7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and...

17
7/10/2017 | 1 Nicholas K. Tagliarino PhD Candidate, University of Groningen Research Analyst, Land Portal Foundation Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and Practices Related to Expropriation, Compensation and Resettlement

Transcript of 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and...

Page 1: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 1

› Nicholas K. Tagliarino

› PhD Candidate, University of Groningen

› Research Analyst, Land Portal Foundation

Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and Practices Related to Expropriation, Compensation and Resettlement

Page 2: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

Roadmap

› Background and methodology

› Discussion of how to use this legal data for monitoring, advocacy, and legal reform purposes

› Overall conclusions & next steps

7/10/2017 | 2

Page 3: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

Expropriation and Sustainable Development

7/10/2017 | 3

Page 4: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

Background & Methodology

7/10/2017 | 4

Page 5: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

Countries analyzed 7/10/2017 | 5

List of countries assessed Asia Africa Latin America

1. Afghanistan

2. Bangladesh

3. Bhutan 4. Cambodia

5. China

6. Hong Kong

7. India

8. Indonesia 9. Laos

10. Kazakhstan

11. Sri Lanka

12. Malaysia

13. Mongolia 14. Myanmar

15. Nepal

16. Papua New

Guinea

17. Pakistan 18. Philippines

19. Taiwan

20. Thailand

21. Vietnam

1. Angola

2. Burkina

Faso 3. Botswana

4. Eritrea

5. Ethiopia

6. Ghana

7. Kenya 8. Lesotho

9. Liberia

10. Namibia

11. Nigeria

12. Rwanda 13. South Africa

14. South Sudan

15. Sierra Leone

16. Swaziland

17. Tanzania 18. Uganda

19. Zambia

20. Zimbabwe

1. Argentina

2. Belize

3. Brazil 4. Ecuador

5. Honduras

6. Mexico

7. Nicaragua

8. Peru 9. Trinidad and

Tobago

Page 6: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

Clearly define “public purpose” to allow for judicial review

Provide just compensation to all legitimate tenure rights holders

Provide productive alternative land and housing

Minimize or avoid involuntary resettlement

7/10/2017 | 6

Page 7: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

New Infographic on Land Portal’s Land Book 7/10/2017 | 7

Page 8: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 8

Page 9: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 9

Key Findings

Page 10: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

Developing Recommendations for Legal Reform

7/10/2017 | 10

Page 11: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 11 Informing World Bank Policy Debates

Page 12: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 12

0 10 20 30 40 50

I s there a national-level law that establishes procedures for

resettling and rehabilitating populations displaced by

expropr iations?

YES PARTI AL NO UNCLEAR

Number of Countries

Page 13: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 13 Informing ADB Policy Debates

Page 14: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 14

Page 15: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 15 Measuring practice on the ground

Page 16: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

Conclusions and Next Steps

7/10/2017 | 16

Page 17: 7/10/2017 | 1 Using Land Portal to Monitor Laws and ...landgovernance.org/assets/Nicholas-Tagliarino.pdf · 7/10/2017 | 1 ›Nicholas K. Tagliarino ›PhD Candidate, University of

7/10/2017 | 17

Thank you for your attention email: [email protected]