a. Affairs/z2... · 2019. 5. 21. · OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program Darlington Nuclear...
Transcript of a. Affairs/z2... · 2019. 5. 21. · OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program Darlington Nuclear...
OPG Darlington Refurtilshment Program
. 4,4 ,~
'· "polli·OI·tooling aria eq'!Jlpmerif J " $ ., H
4::':0,,). 4,:io.b) . Ho c) 4.10 d)
4.10 e) 4.1011
4.10 g)
, ~ecutjon
, Betrollflil 6f
Execution
Forthe plirpose , Firm Price for Primary Side,Cleaning consists'of prices with the following
, pppJ/aable.lndiCf!~:
rvr w e pu'pu,e q~ _ CostAdJustments, the Firm Pric~fo: Primary Side Cleaning.consists of prices-with the following
tlnde' ,3
Iindex '" DodoxS.
Tear , .. ' . Qis.c ,nn«pM'remove cables ..
" Coordinate , . Coordinate.cleao.up of work, are. as and t('liler
Ship " ,
II, "h . , ~'i_<i'
location-n:n~i;~nt w;t~ op~'~r~~~'u-r~ bou~d~ry progra,!,
,",1 '~O"he2."r= (lo't~' _ ___ ~' (Ilrop_onentti> Imort additional 110'" Itom, 1>.lo"flf r"uired]
For the purpose oJ. colcvrormg Econiimic' , iho Fi;;n . , ; VI price,. WI'" m"IVUuwmg
, I Reports
Tu;b~ a~d:P l lig Primary Sid. Inspect ions
iln~rt ' iJ.oms ~1QW: ", rea:u!rj,dl
PrfntedJ l/29/2013 at 9:35 AM
S'
"
I S
~,-
$ IS ' $
S
$
'S $
$ $.
.:.:'
_$.
, ' . c· ',, : .,
:.:. -~ '1:1J,5Q3~ _1,088$ 126;415 , ~o,OQq ~ ..:. .i '1,088 1',088 $
, • , $ - , $
'. 360,810 ' 3.871408 ,§ 30,17'1 , ;_". 3!1,~ a.
167,841 ~..1 --'.:..L::' ..1
.~
86,02 ,,$6,021
- ,";
6,2$0 " : !.:6;-2SlI $ .
.'. ", '
, 1>5 >'
..t ~ Ii. tt ..1
$ $ $' $ $ $
J~ "S,'
65,787 . 65,055
2 26,484 27,2.16
S·' "'- "
:,' "
. +;,","' , 13,O~ ~~
,,: "',;;'--~ . 40,959 ."--'\9;95' . 40,959 -:.40,959
,
:..t
~ :;~ , S
1;088 :$) .
" .'S'
, . S-~..1
' .1.. _ .... S,
,
" .:;.
387.408 I: S ' 387.408
30,031 1,$ 30,031
~~11$ 134,29f
" S, ---- _$ ~ !~
!l ,~~, .369,OM
86;021 86,021 344;084 ...• · "
, · , , ·
.. ' 6,250 6.250 ' 25, -.- · '.
· $
· · $, ,
,
~ .1: ':, ;$ -' , - ' " . $ :
, . 1 S
· , $ ' " .. , s' ~ .~,' $
"
, 65,055 .-~ ,
27,216 27,216 d _c_ c ·
~ '-, ·
~ LJS'i 11$:,
--=- .$
~ - ' · , 13.050 13,050. 52,200
, ' " .
_~,959 . 4Q,!!:>:!i -.1.'.-', 40,959 40,959 ' 163,S36
..:. · · ·
· .:;. $
Page 20/3
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 386 of 573
Version: R05
Prlnttd 11/29/2013 at 9:3~ AM
Fa,: the purpose of calculating. Economic Cost Adjustments, the Firm Price/or I?rimory Side {;Ieaning consists of prices with the following
OP.G Darlington Refurbishment Program
Page 3 of 3
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 387 of 573
'. Darlingt~h Nud~ar Generatlng'Station SteamGen~rator .Refurbishmel1t ONTARIOPOWER . . 'G6NERATION
..... . . v
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 388 of 573
OPG Darl!ngton Refurbishm~nt Progriilm
Prlllted.1.2/29!20J3ot9;J6AM
1 I !
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 389 of 573
Darlington Nuclear Generating Station Steam,Generator Refurbishment
7.1(15) Target ',Cost for Reimbursable Work for Support Services and Equipment
Printed 1.1/29/2013, 9:~6 AM
OP~ Darlington Refurbishment Program
ONTARIOPiiiiiEiI '
Page 1 ojl
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 390 of 573
Darlington ·Nuclear"Generatin-g.Statlon Steam Generator Refurbishment
7.1(16fCost Flow for Reiinbursable Work' Support Servlces.& Equipment PrOvide"forecasted annual expendituresJorthe pu rPoses of apP'lving Econ~mic_CostAdjustm7nts to AdJusta~le,Costs
lndUnlt
Index3 273,424.87 -$ 352,982.98 ' $
41,Ol~.73$ 52,947.4$ $
- Pa e 1 of4-
OPG Darlfngton Refurbishment, Progra"m
DNTARIOFOiiiER . . . GENERATION
·s .~ .:iOO,227.63
Pr/ntr:d,12/3/2013, 4:46 P,¥
-I
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 391 of 573
OPG Darlingtol rbishmeni, Program"
3rd Unit
-Page2of4-- Printed .12/3/2013, 4:46 PM
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 392 of 573
/
.OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
Darlington ' Nuclear Generating Station$tearD ,(jet)er<:!te,r Ref~rqi~ht!,)¢!1~ DNTABIOfOWE,iI 7.1'(1:7) .~eimf)u~s,able Costs with"'NOMark tip ., .. .. G(NtiRATlON,
:,:""1'.
The ,!ollo~I~)fcosts VoI\1I11'0fbe'lritlud~~ifr ari'yT~r~,etCostor Fixed Price or Firm,Prlce and wHibe' palMoron apass;through,Reimbursable .i:ostbasis Y,iit~·l)o ,marj('.UI! · . . ,
Prudently incU'rred 'fr~vel, accOl'ilrnGd:itlonand subsisteAce·CGsts for unfo~i's~d'. resGurG:e,s) . iH·aCcGr.dance
wi.thtH~c()lIe~Jive agreernerrt, pru~~ntl,ilin~urre'd~{(~~el, atcommodati@n and
subsist~nc~:co~ts 'foru~ionised;S'upervjsiGrdnduding Foreman"General Foreman·and SUperintendants;,in
accordante wi,th OPG's Standard Form Business;Experise
I ·
Schedule ,
Travel & Expense Prudently incurred-travel, acccimrnodation and
subsistence costs for noncunionisec:j projei>ts.taff(all grades up to and inciuding'PrOjectDireqor), in
accordance with OPG's Standard Form Buslness.Expense
.. Schedule, " . . ' RelGcation costs (craft labour Qo!v;,'ihequired 'unclEir
6.22
6 .22.1
8.14 I 4.:1 (a)
.4:1 (a)
. 4) (a)
Letters of credit
4\1 (a)
;,
. 'W'Pllc'lble collective agreE!I1)ent o~IYL '
Relocation costs for non-unionized staff in accordance with OPG's Standard Form-BUSinessExpense 'ScheduJe
Cost of Interim Project LC, the Project ~Cand the Warranty~C
Provisfon i!nd '!VJalnt¢nance o(t/le In.teriQ'lPrpject LC Contra~t PriCe ($)
Interill] Project LC Amount (%of COr)tr,actJ)rice) Interim Projec~ L<: Amount($)
Esti,m<lte,d Cost of InterimLC,{%/year) Reimbu.rsable Cost per:Montn ($) , . Estima~e,~ Duration (!Y1pnths)' ,
Estin\~tedTotal CO$tof the IriterimProjj!cHC Provision and Mi!lntenanceot'thePl,oject'lC
Contract Pricej$) 1
Project LeAmQu At (% of Con1;ra0Price) Pmject q::: Amount:($i ,
Estimated Cost of Prpjecf LC(%/y.eat) Reimbursable Cost per lV!orlt.h,{S)
Estimated Duration .(M.bnths) Estimated Total Cost oft!'feProjectLC
Pro,vislonand .Maintenance·of the IN.a'rral1tyLC Contract Price ($) ,
Warranty tC;:.Am.ount (% of ContractPfil:e) Warranty tc Amount($)'
Estimatetftost ofthe Warr,HlW lGJ%!vt:!i!r) . Reimbursable Cost'per Month (ST
Estimi!ted Duration (MOnths) , Estiniat~tHotalCost ofW<lr.rant'l,lC;: :
RST Oil Health/We.lf;lre ," •. ' "" ,', itST on Healtb/Welfare Benefits - applies, to Trac:jes only
. Bimefits .:i-,@'
Version: ROS
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 393 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
Darlington Nuclear Generating Station St!!am Generator Refurbishment .DNTA8IBPiiiii GENERATIO 7.1(18)Milestone;P'!YIl1~nt;S~hedl!le.for Fix.edPrice Work and Fi rm Price Work "Primary Sid'e
in the opinion OPG, with all dispositioned, and cOl7Ist~uctio'n,drawings
to the sat!sfadion of OPG
equipment readyJor use on
testing de\(ic~s
Detailed neering and Construction Drawings
4.2.1
Deta!led .Engineering
Fabrication
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9;39 AM Page 1 of4
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 394 of 573
Con;sumable's" spares, calibration, testing devlc'es and'tciols ' , . "' . . . .
4.2.1 (b) ii.
Detalied Erigineeiin'g "rid Constnictio" Drawings
Fabrication· of waste ·collectfon.system
Fa.bri~atiqnofc9ptainer~ .and fia.ks Forthe 1st Unit
For the .2nd Unit
For the 3rd.,unit
Fo'dhe 4ih·Un·ii
Testing and Com'missioning
' lletwee'n lst;nid 2nd .units
·Between ,Znd..'.rid3rd Units
OPG,Darlington Refurbishment Program
'.0.11 required engiheering.deliverat:>les!or,equJp.rnent' minimum 80'3;{compl~ie in
the opinlqn of OPG; with'ali OP.~ comroef)~ 'sat,isfact:orlly ,dispositioned;
All requiretliel)gine,~~~~.~~fty~rahl,~cqrT),p.t~te in ~he opinion.ofOPG, witti 'all
OPG ,comments ~~tisia.ctq.r,!.\{disposl~o·ned :: ~~(:l:const~ction drawings complete ,(if r~q~J~edl " ' , '
All fabrieaiion compl ,~!e arid _wa~~e ... Colrection.system r~ady for use on' the 1st
unit
Ail containers and flasJ<S .faljt1caied.:, s~pp,iiediand delivered in advance of being
requi~ed ·for·the·1st unit. Ady~nce" p'e;r'iod'~~ be agreed wltti :OPG.
All containers add f1asks'fabricated7~up'plledrand .de1ivered in advance of being ,
required for the 2nd~Ur'ilt~"Adva·nce~pe"od·to be 'agreed with OPG.
AfJ contalners,a~d.flas'~,fu~ri~t~!i, 'suppll~d!apd delivered in' a~val)c~ of being
required .for the 3rd ~hil~ Acr)'an~e, period tp'lbe .agreed ~ith OPG.
Ail contai~ers ~nd fjasks'fa'bhc~ted;'sLippiied?a;nd del.tvered in advance of being '
required.for. .the 4th !Jnit:'Adv~rice 'p'~riod :to lbe agreed with,ORG. . . . ." ., , .. '-.
A11 :testi.ng and commissiOii!~g· compiete, waste collection system complete.:and
rea'!lY for use,:Q'1 th.e. -1"st I Ulii(irtthe ·op,i~ion,of OPG.
All required maint;e·~ance~dmplete.~tooling and equipment' ready for shipping
W required) for llse on fhe'2nd\)l1it'in the opinion of OPG
All required maintenance,;complete~~tooling and,!,!quipment.ready.for,shipping
(if:requiredl for,useon·.tbe 3 rd ,Unlt In ,the~opinion of ,OPG
O· 1-______________ ~B~e~t-w-e-e~n~3c~~an,d-4-t-h-U,nr.:· i-ts~. -,--~~c-~~~-- I~lr=e~qU-lr-e,~-~,al~~-~,n~-·~-f:,.\" C~q-,T7p~!e,te~,,~Qc:?~1in~g~.a,nd_. ~_. -u7.jp_m_en_t-re-a-d-Yf~o-rS-h-jp-~-~-g~ (if, required) for u~e on'the 4th ~~i\~ 'J n .. tre 9j:l!~ipn of OPG
Consumab!eSi 'spares, callbra·tioii,.tes~ih·g' ~devii:~.s All P.SC waste collection ~~te.m\yo~s~tQrri~te\e for all.Units
and tools
4.Z.~(b)vl. PrqtectiveUn.~r~ .'
For. the 2odUnit, :
for·the 3rdunit
For the 4th. Unit
lristaliaiion On the ' 1st Unit
On the 2nd unit
On the 3rCt Unit
O~ the 4th Unit
Removal
From the 1st ~riit·
Frqm the 2nd Unit
From the.3rd Unit
From the 4th .Unit
, 4!3.1 Site DOctlmentation
PrInted 11/29/2013 at 9:39 AM
,All ' pro.tectivtr"HiJ~r~'prp'<9r¢~, ' supp~~~, ~.eih(e:~~;~~:a.if~ re<!~y: tor USE! In :a~v,~:~.ce of.being r:equ[(ed for ~he;ls~. ~n!t,:,,~",'!i!.!1~,ipe.rip~ ~.o 'b,e <agr¢ed WitJ,tOPG.
' , ." :
~11 protective l! rl~rs' p·~!.~.~i!supp.!le8, ~'eli~e(ri:ta'nd r'eady 'for"us~' iri adyance
of being requIred for th~ 'irid.1Jhit.'A~v~nce p~ribd to be agreed with OPG. ::
All prot~ve rfners pro"cured"s'up'pliea, delivered and ready'fo'r use In advance
of'bei~g required for'the'3rd unit: Advance' period to be agreed with OPG.
Ali protective liners.'pro.cUred, supplied, .Cle1iv~re,d an'd ready for . .use in advance
of beIng required for-~h~.4th un.l~. A;d,,"!ance pe~riod to be 'agreed with OPG.
Ali protective liners' instal1ed';'Q~ 'the 1st U!,it1to the satisfaction of OPG
All protective liners ,installed-on the:2nd ·Unif to .thesatisfactlori of.OPG
Ali'protective liners installe<;l 'Qn the '3rd:,Uim to. the satisfaction' of OPG
All prot.ective Iiners' instal1ed on the 4th Unit to·the satisfaction of OPe;"
All protective liners 'removed from on' the lst'Unit'to the satisfaction of OPG'
All protective linerS removed from on·the 2nd. Unit to the ~tlsfaction of OPG
All protective liners remove9.frorh .on.tn'e 3rd Unit to the satisfaction of Op'G
All protect'ive liner's ·rer.'] .ov:d·:~~,m.hn th~ ~~~ ~ Uni' t to the satisfacti~n of OPG
,."' ....
, Pdge2b/4
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 395 of 573
Site nne"mpnt"tin~ for the 2nd Unit
.Site nne, ,mpnt,Hno for the.3rd llni~
Site nne, ,mpnt,tin<i for the 4th Unit '
OPG,Oarlington Refurbishment Program
, r the 2nd Unit complete and accepted by OPG ....L.... I i , , ia;r:the'3rd Unit complete and aceepted by 'OPG Q ,
.11, i oIar'the 4th Unit I !and accepted by OPG
4.3.Hb), ".' shiiiDiili! and Handling
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9:39 AM
Between 1st and 2nd units
Between 2nd and 3rd Units
Be~een ,3rd ~nd 4th Units
D" ~n;.t;a" works
For the 1st Unit
For the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd'unit
Fotthe 4th Unit
,works
For th'e 1st Unit
'Forthe 2nd Unit ,
For the, 3rd unit
For the 4t~ Unit
Project specific tr~ining
Forth. '1st Unit
For th'e 2nd Unit
For the 3rd uriit
For the Jth,Upit,
General; non Uoit-<npHfi. ,pn"
material.slJpply
.
"I. ,;u,u",!", ,. " ... J equlpm~nt ShIPP:,d 1 to sii. alf~r ",ainienante and ,'r.e~dy for, use lon 'the~~'" ' '''' '' ! opin'onoofOPG
AII tooling" , , ,' j to site afti" maintenance and ready for use on,the 4th ,Unit' :::f OPG
works for the 1st 'unit complete fn the opinion of OPG
II pre,ouI,ge wu •• ; .u, ... e ",J uni, complete in the opinion 610PG ,
II.e" ·uu .... .;' 'u • ., ,~, .". ',,'d unitcomplefe inthe opinion of OPG
AII pre.outage works for the 4th .unit complete in the oplnlo~ of OPG
AII pre on·boiler works lor the 1st unit comp'«. i ;oIOPG
AII pre on-boiler wo~ for the 2nd unIt" c~inplete 'inthe opinion of OPG
AII pre on-boiler works for the 3~~ u,nit co.mplete in the opinion of OPG
AII pr~ on-boiler works for the 4th
AII I : training for the 3rd
liprojec~:'!P.e~ifi"\;''"1l'!.f~rthe 4th
I ! In'the opinion ol,OPG
AII works not attribUtable to a specific UnitTelated to
For the 1st U,nit U wU,~"" ,u' _ \'!'f1,st Uni~E~I~'ed to other costs <"",plete
For the 2nd Unit II Unitrelaied,to other, I
For the 3rd unit AiI 'wo/JiSlor the3rd Unit related to other coSts complete
Detailed c"5i"cc""5 a'-,J !=onstruction Drawings AII required engineertng delivera~les complete in the opinion 01 OrG, wit~ all QP.G I : '. i i dispositioned,·and c:onstruction .drawings complete (ifrequired) .
Fabrication
Forthe ist 'Unit AII "oncanon lor the 1st unit comolete and, i "tiSfaetion olOPG - --c---
fto the
For,the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit ' ;,
For the 4th-Unit II 'fabrication fortheAtH, I Isatisfaction.of OPG
"A ihe
Testing and I
For the 1st Unit !and equipment. p , the'
Forthe 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit ,and , " ~I ' . .rJh.L ,"
Forthe4th Unit I 14th Onlt ,n the opinion of OPG
ConsumablesJ spares, calibration, teS!ihg devices and tools -
" AII primary sidebung'Works for the 1st'Unit roniplet. ,_,
For the 2nd !Jnit
. For the 3rd unit Alioprimary side bung works far the'¥9U~if complete
,Forthe4th,Unit ~1I pn[!iary Side bung workS lor the4th Unit coniplet.
• i ,i.
, ~ -" AII required en'gineering deliverables . ""I-" minimum 89.%:.complete the opinion of OPG, with all OPG comments satlsfacto(ily dispositioned.
Engineering
Poge 3 0/4
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 396 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
;~~t~!I~d',~ngineering and Construction Drawings AII 'required ·erigine'~ring · deliverables' complete in'the'.opinion.of OPG, with all
O'L~~~~ ____ ~~~~~ __________________________ ~ O~PG~c~o~m~m~e~n~~' ~sa~t~isfu~ct __ or~ilY~d~iS_P~OS~iti~'O~n~ed~,~an~d~c~o~ns~ttu __ ro~'o~n~d~ra~W~in~gS ____ -4 I' ~ cO!'11plete (if r.equlre(H
, FabricatlCl" ' ,
Version: R05
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9:39 AM
Forthe lst,Unit '". . ." . . ~" .
, "
Tesiinganlfpqmi])issi<i6ihg , For,th~ ist Unit ,
Forthe'3rd unit
. Consuniables,;spares, c.alibratibn, testing devices.
andtdol.
Genenil,· !lpn))!1it,?p~i::i.f!.c" ~q ~iprrient ariB tila.teria,1 supply Forihe lstUnii Forth" 2nd Unit FO\ tl)" 3.!a u~it .
..
~I 'fab~catio.1l for the! 1st unit complete -and· equipment r~cejve'd·to the ~~ti~factjon' Qf ORG • .
AII'fabricati'On;Jor the . .2ncf !Jnlt cQrnpJete, ~nd equiJi",~nt receiyed't9 the satisfactiQn ,~fOP~G . " -
AI1J.aQIj.cali~l' /?'r;:the. ~.dtl!,riJ~ complete and e~ujl:m:~ent' re'c~i"~ed,to the' sati~(a~~i.on o{O.RC3 .. . ' ,
~" " (ifbficfl'tr~r ,:t~~'~.h~;,4rh ;J~!t ~cg!J1~.!~~e,~!;l.d:e,(uiprrient.rec~iveq to the s9tisfactjqn}pM)'pG '~l .• . , " , .
AJI .test!ng:,f,nq c.~mj.ssionjng S~,!!prete anti equi"pm!'?nt ready for use on the
~~St.Utl.it 'i , All h~s~n:" . . " ,, : '. ' : ~omplete. and equlpment.readv for use on the ~n"d .Vpfriirthe:o~pi!J·i9n of~6'~G : ", . Ail . teitli)'f~nd.:~rrrmi~s~o~f~:g c6rri~lete" a'~'d eqy}pment ready for ~se 'on-the 3rd. U!1!t.ln .~~~:C?piriiQn of'OPG : . _ ~lftestihg.an~~com·m ISSioninlrcompIMe'a"nd equlp'menfready for use on the 4t~ ,!Jnit-hi tHe 'opin"jon:afiOP.G
All works for: ,th~ 2h~ J,Init ,r.eJated"t:o other c~s~5 :complete
'Art worlC> for;tne' 3rd Urilt "n!Ii31:ed to' other costs com~lete
Page 4'0/4
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 397 of 573
Darlington Nuclear.Generating Station Steam Generator Refurbishment
7.1(19) Milestone P.ayment Schedule for Reiinbursable Work Fixed' Fee - Primary Side & Secondary Side
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
~ 2,1
2.2
2.3
2.4
Ver.s~on: RCS ,
Reimbursable Work Fixed 'Feel fOr the ist U!1.it Primary Side
Reimbursable Work Fixed'Fee for the 2nd. U~ji • Primary Side
Reimbursable Work Fixed Fee for the .3rd ·Unit'
Primary Side, .
. Reimbursable Work fixed F.eeforthe 1,tnllnit
Pri,mar:y Siq,e
Reimbursable'Work Fixed Fee:for ,.the' lst Unit!.
SecQndary Side
Reimbursable Work Fixed Fee fqrthe.2nd l:Ini(
Secondary SIde
Reimbursable Work Fixed Fee·for the 3r~;.unit.
. ~~confJ~uy Side
"Relmbursable Work Fixed' Fee for the· 4th Unit -Secondary SidLe
Printed 11/19/2013 at 9:39 AM
1DO%
100%
1DO%
1DO%
100% $' 74,506 T80
TBO
100% TBO
100% $ tao
100% $'
OPG Darlington ,Refurblshment Program
ONTARIDPOWE . '. GENmATlO
AlI ·Relmbursable'War1C for the 2nd Unit Primary 'Side complete.
All Reimbursable Work forthe 3rd Unit Primary Side 'cample,te;
All ReImburSable-Work for th~ 4t~ ,uni~.Primary' SJde camplete •
All ' Reimbursable Work far the':lst- Unit Secondary Side i:o'mplete.
All Reimbursable Wark}o~,'the 2'nd Unit Secon,dary Side complete,
A'II Reimbursable Work for-the '3ra Unit Secondary Side' complete.
All Re'imbursable WorHor the 4th Unit"Sec"9ndarv Side ,complete.
Page 1 'fJl2
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 398 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
Darlirlgton 'Nucl!"ar Generating Statlon:Steam Generator Refurbishment . UNfARllJFOifiiEiI . GENERATION 7.1(20). Milestone ' Pay~entS£hedule for Fi"xedPric:eWork al'ld Firm Price Wor~ - Setondary Side .
Drawings 100%
100%
For
100%
es" callier'atlOn, testing devices
, 100%
100% $ $
equiplli-!'nt $ $
For the 'lst;Unit 100%
For 2nd Unit 109%
$
Forthe4th,Unit
' 100%
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9:40 AM Page 1 'of 13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 399 of 573
Bet\V~,~9 ind and 3rd Units 100%
, 6etwee'rl3rdand 4th Units 100% $
Consumables, spares, calibration,·festing , de~ices
,and tool~
For,th,e,]'sMinit "100% $
Forthe.2nd Unit" 100% $, , ; " " ; ," '"
, Forth .. 3rd unit 100%
For the 4th Unit 100% $
/I.,l.l (al iii. , Sludge Removal & Filtration Tooling
Preliminary Engineering 100% $
D.etaiied 'Engineering & Construction,D.rawings 100% ' $
4.1.2 Equipment Tooling and Material Supply
Genera,l;jion Unit-spedfic, eqlii"pmer)t and 100% $ material supply
For the .lst Unit 100% $
'Forthe 2nd Unit 100% $
. ' For the 3rd unit 100%
,. ; For the 4th' Unit 100% $
Maintenance of Toollng,between,Units
Between,ist and ?nd units 100% 1$
Between 2nd and 3r,fUnits" 100% 1$
Between 3td ane4th UnitS 100% $
Consumables, spares"c~libration, testing devices
" and tools
Fo'r tii'e 1st ,Unit 100% $
Forthe 2nd Unit 100% $
Forthe 3rd unit 100% $
For -,he 4th Unit 100% $
4 .. 1.1' (a) 1\1; Visual Inspection Tooling p.~eliminarY'Engineerin·g 100% $
Deiailed Engineering & Construction Drawings 100% $
4.1.2 Equipme'ni'Tooling and Materia) Supply ,
General! non U"riit-specific, equiprrl~nt and 100% $ !)'laterial supply
For !tie lst ,Unit 100%
t"
For the 2nd Unit 100% $
For the 3rd unit 100% $
, Forthe 4th Unit 100% $
Maintenance'of Tooling betWeen ,U~lts
Between 1,5,t and 2nd uriits , 100%
Between 2nd ana 3rd 'Units: 100% $
" Setween 3rd arid 4th Units 100% ,' $ "
, Consumables, , 'pares, calibration,testing·,devices
and tools
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9:4() AM
$
$
20;553 $,
$
I $
15,~S2
- $
- $
$
, - $
-IS $
$ .
. 1 $
$
$
$
- $
3,6,64 $
"
$
$
- $
$
- $
" ,
$
'1 $
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
- ~II r~.~lli~~~a<j~~~v.an~e . c~lTlft<l~te ... ~'.1d.:~,quip~ent ~~ady ~or ,shippi~,g, (If required) 'for use on the.3rd~U'nii: i'n the' opinion of OPG
_ AII:tequired' maintenance complete ·and.equlpment ready for shipping (If
reAu'lr:.ed) for use on 'the' 4th .u~.it. ifl · :the.~nl~n_ Qf o.P(5
J •.
~iO,553:: ~II ' se¢ondary;~~~':~n-boil~r hard slU'dge lancing·tooling.worksJor the 1st Unit o complete
. .-~Jrse·cord~ry 's~~e 'on~9ire( hard '~\-!dge:-!~:l)sJflgtooiing ,~o~,s fg-:.~i,tl.~ ?n~. Unit · .~. !=ompiete ' - ..
..:: All s.eco"nda'ry side"on','-boih;!r h'ard rslud~e fan¢ing t~ciling .work~ fl:?[ tlie 3rd.linit : c~nipl~t; . ,. "",' " '
_ All secondary'side on~boHer hard'sludge:landng' tooling\vorks,for the '4th Unit complete .
' 15;652 All required engIneering deliverables fOr'e~ulpment.iriininjum ~O% "c:~mple'te ' in . .the opinion of OPG, with all 'OPG'commenh satisfactorily., ~jsJ?ositjo~ed.
- ' ~1J.req'~ired··e'rigine_e:ring deliverabl~s,complete.hthe:;oP'iniOri : ofOPG,With all ' 9p~.,C(om~7n!S ~.a(ist~~orii~ 'di~Po;;!tlon~d, a.~d: !=·onstllJ.ction drawing's compl~te (ifnRuired)
_ All general noii·Unit7~peCific. eq'uipmenj:, toolihga'rJ~ materials supplied and
delivered in advance of being:required. Advaoce:period to b.e agreed with OPG.
_ All equipmen.t, tooli ng ,fl nd m~terials :suppliec;f an:d deliv~red ,in adva'nce'of
being require\i forthe ·1:st·unit:·;.\"dvance\ l?eri~d.!.o be agreed with bpG.-
_ All equipment, tooling and materials supplied and'delivered in advance'of being'required forthe.2nd Unit; Ad.Jance:period-tb be qgreed with OPG . .
_ All equlpmenti;tooling and. .maferials ·supplied and delivered in"adva'nce oJ
bei':lg 'required for the 3rd Unit. Advance.per.i~d to be agreed,with OPG.
- A!! equipmf!!nt, tooling anclmatenals supplied .and"delivered' in advance·ot'·, being re~.~i' red , forthe 4th Unit. A~vance period to be' agreed with O~G.
_ All requfred maintenC!n,ce,complete:and equipment ready for.shipping.(lf required) for use on.the:2np· Un!~':I~ithe opini9,n:of'OPG
_ A~I , requlred ma'i"htehance,cofllplete and equiprTi:"e·~t ,re.ady for shipping·li(
. r~q4i[~d) for use on the 3~ Un~~in th~ . oplh·i~~ ,.C!(6pG _ All required maintenancfi"complete"iuid equl p.m~ent're'ady for shipping {if ~ ...
required)for u'e on the 4th Unitinthe ~plriibn i>fiO~G ' ' ... ~
_ All secondary side sludge removal &~ filtrationtcioling works!forthe.1.~t Uni(
!:.omplete _ All secondary 'sidirsludge removill :& f!ltration .tooling works'for the;2nd.Unit
compl.etf;! . ,' .. ..,. ... ,~ , .,~" .. All secondary side sluagefrem'oval' & fiitratio~ .. t60IJrig\vO"rks for'the '3rd tJn1~
cQmplete ,~ 'AI'I, second~:frY side sJ~c;lge' removaf & filtratiori" to'oling worl(s for the 4th Unit
complete
_ All required engineering deliverablE!s for,equipment minini.l!.m.80% complete in· the. opinion of OPG, with all OPG commen~!satisfactorily dlspositioned.
3,664 All req'uired engineering· deliv~ra bles ,comple"te)n;t!le ·oplnion 9f OPG, with ali OPG comrh.ents satisfactorily dispositiq.n~9, an.d ·c~n~tnl~ti~. d!<iwings cQmplete (if required)
_ All gener~1 non'pnit-sp~clflc 'eq,l!ipf!lent:t"ooling.and .ma!efi!!is.supp'!jed ~nd deliver~ in advan.ce, ofbelng.required:. Adv.a~ce. periCid to be agr~ed with 9PG.
_ All eij'uipment, tool,ing and.materials suppJied ~nd delivere~ in' aavance of being required'fodhe 'lst Unit: Advance period,to'be agreed with OPG.
. _ AlI ;equipment) . ~oqling and r:natenals supplied a'r'1d delivered ·in. advance 'of
bei~g requirfxl for the 2n.d Unit, Advance'periodJQ'be agreed.with. OPG.
_,' All equlpnwnt, i:ooiingand ·mate.~ials s~wjlied ~[l~ CI!ifi~ered· i'1 .a·dv.anc~'· of ~eing ·required for the 3rd Unit. Advance peri~c!: to be . a~re;ed.with OPG.
_ AU 'equipment, tooling and materials supplied and qelivered in advanie of .
being required for the 4th Unit. Advance period to be agreed ,:"ith OPG.
_ AII'required ma.intenance complete and .equipmen~,(eac;fy ~or"sflipp!ng· (if l;eQuir:ed) fqr l!se on th~ 2nd Uni~ in .the,opinion 'Qf:OP-G .
_ AU 'required m.aintenance : coJT'!·p'~i::e and : equ(pin~nt re~dy: for.shf"pping (if req,..Ir.~) for use on'the 3rd Unit in the .opiniolJ '~f Op.d ..
_ All required maintenance "Complete 'anCl, equip,ment ready' fil'r,shippi'ngjlf
required) for use on the .4th .Unit in the opl~lon 'of OPG .'
Page 2 0/13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 400 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
For the-1st Unit 100% $ - ~fI' secOll?ary 'Sidevisual in,~pectiont~oi;~'~works;for.the -lst:u,nlt compl~t~;
, <:::> t---~------~~f~. o-r~t~ne~2-nd~,~u7n~it-.----~,~, ~ _,~--~~~----r---~l~O~O%Z·----~$---------------$~------------_~A~.I~ls-ec-o-n~d.-~~' S~id7e-v7i~~U.>Y~in~SP~· e~ct~lo-n~lo~O~II-ng-W-0-r~~~fu-r~~~e~2~n~d~U~nl~tc-o-m-p7Ie~~--4
Forthe 3rd,unit 100% $ $ •. AIi ,~econda"; side vi~u,aUn~p.~ctio~ tooling ~,q~~ :for the '3'rd Unit complet:
For ihe4t!rUnit 100% $ _ All secondarx side ,,?suallnspeetion tooling works for "dle 4th Unit complete
4.1.1Ja) V" , .. FM,ReireivaI-,Too.ling _ AJf:~,l:l,ire·d(jengl"~.irt!l~,~~;~I~ve .~bleS'f~;:eqUIPni'~ni: miril~~rri 8-0% complete in
the opinion of OP,?! wfdi "all OPG com·men~· sa.tisfactorHy dispositioned.
4.1.2
-'.
4.1.1 (a).)Ii.
4.1.2
Preliminary Engi~eerirfg
Detailed 'Engineering & Construi:tioM)r~\Vings . (
EquipmelitToolingand 'Materi~tSupjily
Genera"!, non Unit-:'specific, equipment and
material supply .
Forthe 1st Unit
F,or the 2nd Unit
.
For the '3rd unit
Maintenance 'of Toi>lingQetween Units Between:lst anif2ndunits .
Between 2nd and3rd Units
Between' 3rd and 4th Linits
Consumables, spar,esj calibration, testing dev'iCes
.n·d tools
For the 1st Unit
For the 4th Unit
Off,:BoilerP.ro~ess 'Eqilip~ent
Preliminary Engfneering
Detailed Engineering & C6n'strudion Drawings
Equipment Toolipg arid.l',,;ateriaLSupply' .
General;. np'nunit:~p~cifit, equiprfleht and mateiialsupply
For the 1st Unit
Forthe 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
For the 4th Unit
Maintenanoe'of l'iibling. bet""eenl'~i.!s 'BetWeen'ist.and:ihd,imits, .
100%
100%
100%
100%
· 100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
1dd%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
' 100% ,
100%
$
$
$
$
$
.$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
- $
$
$
- $
$
$
,
$
$
$
$
$ .
$ .-
- $
170,691 $
222,189 '$
$
$
$
$
_ All required e~glheenrig. deliverables comple:'te,in the opinion,pf OP'G, with~~ll OPG'commerits satisfactorily dispositloned, a.nd ·constructJon d~awings complete.(ifrequired) , -
_ AlrgeneraJ .non Unif~'specific ;e'quipmerit,-tooJin'g and-materials supplied at:'l~
delivered i.n advance, of being required. Advance period to ·b,e agreed with QPG.
_ AII .equipment toofing and materials~supp'lie'd :-and delivered.iil~ adVance of
being requ.I(ed for the 1st Unit. Adv~nc~e P~rt?d to be .agreed with ,QPG.
_ All equlp:merit,.tooling and:matenals supplied a~d :delivered ' in advance . ~f being"re'quired for the.2nd Unit: Advance Penocfto be agreed ·with OPG .
_. All equipmen.t. tooling and materials~supplie:d -and delivered In advance of
being required for the 3rd Unit. ,Advance per-iodlo be agre_ed with9PG.
- . .0.1.1 equipment. tooling,a'nd 'm·at_er:i.a!s:suppl.led an~(delivered il} :'I<!~fI~~"cC of
I being :require~ .for ,theAth :U{l.It. A~tY~Q.ce ' R.eri9~ :to~be ,,~gfe~9 ~.j~~ :OPG.
:. Ail,required ma intenance comp.lete: ~n'd :~qJip;"'ent.readV for shipping (if ' _ required) fo~ use ,ory the 2nd.Unit in .-the gpinion of OPG
- Alf.i-equlr~d maln.teriar!""ce corn~:,,:~.r~nd.~~~:'4ilt_l!l~n~,J'eady.t(lf'Ship'ping·· (if required) fQ~ .!J.se on.'the '3rd,Unit:lnlhe,op!h.lQn of. OPG
~ All required'malntel")ance complete a.Qd equjpmeht ready for shipping (if re~~lred) :t~r-use o~ the 4th-'lJnj~ in the ~~:inion of QPG .
_ All seconaaiyslde-FM-fetreivat'.t.Oo.ling works for the' 1st Uni~ com'plete
_ All secondary ,slde FM re~r~Jva! .!ool}f!~ works !?~ t~e 4th Unit complete ,
- All requ:ired e~~in~e,~It'\g ,~~liver~b.t~~~~~r eqtjlpme"i1t .~f~!m~m':8,?%. co~ple'te in the opir)ion of.pP.G, ,~t~h :a'l OPG COmmel")ts satis'facto~ly dispositioned.
11b~691 .AII ~ulr~d , en~l~eering_dellverables complete'in· the 'opinion 'of,OPG, With-'all OPG-commerits satisfactorily disposition ed, and:construction drawings co~pl~te (If,required)
222,289. All"general _nor" Unh~specjficeql:lipmeht,'t'ooll~g arid materials.su·p~lh~d ana ?et"l~ered in -advance:of.being . reql:Jir~d :·AClvance p~riod lo,be:'agreed witb OPG.
_ All equipment,"'-to-oling'andimalerials suppli.ed~n~;de'livered in actva-nce of '
being requlr~d 'forthe 1st Unit . .(\~van_c~ perlpd,to b.e agreed with QPG,'
_ .~r eqUip'Q1e~t;:·tdoli~g ~~nd :m.ar;r1~;1s ~uppl(ea 'and C!elivered in a'clvance of being resuired for the 2J)d· !Jni~. Adv~nce.period to be agreed:-with OPG.
_ All equipm'e'nt~ tooling'cihd materfals supplfed 'and:delivered in advance'of being required '-for-thE~;3rd ' Unit~Advantepmiod to be agreed witn,OPG . .
_. AJLequipment, toOli!11f~hq ma~erial~:s~p'~Htd,"~.~~ d~livered in adva'nce of' b,eingrequired for'the 4~~.' unit. ·A~~,anc:~;p:erio(Uo:be agreed with OPG.
'43,676 $ 51,481 AIt. r$~ uir.~m~Jr~~n~,nce:;;cC?~pl.~te.,.~nd·eq·.~il?m~nt 'ready fo~ ~hi~ping tit
$ '
100% $
."," .r .. ~ .. q .. _u ... ~:~rfO. r, .. u ... s~._._~~nJh_e :2na~J"l. ,no l.tJri,:th .• ,O. p .... ~n .. ,.! .. o •. n .. 0.1,.0. P~ , c, ' ..... ... . . ~ Between 2nd and3rd'Units. 43;676 $ 52'767 ~U , re lie,q~lpment ready lors~ipplng (il I-----------------,-----------~--------~---'--------+--------~--------------~----------~'---,.' __ '",: r~~::!Cq'U~i op[~·ip~ ~fOPG ,'r' "
Betwee(\}rd,antl 4th Units 43;676 $ 55,299 AI!:r ,.,. , eq<iipmentreadv furs~lpping (II required)'for\lse'on the 4th ;. Uni~- in~~he 'oPjni6n ' of OPG .
Cons!Jmapre~, 'spares,J:aHbratiO:n, testing devices . ~nd t~ols . ' . . ' , .
Forth .. 1st .Unit 100% $ $ _ All secondarY"side,off-l::idiler 'pr.oce~ eqqipnieiit works for the 1st Unit compiete
100%"
100% $
For the 4th Unit 100% $ _ AII"Secon'dary. ~ide ~ff-boiler process equipment:wori<s for the 4th Unit
complet~
Printed 11/19/2013 at 9:40 AM Page 3 0/13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 401 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
4.1.1 (d) .' Milck:.up I I"PI" "b' ,cc';,,~ 100% $ $ -: IAII req.uired englneerin~ deliveraQles minimum ' ., "0 Ithe -o~'inion ofOPG, wlth'alrOPG comments satisfactorily dispositionea.
Uet<i 'IiM 'L; '5,,,oo,;rig& C, 'UULUU" ~,a",,,~, 10016 $ - $ . -IAlI ' .' lJellv~raDles complete . ~n the opinion of OPG, with ~ II
1~:~~~::~;~:Uir~dl and constru.ctlon ,drawings ...
4.1.2 . Supply and Installation 100% $ If~r use . ~ tooling ~nd ,eqUlpment supplied and Installed and:ready.
Maint~nce ofTooliiig ~etween Units Between 1st andind units 100% $ $ -I::~~;el~r use on the";'::~i' e an~ opinion olOPG
ee""
Bet~een 2nd and 3ra Units 100% $ - $ I~~~~i~~;~ruse on;he 3id Unit:; ;~n! ":;~!i~~i~;;'u, i .IiI
Between 3rd and 4th Units 100% $ $ -1:'~~:~7U::::n;~~':·ir.: n t~~d:6;~:~~:;~~~u, .y, ",'""" ~. (il C'm,uouau,c" spares, calibration; lestingdeVJCes and tools .
~a~~;~~:~~~~e~~;~'~';;~;cesand spares} 100% $ - $ _IAII .secondary. process equrpm~nt works not att~butable to a .
. , ' . tools Ispecific- I
Forthe 1st Unit 100% $ . $ :, I '"' "I, off-boiler ,,,tworks lorthe 1st Unit complet,
For the 2nd Unit 100% $ - $ -' -1:mPI:;.o., i off-boiler works lor the ind Unit
For the 3rd unit .. 100% $ $ I:~!:~;;eaari siDe off~b~process equipment works for the 3rd.Unit
Forthe 4th Unit 100% $ - $ I:mplete
off.-.bolle~ equipment works lor the 4th Unit
;·;i·'-';.:;·~:' , .'~ l!f:(;\~';\'''i'11SY-', ":;; ,: ..... ' .. .',;':." ~'f.:·'~ :0'"
Site "
4.2.1 For the' 1st Unit 100% $ - $ .r ~ ~ Unit comple,e·."d accepted by OPG
. . For the 2nd Unit 160% $ $ -IAII'ite ~ . "i, LU"'"'.'" ."d accepted by OPG
Forthe 3rd unit 100% $ $ IAllslte , lor the 3rd Unit complete and accepted by OPG
For the 4th Unit 100% $' - $ IAII site r the 4thUnii complete and accepted by OPG
4.23 (aa) Site nn, ."~.nbt;n~ package for, each:SG ,
For the 1stUnit 100% $ $ _1~J~ite documentation for each S6 for the' 1st Un.lt complete and ~c~ePted by
Forthe 2nd Unit 100% $ - $ ~documentation fo~2nd Un~ complete,and acceptedl .... ' .
For the 3rd Wlit 100% $ -$ -~ IoPG
~3rd Unit complete and accepted by
For the 4th Unit 100% $ $ ~ ~SG lor the 4th Unit complete and accepted by IOPG
4:2.3 (bb) t records For the 1st Unit 100% $ - $ IAII wafer lam:rng shift r~ords for the 1st Unit co:nplete and accepted by OPG
< . Forthe 2nd Unit . 100% $ - $ _IAli.~;;;;rlanclng sh~ihe2nd Unit complete and'accepted by OPG
.. . For the 3rd unit '- 100% $ $ -IAII ',,~~3rd Unitcoinplete and accepted by OPG
<
For the 4th Unit 100% $ - $ -IAII shift records ,for-the 4to 'Unit complete and accepted'by OPG
A·2.2' .~. - ' . ,.'" "- c,;, Pre-outage and Pre On-boiler Works
For t'he1st Unit 100% $ 277,127 $ 277,127 I::'b;~-outage and pre on·boiler worksJor the 1stUn~ completein 'the opinion.
For the 2nd Unit , 100% $ 182,370 $ 2i4;9'6O ~workslorthe 2nd Unltcompl,,,e In the
F')r the 3rd unit , 100% $ 182,370$ 22O,32s ~ " ; ~Ior the.3rd Unit complet;,in tll'eopinion . For the 4th' Unit 100% $ 113,104 $ 143,203 fAil ~ works lor the 4th Unit complete In the opinion
10lOPG
~4 . : train'ing .'
For th~ 1st Unit 100% $ 261,116 $ , 261,116 AI' . c training lorthe I . Forihe 2nd. Unit. 100% $ 200,206 $ 23~,984 IAU etrali1lng'fur
For the 3rd:.unit 100% $ iOO,206 $, 241;877 All ~ training lor. the 3rd'
Fprthe 4th"Unit, 100% $ i24;lIii; ' $ 157,ios1AIl 2 training 10rihO 4t~Uhit complete
m)1l~:p ~gWn Ge.t1!!;ator ,. '-;
'4;2.3:(Q) Lpo~e . :/AF wstenj .
Forthe lst.Unit -100% $ $ IAliloos~lancing./ AF system works 10Hhe-1stUnit complete • Forthe 2nd Unit
f 100% $ - $ IAil'loo'e sludge lancing / AF system wo'~ for the 2nd I I '
For ttle:'3rd unit 100% $ - $ _IAllloose sludge lancing / AF system .works for the 3r~ Unit co-mplete
Par the 4th Unit 100% $ $ _ rAIl lo~ sludge lancinglAF system ~orks for the 4th I .. lila.. 4:2.3(p) Drainage system JLl
Fqrt.he 1slL!nit 100% $ -$ IAII drainage system works for the 1st Unit complete I T
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9:40 AM Page 4 0/13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 402 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
_ AI.I · drain~ge ~ystem works for.th~ :~/"ld · Unlt complete
4.2.3 (q)
37-~~995 Ali ham .sludge:lanting .~oi-ks ·for th~ ~th 'Vnit'C9mplete .". .'. -;::c " . , .•
_ All works to iden"tlfy and open SG .tiand-holes for the .1st Un!t complete
_ Ali"wdrks ·to identify a-nd 'b~e!O ~· hand..fto-Ies for the 4th Unit cbmplete
4.2.3 Ul . .
,'. • •• ~. " . f
118Asl All inspeCtion 6"f ~Tl and hot-I~~~NTl iubes'W6r~s for the 1n'd Unit cbmplete
121,409 Arflnspecti'on-of NTL'and not-leg ~JLotabes wor~s :for.tlie;3rd Unjt:c6mplet~
78;910 AIUl1spection of-NTl.and.hot!leg NTl.' tu'bes,works for the :4th.Unit complet~
4.2.3 (k)
4.2.3 (I)
4.2.:3(m)
, '. AIr SG hand:hore"studs:andjlJuts:!!lspectiQn:wQrlq; for the 3fd Unit~cdrJ1plet..e
!:. AlfSG ry'and-hole; stu~s .and ·nuiS ·in\specil~'.!1 ' v.i6rks fdr. the 4th. Unit complete
4.i.3 (0) _ All tubesh~t"lnspeCtion ·siudge:.m<;lpPi~g ~(.,f!ss, rdrt~e ist:Unit com,pie;te
_ Ali tubesheet iospeition ;sllidge,maJ;:j'ping,_wot'ksJor the 4th Unit c'omplete
4.2.3 (r) _ AII-int"erim' tubesh'eet jnspections~worRs·for· 'the lsbUnitcompl,ete
4.2.3 (t)
4.2.3 (u)
4.2.3 (v) _ Aillattlce'b'ar and -ttlermai pla'te : inspectio~ 'w'orks' fo~ the lst.Unit.complete
_ All lattice bar and thermat'plate in spe:c~iofi works for the 2nd Unit c;ompiete
.~ All lattice bar and 'thennal plate, inspection workS for. the 3rd Unit complete
Printed 11/19/2013 at 9:40 AM Page'50/13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 403 of 573
4;2.3;(x)
4.2.3M
4.2.3 (z)
4.2.5 (a)
4.2.5 (e)
4.2,S,(d)
4.2.5 (e)
4.2.5 (f)
4.25 (g)
4.2.5 (h)
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9:40 AM
For the 1st.,Unit iOO%
For the 2nd Unit 100%
For the 3'rd unit 100%
.For the 4th Unit 100%
Hot I.eg,·and cold leg inspections ·F.otthe 1st Unit ~O~
For the2'nd Unit 100%
For ihe3rd unit 100%
For the 4th '[init 100%
$6 hand-hol.eclosing . " Forthe 1st Unit 100%
For the 2nd .Unit 100";';
For the 3rq unit 100%
For'the 4th Unit 100%
Removal of equipment For the lst .Unit 100%
For the.2nd:. Uni.t 100%
100%
100%
Nuclear refurbishment extended tubesheet final visual inspection
F6'r the:lstUnit 100%
"For the.2nd Unit 100% -. -for the 3id' unit i ,. 100%
For the 4th Unit 100%
Tear d9wnsystl,ms
$ '. $
$
$ $
$ $
$ $ $ $
$ $ $ $
$ $ $ $ $ $ $ .$
$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $
$
$ $
$ $
$
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
_ All final Nn, an~ulus and'-fee,dwaier nozzle incpections warks far the 1st Uriit I cpmplete i ........
_ AII ,f1na.nfl"l, annulus an,dJeedwater nazzle in'cpecfions.works for the 2nd Lln{. ~ !=omp.lete . ,_ ~
_ All tina'l NTL, annulus-and feedwater-n'o~zJe Incpectians warks:fbr the' 3r'C! Unit compl~te
_ All final- NTl,.annu,lus'and feedwater nozzle incpecti'ons warks for ,the"4th.Unft cOrrJplete
_ A,I,I hat 'leg and cold leg ins~ecti,ons warks.far the 3rd Unifco~plete _
_' All hat'leg and ,cold leg Inspe~ions works 'fdr the 4th~Un,~ ,complete
_ ~H SG hand-hole dos!n~,,:w9rkS for, the 1st Un.!t complete
_ All removal.?f eq,ui.p~erit works for the 2nd Unit 'Com~'ete
_ All remoyal o.f equipm,ent .~ork~ forll.1~,~.r,(fOriit_c.?mplete
. _ All nuclear refurbishment extended tubesheet final visual inspection works-for . the 1st .Onit ~mp.lete _ Alfnud~ar"refurbishmEmt extended tub~sh~et final'visual' inspection ,#orksJor
the 2nd'Unit complete _ All nucl~ar refu'rbistiment extended iub,esheet final visu-a!:inspection works for the ,3rd 'Unit~mplete . ','_,', "
_ All nuclear refurbishment extendep tub~heet tfnal visuafi!,}spectiO(l workS for the':4th Unit-aimplete ~
For the 4th Unit 100% $ SQ~$i5, ~ll , i:ea'r:down:~yste~s works for ·the .4~~ ;.Unii: 'c0'!lplete "f' ...
Decontamination
For the 1st Unit 100% $ For the 2nd UP it 100% $ Forthe3rd~nit 1001' $ For th~ 4th Unit' 100% $
Housekeeping For the 1st Unit .' 100% $ For the 2nd Unit 100%
. Forthe 3rd unit -. 100%
For the. 4th. U,nit 100%
'Arrange filt.er analysis
For the 1st Unit 100% $ For the 2nd,Un!t 100% $ For the. 3rd unit 100% $ For- the.4th Unit $
Coordjnate dean-up of work ar~~s 'and;trailer For the 1st Unit 100% $
Forthe 2nd Unit 100%
For the 3rd unit 100%
Forthe 4th Unit 100% $
P~ekage and ship'equipment off',site ,
For the lstUnit 100% $
For the 2nd Unit 100% $
For the 3rd unit 100% $
For the 4th Unit 100% $
Equipment transportation
,
_ All ~~.ontamln~_tion ,«?rks}or the 1st Unit complete
_ All decontaminai:ion works for t,he '4th. Unit complete
_ All housekeepir,g .wiirks for: the :~rld jjnit'_cbmplet~
_ All housekeepl,n~ ,worksJor ~,~ ~r.d_: Unit complete
_ ~II ' housekeeping works fortti,e'4th_Unj't .compl!';te
- All arrange filter: .ci~alysis works. for"thf3rd'.Unit .co,r;'plete
- All coordinate clean-up of work areas_~ind-trailer works for'the 1st.Unit complete
_ All coordinate clean-up of work areas-a'nd trailer works for the 2nd Unit· complete
_ AII ,cqordinate clean~up-ofwork areas,:and trailer works for the 3rd' Unit compl~te
_ AJI ,coordin'ate clean-up ofwor:r{'areas .and traile.r works for the 4th),~,nlt complete
8,413 All package and ship equipment off site works for the 1st Un,it cQmplete
: 9,983' All package and ship,equlpment off site works for,the' 2nd Unit'complete
10,233 All packa'ge and ship equipment off site works for the 3rd Unifcorripl~te
6,651 AlI,package and ship equipment off site ~orks for the 4th'Unit comp!-ete v . I.
Page 60[13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 404 of 573
Forth.iis~LJnit Fofthe2nd 'Unit For the ~id,u'nit For tne.4th,llnl'·
. ~ ~-si~stdr~ge Forthelst'Uj1it .pr <).1" Lllu' Unit
."' .~qr ih~ 3r~~ .. nit For th~ 4th'):Jnit
4:·2.S'(j) L~ssoris I~arn.ed summary:iisting
4 .2.5,(k)
4.2.5 (I)
Fortbe 1st Unit" '
For the 2nd Unit '
F.or the 3rd. unit ,
For the 4th Unit
Forthe .2nd Unit' '.
For .,' '~""~ ""
Faithe4th Unit '
Fo~-2rid:~ '. For 'h"," ,rl "nit: .
.Fodhj!,4th .u0if Proiect I aiicl Support
Gen~ral, non U'",~,~"c"k; or.oiect I dUU ~uwuO< <O' :,
, l<>rth~it For.t~e2nd ' U·nit .,.
fdN,he,3rd "nit
1st Acc~ss Port General;nonUnih~~.ifiL, . ~, 0'''' ""a,' eri'gineering .
For the. 1st Unit
For the 2nd Unit
. Forthe, 3rd'uriit'
For the 4th Unit
2nd Access ~Ort General, non . engineering
Forthe1st'Unit
For the '2nd Unit
For:the 3rd:unit
:~ . i I",.'
..
P;;nted 11/29/2013 at 9:40 AM
100% $ 100% $ 100% $ 100% $
100% $ 100% $ ' 100% $ .
; 100% t
100% $
100% $ ,
100% $
100"A. $
100% $
100% .$
100% $
100% .$
' 100% $ 100% $ 100% .$ 100%. $
100% $
100% $ 100% $ 100% $ 100% $
100% $
100% $ 100% $ 100% $
. 100% $
,;'~1,~',;i,'i,!!'\1":
" n
10.0% $
100%
100% $
100% $
100% $
100% $
100% $
100%
100% $
$ $ $ $
$ $ $ $
- $
$
$,
- $
11,876 $
11,467 $
11,467 $
7,111 $
' 11,595 $.
~$. 1p96 $
• 6;944 $ ., ..
568;241 $
1~499. $ . 931,m $ 93'1,223 $
. $77;53.4 .$ ~!;:,
312,448 $
718,9].1 $ 206,306 $ 206;306 $ on~'nR' .~
323,535$
- $ .
,
$
- $
- $
$
- $
.
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
C All i
AlI' . i '
AU off'site ".'
All.,
}'.m. u~'t complete
1 yiorks for ihe .2~d i. ,""'"0<<<
;'forth. ,
'<oniple!e ."
_ All lessons leamed .. somm,ry ilsting'works for ihe 1st Unit complete
'-. _[AU I .
. '. i .. J:.Wo'r!&:'-for:ihe 2nd Unit complete
[All lesSons I I ; for the.3rd Unit complete
_IAII lessons I i 1i<tlnS·wo,ks tOr ili.4th
.
nW . nlo"
13,516 IAU final
1
13,853 IAlI final waterlancing an'd inspection .. , 3rd Unit complete
9,004 IAIl "',., .. i". . I in: pection I r the 4th·Unit complete
n,5951AU lessons " ~ ' O<U'
13,197. IAI~so~ I ,p,i.",
13;527IAI! lessons. '"
S, 1921lill I.esions i.e'rn·ea in~."ting"
568,24~ All execution workS tor all
" tc,ir;<tbe.2ncl'iJni,cO" I
..eI. , "'''. _,"'"0<'<
312.,448 AII·works not i I ' .' specificUnli r~Iated to other., .
218,9: r the :~St~ni.trerai~a fo ol,~~r' ,
243,i,74 All wO'hlor,th .. •· ' I U.n!t"elate<j·.to
'249,:147 ~,Iw~~' .. I '
26.1;298 AII~orl\s,fpr the:
c.
. _ All i , lst< ,," Unit minimum ". the opil)ion OPG;wi~h : all OPG'.comrl).ents
;<f" nHI. rll<~r <Irinn,
_ All I . ,. TOr aCceSs ports mihimum 80% compiete .
in the oplnion'of OPG,·wlth all OPG cc'mments satisfactorily dispositio.l:led.
, ,pn, .
'. c All required engi~~,eiin.g ( ' >'" ,1st Uriit
minimum ~9.~.~n·Ti.ete r'I ,th of (I)PG; with 'all OPG comments i ' .' : i T
_ All. i . 'i deHverablcs'foraccess in tbe opinion"ofOPG, ,with alrOPG comments satisfactorily disPQsitioned.
_ All required engineering'dellverable-s for- access.oor:t.s minlmum:80% complete
in the opinion of:OPG,.with all OPG comments satisfactorily·dlspositioned .
Poge;7 of1,3
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 405 of 573
Printed 11!2~/2013 at 9:40 AM
Forthe4th Unit if
Gener'a( ~On Unit-specific,p,elih'iii1aTY
engineering
Forth" 1st Unit
For the 2nd Unit .'
For the 3rd:uriit
For the 4th Unit
4th Access Port
Gene~~I, non Unit-specific, prelirillnalY
engineering
For the 1st Unit , . "
For the 2nd Unit
Forthe 3rd unit
Forthe 4th .Unit
General, non Unit-specific, preliminary
engineering
For the ist Unit
For the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
For the 4th Unit
6th '!lccess Port
G'enehil"non Un;t-s~ecific, preliminary engineering
Forthe 1st Unit
For the ind Unit
For.the 3rd unit
Forthe4th Unit
7th Acces,s 'Port
General,·,non,Unit-specific, preliminary·
engineering
For' the 1st Unit
For the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
Forthe 4th Unit
100% $ - $
100% $ -$
100% - $
100% $ - $
100% - $
100% - $
100% $ - $
100% $ - $
100% $ - $
100% $ - $
100% $ - $
100% $ $
100% - $
:' 100% - $ .
100% $ $
100% - $
100% $ , $
100% $ $
100?' $ $
100% $
100% $ $
100% $
100% $ $
100% $ $
100% $
100% $ - $
"
.
,
j
.
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
- All required en'gi~eerrng delivera~.res f,or _a f.s~~~ ports nilnimu~ 80% comPleto In the opinion of OPG, with all OP~ comm:~ntS ~tlsfactorlly dispositioned:
. ; -. ~
. ,. _ All required engineering delivera'bles'for.the 3rd access porfnot.attributable'to
a scpec1flc Unit minim~m. 80%'c<?~lPt~t~\'1 . the opinion ofOPG, with all OPG comments satisfactort1y diSpo~i~(onep~. .
_ Allreq"uired engineeringaeliverabies for"'the-3r'd':access portJor the 1st-Unit minimum 80% complete in.the'opinion\if ePG;' with aliOPG .comments . satiSfactorily dispositloned. - . ' .
_. Afl required,engineeringJfeliveraole's for access' ports minimum_80%-complete
in the,oP1E:1ion 'of.OPG: with all-OPG commen~s'satlsfac.torilrdispositiOried. '
_' All required englne_erfng-deliVerables for 'access POrts '-inh1imurii:SO%-complete
in the opinion of OPG; Wjt~ all.DP§ ~~mn;'ents'satisfactorily ,dispositioned.
_ All requ l,red engineering deliver-abies for access ports mi,nir:n~m~80% compJ~te in the 'Opinion of OPG; with 'all OPG-comments satisfaqorily'dispositioned.-
_ All required ,engineering deliverab)g.s for-the ,4th·access 'port not atfributabl,~ , t'o ii' scpecific' Unit minimum 80% co-mpleh!' ln 'the opinion of OPG, with all ORG
comments satisfactorily disposition ed_
_ All required engineering deliv~rable,s foryH~ ~th access-pori for the 1St Unit
minimum 80% complete in the"opin!pn-ofOPG, with~all_OPGcomments
satisfactorily dispositioned ..
_ All required enginefi!ring deliverahres'fo:r a6:ess ports minimum 80% complete
in the opinion of OPG, with aU OPG ,c0l!lme~tS'SatisfactorUy dispositioned .
. ' _ All required engineering deliverabie~'for-access PQrts minimum 80% complete
in the opinion of'OPG, with all ,QPG comments sati~factorily dispositioned,
_ All required engineering,:deliv.erabli:!~for. ac'cess ,ports minimum.80% complete
!n the 'opinion:of O~.G,J.vith all OPG cOmm,ent~ s~tisfactorily disposltloned .
_ All required_engineering deliverables for the 5th ~ccess port not attributable to
a scpedfic-Unit-minimum 80% complete;in the'opinion ofOPG, with all OPG
. comments satisfactorily disposltioned.
_ All requi red,engineeringdeliverable:s for the 5th access port for the -lst'Unlt ,
.,. . minimum 80%' ~~~.~Ie,te, In th::~~_!~iq!! ot oP.G, .Wlth, all 0, ~,G.:omment~ ~ .. - satisfactoiil\i dls,positioned,.,,, ,,. : - ";, :"H. _, ' ,Y"'-, , " • -t. ~ '_ All required engineering deliv~ratile$ fofa'i::cess 'poru rTlirjiinum 80%,complete .....
in the:oplnion'of OPG: with all OPG 'comments sitisfil:ct.~iily dlsposltloned . .
_ AII 'requi,red engineering 'd~liverabl,e's ' fdr'access ports minimum'80%complete
In the opinion of OPG; wjth ·all;QP53"comm~nts satisfactorily dispositioned.,
_ All reqUired engineering'dellverabies for· aCcess' ports rn'jnlmlJm'BO% complete
in the opinion of OPG~ ,wlth'all OPG comnientS:~~'ti~fa~to~i-IY disB'o~lti~necj, .
_. All r~~~,~!redif~gj~eering,~eliVe~~~,~!~~ :f,~r t~~ '.~t~ }.Fci~-po~' t'e t ~~~ti,~~,~~~l~'-to' a scp~cI(ic Unit mini~u~ ~Q~,~~~pl~~e In the 9i:?tnio'rr <?fiO?G';~I'I.th ·aILp~G com m en ts 'sa tisfa ctorily aispositioned.
, _ All required 'engineering deiiverables-for.thi6th~access port for the 1st Unit
mlnimum'BO% comp.:[ete In the oplnlon- o('O~G.- with , all OPG:comments
satlsfactority ,d ispo~itione,:L .
_ All required enginee'ring deliverables for access ports -rril ,l)i~um 8Q% complet:e ' ..
in the-opinion'of OPG,. with all OPG comments satjsfactoril~ dispOsiti9~neli .
_ All required engineering deliverables for access pOIt$ minimur;rl-80%'Ccirhpl,ete'
in the opinion of.OPG, with all OPG comm~nts satisfactorily dispositjO~eci. '
_ All required ,engineering &:!liverabJes fo(access,ports'miriimum BO% complete
In the opinion of OPG, ,with,all OPG comments-satisfact9rily djspositio,ned.
_ All required engineering deiiverabies for'the 7th access'porl not'attributable to
a scpedficUnit mini,mum 80% complete in the opinion of OPG; witli all 'OPG
comments satisfactorily,dispositioned.
_ AlI,requlred engineering deliverables 'for' the 7th access port 'for the 1st Uliit
minimum 80% complete in-the op.inlon ,of qP.G,.with ,_ali OPG, c~mn:!ents satisfactorjly dispositioned. '
_ All n~quired , er'!gineering ,delive;'ables for access 'portS-'m!nlrnum 80%.'corl1plete
in the opinion-of,OPG, with all OPG c~mmEmts'~atjsfacto~IY. disp~~hioned.
_ All required engineenng"deliverablesJor access ports mlnlmum·SO%'comp'lete
in the opinion of OPG, with all OPG ,comments satisfactorily dispositioned.
-. ~II required engineering deliverables for~access port~ minimum 80% cOIl1Plet~
in the opinion of OPG, with all OPG comments.satisfactorily disposltloned. _ y ,'. '.','1'" '" .11
Page8a! 13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 406 of 573
853,740 $
- $
- $
$
- $
- $
- $
- $
- $
-$
$
$
OPG Darlington'Refurbishment Program
853/746 All required engin'~eririg .2~live'rables for th~ 1st access pqrt not attributable to a specific Unit mlnlmum .SO% complete.in t~e .opinion of OPG, with all 'OPG comments satisfactorily dispositi.~ned.
•
, _ All required engineering deliverables for ·tfle 1st access. port for the 1st Unit minimum"SO% complete in the·opinlon.of OPG, with ~rr OPG comments ~tisfactorily dispositibned ..
_ All required engineedng.delrverables for the lst'access port for the 2nd Unit ~'nlmu,m 80% Gomplete,'in -the':opinion of OPG, with,all OPG comments . ~atisfactor'jty d'isposit!Ot:le:d.' '
_ AIl ·re·quired .englrl.eer:in·g del\verablesfor·the 1st access port for the 3rd Unit
minimum.BO%,c:omplete ·jn the-opillion-ofOP'G, with aliOPG comments satisfact~ri.!y dis'p.o~ition:ed. '- -- .. "
_ All required engirleering'4eliverabJes 'for the 1st access port for· the 4th Unl.t , mi.nimum 80%:'compiete i~:the opinion ~f,pPG, with all OPG cominents
s,!'I tisfactoriIY,dispositione!1,
_ All required engineerin'g delive'ralJiesfor:the 2nd access :p6rt not attributable' to a specific Unit-minimum SO% c'omplete in the opinion ofQPG,.with all OPG comments satisfactorily dlspositioned ..
- f\1J r'eqi.jlred : en8·jnee.rihg;d~!iVerableslor the '~n~,aciess P'ort -for the 1st" Unit
. minimu~ 80~~~0'Tlplgte in the op'~:?jon. o(o.PG, with ali·.oPG co'mments satisfactorily,dl,sP9si~ioned, .
- All reqUlr~d .. e·rf~i~.eeii.rig:jd~li,Y~rable~ for;th,¢"2.nd access por~ for the tnd 'Uijlt
mjnimum\~.?.;.~~Goml?r~te,.in th.~:~piDjon .9f.qPGiwi~~f'all . QPG comment.s s.atlsfac~orily di.sppsit.ioned" ' . .
_ Ail reqiJlred 'englneefi"ng ce'liverables for thEf 2nd access port for the'3rd Unit . minimum 'SO%' complete In .the opinion of:OPG,-·with' ~ 1I OPG~cornments
satisfactorily disPJ)si,ti~ried ~
_ All required, enginef!dng delive'rables forthe:.:2nd access .port ·f6r the 4th.Unit ,
, mi!1iml!.m ?~:~,c:ol1}~l~t,~: i!'!J.h~:~pi~ipn,9f QFlG,··.Vo{lth~ all PRG comments satisfCl.ct9!ily.oispos.1tlont!d , . .
_ All required engineering'pe'liverables'for,tt(e":li"d'access port not'attrlbutable to .
a specific Unlt·minimum ~O% cQmplete In t~e opinion <!f O.FlG, with all OPG comm.ents satjsfag.ori1y d.js~ps~~one~.
_ All requfred·erigi'~;7er.!r*:~eli~~,~~t~~,.for:thf:!"3.~~i~ce~: port f~rthe l .st-Unit m lnimum~~O%compl:e~§ln lthe oJ?i~iorro(' 9~~"with a.11 OPG cO:lTimeh~ satjsfactorlly.disposl~i~r\"e.d . . >, ~ '. .. , "
- All require'd engl.neerin'g 'deliver'ables for.the:3rd access,portforthe .2:nd -Unit minimum 80% ·ibrnplete irl"-the'opinion Of,QPA3. with all OPG ~omments satisfact~nly~dispositloned,
_ All require,:!' engifleering;dE!Jiv'erables for.the: Jrd:access port for· the 3rd:Uhi.t
minirri!Jm SO%. compl.ete ir'-t~e 9.pJr1pn;o.f9f@, w.i.~.Z!I! OPG com..m.elJ.ts.
~ ______ ~ __ ~~~~~~ __ ~ ______________ ~~ ____ ~ ____ ~~ ____ ~ ______________ ~ ____________ ~;a~ti~sf~a,~, to~" r!C[lIy , ~~~'~'~" ,~~ ____ ~~~~~ __ ~ _. All required ~I~s€fr~~<~ :3rcj access.-port for the 4th-Un"t $
$
i
- $
q~~piQ~~gf~:;W<?, with 'all"OPG comments minimum satisfactqrily d.i~posi:t:ioned~ :,
- All required erfginee'ring .d.eJ.ivEj!ra~te'-"s for dle.4th.access port not attributabie to a specific Unit · IT!IP.im.~nr~J)%'c,oriJplet~i .n· th~ t;lpirlip~. oi.oP:G, w'ith all oPq comments sati~factotil.Y: dfsp'6siti~'~ .~d. " . . '.' ' .
_ Allrequired . erigin·eering-:cleliverat5les,f!?'r~the ~th:access pbrt ·(orthe ist Unft minimum 80%,complete in.the opinibn'of;:OPG;lwith;aH OPG'comments
satJ"Sfuc~c;)I:l ly djspositioned: ..., All (equ.lred engir:lE~eriii"g',del~yerables for th.eo;~'th.: acces~ port tpr the 2nd:Unit
.~inirri~m~.~.p% cp~pl.ete . in ·.~h.e · .R~j~·I~.trO[QtG,·.~jth '~I; ' Q.P.G . com~ent; ~ ______ ~ __ ~~~~~-.~ __ ~ __ ~~ ____ ~~~ ____ ~ ____ ~~ ____ ,-______________ ~ __________ ~~;a~tI~~~act~o~n~'~~ ' ~~~~~~.~~~~~~~~~~
- AJI required e:., .. )es.f~:r;t.~~.;4th '~cce~: po~. for the 3rd'.UI))r
i $
$
"
$
$
$
$
- $
Printed 11/29/2013 at-9:40·AM
minimum SO%- cort'plete In't e :opinion of OPG, with 'all '6~~~m~en~s ' satisfactori.ly '.dispo~itii?n·ed.
- AII' requifed ;~hglneering 'deliver'ables for,the-4tWactess port.for the 4th Onlt minimum 80% .. co,,"plete'.in:the,opinipn"'of OPG, with all OP,G commertts· satisfacto[Jly.qispositiQned.
._ All 'require.d enginee·~ing·deliverablesJorthe_:S:th · access port nat attributable to a .specifj~ Unit- ml.nlmum .8~·~ornpl~te:in :the'opinion of OPG, with all OPG
com.ments satisfu~or.II.'(:dIS·P.osi~i.of1e'd,
_ Ali -required e!l~jneerfng Clel!yerable{f~r the"'5th :a~t:ess port for the 1st·Unit miniry1urri"SO%'com~pl~"t~ III the Opi;':I'9n:"6f 6~G, ~'ith all OPG.commefits ~ satisfa'ct'orily dl spo~itiohed, ,-
_ All required engineering.deliverables·for-fhe 5tH access port fo(ihe 2nd Ur'lit , ~ini;"ur'n SO%:comple~~.i"n :the:opin·ion pfOeG, with all OPG comments '
satlsf!3~torily .dispos!tiQned,
_ All Lequ.lbid engrneering peliverab.l.es :fo~ the'Sth':access port for. the-3rd Un'it
mi~ifT!um So.~(complet.e i" .. th~>q:pi.nlol1;pf O,RG,- with 'all OPG comments , satlsf~ctorily'disposi~Qn.ed.' _. All re9u'fred engineerlrg:MliveraJlles.fcir the.:·5th acce~s:-port~fo'rthe 4th Unit minr~um-8b% CQ~pl'~t~ In . the .~pin!9_n ~f ORG, with ·~·II' OPG,colJ.lments .'
satiSfactorily disposltione·d.
Page 9 0/13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 407 of 573
. ,
-,
,.
,' .
General, non Unit-speCific, detailed engineering &
construction .drall-{ings
For the istUnit
For the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
For theAth Unit
7th Access Port
General, non Unit-specific, detailed'epgineeHng &
constructio.n drawings
For the 1st Unit
For the 2nd Unit
Forthe 3rd unit
For the 4th Unit
1st Access Port
Forthe 'lstUnit
For the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
For theAth Unit
?nd Access Port Forthe.1st Unit
For the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
For the 4th Unit
, 3rd 'Access ,Port
Forthe1st Unit
, , I Forthe 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
For theAth Unit
4th·Acce,ss,Port .. ,,' . For the,ist Unit ' ,., i ·
For the 2nd Unit
For the 3rd unit
For the 4th Unit
. 5th ActeSs Port
Printed 11/29/1013 at 9:40 AM
100% $ - $
100% $
100% $ - $
100% $ - $
100% $
100% $ $
100% $ $
100% $ - $
100% $ $
100% $ $
$ - $
" 100% - $
100% $ - $
100% $ 293,584 $
100% $ $
100% $ - $
100% $ $
100% $ $
100% $ - $
100% $ - $
100% $ - $
100% $
100% $
100% $
100% $ " - $
100% $ $
,
.1
OPG-Darlington Refurbishment Program
- A, II req~ired .engineer,lng delive,rabl.~, S for the 6th-access I?ort not attributable, '60 a·spedfic Unit minimum "80%~complete In the opinion 'of OPG, with all OPG
co~ments' ~atisfactorilY·"diSPos~ti~ned. . ..
_ A'II required .engineering,qeliverables for the 6th access port for the 1st Uni~ minl,mum 8,0% complete in the "opl~i5m of OPG, with ~1I9PG com'ments satisfactorily , dispositione~. ,
_ All required engineering aeliverables fo r t he. 6th access port for the 2nd Unit minimum 80% "complete, In-t~i7 ?pinion of OPG, with-all OPG comments satisf;;l'ctorily dispositIO(led,.
_ All requil-ed engineerin(deliverables for the 6th access port for the 3rd -Unit minimum 80% complete in ·the opinion of pPG" .with all OPG comments satisfactorily·dispositipned.
_ All required engineering dellverables fcir'the 6th access po;£for-the 4th Unit minimum 80% complete in th~ opi~ion of OPG, with ail,OPG'comments satisfactorily dispositioned.
_ All required engineering deliverables for the 7th access port not attributabl.e'tO a specific Unit minimum 80.% complete in the opinion of oPt, with all -OPG'
~omment:5 satisfactorily diSP-~~i,ti~ned.
_ Atl i:equ'rred engineering ,deliverables'far the_7th' access port for the fit Unit mini mum 80% complete In the opinion 'af OPG, with all OPG comments satisfactorily <;Ilspositloned.
_ All requir.ed engineering delivera_bles for~he 7th access port· for the 2nd Unit
niinimum 80%·completejn the opinion ofOPG, with all OPG·comments sa)isfactorilydispo~'ioned. " "
, _ All requ[red~ehgineering 'deliverables for the .7th ac"~ess,port for the 3"rd Unit rriinimun:-- 80% complete In'the 'opinion of OPG, with all OPG'co~rnents ' satisfattorily disPosltion~d. ' . "
_ All required engineering deliverables for· the 7th acces~:port f6fthe 4th Unit minimum 80%_complete In the opinion of OPG, with arr-OPG'comments
.,: satl~ic.torilv dispositi~ned.
:: AU 'mamifacture and sUP:ijIY,of access ports f6dhe 1st access port fofthe 1st
Unit cO,mplete-in advanc.e,9f being required'forthe.1st Unit~ Advance periog to be agreed with o.PG.
_ All manufacture,and'supply of access ports for the .lst access'port,for the 2nd Unit. d,mplete In advance of b·eing. r~uii~d - for:th'e-2nd Unit: Advance period to be" agreed, with OPG. ;
_ AU man'ufa.dure and supply of access ports:for:the 1st access pofHorJhe 3rd
Unit complete in'advance ,of being,required.for the 3rd tJ"it. Advance·perio.d,to . ...... be agreed with OPG. . . , ~ ...
371:. 712 All manufacture aii"ifsupply of ~access;p6rts for th~ 1st :acce~ port for the ~t:~' .\1 ~ Unit cpmp[ete in _~dva nc~ of bein'g require.,dJRr-the 4th· Unit. ACrva_n'ce' p.er~<?.d to ~ be agreed with OPG.
, ,
_ All manufacture a~~ sup'ply of ·acces~. portsfor the 2nd -acc.es$ port for the ~st Unit complete in advance of being required fo;the ~stUnri"Advance periO~ to be. agreed with OPG. ' ,
, '
!
I
_ All manufatture and supply of access'ports for-the 2nd aC(:ess port:. for the ind
, ~~~t-comple~~ in adva_n5e of being_ r:equl.red for the 2nd Unit. Advance 'perlod to be agreed -with OPG. " .
_ All manufacture a·nd supply of access ports for the 2nd access 'port for the 3rd Unit complete in advance of being required for the 3rd Unit. Advanc.e periQ(fto· be agreed with OPG.
_ AII·manufacture and supply of acces's porti'for the'2nd access port for the 4th
Unit ~omplete In ' ad~an~e of.belng.required fo r the ~th Unrt ., ~dvance·-·~eri6d to: be agreed w:i~h " OPG.
_ All-manufacture and supply of access ports 'for the 3rd 'access' pdrt'fpr,the-lsi: Umt complete in advance of being,required for. the -1sf'Uni't."A:dvance period to be agreed with OPG. . " <, . ' ' . .
_ All manufacture and supplY-of access' ports for th~ '3rd access port for-the-2nd Unit complete in advance·of being required for the 2'nd Unit. Adv<l'nl::e period to be. agreed with OPG. '
~ All manufacture and supply of access ports.fo(the 3rd_access port for" tt{~ 3rd Unit complete in' ady~nce of bei~g require.d for. the 3ni"l:lnit. Advan~e_peri9d to b~,pgreed -.wi~h OPG.
_ Atl ~anu.factu-re and suppiy'ofacce$$ ports for the '3rd access 'P,9rt' for the' 4,th
Unit complete in adva~t~:orf being required:for-tHe 4th Unrt. Advanceperiddto be agreed 'wlth OPG.
_ All ma.nufacture and suppfy of access -ports- for the 4th access po~ for the-1st
Unit complete in advance of being required for the"lsfUnlt. Advance period to b~ agr"eed with OPG. - \' "~ I • - ,: .
_ AIr" man-ufacture and supplyaf,access ports for the 4th access port fcir thE{ 2nd
Unit comp'lete ,~n advance of being r:equired "for 'the 2nd Unit. Advance-period to be a~~eed'with ·OPG. '.
_ All manufactu-r~ and supply of access ports for the 4th 'accE!ss'port for.the3.rd
Unit complete in advance of being required'for the_'3rd Unit. Advance,period.to be agreed with OPG. -- - ~. .
_ Ail m~mufacture and supply of'access"ports for"the'Ath aCCe:ss' port ,for 'tl1e 4th
U, nit complete' in advance of being required,'for the 4th Unit. Adyanc~ peri~d. t.aI • be agreed with OPG. . . ,. 11 . . ~
Pagl.! 100113
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 408 of 573
For the 1st
2ndUnit
Edr
Forthe 4th
. Forthe
For the Uriit
For the 2nd .Unit
For the 3rd unit
.Unit
For
Forthe 4th' Unit
Printed 11/29/2D13 at 9:40 AM
$
100%
100%
100% $
$
$
$
$
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
In advance of for.the.4tf,"O',iU\dv.anc'; '.p,,,io.Hc,beagreed with OP,G.
Page 11 'of 13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 409 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
General, non Unit-specific, detailed engineering & 100% S S -IAii spa,es, calib"'tion, testing devices and tools supplied and ~
construction drawings I delivered . of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to
lag,eed with OPG. For the 1st Unit 100% S - S _IAII spares, calibration, testing devices and tools supplied and "
Idellvered i of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be
la"eed with OPG. For the 2nd Unit 100% $ - $ -IA" spares~ testing devices and tool s supplied and
Idelive,ed i of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be
lag"ed with OPG. For the 3rd unit 100% $ $ _ IAII spares, calibration, testing devices and tools supplied and
Idelivered i of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be la"eed with OPG.
For the 4th Unit 100% $ - S _ IAII spa'os, calib,ation, testing devices and tools supplied and Idellvered i advance of being required for th e 1st Unit. Advance period to be
la"eed with OPG. , spares, ,~libr~tinn, testing devices and tools
General, non Unit-specific, detailed engineering & - 100% $ $ -IA" ~testlng devices and tools supplied and
construction drawings Idelive,ed i of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be
la"eed with OPG. For the 1st Unit 100% $ - $ _[All spares, calibration, testing devices and tools supplied and
I d eliv~red i of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be la"eed with OPG.
For the 2nd Unit 100% $ -$ -IA" = spa,e;;;;iii;~testing devices and tools supplied and Idellvered i advance of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be
la<'eed with OPG. For the 3rd unit 100% $ $ _ All spares, calibration, testing devices and tools supplied and
delivered i advance of being required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be
ag,eed with OPG. For the 4th Unit 100% S 495,006 $ 626,735 ':~Iimed I
spares, ca libration, testing devices and tools supplied and
of beIng required for the 1st Unit. Advance period to be OPG.
;~,',,~ 'Y,:;~J~ nID-,;r,-,::~';;';:;-':;l;;'::( ,;~", :,~~." i,l
_' AlI~;te , ' ....
For the 1st UnJt : lob% $ $: ,en""o, m".~> ''', ,acceptea ay '.u'yU ,J.
For the 2nd Unit 100% $ $ ;, _ AU site documentation for the'2,nd Unit complete and·accepted by OPG
"
For the 3rd unit 100% $ $ _ ,A!I 'site for the 3rd ~nit ~omplete and accepted by:bPG. -"
Forthe-4th Unit 100% $ 145,.94.8 $. .~~ ·,1,0 ' i~ ,.;,J accep\edby oP.G'
t:4\}j~., i: Plarml,n, ,,,' ~.,,"
Gen~ral, non . ' . I ) 'n •• ';n~ & 100% $ 15,121 $ 15,121 :~c~:::~·:~~~Plann!ng "peclfte'
~~ " drawings
" the i st Unit 100% $ $ ~lst' ' ,."u .cce",edby OPG I"""
For the 2nd Unit ' 100% $ $ ~ ". ' 1 , and accepted 'Oli oPG
For the,3rd unit 100% $ $ _ All in'rallation planning 10' the 1st" , and . ·ccepted by OPG
For tne 4th Unit 100% $ 120,639 $ 152,743 Aliinstallatiori "0' 1st Unlt"cbmplete"and accepted by;OPG .
~:3,~3"'~ '. . ~,
I and PreCn-boiler works' , For the 1st.Unit . 106% $ 1$ ~bn-bolli"wO'kScfO,th'-lst , In ,ih.!'opl~iori
For the 2nd Unit 100% $ $ ,", , !'JOrKS for the "2nd unit ~?mplete in the'opinion
10ioPG . For the 3rd unit 100% $ $ ~WOd(SIO'ihe 3,dunit complete i "" .. 0.",lu,}
': For theAth Unit 100% $ 96,301 $ 121,929 1::I~;~outage and p,e on.boile, wo,ksfo, th.4th unit ~omplete-in t~e:oPiriion
4 .. 3.4 I'rojectsDPclfic training
For the 1st Unit 100% $ . 1$ IA" !lstUnit complete
I'or,!he 2nd Unit .. 100% $ i $ <no dUni' c,9mplete . For, the 3rd unit , ,. 100% $ - • $ IAiI '"J' "'8 lorth'e 3,d Unit complete .
. Forthe 4th Unit 100% $ 1,349,420 I $ 1,768,522 IAiI 'tca'n'~,' " me "riUnit complete
I ffli~iEI f,AcceSs' />driS -~ ., ">-
4.3 •. 6 (e) Removable in~ulation patches Forthe 1st Uriit 100% $ - $ -l!it-~~~~I~~:: ~ ",. ! I n otacces~ po,tHo,r. me 151
, For the 2nd Unit 100% $ i $ IAII ~~~~vable insulation patches wmk!~' In,,,!lI~tion 01 a.cess .ports 10, the , For the 3rd Linit ibo% $, - $ -1~~~:i~~:~::::~.lation patches work 10' in,!t')I,'ion of acces' ports lor tfie
Forthe 4th Unit 100% $ $ _ . I ;!nsulation patches work lodnstaliation 01 access portsloi' th~ 14th Unit comolete. .
Installationof'access ports
For the 1st Unit .' 100% $ - $ 1"Unstallation 01 a.ccess ports ,York lor the 1st Unit complete.
Forthe 2nd Unit 100% $ $ IAjiTnStaiiati~~lorihe.2na I
For the 3rd unit 100% $ $ I I , of access ''''om
For the 4th Unit 100% $ 810,693 $ n,c ." Ii , ofaecess ports wOrk 10' the,Aih, ~. ' ~ <u'" '.'<<<. ~ • ~,6(d) ,,~, ,-u,=-u u,uve weld ~'d"""d"U" ~ For the 1st Unit 100% $ $ _ IAII non destructive weld examination work for the .lst Unit complete. - .. '
Printed 11/29/2(J13 at 9;40 AM Page 12 0/13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 410 of 573
, 4.3.7'
4.3c7 (b)
4.~ .. 9
Version: ROS
!I1Spectl(ll' of Insta!led')\ccess:,,1\9rts
Fortbei3rdurlit'
Other i;;,pedians
Forth. 2nd. uiil.t Forthe.;!rd unit
Fo'r the 4,th Unit'
Post R~uisite and Demobilisation
Removal:"fAnfrastru.ctu re· and tem pp,ary
modifi"atio~s
For,t~etsi Unit ,
Filr .the>3rdunl\ ·
For:the.4th Unit
F(kt~e1stJJnit Forthe2nd'-Unit
Foi'the 3ralmit .
Turnover to OPG
TtirnaveFto.: OP.G
OftheJst U.nit
Qf\he 4th Uhlt
I I
For ihe2nd. Unit For the3rcH.injt
. For tli~,4thUriit
O~herGo~ts .General,nonUrlit:sRecific, equipment and mater.ial supply
Forthe 1st Unit ,':
Forihe;4th unit
PrInted 11/29/2013 ot 9:40 AM
$
$ $
$
$
$
$
$
$ $, $ $
$ $
70;360 $
- $
7,71~ 1 $
-$
86;9~7 $
463,326 1 $
$
$ 66S,5~O I $
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
-' AtO!:!f~~~rl.l~~fu,~¥ t?;<sUp~9.rt 6,biZl ~.:~i)st~fl~t!9,~ .~o·rk' for.ftie 1st 'Un·ifcom~lete.
- ~11-idf~~r4~t;f~ 'fl:tsi'~~6~ nOZil€t" n~t~lJaiidn W~k;·fcir~d'e>2nd'Uriit.·co'th~lete .
~ AII ·ins'pe·c;t~atceS5-po:f.ts-.woi'kfo:r.ttl~3·rd .' Ur)itcomplete .
_ -A!I. , ins.e~t.~,~e.ss'p~rts ~oik''f6r:t~e 4t11·' ~·~it .CO·rri~;~~:
.~\ ~lf 'ie,jl'ovafoflnfrastfiJ~ure and-temfiQrary' modifications worl{s-f~r.' the 2na .,. !1ni~ .comple.te ~' All reW'ovatbf.:lnfrastructu·re'ani::l t!,!inporary modifica.tions-works·for the 3i'd
Unit complete • _. AlI:"remo·val-o{ih(r.frtiikture; ~~~:~erj1po~!3'ry .·rn~ificati~ns "work~ 'fo'r:ihe_4~h '
Unit.complete · . , .
_ AII·remoVa rof infrast'nicture' an d_lerriporary .mod iflcations wo'rks··for ·the. i6d . Unitcomplete .
:?: ~U!removal:Sf: infra_s.frw:;t!:lre))~~~:i~iTIpor~rYmq~qi91i(p!ls ~pr~s;fAr ~~'e ~~~ . U.I1It:coIJ!P,i~te . . -_ -~ ' .
_ All tLJrhoYer td OP<3,wor!<S'for the l'st, Uilit Jcomplet~
,
'~I
463,326 AII: ..... :or'ks' notattributa61e to a .~~fic Unit r:elated to:'other costs ~omplet~
Page 13 0/13
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 411 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment- Program
. Darlington Nuclear Generating Station Steam Generator Refurbishment
7.1{71jMilestone Payment Schedule for Op~ional Work (ONTARIOPOiME
. GENEJlATI
$ works'riot attributable to a
._ All werki. not
_ All works not costs complete
training not attrIbutable to 'a specific complete
Printed 11/29/2013 at 9:40 AM Pagel 0/2 .
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 412 of 573
OPG Darlington Refurbishment Program
equipment and 100% $ Allworks not
$ _ All
OJ
Printed"11/29/2013 at 9:40AM Page 2 0/2
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 413 of 573
·~~~~-'Diirliii'itOif.N~liiiir.-~inerating-StationSteainGe-n-eratDrReffi!bJsh~'i~t- -
,.1l2J),:,a~,O~! St.~e~~ie ~-ONTARIOF,Owiil
.. . . ; " GENERATION
2
'. 15
1
2;'25 3:38 3:38
3.~8
4.50.
4,59, 4,SO
2.25 .. 2;~5'
" 2: 25
~.3~ 3:38. 3:38 4~sb 4:~O 4:50
2:2,5 . ' ~~2~
,2'.25 , 3.38 3:38
3.38 '4:@
' 4:~' 4:50 i:25 2.~
2.25
3:?8 .!ds 3:~8 4;:50_ 4.50
~;~~ . :. 2:25
~:~~'. "
!~!: . . 4.50
~.sO ,4.59 2.15 2~25 2,25
3',38
~.38
3.38
4.50 4:50
4:S~
.2.7~
4.,11 "5.'48
£7~ '4.11 5 .. 48 2·7~ 4.1:! 5.48 2)4 4)1 5:48
2.74 4.11
s.:~~ '. 2;7~ ,
92.63 117.90 120 .. 70
-I- """""'-+~"""-c- f . . ~~i5~
14.61 14.6t .19.48 19.48 , 19.:48'
9:74 9.74 9:74 14:61 -14.61
14.61 19.48 19.48
19:48
.9?4 9.7,4
9.74 . . 14.6r-
14.61 14:61
;!l~ 19.48 . 9.7~~ 9.7~4 ·
~.74 14.61 14-.61 14'.61
19.48 19.48 19.48, 9:74'
9.7;4,' 9.74"
1~.61
. ~~:~~ 19:48 l!Ua 191s ?:74 9.74
9.7~
14.61 "14.61
14,~1 19.48
11.66 5~8} 8)5 1L66
~:83 8.75
11.6.~ 5:83
~.75 11.66 .
Lt. i\4 1.52' 1.52
1~~ 0.76
0:7~ 0.7? 1.14 1.14 1.14
1.5\2 1.52 1.52'
0.76 0.76 .0:7'6 1:14 1: 1:~ 1.14 1.52
1~~ 1.52
0':76 0.7.6' 0.76 1.14 1.14
1.14 "1.52
1.52 1.52 0.76
0.76
. ~:7~ ' 1.14 1.14 . Lt4 i :52 1.52 152"
0.76'
03'6 0.76 _ 1.14
1: 14 1.14 1.52 1.52 1.52.
56.08 57.3g 58.68 ' 84.ii 8~.0!
·808.~} 112.17· 114.76
-117.36 53:62 .'
54.76 55":9.1
,80.41 8.2:14
83.87 107.22
10?5~' 111.83 35.'97
36.66 37;36,
,53."95 '5~ :99 56;03
~1.:?~ 73:~?
, 7~:7I
40.38
47:1~ 41.99 60.S? 61.78
62:99 8;0.76 82.37 83:9'9
4~;'79 .45 .. 71 46.63 67.19 '
68,57 69.95 .
89:59
9h'2 .. ~!:~ 50::23 Si.28'
i3.~9\ 75;3~
19:!;I;2. . 98:39
100.47 ·1(n.56 53:30'
79.95 lQ6:~0 51.44 '77.16 ioi.8~ · 50.64 75:.96 :
101.27
49~-£9 74.69
95!.S~ 47.59
7'j~9 95:18 47~S'9 71'.3'9 9,5}.8 . 22.73 34:10
45:46 3/1..27 51.40 68.54 3,9.98
59.97 79.96 43.78 65:68 8'7:57.
~8.24 87.36
0.20
0.20' 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20
~.~O 0:20 0.20
0 .29 0.20 0:20
0.2~ . 0;20'."
0.20 0.20
,~ 0.20
0.20
O·fO 0.2g
0.20 0.20 0.20,
0;20 0.20 0:'20
0:·20 . cho o~io
&:~~: .. O'.~~ 0:20
0:20
0.20 0.20'
ci.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
.. 0.20 'ci:20
0.20
, ~.2~ 0.23
. 0.2.3
0.23 023 "
0.i3 '~.23 .: P,23
O.ri · '0.'13 0:'23
q.2i 0.23 ·
t~ · .~;~: .
"'~~~~ ~ ~~;~) ·~~7~9. ' Z~?l% Z,729 2,729
'Z/21j "
~;?~:9 2,72!J
,.-1,?~ . ~~"~~
- ' ~~i~ '2,729
eli: . iii~ ,Z;72!}
. i~72~ . 2;72'9
:i;tZ9 -:2;:129
.~;~~: 2~7~
' 2,72,
, ~;l~ ·2,729
~i?~. >,719
' : ~,7_~
~;~~ 2,729 ;2;729 ' 2,7.29 2;729 .
2,729 .. . 2,729
);i29 ·:i;729 ·Z.-7'29 .2,729
, I,
.1
0.89
0.85 0.86 0.89
~.8S '
0.~6
0.89
~.8S 0,86
.0.89
O.~S
0.86 0,89
0.85
0.85
0:85
0.85
0.85
. 0.85
0.85.
' 0.85
0.85
0,43
0:~6 0.47
0.43
0.45 0.47
0.47
0.43
0.4!_
0.43
OPG D.~r1I~gtO!l' R~f~rl;1!$h,~e,nt ""R,ra,m . -Turbine Generalor Projec!
:$'64;79/ S66.30/hi $92.8"6;/l1r $·.95~09/hr $ 19'7.32i l '~f ·
~t~~~$r}~~ $·129.69,"/ol1r .$ 6O~io / or $:Sl~64' /hr
'$'63.04' / hr '.' ~-::~~ ~:! $!i2'·;4.3/hr
.~~~~·t:~~{t~ $)i3!18:/,hr
,s, ,~7 '.9/nl S·,58.8S/lir $.'60:i:r /. h~ S. 84~36 H';r $·86~19. /hr A88.0~~. / :hr
·.S'iI2" ll,h, : $-114:86/'hr '
$~ 1;i;.~36~:~h: .' '. S. 3~~~~. / h~
$40.42/hr $·S6.28/hI
$:57:38 /" $58:49"/hi $ 74:97 ibi S76:4!i:/.-.hr · $7?:92' i b/ $' 43.S4·/hr S··iUS/hr S· 45.::14· ;ti~ $ 63~30 lhr $' ~4.59lhr ~ .6S~81ihr S8~;34lhr . $86:0S/hr
$87.7~, /hr $48.22/hr
.' ~49.t~/,hr $SO.2.6) hr .$7rJ.:33' j hr p;.79/pr $ 73.2S / hr $93.70/h(
. ~~(~~ J'~~ S·97.;60:/.- hr
$5l90} h, .. $ '54.64:/ ·h;
$. 5~:19/1:I~ $:77.33/l1r
' $ -78: 9r;,"j~r
$\86~f://~r $ ~0.?- . 2S !, ~.~ $.'O7,46l ~'
.. ~~~:i:,;~· ~~ . :$ 112'.18·./t'ir '
$;.~5:;l/hr . ;$S1.23I.Df . $ ~98.23 ( hr . \$'·5~.6S I hr $ ·7.?J~~:I,hr
$}R:~~,,/~J . $ .. S"3:76/ hr
::o~~/t~~ · }i;?O~"~ ·S'·100.Q6:! hr
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 414 of 573
'113L~~SCA 114!EPSCA
~i5IEPS~A 116: EPSCA
1~17~i~PSCA :~ll:,~rEPSCA 119iEPSCA
12oiEPSc;A
~~~I~:~~ : 123iEPSCA 124jEPSCA .
,1.25!~~SCA 126lEPSCA
' mlm~ 130'iEPSCA 13i!E'PSCA
132!~PSC;A 133iEPSCA
~34j~PS~ 135jEPSCA
136!EPSCA
l.i~!~PS~A 1381Ep,Sq.. 139!EPSCA , 140tEPSCA
: 141!EPSCA
?-83~EPSCA 184iEPSCA 185!EPSCA
18~!EP:SCA 187iEPSCA 188iEPSCA
1~9IEP~~ 199iEPS~A
.~ ~:~I!~~~ ·· .I' 1~3!E'~?CA 194!EPSCA
195iEPSCA 196iEf'SCA
1i17iEPSCA
19~!~PSCA 199!EPSCA
200!EPSCA
201iEPSCA 202iEPSCA
293iEPSCA " 204:EPS'CA
Locals 1007,1151,1 Mllly.'rights
Locals 1097,1151,1 Millwrights Locals 1007,115i,1 M1I!wrights Locals 1007,1151,1 Millwrights
Locals 1007,1151;1 MIII.w(lghts local,s 1007,1151,1 Millwrights local~ 1007,1151,1 Millwrights locals'1007,l1S1,1 !Y1ll1wrlghts
locals 1007,1151,1 f:.:1ll1wri~hts locals'1007,1151,1 MIII,wrights locals 1007,1151,1 MillwrIghts Locals,1007,1151,1 MillwrIghts
Locals 1007,115.;,1 MillwrIghts Locals 1007,1151,1 Mi"llwrights
Locals 1007,1151) ~illwrig~ts locals 1007,1151,1 MiIlwr,ights Locals 1007,1~51,1 MiIlw!ights
locals 1007,1151,1 M1I!wrights locals 1007,1151,1 M1I!w~lghts local 598 Cement Masons
local 598 local 598 •
Local 598 Lbca'IS98 Lo·~1.598 Local 598 Locaf598
Local 598 local 598
Local,~98
Local 598 Local 598 Local 598 L6'~aI598
/ Local 598'
Loca(598
Local 598 Local 8,94 Local,89,4 Local 894 Local 894
local 894 local 894 local 894
loca1894 Lo~189'4 Lo.cal~94 Local 894
Local 894
Loeal721 ,,~ ,
~ocal'721
tocal721 Local 721
Local?21 Local 721
LocalJ21 Local 721
Local 721 , Local721
Local 721 loCal 72'1'
Local 721 Local 721
Local 721 Local 721 Locar721
LOcal 721 Local 721
Local 721 local 721 local 721 local.721 lo'caL721
local721 Local 95
Local 95 Local 95 local 95
local 95 Local 95 Local 95
Loca195 Local 95
ce.~ent.Masons Ce.mentMasons
Cement Mascins C~~'ehtMasons G:e~entMasons Cement Masons
~~m~nt Masons . Cement Masons
. Ce;;'e~t 'M~sons C~m~ntMasons Cement Masons
ce~'~~.~' Mason? Cement Masons
EI~ct~i~al ,Workers ' Electrical Workers EI~ct~lcaL\.V~:rkers Electrical Workers
Electrical Workers Ele¥ ic,aj'workers
Electrical Workers Electric~I'Workers
, Electricar'Wo'rkers
Eleci:rlc~iw~rkers , Electrlc~J'o/0rk E;rs
ElectrIcal Workers Elect r'icalWorkers ElectficarWorkers
Ir~nworkers Ironworkers Ironw'orke}s
Irori~orke!s Ironworkers Ironwo~kers Ironworkers Ironwork'ers
Ironworkers lronwo'rke~s Ironworkers
Ironworkers Iro'A",!orkers
Ironworkers Ironworkers
. I~~'nworkeis Ironworkers [ro'n~orkers Ir~nworkers
Ironworkers
Ironworkers Ironworkers
Ironworkers Ironworkers Ironworkers Ironworkers
Insulators Insulators Insulators
Insulators Insulators
Insulators Insulators Insulators Insulators
05,~9 i~oreman i 436365 05-8 ,, !S';Ibforeman ! '436355
01-May-12
01-May-12
01·~ay-12
01-May-12
01·t.;'IaY~12
01-May·~2
01-May-12 'Ol,~MaY-12 ,o1:~ay.-12
01-May.12
01~May-12
01-May-12
01-MaY~12
30:Apr-13
30-Apr-1.3 30-Apr-13 30-Apr-13 3D-Apr-13 30-Apr-13
3D-Apr-13
3D-Apr"13 3D-Apr-13 3D-Apr-13
3D-Apr-13 3D-Apr-13
05-8 jSubforema,n II! 436355 05~8 iSubforeman 436355
05-6 ! j~urneyman 436335 05-6 !Jour~eyman , 436335
05-~ iJourneyman. I 436335 . 05.-0 !Apprentlce (0 -199~ hrs)j 436315
05-0 IA~~rent'ice (0 -1999 hrs)! 436315 05-0 iApprentice (0 - 1999 hrs)! 436315
05-1 IAPpren~l~e{2000-3~~9 ~ 436315 05~1 iApp,relJ~IFe <.2000: 3999 ~ 4363f 5
05-1 lApp.rentlce {2000 - 3999 ~ 436315
05-2 iApprent!~e (4~PO - 5999 ~ 436315
3D-Apr-13 01-May-12 30-'Apr-13
OS~2 iA~l?,rentice (4000 - 5999 ~ 436315 05-2 iApprentke (4000 :~999. ~ 4363i5
01-M~Y-12 3Q-Apr-13 01~May:12 ' 30-Apr-13 iOl~M.ay_12 30-Apr-13 05;.3 l Apprentic~ (60.00 -' 8000 ~ ~'3'(h:15
05~3 !Appn,;t{tke (6000 - 800b ~ 436315 ,:{i1-May~i2 05·;3 iApp~entice (6000 - 8000,~ 436315 0~;:~ayol:2 1?,-9 iF.~renyan < 1 1,1 443300006655 01-May-09 .
30-Apr~13
30-Apr-13
,, 16-0 16-1 16-1 16-1
16-2
16.-2 16-2
~7-9 , q?-9 07-9 07-8
07,-8 07:8,
07.-6 07-6
07;6 07-6·, 07-6
.D7-6 07-6
07-,6 ~ 07~6
07-0 07-0
07-0 '07-1-
97,-1 07-1 07-2 07-2 07-2
07-3 07-3 07-3
07-4
.07-4 07'4
19:7 19-7
19·7 19~8
19-8
19·8 19·6 19-6
19-6
19·0 19·0 19·0 19-1 19-1 19-1
19-2 19-2 19-2 19-3
19-3 19-3 19-4
--19-4
19·4 19-5 19-5 19-5
22-~
22·9
22-9
_ 01~May:09 i 430065 0~-May-09
"".",
! 4'3P'o55 01~May-09 , 430055 Oi:MaY;.09
4300!;5 > '01~May:.o9 43.~035 '01~N!ay:09
!. 4~093? ' (Jl-May:09 i 4?o.035 ' "01_May-09
pp~e~ntice - 1st Term of: 430015 01-~aY-09 , pp~~~tice -1st Term of l ",4390l~ .~~-M.a y"{)9
I:~~~':~~,::: ~ ~~T;~;: o:fl ':~~~i-~ .0~-MaY-Q9 IApprentlce-2ndTerm of!
iApp~e~~i~~ ~.~ ~.d 1e!m ofi !Appre~tice - 3rd 2000 hr~
! APp,r~ri~i~-.~J~ 2.~00 hr~
. I;qi~::~,e-);d 2000 h'i
I~;:;:;~:~ I jSubforeman ! :Journeyman 'I jJourneyman :
j ~~~~:~n"an !
!:::~:~:,' i !C0tT!mun1catlonsEI~ctrlcli
·· I~~s~g:li:~:~;:f:~i:~:1 I lAPprentlce -1st Period' .j
!App'rentfc'e'-:'2nCr~erlod 1-!Apprentl~ : 2IJdPerlod . ! !Appre~ti~~ ~ 21]d Period ! !~'pp ~enti~e - 3rd Period ! i iA·~~~n!ice~.3rd Period ! 01~May-i2 ! . !Apprenti~e-.3rd P~riod .! ' bl~MaY:12 i
I~p~~e~t;c; - 4t~ ~~riod! 410115 1 ','~~~MM" ~YY"~~~ ' ! iAp,~ rentlce - 4th ferlod ! -410i15 ! _ !A'pprentlce-4th ~erlod! 410115 ' q,1~MaY-12 ! !A'~pre,n~i~e- '~th Period i ~~~:!-,~~' Qi:M~y~12 I '
1 i~~pr.enti~~ -) ~t~ p~fiod I ~nOn5 '~1~May~12 . ' iApprentlce-5th P~riod! '4.10115 01-May-12. ' ls!ili6r'F~re~a~ - Lines &'S~ati~r}s~'OnIY O,i~ M·<!Y:l.2 i~enior F(;m~man - Lines'& St~tl,onS,.only ~ ~ 01;Ma'y~12 !Senior Foreman -lines & Stathi ns only . ' 91;~~'i-12 i _
, IFor~man '. i ~ "~450,6~ , i ~~A~r~+? !,Fore~an i ~45,065 , ! 3~Apr-13 !For~man" i '445065 '
:Fore~an iry Training- Lines & St.~tions 0 " iForema~n inTraining- Lines & Sta~ions ri ]Foreman In Tralning- Lines & Stations ~ isubforem'iI'n ! 445riss
!Subforeman i 41~OSS !Subforeman . i .44~055
l~:~~~:~~:~ :~:~::~~:~:I ::~~~~ '. iJourneyman Ironworker,! 445035 '
,Apprentice - 1st 1000 hrsi ,::~~~~
I:::~:~·~:'~:: ~:~ ~:~ ~~:! 445015 IApprentlce - 2nd 1000 hrJ 445Cll'5
lAppren~lce - ~nd 1000 'hr1 44~015 IAPpre,~tice, - 2nd 1000 h~ 445015 jApprentice - 3rd 1000 hl1/ 445015
!Ap~re~n'~ I~e : 3rd 1000 h~ 445{!15 jApprentlce - 3rd 1000 hrsj 445015
I::'h~~~:::: ~ ::~ ~:~ ~~~ :~~~~
-L ~D-Apr~.113 ., !" , -!_ ... ~~.Apr-13 1 3D-Apr-13 ! ,3(}:Apr-13
! 3D-Apr-i3 ;L 3Q-Apr-13
! 3O:~pr-13 ! 3Q.:Apr-13 ! ' 3D-Apr~13 l 3D-Apr-13
! '3D-~~r"13 ! 3D-[\pr: 13
: " ~D-Apr,-13 ! 3D=Apr-13
i 3Q,.Apr-i3
IAP'prentlce - 4th 1000 hr~ 445015
iAPprentice - 5th 1000 hr~ 445015 ' 3D-Apr-13 iA'ppr~ri~Lce ~ 5th 1000 hr~ 445015 t 3D-Apr-13
- iApprentlcE; .-\ 5t~ 1000 hr~ 445015 01-.May-12 l. 3D-~pr-13 . iAppr~ntlce.~ 6~h 1000 hr~ 445015 01-May-12 i 3D-~pr-13 . iAp~r~~tl~e - 6t~ 1qoo hr4 445015 0l~May-l'2 i 3D-Apr-13
" iAp~rentic~.- 6th 1000 h.~~ 445015 01-May-12! ~D-Apr-13 !Foreman : 445655 15-May-12! 3D-Apr.-13
orel)1a n I 445655 15-May-12 i 3Q-Apr-13
22-8 eman 445665
. 445655 445655 445655 445635 '445635
445635
15-May-12 i 3Q-Apr-13
15-May-12 ,j ~Q.=Apr-~3 15-May-12 i 3~Apr-13 "
15-M~y-12 i 3D-Apr-13
15:May-~2 i 3D-Apr-l~ 15-May-12 i 3D-Apr-13 15-May-12 i .3D-Apr-13
22-8 isubforeman
22-8 :Subfpreman . 22-~ ' . ilnsulatingMechanic 22-6 " !lnsulatingMecha'nlc
1'2-6 !lnsulatlngMechanic
15
1.5
"1.5
15
1.5
1.5
15
1
1.5
15
1.5
15
1.5
1.5 2.
1.5
1.5
15
15
2
15
15
86.16 40.33 60.50 80.66
37.58 56.37
75.16
75.50 37.75 56,63
.~!:~.~. 1:: . ~2:28 i 4%
~:-:~)- l ' :~' ~~:~! 1:: 2,2.48 1 4%
33.-72 1 4%
44.96 .1' 4%
26.30 ! 4%
~9 :45 ']' 4%
.~~:~ I:: 45.17 . . J 4%'
~60~22 !' 4%
41.98 i 10% 62:97 ! 10% ~3 :~6 . < ! 10%
~~::~ ',· I~:
41'.07 · 54.76 29.20 43.80 58.40
3l.03 46.55 62.06 32.85 49:28
65.70 39.78 59.67 79.56
38.2~
57.42
76.5~
36.7~
55.17 73.56
8.62
.3.48 l.66
1.49 0.90
l.35 1:80
1.05 1.58 2.10 l.20 l.8 1
4.20 6.30 ~
8.40 4.09 6.:13 '8:18
3.94 5:91
7.88
3.~0 5.85
'7.80
3.65
5.48 7.30 '
2.19 <3.29
4.38 2.'56
3.83 5.11 2.74 ,
4.11 5.48 2.92
4.38 5.84 3.10 ~:65
6.21 3.29 4.93 6.57 3.98
5:97 7.96 3.83 5.14
7.66 3.68 5.52
7.36
1m
""
5.22
2.49 3.74 4:99 2.27 3.40
4.53 2.27 3.40
4.53 2.27
8.00 4.00 6.00 8.00
4.~0
6.00 8.00 4.00
6:00 8.00 4.00 6.00
~.'oo 4.00 6."60 8.00 4.00
6.00 8.00 1.% 1.96 1,,9.6
.1.96
3.11 4.6,7
6:22 3.11 4.67
6.22 3.11
4.67
6.22 3.11
4.79
6.38 3.19 4.79 6.38 3.19
4.79 6.38 3.19
, 12.qo
6:00 9.00 12.00 6.00 9:00
12.00 6:00 9'.00
12.00 6.00 9.00
12.00
6.00 9.00
12.00 6.00 9.00
12.Q,0 4.00 4.00
4.00 '4.00
1.00 4.00 4.00
, 4.0~
4.00
4.00 4.00
~.OO
10.50
14.00 7.00 10.50
14.00 7.00 10.50
14.00 'i.OO 10.50 14.00
7.00 10.50 14.00
7.00 10.50 14.00
~.OO
10.50
14.00 6.82
10.23 13.64 6.82
10.23 13.64
6.82 10.23
13.64 6.82 10'.23
13.64 6.82
10.23 13.64 6,82 10:'23
13.64
6.82 10.23 13.64 6.82
10:23 13.64 6.82 10.23 13.64
6.82
10.2? 13.64 6.82 10.23
1~.64
7.00 7.00 i.oo 7.00 7.00 7.00
7.00 7.00 7.00
DO
0.85 1.28 l.70 0.85 1.28
1.70
0.~5
1:28 1.70
'0.85 1.28 1.70 0.85
1.28 1.70 0.85
).28 1.70 0.49
0.49
0.~9
0.49 0.49 0.49 0.49 0.49
6:49 0.49 0.49 0.49
0.49 0.49 0.49
0.49 0.49 0.49 '
3:30 ' 4.95 6.60 pO 4.95 6.60 3.30 4.95
6.60 3.30 4.95
6.60 3.30
4.95 6.60 2.30
. 3.45
4.60 2.30 3.45 4.60
2.30 3.45 4.60
2.30 3.45 ,4.60
2.30 3.45 ~.60
0.76 l.14
!.~~ 0:76
1.14 1.52
0.76 1.14
l.52 0.76 1.14 1.52 0.76
1.14 1.52 0.76 1.14 1.52
0.76 1.14
1.52 0.76
1.14 l.52 0.76 1.14
1.52
0.76
1 .. ,14 1.52 0.'76 l.14
1.52 '0.39
0.39 0.39
0.39 0.39 0.39
0.39 0.39 0.39
116.48 55.'21
8.2.82, 110.43
52.19 78.29'
104.38 35.66
53.49 71.31
• 3"9.79
59.69 79.58. 43:9~2
65.88 87.83
4~.,o~ 72.08 •
9~.~0
48.58 69.65
9,0:71
46.~3
67:17 87.41 45.28 64.70
84.1~
27;70 40.32 52.94
35.58 50.14 64.71
41.40 58:87 '76:34 '
'61.22
. 9,1.82
122.43 59.13
88.69 118.25 54:94 82.40
109.87 54.94 82.40
l09.?7 54.94
82.40
28.75 '43.12
57.49 3-iss
4~~42 65.89
37.14 55.71 74.28
41.34 62.01 82.68
45.53 68.30 91:06 56:95 85.42
113 .. 90 55.,74 83.61 ili.48
54.13 81.20
108.26 53.67 80.51
10.7.34
50.92 76.38 101.84
34.86 52.29 69.72
.38.88 58.31 77.?5 40.89 61.33
81.78 42.89 '64.34
85:78
44.90 67:35
, 89.81
46.91 70.36
93.81 54.03 75.91 ')'7:79
52:38 73.43 94.49 50.73 70.96
91.19
c fl.~O
0.20 0.20
.'0:20 .0.20
. ' 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 '0:2~ 0.20
,0.20
0.20 0.20 '0:20
0.20
0.20 , 0.20
0.21 0.21 0.21
0.21 0.21
' 0.21 0.21 0.21
0.21 0.,21 0.21 0.21
0.21
~.,21
0.21
0.21 0.21
O.Zl
O:?O 0.20 0.20 , . '
0.20
0.20 0.20
9·~0 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
"0.2.0 , 0.20
.0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0:2Q
0.20 o.io 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0:20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.2'0
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0:20 0.20 0.20 0.20
' 0~20
0.20 0:20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0:20
0.20 0.20.
0.20 0.20. 0.20 0.20
10,00 10:00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 1ij.oo 10.00 10,00 10,(>0 10.00 10,00 10,00 10m 10.00 JO.oo 10.00 10.00 10.00 • , • .00 10.00 10.00 10,00
10.00 10.00 10,00
10.00 10.00 10.00 10,00 10.00 10.00 10.00
3,650.00
~~6~0.(JO
3,650_00
3:~50:00 3,650.00
3~6sci.oo 3,650:00 !i:·650.00
~,.650.0.o
3,12~.57
3,128.57
3,128;57
3,,~28.,~7 3,128.57
3,~~8;~7 3,128.57
3,,~~~~57 ~,128.57
3,128;57
3',~2~~5! 3,128.57
3,12~ .. ~7 3,128:57 3,128.57
·3,1~8.57
3,128.57 3;12~t57 3;128.57
3,1~~.57
3;128.57.
3:128.5'7 3.128;57
2,729
2,729
2,7~
2,7~
~,729
),7,19 2,7~ '
2,729
,2,?29 ,2,729
2:72~ 2,729
2,729
2,729 2,729
2,72~ ~i.i~9-~ 2;72:9 2,729 2,729
.2,729 2,729
2,729 2,7i9 2,729
2,729
.2,729 '2,729
'2,729
'2,729
~,729
2,729 2,729
2,729 2,729 2,729 2,729 2,729
2,729 2,729
2,7<29 2,729 2,729 2,729 2,729
2,729 2;729
2,729 2,729
2,729 2,729 2,729 2,729
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.78
0.78
0.78
0.78
0.78
0.78
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
6:85
0.85
0.85
0.85
'0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.38
0.38
0.38
0.38
0.38
0.38
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0:43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
,-,-0.43
0.43
OP~ DariingtonRefurbishmentprogram . TurbJne Generator Project
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 415 of 573
' Z37i"EPSI!A , .! . . 238:EPSCA · 239!EPSCA
240! .E~.SCA, ", '~41iEes~ 242!EPSCA ·
" ~~!;~~ 24SIEPSCA ,
24S!EPSCA · 24'iI'PSCA
2481EPscA "
."Z49.EPSCA · ' 2soiEPSCA .
~!~!:.~~ ' z53!EPSo. 2S4!E_PScA 25S!EP.SCA 2.56rE~CA 2S7!EPScA
I '.. 2SBiEPSCA
iS9iEPSCP. p~OiEPSCA
: 261!EPSCA' ·' 26Z iEPSCA
~:!I:~~ 26SiE~CA
• 266i EPSCA
'2671iPsp , Z6BIEPSCA '
2691EPS~ 270iE~~~ 271~EPSCA '
. 272iEPSCA\
273 iEPS~ . . 274jEP.SCA'
' ml~ 2791EPsCA . 2801i;PSCA 2811E'psCi
-'282IE~.S.~ 283iEPS~ 284iEPSCA
1~;~' "Z88 jEPSc:A
" 289iEPSCA > ~~d!~p~SA 291iEPSCA
292!EPSC"A
~:!I;~~ · : 29'S[EPStA ' 296 ~EPSCA ~71~p~CA
• 298[EPS-CA '
: i9~i~t8 ,.300[EftSCA
Local·iS3 local 183 LocalIa3 local183 loci'll.183
t.oca(183 La'callBl
~~:R:! ' ~ciil'183 -Lo~rlB3 Local 183
Local 183 Lcicil183 tJca" 183
lOcal iS3 - l.o~.ll'is3
Loeal183 ' Lociil'183 L~ca1183 Locai183 tOcal183 ~cal '183 ~~ 1 .1a3 Lo"Car183 t.odl ·183
I.cca11~3
Loca118~
Lo.~1183
~caliB3 lo~11~3 , local 183 lo~IHi3 L.Jca~183 Ltii.iL'183 Local"183
Local 183 Lo~r 183 Local 183 locali83
tPcal183
LO~1183 Local.183 locaf183 Local 183
LOC:3:I '183 U;caI183 :
Local 183
~car183 Local 183 LOc;II:183 1:6"611'183 LdQI'i83
lo~1183 . Local 183 ~~li83-' ~cal:183: LO'caI.'(83
·· l.O""clr183 "
tabOrers [~b:orers .
tabo;.crs labore'rs'
Lab'orers '
Lal5i:irers lail'orers !;atXirers Ea't)~'rers laborers laborers .
~~rers , Laborers Labo'rers .
L:a.~~~rs , Labo'rers
Latx:lrers Laborers laborets labor(!n La);orers
. 4boters
Laborer:s:.
~:6:%~ Lab~rers Lab~rers Latk.rers Latx:;rers··
~~1:~ ' laborers Lab""ore rs
laborer~
(a bore;:!: laborers' :.
laborers . Laborers
labOrers (~bc:;rers' l£borers
taborers tabOrerS
Lilborers
~borers. laborers Lab~r~rs
~.:-~:.~:~ .' ~!i~fe'~~"
.. ~~~, La~r~rs ." LabOrers .
[ab~rc~ L.~borers L'atl~rers laborers
L~ borers laDorers
., Jb6~e~" ~borers
laborers L3ti~~~
'445615
, 445615
I" :~:~; G . il ! -' 425065.
!~!e~J;n:~~~~' I! ' !._ .425065::~ i ::~:~:~: ~~:~::: :~~~:~
" i FOr~m3ri - 'G~o~p 'l1 425.065
i Ch-May-14 ! 01-May;14 i '
25{9 '11 Fpn;ma:? -. Group 11 42506.5
·2t.9 Foreman -.Group 11 42506$ 24~8 !SU~fCi ~e.inan':. G~UP I 42~OSS\- 1.,01-MaY-13~ . 24-8' !SUbfoleman. - Groupl 425055 ' JP1-.fV1~y-li T 01; May-13
!~ · I~;~;~;~:;·~·:::·: i :~:~. 'f~~~:~~~~ l · ~~~::~:~! · 24-8 !5ubforemiln~ Group I . '.,.".,'! . 42505~ . o+;May~~3 1 01-fv1aY-1.4 i4~ ]5ubforcman . Grbupl 425055 : 6t;~~~:~.! i 'O~.-MaY~14
~::: . r!~~~tt·~:·~ ~ ~~~~~: ~!~~!:.~' . OfM~Y:14 .i .~ubfor.~~\~r! -"Group I .;1 ' ~125P5~
eman - Group 11 4250;;'5 ! 425055
. ; Group I( i" 42S.oS5 ,SUbforeman'· Group II 425~5
~~ . l:~~~~~:i ~!~:~~:: :~~:~' ~5;8 . 15ublore(TIan •. Group·11 425055
25-~ 15ub(ore.man - Group il 425.955 25-~ 15ubforeman -'Group II 425055 · 27-8 iS~bfo~~rna~ --Group IV 425055' 27-8 js;.ibfcir:eman - Group IV; 425055 ' 27"8 ' >.< ~ GrouP-IV 425055
27-if - Group IV ~ .4.zSoSS 27~ - Group IV ! 42.5055
27-8 - Group lV I 42505:5
27-8 l Silbfor~ma~~ -:Gr~up IV 1 . 425'055 27-8 ISubforeman· Group IV ! 425055
27-8 15u.b~r;,:"an-G.rouPlv .; ' 28~8 lS~bforem,al') ~ Gro~p V l 28-8 i5ubforema~. Group V ! 28-8 15ubforem~n - Group V
425055 · 42505.5 425055 425055
l<0~~M~y-14 01-M~y-12 ! 01-May-13
·01-MaY·12 f ()1-MaY-13
.· ~{~t:~~!~ ! :~~::~!! 0';-May-f3 .j O,l:May-14
.9i..'May·i3. j 01-MaY~14 '01~Mav-14
.Oii 'MilIy-14 L01-tJ!ay-14
01-!tv1ay-12 i 01 May 13
~!:~:~~~~ i .. ,! ·0~·~1:'~~M:.,~y:.'~,·34· . 01~M~Y~13
l?}iM.,iY-13 ' !, .. :!~::{: ~l{AA:~~!! ' ~p'~a.~~l~
~~~~:~:i: i OH;1ay:1~ . 01=M~V~~2" i ,01-May;'13
:·'~t~~~~~~ i ~l~~ai:13:
'~::~::i I ~::~~:: .:Ol-May-i4 i. _ r
28-8 28-8 28-8"
28-8 28';8
28:'8
29~' !5ubfo'r'cman ~ ::: ~ . ~t~:~~!: j , 1 5~bf~remar ~ Gro~p VI 4i51?5? . . 0j.~.aY:l} j 01-May-13
i :::;~;:~:;(~;:::~: . :i1m · 6::~~~;:i ' l ~::~:~;:f I~U,~f6r!~a~. <~·rO UPVI ' . 4i505~ ~ ' Ol-May-13 , i 01-M.ay-~4 I SUbfo~'eman }Gfou~ VI -425;055 .61~ rY1·aY-13 · j 01-.Ma.y-14 '
l#';:1:::~ ~_~~~~~: '. :~~~~~ ::~!~~:~~!! ' ! 01-May·14
29-8 !~~fo,eman .'GrO~~· \Ij I " 4~05S ' '·,Oi.:M-"iy:14
29-8 i5ubfOreman - Group 'It ; 425~~ Oi-May:14 l 30-lf - 1 5Ubfareman '~tGioup VII 1 42~~5 ~ Oi~MaV:12 1 01-May:13
~~~: i ~~'~'~:'~~:~ ~ ~~~~:~:: I ~~505~ .. 0~~~.aY-1~ , 1 ~~~~~~~~ 30·S 15~~f~t .. ~ma.n' - Gropp VJI ~ I ;~~~~~ . }~~~<~;~;~~: . 91-~aY-14 30:8 I r5ubro'feman : 'Group Vll ! .. 425055 01 May 13 i 01 May 14
' 30-8 ' t~ubf~lIelT1an - Group Vll · ! . '~2S955 : di:M'aY~13! 01~MaY~.14 .
~~~~l ~ ;i~ ! ;¥~ 30-8
. ~~8
. iSUbforernan . Group Vll1 i 4is05~ . 0)~May-12 j 01-~ay-1"3 · i5u6~-~0aia.h~up'v111· .,: 4.2505'5 : '; 01",M~y-l'3 101-May·14
'S bl G VIII 4,'5"0"55' : 01 M . 1. I , ~ : }~.Iem~f\ ~ 'I ro~p , .! 425055 ' - ay- .
lil~~~~~ ~. '.lG~:'~O' ~"',;~p. ~.,xxillii i'·'" . 425055
- Group IX r 4~OS(5 .~Ci;i;lip·IX ] r 425055
l.it~~~e~ - ~r~o;~p' I :' !Uiborer-Groupl . . -Gr.olJl?l
-Groupl
I~~~e( ~t:~~: i liibcii''e'~ ; Group ~
· I~!:;:~:~~:: :,
42503!1 425035 425035
~2~O~S, . > 425035 '425035
425035
, I < :i~b:~ ; " 09-25035
·01.,...,Lay_14 ! ' 01~M~V-14 I ' "Oi-M'~Y-12 ! 0~':: May-13
1 22.75 1.5 :' 34.13
.' Z· 45.50'
20:20 1.5 30.30 Z 40.~0
l ' 18'J~ 1.5 Zit13
. 37.50'-. 1 ZZ{94
I:: 10" '''''
I'''· ,''''' 1 10%'
11"",': ! I,"" I,,,,, I,,;,.
2.28
,, 4.55
2.oi· 3,03~
4.04
1~88
~:5 3,Ul
I ,'",~ .-17,40 I
1.5
2. 1
1.5
45:88'
41.10 10%
54.80 ' ' I" ~:
1
. .1.~ 2 "
'.1 (5 _ _ 51.38
68.50 35,16
1.5 52.74 70,32
31;20 1:5 46.80 .2 . 62.40
~ 1 · 32:06'
1.5 48 .. 09 64.12 32.97
1.5 49.46 '
2 65.9;4
32.14 1.5 48:21
64.28 1 33:00
! lO')!, I;", j,"" ,
I", 1: I ..
I" , !'4%
J4" J4" ·1", j4'" .,..
", .
4'"
1 4% I ..
I" 14,,' !4"
3,19
4:78: 6:3,1-:
1:34
2:00 i~6i 1:37
2.06 2.74 1.41:" 2,11
2,8~
·. l,is 1~87 2:50 Li8 1.92
(5· 49.50
4"" '. 2.56'
:4% ' 1;32
1".98 2.64 1,29 1,93
257 1.32
1.98 ' 2.64
I:: 6KOO' 1 .. ,,',
l ' 33.91 ~ I"" 1.36 ' 1.5" 50.87 4" 2.03 2- 67.82 I· 4% 2.71"
l ' 32:39 14"" ' 1.30 1.5 48.59 I "" 1:94
64.78 I 4% 2:59 ' 33.'25' . I 4% 1,33
1$ 49.88 F~" 2.~ .
66.SO i 4'" 2.66' . : 4" 1.37 '
1:5 ' . 51.24' '1"". 2:05 .
:~:~! I.::·· ' ~~;~ 1.5 ~f8.80
65.06
33.39 1.5 ': 50:09
66.78"
34.30 1".5 51.45 2 ' 68~60
. 1 32.58
1.5" 48:87 '
2 ' 65.16 ,
1 . 33.45 1:5 50'.18
66}jO 34.35'"
1.5 ~1.S3
1.5
'1.5 ' 2
68.70 33.08 4~.62
66.1~
33.95 50.93 67.~·0 34:85 5i:28 69:7Q '
33.31 '
4f97 6?62 34.17
1,5 51.26
68.34
~ 3~,08 1.~ 52,6~
7(1:16
. 1 33.81 ' 1 .5 50.72
2 67_62 1 . 34~67 ,'
1.5 ·' 5~:01
' 1 1:5
~ 1
1.5
1,5 ' ' 2
69.34: , 35.58 53.37 71:16,1-
29:45
5idw 30.31 45.47
69.62 . 3,1.22 46.83
6~:44
30.39
'I ,'.'" 1.95 2:60
I,", i34 I",' 2' 00
II. : 2.G? , ~ '" 1.37
1 4'" ·2.06' 1 4" 2:74 ,j 4~' 1~30 1'4')$'. 1.95
1 4" . · Z .~1 i 4~> !4" !:.: t''''' i 4
'" i4" 1' 4"
14" I ,. I" I':" I"" ~ 4"':'
I ~~: 14" I ..
: !4"
t~, ! 4':" 1 4%
! 4" 1."" I'"
14" 14" . !",
1 4!,! , ,"
I· .. · i 4%
j .. %
1 4" .
, 4"" I'"~
14~ ' 1
4" .
14"
2.00 3,01
4.01 2.06
3.08 4.11
2.11 3.16 4.22
&X! . 1.JP i . 2:81
~! , 3.74 "
6"i 1.~~
6~ 1. :~'1
~ I .~j .
~I 6,,1 '6,,1 6% 1
6% i ;
2.89 3.85
3.96
1.93 i:89 3.86 1.98 2.97 3.9.6 .
2.03
3.05 6%'i .4.07
6% i 1.94 6% i 2.92
6% ~ 3.89 ' 6% i 2.00 6%; 2:99
! 6% i 3.9.9
6'i l ' 2~05 6%! 3.07 6% 1 4:10
! , i:9'S' 6,6"' 1". 2.~3 6" i 3.90" '
,e% '[ 2.00
6%! 3.01 6%; . 4:0~· 6%': 2.06 6% : .6% ! "" ,
\ 6"i '
6": 6";
6~! 6%1
'> 6~ ! 6%~
6": 6%[ 6%;
6": 6% ! 6%1
! . . , 6% ~
:.:! 6%;
6%. ! 6% 1
- 6%1
. ~" i 6":
'6%i 6%;
6%1
~' f
: 1 6~.1 G"i
3.09
4.12 1.95
2.9.3 3,9'1
2.00' 3:01
4:01 2.06 fOg 4.12 1.98
2:98 3.97
2:"~"3 . 3.06~
4~07 2.09
3.14
4.1,8 '
2.~ 3.00
4.00
2.05 3.08 £10 2.10 3.16 4:2i 2.03 3.04 4':06'
2:08 3.'12
4.16 2,13
3.20 4:27
1.76
2;65 3.:53 1.8i 2:73 3:64
1.87 2,81 3,75
1.82
2,88-' 2.88
2.88 2.88\
.2:88 2:88 2.88 2~8' 2.88 2.88 ~88
. 2.88. 2.~. 2.40
2:40 2.40 2:40'
2.40 2:40 '
~40' 2:40
2.40
i.4O 2.40 2.40 2;40 2:4Q . 2AO'
2.40
2:40 i:4O 2.40
2:40
5,58;'
. 5.58 5.58" 5,58'
5,58
5.58 5.58 5 .. 58 .5',58
5.58 5.58 5.58 5.58
5:58 5.58 5.58 .-
5.58' 5:58 t:"
5..58
5:.58 . 538 558 5.58 5.58 ' 5.58 ' 5.58
5.58 5.58 558 5-:58 55S
558 5.58 '
5.5~
5.58 5.58 5.58 5~58 5.58 , 5'58
> ;?58
558 5:58
55~
5.58
5.58
5.5~
5.58 5.58 5.58 558
5.58 558
55~ . 5'.58
5.58 5:58 5.58'<
5.58 5,58
558 558
5~8 5:58 5.5'8
5.58
5.58 5.58 5.58
5 .. 58 5,58 55-8
558
S.5~
5.58 5.58
5.58, 5,58
5.58 5.58 5,58
O:~9 0,39
0,:39 0.39 0.39 0.39
0.39' &l9 0,39
0:3.9
25.03 37:54 . '50.05
28.30 38.61 48:92 32,90
45.52 58.14 37.81 52,88
67.95
42.71 60.22
77.74 45,2]
0.20 ,0:20
0:20 " 0.20
0:20 . 0:20
Q.20 ' 0":20
0.20. 0,20
0:20
0.20 0~20 0,20 .
0.50 63:57 ,0.20
0:50 . I 81.94 o:io 0,55 1 46.21 0.20 0.55:- - - 65,04- - - - .....,.-' ~;""~O
0.55 · I 83.88 0.20 0.55 . ~7..21 : . 0."20 ' 0.55 66.54 0,20
0:55 " I' 8~.88 0.20
O,SO I 4'2~8D O.~O· 0.50 · I 59,96 . . 6:i0 0.50 1 ~ i7:i2 0.20 0.55 , I 43.80 0.)0 .
. !;l.55 I 61.43 . . 0.20
0:55 . I 79.06 ~t20 O.5S .1 44.80
0,55 I. 62.93 0.55 81.06 0.50 I 43,83
0.50 I 61:51
0.50 II 79.19 0.55 44.83
~:;~ i :~:~: 0:55
0.55
45,83 . 64.48
0;55 ' 83:13
0.50 44.1i O:~ 61.'92 0.50 79.74: 0.55 45.i1"
' 0:55 6339
0,55 81.6~
0.55 46.11 O:SS 64.89 0,55 83.68 O.?O '. 44.26 0.50 62:15'
0.50
0.55
0:55 0.55' 0.55' 0.55 0.S5
O, 5!? 0,50
O.~O: 0.55 o:sf 0.55
O.~5 0.55
O,~S . 0,50 0:50 '
0:50
0.55 0:55' 0~S5'- ' 0.55 .
0:55 .
0'.$0 ,0,50
0:.5~ · 0.55 0:55',
0.55
0:55 0.55 0.55
o.~ 0.50 O.SO"
0:55 '0.55
0.55
Q~55
0.55 0:55
0:50 0.50 0:50 ' 0.55
o.sS 0:55"
0.~5
0.55 0.55
0.50
80.05 45:26 63~62 81:99 ·46.26
65.13 83.99 44.32 62):4 '80.16 4"5:32
63:72
82.ri . 46:32 . '65.21
84:10
44.87 63,06 8i.26
4??7 64.55 83,22
46.87
66:03 85,20
45.12
63~44 8p6 4p2 64.91 83.'70.
47.12 ' 66.41 85,71 45:67;-
64:27
8i:S6 46.~7
65.74 84,80'
47;67 67:2~
86,81
40.87
57.07 73.27 41.87
58.54
75'.21 42:87
60.04 77.21 41.91
0.20 0,2()- .
.6.20 0,20
0.20
0.20' ' 0.20
0.20 · 0.20 0.20
0.20 0;20
0:20 '
0.29 0.20-
0.20 O,ZO ' '0.20 0:20<
0.20 " 0.20. 0'.:20
0 :20
0.20'
0.20 o.io 0.20, 0,20
0:20 '0.20
~:'~J . 0.21?
0.20 0.20 o.io· ·o:io 0~2g 0.20
0;.20.,. 0:20 ' .
' 0 .20 '
{~~ 0;21> 0:20 0 .. 20' 0,20 ·
0.20 .0,20 ,
0;20'
0:20 0.10:' (i":~0 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20. 0.20 0,20 0,20 0,20
.... 2,729 '
2.72~ .
~72:9 '
0:85
0.85
0.86
0,86
0.89
0.85
0.86
OPGo.rl~~Re~tPrOP.'l' Tur.bineGt~f·iOl"p,~~t . ,
0.43 .
0,46
0.43
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 416 of 573
~ !~:I:~~ · 31611~EP .. _~cA 317,EPSCA
~ ~~: !~~~ 320!EPSCA 321iEPSCA
\ 32ZiEPS'CA -.. 323iEPSCA
3_~~lEPSCA
!~!I~:: 327i.EPSCA 328[EPSCA
~2!!iEPSCA 330iEPSCA
331!EpSCA
33zlEpSCA
::i=: 33~ !EPSCA 336!EPSCA 3371.EP~CA 338i~p~CA
~,!~!,:~'~
391IEP~S~ 392iEPSCA 393iEPStA
3.941EPSCA ·395IEPSCA
· 396i-E-PsCA
i:;I;;~ 409iEP:;~A ~oliEP:SCA ~2]E'PS_~ 4Q3~~P.Sq\ . 404iEPSCA 40S!E!>ScA 406!EPSCA 4071 EPSCA
40'~1 E,PSCA 409!EPSCA
410lEPStA 41l 1E~ 412iEPSCA
413!EPSCA
414i
l:,EPSCA
415jEPSCA
:~~l~::
r:::i:::
· ' 420!EPSCA
i 421jEPSCA ~ .422jEPSCA
' LOtarIa3 local 183 Leca 'IIB3
Lecal Ia3 LoalIa3 Local 'IS3
LoalIa3 local'183 local183 loca!'lB3 local 183 Local 183 Loal 'I S3
local 183 lo<al183 Local 183
Local 183 loca l 183 local 183 locallB3
LoalIa3 LoallS3
Lecarl83 Loca1183
LecalIa3 Local 183 loc'al ·lB3
loallS3 Local 183
Local.IS3
local 183 , ~caU83 Locai'183 Lotali83 locat183 local 183 l6cal '183 Local:183
, Local '183 · LdcaI.183.: Lc5eaf.is3 Lo&1',183 LOcal 'i~i3
. lOcal 183 lOCii,l183 Local·183 loca l 183 L.O:i:a1·183
Lo~a! 183 Loca1183 loca'i:183 local 183 locai.;83 Local"183 ~cai183 . Local 183 Local 183 locai183 locilll83 Locall~3
Lo'cal183 (o"cai"183 Local 793 Loca1793 local 793 tOcal793 local 793 local-793
~:~~:t lOCaI?,93 Local 793
., Lo·cal .793
local 793'
· locaP93 local 793 local 793
"' local'793 Locai '793 Local 793 l ocal 793 Locii 793 local 793 local.793
. "t.ocal 793
Locai793 Local 793 Loci.j}93 local 793 loeal793
· Local.793 Loca17!:!3 loCal 793 Loca1793 Local 793 Local 793 local '193
loCal 793 Local 793 Local 793 Loca1.7~3
Local 793 Local 793 local 793 local 793 local 793 Local 793 local 793 Local'793
" Laborers ~abo~ers laborers
. Labo;t.rs , Laborers
laborers laborers laborers Labo'rers (~:bor~rs Laborers Laborers laborers
la.bo!ers Laborers Laborers Laborers Laborers Laborers laborers laborers Laborers Laborers La~6rers Laborers Laborers laborers
la~o!,&rs la'borers
Labb~ers Laborers
' Lab'orers
Labo.rers Lal::i'6rers Laborers '
L<ibore~ i.~borers ·
, labOrers
~bo'rers tab'ore'rs
l~ko~rs ' ." labtirers
Labciren !.abo'rers
Laborers Laborers L:a~rers Lab,9rers L.aborers Laborers
. ~bor~rs .' C;bor~rs
labcirers ~borers Labor~rs LaboreTS laborers Lai)~rers' L"abor.ers Laborers Uborers LaborC!Ts OperatlngEnglneers
~~~ra~:~: ~~::~::: o~ehll.tlpg E~neef"s OPer~tl~Jn&tn.eefs Operating.Engh;ieers
Oper~tlng ,Engjnee~s
Operaiing'.E,ngineers Operatln.Engineers bp~;'atj~g:E~gjneers
"' OP.,e:l;ailng ,E~n~~ Operating Engineers OPeral!", E~neers 9pe;'~t!rig ,EnglneerS Operating EngIneers
\. o~er.~tj~g".Engineers Operatlng~nglneers
Operating Engineers Operating Engineers Operating Engineers Operating 'Englneers Operaifng:En.glneers OperatIng' Engineers
O~~ra~lng Engineers qperatlng .En,glneers Operatlng'Englneers ORtratlr{gEng.lneers OperatlilgEngineers OperatirigEngtneers Operatill8 .Englneers OperatIng Engineers 9peratlng 'Engineers Operat,l,ngEnglneers Operating Engineers Operating Engineers Operating E'nglneers
, Operatill8 Engineers Operating Engineers Operatlng-Engineers Q'perstlngEnglneers Operating Engineers Operating Engineers OperatingE"ngIneers Operatin(Engineers O~rat!ng Engineers Op:erat(ngEnglneers Operating Engineers
2S~6
25,-6 25-6 25-6
2!!;6 25,6 25,6 25-6 27-6 i7~6 P-6 2~-6
floG "27-6
27~
27-6 27:6 28-6
' 28~ 2~.5 28·6 28-6 28~
28-6
28·6 28':6
29-6
29-6
29·6 2~~ 29-6 29~6 29-6 29~6
'29;£
~O~ 30-6 ~6 3(}:6
30·6 30·6 30!6 30-6
30-6 31·6 3£ .. 6 3i~6
31-6 31~6
31'.:£ 31-6 31-6 31:.6 32-6 32·6 32-6 32-6
32-6 32-6 .32-6' 32-6 32) 6 'Sr:9
51~9 51-9
.' $2-9·
'52~9
.. 52-9 5'3-9 53:9 53-9 54:9 54-, 54:9
:55·9 55-9 55-9
56-9 56-9 S6-9 57~9
57-9 57-9
. 5S.9
~a-9
58-9 59~9
'59-9 59·9 '
.60-. ."60-9 60'·9
61-9 61-9 61-9 62-9 62-9 62-9
63·9 63~9
63-9 64~9 64-9 64-9 51-8 51~8
51-8 ~2-8
52~8
llaborer- Group II 425035
i ,laborer-~r6uPll 425035 ILaborer - Group'!1 425035 i4borer - qro.up·t'l i.4.~0~5 !laborer-G"rol,lpU 4i5035
! .~borer-· ~~up II ~?:SO~~
01~May~12 f 01-MaY-13 '01 'M~v" 12 i ol~May-i3 ,Oi:May::i.3 i 01-~ay-14 ' 01~'~~~l13 ! 01-May-14
"Ol-May-13 ,·'?J>M.ay;.i4
. ;~~;:;;~: 1 1~~~:: .~~~:; :~.~~~~ '" 0~-,~ay-14 !
•. Ql·~,~y~F I. 1?1~Ma'f7~3 01-MaY~12 i '01~May-13 01·May-1.2 i 01-May-.13
'oi-Ma~-h ! 01 May 14
i.!i,borer- ~~ou~. I.V 425035 iLaborer-GrOuP.IV 425035
ita!??rer -'Grou~ IV :~;b;~
J~~~~~: :,:~~:~ 425035
! ~b~~::~:~:' :; ~~:~ 1 ~:~~~::'~:~:'lJ :~~~~~
6::AA:~:Y! I~:;~::;:: ;;~~.:.~!;~;: !
i~lx?rer-.G.ro'lipv 425035 lLabOrer - Grou"pN ;4:25~?,:S lCtbOrer-.Groupv 425035
'!laborer - Group V 425035 ! labOrer '-' Grou~v 42~035 !laborer ~ Group.~ , 425035
01-May-14 01~Mily-12
1.lc!borer: 'Gro.~~.v .. 42~ri35 I Laborer,- Group V 4250.3? 01-May~14 I Laborer- Group.V 42~035 ' QI-May~i4 i lalx)T~r'- Group' VI 425035 0.1-M~y-~2 ! ':abg~.er - Group,. VI 425035 01'..MaY;i2 ! labOre"~:'~.rouP'v.1 4~035 0~·May-12
f~::~:~.;~~~:~;~ ~ :~~~~~ ~~.::;~~~~ i Laborer - GrouR VI. . '425035 01~May-13 ila.borer- Group,YI 425035 01:¥aY~14 'I' tabor~r- Group'VI 4250}5 01-May-14
16~~~.t;~.~: ! 01-May-13
I ~~:~:~~~: ! 01-May-14
ILaborer.- ,G~~p Vj 425~~5 01,~aY714 'l'~bo!ei-.~ro.uPVII 425035 ·Or.~·",ay~i2 1 01-May-13 .
i riborer-..Gr~~pVII 425035 01:May-12 !,.,; °011:.MM· ',VV'-"'" jLaborer - Group.vll 42~~~~ Ql~M,!y~i2 llabo'rer - Gro-U'p~VII 425035 ··Ql."MaY,-i3 t 01 May 14
I.~~orer. Grou~ VII 42503,5 00'lr '~.~MM" , . aa~·yv.~1,· 33 I 01:MaY:14
i,labbrer- GroupVll 425035 01'.M'V.l' I.: 01-May-14 I.Laborer-.GroupVlI 42503S
l ~~~r~~.-;Gropl":l1 :~~~~ . Oi-~aY~14 l ~bOrer-:~rouPvlI ' 0011;.MM;' a~'Yv'·"i'2 ' iLaborer-GroupVIII 42~~5 ! 01-~ay·13 llaborer-·Grot-p'vlil 425035 '01~May-i2 f 01::May-i3 l la~rer ~ Group VIII 425035 01~M~Y-12 i 'Ol-May-13 !Gborer--GrOuPVIll 425035 , Ol-May-13: 01-May-14 . i laborer-c,;ro\.lp ~ lll 425035 Ol-May-13 i 01-May-14 ila·bo'rer.-Groupviil 425035 01' May-13 !,1 01-MaY-14 j Laboi~·- GroupVlI1 425035 Oi~May-14 !t.abore..-Group,\{lil ~2503~ Ol:May-14 ! 'i Laborer- Group VIII 425035 01:May-14
:ll laborer- Group IX 4~50~5 61.M·iv~12 f 01-M~y-13 ,labo~er- Group. IX 4250~5 01-May-12 i 01-May;13 ilaborer - Group IX' 425035 ,· 01;t-i~y-12 I 01-May-13 !laborer- Gro.up, IX 425035 01-~.aY-13! 01-May-14 lLaborer- Group IX 425035 01~May~13! 01-May-14 itaborer- Group.lX 42503:; 01-M'aY~13 1 01-May-14 i laborer-Group'l>~ 425035 01.M~y-14 ! l latK5;'er"~ droup'IX 425035 ,~1;1~~~14 !laborer ~:Gro~p IX . 425035 ' 01-May-14 i'F6reman,Group; (Al, ,420065 01-M~y-12 JFore~an ~roup ~~,{A),' 420065 : ON~1~y~12
I For~a.n ~roup 1 fA) 42066s' 01-May-12 IForeman Group 1 (8) 42~65 01-May-12 !Foreman'Gr~up 1'(8) ' 420065 01-May-12
!ForemanGr.,?uP·i ' ta) ,', "420065 Ol~aY-~2 '. iF(lTI~man ~ri:iup).(A.l 437265 · Ot:M~y-12 'If~ r.' ... m. '.n,Gro.u.p;.i ·.IA .. .J I 43~265 : d'l~MiY-l-2 i · Foreman Group.2 (Al ,I ' 437265 ···Ol:MaY·12 i
! Foh:~m3n;Group"l(Bl 420065 :~ .. noi·_rJtiY2n 1 F.0f~~a~ ,?r~'~p 2)Sl . ! '420065 :'pl;May-12 jForeman'Grpup 2 (al .! 4i0065 ' . 01~May-12 !Fore';;-ii'n.Group- i .11, . '420065 :Oi::M.1y-12 [Foreman Group 3 '420065 01~'MaY;12 if.oreman· G~ouP3 I 420065 01-May-12
, I Fo~e~anGroup"4 '1 - 420055 "01-MaY-12 lForeman Gro~p '4 ,420065 ' 01-May-.12 jforeman,Group 4 : 420065 01-May-12 lFor'e'nian Group 5 \1 420065 01~May:12 ! Forema~'Group 5 420065 01-May-12 [Foreman GroupS I 420065 01-May-12 !Foreman Group 6 i 4200;65 01:May::12
lforel'9an Group 6 "Ii 420065 01-May·12 iForeman Group'6 420065 0'1-May-12
!,~~~:~:~ ~~:~Pp ~ :~~~~ . 01~M<!y-i2 I I ' OVM~y-12 l:oreman Gr,oup 7 I .:~:~ ~~~~:~~~~ i :~::~~::~~:~:~ .~~ 420065 01.May·12 l Forem~n M!sCGr.oup l '(A 420065 ' . 01·Mily-12
iForeman Mi~c'Grp'up 1 . (~ 420065 :ih-May-12 !ForemanMlscGroup'l,'{~ 420065 ' . 01i May-12 IForeman Mise G,~up 1,(B, 420065 01tMay-12 I~.oreman ~ic Group 2 - ~ , 4~0065 01-May~12 jForema,n ¥lc'Group 2 - t{ 420065 _O~_MaY_l.i '1' ~rem;j'nMlc~rou'p2-Hi 420065 Ol·May·1"2
I Foreman M~:GrOup' 3 - 9' 420065 01.MaV-12 " .1 I Foreman Mlc Group 3 - Cl 420665 0kMay-12
I Foreman M. ,IC 'Grt?U. P'3'- q 420065 01-May-12 jForeman Mlc Group 4 - 0; '420065 01-May-12 iForeman Mic Group 4 - q '420065 'Ot-May-12 lForeman Mic Group 4 - 9 "420065 01~May-12 15ubforeman Group' 1 (AI i 4200s5 01-May-12 !5ubforeman Group 1 (A)! :4zOOs5 01·M'!y-12
15ubfore-nian G~o~.~' i (Al I 42065,5 01-May-12
I~~~~:~:~:~'~~;~~ i ~:: 1 ': :~:~ . ~~:~:;~~~
1.5
1.5 2'
1.5
i~5
1.5
2
1.5 2
1.5
1.5
2
1.5
1.5
1.5
1.5
1
1.5
1.5 2
1.5 2
1.5
1.5
1.5
1
1:5
1.5 2
1 .. 5
1:5 ' 2
1.5
·1.5
1'.5
1.5
1.5
1.5 ' 2
_ 1.5
2
1:5
15
1.5 2 .,
1.5
1;5
2 ., 1.5
45.59 i 4%
60.7'8 1'4~ 3'1:25 ·1·4",,4.~
.~6.a8 ,. ~'2:50
I "" I", 14% :'4'" \.:: ] 4"
47.25 l 4". :}~ j 4%
48;~62 I!:: :ci:~~ I':: 46;17 ! 4')1;
61.56 1'4" 31,,"~.5 ! ;4~ 47.48 i 4~ 63.30' !, ~~ ~i:sS I "" 48.83 ! 4" 65:10 i 4" 30;84 i 4')1; ".' h~
:~~~:. ' ~,i,· .4~ ~ 3"l.7Q . It>
, ~7:55 1 4"
6~.:40 'i 4" 32.61 14" 4a~92 I'" 6s:i2 4" 31;'33 ! 4%
· ~7.00 ! 4%
62.66 ! 4%
3t.:l9 1 4" 48.29 14% 64:3a I 4" i~:~O " I 4" 49.65 I 4" 66:20 I 4" 31:55 ! ... " :~:~~ 1
4%'
32.4i I .. ::
4·8'.~3 1"% 64.84 I: 33;33 ....
'50:00 j ""
66.66 I ... "
!:~ I:: '64:10 i 4%
:~::! I:: 65:84 1 '4"
'33."83 1 4~ '50.75 ! 4%
67.65 f 4" 3'.79 I" 59."69 1 4" 7g:S8 '"1 4% 39,34 1' 4%
.59.01 1 4" 78:68. ! ... Wo
3~l!j9 ! "" p~a~ t."" "1,7.18 1'4"
i 4% i : '4')1;'
i4"
j"" ' 56~46 ! ~"" 75.28 ! ""
-37147 i 4"
.'56.'2i i 4% 74.94 i 4%
:35:14 ' 1'4" 52.~71 i 4%.
70:28 ! "" 3~;14 1-''''' si:21 I."" '6a:2a' 1'4%
32.95 I" ~49.43 i :4% .65'.90 ! ""
· '8.11 ·1'" '57.11 ! ""
76:22 ,1 .4~ 3i47 ,.
56:21 I" ;74.94 ~44~ . i 8.59 . '" 57.89 "! '4";
·n'!s . I''''' 31.~9 1,' .4~ ' 47:39 ,.. 63:1a . i l4"
'. 3's.i4 1':4%'
":52:71 '1'::: ~ ,.' '~5' °57~. :7:::"· . 4"
',1 ,'," 74~3~ 3~)"7.~· t";4"'"
· ~5~1.1 !"4"
1,~2 ' '" ! 2:43 . 6" 1
.. ·1 1.88
1.29 ,;. :: .• j ~:~~ ""j . 1.23 .. ~;~ :! 1.84 ~~6'" ! .-
6~ I 6,,·1 1.26
1.89 6% I i:52 6%.1 1:30 ;6"": i~~: . '·~':' li l.i3 . ' 6% 1',85 6"'1 ~:~~ 6% I 1.90 :1 2.53 '" !
:!: .: I 2.60 '" I 1:23 6% i 1:85 :'1 1.27 6" !
1.90 6" 'j '2.54 . ~ 1.30 ":~'I
2.61 1.15
1.88 2.51
1.'93 2.58 1.32 1.99 2.65 i.26
1.89
1.30 1.95 2:59 1.33
=1 "'cl :1 "I . .. I "" '6$ ! 6,,1 6"! 6"i
"I '" .. I .. I ",I
2.00 . ~ ; 2.67 6$ ! 1.28 1:92 2.56 1.32 1.98 2.63 1.35 2.03 2.71
=1 .. I , "'I "'I "'] 6,, 1 ", I .. I
1.59 ·· "'I 2.39 3.18 1:57 2.36 3.1s
:! 6"1 5$ i ",i 6" ! ~ "' I
~:~~ .: I 2.29 .6" ·! 3.05 ' 6" l
"'! ",I ", I
L51
2.26 3.01
2.25
'.00 1.41
"'i '"I 6%1 6,,1
~11 ~" ! i81 . ~I 1.37 2.05 2:73 1.32 1.98
~.52
2~
"'I ~: !
=1 "', 6!' \.
:·1 ' 2:i5' .' 6$ j 3.00 ~ '" I 1':54
P2 3.09
"'I :: I ."" ·, 1
i.53 . 6$1
~':~~ ,: I .. [ i~49 '. 6" ! 2.81
,~! i~ ' . ~; . 1:47 ' 6% t
2:23
2,20 ' 6% i
2.74 . 3:65
" 3.89 1,85
' 2.77
3:~9
1~~9 1;85 '3.80
."1:9'5
2.9.3 3.91 1.85 2:78 3.70 1.90 2.85 3 .. 80 1.96 2.913 3.91
'1,:~ 2.82 3.76 1.93 2.90 3~86 1'.99 ~2.98
3.97 ' 1:.89
2.84
3.79 1.95 2.92 3.89 2:00
. 3.00 4.00
1.92 2.88 3.85
;'1-:98
1::96 3.95
<2.03
3.04 4.06 2.39 3.58 4.77 236
'.54 4.72 2:32 3.47 4.63 2.29 3.43 '4:57 2:26 3:39 4.52 2.25 3.37 450 '2:11
' ~:1~
4.22 2.05 3.07 4.10 1.97 ,2.97 3.95 2.29 3.43 4.57 2.25 3.37 4:50 ·232 --£4,7'
' 4.63 1:90 2.84 3.79 2.11 3.16 4:22 2.23 3.35 4:46 2.20 3.31
2.40 '2.4'0 ,"
2.40 2:;.0 2.40
; 2]40 '·
'2':40
: 2.~0 2.40 2:40 2.40
) ;40 2.40 2.40 '
1'.40 . :i:4'O 2.40
2;40 · 2:40 2:40 2.~0 2.40 2.40 2:40 2.4,0"
2:40 2.40
) :40 ;2: :40 2:.\'O
'2:40
2.40 . 2.40 2.40 2.'40 i:~o 2.40 ·2[40 2.40 2.40 2.'40 2.40
2.40 2.40 2.40 ;Z:40 2.40 2.40 2:40 2.40 2.;40 2;40 4.56 6.84 9.12 4.56
6.84 9:12 4.56
6.84 .9:1"2 4;56 6.84 9.12 4:56 6:84
~h2 4:56 6,84 9;12 4.56 6.84 • . U 4.56 6.84
, 9:12 4.56 6.84 9.12 4:56'
6.84
9.12 4:56 ,6:84 9.~2
4.56 ~:a4
9.12 4.S6 6:84 '9!li
4;56 6.84 9:12 4.56 6:84
9,11 4,56 6.84
5.58
'": ~ i58 ~.58
5.58 5;58
-5'.58
5;58
5.58 '5;58 5.S8
·' 5.5'8 . 5:58
5.58 5.58 5.58 5.58
"5;58 '5.58
. '_5~58
5.58 5:58 5;58 '5 .. 58 558 5'.~8
5.58 5.5·S
5.58 5:58 5.58 :5.58 5.58 5.58 5.58 5.58 "
5.58 5.58 558 5'.58 5.5'8
5.58
5.58 . 5.58
's:SS 558
558 5.58
'S.S8
5.58 5.58 5.58 5.58 558 5.S8
5.58 558 5:58 5.58 5.58 5.58 5:.58 5.58 6.71 10.07 13.42 6.71 10.07 13.42 6:11 10.07 :1.3:42 6.71 10.07 13.42 6'.71
10.07 13:42 6.71 10.07 13.42 '6.71
10.07 lU2 6.71
10.07 13.42 6.71
'10.07 13.42 6.71
10.07 . 13.<12 6.71 10.07 13.42 6:71 10.07
·13:42 6.11 10.07 13.42 '6:71
10.,07 13.42 6:71
10.07 13 •. 42 6.71 10.07
0,50 ·'O.SO
0.55 0.55
':~:'~S 0:?5 ,
"'0.55
6.~5 '0.50
"0.50 " '0;50
d.~5: .0:5'5 0.55
· 0.55'
'c!.S5 0.55 . 0.'50 0';50
0.50 0.55 0.5~
'0.55
0.55 0.55 0:55 O:SiO
'0;50 0.50 0.55 0'.55
0.55 '. '0:55 .
O.S:!; 0~55 0.50 0:50 O.So 0.55 0.55 0:55 0.55 0;55
0.55 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.55 0.55 0.55 '
0:55 0.55 0.55 O.'sa 0.50 0.50 0.55 0.55 0.55 0.55 0.55 0.55 0.50 0:75 1.00 0.50 0.75 1.00 0.50 0;75 1.DO 0.50 0.75 1:00 0.50 0.'15 1.DO 0.50 0.75 fOo 0.50 0.75 1.DO 0.50 0.75 1.00
O.?O 0.75 1.'(X)
0.50 0.75 1.00 0:50 Q:75 1:00 0.50 0.75 LOO 0:50 0.75 1;00 '0:50 Oi75 1:'00
0.50 0.75
1·90 0.50 0.75
5,~.62
75:34 .42.91
. 60:09 ~77:i8
. 43:9i 6i;:S9 . 79.28
,. 4i~ i:8 , . 59.04 75.89 43:18 60:51 . ·irs? 44;18
62~oi ?9.83 ~2:34 59)7 76.20 . ',43:34' 60.75 78~i6 4'4;34'
,62:24 80.14 41;40 5"9.37
76:~3-
43:40 60:84 78~27 44:40 62,.34 80.27 42~~
6O.d 77:'U 43.94 · '61:64 79.35 44.94 63.15 81:35 '.
43:19 60.54 77.89 ·44.19 62:02 79:85 45.19 63.52 81.86 43:74 61:36 78.99 "44.74 62.85 .
'. 80.95 .
45.74 64.35 8i96 55;54 83:31 111.08 55.04
' 82.57 '
110.09 54.22 81.33 108.44 5'3.69
80.54 107.38 :S3.17 79:76
10635 52.99 7.9.48 105:97 50:42 75:64 100.85 -4.9;32 73~99
98.65 48.01 72.02 96.03 53.69 80.54 107.38 52.99 79;48 105;97 54.22 il~'33 108.44 46.52
. 6.~.78
93.04 50."42
75.64 100.85 52,68
79.02 105.36 52,18 ia'j8
0.20
O;.~O '0.20 . 0.20 0.20 '0.20
0:20 '0.20 O:~O
. ~qo 0.20 .
, 0.20
0.20 0:2"0 b.20 0:20 0:20 0.20 0.20
:0.20 0.20
' 0:20
0.20 . 0:20
0:20 0.20 0:20
0.2.0 0.20 0.20 0.20
O.~O
CpO 0,20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.2Q ; 0:20 '0:20 ' ' 0.20 0.20 . 0.20 0.20
O.~O
0;20 0:20 ·Q.20
0.20 0.20 0;20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0;20 0.20 0.20 0.20
. 0.20 0.20
' 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 .0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
10.00 10.00 10.00 10,00 10,00 10.00 10.00 10.00
10~
10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10,00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00 10.00
t;:~~~ 3;65Q.oq
.3,650.00 ?3;65.o';OO 3,650:00 3;650.00,
3, 6;59.0.0
, ~,.6~O.O.o 3;6;?,~,00
~3~6SO.00
·3i6sO~00
3;~,~~:09 3;650:.0.0
, ~,.650:00 ~,.6<5.o .. PO
J;65.o:OO 3)~?..o·09 3;650-90 3~65O.oo
3,650.00 ~;650.00.
3,65(i.'0:0 '3,6SP:OO' 3, 650.00 3;'650:00 3,650.00
~~~sO~OO 3":1;i5q.OO
),1!5.cJ:60, 3;6SCtoo
}i~~~~~: 3,659;0.0
'3,6 .. '6. 3~~~O.OO
·~{~~,O.09 3,650.0.0 3,650;0.0
3~65~:OO 3~6~:9~
.~:;:~
3;12a:57 3,12857 3;.12&.57 3.128,57 3;128.57 ,3,128.57.'
3,,1~8:57 3~128.57
3,128.57 3,U8:57 3.U8.57 3;i28.57 3,128';57
3,128.~!
3,128;57
3;~28:~7
3;U8.s7 3:12&5]' 3,12&57 3,'128:57
3;128.57 3,128.57 3,~i,57
·i:~~~~ 3,128.57 3,128~57 .
3'-~~,~,~7 3,128:57 '3~12~:57 3,1'28:57 '3}128:57 3;11:8.57 3;12857 . 3;U~.57~
'3,128;~7 3;i~8,S7 3,12.8:51 '3,128.57
'3,12lI.57 3~8.57 ·
;~;~8:~7. \3;128:~7 .
·3ilZ8:S7 .. 3,128.~?
3;128.57 3,~~8.57.
3;128:57 ·3;12~57,.
2,729~
2~729
2;7H ·~i?Z? · ~,729
2:729 . 2,i29
2.729 2,129"
'-2,72!J 2;729 .
L 2:t~ 2~729 .' ~;729 2,729 2,729 '2,729
2,729
~i~~:' 2~729 2,i29
2,7,29 2;7J.9 2,729 2,729 2,729
2,~.29
2,729 2,729 2.729 2,729 2)~
~.7i9 2;129 '2,729 2,7z9 .
2,729 2,72'9 2;729 .. 2,729 2;729 2,729 2,729 2i729
2,729 2,?,29 2~j~ 2,729 '2,729 2;729
. 2,729
2,729, 2,729
2,7~ _ ~;!29
2,729 2,729 2,729 2,729
' 2,729
2,729 , 2;729 2.m 2;729 2,729 2;729 2;-729 2,729 2,729
2;'~9 " 2-71.9. '2;729
2,'729 2,i29 2,729 2,729 2;729 2,729 2;729 2,729 2,729 2,729 2,-729 2,729 2,729 2,729
2,729 2~729
2,729 2,729 2,729 2,729 2;729
.2;729 2,72,9 2;729 2,729 2,729 2,729 2~729
~729
2;729 2,729 2;729 2,729 2,729 2,729 ' 2,729
0.86
0.89
0:85
0.86
0.89
0.85
0.86
0.89
0.8S
0.86
0.89
0.85
0.86
0.89
0.8S
0.86
0.89
0.85
0.86
0.89
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.46
0.47
0.43
0.46
0.47
0.43
0.46
0.47
0.43
0.46
0.47
0.43
0.46
0.47
0.43
0.46
0.47
0.43
0.46
OA7
0.43 '
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
OA'
0.43
0,43
0.43
OPG Darlington R. furlnhment Program TurblneGtneJatorf'l'o]ect
$61.89/.hr $ 79.62'/hr
, ~ ·~~.:53)"hr .,S·63:44/hr 'S' Si.,68' /hr
. .1:;~~ .~~~. . $:83.80/hr
, , . S45:p1,~'r. ':$ ,62.32/hr
. ·s80.'.1i ),'n; $46.8'2'/ hr
',~::~:~~:~- ,
~}:~~~r;'~~ ':$' 84:S9'lhr
, "S' 45.;88 lhr $"62;si)"hr $ ·80~53.fhr
.~ 46:9& /hr $'64.14/hr $ 82.61/hr
· $48.08/hr
$,65.72 /hr $84:72/hr $45.95/hr
· $ 62:sa"jhr ··$·.8~,.6~ / hr
.,$.;~7:~5· I hr $ ·~4.23. ! hr $'82.73 :/hr $'141t15/hr
f65.S2,(hr · -S' 84.86 /.hr
·S~i6.52/ hr
$ 63 ,53 i hr $ 81;.~.~./ hr $47.62/hr
"'-$>65:09/hr $83'.87/hr $4Ei'.72-jhr $"65:68/hr $ 86.00·/ hr $'""46.7S ·/hr
"S:63:92Vhr $ ·8'2.33Ihr $4'(89)hr $6'5.49/hr $·8'4'.41/hr
$48.99/hr. $.67..08/ hr $ ~8~.54 j hr
$47:37/hr '$'64.79 Ihr
$83.50/hr S48:48/hr $ 6~.37 'ihr $85.58//:1r $ 49.58-/hr $·67.96/hr $·87.70/hr $59.69/hr $87.52/hr $'ll6:63jhr $59.16Ihr $86.73/hr S11S.58/hr $'S8:29)hr $S5.42"/hr
$ '1l3.83/hr
$57:73 Ihr S84.58'/hr
$ .112.70/hr $ 57.l8.Jhr $ 83.76Ihr
$'. l1i.61 I hr · fS'6.98 ihr $83:46/hr
$ 1'u.21/hr $ 54.26"1 hr
, \ $79:38/hr $'105.77 I hr $53.09/hr $77.63/hr
$·103.'lt4/hr $'51.70,/hr
· SZ5.54/hr $1.~ .. 661hr $5i.H/hr S·84.S8/hr
$112.70 thr · . $56.98 Ihr
$83.46/hr $ 11i.l1'/hr $,58.29/ hr $85.42/hr · J
$ ·1.13.·S,3/hr $50.12-/hr "$"'13.16(hr $'.97.48/hr $54.26/hr
. $79.38/hr
$105.77/hr ~ $· 56.65/ hr
"$'8i:97/hr . S··110.56/hr
$.56:13/hr $82.18 thr
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 417 of 573
4341EPsCA 4351EPsCA
-~:.!-~ ! ~~~-~:. ,4381 EPSCA
' 439iEPSCA 440!EP5CA
, 4411 EPSCA
442rE,~$,CA -443iEPSCA'
:'~:I:~~~': 446:EPSCA',
44~iEPSCA
' ::: 1 ~':~~ '4S6!E'PSCA
45'11 EP~CA 452iEPSc:'.A
453fEPSCA
4~1 ~~Cf' 4551EPSCA '
~ 456!EPScA
;~~j~ .. "459i"EPsCA
. 460I~PsCA 461!fPSCA
: 46Z!i:PSCA
-o.-4,63!EPscA
-!tr:~~ '¢6'lEPSCA
~ ~:~ !:~~ :~~ I ~:~6: 4i~ I~P'5~
< 472iEP5(A
473iE~5CA 4i4iEPSCA
475!EPSCA
:~:I~¥~~: ' :~!I:~~ 480IEPS,~ 481!EPSCA
482!EPsCA ~: 483!EPSCA ' 484iEPScA .
' 485 !'EPSCA
.: 48?!fP5CA
lpcalZ93'
.~:::~~ I.9cal .?9~ L6cal 793
Lbca"793 ~f79l ldcarl~13: lo:cal793 ~caI793' ldcal '793 iiic:.:h93
Locif7:~3
~~:.::~ ~~ : .~:: ' Local}.93 Lbca l';793 ,
Loeal793 l6cati93 lo'ca'I'793
loca l~93 lo'cal793
locaJ'793
Loca'79~ Local}93
locai,793
local 793 locai793 LO'.ca'1793
lo!=<ll793 LOear793 Local '793 Local,7.93
Loca'793 Loc.aI 793
'fc.aIi9~ local 193
!-O:Ca t793
lric.aI7.9~ ' Local.793 thea179}
loeal793 local 793
loeal}93
~~: ~:: Local .793
' lo'cal'793
local 793 Locali93 locar793 ' locaC793 ' local 7'93
Local 793 ~ci793 lOcal '793
Local 793 local 793 local 793
Loeat'793 . local 793
lO,dr-i93
local 793 ' (Otal ~93 .
locaij'93
4'6 f793
LDl:a1793 ' Local 793
cat'793 I.Ocal793
LCicai-,193" lol;31793
local 793 lo~1793 local,793
lo~I-793 lo~:aj'j93
[,ocal793 .: [&:i179;3 "'
locaJ,793 . ~~i~793 ~~J79'3 '
': lOea{793 ' LDtI7:93
lllcal793 • ~~17;'93
~:~~;~ LO~I~'3 LoGlI793 LoQ(793
Operating Engineers
Qp'C!f"a~i_ng .~~neers Operati'ng' ErIslneers
~~~~~I.!'~· E~.nee($ Oper!l.Ung Engineers O"Peratln'g Eil8!neers
Opc~a<tl,,!g E!"gj,neers O~ratlng En<glneers Operat l!)&,Englneel;s 6Per"atl'nS't nSlneefS
. Qper_~t)"#'~ngln~erS
~:~:,~:~,n~~~::'~ §z:~,:,~:~~::~:: ~:
, Qp:~ratlf.'1gE!"glneers
9pef;;ilng ~.O~lnee rs
a~i:;:~:~K:~'~~:~::~: Op'eratni"gfEnglneers
~:~"~,~:,~~. ~~::.~::~: 0 peratl ng:,Engineers pper~'t'i'"g 'E~glncer~ ~.pe r,~:Ir.~ 'E~~neers
6=~:f':~ ~~::~:~: ~r,atl~g:E~glt'1eerS O·peratlng·Englneers O~tlng,e ngll'leers O~atlng Engi~rs O~atln8 .E riglneerS dP&~~i~:EriBlnee r $ ,operatini .Englneers
O~.aling .Englneers OPerating'engineers
qperatir.gEng1neers Oper3t1iig'Engineers
b~;)tlng E.ngineers Operatlniinglneers 6~ttng 'En8lneers
bper~ti!l8:;Englneers ~p'e1atiiig 'En8Ineers
pPera,~lng .E;ngl n~rs OPeratlng'Englneers Operatlngfnglneers Op~'(atlngEnglneers o~;'~tln8.Englneers Opera~ln,g Engineers Operating Engineers Operatlng'.Englneers Operat'i'ng Engineers
opc;ratll"!g:Englneers
~p~ratiM,~'r~nglneerS QperatingEnglneers OpedtlngEnglneers dpi!ratlng.Englneers Operatlng'E'ngineers
operatltig 'Engineers o~ra~ij1g E,l'!8i'neers opJriti~ engineers Op,eratlngEngrneers
Operai!n. E~rneers op~r~ting En&lneers
. qper~ting_Ene:l n~rs
~~:i~~;i:~t:: Oper~ti~g:Engineers Op:eratlng.Englneers Q~}iiing 'Engineers
cii:ifKatingEngineers
ci@'~ti\"lg ~nglneers O~atlit Engineers
~::.~:~,;~~=::~ ~'p~;jtl~.Engrn~ers qperatfrig Enelneers
~=~~.:~::~~:~::;: ~~;;,:-~~:f:'i~: Qpr!ratfng·Englneers
~p£!ri! tt~lE~~ln~ers 6'p~\lng 'E~glneer5 Oper-ilI1k)B ~~g)n~~r~ ci~-a'lns·E' nglf.:ccrs Op~Jii!Jlng: e.n8\ne.er5 .~·r~;!",:.~'.l~~eer5 Operatl,..,Englneers
~p'efl 1iIJJJ9~lne,~ Op£H'"itlr'li ~ngfneers
Ope~~!irg:.~.~gl n~ers g1)eraU"l Ensl ne~rs ~per.a\~ng Ef'I8lneers Operating EnghJeers ~p;;'r~tliig Ensfnecu
~:::~~.::~=d:~: Ap.cr-¥,r,ng. E~~lneers
d::::~~~;~~{ ~Z;~~:~.~~~:z.! dt:/eratingEngineers
S'Ji~1tiiifEriiine~r~'
52-8
53,8
5,." 54--8 ':'
S4.:g.~
54" 55-'8
~5-8
55'-8 '56:.3
56'-8
,56..:g 57-8 57 .. 57-8 S8~-8 58~S
~8:8 59~8
59:8 59:8 60-8 6<>,
6<>' 6178
61-8
~1-~ 62~8
62-8
6~-8
63~~ 63"8 63-8
64-8 &1.8 .... 51-6
51~ 51:6 51=6
52'-52'-5"-53.,6
53~ 54-6 54 ..
54~
. 55-6 55-6 55-6
56-6 56-6 56-6
57-~
57-6
57-6 58-6
58-6
5.8-6 59-6
59·6
59'-59-0 59 .. 59 ..
~ 60'
·60~. fi{i 61.,6.
61-6 . 62'~6 62'-62.6 63--6
6..-63:6 .. .-
' a:6 6,4-~
53-:;0 5~-g 53:;0
53-1 53,1 53;;1
53-2
5.l~~ s'j~i 53;3 53:'3 153-3 53-4 53 ..
53-4 52-:0 52-0.
" .. 5.2-1
52-1 5i'--1 52~i ~2-2
52,2 -7S~9 75-~
75-9
!Subforeman Group 1 (8) j ! 'GIOUP2(A) !
Gi''oU~ '2_ (M! . ~roup' 2:(A) i
1~;;~'~;!:m: 1 iSubforeman Group 3 l
i~~~~:~i~ ~~~~:~ ! i?ub.fofemilli~ro,u.p· 4
is.ubf~r~man Group 4 . isubforem';{n Group'4
iSlub~~relT!~n Groyp 5 !S~bf6~~~~-Group 5
15tl!b~re;m_a~n_ ~roup 5 j5ub%reman Group 6
11 5!JbtO~m~n G~?UP 6,
i~:~:~:Z~ ci~~~: i : 'Ii~ubr,!=lrf!"ma,! Grol,lp 7 f.
siJ~'a l'emari,Gr6up7. ! is.)J"b farl:'".1an~!s.c_Gro_upl ·
15:~~~:: ~:i;~:~~:I '
420055
437255 437255 437255 42005':; 42005,5 42005'5 42()OS5
42005~
420055
. 42005~ '420055
i~U~f&,rman~Mi'sc Group t· j5u.bf'!rtman, MJsc Group j 420055
01-May-12
,-Ot-.May-i2 "or-M aY-'l2
01~Ma""-12
~!~~~:~~~.~ OHy1ay-12 'Oi:May-l:2
'01-Nay-12 01-MaY.-12 01':~~V-12 'tl1-May-12
I~LlbfottmariMlsc GrouP' j 420055 -
is<u~!orem~n .Misc Group i 420055 -Ol-May,l2'
iSullforema'n Misc Gro~p i 420055 ' ... Oo •. "'~~M: :fl,22,
.Mlsc G_roup~ 420055 _ - _,-
• ',",', GG' ~uupp ',; 420055 ;0~~¥~X-1~ .... _ 420055 ':OHJ1~y-12
. Group ~ 420055 .01 May 12 G~Up ~ ·420055 ; ~-Oi:M~/'ii
!~~~!o~~~;n~Mlsc·Gro~{ 420055 J>l-May-iz i Operatl~ E,Rgineer Groll( 4-ido3:; • )~l~~~,li iO~rati~~EngineerGroui 420035 ,;or-May-12 ! opec;atj~E!lgineer~rou( 4.20035 ;':QH~'liiv-12 iOperafing'Englneer Groul 420035 :01-MiiV';12
! Operatl~EngineerGrouj 42~35 ~Oi-_Mav-12
1~:.;~~.i:!:::~i~::I:::E:: .;~~;~:;::: - - - ';~'~~MM:" tYy:.~!22·· ·
joPeraflng ~ni(neer ~.rou~ 44
'2·700",i3,55 '01.M.y.12 ! OPflRtI~g ~n_gin~er Grouj iOperiltingEngineer Grou\- 42'0035 :01-M~y~12 i o~ratfng E~glne~r Gr,ou! 420035 O,l-May:12 iOperatlng Engine:er Grauj 420035' 01-May-12
l o~ratin,g Engineer Grou.1 _ 420035 01-Mav-12 !Operating Engineer Groul 420035 ,01;M,ay:12 i ope~atJng-E'ngineer G'roui 420035 01-May-12
!?peratlrig Engin~er GrOUI - 420035 01-Mi!y-12
i Operatln~ Engll)eer.Groui 420035 '01-MaY-12 !Operating E~gineer ~roui ' 420035 Oi-Miy-12
i operaiin~ ~nglnee-r ~rou\ ' 420035 'O,l:May:12 ,Operating En,g[neer ~rou! 420035 01-j\'Iav-1i !Operating Engineer Gro!J\ 420035 01-MaV-12 ioperat,ng Engineer Groul - 420035 :': 01-M~y~12 loPeratlri~ Engineer GraUl 420035 01-May'-12
i ~~~i::-~::~:~~~~~I ' :~:§! ~~i~,~t!; f~~~:i::'~·~:·~:~.ci~~~j - :i:j~~ " ~t~:t.!·~ · i . · [ngin~r· Groui . :~~~~ ~~~~:~:~~ -
. f ._, .-~.;~;~} ~~! 01-May-12
I ~::~:;:~ ~:~:~:~:: ! ~!~~~::~~
1~~~~'~~i~~~1 :~::~,:. ;~gi' ~,~j~~~llt ~gj! l~~~;f!~: -~~~~:~~~;:~l :i~:~ !~H~av~.12 i q'pe~a!!~g_~~~lneer MI~cl :~~~~
i 8::~: 6t~~~::~~·:~~:J ' 437215 : 8ea,\fY,~D~~V M~sh~n!~,al ~ 4'372'15 i Hea'vY 'D~tV< Miknah1i:;'11 ~'" 'I:leavy Duty tv1!,!chan,ical f.I iHea-» Dutv' M;chankal ~
IHeal(V:QutyMechan1callrl.
:H~~,~ D~tv.M,echan1ca( ~ i.~,~.~yY· ~utr Mechanical ~ i He~Vy Duty Mechanical Pi : 'H~~~ D'Gi;/rVi~chan12al At jH,eayv ~?JY. f..I!~cha~.i~,al .~ iHt-il VY DutV Mechan1callol
! Jie~.vy}?!)tY-' Me~~n,f,c.al ~ j.Hea.v:v Duty MechanicaJ III t'0"~j~i:Appi~ntke lst '2q :.~ning APpr~ntice 1st 2d ! C~Xi~'ApprJntke'ist 2Q '
t~ning'Apprentke 2nd '~"
I.~~'~:~~{:~::~: ;~:J 420015'
lCraning ApPrentice 3rd·21 420015 , .. 3rd 2( 42'0015'
. rentice 3rd_ 2f 420015
I 460765
O;L-May-12 .
01~MaY:12 . 01~"'1aY-12 -'
.ol:~~y .... 12
1.5
2
1.5
1
-1.5
1.5
2 , . 1.5
2
'.5
1.5
2
1.5
2
1.5
2
1.5
1.5
1; 5
2
1;5
1
1.5
1.5
2
1,5
2 l '
1.5
2
1 . 1,5 2 .
1,5
2 l '
1.5 2
1.5 . ;
·1.5
2
1.5 2
.'. 1.5 2 '
1.5
1.5
2 l '
1.5
2 1
1.5
2
1.5
2
1.5
2
1.5
.1
1.5
2
1.5
2
1.5
2
73.48 ! ,% 35.99 ! .. ". '53.99 I .. " 71.98 I .. " 15.51 I .. " 53.27 1"" 71:02 i "" 35.04 ! .. " 52.56 I ""
· ~~~~~ . "1·::
2.94 1.;1'4
2:16 2.88
1-.42'
2.13 2.84 1.40
2.10 2.80 1.39 2.09 -, 52.31 I'"
6~.74 .. 4% 2]9·' .
31;54 48.81 65.0g ·
:31.54 4~;31
63.08 ,3(Q5 ,45.53. 60.70
I'~ 1.30 , '" ' ;.95
. ':: . ~:~~ ,
'II :: : ~::~ 4% . 1.21
I, :: ...
'53.27' 1,% ~ 71:.oi 1 4%
3.4:~? , II .. " ,
52,~1 ' I"" 69 .. 74 t 4?,'.
· 35.99 I 4'"
· .5~:9? .1"4" 71:98 r"" i8,~~c ! 4%" 43:49' ,'4% 57~98 I '"
32.~~\ ·- I! '.~ 48;81 ..
65,08 I.'" '36:19 ! '" i 4.29 ! ~" 72:3B i ~ .. " :35,74 i",> ••••. 5.3,61
71:48 ! . ~" · ~~:::; I::
69.98' !) .. ". 34.51 ' 1.% 51.77 :.1"" 69.02 ' ! 4" 34:04 ! 4'"
51:06 ! .. ,,' .. :::~~ i:: 50.81 , I .. " :i:~: . ,.I ·· ,:~ 47:31 ": ' '" 63.'oir ! .. %
• I 30.S~ ~ i ." 45.81 ! .4~ 61,08 ! ~%..
29:35 '. 1,1 ',".'
44.q3
58:70 ' I' ~% 29.00 !"" :::: . ! .::.
· 3451 1 .. %
51:77:; ! "K>'
· 69.02 ". I ~% 33.'87 1 4% 50:81' i 4% -
67:'74 ·1 "" 34.99 .! 4%.
52;49 1 "" 69.98 I ",, ' 27.99 I 4"
! ,tI: l .'99· I"" . :i:~ '1= 63.08 I'" .d50 ,4": ' 16.25 ~" ·35.00 . ,%, 20.99 ' . I '" 31.49 ! '''' 4~:98 ! .. "
' 24.49 ! 4%
36,7~,' ·14" ~~:!~ ! ::' 41.99 [ .. "
55." t '~. ~i.4~ 4" 47.~4 4" 62.9~ 4'" 17.50 4"
26.25 ! 4~.
35.00 ! 4" '22:74 ' 14" 34.11 ! 4%
45.48 i 4%
27,99 I ", 4~ .~ . 14"" 55:98 I"" '6.4t I ", 54,71 ! '"' 72.94 I .. ~
1.82 2.43
1742 2.13
1.3'9 ..
2.09
2.79-1.44
2.16
2.88 1.16 1.-74 2,32
1.30 .. vi5 .'
1:45
2:17 2.90 '
1.43
2.14 2:86
1.40 . : 2.10
2.80 1.38 _
2.76 1.36 2.04 '
2.72
2.03
'1.89 i .52 '
1.22 1.8 3 '
2.44
1.17 1.16 .
2.35
1:16 ' 1:74 2.32
1:38
2.07 2:76 .
135
2.03
2.71 :
1.40 2.10 2.80
1.12
1.68 2.24 :'
1.89"
2.52
0.84· )'
1.26
1.68'
1.47'._ 1.96
1.68 · 2.24 '
1.26 1.89 2.52 '
1.05
1.40
0.91 1.36 '
1.82
1.12 1,68 2.24
1.46
2.19
2.92
4.41 2.16 3:24 432
2.13 3;20
4.26 2.10 3,15 4,20
2.09 3.14 4.18
1:95 2:93 3.90 .
1.89 2.84 3,78
1.82
2.73
'.64 2:13 3.20
4.26 6~! . 2.09
~~! 3.14
~ I ;:!! _: i 3.i4
6%1 " ~;~ . -6% ! 2,61
- : ~I 'r 3A8
6% i _2. 1,7
6%"
6% i
' 3:26
4:34 i .. 14· 3.22 4.29 2.10 '
3.15
2.07
3.11
4.14 2.04
6% i < 3.06 . 4.08
6% 2.03 6% 3.05 :
4.06 '5% 1.89
6%i 6,, 1 6,,'1, 6"! 6% ! 6% ! 6,,'1 '"I 6% i 6%'-1
. 2.84 3.78
1.83
2.7~
3:66 1.76'
2." 3.52 1.74 2.61 '3:48
1.89
2:84
3.78
1.05
1.58 2.10
6.~ 1 1.26 6% I · 1.89 6%, 1 2.52 , :: i 6,,1 6% i :: I , 6~1 .. ,
~! 6"[ 6%[ 6"[
6%' : 6%i 6% 1 6%; ex! ex ! 6% 1 5% ! ti% ! 6% -i
1.47 2.20 . 2.94 '.
1.68 ' 2.52 3.36
1.89 2.83
3.78 1.05
1.58
2.10
L36
2.OS 2.73
2.52
' .36 2.19 3.28
438
9.12
4.56 6.84 9.12 4.56 6.84
9.12 4.56
6.84 9.12
4.56 6.84 9.12
4.56 6.84
9.12 4.56
6.84 9:12 4.56 6.84 9.12
4.56, 6.84 9.12 4.56 ' 6:84
.9.12 4:56 6.84 9.12 4.56 6:84'
'!:62 4:56'
_6:84 9,11 '
4,56
6:84 9.12 4.56 · 6:84 9.12
4.56 6.84 9.12
4,56 6.84
9.12 4.56 '
6.84 "
9.12 4.56 6.84 '
9.12 : 4.56 6:84 9.12
4;56
6.84
9.12
4.56 6:84 9:12-456 6.84
9,12. (56 6.84
9.12 4.55 ,
6.84 9:1i~
4:56"
1?84'
9.12 4:56 6:84 9.i2· ,
4.56 6.84 9.12
_ 4.56
6.84
9:12 4.56 6.84 9.1f 4.56
6:84
9.12
4.56
6.84
9.12 4.56 6.84
9.12 4.56 6.84
9.12 4:56
6.84 9,12
4.56 6.84 9,12
4.56 6.84
9.12
13.42 1,00 .104.37
6.71 0.50 51".36
10.07 0.75 · 77.94 ·· 13.42 · . 1:00 102.72 '
6.71 ' 0.50 .50,83
10.07 0.75 76.25 13:42 1.00 101'.66 6.71 0.50 . 50.31
10:07 0:75 75.47 13.42 6.71 10.07 13.42
6.1'1 10.07
-- 6.71
6.71
10~07 13:42 6.71
1~.07.
13,42 6:71 ·
, 10.07
10.,?? 13.42
6.71
10.07 13.42
6.71
10:07 13:42 6.71
10.07 13.42
1.00
O,~ 0.75 1.00
O.sO ~~.,S: 1.00 0.50
0.75 ·l.bi)" 0.50 p.75
1.~
0:50
Q.~s 1.00 0.50
0.75 1.00 0.50
0.75 1.00
0.50
0.75 1.00
0.50
0.75
1.00
0.50 0.15 '
lBO 0.50
0.75 1.(10
0.50 0.7S
1.00
100.63
50.13
49.73 74,60 '
99.46 · 49.03~ 73.54 98,oS'
5a:i~ 75:'39
. 1~.~~ 42.56 63.84 '
85.12 4 6~46
69.7(; :
92:93
3~.~1 46:$3: 62:04 34~~6 -' S~,~,~ . 69:72 38.71 58.06 77 .• p 42.56 63.84 85,12
46.41. 69,61
9~:8~ 31.02
46:53 62.oa 36.78 '
55.18 7357 4i.56 63.84
85:12 51.89 77:83
103.77
0.20
0.20 0.20 0,20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0!20 0,20
0,20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0,20
0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 6.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20
0 .20
0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0,20
0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0:20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20 Q,20
0.20
).
T
I I
0;85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0:85
0.85
0;85
0.85
0.85
. 0:85
0:85
0.85 .
0 .. 85
0.85
0.85
0;85
0.85 '
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85
0.85'
0.85
0:85
0.85
0.85
0.43
0:43
0.4~
0.43 , .
0.43
0.43 '
0,43
0.43
OA3 '
0.43
0.43
0.43 '
0;43
0,43 -
0.43
p'.43
0.43
cPo DArfuston R~furbklvMnt Pros!om TurbneG«M!r..tOrPr~
S·S1':23/ hr .
~%:·~~ti {~; . $S5A91h; S 8i:22~/hr
$.108.22 f hr $54~ "lhr $8~~d)lir
.. $. lOZ-:p.fh~.· $ 54.09/hr $·79,lZ /hr
$ id5~421 ~r $.s'i.S3 jhr .S' 78.i8~/ hr
Sjoii:30'/ hr $ 52:9S"/hr
$ 91:¥ -Jhr $"S3.53'jhr
%~l~~:t $.!:~.~~-! hr:
-$ 102:81."'/ hr
~~~~-J ~;" . $ 10t'4i'j'f,r $4~~;Zjhr '~ S'66;8S·/hl
$ .66,86/hr
'- ~,~:~:~,~;~~ , S. 72.99; /hr. $·j97~.25:'lh~
~~t~;,;~t< $.·64.59 1hr
..... n9:~~i~r $~S7.67.1tvS'j·6.82"/tlr S·4s~§2.Jlhr $ 66.861 hr
~.,~~Os I.~~ : S:~~..;~l~j. hr $ 81.71,/hr
s"1os:isyi1r
., ;. , .,
:.~
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 418 of 573
532jEPSCA
533!EPSCA 534!EPSCA 535[EPSCA 536[EPSCA
537!EPSCA
538tEPSCA 539iEPSCA
5401 EPSCA
:"~:~!:~~: " ~~!I::~~
545i.EPSCA
5~6 1~PSCA 547l~PSCA ~~~l EP5CA 5491EPSCA 550lEPSCA 55,I,i'SCA 552 1 EP~i:A 553jE,P,SCA
- s~4i,EPs'CA 555!EPSCA 556iEP5CA '557!EPsCA 558!EPSCA- :
559iEPS~ 560iEPSCA
;;::Ii ~~~~ 565iEPSCA 566l'E~ScA
~:~ !~:~~ , 569!EPSCA
570jEPsCA
~,~~'l~':~~ 573! EPS0 S74iEPSCA
575i.~P~~ -576iEPScA 577jEPSCA
~~: !=: "580tEPSCA
~:i t-~ ' 583iEPSCA
5~4iE_PStA 585iEPSCA
5861EPS'CA " 5871EPSCA
58_~iEPs~ .S8~IEPS~ S9;~i'_EPS~ ,
591iE,PS~
~:!f-= 594lE_PScA 595i-E'PsCA '
5961 EP5CA 597! EPSCA
598!EPSCA '
5~9 lEP5CA
. :!~~~ 602:iEPSCA
60~IE~SCA . 6041 EPSCA
605!EPSCA
613!.~_~stA 6l41EPSCA
61-~ !.EPSCA , 6~6lE_P~CA 6171EPSCA
~ 618iEPSCA
619i ,~PSCA
:ii!~~~ 62f!EPSCA
" 623iEPStA 624!EPSCA 625jEPSCA
626jEP:5CA
:~~t:~~ :!~I:~~: 631:EPSCA
, 6321EPSCA
633iEPSCA
:::I::~~ 6j61EPSCA 637iEPsCA
'· .638IEPSCA
639lEPSCA
&40!EPSCA
lOcan93 local 793 Local 793
Local 793 Local 793 Local 793
Locai"S57 ~ocal .557 Local'557 Local '557
Local 557 Local 557 Loca1557
local 557 locaf557
~car557 CocalSS7 locafsS7
local 557 local 557 Local 557
:LoCilI5'S7
iLocal.5S7
LOCilI ~57 i:9'cai,s57 '
, l.:ocal557
Local 557
Local557 U;ca1557
t:Ocai"557 ' ~'ca I S57 localS57
LocafsF local 557 local 557 locat557
LoealS57 ILoeal ':S'57
ILOCilI '5S7 !toca l.557 lbca l557 loea'1557
Loca l 124
LOca!p4 loca.1124 local 114 local 124 local"l24
Local 124 LDca l124 U,:caI 124
toeai"i14
LocaJ.li4 Loea l·l:'24 .
lo'call:24' LoCill '124 i:oc.iI,:124
LDcal124 Locafi2'4
Loc'a"H24 U;ca-! '114 Lrica'I124
local 124 local 124
locar124 toeal"124 to'cai'721 Local.721 .
. Localiil
. Local-721 Local'.121
(;qcal i721 I,.Oca l'.721 Local 721 l ocal 721
local 7.21 local'721
Loca17~1
Loeal721 Locaf721
loca l ~2 1
locat721 Local 721 lqcal7-21 (ocalnl
Local-721 Local721
L Local721
Local 721 local 721 LDcal.721
Locar721 local 7.21
, local 30
[oear30
Loca!"¥> Loeal30 Local·30 Lo'ca130
Local 30 LocaL30 L..Ocal30
Local 30 local 30 lOCill30
loeal30 local '30 local 30
local 30
Operating Englneers
Operat!ng EnSineers
operai~~kE~jneers , OPet:ating Engineers
Operating Engineers Operating Engineers
P~i (lter.s
Palnter~
Painters pal~ters
Painters Painters Painters
Palnte~s
ral~ters
Painters Painte rs
Painters Palnte'rs Painters '
Pa.1nters Painters
Paintefs Painters Painters p~inte'rs Pal~ter;s Painters Painters,
Painters pail1ters
· Painters Painters
, Painters
Painters Painters
Pai~tefs Painters
P~lnters Palrit"ers
~!ilnters
P'alnte~s " Plasterers
, Plisterers . , plasterers
piinerers
Plasterers plasterers
Plast'erers Plasterers
P.~:~t~r~r~ Plasterers
~ P i~,s~~~~~ : plasterers
! Plasterers pratter~rs PJi,st~r~rs plasterers '
~, rl:ast~rers .~ Pla~erers
Plasterers-'
Pla~h!rers Plasterers .
Plasterer~ ' .
· Plasterers • • J
P1asterer~
· Rodmen
· Rodmen Rddme'n Rodinen Rodmen'
. Rodmen
R~dmen Rodm'en RO'dm'en
Rodme~ Rodmen'
Rodmen Rodmen Ro(tmen
~OOmen ROOmen
Rodmen Rodinen Rodmen
Rodmen ' ~,odmen
Rodmen Rodmen
Rodmen ROOmen.
Roomen
ROOmen Roofers
Roofers Roofers
Roofers Roofers Roofers
Roofers Roofers
Roofers Roofers Roofers
Roofers Roofers'
Roofers
Roof~ Roofers
75~8
75·8
7'-8 7'-6 75-6 75-6
42·9 42-9 42-9 42-8
42~8
42·8 42·6 42-6
4'-6
4'-6 -42-6
42~
.3-0 .... 43·6 43·6 43-6 ~3'·6
44-6 44-6 44-6
44-6
44-6
44-6 42:.0
4'-0 ,,-0 42-'1
4'2-1
4~~1 . 42-2 42:2
4Z-2 4273 '42-3
42'·3 " 17-9
17-9 17-9
17:S 1,7-8 17-8
17-6
'7-6
17~
'7-0 -17-0 17-0
17·1 17~1
17-1
17·2 17-2 17-2 17-3
17~~ 17-3
174 ·17-4
.17.4 21~9
21~9
2i-9
21i·9 21-9 '
21-9 -il-7
21-7 21-7
21·8 21-8
21'-8
21·6 21-6 21-6 21-0
:21-0
11-0 21:'1
21·1
21~1 21~2
21:2 21-2 '
21-3 21-3
21:3 97-9
97-9
97·9 97·6 97-6
97-9 97:.0 97-0 97-0 97~1
97-1 97~1
97-2 97:2
97·2 97-3
if!re~8hter Subforeman i 460755 01~!I.:!aY'.12 -, jA(f!fiB,hterSutiforeman I ~60.755 01~May·12 ,II
il "R",e._ •• ~:tt:5~bforeman II 460755 " 91;M~-y.h ~. ..... 460735 ~ oi -May-12
i Are~~!ers 1.111 460735 -ol-May-12 [' !Flrefighters 4&)"735 :' 01.M~Y.12 IF~r~~n 40576~ I oi-¥.ay-i2 I 3D-Apr-13 I Fore~a n 405765 0~-~,!y-12 I 3D-Apr-13
IFpreman 405765 1 '-<1 '1:MaY~~2 I 30-Apr~13 It~~:~:::~ i :'~~~'~~ ~~'~~:~~~~ I :~:::,~~: \subforcman i 405.755 01-~ay-12 I 30-APr~1-3 l.lpurneyma n I 405735 01-May-12 [I ~0-Apr.~3 l.JourneYma~ I 405735 01-May-12 I 30-Apr-13 Voume:vman I 405735 :pl,~May:i2 1 30-Apr-13
l lead AO~lement ~prker l '405B36 ' 01-MaY~12 ! 30-Apr-13 ilead Abatement Worker I 405836 o'i~~aY~12 I 3().Apr-13
It.e'adAba~e~~nt Worker l 405836 01-May·12 I 3G.Apr-13 j5pray Painte r i 4!)S736 1J1~MaY'12 ! 30.f\pr~13 !5~,¥,pal~ter ~. 405736 '0l-M<!,V'-12 j' 30.""r-13 i~pra~ Painter I 40~j36 01-May-f2 I 30-APr-13 I ~a~~ Blaster 1 405737 ,01:May-12 I 3O-Apr-13 IS~~(f.~l aste; I 4'05737 ":Oi:May~i2 I 3O-Apr-13
j .S~~d BI~,~ter i 405737 01-May-12 I 3D-Apr·13 Piiper Ha'nger, Fabric_Han 405739 ~'ol~M~y'-ii 130:Apr-i~
l, pape~ _~, ~n,'.:~,~:f'a.·brI Cfiarl 4057!~ 01-Mav'~p. , ~O-A:pr-,l3 Paper Hanger, Fabric Ha~ 4~~?39 '01~May-i2 30-Apr-13
~ slg,n.wrlter ~ , . ' I 405738 -: 01-MaY-12 1 30'Apr-l~ !5ig,riwrlter . ' ,J .4'05738 oliMay-12 '30-Apr-13 ! ~Ignwrjter . _ : . 40573B Oi:May"12 3()"Apr~13 ~ • 1st 6 Monthi 405715 . , 0l~May-12 l. 3o..Apr~13
-~~t6 MOrlIN 4057:lS Oi:-M~:12 I ' 3£l.::A:r-13, · lst·6 -Mbnt~ 405715 :Dl;M~V~ii 3().~pr~l~ ~ 2na 6 Mont f, 405715 61.May~12 30:Apr·13
}'p'p'~~nilce~tnd '6Mont~ 405715 , '01-Ma"y-l,2 ! 30-Apr-13
l~ppren~lce :: -2nd 6 Mon.t~ • 405715 ~H~ay:li . ! 30-~pr-13 I:~~:~!~'::,~~,~~:~ !. :~_~~~~ ' 6~:~:~,~~~ II ~~:::~~
:I A~~(e~1Ice.~,FjCI ;.y.ear ' Ii 4057i5 ' ih~MaV·i2 30-Apr-13 :·IMP'rentlce •. 3rClYear . ' 40'5715 "-01~May~12 30.Apr-li .'
I"<ppremlce: 3~d, Year I ' 405715 01:May .. 12 30'Apr~13 '
jAPprent. lce •. 3Tdyear i ' 4057-15 OH~a'y-12 30-Apr-13
· F.orem~fI i '430365 01·May·12 .
I:!;;:~" " I ':Em ' ~:;~!a: ! 5ublo~man 430355 O{May:12 I
, !Subforeman . 430355 ~ ~l.-~aY.::.12 [ !Plasterer 430335 01-May~12 iPlasterer ' ~3033S ' 01 M~y 'i2 I '
I~:;::~~" "1900hou! ::~!~~ . ~:;~i:~; [' IAPpre,n.*e·,-lst ~60' ho'u·1 · 430315 0
0'::1,' ~MM:}"YY' :,i,.',
App~ntlCe': 1st 9'?O hou~ 43o.3~15 Appreritke . 2nd 900 hoLi , 430315 ':()1-May-12
Ap'pn!nt'lco. 2nd'90~ hoJ . 430315 ; ~~~M~Y~f2 Apprentice. 2nd 900 hb~ . 430315 ' 01·MaV·12 ~p,prentlc~. ~.rd ·900 'hou( ' 430315 01-May'-12
IApprentlce ~ 3'fd 900'hOui 430315 'oi:May-12
l'A_pprentlce - 3rd 90Q t<riuj <; 430315 01-May"12 · .-- entlce'- 4th 900 houl -:-430315 01~May"~12
ent~ .\~~ ~ ~.o~l · 430~15 ,0i~MaV:12 • 4th 900 haUl 430315 01~Mily:12
I 'J , •• ~ ~·:;:~:~I :,:~:!; ' ~~~~::~~ . ,.!Apprentlct! · 5th 9OOhoui 430315 Di·May.12
I~nlor F.ore~:an, • .. ynes.?o 'Statlon'~ ?"nIY: 01-May·12 Senior Foreman - Unes & Stations only . 01-May;12
~~~IC?,~ Foreman ~ unes'& I~t~tions ;onJy, 01~May-,12 Forema n I . 445365 oi~~:ay:-12 . 30-Apr-l3 ,fore:~~n . . "-I" 445365 O'l:!May-i2 ' 3D-Apr-l3
I ~orema~ , 1_ ":~4~36~ ,i ~~~~:,~:~~ 3.0-~pr~13 : ::~:~:~ ' :~ '~~!~~:~:.~ ~~::-::~{:~::~! ': . 9.1:MaV·12
IFo;eman'ln Training. Unes-& Stations 0 ql-M,ay-12 ISuD~~~elilan " ., ; i 445-355 01-May-12 30-Apr·13
I'~'f~'remari - ' i 445355 'Oj~M~Y\!2 30-Apr~13
.' SUbfore~an i 44535S 0.1~May'-i2 1 30-Apr~~3 · Journey.man i 445335 ~O~"May-12 3().Apr~U '!Journeyman ' ! 445335 6:it~ay:12 '30-~r '13 ",Journeyman i 44S335 01-May-12 L 3D-Apr~13 Appr.erit:~e -1St 1000 hr~ 445315 01~M~V-12 . i 3D-Apr:13
' I APp~entk:e"' 1st1000hoJ 445315 01-MaY-12 ' 1 3D-Apr-13 Apprentice - 1st 1000 h~ 44531S 01-May.12 '3D-Apr.13,
'IApp~en~1C~: '2nd~1000, j,rj 4453i'5 'Ol-MaY-12 30-Apr·13
:::,~.:~,::~~ :" ~~: ~,~:'~~ : ::~:~~ , ~~:~~~:~; ;~:~:~t! ' A~~~~ll~ • . 3rd·1000 hr~ 445315 01: MaV-l i , ~O.~pr-13 ~p:pt~'ntlc~~ 3~d l000,hoi ,'-445315 , oi-Mav·12 " 30-Apr~13 Apprentice ~ 3rd 1000 hoi 445315 · OH~1ay-12 . 3o.Apr-l~ Apprentice' - 4th'1000 hrJ 445315- 01,May·12 · 30-Apr-13
Appr~ntl~ : 4th'1000 hoi 445315 01-MaY·ii 3D-Apr·13 .
/\PP're,ntlce.,~ 4th'1'OOO hOI ~ 44.5315 Oi.-May-12 30-Apr-13 ',
! F?~e"!lap , I ' 4:i5465 Ot~May-12
lFo.' re~a~ ! 44546~ . 01'-May-12 :orema~ I ~S465 Ol: May,12 Joum~an R,?<,fer IPot~ ~5435 ·61-,M~y'.12 Joum,eyman'Roofer _(I'otn 445435 OH~,aY-12 Joumevman Roofer (Pot~ I. 445435 ,Ol~Mav:12 Pre!~pprentic;e . I' ~45416 ' ( " b'l~May"i2 p~e:.APp rentke I ~ 4~5416 01.~May-12 .pre-App;e~tlce ;. i 445416 01;'May·12
Apprentice 1st Period i 445416 01-May·12
Apprentke 1st Period I 445416 01'. May·12
Apprentice -Ist P.erio'd 1
11
.,1 445416 ~ Oi-May-12 l~pprent1ce 2nd' pe'i'iQd 445416 Ol-May-12
IApprentlCe ~n,d .. ~ei1od 445416 ' Oi~M,!y-12 !Apprent~e 2nd Period «5416 · bi:~aY~12 . ! Appren~lte ~rd Penod . '445416 Of~May-12 .
1.5
,.5
,.5 ,
,.5
,., , ~.5
,.,
,.,
,.,
,.5
,.5
,.,
,., i
,.,
1.'
1,.5
1.5 ..
1.'
,., i
" i.5 ,
1.' . 2 , ,., ., ,.,
1:5
1.,
,.,
,.,
,.5 ,
1.,
1., ., ,.5
,.,
,.,
15
33.87 a 1.35
50.S1 4% 2.03
,67:74 "" 2.71
3.2:87 "" 1.31
49.31 '"' i.97
65.74 "" 2;63 37.06 1:48
51i'i.S ~.i5 74.86 4" ~:99
35.31 4% 1.41 . 53.52 2.14
71.36 4" 2.85' 34.06 4,," , ~:'3q 51:65 2.07 '
68.86 2.75
34.06 51:65
.. % ;,36
.. % 2.07 68.86 . 2:75
35.06 1.40 53:15
70.86 35.06 53:15 70.86 34':56
52.40 "69.86
34.56 , 52.40
69.86 11.41 10":(;6
2,7:54 15.13 23.24 30.9B ·
20.30
3.0 .. 99 41;32 27;17
39.03 .
5B:55 78.06
37!23 55:85 ?:_4~:i6 36.lh 54.05
72.06 ~18,02
21.03 36~b4 23.42 35.13 46,84
' 23,42
35:13
46,."84 28.82
~~:23 .
57:.64 32 .~B
48.65 64.86
41:29 61~'S4 82.58
. 39.65 59'.48
79.30 38.77 58:16 77.54
38.90 5B:35 77:80
35.90 53:85 71,SO
25.13 37,70
50.26 -2B:~i 4}.08 57.44 32..31
48:4I 64:62 34.11 51.17
6B.22 39:02 58.53
4,t .. .. '" '" ' 1 4%
]"" !4" 1 .. %
I"" 1' ''% !"% 1 ,%
II :~ .. 1:
' j ' ~
I:· 1-:
" ! " ~'. I'" ! ... ~
I' :: 1,":: I'" I'" ·1' '''' I'" I '" I '" j . .. ,,' ; I '"
_II: ' ... I:·: 1""6% I ...
1= ," I S% I'" j= !.", 1 6%
I,: I:: . [' "
11 ::"
"6'" '".'
"' -7B:04 "".
' ~ -35.5·2 I '''~ 53.28' I""
. il.04 ! .. %
~~:~ .J::: 35.52 ."
' 21:31 4%
' ,!~:':~ . ;;.: '2.4.87 4" .
37;31 1 "" ,
. ~:~: · I · ~:
2.13 2,S.3 1.40 '2,13 2'.83
1:38 2,10
',i:'79 1.~8
2.10 2.79 0.54
0.83 ' 1.10 ,
0.61
0.93 1.24
0.81 1.24
1:~5
1.09 ' 1.65
·2:20 . Ls6
' .34 ' 3.12
1.49 2;23
2:98
1.44 2.16
:'2.8;8 0.72
'1.08
i :44 0:94 1:41
'; 1.87 'Cdl'4
:). ;41 '
1.87 1;.15
1.73 2.31
. 1.30
t ,95 i.s9 ·2.4B
' 3:72
4.95 2.38 3.57 4.76
2.33 3.49 4.65
2.33 3.50 4.67
2.15 3.23 4.31 1,51
2.26 3.02 1.72
' 2.58
~.45 1.94 2:91 3'.88 '2:95
3.97
'.56 '.34 3.U 1.42 '
'2.# 2:'84 0.71
' r :07 , 1.42 '
Ci:ijS 1.28
' 1.70
0.99 ~,,49
1: 99
1'<14 .
EI ", I
""" j "' I
· 6% 1
'"i
Eli .. .. 6": 6?"i
. s,, '\ 6"! 6% ! 6K 1 6% 1 6% 1 .. i
' .. 1
.. I
.. I 6%1 061
EI 6% ,! ", I '" I "'~ : 1 ", I ''" I · 6%' i
'.6~ i 6"1 6"i 61'--1 6~' ! 6~ ! 6,,1 ",i 6~ 1 6%i
mil 6% ! .6% 1 , 6% ~
6% -t 6%!
GK_! 6%)
! 6%, i .,::' I ' 6Ki
::.j
2.03
3:05 4.06 1.97 2.96
2.22 3.37 4.49 2.12 -3.21
4.28 ~
3.10 4.13
4.13 2.10
2:10 3'.19
.i25
2.07 3.14
.2:07 3.14
, 4.19
0.80
1.24
1.65 0.91
1.39
'.86 1.22 1.86
2.48 ' 1.63
~.34
3.51 - 4.68
2.23
3.35
2.16 ,,24
4:32 1.08 · .
1:62 2.16 1.41 2:11
2.81 , 1.41 2.11
2:81 i:73 2.59,
1.95
2.92 6%1 "'! "' I '"'; '1.65
4" ! 3.30 4",.1 · f:59 4,, ·1 2,38
.4'" I ' 3.1.7 .. % 1 1.55
4"i 2.33
~"i 1.10 4,,1 i.56
",,1 2.33
4%! 3.11
"" j .1.44 ,,,,, '1 2:15 G! 2.87
'"' I 1.01 .. " i ' 1.51 .. ,,! 2.01
.. % i 1.~5
..% i ~ 1 ;72 4%1 2.30 4% i 1.29 ' 4% .1, 1.94
:· 4" i 2-.58 4%'-! 136
;~ I ~:~~-'6"! 2::34
SK _1' 3.51
' · ~t.6B 2 .13 1.10 4.26
1.b7 1.'60 2.13 1.-28
1:92 256
· :~ , I ' ; ~:~: . ~ i i9B
6"] 1.70
4.56 6:84
9:~ 4~S6
•. 84 9.Ii 2.'70 2:70
. 2.70 2.70 2.70 2.70 2.70
2.70
2:70 .
1-.70 2.70
2.70 2.70 2.70 2:70 2.70
2.}0 2.70 2.-'10 2.70 2.70
2.70 2-."70
2.70 ' 2.70 ;2.70 '
2.70 2.70
'.70 '.70 2.70
-2:70
2;'0
i.70 <2.70
·2:70 2.05
2.05 2.05 2,05
2.05 2 ;05
2.05
' .OS '.OS '.OS
'2.OS
2;~
-2.05
2.05 2:05
12'.05
.2-.05 2.05 2:05 ~ 2.05
'.OS ' .OS '.OS '.OS 3~0s 4.58
6.10 3:05
6.10 3:05 4.58 6.10
3.05 , 4.58
6.10
'.OS 4.58. 6.10 .
3.05
4.58 6.10 3:05 4.58 6:10
3.05
4.58 6:10 3.05 4.58
6.10 5.15
5.15 5.15 5:1S 5.15 5:15
. 3.67
' 3~67
:j 3.6.1
'3:96
3.96 3;96
' 4:25
4.25 ' 4 '.:25
' 4.58
6.71
lq.07 13 ~42 '6 .71
' i6.07
ii.!'2
52' 5.25
' 5.25
5:25 "S.25
5':25
5.2;; 5.2S 5;25
'S.i5
5;25 5'.25
5.2~
525
5.2~
' 5:25
5.25 5.25 5,25
5:25 5~25 5.25 5.25 5:25
5:25
S.25 5:25 S.25 5.25
5.25 5.25
5:25 5,25
4.74 '4.7.4 4.ia 4.74 4:74 4:74
·'~.74
4.7' . 4:74
4.74
4.74 4.74
, 4,7~
4,74
4.74 4'.74 4,74
4:74
4.74 4 .. 74
. 4.74 4.74 4.74 4.74
6.42 9.63 12:.84
6,42
9,63 .12,84 ·6.A2 : 9,63
12.84 6,42 9.63
12.84 6.42 ·9.63 i2,84 i;.42
9.63 12.84 6.42
9.63 12 ~84
9.47 9:63
12.84 6.42 9.63
12.84 4.86
4.86 u. 4:86 4..86 '4.86
2.75 ·2',75 ~2 .75
'3.16
'3.16 ·3.16
3.59
~ .59
3.59 ·l .t.02
0.50
0:75 ioo 0: 50 0~75 1".00
.'t.~5 1:15
1.15 1.15 1.15 l :is 1.15 1.15 1:15
1.15 1:15 .
1.15 1.15 1.15
i15 i :15 1:'15
1:15 '1.15 1,1'5
1.15 1=.'15 1.15
1'.15 . 1:15 1.'15 1.15
1.15 1:15
1.1' 1;1s 1.l--5 q5 1.15 1'.15
' 1.15
1--
0.74 1.11 1.48 0.74 1.11
1.48 0.74
1.11 1.48 0.74 Lll 1: 4B 0.74 1.11
1~48
0,14 1~'1l
1.48 0'.74
1.11 1.48 0'.74
1.11
1.48 0~74
1:11 L48 1;30
' .30 1:30
·i23 1.23
1.~3
0.75 0.75
0.75
0.85
0.85 0.85
6.94
~.94 0.94
1:04
49.03 - 73.54
98'.05
4i.93 7l.B9
~5.85
1~J.B7 70.86
91.45 47.94 67.97
87·60 4657
65.91 . ' 84.85
46.57
65.91 84.85 47.67 67:56
'~7.~, 47;67
67:56 87~05 4,]:12 6~~73, 85;95
. "47.12
66.73 '85.95
18.60
26.57 34.14 25.74
34:66 4.3~iB ~i"3 43:19
54.55 38.99 54.54 ' '
69.69 · 49~72
71.19 92.66 47.74 68.22 '
88.70 4.6.42 .
66:24
86.06 26.61
· 36.S2
46.a3 32,55
45.43
5~.31 32.55
· 45:43
58.31 -38.49
54:34 '70;19
42.46
60.30 78:14
83.44
1-11.26 -53:83
80,'74 107,65 52,86
79.-29 105':71
53.00 79.50 106:00 49.70 74.55
99.40 37:85
56.78 75.71 41.80 62.70 83.6p
45.75 68.63 91.50 47.73 71;60
95.46 54.23 75.69 97\5
'50.31 '69.85
89,38
2~:1'1 -36.'n
46.24 31.41 43:13 5~.85
36.14 49 .. 82 63.49
40.86
O.~O
0,20
'0.20 '0.20 ;0.20
0.20 . 0:20
~.~O 0~20
0:20
:0.20
0:70 0.20 o.io · 0.20
, 0;20
0.20 0.20 0'.20
0;20 0'.20
0.20
0.20 . 0.20 0.20 0':20
0.20 0.20
0.20 0,20
'0.20
0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20
~0.20
' 0:20
' 0.20 0.20 '0:20
t>.20 . "0;20
0~20 0.20
0.20 '0.20
0.20
6:20 0.20 0,20
0.20
0.20 0:20
0.20 0:20 0.20 0.20
0..20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0':20
0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 :·Q.20
0:20 0.20
0.20 o:io 0.20 ojo 0.20 0.20 0.20
0.20 ' tHO 0:20
0:20 0:20 0.20
'0.'20
0.20 l20 0:20 0.20 0.'20
0:29 0.20 0.20 O.to 0:20 0.20 0.20
O.~.O
11"'0 11>.00 10.00 !f).DO 1000 11)1)0
10J10 11)1)0
11)1)0
11)1)0
lJ)J)O
11)1)0
1OAIO
'D.O" toOO 10.00
IMO
"'till toOO 10.00 1OAIO 10.lIO
3,650.00 3,650.00
3;650:00 3,650.00
31650.00
:::~~,:~~ 3!6,SO:OO 3,65'o~60
2,729
2,729 2,729
. 2;729
i!?,i9 2,729
~,7Z9
'1.)'l!J 2,?~ · 2,729
2,?29 _' ~~!29
.::;: " 2:729
2,729
2~~i9 ,~;729
. 2;729,
2;729 2;729
2,7~9 2,729
2i729 2'729 i;m 2~7:ig
2).?!3 , 2,729 ~ 2,729
i,!2~ 2,729
" ~?~9 ' Zi729 - ~:729 2;7.2;9 2,729 2;729
2,729
i~7Z9 '2~7~
2,729
2~29
.~;729 2;729
i~729 '2J29 Z,729
2,729 , -2,729
2;729 2,729 2~j29 2~7i9 2,729
2~729
2.729 2i729 2;729 2,729
2,729 2,729 2,729 . 2,-729 -
-2,729 2;j29
'."-2,729
2,729
2;729 " 2-.72.9
2:7~ "2,729
2~729
2;729
2;729 ,1.729
2,729 2,729 2,729 '
2,729
2,729 2,729
2,729 2,729 2,729
1.iZ9 2;729
~729 .2,729
2,729 2,729
2,729 2,729 2,729
2;729 2,729 2,729 2,729
2~729
2,729 2,729
' ,71.9 2,729
2,719 2,1-29
2.7~ 2;72~ 2,729
2,729
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.B5 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.S5 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.B5 0.,3
0.B5 OA'
0.85 0.43
0:85 0;43
0;85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0:85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0:85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43 _
0.85 0:43
0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0;85 0.43
0.85 0.43
0.85 0.43
. QPGDarilngtonRefurbishmenl PrOlram TurbineGenerator pro]ect
$-52.78 lhr : $ 7i.~~ j 'hr
$102.S1/hr $S1.61 /hr .$ 75.40/hr S .. 100.47 / hr
$53.831hr ··$_74.83/hr
$96.68/hr $51:79/hr $ '71.77/ hr
$92.59/hr \'$ 56.33'1 hr
.$69.58/hr :'$89.67/hr
$5~.33/hr $69.sB/hr $.!J!i67/ hr
$si:SO/hr $.71:,33/hr '$92.01 Jhr
$51.50/hr
'-S 71.331 hr $' 92.011hr
=-" '$50.91/hr '; $70.46 ·/l-Ir
,)',~.84/hr
. ;jci::~ ~ ~~ $"90.84/hr
'-Si0'.98/hr , $"'18:1.6ihr
$36.19/hr $ 28.24}hr
~ r36~:4'2ihr $4S.46/hr
$3~.27 i hr $45.47/ hr "$.:57.53/hr $'42.29j hr $ ·S'7.52/hr
$73:S9/hr $53.82/hr
, $75.32/hr '$9B.I0/hr
" $51.7-2/hr " $ 72:'I T/hr
~ $93.90/hr
~$ 50.-32/ .hr . $ 70.07 /hr
$ 91.10 i hr $2930 / hr $'3854 'Zhr
$4,9:06/hr ' ·$' 35.60/hr
$47.99/hT $61:66/hr $'"35.60/hr
.: $47.99/hr
$·61.66/hr $'41.91/hr
' $· S7.~5 /hr ' S·14.27/hr
$.46;12-/.hr $'63.77/hr
$s1,"?o/hr ' S .59.88/hr
~S 87:81/hr $ 117.01/hr $ ~j.97/ hr S-84.93/hr
$ll3;IB.'/hr $56.94/hr
' S83,39/hr
$+11,13/hr $57.09/ hr
-S'"S3.62/hr
-S-111.43/hr
$~3.59/ hr $ 78.37/br $-104.43 ;/ hr
$ 41.02-/hr S '59:51/hr
. $:7!il.28,/hr $45':-21 lilr $65.80/-hr
. $ 87.f?6/hr
$'1~;401 h' $ 72;08'-/ hr
$96.05/hr
.'_S~1.~i.hr , $:75'.24/hr
· $ 100:25/.hr $·~8.33/hr
$79.tl3l~ $·102.6<fj 'or $54.18"thr $ .. 73.6~ / hr $94.36/hT $'29.38/hr $ '_38.46/hr
$48.83/hr , -$34.32/hr
$'45.48/hr
$57.92/hr $39)8/hr
'$52:52/hr .$67.04 Ihr .$ 44.24/nr
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 419 of 573
. 641iE~SCA ' 64iiEPSCA
··~;I~ ~.S!EPSCA
14. ,6 '1' ~PS~ : ' 647 EPSCA
, 6.48 ~EisCA · 6:49JEPSCf'. ~r~ 6S0!EPSCA
~~.l IEP~ 6521EP.S(;A
653 jEPSCA
~~4(E~~CA , . 6551 EPSCA ,
. ?S~~~~~ · 657,EPSCA
· ~S8 rEPscA .. , 6'~i 'PSCA
660'EPSCA
. 6~+psciA 662)EPSCA
6~31I EP5~" '_ 664 EPSCA- . · L
;:' ~5iE,PS<:A~ . 666!EPSCA
6,,1,,= . 6"68IEPsCA;' . 669IEPSCA '
", 670jEPSCA "
6'h lE~~
,,~~I~ '; 6741EI'SCA"
1"67'?!I¥PSCA ' ~?:6. E~~~'~" 6??l~~': ·
~6?~;EPSCA: 6791 ~ps~,
""P]"'" .. ~~,l IE~ '
· 68.f.1E~CA
6~~ [,E~~~A . 684 EPSCA ·
• j 685 f~CA:J ..
;';:":;I;:~~-": 69'7 EPSCA
' 6981"'0.
:~~I~' ':702 [IE~CA . 70"3 EPSCA ~794 EPSCA '0 .
.705 EPSCA
':706'EPSCA '7,O;I {~CA : 7081 E~5CA ; 70;I,eScA 710jEPSCA
7~1 1·~~5CA ii! I:~ i~41 Ef.S<:fo 71'S ,EPSCA ;i61,eScA 71-,I,p,o. 7~~ I EPSCA ·719 jEPSCA 72Q!EPS(A 721iEPSCA 72l I{PSCA 7~3 I EPSCA 724 ~PSCA
~2S I E~5CA ;.~~ I;~ n:8jEpScA
;~~[~~~ 73t EPSCA
i3~ I E'PSCA 733 EPSCA
73~1~~4. , 7_3,~j E~CA.
736 1 '~'"
"'.1 '. " .. CA 738 EPSCA
7l'I" '5;A ~:i !~~ ;74i l~'PS'CA:
7'3,'''0. 744. gPStA . 745 EPSCA
746 EP5CA
!r~7. I~p~ 1~.~ ~,~~~7491 EpstA.
loca.130 . local 30 . local 30
LOcal.30 LOeal30
Lo~I3.0 L.o:caJ30 i1cai I30:
~·~f·~· -L.OcaI'30 ~iar'230 [~'Cah30 i.oc:ab~() L.ocall30
~ca'I~2~~ local 230
~~:~~. Local 230 LoCiI-230 ' l~ca1230 1o~!.~~0 " loCal'230 local~230
locai·i3o tk"eal '230 Local 230 Lo:ca1230 . loealZ30 local·i3b '
lo'eal230 loCi!l1230 ' loca(230 local 230 local'230 local 230 Lo!2-.:i3"O local 463 " i.SciI'4'63 .: .
~C2Ir463 ' LOca'~463 lO.'1'J'~63 ~c.ar~~3' l.oc:ll463 lo-;at'463 lo.i:a1.46·3 Gjcal '463 1oc:a1"463 tOcal4fh Local 463 local"463 toca"'463 " loea, '46( .
Local 463 locai '"463 ~caY463 loca1.463" rO'cal463 li:iqr~63
LOcar463 ~ , i&aJ4'63
.Lpcaf463 l~ca.l '463·
locai '463 Local 463 local46i" locaf 463 local 463 Local '463 Locai ~il63 lo cal 463 loc;aI .463 loca(463 local 463 lotal463 Local"463 tOc:a1463 i'OCi1463
, 1ot.11:463 lo~r463 LDcal463 lo'c.aJ.4'63
1p~.t463 Local463 ldc2l'46'3
:~:.::: Loca) :~,~! loc.aI '463 L.6·CaI -463
~ca1463
· t::;!:~ 1O~f4'63:
~~: ,::~ ~~r::-: [1dl~s3
' local 463
1:Oa1'4'h
~~:~i:} ~~r.:46~
~~}~:~ 1O,eaI,463' iob."r463"
Roofors R'ciofei's Roofers R@fers 'R·oote;.s
Rpofers
eamster ·' :' T.e~(mstOf" ~' Teamster
Teamster , Te~'~ster
,~ Tearllster
;:" Team~~r eariiS1er , e~!fnster
,; ~~:"a~st,~
~ ~!:~~:~
~ Plumbers PI~jmberi
, Plumbers P.liiJi~ers .
P.lu~~ri Plurnbers PJu~ti!rs ·. Plumbers ' Pluinbers p'(umbers
Plum~r~ Pi~mb:ers PlumJ:)!rs .
I P:Il:lmbers Plumbers Plum~rs .
Plumbers , Plumbers . ~Iu;nbers
~Iumbe~s
Plu.!1:bers pJumbers Plumbers Piu'mlicrs Plum.bers: Plum'b'ers
PI~;.noers Plumbers PI-ui?n~rs ~lumJ;lers Plumbers Plu '~bim"' Plumpers PkJrT;bi!rs
:~~:~~ PJum~rs
:~~'~~. Plumbc-Is Pjuilib'Hi Plumbers piurt,be,s"
Plunib:e~s Piumbers. Plumbi:iri
< :~~~~.:~. Plumbers ptij{t;;'; '
: PIu,.f)1bers p:lumbNS PJuifib~rS Plumbers.. Plumbt~ Plumbers
. P~~~'n • P.lumbers
Plumbers Pluri,b~'i5
::J~~~ P.!l!'l!.~~.rs Plumbers
, 445416 Oi~M~Y·12 ! 445416 .ol~May~12 ' I ~S425 :,~l~_M,!y~.12 ! . 44S42S'~ 01"':MaY-12 ! ,
. ~ andler I 445425 · 01-Mar':12 1 anciler SR. Pro~ 445415 ~bl:.~.aY:_12 ., .
Handler 5R. Pro~ 445415" 01 May 12 Ha~d·ler· SR.: ~ro~ 445415 b'1~M~Y~12 "'·1
::~ I~:;~i:~;~~i~:,~~~ iEH; i~~:~~~c l . ~: I~~;:~;~ ~;~::: I :::':€;: '~:~~;:~~i i ~f:~::::: ' , :;~:. ,!~:t~;; :~~~~~ L }~~:i~ ~' ',~~:~:_~~~~' "I.~~:~:~~~ , :;::, ~;::~~;:~:~ , I !~~~!~ : (~;:~:~~~~ '! ~::~:~::: 48-9; ! ~:.ema.{·GrO~pt3 . ' 1 455116-5" . 01-May.-12 j Ol'-May-13
· ::i! . f~~~~;~;J~~' : " -. J :~~:~~ 'cl~~~:~:t~ J-~~:~:~~i~ 46-8' ~i7ub~~::~can. q~o~p l' j ;:~ 4,~54S5 q'~~~~Y~'12 ' l'OloM~'Y~i3
· 46-8 ' IS~bf~~~.a~G~.~~ · l ! 455455 ; 01~May-12 .0kMay.13· 4~·8 -l5u~Joreman.Group 1 i 455455 O:i-M~Y-12, ! '6i~MaY:13
,'.77', .. 8 ... J~£{io_rem~n GG'Zuu' pp.?, . !,,; '.'5,'.5454' '555 ~!~~~Y-~2 i
l ,O~-,M3y-13
,.., Ol-Miiy-iz . 01-May;13 4HI" ·1 455.455 ·01;MaY.o12 j Ol-May:13 .
· 4i~·8 · . 1 4S.~;4~5 , .. ol~.¥~il~ 1 'Ol-M~y-]3 . 48-8 · i5ubfo'remanG'foup3' Ii , 45~4S5 - , 01.MaY-1'~ · 1 Ql"f.Aay~13 4S-.8 ,!5~bfci;~!€~~n: ~ro~p 3 4554SS . '~.1.~aY-IZ " ·[ ' 01~~aY-~3 ' 4s:.6 ~Teamsters ,Group 1, .-: ' 455435 · 0~l..Mav;i2 · ol-May.13
46-6 lTeamsters-Gi9upl " ~' !.ii .. ·455435 . O~:.~~y~~~ ' I · 0~.~~y:13 · .')7.!' .. ·. .. J,;[ TT;'ea'~"'· :m· :~S1'!":t'.',:.·",?','·.:GG~'· n>.~,o' ~'''':P''·''.'2~.· '.' ' ~455d5 01~May;12 ! ,01oMay .• 13
.., . "' :, ' w , • • :;~:!~ . ,~~:~;~:!~ .'. i ~,;~~::~:~: · 47:6 iTe,a.msters Gr'oup';2 \ 455~35 0.~LMaY-12 I 01-May-13
48:6' .iTeamsters·Group3 455'435 ' I o.i~~ay~l,2: '">' I . 61.M~Y.·1~
:':3:~96 ' 1";! ~F~."o':,~.:~:"~::~f~~; ::~::: .' ~~:~:~:~~ I ~~:~:~~!: , u... i 450~5 ~1-~~Y-12 1 ~G-Apr·13
13-9 ' Foreman 1.:, . 450065 .01~May-i-2 3[)'Apr-13 . 13~9 ". :j Foreman 45006~ 01~M~y~1,2 ! ·30.Apr-13
13-9. iFo,rE!'man i 450065 O'i£May-13 i. 30;-Apr.-14
.. 13-9, i Forema'~' ,.,.",1 4590.65 01-t<.1a.y~i3 j ~0-~pr-14 1.3-9 ·' ·iFor!!man. 4S0Cl6S 'Pl: MaV-13 !, 3Q.Apr-14 j3:9 IForeman' . 450065 01-May~:t~ j 30-Apr-15 13-9 . !~r-e;;;an' . ; 4S~.S ,:Qi;MaY:'14' I 3G-Apr.15 H~ . iForeman' ; 1 450065 .~~i.::M, aY:.i4'. < i 3a:Apr:.f5
i3~8 " · 1 5,u~fO.r~ma-n·' .. .1,1 450055 ·~0~~.~~r-12 I 3[)'Apro13 ·U·8·" 15.u!Jf?·reman 45005'5 : ' 01·May-12 i ~o-A'pr-13 13;8 " 1 5ubforema~n . i 450'055.':' ··~I .. ¥aY~l~. ! 3().~pr-13 13:8' tSubfo~man .. !' 450055 01~May-13 ! 3[).Apr-14 U8" lsubfoi-eman t 4sOoS'S ' Oi "May-13- I' 3[)'Apr.14 u:a !~~~r~man' ''' I -4500S5 ' Ql·May-13 ~ 3()'A~-14 13·8 !Subforeman I . 4500sS . ~~~~;~~~: .. ~,i !~~~:~~
g!f~;~~~~~ ' ",,;1,1 ' '~4LS003:~,r. .. ,~~:~!~:~ I :~~~::: 13-6 JJo!Jm~man 01~MaY-12 L 3().Apr·13
'13'-6 . !! JoJo'·. ~m.:tmm',""' 450.0.3.?·· Oj~May-13 i 30:Apr-14 13-6 .. w,.., ' 450(135 ' Oi:; May-13 · 1 .3~Apr-14 13-6 IJourneyman ' ,I : 4soP3S,' 01~May·13 i .30·Apr,:-14
' 13-6 .: IJoJ~rneyman .450035 'Ol~~~y~'14 'I 30-Apr-i5 13-6 .JOurneyman 450035 01·May-14 j ~()'Apr-15 .13 ~6 · I~u~~ey!na fl 450035 < 01~MiiY:14 ! 3a-Apr-15
14-6 ' iPl¢WeJder- 450036 " ~~~~!Yy:~!i 1 3Q.~pr-13 . ',',.~,, ~ , ~,;.~p~,'pe-'~WW· ~"·I~t 4so03'6~ i 3[)'Apr-13
.., u.:, 4S0036 Oi~May~h j·.30-Apr-13 14·6 ,lPi~~elder ' 450036 01-May-13 i 3Q.Apr.-14 14-6 I~ii>ewelder 450036 bi.MaY-l~! 3?-Apr-14 14-6 ,I Pip.~,::"elder 45OO3!;' 01~Ma'y-13! 30-Apr-14 14 6 ,Pipewelder 450036· ·01-MaY.-14 ! 3[)'Apr·15 '14:6 1.PIPew~der 450036' "- 01~Ma:"'-14 i 3[).Apr-15
14'-6 l Pi~;elder 450036 01-May-14 1 30·~r-15 '
::~ i:;~~;~i::;;:;~': ' I :::~ ~::~::::~! :~~:;::: 13'0 IApprentice' lst'Period - i 450615 ' oi~r.iay-.l .. 2 .,.i. "'33~·AA~~1'.3 13:~ i A.pW~.~tice.1st~erlod i 450015, ' 0;l~MaY:f3 V" ",,-
13~ . t~~r~nt~~ lst per~? ! 45{X}]S £~::M~~-l~' ! '3~~r.l1 1"3-0 IAPprentice lsrPerldd ! 45001'5' · .Ol.~MaV~13 ' 3()'Apr#14 13~ !Apprerit'icfl a Period 1 456015 9.1-May~U ; i .3,a-Apt-1S .1,3:0 jA'ppferifid lst,p'erlod 450015 0l-fJliiy-14 i '3I).:Apr~15 13-0 IApp l1!-ntice 1st Pe;rlod 45001?: 01-~ay-14 I 30'~pr-.~5 13'-'1 )Ap~M~e;iri'd p~rlb~ · 450015 :01~MaY-1i'! 3[)'A~r~13
l'3~il1 , ,i Apprentb2n.c:!.Pe.rlod : 450015 01-.May;12! ·3a-Apr-13 ! A,#renti~2nd·p·er.iOd 45001S" dl~)~aY-12 ~ t · 3[).~p.r-l~
li33;'~ i ~!preQtlc:e 2nd'~eri9d ' 450015 : 01~M3y:13 i 3[)'Ap,.1.4 IApprentice 2nd Period 450015' 91"-¥ay-13 . i 3.[)'Apr-14
13-f l A'tpr1i~i~e' 2nd Pe rl:~if 4sOo15-:: ' 'oi'#M~y:i3 i iQ:Aprol:4
1~-~. IA~~r:~t1,c:e ~nd ~~riod 450015 ' 01-May~14 I ·3[).APi-15 13~1 j~ppn?ntlce 2nd'Period 4sobis' ··'01; fv1aY:f4! '30~Afii~15 '1, 33 "2~ i,; ApA· PP.P:''"ntt~'.·'·32f-dd'· ~'·riQood'd ~500~~ 01~ ~~'fay~i4 ' 3Q.Apr 15
- " ILC ' - 4SQo15 O!: MaY-12 ! 30'Apr:13 il-2 ! APi5}entiCec3rd i~;I~d 450015' ~()i:M·3y.~i2 .1, '3'c;:~ro13 13'3""".22'~' ',;.· Ap·,pco .• " .. t ...... ' ~~,d. -'p~.e.·.,. ;.od ....
- j;&.pprentie 3rtf'Perlod :~~,~~~, ~~:~~~~i~ l ·!~::;:~! 13: 2 i ~p~re~~~c~ 3r~ Period 4!;i001.5 p1·MaY-13 i · 3()..Mr~14 13';2 I ~~prentic:e 3rd Period 4500i5 . ~i1~~ay-13 i }Q:Apr-14 13-2 i' e~tic,e.?rd . Perl9d 45'001s ' 01:May:14 ! 3Q.:Apr-15
~:i ! " :f:;:~~ ::}~ b?~t:i: 1 · ~~Apr-.1~ 13:1' I AJ~prr.~.t!~,~.t.~~.e~?d 450015 ~1~~aY-12 ! ' :~~~~~~ -13[3 ' fApprentice4th-Perloi::l 4S0015 0~~MaY~12 i 3()..Apr-13
~::: i ~~~~:~f~:'1~~:~:~~ ::i! ~~~~~~:i~ i,.::333;~;:,~44~ ::~: . f1&;;~:;{{~':~; ::i: ~::~::~:: ! 3~;;:14 13-3" i ApprentlCe:4t~_Perl0d 450015 ' 01-M~:i4· ~ 3a-A$~-15' 13-3 ' i Ap'p~ntice,~th'Pe.~~ 450015 ·, pI-May.-14 l 30:APr~1.S
1.5
2
1.5 '
1 ' 1.5'
1.5 ' 2
I
1,5
2 1
1.5
2
1.5 2 '
1.5
1
1.5
2
1.5 2
1.5
1.5 2 1
1.5
1,5
2
1.5
1
1.5
i .5 2
1.5
1.'
1.5
1.5
1.5
1S
1'.5
2
1.5
15 , ,·1.5
1 .
1.5
l '
~5 2
1 1.' 2
1'·,
1.5
1.5 2 '
1.5
2
1.5
1.5
42.57 56.76 34.29 ' 5U. 68.58 28.73 43.10 57.46 26.62 3,9.93
53:'24 32.36 48.54 64.72 32.71 49.07 65:42 32 .. 96
49.'44 65;92 ' 30.86 46.~9
61,72 31,21 46.82' 62.42 31.46 47.19 62.92 29.36 44.04 58.72 29.71 44.57 59.42 29.96 44.94, 59.92
: 42.80 64.20 85.60 43.82·
'65.73
87 .~
44.84 1)7.26 89,68 40.86 61.29 81.72 41.83 62.7S B3.66~
42.80 64.20 85.60 38.91 58:37 77,82
39,~
. 59.76
79.68 40.76 -
, 61'.14 81.si 38:91 '
58.37
I:: '''' I""
I~ , .%
!4,. 1. 4
"
I:: i:
[i :: .. I:,. 1 .. ,.
1
1 :: .. .%
I '''' 1 i "" '1 I ,,, 1.:4"
14"
14'" ! 4,, ·
I .. , ! .. " 1·10%
! ~cm !10'
I~: , L 11'" j 1.0%
! 10% 11,",-
I ·l~ 1 10% '
111)%
I:: : .~~
i iO% ! 10%
] UJ:16 i t""
!.:: 1
10"
il~ i .l~f ·
!u)" !U!% j 10%' i 10%
I ' ~: ~::~: :' I ~:
, 77.82
39.84
'40.16 'It'''' -61.14 i tO'll;
81:52 110" 1:7 .. 51 i 10%' 26.27 'II~ ' 35.0'2 ' i ~O%. 17.93' t 10% '26.90 ! 10%
35.86 r iOi' .: 18.34" l lO%'
27.51 - l lQ,6'
3,6:6If' ! ~=. 21.40 ' r , 32.10 i.1,",·
-. 42.80 i le%
21.'1 !''1O%' 32.87 i 10%
'43.82 i 10% ~l.42 110% 33.63 ilo,,"
. ~ 44.8,4 i I"" 25.29 j 10%
~~~:: 1-: 25.90 i 10% 38.85 ! 10% ' 51.80 i 10%
26.49 [I(J%:"
39.74 !-1~ Si:98 110% 29:18· '~. i 1~
! 10%' i 10%
! 10% [10%
. 43,'17 58:36 '29.88 44.82 59 .. 76 ! 10% 30.57 i 1O%
45.B6 ' 110'"
1.70 2.27 1:37 2.06
2.74 1.15 1.72 2.30 1.06
1.60 2.13 1.29 1.94 2.59 1.31 1.96' 2.62 1.32 1.98 2.64 1.23 1.85
2:47 1,25
1.87
2.50 1.26 1.89
2.5~
1.17
1.1.6
2.35 1:19
1.78 2.38 1.21? 1.~ ),."
4.28 6.42 '
8.5~ :ua '6'.57
8 .. 76 4 .. 48 ' 6.73 8.97 4.09 '
6.13 8.17
'.18 6:2'7 '
8.37 4.28 6.42 8.'56 3,89
~.84 7.78
3.98 5.98
'/97 4.08 6.11
8.lS
3." 5.84 7.78 3.98 5.98 . 7.97 4:08 6.11
~:15 ~.7~
. ~ , 1?3 3:50 1.-79 ' 2,69 ~
3:59 .1<.83' 2';75
3.67 . 2.14
3:21 4..2:8 2.19 3.29 4 .. 38 2.24 3.36'
4.48 2.53 3.79
5.06 2.59 3.89
5:1~ 2.65'
3.97 S:30 i.92 4.38 5:84
.2.~
4.48 5.98 3.06
4:59
"' I 2.55 :.: ~::
::=11 ~:~
2.59 3.45
6" 1 1,60 6" I 2.40
:","' .11' ~1~ 1.96
'" I" 2.94 • 6% 3.93
:'","11
• !::~ 3.96
6% . 1.85 6%! 2.78
~"' 11 3.70 6% 1 .. 87
':"1' 2.81 3.75 1.89 "I 2.83 ,
6~ 3.78
:11' . ~:: 6% 3.52 : '.' ~:~~ 5%;1 3.57
:: I ~~~
~ •.. ji . 3.60
"", o% l 0'" "" I ""I ': ,1 · :1 "" I "" I em!
:'1' 0% "'1 , "'" .. I .. I 0% 1 O% i 0%: "" I , "' i "'" ... 1 0%1 0%1 0% '1 .
0% ·1 em J
:1 :1 ~: ' I ''"' i ' : -1' 00& ·1 0' j 0%; 0%'·1 0%: ",. ,
.O')/;! 0% .! 0% .1 0%' j 0%1 em ! ",,! , O'X. i
""I "". 1
"" I O%! : 1 ;;. ! O%. j 0% .! md 0%1
: .! em ! ",,1 0% .j
4.S8 4.S8 5.1S 5:15 5.15 5.15 ' 5.15 5.15 5.15 S,lS n ,5-2:90 2.90 2.90 2 .9<)
2.90 ' 2 .9<)
i ,9O '. 2;90 ' 2:90 2:90 2.90 \ 2:90' 2 .. 90 ' -2 .. 90 2:90 ' 2:90 2.90 2.90 2:90 2.9<)
2.90 2.90' ..
1;90 2.90 f90 t9<) i96' 2.40.
3:60 4.80 , 2.40. 3,GO
4.80 ·
2.40 3.60
4:80 . 2.40' 3:60 ' 4:80
240 3.60
'.SO 2.40 3.60 4.80 2;40
3 .. ~ 4:80
2.40
3:60 4.80 2..40 3.60 .
4:8Q 2,40
. 3.60
4.80 2.40 3.60 4.80 2:40 3.60 4:80 2.40 '
3.?0 4.80 2;40
3 .. 60 .
. 4:110
3.60 . 4,80 '
2.40 3.60 4.80 2.40 3.60
4.80 2.40 3.60
4.80 2.ito 3.60
4 ~80 2.40 3,60
4.80 i40 3:60 4:80: 2.40 3.60
4.80 ' 2.40 3.60 4,80 2.40 3.60
4.02 4.02 4.86 4.86 4.86 4.86 4.86 4.86 4.86 4 .~6
4.86 7.00
7.00 7.00 7.00 7.00 7 ,00
7.00 7.00
7.00 7.00 7.00 7.00 7.00
7.00 7.00 7,00
7.00
7.00 7.00
7.00 '7.00
· 7.00 7.00 7.00 7.00
7.00
7·09 6,22 9.33
12.44 6.35 9.53
12.7~
6.48 9.72 iZ-:96 6.22 9:33
12.44 635
'. 9.53 12.70 '6.48'
' 9:12 12.,96 6.22
.933
6.35 .9.53
' 12.70
6.48 9:72
u.~ 6.22
' 9.33 12,44 6:35 '
9.53 12.70 6,48 9.7,i -
12.96 ~:22 -
. 933 '
12.44 6.3'.5'
' . .. 9.53
12:70 6.48 9.72
. 12.96 6.22 9.33
12 .. 44 635
9.53 12.10 6.48 9.72
12.96 6.22 ' 9.33 12.44 6.35 9.53
6.48 9.72 12.96 6.i2
t 9.33 11.44 ' 6.35 9 .. 53 12.70 6.48 9.72
1.04 .
1,04 '.
1 ... 20 . 1.20 1.20 . 1.07 1.07 1,07 1.03 1 .. 03
1.03'. 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65 0,65 0.65 O.pS· 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65 0:65 0.65 0.65
0 .6~ 0.65 0.65 0.65 0,65 0.65 0.65'
0\65 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65 0.65
1 ... 93 2.9Q
.3.8~
1:93 2.90 3.86
1.93 2.90
3.86 1.93 2,90
. 3.86
1.9,3 .2.90 3:8,6 1.93
2.~0
3.86 "1:>93
2.90
, 3.86
1.93 '2.9'0.
3:86'. 1.93 '
-1.90'~
.3!86 ' 1 :93 '2:90 ',
3:86 1.93 2.90
. 3.'$6
1.93
2.96 3:86 1:93 2.90' .'
3.86 " 1.93 2:90 iS6 1:93 2.9O ~
3.86 1,93 2.90 .3:86 1.93
'.9<)
3 :8~ ' '" _1.93 '
2.90 -
3:86
1.93 2,90 3.'86 1,93 . 2.90 .
'3.86 1:93 2.90 3.86 1.93
2.~0 3.86' 1.93
' .9<)
3." 1.93 ·' 2.90'
56.47 7208: 48,93 67.79 86.65 42.68 58:48
-74.29 40.31 54.96 69.60 46.1~
63.94 81'.74 46.53 64.52 82,51
46.81 64.93 83:06 44.50 61.47 78:44 ' 44.88 62.05 79.21 45 .. 1'6 62:46 79.7~
42 .. 85 58."99 75:14 43 .. 23 59.57 75.91 43:51
59:~ 7~6 .46
57.63 86.45
11~.2~ 58.88 88:33
60:13
90~11 120~27, 5S.50',' 83:-:25 Uh:99: 56.69
-· 85.05' li3}9 57.89 86.84 115.78~ 53:35-,80 .. 03
' 106,70
54.50 af.77 -
109,01 ' . 55:65
44.72'
59.62 30.40
~5.61
.60.81
30.98 46.48 61:97 34.09
51.14 68.18 " .
,34:78 52.18
, 69.56 35.47<'
5i2i' 70.94 38 .. 37 · 57:56 .. 76.74 39.17 58.77 78:34 39~95 59.93 79.90 42.65 63,98
a5.30 43:55 65.33 87.10 44.44 66.66
0,20 0.20 0.20 . 0.20 0.20 0.20 0,20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 O.i'o 0,20 0,20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 · 0.20 0,20 0.20
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20' o.iO ·
O.to 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.2Q 0:20
,0,20 , 0.20
0.20 0,20 0:20 0.20 0:.20' 0,20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0,20
0.20
0.20
0 .. 20
0.20 0.20 0.20
'0.20 0.20
9·20
0.20 0.20 0.20 '
0.26 0:20 0,2"0 . 0.20 0.20 0.20 o.io <!.2'o · 0:20 0:20 0:20 0.20' 0.20 r
0:20
0:20 0:20 0.20 0.20 0.20 '
0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 .
0.20 0.20 0.20 0:20 0.20 0.20
0.20 0.20
0.20' 0.20
0.20 0.20'
0.20 0.20
0.85
0.85
, 9·85
0;85
0.85
0.85
0,85
0.85
0.85
0.86
. 0.89
\ '
l
0:.85
0'.86
0.89
0.B5
0,86
O.~
0.85
0.86
0.89
0.43
0.43
0.43
0.43
"0.43
0.43 '
0.47
, 0.43
0.46
0.47
0,43
0.46
0.47
0.43 .
0.46
0;4i
OPG Da"rin(t,O!I~ l!~furbl~~lTlI!nt Prou~ Turb1neGener.l101'Project
Re-Filed: 2017-02-10 EB-2016-0152 Exhibit D2-2-3 Attachment 9
Page 420 of 573