1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West...

53
FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA

Transcript of 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West...

Page 1: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

1

FESTIVAL RETAILING

Eithel M. Simpson

Tanuja R. Sheth

Alastair M. MorrisonPurdue University,

West Lafayette, Indiana

USA

Page 2: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

2

Introduction

Leisure consumption activities & events amusement parks athletic events county fair festivals

Page 3: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

3

Research Background

Organizational & Management needs Economic Impact Products (e.g..: crafts) Tourist Attraction factors

Page 4: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

4

Problem no description of purchase behavior for

non-food products an unclear relationship between:

festival visitor festival retailer

selling tangible non-food products

Page 5: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

5

PurposeTo examine the relationship between

festival non-food retailers and festival visitors,

with specific focus on

the purchase behavior of

the festival visitors

Page 6: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

6

Premise

There are certain characteristics of both the festival and the festival retailer that influences and/or motivates festival visitors to purchase items.

Page 7: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

7

Conceptual Framework

Getz’s model Perspectives of Festivals & Special Events

Page 8: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

Event Tourism Attractions Catalysts Image makers Economic impact

Visitor experiences• Essential services

• Generic and targeted benefits

Tangible product• Event programs

• Packages and tours

• MERCHANDISE

Organizers• Resources

• Survival

• Growth

• Community support

Social and cultural• Celebration of culture

• Leisure and amenities

• Community development

• Social, cultural, health improvements

Environment• Sustainable development

• Quality of the human and natural environments

Fostering and attracting events

Assistanceto organizers

Target marketing

Consumption of events

Volunteer support and attendance

Production of events

Host-guest relations Community relations

Getz’s modelPerspectives of Festivals & Special Events

Getz (1991) Festivals, Special Events, and Tourism pg. 41

Page 9: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

9

Methodology Case Study Focus Sample

Page 10: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

10

Case Study: The Festival

FEAST OF THE HUNTER’S MOON 2-day Historical festival Lafayette, Indiana

Page 11: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

11

Sample Participants

1. Tourism Consumer (Festival Visitor)

2. Tourism Retailer (Festival Vendor)

Page 12: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

12

Tourism Consumer Define & identify example:

Festival Visitor

Page 13: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

13

Festival Visitor PROFILE (n = 496)

Age (17-74 years- 34% 35-44years) Education (47% college degrees) Income (34%= $30-$50,000) trip origination (6 state area)

Page 14: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

14

Tourism Retailer

Define & Identify Example:

Festival non-food Retailer

Page 15: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

15

Festival Vendor Category Profiles

Traditional Craftsmen (n=124 ) Merchants (n=55) Blanket Traders (n=63)

Page 16: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

16

Licensed Festival Products

Baskets - Beads - Brooms- Blankets - Dolls - Calligraphy - Carvings - Coopers - Cordwainers - shawls rugs

ropes - guns - feathers - Decoys - Drums - Indian items Leather crafts - Cordwainers Glassware - Tinware -

Pewterware - Pottery - Quillwork Soaps & herbs

Lace - tatting - musical instrument - furs

toys - ironwork - jewelry - candles - clothes

(not a complete list)

Page 17: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

17

Methodology

Data Collection visitor generated responses visitor intercept interviews site observations of festival

Data Analysis uncover themes, patterns

Page 18: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

18

Data Collection

Methods Used: 1. intercept surveys 2. visitor intercept interviews 3. site observations

Page 19: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

19

Data Analysis

Quantitative Data descriptive statistics cross-tabs

Qualitative Data content analysis for themes & patterns validation

Page 20: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

20

1. Intercept Survey

Variables:

purchase behavior

purchase targets

purchase reasons

Page 21: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

21

1. Survey Variables(quantitative data)

Festival visitor (n=496) purchase behavior purchase target purchase reasons

Page 22: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

22

Purchased Behavior66%

ITEMS purchased Gifts - 22% souvenirs - 40%

purchase TARGETS Self 23% family members 22% self & family 9 % total: 54%

Page 23: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

23

Purchases:Cross-Tab analysis

significant results income education age

Page 24: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

24

2. Visitor Intercept Interviews

Page 25: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

25

2. Interview Variables(qualitative data - n=21)

Festival Visitor Purchase Target Motivations

purchases no purchases

Influences Planned purchase Unplanned purchase

Festival Retailer Role Characteristics Attitudes Toward...

Page 26: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

26

Purchase Target

Self Family Members:

Mom Daughter Children

Page 27: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

27

Product Purchasesmotivations

PRODUCT EXTENDING MEMORY OF FESTIVAL OTHERS SELF

Page 28: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

28

No Product Purchasesmotivations

FESTIVAL FESTIVAL RETAILER PRICE SELF

Page 29: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

29

Purchase Influences

Unplanned (n=9) IMPULSE PRODUCT

style of item liked item souvenir value

FESTIVAL RETAILER Tippecanoe County

Historical Assoc.. booth OTHER

son

Planned (n=5) had previous experience at

festival (4) wanted information on

Native Americans

Page 30: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

30

Retailer Role

COMMERCIAL ROLE N0N-COMMERCIAL ROLE

Page 31: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

31

Important Retailer Characteristics

PRODUCT: FESTIVAL RETAILER

Page 32: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

32

Attitudes toward Retailers

Positive attitudes Negative attitudes

Page 33: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

33

3. Site Observations

Page 34: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

34

3. Site Observations

Purpose Themes

Page 35: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

35

Crowd Behaviors

group movement random barriers central areas for rest

Page 36: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

36

Retailer Interaction

customer attraction artisan credibility & demonstrations booth vending space

Page 37: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

37

Shopping Environment

product accessibility booth size

Page 38: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

38

Decision-Making

merchandise selection “on-the-go” purchases browsing behavior

Page 39: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

39

Summary of Findings

festival visitor purchase behavior influences and motivations interaction between festival visitor and

festival retailer

Page 40: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

40

Implications of Findings

1. Festival Visitors 2. Festival Retailers 3. The Festival itself

Page 41: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

41

Purchase Behaviors Motivation & Influences Retailer Interaction

1. Implications from Visitors

Page 42: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

42

Purchase Behaviors

attracted to booth from crowd influence stands back and watches discusses purchase with “other” visitor makes purchases “on-the-go” browsers

Page 43: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

43

Motivations & Influences

for self & family members to extend memory of event to learn about event wants product authenticity wants reasonable prices

Page 44: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

44

Interaction with Retailer

important & integral to event ample space & accessibility credible & interesting artisans maximum number of customers delays verbal interaction

Page 45: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

45

2. Implications for Festival Retailers

THEMESProduct

Promotions

Place

Price

Page 46: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

46

Product

attracts attention accessible interaction authenticity quality represents event

Page 47: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

47

Promotions

authenticity of claims accurate reflection of event interactive demonstrations artisan credibility

Page 48: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

48

Place

booth site position booth size

Page 49: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

49

Price

broad price range set price ceiling

Page 50: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

50

3. Implications for Festival

Saturation level commercialism vs festival purpose space

pathways dispersion browsing

Page 51: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

51

Limitations

Methodology Narrow Focus Testable Hypotheses Generated Statistical Base

Page 52: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

52

Future Issues

FESTIVAL economic impact retailers mix

FESTIVAL VISITOR purchase decisions vs activity participation

FESTIVAL RETAILERS competitive environment success & failure factors “temporary”ness

Page 53: 1 FESTIVAL RETAILING Eithel M. Simpson Tanuja R. Sheth Alastair M. Morrison Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana USA.

53

Impact of StudyProvides a glimpse of

consumer behavior at festivals with

non-food retail retailers and the

influences, motivations and characteristics

that lead to purchases.