4 Fatalhit-run LAND OF THE SPREE Winner END … Label: CN-KSI-QLI,1STAR,4-4-4,4,93 - Time: Sat Jul 3...

1
The passenger in the cabin said . . . “I could see in his face (the pilot’s) that he felt there was something wrong of course. . . I sensed the airplane sinking and I could sense through the expression on Thurman’s face that the aircraft was out of control.” thrust and goes up for a fourth pass. From the tower, Ackley advises N15NY to change course this time and follow a right pattern for Runway 19. There is oth- er traffic in the area. It means Munson must make right turns instead of left, a slightly more demanding approach be- cause the pilot must look across the cock- pit and visibility is not as good. nnn Two nights earlier, Thurman is in Chi- cago, staying at Bobby and Kay Murcer’s place. After the kids are in bed, Diana watches “A Star Is Born” on TV. When Kris Kristoffersson’s character dies in the end, Diana, a woman who lives life with her feelings out front, finds herself sob- bing. She begins to think about what life would be like if anything ever happened to Thurman. She cries some more. When they speak on the phone that night, she is still upset and she tells him how scared she is. Thurman tells Diana she is his best friend and always will be, how privileged he is to share his life with her. “I love you very much,” he says. He as- sures her everything will be fine, that they will always have each other. His words are a great comfort. nnn 3:59 p.m. Circling back toward the end of 19, Munson is at 3,500 feet and flying at 200 KIAS. He throttles back to lower the speed and altitude, pulling back so far that the landing-gear horn sounds. The horn alerts the pilot if the aircraft doesn’t have sufficient speed for landing and if the gear is not down and locked. Munson manually flicks the horn off. Ackley, who is a minute away from the end of his shift, tells N15NY to fly another mile downwind — parallel to the runway, away from the airport — because of traffic. At 3:59:55, the controller advises N15NY to begin its base turn, beginning the loop back to the runway “anytime now.” Munson turns the aircraft to the right immediately, with about a 30-degree bank and the nose slightly low. He has neither extended the flaps nor put the landing gear down. nnn Diana and the kids — Tracy, 9, Kelly, 7, and Michael, 4 — have just returned home from the store. They were going out to eat that night but decided to stay home and let their dad barbecue some chicken instead. They bought about sev- en pounds of chocolate, too. Thurman Munson loved his chocolate, dunking his chocolate cookies in milk. Munson — irascible, cantankerous Thurman Mun- son — was a complete mushball with his kids. Discipline and punishment were Di- ana’s departments. Time and again, she thinks about how happy they are in their home. Earlier that summer, as dusk began to fall and Yankee manager Billy Martin (above, second from r.) can’t control his emotions at Munson’s funeral. Left, Bill Gallo’s classic tribute to the Yankee captain. Graig Nettles low- ers head during moment of silence honoring Munson at Stadium. Continued on next page she was cleaning up the kitchen after din- ner, Diana looked out the window to see Thurman on the patio, sitting in a chair, smoking a cigar, a look of softness and contentment on his face. She asked him what he was thinking about. He lifted his arm and surveyed their home, their abun- dant life, and asked Diana, “Can you be- lieve we’ve done it?” nnn 4:01 p.m. A pre-landing checklist — a way to make sure everything is properly con- figured for the approach — is standard operating procedure for all pilots; Mun- son does not use the checklist. “I don’t think you want to land this airplane with the gear up,” Hall tells Munson on their final approach. Munson puts the gear down. The plane has slipped below the glide slope — an electronic display that is basically a banister down to the runway. Follow the glide slope and you are fine. N15NY is at about 1,700 feet — 500 feet over the ground — when the gear goes down, but now the increased drag from the gear steepens the descent. “We’re sinking,” Hall tells Munson. He warns Munson about possible down- drafts on the approach to Runway 19. Munson inches the throttle forward. An- derson feels the left wing dip. Nobody is talking much. Propeller planes respond almost instantaneously when they are powered up; jet engines are more power- ful, but they take three to four seconds to spool up. Airplanes get their lift from air rushing over the wings. If you are going too slow, the plane “stalls” and loses its lift and begins to sink. This is what hap- pens to N15NY. The plane keeps sinking. Munson never puts the flaps down, which would give the plane additional lift. The NTSB report would state that Munson was flying an estimated 20 knots too slow for a no-flaps-down landing (about 93 KIAS), creating an excessive sink rate. “The added drag of the gear, the re- duced power and the reduced lift avail- able without flaps extended placed the aircraft in a dangerous situation,” the report would state. The pilot failed “to recognize the need for, and to take ac- tion to maintain, sufficient air speed to prevent a stall during an attempted landing.” Munson digs, seat all the way forward, determined to arrest the descent. He thrusts the throttles all the way forward to try to pull his jet out of it. “I could sense from his face that some- thing was wrong and the airplane was out of control,” Anderson says. Says Bill Crocker, Munson’s friend: “Knowing his personality, he was going to fly that thing himself. He was going to do everything himself.” The plane is maybe 300 feet off DAILY NEWS KEITH TORRIE DAILY NEWS FROM THE NTSB AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT REPORT ENDZONE the 93 I DAILY NEWS l Sunday, July 4, 2004

Transcript of 4 Fatalhit-run LAND OF THE SPREE Winner END … Label: CN-KSI-QLI,1STAR,4-4-4,4,93 - Time: Sat Jul 3...

PL

AT

E-S

IGZ

ON

E:C

N-K

SI-Q

LI,1S

TA

R,4-4-4,B

-B-B

,MA

IN-M

AIN

-MA

IN,4,93:

BL

AC

K O

NLY

Plate L

abel: CN

-KS

I-QL

I,1ST

AR

,4-4-4,4,93 - Tim

e: Sat Ju

l 3 17:34:08 ED

T 2004

Section

: MA

IN - O

utp

ut Q

ueu

e: LV

_AG

FA

New YorkMidday: 735 Win Four: 4349Evening: 553 Win Four: 2242Pick 10: 1-4-5-9-10-12-17-1819-26-29-34-43-45-51-54-5556-69-73Take 5: 3-12-13-18-34Mega Millions:10-25-38-39-50 Mega Ball: 12

New JerseyPick 3: 553 Pays $315.50Box: $105 Pairs: $31.50Pick Four: 1258Pays $1,710 Box: $71Cash 5: 10-20-30-35-36ConnecticutDaily: 694 Play Four: 1956Cash 5: 10-16-27-30-32Classic Lotto:6-16-18-19-27-43

F R I D AY L O T T E R Y

Baby Faces .............. 31Big Town Songbook .33Michael Daly ........... 10Death Notices ......... 47

The Gatecrasher ....... 26Gridlock Sam ........... 42Justice Story ........... 49Weather & Traffic .... 42

Main Number(212) 210-2100

Newsstand Circulation(212) 681-3300

Classified Ads(212) 949-2000

News Tips(212) 210-NEWS

On The Webwww.nydailynews.com

A L S O I N T H I S I S S U E

Home Deliver y (800) 692-NEWS

SUNDAY NOW Hollywood’s new king of come-dy is Will Ferrell, while Keira Knightley is just asardonic Druid guerrilla fighting for freedom in“King Arthur.” Plus Metallica’s sessions with ashrink, and New York’s best movie guide. ALSO:Advice, Atlantic City, Books, Food, Horoscopes, Puzzles,Movie Guide, Music and Theater. THE GATECRASHER “Sex and the City” actorlets loose on Ben Affleck and Kim Cattrall. Andfind out why Jack Nicholson’s daughter bitmagician David Blaine. TV VUE Fireworks from Boston to New Yorkto Washington. A roundup of the shows, themusic and the hosts — and where to tune in.

C S U N D AY J U LY 4 , 2 0 0 4

© 2004 Daily News, L.P. The Daily News, New York's HometownNewspaper (USPS 144-380) is published daily by Daily News, L.P.,

450 W. 33d Street, New York, N.Y. 10001.Periodicals postage paid at New York, N.Y and additional mailing offices.

POSTMASTER: Send address changes to The Daily News,25 Corporate Park Dr., Hopewell Junction, N.Y. 12533.

Sunday, July 4, 2004. Vol. 86, No. 12.For mail subscription orders:

DAILY NEWS L.P., 25 Corporate Park Dr., Hopewell Junction,N.Y. 12533. Phone: 888-853-9932.

I 95

SUNDAY OPINIONS PAGES 35-38

BEST SPORTS SECTION IN NEW YORK PAGES 50-95

SUNDAY TRAVEL SECTION IN THE CENTER

P H O N E N U M B E R S

Tomorrow is a federal and state holiday to mark Indepen-dence Day.

Courts, government offices, financial markets and schoolswill be closed; banks have the option of closing.

Mail service will be suspended, except for Express Mail. TheJames A. Farley Post Office on Eighth Ave. at W. 33rd St. will beopen.

Alternate-side parking rules and pickup of garbage and recy-clables will be suspended in the city. Subways and buses willrun on a Saturday schedule. The Long Island Rail Road andMetro North will operate on a holiday schedule. PATH servicewill operate on a weekend schedule.

WinneraMegamystery

People enjoy the thrill of a ride on the Cycloneroller coaster in Coney Island. See pages 44-45.

LOTTO-PIC Lottery Phone Line 1-900-448-4000 .99 per minuteFor the following states: NY, NJ, CT, PA & FL

BY LISA FLEISHERand JONATHAN LEMIRE

DAILY NEWS WRITERS

A CHINATOWN MAN collectingbottles on the street was runover and killed yesterday morn-ing by a sport-utility vehicle thatsped away from the grisly scene,police said.

“I heard an impact sound — abang — and then I saw a Chineseman laying on the ground,” saidMoon Fung, 52, a postal workerdriving to work. “These people[in the car] have no heart, theyhit people and run away.”

The dead man, Philip Chin, 56,was thrown into the middle of Di-vision St., where he lay silentlyon his back while several pass-ersby ran over to help and call911.

“His eyes slowly opened wideand his hands were shaking,”said Moon, who maneuvered hisown car into the intersection toblock traffic from the accidentscene. “His face turned green.”

Paramedics were on the scenewithin minutes and rushed Chin,

who suffered major head trau-ma, to NYU Downtown Hospitala few blocks away, but he waspronounced dead on arrival, offi-cials said.

Witnesses said that Chin, wholived just a block away on PikeSt., was gathering empties alongDivision St. about 5:40 a.m.when he attempted to cross atthe intersection of Allen St.

A green SUV believed to be alate-model Ford Explorer roaredthrough the intersection andstruck Chin before speedingaway with just a moment’s hesi-tation, police and witnessessaid.

“He should be barred for lifefrom driving,” Moon said. “Whoknows, someday he’s going tokill another one.”

The SUV was last spotted atCanal and Allen Sts., police said.

Cops said it has tinted win-dows and a New York licenseplate. Anyone with informationis asked to call CrimeStoppersat (800) 577-TIPS. All calls willbe kept confidential.

[email protected]

Fatal hit-runin Chinatown

What’s open, what’s not, tomorrow

BY MONIQUE EL-FAIZYDAILY NEWS WRITER

SORRY, NEW YORKERS:Unless someone headedmore than 200 miles north toLowell, Mass., to buy a MegaMillions ticket, we’re outtaluck.

The drawing for the $290million jackpot was held yes-terday in Times Square —but the “I won!” will likely beheard about 30 miles northof Boston.

The winner of the recordhaul didn’t rush forward toclaim the prize.

The winning ticket, bear-ing the numbers10-25-38-39-50 and MegaBall number 12, was sold atPowers Wine Co. in Lowell.

Store manager Raj Patelwas notified by lottery offi-cials at 8:15 a.m. yesterday.

“I’m too excited for this,”Patel said. “I can’t believe itat first.”

The $290 million prize isthe highest in the game’s his-tory and the sixth-largest inNorth American lottery histo-ry.

The chances of one personwinning it all were 1 in135,145,920. The winner cantake a lump-sum payout or26 years of annual paymentsof about $11.2 million — pre-tax.

Mega Millions tickets aresold in 11 states: New York,New Jersey, Massachusetts,Maryland, Virginia, Ohio,Michigan, Georgia, Illinois,Texas and Washington. With News Wire Services

X17

There’s no holiday from shopping for Lindsay Lohan (left)and Tara Reid as the two actresses hit the ground runningyesterday on Robertson Blvd. in Beverly Hills, Calif.

LAND OF THE SPREE

Sun

day,

July

4,2004

DA

ILY

NEW

S 4

Excerpt from the report quote goes here and here ghgh ghghgh ghghg hgdkhgaljd gk alkdjgo qoeiut oiu oqiwuet

poqiwue ptoqiweutpoqwiutoqweutoqwet.

The passenger in the cabin said . . . “I could see in his face (the pilot’s) that he felt there was something wrong of course. . .

I sensed the airplane sinking and I could sense through the expression on Thurman’s face that the aircraft was out of control.”

thrust and goes up for a fourth pass.From the tower, Ackley advises N15NY

to change course this time and follow a right pattern for Runway 19. There is oth-er traffi c in the area. It means Munson must make right turns instead of left, a slightly more demanding approach be-cause the pilot must look across the cock-pit and visibility is not as good.

n n nTwo nights earlier, Thurman is in Chi-

cago, staying at Bobby and Kay Murcer’s place. After the kids are in bed, Diana watches “A Star Is Born” on TV. When Kris Kristoffersson’s character dies in the end, Diana, a woman who lives life with her feelings out front, fi nds herself sob-bing. She begins to think about what life would be like if anything ever happened to Thurman. She cries some more. When they speak on the phone that night, she is still upset and she tells him how scared she is. Thurman tells Diana she is his best friend and always will be, how privileged he is to share his life with her.

“I love you very much,” he says. He as-sures her everything will be fi ne, that they will always have each other. His words are a great comfort.

n n n3:59 p.m. Circling back toward the end of 19, Munson is at 3,500 feet and fl ying at 200 KIAS. He throttles back to lower the speed and altitude, pulling back so far

that the landing-gear horn sounds. The horn alerts the pilot if the aircraft doesn’t have suffi cient speed for landing and if the gear is not down and locked. Munson manually fl icks the horn off. Ackley, who is a minute away from the end of his shift, tells N15NY to fl y another mile downwind — parallel to the runway, away from the airport — because of traffi c. At 3:59:55, the controller advises N15NY to begin its base turn, beginning the loop back to the runway “anytime now.”

Munson turns the aircraft to the right immediately, with about a 30-degree bank and the nose slightly low. He has neither extended the fl aps nor put the landing gear down.

n n nDiana and the kids — Tracy, 9, Kelly,

7, and Michael, 4 — have just returned home from the store. They were going out to eat that night but decided to stay home and let their dad barbecue some chicken instead. They bought about sev-en pounds of chocolate, too. Thurman Munson loved his chocolate, dunking his chocolate cookies in milk. Munson — irascible, cantankerous Thurman Mun-son — was a complete mushball with his kids. Discipline and punishment were Di-ana’s departments.

Time and again, she thinks about how happy they are in their home. Earlier that summer, as dusk began to fall and

Yankee manager Billy Martin (above, second from r.) can’t control his emotions at Munson’s funeral. Left, Bill Gallo’s classic tribute to the Yankee captain.

Graig Nettles low-ers head during moment of silence honoring Munson at Stadium.

Continued on next page

she was cleaning up the kitchen after din-ner, Diana looked out the window to see Thurman on the patio, sitting in a chair, smoking a cigar, a look of softness and contentment on his face. She asked him what he was thinking about. He lifted his arm and surveyed their home, their abun-dant life, and asked Diana, “Can you be-lieve we’ve done it?”

n n n4:01 p.m. A pre-landing checklist — a way to make sure everything is properly con-fi gured for the approach — is standard operating procedure for all pilots; Mun-son does not use the checklist. “I don’t think you want to land this airplane with the gear up,” Hall tells Munson on their fi nal approach. Munson puts the gear down. The plane has slipped below the glide slope — an electronic display that is basically a banister down to the runway. Follow the glide slope and you are fi ne. N15NY is at about 1,700 feet — 500 feet over the ground — when the gear goes down, but now the increased drag from the gear steepens the descent.

“We’re sinking,” Hall tells Munson. He warns Munson about possible down-drafts on the approach to Runway 19. Munson inches the throttle forward. An-derson feels the left wing dip. Nobody is talking much. Propeller planes respond almost instantaneously when they are powered up; jet engines are more power-

ful, but they take three to four seconds tospool up. Airplanes get their lift from airrushing over the wings. If you are goingtoo slow, the plane “stalls” and loses itslift and begins to sink. This is what hap-pens to N15NY. The plane keeps sinking.Munson never puts the fl aps down, whichwould give the plane additional lift. TheNTSB report would state that Munsonwas fl ying an estimated 20 knots tooslow for a no-fl aps-down landing (about93 KIAS), creating an excessive sinkrate. “The added drag of the gear, the re-duced power and the reduced lift avail-able without fl aps extended placed theaircraft in a dangerous situation,” thereport would state. The pilot failed “torecognize the need for, and to take ac-tion to maintain, suffi cient air speedto prevent a stall during an attemptedlanding.”

Munson digs, seat all the way forward, determined to arrest the descent. He thrusts the throttles all the way forward to try to pull his jet out of it.

“I could sense from his face that some-thing was wrong and the airplane was out of control,” Anderson says.

Says Bill Crocker, Munson’s friend: “Knowing his personality, he was going to fl y that thing himself. He was going to do everything himself.”

The plane is maybe 300 feet off

DA

ILY

NEW

S

KEITH TORRIE DAILY NEWS

FROM THE NTSB AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT REPORT

ENDZONEthe

93

I

DA

ILYN

EWS

lS

unday,July

4,2004