65-87 Ramazan Et Al a Review of Orientalist on Quran-Hadith & Seerah (Returned)

7/29/2019 65-87 Ramazan Et Al a Review of Orientalist on Quran-Hadith & Seerah (Returned)

1/23


2/23


3/23


4/23


5/23


6/23


7/23


8/23


9/23


10/23

74 Ramzan et al., A review on the objections

though the forgetting is caused by God.

Incidentally, this implies that the

revelations were not written down.

(Montgomrey , 1988)

The verse of Holy Quran which

Montgomrey Watt has pointed out is:

And remember your God when you

forget something and say that I hope my

God will show me the clear path better

than the previous one. Al-Quran

Thats why in response to their objection,

Allah said that:

We reveal another verse better or at least

same as the previous one if we cancel

some verse. AlQuran

In another verse of Surah Al- Aala, Allah

says:

We will teach you by ourselves. You will

forget nothing except what Allah wishes.

Al-Quran

Answer

In the first verse Allah says that we used to

reveal different proofs of our power and

reveals different verses for the guidance of

the people. We keep the verses in the

hearts of people which we wish them to

remember and forget others that we want

them to forget. This is the Sunnah of Allah

which is not fixed from any specific time.

Here Insah is the form of cancellation.

Cancellation is related with order.

Sometimes order is cancelled but its

recitation remains to continue. But through

Nisah, such type of cancellation is being

discussed here in which recitation along

with the order is cancelled. Moreover,

Allah washes away such verses from the

minds of people through his power. If

human beings forget something it is

considered a weakness among the list of

weaknesses of humans but something

washes away from the minds of people by

Allah is not in the hands of humans. Thats

why it would not be considered as the

weakness of humans (Montgomery, 1988)

ObjectionNo-5. the Different Accents of

Recitation of Holy Quran

Oriental give different direction to the

different accents of recitation of Holy

Quran. They try to prove that as Bible has

different versions. Similarly, these are

different versions of the Holy Quran.

Thats why George Cell says that:

Having mentioned the different editions

of Quran, it may not be a miss here to

acquaint the reader that there are seven

principal editions. If I may so call them as

Gomal University Journal of Research, 28(1). June, 2012


11/23


12/23


13/23


14/23


The Issue to Forbid Writing Hadiths

Oriental say that Prophet Muhammad

(SAW) had forbidden the Muslims to

write Hadiths. Thats why most of the

followers disliked writing Hadiths and

they also forbade the people who wrote

Hadiths. There were other people as well

in the later decades who were against the

writing of Hadiths. At the time of Makkah

victory when Prophet Muhammad (SAW)

delivered the sermon then one Yemenis

stood up. His name was Abu Shah. He

requested the Holy Prophet (SAW) to get

that sermon in the written form. On that

occasion, Holy Prophet (SAW) said to his

followers to write it for Abu Shah. Hazrat

Abdullah Bin Umro says, Whatever I

listen from the Holy Prophet (SAW) I used

to write it. My purpose was to remember it

later. Quraish forbade me to do this and

said, Whatever you listen from the Holy

Prophet (SAW0 you write it. Although,

Holy Prophet (SAW) is a human being and

he speaks in every state, normal or angry. I

left writing and told this thing to the Holy

Prophet. Hazrat Muhammad (SAW)

pointed towards his mind with his index

finger and said, Write whatever you listen

because this tongue always speaks out the

truth. Al-Munahil

The fact is that work of writing and

compilation has always been in progress in

every era. Muslims have never ignored

this job to protect the Hadiths and they

have always used the same method to

protect their manuscripts that accurately

fulfilled the then requirements (Al-Azhari,

1983)

Compilation of Hadiths during the time

of Holy Prophet

Hazrat Abu Huraira (R.A) got a superb

memory and he had saved number of

Hadiths in written with him. Hazrat Fazeel

Bin Hassan (R.A) relates with his father

that once he said, I read a Hadith from

Hazrat Abu Huraira. He didnt admit it. I

told him that I have heard this Hadith from

you. He said if you have really heard this

Hadith from me then it must be written

with me. Then he held my hand and took

me to his house. He showed me many

books of Hadiths of the Holy Prophet. In

those books there was also present the

concerned Hadith. He said I told you that

if you had really heard this Hadith from

me it would be definitely in written with

me. Hazrat Abu Huraira (R.A) permitted

Hazrat Bashir (R.A) to copy his Hadiths

and he also permitted him to relate his

Hadiths. Al-Sunnah



15/23


16/23


17/23


18/23


19/23


they couldnt see any kind of flaws in his

personality. Even the people who were the

worst enemy of the Holy Prophet (SAW)

and had hatched conspiracies against him

couldnt consider him deceiver or cheater.

Rather, they used to keep their precious

belongings with you and called you as

Sadiq and Ameen.(Al-Azhari 1983)

Allah Almighty has said about the Holy

Prophet that:

And of course you are the best example

of morality. Al-Quran

Allah Almighty has used the word to

express the countless qualities of the Holy

Prophet (SAW).

The Holy Prophet (SAW) said that:

I had been sent to set the best example of

morality. (Al-Azhari,1983)

OBJECTION NO-11:NUMBER OF

WIVES

One of the most objectionable and biggest

objections raised against the Holy Prophet

(SAW) by Oriental is of having many

wives. Oriental either of the past or

present, they start the process of putting

fake allegations on Hazrat Muhammad

(SAW) from the number of wives. They

try to spoil the character of Hazrat

Muhammad (SAW). Their objections

regarding the number of wives move

around the following points:

(a) He had been under the control of

sexual desire.

(b) He fixed the number of wives for his

followers and males of his ummah but

himself

didnt act upon it.

(c) He got married with every woman

whom he liked. (Example of Hazrat

Zainab (R.A)

is presented in this regard at very high

level).

(d) Fulfilled his sexual desire under the

cover of many wives.

(e) When he got no recognition he had

only one wife but as soon as he got fame

and

popularity, the number of wives

started increasing.

Answer

The tradition to keep more than one wife

is an old one and no decline in the status

of people in the social society had been

observed due to this reason. Same is the

case with the Holy Prophet (SAW) but if

we have a glance at the life of the Holy

Prophet (SAW) then we came to know



20/23


21/23


22/23


23/23


Sulemani M (1993).Ehsan-ul-Haq, RasoolMubeen , Maqbool Academy, Lahore,

Page -603.

Al- Azhari M K S (1983). Zia-ul-Quran

Publications,Lahore,Volume 7, Page-331.

Edward G (1962).The Decline and Fall of

the Roman Empire Everymen

Arthur G (1979).Islam, Muhammad and

his Religion, Habzmeral Educational,Library London , Volume 5, Page-270. Indiana Police, Page-126.

Montgomery W (1961). Muhammad,

Prophet and Statesman Oxford

University, Page- 234.

Mansoorpuri M S Q . Shiekh Ghulam Ali

& Sons, Lahore, Volume 2, Page 127.

Mansoorpuri M S Q. Shiekh Ghulam Ali

& Sons, Lahore, Volume 2, Page-129.Al- Azhari M K S, Nabi Z (1983). Zia-ul-

Quran Publications, Lahore, Volume 7,Page-392. Al- Azhari M K S (1983). Zia-ul-Quran

Publications, Lahore, Volume 7,

Al-Quran Al-Karim , Surah Al-Kalam,Verse 4. Page 475-479.

65-87 Ramazan Et Al a Review of Orientalist on Quran-Hadith & Seerah (Returned)

Documents

Transcript of 65-87 Ramazan Et Al a Review of Orientalist on Quran-Hadith & Seerah (Returned)