37th Annual Scientific Conferencewsi.org/events/images/WSI-37_Annual-Sci-Conf-brochure.pdfAuthor of...
Transcript of 37th Annual Scientific Conferencewsi.org/events/images/WSI-37_Annual-Sci-Conf-brochure.pdfAuthor of...
Psyc
hoan
alyt
ic an
d Ph
iloso
phica
l Pe
rspe
ctive
s on
Good
and
Evil
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
37th Annual Scientific ConferenceCo-sponsored with The National Association
for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis
PresentersRichard J. Bernstein, Ph.D
Anna Aragno, Ph.D Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D.
SUNDAY, MAY 19, 2013
Non
Pro
fit O
rg.
U.S
. Pos
tage
PAID
Perm
it #
7033
Whi
te P
lain
s, N
Y
WASHIN
GTO
N S
QUARE
INSTI
TUTE
41-5
1 EA
ST 1
1TH
STR
EET
NEW
YO
RK, N
EW Y
ORK
100
03
ABOUT THE CONFERENCEOverview of Good and Evil by Gerd H. Fenchel, Ph.D. Dr. Fenchel opens our conference with a psychoanalytic and philosophical inquiry into human being’s capacity for good and evil behaviors. He provides a thorough exploration of the historical influences of religion, philosophy, literature, culture, politics and psychology and poses thought provoking questions regarding the complexity of human nature.
Presentations:
How Not to Think About Evil By Richard J. Bernstein, Ph.DI want to review briefly some of the ways in which evil has been understood throughout history in philosophical, religious, and literary traditions. I will sketch how deeply entrenched a simplistic quasi-Manichean understanding of the opposition of good and evil pervades our everyday thinking about evil and how it influences our politics—especially in times of crisis. I will contrast this with a much more subtle approach to good and evil that has its sources in Hannah Arendt’s understanding of radical evil and the banality of evil as well as Primo Levi’s analysis of the “gray zone.” Finally I will conclude with some reflections on the relevance of Freud for thinking about evil.
The Devil Within: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Evil By Anna Aragno, Ph.D Of all the great dualities of human experience ’good and evil’ have been the most instrumental in shap-ing the beliefs, rituals, and laws, of Homo Sapiens. The splitting and externalization of our nature into ‘good and bad,’ and the anthropomorphic depiction of these two polarized forces have been with us for millennia, providing inspiration for magical rites, representational forms, and the cornucopia of dramas, narratives, and artworks, to which their characters have given divine expression and while all religions advocate for good, the particular narratives of “good and evil” underlying the traditions of western culture come to us directly from the bible.
Yet ‘Good and Evil’ are theological not psychological constructs, and with Freud, later psychoanalysts and especially Fromm, the dark forces believed to have taken over the mad and evil-doers were defini-tively secularized. This paper adopts a strictly psychoanalytic frame of reference for the concept of evil in an attempt to find a way of understanding how human beings are capable of doing inhuman things. We will look at behaviors manifesting through the psychodynamics of character structure and personal-ity disorders that enable a defacement of the ‘other’ in the creation of an enemy and the breakdown of empathy, offering a few clinical snapshots to illustrate how primitive emotions and defenses, superego pathology, and latent schizoid, narcissistic, and projective mechanisms, provide fuel and rationalization for malignant aggressive, duplicitous, and violent behaviors
What does evil do? By Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D.The polarity of good and evil and the ethical concepts thereof have preoccupied ordinary mankind, cre-ative writers, philosophers, psychologists, theologians since time immemorial. Philosophers saw good as absence of evil, implying that evil is easier to define as such, while unable to reach a unified conception of evil. For Judeo-Christian theologians, evil was sin against WW II by choosing death on September 23, 1939. For ordinary men and women evil has the overwhelming meaning of pain and suffering from illness of body and soul, deprivation, poverty, hunger, hatred, violence, cruelty, torture and God’s commandments. However, theologians were unable to reconcile the existence of evil with the theodicy of God as the source of goodness and universal love. Sigmund Freud (1915) faced the evils the Great War recommended “eradicating evil human tendencies [with] education and a civilized environment,” escaping the evils of killing, rape and sexual enslavement, racial and religious persecution and, last but not least, massacres of innocents by armies and individuals.
WHO SHOULD ATTENDPsychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, licensed psychoanalysts, nurses, marriage/family counselors, EAP and HMO clinicians
37
TH A
NN
UA
L SC
IEN
TIFI
C CO
NFE
REN
CE
Mic
hela
ngel
o, S
istin
e Ch
apel
cei
ling,
pai
nted
bet
wee
n 15
08 a
nd 1
512
SUN
DAY
, M
AY 1
9, 2
01
3
9:3
0 A
.M. -
4:3
0 P
.M.
Psyc
hoan
alyt
ic an
d Ph
iloso
phica
l Pe
rspe
ctive
s on
Good
and
Evil
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
The Last Judgement (Trumpeting Angels) with books of Good and Evil Deeds
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
Registration Begins At 9:00 A.M. Morning Session: 10:00 A.M. – 12:30 P.M.
REGISTRATION
WASHINGTON SQUARE INSTITUTE FOR PSYCHOTHERAPYAtt: Registrar: 41-51 East 11th Street, New York, N.Y. 10003
Phone: (212) 477-2600 Fax: (212) 477-2040
To register: If payment is by check, mail this page with your check made out to WSI
If payment is by credit card, you may call it in at (212) 477-2600, or pay online at: wsi.org/upcoming-events/annual-conference
(Advance registration is recommended due to limited seating.)
❑ Early Bird Special (before April 19, 2013) ..................................... $125.00❑ Advance Registration ................................................................... $140.00 Received before May 1, 2013
❑ Students with ID ............................................................................ $50.00❑ Advance Registration received before May 1, 2013 ......................... $65.00 (If registering by name, enclose copy of Student ID)
❑ At the door ................................................................................. $155.00
❑ WSI faculty and Staff (early bird special before April 19, 2013) ...... $120.00❑ WSI Faculty and Staff .................................................................. $130.00
Enclose this form with a check payable to:WASHINGTON SQUARE INSTITUTE and mail to
Conference, Washington Square Institute,41–51 East 11th Street, New York, NY 10003
Refunds will be given up to one week prior to conference date only.
Registration begins at 9:00 A.M.
Name
Address
City State Zip
Telephone
E-mail Address Washington Square Institute is approved by the American Psychological Association to sponsor continuing education for psychologists. Washington Square Institute maintains responsibility for this program and its contents. Participants in the conference will receive 5 CE credits.
Susan A. Klett, LCSW-R, BCD, Director of Continuing Education
Welcoming Remarks: SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA.
An Overview of Good and Evil: GERD H. FENCHEL, PH.D.
RICHARD J. BERNSTEIN, PH.D.
How Not to Think About Evil
AFTERNOON SESSION: 2:00 P.M. – 4:30 P.M.
Moderator: SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA.
ANNA ARAGNO, Ph.D
The Devil Within: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Evil
HENRY (ZVI) LOTHANE, M.D
What does evil do?PANEL DISCUSSION
Proceedings of the Conference will be published in Issues in Psychoanalytic Psychology
LOCATION Washington Square Institute for Psychotherapy
41-51 East 11th Street (4th Floor), New York, NY 10003
CONFERENCE CO-CHAIRS: Gerd H. Fenchel, Ph.D. and Susan A. Klett, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA
Committee: Marc Angers, LCSW, L.P., NCPsyA., and Marilyn Tauber, M.A., L.P., NCPsyA.
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
PARTICIPANTS In Order of Presentation
Richard J. Bernstein, Ph.D is Vera List Professor of Philosophy of the New School for Social Research where he has been a former Dean. His books include John Dewey (1966), Praxis and Action (1971), Beyond Objectiv-ism and Relativism: Science, Hermeneutics, and Praxis (1983), Habermas and Modernity (editor, 1985), Philosophical Profiles (1986), The New Constellation: The Ethical/Political Horizons of Modernity/ Postmodernity (1991),Hannah Arendt and the Jewish Question(1996), Freud and the Legacy of Moses (1998), Radical Evil: A Philosophic Interrogation (2002) and The Pragmatic Turn. Vio-lence: Thinking without Banisters will be published in the spring of 2013.
Anna Aragno, Ph.D. is a published author of many scholarly papers and of two books, “Symbolization: Proposing a Developmental Paradigm for a New Psychoanalytic Theory of Mind” (IUP, 1997) and “Forms of Knowledge: A Psychoanalytic Study of Human Communication” (PublishAmerica, 2008). Dr. Aragno came to the US from Italy on a Fulbright in the late 60’s. After an interna-tional career as freelance prima ballerina, she resumed academic studies at The New School Graduate Faculty receiving her psychoanalytic training at Washing-ton Square Institute and Post Graduate Center. She devotes her time to private practice specializing in the treatment of creative artists, presenting at conferences, and writing scholarly papers on a variety of topics with a strong emphasis on metapsychological revisions. In pursuit of this interest her affiliations have now expanded to include contributions to the new scientific field of Biosemiotics.
Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D. Clinical Professor of Psychiatry at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York City. Private practice of psychiatry, psychotherapy, and psychoanalysis. Distinguished Life Fellow of the American Psychiatric Association, member of the American and International Psychoana-lytic Associations. Author of the definitive In Defense of Schreber Soul Murder and Psychiatry (expanded version, Seelenmord und Psychiatrie Zur Rehabili-tieung Schrebers), historical research on the life and work of Sabina Spielrein, most recently as co-chair and presenter at the winter meeting of the American Psychoanalytic Association and as invited discussant after the showing of Ken Wydro “Secrets.” and papers on the methodology of psychotherapy and psychoanalysis. In 2009 he created the concept of dramatology, an entry in Wikipedia and a paper in Issues in Psychoanalytic Psychology.
CONFERENCE CO-CHAIRSGERD H.FENCHEL, Ph.D. – One of the original founders of Washington Square Institute. Dr. Fenchel is Co-Director/Dean, Supervisor and Training Analyst, WSI; Fellow, Council of Psychoanalytic Psychotherapists, American Group Psychotherapy Association, and the Pennsylvania Psychological Association, International council of Psychologists; Member National Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis. Licensed Psychologist: New York State, Pennsylvania.
SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA. - Certified Psychoanalyst –Co-Director, Director of Continuing Education, Washington Square Institute; Faculty, Supervisor and Training Analyst, WSI, Faculty and former board member of Postgrad* The Institute of the Post-graduate Psychoanalytic Society; Past President, The Postgraduate Psychoanalytic Society, Co-Chair Planning and Education Program, Past Chair of Education Committee, The New York State Society of Clinical Social Work. Private Practice, New York City.
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
Registration Begins At 9:00 A.M. Morning Session: 10:00 A.M. – 12:30 P.M.
REGISTRATION
WASHINGTON SQUARE INSTITUTE FOR PSYCHOTHERAPYAtt: Registrar: 41-51 East 11th Street, New York, N.Y. 10003
Phone: (212) 477-2600 Fax: (212) 477-2040
To register: If payment is by check, mail this page with your check made out to WSI
If payment is by credit card, you may call it in at (212) 477-2600, or pay online at: wsi.org/upcoming-events/annual-conference
(Advance registration is recommended due to limited seating.)
❑ Early Bird Special (before April 19, 2013) ..................................... $125.00❑ Advance Registration ................................................................... $140.00 Received before May 1, 2013
❑ Students with ID ............................................................................ $50.00❑ Advance Registration received before May 1, 2013 ......................... $65.00 (If registering by name, enclose copy of Student ID)
❑ At the door ................................................................................. $155.00
❑ WSI faculty and Staff (early bird special before April 19, 2013) ...... $120.00❑ WSI Faculty and Staff .................................................................. $130.00
Enclose this form with a check payable to:WASHINGTON SQUARE INSTITUTE and mail to
Conference, Washington Square Institute,41–51 East 11th Street, New York, NY 10003
Refunds will be given up to one week prior to conference date only.
Registration begins at 9:00 A.M.
Name
Address
City State Zip
Telephone
E-mail Address Washington Square Institute is approved by the American Psychological Association to sponsor continuing education for psychologists. Washington Square Institute maintains responsibility for this program and its contents. Participants in the conference will receive 5 CE credits.
Susan A. Klett, LCSW-R, BCD, Director of Continuing Education
Welcoming Remarks: SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA.
An Overview of Good and Evil: GERD H. FENCHEL, PH.D.
RICHARD J. BERNSTEIN, PH.D.
How Not to Think About Evil
AFTERNOON SESSION: 2:00 P.M. – 4:30 P.M.
Moderator: SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA.
ANNA ARAGNO, Ph.D
The Devil Within: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Evil
HENRY (ZVI) LOTHANE, M.D
What does evil do?PANEL DISCUSSION
Proceedings of the Conference will be published in Issues in Psychoanalytic Psychology
LOCATION Washington Square Institute for Psychotherapy
41-51 East 11th Street (4th Floor), New York, NY 10003
CONFERENCE CO-CHAIRS: Gerd H. Fenchel, Ph.D. and Susan A. Klett, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA
Committee: Marc Angers, LCSW, L.P., NCPsyA., and Marilyn Tauber, M.A., L.P., NCPsyA.
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
PARTICIPANTS In Order of Presentation
Richard J. Bernstein, Ph.D is Vera List Professor of Philosophy of the New School for Social Research where he has been a former Dean. His books include John Dewey (1966), Praxis and Action (1971), Beyond Objectiv-ism and Relativism: Science, Hermeneutics, and Praxis (1983), Habermas and Modernity (editor, 1985), Philosophical Profiles (1986), The New Constellation: The Ethical/Political Horizons of Modernity/ Postmodernity (1991),Hannah Arendt and the Jewish Question(1996), Freud and the Legacy of Moses (1998), Radical Evil: A Philosophic Interrogation (2002) and The Pragmatic Turn. Vio-lence: Thinking without Banisters will be published in the spring of 2013.
Anna Aragno, Ph.D. is a published author of many scholarly papers and of two books, “Symbolization: Proposing a Developmental Paradigm for a New Psychoanalytic Theory of Mind” (IUP, 1997) and “Forms of Knowledge: A Psychoanalytic Study of Human Communication” (PublishAmerica, 2008). Dr. Aragno came to the US from Italy on a Fulbright in the late 60’s. After an interna-tional career as freelance prima ballerina, she resumed academic studies at The New School Graduate Faculty receiving her psychoanalytic training at Washing-ton Square Institute and Post Graduate Center. She devotes her time to private practice specializing in the treatment of creative artists, presenting at conferences, and writing scholarly papers on a variety of topics with a strong emphasis on metapsychological revisions. In pursuit of this interest her affiliations have now expanded to include contributions to the new scientific field of Biosemiotics.
Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D. Clinical Professor of Psychiatry at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York City. Private practice of psychiatry, psychotherapy, and psychoanalysis. Distinguished Life Fellow of the American Psychiatric Association, member of the American and International Psychoana-lytic Associations. Author of the definitive In Defense of Schreber Soul Murder and Psychiatry (expanded version, Seelenmord und Psychiatrie Zur Rehabili-tieung Schrebers), historical research on the life and work of Sabina Spielrein, most recently as co-chair and presenter at the winter meeting of the American Psychoanalytic Association and as invited discussant after the showing of Ken Wydro “Secrets.” and papers on the methodology of psychotherapy and psychoanalysis. In 2009 he created the concept of dramatology, an entry in Wikipedia and a paper in Issues in Psychoanalytic Psychology.
CONFERENCE CO-CHAIRSGERD H.FENCHEL, Ph.D. – One of the original founders of Washington Square Institute. Dr. Fenchel is Co-Director/Dean, Supervisor and Training Analyst, WSI; Fellow, Council of Psychoanalytic Psychotherapists, American Group Psychotherapy Association, and the Pennsylvania Psychological Association, International council of Psychologists; Member National Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis. Licensed Psychologist: New York State, Pennsylvania.
SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA. - Certified Psychoanalyst –Co-Director, Director of Continuing Education, Washington Square Institute; Faculty, Supervisor and Training Analyst, WSI, Faculty and former board member of Postgrad* The Institute of the Post-graduate Psychoanalytic Society; Past President, The Postgraduate Psychoanalytic Society, Co-Chair Planning and Education Program, Past Chair of Education Committee, The New York State Society of Clinical Social Work. Private Practice, New York City.
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
Registration Begins At 9:00 A.M. Morning Session: 10:00 A.M. – 12:30 P.M.
REGISTRATION
WASHINGTON SQUARE INSTITUTE FOR PSYCHOTHERAPYAtt: Registrar: 41-51 East 11th Street, New York, N.Y. 10003
Phone: (212) 477-2600 Fax: (212) 477-2040
To register: If payment is by check, mail this page with your check made out to WSI
If payment is by credit card, you may call it in at (212) 477-2600, or pay online at: wsi.org/upcoming-events/annual-conference
(Advance registration is recommended due to limited seating.)
❑ Early Bird Special (before April 19, 2013) ..................................... $125.00❑ Advance Registration ................................................................... $140.00 Received before May 1, 2013
❑ Students with ID ............................................................................ $50.00❑ Advance Registration received before May 1, 2013 ......................... $65.00 (If registering by name, enclose copy of Student ID)
❑ At the door ................................................................................. $155.00
❑ WSI faculty and Staff (early bird special before April 19, 2013) ...... $120.00❑ WSI Faculty and Staff .................................................................. $130.00
Enclose this form with a check payable to:WASHINGTON SQUARE INSTITUTE and mail to
Conference, Washington Square Institute,41–51 East 11th Street, New York, NY 10003
Refunds will be given up to one week prior to conference date only.
Registration begins at 9:00 A.M.
Name
Address
City State Zip
Telephone
E-mail Address Washington Square Institute is approved by the American Psychological Association to sponsor continuing education for psychologists. Washington Square Institute maintains responsibility for this program and its contents. Participants in the conference will receive 5 CE credits.
Susan A. Klett, LCSW-R, BCD, Director of Continuing Education
Welcoming Remarks: SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA.
An Overview of Good and Evil: GERD H. FENCHEL, PH.D.
RICHARD J. BERNSTEIN, PH.D.
How Not to Think About Evil
AFTERNOON SESSION: 2:00 P.M. – 4:30 P.M.
Moderator: SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA.
ANNA ARAGNO, Ph.D
The Devil Within: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Evil
HENRY (ZVI) LOTHANE, M.D
What does evil do?PANEL DISCUSSION
Proceedings of the Conference will be published in Issues in Psychoanalytic Psychology
LOCATION Washington Square Institute for Psychotherapy
41-51 East 11th Street (4th Floor), New York, NY 10003
CONFERENCE CO-CHAIRS: Gerd H. Fenchel, Ph.D. and Susan A. Klett, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA
Committee: Marc Angers, LCSW, L.P., NCPsyA., and Marilyn Tauber, M.A., L.P., NCPsyA.
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
PARTICIPANTS In Order of Presentation
Richard J. Bernstein, Ph.D is Vera List Professor of Philosophy of the New School for Social Research where he has been a former Dean. His books include John Dewey (1966), Praxis and Action (1971), Beyond Objectiv-ism and Relativism: Science, Hermeneutics, and Praxis (1983), Habermas and Modernity (editor, 1985), Philosophical Profiles (1986), The New Constellation: The Ethical/Political Horizons of Modernity/ Postmodernity (1991),Hannah Arendt and the Jewish Question(1996), Freud and the Legacy of Moses (1998), Radical Evil: A Philosophic Interrogation (2002) and The Pragmatic Turn. Vio-lence: Thinking without Banisters will be published in the spring of 2013.
Anna Aragno, Ph.D. is a published author of many scholarly papers and of two books, “Symbolization: Proposing a Developmental Paradigm for a New Psychoanalytic Theory of Mind” (IUP, 1997) and “Forms of Knowledge: A Psychoanalytic Study of Human Communication” (PublishAmerica, 2008). Dr. Aragno came to the US from Italy on a Fulbright in the late 60’s. After an interna-tional career as freelance prima ballerina, she resumed academic studies at The New School Graduate Faculty receiving her psychoanalytic training at Washing-ton Square Institute and Post Graduate Center. She devotes her time to private practice specializing in the treatment of creative artists, presenting at conferences, and writing scholarly papers on a variety of topics with a strong emphasis on metapsychological revisions. In pursuit of this interest her affiliations have now expanded to include contributions to the new scientific field of Biosemiotics.
Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D. Clinical Professor of Psychiatry at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York City. Private practice of psychiatry, psychotherapy, and psychoanalysis. Distinguished Life Fellow of the American Psychiatric Association, member of the American and International Psychoana-lytic Associations. Author of the definitive In Defense of Schreber Soul Murder and Psychiatry (expanded version, Seelenmord und Psychiatrie Zur Rehabili-tieung Schrebers), historical research on the life and work of Sabina Spielrein, most recently as co-chair and presenter at the winter meeting of the American Psychoanalytic Association and as invited discussant after the showing of Ken Wydro “Secrets.” and papers on the methodology of psychotherapy and psychoanalysis. In 2009 he created the concept of dramatology, an entry in Wikipedia and a paper in Issues in Psychoanalytic Psychology.
CONFERENCE CO-CHAIRSGERD H.FENCHEL, Ph.D. – One of the original founders of Washington Square Institute. Dr. Fenchel is Co-Director/Dean, Supervisor and Training Analyst, WSI; Fellow, Council of Psychoanalytic Psychotherapists, American Group Psychotherapy Association, and the Pennsylvania Psychological Association, International council of Psychologists; Member National Association for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis. Licensed Psychologist: New York State, Pennsylvania.
SUSAN A. KLETT, LCSW-R, BCD, NCPsyA. - Certified Psychoanalyst –Co-Director, Director of Continuing Education, Washington Square Institute; Faculty, Supervisor and Training Analyst, WSI, Faculty and former board member of Postgrad* The Institute of the Post-graduate Psychoanalytic Society; Past President, The Postgraduate Psychoanalytic Society, Co-Chair Planning and Education Program, Past Chair of Education Committee, The New York State Society of Clinical Social Work. Private Practice, New York City.
Psyc
hoan
alyt
ic an
d Ph
iloso
phica
l Pe
rspe
ctive
s on
Good
and
Evil
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
37th Annual Scientific ConferenceCo-sponsored with The National Association
for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis
PresentersRichard J. Bernstein, Ph.D
Anna Aragno, Ph.D Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D.
SUNDAY, MAY 19, 2013
Non
Pro
fit O
rg.
U.S
. Pos
tage
PAID
Perm
it #
7033
Whi
te P
lain
s, N
Y
WASHIN
GTO
N S
QUARE
INSTI
TUTE
41-5
1 EA
ST 1
1TH
STR
EET
NEW
YO
RK, N
EW Y
ORK
100
03
ABOUT THE CONFERENCEOverview of Good and Evil by Gerd H. Fenchel, Ph.D. Dr. Fenchel opens our conference with a psychoanalytic and philosophical inquiry into human being’s capacity for good and evil behaviors. He provides a thorough exploration of the historical influences of religion, philosophy, literature, culture, politics and psychology and poses thought provoking questions regarding the complexity of human nature.
Presentations:
How Not to Think About Evil By Richard J. Bernstein, Ph.DI want to review briefly some of the ways in which evil has been understood throughout history in philosophical, religious, and literary traditions. I will sketch how deeply entrenched a simplistic quasi-Manichean understanding of the opposition of good and evil pervades our everyday thinking about evil and how it influences our politics—especially in times of crisis. I will contrast this with a much more subtle approach to good and evil that has its sources in Hannah Arendt’s understanding of radical evil and the banality of evil as well as Primo Levi’s analysis of the “gray zone.” Finally I will conclude with some reflections on the relevance of Freud for thinking about evil.
The Devil Within: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Evil By Anna Aragno, Ph.D Of all the great dualities of human experience ’good and evil’ have been the most instrumental in shap-ing the beliefs, rituals, and laws, of Homo Sapiens. The splitting and externalization of our nature into ‘good and bad,’ and the anthropomorphic depiction of these two polarized forces have been with us for millennia, providing inspiration for magical rites, representational forms, and the cornucopia of dramas, narratives, and artworks, to which their characters have given divine expression and while all religions advocate for good, the particular narratives of “good and evil” underlying the traditions of western culture come to us directly from the bible.
Yet ‘Good and Evil’ are theological not psychological constructs, and with Freud, later psychoanalysts and especially Fromm, the dark forces believed to have taken over the mad and evil-doers were defini-tively secularized. This paper adopts a strictly psychoanalytic frame of reference for the concept of evil in an attempt to find a way of understanding how human beings are capable of doing inhuman things. We will look at behaviors manifesting through the psychodynamics of character structure and personal-ity disorders that enable a defacement of the ‘other’ in the creation of an enemy and the breakdown of empathy, offering a few clinical snapshots to illustrate how primitive emotions and defenses, superego pathology, and latent schizoid, narcissistic, and projective mechanisms, provide fuel and rationalization for malignant aggressive, duplicitous, and violent behaviors
What does evil do? By Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D.The polarity of good and evil and the ethical concepts thereof have preoccupied ordinary mankind, cre-ative writers, philosophers, psychologists, theologians since time immemorial. Philosophers saw good as absence of evil, implying that evil is easier to define as such, while unable to reach a unified conception of evil. For Judeo-Christian theologians, evil was sin against WW II by choosing death on September 23, 1939. For ordinary men and women evil has the overwhelming meaning of pain and suffering from illness of body and soul, deprivation, poverty, hunger, hatred, violence, cruelty, torture and God’s commandments. However, theologians were unable to reconcile the existence of evil with the theodicy of God as the source of goodness and universal love. Sigmund Freud (1915) faced the evils the Great War recommended “eradicating evil human tendencies [with] education and a civilized environment,” escaping the evils of killing, rape and sexual enslavement, racial and religious persecution and, last but not least, massacres of innocents by armies and individuals.
WHO SHOULD ATTENDPsychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, licensed psychoanalysts, nurses, marriage/family counselors, EAP and HMO clinicians
37
TH A
NN
UA
L SC
IEN
TIFI
C CO
NFE
REN
CE
Mic
hela
ngel
o, S
istin
e Ch
apel
cei
ling,
pai
nted
bet
wee
n 15
08 a
nd 1
512
SUN
DAY
, M
AY 1
9, 2
01
3
9:3
0 A
.M. -
4:3
0 P
.M.
Psyc
hoan
alyt
ic an
d Ph
iloso
phica
l Pe
rspe
ctive
s on
Good
and
Evil
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
The Last Judgement (Trumpeting Angels) with books of Good and Evil Deeds
Psyc
hoan
alyt
ic an
d Ph
iloso
phica
l Pe
rspe
ctive
s on
Good
and
Evil
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
37th Annual Scientific ConferenceCo-sponsored with The National Association
for the Advancement of Psychoanalysis
PresentersRichard J. Bernstein, Ph.D
Anna Aragno, Ph.D Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D.
SUNDAY, MAY 19, 2013
Non
Pro
fit O
rg.
U.S
. Pos
tage
PAID
Perm
it #
7033
Whi
te P
lain
s, N
Y
WASHIN
GTO
N S
QUARE
INSTI
TUTE
41-5
1 EA
ST 1
1TH
STR
EET
NEW
YO
RK, N
EW Y
ORK
100
03
ABOUT THE CONFERENCEOverview of Good and Evil by Gerd H. Fenchel, Ph.D. Dr. Fenchel opens our conference with a psychoanalytic and philosophical inquiry into human being’s capacity for good and evil behaviors. He provides a thorough exploration of the historical influences of religion, philosophy, literature, culture, politics and psychology and poses thought provoking questions regarding the complexity of human nature.
Presentations:
How Not to Think About Evil By Richard J. Bernstein, Ph.DI want to review briefly some of the ways in which evil has been understood throughout history in philosophical, religious, and literary traditions. I will sketch how deeply entrenched a simplistic quasi-Manichean understanding of the opposition of good and evil pervades our everyday thinking about evil and how it influences our politics—especially in times of crisis. I will contrast this with a much more subtle approach to good and evil that has its sources in Hannah Arendt’s understanding of radical evil and the banality of evil as well as Primo Levi’s analysis of the “gray zone.” Finally I will conclude with some reflections on the relevance of Freud for thinking about evil.
The Devil Within: A Psychoanalytic Perspective on Evil By Anna Aragno, Ph.D Of all the great dualities of human experience ’good and evil’ have been the most instrumental in shap-ing the beliefs, rituals, and laws, of Homo Sapiens. The splitting and externalization of our nature into ‘good and bad,’ and the anthropomorphic depiction of these two polarized forces have been with us for millennia, providing inspiration for magical rites, representational forms, and the cornucopia of dramas, narratives, and artworks, to which their characters have given divine expression and while all religions advocate for good, the particular narratives of “good and evil” underlying the traditions of western culture come to us directly from the bible.
Yet ‘Good and Evil’ are theological not psychological constructs, and with Freud, later psychoanalysts and especially Fromm, the dark forces believed to have taken over the mad and evil-doers were defini-tively secularized. This paper adopts a strictly psychoanalytic frame of reference for the concept of evil in an attempt to find a way of understanding how human beings are capable of doing inhuman things. We will look at behaviors manifesting through the psychodynamics of character structure and personal-ity disorders that enable a defacement of the ‘other’ in the creation of an enemy and the breakdown of empathy, offering a few clinical snapshots to illustrate how primitive emotions and defenses, superego pathology, and latent schizoid, narcissistic, and projective mechanisms, provide fuel and rationalization for malignant aggressive, duplicitous, and violent behaviors
What does evil do? By Henry (Zvi) Lothane, M.D.The polarity of good and evil and the ethical concepts thereof have preoccupied ordinary mankind, cre-ative writers, philosophers, psychologists, theologians since time immemorial. Philosophers saw good as absence of evil, implying that evil is easier to define as such, while unable to reach a unified conception of evil. For Judeo-Christian theologians, evil was sin against WW II by choosing death on September 23, 1939. For ordinary men and women evil has the overwhelming meaning of pain and suffering from illness of body and soul, deprivation, poverty, hunger, hatred, violence, cruelty, torture and God’s commandments. However, theologians were unable to reconcile the existence of evil with the theodicy of God as the source of goodness and universal love. Sigmund Freud (1915) faced the evils the Great War recommended “eradicating evil human tendencies [with] education and a civilized environment,” escaping the evils of killing, rape and sexual enslavement, racial and religious persecution and, last but not least, massacres of innocents by armies and individuals.
WHO SHOULD ATTENDPsychiatrists, psychologists, social workers, licensed psychoanalysts, nurses, marriage/family counselors, EAP and HMO clinicians
37
TH A
NN
UA
L SC
IEN
TIFI
C CO
NFE
REN
CE
Mic
hela
ngel
o, S
istin
e Ch
apel
cei
ling,
pai
nted
bet
wee
n 15
08 a
nd 1
512
SUN
DAY
, M
AY 1
9, 2
01
3
9:3
0 A
.M. -
4:3
0 P
.M.
Psyc
hoan
alyt
ic an
d Ph
iloso
phica
l Pe
rspe
ctive
s on
Good
and
Evil
PSYCHOANALYTIC AND PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVES ON GOOD AND EVIL
The Last Judgement (Trumpeting Angels) with books of Good and Evil Deeds