20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

download 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

of 54

Transcript of 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    1/54

    Date Target Country Acquirers name

    Jul-07 Nikho Brazil Cadilla Healthcare

    Jul-07 Vit. D business of Solva Netherlands Dish!an "har!a

    #a-07 $aro %ahra!ceuticals &srael Sun "har!a

    #a-07 Ne'!a (abs )rance *ockhardt (td.

    +%r-07 Hollister-Steir ,S+ Jubiliant r'anoss

    Source /N+# esearch

    Exhibit 1: Recent International Acquisitions by Indian Companies

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    2/54

    Value ! mn"# $ales ! mn"#

    12 12

    32.4 11.2

    545 16

    124 340

    331.4 44

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    3/54

    $ummarised Income $tatement

    )8 1004

    $otal inco!e 319:30.5

    #anifacturin' e;%enses 4927:.7

    /!%loee cost 39142.Sellin' < distribution e;%enses 39072.1

    "BD&$+ 395:2.7

    "BD$+ 3932:.2

    "B$ :1.0

    "+$ 11.6

    $ummarised balance sheet:

    %iabilites and &et'orth: )8 1004

    Net =orth 49004.0

    $otal borro=in's 59502.5ther liabilities 6:5.5

    Total %iabilities 1()*+,"-

    Assets:

    >ross fi;ed assets 7952.2

    Net fi;ed assets 2917.4

    &nvest!ents 6:.7

    Current assets9 loans < advances 297:.7

    (ess Current liabilites and %rovisions 19775.3

    Total assets 1()*+,"-

    Source Data %rovided b (u%in (td.

    Exhibit .: $ummari/ed 0inancial in0ormation %upin all figures in rupees million

    ? &t had 0.:54 !illion e@uit shares outstandin' as of #arch 1007 and its avera'e#arch 1007 =as s. 57.04 billion. (u%in =as listed in the leadin' national st

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    4/54

    )8 1002 )8 1007

    379::4.4 119344.1

    4927:.7 4927:.7

    39142. 39142.39216.4 39632.6

    1962.7 59723.:

    19224.7 59:60.5

    19125. :9612.7

    39760.0 19676.

    )8 1002 )8 1007

    295:6.4 95.3

    6931:.4 9254.4642.3 39017.1

    12),13"1 1-),,2"-

    9201.7 309:51.2

    29272.3 7962:.2

    64.0 4.2

    3:9353.7 359744.:

    :9:63.1 59110.7

    12),.1"2 1-),,2"-

    #

    arket ca%italization durin' theck e;chan'es in &ndia

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    5/54

    Sales Avalue Sales Avolu!e

    , 15.00 20.60

    ,S 31.0 2.20

    >er!an 13.0 2:.70

    )rance 34.60 :6.0

    Ja%an 2.10 37.10

    Source "rovided b the co!%an and credited to the Ja%an >eneric #edicines +ssociation *ebsite

    Data concernin' the ,S9 , >er!an and )rance are of 100. Ja%an data are of 1007

    Sales Avalue Sales Avolu!e

    1003 5.70 30.0

    1001 5.0 31.10100: 4.10 32.50

    1005 4.10 32.0

    1004 4.30 37.30

    1002 4.70 32.60

    1007 2.10 37.10

    Source "rovided b the co!%an and credited to the Ja%an >eneric #edicines +ssociation *ebsite

    Exhibit *: $hare o0 4eneric Drugs in 5a6or 5ar7ets 8#

    Exhibit +: $hare o0 9apanese 4eneric Drugs 8#

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    6/54

    UK US Germany France Japan

    0.00%

    10.00%

    20.00%

    30.00%

    40.00%

    50.00%

    60.00%

    70.00%

    80.00%

    2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

    0.00%

    2.00%

    4.00%

    6.00%

    8.00%

    10.00%

    12.00%

    14.00%16.00%

    18.00%

    20.00%

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    7/54

    Sales (value

    Sales

    (v!lume

    Sales

    (value

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    8/54

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    9/54

    asin' their shares in the !arket

    ((2 ;.((< ;.((-E

    8 o0 Total $ales 8 o0 Total $ales 8 o0 Total

    .6 :792:3 6.: 5597: 30.00

    7.: :391 7.6 5:9000 6.20

    7.2 :39564 7. :49020 7.

    2.7 179515 2. :39000 2.6

    5.2 39400 5.2 369500 5.:

    :.5 3:9400 :.: 359100 :.1

    1.6 3:9140 :.: 3:951 :.3

    1.1 309051 1.4 339521 1.2

    1.: 6920 1.5 339511 1.4

    3.6 7927: 3.6 69301 1.0

    3.4 79400 3.6 69000 1.0

    3.3 59400 3.3 49300 3.3

    3.1 59745 3.1 5967: 3.33.1 59500 3.3 59733 3.0

    3.0 59:10 3.3 59267 3.0

    3.3 59:0 3.3 59260 3.0

    3.0 59070 3.0 59:32 3.0

    3.0 59000 3.0 59:00 3.0

    0. :97: 0.6 59310 0.6

    0. :95:0 0. :9470 0.

    53.4 347977 :6.3 3229356 :7.0

    1((8 +(*)3(. 1((8 ++-)-3< 1((8

    :0.5 31:7 :3. 34:5: :5.:

    e!ber 1591006

    nerics &8+,H&N N S&G,, B,NS/& CH,S+F

    E&ERIC$ $A%E$ 9; I& 5I%%I@&$#1#

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    10/54

    )8 1002 )8 1004

    ankin' ankin'

    3 350

    1 :

    : 1

    5 30

    4 4

    2 5

    7 2

    7

    6

    30 6

    33 33

    31 35

    3: 13

    35 36

    34 10

    32 3737 16

    3 32

    36 3

    10 15

    ? Not availableSource "rovided b (u%in (td.

    Top 1( suppliers inancial year .((2#

    Ran7ing $upplier

    3 oa ShoEi

    1 ,Ei "har!a.

    : Nihon Bulk "har!a.

    5 Daito

    4 #iat

    2 #> "hara!a.

    7 aken "har!a.

    Valent %har!a.

    6 Su!ito!o Che!ical

    30 arinco s.%.a$otal

    Top 1( contract manu0acturers

    Ran7ing 5anu0acturer

    3 orin i!edo

    1 Daito

    : $atsu!i ka'aku

    Exhibit 2: 5a6or roducts o0 =yo'a

    Exhibit

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    11/54

    5 "har!a "ack

    4 $oo Ca%sule

    2 Seiko /io 8akuhin

    7 #aruko "har!a.

    $aio 8akuhin

    6 #e'uro ako

    30 anae

    Total

    Source "rovided b (u%in (td.

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    12/54

    Brand Na!eSales AJ"8 !n.

    )8-1004 )8-1002

    )lutcasone nasal solution na? 546.:

    !e%erazole :37.1 5:1.21

    "ravastatin Na :6:.04 :7.3:

    )lunitreza%e! 32.33 136.1:

    (una%ron 10:.73 132.:7

    ashilon 1:6.41 133.60

    (ansa%razole 362.27 105.6:

    Sul%ride 372.56 105.00

    Calfina 374.63 365.43

    #estinon 370.37 360.35

    Si!vastatin 353.30 341.7

    +kriden 311.07 3:7.66

    +!el 30.:0 3:2.40

    #aEo%rin 330.4: 316.03

    Carba!aze%ine 30.6 317.4:

    Neuo!il 33:.05 313.:/%arose 1.33 336.3

    Nifeslo= 332.04 332.77

    $a!sulosin 55.40 302.14

    #il!a' 67.72 305.35

    $otal :956.1: :9671.1

    Category

    +"&)inished %roducts 412.5

    )inished %roducts 522.6

    +"&"har!aceutical vehicle 5:0.0

    +"&&nteri! %roduct :3:.:

    +"& 103.:

    )inished %roducts 310.:

    +"& :.1

    +"&"re%aration 0.4

    +"& 72.5

    +"& 72.1.)*

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    13/54

    hinoEet :7.4

    /%arose 14.6

    (ucus tablet9 +lfos%an tablet 30.:

    Dro;i%oda ca%sule 2.1

    Nito%ress tablet 4.6

    $occata tablet9 #aEo%rin tablet 4.7

    +s%izone 3.

    22*"*

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    14/54

    ;.((*

    Assets

    Depreciation

    roperty) plant and equipment

    "lants and buildin's 7:4)acilit fi;tures and structures :35

    #achines and %rovision 12

    $ools9 e@ui%!ent9 structures and deliver e@ui%. 301

    (and 39:5:

    .)ood=ill 143

    $ele%hone )acilities ri'hts 6

    Soft=are 14

    .-,

    InBestment etc"&nvest!ent securities 32

    >uarant !one and lon' ter! %re%aid e;%. 61

    .2(

    or7ing Capital

    Current asstes:

    Cash and cash de%osits 39030

    Notes receivable 39:75

    +ccounts receivable 39265

    (ess +llo=ance for bad debt -:5

    &nventor 19017

    ther Current +ssets 242)1*2

    Current liabilities:

    Notes %aable 64

    $rade account %aables :74

    ther account %aables 135

    ,n%aid inco!e ta; :5

    De%osit sus%ense recei%t 13

    ,n%aid consu!%tion ta; 0

    1),*3

    &et or7ing Capital *)-.,

    Deferred assets 30

    Total Assets

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    15/54

    >uarantee !one received 567

    Debentures 39330

    etire!ent %ention reserve 17

    ,)2*3

    Total %iabilities and Capital

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    16/54

    ;.((+ ;.((, ;.((2 ;.((< ;.((- ;.((3

    :2 :63 :21

    515 45: 546

    720 73 2716 10 :01

    54 446 444

    311 63 64

    39:5: 39:5: 39:5:

    *)((- .)331 .)3

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    17/54

    403 566 406 406 406 406

    622 394: 39535 39535 39535 39535

    33 5 5 5 5

    2)1.+ 2)

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    18/54

    ;.(1( ;.(11 ;.(1. ;.(1* ;.(1+ ;.(1,

    :9120 :9120 :9120 :9120 :9120 :9120

    3:3 3:3 3:3 3:3 3:3 3:3

    1: 1: 1: 1: 1: 1:

    2)*(1

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    19/54

    406 406 406 406 406 406

    39535 39535 39535 39535 39535 39535

    5 5 5 5 5 5

    2)+,< 2)+,< 2)+,< 2)+,< 2)+,< 2)+,

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    27/54

    )uEi "har!a.

    339153

    15.76

    314.65

    340.7:

    74.7

    A.3

    A5.34

    326.44

    61

    7.43

    55.0

    70.00

    33.50

    3.20

    n.a

    :3.14

    2.2

    n#

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    28/54

    *orkin' Ca%ital &te! No. of das of sales

    Notes receivable 27

    +ccounts receivable 302

    &nventor 4

    Notes %aable -52

    $rade +ccounts %aable -34

    Net =orkin' ca%ital 105

    +ll other current assets and current liabilities !a be assu!ed to be e@ual to )81007 a

    Source "rovided b (u%in (td.

    Exhibit 11: =ey Income Related ro6ections

    a $he %roEection assu!es +%ril 1002 as the date of decision.

    b Sales are e;%ected to 'ro= at 2.529 34.0: and 31.76 for )810079 100 and 1006 res%

    c Cost of >oods Sold as a %ercenta'e of sales is e;%ected to re!ain at 21.0 and 21.40 du

    d )orecast about different co!%onents of S>

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    29/54

    ount. +ssu!in' ear has :24 das. (u%in is o%ti!istic about reducin' das inventor to 62 in )8103:

    ctivel. $hereafter9 it can be assu!ed that o=a sales =ill 'ro= at the sa!e rate as that of >enerics #

    rin' )81007 and )8100 res%ectivel.

    .10

    e. 30.7:

    =th fro! )81007 on=ards.

    n K durin' )81007 and )8 100 and 33 !illion K thereafter. Non-o%eratin' revenues Aincludin' intere

    t si; ear startin' )8100.

    515 !n A:2 !n for )810079 45: !n A:63!n for )8100 and 546 !n A:21 !n for )81006 res%ecti

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    30/54

    and thereafter.

    arket AScenario &&

    st and dividend received =as e;%ected to re!ain at 40 !illion K durin' )81007 - )81006. $hese ca

    el. $hereafter9 a reasonable assu!%tion to !ake is that the invest!ents in fi;ed assets =ould be e@u

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    31/54

    h flo=s !a be i'nored =hile co!%utin'

    l to the e;tent of that de%reciation char'ed.

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    32/54

    ;ear

    $cenario I $cen

    1002 30.5 .5 4.

    1007 3.3 6.4 33.:

    100 35.7 30. 6.

    1006 37.: 31.0 3:.2

    1030 .0 3:.: 4.5

    1033 3:.7 35.4 30.2

    1031 4.: 34.5 5.1

    103: 30.3 32.4 6.0

    1035 7.7 37.2 2.2

    1034 7.7 3.7 2.2

    1032 7.7 10.0 2.2

    1037 7.7 13.: 2.2

    103 7.7 11.7 2.2

    1036 7.7 15.: 2.2

    1010 7.7 14.6 2.2

    1013 3.0 14.6 2.2

    1011 3.0 14.6 2.2

    101: 3.0 14.6 2.2

    1015 3.0 14.6 2.2

    1014 3.0 14.6 2.2

    1012 3.0 14.6 2.2

    1017 3.0 14.6 2.2

    101 3.0 14.6 3.0

    1016 3.0 14.6 3.0

    10:0 3.0 14.6 3.0

    Source 8ano esearch &nstitute9 %rovided b (u%in (td.

    Exhibit 1.: 4eneric Drugs: 4ro'th Rate and $hare in Total harmaceutica

    4eneric: 4ro'th

    rate

    4eneric: $hare in

    total harma"

    mar7et

    4eneric: 4ro'th

    rate

    10.0%

    12.0%

    14.0%

    16.0%

    18.0%

    20.0%

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    33/54

    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 " 1011121314151617181"2021222320.0%

    2.0%

    4.0%

    6.0%

    8.0%

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    34/54

    rio II

    #arket Sales - o=o C>S

    7.4 ;.((2 3.07/I02 79464 0.73 5.6/I0:

    .3 ;.((< 3.3/I02 902 0.26 4.0/I0:

    .7 ;.((- 3.:6/I02 69:03 0.27 4.3/I0:

    6.4 ;.((3 3.20/I02 309560 0.22 2.40/I0:

    30.1 ;.(1( 3.7/I02 339::0 0.20 7.01/I0:

    30. ;.(11 1.01/I02 3191 0.25 7.66/I0:

    33.5 ;.(1. 1.:0/I02 3:9424 0.46 .53/I0:

    31.0 ;.(1* 1.51/I02 3596:4 0.21 6.12/I0:

    31.7 ;.(1+ 1.27/I02 32904 0.20 6.67/I0:

    3:.5 ;.(1, 1.7/I02 379:1: 0.20 3.07/I05

    35.3 ;.(12 :.06/I02 39247 0.20 3.32/I05

    35.6 ;.(1< :.::/I02 109065 0.20 3.14/I05

    34.7 ;.(1- :.46/I02 139253 0.20 3.:5/I05

    32.2 ;.(13 :.2/I02 1:9:07 0.20 3.54/I05

    37.4 ;.(.( 5.32/I02 149301 0.20 3.42/I05

    3.4 ;.(.1 5.5/I02 149:4: 0.47 3.47/I05

    36.4 ;.(.. 5.4:/I02 149202 0.47 3.46/I05

    10.2 ;.(.* 5.47/I02 14921 0.47 3.20/I05

    13.7 ;.(.+ 5.21/I02 129313 0.47 3.21/I05

    11.6 ;.(., 5.22/I02 129:1 0.47 3.25/I05

    15.1 ;.(.2 5.73/I02 129252 0.47 3.24/I05

    14.4 ;.(.< 5.72/I02 12963: 0.47 3.27/I05

    14.4 ;.(.- 5.0/I02 17931 0.47 3.26/I05

    14.4 ;.(.3 5.4/I02 179545 0.47 3.70/I05

    14.4 ;.(*( 5.60/I02 17971 0.47 3.71/I05

    ;.(*1 5.64/I02 17971 0.42 3.71/I05

    5ar7et

    4eneric: $hare in

    total harma"

    mar7et

    #!lu

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    35/54

    425

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    36/54

    Savin's-"roc Savin's-Site C>S - savin's >ross %rofit S>

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    37/54

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    38/54

    Sales Cost

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    39/54

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    40/54

    &nterest and dividenNon-o%eratin' e;%ense &nterest %aid? rdinar inco!e /;traordinar

    506 60

    463

    77 10

    39007 10

    3931 10

    39:42 10

    3954: 10

    3924: 10

    3913 10

    19003 10

    19362 10

    19507 10

    192:5 10

    197 10

    :935: 10

    :9375 10

    :9102 10

    :91: 10

    :9170 10

    :9:0: 10

    :9::2 10

    :9:26 10

    :950: 10

    :95:7 10

    :9573 10

    :9525 10

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    41/54

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    42/54

    Net inco!e b &nco!e ta;?? &et income a0ter tax

    :36 3:5 34

    463 15 :5:

    727 :11 554

    67 534 471

    3930 524 25:

    39::2 423 774

    395:: 201 :3

    392:: 22 657

    3903 742 39055

    3963 :1 39356

    19372 635 39121

    19:7 39001 39:5

    19235 3906 39432

    194 39103 3924

    :931: 39:33 3933

    :9345 39:14 3916

    :932 39:: 395

    :913 39:43 3922

    :9140 39:24 394

    :91: 39:76 39605

    :9:32 39:6: 3961:

    :9:56 39507 3965:

    :9:: 39513 39621

    :9537 395:4 3961

    :9543 39540 19001

    :9555 39557 3966

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    43/54

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    44/54

    hase 5olecules ty =g# $aBingsF=g

    "hase 3

    341 33000 3.27

    140 1000 0.4

    20 6000 0.45

    3:0 3740 0.1:

    30 1400 0.54

    20 30000 0.2

    "hase 3

    0.331 :000000 0.:5

    70 100 0.32

    20 :400 0.133 :00000 0.:

    0 1000 0.32

    $a; benefits

    &t is also e;%ected that (u%in =ill save M0.55 !n on bulk %rocure!ent of +"& in )8 1

    $he %otential ta; savin's due to relocation of certain !anufacturin' activities to &ndia

    )or esti!atin' ter!inal value9 one !a assu!e that (u%in =ill be able to save a!ount

    Source "rovided b (u%in (td.

    5

    .((31(

    anel A: $aBings 0rom site Bariation to India !("((

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    45/54

    Source "rovided b (u%in (td.

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    46/54

    .((31(

    0 0.5 3.27 3.70

    0 0.14 0.40 0.43

    0 0.17 0.45 0.44

    0 0.31 0.1: 0.1:

    0 0.1: 0.54 0.52

    0 0.:0 0.20 0.23

    0 0 0.37 0.:5

    0 0 0.0 0.32

    0 0 0.33 0.130 0 0.34 0.:0

    0 0 0.0 0.32

    0.11 0.12 0.55 0.41

    30

    =as e;%ected to be ,SD 0.11 !n9 0.12!n9 0.55 !n and 0.41 !n res%ectivel for )81030 to )8103:

    s si!ilar to )8103: durin' future ears

    4 2 7

    .(1(11 .(111. .(1.1*

    es o0 !("((.1Ftablet# usd to E%

    300 140 400 -

    0.74 3.74 :.74 2.:

    :00 400 740 -

    0.54 0.74 3.314 1.5

    :.544 7.25 30.2:5 r

    :.544 7.25 340.716:4:6 '

    1.52 4.0 6:.4: 11)1+

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    47/54

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    48/54

    330

    7.02

    0

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    49/54

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    50/54

    Item

    Ja%anese 30 r >ovt Bond A2 !onths avera'e to )ebruar 19 1007

    isk %re!iu! in the Ja%anese !arket?

    Size "re!iu! in Ja%an

    Cost of Debt for si!ilar co!%anies

    +fter-ta; Cost of Debt

    /;chan'e rate AJ"8,SD

    /;chan'e rate AJ"8&N

    ?+vailable fro! &bbotson +ssociates Ja%anese /@uit isk "re!ia e%ort 1002

    Source "rovided b (u%in (td.

    *+CC

    rccf

    /

    D/

    rf

    !r%

    $

    beta u

    beta l

    re

    Exhibit 1,: =ey $toc7 5ar7et and Exchange Rate In0ormation

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    51/54

    Rate

    3.26

    4.0

    :.64

    1.5:

    3.53 3.53

    330

    1.7:

    7.02

    7.52

    0.2 DV 0.50 /V 0.2

    3.26

    4.0

    51

    0.4:4

    0.61

    30.1

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    52/54

    0.2222222227

    0.:437:077

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    53/54

    &nfor!ation $o=a "har!a. )uEi "har!a.

    /VSales 1.26 3.6 3.62 3.1/V/B&$ 37.01 34.5 34.5 6

    /V/B&$D+ 31.1 31.63 33.:3 2.45

    "/ atio 16.07 15 12.77 37.1

    "rice to book value 16.62 13.55 46.63 36.6:

    Beta 0.4: 0.53 0.26 0.2: 0.424

    ,nlevered beta 0.5 0.:4 0.2 0.2: 0.4:4

    Source "rovided b (u%in (td.

    Exhibit 12: 5ar7et 5ultiples o0 5a6or Comparables

    Sa=ai"har!a.

    Nichi-lko"har!a.

    Note $he O"rice to BookL ratio based on 1002 infor!ation9 re!ainin' are based on infor!ation in #arch

  • 7/24/2019 20151028 Lupin-Case Exhibits for Distribution

    54/54

    1007