1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
-
Upload
saif-quader -
Category
Documents
-
view
216 -
download
0
Transcript of 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
1/36
IFRSs and NL GAAPHighlighting the key differences
October 2012
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
2/362
Contacts
IFRS Centre o Excellence, Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Ralph ter Hoeven
Deloittes www.iasplus.com website provides, without charge, comprehensive
inormation about international nancial reporting in general and IASB activities in
particular. Unique eatures include:
daily news about nancial reporting globally;
summaries o all Standards, Interpretations and proposals;
many IFRS-related publications available or download;
model IFRS nancial statements and disclosure checklists;
an electronic library o several hundred IFRS resources;
all Deloitte comment letters to the IASB;
links to nearly 200 IFRS-related websites;
e-learning modules or each IAS and IFRS;
a complete history o adoption o IFRSs around the world;
updates on developments in national accounting standards; and
comparisons between IFRSs and local GAAPs.
For IFRS and NL GAAP videocasts please visit:
www.deloitte.nl/IFRS-NLGAAP
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
3/363IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
Foreword
Welcome to the th edition o IFRSs and NL GAAP, A
pocket comparison. The objective o this publication
is to provide a summary o key dierences between
the requirements o IFRSs compared to NL GAAP. This
publication does not attempt to capture all o the
dierences between IFRSs and NL GAAP that may
exist or that may be material to a particular companys
nancial report.
Our analysis shows that there are many dierences
between IFRSs and NL GAAP. We expect that the
number o dierences will increase in the uture.
The IASB is still working on many dierent projects
which will lead to major changes to current IFRSs.
However, NL GAAP has evolved into a more stable
platorm. Beore 2005 the DASB had a strategy to
implement changes to IFRSs into its own standards.
But the strategy o the DASB was changed as a
consequence o the adoption o IFRSs by the European
Union. The current strategy o the DASB is to ocus onnancial reporting standards or non-listed entities. As a
consequence, we expect that many current dierences
between IFRSs and NL GAAP will remain and that many
orthcoming changes to IFRSs will not be implemented
in DASs. This will lead to an increase o the number
o dierences.
The goal o this publication is to provide you with a clear
and practical oversight o the key dierences between
IFRSs and NL GAAP and the developments herein.
Thereore, we publish this comparison on a yearly basis.
I want to express my gratitude to Dingeman Manschot
or his eorts in editing this comparison.
We trust that you will nd this publication a useul
tool to keep you inormed about the main dierences
between IFRSs and NL GAAP.
Ralph ter Hoeven
Leader IFRS Centre o Excellence, Rotterdam,The Netherlands
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
4/364
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
5/365IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
Comparison of IFRSsand NL GAAP
The table on the ollowing pages sets out some o the
key dierences between IFRSs and NL GAAP or annual
periods beginning on or ater 1 January 2012. The table
also includes new and revised IASB Standards issued
beore 31 July 2012 that have not yet become eective
or annual periods beginning on or ater 1 January
2012. We reer to the end notes or the date on which
new and revised Standards must be applied.
The summary does not attempt to capture all o the
dierences that exist or that may be material to a
particular entitys nancial statements. Our ocus is on
dierences that are commonly ound in practice.
The signicance o these dierences and others not
included in this list will vary with respect to individual
entities, depending on such actors as the nature o the
entitys operations, the industry in which it operates, and
the accounting policy choices it has made. Reerence to
the underlying accounting standards and any relevant
national regulations is essential in understanding the
specic dierences.
The rate o progress being achieved by the IASB to
improve accounting standards means that a comparison
between standards can only refect the position at a
particular point in time. You can keep up to date on
later developments through our IAS Plus website, which
sets out the IASB agendas and timetables, as well as
project summaries and updates.
Abbreviations used in this publication are as ollows:
DAS(s) Dutch Accounting Standard(s)
DASB Dutch Accounting Standards Board
IASB International Accounting Standards Board
IAS
International nancial reporting standard created by the
predecessor body o the IASB and adopted by the IASB
when it took over in 2001
IFRICInterpretation developed by the IFRS Interpretations
Committee
IFRS(s) International Financial Reporting Standard(s)
NL GAAP
Generally Accepted Accounting Standards in the
Netherlands, comprising the Netherlands Civil Code and
the Dutch Accounting Standards published by the DASB
SICInterpretation developed by the IASB's predecessor body
and its interpretative committee
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
6/366
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
General approach Less principles-based standards with
more application guidance.
More principles-based standards
with more options and less application
guidance.
IFRS 1 First-time
adoption
General principle is ull retrospective
application o IFRSs in orce at
the time o adoption, unless theexemptions in IFRS 1 permit or require
otherwise.
No specic standard. Practice is
generally ull retrospective application
unless the transitional provisions in aspecic standard require otherwise.
IFRS 2 Equity-settled
share-based
payments
For equity-settled share-based
payment transactions the goods or
services received are measured at air
value, unless that air value cannot be
estimated reliably.
DASs contain an alternative treatment
allowing to measure equity-settled
share-based payments with employees
at their intrinsic value, initially at the
grant date and subsequently at the
end o each reporting period and at
the date o nal settlement, with any
change in intrinsic value recognised in
prot or loss.
IFRS 2 Share-basedpayments among
group entities
An entity that receives goods orservices in a share-based payment
arrangement must account or
those goods or services no matter
which entity in the group settles the
transaction, and no matter whether
the transaction is settled in shares or
cash.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRS 3 Accounting
method
All business combinations shall be
accounted or using the purchase
method. The pooling o interests
method is prohibited.
The purchase method is required or
combinations classied as acquisitions
and the pooling o interests method is
required or combinations classied as
uniting o interests.
IFRS 3 Recognising
a liability or
a planned
post-acquisition
restructuring
The cost o restructuring the acquiree
is recognised as a liability as part o
the acquisition accounting only i
it is a liability o the acquiree at the
acquisition date.
An acquirer is required to recognise as
part o the acquisition accounting a
provision or terminating or reducing
the activities o the acquiree that was
not a liability o the acquiree at the
acquisition date, provided the acquirer
satises specied criteria.
IFRS 3 Recognising
contingent
liabilities o
acquiree
An acquirer shall recognise separately
the acquirees contingent liabilities (as
dened in IAS 37) at the acquisition
date as part o allocating the cost o a
business combination, provided their
air values can be measured reliably.
An acquirer shall not recognise
separately the acquirees contingent
liabilities. Such contingent liabilities
are subsumed within the amount
recognised as goodwill or negative
goodwill.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
7/367IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRS 3 Intangibles Must always be recognised and
measured. There is no reliable
measurement exception.
An intangible asset is recognised
separately rom goodwill when it
meets the denition o an intangible
asset, its air value can be measured
reliably and it is probable that any
associated uture economic benetswill fow to the acquirer.
IFRS 3 Deerred tax
assets and
liabilities
In determining its air value, acquired
tax assets and liabilities shall be
measured against nominal value. That
means discounting is not allowed.
As an alternative, DASs allow
acquired tax assets and liabilities to be
discounted.
IFRS 3 Goodwill Goodwill shall be capitalised, but
shall subsequently not be amortised.
Instead, it shall be tested or
impairment annually.
The benchmark treatment is that
goodwill shall be capitalised and
subsequently systematically amortised
over its useul lie. There is a
rebuttable presumption that the useul
lie o goodwill will not exceed twenty
years rom initial recognition.
An entity shall, at least at each
nancial-year end, estimate the
recoverable amount o goodwill that
is amortised over a period exceeding
twenty years rom initial recognition,
even i no indication exists that it is
impaired.
Based on Dutch law, DASs also permit
the method by which goodwill is
deducted immediately rom equity or
accounted or as expense in prot or
loss.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
8/368
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRS 3 Excess o air
value o net assets
acquired over
the acquisition
cost (negative
goodwill)
Recognise immediately as a gain. To the extent that negative goodwill
relates to expectations o uture losses
and expenses that are identied in the
acquirers plan or the acquisition and
can be measured reliably, but which
do not represent identiable liabilitiesat the date o acquisition, that
portion o negative goodwill shall be
recognised as income in prot or loss
when the uture losses and expenses
are recognised.
To the extent that negative goodwill
does not relate to identiable
expected uture losses and expenses
that can be measured reliably at the
date o acquisition, negative goodwill
shall be recognised as income in prot
or loss as ollows:
the amount o negative goodwill
not exceeding the air values o
acquired identiable non-monetary
assets shall be recognised as
income on a systematic basis over
the remaining weighted average
useul lie o the identiable,
acquired, depreciable/amortisable
assets; and
the amount o negative
goodwill in excess o the air
values o acquired, identiablenon-monetary assets shall be
recognised as income immediately.
IFRS 3 Acquisition costs Recognise immediately as an expense. Recognise as part o the cost o
acquisition.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
9/369IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRS 3 Contingent
consideration
Contingent consideration must
be measured at air value at the
acquisition date as part o the
consideration transerred. Subsequent
changes in the air value o contingent
consideration that result ormadditional inormation about acts
and circumstances that existed at
the acquisition date that the acquirer
obtains during the measurement
period are measurement period
adjustments. These adjustments
aect the cost o the acquisition (and
thereore goodwill).
The measurement period cannot
be longer than one year rom the
acquisition date.
Contingent consideration must be
recognised as part o the cost o
the acquisition i the contingent
consideration is probable and can be
measured reliably. I the amount o
contingent consideration changes asa result o a post-acquisition event,
the cost o the acquisition (and
thereore goodwill) shall be adjusted
accordingly.
DASs contain no maximum period
or these contingent consideration
adjustments.
IFRS 3 Goodwill and
non-controlling
interests
An entity is permitted to measure
non-controlling interests in the
acquiree at either:
air value; or
its proportionate share in the
recognised net asset value o the
acquiree.
The air value alternative is known
as the ull goodwill method. An
alternative may be elected or each
business combination separately.
The ull goodwill method is not
permitted.
IFRS 3 Step acquisition A previously held equity interest in the
acquiree shall be remeasured at its
acquisition-date air value. A resulting
gain or loss shall be recognised in
prot or loss.
The unit o account or the
remeasurement at air value is the
equity interest itsel.
The recognised assets and liabilities
corresponding with the previous
held equity interest in the acquiree
might (not shall) be remeasured. Any
resulting remeasurement to previously
recognised assets and liabilities shall
be credited directly to equity (as a
revaluation reserve).
The unit o account or the
remeasurement at air value are the
recognised assets and liabilities.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
10/3610
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRS 3 Pre-existing
relationships and
reacquired rights
I an acquirer and an acquiree were
parties to a pre-existing relationship,
this must be accounted or separately
rom the business combination.
In most cases, this will lead to the
recognition o a gain or loss orthe amount o the consideration
transerred to the vendor, which
eectively represents a settlement o
the pre-existing relationship.
However, where the transaction
eectively represents a reacquired
right, an intangible asset is recognised
and measured on the basis o the
remaining contractual term o the
related contract excluding any
renewals. The asset is subsequently
amortised over this remaining
contractual term.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRS 4 Rights and
obligations
under insurance
contracts
IFRS 4 only briefy addresses
recognition and measurement. It is an
interim standard, pending completion
o a comprehensive project.
DASB has published an accounting
standard or insurance companies.
Many dierences exist between this
accounting standard and IFRS 4.
IFRS 5 Non-current
assets (or disposal
groups)held or
sale
Specic requirements to account or
non-current assets (or disposal groups)
held or sale.
No requirements or non-current
assets (or disposal groups) held or
sale.
IFRS 6 Exploration or
and evaluation o
mineral resources
Specic extractive industry guidance
or the recognition, measurement and
disclosure o expenditure incurred on
the exploration or and evaluation o
mineral resources.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRS 7 Disclosures
relating to
nancial
instruments
Qualitative and quantitative
inormation required about exposure
to risks arising rom nancial
instruments, including specied
minimum disclosures about credit risk,
liquidity risk and market risk.
Disclosure requirements are similar to
the previous requirements in IAS 32
(2004).
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
11/3611IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRS 8 Segment reporting Disclosure o segment inormation
is required by those entities whose
equity or debt instruments are traded
in a public market.
Netherlands Civil Code requires that
large legal entities disclose inormation
on net turnover by industry and/or by
geographical area.
I an entity chooses to discloseadditional segment inormation,
the entity is recommended to apply
the guidance o DAS 350 regarding
segment inormation.
IFRS 91 Measurement o
debt instruments
A debt instrument that (1) is held
within a business model whose
objective is to collect the contractual
cash fows and (2) has contractual
cash fows that are solely payments
o principal and interest on the
principal amount outstanding must be
measured at amortised cost unless it is
designated at air value through prot
or loss (see below).
All other debt instruments must be
measured at air value through prot
or loss (FVTPL).
A air value option is also available
as an alternative to amortised
cost measurement (provided that
certain conditions are met) or debt
instruments allowing such instruments
to be designated as nancial assets at
FVTPL.
Debt instruments that classiy as
part o the trading portolio shall be
measured at air value with changes
through prot or loss.
Purchased loans and bonds held until
the end o the term are measured at
amortised cost.
Other purchased loans and bonds
are measured at amortised cost or at
air value. For nancial instruments
measured at air value an entity can
opt to recognise changes in air
value directly in prot or loss or,
to the extent the aggregate o the
revaluation is positive, to recognise it
in the shareholders equity until it is
realised.
Loans granted and other receivables
are measured at amortised cost.
IFRS 9 Measurement o
equity instruments
All equity instruments (e.g. shares) are
to be measured at air value with the
deault recognition o gains and losses
in prot or loss. Only i the equity
instrument is not held or trading an
irrevocable election can be made at
initial recognition to measure it at air
value through other comprehensive
income with only dividend income
recognised in prot or loss.
Investments in listed equity
instruments are measured at air value
with changes through prot or loss.
Investments in non-listed equity
instruments are measured at cost or
at air value. For nancial instruments
measured at air value an entity can
opt to recognise changes in air
value directly in prot or loss or,
to the extent the aggregate o therevaluation is positive, to recognise it
in the shareholders equity until it is
realised.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
12/3612
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRS 9 Measurement o
derivatives
All derivatives within the scope o IFRS
9 are required to be measured at air
value through prot or loss.
Listed derivatives or derivatives with
a listed underlying value shall be
measured at air value through prot
or loss.
Derivatives with a non-listedunderlying value are measured at
cost or air value. Upon measurement
at air value changes in value are
recognised in prot or loss. I
derivatives are measured at cost an
impairment loss shall be recognised
when the air value is lower than
the cost unless cost price hedge
accounting is applied (see section IAS
39; types o hedge accounting).
IFRS 9 Measurement o
nancial liabilities
For a nancial liability designated as at
air value through prot or loss using
the air value option, the change in
the liabilitys air value attributable
to changes in the liabilitys credit
risk is recognised directly in other
comprehensive income, unless it
creates or increases an accounting
mismatch. The amount that is
recognised in other comprehensive
income is not recycled when the
liability is settled or extinguished.
A nancial liability cannot be
designated as at air value through
prot or loss.
IFRS 102 Consolidated
nancial
statements
A parent shall consolidate investees
over which it has control. The
denition o control includes three
elements: power over an investee,
exposure or rights to variable returns
o the investee and the ability to use
power over the investee to aect the
investors returns.
Consolidated nancial statements
shall include the nancial data o the
parent itsel, subsidiaries in the group,
other group companies and other
legal entities over which it can exert
control or over which it has central
management.
IFRS 10 Potential voting
rights
Potential voting rights are considered
when they are substantive and can,
alone or in combination with other
rights, give the current ability to direct
the relevant activities.
The existence and eect o potential
voting rights are considered when
assessing control, i these rights are
currently exercisable.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
13/3613IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRS 113 Joint
arrangements
Joint arrangements are classied as
either joint operations (combining
the NL GAAP concepts o jointly
controlled assets and jointly controlled
operations) or joint ventures
(equivalent to the NL GAAP concept oa jointly controlled entity).
Joint arrangements are classied
as jointly controlled assets, jointly
controlled operations or jointly
controlled entities.
IFRS 11 Joint ventures Investments in joint ventures are
accounted or by using the equity
method.
Investments in jointly controlled
entities are measured at net asset
value or accounted or using the
proportionate consolidation method.
IFRS 11 Loss o joint
control
I an investment in a joint venture
becomes an investment in an
associate, the entity continues to
apply the equity method and does not
remeasure the retained interest.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRS 124 Disclosure o
interests in otherentities
Requires disclosures about interest
in subsidiaries, joint arrangements,associates and structured entities.
The disclosure requirements under NL
GAAP are less comprehensive.
IFRS 135 Fair value
measurement
Denes air value and requires
disclosures about air value
measurements.
Denition o air value is based on
guidance within IFRSs beore the
introduction o IFRS 13. The disclosure
requirements about air value
measurements under NL GAAP are
less comprehensive.
IAS 1 Financial
statements
presentation
Specic line items required. Prescriptive ormats o the balance
sheet and prot or loss statement are
applicable.
IAS 1 Other
comprehensiveincome
Requirement to present other
comprehensive income as part ototal comprehensive income. Other
comprehensive income comprises
items o income and expense
(including reclassication adjustments)
that are not recognised in prot or loss
as required or permitted by IFRSs.
DASs do not require the presentation
o other comprehensive income aspart o total comprehensive income.
Changes in revaluation surplus relating
to property, plant and equipment,
gains and losses arising rom
translating the nancial statements
o a oreign operation and other
items recognised directly into equity
are presented as part o the equity
movement disclosure.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
14/3614
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 1 Third statement
in statement o
nancial position
A third statement at the beginning
o the earliest comparative period6 is
required when an entity applies an
accounting policy retrospectively or
makes a retrospective restatement
o items in its nancial statements orwhen it reclassies items in its nancial
statements.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IAS 1 Departure rom
a standard when
compliance would
be misleading
Permitted in extremely rare
circumstances to achieve a air
presentation. Specic disclosures are
required.
Departure rom Netherlands Civil Code
is required to the extent necessary
to provide a true and air view.
The reasons or departure shall be
disclosed.
Departure rom DASs may only
occur with good reasons. There is no
requirement to disclose a departure
rom DASs.
IAS 1 Classication
o liabilities on
renancing
Current i renancing is not completed
on or beore the balance sheet date.
Allowed to present as non-current
i renancing is completed beore
the date o issuance o the nancial
statements.
IAS 1 Classication o
liabilities due on
demand due to
violation o debt
covenant
Current i the lender has not granted
a 12-month waiver on or beore the
balance sheet date.
Allowed to present as non-current
i the lender has granted a waiver
or a period greater than one year
beore the issuance o the nancial
statements or when the violation is
corrected beore the issuance o the
nancial statements.
IAS 2 Measurement o
inventory
Inventories shall be measured at the
lower o cost and net realisable value.
Inventories shall be measured at
the lower o cost and net realisable
value or at current cost (replacement
value).
IAS 2 Method or
determining cost
LIFO is prohibited. LIFO is permitted, but not
recommended.
IAS 7 Statement o cash
fows
All entities are required to present a
statement o cash fows.
Only large and medium-sized legal
entities are required to present a
statement o cash fows.
IAS 7 Classication o
expenditures on
unrecognised
assets
Only expenditures that result in a
recognised asset in the statement o
nancial position can be classied as
investing activities.
DASs contain no specic requirement.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
15/3615IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 8 Correcting errors Material prior period errors shall be
recognised retrospectively in the rst
set o nancial statements authorised
or issue ater their discovery.
Distinction between undamental and
other material errors. Fundamental
errors shall be recognised
retrospectively in the rst set o
nancial statements authorised or
issue ater their discovery. Othermaterial errors are recognised in prot
or loss.
IAS 10 Declared
dividends ater the
balance sheet date
Declared dividends through holders o
equity instruments ater the balance
sheet date shall not be recognised as a
liability at the balance sheet date.
The balance sheet shall be drawn
up beore or ater the appropriation
o prot. I the latter option is used,
a dierence with IFRSs could arise,
because an entity is allowed to present
the proposed dividend as a liability at
the balance sheet date.
IAS 11 Denition o a
construction
contract
A contract that must be specically
negotiated or the construction o an
asset.
A construction contract is dened
in a more broad sense which might
lead to a broader application o thepercentage o completion method.
IAS 11 Presentation o
construction
contracts
An entity shall present:
the gross amount due rom
customers or contract work as an
asset; and
the gross amount due to customers
or contract work as a liability.
DASs contain an alternative
treatment allowing the balance o all
construction contracts to be shown
as one amount. I this balance is a
credit balance it shall be presented as
a liability. However, i the alternative
treatment is applied an entity shall
disclose the gross amount due to
customers and the gross amount due
rom customers.
IAS 12 Revaluation o
property, plant
and equipment
Items o property, plant and
equipment can be revalued. The
dierence between the carrying
amount o a revalued asset and its tax
base is a temporary di erence and
gives rise to a deerred tax liability.
The recognition o a deerred
tax liability is not required but
recommended. However, i no
deerred tax liability is recognised,
this shall be disclosed including the
quantitative eects.
IAS 12 Recognition o
deerred tax assets
Recognition o a deerred tax asset i
it is probable that taxable prot will be
available against which the deductible
temporary dierence can be utilised.
A deerred tax asset is also recognised
i the probability o realisation is
only connected to the existence o
a deerred tax liability relating to
revalued assets.
A deerred tax asset is not recognised
i the probability o realisation is
only connected to the existence o
a deerred tax liability relating to
revalued assets.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
16/3616
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 12 Measurement o
deerred tax assets
and liabilities
Not to be discounted. Measured at nominal value
(undiscounted) or at present value
(discounted).
IAS 12 Deerred tax:
recovery o
underlying assets
For the purposes o measuring
deerred tax, a rebuttable presumption
exists that the carrying amount o aninvestment property measured using
the air value model in IAS 40 will be
recovered entirely through sale.
DASs contain no rebuttable
presumption.
IAS 16 Costs o
decommissioning,
restoration and
similar liabilities
caused by
construction
o the item o
property, plant
and equipment
The initial estimate o the costs are
included in the initial measurement
o the item o property, plant and
equipment.
Allowed to recognise a provision or
costs o decommissioning, restoration
and similar liabilities over the useul
lie o an item o property, plant
and equipment. The increase o
the provision shall be recognised
systematically in prot or loss. The
increase o the provision shall refect
the pattern in which the related assetsuture economic benets are expected
to be consumed by the entity.
IAS 16 Major inspection
and maintenance
Generally accounted or as part o the
cost o an asset.
Allowed to recognise a provision
or costs o major inspection and
maintenance.
IAS 16 Selling o Items
held or rental
Entities that routinely sell items o
PP&E that they have previously held
or rental to others shall transer such
assets to inventories at their carrying
amount when they cease to be rented.
The proceeds rom the sale o such
assets shall be recognised as revenue
in accordance with IAS 18.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IAS 17 Initial direct
costs o lessors
(other than
those involving
manuacturer or
dealer leases)
Included in the initial measurement o
the nance lease receivable.
Not required, but allowed. An entity
has an alternative to recognise initial
direct costs directly in prot or loss.
IAS 18 Determining
whether an entity
is acting as a
principal or as an
agent
Non-mandatory guidance is included
to determine whether an entity is
acting as a principal or as an agent.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
17/3617IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 19 Post-employment
benet plans
Post-employment benet plans
are classied as either dened
contribution plans or dened benet
plans.
For dened contribution plans, thecost to be recognised in the period is
the contribution payable in exchange
or service rendered by employees
during the period.
For dened benet plans, the amount
recognised in the balance sheet shall
be based on the present value o
the dened benet obligation (in
accordance with the projected unit
credit method) minus the air value o
plan assets at the balance sheet date.
DASs make a distinction between
Dutch (equivalent) post-employment
plans and oreign post-employment
plans.
Dutch plans The entity recognises the
contribution to be paid to the
pension provider (an independent
body in the Netherlands) as an
expense.
The entity must assess on the
basis o the administration
agreement whether and, i so,
which liabilities exist at the balance
sheet date in addition to the
annual contributions payable to the
pension provider.
In addition to the liabilities owed
to the pension provider, there may
also be liabilities that are owed
to employees. These latter may
arise, among other things, rom
ully or partially ununded pension
commitments
Foreign (non-Dutch equivalent) plans
DASs require a best estimate or
the benet obligations o these
plans according to a generally
accepted actuarial method. Theliability is considered to be owed
to the employee which approach
is similar to IAS 19. However, DASs
contain no specic measurement
guidance.
IAS 19 Pension
accounting:
partial adoption o
IFRS or U.S. GAAP
Not allowed to use other standards
than those included in IFRSs.
Entities are allowed to apply
U.S. GAAP or IFRS standards relating
to pensions and other post retirement
benets in their nancial statements,
subject to the condition that these
specic standards are applied
integrally.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
18/3618
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 19
(Revised)7Presentation o
dened benet
cost
The dened benet cost comprises:
service cost recognised in prot
or loss;
net interest on the net dened
benet liability (asset) recognised in
prot or loss; and remeasurements recognised in OCI.
DASs prescribe that pension expense
shall be part o the operational result
within prot or loss.
IAS 19
(Revised)
Other long term
employee benets
Shall be measured and presented
according to dened benet plans.
Measurement shall be based on a best
estimate approach. DASs contain no
presentation descriptions.
IAS 20 Non-monetary
government
grants
Recognised at air value or at a
nominal amount.
DASs contain no specic
requirements. On the basis o general
DASs requirements, measurement at
air value better refects economic
reality.
IAS 21 Goodwill arising
as a result o the
acquisition o aoreign entity
and any air value
adjustments to the
carrying amounts
o assets and
liabilities arising
as a result o the
acquisition
Shall be treated as assets and liabilities
o the oreign operation. Hence, they
shall be expressed in the unctionalcurrency o the oreign operation and
shall be translated to the presentation
currency at the closing rate.
Any goodwill arising as a result o the
acquisition o a oreign entity and any
air value adjustments to the carryingamounts o assets and liabilities arising
as a result o the acquisition shall be
treated as either:
assets and liabilities o the oreign
operation (like IFRS); or
assets and liabilities o the acquirer.
IAS 21 Cumulative
amount o
the exchange
dierences
deerred in
a separate
component o
equity relating to
a disposed oreign
operation
Shall be recognised in prot or loss
when the gain or loss on disposal is
recognised.
Recognition in prot or loss is only
recommended. Under the alternative
allowed it may be transerred directly
to other reserves.
IAS 23 Borrowing costs
that relate to
assets that take a
substantial period
o time to get
ready or use or
sale
Capitalisation is mandatory. Capitalisation is an available
accounting policy choice. It is also
allowed to expense borrowing costs in
prot or loss.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
19/3619IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 24 Related party
disclosures
Disclosure o transactions with related
parties is required.
Signicant transactions that have been
entered into by the entity with related
parties under irregular market (not
at arms length) conditions must be
disclosed. This disclosure requirement
does not apply to medium-sized legalentities (unless the entity is a public
limited company) and small-sized legal
entities.
IAS 24 Government-
related entities
Simplied disclosure requirements or
transactions with government-related
entities.
DASs contain no specic disclosure
requirements or transactions with
government-related entities.
IAS 26 Reporting by
retirement benet
plans
Specic guidance or the accounting
and reporting by retirement benet
plans.
In general, the guidance in
DAS 610 regarding pension unds is
comparable.
IAS 27 Subsidiary
acquired with
the intention todispose o in the
near uture
Consolidation is required. I on
acquisition the subsidiary meets the
criteria o IFRS 5, it shall be accountedor in accordance with that standard.
Consolidation is not required.
IAS 27 Consolidation
exemption or
small-sized groups
No exemption. Consolidation is not required or small-
sized groups.
IAS 27 Consolidation
exemption or
intermediate
holdings
Intermediate holdings need not
present consolidated nancial
statements i, among other
requirements, the ultimate or
any intermediate parent o the
intermediate holding produces
consolidated nancial statements orpublic use that comply with IFRSs.
Intermediate holdings need not
present consolidated nancial
statements i, among other
requirements, the nancial inormation
which the intermediate holding shall
consolidate has been included in the
consolidated nancial statementso the ultimate or any intermediate
parent and these consolidated
nancial statements have been
prepared or public use in accordance
with the provisions o the Seventh
Directive o the EU on Company Law
or in an equivalent manner (IFRSs and
other high quality GAAPs included).
IAS 27 Investment
companies
Investment companies do have to
consolidate subsidiaries.
Investment companies do not have
to consolidate subsidiaries i or these
subsidiaries a concrete exit strategy
is ormulated ever since the date o
acquisition.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
20/3620
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 27 Separate nancial
statements
In the parents separate nancial
statements investments in subsidiaries,
associates and joint ventures (other
than those that are classied as held
or sale under IFRS 5) are accounted
or either at cost or in accordance withIAS 39.
In the parents company-only nancial
statements investments in subsidiaries,
associates and joint ventures are
accounted or at the net asset value
(goodwill is presented separately).
IAS 27 Partial disposal o
an investment in
a subsidiary that
results in loss o
control
The investment retained shall be
measured at air value at the date
when control is lost.
Any dierence between air value
and carrying amount is part o the
gain or loss on the loss o control
transaction.
Although not treated specically a
gain or loss is only allowed or the part
o the investment that is sold.
IAS 27 Partial disposal o
an investment in
a subsidiary whilecontrol is retained
This is accounted or as an equity
transaction with owners (a transaction
between the shareholders o theparent entity and the shareholders o
the non-controlling interests). Hence,
no gain or loss is recognised.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IAS 27 Acquiring
additional shares
in the subsidiary
ater control was
obtained
This is accounted or as an equity
transaction with owners Hence,
acquisition accounting is not allowed
or these acquisitions.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IAS 28 Denition o
associate
An entity in which the investor has
signicant infuence and which
is neither a subsidiary nor a joint
venture.
An entity holds an associate i the
entity, or one o its subsidiaries, has
provided capital or its own account
or urthering its own business
activities by establishing a long-term
relationship.
A distinction is made between
associates (deelnemingen) in which
signicant infuence is exercised and
other associates. This distinction is
made or measurement purposes.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
21/3621IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 28 Measurement o
associates
Associates shall be accounted or
by using the equity method in
consolidated nancial statements
and individual nancial statements.
However, the investor does not apply
the equity method when presentingseparate nancial statements
prepared in accordance with IAS 27.
In the separate nancial statements
investments in associates, joint
ventures and subsidiaries that are not
classied as held or sale in accordance
with IFRS 5 shall be accounted or
either at cost or in accordance with
IAS 39.
An associate in which signicant
infuence is exercised shall be
measured at the net asset value
(goodwill is presented separately) in
consolidated nancial statements and
company-only nancial statements.
In the company-only nancial
statements investments in subsidiaries
and joint ventures shall be measured
at the net asset value (goodwill is
presented separately).
An investor may deviate rom the net
asset value when insucient data is
available. The associate shall then be
valued at the so-called visible equity
value o the associate.
A deviation rom the net asset value
is also allowed i there are grounded
reasons or this departure. The reasons
shall be disclosed in the nancial
statements.
IAS 28 Measurement o
non-associates
Non-associates (no signicant
infuence) shall be accounted or as
nancial instruments in accordance
with IAS 39.
Associates (deelenmingen) in which
no signicant infuence is exercised
shall be measured by using the cost
method or by using current (air) value
(with value dierences recorded in a
revaluation reserve).
Non-associates shall be accounted or
as nancial instruments in accordance
with DAS 290.
IAS 28 Investment in an
associate that
is classied as
held or sale in
accordance with
IFRS 5
Shall not be accounted or using the
equity method, but is measured at the
lower o its carrying amount and air
value less cost to sell.
No accounting concept or assets held
or sale. Thereore, the general rules
on measurement continue to apply.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
22/3622
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 28 Associates held
by venture capital
organizations,
investment unds,
unit trusts and
similar entities
No requirement to apply equity
method provided that upon initial
recognition such investments are
designated upon initial recognition as
at air value through prot or loss.
There is no exemption or venture
capital organisations and similar
entities. However, under NL GA AP
an interest in another entity will not
classiy as an associate i the denition
o an associate (deelneming) isnot met (providing capital or its
own account or urthering its own
business activities by establishing
a long-term relationship).
Non-associates shall be accounted or
as nancial instruments in accordance
with DAS 290.
IAS 28 Goodwill relating
to associates
The initial measurement o an
investment in an associate is based on
the cost o acquisition. Any dierence
between the cost o acquisition
and the investors share o the net
identiable assets o the associate
is accounted or in accordance with
IFRS 3.
Goodwill is included in the carrying
amount o the investment. However,
amortisation is not permitted. Instead,
the entire carrying amount o the
investment is tested or impairment
under IAS 36 Impairment o
assets, whenever application o the
requirements in IAS 39 indicates that
the investment may be impaired.
The recognition is based on the
investors share o the air value o the
net identiable assets o the associate.
Any goodwill shall be recognised and
presented separately as an intangible
asset.
Goodwill is accounted or in
accordance with the accounting or
goodwill relating to subsidiaries.
IAS 28 Excess o air
value o net assets
acquired over
the acquisition
cost (negative
goodwill)
Recognised immediately as a gain. Similar to the accounting o negative
goodwill relating to subsidiaries (we
reer to the dierences relating to
IFRS 3).
IAS 28 Loss o signicant
infuence
On loss o signicant infuence, the
remaining investment is remeasured to
its air value at that date, with the gain
or loss recognised in prot or loss.
Thereater, IAS 39 is applied to the
remaining investment.
On loss o signicant infuence the last
known carrying amount under the
net asset value shall be the basis or
subsequent measurement at cost or
air value.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
23/3623IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 31 Joint venture in
separate nancial
statements
In the separate nancial statements
investments in joint ventures that
are not classied as held or sale
in accordance with IFRS 5 shall be
accounted or either at cost or in
accordance with IAS 39.
A joint venture shall be measured
according to the net asset value in the
company-only nancial statements.
IAS 31 Loss o joint
control
On loss o joint control, the remaining
investment is remeasured to its
air value at that date, with the
gain or loss recognised in prot or
loss. Thereater, IAS 28 or IAS 39,
as appropriate, is applied to the
remaining investment.
DASs contain no specic requirements.
Accounting in analogy with loss o
signicant infuence is appropriate.
IAS 32 Classication as
equity or liability
In the consolidated nancial
statements, individual and separate
nancial statements an instrument
is classied as a liability i the issuer
could be obliged to settle in cash oranother nancial instrument.
In the consolidated nancial
statements the classication o
nancial instruments by issuers is
based on the economic substance
o a nancial instrument, with someexceptions.
In the company-only nancial
statements the classication o
nancial instruments by the issuer
is based on the legal orm o an
instrument instead o the economic
substance o a nancial instrument.
IAS 32 Preerence shares
with contingent
dividends
depending on
the availability o
uture prot
Classication as a liability is required,
because the payment o dividend
is not at the discretion o the issuer
(cannot be avoided indenitely).
Classication as equity instrument
or as nancial liability (accounting
policy choice which shall be disclosed
by entity). DASs consider dividend
payments based on the availability
o uture prot a basic eature o an
equity instrument.
IAS 32 Financial
instrument that
contains both a
liability and an
equity element
The issuer shall classiy the
instruments component parts
separately in accordance with
the substance o the contractual
arrangement on initial recognition and
the denitions o a nancial liability
and an equity instrument.
The issuer may, but is not required to,
classiy the instruments components
separately in accordance with
the substance o the contractual
arrangement on initial recognition and
the denitions o a nancial liability
and an equity instrument. I an entity
chooses not to recognise components
separately, the instrument is classied
based on the prevailing characteristicso the instrument.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
24/3624
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 32 Puttable
instruments at air
value
Classied as equity i they are
subordinated to all other classes
o instruments and i certain other
criteria are met.
Classication as equity is allowed, but
not required i they are subordinated
to all other classes o instruments and
i certain other criteria are met.
IAS 32 Classication
o rights issues(rights, options
or warrants) that
are denominated
in a currency
other than
the unctional
currency o the
issuer
Rights issues where the holder has
the right to acquire a xed number othe entitys own equity instruments
or a xed amount o any currency
are classied as an equity instrument
i, and only i, the entity oers the
nancial instrument pro rata to all
o its existing owners o the same
class o its own non-derivative equity
instruments.
DASs contain no specic guidance or
the classication o rights issues thatare denominated in a currency other
than the unctional. We believe that
the IFRS treatment is an acceptable
alternative under NL GAAP.
IAS 36 Timing o
impairment tests
An impairment test shall be perormed
i an indication o impairment exists,
except or intangible assets with
indenite useul lives, intangible assetsnot yet in use and goodwill acquired
in a business combination. For these
assets an impairment test shall be
perormed at least annually.
An impairment test shall be perormed
i an indication o impairment exists.
IAS 36 Reversals o
impairment losses
or goodwill
Prohibited. Required i the impairment was
due to a specic external event o
an exceptional nature that is not
expected to recur and subsequent
external events have occurred that
reverse the eect o that event.
Prohibited in all other situations.
IAS 37 Cost o major
maintenance
Shall be capitalised as a component
o the asset i recognition criteria
are met. Otherwise the cost shall be
recognised directly in prot or loss.
Allowed to systematically recognise a
provision over the interval period o
the maintenance projects.
IAS 37 Provision or
restructuring
Shall only be recognised i a
constructive obligation or a
restructuring arises. This is the case
when:
there is a ormal plan; and
the entity has raised a valid
expectation in those aected that
it will carry out the plan by either
starting to implement the plan or
announcing its main eatures to
those aected by it.
Allowed to recognise i the
restructuring was started or
announced ater the balance sheet
date but beore the date o issue, i
certain conditions have been met.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
25/3625IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 37 Measurement o
provisions
Where the eect o the time value o
money is material, the amount o a
provision shall be the present value. I
the eect is not material, the use o
the nominal value is allowed.
May be measured at present value or
nominal value.
IAS 37 Accrued interest Where discounting is used, thecarrying amount o a provision
increases in each period with the
accrued interest, to refect the passage
o time. This increase is recognised as
borrowing cost in prot or loss.
Additions to the provision due toaccrued interest shall be presented
either as interest expenses or as part
o the related expense in prot or loss.
IAS 38 Useul lie Required to regard an intangible
asset as having an indenite useul
lie when, based on an analysis o
all o the relevant actors, there is
no oreseeable limit to the period
over which the asset is expected to
generate net cash infows or theentity.
Useul lie o an intangible asset is
always nite.
IAS 38 Intangibles with
indenite useul
lie
Shall not be amortised. The useul lie
o such an intangible shall be reviewed
each reporting period.
No distinction between intangibles
with a nite and indenite useul lie.
Intangibles shall be amortised based
on the expected useul lie. There is a
rebuttable presumption that the useul
lie o an intangible xed asset does
not exceed twenty years.
IAS 38 Impairment test Intangible assets with an indenite
useul lie are subject to an annual
impairment test.
Intangible assets with a useul lie
exceeding 20 years and intangible
assets not yet taken into use are
subject to an annual impairment test.
IAS 39 Categories o
nancial assets
Financial assets must be classied
into one o our categories: at air
value through prot or loss, loans
and receivables, held-to-maturity or
available or sale.
Financial assets must be classied
into one o ve categories: trading
portolio, derivatives, acquired
loans and bonds, loans and other
receivables and investment in equity
instruments.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
26/3626
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 39 Measurement
o nancial
assets (excluding
derivatives)
Ater initial recognition nancial
assets are measured at air value
except or the ollowing categories o
nancial assets, that shall be valued at
(amortised) cost:
loans and receivables; held-to-maturity investments; and
any nancial assets that do not
have a quoted market price in an
active market and whose air value
cannot be reliably measured.
Financial assets that classiy as part
o the trading portolio shall be
measured at air value.
Purchased loans and bonds held until
the end o the term are measured atamortised cost.
Other purchased loans and bonds are
measured at amortised cost or at air
value.
Loans granted and other receivables
are measured at amortised cost.
Investments in listed equity
instruments are measured at air value.
Investments in equity instruments
without stock exchange quotation are
measured at cost or at air value.
IAS 39 Measurement o
nancial liabilities
(excluding
derivatives)
Ater initial recognition an entity
shall measure all nancial liabilities
at amortised cost using the eective
interest method, except or:
nancial liabilities at air value
through prot or loss;
nancial liabilities that arise when
a transer o a nancial asset does
not qualiy or derecognition or
when the continuing involvement
approach applies;
nancial guarantee contracts; and
commitments to provide a loan at
a below-market interest rate.
Ater initial recognition an entity
shall measure nancial liabilities at
amortised cost, except or nancial
liabilities that classiy as part o the
trading portolio.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
27/3627IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 39 Measurement o
derivatives
All derivatives are measured at air
value through prot or loss, except or
derivatives that are part o a hedging
relationship (cash fow hedge or
hedge o a net investment in a oreign
entity).
Derivatives that classiy as part o the
trading portolio shall be measured at
air value through prot or loss.
Listed derivatives or derivatives with
a listed underlying value shall bemeasured at air value with changes
in value recognised directly in prot
or loss.
Derivatives with a non-listed
underlying value are measured at cost
price or air value. Upon measurement
at air value changes in value are
recognised in prot or loss.
IAS 39 Changes in air
value
A recognised gain or loss arising rom
a change in the air value o a nancial
asset or nancial liability that is not
part o a hedging relationship shall be
reported as ollows:
a gain or loss on a nancial asset or
liability held or trading (including
derivatives) or designated at air
value through prot or loss shall be
included in net prot or loss or the
period in which it arises;
a gain or loss on an available or
sale nancial asset shall be either
included in net prot or loss or
the period in which it arises or
recognised directly in equity.
A recognised gain or loss arising rom
a change in the air value o nancial
instruments that classiy as part o the
trading portolio shall be recognised in
prot or loss.
For other nancial instruments
measured at air value an entity can
opt to recognise changes in air
value directly in prot or loss or,
to the extent the aggregate o the
revaluation is positive, to recognise
it in the shareholders equity until
it is realised. Impairments below
(amortised) cost shall be accounted or
directly in prot or loss.
IAS 39 Eective interest
method
Application o eective interest
method is required.
Linear amortisation is allowed i that
does not lead to signicant dierences
with application o eective interest
method.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
28/3628
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 39 Embedded
derivatives
An embedded derivative shall be
separated rom the host contract and
accounted or as a derivative i:
the economic characteristics and
risks o the embedded derivative
are not closely related to theeconomic characteristics and risks
o the host contract;
a separate instrument with the
same terms as the embedded
derivative would meet the
denition o a derivative; and
the hybrid (combined) instrument
is not measured at air value with
changes in air value recognised
in prot or loss (i.e., a derivative
that is embedded in a nancial
asset or nancial liability at air
value through prot or loss is not
separated).
I an entity adopts a policy to measure
stand-alone derivatives at air value,
the accounting or embedded
derivatives is in line with IAS 39.
Otherwise the embedded derivative
shall not be separated rom the hostcontract.
IAS 39 Types o hedge
accounting
IAS 39 identies three types o
hedging relationships:
air value hedge;
cash fow hedge; and
hedge o a net investment in a
oreign entity.
The types o hedge accounting under
IAS 39 are applicable. However,
NL GAAP also identies cost price
hedge accounting. In the event o cost
price hedge accounting recognition
occurs as ollows:
as long as the hedged item is not
yet recognised in the balance
sheet, the hedge instrument is not
revalued;
i the hedged item is recognised in
the balance sheet and comprises
a oreign currency monetary item,
the derivative is measured at the
rate as at balance sheet date;
when the results o the hedged
position are recognised in prot
or loss, the related result on
the hedge instrument is also
recognised in prot or loss.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
29/3629IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IAS 39 Derecognition o
nancial assets
Derecognition o a nancial asset
is not permitted to the extent to
which the transeror has retained (1)
substantially all risks and rewards o
the transerred asset or part o the
asset, or (2) control o an asset or parto an asset or which it has neither
retained nor transerred substantially
all risks and rewards.
Unlike IFRSs, the criteria or
derecognition ocus on a signicant
change in the economic reality
(based on risks and rewards that
are actually expected to occur).
Control is not a specic actor to beconsidered. As a consequence the
derecognition provisions under NL
GAAP are very principles-based and
as a consequence provide more room
or interpretation than under IFRSs.
However, we believe that under NL
GAAP its allowed to use the IAS 39
derecognition provisions as urther
guidance or complex derecognition
issues.
IAS 40 Fair value changes
o investment
property
measured at air
value
Shall be recognised in prot or loss.
A revaluation reserve shall not be
recognised.
Shall be recognised in prot or loss.
However, a revaluation reserve shall
be recognised or the dierence
between cost and the air value until
the air value is realised.
IAS 41 Agriculture Specic accounting requirements or
the ollowing when they relate to
agricultural activity :
biological assets; and
agricultural produce at the point o
harvest.
No specic requirements or
agricultural activity.
IFRIC 1 Decommissioning,
restoration and
other liabilities
Specic accounting requirements or
changes in the measurement.
I the cost o an item o property,
plant and equipment includes
the initial estimate o the costs o
dismantling and removing the item
and restoring the site on which it is
located, the accounting or changes in
the measurement o these liabilities is
similar to IFRIC 1 treatment.
IFRIC 2 Members shares
in co-operative
entities and similar
instruments
Specic requirements or the
classication o these nancial
instruments as nancial liabilities or
equity by the issuer.
In the consolidated nancial
statements the classication o these
nancial instruments by issuers is like
the classication under IFRSs.
In the company-only nancial
statements the classication o
nancial instruments by the issuer isbased on the legal orm o a nancial
instrument instead o the economic
substance o the instrument.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
30/3630
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRIC 4 Determining
whether an
arrangement
contains a lease
Shall be based on the substance o
the arrangement and requires an
assessment o whether:
ulllment o the arrangement is
dependent on the use o a specic
asset or assets (the asset); and the arrangement conveys a right to
use the asset.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
IFRIC 5 Rights to interests
arising rom
decommissioning,
restoration and
environmental
rehabilitation
unds
Specic requirements or the
accounting or an interest in a und
and the accounting or obligations to
make additional contributions.
DASs do not contain specic guidance
or the accounting or an interest in
a und. However, based on general
requirements the required accounting
shall be similar to IFRIC 5.
The guidance under DASs relating to
the accounting or obligations to make
additional contributions is similar to
the requirements under IFRSs.
IFRIC 6 Liabilities arising
rom participating
in a specic
market
Participation in the market during the
measurement period is the obligating
event in accordance with IAS 37.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
IFRIC 7 Applying the
restatement
approach under
IAS 29
In the reporting period in which
an entity identies the existence o
hyperinfation in the economy o its
unctional currency, not having been
hyperinfationary in the prior period,
the entity shall apply the requirements
o IAS 29 as i the economy had
always been hyperinfationary.
The required accounting under
IFRSs is allowed, but not required.
An entity can choose to present
nancial statements to refect the
eect o infation rom the beginning
o the reporting period in which
the entity identies the existence
o hyperinfation in the economy o
its unctional currency (a starting
index o 100% at the beginning
o the reporting year in which the
entity identies the existence o
hyperinfation).
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
31/3631IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRIC 9 Reassessment
o embedded
derivatives
An entity shall assess whether an
embedded derivative is required to be
separated rom the host contract and
accounted or as a derivative when
the entity rst becomes a party to the
contract. Subsequent reassessmentis prohibited unless there is either
(a) a change in the terms o the
contract that signicantly modies
the cash fows that otherwise would
be required under the contract or (b)
a reclassication o a nancial asset
out o the air value through prot
or loss category, in which cases an
assessment is required.
DASs contain no specic guidance
relating to the reassessment o
embedded derivatives.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRIC 10 Interim nancial
reporting and
impairment
An entity shall not reverse an
impairment loss recognised in a
previous interim period in respect o
goodwill.
DASs do not contain this restriction.
Application o the consensus in
IFRIC 10 is allowed, but not required.
IFRIC 12 Service concess ion
arrangements
For all arrangements alling within
the scope o IFRIC 12 (essentially
those where the inrastructure assets
are not controlled by the operator),
the inrastructure assets are not
recognised as property, plant and
equipment o the operator. Rather,
depending on the terms o the
arrangement, the operator recognises:
a nancial asset; or
an intangible asset.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRIC 13 Customer loyalty
programs
IFRIC 13 requires entities to account
or award credits as a separately
identiable component o the sales
transaction(s) in which they are
granted.
A granted award is accounted or as a
separate component o a transaction i
the awards can be exchanged or sales
or services which the entity delivers
as part o their normal activities
and the value o the awards are not
insignicant in relation to the revenue
in which they are granted.
IFRIC 14 The limit on a
dened benet
asset
IFRIC 14 provides guidance on how to
assess the limit on the amount o the
surplus that can be recognised as a
dened benet asset. It also explains
how the pensions asset or liability maybe aected when there is a statutory
or contractual minimum unding
requirement.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
32/3632
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRIC 15 Construction o
real estate
An agreement or the construction o
real estate is a construction contract
within the scope o IAS 11 only when
the buyer is able to speciy the major
structural elements o the design o
the real estate beore constructionbegins and/or speciy major structural
changes once construction is in
progress (whether it exercises that
ability or not). I the buyer has that
ability, IAS 11 applies. I the buyer
does not have that ability, IAS 18
applies.
Pre-completion sales contracts
entered into by an entity carrying out
a real estate development project
are accounted or as construction
contracts. Where the outcome o
the project can be reliably estimated,revenue and expenses must be
recognised by applying the percentage
o completion method to that
proportion o the project represented
by the individual units o property
sold.
IFRIC 16 Hedges o a net
investment in a
oreign operation
The presentation currency does
not create an exposure to which an
entity may apply hedge accounting.
Consequently, a parent entity may
designate as a hedged risk only the
oreign exchange dierences arising
rom a dierence between its own
unctional currency and that o its
oreign operation.
The hedging instrument(s) may be
held by any entity or entities within
the group as long as the designation,
eectiveness and documentation
requirements or a hedge o a net
investment are satised.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRIC 17 Dis tributions o
non-cash assets to
owners
A dividend payable shall be recognised
when the dividend is appropriately
authorised and is no longer at the
discretion o the entity. An entity
shall measure the dividend payable
at the air value o the net assets to
be distributed. The liability shall be
remeasured at each reporting date
with changes recognised directly
in equity. The dierence between
the dividend paid and the carrying
amount o net assets distributed shall
be recognised in prot or loss.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
33/3633IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
IFRIC 18 Transers o assets
rom customers
IFRIC 18 deals with circumstances
where an entity receives rom a
customer an item o PP&E that
the entity then must use either to
connect the customer to a network
or to provide the customer withongoing access to a supply o
goods or services. IFRIC 18 provides
guidance on when a recipient shall
recognise such assets in their nancial
statements. Where recognition is
appropriate, the deemed cost o the
asset is its air value on the date o
the transer. IFRIC 18 also provides
guidance on the pattern o revenue
recognition arising on the transer o
the asset.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRIC 19 Extinguishing
nancial liabilities
with equity
instruments
An entity shall measure the equity
instruments issued as extinguishment
o the nancial liability at their air
value on the date o extinguishment o
the liability, unless that air value is not
reliably measurable. In this case the
equity instruments shall be measured
to refect the air value o the liability
extinguished.
Any dierence between the carrying
amount o the liability (or the part o
the liability) extinguished and the air
value o equity instruments issued is
recognised in prot or loss.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
IFRIC 208 Stripping costs IFRIC 20 provides guidance or waste
removal costs that are incurred
in surace mining activity during
the production phase o the mine
(production stripping costs).
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
SIC-7 Introduction o
the euro
Requirements regarding the
accounting or the changeover rom
the national currencies o participating
Member States o the European Union
to the euro.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
34/3634
IAS/IFRS Topic IFRSs NL GAAP
SIC-10 Government
assistance
Government assistance meets the
denition o government grants in
IAS 20, even i there are no conditions
specically relating to the operating
activities o the entity other than to
operate in certain regions or industrysectors.
DASs contain no specic guidance.
IFRS treatment is allowed.
SIC-12 Special purpose
entities (SPE)
An SPE shall be consolidated when the
substance o the relationship between
an entity and the SPE indicates that
the SPE is controlled by that entity.
SIC-12 provides circumstances which
may indicate a relationship in which an
entity controls an SPE.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
SIC-13 Non-monetary
contributions by
venturers
Requirements regarding the
accounting or non-monetary
contributions by venturers.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
SIC-15 Incentives oroperating leases
All incentives or the agreement o anew or renewed operating lease shall
be recognised as an integral part o
the net consideration agreed or the
use o the leased asset.
Guidance under DASs is similar to therequirements under IFRSs.
SIC-25 Changes in the tax
status o an entity
A change in the tax status o an
entity does not give rise to increases
or decreases in amounts recognised
outside prot or loss.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
SIC-27 Evaluating the
substance o
transactions
involving the legalorm o a lease
A series o transactions that involve
the legal orm o a lease is linked
and shall be accounted or as one
transaction when the overall economiceect cannot be understood without
reerence to the series o transactions
as a whole.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
SIC-29 Disclosure o
service concession
arrangements
Specic disclosure requirements or
operators and grantors relating to
service concession arrangements.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
SIC-31 Bar ter transactions
involving
advertising
services
Guidance to determine when a seller
reliably can measure revenue at the
air value o the advertising serv ices
received or provided in a barter
transaction.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
SIC-32 Website costs Guidance to determine whether the
website is an internally generated
intangible asset and to determine the
appropriate accounting treatment o
such expenditure.
Guidance under DASs is similar to the
requirements under IFRSs.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
35/3635IFRSs and NL GAAP Highlighting the key dierences
(Endnotes)
1. IFRS 9 Financial Instruments: Classication and Measurement is eective or annual periods beginning on or
ater 1 January 2013, with earlier application permitted. Supersedes and modies certain parts o IAS 39 rom
date o application. Endorsement o IFRS 9 or use in Europe has been postponed. IASB has recently proposed to
the delay the mandatory application o IFRS 9 to annual periods beginning on or ater 1 January 2015.
2. IFRS 10 Consolidated Financial Statements is eective or annual periods beginning on or ater 1 January 2013,
with earlier application permitted. Supersedes certain parts o IAS 27 rom date o application. On 1 June 2012,
ARC voted on a regulation that requires IFRS 10 to be applied, at the latest, as rom the commencement date o
a companys rst nancial year starting on or ater 1 January 2014 (early adoption would be permitted once the
standards have been endorsed).
3. IFRS 11 Joint Arrangements is eective or annual periods beginning on or ater 1 January 2013, with earlier
application permitted. Supersedes IAS 31 rom date o application. On 1 June 2012, ARC voted on a regulation
that requires IFRS 11 to be applied, at the latest, as rom the commencement date o a companys rst nancial
year starting on or ater 1 January 2014 (early adoption would be permitted once the standards have been
endorsed).
4. IFRS 12 Disclosure o Interests in Other Entities is eective or annual periods beginning on or ater 1 January
2013, with earlier application permitted. On 1 June 2012, ARC voted on a regulation that requires IFRS 12 to be
applied, at the latest, as rom the commencement date o a companys rst nancial year starting on or ater 1
January 2014 (i.e. early adoption would be permitted once the standard has been endorsed).
5. IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement is eective or annual periods beginning on or ater 1 January 2013, withearlier application permitted.
6. This requirement is changed as a consequence o amendments to IAS 1 as part o the Annual Improvements
2009-2011 Cycle, issued in May 2012. An entity shall present a third statement at the beginning o the preceding
period instead o the beginning o the earliest comparative period presented (i an entity applies an accounting
policy retrospectively or makes a retrospective restatement o items in it s nancial statements or when it
reclassies items in its nancial statements). Related notes to this third balance sheet are no longer required as
a consequence o these amendments to IAS 1. An entity shall apply this amendment retrospectively or annual
periods beginning on or ater 1 January 2013. Earlier application is permitted.
7. IAS 19 (Revised) Employee Benets is eective or annual periods beginning on or ater 1 January 2013, with
earlier application permitted.
8. IFRIC 20 Stripping Costs in the Production Phase o a Surace Mine applies to annual periods beginning on or
ater 1 January 2013. Earlier application is permitted.
-
7/29/2019 1201 44721 Ifrs vs Nl Gaap 2012_view PDF
36/36
Deloitte reers to one or more o Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited, a UK private company limited by guarantee, and its network o
member rms, each o which is a legally separate and independent entity. Please see www.deloitte.com/about or a detailed description
o the legal structure o Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Limited and its member rms.
Deloitte provides audit, tax, consulting, and nancial advisory services to public and private clients spanning multiple industries. With
a globally connected network o member rms in more than 150 countries, Deloitte brings world-class capabilities and high-quality
service to clients, delivering the insights they need to address their most complex business challenges. De loittes approximately 195,000
proessionals are committed to becoming the standard o excellence.
Thi bli i i l i i l d D l i T h T h Li i d i b h i l d