A Database is not what you think and different designs serve different purposes.
-
Upload
unidad-investigacion-ser -
Category
Documents
-
view
516 -
download
0
description
Transcript of A Database is not what you think and different designs serve different purposes.
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Different designs of longitudinal observational studies (databases, registries, cohort studies) serve different purposes Loreto Carmona
Research Unit Spanish Society of Rheumatology
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Why this talk?
• Sometimes the only point in which investigators agree in a given project is about the need to collect data.
• There is indeed much misunderstanding about databases.
• The first principle of data collection: We should not collect data just for the sake of it, without explicit and specified objectives.
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
What is a database?
NOT:
Any set of data entered into a computer
YES:
A tool to organize the data in a study
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
What is not a database?
A dataset
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Other uses
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
What is a database?
• Organizing
• Hierarchical
• Relational
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Structure
patient
treatment
treatment
treatment
treatment
AE
AE
AE
AE
AE
AE
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Structure
patient
visit
visit
visit
visit
outcome
outcome
outcome
outcome
outcome
outcome
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Time and databases
Medicaldatabases
timeLongitudina
lObservation
alStudies
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Can we analyse data directly from a DB?
wide long
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
wide
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
long
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Types of databases
Depend on the purpose and design of the study they serve.
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Types of databases
1. Registries
2. Cohorts
3. Administrative databases
4. Clinical databases
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Registries
• The introduction of new elements is not pre-planned (no schedule).
– relate to the pace of patients entry
– events entry
• The purpose of the registry defines the types of registry:
– Disease registry
– Drug registry
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Registries
• Disease registry:– to estimate incidence of diseases
– pace of new entries = occurrence of new cases
• Drug registry:– The main purpose of such registries is the
identification of adverse events
– pace of entry = initiation of new treatments, of a target drug or therapeutic group, in patients who meet the inclusion criteria
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Cohorts
• Studies set up for testing hypotheses. – Sensu strictu aetiological hypotheses
– they can also be assembled to test prognosis, or to test resource use hypothesis
• Subjects in a cohort must be sampled in a probabilistic way (to be representative).
• Timing of data entry pre-established in visits or examinations at a given interval (periodical).
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Cohorts (concepts)
• Inception cohort– all new cases
– or early
• Nested case-control studies– advantage: cases and controls selected equally
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Cohorts (concepts)
• Open cohorts– Permanent incorporation
– allow the study of the simultaneous influence of calendar time, age (duration) and cohort (onset) in demography, epidemiology, and clinical follow-up
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Cohorts (concepts)
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Cohorts (concepts)
• Closed cohorts– specific research objective (sample size)
– recruitment period
– subjects become older with follow-up
• Permanent surveys– examination over time is established in
repeated cross-sectional surveys
large open cohorts which are monitored over such a long time (Framingham study)
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Cohorts (concepts)
• Randomised controlled trials
– cohorts in which the hypothesis is the efficacy of an intervention
– Not a LOS (planned intervention)
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Cohorts (concepts)
• Aren’t prognosis or resource use studies cohorts?
– OK if the sample is selected in a probabilistic way
– and the hypothesis is pre-established before the launch of the cohort:• link between exposure to prognostic factors
(i.e. determinants) and rate of occurrence of outcome
• link between determinants and rate of use or cost
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Types of databases
1. Registries
2. Cohorts
3. Administrative databases
4. Clinical databases
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Administrative databases
• Specific purpose: managing the economic and organization aspects
• They allow to assess and preview:– the need of workforce – allocation of resources– logistic needs– insurance monitoring– costs, etc.
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Administrative databases as surrogatesPROS
• rapid response (availability)
• large sets of population (increases statistical power)
CONS
• severe selection bias
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Administrative databases’ best use
• To cross-check data in clinical databases:
– to confirm death,
– work status,
– drug consumption...
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Clinical databases
• Quite often physicians record patients characteristic and variables directly from their practice in an intent to monitor health care practices.
• The resulting clinical databases are useful to:– retrieve patients’ reports
– Retrieve individual clinical histories
– assess the individual practice composition of a department or a clinic
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Clinical databases’ bias
• The patients included have not been selected in a probabilistic way, what precludes the use of formal hypothesis testing statistical instruments.
• Representativity
• Difficulty to record all variables with the expected quality of a main outcome variable if one does not know ahead of time what the main outcome variable will be (study protocol)
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Clinical databases’ best use
• To monitor practice
• To identify patients with a given characteristic, and to use them to draw a random sample, better if multicentre, and to test prospectively a research hypothesis
Vienna, June 11th, 2005
Different designs of LOS
Conclusions
• We should bear in mind the meaning and use of databases.
• Different types of databases serve very different purposes.
• A clear understanding of the different investigation designs should avoid many of the databases we launch be just a lot of work and very little of science.