2005 Dragon and Tiger
Transcript of 2005 Dragon and Tiger
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
1/79
Presented by: Ames Gross
President
Pacific Bridge Medical
www.pacificbridgemedical.com
May 16, 2005
Dragon & Tiger:Emerging Power of India and China
in the Pharmaceutical IndustryPresented to: Canadian Association for Pharmacy Distribution Management
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
2/79
Overview of Asia and itsPharmaceutical Market
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
3/79
Demographics
Country Population
Population
Growth (2004
est.) GDP (PPP)
Per Capita
Income
(PPP)
Life Expectancy
(Years)China 1,298,847,624 0.57% $6.449 trillion $5,000 71.96
Hong Kong 6,855,125 0.65% $212.2 billion $28,700 81.39
Philippines 86,241,697 1.88% $390.7 billion $4,600 69.60
Indonesia 238,452,952 1.49% $758.1 billion $3,200 69.26
Japan 127,333,002 0.08% $3.567 trillion $28,000 81.04
Malaysia 23,522,482 1.83% $207.2 billion $9,000 71.95
Singapore 4,353,893 1.71% $109.1 billion $23,700 81.53
South Korea 48,598,175 0.62% $855.3 billion $17,700 75.58
Taiwan 22,749,838 0.64% $528.6 billion $23,400 77.06Thailand 64,865,523 0.91% $475.7 billion $7,400 71.41
Source: CIA World Fact Book 2004
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
4/79
Healthcare Statistics
Country
Number of
Hospitals
Doctors per
1000 Person
Per Capita Spending
on Healthcare (US$)
China 330,348 1.69 30
Hong Kong 103 1.4 N/A
Philippines 1,652 N/A 33
Indonesia1,089 0.14 19
Japan 169,556 1.91 2,908
Malaysia 360 0.7 101
Singapore 28 1.39 4,107
South Korea 21,686 1.35 584Taiwan 18,265 7.42 677
Thailand 1,392 0.32 71
Source: Compiled from various sources by PBI
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
5/79
Size of Asian Pharmaceutical Markets
Source: Compiled from various sources by PBI
Country Pharmaceutical Market Size
China US $23 billion
Hong Kong US $1.5 billion
Philippines US $300 million
Indonesia US $350 million
Japan US $53 billionMalaysia US $210 million
Singapore US $400 million
South Korea US $6.3 billionTaiwan US $2.5 billion
Thailand US $1.5 billion
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
6/79
Overview of Asian
Medical Markets Over 30% of new expenditures on healthcare worldwide is
attributable to Asia
Spending is driven by:
Aging population
Increasing life expectancy
Increasing incidence of major diseases Increasing health consciousness
Higher disposable income
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
7/79
SourcingOpportunities in China
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
8/79
Overview of Sourcing in China
More Western medical companies are sourcing drug raw materials,
excipients and active ingredients to reduce their costs
Many drug manufacturers in Asia have made significantimprovements in product quality
In China:
Manufacturers are becoming increasingly sophisticated Product quality has increased dramatically
Prices remain much lower than most other countries
Identifying the right factory in China can be a challenge for a US
company
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
9/79
Identifying Product Manufacturers in
China Use the Internet and trade catalogues
Will provide you with an initial list of manufacturers
Numerous websites that provide sizeable lists of manufacturersand often include contact information and a brief description ofeach manufacturer
This type of search should only be a starting pointand shouldnot be considered a thorough investigation
Once several potential manufacturers have been identified by theInternet/catalogue search
Examine each manufacturers respective website
To establish an accurate idea of the company, both websites
(English and Mandarin) should be viewed by a person fluent inboth languages
Foreign companies should keep in mind that some of theinformation on the Internet or an individual manufacturerswebsite could be misleading or inaccurate
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
10/79
Initial Planning and Communication
After compiling a list of potential manufacturers,
contact each one directly Emails and phone calls
Can be used to answer initial questions and confirm the
manufacturers production capabilities
Can the manufacturer produce your products to your
specifications and required standards?
Even if the Chinese manufacturer has an English
speaker, it is best for the foreign company to have abilingual speaker available
Begin building a relationship
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
11/79
Determining the Price
If you have a standard product Price quote should be fairly straightforward
If your product has somewhat unique features or specifications, or if you arerequesting atypical quantities General price quote may not be very useful
May be necessary to ask the manufacturer for an itemized quote
Keep in mind:
Many Chinese manufacturers tend to use metric units and may not befamiliar with inches or pounds
The manufacturer may only honor their price quote for a limited amount oftime
Factor in other expenses, such as:
International and domestic shipping Customs duties
Possible travel expenses for visiting the manufacturer
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
12/79
Know the Difference:
Trading Companies vs. Factories Trading companies act as a middleman, purchasing products from a local
manufacturer and selling the products to a foreign buyer
Trading Company Advantages:
Tend to have a wide variety of products available for purchase A foreign company with numerous product lines may be able to use one trading
company for most of their products
Can often purchase products for better prices since they already have well-establishedrelationships with local manufacturers
Usually easier dealing with a trading company since they tend to have more experience
communicating with foreigners and working with foreign companies Trading companies offer short-term profits and generally business relationships with
these companies can be established in less time
Factory Advantages: Foreign company can develop a long-standing relationship with a local Chinese
manufacturer
Have more control over product design and quality
Hopefully more leverage on prices as the relationship and volumes grow
Trading companies could cut off foreign companys supply at any time
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
13/79
Due Diligence Before the Site Visit
At this point in the manufacturer investigation, some major problems should havealready surfaced May still be smaller issues that could cause potential problems
Prior to visiting a local Chinese factory or making a final decision on which factory tovisit, due diligence should be conducted by a local person in that country
Investigation should involve: Confirming that the factory exists and has the necessary business licenses/registrations
Make sure they comply with required labor laws and working conditions
Operations should meet the standards of the foreign company If factory uses a great deal of manual labor, as opposed to machinery, quality control
could potentially be an issue
Buyers Beware: A local Chinese company could claim to have a very large manufacturing operation with
hundreds of workers
In reality it is a trading company with a few people acting as go-betweens in a smalloffice space
Or, a Chinese manufacturer could initially offer excellent and speedy service, whileactually experiencing financial trouble and frequent power outages
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
14/79
Visiting the Factory
After factory investigation is complete, foreign company shouldarrange to visit the factory and begin solidifying the businessrelationship
Face to face communication is necessary
Crucial to developing a good working relationship
During the visit:
Spend time with the key people at the factory
Ask to see business, SFDA and GMP licenses in their offices
If any licenses are missing, this may indicate that the factorylost their license or never held one at all.
Ask whether the factory has passed any international requirements
(GMP, ISO 13845) Get a sense of the factorys financial background and status
If a factory is owned by a single person, it is best to determine thesource of the factorys initial funding when possible
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
15/79
Examine the Regulatory Requirements
Chinese drug manufacturers exporting to the US
are required to meet specific US FDA regulations These regulations can cause compliance problems
for Chinese manufacturers, making it difficult to
source from certain factories Any Chinese drug manufacturers that export to the
US must register with a US Agent and provide this
information to the FDA
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
16/79
Negotiating the Contract
Be concise
Specify how long the price quote is valid for Shipping terms should be well-defined
Important to include a dispute resolution clause in
the contract Though it is best to solve sticky issues and
problems via direct face-to-face meetings
Clause should define the law to be applied,arbitration is almost always a better option in Chinarather than a lawsuit
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
17/79
Establish a Quality
Assurance System Best method for ensuring product quality is to implement a quality assurance
system in China Depending on the shipping terms defined in the contract, the purchaser may
have to pay 100% of the cost of the products at the foreign countrys dock It is preferable to inspect the products prior to shipping
It is possible to hire a local quality control company to conduct an inspection
Many local Chinese manufacturers will not object to a visit from theircustomers own quality control team Higher costs May be more reliable and easier to arrange in some instances
Good idea to select multiple samples from a production run for testing prior topaying 100% of the purchase
If the local Chinese manufacturer is aware of these planned visits or tests, they
may be more conscientious of the factorys quality control methods from thestart
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
18/79
SourcingOpportunities in India
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
19/79
Sourcing from India
India offers:
Many skilled and well-educated workers
Low operational costs
Low-cost R&D
Large and diverse population, making clinical trials less
expensive and often more efficient
Increased patent protection for drugs
Some Indian drug companies have built manufacturing
facilities that meet US FDA standards
Over 60 facilities meeting US FDA to date in India
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
20/79
India company example
Panacea Biotech (India) is a manufacturer of
branded vaccines, pharmaceutical andbiotechnology-based products
Has manufacturing facilities in New Delhi and
Lalru, India Opening a new pharmaceutical formulation plant in
Baddi, India
Facility will meet US FDA, MHRA and WHOregulations
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
21/79
Example: Foreign Companies
Sourcing in India In 2001, Eli Lilly announced plans to source bulk
drugs from India Wyeth has a manufacturing contract with Bharat
Biotech (Vaccine and bio-therapeutic company in
Hyderabad, India) Bristol Myers Squibb has a manufacturing
contract with Biocon (Biopharmaceutical
company in Bangalore, India)
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
22/79
Point of Note
In general, the Indian market has focused on anti-
infections As India becomes more Westernized, anti-
hypertension, anti-cholesterol and depression
drugs will become more prevalent
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
23/79
Outsourcing to Asia
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
24/79
What is being outsourced?
Pharmaceutical companies are choosing to
outsource: Clinical trials
R&D
Manufacturing
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
25/79
Outsourcing Clinical Trials
Costs of clinical trials in Asia much less than in US/Europe
Asian population exceeds 4 billion and is geneticallydiverse
Many of these people have never received medication totreat their conditions
These patients are more suitable for trials because theyhave not been influenced by previous treatment
Some Asian countries now offer incentives to clinical trial
volunteers Example: India provides volunteers with free medication and
often better medical attention than what they would receiveat an average hospital
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
26/79
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
27/79
Outsourcing Clinical Trials:
Company Examples Pfizer began clinical studies in India several years
ago Kendle, a large US CRO, has said that it will open
an office in Delhi soon
Nicolas Piramal Group, an Indian company, set upa subsidiary called Wellquest, which provides
clinical trial services on a contract basis
16 years ago, sales were $3.5 million
Today, sales are $350 million
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
28/79
Downsides to Outsourcing Clinical
Trials Standards and regulations may not be as high as in
the US/EuropeNot all medical procedures uniform within some
Asian countries
Testing is not always sufficiently documented
Some Asian countries have restrictions on the type
of clinical trials that can be carried out Example: India does not allow companies to
conduct Phase I clinical studies for drug safety
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
29/79
Outsourcing Clinical Trials:
India Regulatory Update In the past, a drug had to undergo clinical trial one phase higher in
another country first, before the previous trial phase could beconducted in India
October 2004 Announcement:
MOH plans to amend Drugs and Cosmetics Act to allow foreign anddomestic companies to conduct clinical trials in India and othercountries simultaneously
Applies to Phase II and II trials only Phase I trials not included, since Phase I trials test drug safety
Clearances to conduct trials will be granted on a case-by-case basis
Foreign companies will not be permitted to conduct clinical trials
solely in India MOH will set up special group to monitor clinical trials
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
30/79
Outsourcing R&D:
A Company Example Roche opened new global R&D center in
Shanghai in Nov. 2004 Expected to be a world-class R&D center for new
pharmaceuticals in 3 to 5 years
CEO says: China not only an important salesmarket, but also a vital R&D center
Roche Group has invested more than $300 million
in China and has maintained double-digit growth
in sales output
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
31/79
Outsourcing R&D:
Company Examples Nicholas Piramal just opened a 350,000 sq ft research lab in Bombay
Assists foreign companies with R&D
Currently employs 260 scientists - will soon grow to 400 scientists Ipca Laboratories (Bombay, India), is a large supplier of APIs
Employs 150 people in R&D who focus on cost efficientengineering processes for drugs
There is a $60 billion global market for outsourced pharmaceuticalresearch in India, less than $200 million
Expected strong R&D growth in India
Access to Indias R&D market should prove a competitive advantageto other drug companies not in India
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
32/79
Outsourcing R&D
Drug companies are under intense pressure tocontain R&D expenses
Fewer new drug discoveries, rising drug prices andcompetition from generic drugs
PhD chemist at a U.S. CRO with 10 yearsexperience costs $250,000/year (including salary,benefits, overhead, etc.)
PhD chemist in India (with 10 years experience)costs $30,000 $40,000/year
PhD chemist in China (with 10 years experience)costs $40,000 - $60,000/year
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
33/79
Outsourcing R&D
Concern still exists over communication and
timeliness problems but the situation is gettingbetter
Some Asian CROs can claim business efficiency
equivalent to U.S.-based CRO. Communication typically done through email with
10-12 hour time difference taken into account
Many CROs now have in-house videoconferencingfacilities
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
34/79
Downsides to Outsourcing R&D
Lack of Intellectual Property Rights
This situation is improving, but not great Logistics of moving raw materials and finished
compounds between laboratories, overseas
collaborators, and drug companies can beburdensome
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
35/79
Update: Generic Drugs in India
Increased generic drug use by US and Europe
due to rising costs of healthcare During the next 4 years, $45 billion worth of
drugs to go off-patent
Indian generic drug firms will benefit Have the capabilities to manufacture many of
these drugs
Many US/European drug firms now lookingfor partnerships, mergers or acquisitions inIndia
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
36/79
Update: Patent Protection in India
Previously: India granted process patents
Another drug inventor could patent the same product as longas it was created by a new process
A tiny modification in the synthesis of a molecule wouldjustify a new patent
Passed a new patent law March 23, 2005 Sellers of already-approved generic drugs in India will now
have to pay licensing fees
Generic drug producers can apply to copy a patented drug,
but only after it has been on the market for 3 years Generic producer may have to pay royalty fees
The patent owner can object to the copying
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
37/79
Outsourcing Manufacturing
Cost of labor very low, but quality of work typically
getting better
Some Asian countries (India, the Philippines, Singapore,
etc.) have many workers with fluent English
Large pool of talent in Asia with education and ability to
run manufacturing plants equaling U.S. complexity and
quality
Asian manufacturers are becoming more sensitive to FDA
regulations, ISO and other international standards
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
38/79
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
39/79
Special Economic
Zones (SEZs) Traditionally located in the southern and coastal regions of
China. More areas now being designated by the
government SEZs offer significant tax concessions during early life of
a project
Income tax can be exempt during first 5 years of operation Exemption start date begins when company reaches a
specified percentage of production capacity
Incentives vary from region to region research and
comparison is necessary
Carefully examine conditions placed on SEZ incentives
Export quotas or price ceilings may be too restrictive
China
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
40/79
Outsourcing Manufacturing:
A Company Example Divis Laboratories (Hyderabad, India)
Manufacturer of active pharmaceutical ingredientsand advanced intermediates
Built a 1000m3 GMP fine chemicals plant on 300
acres of land for US$25 million in the mid-1990s In the US, the same facility would have cost
US$250-$400 million
Labor costs in Hyderabad are about 1/10 of those
in the West
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
41/79
Outsourcing Manufacturing:
A Company Example Respironics Inc., a US medical device company
(Murrysville, PA) Set up manufacturing facilities in China and the
Philippines
Contracts out components to Hong Kong China and Hong Kong provide Respironics with a
substantial number of well-trained and experienced
workers, many of whom are fluent in English
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
42/79
Outsourcing Manufacturing:
A Company Example Hikal, an Indian company and originally an
agrochemical producer which expanded into thepharmaceutical industry
Acquired a pharmaceutical ingredient plant in
Bangalore, India in 2001 Overhauled the entire facility, implemented GMP
standards, obtained USFDA approval
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
43/79
Outsourcing :A Company Example
Actavis, an Icelandic pharmaceutical company,purchased Lotus Laboratories in Bangalore, Indiafor approximately $25 million
Actavis will have access to technical expertiseoffered by Indian employees
Lowers R&D expenses
Actavis now looking to source:
APIs and finished dosage forms
Formulation development
Clinical trials
Manufacturing
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
44/79
Outsourcing Manufacturing:
China Regulatory Update July 1, 2004
GMP required for all drug manufacturers
January 1, 2006
GMP required for IVD reagents (administered as drugs)
January 1, 2007
GMP required for medicinal gas manufacturers
January 1, 2008
GMP required for crude drugs for Chinese medicine
How manufacturer processes and contains preparedslices of drugs, including the cleaning, cutting andsteaming processes
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
45/79
Outsourcing Manufacturing:
China Regulatory Update September 2004: SFDA issuedInterim Provisions for Drug Safety
Credit Classification
Applies to foreign and domestic drug companies, includingmanufacturers, distributors, R&D units
Officials will conduct inspections of facilities and assign one of fourcategories based on compliance with drug regulations:
1) Initial compliance or made improvement and is now in compliance
2) Received one warning due to non-compliance3) Received second warning due to non-compliance
4) Received multiple warnings; no effort to comply
Companies with low credit ratings
Subject to higher level of supervision; more frequent inspections Companies with high credit ratings
Less inspections; priority in administrative approval processes
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
46/79
Selling to Asia
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
47/79
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
48/79
Market Research
Is there a demand for your product? If
it sells here, that doesnt mean that itwill sell there
How do you do market research?Real primary research is the way to
go
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
49/79
Market Research
In addition to conducting primary market research
Determine how your competitors do business
How do competitors distribute to:
Doctors
Clinics OEMs
Hospitals
Does competitor export products and use localdistributors? Have local manufacturingcapabilities and their own sales forces?
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
50/79
Finding The Right
Distributor in China
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
51/79
Finding The Right Distributor
Use the same criteria as you would for a
distributor search in the rest of the world In China, relationships and trust are key
Not Lawsuits!Need introductions how do you do this?
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
52/79
China Distributor Search
Previously, distributors in China were state-
owned companiesSlow and methodical
No marketing just here are the productsToday, emergence of private companies that
are usually not well-funded. Many still lack
expertise in selling Western products
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
53/79
China Distributor Search
There are very few large-scale private national
medical device distributors in China; thus it isnecessary to put together several private regional
groups
Recent WTO regulations have opened Chinasmedical device market to foreign companies, but
foreigners have been slow to move in
Some foreign companies have been successful in
the China market, i.e. Zuellig
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
54/79
China Distributor Search
Be careful when selecting a distributor. Whatyou think of the group might not actually be thecase. Always use local insight to get real
background
For foreigners it is hard to tell if local distributorgroups:
Really know the local drug regulations
Have financial staying power, etc.
Bottled water story what you think is not whatyou get
E t bli hi d l ti hi
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
55/79
Establishing a good relationship
with a new distributor Asians put their trust in personal relationships, which
take time to develop
Introductions from friends, colleagues, or classmatesis key
Asian distributor who does not have personal
connection with manufacturer may: Misrepresent himself
Copy manufacturer's technology
Cheat the manufacturer Reputation is not on the line as it would be with a
personal connection
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
56/79
Selling to Asia:Regulations on Drug Sampling and
Promotion
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
57/79
Drug Promotion in Malaysia
Promotional material should be checked by asenior official (preferably a doctor or pharmacist)of the company prior to distribution
Any medical claims promoted must be supportedwith clinical evidence
Promotional material for prescription drugs canonly be provided to medical professionals
Direct consumer advertising is not permitted forprescription drugs, but is allowed for OTCproducts
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
58/79
Drug Promotion in Vietnam
Some forms of promotional activities:
Giving free samples to customers for trial use
Selling goods/providing services at prices lower than normalprices
Who can promote?
Vietnamese enterprises
Foreign-invested enterprises
Branches of Vietnamese and foreign enterprises
Promotional material must be approved by Drug Administration of
Vietnam (DAV) prior to distribution Approved material can be distributed to medical professionals
All promotional material must be in Vietnamese (and can also be inother languages)
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
59/79
Giving Drug Samples in Malaysia
Pharmaceutical Association of Malaysia (PhAMA)regulates the distribution of pharmaceutical samples
Samples can only be given to a doctor or someoneauthorized by a doctor to receive samples on the doctorsbehalf
Cannot be used as an incentive to encourage doctors to
purchase a particular product Companies generally use standard sales packs with the
words sample not for sale
Companies should keep good records of which doctorshave received samples
International companies may request that doctors sign anofficial receipt
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
60/79
Giving Drug Samples in Vietnam
Law states that, Free samples given to customers
must be goods which are currently sold or will be
sold in the market
Ministry of Health states that giving samples to
doctors is not permitted no law exists thatsupports their statement
Non-prescription drugs canbe distributed as
samples to the public, but is not common practice
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
61/79
Business Structures
in China
(If you want to do more than just sell via adistributor)
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
62/79
Business Structures
There are three main types of foreign direct investment
(FDI) in China:
Chinese-foreign equity joint venture (EJV)
Chinese-foreign co-operative joint venture (CJV)
Wholly foreign-owned enterprise (WFOE)
Choice of contract manufacturing, entering into an EJV
or CJV, or setting up a WFOE depends on long-term
goals
Extensive research should be done before selecting
business structure
Chinese Foreign Eq it Joint
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
63/79
Chinese-Foreign Equity Joint
Venture (EJV) Equity joint ventures take the form of a limited
liability company with Chinese legal personstatus
Parties invest together, manage together andshare risks, losses and benefits in proportion totheir contribution to registered capital
Proportion of foreign party's contribution tothe registered capital must not be less than25 percent.
Parties may not reduce amount of registered
capital during the period of the venture
Chinese Foreign Contractual Joint
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
64/79
Chinese-Foreign Contractual Joint
Venture (CJV) Parties determine manner of operation and
management, obligations, risk and profit
sharing, etc. through contract at beginning of
venture
In most CJVs: Foreign party provides all or most of the
funding, technology and key equipment
Chinese party provides land, natural
resources, facilities, and labor
Wholly Owned Foreign
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
65/79
Wholly-Owned Foreign
Enterprises (WFOE) Enterprises established in China in which all funds are
provided by foreign investors
Products made by WFOEs must be sold abroad. If productsintended for Chinese market, separate approval must beobtained
Most WFOEs are greenfield operations
Some result from buyouts of existing partners Risk level higher for WFOE than for JV
Decreased chance to develop relationships and contacts intarget market with WFOE
IBM set up WFOE in 1992 10 years after first enteringChina market
Success stories: 3M, Procter & Gamble
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
66/79
Business Structures
Previously, joint ventures were 50/50
(foreign/Chinese), then 80/20 or 90/10Multiple parties, multiple interests
Communism to capitalism
What is the conflict of interest?
(Experience at one negotiation)
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
67/79
Business Structures
in India
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
68/79
Business Structures in India
Foreign companies may establish presence in
India through:
Liaison/Representative Office
Branch Office
Joint Venture Wholly-Owned Subsidiary
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
69/79
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
70/79
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
71/79
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
72/79
Joint Venture
Advantages:
Indian partner has already-established distribution and
marketing channels
Financial resources of Indian partner
Indian partner has local contacts
Foreign investments are approved by one of two methods:
Automatic Route:
Approvals for foreign equity up to 50%
Government Approval:
Approval from Foreign Investment Promotion Board
(FIPB) when the foreign equity exceeds 50%
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
73/79
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
74/79
Important Cultural Issues When
Doing Business in Asia
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
75/79
Cultural Issues
It is important to understand the cultural
and business norms that are unique to aspecific country or ethnic group
Western Approach Eastern Approach*Do a deal *Build relationships
*Maximize short-term profits *Establish long-term foundations
*Assess competitive capabilities *Assess integrity and trust
*Be frank *Dont deliver bad news
*Make changes fast *Move when ready
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
76/79
Understanding the Chinese
Chinese mentality Importance of family
Concept of face Conducting effective business
Introductions
Negotiating
Little things that mean a lot Gifts
Body language
Conversation
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
77/79
Understanding People in India
Hierarchy (caste system) plays a large role in Indian society
Relationships and trust are key to successful business
Language
Different regions have different dialects
English commonly used for international business
Meetings
Should be arranged well in advance
Greet the most senior person first with a handshake
Exchange business cards
Use formal titles, Dr., Mrs., etc.
Start with informal conversation small talk Negotiations
Can be slow; Middle East mentality
Can be very confrontational
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
78/79
Understanding Southeast Asians
Intercultural communication differentiate Chinese fromlocals
Conducting effective business Personal connections
Negotiating with locals more harmonious
Do not point seen as a threatening gesture Dress conservatively
Do not touch anyones head
Do not point feet towards another
person
-
8/6/2019 2005 Dragon and Tiger
79/79
Cultural Issues
For each other Asian country you must know the
local religious traditions and other unique cultural
factors
Not all Asian countries share the same Asian
attitudes, values and mindset (India is very differentthan China)
Must pay close attention to the particulars of
each individual country
Pearl Harbor