150629 CLI ADVANCED SYLLABUS FALL 2015 Criminal... · 2016. 12. 16. · Page 1 of 6 COURSE SYLLABUS...
Transcript of 150629 CLI ADVANCED SYLLABUS FALL 2015 Criminal... · 2016. 12. 16. · Page 1 of 6 COURSE SYLLABUS...
Page 1 of 6
COURSE SYLLABUS ADVANCED PROSECUTION CLINIC: FALL 2015
INSTRUCTOR’S CONTACT INFORMATION:
George R. Dekle, Sr., Legal Skills Professor Office Location: 100-B, Bruton-Geer Hall Office telephone: (352)273-0815 Cellphone: (386)365-4611 Home telephone: (386)752-2897 Office Email: [email protected] Personal email: [email protected] Office Hours: Tuesday, 10:15am-12:00 noon; 2:00pm-3:00pm. At other times by appointment.
REQUIRED TEXTBOOK:
NDAA National Prosecution Standards, 3rd Ed. (on TWEN).
OTHER RECOMMENDED TEXTS:
ABA Standards for Criminal Justice: Prosecution & Defense Functions (on TWEN). ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct (on TWEN) Florida Rules of Professional Conduct (on TWEN) Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure (on TWEN)
COMMUNICATION WITH PROFESSOR:
Students should feel free to communicate with the professor at any time to discuss any problems confronted or issues requiring guidance. You have my cellphone number. You are encouraged to use it. To insure contact, you may send emails to both my home and office email addresses. The subject line should begin with the notation, in all capitals: “FALL PROSECUTION CLINIC.”
COURSE OBJECTIVES AND GOALS:
To familiarize students with all aspects of the art and craft of prosecution. To instill in students an understanding of the ethical requirements of prosecution. To equip students with the skills necessary for rendering satisfactory performance as entry level prosecutors.
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Page 2 of 6
CLASSROOM AND CLASS TIME
Room 355-D; 4:00pm – 5:50 PM
Pre-Semester Orientation classroom: MLAC 210
PERFORMANCE EXPECTATIONS:
CLASSROOM COMPONENT:
(1) A portion of the classroom component will consist of practical exercises, each of which will have a written component. These exercises will be critiqued by the professor, and the students will be graded upon their preparation for and performance of those exercises. These exercises will comprise 15% of the Classroom Component letter grade. (2) As a portion of the Classroom Component, students will be required to submit a Final Project consisting of a full and complete trial brief of the hypothetical case State –vs- Red Brown [On Case Problem page of the TWEN site & attached to this syllabus]. The trial brief shall include at least the following:
(a) An order of proof [Form 8-3 on the Case Preparation Worksheet page of the course TWEN site].
(b) Direct Examination Worksheets [Form 8-4] for Hugh and Daisy Glass.
(c) A complete opening statement organized in the format:
(i) Attention Step;
(ii) Fact Narration;
(iii) Exit Line.
You may build on your work from the Practical Exercises
(d) (i) A Cross-Examination Worksheet [Form 8-5] and at least four Approach Point Pages [Form 8-6] for Red Brown.
(ii) A Cross-Examination Worksheet [Form 8-5] and at least two Approach Point Pages [Form 8-6] for Cora Brown.
Your pages may be proactive or reactive. You may build on your work from the Practical Exercises.
(e) A complete final argument organized in the format:
(i) Introduction, [may be combined with the Statement of Facts]
(ii) Statement of Facts,
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Page 3 of 6
PERFORMANCE EXPECTATIONS:
(iii) Division,
(iv) Confirmation,
(v) Refutation, and
(vi) Conclusion.
You may build on your work from the Practical Exercises. CLINICAL COMPONENT: (3) Performance of not less than 25 hours per week satisfactory work as a CLI in the assigned State Attorney’s Office (SAO). While working at the assigned SAO, the CLI will
[a] Conform to all canons of ethics and disciplinary rules of the Florida Bar,
[b] Adhere to all performance requirements set by the assigned SAO,
[c] Perform to the satisfaction of the assigned SAO per evaluation of SAO supervisor.
(4) In addition to the work done in the assigned State Attorney’s Office, the students will [a] Submit periodic journals describing the student’s activities as an intern for the unreported time period prior to the journal’s due date. (See Course Materials page for example journals). Journals should be subdivided into daily entries, whose length should be no more than 250 words per day of work in the SAO. For each school day a journal or other written assignment is late, 15 points will be deducted. Up to 20 additional points may be deducted for insufficient discussion. See sample journals posted in the Course Materials section of the TWEN site. [b] Meet in conference with the professor twice during the semester, according to the schedule set forth below. These meetings will be 25 minutes in duration and will count toward the completion of classroom hours. Out-of-circuit students may fulfill this meeting requirement by teleconference. There will be a signup sheet on the TWEN site for each meeting date.
(5) The final Classroom Component grade will be an average of scores on all written assignments and practical exercises. Journals will constitute 20% of the grade. The practical exercises will constitute 20% of the grade. The class project will constitute 60% of the grade. Further information relating to grading policy can be found at http://www.registrar.ufl.edu/catalog/policies/regulationgrades.html.
CLASS ATTENDANCE POLICY:
Students may miss one two hour block of class without the necessity of making up the class. Additional missed classes which are not made up will result in a 5 point reduction of your final grade on the 100 point scale for each class missed. It is the student’s
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Page 4 of 6
CLASS ATTENDANCE POLICY:
responsibility to arrange for makeup assignments. Missed classes may be made up by attendance at designated criminal law related functions during the semester or by arrangement with the professor. No more than two absences may be made up.
PRE-SEMESTER ORIENTATION (MLAC 210)
CLASS DESCRIPTION & READING ASSIGNMENT
8/11/15 8:00-8:50 AM – Course Overview
9:00-9:50 AM – Florida Rules of Procedure – Outline of Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure on TWEN.
10:00-10:50 AM – Discovery – NDAA Stds. 4-9.1 to 4-9.6 with commentary; Fla.R.Crim.P. 3.220
11:00-11:50 AM – Motions and Objections – None.
1:00-1:50 PM – History of the Office of the Prosecutor
2:00-2:50 PM – Charging – NDAA Stds. 4-1.1 to 4.2.4 with commentary
3:00-3:50 PM – Voir Dire – None.
4:00-4:50 PM – Case Management – None.
5:00-5:50 PM – Marshalling the Evidence – None.
8/12/15 8:00-8:50 AM – The Trial Brief – None.
9:00-9:50 AM – Plea Bargaining – NDAA Stds. 5-2.1 to 5-5.2 with commentary.
10:00-10:50 AM – Opening Statement – NDAA Stds. 6-4.1 to 6-4.2, 6-8.1 to 6-8.2 with commentary.
11:00-11:50 AM – Final Argument – NDAA Stds. 6-4.1 to 6-4.2, 6-8.1 to 6-8.2 with commentary.
1:00-1:50 PM – Role of the Prosecutor – NDAA Stds. 1-1.1 to 1-1.6, 1-6.1 with commentary
2:00-2:50 PM – Role of the Defense Attorney – None.
3:00-3:50 PM – Charging – NDAA Stds. 4-1.1 to 4.2.4 with commentary
4:00-4:50 PM – Professional Courtesy – NDAA Stds. 2-7.1 to 2-8.7; Fla. RPC
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Page 5 of 6
PRACTICAL EXERCISES EXERCISE DATE DUE
CASE THEORY/OPENING STATEMENT: Devise a case theory for the Red Brown case. Reduce that theory to writing in a declarative sentence of no more than 40 words. Write an attention step consisting of no more than 150 words. Identify the attention step’s type, and describe how it advances your case theory. Be prepared to deliver this portion of the opening statement in class.
9/3/15
11:55 PM
FINAL ARGUMENT: For the Red Brown case, write the Statement of Facts and the Division of your final argument. Be prepared to deliver these portions of the final argument in class.
10/8/15
11:55 PM
CROSS-EXAMINATION: Prepare two approach point pages (Form 8-6) seeking to support a specific favorable argument on Cross-Examination of Red Brown. Do not seek to impeach Red Brown on these approach point pages. Be prepared in class to conduct the portion of the Cross-Examination of Red Brown directed at supporting those arguments.
11/5/15
11:55 PM
SCHEDULE ASSIGNMENTS DATE TIME – DESCRIPTION
9/3 11:55 PM – Case Theory/Opening Statement Exercise written component due
9/11 11:55 PM – Journal # 1 due
9/17 TBA – Conference with Instructor
10/8 11:55 PM – Final Argument Exercise written component due
10/16 11:55 PM – Journal # 2 due
10/22 TBA – Conference with Instructor
11/5 11:55 PM – Cross-Examination Exercise written component due
11/30 11:55 PM – Journal # 3 due
12/16 11:55 PM – Class Project Due
POLICY RELATED TO MAKE-UP EXAMS OR OTHER WORK:
The law school policy on delay in taking exams can be found at:
4-3.1 to 4-3.5.
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Page 6 of 6
http://www.law.ufl.edu/students/policies.shtml#12.
STATEMENT RELATED TO ACCOMMODATIONS FOR STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES:
Students requesting classroom accommodation must first register with the Office of Disability Resources. The UF Office of Disability Resources will provide documentation to the student who must then provide this documentation to the Law School Office of Student Affairs when requesting accommodation.
INFORMATION ON UF GRADING POLICIES:
The law school grading policy is available at: http://www.law.ufl.edu/students/policies.shtml#9
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
AW >JW^J[b +& ,*HH& J] ,4,*JV& = `J\ MR\YJ]LQNM ]X CX^]N +- 6Xa +-+-& 8NNY 7[NNT&
7JVMNW 7X^W]b& JWM = J[[R_NM J] ]QN [N\RMNWLN& LXW\R\]RWP XO J UXP LJKRW \N]
JYY[XaRVJ]NUb +** bJ[M\ XOO XO J MR[] [XJM& J] ,4./JV( FYXW J[[R_RWP J] ]QN \LNWN& =
VJMN LXW]JL] `R]Q 8JR\b ;UJ\\& G)9& /$,"& ++/ UK\(& 8A6 .),-),*HH'0*& `QX QJM
\L[J]LQ VJ[T\ XW QN[ ]Q[XJ] JWM J KUJLT NbN( DQN `J\ ]NWMRWP ]X QN[ +. VXW]Q XUM
P[JWMMJ^PQ]N[& D`NN]YNJ 6[X`W( 5U\X Y[N\NW] XW ]QN \LNWN `J\ <^PQ ;UJ\\& `)V&
0$."& ,12 UK\(& 8A6 /),),*HH'0,& `QX `J\ XK_RX^\Ub \^OON[RWP O[XV J QNJ_b KUX` ]X ]QN
SJ` `R]Q KUXXM XXcRWP O[XV J Q^PN K[^R\N XW ]QN \RMN XO QR\ OJLN JWM M[RYYRWP O[XV QR\
VX^]Q( ;UJ\\ JYYNJ[NM ]X QJ_N ][X^KUN LUX\RWP QR\ VX^]Q O^UUb M^N ]X ]QN RWS^[b ]X QR\
SJ`( = ^[PNM ]QN ;UJ\\N\ ]X LJUU 3++ JWM \^VVXW NVN[PNWLb VNMRLJU YN[\XWWNU& K^]
<^PQ ;UJ\\ MNLURWNM VNMRLJU J\\R\]JWLN J] ]QJ] ]RVN( ;UJ\\& `QX `J\ LXQN[NW] K^]
XK_RX^\Ub RW V^LQ YJRW& JM_R\NM J\ OXUUX`\4 <R\ `RON QJM KNNW J]]JLTNM Kb QR\ MJ^PQ]N[&
7X[J 6[X`W& JWM QN QJM KNNW J]]JLTNM Kb 7X[Jd\ Q^\KJWM& CNM 6[X`W( <N JM_R\NM
]QJ] QN QJM \QX] CNM 6[X`W& `QX [JW RW]X ]QN `XXM\& JWM ]QJ] 7X[J QJM S^VYNM RW]X QN[
LJ[ JWM M[R_NW J`Jb J] J QRPQ [J]N XO \YNNM( = YQX]XP[JYQNM ]QN RWS^[RN\ ]X ;UJ\\ JWM
QR\ `RON& JWM ]XXT ;UJ\\d\ YR\]XU RW]X L^\]XMb( EQN YR\]XU `J\ J D#G ?XMNU 00 [N_XU_N[
LXW]JRWRWP OR_N (-2%B LJURKN[ \NVR`JML^]]N[\ JWM XWN NaYNWMNM (-2%B LJURKN[ LJ[][RMPN
LJ\RWP RW ]QN LbURWMN[( = J\TNM `QN[N ]QN 6[X`W\ UR_NM JWM `J\ ]XUM ]QJ] ]QNR[ JMM[N\\
`J\ CX^]N +-& 6Xa +-+.& J \RWPUN `RMN ][JRUN[ UXLJ]NM 0* bJ[M\ MX`W ]QN [XJM O[XV ]QN
;UJ\\ QXVN( = Y[XLNNMNM ]X ]QN ][JRUN[ XW OXX] ]X J]]NVY] ]X UXLJ]N ]QN 6[X`W\( @X XWN
`J\ QXVN `QNW = OR[\] J[[R_NM& K^] = QJM KNNW \]JWMRWP J] ]QN O[XW] MXX[ XWUb J \QX[] ]RVN
`QNW = WX]RLNM JW J^]XVXKRUN JYY[XJLQRWP ]QN QX^\N( EQN J^]XVXKRUN& `QRLQ `J\ KNRWP
M[R_NW RW JW N[[J]RL VJWWN[& Y^UUNM RW]X ]QN M[R_N`Jb JWM \]XYYNM Kb [JVVRWP JWX]QN[
LJ[ YJ[TNM RW ]QN M[R_N`Jb( CNM 6[X`W PX] X^] XO ]QN LJ[ XW ]QN M[R_N[d\ \RMN JWM \JRM
eIX^ \X[[b KJ\]J[M! IX^ \QX] VN! = X^PQ] ]X TRUU bX^ `R]Q Vb KJ[N QJWM\!f <N KNPJW ]X
[^W ]X`J[M VN& JWM = \]XYYNM QRV Kb M[J`RWP Vb EJ\N[ JWM RMNW]RObRWP Vb\NUO J\ J
YXURLN XOORLN[( <N RVVNMRJ]NUb JMXY]NM J VX[N LXWLRURJ]X[b ]XWN( = MN]NL]NM ]QN XMX[ XO
JW JULXQXURL KN_N[JPN& JWM 6[X`W QJM KUXXM\QX] NbN\ JWM \U^[[NM \YNNLQ( 5U\X RW ]QN
LJ[ XW ]QN YJ\\NWPN[ \RMN `J\ 7X[J 6[X`W& G)9& /$0"& +,/ UK\(& 8A6 .).),*HH',2& `QX
PGGFOTF SFQPSU CZ PGGJDFS C. GSJFOEMZ
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
JU\X \VNUUNM XO JULXQXU JWM `J\ \^OON[RWP O[XV J \N_N[N K[^R\N ]X QN[ \RMN `QRLQ =
YQX]XP[JYQNM( = OR[\] \YXTN `R]Q \YXTN ]X CNM 6[X`W& G)?& 0$."& ,0* UK\(& 8A6
+*)+2),*HH'-/& `QX [NYX[]NM ]QJ] QN QJM \^\]JRWNM J ]Q[X^PQ JWM ]Q[X^PQ P^W\QX]
`X^WM ]X QR\ UNO] LJUO& `QRLQ = YQX]XP[JYQNM( = J\TNM 6[X`W ]X YN[OX[V J W^VKN[ XO ORNUM
\XK[RN]b NaN[LR\N\& JWM QN YN[OX[VNM YXX[Ub( 8^N ]X QR\ RWS^[NM UNP& = MRM WX] [NZ^R[N QRV
]X MX JWb NaN[LR\N\ RW_XU_RWP `JUTRWP( = MN]N[VRWNM ]QJ] = QJM Y[XKJKUN LJ^\N ]X J[[N\]
6[X`W OX[ 8F=& K^] MNLRMNM ]X `JR] ^W]RU Vb RW_N\]RPJ]RXW `J\ LXVYUN]N KNOX[N YUJLRWP
QRV ^WMN[ J[[N\]( = MNLRMNM ]X ]JTN \`X[W `[R]]NW \]J]NVNW]\ O[XV JUU YJ[]RN\ RW_XU_NM RW
]QN RWLRMNW]( 5\ J Y[NLJ^]RXW& = JM_R\NM JUU YJ[]RN\ XO ]QNR[ [RPQ]\ JWM XK]JRWNM ]QNR[
\RPWJ]^[N\ XW [RPQ]\ `JR_N[ OX[V\( 5O]N[ ]JTRWP JUU OX^[ \]J]NVNW]\& = UXLJ]NM J YRNLN XO
TRWMURWP `XXM RW ]QN ;UJ\\d\ O[XW] bJ[M( =] UXXTNM J\ ]QX^PQ R] QJM KUXXM\]JRW\ XW XWN
NWM( <^PQ ;UJ\\ JM_R\NM ]QJ] ]QN \]RLT `J\ `QJ] 6[X`W ^\NM ]X LU^K QRV( = ]XXT ]QN
\]RLT RW]X L^\]XMb( EQN [N_XU_N[ JWM ]QN \]RLT `N[N ]^[WNM X_N[ ]X ]QN DQN[ROOd\ AOORLN
N_RMNWLN L^\]XMRJW( 5O]N[ LXWLU^MRWP Vb RW_N\]RPJ]RXW = J[[N\]NM 6[X`W OX[ 5]]NVY]NM
?^[MN[ `R]Q J 8NJMUb GNJYXW JWM ][JW\YX[]NM QRV ]X ]QN 7X^W]b >JRU( ;R_NW ]QN WJ]^[N
XO ]QN ONUXWb LQJ[PN\ JPJRW\] QRV& = XY]NM WX] ]X J[[N\] 6[X`W XW ]QN LQJ[PN XO 8F=(
PGGFOTF SFQPSU CZ PGGJDFS C. GSJFOEMZ
QBHF 2
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
?b Q^\KJWM JWM = `NW] ]X ]QN VX_RN\ ]XWRPQ] JWM Vb VX]QN[ TNY] Vb MJ^PQ]N[
D`NN]YNJ( 5O]N[ ]QN VX_RN\& CNM JWM = M[XYYNM Kb ]QN GJ]N[RWP <XUN JWM QJM J ON`
KNN[\ KNOX[N `N `NW] ]X YRLT ^Y D`NN]YNJ( GQNW `N PX] ]X Vb YJ[NW]\d QX^\N& = `NW]
JWM TWXLTNM XW ]QN MXX[( ?XV LJVN ]X ]QN MXX[ L^\\RWP VN OX[ J MXYN \VXTRWP& KNN[
P^ccURWP Q^\\b& JWM \QN ]XUM VN \QN `J\ PXRWP ]X ORUN YJYN[\ ]X QJ_N D`NN]YNJ ]JTNW
J`Jb O[XV VN( = \]J[]NM ]NUURWP QN[ `QJ] = ]QX^PQ] XO QN[& JWM \QN J]]JLTNM VN( GN
`[N\]UNM J[X^WM J `QRUN& `R]Q VN QJ_RWP Vb QJWM\ XW QN[ ]Q[XJ] S^\] ][bRWP ]X TNNY QN[
XOO XO VN& JWM ]QNW `N ONUU ]X ]QN P[X^WM( = PX] XW ]XY JWM `J\ ][bRWP ]X QXUM QN[ MX`W ]X
TNNY QN[ O[XV Q^[]RWP VN& `QNW 8JM LJVN X^] XO ]QN QX^\N `J_RWP J P^W( <N `JUTNM
X_N[ ]X VN JWM TRLTNM VN QJ[M RW ]QN [RK\& JWM = ONUU XOO ?XV( EQNW `J\ `QNW CNM \JRM&
eIX^ LJWd] MX ]QJ] ]X Vb `RON&f JWM QN Y^WLQNM 8JM RW ]QN WX\N( 8JM ONUU MX`W JWM QR]
QR\ QNJM XW ]QN `XXMYRUN& JWM ]QNW QN L^\\NM JWM \QX] CNM( CNM QXUUN[NM eIX^d_N \QX]
VN& bX^ D(A(6(&f JWM 8JM \JRM& e=dUU \QXX] bX^ JPJRW& JWM ]QJ] LXTN \WX[]RWP `RON XO
bX^[\ ]XX& RO bX^ MXWd] PN] XOO Vb Y[XYN[]b(f CNM [JW RW]X ]QN `XXM\ JWM = S^VYNM RW ]QN
LJ[ JWM M[X_N J`Jb OJ\]( = YRLTNM CNM ^Y XOO ]QN \RMN XO ]QN [XJM J LX^YUN Q^WM[NM
bJ[M\ J`Jb O[XV ?XVd\ QX^\N& JWM ]QNW `N M[X_N J[X^WM ]JUTRWP JKX^] `QJ] `N \QX^UM
MX( GN MNLRMNM ]X PX QXVN JWM LJUU ]QN UJ`& JWM `QNW `N PX] QXVN ]QN[N `J\ ]QR\
XOORLN[ JU[NJMb ]QN[N( = `J\ PXRWP ]X LJUU ]QN UJ`& K^] = `JW]NM ]X ]JTN LJ[N XO CNM OR[\]( =
]QRWT =d_N PX] K[XTNW [RK\ `QN[N 8JM TRLTNM VN(
TXPSO TUBUFNFOU PG DPSB CSPXO
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
= `J\ KJKb\R]]RWP OX[ Vb MJ^PQ]N[& 7X[J 6[X`W `QRUN \QN \^YYX\NMUb `NW] ]X ]QN VX_RN\
`R]Q QN[ Q^\KJWM& CNM( EQNb MRMWd] PN] KJLT J] ]QN ]RVN `N JP[NNM XW& \X = Y^]
D`NN]YNJ ]X KNM JWM `NW] ]X KNM Vb\NUO( =dV \^[N ]QNb `NW] X^] LJ[X^\RWP JWM KXXcRWP
RW\]NJM XO PXRWP ]X ]QN VX_RN\ URTN ]QNb \JRM KNLJ^\N XO ]QN LXWMR]RXW ]QNb `N[N RW `QNW
]QNb ORWJUUb LJVN ]X PN] D`NN]YNJ( 5[X^WM ,4**JV& = QNJ[M J KJWPRWP XW ]QN MXX[ JWM R]
`J\ 7X[J( = `NW] JWM PX] D`NN]YNJ JWM LJ[[RNM QN[ ]X ]QN MXX[ ]X PR_N ]X 7X[J( GQNW =
XYNWNM ]QN MXX[& = [NJURcNM ]QJ] 7X[J `J\ M[^WT JWM XW M[^P\& JWM = ]XUM QN[ ]QJ] =
`J\Wd] PXRWP ]X PR_N D`NN]YNJ ]X QN[ `QNW \QN `J\ RW ]QJ] LXWMR]RXW( = LUX\NM ]QN MXX[
JWM Y^] D`NN]YNJ KJLT ]X KNM( 7X[J \]J[]NM KJWPRWP XW ]QN MXX[ JWM bNUURWP& JWM = `NW]
X^]\RMN ]X ][b ]X LJUV QN[ MX`W( GN O^\\NM OX[ J ON` VRW^]N\& JWM ]QNW 7X[J ]JLTUNM VN
JWM = ONUU XW Vb KJLT XW ]QN P[X^WM( 7X[J PX] XW ]XY XO VN JWM \]J[]NM LQXTRWP VN JWM
KJWPRWP Vb QNJM JPJRW\] ]QN P[X^WM( = \]J[]NM \L[NJVRWP OX[ QNUY& JWM ]QNW = YJ\\NM
X^]( = `J\ `JTNM ^Y Kb ]QN \X^WM XO J P^W\QX] JWM `QNW = UXXTNM ^Y& = \J` Vb
Q^\KJWM QXUMRWP J YR\]XU& JWM CNM `J\ [^WWRWP MX`W ]QN M[R_N`Jb RW]X ]QN `XXM\
JL[X\\ ]QN [XJM( 7X[J L^[\NM VN JWM PX] RW]X QN[ LJ[ JWM M[X_N XOO( ?b Q^\KJWM QJM JW
RWS^[b ]X QR\ SJ`& JWM = ][RNM ]X ]NWM ]X R] JO]N[ = LJUUNM ]QN DQN[ROOd\ AOORLN(
TXPSO TUBUFNFOU PG EBJTZ HMBTT
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
+%
*.*
*$
-",!."%
#-
*)
.%
,*
!.
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
?b `RON `J\ KJKb\R]]RWP X^[ P[JWMMJ^PQ]N[ ]XWRPQ] `QRUN Vb MJ^PQ]N[ JWM QN[ Q^\KJWM
`NW] ]X ]QN VX_RN\( = QJM `X[TNM QJ[M JWM `J\ ]R[NM& \X = `NW] ]X KNM NJ[Ub( = JV J
QNJ_b \UNNYN[& K^] = `J\ `JTNM ^Y Kb J LXVVX]RXW PXRWP XW X^]\RMN ]QN QX^\N J[X^WM
,4**JV( ?b `RON `J\ \L[NJVRWP OX[ QNUY JWM Vb MJ^PQ]N[ `J\ bNUURWP e=dV PXRWP ]X TRUU
bX^(f = LX^UM QNJ[ QN[ Q^\KJWM QXUUN[RWP e7QXTN QN[& LQXTN QN[& \QX` ]QJ] KR]LQ `QXd\
KX\\(f = PX] ^Y& Y^UUNM XW Vb YJW]\ [NJU Z^RLT& PX] Vb YR\]XU XOO ]QN WRPQ] \]JWM JWM `NW]
X^]\RMN( = ONU] URTN = WNNMNM ]QN YR\]XU KNLJ^\N CNM R\ J KRP& \][XWP VJW JWM RO QN S^VYNM
XW VN& = `J\ JO[JRM = LX^UMWd] QJWMUN QRV( 6NOX[N = UNO] ]QN QX^\N& = \]^LT ]QN YR\]XU RW]X
Vb `JR\]KJWM( GQNW = PX] X^]\RMN& = \J` Vb `RON XW QN[ KJLT XW ]QN P[X^WM JWM Vb
MJ^PQ]N[ XW ]XY XO QN[ LQXTRWP QN[ JWM KJWPRWP QN[ QNJM XW ]QN P[X^WM( = \J` CNM
\]JWMRWP Kb S^\] bNUURWP J] 7X[J ]X LQXTN 8JR\b( = QXUUN[NM J] CNM ]X PN] 7X[J XOO 8JR\b&
K^] QN \JRM& eIX^ PN] QN[ XOO& bX^ OJ] KJ\]J[M(f = `JUTNM X_N[ ]X 7X[J JWM Y^] Vb OXX] XW
QN[ \RMN JWM Y^\QNM QN[ XOO Vb `RON( 5KX^] ]QN ]RVN = PX] 7X[J XOO Vb `RON& CNM QJM
YRLTNM ^Y J YRNLN XO TRWMURWP `XXM O[XV ]QN `XXMYRUN JWM QN `JUTNM ^Y KN\RMN VN JWM
QR] VN ^Y \RMN XO Vb QNJM `R]Q R]( XO Vb QNJM `R]Q R]( = ONUU ]X Vb QJWM\ JWM TWNN\ JWM
UXXTNM ^Y JWM ]QJ] `J\ `QNW = \J` QN QJM ]QN \]RLT RW QR\ QN [JR\NM ]QN \]RLT ]X QR] VN
JPJRW( = Y^UUNM Vb YR\]XU JWM \QX] QRV RW ]QN UNP JWM QN [JW J`Jb( 7X[J PX] ^Y JWM
\]J[]NM L^\\RWP VN OX[ \QXX]RWP QN[ Q^\KJWM& JWM ]QNW \QN S^VYNM RW]X ]QN LJ[ JWM
M[X_N XOO( =] `J\ ]QNW ]QJ] = WX]RLNM = `J\ VR\\RWP \XVN ]NN]Q XW ]QN [RPQ] \RMN XO Vb
VX^]Q( = L[J`UNM J[X^WM XW ]QN P[X^WM JWM UXXTNM OX[ ]QNV `QRUN `N `N[N `JR]RWP XW
bX^ ]X PN] QN[N& K^] = LX^UMWd] ORWM ]QNV( = P^N\\ = V^\] QJ_N \`JUUX`NM ]QNV(
TXPSO TUBUFNFOU PG IVHI HMBTT
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
?b `RON JWM = `NW] ]X ]QN VX_RN\ ]XWRPQ] JWM Vb VX]QN['RW'UJ` TNY] Vb MJ^PQ]N[&
D`NN]YNJ( 5O]N[ ]QN VX_RN\ `N `NW] ]X ]QN 8N` 8[XY =WW JWM QJM \XVN LXOONN KNOX[N
PXRWP ]X Vb RW'UJ`\ ]X YRLT ^Y D`NN]YNJ( GQNW `N PX] ]X Vb RW'UJ`\d QX^\N& Vb
VX]QN['RW'UJ` LJVN X^] [J_RWP JKX^] QX` `N QJM \]JbNM X^] ]XX UJ]N( 7X[J ]XUM QN[ ]X
\Q^] ^Y X[ \QNdM WN_N[ \NN D`NN]YNJ JPJRW& JWM ]QNW Vb VX]QN['RW'UJ` \UJYYNM 7X[J(
7X[J \UJYYNM QN[ KJLT& JWM 8JR\b ]JLTUNM 7X[J ]X ]QN P[X^WM( EQNb `N[N [XUURWP J[X^WM
XW ]QN P[X^WM `QNW <^PQ LJVN X^] XO ]QN QX^\N `R]Q J YR\]XU RW QR\ QJWM( <N TRLTNM
7X[J XOO XO QN[ VX]QN[ JWM ]QNW QN `NW] X_N[ JWM \]J[]NM ]X \]XVY XW 7X[Jd\ QNJM(
GQNW QN `J\ XOO KJUJWLN O[XV [JR\RWP ^Y QR\ OXX] ]X \]XVY& = QR] QRV `R]Q J KXMb KUXLT
JWM TWXLTNM QRV MX`W( <N QR] QR\ QNJM JPJRW\] ]QN `XXMYRUN& JWM ]QNW QN [XUUNM X_N[
JWM L^\\NM VN JWM \]J[]NM \QXX]RWP J] VN( <N V^\] QJ_N \QX] ]QN P^W M[b& K^] QN XWUb
QR] VN XWLN RW ]QN LJUO `QRUN = `J\ [^WWRWP J`Jb( = [JW MX`W ]QN M[R_N`Jb JWM RW]X ]QN
`XXM\& JWM Vb `RON LJVN JWM YRLTNM VN ^Y JWM `N `NW] \][JRPQ] QXVN( = MXWd] TWX`
QX` bX^ PX] ]X ]QN QX^\N KNOX[N `N MRM( = TWX` bX^d_N PX] R] RW OX[ VN KNLJ^\N =d_N
MXWN ]RVN RW Y[R\XW OX[ K^[PUJ[b JWM JPP[J_J]NM KJ]]N[b& K^] =dV RWWXLNW] ]QR\ ]RVN( = PX]
WX]QRWP NU\N ]X \Jb ^W]RU = ]JUT ]X J UJ`bN[(
TXPSO TUBUFNFOU PG SFE CSPXO
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
<W ]QN 5R[L^R] 5X^[]$ XO ]QN *)\]
=^MRLRJU 5R[L^R]$ RW
JWM OX[ 5JVMNW 5X^W]b$ 8UX[RMJ
D]J]N XO 8UX[RMJ
_&
CNM 4[X`W$
6NONWMJW]&
5J\N @X& 4C%-,0%58
'/"%(#).
EQN MNONWMJW]$ C76 4CAG@$ KNRWP YN[\XWJUUb KNOX[N ]QR\ LX^[] [NY[N\NW]NM Kb B7CCI ?3DA@$ ]QN
J]]X[WNb XO [NLX[M$ JWM ]QN \]J]N [NY[N\NW]NM Kb ;3?<>EA@ 4FC97C$ JWM QJ_RWP
1 KNNW ][RNM JWM OX^WM P^RU]b Kb S^[b'Kb LX^[] XO ]QN OXUUX`RWP L[RVN"\#
NW]N[NM J YUNJ XO P^RU]b ]X ]QN OXUUX`RWP L[RVN"\#
NW]N[NM J YUNJ XO WXUX LXW]NWMN[N ]X ]QN OXUUX`RWP L[RVN"\#
5X^W] 5C<?7
AOONW\N
D]J]^]N !
6NP[NN XO
L[RVN 5J\N ! A4ED !
$ -975627< *$#"#$ &% ,5572;2843 -28847< )*'"#'( % -0!('+!./
<E <D AC67C76 E;3E
1 ]QN MNONWMJW] R\ QN[NKb 36=F6<53E76 9F<>EI XO ]QN JKX_N L[RVN"\#&
JWM QJ_RWP KNNW LXW_RL]NM X[ OX^WM P^RU]b XO$ X[ QJ_RWP NW]N[NM J YUNJ XO WXUX LXW]NWMN[N X[ P^RU]b$
[NPJ[MUN\\ XO JMS^MRLJ]RXW$ ]X J]]NVY]\ X[ XOONW\N\ [NUJ]RWP ]X \Na^JU KJ]]N[b "LQ& .0,#$ UN`M JWM
UJ\LR_RX^\ LXWM^L] "LQ& /((#$ X[ V^[MN[ "\& ./*&(,#$ JPP[J_J]NM KJ]]N[b "\& ./,&(,-#$ LJ[SJLTRWP "\&
/)*&)++#$ X[ QXVN RW_J\RXW [XKKN[b "\& /)*&)+-#$ X[ JWb X]QN[ XOONW\N \YNLRORNM RW \NL]RXW 0,+&+*-$ ]QN
MNONWMJW] \QJUU KN [NZ^R[NM ]X \^KVR] KUXXM \YNLRVNW\&
JWM PXXM LJ^\N KNRWP \QX`W2 <E <D AC67C76 E;3E 36=F6<53E<A@ A8 9F<>E 47
G<E;;7>6&
6A@7 3@6 AC67C76 RW XYNW LX^[] RW 5JVMNW 5X^W]b$ 8UX[RMJ$ XW ]QN +*WM
MJb XO AL]NVKN[$ *(((&
&!&1.1/10 $645-(*5R[L^R] =^MPN
<W ]QN 5R[L^R] 5X^[]$ XO ]QN *)\]
=^MRLRJU 5R[L^R]$ RW
JWM OX[ 5JVMNW 5X^W]b$ 8UX[RMJ
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
D]J]N XO 8UX[RMJ
_&
CNM 4[X`W$
6NONWMJW]&
5J\N @X& 4C%-,0%58
$&)%#,+,&).- *$ "#$#)"!).
C& EQ^VK C& <WMNa C& ?RMMUN C& CRWP C& >R]]UN
>& EQ^VK >& <WMNa >& ?RMMUN >& CRWP >& >R]]UN
8RWPN[Y[RW]\ ]JTNW Kb1 &!#-.*4 %*453')* "*2657 &,*3-++@JVN ER]UN
< ;7C74I 57CE<8I ]QJ] ]QN JKX_N JWM OX[NPXRWP ORWPN[Y[RW]\ XW ]QR\ S^MPVNW] J[N ]QN ORWPN[Y[RW]\ XO
]QN MNONWMJW]$ $ JWM ]QJ] ]QNb `N[N YUJLNM ]QN[NXW Kb ]QN MNONWMJW] RW Vb Y[N\NWLN RW XYNW LX^[] ]QR\ XW ]QN
+*WM
MJb XO AL]NVKN[$ *(HH%-&
5R[L^R] =^MPN
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
4EK 6H; KD9;H ?DL;IJ?=6J?ED <EH FEII?7B; ?DLEBL;C;DJ ?D 8ECC?JJ?D= J>; 8H?C; E< ,==H6L6J;9 -6JJ;HN$
-;<EH; / IF;6A JE NEK# NEK CKIJ KD9;HIJ6D9 NEKH H?=>JI$
&$ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE H;C6?D I?B;DJ$
'$ ,DNJ>?D= NEK I6N 86D 6D9 M?BB 7; KI;9 6=6?DIJ NEK ?D 6 8EKHJ E< B6M$
($ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE 6D 6JJEHD;N 6D9 JE >6L; J>6J 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ M?J> NEK 9KH?D=
GK;IJ?ED?D=$
)$ /< NEK 86DDEJ 6<<EH9 6D 6JJEHD;N# ED; M?BB 7; FHEL?9;9 <EH NEK$
*$ 3; >6L; DE M6N E< =?L?D= NEK 6 B6MN;H 6J J>?I J?C;# 7KJ ED; M?BB 7; 6FFE?DJ;9 <EH NEK# ?< NEK
M?I># ?< 6D9 M>;D NEK =E JE 8EKHJ
.E NEK KD9;HIJ6D9 J>; H?=>JI / >6L; @KIJ H;69 JE NEK+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
3?J> J>;I; H?=>JI ?D C?D9# 9E NEK M?I> JE IF;6A JE C;+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
/ >6L; H;69 EH >69 H;69 JE C; J>; <EH;=E?D= 0?H6D96 36HD?D=# 6D9 / 6C M?BB?D= JE =?L; 6D ?DJ;HL?;M DEM
M?J>EKJ 6D 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ$ / >6L; DEJ 7;;D <EH8;9# J>H;6J;D;9# EH 8E;H8;9 ?D 6DN M6N# DEH >6L; / 7;;D
FHEC?I;9 6DNJ>?D= ?D EH9;H JE E7J6?D CN IJ6J;C;DJ$ / =?L; J>?I IJ6J;C;DJ <H;;BN# LEBKDJ6H?BN# 6D9 E< CN
EMD 688EH9$
.6J;9 J>?I !"# 96N E< # '% $
2?=D;9
3?JD;II
3?JD;II
NJSBOEB XBSOJOH
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
4EK 6H; KD9;H ?DL;IJ?=6J?ED <EH FEII?7B; ?DLEBL;C;DJ ?D 8ECC?JJ?D= J>; 8H?C; E< ,==H6L6J;9 -6JJ;HN$
-;<EH; / IF;6A JE NEK# NEK CKIJ KD9;HIJ6D9 NEKH H?=>JI$
&$ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE H;C6?D I?B;DJ$
'$ ,DNJ>?D= NEK I6N 86D 6D9 M?BB 7; KI;9 6=6?DIJ NEK ?D 6 8EKHJ E< B6M$
($ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE 6D 6JJEHD;N 6D9 JE >6L; J>6J 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ M?J> NEK 9KH?D=
GK;IJ?ED?D=$
)$ /< NEK 86DDEJ 6<<EH9 6D 6JJEHD;N# ED; M?BB 7; FHEL?9;9 <EH NEK$
*$ 3; >6L; DE M6N E< =?L?D= NEK 6 B6MN;H 6J J>?I J?C;# 7KJ ED; M?BB 7; 6FFE?DJ;9 <EH NEK# ?< NEK
M?I># ?< 6D9 M>;D NEK =E JE 8EKHJ
.E NEK KD9;HIJ6D9 J>; H?=>JI / >6L; @KIJ H;69 JE NEK+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
3?J> J>;I; H?=>JI ?D C?D9# 9E NEK M?I> JE IF;6A JE C;+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
/ >6L; H;69 EH >69 H;69 JE C; J>; <EH;=E?D= 0?H6D96 36HD?D=# 6D9 / 6C M?BB?D= JE =?L; 6D ?DJ;HL?;M DEM
M?J>EKJ 6D 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ$ / >6L; DEJ 7;;D <EH8;9# J>H;6J;D;9# EH 8E;H8;9 ?D 6DN M6N# DEH >6L; / 7;;D
FHEC?I;9 6DNJ>?D= ?D EH9;H JE E7J6?D CN IJ6J;C;DJ$ / =?L; J>?I IJ6J;C;DJ <H;;BN# LEBKDJ6H?BN# 6D9 E< CN
EMD 688EH9$
.6J;9 J>?I !"# 96N E< # '% $
2?=D;9
3?JD;II
3?JD;II
NJSBOEB XBSOJOH
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
4EK 6H; KD9;H ?DL;IJ?=6J?ED <EH FEII?7B; ?DLEBL;C;DJ ?D 8ECC?JJ?D= J>; 8H?C; E< ,==H6L6J;9 -6JJ;HN$
-;<EH; / IF;6A JE NEK# NEK CKIJ KD9;HIJ6D9 NEKH H?=>JI$
&$ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE H;C6?D I?B;DJ$
'$ ,DNJ>?D= NEK I6N 86D 6D9 M?BB 7; KI;9 6=6?DIJ NEK ?D 6 8EKHJ E< B6M$
($ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE 6D 6JJEHD;N 6D9 JE >6L; J>6J 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ M?J> NEK 9KH?D=
GK;IJ?ED?D=$
)$ /< NEK 86DDEJ 6<<EH9 6D 6JJEHD;N# ED; M?BB 7; FHEL?9;9 <EH NEK$
*$ 3; >6L; DE M6N E< =?L?D= NEK 6 B6MN;H 6J J>?I J?C;# 7KJ ED; M?BB 7; 6FFE?DJ;9 <EH NEK# ?< NEK
M?I># ?< 6D9 M>;D NEK =E JE 8EKHJ
.E NEK KD9;HIJ6D9 J>; H?=>JI / >6L; @KIJ H;69 JE NEK+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
3?J> J>;I; H?=>JI ?D C?D9# 9E NEK M?I> JE IF;6A JE C;+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
/ >6L; H;69 EH >69 H;69 JE C; J>; <EH;=E?D= 0?H6D96 36HD?D=# 6D9 / 6C M?BB?D= JE =?L; 6D ?DJ;HL?;M DEM
M?J>EKJ 6D 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ$ / >6L; DEJ 7;;D <EH8;9# J>H;6J;D;9# EH 8E;H8;9 ?D 6DN M6N# DEH >6L; / 7;;D
FHEC?I;9 6DNJ>?D= ?D EH9;H JE E7J6?D CN IJ6J;C;DJ$ / =?L; J>?I IJ6J;C;DJ <H;;BN# LEBKDJ6H?BN# 6D9 E< CN
EMD 688EH9$
.6J;9 J>?I !"# 96N E< # '% $
2?=D;9
3?JD;II
3?JD;II
NJSBOEB XBSOJOH
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
4EK 6H; KD9;H ?DL;IJ?=6J?ED <EH FEII?7B; ?DLEBL;C;DJ ?D 8ECC?JJ?D= J>; 8H?C; E< ,==H6L6J;9 -6JJ;HN$
-;<EH; / IF;6A JE NEK# NEK CKIJ KD9;HIJ6D9 NEKH H?=>JI$
&$ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE H;C6?D I?B;DJ$
'$ ,DNJ>?D= NEK I6N 86D 6D9 M?BB 7; KI;9 6=6?DIJ NEK ?D 6 8EKHJ E< B6M$
($ 4EK >6L; J>; H?=>J JE 6D 6JJEHD;N 6D9 JE >6L; J>6J 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ M?J> NEK 9KH?D=
GK;IJ?ED?D=$
)$ /< NEK 86DDEJ 6<<EH9 6D 6JJEHD;N# ED; M?BB 7; FHEL?9;9 <EH NEK$
*$ 3; >6L; DE M6N E< =?L?D= NEK 6 B6MN;H 6J J>?I J?C;# 7KJ ED; M?BB 7; 6FFE?DJ;9 <EH NEK# ?< NEK
M?I># ?< 6D9 M>;D NEK =E JE 8EKHJ
.E NEK KD9;HIJ6D9 J>; H?=>JI / >6L; @KIJ H;69 JE NEK+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
3?J> J>;I; H?=>JI ?D C?D9# 9E NEK M?I> JE IF;6A JE C;+ !/D?J?6B ED; H;IFEDI;"
4;I
1E 55555
/ >6L; H;69 EH >69 H;69 JE C; J>; <EH;=E?D= 0?H6D96 36HD?D=# 6D9 / 6C M?BB?D= JE =?L; 6D ?DJ;HL?;M DEM
M?J>EKJ 6D 6JJEHD;N FH;I;DJ$ / >6L; DEJ 7;;D <EH8;9# J>H;6J;D;9# EH 8E;H8;9 ?D 6DN M6N# DEH >6L; / 7;;D
FHEC?I;9 6DNJ>?D= ?D EH9;H JE E7J6?D CN IJ6J;C;DJ$ / =?L; J>?I IJ6J;C;DJ <H;;BN# LEBKDJ6H?BN# 6D9 E< CN
EMD 688EH9$
.6J;9 J>?I !"# 96N E< # '% $
2?=D;9
3?JD;II
3?JD;II
NJSBOEB XBSOJOH
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle
Adv Criminal Prosection Clinic Fall 2015
Dekle