2016 Delinquency Benchbook - Florida Courts€¦ · November 2016 Office of the State Courts...
Transcript of 2016 Delinquency Benchbook - Florida Courts€¦ · November 2016 Office of the State Courts...
Florida’sJUVENILEDELINQUENCY
BENCHBOOKNovember2016
OfficeoftheStateCourtsAdministrator
ThisprojectwassupportedbyGrantNo.RCC500,awardedbyOfficeofJuvenileJusticeandDelinquencyPrevention,OfficeofJusticePrograms,U.S.DepartmentofJustice.Pointsofviewinthisdocumentarethoseoftheauthoranddonotnecessarilyrepresenttheofficialpositionorpoliciesofthefundingagencyand/orentity.
INTRODUCTION
Educationenhancestheknowledgeandskillsofthejudiciaryandtherefore
contributestotheadministrationofjustice.Tofurtherassistintheadministrationofjustice,theOfficeoftheStateCourtsAdministrator,OfficeofCourtImprovement,hasdevelopedthisbenchbooktoaddressjuveniledelinquencyinFlorida.ThebenchbookwasdevelopedtoassistbothnewandexperiencedjudgesinFloridawhoareassignedtohearjuveniledelinquencycases.
Thebenchbookisorganizedintoa‘GeneralTopics’sectionfollowedbychapters
correspondingwiththejuveniledelinquencyhearingsprovidedforinChapter985.Eachhearingchapteralsohasacorrespondinghearingbenchcard.TheGeneralTopicssectionintroducesmanyimportantancillaryissuesthatwillbeencounteredbythecourt.Thecitationsinthisbenchbookhavebeenabbreviatedtoimprovetextflow.Forexample,acitationtosection985.01,FloridaStatutes,willappearas§985.01andacitationtotheFloridaRulesofJuvenileProcedure8.000willappearasRule8.000.
Ourofficeintendstoupdateandsupplementthisbookperiodically.Accordingly,weinvitesuggestionsregardingtopicsthatneedmoredetailedtreatmentandwaysthatthispublicationcanbemademoreusefultojudgeshearingdelinquencycases.PleaseprovidecommentsandsuggestionstoDorisLaingintheOfficeofCourtImprovement,SupremeCourtBuilding,500SouthDuvalStreet,Tallahassee,Florida,32399-1900,[email protected],or850.410.1889.
Uponrequestbyaqualifiedindividualwithadisability,thisdocumentwillbemadeavailableinalternateformats.Toorderthisdocumentinanalternateformat,pleasecontacttheOfficeofCourtImprovement,SupremeCourtBuilding,500SouthDuvalStreet,Tallahassee,Florida,32399-1900.Phone:850.414.1507.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ThispublicationwasoriginallydevelopedwiththeassistanceofJudgeRaulZambrano,JudgeEdwardNickinson,DeborahShaw,andtheJuvenileJusticeCenteratBarryUniversity.
2016JUVENILEDELINQUENCYBENCHBOOK
TableofContents
Introduction.................................................................................................................iAcknowledgements.....................................................................................................iiDelinquencyCaseFlowChart.....................................................................................xiOverviewoftheFloridaJuvenileDelinquencyProcess.................................................1CommonAcronyms.....................................................................................................3GeneralTopicsAppeals.......................................................................................................................9A. Generally................................................................................................................9B. MotionforRehearing.............................................................................................9C. MotionforExtraordinaryRelief...........................................................................10D. AppealtotheAppellateCourt..............................................................................10
AuthorityofCourtoverParents.................................................................................12A. Generally..............................................................................................................12B. NonattendancebyaParentorGuardian.............................................................12C. CostsofRepresentation.......................................................................................13D. ParentingSkillsCourse.........................................................................................13E. RestitutionorCommunityService........................................................................13F. Fees......................................................................................................................13
ChildAdjudicatedNotGuiltybyReasonofInsanity...................................................14A. AdvisetheCourt...................................................................................................14B. NotGuiltybyReasonofInsanity..........................................................................14C. Treatment.............................................................................................................14
D. Review..................................................................................................................15CommitmentstoDJJ..................................................................................................16A. CommitmentProcess...........................................................................................16B. RestrictivenessLevels...........................................................................................16
ConditionalReleaseandPost-CommitmentProbation..............................................18A. ConditionalRelease..............................................................................................18B. Post-CommitmentProbation...............................................................................18
Confidentiality...........................................................................................................20A. Generally..............................................................................................................20B. Exceptions............................................................................................................20
CostofCourt,Care,andSupervision..........................................................................22A. Generally..............................................................................................................22B. AdditionalFees.....................................................................................................22C. RequiredInformation...........................................................................................22D. FeeDetermination...............................................................................................23E. FeeWaiver...........................................................................................................23F. Child’sObligationuponTurning18......................................................................23G. GuardianshipIssues..............................................................................................24H. ParentalLiability...................................................................................................24I. FeeReimbursement.............................................................................................24J. ExtensionofCare..................................................................................................24
Delinquency/DependencyCrossoverCases...............................................................25A. Statistics...............................................................................................................25B. EffectivePracticesinCrossoverCases..................................................................30
DepartingfromDJJGuidelines...................................................................................33A. Generally..............................................................................................................33B. E.A.R.v.State.......................................................................................................33
DetentionCriteria.....................................................................................................35A. Pre-CommitmentDetention.................................................................................35B. Post-CommitmentDetention...............................................................................37
Discovery..................................................................................................................39A. RequiredDisclosuretotheChild..........................................................................39B. RequiredDisclosuretoDJJ...................................................................................40C. Limitations............................................................................................................41D. Depositions...........................................................................................................41E. Sanctions..............................................................................................................45F. Record..................................................................................................................45
DiversionaryPrograms..............................................................................................47A. Generally..............................................................................................................47B. TeenCourt............................................................................................................47C. CivilCitation.........................................................................................................49D. JuvenileSubstanceInterventionProgram............................................................50E. Expunction............................................................................................................51
DomesticViolenceIssues..........................................................................................52
A. Statistics...............................................................................................................52B. TheeffectsofDomesticViolenceonchildren......................................................53C. HowtoAscertainwhetherDomesticViolencemaybePresent...........................55D. Bestpracticesindelinquencycasesinvolvingdomesticviolence........................57
CommonEvidenceIssues..........................................................................................62A. InvestigatoryStopsversusConsensualEncounters.............................................62B. BodySearches......................................................................................................63C. VehicleSearches...................................................................................................63D. StandardsinaSchoolSetting...............................................................................64E. WeaponsIssues........................................................................................................................64
ImmigrationIssues....................................................................................................66InterpretersforForeignLanguages............................................................................68A. IdentifyNeedforInterpretingServices................................................................68B. PerformAssessmenttoDetermineNeeds...........................................................69C. SelectionofInterpreter........................................................................................70D. ProvisionofServices.............................................................................................71E. ModesofInterpretingandServiceDeliveryMethods.........................................71
InterstateCompact....................................................................................................73A. Generally..............................................................................................................73B. RunawaysandEscapees–Procedure..................................................................73C. VoluntaryReturnProcedure................................................................................74D. ProbationersandParolees...................................................................................74E. SupplementaryAgreements.................................................................................74
JurisdictioninDelinquencyProceedings....................................................................75A. Generally..............................................................................................................75B. RetentionofJurisdiction......................................................................................75
JuvenileAssessmentCenter......................................................................................76JuvenileSexOffendersandTheAdamWalshAct......................................................77A. Generally..............................................................................................................77B. WrittenFindingsRequired...................................................................................77C. Registration..........................................................................................................77D. RemovalfromtheRegistry...................................................................................78
JuvenileSexOffenderPrograms................................................................................79A. Generally..............................................................................................................79B. CommunityBasedTreatmentServices................................................................79C. JuvenileSexualOffenderCommitmentPrograms...............................................80
Medicaid/MedicareEligibilityforServicesuponRelease...........................................81Restitution................................................................................................................82RiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI).............................................................................83ServiceofProcess......................................................................................................84SpeedyTrial..............................................................................................................85A. Generally..............................................................................................................85B. DemandforSpeedyTrial......................................................................................85C. MotionforDischarge...........................................................................................85
TransfertoAdultCourt..............................................................................................87A. Waiver..................................................................................................................87B. DirectFiling...........................................................................................................88C. Indictments..........................................................................................................90
UnifiedFamilyCourt–ModelFamilyCourt...............................................................91WalkerPlanApprovalbyJudge.................................................................................93DelinquencyHearingsDetentionHearingataGlance...................................................................................98DetentionHearingBenchcard..................................................................................100DetentionHearingOutline......................................................................................102A. Generally............................................................................................................102B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................104C. ProbableCauseDetermination..........................................................................105D. Setarraignmenthearing.....................................................................................107E. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdetention....................................................107
ArraignmentHearingataGlance.............................................................................111ArraignmentHearingBenchcard..............................................................................113ArraignmentHearingOutline..................................................................................115A. Generally............................................................................................................115B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................116C. Reviewdelinquencypetition..............................................................................117D. Entranceofaplea...............................................................................................118E. Setnexthearing.................................................................................................120F. Determinecustodypendingdisposition............................................................121
AdjudicatoryHearingataGlance............................................................................124AdjudicatoryHearingBenchcard.............................................................................126AdjudicatoryHearingOutline..................................................................................128A. Generally............................................................................................................128B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................129C. Adjudicatoryhearingprocess.............................................................................131D. Delinquencydetermination................................................................................133E. Custodypendingdisposition..............................................................................134F. Adviseofrighttoappeal....................................................................................134G. Setdispositionhearing.......................................................................................135H. Requirementsforwrittenorderofadjudication................................................135
DispositionHearingataGlance...............................................................................138DispositionHearingBenchcard................................................................................140DispositionHearingOutline.....................................................................................142A. Generally............................................................................................................142B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................143C. Reviewpredispositionreport.............................................................................144D. Commitmentdetermination..............................................................................146E. Detentionpendingcommitment........................................................................149F. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdisposition..................................................149
ViolationofProbationHearingataGlance..............................................................154ViolationofProbationHearingBenchcard...............................................................156ViolationofProbationHearingOutline....................................................................158A. Generally............................................................................................................158B. AdviseofRights..................................................................................................159C. Violationofprobationdetermination................................................................161D. Dispositiondetermination..................................................................................162E. Requirementsforwrittenorder.........................................................................162
ContemptofCourtHearingataGlance...................................................................166ContemptofCourtHearingBenchcard....................................................................168ContemptofCourtHearingOutline.........................................................................170A. Generally............................................................................................................170B. AdviseofRights..................................................................................................171C. Indirectcontempthearingprocedure................................................................173D. Sanctions............................................................................................................174E. Requirementsforawrittenjudgmentofcontempt...........................................175
WaiverofJurisdictionHearingataGlance...............................................................178WaiverofJurisdictionHearingBenchcard................................................................180WaiverofJurisdictionHearingOutline....................................................................182A. Generally............................................................................................................182B. AdviseofRights..................................................................................................183C. Determinethetypeofwaiver............................................................................184D. IssueaSummons................................................................................................185E. Considertheevidencepresented.......................................................................185F. Jurisdictiondetermination.................................................................................186G. Requirementsforawrittenorderonwaiverofjurisdiction..............................187
RestitutionHearingataGlance...............................................................................189RestitutionHearingBenchcard................................................................................191RestitutionHeartingOutline....................................................................................193A. Generally............................................................................................................193B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................194C. HearingProcedure.............................................................................................196D. Restitutiondetermination..................................................................................197E. Requirementsforawrittenorderofrestitution................................................197
CorrectionofOrdersHearingataGlance.................................................................200CorrectionofOrdersHearingBenchcard..................................................................202CorrectionofOrdersHearingOutline......................................................................204A. Generally............................................................................................................204B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................205C. Correctionhearingprocedure............................................................................206D. Correctiondetermination...................................................................................207E. Requirementsforacorrectedorder..................................................................207
CompetencyHearingataGlance.............................................................................210CompetencyHearingBenchcard..............................................................................212
CompetencyHearingOutline...................................................................................214A. Generally............................................................................................................214B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................215C. Competencyhearingprocedures.......................................................................216D. Competencydetermination...............................................................................217E. Confinementassessment...................................................................................218F. Requirementsforawrittenorderofincompetency..........................................220
AppendicesAppendix1:DetentionRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI)Appendix2:TenThingsEveryJuvenileCourtJudgeShouldKnowAboutTraumaandDelinquencyAppendix3:HelpingTraumatizedChildren:TipsForJudges
DELINQUENCYCASEFLOWCHARTAdigitalcopyoftheDelinquencyFlowChartisnotavailableinthisformat,pleaseview
thePDFversionofthisdocument.
1
OVERVIEWOFTHEFLORIDA
JUVENILEDELINQUENCYPROCESS
ThejuveniledelinquencyprocessinFloridaisgovernedprimarilybyChapter985,FloridaStatutes.Thecircuitcourtshaveexclusiveoriginaljurisdictionoverproceedingsinwhichachildisallegedtohavecommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflaw.Achildisdefinedassomeonelessthan18yearsofage.TheFloridaDepartmentofJuvenileJustice(DJJ)istheagencychargedwithadministeringthejuvenilejusticesysteminFlorida.DJJmakesrecommendationstotheStateAttorney,whothendecideswhethertoproceedjudiciallyornon-judicially.Generally,childrenthatarechargedbylawenforcementwithdelinquentactsorviolationsoflawaretakentoajuvenileassessmentcenter(JAC)forintakescreeningandtoassesswhethersometypeofdetentionisnecessary.Incountiesthatdonothaveanassessmentcenter,thelawenforcementofficercallsaDJJ“on-callscreener”toassessthejuvenile’sriskanddetermineifdetentionisnecessary.Ifdetentionisnecessary,thechildwillbedeliveredtothenearestJACorDJJfacility.Withsomeminoroffenses,lawenforcementmayreleasethechildtoaparentorguardianandforwardthechargestothelocalclerkofcourtandDJJProbationOffice.IntakeandReferral
WhenachildisturnedovertoDJJ,oranon-callscreeneriscontacted,aJuvenileProbationOfficer(JPO)gathersinformationandreviewsthecase.Aspartoftheintakeprocess,theJPOcompletesastandardizedRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI).DJJmakestheinitialdeterminationastowhethertoreleaseordetainthechildbaseduponariskassessmentthatincludestheresultsoftheRAI.DetentionHearing
IfDJJdecidestodetainthechild,§985.26requiresadetentionhearingbeforethecircuitcourtwithin24hoursofbeingtakenintocustody.Thishearingisanalogoustothefirstappearancehearingincriminallaw.Thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthereisprobablecausethatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflawandwhetherfurtherdetentionisnecessary.Acourtcannotfurtherdetainachildunlessthecourtfindsthestatutorycriteriasetforthin§985.255aremet.Thechildisthenreleasedorretainedindetentionpendingfurtherproceedings.Achildcannotbedetainedinexcessof21dayswithoutthecommencementofanadjudicatoryhearingunlessanextensionforgoodcauseisshown.Someseriousoffenderscanbeheldinsecuredetentionforupto30days.§985.26(2).
2
DelinquencyPetition
IftheStateAttorneydecidestoproceedjudicially,adelinquencypetitionwillbefiled.IftheStateAttorneydecidestoproceedsnon-judicially,thechildwillbeplacedintoadiversionaryprogramagreeduponbyallparties.Ifthechildsuccessfullycompletestheagreeduponprogram,thedelinquencycaseisdismissed.ArraignmentHearing
Ifadelinquencypetitionisfiled,thenextstepisanarraignmenthearingwherethechildentersapleaofnotguilty,guilty,ornolocontendere.Thecasethenproceedstoeitheranadjudicatoryhearingifthepleawasnotguiltyoradispositionhearingifthepleawaseitherguiltyornolocontendere.AdjudicatoryHearing
Atanadjudicatoryhearing,thecourtmustdecidewhetherthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflaw.Theadjudicatoryhearingisanalogoustothetrialincriminallaw.Ifitisfoundthatadelinquentactwascommitted,thecourtcanwithholdadjudicationoradjudicatethechilddelinquent,wherebythecaseproceedstodisposition.DispositionHearing
Thedispositionhearingisanalogoustosentencing.Thedispositionhearingcanimmediatelyfollowtheadjudicationorcanbescheduledforalaterdatedependingonwhetherapredispositionreport(PDR)waspreparedbyDJJ.DJJsubmitsapredispositionreportthatcontainstheirrecommendationsastohowthecaseshouldbedisposed.ThecourtcandeviatefromDJJ’srecommendationsbutmustmaketheappropriatewrittenfindingsinthedispositionorder.Followinganycommitment,offenderscanbeplacedonpost-commitmentsupervisionsuchasprobationand/orconditionalrelease.
3
CommonAcronyms
DJJ FloridaDepartmentofJuvenileJusticeDCF FloridaDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesJPO JuvenileProbationOfficerRAI RiskAssessmentInstrumentJAC JuvenileAssessmentCenterPDR PredispositionReportUFC UnifiedFamilyCourt
4
GeneralTopics
5
GeneralTopics
TableofContents
Appeals.......................................................................................................................9A. Generally................................................................................................................9B. MotionforRehearing.............................................................................................9C. MotionforExtraordinaryRelief...........................................................................10D. AppealtotheAppellateCourt..............................................................................10
AuthorityofCourtoverParents.................................................................................12A. Generally..............................................................................................................12B. NonattendancebyaParentorGuardian.............................................................12C. CostsofRepresentation.......................................................................................13D. ParentingSkillsCourse.........................................................................................13E. RestitutionorCommunityService........................................................................13F. Fees......................................................................................................................13
ChildAdjudicatedNotGuiltybyReasonofInsanity...................................................14A. AdvisetheCourt...................................................................................................14B. NotGuiltybyReasonofInsanity..........................................................................14C. Treatment.............................................................................................................14D. Review..................................................................................................................15
CommitmentstoDJJ..................................................................................................16A. CommitmentProcess...........................................................................................16B. RestrictivenessLevels...........................................................................................16
ConditionalReleaseandPost-CommitmentProbation..............................................18A. ConditionalRelease..............................................................................................18B. Post-CommitmentProbation...............................................................................18
Confidentiality...........................................................................................................20A. Generally..............................................................................................................20B. Exceptions............................................................................................................20
CostofCourt,Care,andSupervision..........................................................................22A. Generally..............................................................................................................22B. AdditionalFees.....................................................................................................22C. RequiredInformation...........................................................................................22D. FeeDetermination...............................................................................................23E. FeeWaiver...........................................................................................................23F. Child’sObligationuponTurning18......................................................................23G. GuardianshipIssues..............................................................................................24H. ParentalLiability...................................................................................................24I. FeeReimbursement.............................................................................................24J. ExtensionofCare..................................................................................................24
Delinquency/DependencyCrossoverCases...............................................................25A. Statistics...............................................................................................................25B. EffectivePracticesinCrossoverCases..................................................................30
6
DepartingfromDJJGuidelines...................................................................................33A. Generally..............................................................................................................33B. E.A.R.v.State.......................................................................................................33
DetentionCriteria.....................................................................................................35A. Pre-CommitmentDetention.................................................................................35B. Post-CommitmentDetention...............................................................................37
Discovery..................................................................................................................39A. RequiredDisclosuretotheChild..........................................................................39B. RequiredDisclosuretoDJJ...................................................................................40C. Limitations............................................................................................................41D. Depositions...........................................................................................................41E. Sanctions..............................................................................................................45F. Record..................................................................................................................45
DiversionaryPrograms..............................................................................................47A. Generally..............................................................................................................47B. TeenCourt............................................................................................................47C. CivilCitation.........................................................................................................49D. JuvenileSubstanceInterventionProgram............................................................50E. Expunction............................................................................................................51
DomesticViolenceIssues..........................................................................................52A. Statistics...............................................................................................................52B. TheeffectsofDomesticViolenceonchildren......................................................53C. HowtoAscertainwhetherDomesticViolencemaybePresent...........................55D. Bestpracticesindelinquencycasesinvolvingdomesticviolence........................57
CommonEvidenceIssues..........................................................................................62A. InvestigatoryStopsversusConsensualEncounters.............................................62B. BodySearches......................................................................................................63C. VehicleSearches...................................................................................................63D. StandardsinaSchoolSetting...............................................................................64E. WeaponsIssues....................................................................................................64
ImmigrationIssues....................................................................................................66InterpretersforForeignLanguages............................................................................68A. IdentifyNeedforInterpretingServices................................................................68B. PerformAssessmenttoDetermineNeeds...........................................................69C. SelectionofInterpreter........................................................................................70D. ProvisionofServices.............................................................................................71E. ModesofInterpretingandServiceDeliveryMethods.........................................71
InterstateCompact....................................................................................................73A. Generally..............................................................................................................73B. RunawaysandEscapees–Procedure..................................................................73C. VoluntaryReturnProcedure................................................................................74D. ProbationersandParolees...................................................................................74E. SupplementaryAgreements.................................................................................74
JurisdictioninDelinquencyProceedings....................................................................75
7
A. Generally..............................................................................................................75B. RetentionofJurisdiction......................................................................................75
JuvenileAssessmentCenter......................................................................................76JuvenileSexOffendersandTheAdamWalshAct......................................................77A. Generally..............................................................................................................77B. WrittenFindingsRequired...................................................................................77C. Registration..........................................................................................................77D. RemovalfromtheRegistry...................................................................................78
JuvenileSexOffenderPrograms................................................................................79A. Generally..............................................................................................................79B. CommunityBasedTreatmentServices................................................................79C. JuvenileSexualOffenderCommitmentPrograms...............................................80
Medicaid/MedicareEligibilityforServicesuponRelease...........................................81Restitution................................................................................................................82RiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI).............................................................................83ServiceofProcess......................................................................................................84SpeedyTrial..............................................................................................................85A. Generally..............................................................................................................85B. DemandforSpeedyTrial......................................................................................85C. MotionforDischarge...........................................................................................85
TransfertoAdultCourt..............................................................................................87A. Waiver..................................................................................................................87B. DirectFiling...........................................................................................................88C. Indictments..........................................................................................................90
UnifiedFamilyCourt–ModelFamilyCourt...............................................................91WalkerPlanApprovalbyJudge.................................................................................93
8
9
AppealsA. Generally
Sections985.534-985.536governtheprocedurefordelinquencyappeals.Therearetwoproceduresthatthetrialcourtmayoversee:motionforrehearingandmotionforextraordinaryrelief.Rules8.130and8.140.Thissectionwilldiscussthesetwoprocedures,andprovideanoverviewofthetrialcourt’sresponsibilitieswhenapartyappealstotheappellatelevel.
B. MotionforRehearing
Afterthecourthasenteredarulingonapretrialmotion,orderofadjudication,ororderwithholdingadjudication,anypartymaymoveforarehearing.Rule8.130(a).Thegroundsforsuchamotioninclude:• Thatthetrialcourterredinthedecisionofanymatteroflawarisingduringthe
hearing.• Thatapartydidnotreceiveafairandimpartialhearing.• Thatanypartyrequiredtobepresentatthehearingwasnotpresent.• Thatthereexistsnewandmaterialevidencewhich,ifintroducedatthehearing,
wouldprobablyhavechangedthecourt’sdecisionandcouldnotwithreasonablediligencehavebeendiscoveredbeforeandproducedatthehearing.
• Thatthecourtiswithoutjurisdictionoftheproceeding.• Thatthejudgmentiscontrarytothelawandevidence.Rule8.130(a)(1)-(6).Amotionforrehearingmustbemadewithin10daysoftheentryoftheorderbeingchallenged,andcanbemadeassoonasthecourtannouncesitsjudgment.Rule8.130(b)(1).Ifthemotionisinwriting,itmustbe“servedasprovidedintheserulesforserviceofotherpleadings.”Rule8.130(b)(2).Thecourtmayruleuponthemotionimmediately.Rule8.130(b)(1).Ifthecourtgrantsthemotion,thecourtmaymodifyorvacatetheorderinallorinpartandallowadditionalproceedingsasitdeemsjust.Rule8.130(c)(1).Thecourtmayenteranewjudgment,andcankeepthechildindetentionpendingfurtherproceedings.Rule8.130(c)(1).Thecourtmayonitsowninitiativevacateormodifyanyorder,aslongasitisdonewithin10daysoftheentryoftheorder.Rule8.130(c)(2).Themotionforrehearingwilltollthetimeforthetakingofanappeal.Rule8.130(b)(3).
10
C. MotionforExtraordinaryRelief
Thecourtmay,onmotionand“uponsuchtermsasarejust,”provideapartyorparty’slegalrepresentativeextraordinaryrelieffromanorder,judgment,orproceeding.Rule8.140(a).Thecourtmaybasesuchreliefon:• Mistake,inadvertence,surprise,orexcusableneglect.• Newlydiscoveredevidencewhichbyduediligencecouldnothavebeen
discoveredintimetomoveforrehearing.• Fraud(intrinsicorextrinsic),misrepresentation,orothermisconductofany
otherparty.• Thattheorderofjudgmentisvoid.Rule8.140(a)(1)-(4).
Themotionmustbemadewithinareasonabletime–forthefirstthreebases,notmorethanoneyearafterthejudgment,order,orproceedingwastaken.Rule8.140(b).
D. AppealtotheAppellateCourt
Thechildorhisorherlegalparentorguardianmayfileanappealatanytimebetweenrenditionofthefinaljudgmentand30daysfollowingrenditionofawrittenorderimposingsentence.Rule9.140(b)(3).Thechildmayappealfromajudgmentbasedonanocontestpleaifthechildexpresslyreservedtherighttoappealadispositiveorderofthecourt,identifyingwithparticularitythepointoflawbeingreserved.M.N.v.State,16So.3d280(Fla.2dDCA2009).Thefailuretopreserveanissueforreviewaftertheentryofapleaisnotajurisdictionalbarbutratheralimitationontheissuesthatcanbeaddressedonappeal.Leonardv.State,So.2d114(Fla.2000).Anissueisnotproperlypreservedforappealunlessthereisanexpressreservationoftherighttoappealaparticularpointoflawandthecourtdeterminesthatitspriororderonthatpointwasdispositive.T.A.R.v.State,2So.3d993(Fla.2dDCA2008).Thestatemayfileappealonalimitednumberofgrounds,Rule9.145(c),within15daysoftherenditionoftheordertobereviewed.Rule9.140(c)(3).Thetakingofanappealdoesnotoperateassupersedeasunlesspursuanttoacourtorder.§985.534(3).Anappealbythestateonanorderfromapre-adjudicatoryhearingwillstaythecaseuntiltheappealisdetermined.§985.535(2).Iftheappellatecourtdeterminesthatthesubjectmatteroftheorderwouldmateriallyassistthestateinprovingitscaseagainstanotherchild(notthechildinthecurrentcase),theappellatecourtcanstaythatchild’scaseuntilthecurrentappealisdetermined.§985.535(2).
11
Whileanappealispending,thetrialcourthasdiscretionoverwhethertoreleasethechildorretainhimorherincustody.§985.535(2).Whenthestateappealsfromarulingonaquestionoflawadversetothestate,theappellatecourtmustdecidethequestion.§985.536(2).
12
AuthorityofCourtoverParentsA. Generally
Parents/guardiansaredeemedresponsibleforprovidingfortheirchildrenanddeterringthemfromcommittingdelinquentacts.§985.02(6).Ifthechilddoescommitadelinquentact,theemotional,legal,andfinancialresponsibilitiesoftheparentsorguardianswithregardtothecare,custody,andsupportofthechildcontinuewhileheorsheisunderthecareofDJJ.§985.02(6).
B. NonattendancebyaParentorGuardian
Theparentsarerequiredtoattendhearingsiftheyhavebeenserved,andfacethepossibilityofcontemptiftheyfailtoobeythesummons.§985.319(7).Ifadiligentsearchwasmadeandtheparentscouldnotbelocated,anAffidavitofDiligentSearchmustbefiled.Fla.R.Juv.Pro.Form8.968.Theformlistsoutseveralsearchmethodsthatmustbeperformedbeforefiling,includingattemptingto:• telephonetheparents;• searchthetelephonedirectoryforinformation;• sendacertifiedlettertothelastknownaddress,returnreceiptrequested;• personallyvisitthelastknownaddress;• inquireofalloftherelativesanyinformationabouttheparents’whereaboutsor
currentaddresses;and• inquireoffederalagencies,mentalandphysicalhealthfacilities,astothe
possiblelocationoftheparents.Onlyafterthesepossibilitiesareexhaustedmaytheformbefiledwiththecourt.Aslongasdiligenteffortsweremadetolocateandservetheparents,theirnonattendancedoesnotbaradetentionorarraignmenthearingfromtakingplace.Rules8.010and8.015.Further,iftheidentityorlocationoftheparentsisunknownafterthediligentsearch,thecourtmustappointaGuardianadLitemforthechild,ifappropriate.§985.319(7).Thenonattendancebyaparentorguardianmayrequirethecontinuanceofanadjudicatory,disposition,restitution,correctionoforders,violationofprobation,orcontempthearing.Ifthecourtordersthechildtopaymonetaryrestitution,itisdonethroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Additionally,thestatemayseekrestitutionorcommunityservicebythechild’sparents;aseparatepetitioncalleda“PetitionforParentalSanctions”mustbefiledwiththecourt,andtheparentsorguardiansmustbeserved.Rules8.030and8.031.Ifeitherofthesesituationshasoccurred,alackofserviceorafailuretoappearmay
13
begroundsforacontinuanceofthehearing,ifapartycanshowgoodcauseforthecontinuance.Rule8.100(e).
C. CostsofRepresentation
Parentsorguardiansareresponsibleforpayingcostsassociatedwithrepresentationofthechild.§985.511.Ifthechildandtheparentsareindigent,thecourtshallappointrepresentation.§985.033(1).Iftheparentsandchildarenotindigentbutrefusetoemploycounsel,thecourtshallappointcounseluntilcounselisprovided.§985.033(3).Costsareimposedasprovidedby§§27.52and938.29.
D. ParentingSkillsCourse
Thecourtmayordertheparentorlegalguardianofachildadjudicateddependent,achildinneedofservices,orachildadjudicateddelinquenttoattendaparentingskillscourse,acceptcounseling,orreceiveotherassistancefromanyotheravailableagency.§985.512.Theparentsorguardiansmayalsobeorderedtoparticipateinsuchcounselingasdeemednecessaryfortherehabilitationofthechild.§985.513(2).
E. RestitutionorCommunityService
Thecourt,havingjurisdictionoverachildadjudicateddelinquent,may(byanorderstatingthefactsuponwhichadeterminationwasmade):• Orderthechild’sparentorguardian,alongwiththechild,torendercommunity
serviceinapublicserviceprogramortoparticipateinacommunityworksproject.Thecourtmayordertheparentsorguardianstoperformcommunityserviceifthecourtfindsthattheydidnotmakeadiligentandgoodfaithefforttopreventthechildfromengagingindelinquentacts.
• Orderthechild’sparentorguardiantopayrestitutioninmoneyorinkindforanydamageorlosscausedbythechild’soffense.Furthermore,theparentmayberesponsibleforanyrestitutionorderedagainstthechild.Thecourtmayretainjurisdictionoverthechildandparentsuntiltherestitutionorderissatisfiedorthecourtordersotherwise.§985.513(1)(a)&(b).
F. Fees
Whenachildisplacedintosecureornonsecuredetentioncarepursuanttoacourtorderfollowingadetentionhearingoradjudicatoryhearing,regardlessofadjudication,theparentsmustpayfeesasprovidedin§985.039.§985.514(1)&(2).Whenthecourtordersanychildtobeprosecutedasanadult,theparentsmustpayfeesasprovidedin§985.039forthechild’scommitmenttoorsupervisionbytheDJJ,§985.514(3),exceptwherethefeeiswaivedorreducedduetosignificantfinancialhardshiporafindingthattheparentwasavictimofthechild’sunlawfulbehaviorandiscooperatingwiththeauthorities.§985.039(3)&(4).
14
ChildAdjudicatedNotGuiltybyReasonofInsanityA. AdvisetheCourt
Ifthechildnamedinthepetitionintendstopleadinsanityasadefense,thechildhastoadvisethecourtinwritingnotlessthan10daysbeforetheadjudicatoryhearingandmustprovidethecourtwithastatementofparticularsshowingasnearlyaspossiblethenatureoftheinsanityexpectedtobeprovedandthenamesandaddressesofwitnessesexpectedtoproveit.Rule8.095(b)(1).Oncefiled,thecourtmayorderthechildtobeexaminedinaccordancewiththeproceduresinRule8.095.Rule8.095(b)(1).Thecourt,upongoodcauseshowingandinitsdiscretion,maywaivetheserequirementsandpermittheintroductionofthedefense,ormaycontinuethehearingforthepurposesofanexaminationinaccordancewithRule8.095.Rule8.095(b)(2).Acontinuancewilltollspeedytrialandthelimitationondetentionpendingadjudication.Rule8.095(b)(2).
B. NotGuiltybyReasonofInsanity
Ifthechildisfoundnotguiltybyreasonofinsanity,thecourtwillentersuchfindinginitsjudgment.Rule8.095(e)(1).Afterarulingofnotguiltybyreasonofinsanity,thecourtwillconductahearingtodeterminewhetherthechildpresentlymeetsthestatutorycriteriaforinvoluntarycommitmenttoaresidentialpsychiatricfacility.Rule8.095(e)(2).Iftherequirementsaremet,thecourtmustcommitthechildtotheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesforimmediateplacementinaresidentialpsychiatricfacility.Rule8.095(e)(2)(A).Iftherequirementshavenotbeenestablished,thecourtwillorderthechildtoreceiverecommendedandappropriatetreatmentatanoutpatientfacility.Rule8.095(e)(2)(B).Ifthecourtdeterminesthattreatmentisnotneeded,thecourtwilldischargethechild.Rule8.095(e)(2)(C).
C. Treatment
Commitmenttoaresidentialpsychiatricfacilityisgovernedbychapters985or394,FloridaStatutes,exceptthatrequestsfordischargeorcontinuedinvoluntarycommitmentmustbedirectedatthecourtthatcommittedthechild.Rule8.095(e)(2)(D).Ifachildisnotcommittedtoaresidentialpsychiatricfacilityandhasbeenorderedtoreceivetreatmentatanoutpatientfacility,anditappearsduringthecourseoftheorderedtreatment,• thattreatmentisnotbeingprovidedorthatthechildnowmeetsthecriteriafor
hospitalization,thecourtmustconductahearingpursuanttosubdivision(e)(2)ofthisrule;or
15
• thatthechildnolongerrequirestreatmentatanoutpatientfacilityorservice,thecourtmustenteranorderdischargingthechild.Rule8.095(e)(2)(E)(i)-(ii).
D. Review
Duringthetimethechildisreceivingtreatment,eitherbyhospitalizationorthroughanoutpatientfacility,anypartymayrequestthecourttoconductahearingtodeterminethenature,quality,andneedforcontinuedtreatment.Thehearingmustbeconductedliketheinitialinvoluntarycommitmenthearing.Rule8.095(e)(2)(F).Nolaterthan30daysbeforereachingage19,achildstillundersupervisionofthecourtunderthisrulemustbeaffordedahearing.Atthehearing,adeterminationmustbemadeastowhetherthechildneedscontinuedhospitalizationortreatment.Ifthecourtdeterminesthatcontinuedcareisappropriate,involuntaryplacementproceedingsshouldbeinitiatedunderchapter394,FloridaStatutes.Ifthecourtdeterminesfurthercareisunnecessary,thechildshouldbedischarged.Rule8.095(e)(2)(G).
16
CommitmentstoDJJ
A. CommitmentProcess
ThecommitmentprocessbeginswhenachildisbroughtforintaketotheDJJ.§985.14(1).Thechildisassignedtoajuvenileprobationofficer(JPO)whowillassessthechild’sneedsandrisks,anddeterminethemostappropriatetreatmentplanandsettingaccordingtothechild’sneedsandrisks.§985.14(1).TheJPOwillprepareapredispositionreport,whichispresentedtothecourtatthedetentionhearing§985.14(3)(a).Thecourtusesthepredispositionreport,alongwithothermaterialsandevidence,inthepre-sentencinghearings.Ifthechildisadjudicateddelinquent,thecourtwillreviewDJJ’srecommendationsforcommitment,and,byanorderstatingthefactsuponwhichthedeterminationwasmade,orderthechildintoaspecifiedcommitmentprogramorlevelofcommitment.§985.441(1).DJJhasfourrestrictivenesslevelsdependingontheprogramneedsandrequiredsupervisionofthechild,asdefinedin§985.03(44)(a)-(d):(a)minimum-risknonresidential,(b)nonsecureresidential,(c)high-riskresidential,and(d)maximum-riskresidential.Achildonprobationforamisdemeanormaynotbecommittedtoarestrictivenesslevelotherthanminimum-risknonresidentialforamisdemeanoroffenseoratechnicalprobationviolation.However,thechildcouldbecommittedtoanonsecureresidentialplacementifthechildhadpreviouslybeenadjudicatedorhadadjudicationwithheldforafelony.Thechildmayalsobecommittedtoanonsecureresidentialplacementifthechildhadpreviouslybeenadjudicatedorhadadjudicationwithheldforthreeormoremisdemeanorswithinthepreceding18months.§985.441(2)(a),(b).
B. RestrictivenessLevels
• Minimum-risknonresidential.Programsorprogrammodelsworkwiththechildwhoremainsinthecommunityandparticipatesatleast5daysperweekinadaytreatmentprogram.Achildassessedandclassifiedforaminimum-risknonresidentialprogramrepresentsaminimumrisktohimself/herselfandtopublicsafety,anddoesnotrequireplacementandservicesinresidentialsettings.Achildinthislevelhasfullaccessto,andresidesin,thecommunity.However,achildwhowasfoundtohavecommitteddelinquentactsthatinvolvedfirearms,thatweresexualoffenses,orthatwouldhavebeenlifefeloniesorfirstdegreefeloniesifcommittedbyanadultmaynotbecommittedtoaprogramatthislevel.
• Nonsecureresidential.Programsatthiscommitmentlevelareresidentialbutmayallowthechildtohaveunsupervisedaccesstothecommunity.Facilitiesare
17
eitherenvironmentallysecure,staffsecure,orhardware-securewithwalls,fencing,orlockingdoors.Facilitiesatthiscommitmentlevelshallprovide24-hourawakesupervision,custody,care,andtreatmentofresidents.Achildassessedandclassifiedforplacementinprogramsatthiscommitmentlevelrepresentsalowormoderaterisktopublicsafetyandrequiresclosesupervision.Thestaffatafacilityatthiscommitmentlevelmaysecludeachildwhoisaphysicalthreattohimorherselforothers.Mechanicalrestraintmayalsobeusedwhennecessary.
• High-riskresidential.Atthiscommitmentlevel,programsareresidentialanddonotallowthechildtohaveaccesstothecommunity,exceptthattemporaryreleaseprovidingcommunityaccessforupto72continuoushoursmaybeapprovedbyacourtforachildwhohasmadesuccessfulprogressinhisorherprograminorderforhimorhertoattendafamilyemergencyor,duringthefinal60daysofhisorherplacement,tovisithisorherhome,enrollinschooloravocationalprogram,completeajobinterview,orparticipateinacommunityserviceproject.High-riskresidentialfacilitiesarehardware-securewithperimeterfencingandlockingdoors.Facilitiesprovide24-hourawakesupervision,custody,care,andtreatmentofresidents.Achildassessedandclassifiedforhigh-riskresidentialplacementrequiresclosesupervisioninastructuredresidentialsetting.Placementinprogramsatthislevelispromptedbyaconcernforpublicsafetythatoutweighsplacementinprogramsatlowercommitmentlevels.Thestaffatafacilityatthiscommitmentlevelmaysecludeachildwhoisaphysicalthreattohimorherselfortoothers.Mechanicalrestraintmayalsobeusedwhennecessary.Thefacilitymayprovideforsinglecelloccupancy.
• Maximum-riskresidential.Programsatthiscommitmentlevelincludejuvenilecorrectionalfacilitiesandjuvenileprisons.Theprogramsarelong-termresidentialanddonotallowthechildtohaveaccesstothecommunity.Facilitiesaremaximum-custody,hardware-securewithperimetersecurityfencingandlockingdoors.Facilitiesprovide24-hourawakesupervision,custody,care,andtreatmentofresidents.Thestaffatafacilityatthiscommitmentlevelmaysecludeachildwhoisaphysicalthreattohimorherselfortoothers.Mechanicalrestraintmayalsobeusedwhennecessary.Thefacilitymustprovideforsinglecelloccupancy,exceptthatchildrenmaybehousedtogetherduringprereleasetransition.Achildassessedandclassifiedforthislevelofplacementrequiresclosesupervisioninamaximumsecurityresidentialsetting.Placementinaprogramatthislevelispromptedbyademonstratedneedtoprotectthepublic.
18
ConditionalReleaseandPost-CommitmentProbationA. ConditionalRelease
Conditionalreleaseis“thecare,treatment,help,andsupervisionprovidedjuvenilesreleasedfromresidentialcommitmentprogramstopromoterehabilitationandpreventrecidivism.”§985.46(1)(a).Commitmentprogramsshouldincluderehabilitativeeffortsforpreparingthechildforasuccessfulreleaseintothecommunity,§985.46(2)(a),withconditionalreleasetransitionplanningoccurringasearlyinthecommitmentprocessaspossible.§985.46(2)(b).ConditionalreleaseservicesareprovidedbyDJJ,andcaninclude:• Assessingachildplacedintoaresidentialcommitmentprogramtodetermine
theneedforconditionalreleaseservicesuponreleasefromtheprogram;• Supervisingthechildwhenheorsheisreleasedintothecommunityfroma
residentialcommitmentfacility;• Providingcounselingandotherservicesasnecessaryforthechild’sfamily;and• Assistingthefamilyintheirpreparationsforthereturnofthechild.§985.46(3).Participationintheeducationalprogrambystudentsofcompulsoryschoolattendanceageismandatoryforachildonconditionalreleasestatus.§985.46(5).Achildofnon-compulsoryschoolattendanceagewhohasnotreceivedhisorherhighschooldiplomaoritsequivalentmustparticipateintheeducationprogram.§985.46(5).Achildwhohasreceivedahighschooldiplomaoritsequivalentandisnotemployedmust,whileintheconditionalreleaseprogram,participatein:• Workforcedevelopmentorothercareerortechnicaleducation,or• Attendcommunitycollegeorauniversity.§985.46(5).
B. Post-CommitmentProbation
Thecourtmayorderachildadjudicateddelinquenttobeplacedintoapost-commitmentprobationprogram.§985.435(1).ThechildmustbeplacedintoaprogramsupervisedbyanauthorizedagentofDJJorbyanyotheragencyorpersonspecificallyauthorizedandappointedbythecourt.§985.435(1).Theprogrammaybeinthechild’shome,thehomeofarelative,oranothersuitableplaceundertheconditionsspecifiedbythecourt.§985.435(1).Theprobationprogrammustincludeapenaltycomponent.§985.435(2).Commonpenaltycomponentsofprobationprogramsinclude:• Restitutioninmoneyorinkind;• Communityservice;
19
• Acurfew;or• Revocationorsuspensionofthechild’sdriver’slicense.§985.435(2)(a)-(d).Othernonresidentialpunishmentsappropriatetotheoffensemaybeorderedbythecourt.§985.435(2)(e).Theprobationprogrammustalsoincludearehabilitationcomponent.§985.435(3).Commonrehabilitationcomponentsincludeparticipationinaschoolorsimilareducationalprogramorparticipationinasubstanceabuseprogram.§985.435(3).Participationintheeducationalprogrambyachildofcompulsoryschoolattendanceageismandatoryforachildonpost-commitmentprobationstatus.§985.46(5).Thechild’sconsentisnotnecessaryforthecourttoorderhimorhertoparticipateinthespecifiedrehabilitationcomponent.§985.435(3).Thecourtmayalsoorderrandomtestingforthepurposesofdetectingandmonitoringtheuseofalcoholorcontrolledsubstance.§985.435(3).Aprobationprogrammayalsoincludeanalternativeconsequencecomponenttoaddressinstancesinwhichachildisnoncompliantwithtechnicalconditionsofhisorherprobationbuthasnotcommittedanynewviolationsoflaw.Iftheprobationprogramincludesthiscomponent,specificconsequencesthatapplytononcompliancewithspecifictechnicalconditionsofprobationmustbedetailedinthedispositionorder.§985.435(4).
Ifthecourtorderspost-commitmentprobation,theperiodofprobationmustbeconsistentwithanytreatmentorrehabilitationneedsidentifiedforthechild.§985.435(5).Ifthecourtordersspecialconditionsofprobation,theymustbepronouncedorallyatdispositionorstatutorilyauthorized.J.W.J.v.State,994So.2d1223(Fla.1stDCA2008).Additionally,theprobationperiodmaynotexceedthetermforwhichsentencecouldbeimposedifthechildwerecommittedfortheoffense.§985.435(5).However,thereisanexception:iftheoffenseisamisdemeanoroftheseconddegreeorequivalenttoaseconddegreemisdemeanor,theprobationperiodmaybeforaperiodofnomorethansixmonths.§985.435(5).Ifthecourtorderspost-commitmentprobation,specifyintheorderthelengthoftheprobation.S.T.v.State,8So.3d1153(Fla.1stDCA2009).Thecourtmayconductjudicialreviewhearingsforachildplacedonprobation,tofosteraccountabilityanddeterminethatthechildiscomplyingwiththeprobationrequirements.§985.435(6).Thecourtmayalsoallowforearlyterminationoftheprobationforachildwhohassubstantiallycompliedwiththetermsoftheprobation.§985.435(6).
20
ConfidentialityA. Generally
Withafewexceptions,allinformationobtainedinadelinquencyproceedingisconfidential,solongastheinformationwasobtainedinthedischargeofanofficialdutybyanyjudge,employeeofthecourt,authorizedagentofDJJ,theParoleCommission,theDepartmentofCorrections,thejuvenilejusticecircuitboards,lawenforcementofficer,orlicensedprofessionalorlicensedcommunityagencyrepresentativewhoisparticipatingintheassessmentortreatmentofajuvenile.§985.04(1).Anyinformationsoobtainedmaybedisclosedonlytotheauthorizedpersonnelofthecourt,theDJJanditsdesignees,theDepartmentofCorrections,theParoleCommission,lawenforcementagents,schoolsuperintendentsandtheirdesignees,licensedprofessionalsorprofessionalagencyrepresentativesparticipatingintheassessmentortreatmentofthejuvenile,oranyotherpersonentitledunderthischaptertoreceiveaccesstotheinformation.§985.04(1).Thecourtmayalso,byorder,allowothersnotlistedaccesstoinformation.§985.04(1).
B. Exceptions
1. Thename,photograph,addressandcrimeorarrestreportofachildisnotconsideredconfidentialandexemptfrom§119.07(1)solelybecauseofthechild’sage,ifthechild:• Hasbeentakenintocustodybyalawenforcementofficerforaviolationof
thelawthat,ifcommittedbyanadult,wouldbeafelony;• Wasfoundbythecourttohavecommittedthreeormoreviolationsofthe
lawthat,ifcommittedbyanadult,wouldbemisdemeanors;• Wastransferredtotheadultcourtsystem,indicted,orwaivedunderthe
provisionofchapter985;• Wastakenintocustodybyalawenforcementofficerforaviolationofthe
lawunder§986.557(2)(b)or(d);or• Wastransferredtotheadultcourtsystembutwassentencedtothejuvenile
justicesystemunder§985.565.§985.04(2)(a)-(e).
2. Thevictimoftheoffensemayreceiveacopyofthejuvenileoffensereport;however,suchinformationmustnotberevealedtoanyoutsideparty,exceptasreasonablynecessarytopursuelegalremedies.§985.04(3).
3. RecordsmaintainedbythecourtorDJJthatpertaintoachildadjudicatedguilty
oforwithadjudicationwithheldforadelinquentactthat,ifcommittedbyanadult,wouldbeacrimeunder§§435.03and435.04,maybeusedonlyformeetingthescreeningrequirementsforpersonnelin§402.3055orunderdepartmentalrule.§985.04(6)(a).Thereleaseofsuchinformationmayonlybe
21
fortheabovepurposes;thecourthasthepowertopunishbycontemptofcourtanyonewhoreleasesorusestheinformationforanyunauthorizedpurposes.§985.04(6)(a).
4. Sexualoffenderandpredatorregistrationinformationisapublicrecordas
providedbylaw.§985.04(6)(b).5. RecordsinthecustodyofDJJregardingchildrenmaybeinspectedonlyonthe
orderoftheSecretaryofJuvenileJusticeorhisorherauthorizedagent,bypeoplewhohavesufficientreasonandonsuchconditionsfortheiruseanddispositionastheSecretaryorhisorherauthorizedagentdeemsproper.§985.04(7)(a).Theinformationmayonlybedisclosedtootheremployeesofthedepartmentwhohaveaneedfortheinformationtoperformtheirofficialduties,tootherpeopleasauthorizedbythedepartment’srules,andonrequesttotheDepartmentofCorrections.§985.04(7)(a).
22
CostofCourt,Care,andSupervisionA. Generally
Whenanychildisplacedintononsecuredetention,probation,orothersupervisionstatuswithDJJ,oriscommittedtotheminimum-risknonresidentialrestrictivenesslevel,thecourtmustordertheparent(s)orguardian(s)topaytoDJJafeeofonedollar($1.00)perdayforeachdaythatthechildisinsuchstatusforthecostofthesupervision.§985.039(1)(a).WhenanychildisplacedintosecuredetentionorplacedoncommittedstatusandthetemporarylegalcustodyofsuchchildisplacedwithDJJ,thecourtmustordertheparent(s)orguardian(s)topaytoDJJafeeoffivedollars($5.00)perdayforthecostofthecareforeachdaythatthechildisinthetemporarylegalcustodyoftheDJJ.§985.039(1)(b).Thesefeesmaybereducedorwaivedonlywithafindingthatthefeeswouldcreatesignificantfinancialhardshiporthattheparentwasavictiminthechild’sdelinquentactandwascooperatingwiththeinvestigationoftheoffense.§985.039(3)&(4).
B. AdditionalFees
Additionally,whenachildisadjudicateddelinquentfor,orpleadsnolocontendereto,amisdemeanor,oracriminaltrafficoffenseunderstatelaw,oraviolationofanymunicipalorcountyordinanceiftheviolationconstitutesamisdemeanorunderstatelaw,thecourtmustassesscourtcosts.§775.083(2).Thecourtcostisfiftydollars($50.00)forafelonyandtwentydollars($20.00)foranyothercrime.Thecourtcanonlyassessthesecostsifthereisanadjudicationofdelinquency;ifadjudicationiswithheld,thecostcannotbeimposed.R.A.V.v.State,22So.3d140(Fla.1stDCA2009).Thecourtmustalsoassessanadditionalfiftydollar($50.00)feeonanychildwhoisadjudicateddelinquentfor,pleadsnolocontenderefor,orhasadjudicationwithheldforanyfelony,misdemeanor,delinquentact,orcriminaltrafficoffenseunderthelawsofthisstateortheviolationofanymunicipalorcountyordinancewhichadoptsbyreferenceanymisdemeanorunderstatelaw.§938.03(1).Thisfeeisinadditiontothefeemandatedin§775.083andanycostsassessedasper§985.039,andcannotbewaived.§938.03(2).
C. RequiredInformation
TheparentofanychildwhohasbeenplacedunderthesupervisionorcareofDJJmustprovidetoDJJhisorher:• name,• address,• socialsecuritynumber,• dateofbirth,• driver'slicensenumberoridentificationcardnumber,and
23
• sufficientfinancialinformationtoassistthecourtindeterminingtheparent'sabilitytopayanyfeeassociatedwiththecostofthechild'ssupervisionorcare.§985.039(2).
IftheparentrefusestoprovideDJJwiththerequiredinformation,thecourtmustordertheparenttoprovidetherequiredinformation.§985.039(2).Thefailureoftheparenttocomplywithanorderofthecourttoprovidetherequiredinformationconstitutescontemptofcourt,andthecourtmaypunishtheparentaccordingly.§985.039(2).
D. FeeDetermination
Atadetentionordispositionhearing,thecourtwillreceivetherequiredinformationaswellasanyotherverbalorwritteninformationofferedbytheparentofthechildbeingplacedinDJJ’scareandsupervisionastohisorherabilitytopayanyfeeimposedpursuanttothissectionandwhetherthepaymentofsuchfeewillcreateasignificantfinancialhardship.§985.039(3).Thecourtmaydividetheobligationforthefeebetweeneachparentinamanneritdeemsappropriate;however,thetotalamountofthedailyfeemaynotexceedtheamountsspecifiedinthissection.§985.039(3).Anyfindingmadebythecourtastotheabilityoftheparenttopaysuchfee,includinganyfindingofindigencyorsignificantfinancialhardship,mustbeinwritingandcontainadetaileddescriptionofthefactssupportingsuchfinding.§985.039(3).Ifthecourtmakesafindingofindigencyandsignificantfinancialhardship,thecourtmustwaivethefeeorreduceittoanamountdeemedappropriate.§985.039(3).Anyorderthatfeesaretobepaid,feesaretobepaidinareducedamount,orfeesarewaived,mustbeincludedinthedetentionordispositionorder.§985.039(5).Afailuretoincludeanythingregardingcostsintheorderwillmeanthattheparentisdeemedtohavetopaythefullamountasspecifiedbylaw.§985.039(5).
E. FeeWaiver
Thecourtmayreduceorwaivethefeeastoeachparentifthecourtmakesafindingontherecordthattheparentwasthevictimofthedelinquentactorviolationoflawforwhichthechildhasbeenplacedunderthesupervisionorcareofthedepartmentandthattheparentiscooperatingorhascooperatedwiththeinvestigationoftheoffense.§985.039(4).
F. Child’sObligationuponTurning18
Forachildwhoreachestheageof18priortothedetentionordispositionhearing,thecourtmaydirectanorderregardingcostofcareandfeeassessmentstothechild,ratherthantothechild'sparent.§985.039(6).Ifachildreaches18whileunderthesupervisionorcareofthedepartment,thecourtmay,uponpropermotionofanyparty,holdahearingtodeterminewhetheranypartyshouldbe
24
furtherobligatedtopayanyfeeassociatedwithcostofthesupervisionorcareofthechild.§985.039(6).Ifthecourtdoesnotenteranorderwhenthechildreachestheageof18whileunderthesupervisionandcareofDJJ,itispresumedthattheparentmustpayorcontinuetopaythefeesspecifiedin§985.039(6).Anyorderenteredpursuantto§985.039(6)mustincludespecificfindingsastowhatfeesareordered,reduced,orwaivedastothechild.
G. GuardianshipIssues
Ifanyorderenteredpursuantto§985.039affectstheguardianshipofanestate,acertifiedcopymustbedeliveredtothejudgethathasjurisdictionovertheguardianshipoftheestate.§985.039(8).
H. ParentalLiability
Noparentorchildshallbeliableforanyfeeprovidedinthissectionunless:• thechildisadjudicateddelinquent,orhasadjudicationofdelinquencywithheld,
fortheoffensethatgaverisetothesupervisionorcare;or• thechildisfoundtohaveviolatedanorderofthecourt,includinganyorderof
supervisionorcare,andthecostsareassociatedwiththeviolationofsuchorder.§985.039(12)(a)&(b).
I. FeeReimbursement
Ifanyfundsarepaidforthesupervisionorcareofachildwhoisdeterminednottomeetthecriteriaspecifiedabove,thosefundsmustberefundedtothepayorimmediately.§985.039(12).
J. ExtensionofCare
Undernocircumstancesmaythecourtorthedepartmentextendthechild'slengthofstayinthedepartment'ssupervisionorcaresolelyforthepurposeofcollectingthefeesspecifiedinthissection.§985.039(11).
25
Delinquency/DependencyCrossoverCasesCrossover child: a child who is under the dual jurisdiction of the delinquency anddependencycourts,thoughnotnecessarilyunderthecareandsupervisionofeitherDJJorDCF.
A. Statistics
Researchhasshownthatvictimsofphysicalabuse/neglectareatanincreasedriskofbecomingcrossoverchildrenandengagingindelinquentacts.1In1995,researchersfoundthatbetween9%and29%ofdependencychildrencrossedoverintodelinquencycourt.2Amorerecentstudyfoundthatthedelinquencyrateforchildrenpreviouslyabusedorneglectedis47%higherthanforthosewithnosuchhistory.3Crossoverchildrentypicallycrossintothedelinquencycourtforthefirsttimearound14yearsofage,althoughdelinquentordisruptivebehaviorcanbeginasearlyas7yearsofage.4Thereareseveralfactorsthathavebeenfoundtoinfluencethechancesadependency-onlychildwillbecomeacrossoverchild.Eachofthefollowingfactors,ifpresent,hasbeenfoundtoincreasethelikelihoodofcrossingover.
MaltreatmentStudieshaveshownthattheabuse/neglectwhichcausesachildtofallunderthedependencycourt’sjurisdictioncanalsoaffecthisorherlikelihoodofbecomingacrossoverchild.Specifically,abuseorneglectlimitedtoadolescenceorcontinuousabuseorneglectthroughoutchildhoodcanleadtoawidevarietyofnegativeoutcomes,chiefamongthemjuveniledelinquency.5Suchabuseand/orneglecthasbeenestimatedtoincreasetheriskofarrestasajuvenileby55%andincreasethe
1DeniseHerz&JosephRyan.BuildingMultisystemApproachesinChildWelfareandJuvenileJustice.NationalAssociationofPublicChildWelfareAdministrators(2008)at34.Theauthorsciteto8otherresearchprojectsthatsupportthisproposition,includingKelly,B.T.;Thornberry,T.;&Smith,C.Inthewakeofchildmaltreatment.OJJDPJuvenileJusticeBulletin.Washington,D.C.(1997);Ryan,J.P.&Testa,M.K.Childmaltreatmentandjuveniledelinquency:Investigatingtheroleofplacementandplacementinstability.27ChildrenandYouthServicesReview227-249(2005);andWiig,J.K.;Widom,C.S.;&Tuell,J.A.Understandingchildmaltreatmentandjuveniledelinquency:Fromresearchtoeffectiveprogram,practice,andsystemicsolutions.Washington,DC:ChildWelfareofAmericaPress(2002).2ShayBilchik&MichaelNash.ChildWelfareandJuvenileJustice:TwoSidesoftheSameCoin.JuvenileandFamilyJusticeToday16(Fall2008)at17.3AmericanBarAssociation.PolicyandReportonCrossoverandDualJurisdictionYouths(February2008).4TerenceP.Thornberry,DavidHuizinga,&RolfLoeber.TheCausesandCorrelatesStudies:FindingsandPolicyImplications.9(1)JuvenileJustice3(2004)at14.5Supranote1at38-39.
26
riskofaviolentcrimearrestasajuvenileby96%.6However,ifthemaltreatmentislimitedtoearlychildhood,andendsbeforeadolescence,thechildmaynotbeimpactedsignificantlyenoughforjuveniledelinquencytobeacommonoutcome.7Childhoodabuseingeneralincreasestheoddsoffuturedelinquencyby29%,althoughthelikelihoodofbeingarrestedasachildincreasesby59%.8Inonestudy,researchersfoundthatmaltreatedyouthswere4.8timesmorelikelytobearrestedaschildrenand11timesmorelikelytobearrestedforaviolentcrimethanmatchedcontrolchildrenwhohadnotbeenmaltreated.9Further,maltreatedchildrenwereyoungeratthetimeoftheirarrestandcommittednearlytwiceasmanyoffenses.10Theimplicationthatchildrenwhoareabusedand/orneglectedtendtoengageindelinquentactsatanearlyageisnoteworthy.Asonestudynoted,youngoffendersare3timesmorelikelytobecomeseriousviolentoffenders.11Thus,thereisarealneedtounderstandtherelationshipbetweenchildmaltreatmentandjuveniledelinquency.
NumberofPlacementsAfactorthathasbeencloselytiedtodelinquencyisthenumberofout-of-homeplacementsachildhasexperienced.Evenonefostercareplacementsignificantlyraisesthelikelihoodthatachildwillcomeunderdelinquencycourtjurisdiction.12Nationaldatafrom2008indicatedthatchildrenindependencysystemsacrossthecountryhadanaverageof3.2out-of-homeplacementsperchild,withanaveragetimeincareperplacementof15.3months.13ResearchersfromastudyinCaliforniareportedsimilarresults.Ninety-eightpercentofallcrossoverchildrenhadatleastoneout-of-homeplacement.14Sixty-threepercenthadbeenplacedwitharelativeatsometime,and62%hadbeenplacedinagrouphome.DatafromFloridabetweenOctoberof2007andSeptemberof2008indicatesthatthereisadirectcorrelationbetweenincreasedplacementsandthelengthoftimethechildremains
6Idat34.7Idat38-39.8JanetK.Wiig,withJohnA.Tuell.GuidebookforJuvenileJusticeandChildWelfareSystemCoordinationandintegration:AFrameworkforImprovedOutcomes.ChildWelfareLeagueofAmerica(2008)atxiii-xiv.9BernardineH.Watson.Multi-ProblemYouth:AGrowingConcern.StoneleighCenter(2008)at4.10Supranote9atxiii-xiv.11JosephP.Ryan,DeniseHerz,PedroM.Hernandez,JaneMarieMarshall.MaltreatmentandDelinquency:InvestigatingChildWelfareBiasinJuvenileJusticeProcessing.29ChildrenandYouthServicesReview1035(2007)at1045.12Supranote4.13PeterJ.Pecora.WhyShouldChildWelfareFocusonPromotingPlacementStability?CW360:PromotingPlacementStability(Spring2010)at4.14Supranote1at50.
27
inDCF’scare.15Forchildrenincareforlessthantwelvemonths,approximately83%hadtwoorfewerplacementsettings.16However,forchildrenincarebetween12and24months,61%hadtwoorfewerplacementsettings.17Finally,forchildrenincareforlongerthan24months,only33%hadtwoorfewerplacementsettings.18Further,placementdisruptionhasbeenlinkedtoattachmentdisordersandotherbehavioralandemotionalproblemsinchildren.19Inparticular,attachmentdisorderssuchasReactiveAttachmentDisordermayfrequentlyresultfromanincreasednumberofplacements,asthefrequencyofchangesinplacementsandimpermanenceofcareinhibitachildfromdevelopinghealthy,secureattachmentswithacaregiver.20Themorechangesincaregiverachildexperiences,themorelikelythechildistodevelopanattachmentdisorderorbehavioralproblem.21Instabilityinthedependencysystem,whichresultsinahighernumberofplacements,hasalsobeenlinkedtoratesofdelinquency.Childrenwithmultipleplacementsaremorelikelytoenterthedelinquencysystem.22Inonestudy,maleswith3placementswere1.5timesmorelikelytobecomedelinquent,andmaleswith4ormoreplacementswere2.1timesmorelikelytobecomedelinquentascomparedtomaleswithonlyoneplacement.23
PlacementSettingStudieshaveshownthatchildreninsubstitutecaresettingsareapproximatelytwotimesmorelikelytoengageindelinquencyascomparedtothosereceivingin-homecare.24Specifically,grouphomesettingsappeartobethemostworrisome;inaLosAngelesstudy,childrenwithatleastonegrouphomeplacementhad2.5timesgreaterriskofdelinquencyascomparedtosimilarchildreninotherfostercare
15FosteringCourtImprovement.ChildrenandFamilyServicesReviewMeasuresDuringOctober2007throughSeptember2008.Availableonlineathttp://fosteringcourtimprovement.org/fl/DCFDistrict/cfsr2_summary.html.16Id.17Id.18Id.19DanaK.Smith,ElizabethStormshak,PatriciaChamberlain,andRachelBridgesWhaley.PlacementDisruptioninTreatmentFosterCare.9(3)JournalofEmotionalandBehavioralDisorders200(Fall2001)at200.20BethTroutman,SusanRyan,andMichelleCardi.TheEffectsofFosterCarePlacementonYoungChildren’sMentalHealth.16(1)ProtectingChildren(2000)at30.21Id.22Supranote20at36.23Id.24Idat35.
28
settings.25Inthatstudy,2106childrenwerefoundtobeassociatedwithatleastonearrest.26Ofthatnumber,1671(79%)experiencedtheirfirstarrestwhileinsubstitutecaresettings.27Andofthatnumber,675(40%)ofthearrestsoccurredwhiletheadolescentwasinagrouphomeplacement.28Thisstatisticbecomesmoreconcerningwhenthenatureofthearrestisconsidered.Atleastone-third(31%)ofallarrestswererelatedtoplacement,andtwo-thirds(66%)ofallplacement-relatedoffensesoccurredatagrouphome.29Childreningrouphomeswerefoundtobehalfaslikelytobearrestedforaweapons-relatedoffenseasthosenotingrouphomes.30However,grouphomechildrenarethreetimesaslikelytobearrestedforathreat-relatedoffense,andtwiceaslikelytobearrestedforaviolentoffense.31
PeerContagionAnadditionalfactorthatmayaffectadolescentsispeercontagion–typesofnegativeexposureandsocializationprocessesthatarelikelytoshapenegativebehaviorsandattitudes.32Peercontagioncanincreaseproblembehaviorsandnegativelifeoutcomesthroughoutadolescence.33Prolongedexposuretohigh-riskpeershasanunintendedeffectofheighteningdeviantbehaviorviasocialrelationships.34Inthedependencysystem,delinquencycanemergeasachildexperiencesincreasedplacementinstability.Thebondsthechildformsmaybestrongerwithotherdelinquentchildren,duetotheunstableenvironment,andwillresultintheintakeandinternalizationofdelinquentbeliefs.35Oncethesedelinquentpatternsform,theyhavea“feedbackeffect,furthercompromisingone’sbondwithconventionalsocietalnorms.”36Theconceptofdeviantpatternsincludessmoking,alcoholproblems,aggression,anddelinquency,amongothers.37
GangMembership
25JosephP.Ryan,JaneMarieMarshall,DeniseHerz,PedroM.Hernandez.JuvenileDelinquencyinChildWelfare:InvestigatingGroupHomeEffects.30(9)ChildrenandYouthServicesReview1088(2008).26Id.27Id.28Id.29Supranote1at36-37.30Supranote25.31Id.32Supranote1at36.33Id.34Id.35Idat42.36Id.37Supranote25.
29
Peercontagionisanissue,especiallyinthechildwelfaresettingandgrouphomeplacementinparticular,butanotheraspectofpeercontagioncanbeseeningangmembership.InastudydoneinNewYork,approximately30%ofthechildrenstudiedjoinedagangatsomepointbetweentheagesof14and18.38Gangmembersaccountedforthemajorityofalldelinquencyinthestudy,withgangmembersinvolvedin63%ofalldelinquentacts,82%ofseriousdelinquencies,70%ofdrugsales,and54%ofallarrests.39Further,theresearchersfoundthatgangmembershadahigherrateofdelinquencyduringtheperiodofgangmembership,butnotbeforeorafterthatperiod.40AstudyinDenverconfirmedtheNewYorkfindings.IntheDenverstudy,gangmembersaccountedforapproximately80%ofallseriousandviolentcrime(excludinggangfights).41Thesefindingssuggestthatgangmembershipfacilitatesdelinquentprocessesandpatterns,makingdelinquencyamuchmorelikelyoutcome.
DepthofInvolvementResearchsuggeststhat“aspenetrationofthesystemdeepened,”crossoverchildrenrepresentlargerportionsofdelinquencycases.42InanArizonastudy,only1%ofinformaldiversiondelinquencycaseswerecrossover,comparedto7%ofprobationsupervisioncasesand42%ofprobationplacementcases.43Onestudyindicatedthatjudicialdecisionsresultingindetentionarestronglyassociatedwithachildbeinginout-of-homeplacementatthetimeoftheoffense,previouscrossoverreferrals,ahistoryofrunningaway,andsubstanceabuseproblems.44
RecidivismCrossoverchildrenhavebeenfoundtobeasmuchastwiceaslikelytorecidivateascomparedtodelinquency-onlychildren.45Olderchildrenaresignificantlymorelikelytorecidivate,andchildrenexhibitingtruancypatternsaremorethantwiceaslikelytorecidivate.46Further,thetrendtorecidivatetypicallycontinuesintoadulthood.Onestudyfoundthat,bytheageof28,89%ofboysand81%ofgirlsinthestudywererearrested,and85%oftheboysand63%ofthegirlswereconvicted.47In
38Supranote5at9.39Id.40Idat10.41Id.42Supranote1at43.43Id.44Supranote3at19.45Supranote1at53.46DeniseC.Herz,JosephP.Ryan,andShayBilchik.ChallengesFacingCrossoverYouth:AnExaminationofJuvenile-JusticeDecisionMakingandRecidivism.48(2)FamilyCourtReview305(2010)at315.47RebeccaColman,DoHanKim,SusanMitchell-Herzfeld,ThereseA.Shady.Long-TernConsequencesofDelinquency:ChildMaltreatmentandCrimeinEarlyAdulthood.(2008)atexecutivesummary7.
30
termsofcross-systeminvolvement,89%ofdelinquentboysand87%ofdelinquentgirlswerearrestedoridentifiedasconformedperpetratorsofabuseorneglectbeforeage28.48
B. EffectivePracticesinCrossoverCases
CourtcommunicationThecourtshouldaskateveryhearingwhetherthepartiesinvolvedinthedelinquencyproceedingareinvolvedinanyrelateddependencycases.49Ifotherrelatedcasesareidentified,thecourtshouldcommunicatewiththejudgeorjudgesthatarehearingtheothercasesinvolvingthecrossoverchild.Theabilitytoidentifyacrossoverchildcanpreventavarietyofproblems,includingduplicationofefforts,miscommunication,andextendeddetention,50byincreasingcoordinationbetweencourtshearingcasesinvolvingthecrossoverchild.Inter-agencycollaborationStudieshaveshownthatwherecoordinationislacking,childfunctioningandwellbeingisnegativelyimpacted.51Oneofthemosteffectivepracticesthecourtcanengageinisensuringthatthechildgetsthehelpandresourcesheorsheneedsfromboththedependencyanddelinquencyagencies.52Thecourtmayinquire,whereappropriate,oftheagencyrepresentativesastothestateoftheprovisionofservicestothechildbybothagencies.
DispositionalconsiderationsTraditionaldelinquencypracticescanfailtoadequatelyaddresscommonconsequencesoftrauma,andmayre-traumatizeavulnerablechild.53Thus,whenthecourtreviewspossibledispositionaloutcomesforacrossoverchild,thecourtshouldconsidernotjustthecrossoverchild’sactionsbutalsohislivingsituation.54Suchacomprehensiveexaminationofthefamily’sneedsandstrengths,combinedwithanassessmentbyDJJorDCFtodeterminewhetherthechildisatriskofabuse
48Idatexecutivesummary9.49Supranote3at19.50GeneSiegel,andRachaelLord.WhenSystemsCollide:ImprovingCourtPracticesandProgramsinDualJurisdictionCases.56JuvenileandFamilyCourtJournal39(2005)at40.51SaraMunson,&MadelynFreundlich.DoubleJeopardy:YouthinFosterCareWhoCommitDelinquentActs.25Children’sLegalRightsJournal9(2005)at9.52Seeforexamples:GeneSiegel,andRachaelLord.WhenSystemsCollide:ImprovingCourtPracticesandProgramsinDualJurisdictionCases.56JuvenileandFamilyCourtJournal39(2005);andMichaelNash,ShayBilchik.ChildWelfareandJuvenileJustice–TwoSidesoftheSameCoin,PartII.JuvenileandFamilyJusticeToday22(Winter2009).53Supranote47atexecutivesummary12.54Supranote3at19.
31
orneglect,canensurethatthecourthasthenecessaryknowledgetoappropriatelydeterminethecrossoverchild’soutcome.55Possibledispositionaloutcomesthatthecourtmayconsiderincrossovercases,inadditiontotraditionaldispositionaloptions,includeorderingtheparentorlegalguardianofacrossoverchildadjudicateddelinquenttoattendacourseofinstructioninparentingskills,andorderingthechildand/orparentorguardiantoacceptcounselingortoreceiveotherassistancefromanyagencyinthecommunity.56Theseapproachesresultinreducedrecidivism,fewerinstitutionalcommitments,lesscriminalityamongparentsandolderchildren,improvededucationalstatus,andimprovedfamilyfunctioning,amongotherpositiveresults.57
ConfidentialityofInformationThecourtshouldmakecertainthatanyinformationgatheredfromacrossoverchildaspartofadiagnosticevaluationisnotlaterusedagainstthechildasevidenceincourttosupportafindingofguiltortoenhancepunishment.58Anysuchusewould“compromisethetherapeuticprocessintendedtohelptroubledfosteryouthbyusingitasanopportunityfortheirself-incriminationratherthanasameanstopromotetheprocessofrehabilitationandrecoveryfromtheirvictimization.”59
AlternativecourtmodelsIfthecourtusesanalternativecourtmodel,suchastheUnifiedFamilyCourtmodel,thecourtmayhearallcasesinvolvingthecrossoverchildandhisorherfamily,asunifiedfamilycourtsoperateonthe“onefamily,onejudge”principle.Formoreinformationaboutcrossoverchildreninunifiedfamilycourts,seeGeneralTopics.TheBreakthroughSeriesCollaborativeTeamModelAlsoknownasthe“GeorgetownModel,”theBreakthroughSeriesCollaborativeTeamModelisintendedtoprovideacollaborativeframeworkforcourtsdealingwithcrossoverchildren.Themodelguidescourtsandagenciestoworktogetherandshareinformationandduties.Themodelencouragesfamilyparticipationandemphasizesthatcrossoverchildrenandtheirfamilieshavestrengthswhich,ifusedproperly,wouldcreateimprovedservicesforthechildren.60Thismodeliscurrentlybeingusedin11thcircuit,withexpansionstothe13thand17thcircuitsplanned.
55Id.56F.S.A.§985.512.57Supranote50at51.58Supranote4.59Id.60LorrieLutz,MaconStewart,withcontributionsfromLymanLegters.CrossoverYouthPracticeModel.CenterforJuvenileJusticeReform(2008)at17.Formoreinformationonthismodel,pleaseseethe
32
TimemanagementThecourtmayconsiderreservingablockoftimeonthecourt’scalendarspecificallyforcrossovercasehearings.61Coordinatingtheschedulesofthepartiesinvolvedcouldbestreamlinedbyareservedperiodoftime62,asopposedtoanunmanagedsetofcrossovercasesinterspersedthroughoutthenon-crossovercases.Additionally,schedulingfortime-certainhearingscanimprovethepredictabilityofcourteventsandenhancethecredibilityandpublicperceptionofthecourt.63
CourtroompracticesCrossoverchildrenoftencomeunderthejurisdictionofthedependencycourtasaresultofabuseinthehome.Thecourtinadelinquencyproceedingshouldbeawareofthedynamicsoffamilydomesticabuseandhowtheymayaffectthechildorthechild’sparentsorguardians.Forinformationoncourtroompracticeswheredomesticviolenceispresent,seeGeneralTopics.
centerforJuvenileJusticeReformwebsite,availableonlineathttp://cjjr.georgetown.edu/pm/practicemodel.html.61Supranote50at45.62Id.63Idat46.
33
DepartingfromDJJGuidelinesA. Generally
Section985.433(7)detailstheroleofDJJinthedispositionofachildadjudicateddelinquent.DJJpreparesarecommendationforthecourt,indicatingthemostappropriateplaceandtreatmentplan,specificallyidentifyingthelevelofrestrictivenessappropriateforthechild.§985.433(7)(a).Thecourtisrequiredtoconsiderthatrecommendationwhendeterminingdispositionofthechild.§985.433(7)(a).However,thecourtisnotobligatedtofollowDJJ’srecommendation.Accordingto§985.433(7)(b),thecourtcanfollowDJJ’srecommendationormayorderthechildintoadifferentplacementlevel.Anydeviationmustbesupportedbyreasonsrecordedbythecourtandsupportedbyapreponderanceoftheevidence.§985.433(7)(b).
B. E.A.R.v.State
InJanuaryof2009,TheFloridaSupremeCourtreleasedanopiniononacase,E.A.R.v.State,4So.3d614(Fla.2009).Inthatcase,thecourtexaminedwhatstandardsatisfiedtherequirementssetforthin§985.433(7)(b)(“statefortherecordthereasonsthatestablishbyapreponderanceoftheevidencewhythecourtisdisregardingtheassessmentofthechildandtherestrictivenesslevelrecommendedbythedepartment.”),astheDistrictCourtsofAppealweresplitonthatissue.TheFirst,Second,andFifthDistrictCourtsofAppealrequiredthejudgetospecificallyidentifythecharacteristicsoftherestrictivenesslevelimposedwithregardtotheneedsofthejuvenile.TheFourthDistrictheldthatsucharequirementdidnotapply.1TheFloridaSupremeCourtheldthattheFloridaStatutesnotonlyrequirethatthecourtstateitsreasonsfordepartingfromDJJ’sguidelines“ontherecord”andthatthereasonsbesupportedbyapreponderanceoftheevidence,butalsothatthereasonssuppliedbythecourtexplain,support,andjustifywhyonerestrictivenesslevelismoreappropriatethananother.Acourtmust:
(1)Articulateanunderstandingoftherespectivecharacteristicsoftheopposingrestrictivenesslevelsincluding(butnotlimitedto)thetypeof child that each restrictiveness level is designed to serve, thepotential "lengths of stay" associated with each level, and the
1ThissummarytakenfromtheOfficeofCourtImprovement’sCaseLawUpdate,February2009,availableonlineathttp://flcourts.org/gen_public/family/bin/OSCA-OCI-Case-Law-Update-February.pdf.
34
divergenttreatmentprogramsandservicesavailabletothejuvenileattheselevels;and
(2) Then logically and persuasively explain why, in light of thesedifferingcharacteristics,onelevelisbettersuitedtoservingboththerehabilitativeneedsofthejuvenile—intheleastrestrictivesetting—andmaintaining the ability of the State to protect the public fromfurtheractsofdelinquency.2
Appellatecourtshavesubsequentlyanalyzedhowjuvenilecourtsareaffectedbythisopinion.Forexample,theFifthDCA,inB.C.v.State,29So.3d386(Fla.5thDCA2010),heldthatacourtmaysentenceachildtoconsecutiveratherthanconcurrentsentences,asrecommendedbyDJJ,aslongasthelevelthechildissentencedtoisthatrecommendedbyDJJ.TheFifthDCAreasonedthatsuchadeterminationiswithinthecourt’straditionaldiscretionandnotprohibitedbyE.A.R.v.State.Further,theFirstDCA,inJ.B.S.v.State,90So.3d961(Fla.1stDCA2012),heldthatacourtmaydeviatefromaprobationrecommendationandfollowasubsequentrestrictivenessrecommendation.Likewise,theFirstDCAreasonedthatsuchadeterminationiswithinthecourt’straditionaldiscretionandnotprohibitedbyE.A.R.v.State.However,aprobationrecommendation,withoutanyalternativeanalysisorrestrictivenessrecommendation,isinsufficienttoallowthecourttoproceedwithafinalcommitmentdispositionorder.TheFirstDCAreasonedthatsuchadeterminationisprohibitedbyE.A.R.v.State.B.K.A.v.State,122So.3d928(2013).InbothJ.B.S.v.StateandB.K.A.v.State,theFirstDistrictmadeitclearthatthedecisiontocommitornottocommitisthatofthecourtandnotarecommendationofDJJ.Accordingly,anE.A.R.analysisdoesnotapplytoinitialdeterminationsofcommitment.See§985.433.
2E.A.R.v.State,4So.3d614(Fla.2009)at638.
35
DetentionCriteriaA. Pre-CommitmentDetention
Section985.255detailsthecriteriacourtswillusewhendeterminingwhetherachildmaybeplacedintopre-commitmentdetention.Acourtcannotdetainachildifthecriteriaarenotmet.Ifachildhasbeentakenintocustodyandplacedintodetentioncarepriortoadetentionhearing,thecourtmaycontinuetodetainthechildifthechildmeetsanyofthefollowing,from§985.255(1)(a)-(j):• Thechildisallegedtobeanescapeefromaresidentialcommitmentprogram;an
absconderfromanonresidentialcommitmentprogram,probationprogram,orconditionalreleasesupervision;orisallegedtohaveescapedwhilebeinglawfullytransportedtoorfromaresidentialcommitmentprogram.
• Thechildiswantedinanotherjurisdictionforanoffensewhich,ifcommittedbyanadult,wouldbeafelony.
• Thechildischargedwithadelinquentactorviolationoflawandrequestsinwritingthroughlegalcounseltobedetainedforprotectionfromanimminentphysicalthreattohisorherpersonalsafety.
• Thechildischargedwithcommittinganoffenseofdomesticviolenceandisdetainedasprovidedbelow.
• Thechildischargedwithpossessionordischargingafirearmonschoolpropertyinviolationof§790.115.
• Thechildischargedwithacapitalfelony,alifefelony,afelonyofthefirstdegree,afelonyoftheseconddegreethatdoesnotinvolveaviolationofchapter893,orafelonyofthethirddegreethatisalsoacrimeofviolence,includinganysuchoffenseinvolvingtheuseorpossessionofafirearm.
• Thechildischargedwithanyseconddegreeorthirddegreefelonyinvolvingaviolationofchapter893oranythirddegreefelonythatisnotalsoacrimeofviolence,andthechild:o Hasarecordoffailuretoappearatcourthearingsafterbeingproperly
notifiedinaccordancewiththeRulesofJuvenileProcedure;o Hasarecordoflawviolationspriortocourthearings;o Hasalreadybeendetainedorhasbeenreleasedandisawaitingfinal
dispositionofthecase;o Hasarecordofviolentconductresultinginphysicalinjurytoothers;oro Isfoundtohavebeeninpossessionofafirearm.
• Thechildisallegedtohaveviolatedtheconditionsofthechild'sprobationorconditionalreleasesupervision.However,achilddetainedunderthisparagraphmaybeheldonlyinaconsequenceunitasprovidedin§985.439.Ifaconsequenceunitisnotavailable,thechildshallbeplacedinnonsecuredetentionwithelectronicmonitoring.
36
• Thechildisdetainedonajudicialorderforfailuretoappearandhaspreviouslywillfullyfailedtoappear,afterpropernotice,foranadjudicatoryhearingonthesamecaseregardlessoftheresultsoftheriskassessmentinstrument.Achildmaybeheldinsecuredetentionforupto72hoursinadvanceofthenextscheduledcourthearingpursuanttothisparagraph.Thechild'sfailuretokeeptheclerkofcourtanddefensecounselinformedofacurrentandvalidmailingaddresswherethechildwillreceivenoticetoappearatcourtproceedingsdoesnotprovideanadequategroundforexcusalofthechild'snonappearanceatthehearings.
• Thechildisdetainedonajudicialorderforfailuretoappearandhaspreviouslywillfullyfailedtoappear,afterpropernotice,attwoormorecourthearingsofanynatureonthesamecaseregardlessoftheresultsoftheriskassessmentinstrument.Achildmaybeheldinsecuredetentionforupto72hoursinadvanceofthenextscheduledcourthearingpursuanttothisparagraph.Thechild'sfailuretokeeptheclerkofcourtanddefensecounselinformedofacurrentandvalidmailingaddresswherethechildwillreceivenoticetoappearatcourtproceedingsdoesnotprovideanadequategroundforexcusalofthechild'snonappearanceatthehearings.
Ifthechildhasbeenchargedwithcommittingadomesticviolenceoffense,andthechilddoesnotmeetanyoftheotherdetentioncriteriaabove,thecourtmayorderthechildtobeheldinsecuredetentionifthecourtmakesspecificwrittenfindingsthatrespitecareisnotavailableforthechild,and/orthatitisnecessarytosecurelydetainthechildtoprotectthevictimfrominjury.§985.255(2).Ifthechildisdetainedbysuchwrittenfindings,thecourtmustholdahearing48hourslatertodeterminewhetherthechildshouldcontinuetobedetained.§985.255(2).Thechildmaycontinuetobedetainedonlyifthecourtmakesspecificwrittenfindingsthatcontinueddetentionisnecessarytoprotectthevictimfrominjury.§985.255(2).Anychildheldthuslymaynotbedetainedforlongerthanthetimelimitssetforthin§985.26.Anychildwhoisdetainedunder§985.255mustbegivenadetentionhearingwithin24hoursafterbeingtakenintocustody,todeterminetheexistenceofprobablecausethatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationofthelawthatheorsheischargedwithandtheneedforcontinueddetention.§985.255(3)(a).IfthecourtordersaplacementmorerestrictivethanindicatedbytheresultsoftheRAI,thecourtmuststate,inwriting,clearandconvincingreasonsforsuchplacement.§985.255(3)(b).Ifthecourtordersdetentionbutdoesnotincludeareleasedateintheorder,DJJmustrequestthecourtsetoneonthesamedatethechildisplacedintodetentioncare.Ifsubsequenthearingsareneededforsafetyplanning,theinitialordershall
37
reflectthatthenextreviewhearingshallbeheldwithinthreedaysaftertheinitialdetentionplacement.§985.255(3)(c).Achildmaynotremainindetentionunderaspecialdetentionorderformorethan21days,unlessanadjudicatoryhearingforthecasehascommencedingoodfaith.§985.26(2).However,iftheoffensewouldbe,ifcommittedbyanadult,acapitalfelony,alifefelony,afelonyofthefirstdegree,orafelonyoftheseconddegreeinvolvingviolenceagainstanindividual,thecourtmay,uponagoodcauseshowingthattheprosecutionordefenseneedsmoretimetoprepareduetothenatureofthecharge,extendthelengthofdetentionforanadditional9days.§985.26(2).Thetimelimitsabovedonotincludetimeextensionsduetocourt-grantedcontinuances.§985.26(4).Shouldatimelimitbetolledduetoacontinuance,thecourtmustreviewthecontinuancewithahearingevery72hours,excludingSaturdays,Sundays,andlegalholidays,todeterminetheneedforcontinueddetentionandfurthercontinuanceoftheproceedings.§985.26(4).Exceptasprovidedabove,achildmaynotbeheldinsecureornonsecuredetentioncareformorethan15daysfollowingtheentryofanorderofadjudication.§985.26(3).Thetimelimitabovedoesnotincludetimeextensionsduetocourt-grantedcontinuances.§985.26(4).Shouldthetimelimitbetolledduetoacontinuance,thecourtmustreviewthecontinuancewithahearingevery72hours,excludingSaturdays,Sundays,andlegalholidays,todeterminetheneedforcontinueddetentionandfurthercontinuanceoftheproceedings.§985.26(4).
B. Post-CommitmentDetention
Allchildrenwhoareadjudicateddelinquentandareawaitingplacementmustbecommitted,butthepost-commitmentdetentioncriteriavary,dependingonthenatureoftheadjudicationandcommitmentlevelordered.§985.27(1).• Achildwhoisinnonsecuredetentionmaybeplacedonelectronicmonitoring.
§985.27(1).• Achildwhoisawaitingplacementinalow-riskresidentialprogrammustbe
removedfromdetentionwithin5days,excludingSaturdays,Sundays,andlegalholidays.§985.27(1)(a).Anychildbeingheldinsecuredetentionforthe5daysmustmeetthedetentioncriteriain§985.255.
• Achildwhoisawaitingplacementinamoderate-riskresidentialprogrammustberemovedfromdetentionwithin5days,excludingSaturdays,Sundays,andlegalholidays.§985.27(1)(b).Anychildbeingheldinsecuredetentionforthe5daysmustmeetthedetentioncriteriain§985.255.DJJmayaskforcontinueddetentioninsecuredetentionfacilities,ifsuchisnecessarytosecureappropriateresidentialplacementforthechild.§985.27(1)(b).Thecourtmaygrantsuchanextensionnotexceeding15daysaftertheentryofanadjudicationorder,excludingSaturdays,Sundays,andlegalholidays,andexceptasprovidedin§985.27.
38
• Achildwhoisawaitingplacementinahigh-riskresidentialprogrammustbeheldindetentioncareuntilplacementorcommitmentisaccomplished.§985.27(1)(c).
• Achildwhoisawaitingplacementinamaximum-riskresidentialprogrammustbeheldinsecuredetentioncareuntilplacementorcommitmentisaccomplished.§985.27(1)(d).
39
Discovery
Discoveryisnotamandatorypartofthedelinquencyprocess.Toengageindiscovery,achildcanelecttoparticipate,filingwiththecourtandservingonDJJa“noticeofdiscovery”whichservestoinformallinvolvedofthechild’sdesiretoengageindiscovery;thiselectionalsoservestobindallpartiestotherulesofdiscoveryascontainedintheRulesofJuvenileProcedure.Rule8.060(a)(1).Thecourtmay,ongoodcauseshown,alterthetimesforcompliancewithanydiscovery.Rule8.060(g).Exceptasotherwiseprovided,nopartyshalladviseapersonwhohasrelevantmaterialorinformation,exceptthechild,torefrainfromdiscussingthecasewithopposingcounselorfromshowingopposingcounselanyrelevantmaterial,andnopartymayimpedeopposingcounsel’sinvestigationofthecase.Rule8.060(i).
A. RequiredDisclosuretotheChild
Ifachildhaselectedtoparticipateandfileda“noticeofdiscovery,”DJJhas5daystoserveawrittendiscoveryexhibitonthechild.Thewrittendiscoveryexhibitinformsthechildofthefollowing,andallowshimorhertoinspect,copy,test,andphotographanyofthefollowinginformationormaterialinDJJ’spossessionorcontrol:• NamesandaddressesofeveryoneknowntoDJJtohaveinformationthatmight
berelevanttothecrimealleged,toanydefense,ortoanysimilarfactevidencethatmaybepresentedattheadjudicationhearing.Thenamesandaddressesmustbecategorizedasfollows:o CategoryA:witnessessuchaseyewitnesses;alibiwitnessesandwitnesses
rebuttalalibi;witnessespresentduringrecordedorunrecordedstatementsbythechild;investigatingofficers;witnessesknownbyDJJtohaveinformationthattendstonegatetheguiltofthechildastotheallegations;childhearsaywitnesses;andexpertwitnesseswhohavenotprovidedawrittenreportandcurriculumvitaeorwilltestifytotestresultsorgiveopinionsthatwillmeettheDauberttest(Daubertv.MerrellDowPharm.,Inc.,509U.S.579(1993);seealsoFed.R.Evid.702.
o CategoryB:witnessesnotlistedinCategoryAorCategoryC.o CategoryC:witnesseswhoperformonlyministerialfunctionsorwhomDJJ
doesnotintendtocallatthehearingandwhoseinvolvementandknowledgeissetforthinastatementfurnishedtothechild.
• Anystatementbyapersonwhosenameissuppliedabove.Astatementinthiscaseis“awrittenstatementmadebysaidpersonandsignedorotherwiseadoptedbyhimorherandalsoincludesanystatementofanykindormannermadebysuchpersonandwrittenorrecordedorsummarizedinanywritingorrecording,”andisintendedtoincludeallpoliceandinvestigativereportsofany
40
kindpreparedinconnectionwiththecase,butnotnotesfromwhichthereportsarecreated.
• Anywrittenorrecordedstatementsandthesubstanceofanyoralstatementsmadebythechild,includingacopyofanystatementscontainedinpolicereportsorsummaries,alongwiththenameandaddressofeachwitnesstothestatements.
• Ifthereisacodefendantandthehearingistobeajointhearing,anywrittenorrecordedstatementsandthesubstanceofanyoralstatementsmadebythecodefendant.
• Ifthechild’scasewasthesubjectofagrandjury,anyportionsoftherecordedgrandjuryminutesthatcontaintestimonyfromthechild.
• Anytangiblepapersorobjectsobtainedfromorbelongingtothechild.• WhetherDJJreceivedanymaterialsorinformationfromaconfidential
informant.• Iftherehasbeenelectronicsurveillance,includingwiretapping,theDJJmust
informthechildthatitwasusedandofanyconversationstowhichthechildwasaparty;DJJmustalsoincludeinthisanydocumentsrelatingtothewirelesssurveillance.
• DJJmustinformthechildwhethertherewasanysearchorseizureandanydocumentsrelatingtosuch.
• Reportsorstatementsofexpertsmadeinconnectionwiththechild’scase,includingresultsofphysicalormentalexaminationsandofscientifictests,experiments,orcomparisons.
• AnyothertangiblepapersorobjectsDJJintendstouseinthehearingthatwerenotobtainedfromorbelongedtothechild.Rule8.060(a)(2)(A)-(K).
Assoonaspracticableafterthedelinquencypetitionisfiled,DJJmustdisclosetothechildanyinformationintheState’spossessionorcontrolthattendstonegatetheguiltofthechildastothecrimealleged.Rule8.060(a)(3).Thecourtmayorderotherdiscoveryasjusticemayrequire.Rule8.060(a)(5).
B. RequiredDisclosuretoDJJ
Ifachildhaselectedtoparticipateandfileda“noticeofdiscovery,”thechildhas5daystomakethefollowingdisclosures:• Awrittenlistofallofthepeoplethechildexpectstocallaswitnessesatthe
hearing.• Thechildmustserveawrittendiscoveryexhibit,whichinformsDJJofthe
following,andallowsDJJtoinspect,copy,test,andphotographanyofthefollowinginformationormaterialinthechild’spossessionorcontrol:o Statementsfromanyonethechildexpectstocallasatrialwitness(other
thanhimself);
41
o Reportsorstatementsofexpertsmadeinconnectionwiththechild’scase,includingresultsofphysicalormentalexaminationsandofscientifictests,experiments,orcomparisons;and
o Anytangiblepapersorobjectswhichthechildintendstouseinthehearing.Rule8.060(b)(1)(A)-(B).
IfDJJfilesaprotectiveorder,thetimeprovidedaboveisautomaticallystayed.Rule8.060(b)(3).Iftheorderisgranted,thechildmay,within2daysofsuch,orbeforeDJJprovidestheinformationormaterialthatisthesubjectoftheprotectiveorder,withdrawthedemandandnotberequiredtofurnishreciprocaldiscovery.Rule8.060(b)(3).
C. Limitations
Uponapplicationbyaparty,thecourtmaydenyorlimitdisclosureifthecourtfindsasubstantialrisktoanyoneofphysicalharm,intimidation,bribery,economicreprisals,orunnecessaryannoyanceorembarrassmentresultingfromthedisclosure,whichoutweighsanyusefulnessofdisclosuretothepartyattemptingtodisclose.Rule8.060(c)(1).Anyonecanmoveforanorderdenyingorregulatingdisclosureofmaterial;thecourtmayconsiderthemotionincamera.Rule8.060(l)(1).However,certaininformationisnotsubjecttodisclosure,including:• legalresearchorofrecords,correspondence,ormemoranda,totheextentthat
theycontaintheopinion,theories,orconclusionsoftheprosecutingordefenseattorneyormembersoftheirlegalstaff.
• Disclosureofaconfidentialinformantisnotrequiredunlesstheinformantwillbeproducedatahearing,orfailuretodisclosetheinformant’sidentitywillinfringeonthechild’sconstitutionalrights.Rule8.060(c)(2)(A)-(B).
Onashowingofgoodcause,thecourtmayorderatanytimethatcertaindisclosuresberestricted,deferred,orexemptfromdiscovery;thatcertainmattersarenottobeexamined;thatthescopeofadepositionistobelimitedtocertainthings;orthatadepositionistobesealedandabletobeopenedonlybycourtorder.Thecourtmayalsomakeanyotherappropriateordertoprotectawitnessfromharassment,unnecessaryinconvenience,orinvasionofprivacy,includingprohibitingthetakingofadeposition.Rule8.060(j).However,allmaterialthatapartyisentitledtomustbedisclosedwithsufficienttimetopermitthepartytomakebeneficialuseoftheinformation.Rule8.060(j).
D. Depositions
NodepositionsareallowedincaseswherethedelinquencypetitionallegesonlyamisdemeanororcriminaltrafficcourtviolationwhenallotherdiscoveryprovidedbyRule8.060hasbeencompliedwith,exceptwheregoodcausecanbeshowntothetrialcourt.Rule8.060(d)(2)(I).Initsdeterminationofwhethertoallowdepositions,
42
thecourtshouldconsidertheconsequencestothechild,thecomplexityoftheissues,thecomplexityofthetestimonysought,andtheotheropportunitiesavailabletothechildtodisclosetheinformationsoughtbydeposition.Rule8.060(d)(2)(I).Theprohibitionagainsttakingdepositionsisnotapplicableif,followingthefurnishingofdiscoverybythechild,DJJtakesthestatementofalisteddefensewitnesspursuanttotheStateAttorney’spowerandauthoritytosummonwitnesses.Rule8.060(d)(2)(I).Whenpermitted,depositionscanbetakenatanytimeafterthefilingofthedelinquencypetition,andanypartymaytakeadepositionofanypersonauthorizedbythisrule.Rule8.060(d)(1)(A).Thecourtmay,afternoticetotheparties,issuesubpoenasforpartiestobedeposed.Rule8.060(d)(2)(B).Depositionsofwitnessesresidinginthecountywheretheadjudicatoryhearingwilltakeplacemustbetakeninthebuildingwherethehearingistotakeplace,anotherlocationagreedtobytheparties,oranotherlocationspecifiedbythecourt.Rule8.060(d)(1)(B).Ifthewitnessresidesoutsidethecountywheretheadjudicatoryhearingwilltakeplace,thedepositionmusttakeplaceinacourtreporter’sofficeinthecountywherethewitnessresides,anotherlocationagreedtobytheparties,oranotherlocationspecifiedbythecourt.Rule8.060(d)(1)(B).Anywitnesswhorefusestoobeyadulyservedsubpoenamaybeadjudicatedincontemptbytheissuingcourtforsuchrefusal.Rule8.060(d)(5).Generally,witnessescanonlybedeposedonce,withtwoexceptions:ifthepartiesconsenttomultipledepositions,orifthecourtordersasubsequentdeposition,ongoodcauseshown.Rule8.060(d)(2)(D).Thepartytakingthedepositionshouldprovidereasonablewrittennoticetoeveryotherparty,andmakeagoodfaithefforttocoordinatewiththeotherpartiesandthewitnesstobedeposed.Thenoticemuststatethetimeandlocationofthedeposition,thenameofeachpersonbeingdeposed,andacertificateofcounselthatagoodfaitheffortwasmadetocoordinatethedepositionschedule.Rule8.060(d)(2)(A).Afternoticetotheparties,thecourtmay,afterashowingofgoodcause,changethetimeorlocationofthedeposition.Rule8.060(d)(2)(C).Theprocedurefortakingadeposition,includingthescopeofthedepositionanduseofasubpoena(otherthanasubpoenaducestecum),isanalogoustotheproceduredescribedintheFloridaRulesofCivilProcedure.Rule8.060(d)(2)(E).Depositionsofchildrenunder16yearsofageshallbevideotapedondemandfromapartyunlessotherwiseorderedbythecourt.Rule8.060(d)(9).Thecourtmayorderthevideotapingofadepositionofawitnessoffragileemotionalhealth.Thecourtmayalsoorderthedepositionofthefragilewitnesstobetakeninthepresenceofaspecialmagistrateorthetrialjudge.Rule8.060(d)(9).BadFaithDepositionsAtanytimeduringthetakingofadeposition,onamotionbyapartyorbythepersondeposed,andonashowingthatthedepositionisbeingconductedinbad
43
faithorinamannerdesignedtoannoy,embarrass,oroppressthewitnessoraparty,thecourtmay:• Terminatethedeposition;• Limitthescopeandmannerofthetakingofthedeposition;• Limitthetimeofthedeposition;• Continuethedepositiontoalaterdateandtime;• Orderthedepositiontobetakeninopencourt;and• MayimposeanysanctionauthorizedbyRule8.060.Rule8.060(k).Ifthecourtorderterminatesthedeposition,itcanonlyberesumedbyanorderofthecourt.Rule8.060(k).Upontherequestofapartyorwitness,thedepositionmaybesuspendedforthetimenecessarytomakeamotionforanorder.Rule8.060(k).Child’sPresenceatDepositionAchildmaynotbepresentatadepositionexceptonstipulationofthepartiesorbyanorderofthecourtonashowingofgoodcause.Rule8.060(d)(6).Inmakingsuchanorder,thecourtmayconsidertheneedforthephysicalpresenceofthechild;theintimidatingeffectthechild’spresencemayhaveonthewitness;anycostorinconveniencethatmayresult;andanyalternativeelectronicmeansavailabletoprotectthechild’sabilitytoparticipateindiscoverywithoutbeingphysicallypresent.Rule8.060(d)(6).
Witness’PresenceatDepositionTheabilitytodeposeawitnessdependsonthetypeofwitness.• DJJcan,withoutleaveofthecourt,takethedepositionofanywitnesslistedby
thechild.• Thechild,withoutleaveofthecourt,cantakethedepositionofanywitness
listedbyDJJasa“CategoryA”witness.• Thechildcan,withoutleaveofthecourt,takethedepositionofanyunlisted
witnesswhomayhaveinformationrelevanttothedelinquencypetition’sallegations.
• NopartycandeposeawitnesslistedbyDJJasa“CategoryB”witness,exceptbyleaveofthecourt.
• A“CategoryC”witnesscannotbedeposedbyanypartyunlessthecourtdeterminesthewitnessshouldbelistedinanothercategory.Rule8.060(d)(2)(F)-(H).
• Uponstipulationofthepartiesandconsentofthewitness,thestatementofalawenforcementofficercanbetakentelephonicallyinlieuofadeposition.Thestatementmustberecordedandcanbeusedforimpeachmentpurposesattrial.Rule8.060(d)(7).Lawenforcementofficersshallbedeposedwithoutsubpoena,uponwrittennoticeofthedepositiontotheaddressdesignatedbythelawenforcementagencyor,ifnoaddressisdesignated,totheaddressofthelaw
44
enforcementagency5daysbeforethedateofthedeposition.Alawenforcementofficerwhofailstoappearaftersuchnoticeissubjecttocontemptproceedings.Rule8.060(d)(8).
Indeterminingwhetherapartymaydeposea“CategoryB”witness,thecourtshouldconsidertheconsequencestothechild,thecomplexityoftheissues,thecomplexityofthetestimonysought,andtheotheropportunitiesavailabletothechildtodisclosetheinformationsoughtbydeposition.Rule8.060(d)(2)(G).Uponrequest,thecourtmustallowthechildtomakeanexparteshowingofgoodcauseforthetakingofadepositionofa“CategoryB”witness.Rule8.060(l)(2).Afterthefilingofapetition,uponapplicationandsubjecttoconstitutionallimitations,thecourtmay,bydirectionsastotime,place,andmethod,andonconditionsthatarejust,requirethechildinallproceedingsto:• Appearinalineup;• Speakforidentificationbyawitnesstotheoffense;• Poseforphotographsnotinvolvingareenactmentoftheoffense;• Tryonarticlesofclothes;• Permitthetakingofmaterialunderthefingernails;• Permitthetakingofmaterialsofthebody,whichinvolvenounreasonable
intrusion,includingbloodandhair;• Provideahandwritingsample;and• Submittoareasonablephysicalormedicalinspection.Rule8.060(f)(1).
Thecourtmayalsoorderadditionaldiscoveryasjusticemayrequire,onashowingthatsuchdiscoverywouldberelevantormaterial.Rule8.060(f)(2).OrdertoPerpetuateTestimonyAfterthefilingofapetition,andonreasonablenotice,apartymayapplyforanordertoperpetuatetestimony.Theapplicationmustbesupportedorverifiedbyaffidavitsofcrediblepeople,andmuststatethatthewitnesslivesbeyondthecourt’sjurisdictionormaybeunabletoattendcourtproceedings,orthattherearegroundstobelievethatthewitnesswillabsenthim-orherselffromthecourt’sjurisdiction;thatthetestimonyismaterial;andthatitisnecessarytotakethedepositiontopreventafailureofjustice.Rule8.060(e)(1).Iftheapplicationisdoneinatimelymannerandiswell-founded,thecourtmustorderacommissiontobeissuedtotakethedepositionofthewitnesstobeusedinsubsequentcourtproceedings.Rule8.060(e)(2).Thecommissionmuststatethetimeandplaceofthedepositionandmustbeservedonallparties.Rule8.060(e)(2).Thecourtmustalsoorderanydesignatedbooks,documents,ortangibleobjectsnotprivilegedbeproducedatthetimeofthedeposition.Rule8.060(e)(2).Thecommissionmaybeissuedtoanycourtreporter,totranscribethedepositionandfileitwiththecourt.Rule8.060(e)(2).
45
SubsequentDutytoDiscloseIf,subsequenttocompliancewiththerulesofdiscovery,apartydiscoversawitness,evidence,ormaterialthatthepartywouldhavebeenunderadutytodiscloseorproducepreviously,thepartymustpromptlydiscloseorproducesuchinthesamemannerasrequiredbytherulesforinitialdiscovery.Rule8.060(h).UsesofDepositionsAnydepositiontakenmaybeusedatanyhearingbyanypartyforthepurposeofimpeachingthedeponent.Rule8.060(d)(3).Ifonlypartofthedepositionissubmittedintoevidencebyaparty,anadversepartymayincludeanyotherpartofthedepositionthatinfairnessoughttobeconsideredwiththepartsubmitted,andanypartycanofferanypartofthedepositionintoevidence.Rule8.060(d)(4).However,nodepositionmaybereadintoevidenceifthewitnesscanattendthehearing.Rule8.060(e)(3).Further,ifitappearsadeposedwitnesshasabsentedhim-orherselfasaresultofprocurement,threats,orinducementsbyoronbehalfofaparty,thedepositionmaynotbereadintoevidenceonbehalfofthatparty.Rule8.060(e)(3).
E. Sanctions
Ifatanytimeitisbroughttotheattentionofthecourtthatapartyhasfailedtocomplywiththerulesofdiscoveryoranorderissuedpursuanttoaruleofdiscovery,thecourtmay:• Orderthepartytocomplywithdiscoveryrequest;• Grantacontinuance;• Grantamistrial;• Prohibitapartyfromcallingawitnessnotdisclosed,orintroducingmaterialnot
disclosed;or• Enteranorderthecourtdeemsjustunderthecircumstances.Rule
8.060(m)(1)(A)-(E).
Ifcounselorapartynotrepresentedbycounselwillfullyviolatestherulesofdiscoveryoranorderbasedonanapplicablerule,thatcounselorpartynotrepresentedmaybesubjecttoappropriatesanctionsbythecourt.Rule8.060(m)(2).Thesanctionsmayinclude,butarenotlimitedto,contemptproceedingsagainsttheattorneyorpartynotrepresentedandanassessmentofcostsincurredbytheopposingpartywhenappropriate.Rule8.060(m)(2).
F. Record
Arecordshallbemadeofdiscoveryproceedings.Ifthecourtentersanordergrantingreliefafteranincamerainspectionorafteranexparteshowing,the
46
completerecordmustbesealedandincludedintherecordsofthecourt,andmustbemadeavailabletotheappellatecourtshouldtherebeanappeal.Rule8.060(l)(3).
47
DiversionaryProgramsA. Generally
Section985.125establishesthatlawenforcementagenciesorschooldistrictsmayestablishpre-orpost-arrestdiversionprograms,withthecooperationofthestateattorney.Asapartofanydiversionprogram,achildallegedtobedelinquentmayhavetosurrenderhisorherdriver’slicense,or,ifthechilddoesnotcurrentlyhaveadriver’slicense,refrainfromapplyingforadriver’slicenseforaperiodnotexceeding90days.§985.125(2).Ifthechildfailstocomplywiththerequirementsofthediversionprogram,thestateattorneymaynotifytheDepartmentofMotorVehiclesinwritingandrequestthedepartmentsuspendthechild’sdriver’slicenseforaperiodnotexceeding90days.§985.125(2).Theprocessforentranceintoadiversionprogrambeginsatintake.TheJuvenileProbationOfficer(JPO)servesastheprimarycasemanagerforthechild.§985.145(1).TheJPOreviewsanydocumentssubmittedastoprobablecauseandscreensthechild.§985.145(1)(a)-(c).Duringscreening,theJPOwilldeterminewhetherthechildiseligibleforadiversionprogram,andifso,whichprogram.§985.145(1)(c).IftheJPOdeterminesthatthechildiseligibleforadiversionprogram,andthattheprogramwouldbeappropriateforthechild,theJPOwillreferthechildtotheselectedprogram.§985.145(1)(h).Theresultsofthescreening,alongwiththeJPOsrecommendations,aresubmittedtoDJJ,whocanpetitionastateattorneytoreviewtherecommendationwithin10daysofthestateattorney’sreceiptofthepetition.§985.145(1)(i).
B. TeenCourt
TheTeenCourtconceptwasinitiallydevelopedin1967,whenthePresident’sCommissiononLawEnforcementandAdministrationofJusticerecommendedreducingtherolejuvenilecourttookinhandlingjuvenileoffenders.1Theoriginatorsoftheteencourtmodelreasonedthatasystemallowingteenstoconfrontyouthfuldelinquentsabouttheirbehaviorcouldhaveapowerfulrehabilitativeeffect.2Asof2005,therewere1035TeenCourtsoperatingnationwide.3Itisestimatedthat,
1Seyfrit,C.L.,Reichel,P.L.,&Stutts,B.L.PeerJuriesasaJuvenileJusticeDiversionTechnique.18(3)YouthandSociety302(1987).2Weisz,V.,Lott,R.C.,&Thai,N.D.ATeenCourtEvaluationwithaTherapeuticJurisprudencePerspective.20BehavioralSciencesandtheLaw381(2002).3Pearson,S.S.&Jurich,S.YouthCourt:ACommunitySolutionforEmbracingAt-RiskYouth.ANationalUpdate.Washington,D.C.:AmericanYouthPolicyForum(2005).
48
nationwide,between110,000and125,000teenoffendersareinvolvedinTeenCourteveryyear.4Thereare4commonTeenCourtmodels.TheAdultJudgeModelallowsteenstoactineveryrole(prosecutor,defense,bailiff,clerk,andjury)withanadultpresidingoverthehearing.5Theadult’sroleisminimal.ThePeerJuryModeldoesnotinvolveattorneys,butinstead,thejuryquestionstheoffenderdirectly,underthesupervisionofanadultjudge;thejuryisresponsibleforprovidingsanctions.6AthirdmodelistheYouthJudgeModel,whichresemblestheAdultJudgemodel,exceptthatateenservesasthejudgeasopposedtoanadult.7ThefourthmodeliscalledtheYouthTribunalModel,wherein3or4teenjudgesquestiontheoffenderandprovidesanctions.8Inthismodel,nojuryorattorneysarepresent,althoughanadultisintheroomtosupervisetheproceedings.9AccordingtotheFloridaAssociationofTeenCourts,the75FloridateencourtsalladheretotheAdultJudgeModel.10TeenCourtsallowfirsttimeoffendersanopportunitytohavetheircaseheardbyajuryoftheirpeers.Thejuryevaluatestheoffensecommitted,andprovidesappropriatesanctions.11Accordingtoa1998survey,themostcommonlyhandledoffensesaretheft,minorassault,disorderlyconduct,alcoholpossession,vandalism,andmarijuana.12Intermsofsanctionsprovided,juriesincludeelementsofcommunityservice,apology,writtenessays,teencourtjuryduty,andsubstanceabuseclasses.13Teencourthasbecomeawidelyuseddiversionprogrambecauseitencouragesproceduraljustice.Inmultiplestudies,theparticipantshavedemonstratedagreaterunderstandingofthelegalprocess,increasedbeliefinthefairnessoftheteencourtsystem,andincreasedbeliefinthetrustworthinessofauthority.14Additionally,useofateencourtdiversionprogramcanreduce“secondarydeviance”byreducing
4Id.5Godwin,T.M.PeerJusticeandYouthEmpowerment:AnImplementationGuideforTeenCourtPrograms.Washington,DC:AmericanProbationandParoleAssociation(1998).6Id.7Id.8Id.9Id.10Seehttp://www.flteencourt.net/formoreinformation.11Supranote3.12Butts,J.A.,&Buck,J.TeenCourts:Afocusonresearch.JuvenileJusticeBulletin(2000).13Id.14Logalbo,A.P.andCallahan,C.M.AnEvaluationofTeenCourtsasaJuvenileCrimeDiversionProgram.JuvenileandFamilyCourtJournal(Spring2001);Wells,J.B.,&Minor,K.I.AnEvaluationofKentucky’sTeenCourtPrograms.1995(Unpublishedmanuscript,onfileatEasternKentuckyUniversity).
49
offenders’exposuretoformallabelingbyDJJ.15Qualifiedchildrenaredivertedtoteencourtandarenotconsidered“delinquent,”andthushaveadecreasedtendencytodefinethemselvesas“delinquent”andengageinfurtherdelinquentacts.16Additionally,teencourtisprimarilyaimedatprovidingrehabilitativesanctionsanddivertingoffendersawayfromthejuvenilejusticesystemandtowardsomethingmoreconventional.17Proceduraljustice,labelavoidance,andrehabilitativesanctionshavebeenshowntodecreasethelikelihoodofrecidivism.18TeenCourtsareauthorizedunder§938.19,andmaybeadministeredbyanonprofitorganization,alawenforcementagency,thecourtadministrator,theclerkofthecourt,oranothersimilaragencyauthorizedbytheboardofcountycommissioners.§938.19(6).
C. CivilCitation
Thecivilcitationprocessis“anefficientandinnovativealternativetocustodybytheDepartmentofJuvenileJustice…”§985.12(1).CivilCitationsaredesignedtobeusedforchildrenwhocommitnon-seriousdelinquentactsandtoensureswiftandappropriateconsequences.§985.12(1).Anylawenforcementofficer,uponmakingcontactwithachildwhohasadmittedtocommittinganon-seriousdelinquentact,mayissueacivilcitation.§985.12(1).AcopyofthecitationissuedmustbesenttoDJJ,thecountysheriff,thestateattorney,appropriateintakeofficeofDJJ,designatedcommunityservicemonitor,theparentorguardianoftheoffender,andthevictim.§985.12(1)&(3).Theofficermayassessnotmorethan50communityservicehourstothechild,andrequireparticipationininterventionprogramsappropriatetothechild,includingfamilycounseling,urinalysismonitoring,andsubstanceabuseormentalhealthtreatment.§985.12(1).Onceissuedacitation,thechildmustreporttothedesignatedcommunityservicemonitorwithin7businessdaysofthedateonthecitation.§985.12(4).Thecommunityservicemustbecompletedatarateofnolessthan5hoursperweek.§985.12(4).Themonitorwilladvisetheintakeofficeoncethechildhascompletedthecommunityservicerequirement.§985.12(4).Ifthechildfailstocomplywiththetermsofthecivilcitation,orifthechildcommitsasubsequentmisdemeanor,the
15Dugas,D.M.IstheEffectivenessofTeenCourtDependentonGender?2006(unpublishedmanuscript,onfileatUniversityofMaryland).16Matsueda,R.L.(1992).ReflectedAppraisals,ParentalLabeling,andDelinquency:SpecifyingaSymbolicInteractionistTheory.6AmericanJournalofSociology1577(1992).17Povitsky,W.TeenCourt:DoesitReduceRecidivism?2005(unpublishedmanuscript,onfileatUniversityofMaryland).18Supranotes14and17.
50
lawenforcementofficermustissueareportallegingthatthechildcommittedadelinquentact,whichwillcausethejuvenileprobationofficertoprocesstheoriginaldelinquentactasareferraltotheDJJandreferthereporttothestateattorneyforreview.§985.12(6).Thechildmaychoosetorefuseacivilcitation–ifheorshedoesrefuse,thelawenforcementofficerwillrefertheoffendertotheintakeofficeofDJJ.§985.12(5).Thisoptionisavailabletothechildatanytimepriortothecompletionoftheassignedcommunityservice.§985.12(5).
D. JuvenileSubstanceInterventionProgram
Achildwhoischargedwithafelonyofthesecondorthirddegreeforthepurchaseofpossessionofacontrolledsubstance(perchapter893,FloridaStatutes),tamperingwithevidence,solicitationforpurchaseofacontrolledsubstance,orfraudulentlyobtainingaprescription,iseligibleforvoluntaryadmissionintoajuvenilepretrialsubstanceabuseinterventionprogram,includingadrugtreatmentcourtprogram.§985.345(1).Thelengthoftimeoftheprogramdependsontheprogramrequirementsandthetreatmentservicessuitabletothechild.§985.345(1).Admissionintoaprogramcanberequestedatthemotionofeitherparty,orbythecourt.§985.345(1).However,ifthechildallegedlycommittedaviolationofthelawandwasinvolvedindealingand/orsellingdrugsorothercontrolledsubstances,thecourtmustholdapreadmissionhearing.§985.345(1).Ifatthathearingthestateattorneyshows(byapreponderanceoftheevidence)thatthechildwasinvolvedinthedealingorsellingofcontrolledsubstances,thecourtmustdenyadmissiontoapretrialinterventionprogram.§985.345(1).Whileenrolledinatreatmentprogram,thechildissubjecttoacoordinatedstrategydevelopedbyadrugcourtteam.§985.345(2).Thestrategymayinclude,amongotherthings,ameansofsanctioninganoncompliantchild.Thesanctionsmayincludeplacementinasubstanceabusetreatmentcenter,ortimeinsecuredetention.§985.345(2).Anystrategymustbeprovidedtothechildinwritingbeforeheorsheagreestoanypretrialinterventionprogram.§985.345(2).Attheendoftheinterventionperiod,thecourtmustconsidertherecommendationsofthestateattorneyandpretrialdiversionprogramcoordinatorastothedispositionoftheyouth.§985.345(3).Thecourtmustfind,inwriting,thateitherthechildhassuccessfullycompletedthepretrialinterventionprogramorthechildhasnot.§985.345(3).Ifthecourtfindsthatthechildhasnotcompletedthepretrialprogram,thecourtmayorderthechildtocontinuetoattendaninterventionprogram(ifresourcesareavailable)ormayorderthatthechargesrevertbacktonormaldelinquencyprocedures.§985.345(3).Thecourtmaydismissthecharges
51
onlyifthecourtfindsthatthechildhassuccessfullycompletedthepretrialinterventionprogram.§985.345(3).
E. Expunction
Apre-orpost-arrestdiversionprogrammayprovidefortheexpunctionofthenon-judicialarrestrecordifthechildsuccessfullycompletestheprogram.§985.125(3).Ifthechild’srecordsareexpunged,theymaystillbeavailabletocriminaljusticeagenciesfordeterminationsofeligibilityinpre-orpost-arrestdiversionprograms;theymayalsobeavailableiftherecordissoughtaspartofacriminalinvestigationorwhenthechildisacandidateforemploymentwithacriminaljusticeagency.§943.0582(2)(a)(1).However,foranyotherpurpose,thechildmaylegallydenyorfailtoacknowledgethearrestandchargeoftheexpungedrecord.§943.0582(2)(a)(1).Toexpungearecord,thechildmust:• Successfullycompleteapre-orpost-arrestdiversionprogramthatexpressly
permitsexpunctiontooccur,andthatisbasedonnonviolentmisdemeanorsthatdonotqualifyasactsofdomesticviolence;
• Submitanapplicationforexpunction,nolaterthan6monthsaftercompletionoftheprogram;
• Submitanofficialwrittenstatementfromthestateattorneycertifyingthecompletionoftheprogram,andthattheprogramwaslimitedtominorsarrestedfornonviolentmisdemeanorswhohavenotbeenotherwisechargedwithorfoundtohavecommittedanycriminaloffensesorcomparableordinanceviolations;and
• Havenever,priortoapplyingforexpunction,beenchargedwithorfoundtohavecommittedanycriminaloffensesorcomparableordinanceviolations.§943.0582(3)(a)-(f).
Expunctionofachargedoesnotpreventthechildfrompetitioningfortheexpunctionofalatercriminalrecord,ifthechildisotherwiseeligible.§943.0582(6).Thedepartmentisallowedtochargeaseventy-fivedollar($75)processingfeeforeachrequestforexpunctionunlessthefeeiswaivedbytheexecutivedirector.§943.0582(4).
52
DomesticViolenceIssuesA. Statistics
Manyofthestatisticsinthissectionarepresentedasarange,asmanyresearchersinthisfieldcalculatetheirdatabasedoffofnationalsurveysandcensuses.1Eachyearitisestimatedthatbetween7millionand14millionchildren2areexposedtoviolenceagainsttheirmothersorfemalecaretakersbyotherfamilymembers.Childreninhomeswheredomesticviolenceoccursarephysicallyabusedorneglectedbetween9and15timeshigherthanthenationalaverage.3Inonestudy,morethan60percentofthechildrensurveyedwereexposedtoviolencewithinthepastyear,eitherdirectlyorindirectlyandnearlyone-halfofthechildrenandadolescentssurveyed(46.3percent)wereassaultedatleastonceinthepastyear.4Researchsuggeststhatbeingbatteredisthemostcommonfactoramongmothersofabusedchildren.Ithasbeenestimatedthat30–60%ofchildrenwhosemothersarebatteredarethemselvesvictimsofabuse.Childrenlivingwithanabusedmotherhavebeenfoundtobe12to14timesmorelikelytobesexuallyabusedthanchildrenwhosemotherswerenotabused.5Onerecentstudyfoundthat,intheUnitedStates,stepfathersabusechildrenunder5yearsoldtodeathatarateof55.9deathspermillionatriskchildrenperyear,comparedto5.6deathspermillionatriskchildrenperyearbybiologicalfathers.6Theauthorsofthestudynotedthatiftheyhadexpandedthedefinitionof“stepfather”toincludelive-inboyfriendsandothersimilarlysituatedrelationshiprolesandincludedalltypesofabuserelateddeaths(notjustbatteringdeaths),at
1JeffreyL.Edleson,AmandaL.Ellerton,EllenA.Seagren,StaciL.Kirchberg,SarahO.Schmidt,AmirithiT.Ambrose.AssessingChildExposuretoAdultDomesticViolence.ChildrenandYouthServicesReview2(2007).2Idat2-3,citingB.E.Carlson.Childrenexposedtointimatepartnerviolence:Researchfindingsandimplicationsforintervention.1Trauma,Violence,andAbuse4,(2000).3ToddHerrenkohl,CynthiaSousa,EmikoA.Tajima,RoyC.Herrenkohl,CarrieA.Moylan.IntersectionBetweenChildAbuseandChildren’sExposuretoDomesticViolence.Trauma,ViolenceandAbuse84(2008)at87.4DavidFinkelhor,HeatherTurner,RichardOrmrod,SherryHamby,KristenKracke.Children’sExposureToViolence:AComprehensiveNationalSurvey.OfficeofJuvenileJusticeandDelinquencyPrevention,JuvenileJusticeBulletin(October2009)at1.5SuzanneC.Swan,LauraJ.Gambone,JenniferE.Caldwell,TamiP.Sullivan,DavidL.Snow.AReviewofResearchonWomen’sUseofViolenceWithMaleIntimatePartners.23VictimsandViolence301(2008)at308.6MartinDaly,&MargoWilson.The“CinderellaEffect”:ElevatedMistreatmentofStepchildreninComparisontoThoseLivingwithGeneticParents.(2008)at2-3.
53
riskchildrenlivingwitha“stepfather”wouldbe100timesmorelikelytobekilledthanchildrenlivingwithbiologicalparents.7However,abusedmothersindomesticviolencesituationsarealsomorelikelytoabusetheirchildren–8timesmorelikelythannon-abusedmothers.8Finally,asmanyas87%ofchildreninhomeswherethereisdomesticviolencebetweenparentswitnessit.9
B. TheeffectsofDomesticViolenceonchildren
Familyviolenceismoretraumaticformostchildrenthanstreetviolence.Thevictimsandperpetratorsaremostoftenpeoplethechildknowsintimatelyanddependsonforloveandprotection.10However,domesticviolencecanaffecteachchilddifferently.Onestudycoinedtheterm“adversitypackage”todescribethefactorsthatcanaccumulateinachild’slife;11thesefactorsincludechildabuse,parentalsubstanceabuse,mentalhealthdifficulties(intheparentsorinthechild),socialisolation,unemployment,homelessness,andinvolvementincrime.12Thepresenceorabsenceofmultiplefactorscanalterthechild’sreactiontodomesticviolence,bothintheshorttermandinthelongterm.13Amultitudeofstudieshavedemonstratedthatchildrenexposedtodomesticviolencetendtohaveworseproblemsthanthosenotexposed.14Andchildrenexposedtodomesticviolenceexperienceproblemsequallyasbadaschildrenphysicallyabusedorphysicallyabusedandexposedtodomesticviolence.15Examplesofhowchildrencanbephysicallyharmedbydomesticviolenceinclude:• Childrencanthemselvesbephysicallyabused;• Childrenoftentrytointervenetoprotecttheadultvictim,whichputsthemin
dangerfromtheabuser;
7Idat3.8LeighGoodmark.FromPropertytoPersonhood:WhattheLegalSystemShouldDoforChildreninFamilyViolenceCases.102W.Va.L.Rev.237(1999)at241.9Idat243.10HowDoesExposuretoViolenceAffectVeryYoungChildren?TheHarvardMentalHealthLetter,vol.11,No.7,January,1995.11StephanieHolt,HelenBuckley,&SadhbhWhelana.TheImpactofExposuretoDomesticViolenceonChildrenandYoungPeople:AReviewoftheLiterature.32ChildAbuseandNeglect797(2008)at803.12Id.13Id.14Supranote1at3.Thereissomecontroversyastohowsignificantthevarianceinproblemsbetweenaffectedchildrenversusunaffectedchildrenactuallyis,butstudiesallagreethereisavariation.15Idat4.
54
• Domesticabusersmayusechildrentocontroltheadultvictimbyviolenceorthreatsofviolenceagainstthechildren.
StudiesmostoftenusetheChildBehaviorChecklisttoassesstheeffectofdomesticviolence.16Exposedchildrengenerallyexhibitmoreaggressivebehavior,antisocialbehavior,internalizedbehavior,lowersocialcompetenceandpooreracademicperformancethanthosenotexposed.17Adultdomesticviolencecanhaveotherdevastatingconsequencesforchildreninadditiontobodilyinjury.• Domesticviolencecandeprivechildrenofhousing,schooling,ormedicalcare.• Flightfromdomesticviolenceoftenleadstohomelessnessamongvictimsand
children,andisaprimaryreasonwhyadolescentsrunawayfromhome.18• Childrenexposedtodomesticviolenceoftenhavehigherratesofcognitive,
psychologicalandemotionalimpairmentsthanthosenotexposed.19
Anumberoflongtermeffectsonchildrenexposedtodomesticviolencehavealsobeendocumented,asfollows:• Psychologicalproblems,suchaswithdrawal,hypervigilance,nightmares,
anxiety,depression,lowself-esteem,andshame.20• Physicalsymptoms,oftenidentifiedasreactionstostress,includesleep
disorders,headaches,diarrhea,ulcers,asthma,anddepression.• Academicproblemssuchaspoorschoolperformance,truancy,absenteeism,
difficultyconcentrating,andschoolfailure.21• Socialandbehavioralproblems,suchasinabilitytoformtrustingrelationships,
aggressiveorviolentbehavior,andsubstanceabuse.Anexposedchildismorelikelytobephysicallyaggressivetowardothersinthecommunity,22andiseighteentimesmorelikelytobephysicallyaggressivetowardhisorherparents.23
Therearealsoeffectsonchildrenexposedtoviolencethatcanlastanentirelifetime,including:
16JeffreyL.Edleson,inconsultationwithBarbaraNissley.EmergingResponsestoChildrenExposedtoDomesticViolence.NationalOnlineResourceCenteronViolenceAgainstWomen(October2006)at2.17Id.18W.Richie.TheImpactofDomesticViolenceontheChildrenofBatteredWomen.Children’sAidSocietyNewsletter(Spring,1992)at3.19Supranote2at89.20Id.21Id.22Supranote16at2.23Supranote11at801.
55
• Depression;• Eatingdisordersandotherhealthproblems;• Druguseandalcoholism;and• Criminality.24Finally,onestudyfoundthatthereis“anintergenerationaltransmissionrateof30%whichcanmanifestitselfinmanyways.”25Atwelve-yearstudyfoundthatchildrenexposedtoviolencewerealmosttwiceaslikelytoexperienceviolenceintheirownadultrelationships.26Itshouldbenotedthatcurrentresearchissomewhatconflictingregardingtheeffectsofabuseonchildren.Whileseveralstudiessupporttheinformationprovidedabove,twostudiesfoundthatmanychildrensuffernogreaterproblemsthanchildrennotexposedtodomesticviolence.27Further,onearticlesuggestedthatthevariancefoundinpapersisaresultofvaguedefinitionsorretrospectiveaccounts.28Forexample,researchersdifferonhowtodefinetermssuchas“exposuretodomesticviolence”andwhatactsconstituteadultdomesticviolence.29
C. HowtoAscertainwhetherDomesticViolencemaybePresent
Domesticviolencecanbeverydifficulttodetect.Oftenchildrenandparentsorguardianswillnotdiscloseincidentsofdomesticviolencebecauseofthepervasivefearthatdisclosurewillresultinthechildbeingremovedfromthehome.IfDJJand/orDCFhasnotnotifiedthecourtthatdomesticviolenceispresent,itisverylikelybecausetheyhavenotencounteredanyevidenceofabuseduringtheirinvestigation.However,asdomesticviolencecanbeconcealedfromcaseworkers,investigators,andotherprofessionalstrainedtolookforit,thefollowingaresignsofdomesticviolenceinchildrenandadults.Thepresenceorabsenceofsuchsignsdoesnotnecessarilycorrelatetothepresenceorabsenceofdomesticviolence.However,theyaresignsthattheremightbedomesticviolence,thusprovidingthecourtanopportunitytoexaminemorecloselyfordomesticviolence.30
24Supranote3at89.25Supranote11at805.26Id.27Supranote1at4.28Idat3.29Id.30Wherethearticleshereunderdiscussthesignsofabuseassignalsforparents,thesesignsmaybepresentinabusiveandabusedjuvenilesalso.
56
Childrenhaveseveralcuesthattheymaybelivingwithsomeformofviolence.Thesecuesinclude:• Physicalviolencetowardsanimalsorpeople;• Aggressivebehavior;• Substanceoralcoholabuse;• Difficultypayingattention;or• Withdrawnorabsenceofemotions;• Anxietyorhyper-vigilance;• Risk-takingbehaviors• Problemsinschool;• Difficultywithpeerrelationships.31Therearemanypossiblesignsofanabusiveparty.Thesignsthatsuggestpossibledomesticviolencearethosethatindicatedisrespecttowardoneparty.32Theycanbebrokenintotwosections,generalsignsandbehaviorincourt.Generalsignsofabusivepartiesmayinclude:• Authoritariandemeanororparentingstyle;• Under-involvedinfamilymembers’lives;• Consideringthemselvessuperiorinallaspectsoffamilylife;• Placinglittletonovalueonabusedparty’sabilities;or• Continuouscriticismofabusedparty.33Behavioralsignalsincourtofabusivepartiesmayinclude:• Claimingtheotherpartyisstupidorinflexible;• Angeringeasily;• Attemptingtoportrayhim/herselfasthetruevictim;• Attemptingtoengendersympathywiththecourt;• Anunwillingnesstounderstandanother’sperspective;• Advocatingoradheringtostrictgenderroles;• Patronizingtheotherparty,counsel,orthecourt;• Attemptingtocreateanalliancewiththecourt;• Minimizing,denying,blamingtheotherpartyfor,orexcusinginappropriate
behavior;34or
31NationalCouncilofJuvenileandFamilyCourtJudges,AJudicialChecklistforChildrenandYouthExposedtoViolence.(2006)at2.32Idat8.33JonathonW.Gould,DavidA.Martindale,MelisseH.Eidman.AssessingAllegationsofDomesticViolence.4JournalofChildCustody1(2007)at30.34Supranote31at9.
57
• Speakingmorethanseventy-fivepercent(75%)ofthetime.35Therearesignstolookforintheabusedpartyalso.Thesesignsinclude:• Difficultypresentingevidence(perhapsfromfear,abuse,orthebeliefthatshe
willnotbebelieved);• Inappropriateresponseresultingfromfear,depression,stressorotherabuse;• Anxiousorunfocusedinthepresenceoftheabusiveparty;• Aggressiveorangrywhentestifying;• Stressorduresswhenotherpartyistestifying;or• Appearnumb,disinterested,orunaffected.36Thereareothersignsthatabusemaybepresent.Thesesignsmaybedisplayedbyeitherparty,andmaymeandifferentthings,dependingonwhethertheyaredisplayedbytheabuserortheabused.Thesesignsinclude:• Onepartyalwayswaitsfortheothertospeakfirst.Thiscouldbeanindicatorof
controlifdonebytheabuserorfearifdonebytheabused.• Onepartyglancesattheothereachtimeheorshespeakstocheckforthe
other’sreaction.Thiscouldbeanindicatorofintimidationifdonebytheabuserorfearoflaterretributionifdonebytheabused.
• Onepartyexcuseseveryconflictdiscussed.Thiscouldbeasignthateitherpartyisattemptingtominimizetheabuse.
• Onepartysendstheotherfacialcues.Thiscouldbeasignofanumberofissues.Ifdonebytheabuser,itcouldbeasignofcontrolorintimidation.Ifdonebytheabused,itcouldbeasignoffearorapology.37
D. Bestpracticesindelinquencycasesinvolvingdomesticviolence
Thisbestpracticesmodelisintendedtoserveassuggestedguidelinesforhowdomesticviolenceshouldbesafelyhandledindelinquencycases.Itspurposeistoprovideguidanceonissuesrelatedtodomesticviolenceindelinquencycases.
FlexibilityofResponseThroughoutthedelinquencyprocess,wheneverdomesticviolenceispresent,trytoremainflexibleinrespondingtotheproblem.Ensureabusedpartieshaveaccesstosupportresourcessotheymaydevelopplanstoreduceoreliminatethedangersof
35AlexandriaZylstra.MediationandDomesticViolence:APracticalScreeningMethodforMediatorsandMediationProgramAdministrators.2001J.Disp.Resol.253(2001)at275.36Supranote31at10.37Supranote35at256-257.
58
domesticviolence.38Considereachchild’ssituationincontextandinlightofwhatishelpfulandsafeforindividualfamilymembers.39Avoidautomaticallyreferringajuveniletoastandardsetofprocessesandservices;40instead,trytodeterminewhichinterventions41areappropriateforeachyouthbasedonthespecificcharacteristicsorpatternsofviolence.42
NeedforConfidentialityThedelinquencycourtisresponsibleforalargevolumeofinformation,oftensensitiveorconfidential.Thisresponsibilityisheightenedwhenthereisdomesticviolencepresent.Whenmakingdecisionsandpoliciesaboutinformationdisclosure,balance:• theneedforinformationrequiredtoprovetheoccurrenceofchildmaltreatment
andtokeepchildrensafe,with• theneedofbatteredpartiestokeepinformationconfidentialinorderto
maintainandplaneffectivelyfortheirsafety.43
Informationthatshouldbeverycarefullyprotectedincludesthevictim’ssafetyplanandcurrentaddress.44Form12.980(h),whichisusedinthedomesticviolenceinjunctionprocess,isthemechanismforapetitionertorequesthisorheraddressbekeptconfidential.Finally,intheeventthatvictimsareaskedtowaivetheir
38SusanSchechter,withJeffreyEdleson,withmajorcontributionsbyLeonardEdwards,LindaSpears,AnnRosewater,ElizabethStoeffel.EffectiveInterventioninDomesticViolenceandChildMaltreatmentCases:GuidelinesforPolicyandPractice.NationalCouncilofJuvenileandFamilyCourtJudges(1999)at22.39NancyVerSteegh,&ClareDalton.ReportfromtheWingspreadConferenceonDomesticViolenceandFamilyCourts.(2007)at17.40Idat16.41Onearticleincludedalistofresources,including:lethalityassessment;batterers’treatmentandangermanagementprograms;alcoholanddrugtreatment;dual-diagnosisconsultantsandtreatment;victimsupportandtreatment;post-traumaticstressgroups;therapy;mediation;supervisedaccessandexchangefacilities;reunificationtherapists;parentingcoordination;assistanceinimplementingcourt-orderedparentingplans;treatmentfortraumatizedchildren;parentingwithoutviolenceclasses;parentingeducation,skillstraining,andcoaching;custodyevaluation;childprotectionservices;protectiveorders;removalofweapons;criminalpenalties;courtorderswithtriggers;suspendedorsupervisedvisitation;casemanagement;interpreterservices;housingandemploymentsupervisedaccessandexchangefacilities;reunificationtherapists;parentingcoordination;assistanceinimplementingcourt-orderedparentingplans;treatmentfortraumatizedchildren;parentingwithoutviolenceclasses;parentingeducation,skillstraining,andcoaching;custodyevaluation;childprotectionservices;protectiveorders;removalofweapons;criminalpenalties;courtorderswithtriggers;suspendedorsupervisedvisitation;casemanagement;interpreterservices;housingandemploymentassistance;immigrationservices;establishingchildsupportandpaternity;childcare;andadvocacy.Wingspread,idat17-18.42Idat17.43Supranote38at42.44Idat43.
59
privilegeregardingconfidentialinformation,verifythatthevictimunderstandstheimplicationsofsuchawaiver.45
InitialHearingsManybatteredpartiesareafraidtoadmitthattheyarevictimsofabuse.Thus,theabsenceofallegationsofabusedoesnotmeandomesticviolenceisnotpresent.Recognizethatabusevictimsmayattempttohidetheproblemforreasonswhichincludefear,shame,orembarrassment.46Ineverycase,trytospotthesignsofabuseasearlyaspossible.Theearlierinacasesignsofabuseandcoerciveorcontrollingbehaviorscanberecognized,thefastertheresponsetocreateasafeenvironmentforthechildand/orvictim.47Ifthechildistheabuseranddomesticviolenceisalleged,andthechilddoesnotmeetthedetentioncriteria,thechildmaybeplacedinsecuredetentionifthecourtmakesspecificfindingsthat:• Respitecareforthechildisnotavailable.• Itisnecessarytoplacethechildinsecuredetentioninordertoprotectthe
victimfrominjury.§985.255(2)(a)&(b).Asidefromthisprovision,thechildshallbeprocessedinthesamemannerasanyotherchildallegeddelinquent.DutytoReportIfthechildisormaybeavictimofdomesticviolence,thecourtmustreportanyknowledgeorsuspicionofabusetotheDepartmentofChildrenandFamilies.§39.201(1)(a).Ajudgemakingareportmustincludehisorhername;thisinformationisconfidentialandexemptexceptasprovidedin§39.202.§39.201(1)(b).
CourtroomPracticesThefollowingisalistofbestpracticesfordelinquencyhearingswheredomesticviolenceispresent.
Judgesshouldpromoteacultureofpatienceandcourtesythroughoutthecourtsystemsothateveryoneistreatedwithdignityandrespect.48
45Idat44.46JerryJ.Bowles,KayeK.Christian,MargaretB.Drew,KatherynL.Yetter.AJudicialGuidetoChildSafetyinCustodyCases.NationalCouncilofJuvenileandFamilyCourtJudges(2008)at20.47Idat19.48Supranote38at101.
60
• Insistthatanyattorneyspresenttreatallpartieswithrespect.Iftheabusiveparty’sattorneyisallowedtobedisrespectfultowardtheopposingparty,oranywitnesses,thatbehaviorservestoempowertheabusivepartyandcantherebyincreasethesafetythreattotheat-riskparty.
• Becausetheat-riskpartymayneedadditionaltimetoanswerquestions,insistthateachpartyisgivenadequatetimetorespond.
• Insistthatcounselmaintainarespectfuldistancefromthewitness.• Warnthepartiesandcounselagainsttheuseofsarcasticorotherdisrespectful
remarksortone.• Considerimposingsanctionsforthecontinueduseofdisrespectfultone,
remarks,ortactics.• Watchoutforandintervenetostopanycontrollingnon-verbalbehaviorbyone
partytowardtheother.49
Toensuresafetyduringthecourseofthehearingswhenthereissuspicionthatonepartyhasbeencontrolledbytheotherparty:• Informsecuritythatthesuspectedabusivepartymustbekeptasafedistance
fromtheat-riskparty.Thismayincludeescortingtheat-riskpartyintoandoutofthecourthouse.50o Physicallyseparatethepartiesinthewaitingareaandinthecourtroomto
ensurethatthereisnocommunicationbetweenthem.51• Considerusingtheservicesofavictimadvocateinthecourtroom.52
Inadditiontothesepractices,encouragethesamecaseworkerandattorneyforthechildrenandpartiestoappearatallhearingsonthecase.53Finally,rememberthattheat-riskpartymaybere-traumatizedbythepresenceoftheabusiveparty,whichmayaffecthisorhertestimonyandwhetherornotitwillbepresented.54DraftingOrdersAsageneralguide,ordersshouldbedraftedwiththefollowinggoalsinmind:• keepingthevictimsafe;
49ThomasD.Lyon,MindyB.Mechanic.DomesticViolenceandChildProtection:ConfrontingtheDilemmasinMovingFromFamilyCourttoDependencyCourt.HANDBOOKONCHILDREN,CULTURE,ANDVIOLENCE(N.Dowd,D.Singer,&R.F.Wilson2005)at13.50Id.51OfficeoftheStateCourtsAdministrator,Florida’sDomesticViolenceBenchbook(2008)at8.52Id.53Supranote38at101.54Supranote49atcard4.
61
• identifyingtheserviceneedsofthechild,includingallformsofassistanceandhelp;and
• rehabilitationandaccountabilityfortheperpetrator.55
ThecourtshouldtakesufficienttimetoexamineeachcasecarefullyandthenregularlyrevieweachcasetoensurethatcourtordersarecarriedoutbyDJJ,DCF,orotherserviceproviders.56Setadateinafewmonthstoreviewcomplianceandanydifficultiesthatthechildmightbeexperiencing.57Inthisfashiontheorderscanbetailoredtoeachspecificcaseandmonitoredforeffectiveness.
Iftheyouthistheabuser,considerorderinghimorhertoacertifiedBatterer’sInterventionProgram.Iftheyouthisnottheabuser,buthasbeenabusedorhaswitnessedabuse,considerorderingtheyouthtocounselingfordomesticviolence-relatedmentalhealthissues.
Avoiddraftingordersthatmandatealargeportionoftimeinwhichtheabusedpartyandabusivepartyareincontact.Promotingparent–childcontactwherepartiesarepronetobecomephysicallyviolentmaycreateopportunitiesforreneweddomesticviolence.58
55Supranote38at107.56Supranote38at101.57Supranote49at34.58PeterG.Jaffe,JanetR.Johnston,ClaireV.Crooks,NicholasBala.CustodyDisputesInvolvingAllegationsofChildAbuse:TowardaDifferentiatedApproachtoParentingPlans.46FamilyCourtReview500(2008)at502.
62
CommonEvidenceIssuesA. InvestigatoryStopsversusConsensualEncounters
Thereisamarkeddifferencebetweenconsensualencountersandinvestigatorystops.Aconsensualencounterisoneinwhichthecitizenisundernoobligationtocomplywiththeofficer’srequests,andmayfreelyignoretherequestsandleaveatanytime.1Assuch,noconstitutionalsafeguardsareinvoked.2Aninvestigatorystop,ontheotherhand,ismadebasedonwell-founded,articulablesuspicion.3Atthislevel,thepoliceofficercanreasonablydetainthecitizentemporarilytoascertainwhetheranyviolationsoflawhaveorareabouttooccur.4Constitutionalprotectionssuchasthe4thamendmentareinvolvedininvestigatorystops.5Adeterminationastowhetherastopwasconsensualorinvestigatoryrevolvesaroundthequestionofwhetherachildwouldreasonablyfeelfreetodisregardthepoliceandleave.6Suchadeterminationcoulddependonfactorssurroundingthestopsuchasthe"threateningpresenceofseveralofficers,thedisplayofaweaponbyanofficer,somephysicaltouchingofthepersonofthecitizen,ortheuseoflanguageortoneofvoiceindicatingthatcompliancewiththeofficer'srequestmightbecompelled."7Whereapoliceofficerdoesnotaskwhetherachildmindstalkingtohimorherandansweringquestions,butinsteaduseswordsofcompulsiontoorderachildtoengagewiththepoliceofficer,theencounterisnotconsensual,butisinsteadinvestigatory.8Indeterminingwhetherastopwasconsensualorinvestigatory,examinewhether,underatotalityofthecircumstances,areasonablepersonwouldhavefeltatlibertytoignorethepolicepresenceandgoonwithhisorherbusiness.9Whereevidencewasseizedunderastopdeterminedtobeinvestigatoryratherthanconsensual,verifythatthepoliceofficerhadtheappropriatereasonablesuspiciontoperformthestop.
1Popplev.State,626So.2d185(Fla.1993).2Idat186.3Id.4Id.5Id.6P.W.v.State,965So.2d1197(Fla.4thDCA2007)at1199.7UnitedStatesv.Mendenhall,446U.S.544(1980)at554.8D.G.v.State,714So.2d644(Fla.4thDCA1998)at646.9Caldwellv.State,985So.2d602(Fla.2dDCA2008)at606.
63
B. BodySearches
Ithasbeenwell-establishedthatalawfullyarrestedpersoncanbesearchedwithouttheneedforasearchwarrant.10However,whereapersonhasnotbeenlawfullyarrestedbutisinsteadonlydetainedbythepoliceinaninvestigatorystop,theabilitytosearchthedetainedpersonisseverelylimited.UnderFlorida’sStopandFriskLaw,§901.151,alawenforcementofficermayperformaverylimitedsearchofthepersononlywhentheofficerhasprobablecausetobelievethatthepersonisarmedwithadangerousweaponandthereforeoffersathreattothesafetyoftheofficeroranyotherperson.Thelimitedsearchmaynotinitiallygobeyonda“patdown.”11Onlyiftheofficerfeelsanobjectheorshereasonablybelievestobeaweaponmaytheofficerseizetheobject.12Courtshaveheldittobeunreasonableforapoliceofficer,withnobasisforsuspectingtheyouthhadaweapon,toperformaweaponssearchwhentheofficerhasnotperformedapatdownfirst.13Evenwhenachildputsahandinapocketinnon-compliancewithanordertoshowbothhands,theStopandFriskLawonlypermitsapatdownsearch,afterwhichaweapon,iffound,maybeseized.14
C. VehicleSearches
Whereapersonvoluntarilyconsentstoasearchofhisorhervehicle,thesearchmustbedonewithintheconstraintsofthatconsent.15Themeasureoftheconsent–andwhatpreciselyitcontains–canbedeterminedbyatestofobjectivereasonableness:whatanordinaryreasonablepersonwouldhaveunderstoodtobethescopeofconsentbytheexchangebetweentheofficerandtheconsentingperson.16Whereconsentisgiven,butlimitedduetoalockedcontainer,andafterarequestbythepoliceforthecontainertobeopenwasdenied,theconsentiseffectivelylimited,bydenial,toexcludethelockedcontainer.17Whenapersonhasbeenarrested,avehiclecanbesearchedasacontemporaneousincidenttothearrest.18However,thisabilityisnotunlimited.Whilethearrestedpersondoesnotneedtobeinthevehicleatthetimeofarrestandsearch,heorshe
10UnitedStatesv.Robinson,414U.S.218(1973).11D.B.A.v.State,962So.2d406(Fla.2dDCA2007)at407.12Id.13L.C.v.State,2009WL3763278(Fla.3dDCA2009).14Supranote11.15Davisv.State,594So.2d264(Fla.1992)at266(quotingUnitedStatesv.Blake,888F.2d795(11thCir.1989)at800).16J.J.V.v.State,17So.3d881(Fla.4thDCA2009)at884(quotingFloridav.Jimeno,500U.S.248,(1991)at251).17Idat885-886.18Thorntonv.UnitedStates,541U.S.615(2004)at617.
64
doesneedtobein"closeproximity,bothtemporallyandspatially”tothevehicle.19Therationaleforasearchwhenthearrestedpersonisincloseproximitytothevehicleisthatthearrestedpersonisstillabletodestroyevidenceinthevehicleand/orlungeforaweapon20,makingasearchofthevehicleasafetyprecautionaswellasanevidencepreservationmethod.However,theabilitytosearchthevehiclehingesontheproximaltimeanddistancethevehicleisfromthesuspect.Whereanarresteeis30-60feetfromthevehicle,aftera35minutelapsefromthetimethearresteeexitedthevehicle,andthearresteenolongerhaskeystothevehicle,thearresteeisnolongerincloseproximity,neitherspatiallynortemporally,tothevehicle.21Assuch,searchofthevehicleincidenttothearrestwouldrenderanyevidencefoundasinadmissibleunderthattheory.
D. StandardsinaSchoolSetting
Inparticular,standardsforsearchesinaschoolsettingareuniquetodelinquencycourts.Inaschoolsetting,thestandardforconductingawarrantlesssearchisdifferentthanthestandardneededoutsideofschool.Outsideofschool,thestandardisprobablecause;insidetheschool,thelawenforcementofficerneedsonlytohavereasonableorfoundedsuspicion.22Further,thisreasonablesuspicionisconsideredfromtheviewpointofareasonableofficerwiththeactualofficer’strainingandexperience.23Thereasonablesuspicionmustbebasedon“specificandarticulablefactsthat,whentakentogetherwiththerationalinferencesfromthosefacts,reasonablywarranttheintrusion."24A“hunch”or“intuition”aloneisaninsufficientbasisfora“reasonablesuspicion,”uponwhichawarrantlesssearchrelies.25Ifanofficerisjustifiedinorderingajuveniletoemptyhisorherpockets,suchanorderisequivalent,for4thamendmentpurposes,totheofficersearchingthejuvenilebyreachinginsidethejuvenile’spockets.26
E. WeaponsIssues
Section790.001(13)definesaweaponasany“dirk,knife,metallicknuckles,slungshot,billie,teargasgun,chemicalweaponordevice,orotherdeadlyweaponexceptafirearmoracommonpocketknife,plasticknife,orblunt-bladedtableknife.”Commonpocketknivesaredescribedincaselawasaknifewithabladethatcanbefoldedintothehandlethatiscarriedintheclosedpositionandthathasno
19Idat619.20Idat621.21A.T.P.v.State,973So.2d650(Fla.2dDCA2008)at653.22R.B.v.State,975So.2d546(Fla.3dDCA2008)at547.23Idat548.24C.G.v.State,941So.2d503(Fla.3dDCA2006)at504.25C.A.v.State,977So.2d684(Fla.3dDCA2008)at686.26Supranote22at548.
65
weapon-likecharacteristics(hiltguardornotchedgrip,forexample).27Additionally,ifthepocketknife’sbladeisfourinchesorless,theknifeisconsideredacommonpocketknife.28Adeadlyweaponisdefinedasanitemwhich,ifusedintheordinarymannercontemplatedbyitsdesign,islikelytocauseseriousbodilyharmordeath.29Whethertheitemisadeadlyweaponisafactualquestiondeterminedbyconsideringsize,material,andmannerinwhichitwasusedorcouldbeused.30Severalexamplecaseshavedemonstratedtheanalysisthecourtsengageinwhendeterminingwhetheranobjectisa“deadlyweapon.”31Asdiscussedabove,whenalawenforcementofficerhasprobablecausetobelieveachildmaybecarryingadangerousweapon,thatofficermayengageinalimitedsearchcalleda“patdown”todetermineifthechildisinfactcarryingadangerousweapon.32Onlyiftheofficerfeelsanobjectthatheorshereasonablybelievestobeadangerousweaponmayheorsheseizetheweapon.33
27SeeJ.R.P.v.State,979So.2d1178(Fla.3dDCA2008)foranexample.28L.B.v.State,700So.2d370(Fla.1997)at372.29J.W.v.State,807So.2d148(Fla.2dDCA2002)at149.30Simmonsv.State,780So.2d263(Fla.4thDCA2001)at265.31SeeD.B.B.v.State,997So.2d484(Fla.2dDCA2008)(abicyclethrown10feetfromtheintendedvictimthatonlytraveled5feetwasnotadeadlyweapon);E.J.v.State,554So.2d578(Fla.3dDCA1989)at579(determiningthataskateboardthrownatavehiclewasnotadeadlyweapon);Forchionv.State,214So.2d751(Fla.3dDCA1968)at752(findingthatatwofootlongpartofabroomhandlethrownfromtwelvetofifteenfeetawaywasnotadeadlyweapon);Roganv.State,203So.2d24(Fla.3dDCA1967)at25(concludingthataone-footdiameterflowerpotfilledwithdirt,whichwasthrownthroughthewindowofaresidence,didnotqualifyasadeadlyweaponwherethevictimwasseatedfivefeetfromthewindow).32Supranote11.33Id.
66
ImmigrationIssuesJuvenileadjudicationsofdelinquencyarenot,forthepurposesoftheImmigrationandNaturalizationAct(INA),considered“convictions.”1AsmostoftheprovisionsintheINA’sDeportableAliensection(8CFR1227)aretriggeredonlywherethereisaconviction,adjudicationsofdelinquencydonotoftenresultincontactwithImmigrationandNaturalizationService(INS).However,therearecertainoffensesin§1227thatdonotrequireaconvictiontorenderanoncitizenjuveniledeportable.Theseoffensesinclude:
• Anyalienwhois,oratanytimeafteradmissionhasbeen,adrugabuseroraddict,8CFR1227(a)(2)(B)(ii);
• Anyalienwho,atanytimeafteradmission,isenjoinedunderavalidprotectionorderandwhomthecourtdetermineshasengagedinconductthatviolatestheportionofaprotectionorderthatinvolvesprotectionagainstcrediblethreatsofviolence,repeatedharassment,orbodilyinjurytothepersonorpersonsforwhomtheprotectionorderwasissued,8CFR1227(a)(2)(E)(ii);
• Anyalienwhoengagesinorattemptstoengageinhumantrafficking,orwhohasbeenaknowingaider,abettor,assister,conspirator,orcolluderwithsuchatraffickerinsevereformsoftraffickinginpersons,8CFR1227(a)(2)(F);
• Anyalienwhofalselyrepresents,orhasfalselyrepresented,himselftobeacitizenoftheUnitedStatesforanypurposeorbenefitunderthischapteroranyFederalorStatelaw,8CFR1227(a)(3)(D);and
• Anyalienwhohasengaged,isengaged,oratanytimeafteradmissionengagesinespionage,sabotage,oranyothercrimethatendangerspublicsafetyornationalsecurity.8CFR1227(a)(4)(A).
Furthermore,anadjudicationofguiltmayresultindeportationevenifitdidnotstemfromoneoftheaboveoffenses.IfthedispositionorderedforthechildincludesasubstantialperiodoftimeinthecustodyofDJJ,anoncitizenjuvenilemaybedeportable.Additionally,ifanoncitizenjuvenileisdeterminedtobeincompetentandisorderedintoDCF’scustodyforasubstantialperiodoftime,thejuvenilemaybedeportable.Section1227(a)(5)says,“anyalienwho,withinfiveyearsafterthedateofentry,hasbecomeapublicchargefromcausesnotaffirmativelyshowntohavearisensinceentry…”Publicchargehasbeendefinedasbecomingprimarilydependentonthegovernmentforsubsistence,asdemonstratedbyreceiptofpublicassistance,orinstitutionalizationforlong-termcareatgovernmentexpense.2(emphasisadded)
1InreDevison,22I&NDec.1362(BIA2000).2U.S.CitizenshipandImmigrationServices.QuestionsandAnswers:PublicCharge.USDepartmentofHomelandSecurity(May,1999),availableathttp://www.uscis.gov/files/article/public_cqa.pdf.
67
Asaresult,therearecircumstanceswhereanoncitizenjuvenilemaynotbefullyawareoftheconsequencesofapossiblenolocontendereorguiltyplea.Thus,thecourtmayincludeinitscolloquythatisprovidedpriortodeterminingthevoluntarinessofanolocontendereorguiltypleaashortstatementaboutthepossibilityofdeportationforcertainactsorconsequences,asindicatedintheArraignmentHearingSectiononpage125-126.
68
InterpretersforForeignLanguagesThecourtwilloftenbepresentedwithindividualswhocannotcommunicateproperlyinEnglish.ItmaybethattheindividualdoesnotspeakEnglishatallorspeakslimitedEnglishinsufficientforcourtcommunications.Insituationssuchasthese,thecourtmustbeabletoidentifythecommunicationbarriers,determinethebestmethodforsurmountingtheobstacle,andprovideanindividualorservicecapableofresolvingtheproblem.1
A. IdentifyNeedforInterpretingServices
Thefirstthingthecourtmustdoisidentifythatacommunicationproblemexists.Itmaybethecasethatthepersoninneedofservicesrequestsinterpreterservices,oranon-courtpersonnelinitiallydeterminesthataninterpreterisneededandcommunicatessuchtothecourt.2However,thecourtmaynothaveanyindicationthatinterpreterservicesarerequireduntilthepersoninneedofservicesisinthecourtroomduringahearing.Inwhatevermannerthecourtlearnsoftheneedforservices,oncetheneedisidentified,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherandwhattypeofinterpreterserviceisrequired.TheRulesofJudicialAdministrationspecifyinwhichcircumstancesaninterpreterisrequired,andwhenthecourtmayfindthattheservicesarenotrequired.3Wheretheproceedingisacriminalorjuveniledelinquencyproceeding,andthepersoninneedofservicesistheaccused,thecourtmustappointaninterpreterforthatperson.4Further,iftheproceedingisadependency,delinquency,orChildorFamilyinNeedofServicescase,courtinterpretingservicesarerequiredforeverypersonwhoisapartytothecase(includingparentsorguardians).5Ifthevictimisthepersoninneedofservices,thecourtmustappointaninterpreterunlessitfindsthatthevictimdoesnotrequirethoseservices.6Inallotherproceedings,aninterpreterforalitigantinneedofinterpretiveservicesmustbeappointedifthecourtdetermines“thattheinabilitytounderstandEnglishdeprivesthelitigantofanunderstandingofthecourtproceedings,thatafundamentalinterestisatstake(suchasinacivilcommitment,terminationofparentalrights,paternity,ordependency
1CommissiononTrialCourtPerformanceandAccountability,RecommendationsfortheProvisionofCourtInterpretingServicesinFlorida’sTrialCourts.DRAFT(2010)at10.2Idat11.3Fla.R.ofJud.Admin.2.560(2009),hereinafterreferredtoas“Rule2.560.”4Rule2.560(a).5CommitteeonTrialCourtPerformanceandAccountability.CourtInterpreters:ReportandRecommendations.(January2002)at13,availableonlineathttp://www.flcourts.org/gen_public/pubs/bin/CourtInterpretersFinalReport.pdf.6Id.
69
proceeding),andthatnoalternativetotheappointmentofaninterpreterexists.”7Finally,inanyproceedingwhereawitnessisthepersoninneedofservicestheappointmentofaninterpreterisgovernedbytheapplicableprovisionsoftheFloridaEvidenceCode.8Ifthechildisnon-English-speakingorlimited-English-proficient,appointaninterpreter.Ifthevictimisnon-English-speakingorlimited-English-proficient,appointaninterpreterunlessthecourtfindsthatthevictimdoesnotrequiresuchservices.Rule2.560(a).Ifthewitnessisnon-English-speakingorlimited-English-proficient,appointmentofaninterpreterisgovernedbytheFloridaEvidenceCode.Rule2.560(c).Inmakingdeterminationsregardingtheappointmentofaninterpreter,ensurecompliancewiththerequirementsofTitleVIoftheCivilRightsActof1964.Rule2.560(d).Wheneverpossible,acertifiedorotherdulyqualifiedinterpreter,asdefinedintheRulesforCertificationandRegulationofSpokenLanguageCourtInterpreters,mustbeappointed.Rule2.560(e)(1).Preferenceisgiventoappointmentofcertifiedandlanguageskilledinterpreters,thentopersonsholdingaprovisionallyapproveddesignation.Rule2.560(e)(1)andRule14.100(a)-(e).If,afterdiligentsearch,acertifiedorotherdulyqualifiedinterpreterisnotavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreterwhoisregisteredwiththeOfficeofStateCourtsAdministrator.Thecourtmustmakeadetermination,ontherecord,thattheproposedinterpreteriscompetent.Rule2.560(e)(2).Ifnocertifiedorotherdulyqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotcertifiedorqualifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexists,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(3).SuchanappointmentislimitedtoaspecificproceedingandcannotbeextendedtosubsequentproceedingswithoutadditionalfindingsofgoodcauseandtherequirementssetforthinRules2.560(e)(3)and(4).Rule2.560(e)(5).IftheinterpreterisnotappointedunderRule2.560(e)(1),thecourtmustsoadvisethechild,ontherecord,andthechildmayobjectorwaivetheappointment.Rule2.560(e)(4).
B. PerformAssessmenttoDetermineNeeds
Whenthecourthasdeterminedthatthereisaneedforinterpretiveservices,thenextstepistodeterminewhichinterpretiveserviceismostappropriatebyperforminganassessmentoftheperson’sneeds.Iftheneedforserviceshasbeenidentifiedinadvanceoftheproceeding,thecourtcanusetheinformationsubmittedtoperformtheassessment.9Iftheperson’sneedsarenotidentifieduntilthepersonisincourt,thecourtshouldconductabriefquestionnaire,askingquestionsthat
7Rule2.560(b).8Rule2.560(c).9Supranote1at11.
70
involvedescriptionsornarrationstodeterminetheextentofthecommunicationbarrierandtheservicesrequired.10WhenthecourtdeterminesthatapartyorwitnesscannotunderstandtheEnglishlanguage,orcannotexpresshim-orherselfinEnglishsufficientlytobeunderstood,thecourtmustbringinaqualifiedinterpreter.§90.606(1)(a).ThisisnotlimitedtoindividualswhospeakalanguageotherthanEnglish,butincludesanypersonwhocannotbereasonablyunderstood,orcannotreasonablyunderstandquestioningwithouttheaidofaninterpreter.§90.606(1)(b).
C. SelectionofInterpreter
Oncethecourthasdeterminedthataneedforinterpretiveservicesexists,andhasassessedtheextentofthecommunicationbarrier,thecourtmustselectaninterpreterfortheproceeding.11Typically,thecourtadministrationwillhavecontactswithappropriateinterpreters,andcanassignaninterpreterbasedonseveralfactors,suchas:thelanguageneeded,typeofcase,complexityofproceedings,qualificationsofinterpreter,location,andavailabilityofremoteinterpretingtechnology.12Wheneverpossible,acertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpretermustbeappointed.13Fornon-Englishinterpreters,certifiedhasbeendefinedas,“aninterpreterwhohascompletedthemandatoryrequirementsasdefinedbytheserulesandholdsavalidcertificateasacertifiedcourtinterpreterissuedbytheOfficeoftheStateCourtsAdministratorandisnamedintheregistryofcertifiedcourtinterpretersmaintainedbytheOfficeoftheStateCourtsAdministrator.”14Dulyqualifiedhasbeendefinedas,“aninterpreterwhohasobtainedapassinggradeonawrittenexamination,whohasattendedatwo-dayorientationprogramofferedbytheOfficeoftheStateCourtsAdministrator,whoisfamiliarwithPartIIIoftheserules,andwhohasanunderstandingofbasiclegalterminologyinbothlanguages.”15Theremaybesituationswhereacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpretercannotalwaysbereadilyappointed;aninterpreterwhoisneitherdulyqualifiednorcertifiedmaybeappointedduringaproceeding,ifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsforsaidappointment,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andthe
10Id.11Id.12Id.13Rule2.560(e)(1)andFla.Stat.90.6063(2).14RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters(hereinafter“Rule”),Rule14.100(a)(2009).15Rule14.100(b).
71
proposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.16Incriminalandjuveniledelinquencyproceedings,adefendantisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreterwhoisneitherdulyqualifiednorcertified.17
D. ProvisionofServices
Beforeprovidinganyinterpretiveservices,theinterpretermusttakeanoaththatheorshewillmakea“trueinterpretation”ofthequestionsaskedandtheanswersgiven,andthattheinterpreterwillmakea“truetranslation”intoEnglishanywritingthatheorsheisrequiredtotranslate.18Aninterpreterforadeaforhard-of-hearingpersonmustdemonstratethatheorsheisabletocommunicatereadilywiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.19Interpretersareexpectedtorendercompleteandaccurateinterpretationwithoutaltering,omitting,explaining,oraddinganythingtowhatthepersoninneedofservicescommunicates.20Further,interpretersareexpectedtobeimpartialandunbiased.Ifthereisanyrealorperceivedconflictofinterest,theinterpretermustdisclosesuchtothecourt.21Interpretersaresubjecttothesameprovisionsaswitnesses,22andmustprotecttheconfidentialityofallprivilegedandconfidentialinformation.23
E. ModesofInterpretingandServiceDeliveryMethods
Thereareseveralmodesofinterpretingthatmaybeavailabletothecourt.Thefirstisconsecutiveinterpretation,inwhichtheinterpreterrendersstatementsfromortothepersoninneedofservicestoorbythecourtintermittently,afterapausebetweenstatementsbythespeaker.24Consecutiveinterpretingmayrequirecommunicationsbetweenpartiestobebrokenbytheinterpreterintosmallutterancesthattheinterpreteriscapableofrememberingforinterpretation.Alternatively,theinterpretermayengageinsimultaneousinterpretation,renderinganinterpretationcontinuouslytothepersoninneedofservicesatthesametimethatthespeakeriscommunicating.25Simultaneousinterpretationisintendedtobe
16Rule2.560(e)(2).17Supranote1at12.18Fla.Stat.90.606(3)andFla.Stat.90.6063(7).19Fla.Stat.90.6063(6).20Rule14.310.21Id.22Fla.Stat.90.606(2).23Rule14.340andFla.Stat.90.6063(7).24Supranote1at12.25Id.
72
receivedbythepersonbeingaddressedbythepersoninneedofservices;assuch,theinterpretermayuseequipmenttoensuretheinformationisreceivedproperlywithoutdisruptionstotheproceeding.26Anothermodeofinterpretingissighttranslation,whereintheinterpreterprovidesanoralrenditionofasourcetextfromonelanguagetoanother.27Finally,theinterpretercanengageintranslationservices,whereinheorshecreatesawrittendocumentinthetargetlanguagethataccuratelyreproducestheequivalentofthewrittensourcelanguagedocument.28Theaboveservicescanbedeliveredinavarietyofways.Commonly,theinterpreterisphysicallypresentattheproceeding.Thismaybedesirablewherethehearingwillbelengthyorcomplex,orwheretechnicalissuesorlimitationsmayexist.29Analternativetothisisremotetelephoneinterpretation,wheretheinterpreterusesastandardtelephonelineandaspeakerphonetoconsecutivelyorsimultaneouslyinterpretthecommunicationstoorfromthepersoninneedofservicesandthecourt.30Thismaybeusedwhenaninterpreterisunabletobepresentforthehearingduetodistanceorotherfactorsbutisstillavailabletointerpret.Asecondalternativeisremoteaudio/videointerpretation,whereinterpretersuseintegratedaudio-visualorinternet-basedsystemstofacilitatecommunication.31Theadvantagesofthissystemareevengreaterthanthosewithtelephonicinterpretation,asthevideocommentallowsaninterpretertoactuallyviewtheactivitiesinthecourtroomastheyareprovidingtheinterpretingservice,andaudiomixersallowforspeakerisolation.
26Id.27NationalAssociationofJudiciaryInterpretersandTranslators.TermsoftheProfession.(n.d.)availableonlineathttp://www.najit.org/Publications/Terms%20of%20the%20Profession.pdf.28Supranote1at13.29Id.30Id.31Id.
73
InterstateCompactA. Generally
TheInterstateCompactisanagreementamongandbetweenthestatestocooperatewitheachotherinreturningchildrentostateswhentheirreturnissought,andinacceptingthereturnofchildrenwheneverachildresidinginastateisfoundorapprehendedinanotherstate.§985.801(2).TheCompactcanbefoundat§985.802.
B. RunawaysandEscapees–Procedure
ArticleIVoftheCompactdiscussesthereturnofrunaways,whileArticleVdiscussesthereturnofescapees.BothArticlesoperateinafunctionallysimilarmanner.Apersonoragencythathaslegalcustodyofachildwhohasnotbeenadjudicateddelinquentbuthasrunawaywithoutconsent,orachildadjudicateddelinquentwhohasescapedcustody,maypetitiontheappropriatecourtinthedemandingcourtforanissuanceofa“RequisitionfortheJuvenile’sReturn.”Thepetitionmusteitherstatesuchfactsastendtoshowthattheunemancipatedchildwhohasrunawayisendangeringhisorherownwelfareorthewelfareofothers,or(ifthechildhasbeenfounddelinquent)statetheparticularsofthechild’sadjudicationofdelinquencyandthecircumstancesofthebreach.Thepetitionmustbeverifiedbyaffidavit,andbeaccompaniedbycertifiedcopiesofdocumentsonwhichthepetitioner’sentitlementofthechild’scustodyisbased.Thecourttowhichthepetitionerappliesmayholdahearingtodeterminecustodyandemancipationstatusaswellaswhetheritisinthechild’sbestintereststobereturnedtothestate.Ifthecourtdetermines,withorwithoutahearing,thatthechildshouldbereturned,thecourtshallpresenttotheappropriatejurisdictionwherethechildisallegedtobeawrittenRequisitionfortheJuvenile’sReturn.Thecourtwillthenissueanorderforanylawenforcementofficertotakethechildintocustody.Oncethechildistakenintocustody,thecourtmayappointhimorheraGuardianadLitemorcounsel.Iftherequisitionisinorder,thecourtmustdeliverthechildtoanofficerofthecourtdemandingthechild.IfthereisnoRequisitionoutstanding,butthecourthasreasonableinformationthatthechildhasrunawayfromorescapedfromanotherstate,thecourtcantakethechildintocustodytodeterminewhetherprobablecauseexiststoholdthechild.ThecourtmayappointthechildcounselorGuardianadLitem.Thecourtmayholdthechildforupto90daystoenablethechildtoreturntoanotherstatewhereinanagencyorpartyhaslegalcustodyoverthechild.Ifthechildhascommittedadelinquentactinthestateheorshehasrunawaytoorescapedto,thechildmaynotbereturnedtohisorherhomestatewithouttheconsentofthecourtwithoutfirstdischarginganyobligationsarisingfromthecommissionofthedelinquentact.
74
C. VoluntaryReturnProcedure
ArticleVIdetailshowachildmayvoluntarilyreturntoastateheorsheranawayorescapedfrom.Whenarunawayorescapeechildistakenintocustody,heorshecanconsenttobereturnedtohisorherhomestate,withorwithoutaRequisitionofReturnfiled.ThecourtmustinformthechildofhisorherrightsundertheCompactbeforeallowingthechildtoreturntothehomestate.
D. ProbationersandParolees
ArticleVIIindicatesthatwhenprobationersorparoleesmovefromonestatetoanother,thereceivingstatemay,afteranexaminationofthefactssurroundingthechild’scase,acceptsupervisionoftheparoleeorprobationer.
E. SupplementaryAgreements
TheInterstateCompactdoesnotbarstatesfromenteringintosupplementaryagreementswithotherstates.
75
JurisdictioninDelinquencyProceedingsA. Generally
Thecircuitcourtsaregrantedoriginaljurisdictionoverjuveniledelinquencyproceedings.§985.0301(1).Jurisdictionattachestoacaseandthesubjectchildineitheroftwosituations.Whenthechildhasbeentakenintocustodywithorwithoutserviceofsummonsandbeforeorafterfilingofadelinquencypetition,personaljurisdictionattachestothechild.§985.0301(2)&(4)(b).Or,whenthechildandhisorherparentorguardianhasbeenservedsummons,subjectmatterjurisdictionattaches.§985.0301(2)&(4)(b).Petitionsallegingdelinquencymustbefiledinthecircuitwheretheallegedviolationoccurred,butmaybetransferredtothecircuitinwhichthechildlives.§985.0301(4)(a).
B. RetentionofJurisdiction
Oncejurisdictionattaches,thecircuitcourtwillinmostcasesretainjurisdictionoverachildadjudicateddelinquentuntilthechildturns19yearsold,unlessthecourtrelinquishesjurisdictionsooner,§985.0301(5)(a),thoughthetermsofcommitmentmayrununtilthechildturns21yearsold.§985.0301(5)(c).Exceptionsto(5)(a)includechildreninhighormaximumriskfacilitiesandsexualoffenders,overwhomthecourtmayretainjurisdictionuntilthechildturns21yearsofage,§985.0301(5)(d)-(g),thoughthetermsofcommitmentunderjuvenilecourtremainlimitedtothechild’sturning21yearsofage.§985.0301(5)(f).Oncejurisdictionhasattached,thecourtretainsjurisdictionoveranyrestitutionorderuntiltheorderissatisfied.§985.0301(5)(h).Therestitutionorderisseparatefromthedispositionorderororderofcommitment.
76
JuvenileAssessmentCenter
JuvenileAssessmentCenters(JAC)arecommunityoperatedfacilitiesthatprovidecollocatedcentralintakeandscreeningservices,aswellasabroadarrayofyouth-relatedservices.§985.135(1)&(2).Thecentersaremanagedandgovernedbytheparticipatingagenciesthroughinteragencyagreementsandanadvisorycommitteethatguidesthecenter’soperation.§985.135(3).Theparticipatingagencieshaveoperationaloversightononlythoseindividualservicecomponentsforwhichtheagencyhasstatutoryauthorityandresponsibility.§985.135(3).EachJACprovidesacentralintakeandscreeningservicesforchildrenreferredtoDJJ.Thecentermustprovidesufficientservicestofacilitateinitialscreeningandcaseprocessing,includingdelinquencyintake,identificationofthechild,aneedsassessmentandsubstanceabuse,mental,andphysicalscreenings,anddiagnostictestingwhereappropriate.§985.135(4).Thecenterscanalsobeusedtoconductpredispositionsandassessmentsofchildrenindetentioncenters.§985.135(7).TheJACsarealsoencouragedtoprovideatruancyprogramthatwouldprovidecentralintakeandscreeningoftruantchildrenwithinaspecificarea.§985.135(5).
77
JuvenileSexOffendersandTheAdamWalshActA. Generally
In2006theAdamWalshChildProtectionandSafetyAct(42USC16901)wasenactedinanefforttoassistlawenforcementintrackingsexualoffenders.Toconformwiththenewfederallaw,§943.0435wasamendedtorequirecertainjuvenilesexoffenderstoregisterwiththeFloridaDepartmentofLawEnforcement(FDLE)andtheiridentitybepostedontheFDLEpublicwebsite.The“AdamWalshAct”requirestheinclusionofchildren14yearsorolderatthetimethecrimewascommittedifthecrimewascomparableormoreseverethanaggravatedchildabuseasdescribedin18USC2241.Asaresult,§943.0435(1)(a)(1)(d)providesthatjuvenilesexoffendersarerequiredtoregisteriftheywere14yearsorolderatthetimethecrimewascommittedandthecrimewas:• SexualBattery§794.011excluding§794.011(10);• LewdandLasciviousBattery§800.04(4)(b)wherethevictimisunder12yearsof
ageorthecourtfindssexualactivitybytheuseofforceorcoercion;• LewdandLasciviousMolestation§800.04(5)(c)(1)wherethecourtfinds
molestationofavictimunder12yearsofagebyanoffenderunder18yearsofage,andthemolestationinvolvedunclothedgenitals;or
• LewdandLasciviousMolestation§800.04(5)(d)wherethecourtfindsmolestationofavictimages12-16byanoffenderunder18yearsofage,wherepresentweretheuseofforceorcoercionandunclothedgenital.
B. WrittenFindingsRequired
Forallqualifyingoffenses,thecourtmustmakeawrittenfindingoftheageoftheoffenderandtheageofthevictimatthetimeoftheoffense.Makingthisfindinginallcasesinvolvingasexualoffenseisabestpracticeforhandlingthisrequirement.§943.0435(1)(a)(2).Foraviolationof§800.04(4),thecourtmustmakeanadditionalwrittenfindingindicatingthattheoffensedidordidnotinvolvesexualactivityandindicatingthattheoffensedidordidnotinvolveforceorcoercion.§943.0435(1)(a)(2).Foraviolationof§800.04(5),thecourtmustmakeanadditionalwrittenfindingthattheoffensedidordidnotinvolveunclothedgenitalsorgenitalareaandthattheoffensedidordidnotinvolvetheuseofforceorcoercion.§943.0435(1)(a)(2).
C. Registration
Thequalifyingjuvenilesexoffendermaymotionthecourttoremovetheregistrationrequirementsifthechildisnotmorethan4yearsolderthanthevictimwhowas14
78
yearsofageorolderbutnotmorethan17yearsofageatthetimeoftheoffense.§943.04354(1)(c).Forthosewhomustregisterasasexualoffender,theyarerequiredtopresentinformationtotheSheriff’sofficeinthecountywheretheyreside,andprovidetheauthoritieswithinformationregardingtheirabode,identifyingcharacteristics,methodsofcommunication(e.g.telephonenumber,emailaddress,instantmessagename),andmustbephotographedandfingerprinted.§943.0435(2).Thisinformationisenteredintoanationaldatabaseandmaybepublic.Juvenilesexualoffendersmustre-registeronaquarterlybasis.§943.0435(14)(b).
D. RemovalfromtheRegistry
Anoffenderwillstayontheregistryforthedurationofhisorherlife,unlessthatoffenderhasreceivedafullpardonorhashadaconvictionsetasideinapost-convictionproceedingforanyoffensethatmeetsthecriteriaforclassifyingthepersonasasexualoffenderforpurposesofregistration.§943.0435(11).However,selectoffendersmaybeabletohavetheirnamesremovedfromtheregistryandmayhavetheregistrationrequirementremovediftheyhavebeenlawfullyreleasedfromconfinementorsupervisionfor25years,havenotcommittedanymisdemeanororfelonyoffenseinthattime,andwerenotguiltyofcertainoffensescommittedasadults.§943.0435(11)(a).
79
JuvenileSexOffenderProgramsA. Generally
Juvenilesexualoffenderbehaviorrangesfromnoncontactsexualbehavior(e.g.obscenephonecalls,exhibitionism,andvoyeurism)tovaryingdegreesofsexualcontact(e.g.frottage,fondling,rape,andothersexuallyaggressiveacts).§985.475(1)(b).
B. CommunityBasedTreatmentServices
Followingadelinquencyadjudicatoryhearing,thecourtmay,onitsownoronrequestbyDJJorthestate(subjecttospecificappropriation),makedeterminationsastothebestplacementofthechildandmayorderacomprehensiveassessmentthatfocusesspecificallyonsexuallydeviantbehavior.§985.475(2).Anyreportsoorderedmustcontain,ataminimum:• anaccountbytheoffenderoftheincident;• theofficialhistoryofthecase;• thejuvenile’soffensehistory;• anassessmentoftheoffender’ssexuallydeviantbehaviors,includingan
assessmentbyacertifiedmentalhealthprofessional;and• anassessmentoftheoffender’sfamily,social,educational,andemployment
situation.§985.475(2)(a).Thereportmustalsocontainanassessmentofthechild’samenabilitytocommunity-basedtreatmentandanythreatorrisktothevictimorcommunity,§985.475(2)(b),aswellasaproposedtreatmentplanthatdetailstherapyinteractionsandduration.§985.475(c).Ifafterreceivingthereport,thecourtdeterminesthatthecommunitytreatmentisappropriate,thecourtmayplacethechildintreatmentforupto3years.§985.475(e).Thecourtmayrequirethechildtocomplywithvariousconditionsofcommunitytreatment,includingtreatmentplancomplianceandphysicalgeographicboundaries.§985.475(e)(1)&(2).Thetreatmentprovidermustsubmitquarterlyreportstothecourtandtothepartiestotheproceedings,detailingthechild’sprogressintreatment.§985.475(2)(f).Thereportmustreferencethetreatmentplanandmustincludeataminimum:• datesofthechild’sattendance;• thechild’scompliancewiththerequiredtreatment;• adescriptionofthetreatmentactivities;• thechild’srelativeprogress;
80
• thechild’sfamilysupportofthetreatment;and• anyothermaterialspecifiedbythecourtatdisposition.§985.475(f)(1)-(6).Ifthechildfailstocomplywiththecommunitytreatmentservices,thecourtmayrevokethetreatmentandorderthechildtobecommittedtoDJJ.§985.475(h).
C. JuvenileSexualOffenderCommitmentPrograms
DJJisauthorizedtoimplementandoperateprogramsthatprovide“intensiveeducationalandpsychologicalservicesandothertreatmentsforjuvenilesexualoffenders,”§985.48(2),andmaycontractwithprivateorganizationsfortheoperationofsuchprograms.§985.475(7).Ajuvenilesexualoffenderprogrammustincludeeducationalcomponents,lifemanagementtraining,substanceabusetreatment,andintensivepsychologicaltreatmentprovidedbyappropriatementalhealthprofessionals.§985.475(4).DJJmayincludeanintensiveconditionalreleasecomponentthatwouldassistinachild’stransitionintothecommunity.§985.475(5).Suchacomponentmayincludetermsandconditionssuchaselectronicmonitoringofthechild.§985.475(5).Whenachildisreturnedtothecommunity,DJJmustinformtheschools,lawenforcementagencies,andthecourt.§985.475(6).DJJmustconductinspectionsofthejuvenilesexualoffenderprogramstoverifyqualityassuranceandtodeterminethateachprogramcomplieswithDJJrulesforcontinuedoperation,§985.475(9),andmustkeeprecordsnecessarytoevaluatetheeffectivenessofsuchprograms.§985.475(10).
81
Medicaid/MedicareEligibilityforServicesuponRelease1DelinquentchildrenputinDJJcustodyareeligibleforMedicaidservicesonlyiftheyareplacedinLoworModerateRiskNON-stateoperatedresidentialprograms.AnyotherformofresidentialcarewillcausethechildtobeineligibleforMedicaid.RequirementsforapplyingorreapplyingforMedicaidfollowingachild’sreleasefromDJJcaredependonwhetherthechildhasfamilythatwerereceivingMedicaidbenefitsatthetimeheorshewasplacedintoDJJ’scustody.IfthechildwasreceivingMedicaidbenefitsatthetimeheorshewasdetained,andifheorshehasotherfamilymembersreceivingbenefits,thechildcanregainhisorherbenefitsif,uponreleasefromDJJcare,afamilymemberinformsandrequestsDCFforre-instatementofthechild’sbenefits.IfthechildwasreceivingMedicaidbenefitsatthetimeofdetention,butnootherfamilymemberswerereceivingbenefits,thechildcanregainhisorherbenefitsif,uponreleasefromDJJcare,afamilymembercompletesanapplicationforMedicaidbenefitsandsubmitsittothelocalDCFservicecenter.TheDCFMedicaidapprovalprocesscantakeupto45days.OnceachildisapprovedforMedicaidbenefits,aformletterwillbesenttotheparentorcustodian.
1InformationinthissectionfromDepartmentofJuvenileJustice,availableonlineathttp://www.djj.state.fl.us/AboutDJJ/faq.html#HealthP3.
82
RestitutionThecourtthathasjurisdictionoverachildadjudicateddelinquentmay,byanorderstatingthefactsuponwhichadeterminationofrestitutionwasmade,orderthechildtomakerestitution.§985.437(1).Achildhasaconstitutionalrighttobepresentatarestitutionhearing,unlessheorshehasknowinglyandvoluntarilywaivedthatright.J.C.v.State,1So.3d1196(Fla.5thDCA2008).Suchrestitutionwouldbepartoftheprobationprogramor,foracommittedchild,partofthecommunity-basedsanctionsorderedbythecourt.§985.437(1).Therestitutionorderedmaybemonetaryormayberestitutioninkind,andwouldbethroughapromissorynotecosignedbythechild’sparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Wheneverrestitutionisordered,theamountmaynotexceedanamountthechildandparentorguardiancouldreasonablybeexpectedtopay,§985.437(2),andmustbebasedonadeterminationofthechild’sexpectedearningsuponfindingsuitableemployment.K.T.M.v.State,969So.2d542(Fla.2dDCA2007).Thecourtmayrelyondirecttestimonyoffairmarketvaluetodeterminetheamountofrestitution.Ifdirectevidenceoffairmarketvalueisnotavailable,thecourtcanrelyonthefollowingtoascertainfairmarketvalue:• originalmarketcost;• mannerinwhichtheitemwasused;• generalconditionandqualityoftheitem;and• thepercentageofdepreciation.K.W.v.State,983So.2d713(Fla.2dDCA2008)
Thecourtmayalsobasetheamountofrestitutiononreplacementcosts,asanalternativetofairmarketvalue.983So.2dat715.Anotheralternativeavailabletothecourtisout-of-pocketvaluation;ifthisisused,theamountofrestitutionshouldbeoffsetbythesalvagevalueofanypropertyreturned.C.M.S.v.State,997So.2d520(Fla.2dDCA2008).
Afindingthattheparentorguardianmadeagoodfaithefforttopreventthechildfromcommittingthejuvenileact(s)mayabsolvetheparentorguardianfromliabilityforrestitution.§985.437(4).
Finally,thecourtmayretainjurisdictionoverthechildandthechild’sparentorguardianwhomthecourthasorderedtopayrestitutionuntiltherestitutionispaidinfullorthecourtordersotherwise.§985.437(5).
83
RiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI)Thecourt’sdeterminationsandordersregardingplacementofachildintodetentioncaremustbebasedonariskassessmentofthechild,unlessheorsheisplacedintodetentioncareasaresultofadomesticviolenceoffense.§985.245(1).TheRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI)takesintoconsiderationavarietyoffactors,includingbutnotlimitedto:• historyoffailuretoappear;• prioroffenses;• offensescommittedpendingadjudication;• unlawfulpossessionofafirearm;• theftofamotorvehicleorpossessionofastolenmotorvehicle;and• probationstatusattimetakenintocustody.§985.245(2)(b).TheRAImayalsotakeintoconsiderationanymitigatingoraggravatingfactors,andmustincludeanyinformationconcerningahistoryofabuseorneglect.§985.245(2)(b).TheRAIwillalsoexaminethedelinquentactthechildisallegedtohavecommitted,andassignpointvaluestocurrentandpreviousoffenses,aswellashistory,legalstatus,andotherfactors.Ifpossessionoruseofthefirearmispartoftheinchoateoffense(i.e.aggravatedassaultwithafirearm)thenfirearmassessmentpointsshouldnotbeincluded,andisanimpermissibledoublescoring.M.W.v.DepartmentofJuvenileJustice,15So.3d782(Fla.1stDCA2009).Thetotalnumberofpointswilldeterminethechild’srecommendeddetention.Ifthechildscoresmorethan12points,heorshewillberecommendedforsecuredetention.Ifthechildscoresbetween7and11points,therecommendationwillbefornon-securedetention.Finally,ifthechildscores6pointsorless,heorshewillberecommendedforrelease.AsampleRAIisincludedintheAppendices.
84
ServiceofProcessUponthefilingofapetitionallegingthatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationofthelaw,theclerkordeputyclerkwillissueasummons.§985.319(2).Thesummonsmusthaveacopyofthepetitionattachedandmustorderthepersonservedtoappearforahearingbeforethecourtonaspecifiedtimeandplace,nolessthan24hoursafterservice,exceptinthecaseofamedicalemergency.§985.319(3).Ifthechildhasnotbeendetained,heorshemustappearatthehearing.§985.319(3).Lawenforcementmustserveprocesswithin7daysafteranarraignmentorassoonaspossibleafter,exceptthatnoserviceisdoneonSundays.§985.319(4).Thesummonsmustbedirectedtoandservedupon,thechild,theparentsofthechild,andanylegaloractualguardiansorcustodians,andthechild’sGuardianadLitem.§985.319(5).Ifthecourtdeemsitadvisableunderthelisteddetentioncriteria,thechildmaybetakenintocustodywhenserved.§985.319(6).Iftheidentityoftheparents,custodians,orguardiansareunknownafteradiligentsearch,oriftheyliveoutsideofthestate,oriftheyevadeservice,thepersontaskedtoservethemmustfileacertificateofthosefacts;ifthisoccurs,thecourtmustappointaGuardianadLitemtothechildifappropriate.§985.319(7).Ifanyofthepartiesrefusestocomplywithservice,thecourtmayorderthemtakenintocustodyforahearingtoshowcausewhythenoncompliantpartyorpartiesshouldnotbeheldincontemptofcourt.§985.319(7).Uponapplicationbythechildorthestateattorney,theclerkshallissue,orthecourtmayissue,subpoenasforwitnessesand/orrecordsorothertangibledocumentsatahearing.§985.319(8).Processandordersissuedbythecourtareservedandexecutedasanyotherprocessororderfromthecircuitcourt.§985.319(9).
85
SpeedyTrialA. Generally
Allchildrenhavearighttobebroughttoanadjudicatoryhearingwithin90daysoftheearlierofeitherthedatethechildwastakenintocustodyorthedateofserviceofsummonsissuedwhenthedelinquencypetitionwasfiled.Rule8.090(a).Ifthechild’scaseisnotheardwithinthe90daylimit,andtherearenocircumstancesthatinterrupttherunningofthetimeperiod,thechildisentitledtoappropriaterelief.Rule8.090(b).
B. DemandforSpeedyTrial
However,achildmay,bypetition,demandaspeedytrial.Rule8.090(g).Thechildwillhavetherighttoanadjudicatoryhearingwithin60daysbyfilingapetitionentitled“DemandforSpeedyTrial”withthecourtandservingitontheprosecutingattorney.Rule8.090(g).Afterfilingsuchapetition,thecourthas5daystoholdahearingforreportandannouncedreceiptofthedemand.8.090(g)(1).Atthereport,thecourtwillsettheadjudicatoryhearingnolessthan5daysandnomorethan45daysfromthedateofthereport.Rule8.090(g)(2).Ifthechildisnotbroughttoanadjudicatoryhearingwithin50daysfromthedateoffilingthedemand,thechildwillhavetherighttoappropriaterelief.Rule8.090(g)(4).ADemandforSpeedyTrialisdeemedapleadingthatthechildisavailablefortheadjudicatoryhearing,hasdiligentlyinvestigatedthecase,andispreparedorwillbepreparedfortheadjudicatoryhearingwithin5days.Rule8.090(h).Suchademandmayonlybewithdrawnbygoodcauseshown,consentbytheprosecutingattorney,orbyorderofthecourt.Rule8.090(h).
C. MotionforDischarge
Aftertheabovetimelimitshavebeenexceededwithoutanadjudicatoryhearing,thechildmayfileamotiontodischarge.Rule8.090(m)(2).Nolaterthan5daysafterthefilingofthemotion,thecourtwillholdahearingonthematterandorderthechildtobebroughttotrialwithin10days,unless:• Thechildhasvoluntarilywaivedtherighttoaspeedytrial.• Anextensionoftimehasbeenordered.Anextensioncanresultfromanyofthe
following:o Stipulation,announcedtothecourtandsignedbythechildorthechild’s
attorney;o Writtenorrecordedorderbythecourtcitingthereasonsandexceptional
circumstancesfortheextension.Exceptionalcircumstancesinclude:§ Unexpectedillnessorincapacityorunforeseeableandunavoidable
absenceofanecessaryperson;
86
§ Ashowingbythestatethattheunusualandcomplexnatureofthecaserequiresadditionaltime;
§ Ashowingbythestatethatspecificevidenceortestimonyispresentlyunavailabledespiteeffortstosecureit,butwillbecomeavailableatalatertime;
§ Ashowingbythechildorstatethatdelayisnecessarybasedondevelopmentsthatcouldnothavebeenforeseenandwhichwillmateriallyaffectthecase;
§ Ashowingthatdelayisnecessarytoaccommodateaco-respondent,wherethereisareasonnottoseverthecase;or
§ Ashowingbythestatethatthechildhascausedmajordelayordisruptionofpreparationorproceeding.
o Writtenorrecordedorderofthecourtforaperiodofreasonableandnecessarydelaythatresultsfromproceedingsincludingbutnotlimitedtohearingastomentalcompetenceorphysicalabilitytostandtrial,appealsbythestate,oradjudicatoryhearingsonotherpendingchargesagainstthechild.Rule8.090(f)
• Thefailuretoholdanadjudicatoryhearingisattributabletothechild,co-respondentinthesameadjudicatoryhearing,ortheircounsel.
• Thechildisunavailablefortheadjudicatoryhearing,whereunavailablemeans:o Thechildorthechild’scounselfailstoattendaproceedingwheretheir
presenceisrequired;oro Thechildorchild’scounselisnotpreparedfortheadjudicatoryhearingon
thedateitisscheduled.Nopresumptionofnonavailabilityattachesunlesstheprosecutingattorneyobjectstothedismissalandpresentsevidenceofnonavailability;thechildmustthenestablishavailabilitybycompetentevidence.
• TheDemandforSpeedyTrialisinvalid.• Ifthecourtfindsdismissalisnotappropriate,thependingmotiontodismiss
mustbedenied,andanadjudicatoryhearingmustcommencewithin90daysofawrittenorrecordedorderofdenial.Rule8.090(d)(1)-(6).
Note:Ifnoneoftheaboveappliesand10dayspasswithoutthechildbeingbroughttoanadjudicatoryhearing,throughnofaultofthechild’s,thechildwillbeforeverdischargedofthecrime.Rule8.090(m)(4).
87
TransfertoAdultCourtA. Waiver
AVoluntaryWaivertakesplacewhenachild,allegedtohavecommittedaviolationofthelawandpriortothestartofanadjudicatoryhearing,petitionsthecourtwiththeparentorguardian’sconsenttobetriedasanadult.§985.556(1).Thecourtmustthenholdavoluntarywaiverhearing.§985.556(1).Afterthehearing,thechildistransferredtoadultcourtjurisdictionandmustbehandledthereafterineveryrespectasanadultforthatandeverysubsequentviolationofthelaw,unlesstheadultcourtimposesjuvenilesanctions.§985.556(1).AnInvoluntaryDiscretionaryWaivertakesplacewhen,exceptasprovidedbyinvoluntarymandatorywaivers,thestateattorneychoosestofileamotionrequestingthatthecourttransfertoadultcourtifthechildwas14yearsoldorolderatthetimetheallegeddelinquentactofviolationoflawoccurred.§985.556(2).AnInvoluntaryMandatoryWaivercanoccurintwoways.• Ifthechildwas14yearsofageorolderandhasbeenpreviouslyadjudicated
delinquentforanactclassifiedasafelony,whereheorshewasadjudicatedforthecommissionof,attempttocommit,orconspiracytocommitmurder,sexualbattery,armedorstrong-armedrobbery,carjacking,home-invasionrobbery,aggravatedbattery,aggravatedassault,orburglarywithanassaultorbattery,andifthechildiscurrentlyallegedtohavecommittedaviolentcrimeagainstaperson;or
• Ifthechildwas14yearsoldorolderatthetimeofthecommissionofafourthorsubsequentallegedfelonyoffenseandthechildwaspreviouslyadjudicateddelinquentorhadadjudicationwithheldfororwasfoundtohavecommittedorattemptedorconspiredtocommitthreeoffensesthatarefelonyoffensesinvolvingtheuseorpossessionofafirearmorviolenceagainstaperson;
Thestateattorneymustrequestthatthecourttransferthechildtoadultcourtorprovidereasonstothecourtforfailingtomakesucharequest,ordirectfile.§985.556(3).TheEffectofaWaiveristhatthecourtmustholdawaiverofjurisdictionhearingtodeterminewhetherjurisdictioncanbewaivedforthechild.
88
B. DirectFiling
DiscretionaryDirectFileoccursif,withrespecttoachildthatis14or15yearsoldatthetimeofthecommissionoftheallegedoffense,thestateattorneymayfileaninformationwiththeadultcourt.§985.557(1)(a).Inthestateattorney’sjudgmentanddiscretion,thepublicinterestrequiresthatadultsanctionsbeconsideredorimposedandwhentheoffensechargedisforthecommissionof,attempttocommit,orconspiracytocommit:• Arson;• Sexualbattery;• Robbery;• Kidnapping;• Aggravatedchildabuse;• Aggravatedassault;• Aggravatedstalking;• Murder;• Manslaughter;• Unlawfulthrowing,placing,ordischargingofadestructivedeviceorbomb;• Armedburglaryorspecifiedburglaryofadwellingorstructure,orburglarywith
anassaultorbattery;• Aggravatedbattery;• Anylewdorlasciviousoffensecommitteduponorinthepresenceofaperson
lessthan16yearsofage;• Carrying,displaying,using,threatening,orattemptingtouseaweaponor
firearmduringthecommissionofafelony;• Grandtheft;• Possessingordischarginganyweaponorfirearmonschoolproperty;• Homeinvasionrobbery;• Carjacking;or• Grandtheftofamotorvehicleorgrandtheftofamotorvehiclevaluedat
$20,000ormoreifthechildhasapreviousadjudicationforgrandtheftofamotorvehicle.
DiscretionaryDirectFilealsooccursif,withrespecttoachildwhowas16or17atthetimeoftheoffense,thestateattorneymayfileaninformationwhen,inhisorherjudgmentanddiscretion,thepublicinterestrequiresthatadultsanctionsbeconsidered.§985.557(1)(b).However,thestateattorneymaynotfileifthechildwaschargedwithamisdemeanor,unlessheorshehadatleasttwopreviousadjudicationsoradjudicationswithheld,atleastoneofwhichwasclassifiedasafelony.§985.557(1)(b).
89
MandatoryDirectFilecanoccurindifferentways.• Wherethechildwas16or17atthetimeoftheoffense,andthechildhasbeen
previouslyadjudicateddelinquentforafelonywhereadjudicationwasforthecommissionof,attempttocommit,orconspiracytocommitmurder,sexualbattery,armedorstrong-armedrobbery,carjacking,home-invasionrobbery,aggravatedbattery,oraggravatedassaultandthechildiscurrentlychargedwithasecondorsubsequentviolentcrimeagainstaperson,thestateattorneymustfileaninformation.§985.557(2)(a).
• Wherethechildwas16or17atthetimeofanoffenseclassifiedasaforciblefelony,ifthechildwaspreviouslyadjudicateddelinquentorhadadjudicationwithheldforthreepreviousfelonyactseachwhichoccurredatleast45daysapart,thestateattorneymustfileaninformation,UNLESSheorshehasgoodcausetobelieveexceptionalcircumstancesexistthatprecludethejustprosecutionofthechildinadultcourt.§985.557(2)(b).
• Where,regardlessofthechild’sageatthetimeoftheoffense,ifthechildisallegedtohavecommittedanactthatwouldbeaviolationofthelawifthechildwereanadultandinvolvesstealingamotorvehicle,includingbutnotlimitedtocarjacking,grandtheftofamotorvehicle,andwherethechild,whileinpossessionofthevehicle,causedseriousbodilyinjuryordeathofapersonwhowasnotinvolvedintheunderlyingoffense,thestateattorneymustfileaninformation.Thisappliestothedriverofthevehicleandallwillingpassengersatthetimeofsuchseriousinjuryordeath.§985.557(2)(c).
• Wherethechildwas16or17yearsoldatthetimeoftheoffense,ifthechildwaschargedwithcommittingorattemptingtocommitanoffenselistedin§775.087(2)(a)(1)(a)-(q),andduringthecommissionorattemptedcommission,thechild:o Actuallypossessedafirearmordestructivedevice.o Dischargedafirearmordestructivedevice.o Dischargedafirearmordestructivedevice,and,asaresultofthedischarge,
deathorgreatbodilyharmwasinflicteduponanyperson.Thestateattorneymustfileaninformation,unlessthestateattorneyhasgoodcausetobelieveexceptionalcircumstancesexistthatprecludethejustprosecutionofthechildinadultcourt.§985.557(2)(d)(1)&(4).
Onceachildhasbeentransferredpursuanttoaninformation,andhasbeenfoundtohavecommittedtheoffensechargedoralesserincludedoffense,thechildwillbetreatedineveryrespectasanadult,forthatandanysubsequentoffenses,unlesstheadultcourtelectstoimposejuvenilesanctions.§985.557(3)(a).Thus,thecourtmustimmediatelytransferandcertifyallfelonycasespertainingtothechildwhichhavenotyetresultedinaguiltypleaorpleaofnolocontendere,orinwhichafindingofguilthasnotbeenmade.§985.557(3)(b).
90
C. Indictments
Achildofanyagethatischargedwithaviolationofthelawpunishablebydeathorlifeimprisonmentissubjecttothejurisdictionofthejuvenilecourtunlessanduntilanindictmentonthechargeisreturnedbyagrandjury.§985.56(1).Whensuchanindictmentisreturned,thedelinquencypetitionmustbedismissedandthechildmustbehandledineveryrespectasanadult,ontheoffensepunishablebydeathorlifeimprisonment,andonallotherfeloniesormisdemeanorschargedintheindictmentandbasedonthesametransactionastheoffensepunishablebydeathorlifeimprisonmentorononeormoreactsortransactionsbasedontheoffensepunishablebydeathorlifeimprisonment.§985.56(1).Inaddition,thecourtmustimmediatelytransferandcertifyallfelonycasespertainingtothechildwhichhavenotyetresultedinaguiltypleaorpleaofnolocontendere,orinwhichafindingofguilthasnotbeenmade.§985.56(4)(b).Thegrandjuryhas21daystoactandreturnanindictment.Thejuvenilecourtmaynotholdanadjudicatoryhearingforthose21daysunlessthestateattorneynotifiesthecourtthatheorshedoesnotintendtopresentthecasetothegrandjury,orhaspresentedittothegrandjuryandthegrandjuryhasnotreturnedanindictment,inwhichcasethecourtmayholdanadjudicatoryhearingsoonerthan21days.§985.56(2).Ifthegrandjuryfailstoactwithinthe21dayperiod,thecourtmayholdanadjudicatoryhearingafterthatperiod.§985.56(2).Ifthejuvenilecourtholdsanadjudicatoryhearingandthechildisfoundtohavecommittedtheallegedoffensepunishablebydeathorlifeimprisonment,thecourtmustsentencethechildasanadult.§985.56(3).Ifthecourtfindthatthechilddidnotcommittheindictableoffensebutcommittedalesserincludedoffenseoranyotheroffenseheorshewasorcouldhavebeenindictedforasapartofthecriminalepisode,thecourtmayimposealternativejuvenilesanctionsunder§985.565.
91
UnifiedFamilyCourt–ModelFamilyCourt
Ifthejudicialsystemencouragesalternativestotheadversarialprocess,empowerslitigantstoreachtheirownsolutions,andassistsincraftingsolutionsthatpromotelong-termstabilityinmattersinvolvingchildrenandfamilies,thelikelihoodoffuturecourtinterventioninthefamilyshouldbedecreased–whetherthis be through minimizing post-judgment litigation orpreventing the dependent child of today frombecoming thedelinquent child of tomorrow. Our ultimate goal remains tofacilitate the resolution of disputes involving children andfamiliesinafair,timely,effectiveandcost-efficientmanner.1
Intraditionalcircuits,familiescomeintocontactwithavarietyofcourtsforavarietyofreasons:divorce,domesticviolence,abandonmentormistreatmentofchildren,ormisbehaviorofchildren.Thesefamiliesmay“spinfromcourtroomtocourtroomcaughtinaprocessthatdepletestime,money,andenergy,andyetneverreallyaddressesthecoreoftheproblem.Ironically,children,theintendedbeneficiariesofourfamilycourts,suffermostasaresult.”2UnifiedFamilyCourts(UFCs)servetocoordinatejudicialeffortsincasesinvolvingthesamefamily,regardlessofthemannerinwhichdocketsfordifferenttypesofcasesarestructuredandmanaged,3andprovideonecourtthatwillhearthevarietyofcasesfacingafamilyinaconsolidated,coordinatedfashion.TheFloridaSupremeCourtenumeratedtheguidingprinciplesofaUFC,saying,“Thelegalsystemshouldfocusontheneedsofchildrenwhoareinvolvedinthelitigation,referfamiliestoresourcesthatwillmaketheirrelationshipsstronger,coordinatetheircasestoprovideconsistentresults,andstrivetoleavefamiliesinbetterconditionthanwhentheyenteredthesystem.”4Theguidingprinciplesareallaimedatincreasingstabilitywithinthefamily,increasingcourtfunctionalityandcoordination,andconservingresources,bothjudicialandfamilial.
AUFCmayhearcasesinvolvingdivorceordissolutionofmarriage,childsupportissues,civildomesticviolenceinjunctions,juveniledependency,juvenile
1InreReportofFamilyCourtSteeringCommittee,794So.2d518(Fla.2001)535-536.2Wright,C.RepresentationofChildreninaUnifiedFamilyCourtSysteminFlorida,14U.Fla.J.L.&Pub.Pol’y179(2002-2003)at180.3InreReportoftheCommissiononFamilyCourts,633So.2d14(Fla.1994)at17.4Supranote1at524(quotingtheCommittee’scommentary).
92
delinquency,andtruancyissues5,andthecourtmustbehighlycoordinated,responsivetotheneedsofthefamiliesandchildren,andflexibleisitsresponses.CoordinationofcaseswithintheUFCrequiresthecourttoidentifyallcasesinvolvingthefamily.6Thecourtshouldinquireateachhearingorconferencewhetherthereareanycasespendingthatinvolvethefamily.Responsivenesstothefamilyrequires“continuedattentiontotheneedsofthechildrenandfamilyasthecasemovesthroughthejudicialsystemsothattheappropriatecourtresourcesaremadeavailableandlinkagestoappropriatecommunityresourcesarefacilitated.”7Thecourtshouldbeawareofthefamily’ssituationanddeterminewhichcourtactionsandresourceswillbestbenefitthefamily.ThecourtshouldalsobeawareofanystepstakenbythechildtoengagewiththeindependentlivingprogramsofferedbyDepartmentofChildrenandFamilies.IndependentlivingcourtsaredesignedtoeducatechildreninthecareoftheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesastotheirrights,andtoteachthemeducationalandlifeskillstobeableto“makeitontheirown.”8Theseindependentlivingcourtsbringtogetherrepresentativesfromavarietyofagencies,includingbutnotlimitedtoGuardianadLitem,communitybasedcarecaseworkers,andDJJstaff,toensurethechildhasanindependentlivingcaseplanandsufficientresourcestosupportthechildasheorsheagesoutofthecareofastateagencyandtransitionsintoindependentadulthood.AUFCmayfaceagencycoordinationissuessimilartothoseissuespresentintraditionalcircuitsthathandlecrossovercases.AUFCshouldengageinthesamepracticesdiscussedintheCrossoverCasesgeneraltopic.Additionally,asaUFCmayhearcasesthatinvolveaspectsofdomesticviolence,aUFCshouldconformthecourtroompracticestothosediscussedintheDomesticViolenceandDelinquencygeneraltopic.
5Idat525.6Idat529.7Id.8Pudlow,J.IndependentLivingDocket:HelpingFosterKidsTransitionintoAdulthood.(December1,2008).
93
WalkerPlanApprovalbyJudgeAfteradelinquencypetitionisfiledbutpriortoanadjudicatoryhearing,aplanofproposedtreatmentorconductmaybesubmittedforthechildinlieuofaplea.Rule8.075(b).ThetermsandconditionsoftheplanmustbeworkedoutwiththeassistanceofDJJandothersupervisingagencies.Rule8.075(b).Theplanmaybeforanindeterminateperiodoftime,orforaspecifiedperiod,oruntilthepetitionisdismissed.Rule8.075(b)(5).Thecourthasnoobligationtoacceptanyplanoffered.Ifthecourtrejectstheproposedplan,thecourtmuststateonrecordthereasonsforrejectingtheproposal.Rule8.075(b)(3).However,ifaplanisaccepted,theplanmustbeinwriting,agreedtoandsignedbythestateattorney,thechild,thechild’scounsel(ifthechildhasone)andthechild’sparentsorguardiansunlessexcusedbythecourt.Rule8.075(b)(1).Additionally,anagentfromDJJorothersupervisingagencymustsigntoindicateconsent.Rule8.075(b)(1).Ifthechildviolatestheplan,theviolationorviolationsmustbepresentedtothecourtbymotionofthesupervisingagencyoranyotherparty.Rule8.075(b)(4).Ifthecourtfindsthataviolationhasoccurred,thecourtmayacttoenforcetheplan,modifytheplanbysupplementalagreements,orsetthecaseforahearingontheoriginalpetition.Rule8.075(b)(4).
94
DelinquencyHearings
TableofContentsDetentionHearingataGlance...................................................................................98DetentionHearingBenchcard..................................................................................100DetentionHearingOutline......................................................................................102A. Generally............................................................................................................102B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................104C. ProbableCauseDetermination..........................................................................105D. Setarraignmenthearing.....................................................................................107E. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdetention....................................................107
ArraignmentHearingataGlance.............................................................................111ArraignmentHearingBenchcard..............................................................................113ArraignmentHearingOutline..................................................................................115A. Generally............................................................................................................115B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................116C. Reviewdelinquencypetition..............................................................................117D. Entranceofaplea...............................................................................................118E. Setnexthearing.................................................................................................120F. Determinecustodypendingdisposition............................................................121
AdjudicatoryHearingataGlance............................................................................124AdjudicatoryHearingBenchcard.............................................................................126AdjudicatoryHearingOutline..................................................................................128A. Generally............................................................................................................128B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................129C. Adjudicatoryhearingprocess.............................................................................131D. Delinquencydetermination................................................................................133E. Custodypendingdisposition..............................................................................134F. Adviseofrighttoappeal....................................................................................134G. Setdispositionhearing.......................................................................................135H. Requirementsforwrittenorderofadjudication................................................135
DispositionHearingataGlance...............................................................................138
95
DispsitionHearingBenchcard..................................................................................140DispositionHearingOutline.....................................................................................142A. Generally............................................................................................................142B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................143C. Reviewpredispositionreport.............................................................................144D. Commitmentdetermination..............................................................................146E. Detentionpendingcommitment........................................................................149F. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdisposition..................................................149
ViolationofProbationHearingataGlance..............................................................154ViolationofProbationHearingBenchcard...............................................................156ViolationofProbationHearingOutline....................................................................158A. Generally............................................................................................................158B. AdviseofRights..................................................................................................159C. Violationofprobationdetermination................................................................161D. Dispositiondetermination..................................................................................162E. Requirementsforwrittenorder.........................................................................162
ContemptofCourtHearingataGlance...................................................................166ContemptofCourtHearingBenchcard....................................................................168ContemptofCourtHearingOutline.........................................................................170A. Generally............................................................................................................170B. AdviseofRights..................................................................................................171C. Indirectcontempthearingprocedure................................................................173D. Sanctions............................................................................................................174E. Requirementsforawrittenjudgmentofcontempt...........................................175
WaiverofJurisdictionHearingataGlance...............................................................178WaiverofJurisdictionHearingBenchcard................................................................180WaiverofJurisdictionHearingOutline....................................................................182A. Generally............................................................................................................182B. AdviseofRights..................................................................................................183C. Determinethetypeofwaiver............................................................................184D. IssueaSummons................................................................................................185E. Considertheevidencepresented.......................................................................185F. Jurisdictiondetermination.................................................................................186G. Requirementsforawrittenorderonwaiverofjurisdiction..............................187
RestitutionHearingataGlance...............................................................................189RestitutionHearingBenchcard................................................................................191RestitutionHearingOutline.....................................................................................193A. Generally............................................................................................................193B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................194C. HearingProcedure.............................................................................................196D. Restitutiondetermination..................................................................................197E. Requirementsforawrittenorderofrestitution................................................197
CorrectionofOrdersHearingataGlance.................................................................200CorrectionofOrdersHearingBenchcard..................................................................202
96
CorrectionofOrdersHearingOutline......................................................................204A. Generally............................................................................................................204B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................205C. Correctionhearingprocedure............................................................................206D. Correctiondetermination...................................................................................207E. Requirementsforacorrectedorder..................................................................207
CompetencyHearingataGlance.............................................................................210CompetencyHearingBenchcard..............................................................................212CompetencyHearingOutline...................................................................................214A. Generally............................................................................................................214B. Adviseofrights...................................................................................................215C. Competencyhearingprocedures.......................................................................216D. Competencydetermination...............................................................................217E. Confinementassessment...................................................................................218F. Requirementsforawrittenorderofincompetency..........................................220
97
98
DETENTIONHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;741.28;790.22;901.02;985.02;985.033;985.035;985.039;985.16;985.24;985.245;985.25;985.255;985.26;985.27;985.275;985.335RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.013;8.015;8.100;8.110;8.165;8.929RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARING
Thepurposeofthedetentionhearingistodeterminewhetherprobablecauseexiststhatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflawand,ifso,whethercontinueddetentionisnecessary.§985.255(3)(a);Rule8.010(g).
TIMEFRAME
Thedetentionhearingmustbeheldwithin24hoursofthechildbeingtakenintocustody.§§985.255(3)(a);985.26(1).Undercertaincircumstancesthedetentionhearingmaybecontinuedforupto72hoursifastatutoryneedfordetentionismetandthecourtisunabletomakeaprobablecausedetermination.Rule8.010(h).Detentioncannotexceed21dayswithoutthecommencementofanadjudicatoryhearing.§985.26(2).
BURDENOFPROOF Standardofproofforprobablecauseisthatwhichisnecessaryforanarrestwarrant.Rule8.010(g)(1).
RULESOFEVIDENCEThecourtmayhearallrelevantmaterialevidence.Rule8.010(g)(1)&(2).Allpartiespresenthavetherighttobeheardregardingtheissueofdetentionifthecourtfindsprobablecause.Rule8.010(a).
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
NEXTHEARINGAnarraignmenthearingmustbeheldwithin48hoursafterthefilingofadelinquencypetition(excludingSaturdays,Sundaysorlegalholidays).Rule8.015(a).
99
100
DETENTIONHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Thepurposeofthedetentionhearingistodeterminewhetherthereisprobable
causethatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflaw.Ø Iftestimonywillbeoffered,placeallwitnessesunderoath.Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameandcurrent
address.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestthatDJJgiveathoroughdescription
ofthestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Advisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildandhisorherparentsareinsolvent,advisethechildthatheorshehas
therighttohavecounselappointed.Ø Ifthechilddoesnothavecounsel,appointcounselasnecessaryunlesswaivedin
writing.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.
Ø Ifthechildwaivescounsel,determinethatthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
Ø Advisethechildofhisorherrighttoremainsilent,andthatanythingthechildsaysmaybeusedagainsthimorher.
Ø Ifthechild’sparent,custodianorcounselisnotpresent,advisethechildofhisorherrighttocommunicatewiththem,andifnecessary,thatreasonablemeanswillbeprovidedtodoso.
Ø Advisethechildofthenatureofthecharges.Ø Advisethechildofthereasonscontinueddetentionisrequested.
101
C. ProbableCauseDetermination
Ø Explaintothechildthatthestandardofproofiswhetherthecourt,basedontheinformationbeforeit,“reasonablybelievesthatthepersoncomplainedagainsthascommittedanoffense”withinthecourt’sjurisdiction.
Ø Ifthecourtfindsnoprobablecause,thechildmustbereleasedfromdetention.Ø Ifprobablecausecannotbedetermined,butastatutoryneedfordetentionexists,
thecourtmaycontinuethedetentionhearingforupto72hours,onashowingofgoodcause.
Ø Ifthereisprobablecause,determinewhethercontinueddetentionisnecessary.ReviewdocumentssuchastheRAI,DJJ’sdetentionrecommendations,andthedetentionpetition.
Ø Ifthereisprobablecauseandifdetentioniswarranted,explaintothechildwhatlevelofdetentionheorshewillbeunderandthereasonsforthedetentiondetermination.
Ø Ifthereisprobablecauseandifthechildisundernonsecuredetention,explainwhatthatmeansandwhatisexpectedofthechild.
D. Setanarraignmenthearing
Ø Thehearingmustbewithin48hoursofthefilingofadelinquencypetition,excludingSaturdays,Sundays,orlegalholidays.
E. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdetention
Ø Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifyhimorherwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Statetheageandsexofthechild.Iftheageisunknown,statethatthechildisbelievedtobeofanagethatmakeshimorhersubjecttothejuvenileproceedings.
Ø Directthedetentionofthechildandstatethereasonsor,ifappropriate,orderthereleaseofthechildandreturntohisorhernonresidentialcommitmentprogram.
Ø Makeafindingofprobablecauseorthatsuchafindingcannotbemadeatthistimeandthatthecaseiscontinuedforsuchadeterminationwithin72hoursofthechildbeingtakenintocustody.
Ø Designatetheplaceofdetentionorpersonoragencyresponsibleforsupervision,andanyspecialconditions.
Ø Statethedateandtimetheorderwasissued,thecountyandcourtfromwhereitwasissuedandthedateandtimethechildwastakenintocustody.
Ø Makeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare.Ø Orderthatchildtobereleasednolaterthan5:00p.m.onthelastdayofthe
specifiedstatutorydetentionperiodunlessacontinuancehasbeengrantedforgoodcause.
Ø Setthenextdetentionhearingdateifanextensiongranted.Ø Setdateforarraignmenthearing.
102
DETENTIONHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationIfthechildisdeaf,thecourtmustdeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideaqualifiedinterpreter.§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointanon-qualifiedinterpreteruponafindingofgoodcause,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(3).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Explainthepurposeofthedetentionhearing.Thepurposeofthedetentionhearingistodeterminewhetherthereisprobablecausethatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflaw.Rule8.010(g)(1).Ifthecourtfindsprobablecause,thenthecourtmustdeterminewhat,ifany,detentionisnecessary.§985.255(3)(a);Rule8.010(h).WhenlawenforcementturnsachildovertoDJJ,theymakestheinitialdeterminationofwhethertodetainthechildbasedonitsreviewofallavailableinformationandtheRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI).§985.245.
4. HearingTimeframe;StandardofProof
Anychildbeingdetainedmusthaveadetentionhearingwithin24hoursofbeingtakenintocustody,andnochildcanbedetainedlongerthan24hoursunlessthecircuitcourtholdsadetentionhearingandeitherentersadetentionorderorcontinues,onashowingofgoodcause,thehearingforupto72hours.§985.26;Rule8.013(a).Nodetentionordercanbeenteredwithoutahearingatwhichallpartieswillhaveanopportunitytobeheardonthenecessityforthechildtobeheldindetentionunlessthecourtfindsthattheparentorcustodiancannotbelocatedorthechild’smentalhealthorphysicalconditionissuchthatacourtappearanceisnotinthechild’sbestinterest.Rule8.010(a).Thecourtgenerally
103
decideswhetherthereisprobablecausebaseduponswornstatementsortestimonypresentedbytheState.Thestandardofproofisthesameasforanarrestwarrant.Rule8.010(g)(1).
5. DetentionIssues
Thecourtcannotorderdetentionunlessthestatutorycriteriaof§§985.24and985.255aremet.Therearetwotypesofdetention:secureandnon-secure,§985.25.ThecourtcanorderaplacementmorerestrictivethanindicatedbytheRAIscore,butthecourtmuststate,inwriting,clearandconvincingreasonsforsuchplacement.§985.255(3)(b).Detentioncannotexceed21dayswithoutthecommencementofanadjudicatoryhearingunlessanextensionoftimeforgoodcauseisshown.However,someseriousoffenderscanbeheldinsecuredetentionforupto30daysiftheoffenseisonethatwouldbe,ifcommittedbyanadult,acapitalfelony,lifefelony,felonyofthefirstdegree,orfelonyoftheseconddegreethatinvolvesviolenceagainstanindividual.§985.26(2).Undernocircumstancesmayachildallegedtobedependentunderchapter39beplacedintoorheldinsecuredetention.§985.24(3).
6. IdentifyThosePresent
Identifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesforthecourtandtherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
7. NoticeAssessmentIftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Rule8.010(d)requiresthattheDJJintakeofficermustmakeadiligentefforttonotifytheparentorcustodianofthetimeandplaceofthedetentionhearing.Noticemaybebythemostexpeditiousmethodavailable.Thechildhasarighttospeakwithanyabsentparentorguardianand,ifnecessary,reasonablemeansshouldbeprovidedtodoso.Rule8.010(f)(3).However,thefailuretonoticeorthenonattendanceoftheparentorguardiandoesnotinvalidatethehearingorthedetentionorder.Rule8.010(d).Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearch,followingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.
8. PlaceAnyWitnessesUnderOath
Thecourtshouldplaceanywitnessesunderoath.8.010(g)(2).Priortotheexaminationofanywitnesses,anypartymayinvoketheruletohavethewitnessessequesteredtopreventcommunicationbetweenthewitnesses.Rule
104
8.100(c).
9. OtherProceedingsDeterminationDeterminewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
AchildindelinquencyproceedingsisgenerallyaffordedthesameConstitutionalrightsasadultsincriminalproceedings.Theonenotableexceptionisthatthechildisnotentitledtoajurytrial.Rule8.010(f)(1)-(4)specificallyprovideswhatrightthechildmustbeadvisedofatthedetentionhearing.1. RighttoReviewPacket;RighttoKnowCharges
Advisethechildofthecharges.Rule8.010(f)(1).Thechildhastherighttoreviewthedetentionpacketsubmittedtothecourtandbeapprisedofthecharges.
2. RighttoCounselAdvisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Rule8.010(e).Thechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatthedetentionhearing.TheCourtmustdeterminewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustmakeaspecificinquirytodeterminewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtshallmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifinsolvent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthatifheorsheisinsolvent,thechildhastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,determineifthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegal
105
counselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlessthecourtdeterminesthattherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Further,waiverofcounselcanonlyoccurafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardinganyfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.
3. RighttoRemainSilent
Advisethechildoftherighttoremainsilent.Rule8.010(f)(2).Thechildmustbeadvisedthatheorshehastherighttoremainsilentandthatanythingthatthechildsayscanbeusedagainsthimorher.
4. RighttoCommunicate
Ifthechild’sparent,custodian,orcounselisnotpresent,advisethechildofhisorherrighttocommunicatewiththem,andifnecessary,thatreasonablemeanswillbeprovidedtodoso.Rule8.010(f)(3).
5. RighttoKnowwhyContinuedDetentionisRequestedAdvisethechildofthereasonscontinueddetentionisrequested.Rule8.010(f)(4).
C. ProbableCauseDetermination
Thecourtmaybaseitsprobablecausedeterminationonasworncomplaint,affidavit,deposition,ortestimonyunderoath.Rule8.010(g).
1. StandardofProof
Thestandardofproofnecessaryfordeterminingprobablecauseisthesamestandardusedforanarrestwarrant.Rule8.010(g)(1).Thestandardofproofforanarrestwarrantiswhetherthejudge,basedontheinformationbeforehim,“reasonablybelievesthatthepersoncomplainedagainsthascommittedanoffense”withinthecourt’sjurisdiction.§901.02(1).
2. ProbableCauseDetermination
Ifnoprobablecause,thechildmustbereleasedfromdetention.Rule8.010(h).Thereleaseofthechildbaseduponafindingthatnoprobablecauseexistsdoesnotprohibitthefilingofadelinquencypetitionorfurtherdelinquencyproceedings.Rule8.010(h).
106
Ifprobablecausecannotbedetermined,butastatutoryneedfordetentionexists,thecourtmaycontinuethedetentionhearingforupto72hours.Rule8.010(h).Thecourtonashowingofgoodcausemaycontinuethehearingasecondtimeforaperiodnotmorethan24hoursbeyondthe72hourperiod.Rule8.010(h).Ifprobablecauseisfound,thecourtmustthendeterminewhethercontinueddetentionisnecessaryandwhatdetentionshouldbeimposed.Rule8.010(h).Evidenceforsuchadeterminationmaybeconsideredtotheextentofitsprobativevalueeventhoughitwouldnotbecompetentatanadjudicatoryhearing.Rule8.010(g)(2).Thecourtmaycontinueormodifythecurrentdetentionplacement.DJJwillmakerecommendationstothecourtregardingthelevelofdetentionandplacement.Thecourt’sdecisionswillbebasedontheresultsoftheRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI)performedbythejuvenileprobationofficerandthestatutorydetentioncriteria.§985.245.ThecourtshouldreviewtheRAIandcorrectanymistakesmadeincalculatingtheRAIscore.§985.245(3).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonRiskAssessmentInstruments.
3. AdditionalActswhileunderSupervisionIfthechildischargedwithadditionalactswhileundersupervision,theRAIshouldbeupdatedtoreflecttheadditionalcharges.§985.245(2)(b).Thecourtshouldreviewallrelevantevidencetodeterminewhetherdetentionisstillnecessaryandwhethertherecommendedleveliscommensurate.Section985.255(3)(b)requiresthatifthecourtordersaplacementmorerestrictivethanindicatedbytheRAI,thecourtmuststateinwritingtheclearandconvincingreasonsforsuchplacement.Thecourtisnotauthorizedtoimposeaformofdetentionmorerestrictivethanthestatutorymaximum.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonmorerestrictiveplacements.Rule8.110(a)providesthatallpartiesatthedetentionhearingmustbegiventheopportunitytobeheardonwhethercontinueddetentionisnecessaryunlesstheparentscannotbelocatedorthechild’sphysicalormentalconditionprecludesappearingforthehearing.Section985.02(4)(a)requiresthattheleastrestrictivemeansthatmeettheneedsofthechildandofpublicsafetyshouldalwaysbeutilized.
4. ContinuedDetentionRegardlessofRAIScoreSection985.255setsforththestatutorycriterianecessarytocontinueachildindetention.SeeGeneralTopicsformoredetailedinformationondetentioncriteria.AlldeterminationsandcourtordersplacingachildindetentionmustalsobebasedupontheRAI,unlessthechildisplacedintodetentioncarefordomesticviolenceasdefinedin§741.28.Insuchacase,thechildwhodoesnotmeetdetentioncriteriamaybeheldinsecuredetentionifthecourtmakesspecificwrittenfindingsthat:
107
• Respitecareforthechildisnotavailable;or• Itisnecessarytoplacethechildinsecuredetentioninordertoprotectthe
victimfrominjury.§985.255(2).
Achildmaynotbeheldindetentionunder985.255(2)formorethan48hourswithoutcourtorder.§985.255(2).Additionally,after48hours,thecourtmustholdahearingifthestateattorneyorthechildrequeststhatdetentionbecontinued.§985.255(2).Detentionmaybecontinuedifthecourtmakesspecificwrittenfindingsthatcontinueddetentionisnecessarytoprotectthevictimfromfurtherharm,anddetentioncannotcontinuepastthetimelimitsestablishedinFloridastatute.§985.255(2).Further,achildmaybeheldindetentionregardlessoftheRAIifthechildhadpreviouslyfailedtoappearforanadjudicatoryhearingonthesamecase,ortwoormorehearingsofanynatureinthesamecase.§985.255(1)(i)&(j).
5. IfanAnswerisFiledIfthechildfilesananswertothepetitionthatadmitstotheallegationsofthepetition,thecourtshouldverifythattheansweracknowledgesthatthechildwasadvisedofhisorherrights,andofthepossibledispositionsavailabletothecourt.§985.335.Theanswermustalsoprovideawaiverfortheadjudicatoryhearing,astatementofconsenttoanorderofadjudication,andanauthorizationforthecourttoproceedwithadispositionhearing.§985.335.Thecourtshouldfileanorderofadjudicationandsetthedispositionhearingattheearliestpracticabletimethatallowsforthecompletionofthepredispositionreportandresultingclassification.§985.335.
D. Setarraignmenthearing
Thehearingshallbewithin48hoursofthefilingofadelinquencypetition,excludingSaturdays,Sundays,orlegalholidays.Rule8.015(a).Thechildmustbegivennoticeofthearraignment;however,personalappearancebythechildbeforethecourtshallremovethenecessityofservingprocessonhimorher.Rule8.015(b)(1).
E. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdetention
1. ThecourtmaybepresentedwithadetentionorderpreparedbytheStateAttorney,ormaydrafttheorderincourt.Anydetentionordermustbeauthorizedbythecriteriasetforthin§§985.24and985.255.• Nameandaddress.Statethenameandaddressofthechildorifunknown,
designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.Rule8.013(c)(2).
• Ageandgender.Statetheageandsexofthechild.Iftheageisunknown,
108
statethatthechildisbelievedtobeofanagethatmakeshimsubjecttothejuvenileproceedings.Rule8.013(c)(3).
• WaiverofCounsel.Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
• Detentiondirections.Directthedetentionofthechildandstatethereasonsthereforor,ifappropriate,orderthereleaseofthechildandthereturntohisorhernonresidentialcommitmentprogram.Rule8.013(c)(4).
• Probablecausefinding.Makeafindingofprobablecauseorthatsuchafindingcannotbemadeatthistimeandthatthecaseiscontinuedforsuchadeterminationwithin72hoursofthechildbeingtakenintocustodyunlessthistimeisextendedbythecourtforgoodcauseshownfornotlongerthananadditional24hours.Rule8.013(c)(5).
• Detentionlocationdesignation.Designatetheplaceofdetention,orpersonoragencyresponsibleforsupervision,andanyspecialconditions.Rule8.013(c)(6).
• Dateandtime.Statethedateandtimetheorderisissued,thecountyandcourtfromwhereissued,andthedateandtimethechildwastakenintocustody.Rule8.013(c)(7).
• Releaseinstructions.Orderaspecificreleasetime,orthatthechildistobereleasednolaterthan5:00p.m.onthelastdayofthespecifiedstatutorydetentionperiodunlessacontinuancehasbeengrantedforgoodcause.Rule8.013(c)(8);§985.255(3)(c).Exceptasprovidedin§§790.22(8)or985.27,whenachildisplacedintosecureornon-securedetentioncare,orintoarespitehomeorotherplacementpursuanttoacourtorderfollowingahearing,thecourtordermustincludespecificinstructionsthatdirectthereleaseofthechildfromsuchplacementnolaterthan5:00p.m.onthelastdayofthedetentionperiodspecifiedin§§985.26or985.27,whicheverisapplicable,unlesstherequirementsofsuchapplicableprovisionhavebeenmetoranorderofcontinuancehasbeengrantedunder§985.26(4).
• Findingofcost.Thecourtmustmakeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare,ormakeafindingastoanyreductionorwaiverofcost,includingthereinthereasonsforsuchafinding.§985.039.Whenachildisplacedintononsecuredetention,probation,orothersupervisedstatuswiththeDJJ,orwhenachildiscommittedtoaminimum-risknon-residentialrestrictivenesslevel,ordertheparentorguardiantopayonedollar($1.00)perdaytotheDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(a).IfachildisplacedinsecuredetentionorplacedoncommittedstatusandtheDJJacquirestemporarylegalcustodyofsaidchild,ordertheparentorguardiantopayfivedollars($5.00)perdaytotheDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(b).IfthecourtfailstoincludeintheDetentionOrderinformationregardingcostofsupervisionandcare,theparentisdeemedtohaveanobligationtopayDJJonedollar($1.00)perdayforeachdaythechildisunderthesupervision
109
ofDJJandfivedollars($5.00)perdayforeachdaythechildremainsinthecareofDJJ.§985.039(5).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoncosts.
• Setnexthearing.Setthenexthearingdateifanextensionisgranted.Rule8.010(h).Ifnoextensionisgranted,setthedateforthearraignmenthearing.Rule8.015(a).
110
111
ARRAIGNMENTHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;741.28;985.033;985.035;985.039;985.0435;985.185;985.24;985.25;985.255;985.26;985.318;985.335RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.035;8.070;8.075;8.080;8.090;8.100;8.110;8.165;8.929RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARING
Thepurposeofthearraignmenthearingisforthechildtoenterapleaofnotguilty,guiltyornolocontendereinresponsetothedelinquencypetition.Rule8.070.Thishearingissimilartoarraignmentincriminalcourt.
TIMEFRAMEIfchildisdetained,thearraignmenthearingmustbeheldwithin48hoursofthefilingofthedelinquencypetitionexcludingSaturdays,Sundays,andlegalholidays.§985.26(6);Rule8.015(a).
BURDENOFPROOF
Thedelinquencypetitionmustbereviewedtodeterminewhetheritstatesaprimafaciecasefordelinquencyiftherehasbeennodetentionhearing.§985.13.Thereisnoburdenofproofatanarraignmenthearing.
RULESOFEVIDENCE Noevidenceissubmittedatanarraignmenthearing.
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
NEXTHEARING
Ifchildpleadsnotguilty-Adjudicatoryhearingmustcommenceassoonaspracticable(§985.35)within21daysofthechildbeingtakenintocustody.§985.26(2);Rule8.070.Ifchildpleadsguiltyornolocontendere–Dispositionmayimmediatelyfollowarraignmentifpredispositionreportisavailable(Rule8.115(b))orthedispositionhearingmaybescheduledforafuturedate.Rule8.070.
112
113
ARRAIGNMENTHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Informthechildthatthepurposeofthearraignmenthearingisforthechildtoenter
apleaofnotguilty,guiltyornolocontenderetothedelinquencypetitionfiledbytheStateAttorney.
Ø Placethechildunderoath.Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameandpermanent
address.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestDJJgiveathoroughdescriptionofthe
stepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Ifthecourtisa
UFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifchildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildofrighttocounsel,anddetermine
whethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifthechildandchild’sparentsorguardiansareinsolvent,adviseoftherighttohave
counselappointed.Thecourtshallappointcounselunlesswaivedinwritingbythechild.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.
Ø Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Ø Advisethechildoftherighttoremainsilent,andthatanythingthechildsaysmaybe
usedagainsthimorher.
C. Reviewdelinquencypetition
Ø Reviewthedelinquencypetitiontodeterminewhetherthepetitionstatesaprimafaciecaseofdelinquency.
114
D. Entranceofaplea
Ø Explaintothechildthatapleaisananswertothecomplaintbroughtagainsthimorher.Verifythatthechildunderstandsthatheorshemaypleadnotguilty,guilty,nolocontendere,ormayremainsilentandrefrainfrommakingaplea.
Ø Beforeacceptingapleaofguiltyornolocontendere,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthepleaisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Additionally,thecourtmustdeterminethatthereisafactualbasisforacceptingtheplea.
Ø Ifthepleaisacceptedbythecourt,thecaseproceedstodispositionhearing.Explaintothechildwhatwillhappennext,andwhatisexpectedofthechild.
Ø Ifpleaisnotguilty,thecaseproceedstoanadjudicatoryhearing.Explaintothechildwhatwillhappennext,andwhatisexpectedofthechild.
Ø Ifthechildismuteorpleadsevasively,enterapleaofnotguilty.
E. Setnexthearing
Ø Ifpleawasnotguilty,settheadjudicatoryhearingforassoonaspracticableandwithin21daysfromthedatethechildwasplacedintodetentioncare.Ifthechildwasnotplacedintodetentioncare,thenexthearingmustbewithin90daysoftheearlierofeitherthefilingofthepetitionorthetakingofthechildintocustody.
Ø Ifpleawasnolocontendereorguilty,thedispositionhearingmaytakeplaceimmediatelyormaybescheduledfortheearliestpracticabletimethatwillallowforthecompletionoftheassessmentprocessresultingfromthepredispositionreport.
F. Determinecustodypendingdisposition
Ø Ifthechildwasheldindetentionpriortothearraignmenthearing,thecourtwillhavetodeterminewhethercontinueddetentionisnecessarypendingdisposition.
Ø Ifthechildhascommittedadomesticviolenceoffense(asdefinedin§741.28)andheorshedoesnotmeetdetentioncriteria,thecourtcanorderthechildtobeheldinsecuredetention,withappropriatefindings.
115
ARRAIGNMENTHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Explaintothechildthatthepurposeofthearraignmenthearingistoprovideanopportunityforthechildtoenterapleaofnotguilty,guiltyornolocontenderetothedelinquencypetitionfiledbytheStateAttorney.Ifthechildisdetained,thearraignmenthearingmusttakeplacewithin48hoursofthefilingofthedelinquencypetitionexcludingSaturdays,Sundaysandlegalholidays.§985.26(6);Rule8.015(a).
4. IdentifyThosePresent
Identifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
5. NoticeAssessmentDeterminestepstakentolocateandnoticeanyidentifiedandabsentparentsorguardiansofthearraignmenthearing.Parentsorguardiansshouldbenotifiedofthearraignmenthearing.Diligenteffortsmustbemadetonotifytheparentsorguardianofthechildofthearraignmenthearing.Rule8.015(b)(3).However,
116
failureofnoticeornonattendancedoesnotinvalidatethehearing.Rule8.015(b)(4).Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearch,followingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.
6. Placethechildunderoath
7. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
1. RighttoCounselDeterminewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifchildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.§985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandchild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtshallmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthatifindigent,heorshehastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowingly,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodetermine
117
whethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecordandinwriting.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthechildappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
2. RighttoCommunicate
Unlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
C. Reviewdelinquencypetition
1. ReviewforPrimaFacieCaseofDelinquencyReviewthedelinquencypetitiontodeterminewhetherthepetitionstatesaprimafaciecaseofdelinquency.TherequirementsforthedelinquencypetitionaresetforthinRule8.035.Thechilddoesnotneedtofileananswertothepetition.Anymattersthatcouldbeinananswermaybepleadedorallybeforethejudge.§985.335.
118
2. AnswerFiledIfthechildfilesananswertothepetitionthatadmitstotheallegationsofthepetition,verifythattheansweracknowledgesthatthechildwasadvisedofhisorherrights,andofthepossibledispositionsavailabletothecourt.§985.335.Theanswermustalsoprovideawaiverfortheadjudicatoryhearing,astatementofconsenttoanorderofadjudication,andanauthorizationforthecourttoproceedwithadispositionhearing.§985.335.Fileanorderofadjudicationandsetthedispositionhearingattheearliestpracticabletimethatallowsforthecompletionofthepredispositionreportandresultingclassification.§985.335.
D. Entranceofaplea
1. GenerallyThechildmustenterapleaofguilty,notguilty,ornolocontenderetothechargesinthedelinquencypetition.Ifachildstandsmuteoranswersevasively,apleaofnotguiltyshallbeenteredbythecourt.Rule8.075(d).Thechildshallbepermittedtowithdrawaguiltypleaatanytimepriortothebeginningofthedispositionhearingwithashowingofgoodcause,andthewithdrawnpleaisnotconsideredanadmission.Rule8.075(e).Pleaproceedingsshallbeofrecord.Rule8.080(d).Untilacceptedbythecourt,thepleaofferornegotiationmaybewithdrawnbyeitherparty.Rule8.080(e).Failuretofollowtheruleshallnotrenderthepleavoidabsentashowingofprejudice.Rule8.080(g).
2. PleaofNotGuilty
Ifthechildentersapleaofnotguilty,determinewhethertheadjudicatoryhearingmaytakeplaceimmediatelyorifitmustbesetforafuturedate,nolaterthan21daysafterthechildwastakenintocustody.
3. PleaofGuiltyorNoloContendere
Ifthechildentersapleaofguiltyornolocontendere,determinewhetherpleaisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Rule8.075(a).Thecourtmayrefusetoacceptapleaofguiltyornolocontendereandmustnotaccepteitherpleawithoutfirstdeterminingthatthepleaisvoluntary,andwiththefullunderstandingofthenatureoftheallegationsandthepossibleconsequencesofthepleaandthatthereisafactualbasisforsuchplea.Rule8.075(a).Ifitisanticipatedthataguiltyornolocontenderepleaisgoingtobeentered,defensecounselcanrequestapredispositionreportbepreparedpriortothearraignmenthearing.
4. DetermineVoluntarinessofGuiltyorNoloContenderePlea
Beforeacceptingapleaofguiltyornolocontendere,thecourtmustdeterminethatthepleaisknowingly,intelligently,andvoluntarilyenteredandthatthereisafactualbasisforit.Rule8.080(a).Whenmakingthisdetermination,thecourtmustaddressthechildpersonally.Rule8.080(b).Determinethatthechildunderstands:
119
• thenatureofthechargestowhichthepleaisofferedandthepossibledispositionsavailabletothecourt,Rule8.080(b)(1);
• that,ifnotrepresentedbycounsel,therighttocounselandtherighttohavecounselifindigent,Rule8.080(b)(2);
• therighttopleadnotguilty,therighttoanadjudicatoryhearingwherethechildhastherighttocounsel,therighttocompeltheattendanceofwitnessesonhisorherbehalf,therighttocrossexamineadversewitnesses,therighttotestify,andtherightnottotestify,Rule8.080(b)(3);
• that,ifthechildpleadsguiltyornocontestwithoutexpressreservationofrighttoappeal,therighttoappealallmattersrelatedtothejudgmentarewaived.Reviewbycollateralattackisnotimpaired,Rule8.080(b)(4);
• thatapleaofguiltyornocontestwaivestherighttoanadjudicatoryhearing,Rule8.080(b)(5);
• that,ifthechildpleadsnocontestorguilty,thecourtcanaskthechildquestionsunderoathandtheanswerscanbeusedforasubsequentperjuryprosecution,Rule8.080(b)(6);
• thecompletetermsofthepleaagreementincludingallobligationsthechildwillincurasaresult,Rule8.080(b)(7);and
• thatifthechildpleadsguiltyornolocontenderetoasexuallyviolentorsexuallymotivatedoffense,orifthechildhasbeenpreviouslyadjudicatedforsuchanoffense,thepleamayresultinthechildbeingplacedincivilcommitmentasasexuallyviolentpredatoruponthecompletionofhis/hersentence.Rule8.080(b)(8).
5. DeterminationofVoluntarinessandNon-CitizenJuveniles
Althoughthereisnoequivalentdelinquencyrule,theFloridaRuleofCriminalProcedure3.172(c)(8)makesmandatorythattheadultcriminalcourtincludeinadeterminationofthevoluntarinessofapleathefollowing:• Ifthedefendantpleadsguiltyornolocontendere,ifheorsheisnotaUnited
Statescitizen,thepleamaysubjecthimorhertodeportationpursuanttothelawsandregulationsgoverningtheUnitedStatesImmigrationandNaturalizationService.ItshallnotbenecessaryforthetrialjudgetoinquireastowhetherthedefendantisaUnitedStatescitizen,asthisadmonitionshallbegiventoalldefendantsinallcases.
Furthermore,thecourtinInreAmendmentstotheFloridaRulesofCriminalProcedure,536So.2d992(Fla.1988),indicatedthattheadultruleismandatory,withoutinquiringastothedefendant’scitizenship,“toprotectthedefendant’sdueprocessrights.”
Thus,priortothechildenteringaplea,thejuvenilecourtmayalsoadvisethechildthat,ifheorsheisnotaUnitedStatescitizen,apleaofguiltyornolocontenderemaysubjecthimorhertodeportationpursuanttothelawsand
120
regulationsgoverningtheUnitedStatesImmigrationandNaturalizationService.Ifsuchastatementisincludedinavoluntarinessdetermination,similartotheadultcriminalrule,itshouldbegiventoalljuvenilesinalljuveniledelinquencycases;thecourtisnotrequiredtoinquireastowhetherthejuvenileisaUnitedStatescitizenbeforeprovidingsuchastatement.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformation.
6. AcknowledgementbytheChild
Beforethecourtacceptsaguiltyornocontestplea,thecourtmustdeterminethatthechildeither:• acknowledgesguilt,Rule8.080(c)(1);or• acknowledgesthatthepleaisinthechild’sbestinterest,whilemaintaining
innocence.Rule8.080(c)(2).
Importantnoteforcertainjuvenilesexoffenders.EffectiveJuly1,2007,§943.0435,wasamendedtorequirecertainjuvenilesexoffenderstoregisterwiththeFloridaDepartmentofLawEnforcement(FDLE)andtheiridentitybepostedontheFDLEwebsite.ForoffensesoccurringonorafterJuly1,2007,ajuvenilewhowas14yearsofageorolderatthetimeoftheoffenseandisadjudicateddelinquentofaqualifyingoffensemustregisterasasexualoffender.Tohelpensurethatpleasareknowinglymade,anypleacolloquyforaqualifiedoffenseshouldincludeinformationaboutthesexoffenderregistrationrequirements.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonjuvenilesexualoffenders.
E. Setnexthearing
1. IfaPleaofGuiltyorNoloContendereIfthechildpleadsguiltyornolocontendere,adispositionhearingcanoccurimmediatelyafterthepleaistakenifapredispositionreporthasbeenprepared.Rule8.070(b).Thecasecanalsobesetforadispositionhearingforalaterdate.§985.335.Priortodisposition,ifthechildisindetention,theneedforcontinueddetentionmustalsobereviewed.§985.26.Acomprehensiveevaluationfordispositionisrequiredifresidentialcommitmentisanticipatedorrecommended,§985.185(1),includingapredispositionreport.§985.43(1)(a).
2. IfaPleaofNotGuilty
Ifthechildpleadsnotguilty,thecaseproceedstoanadjudicatoryhearingand/ormediation.Theadjudicatoryhearingcancommenceimmediatelyorthecourtmaysetafuturetimefortheadjudicatoryhearing.Rule8.110(b).Ifthechildisrepresentedbycounsel,thechildmayfileawrittenpleaofnotguiltyatorbeforethearraignmenthearingandthearraignmentproceedingwillbedeemedwaived.Rule8.070(b).Thechilddoesnotneedtobepresentatthearraignmentifawrittenpleaofnotguiltyhasbeenentered.
121
3. TimeLimits
Ifthereistobeanadjudicatoryhearing,andthechildisnotheldindetention,itmustoccurwithin90daysoftheearlierof:• thedatethechildwastakenintocustody;or• thedatethechildwasservedwiththesummonsthatwasissuedwhenthe
petitionwasfiled.Rule8.090(a).However,thechildcanfilea“DemandforSpeedyTrial”andhavetherighttotheadjudicatoryhearingwithin50daysofthefilingofthedemand.Rule8.090(g)(4).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonspeedytrials.Ifthechildisheldindetention,theadjudicatoryhearingmustbecommencedwithin21daysofthechildbeingplacedintodetentioncare,§985.26,unlessthechildhaswaivedthetimeperiodsbyrequestingcontinuances.
F. Determinecustodypendingdisposition
1. ReviewRAIIfthechildwasheldindetentionpriortothearraignmenthearing,thecourtwillhavetodeterminewhethercontinueddetentionisnecessarypendingdisposition.§§985.24(1);985.255(2).ThecourtmayreviewtheRAIscoreforassistanceindeterminingcustody,andwillneedtomakefindingsthatthechild:• Presentsariskofnotappearingatthenexthearing;• Presentsariskofbodilyharmtoothersasevidencedbyrecentbehavior;• Presentsahistoryofcommittingpropertyoffensespriortoadjudication,
disposition,orplacement;or• Requestsprotectionfromimminentbodilyharm.§985.24(1)(a)-(c),(e).
2. IfaDomesticViolenceOffenseisAlleged
Ifthechildisallegedtohavecommittedadomesticviolenceoffense(asdefinedin§741.28)andheorshedoesnotmeetdetentioncriteria,thecourtcanorderthechildtobeheldinsecuredetentionifthecourtmakeswrittenfindingsthat:• Respitecareforthechildisnotavailable.• Itisnecessarytoplacethechildinsecuredetentiontoprotectthevictim
frominjury.§985.255(2)(a)-(b).
Achildmaynotbeheldindetentionunder985.255(2)formorethan48hourswithoutcourtorder.§985.255(2).Additionally,after48hours,thecourtmustholdahearingifthestateattorneyorthechildrequeststhatdetentionbecontinued.§985.255(2).Detentionmaybecontinuedifthecourtmakesspecificwrittenfindingsthatcontinueddetentionisnecessarytoprotectthevictimfromfurtherharm,anddetentioncannotcontinuepastthetimelimitsestablishedinFloridastatute.§985.255(2).
122
3. ReasonsnottoPlacetheChild
However,achildmaynotbeplacedintodetentioncareforanyofthefollowingreasons:• toallowaparentorguardiantoavoidhisorherlegalresponsibility;• topermitmoreconvenientadministrativeaccesstothechild;• tofacilitatefurtherinterrogationorinvestigation;or• duetoalackofmoreappropriatefacilities.§985.24(2)(a)-(d).
Also,achildmaynot,underanycircumstances,beplacedintosecuredetentionifthechildisallegedtobedependentunderChapter39.§985.24(3).
123
124
ADJUDICATORYHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§985.033-985.039;985.185;985.26;985.35;985.43;985.445;985.534;985.35RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.055;8.060;8.065;8.090;8.100;8.110;8.165;8.929RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARINGThepurposeoftheadjudicatoryhearingistodeterminewhetherthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflaw.
TIMEFRAME
Forachildheldindetention,theadjudicatoryhearingmustbecommencedwithin21daysofthechildbeingtakenintocustody.Thecourtmayextendthelengthofdetentionanadditional9daysforcertainoffenses.§985.26(2)Forachildnotheldindetention,theadjudicatoryhearingmustbeheldwithin90daysofthefilingofthedelinquencypetition,orwithin50daysofthefilingbythechildofaDemandforSpeedyTrial.Rule8.090(g)(4).
BURDENOFPROOF
Thepetitionermustprovetheallegationsinthedelinquencypetitionthatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflawbeyondareasonabledoubt.§985.35(2)(a).
RULESOFEVIDENCE Rulesofevidenceusedincriminalcases.§985.35(2).
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
NEXTHEARING
Adispositionhearingmustoccurassoonaspossibleaftertheadjudicatoryhearing.Childcannotremainindetentionforlongerthan15daysfollowingentryofanorderofadjudication.§985.26(3).
125
126
ADJUDICATORYHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepurposeoftheadjudicatoryhearingistoallowthe
petitioneranopportunitytoprovetheallegationsinthedelinquencypetitionbeyondareasonabledoubt.
Ø Placethechildandallwitnesses,includingtheparents,underoath.Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameand
permanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestDJJgiveathoroughdescriptionof
thestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthehearing.Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Ifthecourtis
aUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thecourtshallappoint
counselunlesswaivedbythechild.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.Thiswaivershallbeinwriting.
Ø Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Ø Advisethechildofhisorherrighttoremainsilent,andthatanythingthechildsays
canbeusedagainsthimorher.
C. Adjudicatoryhearingprocess
Ø Thechildmaytestifyonhisorherownbehalfandintroduceevidence.Verifythatthechildunderstandswhatthismeans.
Ø Therulesofevidenceandproceduresappliedincriminalcasesareappliedindelinquencycases.Explaintothechildthatthepetitionermustprovethechargeofdelinquencybeyondareasonabledoubt-thatthechargemustbeproventotheextentthatthereisno"reasonabledoubt"inthemindofareasonablepersonthatthechildisguilty.
127
D. Delinquencydetermination
Ø Ifdelinquencyisnotproven,dismissthecaseanddischargethechild.Ø Ifdelinquencyisproven,thecaseproceedstodisposition.Explainwhatwill
happennextandwhatisexpectedofthechild.Ø Ifdelinquencyisproven,determinewhethertowithholdadjudicationor
adjudicatethechilddelinquent.Ø Statethefactualbasisforthedetermination.Tellthechildthereasonsforthe
determinationinclear,simpleterms.
E. Custodypendingdisposition
Ø Explaintothechildanycustodydecisionsmadeandthereasonsforthem.
F. Adviseofrighttoappeal
Ø Verifythatthechildunderstandthisright.
G. Setdispositionhearing
Ø Ifapredispositionreporthasnotbeendone,orderittobedoneandsetthedispositionforadateafterthereporthasbeencompleted.
Ø IfapredispositionreporthasbeencompletedandDJJhasissueditsrecommendation,thecourtmayholdthedispositionhearingimmediately,ormaysetitforafuturedate.
Ø Adispositionhearingmustoccurassoonaspossibleaftertheadjudicatoryhearing.Ifthechildisindetentioncare,thedispositionhearingmustbeheldnolaterthan15daysfollowingentryofanorderofadjudication.
H. Requirementsforwrittenorderofadjudication
Ø Itmuststatethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Ifcounseliswaived,makefindingthatwaiverwasknowing,voluntary,andintelligent.
Ø Writtenordermuststatefindingsandfactualbasisfordelinquencydecision.Ø Ifchildisfoundnottohavecommitteddelinquentact,makefindingandorderthe
releaseofthechild.Includereasonsforsuchafinding.Ø Ifchildisfoundtohavecommittedadelinquentact,makefindingandorderan
adjudicationofdelinquencyorwithholdingofadjudication.Includereasonsforsuch.Ø Directthedetentionofthechildandstatethereasonsor,ifappropriate,orderthe
releaseofthechildandreturntohisorhernonresidentialcommitmentprogram,orreleasethechildpendingdisposition.
Ø Makeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare.Ø Setthenexthearingdate.
128
ADJUDICATORYHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. PurposeExplainthatthepurposeoftheadjudicatoryhearingistoprovidethepetitioneranopportunitytoprovetheallegationsofthedelinquencypetitionbeyondareasonabledoubt.§985.35(2)(a).Delinquencyadjudicatoryhearingsareconductedbythecourtwithoutajury.Rule8.110(c).Therulesofevidenceusedincriminalcasesapplytoadjudicatoryhearings.§985.35(2).Thechildhastherighttopresentevidenceandtocross-examinewitnesses.§985.35(2)(b).Theadjudicatoryhearingmustbeheldassoonaspracticableafterthepetitionfordependencyisfiled,butnotmorethan21daysafterchildisplacedindetentioncare.§985.26(2).Forachildnotheldindetention,theadjudicatoryhearingmustbeheldwithin90daysofthefilingofthedelinquencypetition,orwithin50daysofthefilingofademandforaspeedytrial.Rule8.090(g)(4).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonspeedytrials.
4. IdentifyThosePresentIdentifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thosepresentshouldidentifythemselvesforthecourtandtherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
129
5. NoticeAssessment
Ifthereareanyidentifiedparentsorguardianswhoareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinestepstakentolocateandservenoticeoftheadjudicatoryhearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearch,followingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.Thenonattendancebyaparentorguardianmayrequirethecontinuanceofanadjudicatoryhearing.Ifthecourtordersthechildtopaymonetaryrestitution,itisdonethroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Additionally,thestatemayseekrestitutionorcommunityservicebythechild’sparents;aseparatepetitioncalleda“PetitionforParentalSanctions”mustbefiledwiththecourt,andtheparentsorguardiansmustbeserved.Rules8.030and8.031.Ifeitherofthesesituationshasoccurred,alackofserviceorafailuretoappearmaybegroundsforacontinuanceofthehearing,ifapartycanshowgoodcauseforthecontinuance.Rule8.100(e).
6. Placethechildandanywitnesses,includingtheparents,underoathIfthechildispresentingtestimonyonhis/herownbehalf,thecourtshouldplacethechildunderoath.Rule8.110(d).Thecourtshouldalsoplaceanywitnesseswhowillpresenttestimonyunderoath.Priortotheexaminationofanywitnesses,anypartymayinvoketheruletohavethewitnessessequesteredtopreventcommunicationbetweenthewitnesses.Rule8.100(d).
7. JointTrials
Where2ormorechildrenareallegedtohavejointlycommittedadelinquentactorviolationofthelaw,theyshallbetriedjointlyunlessthecourtisitsdiscretionordersseparatetrials.Rule8.110(e).
8. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
AchildindelinquencyproceedingsisgenerallyaffordedthesameConstitutionalrightsasadultsincriminalproceeding.Childrenareentitledtodueprocess,righttocounsel,andrightagainstself-incriminationandillegalsearchandseizure.§985.35(2).Theonenotableexceptionistherighttoajury–achildinadelinquencyproceedingdoesnothavetherighttoatrialbyjury.
130
1. RighttoCounsel
Determinewhetherthechildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisehimorheroftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtshallmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthatifindigent,heorshehastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowingly,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecordandinwriting.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
2. RighttoCommunicate
Unlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresence
131
ofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
3. RighttoRemainSilentAdvisethechildofhisorherrighttoremainsilent.Thechildmustbeapprisedthatheorshehastherightagainstself-incrimination.Thecourtmustadvisethechildthatheorshehastherighttoremainsilentandthatanythingthechildsayscanbeusedagainsthimorherasanadmission.§985.35(2).
C. Adjudicatoryhearingprocess
Conductthehearing,tothefullestextentpracticable,inlanguageunderstandabletothechildbeforethecourt.§985.35(2).1. DefenseofAlibi
Ifachildwantstopresentanalibiasadefense,thestateattorneymaydemandinwritingthatthechildprovidethestateattorneywiththedetailsofthealibidefense;thechildmustcomplynotlessthan10daysbeforethetrialdate.Rule8.065(a).Thestateattorneymaythenpreparealistofrebuttalwitnesseswithin5daysofreceiptoftheinformation,andmustpresentthatlisttothechild.Rule8.065(b).ShouldthechildfailtoorrefusetocomplywithRule8.065,thecourtmay,initsdiscretion,excludetestimonyofalibiwitnessesotherthanthatofthechild.Rule8.065(c).ShouldthestateattorneyfailtocomplywiththeRule8.065,thecourtmay,initsdiscretion,excluderebuttaltestimonyofferedbythestate.Rule8.065(c).AsperRule8.065(d),forgoodcauseshown,thecourtmaywaivetherequirementsofRule8.065.
2. ParticipationintheDiscoveryProcess
Participationbythechildinthediscoveryprocessshallbeanelectiontoparticipateindiscovery.Rule8.060(a)(1).Ifthereisashowingofmaterialitytothepreparationofthedefense,thecourtcanorderdiscoveryotherthaninthewrittendiscoveryexhibit.Rule8.060(a)(5).Uponapplication,thecourtmaydeny
132
orpartiallyrestrictdisclosureauthorizedbyRule8.060ifitfindsthereisasubstantialrisktoanypersonofphysicalharm,intimidation,bribery,economicreprisals,orunnecessaryannoyanceorembarrassmentresultingfromsuchdisclosure,whichoutweighsanyusefulnessofthedisclosuretothepartyrequestingit.Rule8.060(c)(1).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediscoveryprocess.
3. RulesofEvidence
Therulesofevidenceappliedincriminalcasesareappliedindelinquencycases.§985.35(2).Achildchargedwithadelinquentactorviolationofthelawisaffordedallrightsagainstself-incrimination.§985.35(2)(c).Evidenceillegallyseizedorobtainedshallnotbeadmittedintoevidencetoestablishtheallegationsagainstthechild.§985.35(2)(c).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoncommonevidenceissues.
4. ChildAllowedtoTestifyandIntroduceEvidence
Thechildmaytestifyonhisorherownbehalfandintroduceevidence.§985.35(2)(b).Thechildmaybecross-examinedlikeotherwitnesses,Rule8.110(d),andmaycross-examinewitnesses.§985.35(2)(b).Nochildcanbecompelledtogivetestimonyagainsthim-orherself,andnoprosecutingattorneycancommentonanysuchfailuretotestify.Rule8.110(d).
5. RighttoaClosingArgument
Allchildrenhavetherighttoaclosingargument.However,theorderinwhichthechildandthestatepresenttheirclosingargumentsmayvary,dependingonwhetherthechildhaspresentedanyevidenceorofferedanytestimonyotherthanhisorherown.Ifthechildhaspresentedevidenceortestimonyotherthanhisorherown,thestatepresentsthefirstclosingargument(andtherebuttalclosingargument)andthechildpresentsthesecondclosingargument.If,however,thechildhaspresentednotestimonyorevidenceotherthanhisorherown,thechildisentitledtopresenttheinitialclosingargumentandarebuttalargument.Rule8.110(d).Thestateisallowedtopresentthesecondclosingargument.
InD.B.v.State,979So.2d1119(Fla.3dDCA2008),thecourtheldthatD.B.,whopresentednoevidencenorofferedanytestimonyotherthanhisown,wasentitledtopresentthefirstandfinalclosingarguments;thisisheldtobedifferentthanadultcriminalprosecutions,wheretheStateisentitledtogivethefirstandreplyclosingarguments,perFla.R.Crim.P.3.381.Thecourtfurtherheldthatthisrightisavestedproceduralright.
133
D. Delinquencydetermination
1. IfDelinquencyisnotProvenIfdelinquencyhasnotbeenproven,dismissthecaseanddischargethechild.§985.35(3);Rule8.110(f).
2. IfDelinquencyisProvenIfdelinquencyhasbeenproven,determinewhethertowithholdadjudicationoradjudicatechilddelinquent.§985.35(4).Thecourtcanimposeanarrayofconditions,includingbutnotlimitedtorestitution,communityservice,orcurfew.§985.35(4)(a).Ifthechildfailstocomply,thecourtmayafterahearingonnoncomplianceenteranadjudicationofdelinquency.§985.35(4)(c).Ifthechildisadjudicateddelinquent,thecourtmustthendecidedisposition.Ifthepre-dispositionreportisavailable,thecourtmayimmediatelyproceedtodisposition,orcontinuethecasetoadispositionhearing.Rule8.110(g).Ifapredispositionreportisnotready,thecourtwillcontinuethecaseandreferthechildtotheappropriateagency.Rule8.110(g).Anadjudicationofdelinquencyshallnotbedeemedtobeaconviction,norwillthechildbedeemedtobeacriminalbyreasonofthatadjudication.§985.35(6).
3. WithholdingAdjudication
Thecourtmay,initsdiscretion,enteranorderstatingthefactsuponwhichitsfindingisbasedbutwithholdadjudication.§985.35(4).Uponwithholdingadjudication,thecourtmayplacethechildinaprobationprogramunderthesupervisionofDJJ.§985.35(4)(a).Onerecentarticlesuggestedthatwithholdingadjudicationmaybebeneficialtothecourtbecauseawithholdingwillincreasejudicialefficiency,andmayallowthecourtanopportunitytodemonstrateleniencyforuncharacteristicbehavior.(seeTragos,G.andSartes,P.WithholdofAdjudication:WhatEveryoneNeedstoKnow.FloridaBarJournal(Feb.1,2008).)Withholdingadjudicationmaybebeneficialtothechildaswell.Awithholdingofadjudicationcouldprecludethechildfromcollateralconsequencestoanadjudicationofdelinquency(seeTragosandSartes,supra)andkeepthechild’slegalrecordclearofdelinquentadjudications.
4. WrittenFindingifChildisinaPublicSchool
Regardlessofwhetheradjudicationiswithheld,ifthechildisattendingpublicschoolandthevictimorsiblingalsoattendsthatschool,thecourtmustmakeawrittenfindingunder§985.455(2).Thecourtmustdeterminewhetheranocontactorderinfavorofthevictimorvictim’ssiblingisappropriate.Ifthecourtfindsthatitisappropriate,andifthevictimorvictim’srepresentativefindsitappropriate,thecourtmayreflectsuchdeterminationsinwritingorinopencourt,andincludeastatementthatthevictimorvictim’srepresentativedidnotobjecttotheoffenderchildattendingthesameschoolorridingthesamebusas
134
thevictimorvictim’ssiblings.§985.455(2).5. OrderofAdjudication
Ifthecourtfindsthechildhascommittedadelinquentactorviolationofthelaw,thecourtshallincorporatethatfindingintoanorderofadjudicationofdelinquency,statingthefactsuponwhichthefindingismade.§985.35(5).
6. DegreesofOffensesIncluded
Ifthepetitionallegesanoffenseoroffensesthataredividedintodegrees,thecourtmayfindthatthechildcommittedanoffenseofthedegreeallegedortoalesserdegree.Rule8.110(h).Onapetitionforanyoffense,thecourtmayfindthatthechildcommittedanattempttocommittheoffenseoranynecessarilyincludedorlesserincludedoffenseoftheoffensechargedinthepetition.Rule8.110(j).
7. MotionforJudgmentofDismissal.Rule8.110(k).
Atthecloseofpetitioner’sevidence,thecourtmaydismissthepetitiononitsown,oronmotionbythestateattorneyorthechild,ifthecourtfindstheevidenceinsufficienttoestablishaprimafaciecaseofdelinquency.Whenmakingsuchadetermination,thecourtmustviewtheevidenceinthelightmostfavorabletotheState.
E. Custodypendingdisposition
Ifthecaseiscontinuedpendingadispositionhearing,thecourtmayorderthechilddetained.Rule8.110(g).However,thecourtmustplaceindetentioncareallchildrenwhoareadjudicateddelinquentandawaitingplacementinacommitmentprogram.§985.27.
F. Adviseofrighttoappeal
Anappealfromanadjudicatoryordermaybetakentotheappropriatedistrictcourtwithinthetimeandmannerprescribedin§924.051andFla.RulesofAppellateProcedurebythechild,parentorguardian,orthestate.§985.534(1)(a)&(b).InL.B.v.State,10So.3d1161(Fla.3dDCA2009),thecourtheld,“Topreserveanissueforappeal,alitigantmustmakeatimely,contemporaneousobjection,statingalegalgroundforthatobjection.Thepurposefortheruleisto‘placethetrialjudgeonnoticethaterrormayhavebeencommitted,andprovidehimanopportunitytocorrectitatanearlystageoftheproceedings.’(citingHarrellv.State,894So.2d935(Fla.2005)at340).”(Emphasisadded.)
135
G. Setdispositionhearing
1. GenerallyApredispositionreportmustbeorderedbythecourtforanychildforwhomaresidentialcommitmentdispositionisanticipatedorrecommendedbyanofficerofthecourtorDJJ.Evaluationshallbeorderedforanychildforwhomresidentialcommitmentdispositionisanticipatedorrecommended.§985.185(1).Thecourtmayorderanyadditionalreports.§985.185(2).Achildwhowasnotinsecuredetentionatthetimeoftheadjudicatoryhearing,butforwhomresidentialcommitmentisanticipatedorrecommended,maybeplacedunderaspecialdetentionorderunder§985.26(5)forthepurposeofconductingacomprehensiveevaluation.§985.43(1).
2. IfReportisUnavailable
Ifthepredispositionreportisunavailableatthetimeoftheadjudicatoryhearing,thecourtmaycontinuethecaseuntilsuchatimeasitisavailable,Rule8.110(g),althoughnotmorethan15daysfollowingtheentryofanorderofadjudication,ifthechildisindetentioncare.§985.26(3).Thecourtshouldreferthechildtotheappropriateagencyforastudyandrecommendation.Rule8.110(g).
H. Requirementsforwrittenorderofadjudication
1. Thecourtordermustbeinwritingandmustsetforththefactsuponwhichthefindingthatthechildcommittedadelinquentactisbased.Rule8.055.• Nameandaddress.Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,
designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
• WaiverofCounsel.Ifcounselwaswaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,voluntary,andintelligent.
• Detentiondirections.Directthedetentionofthechildpendingdispositionandstatethereasonsthereforor,ifappropriate,orderthereleaseofthechildandreturntohisorhernonresidentialcommitmentprogram.
• FindingofAdjudication.Ifthechildwasfoundnottohavecommitteddelinquentact,makeafinding,statingfactsthefindingisbasedon,andorderthereleaseofthechild.Ifthechildwasfoundtohavecommittedadelinquentact,makeafindingandorderthechildadjudicateddelinquentorwithholdadjudication,andbrieflystatethefactsuponwhichthefindingismade.§985.35(5).
• Specifyoffenses.Ifthepetitionallegesmorethanoneoffense,oranoffensedividedintodegrees,specifywhichoffenseoroffensesthechildwasfoundtohavecommitted.Rule8.110(i).
• Releaseinstructions.Exceptasprovidedin§§790.22(8)or985.27,whenachildisplacedintosecureornonsecuredetentioncare,orintoarespitehomeorotherplacementpursuanttoacourtorderfollowingahearing,the
136
courtordermustincludespecificinstructionsthatdirectthereleaseofthechildfromsuchplacementnolaterthan5:00p.m.onthelastdayofthedetentionperiodspecifiedin§§985.26or985.27,whicheverisapplicable,unlesstherequirementsoftheapplicableprovisionhavebeenmetoranorderofcontinuancehasbeengrantedunderFla.Stat.§985.26(4).
• Findingofcost.Thecourtmustmakeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare,ormakeafindingastoanyreductionorwaiverofcost,includingthereinthereasonsforsuchafinding.§985.039.Whenachildisplacedintononsecuredetention,probation,orothersupervisedstatuswithDJJ,orwhenachildiscommittedtoaminimum-risknon-residentialrestrictivenesslevel,ordertheparentorguardiantopayonedollar($1.00)perdaytoDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(a).IfachildisplacedinsecuredetentionorplacedoncommittedstatusandDJJacquirestemporarylegalcustodyofthechild,ordertheparentorguardiantopayfivedollars($5.00)perdaytoDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(b).IfthecourtfailstoincludeintheDetentionOrderinformationregardingcostofsupervisionandcare,theparentisdeemedtohaveanobligationtopayDJJonedollar($1.00)perdayforeachdaythechildisunderthesupervisionofDJJandfivedollars($5.00)perdayforeachdaythechildremainsinthecareofDJJ.§985.039(5).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoncosts.
• Setnexthearing.
137
138
DISPOSITIONHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;318.143;790.22;938.03;985.0301;955.033;985.035;985.039;985.255;985.26;985.27;985.35;985.43;985.433;985.435;985.437;985.441;985.455;985.46;985.601;985.721RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.055;8.100;8.110;8.115;8.165;8.929;8.947RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARINGThepurposeofthedispositionhearingisforthecourttoconsiderreports,recommendations,andotherevidencetodeterminethedispositionofthecase.
TIMEFRAMEThedispositionhearingshouldbeheldnotmorethan15daysfollowingtheentryofanorderofadjudication,ifthechildisindetentioncare.§985.26(3).
RULESOFEVIDENCE
Courtmayreceiveanyrelevantandmaterialevidencehelpfulindeterminingtheproperdisposition.Thecourtmayrelyuponsuchevidencetotheextentofitsprobativevalue,evenifitisnotcompetentinanadjudicatoryhearing.Rule8.115(a).
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
139
140
DISPOSITIONHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepurposeofthedispositionhearingisforthecourtto
considerreports,recommendations,andotherrelevantandmaterialevidencetodeterminethedispositionofthecase.
Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameandpermanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestthatDJJgiveathoroughdescription
ofthestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thecourtshallappoint
counselunlesswaivedbythechild.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.Thiswaivershallbeinwriting.
Ø Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Ø Advisethechildofhisorherrighttoremainsilent,andthatanythingthechildsays
canbeusedagainsthimorher.
C. Reviewpredispositionreport
Ø Thecourtmustconsiderthepredispositionreportifonewasprepared.Ø Inadditiontothepredispositionreport,thecourtmustconsidertheunderlying
comprehensiveassessmentandrecordsofearlierjudicialproceedings.Ø Thecourtcanwithholdadjudicationifthecourtfindsthatnoactionotherthan
supervisioninthechild’shomeisrequired.Ø Thecourtmayalsowithholdadjudication,placethechildinaprobationprogram
andimposepenaltycomponentssuchasrestitution,communityservice,orother
141
nonresidentialpunishmentappropriatetotheoffense.
D. Commitmentdetermination
Ø Thefirstdeterminationthecourtmustmakeisadeterminationofsuitabilityforadjudicationandcommitmentofthechildtothedepartment.
Ø Ifthecourtadjudicatesthechilddelinquent,thecourtmustthendecidewhethercommitmentisappropriatebaseduponthedetentioncriteria.
Ø DJJwillrecommendtothecourtaplacementlevelandindividualizedtreatmentplanforthechild.
Ø Thecourtmustincludeapenaltycomponentinaprobationprogramforachildadjudicateddelinquent.
Ø Thecourtmayorderachildadjudicateddelinquenttomakerestitution,ormayordertheparentorguardiantomakerestitution.
Ø Thecourtmayalsoorderthechildbeplacedonpost-commitmentprobationatanytimebeforerelease.
Ø Thecourtmayorderconditionalreleaseservicestopromoterehabilitation.Ø Thecourtmustorderotherpenaltiesifthechildisadjudicatedforoffenses
involvingfirearmsandoffensesinvolvingalcoholconsumption.Ø Verifythatthechildunderstandswhatisbeingordered,howitwillaffectthechild,
andwhatwillbeexpectedofhimorher.Explainthetermsofdispositionclearlyandinlanguagethechildcanunderstand.
E. Detentionpendingcommitment
Ø Childrencommittedtoaresidentialprogrammustbeplacedintosomeformofdetentioncarependingplacementintotheresidentialprogram.Explainwhatthatmeans,whatisexpectedofthechild,andwhattheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequiredare.
F. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdisposition
Ø Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Statethedispositionofeachcountspecifyingthecharge,thedegreeofoffense,andthemaximumpenaltydefinedbystatute.
Ø Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,voluntary,andintelligent.
Ø Stategeneralandspecificconditionsorsanctions,includinganyrestitutionorprobationprovisions.
Ø Makefindingsastothedispositionofthechild.Ø Statethedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountryandcourtwhereissued.Ø Thechild’sfingerprintsshallbeaffixedtotheorderofdisposition.Ø Statetheperiodofthedisposition.Ø Statewhetherthecourtretainsjurisdictionoverdischarge.
142
DISPOSITIONHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Explaintothechildthatthepurposeofthedispositionhearingisforthecourttoconsiderreports,recommendations,andotherrelevantandmaterialevidencetodeterminethedispositionofthecase.Allpartiespresenthavetherighttobeheard.Forpurposesofdisposition,thisincludesparents,guardians,legalcustodians,child’scounsel,stateattorney,DJJrepresentatives,thevictimorvictim’srepresentative,representativesoftheschoolsystem,andlawenforcementofficersinvolvedinthecase.I.H.v.State,584So.2d230(Fla.5thDCA1991).Thedispositionhearingisakintothesentencinghearingincriminallaw,andfollowseitheracourtfindingthatthejuvenilecommittedadelinquentactorapleaofguiltyornolocontenderewasentered.Thecourthasawiderangeofdispositionoptionsrangingfromajudicialwarning,probationonly,commitmenttoalicensedchildcaringagency,orcommitmenttoDJJ.
4. IdentifyThosePresent
Identifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
143
5. NoticeAssessment
Iftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearchfollowingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.
Thenonattendancebyaparentorguardianmayrequirethecontinuanceofthedispositionhearing.Ifthecourtordersthechildtopaymonetaryrestitution,itisdonethroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Additionally,thestatemayseekrestitutionorcommunityservicebythechild’sparents;aseparatepetitioncalleda“PetitionforParentalSanctions”mustbefiledwiththecourt,andtheparentsorguardiansmustbeserved.Rules8.030and8.031.Ifeitherofthesesituationshasoccurred,alackofserviceorafailuretoappearmaybegroundsforacontinuanceofthehearing,ifapartycanshowgoodcauseforthecontinuance.Rule8.100(e).
6. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
1. RighttoCounselDeterminewhetherthechildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigencystatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtmustmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Aperson
144
seekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthat,ifindigent,heorshehastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthechildappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
2. RighttoCommunicate
Unlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
C. Reviewpredispositionreport
1. ConsiderDispositionReport
145
Thecourtmustconsiderthepredispositionreport.ThepredispositionispreparedbythejuvenileprobationofficerandcontainsDJJ’srecommendationsfordisposition,and,ifprepared,mustbesubmittedtothecourtnolessthan48hourspriortothedispositionhearing.§985.43(3).Apredispositionreportisrequiredwhenresidentialcommitmentisanticipated.§985.43(1)(a).Thechild,thechild’sattorney,thechild’sparentorcustodian,andthestateattorneyareentitledtodisclosureofallinformationcontainedinthepredispositionreportandallreportsandevaluationsusedinthepreparation.Rule8.115(c).However,thepredispositionreportcannotbereviewedbythecourtwithouttheconsentofthechilduntilthechildhasbeenfoundtohavecommittedadelinquentact.§985.43(3).Thepredispositionreportmaybereliedupontotheextentofitsprobativevalue,eventhoughnotcompetentinanadjudicatoryhearing.Rule8.115(a).
2. ConsiderOtherRecords
Inadditiontothepredispositionreport,thecourtmustconsidertheunderlyingcomprehensiveassessmentandrecordsofearlierjudicialproceedingspursuantto§985.43(2).Thecourtmayalsoconsideranyrelevantandmaterialevidencethatmaybehelpfultodeterminingtheproperdisposition.Evidencemaybereliedupontotheextentofitsprobativevalueevenifthisevidencewouldnotbecompetentatanadjudicatoryhearing.Rule8.115(a).
3. BeforeDeterminingDisposition
Beforedeterminingdisposition,thecourtmust:• Stateclearly,usingcommonterminology,thepurposesofthehearingand
therightofthosepresenttocommentatappropriatetimes;• Discusswiththechildhisorhercompliancewithanyplanimposedsincethe
dateoftheoffense;• Discusswiththechildhisorherfeelingsabouttheoffensecommitted,the
harmdone,andwhatpenaltyheorsheshouldfacefortheoffense;and• Giveallpartiesanopportunitytocommentontheissueofdispositionand
anyproposedrehabilitativeactions.§985.433(4)(a)-(d).4. DetermineDisposition
Oncethecourthasconsideredthepredispositionreportandalltheevidence,determinedisposition.§985.433(7).Thecourtmustdeterminewhatprogrambestmeetstheneedsofthechildandthepublicsafety.§985.433(9).Thecourthastheoptiontoadjudicatethechilddelinquentortowithholdadjudication.Thecourtcanwithholdadjudicationifthecourt,initsdiscretion,entersanorderwithholdingadjudicationandstatesthefactsuponwhichthefindingisbased.§985.35(4).Under§985.35(4),thecourtmaywithholdadjudicationandplace
146
thechildinaprobationprogram,andmayimposeotherpenaltycomponentsasaconditionoftheprogram.
Thecourtmaynotcommitajuveniletoalifesentencewithoutparoleiftheoffenderdidnotcommithomicide.Grahamv.Florida,2010WL1946731(U.S.2010).
D. Commitmentdetermination
1. SuitabilityofAdjudicationDeterminationThefirstdeterminationthecourtmustmakeisadeterminationofsuitabilityforadjudication.§985.433(6).Thedeterminationshallincludeaconsiderationoftheinformationpresentedbyallparties,includingbutnotlimitedtothepredispositionreport,thenatureandcircumstancesofthedelinquentact,andthechild’seducationalstatus.
2. DetermineCommitment
Ifthecourtadjudicatesthechilddelinquent,thecourtmustthendecidewhethercommitmentisappropriatebaseduponthecriteriain§985.433(6).
DJJwillrecommendtothecourtaplacementlevelandindividualizedtreatmentplanforthechild,whichthecourtmustconsiderbeforedecidingthecommitmentofthechild.§985.433(6).ThecourtmaycommitthechildtothelevelrecommendedbyDJJoritcanrejecttherecommendation.§985.433(7)(b).Thecourtcandeviatefromtherecommendation;ifitdoesso,itmustfollow§985.433(7)(b)andtheFloridaSupremeCourt’srulinginE.A.R.v.State,4So.3d614(Fla.2009).ThecourtmaynotdirectDJJtoplaceachildataspecificfacility.Dept.ofJuvenileJusticev.K.B.,784So.2d556(Fla.1stDCA2001).Thecourtcanonlyorderthecommitmentlevel.
147
InE.A.R.v.State,4So.3d614(Fla.2009),thecourtheldthat,iflowercourtswantedtodivergefromtherecommendationsofDJJ,thejuvenilecourtmust:“articulateanunderstandingoftherespectivecharacteristicsoftheopposingrestrictivenesslevels,including,butnotlimitedto,thetypeofchildthateachrestrictivenesslevelisdesignedtoserve,thepotential“lengthsofstay”associatedwitheachlevel,andthedivergenttreatmentprogramsandservicesavailabletothejuvenileattheselevels;andlogicallyandpersuasivelyexplainwhy,inlightofthesedifferingcharacteristics,onelevelisbettersuitedtoservingboththerehabilitativeneedsofthejuvenile,intheleastrestrictivesetting,andmaintainingtheabilityoftheStatetoprotectthepublicfromfurtheractsofdelinquency.”SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonmorerestrictiveplacements.
3. PeriodofCommitment
Theperiodofcommitmentisindeterminate,butcannotexceedthemaximumadultsentenceforthesameoffense.§985.455(3).ThisallowsDJJtoretainthechildinanappropriatecommitmentplacementuntilrehabilitationisachieved.Howeverforsomeoffenderssuchassexoffenderorjuvenileprisoncommitment,jurisdictionisuntil21yearsofage.§985.0301(5).Jurisdictioncanbeextendeduntil22yearsofageforhigh-riskandmaximum-riskoffenderstoallowthechildtoparticipateinajuvenileconditionalreleaseprogram.§985.0301(5)(d).DJJcommitmentshavevaryinglevelsofrestrictiveness.Restrictivenesslevelmeansthelevelofprogrammingandsecurityprovidedbyprogramsthatservicethesupervision,custody,care,andtreatmentneedsofcommittedchildren.Sections985.601(10)and985.721applytochildrenplacedinprogramsatanyresidentialcommitmentlevel.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoncommitmenttoDJJ.
4. Probation
Thecourtmayincludeaprobationprogramforachildadjudicateddelinquent.§985.435.Juvenileprobationisanindividualizedprogramthatincludesbothapenaltyandarehabilitativecomponent.§985.435(2)&(3).Theprobationmustincludetreatmentdesignedtoachieverehabilitationsuchassubstanceabusetreatment,requiredschoolattendance,educationalorworkprograms,counseling,andcommunitybasedprogramsforyouths.§985.435(3).Aprobationprogrammayalsoincludeanalternativeconsequencecomponenttoaddressinstancesinwhichachildisnoncompliantwithtechnicalconditionsofhisorherprobationbuthasnotcommittedanynewviolationsoflaw.§985.435(4).Amandatory$50.00victim’scrimecompensationtrustfundfee
148
mustbeimposedregardlessofwhetheradjudicationiswithheld.§938.03(1).Thecourtmayimposeanyspecialconditionofprobationaslongasitbearsarelationshiptothecrime,relatestoconductwhichisinitselfcriminal,orrequiresorforbidsconductwhichisreasonablyrelatedtofuturecriminality.Billerv.State,618So.2d734(Fla.1993).Thecourtmayimposeelectronicmonitoringasaconditionofjuvenileprobation.T.S.v.State,682So.2d1202(Fla.4thDCA1996).Anorderofprobationisindeterminatebutcannotextendbeyondthechild’s19thbirthday.§985.0301(5)(b).Thedurationcannotexceedthetimethatcouldbeimposedforwhichanadultsentencecouldbeimposed,exceptthatformisdemeanorsoftheseconddegree,probationmaybeimposedforupto6months.§985.455(3).
Thecourtmayalsoorderthechildbeplacedonpost-commitmentprobationatanytimebeforerelease.§985.433(7)(c).Thecourtmaysuspendimpositionofthecommitmentandplacethechildonjuvenileprobationwithin60daysfromthedateofdisposition.§985.455(4).
5. Restitution
Thecourtmayorderachildadjudicateddelinquent(orwhereadjudicationhasbeenwithheld)tomakerestitutionorordertheparentorguardiantomakerestitution.§985.437.Thecourtmayorderthechildtomakerestitutioninmoneythroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorinkindfordamagesorlosscausedbytheoffense.§985.437(2).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonrestitution.
6. ConditionalReleaseServices
Thecourtmayorderconditionalreleaseservicestopromoterehabilitation.§985.46.Theseservicescancontributetoasuccessfultransitionofadelinquentchildfromcommitmentbackintothechild’scommunity,andthusshouldbeincludedinthecontinuumofcare.§985.46(1).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonconditionalrelease.
7. OffensesInvolvingFirearms
IfthechildisadjudicatedforanoffenseinvolvingtheuseorpossessionofafirearmandisnotcommittedtoDJJ,thecourtmustorder,inadditiontoanyotherpenalty,atleast15daysinsecuredetention,100hourscommunityservice,andplacementonprobationorinanonresidentialcommunityprogramforafirstoffense.§790.22(9).Thecourtmustorderatleast21dayssecuredetentionand100-200hoursofcommunityserviceandplacementinprobationorinanonresidentialcommunityprogramforasecondorsubsequentoffense.§790.22(9).Inaddition,thechild’sdriver’slicensemustberevokedorwithheldforuptooneyearforafirstoffenseandupto2yearsforasecondorsubsequentoffense.§790.22(10).Thechilddoesnotgetcreditfortimealready
149
servedinsecuredetention.§790.22(9).8. OffensesInvolvingAlcohol
Childrenwhoviolatethealcoholstatuteprohibitingpersonslessthan21yearsofagefromdrinkingalcoholarerequiredtohavetheirdriver’slicenserevokedorwithhelduntiltheyturn18yearsofageforthefirstoffenseanduntiltheyturn21yearsofageforasecondorsubsequentoffense.§318.143(4).
E. Detentionpendingcommitment
Childrencommittedtoaresidentialprogrammustbeplacedintosomeformofdetentioncarependingplacementintotheresidentialprogram,§985.27(1),andmustmeetdetentioncriteriaoutlinedin§985.255.Achildawaitingplacementinalowtomoderateriskresidentialprogrammaybeplacedinsecuredetentionforupto5days.§985.27(1)(a).Ifamoderate–riskresidentialprogramisbeingimposed,DJJmayrequestanextensionofupto15workingdaysforplacement.§985.27(1)(b).Achildawaitingplacementinalowtomoderateresidentialplacementmaybeplacedinnonsecuredetentionwithelectronicmonitoring.§985.27(1).Whenachildisplacedindetentioncare,thecourtmustordertheparentstopay$5.00/daytooffsetthecostofthechild’scare,§985.039(1)(b),unlessthecourtordersthatareductionincostorwaiverofcostisappropriate,supportedbyappropriatefindings.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformation.
F. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdisposition
1. Thecourtordermustbeinwritingandmustsetforththefactsuponwhichthefindingthatthechildcommittedadelinquentactisbased.Rule8.055.TheFloridaSupremeCourthasanapprovedformavailableforuse,Form8.947.• Nameandaddress.Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,
designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.Rule8.115(d)(1).
• Dateandtime.Specifythedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountyandcourtwhereissued.Rule8.115(d)(5).
• WaiverofCounsel.Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
• Detentiondirections.Directthedetentionofthechildandstatethereasonssupportingsuchor,ifappropriate,orderthereleaseofthechildandreturntohisorhernonresidentialcommitmentprogram.
• Findingsoffact.Makeallfindingsoffactrequiredbylaw.Rule8.115(d)(4).• Specifyoffenses.Ifthepetitionallegesmorethanoneoffense,oranoffense
dividedintodegrees,thecourtmustspecifyofwhichoffenseoroffensesthechildhasbeenadjudicateddelinquent.Rule8.110(i).
150
• Disposition.Statethedispositionofeachcountspecifyingthechargetitle,thedegreeofoffense,andthemaximumpenaltydefinedbystatute.Rule8.115(d)(2)&(d)(3).
• Specialdisposition.Orderprobation,restitution,communityservice,curfew,and/orapologiesasappropriate.Ordernocontactwithvictims,ifappropriate.Rule8.115(d)(3).
• Determinationofgangmembership.Includeanydeterminationthatthechildwasamemberofastreetgang.§985.433(7).Suchadeterminationmustbegiven“greatweight”inidentifyingtheappropriatelevelofrestrictiveness.§985.433(7)(a).
• Releaseinstructions.Exceptasprovidedin§§790.22(8)or985.27,whenachildisplacedintosecureornonsecuredetentioncare,orintoarespitehomeorotherplacementpursuanttoacourtorderfollowingahearing,thecourtordermustincludespecificinstructionsthatdirectthereleaseofthechildfromsuchplacementnolaterthan5:00p.m.onthelastdayofthedetentionperiodspecifiedin§§985.26or985.27,whicheverisapplicable,unlesstherequirementsoftheapplicableprovisionhavebeenmetoranorderofcontinuancehasbeengrantedunder§985.26(4).
• Findingofcost.Thecourtmustmakeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare,ormakeafindingastoanyreductionorwaiverofcost,includingthereinthereasonsforsuchafinding.§985.039.Whenachildisplacedintononsecuredetention,probation,orothersupervisedstatuswithDJJ,orwhenachildiscommittedtoaminimum-risknon-residentialrestrictivenesslevel,ordertheparentorguardiantopayonedollar($1.00)perdaytoDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(a).IfachildisplacedinsecuredetentionorplacedoncommittedstatusandDJJacquirestemporarylegalcustodyofsaidchild,ordertheparentorguardiantopayfivedollars($5.00)perdaytoDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(b).IfthecourtfailstoincludeintheDetentionOrderinformationregardingcostofsupervisionandcare,theparentisdeemedtohaveanobligationtopayDJJonedollar($1.00)perdayforeachdaythechildisunderthesupervisionofDJJandfivedollars($5.00)perdayforeachdaythechildremainsinthecareofDJJ.§985.039(5).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoncosts.
Thechild’sfingerprintsmustbeaffixedtotheorderofdisposition.Rule8.115(e).
151
152
OtherHearings
153
154
VIOLATIONOFPROBATIONHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;790.22;985.033;985.035;985.039;985.245;985.255;985.26;985.27;985.433;985.435;985.439RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560
RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.100;8.110;8.115;8.120;8.165;8.929;8.947RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARINGThepurposeoftheviolationofprobationhearingistodeterminewhetherthechildviolatedthetermsandconditionsofhisorherprobationorconditionalrelease.
TIMEFRAMEProbablecausehearingwithin24hoursafterthechildistakenintocustody.§985.439(2).ViolationofProbationhearingmustbewithinthetimelimitssetoutin§985.255.
BURDENOFPROOFThepetitionermustprovetheallegationsoftheviolationofprobationpetitionfiledbytheJPO.Theburdenofproofisbyapreponderanceoftheevidence.
RULESOFEVIDENCEThecourtisnotrequiredtofollowthestrictrulesofevidenceandmayconsideraffidavitsandotherdocumentsasarerelevant,eventhoughthatevidencemaynotbeadmissibleinacriminaltrial.
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
155
156
VIOLATIONOFPROBATIONHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepurposeoftheviolationofprobationhearingisto
determinewhetherthechildhasviolatedthetermsandconditionsofhisorherprobationorconditionalrelease.
Ø Placethechildandanywitnessesunderoath.Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameand
permanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestthatDJJgiveathorough
descriptionofthestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thecourtshallappoint
counselunlesswaivedbythechild.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.Thiswaivershallbeinwriting.
Ø Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Ø Advisethechildofhisorherrighttoremainsilent,andthatanythingthechildsays
canbeusedagainsthimorher.
C. Violationofprobationdetermination
Ø Thecourtmustconsiderthepredispositionreportifonewasprepared.Ø Inadditiontothepredispositionreport,thecourtmustconsidertheunderlying
comprehensiveassessmentandrecordsofearlierjudicialproceedings.Ø Thecourtcanrequireadditionalassessmentsofthechild.Ø Thecourtcanwithholdadjudicationifthecourtfindsthatnoactionotherthan
supervisioninthechild’shomeisrequired.
157
Ø Ifthecourtfindsthechildviolatedprobation,thecourtshallenteranorderrevoking,modifying,orcontinuingprobationorpost-commitmentprobation.985.439(4).
D. Dispositiondetermination
Ø Statethefactualbasisforthedetermination.Tellthechildthereasonsforthedeterminationclearlyusinglanguagethechildcanunderstand.Verifythatthechildunderstandswhatthedeterminationmeans,whatwillbeexpectedofhimorher,andtheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequired.
Ø Childrencommittedtoaresidentialprogrammustbeplacedintosomeformofdetentioncarependingplacementintotheresidentialprogram.
E. Requirementsforwrittenorderofdisposition
Ø Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Statethedispositionofeachcountspecifyingthecharge,thedegreeofoffense,andthemaximumpenaltydefinedbystatute.
Ø Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
Ø Stategeneralandspecificconditionsorsanctions.Ø Makefindingsastothedispositionofthechild.Includethefactsunderlyingany
finding.Ø Statethedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountryandcourtwhereissued.Ø Besignedbythecourtwiththetitleofoffice.Ø Thechild’sfingerprintsmustbeaffixedtotheorderofdisposition.Ø Statetheperiodofthedisposition.Ø Statewhetherthecourtretainsjurisdictionoverdischarge.
158
VIOLATIONOFPROBATIONHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Aviolationofprobationhearingdetermineswhetherthechildhasviolatedthetermsandconditionsofhisorherprobationorconditionalrelease.Whenachildisallegedtohaveviolatedprobation,itisnecessarytodeterminewhetherthechildshouldbeheldindetentionpendingtheviolationhearing.Section985.255(1)(h)authorizesdetentionifachildisallegedtohaveviolatedtheconditionsofprobation.However,theformofdetentionthatmaybeimposedislimitedtoaconsequenceunit–asecurefacilitydesignatedbyDJJforthepurposesofdetainingchildrentakenintocustodyforviolatingtheirprobation.§985.439(2).Ifthechildhasnotallegedlycommittedanewdelinquentactaspartoftheviolationofprobationandifaconsequenceunitisnotavailable,thenthechildmustbedetainedintohomedetentionwithelectronicmonitoring.InR.A.P.v.CharlesParkins,SuperintendentoftheAlachuaRegionalJuvenileDetentionCenterandtheStateofFlorida,994So.2d414(Fla.1stDCA2008),theFirstDistrictCourtofAppealheldthatwhereneitheraconsequenceunitnorelectronicmonitoringforhomedetentionisavailablewithinthetrialcourt'sgeographicjurisdiction,onlyalessrestrictiveformofdetention,suchashomedetention,ispermissible.Ifanewcrimeisallegedastheviolationofprobation,detentionisgovernedby§985.245(4).AnRAIthatincludestheunderlying
159
offenseandthenewoffense(s)isscored.BaseduponthenewRAI,thechildmaybesubjecttomorerestrictivedetention.
4. IdentifyThosePresentIdentifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
5. NoticeAssessmentIftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Parentsorguardiansshouldbenotifiedofthehearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearchfollowingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.Thenonattendancebyaparentorguardianmayrequirethecontinuanceoftheviolationofprobationhearing.Ifthecourtordersthechildtopaymonetaryrestitution,itisdonethroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Additionally,thestatemayseekrestitutionorcommunityservicebythechild’sparents;aseparatepetitioncalleda“PetitionforParentalSanctions”mustbefiledwiththecourt,andtheparentsorguardiansmustbeserved.Rules8.030and8.031.Ifeitherofthesesituationshasoccurred,alackofserviceorafailuretoappearmaybegroundsforacontinuanceofthehearing,ifapartycanshowgoodcauseforthecontinuance.Rule8.100(e).
6. PlacetheChildandAnyWitnessesUnderOath
Thecourtshouldplacethechildandanywitnessesunderoath.Rule8.120(a)(5).Priortotheexaminationofanywitnesses,thecourtmayinvoketheruletohavethewitnessessequesteredtopreventcommunicationbetweenthewitnesses.Rule8.100(d).
7. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. AdviseofRights
1. RighttoCounsel
160
Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifchildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtshallmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthatifindigent,thechildhastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowingly,intelligentandvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freelyandintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freelyandintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
161
2. RighttoCommunicateUnlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
C. Violationofprobationdetermination
1. Thecourtshallaskthechildtoenteraplea.
2. IftheChildAdmitsIfthechildadmitstotheviolation,thecourtshallenteranorderrevoking,modifying,orcontinuingprobationorpostcommitmentprobation.§985.439(4).
3. IftheChildDeniesIfthechilddeniestheallegedviolation,thecourtshall,atthechild’srequest,appointcounseltorepresentthechild.§985.439(3).Thecourtshallsubsequentlyholdahearingtodeterminewhetherthechildviolatedprobation.Thehearingmayimmediatelyfollowtheprobablecausehearingormaybeheldatafuturedate.Ifthehearingisheldatafuturedateandthechildisincustodypendingthehearing,thedetentionmustcomportwiththecriteriasetoutin§§985.255and985.26.
4. RulesofEvidence
Attheviolationofprobationhearing,thecourtisnotrequiredtofollowthestrictrulesofevidenceandmayconsidersuchaffidavitsandotherdocumentsasarerelevant,eventhoughsuchevidencemaynotbeadmissibleinacriminaltrial.Wheelerv.State,344So.2d630(Fla.2dDCA1977).
162
5. BurdenofProofTheprosecutionmustprovebyapreponderanceoftheevidencethatthechildviolatedhisorherprobation.VanWagnerv.State,677So.2d314(Fla.1stDCA1996).
6. PossibleCourtActionsIfthecourtfindsthechildviolatedprobation,thecourtshallenteranorderrevoking,modifying,orcontinuingprobationorpostcommitmentprobation.Ineachsuchcase,thecourtshallenteranewdispositionorderand,inadditiontothesanctionsthecourtcouldhaveimposedattheoriginaldispositionhearing,thecourtmayimposeothersanctionsassetoutin§985.439(4).
D. Dispositiondetermination
Ajuvenileisnotentitledtocreditonprobationfortimespentindetention.However,onceaviolationofprobationisfiled,thechildisentitledtocreditfortimeservedbeforethefilingofthepetition.Davisv.State,667So.2d885(Fla.1stDCA1996).Additionally,uponrevocationofprobation,thetimeachildhasalreadyservedonprobationforagivenoffensemustbecreditedtowardanynewtermofprobationimposedforthatoffense,whennecessarytoensurethatthetotaltermofprobationdoesnotexceedthestatutorymaximumforthatoffense.Statev.Summers,642So.2d742(Fla.1994).
E. Requirementsforwrittenorder
1. Ifthecourtfindsthatthechildhasviolatedtheconditionsofprobationorpost-commitmentprobation,thecourtshallenteranewdispositionorder,andmayimposefurthersanctionsasnotedabove.ThenewdispositionordercanbefoundintheSupremeCourtapprovedforms,Form8.947.• Nameandaddress.Statethenameandaddressofthechildorifunknown,
designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.Rule8.115(d)(1).
• Ageandgender.Statetheageandsexofthechild.Iftheageisunknown,statethatthechildisbelievedtobeofanagethatmakeshimsubjecttothejuvenileproceedings.Rule8.115(d)(1).
• Dateandtime.Specifythedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountyandcourtwhereissued.Rule8.115(d)(5).
• WaiverofCounsel.Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,voluntary,andintelligent.
• Findingoffact.Makeallfindingsoffactrequiredbylaw.Rule8.115(d)(4).• Detentiondirections.Directthedetentionofthechildandstatethereasons
thereforor,ifappropriate,orderthereleaseofthechildandreturntotheirnonresidentialcommitmentprogram.Rule8.115(d)(3).
163
• Specifyoffenses.Ifthepetitionallegesmorethanoneoffense,oranoffensedividedintodegrees,thecourtshallspecifywhichoffenseoroffensesofwhichthechildhasbeenadjudicateddelinquent.Rule8.110(i).
• Disposition.Statethedispositionofeachcountspecifyingthechargetitle,thedegreeofoffense,andthemaximumpenaltydefinedbystatute.Rule8.115(d)(2)&(d)(3).
• Specialdisposition.Orderprobation,restitution,communityservice,curfew,and/orapologiesasappropriate.Ordernocontactwithvictims,ifappropriate.Rule8.115(d)(3).
• Determinationofgangmembership.Includeanydeterminationthatthechildwasamemberofastreetgang.§985.433(7).
• Releaseinstructions.Exceptasprovidedin§§790.22(8)or985.27,whenachildisplacedintosecureornonsecuredetentioncare,orintoarespitehomeorotherplacementpursuanttoacourtorderfollowingahearing,thecourtordermustincludespecificinstructionsthatdirectthereleaseofthechildfromsuchplacementnolaterthan5p.m.onthelastdayofthedetentionperiodspecifiedin§§985.26or985.27,whicheverisapplicable,unlesstherequirementsofsuchapplicableprovisionhavebeenmetoranorderofcontinuancehasbeengrantedunderFla.Stat.§985.26(4).
• Findingofcost.Thecourtmustmakeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare,ormakeafindingastoanyreductionorwaiverofcost,includingthereinthereasonsforsuchafinding.§985.039.Whenachildisplacedintononsecuredetention,probation,orothersupervisedstatuswiththeDJJ,orwhenachildiscommittedtoaminimum-risknon-residentialrestrictivenesslevel,ordertheparentorguardiantopayonedollar($1.00)perdaytotheDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(a).IfachildisplacedinsecuredetentionorplacedoncommittedstatusandtheDJJacquirestemporarylegalcustodyofsaidchild,ordertheparentorguardiantopayfivedollars($5.00)perdaytotheDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(b).IfthecourtfailstoincludeintheDetentionOrderinformationregardingcostofsupervisionandcare,theparentisdeemedtohaveanobligationtopayDJJonedollar($1.00)perdayforeachdaythechildisunderthesupervisionofDJJandfivedollars($5.00)perdayforeachdaythechildremainsinthecareofDJJ.§985.039(5).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoncosts.
Inadditiontotheaboverequirements,thecourtmay:• Placethechildinaconsequenceunitinthatjudicialcircuit,ifavailable,forup
to5daysforafirstviolationandupto15daysforasecondorsubsequentviolation;
• Placethechildonhomedetentionwithelectronicmonitoring.However,thissanctionmaybeusedonlyifaresidentialconsequenceunitisnotavailable;
• Placethechildinanalternativeconsequenceprogramdesignedtoprovide
164
swiftandappropriateconsequencestoanyfurtherviolationsofprobation,ifchildisnoncompliantwithtechnicalconditionsofhisorherprobationbuthasnotcommittedanynewviolationsoflaw;
• Modifyorcontinuethechild'sprobationprogramorpostcommitmentprobationprogram;or
• Revokeprobationorpostcommitmentprobationandcommitthechildtothedepartment.§985.439(4)(a)-(e).
Thecourtmayalsoorderthechildtosubmittorandomtestingforthepurposesofdetectingandmonitoringtheuseofalcoholorcontrolledsubstances.§985.439(5).Thechild’sfingerprintsshallbeaffixedtotheorderofdisposition.Rule8.115(e).
165
166
CONTEMPTOFCOURTHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;790.22;985.033;985.035;985.037;985.039;985.26;985.27RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560
RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.100;8.150;8.165;8.929RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARINGThepurposeofthecontemptofcourthearingistodeterminewhetherthechildhasviolatedthetermsandconditionsofacourtorder.
TIMEFRAME Thecontempthearingmustbeheldwithin24hoursofthechildbeingchargedwithindirectcontempt.
BURDENOFPROOF Presumedinnocentuntilprovenguiltybeyondareasonabledoubt.
RULESOFEVIDENCE Rulesofevidenceusedincriminalcases.
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
167
168
CONTEMPTOFCOURTHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepurposeoftheindirectcriminalcontemptofcourt
hearingistodeterminewhetherthechildhascommittedindirectcriminalcontemptofavalidcourtorder.
Ø Placethechildandanywitnessesunderoath.Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameand
permanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestthatDJJgiveathoroughdescription
ofthestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thecourtshallappoint
counselunlesswaivedbythechild.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.Thiswaivershallbeinwriting.
Ø Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Ø Advisethechildofhisorherrighttoremainsilent,andthatanythingthechildsays
canbeusedagainsthimorher.Ø Advisethechildofhisorherdueprocessrights.
C. Indirectcontempthearingprocedure
Ø IssueandsignanOrdertoShowCauseandspecifythetimeanddateofthecontempthearing.
Ø Ifthecourthasreasontobelievethatthechildwillnotappear,thecourtcanissueanorderofarrest.
Ø Arraignthechild.Askhimorhertoenterapleaofguilty,notguiltyornolo
169
contendere.Explainwhateachpleasignifies,andinformthechildheorshehastherighttorefrainfromenteringanyplea,inwhichcasethecourtwillenterapleaofnotguilty.Verifythechildunderstandstheimplicationsofthepleas.
Ø Conductthehearing,followingtherulesofevidenceusedincriminalcases.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepetitionermustprovethechargeofdelinquency
beyondareasonabledoubt-thatthechargemustbeproventotheextentthatthereisno"reasonabledoubt"inthemindofareasonablepersonthatthedefendantisguilty.
Ø Attheconclusionofthecase,signandenterajudgmentofguiltyornotguilty.Ø Pronouncethesentenceinopencourt.Explaintothechildthereasonsforthe
orderinclear,simplelanguage.
D. Sanctions
Ø Followthesanctionguidetodeterminewhichsanctionsareappropriate.Ø Explaintothechildwhatthesanctionsmean,whatwillbeexpectedofhimorher,
andtheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequiredinclear,simplelanguage.
E. Requirementsforwrittenjudgmentofcontempt
Ø Statethenameandaddressofthechildorifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
Ø Includearecitalofthefactsconstitutingthecontemptofwhichtheaccusedhasbeenfoundguilty.
Ø Statethesanctionsapplicableforthechild.Ø Makeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare.Ø Statethedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountryandcourtwhereissued.Ø Includeasignaturebythecourtwiththetitleofoffice.
170
CONTEMPTOFCOURTHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. DirectContemptofCourt
Acontemptofcourtmaybepunishedsummarilyifthecourtsaworheardtheconductconstitutingthecontemptcommittedintheactualpresenceofthecourt.Rule8.150(a).Ifthecourtwitnessesthecontemptuousconduct,thecourtmayissueajudgmentofcontempt,includingarecitalofthefactsuponwhichtheadjudicationofguiltisbased.Rule8.150(a).Priortoadjudication,thecourtshallinformthechildoftheaccusationandinquireastowhetherthechildcanshowcauseastowhyheorsheshouldbenotbeadjudicatedguilty,givingthechildtimetopresentevidenceofexcusingormitigatingcircumstances.Rule8.150(a).
3. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
4. Purpose
Anindirectcontemptofcourthearingdetermineswhetherthechildhasbreachedorviolatedavalidcourtorder.
5. IdentifyThosePresentIdentifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublic
171
unlessthecourtthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
6. NoticeAssessmentIftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Parentsorguardiansshouldbenotifiedofthehearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearchfollowingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.Thenonattendancebyaparentorguardianmayrequirethecontinuanceofthecontempthearing.Ifthecourtordersthechildtopaymonetaryrestitution,itisdonethroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Additionally,thestatemayseekrestitutionorcommunityservicebythechild’sparents;aseparatepetitioncalleda“PetitionforParentalSanctions”mustbefiledwiththecourt,andtheparentsorguardiansmustbeserved.Rules8.030and8.031.Ifeitherofthesesituationshasoccurred,alackofserviceorafailuretoappearmaybegroundsforacontinuanceofthehearing,ifapartycanshowgoodcauseforthecontinuance.Rule8.100(e).
7. PlacetheChildandAnyWitnessesUnderOathThecourtshouldplacethechildandanywitnessesunderoath.Rule8.150(b)(4).Priortotheexaminationofanywitnesses,anypartymayinvoketheruletohavethewitnessessequesteredtopreventcommunicationbetweenthewitnesses.Rule8.100(d).
8. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. AdviseofRights
1. RighttoCounselDeterminewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifchildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybe
172
acceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtmustmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).
Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthat,ifindigent,heorshehastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowingly,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
2. RighttoCommunicate
Unlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;
173
• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttimetoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
3. DueProcessRights
Advisethechildofhisorherdueprocessrights.Thefollowingdueprocessrightsmustbeprovidedtothechild:• Therighttoacopyoftheordertoshowcauseallegingfactssupportingthe
contemptcharge.• Therighttoanexplanationofthenatureandtheconsequencesofthe
proceedings.• Therighttolegalcounselandtherighttohavelegalcounselappointedby
thecourtifthejuvenileisindigent,under§985.033.• Therighttoconfrontwitnesses.• Therighttopresentwitnesses.• Therighttohaveatranscriptorrecordoftheproceeding.• Therighttoappealtoanappropriatecourt.§985.037(4)(b)(1)-(7).
Thetranscriptorrecording,ifrequestedbyamotiontothecourt,ispaidforbythestate.
C. Indirectcontempthearingprocedure
1. IssueanOrdertoShowCauseThismaybedoneonthecourt’sownmotionoruponaffidavitofanypersonhavingknowledgeofthefacts.Rule8.150(b)(1).Theordershallspecifythetimeandplaceofthehearing,withreasonabletimeallowedforthepreparationofadefenseafterserviceoftheorderontheaccused,Rule8.150(b)(1),butthehearingmusttakeplacewithin24hoursofthechildbeingcharged.§985.037(4)(b).Thechildmaymovetodismisstheorder,moveforastatementofparticulars,oranswer.Rule8.150(b)(2).Allmotionsandanswersshallbeinwritingunlessotherwisespecifiedbythecourt.Rule8.150(b)(2).Anyfailuretoanswerorrespondshallnotbedeemedanadmissionofguilt.Rule8.150(b)(2).
2. IssueOrderofArrest
Ifthecourthasreasontobelievethatthechildwillnotappear,thecourtcanissueanorderofarrest.Thechildmustbeadmittedtobailinthemannerprovidedbylawincriminalcases.Rule8.150(b)(3).
174
3. ArraignthechildThechildmaybearraignedatthecontempthearingorpriortothehearinguponrequest.Rule8.150(b)(4).
4. IftheChildPleadsGuilty
Ifthechildpleadsguilty,thecourtmustissueajudgmentofguiltyandsentencethechild.
5. IftheChildPleadsNotGuilty
Ifthechildpleadsnotguilty,thecourtwillconductahearing,followingtherulesofevidenceusedincriminalcases.Thecourtmayconductthehearingwithoutassistanceofcounsel,ormaybeassistedbystateattorneyoranotherattorneyappointedforthatpurpose.Rule8.150(b)(4).Thechildisentitledto:• Representationbycounsel;• Compulsoryprocessfortheattendanceofwitnesses;and• Theoptionoftestifyinginhisorherowndefense.Rule8.150(b)(4).
6. BurdenofProof
Theburdenofproofinindirectcontempthearingsisthesameasforcriminalcases;thestatemustprovethechild’sguiltbeyondareasonabledoubt.Forbesv.State,933So.2d706(Fla.4thDCA2006).
7. JudgmentandPronouncementofSentence
Attheconclusionofthecase,signandenterajudgmentofguiltyornotguilty.Includeinthejudgmentarecitalofthefactsconstitutingthecontemptofwhichtheaccusedhasbeenfoundguilty.Rule8.150(b)(6).Pronouncethesentenceinopencourt,inthepresenceofthechild.Rule8.150(b)(7).Priortothepronouncement,informthechildoftheaccusationandjudgmentagainsthimorherandinquireastowhetherthereisanycausetoshowwhythesentenceshouldnotbepronounced.Rule8.150(b)(7).Allowthechildanopportunitytopresentmitigatingcircumstances.Rule8.150(b)(7).
D. Sanctions
1. MandatorySanctionsUpondeterminingachildhascommittedindirectcontemptofcourt,thecourtmustorderthechildtoperform50hoursofcommunity-servicemanuallabororasimilaralternativesanction,unlessanalternativesanctionisunavailableorinappropriate,orunlessthechildhasfailedtocomplywithaprioralternativesanction.§985.037(3).Thecourtmayrequestthealternativesanctionscoordinatortorecommendthemostappropriateavailablealternativesanction.§985.037(3).
175
2. IfnoAlternativeSanctionsIfalternativesanctionsareunavailableorinappropriate,orifthechildhasalreadybeenorderedtoserveanalternativesanctionbutfailedtocomplywiththesanction,thecourtmayorderthechildtobeplacedinasecurefacilityforpurposesofpunishmentforcontemptofcourt.§985.037(2).Thecourtisencouragedtoorderthechildtoperformcommunityservicewhereappropriatebeforeorderingthatthechildbeplacedinasecurefacilityaspunishmentforcontemptofcourt.§985.037(4)(c).Adelinquentchildwhohasbeenheldindirectorindirectcontemptmaybeplacedinasecuredetentionfacilitynottoexceed:• 5daysforafirstoffense;and• 15daysforasecondorsubsequentoffense.§985.037(2).
Thecourtshallreviewtheplacementofthechildonlyuponmotionbythedefenseattorneyorstateattorneytodeterminewhetheritisappropriateforthechildtoremaininthefacility.§985.037(4)(b).
3. DiscretionarySanctionInadditiontoanysanctionimposedunderthissection,thecourtmaydirecttheDepartmentofHighwaySafetyandMotorVehiclestowithholdissuanceof,orsuspend,achild’sdriver’slicenseordrivingprivilege.§985.037(4)(d).Thecourtmayorderthechild’sdriver’slicenseordrivingprivilegebewithheldorsuspendedforupto:• Oneyearforafirstoffense;and• 2yearsforasecondorsubsequentoffense.§985.037(4)(d).
Ifthechild’sdriver’slicenseordrivingprivilegeisbeingwithheldorsuspendedatthetimethesanctionforcontemptisimposed,theperiodofsuspensionorrevocationshallbeginonthedateonwhichthechildisotherwiseeligibletodrive.§985.037(4)(d).
E. Requirementsforawrittenjudgmentofcontempt
1. Attheconclusionofthehearing,thecourtshallenterandrecordajudgmentofguiltyornotguilty.Rule8.150(b)(6).Thejudgmentshallbeinwritingandincludethefollowing:• Nameandaddress.Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,
designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
• Ageandgender.Statetheageandsexofthechild.Iftheageisunknown,statethatthechildisbelievedtobeofanagethatmakeshimorhersubjecttothejuvenileproceedings.
• Dateandtime.Statethedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountryandcourtwhereissued.
176
• WaiverofCounsel.Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,voluntary,andintelligent.
• Recitationoffacts.Includearecitalofthefactsconstitutingthecontemptofwhichtheaccusedhasbeenfoundguilty.
• Applicablesanctions.Statethesanctionsapplicabletothechild.• Releaseinstructions.Exceptasprovidedin§§790.22(8)or985.27,whena
childisplacedintosecureornonsecuredetentioncare,orintoarespitehomeorotherplacementpursuanttoacourtorderfollowingahearing,thecourtordermustincludespecificinstructionsthatdirectthereleaseofthechildfromsuchplacementnolaterthan5:00p.m.onthelastdayofthedetentionperiodspecifiedin§§985.26or985.27,whicheverisapplicable,unlesstherequirementsofsuchapplicableprovisionhavebeenmetoranorderofcontinuancehasbeengrantedunder§985.26(4).
• Findingofcost.Thecourtmustmakeafindingregardingcostorsupervisionandcare,ormakeafindingastoanyreductionorwaiverofcost,includingthereinthereasonsforsuchafinding.§985.039.Whenachildisplacedintononsecuredetention,probation,orothersupervisedstatuswithDJJ,orwhenachildiscommittedtoaminimum-risknon-residentialrestrictivenesslevel,ordertheparentorguardiantopayonedollar($1.00)perdaytoDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(a).IfachildisplacedinsecuredetentionorplacedoncommittedstatusandDJJacquirestemporarylegalcustodyofsaidchild,ordertheparentorguardiantopayfivedollars($5.00)perdaytoDJJforeachdaythechildisinthatstatus.§985.039(1)(b).IfthecourtfailstoincludeintheDetentionOrderinformationregardingcostofsupervisionandcare,theparentisdeemedtohaveanobligationtopayDJJonedollar($1.00)perdayforeachdaythechildisunderthesupervisionofDJJandfivedollars($5.00)perdayforeachdaythechildremainsinthecareofDJJ.§985.039(5).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoncosts.
177
178
WAIVEROFJURISDICTIONHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;985.033;985.035;985.319;985.55;985.556;985.557;985.57RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.100;8.105;8.160;8.165;8.929RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtinterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARINGThepurposeofthewaiverofjurisdictionhearingistodeterminewhetherthechildshouldremainunderthejuvenilecourt’sjurisdictionorbetransferredtoanothercourt.
TIMEFRAME
Thehearingmustbeheldwithin7days(excludingSaturdays,Sundaysandlegalholidays)afterthedateofthepetitionallegingthatthechildhascommittedadelinquentactorviolationofthelawhasbeenfiled,orlaterwithapprovalfromthecourt.
RULESOFEVIDENCE Section985.556specifieswhatthecourtshallconsider.
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
179
180
WAIVEROFJURISDICTIONHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepurposeofthewaiverofjurisdictionhearingisto
determinewhetherthechildshouldbetransferredtothejurisdictionofanothercourt.
Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameandpermanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestthatDJJgiveathoroughdescription
ofthestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thecourtshallappoint
counselunlesswaivedbythechild.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.Thiswaivershallbeinwriting.
Ø Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Ø Advisethechildofhisorherrighttoremainsilent,andthatanythingthechildsays
canbeusedagainsthimorher.
C. Determinethetypeofwaiver
D. Issueasummons
E. Considerevidencepresented
Ø Priortothehearing,anauthorizedagentofthedepartmentshallprepareastudyandreportrelevanttotheissueofjurisdiction.
Ø Thechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansandcounselshallhavetherightto
181
examinethesereportsandquestionthepartiesresponsibleforthem.Verifythatthechildunderstandshowheorshecanactonthisright.
F. Jurisdictiondetermination
Ø Explainthedeterminationtothechildinclear,simplelanguage.Verifythatthechildunderstandswhatwillhappennextandwhatwillbeexpectedofhimorherandtheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequired.
G. Requirementsforwrittenorderonwaiverofjurisdiction
Ø Statethenameandaddressofthechildorifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
Ø Includespecificfindingsoffactwithrespecttoandinconsiderationofthecriteriain§985.556(c).
Ø Includethereasonstoimposeadultsanctions.Ø Statethedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountryandcourtwhereissued.Ø Signtheorderbythecourtwiththetitleofoffice.
182
WAIVEROFJURISDICTIONHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Awaiverofjurisdictionhearingdetermineswhetherthechildshouldbetransferredtothejurisdictionofanothercourt.Achildcanbetriedcriminallyasanadultifjuvenilejurisdictioniswaivedbythecircuitcourt;orthecaseistransferredtocriminalcourtbecauseofadirectfilingorindictment.Rule8.105;§§985.556&985.57.
4. IdentifythosepresentIdentifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
5. NoticeAssessmentIftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Parentsorguardiansshouldbenotifiedofthehearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearchfollowingadetailedandthoroughlist
183
ofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.
6. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. AdviseofRights
1. RighttoCounselDeterminewhetherthechildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtshallmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthat,ifindigent,thechildhastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowingly,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,the
184
offerofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
2. RighttoCommunicate
Unlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
C. Determinethetypeofwaiver
1. VoluntaryWaiverAwaiverisvoluntaryifthechilddemandsinwritingtobetriedasanadult.Thecircuitcourtmusttransferandcertifythechild’scasefortrialasanadult.Thedemandmustbemadepriortothecommencementofanadjudicatoryhearingandmustbejoinedbyaparentor,intheabsenceofaparent,theguardianorguardianadlitem.§985.556(1).
2. DiscretionaryInvoluntaryWaiver
Awaiverisinvoluntaryanddiscretionaryifthechildwas14yearsoldatthetimeoftheallegedact.Thestateattorneyhasthediscretiontofileamotionrequestingthecourttowaivejurisdictionandtransferandcertifyachild’scasefortrialasanadult.§985.556(2).
3. MandatoryInvoluntaryWaiver
Awaiverisinvoluntaryandmandatoryifthechildwas14yearsoldatthetimeoftheallegedact,andif:
185
• ifthechildhasbeenpreviouslyadjudicateddelinquentforanactclassifiedasafelony,whichadjudicationwasforthecommissionof,attempttocommit,orconspiracytocommitmurder,sexualbattery,armedorstrong-armedrobbery,carjacking,home-invasionrobbery,aggravatedbattery,aggravatedassault,orburglarywithanassaultorbattery,andthechildiscurrentlychargedwithasecondorsubsequentviolentcrimeagainstaperson;or
• Ifthechildwas14yearsofageorolderatthetimeofcommissionofafourthorsubsequentallegedfelonyoffenseandthechildwaspreviouslyadjudicateddelinquentorhadadjudicationwithheldfor,orwasfoundtohavecommitted,ortohaveattemptedorconspiredtocommit,threeoffensesthatarefelonyoffensesifcommittedbyanadult,andoneormoreofsuchfelonyoffensesinvolvedtheuseorpossessionofafirearmorviolenceagainstaperson.§985.556(3).
Thestateattorneymustrequestthecourttotransferthechildtoanadultcourtorshallprovidewrittenreasonstothecourtfornotmakingsucharequest,orproceedunder§985.557(1).
D. IssueaSummons
Thesummonsmustbeissuedandservedinconformitywith§985.319.Verifythatacopyofthemotionandacopyofthedelinquencypetition,ifnotalreadyserved,areattachedtoeachsummons.§985.556(4)(b).
E. Considertheevidencepresented
1. StudyandReportbyDJJ
Priortothehearing,astudyandreportmustbemadebyanauthorizedagentoftheDJJ.§985.556(4)(d).Thisreportandstudywillanalyzefactorsthatassistthecourtinmakingthedetermination,including:• Theseriousnessoftheallegedoffensetothecommunityandwhetherthe
protectionofthecommunityisbestservedbytransferringthechildforadultsanctions.
• Whethertheallegedoffensewascommittedinanaggressive,violent,premeditated,orwillfulmanner.
• Whethertheallegedoffensewasagainstpersonsoragainstproperty,greaterweightbeinggiventooffensesagainstpersons,especiallyifpersonalinjuryresulted.
• Theprobablecauseasfoundinthereport,affidavit,orcomplaint.• Thedesirabilityoftrialanddispositionoftheentireoffenseinonecourt
whenthechild'sassociatesintheallegedcrimeareadultsorchildrenwhoaretobetriedasadults.
• Thesophisticationandmaturityofthechild.
186
• Therecordandprevioushistoryofthechild,including:o Previouscontactswiththedepartment,theDepartmentofCorrections,
theformerDepartmentofHealthandRehabilitativeServices,theDepartmentofChildrenandFamilyServices,otherlawenforcementagencies,andcourts;
o Priorperiodsofprobation;o Prioradjudicationsthatthechildcommittedadelinquentactorviolation
oflaw,greaterweightbeinggivenifthechildhaspreviouslybeenfoundbyacourttohavecommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflawinvolvinganoffenseclassifiedasafelonyorhastwicepreviouslybeenfoundtohavecommittedadelinquentactorviolationoflawinvolvinganoffenseclassifiedasamisdemeanor;and
o Priorcommitmentstoinstitutions.• Theprospectsforadequateprotectionofthepublicandthelikelihoodof
reasonablerehabilitationofthechild,ifthechildisfoundtohavecommittedtheallegedoffense,bytheuseofprocedures,services,andfacilitiescurrentlyavailabletothecourt.§985.556(4)(c)(1)-(8).
2. Child’sRighttoExamine
Thechildandthechild'sparentsorlegalguardiansandcounselandthestateattorneyshallhavetherighttoexaminethesereportsandtoquestionthepartiesresponsibleforthematthehearing.§985.556(4)(d).
3. AdditionalMaterialsAvailable
Thecourtshallconsiderthestudyandreport,aswellasotherevidenceandtestimonyoffered,whenmakingitsdetermination.
F. Jurisdictiondetermination
1. OrderWaivingJurisdictionThecourtmayenteranorderwaivingjurisdictionandcertifyingthecasefortrialasifthechildwereanadult.Rule8.105(b)(5)(A).Theordermustsetforththebasisforthedecision.Rule8.105(b)(5)(A).Providecopiestoalltheparties,andprovideacertifiedcopytotheclerkofthecourthavingjurisdictiontotrythechildasanadultandtotheprosecutingofficerofsaidcourtwithin5daysofthedateoftheorder.Rule8.105(b)(5)(A).Thechildistobeimmediatelydeliveredtothesheriffofthecountyinwhichtheadultcourtislocated.Rule8.105(b)(5)(A).
2. OrderDenyingWaiverofJurisdiction
Thecourtmayenteranorderdenyingthewaiverofjurisdiction,andgivereasonsforthisdenial.Rule8.105(b)(5)(B).Ifthewaiverisdenied,thecourt,withtheconsentofthestateandthechild,mayproceedimmediatelywiththeadjudicatoryhearing.Rule8.105(b)(5)(B).
187
G. Requirementsforawrittenorderonwaiverofjurisdiction
1. Nameandaddress.Statethenameandaddressofthechildorifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
2. Ageandgender.Statetheageandsexofthechild.Iftheageisunknown,statethatthechildisbelievedtobeofanagethatmakeshimsubjecttothejuvenileproceedings.
3. Dateandtime.Statethedateandtimetheorderisissued,thecountyandcourtfromwhereissuedandthedateandtimethechildwastakenintocustody.
4. Waiverofcounsel.Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
5. Recitationoffacts.Includespecificfindingsoffactwithrespecttoandinconsiderationofthecriteriain§985.556(c).
6. Rationale.Includethereasonstoimposeadultsanctions.
188
189
RESTITUTIONHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;775.089;90.6063;985.0301;985.033;985.035RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.100;8.165,8.929RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARING
Thepurposeoftherestitutionhearingistosetrestitutionamountifnotdeterminedatdisposition,todeterminewhetherthechildorthechild’sparentsorguardiansarecurrentwithrestitutionpayments,ortoorderthepaymentstobeginifpayorfailedtomakepaymentsasordered.
BURDENOFPROOF Anydisputeastotheproperamountortypeofrestitutionshallberesolvedbythecourtbythepreponderanceoftheevidence.
RULESOFEVIDENCE Rulesofevidenceusedincivilcases.
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
190
191
RESTITUTIONHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepurposeoftherestitutionhearingistosetrestitution
amountifnotdeterminedatdisposition,todeterminewhetherthechildorthechild’sparentsorguardiansarecurrentwithrestitutionpayments,ortoorderthepaymentstobeginifpayorfailedtomakepaymentsasordered.
Ø Placethechildandanywitnessesunderoath.Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameand
permanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestthatDJJgiveathoroughdescription
ofthestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Thechildhasarighttobepresentatanyrestitutionhearing.Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifinsolvent,advisethechildthatheorshehastherighttohavecounsel
appointed.Ø Ifthechilddoesnothavecounsel,appointcounselasnecessaryunlesswaivedin
writing.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.
Ø Ifthechildwaivescounsel,determineifthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
C. Hearingprocedure
Ø Ifthechildadjudicateddelinquentandthestateattorneycouldnotagreetoarestitutionamountatdisposition,thehearingwillbetodeterminetheamountofrestitutiondueandpaymentprocess.
Ø Iftherestitutionamountissetandthechildadjudicateddelinquentischallenging
192
theamount,thehearingwillbetoreviewtheamountofrestitutiondueandmodifyasnecessary.
Ø Iftherestitutionamountissetandthestateattorneyrequestedthehearingtoreviewcompliance,thehearingwillbetoverifycomplianceandenforcetheorderinthesamemannerasajudgmentinacivilaction.
D. Restitutiondetermination
Ø Explaintothechildwhatthedeterminationmeansandhowthecourtarrivedatthatdeterminationinclear,simplelanguage.
Ø Onanyfindingthatrestitutionisdue,verifythatthechildknowswhatisrequiredofhimorher,andtheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequired.
E. Requirementsforawrittenorderofrestitution
Ø Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Statethenameandaddressoftheparentorguardianor,ifunknown,designatetheparentorguardianbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifytheparentorguardianwithreasonablecertainty.
Ø Statethenameandaddressofthepayee.Ø Statethecasenumber.Ø Statethedate.Ø Statetheamountpaid.Ø Statetheamountdue.Ø Listanyotherfeesdue.
193
RESTITUTIONHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Thepurposeoftherestitutionhearingistosetrestitutionamountifnotdeterminedatdisposition,todeterminewhetherthechildorthechild’sparentsorguardiansarecurrentwithrestitutionpayments,ortoorderthepaymentstobeginifpayorfailedtomakepaymentsasordered.Itcanbeinitiatedattherequestofthepayororthestateattorney.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonrestitution.
4. IdentifyThosePresent
Identifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
5. NoticeAssessmentIftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Parentsorguardiansshouldbenotifiedofthehearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsor
194
guardiansmustperformadiligentsearchfollowingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.Thenonattendancebyaparentorguardianmayrequirethecontinuanceoftherestitutionhearing.Ifthecourtordersthechildtopaymonetaryrestitution,itisdonethroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Additionally,thestatemayseekrestitutionorcommunityservicebythechild’sparents;aseparatepetitioncalleda“PetitionforParentalSanctions”mustbefiledwiththecourt,andtheparentsorguardiansmustbeserved.Rules8.030and8.031.Ifeitherofthesesituationshasoccurred,alackofserviceorafailuretoappearmaybegroundsforacontinuanceofthehearing,ifapartycanshowgoodcauseforthecontinuance.Rule8.100(e).
6. PlacetheChildandAnyWitnessesUnderOath
Thecourtshouldplacethechildandanywitnessesunderoath.Priortotheexaminationofanywitnesses,anypartymayinvoketheruletohavethewitnessessequesteredtopreventcommunicationbetweenthewitnesses.Rule8.100(c).
7. OtherProceedingsDeterminationDeterminewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
1. RighttobePresentThechildhasarighttobepresentatanyrestitutionhearing.T.L.v.State,967So.2d421(Fla.1stDCA2007).
2. RighttoCounsel
Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifchildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).
195
Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtmustmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthat,ifindigent,thechildhastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
3. RighttoCommunicateUnlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
196
Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
C. HearingProcedure
Therestitutionreviewhearingcanberequestedbythestateattorneyorthechildadjudicateddelinquent.1. RulesofEvidence
Anydisputeastotheproperamountortypeofrestitutionshallusetherulesofevidenceusedincivilcases,andshallberesolvedbythecourtbythepreponderanceoftheevidence.§775.089(7).
2. WhenRestitutionAmountisinDispute
Ifthechildadjudicateddelinquentandthestateattorneycouldnotagreetoarestitutionamountatdisposition,thehearingwillbetodeterminetheamountofrestitutiondueandpaymentprocess.Theburdenofdemonstratingtheamountofthelosssustainedbyavictimasaresultoftheoffenseisonthestateattorney.§775.089(7).• Whensettingtheamountofrestitution,considerthefairmarketvalueof
theitemsthevictimaskedrestitutionfor,andoffsetanysalvagevalueiftheitemsarereturned.G.M.H.v.State,18So.3d728(Fla.2dDCA2009).Fairmarketvaluecanbedeterminedbylookingat:
o originalmarketcost;o mannerinwhichtheitemwasused;o thegeneralconditionandqualityoftheitem;ando thepercentageofdepreciation.K.W.v.State,983So.2d713(Fla.2d
DCA2008)• However,thatalthoughfairmarketvaluationisthecommonapproachto
determinerestitution,itisnottheonlypermissibleapproach.Courtmaybaserestitutionawardsonout-of-pocketcosts,offsettingtheawardbythesalvagevalueofanyitemsreturned.C.M.S.v.State,997So.2d520(Fla.2dDCA2008).
• Restitutionmaynotbeorderedforitemsnotreferencedinthechargingdocument.G.P.v.State,996So.2d920(Fla.4thDCA2008).
3. WhereChildisChallengingRestitutionAmount
Iftherestitutionamountissetandthechildadjudicateddelinquentischallengingtheamount,thehearingwillbetoreviewtheamountofrestitutiondueandmodifyasnecessary.Theburdenofdemonstratingtheamountofthelosssustainedbyavictimasaresultoftheoffenseisagainonthestateattorney.§775.089(7).Incalculatingvalueoftheitems,thecourtmayusethefairmarketvaluationmethodaboveoranotheracceptablemethodatitsdiscretion.
197
4. WherethereisNoncompliancewithaValidRestitutionOrder
Iftherestitutionamountissetandthestateattorneyrequestedthehearingtoreviewcompliance,thehearingwillbetoverifycomplianceandenforcetheorderinthesamemannerasajudgmentinacivilaction.Theburdenofdemonstratingthepresentfinancialresources,theabsenceofpotentialfuturefinancialresources,andthefinancialneedsofthepayorisonthepayor.§775.089(7).Remindthepayorthatthejuvenilecourtmayretainjurisdictionoverthechildorchild’sparentorguardianuntiltherestitutionorderissatisfied.§985.0301(5)(i).
D. Restitutiondetermination
Explaintothechildwhatthedeterminationmeansandhowthecourtarrivedatthatdeterminationinclear,simplelanguage.Onanyfindingthatrestitutionisdue,verifythatthechildknowswhatisrequiredofhimorher,andtheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequired.Wherethecourtordersrestitution,thecourtmaybeininstallmentsormaybeinlumpsumimmediately.§775.089(3)(a)&(c).Wheretheorderissilentastothemannerofpaymentofrestitution,restitutionmustbemadeimmediately.§775.089(3)(d).Thecourtmayordertheclerkofthecourttocollectanddispenserestitutionpayments.§775.089(11)(a).
E. Requirementsforawrittenorderofrestitution
1. Thecontentsoftherestitutionarelimitedby§985.0301(5)(i).Therestitutionordershallinclude:• Nameandaddressofchild.Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,if
unknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
• Nameandaddressofparentsorguardians.Statethenameandaddressoftheparentorguardianor,ifunknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
• Nameandaddressofpayee.Statethenameandaddressofthepayee.• Casenumber.Statethecasenumber.• Dateandamount.Statethedateandamountofrestitutionordered.• Amountpaid.Statetheamount,ifany,ofrestitutionpaidtodate.• Amountdue.Statetheamountofrestitutiondueandowing.• Otherfeesdue.Statethatcosts,interest,penalties,andattorney’sfeesmay
alsobedueandowing.
198
2. TermsSubjectto§775.089(5)
Notethatthetermsoftherestitutionorderaresubjectto§775.089(5),whichdiscussesenforcementofarestitutionorder.Restitutionorderscanbeenforcedinthesamemannerasajudgmentinacivilaction.Theoutstandingrestitutionbearsinterestand,whenproperlyrecorded,becomesalienonanyrealestateownedbythechildorthechild’sparentorguardian.Ifcivilenforcementisnecessary,thechildorchild’sparentorguardianisresponsibleforcostsandattorney'sfeesincurredbythevictiminenforcingtheorder.
199
200
CORRECTIONOFORDERSHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;985.033;985.035
RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.100;8.135;8.165;8.929RulesofAppellateProcedure9.110;9.140;9.145RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARINGThepurposeofthecorrectionofordershearingistodeterminewhetherthecourthasmadeanerrorinthedispositionorcommitmentorderthatmustbecorrected.
RULESOFEVIDENCE Thesamerulesofevidenceusedinevidentiaryhearings.
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
201
202
CORRECTIONOFORDERSHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explainthepurposeofthecorrectionofordershearing.Letthechildknowthat
thepurposeofthehearingistodeterminewhetherthecourthasmadeanerrorinthedispositionorcommitmentorderthatmustbecorrected.
Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameandpermanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestthatDJJgiveathoroughdescription
ofthestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifinsolvent,advisethechildthatheorshehastherighttohavecounsel
appointed.Ø Ifthechilddoesnothavecounsel,appointcounselasnecessaryunlesswaivedin
writing.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.
Ø Ifthechildwaivescounsel,determineifthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
C. Correctionhearingprocedure
Ø Oncethecourtreceivesamotionforcorrection,thecourtmustdeterminewhetheritcanresolvethemotionasamatteroflawwithoutahearing.
Ø Ifahearingisnecessary,thecourtwillhavetendaysfromthefilingtoholdaninitialhearing,withnoticetoallparties.
Ø Thecourtisrequiredtofileanorderrulingonthemotionwithin30daysofthedateoftheinitialfiling.
203
D. Correctiondetermination
Ø Thecourtshouldexaminetherecordsofthehearingthatprovidethebasisfortheorderinquestionanddeterminewhethertherewasanerrorintheorder.
Ø Explaintothechildwhatthedeterminationmeansandhowthecourtarrivedatthatdeterminationinclear,simplelanguage.Verifythatthechildknowswhatisrequiredofhimorher,andtheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequired.
E. Requirementsforacorrecteddispositionorder
Ø Clearlymarkthattheorderisanamendedorder.Ø Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,designatethechildbya
nameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.Ø Statethedispositionofeachcountspecifyingthecharge,thedegreeofoffense,
andthemaximumpenaltydefinedbystatute.Ø Ifcounselwaived,makefindingthatthewaiverwasknowing,intelligent,and
voluntary.Ø Stategeneralandspecificconditionsorsanctions.Ø Makefindingsastothedispositionofthechild.Ø Statethedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountryandcourtwhereissued.Ø Thechild’sfingerprintsmustbeaffixedtotheorderofdisposition.Ø Statetheperiodofthedisposition.Ø Statewhetherthecourtretainsjurisdictionoverdischarge.
204
CORRECTIONOFORDERSHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Thepurposeofthecorrectionhearingistodeterminewhetherthecourthasmadeanerrorinthedispositionorcommitmentorderthatmustbecorrected.
4. IdentifyThosePresent
Identifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
5. NoticeAssessmentIftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Parentsorguardiansshouldbenotifiedofthehearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearchfollowingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.
205
Thenonattendancebyaparentorguardianmayrequirethecontinuanceofthecorrectionhearing.Ifthecourtordersthechildtopaymonetaryrestitution,itisdonethroughapromissorynotecosignedbytheparentsorguardians.§985.437(2).Additionally,thestatemayseekrestitutionorcommunityservicebythechild’sparents;aseparatepetitioncalleda“PetitionforParentalSanctions”mustbefiledwiththecourt,andtheparentsorguardiansmustbeserved.Rules8.030and8.031.Ifeitherofthesesituationshasoccurred,alackofserviceorafailuretoappearmaybegroundsforacontinuanceofthehearing,ifapartycanshowgoodcauseforthecontinuance.Rule8.100(e).
6. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
1. RighttoCounselDeterminewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifchildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtmustmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthat,ifindigent,heorshehastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselat
206
allstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-clientrelationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
2. RighttoCommunicate
Unlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
C. Correctionhearingprocedure
1. MotionbeforeappealIftheState,child,orDJJfilesamotiontocorrectanorder,themotionmustbefiledwithinthetimeframespecifiedintheRulesofAppellateProcedure.Rule8.135(b)(1).Thechildmustfilewithin30daysofrenditionofthewrittendispositionorderorcommitmentorder.Rule9.140(b)(1)(B).TheStatemustfilewithin15daysofrenditionofthewrittenordertobereviewed.Rule9.140(c)(3).IftheStateisfilingamotiontocorrectapre-adjudicationorder,thenoticeofappealmustbefiledwithin15daysoftherenditionoftheorderandmustbebeforecommencementoftheadjudicatoryhearing.Rule9.145(c)(2).
207
2. MotionpendingappealTheStateorchildmayfileamotiontocorrectwhileanappealispendingifitisdonebeforetheparty’sfirstbriefisserved.Rule8.135(b)(2).Unlessthemotionexplicitlystatesotherwise,trialcounselwillrepresentthemovingparty.Rule8.135(b)(2)(A).IftheStateisthemovingparty,thechildwillberepresentedbythetrialcounselunlessthecourtisotherwisenotified.Rule8.135(b)(2)(A).TheStatemayfileonlyifthecorrectionoftheerrorwouldbenefitthechildortocorrectascrivener’serror.Rule8.135(b).InJ.D.v.State,849So.2d458(Fla.4thDCA2003),thecourtindicatedthatascrivener’serrorreferredto,“clericalorministerialerrorsinacriminalcasethatoccurinthewrittensentence,judgment,ororderofprobationorrestitution.”
3. DeterminewhetherHearingisNecessary;HearingTimeframe
Oncethecourtreceivesamotionforcorrection,thecourtmustdeterminewhetheritcanresolvethemotionasamatteroflawwithoutahearing.Rule8.135(b)(1)(B).Ifahearingisnecessary,thecourtwillhave10daysfromtheinitialfilingtoholdaninitialhearing,withnoticetoallparties.Rule8.135(b)(1)(B).Thecourtisrequiredtofileanorderrulingonthemotionwithin30daysfromthedateoftheinitialfiling.Rule8.135(b)(1)(B).Themotionwillbedeemeddeniedifnoorderisfiledwithin30days.Rule8.135(b)(1)(B).
D. Correctiondetermination
Thecourtshouldexaminetherecordsofthehearingthatprovidethebasisfortheorderinquestion.Comparethehearingrecordswiththewrittenorder,taketestimonyasnecessary,anddeterminewhethertherewasanyerror.Explaintothechildwhatthedeterminationmeansandhowthecourtarrivedatthatdeterminationinclear,simplelanguage.Verifythatthechildknowswhatisrequiredofhimorher,andtheconsequencesoffailingtoactasrequired.
E. Requirementsforacorrectedorder
1. Thecourtisrequiredtofileawrittenorderrulingonthemotionwithin30daysfromthedateoftheinitialfiling.Rule8.135(b)(1)(B).• Veryclearlymark“Amended”atthetopoftheneworder.Inthismanner,
affectedpartieswillknowthattheorderisacorrectedorder.• Nameandaddress.Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,ifunknown,
designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
• Dateandtime.Specifythedateandtimewhenissuedandthecountyand
208
courtwhereissued.• Finally,includethoseelementsasrequiredbythetypeoforderbeing
corrected.
209
210
COMPETENCYHEARINGATAGLANCE
RELEVANTSTATUTES&RULES
FloridaStatutes§§27.52;90.6063;985.033;985.035;985.19;985.29
RulesofJudicialAdministration2.560RulesofJuvenileProcedure8.010;8.015;8.030;8.031;8.085;8.090;8.095;8.100;8.165;8.929RulesforCertificationandRegulationofCourtInterpreters14.100
PURPOSEOFHEARINGThepurposeofthecompetencyhearingistodeterminewhetherthechildallegeddelinquentmaybeincompetenttoproceedwiththechargesagainsthimorher.
BURDENOFPROOF Clearandconvincingevidence.
RULESOFEVIDENCE Rulesofevidenceusedincivilcases.
RIGHTTOCOUNSEL
Thecourtmustadvisethechildofhisorherrighttocounselanddeterminewhethertherightisunderstood.§985.033;Rule8.165(b).Thecourtmustalsodeterminewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsareindigent.Ifso,thecourtmustadviseoftherighttohavecounselappointedinaccordancewith§27.52.Ifcounseliswaived,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.§985.033;Rule8.165.
211
212
COMPETENCYHEARINGBENCHCARDA. Generally
Ø Determinewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.
Ø Verifythattheproceedingisbeingrecordedortranscribed.Ø Explaintothechildthatthepurposeofthecompetencyhearingistodetermine
whetherthechildmaybeincompetenttoproceedwiththechargesagainsthimorher.
Ø Haveallthepartiesidentifythemselvesfortherecordwithfullnameandpermanentaddress.Advisethepartiesthatthecourtwillusetheaddressesprovidedfornoticepurposesunlessotherwisenotifiedinwriting.
Ø Determinewhethertheparents/legalguardiansarepresentorabsent.Ø Ifparents/legalguardiansareabsent,requestDJJgiveathoroughdescriptionof
thestepstakentolocatetheparentsandprovidethemnoticeofthedetentionhearing.
Ø Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
Ø Determinewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ø Ifthechildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel,and
determinewhethertherightisunderstood.Ø Ifinsolvent,advisethechildthatheorshehastherighttohavecounsel
appointed.Ø Ifthechilddoesnothavecounsel,appointcounselasnecessaryunlesswaivedin
writing.Waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingthechild’srighttocounsel,theconsequencesofwaivingcounsel,andanyotherfactorsthatwouldassistthechildinmakingthedecisiontowaivecounsel.
Ø Ifthechildwaivescounsel,determineifthewaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.
C. Competencyhearingprocedure
Ø Thecourtmust,uponmotionfromthebythechildorthestate,ormayuponthecourt’sownmotion,stayanyandallproceedingsandorderanevaluationofthechild’smentalcondition.
Ø Thehearingshallbesetforatimedeterminedbythecourt.Verifythatthechildunderstandsthepurposeofthehearinginclear,simplelanguage.
213
D. Competencydetermination
Ø Alldeterminationsofcompetencyshallbebasedontheevaluationofthechild’smentalconditionmadebynolessthantwoandnomorethan3expertsappointedbythecourt,thoughothercompetentevidencemaybeintroducedatthehearing.Explaintothechildthepurposeoftheevaluationsandhowtheyareusedintheproceeding.
Ø Theevaluationsbythecourt-appointedexpertsmustincludethebasisforanydetermination,andarecommendationastowhetherresidentialornonresidentialtreatmentortrainingisrequired.
Ø Thecourtshalldeterminewhetherthechildisincompetenttoproceed.Verifythatthechildunderstandswhatthedeterminationmeansandwhatisexpectedofhimorher.
E. Confinementassessment
Ø Ifthechildisdeterminedtobecompetent,proceedaccordingly.Ø Ifthechildisdeterminedtobeincompetent,determinewhetherheorshemust
begivenintothecustodyoftheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesfortreatment,training,oreducation.
Ø IfthechildisdeemedincompetenttoproceedbutisnotputintothecustodyoftheDepartmentofChildrenandFamilies,determinewhetheranyformofcourt-orderedtreatmentisnecessary,and,ifso,orderit.
Ø Ifthechildisdeterminedtobeincompetent,setthenexthearingatmost6monthsfromthedateoftheorderofincompetency.
F. Requirementsforawrittenorderofincompetency
Ø Nameandaddressofchild.Ø Includewrittenfindingsthatserveasthebasisfortheorder.Ø Specifythetreatmentordered.Ø Dateofnexthearing.
214
COMPETENCYHEARINGOUTLINEA. Generally
1. InterpreterDeterminationDeterminewhetheraninterpreterisneededtofacilitatecommunicationsinthehearingprocess.Checkforpriornotificationofneedforservices.Ifaninterpreterhasalreadybeenselectedandisavailableattheproceeding,verifythattheinterpretercanreadilycommunicatewiththepersoninneedofservicesandcanrepeatandtranslatecommunicationeasily.§90.6063(6).Ifaninterpreterhasnotbeenpre-selected,workwithcourtadministrationtoprovideacertifiedordulyqualifiedinterpreter.Rule14.100(a)&(b),and§90.6063(3)(b).Ifnoqualifiedinterpreterisavailable,thecourtmayappointaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertifiedifthecourtfindsthatgoodcauseexistsfortheappointmentofanon-qualifiedinterpreter,suchasburdensomedelayorotherunusualcircumstance,andtheproposedinterpreteriscompetenttointerpret.Rule2.560(e)(2).Verifythatthechildknowsthatheorsheisallowedtoobjecttotheproposedappointmentofaninterpreternotqualifiedorcertified.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationoninterpreters.
2. Recording
Arecordofallhearingsmustbemadebyanofficialcourtreporter,acourtapprovedstenographer,orarecordingdevice.Rule8.100(f).
3. Purpose
Thepurposeofthecompetencyhearingistodeterminewhetherthechildmaybeincompetenttoproceedwiththechargesagainsthimorher.
4. IdentifyThosePresent
Identifythosepresentandtheirrelationshiptothecase.Thepartiesshouldidentifythemselvesfortherecord.Delinquencyhearingsareopentothepublicunlessthecourtthecourtfindsthatitisinthechild’sbestinteresttorestrictthoseinattendance.§985.035.
5. NoticeAssessmentIftheparentsorguardianshavebeenidentifiedandareabsentfromtheproceeding,determinethestepstakentolocateandprovidenoticeofthedetentionhearing.Parentsorguardiansshouldbenotifiedofthehearing.Arepresentativefromtheagencyresponsibleforservingnoticeontheparentsorguardiansmustperformadiligentsearchfollowingadetailedandthoroughlistofsourcesheorshemustcheck,beforeheorshecanreportthefailuretonotice.SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationonthediligentsearchrequirement.
215
6. OtherProceedingsDetermination
Determinewhetherthechildisinvolvedinothercourtproceedings.Form8.929.IfthecourtisaUFC,considerconsolidatingthecasesorhearingthemtogether.
B. Adviseofrights
1. RighttoCounselDeterminewhetherchildisrepresentedbycounsel.Ifchildappearswithoutcounsel,advisethechildoftherighttocounsel.Section985.033requiresthatthechildmustbeadvisedoftherighttocounselatallstagesofanydelinquencycourtproceeding.Determinewhethertherighttocounselisunderstood.Thecourtmustinquirewhetherthechildunderstandsthisright.Rule8.165(b)(2).Nowaivermaybeacceptedifitappearsthatthechildisunabletomakeanintelligentandunderstandingdecisionduetomentalcondition,age,education,experience,thenatureofthecase,orotherfactors.Rule8.165(b)(4).Determinewhetherthechildandthechild’sparentsorguardiansmaybeconsideredindigent.Iftheclerkofcourthasnotmadeadeterminationofindigentstatusatorbeforethetimeofthehearing,thecourtmustmakeapreliminarydeterminationofindigentstatus,pendingfurtherreviewbytheclerk,andmay,bycourtorder,appointapublicdefender.§27.52(3).Apersonseekinganappointedcounselbasedonaninabilitytopaymustapplytotheclerkofcourtforindigentstatususingthestandardapplicationform.§27.52(1).Ifindigent,adviseoftherighttohavecounselappointed.Thechildmustbeadvisedthat,ifindigent,thechildhastherighttohavecounselappointedbythecourtinaccordancewith§27.52.§985.033(4).Ifcounseliswaived,determineifwaiverisknowing,intelligent,andvoluntary.Section985.033(2)requiresthatachildmustberepresentedbylegalcounselatallstagesofalljuvenilecourtproceedingsunlesstherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild.Thecourtmustinquiretodeterminewhethertherightisknowingly,freely,andintelligentlywaivedbythechild;waiverofcounselcanoccuronlyafterthechildhashadameaningfulopportunitytoconferwithcounselregardingrighttocounselandconsequencesofwaivingcounsel.Rule8.165(a).Waiverofcounselmustbeontherecord.Rule8.165(a).Ifawaiverofcounselisacceptedatanystageoftheproceedings,theofferofcounselmustberenewedbythecourtateachsubsequentproceedingatwhichthepartyappearswithoutcounsel.Rule8.165(b)(5).Ifanattorney-client
216
relationshipisdiscontinued,thecourtmustadvisethechildoftherighttohavenewcounselretainedorappointedfortheremainderoftheproceedings.§985.033(1).
2. RighttoCommunicate
Unlikethedetentionhearing,thechildhasnoexplicitrighttocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardian.However,somecourtshaveattemptedtomaintainflexibilitywithregardtothehearingwhenachilddesiresthepresenceofanabsentparentorwishestocommunicatewithanabsentparent.Thesepracticesarenotcodifiedinstatuteorrule;assuch,theyaresimplypromisingpracticesthecourtmayengageinwhenachilddesirestocommunicatewithanabsentparentorguardianatahearingwherethereisnoexplicitrighttocommunicate.Promisingpracticesthatallowthechildanopportunitytocommunicatewithanabsentparentinclude:• Providingatelephonetofacilitatecommunicationifaparentisavailable
telephonically;• Delayingthehearingforalatertimeonthesamedaytoallowaparenttime
toattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork;or
• Continuingthehearingtoanotherdaytoallowtheparentanopportunitytoattendthehearing,ifaparentcannotattendthehearingduetoanunchangeablescheduleobligationsuchaswork.
C. Competencyhearingprocedures
1. StayanyandallProceedingsThecourtmust,uponmotionfromthebythechildorthestate,ormayuponthecourt’sownmotion,stayanyandallproceedingsandorderanevaluationofthechild’smentalcondition.§985.19(1).Ifthechild’sattorneysubmittedthemotion,themotionmustincludeacertificatethatthemotionwasmadeingoodfaithandonreasonablegroundstobelievethatthechildisincompetenttoproceed.Rule8.095(a)(1)(A).Themotionmustincludearecitalofobservationsandfactsthat,whilenotinvadinglawyer-clientprivilege,formthebasisforthemotion.Rule8.095(a)(1)(A).Ifthestatefilesthemotion,themotionmustincludeacertificatethatthemotionismadeingoodfaithandonreasonablegroundstobelievethatthechildisincompetent,includingarecitalofobservationsandstatementsofthechildthathaveformedthebasisforthemotion.Rule8.095(a)(1)(B).
2. Service
Anymotionquestioningthecompetencyofachildmustbeservedonthechild’sattorney,thestateattorney,theattorneysrepresentingtheDepartmentofChildrenandFamilies,andtheattorneysrepresentingtheDJJ.§985.19(1)(a).
217
3. SpeedyTrialTimeTollsUponthefilingofamotionbythechild’scounselallegingincompetencytoproceed,oronthecourt’sorderfindingthechildincompetenttoproceed,speedytrialshallbetolleduntilasubsequentorderthatthechildiscompetenttoproceed.MotionsbythestateorbythecourtitselfthatthechildisincompetenttoproceedmaytollspeedytrialpursuanttoRule8.090(e).Rule8.095(a)(9).SeeGeneralTopicsformoreinformationaboutspeedytrials.
4. SettheHearing
Thehearingshallbesetforatimedeterminedbythecourt.Rule8.095(a)(2).Thehearingdatemustallowtimeforexpertstoexamineandevaluatethechild’smentalcondition.
5. DetentionisPermissible
Thecourtmayorderthechilddetainedpendingexamination;thisinnowayaddsanydetentionpowernotprovidedbystatuteorcaselaw.Rule8.095(c)(2).
D. Competencydetermination
1. BasisforaDeterminationAlldeterminationsofcompetencyshallbebasedontheevaluationofthechild’smentalconditionmadebynolessthan2andnomorethan3expertsappointedbythecourt,§985.19(1)(b),thoughothercompetentevidencemaybeintroducedatthehearing.Rule8.095(c)(1).Theappointmentofexpertsbythecourtdoesnotprecludethechildorthestatefromcallingotherexpertwitnessestotestify.Rule8.095(c)(1).
2. EvaluationbyExperts
Theevaluationsbythecourt-appointedexpertsmustincludethebasisforanydetermination,andarecommendationastowhetherresidentialornonresidentialtreatmentortrainingisrequired.§985.19(1)(b).Theevaluatorsmustdeterminewhetherthechildhassufficientpresentabilitytoconsultwithcounselwithareasonabledegreeofrationalunderstandingandwhetherthechildhasarationalandfactualunderstandingofthepresentproceedings.Rule8.095(d)(1)(A).Theevaluationmustaddressthechild’scapacityto:• Appreciatethechargesorallegationsagainstthechild;• Appreciatetherangeandnatureofpossiblepenaltiesthatmaybeimposed
intheproceedingsagainstthechild,ifapplicable;• Understandtheadversarialnatureofthelegalprocess;• Disclosetocounselfactspertinenttotheproceedingsatissue;• Displayappropriatecourtroombehavior;and• Testifyrelevantly.§985.19(1)(f)(1)-(6).
218
3. ExpertReportIftheexpertsrecommendthatthechildisincompetenttoproceed,theymustincludeintheirreportanyrecommendedtreatmentforthechildtogaincompetencetoproceed.Rule8.095(d)(2).Inconsideringissuesrelatedtotreatment,theexpertsmustreportonthefollowing:• Thementalillness,mentalretardation,ormentalagecausingincompetence;• Thetreatmentoreducationappropriateforthementalillnessormental
retardationofthechildandanexplanationofeachofthepossibletreatmentoreducationalternatives,inorderofrecommendation;
• Theavailabilityofacceptabletreatmentoreducation.Iftreatmentoreducationisavailableinthecommunity,theexpertsmuststatethatinthereport.
• Thelikelihoodofthechildattainingcompetenceunderthetreatmentoreducationrecommended,anassessmentoftheprobabledurationofthetreatmentrequiredtorestorecompetence,andtheprobabilitythatthechildwillattaincompetencetoproceedintheforeseeablefuture;and
• Whetherthechildmeetsthecriteriaforinvoluntaryhospitalizationorinvoluntaryadmissionstoresidentialservicesunderchapter985,FloridaStatutes.Rule8.095(d)(2)(A)-(E).
4. “MentalRetardation”or“Autism”
Ifthemotionalleges“mentalretardation”or“autism,”thecourtshallordertheAgencyforPersonswithDisabilitiestoexaminethechildtodeterminewhetherthechildmeetsthedefinitionof“mentalretardation”or“autism,”and,ifso,whetherthechildiscompetenttoproceedwiththedelinquencyproceedings.§985.19(1)(e).
5. IfFoundCompetent
Ifthechildiscompetent,enteranordersofindingandproceedaccordingly.Rule8.095(a)(3).
6. IfFoundIncompetent
Ifthecourtfindsthechildincompetenttoproceed,thechildmustbeadjudicatedincompetenttoproceed.Thecourtmustthendeterminetheappropriatetreatmentortrainingforthechild.Rule8.095(a)(4).
E. Confinementassessment
1. CommitmenttoDCFAchildwhoisadjudicatedincompetenttoproceed,andwhohascommittedadelinquentactorviolationofthelaw,eitherofwhichwouldbeafelonyifcommittedbyanadult,mustbecommittedtoDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesfortreatmentortraining.§985.19(2).
219
2. WhenCommitmenttoDCFisImpermissibleAchildwhoisadjudicatedincompetenttoproceed,andwhohascommittedadelinquentactorviolationofthelaw,eitherofwhichwouldbeconsideredamisdemeanorifcommittedbyanadult,maynotbecommittedtotheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesforrestoration-of-competencytreatmentortrainingservices.§985.19(2).Achildwhoisadjudicatedincompetenttoproceedbecauseofageorimmaturity,orforanyreasonotherthanformentalillnessorretardationorautism,mustnotbecommittedtotheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesforrestoration-of-competencytreatmentortrainingservices.§985.29(2).
3. SecurePlacementDetermination
Ifthechildisadjudicatedincompetenttoproceedbecauseofmentalillness,retardation,orautism,thecourtmustdeterminewhetherthechildmeetsthecriteriaforsecureplacement.§985.19(3).Thecriteriaforsecureplacementisafindingbasedonclearandconvincingevidencethatthechildismentallyill,mentallyretardedorhasautism,andbecauseofthat:• thechildismanifestlyincapableofsurvivingwiththehelpofwillingand
responsiblefamilyorfriends,includingavailablealternativeservices,andwithouttreatmentortrainingthechildislikelytoeithersufferfromneglectorrefusetocareforself,andsuchneglectorrefusalposesarealandpresentthreatofsubstantialharmtothechild'swell-being;or
• thereisasubstantiallikelihoodthatinthenearfuturethechildwillinflictseriousbodilyharmonselforothers,asevidencedbyrecentbehaviorcausing,attempting,orthreateningsuchharm;
andallavailablelessrestrictivealternatives,includingtreatmentortrainingincommunityresidentialfacilitiesorcommunitysettingswhichwouldofferanopportunityforimprovementofthechild'scondition,areinappropriate.§985.19(3).
4. WhereDetentionCriteriaareMet
Achildadjudicatedincompetenttoproceedbecauseofmentalillness,retardation,orautism,andwhomeetsthedetentioncriteriain§985.19(3)mustbecommittedtotheDepartmentofChildrenandFamilies.Rule8.095(a)(6).AchildadjudicatedincompetentbecauseofmentalretardationmaybeorderedintoaprogramdesignatedbyDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesforretardedchildren.Rule8.095(a)(6)(A).AchildadjudicatedincompetentbecauseofmentalillnessmaybeorderedintoaprogramdesignatedbytheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesformentallyillchildren.Rule8.095(a)(6)(B).
5. WhereDetentionCriteriaarenotMet
220
Achildadjudicatedincompetenttoproceedbecauseofmentalillness,retardation,orautism,andwhodoesnotmeetthedetentioncriteriashallbeorderedintotheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliescareandprovidedappropriatetreatmentandtraininginthecommunity.Rule8.095(a)(8).Allcourt-orderedtreatmentmustbeintheleastrestrictivesettingconsistentwithpublicsafety.Rule8.095(a)(8).
6. ReportbyServiceProvider
Theserviceproviderwhoisprovidingtreatmentoreducationtothechildmustfilewiththecourtawrittenreportnotlaterthan6monthsafterthedateofcommitment,orattheendofanyperiodofextendedtrainingoreducation,andatanytimetheDepartmentofChildrenandFamiliesdeterminesthechildhasattainedcompetency,orsoonerifsoorderedbythecourt.§985.19(4)(e).
7. RetentionofJurisdictionThecourtshallretainjurisdictionofachildadjudicatedincompetenttoproceedforupto2yearsafterthedateoftheorderofincompetency,withreviewsatleastevery6monthstodeterminecompetency.§985.19(5)(a).Ifthecourtdeterminesthatthechildhasnotattainedcompetency,thecourtshallorderappropriatenondelinquenthospitalizationortreatmentinconformitywithRule8.095andtheapplicablesectionsofChapter985,FloridaStatutes.Rule8.095(a)(5)(A).Ifthecourtatanytimedeterminesthatthechildwillneverattaincompetency,thecourtmaydismissthedelinquencypetitionorpetitionallegingviolationofjuvenileprobation.Rule8.095(a)(7)(A).Ifnecessary,thecourtmayorderproceedingsunderChapter393,FloridaStatutes(DevelopmentalDisabilities)orChapter394,FloridaStatutes(FloridaMentalHealthActorTheBakerAct)beinstitutednotlessthan60daysbeforethedismissalofthedelinquencypetition.Rule8.085(a)(7)(C).
8. DismissalofDelinquencyPetition
If,attheendofthetwo-yearperiod,thechildhasnotattainedcompetencyandthereisnoevidencethatheorshewillattaincompetencywithinoneyear,thecourtmustdismissthedelinquencypetition.Rule8.095(a)(7)(B).
F. Requirementsforawrittenorderofincompetency
1. Theorderofincompetencymustinclude:• Nameandaddressofchild.Statethenameandaddressofthechildor,if
unknown,designatethechildbyanameordescriptionthatcanidentifythechildwithreasonablecertainty.
• Writtenfindings.Includespecificwrittenfindingsastothenatureoftheincompetencyandwhetherthechildrequiressecureornonsecuretreatmentortrainingenvironments.§985.19(1)(c).
• Treatmentordered.Includethetreatment,training,oreducationordered
221
forthechild,andthefindingssuchisbasedon.• Dateofnexthearing.Includeintheorderthedateofthefollowuphearing
toassesswhetherthechildhasattainedcompetence.
223
Appendices
TableofContentsAppendix1:DetentionRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI)Appendix2:TenThingsEveryJuvenileCourtJudgeShouldKnowAboutTraumaandDelinquencyAppendix3:HelpingTraumatizedChildren:TipsForJudges
Appendix1:DetentionRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI)Appendix1isnotavailableinelectronicformat,ifyouwouldliketorequestahardcopyofthisdocumentpleasecontactourofficeat:OSCA,OfficeofCourtImprovement,500
SouthDuvalStreet,Tallahassee,Florida32399.Telephone:850/414.1507.
226
Appendix2:TenThingsEveryJuvenileCourtJudgeShouldKnowAboutTraumaandDelinquency1
Appendix2isavailableinelectronicformatatthefollowingwebsite:http://www.ncjfcj.org/sites/default/files/trauma%20bulletin_1.pdf
1KristineBuffington,CarlyB.Dierkhising,&ShawnC.Marsh.TenThingsEveryJuvenileCourtJudgeShouldKnowAboutTraumaandDelinquency.Reno,NV:NationalCouncilofJuvenileandFamilyCourtJudges(2010).
Appendix3:HelpingTraumatizedChildren:TipsForJudges1
Appendix3isavailableinelectronicformatatthefollowingwebsite:
http://www.nctsn.org/sites/default/files/assets/pdfs/JudgesFactSheet.pdf
1NationalChildTraumaticStressNetwork,JusticeSystemConsortium.HelpingTraumatizedChildren:TipsforJudges.LosAngeles,CA&Durham,NC:NationalCenterforChildTraumaticStress(2009).
236
Index
Index
AAdjudicatoryHearingBenchcard,126AdjudicatoryHearingOutline,128Child'sRights,129ClosingArgumentOrder,132CustodyPendingDisposition,134DefenseofAlibi,131DegreesofOffensesIncluded,134DelinquencyDetermination,135JointTrials,131MotionforDismissal,134NoticeAssessment,129ParticipationinDiscovery,131Purpose,128RequirementsforWrittenOrderofAdjudication,135
RighttoAppeal,134RulesofEvidence,132SettingDispositionhearing,135WrittenFindingifChildisinPublicSchool,133
Appeals,9AppealtotheAppellateCourt,10Generally,9MotionforExtraordinaryRelief,10MotionforRehearing,9
Appendix1DetentionRiskAssessmentInstrument(RAI),225
Appendix2TenThingsEveryJuvenileCourtJudgeShouldKnowAboutTraumaandDelinquency,226
Appendix3HelpingTraumatizedChildrenTipsForJudges,227
ArraignmentHearingBenchcard,113ArraignmentHearingOutline,115Child'sRights,116CommitmentIssueifDomesticViolenceisAlleged,121
CustodyDeterminationPendingDisposition,121
DeterminationofVoluntarinessofPlea,118
IfAnswerisFiled,118Non-CitizenJuvenileVoluntarinessIssue,119
NoticeAssessment,115PleaofGuiltyorNoloContendere,118
PleaofNotGuilty,118PrimaFacieCaseofDelinquency,117Purpose,115ReasonsnottoPlacetheChild,122RequiredAcknowledgmentforPlea,120
SettingAdjudicatoryHearing,120AuthorityofCourtoverParents,12CostsofRepresentation,13Fees,13NonattendancebyaParentorGuardian,12
ParentingSkillsCourse,13RestitutionorCommunityService,13
CChildAdjudicatedNotGuiltybyReasonofInsanity,14NotGuiltybyReasonofInsanity,14Review,15Treatment,14
CommitmenttoDJJ
238
High-riskresidential,17Maximum-riskresidential,17Minimum-risknonresidential,16Nonsecureresidential,16RestrictivenessLevels,16
CommitmentstoDJJ,16CommitmentProcess,16
CommonAcronyms,3CommonEvidenceIssues,63BodySearches,64InvestigatoryStopsversusConsensualEncounters,63
StandardsinaSchoolSetting,65VehicleSearches,64WeaponsIssues,65
CompetencyHearingBenchcard,212CompetencyHearingOutline,214Child'sRights,215CompetencyDetermination,217ConfinementAssessment,218EvaluationbyExperts,217NoticeAssessment,214Purpose,214ReportbyServiceProvider,220RequirementsforaWrittenOrderofIncompetency,220
RetentionofJurisdiction,220SecurePlacementDetermination,219StayingOtherProceedings,216
ConditionalReleaseandPost-CommitmentProbation,18ConditionalRelease,18Post-CommitmentProbation,18
Confidentiality,20Exceptions,20
ContemptofCourtHearingBenchcard,169
ContemptofCourtHearingOutline,170BurdenofProof,174Child'sRights,171DirectContemptofCourt,170IftheChildPleadsGuilty,174IftheChildPleadsNotGuilty,174IndirectContemptHearingProcedure,173
JudgmentandPronouncementofSentence,174
NoticeAssessment,171Purpose,170RequirementsforaWrittenJudgmentofContempt,175
Sanctions,174CorrectionofOrdersHearingBenchcard,202
CorrectionofOrdersHearingOutline,204Child'sRights,205CorrectionDetermination,207HearingTimeframe,207MotionFiledBeforeAppeal,206MotionFiledPendingAppeal,207NoticeAssessment,204Purpose,204RequirementsforaCorrectedOrder,207
CostofCourt,Care,andSupervision,22AdditionalFees,22Child'sObligationuponTurning18,23FeeDetermination,23FeeReimbursement,24FeeWaiver,23Generally,22ParentalLiability,22RequiredInformation,22
D
239
DelinquencyCaseFlowChart,11Delinquency/DependencyCrossoverCases,25EffectivePracticesinCrossoverCases,30
Statistics,25DepartingfromDJJGuidelines,33E.A.R.v.State,33
DetentionCriteria,35Post-CommitmentDetention,37Pre-CommitmentDetention,35
DetentionHearingBenchcard,100DetentionHearingOutline,102AdditionalActswhileunderSupervision,107
ArraignmentHearingTimeframe,108Child'sRights,104ContinuedDetentionRegardlessofRAIScore,107
DetentionIssues,103HearingTimeframe,103NoticeAssessment,104ProbableCauseDetermination,106Purpose,103Requirementsforwrittenorderofdetention,108
StandardofProof,106Discovery,39Depositions,41Limitations,41RequiredDisclosuretoDJJ,40RequiredDisclosuretotheChild,39Sanctions,45
DispositionHearingBenchcard,138DispositionHearingOutline,142Child'sRights,143CommitmentDetermination,146
DetentionPendingCommitment,149NoticeAssessment,141OffensesInvolvingAlcohol,149OffensesInvolvingFirearms,148Probation,147Purpose,142RequiredBeforeDeterminingDisposition,145
RequirementsforaWrittenOrderofDisposition,149
Restitution,148ReviewofPredispositionReport,144
DiversionaryPrograms,47CivilCitation,49Expunction,51Generally,47JuvenileSubstanceInterventionProgram,50
TeenCourt,47DomesticViolenceIssues,52Bestpracticesindelinquencycasesinvolvingdomesticviolence,57
CourtroomPractices,59HowtoAscertainwhetherDomesticViolencemaybePresent,55
Statistics,52IImmigrationIssues,66InterpretersforForeignLanguages,68InterpreterDetermination,109ModesofInterpretingandServiceDeliveryMethods,71
PerformAssessmenttoDetermineNeeds,69
ProvisionofServices,70SelectionofInterpreter,69
InterstateCompact,73RunawaysandEscapees,73
240
JJurisdictioninDelinquencyProceedings,75RetentionofJurisdiction,75
JuvenileAssessmentCenter,76JuvenileSexOffenderPrograms,79CommunityBasedTreatmentServices,79
JuvenileSexualOffenderCommitmentPrograms,80
JuvenileSexOffendersandTheAdamWalshAct,77Generally,77Registration,77RemovalfromtheRegistry,78WrittenFindingsRequired,77
MMedicaid/MedicareEligibilityforServicesuponRelease,81
OOverviewoftheFloridaJuvenileDelinquencyProcess,1
RRestitution,82AlternativestoFairMarketValue,82FairMarketValue,82
RestitutionHearingBenchcard,191RestitutionHearingOutline,193Child'sRights,194NoticeAssessment,193RequirementsforaWrittenOrderofRestitution,201
RestitutionDetermination,197RulesofEvidence,196WhenRestitutionAmountisinDispute,200
WhereChildisChallengingRestitutionAmount,196
WherethereisNoncompliancewithaValidRestitutionOrder,197
RiskAssessmentInstrument,83SServiceofProcess,84SpeedyTrial,85DemandforSpeedyTrial,85MotionforDischarge,85
TTableofContents,5Appendices,10GeneralTopics,5
TransfertoAdultCourt,87DiscretionaryDirectFile,88Indictments,90InvoluntaryDiscretionaryWaiver,87InvoluntaryMandatoryWaiver,87MandatoryDirectFile,89VoluntaryWaiver,87
UUnifiedFamilyCourt–ModelFamilyCourt,91
VViolationofProbationHearingBenchcard,156
ViolationofProbationHearingOutline,158BurdenofProof,160Child'sRights,159DispositionDetermination,162NoticeAssessment,159Purpose,158RequirementsforaWrittenOrder,162
241
RulesofEvidence,161ViolationofProbationDetermination,161
WWaiverofJurisdictionHearingBenchcard,180
WaiverofJurisdictionHearingOutline,182Child'sRights,183
DiscretionaryInvoluntaryWaiver,184EvidenceConsideration,185JurisdictionDetermination,186MandatoryInvoluntaryWaiver,184NoticeAssessment,182Purpose,182RequirementsforaWrittenOrderonWaiverofJurisdiction,187
VoluntaryWaiver,184WalkerPlanApprovalbyJudge,93