, Hegel-Studien 15 Stillman, P.G. (1980) ‘Hegel’s civil society: a locus of freedom,’ Polity 12(4), Summer 1980, pp. 622-46 Schmidt, J. (1981) ‘A paideia for the “Bürger als bourgeois”: the concept of ‘civil society’ in Hegel’s political

thought’, History of Political Thought 2(3) Vincent, A.W. and George, M. (1982) ‘Development and self-identity: Hegel’s concept of Bildung’, Educational

Theory 32(3-4), pp. 131-141 Stillman, P.G. (1987) ‘Partiality and wholeness: economic freedom, individual development, and ethical

institutions in Hegel’s political thought,’ in W. Maker (ed.) Hegel on Economics and Freedom Smith, J.H. (1988) The Spirit and its Letter: Traces of Rhetoric in Hegel’s Philosophy of Bildung Honneth, A. (1992) ‘Moral development and social struggle: Hegel’s early social doctrines’, in A. Honneth et al.

(eds.) Cultural-Political Interventions in the Unfinished Project of Enlightenment Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, p.155 Fernald, D.H. (2004) Spirit’s Philosophical Bildung: Image and Rhetoric in Hegel’s Phenomology of Spirit and

Science of Logic @ Contradictions of civil society (And the transition from civil society to the state) (Here the issue of the relationship between recognition and work recurs within Philosophy of Right) Reyburn, H.A. (1921) The Ethical Theory of Hegel, chs. 10-12 Marcuse, H. [193?] Reason and Revolution, ch. 6 Ritter, J. [1956] ‘Hegel and the French Revolution’, secs. 2-3, in his Hegel and the French Revolution, tr. R.

Winfield 1982 Plamenatz, J. (1963) Man and Society vol. 2, ch. 4 esp. pp. 241-261 Riedel, M. [1969] ‘The framework and meaning of objective spirit’, as ch.1 of his Between Tradition and

Revolution, tr. W. Wright 1984 Plant, R. (1973) Hegel: An Introduction, 2nd ed. 1983, ch. 9 Horstmann, R.-P. [1974] ‘The role of civil society in Hegel’s political philosophy’, in R. Pippin and O. Höffe

(eds.) Hegel on Ethics and Politics, 2004 [1] Göhler, G. and Roth, ? (1981) ‘Der Zusammenhang von Ökonomie, Recht und Staatsgewalt. Hegels

philosophische Begründung in der gegenwärtigen Diskussion’, Zeitschrift für philosophische Forschung 35 Ryan, A. (1984) ‘Hegel on work, ownership and citizenship’, in Pelczynski (ed.) The State and Civil Society Pelczynski, Z.A. (1984) ‘Introduction: the significance of Hegel’s separation of the state and civil society’, in

Pelczynksi (ed.) The State and Civil Society Ilting, K.-H. (1984) ‘The dialectic of civil society’, in Z. Pelczynski (ed.) The State and Civil Society Wood, A. (1990) Hegel’s Ethical Thought, ch. 14 Theunissen, M. (1991) ‘The repressed intersubjectivity in Hegel’s philosophy of right’, in Cornell et al eds., last

two secs. (pp. 36-57)* Arato, A. (1991) ‘A reconstruction of Hegel’s theory of civil society’, in Cornell et al (eds.) Hegel and Legal

Theory, slightly revised as J.L. Cohen and A. Arato, Civil Society and Political Theory, 1992, ch. 2, second section

Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation, ch. 6 @ State and constitution (Including discussions of individualism and Hegel’s attempts to overcome it in the modern state, and of his

attempt to reconcile the public and private) (See also ‘Social contract theory: Hegel’s critique’, and for organicism in Hegel ‘Community and individual’) Marx, K. [1843] Critique of Hegel’s ‘Philosophy of Right’ Bosanquet, B. (1899) The Philosophical Theory of the State, ch. 9 sec. 8 ‘The state proper’ and following two

sections (pp. 280-95) Stillman, P.G. (1988) ‘Hegel’s idea of constitutionalism,’ in A.S. Rosenbaum (ed.) Constitutionalism: The

Philosophical Dimension, Contributions in Legal Studies, Number 46, pp. 88-112

Wolff, M. [1984] ‘Hegel’s organicist theory of the state’, in R. Pippin and O. Höffe (eds.) Hegel on Ethics and Politics 2004

Sedgwick, S. (2001) ‘The state as organism: The metaphysical basis of Hegel’s ‘Philosophy of Right’’, Southern Journal of Philosophy 39

@ Democracy and monarchy in Hegel Philosophy of Right, §§273-279, 281, 301, 303, 308 Yack, B. (1980) ‘The rationality of Hegel’s concept of monarchy’, American Political Science Review 74(3) Hartmann, K. (1984) ‘Towards a new systematic reading of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right’, in Pelczynski (ed.) The

State and Civil Society, also in Hartmann’s Studies in Foundational Philosophy 1988 Tunick, M. (1991) ‘Hegel’s justification of hereditary monarchy’, History of Political Thought 12(3) Kervegan J.F. (2000) ‘Sovereignty and representation in Hegel’, Philosophical Forum 31(3-4) Lagerspetz, E. (2004) ‘Hegel and Hobbes on institutions and collective actions’, Ratio Juris 17(2) Brooks, T. (2006) ‘Plato, Hegel, and democracy’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 53-54 Brooks, T. (2007) ‘No rubber stamp: Hegel’s constitutional monarch’, History of Political Thought 28(1) @ War and international relations in Hegel Philosophy of Right §321-340 Armstrong, A.C. (1933) ‘Hegel’s attitude on war and peace’, Journal of Philosophy 30:25 Avineri, S. (1961) ‘The problem of war in Hegel’s thought’, Journal of the History of Ideas 22(4) Mitias, M. (1980) ‘Hegel on international law’, Clio 9 Smith, S.B. (1983) ‘Hegel’s views on war, the state, and international relations’, American Political Science

Review 77(3) Hicks, S.V. (1999) International Law and the Possibility of a Just World Order: An Essay on Hegel’s

Universalism Fine, R. (2003) ‘Kant’s theory of cosmopolitanism and Hegel’s critique’, Philosophy and Social Criticism 29(6) @ Civic humanism and other forms of republicanism in Hegel Taylor, C. (1991) ‘Hegel’s ambiguous legacy for modern liberalism’ in D. Cornell et al. (eds.) Hegel’s Legal

Theory Patten, A. (1999) Hegel’s Idea of Freedom, ch. 1 sec. 6 @ History (philosophy of): texts Lectures on the Philosophy of World History: Introduction, tr. Nisbet 1975, pp. 25-101, 138-151 (roughly the

same material, abridged and rearranged by Hegel’s son, appears as chs. 2-3 and pp. 67-82 of Introduction to the Philosophy of History, tr. Rauch 1988; as chs. 2-3 and pp. 78-95 of Reason in History, tr. Hartman 1953; and as pp. 9-53 and 63-79 of The Philosophy of History, tr. Sibree 1956)

Philosophy of Right, Preface, §§341-360 Introduction to the Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Knox and Miller, pp. 15-52 ‘Berlin Introduction’ Encyclopaedia Logic §§13-14, §86 and additions Phenomenology, Preface §§27-29, ch. 8 §§800-808 Philosophy of History @ History (philosophy of): short introductions Kaufmann, W. (1965) Hegel: Reinterpretation, Texts and Commentary, ch. 6* Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 15 Forbes, D. (1975) ‘Introduction’ to Nisbet (ed.) Lectures on the Philosophy of World History. Introduction Cohen, G.A. (1978) Karl Marx’s Theory of History, ch. 1* Singer, P. (1983) Hegel Past Masters, chs. 2-3 Houlgate, S. (1991) Freedom, Truth and History, ch. 1 Chitty, A. (1997) ‘The direction of contemporary capitalism and the practical relevance of theory’, Review of

International Political Economy 4(3) @ History (philosophy of): commentaries and collections Hyppolite, J. (1948) Introduction to Hegel’s Philosophy of History, tr. 1996 O’Brien, G.D. (1971) ‘Does Hegel have a philosophy of history?’, History and Theory 10(3), reprinted in Inwood

(ed.) Hegel Walsh, W.H. (1971) ‘Principle and prejudice in Hegel’s philosophy of history’ in Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s

Political Philosophy Wilkins, B.T. (1974) Hegel’s Philosophy of History

O’Brien, G.D. (1975) Hegel on Reason and History Stepelevich, L.S. and Lamb, D. (eds.) (1983) Hegel’s Philosophy of Action Inwood, M. (1983) Hegel, Arguments of the Philosophers, ch. 11 Perkins, R.L. (ed.) (1984) History and System: Hegel’s Philosophy of History* Jaeschke, W. (1984) ‘World history and the history of absolute spirit’ in R.L. Perkins (ed.) History and System:

Hegel’s Philosophy of History Bautz, T. (1988) Hegels Lehre von der Weltgeschichte. Zur logischen und systematischen Grundlegung der

Hegelschen Geschichtsphilosophie* McCarney, J. (2000) Hegel on History, Routledge Philosophy Guidebook Rosen, S. (19?) ‘Hegel and historicism’, in ?, reprinted in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 4,

1993 Houlgate, S. (1990) ‘World history as the progress of consciousness: an interpretation of Hegel’s philosophy of

history’, The Owl of Minerva 22(1), reprinted in R. Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 4, 1993 @ History as progressive, the cunning of reason Plamenatz, J. (1971) ‘History as the realisation of freedom’, in Pelczynski (ed.) Hegel’s Political Philosophy Avineri, S. (1971) ‘Consciousness and history: List der Vernunft in Hegel and Marx’, in W.E.

Steinkraus (ed.) New Studies in Hegel’s Philosophy Taylor, C. (1999) ‘Comment on Jürgen Habermas’ “‘From Kant to Hegel and back again”‘, European Journal of

Philosophy 7(2) Pippin, R.B. (2001) ‘Hegel and institutional rationality’, Southern Journal of Philosophy 39 @ History of philosophy (And historical role of philosophy, historicity of philosophy, Hegel’s historicism) Hegel [1820s] Introduction to the Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Knox and Miller, pp. 5-28, 41-52

(roughly the same material appears as Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Haldane, vol. 1 pp. pp. 1-19, 27-36, 49-61) and pp. 65-114 (a fuller elaboration of the same ideas)

Walsh, W.H. (1965) ‘Hegel on the history of philosophy’, History and Theory, Beiheft 5 Houlgate, S. (1991) Freedom, Truth and History, ch. 1 Beiser, F.C. (1993) ‘Hegel’s historicism’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Browning. G. (1999) Hegel and the History of Political Philosophy Duquette, D.A. (ed.) (2003) Hegel’s History of Philosophy: New Interpretations @ Historical role of Hegel’s philosophy (See also ‘Bifurcation, and the standpoint of modern thought, Kant’s standpoint as a whole’) Faith and Knowledge Introductory Lectures on Aesthetics ‘Preface’ to The Philosophy of Right Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 1 ‘Why the Phenomenology of spirit?’ Hardimon, M.O. (1994) Hegel’s Social Philosophy: The Project of Reconciliation @ End of history in Hegel Lectures on the Philosophy of World History: Introduction, tr. Nisbet, pp. 145-149 Philosophy of History, pp. 442-457 Kojève, A. (1947) Introduction to the Reading of Hegel, pp. 157-168 Inwood, M. (1983) Hegel, Arguments of the Philosophers, pp. 509-519 Cooper, B. (1984) The End of History: An Essay on Modern Hegelianism, University of Toronto Press, Toronto Roth, M.S. (1985) ‘A problem of recognition: Alexandre Kojève and the end of history’, History and Theory 24 Berthold-Bond, D. (1988) ‘Hegel’s eschatological vision: does history have a future?’, History and Theory 27(1) Fukuyama, F. (1989) ‘The end of history?’, The National Interest 16 Bubner, R. (1991) ‘Hegel and the end of history’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain, 23-24 Malabou, C. [1996] The Future of Hegel: Plasticity, Temporality and Dialectic, tr. 2005 @ RELIGION AND ART @ Philosophy of religion in general (For Christian religion see ‘Christianity and Hegel’) Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion Fackenheim, E.L. (1967) The Religious Dimension in Hegel’s Thought Christensen, D.E. (ed.) (1970) Hegel and the Philosophy of Religion

Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 18 Reardon, B.M. (1977) Hegel’s Philosophy of Religion Butler, C. (1977) G.W.F. Hegel Williamson, R.K. (1984) Introduction to Hegel’s Philosophy of Religion* Jaeschke, W. [1986] Reason in Religion: The Foundations of Hegel’s Philosophy of Religion, tr. J.M. Stewart and

P.C. Hodgson 1990 Walker, J. (ed.) (1991) Thought and Faith in the Philosophy of Hegel* Jaeschke, W. (1992) ‘Philosophical theology and the philosophy of religion’ in D. Kolb (ed.) New Perspectives

on Hegel’s Philosophy of Religion Kolb, D. (ed.) (1992) New Perspectives on Hegel’s Philosophy of Religion Merklinger, P.M. (1993) Philosophy, Theology and Hegel’s Berlin Philosophy of Religion 1821-1827 Hodgson, P.C. (2005) Hegel and Christian Theology: A Reading of the Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion @ Kant and Fichte’s theology and Hegel (See also ‘Natural theology and the young Hegel’) Kant, I. [1781] Critique of Pure Reason, B595-607, 639-40, 826, 837-46 Kant, I. [1788] Critique of Practial Reason Kant, I. [1790] Critique of Judgement Fichte, J.G. [1792] Attempt at a Critique of All Revelation, tr. G. Green 1978 Kant, I. [1793] Religion within the Limits of Reason Alone Jaeschke, W. [1986] Reason in Religion: The Foundations of Hegel’s Philosophy of Religion, tr. J.M. Stewart and

P.C. Hodgson 1990 , ch. 1 @ Religion in the Phenomenology (See also ‘Christianity and Hegel’)* Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 7 Phenomenology of Spirit, ch. 4 ‘The unhappy consciousness’, ch. 6 ‘Faith and insight’ Hyppolite, J. [1946] Genesis and Structure of Hegel’s ‘Phenomenology of Spirit’, part 6 ch. 3 Taylor, C. (1975) Hegel, ch. 7 Westphal, M. (1979) History and Truth in Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 7 Flay, J. (1981) ‘Religion and the absolute standpoint’ Thought 56, pp. 316-327 Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, ch. 10 Pinkard, T. (1994) Hegel’s Phenomenology, ch. 6 sec. 1 Jamros, D.P. (1990) ‘The appearing God in Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, Clio 19 Jamros, D.P. (1994) The Human Shape of God: Religion in Hegel’s “Phenomenology of Spirit” @ Natural religion Vieillard-Baron, J-L. [1971] ‘Natural religion: an investigation of Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, tr. J. Stewart

in Stewart (ed.) The Phenomenology of Spirit Reader 1998 @ Judaism and Hegel ‘The spirit of Christianity and its fate’ esp. first part Phenomenology §§340, 720 Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, Volume 2, ‘The religion of sublimity’ Fackenheim, E. (1973) Encounters Between Judaism and Modern Philosophy, pp. 81-134 Poggeler (1974) ‘Hegel’s interpretation of Judaism’, Human Context 6 Stepelevich, L. (1975) ‘Hegel and Judaism’, Judaism 2 Hodgson, P.C. (1987) ‘The metamorphosis of Judaism in Hegel’s philosophy of religion’, Owl of Minerva 19(1) Luft, E.V.D. (1989) ‘Hegel and Judaism: a reassessment’, Clio 18(4) Smith, S. (1997) Spinoza, Liberalism and the Question of Jewish Identity, pp. 185-196 Yovel, Y. (1998) Dark Riddle: Hegel, Nietzsche and the Jews Leopold, D. (1999) ‘The Hegelian anti-semitism of Bruno Bauer’, History of European Ideas 25(4) @ Christianity and Hegel, Hegel’s christology (Hegel’s account of Christianity, and of its relationship with philosophical knowledge of the absolute. Also

discussions of his conception of Jesus and of whether Hegel is a Christian) (See also ‘Christian theology in general and Hegel’) (For discussions of religion in the Phenomenology see ‘Religion in the Phenomenology’) Phenomenology, ch. 7C Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, part 3

Preface to the 2nd edition and foreword to 3rd edition of the Encyclopaedia, in The Encyclopaedia Logic, tr. Geraets et al

‘Reason and religious truth’, foreword to H. Hinrich Religion in its Inner Relation to Science, in F. Weiss (ed.) Beyond Epistemology: New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, pp. 227-244

McTaggart, J.M.E. (1901) Studies in Hegelian Cosmology, ch. 7 Lauer, Q. (1970) ‘Hegel on the identity of content in religion and philosophy’ in D.E. Christensen (ed.) Hegel and

the Philosophy of Religion Kojève, A. (1970) ‘Hegel, Marx and Christianity’, Interpretation Yerkes, J. (1978) The Christology of Hegel McCarthy, V.A. (1986) Quest for a Philosophical Jesus: Christianity and Philosophy in Rousseau, Kant, Hegel,

and Schelling, ch. 3 ‘Hegel and the Jesus of consummate religion’ Houlgate, S. (1991) Freedom, Truth and History, ch. 5 Shanks, A. (1991) Hegel’s Political Theology Jaeschke, W. (1991) ‘The history of religion and absolute religion’, in J. Walker (ed.) Thought and Faith in the

Philosophy of Hegel + Dickey, L. (1993) ‘Hegel on religion and philosophy’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Rocker, S. (1995) Hegel’s Rational Religion: The Validity of Hegel’s Argument for the Identity in Content of

Absolute Religion and Absolute Philosophy Desmond W. (2003) Hegel’s God: A Counterfeit Double? Schickler, J. (2005) Metaphysics as Christology: An Odyssey of the Self from Kant and Hegel to Steiner Hodgson, P.C. (2005) Hegel and Christian Theology: A Reading of the Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion O’Regan, C. (2006-06) ‘Philosophy of religion in the context of Hegel’s philosophy’, The Owl of Minerva 37(1) Jamros, D.P. (1995) ‘Hegel on the incarnation: unique or universal?’ Theological Studies, also available online @ Trinitarianism in Hegel (See also ‘Christianity’ and ‘Metaphysics of Hegel: theological interpretations’) Schlitt, D.M. (1984) Hegel’s Trinitarian Claim: A Critical Reflection O’Regan, C. (1994) The Heterodox Hegel Calton, P.M. (2001) Hegel’s Metaphysics of God: The Ontological Proof as the Development of a Trinitarian

Divine Ontology Hodgson, P.C. (2005-06) ‘Hegel: theologian of freedom’, The Owl of Minerva 37(1) @ Religion and philosophy in general (The relation between religion and philosophy in general, and between the history of religion and the history of

philosophy. For discussions specifically on the relation between Christian religion and Hegel’s own philosophy, see ‘Christianity’)

‘Reason and religious truth’ [1821], foreword to H. Hinrich Religion in its Inner Relation to Science, in F. Weiss (ed.) Beyond Epistemology: New Studies in the Philosophy of Hegel, pp. 227-244. Available online: German text

Introduction to the Lectures on the History of Philosophy [1820-27], tr. Knox and Miller pb, pp. 25-42, 114-163 (roughly the same material appears as Lectures on the History of Philosophy, tr. Haldane, vol. 1 pp. 55-94)

Wallace, W. (1873) ‘Bibliographical notice’ in Wallace (ed.) Hegel’s Logic @ Religion and the state Philosophy of Right §270 ‘The relationship of religion to the state’, in Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion: Volume 1, (ed.) P. Hodgson Olson, A. (1992) Hegel and the Spirit: Philosophy as Pneumatology Rocker, S. (1995) Hegel’s Rational Religion: The Validity of Hegel’s Argument for the Identity in Content of

Absolute Religion and Absolute Philosophy @ Art and aesthetics Phenomenology, ch. 7B Lectures on Aesthetics Kaminsky, J. (1962) Hegel on Art* Henrich, D. [1970] ‘The contemporary relevance of Hegel’s aesthetics’, in Inwood (ed.) Hegel Solomon, R. (1983) In the Spirit of Hegel, pp. 604-614 Bungay, S. (1984) Meaning and Truth: A Study of Hegel’s Aesthetics Desmond, W. (1986) Art and the Absolute: A Study of Hegel’s Aesthetics+ Inwood, M. (1993) ‘Introduction’ to the Introductory Lectures on Aesthetics Steinkraus, W.E. and Schmitz, K.L. (eds.) (1980) Art and Logic in Hegel’s Philosophy

+ Wicks, R. (1993) ‘Hegel’s aesthetics: an overview’, in F.C. Beiser (ed.) The Cambridge Companion to Hegel Wicks, R. (1994) Hegel’s Theory of Aesthetic Judgment Maker, W. (ed.) (2000) Hegel and Aesthetics Pillow, K. (2000) Sublime Understanding: Aesthetic Reflection in Kant and Hegel Etter, B.K. (2006) Between Transcendence and Historicism The Ethical Nature of the Arts in Hegelian Aesthetics Houlgate, S. (ed.) (2007) Hegel and the Arts @ SUBSEQUENT PHILOSOPHERS AND HEGEL @ Schellingian critiques of Hegel (This is essentially the critique, initiated by the later Schelling, that there is always more to reality than our

concepts of it, and that Hegel failed to recognise this) (For Adorno, see ‘Adorno and Hegel’) (For Levinas, see ‘Levinas and Hegel’) (See also ‘metaphysics of Hegel: positivist and category theory interpretations’ above; Hartmann’s category

theory interpretation is meant to preserve the existence/essence distinction that Schelling claims Hegel collapses)

(See also ‘Sense-certainty, ch. 1’) Schelling, F. [1832-33] Grundlegung der positiven Philosophie, (ed.) H. Fuhrmans 1972 Schelling, F. [1833-34] On the History of Modern Philosophy, tr. A. Bowie 1994, section on Hegel,

partly available online* Feuerbach, L. [1839] ‘Towards a critique of Hegel’s philosophy’ in L.S. Stepelevich (ed.) The Young

Hegelians 1983; also in Stern (ed.) G.W.F. Hegel: Critical Assessments vol. 1 Marx, K. [1844] Economic and Philosophical Manuscripts final section, ‘Critique of Hegel’s dialectic’ Heidegger, M. [1956] Hegel’s Concept of Experience White, A. (1983) Absolute Knowledge: Hegel and the Problem of Metaphysics Bowie, A. (1993) Schelling and Modern European Philosophy: An Introduction, ch. 6 Houlgate, S. (1994) ‘Hegel and Fichte: recognition, otherness, and absolute knowing’, Owl of Minerva 26(1) @ Marx and Hegel (See A Marx bibliography: ‘Hegl and Marx’, ‘Marx’s critique of Hegel’s ontology’, ‘Alienation: Marx’s critique

of Hegel’s concept of it’ and ‘Method of Capital: Hegelian interpretations’) @ Kierkegaard and Hegel Kierkegaard, S. ‘Early journal entries’ in H.V. Hong and E.H. Hong (eds.) The Essential Kierkegaard, 2000 Kierkegaard, S. Repetition, section on Job Kierkegaard, S. Fear and Trembling, section on Abraham and Isaac Kierkegaard, S. [1846] Concluding Unscientific Postscript, esp. book 1 ch. 2 and book 2 part 1 Sartre, J.-P. ‘Marxism and existentialism’, in W. Kaufman (ed.) Existentialism from Dostoevsky to Sartre Wahl, J. (1934) L’Etude de J. Wahl dans les rapports du IIIe Congrès hégélien de Rome Hyppolite, J. [1955] ‘The concept of existence in the Hegelian phenomenology’, in his Essays on Hegel and Marx Thulstrup, N. [1969] Kierkegaard’s Relation to Hegel, tr. 1980 Solomon, R.C. (1978) ‘The secret of Hegel (Kierkegaard’s complaint): a study in Hegel’s philosophy of

religion’, The Philosophical Forum 9(4) Taylor, M.C. (1981) Journeys to Selfhood: Hegel and Kierkegaard Cruysberghs, P. (1995) ‘Beyond world history: on Hegel’s and Kierkegaard’s interests in ethics and

religion’, History of European Ideas 20 (1995) Stewart, J. (2003) Kierkegaard’s Relations to Hegel Reconsidered Cruysberghs, P. (2005) ‘Hegel has no ethics: Climacus’s complaints against speculative philosophy’,

in Kierkegaard Studies Yearbook @ Nietzsche and Hegel Nietzsche, F. [1874] ‘The uses and disadvantages of history’ in Untimely Meditations (also translated as Thoughts

out of Season) Houlgate, S. (1986) Hegel, Nietzsche, and the Criticism of Metaphysics Miklowitz, P.S. (1998) Metaphysics to Metafictions: Hegel, Nietzsche, and the End of Philosophy Dudley, W. (2002) Hegel, Nietzsche, and Philosophy: Thinking Freedom Zimmerman, R.L. (2005) The Kantianism of Hegel and Nietzsche: Renovation in 19th-Century German

Philosophy

@ British Idealism (or British Hegelians) (See also ‘Concrete universal in British idealism’) Bradley, F.H. (1883) The Principles of Logic, 2nd ed. 1922 available online Bradley, F.H. (1893) Appearance and Reality: A Metaphysical Essay, 2nd ed. 1897, available online McTaggart, J.M. (1896) Studies in the Hegelian Dialectic, 2nd ed. 1922, available online McTaggart, J.M. (1901) Studies in Hegelian Cosmology, 2nd ed. 1918, available online Mackintosh, R. (1903) Hegel and Hegelianism, reprinted 1990 Bosanquet, B. (1912) The Principle of Individuality and Value, The Gifford Lectures for 1911, available online Bradley, F.H. (1914) Essays on Truth and Reality, available online Royce, J. (1919) Lectures on Modern Idealism, available online Robbins, P. (1982) The British Hegelians, 1875-1925 Stern, R. (1994) ‘British Hegelianism: a non-metaphysical view’, European Journal of Philosophy 2 Den Otter , S.M. (1996) British Idealism and Social Explanation: A Study in Late Victorian Thought Sweet, W. et al. (2004) Early Responses to British Idealism Sweet, W. (ed.) (2007) Bernard Bosanquet and the Legacy of British Idealism @ British idealism: ethical and political thought Bradley, F.H. (1876) Ethical Studies, esp. ‘My station and its duties’ Green, T.H. (1883) Prolegomena to Ethics Bosanquet, B. (1899) The Philosophical Theory of the State Nicholson, P.P. (ed.) (1990) The Political Philosophy of the British Idealists: Selected Studies Sweet, W. (1996) Idealism and Rights: The Social Ontology of Human Rights in the Political Thought of Bernard

Bosanquet Boucher, D. and Vincent, A. (2000) British Idealism and Political Theory @ Whitehead and Hegel Lucas, G.R. (1979) Two Views of Freedom in Process Thought: A Study of Hegel and Whitehead Ellis, R. (1981) ‘From Hegel to Whitehead’, The Journal of Religion 61(4) Lucas, G.R. (ed.) (1986) Hegel and Whitehead; Contemporary Perspectives on Systematic Philosophy Christensen, D.E. (1986) The Search for Concreteness: Reflections on Hegel and Whitehead Nussbaum, C. (1986) ‘Logic and the metaphysics of Hegel and Whitehead’, Process Studies 15(1), also available

online Lakeland, P. (1986) ‘Process and revolution: Hegel, Whitehead, and liberation theology’, Process Studies 15(4),

also available online @ Freud, Lacan and Hegel (See also ‘Madness and Hegel’) Ricoeur, P. [1965] Freud and Philosophy, tr. 1970, ch. on Hegel Hyppolite, J. [1971] ‘Hegel’s phenomenology and psychoanalysis’, in W.E. Steinkraus New Studies in the

Philosophy of Hegel 1971 Butler, C. (1976) ‘Hegel and Freud: a comparison’, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 36(4) Mills, J. (2002) The Unconscious Abyss: Hegel’s Anticipation of Psychoanalysis @ Heidegger and Hegel (See also ‘Heidegger on intersubjectivity, recognition and Mitsein’) Heidegger, M. [1927] Being and Time, section 82 Heidegger, M. [1930-31] Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit Marcuse, H. [1932] Hegel’s Ontology and the Theory of Historicity Heidegger, M. [1956] Hegel’s Concept of Experience Heidegger, M. [1958] ‘Hegel and the Greeks’ in W. McNeill (ed.) Pathmarks 1998 (another English translation

is available online) Heidegger, M. [19?] The Metaphysical Foundations of Logic Gadamer, H.-G. (1967) ‘Hegel and Heidegger’ in his Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Hermeneutical Studies Krell, D.F. (1980) ‘Hegel, Heidegger, Heraclitus. in J. Sallis (ed.) Heraclitean Fragments Gillespie, M.A. (1984) Hegel, Heidegger and the Ground of History Kolb, D. (1986) The Critique of Pure Modernity: Hegel, Heidegger and After Schmidt, D.J. (1988) The Ubiquity of the Finite: Hegel, Heidegger and the Elements of Philosophy De Boer, K. (2000) Thinking in the Light of Time: Heidegger’s Encounter with Hegel @ French philosophers and Hegel

Baugh, B. (2003) French Hegel: From Surrealism to Postmodernism Keenan, D.K. (ed.) (2004) Hegel and Contemporary Continental Philosophy @ Bataille and Hegel Bürger, P. [1998] The Thinking of the Master: Bataille between Hegel and Surrealism, tr. 2002 Gemerchak, C.M. (2003) The Sunday of the Negative: Reading Bataille, Reading Hegel @ Kojève and Hegel (See ‘Kojève’) @ Sartre and Hegel (See also ‘Sartre on recognition’) Sartre, J.-P. [1943] Being and Nothingness, tr. H. Barnes, pp. 233-252 Hartmann, K. (1966) Sartre’s Ontology: A Study of ‘Being and Nothingness’ in the Light of Hegel’s Logic Ogilvy, J. 91980) ‘Mastery and sexuality: Hegel’s dialectic in Sartre and post-freudian psychology’, Human

Studies 3(1) O’Hagan, T. (1981) ‘Reading Hegel through Sartre’, Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 12 Butler, J. (1987) Subjects of Desire: Hegelian Reflections in 20th Century France, chapter on Sartre Honneth, A. [1992] The Struggle for Recognition, tr. 1995, chapter on Sartre Matarrese, C. (2001) ‘Solidarity and fear: Hegel and Sartre on the mediations of reciprocity’, Philosophy

Today 45(1) Gardner, S. (2005) ‘Sartre, intersubjectivity, and German Idealism’, Journal of the History of Philosophy 43 Evans, D. (2009) ‘Sartre and Beauvoir on Hegel’s Master-Slave Dialectic and the Question of the “Look”‘, in C.

Daigle and J. Golomb (eds.) Beauvoir and Sartre: The Riddle of Influence @ De Beauvoir and Hegel (With thanks to Alison Stone) de Beauvoir, S. (1949) The Second Sex, ‘Introduction’ and ‘The Data of Biology’ Lundgren-Gothlin, E. (1996) Sex and Existence: Simone De Beauvoir’s The Second Sex’, section on ‘The master-

slave dialectic in The Second Sex’, reprinted in E. Fallaize (ed.) Simone de Beauvoir: A Critical Reader 1998 Bauer, N. (2001) Simone de Beauvoir, Philosophy and Feminism, chs. 3-7 Bauer, N. (2001) ‘Being-with as being-against: Heidegger meets Hegel in The Second Sex’, Continental

Philosophy Review 34(2) Changfoot, N. (2009) ‘The Second Sex’s continued relevance for equality and difference feminisms’, European

Journal of Women’s Studies 16(1) Evans, D. (2009) ‘Sartre and Beauvoir on Hegel’s Master-Slave Dialectic and the Question of the “Look”‘, in C.

Daigle and J. Golomb (eds.) Beauvoir and Sartre: The Riddle of Influence @ Levinas and Hegel (See also ‘Irigaray and Hegel’) Levinas, E. [1982] Ethics and Infinity: Conversations with Philippe Nemo, tr. 1985, c. pp. 66-90 Bernasconi, R. (1982) ‘Levinas face to face with Hegel’, Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 13(3) Bernasconi, R. (1986) ‘Hegel and Levinas: the possibility of forgivenness and reconciliation’, Archivio Di

Filosofia 54 Schroeder, B. (2000) ‘The (non)logic of desire and war: Hegel and Levinas’, in H.J. Silverman (ed.) Philosophy

and Desire @ Marxists on Hegel Engels, F. [1888] Ludwig Feuerbach and the Outcome of Classical German Philosophy, ch. 1 Marcuse, H. [1932] Hegel’s Ontology and the Theory of Historicity Marcuse, H. (1941) Reason and Revolution, part 1 Lukács, G. [1948] The Young Hegel Lukács, G. [19?] The Ontology of Social Being: Hegel, tr. 1978 Lukács, G. [19?] Hegel’s False and his Genuine Ontology, tr. D. Fernbach, 1982 Althusser, L. [1965] For Marx @ Wittgenstein and Hegel Lamb, D. (1980) Language and Perception in Hegel and Wittgenstein @ Adorno and Hegel

(See also A Marx bibliography: ‘Adorno on identity thinking’) Adorno, T.W Adorno, T.W. [1960] Ontologie und Dialektik (lectures corresponding to Negative Dialectics part 1) Adorno, T.W. [1963] Hegel: Three Studies, tr. 1993 Adorno, T.W. [1964-65] History and Freedom, tr. 2006 Adorno, T.W. [1965-66] Vorlesung über Negative Dialektik, 2003 (lectures corresponding to Negative

Dialectics part 2 and addition corresponding to the introduction), see lecture 2, translation available online Adorno, T.W. [1966] Negative Dialectics, tr. 1973 Bernstein, J.M. (2004) ‘Negative dialectic as fate: Adorno and Hegel’, in T. Huhn (ed.) The Cambridge

Companion to Adorno Jarvis, S. (2004) ‘What is speculative thinking? (Adorno, Hegel, Kant)’, Revue Internationale de

Philosophie 58(227) O’Connor, B. (2004) Adorno’s Negative Dialectic: Philosophy and the Possibility of Critical Rationality @ Gadamer and Hegel Gadamer, H.-G. [1973] Hegel’s Dialectic: Five Phenomenological Studies @ Nancy and Hegel (See also ‘Nancy on intersubjectivity and recognition’) Nancy, J.-L. [1973] The Speculative Remark: One of Hegel’s Bon Mots, tr. C. Surprenant 2001 Nancy, J.-L. [1997] Hegel: The Restlessness of the Negative, tr. J. Smith and S. Miller 2002 @ Irigaray and Hegel (With thanks to Alison Stone) (See also ‘Levinas and Hegel’) Irigaray L. [1974] Speculum of the Other Woman, ‘The eternal irony of the community’ Irigaray L. [1987] Sexes and Genealogies, tr. 1987, ‘The universal as mediation’, ‘The female gender’ Irigaray, L. [1992] I Love to You: Sketch for a Felicity within History, tr. 1996, especially the essay ‘Love

between us’ Irigaray, L. [1994] To Be Two Irigaray, L. [19?] ‘Sexual difference’ in McNeill and Feldman (eds.) Continental Philosophy: A Reader Chanter, T. (1995) Ethics of Eros, ch. 3 Cheah, P. and Grosz, E. (1998) ‘Of being-two: introduction’ to Irigaray and the political future of sexual

difference’, Diacritics 28: 1 Walsh, L. (1999) ‘Her mother her self: the ethics of the Antigone family romance’, Hypatia 14(3) Joy, M. (2000) ‘Love and the labor of the negative: Irigaray and Hegel’, in D. Olkowski (ed.) Resistance, Flight,

Creation: Feminist Enactments of French Philosophy @ Habermas on Hegel, and on philosophy after Hegel (Habermas’s 1967 ‘Labour and Interaction’ and responses to it are in see ‘Recognition in the Jena writings ‘) (See also A social and political philosophy bibliography: ‘Political role of philosophy’) (Also on metaphysics as a guide to action; see also A social and political philosophy bibliography: ‘Self’) Horkheimer, M. (1947) Eclipse of Reason, Seabury, c. pp.12-24, 61-62 Habermas, J. [1965] ‘Knowledge and human interests: a general perspective’ (the 1965 Frankfurt inaugural

address), appendix to Knowledge and Human Interests, 1987, pp.301-317 Habermas, J. [1966] ‘On Hegel’s political writings’, in his Theory and Practice Habermas, J. [1968] Knowledge and Human Interests, chs. 1,9 Habermas, J. [1971] ‘Why more philosophy?’ Social Research 38 Habermas, J. [1975] ‘The place of philosophy in Marxism’, Insurgent Sociologist 5(2), 1975, pp 41-48 McCarthy, T. (1978) The Critical Theory of Jürgen Habermas, 2nd ed. Polity 1982, sec. 2.5 ‘The idea of

philosophy and its relation to critical theory’ (pp.102-111 is on H’s attempt to see ideology-critique as the successor to philosophy)

Kortian, G. (1980) Metacritique: The Philosophical Argument of Jürgen Habermas Habermas, J. [198?] ‘Philosophy as stand-in and interpreter’, in Baynes, K. et al. (eds.) After Philosophy: End or

Transformation? 1987 Habermas, J. [1985] The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity, tr. 1990, lecture 2 Habermas, J. [1988] ‘Themes in postmetaphysical thinking’, in Postmetaphysical Thinking, tr. 1992 Habermas, J. (1999) ‘From Kant to Hegel and back again: the move towards detranscendentalization’, European

Journal of Philosophy 7(2)

@ Lyotard, postmodernism and Hegel Lyotard, J.-G. [1979] The Postmodern Condition Browning, G.K. (2003) ‘Lyotard and Hegel: what is wrong with modernity and what is right with the philosophy

of right’, History of European Ideas, 29(2) @ Derrida and Hegel Derrida, J. [1967] From restricted to general economy: a Hegelianism without reserve’, in Writing and Difference Derrida, J. [1971] ‘The pit and the pyramid: an introduction to Hegel’s semiology’, in Margins of Philosophy Derrida, J. [1974] Glas, tr. 1986 Barnett, S. (1998) Hegel After Derrida Magnus, K.D. (2001) Hegel and the Symbolic Mediation of Spirit @ Analytic philosophy and Hegel Rockmore, T. (2005) Hegel, Idealism, and Analytic Philosophy @ McDowell on Hegel McDowell, J. (1996) Mind and World Friedman, M. (1996) ‘Exorcising the philosophical tradition: Comments on John McDowell’s Mind and

World’, Philosophical Review 105, reprinted in N.H. Smith (ed.) Reading McDowell: On Mind and World, 2002

Sedgwick, S. (1997) ‘McDowell’s Hegelianism’, European Journal of Philosophy 5(1) Stern, R. (1999) ‘Going beyond the Kantian philosophy: McDowell’s Hegelian critique of Kant’, European

Journal of Philosophy 7(2), also available online Sedgwick, S. (2000) ‘Hegel, McDowell and recent defences of Kant’, Journal of the British Society for

Phenomenology 31(3), reprinted in K. Deligiorgi (ed.) Hegel: New Directions, 2006 McDowell, J. [2001] ‘Hegel’s idealism as a radicalisation of Kant’ in McDowell, Having the World in View,

2009, originally published as ‘L’Idealismo di Hegel come Radicalizazzione di Kant’, Iride 34, 2001 Bernstein, R.J. (2002) ‘McDowell’s domesticated Hegelianism’, in N.H. Smith (ed.) Reading McDowell Pippin, R.B. (2002) ‘Leaving nature behind: or two cheers for ‘subjectivism’”, in N.H. Smith (ed.) Reading

McDowell: On Mind and World, reprinted in Pippin’s The Persistence of Subjectivity: On the Kantian Aftermath, 2005 (critique of McDowell on Hegel)

McDowell, J. (2002) ‘Responses’, in N.H. Smith (ed.) Reading McDowell: On ‘Mind and World’ McDowell, J. (2003) ‘The apperceptive I and the empirical self: towards a heterodox reading of “lordship and

bondage” in Hegel’s Phenomenology’, Bulletin of the Hegel Society of Great Britain 47-48, reprinted in K. Deligiorgi (ed.)Hegel: New Directions, 2006

McDowell, J. (2003) ‘Hegel and the myth of the given’, in W. Welsch and K. Vieweg (eds) Das Interesse des Denkens: Hegel aus heutiger Sicht

Pippin, R.B. (2005) ‘Postscript: on McDowell’s response to “Leaving nature behind”‘, in The Persistence of Subjectivity: On the Kantian Aftermath

Houlgate, S. (2006) ‘Thought and experience in Hegel and McDowell’, European Journal of Philosophy 14(2) Westphal, K. (2006) ‘Contemporary epistemology: Kant, Hegel, McDowell’, European Journal of

Philosophy 14(2) McDowell, J. (2007) ‘On Pippin’s postscript’, European Journal of Philosophy 15(3), section 4 Rödl, S. (2008) ‘Eliminating externality’, Internationales Jahrbuch des Deutschen Idealismus 5 @ Brandom on Hegel (Brandom, R. (1979) ‘Freedom and constraint by norms’, American Philosophical Quarterly 16(3) Brandom, R. (1994) Making It Explicit* Brandom, R.B. (1999) ‘Some pragmatist themes in Hegel’s idealism: negotiation and administration in Hegel’s

account of the structure and content of conceptual norms’, European Journal of Philosophy 7(2), reprinted in his Tales of the Mighty Dead: Historical Essays in the Metaphysics of Intentionality, 2002

McDowell, J. (1999) Comment on Robert Brandom’s ‘Some pragmatist themes in Hegel’s idealism’, European Journal of Philosophy 7(2)

Habermas, J. (2000) ‘From Kant to Hegel: on Robert Brandom’s pragmatic philosophy of language’, European Journal of Philosophy 8(3)

Brandom, R.B. (2001) ‘Holism and idealism in Hegel’s Phenomenology’, Hegel-Studien 36, reprinted in his Tales of the Mighty Dead: Historical Essays in the Metaphysics of Intentionality, 2002

Rockmore, T. (2002) ‘Brandom, Hegel and inferentialism’, International Journal of Philosophical Studies 10(4) Testa, I. and Brandom, R.B. (2003) ‘Hegelian pragmatism and social emancipation: an interview with Robert

Brandom’, Constellations 10(4)

Pippin, R.B. (2005) ‘Brandom’s Hegel’, 13(3) Brandom, R.B. (2005) ‘Sketch of a program for a critical reading of Hegel: comparing empirical and logical

concepts’, in K. Ameriks (ed.) Internationales Jahrbuch des Deutschen Idealismus / International Yearbook of German Idealism, Vol. 3

* Brandom, R.B. (2007) ‘The structure of desire and recognition: self-consciousness and self-constitution’, Philosophy and Social Criticism 33(1), reprinted in H. Ikäheimo and A. Laitinen (eds) Recognition and Social Ontology, 2011

de Laurentiis, A. (2007) ‘Not Hegel’s tales: applied concepts, negotiated truths and the reciprocity of un-equals in conceptual pragmatism’, Philosophy and Social Criticism 33(1) [#]

Brandom, R. (2008) ‘Georg Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit’, Topoi 27 [#] O’Connor, B. (2008) ‘Hegel’s Phenomenology and the question of semantic pragmatism’, The Owl of

Minerva 38(1-2) Houlgate, S. (2009) ‘Phenomenology and De Re interpretation: a critique of Brandom’s reading of

Hegel’, International Journal of Philosophical Studies 17(1) deVries, W.A. (2011) ‘Brandom and the spirit of Hegel’, in H. Sturm and C. Barth (eds) Robert Brandom’s

Expressive Vernunft: Historische und systematische Untersuchungen, also available online Redding, P.A. (2011) ‘The analytic Neo-Hegelianism of John McDowell and Robert Brandom’, in S. Houlgate

and M. Baur (eds) A Companion to Hegel [end]

A Hegel Bibliography

Documents

Transcript of A Hegel Bibliography