802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver,...

103
802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda John Messenger – IEEE 802.1 Acting WG Chair [email protected]

Transcript of 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver,...

Page 1: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada

Closing Agenda

John Messenger ndash IEEE 8021 Acting WG ChairJMessengeradvaopticalcom

8021 plenary agendaMonday opening Call for Patents Participation guidelines Administrative Membership status Future Meetings 802 reports Sanity check ndash current

projects Incoming Liaisons TG agendas

Thursday closing Call for Patents Membership status Future Meetings Sanity check ndash current projects 802 reports TG reports Outgoing Liaisons Motions for EC Motions for 8021

2

The IEEE-SA strongly recommends that at each WG meeting the chair or a designeebull Show slides 1 through 4 of this presentationbull Advise the WG attendees that

bull IEEErsquos patent policy is described in Clause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawsbull Early identification of patent claims which may be essential for the use of standards under

development is strongly encouraged bull There may be Essential Patent Claims of which IEEE is not aware Additionally neither IEEE the WG

nor the WG Chair can ensure the accuracy or completeness of any assurance or whether any such assurance is in fact of a Patent Claim that is essential for the use of the standard under development

bull Instruct the WG Secretary to record in the minutes of the relevant WG meetingbull That the foregoing information was provided and that slides 1 through 4 (and this slide 0 if applicable)

were shown bull That the chair or designee provided an opportunity for participants to identify patent claim(s)patent

application claim(s) andor the holder of patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) of which the participant is personally aware and that may be essential for the use of that standard

bull Any responses that were given specifically the patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) andor the holder of the patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) that were identified (if any) and by whom

bull The WG Chair shall ensure that a request is made to any identified holders of potential essential patent claim(s) to complete and submit a Letter of Assurancebull It is recommended that the WG Chair review the guidance in IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual635 and in FAQs 14 and 15 on inclusion of potential Essential Patent Claims by incorporation or by reference

Note WG includes Working Groups Task Groups and other standards-developing committees with a PAR approved by the IEEE-SA Standards Board

Instructions for the WG Chair

(Optional to be shown)

Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE

bull Participants shall inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of each holder of any potential Essential Patent Claims of which they are personally aware if the claims are owned or controlled by the participant or the entity the participant is from employed by or otherwise represents

bull Participants should inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of any other holders of potential Essential Patent Claims

Early identification of holders of potential Essential Patent Claims is encouraged

Slide 1

Ways to inform IEEE

bull Cause an LOA to be submitted to the IEEE-SA (patcomieeeorg) or

bull Provide the chair of this group with the identity of the holder(s) of any and all such claims as soon as possible or

bull Speak up now and respond to this Call for Potentially Essential PatentsIf anyone in this meeting is personally aware of the holder of any patent claims that are potentially essential to implementation of the proposed standard(s) under consideration by this group and that are not already the subject of an Accepted Letter of Assurance please respond at this time by providing relevant information to the WG Chair

Slide 2

Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetingsbull All IEEE-SA standards meetings shall be conducted in compliance

with all applicable laws including antitrust and competition laws

bull Donrsquot discuss the interpretation validity or essentiality of patentspatent claims

bull Donrsquot discuss specific license rates terms or conditionsbull Relative costs of different technical approaches that include relative costs of

patent licensing terms may be discussed in standards development meetings

bull Technical considerations remain the primary focus

bull Donrsquot discuss or engage in the fixing of product prices allocation of customers or division of sales markets

bull Donrsquot discuss the status or substance of ongoing or threatened litigation

bull Donrsquot be silent if inappropriate topics are discussed hellip do formally object

---------------------------------------------------------------For more details see IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual clause 5310 and

Antitrust and Competition Policy What You Need to Know at httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesantitrustpdf

Slide 3

Patent-related information

The patent policy and the procedures used to execute that policy are documented in the

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesbylawssect6-7html6)

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesopmansect6html63)

Material about the patent policy is available at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcommaterialshtml

If you have questions contact the IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee Administrator at patcomieeeorg

Slide 4

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 2: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

8021 plenary agendaMonday opening Call for Patents Participation guidelines Administrative Membership status Future Meetings 802 reports Sanity check ndash current

projects Incoming Liaisons TG agendas

Thursday closing Call for Patents Membership status Future Meetings Sanity check ndash current projects 802 reports TG reports Outgoing Liaisons Motions for EC Motions for 8021

2

The IEEE-SA strongly recommends that at each WG meeting the chair or a designeebull Show slides 1 through 4 of this presentationbull Advise the WG attendees that

bull IEEErsquos patent policy is described in Clause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawsbull Early identification of patent claims which may be essential for the use of standards under

development is strongly encouraged bull There may be Essential Patent Claims of which IEEE is not aware Additionally neither IEEE the WG

nor the WG Chair can ensure the accuracy or completeness of any assurance or whether any such assurance is in fact of a Patent Claim that is essential for the use of the standard under development

bull Instruct the WG Secretary to record in the minutes of the relevant WG meetingbull That the foregoing information was provided and that slides 1 through 4 (and this slide 0 if applicable)

were shown bull That the chair or designee provided an opportunity for participants to identify patent claim(s)patent

application claim(s) andor the holder of patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) of which the participant is personally aware and that may be essential for the use of that standard

bull Any responses that were given specifically the patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) andor the holder of the patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) that were identified (if any) and by whom

bull The WG Chair shall ensure that a request is made to any identified holders of potential essential patent claim(s) to complete and submit a Letter of Assurancebull It is recommended that the WG Chair review the guidance in IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual635 and in FAQs 14 and 15 on inclusion of potential Essential Patent Claims by incorporation or by reference

Note WG includes Working Groups Task Groups and other standards-developing committees with a PAR approved by the IEEE-SA Standards Board

Instructions for the WG Chair

(Optional to be shown)

Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE

bull Participants shall inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of each holder of any potential Essential Patent Claims of which they are personally aware if the claims are owned or controlled by the participant or the entity the participant is from employed by or otherwise represents

bull Participants should inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of any other holders of potential Essential Patent Claims

Early identification of holders of potential Essential Patent Claims is encouraged

Slide 1

Ways to inform IEEE

bull Cause an LOA to be submitted to the IEEE-SA (patcomieeeorg) or

bull Provide the chair of this group with the identity of the holder(s) of any and all such claims as soon as possible or

bull Speak up now and respond to this Call for Potentially Essential PatentsIf anyone in this meeting is personally aware of the holder of any patent claims that are potentially essential to implementation of the proposed standard(s) under consideration by this group and that are not already the subject of an Accepted Letter of Assurance please respond at this time by providing relevant information to the WG Chair

Slide 2

Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetingsbull All IEEE-SA standards meetings shall be conducted in compliance

with all applicable laws including antitrust and competition laws

bull Donrsquot discuss the interpretation validity or essentiality of patentspatent claims

bull Donrsquot discuss specific license rates terms or conditionsbull Relative costs of different technical approaches that include relative costs of

patent licensing terms may be discussed in standards development meetings

bull Technical considerations remain the primary focus

bull Donrsquot discuss or engage in the fixing of product prices allocation of customers or division of sales markets

bull Donrsquot discuss the status or substance of ongoing or threatened litigation

bull Donrsquot be silent if inappropriate topics are discussed hellip do formally object

---------------------------------------------------------------For more details see IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual clause 5310 and

Antitrust and Competition Policy What You Need to Know at httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesantitrustpdf

Slide 3

Patent-related information

The patent policy and the procedures used to execute that policy are documented in the

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesbylawssect6-7html6)

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesopmansect6html63)

Material about the patent policy is available at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcommaterialshtml

If you have questions contact the IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee Administrator at patcomieeeorg

Slide 4

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 3: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

The IEEE-SA strongly recommends that at each WG meeting the chair or a designeebull Show slides 1 through 4 of this presentationbull Advise the WG attendees that

bull IEEErsquos patent policy is described in Clause 6 of the IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylawsbull Early identification of patent claims which may be essential for the use of standards under

development is strongly encouraged bull There may be Essential Patent Claims of which IEEE is not aware Additionally neither IEEE the WG

nor the WG Chair can ensure the accuracy or completeness of any assurance or whether any such assurance is in fact of a Patent Claim that is essential for the use of the standard under development

bull Instruct the WG Secretary to record in the minutes of the relevant WG meetingbull That the foregoing information was provided and that slides 1 through 4 (and this slide 0 if applicable)

were shown bull That the chair or designee provided an opportunity for participants to identify patent claim(s)patent

application claim(s) andor the holder of patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) of which the participant is personally aware and that may be essential for the use of that standard

bull Any responses that were given specifically the patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) andor the holder of the patent claim(s)patent application claim(s) that were identified (if any) and by whom

bull The WG Chair shall ensure that a request is made to any identified holders of potential essential patent claim(s) to complete and submit a Letter of Assurancebull It is recommended that the WG Chair review the guidance in IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual635 and in FAQs 14 and 15 on inclusion of potential Essential Patent Claims by incorporation or by reference

Note WG includes Working Groups Task Groups and other standards-developing committees with a PAR approved by the IEEE-SA Standards Board

Instructions for the WG Chair

(Optional to be shown)

Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE

bull Participants shall inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of each holder of any potential Essential Patent Claims of which they are personally aware if the claims are owned or controlled by the participant or the entity the participant is from employed by or otherwise represents

bull Participants should inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of any other holders of potential Essential Patent Claims

Early identification of holders of potential Essential Patent Claims is encouraged

Slide 1

Ways to inform IEEE

bull Cause an LOA to be submitted to the IEEE-SA (patcomieeeorg) or

bull Provide the chair of this group with the identity of the holder(s) of any and all such claims as soon as possible or

bull Speak up now and respond to this Call for Potentially Essential PatentsIf anyone in this meeting is personally aware of the holder of any patent claims that are potentially essential to implementation of the proposed standard(s) under consideration by this group and that are not already the subject of an Accepted Letter of Assurance please respond at this time by providing relevant information to the WG Chair

Slide 2

Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetingsbull All IEEE-SA standards meetings shall be conducted in compliance

with all applicable laws including antitrust and competition laws

bull Donrsquot discuss the interpretation validity or essentiality of patentspatent claims

bull Donrsquot discuss specific license rates terms or conditionsbull Relative costs of different technical approaches that include relative costs of

patent licensing terms may be discussed in standards development meetings

bull Technical considerations remain the primary focus

bull Donrsquot discuss or engage in the fixing of product prices allocation of customers or division of sales markets

bull Donrsquot discuss the status or substance of ongoing or threatened litigation

bull Donrsquot be silent if inappropriate topics are discussed hellip do formally object

---------------------------------------------------------------For more details see IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual clause 5310 and

Antitrust and Competition Policy What You Need to Know at httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesantitrustpdf

Slide 3

Patent-related information

The patent policy and the procedures used to execute that policy are documented in the

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesbylawssect6-7html6)

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesopmansect6html63)

Material about the patent policy is available at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcommaterialshtml

If you have questions contact the IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee Administrator at patcomieeeorg

Slide 4

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 4: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE

bull Participants shall inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of each holder of any potential Essential Patent Claims of which they are personally aware if the claims are owned or controlled by the participant or the entity the participant is from employed by or otherwise represents

bull Participants should inform the IEEE (or cause the IEEE to be informed) of the identity of any other holders of potential Essential Patent Claims

Early identification of holders of potential Essential Patent Claims is encouraged

Slide 1

Ways to inform IEEE

bull Cause an LOA to be submitted to the IEEE-SA (patcomieeeorg) or

bull Provide the chair of this group with the identity of the holder(s) of any and all such claims as soon as possible or

bull Speak up now and respond to this Call for Potentially Essential PatentsIf anyone in this meeting is personally aware of the holder of any patent claims that are potentially essential to implementation of the proposed standard(s) under consideration by this group and that are not already the subject of an Accepted Letter of Assurance please respond at this time by providing relevant information to the WG Chair

Slide 2

Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetingsbull All IEEE-SA standards meetings shall be conducted in compliance

with all applicable laws including antitrust and competition laws

bull Donrsquot discuss the interpretation validity or essentiality of patentspatent claims

bull Donrsquot discuss specific license rates terms or conditionsbull Relative costs of different technical approaches that include relative costs of

patent licensing terms may be discussed in standards development meetings

bull Technical considerations remain the primary focus

bull Donrsquot discuss or engage in the fixing of product prices allocation of customers or division of sales markets

bull Donrsquot discuss the status or substance of ongoing or threatened litigation

bull Donrsquot be silent if inappropriate topics are discussed hellip do formally object

---------------------------------------------------------------For more details see IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual clause 5310 and

Antitrust and Competition Policy What You Need to Know at httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesantitrustpdf

Slide 3

Patent-related information

The patent policy and the procedures used to execute that policy are documented in the

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesbylawssect6-7html6)

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesopmansect6html63)

Material about the patent policy is available at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcommaterialshtml

If you have questions contact the IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee Administrator at patcomieeeorg

Slide 4

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 5: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Ways to inform IEEE

bull Cause an LOA to be submitted to the IEEE-SA (patcomieeeorg) or

bull Provide the chair of this group with the identity of the holder(s) of any and all such claims as soon as possible or

bull Speak up now and respond to this Call for Potentially Essential PatentsIf anyone in this meeting is personally aware of the holder of any patent claims that are potentially essential to implementation of the proposed standard(s) under consideration by this group and that are not already the subject of an Accepted Letter of Assurance please respond at this time by providing relevant information to the WG Chair

Slide 2

Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetingsbull All IEEE-SA standards meetings shall be conducted in compliance

with all applicable laws including antitrust and competition laws

bull Donrsquot discuss the interpretation validity or essentiality of patentspatent claims

bull Donrsquot discuss specific license rates terms or conditionsbull Relative costs of different technical approaches that include relative costs of

patent licensing terms may be discussed in standards development meetings

bull Technical considerations remain the primary focus

bull Donrsquot discuss or engage in the fixing of product prices allocation of customers or division of sales markets

bull Donrsquot discuss the status or substance of ongoing or threatened litigation

bull Donrsquot be silent if inappropriate topics are discussed hellip do formally object

---------------------------------------------------------------For more details see IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual clause 5310 and

Antitrust and Competition Policy What You Need to Know at httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesantitrustpdf

Slide 3

Patent-related information

The patent policy and the procedures used to execute that policy are documented in the

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesbylawssect6-7html6)

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesopmansect6html63)

Material about the patent policy is available at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcommaterialshtml

If you have questions contact the IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee Administrator at patcomieeeorg

Slide 4

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 6: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetingsbull All IEEE-SA standards meetings shall be conducted in compliance

with all applicable laws including antitrust and competition laws

bull Donrsquot discuss the interpretation validity or essentiality of patentspatent claims

bull Donrsquot discuss specific license rates terms or conditionsbull Relative costs of different technical approaches that include relative costs of

patent licensing terms may be discussed in standards development meetings

bull Technical considerations remain the primary focus

bull Donrsquot discuss or engage in the fixing of product prices allocation of customers or division of sales markets

bull Donrsquot discuss the status or substance of ongoing or threatened litigation

bull Donrsquot be silent if inappropriate topics are discussed hellip do formally object

---------------------------------------------------------------For more details see IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual clause 5310 and

Antitrust and Competition Policy What You Need to Know at httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesantitrustpdf

Slide 3

Patent-related information

The patent policy and the procedures used to execute that policy are documented in the

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesbylawssect6-7html6)

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesopmansect6html63)

Material about the patent policy is available at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcommaterialshtml

If you have questions contact the IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee Administrator at patcomieeeorg

Slide 4

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 7: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Patent-related information

The patent policy and the procedures used to execute that policy are documented in the

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesbylawssect6-7html6)

bull IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual(httpstandardsieeeorgdeveloppoliciesopmansect6html63)

Material about the patent policy is available at httpstandardsieeeorgaboutsasbpatcommaterialshtml

If you have questions contact the IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee Administrator at patcomieeeorg

Slide 4

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 8: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Decorum

Press (ie anyone reporting publicly on this meeting) are to announce their presence (SASB Ops Manual 5333)

Photography or recording by permission only (SASB Ops Manual 5332)

Cell phone ringers off please

8

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 9: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

8021 officers Officers

ndash (Chair Glenn Parsons)ndash Vice Chair and acting Chair John Messengerndash Recording Secretary and acting Vice Chair Jessy Rouyerndash Security TG Chair Mick Seamanndash TSN TG Chair Jaacutenos Farkas

bull TSN TG Vice Chair and Secretary Craig Guntherndash IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project chair Ludwig Winkel

bull IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project secretary Josef Dorr ndash OmniRAN TG Chair Max Riegelndash Maintenance TG chair Paul Congdonndash NEND ICA chair Roger Marksndash YANGsters chair Scott Mansfieldndash Maintenance of website Paul Unbehagenndash Maintenance of Email exploder Hal Keen amp Mark Hantel

Websitendash httpwwwieee802org1

9

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 10: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

The following are 8021 voters (61)

10

Assmann RalfBierschenk JensBoiger ChristianBottorff Paul Canchi RadhakrishnaChen DavidChen FengCheng WeiyingCongdon PaulCummings RodneyDorr JosefElbakoury HeshamEnzinger ThomasFarkas JanosFinn NormanGarner Geoffrey Gray Eric Gunther CraigGutierrez MarinaHaddock StephenHantel Mark

Holness MarcItaya SatokoKarl MichaelKehrer StephanKoto HajimeMangin ChristopheMansfield ScottMaruhashi KenichiMcintosh JamesMcmillan LarryMessenger John Mustala TeroOhsawa TomokiOhue HiroshiPannell Donald RParsons Glenn Pienciak WalterPotts MichaelQiu WeiRandall KarenRiegel Maximilian

Rouyer JessySato AtsushiSchewe FrankSeaman MichaelSeewald MaikSpecht JohannesStanica MariusSteindl GuenterUnbehagen PaulWang XinyuanWang TongtongWang HaoWeber KarlWeis BrianWinkel LudwigWoods JordonYamaura TakahiroYu XiangZein Nader

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 11: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

The following became voting members this week

Dorr JosefEnzinger ThomasMcMillan LarrySeewald MaikStanica MariusSteindl Guenter

11

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 12: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week

12

Ito Yoshihiro

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 13: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week

13

Bechtel GordonBelliardi RudyChang XinChen LihaoChou VincentDeLaOlivaDelgado

AntonioEllegaard LarsFan XiaojingFang YonggangFontaine Mickael

Gravel MarkHarima TaroHasegawa AkioHemmer DavidHotta YoshifumiKondo KenjiKondo YoshihisaLi DongOhori FumikoOsagawa DaisukeShen Li

Sun WenhaoTarui IsaoTing AoWamsser ReinerWood GraemeYu YiZhang JiayiZuponcic Steven

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 14: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this weekNone

14

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 15: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

15

None (but warnings will be issued)

The following will lose their voting membership at the end of the plenary through lack of qualifying WG letter ballot voting

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 16: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

80211 Reciprocal credit

8021 voters may get credit for attending any 80211

8021 voting members who are also 80211 voting members may get a popup in IMAT each time they register attendance to ask which group they are accumulating credit for this plenary

8021 attendance credit will not be granted from a voter who attended only 80211 meetings

16

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 17: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Future interim meetings May 20-24 2019

ndash Ethernet Alliance in Salt Lake City USAbull Hotel cutoff April 19th Registration deadline April 23rd

September 16-20 2019 ndash ADVA Optical Networking hosting in Edinburgh

September 23 2019ndash Proposal TSN interim meeting for 8021DG

hosted by GM in Detroit prior to IEEE EthernetIP Automotive Tech Day

Jan 20-24 2020 (workshop Jan 25)ndash Proposal 80238021ITU-T for Geneva CH

May 18-22 2020ndash Ethernet Alliance in North America

September 2020ndash Potential Huawei proposal for China 17

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 18: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023 Hosts International Telecommunication Union (ITU)

Nokia and IEEE 8023 Dates 20-24 January 2020 Location ITU Headquarters (Geneva Switzerland) Meeting Fee None (but you buy your own breakfast

coffee) No designated meeting hotel you are free to use

ndash Any of the ITU negotiated rates httpwwwituinttravelindexhtml

ndash Your company negotiated hotel dealsndash Your favorite travel website

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 19: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided

IEEE 8021ndash Tower Room C1 (108 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room H1 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms L1 (30 seats)

IEEE 8023ndash Tower Room A (82 seats)ndash Tower Rooms Popov 1 (124 seats) and Popov 2 (124 seats)

(combine for 248 seats)ndash Tower Room C2 (108 seats) ndash Montbrillant Room H2 (50 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms K1 (50 seats) and K2 (50 seats) (combine for

100 seats)ndash Montbrillant Room L2 (30 seats)ndash Montbrillant Rooms M1 (30 seats) and M2 (30 seats) (combine for

60 seats)

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 20: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings

Joint IEEE 8021 8023 and ITU-T Study Group 15 WorkshopSaturday 25 January 2020 Topics expected to includendash High Speed and Long-Reach Optical Interfaces (IEEE P8023cn

P8023ct ITU-T Q615 Q1115)ndash Passive Optical Networking (IEEE P8023ca P8023cp P8023cs

ITU-T Q215)ndash 5G Mobile Transport (IEEE 8021CM ITU-T Q215 Q1115 Q1315)ndash YANG and data modeling

ITU-T Study Group 15 Plenary Meeting ndash 27 January-7 February 2020

(workshop of January 2018 httpswwwituintenITU-TWorkshops-and-Seminars20180127PagesProgrammeaspx)

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 21: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

This plenary survey Do you like this venue

ndash Yes 56_ No 2_ Did you like the social

ndash Yes 54_ No 0_ Did you go to the social

ndash Yes 58_ No 6_

21

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 22: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Future plenaries July 14-19 2019 ndash Vienna Austria

ndash Austria Congress Centre November 10-15 2019 ndash Waikoloa HI USA

ndash Hilton Waikoloa Village March 15-20 2020 ndash Atlanta GA USA

ndash Hilton Atlanta July 12-17 2020 ndash Montreal QC Canada

ndash Sheraton Montreal November 8-13 2020 ndash Bangkok Thailand

ndash Bangkok Marriott Marquis Queenrsquos Park March 14-19 2021 ndash Denver CO USA

ndash Hyatt Regency Denver

22

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 23: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Promotional Activities

TSN has been promoted through various conferences and publications

Upcoming relevant events includendash ISPCS September 22-27 2019 in Portland

Oregon USAbull Contact Bob Noseworthy Presentation

ndash IEEE-SA Ethernet amp IP Automotive Technology Day September 24-25 2019 in Detroit MI USA

bull Contact Mike Potts Craig Gunther and John Messengerndash TSNA Conference 2019 October 8-9 2019 in Bad

Homburg Germanybull Contact Craig Gunther Presentation

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 24: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Sanity check ndash current workload

24

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 25: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

8021 plenary schedule

25

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs KEY1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg

1930-2000 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG

2030-2100 SEC Security

2100-2130 OR OmniRAN

2130-22002200-2230

NEND ICA

Break Break

ITU

Break

MTN TG

Break

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 3 OR

Lunch (Editors Meeting)

Trk 4 SEC

MONDAY

Break

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 4 SEC

Opening 8021 plenary

Break

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

EC

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

V2TUESDAY

8021 tracks and timesTHURSDAY FRIDAY

Lunch

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 1 TSN

WEDNESDAY

Trk3 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Social event

Break

Trk 2 60802

Break

Closing 8021 plenary

Break

Closing 8021 plenaryTrk 1 TSN

Lunch

Trk 2 60802

Trk 4 SEC

Break

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Break

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

Closing 802 EC

Trk 2 60802

Trk 3 OR

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802

802 NEND ICA

Trk 4 SEC

Trk 1 TSN

Trk 2 60802

Trk 1 TSN

Joint 80224YANGsters

8021

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
V2 IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSION
Vancouver BC Canada
March 10-15 2019
8021 tracks and times
SUNDAY SUN MONDAY TUESDAY WEDNESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY
0700-0730
0730-0800
0800-0830 Trk 1 TSN EC MTN TG Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 NEND ICA ITU Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
0830-0900
0900-0930 Trk3 SEC
0930-1000
1000-1030 Break Break Break Break Break
1030-1100 Opening 8021 plenary Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802
1100-1130
1130-1200
1200-1230 Lunch
1230-1300 Lunch Lunch (Editors Meeting) Lunch Lunch
1300-1330 Trk 1 amp 2TSN amp 60802 Closing 802 EC
1330-1400 Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 3 OR Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1400-1430
1430-1500
1500-1530
1530-1600 Break Break Break Break
1600-1630 Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 4 SEC Trk 1 TSN Trk 2 60802 Trk 4 SEC Closing 8021 plenary
1630-1700
1700-1730
1730-1800
1800-1830 TG Break Joint 80224 YANGsters Break Break
1830-1900 Chairs 802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it Social event KEY
1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time Sensitive Netwkg
1930-2000 802 NEND ICA 60802 IECIEEE 60802 JP
2000-2030 MTN TG Maintenance TG
2030-2100 SEC Security
2100-2130 OR OmniRAN
2130-2200
2200-2230
Page 26: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

802 reports IETF SC

ndash Did not meet JTC1 SC ITU SC

ndash Did not meet

26

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 27: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

802 reports 802 Task Force

ndash The 802 Task Force meetings will become teleconferences with a follow-up at SASB meetings

ndash Initial call will be 28 May 2019 11am-noon ETndash IEEE SA tools update will be given at SASB next weekndash Web conferencing do we want to switch to WebExndash Bulk Framemaker licensing will be investigated by IEEE

27

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 28: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

TG reports

Maintenance Nendica OmniRAN Security TSN YANGsters

29

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 29: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report

March 14 2019Paul Congdon

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 30: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Maintenance Item Status Update

bull Updated maintenance sessions slides show detailed progress and statusndash httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-

congdon-session-0319-v02pdf

bull Progressed Summary ndash 1 technical experts review -gt complete then ballotndash 1 received -gt complete then ballotndash 4 received -gt technical experts review

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 31: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status

bull 28 standards currently PSDO approvedbull 4 standards in PSDO adoption processbull 3 standards in PSDO 60-day pre-ballotsbull 3 standards queued up to send to PSDO (already approved by WG to send)bull 1 standard to send for informationbull 0 Motions for documents sent for adoptionbull 2 Motions to approve liaison response to comments

bull IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-A2015FDAmd 2)bull IEEE 8021Q (ISOIECIEEE 8802-1Q2016)

bull 2 responses under development by Security TG ndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018 ndash comment responsendash IEEE 8021AE-2018ndash comment response

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 32: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Maintenance Next Steps

bull Proposing teleconferences to progress 8021CB items and any new businessndash 14th May 2019 at 11am ESTndash 9th July 2019 at 11am EST

bull Review Security TG responses to JTC1SC6 CN comments in May to be approved in Julyndash IEEE 8021Xck-2018ndash IEEE 8021AE-2018

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 33: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Nendica Meeting Report March 2019 IEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo ICA Tuesday 1930-2130 Wednesday 0800-1000 Detailed agenda 8021-19-0024-00 23 people logged Agreed again (1800) to forward the ICAID renewal request

proposing extension to March 2021ndash No changes since no comments were received

Agreed to initiate second FFIoT Call for Commentsndash to begin after ICAID is formally renewed

Data Center Networks contribution presented ndash Discussion about followup possible NANOG presentations

80221 Study Group (Virtual Reality) presentation Scheduled teleconferences

ndash 2019-04-10 1100 ET (Data Center Networks focus)ndash 2019-04-18 0900 ET (FFIoT focus) ndash 2019-05-07 0900 ET (FFIoT focus)ndash Meeting at May Wireless and May 8021 Interim

34

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 34: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

OmniRAN closing report

35

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 35: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th

P8021CF ndash Forwarded to REVCOM for approval on March 20th

ndash Initial publicity actions plannedbull Contribution to the IEEE beyond standards blogbull Short notice to IEEE Communications Standards Magazinebull Updated introductory slideset on 8021 websitebull Full article for IEEE Communications Standards Magazine

P8021CQ ndash Local address assignment protocolndash Potential alignment with IEEE 1722 MAAP

bull Considerations of reuse of MAAP concepts for P8021CQbull Liaison to IEEE 1722 drafted to determine potential cooperation

ndash ToC establishedbull Unicast amp multicast stateful amp stateless

ndash Deployment in 80211bull Reviewed proposed additions to PAD

ITU-T JCA IMT2020ndash Liaison to clean up list of 8021 standards on ITU-T website

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 36: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Looking forward to next sessions OmniRAN TG will not meet in May but will progress

P8021CQ through a series of conference callsndash Allowing all interested parties to attend and contribute

bull Interest from TSN participants P60802 participants and 80211 participants

Envisioned topicsndash P8021CQ

bull Create initial draft specificationbull Follow up on cooperation with IEEE 1722bull Interaction with IEEE 80211 on solution for WLAN

Upcoming conference callsndash Apr 5th 2019 0900AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26th 2019 0900AM ET 15hr

bull Mainly covering 1CQ contributions

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 37: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Report ndash Security1 ISOIEC JTC1 PSDO processing hellip

bull Reviewed status FDIS pre-ballots closed 11th March - 8021AE-Rev 8021Q-Rev 8021Xck

Response to 8021Q-Rev prepared will be Maintenance TG motion2 P802E Privacy (Recommended Practice for 802)

bull D13 Task Group ballot resolution Concluded will request 8021 approval to go to WG ballot resolve in July

3 P8021X-Rev Port-Based Network Access Controlbull D10 Working Group ballot resolution (resolution not yet concluded) Ballot passed number of detailed YANG comments there will be one or more recirculation

ballots prior to the July plenary4 IEEE 8021AEmdash2018 Corrigenda

Reviewed proposed PAR motion to request forwarding to NesCom5 Traffic flow privacy

bull docs2019new-fedyk-traffic-flow-security-0219pdf Discussed Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

6 AOBbull Brief review of security aspects of docs2019new-seaman-cut-through-scissors-

0119-v01pdf7 Future meetingsteleconferences

Will meet during the May interim (though attendance is expected to be low) Telecons to finalize 1X-RevD10 ballot resolution prior to recirculation

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 38: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

8021 TSN TG Agenda

39- Note that the TSN agenda is subject to change eg depending on progress etc- TSN TG agenda details are available at httpieee802org1tsntsn-task-group-agenda

IEEE 802 PLENARY SESSIONVancouver BC CanadaMarch 10-15 2019

SUN0700-0730 0730-08000800-08300830-09000900-09300930-10001000-10301030-11001100-11301130-12001200-12301230-13001300-13301330-14001400-14301430-15001500-15301530-16001600-16301630-17001700-17301730-18001800-1830 TG1830-1900 Chairs1900-1930 Mtg TSN Time-Sensitive Ntwking1930-2000 IECIEEE 608022000-2030 MTN Maintenance TG2030-21002100-21302130-22002200-2230

Lunch (Editors meeting)

802 NEND ICA

Lunch

P8021QcwP8021Qcr

TSN ConfigurationFlexible Factory

24 - TSNYANGsters

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021CSP8021QddP8021QczP8021CBdb

KEY

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JPliaisons

motionsP8021AS-Rev

Opening 8021 plenary

Lunch

P8021Qcx

Break

802 Tutorial Spectrum - Use it or Share it

WEDNESDAY

Break

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021QcjP8021CS

P8021CQP8021AS-Rev

Trk A60802 JP

Trk BP8021DG

P8021AS-RevBreak

8021 Time-Sensitive Networking (TSN) TGV3

Social event

Break

Whole TSN IECIEEE 60802 JP

Closing 8021 plenary

Lunch

TUESDAY THURSDAY FRIDAY

Whole TSNIECIEEE 60802 JPBreak

MONDAY

Lunch

MTN

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 39: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Management Address Grouping (1Qcx) Comment discussionndash Reviewed the current up to date proposal with the results from the email discussions

IETF Module on Ethertypesndash Brief recap of the issuendash Postponed to next meeting

IEEE Website for YANG modulesndash Discussed what is required and what is missing to set up a page for YANG modules on

the IEEE 8021 Websitendash The discussion directly tied into the next topic

YANG Catalog Issuesndash Brief recap of the current statusndash Discussed on how to proceed with the open topicsndash Decision process needs to be further clarified to solve the open topics for this topic as

well as the Website questions IEEE Open Source Initiative

ndash Brief recap of the topic and discussion at the last callndash More information on the topic is currently being collected and compiledndash Postponed to YANGsters call in April

Future meetingsteleconferencesndash Decision monthly teleconferences should be continuedndash New date suggested (last Tuesday of each month)ndash There will be a motion asking for authorization of the calls during the closing plenary

YANGsters

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 40: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Liaisons

41

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 41: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Incoming Liaisons TSN

ndash CPRI Cooperation ndash Category A+ requirementndash IEEE 1914 - Extension of P19143 Radio over Ethernet Encapsulations and

Mappingsndash IETF LSVR ndash Link State over Ethernet ndash ITU-T SG15 LS 176 ndash Coordination of Ethernet information and data

modelling

42

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 42: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Outgoing liaison discussion

P8021DG eBlast (IEEE SA promotion activity) 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press release [CA]

Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176 [CA]

Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmap [CA]

PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017 [CA]

ODVA Liaise P8021AS-Rev latest draft (EC II) Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ [CA]

Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernet [CA]

Liaison response to OPC Foundation [CA]

Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAP43

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 43: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

EC consent agenda motions

44

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 44: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Agenda - 1

PARsICAIDs to NesComICCom (ME)ndash 5xxx P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR - Media Access Control (MAC)

Security - Corrigendum 1 Tag Control Information Figurendash 5xxx IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Drafts to Sponsor Ballotndash 5xxx P8021AX-Rev Link Aggregation revision

External Communication (ME)ndash 7xx 8021Qcp YANG Data Model press releasendash 7xx Liaison response to ITU-T SG15 on LS176ndash 7xx Liaison to ITU-T JCA IMT2020 on IMT2020 Roadmapndash 7xx PSDO Comment Responses on 802c-2017

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 45: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Agenda - 2

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1914 on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to CPRI Cooperation on Category A+ndash 7xx Liaison to IETF LSVR WG on Link State over Ethernetndash 7xx Liaison response to OPC Foundation

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 46: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 47IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

NesCom

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 47: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 48ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve forwarding P8021AE-2018Cor 1 PAR

documentation in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019ae-cor1-draft-par-0319-v00pdfto Nescom[Corrigendum PAR no CSD]

bull In the WG Proposed Seaman Second Congdonndash PAR (yna) 43 0 0

bull In LMSC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 48: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 49ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID

Approve forwarding IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID documentation in IEEE 8021-18-0079-02httpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0079-02-ICnedocxto ICCom

In the Working Group Moved Marks Second CongdonY 43 N 0 A 1

In LMSC Moved Messenger Second MarksY N A

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 49: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 50ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

IEEE 802 Nendica ICAIDTitleIEEE 802 ldquoNetwork Enhancements for the Next Decaderdquo Industry Connections ActivityExplanatory technical background materialThe initial term of the IEEE 802 Nendica was March 2017 to March 2019 During that period two Work Items were initiated The Lossless Data Center Networks Work Item led to a published Nendica Report a PAR (P8021Qcz ndash Congestion Isolation) external cooperation activities and a proposal to initiate an enhanced revision The Flexible Factory IoT Work Item has led to a Draft Nendica Report with comment resolution leading to a second draft The current two-year charter of the IEEE 802 Nendica is set to expire in March 2019 Additional topics may also arise An Industry Connections Activity can be renewed with a new ICAID Nendica has produced a 2018 Annual Report as background information lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn181-18-0078-02-ICnepptgt and a Nendica Status Report for ICCom lthttpsmentorieeeorg8021dcn191-19-0015-01pptxgt StatusA draft ICAID proposing extension to March 2021 was circulated to 802 under the 30-day rule along with background information

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 50: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 51IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

drafts to Sponsor ballot

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 51: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 52ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Conditionally approve sending P8021AX-Rev D20 to

Sponsor Ballotbull Note there are no CSD for this maintenance project

bull P8021AX-Rev D10 had 90 approval at the end of the last WG ballot

bull In the WG Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyerndash Sending draft (yna) 4400

bull In EC Mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 52: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 53ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Revbull WG ballot closed 10 January 2019bull All WG ballot requirements are metbull The ballot resulted in

bull 2 outstanding Disapprove votesbull 0 outstanding Must Be satisfied

commentsbull Comment resolution available here

httpwwwieee802org1filesprivateax-rev-draftsd1802-1AX-Rev-d1-0-dis-v02pdf

bull Recirculation ballot will be conducted during March with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls A possible final recirculation in May if required with comment resolution on the TSN TG calls and during the May Interim if required

Ballot results

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 53: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 54ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Supporting information P8021AX-Rev

bull Voters with outstanding Disapprove votesndash Cheng Weiyingndash Seaman Michael

bull These voters have indicated that they are satisfied with the disposition of their comments but they would like to see the next draft

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 54: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 55IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Drafts to RevCom None

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 55: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 56IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

ec-19-0043-00

8021 Motions2019-03

Consent Agenda

Liaisons and external communications

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 56: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 57ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the press release on IEEE Std 8021Qcp in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019cp-draft-press-release-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 57: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 58ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following response (to LS 176) to

ITU-T SG15bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-

response-SG15-LS176-data+info-model-0319-v01pdfbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial licensebull This approval is under LMSC OM ldquoProcedure for

public statements to government bodiesrdquobull In the WG (yna) 41 0 0

bull Proposed Janos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 58: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 59ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 802c-2017 (ISOIECIEEE FDIS 8802-

A2015FDAmd 2)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6CommentResponse802c-v03pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seamanndash (yna) 42 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 59: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 60ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to IEEE 1914bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liais

on-response-1914-Category-A+-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 2bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 60: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 61ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to CPRI Cooperation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-CPRI-Category-Aplus-Requirement-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 1bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Jessy Rouyer

bull In EC for information

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 61: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 62ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to the IETF LSVR WG

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-IETF-LSVR-Link-State-over-Ethernet-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 39 0 2bull Proposed Paul Congdon Second Mick Seaman

bull In EC for information

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 62: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 63ec-19-0043-00 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following response to OPC Foundation

bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019liaison-response-OPCF-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In EC for information

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 63: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

EC regular motions

64

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 64: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Regular motions Agenda - 1

External communications (ME)ndash 7xx eBlast on P8021DG Automotive Profile for TSNndash 7xx PSDO comment responses on 8021Q-2018ndash 7xx P8021AX-Rev to JTC1SC6 for information under PSDO

Information Items (II)ndash 7xx Liaison to IEEE 1722 on MAAPndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion

and Time Synchronizationndash 7xx Liaise P8021AS-Rev to IEEE1588

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 65: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 66IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

External Communications

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 66: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 67ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve the eblast on the P8021DG project in httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019dg-draft-cfp-0319-v01pdf to be released with editorial changes as deemed necessary

bull In the WG (yna) 27 0 0bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas Second Craig Gunther

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawbull (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 67: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 68ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motionbull Approve liaison of the following comment responses to

ISOIEC JTC1SC6 under the PSDO agreementbull CN1 on IEEE 8021Q-2018 (revision to ISOIECIEEE 8802-

1Q2016)bull httpwwwieee802org1filespublicdocs2019maint-randall-

SC6Ballotresponse1Q2018-0319-v01pdf

bull In the WG Proposed Mick Seaman Second Paul Congdonndash (yna) 41 0 0

bull In EC mover John Messenger Second David Lawndash (yna) ltygtltngtltagt

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 68: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 69IEEE 802 LMSCec-16-0170-03

EEE802

Information Items (II)

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 69: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 70ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve sending the following liaison to IEEE 1722bull httpsmentorieeeorgomnirandcn19omniran-19-

0018-01-00TG-802-1-liaison-to-ieee-1722docxbull Granting the IEEE 8021 WG chair (or his delegate)

editorial license

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

bull Proposed Max Riegel Second Roger Marks

bull In EC for information

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 70: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 71ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to ODVA SIG for Distributed Motion and Time Synchronization

bull Proposed Jordon Woodsbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 71: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

WG motions

72

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 72: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

MOTION 8021 approves the November 2018 (Plenary) and

January 2019 (Interim) minuteshttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2018-11-minutes-v2pdfhttpieee802org1filespublicminutes2019-01-minutes-v2pdf

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Approved by Acclamation

73

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 73: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

MOTION 8021 approves to hold an 8021 interim session

January 20-24 2020 in Geneva Switzerland hosted by International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Nokia and IEEE 8023ndash Proposal in httpieee802org1filespublicdocs2019admin-

ITU-jan-2020-interim-0319-v02pdf 8021 approves participation in a Joint Workshop with

ITU-T SG15 and 8023 at ITU-T Headquarters hosted by ITU Nokia and IEEE 8023 in Geneva Switzerland on January 25 2020

Proposed Jessy Rouyer Seconded Jaacutenos Farkas Y 39 N 0 A 1

74

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 74: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Maintenance TG motions

75

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 75: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the Maintenance TG to hold teleconferences on May 14 2019 and July 9 2019 at 1100 AM EST if necessary Access information will be posted to the 8021 reflector in advance

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 76: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

OmniRAN TG motions

77

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 77: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion Approve OmniRAN TG conference calls

ndash Apr 5 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Apr 26 2019 0900 AM ET 15hrndash Further conference calls until the July 2019 plenary with at

least 14 days prior notice to the 8021 mailing list ndash Agenda proposal and call-in details will be announced at

least 14 days prior to the call on the 8021 mailing list and made available on http1ieee802orgomniran

Moved Max Riegel Second Hao Wang

Result Approved by acclamation

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 78: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Security TG motions

79

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 79: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

MOTION 8021 authorizes the Security Task Group to

hold teleconferences to progress P802E P8021X-Rev PAR development for 8021AE privacy enhancements and task group matters arisingndash Datestimes to be announced subject to notice of

at least 10 days to the 8021 email exploder

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh Approved by acclamation

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 80: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

MOTION 8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim

to generate a PAR and CSD for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AE specifying Privacy enhancements for use with MACsec

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 81: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

MOTION 8021 authorizes the editor of P802E

(Recommended Practice for Privacy Considerations for IEEE 802 Technologies) Jerome Henry to produce drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

Proposed Congdon Second McIntosh For 40 Against 0 Abstain 1

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 82: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

TSN TG motions

83

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 83: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting in Vienna on July 19 2019 (ie the Friday after the IEEE 802 Plenary session) together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 41 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 84: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Unbehagen the editor of P8021Qcj Automatic Attachment to Provider Backbone Bridging (PBB) Services to prepare drafts for and conduct Working Group balloting

bull Proposed Paul Unbehagenbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 85: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes Paul Congdon the editor of P8021Qcz Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Congestion Isolation to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Rodney Cummings

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 86: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes Christophe Mangin the editor of P8021CBdb Frame Replication and Elimination for Reliability Amendment Extended Stream Identification Functions to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 87: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes Feng Chen the editor of P8021Qdd Bridges and Bridged Networks Amendment Resource Allocation Protocol to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Ludwig Winkel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 88: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes Jaacutenos Farkas the editor of P8021CMde Time-Sensitive Networking for Fronthaul Amendment Enhancements to Fronthaul Profiles to Support New Fronthaul Interface Synchronization and Syntonization Standards to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Tero Mustalabull In the WG (yna) 42 0 1

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 89: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes Craig Gunther the editor of P8021DG Time-Sensitive Networking Profile for Automotive In-Vehicle Ethernet Communications to prepare drafts for and conduct Task Group balloting

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Mike Potts

bull In the WG (yna) 43 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 90: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE Std 8021AB to specify LLDPv2

bull Proposed Paul Congdonbull Second Mark Hantel

bull In the WG (yna) 42 0 0

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 91: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

8021 authorizes the May 2019 Interim to generate PAR and CSD for pre-circulation to the EC for an amendment to IEEE 8021Q to specify TSN Configuration Enhancements

bull Proposed Stephan Kehrerbull Second Jaacutenos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 37 0 1

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 92: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold pre-meeting on the Monday morning of the July 2019 Plenary session

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkasbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 93: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold an Interim meeting on September 23 2019 to progress the IEEE P8021 DG Project The meeting is hosted by General Motorsbull No registration feebull Location General Motors VEC-East 30400 Van

Dyke Warren MI 48093 USA bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Gunther

bull In the WG (yna) 40 0 0

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 94: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motion

bull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold teleconferences weekly on Mondays from 1100 AM (US-Eastern) to 100 PM (US-Eastern)

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Craig Gunther

bull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 95: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences together with IEC 65CMT9 to progress the IECIEEE 60802 Joint Project on Mondays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 25 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Ludwig Winkelbull Approved by acclamation

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 96: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motionbull 8021 authorizes the TSN Task Group to hold bi-weekly

teleconferences to progress the P8021DG project on Tuesdays from 900 AM (US-Eastern) to 1000 AM (US-Eastern) starting on April 2 2019

bull Access information is posted on the httpwwwieee802org1tsn page and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Michael Pottsbull Second Craig Guntherbull Approved by acclamation

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 97: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

YANGsters motion

98

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 98: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motionbull 8021 authorizes monthly teleconferences for the YANGsters

group convening on the last Tuesday of every month from 1000 AM (US-Eastern) to 1100 AM (US-Eastern) starting on March 26 2019

bull Access information is posted on the https1ieee802orgyangstersyangsters-call-informationpage and will be updated as necessary

bull Agenda will be announced on the 8021 email reflector at least 5 days before the call

bull Proposed Jaacutenos Farkas bull Second Stephan Kehrer

bull Approved by acclamation

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 99: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Nendica motion

100

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 100: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

MOTION 8021 Authorizes Nendica to meet in person on

May 14 2019 in Atlanta (at the Wireless interim meeting) and to hold teleconferences on April 10 2019 (1100 AM ET) April 18 2019 (0900 AM ET) and May 07 2019 (0900 AM ET) with additional teleconferences to be announced at least 10 days in advancendash Access information is posted on the

https1ieee802org802-nendica pagendash Agenda will be provided at least 5 days before the

call

Proposed Zein Second Marks For_40_Against_0 Abstain_0_

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 101: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 102ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Liaise the latest revision of the P8021AS-Rev draft specification to IEEE 1588 WG

bull Proposed Rodney Cummingsbull Second Don Pannell

bull In the WG (yna) 24 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 102: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Page 103ec-16-0170-02 IEEE 802 LMSC

EEE802

Motion

bull Approve liaison of the following drafts to ISOIEC JTC1SC6 for information under the PSDO agreement at sponsor ballot time

bull P8021AX-Rev

bull Proposed Jessy Rouyerbull Second Janos Farkas

bull In the WG (yna) 19 0 0bull In the LMSC for information

jlm
Highlight

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others
Page 103: 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canadagrouper.ieee.org/groups/802/1/files/public/minutes/2019-03-closing... · 802.1 Plenary – March 2019 Vancouver, Canada Closing Agenda

Motions ndash Any others

104

  • 8021 Plenary ndash March 2019Vancouver Canada
  • 8021 plenary agenda
  • Instructions for the WG Chair
  • Participants have a duty to inform the IEEE
  • Ways to inform IEEE
  • Other guidelines for IEEE WG meetings
  • Patent-related information
  • Decorum
  • 8021 officers
  • The following are 8021 voters (61)
  • The following became voting members this week
  • The following will become voting members whenif they show up here this week
  • The following could become voting members if they email me indicating their intention to do so and if they show up here this week
  • The following will lose voting member status for lack of qualifying attendance unless they show up here this week
  • Slide Number 15
  • 80211 Reciprocal credit
  • Future interim meetings
  • January 2020 Interim Meeting Proposal - IEEE 8021 and 8023
  • Jan 2020 Meeting Rooms Provided
  • Jan 2020Adjacent and Related Meetings
  • This plenary survey
  • Future plenaries
  • Promotional Activities
  • Sanity check ndash current workload
  • 8021 plenary schedule
  • 802 reports
  • 802 reports
  • TG reports
  • Maintenance Task GroupClosing Report
  • Maintenance Item Status Update
  • ISOIEC JTC1 SC6 Status
  • Maintenance Next Steps
  • Nendica Meeting Report March 2019
  • OmniRAN closing report
  • OmniRAN TG AchievementsVancouver BC meeting March 11th ndash 13th
  • Looking forward to next sessions
  • Report ndash Security
  • 8021 TSN TG Agenda
  • YANGsters
  • Liaisons
  • Incoming Liaisons
  • Outgoing liaison discussion
  • EC consent agenda motions
  • Agenda - 1
  • Agenda - 2
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent AgendaNesCom
  • Motion
  • Motion IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • IEEE 802 Nendica ICAID
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agendadrafts to Sponsor ballot
  • Motion
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • Supporting information P8021AX-Rev
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Drafts to RevCom None
  • 8021 Motions2019-03Consent Agenda Liaisons and external communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • EC regular motions
  • Regular motions Agenda - 1
  • External Communications
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Information Items (II)
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • WG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • Maintenance TG motions
  • Motion
  • OmniRAN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Security TG motions
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • MOTION
  • TSN TG motions
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • YANGsters motion
  • Motion
  • Nendica motion
  • MOTION
  • Motion
  • Motion
  • Motions ndash Any others