20th Century Hermeneutic Phenomenology for the Human Sciences and Practical Disciplines

8/14/2019 20th Century Hermeneutic Phenomenology for the Human Sciences and Practical Disciplines

1/22

Dcopkjke ipah }uck}jc}b lck}spz bcphckcs}jl ~bckahckadaez iap }bc bshok |ljcklc|

okm ~pol}jlod mj|lj~djkc|

Lahhakodj}jc| opc mpouk ipah ijyc fcz }bjkfcp| jk }uck}jc}b lck}spz ~bckahckadaez jk

hofjke o pc}spk }a apjejkod ojh| }a eo}bcp }bcjp lak}pj`s}jak| okm pc(~pc|ck} }bch iap

lak}ch~apopz ~pagcl}|+ Jk |bap}$ j} j| opescm }bo} ~bckahckadaez lok akdz a~cpo}c o|

bcphckcs}jl ~bckahckadaez+ Bcphckcs}jl| opa|c uj}bjk Ecphok jmcodj|h+ J} `ceok uj}b

Ipjcmpjlb O|} okmBcjkpjlb \lbdcjcpholbcp okm uo| isp}bcp mcycda~cm `z Ujdbcdh Mjd}bcz$

Hop}jk Bcjmceecp okm a}bcp|+ Bcphckcs}jl| ldojh| }bo} }bcpc j| ~pjap skmcp|}okmjke }bo} j|

}ofck }a okz kcu |j}so}jak jk lpco}jke lsppck} skmcp|}okmjke+ \slb jkj}jod skmcp|}okmjke j|

jh~ap}ok} `clos|c j} |c}| o mjpcl}jak okm |la~c iap jkqsjpz ap ol}jak+ ]bc jkj}jod

skmcp|}okmjke hoz laklcpk ubo} okm bau }bjke| opc `cdjcycm }a crj|} ap ka} crj|}+

\s`|cqsck} }bjkfjke okm ol}jak opc ò|cm ak ubo} bo| `cck `cdjcycm+ Jk |ahc lo|c|$ ubo}

hoz pc|sd} j| }bc iod|c lakijpho}jak ai }bc apjejkod jkollspo}c skmcp|}okmjke+ Iap }bc|c

pco|ak|$ j} j| jh~ap}ok} }a `c ldcop oàs} ubo} okm bau jkj}jod skmcp|}okmjke| opc homc jk

~bckahckadaez okm bau }bo} jkiaph| }bc Bs||cpdjok ~bckahckadaez ai jk}ck}jakodj}z okm

ch~jpjlod ~bckahckadaez+

Aycpyjcu

]bj| ijp|} |cl}jak ~payjmc| ok aycpyjcu ai }bc opeshck} ~payjmcm jk }bc pchojkmcp ai }bc

~o~cp+ ]bcpc j| o qsc|}jak oàs} }bc mcepcc }a ubjlb okz pc|coplb$ jkldsmjke ~bckahckadaez

ai okz |ap} lok `c ~pc|s~~a|j}jakdc||+ Bs||cpd| ~bckahckadaez uo| o }bcapc}jlod |}smz iap

~bjda|a~bz okm okz ch~jpjlj|h `z skmcp|}okmjke lak|ljas|kc||+ ]bc ~bjda|a~bjlod

~bckahckadaez ai lak|ljas|kc|| jk j}| pcod uapdm ~|zlbadaejlod iaph$ ap }bc }pok|lckmck}od

|}smz ai hcokjke jk o ~s`djl uapdm$ à}b ojh }a ijkm }bc jkyopjok} ko}spc ai lak|ljas|

cr~cpjcklc+ Bs||cpd| hc}bam uapfcm ak }bc pou mo}o ai }bc hokz la(allsppjke }z~c| ai

lak|ljas| |ck|c|$ jk apmcp }a lakldsmc ak }bc ko}spc ai }bc iaph| ai jk}ck}jakodj}z }bo} opc

lpco}jyc ai }bch "Hopòlb$ ?::0*+ Iap Bs||cpd$ }bc mpcoh uo| kcycp aycp }bo} }pok|lckmck}od

~bckahckadaez okm j}| kak(~op}jlj~o}jke ak daafcp| lasdm lakldsmc ak }bc }ps}b oàs}

lak|ljas|kc|| "?:39!?:5>$ ~~+


2/22

aycplahc }bc yjljas| ljpldc+ \~cljijloddz$ ko}spod |ljcklc lokka} lak}pj`s}c }a epaskmjke

j}|cdi$ `clos|c }a ma |a j| }a `c jkyadycm jk o yjljas| ljpldc$ "?:??!?:2?o$ ~+ ?50*+ Jk }bj|

lo|c$ }bc yjljas| ljpldc j| `cjke ch~jpjloddz pcdo}jyj|}jl7 ]bc o||sh~}jak }bo} akdz

cr~cpjhck}odj|h lok ijkm }bc }ps}b oàs} okz ho}}cp+ ]bc ~|zlbadaejlod jh~ol} j| }bo} odd ai

djic allsp| }bpaseb yopjas| }z~c| ai ouopckc|| oàs} a`gcl}| }bo} ~pamslc| mjiicpck} |ck|c| ai

}bch }bo} lok `c epo|~cm jk yopjas| lak}cr}| ( cyck ji }ba|c lak}cr}| opc jk}cp~pc}jyc akc| ai

skmcp|}okmjke ap `c }bcz ~cplc~}sod ap ~|zlbadaejlod lak}cr}| uj}b pc|~cl} }a }bc lak}cr} jk

qsc|}jak+ O ~pa~cp cr~doko}jak jk ~pol}jlc okm }bcapz laklcpk| hofjke cr~doko}jak| jk }cph|

ai jk}ck}jakodj}jc| jk cr~dojkjke bau o hchapz cr~cpjck}joddz la(allsp| jk }bc ~cplc~}sod

~pc|ck}$ iap jk|}oklc+

Baucycp$ Go|~cp|$ Bcjmceecp$ Hcpdcos(âk}z okm Pjlacsp mjm ka} oepcc uj}b }bc ldojh }bo}

}pok|lckmck}od ~bckahckadaez lasdm aycp}bpau }bc ljpldc `c}ucck }bc ojh(~payjmjke

~pa`dch| o| ai j}| hc}bam| `clos|c o lcp}ojk daejlod bophakz `c}ucck }bc esjmjke

~pa`dch|+++ okm ~pclj|cdz |slb iaskmo}jak| okm hc}bam| crj|}| "Bs||cpd$ ?:??!?:2?o$ ~+

?2:*+ Jk oepcchck} uj}b }bc|c upj}cp|$ }bj| ~o~cp opesc| }bo} okz jkqsjpz ap |ljcklc lok akdz

`c bcphckcs}jl jk }bc |ck|c }bo} j} |basdm `c |cdi(pcidcrjyc jk skmcp|}okmjke ubo} j} }ofc| }a

j}| |s`gcl} ho}}cp okm bau j} hofc| |ck|c+ J} spec| lak}ch~apopz uapfcp| jk ch~jpjlod

~bckahckadaez okm ~|zlbadaez }a }ofc bccm ai ubo} }bc bcphckcs}jl ljpldc hcok|7 }bo} }bcpc

opc ka sk~pcgsmjlcm yjcu|+ ^pjap yjcu| boyc jkidscklc okm hoz`c cyck lpco}c ubo} j| iaskm

`z }bc hcok| ai }bc hamc ai o}}ck}jak }a }bc a`gcl} ai |}smz+ Ji }bc ~pa~a|j}jak ai }bc

bcphckcs}jl ljpldc j| ollc~}cm$ }bck j} j| oepccm }bo} }bo} j} j| jh~a||j`dc }a cpomjlo}c }bc

jkidscklc ai }bc ~o|} ak skmcp|}okmjke+ ]bj| j| ~op}jlsdopdz ~pa`dcho}jl ubck j} lahc| }a

hofjke laklds|jak| jk ch~jpjlod ~bckahckadaez$ qsodj}o}jyc ap |ljck}jijl ~|zlbadaez okm

a}bcp }z~c| ai ch~jpjlod pc|coplb+

Jk apmcp }a |bau }bo} }bc|c ldojh| opc gs|}jijcm$ j} j| kclc||opz }a |jmc(|}c~ |ahc ck}pcklbcm

hj|(skmcp|}okmjke| oàs} ~bckahckadaez+ Bcpc ka lpj}jlj|h j| homc ai ch~jpjlod

~bckahckadaez iaddaujke }bc jkidscklc ai Espuj}|lb$ Lojpk|$ Ejapej$ Ucp}w$ Ch`pcc okm

a}bcp|+ Baucycp$ }bc|c lok odd `c ldo||jijcm o| a`gcl}(apjck}cm ch~jpjlod ~bckahckadaez+ Ok

crlds|jyc ials| ak }bc |ck|c ai a`gcl}| uo| kcycp Bs||cpd| ~pagcl} ai }bc |}smz ai djkf|

`c}ucck }bc iaph| ai jk}ck}jakodj}z$ }bc |ck|c| a`}ojkcm oàs} |~cljijl a`gcl}| ai o}}ck}jak$


3/22

okm skmcp|}okmjke bau }bc|c crj|} jk lak}cr}| ap bapjwak| "Bs||cpd$ ?:?(?(?3?$ ?:2>!0>>3*+ Lak|cqsck}dz$ Bs||cpdjok ~bckahckadaez uo| kcycp hcpcdz }bc

mc|lpj~}jak ai }bc |ck|c| ai a`gcl}| o| ok ckm jk j}|cdi+ Iap Bs||cpd$ }bc ~pjhopz ials| ak

jk}ck}jakodj}z uo| jh~cmcm `clos|c }bc ~bckahckadaejlod hc}bam+++ akdz dcom| s| ijp|} jk}a

o kcu koyc} }bo} ai |jh~dc mc|lpj~}jyc ol} okodz|j| }bo} bc |ahc}jhc| loddcm kac}jl

~bckahckadaez$ kac}jl|$ jk}ck}jakod okodz|j|$ jk}ck}jakod ~|zlbadaez$ cdsljmo}jak

ap cr~djlo}jak$ Os|dceske "|}o}cm `z Bs||cpd jk Oses|} ?:


4/22

]bc ha|} eckcpod lo|c ai }bc ~pa`dch ai }bc bcphckcs}jl ljpldc iap |ljcklc okm olomchjl

jkqsjpz j| }bo} }bc lsppck} a`gcl} j| skmcp|}aam ak }bc `o|j| ai }bc adm$ }a |slb o mcepcc }bo}

~o|} dcopkjke lok a`|lspc }bc lsppck} a`gcl}+ ]bc bcphckcs}jl ljpldc j| }bc }a(okm(ipa

haychck}+++ `c}ucck jk}cp~pc}jke jkmjyjmsod ~bckahcko okm jk}cp~pc}jke }bc ubadc }bo} j|

lbopol}cpj|}jl ai odd jk}cp~pc}o}jak$ "Pjlfhok$ 0>>=$ ~+ 5


5/22

lak|ljas| cr~cpjcklc|+ Bc ldojhcm }bo} }pok|lckmck}od ~bckahckadaez lok ec} as}|jmc ai }bc

bcphckcs}jl ljpldc+ @s} `clos|c Bs||cpd bcdm }bc ~a|j}jak loddcm }pok|lckmck}od jmcodj|h }bo}

j} j| kak|ck|c }a |~cof ai o iskmohck}oddz skfkauo`dc `cjke }bo} |}jdd djc| `czakm }bc|c

sd}jho}c|+++ V`clos|c ubo} lask}| j|X }bc lak|}j}s}jak ai `cjke jk lak|ljas|kc||$ odake uj}b

}bc pcdo}cm ~pa`dch| ai `cjke$ "Bs||cpd| dc}}cp }a Mjd}bcz ai 3 Gsdz$ ?:??$ ?:92!?:2?`$ ~+

0>5*+ J} j| ka} ldcop bau Bs||cpd aycplohc }bc ljplsdopj}z uj}bjk bj| auk ~pol}jlc okm }bcapz+

Bs||cpd od|a |}o}cm }bc iaddaujke jk akc |ck}cklc ubjlb j| }bc a~~a|j}c ai ubo} Bcjmceecp

lak}ckmcm7 Odd cr~cpjck}jod fkaudcmec ai djic j| pc|}pjl}cm `z }bc ~op}jlsdop pc|~cl}jyc djic(

~pol}jlc$ ubjlb ~pcmcdjkco}c| bau iop }bc mc}cphjkoljc| opc }a `c mc}cphjkcm jk omyoklc6

}bcapc}jlod jk}cpc|} okm |ljcklc opc ~pol}jloddz skjk}cpc|}cm okm }bcpc`z skdjhj}cmdz odd(

jklds|jyc jk }bcjp ials| "?:90!?:55$ =3$ ~+ ?50*+ Iap Bcjmceecp$ }bcapj|jke okm jk}cp~pc}jke

jkldsmc| o ~pol}jlc ai o |ap} o| mac| ~pol}jlc jkldsmc }bcapz ai o |ap}+ Bs||cpd| a`gcl} uo| }a

skmcp|}okm lak|ljas|kc|| eckcpoddz$ okm bj| hc}bam jkyadycm cdsljmo}jke bj| auk

lak|ljas|kc|| okm jhoejkjke }bc cr~cpjcklc| ai a}bcp ~cp|ak| "Bs||cpd$ ?:5

< ]bc o`jdj}z }a jhoejkc oka}bcp| cr~cpjcklc| j| djhj}cm ollapmjke }a }bc `pcom}b ai akc|

|aljod okm lsd}spod cr~cpjcklc|+

= ]bcpc j| mjiijlsd}z fkaujke ubo} |ap} ai bshok cr~cpjcklc }a jkldsmc okm bcklc bau }a

lo~}spc }bc ubadc ai o pcejak jk pcdo}jak }a j}| epco}cp ubadc|+ Bs||cpd ldo||cm

~bckahckadaez o| o }bcapz(hofjke ~palcmspc ka} ok ch~jpjlod akc+

Ycpz ~cp}jkck}dz iap Bs||cpdjok ~bckahckadaez$ }bcpc j| lakis|jak `c}ucck ojh| okm

hc}bam|$ ~op}jlsdopdz ubck }bcpc j| o ldojh }a `c ~pc|s~~a|j}jakdc||+ Bs||cpd |}o}cm o dosmo`dc


6/22

jmcod ubck bc upa}c }bo}7 ]bc }psc hc}bam iaddau| }bc ko}spc ai }bc }bjke| }a `c jkyc|}jeo}cm

okm ka} asp ~pcgsmjlc| okm ~pclaklc~}jak|$ "?:??!?:2?o$ ~+ ?5:*+ @s} }bc ~pa`dch j|

~pclj|cdz bau j| j} ~a||j`dc }a pchayc }bc jkidscklc ai }bc ~o|} okm jkyj|j`dc esjmjke

o||sh~}jak|$ okm alls~z o ~a|j}jak ai ka `jo| }auopm| }bc hcokjkeisd ~bckahcko ai

lak|ljas|kc||1 ]bj| dcoyc| ok skok|ucpcm qsc|}jak jk bj| uapf laklcpkjke }bc |cdi

skmcp|}okmjke ai }bc }pok|lckmck}odj|} ~bckahckadaej|} ap kak~op}jlj~o}jke akdaafcp uba

mac| ka} boyc }a o||cp} okz pcodj}jc| okm ~a||j`jdj}jc| uj}b pc|~cl} }a }bc ol}sod okm qso|j(

mo}o `cdakejke }a }bc Cea skmcpkco}b+ Ubo} bc o||cp}| jk }bj| pc|~cl} opc pcodj}jc| okm

~a||j`jdj}jc| jk qsa}o}jak hopf|$ "?:2>!0>>3$ }cr} 0>$ ~+ 9:5$ ik ?


7/22

bcphckcs}jl| j| }a oepcc }bo} j} j| ~a||j`dc }a lpco}c |lbaad| ai pc|coplb }bo} opc |cdi(pcidcrjyc

jk skmcp|}okmjke bau }bcz mpou }bcjp laklds|jak|+ ]bj| j| ollask}jke iap akc| auk

~cp|~cl}jyc jk }cph| ai bau hcokjke okm los|c opc lakldsmcm ak$ iap jk|}oklc+ ]bc padc ai

bcphckcs}jl| j| olomchjl }bcapc}jlod mj|lasp|c }auopm| }bc ojh ai |cdi(pcidcrjyj}z+

Bs||cpd| ~a|j}jyc dceolz

Kau }bo} }bc opeshck} ai }bj| ~o~cp bo| `cck ~pc|ck}cm jk isdd$ }bc pchojkmcp ai }bc ~o~cp

uapf| }a ~payjmc cyjmcklc iap j}| fcz ldojh|+ ]bc |cl}jak| `cdau |}op}| uj}b |ahc lahhck}|

ak }bc mc}ojd ai bcphckcs}jl| opc ~payjmcm+ \clakm$ j} j| ka}cm bau }bc ~bckahckadaejlod

haychck} mcycda~cm }auopm| bcphckcs}jl| okm hcokjke$ ouoz ipah }bc apjejkod ldojh }a `c

~pc|s~~a|j}jakdc|| okm }a boyc aycplahc }bc bcphckcs}jl ljpldc+ ]bjpm$ jk |s~~ap} ai }bc djkf

`c}ucck ~bckahckadaez okm bcphckcs}jl|$ }bc lahhakodj}jc| |cck olpa|| o ksh`cp ai

}uck}jc}b lck}spz bcphckcs}jl ~bckahckadaej|}| opc |}o}cm jk pcdo}jak }a ~|zlbadaez+ O |bap}

ksh`cp ai eckcpod laklds|jak| opc |}o}cm iap }bc bshok |ljcklc| jk }bc hojk$ od}baseb }bc

eckcpod laklds|jak| ~payjmcm o~~dz }a a}bcp| opco|+

J} j| ucdd fkauk }bo} Bs||cpd bo| bom ckaphas| jkidscklc jk o ksh`cp ai opco|+ @s} ka a}bcp

~cp|ak| boyc iaddaucm bj| hc}bam| okm jmco| }a }bc dc}}cpjk }bcjp mcycda~hck}| ai bj| uapf+

Ka} cyck }bc lda|c|} jk}cp~pc}cp| djfc Fcpk$ Hop`olb$ \}pfcp okm Woboyj boyc ~s`dj|bcm

uapf| }bo} |bau }bc mc}ojd| ai }bc }baseb} cr~cpjhck}| }bo} bc specm+ ]bj| ahj||jak jh~djc|

lpj}jlj|h+ Kaubcpc bo| }bj| `cck hapc ~pcyodck} }bok jk }bc opco loddcm bcphckcs}jl

~bckahckadaez+ @cdau$ }bsh`kojd |fc}lbc| ai o |cdcl}jak ai }uck}jc}b lck}spz upj}cp| opc

~payjmcm jk |s~~ap} ai }bc lahhak }bpcom }bpasebas}7 }bo} ~bckahckadaez lok akdz crj|} o|

o bcphckcs}jl okm cr~djlj}dz |cdi(pcidcrjyc o~~paolb+ Ubo} }bj| hcok| j| }bo} o |siijljck}

skmcp|}okmjke kccm| }a `c }ofck }a o ~bckahckak jk apmcp }a pcycod j} ~pa~cpdz + ]bc a~~a|j}c

ciicl} j| od|a ka}jlco`dc+ ^aap ap maukpjeb} upake skmcp|}okmjke lok `c o~~djcm ( }bo}

a`|lspc| okm hj|(pc~pc|ck}| ( |a dcomjke fkaudcmec okm ~pol}jlc| ouoz ipah }bcjp ojh| okm

a`gcl}|+


8/22

Bs||cpd |c} }bc |lckc iap o hapc pomjlod }spk }a cr~cpjcklc }bok Fok} `z ka}jke }bo} `cdjci j|

lda|c }a ~cplc~}jak okm a}bcp iaph| ai }bc ejyckkc|| ai hcokjke| ai mjiicpck} |ap}|

"?:5

bcopm$ |cck okm icd}$ pcqsjpc jk}cddcl}sod uapf uj}b pc|~cl} }a lak|ljas| cr~cpjcklc+ Okz

o||cp}jak| o`as} los|c$ ha}jyc| iap ol}jak okm ubo} j| ldojhcm }bo} a}bcp| iccd ( ap ubo}

ha}jyo}c| }bch jk }ps}b hs|} opj|c ipah }bc `c|} ~a||j`dc cyjmcklc iap |slb o||cp}jak|+

Jkmccm$ Bs||cpd| mcijkj}jak ai pco|ak laklcpkcm mclpco|jke ~op}jod ejyckkc|| ap ch~}z

laklc~}sod ejyckkc||$ jk apmcp }a eojk isdijddcm cr~cpjcklc| }bch|cdyc| okm `clahc o`dc }a

hofc ~pa~cp laklds|jak| "?=3$ ~+


9/22

Bcphckcs}jl|

]bj| |cl}jak |fc}lbc| }bc aycpodd ko}spc ai bcphckcs}jl| yjo |ahc `pjci |fc}lbc| ai }bc copdz

lak}pj`s}ap|+ J} uo| Ipjcmpjlb O|} uba |cch| }a boyc `cck }bc ijp|} ~cp|ak }a iaphsdo}c }bc

ò|jl ~pa~a|j}jak }bo} do}cp `clohc fkauk o| }bc bcphckcs}jl ljpldc "ôdhcp$ ?:9:$ ~+ 55*+

]bj| ò|jl jmco uo| mcycda~cm `z \lbdcjcpholbcp okm Mjd}bcz+ Ubo} odd do}cp bcphckcs}|

|bopc j| }bc mcycda~hck} ai O|}| apjejkod jmco+ Bcjkpjlb \lbdcjcpholbcp |}o}cm }bc ljplsdopj}z

jk }bc iaddaujke uoz7 bau }bjke| hofc |ck|c j| }bo} uc lah~opc }bc kcu }a ubo} uc odpcomz

fkau "~+ 25*+ \lbdcjcpholbcp mcycda~cm }bc jmco }bo} }bc ~op} okm }bc ubadc jk}cp(ol} }a hofc

|ck|c+ Iap bjh$ }bc ~op} okm }bc ubadc mc}cphjkc colb a}bcp7 Bc loddcm }bc aycpodd ciicl} }bc

bcphckcs}jl ljpldc+ Skmcp|}okmjke j| ljplsdop `clos|c }bcpc j| o òlf okm iap}b haychck}

`c}ucck }bc ubadc }bo} mcijkc| j}| ~op}| ( okm }bc ~op}| }bo} lak}pj`s}c }a }bc ubadc+

Mc~ckmjke ak }bc |la~c }ofck$ }bcpc opc epco}cp ubadc| okm dc||cp ~op}|+

Ujdbcdh Mjd}bcz mcycda~cm bcphckcs}jl| jk }bc mjpcl}jak ai o eckcpod }bcapz ai

skmcp|}okmjke+ Bc mj|}jkesj|bcm `c}ucck cdchck}opz$ iskmohck}od okm lahhak

skmcp|}okmjke ( }bo} cko`dc| }bcpc }a `c bjebcpskmcp|}okmjke| ai lahhskjlo}jak ai yopjas||ap}| "Mjd}bcz$ ?:59$ ~~+ 0?2(003*+ Iap jk|}oklc$ ch~o}bz uj}b bj|}apjlod lbopol}cp| okm

|j}so}jak| j| kclc||opz }a skmcp|}okm }bc bj|}apjlod lak}cr} jk ubjlb }bcz ucpc djyjke+ Akdz ak

}bo} ò|j| lok }bcpc `c ollspo}c pcomjke| ai bj|}apz+ ]a |j}so}c o |~cljijl }cr} jk j}| eckpc

allsp| }bpaseb pcomjke }bc eckpc+ Jk lak}ch~apopz Ckedj|b dokesoec ljpldc|$ Bok| ^c}cp

Pjlfhok "0>>=* bo| makc o epco} mcod }a cr~dojk okm `sjdm ak }bc lakkcl}jak| `c}ucck Fok}

okm Mjd}bcz+ Pjlfhok |sh| s~ }bc bcphckcs}jl ljpldc o| hayjke `c}ucck jk}cp~pc}jkejkmjyjmsod ~bckahcko okm jk}cp~pc}jke }bc ubadc ai ubjlb }bcz opc |s~~a|cm }a iaph ~op} j|

lbopol}cpj|}jl ai odd jk}cp~pc}o}jak ]bcpc j| ka o`|ads}c |}op}jke ~ajk}$ ka pjejm ipohcuapf

ai o||sh~}jak| ak ubjlb ok jk}cp~pc}o}jyc }bcapz lok pc|}+++ Jk}cp~pc}o}jak j| o ho}}cp ai

ec}}jke o} }bc hcokjke ai bshok ~bckahcko ai mj|laycpjke ipah }bcjp cr~pc||jak| ubo}

~ca~dc }bjkf$ iccd$ okm uok}$ "~+ 5


10/22

Hop}jk Bcjmceecp| o~~paolb `clohc ~a~sdop `clos|c bc }aaf Bs||cpd| o}}ck}jak }a djycm

cr~cpjcklc|$ okm jk lpco}jke bj| iskmohck}od ak}adaez$ bc jkmjlo}cm }bo} }bc ~o}b iap

~bjda|a~bz uo| }a ~s} j}| bas|c jk apmcp `z `o|jke j}| ldojh| o`as} ubo} crj|}| ap ka}$ ak }bc

ha|} iskmohck}od okm odd(cklah~o||jke mjpcl} cr~cpjcklc ai crj|}cklc okm kak(crj|}cklc

"?:05!?::9$


11/22

]bc bcphckcs}jl lahhakodj}z uj}bjk }bc bj|}apz ai ~bckahckadaez

]bj| |cl}jak pcicp| }a }ba|c uba mcycda~cm ~bckahckadaez$ lpj}jqscm Bs||cpd okm mcycda~cm

bj| jmco|+ ]bc Ipcklb pcomjke| ai Bs||cpd okm Bcjmceecp ucpc hjrcm uj}b a}bcp o|~cl}| ai

~adj}jl|$ ~bjda|a~bz$ ~|zlba(okodz|j| okm ec|}od} ~|zlbadaez }a ~pamslc }bc cr~okmcm yjcu

loddcm crj|}ck}jod ~bckahckadaez+ Akdz o icu lahhck}| ujdd `c homc ak }bc ~a|j}jyc dcom |c}

`z Bcjmceecp jk pceopm }a skj}jke bcphckcs}jl| okm ~bckahckadaez+ ]bck |ahc `pjci

lbopol}cpj|o}jak| ai \op}pc okm mc @cosyajp opc ~payjmcm }a |bau }bcjp o}}ck}jak }a hcokjke+

Mc|~j}c }bc jk}pamsl}apz okm jpakjl lahhck}| }bo} ~bjda|a~bcp| |basdm `c esjmcm `z bau

}bjke| |bau }bch|cdyc| "Bcjmceecp$ ?:05!?::9$ 5l$ ~+ *$ okm }bo} }bcpc |basdm `c }bc s|c

ai bcphckcs}jl| jk o}}ckmjke }a kak(ycp`od hcokjke "


12/22

`cjke }bpaseb o bcphckcs}jl ai }bc iol}jlj}z ai Mo(|cjk jk eckcpod "?:05!?::9$ ~+ =>?$ k ?*

`z ubjlb bc hcok} ijkmjke }bc cko`djke lakmj}jak| iap `cjke jk o uapdm }bpaseb opeshck}

laklcpkjke cycpzmoz cr~cpjcklc7 djfc s|jke o bohhcp "bcphckcs}jl ljpldc okm crch~djijcm j} jk bj| o~~paolb }a ~|zlba~o}badaez "?:?


13/22

pcqsjpcm iap hofjke |slb mj|}jkl}jak|+ ]bcpciapc$ ~bckahckadaez j| bcphckcs}jl|

"?:53!?:53$ ~+ ::*+ ]bc djkf `c}ucck ubo} Pjlacsp ~ajk}cm as}$ okm ubo} Bs||cpd apjejkoddz

upa}c$ j| }bo} ~bckahckadaez lahc| jk}a `cjke ubck uc }bcpciapc o|f qsj}c skjycp|oddz+++

ubo} j| cyjmck}joddz jkbcpck} jk }bc ubadc pcmslcm ~bckahckak+++ j}| ~cplcjycm o|

~cplcjycm$ "?:?$ ~+ 00>*+ ]bc lahhak ojh j| }a jk}cp~pc} ~bckahcko ~pa~cpdz$

ollapmjke }a }bcjp ecksjkc hokkcp ai `cjke ubjlb j| bau }bc jk}ck}jakodj}jc| okm }bc |ck|c|

~pamslcm aycpdo~ okm jk}cphjkedc "?:90!?:55$

|j}so}jak+ Bc opescm }bo} bshok crj|}cklc j| o ubadc$ ka} gs|} o |cpjc| ai ~op}|+ Okm }bo} }bc

~op}| jkmjlo}c }bc ubadc }a ubjlb }bcz `cdake7 hok j| o }a}odj}z okm ka} o laddcl}jak+

Lak|cqsck}dz bc cr~pc||c| bjh|cdi o| o ubadc jk cyck bj| ha|} jk|jekjijlok} okm bj| ha|}

|s~cpijljod `cboyjap+ Jk a}bcp uapm| }bcpc j| o ka} o }o|}c$ o hokkcpj|h$ ap ok bshok ol} }bo}

j| ka} pcycodjke$ "~+ 392*+ ^pc(lak|ljas| hcokjke| lok `c jk}cp~pc}cm `z eajke ipah }bc

lak|ljas| }auopm| }bo} ubjlb j| lsppck}dz as} ai lak|ljas|kc||$ `s} j} lok `c pc}pjcycm

}bpaseb mj|ls||jak+ Bc loddcm bj| hc}bam crj|}ck}jod ~|zlbaokodz|j|7 J}| ~ajk} ai mc~op}spc j|

cr~cpjcklc6 j}| ~jddop ai |s~~ap} j| }bc iskmohck}od$ ~pc(ak}adaejlod lah~pcbck|jak ubjlb

hok bo| ai }bc bshok ~cp|ak+++ colb bshok jkmjyjmsod kcycp}bcdc|| ~a||c||c| o ~pjapj }bc

hcokjkeai }bc pcycdo}apz yodsc ai }bc|c hokjic|}o}jak| okm j| lo~o`dc ai mclj~bcpjke }bch +++

J}| hc}bam j| lah~opo}jyc$ "~~+ 392(:*+ ]bc lahhck}| boyc ujmc(pokejke jh~djlo}jak| jk

}cph| ai mcijkjke ubo} j| olbjcyo`dc jk bshok jkqsjpz+ J} j| ldojhcm }bo} \op}pc mjm gs|}jlc }a

bau lah~dcr okm lak|}psl}cm j| cycpz o|~cl} ai apmjkopz djyjke+


14/22

\jhakc mc @cosyajp uo| oka}bcp uba uo| crch~dopz jk }ofjke ~bckahckadaez okm o~~dzjke

j} }a bshok mcycda~hck}$ eckmcp pcdo}jak| okm |crsodj}z$ iap jk|}oklc "?:=:o$ ?:=:`*+ \bc

ollc~}cm Gcok(ôsd \op}pc| ubadj|h okm o~~djcm o lak}cr}sod yjcu ai }bc jk}ck}jakodj}z ai

ol}jak }a cycpzmoz djic+ Iap bcp$ ol}jak| hofc |ck|c jk }bcjp lak}cr} okm ojh aycpodd+ \a }bo}

}bc |ohc ol}jak kccm| }a `c skmcp|}aam }bpaseb epo|~jke }bc o}}j}smc okm ~sp~a|c ai }bc

|~cljijl ol}ap+ \slb ok o~~paolb j| s|cisd jk }ofjke }bcapz }a }bc jkmjyjmsod$ jk skmcp|}okmjke

ubo} bo~~ck| iap }bch$ jk okz ejyck |j}so}jak+ \a j} j| o ~pc(pcqsj|j}c iap skmcp|}okmjke

~cp|akodj}z okm bau |~cljijl cyck}| hofc |ck|c }a a}bcp|+ ]bj| ubadj|h j| lahhak }a \op}pc

okm }bc ~|zlbjo}pj|} Fopd Go|~cp| o| ucdd+

\ahc jh~djlo}jak| iap }bc bshok |ljcklc|

]a pc}spk }a }bc apjejkod ojh ai }bc ~o~cp$ j} |basdm kau `c ldcopcp bau jh~ap}ok} j} j| }a `c

|cdi(pcidcrjyc jk hofjke ldcop }a laddcoesc| okm asp|cdyc|$ asp auk ~cp|akod pc|~ak|j`jdj}z jk

bau uc hofc |ck|c ai |j}so}jak|+ ]bj| j| }bc laklcpk }bo} lpco}c| okrjc}z oàs} pc(|coplb

hc}bam| okm }bc mc|jpc iap omcqso}c gs|}jijlo}jak jk yopjas| iaph| ai hcokjke(apjck}cm

|coplbjke oeojk+ Oka}bcp lahhak o|~cl} `c}ucck }bpcc ai }bc fcz }bjkfcp| hck}jakcm oàycj| kau o~~poj|cm okm }bo} j| }bc padc ai ch~o}bz jk mako}jke |ck|c }a ubo} o~~cop|+

Iaddaujke Mjd}bcz$ Bs||cpd okm Go|~cp|$ ubo} ch~o}bz lak}pj`s}c| }a ~|zlbadaejlod pc|coplb

j| }bo} j} j| }bc iskmohck}od iaph ai skmcp|}okmjke }bo} epo|~| ubo} j| a`|cpyo`dc okm

pclapmo`dc+ Ch~o}bz `pco}bc| ~|zlbadaejlod hcokjke jk}a dj|}ckjke }a ~ca~dc$ uo}lbjke kak(

ycpòd|$ pcomjke upj}}ck mc|lpj~}jak| okm lakldsmjke ak ubo} |}o}j|}jl| hcok+ ^|zlbadaejlod

hcokjke| akdz o~~cop }bpaseb ch~o}bjl skmcp|}okmjke okm opc }bch|cdyc| jklo~o`dc ai `cjkepclapmcm+ ]bc }cph| ch~o}bjl skmcp|}okmjke okm ~|zlbadaejlod skmcp|}okmjke opc jmck}jlod

okm opc o ~op} ai }bc epco}cp cr~ok|c ai lahhak|ck|c+ Iap jk|}oklc$ jk}ck}jak| okm }bc mc}ojd|

ai }bc cr~cpjcklc| ai a}bcp| opc jkmjlo}cm }bpaseb ubo} ~ca~dc |oz oàs} }bcjp hchapjc|$

ok}jlj~o}jak| okm ubo} j} j| djfc iap a}bcp| }a dcom }bcjp djyc|+ Ubo} jk}ck}jakodj}z hcok| jk

pcdo}jak }a hcokjkeisd a`gcl}|$ j| }bo} j} |bau| bau ~ca~dc pcol} }a hcokjke| }bo} opc ka}


15/22

o~~opck} }a a}bcp|+ \}o}jke }bj| ~ajk} ycpz eckcpoddz$ ~ca~dc pcol} }a ubo} }bcz ok}jlj~o}c$ iccd

okm pco|ak hjeb} bo~~ck+ ]bc|c jk}ck}jakodj}jc| opc ka} boddsljko}jak ap mpcohjke+

Ok}jlj~o}jak$ cha}jak$ okm pco|akjke hjeb} `c jk oepcchck} uj}b }bc yjcu| ai a}bcp| oàs}

}bc |ohc ~bz|jlod a`gcl}$ jk }bc bcpc okm kau ap ka}+ Ollapmjkedz$ pcol}jak| }a ubo} j|

ok}jlj~o}cm$ yodscm$ pchch`cpcm$ icd} ap pco|akcm oàs} ( opc }bc pc|sd} ai hcokjke(hofjke

~palc||c|+ \slb los|c| ai bshok `cboyjasp cyomc ~|zlbadaez o| ko}spod |ljcklc+ Zc} }bc|c

cr~cpjcklc| opc yodjm okm crj|}ck} ~bckahcko7 }bc|c jk}okej`dc| opc jk}cp~pc}cm

~|zlbadaejlod pco|ak| iap ol}jke ai o mjiicpck} |ap} }a }bc ko}spod los|c| ai eckc}jl }poj}| okm

lbchjlod| jk }bc `daam|}pcoh+ ]bc padc ai }bc bcphckcs}jl ljpldc j| skmcp|}okmjke }bo} }bc

~pcyjas| jhhcp|jak jk }bc |aljod uapdm }colbc| bau }a hofc |ck|c ai }bc lsppck} hahck}+

Ubo} j| lahhak }a Bs||cpd okm Go|~cp| j| jhhcp|jke akc|cdi jk }bc mc|lpj~}jak| ai }bc

cr~cpjcklc| ai a}bcp|$ jk apmcp }a epo|~ |ahc}bjke djfc ubo} }bcjp ijp|}(bokm cr~cpjcklc hjeb}

`c "Bs||cpd$ ?:5

skmcp|}okmjke "Ycp|}cbck* |adcdz iap }bc skmcp|}okmjke ai ~|zlbjl cyck}| ipah uj}bjk+

]bc cr~pc||jak ujdd kcycp `c s|cm iap }bc o~~pcljo}jak ai a`gcl}jyc los|od lakkcl}jak|$ ubjlb

uc boyc |ojm lok akdz `c |cck ipah uj}bas}$ "~+ 02*+ ^cplc~}sod ~pc|cklc jkmjlo}c| ubo} j|

pcod bcpc okm kau+ J} bo| }a `c ka}cm }bo} ubo} j| ~|zlbadaejlod j| kcj}bcp ~cplc~}sod kap

pcod bcpc okm kau jk }bc |ck|c }bo} j} j| mjpcl}dz a`|cpyo`dc `z okzakc cd|c+ @s} j} j|

jk}cp~pc}o`dc msc }a |aljod dcopkjke+ ]bc }z~c ai pcodj}z ai }bc ~|zlbadaejlod a`gcl} j|

jk}ck}jakod okm |bopcm `c}ucck ~ca~dc+ J} j| o hjr}spc ai }bc ~o|} okm is}spc jk }bc ~pc|ck}+ J}

j| }bc pc|sd} ai ~o|} dcopkjke okm lok `c a~ck }a pc(dcopkjke+

]bc lahhakodj}z `c}ucck Bs||cpd okm Go|~cp| laklcpk| }bc |bopjke ai }bchc| ai

jk}ck}jakodj}z$ ch~o}bz okm }bc mc|jpc }a o}}ckm }a ubo} a}bcp ~ca~dc cr~cpjcklc$ jk }bc

~op}jlsdop$ okm jk }bcapz(hofjke+ Okz laklds|jak| oàs} a}bcp| pcqsjpc }bc lak|ljas|

cyjmcklc ai ubo} }bcz cr~cpjcklc+ ]bj| eckcpod ~pjklj~dc j| loddcm isdijdhck}$ o| ka}cm

oàyc+ Jk }bj| lo|c$ j} j| o qso|j(cr~cpjckljke }bpaseb ~|zlbadaejlod skmcp|}okmjke$ ck}jpcdz

a`}ojkcm }bpaseb jhoejko}jak okm ch~o}bz oàs} a}bcp ~cp|ak|$ jk lakkcl}jak uj}b akc|


16/22

auk djic cr~cpjcklc| okm }bc ò|jl o`jdj}z }a jhoejkc ubo} djic j| djfc iap a}bcp|$ cyck }baseb

}bcz hjeb} `c pomjloddz mjiicpck} }a akc|cdi+ J} j| jh~ap}ok} }a lakldsmc ipah cr~cpjck}jod

cyjmcklc ai akc| auk jk}ck}jakodj}jc|$ o| a}bcp| }spk }auopm| }bc |ohc ap |jhjdop lsd}spod

a`gcl}|+ Iaphod ~|zlbadaejlod laklc~}| lok akdz `c mcpjycm ipah |slb skmcp|}okmjke+

Bs||cpd| }cph iap }bj| uo| os}bck}jl ch~o}bz okm }bj| j| |zkakzhas| }a }ofjke }bc

~cp|akodj|}jl o}}j}smc }auopm| a}bcp|7 Bc uo| ldcop }bo} }bj| j| }bc `cmpalf iap ecksjkc

bshok |ljcklc| "Fcpk$ ?::5*+

Od}baseb }bc `ja~|zlba|aljod o~~paolb j| dosmo`dc$ j} pchojk| }a `c |cck ~pclj|cdz bau

ko}spc okm ksp}spc lok `c homc jk}a o skjijcm ubadc `clos|c colb mj|lj~djkc lahc| ipah

pomjloddz mjiicpck} ak}adaejlod ò|c|+ ]bcpc j| o hogap }ck|jak `c}ucck o ials| ak }bc

`jadaejlod ò|j| iap `cboyjasp o| a~~a|cm }a }bc a~ck cr~dapo}jak ai hcokjkeisd qsodj}o}jyc

cr~cpjcklc|+ Bcphckcs}jl ~bckahckadaez laklcpk| j}|cdi uj}b }bc iskmohck}od| iap o

qsodj}o}jyc o~~paolb }a }bcapz okm ~pol}jlc+ J}| |}pcke}b j| }bo} j} j| pcomz }a ollask} iap

yopjo`jdj}z jk }bc |ck|c| ai }bc |ohc a`gcl}+ J} lok uapf uj}b lah~dcr cr~cpjcklc| `clos|c j}|

ubadj|h lok jmck}jiz }bc lak}pj`s}apz ~op}| ai cr~cpjcklc o| jk}ck}jakodj}z$ |ck|c$ a`gcl} okm

lak}cr}+ Ubo} ~bckahckadaez |bau| j| }bo} |ahc ~bckahcko opc jkyj|j`dc }a }bc ko}spod

|ljcklc o~~paolb okm }bcz iodd as}|jmc ai j}| pchj}+

Jk uapfjke }auopm| o laklapmok} `ja~|zlba|aljod yjcu$ o bcphckcs}jl o~~djcm ~|zlbadaez

lasdm |s~~ap} }bc skmcp|}okmjke ai bshok `cjke o| lah~pj|cm ai `jadaejlod$ ~|zlbadaejlod

okm |aljod o|~cl}|$ jk ubjlb o epco} hokz lak}cr}| ai ~op}| okm ubadc| lasdm `c jmck}jijcm

"Fcpk$ ?:29*+ ]bc }z~c ai los|odj}z o} ~doz iap bshok `cjke| j| hsd}j(iol}apjod$ à}b ko}spc

okm ksp}spc+ Ko}spod los|c j| jppcycp|j`dc `jadaejlod los|c jk eckc}jl| jk }ckmckljc| }a boyc o

|~cljijl |ap} ai ~cp|akodj}z okm |~cljijl |ap}| ai ~|zlbadaejlod ~pa`dch "Djyc|dcz$ 0>>


17/22

}bc ujmc|} uapdm ~a||j`dc ai |aljc}z okm jk}cpko}jakod jkidscklc| ak }bc jkmjyjmsod djic okm

bj|}apz+

Laklds|jak

Cyck kau akdz o |hodd ~pa~ap}jak ai }bc apjejkod upj}jke| ai Cmhskm Bs||cpd opc oyojdo`dc }a

}bc ~s`djl okm }bcjp |dau }pok|do}jak jk}a Ckedj|b bo| mcdozcm }bc epo|~jke ai }bcjp isdd jk}ck}

okm ~cp|~cl}jyc+ ]bc ho}spc uapdmyjcu ai Bs||cpd uasdm kau `c loddcm |aljod lak|}psl}jak

`s} }bc }cph lpco}cm `z Bs||cpd uo| eckcpo}jyc ~bckahckadaez ai }bc ollpsod ai hcokjke

olpa|| }bc mcycda~hck} ai bshok ljyjdj|o}jak "\}cjkàlf$ ?::3*+ Bs||cpd }aaf o ubadj|}jl

yjcu ai }bc mcycda~hck} ai }bc djicuapdm+ Bc ials|cm ak |aljod bj|}apz o| }bc |la~c iap }bc

lpco}jak okm hojk}ckoklc ai hcokjke+ Jk aycpyjcu7 lsd}spod uapdm| lpco}c }bch|cdyc| olpa||

bj|}apz+ ]bj| hcok| }bo} la(lak|}psl}jak allsp| }bpaseb ~ca~dc uba fkau colb a}bcp iolc }a

iolc okm }bpaseb dou|$ |aljc}od ~pcicpcklc| okm }pomj}jak| ai yopjas| |ap}|+ ]bc }cph uapdm

jk ~bckahckadaez hcok| o uapdm(bapjwak }bo} lak}ojk| uj}bjk j} o |c} ai hcokjkeisd lsd}spod

a`gcl}| ai yopjas| fjkm| |slb o| hs|jl$ iaam$ jmco|$ |aljod padc|$ okm cha}jakod pc|~ak|c| uj}b

pc|~cl} }a }bc crlj}chck}| okm mj|o~~ajk}hck}| iaskm }bcpc+ âc}pz$ mpoho okm ijdh mc~jl}

`cjke jk }bc uapdm| ai a}bcp| jk lah~opo`dc uoz| }a dj|}ckjke }a |ahcakc |~cof oàs} }bcjp

djic+ Ka} hslb kccm| }a `c |ojm `ciapc ch~o}bz ijdd| jk }bc eo~| okm hofc| |ck|c oàs} ubo}

j| osmj}apjoddz ~pc|ck}cm+

Baucycp$ ubo} jk}ck}jakodj}z hcok| j| }bo} laklc~}| okm cr~cpjcklc| pcicp }a }bc uapf makc

`z lak|ljas|kc|| jk hofjke hcokjke+ J} j| o hogap }o|f ai Bs||cpd| ~bckahckadaez }a epo|~

}bj| o`jdj}z+ O dopec ~ap}jak ai ~|zlbadaejlod djic laklcpk| ~|zlbadaejlod skmcp|}okmjke oàs}

}bc jk}ck}jak| okm iccdjke| ai a}bcp|+ @s} }bc pcejak ai ko}spod los|c mac| ka} ~pa~cpdz o~~cop

jk bshok `cboyjasp okm cr~cpjcklc okm j| bopm }a jmck}jiz+ Lak}popz }a Bs||cpd$ ubck

bcphckcs}jl| j| ollc~}cm }bcpc opc ka o`|ads}c |}op}jke ~ajk}|$ ~pjyjdcecm |}op}jke ~ajk}| okm

ka ~a||j`jdj}z ai |cdi(yodjmo}jak `z o~~cod }a |ahc `c|} cyjmcklc as}|jmc ai }bc bcphckcs}jl

ljpldc+ Iap }bc ho}spc Bs||cpd7 Bj|}apz j| }bc epco} iol} ai o`|ads}c @cjke6 okm }bc sd}jho}c

qsc|}jak|$ }bc sd}jho}c hc}o~bz|jlod okm }cdcadaejlod qsc|}jak|$ opc akc uj}b }bc qsc|}jak|

pceopmjke }bc o`|ads}c hcokjke ai bj|}apz$ "?:39$ ~+ 3>9$ lj}cm jk @cpkc}$ Fcpk ) Hopòlb$


18/22

?::


19/22

Lojpk|$ M+ "Cm*"?:59*+ Lakycp|o}jak| uj}b Bs||cpd okm Ijkf+ ]bc Boesc7

Hop}jks| Kjgbaii+

Mjd}bcz$ U+ "B+^+ Pjlfhok Cm ) ]pok|*"?:59*+ Mjd}bcz7 \cdcl}cm upj}jke|+

Loh`pjmec7 Loh`pjmec Skjycp|j}z pc||+

Bcjmceecp$ H+ "?:05!?::9*+ @cjke okm }jhc+ "]pok| G+ \}oh`oseb*+ Kcu Zapf7 \SKZ+

QQQQQQQQQQQ "?:53!?:20*+ ]bc `o|jl ~pa`dch| ai ~bckahckadaez+ "]pok| O+ Bai|}om}cp*+

@daahjke}ak7 Jkmjoko Skjycp|j}z pc||+

Bs||cpd$ C+ "P+ @acbh Cm*"?:39*+ Cp|}c ~bjda|a~bjc "?:0

~bkahckadaej|lbck pcmsl}jak+ Boesc7 Hop}jks| Kjgbaii+

QQQQQQQQQ "?:0:!?:9:*+Iaphod okm }pok|lckmck}od daejl+ "]pok| M+ Lojpk|*+ ]bc Boesc7

Hop}jks| Kjgbaii+

QQQQQQQQQ "?:39!?:5>*+ ]bc lpj|j| ai Cspa~cok |ljcklc| okm }pok|lckmck}od ~bckahckadaez+

"]pok| M+ Lopp*+ Cyok|}ak7 Kap}buc|}cpk Skjycp|j}z ^pc||+

QQQQQQQQQ "J+ Fcpk Cm*"?:5


20/22

QQQQQQQQQ "?:90!?:55*+ ^bckahckadaejlod ~|zlbadaez7 Dcl}spc|$ |shhcp |chc|}cp ?:03+

"]pok| G+ \lokdak*+ ]bc Boesc7 Hop}jks| Kjgbaii+

QQQQQQQQQ "?:??!?:2?o*+ ^bjda|a~bz o| pjeapas| |ljcklc+ Jk ^+ HlLaphjlf ) I+O+ Cddj|}ak

"Cm|* Bs||cpd7 \bap}cp uapf|+ "]pok| _+ Doscp*+ "~~+ ?99(?:5*+ Ka}pc Mohc7 Ka}pc Mohc

Skjycp|j}z ^pc||+

QQQQQQQQQ "?:92!?:2?`*+ ]bc Mjd}bcz(Bs||cpd lappc|~akmcklc+ Jk ^+ HlLaphjlf ) I+O+

Cddj|}ak "Cm|* Bs||cpd7 \bap}cp uapf|+ "]pok| G+ Oddck*+ "~~+ 0>:*+ Ka}pc Mohc7 Ka}pc

Mohc Skjycp|j}z pc||+

QQQQQQQQ "?:?

~bckahckadaejlod ~bjda|a~bz7 Ijp|} aaf+ "]pok| I+ Fcp|}ck*+ Mapmpclb}7 Fdsucp

Olomchjl+

QQQQQQQQ "?:92!?::5o*+ ^bckahckadaezCklzlda~ocmjo @pj}}okjlo op}jldc$ Mpoi} M+ Jk C+

Bs||cpd "]+ \bccbok ) P+C+ ^odhcp$ Cm| ) ]pok|* ^|zlbadaejlod okm }pok|lckmck}od ~bckahckadaez okm }bc lakipak}o}jak uj}bBcjmceecp "?:05(?:


21/22

QQQQQQQQ "?:2>!0>>3*+ ^bok}o|z$ jhoec lak|ljas|kc||$ okm hchapz "?2:2(

?:03*+ "]pok| G+@+ @paseb*+ Mapmpclb}7 \~pjkecp+

Go|~cp|$ F+ "?:?

Dozlalf ) G+E+ Bop} "Cm|* C||oz| jk ~bckahckadaejlod }bcadaez+ "~~+ 0


22/22

^odhcp$ P+C+ "?:9:*+ Bcphckcs}jl|+ Cyok|}ak7 Kap}buc|}cpk Skjycp|j}z ^pc||+

Pjlfhok$ B+^+ "0>>=*+ ]bc pjmmdc ai }bc |~bjkr7 Jk}cp~pc}jke }bc bshok uapdm+ Hommj|ak7

Iopdcjeb Mjlfjk|ak Skjycp|j}z ^pc||+

Pjlacsp$ ^+ "?:53!?:53*+ ^bckahckadaez okm bcphckcs}jl|+ "]pok| P+@+ McIapm*+ Ka|$ :$

23(?>0+

\op}pc$ G+(^+ "?:=

ak}adaez+ "]pok| B+ @opkc|*+ Dakmak7 Hc}bsck+

\}cjk`alf$ O+G+ "?::3*+ Bahc okm `czakm7 Eckcpo}jyc ~bckahckadaez oi}cp Bs||cpd+

Cyok|}ak7 Kap}buc|}cpk Skjycp|j}z pc||+

Ujeejk|$ A+^+ ) \lbuop}w$ H+O+ "?::5*+ Cmhskm Bs||cpd| jkidscklc ak Fopd Go|~cp|

~bckahckadaez+ bjda|a~bz$ ^|zlbjo}pz okm |zlbadaez$ =$ ?3(

20th Century Hermeneutic Phenomenology for the Human Sciences and Practical Disciplines

Documents

Transcript of 20th Century Hermeneutic Phenomenology for the Human Sciences and Practical Disciplines