1-' !u 2 20/2 - Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · 2012-02-29 · 2332 greens run rd st....
12
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS OF WEST VIRGINIA Upon Original Jurisdiction No. 12-0185 1-' rFi' !u 2 I 20/2 lUi STATE OF WEST VIGINIA, ex rei. DONNA J. BOLEY, Petitioner, . v. NATALIE E. TENNANT, SECRETARY OF STATE OF THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA, and FRANK DEEM, Respondents. ! L.:.i APPENDIX TO RESPONSE OF FRANK DEEM TO THE EMERGENCY PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS OF PETITIONER DONNA J. BOLEY February 21, 2012 Benjamin L. Bailey (WVSB#200) Jonathan S. Deem (WVSB#10344) 209 Capitol Street Charleston, WV 25301 Phone: 304-345-6555 [email protected] jdeemra),baileyglasser.com Counsel for Respondent Frank Deem
Transcript of 1-' !u 2 20/2 - Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia · 2012-02-29 · 2332 greens run rd st....
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS OF WEST VIRGINIA Upon Original Jurisdiction
No 12-0185 Irr=-~ ~~O ~ ~----~ 1- rFi
u ~fB 2 I 202 lUi STATE OF WEST VIGINIA ex rei DONNA J BOLEY
Petitioner
v
NATALIE E TENNANT SECRETARY OF STATE OF THE STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA and FRANK DEEM
Respondents
Li
APPENDIX TO RESPONSE OF FRANK DEEM TO THE EMERGENCY PETITION FOR WRIT OF MANDAMUS OF PETITIONER DONNA J BOLEY
February 21 2012
Benjamin L Bailey (WVSB200) Jonathan S Deem (WVSB10344) 209 Capitol Street Charleston WV 25301 Phone 304-345-6555 bbaileybaileyglassercom jdeemra)baileyglassercom Counsel for Respondent Frank Deem
CERTIFICATE OF ACCURACY OF APPENDIX CONTENTS
I Jonathan S Deem counsel for Respondent do on this the 21 st day of February 2012
hereby certify pursuant to the provisions of Rule 7(c)(2) and Rule 16(3) of the Revised Rules of
Appellate Procedure that the contents of this Appendix are to the best of my knowledge and
belief accurate copies of the items that I have described in the TABLE OF CONTENTS OF
THIS APPENDIX and RESPONSE OF FRANK DEEM TO THE EMERGENCY PETITION
FOR VRIT OF MANDAMUS OF PETITIONER DONNA 1 BOLEY to which this Appendix is
appended
n L Bailey (WVSB 20 J na an S Deem (WVSB 10344)
ai Y amp Glasser LLP Capitol Street
Charleston WV 2530 I Phone (304) 345-6555 Fax (304) 342-1110 Counsel for Respondent Frank Deem
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO1 List of Candidates for 050812012-Primary 2012 1-2
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO2 List of District 3 Combined Population 3
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO3 List of District 3 Total Number of Registered V oters and Party Affiliation 4
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO4 Letter Dated 0511485 from Governor Arch Moore to Secretary of State Ken Hechler Appointing Donna J Boley to Third Senatorial District Seat 5
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO5 Election Information on Donna Boley from Ballotpediaorg 6
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO6 Members of West Virginia Senate 1982 to 1994 7
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO7 Election Information on Frank Deem From Ballotpediaorg 8
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO8 Secretary of State Records Re Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents 9
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012 Officeffiistrict Division
Party Candidate State Senator 1st Senatorial District
Republican PAT MCGEEHAN Democrat JACK YOST
2nd Senatorial District Democrat JEFFREY V KESSLER
3rd Senatorial District Republican DONNA J BOLEY Republican FRANK DEEM
4th Senatorial District RepUblican MITCH B CARMICHAEL Democrat MARLA DEE INGELS Democrat MICHAEL Mike BRIGHT
5th Senatorial District Democrat ROBERT H Bob PLYMALE
6th Senatorial District Republican BILL COLE Democrat MARK WILLS Democrat MICHAEL Mike MITCHEM
7th Senatorial District Democrat ART KIRKENDOLL Democrat SAMMY D DALTON
8th Senatorial District Republican CHRIS WALTERS Democrat JENNlFER SCRAGG KARR Democrat JOSHUA R MARTIN
9th Senatorial District Republican EPP E CLINE Democrat DANIEL HALL Democrat RICHARD BROWNING
10th Senatorial District Democrat WILLIAM R LAIRD IV
I tth Senatorial District Republican CLARK BARNES Democrat MARGARET KERR BECKWITH Democrat PAUL PJ LOUK
Address
616 FLORIDA AVE APT5 CHESTER WV 26034 1413 PLEASANT AVENUE WELLSBURG WV 26070
607 WHEELING A VENUE GLEN DALE WV 26038
2332 GREENS RUN RD ST MARYS WV 26170 5518 2ND AVENUE VIENNA WV 26105 - 1916
2 Colonial Drive RIPLEY WV 25271 161 LYNN DRIVE NEW HAVEN WV 25265 - 0000 475 WEST VIEW DR RIPLEY WV 25271
206 CLlFFVIEW DR HUNTINGTON WV 25704
404 OAKHURST A VENUE BLUEFIELD WV 24701 218 HALE A VENUE PRINCETON WV 24740 IAEGER - SANDY RIVER DISTRICT COONBRANCH RD
12 KIRKENDOLL LANE CHAPMANVILLE WV 25508 RT 1 BOX 378 HARTS WV 25524
Route I Box 150 RED HOUSE WV 25168 1750 CROSS CR BUFFALO WV 25033 10 BRANDY LANE POCA WV 25159
119 U-DELL DR OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000 136 Upper Oak Grove OCEANA WV 24870 303 MULBERRY ST OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000
225 HIGHLAND A VB OAK HILL WV 25901
RT 2 BOX 12-C BEVERLY WV 26253 EXHIBIT
i 136 VECTOR AVENUE ELKINS WV 26241 I DRY RUN RD MILL CREEK WV 26241
City County
Chester Hancock Wellsburg Brooke
Glen Dale Marshall
St Marys Pleasants Vienna Wood
Ripley Jackson New Haven Mason rupley Jackson
Huntington Wayne
Bluefield Mercer Princeton Mercer Iaeger Mcdowell
Chapmanville Logan Harts Logan
Red House Putnam Buffalo Putnam Poca Putnam
Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming
Oak Hill Fayette
Beverly Randolph Elkins Randolph Mill Creek Randolph
OfficelDistrict Division
Party Candidate 12th Senatorial District
Democrat DOUG FACEMIRE
13th Senatorial District Republican CASEY MAYER
Democrat ROMAN W PREZIOSO JR
14th Senatorial District Democrat BOB WILLIAMS
15th Senatorial District Republican CRAIG P BLAIR
16th Senatorial District Republican JIM RULAND
Democrat HERB SNYDER
17th Senatorial District Democrat COREY PALUMBO
Total Candidates 32
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012
Address
255 N HILLCREST DR PO BOX 215
1010 EAST BROOKSIDE DR FAIRMONT WV 26554
1806 DOGWOOD DRIVE FAIRMONT WV 26554
131 FOREST DRIVE BRIDGEPORT WV 26330
47 WASSER DRIVE MARTINSBURG WV 25403
51 REBELS ROOST CT HARPERS FERRY WV 25425 - 0000
1113 SHENANDOAH JUNCTION RD SHENANDOAH JUNCTION WV
1206 WILLIAMSBURG WAY CHARLESTON WV 25314
City County
Sutton Braxton
Fainnont Marion
Fainnont Marion
Bridgeport Taylor
Martinsburg Berkeley
Harpers Ferry Jefferson
Shenandoah Jefferson
Charleston Kanawha
D~3middot
Pleasants WV County
Roane WV County VTD 15 VTD 16 VTD 25 (part)
VTD28 VTD4 VTD5 VTD7
Roane WV Conoty Subtotal
Wilt wv County
Wood WV County Distrid 3 Subtotal DisbiCt)4~
7605
359 576 934 985 504
1720 531
5609
5717
86956 105887
EXHIBIT
i 2-
Senatorial District 3
PLEASANTS 2564 1585 0
ROANE 1757 1202 5 755 7 ~l2~ WIRT 2090 1483 5 703 62 ~4
WOOD 21035 21531 40 11052 424Si4CJ82
Source West Virginia Statewide Voter Registration System (010000 February 17 2012)
EXHIBIT
I $
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
CERTIFICATE OF ACCURACY OF APPENDIX CONTENTS
I Jonathan S Deem counsel for Respondent do on this the 21 st day of February 2012
hereby certify pursuant to the provisions of Rule 7(c)(2) and Rule 16(3) of the Revised Rules of
Appellate Procedure that the contents of this Appendix are to the best of my knowledge and
belief accurate copies of the items that I have described in the TABLE OF CONTENTS OF
THIS APPENDIX and RESPONSE OF FRANK DEEM TO THE EMERGENCY PETITION
FOR VRIT OF MANDAMUS OF PETITIONER DONNA 1 BOLEY to which this Appendix is
appended
n L Bailey (WVSB 20 J na an S Deem (WVSB 10344)
ai Y amp Glasser LLP Capitol Street
Charleston WV 2530 I Phone (304) 345-6555 Fax (304) 342-1110 Counsel for Respondent Frank Deem
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO1 List of Candidates for 050812012-Primary 2012 1-2
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO2 List of District 3 Combined Population 3
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO3 List of District 3 Total Number of Registered V oters and Party Affiliation 4
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO4 Letter Dated 0511485 from Governor Arch Moore to Secretary of State Ken Hechler Appointing Donna J Boley to Third Senatorial District Seat 5
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO5 Election Information on Donna Boley from Ballotpediaorg 6
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO6 Members of West Virginia Senate 1982 to 1994 7
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO7 Election Information on Frank Deem From Ballotpediaorg 8
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO8 Secretary of State Records Re Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents 9
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012 Officeffiistrict Division
Party Candidate State Senator 1st Senatorial District
Republican PAT MCGEEHAN Democrat JACK YOST
2nd Senatorial District Democrat JEFFREY V KESSLER
3rd Senatorial District Republican DONNA J BOLEY Republican FRANK DEEM
4th Senatorial District RepUblican MITCH B CARMICHAEL Democrat MARLA DEE INGELS Democrat MICHAEL Mike BRIGHT
5th Senatorial District Democrat ROBERT H Bob PLYMALE
6th Senatorial District Republican BILL COLE Democrat MARK WILLS Democrat MICHAEL Mike MITCHEM
7th Senatorial District Democrat ART KIRKENDOLL Democrat SAMMY D DALTON
8th Senatorial District Republican CHRIS WALTERS Democrat JENNlFER SCRAGG KARR Democrat JOSHUA R MARTIN
9th Senatorial District Republican EPP E CLINE Democrat DANIEL HALL Democrat RICHARD BROWNING
10th Senatorial District Democrat WILLIAM R LAIRD IV
I tth Senatorial District Republican CLARK BARNES Democrat MARGARET KERR BECKWITH Democrat PAUL PJ LOUK
Address
616 FLORIDA AVE APT5 CHESTER WV 26034 1413 PLEASANT AVENUE WELLSBURG WV 26070
607 WHEELING A VENUE GLEN DALE WV 26038
2332 GREENS RUN RD ST MARYS WV 26170 5518 2ND AVENUE VIENNA WV 26105 - 1916
2 Colonial Drive RIPLEY WV 25271 161 LYNN DRIVE NEW HAVEN WV 25265 - 0000 475 WEST VIEW DR RIPLEY WV 25271
206 CLlFFVIEW DR HUNTINGTON WV 25704
404 OAKHURST A VENUE BLUEFIELD WV 24701 218 HALE A VENUE PRINCETON WV 24740 IAEGER - SANDY RIVER DISTRICT COONBRANCH RD
12 KIRKENDOLL LANE CHAPMANVILLE WV 25508 RT 1 BOX 378 HARTS WV 25524
Route I Box 150 RED HOUSE WV 25168 1750 CROSS CR BUFFALO WV 25033 10 BRANDY LANE POCA WV 25159
119 U-DELL DR OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000 136 Upper Oak Grove OCEANA WV 24870 303 MULBERRY ST OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000
225 HIGHLAND A VB OAK HILL WV 25901
RT 2 BOX 12-C BEVERLY WV 26253 EXHIBIT
i 136 VECTOR AVENUE ELKINS WV 26241 I DRY RUN RD MILL CREEK WV 26241
City County
Chester Hancock Wellsburg Brooke
Glen Dale Marshall
St Marys Pleasants Vienna Wood
Ripley Jackson New Haven Mason rupley Jackson
Huntington Wayne
Bluefield Mercer Princeton Mercer Iaeger Mcdowell
Chapmanville Logan Harts Logan
Red House Putnam Buffalo Putnam Poca Putnam
Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming
Oak Hill Fayette
Beverly Randolph Elkins Randolph Mill Creek Randolph
OfficelDistrict Division
Party Candidate 12th Senatorial District
Democrat DOUG FACEMIRE
13th Senatorial District Republican CASEY MAYER
Democrat ROMAN W PREZIOSO JR
14th Senatorial District Democrat BOB WILLIAMS
15th Senatorial District Republican CRAIG P BLAIR
16th Senatorial District Republican JIM RULAND
Democrat HERB SNYDER
17th Senatorial District Democrat COREY PALUMBO
Total Candidates 32
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012
Address
255 N HILLCREST DR PO BOX 215
1010 EAST BROOKSIDE DR FAIRMONT WV 26554
1806 DOGWOOD DRIVE FAIRMONT WV 26554
131 FOREST DRIVE BRIDGEPORT WV 26330
47 WASSER DRIVE MARTINSBURG WV 25403
51 REBELS ROOST CT HARPERS FERRY WV 25425 - 0000
1113 SHENANDOAH JUNCTION RD SHENANDOAH JUNCTION WV
1206 WILLIAMSBURG WAY CHARLESTON WV 25314
City County
Sutton Braxton
Fainnont Marion
Fainnont Marion
Bridgeport Taylor
Martinsburg Berkeley
Harpers Ferry Jefferson
Shenandoah Jefferson
Charleston Kanawha
D~3middot
Pleasants WV County
Roane WV County VTD 15 VTD 16 VTD 25 (part)
VTD28 VTD4 VTD5 VTD7
Roane WV Conoty Subtotal
Wilt wv County
Wood WV County Distrid 3 Subtotal DisbiCt)4~
7605
359 576 934 985 504
1720 531
5609
5717
86956 105887
EXHIBIT
i 2-
Senatorial District 3
PLEASANTS 2564 1585 0
ROANE 1757 1202 5 755 7 ~l2~ WIRT 2090 1483 5 703 62 ~4
WOOD 21035 21531 40 11052 424Si4CJ82
Source West Virginia Statewide Voter Registration System (010000 February 17 2012)
EXHIBIT
I $
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO1 List of Candidates for 050812012-Primary 2012 1-2
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO2 List of District 3 Combined Population 3
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO3 List of District 3 Total Number of Registered V oters and Party Affiliation 4
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO4 Letter Dated 0511485 from Governor Arch Moore to Secretary of State Ken Hechler Appointing Donna J Boley to Third Senatorial District Seat 5
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO5 Election Information on Donna Boley from Ballotpediaorg 6
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO6 Members of West Virginia Senate 1982 to 1994 7
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO7 Election Information on Frank Deem From Ballotpediaorg 8
RESPONDENT EXHIBIT NO8 Secretary of State Records Re Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents 9
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012 Officeffiistrict Division
Party Candidate State Senator 1st Senatorial District
Republican PAT MCGEEHAN Democrat JACK YOST
2nd Senatorial District Democrat JEFFREY V KESSLER
3rd Senatorial District Republican DONNA J BOLEY Republican FRANK DEEM
4th Senatorial District RepUblican MITCH B CARMICHAEL Democrat MARLA DEE INGELS Democrat MICHAEL Mike BRIGHT
5th Senatorial District Democrat ROBERT H Bob PLYMALE
6th Senatorial District Republican BILL COLE Democrat MARK WILLS Democrat MICHAEL Mike MITCHEM
7th Senatorial District Democrat ART KIRKENDOLL Democrat SAMMY D DALTON
8th Senatorial District Republican CHRIS WALTERS Democrat JENNlFER SCRAGG KARR Democrat JOSHUA R MARTIN
9th Senatorial District Republican EPP E CLINE Democrat DANIEL HALL Democrat RICHARD BROWNING
10th Senatorial District Democrat WILLIAM R LAIRD IV
I tth Senatorial District Republican CLARK BARNES Democrat MARGARET KERR BECKWITH Democrat PAUL PJ LOUK
Address
616 FLORIDA AVE APT5 CHESTER WV 26034 1413 PLEASANT AVENUE WELLSBURG WV 26070
607 WHEELING A VENUE GLEN DALE WV 26038
2332 GREENS RUN RD ST MARYS WV 26170 5518 2ND AVENUE VIENNA WV 26105 - 1916
2 Colonial Drive RIPLEY WV 25271 161 LYNN DRIVE NEW HAVEN WV 25265 - 0000 475 WEST VIEW DR RIPLEY WV 25271
206 CLlFFVIEW DR HUNTINGTON WV 25704
404 OAKHURST A VENUE BLUEFIELD WV 24701 218 HALE A VENUE PRINCETON WV 24740 IAEGER - SANDY RIVER DISTRICT COONBRANCH RD
12 KIRKENDOLL LANE CHAPMANVILLE WV 25508 RT 1 BOX 378 HARTS WV 25524
Route I Box 150 RED HOUSE WV 25168 1750 CROSS CR BUFFALO WV 25033 10 BRANDY LANE POCA WV 25159
119 U-DELL DR OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000 136 Upper Oak Grove OCEANA WV 24870 303 MULBERRY ST OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000
225 HIGHLAND A VB OAK HILL WV 25901
RT 2 BOX 12-C BEVERLY WV 26253 EXHIBIT
i 136 VECTOR AVENUE ELKINS WV 26241 I DRY RUN RD MILL CREEK WV 26241
City County
Chester Hancock Wellsburg Brooke
Glen Dale Marshall
St Marys Pleasants Vienna Wood
Ripley Jackson New Haven Mason rupley Jackson
Huntington Wayne
Bluefield Mercer Princeton Mercer Iaeger Mcdowell
Chapmanville Logan Harts Logan
Red House Putnam Buffalo Putnam Poca Putnam
Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming
Oak Hill Fayette
Beverly Randolph Elkins Randolph Mill Creek Randolph
OfficelDistrict Division
Party Candidate 12th Senatorial District
Democrat DOUG FACEMIRE
13th Senatorial District Republican CASEY MAYER
Democrat ROMAN W PREZIOSO JR
14th Senatorial District Democrat BOB WILLIAMS
15th Senatorial District Republican CRAIG P BLAIR
16th Senatorial District Republican JIM RULAND
Democrat HERB SNYDER
17th Senatorial District Democrat COREY PALUMBO
Total Candidates 32
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012
Address
255 N HILLCREST DR PO BOX 215
1010 EAST BROOKSIDE DR FAIRMONT WV 26554
1806 DOGWOOD DRIVE FAIRMONT WV 26554
131 FOREST DRIVE BRIDGEPORT WV 26330
47 WASSER DRIVE MARTINSBURG WV 25403
51 REBELS ROOST CT HARPERS FERRY WV 25425 - 0000
1113 SHENANDOAH JUNCTION RD SHENANDOAH JUNCTION WV
1206 WILLIAMSBURG WAY CHARLESTON WV 25314
City County
Sutton Braxton
Fainnont Marion
Fainnont Marion
Bridgeport Taylor
Martinsburg Berkeley
Harpers Ferry Jefferson
Shenandoah Jefferson
Charleston Kanawha
D~3middot
Pleasants WV County
Roane WV County VTD 15 VTD 16 VTD 25 (part)
VTD28 VTD4 VTD5 VTD7
Roane WV Conoty Subtotal
Wilt wv County
Wood WV County Distrid 3 Subtotal DisbiCt)4~
7605
359 576 934 985 504
1720 531
5609
5717
86956 105887
EXHIBIT
i 2-
Senatorial District 3
PLEASANTS 2564 1585 0
ROANE 1757 1202 5 755 7 ~l2~ WIRT 2090 1483 5 703 62 ~4
WOOD 21035 21531 40 11052 424Si4CJ82
Source West Virginia Statewide Voter Registration System (010000 February 17 2012)
EXHIBIT
I $
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012 Officeffiistrict Division
Party Candidate State Senator 1st Senatorial District
Republican PAT MCGEEHAN Democrat JACK YOST
2nd Senatorial District Democrat JEFFREY V KESSLER
3rd Senatorial District Republican DONNA J BOLEY Republican FRANK DEEM
4th Senatorial District RepUblican MITCH B CARMICHAEL Democrat MARLA DEE INGELS Democrat MICHAEL Mike BRIGHT
5th Senatorial District Democrat ROBERT H Bob PLYMALE
6th Senatorial District Republican BILL COLE Democrat MARK WILLS Democrat MICHAEL Mike MITCHEM
7th Senatorial District Democrat ART KIRKENDOLL Democrat SAMMY D DALTON
8th Senatorial District Republican CHRIS WALTERS Democrat JENNlFER SCRAGG KARR Democrat JOSHUA R MARTIN
9th Senatorial District Republican EPP E CLINE Democrat DANIEL HALL Democrat RICHARD BROWNING
10th Senatorial District Democrat WILLIAM R LAIRD IV
I tth Senatorial District Republican CLARK BARNES Democrat MARGARET KERR BECKWITH Democrat PAUL PJ LOUK
Address
616 FLORIDA AVE APT5 CHESTER WV 26034 1413 PLEASANT AVENUE WELLSBURG WV 26070
607 WHEELING A VENUE GLEN DALE WV 26038
2332 GREENS RUN RD ST MARYS WV 26170 5518 2ND AVENUE VIENNA WV 26105 - 1916
2 Colonial Drive RIPLEY WV 25271 161 LYNN DRIVE NEW HAVEN WV 25265 - 0000 475 WEST VIEW DR RIPLEY WV 25271
206 CLlFFVIEW DR HUNTINGTON WV 25704
404 OAKHURST A VENUE BLUEFIELD WV 24701 218 HALE A VENUE PRINCETON WV 24740 IAEGER - SANDY RIVER DISTRICT COONBRANCH RD
12 KIRKENDOLL LANE CHAPMANVILLE WV 25508 RT 1 BOX 378 HARTS WV 25524
Route I Box 150 RED HOUSE WV 25168 1750 CROSS CR BUFFALO WV 25033 10 BRANDY LANE POCA WV 25159
119 U-DELL DR OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000 136 Upper Oak Grove OCEANA WV 24870 303 MULBERRY ST OCEANA WV 24870 - 0000
225 HIGHLAND A VB OAK HILL WV 25901
RT 2 BOX 12-C BEVERLY WV 26253 EXHIBIT
i 136 VECTOR AVENUE ELKINS WV 26241 I DRY RUN RD MILL CREEK WV 26241
City County
Chester Hancock Wellsburg Brooke
Glen Dale Marshall
St Marys Pleasants Vienna Wood
Ripley Jackson New Haven Mason rupley Jackson
Huntington Wayne
Bluefield Mercer Princeton Mercer Iaeger Mcdowell
Chapmanville Logan Harts Logan
Red House Putnam Buffalo Putnam Poca Putnam
Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming Oceana Wyoming
Oak Hill Fayette
Beverly Randolph Elkins Randolph Mill Creek Randolph
OfficelDistrict Division
Party Candidate 12th Senatorial District
Democrat DOUG FACEMIRE
13th Senatorial District Republican CASEY MAYER
Democrat ROMAN W PREZIOSO JR
14th Senatorial District Democrat BOB WILLIAMS
15th Senatorial District Republican CRAIG P BLAIR
16th Senatorial District Republican JIM RULAND
Democrat HERB SNYDER
17th Senatorial District Democrat COREY PALUMBO
Total Candidates 32
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012
Address
255 N HILLCREST DR PO BOX 215
1010 EAST BROOKSIDE DR FAIRMONT WV 26554
1806 DOGWOOD DRIVE FAIRMONT WV 26554
131 FOREST DRIVE BRIDGEPORT WV 26330
47 WASSER DRIVE MARTINSBURG WV 25403
51 REBELS ROOST CT HARPERS FERRY WV 25425 - 0000
1113 SHENANDOAH JUNCTION RD SHENANDOAH JUNCTION WV
1206 WILLIAMSBURG WAY CHARLESTON WV 25314
City County
Sutton Braxton
Fainnont Marion
Fainnont Marion
Bridgeport Taylor
Martinsburg Berkeley
Harpers Ferry Jefferson
Shenandoah Jefferson
Charleston Kanawha
D~3middot
Pleasants WV County
Roane WV County VTD 15 VTD 16 VTD 25 (part)
VTD28 VTD4 VTD5 VTD7
Roane WV Conoty Subtotal
Wilt wv County
Wood WV County Distrid 3 Subtotal DisbiCt)4~
7605
359 576 934 985 504
1720 531
5609
5717
86956 105887
EXHIBIT
i 2-
Senatorial District 3
PLEASANTS 2564 1585 0
ROANE 1757 1202 5 755 7 ~l2~ WIRT 2090 1483 5 703 62 ~4
WOOD 21035 21531 40 11052 424Si4CJ82
Source West Virginia Statewide Voter Registration System (010000 February 17 2012)
EXHIBIT
I $
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
OfficelDistrict Division
Party Candidate 12th Senatorial District
Democrat DOUG FACEMIRE
13th Senatorial District Republican CASEY MAYER
Democrat ROMAN W PREZIOSO JR
14th Senatorial District Democrat BOB WILLIAMS
15th Senatorial District Republican CRAIG P BLAIR
16th Senatorial District Republican JIM RULAND
Democrat HERB SNYDER
17th Senatorial District Democrat COREY PALUMBO
Total Candidates 32
List Of Candidates For 05082012 -- PRIMARY 2012
Address
255 N HILLCREST DR PO BOX 215
1010 EAST BROOKSIDE DR FAIRMONT WV 26554
1806 DOGWOOD DRIVE FAIRMONT WV 26554
131 FOREST DRIVE BRIDGEPORT WV 26330
47 WASSER DRIVE MARTINSBURG WV 25403
51 REBELS ROOST CT HARPERS FERRY WV 25425 - 0000
1113 SHENANDOAH JUNCTION RD SHENANDOAH JUNCTION WV
1206 WILLIAMSBURG WAY CHARLESTON WV 25314
City County
Sutton Braxton
Fainnont Marion
Fainnont Marion
Bridgeport Taylor
Martinsburg Berkeley
Harpers Ferry Jefferson
Shenandoah Jefferson
Charleston Kanawha
D~3middot
Pleasants WV County
Roane WV County VTD 15 VTD 16 VTD 25 (part)
VTD28 VTD4 VTD5 VTD7
Roane WV Conoty Subtotal
Wilt wv County
Wood WV County Distrid 3 Subtotal DisbiCt)4~
7605
359 576 934 985 504
1720 531
5609
5717
86956 105887
EXHIBIT
i 2-
Senatorial District 3
PLEASANTS 2564 1585 0
ROANE 1757 1202 5 755 7 ~l2~ WIRT 2090 1483 5 703 62 ~4
WOOD 21035 21531 40 11052 424Si4CJ82
Source West Virginia Statewide Voter Registration System (010000 February 17 2012)
EXHIBIT
I $
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
D~3middot
Pleasants WV County
Roane WV County VTD 15 VTD 16 VTD 25 (part)
VTD28 VTD4 VTD5 VTD7
Roane WV Conoty Subtotal
Wilt wv County
Wood WV County Distrid 3 Subtotal DisbiCt)4~
7605
359 576 934 985 504
1720 531
5609
5717
86956 105887
EXHIBIT
i 2-
Senatorial District 3
PLEASANTS 2564 1585 0
ROANE 1757 1202 5 755 7 ~l2~ WIRT 2090 1483 5 703 62 ~4
WOOD 21035 21531 40 11052 424Si4CJ82
Source West Virginia Statewide Voter Registration System (010000 February 17 2012)
EXHIBIT
I $
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
Senatorial District 3
PLEASANTS 2564 1585 0
ROANE 1757 1202 5 755 7 ~l2~ WIRT 2090 1483 5 703 62 ~4
WOOD 21035 21531 40 11052 424Si4CJ82
Source West Virginia Statewide Voter Registration System (010000 February 17 2012)
EXHIBIT
I $
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
ARCH A MOORE JR GOVERNOR
STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA
OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
CHARLESTON 25305
May 14 1985
The Honorable Ken Hechler Secretary of State State Capitol Charleston West Virginia 25305
Dear Mr Secretary
As Governor of the State of West Virginia I have today appointed Donna J Boley of St Marys pleasants County West Virginia to serve the vacancy presently existing in the Third Senatorial District which was created by the resignation of Senator Sam White
please issue commission accordingly
Sincerely
~a Arch A
BY THE GOVERNOR
SECRETARY OF STATE
cc The Honorable Dan Tonkovich The Honorable Donna J Boley The Honorable C N Harman
EXHIBIT
I J
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
)onna Boley - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorgjwikiindexphptitle=Donna_ Bol eyampprintabJe=ye
10f3
Donna Boley
From Ballotpedia
Donna Boley is a Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate She has represented District 3 since her appointment Contents in 1985
She served as Senate Minority Leader from 1991 to 1997 She also worked as a Senior Advisor for the George W Bush for President West Virginia Campaign in the year 2000 In 2008 she worked as Chair for West Virginia Women McCain for President
Boley received her diploma from Sisterville High School in 1953 She went on to attend West Virginia University Parkersburg in 1981
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 11 2011-2012 bull 12 2009-2010
bull 2 Elections bull 212012 bull 222008
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312008
bull 4 Personal
bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Boley has worked as both a businessperson and bookkeeper[I]
Committee assignments
2011-2012
In the 2011-2012 legislative session Boley has been appointed to these committees
bull Children Juveniles and Other Issues Committee West Virginia State Legislature
bull Council of Finance and Administration West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Education Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Education Accountability Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Finance Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Health and Human Resources Accountability Committee West Virginia
State Legislature bull Military Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Rule-Making Review Committee West Virginia State Legislature bull Rules Committee West Virginia State Senate bull Special Investigations Committee West Virginia State Legislature
2009-2010
In the 2009-2010 legislative session Boley served on these committees
bull Education Committee West Virginia Senate bull Finance Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Government Organization Committee West Virginia Senate bull Health and Human Resources Committee West Virginia Senate
Donna Boley
West Virginia State Senate District 3
Incumbent In office
1 985-Present
Tenn ends January 9 2013
Yean in position 27
Party Republican Compensation
Base salary $20000year
Per diem $131day during session
Elections and appointments Last election 2008
middot Flnt elected 1984 middot Next election November 6 2012 i Tenn limits NA
Education
High school Sistersville High School 1953
Penonal
Birthday December 9 1935 Place of birth Tyler Cowrty WV
Religion Methodist Website
Office website (httpwwwlegisstatewvus ISenatellMembers
bull Isenmemviewcfminput=Senator20Boley)
EXHIBlT
S 21202012429 PI
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
iE mstcong M 1l~ 1872 kor John 1M bullbull 1923middot 25 nis1 0 1985 31 dor~ Rnrumd 1917 19 01~ Tha 1815 77 bull rdman Syl~lArf 1893 ~ 9S~
Orton A W18middot 74 7ampmiddot 16middot77 78 FlO bull il bull 8 83 84
H~knQli Orion R 1917 bull 49 Cult)middot R L 1957 oR 59 bull 61) Known E W _ 1905 Q7
VI Brad 1969 - 70 itt1gt J I fill bull lao ooyald Hurry C 18911middot1901 ooynrd WiIIiM U83 bull l~ JOdym William 1929 in
[ERS ms W W 1877 7~ (trsm lltrd 1991 middot92middot93middot94middot95middot B - 97 bull 10 RK1ud p 1977 7819 f[) middotIll- 112 bull Iter Carl C~ 1913middot 15middot17 19middot21 l~ lont tL C~J Jr bullbull 1972middot 7(J ~ 74 ii) inn Mttrirll 1885 - 87 ~ltJS William 1893 95 lItlm~ Jack ~ 197amp ~ 1a Iy T 11 1927 2~ NltltI Forest L 1947 - 49 lar Rsy E 1967 - ~ll 69middot70 ig J 1ynn 1 ifgt 1 bull 01
)It
IIy B F 1907 bull 09 matte John S 185middot ttl ther J IL 1869middot70middot72 lliB Thomas til 188 I)j 19(11 idmon Hrry 1M] hllm Samamp E 1895 97 rman C N 1972middot 7S - 74 75 71~ 77 18 79 eomiddot 81 bull fill bull 83 S4 S5 gamiddot 87 $11middot89middot90
ssen William J 1935 41 08 Edward 199fl wlon Charles W~ 1877 79 dJip bullbull A Hood L911middot Ill ill son Ira It 1003 1Il1 Dr Ch~rl A 1917 19 ldru-th F 8 1923 26 tkius W ltwlie 1929middot31 then J M 1991 92 93 94
Ell ling B 0 1)15 bull 17 in William 1879 lH Icy Johu B lemiddotsa 95 lmick A L 1)21 23middot 25 27 29 a1middot m 35 37 as H 43 ohnrt1 K~IlII IM~ j~ 65 66middot67middot 8 middot59 T A C IRM 81 L~ltr Sarah M 1995middot00middot ~7
I e[nan Willim [ 1B68middot 71 middott W IL 1918 bull l7 1k1 EltllrMlI 1941 middot43 lignn Wlllinm r bullbull IS2 - 7l 74middot 7ii bull 75 77middot78middot~ middot60middot81middot82
1 T p WOG 07 1921 Zll nnon Daniel n 18nmiddot 79 rns ldliam 1891 98 Wslw R 1937 middot29
St~mHk~11 (t Fl bull )911 13 Stlnlh Anthyl8113middot 85 1899middot1901 SWftCl1elt fohn D t Ht7 ~ raquo Tun Cnml Donald 19lt17middot 49 Yaung Frank A bull Ig35 37
UPSHUR Arnold Gorum C 1917 )9middot21 middot2i Arnold SIpounduk W 188ii middot87 Carper William C 1871 72 larllSVlorth D1)l 1863middot60 Ismmiddot ia llIrnowofJ Ihamaa j lR81 middot81
middothklo J D 1 11)70 71 bull 72 73 bull 74 75middot76middot 78(1) 80
~Poer Willi3m lI~Oll I1abrLI William I r 19lt1lt lamplbott W D 1906middot
YOllng G 0 1935 agmiddot 41 bull 4~middot 4~ Young t (l 18ft5 97
WAYNE 1Iltgt c 101m A IH61 bull n5
Brubeck Hatro1d 1957 Bagetll Gohlr 1883 86 D31-by R D1 1973 74middot75middot 76 Ferguson Wnyn( 1877 79 GarrelL Ilooro 18117 bull 99 lJllIllt Homer 1981 82 - 83 lH 1989 90
91middot92 Jarren Mack G 1965middot86 87 - 8amp
McKown C11 1941 middot43middot 45 middot~7middot 19 51 53 56 - 56 959middot eo 61 bull 62 63 64 65 66middot 67 68 - 69 70 71middot 72
Millampnltl C Frank fIH2 36 - 37 middot31) Plymale Rtherl fl 19J13 IH bull 95 96 97 Prichard B J 1889 middot9] UOIdll Z Do l86g 70 Rollin Waluf 1971 bull 78middot79middot80
Sammons Uetilll-d 195amp Wilkineon Wmioll E 1872 n York John t 1901middot 03
~1mSTEl Cooper WCl~4L McCourt g Hlllrnril UIS [8 5~ eo
61 IJ2middot 63middot64middot61) 86middot A7 68middot69middot70 71middot72
Mortnn EskridI Ii 191517 19middot21
WETZEL Bo~B Th~dDlb M HM3 -- ~6~ J ~49 Oe 51 ~ gy oo~nmiddotsmiddotoomiddotmmiddotRmiddota middot64 11169middot 7f1-71 72
lliown J~hn R 1$7(1 71 Buri1 Wlt~r 1 lS17middot 19 Cbirk AndftlVl 1901 bull l3
4t)lpoundhran bullbull Jacaht laSi) HaJJ Sepiimilt 1872middot73 llillhl~nd Cooil B 1925 - 27 Huge John A 1895 07
HO~1utl D M bull 1SB~ lhrfhoma E 198084 8G 86 ili
88middot 89 Lowo LAvi Ai ) ~77 bull 79 Mucnauglran Don middotJr 1001 92 93 94 - 9
middot96-9 Mnm Rituben 1667 68
405
Mont~tney C Dick 1965 66middot67 68 MOlgal John 11 187 MoCakOy A hi H)ll 15
~NU D Ilalt~r 1913 Sun J W 1907 09
middotSnodacra Gln 1 SJ L Snyder L B 19lt17 middot89 bull
1homn bullbull Wa A 1 IlAV flO YIater J W 1889 middot91
1IlIRT r~mVlfn -fhnma5f A 1903 Cldwoll Cllorl bullbull T 1872middot 73 DeVore Jam M 1925middot27 Footer Alf~ IR~ middot119 Gm) It llplt 19L8 1 bull Lowther Millon R 1889 91 Rnbnw D A 1581 middot85
woon Deall Russell Q 1971 72middot73middot74 75middot
16 77 78 ampnu K D J 188middot 11 BOlltlmrl1 Ii S 1943 45 bull 47 49 Burdettlt Keith 19r bull B~ bull at bull 86 l7 88
89 bull flQ 91 92- ~ fi3 ~ 34
BlJrk Hobrt I rr 1969middot711 Caldwell CllnrloB T bull 1003 l5 Dern J Ftal1k 1~79 bull SOmiddot 81 12 19fi5
96 -)7 Dotenl1 Commndoa D) IS) - 99 GalWan Thomas 1l07 bull os GCbmiddotrIlabert r bullbull 191middot17
Handlan bullbull 1_ph M 1958middot M - 00 - 61 62 Hende n H C bullbull 183 - 95 Howurd CHnLon 1 1935middot37 lohn80n Oky 187 Lonard GorglgtK 1869middot70 rlOlni bullbull Gltr~c IS bull 77 MBh H a) 1923 25
Miller ldd~ H6J - 6-1 ~5 middot56middot67 68middot 00 Nle HwRnl F bullbull 1031 a3 pultkin W G 1911 13 Stallo r~dir R 191921 Ston William E 18113 GS Illt Jolon 91 bull 179 81
~S earing~n Andy 1951 58middot56middot G6 57 Whit bullbull AlurL 11 1927 29
WYOMING ~Bty BlIl- Wilyne It 19Jl middot92 - samiddot 01middot
95 9l 97 B~il~y It I) 1943 (~lr Mitchell 1870middot 71 Cook William H H 1895middot97 W()lmiddot 05
middotCook Jobo 1006 Hylton Tcy W 196middot S6 67 58 bull 69 bull
7071 7Z McDonaltl JSBIlC E 1872middot75 ML-GW Warm R 1)737475middot Inmiddot 77
7~ 79 30 81 82 bull 83 84 1llUldl Juliol Walko 1989middotmiddot 9 Wimana 11 O~ 1985middot 86 bull amp7 88
Wylie Wn] 193~ ]945 middot17middot4$ middot51 ii~middotllb 66 67 59middot60middot61middot621i3 S4
EXHIBIT
I
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
Frank Deem - Ballotpedia httpballotpediaorglwikiindexphptitle=Frank_Deemampprintable=ye
of3
Frank Deem
From Ballotpedia
Frank Deem (b March 20 1928) is a former Republican member of the West Virginia State Senate re presenting District 3 from 1994 to 2010 and from 1964 to 1978 Deem is a 2012 Republican candidate for District 3 of the West Virginia State Senate
Deem has served as a delegate in the West Virginia House of Delegates two times He served from 1954 to 1962 and then again from 1988 to 1990 Deem has also served two separate terms in the West Virginia State Senate His first term was from 1964 to 1978 and he has also served from 1994 to 2010
Deem has attended both West Virginia University and Mountain State Business College He went on to earn his BS from Marietta College
Contents
bull 1 Committee assignments bull 2 Elections
bull 21 2012 bull 222010 bull 232006
bull 3 Campaign donors bull 312006
bull 4 Personal bull 5 External links bull 6 References
Frank Deem West Virginia State Senate District 3
Fonner member
In office
1994-2010 1964 - 1978
Party Republican
Prior offices
West Virginia House of Delegates
1954 - 1962 1988-1990 Education
Bachelors Marietta College
Military service
Servicebranch United States Navy
Deem has served in the United States Navy He has also worked as an oil and gas producer as well as a businessman [1]
Committee assignments
Wile a member of the West Virginia State Senate Deem served on the following committees
bull Banking and Insurance Committee West Virginia Senate bull Energy Industry and Mining Committee West Virginia Senate bull Judiciary Committee West Virginia Senate bull Labor Committee West Vrrginia Senate bull Natural Resources Committee West Virginia Senate bull Pensions Committee West Virginia Senate
Elections
2012
See also West Virginia State Senate elections 2012
Deem is running in the 2012 election for West Virginia State Senate District 3 Deem is opposed by incumbent Donna J Boley in
the May 8 primary election The general election takes place on November 6 20 l2P1
2010
Frank Deem was defeated by David Nohe in the May 11 primary in his bid for re-election to the West Virginia State Senate
District 3 [3]
2006
On November 7 2006 Frank Deem won re-election to the West Virginia State Senate District 3 [41
Deem raised $17750 for his campaign [5] EXHIBIT
7 2202012429 PlV
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
Donna Boleys Historical Election Opponents
Year Office PrimaryGeneral OpponentHometown
1988 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1988 State Senate-3rd General Bruce MartinIFriendly (Tyler Co)
1992 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent
1992 State Senate-3rd General Ronald BlakenshipGrantsville (Calhoun)
1996 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 1996 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeiSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2000 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2000 State Senate-3rd General Louis F FladeSt Marys (pleasants Co) 2004 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2004 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd Primary No Opponent 2008 State Senate-3rd General No Opponent
EXHIBIT
I 8
