10.1 Powder mechanics - Åbo Akademi · 2018-05-08 · Powder (flow) behaviour Powder will flow...
Transcript of 10.1 Powder mechanics - Åbo Akademi · 2018-05-08 · Powder (flow) behaviour Powder will flow...
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
10Fluid and Particulate Systems 424521 /2018
POWDER MECHANICS & POWDER FLOW TESTING(flow / no flow)
Ron ZevenhovenÅA Thermal and Flow Engineering
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
10.1 Powder mechanics
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 2/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Types of flow of powders in silos [2]
a. Mass flow b. Funnel flowc. Expanded flow d. “Pipe”e. Rathole f. Arching
Differences :- Residence time
variations- Wear of wall- Food / non-food
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 3/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Stresses in a powder
http
://di
etm
ar-s
chul
ze.d
e/sp
anne
.htm
l
fluid powder
In solids, horizontal and verticalstresses are different,σh/σv typically ~ 0.3 ... 0.6
In fluids (non-flowing) σh/σv ~ 1
Fluids: surface tension, viscosity
Powders: cohesion
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 4/38
SeeJanssen Equation(1895)
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Stresses experienced by particles in powder, stresses in a silo [1,9]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 5/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Powder (flow) behaviour Powder will flow when a critical stress is overcome At low stress powder won’t flow, and forms heaps. In a powder flow stress are not dependent on flow rate.
Before flow, powders swell. Powders can consolidate, compact, decreasing porosity. Powders tend to form dense masses. Fluidisation is possible. Powders can segregate: particles with
different shape, size, density, etc. willrespond differently to forces and strains and as a result follow different paths.
No surface tension: particles can enter through small holes
Source: K. Heiskanen, 2000
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 6/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Normal stress, shear stress & sliding[4]
At contact point: normal force and shear force
Negative normal force = tensile force For non-cohesive powders:normal force can only be compressive
If shear force > ƒ normal force,with ƒ = coefficient of friction,then the powder granules will slide.
ƒ = tan (φ), with angle of friction φ
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 7/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Stress componentsnote: stress is result of strain
Under a certain orientation, along the principal axes, the shearstresses go to zero. The stresses are then the principal stresses.With maximum stress σ1, intermediate stress σ2, minimum stress σ3.Sum σ1+ σ2+ σ3 = constant and irrespective of direction.Of interest here are primarily (only) σ1 and σ3, when an axis of symmetry exists then σ3 = σ2 .
http
://w
ww
.sv.
vt.e
du/c
lass
es/E
SM
4714
/met
hods
/EE
G.h
tml
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 8/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Transformation of stresses into major & minor principal stresses
xx and yy [4]
eliminate α: 2
2122
21
22
is a circle in σ, τ plot
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 9/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Yield locus of a Coulomb powder [1]
= c + ∙tan
2
τc = cohesion
ϕ = internal angleof friction
Usually the Yield Locus
is curved!
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 10/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Arching in silos (hoppers) [8]
Important for silo/hopper design is the conditionof collapse of the arch outlet size B design.
The unconfined yield stress fc is the maximum normal stress under which a powder with a free, unstressed surface will yield
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 11/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Yield locus & Mohr circles for Coulomb powder A: no flow, B: flow [3]
τ = c + σꞏtan (φ)
σ3 σ1
o
o
c
sin
sin
sin
sin 0c if
sin
cos
sin
sin
1
1
1
1
1
2
1
1
3
1
33
1
φ0
φ internal angleof friction
φo effective internalangle of friction
Tensile strenght σt
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 12/38
shear stress < critical value, except at point *
*
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Multiple yield loci [9]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 13/38
δ = effective angle of internal frictionJYL = Jenike yield locus
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
10.2 Powder flow testing, sheartesting
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 14/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Jenike shear tester (~1979) [1,5]
http
://w
ww
.free
man
tech
.co.
uk/im
ages
/sto
ries/
pow
dert
estin
g/re
port
_moh
r_lg
.gif
Force measured with for examplea piezo-electric element
Moves at 1-3 mm/min
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 15/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Principles of Jenike shear testing /1[e.g. 5,6]
Determines the shear strength of a particulate material under a certain load.
Results in yield locus (Y.L.) for a certain consolidation. Y.L. gives minimum shear stress, , needed to initiate
flow, as a function of the normal stress, , on the shear plane at a given bulk density.
The consolidation can be quantified by a Mohr circle. Coulomb flow is assumed, i.e. = A + B Material sheared against itself angle of internal
friction, effective angle of internal friction Material sheared against wall angle of wall friction
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 16/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Dimensions of the Jenike shear cell [5]
http
://w
ww
.sol
idsh
andl
ingt
ech.
com
/
Weight for normal stress
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 17
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Jenike shear cell testing [5]
Stress-strain curves for over- (1),critically (2) and under- (3)
consolidated samples
Stress-strain curve: pre-shear, weight reduction, shear
Experience: pre-shear (kPa) ~ 0.08×√powder density (kg/m3)and multiples of that.
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 18/38
one test in two steps
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Yield loci and Mohr circles for shear test data [5,8]
A family of yield loci Yield locus showing validshear points
fc σmax
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 19/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Typical data: free-flowing powders [8]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 20/38
Lucite =Perspex
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Typical data: cohesive powders [8]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 21/38
Warren-Spring (WS) equation:
Or, a linear fit:
using parameters from the tableFF = flow function
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
10.3 Silo design
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 22/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Silo types, flow types Silo’s have typical sizes of the order of 1000 m3, say,
800 – 3500 m3. Larger than 1000 m3: concrete, smaller than 650 m3: steel.
Very large ”mammoth”silo’scan contain up to 100 000 m3, with diameters up to 30 m, heights up to 70 m.
Powder flow type depends on Internal friction of material Wall friction of material Half-angle of cone
http
://w
ww
.free
man
tech
.co.
uk/im
ages
/sto
ries/
FT
4/F
T4H
oppe
rDia
g.jp
g
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 23/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Shear test data yield locus Y.L. Mohr circle through consolidation point gives Mohr circle
with minor and major consolidating stresses min and max. Mohr circle through 0 (i.e. σ3 = 0), tangential to Y.L., gives
unconfined yield stress, fc, which is the normal stress needed to break and arch at a free surface (such as a hopper outlet).
Flow Function, FF = max / fc gives first information : – FF < 2 : extremely cohesive, – 2 < FF < 4 : cohesive, – 4 < FF < 10 : easy flowing, – FF > 10 : free flowing.
Combined with flow factor, ff, from design charts, a critical aperture size can be estimated using a flow/no flow analysis.
Jenike shear testing & silo design /1 [e.g. 3,6]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 24/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
The Jenike Flow / No flow criterion [3,6,8]
fc (Pa)
max (Pa)
Flow function, FF’max (Pa)
&
’max = 1/ff max
max, crit
fc, crit
Flow
No Flow
max / ff > fc,crit
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 25/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Data: flow function and effectiveangle of friction for common
materials [8]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 26/38
Consolidation: σn = 1.96, 4.90, 7.84 kPa
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Flow function, ff, for a conical hopper [1]
for given hopper half-angle ;angle of wall friction, w ;
effective angle of friction for the powder, = 50°
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 27/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Flow function, ff, for two hoppers [8]
for given hopper half-angle ;angle of wall friction, w ;
effective angle of friction for the powder, = 40°
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 28/38
Square; length L > 3x width B
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Jenike shear testing & silo design /2 [e.g. 6,9]
Y.L. angle of internal friction, , and effective angle of friction, ,
Wall Y.L. angle of wall friction w. Mass flow criterion for conical hopper :
<< 45° - w i.e. = 45° - 1.2w
where = half-angle with respect to gravity. Minimum bottom opening dcrit = fc,crit H()/(g bulk)
using design graphs for H() “Rule of thumb” : dcrit > 7 x particle size...... For a conical hopper: H(α) = 2 + α/60 For a symmetrical slot outlet: H(α) = 1 + α/180, L > 3W
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 29/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Function H() for hopper aperture versus hopper half-angle
(conical and pyramidal hoppers) [1,8]
Manyempirical
designdiagramslike this
are used !
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 30/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Design charts [9]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 31/38
δ = effective angle of internal friction
δw = angle of wall friction
L > 3W
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Design charts [9]
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 32/38
δ = effective angle of internal friction
δw = angle of wall friction
d
α
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
10.4 Exercises 15
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 33/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Exercises 15 a. With a Jenike standard shear tester a powder with a particle size
< 10 μm is being sheared, giving the tabelised (σ, τ) data for each pre-shear / shear test combination. See the three tables below (also next page)
Produce the 3 yield loci for these tests, create the Mohr circles, determine the unconfined yiels stress c and the flow factor FF. Is this a cohesive powder?
σpre-shear
(kPa)τpre-shear
(kPa)σshear
(kPa)τshear
(kPa)
2 1.8 1.5 1.62
2 1.97 1.5 1.67
2 1.87 1 1.35
2 1.94 1 1.39
2 1.92 1 1.43
2 1.87 1 1.45
2 1.85 1 1.47
2 1.8 1 1.46
average τpre-shear :
1.88
σpre-shear
(kPa)τpre-shear
(kPa)σshear
(kPa)τshear
(kPa)
5 4.5 4 4.04
5 4.43 4 3.90
5 4.1 3 3.19
5 4.67 3 3.08
5 4.43 2 2.66
5 4.5 2 2.74
5 4.6 1 1.83
5 4.4 1 1.87
average τpre-shear :
4.45
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 34/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Exercises 15
b. The powder discussed in question 15a is to be stored in a conical hopper under mass flow conditions. Shear tests with a sample of the wall material give an angle of wall friction φwall =33.Using the Figures given here (for δ=φi = 50), deterimine
the angle α
the flow function for this hopper the critical unconfined yield stress, c,crit
the minimum bottom opening dcrit
Assume a powder bulk density ρbulk= 900 kg/m³.
σpre-shear
(kPa)τpre-shear
(kPa)σshear
(kPa)τshear
(kPa)
9 8.3 7 6.9
9 8.2 7 7.2
9 8.1 5 5.6
9 8.6 5 5.5
9 7.9 3 4.1
9 8.6 3 4.0
9 7.9 1 2.40
9 8.7 1 2.34
average τpre-shear
8.3
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 35/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
Exercises 15T
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 36/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018
References [1] Iinoya, K., Gotoh, K., Higashitani, K. “Powder technology
handbook”, Marcel Dekker, New York (1991) Chapters II.1, II.3, III.12, V. 4
[2] F.J.C. Rademacher “Storage and handling of bulk powders” (in Dutch),ProcesTechnologie Oct. 1992 36-41 & Nov. 1992, 27-32
[3] H. Rumpf “Mechanische Verfahrenstechnik” (in German) Carl Hanser Verlag, München/Wien (1975) Chapter 3.4
[4] A. Verruijt “Soil mechanics” (in Dutch) Delft Publishing Co., Delft (1983) [5] “Standard shear cell testing technique (for particulate solids using the Jenike shear
cell)” Institute of Chemical Engineers, European Federation of Chemical Engineering, Rugby (UK) (1989)
[6] Zevenhoven, C.A.P. “Particle charging and granular bed filtration for high temperature application” PhD thesis Delft Univ. of Technol., Delft (1992) Chapter 9.3
[7] L-S Fan, C Zhu “Principles of gas solid flows”, Cambridge Univ. Press (1998) Chapter 8 [8] C06: Crowe, C.T., ed., Multiphase Flow Handbook. CRC Press, Taylor & Francis
(2006), Chapter 9 [9] George G. Chase, SOLIDS NOTES 10, The University of Akron OH, USA
available at: https://www.inti.gob.ar/cirsoc/pdf/silos/SolidsNotes10HopperDesign.pdf See also: D. Schulze “Powders and bulk solids”, Springer (2008)
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 37/38
Flu
id &
Par
ticul
ate
Sys
tem
s42
4521
/ 2
010
Flui
d &
Par
ticul
ate
Syst
ems
ÅA
424
521
/ 2
018 End of course 424521 / year 2018
Åbo Akademi University - Värme- och Strömningsteknik Biskopsgatan 8, FI-20500 Åbo / Turku Finland
RoNz 38/38