19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and...

35

Transcript of 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and...

Page 1: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and
Page 2: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and
Page 3: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

UNIT OBJECTIVES

Upon completion of this unit of study, the student should be able to:

1. Identify the responsibilities of the fire fighter in determining the point of originof a fire and the basic steps to accomplish this task.

2. Identify the reasons for determining the cause of fires.

3. Identify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence offire causes.

4. Explain the indicators of a fire's area of origin and fire cause.

5. Explain the procedures for the preservation and protection of fire cause evi-dence.

6. Demonstrate the methods for scene and evidence protection.

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 1

Page 4: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

Successful completion of the information in this section is necessary to fulfill therequirements of the following sections of NFPA 1001-2008:

Fire Fighter I Standard

5.3.8* Extinguish fires in exterior Class A materials, given fires in stacked or piled andsmall unattached structures or storage containers that can be fought from the exterior, attacklines, hand tools and master stream devices, and an assignment, so that exposures areprotected, the spread of fire is stopped, collapse hazards are avoided, water application iseffective, the fire is extinguished, and signs of the origin area(s) and arson are preserved.(A) Requisite Knowledge. Types of attack lines and water streams appropriate forattacking stacked, piled materials and outdoor fires; dangers — such as collapse —associated with stacked and piled materials; various extinguishing agents and their effecton different material configurations; tools and methods to use in breaking up various typesof materials; the difficulties related to complete extinguishment of stacked and piledmaterials; water application methods for exposure protection and fire extinguishment;dangers such as exposure to toxic or hazardous materials associated with storage buildingand container fires; obvious signs of origin and cause; and techniques for the preservationof fire cause evidence.(B) Requisite Skills. The ability to recognize inherent hazards related to the material’sconfiguration, operate handlines or master streams, break up material using hand tools andwater streams, evaluate for complete extinguishment, operate hose lines and other waterapplication devices, evaluate and modify water application for maximum penetration,search for and expose hidden fires, assess patterns for origin determination, and evaluatefor complete extinguishment.

5.3.13 Overhaul a fire scene, given personal protective equipment, attack line, hand tools,a flashlight, and an assignment, so that structural integrity is not compromised, all hiddenfires are discovered, fire cause evidence is preserved, and the fire is extinguished.(A) Requisite Knowledge. Types of fire attack lines and water application devices mosteffective for overhaul, water application methods for extinguishment that limit waterdamage, types of tools and methods used to expose hidden fire, dangers associated withoverhaul, obvious signs of area of origin or signs of arson, and reasons for protection offire scene.(B) Requisite Skills. The ability to deploy and operate an attack line; remove flooring,ceiling, and wall components to expose void spaces without compromising structuralintegrity; apply water for maximum effectiveness; expose and extinguish hidden fires inwalls, ceilings, and subfloor spaces; recognize and preserve obvious signs of area oforigin and arson; and evaluate for complete extinguishment.

NFPA STANDARDS

2 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 5: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

NFPA STANDARDS

Fire Fighter II Standard

6.3.4* Protect evidence of fire cause and origin, given a flashlight and overhaul tools, sothat the evidence is noted and protected from further disturbance until investigators canarrive on the scene.(A) Requisite Knowledge. Methods to assess origin and cause; types of evidence; meansto protect various types of evidence; the role and relationship of Fire Fighter IIs, criminalinvestigators, and insurance investigators in fire investigations; and the effects andproblems associated with removing property or evidence from the scene.(B) Requisite Skills. The ability to locate the fire’s origin area, recognize possible causes,and protect the evidence.

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 3

Page 6: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

I. Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

A. It is the responsibility of every fire fighter to learn asmuch as he or she can about the circumstances sur-rounding the origin and cause of each fire

B. All fires should be investigated in order to bettereducate the citizens of the community

C. The investigation of fires is an important component infire prevention and public education

D. Arson fires result in the loss of millions of dollars ofproperty and deaths and injuries throughout America

1. Arsonists constantly put fire fighters at risk as theyattempt to suppress fires that were intentionally set

2. Fire fighters must learn to recognize and preservethe evidence of a fire cause for fire investigators.

II. Fire Fighter's Responsibilities in Fire Investigation(Essentials p. 909)

A. Fire fighters play a vital role in the investigation of anyfire

1. Usually the first to observe and identify evidence ofthe fire cause

2. Fire cause evidence can be destroyed by suppres-sion crews without proper recognition and proce-dures

3. Investigators are not always present during suppres-sion and overhaul and rely on fire fighters forimportant information to assist with the fire causedetermination

4 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 7: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

B. In most jurisdictions, the fire chief has the responsibil-ity to determine the origin and cause of a fire

1. This may be delegated to fire officers or fire fight-ers depending on local policies

2. Many departments have fire marshals, fire inspec-tors, fire investigators, or other members assignedto investigating fires

C. Missouri Division of Fire Safety fire investigations

1. Division fire investigators are stationed throughoutthe state and respond to requests for assistance fromlocal fire departments and law enforcement agen-cies for fire and explosion investigations

2. Investigators are certified law enforcement officersand have arrest authority in these investigations andare trained in:

a. Fire and explosion investigation techniques

b. Evidence collection

c. Interviewing

d. Fraud investigation

e. Other aspects of criminal investigation

III. Observations on the Scene (Essentials p. 910)

A. Notification of the fire may come from other thannormal channels

1. Reporting individual may walk in the fire station toreport fire

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 5

Page 8: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

2. Personnel may be stopped on the street by reportingperson

3. Personnel may be called at home

4. The identity of reporting individual, including ahome phone number must be obtained for a laterinterview

B. While en route to the incident

1. Time of day

a. Personnel must be alert to circumstanceswhich may not be normal for the time of thefire

b. Are occupants dressed as they normally wouldfor the hour?

c. Are the fire cause indicators normal for thetime?

(1) Business operations after normal workinghours

(2) Cooking fires at unusual times

2. Weather conditions

a. Bad weather conditions have an affect on thefire

b. Fire could be blamed on lightning

c. Severe conditions may slow fire departmentresponse thus allowing more damage to be done

6 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 9: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

3. Forced delays and man-made barriers

a. The longer it takes to get to a fire, the moredamage is done

b. An arsonist may create delays and barriers toslow fire extinguishment

(1) Locked gates

(2) Fallen trees

(3) Stalled vehicles on access route

(4) False alarms some distance from the fire

(5) Diversionary fires set in another location

(6) Obstructions to fire hydrants or sprinklerconnections

4. People and vehicles fleeing the scene

a. People are generally drawn to a fire

b. It may be unusual for an innocent person to berapidly fleeing the area

c. A fleeing individual may be the firesetter at-tempting to escape the area

d. Responding personnel should attempt to get adescription of:

(1) Vehicles leaving scene

(2) Individuals leaving the area

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 7

Page 10: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

e. Even when an identification can not be obtained,report the fact that someone did flee the scene

5. Observation of smoke and flame color

a. The significance of smoke or flame colordepends upon the stage of the fire when it wasobserved

b. Dark black smoke and deep red flames in earlystages of the fire may indicate a petroleumproduct is burning

c. Black smoke in later stages of fire might onlyindicate roofing materials and contents areburning

C. Observations upon arrival at the fire scene

1. Location of the fire

a. Fires burning in separate locations should beconsidered suspicious

b. Fires burning in unusual locations

(1) Under or on porches

(2) Along exterior walls with no extensionfrom the interior

c. Look for indicators that flashover or self-ventilation has occurred

8 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 11: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

2. Conditions of windows and doors

a. View into the structure may be blocked to delaydiscovery of the fire

b. Windows may be intentionally left open to helpventilate the fire

c. Windows broken prior to or at ignition of thefire

(1) Clean, unsmoked glass on the exterior mayindicate the glass was broken before thefire could build

(2) Clean window glass some distance from thestructure could indicate an explosion oc-curred before or as the fire ignited

3. Evidence of forced entry before arrival

a. Always remember to try to open a door beforeprying it

b. The firesetter may have forced entry prior thearrival of fire fighters

c. Lack of forced entry may indicate firesetter hada key

d. Always report evidence of forced entry toofficer-in-charge

4. Entry may be intentionally blocked to delay extin-guishment

a. Doors nailed shut

b. Contents placed in front of doors

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 9

Page 12: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

c. Door hardware removed

5. Condition of utility service

a. Confirm whether utilities were on or off

b. May assist with elimination of accidental causes

c. Check utilities for the safety of personnel

D. Observations while fighting the fire

1. Unusual odors

a. May be detected by personnel on the exterior

b. Unburned ignitable liquid or fuel gas odors

c. Can give fire fighters warning of possible flashfire

2. Reaction to hose streams

a. Observe fire behavior when water is applied

b. Flame flashback may be an indicator of ignit-able liquids burning

c. Water applied to burning ignitable liquids maycause it to splatter and intensify the burning

3. Be alert for possible traps designed to slow orstop fire fighters

a. Holes cut in floors

b. “Touch-off” containers of flammable liquids

c. Missing stairs or handrails

10 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 13: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

4. Watch for indications that explosion may haveoccurred

a. Possibility of second explosion

(1) Gas leak

(2) Undetonated explosives

b. Weakened walls and structural supports whichcan lead to subsequent collapses

5. Observe the location of the fire and what is burn-ing

a. Separate fires with no natural connection

b. Fires burning on floors

c. Fires in unusual or unnatural locations

(1) Closets

(2) Crawl spaces

(3) Under furniture

(4) Areas where there are no apparent acciden-tal fire causes

d. A large amount burned or unburned fuel in thearea

(1) Combustible fuels may be added to thenormal fuel load in an attempt to increasethe damage

(2) Be alert to a large amount of combustiblematerials piled in unusual areas

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 11

Page 14: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

6. Unburned or burning trailers

a. Rags, newspapers, contents, or ignitable liquidsintentionally used to help the fire spread fromone location to another

b. Trailers usually leave burn patterns on thesurfaces where placed

7. Volatile liquid containers

a. Consider the location and occupancy beforeconsidering containers unusual

b. Containers would probably be found in garages,workshops, etc.

c. An unusual number of containers may be suspi-cious

8. Structural alterations

a. Holes may have been broken into walls, floors,or ceilings to allow the fire to spread faster

b. Attempt to determine whether the damage wasdone prior to the fire and was not a result of thefire or fire suppression activities

9. Note any indicators of irregular or unnatural burn-ing

10. Note evidence of the fire being more intense thanwould normally be expected in the particular occu-pancy, which may indicate the use of accelerants

12 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 15: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

11. Observe the building contents

a. Valuable or personal property may have beenremoved before the fire

b. Note any of the following:

(1) An obvious lack of contents

(2) Contents scattered about, drawers open ormissing

(3) Furniture piled together at the seat of thefire or at points of entry

(4) Crates, merchandise piled around sprinklerheads to defeat the sprinkler operation

(5) Crates and boxes opened to expose com-bustible materials

c. Major appliances may be removed or replacedwith junk appliances

12. Fire protection and detection systems

a. If the building is protected by automatic firealarm or extinguishing system, systems may bedisabled or altered to defeat its operation

b. Sprinkler systems may be turned off

c. Sprinkler heads may be wired shut

d. Fire department sprinkler connection may beblocked by gravel or other obstructions

e. Automatic fire alarms disconnected

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 13

Page 16: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

f. Burglar or intrusion alarms may be disconnectedor turned off

13. Observe the spectators at the scene

a. Same people may repeatedly show up at fires

b. Spectators may try to hamper fire fightingoperations

c. Listen for comments from spectators

d. Watch for eager civilian volunteers who want tohelp fight the fire, may be a disturbed individualwho set the fire to help fight it

14. Observe the actions of the owners/occupants

a. Actions may be inappropriate for the situation

(1) Lack of concern

(2) Anger with fire fighters

b. Dress may be inappropriate for time of day -fully clothed in middle of night

c. May urge fire fighters not to extinguish fire

15. Watch for injuries to owners or occupants

a. May have been injured in a flash fire whenvolatile liquid vapors ignited

b. May involve burn injuries to feet, hands or face

c. A firesetter may be uninjured but have burnedclothing

14 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 17: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

E. After extinguishment of the fire

1. Fire fighters should report all of their observationsabout the fire to the officer-in-charge as soon aspossible

2. If at all possible, fire fighters should remain at thescene until the investigator arrives so the informa-tion can be given directly to him or her

3. Overhaul should be limited

a. Overhaul may change the fire scene and hamperthe investigation into the fire cause due to:

(1) Removal of contents

(2) Opening of walls and ceilings

(3) Destruction and removal of evidence

(4) Breaks in the chain of evidence

(5) Loss of flammable accelerant residue

(6) Destruction of the fire cause

b. In any case where a detailed fire scene examina-tion is going to be conducted into the cause of afire, overhaul must be limited until an investiga-tor has examined the scene

4. Fire fighters should make an effort to recall anyinformation they gathered and observed during theresponse and extinguishment of the fire

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 15

Page 18: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

5. Personnel should make a written account of theirobservations and actions

a. This written account is valuable if fire fightershave to testify in court later

b. Cases may come to court years after an incident

6. When a potential witness supplies information:

a. The witness should be taken to a fire officer ora law enforcement officer to obtain contactinformation

b. At a minimum, personnel should obtain informa-tion where that witness can be later contactedfor an interview by the investigator

c. Witnesses should be requested to remain in thearea until they can be contacted by the investiga-tor

7. Fire fighters should never attempt to interrogate apotential suspect

8. Fire personnel should not make any statements ofaccusations, personal opinion, or probable causeto anyone

a. These opinions can be easily overheard bybystanders or the news media

b. Careless joking or unauthorized comments canbe embarrassing to the fire department andpotentially impede an investigation

c. Unless authorized as the investigator, all firepersonnel should not give any opinion as to thefire cause

16 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 19: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

d. Personnel should simply state that the fire isunder investigation and avoid any other personalopinions

IV. Securing the Scene (Essentials p. 917)

A. Proper scene security is vital to the investigation ofevery fire

B. The scene must be secured until an investigatorarrives and the scene examination has been completed

C. The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that fire officials canremain at a fire scene for a reasonable time to investi-gate the cause of a fire

1. Michigan v. Tyler (1978) and Michigan v. Clifford(1981)

2. Due to these rulings, the investigation of a fire mustbe a continuation of the initial fire departmentresponse to the emergency

3. Fire personnel must have continuous control of thescene by physically being on the property

D. If a break in control of the scene occurs:

1. The investigator and fire department will be re-quired to obtain either a search warrant or volun-tary consent to reenter the property

2. The investigator may not be allowed to enter thescene at anytime

3. Evidence collected from an unprotected scene maynot be admissible in court

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 17

Page 20: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

E. Scene security procedures

1. Arrange for personnel to secure and guard thescene

a. Instruct personnel to remain at entry points andnot enter the area of the investigation

b. Unnecessary personnel in the scene may in-crease the loss of evidence

2. People who may try to enter fire scene:

a. Owners and/or occupants

b. Spectators/neighbors

c. News media

d. The firesetter

(1) To remove or destroy evidence

(2) To mislead investigators

(3) To cover-up the fire cause

3. It should be explained that the scene cannot beentered because:

a. Fire fighters have not finished their work

b. Structure is unsafe

c. They could destroy or contaminate the evidenceof the fire cause

18 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 21: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

4. Cordoning off the scene with rope or barrier linetape can help keep bystanders at a safe distance andhelp with security

a. The area to be cordoned off should be largeenough to protect any evidence and personnelinvolved with the investigation

b. The boundary must be monitored by personnel toprevent unauthorized entry

V. Protection of Evidence (Essentials p. 918)

A. If fire fighters discover possible evidence, it shouldbe protected and untouched if at all possible

B. Potential evidence must not be seized unless it isnecessary to prevent its destruction

1. The officer-in-charge must be notified of any dis-covery of possible evidence

2. Small items or areas of evidence may be coveredwith a box or salvage covers to protect it fromfurther damage

3. If the fire cannot be controlled, fire fighters mayhave to take evidence before it is further damaged

4. If it is necessary to remove evidence, the firefighter becomes part of the chain of custody of theevidence and may have to testify about the handlingprocedures for that evidence

5. If possible, any evidence to be moved must beproperly documented in place before removal

a. Photograph it in place

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 19

Page 22: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

b. Measure its location and record it on a sketch

c. Maintain a signed log of everyone who hadcontact with the item

6. By touching or moving evidence, fire fighters candestroy its acceptability in court

7. Evidence must never be left unattended

C. Contamination of fire scene evidence has become amajor issue in fire investigations

1. Fire cause evidence undergoes contamination fromthe moment it is placed in a scene

a. The fire itself partially destroys the evidence

b. Fire streams and suppression techniques furtherdamage evidence

2. To minimize further contamination of evidence, firepersonnel must not handle evidence with leather firefighting gloves which have contacted other debris

3. Evidence must be handled only with new rubbergloves, which are used only once

4. Personnel must use caution with their boots to avoidbringing traces of ignitable liquids into the scene

VI. Basic Fire Origin and Cause Determination

A. A fire scene investigation should be conducted at everyincident

1. Some fire causes may be obvious and not require anin-depth scene examination

20 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 23: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

2. Many other fires will require a length of time tocorrectly identify the fire cause

3. Regardless of any information supplied, the firecause must be determined from an independent andunbiased point of view and from the physicalevidence at the scene

B. Point of origin

1. Point of origin: the place where the fire started

a. May be an exact point, such as an electricalcord

b. May be a general area, such as a ignitable liquidpour

2. The fire cause will usually be located at or near thepoint of origin

3. Fires typically burn longer near the point of origin

a. The longer the fire burns at a location, the moredamage is done

b. Fires naturally grow upward and outward fromthe point of origin

C. Examination of the fire scene

1. Examination of the structure should begin on theexterior

a. Observe areas of fire extension from the interiorto the exterior

b. Check openings, such as doors and windows,into the structure

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 21

Page 24: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

c. Look for possible indicators that the fire beganon the exterior and spread to the interior

d. Be alert for possible evidence of incendiarismon the exterior

(1) Discarded flammable liquid containers

(2) Removed contents

2. Interior examination

a. Work backwards in relation to the fire’s travelor spread

b. Examine areas of little or no damage and worktowards areas of more severe damage

(1) Little smoke staining to heavy smoke stain-ing

(2) Little heat damage to heavy heat damage

(3) Light charring to heavy charring

c. Check the entire structure for fire travel

d. Ceiling damage will usually be more severeover or near the area of origin

3. Look for low level burning

a. Burning downward is usually slow

22 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 25: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

b. The point of origin may be found near the lowestlevel of burning

(1) Falldown burning must be eliminated

(2) Falldown burning debris may cause whatappears to be separate points of origin

(3) Falldown burning will not be as severe asthe low burning at the point of origin

c. Examine the underside of contents and structuralelements for low level damage

4. “V” patterns and the point of origin

a. The upward and outward growth of fire fre-quently produces a burn in the shape of a “V”

b. “V” will usually point towards the area oforigin

c. “V” may extend around corners, doors and walls

d. Falldown burning may cause secondary “V”patterns - remember to compare the amounts ofdamage

5. Check for the depth of charring of combustibleobjects

a. Deeper charring is usually found near the pointof origin

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 23

Page 26: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

b. The presence of flammable liquids increases theamount of charring

c. Be sure to compare only like fuels

6. Light bulbs and the point of origin

a. Light bulbs will swell or distort when exposedto heat

b. Bulbs may distort and point toward the area oforigin

D. After locating the point of origin, establish the firecause

1. Elements of a fire cause

a. Heat source

b. Fuel

c. Event which brings the heat source and fueltogether

(1) May be an action - striking a match

(2) May be inaction - not extinguishing a ciga-rette

2. Types of fire causes

a. Accidental

(1) Actions or inactions not intended to start afire

(2) Includes natural causes, such as lightningand spontaneous heating

24 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 27: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

b. Incendiary: fires caused intentionally or al-lowed to start intentionally

c. Terms such as suspicious, undetermined orunknown refer to the status of the incident, notthe cause of the fire

E. Accidental fire causes

1. Accidental fire causes must be eliminated before anincendiary cause can be established

2. From a fire prevention standpoint, it is as importantto determine accidental fire causes as incendiarycauses

3. Electrical fire causes - for ignition to be from anelectrical source:

(1) Sufficient heat to ignite the closest combus-tible must be produced

(2) The electricity must have been on

(3) The electrical component must have beenenergized

4. Heating equipment - most fires involving heatingequipment result from combustible materials incontact with the equipment

5. Cooking equipment - the fire origin is usually aboveor around the appliance

6. Smoking materials - smoking materials in contactwith lightweight combustibles may cause ignition

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 25

Page 28: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

7. Spontaneous heating - occurs in organic materials

8. Lightning -may produce unnatural burn patterns

F. Incendiary fire causes

1. Incendiary: intentionally set

2. Arson: the crime of intentionally damaging a build-ing or inhabitable structure by setting a fire orcausing an explosion

3. All incendiary fires do not involve the crime ofarson

a. Burning trash

b. Igniting a fireplace fire

4. To be the crime of arson, a fire must be incendiaryin origin

5. To prove that any fire was incendiary, all accidentalcauses at the point of origin must be eliminated asthe cause

6. Indicators of incendiary fires

a. Multiple fires: fires started in separate loca-tions at about the same time

b. Trailers - any combustible or flammable spreadto help speed fire extension to other areas

26 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Page 29: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINEMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

SLIDES

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

c. Use of ignitable liquids

(1) One of the most common indicators ofincendiarism

(2) Most structure fires produce little floorcharring prior to flashover

(3) Liquid accelerants intentionally pouredleave very distinctive burn patterns

(4) Liquids may leave “fingers” or “runs”

VII. Protecting Fire Cause Evidence Summary

A. Every fire fighter must learn as much as he or she canabout the circumstances surrounding the origin andcause of each fire

1. Fires are not only investigated to prove whether ornot they were intentionally started

2. The investigation of fires is an important componentin fire prevention and public education

3. When dangerous products are found and recalls areissued, it is because investigations found thoseproducts caused fires

B. The role of any fire fighter assisting with a fire investi-gation begins during the response to the scene andcontinues through suppression and extends until afterthe fire is extinguished

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 27

Page 30: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

TEACHING OUTLINESLIDESMaterial in italics is NOT included in the Student Manual

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

28 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

1. Fire fighters must be able to recognize potential firecause evidence while fighting a fire and take rea-sonable precautions to protect that evidence

2. Evidence can easily be destroyed by fire personnelnot being aware of their activities

Page 31: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

Name: ___________________________________________ Date: ___________________

1. When responding to the scene of a fire, personnel should be aware for all of thefollowing except __________.

a. vehicles leaving the sceneb. man-made barriersc. black smoke as fire burns through the roofd. obstructions to fire hydrants

2. Which of the following might be considered normal about the location of the fire?a. Fires along exterior walls with no extension from the interiorb. Flames coming from windowsc. Fires in separate, unconnected locationsd. Fires on or under porches

3. Clean, unsmoked window glass found laying on the exterior of a burning structurecan indicate __________.

a. the window broke from heat as the fire burned insideb. the glass is not part of the fire scenec. the glass was in place as the fire was buildingd. the condition of the glass could indicate an explosion before or as the fire

ignited

4. While fighting a fire, _____________ could be an important observation not only forthe fire cause but also for personal safety.

a. indications of previous forced entryb. unusual odorsc. a lack of contentsd. missing doors

5. Fire fighters should observe the building's contents and be alert to the all of thefollowing except __________.

a. an obvious lack of contentsb. contents scattered aboutc. numerous crates and boxes laying opend. cabinets doors closed and contents orderly

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE QUIZ

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 29

Page 32: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

30 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

PROTECTING FIRE SCENE EVIDENCE QUIZ

6. Which of the following is not usually considered to be some of the potential firecause evidence that fire fighters should protect?

a. Flammable trailersb. Vehicles in a garagec. Liquid containersd. Liquid burn patterns on a floor

7. If a break in control of a fire scene occurs, all of the following may happen except__________.

a. only the State Fire Marshal can reenter the sceneb. a consent to search may be required to reenter the scenec. a search warrant may be required to reenter the scened. evidence from the scene may be inadmissible in court

8. Fires typically burn_____________ the point of origin.a. up and in towardb. up and outward fromc. downward fromd. downward and outward from

9. When attempting to locate the point of origin, investigators typically work_____________ in relation to the travel of the fire.

a. backwardsb. forwardsc. paralleld. downward

10. Which of the following is not typical of "V patterns?"a. They usually point toward the area of originb. They can be caused by falldown burningc. They can extend around corners, doors, and wallsd. They point away from the point of origin

Page 33: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

LOSS CONTROL

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY FIRE FIGHTER I & II

32 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

PRACTICAL SKILLS

These Lead Instructor Practical Skills are designed to provide the LeadInstructor for a Fire Fighter I and II course with a more detailed overviewof the practical skills required of all students.

The appropriate skills from NFPA 1001-2008 are listed at the front of eachskill's section. Although the skills from NFPA 1001-2008 are written as JobPerformance Requirements, these have been divided into individual skillelements. This is to allow for consistency in the evaluation of each skillelement.

Students must successfully complete each step of each practical skill duringthe practical skills evaluation portion of a Fire Fighter I and II course. Atthe time of a Fire Fighter I and II Certification Examination, the skill stepshave been prioritized to allow a student to miss a predetermined number ofsteps.

INSTRUCTOR'S GUIDE

Page 34: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY

FIRE FIGHTER I & II PRACTICAL SKILLS

Successful completion of the practical skills in this section are necessary to fulfill therequirements of the following sections of NFPA 1001-2008:

Fire Fighter II Standard

6.3.4* Protect evidence of fire cause and origin, given a flashlight and overhaul tools, so that theevidence is noted and protected from further disturbance until investigators can arrive on the scene.

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - 33

Page 35: 19 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - IG · PDF fileIdentify the fire fighter's role and responsibility in the protection of evidence of fire causes. 4. ... Types of attack lines and

MISSOURI DIVISION OF FIRE SAFETY

FIRE FIGHTER I & II PRACTICAL SKILLS

Items to be checked

If the candidate:

1. Locates and identifies any potential fire origin and cause evidence within a fire scene.

2. Identifies the preferred method of preserving evidence is to leave it exactlyas found, if possible, with minimal water damage.

3. Explains the need for scene security until the investigation of the fire has been com-pleted.

4. Explains or demonstrates the following methods to protect evidence from further damage:a. Avoid handling or moving evidenceb. Cover potential evidence with salvage coversc. Rope off or otherwise secure the area

5. Explains how to document the type of locations of potential evidence.

Protecting Fire Scene Evidence - NFPA 1001-2008, 6.3.4Demonstrate Locating and Protecting Fire Cause Evidence

Test Objective: The candidate shall demonstrate how to locate potential evidence of the fire'sorigin and cause while attempting to preserve evidence for investigators.

Test Procedure: The evaluator shall have the candidate identify any potential evidence anddemonstrate or explain any methods which may be used to protect the evidence until the arrivalof an investigator.

Students are allowed two chances at each skill for successful completion. Any step listed initalics shall result in failure of the skill. Otherwise, students are allowed to miss a maxi-mum of one of the following steps and pass this skill.

34 - Protecting Fire Scene Evidence