2011-11-15 - London, Ontariocouncil.london.ca/CouncilArchives/Reports and... · Beer market trends:...
Transcript of 2011-11-15 - London, Ontariocouncil.london.ca/CouncilArchives/Reports and... · Beer market trends:...
2011-11-15
EMC is Lean and Linked ... Over 150,000 individual Members! EMC: 950+ Corporate Mfg. Members! Over 5000 members engaged each week! Communication reach to al l sectors: 100,000+ touch points every week! 53 Consortium Regions
1
2011-11-15
0
0
2
2011-11-15
0
Why Focus on Manufacturers?
There are three primary methods of creating new wealth in our economy:
1. You BUILD it.
2. You GROW it.
3. You DIG it out of the ground.
The MANUFACTURING SECTOR has the greatest potential t o rapidly affect change in our local economy ...
3
2011-11-15
Cha I lenges for Industry ... China Syndrome: Increasing competition from China, Mexico, India ... and around the World
Aging Canadian Workforce: Within the next decade:
- For every 2 people who retire, only one person will be available to replace those positions
Canadian Dollar: +$ Par is not always a good score! Rising Cost of Business: - Energy, Utilities, Health Care Benefits and Overall
Business costs are continuing to grow
EMC Presence in London
Members in the Food & Beverage sector: Labatt The Original Cakerie Kellogg McCormick Canada
* Cargill Argo Pure (Bright Cheese) Heritage Coffee Kerry Canada
All employ 100+ (except Heritage Coffee)
4
2011-11-E
Our challenge is to level the field.
5
1511 11201 1
November Sth, 2011
Brewing beer in London since 1847
Part of Anheuser-Busch InBev: 18 breweries in North America Focus on 'Better World' initiatives:
- -
i. Environmental, Community & Responsible U5e
Compete externally with other beer comDanies for &
Compete internally with other Labatt breweries for Droduction volume ,
, Proven water conservation
London Brewery is Labatt's "Hometown Brewery". We are proud of our London heritage
1
15/11/2011
~~ ~~~~~~~~ ~~~ ~. ~~ ~~ ~~ ~
$27 Million in salary and wages
450 employees
Since 2004, $77 rniiiion in capital expenditures
Normal course of business economic spinoffs - transportation, raw materials to name a few
Sponsorship
Community investment
MUSEUM LONDON
2
15/11/2011
.~.. ~~ ~~~ ~ ~~~ ~~
Our London Brewery has extra capacity to draw new brands, volume into the plant - we can grow
Beer market trends: smaller size, specialty brands - - Must justify volume addition by being the low cost producer
Additional volume may require new capital expenditures which will bring construction investment into London‘s economy
London Brewery is “Open for Business“ but need City of London‘s support to keep us competitive & relevant in decisions to allocate brewery volume
- - _ -~ _ _ ~
45% REDUCTION ! Winner of OWWA 2011 Award of Excellence in Water Efficiency
London Water Usage 2005 to 2012 - ~~ -~
E t
3
15/11/2011
$0.80
$0.70 -- __-___...
57% INCREASE IN RATE OVER 7 YEARS INCREASES ARE MUCH HIGHER THEN INFLATION
-Total Water & Sewer Rate - actual
+Total Water & Sewer Rate - CPI inflation
-
Labatt London Water & Sewer Rate
~ ...... ~.~ ......... ~
.. ~ ~ ~. .~ ~~~ . ~~ ~. Compete internally with other Labatt breweries for production volume - must stav a low cost Droducer in order to arow and re-invest in London
Labatt is London proud - 167 years - Brewery employees - Construction jobs - Materials, Transportation, etc. - Community investment
Proven water conservation BUT this is not producing cost savings due to large increases annually t o water and sewer rates
RECOMMENDATION: Continue water rate freeze or reduce any rate increase to be in line with rate of inflation
4
Combined water and sanitary sewer rate changes - -
2010 vs 2005 - 82% increase in spending on 9% lower aggregate volume 2009 vs 2005 net of strength surcharges (phosphorous)- 32% increase on 4.5% lower aggregate volume
City of London chose to begin billing for Phosphorous in 2007 (in accordance with existing bylaws) which added significant incremental costs to Casco - Phosphorous comes in as part of the corn and reports to sludge in our pre-treatment
system. Phosphorous could be removed based on trial work here with clarification and sludge dewatering (42 .5MM capital cost)
Average unit potable water costs for sister operations in USlCanada are 50% of London’s current rate with closest being California - still 23% lower than London’s 2007 rate Incremental costs already realized for Casco represent lOFTE Parent corporation expects us to deliver 2-3% savingdyear. All increases in costs realized are expected to be offset with savings in other areas Contradicts the City’s strategic decision attract and retain businesses in the Agrifood /Agribusiness sector by incrementally reducing attractiveness and competitiveness
-
Planning, Environmental & Engineering
Water and Wastewater Services “Critical” fundamental public services - Health care and Environmental Business
Protection and maintenance of health
- Fire Protection Saves lives
- Quality of Life Services Water supply and Wastewater treatment
1
Water and Wastew
Renewal, operation and maintenance of water supply and wastewater and treatment systems
Drinking water quality management compliance Long-term system planning and modeling Customer billing contract management
Reservoirs, Pump Stations, Pipes, Water Meters, Storm Water Management Facilities, Treatment Plants
- Sewer $3.6 billion
Why We Need To Invest Proper operation of the system for the health of Londoners Support economic development and growth Enable us to live and grow as a community Address the infrastructure gap - Renew aging and deteriorating infrastructure
Compliance with regulatory/environmental requirements Consumption reductions Ensure intergenerational equity - While deferring future expansions
Avoiding future debt
2
Water Consumption I
--. . _-. , C 1 * . * &
Addressing Revenue Reductions Due to Declining Water Consumption?
o Rate Structure Review analysis underway Cost of servicing rate review (Deferred) Fixed component vs. variable component - Anticipated reporting back to Council by year-end
o Exploring opportunities to generate other revenue
o Utilize Senior Government funding opportunities sources
,Future rate increases to be adjusted if other funding urces become available
3
Water & WWT Financial Infrastructure Gap Financial Infrastructure Gap - Combined W a t e r W infrastructure
gap = $450 M+ I WATER 8 WWT - Objective to manage gap to acceptable
levels (cannot eliminate) "Gap"showing up as - frequent equipment failures, main
- more extensiveltoo frequent breaks, etc.
- Addressing consumption decline cunm - Increasing capital funding rpnr 2ol&..Iulurc
. . - Leveraging new technology I innovation ,.I .,.to minimize operating costs , ,
4
- 2012 Utility Budgets
n NEED TO INVEST "
Sustaining Our Future
1 Utility strategy: - Continued protection of health and environment - Support economic development
Generate jobs Industrial strategy
Fire protection Quality management and quantity management
- Investing in service improvement
5
Residential Charges - Water/ WWT
ComRorcIaI Charges .Water IWWT
1
IndustrialCharges. Water1 WWT
S IC00 I
Residential Rate Change Comparison 2010 - 2011
l% 8 Water W sanitary
6
Long-Term Financial Sustainability Impacts
WATER
Residential Water Savings Average Cost of Annual Water Blll
(persingle farnllyhorne) 0 .
. .- . .
CnlarrUmYiw .Iwml*wlll M(m'n7Jlhod
......... "
. . . . . .
7
Strategies For Reducing Consumption And Ultimately Costs
a
Water $1 - refill your reusable bottle 1,238 times
I Average cost per day = 87 cents
Sewer A flus I
I costs less than 2@
--..--,. C " " A O * lI/li~''~'~"
It Is Therefore Recommended ....
To increase Water rates by 8% and
Wastewater and Treatment rates by 7%
9
QUESTIONS?
Water Background
Asset Value of $1.8 billion (including Joint Water Boards plant & pipelines) High water quality & service reliability (incl. fire protection)
Infrastructure risk mitigation - Failure cost, property damage, lost water and social disruption
Increasing regulatory standards Revised Financial Plan received by the MMAH in 201 1
10
C * U * D *
Wastewater & Treatment Background
Asset Value of $3.6 billion
Many system deficiencies developed over decades
Significant investment required
High debt servicing costs b 201 1 - debt servicing of 13.2M and total potential
debt of $1 30M
Value b huge benefit to community
\ Sustainability in 2018 \
11
Lifecycle Renewa I
Trenchless installation of a new replacement main utilizing a
directional drill unit
, ,. , . , . ,, .,..,, ,' . , . , . ~,.;,,'.:.: .
. . , , . . , .,
Trenchless Reha Tech n i a ues
,, .':Cement , ., mortar lining providing Structural lining providing <&a$erq.uality ::::' ~.> x~ ~.. and hydraulic ..,,.R$@~,ditioning of an existing main
water quality, hydraulic and structural reconditioning of an existing main
,'\~,, ., .~ ~, ..;. .,
12
Approach to New
Reduced excavation Proactive inspection and reinstatement and monitoring
, . .
'.. ,.
Centre Cres Dufferin Ave Hole in the pipe along with cracks and fractures in
sanitary sewer Start of a collapse in the storm sewer
13
2012 Sewer Works Horton St E Burnside Dr
Improperly cappedabandoned PDCs allowing bedding granular material to enter pipe
(Sanitary sewer)
Heavy encrustation caused by infiltration, along with cracks and possibly fractures (Sanitary sewer)
Gordon Avenue Emergency Work
Major trunk sewer - >27 MLD dry weather flows up to 200 MLD peak wet weather flows Successful relining - quick turn around - more to come
14
Water Scenario 3% In 2012 And Beyond
30 0% ... .. . . .... ~~ ~ -
-. 20.05 (Y
E .- 15.0% -
Water Scenario Prior Year Financial Plan
a20
$0
___---------- 25.0%
2023 2024 2025 2326 2027 2028 2029 2030 , I , / , , . I I . ! , ,
15
Recommended Financial Plan
R
0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 5.0% 3 . W 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0% 3.0s * A - - - . - A - - - - - _ _ - - - - - - - - -
. , .. . , ., . .. , . ..
; , . I I . , I . , , I . , I , I . I . L
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2C17 2018 2010 2020 2021 2M2 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 202s 2oB 2030 2031
Y E I l
' , , . ,
I -R"I1.FyI- --imR"Il.Fw8.UK. ,, 0- - C U D * R ' . I I I I U Y . 1
30 0%
25.096
20 0%
i
i o 0% ; 150%
E - z?
r son 2
D *
0 0%
3% In 2012 And Beyond
Rate & Debt Comparison 3 R r n
e P 100%
- A n n u a l m e Increase --DebtJeNtclngloRevenue -Cvbt Llmlt
5 Year Capital Plan Impact - ($41 M)
16
Prior Year Financial Plan
1: ',. .... . . . , .,,, . . .
. , . ,. ' , , . . . -hnnualRate Ixrem -DebtServiclng To Reven~e -Debtlimit
5 Year Capital Plan Impact - ($5 M) . . , . ' 20 Year Capital Plan Impact - ($80 M)
WWT Scenario Recommended Financial Plan
5 Year Capital Plan Impact - $0
17
London Is A Top Performer Non-Revenue Water
Goals of Strategic Financial Plan
18
Sewer - Residential
$700 ,
MUNICIPALITY
Water- Residential
1700
MUNICIPALITY
19
Value to the C
I
Long-Term Financial Sustai na bi lity Impacts WATER
Rate Scenarios
20