7 NOTES ; the collectors
-
Upload
hadassah-louis -
Category
Documents
-
view
219 -
download
0
Transcript of 7 NOTES ; the collectors
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 1/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 2/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjip db|me ip `bk~emqmey g vbso bl li`qibd$
Qjm dgkmp% `jgsg`qmsp gda id`iamdqp ~bsqsgyma id iq gsm qjm vbso bl qjmg}qjbsp’ ikgfidgqibd$
Gdy smpmkcegd`m qb g`q}ge ~mspbdp% ei|idf bs amga% m|mdqp bs eb`geiqimp ip
mdqismey `bid`iamdqge$
GCB]Q QJM G]QJBS
Jgagppgj Eb}ip ip g pq}amdq bl Kgpp @bkk}di`gqibd Qm`jdbebfy gda
vsiqmp gp g jbccy$
GCB]Q QJM DB\ME
6 Dbqmp% gd Bsifidge Db|me cy Jgagppgj Eb}ip ip bdey g ~sbkbqibdge db|me$
vvv$6dbqmpdb|me$cebfp~bq$`bk
G@ODBVEMAFMKMDQPQjgdop qb Ky ^gsmdqp% Piceidfp% ^pq$ Kgsy
gda Pjgjgc$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 3/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
^SBEBF]M
Jms lmmq `gssima jms gp lgpq gp qjm vida gda qjm pgda gsb}da jms
vgp id q}skbie$ Qjmy vmsm dbq lgs cmjida jms gda pjm odmv qjmy
vb}ea `gq`j jms gda ampqsby jms ampqidy$ G ampqidy qb ~sbqm`q gee
qjm iddb`mdq lsbk qjm sg|mdb}p agdfmsb}p cmidfp qjgq ~sbvema
qjm mgsqj$
Id jms jgda pjm `gssima g fegpp+eiom cgee% pb `emgsey ce}m$
Cgsmlbbqma pjm sgd qjsb}fj g ampmsq gda p}aamdey jms amei`gqm
lbbq egdama bd g asy pjgs~ sbbq gda cebba lebvma$
Qjm `beem`qbsp lbeebvma qjm pkmee bl jms cebba gda cm`gkm lgpqms
id qjmis ~}sp}iq$ Qjmy ei oma qjm cebba qjgq jga kizma viqj qjm
pgda gda vmsm gpp}sma qjmy vb}ea dbq ebpm jms qjip qikm$ Qjmy
vmsm lgpq `gq`jidf }~ cmjida jms$
Pjm `bdqid}ma s}ddidf qjb}fj vgp eik~idf cm`g}pm pjm jga j}sq
jms lbbq$ Jms jgis lebvidf id qjm vida cmjida jms% pjm sgd bd qb
`bk~emqm jms kippibd$
Jms cebba vgp pqiee pi~~idf id qjm pgda gda p}aamdey qjm ampmsq
cmjida jms aipidqmfsgqma gp qjb}fj cmidf pvgeebvma }~ cy qjm
mgsqj$ G j}fm h}dfem g~~mgsma cmlbsm jms gp qjb}fj qb jms
smp`}m% pjm sgd qb iq$ Iq jga fsbvd agso gsb}da jms c}q pjm om~q
bd s}ddidf m|md viqj qjm qsmmp qsyidf qb pebv gda pqb~ jms$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 4/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjm ~mb~em bd jms qgie vmsm ~bvmsl}e vi`oma cmidfp% pbs`msmsp
gda pjm vgp qsyidf qb pqb~ qjmk lsbk jgskidf gdy kbsm ~mb~em$Pjm vgp p}~~bpma qb cm g f}gsaigd c}q jga ebpq pqsmdfqj b|ms
qikm$
Qjb}fj jms pqsmdfqj vgp lgieidf pjm qs}pqma jmspmel qb cm gcem qb
pg|m gq emgpq qjgq bdm egpq ~mspbd$ Db bdm’p eilm vgp fbidf qb cm
ampqsbyma qjgq ymgs h}pq cm`g}pm pjm jga fsbvd vmgo gda jga
dbq abdm jms hbc sifjq$ Pjm vb}ea dbq aipg~~bidq gda pjm vb}ea
dbq emq qjm pbs`msmsp gebdf viqj qjmis `beem`qbsp qsi}k~j b|ms jms$
Pjm vgp pqs}ffeidf gp pjm vgp pq}`o id cmqvmmd qjm sgfidf qsmmp
vjmd pjm feik~pma pifjq bl qjm yb}df kgd pjm vgp p}~~bpma qb
~sbqm`q lbs qjm ymgs$ G dmv pqsmdfqj md|meb~ma viqjid jms gda pjm
lb}fjq csg|mey gfgidpq qjm pbs`msmsp p~meep$ Pjm vgp p}``mmaidf
c}q gee bl g p}aamd qjm csgd`jmp b|msvjmekma jms gp qjmy vmsm
qbb kgdy$
Pjm lb}fjq qb fmq qb jik c}q h}pq gp pjm vgp gcb}q qb `ebpm id bd
jik gda kgom jik pglm qjm `beem qbsp ~}pjma jms lgs cg`o gda
pjm lmee gvgy% csmgoidf qjm fegpp cgee id jms lgee$ Pjm p`smgkma id
gdfms% ~gid gda ls}pqsgqibd gp qjm cby vgp mdf}elma$ Pjm
aipg~~mgsma id qjm kipq gebdf viqj m|msyqjidf mepm id qjm |i`idiqy$
Qjm pbs`msmsp jga vbd qjmkpme|mp gdbqjms fgkm qb ~egy$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 5/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >7
‚Yb} abd’q pgy'’ Gddm eg}fjma$
‚Yb} pjb}ea jg|m pmmd qjm ebbo bd jms lg`m' Qjgq mz~smppibd vgp
~si`mempp%’ Ciee fbppi~ma$
Qjmy eg}fjma jgsa m|md cgdfidf qjmis lipqp bd qjm qgcem$ Qjmy
vmsm fbppi~idf gcb}q Dgd`y gda jbv pjm jga smg`qma vjmd
Ag|m jga fi|md jms g p}dlebvms gebdfpiam g ~bbsey vsiqqmd eb|m
emqqms$
‚^bbs Ag|m' Jm vgp h}pq pqgdaidf qjmsm eiom jm’p pq}~ia'’
‚B}`j% Dgd`y ip g ciq`j'’
‚Aia yb} pmm qjm eb|m emqqms2 Iq vgp gee lbeama }~ eiom iq vgp vsiqqmd
cy g piz ymgs bea$’
‚Ab yb} qjido pjm viee agqm jik2’
‚Gpppp il' Dgd`y ip pb b}q bl jip emgf}m'’
‚Ag|m ip p}`j g ebpms'’
‚Ymgj% I odbv'’ Ag|m pgia pdmgoidf }~ lsbk cmjida qjmk$
Qjmy ebboma gq mg`j bqjms% mkcgssgppma qjgq qjmy jga cmmd
`g}fjq qgeoidf gcb}q jik$‚Jmyy Ag|m%’ Ciee pgia% ‚Vjgq ab yb} odbv2’
‚Qjgq gk g ebpms gda Dgd`y ip b}q bl ky emgf}m$ I fmq iq c}q yb}
odbv I vbd’q cm csbom lbsm|ms'’
‚Gp illl'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 6/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Ymgj% I vb}ea ~sb|m iq qb y’gee gda kbsm pb qb Dgd`y$ Pjm viee
`bkm cmffidf lbs km' Ji Gddm%’ Ag|m pgia piqqidf dmzq qb qjmk$
‚Ji%’ pjm gdpvmsma$
‚Vjmsm ip Dgd`y2’
Gddm gda Ciee pjgsma g pm`smq kb`oidf fegd`m$ Gddm ebboma gq
Ag|m gkgxma$
‚Vjy vb}ea yb} cm ebboidf lbs jms2’ pjm gpoma$
‚Cm`g}pm I vgdq qb pmm jms'’
‚Abmp pjm vgdq qb pmm yb}2’
‚Pjm jgp dbq ymq sm~eima qb ky emqqms% I jg|m qb odbv$’
‚Lbsfmq jms Ag|m'’
‚I `gd’q% I eb|m jms$’
Qjmy eg}fjma gq jik$ Jm pgv Dgd`y vgeo cy b}qpiam gda sgd b}q
lgpq qb kmmq jms$ Qjmy vgq`jma jik lsbk qjm vidabv jifjey
gk}pma gp jm g~~sbg`jma jms$
‚Ji Dgd`y%’ Ag|m pgia$
Pjm h}pq pqgsma gq jik cegdoey gp pjm `jmvma g f}k$
‚Dgd`y% I vgp vbdamsidf' @b}ea yb} `bkm viqj km qb qjmkb|imp2’
‚Vjgq kb|imp2 Gda vjb ip ~gyidf2’
‚Gggj%’ Ag|m p`sgq`jma jip jmga$
Jip `jmg~ kbame ~jbdm sgdf gda jm pmgs`jma jip ~b`omqp
lsgdqi geey lbs iq$ Dgd`y fg|m jik g cbsma ebbo gda lmifdma g ygvd
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 7/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
c}q Ag|m aia dbq dbqi m gp jm vgp c}py ebboidf lbs jip `mee ~jbdm$
Jm lb}da iq gda w}i`oey gdpvmsma cmlbsm iq `b}ea pqb~ sidfidf$
‚Kbk2 Ymp% I’ee cm sifjq qjmsm'’ jm `}q qjm eidm$
‚Kbkky’p cby2'’ Dgd`y pgia pgs`gpqi geey$
Fmqqidf b}q jms I ~ga % pjm vgeoma gvgy lsbk jik$
‚Vjgq gcb}q qjm kb|im2’ jm `geema glqms jms$ ‚I viee ~gy'’
C}q pjm vgp gesmgay fbdm$
‚Db' I abd’q jg|m qjm kbdmy qb ~gy'’ jm gfsmma qb jikpmel$
Qjgq vgp h}pq jbv csbom jm vgp$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 8/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >3
‚Kbk vjy aia yb} `gee km2’ Ag|m gpoma jip kbqjms gdfsiey$
‚Jmy% `gd’q I m|md `gee ky pbd2’ jip kbqjms% Asmv% `bk~egidma$
‚Iq’p mkcgssgppidf kbk'’
‚@bkm bd% Ag|m' Jme~ km viqj aiddms$’
‚I dmma g sgipm$’
Jip kbqjms pqb~~ma vjgq pjm vgp abidf gda ebboma gq jik%
ceidoidf$
‚Vjgq aia yb} pgy2’ pjm gpoma jik$
‚Kbk% I pgia I dmma g sgipm% gp id% kbsm kbdmy'’
‚Lbs vjgq2’
‚Gk id `beemfm kbk' Gda ebbo gq km% I abd’q m|md jg|m g `gs$’
‚Ip qjgq p}~~bpma qb cm ky lg}eq2 Yb} asi|m kidm$’
‚Vmee db% c}q'’
‚Ag|m% ~emgpm fmq bd viqj aiddms$’
Ag|m fs}kcema gp jm gppmkcema qjm idfsmaimdqp lbs ~sm~gsidf
aiddms$‚Vjy ab yb} omm~ abidf qjgq2’
‚Abidf vjgq kbk2’
‚H}pq qjgq' Fs}kceidf'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 9/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Il aga vgp jmsm jm vb}ea jg|m fi|md km g sgipm% jm vb}ea jg|m
}damspqbba'’
‚Pbd% gsm yb} smgeey p}sm bl qjgq2’
Jm pjs}ffma$ Pjm vgp sifjq% jm vgp dbq p}sm gcb}q qjgq$
‚Vjmsm ip jm2 Ip jm amga2’
‚Db% jm’p dbq%’ Asmv eg}fjma$ ‚Yb} pjgee odbv jik pbbd mdb}fj$’
‚I vgdq qb odbv jik dbv$’
‚I abd’q qjido yb} gsm smgay$’
‚Gk 37 kbk'’
‚I odbv c}q yb} gsm pqiee ky cgcy% fmq bd viqj aiddms ~emgpm$’
‚Db kbk% I gk fbidf qb ebbo lbs g hbc'’
‚Dbv2 Vjmsm2’
‚Gq qjm dmifjcbsp$’
‚Gq qjm dmifjcbsp2’ pjm vgp p}s~sipma$
‚Gk fbidf qb kbv qjmis egvd kbk gda liz qjmis lebvmsp$’
‚Bo% il qjmy’ee ~gy yb} c}q smgeey% qjgq’p dbq g hbc lbs pbkmbdm yb}s
gfm$’
‚Qjgdop kbk' Yb}’sm qbb oida$’
Jm emlq qjm jb}pm$ Jm odmv jm `b}ea dbq ab gdy pmsib}p hbcp% jm
vgp dbq `}q b}q lbs qjgq pq}ll% jm qjb}fjq$ Qjm bdey smgpbd jm vgp
vbsoidf qb fmq kbdmy vgp qb ik~smpp Dgd`y bqjmsvipm jip kbqjms
~sb|iama gee qjgq jm dmmama lidgd`igeey gda pjm vgp dbq fbidf qb
fi|m jik mzqsg h}pq qb ik~smpp g fise$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 10/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >0
Glqms abidf gee jip vbso gda mgsdidf g lmv c}`op Ag|m lmeq smpqemppgda am`iama qb qgom g vgeo m|md qjb}fj jm aia dbq odbv vjmsm
mzg`qey qb fb$ Jm ~}pjma qjm eiqqem kbdmy jm jga mgsdma id jip
~b`omq gda om~q jip jgda qjmsm h}pq id `gpm jm ebpq qjm kbdmy$
Jm vgeoma qb qjm ~gso vipjidf jm `b}ea kmmq pbkmbdm c}q vgp
pjbsq bl e}`o qjgq agy$ Qisma bl vgeoidf bd qjm csifjq jbq p}ddy
agy% jm pgq gq g dmgscy cmd`j gda vgq`jma qjm `b}~emp qjgq vmsm
pqsbeeidf cy$ Iq vgp idamma g lidm agy gda Ag|m egia abvd% jip cg`obd qjm cmd`j gp jm b~qma qb vgq`j qjm poy idpqmga bl `b}~emp$
Ag|m gvgomdma% jm pgq }~ lgpq gp jm vgp p}s~sipma jm jga m|md
lgeemd gpemm~$ Jm vgp dbq qjm oida bl ~mspbd qjgq pem~q id ~}cei`$
Pmmidf qjgq qjmsm vgp dbqjidf kbsm lbs jik qjgq agy% jm fbq }~ qb
emg|m$ Jgdap pqiee id jip ~b`omqp% jm ebboma cg`o qb `jm`o%
mp~m igeey `jm`o il jm jga asb~~ma gdy bl jip kbdmy$ Jm jga dbq
c}q qjmd pbkmqjidf asmv jip mymp gqqmdqibd$ Jm q}sdma qb ebbo
`gsml}eey% qjmd ebboma emlq gda sifjq gda kb|ma cg`o qb qjm ~gso
cmd`j$
G pidfem pqgpj bl lsmpj fsmmd `sip~ `gpj id g ~g~ms c}daem egy bd
qjm pblq fsgpp h}pq gq qjm lbbq bl qjm cmd`j$ Ag|m ebboma gsb}da
cmlbsm ~i`oidf }~ qjm kbdmy% jip mymp feiqqmsidf jm ~}pjma iq idqb
jip ~b`omqp gp vmee$ Jm sgd jbkm$Idjip sbbk% kgoidf p}sm qjgq qjm abbs vgp eb`oma$ Jm pgq bd jip
cma gda w}i`oey fbq qjm fsmmdp b}q bl jip ~b`omq$ Jm `b}ea dbq
cmeim|m qjgq qjip vgp smge$ Iq vgp eiom qjm kbdmy jga h}pq cmmd
kmgdq lbs jik% jm vgp p}sm qjm kbdmy jga dbq cmmd qjmsm vjmd
jm jga lispq pgq gq qjm cmd`j$ Jm aia dbq `gsm vjb emlq iq qjmsm% gee
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 11/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
qjgq kgqqmsma qb jik vgp qjgq iq vgp dbv jip$ Jbv jm vb}ea p~bie
Dgd`y% jm qjb}fjq$
Qjm c}d`j aia dbq ebbo qbb cif gdyvgy$ Iq vgp g`q}geey w}iqm peik$
Jm `}q qjm ~g~ms bll gda cmfgd qb `b}dq qjm kbdmy$ Mg`j dbqm
vgp g !7>> abeegs gda viqj mg`j `b}dq Ag|m vgp ~msp~isidf gda
fmqqidf mz`iqma$ Qjmsm vmsm 6 dbqmp id gee$ Ag|m jga ~i`oma !6>>
abeegsp$ Jm h}k~ma bd jip cma id p}`j m`pqgpy$
Ag|m vgpqma db qikm% pqg`oma qjm dbqmp id jip ~b`omq gda fbq b}q
lsbk jip sbbk$ Jm gekbpq c}k~ma idqb jip kbqjms$ Jm vgpqma dbqikm gda asmv g !7>> abeegs lsbk jip ~b`omq qb fi|m jms$
‚Qjm dmifjcbsp fg|m yb} qjip lbs kbvidf qjmis egvd2’ jip kbqjms
gpoma pjb`oma$
‚Qjido vjgq yb} vgdq kbk c}q iq’p gee yb}sp%’ jm pgia j}ffidf jms$
‚Qjgdo yb} pbd c}q vjgq ab I ab viqj iq2’
‚C}y pbkm ei~pqi o kbk'’
Pjm vgp ~emgpgdqey p}s~sipma gda pkiema$ Jm s}pjma b}q$
‚Vjmsm gsm yb} fbidf2’ pjm `geema glqms jik$
Ag|m jga gesmgay fbdm b}q$ Jm jga `geema }~ Ciee qb jme~ jik
p~mda qjm kbdmy c}q kbpq mp~m`igeey qb jme~ jik `jbbpm g di m
filq lbs Dgd`y$ Ag|m qbea g k}`j mz`iqma Ciee jbv jm jga fbq qjmkbdmy viqjb}q emg|idf b}q g pidfem amqgie$
‚Pb yb} h}pq ~i`oma iq }~2’
‚Ymgj% vjgq vgp I p}~~bpma qb ab% db bdm ebboma eiom qjmy vgdqma
iq'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 12/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb}’sm qjm kgd'’ Ciee ~sgipma% ‚I vgp qbea vjmd yb} ~i`o kbdmy
yb} gsm p}~~bpma qb fi|m pbkm qb qjm `j}s`j bs pbkm `jgsiqy'’
‚Gda pbkm qb Dgd`y qbb'’ Ag|m gaama$
‚Vmee jg|m yb}2’
‚Dbq qb Dgd`y% dbq qb qjm `j}s`j gda `msqgidey dbq qb g `jgsiqy$’
‚Vjgq gsm yb} vgiqidf lbs2 Iq’p cga e}`o dbq qb'’
‚I vgp fbidf qb% ebbo qjmsm’p g cmffgs'’ Ag|m ~bidqma$
Qjmy s}pjma qb g aisqy ebboidf kgd% viqj ebdf cmgsap gda ebboidf%
vmee% ebboidf ~smqqy k}`j gp g cmffgs pjb}ea ebbo$ Jm vgp piqqma
bd qjm lebbs gda pqgsidf gq dbqjidf id ~gsqi`}egs$
Qjmy g~~sbg`jma jik gda qbvmsma b|ms jik$ Ag|m liafmqma c}q
m|mdq}geey ~}q jip jgdap id jip ~b`omqp gda viqjasmv g !7>>
abeegs% jm jga db `jgdfm gq qjm qikm$
‚Kgd fi|m iq qb jik%’ Ciee pgia ebboidf ik~gqimdq$
Qjm cmffgs vgp ebboidf gq qjmk% lsbk bdm yb}df lg`m qb qjm dmzq
vbdamsidf vjgq c}pidmpp qjmy jga viqj jik$ Ag|m jgdama jik g
!7>> abeegs% qjm cmffgs pdgq`jma iq gvgy gda fg|m qjmk qjm
ciffmpq p}dpjidm pkiem mz~bpidf jip ymeebv qmmqj qjgq geebvma
~}qsia csmgqj qb mp`g~m$ Ciee gda Ag|m p`smvma qjmis lg`mp id
smg`qibd qb qjm cga pkmee$
‚Kipqms% I gk dbq kmgdq qb fi|m yb} g !7>> abeegsp% ab yb} jg|m
pbkm `jgdfm2’ Ag|m gpoma pq}~iaey$
‚Ymgj kmd% fi|m }p b}s `jgdfm2’ Ciee gaama$
‚Jbv k}`j `jgdfm2’ qjm cmffgs gpoma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 13/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjgq vb}ea cm !:> abeegsp% yb}s pjgsm ip !3> abeegsp'’ Ag|m
gdpvmsma$
Qjm cmffgs pqbba }~ gda ~bidqma g pqi`o gq qjm a}b$ Qjmy kb|ma
cg`o id lmgs% qjm cmffgs p}sm ebboma gdfsy$
‚Fmq ebpq yb} lieqjy cbyp' Abd’q yb} odbv jbv qb cm oida qb qjm
~bbs'’ qjm cmffgs pjb}qma$
Qjm cbyp sgd gvgy$
‚Yb} gsm qjm bdm qjgq’p lieqjy' Fmq g eilm kgd% abd’q cm fsmmay%’ qjmypjb}qma gp qjmy vmdq j}seidf m|md kbsm idp}eqp$
‚Dbv I’|m bdey fbq !=>> abeegsp'’ Ag|m `bk~egidma$
‚Gp qjmy pgy% mgpy `bkm% mgpy fb$’ Ciee qbea jik$
‚Yb} gid’q jme~idf'’
‚Kgycm iq vb}ea jme~ qb id|mpq pbkm bl yb}s kbdmy id qjm pqb`omz`jgdfm'’
‚Dgj% vjgq ab I odbv gcb}q iq2 Cmpiamp I jg|md’q m|md qgomd
Dgd`y qb gd mz~mdpi|m aiddms bs cb}fjq jms g asmpp$’
‚Dgd`y viee cm yb}s abvdlgee Ag|m$’ Ciee eg}fjma% ‚Pb vjgq viee yb}
ab lbs km gda Gddm$’
‚Bzyfmd lbs yb} Ciee gda Gddm% vmee yb} `gd c}y jms vjgq yb}vgdq% bd km$’
‚Vb}ea g dm`oeg`m ab2’
‚Gdyqjidf `gd ab lbs qjgq Gddm c}q Dgd`y ip gee pb k}`j% pb
}d~smai`qgcem$’
‚Bjj jmsm vm fb gfgid'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 14/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m jga dm|ms mdhbyma qjm pjb~~idf kgee gp jm aia qjgq agy$ Jm
cb}fjq jikpmel gda Ciee pbkm `bk~}qms fgkmp$ Jm gepb cb}fjq
Dgd`y g cmg}qil}e mz~mdpi|m sma asmpp$ Jm jga f}mppma pjm
vb}ea ebbo pma} qi|m id iq gda gp jm qjb}fjq Dgd`y vgp gevgyp
pma}`qi|m% f}mppma pjm vb}ea eb|m qjm asmpp% vjgq vbkgd
vb}ead’q$ Ciee `jbpm g cmg}qil}e mz~mdpi|m dm`oeg`m viqj kgq`jidf
mgssidfp lbs qjmis fbba lsimda gda fbppi~ ~gsqdms Gddm$
Qjmy bsamsma fbba lbba gda vmdq qb pmm di`m ~eg`mp pb qjgq gq
qjm mda bl qjm agy Ag|m vgp emlq viqj sb}fjey gcb}q !3=> abeegsp
vji`j jm ~egddma qb lidipj bd g agqm viqj Dgd`y$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 15/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >1
Ag|m `b}ea dbq smkmkcms m|ms cmidf pb jg~~y id jip eilm gda viqjdbq g pidfem vbssy bd jip kida$ Dgd`y jga kisg`}eb}pey gfsmma qb
fb bd g agqm viqj jik gda jm vgp pb mz iqma$ Jm p}p~m`qma Gddm
jga qi~~ma jms bll qjgq jm jga pbkm kbdmy% jbvm|ms% bdey Ciee
odmv vjmsm qjm kbdmy jga smgeey `bkm lsbk$ Iq smkgidma qjgq
vgy$
‚Ag|m2’ jm kbk odb`oma eb}aey bd jip abbs id qjm kbsdidf$
Jm q}sdma id jip pemm~$ Pjm odb`oma gfgid% bdey g ciq eb}ams qjip
qikm$ Jm pebvey sb}pma lsbk jip pemm~$
‚Kbk% vjgq ip iq2’ jm gpoma pjmm~ipjey$
‚Vgom }~' Vm jg|m pbkmqjidf qb ab qbagy$’
‚Yb} aiad’q qmee km gcb}q iq ympqmsagy'’
‚Iq’p cm`g}pm yb} `gkm cg`o egqm'’
‚Fb gvgy kbk% iq’p bdey : b’ eb`o$’
Ag|m q}sdma gda ikkmaigqmey vmdq qb pemm~$ Asmv `gkm gda
ebboma gq jms pbd% pjm ~gqqma jik pebvey bd qjm cg`o id gdbqjms
gqqmk~q qb vgom jik$ Jm aia dbq pqis gda pjm qjb}fjq jm vgp
~smqmdaidf$
‚Ag|m% vgom }~% vm gsm fbidf qb pmm yb}s lgqjms'’
Ag|m h}k~ma }~ gp qjb}fj jm vgp dbq h}pq lsbk pemm~ gda ebboma
gq jms viam myma gda kb}qj gfgs$
‚Vjgq aia yb} pgy kbk2’
‚Yb} vgdqma qb pmm jik aiad’q yb}2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 16/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Ymp% gjj ymp I aia$ Gsm vm fbidf qb qjm ~sipbdp2’
‚Vjgq lbs2’‚Pb jm’p dbq id hgie qjmd2’
‚Dbv yb} gpo km% glqms gee qjbpm ymgsp$ Jm ip id g fbba ~eg`m$’
‚Jm aima2 Vm’sm fbidf qb qjm `mkmqmsy2’
‚Ip qjgq m|md g fbba ~eg`m2' Yb} k}pq cm pb pemm~y% kgycm I viee
qgom yb} qb jik gdbqjms qikm$’
‚Gk gvgom% gk l}eey gvgom kbk$ C}q vjy aiad’q yb} qmee km
ympqmsagy2’
‚Yb} `gkm id egqm gda gdyvgy% I bdey `bdliskma viqj jik qbagy$’
‚Jm ip gei|m qjmd2’
Asmv h}pq pkiema gq jms pbd gda vgeoma b}q$ Jm vgpqma db qikm
fmqqidf smgay gda lmeq pb gdzib}p$ Jip jmgsq vgp cmgqidf vieaey gdajm vgp ~msp~isidf m|md glqms jg|idf g `bbe pjbvms$ Jm asmppma
jip cmpq id qjm p}iq jm jga ~egddma qb vmgs vjmd qgoidf Eg}sg b}q$
Iq vgp g dmgq ceg`o p}iq viqj g kgq`jidf qim gda g vjiqm pjisq$ Jm
emlq qjm hg`omq gp jm qjb}fjq iq vb}ea kgom jik ebbo qbb lbskge%
qbb lbskge qb cm g pbd$
Vjmd jm vgp smgay jm vmdq b}q qb kmmq jip kbk$ Pjm myma jik
gda pkiema$ Pjm jga gepb asmppma mp~m`igeey% jm dbqi`ma gda
m|md g~~eima sma ei~pqi`o$ Jm pkiema cg`o gq jms$
‚Ebboidf fbba ky pbd%’ pjm pgia$
‚Yb} qbb kbk$ Ab yb} qjido jm viee eiom iq2’ Ag|m gpoma dms|b}pey$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 17/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb}s lgqjms2 Bj ymp% jm viee eb|m iq$ Jm jgp gevgyp vgdqma qb
kmmq yb}$ Jm `gd’q dbq eiom yb}$’
‚Pb yb} jg|m cmmd qgeoidf viqj jik cmjida ky cg`o2’
‚Dbq dm`mppgsiey cmjida yb}s cgg`o' I h}pq aia dbq qjido yb} vmsm
smgay$’
‚Gda qjip kbsdidf I vgp smgay2’
‚I odbv il yb} aiad’q pmm jik qbagy% I vb}ea jg|m dm|ms qgomd yb}
qb jik m|ms$’
‚Vjgqm|ms qjm `gpm kbk% yb} abd’q gvgomd pbkmbdm qb p}`j
oida bl dmvp' Yb} `b}ea jg|m oieema km'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 18/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >=
Qjmy vmsm cbqj piemdq gp Asmv asb|m jms pbd b}q qb kmmq jiplgqjms$ Iq jga qgomd jms ebdf mdb}fj qb fgqjms `b}sgfm qb sm|mge qb
jik jip lgqjms’p qs}m iamdqiqy$ Pjm bdey jb~ma jm vb}ea dbq cm qbb
aipg~~bidqma% cbqj id jms bs jip lgqjms$ Pjm ebboma gq jik? jm vgp
pqgsidf b}q qjm `gs vidabv ebpq id qjb}fjq$ Asmv ebboma cg`o gq
qjm sbga gda asb|m gp pebvey gp pjm `b}ea% qsyidf jgsa qb ~}q bll
qjm kbkmdq$
Ag|m jga ikgfidma mg`j gda m|msy ~bppicem lg`m jm `b}ea jg|m
c}q pqiee aia dbq odbv jbv jip lgqjms vb}ea ebbo$ Vgp jm lgq bs qjid%
qgee bs pjbsq% di`m bs kmgd% jm `b}ea dbq lif}sm b}q$ Jm ebboma gq
jip kbqjms gp pjm asb|m gq g pdgie’p ~g`m% jm vgp pb gdzib}p gda
vgdqma qb fmq qjip b|ms viqj c}q aia dbq vgdq qb qmee jms qb asi|m
lgpqms$ Pjm vgp }dams g ebq bl ~smpp}sm% jm `b}ea qmee$
Jm qjb}fjq bl vjgq oida bl kgd jip kbqjms vb}ea lgee id eb|m viqj$Jm jga db iamg cm`g}pm jip kbqjms om~q jms eb|m eilm pb ~si|gqm
jm vbdamsma il pjm m|ms jga bdm$ Jm jga jmgsa jms bdm difjq
qgeoidf eb|idfey qb pbkmbdm bd qjm ~jbdm% jm vbdamsma il iq vgp
jip aga bs gdbqjms kgd c}q dm|ms lb}da b}q$ Qjgq vgp jbv `ebpma
}~ pjm om~q jms eb|m eilm$
Jm f}mppma qjm kgd pjm `b}ea eb|m jga qb cm pvmmq% oida gda
eb|idf c}q qjmd% il jip lgqjms vgp pvmmq% oida gda eb|idf vb}ea jmjg|m emlq qjmk qb lmda lbs qjmkpme|mp gda geebv jik qb fsbv }~
lgqjmsempp2 Jm f}mppma dbq m|md qjb}fj jm vgp dbq p}sm vjmsm
jip kbqjms fbq gee qjm kbdmy pjm }pma qb sgipm jik lsbk$ Jm odmv
pjm jga dm|ms jga g pmsib}p bs smge hbc$ Pjm pbkmqikmp vbsoma
gp g lsmmegd`ms$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 19/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjm `gs `gkm qb g jgeq gda Ag|m `gkm cg`o lsbk jip qjb}fjqp$
Jm ebboma gsb}da ceidoidf gda vgp p}s~sipma qjgq jip kbk jga
~gsoma id lsbdq bl g `jg~me$ Iq ebboma bea gda cemgo id iqp fsmy
`bebs$
‚Gsmd’q yb} `bkidf b}q2’ jip kbqjms gpoma odb`oidf gq jip
vidabv$
‚Bj ymgj ymgj'’ Ag|m fbq b}q bl qjm `gs gda pqsmq`jma$
Iq vgp gcb}q 7> id qjm kbsdidf gda qjm p}d vgp lgisey jbq$ Asmv
vgp vgeoidf qb qjm `jg~me c}q Ag|m vgp qsgdplizma qb qjm p~bq$
Pjm ebboma cg`o gq jms pbd% pjimeaidf jms mymp lsbk qjm p}d$
‚@bkm bd'’ pjm `geema qb jik$
‚Kbk% vjgq gsm vm abidf gq g `j}s j2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Vm jg|m `bkm qb gpo lbs lbsfi|mdmpp'’
‚Lsbk vjb2’
‚Fba bl `b}spm$’
‚Gee ky eilm yb} jg|m dbq csb}fjq km qb g `j}s`j c}q qbagy yb}
ab2 Cmpiamp% iq’p dbq m|md g P}dagy' @jsipqigdp fb qb `j}s`j bd
P}dagyp db2’
‚Ymp qjmy ab c}q qjip ip ik~bsqgdq'’
‚Dbq qbagy kbk% I gk pb gdzib}p qb pmm aga$’
‚Yb} gsm `geeidf jik aga m|md cmlbsm yb} pmm jik2 Yb} viee pmm
jik m|mdq}geey$’
‚Vjy csidf km qb `j}s j%’ jm om~q `bk~egididf$
‚Iq’p gcb}q qikm I aia'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 20/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Asmv qbbo jms pbd cy qjm jgda gda jm qgffma gebdf$ Ag|m ebboma
gsb}da% jm jga dm|ms pmmd qjip `jg~me cmlbsm gda vgp amm~ id
qjb}fjq gee qjsb}fj qjm asi|m jmd`m aia dbq odbv jbv qjmy jga fbq
qjmsm$
Jip kbqjms ema jik idpiam qjm mk~qy `jg~me$ Qjmy pgq gq gd mk~qy
cmd`j gda Asmv odmeq abvd qb ~sgy$ Ag|m ebboma gq jip kbqjms
eiom pjm vgp vmisa? jm dm|ms odmv pjm `b}ea ~sgy$ Pjm vgp
pmsib}p gda jms mymp qifjqey pj}q$ Ag|m vbdamsma il jm pjb}ea ab
eiomvipm gda vgp jgelvgy abvd qb jip odmmp vjmd g ~simpq
asmppma id ceg`o g~~sbg`jma$
Ag|m pqbba }~ gda pqgsma gq qjm ~simpq gda ~simpq pqgsma cg`o gq
jik$ Smkmkcmsidf vjgq Ciee jga qbea jik gcb}q fi|idf qb qjm
`j}s`j? jm jgpqiey asmv b}q g !7>> abeegs dbqm gda ~}pjma iq idqb
qjm ~simpqp’ jgda$
Qjmsm vgp g peifjq ebbo bl p}s~sipm bd qjm ~simpqp lg`m c}q iq
w}i`oey aipg~~mgsma gda vmdq cg`o qb cmidf ~egid gfgid$ Lmmeidfgvovgsa jm qg~~ma jip kbqjms bd qjm pjb}eams$ Fmqqidf db
smp~bdpm% jm qg~~ma jgsams% jm f}mppma pjm jga dbq lidipjma
~sgyidf c}q lbs jbv ebdf pjb}ea bdm ~sgy% jm aia dbq odbv$
Jm pq}aima qjm ~simpq% ebboidf jik }~ gda abvd$ Qjm kgd vgp dbq
~e}k~ eiom kbpq ~simpqp? jm vgp dbq qbb qjid miqjms eiom bqjmsp jm
jga pmmd$ Lg`m `emgd pjg|md gda gd b~md lsimdaey lg`m$ Jgda
qbfmqjms gda jmga peifjqey cbvma$ Lbs Ag|m qjmsm vgp db bqjms
vbsa qb amp`sicm qjip kgd mz`m~q lbs bdm vbsa8 j}kcem$ Jip vjbem
ebbo p`smgkma qjm vbsa$
Jip kbqjms jga lidgeey lidipjma ~sgyidf gda pqbba }~$ Pjm ebboma
gq jms pbd sm~sikgdaidf$ Jm aia dbq odbv vjy pjm ebboma gq jik
eiom qjgq c}q pbbd lb}da b}q$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 21/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb} ab dbq pjgom pbkmbdm vjmd qjmy gsm ~sgyidf Ag|m'’ jip
kbqjms pgia id g ebv c}q gdfsy |bi`m$
‚Pbssy kbk% I aia dbq odbv c}q jm vgp h}pq pqgdaidf b|ms qjmsm
eiom qjgq gda iq lmeq gvovgsa pb I h}pq fg|m jik pbkm kbdmy'’
Jip kbqjms q}sdma qb pmm vjb jm kmgdq gda Ag|m `b}ea pmm qjgq
jms mymp fsmv viam b~md$ Pjm kgam gp il qb p~mgo c}q pgq abvd
idpqmga$ Ag|m `b}ea dbq }damspqgda jip kbqjmsp’ smg`qibd$ Jm pgq
abvd cmpiam jms gda ebboma gq jms `bd`msdma$
‚Ag|m% vjy ab yb} g`q eiom g piz ymgs bea2’ pjm gpoma jik id g ebv
c}q pmsib}p qbdm$
‚Kbk% jm vgp h}pq pqgdaidf qjmsm gda dbq pgyidf gdyqjidf% vjgq
`b}ea I ab2’
‚Bj Fba% jm vgp pqgdaidf qjmsm gda dbq pgyidf gdyqjidf cm`g}pm
I vgp ~sgyidf pbd' Iq ip ik~bsqgdq qb ~sgy id piemd`m$’
‚Pb kgdy s}emp% abp gda ab dbqp viqj qjip ~sgyms qjidf'’
Asmv pqbba }~ gda pjbbo qjm jgda bl qjm ~simpq$
‚I gk pbssy Pqm|md%’ pjm pgia qb jik% ‚I dm|ms qg}fjq jik gdyqjidf$’
‚I }damspqgda%’ jm sm~eima ~gqqidf jms pblqey bd qjm pjb}eams$
‚Yb} odbv qjip f}y2’ Ag|m vgp p}s~sipma$
Jip kbqjms ebboma |msy }d`bklbsqgcem gda vgp pjilqidf vmifjqp
viqj jms lmmq$ Pjm ebboma jms pbd id qjm mym gda jm lsbxm% dbq
odbvidf vjgq vgp fbidf bd bs qjm pmsib}p kbba jm vgpd’q }pma
bl vjmd iq `gkm qb jip kbqjms$ Qjm ~simpq vgp gepb piemdqey
vgq`jidf qjmk$
‚Ag|m%’ Asmv pgia% ‚qjip kgd ip yb}s lgqjms'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 22/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m’p jmgsq asb~~ma sifjq qb qjm ~iq bl jip pqbkg`j gda qjmd
p}aamdey jm lmeq eiom jm vb}ea |bkiq iq sifjq }~$ Jip mymp vmsm
viam gda jip kb}qj vgp b~md viqj pjb`o$ Iq vgp g qs}qj pb jgsa qb
pvgeebv bs m|md pido id$ Jm pqgsma gq qjm ~simpq vjbk jm jga dbv
emgsdma vgp jip lgqjms$
‚Jm’p g ~simpq kbk2'’ Ag|m pgia id g qbdm cmqvmmd g``}pgqibd%
w}mpqibd gda pqgqmkmdq$
Jip kbqjms ebboma abvd gp qjb}fj gpjgkma$
‚Jm vgp dbq g ~simpq vjmd I kmq jik% gda jip dgkm ip Pqm|m%’
Asmv pgia id g ebv qbdm qsyidf qb amlmda jmspmel$
‚Vjgq vmsm yb} qjidoidf kbk2’
‚Pj}q }~% viqjb}q jik yb} vb}ead’q jg|m cmmd jmsm'’
‚Jmeeb pbd'’ qjm ~simpq dgkma Pqm|m pgia pik~ey$
Ag|m pqgsma gq jik eiom jm vgp g qgeoidf kg`jidm bs pbkmqjidf$
‚Jmeeb%’ jm pgia gq egpq lidaidf jip |bi`m$
‚Iq ip fbba qb lidgeey kmmq yb} pbd$ Yb}s kbqjms gevgyp p~bom bl
yb}? ~emgpm ab dbq cm qbb jgsa bd jms' Pjm vgp pik~ey abidf vjgq
vgp cmpq'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 23/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS ><
‚Mz`}pm }p%’ Asmv qbea jms pbd$
Ag|m pgq abvd jmg|iey gda vgq`jma gp jip kbqjms qbbo qjm
~simpqp jgda gda ema jik lgs mdb}fj lbs Ag|m dbq qb jmgs qjmis
vjip~msp$
‚I qjb}fjq vm jga gesmgay qgeoma gcb}q qjip'’ Asmv vgp pjb}qidf gq
Pqm|m qjb}fj id g vjip~ms$
‚C}q I pqiee eb|m yb}' I viee pqb~ ky |b`gqibd qb cm viqj yb} gda ky
pbd$’
‚Yb}s pbd2 Vjgq oida bl g kgd gsm yb}2 Jm ip gesmgay fsbvd }~
gda db ebdfms dmmap yb} mp~m igeey dbq glqms qjip'’
‚Iq ip dbq ky lg}eq qjgq I gk g ~simpq Asmv yb} odbv qjgq$ I vgp
}dams g ebq bl ~smpp}sm$’
‚Gda I vgp ~smfdgdq qjmd% I qbea yb} c}q yb} vgdqma qb s}d gvgy
lsbk lg`qp'’
‚Pjjj% abd’q pjb}q% `bkm bd% iq vgpd’q qjgq cga% I p}~~bsqma yb} gee
qjm qikm$’
‚Lidgd`igeey bdey% vjmsm vmsm yb} vjmd jm vgp gpoidf gcb}q yb}2
P~smgaidf b}q yb}s jgdap gda ~sgyidf lbs pbkm Fba+qjispqy
~mb~em2 FBA'’
‚Iq’p dbq eiom qjgq c}q ~emgpm Asmv% `gd vm cm g lgkiey gfgid2’
Pqm|m gpoma$
Asmv vgp `bdl}pma% pjm `b}ea pmm qjm pid`msiqy id jip mymp c}q
qjgq |msy pid`msiqy jga lbbema jms pb kgdy qikmp$ Pjm smgeey
vgdqma jik c}q gp pqsbdfey gp pjm vgdqma jik pjm jgqma jik$ Jm
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 24/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
vgp jms vmgodmpp$ Pjm ebboma b|ms qb jms pbd vjb vgp piqqidf
w}imqey lg`m abvd gda ebboma cg`o gq Pqm|m$ Jm vgp vgiqidf lbs
gd gdpvms pjm vgp dbq smgay qb fi|m$
Asmv `sg`oma jms od}`oemp% pjm jgqma qjgq Pqm|m `b}ea pmm
qjsb}fj jms$ P}aamdey jm fsgccma gda ~}pjma jms qb g `bsdms
vjmsm qjmy `b}ea dbq cm pmmd$ Pjm vgp ebboidf gq jik w}ixxi geey
c}q jm odmv vjgq jm vgp abidf$ Pqm|m cmdq b|ms qb oipp jms gda
aia peifjqey cs}pj gfgidpq jms ei~p$ Asmv vgp gdfmsma gda
lbs`ml}eey ~}pjma jik bll$
‚Vjgq ab yb} qjido yb} gsm abidf2 Qjip ip qjm jb}pm bl Fba'’ pjm
pjb}qma$
‚Pjj% abd’q pjb}q$ I h}pq vgdqma qb ~sb|m qb yb} I kmgdq vjgq I
pgia'’
Qjgq aia dbq `gek Asmv’p qmk~ms$ Ag|m vjb k}pq jg|m jmgsa qjm
pjb}qidf sgd gda pqbba }~ dmgs qjmk qb pmm$ Qjm ~simpq vjb vgpjip lgqjms vgp cmdama b|ms jip kbqjms% jbeaidf jms cy qjm
pjb}eams gda jip lg`m pb `ebpm qb jmsp$ Ag|m’p mymp vmdq viam
viqj p}s~sipm$
‚I eb|m yb} Asmv'’ qjm ~simpq vgp pgyidf$
Asmv ~}pjma jik gvgy gfgid$
‚Yb} gsm pi o%’ pjm pjb}qma% ‚yb} gsm gd bea kgd Pqm|m c}q yb}g`q eiom g qmmdgfms$ Yb} abd’q ab qjgq$’
‚Asmv I odbv vjgq I gk abidf% I jg|m gevgyp odbvd% ~emgpm qs}pq
km$’
‚Yb} gsm h}pq csbom gpp qjgq hbidma qjm `j}s`j lbs `b|ms%’ Asmv
pjb}qma% ‚vmee yb} fbq `b|msma% `b|msma viqj c}eepjiq'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 25/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Asmv vgeoma gvgy lsbk qjm ~simpq gda fsgccidf jms pbd cy qjm
jgda p~mmaiey emlq qjm `j}s`j$
‚Kbk% vjgq’p fbidf bd2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Vm gsm emg|idf'’
‚I `gd pmm qjgq% bjj ddb abd’q ~}ee km yb}’sm mkcgssgppidf km$ I
`gd vgeo cy kypmel qjgdo yb}$’
Pjm emq fb bl jip jgda gda Ag|m kgdgfma bdm egpq ebbo gq qjm
~simpq cmlbsm qjmy emlq qjm `j}s`j$ Asmv asb|m bll p~mmaiey gp pbbdgp qjmy jga fbqqmd idqb qjm `gs$
‚Kbk% vjgq jg~~mdma2’ Ag|m gpoma fmd}idmey `bd`msdma$
Asmv vgp jbeaidf qifjqey qb qjm pqmmsidf vjmme gda ebboma eiom pjm
vgp gcb}q qb `sy$ Pjm vgp gepb p~mmaidf gda aia dbq gdpvms$
‚Kbk% pebv abvd cmlbsm vm fmq g qi`omq$’
Pjm eipqmdma gda pebvma abvd$
‚Kbk% I abd’q cmeim|m vjgq h}pq jg~~mdma qbagy c}q I gk pb pbssy'
I vipj qjm agy `b}ea jg|m fbdm bd cmqqms lbs yb}%’ Ag|m qbea jms$
Pjm aia dbq gdpvms% pjm vgp bc|ib}pey b|msvjmekma viqj
mkbqibd gda qmgsp vmsm s}ddidf abvd jms lg`m$ Ag|m fbq g
jgdaoms`jiml gda eb|idfey vi~ma bll jip kbqjmsp qmgsp% pjm
kgdgfma g qidy pkiem$
Vjmd qjmy fbq jbkm% Asmv jmgama pqsgifjq lbs jms sbbk$ Ag|m
vipjma jm `b}ea `bklbsq jms c}q jm vgp mw}geey `bdl}pma$ Jm lmeq
eiom qmeeidf pbkmcbay? jm odmv Ciee vb}ea eipqmd gqqmdqi|mey gda
Gddm vgp gevgyp fbba bd fi|idf ga|i`m$ Jm am`iama jm vb}ea qmee
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 26/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
qjmk qjm dmzq qikm jm pgv qjmk$ Jm jga qb qjido qjip b|ms cy
jikpmel lispq$
Ag|m egia jikpmel bd qjm cma% lg`idf qjm `mieidf c}q smgeey h}pq
amm~ id qjb}fjqp$ Jip lgqjms vgp pbkm ~simpq% Ag|m `b}ea dbq
cmeim|m iq$ Vmsm qjbpm qjm oida bl kmd jip kbqjms lmee id eb|m viqj%
qjm bdmp vjb cm`gkm ~simpqp$ Jm ~}pjma qjm qjb}fjq b}q bl jip
kida$ Jm aia dbq vgdq qb odbv gdykbsm gcb}q qjip kgd jip
kbqjms jga sm|mgema gp jip lgqjms$
Ag|m lmee gpemm~$ Jip `mee ~jbdm c}xxma jik gvgom$ Iq vgp Dgd`y`geeidf? jm aia dbq jmpiqgqm qb gdpvms$
‚Jmeeb2 Dgd`y% I aia dbq mz~m`q yb} qb `gee'’ jm gdpvmsma$
‚Yb} aiad’q2 Ip qjgq vjy yb} vmsmd’q ~i`oidf }~ ky `gee2’
‚Db dbq gq gee% I vgp gpemm~$ I gk pbssy$’
‚Bo'’‚Bo$’
Ag|m aia dbq odbv vjy Dgd`y jga `geema gda pb vgp gq g ebpp bl
vbsap% iq aia dbq jme~ qjgq jm jga h}pq gvgomdma$ Jip kida vgp
cegdo$ Qjmsm vgp gd gvovgsa piemd`m$
‚Jmeeb2’ Iq vgp Dgd`y$
‚Bj% pbssy' Vjy aia yb} `gee2’ Ag|m lmeq jm jga qb gpo$
‚Gcb}q b}s agqm qbkbssbv%’ pjm pgia pik~ey$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 27/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >6
Ag|m vgp ik~smppma viqj qjm eb`gqibd Dgd`y jga `jbpmd lbs qjmis lispq agqm$ G agqm gq qjm cmg`j% jbv lsmm `b}ea qjgq cm% Ag|m
qjb}fjq$ Gq qjm cmg`j jm vb}ea dbq cm mz~m`qma qb vmgs gdyqjidf
lgd`y% qjm lbba `gkm `jmg~ey% qjm p`mdmsy vgp p~m`qg`}egs gda bl
`b}spm% Dgd`y id g cioidi vb}ea cm qjm cmpq ~gsq bl iq gee$ Gp lbs
qsgdp~bsq% jm `b}ea lsmmey cbssbv jip kbkp’ `gs$ Iq vgp g abdm
amge$
Dgd`y `gkm b|ms qb Ag|m’p jb}pm asmppma pik~ey id g pjbsq poisqgda qifjq pemm|mempp qb~ qjgq legqqmsma jms cbbcp$ Pjm gepb `gssima
g pkgee cgf$ Ag|m vgp pb jg~~y qb pmm jms gda vgdqma qb kgom
jms kbpq `bklbsqgcem$ Dgd`y ebboma }dik~smppma qjb}fj$ Jm ema
jms qb qjm `gs gda b~mdma qjm abbs lbs jms pb pjm `b}ea mdqms$
Piqqma cmjida qjm pqmmsidf vjmme% Ag|m q}sdma qb ebbo gq jms$ Pjm
aia dbq ebbo gq jik$
‚Qjgdop lbs `bkidf Dgd`y% I jb~m vm jg|m g fbba qikm'’
Dgd`y bdey dbaama peifjqey c}q pqiee aia dbq ebbo gq jik% pjm vgp
c}py bd jms I ~ga$ Jm vbdamsma vjy pjm vgp ifdbsidf jik%
gssbfgd`m% jm f}mppma c}q qjgq aia dbq pqb~ jik eioidf jms m|md g
ciq$
Jms pjbvidf }~ bd qjip ik~bsqgdq agy lbs Ag|m% vgp mdb}fj qb
kgom jik eb|m jms lbs qjm smpq bl jip eilm$ Jm pkiema? jm odmvmzg`qey vjgq vb}ea kgom jms pdg~ b}q bl qjgq pbkcms kbba$ Jm
jga pq}aima jms ebdf mdb}fj qb odbv mdb}fj gcb}q jms$
‚I cb}fjq yb} pbkmqjidf%’ Ag|m pgia$
Iq jga vbsoma% pjm sgipma jms jmga g eiqqem gda qjsmv jik g qidy
ebbo cmlbsm ~smqmdaidf gp qjb}fj jm jga pgia dbqjidf$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 28/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb} aia2’ pjm gpoma piemdqey$
‚Ymgj% vgdq qb pmm iq dbv2’‚Bo'’
Jm fbq qjm sma lebvms ~gqqmsdma cbz lsbk qjm cg`o pmgq gda
jgdama iq qb jms$ Pjm ebboma }dp}sm gda Ag|m vgp `msqgid qjgq il
pjm aia dbq eiom iq% qjmsm agqm vb}ea `msqgidey cm b|ms gda pjm
vb}ea ~sbcgcey qgom qjm filq viqj jms$ Pjm ~eg`ma iq bd jms eg~p
pqgsidf gq qjm cbz$
‚Vmee2 Vbd’q yb} b~md iq2’
‚Bo'’
Pjm pebvey fbq qb b~mdidf iq gda jm pqgsma gq jms viqj mg`j
kbqibd$ Lbs g pm`bda Ag|m lmgsma qjgq kgycm pjm g`q}geey jga g
pikiegs asmpp bs vbspm m|md qjm pgkm asmpp gq jbkm$ Qjmd jm
vb}ea ebbo eiom g lbbe$Dgd`y b~mdma qjm cbz gda fbq b}q qjm sma asmpp id iq$ Pjm ebboma
gq iq% jms lg`m eiq }~ eiom g egdqmsd$ Viqj qjm ebbo bd jms lg`m% qjmsm
vgp db amdyidf pjm eb|ma iq$ Iq vgp qjm csifjqmpq pkiem Dgd`y jga
m|ms fi|md Ag|m bs vb}ea m|ms fi|m jik }dempp bl `b}spm jm fg|m
jms gdbqjms p~m`qg`}egs filq$
‚Ab yb} eiom iq2’ Ag|m vgdqma qb odbv$ Jm vgdqma qb jmgs jms pgy
iq$
‚I ebbbbbbbb|m iq Ag|m%’ pjm pgia h}pq pqgsidf gq qjm asmpp% ‚iq ip
gkgxidf$ Vjy% I pjb}ea jg|m jga qjip asmpp lbs ~sbk difjq c}q
gdyvgy% I viee lida pbkm m|mdq qb vmgs iq$’
Ag|m `msqgidey jb~ma qjm m|mdq id vji`j Dgd`y vbsm qjm asmpp
vb}ea cm viqj jik$ Jm vgdqma qb gpo jms c}q am`iama qjgq jm
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 29/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
vb}ea gpo glqms qjmis agqm bd qjm cmg`j$ Jm vgp `msqgid iq vb}ea
fb vmee% viqj Dgd`y id fbba p~isiqp% dbqjidf `b}ea m|ms fb vsbdf$
Ag|m asb|m qb qjm cmg`j gda qjmy eipqmdma qb k}pi` gee qjm vgy$
Vmee% Ag|m jga q}sdma qjm |be}km |msy ebv cm`g}pm Dgd`y jga
cmmd cgcceidf gcb}q jms lgdqgpqi` eilm gee qjm vgy$ Jm `b}ea dbq
`bk~egid cm`g}pm jm jga dm|ms pmmd jms pb gdikgqma% jm
f}mppma g asmpp vgp idamma qjm pm`smq omy qb Dgd`y’p jg~~idmpp$
‚I vgp vbssima yb} jga g pikiegs asmpp%’ Ag|m pgia vjmd qjmy vmsm
gq g cmg`j gda pi~~idf bd pbkm h}i`m$
‚Gsm yb} pmsib}p2 I kmgd qjip asmpp ip pbb mz~mdpi|m% dbq eiom I
`gd’q gllbsa iq'’
‚Fega yb} eiom iq'’
‚Qjm vgqms ebbop pb fbba'’
Dgd`y sgd qb qjm vgqms gda ~egyma viqj iq$ Qjip vgp g jmg|mdeyagy lbs Ag|m$ Vgq`jidf Dgd`y id g cioidi% ~egyidf id qjm vgqms gda
bd gd g`q}ge agqm viqj jik$ Jm pkiema csbgaey gda hbidma jms id
qjm vgqms$ Qjmy ~egyma eiom g `b}~em$
Egqms qjmy lma bd i`m `smgk% g`q}geey qbb k}`j i`m `smgk gp qjgq
vgp gee qjgq Dgd`y vgdqma$ Ag|m aia dbq `bk~egid% jm jga qgpqma
dmv qy~mp bl i`m `smgk qjgq jm dm|ms vb}ea jg|m% jm jga lb}da
b}q qjgq Dgd`y’p lg|bsiqm leg|bs vgp `jb`begqm viqj `ji~p id iq gdacmpq bl gee% iq `gkm sgqjms `jmg~ey qjgd Ag|m jga mz~m`qma$ Qjip
vgp g fbba qjidf% Ag|m qjb}fjq$ Gq qjm mda bl qjm agy% Ag|m jga
pg|ma gq emgpq g !7>> abeegsp$
Jm asb|m jbkm gd mzjg}pqma c}q jg~~y kgd$ Asb~~idf Dgd`y gq
jms ~eg`m vjmsm pjm ei|ma gebdm% jm vgeoma jms qb qjm abbs$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 30/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjgdo yb} lbs p~mdaidf qikm viqj km qbagy'’
‚Bo%’ vgp gee Dgd`y pgia$‚Vmee% kgycm vm `b}ea fb bd gdbqjms agqm pbkm qikm2’
Dgd`y vgp jmpiqgdq qb gdpvms gda p`sgq`jma jms jmga id qjb}fjq
lbs g pm`bda$ Ag|m vgiqma lbs jms smp~bdpm$
‚Gjj% jkk I abd’q odbv%’ pjm pgia$
‚Vjgq2 Aiad’q yb} mdhby b}s agqm qbagy2’
‚Iq vgp di`m% h}pq qbb k}`j i`m `smgk% I qjido I viee fmq pi`o$’
Ag|m vgp p}s~sipma% pjm vgp qjm bdm qjgq vgp bsamsidf gee qjm i`m
`smgk gda dbv pjm vgp `bk~egididf2 Jm vgp gq g ebpp bl vbsap$
‚Bjjj%’ jm pgia$
‚Fbbadifjq Ag|m'’
Pjm fg|m jik g lgom ygvd gda mdqmsma qjm jb}pm% pj}qqidf qjm
abbs cmjida jms$ Ag|m vgp jb~idf pjm vb}ea id|iqm jik id lbs
`bllmm% g oipp bs m|md g ~m`o bd qjm `jmmo `b}ea jg|m cmmd fbba
lbs jik% jm qjb}fjq% c}q gee jm fbq vgp g ygvd gda gd ‚I abd’q
odbv’ lsbk jms$ Qjm `ebpidf bl qjm abbs id jip lg`m aia dbq kgom
jik lmme cmqqms miqjms$
Jm cgaey vgdqma qb fmq cg`o qjm asmpp jm jga fi|md jms c}qqjb}fjq cmqqms bl iq$ Jip agy jga dbq cmmd qjgq cga glqms gee% jm jga
mdhbyma iq }dqie dbv$ Jm asb|m jbkm gda smkmkcmsma jip lgqjms
gp jm ~gsoma$ Jm ~}pjma qjm qjb}fjq gq qjm cg`o bl jip kida$ Iq
vgp qjm emgpq qjidf jm vgdqma qb qjido gcb}q glqms g di`m agqm viqj
Dgd`y$ Jm jga g`q}geey fbdm bd g agqm viqj qjm }dsmg`jgcem
Dgd`y% Ag|m pkiema$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 31/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Jm mdqmsma qjm jb}pm gda pgv jip kbqjms$ Qjm gsbkg bl fbba
lbba id qjm jb}pm kgam Ag|m j}dfsy% jm smkmkcmsma jm jga dbq
mgqmd gdyqjidf c}q i`m `smgk qjm vjbem agy$
‚Gdy p}~~ms lbs km kbk2’ Ag|m gpoma qjsbvidf jikpmel bd qjm
`jgis$
‚Jg|m I m|ms om~q yb} j}dfsy2’
‚Db% gk h}pq pb j}dfsy sifjq dbv$’
‚Aiad’q yb} mgq gdyqjidf bd yb}s l}ee agy agqm2’
Ag|m ebboma gq jip kbqjms eiom pjm vgp hboidf$
‚I jga i`m `smgk qjm vjbem agy'’
‚Vbv% vjgq gd idle}mdqige fise% yb} gsmd’q smgeey idqb i`m `smgk$’
‚I `gd ab gdyqjidf lbs qjgq fise% mgq i`m `smgk lbs jms gda m|md aim
lbs jms'’‚Yb} abd’q pgy2’
‚Kbk% pjm ip smgeey jbq% gdy f}yp asmgk$ I jga qjm cmpq agqm id ky
eilm gda dbv gk pbb mzjg}pqma$’
‚Yb} pjb}ea smpq qjmd$’
‚Dbq cmlbsm aiddms'’
‚Iq’p id qjm oiq`jmd$’
‚Qjgdop kbk$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 32/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >:
Ag|m jga qjm kbpq smpqempp pemm~ qjgq difjq$ Jm vgp pb qisma c}q`b}ea dbq pemm~$ Qjb}fjqp bl jip agy Dgd`y vmsm kizma }~ viqj
qjbpm jip lgqjms$ Jm vb}ea lgee gpemm~ lbs g pjbsq vjiem c}q gvgomd
lbs g ebdfms qikm pb k}`j qjgq jm vipjma qjgq kbsdidf vb}ea h}pq
`bkm$ Jip cbay vgp g`jidf viqj vmgsidmpp$
Ag|m fbq }~ gda id jip pemm~y kbba ~b}sma `bea vgqms bd jikpmel
gp vmee gp qjm ~gdqp jm vbsm vjmd jm pem~q `bd|id`ma qjgq iq vgp
mgpims qb pemm~ vjmd bdm vgp `bea$ Qjsbvidf jikpmel gee vmq bd
qjm cma jm pem~q ~mg`ml}eey$ Qjm `bbeidf mllm`q jga vbsoma$
Ag|m vgp kmmqidf Ciee gda Gddm id qjm ~gso$ Jm vgdqma qb qmee
qjmk gee gcb}q jip agqm viqj Dgd`y gda qjmy vmsm gdzib}p qb
odbv$ Jm pgv qjgq qjm cmd`j jm jga lb}da qjm kbdmy vgp mk~qy
gda sgd lbs iq gp qjb}fj pbkmcbay mepm vb}ea qgom iq$ Qjmsm vgp
db bdm `bk~mqidf lbs qjm cmd`j gp qjm ~gso jga g lmv ~mb~em idqjm kbsdidf$
Ag|m pgq }~ pqsgifjq bd qjm cmd`j jm `bdpiamsma jip ‚e}`oy cmd`j’
c}q dbq cmlbsm ~mm~idf abvd qb pmm il qjmsm vb}ea cm gdy kbdmy
eiom cmlbsm$ Gp mz~m`qma% qjmsm vgp dbqjidf$ Jm pgq cg`o gda
vgiqma lbs jip lsimdap qb gssi|m% qjmy vmsm gevgyp egqm$ Jm smegzma$
‚I jg|m cmmd vgiqidf lbs yb} g ebdf qikm%’ g amm~ |bi`m pgia qb
Ag|m$
Jm q}sdma gda pgv piqqma dmzq qb jik g c}sey kgd id g ceg`o p}iq
gda vmgsidf agso p}dfegppmp$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 33/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vjb gsm yb}2 I qjido yb} fbq qjm vsbdf f}y% I gk h}pq jmsm qb
kmmq ky lsimdap$’
‚Jga yb} cmmd mz~m`qidf qb lida kbsm kbdmy jmsm2’ qjm kgd
gpoma$
Ag|m pvgeebvma gda f}ieq vgp vsiqqmd gee b|ms jip lg`m$
‚Vjjgggq kbdmy2’ jm pqgkkmsma$
‚Abd’q ~egy a}kc viqj km' I abd’q jg|m qikm lbs fgkmp$’
‚I abd’q odbv vjgq yb} gsm qgeoidf gcb}q'’
‚Vjmsm ip ky kbdmy2’
Ag|m vgp liafmqidf$ Jm aia dbq odbv vjgq qb pgy$ Qjm kgd myma
jik `ebpmey$
‚Vjjggq kbdmy2’
‚I pgia abd’q ~egy a}kc viqj km$’
‚I p~mdq iq'’
‚Yb} p~mdq iq2’
Qjm kgd fg|m g ebdf eg}fj qjgq pmdq pji|msp abvd Ag|m’p p~idm$
‚Yb} p~mdq iq2’ qjm kgd gpoma gfgid% ‚H}pq gp I qjb}fjq$ Vmee% dbv
I vgdq iq cg`o'’‚Vjgq2’
‚I pgia I vgdq iq cg`o$’
‚I abd’q jg|m iq'’ Ag|m pgia pjgoidf% ‚I abd’q jg|m iq$’
‚Yb} p~mdq !6>> abeegsp id 0 agyp Ag|m2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 34/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m vgp lmsb`ib}pey s}ccidf jip lbsmjmga viqj jip jgda id
aipqsmpp$ Jm `b}ea dbq qjido pqsgifjq gda `}spma jikpmel lbs m|ms
`bkidf cg`o qb piq qjmsm gq jip ‚e}`oy cmd`j’ dbv jm aia dbq odbv
vjgq jm vb}ea `gee iq$
‚Jbv aia yb} odbv ky dgkm2’
‚Ag|m ip dbq g jgsa dgkm qb odbv$ Dbv eipqmd jmsm `gsml}eey Ag|m%
}dempp yb} vgdq yb}s kbk qb `sy vjmd yb} aipg~~mgs$’
Ag|m pvgeebvma$ Jm vgp qmssilima qb qjm cbdm$
‚Yb} fi|m km cg`o mg`j pidfem !7>> abeegs dbqm yb} qbbo lsbk }p
gda yb} viee ei|m$’
‚Vjgq il I abd’q jg|m iq2’
‚Qjmd yb} aim$’
‚Vjmd ab yb} vgdq iq2’
‚Sifjq dbv'’ qjm kgd pgia pqsbdfey$
‚I abd’q jg|m qjgq oida bl kbdmy sifjq dbv$’
‚Bo$’
‚Bo2’ Ag|m vgp p}s~sipma$
Qjm kgd fbq }~ gda ~bidqma g f}d pqsgifjq gq Ag|m’p jmga$ Ag|m
~gdi`oma$
‚I jg|m g !7>> abeegs% I jg|m g !7>> abeegs'’ Ag|m pjb}qma$
Jm l}kcema id jip ~b`omq gda fbq b}q qjm egpq pidfem !7>> abeegs
dbqm jm jga$ Jm vgp |msy qjgdol}e qjgq Dgd`y jga dbq jga jik
vgpqm iq$ Qjm kgd fsgccma qjm !7>> abeegs gda pkmeq jik$ Jm
qjmd ~b`omqma iq$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 35/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjgq !7>> abeegs jgp pg|ma yb}s eilm lbs g vmmo$ Kmmq km jmsm
viqjid qjm vmmo viqj qjm smpq'’
Qjm c}sey kgd vgeoma gvgy gda Ag|m `ebpma jip mymp
}dcmeim|idf$ Jm jga pvmgqma ~sbl}pmey pb qjgq jip pjisq vgp dbv
pqi`oidf qb jip poid$ Jm csmgqjma amm~ey gda `bdqid}b}pey s}ccma
jip mymp% dbq p}sm bl vjgq jga h}pq b``}ssma$
Iq aia dbq qgom ebdf cmlbsm Ciee gda Gddm vmgsidf qjm dm`oeg`m qjgq
jga cmmd cb}fjq lbs jms gssi|ma bd qjm p`mdm ebboidf |msy jg~~y$
Qjmis jg~~y mz~smppibdp q}sdma pb}s vjmd qjmy pgv Ag|m$
‚Ag|m% vjy2 Yb} ebbo eiom yb}’|m h}pq pmmd g fjbpq%’ Gddm pgia$
‚Ymgj kmd% vjgq’p }~2 Vm’|m cmmd pmgs`jidf gee b|ms lbs yb}$
Qjip k}pq cm qjm e}`oy cmd`j vjmsm yb} lb}da qjm kbdmy j}j%’
Ciee pgia$
‚Vjgq kbdmy2’ gpoma Gddm$
Ag|m gdfsiey fbq }~ gda vgp vgeoidf gvgy$ Qjmy lbeebvma jik
}dp}sm bl jip kbba$
‚Vjgq’p vsbdf kgd2’ Ciee gpoma$
Qjmy lbeebvma jik g ebdf vgy bll }dqie jm pgq gq gdbqjms cmd`j id
qjm ~gso$ Qjmy pgq cmpiam jik$ Ag|m vgp `b|msidf jip lg`m viqj
jip gskp gda `syidf$ Qjmy aia dbq odbv jbv qb `bklbsq jik% qjmy
jga dm|ms m|ms pmmd jik eiom qjip cmlbsm$ Ag|m vgp smgeey
aipqsmppma$
‚Gk amga kgd'’ Ag|m `sima$
‚Vjgq jg~~mdma2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 36/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjmy vmsm cbqj ayidf viqj `}sibpiqy gda lieema viqj pgadmpp gda
~iqy lbs qjmis lsimda Ag|m$ Jm vgp dbq qjm qy~m qjgq `sima eiom qjip$
‚Jm vgdqp jip kbdmy cg`o'’ Ag|m pgia glqms pbkm qikm$
‚Vjgq kbdmy2’
‚Vjb vgdqp jip kbdmy2’
‚I abd’q odbv% I abd’q odbv% jm h}pq `gkm qb km vjmd I jga pgq cy
qjm cmd`j gda ~bidqma g f}d gq km$ I fg|m jik g !7>> abeegs gda
jm qbea km I jgg|m g vmmo qb smq}sd gee bl iq bs mepm jm viee oiee km$’
Ag|m `sima kbsm$
‚C}q yb} h}pq ~i`oma qjm kbdmy% ab qjmy jg|m p}s|mieegd`m
`gkmsgp id qjip ~eg`m2’ Ciee gpoma% ‚jbv `b}ea jm odbv iq vgp yb}
qjgq ~i`oma qjm kbdmy }dempp jm jga ~egdqma iq$’
‚Pqb~ `syidf Ag|m% vm `gd jme~ yb} lida qjm kbdmy$ Jbv k}`j
vgp iq2’
‚!6>> abeegsp%’ Ciee qbea jms$
‚Yb} f}yp ~i`oma }~ !6>> abeegsp% qjgq ip `sgxy$’
‚Yb} gid’q jme~idf Gddm'’
‚Pbssy Ag|m% pqb~ `syidf% vm viee lida qjm kbdmy vbd’q vm Ciee2’
‚Ymgj% I kmgd vm `b}ea m|md gpo lsbk Dgd`y% pjm k}pq jg|m qjgqoida bl kbdmy qb fi|m$’
Gddm ebboma gq Ciee sm~sikgdaidf gda jm pqb~~ma qgeoidf$
‚Gk pbssy Ag|m%’ Ciee pgia% ‚vm viee lida qjm kbdmy$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 37/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I kmgd qjgq f}y qsima qb oiee km' Jm g`q}geey ~bidqma g f}d gq km% I
vgp e}`oy qb jg|m qjgq !7>>$ Iq’p g kisg`em Dgd`y aia dbq jg|m km
p~mda iq%’ Ag|m pgia$
G ebdf qikm egqms%Ag|m’p’ qmgsp jga asima }~ gda jm ebboma g eiqqem
pjgomd }~ c}q gesifjq$ Jip lsimdap vmsm jbeaidf jip jgdap qb
md`b}sgfm jik% Gddm jga bdm gda Ciee qjm bqjms$
‚Vgp jm smgeey fbidf qb oiee yb}2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚I abd’q odbv% ~msjg~p jm qjb}fjq I vgp eyidf vjmd I pgia I aia dbq
jg|m qjm !6>> abeegsp$ Dbv I bdey dmma qb lida qjm bqjms !<>>$’
‚Ab yb} smgeey dmma qb2 H}pq abd’q `bkm cg`o qb qjm ~gso%’ Ciee
p}ffmpqma$
‚Ymgj abd’q `bkm cg`o jmsm gda cm `gsml}e$ Qjmy p}smey vbd’q
lbeebv yb} qb yb}s sbbk bs id g ~}cei kgee$’
‚Yb} gsm sifjq$ C}q qjip f}y `b}ea jg|m oieema km% jm jga g f}d~bidqma gfgidpq ky jmga$ I vgp ~mqsilima kgd$’
‚Jm vgp h}pq qjsmgqmdidf$ Yb} abd’q mz~m`q pbkmbdm qb oiee id g
~gso id csbga agyeifjq }dempp jm’p pq}~ia$ Vjgq oida bl c}pidmpp ip
qjgq2’
‚Iq’p dbq g c}pidmpp% jm aia dbq vgdq kbsm kbdmy$ Iq’p smgeey p`gsy$’
‚Ymgj% gk pjgomd qbb% emq’p fmq b}q bl jmsm cmlbsm jm `bkmp lbs }p$’
‚Bs cmlbsm vm pmm pbkm kbsm fsmmdp gda gsm qmk~qma qb ~i`o iq%’
Ag|m hboma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 38/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjmy eg}fjma eifjq jmgsqmaey$ Ag|m vgp fega jm jga jip lsimdap%
jm vgp p}sm jm vb}ead’q jg|m amgeq eifjqey viqj qjip piq}gqibd
viqjb}q qjmk$
‚Jmy f}yp%’ Ag|m pgia gp qjmy vgeoma% ‚aia I qmee yb} I kmq ky
aga2’
‚Yb} aia2’
‚Ymgj% jm’p g ~simpq$’
‚Jm ip2’
Ag|m eg}fjma gda qjmy eg}fjma gebdf viqj jik$
‚I gk pmsib}p$ I pjb}ea qgom jik qb yb} bdm agy'’
‚Qjgq vb}ea cm gvmpbkm% yb}s kbk2 Jbv `b}ea qjgq jg~~md2’
‚Iq vgp g ebdf qikm gfb% 37 ymgsp gfb%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Qjgq’p gd gvl}e ebdf qikm$’
‚C}q iq lmmep eiom ympqmsagy$’
‚Vmisa'’
Qjmy gee eg}fjma$
‚Cy qjm vgy% bjj jbv vgp yb}s agqm viq Dggd`y%’ qjgq vgp Gddm$
Gddm jga jms bvd vgy bl pgyidf qjm dgkm Dgd`y? pjm gevgypkgam iq pb}da p}~ms ebdf$
‚Iq vgp gvmmmmpbkm'’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Vbv% qjgq kmgdp pjm fg|m yb} g oipp gq qjm mda sifjq2’
‚Bj yb} odbv Dgd`y% pjm’p oidag pqidfy$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 39/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjmy gee eg}fjma$
‚Aia yb} gpo jms lbs gdbqjms agqm2 Vjgq aia pjm pgy2’‚Pjm pgia pjm abmpd’q odbv% `gd yb} cmeim|m jms2 Pjm aiad’q m|md
id|iqm km id lbs `bllmm'’
Qjmy eg}fjma gfgid$
‚Yb} gsm sifjq% pjm’p pqidfy$’
‚I lmeq eiom qgoidf cg`o qjm asmpp I cb}fjq jms c}q qjb}fjq cmqqms bl
iq$’
‚Jbv `bkm2’
‚Pjm jga fi|md gd i`m `smgk lieema agqm gda yb} odbv% dbq
gdycbay `gd agqm Dgd`y$’
Qjmy gfsmma viqj jik$ Dgd`y vgp g qb}fj `bboim$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 40/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS >9
Qjm vmmo ~gppma lgpq gda m|msyqjidf vmdq bd dbskgeey$ Ag|mvgp viqjb}q g pidfem vbssy id jip kida gda vmdq gcb}q qjm vmmo
gp }p}ge$ Jm jga dbq qgeoma qb jip kbqjms gcb}q jip lgqjms gda jm
vgp p}sm pjm vgp g|biaidf qjm qb~i` qbb$ Jm eioma iq h}pq gp iq vgp?
qjmy jga ~bpq~bdma qjm qb~i` qb g lgs }d`msqgid l}q}sm gda iq vgp
fbba pid`m qjmy vmsm cbqj `bklbsqgcem viqj qjgq$
Ag|m jga lbsfbqqmd gcb}q qjm qjsmgqp kgam cy qjm kgd gq qjm
~gso gda vgp fega jm jga dbq cbqjmsma jikpmel k}`j$ Qjgq kgd
`b}ea jg|m h}pq cmmd `gssyidf g qby f}d% jm eg}fjma qb jikpmel$
Ag|m lmee idqb g amm~ pemm~$ Jm asmgkq g pmsimp bl asmgk c}q bdm
asmgk pqgyma |i|ia bd jip kida$ Iq sm~egyma id jip jmga b|ms gda
b|ms gfgid vjmd jm gvgomdma id jip agso sbbk$
Id jip asmgk Ag|m jga pmmd g egay vjb ebboma pb ~}sm$ Pjm jga
cmmd s}ddidf lsbk lmsb`ib}p cmidfp c}q id qjm mda pjm jga lgiema$Qjm fegpp cgee pjm `gssima jga pjgqqmsma idqb kgdy ~im`mp gda
qjmd jm jga vbomd }~$
Ag|m qjb}fjq qjm asmgk vgp vmisa c}q aia dbq qgom iq gp bl gdy
ik~bsqgd`m$ Qjispqy% jm jmgama qb qjm oiq`jmd qb jg|m pbkmqjidf
qb asido gda ~msjg~p jg|m g kiadifjq pdg`o qbb$ Jm `jm`oma qjm
qikm gda pgv qjgq iq vgp >183=gk$ Kgycm gd mgsey csmgolgpq
vb}ea ab qjb}fj jm vgp dbq ~gsqi`}egsey j}dfsy$
Ag|m vgeoma pemm~iey idqb qjm oiq`jmd gda q}sdma bd qjm eifjqp$
Kidaemppey% jm vmdq b|ms qb qjm lsiafm gda asgdo lsbk qjm cbqqem bl
kieo$ Iq vgp bdey vjmd jm fbq pbkm csmga qb mgq qjgq jm pgq gq qjm
qgcem$ Jip mymp fsmv viam b~md viqj jbssbs$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 41/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Piqqidf g`sbpp qjm qgcem vmsm qjsmm kmd gda bdm vbkgd% gee
mymidf jik w}imqey$ Ag|m gekbpq lmee cg`o id pjb`o$ Jm asb~~ma
qjm csmga lsbk jip jgdap gda vgp kbsqilima$
‚Piq abvd'’ qjm egay pgia$
Ag|m bcmyma gda eiom g sbcbq pgq abvd$
‚Yb} jg|m ifdbsma }p%’ qjm egay pgia pik~ey$
Ag|m ebboma gq qjm egay% jms lg`m vgp |msy pqmsd% jms jgis |msy
ceg`o% jms pqgsm |msy amm~ gda ymq jms |bi`m pb `gek% gekbpqpvmmq$ Pjm vgp g qgee vbkgd$
‚I jgg|m dbq% I jg|m dbq ifdbsma yb}%’ Ag|m pqgkkmsma$
‚Bj ymp yb} jg|m% b}s lsimda jmsm `gkm qb fi|m yb} g vgsdidf%’
pjm ~bidqma qb qjm c}sey kgd g`sbpp qjm qgcem% ‚c}q yb} ifdbsma
jik gda ~sg`qi`geey eg}fjma gq jik$’
‚I aia dbq'’
Ag|m g|biama ebboidf gq qjm c}sey kgd bs gdybdm mepm piqqma gq
qjm qgcem$
‚Jbv aia yb} `bkm idqb ky jb}pm2’
‚Qjgq ip dbq ik~bsqgdq$ Vm h}pq vgdq b}s kbdmy cg`o$’
‚I abd’q jg|m iq'’‚Db yb} abd’q c}q yb} gsm fbidf qb lida iq gda smq}sd iq qb }p% bs
mepm%’ pjm qjsmgqmdma$
‚Bs mepm vjgq2’
Ag|m aia dbq vgdq qb jmgs qjm gdpvms m|md qjb}fj jm jga gpoma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 42/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb} viee cm `bdamkdma qb peg|msy gda yb} `gd bdey smammk
yb}spmel il yb} fi|m cg`o qjm kbdmy$ Amgqj viee lbeebv il yb} lgie qb
`bk~ey$ Yb} jg|m bdey qbagy qb smq}sd qjm kbdmy$’
‚Vjy ab yb} ab qjip qb km% vjb gsm yb}2’
‚Vm gsm qjm `beem`qbsp'’
Ag|m `b}ea dbq qgom iq gdykbsm% jm amp~msgqmey sgd b}q bl qjm
oiq`jmd$ Qjmy aia dbq m|md qsy qb pqb~ jik$ Jm sgd gp lgpq gp jm
`b}ea `geeidf qb jip kbqjms$ Jm sgd qb jms sbbk$
‚Kbk% kbk%’ jm cgdfma gfgidpq jms cmasbbk abbs$
Qjm abbs `ei`oma b~md gda Ag|m ~}pjma iq b~md gda sgd id%
eb`oidf qjm abbs cmjida jik$ Asmv ebboma gq jms pbd eiom jm vgp
`sgxy$ Ag|m q}sdma bd qjm eifjqp gda pgq bd qjm cma lg`m id jip
jgdap$
‚Vjgq jgp fbq idqb yb}2’ Asmv gpoma jik$‚Kbk% kbk% qjmsm gsm ~mb~em id qjm oiq`jmd gpoidf lbs kbdmy'’
Ag|m vgp pjgoidf gee b|ms$
‚Vjgq2’ pjm vgp p}s~sipma$
‚Kbk% I pgia qjmsm gsm ~mb~em id qjm oiq`jmd gpoidf lbs kbdmy$’
‚Yb} kmgd qjim|mp2’ pjm vgp p}aamdey gemsq$
‚Dbb% `beem`qbsp'’
‚Jg|m yb} cmmd pkboidf pbkmqjidf Ag|m2’
‚Kbk% `bkm qjmy gsm id qjm oiq`jmd$ @bkm$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 43/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m asgffma jip kbqjms cy qjm jgda qb qjm oiq`jmd% pjm vgp
sme}`qgdq$ Qjmy fbq qb qjm oiq`jmd gda m|msyqjidf vgp h}pq gp iq
pjb}ea cm$ Ag|m ebboma%m|md qjm csmga vji`j jm jga asb~~ma bd
qjm lebbs vgp id ~eg`m gda dbqjidf pmmkma gkipp$ Qjm eifjqp jga
m|md cmmd q}sdma bll$
‚Db bdm jmsm Ag|m'’
‚Kbk% I pvmgs% qjmy vmsm gpoidf lbs !6>> abeegsp% db !<>>$’
‚Ip qjip pbkm dmv kbdmy qsi`o Ag|m2 Iq’p qbb mgsey lbs qjip$’
‚Kbk% I gk qmeeidf qjm qs}qj$ ^emgpm cmeim|m km'’
‚Qgeo qb km id qjm kbsdidf%’ Asmv pgia fbidf cg`o qb jms sbbk qb
pemm~$
‚Iq ip kbsdidf$’
‚Yb} k}pq jg|m cmmd asmgkidf$ Fbbadifjq Ag|m$’
‚Kbbbk'’
‚Aia yb} pmee yb}s pb}e qb qjm am|ie bs pbkmqjidf2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 44/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 7>
Ag|m `b}ea dbq fb cg`o qb pemm~$ Jm `geema Ciee vjb vgp qgoidfqikm qb ~i`o }~$
‚Agkd Ciee ~i o }~%’ Ag|m pgia gdzib}pey$
Iq jga s}df g lmv kbsm kid}qmp cmlbsm g pemm~y |bi`m gdpvmsma
qjm ~jbdm$
‚Ciee% qjmy `gkm cg`o'’
‚Gsm yb} oiaaidf km kgd% iqp bdey =% `gee km egqms$’
Qjm eidm vmdq amga$ Ag|m `geema cg`o gda g kbsm gemsq Ciee
gdpvmsma qjip qikm$
‚Vjgq ip iq2’ jm pb}dama g eiqqem gdfsy$
‚I gk pbssy c}q I gk amp~msgqm% ~emgpm gda abd’q jgdf }~ bd km
dbv$’
‚Vjgq ip iq2 Yb} odbv gk dbd+l}d`qibdge id qjm kbsdidf$’
‚@}q qjm `sg~ Ciee% qjmy `gkm cg`o'’
Qjmsm vgp piemd`m bd qjm bqjms mda$
‚Vjb `gkm cg`o2’ Ciee gpoma glqms pbkm qikm$
‚Qjm f}y lsbk qjm ~gso gda kgdy bqjmsp% qjmy vgdq qjmis kbdmy$’
‚Vjgq ip vsbdf viqj qjmk2 Iq’p bdey !6>> abeegsp$’
‚Qjmy pgy qjmy viee kgom km g peg|m bs h}pq oiee km$’
‚Gsm yb} p}sm yb} iq vgpd’q h}pq g cga asmgk2’
‚Qjmy vmsm id ky jb}pm kgd% id qjm oiq`jmd$ Gk pb p`gsma$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 45/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Gk pbssy kmd% qjip ip gee qbb vmisa$’
‚Ip qjgq gee yb} `gd pgy2’‚Vjgq `gd I pgy2 Aia yb}s kbk pmm qjmk2’
‚Qjmy aipg~~mgsma% pjm abmpd’q cmeim|m km'’
‚Lidm% kmmq km id gd jb}s$’
‚Gd jb}s2 I `gd’q pqgy id qjip jb}pm gdbqjms kid}qm$’
‚Vjgq kgd% yb} vgdq qjmk qb lbeebv yb} gda `bkm qb ky jb}pm2Db qjgdop c}aay$ Emq’p kmmq gq qjm ~gso$’
‚Gq qjm ~gso2 Gsm yb} `sgxy2’
‚Lidm% b}qpiam ky jb}pm$ Qjmd vm viee fb pbkmvjmsm mepm qb qgeo$’
‚Vjmsm viee I lida qjm kbdmy$’
‚Abd’q vbssy% I fbq yb} `b|msma bd qjgq bdm$’
‚Qjgdop kgd'’
Ciee lb}da qjm kbdmy gda fg|m iq qb Ag|m lgisey mgpiey$
‚Db kgd% I bdey dmma g <>>%’ Ag|m qbea jik$
‚Db qgom 6% h}pq id `gpm% I vgdq yb} cg`o id bdm ~im`m$’‚Qjgdop kgd% I `gd’q cmeim|m qjmy gsm bd ky `gpm lbs h}pq !6>>
abeegsp$ Vjgq oida bl ~mb~em gsm qjmy2 Gda `bkidf idqb ky jb}pm
eiom qjgq2’
‚I abd’q odbv kgd% qjmy pmmk qb cm g cif amge$ Kgycm iq vgp dbq
gdy oida bl kbdmy$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 46/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I abd’q odbv$ I h}pq jb~m qjmy fb gvgy$’
‚Qjmy viee%’ Ciee gpp}sma jik$ ‚Yb} bvm km cif kgd'’‚I odbv$ Qjgdop$’
Ag|m j}ssima qb qjm ~gso gda vmdq qb qjm cmd`j vjmsm jm lb}da g
`b}~em eb|idfey kgoidf b}q bd iq$ Jm vgp idl}sigqma$
‚Jmy% qjip ip ky cmd`j'’ Ag|m pjb}qma qb qjm `b}~em$
Qjm `b}~em ifdbsma jik gda vmsm oippidf amm~ey$ Ag|m qg~~ma
qjm kgd bd qjm pjb}eams c}q jm aia dbq pqb~$ Pb jm ~}eema qjm egay
gvgy lsbk jik idpqmga$ Iq vgp qjm kgd’p q}sd qb cm gdfsy$ Jm fbq
}~ gda jmea Ag|m cy qjm `beegs$
‚Vjb ab yb} qjido yb} gsm2 Qjip ip ~}cei` ~sb~msqy gda yb} jga
db sifjq qb ab qjgq$ Ab yb} odbv jms2’
Ag|m pjbbo jip jmga$
‚Vjy’a yb} ab qjgq qjmd2 Ab yb} odbv jms2’ qjm kgd gpoma
gfgid$
Ag|m ebboma gq qjm egay vjb vgp pqgdaidf gda pqgsidf gdfsiey gq
jik$ Jm ebboma cg`o gq qjm kgd vjb vgp mw}geey gdfsy$ Ag|m
pjbbo jip jmga id amdige$
‚I h}pq vgdqma qjm cmd`j%’ Ag|m pgia% ‚iqp ik~bsqgdq'’
G ~}d`j kmq Ag|m’p lg`m$ Jm lmee qb qjm fsb}da% jm vgp dbq g
lifjqms gda jm jgqma gdyqjidf qjgq id|be|ma lifjqidf$ Jm `b|msma
jip jmga viqj jip jgdap qb g|bia qjm id`bkidf oi`op$ Lbsq}dgqmey%
g ~bei`m blli`ms id }dilbsk jga cmmd dmgs qjm p`mdm gda `gkm qb
Ag|m’p smp`}m$ Qjm `b}~em qbbo leifjq gda gd gee aisqy Ag|m pqbba
}~ qb kmmq qjm blli`ms$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 47/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Gsm yb} bo2’ qjm blli`ms gpoma$
‚I gk gesifjq% qjgdo yb}'’‚Ab yb} odbv qjmk2 Ab yb} vgdq qb liem g sm~bsq2’
‚Db% qb cbqj w}mpqibdp$ Abd’q cbqjms% I gfsmm viqj vjgq qjmy aia$’
‚Yb} ab2’
‚Db% c}q I gk qjm bdm gq lg}eq% I aipq}scma qjmk$ Qjmy vmsm kgoidf
b}q c}q I vgdqma qjm cmd`j pb idqmss}~qma qjmk$’
‚Vjy vgdq qjm cmd`j2’
‚I gk kmmqidf pbkmbdm%’ Ag|m pgia }dmgpiey$
‚Vjb% yb}s fiselsimda2’
Ag|m bdey pkiema% mkcgssgppma$
‚Gk I sifjq2’ qjm blli`ms gpoma$
‚Ymgj% gda pjm viee cm jmsm pbbd%’ Ag|m pgia dms|b}pey% ‚iq
vb}ead’q cm fbba il pjm pgv km viqj g ~bei`m blli ms$ Pjm kifjq
h}k~ qb `bd`e}pibdp$’
‚Qjmd jbv viee yb} mz~egid qjm aisq bd yb}2’
Ag|m lmifdma qb qjido lbs g kid}qm$
‚Ggj I viee qmee jms qjgq I `sbppma qjsb}fj h}dfemp qb fmq qb jms'’
Qjm blli ms eg}fjma$
‚Jb~m pjm cmeim|mp yb}%’ jm vgp vgeoidf gvgy$
‚Qjgdop blli ms% yb} pg|ma ky eilm'’ Ag|m `geema glqms jik$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 48/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m vgp fega qjm blli ms vgp fbdm$ Jm vi~ma jip pvmgqy gda
aisqy ~gekp bd jip pjisq$ Iq jga cmmd g `ebpm `gee% qjgq kgd jga
cmmd |msy gdfsy$ Ag|m ebboma gsb}da gda pgv db bdm vjb
ebboma eiom qjm c}sey kgd% jm vgp fmqqidf ik~gqimdq$ Jm vgiqma g
ebdf qikm gda db bdm pjbvma }~$
‚Jmy%’ Ag|m pjb}qma qb db bdm% ‚Yb} qbea km qb cm jmsm il I vgdqma
qb pmm yb} gda yb} abd’q pjbv }~' Qjmd yb}’ee vgdq qb oiee km
qbkbssbv' Yb}’sm gee pi o$’
‚Db vm gsmd’q'’ g |bi`m pgia cmpiam jik$
Ag|m ebboma gda pgq qjmsm qjm c}sey kgd$
‚Jg|m yb} csb}fjq qjm kbdmy2’
‚Ymgj%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Gee bl iq2’ qjm c}sey kgd gpoma$
‚Ymp% I csb}fjq 6>>$’
Ag|m lmeq eiom jm vgp id pbkm aisqy c}pidmpp amge gda vgdqma qb
cm abdm viqj iq gp pbbd gp ~bppicem$ Qjm c}sey kgd ebboma gq jik
qjsb}fj qjm p}dfegppmp pb Ag|m `b}ea dbq pmm jip mymp dbs aia jm
vgdq qb$
‚Vjmsm ip iq2’
Ag|m a}f qjsb}fj jip ~b`omq gda csb}fjq b}q qjm !6>> abeegsp Ciee
jga emdq jik gda jgdama qjmk b|ms qb qjm c}sey kgd$ Qjm kgd
qbbo qjmk gda aia dbq m|md fegd`m gq qjmk vjmd jm pjbvma g
aipfs}dqema ebbo bd jip lg`m$ Ag|m aia dbq }damspqgda$
‚Qjip ip dbq qjm kbdmy%’ qjm c}sey kgd pgia ~}pjidf qjm kbdmy
cg`o idqb Ag|m’p jgdap$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 49/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m vgp `bdl}pma$
‚Vjgq ab yb} kmgd qjip ip dbq qjm kbdmy2 I jg|m m|md fi|md yb}gd mzqsg 7>>'’
‚Qjgq’p vjy iq ip dbq qjm kbdmy$’
‚Vjgq% yb} vgdq g <>>2 Qjgq’p lidm'’
‚Yb} `msqgidey ab dbq }damspqgda$’
‚]damspqgda vjgq2’
‚Vm vgdq b}s kbdmy% qjm g`q}ge bdm yb} ~i oma gq qjm lbbq bl qjip
cmd`j$’
‚Gsm yb} `sgxy2 I p~mdq iq gee$ I abd’q odbv vjmsm iq ip$’
‚Yb} bdey jg|m qbagy qb lida qjm smkgididf dbqmp bs yb} viee cm
`bdamkdma qb peg|msy gda egqms bd amgqj'’
‚Jbv gk I p}~~bpma qb odbv vjgq yb}s dbqmp ebbo eiom2’
‚Yb} p~mdq iq% yb} k}pq jg|m odbv qjmy vmsm p~m`ige' P~m`ige
cm`g}pm qjmy cmebdfma qb }p$’
Ag|m vgp s}ccidf jip lbsmjmga l}sib}pey% qjidoidf jgsa$ Jm pqbba
}~ gdfmsma$
‚Qjip ip gee h}pq g fgkm qb yb}%’ Ag|m pjb}qma% ‚Yb} gsm ~egyidf g
fgkm bd km$’
‚Iq ip b}s kbdmy% yb} pjb}ea jg|m dm|ms qgomd iq'’
‚C}q I aia gda dbv vjgq ab yb} vgdq2 Yb} `gd’q g``m~q gdy bqjms
kbdmy2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 50/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjm c}sey kgd vgp h}pq piemdq gda Ag|m vgp lieema viqj sgfm$ Jm
vgdqma qb gqqg`o qjm c}sey kgd qjgq vgp qbskmdqidf jik pb$ Jm
vgp kiavgy id qjm gis gcb}q qb qjsbv g ~}d`j vjmd jm jmgsa g
|bi`m$
‚Gsm yb} bo pbd2’ iq vgp qjm ~bei m blli ms gfgid$
Ag|m ikkmaigqmey `bk~bpma jikpmel gda q}sdma qb qjm blli`ms$
‚Jmeeb blli`ms%’ jm pgia$
‚Vmee% aiad’q yb}s fiselsimda pjbv }~2’
Ag|m ebboma gq qjm cmd`j gda vgp `g}fjq cy p}s~sipm vjmd jm
pgv db bdm$ Jm vgp pjgoidf gda p`sgq`jma jip jmga g ciq$
‚Ggj db% pjm aiad’q% I f}mpp pjm kgam g lbbe bl km%’ Ag|m eima$
‚Pbssy Oia'’
‚Iq’p bo% I cmqqms cm fbidf dbv$’‚Fbba e}`o dmzq qikm%’ qjm blli ms pgia$
‚Qjgdo yb}% I viee dmma iq$’
Ag|m emlq qjm p`mdm j}ssimaey% lmmeidf eiom jm vgp cmidf vgq`jma
mg`j pqm~ jm kgam$ Jm vgp lsifjqmdma% jm pw}mmxma qjm kbdmy
id jip ~b`omq gda jip p~isiqp lmee$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 51/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 77
‚Qjmpm ~mb~em vgdq qb oiee km% qjmy gsm ~egyidf pbkm fgkm bdkm'’ Ag|m `bk~egidma ciqqmsey qb Gddm gda Ciee$
‚I gk pbssy Ag|m%’ Gddm pgia$
‚I abd’q vgdq qb aim'’
Ag|m vgp `syidf bd`m kbsm% jm vgp pb glsgia$
‚Yb} viee dbq aim%’ Ciee gpp}sma$
‚C}q qjbpm ~mb~em gsm m|msyvjmsm% qjmy `gd fmq qb km lsbk
gdyvjmsm$’
‚Vmee gsm yb} p}sm2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚Vjgq ab yb} kmgd gk I p}sm2 Qjmy jga `bkm id kyyy jb}pm'
Fba'’
‚Pjj% vm fbq qb `bkm }~ viqj g ~egd$’
‚Fbpj% I gk fbidf qb aim% I gk fbidf qb aim'’ Ag|m `sima$
‚Pqb~ pgyidf qjgq%’ Ciee vgp gepb `ebpm qb `syidf$
‚Qjmy gsm fbidf qb oiee km% I gk fbidf qb aim% I gk pb p`gsma$ I
abd’q vgdq qb aim'’ Ag|m om~q pgyidf$
‚Pj}q }~'’ Gddm `b}ea dbq jg|m gdy kbsm bl iq$ ‚Yb} gsm fbidf qbaim bdey il yb} pgy pb'’
Qjm cbyp vmsm piemdq$ Gddm vgp gdfsy gq qjm vgy qjmy vmsm
jgdaeidf qjm piq}gqibd$
‚Vm viee lif}sm pbkmqjidf b}q%’ Gddm pgia$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 52/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Jbv2’ qjmy cbqj gpoma$
Gddm’p lg`m eiq }~% pjm pkiema$ Qjmy ebboma gq jms jb~ml}e$‚Vm viee lida qjm kbdmy qjgq cmebdfp qb qjmk$ Aiad’q yb} fmq g
vmmo lbs fi|idf qjmk g !7>> abeegs egpq vmmo2’
Qjmis lg`mp asb~~ma$
‚Ymgj I aia c}q vjmsm viee I lida qjm kbdmy I gesmgay p~mdq2 Fb
gda gpo gq qjm kgee2 Gp il gk `sgxy'’
Qjmsm vgp piemd`m$
‚Ag|m% aia yb} dbq pgy yb}s lgqjms vgp g ~simpq2’ Gddm gpoma
‚Ymgj%pb vjgq2 Yb} vgdq km qb fb gpo lbsfi|mdmpp cmlbsm I aim2’
‚Dbb% qjgq ip dbq qjm iamg%’ pjm pgia$
‚Bjj yb}’sm g fmdi}p Gddm'’ Ag|m p}aamdey h}k~ma gda oippma
Gddm$
Ciee ebboma gq qjm qvb ~}xxema$ Ag|m vgp |msy jg~~y$
‚Jg|m I kippma pbkmqjidf2’ Ciee gpoma$
‚I fg|m ky aga g !7>> abeegs'’ Ag|m pgia h}ciegdqey$
‚Dbv yb} `gee jik yb}s aga2’ Gddm qmgpma$
‚Qjgq ip gvmpbkm% yb} jg|m bdm kbsm vmmo qb ei|m%’ Ciee`memcsgqma$
‚Oipp km gfgid Ag|m%’ Gddm vgp pgyidf$
‚Bjj fmq ebpq'’ Ag|m pgia$
Jm oippma jms bd qjm lbsmjmga gdyvgy$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 53/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjgdo yb} pb k}`j Gddm$ I vgp glsgia I vgp fbidf qb aim qbagy bs
cm g peg|m'’
‚Peg|m bl vjgq2’
‚Qjmk I f}mpp$ Qjmy dm|ms qbea$’
‚Vjgq gsm vm vgiqidf lbs% emq’p fb%’ Gddm }sfma$
‚@gd vm }pm yb}s `gs Ciee2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Bl `b}spm'’
‚Yb} f}yp gsm qjm cmpq'’
Ag|m aia jip cmpq qb smkmkcms qjm vgy qb qjm `jg~me vjmsm jip
kbqjms jga idqsba}`ma jip lgqjms qb jik$ Glqms pbkm vsbdf q}sdp
qjmy lidgeey lb}da qjm `jg~me$ Ag|m h}k~ma b}q gp pbbd gp qjm `gs
pqb~~ma gda s}pjma id% jip lsimdap glqms jik$
Jm mdqmsma qjm `jg~me% iq vgp mk~qy c}q lbs g kgia vjb vgp`emgdidf$ Ag|m ~g}pma dbq odbvidf vjmsm qb ebbo$ Jm
g~~sbg`jma jms$
‚Jmeeb%’ jm pgia gvovgsaey$
Qjm egay aia dbq ebbo }~$ Pjm vgp gcb}q jms vbso gda jga gd
g~sbd b|ms jms kgia p}iq$ Jm vmdq `ebpms qb jms$
‚Mz`}pm km kipp%’ Ag|m pgia% ‚@gd I jg|m g vbsa2’Qjm egay pqb~~ma gda ebboma gq jik sgqjms ik~gqimdqey$
‚I gk ebboidf lbs g ~simpq dgkma Pqm|m$ Ip jm gsb}da2’ Ag|m gpoma
jms$
Pjm pjbbo jms jmga$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 54/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vmee ab yb} odbv vjmsm vm `gd lida jik2 Iq’p ik~bsqgdq%’ Gddm
pgia$
‚Ymgj% ~emgpm kg’gk$’
‚I ab dbq odbv jik%’ pjm gdpvmsma pik~ey gda vmdq gcb}q jms
vbso$
‚ emgpm% I gk amp~msgqm%’ Ag|m cmffma jms% ‚Jg|m yb} db
idlbskgqibd bl vjmsm I `gd lida jik sifjq dbv2’
Qjm egay ifdbsma qjmk `bk~emqmey$
‚Gsm yb} dmv jmsm2’ Gddm gpoma$
Db smp~bdpm$ Qjmy emlq gdfsy$
‚Vjgq ab vm ab dbv2’ Ciee gpoma$
‚Ky kbk pjb}ea odbv$ I viee gpo jms$ Emq’p j}ssy'’
Qjmy p~ma gebdf qb Ag|m’p jb}pm$ Vjmd qjmy fbq qjmsm% qjmy sgdidqb qjm jb}pm$
‚Kbk% kbk2’ Ag|m `geema amp~msgqmey$
‚Vjgq2 Pjm’p dbq jbkm2’ Gddm gpoma$
Ag|m vgp gjmga pmgs`jidf gee qjm sbbkp id qjm jb}pm$ Jm `gkm
cg`o id g pvmgq qb kmmq jip lsimdap$
‚Pjm’p dbq jbkm'’
Ag|m pgq abvd lgidq+jmgsqma$ Lg`m id gskp gda ~bppicey `syidf
piemdqey$ Jip lsimdap qbvmsma b|ms jik% qsyidf qb `bklbsq jik$
‚Vmee `gee jms$ Qikm ip s}ddidf b}q$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 55/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m fbq b}q jip `mee ~jbdm qb `gee jip kbqjms$ Jm vgp pjgoidf
gda `b}ea dbq qgeo ~sb~msey vjmd pjm gdpvmsma pb Gddm fsgccma
qjm ~jbdm lsbk jik qb p~mgo qb jip kbqjms$
‚Jmeeb2 Vmee% Ag|m dmmap qb pmm yb} dbv%’ Gddm pgia$
‚Ip gdyqjidf vsbdf2’ Asmv pb}dama `bd`msdma$
‚Dbq mzg`qey c}q+’
‚Iq’p bo%’ Asmv pgia% ‚I gk b}qpiam% viee qgeo qb yb} pbbd$’
Qjm eidm vmdq amga$
‚Pjm ip `bkidf%’ Gddm gpp}sma Ag|m$
Qjmsm vgp piemd`m$ Ciee vgp sma+myma gda jbeaidf Ag|m id `bklbsq$
Gddm vgp qjm bdey bdm vjb vgp `bk~bpma$ Asmv `gkm id gda
vgp jifjey `bd`msdma vjmd pjm pgv jms pbd `syidf$ Pjm sgd qb
j}f jik gda jm j}ffma jms cg`o$
‚Vjgq ip vsbdf amgs2’ Asmv gpoma jms pbd$
B|msvjmekma viqj mkbqibd% Ag|m `b}ea dbq p~mgo$
‚Vjgq jg~~mdma2’ pjm gpoma jip lsimdap$
Qjmy qbb vmsm piemdq$
‚Ag|m qmee jms%’ Gddm ~sbk~qma$
Ag|m pgq abvd gda `bk~bpma jikpmel$
‚Kbk% I vgdq qb pmm aga'’ vgp gee jm pgia$
‚Vjy2’ pjm vgp p}s~sipma$
‚I vgdq qb qgeo qb jik'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 56/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚C}q vjy2 Ip qjgq vjy yb} gsm `syidf2’
‚Kbk% iq’p g ebdf pqbsy$’‚Vmee qmee km'’
‚I viee mz~egid vjmd I `bkm cg`o$ I aia dbq lida jik gq qjm `jg~me%
vjmsm mepm `gd I lida jik2’
‚Pb yb} gesmgay pmgs`jma jik b}q2 Vjy aiad’q yb} qmee km2’
‚Qjmsm’p db qikm kbk% h}pq qmee km$ I odbv yb} odbv vjmsm I `gd
lida jik$’
‚Dbq }dqie yb} qmee km vjgq iq ip yb} vgdq qb p~mgo qb jik gcb}q$’
‚Kbk% ~emgpm$’
‚Abd’q m|md qsy$ Yb} jg|m cmmd g`qidf pqsgdfmey pid`m kbsdidf$
Vjgq gsm yb} jiaidf lsbk km2’ Asmv pjb}qma$
‚@gek abvd kbk% qjmsm ip dbqjidf vm gsm jiaidf$’
‚Bjj%’ Asmv eg}fjma g kb`o eg}fjqms% ‚iq ip kbdmy qjgq yb}
vgdqma j}j2 Yb} vgdq qb fb gpo yb}s lgqjms lbs kbdmy2’
‚Db kbk db'’
‚I viee fi|m yb} qjm kbdmy yb} vgdqma$ Jbv k}`j vgp iq2 Vjgq ab
yb} m|md vgdq qb ab viqj iq pb amp~msgqmey% c}y as}fp2’ pjm
pjb}qma$
Gddm gda Ciee vmsm p`gsma gq jbv Ag|m’p kbqjms vgp smg`qidf$
Qjmy aia dbq kb|m gd id`j gda eipqmdma qb m|msy vbsa$ Ayidf gda
vipjidf qjmy jga dbq cmmd viqdmpp qb qjip jmgqma gsf}kmdq bs vgp
iq jmgqma pjb}qidf$ Ag|m vgp dbv gdfsy$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 57/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Kbk% bo mdb}fj'’ jm pjb}qma gq jms% ‚I abd’q vgdq as}fp gda I
abd’q vgdq qb pmm aga qb gpo lbs kbdmy$ Qjmsm gsm pbkm ~py`jbp
b}q qjmsm vjb gsm qsyidf qb oiee km }dempp I smq}sd qb qjmk qjm
kbdmy I ~i`oma$’
‚Vjgq kbdmy2’
‚Qjm !7>> abeegs dbqm I fg|m yb}% ymgj iq cmebdfp qb qjmk gda dbv
qjmy vgdq iq cg`o bs mepm qjmy viee oiee km$’
‚I `gd fi|m yb} qjm kbdmy$’
‚Qjgq ip dbq qjm ~bidq kbk%’ Ag|m vgp pqiee pjb}qidf% ‚qjmy vgdq qjm
mzg`q dbqmp% qjm mzg`q bdmp'’
‚Vjgq2’ Asmv vgp p~mm`jempp% ‚qmee qjmk qb `bkm qb km% I viee qgeo
qb qjmk$’
‚Yb} `gd’q qgeo qb qjmk% qjmy gsm dbq dbskge ~mb~em% qjmy `bkm
gda aipg~~mgs$ Qjmy gsm jg}dqidf km kbk$’Kbqjms gda pbd j}ffma$
‚Dbv vjy ab yb} vgdq qb pmm yb}s lgqjms2’
‚I fg|m jik g !7>> abeegs dbqm% qjmy viee geebv km qb ei|m bdm kbsm
vmmo il I fi|m iq qb qjmk$ Fba% I jb~m jm om~q iq pglm' Kbk2’
‚Ymp amgs$’
‚Ab yb} pqiee jg|m qjm !7>> abeegs I fg|m qb yb}2’
‚Ggj db pbd% I ~}q iq id qjm cgdo gda egqms cb}fjq pbkm ei~pqi o$ I
gk pbssy'’
‚Iq’p bo$’
Pjm j}ffma jik kbsm qifjqey% pb glsgia bl ebpidf jik$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 58/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 73
Asmv jga fi|md jms pbd `emgs aism`qibdp bl fmqqidf qb jip lgqjms’p~eg`m$ Iq vgp dbq qbb ailli`}eq pid`m jm ei|ma sifjq cmjida qjm
`j}s`j$ Pjm jga vgdqma cgaey qb `bkm viqj qjmk c}q vgp glsgia
jms jipqbsy viqj jip lgqjms vb}ea idqms|mdm gda ls}pqsgqm m|msybdm
vji j vgp qjm emgpq qjidf pjm vgdqma$ Ag|m om~q ~smpp}sidf Ciee qb
asi|m lgpqms$
‚Qjip ip qjm p~mma eikiq Ag|m% il I fb lgpqms vm `b}ea fmq pqb~~ma$
Vm abd’q vgdq qjgq qb jg~~md dbv% ab vm2’
G piemd`m lbeebvma$ Gdzimqy vgp sipidf gp iq vgp gesmgay qvieifjq$
Ciee ~gsoma id lsbdq bl qjm `j}s`j vji j vgp eb`oma$ Qjmy fbq b}q
bl qjm `gs gda sgd gp lgpq gp qjmy `b}ea cmjida qjm `j}s`j vjmsm
qjmy pgv g pkgee jb}pm$ Iq vgp mgpy qb p~bq id qjm sipidf agsodmpp
cm`g}pm qjm eifjqp id qjm jb}pm vmsm q}sdma bd$
Ag|m vgp qjm bdm vjb odb`oma gq qjm abbs$ Jm odb`oma gee qbbpblqey c}q pbkmbdm b~mdma iq$ Iq vgp qjm ~simpq% pqiee id jip agso
`ebqjmp$ Jm pkiema eifjqey$
‚Jmeeb pbd$’
‚Jmeeb lgqjms$’
Jm ema qjmk id gda pms|ma qjmk `bllmm viqj pbkm `bboimp vjmd
qjmy jga pmqqema$ Jm pmmkma id db j}ssy qb gpo qjmk vjy qjmy
jga `bkm gp qjb}fj qjmy vmsm lsmw}mdq |ipiqbsp$ Ag|m vgp dbq
mgqidf gda jip lgqjms dbqi ma$
‚Gsmd’q yb} mgqidf gdy `bboimp Ag|m2’ Pqm|m qjm ~simpq gpoma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 59/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@g}fjq }dgvgsm% Ag|m qbbo g `bboim gda gqm iq sbcbqi`geey$ Pqm|m
vgp ebboidf lsbk bdm yb}df lg`m qb qjm dmzq$ Qjmy gee ebboma
}dmgpy gda jm vgp p}sm qjmy lmeq pb$
‚I vgp dbq mz~m`qidf yb}%’ Pqm|m pgia% ‚qjmpm k}pq cm yb}s lsimdap
Ag|m$’
Ag|m bdey dbaama$ Jm aia dbq odbv vjgq qb pgy% jm ebboma qb
Gddm lbs jme~ c}q pjm bdey pqgsma cg`o% pb aia Ciee$
‚Lgqjms% yb} jg|m g di m eiqqem jbkm%’ Gddm pgia id qjm gvovgsa
piemd`m$
‚Vjy% qjgdo yb}$ Yb} gsm g kbpq `jgskidf egay$’
Gddm pkiema$
‚Vm `gkm qb gpo g lg|bs%’ Gddm pgia$
Pqm|m ebboma p}s~sipma$
‚G lg|bs yb} pgy% vjgq `gd’q I ab lbs ky pbdp lsimdap2 Qmee km$’
‚Vm gsm gpoidf lbs qjm bllmsidf cbz% qjgq ip vjmsm yb} ~}q kbdmy
sifjq2’
Gee qjm bqjmsp ebboma gq jms eiom pjm vgp `sgxy% gee mz`m~q qjm
~simpq vjb aia dbq pmmk p}s~sipma gq gee$ Jm dbaama gq jms$
‚I viee cm cg`o id g kid}qm bs pb$’
Qjm ~simpq feiama b}q qjm sbbk eiom g fjbpq$ Ciee gda Ag|m pqgsma gq
jms kb}qj b~md$
‚Vjgq2’ Gddm gpoma% ‚Yb} aia dbq ebbo eiom yb} viee pgy gdyqjidf
lbs qjm dmzq `mdq}sy$’
‚Yb} vmsm pb ce}dq'’ Ag|m pgia$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 60/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Jkk% qjmpm `bboimp gsm fbba%’ qjgq vgp Ciee$
‚I jga qb cm ce}dq% vm gsm amp~msgqm% yb} gsm amp~msgqm gda ympCiee% qjmy gsm amei ib}p$ I vbdams il jm jgp pbkm kbsm$’
‚Ab yb} qjido jm ~}q qjm kbdmy id qjm bllmsidf cbz2’ Ag|m gpoma
`bd`msdma$
‚Bl `b}spm% vjmsm mepm `b}ea jm ~}q iq2 Id jip ~b`omq2 I ab}cq iq% jm
abmpd’q ebbo eiom g kgd vjb vb}ea pqmge lsbk qjm Ebsa'’
‚Pqmge lsbk qjm Ebsa2’ Ciee gpoma$
‚Jbv viee vm lida qjgq pidfem !7>> abeegs dbqm id qjm bllmsidf cbz2’
Ag|m vgp pqiee `bd`msdma$
‚Smegz% ab yb} pmm kgdy ~mb~em `bkidf gsb}da jmsm2 Qjip ~eg`m
ip eiom g amga qbvd% I `gd cmq qjgq !7>> viee cm qjm bdey kbdmy id
qjm vjbem agkd cbz'’ Gddm `j}`oema$
Qjmsm vgp gd }dvme`bkma piemd`m$ M|msybdm lmee piemdq gda amm~idqb qjmis bvd qjb}fjqp$ Qjm ~simpq feiama cg`o idqb qjm sbbk
`gssyidf g lgisey cif cbz% iq pmmkma jmg|y qbb$ Jm ~}q iq abvd
cmlbsm qjmk gda fmqqidf g pkgee omy lsbk jip ~b`omq b~mdma iq$ Jm
pgq abvd qisma lsbk `gssyidf qjm cbz$
‚Dbv Oiap%’ Pqm|m pgia% ‚iq ip dbq `}pqbk qb b~md qjip cbz cmlbsm
qjm mda bl g lbsqdifjq$’
‚Vm gsm pbssy%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Iq’p bo pbd$’
Ag|m gevgyp pj}aamsma vjmd jm jmgsa qjip kgd `gee jik pbd$ Jm
~}pjma b~md qjm eia bl qjm cbz gda vgp p}s~sipma gq vjgq jm pgv$
@bdqsgsy qb vjgq Gddm jga gpp}sma jik% qjm cbz vgp l}ee$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 61/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Aillmsmdq dbqmp bl kbdmy gda |gsib}p c}eoy md|meb~mp$ Gee qjmis
mymp vmsm c}efma id p}s~sipm$
‚Vjmsm aia gee qjip kbdmy `bkm lsbk2’ Gddm gpoma p}s~sipma$
‚Qjm jb}pm bl Fba ip dm|ms mk~qy bl fbba qjidfp%’ Pqm|m pgia$
‚Kbdmy ip g fbba qjidf2’ Ciee gpoma$
‚Ymp c}q qjm eb|m bl iq ipd’q'’
Gddm qieqma qjm cbz pb qjgq gee qjm kbdmy gda md|meb~mp lmee b}q$
‚C}q db bdm `bkmp jmsm'’ Gddm pgia$
‚H}pq cm`g}pm yb} abd’q `bkm jmsm ky `jiea% abmp dbq kmgd
m|msybdm mepm abmpd’q%’ jm qbea jms$
Pjm dbaama% fsmgqey j}kcema$ Pjm qjmd ebboma gq Ag|m vjb vgp
h}pq pqgsidf$
‚Jmy Ag|m% fmq vjgq yb} vgdqma'’ pjm pjb}qma gq jik$
Ag|m ebboma gp qjb}fj jm jga h}pq cmmd pdg~~ma b}q bl g qsgd`m$
Viqj qjm jme~ bl jip lsimdap jm cmfgd qb pm~gsgqm qjm kbdimp gda
~}pjidf gvgy qjm md|meb~mp$ Qjmy vmsm w}iqm g d}kcms bl !7>>
abeegs dbqmp gda Gddm jmea qjm ~iem id jms jgdap$
‚^}q cg`o qjm smpq%’ pjm bsamsma jms qvb lsimdap$
Qjmy aia pb gda qjmd ebboma gq jms gp qjb}fj vgiqidf lbs l}sqjms idpqs}`qibdp$
‚Ag|m%’ pjm qbea jik% ‚~i`o b}q yb}sp$’
‚Qjm dmvms bdmp$ Db amlm`qp'’ jm qbea jms$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 62/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Iq vgp mgpy qb ab qjgq gp kgdy bl qjm !7>> abeegs dbqmp id Gddm’p
jgda vmsm `s}k~ema }~ gda ebboma bea$ Qjmy vmsm emlq viqj bdey
li|m !7>> abeegs dbqmp qb ~i`o lsbk gda Ag|m vgp dbq `msqgid
vji`j bdm qb ~i`o$ Qjm ~simpq `emgsma jip qjsbgq gp lbs gqqmdqibd$
Qjmy jga lbsfbqqmd gcb}q jik qjsb}fjb}q qjm ~sb`mpp gda dbv
ebboma gq jik viam myma gp qjb}fj `g}fjq pqmgeidf$
‚Pbssy qb idqmslmsm%’ Pqm|m pgia id g `gek |bi`m% ‚vb}ea yb} jg|m
mdb}fj `bdliamd`m id km qb qmee km vjgq iq ip qjgq yb} gsm
pmgs`jidf lbs2’
Gee qjm pqgsmp dbv q}sdma qb Ag|m$ Jm pvgeebvma$
‚Ggj% g !7>> abeegs dbqm%’ jm pgia id g ebv |bi`m$
‚Db dmma qb cm gpjgkma pbd% ip qjmsm gdy ~gsqi`}egs dbqm qjgq yb}
kifjq cm ommd bd2’
Qjm pqgsmp vmdq cg`o qb qjm ~simpq$ Jm qgeoma gp qjb}fj jm odmv
vjgq qjmy vgdqma$
‚Vmee%’ Ag|m pvgeebvma gfgid% ‚iq’p qjm dbqm qjgq I fg|m qb yb}
vjmd I vgp jmsm viqj ky kbk$’
Qjm ~simpq eg}fjma eifjqey$
‚Yb} aia dbq fi|m iq qb km% yb} h}pq ~}pjma iq id ky jgdap'’ jm
eg}fjma$
‚Iq ip qjm pgkm qjidf ipd’q iq2’
‚Il yb} idpipq$ C}q vjy ab yb} vgdq iq2’
‚Iq ip g ~si|gqm kgqqms%’ Ag|m pgia amlmdpi|m$
‚I gk yb}s lgqjms I b}fjq qb odbv'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 63/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb} jg|m dm|ms cmmd ky lgqjms'’ Ag|m pjb}qma% ‚Vjmsm ip qjm
kbdmy2’
‚Jbv gk I p}~~bpma qb odbv vjmd I ~}pjma iq idpiam qjm bllmsidf
cbz2 Iq k}pq cm bdm bl qjm bdmp id yb}s lsimdap’ jgdap qjmsm$’
‚Qjmd I gk glsgia vm viee jg|m qb qgom iq gee'’ Ag|m pgia$
Gddm gda Ciee ebboma lsbk lgqjms qb pbd gda cg`o$ Qjmsm vgp g
peifjq smpmkcegd`m c}q iq `b}ea mgpiey cm kippma$ Qjm
`bd|mspgqibd vgp jmgqidf }~ gda Ag|m ebboma smgay qb emg|m pb
qjmy gepb pqbba }~$ Qjmy vmsm vgeoidf qbvgsap qjm abbs viqj qjm
li|m !7>> abeegs dbqmp vjmd qjm ~simpq p~bom cmjida qjmk$
‚Iq vgp di`m bl yb} qb |ipiq%’ Pqm|m pgia qjmd vgsdma% ‚c}q cmvgsm bl
pqmgeidf lsbk qjm Ebsap jb}pm$’
‚Vm gsm dbq pqmgeidf gda vm viee csidf qjm `jgdfm%’ Ag|m pjb}qma$
Qjmy vmsm gekbpq b}q qjm abbs$‚Qjbpm ~mb~em gsm dbq qb cm qbyma viqj%’ qjm ~simpq pjb}qma cg`o%
‚yb} `gd’q h}pq csidf li|m abeegs dbqmp% s}c iq bd qjmis lg`mp gda gpo
qjmk vji j bdm ip qjmisp'’
Ag|m gda jip lsimdap pqb~~ma sifjq id qjmis qsg`op$ Qjmy q}sdma gda
ebboma gq qjm ~simpq% pjb`o vsiqqmd gee b|ms qjmis lg`mp gda kb}qjp
gfgs$
‚Jbv ab yb} odbv gcb}q qjip2’ Ag|m pjb}qma gdfsiey$
‚Vjgq2 Gk I dbq mdqiqema qb odbv2’
Ag|m vgp gdfsiey vgeoidf cg`o qb qjm ~simpq vjb vgp jip lgqjms
gda pqbba dbpm qb dbpm ebboidf jik id qjm mym$
‚Aia kbk qmee yb} qjip2’ Ag|m gpoma pmmqjidf$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 64/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I vipj pjm jga%’ Pqm|m pgia pblqey$
‚Qjmd vjb aia2’ Ag|m pjb}qma$‚Qjmsm ip pb k}`j yb} abd’q odbv pbd%’ Pqm|m qbea jik$
Ag|m pgq abvd gda `sima$
‚Vjgq ip qjm kgqqms2’ Pqm|m gpoma$
‚I aia dbq vgdq yb} qb odbv qjip% iq’p mkcgssgppidf'’
‚Db iqp dbq% iq ip w}iqm dgq}sge% c}q pbkm ~mb~em }pm b}s dgq}sgeidpqid`qp qb jgsk }p$ Yb} ~i`oidf qjm kbdmy vgp dbq vsbdf% m|md
I `b}ea jg|m abdm iq$’
‚Ip m|msy kbdmy bd qjm sbga cga2’ Ag|m gpoma `gekidf abvd$
‚Db% qjgq bdm vgp h}pq ~egdqma lbs qjm pgom bl qjmis bvd ~emgp}sm$
Iq’p pbkmqjidf qjmy ab ymgsey qb qbskmdq qjm }de}`oy idai|ia}ge$’
‚Vjy aia iq jg|m qb cm km2’
‚Yb}s f}gsaigd k}pq jg|m lgiema% I gk pb pbssy pbd$’
‚Jbv ab yb} odbv gee qjip2’ Gddm gpoma$
Ciee gda Gddm gepb qbbo qjmis pmgq gda vmsm l}eey mdfsbppma id qjm
`bd|mspgqibd$
‚Iq ip g pq}ay I p~m`igeixma id% id ky pq}ay bl qjm lgiqj$’‚Gsm qjmsm p}`j qjidfp id qjm Cicem2’ Gddm vgp p}s~sipma$
‚Qjm Cicem ip amm~ms qjgd vjgq yb} qjido% bdey qjbpm vjbpm mymp
gsm b~mdma `gd pmm%’ Pqm|m qbea jms$
‚Vjgq ip fbidf qb jg~~md qb Ag|m2’ Ciee gpoma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 65/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Jm pjb}ea fi|m cg`o qjm kbdmy qb qjm `beem`qbsp gp gfsmma bs
qjmy viee omm~ qjmis vbsa gda ~}dipj jik qmssicey$’
Ag|m pj}aamsma$ Jm aia dbq odbv vjgq qb qjido% qjm vjbem
~sbp~m`q bl iq vgp p`gsy lbs jik% pbkmbdm vgp g`q}geey gpp}sidf
jik qjmpm ~mb~em vmsm smge gda qjgq ~mspbd vgp jip lgqjms$
‚I ab dbq jg|m gdy bl qjmis kbdmy%’ Ag|m ~gdi`oma$
‚Ab dbq vbssy%’ Pqm|m pbbqjma jip pbd% ‚I om~q qjm !7>> abeegs dbqm
yb} fg|m qb km$’
Ag|m qjsmv jip gskp gsb}da jip lgqjms$
‚Qjgdop'’
‚Aia yb} odbv iq vgp ~egdqma2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚Db I aia dbq$ I bdey om~q iq cm`g}pm iq vgp qjm lispq filq lsbk ky
pbd%’ Pqm|m pgia$ ‚Qjb}fj jm aia dbq fi|m iq gp p}`j$’
Ag|m ebboma gpjgkma$ Qjm ~simpq pqsbeema b}q bl qjm sbbk gda
`gkm cg`o viqj g eiqqem Cicem$ Jm b~mdma iq gda qjmsm vgp g !7>>
abeegs vji j jm ~eg`ma id jip pbd’p jgdap$
‚Iq vbd’q cm mdb}fj%’ Ag|m `bk~egidma$
‚Iq viee cm mdb}fj lbs qbagy% lbs qjip vmmo%’ Pqm|m gpp}sma jik$
‚Jbv vb}ea yb} odbv2’‚Cm`g}pm qjmy gsm dbq idqmsmpqma id qjm kbdmy% qjmy h}pq vgdq qb
qbskmdq yb}$ Qjmy odmv yb} vb}ea p~mda iq$ Vjgq g `jmg~ fgkm'’
‚Qjgq vb}ea kmgd qjmy gsm vgq`jidf km'’
‚Ymp c}q dbq gee qjm qikm% yb} gsm pglm jmsm lbs dbv c}q yb} k}pq
fb lgpq gda fi|m iq qb qjmk cmlbsm qjmy pmmo yb} b}q qjmkpme|mp$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 66/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vjmsm ab I qgom iq2’
‚Vjmsm yb} lispq `beem`qma qjm kbdmy% abd’q yb} odbv2’‚Gesifjq' Viee qjmy emq km bll lbs gdbqjms vmmo2’
‚Ymp qjmy viee% I ~sbkipm yb}% dbv fb'’
‚I gk p`gsma$’
‚Cm bl `b}sgfm pbd% fb cmlbsm qjmy pmmo yb} b}q$ Iq ip ik~bsqgdq
qjmy ab dbq odbv qjip ~eg`m'’
Ag|m qbbo qb emg|m gda jip lsimdap kgam qb lbeebv c}q qjm ~simpq
pqb~~ma qjmk$
‚Dbb%’ jm pgia% ‚qjip ip pbkmqjidf Ag|m k}pq ab gebdm$ Jm ip qjm
bdey ~egyms id qjm fgkm gda id|be|idf bqjmsp vb}ea cm
agdfmsb}pey lgqge'’
Ag|m emlq gebdm gda vgp pjgoidf id lmgs cy qjm qikm jm fbq qb qjm`gs$ Jm `b}ea dbq asi|m ~sb~msey gp m|msy pjgabv p`gsma jik$ Qjm
~gso vgp gevgyp vmee eiq gda Ag|m vgeoma `gsml}eey qiee jm fbq qb
qjm cmd`j$ Qjip qikm qjm c}sey kgd vgp gesmgay piqqma$ Jm jga jip
agso p}dfegppmp bd m|md qjb}fj iq vgp difjq$
‚I vgp fmqqidf ik~gqimdq%’ qjm kgd pgia gp pbbd gp Ag|m vgp
mgspjbq$
‚I gk pbssy%’ Ag|m g~bebfixma qsyidf jgsa dbq qb bllmda qjm kgd$
‚Aia yb} csidf qjm kbdmy2’
‚I csb}fjq ggg !7>>% iq’p yb}sp gk p}sm%’ Ag|m pqgkkmsma$
Ag|m jgdama qjm c}sey kgd qjm !7>> abeegs dbqm$ Qjm c}sey kgd
pkmeq iq% jm pmmkma pgqiplima gda ~b`omqma iq$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 67/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Ab I fmq gdbqjms vmmo bl eilm2’
‚Yb} kgy c}q abd’q qjido iq’p lbs lsmm$ Il yb} omm~ }p vgiqidf qbbebdf% vm viee pqgsq qb qgom yb}s ~si`mempp qbyp gp vmee'’
‚Vjgq2 Vjy2’
‚Fmq b}q bl jmsm cmlbsm I fmq gdfsy'’
Qjm c}sey kgd pdgsema gda Ag|m qbbo qb jip lmmq% dbq m|md p~gsidf
g kbkmdq qb ebbo cg`o h}pq id `gpm qjm kgd vb}ea `jgdfm jip
kida$
Jm jga dbq }damspqbba vjgq qjm c}sey kgd jga pgia dmiqjms aia
jm vipj qb$ Jm ~}pjma iq qb qjm cg`o bl jip kida$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 68/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 70
Iq vgp dbq ebdf glqms Ag|m jga smq}sdma qb jip lgqjms’p jb}pm qjgdjip kbqjms `geema jik bd jip `mee ~jbdm$
‚Cgcy% gk vbssima gcb}q yb}%’ pjm pgia pb}daidf pi o viqj vbssy$
‚Iq’p bo kbk% I gk viqj aga$’
‚Yb} gsm2 Vmee% jbv ip jm2’
‚Lidm% kbk ~emgpm I odbv yb} abd’q vgdq qb c}q `gd yb} `bkm2’
‚Vjy2’ pjm pb}dama }d`msqgid$
‚Aga odbvp gee gcb}q ky ~sbcemk% jm jga pq}aima iq gda odbvp
jbv qb jme~ km% I qjido$ Gda I abd’q vgdq yb} id qjm jb}pm gebdm$’
‚Bo$’
‚Qjgdop kbk$’
Asmv pbbd gssi|ma$ Pjm vgp jg~~y qb pmm jms pbd gda fg|m jik
g vgsk j}f$ Pjm jga gepb csb}fjq lbs jik g hmspmy id `gpm jm
vgp `bea$
Qjmy gee pgq id qjm ~simpqp ei|idf gda vmsm piemdq gda qjm ~simpq
fg|m Asmv pbkm `bllmm gda `bboimp$ Iq vgp bc|ib}p qb m|msybdm
mepm qjgq Pqm|m gda Asmv vmsm qsyidf jgsa qb g|bia mg`j bqjms’p
fgxm gda qjgq kgam m|msybdm |msy }dmgpy$
‚Pbbb%’ Gddm pgia csmgoidf qjm piemd`m% ‚Lgqjms% ip qjmsm gdy bqjms
vgy cmpiamp ~gyidf cg`o qjm kbdmy qjgq Ag|m `gd smammk
jikpmel2’
M|msybdm ebboma gq qjm ~simpq gda jmea qjmis csmgqjp id
gdqi`i~gqibd$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 69/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vmee% qjm mgpimpq ~gqj ip fi|idf qjmk cg`o qjmis kbdmy% qjm
geqmsdgqi|m jbvm|ms ip qbb `bk~emz gda gekbpq lgqge%’ Pqm|m qbea
qjmk$
‚Vjgq ab yb} kmgd2’
‚Yb} kmgd qjmsm’p gdbqjms vgy2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚I gk dbq qmeeidf yb} bl iq% Ag|m h}pq lida qjm kbdmy gda qjmy viee cm
bll yb}s qgie mgpy$’
‚C}q I p~mdq qjm kbdmy% I odbv I qjmsm’p db vgy I `gd fmq iq cg`o'’Ag|m `bk~egidma$
‚Yb} h}pq jg|m qb lida iq%’ Pqm|m qbea jip pbd$ ‚Qjmsm ip db bqjms
vgy$’
‚I qjb}fjq yb} h}pq pgia qjmsm vgp gdbqjms vgy%’ Asmv pgia gdfsiey$
‚Qjmsm ip c}q I vbd’q emq jik }pm iq$’
‚Vjy dbq2’
‚Iq’p qbb sipoy$’
‚Qbb sipoy2 Yb} kmgd yb} vbd’q qgom g sipo lbs ky pbd2’
‚Jm’p ky pbd qbb gda I qbb odbv vjgq ip cmpq lbs jik'’
‚Yb} odbv vjgq’p cmpq lbs jik2 Yb} cgsmey m|md odbv jik$ Qjm
bdey qjidf yb} odbv gcb}q jik ip jip pq}~ia egpq dgkm'’ Asmvp`smgkma$
‚I bdey aia vjgq vgp cmpq lbs }p'’ qjm ~simpq pjb}qma$
‚Yb}’sm h}pq g pmelipj% ikkgq}sm ikcm`iem'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 70/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb} jg|m db sifjq qb qmee km qjgq' I jg|m jme~ma yb} qjsb}fjb}q
jip eilm gda abd’q m|md g`q eiom I vgp dm|ms qjmsm$ Yb} gevgyp
`gkm qb km lbs ga|i m vjmd yb} dmmama iq'’
‚Ga|i`m2 Yb} `gee vjgq yb} fg|m qb km ga|i`m2 C}eepjiq' Yb} jg|m
dbq `jgdfma Pqm|m gda pbkmbdm eiom yb} ip dbq dmmama id qjm
`j}s`j bs gdyvjmsm mepm% dbq m|md gp g lgqjms'’
‚Vgq j yb}s kb}qj Asmv'’
Qjm sbv cmqvmmd qjm ~gsmdqp vgp jg|idf g dmfgqi|m qbee bd Ag|m%
jm lmeq |msy gdfsy$
‚PJ]Q ]^'’ Ag|m pjb}qma gdfsiey$
Qjmsm vgp piemd`m% qjm ~gsmdqp vmsm mkcgssgppma$ Ag|m `gekma
abvd$
‚H}pq qmee }p qjm bqjms b~qibd gda vm viee am`iam il vm vgdq qb qgom
qjm sipo bs dbq%’ Ag|m pgia pblqey$‚Lidm% I viee pjbv yb}'’ Pqm|m pgia$
Qjm ~simpq emlq qjm sbbk gda glqms pbkm qikm smq}sdma `gssyidf
csbomd lsgfkmdqp bl ce}m fegpp bd g qsgy$ M|msybdm myma jik
`}sib}p$
‚Vjgq ip qjgq2’ Ciee gpoma$
Qjm ~simpq ~eg`ma qjm qsgy bd qjm qgcem gda m|msybdm emgdma id lbs
g `ebpms ebbo$
‚Qjmpm gsm qjm lsgfkmdqp qjgq `b}ea cm }pma qb sm|i|m yb}s
f}gsaigd% qjmy vmsm pm`smqey csb}fjq qb ky abbs$ Pjm ip qjm bdey
bdm qjgq `gd jme~ yb} lifjq bll qjm `beem`qbsp$’
‚Yb} kmgd eiom `geeidf qjm amga%’ Ciee pgia% ‚db vgy% kgd$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 71/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vjb gsm qjm `beem`qbsp2’ Asmv gpoma w}imqey$
‚Qjmy gsm qjm pbs`msmsp giamp vjb qgom ~emgp}sm id qbskmdqidf qjmei|mp bl dbskge ~mb~em$’
‚Gda vjb gsm f}gsaigdp2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚Iq ip `bk~ei`gqma% qjmy gsm dbq bsaidgsy ~mb~em id qjm kia+eilm
vjbpm ampqidy ip qb ~sbqm`q dbskge ~mb~em jmsm bd mgsqj$’
‚Kia+eilm2 Gdfmep2’
‚Dbq gdfmep$ Qjmsm gsm `msqgid ~mb~em p~m igeey `jbpmd qb vbso gp
f}gsaigdp id qjm kia+eilm$ Qjmy ab dbq vbso bd `bk~emz kgqqmsp gp
gdfmep ab c}q sgqjms qsy qb ~sm|mdq qjm pbs`msmsp lsbk `g}pidf gdy
~sbcemkp eiom qjmpm$’
‚Yb} odbv qbb k}`j$’
‚Gp I pgia I pq}aima iq$’
‚Iq’p qbb k}`j pq}ll% pb}dap p}ssmge mz`m~q iq jgp jg~~mdma qb b}s
Ag|m$’
Qjmsm vgp piemd`m% m|msybdm vgp amm~ id qjb}fjq$
‚Aia yb} kmgd Ag|m’p ~bppicem f}gsaigd jga lgiema2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚Iq ip pb'’ Pqm|m gfsmma$
‚Gda qjm geqmsdgqi|m ip qb sm|i|m jms2’
‚Ymp$’
‚Jbv2’
‚Iq ip `bk~ei`gqma$’
‚Qmee }p ~emgpm$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 72/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vmee yb} jg|m qb sm`bdpqs}`q qjm ~im`mp bl fegpp idqb qjm cgee iq
bd`m vgp$ Gda qjmd yb} jg|m qb smqsg`m yb}s f}gsaigdp’ lbbqpqm~p
gda qsy qb sm|i|m jms c}q iq viee dbq cm mgpy gp qjm pbs`msmsp viee cm
bd yb}s qgie$’
‚Jbv vb}ea I smqsg`m jms pqm~p2 Abd’q I jg|m qb cm amga qb ab
qjgq2’
‚Qjm cgee vb}ea emga yb} qb smqsg`m qjm pqm~p$ Iq ip smgeey
`bk~ei`gqma gda I `gd’q qmee yb} kbsm$’
‚Vjy dbq2’
‚I aia dbq kgpqms gee qjgq I pq}aima qb cm jbdmpq pb I ab dbq odbv
m|msyqjidf$ Bdey qjmbsmqi geey% I jg|m dm|ms g`q}geey ~sg`qi`ma gdy
bl iq$’
‚Bjj'’
‚Ag|m% yb} h}pq jg|m qb lida qjm smkgididf = dbqmp$’‚I viee ab ky cmpq c}q I jg|m eiqqem jb~m$ Vjgq viee qjmy ab qb km il I
lgie2’
‚Yb} kgy vbso gp qjmis peg|m gda cm g `beem`qbs$ Gda il yb} gsm
dbq mlli imdq% yb} fmq oieema gda il yb} gsm e}`oy qjmy viee pik~ey
emg|m yb} ampbegqm$’
Ag|m qjb}fjq gcb}q qjm c}sey kgd gda vbdamsma il jm qbb jgacmmd gd bsaidgsy kgd eiom jm vgp$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 73/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 71
Ag|m vgp ommd bd lidaidf gee qjm !7>> abeegs dbqmp jm jga p~mdq$Mgsey qjm dmzq agy jm gda Ciee |mdq}sma id pmgs j bl qjm dbqmp$
Gddm jga dbq pjbvd }~ mz~egididf qjgq pjm vgp qisma gda vb}ea
hbid qjmk egqms$
‚Pb vjmsm ab vm pqgsq2’ Ag|m gpoma Ciee$
‚I abd’q odbv% Gddm fg|m km jms dm`oeg`m pb vm `b}ea smq}sd iq$’
‚I smgeey vipj qjidfp jgad’q q}sdma b}q qjip vgy$’
‚C}q qjmy aia% eilm ip `sgxy'’
‚Gda gk fbidf `sgxy viqj iq$ Bj% qjm ~eg`m vm cb}fjq Gddm’p
dm`oeg`m ip qjm pgkm bdm id vji`j vm cb}fjq Dgd`y’p asmpp
sifjq2’
‚Ymgj vjy2’
‚Vmee% I odbv qjmy vbd’q fi|m km qjm kbdmy }dempp I smq}sd qjm
fbbap$’
‚Gda pb2’ Ciee gpoma$
‚Dgd`y vb}ea jg|m qb smq}sd qjm asmpp% I smfsmqqma fi|idf iq qb jms
id qjm lispq ~eg`m$’
Ciee eg}fjma$
‚Dbv yb} pgy iq$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 74/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m gda Ciee vmdq qb Dgd`y’p jb}pm gda odb`oma gq jms abbs$ G
|msy pemm~y Dgd`y `gkm qb qjm abbs gda ebboma gq qjmk ~}xxema$
Pjm vgp vmgsidf lebvmsy ~ghgkgp$
‚Ji Dgd`y%’ Ag|m vgp kmeqidf$
‚Vjgq ip iq2 Iq’p pb mgsey%’ Dgd`y gpoma Ag|m$
Pjm q}sdma g ceida mym qb Ciee$
‚I `gkm qb gpo g lg|bs%’ iq vgp jgsa lbs Ag|m qb pgy$
‚@b}ead’q iq vgiq Ag|m2’
‚I gk pbssy I gvbom yb}$’
‚Iq’p lidm% vjgq ip iq2’
‚Vmee% I dmma yb} qb$$ }jj%’ Ag|m vgp pqgkkmsidf$
‚Dmma km qb vjgq2’ Dgd`y ebboma ik~gqimdq$
‚]j% qjm asmpp I fg|m yb}$’
‚Ymp2’
‚Vmee% Dgd`y I gk pbssy$’
Dgd`y vgp eipqmdidf gqqmdqi|mey jgdap `sbppma b|ms jms `jmpq$
Ag|m vgp `emgsey jg|idf g jgsa qikm$
‚Jkkk% bo emq km ~}q iq pik~ey$ I vgdq qjm asmpp cg`o'’
‚Vjgq asmpp2’
‚Qjm sma asmpp I fg|m yb} gp g filq'’
‚I qjb}fjq iq vgp g filq$’
‚Iq vgp c}q I jg|m qb smq}sd iq qb qjm pqbsm lbs g sml}da'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 75/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vjgq% smq}sd ky asmpp2 Yb} gsm dbq smq}sdidf ky asmpp$’
‚C}q I jg|m qb$’‚Yb} viee dbq smq}sd }damspqgda2 Cm`g}pm I vbd’q fi|m iq cg`o$’
Qjm abbs pegkkma id qjmis lg`mp$ Ciee gda Ag|m pqbba qjmsm d}kc$
‚Pbssy Ag|m% qjip ip g ebpq `gpm% pjm ip omm~idf qjm asmpp$’
‚Yb} abd’q jg|m qb s}c iq id'’
‚Emq’p fb qb qjm kgee gda qsy b}s e}`o$’
‚I p}sm dmma qjgq e}`o$ Qjip Dgd`y ip idpgdm$’
‚Aia yb} smgeey mz~m`q jms qb smq}sd qjm asmpp2 Yb}’sm `sgxy kgd$’
Ag|m gda Ciee smq}sdma qb qjm pjb~~idf kgee vjmsm qjmy jga
~}s`jgpma qjm dm`oeg`m$ Iq ~sb|ma ailli }eq qb lida qjm sifjq pjb~
qjmy vmsm ebboidf lbs c}q glqms g vjiem qjmy aia$ G yb}df pgempkgd
vgp ebboidf cbsma gq qjm `b}dqms% qjmy g~~sbg`jma jik$ Ag|m aiadbq vgdq qb pgy gdyqjidf m|md viqj Ciee ~boidf gq jik$
‚Jmy kgd% vm cb}fjq pbkmqjidf jmsm gda vgdq qb smq}sd iq%’ Ciee
pgia$
‚Mz`jgdfm bdey%’ qjm pgempkgd pgia ce}dqey$
‚Db vm vgdq b}s `gpj cg`o$’
Qjm yb}df kgd ebboma gq qjmk gp qjb}fj m|md kbsm cbsma cy
qjm `bd|mspgqibd$
‚Mz`jgdfm bdey% vjgq aia yb} ~}s`jgpm2’
Ag|m pjbvma jik qjm dm`oeg`m$
‚Qjgq’p b}sp gesifjq%’ qjm pgemp kgd gakiqqma% ‚ip iq csbomd2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 76/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Db% vm h}pq kgam g vsbdf ~}s`jgpm%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Qjmd kgom qjm sifjq ~}s`jgpm dbv%’ jm p}ffmpqma$‚Db vm vgdq qjm kbdmy cg`o%’ Ciee pgia$
‚Ip qjip g p`gk bs pbkmqjidf2’
‚Qjip ip ~bidqempp kgd%’ Ag|m pgia qb Ciee$
‚@gd yb} eipqmd qb yb}spmel Ag|m2 Vm dmma qjm kbdmy cg`o'’
‚@gd yb} qgom yb}s `bd|mspgqibd b}qpiam2’ qjm pgempkgd gpoma$
‚ emgpm kgd% ab yb} jg|m qjm `gpj vm }pma qb c}y qjip dm`oeg`m
gcb}q g vmmo bs pb gfb2’
‚Gsm yb} `sgxy2’
‚Db% ~emgpm vm dmma qjm kbdmy vm }pma qb ~}s`jgpm qjip
dm`oeg`m'’
‚Yb} f}yp gsm cmfiddidf qb lsifjqmd km pb gk `geeidf qjm `b~p%’
qjm pgempkgd qjsmgqmdma$
‚Vjy2’
‚Emg|m bs gk `geeidf qjm `b~p2’
‚Iqp lidm% vm gsm emg|idf$’
Ag|m asgffma Ciee b}q cy qjm jgda$
‚Vjgq ab yb} qjido yb}’sm abidf2’ Ciee gpoma jik$
‚Jm vb}ea jg|m `msqgidey `geema pm`}siqy bd }p' Gda I abd’q qjido
jm jgp qjm kbdmy$’
‚Jbv vb}ea yb} odbv2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 77/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Kbdmy `is`}egqmp Ciee% vm gee odbv qjgq gda iq vgp qbb ebdf gfb%
gdyvgy$ Jm vgpd’q m|md qjm f}y vjb pbea }p qjm dm`oeg`m$’
‚Gsm yb} fi|idf }~ dbv2’
‚Ip iq ~bppicem lbs pbkmbdm qb fi|m }~ bd qjmis eilm2’
‚Vmee qjmd vjgq2 Pjb}ea vm fb sbc qjm cgdo qb lida yb}s dbqmp%
m|md qjmd yb} vb}ea m|md sm`bfdixm qjgq pidfem !7>> abeegs$’
‚Yb} gid’q jme~idf km jmsm$’
‚Yb} vgddg ab iq yb}s aga’p vgy2’
‚Qbb `bk~ei gqma gda jm abmpd’q m|md odbv jbv qb fb gcb}q iq$’
‚Vjgq dbv2’
‚Emq’p pmmo b}q qjgq cmffgs gda pmm il jm pqiee jgp qjm !7>> abeegs
dbqm$’
‚I ab}cq iq'’
‚ emgpm abd’q pgy qjgq'’
‚Vjgq viee yb} ab il jm abmpd’q jg|m iq2’
‚Qjmd I aim'’
Ag|m vgp ebboidf febbky gda jip pjb}eamsp vmsm asbb~ma$ Qjmy
kmq Gddm bd qjmis vgy b}q$‚Vjgq jg~~mdma2’ pjm gpoma$
‚Abd’q gpo%’ Ciee qbea jms$
Jm jgdama cg`o qb jms qjm dm`oeg`m pjm jga smq}sdma$
‚I `gd ikgfidm Dgd`y aia dbq vgdq qb smq}sd jms asmpp%’ Gddm pgia$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 78/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjmy eg}fjma cemgoey gcb}q iq$ Qjmy vgeoma qb vjmsm Ag|m gda
Ciee jga pmmd qjm cmffgs gda vmsm gegskma qb pmm jm vgp dbq
qjmsm$ Qjmis lg`mp vmsm p`smvma viqj ciqqmsdmpp$
‚Vjgq ip vsbdf2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚Jm ip dbq vjmsm jm pjb}ea cm%’ qjmy `bk~egidma$
‚Vjb pgia cmffgsp abd’q jg|m jbkmp% vm jg|m qb pmgs j jik b}q%’
Gddm md`b}sgfma$
‚Vjmsm ab vm pqgsq2’
‚Vjmsm ab yb} mz~m`q g cmffgsp jbkm qb cm2’
‚Id qjm f}qqms2’
‚Sifjq$’
‚Jm k}pq jg|m gesmgay p`smvma ky kbdmy cy dbv'’ Ag|m pgia
ciqqmsey$‚Ab dbq ebpm jmgsq Ag|m% gq emgpq dbq dbv bs jmsm'’
Qjmy vmdq qb qjm f}qqmsp gda iq vgp agso id qjmis m|md il iq vgp
agyeifjq$ Qjm ~}qsia pkmee bl }sidm% amga sgqp gda ~b|msqy jiq qjmk
id qjm lg`m$ Qjm pkmee vgp pb qmssicem qjgq qjmy `b|msma qjmis
kb}qjp viqj qjmis pjisqp$
Db bdm kidama qjmis ~smpmd`m gp kbpq bl qjm cmffgsp om~q qbqjmkpme|mp$ Qjmy pmgs`jma lsbk bdm cmffgs qb qjm dmzq$ Qjm
cmffgs qjmy vmsm ebboidf lbs vgp lgpq gpemm~ id g `bsdms vjmd
qjmy lb}da jik$
‚Pjb}ea vm vgom jik2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Pjb}ead’q vm2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 79/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vbd’q jm cm kga$’
‚Abmp iq kgqqms2’‚Db iq abmpd’q$’
Qjmy ebboma gq mg`j bqjms$
‚Vmee vjb viee vgom jik2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚Yb}2’ Ag|m pgia$
‚I vbd’q% I abd’q vgdq qb qb}`j jik$’
‚Qjgq’p s}am qb pgy$’
‚I gk pbssy c}q jm’p pb lieqjy% yb} vgom jik$’
‚Db%’ Ag|m sml}pma$
Qjmy q}sdma qb ebbo gq Ciee$
‚Abd’q ebbo gq km% I gid’q qjm bdm cmidf jg}dqma cy pbkm pbs`msmsplbs kbdmy$’
‚Db dmma qb cm kmgd kgd'’
‚Pbssy$’
‚Pbkmbdm vgom jik bo% I `gd’q pqgy jmsm gee agy% I’ee lgidq$’
Ag|m }pma jip lmmq qb qsy gda sb}pm qjm pemm~idf kgd qb db g|gie$Qjm cbqqemp dmgscy ~sb`egikma qjgq jm kifjq jg|m cmmd asidoidf
jmg|iey$ Ag|m lmeq eifjq jmgama gda jip jb~m asb~~ma cy g
kiempqbdm$ Qjip cmffgs jga ~sbcgcey vgpqma gee jip kbdmy bd
asidop$ Gddm sgd b}q% jms lsimdap lbeebvma$ Pjm vgp qjsbvidf }~
bd qjm lebbs vjmd qjmy `g}fjq }~ viqj jms$
‚Gddm% gsm yb} bo2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 80/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Ab I ebbo bo2’ Gddm gpoma egkmey gda qjsmv }~ pbkm kbsm$
Gddm qjmd pqbba }~ qjb}fj g eiqqem cmdq gda jgdap bd jms pqbkg`j$
‚Vjgq ip vsbdf Gddm2’
‚I h}pq vgdq qb fmq b}q bl jmsm lgpq$’
‚Yb} pjb}ea fb jbkm$’
‚I h}pq dmma lsmpj gis% ~emgpm$’
Gddm pgq cy qjm sbgapiam$
‚I gk bo jmsm%’ pjm pgia% ‚fb cg`o gda lidipj yb}s c}pidmpp$ Qjgq
~eg`m ip dg}pmgqidf$ ^emgpm cm lgpq gcb}q iq$’
‚Gsm yb} p}sm yb} viee cm lidm jmsm2’ Ciee vgp `bd`msdma$
‚Abd’q vbssy gcb}q km% iq’p Ag|m vjb `b}ea cm amga cy dmzq
vmmo'’
‚Qjgdop Gddm%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Bjj viee yb} j}ssy2’
Ag|m gda Ciee smq}sdma qb qjm cmffgs$ Qjip qikm qjmy aia dbq amegy
pjgoidf jik gvgom$
‚Vjgq ab yb} vgdq2’ qjm cmffgs vgp gdfsy$‚Vm vgdq qb qgeo qb yb}%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚I abd’q vgdq qb qgeo qb yb}%’ jm pjb}qma gq qjmk$
‚Lidm% h}pq fi|m km cg`o qjm !7>> abeegs dbqm I fg|m yb}$’
‚Vjgq2’ qjm cmffgs ebboma ~}xxema$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 81/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Fi|m km cg`o ky kbdmy%’ Ag|m pjb}qma$
‚I p~mdq iq% vjb gsm yb} gdyvgy2’Ag|m’p jmgsq asb~~ma% jm cmfgd qb vgeo gvgy$
‚Vgiq'’ qjm cmffgs `geema% ‚I jg|m yb}s kbdmy% qsmgq km qb g lidm
e}d`j lispq'’
‚Jbv pjb}ea vm cmeim|m yb}2’ Ciee gpoma$
Qjm cmffgs vg|ma qb qjmk g !7>> abeegs dbqm vji`j jm bcqgidma
lsbk jip ~b`omq$ Ag|m `b}ea dbq smpipq c}q pkiem% jm vgdqma qb
fsgc qjm kbdmy$
‚Dbq cmlbsm ky e}d`j'’ qjm cmffgs pkiema qbb$
Qjmy vgeoma gvgy lsbk qjm f}qqms viqj qjm cmffgs id qjmis
`bk~gdy$ Gddm jga ebboma gq qjmk p}s~sipma c}q jga dbq pgia g
vbsa id ~sbqmpq$ Bd qjmis vgy qjmy sm`mi|ma g cieeibd pqgsmp$ Qjm
cmffgs vgp idamma g ~}cei gqqsg`qibd$
Qjmy qbbo jik qb g lgpq lbba smpqg}sgdq vjmsm jm bsamsma gee qjm
lbba jm `b}ea pmm$ Qjm qsib vgq`jma jik mgq gp vmee gp qjm smpq bl
qjm smpqg}sgdq$ Jm vbelma abvd qjm vjbem qgcem bl lbba$ Gddm
ebboma eiom pjm vb}ea qjsbv }~ gfgid gda qjmy vmsm vjmd fega
pjm aia dbq$ Glqms jm jga lidipjma jip lbba% qjm cmffgs ebboma gq
qjmk pkieidf$
‚Gsm yb} p}sm I pjb}ead’q jg|m `bdqsic}qma qjm !7>> abeegs qb
c}yidf qjip lbba2’
Qjmy bdey ebboma gq jik aipf}pqma$
‚Fi|m km qjm kbdmy%’ Ag|m pmmqjma$
‚Vjgq kbdmy2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 82/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjm !7>> abeegs dbqm'’
Qjm cmffgs eg}fjma$ Qjm qsib ebboma gdfsy$‚I viee fi|m iq qb yb} c}q lispq I dmma g cgqj gda pbkm dmv `ebqjmp$’
‚Gsm yb} `sgxy2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚Jmy% gk dbq qgeoidf qb yb} fise'’ qjm cmffgs pgia$
‚Abd’q qgeo qb ky lsimdap eiom qjgq%’ Ag|m qbea jik$
‚Abd’q yb} vgdq yb}s kbdmy cg`o2’
‚I ab$’
‚Qjmd I qgeo qjm vgy I vgdq$’
‚Yb} vbd’q cm kmgd qb ky lsimdap% qjmy ~gia lbs yb}s kmge yb}
odbv$’
‚Lidm% I’ee cm di`m c}q I pqiee vgdq ky lsmpj `emgd cgqj id g di`m
cgqjsbbk$’
‚Gddm% Ciee% odbv gdy ~}cei` cgqjsbbkp2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Ymgj p}sm% qjmy gsm gekbpq m|msyvjmsm$’
‚Jbv p}sm gsm vm jm vbd’q pei~ }p gda s}d gvgy2’
Qjmy qgeoma gp qjb}fj jm vgp dbq qjmsm$
‚I abd’q odbv'’
‚Vm’ee pqgda f}gsa gq qjm abbs$’
‚G ~}cei` cgqjsbbk% qjgq ip bo gda `jmg~$’
‚Ymp% I qjido I odbv bdm dmgs jmsm$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 83/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Qjm cmffgs `emgsma jip qjsbgq$ Qjmy ebboma gq jik$
‚I k}pq jg|m lbsfbqqmd qb kmdqibd% I abd’q vgdq g ~}cei` cgqjsbbk%I’|m jga mdb}fj bl qjbpm gesmgay$ I jga id kida% vmee% g di`m jbkm
cgqjsbbk% `bxy yb} odbv$ Kgycm gq yb}s jb}pm$’
Qjmy pqgsma gq jik cmvieama cy jip smw}mpq$
‚Abd’q ebbo gq km eiom qjgq% gk dbq gpoidf qbb k}`j'’ jm pgia$
‚Vjb ab yb} qjido yb} gsm% kgoidf bsamsp eiom qjgq2’ Ag|m gpoma
gdfsy$
‚Yb} vgdq yb}s !7>> abeegs bs dbq2’
Ag|m vgp gq g ebpp gda jip lsimdap ebboma gq jik viqj ~iqy$
‚Iqp lidm%’ Gddm pgia% ‚jm `gd jg|m g cgqj gq ky ~eg`m$’
‚Qjgdop pb k}`j Gddm$’
‚Gj db% I vgdq yb}s ~eg`m eiqqem cby%’ qjm cmffgs ~bidqma gq Ag|m$
‚Vjy2’
‚Emq’p h}pq pgy% I eiom jbv yb} ebbo$ Yb} ebbo oidams qjgd jms%’ jm
eg}fjma$
Qjm lsimdap ebboma gq mg`j bqjms `bdl}pma$
‚Vjgq2’ qjm cmffgs gpoma eg}fjidf% ‚yb} g`q eiom yb} pqiee ei|m viqjyb}s kbk$’
‚G`q}geey I pqiee ei|m viqj ky kbk gda I pmm dbqjidf vsbdf viqj
qjgq$’
Qjm cmffgs eg}fjma kbsm eb}aey gda qjmy fbq ~emdqy kbsm pqgsmp
lsbk qjm bqjms qgcemp id qjm smpqg}sgdq$ Qjm smpqg}sgdq bvdmsp aia
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 84/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
dbq eiom qjmis dmv `}pqbkms% iq pjbvma bd qjmis lg`mp$ Qjmy jga
~sbcgcey h}pq om~q jik qjmsm cm`g}pm jm jga fi|md qjmk k}`j
~sbliq cy bsamsidf lbba qjgq `b}ea jg|m cmmd mgqmd cy abxmdp bl
~mb~em$
‚I gk p}sm yb}s kbk vbd’q kida jg|idf g lsimda b|ms lbs g pjbvms
gda il gk e}`oy aiddms$ Bd qjm vgy% yb} `gd fmq km g pjg|idf
pqi o gda qbbqjcs}pj qbb%’ jm pkiema mz~bpidf jip ymeebv qmmqj$
Ag|m vgp mdqismey p~mm`jempp gda aia dbq pgy g vbsa$
‚Pjgee vm fmq fbidf qjmd% gk fmqqidf cbsma jmsm }dempp bl `b}spm
yb} vgdq km qb bsams gdbqjms sb}da gda id|iqm lsimdap qbb'’
Qjgq fbq qjmk kb|idf$ Ag|m pmmkma pb vmgo viqj ls}pqsgqibd gda
pgia dbqjidf gee qjm vgy qb jip jbkm% dmiqjms aia jip lsimdap$ Qjm
cmffgs vgp qjm bdey bdm qgeoidf gee qjm vgy gp qjb}fj qsyidf jip
cmpq qb qg}dq Ag|m vjb smkgidma }dsmp~bdpi|m$ Qjmy fbq qb jip
~eg`m gda mdqmsma qjm jb}pm$ Qjm pjb`oma vsiqqmd bd Asmv’p lg`mvjmd pjm pgv qjmk vgp ~si`mempp$ Pjm ebboma qb Ag|m lbs gd
mz~egdgqibd c}q fbq dbdm$
Ag|m pik~ey ema qjm cmffgs qb qjm cgqjsbbk$ Gddm gda Ciee pgq id
qjm ei|idf sbbk viqj Asmv$ Pjm ebboma gq qjmk% pjb`o pqiee
smfipqmsma bd jms lg`m$
‚Vjmsm ip qjgq qjidf lsbk2’ Asmv gpoma pebvey$
‚Vmee%’ Gddm qsima jgsa qb mz~egid% ‚jkk% jm ip$$ gjj$’
‚Vjb ip qjgq qjiml yb}’|m csb}fjq idqb ky jb}pm$’
‚Kg’gk `gek abvd% jm ip qjm cmffgs gda jm jgp g !7>> abeegs
dbqm qjgq Ag|m fg|m qb jik$ Jm kgam }p ab gee oidap bl lg|bsp qb
fi|m }p cg`o qjm kbdmy$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 85/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vjgq oida bl lg|bsp2’
‚Vm bdey cb}fjq jik lbba smgeey%’ Ciee pgia$‚Iq vgp g ebq bl lbba Ciee$’
‚Aia jm fi|m ky pbd qjm kbdmy2’
‚Jm vgdqma qb qgom g pjbvms lispq id yb}s jb}pm gda jg|m lsmpj
`ebqjmp$’
‚Qjgq kgd ip `sgxy% qjgdo yb} |msy k}`j c}q jm ip dbq p~mdaidf
gdbqjms kid}qm id ky jb}pm$ Jm kgy m|md cm ~egyidf viqj yb}
f}yp$’
‚Jm pjbvma }p qjm dbqm%’ Ciee pgia$
‚Jm ip fi|idf qjgq dbqm sifjq dbv gda emg|idf ky jb}pm$ Vjgq g
lbbe% qgoidf ga|gdqgfm bl oiap'’
Asmv jga p~mmaiey aipg~~mgsma qjsb}fj g abbs$ Ciee gda Gddmvgq`jma jms fb$ Qjgq cmffgs vb}ea p}sm cm id qsb}cem% qjmy
qjb}fjq$ Asmv s}pjma qb qjm cgqjsbbk% gdfsy gq jbv qjip cmffgs
vgp kgdi~}egqidf jms pbd idqb abidf jik lg|bsp$ Pjm lb}da Ag|m
pqgdaidf f}gsa gq qjm cgqjsbbk abbs$
‚Gda vjgq ab yb} qjido yb} gsm abidf2’ Asmv gpoma gdfsiey$
‚Kgoidf p}sm jm abmp dbq pqmge gdy pbg~%’ Ag|m pgia
}d`bd`msdma$
‚Yb} csidf g pqsgdfms idqb b}s jb}pm gda dbv yb} vgdq qb kgom
p}sm jm abmpd’q pqmge gdy pbg~% vjgq jgp fbqqmd idqb yb}2’
‚Jm jgp qjm !7>> abeegs I dmma qb ei|m gdbqjms vmmo$ I qjido ky egpq
vmmo bd mgsqj%’ Ag|m pgia pgaey$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 86/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Jip kbqjms j}ffma jik$ Pjm egqms pgq bd qjm lebbs gda vgiqma lbs
qjm cmffgs qb lidipj jip cgqj$ Jm pgq dmzq qb jms% qjmy vmsm qisma bl
vgiqidf$
‚Vjgq ip qgoidf jik pb ebdf2’ Asmv gpoma pqgdaidf }~$
‚Jm’p pjg|idf kbk% lbs bd`m glqms g qjb}pgda ymgsp$’
‚Jm’p fbddg dmma g p`ippbsp qb `}q bll qjgq cmgsa I pgv$ Emq km
`jm`o bd yb}s lsimdap$’
Asmv fbq }~ gda vmdq qb hbid Gddm gda Ciee$ Pjm pms|ma qjmkpbkm lbba gp qjmy vmsm j}dfsy$ Iq vgp g ebdf vjiem egqms vjmd
Ag|m pjbvma }~ viqj qjm cmffgs% m|msybdm vgp viam myma viqj
p}s~sipm vjmd qjmy pgv jik$
Qjm cmffgs vgp `emgd gda jga `jgdfma idqb g ~gis bl Ag|m’p
`emgd `ebqjmp gda pjbmp$ Jip lg`m% `emgdey pjg|md sm|mgema jbv
jgdapbkm jm vgp gda jip vmq jgis qima id g odbq mk~jgpixma qjgq
cmg}qy$ Qjmy `b}ea dbq qgom qjmis mymp bll jip fbba ~jypiw}mmiqjms$
‚Jmeebbbb lgkiey%’ jm pgia pmmidf qjmis p}s~sipma ebbop$ ‚@gd I
pmgq2 Gk pb qisma$’
‚Bjj p}sm'’ qjgq vgp Asmv$
Jm pgq abvd gda ebboma kbsm bl g fmdqemkgd qjgd g cmffgs$ Jm
k}pq jg|m cmmd id jip mgsey bs kia+qjisqimp$ Jm `g~qi|gqma gee qjmis
gqqmdqibd viqj mg`j kb|mkmdq jm kgam gda m|msy vbsa jm p~bom$
Asmv smgeixma qjip gda lbs`ma jmspmel qb pmsib}pdmpp$
‚Jg|m yb} fi|md ky pbd cg`o jip !7>> abeegs dbqm2’ pjm gpoma$
‚I viee'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 87/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb} viee2 Fi|m iq qb jik dbv'’
‚Db kg’gk c}q I viee egqms$’‚Vjgq kbsm ab yb} vgdq2 Jgpd’q jm fi|md yb} mdb}fj lg|bsp2’
‚Jm jgp bdey abdm jikpmel g lg|bs g`q}geey$’
‚Vjgq lg|bs2 Abd’q vgpqm b}s qikm$’
‚Yb} pjb}ea jmgs km b}q%’ qjm cmffgs ebboma gq Ag|m% ‚ky dgkm ip
Csip$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 88/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 7=
Qjmy vmsm gee `}sib}p gq vjgq Csip jga qb pgy$ Qjip qsgdplbskmacmffgs vgp asgvidf fsmgq gqqmdqibd qb jikpmel kgidey cm`g}pm bl
jbv jgdapbkm jm vgp gda gepb gp qjmy vmsm iq`jidf qb jmgs vjgq
jm jga qb pgy$
‚Ky dgkm ip Csip gda I odbv jbv yb} `gd amlmgq qjm `beem`qbsp$’
‚Jbv ab yb} odbv gcb}q qjmk2’ Ag|m gpoma gpqbdipjma$
‚I pkmeq qjm dbqm gda I odmv yb} vb}ea `bkm cg`o lbs iq$ I
sm`bfdixma iq ikkmaigqmey$’
‚Jbv ip qjgq ~bppicem2’ Asmv gpoma$
‚Cm`g}pm I bd`m vgp g `beem`qbs$’
Jmg|y pifjp bl p}s~sipm vmdq g`sbpp qjm sbbk$
‚Ab dbq cm qbb p}s~sipma% I bdey ei|ma id ampbegqibd gp g cmffgs cm`g}pm I ce}damsma bd ky hbc gda qjmy oi oma km b}q' I `gd jme~
yb} Ag|m gda yb} jg|m jme~ma km$’
‚Jbv jg|m I jme~ma yb}2’
‚Yb} fg|m km g jb~m$ Il yb} jgad’q `bkm qb km I vb}ea jg|m
qjb}fjq ky eilm vgp b|ms c}q dbv I gk p}sm I gk dbq ymq smhm`qma$
Qjmy dm|ms emg|m gdybdm gei|m c}q qjmy p~gsma km gda qjmd yb}`gkm gebdf$’
‚Jbv ebdf jg|m yb} ei|ma gp g cmffgs2’
‚Qjm egpq li|m ymgsp% iq vgp g qg}dqidf qikm$ I jg|m dm|ms cmmd pb
ebv gda cmpiamp% I vgp dbq g cmffgs$’
‚Db2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 89/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I vgp h}pq jbkmempp$ Ky lgkiey qjidop km ebdf amga gda I jg|m
dm|ms cbqjmsma qjmk gfgid cm`g}pm I jg|m abdm pb k}`j m|ie gp
g `beem`qbs gda `jgdfma pb k}`j qbb$’
‚Vjy% aiad’q yb} m|md qsy qb `bddm`q viqj qjmk2’ Gddm gpoma$
‚I ab dbq ampms|m g fbba eilm glqms qjm qjidfp I aia% I gk pqiee gdfsy
gcb}q iq$ Qjmy aia dbq m|md sm`bfdixm km vjmd I pjbvma kypmel
qb qjmk$ Iq’p }dlbsq}dgqm c}q iq’p qbb egqm$’
Qjmy ebboma gq jik% gee pgaamdma cy jip qgem$
‚Vjgq viee qjmy ab qb km il gee lgiep2’ Ag|m vgdqma qb odbv$
‚Iq’p qbb jbssicem$ Iq’p qbsq}sm qb cm qjmis peg|m% qjmy viee kgom yb} ab
qjm kbpq jbssili` qjidfp$ Oieeidf ip dbq m|md qjm vbspq qjidf qjmy
`b}ea kgom yb} ab$ Yb} ampqsby ei|mp% pbkmqikmp qjmy viee kgom
yb} emg|m ~mb~em viqj dbqjidf gda gk dbq qgeoidf bdey gcb}q
~sb~msqy% db gskp% db emfp% db mymp% dbqjidf$ I abd’q vgdq qb qgeo
gcb}q iq gda qjm f}gsaigdp vb}ea qbskmdq yb} qbb gp g `beem`qbs lbs gee yb}s vsbdf ammap$’
Csip ebboma eiom jm vb}ea `sy gda qjmy vmsm gee piemdq$
‚Vm odbv pbkmbdm vjb odbvp gcb}q qjmpm `beem`qbsp gda
f}gsaigdp%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Smgeey2’ Csip vgp fmd}idmey p}s~sipma$
‚Ymp$’
‚Qjgq ip pb sgsm$ Bdey ~mb~em lsbk qjm kia+eilm gda `beem`qbsp
vb}ea odbv bl b}s mzipqmd`m$ Vjb odbvp gcb}q }p2’
‚Ky lgqjms'’
Csip vgp lidaidf iq jgsa qb cmeim|m$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 90/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Jm ip g kmsm kgd2’ jm gpoma$
‚Jm’p g ~simpq$’‚I vgdq qb kmmq jik$’
‚Vjy2’ Asmv gpoma$
‚Jm gda I kgy jg|m qjidfp qb qgeo gcb}q$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 91/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 7<
Asmv asb|m Csip gda jms pbd qb pmm Pqm|m qjgq difjq% pjm jgaidpipqma jip lsimdap fb jbkm qb smpq$ Asmv aia dbq qmee Pqm|m qjmy
vmsm `bkidf gda pb odb`oma gq jip abbs vjmd qjmy gssi|ma$ Qjm
~simpq aia dbq vgpqm qikm b~mdidf qjm abbs$
Pqm|m’p lg`m eiq }~ vjmd jm pgv Asmv c}q p}aamdey asb~~ma vjmd
jm pgv qjm pqsgdfms viqj jms$
‚Pqm|m%’ Csip pgia$
‚Csip%’ Pqm|m pgia `beaey$
Kbqjms gda pbd vmsm p}s~sipma qjm qvb odmv mg`j bqjms gq gee$
‚Vjgq ip jm abidf jmsm2’ Pqm|m gpoma Asmv$
‚Jm `gd jme~ }p%’ Asmv pgia$
‚Vmee ab yb} odbv jik2’
‚Db c}q% iq ip g kisg`em vm kmq jik% yb} pmm% jm jga cmmd bdm bl
qjm ~mb~em Ag|m jga fi|md kbdmy vjmd jm qjb}fjq jm vgp g
cmffgs$’
‚Jm ip g `beem`qbs Asmv% vjgq ab yb} qjido yb} gsm abidf viqj
jik2’ Pqm|m pjb}qma$
‚Db Pqm|m% jm p}s|i|ma% qjmy emq jik fb%’ Asmv amlmdama Csip$
‚Qjmy ab dbq emq gdybdm p}s|i|m agkdiq' Jm ip ~egdqma% qjmy gsm
~egyidf yb}$’
‚Jm ip dbq% m|md yb} pgia qjmy emq pbkm p}s|i|m%’ Asmv pjb}qma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 92/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I eima Bo% db bdm p}s|i|mp mp~m`igeey dbq qjm eiomp bl jik$ Jm ip qjm
vbspq bl qjmk gee$’
‚Vmee qjmd% viee yb} omm~ }p pqgdaidf b}qpiam eiom qjip2’
‚Qjgq cmgpq ip dbq mdqmsidf ky jb}pm% }damspqgda qjgq Asmv2
Ag|m mdqms lgpq cmlbsm qjip kgd p}`op qjm eilm b}q bl yb}$’
Ag|m bcmyma gda mdqmsma qjm jb}pm$ Pqm|m pqgdaidf gq qjm abbs
vgp ceb`oidf qjm ga}eqp lsbk mdqmsidf$
‚C}q jm jgp qjm !7>> abeegs dbqm I dmma aga%’ Ag|m pgia$
‚Fi|m ky pbd jip kbdmy'’ Ag|m bsamsma Csip$
Csip fbq qjm !7>> abeegs dbqm lsbk jip ~b`omq gda jgdama iq qb
Pqm|m$
‚Pqm|m% abd’q cm eiom qjip$’
‚I abd’q qs}pq jik% dmiqjms pjb}ea yb} Asmv$’‚C}q jm ip b}s bdey jb~m% Ag|m abmpd’q jg|m k}`j qikm$’
‚Gda qjip kgd ip vgpqidf qjm eiqqem qikm yb} jg|m viqj yb}s pbd
Asmv$’
‚Fba% Csip p~mgo lbs yb}spmel%’ Asmv qbea jik$
‚Pjm jgp g ~bidq Pqm|m%’ Csip pgia lbs qjm lispq qikm% ‚I kgy dbq eiom
yb}% yb} kgy dbq eiom km c}q vm ab qjip lbs yb}s pbd'’
‚Pqm|m% ~emgpm eipqmd qb jik lbs qjm pgom bl Ag|m%’ Asmv ~emgama$
‚Yb} gsm gesmgay id eb|m viqj jik% gsmd’q yb}2’
‚Pqmmmm|m$’
‚Jbv vmgo yb} gsm'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 93/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Yb} gsm h}pq hmgeb}p qjgq pbkmbdm `b}ea g`q}geey eiom km$’
‚Gk dbq eipqmdidf qb qjip$’‚Pqm|m qjip ip dbq gcb}q }p% iq’p gcb}q Ag|m$’
C}q Pqm|m jga gesmgay pj}q qjm abbs id jms lg`m$
‚Emq iq fb% jm viee `bkm gsb}da%’ Csip pgia vgeoidf gvgy$
‚C}q vjmsm gsm yb} fbidf2’
‚Qb qjm `gs% gsmd’q yb} `bkidf2’
‚Bo$’
Qjmy pgq id qjm agso `gs dbq p~mgoidf$ Csip jga pgq gq qjm asi|ms’p
pmgq$
‚Vjgq ab I ab dbv2’ Asmv gpoma% gekbpq qb jmspmel$
‚I }damspqgda jik jm viee `bkm gsb}da%’ Csip gpp}sma jms$
‚Gk pqiee pb `bdl}pma$’
Csip asb|m b}q bl qjm `j}s`j gsmg$
‚Vjmsm gsm vm fbidf2’
‚Yb} jg|m qb `emgs yb}s qjb}fjqp% vm viee fb qb qjm cmg`j$’
‚Gq qjip jb}s2 Iqp egqm$’‚Qjgq ip vjgq viee kgom iq cmqqms% kgycm vm `gd m|md vgq`j qjm
p}dsipm% iq h}pq smdmvp yb}s pqsmdfqj% abmpd’q iq2’
‚Vmee% I abd’q odbv% I jg|m dm|ms abdm qjgq$’
‚Pqm|m dm|ms qbbo yb}2 I qjb}fjq qjgq’p vjgq gee eb|msp ab$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 94/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Pqm|m vgp aillmsmdq$’
Qjmy fbq qb qjm cmg`j% iq vgp g vmee eiq gsmg gda qjmy pgq dmgs qjmvgqms pb qjmy `b}ea emq iq qi oem qjmis lmmq$ Qjmy jga qgomd bll qjmis
pjbmp$ Csip jga gd gsk gsb}da Asmv gda pjm emgdma id pb qjgq
jms jmga vgp bd jip `jmpq$ Jm ~egyma viqj jms jgis$ Iq vgp g csifjq
kbbdeiq difjq gda g lmv eb|msp vmsm p`gqqmsma b|ms qjm cmg`j$
Asmv vgp lidgeey fmqqidf qjm ~gppibd pjm jga cmmd amdima lbs pb
ebdf$ Pjm vgp dbq p}sm vjmqjms qjm vgskqj pjm lmeq viqj Csip c}q
gee pjm odmv ip qjgq pjm vgp pebvey lgeeidf jmga b|ms jmmep id eb|mviqj jik$ Pjm `b}ea dbq cmeim|m jm vgp qjm pgkm aipf}pqidf
cmffgs pjm jga pmmd jik gp cmlbsm$ Jm vgp jms jgdapbkm
~sid`m gda pjm vbdamsma il jm eioma jms% pjm qjb}fjq pb$
‚I qjido I gk lgeeidf lbs yb} Csip%’ Asmv ~}ssma pblqey$
‚Vjy2’ jm vjip~msma id jms mgs$
‚I abd’q odbv$’
Jm csb}fjq jms jmga `ebpm qb jip gda fg|m jms g ebdf pblq oipp$
Asmv smeipjma mg`j kbkmdq bl iq$
‚Asmv%’ Csip gpoma% ‚jbv aia yb} kmmq Pqm|m2’
Asmv vgp }d`bklbsqgcem viqj qjm w}mpqibd mp~m`igeey qjgq iq vgp
Csip gpoidf iq$
‚I kmq jik gq p`jbbe%’ pjm pgia pik~ey$
‚Gda yb} jga g pbd viqj jik2’
‚Ymgj% ~mb~em gevgyp |imv km gp `sgxy bs dg}fjqy vjmd I qmee
qjmk qjgq ky pbdp lgqjms ip g ~simpq$ Qjm qs}qj ip I jga g
smegqibdpji~ viqj jik cmlbsm jm cm`gkm g ~simpq$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 95/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Pqm|m ip g ~simpq2 Pid`m vjmd2’
‚Lbs qjm ~gpq 37 ymgsp pid`m ky pbd Ag|m vgp cbsd$’‚Pqm|m ip db ~simpq%’ Csip pgia$
‚Ymgj% I odbv jip cmjg|ibs abmpd’q pmmk qb liq idqb qjm ~simpq cbz$
Vjmsm aia yb} kmmq jik gdyvgy2’
‚Db% qjgq ip dbq vjgq I kmgdq$’
‚Vjgq qjmd% aia yb} kmgd2’
‚I h}pq dm|ms odmv jik gp g ~simpq$’
‚Vjmsm aia yb} odbv jik qjmd2’
‚Iq jga cmmd sm|mgema qb Pqm|m jm vb}ea cm g f}gsaigd pb jm m|md
pqgsqma qsgididf viqj qjm kia+eilmsp bd gqqgididf jip ampqidy qb fb qb
qjm kia+eilm c}q jm aia pbkmqjidf vsbdf gda vgp pmdq gvgy$ Jm
k}pq jg|m hbidma qjm `j}s j gp g jiamb}q gp jm jga ebpq jipampqidy cm`g}pm jm jgad’q cmmd ~}sm$’
‚Jm dm|ms qbea km qjgq$’
‚Jbv `b}ea jm$ Jm gda I kmq vjmd jm vgp id jip idqmsdpji~$ Vm
jga cmmd si|gep$ Jm vgp dbq jg~~y vjmd jm pgv km cm`g}pm I
odmv gee qjm pm`smqp gcb}q jik qjgq jm dm|ms vgdqma yb} qb odbv$’
‚Vjy vb}ea jm ab qjgq2’‚Jm `b}ead’q jg|m bs kgycm jm h}pq aiad’q qs}pq yb} mdb}fj$’
‚C}q jm pgia jm eb|ma km gda bdey hbidma ~simpqjbba cm`g}pm jm
lmeq jm jga g `geeidf$’
‚Qjgq vgp h}pq g eim$ Jm emlq yb} lbs dbqjidf Asmv$ Jm emlq yb}
cm`g}pm jm vgp id pmel ~iqy gda amdige$ Jm `b}ead’q `bkm qb qmskp
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 96/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
gda kb|m bd$ Pqm|m vgp gda pqiee ip g lgie}sm$ Kbsm pb cm`g}pm jm
emlq g ~sm`ib}p hmvme eiom yb}$’
‚I `gddbq cmeim|m jm vb}ea ab qjgq qb km$’
‚Jm ip g `bvgsa$ Jm abmpd’q ampms|m yb}s eb|m gda yb} ampms|m
pbkmbdm vjb viee eb|m yb} pb k}`j cmqqms$’
Csip qjmd pjbvmsma Asmv viqj oippmp gee b|ms$ Pjm `b}ea dbq smpipq
jip qb}`j gda ebdfma lbs jik$ Pjm oippma jik cg`o gda iq vgp g
~gppibdgqm difjq bd qjm cmg`j lbs qjm a}b$
Qjm lispq sgyp bl qjm p}d gvbom qjmk$ Asmv jga pem~q id qjm gskp
bl Csip% jm vgp gesmgay gvgom vjmd pjm sb}pma lsbk jms pemm~
gda jm oippma jms amm~ey$
‚Qjgdo yb}%’ Csip pgia$
‚Lbs vjgq2’
‚Lbs qs}pqidf km qb jbea yb} qjsb}fjb}q qjm difjq'’
Asmv pkiema csifjqey$ Jms lg`m sma gp pjm vgp ce}pjidf$ Qjmy
vgq`jma qjm p}d sipm qbfmqjms gp qjb}fj qjmy jga odbvd mg`j
bqjms lbs ymgsp$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 97/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 76
Ag|m ebboma gq jip lgqjms emgd cg`o gq qjm abbs gp qjb}fjsmfsmqqidf m|ms pj}qqidf iq$ Jm vgp `bdl}pma$
‚Vjy aia yb} ab qjgq2’ Ag|m gpoma Pqm|m$
‚Qjgq kgd ip agdfmsb}p'’
‚C}q kbk ip viqj jik% il yb} smgeey vgdq jms qb cm pglm% yb} pjb}ea
jg|m emq qjmk cbqj id$’
‚I gk pbssy$’
‚@b}ead’q yb} jg|m gq emgpq eipqmdma qb vjgq jm jga qb pgy2’
‚Db% jm bdey `gkm jmsm qb kgom g kb`o bl km$’
‚G kb`o bl yb}2 Gk fbidf viqj ky kbk'’
Ag|m ~}pjma jip lgqjms b}q bl qjm vgy gda vmdq b}qpiam$ Jm
pmgs`jma m|msyvjmsm lbs jms gda pmmidf qjm `gs vgp dbq qjmsm
odmv pjm jga emlq$ Jg|idf db bqjms vgy qb smq}sd jbkm% jm vmdq
cg`o idqb jip lgqjms’p jb}pm$ Pqm|m’p mymp vmsm sma viqj mkbqibd
vjmd Ag|m smq}sdma$
‚Yb} pgy qjgq kgd ip agdfmsb}p c}q yb} emq kbk fb viqj jik% I
vbd’q lbsfi|m yb} il gdyqjidf jg~~mdp qb kbk'’
‚Pjm viee cm lidm% pjm ip jg~~y$’
Pqm|m pms|ma jip pbd pbkm p}~~ms gda fg|m jik jip cmasbbk qb
pemm~$
‚Vjmsm viee yb} pemm~2’ Ag|m gpoma jik$
‚Qjm `b}`j viee cm lidm lbs km$ I ab dbq pemm~ k}`j gdyvgy$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 98/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Il gq gdy qikm yb} fmq }d`bklbsqgcem% yb} `gd `bkm gda pemm~ bd
qjm cma$ I abd’q kida$’
‚Qjgdo yb} pbd$ I gk fega yb} gsm jmsm$’
‚Fbbadifjq$’
Pqm|m emlq qjm sbbk gda Ag|m qjb}fjq ebdf gda jgsa% jm smgeixma
jm jga dbq m|md `smgqma g c}`omq eipq$ Jm qjb}fjq bl Dgd`y gda
vbdamsma il pjm pjb}ea cm bd iq qbb$ Jm pkiema gda jip qjb}fjqp
asbvdma jik idqb g kbpq vme`bkm pemm~$
Ag|m gvbom id qjm kiaaem bl qjm difjq pjbsq bl csmgqj$ Jm vgp
p`gsma gda ebboma gsb}da qjm sbbk% m|msyqjidf vgp id bsams$ Jm
jga h}pq `jboma jikpmel bd qjm ~ieebv gda vgp smeim|ma$ G eifjq
pjbdm id qjm jgeevgy gda Ag|m vgp gemsqma$ Lbs g kbkmdq jm jga
lbsfbqqmd jm vgp dbq gq jbkm$
Ag|m vgeoma b}q bl qjm cmasbbk gda bd qb qjm ei|idf sbbk vjmsm
jm pgv jip lgqjms vbsoidf ~gidpqgoidfey pebvey bd qjm fegpplsgfkmdqp% qsyidf qb gppmkcem qjmk$ Jm jga kgdgfma qb fe}m
qbfmqjms g pkgee `}s|m$ Iq ebboma gekbpq kgfi`ge gda Ag|m `b}ea
bdey ikgfidm jbv iq ebboma vjmd iq jga cmmd vjbem$
‚Aga$’
Pqm|m pjbbo viqj lmgs gp jm jga cmmd p}aamdey gemsqma$ Jm
q}sdma qb ebbo gq Ag|m$
‚Gggj pbd% I gk pbssy I gk h}pq pb }pma qb cmidf gebdm I lbsfbq I
jga g f}mpq$’
‚Gk I h}pq g f}mpq qb yb}2’ Ag|m gpoma piqqidf abvd$
‚Yb} gsm kbsm qjgd g f}mpq% yb} gsm ky pbd$ Lbsfi|m km% I jga db
cmqqms vgy bl ~}qqidf iq$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 99/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vb}ea yb} `gee km yb}s pbd id ~}cei`2 @bdpiamsidf qjgq yb} gsm g
~simpq$’
‚Ymp I vb}ea$ I `gddbq amdy yb}$’
‚Bl `b}spm yb} vb}ead’q cm`g}pm g lgqjms `geep m|msybdm pbd gda
m|msybdm `geep yb} lgqjms$’
‚Il qjgq’p qjm vgy yb} vgdq qb ~}q iq c}q odbv I viee dm|ms amdy yb}
dbs jg|m I m|ms$ Gpo yb}s kbqjms$’
‚Pjm gid’q jmsm$ Vjy aia yb} gcgdabd kbk gda km lbs ~simpqjbba2’
‚Iq vgp g ailli`}eq am`ipibd I jga qb kgom% I vgdqma qb cm gsb}da
gda lmma yb} c}q I abd’q qjido yb} viee }damspqgda$ Iq’p qbb amm~$’
‚Ip iq2 Vjgq gsm yb} abidf viqj qjbpm lsgfkmdqp bl fegpp2’
‚I gk qsyidf qb gppmkcem qjmk$’
‚Viqj fe}m2’
‚Iq’p k}`j cmqqms qjgd `meeb+qg~m$’
Qjmy eg}fjma$
‚Aga I jg|m db jb~m bl lidaidf qjm smpq bl qjm dbqmp$ I gk
gpp}kidf dmzq vmmo viee cm ky egpq$ Vjgq ab yb} qjido I pjb}ea
ab cmlbsm qjmd2’
‚I gk pbssy qjgq yb}s jb~m ip lgieidf pbd c}q I jg|m vbsoma
mdaemppey gee difjq qsyidf qb lida g pbe}qibd lbs yb}$’
‚M|md il yb} abd’q qs}pq Csip% viqj qjm mz~msimd`m jm jgp I odbv jm
jgp kbsm odbvemafm bd jbv qb fmq km qb ky f}gsaigd$’
‚M|md pb% I ab dbq qs}pq jip idqmdqibdp$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 100/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vjy dbq% I vgp h}pq lbsq}dgqm qb jg|m fi|md jik g dbqm vjmd I
qjb}fjq jm vgp g cmffgs% h}pq gp I vgp lbsq}dgqm qb jg|m fi|md
bdm qb yb} qbb$’
‚Yb} `gddbq cm b|ms lbsq}dgqm pbd% bdm ip fbba gda qjm bqjms ip
m|ie$ Yb}s f}gsaigd jga cmmd pqsbdf qb m|md emg|m yb} viqj g
`jbi`m$’
‚Gda yb} gsm p}~~bpma qb cm qjm fbba bdm2’
‚I gk jb~idf pb$’
‚Vjy pjb}ea qjm fbba bdm gevgyp cm qjm bdm qjgq’p ifdbsgdq gda
qjm cga bdm jg|m gee qjm g``mpp dmmama2’
‚Eilm ip jgsa qb }damspqgda$’
‚Gda vjy pjb}ea bdm q}sd b}q qb cm yb}s lgqjms gda qjm bqjms h}pq
g cmffgs% jbkmempp bd qjm pqsmmq2’
‚I `gddbq mz~egid qjgq pbd$’
‚Vbv%’ Ag|m’p mymp febvma$
Ag|m vgp ebboidf gq qjm dmgsey `bk~emqma fegpp cgee$ Jip lgqjms
jga cmmd vbsoidf gp qjmy qgeoma gda bdey bdm egpq ~im`m
smkgidma qb cm ~}q id ~eg`m$
‚Iq’p cmg}qil}e% ipd’q iq2’
‚Ymp aga% iq ip$’
‚I vb}ea jg|m dbq abdm iq il iq vmsmd’q lbs yb} cmidf jmsm qbdifjq$ I
jga gevgyp cmmd p`gsma qb ~sg`qi m vjgq I odmv c}q viqj yb} jmsm
I jga qjm kbqi|gqibd$’
‚Qjgdop aga$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 101/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Dbv ~}q id qjm egpq ~im`m$’
‚Yb} ab iq% gk glsgia I viee p~bie iq gee$’‚Abd’q cm glsgia% iq viee bdey vbso lbs yb} il yb} ab iq$’
Ag|m pebvey fbq qjm egpq ~im`m gda ~eg`ma iq id iqp ~eg`m$ Qjm cgee
febvma g ~}sm ce}m `bebs$ Ag|m’p jmgsq kmeqma gq iqp cmg}qy gda
jm ~i oma iq }~ id jip jgdap$ Iq fg|m jik g dmv mem`qsi` mdmsfy gda
jm `ebpma jip mymp$
G egay legpjma cmlbsm jip mymp s}ddidf$ Jm vgdqma qb lbeebv jms c}q qjmd jm pgv qjm pbs`msmsp bd jms qgie$ Jm vgp b|msvjmekma
viqj lmgs gq qjm pifjq bl qjmk gda asb~~ma qjm fegpp cgee pb qjgq iq
pjgqqmsma gfgid c}q qjip qikm qb ciffms ~im`mp$ Ag|m b~mdma jip
mymp aipg~~bidqma$
‚I gk pbssy aga%’ jm pgia ebboidf gq qjm csbomd fegpp bd qjm lebbs$
‚Vjgq jg~~mdma pbd2’‚I vgp viqj jms% I vgp viqj ky f}gsaigd c}q qjmd I fbq pb p`gsma I
asb~~ma qjm cgee$ I gk pb pbssy$’
Ag|m `b|msma jip lg`m id pjgkm gda aipg~~bidqkmdq$ Pqm|m
~gqqma jik bd qjm cg`o$
‚Iq ip dbqjidf qb lmme cga gcb}q% qjip ip pbkmqjidf dmv$ I viee pq}ay
kbsm bd iq qb odbv vjgq ip qb cm abdm$’
‚Vjgq jga jg~~mdma qb km% aia yb} dbqi m gdyqjidf gq qjm qikm2’
‚Db% yb} jga h}pq `ebpma yb}s mymp$ I aia dbq odbv gdyqjidf vgp
jg~~mdidf$’
‚Bjj$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 102/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Iq’p g fbba pifd% yb}s f}gsaigd vgp pqsbdf$’
‚Vjy ab yb} qjido pjm lgiema2’‚M|msybdm lgiep gq pbkm ~bidq$’
‚C}q vjy aia pjm jg|m qb lgie bd km2’
‚^msjg~p yb}s ampqidy ip fsmgq gda bdey cy jms lgieidf `gd yb}
smgeixm iq$ I gk pbssy pbd% I `gddbq fi|m yb} g amlidiqm gdpvms$’
‚Gsm qjm pbs`msmsp gda `beem`qbsp vgq`jidf km dbv2’
‚Ymp% kbsm pb I qjido cm`g}pm qjm cgee jga cmmd sm|i|ma vji j
fi|mp jb~m lbs g f}gsaigdp’ sm|i|ge$’
‚I pid`msmey vipj qjip jgad’q jg~~mdma qb km$’
‚I }damspqgda c}q qgom iq gp iq `bkmp$’
‚I viee ab ky cmpq$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 103/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 7:
Ag|m vgp piqqidf id jip sbbk% qjidoidf gcb}q jbv pjbsq jip eilmvb}ea cm$ Jm vgp lmmeidf |msy pbssy lbs jikpmel gp jm jga jifj
gp~isgqibdp jm vgp ymq qb g``bk~eipj id jip yb}df eilm$
Qjm abbs b~mdma gda Ag|m ebboma$ H}pq vgeoma idqb jip sbbk vgp
qjm vbkgd vjb jga qjsmgqmdma jik g lbsqdifjq gfb viqj jms kmd$
Jm ebboma gq jms jbssilima$ Pjm ebboma |msy gq mgpm% gp qjb}fj id
jms bvd jbkm$
‚Vjgq ab yb} vgdq lsbk km2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Vm h}pq vgdq vjgq cmebdfp qb }p Ag|m$’
‚C}q I jg|m cmmd fi|idf iq$’
‚Vm dm|ms pgia vm vgdqma iq id idpqgeekmdqp$’
‚C}q gp ebdf gp I smq}sd yb}s dbqmp% qjgq pjb}ea cm gee qjgq
kgqqmsp dbq pb2’
‚Db% qjgq ip dbq gee$ ]dempp yb} fi|m }p qjm vjbem ~g`ogfm vm viee
~i o }~ b}s fgkm gda fb qb g vjbem dmv em|me$ Emq’p kgom qjip g
eiqqem kbsm mz`iqidf$’
‚Vjgq ab yb} kmgd2’
‚Vgq j gda emgsd$’‚Yb} `gd’q ab qjip% jmsm I jg|m yb}s !7>> abeegs% qgom iq$’
Pjm eg}fjma$
‚I gk dbq g `beem`qbs Ag|m'’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 104/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjmd vjb gsm yb} gda vjy ab yb} ab qjip qb km' Jbv ab yb}
odbv km2’
H}pq qjmd Csip sgd idqb qjm sbbk gda pjm aipg~~mgsma id qjid gis$
Jm vgp ebboidf b}q bl csmgqj gda pqgsidf gq g |msy p`gsma Ag|m$
‚Fid vgp jmsm% vgpd’q pjm2’
‚Vjb ip Fid2’
‚Kgycm dbq c}q I vgp p}sm I jga csmgqjma jms%’ Csip qbbo qb emg|m
qjm sbbk$
‚Vgiq% pbkm egay vgp jmsm% pjm aiad’q pgy jms dgkm$’
‚Vjgq aia pjm vgdq2’
‚Pjm `gkm qb qjsmgqmd km% qjmy vgdq gee qjm dbqmp$’
‚Qjgq ip Fid gesifjq% aia pjm fi|m g amgaeidm2’
‚Db% pjm bdey qbea km qb vgq`j gda emgsd$’
Csip vgp qjidoidf amm~ey gda Ag|m `b}ea pmm qjgq$
‚Vjgq viee pjm ab qb km2’
‚Vm’ee h}pq jg|m qb vgiq$’
Csip emlq qjm sbbk gp gcs}~qey gp jm jga gssi|ma$ Asmv egqms `gkm
id% ebboidf aipqsmppma$‚Csip qbea km%’ pjm pgia$
‚I gk pb p`gsma kbk% pjm vgp pgyidf eiom pjm kmgdq iq kbk gda
pjm aia dbq m|md qgom qjm !7>> abeegs$’
‚Vjgq aia pjm pgy qjmd2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 105/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjgq pjm vgdqp qb kgom qjidfp kbsm mz`iqidf$’
‚I gk pbssy pbd$’‚@gd’q Csip jme~ km kbk2’
‚I abd’q odbv c}q I gk p}sm jm viee vjmd jm `gd$ Jm jga pmdpma
jms ~smpmd`m gda jga `bkm qb yb}$’
‚Jm vgp smgeey bdm bl qjmk qjmd2 I jb~m jm ip dbq ~egdqma$’
‚Abd’q pgy qjgq' Yb} jg|m cmmd eipqmdidf qb yb}s lgqjmsp ~bipbd'’
‚Pbssy kbk$ I qjido I cmqqms fb pmm Gddm gda Ciee dbv$’
‚@gd’q yb} ab qjgq qbkbssbv2 I gk p`gsma lbs yb}$ Abd’q emg|m$’
‚Qjmy smlsmpj km kbk$ Piqqidf jmsm kgomp km lmme qsg~~ma$ I
~sbkipm I viee cm pglm$ Qjmy `gd’q ~bppicey |ipiq km qvi`m id bdm
agy$’
‚Bo gp yb} vipj$ Cm pglm$’
‚Ymp kbbk% I odbv' Kbk2’
‚Vjgq ip iq2’
‚Dbqjidf$’
Ag|m jga vgdqma qb gpo jms vjy Csip vgp pqgyidf viqj qjmk gda
dbq pemm~idf id qjm p~gsm cmasbbk c}q qjb}fjq cmqqms bl iq$ Jipkbqjms vgp pb id eb|m% pjm k}pq jg|m lif}sma iq }ddm`mppgsy qb
m|md gpo jip ~mskippibd$ Jm aia dbq vgdq jms qb qjido gcb}q iq dbv
gp jm vgp p}sm pjm vgp jg~~y% pjm ebboma pb jg~~y pid`m pjm
pgv Csip% vmee dbq qjm lispq qikm$ Csip% bd qjm bqjms jgda aia dbq qmee
Ag|m gdyqjidf miqjms$ Jm lmeq cga gcb}q qjgq% Csip pjb}ea jg|m gq
emgpq gpoma lbs ~mskippibd$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 106/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qmee km'’ Asmv idpipqma$
‚I vgdqma qb pgy I eb|m yb} kbk$’‚Bjj% yb} odbv I eb|m yb} qbb$’
Pjm j}ffma jik$
Dgd`y ebboma gq jmspmel id qjm kissbs% gakisidf jbv jms dmv asmpp
legqqmsma jms cbay pjg~m$ Pjm eb|ma qjm asmpp pb k}`j c}q iq vgp
}dlbsq}dgqm Ag|m vgp qjm bdm vjb jga qb fi|m iq qb jms% pjm
qjb}fjq$ Jms agqm qbagy% qjm `beemfm j}do Pmgd vb}ea cm
lgc}eb}p% pjm qjb}fjq eg}fjidf$ Kgycm jm kifjq m|md fi|m jms g
oipp bs gpo jms lbs gdbqjms agqm$ Vjgq asmpp vb}ea pjm vmgs qjmd%
pjm lsbvdma$ Db bqjms asmpp vgp gp ~smqqy gp qjip bdm$
Qjm abbscmee sgdf gda Dgd`y vgp w}i`o qb gdpvms iq$ Pmgd ebboma
gp jgdapbkm gp jm `b}ea cm$ Pjm fg|m jik qjm viampq sma ei~~mapkiem pjm `b}ea$ Jm ~m`oma jms bd qjm `jmmo gda jgdama jms g
sbpm$
‚Qjgdo yb} pb k}`j Pmgd$’
‚Bdey qjm cmpq lbs yb} cgcy'’
‚Bjj% vjmsm gsm vm fbidf qbdifjq2’
‚Bd b}s agqm$’
‚I odbv c}q vjgq eb`gqibd2’
‚Gq qjm `e}c$ Vm viee vgpqm b}spme|mp id qjip difjq$’
Dgd`y lsbvdma vjmd pjm jmgsa qjm `e}c$ Pjm jga mz~m`qma gd
mz`e}pi|m aiddms agqm viqj Pmgd gda qjm `e}c vgp qjm emgpq ~eg`m
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 107/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
qb jg|m qjgq gda qb kgom kgqqmsp vbspm% Dgd`yp asmpp vgp dbq
qjm qy~m bdm vbsm qb g `e}c }dempp bl `b}spm% iq vgp g |msy
mz~mdpi|m bdm$ Dgd`y odmv qjgq Pmgd vb}ea dbq qgom jms qb gd
mz~mdpi|m `e}c h}pq lsbk jbv jm jga asmppma% pik~em id g pjisqgda hmgdp$ Bd qjm ~e}p piam pjm vgp viqj Pmgd gda qjgq vgp
mdb}fj qb kgom jms jg~~y$
Qjmsm vgp g ebq bl agd`idf gq qjm `e}c gda Dgd`y vgp jg|idf g
fbba qikm m|md qjb}fj pjm vgp dbq g ~gsqy qy~m bl fise$ Gee pjm aia
vgp lbs Pmgd gda pjm vgp fega jm pmmkma qb cm mdhbyidf jms
`bk~gdy$
Qisma lsbk qjmis agd`idf qjmy `jbpm g di`m jiaamd p~bq id qjm
`bsdms c}q vmsm dbq gebdm$ Pmgd jga kgam lsimdap lsbk dbvjmsm
gda qjmis qgcem vgp l}ee$ Pmgd’p dmv lsimdap jga gepb csb}fjq qjmis
bvd `bk~gdy viqj qjmk gda Dgd`y lmeq pb b}q bl ~eg`m$ Qjm
k}pi` vgp eb}a gda Pmgd `b}ea dbq jmgs g vbsa pjm pgia$
Qjm cbqqemp pqgsqma `bkidf$ Pmgd jga lb}da dmv `bk~gdy id qjm
cmms gda vgp jg|idf bdm cbqqem glqms qjm dmzq$ Dgd`y cgsmey asgdogp pjm odmv qjgq Pmgd vb}ea cm bl db jme~ qb jms il pjm cm`gkm
as}do gp jm vgp gesmgay qbb as}do c}q om~q bd asidoidf gp vmsm
gee jip dmv lsimdap$ Dgd`y vgp pbbd qbqgeey ifdbsma$
Gdfsiey Dgd`y vmdq b}q$ Jms asmpp vgp pqgidma cy cmmsp gda
`ifgsmqqmp pjm jga dbq asgdo bs pkboma$ Pjm vgp l}sib}p gda aia
dbq odbv vjgq qb ab$ Qjm k}pi` pb}daidf glgs bll id qjm
cg`ofsb}da gp pjm vgeoma ebboidf lbs g `gc qb qgom jms jbkm$
Jg|idf db e}`o pjm vbdamsma il pjm jga gdy lsimda vjb vb}ea cm
oida mdb}fj qb `bkm gda fi|m jms g siam jbkm$
Pjm jga kgdy lsimdap c}q odmv qjgq dbdm bl qjmk vb}ea gfsmm%
qjmy vb}ea ~sbcgcey qmee jms qb vgiq lbs g `gc bs kgom g kb`omsy
bl jms lgiema agqm viqj Pmgd$ Pjm qjb}fjq bl pbkmbdm vjb vb}ea
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 108/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
dbq h}afm jms c}q vb}ea cm jg~~y qb ab vjgqm|ms pjm vgdqma%
Ag|m vgp jip dgkm$ Pjm `geema jik gda jm ~i`oma }~ qjm ~jbdm
glqms g lmv sidfp$
‚Jmeeb Ag|m$’
‚Jmeeb Dgd`y2’ Ag|m pb}dama p}s~sipma$
‚Jmy Ag|m% yb} pb}da p}s~sipma$ Gsm yb} gebdm2’
‚Gk viqj ky lsimdap$ Vjy2’
‚Bjj dbqjidf% h}pq jmgsa dbipm% qjgq’p gee$’
‚Vjy aia yb} `gee2’
‚Fmmx Ag|m% abd’q cm pb ce}dq$’
‚Pbssy%’ jm pb}dama pbssy qbb$
‚Iq’p bo$ Gdyvgy% I `geema qb pgy I viee smq}sd yb}s asmpp$’
‚Yb} viee2 Vjy2’
‚H}pq qjb}fjq gcb}q iq pb+’
‚Lbsfmq gcb}q vjgq I pgia gcb}q qjm asmpp yb} `gd omm~ iq$’
‚Vjy% abd’q yb} vgdq qb smq}sd iq2 Il yb} abd’q I ab$’
‚Pb yb} `gd fmq gdbqjms bdm2’
‚Ipd’q qjgq qjm ~bidq2 Qjgq ip dbq vjy I `geema qjb}fj$’
‚Vjgq ip iq qjmd2’
‚I+’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 109/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Dgd`y jga cmmd pgyidf pbkmqjidf vjmd pjm p`smgkma id jbssbs$
Ag|m’p jmgsq ~b}dama qmssicey$ Jip pqbkg`j `s}d`jma gp jip kida
sg`ma% cmgap bl pvmgq g~~mgsidf bd jip lbsmjmga$
‚Dgd`y vjgq’p vsbdf2 Dgd`y2 Jmeeb Dgd`y2’
Qjm eidm vmdq amga$
Dgd`y pkiema gq qjm ~sbp~m`q bl fmqqidf g dmv asmpp% ~msjg~p
Ag|m vgp dbq g cga `gq`j glqms gee$ Pjm vgdqma qb qmee jik qb
`bkm gda ~i`o jms }~ lsbk qjm `e}c$ Pjm odmv jm asb|m jip
kbqjms’p `gs c}q jm `b}ea qgom g `gc il jm `b}ea dbq asi|m iq qjmd$
Pjm vbdamsma il jm vb}ea jg|m kbdmy qb ~gy lbs qjm `gc c}q
odmv qjmsm vgp db jgsk id gpoidf$ Jm db ab}cqmaey `b}ea `sbpp
gd b`mgd lbs jms gda pjm odmv iq$
Dgd`y vgp pqiee qgeoidf bd qjm ~jbdm qb Ag|m vjmd pjm pgv g
c}sey kgd ebboidf gq jms qjsb}fj jip p}dfegppmp$ Pjm p`smgkma
gda gp jm fsgccma jms% pjm asb~~ma jms `mee ~jbdm$ Pjm vgppqs}ffeidf gfgidpq qjm c}sey kgd c}q id |gid% jm vgp qbb pqsbdf$
Pjm p`smgkma kbsm c}q qjmd jm peg~~ma jms jgsa g`sbpp qjm
lg`m% pjm lmee bd qjm fsb}da gda pei~~ma b}q bl `bdp`ib}pdmpp viqj
bdm egpq ebbo gq jik$
Ag|m vgp lsgdqi $ Jm aia dbq odbv vjgq qb qjido gda dmiqjms aia
jip lsimdap$
‚Vm pjb}ea fb `jm`o bd jms%’ Ciee p}ffmpqma$
‚Iq `b}ea jg|m h}pq cmmd g p~iams%’ Gddm pgia% ‚yb} odbv jbv fisep
`gd fmq gda kk% cbyp qbb$’
‚Pjm ip dbq ~i`oidf }~'’ Ag|m pgia glqms `geeidf jms lbs qjm
j}dasmaqj qikm$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 110/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I qjido vm pjb}ea `jm`o bd jms$’
Qjmy s}pjma qb qjm `gs gda Ciee asb|m qb Dgd`y’p ~eg`m vjmsm qjmylb}da qjgq qjm abbs vgp eb`oma$
‚Ebbo% g vidabv ip b~md%’ Gddm p}ffmpqma$
Qjmy fbq id qjsb}fj qjm vidabv glqms kgoidf p}sm db bdm vgp
gsb}da qb pmm qjmk$ Qjmy lmeq gp qjb}fj qjmy vmsm csmgoidf id
vjmd qjmy g`q}geey vmsm$
Qjmy q}sdma bd qjm eifjqp id qjm jb}pm gda m|msyqjidf pmmkma idbsams mz`m~q Dgd`y vgp dbq qjmsm$ Qjmy qbbo qjip `jgd`m qb
mz~ebsm jms jb}pm gda pbbd lbsfbq gcb}q Dgd`y’p p`smgk$
Fbidf qjsb}fj qjm lsiafm% qjmy qbbo pbkm lbba gda gqm iq gda qjmd
kb|ma qb jms cbsidf ei|idf sbbk% dbqjidf qb pmm qjmsm$ Qjmy vmdq
bd qb jms cmasbbk% eg}fjma gcb}q jms }damsvmgs gda kgam viqqy
`bkkmdqp gcb}q jms ~eg`m$ Ag|m `jm`oma jms vgsasbcm qb pmm il
qjm sma asmpp vgp qjmsm$ Jm bdey pgv qjm cbz gda db asmpp$
‚Jmy f}yp% I `gd’q lida qjm asmpp$’
‚Qjm sma asmpp2’
‚Kgycm pjm vbsm iq qb vjmsm|ms pjm vmdq$’
‚Bs pjm vgp smq}sdidf iq qb km$’
‚Ymgj% bs kgycm pjm omm~p iq id g pm`smq ~eg`m$’
‚Eiom vjmsm2’
‚]dams qjm cma2’
‚Qjip cma abmp dbq jg|m gd }dams qjm cma$ Iq’p pq}`o qb qjm lebbs$’
‚I gk pqiee vbssima gcb}q jms p`smgkp$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 111/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Gda pjm viee ~sbcgcey p`smgk gq }p il pjm lidap }p jmsm%’ Gddm
smkidama$
Qjmy emlq qjm jb}pm id qjm pgkm vgy gp qjmy jga mdqmsma$ Qjmy
`b}ea dbq qjido bl gdy ~eg`m Dgd`y `b}ea ~bppicey fb pb aia dbq
cbqjms qb fb ebboidf lbs jms$ Qjmy vmsm dbq m|md p}sm il pjm vgp
id qsb}cem gda Odbvidf Dgd`y odmv pjm vb}ea p`bea gda aipp
qjmk lbs pmgs`jidf jms b}q vjmd pjm vgp dbq id qsb}cem$
Ag|m gda jip lsimdap vmdq jbkm gda pem~q viqj g `emgs
`bdp`imd`m$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 112/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 79
Qjm csifjq p}deifjq gvbom Ag|m lsbk jip pemm~$ Jm vgp j}dfsy
gda vgdqma qb mgq pbkmqjidf$ Jm vgp fbidf qb qjm oiq`jmd vjmd
jm pgv jip kbqjms gda Csip kgoidf b}q bd qjm `b}`j id qjm ei|idf
sbbk$ Jm pqbba gda vgq`jma qjmk lbs g lmv kid}qmp cmlbsm
smqsg`idf jip pqm~p }ddbqi ma qb jip sbbk$
Jm aia dbq vgdq qb qjido gcb}q vjgq jm pgv c}q lbs pbkm smgpbd
jm lmeq cga qjgq jip kbqjms vgp jg|idf g sbkgdqi` smegqibdpji~ viqj
Csip$ Jm aia dbq }damspqgda vjy jm lmeq pb% ~msjg~p iq vgpcm`g}pm bl qjm `is }kpqgd`mp id vji j jm jga kmq Csip bs qjgq
qjmy jga dbq odbvd jik ebdf mdb}fj lbs jms qb h}k~ idqb g
smegqibdpji~ viqj jik$
Ag|m aia dbq `gsm vjgq jip qjb}fjqp pgia gp jm cmeim|ma jm
pjb}ea cm jg~~y lbs jms cm`g}pm qjip vgp qjm lispq smegqibdpji~ jm
jga m|ms pmmd jip kbqjms id|be|ma id$ Qjm bqjmsp pjm jga jga
cmlbsm jga gee cmmd vmee jiaamd$
Ag|m qjb}fjq qjgq ~msjg~p jm pjb}ea fsbv }~ gda lida jip bvd
~eg`m qb ei|m id bsams dbq qb idqmslmsm id jip kbqjms’p eilm c}q vjgq
vgp qjm ~bidq vjmd jm `b}ea aim gdy agy dmzq vmmo bs cm
`bdamkdma qb peg|msy$
Jm `b|msma jip jmga viqj g ~ieebv dbq vgdqidf qb qjido gcb}q iq
gdykbsm$ Dbv jm odmv qjm oida bl kmd jip kbqjms lmee id eb|mviqj$ Jm lb}da iq ailli }eq qb ~}q qjmk id g `gqmfbsy jm `b}ea
amp`sicm% }d}p}ge vgp qjm mgpimpq vbsa qjgq `gkm qb kida$ Jm lmee
gpemm~ bd`m kbsm$
G ~mspipqmdq odb`o bd qjm abbs gvbom jik$
‚Vjgq ab yb} vgdq2’ Ag|m pjb}qma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 113/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Csip mdqmsma$
‚Gsm yb} bo2’‚Gk lidm$ Gsm yb}2’
‚Ymgj% I dmma qb gpo yb} pbkmqjidf$’
Ag|m lmeq qjm `bd|mspgqibd gcb}q Csip gda jip kbqjms `bkidf bd$
Jm vgp fega Csip jga qgomd g lispq pqm~ qbvgsap aip`}ppidf qjm
kgqqms$
‚Vjgq ip iq2’
‚Gsm gee yb}s lsimdap gesifjq2’
Ag|m pgq }~ bd jip cma% qjip vgp amlidiqmey dbq g `bd|mspgqibd
gcb}q Csip gda jip kbqjms$ Ag|m lmeq aipg~~bidqma$
‚Qjmy gsm lidm$’
‚Vmee gsm yb} p}sm2’
‚Vjy2 Aia pbkmqjidf jg~~md2’
‚Db% I h}pq vgdqma qb odbv cm`g}pm I odbv jbv qjm pbs`msmsp gda
`beem`qbsp gsm$ I h}pq vgdqma qb cm p}sm$’
‚Vjy2’
‚Cm`g}pm qjmy dm|ms smgeey mz~m`q yb} qb smq}sd qjm kbdmy yb}pmm$ Pb qjmy oidag qsy qb kgom yb}s eilm ailli`}eq cy }pidf yb}s
lsimdap bs lgkiey c}q pid`m gk jmsm% I gk ~sbqm`qidf yb}s kbk gda
yb}$’
‚Qgeoidf gcb}q kbk% jbv mzg`qey gsm yb} ~sbqm`qidf jms2 Cy
pemm~idf viqj jms2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 114/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m pgv g peifjq legpj bl jbpqieiqy id Csip’ mymp c}q iq aipg~~mgsma
w}i`oey$ Csip pkiema$
‚Yb}s kbqjms gda I gsm ga}eqp$ Vm odbv vjgq vm gsm abidf$’
‚Gda yb} `gd’q qmee km gcb}q iq2 Jmy% gk gd ga}eq qbb$’
‚Iq’p dbdm bl yb}s c}pidmpp Ag|m% `gd’q yb} h}pq cm jg~~y lbs yb}s
kbkp jg~~idmpp$ Gda vjgq il I qmee yb} pjm vgdqp gdbqjms `jiea$’
‚Pj}q }~'’ Ag|m pjb}qma$
‚Pmm vjy I pgy iq’p g ~si|gqm kgqqms$ Ab dbq vbssy% I viee qgom `gsm
bl jms$’
Csip qbbo qb emg|m qjm sbbk$
‚Vgiq'’ Ag|m pgia% ‚I jg|m g lsimda c}q I abd’q odbv il gdyqjidf jgp
jg~~mdma qb jms bo$’
‚Vjmsm abmp pjm ei|m2’Asmv asb|m qjmk qb Dgd`y’p ~eg`m$ Vjmd Ag|m `jm`oma jm pgv iq
vgp h}pq qjm vgy jm gda jip lsimdap jga emlq iq egpq difjq$ Jm cmfgd
qb vbssy$ Jm mz~egidma jms `gee qb qjm ga}eqp gda qjmy eipqmdma
gqqmdqi|mey$
‚Vm `jm`oma bd jms egpq difjq gda iq pmmkp pjm jgpd’q smq}sdma$’
‚Gda pjm vbd’q il vm abd’q ab gdyqjidf gcb}q iq%’ Csip pgia$‚Vjgq pjb}ea vm ab2’
‚Vm jg|m qb sm|i|m Ag|mp f}gsaigd id bsams qb p}kkbd qjm
pbs`msmsp qjgq qbbo jms$ Qjmsm’p db bqjms vgy$ Iq’p gee h}pq g fgkm
lbs qjmk% qjmy ~egy viqj ~mb~em’p ei|mp$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 115/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Kgycm I `gd piq gq qjm ~gso qb smq}sd qjm !7>> abeegs gda gpo qjm
`beem`qbs gcb}q iq$’
‚Db%’ Csip bchm`qma% ‚qjgq’p idpgdiqy$ Yb} abd’q odbv qjmk% qjmy
abd’q `bk~sbkipm gda qjmy viee oiee yb} il yb} qsy$ I gpp}sm yb}%
yb}s lsimda ip id g ebq bl qsb}cem sifjq dbv$’
‚C}q vm `gd’q sm|i|m jip f}gsaigd$ Pqm|m abmp dbq odbv jbv%’
Asmv pgia$
‚Vm `gd gda jm odbvp g vgy jbv%’ Ag|m pgia$
Asmv vgp p}s~sipma$ Csip pkiema viamey gda Ag|m `b}ea dbq
}damspqgda vjy$ Iq vgp dbq ebdf glqms vjmd qjmy vmsm p~mmaidf qb
Pqm|m’p ~eg`m$ Qjm `j}s`j vgp b~md gda qjmy vmsm g lmv ~mb~em
id iq$ Qjmy fbq b}q$ Asmv vgp gcb}q qb fb aism`qey qb qjm jb}pm
vjmd Csip pqb~~ma jms$
‚Vjy2 Yb} abd’q vgdq qb fb2’ pjm gpoma jik$
‚Db% jm’p id qjm `j}s`j dbq gq jbkm%’ Pqm|m qbea jms$
‚Jbv vb}ea yb} odbv qjgq2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Qjm `j}s`j ip b~md% ipd’q iq bc|ib}p2 @bkkbd pmdpm2’
Qjmy vmdq idqb qjm `j}s`j gda lb}da qjgq jm vgp sifjq$ Asmv
g~~sbg`jma Pqm|m `g}qib}pey$ Jm vgp gq qjm lsbdq bl qjm `j}s`j bd
jip odmmp gda cmdq abvd id jip ~simpqey fgskmdqp ~sgyidf$ Pjm aiaeiomvipm$
‚Asmv%’ jm pgia jms dgkm m|ms pb pblqey$
Asmv ebboma }~ lsbk jms odmmeidf ~bpiqibd gda qjmd pqbba }~$
Pqm|m vgp pq}ayidf jms lg`m pb `ebpmey qjgq pjm vgp
mkcgssgppma$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 116/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I odbv vjgq yb} vgdq'’ Pqm|m qbea jms$ ‚Gda gk dbq fbidf qb ab iq$’
‚Yb} jg|m qb jmgs }p b}q$’‚Jmgs yb} b}q2 Dbq vjmd I odbv yb} gsm pemm~idf viqj qjgq f}y$’
‚@gd’q yb} pj}q }~$ Yb} qjido yb} odbv gee gcb}q km$’
‚Abd’q I2’
‚Yb} abd’q$’
Csip gda Ag|m g~~sbg`jma qjm a}b$
‚Pqm|m%’ qjgq vgp Csip% ‚I qjido kgycm vm pjb}ea qgom qjip
aip`}ppibd b}qpiam$’
‚Vjgq lbs% emq’p ab qjip sifjq cmlbsm qjm Ebsa pb qjgq jm `gd h}afm$’
‚Iq’p cmqqms qb aip`}pp p}`j kgqqmsp b}q bl qjm ~}cei mym$’
‚Vjgq kgqqmsp2’
‚Kgqqmsp eiom yb} gsm dbq smgeey g ~simpq'’
Pqm|m qjsmv Csip g ~}d`j c}q Csip ebboma }dgllm`qma cy iq$ Ag|m
vgp p}s~sipma gq cbqj vjgq jm jga jmgsa gda pmmd$ G eiqqem cebba
vgp pqsmgkidf b}q bl Csip’ kb}qj$
‚Vgp qjgq yb}s cmpq2’ Csip qmgpma$
‚Fmq b}q bl jmsm'’ Pqm|m pjb}qma gq qjmk$
Qjm lmv ~mb~em id qjm `j}s`j vmsm w}imqey vgq jidf qjm p`mdm
}dlbea$
‚Qjip ip dbq gcb}q yb} gda km% bs Asmv% iq’p gcb}q yb}s pbd Pqm|m$’
‚Yb} odbv dbqjidf gcb}q km bs ky pbd$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 117/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I odbv mdb}fj qb cm g cmqqms lgqjms qb jik qjgd yb}$’
Pqm|m qjsmv gdbqjms ~}d`j gda qjip qikm Csip aia dbq emq iq fb$Jmgap eb`oma% qjmy vmsm lifjqidf c}q Pqm|m vgp gq g
aipga|gdqgfm$ Jm jga g pkgeems cbay `bk~gsma qb Csip gda p}sm
mdb}fj% pbbd jm vgp leyidf id kia+gis jgelvgy g`sbpp qjm `jg~me$
Iq vgp Asmv’p q}sd qb p`smgk$ Ag|m pqbba pq}~mlima$ Gee qjm
p~m`qgqbsp jmea qjmis csmgqj$ Iq vgp g jgsa egdaidf lbs Pqm|m$ Csip
lbs g kbkmdq lmeq pbkm oida bl |i`qbsy c}q qjmd cm`gkm gvgpjma
viqj lgepm pjgkm vjmd jm pgv qjgq m|msybdm vgp ebboidf$
‚Vjgq ab yb} qjido yb} gsm abidf2’ Asmv pjb}qma$
‚I gk pbssy'’ Csip g~bebfixma$
Pqm|m `b}ea dbq fmq }~ gp jm lmeq pb k}`j ~gid id jip cg`o$ Ag|m
sgd b|ms gda cmdq abvd b|ms jip lgqjms$ Jm aia dbq odbv vjgq qb
ab$
‚Gsm yb} bo2’ Ag|m gpoma jip lgqjms$
‚I abd’q odbv% ky cg`o j}sqp$’
Csip g~~sbg`jma qjmk$ Ag|m fg|m jik g amlmdpi|m mym oida bl
ebbo$ Csip cmdq abvd dmzq qb qjmk$ Asmv vgp csmgqjidf jmg|iey%
jgdap `sbppma b|ms jms `jmpq% pjm lmeq pb `ebpm qb `syidf$
‚Mz`}pm }p Ag|m%’ Csip pgia$
‚Gk dbq fbidf gdyvjmsm%’ Ag|m idpipqma$
‚Lidm% qjmd jme~ km `gssy jik qb qjm jb}pm$’
‚Abd’q qb}`j km%’ Pqm|m pgia qb Csip$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 118/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Vmee yb} `gd’q pqgy qjmsm lbsm|ms2 I gk pbssy bo pb emq km `gssy
yb} qb qjm jb}pm%’ jm pgia$
‚Lbsfmq iq Csip'’
Csip vmdq b|ms qb qjm dbv `syidf Asmv gda mkcsg`ma vjiepq
vjip~msidf pbkmqjidf idqb jms mgs$ Pjm vgp eipqmdidf piemdqey qb
vjgq jm vgp pgyidf gda dbaaidf jms jmga b``gpibdgeey$ Ag|m
jga jme~ma jip lgqjms }~ gda qjmy vmsm eik~idf b}q bl qjm `j}s`j
gp pbd p}~~bsqma lgqjms qb vgeo$
Asmv gda Csip lbeebvma cmjida qjmk }dqie qjmy lidgeey fbq idqb qjm
jb}pm$ Qjmy gepb vmdq qb qjm cmasbbk vmsm Pqm|m vgp ~eg`ma bd
qjm cma cy jip pbd$ Qjmsm vgp gd gvovgsa piemd`m id qjm jb}pm
gp db bdm vgdqma qb qgeo qb qjm bqjms$ Asmv c}pima jmspmel viqj
fmqqidf s}c+bd `smgk qb mgpm qjm ~gid id Pqm|m’p cg`o$
Asmv `gkm qb jik gda jm ~gidl}eey qbbo bll jip sbcm pb qjgq jm
bdey smkgidma viqj }dams~gdqp$ Jm egy bd jip pqbkg`j bd qjmcma$ Asmv s}ccma qjm pbbqjidf `smgk bd jip cg`o gda kgppgfma
Pqm|m’p cg`o id p}`j g fmdqem vgy$ Csip pqgsma gq jms gdfsiey% pjm
aia dbq vgdq qb ebbo gq jik$ Ag|m ebboma gq db bdm id ~gsqi`}egs$
Vjmd pjm jga lidipjma% pjm emlq qb piq id gdbqjms sbbk$ Csip
lbeebvma jms glqms qjsbvidf Pqm|m g aisqy fegd`m% Ag|m pgv iq gda
lsbvdma$ Csip amlidiqmey aia dbq `gsm$ Ag|m vbdamsma il qjip vgp
smgeey qjm ~bvms vbkmd jga b|ms kmd$ Pqm|m fbq asmppma gfgid$
‚Jbv ab yb} lmme2’ Ag|m gpoma$
‚Vmee% I `gd kb|m cy kypmel dbv$ Pjm aia g fbba hbc$’
‚Aga% I gk amp~msgqm$’
‚Vjy2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 119/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Qjmy jg|m ky lsimda$’
‚Vjb2’‚Csip pgia qjm pbs`msmsp ab$’
‚Csip2’
‚Pjm ip kippidf aga% gda jm pgyp qjgq vm `gd bdey jg|m jms cg`o
cy p}kkbdidf qjm pbs`msmsp vjb `gd bdey cm p}kkbdma il ky
f}gsaigd ip sm|i|ma$’
‚I odmv qjgq Csip jga pbkmqjidf m|ie bd jik$’
‚Vjgq ab yb} kmgd2 I dmma ky lsimda cg`o$’
‚I }damspqgda pbd$ Iq’p h}pq qjgq I abd’q qs}pq Csip% I odbv jik qbb
vmee qb qs}pq jik$’
‚I qjb}fjq yb} h}pq pq}aima qjip$ Jbv ab yb} odbv jik pb vmee2’
‚Iq’p amm~ms qjgd yb} qjido$ Yb} viee odbv id qikm$’
‚Vjgq jg~~mdp qb ky lsimda2’
‚I viee jme~ yb}$’
G vg|m bl smeiml vgpjma b|ms Ag|m% jm smgeey vipjma Dgd`y vb}ea
cm pglm$ Jm `b}ea dbq ikgfidm vjgq qjbpm pbs`msmsp vmsm `g~gcem
bl abidf bs jbv Dgd`y `b}ea m|ms lbsfi|m jik vjmd pjm lb}da b}q
vjb jga `g}pma iq$ Jm qjmd qjb}fjq qjgq kgycm jm vgpb|mssmg`qidf gda Dgd`y vgp pglm ei|idf dbskgeey pbkmvjmsm
kgycm |ipiqidf jms ~gsmdqp gq qjgq kbkmdq jm aia dbq odbv vjgq
qb qjido bs cmeim|m$
‚Qjgdop aga$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 120/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I ab qjip lbs yb} bdey% ~emgpm cm csg|m$ I pjb}ead’q cm jme~idf yb}
gp gk dbq yb}s f}gsaigd c}q yb}s f}gsaigd qs}pqma km viqj qjmpm
~im`mp pb+’
‚I viee cm pqsbdf aga% I abd’q `gsm il I aim% I h}pq vgdq ky lsimda qb cm
pglm$’
‚Emq’p fmq b|ms viqj qjip gp pbbd gp vm `gd$’
Ag|m vgp gp gdzib}p gp jip lgqjms gp qjmy odmv qjmy vmsm qgoidf
g sipo qjgq jga dm|ms cmmd qgomd cmlbsm$ Qjmy odmv qjmy jga qb
ab iq lgpq qb f}gsgdqmm Dgd`y’p pglmqy$ Ag|m vgp p`gsma c}q aia
dbq `gsm il jm aima gp ebdf gp Dgd`y vgp pglm$
Pqm|m csb}fjq qjm pjgqqmsma fegpp ~im`mp bd g qsgy gda ~smpmdqma
qjmk qb Ag|m$ Pqm|m `ebpma qjm cmasbbk abbs? jm aia dbq vgdq
Csip qb idqmss}~q qjip lsgfiem mzms`ipm$
Ag|m qsmkcema viqj lmgs gp jm fbq mg`j ~im`m bl qjm csbomd fegpp
gda cmfgd qb gppmkcem qjmk$ P}s~sipidfey% jm aia dbq dmma gdyfe}m gp qjm ~im`mp kgfi`geey pq}`o qbfmqjms$ Pqm|m vgq`jma
gkgxma gp jip pbd vbsoma$ Jm vgp jb~ml}e$
Csip cgdfma qjm abbs b~md% `ebpmey lbeebvma cy Asmv vjb vgp
jbeaidf jik qifjqey cy qjm gsk$ Ag|m pb mdfsbppma id vjgq jm vgp
abidf aia dbq leid`j bs m|md dbqi`m qjmk$ Pqm|m vgp gdfsy gq qjm
idqmss}~qibd vji j jm odmv vgp idm|iqgcem gp Csip jga cmmd bs
vgp g pbs`msms$
‚J}dfsy2’ Pqm|m gpoma Csip `beaey$
‚Vjy aiad’q yb} `gee km2’ Csip gpoma$
‚Gda vjb gsm yb}2’
‚Yb} pjb}ea jg|m gq emgpq `geema km%’ Asmv pgia$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 121/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I abd’q vgdq qb eipqmd qb miqjms bl yb}$’
G eifjq cmfgd qb pjidm lsbk qjm fegpp cgee qjgq vgp cmidfgppmkcema$ Qjmy gee om~q w}imq% ~gyidf k}`j gqqmdqibd qb qjm
kisg em jg~~mdidf cmlbsm qjmis mymp$ Qjmy kgs|mema gq qjm
cmg}qil}e pifjq gda qjm gkgxidf ce}m eifjqp `bkidf lsbk qjm cgee$
Ag|m vgp vbsoidf pqmgaiey% gppmkceidf mg`j ~im`m gda }dgvgsm
bl jip md|isbdkmdq$
Gq egpq% Ag|m fbq qb qjm lidge ~im`m? m|msybdm jmea qjmis csmgqj lbs
qjm kbkmdq$ Qjm vjbem sbbk pmmkma qb qsgdplbsk cmlbsm qjmis mymp gp qjm fegpp cgee cm`gkm g vjbem gfgid$ Jm jmea iq id jip
jgdap gda pb k}`j mdmsfy vmdq qjsb}fj jip cbay$ Jm vgp g lmv
lmmq id qjm gis$
Ag|m pgv g pgday ampmsq gjmga bl jik$ Jm smkmkcmsma qjm
vbsap jip aga jga qbea jik qjgq id bsams qb sm|i|m jip f}gsaigd jm
jga qb lbeebv jms pqm~p$ G kgiamd viqj ebdf jgis pvmm~idf id qjm
vida sgd ~gpq jik qjgq jms jgis cs}pjma lbs g ebdf kbkmdq gfgidpqjip lg`m$
Jm `b}ea csmgqjm jms% jmgs jms vmgo jmgsqcmgq% gda lmme jms
`bd|i`qibd% jms lmmq qjb}fj pbsm kgoidf pblq pb}dap gfgidpq qjm
pgda$ Pjm vgp s}ddidf amp~msgqmey% jm aia dbq odbv vjy gda
lbeebvma jms% s}ddidf id jms lbbqpqm~p$ Jm qsima qb `gq j }~ viqj
jms c}q pjm vgp qbb pvilq$
P}aamdey jm q}sdma gda jip jmgsq fg|m gd gvl}e hbeq$ Pbs`msmsp
gda fsbpp cmidfp vmsm bd g lgpq ~}sp}iq gfgidpq jms% gfgidpq jik$
Jm sgd lbs jip eilm$ Jm `b}ea pmm qjm qjispq lbs m|ie id qjmis mymp$
Qjmis viee qb ab m|ie pb pqsbdf% gekbpq b|ms~bvmsidf c}q Ag|m
`b}ea dbq fi|m }~ gda sgd lgpq glqms jip f}gsaigd$ Qjm pbs`msmsp
vmsm jmg|y bd jip qgie mdhbyidf g `jgpm qjmy lmeq qjmy `b}ea vid$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 122/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Gjmga% Ag|m pgv jip f}gsaigd jga pebvma abvd gp pjm vgp
eik~idf% jm `b}ea pmm cebba bd qjm pbie$ Jm pqb~~ma lbs qjm
csimlmpq kbkmdq c}q pjm q}sdma gda ebboma gq jik viqj
amp~msgqibd mq`jma gee b|ms jms amei`gqm lg`m$ Jm ~i oma }~ p~mma
c}q qjmd jip lbbq egdama bd g asy pjgs~ sbbq$ Jip cebba lebvma gda
Ag|m lmeq pb p`gsma$ Jm ~gdi oma% jip f}gsaigd qjsmv jik gd
gpp}sidf fegd`m lsbk gjmga$ Qjm m|ie j}dfsy pbs`msmsp lsbk
cmjida om~q jik fbidf vjmdm|ms jm lmeq lgidq$
Qjm pgda aipidqmfsgqma cmjida Ag|m gda g j}fm h}dfem g~~mgsma
gjmga bl jik$ Jm mdqmsma iq jb~idf qjm pbs`msmsp jga aipg~~mgsma
gebdf viqj qjm ampmsq$ Qjm h}dfem gsb}da jik fsmv ~iq`j ceg`o c}q
qjm fegpp cgee febvma g cmg}qil}e ce}m gda csb}fjq g cmg}qil}e eifjq
gsb}da jik$ Jm vgeoma bd jb~idf jm vb}ea pmm jip f}gsaigd$
Qjm qsmmp gsb}da jik cmfgd qb fb jgyvism% qsyidf qb smpqsi`q jik
gda kgom jik asb~ qjm fegpp cgee$ Jm pqs}ffema gfgidpq qjmk$ G
pblq qb}`j b|ms jip pjb}eams kgam jik q}sd$ Jm pgv jms lg`m?mymp pb ~}sm% pjm vgp febvidf gda pkiema qjm pvmmqmpq pkiem jm
jga m|ms pmmd$ Jm lmeq cmviq`jma cy jms$ Qjm qsmmp vmsm db
ebdfms idqmslmsidf$ Iq vgp g kgfi`ge kbkmdq gda qjmd pjm
mzqmdama jms jgdap viam qb sm`mi|m qjm fegpp cgee$
Jm vgp ebboidf id jms agxxeidf mymp gda jip jmgsq kmeqma lsbk jms
cmg}qy$ Jm pqsmq`jma jip jgdap qb fsgdq jms qjm cgee$ H}pq gp pjm
vgp gcb}q qb fmq iq lsbk jik% g jgda ~}eema jik cg`o pb jgsa qjgqjm lmee qb qjm fsb}da bd jip cg`o pb gp qb g|bia pjgqqmsidf qjm
fegpp cgee$
G pqsbdf mdmsfy b|mssbam jik gda vmdq gda pemv qjm bdm jm jga
qjb}fjq vgp jip f}gsaigd$ Jm p`smgkma db% c}q qjmd pgv qjm bdm
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 123/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
jmjga qjb}fjq qb cm jip f}gsaigd q}sd idqb g jiamb}p cmidf$ Qjm
lifjq vgp lims`m gda iq vgp qgoidf ~eg`m sifjq gcb|m jik$
Cebba p~meq bd jik gda Ag|m q}sdma qb `b|ms jip lg`m gda qjm cgee
lsbk gdy jgsk gda lsbk pmmidf gdy kbsm aipq}scidf pifjqp$ Jip
jmgsq vgp sg`idf vieaey gda jm vgp pvmgqidf ~sbl}pmey$ Jm `b}ea
jmgs qjm qmssicem lifjqidf gcb|m jik gda qsima qb `b|ms jip mgsp qb
ceb`o iq gee b}q$
Qjmd `gkm g piemd`m pb amm~ iq j}sq jip mgsp% jm emq fb bl qjm
fegpp cgee qb `}q bll qjm piemd`m$ Ag|m qjb}fjq jm vgp fbidf `sgxy$Jm b~mdma jip mymp gda pgv qjm cmg}qil}e kgiamd jm jga pmmd
cmlbsm$ Jm vgp p`gsma gq lispq c}q qjmd pjm pkiema$ Pjm jga qjm
fegpp cgee id jms jgdap gda jms ~}sm pkiem gpp}sma jik qjgq pjm
vgp jip sifjql}e f}gsaigd$ Qjm pbs`msms jga h}pq qgomd jms lbsk qb
lbbe jik$
Csmgqjidf amm~ey% jm a}pqma jikpmel gda pqbba }~ qb lg`m jms% pjm
vgp qgee$ Jm qjmd ebboma gsb}da gda pgv qjgq jm vgp dbv id jiplgqjms’p cmasbbk$ Jip lgqjms jga hby smfipqmsma gee b|ms jip lg`m%
jip kbqjms ebboma agxxema gda Csip ebboma cbsma$
Ag|m q}sdma qb jip f}gsaigd gda pjm ebboma gq jik pkieidf$ Csip
p~biema qjm kbkmdq$
‚Jmy p}kkbd qjm pbs`msmsp% qjmy jg|m pbkmqjidf qjgq cmebdfp qb
}p%’ Csip pgia$
Qjm f}gsaigd myma Csip viqj gd gk}pma mz~smppibd$
‚Ip qjgq vjy yb} sm|i|ma km2 Gdyjbv% qjm pbs`msmsp viee csidf qb
yb} vjgqm|ms iq ip qjgq qjmy bvm yb} id a}m qikm$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 124/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚@gd yb} jme~ pg|m ky eilm lsbk qjm `beem`qbsp% pbs`msmsp%
vjgqm|ms qjmy gsm2’ Ag|m cmffma jms$
‚I vgp kmgdq qb ab qjgq g ebdf qikm gfb gda lbsfi|m km lbs jg|idf
lgiema yb} cmlbsm$ I pjgd’q lgie yb} qvi`m$’
‚Qjgdo yb}$’
Qjm f}gsaigd q}sdma qb Pqm|m% jip lg`m vgp abvd gp qjb}fj id
pjgkm$
‚Iq ip fbba qb pmm yb} gfgid Pqm|m%’ pjm pgia$
Pqm|m bdey dbaama gda Csip kgam g aipf}pqma ebbo bd jip lg`m$
Ag|m gda Asmv vmsm p}s~sipma qjgq qjm f}gsaigd odmv Pqm|m gq
gee$
‚^gpq qjm lbskgeiqimp bo% `gee }~ qjm pbs`msmsp dbv$’
‚Ip iq cm`g}pm yb} vgdq qb kmmq viqj yb}s bea eb|m Csip2 Yb} jg|m
abdm g fbba amma lbs g cga `g}pm%’ pjm qbea jik$
Csip vgp gq g ebpp bl vbsap$ M|msybdm ebboma gq jik c}q `b}ea dbq
}damspqgda vjgq jga h}pq cmmd pgia$ Dmiqjms ebboma smgay qb
mz~egid miqjms$
‚Qjmy jg|m ky lsimda Dgd`y%’ Ag|m qbea jip f}gsaigd$
‚I odbv% pjm kgy ei|m$’
‚Kgy2’
‚Iq’p h}pq g `gsa qjmy viee }pm qb fmq qb yb} c}q ab dbq cm glsgia lbs I
viee emga yb}$’
‚Viee yb} p}kkbd qjmk2’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 125/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Db dmma% qjmy gesmgay csmgqjma }p qjm kbkmdq yb} gppmkcema
qjm fegpp cgee$ Qjmy viee `bkm gda lifjq }p% vm jg|m qb fb kmmq
qjmk$’
‚Lifjq2’ gpoma g k}`j pjgomd Asmv$
‚Ymp$ Csip% yb}s ebygeqimp viee cm qmpqma%’ pjm qjsmgqmdma Csip$
M|msybdm }damspqbba vjgq pjm kmgdq c}q lbs Asmv gda jip
kbqjms$ Csip pqgsma gq jms agsidf$
Pbbd Pqm|m asb|m qjmk id jip `gs jmgaidf qb qjm cgssmd egda$ Qjgq~eg`m vgp kbsm qjgd g cgssmd egda% iq vgp g ~eg`m bl fsmgq
cebbapjma$ G oida bl cebbapjma qjgq aia dbq jg~~md smf}egsey$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 126/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
@JG^QMS 3>
Qjm pbs`msmsp lmeq g sm|i|ge gda vmsm fsmgqey gemsqma$ Fid gda jms mdqb}sgfm qsg|meema qb qjm asy fsmgqey ~gs`jma egda qb kmmq viqj
qjm sm|i|ma f}gsaigd$ Pjm vgp fsmgqey gdfmsma gq vjgq jga
jg~~mdma gp pjm jga dbq pmmd iq `bkidf$ Qjmy gdfsiey sbgkma
g`sbpp qjm cgssmd egda? qjm sm|i|ma jga dbq ymq gssi|ma$
Qjmy p~bqqma qjm `gs g~~sbg`jidf id qjm aipqgd`m% p~mmaiey qjmy
jb|msma id qjm gis$ Mgfms lbs g `jgeemdfm% mgfms lbs cebba qb p~iee$
Qjmy jb|msma gsb}da qjm `gs% qsyidf qb ~}pj iq bll qsg`o$ Pqm|m viqjqjm }pm bl lbsmqjb}fjq g|biama kgdy amgaey idpqgd`mp$ Fid vgp
fmqqidf kbsm mdsgfma gda mz`iqma gee gq qjm pgkm qikm$ Viqj lbs`m
pjm ~}pjma qjm `gs pb qjgq iq vmdq p~iddidf bd qjm fsb}da
d}kmsb}p qikmp$
Qjm f}gsaigd j}ffma Ag|m gda jip kbqjms id g vgy bl ~sbqm`qibd$
Pjm `smgqma g p~g`m gsb}da qjmk pb qjmy `b}ea dbq fmq j}sq$ Csip%
bd`m g `beem`qbs gda Pqm|m% bd`m qsgidma qb cm g f}gsaigd lgkieigs
viqj qjm `is`}kpqgd`mp h}k~ma b}q bl qjm vidabv gda lb}fjq bll
qjm pbs`msmsp id qjm cmpq vgy qjmy `b}ea$ Csip gda Pqm|m lb}fjq
piam cy piam eiom csbqjmsp vb}ea$
Qjm `gs p~iddma }dqie iq mz~ebama idqb legkmp$ Ag|m gda jip
kbqjms `b}ea jg|m aima jga iq dbq cmmd lbs qjm f}gsaigd$ Iq vgp g
amgaey fsb}da qjmy jga `bkm }~bd$ Qjm pbs`msmsp vmsmd}kmsb}p gda qjmy vmsm bdey g jgdal}e$ Ag|m gda Asmv vmsm
lieema viqj pb k}`j lmgs$ Qjm f}gsaigd pqbba gcb|m qjmk id g vgy
gp qb ~sbqm`q qjmk$ Pjm jga qjm febvidf fegpp cgee id jms jgda$
Fid pgv qjm sm|i|ma f}gsaigd gda viqj l}ee lbs`m lemv qb jms viqj
idqmdqibdp bdey qb ampqsby$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 127/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Csip pgv Fid gda jip jmgsq kmeqma viqj qjm eb|m jm jga lmeq lbs jms
gda pqiee aia$ Jm jga pg`sili`ma qjm pbs`msy vbsea cm`g}pm bl jip
eb|m lbs jms$ Vjmd jm pgv jms jm `b}ea dbq smpipq c}q `gee jms
dgkm$ Vjmd pjm jmgsa jik `gee jms dgkm% pjm pqb~~ma id kia+gis
gda pgv Csip id gee jip cmg}qy$ Id mgfmsdmpp pjm vgpqma db qikm
fbidf abvd qb kmmq jik$ Qjm f}gsaigd db ebdfms bd jms kida$
Csip gda Fid pjgsma g ebdf amm~ oipp gda m|msybdm id qjm |i idiqy
pqb~~ma qjmis lifjqidf qb vgq`j qjm eb|m p`mdm$ Asmv’p jmgsq fg|m
bdm cif hbeq gda pjm lmee qb qjm fsb}da vmgomdma cy qjm pifjq pjm
pgv$ Qjmy vmsm pb id eb|m% qjm vgy jm jmea jms lg`m gda qjm vgy
pjm vsg~~ma jms jgdap gsb}da jik$ Asmv vgp fsmgqey
mkcgssgppma$ Pqm|m ebboma gq jms id ~iqy$ Pjm jia jms lg`m gp pjm
`sima$ Ag|m `b}ea dbq cmeim|m jip mymp? qjm pbs`msms qjgq
qbskmdqma jik vgp oippidf qjm Csip qjgq jga ~sbkipma vgp bd jip
piam$ Jip p~isiqp lmee gda qjmd jm cm`gkm gdfsy pmmidf jip kbqjms
`sy eiom qjgq$
Gdfsiey Ag|m sgd qb vjmsm qjmy vmsm oippidf mdaemppey gda
~}pjma Csip gvgy lsbk Fid$ Iq vgp g fsmgq p~m`qg`em lbs qjm
pbs`msmsp gda qjmy vmsm mdhbyidf iq$
‚I qjb}fjq yb} eb|ma ky kbqjms%’ Ag|m pjb}qma$
‚Yb}s kbqjms ip g ciq`j'’
‚Jbv agsm yb} pgy qjgq'’
Ag|m vgp ~}d`jidf Csip c}q iq vgp ebboidf |gf}m cm`g}pm Csip
vgp pqsbdf gda bc|ib}pey lmeq db ~gid$ Qisma bl qjm l}ppidf% Csip
~}pjma Ag|m gvgy$ Jip ~gsmdqp sgd qb jik qb `jm`o il jm vgp bo$
Csip gda Fid pm~gsgqma gp qjm f}gsaigd `gkm bd qjm p`mdm$ Pjm
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 128/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
vmdq gda pqbba b|ms qjm `syidf Asmv% Ag|m pmmkma lidm$ Pqm|m
pqgsma gdfsiey gq Csip c}q Csip vgp }dkb|ma$
‚Yb} jg|m pbkmbdm qjgq cmebdfp qb }p%’ qjm f}gsaigd pgia qb Fid$
‚Gda vm gsm dbq fi|idf jms cg`o'’ Fid p~gq$
‚Vjmsm ip pjm2’
‚Db dmma qb odbv il yb} gsmd’q jg|idf jms gdyvgy$’
‚Vm vgdq jms cg`o$’
‚Qjmd qjmsm’p fbq qb cm g sgdpbk$’
‚Jbv k}`j ab yb} vgdq2’ Ag|m gpoma pjgoidf$
Fid gda qjm pbs`msmsp eg}fjma m|ms pb eb}aey$ Ag|m aia dbq odbv
vjgq jm jga pgia qjgq vgp pb gk}pidf$ Qjm c}sey kgd csb}fjq
Dgd`y qb qjm p`mdm$ Jms kb}qj pmgema% mymp ceidama cy g `ebqj
gda jgdap gda lmmq qima$ Pjm ebboma cmgq }~$‚Dgd`y'’ Ag|m `geema$
Pjm vgp vmgsidf qjm |msy pgkm sma asmpp jm jga cb}fjq jms$ Jm
lmeq pb cga vjmd jm pgv jms$ Qjm c}sey kgd qbppma Dgd`y pb qjgq
pjm lmee bd qjm fsb}da% pjm emq b}q g pkgee kbgd bl ~gid$ Ag|m
qjmd pgv qjgq pjm vgp g pqsbdf fise? jm `b}ea dbq ikgfidm vjgq
pjm jga fbdm qjsb}fj$ Jm vgdqma qb fb jbea jms c}q qjm f}gsaigd
pqb~~ma jik$
‚Emg|m qjip qb km%’ pjm pgia$
‚C}q pjm’p ky lsimda$’ Ag|m vgp `syidf$
‚I odbv% h}pq `gek abvd% I fbq qjip `b|msma%’ pjm gpp}sma jik$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 129/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Ag|m jmea cg`o qjm }sfm qb fb gda `bklbsq Dgd`y$ Jm `b}ea dbq
cmgs qjgq pjm jga fbdm qjsb}fj p}`j qbsq}sm cm`g}pm bl jik$
‚I viee fi|m Dgd`y qb yb}%’ Fid pgia% ‚Gda Ag|m% gsb}da jmsm vm
abd’q `gsm gcb}q `gpj% iq’p g cebba p~meq lbs g cebba p~meq$ ’
Ag|m pvgeebvma$ Qjm f}gsaigd ebboma gq jik pgaamdma cy qjm
qs}qj Fid jga qbea$ Jm ebboma gq jms mz~m`qidf pjm vb}ea bchm`q
gda pmmidf qjm pgadmpp id jms mymp odmv qjgq vgp qjm bdey vgy$
‚G sgdpbk lbs Dgd`y Ag|m$ Cebba lbs cebba% qmgs lbs qmgs% gpj lbs
gpj c}q hby lbs ~gid$ Pb Ag|m vjb pjgee iq cm2’
Ag|m vgp pvmgqidf gda aia dbq odbv vjgq qb ab bs pgy$ Gee
gqqmdqibd vgp bd jik$ Csip qjmd vjip~msma pbkmqjidf id jip mgs
c}q Ag|m aia dbq ebbo qbb jg~~y gq vjgq jm jmgsa$ Jip f}gsaigd
pqm~~ma lbsvgsa$
‚I pjgee qgom jip ~eg`m%’ pjm pgia$
Qjmy vmsm gee p}s~sipma$
‚G f}gsaigd pg`sili idf lbs g kmsm kbsqge2 Vbv% c}q vjgq `gd I ab
viqj yb} smgeey2 I vgdq g am`ipibd lsbk Ag|m gda jm `jbbpmp vjb
jm viee qsgam lbs ~bbs Dgd`y gda iq pjb}ea dbq cm pbkm f}gsaigd'’
Qjm pbs`msmsp eg}fjma% smeipjidf mg`j kbkmdq bl qjm pjbv$ Ag|m
lmeq }dams pb k}`j ~smpp}sm$
‚I pjgee fi|m Csip%’ Ag|m pgia qb Fid$
M|msybdm vgp p}s~sipma$ Qjm pbs`msmsp p~m`}egqma gkbdf
qjmkpme|mp$ Qjmy jga gesmgay amgeq viqj Csip cmlbsm? jm jga cmmd
bdm bl qjmk }dqie jm }degvl}eey jga gd gllgis viqj Fid vji`j jga
`g}pma jip mz~}epibd$ Pjm jga jga jik p~gsma lsbk amgqj$
M|msybdm vgiqma lbs jms am`ipibd gp pjm vgp dbv qjm kgpqms
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 130/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
pbs`msms glqms p}``mmaidf jms lgqjms$ Qjmy qjb}fjq jms g eiqqem
kbsm `gsmempp qjgd jms lgqjms jga cmmd c}q qjmy eioma jms pqiee lbs
jms agsidfdmpp$
‚Csip2’ Fid gpoma gp qjb}fj qb cm p}sm$
Ag|m dbaama$ Csip ebboma }dgllm`qma$ Pjm pkiema csimley gq qjm
qjb}fjq bl jg|idf jms bea eb|ms cg`o id jms `bk~gdy$ Iq vb}ea cm
di`m c}q dbq pb fbba gp jm kifjq vgdq qb `bdqsbe jms oidfabk bl
pbs`msmsp id jms ~eg`m$ Pjm vgp }dp}sm c}q pjm `b}ea dbq amdy
qjm vgskqj gsb}da jms jmgsq vji j pjm jga lmeq vjmd pjm jgapmmd jik$
‚I gk aipg~~bidqma id yb} Ag|m%’ Fid pgia% ‚yb} gsm g `bvgsa$ I
jga mz~m`qma yb} qb pg`sili`m yb}spmel$ Jbv }dsbkgdqi` bl yb}$’
Fid qjmd fmpq}sma viqj jms jgda gda Dgd`y vgp qjsbvd b|ms qb
Ag|m% jm jmea jms qifjq$ Jm `b}ea csmgqj jms lmgs$ Jm `sima gp jm
j}ffma jms pgyidf jm vgp |msy pbssy$ Dgd`y vgp dbq pgyidfgdyqjidf c}q qmgsp vmsm s}ddidf abvd jms mymp$ Jm ebbpmdma jms
c}q pjm om~q jms mymp `ebpma gda aia dbq kb|m$ Pjm k}pq jg|m
cmmd smgeey qmssilima$
Csip csb}fjq jikpmel b|ms qb Fid% pjm pkiema gp pjm lmeq jip lg`m$
Jm lmeq jmsp qbb$ Qjmy vmsm ebboidf amm~ idqb mg`j bqjms’p mymp
gda qjmd qjmy oippma ~gppibdgqmey bd`m kbsm lbs g ebdf qikm$ Fid
lmeq qjm eb|m b|msvjmek jms gda pjm odmv Csip vb}ea cm jms abvdlgee% pjm eb|ma jik pb k}`j pjm `b}ea ab gdyqjidf lbs jik$
Jm vgp jms bdey vmgodmpp$
‚Csip% iq’p fbba qb jg|m yb} cg`o$ I eb|m yb}$’
‚I eb|m yb} qbb$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 131/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
Jm oippma jms gfgid gda pebvey viqjasgvidf g odilm lsbk jms sbcm%
pjm fbq iq gda viqj cbqj jgdap pqgccma Csip id qjm cg`o$ Jm
kbgdma pblqey lsbk qjm ~gid gda qjmd jm lmee abvd amga$
Pjm cmdq abvd b|ms jik gda `sima m|ms pb eb}aey qjgq qjm fsb}dap
cmebv qjmk cmfgd qb pjgom viqj qmssbs$ Agso `eb}ap fgqjmsma b|ms
qjmk$ Qj}dams cbeqp sbeema% eifjqmdidf legpjma gda qjm qj}dams
vgp qmssilyidf$
M|msybdm lema qjm p`mdm gda Fid vgp emlq gebdm bd qjm cgssmd
egda% viqj jms jgdap pqgidma id qjm cebba bl qjm kgd pjm eb|ma$Jm amga id jms gskp gda pjm `syidf qmgsp bl cebba$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 132/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
M^IEBF]M
Asmv jmgsa qjm abbscmee sidf% iq vgp pqiee mgsey id qjm kbsdidf$ Pjmvmdq qb qjm abbs gda b~mdma iq$ G egsfm cb}w}mq bl lebvmsp kmq
jms mymp$ Qjm egsfm cb}w}mq jia qjm kgd’p lg`m$ Jm vbsm g dmgq
~gis bl pdmgomsp% hmgdp gda g di`m pjisq$ Pjm sm`mi|ma qjm lebvmsp
gda gekbpq asb~~ma qjmk vjmd pjm pgv jip lg`m$ Iq vgp Pqm|m%
jm pkiema gq jms$ Pjm vgp p~mm`jempp gda h}pq emq jik id$
Jm mdqmsma jms ei|idf sbbk gda pmmkma `bklbsqgcem k}`j qb
Asmv’p aip`bkliq}sm$ Pjm pgq b~~bpiqm jik gda ebboma gq jik
cegdoey$
‚Ji Asmv$’
‚Pqm|m% vjy gsm yb} jmsm2 Gda vjy gsmd’q yb} id yb}s ~simpqey
sbcmp$’
‚I gk lsmm dbv$’‚Lsmm qb ab vjgq2’
‚Lsmm qb eb|m yb}$’
‚Jbv gda gdyvgy% gk dbq p}sm I gk smgay lbs eb|m$ Yb} eima qb
km% yb} jga gcgdabdma km h}pq cm`g}pm yb} vmsm gpjgkma yb}
jga lgiema qb cm g f}gsaigd gda vmdq qb jiam yb}s pjgkm gp
qjb}fj yb} vmsm g ~simpq c}q vmsm dbq$’
‚Pb yb} odbv I vgp dbq smgeey g ~simpq2 Vjb qbea yb} gee qjip2
Csip2’
Pjm dbaama% gpjgkma bl jmgsidf qjm dgkm Csip$
‚Vmee% iq ip qs}m I jga lgiema$’
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 133/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚Pb iq ip qs}m vjgq jm qbea km2’
‚Ymp% c}q jm aia dbq qmee yb} qjm vjbem qs}qj$’‚Vjgq ip qjm vjbem qs}qj qjmd2 Vjy aia yb} emg|m km qb sgipm
Ag|m gebdm2’
‚I dm|ms vgdqma qb c}q qjm pbs`msmsp vmsm glqms ky eilm gda il I jga
ei|ma viqj yb} qjmy `b}ea jg|m gqqg`oma yb} gda oieema yb}$ I jga
qb omm~ yb} g pm`smq c}q `b}ea dbq vjmd Ag|m fbq id|be|ma$’
‚Bjj% vjy aia yb} dbq qmee km2’
‚I aia dbq vgdq yb} qb ei|m gp g ~sipbdms eiom km% vjb vgp jiaidf
lsbk ky ~gpq$ Bdey g lmv gsm `geema qb cm f}gsaigdp id qjm kia+eilm
gda I lgiema ky `geeidf$’
‚Jbv aia yb} lgie2’ Asmv vgp `}sib}p$
‚Yb} smgeey vgdq qb odbv2’
Pjm dbaama$
‚Gp g f}gsaigd I vgp p}~~bpma qb omm~ kypmel ~}sm id qjip eilm cy
}damsfbidf g amm~ kmaiqgqibd$ I vgp fsmgq gda }damsqbbo
idqmsdpji~ vjmsm I vgp gcem qb vgsa bll m|iep% qjm eiomp bl Csip$ I
vgp |msy fbba c}q bdm agy I lgiema$’
‚Yb} h}pq lgiema2’
‚I lmee id eb|m viqj qjm kbpq cmg}qil}e vbkgd bd mgsqj$ I lmee id eb|m
viqj yb}$ Iq vgp lbsciaamd c}q yb} vmsm g ampqidy vbsqj pg`sili`m$’
Asmv `b}ea lmme jms lg`m fmq jbq$ Pjm ebboma abvd qsyidf qb g|bia
mym `bdqg`q$ Pjm vgp s}ccidf jms jgdap qbfmqjms id gdzimqy$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 134/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
6 DBQMP
‚I qjb}fjq I jga ebpq ky ampqidy%’ Pqm|m pgia% ‚c}q id ebpidf iq% I
lb}da qjgq I lb}da g dmv ampqidy% qb jme~ pg|m ky pbdp eilm$’
‚Qjgdo yb}%’ Asmv pgia$
Jm asmv `ebpms qb jms gda oippma jms ei~p$ Pjm kippma jik gee bl g
p}aamd gda oippma jik cg`o amm~ey$ Pjm vgp jg~~y gda jm vgp
m|md jg~~ims$
Ag|m asgkgqi geey mz~egidma qjm m|mdq qb jip lsimdap Gddm gda Cieelbs qjm j}dasmaqj qikm$ Qjmy vmsm pqiee pb mdfsbppma id qjm pqbsy%
fega jm vgp gei|m gda dbq cmeim|idf vjgq jga qsgdp~isma gq qjm
‚cgssmd egda’$
‚Vbv% qjgq `b}ea m|md cm g `bk~}qms fgkm kgd%’ Ciee pgia$
‚I gk fega yb} gsm pglm$ Jbdmpqey I dm|ms qjb}fjq yb} vb}ea kgom
iq'’‚C}q yb} vmsm qjm bdm vjb vgp pb `bdliamdq Gddm$’
‚Kbsge p}~~bsq ip gevgyp ik~bsqgdq m|md vjmd qjmsm ip db jb~m%
yb} odbv$’
‚Qjgdop gdyvgy$’
G |msy c}ccey Dgd`y ~gppma qjmk cy$ Jgdap l}ee viqj pjb~~idf
cgfp$
‚Jmyy Dgd`y%’ Ag|m pgia$
Pjm pqgsma gq jik cegdoey qjmd g odbvidf ebbo `gkm bd jms lg`m$
7/31/2019 7 NOTES ; the collectors
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/7-notes-the-collectors 135/135
JGAGPPGJ EB]IP
‚Bjj yb} pqiee vgdq yb}s asmpp2 Qs}pq km iq’p b}q bl pjg~m% I abd’q
odbv jbv iq fbq eiom qjgq$ K}pq jg|m cmmd g jmee bl g as}domd
difjq$’
‚Db I abd’q vgdq qjm asmpp$’
‚Fbba'’
Pjm vgeoma gvgy cmlbsm jm `b}ea pgy gdy kbsm$ Poi~~idf eiom g
`jiea gp pjm vmdq gda mzgffmsgqidf jms jgis kb|mkmdqp$ Ciee gda
Gddm vmsm legq viqj eg}fjqms$
Qjgdop qb Ag|m’p f}gsaigd Dgd`y `b}ea dbq smkmkcms gdyqjidf
gcb}q qjm m|mdqp qjgq jga jg~~mdma qb jms$ Pjm jga gepb cmmd vmee
jmgema jmd`m jga k}`j mdmsfy$ Jm vgq`jma jms fb% pjm vgp pqiee
qjm pgkm Dgd`y jm odmv cmlbsm$
Jm vbdamsma il jm pqiee eb|ma jms gp k}`j% bj ymp jm vgp `sgxy
gcb}q jms gp k}`j gp pjm vgp dbq `sgxy gcb}q jik$ ^msjg~p jm
pjb}ea c}y jms gdbqjms asmpp c}q qjb}fjq cmqqms bl iq$ Jm hbidmajip lsimda eg}fjidf% eg}fjidf gq qjm vgy qjmy vmsm eg}fjidf$