1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse...

21
1 Forced Forced decaying decaying Helical – Helical – nonhelical nonhelical
  • date post

    15-Jan-2016
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    212
  • download

    0

Transcript of 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse...

Page 1: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

1

Forced – decayingForced – decayingH

elic

al –

non

helic

alH

elic

al –

non

helic

al

Page 2: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

2

Points of the talkPoints of the talk

• Resistive effects during inverse transfer

• B-field does not care about irrotational part

• Magnetic helicity from 1-D data sets

Page 3: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

3

(i)(i) Small scale dynamoSmall scale dynamo

(i)Exponential growth

(ii)Growth rate proportional to Rm1/2

(iii)Kazantsev spectrum

Page 4: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

4

(ii) Large-scale dynamo(ii) Large-scale dynamo

• Similar to SS dynamo at early times

• Inverse cascade/transfer behavior

• Resistively slow saturation (!)

Page 5: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

5

(iii) Non-helical decay(iii) Non-helical decay

• Fast decay at small scales

• Slight increase for small k and strong B

Page 6: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

6

(iv) Helical decay(iv) Helical decay

• Inverse cascade on large scales

Christensson et al.(2001, PRE 64, 056405)

Initial slope E~k4

Page 7: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

7

Revised helical decay lawRevised helical decay law

HkH H22

sI tHE 22/1/||

H not exactly constant

rHH ttkk 00 /Assume power law, not const

H follows power law iff r=1/2; thenstH 2

2diff

20

20 / HHH tktks

M. Christensson, M. Hindmarsh, A. Brandenburg: 2005, AN 326, 393M. Christensson, M. Hindmarsh, A. Brandenburg: 2005, AN 326, 393

Page 8: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

8

Dynamos: small-scale vs large-scaleDynamos: small-scale vs large-scale

B-scale larger than U-scale

B-scale smaller than U-scale

Wavenumber=1/scale

energy

injectionscale

Page 9: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

9

SS and LS dynamos

Page 10: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

10

Small-scale vs large-scale dynamoSmall-scale vs large-scale dynamo

Page 11: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

11

Inverse cascadeInverse cascade

Page 12: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

12

Resistive effects on inverse transfer

2/1frms

2/1

1rms

2/1

2/1

tkut

tuRk

tk

mm

m

Page 13: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

13

Application to phase transitionsApplication to phase transitions

• Forcing purely potential• No vorticity production?

ln2

2

Sωωuω

BBuB

t

t

Page 14: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

14

Gaussian expansion wavesGaussian expansion waves

Page 15: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

15

No dynamo from potential flowsNo dynamo from potential flows

No dynamo actionin nearly potentialflows (at least notfo far)

Page 16: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

16

No vorticity eitherNo vorticity either

ln2

2

Sωωuω

BBuB

t

t

Page 17: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

17

Vorticity productionVorticity production

• if 2/urms kf > 1

• if Ma > 0

Page 18: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

18

B field ignores irrotational partB field ignores irrotational part

Page 19: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

19

Helicity from 1-D data setsHelicity from 1-D data sets

)()( xBxBM jiij

)(

)()(

kHki

kEkkkM

kijk

jiijij

)()( xBxBM jiij

)()()( rxxr jiij BBM

Matthaeus et al. (1982) Measure correlation function

In Fourier space, calculatemagnetic energy and helicity spectra

Should be done with Ulysses data away from equatorial plane

Page 20: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

20

Bi-helical fields from UlyssesBi-helical fields from Ulysses

• Taylor hypothesis• Broad k bins• Southern latitude

with opposite sign• Small/large distances• Positive H at large k• Break point with

distance to larger k

Page 21: 1 Forced – decaying Helical – nonhelical. 2 Points of the talk Resistive effects during inverse transfer B-field does not care about irrotational part.

21

ConclusionsConclusions

• Resistive effects during inverse transfer

• B-field does not care about irrotational part

• Magnetic helicity from 1-D data sets