1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
-
Upload
neil-gillespie -
Category
Documents
-
view
219 -
download
0
Transcript of 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 1/15
t ion ,
Co• •
rul
accolllpU.h
00\ln801,
(198R),
a t
t
19At log
rocOIQmondGd
h . ; r
yonto
takon
in to
acco\ant
....
_ _ 1 ~ _ ~
aublllto
tha t
.ft
,holf yoon.
long ter'" t rot tbumt
in.toneD.
1
~
,1
I
IN
'iUB
CIRCUIT CO\IRT rOR T1Ui nl).-TIt J\lUICSk.l. CUtCtlJ1'
,
OF
rt,ORIOA,:IIH AltD ron l I N J . l . l . M ~ C'O\lltT\' ,
!
J
!'
, 8 T ~ f \ OF
, (pnIOA
\
V.
'j
)
DENNIS b. COHR .A
'
2
(\
'/
3 3
'/1 u _ . . . .
__
/
, ~
,:.
.
. ,\
I) . '
OIlIlfPNft.. llIlQUL.O" . Q U I ~ .•.
JlIKQ .UUlt
, .,
:
or
. . . . u . _ . u L 8 U Q B . . t ~ _ Q . I . . A J ) . O l n M O .PI
" ..I,V" " , t ~ : U
l1L'.I1ttAOla ! ,"
t>J
~ §
•
1 .
t r r o b
Y
dubJlitd
t lh'o l u ~ ' ( ) l ' n n ( h l J l fo r thp ( : o U n . 9 ~ ' f l C 0 1 0
in O ( l n n o e ~ l l o n with gUnhHl( ; ' I ' IQ. In f \ n ~ t h t : l l : U w ~
of
tho lJQ,ltlA unclet'lV"
I
1n9
tho s ~ ~ t C \ n c i n q
G u i d g l 1 , , ~ n .
,. 9;2)
. 0 0 \
, , ~ ( ~ . • r lo r lc13 O t . n t \ ) t , ~ 9
:1
if'
l\J>proprint-:)A
to l.n(or_ t h l d
C O \ l t t i p f tha. t . ) ( ' , ~ t ~ f W ~ or
1
"
factors "'h 1\,h
"'"
(
fIImt. "
c l o v , , , , ~
1',l1.dQ",,lt
ft.
u q f
n ) ~
oontono
Inq t ; l \ n f J ~
of
fO\J;
I\hd
( ) n q ~ h t ~
1 f· \ n
f
I
, , : 8 t i ~ l H H ~ ;
I
n c n t ~ o < n t l ~ l .
'
0
I
t I nU nq
r
l't
0
vII
\ ell
' ' ' ' 0 '
Tllo \KI
l n c l n < 1 ~
Hr.
C o r r ~ 3 ' O
nlHtnAbSllly
to
n ~ I H . b l l t A
tho
,oubnt.nntlnliilkftlU10«) t.hAl
n ~ h l 1 ~ l l ) J ~ t : A \ . O \
lll
b ~ A \ J C
~ n d t h ~ dCJtoncJat\t'
II
qctnutuq l'Q1IIIOtit ...
i1J\'1
GtrQf lg l.lIHi
1
1'0 , 'U)
"
comploto' ....uU, l tut ton.
p ~ r l o d p r
'ncate'OfAllon
or no ~ ( l t 9 tho\ t \ tvo And O f \ ~
rol lovod lIoY l'rolXlllon vl th 'M ••Ielf ' \>rovloh,n fo,'
nnd v h ~ t h .
l ' e l iUtut 'on l J 1 ~ p { J t ( } I ; r l - 4 t 9 I J f 1 thlli
R· I
MoraovQr,
any
l I o n t ~ n l J C t
In
e;cctutlj , (
t . h ~
loY
f ind
t
th.·
.
:
.
I
I
-
'l
~
(.
.
r
I
)
If
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 2/15
••
,·
I
.i
Tha 1 ~ t q v mJ
I
t.
()
t
hp 'nf '
nn. : l t
l on ('J' t l t '
A I J ~ I npt. MI-.
)
Corron
~ y
t ha
StAtn AI' ' ' ' n«t 'HHlI"Cp. t lf t::<)I\t pnt
HI'" ('<"In'c.;Ii'
Ch41'qod
wi th
f lvo
count
oJ
111';\1,,1
U \ l ~ ( f ( ~ ( ~ U 1 ~ \ t t ~ ' ( U ~ , , , p ' V f > e n
"l'l't(1X\'"
..n
'mnto ly Octob@I'
' )( ' , ",UH.
AnI'
( ) t : tobDI" \,-PJ;1t '
Vio lAt lon
( ' f
Chaptor 012.cH", r io t ' l dA f . t A t \ l t pP , Thl'O\lI.lHl\,t
n l lU 'A ( I
Or bl) th
, tho f loa' leln I \ .n 'o n v l ~ t Irlttl ll)n Alld thD P ' \ P D t ' \ I D ~ ' \ i ~ h y hy t t l ",
sta to t t o l ~ : a y '
orrleg. W1'OI\I : )(I" \" \ (1
~
n ~ l S t ·
, 1 ~ t \ , p ( l
f '( (;QVf I 'qc.J
{
\1
P .
tt
0
t
0
1y h n
p Hr.
COl" ..
Q' c l
q
r
,. (,1 f \) 1
l ) t
\II'
t
h
, , '
v
p
g t
1fJ A
t i I\fJ
!i
author 1t
1 t H ~ l by,
opcHll
f lq h ' A
l ' p ~ o r d p . hq 'n r
A C '
vo
hlf\ton '1..,·
\ f ~ f \ e ; l l
1
r o .
tho ~ ~ o r l d A lll\l" ~ P O t 1 , . , t i o t \ , , , o f \ ~ . ~
OctobGr
20,
199) ,
·Hr ,
Cor
J
t·
a vo 1' J ' l l31· l
1
Y
Ailf'lk C:'
. ~ f \ · { l c t t (}3
, , ' t
I' t t \ ~
prODGCutora
It d n 1 , , ~ ( '
t t : h \ ~ c ; u u ~ ,
n ~ \ '3f
l I
Hr,'.l\y . .,.fll1 I ; O ~ . l l ~ t o . l ~ ·
I
,
'I
dotal1Qd t\
i
A
cr1mlnol
~ O I ~ , h J ( , ; l &\ ,,(1 h i t l ~ p
I'
q t.
I t ) ;
t;I t\J
11 r ~ t i t : i tu
t lon.
; i
In otni1cll ' lq Ull to t h ~ J l ~ n ( ' l n ~ J c h r ' r l q ~ vl t , A t ~ ~ 3 ( l r p ' . l . n R l A t . ~ I ( ~ f : l
on ,1.,tklnq
r;o'otltutlon
COT
hla
nlfHhl@dCi,
Hr,
C t U ' f ~ ~
h a ~
f l ~ ~ f H l 9 t l ' a t e ~ i
h i . r 8 1 f t O r 8 ~ fOl- t ha
b r ~ 3 c ' , or tr \ ' iat
"lnlt·@(l
uJ)Otl h l ~ ~ l l ~ f \ l ~ lly '.\ls
'.
actions.
Hr.
Co..
r o ~ ' C
r ~ · o t ~ g
·lft
c o r r O l ) ( ~ r A t . ' ? d l)y ·.qr,lal
1 1 ~ · 3 1 t h .
.
counaolol' Sar"h R.
tl
.. f t t U ; ~ Y , td .n . ' ,v l t .h "ho"
h ~ t ~ f j ' ~ ( i j h
'1n
tUHtt."
.
•1
Iftctnt
..
ihca
appro)(hsatolv
,JtU1\lary ot 19 2. coJt
t>( KR. , f i t A ~ l ~ y - g
•
,R .
Qurrlculu. vit3A 1 ~ GttAchftd h Q r ~ t a 3 . t ~ h ' b l l t h ~ ~ t h ~ h t ' c i t v
o f
tho Datandl ln t ' . fQaotaA h ~ t l
MC!n
,-all't.l(=Jll.ly (1()':\lJl't'9hlQ:l.1 by l)t f
G . r a ~ d
R. RoVtloldB,
Ph.O.,
who,.
( ~ l . l n i c A l
O Y 3 1 \ ) ~ l t . . ( ) n
tJt
Ht. CorrOli
.
\
r.veala not only that th f t tpefend8nt lo Ittwpor
i . n . t ~ r :
''9
t J ~ m . t t \ §
' t ~ f ) l ' R t l
-
..
:
bUt that hi"
ab l l i t v
lei ' c c o l ' p l l ~ h v le t l
.. r ~ A t · . J t ' t t l t ) n ~ 1 _ . 1
~ 1 1 1 V 8
•• ' ,
'0:
, ;,
G.
,.
.
, . .;
.
.
-.:
.'.:_. . _.: •.. - : -:.; .
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 3/15
8 l q n i f l c n n t ~ n d t h ~ I n p p \ l t
h.' r n l p '
h \A ..
~ h ~ l q
1
\ ( \ l l .Qf f 'H · t .
Ray
0
1(t
A '
.. ti
A
\J Jl
Q
\
A
:t
t
t
(
1\ (J
<1
h p .. .
0'
.\ :\ r:. 'I h
i
1, ,t •1 .,
0\1 r i nq .
I
II ') 0
)'
P
A
I' ( t ip
1>11
A 111
l\
, . , \ C \ I \lJ a" n P.)' I ' h . , r t
0\
t Q
o
C
F lo
.. I
cI
Hr .
Cor
1
Q.'\
f 1 . , ~
IH1.) .,
I
P
P\I '
l\'
\
n
;\
n
Ib1t
II
\
Q
1
co
ct •
. , : \
P
;\
h
1
qhJ
Y c O l ~ p n t. P
IH J'
....
\1.
\'
\ I ~ n p
r \ n
' h e
riP
I I
f Q ~ ~ } l '
1: ,,, \
'J
;\f\<1
r
. 1nva
0 t
rnan t
C
0 \
I / ; C '
I
I n ' ) .
r"
h
1 , .
p..
•
P n l\ I
1
I
r.,.
H ,.' ( ,
.• 'I 1- P
h p I p P
i j
mnrr Ipcl fo r ) ' , 't'pi'll-n '0
h i Q
, ' I I dhe' ,"l
PVC10t
h C 1 ~ f ; t ,
.hHl)'
Ct
Toqft t h(u'
t
hoy
h;\
V p
, . ,
I ft (1"
t
' 0 0 h i I '11 on , eh r \ Q J U ~ . ~ T
1 '\<1
, \
r. p : \ And
Colby C o r r ~ : \
J
f
which
v l 1 1 : p n n b l p
n: \ lo
t:)(
ft
cut
1v g
0
r
f 1C P I' 0
r
.. I
1\
'H' \
I
r
C).:
\1 P: t n (' '. I
~ I r II
I
I)
:\ l\ , ts n,t Hf .
t
••
Corrt tn
•
A
prob 1qr.eA .
:\I\C) / ; ~ ~
•
nnnC3t. hC) 1 a , l''
l t ~ .
Of) 'n C?J1 .) 1 (l-" t. 0
Dofon<Innt
't.o
n ~ l k g t . t hC'
c#r l):\n)·
i
p
Q ~ 1 v i ( C 'P ua
\
f \ ~ J h ' s:a fltf::' f ~ f , n t J
f
)
oxport lgg.
r
t
tho corpotn to chack 1nt' n ( . ~ r ( } \ . t . .
v l
11
r Or ",11
A.\(l Or.
,
Roynoldn,
H, . HcGovRn vl11
h.q
p r ~ A ~ t \ t : \ t
~ . ~ t l ~ : n
...
J l c ~ t l n ~
, cj
,,\
I>or".onttlly t t . ~ , . t t.n
h f
c : 0 1 l ~ l t n a , , t.<l f i r . C - : ~ ] ~
~ , , ; ( t
t;C:J
aJlrlt
~ @ t g
q\loationn or· conagrnn
or
t ho
Co.\,rl.
i
Hr. 'Corra"
h ,*
3 1 9 0 h o . ~ n
o r r ~ r C J f l
t h o OJllH,t{un-tty t ,Ll
vb':k '11th
..
.. .
,.
eo
,
.
:',
. .:?:.:=
. : ; c
; >
...
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 4/15
, .
.. .
. ~
1)
hovoxor.
hOJll"""
to d c w ( ) t , ~ "
P\ll\ l l tAnt\Al
~ t . r t lm,j"f hi l f l \ ~ N I . ~ to
•
•
·
.,
Y lo t
1. raot Wtl\Jt
ion. j
j
noc ,aui, t · h ~
C(l\srl
v , \:) hc:Ji\1 r r n t
hC' n \ I l ~ O \ , j ~ l ' v i
c l \ J ~ ) f j V)l l '
, f t)
,I
.-
wlllh
to
nJ\Ct1tk
on
HI',
( ( \ I ~ ~ A P
l p h ~ \ f
; \ t
'ho
t'
r
q ~ t \ t .
C : S ( ~
t \ ~ J
•
i
r
u r
t
h tH' .@
1n
bo I' \ t 1()1\ 1n t 0 ;l h cs 1\" t \J
I'
;H\CI
I'
Ii ( 1'''( \{ \f )4 r . ( <.n t cs l\ • P
8upport natvork 1 I \ I \ A C ~ t , \ ~ t ; t n
thp , , , ; ~ I ~ h \ t ; tn
\n 1'(\t\tP l((
;&PJr.<ll, . .
ncluIl
.
. '
\ COlllp
1n t lon
(' f
1p t t
P.
I'll
f 1 ' ( \1 \ HI' , m'l p ' f a P\I' ')l.ll
,
tJr
1\3
Fl b ~ t ; \
RUbmlt't@d
uncleu' PPJ14u·"tcs
("(wAr,
, ' u l t f ln
p
o \ lA l ) W ~ ' t h ' ~ ¢ ( ~ 1 · 3 t l ( h u . ,
Horo p'·AAA' l(1
1
R t .\() , , ~ p { l ,()
P1
il '"t:) H1".
Cnt'
.. Q .Q' t· \J.,t IQt' ,., l l \ ~
contoxt or 'rhft In" Aft
it.
l ~ a r ' : \ ' ' ' f : I te.)
~ J - ) ~ ' l l ( · : \ '
'()'\\{If t t l ~ ~ f , t ~ f \ . ~ l , , '
'
Q\11tlo11ngg.i:{
r l l ~
( 1 1 ~ c \ I R A ' I ) v , l ( ~ l , f ( l 1 1 n v ~ th,., ..
~ r C ) t · p . ' . . ~ n d @ , l
to
<}1
va th C.O\lrt "n cn:p \
l C. · t l dtl
or t ha
C ~ ~ P 1
: \ ,w f ~ ( H H : ~ I t \ \ t , , - ~
"'IHM'
·i
.1 t lgn t lnq : - j c l r C \ J I l A t ' l ( ~ ~ A _ . ~ r ' · # l n t . ( l 4 ~ l ~ r t \ .. '·.., r1"()",.IJlC - : J \ J ' d ~ ' ,.·,.A.
. .\
1 ..
II
I
In nn or
fOl t to
n t ~ ~ ~ V ~ a· tJr41;J
. ~ . .
( l ~ f J l · q ~ . ( ; ~ l ~ 1
~ { ~ ' Y atl(l.
I
falrn@t\o
in
th rumt@fH;sn"
. l J ' (H:OA9
t.hl' oll ' lhn"
,
. .ontenclnq
( J \ l l d f t p n o ~
\ l O ~ ~ ' J l . ~ ~ ~ 1 t p M . ~ d
In
(.;\11
(,r
~ J 1 ~
9f.1L
;'
\
:.
) •
101,
.. 1 . R Cr 1*' .•". , , ~ ~ ; .
A
r
t_
1
(·.\1·1 A t q.l'] l ' \ t.Jlq. /. t. J;.t; t ; ) p . ~ .,t. ()f
r
Ili')[:iP
4'
auation o ~ thQ g U d ~ l n q l
.
, ..
JThCl
ptJrpotl"
-or C ' l t ~ n o 1nrl
q\ J ltlCJ 11
@ ~ if) t . { )
~ ~ t
Ab·ll
ft
un I',r'ora Ret
o f
atatttJArdl tt> (j\J Idf)
t.hfl
_ O f ' l o n ~ . ' n9 ' t i { l ~ e
in tho .onlQ',CO { 1 . · p l . l ( j n ~ . 3 k l nt "rocfl"". T1\;; (f \•.Itle I t ~ R
roproo.nt'
A
. y n t ~ . l f l Of ~ j r t . l \ t ·
. Q n ~ ~ i l ~ ~ ' ~ hq ) ~ A l t . . - l c j e B
,-
.
t h r o , ~ q h o u t
tho
a t 8 . t ~ o , s ntflIlU
. I.f19
flU
11
he_ .8 f
@ l · n t o f l . ~ l J
to
01
'
.. lnatO u n a r l ' ~ n t f d VAt 1at
Ion In
t
. . . .
8f.ttlt@ttOI-ttq
proe
• • • by
tad\)dln
t
j
thQ faUb·jeotlvlt.y l . I n \ i ~ - J ) t A t l n g
ilp-Go'l
f lo
of
tonlo
...
r.t,,':@tl
Bm1
O f r @ t l l l ~ t i O W t ~ . t . ~ t l l } . I 1
c f
It@l'
J.3
antJ 1n
dotlni.n9 tho i r
"013t 'V4 l_pntt3nCtl I ~ . n
~ ~ ' l t 9 · h - ~ ~
in-t) dCloJnloh.
, .
Rul.
J . 1 0 l ( b ) .
rltt .R.Ctl. ,P. g G l ) l ~ t )
n J _ a n a . J l , . , , ~ \... i t a ~ t . l MH g o . ~ d
-512 ' ( r lao 1990) ( Q . \ l o . . t t n ~
~ n . t . f L t Y J t . _ Q . ( _ ' t 1 l t l n a 1 . ~ ~ l ( : ~ ~ ~ J X 4 L . L ~ , t f i t . . , - n t t :
.
>}l..
: ,
- ..
..
-,
l·.
.
..
~ . . .
r
*
;.
.
~ ~ . : . . . . ; ; . ~
...
..
. ..
-: ..
w .
, '
- : • , ' ' ' ' ' ~ .
~ ~ d ~ : j ~ ~
L
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 5/15
. f
..
,
f'
' ~ H l \ i l t e d
1989,);
of
,
•
'I
.
n
\}
..
•
·r
1 r n L . G . \ l 1 . d . e l 1 . n ~ D J , ' ~ { \ .
n.II,
1'1. r,) I
r
1A .
\<>1I1II . t
. ,
tho
9 U l d a l 1 r ~ ' H ~
not
\ n t t ~ I H ~ d h ' ~ l . l n ' n ~ \ o ullc:, ' A I
, t l ~ H ' r p . t . h H ' in
!
thG
. on tone
h c J . prOCCHHI ,
~ O I \ ( J U\O
A l l o c ' , n C A )
p . . l \ U t ~ i ~ t p . i l " .. ' t H ~
.1
I P
plaa
Of:'hOdldt'
in
the
q i d ~ l \ ~ p
'9
tho tone t
t h A ?
. I
. Wh\ It'} 'hf t 9 ~ m t a ~ \ f \ c l
(J\)\dollncHl
At P < 1 c : ~ I . . J I \ P <
\.'
t I t ' f )
u , , ~ ' \ l C ' ( ' ~ ,,,
thn
R Q t q , h c ~ n c J i ) ~ ~ l A l n
~ t \ i J
~ t p ~ , ,t ' U ~ h l l c J
° t o
\ l f p
' d \ c ' ~ l c J \ ~ c ..
lon,
c 1 0 J ' A r t \ t l ' e ~ ftl l th J H ' p . ~
numpt.l
VC
rumtC?'nc;o9
t.: h 1 'f:iholl \
f\ t h ~
lJ\I
l ( l ~ I
(-
. ( , ) ~ p h ~ ) 1
bp
I\rtlr:u13t.fSl1
In
''' .. I t \nQ nil
"0)(1,,s v h ~
f ' f H ' ~ ~ . ~ ' ~ t H . , ~ r a
Of'
f M:tofn
r p . l I o n ~ h l y
' \ lAt \
r.,.
t A C ~ I J l . · : : \ t '
\)lJ:
ta I
t ' q A t '
oh
r
or t ha Au"te nco. Thp. I (,)VI;t 1 Jlrl W r n , , 1 I ~ I H 1 Q ; \ ) '
t o
,",pt Ah
1hah B d f t p l \ r t \ l r ~
fro:)
A
~ ~ n t . ' m l · O
Im( )PI t h ~
(J\ l h l ~ \ ll\p[t \
• preponderanoe or the eVldenae. "
Rula ) . ' 101011) ( ) ,
n , n , l . r \ ~ . l · . ~ thQ 1 1 \ J \ f ' p l l l \ a A ~ l , p ( ' H i l : \ l l r
l'l'Q
vido for
d g ~ n r t u n ~
'hnll thar; ,
~ n d ~ t ' · l r n m q t . t H ~ ~ 01'
f ; \C\ ' I 'R
th,H
rOlUlon;\hly
!
\1\1£1t l r y MJ
'
fl · ...
'"
HJ ..". I \ \ t l ~ t
''''J
t h a PQl\tOtll 'O"
r ia:
" .
R, Cr hL
I ' . ,
1
• 101
(cl) ( \ \ ).
I ' t
' d t . h o \ l c ~ h
t h ~ ' f ..
: \ n e n ~ : of ' h ~
<ll1i f lql i t \ap
v ~ t t : l , · ~ t · a f . l
tH'''' to
plneo l l t . \ l t .nt lonn 0/\
t . h ~ ~ . M · t o r p .
J r o p ~ r l Y ( ( m ~ I ~ I a r )
i n
~ h l ~ l Q f \ ,
'j
or .<JIlr. VA
t l on
o f
. .Antft , ) ; . .
tho
' I
I dft 1 I nAR .In ,M In
, - .
I 'f
nv , , ,
t h o t
(r)onRon
fol '
f l Q v A ~ l l n ( ,
f r c ) ~
th'.?
q ' d ~ 1 1 t l a , ,
p h ~ l )
hrH:
l olu(1e
J: .
,',
faotoro ro13t luq to I ' f lor t .hr r
p
p t R
'Uhou' r:otWlr.ti\lntl ( ) t \ .hq H : a t ~ f \ f ,
offGn80A
' -Of
\
hAVA n{lJ ) ~ o n O ~ t h t . 3 ' n ~ d , .. ,,1
__
'
• ) . 101(d) 0:'
r13.ft.Cr' ' ' ' . ' ' ,
c O ~ ' f $ , ~ h H ' V ; U ~ r:<\l'g \ll t l ~ t \ , h , u
lnto, hO 'Q\/or. t h ~ t l I (o ) ther r30t.(H'£*. c o n ~ l R t , l qfH) f\M In . : : m l t J . . l ~ l
v i ~ h
t ho a t o t
••
Ant o f '''''jl'O 0 •
,y·l,..
.n a I dot
t<'
I IUI I , . · ,1 by
thA
.............. :I
_ ~ ~
•
..,
..... , ~ . ' h .. ..
t.
'Pr iol '
to tho
11)911 A.uHHln.(!nl,*. t . h ~
f*l:\ndlil,l4'<t( Pl'l Q[
tot d o p ~ r t u r l t
I to
thg
9 u l d ( t l 1 f 1 l H ~
'VaR · c . ~ 3 r
1 U : ~ 1
totWIrttHfirJ;' · . s . Y l ~
d*noti. tn
~ U n Y L
... D . . t . ~ t J ,
5 4 ~
n o . ~ d
iH
t r lB, 1st u.e.A.
thO
Fird t Ci rcui t Court.
or App.gl}l
lhHil3ltr@
Hu
e o f t ~ t i t \ i t i o l 1 t l i t y
ot
t o
roduetlon in tho ot3n(lAfd
or
proor lQ J l r ~ ~ t ) , ~ j P . t A t l ( ; ~
evldonc.o. . .
. !
,:,
"
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 6/15
. . . ---- .....,
..
_ _ ~ . - - - - ~ - - - ~ - -
etl
1
{:
c
'AU \ 1;\ ( '
II
n t IS '* «(') (\))
'\
(190"0 AIlU'uH\l 'pntn). ;:
I t
1" ~ 1
n"t. to.h
\
A
r l ~ i D a V ( ) ~ t , h ~ l
t
r
1
{,,,
if'tA
~ . ~ ( I r
9
h ~ \ : ~ I".,
e;t ' \
I
g r n l ~ p 1 i nCJ
t , ~ )
(1\1
r
i
t
he) r t \ r t ~ t ..
P
(l
r
.,
l
tone 1nq
.
f lop
Sta le .
v. 1 1 1 ~ h . l e . l : .
..
A 11 r:n. ;,,,, ~ , ; , <.t
\.:\. \
t.)
11(.)
( no t ' 1\'-'
t h n t
o
n 1
n c ~
t.he? l all
llP'U ll\t
<'\ t \on (l
r
u,p IJ\ll dp 1
' ncsp
•
. ~ h P (\
v a .1 r
l("t
,co\Jrtn
hnd e o , , ~ t o
c t l A J H H . : \ t a
\ ~ ( ' ) n . : h ' R \ ( l I \ A
( lVCI'
v h t f h o r ~ \ 1 ' ~ n \ ' I ' ~ l
r 0
t\
. 0 r
0 ,.
1):1 l'
t \&
r
A 'n 1P" .. :\
n()
(
{, f' '. ' \ 1\ (. , h f J
-,
T" t " p ,V f:'
"tho.o which
hap
csl;lPl ' l lpd
III
t he
:\00
\Q
t h < \ t ~
n i t h'Rt i on
c)f
01
roc
0
am
00(1
a c[
n
@ "
t.
.., r,
(
1
'"
I'
t
i\
t
e,
1
v I,
c;a f\
t
r
( l l '
'J
b
r i c
t )
II
f
,.
~ ; . \ ( ~ t \
,
t ho
d o r o n ( O I ~ l l I ) o g ~ n no (u ' t 1 0
t '\1 ~ ~ t
'(l n t l ( O
\ ~ ' ) ' .
n ~ ~
r ~ .
~ ) i a p , l g
; {
5 t . A t . Q . . . _ V ' ~ ~ . : ; ' 1 h . a ,
'; H. [ :0 . 1 (1 n (rll). 1
?
A I t ) ((lQ f ~ f l ( l ~ t\' ' Q C' < ,,1m:' 1 ~ \tV",
,
lin
t l l o l n t ( \ ( ~
lnc1dpl\ ' , t h ~ J t c ; )
'p
n ( ~ · r'Jt,\a .. th1"e;t:lt te l Q f l ( · \ ~ t ; ) l U ~ . ~ ~ ~
;
~ J . . . Q . t . . b j t Q ,
~ ) ( . no
..
}tl
l ' ; ( . ~ i · l A .
111
n . ( . ~ .
\ ' "nn)
(p ibm ' j
r U l t . . ' V ~ O h \ 0
rahAbl11 t n t 10n nnd
~ ) ( c a 11
t. I't'
"
h
11
't 't' (l r
.. qhMi
.1
\t a t
\ <Jtl
:\ , ' fs *311d "
f.
baool1 r01·
<lo,,',v,'\ ,-(1 tlft1
,
n ,-
,-
( 1 r ~ ) ; 3
ta t-Q.
_Y. l \ . e g a ~ l .
" r;(). ' , l
\; l Of) ( t
1 it ,
,
ffi
~ d 0 , C. A. 19' )0) C ( I A f ' ~ n d A t , f l (1 \(1
~ , o t
C O f ~ t t \ltq : \ ' t o t , t ~ ~ t t . · l) ~ ( ) · t ~ l Q ' . , V
l \ ,
whero ttlO
P ; \ , ~ t lC\J 1
1\' l
r ~ ' \ J n t 1 t A t ' ( ~ c : ) Q of
('I'
l l \p
~ n o
I ' f ) f3t .RC\
t:',i;!
1ova 1 0 f
t h1)
'db f cmdtt nt.
'
II' It ..,.. ~ ( ) r R I C H J It i l l i j),): .'Pl.'JL'i..•.. I . : ~ t . t ,
4 4 1 8 0 ,2 <1
lO'11,
iO'ln ( r l : t . 1 ? 1 ) ( ~ V 1 d ~ ~ ~ ~ or f ' ~ R 0 1 · ~ h - ~ y t H ' o . P ~ 1 · . 1 V
bo
confllf.lftt"o(1
In a l l l q A t lo n o f f t ~ l t n e t : l ) .
r ~ n h t \ p ( l b4J<M.\UU! t ~ J l A h
I t
H ,3 U on ho
l,lei
h 1 ~ : ~ . . tp,
I
'n iUt U1Y
,
lIoclCttlctA' pr.ot.Qtlt lon
IHI"lnrtt. c l 'hHnAl r t : l ( ~ l r H \ ' ~ ,
" , . ' ~ r Q h ( j t l n t ' ~
.
- t
('
aMonablllty
to
ff thobUltet . loh hi
3*\-on 1
t.h'" . ( l ~ t ..
.I '9.Q,'MlllY a'",lhm ..
Iated
r 03g0n . tor (tOYnv"ttt (1oY i ~ t . l ( ) f l f t01l A f ~ C ( } 1 l . ~ ~ ~ I Q - d
i t q h l 9 f i C ~ .
1110 t lor hln
Suptt l'Ift
court rtal int ly ..-.phAtiI' . ~ . ; ) 1 \ , , : ' ~ ~ l Q t ) O r : l . ~ n ( ~ ~ of
.
"
.
~
.... ...
~ : : :
•
1
'.";',
J'
. .
i
t •
,
. J
'*
.
:·1:
-
j ~ ~ ;
~ c : ~
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 7/15
\i
I
"
eJ
t o .
rQhAhl 1
Hl\ t jann the:
r r ~ ~ \ t C ' ' ' t \ Y ~ ( . ~ H C d 'hH'lt*'on.
O'.r, tln
.....
Y_"
..•s.tate, ~ ( ) b
lo.
1d
n
(r
lol'. 1t;J9 0). tn.
Itt1,\,n.
\. r ' ; \ )
1\ldqo d ~ p
..
\ l" t"d ( ro l S the: (U'C'AUftpt tv, . 9csi ,tp ' \ l" ' \ fJ
~ : ~ J P
.,r P . t V € \ ~
throQ
"nd
01'\ 'n-h31f
;\",1
ro'lIr
"""I
o t l p -h" l r YP:\IP
,U" ' ; \ f ' ·P tOll t . lo ' l
;\n{\
,
one
yonr
of lia'ol'nt lnn, C1HnlJ n i l t ~ e l a
V.
Glate, t',(),; rhl.;>(} .. \ (rln.
,i 1••"
. I
J
987) , ' t ho
~ r l \
' \Il! ' lP A t ~ \ P f a { l P c I l I P t ' r i " ' h
ro'P1 \ : \ " I r ~ . j
t.
y t e' t'" P n t
n..,,,t
)
i
no
avldanc4: <l
b)'
hlA v ( ) h ' l f ~ r y PIlT'ol lnpnt
In. '''·1' I n'.
~ · ' I ' ' '
Uet',rl0,
'H.n Hn, )C' ; '\t
' ) ) I.
l
.f:
OnAo(1 on:-.
, ~ : - . r r ( l V r " " t i l , , , . n f
n.ilthera. thIS ' e r ~ t : ' I l } l A ' H ' \ CO\lt·\'
or
A p l ) ( ~ n l lqnorCld t .h"
trlnl "IIIIJt"" rt",1\neJ
wi th
' !PQ:H
c
l
to
; \ t I o P . f H l ~
b i l l t Y t.o n ~ t l t 1 h i 1 it \Ion I' r p ..· eH AP(} , r C l n ~
AC'
1",1)' 01' thp
8ubatnncC1 n ~ m A P H l l l C H ~ t . A
o f Ua:.r.lH ,ra.
t.hp ,1lpl,r \C"t, nnll ( d ~ t ~ I I . ~ ( 1
I
thAt
l n t o ) ( l ~ = : - . t l ( ) f 1 nr ~ \ I h ~ : \ I \ ; c : l : \ \ , ~ e can Ius c : l ~ ~ 1 :,,,,1 cf",wlnr.nf l f"
'"
,
roAoon Cor ~ o v ~ v n r d
cnAO
In n . a , J : ~ ~ t , f ) , thq
f l ~ ( p . i ~ l n t .
I
l n t , ( ) l C i f ~ 3 t . ~ n t .thl" t t h ~ U,*" e"'-e
}
I
~ 1 ~
WAll
COllII'
1
t tCld.
•
{"
D a c H \ u n ~ thq lhH.lond 0 l A ~ l r lcH. Court
of
"PilAt' 1 At r ' ( ' l 1h : p r ~ l J q
..
·1
hUon of
D U ~ J : a
c o n f l I C I ~ v l th
tM t
of a tho ' I ~ t . Id COut ' : . , tho
suprQllo cour t A c c a p t ~ d ) \ J ~ l ~ d k t ' o n t f l ha.!'r t he J ~ ; H I C . h i . , t ~ J ..n. S(jO
t
:: ' , '1
"
So.2d n t 921. n i ( ) n l f l c ~ , i t y , tllp cour t 9 t . ~ t ~ ( 1 ~ , H h O \ I l . h C ; l ~ l t ~ t , h j n
U·
ite
un",
n(,nenn to ho) el t h3 l ~ \ , b & t 3 h ~ q 3 b \ J ~ q
( ~ 3 n
only v ' U t ' 8 ' l ~
:f
._
...
;
t:=-'_.-
........
:..... · ~ I ....;..
.
, ,
;
":
~
.
,
..
:
. :" i-·
euL
\,
:
·,:,
~ ;
.'
W
: .
7
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 8/15
4
l l lal
ant1. t.llt .
tll' "itt
eij
{i
•
dopa.ft\,ro
l n
' ) '
t hOlla eft O ~
1.'
wh i eh
t-h4'1'
l A
1\
' t ll '3 tI _ J\p f \ t .
\
I t , ~ '-
l ~
tho crimI'
\
'COlSJ:l it t . J
n
) « H ~ . l \ I\<Jv \ t
h t
\JU' 1 \ ' ' ' '<hH' ' ) ' ' t'tt;J
wh' \·h
~ l \ J
1
(1
J'l)rn
\
t ,1()vnvA "tl rlcf,\;\ ,:. t
\)1
'n aVP I ' \' •
: '.
,
enaCt
o f d r ug A 1coho 1
\
ct ion ,
t t V ~ D I , ~ ~ r t l l t
ur
on
. \.hp.
't'
I
1'
1udgo
'
fJ
r
l,,(Iln(J of
<'t-\Iq t l l ' \ c t
l( ' l ' cO"'llPc' w l t ~ l K ; ; . \ ~ t \ a \ '·.t)
t()
j .t:
rohRbll}tat . lo ' l , .
t.hp ( 'O \ l r t
rbI ' pm'pOAtH\
o r ( ~ U , rhd
,,;tf2 d ~ l ; t U.- • • }/..
el' r d.f'··
dnnt
I II D\Jl lRtnf lca
l . ) \ a ~ ~ ~ \ , p t .
, ~
C.·(\f\p ' ( l ~ , o ( l t J } . J ~ ~ f . ?
vi t l \
t l l 0
r I' a r
"l " UJ
n
nI)' 1
1
t.)' -t 0 ,.
es
f,., l ,'
1 ,
t.
t \ n 1\.
. . .
t
W
1
Jl' I ,1
tho t d\)bnOta ( ~ C n t ) \ . f : ' ~
•
At.
And'
nIl .,
1
() Q,
.
( ~ : \ n l \ ~ l . \ \IA t
i
r \ ;\
d Q p a r t ~ t r @ .
T l ' f t r ~ ~ \ , q . t
1,*'.l
l"a
p\
f \ ,.1
\
1 ' ~ ~ . ~ ( 1 I-'(.)t, C:( la
pot.ontMA\JllAtt\nllal
~ l < 1 P ( . ~ ~ t.J\at
'r
t l l ~ f l ~ r q ' i \ ( l # t n t . '
~ n ·
to J C 0
a r lJu
(I
1
nor (1
.. t () 1
n 1 t. 'r
"
t '"
An' f ()..
t.
tl
{ ' f t p o n ( l ~ 1 1 Y ,
lhaa·C} l
R
t ' ~ 3 o n ~ l l l D
J l ( lPP ' 1"·\ 't. '
t t \ ~ \ ~ ' . r l l ,
t l' e "
t m*
n t 1 ,,1
1 1 he
( U H ~
(:
12tH \J'1 .
•j
110J:1:10, 560;? ]O.2C) nt·,
t hn t
fphnl)L 1
At.lc)l' vi'
1 '>4
~ \ J C ( + t . ' f , * .'\J
I ) .
(:
ta,
Ilorl ·"" n
cnBO,
t I t .
C f , ) ~ l t t .
( ~ ( ) ' l c J u { l ' l l
t.llA':
' - J l ~
~ \ l l ( l ~ t , . ~ g
'139
, j.
J r,
suf
f
Ie l on t to A\JPCl'0r
t.
t h ~ ' .. @ d \ ) ~ ( d
A ~ t \ t ~ f U ~ t 1 ,
•
T h ~
r at;t.
that. Itlt £l'.
n
had f t b D t l ~ l u S
frol l (h',a<jA for
i t Jl4Sl'Io(')
or tloCJ. ro)hlVh"-, t1.h l np , l iH
.
por lod
or
~ l \ t f \ t f t l · Y t r @ ~ t . q n l v#.\ ' f J . C 1 t e · ~ t . l '
J:i\
.. ffir lC?" '- ~ ' f l @ t l - l ' g t j (
tJ'e
potent1"l
tor
r@I,,,Illlltiit 'on.
l J . ~ 1 ; . t l n ,
141A
n· f ) ~ ) ' ,
f u r t h ~ r
b ~ l i n q
t . i e { l n ~ l o t : ~ ~ \ @ rOittf . \ont
\ 3 3 gQ\ l f lh lVap .
fO\ltV-J
.
eonolu.lon. UI..t.t.ln, ~ ( , O
60.
; Z ~ 1 t ~ 2 : r . . ~ . . , {
Ao 1n IlJtxAn,
Hr.
Corroft'
fJ
f \ · . ~ ~ f \ , , ' ) i
11
t Y l<) · 1 t @ A \ . , , ~ ~ ~
.:
I t rongth
t hid
<Jo." I t.-ent, to t@hab"lll
tAt
l(lO ~ f ' \ ~ v i I C J ~ ' l - e f l ( l
voluntary ..ubldth,lon to counlllJJ InfJ
pt
hn
t.o
t h ~ ~ n - r . ? l ~ t i u r ; ot
·
U U ~
1
. . .
f
....:
01
2
•
.
.
. ..
.
·J.t
i ,
;, .
;:.;
\i •
:.. -
8
.-_.
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 9/15
.
.
.}
:
•
~ l
·
criminal
n,t
hy
hlR cnnt· Il\uo,' { ~ ) = - l t f t l ~ ~ ' f '
t h G ~ P Y t . h l ~ O t l h t h ~ l ' l 'pgt·tnt ( , : \ ~ .
t iPP ,,1 "( ' rl aBtel. t 1 (\ ) (1
At
.
574 ( d C l r ( l r H ~ ~ l t · vo l\1nt , ; ~ , Ia
\1 h'tl \
p g
1
(\Il
h \ , ' \ l l l l l p
p,
f l ' J
pr
1,'1r
9 ~ f ·
tanc lnq .,,,.Ii
w, \1 lnclnnAn i,n I \ ~ r t c 5 \ ~ t 1 n t
r : t ' l
n.".,t f ~ \ J r ~ n ~ f · p
t-
COt' : 4) n
..
1 1
n
t.
t
p p t t n h I q (' 0
J '
n \ t n p r,
t
t , " II t I
1\
\I
jl
tIP ,t p.1\ t f' 1\ f :)
R
10 n
q
nu
np
C CUl :\ r )' t 0 I'll"< . oJ" l ' 1 , h (. (\ 'tIl\ 1
t
a f' P h
~
l' I t
:\ t
I tH '
" t
hO\HJh t
hn
t
1
(11'
l l t : l
i l lPI
nna ( 'O l l l
t j'.I
pa ..
I f \ .' ~ i ~ ~
,te t
p,
13
lilac) t iM, .
o Xptn '
t t c:)Sl t \
\IIOIlY
lla f lO
t
,\ n e
P
f : l lQ" I ) t 1Q \I .'lH', t
( l l ~ I , ..
,) f Ol n' a 1\:\ ' \ ill·
t
Y
tor
h
n
b I
1
I t
:\
tin
n.
II
e
r
1
1:11.
(,
n
() . ;
I I
:\
t
t
'p
C
')
r t
p
f \n
t
r
a 1
y 0 )( C 1 \IT
l
v pI}' 0 n
HI .
() I r Q I'l • R t:t c:>l r ·
'.I
o I v \ I \ IJ
t t;'pI
e P .,. n t I t t jon p , "
nn 0)(
t
ft
nd #
p
g r 1()(1 C) r t 1na
I
i
I"
:\ 1,
1\
1· ., 11 1I )) ' v \ 1 1 .. ,
P
R
t t f ) t h «3 , 1 f @.., ..
. 1
,
J '
l
thn t
rgh
h.\ 1
1 t.
A
\
btl c:.,
n
l ~ . f t
rl 1\111)
I \
h
: "
v \
t
h l"
t l r'l.
I mac-I'
t h·
.. . VY :
0 .
Raynoldn wl11 t g l l
t.hg Cc'\llJlrt . h ~ t Hr.
C·O . . . .
D ; l lQ ~ \ n t
( ' tnl ,
c ~ l * H · h H \ C - ·
f·
, .
• I i
1
nq
roact
I
c)@llt:ClPfq
o f
c
1 \
n
I
COl
I
Q
J
I
r
~ r \ ( · e .
1'\lt.
t
hI:?
<f
o\lf farn
f
ron
A
IlorAonn
11 ( pt"lr(l
a
r .
n ~ ~ o d
UllQ",
(3 :£ '
aht1 '
J \ A ) . ~ . , O
, •
..
• I
\
I
;
r
loqlc4\
1
tnn t lnfJ
n"f.1
Qvn
f\lnt ion
n1' , ~ i · l o ) r J a v
L
,
l O l \ l ~
,
h ~
w'lth
t
U·
lonq-torC '
.. trant.llt\nt.
C o r ~ A v i I I ~ h l ~ t.r, n ~ ~ . \ ; ~
Jllc;t
r ~ ~ ) v -
.
Qry.
..
: n : : : : : : : : t c ~ C : l l : l l ( : : 3 l:csOl .1A rQ;u l y i\7,i.c>nrlhlc n ~ h ~ h &
Hl\Utfr r
t·
Althouqh
lLor.IJ..n
d g ~ l t . w1th l l ruf j
,Mklloh.
~
t ;utt .or
h-6t
tl-1'@R9'll
» '
1n tho
CliSO
8t
.bar, t h ~
( ~ t ) \ l r t l
o f t .hl0 C * l ~ · . ~
~ ~ · · ~ . o
f ~ r - « ) l , n ~ ~ .t.hAt. a
If
1
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 10/15
.,
'
..
.
1uotlfy ml, ,1Ql\t . l ()n
o f
A P , ~ t Q n c p
v l \ ~ t \
( ( ' \ a r ~ l p c ' vltt,
anc t \ 3h l l l t ' v
.i'
,
r . h l l b l 1 1 t ~ t ~ o n . 5.nlth v. : ' ~ _ l a ~ e , 0;1) In
.•
h1 o;n (r l4i .
'.1
( ' .eA. '·.HUq: ·
s . t . a ~ o ....Y_t. ,1)(e1Yes. H , 1
h l .
} : ~ l
• 1 1.1
( l ,
C , A I '.11' I; ·(1
r.
le
r l . h'"
Y . . . . _ A . l ~ ~ . ~ l l e . t . ")') \ : ~ o . J< \ <lJ
Q
(r
1 ,(\ P. C . 11, ' 1 ' j ~ ~ ) It \ At 1n J\\1'
~ , \ ,
nCJ
\ i
tlielYo8 0
n CJ t" O\J
nt l t:' t. h: \ t :\
n
p :t. , 1 \ t
\' t
t
r
(2 t I t C)
n
'.:: J
r\c,t
es41,a \ ...
:\
1
~ n '
to
Bhow
l
nq
i\
'* t:
r
onr-l
not I ..." ,
Lon
r,'.'
,ph : \ t\ \ 1 \
t l\ \ \
( ~ \ - l t h ~ ~ a l _ \; ,f
Ilte.l.Y.e
Q, " (,
1
li ( l
• ) (1
f)
l (r
1:\,
1 r1 ( ' l ,
C
. A .
1
.)
n ~ , ) . r
f\ I , t l
g' :\
Uf.· •
h
\ l l )on
g ) ( p n r t ~ ' : av l ~ n c p
' hn t
t h e ( l O r ~ l \ ( l ; ' \ n ' QU(
rClc ·41
( rC\ : I J'(\Jit T 1 · : t \ ) f t ~ t ; lc
S t rODR n1 R i h r f l ~ r
wh
leh w:\
a :\
f t c
n: \
h'
a , <) UP=- t P H t by f h , , ~
' I tn:\
t·
O\l t rQI \ ( : l , pt(){ lr i \nR.
T l , ~ ( ' ~ l \ l t ' t \ f ; \ A P ~ l ' Q \ I ~ c ( l fUI'iJ ,o"
- ( \ t l c ~ r · t ' I J \ q
,
)
:! do f ondl l n
t •
A pot q n t 1 ,
f
t r . ; ~ . r o'Sh:t h \,1 \ t t
h}' \ he 1:-r R t. \
nl\ ,,;
n e; .
l f ~ . l ( . I
(I-om rn1D11y, fr ani lA :\.\(1 'rnlll(.) ....
Q
.. tn , n g ~ A n t t . ' 3 ~ ~ , t .ho f i \ f . ~ t _
, 'n '
thn t
Hr.
CQrr f t3 hn"
t h "
0rrc,nvhtl. n,n
q
AUN'lot 't
I)f . ' \R f ~ . I l ~ ' . frh!tHtn
an(1
potan
t
lAl ca'v 1oyq
r
A ... « l I ~ u.,· ctlh" n-CC31
h'
~ i o t . . : S f , t i A
t.
tn · l ~ ~ l f ( ) ~
-) h
Cully
rahnb, l l l
t"ltu1. r J ~ ~
1
pI: tc
r4 bn
it cHI' 'JWW
Ae$}
. .
r a '
. O \ , l ~ f :
Tl1Cl
~ ) ( Q . l ~ Y R Q
( ' ~ C ,
9
'on
va
A \ I I ~ ~ ~ f · J ' I ~ t .
1
Y
\ t,
~ ~ . 1
v,
t
t\ :tl'l1r()'(A
1
lty
tho
8tlcon(f
plnt r
l e t Court o t
A l l P ~ A
I l
( ; t \ A ~ • n
\Ill \ ch t l , ~ · c l p f ~ f \ . ~ 1 3 h l
raco 1vad R n 1
t
1qll tOfl 9 \ f l c ~
r
o r ' : ( lnV' 0 1 Cf}\ .J ' , l 9 )f
I'
8endinfJ thraatonlnq l Q t ~ Q r Mid
tour ~ { ) \ J J \ t :
or t ~ f ~ 3 l ~ h i ; \ ~ h#U.
to
II
pUbllc , l I f t rVf tht b ; t t t ~ d upon t hq t . nA I C ~ \ J I . t , ~ n , f V l I . ~ t,h\\t hi,*
aotion. ""ora
..
) t v 3 t ~ d I)"f
' ~ t , ~ . t r A 1 \ ~
q ~ l ) ' ~ ( } n ; \ \ {()h(l't.'I.I)n'"
.•
aaltb.
5)2
so.2d At
I n Af r ' l ~ '
nq
lhC ·f.ltilfnXtl'''.' ( l ~ I ) A t tu."\ , ' ~ h ~
'The
atJo of t . . h ~ dot 'ant , , ~ U ~ 1 8 0
bqt tn
· h ~ · l · , . ) to ·• . ltlq"t . .lnq
fao·tor
whon,
by vlrt'lo () age, t.hlQ ( i J l r 4 · r . . ~ J ~ n t
... t)()/)f!')
( ~ ~ n < J l e : i 8 t e
fof
rClhablll·tatl()n. j).l,At..,t. ..· .•~ ~ l t O I . ' ..ll4; ~ ~ ~ t$-9,ll.1 4 ~ . ( r IA. ~ t h
D·.el-A;
19a8).
.
t .· '
_
. r:'.
." - _ *
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 11/15
__
-
.. .
-. .
..__ r ....
• It . ·
.
It
d ~ , D t r l c t
~ ~ O \ . r t ( . ) l ) o r v , , ( ' ~ t l \ l \ t
the) ~ V ' t ' O f \ ( i
( ~ ~ ' ' ' C 4 : t 1 tl'"'J
- t . h ~
~ 1 ~ f O t l 1 1 \ l · p
UiO'i<Jh
~ o t i O n l \ t b l l n t ~ l l p . ~ h ~ A l I H t ~ )u12tHl,," ( 'l\thHl' P.\'P.t\
j
j:
t
n t o P J ) @ ~ ho r t of c h u ~ q f \ l J t : \ U f \ q \.H.·onl'C2t.C3tlC
D
,\.
ntntad b y ~ } t Q
( l lAt ' - let ~ ( \ \ . r t :
i
1)1' in , , ;u\J ty .
J.d, Aft
;
','
Slta'th
A I 'Hln '
R h p ~ n t \
R . . .
'n \ '0
t J ; \ \ ) rJ f ) f f ' \ ) ,
. ~ \ t f ' l l
a3 t t.C'llin All h ' n d ~ n ~ l l · o \ ) P ~ ~ ( . l ,
t
t \1) l'
t\fl' J
,Nt <'f r ~ ( : I,d' •
v
1
the ..
\11'
1 h , l ~ r ' o , , ~ ,
rtn(' t.
h ~ l ' H . , ~ , P '
\ , t
\' t t l A t
I
P
b ~ I \ v l o l t
vt\g
inf
l \1pnr",l
,'\ '
..
t ( ~ r A
''(It. l ' t ' t i p ) ) '
v \ t..
l ' \ I '
" 'A cOt,t i· C)
1. .
froq\JO.lt clt.C:'(l
'n
P\IJlJlt\I" ( l ( < 1 o v : v ~
..
(l c.l"'l.. ~ r t \ a . ' t ; t
i p
:t f l ~ r ~ n ( l a t \ t . f
p
{Jaf\\) 1no
I ' ~ ~ o r
• rO l ' CC'"P t
l
t
u t
h)l\:t
\ t
Q; l
1
; \c}c
0
r t "'n01
PP
c l \ I ~ o t
c o n 8 t l t . u t ~
n .vnl1cl
~ A A ( l n f<.l"
lJ,J)v:tr,l
f l q l ' ~ r t ~ \ , J l ' ~ r t ( l ~ t - ' l ~ ' J \ J l ( l ~ - ,
.,
.
11noo. I h ~ r t
1
t
~ = o t ' g ~ ;
on ' - h ~
l ~ : \ n
llf
t
hp
I J f r ; ~ v , ~ t - i§-:l,Y. h o v ~ V ~ t · .
...
.
proparly l)(t
c o O ' c _ 1 ~ 1 · ~ ( 1 .,,* n
l1it. ' f ' ~ Itv(J
r ~ ( 7 t . ' . ) r . ~ ~ t a . t e
Y . ~ .
Ji.A.J;J\ l.
~ 2 ~
\i' .
S O . ~ d
a t
l ~ Q P e : __ v . _ ~ .. ' - u ~ r , - e . H I r ~ o . ' : c ) ;It_ I O · F · ~ l h V .-::o'Wit'lch,rl
ovldunco
o f t ' o ~ o r O Q
tsny
tOIHHIJr,y cot"llcl,?,'' ' 't'
, , ,
* , l th '3t. lc);\ ot
tho
8ontQnco):
f . t t _ Q . _ t . t ~ y _
...
_ U P l f t ~ , i l .
'j '11
00.
}cl
10.09
n:J.
)
t U.
A,
·\
9',)l.)
,
.
;
.
',
1
n
tt,o 1
nn t.
ftnt
~ ' a ~ , H,·.
..
r@A vi 11 A l ~ q : , lij' I""t:
onil l l
V
of III @
\
f lHH){
o f
h h
t)r.
Neynoida'
•
<
b)· tho l tu:it
'l\onv:{,r \ : 1 · ~ . A t t l n ~
~ @ n l \ l
~ l l l ~ h ~ r ~ ~ l ~ .
t-r.;tfQi,\'A t t ~ ' t n g n l
In
U l ~ r t t p y
:r"uttt U n d ~ l l V l f l f l
t
Dol. ly
on
tha 1 ) 9 f ~ n d a f l t ~ ' A
PO
If ~ f t f l 1 ' V ' n'1 tupt H ) ~ . 'I
rOlllor.o. Hr.
Corr'-n'g
~ j r - o · - l ) r r J e
, , ,
e t J r r C ) l ) ( l t · ~ ' : ~ · J ; ·
tty
'.'
.
••
plrlca 1
f
IndlnfJ"
ft8
voU
, .
..
w·
hoslth
counnolor.
SAfah
b r ~ d l o y . b r ~ d l ~ y
Court
tho btoal(
th·rourlh
v h l ( . ~ h
o<obtted 1ft"".
"hon
'ho
wa
•. t lnally
ttblo
rovt:t-.tl
Ji
"
.
. r . . ~
• J
' . . ,
,
I •
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 12/15
•
~ .-_. ".:
..
-_._-:-._-----_.__
.•.. _ _ _ _ ~
,
, .
Ii
c r
1.1
3 1
ellA ·C}Q f ( l ~ ' '1,,1 eh Ill'
n<.'v r
A
t
l
nu
. 0.,1)1'
\Of,
J .. .
tho n ~ f ' n d n \ h \
P
to ht;hJ
\ '-
n
\ ¥
I t
h
ta
n .m \ ' ( l t l U nt 0\11
H
· ',
1:
"n(1
t ' o J \ o r ~ a .
wh
' e h
h:\lt , \1
h P l '
t.
n
f \11' p , i I J h ~ d ~ f 4 . : hP.o1 v, \
\' , } , ~ o n
h '
n .
: ,.
'; / II
i·
o 1C:l v 'ncJ vo
h l l l t
l' , 1Y ;..
III
U n r ~ \ l l t:*h ,,1 h'
A \
l ," l ~ r 'n l 't
~ . ~ t . h'p. 1
BY •
Hr,
Con'' ' 'n P01UUH1
n(l
r
\It. 11 r
P.
t h ,. P 3 t
'n
A C ) ( ~ ,
p.'
),', : ~ r . (t
..
t,.,3 ~ ' \ ' W f = ( . '
ntnn, .hovovp.r, t.hA of U\p ~ r f a I \ P P \ { h ~ f h ha hO\p < : · W ~ · : l : l l t h : H l
l
\
Ul ' lm I P t \A .AR
ftnd
ack
now 1 A d ( , p . ~ t
h:\
l
n
pP.
t '1
1
0 f \ Ill :\
f' c a,
' ( t ; '
f
t.
I
Iv., •
1Hl{:onl
Inqly, thn ( ' c , f g t ' ~ {1(lPR rH'·, A ~ O ~ ttl ~ v ( ) ' { I . l , , ( ' 1 : \ . ' · ' ~ c ; l ' · ; ' t ' . \ f l . ' l ~ ' . h @ t .
i t
i
g \ J l l ~ l t . t : q ( l
t.t,,,t
n
f l ' a , · ~ ~
..
t \ . I P
~ p n t . c I a
in
t.1)o
t ~ Q ~
o f
tV(\
at\{l
.i
.'
ono-hn 1r Y · ~ ~ 1'"0 l A , l r t ' OJ'll' , t't t \ I n , l ~ l ~
t 'hp
c l r ( : , . . ~
t
A \ ( : : p ~ 't r h 9 C; \Ae.
I
Horcrovor.
;l:lnv. ' P t . Q I H ; ~ ' C J i I ~ ~ t j : I
of ,.
hAt vh ' d l 'Q ..
a . ( ~ \ . ~ A t ~ t l
\ to \
ld
.j
oorvo no
, : ~ g n : t l ) l o J l \ l l ' l l O ~ ~
n t ' h ~ , ' t . J l ~ n
t,(.l
J . t . ~ ~ p
) ~ f \ ~ ) ( ~ i i J \ l ~
()f t f \ i .a
; . }
,
dofandant.
I :
: ~ . •
Wh 11
fJ
., b 9 V g r Q
~ @ I ' t . n ( ~ q ( ~ ~ n
J l ~ n d tl . 1
1) I
q f t ~ ~ PAqq
t
4'
:.
doolcrty 'han t \ C h l ~ . h l @ t ~ J In
· t e t l ~
prolHH'
c;(Jfltp.d,
~ . l A t ~ n ( ~
of
.hq
..
co.po
111 O<J n 1t, 'fa t l <1
r
+Ic
t.or't' 'n t t l q
AP. #\
t.
b=t r
C o u n ~
1 ·
~ q ; \
\ j",-t
.
1,
h
8uch l \ ~ t
10n.
\
a.an3bl Q
rol1ot) 11 , tn t ' on :\f"1
At..
r i)"q
ly ..t' v ~ t . . f ? { l
tC:l Ach i e \ i ~
~ . ' I
,'; , .
c o . p l Q . Q n ~ 3 ~ Y
flO,,11) of t.()t..Bl i ~ q l 1 3 t l l l ' t . 3 t l t } f \ ~ h d c f ~ n I 1 1 9 l ~
Viet l .
" .
c.J
.
r
••t l tutlofl , Thct
O U b ~ t t n t l B l l l k ~ l l h O { ) f l thM.
l I l . b ~ f ~ h 1 3 f \ t . Will 1>9
;
.- :.
"
8ucca
• •
'u l i '\ h i d gffo t th to
A(1c'oi.qllllj})
t o h ~ l ) l ~ : ·
'.101i
18 ' , l l i j s t : r t t ~
.... ,.
:'. -.'
='t • •
r
.
@d
by
hiD,
(IOnulno
r c u ~ o r . e A",ft by Ills' Alt<H\il c ~ O ~ ) t J ~ ; 4 l to V.tthtl-
• I
.
pa.tlon in tt
ttGfttJ\ont
tJI}';Ilnll._ b·ott, ttl '. t ~ ) r r @ ~ ' ~ t . r · ~ f t l l ' ' ' ' ( j MiJf\t··A.i
hoal
th oounoo lor.
~ ~ Y d 1 t . 1 O J
At.Af8 h .nf3d.iey. 3fit levt)
ru;,u.l
n ~ - : .Ut
.
aera'ld
RtJynOlt.lta; 89t9@ tba l
•
' l r l ~ o n t ~ t _ Itl ~ M C · · 1 a 9 of {h-at · P t ~ I · @ d
ri ' -
.;
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 13/15
't
.:
l
• V
f
.
. by
tho dafCHHH1 w(.l\lhl,
at.;·
~ ~ l , l l t:\l ) ' ancl, At ' 'nAt e \ ) . ~ ~ t ..nt . n \ '
hn.po
I ' , t
ha
u l t ,
n:\\
Q I J o ~ : l c\
f
r
CSh3
h t
1I
t . t
'I'''.
'f)
WH t:1U: rotH:.;.
I lJ \d ,
r \ h ~
IliH \
1n i l a,' I I e\ l " , I : I ' I I ,'eoy .,
f t
h ' I l l ( ' : \ '* . t. h p
O o f ~ n d l \ n t
1 ~ n Y A
t IMt t h I
{ ()\In
v,
11
n H c s r 1 1 1 ~
\ I \ ~
' ,ItI ' · O\Q
'''Ii'
l. .
oy to bi ) p ~ l 9 a n
t ad 0\ t
t
h., ho , 1 1 ) I '''
tl e'VoJlho t
£ I
OJ
Q 1. :\
,I h l l p ( \ ~
f:
(\ lD
1t 1
q:\ t
o , \ 1 1 ~
nn \
.m e tI 0 f
h w nd c.'n - h . .
l r Q of)' a In, 'a 1 ' ( ' , · : \ t , f 'n
,
1
r o l l o"'Qd b ~ pr
0 <1
\
10 w l.. h
t
h "
R p p C
If I
C
J't ( l V I I r 1 I (\nc,J _ h:a n .
o 'i)
.
~ c1
n)'
ctr ~ l \' ft f
t
r .
\
(OJ
'.J
, •
~ •. ;
.#
.
0
.
I
)
.'
;
'\·,
~ 1 ~ h
\.,
r - i \ ( l ( ~ l
]
I
A';Q,' .A. t r ~ . Ii, 'Ii
·ito11
'J-Jir,c..... ••
0') R :t
(1
A It n,
J
. I l 1
\ " . A .
,•
J'
<7 u,',
t
t gl t
. ,.
'=
,
\ I l t ~ r
( 1
;\ ..V
i\
t p
r . 0
l' ,
(1 A
'I
P
l () t '( l n:\ I' .,
(1
. ( l
.,
R , fl 1
( A l l ) 4 J , o f J u ~
:[
f,
·.f .
:{
t
t
I,
f .
iI
:. r
.:#
...
f' .
'
f · · \
.'
,
~ J l t , X \ t ¥ i } f ~ : i : · · S
. . i ttff
±ris'
0
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 14/15
•
\
':
.
' ..
;
C- lflCAI.I,
01
e
.•'I.CI
I I n : R ~ i Cf:RT'nV t h ~ t a t n H ~
a r ~ l { lO I I 'A t ' t
~ n . i .
nr. t.he.
f , ) r ~ q ( ) l Q
haa baan f fu·n i .h"d. by
h,,'HI.
t t l
Rl1t\tffT
I.nflt1.
j:tlQtH.Hi.
-"llftSlitant
Stato tlQ
i
1 UY. f
1
44tr,,\
VQn \ lR
"o
..
t.h.,
C \ O ; \ r - · ~ t ~ r . r,l,c;'1
Ida
,.t.,,,.
on
th lo ~ ~ 1 ~ L dOly or Hovr(;t.t\bcll'. l Q0 1 , .
f '
.
I • . I (
, , ~ ~ j \ I . I ~ ~ j
~ / { ~ ~
~ ; ~ _ , . _ ......
Q
lh:nrn
, . .
' ' ' '
tin
. ,
I
11
).
)1
t,
J
.
J.4
i
.
~ I k
.
. . .
: •
:. .
.
8/9/2019 1993, 11-05-93, Memorandum, Downward Departure Sentencing, opt.pdf
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1993-11-05-93-memorandum-downward-departure-sentencing-optpdf 15/15
•
,r:l
e
"
.'
..
.
•
...
-fl
:
H UC\l(l ' l \ iU\( (oh\l\('1 ChMlt'\ n. Ad.lit.
t
\ , ~ .
Hr.
Mr. Arthur E. if\dmlr\'
:
~ I r ~ . [ ) ( ) n ) t l \ ) · · , ~ I .
,.\llll\lr(' ,:
al
~ I r . Rt)tlCrt I'. ~ ) R l (
~
M r ~ . I!t'th !J<>)"th
~ t r . \"111
\\. l k ~ ~
7)
r r l l ( l r l \ ~ ~
\\ '. ( ~ i ~ ~ > ,
F\<l
l i i rt'
8) ~ 1 5 .
' \ ' l l l ,\
1\ ( i ~ r \ O l \
Q
9)
.•\,\(1 \ l\('u
t)('ll
("'ar
\flll
10)
1r.
(),(k I).l i1
11)
..
\ I \ x ~ r t J. I:crr·aro. Sr.
12) ~ t r s . Ide' rt'rra.:{)
l.J)
~ t r .
Ntc
l o l ~ ,
\
r r r r ~ , r f
.
1·$) ~ t r . lC{ll\. J='Jtlt'"
f:
1..) ~ ,... I\ r t.llll
r
I). II
,1.1
1 )
~ t s ,
'11,(!Ill'.1 'ti I'.
R
11' ''-1111 "'1\
1;) Captain Richardt. Holly
), Ell" I),
1 1 ~ 1 1 1 f l l ,
{).ll.S.
1,'))
~ · f r .
Ita'11\C)·I.l.
11\1\\ .
It ~ I i . 1 . ~ \ l l c s. ~ ; l ) l o r
2'·)
~ 1 , r . Jotll1 (J., ~ ~ . I \ C ) ·
l2) ~ f r s , ; S\JC S. K I * ~ k . 1 l t ~ f ·
2.J) K)' M. I(och.
M ~ q u l r { .
1
Da\'ld
J\.
ttl'
~ l k .
If..\(l utrt'
25) ~ t r . IICI(!r l e r o ~
lfl)
f\1r.
alic" r\
'
J, ~ f i ( ~
11
acl R · l ~ . I I 1 1 f l l ( J
.•
r
27)
f\lr., 1)111111' J. ( ) e r ~
\:.
{:
I
28)
~ f J · . Sln.ntaf' Slll.itll.
}
j
29) ~ I s . S y l \ I ~ \
( ).
S t C l l l l C . l ~ ( ) I \
r
0) ~ t r . Jolln 1 ~ t l l 1 P \ ( ) t \
•
.'
: 1)
~ b f t:>orolJl)t It
ry.'ht
t)
1
2) ~ l r . tfllf)'lmS \ V a l l c r ~
3.3) ~ t r .
nrld
~ l t
Ray
\Vcbllef
34) David 2 ~ ~ l t ( ) ( k l . O,t),s.
,Ii
J
..
!
, '
'. t