2010isss.jp.net/isss-site/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/C-2.pdf2010 Triggering of resident evacuation...
Transcript of 2010isss.jp.net/isss-site/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/C-2.pdf2010 Triggering of resident evacuation...
2010��������� ����������
Triggering of resident evacuation from tsunamis caused by Chile Earthquake in 2010
�� ���1�� �
2
Shinichiro MORI
1 and Naoki MATSUURA
2
1 � ��� ��������� / ���������� Center for Research on Disaster Mitigation Informatics, Ehime Univercity 2 � �� !"#$%&'()� ����*�+, Ehime Prefecture (Former undergraduate sudent of Ehime University)
Tsunami warning of major tsunami/tsunami was issued by The Japan Meteorological Agency (JMA) in the morning of the next day of occurrence of the magnitude 8.8 earthquake off the Chilean coast on February 27, 2010, and it was followed by issuance of evacuation warning alerts by local goverments in Pacific Ocean coastal regoins. Authors have conducted a series of investigation on resident evacuation from the tsunami expected to hit the regions, by personal interviews to 381 residents in 82 districts of 25 cities and towns in Ehime, Kochi and Tokushima Prefectures in Shikou region. Moreover, a comparative study was carried out in Iwate and Chiba Prefectures as well. This paper discusses the triggering of evacuation of residential people in the three Shikoku prefectures. Keywords: tsunami, evacuation, interview survey, triggering, 2010 Chile Earthquake tsunami
����� � -./0�2010123456789:;<=>?@AB>CDEFGH8:;IJEKL8201013MHG7M8HNOCPQRS4T><=U��VW�XY8Z[
\O�?@Q]H^R<=>_`)ab)AB>cdJ
?@QR<=>?@AB>e3f�8g\OhiEjk
;IJlKLTm;n201113M11o8p+QRqr4stuvw458x;yz�{|67�}E~�)XYQ
Rl��>IJ0��)�j80`�QO\]\n 201012M27o'",15:34823�*�����60 kmTp+QR���2W��'Mw,8.8>��458x�p+QR67l��28o'o,��o-��8��Q�o-��>tuv��z8�R��\&T1�3 m>��>67l����;JQO� ¡¢HG67£�'�*
T0�67£�,l¤�����E¥NO¦4>§!¨
T0?@©ª'�*T0?@«¬,lp��RnQH
Q�¦4T®¯��R67��0°�E±²��³QO
´10 cmJµ�¶�67·}J\¸¹T0º\Tm^Rn�s�67£�>p»?@«¬)©ª>p]¼>�
�A½HG>��p¾8¿HH�GÀ�ÁÂ4z>�Ã
?@Ä&Å>?@ÆlÇH^R1) n(1)67>°ÈJ£�p� (2)É>��ÊËÌÊ>9Í�(3)4s§!¨8x;?@AB>ÎÏ�(4)67J?@8Ê:;�Ð]¼HG�ÑÒÓJQOÔ>3Ó8Õ���;J`ÖR2)n )� ?@9¡4×Ø<Ù´89:;?@Ù´>ÚÆTm
;?@ÆlÇ\'RJÖÛ�uÜ?@Æ3.8%]¼,n )� ?@QO¿Ý17K>��°ÞÃßEcàRáHGâãÙlS��67��lä�J];ÃåæT?@Ä
&8çè:;éêlëìQO\;n )� cí867·}E¥NO\;4zT�Ö¿?@Æl
Ç\JIîlï\n Sè�ðñ45)qðñ45EòóJ:;�45>p
+liôæ�Oõ��ö8ñ�*T>67·}>Çë0�
?@AB>÷ø8HH^O\;Ró�ù44567Jo
->úûôûüzT>4567>ý\I�m��I>Ñ
Ò89:;÷þ]$C��J��8Z[¶<=>���
�J?@AB��>x���]�lH�]\n�>
Ró80� ²>2345678õN;§��� �>
?@ÎÏJ��><=>?@AB>CDJ��GAB�
Þ>cd]¼>��0�4z����>®ÓHG¿��
J`ÖG�Rl�¦4zT>CD>XY0��T�]\n �IT��ÙG0��É8õ\O�67£�lp�
�R9¡4z�m;\0�?@©ªlp��R¦��
�>9¡4zE9¡8QO�<=>?@AB8Ê:;C
DJ��8ÊQO�S4U��VW�XYEA¸JJ¿
8� �O�4!)4"»#�)Õ$>%&¿®'QRn
�>�åL]()8g\O0:T8�ªQR2)n�G8�
4s8x;*+EÚ,)��:;Ró8�-.s/T�
01�>6��8õ\O¿XYQRnä2L8��É3�25���824×3813J01�6��1003><=8U��VW�lT�Rn�ÙG>XY0�4�5�eXY]¼
JÚk;J6�78´0ì]\l�9:¹:8x;J\
¸Ólö;LTm;n ]õ�-��><)0�É"=>?�É4s@ABC
8DNG�RE�É8õN;45)679F4�GUH
3�IJK'LMN�1OP �h��QR,>E20101234567XY���ªS�201112M28oK850T�U8�R�æJóG�O\;n-./0�>�*Tm;n
������������ !"#�$%&' (1)� XY9¡4z � ��V����h�8õ\O� ¡¢x�67£
�lpW��R�O>���'"X�YZ0���l?
@©ªEpQR,>ñ��\>4×><=E9¡JQ
Rnö8�?@©ª>p��R4×T¿�ä¿[�>
Ç\×z<=�:]�\�4×CT¿67·�3]^>
地域安全学会梗概集 No.28, 2011. 5
- 57 -
�
ä¿�\×z><=Å>XYE�_8`\Rn � �N5��234×1703��h�N16��444×
1353�V��4��154×763��É3�25�824×3813><=89QO�§aõxbc&<=>?@ABJA
½)d�eõxb§��� �>?@ÎÏ8Ê:;S4
U��VW�XYEA^Rnf-18XY4ÓE¬:n�É>?@AB8m;�ghJöihEijó;IJEK
LJQO�Ú,>Ró>01�Jkl�>XY0���
m�6M84oåJ7M82oåTnk1038x^Rn�É4z>XY0�3M3oHG5M21oæT>�Ô'�z,J6M26oHG7M6oæT>oÔ'�ð�pqXY,8rN�ê�7²15oåTnk3638x�CPQRn-./T0��É4s>ûs�t¸n (2)� U��VW�XY>s/ � �3>AB��>uv�wx�»4zyz>CD>
��8{KQRn ²>67°È��J4z>4"»[
�HGiO673]^l�\Jab��;4z>S48
A���IT>�>A3�Z¤3�|Ê}»§ã~8\
;3��Z)�Z»��T>��Ù]¼�XYÙJKE
9:ê��O:cT�;3E�]9¡JQRnm;\0�
�ãE�ÑQOXYQRnS4T>>A3»Z¤3E9
¡JQR����8U��VW�XY8x���3õx
bØ<4z>?@AB>CDEh;IJEKLJQRn
�>Ró�´38U��VW�:;IJ8x���E�
�:;IJE�ûRn U��VW�XY8���]�+8��>s/E��
��;Ró�0.ó0~�>m;Q�J��8XYEA
^Rn²´E��R�8�Q�l6�U��VW4�8
]��+8U��VW�E��O���Ef^Rn��
QRIJE��QR�0���TXYE��Rn � XY�K0�67Áo>&è4��3»4z<=>?
@AB>$C��3>?@AB>������3>?@
AB>pq�?@Q]H^R���©ªpHG�æ
T>���Õ�B�4zT>A½>?@ÎÏ�B>CD�
?@Ä&�4z>§����B>%&�� >?@¡¢
%&J£¤d¥�c&>?@AB'h^O\�Û?@Ù
>�3¦,�cí>4567'19461§¨ðñ45�19601234567,>�©»�>%&]¼Tm;n U��VW�/0�ª�Lr«><¬hE`�Qgg�
9¡Ù>�3L4zLöh>¤8z®Tm;J>®Ó
HG¯°±²U��VW�>1/EJ^RnÄê8x^
O�?@Ù>³¦)<Ø]¼>ÊË��l�G�RÄê
80��ÑQOU��VW�:;IJE´}QRn U��VW�XYT0�µ�eÅ>u¶Es�]lG
A\�IC·¸�¹�8x�IºE�»QRnØã8�ÑQOU��VW�XY:;Äê80�¼½E�O�V¾
¿B�EÀÁQRnIº>ÂÃJCÄ�lÄÅ8];n
I�G>IC·¸�¹�'»V¾¿,8x;�»QRIº0�ÆÇ�O�eÈ�]^37ÉÊ�'/ËÌIQ,E
A^RnW-18����8U��VW�XY>ÍÑ�KJ¾��@�>s/E¬:nW�Î0�4×0Ï/ËT
2-3>¸��T�¾��r«Î>�3>öÞ0Ð4׸��8U��VW�EA^RÑTËÒ>>QÓÔEÕÖQ�
×h0M�Øh0FJW�QRnhÙErN;>0�hÙTAB"D)_`"Dl+];HGTm;Ú � ù445Tm;Ró67��>Û1YZ8�}3]^
>�hl�ÜÝTm;IJE`Ö�?@©ª>Þh8ß
àQO?@QRÙEÝBL?@Ù�d�e�»§���
�á�»c&>3HG9:âbHNG�RIJ8x^
O?@E��Q?@QRÙE¥BL?@ÙJâãn (�$%)*+,-.,/0NKR�12 I>4×0�� ��ð�>34]äñ�8å`QO
\;n67>��1m>67£�lpW���I>4×T0�224æü�5313E9¡8?@©ªlp��O\Rl�d�T0?@Ùl����O\]\n f-28NKR4×>4"J[�ç�è�é>êë£ìz
JQO[�5mJ�«Þ�?@z>[�10mE¬:n«Þ
��
�
f-1� <=67?@ABU��VW�XY4Ó'�É,
���
���
���
�
� ��
���
���
����
��������
����
��� ���
���
!"�
���
#$�
%&�
'()�
*+�
,��
-.�
/0�
12�
34�#%�
$�56��
���
���
���
�
� ��
���
���
����
��������
����
��� ���
���
!"�
���
#$�
%&�
'()�
*+�
,��
-.�
/0�
12�
34�#%�
$�56��
���8�í7'http://maps.google.co.jp/,Eîï
789:; <=>? <=@A
BCDE
BCFGH IJ9KL8MF NOMPQMPFR
BCFGH IJ9KL8ST �UAVW
XYZ��P�UAVW[BCF\1]^_`abcdePf�cde
gFXST hijklm`YT
nopqrspt uvqmPwxtPyzPN{PZ|}`~�
BCFGH IJ9KL�8 ��pP��p
BCFGH ��J����98 ��J����98q�W���~tP����8
��y Z��`����P�0��`��
� 0¡¢v������`��P£¤`��P¥�H¦§¨©ªFR
��«¨��`¬P��`®¯P��STP°±FRP©ªFRP��F²
³´Cµ���k¶�·^¸kCµP��¹ºk¶¹º·^¸kCµP��»©ª�kCµ
����»�¸k¦¼½¾KP�¿ÀPÁ¯ÃÄÅP��5Æ�ÇPÈÁh¨ÇPÈÁÉÊPhËÁÂÌ`ÍPÎT`ÍPÏÐ
ÑÒ`��«¨ ÓÔÕÖ
��ST`×Ø ÓÔÕÖ
��«¨ÙÚÛÜÝÞß ÓÔÕÖ
nopàáâÜ=ãß ÓÔÕÖ
ÔÕÖ Âäåoæçè éê`ÂäëoPéê`Âäçè
ÓÔÕÖ ì¼`��íî Z�`ïðPÏÐ`ñòPóÍ`ñò
ÓÔÕÖ ôõLö÷8øùJ Z�`úû¹PÏÐü`ýþüþPÑÒü`ýþüþ
ÓÔÕÖ gZ`�0�¹c�de ��PA�Pç�
ÔÕÖIJ9KL8q��t
ÔÕÖIJ9KL8q��t
ÓÔÕÖIJ9KL8
�8��IJ9KL8�`<=@Aü789BC`�
W-1� ����8U��VW�XY>ÍÑ�KJ¾��@�>s/�
NKR-3F
NKR-1F
NKR-2F
NKR-4F
NKR-1M
��
NKR-5F
NKR-6F
�8��8S
NKR-2M
NKR-3M
��p
��p
�`m
�F��ST
NKR-4M
NKR-8M NKR-8F
NKR-9M
NKR-5M,6M,7M
NKR-10M
NKR-14F
NKR-9F
NKR-11F
NKR-10F
NKR-11M
NKR-12F
NKR-13F
NKR-12M NKR-7F
NKR-3F
NKR-1F
NKR-2F
NKR-4F
NKR-1M
��
NKR-5F
NKR-6F
�8��8S
NKR-2M
NKR-3M
��p
��p
�`m
�F��ST
��p
��p
�`m
�F��ST
NKR-4M
NKR-8M NKR-8F
NKR-9M
NKR-5M,6M,7M
NKR-10M
NKR-14F
NKR-9F
NKR-11F
NKR-10F
NKR-11M
NKR-12F
NKR-13F
NKR-12M NKR-7F
f-2 �ð� NKR4×>4"J·�Ùrð�
- 58 -
�
?@Ä&�U��VW�9¡Ù&è4Óç¿ �O¬Q
RnI>4×019601234567Têë~�lm�'Y(HG>ñ�s�XYTaFQO\;,�NKR��ò0�ÉL�ò��QóT>ôõ¥õòTm;]¼>ö
;lm;n§¨ðñ45T0ö�70��H^Rlêë
QO\]\n26¦8U��VW�QRnU��VW�XYT�26¦�3¦0?@QO\RIJ�?@Ä&Å>?@Ù8÷øQRIJ�ù?@ÙHG¿?@Ùl\RIJE
ñ¶IJlT�RnI>XYT0�1960234567T>êëE´30ú^RlÐï¶>30EêëQ]H^
RKJbÞQO\R>lûK:k�IJTm^Rn ?@QRüQ]\>¦�ýEþ�:;n � NKR-1F��N70�Øh����Ù>�J23�GQn?@©ªp�:8�Z8<�'40� ,HGE?@:;]G�ó8QRƸl\\HG�KJ\¸�ºl
m^Rl�c&>3J��Q�?@:;��0]\Ja
bQRn��T¿�>Ró8?@>�A0QRn�l?
@���ÙTm;Ró�z$>�80c&>s8�O¿
G¸x¸8QOõ��Áÿc&H>3HG�E?@�
�;�KJË�lm^R��E¼¸H]�KJ�Å>�
Ñlm^R�QRn��0?@E�¶©ó;x¸]CÄ
T0]\J�.Rn§ã(>�Î8\RJIî�d�e
>sHGE¼¸T:H�� ���T:H�KJ�EHN
G�Rn(B�?@0QO\]\n�o�c&>3HG
��Ùl 3H!="8?@QRJñ\Rn � I>·�Ù0�§r�3T0ab8#\?@AB>e
3f�lHNG�À���$è��>ÆH�c%Ù)c
&)d�e]¼5¦x�?@8ÊQO&\âbHNlm^R8¿HH�GÀ�\À�¿abE-38'(�;¿>
Tm��()L8?@Q]\J\¸abEQRl��o�
?@QR3l\;J>IJl�H^RJ>¶(�>Iº
>��)*JQ]\W�8+�^Rn NKR-4F��N50�Øh�13�GQnU��VW�4
ÓT§,-'§ã0ÙãT� 8å`,E,�T\;n
§ã(>�Î8\RJIî�d�>3HG�E67£�
lpW��O\æ:HG�!="»];k¶�\JIî
8?@QO¶(�\nKJ\¸?@>âbHNE¥N;n
§a0�.>"%HG�/0QO\]H^Rl�9:â
bHNG�RRó� 8m;§ã8âã'?@,QRn
19601>234567Ã0�-4×8Ø<QO]\Ró67>~�]Qnc&>3J0��QO\]\n13H
GE!="8A¶�KJ\¸�ºlm^Rl�§ãl!
="x�¿� 8å`:;Ró§ã8â;J23QRn
�8�!="810¦d¥?@QRJñ\Rn I>·�Ù0�cí>67¨�0]¶��®T?@>
��E�.O\]H^Rl�13HG>?@>Î\Jd
�>�\âbHN8x�?@E�bQRn�oñ\R4
Ù>?@AB8§5>ab>÷þhE��:;x¸]W
�)úXTm^Rn I>2ý0���É687íe8�^8x;?@>�
\âbHN0?@>e3f�EHN;'?@>�bE:
;,9ïJQOz®Tm;IJE¬QO\;:¹�7í
e8�^l;<T¿=�E>:x¸]��l]\J®)
l]\IJE9?L8¬QO\;n 3�$%45�6789: (1)� ·�Ù>°< f-3(a)8U��VW�XY·�Ù>�É3��¨T>hÙéêE¬:n²3Ù>×ØÚ04:6Tm��§��� �E9¡8QR4�5�eXY]¼T0×hl8éYÎE@ó;IJE`Ö�Û�3AÚÆ8c\JBÖ;nf-
3(b)8-.¶�É3��¨>1�CÙ>éêE¬:n60�J70�>ê�l¯rE@ó�80�J50�l��m�1/8ÀgTm;n10�HG40�æT>Cl2éƼDæ�O\;>lö;Tm;n (2)� ?@Æ f-48U��VW�XY·�Ù>?@ÆE¬:n�É
�¨T026%8];l�¦�TXYE¥]¼l+];>T��ÀQ¿�>öhEFC8WQO\;�NT0]\n
���ÙTi;J�-.�C�G::;���T¿�?
@Æ0��¶+]^Rn f-58hÙ8x;?@ABE¬:nØhl×h>1.5H
>?@ÆTm;nS%�§����B0×hl�¨J]
^O\;l�Øh>sl3]^��]l�\JBÖ;n
f-681�CÙ8x;XY·�Ù>?@ABE¬:n60�YÎl?@Æl�¶�3]^��]lI�Tm;nQ
HQ�50�lä¿?@ÆlǶ�?@Q]\ABEJ^O\;n�J^K\3]^��]H¿Q�]\n10�>?@Æ0�30�40�J-d¥Tm��LM>N�E`ÖR?@AB'Ö>-Æ>()J_��;n (3)� ?@QR�O �É3��¨T>?@ABE��QRä�>�O>éêEi;J�äïlE?@��;�(HGK'18%,Tm^Rn?@��;�8\;IJl?@ÆEPÎ��O\
;n?@�Q>RS0?@AB>T¤8g]l;ÜÝh
�
43%
39%
42%
50%
57%
61%
58%
50%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
��3�(381)
���(170)
���(76)
���(135)
��(%)
3%
4%
7%
1%
1%
1%
1%
5%
6%
7%
2%
6%
8%
7%
2%
13%
14%
9%
15%
26%
22%
28%
30%
28%
25%
21%
35%
13%
15%
13%
10%
6%
5%
8%
4%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
��3�(381)
���(170)
���(76)
���(135)
�É
�
��(%)
60�
70�
80���
�
�
50�
40�
30�
20�
10�
(a)×ØÚ� � � � � (b)1�CÙéê f-3� ·�Ù>Uh
��«¨`��q���k^P�·^¸k^t
���
��
��
� �
�
!�
�
���
� �
!��
! �
�
"� �"� �"� �"� �"� ""�
���
���
���
��#�
rs
$|
��q%t
�k
¹ºk
º&
���������
29.6%
20.0%74.5%
65.7%3.2%
3.0%2.4%
1.4%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
��(165)
�� 216�
��
� %�
���� 97� ���� 265�
��� 12� �� 7�
n=381
�������
77%
100%
68%
77%
80%
66%
70%
57%
76%14%
29%26%
31%
16%23%
26%
0%
23% 0%
0%
0%0%
0%
1%
4%
12%
5%
0%
2%
5%
2%
4%
0%
5%
0%
0%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
10� 13�
20� 2�
30� 19�
40� 22�
50� 50�
60� 99�
70� 106�
80��� 49�
�� 21�
���
� %�
���� 97� ���� 265���� 12� �� 7�
n=381
f-4� U��VW�XY·�Ù>?@AB'?@Æ,�
f-5� hÙ8x;XY·�Ù>?@AB'?@Æ,�
f-6� 1�CÙ8x;XY·�Ù>?@AB'?@Æ,�
- 59 -
�
lm;n §5>N�>Ró8?@:;3T0�§���>3)
×M)d�e>3]¼HG9:�?@>âbHNE¥N
RHG'16V,Jä¿ïH^Rn�����$è�y�W]¼HG>?@>âbHNlm^RHG'14%,�?@©ªl¤RHG'10%,l��8Ò¶nc&)%XHG?@>Ë�)âbHNE¥NRHG'3%,Eäï>16%8¤Ö;J19%J];n§5>Ró8?@QR3(NE`Ö�Û���m�>éê0�20%�18%�13%�24%J];nd�e»c&)%X)�Y]¼HG>9:>âbHNl�?@QRä�>�OJQO1/4>3lZ[O\;IJ8];n�G8���$è»y�W]¼8x
;��'d�,8x;âbHNE¤Ö;J�9:å:>
âbHNl?@>�^HJ];>l38%��4é>?@Ù0âbHNlm^RHG?@E��QRJ`ÖG�;n
E?@>¢�>g¿�KT?@QR3l4%\;nc&>3>?@:;\L»?@�QQO\;\LEiR>E�
b�O8QO\;3l3%\;n I�G>?@�b'e3f�,�O80�×Ø*lm
;J_��;nf-78×ØÙ8?@ABE��QRä�>�O>éêE¬:n×ØT]F]ý\lS�O\;n
×hT0�E?@��;Kläï'4é,Tm��^ILáé>ÕÖlz®Tm;JBÖ;n_å>+²EiOA
BE�ó;JHcí>~�EÈÌ:;]¼��¨L8A
B`àEaó;bPlm����lABEcd:;JB
Ö;n�s�ØhT0�E9:)å:>âbHNKJ
Ec&)%X>âbHNKläï'5é,T�4ÙßehÐ-Xhl�¶�âbHN8&\JBÖ;n×hT09:
âbHN0Ðå:x�z®Tm;n �É8õ\O0�67£�f?@©ªf��$è»y
�W8x;?@>âbHNy�f4z>'¹�>m;,
d�e)§���I>3>9:>?@>âbHNf§5
>673]^gh8?GQR�/���J\¸ÑiT3
]^�Þ>�\3HG?@>�bE:;J\¸uv�w
xTm;J\¸IJl�H;nj-k$Ù>ﶻñE
loc¶TiO\;3�m;\0��i����>�\
<=>x¸8�§5>673]^gh>Ýml�\J_
^O\;3T0�9:8?@EâbHNG�;%&8]
^O¿?@AB8¤]\J`ÖG�;n§589:;c
¾0?@�bABEn[O\;JBÖ���L3]^�
�]Ea8gN;��hEoÌQO\;n YÎEpê:�Û�×hÅ>?@ÎÏ»âbHN>á
é>ÕÖ�ØhÅ>c&Å>âbHN�B>qr]¼�
EâbHNsBK>Rtl�?@ÆPÎ80z®Tm;
J`ÖG�;næR�67~�Ù)j-k$Ù]¼>�
*8iG�;?@Å>øÞL]BBEuv:;x¸]�
HG>�B¿�3]^��]PÎ>Ró8��Tm;n �s�67£�>pW(NT?@E�bQR30ì]
¶�£�»©ª]¼Twx>BP8û�Ey�À8�b
T�;30���8z98:ÍQ�3]^�Þl�¶�
ï´{-XhlÇ\J`ÖG�;nI>x¸]3E|}
QR�:;IJ¿3]^�ÞE�ó;IJ8zïH¿Q
�]\n æR�?@¡¢£¤Ù038Vl?@Q�£¤QRIJ
l]\Ù09Vl?@QRn?@¡¢£¤Ùl��£¤Ù8ÚkO�4H>3l?@QRnI>IJHG?@¡¢>£¤0?@AB>�b8�Þ>®)lm;n ;�4< = �É3�>?@©ª>p��R���>ñ�8c\4zT<=8S4U��VW�XYEA^Rn?@ABe
3f�8ÊQO��QR()>�*EJ.QRnY±>
IJl(.JQOBÖ;n (1) U��VW�XY8x;?@:k�ñ�8�¸4×
>?@Æ0��É�¨T026%�� �T033%�V��T016%��h�T023%Tm^Rn4×>��8$9~h8NO\;Róª��J\¸x�
�g>£`«[Tm;n (2) ?@QRä�>�OJQO0E?@��;KJ\¸
>läïTm^Rn?@:k�Ä&8\Rù?@<
=>ï¶0�?@Q]\T�\J\¸Eê�LK
'×h,E��LK'Øh,`àEigN;x¸_
`QO\Rn (3) ¥BL?@<=>?@>��E�:ä�>��0�
d�e�»§���á�8x;9:>?@>âbH
N�c&>38x;9:>âbHN���>y�W
»d�W>���8x;?@'û��ÌT0]¶,
>âbHN�]¼âbHNlz®Tm;nR(Q�
âbHNsl��¯�]Äê���l?@Q]\J
\¸�b8+��¸;ý¿ï¶�âbHNR8¿�
�l��Tm;n (4) ?@QRä�>�O'e3f�,0�×ØT]F]
ý\lS�Rn×hT0�E?@��;Kläï
'4é,Tm��^ILáé>ÕÖlz®Tm;JBÖ;n�s�ØhT0�EâbHNKläï'5é,T�4Ùßeh�-Xhl�¶�âbHNlz
®Tm;n×hT09:âbHN0Ðå:x�z®
Tm;nâbHNsB>Rtl��Tm;n (5) ?@¡¢l?@��>�<8��¶�Ö:;nù£
¤Ù8ÚkO£¤Ù>?@Æ04HTm^Rn >?N�ð���s��������ð���7���
��>d�)�Ì���ÊË*�80�4×Ù?@Ù´
��EQÖO��æQRn�*>�λ�Ñ>U��V
W�8¿HH�GÀ�É3�'� )�h)V�,25���814×381¦><=>s�8õ3Ö��æQRnæR�� ��45�����>�����������
������� ¡�����º�80U��VW�T
¢mE�æQRn @9ABC 1) d�¢N23�*��E5£J:;458x;678g\O'Ý19�,�u<22 13 M8 o12 Ã00r�http://www.fdma.go.jp/data/�011003071542404313[1].pdf
2) � ����� �N2010123456789:;�É8õN;?@AB8Ê:;XY�4zN��I
¤³Õ, No.26, pp.17-20, 2010.6.
�
42.4%12.1%
9.1%
6.1%
6.1%
3.0%
3.0%
3.0%
3.0%
0.0%
6.3%
9.4%
20.3%
18.8%
1.6%
3.1%
4.7%
4.7%
0.0%
4.7%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45%
��¹ºÜ'
����
(�)*^+
²�)*^+
éê`�0`ç�
ÎT`×Ø
��`î,
£¤»-.k
"/`0Ö1�
ÎTæú2`)*^+
��(%)
×h'N=33,Øh'N=64,
N=97
¥R(Q�97¦>¸\�×Ø>éêl\À�¿2 %Y±>ì´²3'×h1�Øh7²3,J�OlñNÀ'×h3�Øh10²3,�0f²�À
¦ý
f-7� ?@AB��>ä�>�O>éê'×ØÙ,
- 60 -