Subject: Fw: Encroachment on Engineers Role Under Comprehensive Architectural Services COA Handbook page53+Role of Chartered Engineers(India)

From: suraj singh (suraj_engineer@yahoo.co.uk)

To: info@ice.net.in;

Cc: spgc@rediffmail.com;

Date: Monday, 8 August 2016, 11:53

The Institution of Civil Engineers,Karol Bagh, New Delhi -110005FYIThanks & Warm RegardsHave a nice timeInt P Engineer (India): Suraj SinghContracts Arbitration & Civil Engineering ConsultantMobile (+91-9810610718)/(430 /21 B- NCR Faridabad, India)

I E I Certification Int P Eng (I) : 800042-9The Institution of Engineers (India)Issuing Authority: Board For CertificationDiscipline: Civil EngineeringCertificate Valid Up to: 30/09/2015

Show original messageOn Monday, 8 August 2016, 7:15, suraj singh <suraj_engineer@yahoo.co.uk> wrote:

NOTICE TO COA Council of Architecture8.8.2016

IntPE(India) Eng Suraj Singh430 Sector 21B Faridabad NCR 121001

Encroachment on Engineers Role Under Comprehensive Architectural Services COAHandbook page 53+Role of Chartered Engineers(India) The Registrar/SecretaryCouncil of ArchitectureIndia Habitat Centre, Core 6A, 1st Floor,Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003 India

Copies of this E mail also addressed to Hon Ministries of Law, Urban Development, HumanResources & Development & The Institution of Engineers (India) for Information

Dear Sirs,1 With reference to issue of Encroachment on Role of Chartered Engineers (India)

Print https://uk-mg42.mail.yahoo.com/neo/launch?.rand=8lt0s5qfs84pb#9745...

1 of 5 08-Aug-16 11:58 AM

Civil/Structural & Services to professionally conduct practice on buildings developmentactivities / works/projects, this notification is formally served on Council of Architecture torespond to following questions2 In continuation to Council of Architecture notification 11.5.1989 respectingProfessional Conduct practice regulations, constituted under Architects Act 1972 Section 45,Practice rules were documented by COA as referred on COA Handbook page 53, whichdetailed inclusions are reproduced below for quoted referenceQuoteArchitectural Practice (COA/DOC/03/2002/APR/12&13) Comprehensive ArchitecturalServices part 1 & part 2Part 1-Architecture

1 Taking clients instructions & preparation of design brief2 Site evaluation, analysis & impact of existing &/or proposed development on itsimmediate environs3 Design & site development4 Structural design5 Sanitary, plumbing, drainage, water supply & sewerage design6 Electrical, electronics, communication systems & design7 Heat ventilation & air conditioning design (HVAC) & other mechanical systems8 Elevators, escalators etc..9 Fire detection, fire protection & security systems etc10 Periodic inspection & evaluation of construction works Issue 3 & 4Part 2-Allied fields1 Landscape architecture2 Interior architecture3 Architectural conservation4 Retrofitting of buildings5 Graphic design & signage

Unquote1 Foregoing services list includes various of all professional services that must beconducted or provided by Chartered Engineers (India) Civil & structural) CharteredEngineers (India) (Mechanical) & Chartered Engineers (India)(Electrical) etc.2 COA has encroached upon Engineers Profession by including all such professionalservices by pulling respective strings into domain of Architect's Role by bad / calculatedintention, which situation consequently prevents Engineers from carrying out professionalpractice on buildings, which is a Chartered Professional Right, warranted on to Engineers byMandate of The Institution of Engineers (India) Charter 1935 And by aforesaid incorrect actincluded through Rules under Architect Act 1972 & these regulations in continuation tonotification 11.5.1998, COA has practically acted against provisions of Constitution of India

Print https://uk-mg42.mail.yahoo.com/neo/launch?.rand=8lt0s5qfs84pb#9745...

2 of 5 08-Aug-16 11:58 AM

Fundamental Rights Article 19(g) to practice any profession & business, trade or occupationetc. which right is conferred upon every citizen of Bharat / India3 For obtaining remedy from such violation of Fundamental Rights, aggrieved person canresort to following remedial constitutional provisions by operating legal processReferences QuoteConstitutional Article 32 (1)Right to move Supreme Court by appropriate proceedings for enforcement of rights conferredby this Part is guaranteed.Constitutional Article 32(2)Supreme Court shall have power to issue directions or orders or writs, including writs innature of habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, quo warranto and certiorari, whichevermay be appropriate, for enforcement of any of rights conferred by this Part.UnquoteAnd, Role of Chartered Engineer (India) requires to be prayed upon to be issued with QuoWarranto by Hon SCIPrayer shall made on PIL for following issuesPrayer to be made on proposed petition, which explanation has been included conclusive endof this Notice1 Kindly delete/remove undefined role of Civil Engineers/Structural Engineers disciplinesexisting in architect’s name from Architects Act 1972 & Conduct Regulations 1989 11.5.1989Architectural Practice (COA/DOC/03/2002/APR/12&13) Comprehensive ArchitecturalServices part 1 & part 2 2 Kindly delete/remove undefined role of Building Services Engineers such as,Mechanical Engineers,, Electrical Engineers & others disciplines existing in architect’s namefrom Architects Act 1972 & Conduct Regulations 1989 11.5.1989 Architectural Practice(COA/DOC/03/2002/APR/12&13) Comprehensive Architectural Services part 1 & part 2 3 Kindly adjudicate that Chartered Engineers (India) & per IPEA Professional Engineers(India) & Engineers enrolled with various other Professional Societies are legally authorisedto be invited by public, by states/ by central government, by all authorities & others forbuildings designs & supervision/superintendence practice, related to all buildings structuraldesigns, buildings construction supervision, superintendence, construction completion etc. asis required by law & under bye law of relevant bodiesConcluding Prayer would be included on PILConcluding Payer1 Therefore, Honourable Supreme Court is prayed to devise a direction to Government ofIndia, all state governments, all such state governments authorities, all authorities, otherauthorities & others, as relevant in India to direct them in all required aspects & respects, tocomply with provisions, included within IEI Charter 1935, so that Chartered Engineers(India) & Professional Engineers (India) & other Engineers attached to various professionalsocieties, from respective branches of engineering may be able to be publically requiredlegally, to work on various engineering disciplines, respecting all engineering activitiescompetency wise, so as to realise in reality professional practicing role of engineers in society

Print https://uk-mg42.mail.yahoo.com/neo/launch?.rand=8lt0s5qfs84pb#9745...

3 of 5 08-Aug-16 11:58 AM

& contribute onto national development/delivering Quality Engineering Services2 To an extent, when deciding concerned professional engineering competencies, it is anobligatory on Chartered Responsibility of ‘The Institution of Engineers (India)’ to notify alldetails, related to each discipline & specialisation competencies in all branches ofEngineering, so as to enable public & all authorities, apprise themselves limits, mandatoryresponsibilities & obligations statutorily, which shall also, keep all professional engineers &all engineers in profession, whosoever binding, during providing such designated professionalengineering services to, whosoever be a client or user of such professional engineeringservice, whether or not, in public or private sector or others 3 And that a prayer is also, moved that all Engineering Services, respecting StructuralEngineering, Civil Engineering, Electrical Engineering, Mechanical Engineering HVACsystems etc. Water Supply & Sanitary Engineering, Security Engineering etc. should be struckoff from Architectural Comprehensive Services List, declared by Council of Architecture,under included Council of Architecture Regulation 1989 & Relevant Professional ConductDocument, which document enlists all disputed list on page 53 handbook of professionaldocuments, Council of ArchitectureTherefore, keeping abreast foregoing contents related to this Mail, COA is served with 30days notice, to remove encroachments, made by it by striking off / removing Engineers role,under Comprehensive Architectural Services, so that Engineers find respective roles in publicdomain directly from public & not through Architect PracticeFailing to effect as aforesaid or ignoring this service of Notice by Council of Architecture,may allow us Engineers full liberty to move SCI to file PIL against COA under Rules of SCI1966Attached IEI Royal Charter 1935 CopyAttached This Notice word file

Eng Suraj SinghSuraj_engineer@yahoo.co.uk9810610718Eng Satya Paulspgc@rediffmail.com9899045177Eng Ashok Manhar & many othersashok_manhar@hotmail.com

Thanks& Warm RegardsHave a nice timeInt P Engineer (India): Suraj SinghContracts Arbitration & Civil Engineering ConsultantMobile (+91-9810610718)/(430 /21 B- NCR Faridabad, India)

I E I Certification Int P Eng (I) : 800042-9The Institution of Engineers (India)Issuing Authority: Board For CertificationDiscipline: Civil EngineeringCertificate Valid Up to: 30/09/2015

Print https://uk-mg42.mail.yahoo.com/neo/launch?.rand=8lt0s5qfs84pb#9745...

4 of 5 08-Aug-16 11:58 AM

Attachments

11-PE11-IEIRoyalCharter1935.pdf (2.44 MB)NOTICE TO COA Council of Architecture8.8.2016.docx (17.48 KB)

Print https://uk-mg42.mail.yahoo.com/neo/launch?.rand=8lt0s5qfs84pb#9745...

5 of 5 08-Aug-16 11:58 AM