1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific...

31
22/nov/2013

Transcript of 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific...

Page 1: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

122/nov/2013

Page 2: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

2

Workshop GoalsWorkshop Goals To present some tips for writing

good paper bodies for scientific papers

To gain hands-on experience applying some of the tips to real examples

Page 3: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

3

Four Sections Scheme

Paper BodyPaper Body

Page 4: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

4

2. Describe the problem/question to be solved

3. Describe your solution

4. Evaluation and Results

5. Related Work and Discussion

Four Sections SchemeFour Sections Scheme

Page 5: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

5

Section 2

2. Describe the problem/question to be solvedn(based on related works)

Why is it a problem/question?

Why is it important to solve it?

Background/research context

Page 6: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

6

Section 33. Describe your solution

You are convincing the PC member that your solution really could solve the problem/question

This section is sometimes supplemented with a section describing implementation details

Page 7: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

7

Page 8: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

8

Page 9: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

9

Page 10: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

10

Section 5

5. Related Work and Discussion:

Describe what other people have done in the area and compare with your work/results

Convince others that what you have done is novel and relevant

Page 11: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

11

Section 55. Related Work and Discussion:

(cont.)

What might the answer imply and why does it matter?

How does it fit in with what other researchers have found?

What are the perspectives for future research?

Page 12: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

12

Section 55. Related Work and Discussion:

(cont.)

What might the answer imply and why does it matter? Conclusion

How does it fit in with what other researchers have found?

What are the perspectives for future research? Conclusion

Page 13: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

13

Page 14: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

14

Page 15: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

15

Results Interpretation

Page 16: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

16

Results Interpretation

Page 17: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

17

Page 18: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

18

Results and Discussion

Style: Results/past-present;

Discussion/present 3rd Person, preferably: related

work 1st person, plural: the rest Use active voice whenever possible Subsections may improve

organization and comprehension

Page 19: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

19

Body Paper: Four Sections SchemeBody Paper: Four Sections SchemeEstimated Length for each Section Estimated Length for each Section

Abstract– 4 sentences – 150 words Section 1: Introduction – 1p (p= A4

page) Section 2: Research Problem – 1p Section 3: Solution – 2/5p Section 4: Results – 2/5p Section 5: Discussion – 1/2p Section 6: Conclusion – 0.5p

Page 20: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

20

IMRAD structure

An acronym for Introduction, Methods, Results, And Discussion

Alternative SchemeAlternative Scheme

Page 21: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

21

IMRAD structure

An acronym for Introduction, Methods, Results, And Discussion

Usual in medicine, electronics and experimental software engineering

papers!

Alternative SchemeAlternative Scheme

Page 22: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

22

IMRAD structure

IntroductionWhy was the study undertaken?

What was the research question, the tested hypothesis or the purpose of the research?

Page 23: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

23

IMRAD structure

MethodsWhen, where, and how was the study done?

What materials were used or who was included in the study groups (patients, professionals, students, etc.)?

Page 24: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

24

IMRAD structure

ResultsWhat answer was found to the research question?

What did the study find?

Was the tested hypothesis true?

Page 25: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

25

IMRAD structure

And DiscussionWhat might the answer imply and why does it matter?

How does it fit in with what other researchers have found?

What are the perspectives for future research?

Page 26: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

26

Erwann Wernli, Mircea Lungu, Oscar Nierstrasz, “Incremental Dynamic Updates with First-class Contexts”, Journal of Object Technology, Volume 12, no. 3 (August 2013), pp. 1:1-27, doi:10.5381/jot.2013.12.3.a1.

Page 27: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

27

1 Introduction2 Running Example

2.1 The Problem with Updates2.2 Lifecycle of an Incremental Update

3 First-class Context4 Implementation5 Validation

5.1 First Experiment: Evolution5.2 Second Experiment: Run-time

Characteristics6 Discussion7 Related Work8 ConclusionReferences

Page 28: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

28

Yannis Lilis, Anthony Savidis. An Integrated Approach to Source Level Debugging and Compile Error Reporting in Metaprograms. In Journal of Object Technology, vol. 12, no. 3, 2013, pages 2:1–26. doi:10.5381/jot.2013.12.3.a2.

Page 29: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

29

1 Introduction2 Related Work

2.1 Compile-Time Debugging of Stages

2.2 Compile-Error Reporting3 Language4 Compile Errors5 Stage Debugging6 Evaluation7 ConclusionReferences

Page 30: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

30

The EndThe End

Page 31: 1 22/nov/2013. 2 Workshop Goals  To present some tips for writing good paper bodies for scientific papers  To gain hands-on experience applying some.

31