shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf ·...

39
CHAPTER 2 GENERALISED BUS IMPEDANCE ALGORITHM 2*1 INTRODUCTION Bub impedance matrix of a network is a mathematical equivalent which relates the bus voltages explicitly in terms of the bus currents. The primitive impedance matrix and the network topology are required to construct the bus impedance matrix Zg^. The elements of the bus impedance matrix can be interpreted as the open circuit impedance parameters relating the bus voltages and currents. Alternatively using linear graph theory the bus impedance matrix can be viewed as the multi terminal representation in impedance form correspon- oc 07 ding to the Lagrangian tree as the terminal graph * ' The topological formula for the computation of Zgug however requires, the matrix inversion of the order equal to the number of independent loops in the network and hence cannot be used to compute Zgug of large networks. The alternate method of constructing the bus impedance matrix by adding one element at a time has been very popular with power engineers and is known as Zgus building algorithm. The bus impedance algorithm was originally developed in I960 by Brown, Person, Kirchmayer and 28 29 Stagg ' . This algorithm was developed interpreting

Transcript of shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf ·...

Page 1: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

CHAPTER 2

GENERALISED BUS IMPEDANCE ALGORITHM

2*1 INTRODUCTION

Bub impedance matrix of a network is amathematical equivalent which relates the busvoltages explicitly in terms of the bus currents.The primitive impedance matrix and the networktopology are required to construct the bus impedancematrix Zg^. The elements of the bus impedancematrix can be interpreted as the open circuitimpedance parameters relating the bus voltages andcurrents. Alternatively using linear graph theorythe bus impedance matrix can be viewed as the multiterminal representation in impedance form correspon-

oc 07ding to the Lagrangian tree as the terminal graph * ' The topological formula for the computation of Zgug however requires, the matrix inversion of the order equal to the number of independent loops in the network and hence cannot be used to compute Zgug of large networks. The alternate method of constructing the bus impedance matrix by adding one element at a time has been very popular with power engineers and is known as Zgus building algorithm.

The bus impedance algorithm was originallydeveloped in I960 by Brown, Person, Kirchmayer and

28 29Stagg ' . This algorithm was developed interpreting

Page 2: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

15

the elements of ZgUjg as the open circuit parametersof the network. While constructing the Zg^, theelements are added to the partial network one at atime. The added element will be either a branch ora link. When a branch is added the elements of thebus impedance matrix corresponding to the partialnetwork are not altered. This result was used whileobtaining the modified hue impedance matrix due tothe addition of a link also, by first considering theadded element as a branch creating a fictitious bus.This has resulted in a two step procedure for theaddition of a link algorithm. Furthermore, thealgorithm for the modification of the bus impedancematrix dup to the removal of elements from thecoupled group is much involved. This originalalgorithm has since been expanded upon by several

30-3'5authors for new applications ^ ,

Bhat has developed the bus impedance algorithm27based on linear graph theory . Using the theorem on

multi terminal representation, the modified bus imped­ance matrix due to changes in the network Was obtained by deriving the impedance representation of the modified network, taking the Lagrangian tree with ground as reference, as the terminal graph. When certain elements in the network are mutually coupled, it is necessary in this algorithm that the coupled group should be added as

Page 3: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

16

a Whole and not one element at a time. Por removal of elements from coupled group, a two step procedure will be required. In the first step the coupled group should be removed as a whole and in the second step . the elements that are not to be removed should be added.

The existing algorithms do not effectively utilize the topology of the network and cannot deal with the effects of mutual coupling satisfactorily. Besides, the presence of phase shifting component is ignored except in reference 23. It is therefore desirable to have a comprehensive and generalised algorithm which does not have the drawbacks discussed above and yet is based on firm topological considera­tions. This chapter is devoted to the development of such an algorithm.

2.2 SOME USEFUL RESULTS PROM GRAPH THEORY

The bus impedance matrix of a network depends on the parameters of the elements that constitute the network and the network topology. The parameters of the elements are given by the primitive impedance matrix and the bus incidence matrix gives the complete information as to how the elements are interconnected. Some pertinent results of linear graph theory are briefly reviewed below.

Page 4: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

17

!Dhe elements of the bus incidence matrix A

are defined as follows?

alJ = +1 If the element corresponding to the Jth

column is incident to the feus corresponding to.

the ith row and is directed away from it.

ai3 “ el®®®n,fc corresponding to the Jth

column is incident to the bus corresponding

to the ith row and is directed towards it.

aii = 0 if element corresponding to the Jth

column is not incident to the bus corresponding

to the ith row.

For a network with N buses and e elements the bus

incidence matrix A is of dimension N-l x *, the trow esasresponding<t© the reference bus being deleted.

29Consider an oriented connected graph for

which A is the bus incidence matrix. Let v#i be

the element voltage and current vectors and Vgus,

Igus be the bus voltage and current vectors,29W v, i and A are then related aa

Tv = A Y.Bias

Bus A i(2.1)(2.2)

T .where A is the transpose of A. If y denotes the

primitive admittance matrix, i.e. i = y v, then from (2.1) and (2.2), the well known expression for bus

admittance matrix is obtained as

Bus = A y A (2.3)

Page 5: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

18

2.3 PRELIMINARY RESULTS USEFUL FOR THE DEVELOPMENTLet zoi Aq and Zg^o) be the primitive impedance

matrix, bus incidence matrix and bus impedance matrix respectively of the partial network shown in Figure 2.1.

FIGURE 2.1: Partial network(Interconnections are not shown).

When certain modifications such as switching in andout of certain line(s) in the network are made, we

would like to know the modified bus impedance matrixZ_ of the new network in terms of L , nus Bus (o)

For the partial network, using (2.3) we have

ZBus(o) “ YBus(o) = £Ao zoo Ao 3 (2.4)

Suppose element a having self impedance zaa and mutual impedance zQa with the elements of the partial network,

Page 6: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

19

is added to the partial network. For the new network, the element voltages and currents are . deaofceddbjr

where vq and iQ are the element voltage and current vectors of elements in the partial network, v and

ia are the eleaent voltage and current corresponding to the element a.

The primitive equations in the impedance form are

V zoo zQCC

1—otl!_

V zao Zaa vu wThe inverse form of (2.5) is given by

io oo y0a~ V'*« fa**- M

yao 7<UC vau. —1

In (2.5) and (2.6) zQQf yQQ are matrices, zQa, zao> yQa, yaQ are vectors and zaa, yaa are scalars. Using (2.5) and (2.6) the primitive equations in mixed form^

can be expressed as

(2.7)

Page 7: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

20

Prom the discussion in the previous section, for the new network

A1 V,Bus (2.8)

where A is the bus incidence matrix of the With these preliminaries we now proceed to

(2.9)

new network, the specific

cases.

2.4 ADDITION OP LUffKfS)

Let element a he added between buses p and q with the orientation from p to q as shown in figure 2.2.

FIGURE 2.2: Near network due to addition of a link

Page 8: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

21

In this case no new bus is created. The bus incidence matrix A for the new network can be partitioned as

* [a0 : ^3 (2.10)

where ® submatrix of the bus incidence matrix corresponding to the added element. Subscripts p and q in (2,10) refer to the pth row and the qth row

respectively. essentially shows how the new element is incident to the partial network. Making use of (2.10) in (2.8) and (2.9), for the new network,

the bus variables and primitive variables are related

as

A =

f 0

0A.o i

»

♦ •I 0

aAo *0 + % *«

A ^ v o Bus

jr ® w*1 VBus •*3 us

(2.11)(2,12)(2.13)

For the new network, the primitive equations in mixed form are as shown in (2.7). Now to get an explicit

relation between ?gug and IBug the other variables vQ, iQ, va and ia are to be eliminated from the set of equations (2.7), (2.11), (2.12) and (2.13).

Page 9: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

22

Elimination of vQ, iQ and va from the above set of

equation gives** -IT

A_ z** A*0 00 0 ^l^o yoa ^aa VBus*b«7

*(% +^aa ^ao ^o ^ y “1Jaa hi _

ss0

(2.14)

Symbolically (2.14) can be written as%

B11 B12 M— —.vBus Bus1 sc .

_B21 B22_ ia 0.(2.15)

Finally eliminating the variable ±a from the above equation

[B11 " B12 ®22-1 B2l^ VBus * l̂US

(2.16)

From the above equation, the bus impedance matrix of the new network can be written as

ZBus B12 B22 1 (2.17)

To evaluate the inverse on the right hand side of(2.17), Householder's special matrix inversion formula^

given by[F+G H K]-1 = F^1 - F”1 GCH**1 + K F"*1 G]**1 K F”1

can be used. This gives(2.18)

ZBus ' B11 1+B11 1 B12^"B21 B11 1 B +B-]% Bn-112^22(2.19)

Page 10: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

23

Making use of (2.4) it is observed

Bn i *"1 = [A zJ1 A^]"1 = .11 o oo o ** Bus(o)

Hence the expression for Zg^ reduces to

ZBus * ZBus(o) “ hu&(o) C12 D 1 °21 ^usCo)

whereAo »oa

C,„ * K« +12 1 yactv A

p _ v- T a. o°21 ~ *1 + yJ aa

^us^'21 “Bus"'7 12 yaa

(2.20)

(2.21)

(2.22)

(2.23)

(2.24)

When there is no mutual coupling between the

added element and the elements in the partial network

both y and y become null vectors and hence the bus oa ao

impedance matrix of the new network is given by

JBus Bus(o)

Wo) *1 glT Wo)

K1 . ZBus(o) % + zaa(2.25)

where zaa is the primitive impedance of the added element.

It is to be noted that C^g and Cg^ in (2.22) and

(2.23) need not be the transpose of each other. When the

element considered is a phase shifting component,T Tyoa 4 yao and hence C12 j C21 . Phase shifting components

such as delta-wye transformer, tap changing transformer with

Page 11: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

24

complex turns ratio etc. can fee represented fey V-equivalents^ . The primitive admittance matrix of

the phase shifting component is a 2 x 2, unsymmetrie

and singular matrix. The presence of such unsymmetry

in the primitive admittance matrix will make the feus

impedance matrix unsymmetrie. So far in our develop­

ment no assumption has feeen made regarding the

symmetry of the primitive impedance and the feus

impedance matrices. Hence (2.21) and (2.25) are

applicafele even when the added element is a phase

shifting component. However, the singular nature ef

the primitive admittance matrix calls for a special computational procedure^ while adding a phase shift­

ing component. This is illustrated in the example 4

in Section 2.9.

In the subsequent discussion of this section it is assumed that the added element is not a phase

shifting component.

Addition of a link with mutual coupling

Since the added element is not a phase shiftingm

component, yQa = yao and hence (2.21) is simplified as

7-7 _ ^UBto) °1 °1 ZBus(o)ZBus ZBus(o) -r----------- ~ ~ } <2-26>

°i zbus(o)ci+'1/wwhere

A yn - v j. 0 0<x°1 ~ *1 + yJaa

(2.27)

Page 12: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

25

Addition of a link with no~mutual coupling

When there is no mutual coupling between the added link and the elements in the partial network (2,26) reduces to

7 = 7^ . v ZBus(o) \ ZSus(o) (n .% ^BusCo) + Zaa

where zaa is the primitive impedance of the added element.

As a special case, if the added link is between the reference bus and the bus q, then vector reduces to

K1 (2.29)

This vector has to be used in the appropriate equations.

Addition of links with mutual coupling

When a number of links are added at a time, following a similar procedure, we get

ZBuS - *80.(0) - ZBUS(0) °1 C1T *80.(0) (2-30)

where the matricesS = °1T ZBue(o) °1 + yaa*1 <2-^

Page 13: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

26

C1 - % + Ao yoain which is the .bus incidence matrix correspondingto the added links. Further, it is to be noticed thaty_ and y_ are now matrices obtained from (2,6).

oce aceAddition of links with no mutual coupling

When the added links are not mutually coupled with any element in the partial network, (2.30) reduces to

ZBus * ZBus(o) "'^BubCo) K1 25 K1 ZBus(o)

wherez = K, Z , . JL, + z1 j3us (o) 1 T aa

(2.33)

(2.34)

in which zaa is the primitive impedance matrix of the added elements.

2.5 ADDITION OF BRANCH(ES)

Let element a be added at the bus p creating a new bus q with the orientation from p to q as shown in Figure 2.3. The bus. incidence matrix for the new network is given by

A *

1 0 1 :

A.

0

i 01 1I 1 0

-410 ( -1

(2.35)

Page 14: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

27

FIGURE 2.3: New network due to addition of a' branch.

Defining

(2.36)

(2.37)

let Vs(o)’ Wo) be the bus varlables for the P®1-*181network and V _ , I _ be the bus variables for theq Bus q Busnewly created bus q. Then the bus variables VL andBusI for the new network can be written as Bus

Page 15: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

28

VBus(o) ■^Bus(o)

V =vBus\BUS

; ^US =

Xq Busi

Subst itut ing (2 .37) and (2.^6) in (2,8) and (2.9)# we

get

voTAo ^Bus(o) (2.39)

va = E2 ¥Bus(o) Vq Bus

(2.40)

Ao xa + K2 ia “ IBus(c>) (2.41)

•^a "*Xq Bus (2.42)

Again the primitive equation for the new network is

given by (2.7). To obtain the relation between Vx5USand Vs’ other tables T0, i0> and i„ are to be

eliminated from the set of equations (2.7)* (2.39) to

(2.42). After eliminating these variables, we get

-1 TAz A_0 oo 0~(^2+Ao^oa^aa ^ VBus(o)

mm"XBus(o)

tv T “1 a T\_2(K2 +*aa yaoAo > -1”^aa _ -Jq Bus__ -V_ q Bus_

(2.43)

Rearranging (2.43) to express vBus(0) and

explicitly in terms of IBus(0) and I^.^g and making

use of (2.20), we get

Page 16: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

29

V , xBus(o) Z , VBus(o) ZBus(o)^12 "'‘Bus (o)

V „__ q Bus_ ^21^8(0) D21ZBus(o)D12+ y^ *q Bus

(2.44)where

A« yrtiVTV * 7 j, Q -Off-Dia K2 + -y^“TV - K T 4- ygQ A°D21 " K2 + y,

(2.45)

(2.46)oca

Hence the bus impedancejof the new network is given by

JBus^Bus (o) ZBus(o) D12

D21ZBus(o) D21ZBus(o)D12 + yaa

(2.47)

where D^2 and are as given by (2.45) and (2.46).

When there is no mutual coupling between the added element and the elements in the partial network, the bus impedance matrix of the new network is computed from

JBusJBus(o) ZBus(o) K2

*2* ZBus(o) K2TzBus(o)E2 + zaa (2.48)

where zaa is the primitive impedance of the addedelement.

It should be noted that D-^ and in (2.45) and (2.46) need not be the transpose of each other.

Page 17: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

30

Expressions (2.47) and (2.48) are very general

expressions which can he used even if the added element is a phase shifting component. In the subsequent discussion it is assumed that the added

element is not a phase shifting component.

Addition of a branch with mutual coupling

Since the added element is not a phase shifting component, yoa = yaQT and hence (2.47) reduces to

husJBus(o) ZBus(o) C2

°2 ZBus(o) C2TzBus(o)C2 + yact

wheren = K + -^oa °2 2 + y

Jaa

(2.49)

(2.50)Addition of a branch with no mutual coupling

. When there is no mutual coupling between theadded element and the elements in the partial network

f(2.49) simplifies as

BusJBus (o) ^US ( 0 ) K,K2TzBus(o) K2 ZBus(o)K2+zaa

(2.51)

where zaa is the primitive impedance of the added element.

As a special case, the added branch may be from the reference bus. In such a case the vector

Page 18: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

31

reduces to a null vector. This null vector has to be

used in the appropriate equations.

Addition of branches with mutual coupling

Similar procedure can be followed when a

number of branches are added at a time. In such a

case.

JBus

JBus(o) ZBus(o) C2

°2IzBus(o) 02TiWo)02+yaa'1(2.52)

where the matrix

C2 " E2 + Ao yoa y -1 ■aa 4-524 1

(2.53)

in which is the submatrix of the bus incidence

matrix corresponding to the added branches. Further

it is to be noticed ■

obtained from (2.6).

it is to be noticed that y and y„ are now matricesoa aa

Addition of branches with no mutual coupling

♦When the added branches are not mutually

coupled with any element in the partial network,

(2.52) reduces toZBus(o) ZBus(o) K2

JBus.K2 ZBus(o) K2*ZBus(o)K2 + zaa

(2.54)

in which zaa is the primitive impedance matrix of the

added elements.

*(>

Page 19: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

32

2.6 REMOVAL OP LINK(S)

Removal of a link with mutual couplingRemoval of a link from a network makes the

•self and mutual admittances corresponding to the element "being removed as zero and hence can be simulated by adding a fictitious link in the network. This fictitious link has self and mutual admittance as the negative of those of the link to be removed and the mutual admittance between the fictitious link and the link to be removed as zero. To add this fictitious link, the algorithm for addition of a link can be used.

Because of the zero mutual coupling betweenthe fictitious link and the link to be removed, itis to be noticed that the product of the bus incidence

*matrix of the network and the mutual admittance vector corresponding to the fictitious element is equal to

network with element a removed and y is the vectoroaShowing the mutual admittance between element a andthe other elements in the network. Furthermore, theself admittance of the fictitious element is -y •aaTherefore the vector can still be computed from (2.27). Thus when a link a is*removed from the net­work whose bus impedance matrix is Z£Ug(0)r the modified bus impedance matrix ZgUj5 is given by

*-Aoyoa where Aq is the bus incidence trix of the

Page 20: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

bUS7 - ^Bus(o) ^1 ^Bus(o)SusCo) “ 2 C -fl /v )

C1 ZBus(o) C1(2.55)

33

where%

Ao yoa yaa

(2.56)

Removal of a link with no mutual couplingIf the link to he removed is not mutually

coupled with any other element in the network, (2.55) reduces to

5?7,-7 - ZBus(o) K1 K1 husjo)i3us “ ^Bus(o) m

K1 ZBus(o) K1 ” zaa(2.57)

where 2(xa is the primitive impedance of the element to he removed.

Removal of links with mutual couplingThe algorithm for removal of links can he

derived along the similar line and is given hy

ZBue " ZBus(o) - *Bua(o) °1 ^ «L* <2-58>where

2 = °1T ZBus(o) °1 - ^aa'1 <2-59)

°1 * h + Ao yoa yaa'1 <2-60>

in which y_ is the matrix obtained from (2.6). Further,aa

it is to he noticed that K-. and y in (2.60) are no• OCXlonger vectors hut are matrices.

Page 21: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

34

Removal of links with, no mutual coupling

When the links to he removed are not mutually

coupled with any element in the partial network,

(2.58) reduces to

ZBus * ZBus(o) * Wo) *1 ^ *1 ZBus(o) <2-61> where

fi = V Wo) *1 - z«« 1 (2-62)in which zaa is the primitive impedance matrix of the

links to he removed.

2.7 HINTS FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ALGORITHM

The following remarks Serve to clarify the

implementation of the algorithm for numerical problems.

Consider the case of addition of a link. If the

*dded element has no mutual coupling, the vector yoa

becomes a null vector. In such a case, while computing

A0 yoa the hue incidence matrix A„ need not he consi-

dered at all. If the added element is mutually coupled,

then it is enough to consider the elements in the

coupled group alone since the components of yQa corres­

ponding to the elements that are not in the coupled

group are zero. While computing AQ 7oar reduced yQa

vector denoted by yQa and reduced AQ matrix denoted

by Aq can be used. The rows of yQa and the columns«na»

of Aq correspond to the elements having mutual coupling

with the added element a. The order of the matrix to

Page 22: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

55¥

■be inverted to find yQa and yaa is now limited to the number of elements in the coupled group. All these remarks are applicable not only for the case of addition of a link but also for all other cases dis­cussed.

A word of caution is necessary regarding the orientations of the elements and the sign of the mutual impedances in the primitive impedance matrix of the coupled group. In circuit theory the proper dot convention is normally followed to specify the sign of mutual impedances. But in power systems mutual coupling arises w|ien two transmission lines

* 'V»run in parallel for a cirisiderable distance. The sign of mutual impedance depends on the orientations assigned to them in the oriented graph. If the elements have alike orientations, then the mutual impedance will have positive value and if the elements have opposite orientations then the corresponding mutual impedance will have negative value.

All these points are brought out in the numeri­cal examples given in the Section 2.9.

2.8 SPECIAL CASES Removal of radial line

When an element corresponding to a radial line is removed one bus gets isolated and the number of buses in the network is reduced by one. From (2.49)

Page 23: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

36

14t can be inferred that the modified bus impedance matrix due to removal of radial line can be obtained from the original bus impedance matrix by simply deleting the row and column corresponding to the isolated bus. If the isolated bus is the reference bus itself, then the bus impedance matrix of the new network is indefinite.

Isolated bus

When a set of elements are removed, some buses may become- isolated. For example let us assume that when r numbers of elements are removed, one bus becomes isolated. Iheh; from these r elements, it is possible to pick out ^elements which on removal will maintain the network graph as connected one. Removing these r-1 elements first, ty using the removal of links algorithm, the bus impedance matrix is modified. In this resulting bus impedance matrix, the row and column corresponding to the bus which would become isolated is now deleted to get the final modified bus impedance matrix due to the removal of all the r elements*

Parameter changes

When the parameter of an element is changed, the bus impedance matrix can be modified by simultane­ously removing the element with the old parameter and adding an element with the revised parameter. Ihis

Page 24: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

particular case has been illustrated through the

numerical example 2 in the following section.

2.9 NUMERICAL EXAMPLES

The networks that are considered in the first

three numerical examples are taken from reference 32

Example 1-

Consider the network shown in Figure 2.4,

whose line impedances are marked in the figure. The

bus impedance matrix of this network, is

1 2 3.4

1 0.0862 0.0372 0.0319 0.0660

2 0.0372 0.2074 0.1064 0.0532

3 0.0319 0.1064 0.2340 0.1170

4 0.0660 0.0532 0.1170 0.2085

Calculate the modified bus impedance matrix

when the line f is removed.

Solution:

It is to be noticed that the element f ‘lias

mutual coupling with the element d which?has mutual■m

coupling with the element e. Thus the coupled group

to be considered consists of elements d, e and f.

Let us assume the orientations of the elements d, e

and f as shown in the oriented graph in Figure 24>.

Then the primitive impedance matrix of the coupled

group is

Page 25: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

38

14 3

FIGURE 2.4: Network of example 1.

e

*

* k#

*

Page 26: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

39

d e f

d 0.4 0.1 -0.2

e 0.1 0.2 0.0

f -0.2 0.0 0.3

Taking the inverse of this, the primitive admittance

matrix of the coupled group is obtained as

d

e

f

Therefore

oa

d

4-6153

■2.3077

3.0769

3.0769

,^1.5385,

e f

-2.3077 3.0769

6.1538 -1.5385

-1.5385 5.3846

’’ yaa " 5-3846

Further, from the oriented graph shown in Figure 2.5

1 1" ~0~

-1 0 0—

0 0; % «

1

0 -1 f» H

Now substituting yQa, yaa, AQ and in (2.56)1

T** —90 1

*

*

r— -a» 1 1

■■ mr.c

*n;•*+w -*■

0.286.

0 1 -1 0 “3.0769 -0.576

1+ 5.3846 «

0 0 ■ -1.5385 ,1.*0♦

-1*-* -mA ' 0 -1mm*

-0.714

Page 27: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

40*

Substituting the given Zgu8(0) and the calculated yaa and C1 in (2.55)> the modified bus impedance matrixis computed as

1 2 3 41 0.09 0.05 0.0 0.082 0.05 0.25 0.0 0.15

z =Bus ^ 0.0 0.0 0.5 0.04 0.08 0.15 0.0 0.26

Example 2For the network given in example 1, calculate

the modified bus impedance matrix when the self impedance of the line f is changed from 0.3 to 0.24 and also the mutual impedance between the lines d and f is changed from 0.2 to 0.0.

SolutionsThis case can be treated as simultaneous

removal of the line f with old impedance value (which can be viewed as the addition of fictitious link) and the addition of a line f' with new impedance yalue. ,Thus this belongs to the case of addition of Itfiks ,

*with mutual coupling. The orientations of the elements * in the coupled group are now assumed. Figure 2*6 shows the oriented graph. Then the primitive impedance matrix of the coupled group is

Page 28: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

41f •

d e f t*'

'd ^0.4 0.1 -0.2 0,0e 0.1 0.2 0.0 0.0f -0.2 0.0 0.3 0.0f' 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.24

Inverting this, the primitive admittance matrixthe coupled group is obtained as

d e f f •d *-4.6153 -2.3077 3.0769 0.0

e -2.3077 6.1538 -1.5585 0.0f 3.0769 -1.5385 5.3846 0.0f * 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.1667

Remembering that f is the element to be removed, now v. c have- ♦ * "

“^3.0769 0.0 "-5.3846 0.0yoa 1.5385 0.0

•9 0.0 4.1667

Also fr^m’ the Oriented graph shown in Figure 2.6,

Page 29: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

42

Ao =

• [HP**- **•

r 1 0 0-l 0

ti

M 0 0

0 0 1 1

0 -1 -1 -1mm*. --- mmm

For this case

-1aa

-0.186 0.0

0.0 0.240

Substituting the values of yoa, y„e' , A0 end ^ in (2.32)

Ci -

0.2855 0.0>0.5715 0.01.0 1.0■0.7140 -1.0

-1Knowing zgue(0)» 0^ and yaa 9 irom (2*3l) z is obtainedas

Z as

Hence

a-iz

•0.0369 0.1428

0.1428 0.4485

-12.230 3.890

3.890 1.007

Page 30: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

43

Finally substituting the values of given andcalculated and z“^ in (2,30) the modified bus

impedance matrix is obtained as

1 2 3 41 0.0836 0.0420 0.0400 0.05922 0.0420 0.2400 0.5000 0.07403 0.0400 0,5000 0.2500 0.13004 0.0592 0.0740 0.1300 0.1920

mm

Example 5

Hie bus impedance matrix of the network shown in Figure 2.7 is

1 2 3 41 0.0831 0.0414 0.0430 0.0570*

2 0.0414 0.2392 0.0538 0.07213 0.0430 0.0538 0.2312 0.13974 0.0570 0.0721 0.1397 0.1810

Calculate the modified bus impedance matrix when the lines d and g are removed. Values that are marked in the figure are impedances.

*Solution:This case belongs to the removal of links with

mutual coupling discussed in Section 2.6, It is to be noticed that the element d is coupled with element e and the element g is coupled with element f. Hence

Page 31: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

44

elements d and g as a group have mutual coupling with

elements e and f. let us assume the orientations of the coupled elements d, e, f and g as shown in the oriented graph in Figure 2.8. The primitive impedance

FIGURE 2.7: Network of example 3-

FIGURE 2.8: Oriented graph of example %

Page 32: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

45

matrix of the coupled group is

d e f gd

MM*w

0.4 0.1 0.0 0.0 ~

e 0.1 0.2 OOO 0.0f 0.0 0.0 0.24 0.1g 0.0 0.0 0.1 0.24

Inverting this, the primitive admittance matrix of the coupled group is obtained as

d e f gd 2.85 71 -1.4286 0.0 0.0e -1.4286 5.7143 0.0 0.0f 0.0 0.0 5.0420 -2.1008g 0.0 0.0 -2.1008 5.0420

Therefore""-1.4286 0.0 "2.8571 0.0

J =0.0 -2.1008 0.0 5.0420

Prom the oriented graph shown in Figure 2.8

~i o~ ~1 0 ~0 0 -1 0; Kj =0 1 0 1

1 H 1 H 0 -1——- —ft

Page 33: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

46

For this case

-1acc

0.3504 0,0

0.0 0*1987-1Substituting the values of AQ, yQa and yaa * in

(2.60)

0.5 0.01.0 0.00.0 0.5820.5 •-0.582

and y -1

obtained as

Hence

z

•0.12867 -0.00721

■0.00721 -0.15170

-7.800 0.37l"

0*371 -6.620

Finally substituting the values of the given 2gue(0) and the calculated and in (2.58), we get the modified bus_ impedance matrix as

Bus

0.0904 0.0 0.0481 0.07110.0 0.4998 0

•0 0.0

0.0481 0.0 0.2596 0.14420.0711 0.0 0.1442 0.2129

Page 34: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

47

Example 4Construct the bus impedance matrix of the

*37 *38network shown in Figure 2.5r * , which contains aphase shifting component. The values marked in the figure are impedances.

Let us create bus 3 such that element having impedance of 0.07+30.1 be between buses 1 and 3 and the phase shifting component be between buses 3 and 2. Knowing the transformation ratio (t = 0.6) and the angle of phase shift (9 * 30°), the V-equivalent of the phase shifting component^'J shown in Figure 2.10 can be obtained. The primitive admittance matrix corresponding to the elements d and e is computed as follows:

d e d ey32 _hz~ d 7.650-314.36 -8.30+15.17t2 CD1

y32mm mmmmbmm

t/ei*.

y32 e 0.333+3 9.778 2.76-35.16

Now the bus impedance matrix of the network can be constructed as follows:

Step 1: Add the element between the buses 0 and 1.1

ZBus * 1 C i-0^0-0 J

Page 35: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

48

FIGURE 2.9: Network of example 4.

3 2

FIGURE 2.10: V-equivalent of the phase shifting component.

Page 36: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

49

Step 2: Add the element between the buses 1 and 2,1 2 l.O+JO.O l.O+jO.Ol.O+jO.O 1.06+jO.20

Step 3s Add the element between the buses 1 and 312 3

"l.O+jO.O l.O+jO.O l.O+jO.O

Bus

123

l.O+jO.O 1.06+j0.2 l.O+jO.O1.0+30.0 1.0+30.Q 1.07+30.1

Step 4: Add the element d (Figure 2.10).

This is a link between buses 0 and 3# and it has no mutual coupling with the partial network.Since the primitive admittance matrix corresponding to elements d and e is singular, the self impedance of the element d is infinity. Adding a link of infinite impedance will not cause any change in the bus impedance

matrix. Thus Zgu remains same as calculated in step 3.

Step 5; Add the element e (Figure 2.10).

This is a link which has unsymmetric mutual couplings with the element d in the partial network. For this case

1 “0“" > 1 0Kl" 2 1 f A0 = ^ 0

3 0 3 _JL_

Page 37: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

50

yQa = -8.3+35.17

yao = 0.333+j9.778

yaa *= 2.76-35.16

Substituting these values in (2.22), (2.23) and (2.24)

C12

0.0+30.0 1.0+30.0 4..44-jO. 832

°21 ® CO.O+jO.O -1.0-30.0 1.44-30.832]

D *= 1.2361+30.6264

Now from (2.21) ZBug is computed as

Bus

0.4222+30.29530.5601+30.25700.2827+30.3048

0.3777+30.43090.5912+30.56520.2179+30.4634

0.3521+30.17480.4998+30.16570.2789+30.2545

Step 6: Add the element between the buses 0 and 2.

This is a link with no mutual coupling. For

this case

oca O.O+31.O

Substituting these values in (2,28)

Page 38: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

511

zBus0.2117+JO.28020.2589+j0.2620

3 0.1057+JO.2398

2

0.1202+JO.3207 0.2112+JO.4409 0.0240+jO.3051

30.1719+jO.1818 0.2445+JO.1982 0.1225+JO.215 9_

Deleting the row and column corresponding to the hue 3>the additional bus that has been created, the busimpedance matrix of the given network is obtained as

1 2 0.2117+JO. 2802 0.1202+JO. 3207*"

0.2589+JO.2620 0.2112+jO.4409

2.10 CONCLUSIONSIn this chapter a generalised bus impedance

algorithm has been developed based on certain funda­mental concepts of graph theory. The bus incidence matrix which shows how various elements are inter­connected is essentially used at various stages. In other words this development exploits the topology of the network. The merits of this algorithm are summarised below.

i) In contrast to the algorithm given in reference 29^ the present algorithm for the addition of a link needs only one step instead of a two step procedure.

ii) Mutual couplings between the elements of the network do not pose any problem either at the addition or removal stage.

Page 39: shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.inshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/74028/10/10_chapter 2.pdf · /0 1 213456 25 6 % #' # # $ ) &' $# % # ! & # ) $ - !' $ )# $ ! % # , $# 7. Created

52

iii) The algorithm is amenable for the addition

of link and branch either one at a time or in groups.

iv) The algorithm is comprehensive so as to

include the effects of phase shifting components,

changes in network parameters etc*