1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS...

52
Experimental Research Centre «ELECTRODYNAMICS» FUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC «NIIPT» DIGITAL-ANALOG-PHYSICAL COMPLEX Dr. Arkady H. Esipovich Deputy Head of Experimental Research Centre «Electrodynamics»

Transcript of 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS...

Page 1: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

Experimental Research Centre «ELECTRODYNAMICS»

FUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING

JSC «NIIPT» DIGITAL-ANALOG-PHYSICAL COMPLEX

Dr. Arkady H. EsipovichDeputy Head of Experimental Research Centre

«Electrodynamics»

Page 2: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

The unique JSC «NIIPT» digital-analog-physical complex is the largest electrodynamic model of power system in the

world 2

JSC «NIIPT» digital-analog-physical complex’scontrol room

Page 3: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

3

JSC «NIIPT» digital-analog-physical complex comprises:

80 generators andprime movers

150 power transformers,700 transmission lines

8 HVDC transmissions,shunt reactors, SVC, SC,

STATCOM166 complex loads

Control room

Page 4: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

В составе ЦАФК ОАО «НИИПТ» ─ крупнейшая в мире электродинамическая модель (ЭДМ) энергосистемы 4

Machine room

Page 5: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

5

Analog and digital parts of JSC «NIIPT» digital-analog-physical complex

• Adjustable analog and digital models of steam,hydraulic and gas turbines with its control systems

• Models of automatic voltage regulators of variousmodifications

• Devices of power system perturbation modeling andoperation of the local and centralized emergencyautomation complexes

• Transducers for electric parameters (I, U, P, Q, δ, s) thesignals of which are used for control, measurementand registration

• System of digital oscillographing

Page 6: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

6

Basic applications ofJSC «NIIPT» digital-analog-physical complex

• Researches of power systems of any level ofcomplexity

• Expertise of new automatic voltage regulators anddevelopment of recommendations about itsapplication in the unified power system (UPS) ofRussia

• Adjustment of automatic voltage regulators forconcrete generators in power system «on a turn-keybasis»

• Full-scale functioning tests of control devices,protection and automatics, systems of automated datamanagement (in real time)

Page 7: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

7

RESEARCHES OF POWER SYSTEMS OF ANY LEVEL OF COMPLEXITY

Page 8: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

8

The «Three Gorges» power system

HVDC

The world largest physical model was created in JSC «NIIPT»in 1997 for the «Three Gorges» (China) power system research

Power systemof Central China

Power system of Eastern China

Page 9: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

9

Power system of Central China

Page 10: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

10

Power system of Eastern China

Page 11: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

11

EXPERTISE OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS

GENERATORS AND DEVELOPMENT OF RECOMMENDATIONS

ABOUT ITS APPLICATION IN UPSOF RUSSIA

EXPERTISE

Page 12: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

12

Official letter «About applicationof automatic voltage regulators

for generators with the capacity 63–1200 МW»

Page 13: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

13

Typical test program for expertise of digital AVR of synchronous generators

Page 14: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

14

Minutes of the meeting

Page 15: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

15

Scientific and technical recommendations for AVR application

Page 16: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

16

Test scheme of the electrodynamic model for AVR expertise

~

АЭС ГЭС

~

~ ЭС

Г-2

31

Г-1

ГРЭС 500 1

Л 12

Л 15

Л 18 Л 6

Л 11 Л 17

3 2

4

Н-1_1

Д-3 R-3

Д-4 R-4

Л 8

КС-1_3 С1

КС-1_2 С1

КС-1_1 С1

КС

Д-5 R-5

Г-2сд ~ ~

Г-5 Г-3

Г-4

Т-2сд Т-2 Т-1

Т-5 Т-3

Т-4

Н-1_3

~

Page 17: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

17

Test scheme of the electrodynamic model.Frequency characteristics

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4

Частота, Гц

Амплитуда (о.е.)

Полная схема

Ремонт ВЛ 1-5 (1,2)

Ремонт ВЛ 1-4 (1), 1-5 (1,2), 3-5.

Page 18: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

18

Test scheme of the electrodynamic model. Generators’ areas of oscillatory stability

Page 19: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

19

The test scheme of the electrodynamic model completely meetsthe demands of typical test program for expertise of digital AVR

The following AVR were examined in the test scheme:• ARV-М, АRV-2М, ARV-3М (JSC «Power Machines», Russia)• АVR-2 (JSC «Energocomplect», Russia)• UNITROL-5000 (ABB, Switzerland)• DESC-400 (Basler electric, USA)• ARV-NL (JSC «Elsib», Russia)• KOSUR-C (JSC «NIIElectromash», Russia)• REM and REM-700 (JSC «Ruselprom-Electromash», Russia)• P320 AVR V2 and CONTROGEN V3 (ALSTOM, France)

April 2010 – tests of UNITROL-6000 (ABB).

The Protocol about the test of SIEMENS AG AVR in NIIPT’s scheme has been signed. Negotiations are carrying out with:

• AEG (Germany)• JSC «Preobrazovatel» (Ukraine)

Test scheme of the electrodynamic model

Page 20: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

20

АRV-2М tests(JSC «Power Machines», Russia)

АRV-2М tests

During tests

Page 21: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

21

UNITROL-5000 tests (ABB, Switzerland)

Tests of UNITROL-5000regulator

Connection of UNITROL-5000 regulatorto the test scheme of the physical model

of the power system

Page 22: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

22

ARV-NL tests (JSC «ELSIB»)

ARV-NL tests

Discussion of the tests results

Page 23: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

23

DECS-400 tests (Basler electric, USA)

Regulator DECS-400 tests

Team of testers

Page 24: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

24

KOSUR-C tests (NIIElectromash, Russia)

Regulator KOSUR-C tests

Preparations before the experiment

Page 25: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

25

P320 AVR V2 and CONTROGEN V3 tests(ALSTOM, France)

P320 AVR V2 and CONTROGEN V3

Discussion of the experiment

Page 26: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

The business visit of Siemens AG (Germany)and ENKA (Turkey) to NIIPT on 29 October, 2009

Getting acquainted with the Centre

Discussion of the order for regulator’s test in the «Yayva TPP» project

262626

Page 27: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

27

Stages of the expertise.Program of tests

• Development of the individual test program for AVR• Holding tests• Development of the scientific and technical

recommendations concerning AVR application in UPS ofRussia

PROGRAM OF TESTS

PSS efficiency is checked by means of oscillation damping estimation during the small-signal disturbances.

Various operating conditionsof generators/station are examined.

STAGES OF THE EXPERTISE

Page 28: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

28

Estimation of PSS2B UNITROL-5000 (ABB)settings quality by the character of instability

Aperiodic character of instability PSS is switching off

Page 29: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

29

Estimation of postemergency oscillations damping quality

Estimation of postemergency oscillations damping quality andperformance capabilities of the power part of excitation systems arecarried out during rated disturbances, according to «Method powersystem stability directions» (Order of Department of Energy RussianFederation):

• Emergency power imbalances

• Transmission line tripping

• 1-phase, 2-phase (to earth), 3-phase short circuits withtransmission line tripping

• Successful 1-phase and 3-phase automatic reclosing

• Unsuccessful automatic reclosing on transmission linesunder all kinds of short circuits with one phase ofa breaker failure and breaker fail protection operation

Page 30: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

30

2-phase short circuit on line (1−4) near APP 500 kVbuses with the line switching. Pgen=Prated.

PSS is in operation. (Unitrol-5000)

Page 31: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

31

2-phase short circuit on transmission line near APP buses with breaker fail protection operation

(DECS-400)

Page 32: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

32

Under excitation limiter test (DECS-400)

Entering UEL zone during the slow voltage increasing in the system

Page 33: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

33

Under excitation limiter test.(CONTROGEN V3, ALSTOM)

Entering and leaving UEL zone during the switching on(and off in 9 sec) the capacitors on the APP buses

Page 34: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

34

Over excitation limiter tests (АRV-МА)

Проверка работы ограничителя тока ротора в оси Qпри программной форсировке возбуждения.

1. Ufq_Г8 2. Ifq_Г8

9876543210

Uf,If,о.е.Uf,If,о.е.Uf,If,о.е.2.7

Uf,If,о.е.

2.4

Uf,If,о.е.

2.1

Uf,If,о.е.

1.8

Uf,If,о.е.

1.5

Uf,If,о.е.

1.2

Uf,If,о.е.

0.9

Uf,If,о.е.

0.6

Uf,If,о.е.

0.3

Uf,If,о.е.

0

1

1

1

1

2

2

2

2

Page 35: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

35

AVR-2 efficiency check

Page 36: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

36

Check the efficiency of the AVR operation in the scheme of the doubled unit

~ Г211

ГРЭС

~ Г112 Uг

U_500 кВ

Рн

~ Рн

МГ-55 МГ-47

1

5 МГ-7

Г511

Page 37: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

37

Check the efficiency of the AVR operation in the scheme of the doubled unit

(CONTROGEN V3, ALSTOM)

Voltage set point (of one of the generators in doubled unit) is increased for some time in the underexcitation mode

Page 38: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

38

Development and verificationof regulator digital models

The aim isto develop adequate digital models of AVR and its transfer to System Operator for AVR

settings quality check

Page 39: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

39

Model of the regulator PЗ20 AVR V2 (ALSTOM)

Mathematical model of voltage regulator (type ST7B)

Digital model of voltage regulator (type ST7B)implemented in EUROSTAG

4

GRV1

16

03 фазы

p.u.

9

03 фазы

p.u.

1

03 фазы

p.u.

2

0

11-1

11

^U0

1PRV6TRV6

25

^U0

26

0

PSS_OUT1

5

0

1TRV1TRV3

10

01TRV2

8

_EFD

EFD

12

EMAX

13

EMIN

76

0

1

1

15

_EFD

14

0

1

1

1

3

0.866

C:\Eurostag43\Work\ALSTOM\ALSTOM_REG\alst_avr.frm

Page 40: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

40

Model of the regulator PЗ20 AVR V2 (ALSTOM)

Mathematical model of power system stabilizer (type PSS2B)3

_OMEGATW1TW1

6

^P0TW3TW3

14

0

1T3T4

1

0.

OMEGA1

2

03 фазы

о.е. (SN)

13

0

1T1T2

4

0TW2TW2

7

0KS2T7

8

0

1T8T9

9

01T9

10

01T9

11

01T9

12

0

1-1

15

0

1T11T21

16

0

1T31T41

18

0

PSS_OUT

MXSP

-MXSP

5

0

1KS3

17

KS1

19

0

1

C:\Eurostag43\Work\ALSTOM\ALSTOM_REG\als t_pss.frm

Digital model of the power system stabilizer (type PSS2B)implemented in EUROSTAG

Page 41: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

41

Regulator PЗ20 AVR V2 (ALSTOM)model verification

Phase-frequency characteristic

ST7B PSS2BΔP stabilization channel

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Частота, Гц

Амплитуда, о.е. Регулятор возбуждения

Цифровая модель регулятора возбуждения

0

40

80

120

160

200

240

0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1

Частота, Гц

Фаза, ° Регулятор возбуждения

Цифровая модель регулятора возбуждения

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Частота, Гц

Амплитуда, о.е.Регулятор возбуждения

Цифровая модель регулятора возбуждения

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Частота, Гц

Фаза, ° Регулятор возбуждения

Цифровая модель регулятора возбуждения

PSS2BΔω stabilization channel

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Частота, Гц

Амплитуда, о.е.Регулятор возбуждения

Цифровая модель регулятора возбуждения

Amplitude-frequency characteristic

-250

-200

-150

-100

-50

0

50

100

150

200

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Частота, Гц

Фаза, ° Регулятор возбуждения

Цифровая модель регулятора возбуждения

Page 42: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

42

METHODOLOGY OF DIGITAL AVR TESTS USING ELECTRO DYNAMIC SIMULATOR (EDS).

AVR ADJUSTMENT FOR CONCRETE POWER INSTALLATIONS «ON A TURN KEY BASIS»

METHODOLOGY OF DIGITAL AVR TESTS

Page 43: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

43

Methodology of digital AVR tests

Methodology comprises the following steps:

• Using EDS, physical model of the power systemis created

• Program of tests is developed• AVR and PSS tests and adjustments «on the turn

key basis»

Page 44: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

44

Physical model of Siberian power system implemented for digital AVR tests

of Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP

Новокузнецкая

Алтай

Беловская

Беловская ГРЭС

Ново-Анжерская

Томск

Саяно-Шушенская ГЭС

Майнская ГЭС

Березовская ГРЭС

Означенное

Абакан

Итат

Назаровская 220

Красноярская ГЭС

Назаровская 500 Красноярская ГЭС-500 Красноярская

С Маг 220

ВЛ 541,542

ВЛ 543, 544

ВЛ 547

ВЛ 546

Г 1 (МГ-62) Г 2

(МГ-65) Г 3 (МГ-61) Г 4

(МГ- 56)

Page 45: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

45

Program of system tests and AVR adjustments

It comprises:

• Estimation of oscillation damping in different schemes andconditions of power system during small-signal disturbancesand AVR settings adjustment

• Checking AVR efficiency during rated emergencydisturbances

• Estimation of intraplant oscillation damping (for multiunitpower stations)

• Checking AVR operation in specific conditions duringlarge-signal disturbances

Program of system tests and AVR adjustments iscoordinated with JSC «SO UPS» and approved by Customer.

Page 46: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

46

Character of instability (transmission capacity limit is reached)

1. Угол У-И ГЭС - Красноярск 2. Р_У-И ГЭС-500 (Г1) 3. Р_У-И ГЭС-500 (Г2) 4. Р_ ВЛ-572 (У-И ГЭС - БПП)

t,c.t,c.t,c.4 t,c.3.5 t,c.3 t,c.2.5 t,c.2 t,c.1.5 t,c.1 t,c.0.5 t,c.0

P,МВтP,МВт б,гр.200

б,гр.

180

б,гр.

160

б,гр.

140

б,гр.

120

б,гр.

100

б,гр.

80

б,гр.

60

б,гр.

40

б,гр.

20

б,гр.

0

б,гр.

-20

б,гр.

-40

б,гр.

-60

б,гр.

-80

б,гр.

-100

б,гр.

-120

б,гр.

-140

б,гр.

-160

1 11

1

1

2 2 2

22

3 3 3

33

4 4 4

4

4

P,МВтP,МВтP,МВт2 500

P,МВт

2 250

P,МВт

2 000

P,МВт

1 750

P,МВт

1 500

P,МВт

1 250

P,МВт

1 000

P,МВт

750

P,МВт

500

P,МВт

250

P,МВт

0

P,МВт

-250

P,МВт

-500

P,МВт

-750

P,МВт

-1 000

P,МВт

-1 250

P,МВт

-1 500

P,МВт

-1 750

P,МВт

-2 000

Character of instability during the increasingof power flow from Ust-Ilimskaya HPP

to Krasnoyarsk power system. Lines 560, 571,570, 569 are switched off

1. Угол Бр.ГЭС-Красноярск 2. Угол Бр. ГЭС - У-И ГЭС 3. Р_У-И ГЭС (Г1) 4. Р_У-И ГЭС-500 (Г2) 5. Р_У-И ГЭС-220 (Г3) 6. Р ВЛ-572 (У-И ГЭС - БПП) 7. P ВЛ-571 (У-И ГЭС - Бр. ГЭС)

t,c.t,c.t,c.6 t,c.5 t,c.4 t,c.3 t,c.2 t,c.1 t,c.0

P,МВтP,МВт б,гр.180

б,гр.

160

б,гр.

140

б,гр.

120

б,гр.

100

б,гр.

80

б,гр.

60

б,гр.

40

б,гр.

20

б,гр.

0

б,гр.

-20

б,гр.

-40

б,гр.

-60

б,гр.

-80

б,гр.

-100

б,гр.

-120

б,гр.

-140

б,гр.

-160

б,гр.

-180

1 11

1

1

2 22

22

3 3 3

3

34 4 4

4

45 5 5

5

5

6 6 66

6

7 7 7

7

7

P,МВтP,МВтP,МВт4 500

P,МВт

4 000

P,МВт

3 500

P,МВт

3 000

P,МВт

2 500

P,МВт

2 000

P,МВт

1 500

P,МВт

1 000

P,МВт

500

P,МВт

0

P,МВт

-500

P,МВт

-1 000

P,МВт

-1 500

P,МВт

-2 000

P,МВт

-2 500

P,МВт

-3 000

P,МВт

-3 500

P,МВт

-4 000

P,МВт

-4 500

Character of instability during the increasingof power flow from Krasnoyarsk power system

to Bratskaya HPP. Lines 560, 570, 569are switched off

Efficiency of the chosen AVR settings

Page 47: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

47

1. Угол СШГЭС-Алтай 2. U СШ ГЭС-500 3. Р ВЛ СШ ГЭС - Новокузнецкая (1,2) 4. Uв СШ ГЭС (Г1)

t,c.t,c.t,c.7 t,c.6 t,c.5 t,c.4 t,c.3 t,c.2 t,c.1 t,c.0

Uв.,о.е.Uв.,о.е. б,гр.150

б,гр.

135

б,гр.

120

б,гр.

105

б,гр.

90

б,гр.

75

б,гр.

60

б,гр.

45

б,гр.

30

б,гр.

15

б,гр.

0

б,гр.

-15

б,гр.

-30

б,гр.

-45

б,гр.

-60

1 11 1 1

22

2 2 23

33 3 3

4

4

44 4

U,кВU,кВU,кВ750

U,кВ

675

U,кВ

600

U,кВ

525

U,кВ

450

U,кВ

375

U,кВ

300

U,кВ

225

U,кВ

150

U,кВ

75

U,кВ

0

U,кВ

-75

U,кВ

-150

U,кВ

-225

U,кВ

-300

P,МВтP,МВтP,МВт1 500

P,МВт

1 350

P,МВт

1 200

P,МВт

1 050

P,МВт

900

P,МВт

750

P,МВт

600

P,МВт

450

P,МВт

300

P,МВт

150

P,МВт

0

P,МВт

-150

P,МВт

-300

P,МВт

-450

P,МВт

-600

Uв.,о.е.Uв.,о.е.Uв.,о.е.3

Uв.,о.е.

2.7

Uв.,о.е.

2.4

Uв.,о.е.

2.1

Uв.,о.е.

1.8

Uв.,о.е.

1.5

Uв.,о.е.

1.2

Uв.,о.е.

0.9

Uв.,о.е.

0.6

Uв.,о.е.

0.3

Uв.,о.е.

0

Uв.,о.е.

-0.3

Uв.,о.е.

-0.6

Uв.,о.е.

-0.9

Uв.,о.е.

-1.2

Single phase short circuit near 500 kV busesof Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP

with an unsuccessful single phase automatic reclosing of the line

1. Угол б У-И ГЭС - Красноярск 2. U У-И ГЭС-500 3. Р_У-И ГЭС-500 (Г1) 4. Р ВЛ-572 (У-И ГЭС - БПП) 5. P ВЛ-571 (У-И ГЭС - Бр.ГЭС) 6. P ВЛ-569,570 (Бр.ГЭС-БПП)

t,c.t,c.t,c.13.5 t,c.12 t,c.10.5 t,c.9 t,c.7.5 t,c.6 t,c.4.5 t,c.3 t,c.1.5 t,c.0

P,МВтP,МВт б,гр.75

б,гр.

67.5

б,гр.

60

б,гр.

52.5

б,гр.

45

б,гр.

37.5

б,гр.

30

б,гр.

22.5

б,гр.

15

б,гр.

7.5

б,гр.

0

б,гр.

-7.5

б,гр.

-15

б,гр.

-22.5

б,гр.

-30

б,гр.

-37.5

б,гр.

-45

б,гр.

-52.5

б,гр.

-60

1

11 1 1

2 2 2 2 2

3

3 3 3 3

4 44 4 4

5

5 5 5 5

6

6 6 6 6

U,кВU,кВU,кВ750

U,кВ

675

U,кВ

600

U,кВ

525

U,кВ

450

U,кВ

375

U,кВ

300

U,кВ

225

U,кВ

150

U,кВ

75

U,кВ

0

U,кВ

-75

U,кВ

-150

U,кВ

-225

U,кВ

-300

U,кВ

-375

U,кВ

-450

U,кВ

-525

U,кВ

-600

P,МВтP,МВтP,МВт2 500

P,МВт

2 250

P,МВт

2 000

P,МВт

1 750

P,МВт

1 500

P,МВт

1 250

P,МВт

1 000

P,МВт

750

P,МВт

500

P,МВт

250

P,МВт

0

P,МВт

-250

P,МВт

-500

P,МВт

-750

P,МВт

-1 000

P,МВт

-1 250

P,МВт

-1 500

P,МВт

-1 750

P,МВт

-2 000

Double phase short circuit near 500 kV busesof Ust-Ilimskaya HPP with a closing

of the line 571, breaker failure

Estimation of AVR efficiency during rated disturbances (emergency automation operation

is taken into account)

Page 48: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

48

Estimation of AVR efficiency operation during liquidation of system failures' consequences

1. Р ВЛ СШ ГЭС-Новокузнецкая 2. iв СШ ГЭС (Г1) 3. Uв СШ ГЭС (Г1) 4. U Г1 СШ ГЭС 5. Угол СШ ГЭС-Иркутск

t,c.t,c.t,c.9 t,c.8 t,c.7 t,c.6 t,c.5 t,c.4 t,c.3 t,c.2 t,c.1 t,c.0

б,гр.б,гр. P,МВт2 000

P,МВт

1 800

P,МВт

1 600

P,МВт

1 400

P,МВт

1 200

P,МВт

1 000

P,МВт

800

P,МВт

600

P,МВт

400

P,МВт

200

P,МВт

0

P,МВт

-200

P,МВт

-400

P,МВт

-600

P,МВт

-800

P,МВт

-1 000

P,МВт

-1 200

P,МВт

-1 400

P,МВт

-1 600

P,МВт

-1 800

P,МВт

-2 000

1

1

1 1 1

22

22 2

3

3

3

3

3

4 4 4 4 4

55

5

55

i,о.е.i,о.е.i,о.е.2

i,о.е.

1.8

i,о.е.

1.6

i,о.е.

1.4

i,о.е.

1.2

i,о.е.

1

i,о.е.

0.8

i,о.е.

0.6

i,о.е.

0.4

i,о.е.

0.2

i,о.е.

0

i,о.е.

-0.2

i,о.е.

-0.4

i,о.е.

-0.6

i,о.е.

-0.8

i,о.е.

-1

i,о.е.

-1.2

i,о.е.

-1.4

i,о.е.

-1.6

i,о.е.

-1.8

i,о.е.

-2

u,о.еu,о.еu,о.е3

u,о.е

2.7

u,о.е

2.4

u,о.е

2.1

u,о.е

1.8

u,о.е

1.5

u,о.е

1.2

u,о.е

0.9

u,о.е

0.6

u,о.е

0.3

u,о.е

0

u,о.е

-0.3

u,о.е

-0.6

u,о.е

-0.9

u,о.е

-1.2

u,о.е

-1.5

u,о.е

-1.8

u,о.е

-2.1

u,о.е

-2.4

u,о.е

-2.7

u,о.е

-3

б,гр.б,гр.б,гр.150

б,гр.

135

б,гр.

120

б,гр.

105

б,гр.

90

б,гр.

75

б,гр.

60

б,гр.

45

б,гр.

30

б,гр.

15

б,гр.

0

б,гр.

-15

б,гр.

-30

б,гр.

-45

б,гр.

-60

б,гр.

-75

б,гр.

-90

б,гр.

-105

б,гр.

-120

б,гр.

-135

б,гр.

-150

Liquidation of the asynchronous motion.Operation of ARV-M regulator installed on Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP

Page 49: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

49

Stepwise reconstruction of power station

1. U У-И ГЭС-500 2. Р Г1 (АРВ-М) 3. Q Г1 (АРВ-М) 4. Р Г2 (АРВ-СД) 5. Q Г2 (АРВ-СД)

t,c.t,c.t,c.9 t,c.8 t,c.7 t,c.6 t,c.5 t,c.4 t,c.3 t,c.2 t,c.1 t,c.0

P,Q,МВ*AP,Q,МВ*A U,кВ750

U,кВ

675

U,кВ

600

U,кВ

525

U,кВ

450

U,кВ

375

U,кВ

300

U,кВ

225

U,кВ

150

U,кВ

75

U,кВ

0

1 1 1 1 1

22

2 2 2

3

3

3 3 3

44

4 4 4

55

5 5 5

P,Q,МВ*AP,Q,МВ*AP,Q,МВ*A300

P,Q,МВ*A

270

P,Q,МВ*A

240

P,Q,МВ*A

210

P,Q,МВ*A

180

P,Q,МВ*A

150

P,Q,МВ*A

120

P,Q,МВ*A

90

P,Q,МВ*A

60

P,Q,МВ*A

30

P,Q,МВ*A

0

Single phase short circuit (t = 0.12 seс) on 500 kV buses of the doubled unit of Ust-Ilim HPP.Combined operation of ARV-M and ARV-CD

1. U У-И ГЭС-500 2. Р Г1 (АРВ-М) 3. Q Г1 (АРВ-М) 4. Р Г2 (АРВ-СД) 5. Q Г2 (АРВ-СД)

t,c.t,c.t,c.18 t,c.16 t,c.14 t,c.12 t,c.10 t,c.8 t,c.6 t,c.4 t,c.2 t,c.0

P,Q,МВAP,Q,МВA U,кВ675

U,кВ

600

U,кВ

525

U,кВ

450

U,кВ

375

U,кВ

300

U,кВ

225

U,кВ

150

U,кВ

75

U,кВ

0

U,кВ

-75

U,кВ

-150

1 1 1 1 1

2 2 2 2 2

3

3

3 3 3

4 4 4 4 4

5

5

5 5 5

P,Q,МВAP,Q,МВAP,Q,МВA270

P,Q,МВA

240

P,Q,МВA

210

P,Q,МВA

180

P,Q,МВA

150

P,Q,МВA

120

P,Q,МВA

90

P,Q,МВA

60

P,Q,МВA

30

P,Q,МВA

0

P,Q,МВA

-30

P,Q,МВA

-60

Voltage setpoint of ARV-M is changed on 5%in 5 sec. Combined operation of ARV-M and

ARV-CD in the scheme of doubled unit of Ust-Ilim HPP

Page 50: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

50

Tuning on the «turn key» bases is producedfor significant objects of the power system

(HPPs and NPPs of large rated power)

• Sayano-Shushenskaya HPP (6.4 GW)• Ust-Ilimskaya HPP (3.5 GW)• Zagorskaya HAPP (1.2 GW)• Kolskaya NPP (1.44 GW)

• Kalininskay NPP (3 GW) – January 2010• Boguchanskaya HPP (3 GW) – February 2010• Smolenskaya NPP (3 GW) – March 2010

Page 51: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

51

Conclusions

Tests held according to the «Program…» provide AVRand PSS efficiency assessment and their adaptationto the conditions of operation in UPS of Russia.

Correctness and efficiency of AVR and PSS tuning ischecked using digital and physical models of the powersystems.

Page 52: 1стр Functioning tests of automatic voltage regulators of ... · PDF fileFUNCTIONING TESTS (EXPERTISE) OF AUTOMATIC VOLTAGE REGULATORS OF SYNCHRONOUS GENERATORS USING JSC ... (DECS-400)

52

Thank you for your attention!

Please, your questions!