2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318...

34
2016 Annual Meeting Conference 2016 Annual Meeting Conference 2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Litigation Track Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney, III Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice, L.L.P. One Wells Fargo Center Suite 3500, 301 South College Street Charlotte, North Carolina 28202

Transcript of 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318...

Page 1: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

2016 Annual Meeting Conference2016 Annual Meeting Conference2016 Annual Meeting Conference

Litigation TrackLitigation TrackLitigation Track

Rooms 316-318

TUESDAY, JUNE 14TUESDAY, JUNE 14TUESDAY, JUNE 14

Anatomy of a Hoax

9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m.

Presented by James Cooney, III

Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice, L.L.P. One Wells Fargo Center

Suite 3500, 301 South College Street Charlotte, North Carolina 28202

Page 2: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Anatomy of a Hoax

Page 3: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Detective Ben Himan

Page 4: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Opportunity

Page 5: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Twenty to Thirty Minutes

Page 6: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

March 13-14, 2006

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

Page 7: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

March 13-14, 2006

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Page 8: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

March 13-14, 2006

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

Page 9: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

March 13-14, 2006

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

12:06a12:14a

8 Cell Calls by SeligmannCalls Cab at

12:14aElmostafa

Cell

Page 10: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

12:06a12:14a

8 Cell Calls by SeligmannCalls Cab at

12:14aElmostafa

Cell

Elmostafa Picks Up

Seligmann and

Wellington

12:19a

March 13-14, 2006

Page 11: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

12:06a12:14a

8 Cell Calls by SeligmannCalls Cab at

12:14aElmostafa

Cell

Elmostafa Picks Up

Seligmann and

Wellington

12:19a

Seligmann Reenters

Dorm

12:46a

Seligmann at

Wachovia ATM

12:24a

March 13-14, 2006

Page 12: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

12:06a12:14a

8 Cell Calls by SeligmannCalls Cab at

12:14aElmostafa

Cell

Elmostafa Picks Up

Seligmann and

Wellington

12:19a

12:26aMangum

Cell

Seligmann Reenters

Dorm

12:46a

Seligmann at

Wachovia ATM

12:24a

March 13-14, 2006

12:22a

Finnerty Cell Call

12:24aFinnerty Cell Call

12:30a12:33a

Finnerty Calls

Domino’s Pizza

11:29pEvans’ Cell

12:34a -12:50

Evans’ Cell

Page 13: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

A Picture Story

Page 14: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Dave Evans’ Camera

Page 15: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Dave Evans’ Camera

Item 14: Seized by the Durham Police Department on March 16, 2006

13 Hours Difference

Page 16: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Dave Evans’ Camera

Item 14: Seized by the Durham Police Department on March 16, 2006

March 14, 2006 12:02:03 AM

Page 17: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Kevin Coleman’s CameraMarch 16, 2006

Page 18: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

March 13-14, 2006

11:00p 1:00a11:02p

Pictures Coleman

11:08p

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:09p11:10p

PicturesEvans (Item 14)

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

12:04a

8 pictures (7 Coleman, 1

Evans)

12:06a12:14a

8 Cell Calls by SeligmannCalls Cab at

12:14aElmostafa

Cell

12:10aColeman Picture

12:19a

Elmostafa Picks Up

Seligmann and

Wellington

12:24a

Seligmann at

Wachovia ATM

12:30a12:38a

6 pictures Coleman

12:41a

Mangum Leaves

Coleman Picture

12:46a

Seligmann Reenters

Dorm

12:55a

Roberts 911 Calll

12:26a

12:26aMangum

Cell

Page 19: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Trying to Change Time

Page 20: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

12:06a12:14a

8 Cell Calls by SeligmannCalls Cab at

12:14aElmostafa

Cell

Elmostafa Picks Up

Seligmann and

Wellington

12:19a

12:26aMangum

Cell

Seligmann Reenters

Dorm

12:46a

Seligmann at

Wachovia ATM

12:24a

March 13-14, 2006

12:22a

Finnerty Cell Call

12:24aFinnerty Cell Call

12:30a12:33a

Finnerty Calls

Domino’s Pizza

11:29pEvans’ Cell

12:34a -12:50

Evans’ Cell

11:02p11:08p

Pictures Player

PicturesEvans (Item 14)

11:09p11:10p

12:04a

8 pictures (7 Player, 1

Evans)

12:10aPlayer Picture

6 pictures P layer12:30a12:38a

Mangum Leaves Player

Picture

12:41a

December 21, 2006 Version

Mangum Arrives

Mangum Dance

Rape Begins 11:40p

Rape Ends Midnight

Page 21: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

11:00p 1:00a

11:11p11:12p

Mangum Cell

11:22p11:24p

Mangum Cell

11:25p11:32p

Mangum Cell

Home Tele #l

11:33p11:34p

Mangum Cell

11:36p11:39p

11:50p11:52p

Seligmann Cell

Jandl Cell

Midnight

Jason Bissey

12:06a12:14a

8 Cell Calls by SeligmannCalls Cab at

12:14aElmostafa

Cell

Elmostafa Picks Up

Seligmann and

Wellington

12:19a

12:26aMangum

Cell

Seligmann Reenters

Dorm

12:46a

Seligmann at

Wachovia ATM

12:24a

March 13-14, 2006

12:53a

12:22a

Finnerty Cell Call

12:24aFinnerty Cell Call

12:30a12:33a

Finnerty Calls

Domino’s Pizza

11:29pEvans’ Cell

12:34a -12:50

Evans’ Cell

11:02p11:08p

Pictures Player

PicturesEvans (Item 14)

11:09p11:10p

12:04a

8 pictures (7 Player, 1

Evans)

12:10aPlayer Picture

6 pictures P layer12:30a12:38a

Mangum Leaves Player

Picture

12:41a

December 21, 2006 Version

Mangum Arrives

Mangum Dance

Rape Begins 11:40p

Rape Ends Midnight

Mangum Arrives per Brian Taylor

Receipt

Page 22: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

The DNA

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16

1 3 4 7 16

Page 23: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16

16

100% Exclusion

Page 24: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,
Page 25: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

The DNADoes Not Match Defendants, Lacrosse Team or Mangum Boyfriend

Page 26: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

The DNASection 2 Pubic CombAt Least 2 Males

Page 27: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

How Close Was This?

Page 28: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

How Close Was This?

Alan Gell was Sentenced to Death in February 1997

A Single Vote

Page 29: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Jenkins’ Body Found

Morris and Hall Claim Jenkins is Killed If Allen Ray Jenkins Did Not Die

on April 3, 1995, Then Alan Gell Is Innocent

Page 30: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Jenkins’ Body Found

Morris and Hall Claim Jenkins is Killed

Sidney Jenkins sees Jenkins AliveWillie Hoggard sees

Jenkins Alive

Ricky Odom sees Jenkins Alive

Donald Hale sees Jenkins Alive

The Hunts see Jenkins Alive

The Adams see Jenkins Alive

Richard Jones sees Jenkins Alive

Danny Brogdin sees Jenkins Alive

Larry Luke sees Jenkins Alive

Benjamin Parker sees Jenkins Alive

Paula Brabble sees Jenkins Alive

Janelle Harris sees Jenkins Alive

Linwood Rawls sees Jenkins Alive

Peggy Moore sees Jenkins Alive

Addie Wilder Stops Hearing Sounds from Jenkins’ House

Robert Jerome Blowe sees Jenkins

17 Witnesses Saw Allen Ray Jenkins Alive After April 3,

1995

Page 31: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Open File Discovery

Page 32: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

How Close Was This?

Alan Gell was Sentenced to Death in February 1997

A Single Vote

Page 33: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Observations on Crisis Management

You Will Not Always See It Coming

You May Not Even Recognize It as a Crisis (At First)

The Value of Good Information (and Who Has It)

Who You Are Does Not Change: Remember Who You Are

Always Wear Clean Underwear

Do Not Be Afraid to Say You Are Sorry

Page 34: 2016 Annual Meeting Conference...2016 Annual Meeting Conference Litigation Track Rooms 316-318 TUESDAY, JUNE 14 Anatomy of a Hoax 9:10 a.m. - 10:10 a.m. Presented by James Cooney,

Just as, all too often,

some huge crowd is seized by a vast uprising,

the rabble runs amok, all slaves to passion,

rock, firebrands flying. Rage finds them arms

but then, if they chance to see among them,

one whose devotion and public service lend him weight,

they stand there, stock-still with their ears alert as

he rules their fervor with his words and calms their passion

Virgil “The Aeneid” I:174-81


Hoax of Higher Criticism

Hoax of Higher Criticism

Sam Loyd Successful Hoax

Sam Loyd Successful Hoax

The Hydrogen Hoax

The Hydrogen Hoax

Apollo Moon Landing Hoax

Apollo Moon Landing Hoax

Masonic Hoax

Masonic Hoax

The Benghazi Hoax

The Benghazi Hoax

Language Hoax

Language Hoax

More Than a Hoax

More Than a Hoax

The Hieronymus Hoax - leehite.org

The Hieronymus Hoax - leehite.org

Eskimo Hoax

Eskimo Hoax

The Soprano Trombone Hoax

The Soprano Trombone Hoax

The Great Hoax

The Great Hoax

Click on a county....March 30 March 30 April 1 April 13 April 6 April 10 March 30 11 a.m. 10 a.m. - 4 p.m. 10 a.m. 9 a.m. 9 a.m. 8 a.m. 10 a.m. - 1 p.m. Dennis Township Municipal Garden

Click on a county....March 30 March 30 April 1 April 13 April 6 April 10 March 30 11 a.m. 10 a.m. - 4 p.m. 10 a.m. 9 a.m. 9 a.m. 8 a.m. 10 a.m. - 1 p.m. Dennis Township Municipal Garden

E.T… Real Or Hoax By Colter Mouw. E.T… Real Or Hoax By Colter Mouw.

E.T… Real Or Hoax By Colter Mouw. E.T… Real Or Hoax By Colter Mouw.

Profiling Hoax Callers - Carnegie Mellon Universitymlsp.cs.cmu.edu/people/rsingh/docs/Profiling-hoax-Singh.HST2016.pdfProfiling Hoax Callers Rita Singh y, Joseph Keshet z, Eduard

Profiling Hoax Callers - Carnegie Mellon Universitymlsp.cs.cmu.edu/people/rsingh/docs/Profiling-hoax-Singh.HST2016.pdfProfiling Hoax Callers Rita Singh y, Joseph Keshet z, Eduard

Satan's Greatest Hoax

Satan's Greatest Hoax

Dealing with Hoax

Dealing with Hoax

Apolllo 11 hoax (1)

Apolllo 11 hoax (1)

Grant County, Washington · 2018. 6. 5. · Page 2 of 7 Grant County Commissioners Minutes Week of May 7, 2018 9:30 a.m. - 10:00 a.m. 10:00 a.m. - 10:15 a.m. 10:30 a.m. - 10:45 a.m.

Grant County, Washington · 2018. 6. 5. · Page 2 of 7 Grant County Commissioners Minutes Week of May 7, 2018 9:30 a.m. - 10:00 a.m. 10:00 a.m. - 10:15 a.m. 10:30 a.m. - 10:45 a.m.

London Beheading Hoax Confirmed

London Beheading Hoax Confirmed