19 Lawson BkRevs JAOS133.2

7/27/2019 19 Lawson BkRevs JAOS133.2

1/5

390 Journal of the American Oriental Society 133.2 (2013)

A u c , I , uc Qu cu u , u cpu,u c, u c pcu cu -, c cu qu uu x .

I c x u Qu c ux, Rc Qu B, cp pp-, uc . I ju p , u uc c u k ucu u c Qu c pc c , c p cu- .

T c cu cp Quc u. I uc k c c, u c u Qu.

Daniel A. MadiganGeorgetown University

Revelation and Falsication: Te K -q o Ahmadb. Muhammad al-Sayyr. E EtanKohlberg Mohammad Ali Amir-Moezzi. Tx Su Qu, . 4. L:Brill, 2009. Pp. + 363 + 201 (Ac). $259.

T u cp, , c uu cc c, A A A . Mu . S, k cf u -S , , u, -I, -B, -Qu, -K. H c u- T - -Ak (254260/868873) u k c Np. H p c-

c - -cu p-T c Qu. W pc . S u c u/ cu (.., Buu), u c . I p u p up x (gult), T S u pcu c c-cuc (u c ).

T x cu. T p u uc xu cp. Tu pk upp pc u c cc u u , , u cc, c u cc c p-cp -cu k. I u , , c ( puc) u cup Uc muha c -k cpu ccpc k T c

c, cu cc Qu c.T k c p. T c ju p

. P uu Ac xp c, c, upk p uc, u 201 p. T ppu cu u, k u ucp u c E uc (pp. 4650), pu x, 1076/1666 (M), uk (L),1311/18934 (T), 1319/1901 (B). T ucp cc u-N - (. 1902), u c Fal al-kib tahr kitb rabb al-arbb Mustadrak al-wail. T c x c Uc muha pc p c K - . T x cc 725 p akbr , cp asnd.

Ec p u pp u k u u xu pc N, j c


2/5

391Reviews of Books

(pp. 53289). G ucp, pu , k u .

T x p u (qirt) Uc muha, c pc . K (pp. 4142) cc cu- c p:

(1) c c; (2) uu ;(3) c ; (4) ; (5) c c (1) (4). A c, c: (I) c I . T . . . p-I, u k . . . () xpc . . . c :A ( p . . .); I, Pp ; walya; Pp ( pj pp); I, c, c. () pc p-I . . . I cc pp p S x. (II) u . [. . .] [c] xpc pc I . . . . R c (I)

c u I u (xcp pc pup); c (II) c (I) u -I k.

T pc p c; xqu c k p c puc p cu , u pc u . A K (p. 45), x uk cc pu cup Uc c u. Bu k p u c T ( u I) S Quc Su G B J D McAu. A c p pp .O c -S cuck barzak. T c k

ccu uc (pp. ), cp (bb) c basmala (pp. ) cp F (pp. ) c cp Uc Qu p. T cp, al-baqara, c pp. , cp c p u; .., cp 54 (pp.

) al-af(Q 61), al-jumua (Q 62), al-munqn (Q 63).T x p u Qu

, , O pp, , , Qu u c ujc c: O-u cc u , -u cc u [ I], -u up , -u cp c ( p c S). T c c qu -k I Mu -Bq (. 735), c Qu p [ u ], u (haqqun)

u . W u qim c Qu . T cp Qu cp 17,000 ( 6,000 pu Uc c) p [c] x, u Qu x , AL (pp. ).

T p c basmala c k basmala p , basmala Qu ( p u u x u basmalau cu p ). T uu p p u Q 17:46 cu basmala up c cu u u ck up T . T c c p u u

tasru c u u: -Bq k tasr basmala p, b p uu u G


3/5


(ba All), sn p p G (san All), mm p /k (mulk) ( , [majd] G); G c , H al-rahmn H c al-rahm xcu . A p F cpc c saba min al-matn(Q15:87) pup c basmala u. Bu u x. T basmala.

T pu, cc F pp : idin al-ir al-mustaqm 6, u idin ir al-mustaqm; iral-ladna anamta alayim 7, u ir man anamta alayim; wa-llln 7.3, p wa-gayri al-lln.

A k cp al-baqara pcu u c-c. A 2:1, dlika l-kitb cc tanzl al-kitb. T ccc yt u, x 2:255, T .I , , c c u 2:255 cu 2:1 . A cu c Uc c ,

G u u, u, Mcu Cp (bad) , u , . S p pk c T , pp G Mu pp u .

A 2:87 c -Bq c tahr ptasr. Acc cu c uc . T I p Mu c u, u u , , walya A, u x pu p Mu (l Muhammad) u p u k. T a-stakbartum, c u pc Ucistakbartum. Y pc c u c al al-bayt. T cp ck p u x pp. H, 2:91,

c c , A , B A concerning Al, , W [] u. A2:102 p: Uc A [] cu S A [] c about tewalyao te devils u S. A 2:90, A xpu , c G cu u Mu (nazala Jabrlbi-dii l-ya kad): E c u A about Al u (bagiyan). . . . T u tasr u ( jup 2:1 2:255). H x p ck 2:90 2:6 u p c. Tu p p -Bq , I, walya o Al u . Nx, 2:59,

G c , T uu amily o Muhammad up am-ily o Muhammad c pu. F p cp xc (20:115) Mu uc pcc Qu: A c wit specic words concern-ing Muhammad and Al and al-asan and all te Imams rom teir descendants (durriyyatiim) u . T c u J -q, :Tu, G, c Mu, up pc! A xp pp u u c 2:214 cu -qc T uc p p k ten saken again u [] , W p G? Uqu

p G . H, x u p pcc S qu -q u p (al-alt al-wus) 2:238


4/5

393Reviews of Books

c x I c , M c p p, and te ar prayer, G, u . T , p p, Mu c . W cc -k u cc cc c (ar) I c . F ucc, cu c -Bq c I A , c up c p arp. T x 2:106 cc p one better tan it like it k . Skpp 2:132 cu u cc. W Uc x , . . . G c u , xcp musallimn [ muslimn] to te walya o Alibn Ab lib. S 2:159 -q , V xp about Al W xp pp Bk . . . G cu. . . . T c 2:97 2:98 p upp :Jabral. T p x p,u 2:23, -Bq u G c , A u u u W up Ou S about Al, puc u

k . . . . A 2:177 xc c I p c hubbii hubb Al. A 2:269 ul l-albb u te sa o Al, may Godbless im, and Al is te gate (al-bb). A 2:275 D Ruc u Uc x. T cp c cu p,, 2:234. T cc u cu pc 2:240 p p u xp tahr.

A , ppu, E , u uc. T p (pp. 130), A-M, p u Wcp qu xu cup Qu, u p Ic uc, cu pcc T qu. Kc uc (pp. 3053) k -S, ucu

c k , cc p p k.T uu ( c cc ) x (pp. 32554) x Quc (pp. 35563). A u p ,p cup : c pu al-Durr al-tamn kamsmiat ya nazalat mawln amr al-muminn bi-ittiq aktar al-muassirn min al al-dn -cu AS c Rj -Bu (Bu: Mu -A --M, 2003) p c R Bu, T Dpu u Fc Qu Su S 20 Cu, Studies in Arabic and Islam: Proceedings o te 19t Congress, UnionEuropenne des Arabisants et Islamisants, Halle 1998, . S. L . (Lu: P, 2002),pp. 43746. T c pu k -Bu, Masriq al-amn wa-lubb haqiqal-mn (Bu, 2009) p - Fal al-kib(C, 2010) u u k puc.

I 873-4 pc I pc SI. T cc I dawa, uu I c p c (qira) Ep Su I - c. T c ppc I c -c T S u pc pp: cc c, BSu I p ucu. B I S, u uc c ccc u pu c pc, cpu, uc, u . I tanzl wa-tahr(c. tanzlwa-tawl) S c S c tahr u Ku( Ku), Mu c- u T x p cpu c

c u al-K. I p u cu, T c c c uc . I u cc


5/5


c p F ccup B u - T -tahrc A J - (. 1067). C, pc ju u pc cu p p. I uc cx, cu -S u T cu Su- uc u . H ccu xc u S?I , c c, c uc c marginaux u pu c pc Ic cp.

Todd LawsonUniversity o Toronto

Te Perect Guide to te Sciences o te Qurn (al-Itqn Ulm al-Qurn), by Imm Jall-al-Dn

Abd al-Rahmn al-Suy, . 1. T amid Algar, Mihael Shb, Ayman

Abdel aleem; O S. A. I A. -B. T G Bk Ic C-. R, UK: Garnett Pblishing, 2011. Pp. xxx + 301. 60.

Al-Itqn ulm al-Qur n J -D -Su (. 911/1505) p cu ujc c k cc Qu, c u- Mu u cpu; uu u k p.T u c/cp (. naw) cu c Qu , , cc x, p,xc, x, c, , x, Qu. Ec c c-c ujc u - k -Su.M Aku cc c, Iuc: B ppc u cqu,

Lectures du Coran (P, 1982; E. . Te Quran: Style and Contents, . A. Rpp [A,2001]), u -Su ccp: T ppc xu, c , cu, x c u cp, c- cc, cuc cp u (., p. 302). I u, Aku, k ortodoxy ortopraxy cc Qu (p. 303) p . A , al-Itqn c -cu Quc cc;-Su pc c pc u cc uc . Fu, pc hadt p c I T (. 728/1327) IK (. 774/1373). F, -Su p c - p up uc - -cu cp Qu, p c Aku .

A -Su k u u - . T pcu al-Itqn p . I k uc G Bk Ic C uc . I , p k cc p.T xcp naw c u .u.c/q/; R A -B Iu Ic Tu (.c) uc puc u G C H Qu .

T u c - naw, p u-p, -u Mu A F I (C, 1967). Cc k u p xc. W c cc x, ppc k u ck c. T

cc Quc p c. T , I cu cp u ,

19 Lawson BkRevs JAOS133.2

Documents

Transcript of 19 Lawson BkRevs JAOS133.2