448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

73

Transcript of 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

Page 1: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013
Page 2: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

“I hereby declare that I have read this thesis and in my opinion this thesis is

sufficient in terms of scope and quality for the award of the degree of Bachelor of

Engineering (Electrical- Electronics)”

Signature : ..................................................................

Name of Supervisor : DR EILEEN SU LEE MING

Date : 24th

JUNE 2013

Page 3: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

PORTABLE DETECTION DEVICE FOR PATIENTS WITH SLEEP APNEA

ASYRAN ZYRATI BINTI YAHYA

A thesis submitted in fulfillment of the

requirements for the award of the degree of

Bachelor of Engineering (Electrical-Electronics)

Faculty of Electrical Engineering

Universiti Teknologi Malaysia

JUNE 2012

Page 4: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

ii

I declare that this thesis entitled “Portable Detection Device for Patients With Sleep

Apnea” is the result of my own research except as cited in the references. The thesis

has not been accepted for any degree and is not concurrently submitted in

candidature of any other degree.

Signature : ………………………………….........

Name : ASYRAN ZYRATI BINTI YAHYA

Date : 24th

JUNE 2013

Page 5: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

iii

To my beloved father, Yahya bin Md Nor, my loving siblings, compassionate friends

and companions and dedicated lecturers who have guided, encouraged and inspired

me throughout my journey of education

Page 6: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

iv

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

Alhamdulillah and thanks to Allah S.W.T for giving me the opportunity and

bless in completing this final year project. First and foremost, I would like to

express my sincere gratitude to my advisor, Dr Eileen Su Lee Ming for her

continuous support and guidance throughout this project development.

I would like to offer my earnest thanks to my family for the non-stop

encouragement that I received throughout the precious time I spent here. Without

their utmost support, it is probably impossible for me to go through the tough

journey of the campus life.

Next, I would like to thank my friends for their generous support and

willingness to go through thick and thin together. Last but not least, I would like to

thank all the staffs for their cooperation and all the lecturers for all the irreplaceable

knowledge that have been passed onto me.

Thank you very much. Without everyone contribution and support, this

thesis would not have been possible to finished.

Page 7: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

v

ABSTRACT

Sleep apnea is a syndrome that causes a pause in breathing during night time

sleep. It is a dangerous disease as it can cause sudden death if left untreated. The

method that is widely used to detect sleep apnea is the polysomnography or sleep

test that is done by the sleep test expert. However, this method is considered as

inconvenient as the patient needs to be hospitalized with a lot of wires around the

body to get the test done. The test fee is also expensive in most hospital or sleep

clinic. The purpose of this project is to build a portable sleep apnea detection device

which is affordable and easy to use. Apart from that, the objective of this project is

to be able to interface multiple sensors and process the signals for sleep apnea

classification. The portable device was made in a way that it can detect sleep apnea

through oronasal airflow. This project implemented the use of both hardware and

software. A source code was made to make the hardware which consists of sensors

and a microcontroller to function properly. The sensors used are the OMRON

2SMPP-02 pressure sensor, Pulse Sensor and SO-MIC sound sensor. The device

was tested to check on its reliability as a detection device. The device can

successfully detect the presence of breathing and show the result on LCD display.

As a conclusion, the device can work as a detection device but there are still many

rooms for improvement.

Page 8: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

vi

ABSTRAK

Apnea tidur adalah satu sindrom yang menyebabkan nafas terhenti seketika

ketika tidur pada waktu malam. Penyakit ini berbahaya kerana ia boleh

menyebabkan kematian mengejut jika tidak dirawat. Penyakit ini dikesan melalui

kaedah polisomnografi atau ujian tidur yang dijalankan oleh pakar tidur.

Bagaimanapun, cara ini agak menyusahkan memandangkan pesakit perlu bermalam

di hospital dan disambung dengan pelbagai wayar di seluruh tubuh untuk

menjalankan ujian. Bayarannya juga agak tinggi di kebanyakan hospital atau klinik

tidur. Tujuan projek ini dijalankan adalah untuk menghasilkan alat pengesan sleep

apnea mudah alih yang mudah digunakan dengan harga berpatutan. Selain itu,

objektif projek ini adalah untuk mengantara muka pelbagai jenis sensor dan

memproses isyarat tersebut untuk pengelasan apnea tidur. Alat mudah alih ini

dihasilkan supaya ia dapat mengesan apnea melalui saluran udara hidung dan mulut.

Projek ini mengaplikasikan kedua-dua cara perkakasan dan perisian. Satu code

sumber telah dibina bagi memastikan perkakasan yang terdiri daripada sensor and

mikropengawal berfungsi dengan betul. Antara sensor yang digunakan adalah

sensor tekanan OMRON 2SMPP-02, Pulse Sensor dan sensor bunyi SO-MIC. Alat

ini telah diuji keberkesanannya sebagai alat pengesan. Alat ini berjaya mengesan

kehadiran nafas dan memaparkan hasilnya pada paparan LCD. Sebagai konklusi,

alat ini berupaya untuk berfungsi sebagai alat pengesan tetapi masih terdapat banyak

ruang untuk diperbaiki.

Page 9: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

vii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

CHAPTER TITLE PAGE

DECLARATION ii

DEDICATION iii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iv

ABSTRACT v

ABSTRAK vi

TABLE OF CONTENTS vii

LIST OF TABLES xi

LIST OF FIGURES xii

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS xiv

LIST OF APPENDIX xvi

1 INTRODUCTION 1

1.1 Background of Study 1

1.2 Problem Statement 3

1.3 Objectives of Project 3

1.4 Scope of Work 4

Page 10: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

viii

1.5 Thesis Outline 5

2 LITERATURE REVIEW 6

2.1 Previous Works 6

2.2 Sleep Apnea 9

2.2.1 Introduction 9

2.2.2 Common Symptoms 11

2.2.3 Diagnosing Method 12

2.3 PIC16F877A and SK-40C 13

2.4 Sensors 16

2.4.1 OMRON MEMS Pressure Sensor –

2SMPP-02

16

2.4.2 SO-MIC-MOD Digital Sound Module 18

2.4.3 LM35 Temperature Sensor 19

2.4.4 Pulse Sensor Amped 20

2.5 Software and Tools 22

2.5.1 MPLAB IDE 22

2.5.2 Hi-Tech C Compiler 23

2.5.3 PICkit2 Application 23

3 METHODOLOGY 25

Page 11: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

ix

3.1 Introduction 25

3.2 Project Description 25

3.3 Hardware Implementation 27

3.3.1 SO-MIC Sound Module 27

3.3.2 LM35 Temperature Sensor 27

3.3.3 2SMPP-02 Pressure Sensor 28

3.3.3.1 Instrumentation Amplifier 28

3.3.4 Pulse Sensor 31

3.3.5 Completed Circuit Prototype 31

3.4 Software Implementation 32

4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 37

4.1 Introduction 37

4.2 Final Results 37

4.2.1 Breathing 39

4.2.2 Not Breathing 40

4.2.3 Pulse Rate 42

4.3 Discussion 43

5 CONCLUSION 44

Page 12: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

x

5.1 Introduction 44

5.2 Conclusion 44

5.3 Recommendation 46

REFERENCES 48

APPENDIX 51

Page 13: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

xi

LIST OF TABLES

TABLE NO. TITLE PAGE

2.1 Sleep apnea classification 10

3.1 Resistors and gain(AV) values 29

4.1 Pulse rate reading test results 42

Page 14: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

xii

LIST OF FIGURES

FIGURE NO. TITLE PAGE

2.1 Partial and complete airway obstruction 10

2.2 PIC16F877A pin-out by Microchip 14

2.3 SK-40C 15

2.4 OMRON 2SMPP-02 pressure sensor 17

2.5 2SMPP-02 terminal arrangement 17

2.6 SO-MIC MOD sound module 18

2.7 LM35 19

2.8 LM35 pin connection 19

2.9 Pulse sensor application 21

2.10 PICkit2 application interface 24

2.11 UIC00B 24

Page 15: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

xiii

3.1 Block diagram of project 26

3.2 Instrumentation amplifier 30

3.3 Complete project connection 31

3.4 Algorithm flowchart 32

3.5 Select Language Toolsuite window 33

3.6 MPLAB project workspace window 34

3.7 Project output 35

4.1 Project prototype 38

4.2 LCD display information 38

4.3 Result when breathe detected 40

4.4 Results when not breathing 41

Page 16: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

xiv

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

LCD Liquid-Crystal Display

LED Light Emitting Diode

OSA Obstructive Sleep Apnea

CSA Central Sleep Apnea

PSG Polysomnography

EEG Electroencephalogram

AHI Apnea-Hypoapnea Index

PIC Peripheral Interface Controller

RAM Random Access Memory

EEPROM Electrically Erasable Programmable Read-Only Memory

SSP Synchronous Serial Port

SPI Serial Peripheral Interface

Page 17: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

xv

CMOS Complementary Metal–Oxide–Semiconductor

USB Universal Serial Bus

MEMS Micro Electro Mechanical Systems

Page 18: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

xvi

LIST OF APPENDIX

APPENDIX TITLE PAGE

A Programming Source Code 51

Page 19: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background of Study

Advancement in technology has made it possible for human beings in

discovering many kinds of diseases, sickness and abnormalities. One of it is the

sleep apnea disorder. Not many people know about sleep apnea and what it can do

to affect our daily life. Apnea or apnoea – as it is known in Europe – is the

temporary absence or cessation of breathing. It is a condition when someone stops

breathing for a while either voluntarily or involuntarily. In this context, sleep apnea

is known as a disorder that causes a pause in breathing when a person has a night

sleep.

Sleep apnea disorder is divided into three categories which are Obstructive

Sleep Apnea (OSA) and Central Sleep Apnea (CSA). The third category is the

combination of both OSA and CSA. According to Janet MT et al, OSA is caused by

intermittent closure of airway whereby CSA happened when the abnormal messages

sent by the brain make breathing stop inappropriately. There are symptoms that can

relate to sleep apnea and that include loud snoring, restless night sleep and daytime

Page 20: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

2

sleepiness. Most of the time, people with sleep apnea did not realize that they have

this disease as the pause happened during sleep.

Although some people might have not heard of sleep apnea, it should not be

taken lightly. Sleep apnea occurs to anyone regardless of their genders, age and

ethnicity. If it is not treated or controlled properly, it can even lead to several other

diseases which among others did include sudden death, heart attack, high blood

pressure and hypertension. There are several factors that might cause sleep apnea.

Obesity, alcohol consumption and nasal or oral airway abnormalities are some of the

factors that worth mention.

According to Datuk Dr Noor Hisham Abdullah, the Deputy Director of

Health (Medical) on 2011, the social and industrial progress led to the sleep-related

problems. In a book “Standards of Sleep Facility in Ministry of Health, Malaysia”, it

is stated that a research has been done by the University Malaya on sleep apnea,

particularly on the obstructive sleep apnea, where in Malaysia, it is estimated that the

syndrome is 9% and 4% respectively for middle aged men and women[1].

However, concerned people who feel like they do have sleep apnea can have

themselves go for a polysomnography test or sleep test at respective clinic or

hospital. Polysomnography (PSG) is the study of sleep where several conditions

such as abdominal movement, electroencephalogram (EEG) and electro-oculogram

of a patient were being monitored and analyzed. PSG can only be done by

profesional sleep technicians or doctors. Another method to diagnose this disorder is

to analyze the medical history of a patient by understanding the eating lifestyle,

smoking or drinking habit or sleeping pattern.

Page 21: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

3

1.2 Problem Statement

Polysomnography (PSG) or the sleep test is the most accurate way of

diagnosing sleep apnea at this point of time. Patients who want to have the test are

required to spend the night at the hospital or the sleep centre where they will be

tended by profesional sleep test attendants and doctors. This can be a bit

burdensome to some people who did not like to set their feet in hospitals. There is

also a home sleep test where the patients will be given the PSG machine and have

the test at their home but in Malaysia, this method is not fully implemented yet.

Furthermore, sleep test through PSG would need the patients to be hooked up

to many wires which can be very discomforting. So, even though they get to feel the

comfort for being in their own home, the feeling of being tangled with wires is

somehow can be unpleasant. In Malaysia, sleep test can be done in government

hospital for a relatively low fee as compared to the private hospital, but the waiting

time to get the treatment can be long. Sleep test in private hospital would probably

did not take much time to wait but the fee is very costly. The PSG machine is also

huge and not portable and this would make it hard for the patients to move around

when they sleep.

1.3 Objectives of Project

For this project, there are three objectives that had to be achieved. Firstly, it

is to develop a portable diagnosing tool for patients with sleep apnea. Next, this

device is also supposed to be very affordable for the users where many people can

benefit from it with a one-time investment. The operation of this device is also had

Page 22: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

4

been simplified so that the users can check for themselves whether they have sleep

apnea or not. The final objective is to interface and process the sensor signals for

sleep apnea classification. By analyzing the input signals from the sensors, we can

determine the severity of the sleep apnea of the users.

1.4 Scope of Work

The scope of work encompasses two areas, the hardware and software. For

hardware, it basically involved the interfacing of multiple sensors to a

microcontroller for sleep apnea diagnosis. The result would then be interpreted and

showed on the output devices. There were four types of sensors, one PIC

microcontroller and three types of output devices used for this purpose. Some

electrical components such as the Op-Amp had also been used in this project.

For software implementation, it basically involved the programming part of

the whole system. A source code was written to make sure the device works

properly. The written source code would then be compiled and download to the

microcontroller and the completed circuit.

Page 23: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

5

1.5 Thesis Outline

This thesis had been organized into five separate chapters and each has its

own title. The first chapter is the Introduction part where it mainly explained the

background of the study. Chapter 1 also outlined the problem statements, objectives

and project scoped of this thesis.

Chapter 2 is on Literature Review. This chapter serves as the part where all

the previous work related to this project had been discussed. In-depth explanation

on each components used in this project can also be found in this chapter. In

addition, more detail on sleep apnea will also be discussed here.

The third chapter is Chapter 3 and it is about Methodology. This chapter

described all the steps taken to finish the project. It also explained how the

components had been put to use to make sure the device functions well and to ensure

the success of this project.

Next chapter is Chapter 4 and it is on the Results and Findings of the project.

Any findings regarding the prototype design of the project had been discussed here.

Not only that, the analysis on any data taken from the device can also be found here.

Finally, the fifth and the last chapter of this thesis - Chapter 5 – and it is

about the conclusion that has been made throughout the project. This chapter also

outlined some of the recommendation or suggestion of this project, should there be

any continuation to be done by other people on the same topic.

Page 24: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

CHAPTER 2

LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Previous Work

As there are many concerns on the effect of sleep apnea on one’s daily life,

there have been many researches written on this topic. One of the most mentioned

subjects is on the effect of portable diagnosing for sleep apnea patients. Throughout

the years, PSG has become the primary method of diagnosing sleep apnea. Knowing

that PSG test in hospital can be very much uncomfortable, portable PSG machine for

home test has been developed. But still, the test still proves to be burdensome and

the machine is not really cheap and affordable. At this time of thesis writing, no

portable device for sleep apnea detection other than PSG machine has been

developed commercially. Even so, continuous research and studies had been done

by many individuals and organizations on the portable detection device as it is

beneficial to the public.

In 1997, Koja et. al[2] has done a research on developing portable sleep

apnea detector. On their research, they also included the verification on the

usefulness of their portable detection device for screening sleep apnea. The portable

device was made of three sensors for respiratory movements, a sensor for breath

Page 25: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

7

detection and a data recorder. To ensure the patients’ comfort during the diagnosis,

the movement sensors were placed between the mattress and bed sheet and not on the

patients’ body. A sound sensor was used to detect breathing sound such as snoring.

The study was done and tested on 50 sleep apnea patients with average age of 47 and

consists of both genders. To compare the reliability of their device, PSG test was

also done simultaneously. For this research, it is concluded that the device is useful

for sleep apnea syndrome screening purpose.

One of the early research and study on portable sleep apnea detector was

done by Emsellem et. al[3] in 1990. For this research, they had developed a portable

device that can measure nasal/oral airflow, chest wall movement, cardiac rhythm and

blood oxygen saturation. As verification of the usefulness of the device must be

made, they had compared the data obtained from the device with the data obtained

from the standard PSG method. The study was conducted on 67 sleep apnea

patients. From the research, they had found that the device has a sensitivity of 95%

and a specificity of 96%.

In an article published by María et. al[4] in 2007, a discussion and findings

on the reliability of home diagnosis and the costs’ analysis had been done. The study

was conducted by implementing the home respiratory polygraphy on 45 patients with

sleep apnea. The results from the diagnosis had been compared to the result taken

from the PSG test to measure the accuracy of home respiratory polygraphy. For the

cost analysis, the calculation was done theoretically for a population of 1000

individuals. At the end of the study, it is concluded that home respiratory

polygraphy is a reliable method for diagnosing sleep apnea syndrome. In addition, it

was also mentioned that the method was more economical when it is compared to the

in lab PSG test.

Another article that also mentioned about portable sleep apnea detector was

done by Hida et. al[5] in a research paper published in 1995. A portable device was

Page 26: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

8

developed with the understanding that other detection devices were deemed to be

hard for normal people to operate. The portable device developed by the team can

measure three variables which are the oronasal airflow, tracheal sound and electrical

activity of the heart. It also can store the time of apnea events, duration and R-R

intervals with a built-in microcomputer. The portable device had system’s sensitivity

and specificity if 92.5% and 87.5% respectively. In conclusion, the device is useful

and can be used for the screening of outpatients with sleep apnea syndrome.

Rotariu and Costin[6], had developed a remote monitoring system for sleep

apnea syndrome diagnosis. It is to be used both in-hospital or in-home tests. For the

research, the respiratory rate of the patient was continuously measured by using

wireless devices and the data was sent to the central monitoring station via a wireless

sensor network. The system can also activate an alert upon the detection of sleep

apnea episodes. A prototyped was made, tested and implemented and it is user

friendly. The prototype was also flexible, scalable and cost-effective. This system

had served it purpose as an alternative to medical supervision in hospital especially

for elderly who suffered sleep apnea problem.

In order to develop a portable device on sleep apnea syndrome detection, a

thorough understanding and knowledge on the related subject must be studied and

fully understood. The following sections will explain and discuss the details on the

related subjects related to this project development.

Page 27: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

9

2.2 Sleep Apnea

This subsection will have some explanation on the introduction of sleep

apnea along with its background. Common sleep apnea symptoms are also been

discussed in this section. The next subsection will explain more on the method of

sleep apnea diagnosis.

2.2.1 Introduction

Sleep apnea is a syndrome where a person experiences a sudden pause in

breathing during a night time sleep. Guilleminault et. al[7] had defined asleep apnea

as the cessation of air flow at the nose and mouth for at least 10 seconds. Sleep

apnea can be categorized into three types with the first being Obstructive Sleep

Apnea (OSA) followed by Central Sleep Apnea (CSA). The third type comprises of

both OSA and CSA. Apnea event is further divided into two categories which are

apnea and hypoapnea. The condition when the flow of air slows during sleep – with

at least 30% - is known as hypoapnea. But when the flow of air stops completely

during sleep – for at least 10 seconds – it is known as apnea[8]. The severity of sleep

apnea can be determined by implementing the Apnea-Hypoapnea Index (AHI).

According to Bradley et. al[9], AHI is the frequency of apneas and hypoapneas per

hour of sleep and it is the measure of the severity of sleep apnea. The severity of

sleep apnea can be classified into three conditions and details were shown in the

following Table 2.1.

Page 28: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

10

Table 2.1 : Sleep apnea classification

Severity AHI

Mild 5-14

Moderate 15-30

Severe >30

A person is considered to have OSA if the apnea and hypoapnea event that

happened are due to the collapse or blockage of the upper airway[8]. Janet et. al[11],

mentioned that an obstructive sleep apnea is caused by intermittent closure of airway.

Virend et. al[22], in their research paper had characterized OSA by repetitive

interruption of ventilation during sleep and this was caused by the collapse of

pharyngeal airway. Compared to CSA, OSA is much predominant among people.

The following Figure 2.1 is showing the condition of a person when he experience

partial or complete airway obstruction.

Figure 2.1 : Partial and complete airway obstruction

Page 29: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

11

2.22 Common Symptoms

There are certain symptoms that can relate to sleep apnea. One of the

common symptoms that is often associated with sleep apnea is excessive daytime

sleepiness[10]. The prevalence is estimated to be 8% to 30% through

epidemiological studies. Excessive daytime sleepiness is a challenging symptom to

detect as people has difficulty to differentiate it with tiredness. According to Ramsey

et. al[10], sleepiness was described as the tendency to fall asleep, whereas fatigue

involved a task context with musculoskeletal or neurasthenic qualities. In a study

done by students of Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, they found out that daytime

sleepiness was 35.5% - for those undergoing clinical postings. Although excessive

daytime sleepiness is on of the most occurred symptoms of sleep apnea, it is rarely

used as an indication of any disease.

During breath, certain obstructions that may occur along airflow path will

lead to irregular, turbulent air movement[8]. The turbulent is co-related with the

irregular vibration of the upper airway structure and the sound that is produced from

it is what had been called as snoring. In the field of sleep apnea study, it is agreed

that snoring the most occurred symptoms that happened to sleep apnea patients.

People who always snore when sleeping are probably having sleep apnea. This is

due to the fact that snoring is a sign of increased upper airway resistance and this

somehow related to sleep apnea condition. Snoring is not a trivial matter. It has

been reported that one forth of world’s population snores and there is a percentage of

14.5% of children in Hospital Kuala Terengganu who snores[1]. Even so, there is

still some occurrence of sleep apnea among non-snoring patients.

Page 30: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

12

2.2.3 Diagnosing Method

Numerous ways has been developed for diagnosing sleep apnea syndrome.

But the most common and accurate diagnosing method was through

polysomnography (PSG). According to Bradley et. al[9], PSG is a multichannel

electrophysiological recording of electroencephalographic, electroculographic,

electromyographic, ECG and respiratory activity to detect breathing disturbance

when sleeping. Individuals who want to have diagnosis of sleep apnea through this

method must have an all-nighter in the respective hospitals or sleep-clinic where the

PSG test is available. Normally, patients will be asked to undergo the test for at least

one time – depends on the analysis of the collected data. During the stay, profesional

sleep-test attendants will tend to the patients and installed the PSG machine to the

respective places of the patients. The behavior of the patient during the time of the

test will be monitored by the doctors or the profesional attendants. Through various

reading that has been collected through the study, the number of apnea episodes and

their length was measured[11].

Not only that, in normal sleep studies like PSG, the amount or concentration

of oxygen in patient’s blood, heart rate and abnormal body movement – particularly

eye and leg - was also measured. Patients with sleep apnea often associated with

having low concentration of oxygen in blood. While normal healthy people without

sleep apnea have oxygen level of more than 90% - normally 97% - sleep apnea

patients have a much lower oxygen level than that[8]. Lack of oxygen in blood is

due to the fact that when a person stops breathing, the lungs will stop filling air and

hence will slow the oxygen delivery to the whole body systems. This is where pulse

oxymeter comes in handy as it is widely used to measure blood’s oxygen

concentration.

Sleep studies can also be done in the patients’ home. It is available upon

request by the patients who did not want to spend the night at the clinic. For home

Page 31: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

13

sleep test, firstly the patients will be given instruction on how to wear the machine by

the sleep experts. The patients are required to collect the data and give them to the

doctors for further analysis. Home sleep test is much favorable by some patients as

the test is done at one’s home comfort. Home sleep test in Malaysia is not fully

implemented yet so the only option is to spend the night at the clinic. But still,

diagnosing method by using PSG is far from being comfortable as the patients will

be wired up on most parts of the body. The number of connections depends on how

many data we want to analyze. Other than being uncomfortable, sleep test is costly

and the data can only be analyzed by experts.

2.3 PIC16F877A and SK-40C

PIC16F877A is a 40-pins Peripheral Interface Controller (PIC)

microcontroller manufactured by Microchip[12]. Prior to it being a PIC-typed

microcontroller, there are several advantages of 16F877A which lead to its

implementation in this project development. From the datasheet provided by

Microchip on this device, it is described as a CPU with high-performance RISC and

have only 35 single-word instructions to learn[13]. 16F877A has a data memory

capacity (RAM) of 368 bytes and 8192 words of Program Memory. Built with 33-

pins of Input and Output (I/O), this PIC has 256 bytes of EEPROM and can operate

from 2-5V voltage source. The pin-out of PIC16F877A can be seen in Figure 2.2.

Page 32: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

14

Figure 2.2 PIC16F877A pin-out by Microchip

PIC16F877A has 10-bit Analog-to-Digital module and so it can store 10-bit

digital output data which is sufficient for this project. 10-bit resolution is compatible

for analog data conversion from various sensors that has been used in this project.

Furthermore, 16F877A has 8 analog input channels which are more than enough for

the project. 16F877A has three timer modules namely Timer0, Timer1 and Timer2

and two analogue comparators. Timer0 and Timer2 are 8-bit timer/counter while

Timer1 is 16-bit. 16F877A has synchronous serial port (SSP) with SPI (Master

mode) and I2C (Master/Slave). Some of the special feature of this PIC is that it can

withstand 100,000 erase/write cycles and has EEPROM data retention of more than

40 years. As it is developed based on CMOS technology, this microcontroller

consumes low-power usage.

With it being a PIC microcontroller, it can be found easily at a relatively low

price. Microchip, as the developer of this PIC had provided the user with free

development software with on-line tutorials which is proven to be beneficial for new

programmers. As 16F877A is a mid-range PIC, the programming is quite straight

Page 33: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

15

forward and easier. One disadvantage of 16F877A is, it does not have internal

oscillator and so the use of external oscillator is a must. Normally, 20 MHz crystal

oscillator was used to serve this purpose.

There are three essential elements that a microcontroller needs in order for it

to work properly. Those three elements are the oscillator, power supply and reset.

The elements must be connected to the microcontroller along with other electrical

components like resistors and capacitors. Normally, users will develop their own

circuits with the needed components to use the microcontroller but nowadays there is

already a development board that is available to purchase. For this project, a PIC

development board SK-40C by Cytron was used as in Figure 2.3. SK-40C is a

development board that can be used with any 40-pins PIC microcontroller. It is a

handy and easy PIC development board for amateurs or even professionals. The

board was equipped with a connector for a programmer, USB connector, RESET

button, two push buttons, switch for power supply and many more[14]. No further

connection was needed for this board as it has already connected to a 20 MHz

oscillator and voltage regulator.

Figure 2.3 : SK-40C

Page 34: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

16

2.4 Sensors

To achieve the objective of this research which is to interface multiple

sensors on a microcontroller, many sensors had been selected and chosen. Omron

MEMS pressure sensor, SO-MIC-MOD sound module and LM35 were used in this

project as a set of breathing sensor. Pulse sensor was used to detect patient’s pulse

and measure the heart beat. The details and explanation of these sensors can be

found on their respective subsections below.

2.4.1 OMRON MEMS Pressure Sensor – 2SMPP-02

OMRON has invented a piezoresistive MEMS pressure sensor with ultra

miniature size for various applications[15]. With only the size of 6.1 x 4.7 x 8.2mm

(L x W x H), it can withstand applied pressure with the range of 0 to 37kPa. From

the datasheet provided by OMRON, 2SMPP-02 has offset and span voltage of -

2.5±4mV and 31.0±3.1mV respectively. This surface mount sensor has low power

consumption with only 0.2mW and low temperature influence of ±1.0%FS (span)

and ±3.0%FS (offset). This piezo resistive sensor is able to detect gauge pressure

with the applicable gases being non-corrosive and dust free air.

2SMPP-02 is a MEMS-based sensor. MEMS stand for Micro-Electro-

Mechanical Systems and it is known as the miniaturized mechanical and electro-

mechanical elements. MEMS devices development involved the microfabrication

techniques. Many sensors nowadays had implemented MEMS technology in their

design as MEMS are proved to be lightweight, small and easy to use. Other sensors

that use MEMS technology alongside pressure sensors are temperature and radiation

sensors. The actual sensor can be seen in the following Figure 2.4.

Page 35: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

17

Figure 2.4 : OMRON 2SMPP-02 pressure sensor

OMRON 2SMPP-02 is a piezoresistive-typed sensor and so, it is a solid state,

monolithic sensor that is fabricated through silicon processing. It is usually

constructed in silicon and the sensing element is actually a four element bridge.

Piezoresistive sensor worked in a way that an applied stress will cause a change in

the resistivity of a material[16]. The terminal arrangement of 2SMPP-02 can be seen

in the following Figure 2.5.

Figure 2.5 : 2SMPP-02 terminal arrangement.

Page 36: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

18

2.4.2 SO-MIC-MOD digital Sound Module

SO-MIC is a sound module bought from Cytron Corporation[17]. It is a

microphone module that can be used for any audio detection. Operate at 3.3V to 5V

DC supply voltage; this sound module can only produce digital output. This sound

module has an on-board potentiometer so the user can change the threshold as they

like. The digital output (DO) produced will be LOW if there is sound detected and

goes HIGH when there is no sound detected. There is an LED on-board that act as

an indicator when the sound is detected. Cytron has made it easy for the user to

interface the microphone module to any microcontroller by making it a 3-pin device.

The pins are VCC, GND and OUT respectively. The OUT pin is supposedly to be

connected to the digital input pin of a microcontroller. Figure 2.6 below is taken

from the startup guide by Cytron.

Figure 2.6 : SO-MIC MOD sound module

Page 37: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

19

2.4.3 LM 35 Temperature Sensor

LM35 is a temperature sensor developed by National Semiconductor[18]. It

is a precision centigrade temperature sensor and so the output voltage is directly

proportional to the Celsius (centigrade) temperature. This feature enables users to

directly calibrate the reading in Celsius without having to convert it from Kelvin or

Fahrenheit. It is an analog-typed sensor and has the scale factor of 10.0mV for every

°C. LM35 has low self heating which is less than 0.1°C in still air and has accuracy

of 0.5°C (at 25°C). This sensor can operate from 4 to 30V and has temperature range

of -55°C to 150°C. LM35 also comes with 3-pins which are VS, VOUT and GND. All

three pins are connected to voltage source, microcontroller input pin and ground

respectively. Since LM35 is an analog temperature sensor, the VOUT pin must be

connected to an analog pin of a microcontroller for data conversion from analog to

digital. While it does have many good features, this sensor is easily available at very

affordable price. The actual picture and pin connection can be seen in Figure 2.7 and

Figure 2.8 respectively.

Figure 2.7 : LM35

Figure 2.8 : LM35 pin connection

Page 38: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

20

2.4.4 Pulse Sensor Amped

Pulse sensor amped was made by Joel Murphy and Yury Gitman of

PulseSensor. It is a plug-and play heart rate sensor for Arduino[19] but it can still be

used with other microcontrollers like PIC. It is made by for users to incorporate live

heart rate date into any projects. Pulse sensor can be used to detect pulse rate either

from the fingertip (Figure 2.9(b)) or earlobe (Figure 2.9(c)).

It works with voltage supply of 3 to 5V. Pulse sensor is mounted with three

connection wires for Vs, Signal and GND. As this is an analog sensor, the Signal pin

must be connected to the analog input pin of a microcontroller. Single LED that has

been used for this sensor is an LED from Avago APDS-9008 green LED and it has

the wavelength of 565nm. The following Figure 2.9(a) is the actual image of the

pulse sensor.

Page 39: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

21

(a)

(b)

(c)

Figure 2.9 : Pulse sensor application (a) Pulse sensor (b) Pulse sensor on fingertip

(c) Pulse sensor on earlobe

Page 40: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

22

2.5 Software and tools

This subsection is mainly discussed on the software used for this project

development. There is several software programs that have been used for this project

and each function were discussed in the following subsections.

2.5.1 MPLAB IDE

MPLAB IDE is software that runs on PC to develop applications for

Microchip microcontrollers and digital signal controllers. It is provided for free for

users[13]. IDE stands for Integrated Development Environment as it is believed to

provide a single integrated environment of code development for embedded

microcontrollers. This development system for embedded controllers is a system

running on a PC to write, edit debug and program code and it contains all the

components needed to design and deploy embedded systems applications.

There are some built-in components in MPLAB IDE and consist of project

manager, editor, assembler/linker and language tools, debugger and finally the

execution engines. The project manager provides integration and communication

between the IDE and the language tools. Editor is a text editor that is also act as a

window into the debugger. An assembler can be used alone to assemble a single file,

or used with linker to build projects from separate source file. Debugger works with

an editor and it allows breakpoints, single stepping, watch windows and many more.

Finally, there is an execution engine where it functions as software simulators.

Page 41: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

23

2.5.2 Hi-Tech C Compiler

MPLAB IDE is designed to work with many Microchip and third party

language tools. These tools will create an executable code that can be programmed

to selected device from an application code written in assembly, C or BASIC

language[20]. Hi-Tech language tools are supported by MPLAB IDE and the tools

include the C Compiler, Assembler and linker. HI-TECH C is a compiler featuring

Omniscient Code Generation™

, whole-program compilation technology, for

Microchip Technology's 8-, 16-, and 32-bit PIC® microcontroller and dsPIC

® digital

signal controller architectures.

Hi-Tech C Compiler is a freeware compiler if it was used in Lite Mode

version. It supports PIC10, PIC12 and PIC16 series devices. It is fully compatible

with MPLAB IDE and also fully ANSI-compliant. For ease of use, Hi-Tech also

includes Library source, macro assembler, linker, pre-processor and one step driver.

2.5.3 PICkit2 Application

PICkit2 is a programmer/debugger application by Microchip. It allows the

user to program all supported devices as listed in PICkit2 Readme file. The interface

of the application can be seen from Figure 2.10.

Page 42: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

24

Figure 2.10 : PICkit2 appilication interface

To write a program to a microcontroller, a written source code must be

compiled first and to generate a .HEX file. When the .HEX file is generated, PICkit2

must import the file first and finally the program can be load into the selected device.

But to load the program into the device – microcontroller – a help from a

programmer was needed. For this project, a programmer UIC00B by Cytron was

used. To use it, the user needs to connect the programmer to the microcontroller and

click the button Write on the PICkit2. A successful program load will be mentioned

by PICkit2. UIC00B by Cytron is small as can be seen in Figure 2.11.

Figure 2.11 : UIC00B

Page 43: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

CHAPTER 3

METHODOLOGY

3.1 Introduction

This chapter will discuss the methodology that has been applied towards

finishing this project. For easy understanding of this project development, the

project methodology has been divided into three parts which are the introduction,

hardware and software. Both hardware and software can be found in the latter part

of this chapter.

3.2 Project Description

Figure 3.1 is the block diagram of the project. It basically tells the reader the

overview on what this project is really about and the real function of the project

prototype. Figure on the next page is the block diagram that described the flow of

the project prototype. The figure started with data acquisition process of the patients

through several sensors. The signals from the sensor will be received by the

microcontroller and the next process that takes place is the data conversion from

analog signal to digital – for analog input signal only. This was done by the built-in

Page 44: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

26

ADC that exist in the PIC 16F877A. Following the conversion process, the newly

stored digital data was processed by the microcontroller and the result will be

represented by the LCD display, buzzer and LEDs. The last step is to analyze the

data to determine the sleep apnea condition.

Figure 3.1 : Block diagram of project

Page 45: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

27

3.3 Hardware Implementation

Hardware section will explain more on the steps taken to build the working

circuit of project prototype. At the start of the project development, all of the

sensors had been tested for their functionality using simple circuits made up of

sensors, power supply and digital multimeter. After it was confirmed that the

sensors function properly, the complete circuit was made by interfacing the sensors

to the microcontroller. Output devices such as LCD display, LEDs and buzzer had

also been connected to the microcontroller and the sensors.

3.3.1 SO-MIC Sound Module

The pins of the sound module were connected properly to the voltage source

and ground. After it is sure that the connection is fine, the power was ON. The

sound module was tested by blowing the condenser microphone onboard the module.

The test was successful since the onboard LED of the module did light up from the

blowing. It has been showed that the SO-MIC sound module can detect sound

properly. The test was successful.

3.3.2 LM35 Temperature Sensor

The same procedures as SO-MIC sound module had been applied on the

LM35 sensor to test the device functionality. The differences were the Output pin

was connected on digital multimeter and LM35 was tested by applying body heat on

Page 46: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

28

the sensor’s surface and the. This was done by placing fingertips onto LM35. After

the power supply is turned ON, the temperature will first detect the surrounding

temperature and display the value in Volt on the digital multimeter. When the heat

has been applied to the sensor, there will be slight changes on the voltage reading.

Since body temperature is much higher than the surrounding temperature at the point

of sensor testing, the multimeter showed an increase in reading. The reading on the

multimeter is based on the understanding that 10mV=1°C. If the reading on the

multimeter showed 0.350V, then the temperature is supposedly ±35°C. This test was

also successfully done.

3.3.3 2SMPP-02 Pressure Sensor

Device testing on the 2SMPP-02 pressure sensor is the same as the one for

SO-MIC sound module. But, to simulate the condition of breathing – exhale and

inhale – air draw in and blowing were done simultaneously. It is observed from the

digital multimeter that when the air was blown to the sensor (exhale), the reading on

the multimeter decreases. When air was drawn out of the sensor (inhale), the

reading showed an increase in voltage value. Since the pressure sensor reacted

properly, it is assumed that the test was also successful.

3.3.3.1 Instrumentation Amplifier

The sensor’s output signal is relatively small compared to the step size of the

ADC (as explained in Software Implementation section), so to make sure the signal

coming out from pressure sensor can be read properly by 16F877A built-in ADC, an

Page 47: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

29

instrumentation amplifier circuit was built. The purpose of an instrumentation

amplifier is to amplify the sensor’s output signal so that it will be high enough for

the ADC to convert it with more accuracy. The instrumentation amplifier was built

by using several resistors and an LM324 Quad Operational Amplifier. LM324 is a

PDIP-14 low cost amplifier and can operate at various supply voltage as low as 3V

to 32V. It is a quad op-amp which means it has four amplifiers built internally as

seen in Figure 3.2 (a).

The circuit for the instrumentation amplifier was made on a breadboard and

the connection can be seen as in Figure 3.2 (b). Pin V1 and V2 were to be connected

to pin VOUT+ and VOUT- of 2SMPP-02 pressure sensor respectively. The voltage gain

was calculated by using the formula for instrumentation amplifier gain calculation.

The details of the calculated gain, AV, and the values of the resistors were tabulated

in the following Table 3.1.

Table 3.1 : Resistors and gain (AV) values

R1 10kΩ

R2 1kΩ

R3 1kΩ

RG 180Ω

AV 11

Page 48: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

30

(a)

(b)

Figure 3.2 : Instrumentation amplifier (a) LM324 Quad Core Amplifier (b)

Instrumentation amplifier circuit connection

Page 49: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

31

3.3.4 Pulse Sensor

Similar test also had been applied on the pulse sensor. But, unlike SO-MIC

sound module and 2SMPP-02 sensor, test on pulse sensor was only done by strap it

properly on the fingertips. The digital multimeter will produce a non-constant

voltage reading. This is because the sensor was measuring the human pulse which is

changing every few hundred millisecond. According to the developer, once the user

had put on the sensor, the output voltage should be around half of the supply voltage.

For this test, since the voltage supply was 5V DC, the readings on the multimeter

should be ±2.5V. Once there were appropriate readings displayed on the digital

multimeter, it is concluded that the sensor was working properly.

3.3.5 Completed Circuit Prototype

Once it is made sure that all the sensors were properly function, all needed

components were connected together on a breadboard. The following Figure 3.3

depicted how the connection was made.

Figure 3.3 : Complete project connection

Page 50: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

32

3.4 Software Implementation

This section will discuss on how the process of source code creation was

made by using programming software such as MPLAB IDE, Hi Tech and PICkit2.

Before the program was written, the whole process or events must be understood

first so that a right source code can be made. A flowchart as in Figure 3.4 was made

so that we have a clear perspective on what to write in the text editor.

Figure 3.4 : Algorithm flow chart

Page 51: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

33

When the portable detector device was power up, the system will start

running and followed by ADC initialization and ADC read. When there was an

event of breathing, only the red LED1 on the development board will light up.

However, only yellow LED2 will light up when there was no breathing event. The

system will check for the event of not breathing for time more than 10 seconds. If

Yes, then it will count up and if No, it will restart the time and return to ADC read.

In an event when the time is more than two minutes, an alarm will trigger through a

buzzer. These whole events will be turned into programing code afterwards.

By using MPLAB IDE, users can write any programming code so that they

can compile and download it into a microcontroller. For this project, C language

was used instead of assembly language as it is easier to understand and is much

shorter than assembly code. Hi Tech ANSI C Compiler needed to be used together

with this software for compiling purpose as the PIC16 was used. As such, HI TECH

Universal ToolSuite was selected as seen in Figure 3.4. As shown in the Figure 3.5,

the program was written with MPLAB IDE and as it was written in C language, the

file needed to be SAVE as .c file before it was compiled.

Figure 3.5 : Select Language Toolsuite window

Page 52: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

34

Figure 3.6 : MPLAB project workspace window

After writing the program, it was built and compiled to see if the code is

working or not. The other purpose for compiling is for the compiler to turn the .C

file into .HEX file so it can be written into the microcontroller. A successful build

and compilation will generate an Output window that mentioned about the built

program as shown in Figure 3.6(a). A folder that will keep all the files generated

from this project was created on the computer. Take note that the .C and .HEX file

were also located here and they can be seen in Figure 3.6 (b).

Page 53: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

35

(a)

(b)

Figure 3.7 : Project output (a) MPLAB Output window (b) File directory

Page 54: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

36

To download the newly written source code into the microcontroller, PICkit2

with the help of a programmer was used. Firstly, the programmer must be connected

to the development board that has been installed with PIC16F877A. Then, PICkit2

must be able to detect the device before it downloads the program. Next, the .HEX

file that was generated before was loaded and written into the microcontroller by

clicking write button. A successful program writing to the microcontroller will be

mentioned through the PICkit2 window.

Page 55: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

CHAPTER 4

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

4.1 Introduction

This chapter will discuss on the results of this project. Any observations that

have been found throughout project development will be explained in this chapter as

well. Analysis and discussion on the collected data from the project simulation will

also be described in detail here.

4.2 Final Results

A project prototype (Figure 4.1) was successfully developed and the

functionality of the prototype had been tested as well. The portable device was

finally built with multiple sensors – OMRON 2SMPP-02, Pulse Sensor and SO-MIC

- that were interfaced to a microcontroller and have the reading displayed on the

LCD display. The breathing event indicators were represented by two LEDs that

come with the development board.

Page 56: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

38

Figure 4.1 : Project prototype

The prototype’s test was done by simulating the condition when a person

breathing. The corresponding result will be shown on all the output devices. LCD

display will indicate the time, pulse beat per minute, the apneic event counter and the

digital output value from the signal coming from sensors. They were all represented

by T, BPM and C respectively as shown in Figure 4.2.

Figure 4.2 : LCD display information

The test on the prototype was done right after downloading the written

program into the microcontroller. From the test done on the project prototype, it is

found that the device can successfully detect breathing and display the result through

Page 57: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

39

onboard LEDs and LCD. The buzzer also gave out an alarm when there is no

breathing event for more than two minutes.

4.2.1 Breathing

To make the device able to detect breath, two breathing conditions have been

identified which are through the nose (nasally) or mouth (orally). The sensors those

were responsible for detecting nasal airflow are the LM35 temperature sensor and

the OMRON 2SMPP-02 pressure sensor. SO-MIC sound sensor was responsible

was detecting oral airflow and the snoring sound. This is based on the earlier

understanding that when a person breathes, he will let out air through nasally or

orally. It is also implied that a person is breathing when he snores.

The first breathing test was done to detect nasal airflow through temperature

sensor and pressure sensor. It was done by placing a finger on the pressure sensor to

simulate exhaling condition. This was done due to the pressure sensor was placed

directly onto the breadboard and by placing a finger on the sensor, the pressure was

reduced and hence having the same situation as breathe out as described in Chapter 3

of methodology. In addition, the test on temperature also implements the same

finger placing technique to give heat directly to the sensor. Red LED1 was light up

whenever the fingers were placed on either of the sensors. The LCD display was

able to display the digital output reading from the sensors as well. The time on the

LCD was reset whenever the fingers were placed on both sensors and as this event

was the indicator of human breath, the counter did not count up. The result can be

seen from the following Figure 4.3.

Page 58: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

40

Figure 4.3 : Result when breath detected

The second breathing test was done by making a sound (to simulate snore)

and blowing air to the condenser microphone (to simulate breathing through mouth).

This second test was able to yield the same result as the first breathing test as it was

able to turn on red LED1 whenever there was sound present and when the air was

blown to the sound sensor. The LCD display was also able to reset the time and did

not trigger the apneic event counter.

4.2.2 Not breathing

The condition when there was no airflow or snoring sound detected was

classified as not breathing. As there were no signals detected by the sensor, the

timer started moving to count for 10 seconds interval time. If the time is less than 10

seconds, the apneic event counter will remain the same as depicted in the Figure 4.4

(a). But if it is already 10 seconds or more, the apneic counter will start to count up

as in Figure 4.4 (b). As an alert to the user, the buzzer that existed on the circuit will

give out sound whenever the user stop breathing for a long time which is more than

two minutes. This was programmed so that the user will wake up and starts

breathing again and hopefully can avoid having brain damage.

Page 59: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

41

(a)

(b)

Figure 4.4 : Results when not breathing (a) Not breathing for t<10s, C=0 (b) Not

breathing for t>10s, C=1

Page 60: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

42

4.2.3 Pulse Rate

Pulse sensor was wrapped around a finger and the reading of the pulse rate

was taken from the data on the LCD display. The test on pulse sensor was done on

four female subjects. The results from the pulse sensor were compared with the

results taken from manual reading and digital pulse oxymeter. The results were

tabulated as below.

Table 4.1 : Pulse rate reading test results

Subject Pulse Sensor (bpm) Manual Reading (bpm) Pulse Oxymeter (bpm)

A 68 74 75

B 88 85 88

C 76 77 78

D 89 87 90

It can be seen from the table that the data taken from the three methods did

not differ much except from the reading of the subject A. The reading taken from

the subject through pulse sensor differed from the reading from manual reading and

pulse oxymeter. But as a whole, the pulse sensor is able to measure human pulse

rate and was working properly.

Page 61: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

43

4.3 Discussion

During the early project development, there were many problems faced

throughout the process. First problem was regard to the pressure sensor. At first, the

sensor was not able to detect any signal when it was connected to the

microcontroller. This was due to the signal of the sensor was relatively small

compared to the step size of the 16F877A ADC which is 4.888mV/step. This

problem was solved by applying the instrumentation amplifier circuit to the sensor

before it is been connected to the microcontroller.

Aside from that, the temperature sensor was omitted from the final prototype

although it can detect temperature decently. This is because, temperature sensor has

reaction rate that is much slower than the pressure sensor. The sensor was tested

both in normal room temperature and in air-conditioned room. When tested in a

much colder environment, the reading displayed on the LCD is a little bit slow. This

might be due to the nature of the sensor which the main purpose is to detect ambient

temperature.

The next problem was related to the pulse sensor. During the early test on

the sensor, the reading varies too much and to counter the problem, a new code was

written by adjusting the time delay in the source code. Another problem with this

pulse sensor is that, the accuracy in reading human’s pulse rate is slightly influenced

by the way of wrapping the sensor around finger. The wrapping must not be too

tight or too loose for it to work properly.

For this project, the pulse sensor can only detect pulse rate as it is not made

with red and infrared LEDs like what a standard pulse oxymeter used. The pulse

sensor used a green LED with the wavelength not suitable for measuring oxygen

concentration (SpO2) in blood. Even so, there is a relationship between pulse rate

Page 62: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

44

and SpO2 which is the higher the pulse rate, the lesser the SpO2[21]. But

unfortunately, since this device can only display the pulse beat per minute on the

LCD display it is hard to decide the apneic condition by this method.

For the final prototype of this project, it was decide that the portable device

will consist of pressure and sound sensor as the oronasal breath detector and the

pulse sensor to measure the pulse rate. From the finished prototype, it can be seen

that the device is small enough to describe it as portable.

Page 63: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

CHAPTER 5

CONCLUSION

5.1 Introduction

Chapter 5 is the final chapter in this thesis and in this chapter, there will be a

conclusion made on this project. This project still has its loophole and for this

reason there will be some recommendation section where it will discuss on the

improvement of the project. By making this recommendation, it is hope that it will

be useful for other people to use it as a reference in developing similar projects.

5.2 Conclusion

The conclusion that is made from finishing this project is that the objectives

stated earlier in this thesis had been accomplished successfully. It is to say that, at

the end of the project development, it is found that the device is portable and can be

used to detect human breathing and measure pulse rate. The process of interfacing

multiple sensors to a single microcontroller to determine the apneic event was also

Page 64: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

46

successfully achieved. To get an appropriate reading of the sensors, improvement on

the circuitry has also been done correctly for example in the case of pressure sensor

and the instrumentation amplifier. The device can also display the result as planned

when it was tested.

5.3 Recommendation

Throughout the development of this project, it was found out that there are

still rooms for improvements. This is due to some limitations still present in this

device. At first, there should be a data storage function for the purpose of storing the

data so that a much thorough analysis on the sleep apnea syndrome could be made.

This feature is especially useful for the pulse sensor as it cannot display the user’s

pulse pattern for analysis and comparison purpose. A new type of microcontroller

must be used since PIC16F877A is not powerful enough for a large data storing

purpose particularly in the use of SD card. Another method is to have the 16F877A

equipped with the USB function for easy data transfer to PC.

Another improvement is on the circuitry of the device. For the device to have

better accuracy, the circuit should be connected properly by building them on a

printed circuit board (PCB) instead of a breadboard. This is because the connection

on the breadboard is loose and can cause noise. Furthermore, the manual design

instrumentation amplifier can be replaced with the actual instrumentation amplifier

IC so that the there will be less glitch when it is used with pressure sensor.

Page 65: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

47

Finally, the last recommendation is to replace the pulse sensor with another

sensor that can act like pulse oxymeter. This improvement will make it easier for the

device to identify sleep apnea by measuring the SpO2 directly. In addition, a pulse

oxymeter can be programmed to calculate pulse rate as well.

Page 66: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

48

REFERENCES

1. Medical Development Division (2011). MOH/P/PAK/210.10(BP). Putrajaya:

Malaysia Ministry of Health.

2. Koja. S, Arakaki. H, and Ogura. C. (1997). Developing the portable type

sleep apnea detector, and verifying the usefulness of the device. Seishin

Shinkeigaku Zasshi. 99(4): 181-197.

3. Emsellem. H. A, Corson. W. A, Rappaport. B. A, Hackett. S, Smith. L. G,

and Hausfeld. J. N. (1990). Verification of sleep apnea using a portable sleep

apnea screening device. South Med J. 83(7): 748-752.

4. Maria. L. A. A, Joaquin. T. S, Jose. C. G, Monica. G. M, Luis. R. P, Jose. L.

V. B. and Angel. M. C. (2008). Reliability of home respiratory polygraphy

for the diagnosis of sleep apnea-hypoapnea syndrome. Analysis of costs.

Arch Bronconeumol. 44(1): 22-28.

5. Hida. W, Kurosawa. H, Miki. H, Go. T, Shindoh. C, Kikuchi. Y, Takishima.

T, and Shirato. K. (1995). Portable home monitoring system in screening for

sleep-disordered breathing. Nihon Kyobu Shikkan Gakkai Zasshi. 33: 46-49.

6. Rotariu. C, and Costin. H. (2013). Remote respiration monitoring system for

sleep apnea detection. Revista medico-chirurgicala a Societatii de Medici si

Naturalisti din Iasi. 117(1): 268-274

Page 67: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

49

7. Guilleminault. C, Tilikian. A, and Dement. W. C. (1976). The sleep apnea

syndromes. Annual Review of Medicine. 27: 465-484.

8. Samuel S. Becker. (2010). Snoring and Obstructive Sleep Apnea: Patient’s

Guide to Minimally-Invasive Treatments. N.J.: The New Jersey Centre.

9. Bradley. T. D, and Floras. J. S, (2003). Sleep apnea and heart failure: part I:

obstructive sleep apnea. Circulation. 107: 1671-1678.

10. Ramsey. R, Amit. K, and Kingman. P. S. (2007). Sleep Apnea: Diagnosis and

Treatment. Stanford, C.A.: Informa Healthcare.

11. Janet. M. T, Cassio. L, and Robert. M. C. (2011). Sleep Apnea. The Journal

of the American Medical Association. 305(9): 956.

12. Microchip, “ 8/40/44-Pin Enhanced Flash Microcontrollers,” PIC16F87XA

datasheet, 2003.

13. Martin P. Bates. (2008). Programming 8-bit PIC Microcontrollers in C with

Interactice Hardware Simulation. (2nd

ed.). U.K.:Newnes.

14. Cytron, “SK40C Enhanced 40 Pins PIC Start-Up Kit,” SK-40C user guide,

Mar. 2012.

15. OMRON, “MEMS Gauge Pressure Sensor,” SMPP datasheet, 01 .

16. Smith. C. S. (1954). Piezoresistance effect in germanium and silicon.

Physical Review. 94:42-49.

17. Cytron, “Mini Microphone Module,” SO-MIC-MOD guide, Dec. 2012.

18. National Semiconductor, “Precision Centigrade Temperature Sensors,” LM35

datasheet, Nov. 2000.

Page 68: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

50

19. PulseSensor, “Pulse Sensor Getting Started Guide,” Pulse Sensor Amped

guide, 2012.

20. ICircuit Technologies, “Hi-Tech C Compilers,” Hi-Tech C setup guide, 2009.

21. Walter. J. D, and Stuart. B. (1962). Effects of oxygen breathing on the heart

rate, blood pressure ad cardiac index of normal men resting, with reactive

hyperemia, and after atropine. Journal of Clinical Investigation. 41(1): 126-

132.

22. Virend. K. S, David. P. W, Raouf. A, William. T. A, Fernando. C, Antonio.

C, Stephen. D, John. S. F, Carl. E. H, Lyle. J. O, Thomas. G. P, Richard. R,

Mary. W, and Terry. Y. (2008). Sleep apnea and cardiovascular disease.

Journal of the American College od Cardiology. 52(8):686-717.

23. ON Semiconductor, “Single Supply Quad Operational Amplifiers,” LM3 4,

LM324A, LM224, LM2902, LM2902V, NCV2902 datasheet, Dec.

2010[Rev.24]

Page 69: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

51

APPENDIX A

Programming Source Code

//===============================================================================

// Author : ASYRAN ZYRATI YAHYA

// Project : PORTABLE SLEEP APNEA DETECTION DEVICE

// Project description : INTEGRATED SENSOR WITH LCD DISPLAY

// Remarks : lcd.h & system.h FILES ARE COURTESY FROM CYTRON

//===============================================================================

//===============================================================================

// include

#include <htc.h>

#include "lcd.h"

#include "system.h"

__CONFIG(0x3F32);

#define CHANNEL1 0b10001001 //Use channel1

#define CHANNEL2 0b10010001 //use channel2

#define snd1 RB3

#define buzzer RB2

#define LED3 RA5

//===============================================================================

//Function prototype

void breathing(void);

void interrupt ISR(void);

void delay1(unsigned long i);

void ADC_read(void);

unsigned short read_pressure(void);

unsigned short read_pulse(void);

int j;

int k;

int x;

int y;

unsigned char counter;

unsigned char count;

unsigned long BPM;

//===============================================================================

//Main Function

unsigned short result;

unsigned short pressure;

unsigned short pulse;

void main(void)

ADRESH=0;

ADRESL=0;

ADCON1=0b10000010; //vref=vdd

TRISA=0b00000110; // set AN1 as input port

TRISB=0b00001011; // set PORTB RB0-RB2 as input

TRISD=0b00000000; // set PORTD as OUTPUT

Page 70: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

52

GIE = 1; //Enable Global Interrupt

INTE = 1; //Enable RB0/INT external Interrupt

PEIE = 0; //Disable all unmasked peripheral interrupt

INTEDG = 0; //Interrupt on falling edge

TMR0IE=1;

T0CS=0;

T0SE=0;

PSA=0;

PS2=1;

PS1=1;

PS0=1; //set prescale 1:256

PORTA = 0; // clear PORT

PORTB = 0;

PORTD = 0;

lcd_initialize();

lcd_clear();

lcd_goto(0x00);

lcd_putstr("T:");

lcd_goto(0x40);

lcd_putstr("C:");

lcd_goto(0x45);

lcd_putstr("BPM:");

while(1)

ADCON0=CHANNEL2;

ADC_read();

pulse=read_pulse();

//lcd_goto(0x4C);

//lcd_bcd(4,pulse);

x=x++;

//lcd_goto(0x42);

//lcd_bcd(2,x);

if(x<90)

if(pulse<=516) //rise h.beat

LED3=0;

else if(pulse>516) //not beating

LED3=1; //RA5 lights on

y=y++;

else if(x==90)

BPM=4*y; //calculate for beat per minute

lcd_goto(0x49);

lcd_bcd(3,BPM);

x=0;

y=0;

delay1(25000); //delay2ms

Page 71: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

53

//===============================================================================

//Function for breathing -breath in and out

void breathing(void)

ADCON0=CHANNEL1;

ADC_read();

pressure=read_pressure();

lcd_goto(0x0C);

lcd_bcd(4,pressure);

if((pressure<196)&&(snd1==1)) //normal breathing without snoring

LED1=1; //RB6 lights on

LED2=0;

j=0;

delay1(500);

else if((pressure<196)&&(snd1==0)) //snoring with mouth close

LED2=0; //RB6 lights on

LED1=1;

j=0;

delay1(500);

else if((pressure>=196)&&(snd1==0)) //breathing or snoring through mouth

LED1=1;

LED2=0;

j=0;

delay1(500);

else if((pressure>=196)&&(snd1==1)) //not breathing -- no heat + no sound

LED1=0; //RB6 lights on

LED2=1;

delay1(500);

//===============================================================================

//subroutine ADC INITIALIZE

void ADC_read(void)

unsigned short m;

unsigned long digital_reading=0;

for(m=5;m>0;m-=1)

GO_DONE=1; //ADGO is the bit 2 of the ADCON0 register

while(GO_DONE==1); //ADC start, ADGO=0 after finish ADC progress

result=ADRESH;

result=result<<8; //shift to left for 8 bit

result=result|ADRESL; //10 bit result from ADC

digital_reading+=result;

Page 72: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

54

result=digital_reading/5;

unsigned short read_pressure(void)

unsigned short pressure;

pressure=result;

return pressure;

unsigned short read_pulse(void)

unsigned short pulse;

pulse=result;

return pulse;

//===============================================================================

//subroutine DELAY

void delay1(unsigned long i)

for(;i>0;i--);

//===============================================================================

//subroutine INTERRUPT TIMER0

void interrupt ISR(void)

TMR0IF=1;

counter++;

if(counter==25)

breathing();

if(LED2==1) //not breathing

j=j++;

lcd_goto(0x02);

lcd_bcd(2,j);

if(j==30)

k=k++;

lcd_goto(0x42);

lcd_bcd(1,k);

else if((j>30),(j<50))

k=k;

lcd_goto(0x42);

lcd_bcd(1,k);

else if(j>50)

k=k;

buzzer=1;

else

Page 73: 448_ASYRANZYRATIBINTIYAHYA2013

55

j=0;

lcd_goto(0x02);

lcd_bcd(2,j);

counter=0;

TMR0IF=0; // clear the interrupt flag