A Case Report of Successful Long-term Relapse Control by Protein-A Immunoadsorption in an...

7
A Case Report of Successful Long-term Relapse Control by Protein-A Immunoadsorption in an Immunosuppressive-treated Patient With End-stage Renal Disease Due to Wegener’s Granulomatosis Michael Koch, Matthias Kohnle, and Rudolf Trapp Center of Nephrology, Mettmann, Germany Abstract: A long-term female hemodialysis patient with end-stage renal disease due to Wegener’s granulomatosis (WG) experienced a severe relapse when immunosuppres- sive therapy was switched from prednisone and cyclophos- phamide to azathioprine maintenance therapy.Ten courses of protein A immunoadsorption therapy and switching immunosuppressive therapy to mycophenolate mofetil have proved to be very successful and free of side effects. The patient has fully recovered from all clinical WG symptoms and is still in remission ten months after the treatment. Key Words: End-stage renal disease, Immuno- suppressive therapy, Protein A immunoadsorption, Relapse, Wegener’s granulomatosis. Wegener’s granulomatosis (WG) is a form of small- and medium-sized vessel vasculitis of unknown etiology that affects mainly the upper airways, lungs, kidneys, and other organs. Due to its end-organ damage, it can be a serious disease with a typical relapsing–remitting course that requires long- term treatment with immunosuppressive therapy (1). It is named after Friedrich Wegener, who described the disease in 1936 (2). Organ inflammatory damage is mediated by cytoplasmic-staining antineutrophil- cytoplasmic-antibodies (cANCA), and their detec- tion is a component of the diagnosis, as well as clinical signs and symptoms, and histopathological biopsy abnormalities. We describe the case of a young female patient with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) and WG undergoing long-term hemodialysis, whose clinical and serological symptoms could be controlled using long-term immunosuppressive therapy with prednisone and oral and intravenous pulse cyclo- phosphamide, but who developed serious, fulminant symptoms after being switched to azathioprine, which, however, could be successfully treated by protein A immunoadsorption (IA). The remarkable aspect of this case is that although under long-term hemodialytic and immunosuppressive therapy, her WG became active and fulminant after switching to azathioprine. However, protein A IA therapy, used in lieu of conventional plasma separation and known as a procedure being carried out without serious side effects in a significant number of treatments to date (3), proved very effective and free of side-effects in our case as well. The patient completely recovered from all WG symptoms and is still in remission ten months after this treatment. CASE REPORT A 31-year-old female patient (height 173 cm,weight 67 kg) presented in October 2001 with a long history of the usual symptoms of WG (see Table 1). Our patient exhibited involvement of the lung and kidneys, and despite effective long-term immunosup- pression therapy (lymphocyte count < 1000/mm 3 ) with prednisone and oral and intravenous pulse cyclo- phosphamide, she developed severe symptoms asso- ciated with frailness, weakness, and the worsening of Received February 2008; revised June 2008. Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr Michael Koch, Gartenstraße 8, 40822 Mettmann, Germany.Tel: +49 2104 979 960; Fax: +49 2104 979 9671; Email: Koch@dialyse- mettmann.de Therapeutic Apheresis and Dialysis 13(2):150–156 doi: 10.1111/j.1744-9987.2009.00670.x © 2009 The Authors Journal compilation © 2009 International Society for Apheresis 150

Transcript of A Case Report of Successful Long-term Relapse Control by Protein-A Immunoadsorption in an...

A Case Report of Successful Long-term Relapse Controlby Protein-A Immunoadsorption in an

Immunosuppressive-treated Patient With End-stage RenalDisease Due to Wegener’s Granulomatosis

Michael Koch, Matthias Kohnle, and Rudolf Trapp

Center of Nephrology, Mettmann, Germany

Abstract: A long-term female hemodialysis patient withend-stage renal disease due to Wegener’s granulomatosis(WG) experienced a severe relapse when immunosuppres-sive therapy was switched from prednisone and cyclophos-phamide to azathioprine maintenance therapy. Ten coursesof protein A immunoadsorption therapy and switchingimmunosuppressive therapy to mycophenolate mofetil

have proved to be very successful and free of side effects.The patient has fully recovered from all clinical WGsymptoms and is still in remission ten months after thetreatment. Key Words: End-stage renal disease, Immuno-suppressive therapy, Protein A immunoadsorption,Relapse, Wegener’s granulomatosis.

Wegener’s granulomatosis (WG) is a form ofsmall- and medium-sized vessel vasculitis ofunknown etiology that affects mainly the upperairways, lungs, kidneys, and other organs. Due to itsend-organ damage, it can be a serious disease with atypical relapsing–remitting course that requires long-term treatment with immunosuppressive therapy (1).It is named after Friedrich Wegener, who describedthe disease in 1936 (2). Organ inflammatory damageis mediated by cytoplasmic-staining antineutrophil-cytoplasmic-antibodies (cANCA), and their detec-tion is a component of the diagnosis, as well as clinicalsigns and symptoms, and histopathological biopsyabnormalities. We describe the case of a youngfemale patient with end-stage renal disease (ESRD)and WG undergoing long-term hemodialysis, whoseclinical and serological symptoms could be controlledusing long-term immunosuppressive therapy withprednisone and oral and intravenous pulse cyclo-phosphamide, but who developed serious, fulminant

symptoms after being switched to azathioprine,which, however, could be successfully treated byprotein A immunoadsorption (IA). The remarkableaspect of this case is that although under long-termhemodialytic and immunosuppressive therapy, herWG became active and fulminant after switching toazathioprine. However, protein A IA therapy, used inlieu of conventional plasma separation and known asa procedure being carried out without serious sideeffects in a significant number of treatments to date(3), proved very effective and free of side-effects inour case as well. The patient completely recoveredfrom all WG symptoms and is still in remission tenmonths after this treatment.

CASE REPORT

A 31-year-old female patient (height 173 cm,weight67 kg) presented in October 2001 with a long historyof the usual symptoms of WG (see Table 1). Ourpatient exhibited involvement of the lung andkidneys, and despite effective long-term immunosup-pression therapy (lymphocyte count < 1000/mm3)with prednisone and oral and intravenous pulse cyclo-phosphamide, she developed severe symptoms asso-ciated with frailness, weakness, and the worsening of

Received February 2008; revised June 2008.Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr Michael

Koch, Gartenstraße 8, 40822 Mettmann, Germany. Tel: +49 2104979 960; Fax: +49 2104 979 9671; Email: [email protected]

Therapeutic Apheresis and Dialysis 13(2):150–156doi: 10.1111/j.1744-9987.2009.00670.x© 2009 The AuthorsJournal compilation © 2009 International Society for Apheresis

150

TAB

LE

1.M

edic

alhi

stor

yof

the

patie

nt(b

orn

1970

)be

twee

nJu

ne19

96–J

une

2007

Dat

eC

linic

alL

abor

ator

yD

iagn

osti

csT

hera

py

June

1996

Firs

tsy

mpt

oms

appe

aras

uppe

rja

wpa

in;c

ondi

tion

was

trea

ted

repe

ated

lyby

ade

ntal

prac

titi

oner

;he

arin

gim

pair

men

t

N/A

N/A

N/A

Aug

ust

1996

Ear

drum

perf

orat

ion

and

max

illar

ysi

nusi

tis

(lat

eral

sofr

onta

lsin

usit

is);

alte

rnat

ing

mus

culo

skel

etal

sym

ptom

spa

rtic

ular

lypr

eval

ent

inth

eba

ckof

the

neck

and

foot

N/A

N/A

Alt

erna

ting

anti

biot

icth

erap

y:su

lfam

etho

xazo

l/tri

met

hrop

rim

,ce

phal

ospo

rin,

and

clin

dam

ycin

Sept

embe

r19

96Te

mpe

ratu

res,

slig

htpr

oduc

tive

coug

h,no

sebl

eeds

N/A

N/A

N/A

Oct

ober

1996

Swel

ling

of2n

dra

yof

righ

tha

ndan

d3r

dra

yof

left

hand

;wei

ght

loss

(5kg

);ho

spit

aliz

atio

n

Wes

terg

ren

ESR

110/

130

mm

(inc

reas

ed);

leuc

ocyt

es26

.2/n

L(m

ax.)

(inc

reas

ed);

thro

mbo

cyte

s86

4mL

(max

.)(i

ncre

ased

);he

mog

lobi

n10

.4g/

dL(n

orm

al);

CR

P9.

1m

g/dL

(inc

reas

ed);

crea

tini

ne0.

75m

g/dL

(nor

mal

);pr

otei

nuri

a0.

5g/

L,m

inim

ally

sele

ctiv

egl

omer

ular

and

low

-gra

delo

w-m

olec

ular

prot

einu

ria,

mic

rosc

opic

anal

ysis

reve

aled

pred

omin

antl

ydy

smor

phic

eryt

hroc

ytes

;no

hist

olog

ical

confi

rmat

ion

atth

isti

me

Che

stX

-ray

:bila

tera

lpar

tial

lydi

ffus

e,pa

rtia

llyci

rcum

scri

bed

intr

apul

mon

ary

opac

ifica

tion

,m

ost

pron

ounc

edin

the

righ

tlo

wer

field

,whi

chre

gres

sed

duri

ngth

eco

urse

ofim

mun

osup

pres

sion

Che

stC

T:t

ypic

algr

anul

omas

indi

cati

veof

WG

,mul

tipl

eoc

curr

ence

sof

pleu

ralt

hick

enin

gP

aran

asal

sinu

sC

T:p

olyp

oid

muc

osal

swel

ling

inth

eri

ght

max

illar

ysi

nus,

left

side

dm

axill

ary

sinu

sop

acifi

cati

on,

ethm

oida

lcel

lopa

cific

atio

n(l

eft>

righ

t),m

ucos

alsw

ellin

gin

the

sphe

noid

alsi

nus,

opac

ifica

tion

ofal

llef

tm

asto

idce

lls

Met

hylp

redn

isol

one

250

mg

4–6

Oct

,th

en60

mg

wit

hgr

adua

ldos

ere

duct

ion

→cy

clop

hosp

ham

ide

750

mg

bolu

s8

Oct

,the

nor

alth

erap

y10

0m

g/da

yun

tilJ

une

1997

,the

ndi

scon

tinu

atio

nof

ther

apy

afte

rre

mis

sion

Apr

il19

99A

fter

anas

sum

edflu

-lik

ein

fect

ion,

ther

ew

asoc

curr

ence

ofjo

int

and

mus

cula

rpa

in,m

ucos

alsw

ellin

gin

the

para

nasa

lsin

uses

and

incr

ease

dpr

otei

nuri

a

N/A

N/A

Cor

tiso

neth

erap

y10

0m

g/da

yw

ith

regr

essi

onof

sym

ptom

s

July

2000

Mus

cula

rpa

inan

djo

int

pain

,the

nep

iscl

erit

is,p

aran

asal

sinu

ssy

mpt

oms,

skin

chan

ges

(han

ds)

N/A

N/A

Pre

dnis

one

100

mg/

day

Dec

embe

r20

00In

crea

sed

prot

einu

ria,

hype

rten

sion

;re

nalb

iops

y:m

esan

giop

rolif

erat

ive

glom

erul

onep

hrit

is

Cre

atin

ine

1.4

mg/

dLL

owdo

sepr

edni

sone

Wegener’s Granulomatosis Relapse Control 151

© 2009 The AuthorsJournal compilation © 2009 International Society for Apheresis Ther Apher Dial, Vol. 13, No. 2, 2009

TAB

LE

1.C

ontin

ued

Dat

eC

linic

alL

abor

ator

yD

iagn

osti

csT

hera

py

Oct

ober

2001

(ref

erra

lto

our

cent

er)

Seco

ndre

nalb

iops

y:ra

pidl

ypr

ogre

ssiv

egl

omer

ulon

ephr

itis

wit

had

vanc

edsc

arri

ng,o

nly

disc

rete

rece

ntne

crot

izin

gin

tra-

and

extr

acap

illar

ygl

omer

ulon

ephr

itis

,ex

tens

ive

foca

ltub

ular

atro

phy

and

inte

rsti

tial

fibro

sis

Cre

atin

ine

1.7

mg/

dL;E

CC

34m

L/m

in;p

rote

inur

ia51

00m

g/24

h;cA

NC

A63

RU

/mL

N/A

N/A

Nov

embe

r20

01N

/AC

reat

inin

e2.

6m

g/dL

N/A

1st

puls

ecy

clop

hosp

ham

ide

ther

apy

ofth

iscy

cle

(100

0m

g)

Dec

embe

r20

01P

ersi

sten

tal

tern

atin

gjo

int

pain

,m

yopa

thy

has

subs

ided

,im

prov

edhe

alth

stat

us;n

olo

nger

join

tpa

in,

heal

thst

atus

cont

inue

sto

impr

ove;

pete

chia

lble

edin

gof

the

thig

h;co

ntin

ued

putr

idbl

oody

secr

etio

nfr

omth

eno

se

Cre

atin

ine

3.5

mg/

dL;E

CC

21.5

mL

/min

;pro

tein

uria

5300

mg/

24h;

Hb

10.3

g/dL

;le

ucoc

ytes

1100

0/mL

N/A

2nd

puls

ecy

clop

hosp

ham

ide

ther

apy

600

mg,

epoe

tin

alfa

ther

apy

Janu

ary

2002

Con

tinu

edhy

pert

ensi

on,l

ower

thig

hed

emas

,occ

asio

nalt

inni

tus

righ

tea

r,no

long

erna

sals

peak

ing,

nom

yopa

thy,

occa

sion

alca

lfm

uscl

ecr

amps

atni

ght,

cont

inue

dne

phro

tic

stat

e,qu

esti

onab

leal

lerg

icch

ange

sof

the

skin

unde

rur

omet

ixan

,im

prov

emen

taf

ter

disc

onti

nuat

ion

Cre

atin

ine

5.07

mg/

dL;E

CC

14.4

mL

/min

;pro

tein

uria

6118

mg/

24h;

Hb

11.7

g/dL

;le

ucoc

ytes

7100

/mL

;cA

NC

Ane

gati

ve

N/A

3rd

puls

ecy

clop

hosp

ham

ide

ther

apy

600

mg

Aug

ust

2002

N/A

Cre

atin

ine

5.99

mg/

dL;E

CC

12m

L/m

in;p

rote

inur

ia24

91m

g/24

h

N/A

Firs

the

mod

ialy

sis

via

Cim

ino

shun

t

Oct

ober

2002

Dys

plas

tic

nevo

cellu

lar

nevu

sof

the

righ

tba

ckN

/AN

/AN

/A

Apr

il–Ju

ne20

03R

ecur

rent

hem

opty

sis,

mal

aise

cAN

CA

20R

U/m

LN

/AIn

itia

ltri

ple

cycl

opho

spha

mid

ehi

gh-d

ose

ther

apy

750

mg

+25

0m

gpr

edni

solo

ne,t

hen

step

wis

ere

duct

ion,

sulf

amet

hoxa

zole

/tr

imet

hopr

impr

ophy

laxi

s;fr

omJu

n–O

ct20

03:l

ong-

term

azat

hiop

rine

trea

tmen

t

Sept

embe

r20

03Jo

int

pain

,myo

path

ycA

NC

A50

RU

/mL

N/A

Pre

dnis

one

incr

ease

dto

75m

g/da

y

M Koch et al.152

© 2009 The AuthorsJournal compilation © 2009 International Society for ApheresisTher Apher Dial, Vol. 13, No. 2, 2009

TAB

LE

1.C

ontin

ued

Dat

eC

linic

alL

abor

ator

yD

iagn

osti

csT

hera

py

Oct

ober

–Nov

embe

r20

03H

emop

tysi

s,re

curr

ent

join

tpa

inof

PIP

3-D

III

righ

t,bi

late

ralk

nee

join

tscA

NC

A20

RU

/mL

N/A

Ora

lcyc

loph

osph

amid

eth

erap

y10

0m

g/da

ysi

nce

1O

ct20

03,a

nd50

mg/

day

sinc

e11

Oct

2003

plus

sulf

amet

hoxa

zole

/tri

met

hopr

im;

pred

niso

ne50

mg

wit

hst

epw

ise

redu

ctio

n;cy

clop

hosp

ham

ide

50m

gev

ery

2da

ysbe

ginn

ing

15N

ov20

03

Mar

ch–A

ugus

t20

04N

osy

mpt

oms

cAN

CA

64R

U/m

LN

/AC

yclo

phos

pham

ide

50m

g/da

y,th

enev

ery

2da

ys50

mg

unti

lDec

2004

,th

en50

mg/

day,

begi

nnin

g18

Feb

2005

agai

nev

ery

seco

ndda

y50

mg

unti

l22

Apr

,the

n50

mg/

day;

pred

niso

nedi

scon

tinu

edon

14M

ar20

05;l

ast

dose

was

2.5

mg/

day

Mar

ch–A

ugus

t20

05N

osy

mpt

oms

cAN

CA

92R

U/m

LN

/AA

pr–A

ug20

05:5

0m

gcy

clop

hosp

ham

ide/

day;

inA

ug20

05:

swit

chfr

omcy

clop

hosp

ham

ide

toaz

athi

opri

ne50

mg/

day,

then

75m

g/da

y

Mar

ch–N

ovem

ber

2006

No

sym

ptom

sN

/AN

/A50

mg

azat

hiop

rine

/day

;as

ofJu

l20

06:d

ose

alte

rnat

edbe

twee

n50

and

25m

gda

ily;a

sof

Nov

2006

:100

mg,

then

75m

g

Janu

ary

2007

See

sym

ptom

sbe

twee

n19

96an

d20

03cA

NC

A14

3R

U/m

LN

/AA

sof

Jan

2007

azat

hiop

rine

:50

mg;

asof

Feb

2007

:75

mg/

day

May

–Jun

e20

07A

sust

aine

dsi

gnifi

cant

impr

ovem

ent

ofsy

mpt

oms

was

alre

ady

obse

rved

whi

lepr

otei

nA

IAth

erap

yw

ason

goin

g

cAN

CA

573

RU

/mL

N/A

As

of23

May

2007

:150

mg/

day

pred

niso

new

ith

step

wis

ere

duct

ion;

10im

mun

oads

orpt

ions

from

24M

ay–1

2Ju

n20

07;c

yclo

phos

pham

ide

700

mg

on31

May

2007

;as

of12

Jun

2007

:myc

ophe

nola

tem

ofet

il2

¥50

0m

g/da

y

cAN

CA

,cyt

opla

smic

-sta

inin

gan

tine

utro

phil-

cyto

plas

mic

-ant

ibod

ies,

the

pres

ente

dva

lues

are

the

high

est

mea

sure

din

asp

ecifi

cm

onth

orra

nge

ofm

onth

s;C

RP,

C-r

eact

ive

prot

ein;

EC

C,

esti

mat

edcr

eati

nine

clea

ranc

e;E

SR,

eryt

hroc

yte

sedi

men

tati

onra

te;

Hb,

hem

oglo

bin;

IA,

imm

unoa

dsor

ptio

n;N

/A,

not

appl

icab

leor

not

avai

labl

e;P

IP3-

DII

I,3r

dpr

oxim

alin

terp

hala

ngea

ljoi

ntof

the

3rd

digi

t;W

G,W

egen

er’s

gran

ulom

atos

is.

Wegener’s Granulomatosis Relapse Control 153

© 2009 The AuthorsJournal compilation © 2009 International Society for Apheresis Ther Apher Dial, Vol. 13, No. 2, 2009

her overall health, without typical organ involvement(e.g. hemoptysis) after being switched to azathioprinemaintenance therapy. Concentrations of the mostcommon biomarker of WG (cANCA bound to theproteinase-3 [PR3] target) ranged between 0 and 92relative units (RU) per millimeter between October2001 and December 2006 (see Table 1), but signifi-cantly increased (without complement depletion)starting August 2005 under azathioprine therapy,reaching its peak in May 2007 (see Fig. 1) and includ-ing significant deterioration of her overall generalhealth.

Due to the severe worsening of the patient’s clini-cal status, our patient was subjected to ten sessions ofprotein A IA therapy—which, in contrast to conven-tional plasma exchange, selectively removes immu-noglobulins and immune complexes from plasma—between May and June 2007 using protein A columns(Immunosorba; Fresenius Medical Care, Bad Hom-burg, Germany), while immunosuppression therapywas switched to mycophenolate mofetil. We havepreviously described the procedure of protein A IA(4). In the present case, the patient received fourtreatment cycles per week, with 5–6 L of processedplasma during each cycle.

With increasing cANCA titers, our patient experi-enced the following symptoms and signs: increasingweakness, weight loss of 3 kg, intermittently elevatedtemperatures of up to 38°C (100.4°F), a mild, non-focal increase in C-reactive protein, no signs of leu-

kocytosis, no symptoms associated with the joints(such as pain, swelling, or redness), nasal speech, non-bacterial conjunctivitis, severe malaise, an increase inblood pressure, hoarse voice, and a productive coughwith bloody imbibition.

During the initial treatment the patient’s weaknesshad further progressed, and she reported thatbetween the first and second treatment cycles she hadbeen suffering from severe back pain despite takingparacetamol. As of the third treatment, the patientwas slowly feeling clinically better, although herhemoglobin (Hb) level had dropped to as low as7.8 g/dL. Due to persisting low Hb levels despiteadministration of high doses of erythropoietin, thepatient was subjected to a blood transfusion duringthe seventh protein A IA treatment, which causedthe Hb levels to increase to 10.0 g/dL. The leukocytecount remained between 5500 and 7800/mL duringthe entire course of treatment.

The final, tenth protein A IA treatment took placeon 12 June 2007 and the patient felt much improved;however, she did complain of some newly developedrespiratory-related symptoms in the left paraverte-bral region that finally disappeared, and prednisonedose could then be reduced to 10 mg per day. Tenmonths after treatment, the patient is currently incomplete disease remission without any clinicalsymptoms of WG.

Concentrations of cANCA decreased markedly(see Fig. 1) from the beginning of protein A IA treat-ment, and since the beginning of October 2007cANCA has either not been detectable or is presentin very low concentrations (20 RU/mL in April 2008).Also, since all other subclasses of immunoglobulin G(IgG) are also eliminated by the protein A column,the serum IgG titer reached a value as low as44 mg/dL at the conclusion of the ninth protein A IAtreatment (reference range 800–1800 mg/dL).

DISCUSSION

We have described the case of a young woman withESRD due to WG, who had been undergoing long-term hemodialytic and immunosuppressive treat-ment in order to successfully control her clinical andserological WG symptoms and signs. However, afterbeing switched to the standard maintenance therapyazathioprine, the patient developed a disease relapsewith slowly increasing anti-PR3/cANCA levels(Table 1 and Fig. 1), but initially without concomitantclinical symptoms. After reaching the peak cANCAlevel (573 RU/mL), her clinical symptoms becamefulminant and her overall health markedly deterio-rated. A single treatment of intravenous pulse cyclo-

02/0

703

/07

04/0

705

/07

06/0

707

/07

08/0

709

/07

10/0

7

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Time (month/year)

protein A IA mycophenolate mofetilazathioprine

c-A

NC

A (

RU

/mL

)

FIG. 1. Blood serum concentrations (relative units, RU) ofthe antiproteinase-3 (PR3)/cytoplasmic-staining antineutrophil-cytoplasmic-antibody (cANCA) complex between February andOctober 2007, measured by ELISA immunoassay. All values arethe highest measured in a specific month. Starting August 2005, thepatient had been under azathioprine immunosuppression therapy75 mg/day. Starting in May 2007, the patient was switched toprotein A immunoadsorption therapy (IA) with additional immu-nosuppressive cyclophosphamide (700 mg) on 31 May 2007, whichwas replaced by mycophenolate mofetil (2 ¥ 500 mg/day) starting12 June 2007 (see Table 1).

M Koch et al.154

© 2009 The AuthorsJournal compilation © 2009 International Society for ApheresisTher Apher Dial, Vol. 13, No. 2, 2009

phosphamide and ten courses of protein A IAtherapy combined with mycophenolate mofetilmaintenance therapy, however, resulted in completeremission of WG. While still under hemodialysis andmycophenolate mofetil immunosuppressive therapy,the patient is currently completely rehabilitated andclinically and serologically symptom-free half a yearafter protein A IA.

Our WG patient on long-term hemodialysis hadbeen treated with standard therapy to successfullycontrol clinical and serological symptoms of thedisease. Standard management of WG can be dividedin two stages: induction or remission by cyclophos-phamide and prednisone, and maintenance therapyby, for instance, azathioprine to reduce toxicity due tocumulative cyclophosphamide (5,6). Several authorshave found that hemodialysis itself, either withoutor with minimal immunosuppressive therapy, mayprotect, although not always, against disease activity(7,8) or relapse (9), whereas others could not confirma different relapse rate between dialyzed and non-dialyzed WG patients (10). We assume that in ourpatient the relapse of WG, reflected by increases ofPR3/cANCA levels and concomitant fulminant clini-cal symptoms, may be due to azathioprine failure. Wetherefore switched azathioprine therapy to plasma-pheresis therapy in the form of protein A IA, whichhad previously proved successful in similar cases(11,12), in combination with mycophenolate mofetilas long-term maintenance therapy.

The rationale behind the therapy used was toreduce or eliminate cANCA titers and all other sub-classes of IgG by protein A IA (and consequently toimprove the described clinical symptoms), whileinhibiting new cANCA formation by adding myco-phenolate mofetil to the treatment regimen. Myco-phenolate mofetil has shown favorable results in thetreatment of WG (13). A high-maintenance therapywith cyclophosphamide was not considered becausethe patient had previously been treated with cyclo-phosphamide and had already received a high totalcumulative dose during the course of her illness.

Alternative treatments for WG have beendescribed in the literature, for example Iwatani et al.(14) have successfully used double filtration plasma-pheresis (DFPP) in combination with steroids andimmunosuppressants in a patient in whom WG wasassociated with severe pulmonary bleeding. Nonethe-less, DFPP has been mainly described in retrospec-tive case reports from Japanese authors, mainly inconjunction with Guillain–Barré syndrome (15).Other authors describe the use of intravenousimmunoglobulin (IVIg) in patients with cANCA-associated systemic vasculitis who suffered from per-

sistent disease or who were poor respondersto conventional therapy (16,17). Richter et al. (16),however, observed a benefit in only 40% of hispatients, whereas complete remission of diseaseactivity did not occur in any of them. Jayne et al. (17)described mild adverse effects in all of his 17 IVIg-treated patients.

CONCLUSION

We understand that WG patients may respond dif-ferently toward a certain therapy and that generaliza-tion about the most beneficial therapy in thesepatients may not be possible. However, in our specificcase of a WG patient with failed standard mainte-nance therapy, protein A IA therapy—which does nothave the risk of transmitting any microorganisms orviruses and during which a high volume of plasma canbe processed, removing up to 87% of the initial levelof IgG in one session without a clinically significantloss of fibrinogen—combined with the immunosup-pressant mycophenolate mofetil proved very success-ful clinically, meaning that ten months after protein AIA, and while still under hemodialysis and mycophe-nolate mofetil therapy, our patient is completely reha-bilitated. We consider that achieving long-termremission under the described therapy that does notinclude any long-term, high-dose cyclophosphamidetherapy is rather unique and has, to our knowledge,not yet been described in the literature. The clinicalimprovement was associated serologically with a sig-nificant decrease of cANCA and IgG levels, support-ing the notion that the cANCA titer level is a goodindicator of disease activity and correlates very wellwith disease severity, at least for the higher titer levelssuch as those observed in our patient.

Acknowledgments: We thank Silke Haidekker, PhD,ELS, for her excellent assistance in the preparation of themanuscript.

REFERENCES

1. Seo P, Stone JH. The antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibody-associated vasculitides. Am J Med 2004;117:39–50.

2. Wegener F. Über generalisierte, septische Gefässerkrankun-gen. Report of 3 cases. Verh Dtsch Ges Pathol 1936; 29:202.

3. Belak M, Borberg H, Jimenez C, Oette K. Technical and clini-cal experience with protein A immunoadsorption columns.Transfus Sci 1994;15:419–22.

4. Koch M, Trapp R. Ethyl mercury poisoning during a proteinA immunoadsorption treatment. Am J Kidney Dis 2006;47:e31–4.

5. Riccieri V, Valesini G. [Treatment of Wegener’s granulomato-sis]. Reumatismo 2004;56:69–76.

6. Haubitz M. ANCA-associated vasculitis: diagnosis, clinicalcharacteristics and treatment. Vasa 2007;36:81–9.

Wegener’s Granulomatosis Relapse Control 155

© 2009 The AuthorsJournal compilation © 2009 International Society for Apheresis Ther Apher Dial, Vol. 13, No. 2, 2009

7. Pedersen RS, Aunsholt NA. Hemodialysis does not alwaysprotect against recurrence of Wegener’s granulomatosis.Scand J Urol Nephrol 1990;24:223–5.

8. Kuross S, Davin T, Kjellstrand CM. Wegener’s granulomatosiswith severe renal failure: clinical course and results of dialysisand transplantation. Clin Nephrol 1981;16:172–80.

9. Weidanz F, Day CJ, Hewins P, Savage CO, Harper L. Recur-rences and infections during continuous immunosuppressivetherapy after beginning dialysis in ANCA-associated vasculi-tis. Am J Kidney Dis 2007;50:36–46.

10. Haubitz M, Koch KM, Brunkhorst R. Survival and vasculitisactivity in patients with end-stage renal disease due toWegener’s granulomatosis. Nephrol Dial Transplant 1998;13:1713–8.

11. Matic G, Michelsen A, Hofmann D et al. Three cases ofC-ANCA-positive vasculitis treated with immunoadsorption:possible benefit in early treatment. Ther Apher 2001;5:68–72.

12. Schneidewind J, Gliesche T, Sehland D et al. [Protein A immu-noadsorption al a new apheresis procedure for elimination of

HLA antibodies]. Beitr Infusionsther Transfusionsmed 1994;32:360–5.

13. Antoniu SA. Treatment options for refractory Wegener’sgranulomatosis: a role for rituximab? Curr Opin InvestigDrugs 2007;8:927–32.

14. Iwatani H, Uzu T, Kakihara M et al. A case of Wegener’sgranulomatosis with pulmonary bleeding successfully treatedwith double filtration plasmapheresis (DFPP). Clin ExpNephrol 2004;8:369–74.

15. Lyu RK, Chen WH, Hsieh ST. Plasma exchange versus doublefiltration plasmapheresis in the treatment of Guillain-Barresyndrome. Ther Apher 2002;6:163–6.

16. Richter C, Schnabel A, Csernok E, De Groot K, Reinhold-Keller E, Gross WL. Treatment of anti-neutrophil cytoplasmicantibody (ANCA)-associated systemic vasculitis with high-dose intravenous immunoglobulin. Clin Exp Immunol 1995;101:2–7.

17. Jayne DR, Chapel H, Adu D et al. Intravenous immunoglobu-lin for ANCA-associated systemic vasculitis with persistentdisease activity. QJM 2000;93:433–9.

M Koch et al.156

© 2009 The AuthorsJournal compilation © 2009 International Society for ApheresisTher Apher Dial, Vol. 13, No. 2, 2009