49459414 Commodity Markets
-
Upload
shahtejas12 -
Category
Documents
-
view
222 -
download
0
Transcript of 49459414 Commodity Markets
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
1/93
Indian Commodity Markets
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
2/93
2
TopicsCommodity markets overview
Commodity Markets
Global Commodity markets
Indian Commodity markets
Regulations and Risk management
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
3/93
3
INDIA Macro-Economic Indicators
One of worlds fastest growing
significant economiesGDP growth rate > 8% pa
Forex reserves > $ 275 billionPopulation one billion:>110 cr.
crores growing at 1.5% paThird largest producer of food
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
4/93
4
Commodities- Defined
Goods with economic value; traded
in bulk; usually raw material forfurther processing;
Agri: Food crops, non-food crops;
Non-agri: metals, energy, polymers
Others: cattle head, orange juice
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
5/93
5
What is a Commodity ?
Commodity includes all kinds of goods Commodity futures contracts are
regulated under the Forward MarketContracts (Regulation) Act, 1952
FCRA defines goods as every kind ofmovable property other than actionableclaims, money and securities
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
6/93
6
Commodities Segment wise
COMMODITIES
MetalsMetals Edible OilsEdible Oils SoftsSofts Other Agri.
Comm.
Other Agri.
Comm.
Cotton
Sugar
Silk
Gur
Wheat
Guar Seed
Soy Beans
Castor Mustard
Urad
Rice
Chana Etc..
Copper
Nickel
Tin
Crude Palm Oil
Soy Oil
Mustard Oil
Gold
Silver
Steel
EnergyEnergy
BrentcrudeOil
Furnace Oil
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
7/93
7
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
8/93
8
Worlds Major
Commodity Exchanges
NCDEX
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
9/93
9
Major Global Commodity Exchanges
CBOT Chicago Board of Trade (1848)
Oldest existing commodity exchange in the world Initially started with agricultural commodities like corn,
wheat, soybeans and oats
Now trading in non-storable agricultural commoditiesand non-agricultural products also
Electronic trading introduced in 1994 after 150 years of
existence NYMEX
Two divisions
NYMEX division trading in energy and platinum andCOMEX division trading in other metals.
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
10/93
10
Major Global Commodity Exchanges
CME Chicago Mercantile Exchange (1898)
Largest futures exchange in the Us and the largest futuresclearing house in the world for futures and options trading Introduced the first financial futures Most volumes in interest rate futures, stock indices and
foreign exchange futures LME London Metal Exchange (1877)
Worlds premier non-ferrous metals market, with highly
liquid contracts IPE International Petroleum Exchange SIMEX Singapore International Monetary Exchange
Contracts in different Fuels and Gold
SICOM Singapore Commodity Exchange variousrubbers and robusta coffee
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
11/93
11
Major Global Commodity Exchanges
KLCE Kuala Lumpur Commodity Exchange Non-fuel commodities
First exchange to start crude palm oil contracts in 1980
Brazil Bosla de Mercadorias and Futuros US$denominated coffee, soyabean, live cattle, feedercattle, cotton, crystal sugar, corn and gold
Buenos Aires Grain Exchange, Australia 1854
one of the oldest in the world Grain futures started in 1907
Wheat, maize, sunflowers, soybeans,
US$ denominated contracts
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
12/93
12
Evolution of Commodity Derivatives
Age-old phenomenon
12th century BC: China, Egypt, Austria, India and Japanused forward market.
In 17th Century, Japanese Rice Farmers have usedfutures market to secure the future value of theirproduction.
1848 CBOT
1875 Bombay Cotton Traders Association
1919 Calcutta Hessian Exchange Ltd which wasnamed in 1945 as EIJHE with the merger of East IndiaJute Association Ltd
Indian Context Various
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
13/93
13
Indian Context - VariousCommittees
Khusro Committee
The Khusro Committee (June 1980) had recommended reintroduction of
futures tradingin most of the major commodities , including cotton, kapas,raw jute and jute goodsand suggested that steps may be taken forintroducing futures trading in commodities, like potatoes, onions, etc. atappropriate time. The government, accordingly initiated futures trading inPotato during the latter half of 1980 in quite a few markets in Punjab and
Uttar Pradesh
Kabra Committee (1994)
Reintroduction of futures tradingin various commodities like BasmatiRice, Cotton and Kapas, Raw Jute and Jute Goods, Groundnut ,rapeseed/mustard seed , cottonseed , sesame seed , sunflower seed ,safflower seed , copra and soybean , and oils and oilcakes of all of them,Rice bran oil, Castor oil and its oilcake, Linseed, Silver and, Onions.
Upgradation of existing futures exchanges
Upgradation of facilities in the physical commodities markets also by way ofimproving the quality of warehousing etc.
E l ti f I di C dit
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
14/93
14
Evolution of Indian Commodity
Derivatives 1969 Ban on Commodity Futures
1990s many committees appointed tostudy need of commodity futures trading
1997 invitation to set up NMCEs 2003 Ban totally lifted, 54 commodities
freed up
P R i it f S tti f
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
15/93
15
Pre-Requisite for Setting up of aCommodity Exchange
These multi-commodity exchanges have the following
essential features. De-mutualized form of organization
On-line trading and clearing system with national reach
Delivery of underlying commodity backed by a warehouse receipt Real time price and trade information dissemination
Transparency in operations
Professional management
Participation of reliable intermediaries such as Banks/ Institutions/Warehouses
3 NMCES -- NMCE, MCX and NCDEX
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
16/93
16
Commodity Exchanges
National CommodityExchange
Regional CommodityExchange
1 Compulsory online trading No compulsion for online trading
2 exchange should bedemutualised
exchange need not bedemutualises
3 exchange is recognised on apermanent basis
Exchange is recognised for a fixedperiod, after which it has to applyfor re-registration
4 All commodities permitted bygovernment for futures tradingcan be traded
Exchange has to apply for eachcommodity for futures trading.Sensitive commodities like goldand silver, rice and wheat are not
permitted for trading
Obj ti f C dit
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
17/93
17
Objectives of CommodityFutures Trading
Leads to price discovery and Price RiskManagement Buyers and sellers at the futures exchanges conduct
trading based on their assessment of inputs regarding
specific market information, expert views andcomments, the demand supply equilibrium, governmentpolicies, inflation rates, weather forecast, marketdynamics, hopes and fears
Obtaining protection from uncertain adverse pricemovements
Provides hedging option
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
18/93
18
Investment in Commodities.. Why?
A smart Investment choice
Risk Adjusted returns of a portfolio comprisingcommodities can be better than a pure equityor bond portfolio
Volatility is much lower in the commoditymarket compared with that in equities andbonds
Commodity market has little correlation withthe equity and bond markets.
Thus, commodity futures are an other asset class totraditional equity and bond market investors.
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
19/93
19
Diversification Benefits
Prtfolio Structure Absolute
cumulative
returns
Risk of
portfolio
Adjusted
Returns
100% stocks 73.7 24.3 3.0250% stocks + 50% gold 47.8 14.37 3.33
50% stocks + 50% silver 48.3 13.29 3.63
100% gold 21.8 10.89 2
100% silver 22.9 13.14 1.74
100% bonds 25.2 7.92 3.18
50% bonds + 50% gold 23.5 8.79 2.67
50% bonds + 50% silver 24 6.58 3.65
source: NCDEX
Risk Adjusted Returns for the period 1997-2003, in %
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
20/93
20
Volatility comparison - Summary
Average annual volatility
Sensex or Nifty 25-30%Govt Sec Index 5-10%Gold 12-18%
Silver 15-25%Cotton 10-12%
Oil seeds 15-20%Commodities are less volatile compared toequity market, but more volatile as compared
to G-Secssource: NCDEX and www.ficci.com - conference on commodity derivatives
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
21/93
21
Correlation coefficients in Indian Markets
Gold Silver Stocks BondsGold 1 0.55 -0.09 -0.028
Silver 1 -0.06 -0.015Stocks 1 -0.112
Bonds 1
Data: LBMA bullion prices, NSE Nifty, NSE G-Sec IndexSource: NCDEX
Objectives of Commodity
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
22/93
22
Objectives of Commodity
Futures Trading Integrates players and markets
Improves cropping pattern Ensures Liquidity
Provides Leverage Provides Credit Accessibility
B fi i i
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
23/93
23
Beneficiaries
Farmers/Primary producers
Processors/Manufacturers Exporters/Importers
Traders/Brokers/Speculators
Government Banks and Financial Institutions
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
24/93
24
Banks as Market Players
Owner/Promoter (ICICI , PNB, UBI,Canara, BOI, SBI, Corporation etc.)
Clearing Member (HDFC, ICICI etc.)
Investor/Trader/Broker
Financier (PNB, HDFC, Corporation,Axis, SBI, Karur Vysya, ICICI etc.)
Warehouse Receipts backed by acommodity Exchange
Non-fund based financing.
D d & S l D i
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
25/93
25
Demand & Supply Drivers
Fundamental factors: weather,
quantum of output, quality, stocks,export / import trade, govt policies,tariffs, taxes, Tastes, prices,
population, level of economicactivity, income (and changes
therein);Price drivers: role of funds; geo-
political concerns; inflation;
Global Agribusiness
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
26/93
26
Global Agribusiness
Rising output, falling prices; demand
trails supplies;Technology (agbiotech) & subsidy
(OECD) drive output growth
Growth expected in Asia, bothproduction and consumption;
Outlook now changing effect ofhigh crude prices? WTO? Diseases?
Gl b l N i M k
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
27/93
27
Global Non-agri Markets
Energy, base metals, precious
metals huge demand surge(China / Asia factor), supply
constraints, natural calamities,geo-political concerns, inflation
fears, huge speculativeinterest, role of funds;
Indian Agribusiness
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
28/93
28
Indian Agribusiness
Highly fragmented and low scale -
production, processing, marketing;Uncertainty in output, quality, price;
Long supply chain; too manyintermediaries; no primary grading/processing; non-standard quality;
Marketing restrictions
External & internal challenges
I di i k t
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
29/93
29
Indian non-agri market
Economic growth driving
demand for energy products;base metals; iron ore and steel;
Will India go the China way?Huge appetite for bullion;
demand income and priceelastic;
Thrust of Government Policy
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
30/93
30
Thrust of Government Policy
Economic liberalisation;internal
reforms; trade freedom /no controlsNational Agricultural Policy
Protection to domestic producersWTO compatibility
Risk management
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
31/93
31
Emerging Scenario
Expansion of commodity trade
Shorter supply chain
Competition from imports
Entry of multinationals
Dominance by a few large firms
S
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
32/93
32
Emerging Scenario
Waning role of government
Role for technology: InformationTechnology, agriculture and
biotechnology applications Integration of domestic market with
global marketHeightened risk perception
Global Commodity Market
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
33/93
33
Global Commodity Market
Market faces uncertainties: high crudeprices threaten global growth; Chinafactor; will supply respond to high prices?
Rising profile of commodities high
rewards; investors more aware; pricestouch multi-year highs; media;
Institutional investor interest rising MFs, pension funds;
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
34/93
34
Commodities MarketsSpot Market
Derivatives Market
Spot Commodities Markets
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
35/93
35
p
(Mandi Trading) Governaned by State Agricultural Marketing
Boards(SAMB), Mandi Board (Farmers, Traders,
State) More than 7000 Mandis trading in about 140 crops
Participants : Farmers, Licensed Traders, Brokers& Wholesale Dealers
Mandi Inspectors issue type & quantity certificate
Mandi fees :Transaction fee, Taxes; total variesbetween 4% and 12%
Trading, Clearing and Settlement
A D i ti i
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
36/93
36
A Derivative is
A security or contractdesigned in
such a way that Its price is derivedfrom the price
ofAn underlying asset Underlying asset for the derivative
Equity shares, indices, debt instruments,commodities, currency, interest rate,
derivatives
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
37/93
37
Derivatives Market
Derivatives are financial contracts.
The value of such contracts is derived from the value of someunderlying assets. Such underlying asset may be equity,commodity, currency, or debt instrument or borrowing amountetc.
With Securities Laws (Second Amendment) Act, 1999, Derivativeshas been included in the definition of Securities. The termDerivative has been defined in Securities Contracts
(Regulations) Act, as :A Derivative includes :
(a) A security derived from a debt instrument, share, loan, whether
secured or unsecured, risk instrument or contract fordifferences or any other form of security;
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
38/93
38
Derivatives Market
(b) A contract which derives its value from the prices,
or index of prices, of underlying securities;
Derivatives are a key part of the financial markets.
Derivatives market is comprised of
(a) Derivative products or financial contracts
(b) Participants in the derivatives market(c) Regulator(s)
Gl b l D i i I d Ch l f
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
39/93
39
Global Derivatives Industry - Chronology ofInstruments
Forward contract - is the oldest instrument.
1874 - Commodity futures. 1972 Futures contract on foreign currencies.
1973 Equity options.
1975 Interest rate futures.
1981 Currency swaps
1982 Interest rate swaps, equity index futures.
1983 Stock index options
1994 Introduction of credit derivatives.
Derivative Markets in India
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
40/93
40
Derivative Markets in India
The prohibition on options in SCRA was removed in1995. Foreign currency options in currency pairs otherthan rupee were the first options permitted by RBI.
The Reserve Bank of India has permitted options,interest rate swaps, currency swaps and other risk
reductions OTC derivative products. Besides the Forward market in currencies has been a
vibrant market in India for several decades.
D i ti M k t i I di
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
41/93
41
Derivative Markets in India
In addition the Forward Markets Commission has allowed thesetting up of commodities futures exchanges. Today we have 24
commodities exchanges most of which trade futures.
e.g. The Indian Pepper and Spice Traders Association (IPSTA) andthe Coffee Owners Futures Exchange of India (COFEI).
In 2000 an amendment to the SCRA expanded the definition ofsecurities to included Derivatives thereby enabling stockexchanges to trade derivative products.
In the year 2000 exchange-traded equity derivatives wereintroduced in the Indian market.
D i ti P d t
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
42/93
42
Derivative Products
OTC products (over the counter)
(a) Forward contracts (b) Interest rate swaps
(c) Forward rate agreements.
Traded through exchanges
(a) Futures contracts
(b) Options contract.
Forward / Futures
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
43/93
43
Contracts
Governed by provisions of
Forward Contracts (Regulation)Act, 1952
Three broad categories ofcontracts: Ready Delivery;
Forward; Option in goods.
Forward / Futures contracts
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
44/93
44
Forward / Futures contracts
Ready Delivery Contracts:
contracts for delivery ofgoods where delivery of
goods and payment thereofcompleted within 11 days
from contract date; suchcontracts outside purview ofFCR Act.
Forward / FuturesC
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
45/93
45
Contracts
Forward Contracts: contracts for
delivery of goods that are notready delivery contracts (i.e.
completion of delivery and/orpayment beyond 11 days); such
contracts governed by FCR Act.
Forward / FuturesC
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
46/93
46
Contracts
Option in goods: currently,
totally prohibited under FCR Act.An agreement which gives option-buyer the right but not obligation to
buy or sell a particular futurescontract at a stated price at any
time prior to a specified date
Forward Contracts two types
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
47/93
47
Forward Contracts two types
Specific delivery contracts
Other than specific deliverycontracts though contract of
second type has not been definedunder FCR Act, it is called futures
contract in trade parlance.
Specific Delivery Contracts
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
48/93
48
p y
Essentially for merchandising;
enable producers & consumers tomarket / cover a commodity
Generally negotiated directly
including contract terms bysellers/buyers
TSD and NTSD contracts
Futures Contracts
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
49/93
49
Futures Contracts
Are forward contracts other than
specific delivery contracts;Entered into under auspices of an
exchange or association;
Contract terms goods quantity,quality, place of delivery and time
of contract maturity standardised;parties to negotiate only rate
Futures Contract -St d di ti
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
50/93
50
Standardisation
Trading in standard unit only
Price quote for basis variety Delivery month standardised
All open position marked-to-marketdaily at settlement price
Tenderable goods must meet contract
specifications Tendered goods to be certified by
approved surveyor
Benefits of Futures Trading
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
51/93
51
g
Price discovery helps producers/sellers and consumers/buyers as alsoexporters discover price for a futuredate; helps take informed decision;
Price risk management helps hedgeprice risk or insure against adverseprice movement
Benefits of Futures Trading
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
52/93
52
e e ts o utu es ad g
Stabilises prices: helps moderate
heavy price fluctuations Integrates prices nationwide
Balances demand-supply over time
Fosters healthy competition
Barometer for farmers and traders
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
53/93
53
WHO BENEFITS.
Speculators benefit through pricefluctuation.
Intermediaries benefits through priceadvantage between ready and futureprices (Basis) and prices between
two futures contract (Spread) End users benefit because of lock-in of
prices.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
54/93
54
IS FUTURES TRADING SAME ASFORWARD TRADING? Futures Trading is a refined approach to the
forward trading It is a forward contract which isnot a specific delivery contract.
Forward trading is
a bilateral contract;
non-standardised contract specifications
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
55/93
55
WHO ARE THE CONSTITUENTS OFFUTURES TRADING? Hedgers who lock the prices in order to minimise
the risk.
Speculators who take advantage of the pricedifferences and play in the market.
Traders who offer two way quotes and provideliquidity.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
56/93
56
WHAT ARE THE ECONOMIC FUNCTIONSOF FUTURES TRADING? Price Discovery
Price Risk Mechanism
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
57/93
57
DOES FUTURES TRADING
GUARANTEE ANY PROFIT? Futures Trading does not guarantee any profit or
minimise the loss. It is purely a hedginginstrument
by which the prices are locked in as per the choiceof the parties.
There is another derivative product called options(not permitted in India for commodities) which actsas an insurance by paying a premium to the writerof the optionswhereby the losses are restricted butthe profits are unlimited.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
58/93
58
WHAT ARE THE CHARACTERISTICS
OF A GOOD FUTURES MARKET? There should be enough liquidity in the ready
market.
There should be large number of players fromdifferent categories.
The prices quoted in the futures market should
have linkage with the ready market rates. The tick size should be minimum enough to attract
enough liquidity.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
59/93
59
FUTURES MARKET SCENARIO IN
INDIA Illiquid markets
Fragmented markets
Multi-commodity risks
Different contract specifications for the
same commodity in different Exchanges Absence of Options Trading
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
60/93
60
HOW TO SELECT A COMMODITY FORFUTURES TRADING? Homogenous specification
Adequate liquidity in the ready market
Large number of players for the commodity Commodities that can be stored for a
reasonable period
Need to have a demand supply mismatch Prices not to be controlled by the Government
No restriction as to movement of goods
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
61/93
61
COMMODITIES NOT COVERED UNDERTHE PRESENT PROVISION (FC(R)ACT) Present Act permits only moveable property other
than actionable claims, money and securities.
Not including intangible items like electricity,weather, indices.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
62/93
62
CONVERGENCE OF FUTURES ANDREADY MARKET: The difference between the ready and futures
market is generally the carry-over cost.
On the due date, both the prices converge.
In case the settlement rates are proper (perfect),then it makes no difference if the deliveries aresettled within or outside the Exchange.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
63/93
63
HOW TO ORGANISE FUTURESTRADING? Select the commodities that fulfill the basic
criteria for the futures trading.
Set contract specifications which should be intune with market conditions.
Set limits for trading.
Design appropriate risk managementtechniques to ensure default-free trading,clearing and settlement environment.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
64/93
64
HOW TO ORGANISE
Ensure contract terms are not changed duringthe running of the contract.
Trading may be open ended or bracketed.
Positions on the due date is either settled incash or by physical delivery.
Open positions are not allowed to be carried
over to the new settlement. Delivery may be compulsory OR at the
option of the buyer or seller.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
65/93
65
FUTURES TRADING FROM ANINVESTORS POINT OF VIEW Futures trading is a form of investment which
involves speculating the price of a commodity goingup or down in the future.
This a highly leveraged instrument: by paying asmall margin, you can play on a large scale.
High leverage is both advantageous or lossmaking: depending upon you value judgment.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
66/93
66
FUTURES FROM AN INVESTORS
. Spread trading catches up the fancy of theinvestors; i.e; trade on buy-sell bid (if the currentrate for a derivative product X is say Rs. 400/-,buy at Rs. 402/- and sell at Rs. 398/- ) Trade on thisspread.
You may put stop-loss order to arrest losses.
In case of highly liquid market, the volumes arehuge and hence the losses are generally minimalwith an immediate entry/exit.
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
67/93
67
HOW FUTURES WILL HELP YOURBUSINESS? Anticipate profit margins
Improve your marketing plan
Maintain or increase your customer base withinnovative pricing contracts
Reduce the cost of storing commodities
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
68/93
68
FUNCTIONS OF THE COMEXES:
Membership Trading, Clearing and Settlement
Margining and Surveillance
Disputes and Redressal Mechanism
Disciplinary Procedures
Emergency Measures Suspension and Defaults
CONCEPT OF FUTURES TRADING
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
69/93
69
GOVERNANCE OF THE COMEXES:
AoP, Limited Companies Mutualised and Demutualised
Board Managed
3 Public Representatives and oneGovernment Nominee
Day to day affairs left to professionals Various Committees to manage the
operations
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
70/93
70
Regulation
System of Regulation 3-tier
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
71/93
71
Central Govt: broad policy oncommodities, territorial area andrecognition of exchange
FMC: approval of exchange rules;
permission for trading in contracts;monitor market conditions;
Exchange: forum to conduct trade;
records contracts, execution,settlement, payment etc.
Regulatory Measures
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
72/93
72
Hedgers: those with underlyinginterest in specific delivery or readydelivery contracts, and use futures toinsure against adverse price
movement Speculators: may not have an
interest in ready contract, but see
opportunity of price movementfavourable to them; provide usefuleconomic function
Safeguard / Regulatory Measures
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
73/93
73
Limit on open position
Limit on price fluctuation Special margin
Minimum/ maximum prices
Extreme steps: skipping trading;closing market; closing out
contracts
Recent Developments
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
74/93
74
Futures / forward trading in mostcommodities allowed
Three nationwide online tradingexchanges in operation
Trading volumes expandingSeveral new products launched
Autonomy for FMC on the cards FCRA amendment
Commodity RiskManagement
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
75/93
75
Identifying key risksWeather conditions
Government policiesDemand and supply
conditions
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
76/93
76
WHAT IS RISK MANAGEMENT? Risk Management is to assess the overall risk of
the Exchange in respect of one or more derivativeproducts to ensure default-free trading, clearingand settlement mechanism
Risk mitigation must
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
77/93
77
Stakeholders today face greater price
risk than ever before; Trade sentimentchanged; Longer the process, greaterthe risk; Someone must assume the
risk in every economic activity;
Enter futures trading
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
78/93
78
HOW ARE COMMODITY RISKS ASSESSED?
Every uncertainty is exposed to risk.
Commodities, by their very nature, have risks.
Inherent risks associated with the
commodities Most of the agricultural commodities undergo
change in quality over a period of time (shell
life). Futuristic Risk due to internal, external and
uncontrollable factors.
Delivery risk.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
79/93
79
FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO RISK:
Fungibility Production vagaries of monsoon
Government interference
Transportation and Warehousing
Effect of substitute products
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
80/93
80
HOW IS RISK ASCERTAINED BY THEEXCHANGE? Risk arising out of the
daily market fluctuation
speculative transactions
members open interest
illiquid markets forcing Exchange to go in formark-up prices
multi-contract, multi-commodity and multi-exchange.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
81/93
81
HOW ARE RISK MANAGEMENTINSTRUMENTS DESIGNED?
Circuit Filters
Circuit Breakers
Margin calls Regular
Occasional (Need-based)
Marked-to-market
Mark-up prices
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
82/93
82
PRE-REQUSITIES FOR A GOOD RISKMANAGEMENT INSTRUMENT It should not suppress a healthy volume.
It should be in a position to segregate hedging
risk and speculative risk. It should be capable of implemented for
different categories of players at different times.
The risk should be based on the marketmovement (pulse of the market rather thanprice per se).
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
83/93
83
PRE-REQUSIITES An adequate and efficient surveillance mechanism
goes hand in hand with the risk managementimplementation
It should function independently without fear or
favour. It should be capable of assessing the futuristic risk
in respect of contracts / members for facilitating
corrective measures.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
84/93
84
HOW RISK MANAGEMENT ISIMPLEMENTED? Creation of Trade Guarantee Fund.
Utilisation of Trade Guarantee Fund
Modus operandifor replenishing the TGF Online collection of margin.
Daily clearing
Tab on the price movements on real time basis. Monitoring the exposure of the members.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
85/93
85
HOW TO IMPLEMENT Assess the market at frequent intervals and take
corrective measures.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
86/93
86
RISK MANAGEMENT FOR TRADING Ensure collection of transaction slips immediately
after trade (not applicable in case of online trading) Ensure that the slips received / bid-offer rates are
in consonance with the prevailing rates.
Have strict vigil over out-trades trades donebeyond the quotes (as they affect the flow of slipsas well as real price discovery)
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
87/93
87
RISK MANAGEMENT FOR TRADING If the trading does not take place due to abnormal
market behaviour, then re-open the trading withrealistic rates (called mark-up prices) and collectthe difference money immediately. This will avoid
potential default. Avoid circular trading as this will create unhealthy
and unreliable market conditions.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
88/93
88
RISK MANAGEMENT FOR TRADING .. It is preferred to impose margin on tapering basis
(based on the exposure / position of the members). Have check on Negotiated Deals.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
89/93
89
RISK MANAGEMENT FORDELIVERIES Despite being a hedged instrument, the Certified
Warehouse Receipt (CWR) in itself is subjected toprice risk rates prevailing on the date of
settlement to the actual handing over of CWR. Delivery margin from the buyer to cover the above
risk.
Risk arising out of delivery committed but notactually tendered by the seller..
Risk arising out of delivery allotted to the buyer but
not lifted.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
90/93
90
OTHER ASPECTS CONCERNING THE RISKMANAGEMENT:
Is there any optimum risk that can be ascertainedby the Exchange?
Risks associated with the constituents.
Risks associated with the CWRs of one Exchangebeing tendered for delivery in other Exchange.
Gross Exposure VsNet exposure concept.
Very negligible or nil deliveries being tendered.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
91/93
91
EFFECT OF RISK MANAGEMENT
Proper risk management facilitates default-free environment
Proper risk management ensures that
trades are done in an orderly manner. A sound risk management ensures that
even potential default cases are brought to
notice immediately.
RISK MANAGEMENT
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
92/93
92
KEY TO TIMING YOUR TRADES When is the best time to buy or sell
When to use the futures market to hedge apurchase or sale
Which futures month to place a hedge
When to accept suppliers offer
Forward bids to your clients
Resale bids
Summary
-
8/6/2019 49459414 Commodity Markets
93/93
93
Commodity as an asset class
Commodity market functions and role Commodities traded
Regulations
Risk management