09-50026-reg Doc 11535 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12...

740B8>6 30D4 0>3 D8=4/ 0WXPS ),# )'() HZ ./*+ H%T% !4HYZLXU DPTL"

B4C@?>C4 3403<8>4/ 0WXPS (.# )'() HZ */'' W%T% !4HYZLXU DPTL"

8Sddk E) IW[VW^ $8I(,4/0%IfWXS`[W 8[dTdaiWd >dWWd $I>(-343%;@9BIJ<@E I?7G@HF CCG,1.. 8daSViSkEWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,++,4(12+3JW^WbZa`W5 $-,-% -22(10++=SUe[_[^W5 $-,-% -22(10+,

7ffad`Wke Xad Dafade C[cg[VSf[a`9a_bS`k >K9 Jdgef

E>8D43 CD0D4C 10>;BE@D2G 2?EBD

C?ED74B> 38CDB82D ?5 >4F G?B;

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$]

/

8U XL / 2OHWZLX (( 2HYL >V%

/

=?D?BC <8AE830D8?> 2?=@0>G# #% "$!# / '.$+''), !B46"

M&R&H 6LULXHS =VZVXY 2VXW%# #% "$! /

/

3LIZVXY% / !9VPUZS^ 0KTPUPYZLXLK"

/

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$]

>?D824 ?5 ?1942D8?> D? @B??5

?5 2<08= >?% -()*. 58<43 1G =0B9?B84 0% 2B40=4B

@<40C4 D0;4 >?D824 fZSf a` DSdUZ --' -+,-' fZW Dafade C[cg[VSf[a`

9a_bS`k >K9 Jdgef $fZW o6E2 DX[YZp%' Xad_WV Tk fZW STahW(USbf[a`WV VWTfade $Ua^^WUf[hW^k'

fZW o3LIZVXYp% [` Ua``WUf[a` i[fZ fZW ;WTfaden IWUa`V 7_W`VWV Aa[`f 9ZSbfWd ,, G^S`' VSfWV

DSdUZ ,3' -+,,' X[^WV [fe aT\WUf[a` fa bdaaX aX U^S[_ `g_TWd 2,-/4 X[^WV Tk DSd\ad[W 7) 9dWS_Wd

$fZW o?IQLJZPVUp%' S`V fZSf S ZWSd[`Y $fZW o7LHXPUNp% fa Uaè[VWd fZW FT\WUf[a` i[^^ TW ZW^V

TWXadW fZW ?aàdST^W HaTWdf <) >WdTWd' K`[fWV IfSfWe 8S`]dgbfUk AgVYW' [` Haa_ 1-, aX fZW

K`[fWV IfSfWe 8S`]dgbfUk 9agdf Xad fZW IagfZWd` ;[efd[Uf aX EWi Oad]' F`W 8ai^[`Y >dWW`'

EWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,+++/' a` 0WXPS ),# )'()# HZ ./*+ H%T% !4HYZLXU DPTL"# ad Se eaa`

fZWdWSXfWd Se UagèW^ _Sk TW ZWSdV)

@<40C4 D0;4 5EBD74B >?D824 fZSf S`k dWebaèW fa fZW FT\WUf[a` _gef

09-50026-reg Doc 11535 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Main Document Pg 1 of 12

-

TW [` id[f[`Y' eZS^^ Ua`Xad_ fa fZW =WVWdS^ Hg^We aX 8S`]dgbfUk GdaUWVgdW S`V fZW CaUS^ Hg^We

aX fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 9agdf' S`V eZS^^ TW X[^WV i[fZ fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 9agdf $S% W^WUfda`[US^^k [`

SUUadVSÙW i[fZ >W`WdS^ FdVWd D(.44 $iZ[UZ US` TW Xag`V Sf iii)`keT)geUagdfe)Yah% Tk

dWY[efWdWV geWde aX fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 9agdfne X[^[`Y ekefW_' S`V $T% Tk S^^ afZWd bSdf[We [` [`fWdWef'

a` S 9;(HFD ad .)0 [ÙZ V[e]' [` fWjf(eWSdUZST^W badfST^W VaUg_W`f Xad_Sf $G;=% $i[fZ S ZSdV

Uabk VW^[hWdWV V[dWUf^k fa 9ZS_TWde%' [` SUUadVSÙW i[fZ fZW Ugefa_Sdk bdSUf[UWe aX fZW

8S`]dgbfUk 9agdf S`V >W`WdS^ FdVWd D(.44' fa fZW WjfW`f Sbb^[UST^W' S`V eWdhWV [` SUUadVSÙW

i[fZ >W`WdS^ FdVWd D(.44 S`V a` $[% ;[U]efW[` IZSb[da' CCG' Sffad`Wke Xad fZW >K9 Jdgef' ,1..

8daSViSk' EWi Oad]' EWi Oad]' ,++,4(12+3 $7ff`5 8Sddk E) IW[VW^' <ec)' S`V IfWXS`[W

8[dTdaiWd >dWWd' <ec)%6 $[[% fZW ;WTfade' U*a Dafade C[cg[VSf[a` 9a_bS`k' /+, IagfZ F^V

MaaViSdV 7hW`gW' Ig[fW .2+' 8[d_[`YZS_' D[UZ[YS` /3++4 $7ff`5 JZa_Se Daddai %6 $[[[%

>W`WdS^ Dafade' CC9' /++ HW`S[eeSÙW 9W`fWd' ;Wfda[f' D[UZ[YS` /3-10 $7ff`5 CSidWÙW I)

8gaà_a' <ec)%6 $[h% 9SViS^SVWd' M[U]WdeZS_ # JSXf CCG' Sffad`Wke Xad fZW K`[fWV IfSfWe

;WbSdf_W`f aX fZW JdWSegdk' F`W Mad^V =[`SÙ[S^ 9W`fWd' EWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,+-3, $7ff`5

AaZ` A) HSb[eSdV[' <ec)%6 $h% fZW K`[fWV IfSfWe ;WbSdf_W`f aX fZW JdWSegdk' ,0++ GW`èk^hS`[S

7hW`gW EM' Haa_ -.,-' MSeZ[`Yfa`' ;)9) -+--+ $7ff`5 AaeWbZ IS_Sd[Se' <ec)%6 $h[% LWVVWd

Gd[UW' G)9)' Sffad`Wke Xad <jbadf ;WhWâb_W`f 9S`SVS' ,1.. 8daSViSk' /2fZ =âad' EWi Oad]'

EWi Oad] ,++,4 $7ff`5 D[UZSW^ A) <VW^_S`' <ec) S`V D[UZSW^ C) IUZW[`' <ec)%6 $h[[% BdS_Wd

CWh[` ESXfS^[e # =dS`]W^ CCG' Sffad`Wke Xad fZW efSfgfadk Ua__[ffWW aX gèWUgdWV UdWV[fade'

,,22 7hW`gW aX fZW 7_Wd[USe' EWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,++.1 $7ff`5 JZa_Se DaWde DSkWd' <ec)'

HaTWdf IUZ_[Vf' <ec)' CSgdW` DSU]eagV' <ec)' S`V AW``[XWd IZSddWf' <ec)%6 $h[[[% fZW FXX[UW aX

fZW K`[fWV IfSfWe JdgefWW Xad fZW IagfZWd` ;[efd[Uf aX EWi Oad]' .. MZ[fWZS^^ IfdWWf' -,ef =âad'

EWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,+++/ $7ff`5 JdSUk ?abW ;Sh[e' <ec)%6 $[j% fZW K)I) 7ffad`Wkne FXX[UW'


.

I);)E)O)' 31 9ZS_TWde IfdWWf' JZ[dV =âad' EWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,+++2 $7ff`5 ;Sh[V I) Aa`We'

<ec) S`V ESfS^[W BgWZ^Wd' <ec)%6 $j% 9Sb^[` # ;dkeVS^W' 9ZSdfWdWV' Sffad`Wke Xad fZW aXX[U[S^

Ua__[ffWW aX gèWUgdWV UdWV[fade Za^V[`Y SeTWefae(dW^SfWV U^S[_e' .20 GSd] 7hW`gW' .0fZ =âad'

EWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,+,0-(.0++ $7ff`5 <^[Zg @èW^TgUZ' <ec) S`V H[fS 9) JaT[`' <ec)% S`V

F`W JZa_Se 9[dU^W' E)M)' Ig[fW ,,++' MSeZ[`Yfa`' ;9 -+++0 $7ff`5 JdWhad M) IiWff @@@' <ec)

S`V BWh[` 9) DSU^Sk' <ec)%6 $j[% Ifgfl_S`' 8da_TWdY' <eeWd_S` # G^[X]S' 7 GdaXWee[a`S^

9adbadSf[a`' Sffad`Wke Xad ;WS` D) JdSXW^Wf [` Z[e USbSU[fk Se fZW ^WYS^ dWbdWeW`fSf[hW Xad XgfgdW

SeTWefae bWdea`S^ [`\gdk U^S[_S`fe' -.-. 8dkS` IfdWWf' Ig[fW --++' ;S^^Se' JWjSe 20-+, $7ff`5

IS`VWd C) <eeWd_S`' <ec) S`V HaTWdf J) 8dageeWSg' <ec)%6 $j[[% >[Tea`' ;g`` # 9dgfUZWd CCG'

Sffad`Wke Xad M[^_[`Yfa` Jdgef 9a_bS`k Se >K9 Jdgef 7V_[`[efdSfad S`V Xad M[^_[`Yfa` Jdgef

9a_bS`k Se 7ha[VSÙW 7Uf[a` Jdgef 7V_[`[efdSfad' -++ GSd] 7hW`gW' /2fZ =âad' EWi Oad]'

EWi Oad] ,+,11 $7ff`5 BW[fZ DSdfadS`S' <ec)%6 $j[[[% =J@ 9aèg^f[`Y' Se fZW >K9 Jdgef

Da`[fad S`V Se fZW 7ha[VSÙW 7Uf[a` Jdgef Da`[fad' F`W 7f^S`f[U 9W`fWd' ,-+, MWef GWSUZfdWW

IfdWWf' Ig[fW 0++' 7f^S`fS' >WadY[S .+.+4 $7ff`5 7``S GZ[^^[be%6 $j[h% 9daiW^^ # Dad[`Y CCG'

Sffad`Wke Xad fZW HWh[fS^[l[`Y 7gfa 9a__g`[f[We <`h[da`_W`fS^ HWebaèW Jdgef' 04+ DSV[ea`

7hW`gW' ,4fZ =âad' EWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,++--(-0-/ $7ff`5 D[UZSW^ L) 8^g_W`fZS^' <ec)%6 S`V

$jh% B[d] G) MSfea`' <ec)' Se fZW 7eTWefae Jdgef 7V_[`[efdSfad' -.+, MaaV^Si` 8ag^WhSdV'

7gef[`' JWjSe 232+.' ea Se fa TW dWUW[hWV à ^SfWd fZS` 0WXPS (.# )'()# HZ */'' W%T% !4HYZLXU

DPTL" $fZW oBLYWVUYL 3LHKSPULp%)

@<40C4 D0;4 5EBD74B >?D824 fZSf' [X à dWebaèWe SdW f[_W^k X[^WV S`V

eWdhWV i[fZ dWebWUf fa fZW FT\WUf[a`' fZW >K9 Jdgef _Sk' a` ad SXfWd fZW HWebaèW ;WSV^[`W'

egT_[f fa fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 9agdf S` adVWd egTefS`f[S^^k [` fZW Xad_ aX fZW bdabaeWV adVWd S``WjWV

fa fZW FT\WUf[a`' iZ[UZ adVWd _Sk TW W`fWdWV i[fZ à XgdfZWd àf[UW ad abbadfg`[fk fa TW ZWSdV


/

aXXWdWV fa S`k bSdfk)

;SfWV5 EWi Oad]' EWi Oad]DSdUZ --' -+,-

#B# .C561>95 %9A2A?D5A (A55A000000

8Sddk E) IW[VW^ $8I(,4/0%IfWXS`[W 8[dTdaiWd >dWWd $I>(-343%

;@9BIJ<@E I?7G@HF CCG,1.. 8daSViSkEWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,++,4(12+3JW^WbZa`W5 $-,-% -22(10++=SUe[_[^W5 $-,-% -22(10+,





8Sddk E) IW[VW^ $8I(,4/0%IfWXS`[W 8[dTdaiWd >dWWd $I>(-343%;@9BIJ<@E I?7G@HF CCG,1.. 8daSViSkEWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,++,4(12+3JW^WbZa`W5 $-,-% -22(10++=SUe[_[^W5 $-,-% -22(10+,



C?ED74B> 38CDB82D ?5 >4F G?B;

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$]

/


/

=?D?BC <8AE830D8?> 2?=@0>G# #% "$!# / '.$+''), !B46"


/


/

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$]

?1942D8?> D? @B??5 ?5 2<08=

>?% -()*. 58<43 1G =0B9?B84 0% 2B40=4B

JF J?< ?FEFH78C< HF8<HJ <) ><H8<HKE@J<; IJ7J<I 87EBHKGJ9O AK;><5

JZW Dafade C[cg[VSf[a` 9a_bS`k >K9 Jdgef $fZW o 6E2 DX[YZp%' Xad_WV Tk

fZW STahW(USbf[a`WV VWTfade $Ua^^WUf[hW^k' fZW o 3LIZVXYp% [` Ua``WUf[a` i[fZ fZW ;WTfaden

IWUa`V 7_W`VWV Aa[`f 9ZSbfWd ,, G^S`' VSfWV DSdUZ ,3' -+,, $Se _Sk TW S_W`VWV'

egbb^W_W`fWV' ad _aV[X[WV Xda_ f[_W fa f[_W' fZW o @SHUp%' aT\WUfe fa bdaaX aX U^S[_ `g_TWd

2,-/4 X[^WV Tk DSd\ad[W 7) 9dWS_Wd $fZW o2SHPTp%' a` fZW TSe[e fZSf fZW 9^S[_ eWW]e

dWUahWdk Xad S_ag`fe Xad iZ[UZ fZW ;WTfade SdW `af ^[ST^W) Ja fZW WjfW`f ^[ST[^[fk Wj[efe a`

SUUag`f aX fZW U^S[_' egUZ ^[ST[^[fk [e fZW aT^[YSf[a` aX >W`WdS^ Dafade' CC9 $o >L\ 6=p%)

@` egbbadf aX fZ[e FT\WUf[a`' fZW >K9 Jdgef dWebWUfXg^^k dWbdWeW`fe5


-

@B4<8=8>0BG CD0D4=4>D

,) F` ;WUW_TWd --' -+,,' De) 9dWS_Wd' S @A? B5 ^[f[YS`f' X[^WV fZW 9^S[_ [`

fZW S_ag`f aX "-'+++'+++' eWW][`Y fa dWUahWd VS_SYWe Xad bWdea`S^ [`\gdk USgeWV Tk S` SUU[VW`f

[`ha^h[`Y S` S^^WYWV^k VWXWUf[hW hWZ[U^W $o0JJPKLUZp%) JZW 7UU[VW`f S^^WYWV^k aUUgddWV a`

IWbfW_TWd -/' -++4) 7e eWf XadfZ _adW Xg^^k ZWdW[`' U^S[_e $[X S`k% dWeg^f[`Y Xda_ fZW 7UU[VW`f

SdW ^[ST[^[f[We fZSf iWdW Seeg_WV Tk EWi >D' S`V SdW àf fZW dWebaè[T[^[fk aX fZW ;WTfade)

-) De) 9dWS_Wd X[^WV S` SUf[a` SYS[èf fZW ;WTfade dW^SfWV fa fZW 7UU[VW`f [`

fZW K`[fWV IfSfWe ;[efd[Uf 9agdf [` BSèSe' S`V ZSe Ua`f[`gWV WXXadfe fa bgdegW egUZ SUf[a`'

VWeb[fW fZW Sgfa_Sf[U efSk) 7VV[f[a`S^^k' fZagYZ fZ[e [e fZW X[def aT\WUf[a` X[^WV Tk fZW >K9 Jdgef

fa fZW 9^S[_' De) 9dWS_Wd ZSe S^dWSVk eW`f eWhWdS^ ^WffWde fa fZW 9agdf dW^SfWV fa fZW 9^S[_)

7_a`Y afZWd fZ[`Ye' De) 9dWS_Wd ZSe dWcgWefWV oS` gdYWÙk a` fZW VWU[e[a`p dW^SfWV fa fZW

9^S[_' fZagYZ eZW Sêa SU]ài^WVYWe fZSf eZW [e Se][`Y fZW ;WTfade fa bSk ZWd S` oWjadT[fS`f

S_ag`fp aX _a`Wk) IWW <jZ[T[f 7 Sf /) ;Web[fW WXXadfe Tk fZW >K9 Jdgef S`V [fe UagèW^ fa

Wjb^S[` fa De) 9dWS_Wd fZSf EWi >D [e ^[ST^W Xad S`k VS_SYWe dWeg^f[`Y Xda_ fZW 7UU[VW`f $S`V

fZSf' [` S`k WhW`f' fZW 9^S[_ [e àf hS^[V TWUSgeW [f iSe àf f[_W^k X[^WV%' De) 9dWS_Wd ZSe

[`V[USfWV fZSf eZW [`fW`Ve fa ^[f[YSfW fZW 9^S[_)

.) @` ^[YZf aX fZW XadWYa[`Y' S`V Se _adW Xg^^k eWf XadfZ ZWdW[`' fZW >K9 Jdgef

eWW]e W`fdk aX S` adVWd $[% V[eS^âi[`Y S`V Wjbg`Y[`Y fZW 9^S[_ bgdegS`f fa eWUf[a` 0+-$T% aX

f[f^W ,, aX fZW K`[fWV IfSfWe 9aVW $fZW o1HURX[WZJ^ 2VKLp% S`V Hg^W .++2$S% aX fZW =WVWdS^

Hg^We aX 8S`]dgbfUk GdaUWVgdW $fZW o1HURX[WZJ^ B[SLYp% S`V $[[% bdah[V[`Y fZSf' fa fZW WjfW`f

De) 9dWS_Wd X[^We S`k XgdfZWd b^WSV[`Ye' U^S[_e' ad afZWdi[eW fS]We SUf[a` SYS[èf fZW ;WTfade ad

fZW >K9 Jdgef [` fZ[e 9agdf' `W[fZWd fZW ;WTfade àd fZW >K9 Jdgef eZag^V TW dWcg[dWV fa X[^W S

dWebaèW ad fS]W S`k SUf[a` g`^Wee V[dWUfWV Tk fZ[e 9agdf)


.

9EB8C382D8?>

/) JZ[e 9agdf ZSe \gd[eV[Uf[a` fa Uaè[VWd fZ[e _SffWd bgdegS`f fa -3 K)I)9)

rr ,02 S`V ,../) JZ[e [e S UadW bdaUWWV[`Y bgdegS`f fa -3 K)I)9) r ,02$T%)

D74 2<08=

0) F` DSdUZ ,0' -+,,' De) 9dWS_Wd X[^WV S Ua_b^S[`f SYS[èf fZW ;WTfade [`

fZW K`[fWV IfSfWe ;[efd[Uf 9agdf [` BSèSe eWW][`Y "-'+++'+++ Xad S^^WYWV VS_SYWe dWeg^f[`Y

Xda_ fZW 7UU[VW`f' iZ[UZ S^^WYWV^k faa] b^SUW a` IWbfW_TWd -/' -++4 $fZW o<PZPNHZPVUp%), F`

Ag^k ,0' -+,,' fZW 9agdf W`fWdWV S` adVWd V[e_[ee[`Y fZW C[f[YSf[a` i[fZagf bdW\gV[UW TWUSgeW aX

fZW Sgfa_Sf[U efSk fZSf iW`f [`fa WXXWUf gba` fZW ;WTfaden TS`]dgbfUk X[^[`Y) IWW <jZ[T[f 8) De)

9dWS_Wdne SbbWS^ fa fZW JW`fZ 9[dUg[f 9agdf aX 7bbWSê aX fZ[e VWU[e[a` iSe V[e_[eeWV Se

g`f[_W^k) IWW <jZ[T[f 9)

1) 7XfWd V[e_[eeS^ aX fZW C[f[YSf[a` S`V dW\WUf[a` aX ZWd SbbWS^' De) 9dWS_Wd

Ua`f[`gWV fa SffW_bf fa X[^W VaUg_W`fe [` fZW USeW) JZW 9agdf [`Xad_WV De) 9dWS_Wd' [` id[f[`Y'

fZSf à XgdfZWd X[^[`Ye [` fZW USeW iag^V TW SUUWbfWV' S`V V[dWUfWV ZWd fa SbbWS^ fZW USeW fa fZW

K`[fWV IfSfWe IgbdW_W 9agdf [X eZW VWe[dWV fa bgdegW fZW _SffWd) IWW <jZ[T[f ;) De) 9dWS_Wd

Ua`f[`gWV fa eW`V ^WffWde fa fZW Uagdf' iZ[UZ SbbWSd a` fZW VaU]Wf Tgf iWdW àf _SVW bSdf aX fZW

aXX[U[S^ dWUadV) IWW <jZ[T[f <)

2) F` ;WUW_TWd --' -+,, $ahWd fia kWSde SXfWd fZW 7UU[VW`f S`V fZW

Sbb^[UST^W 8Sd ;SfW%' De) 9dWS_Wd X[^WV fZW 9^S[_' eWW][`Y fa dWUahWd "-'+++'+++ Xda_ fZW

;WTfade Xad VS_SYWe S^^WYWV^k dWeg^f[`Y Xda_ fZW 7UU[VW`f) IWW <jZ[T[f =) De) 9dWS_Wd ZSV àf

bdWh[age^k X[^WV S U^S[_ SYS[èf fZW ;WTfade [` Ua``WUf[a` i[fZ fZW 7UU[VW`f)

, F` IWbfW_TWd ,0' -+,,' De) 9dWS_Wd Sêa X[^WV S ^Sieg[f SYS[èf fZW o<I@I 9^S[_e K`[fp eWW][`Y"-'+++'+++)++ [` VS_SYWe dW^SfWV fa fZW 7UU[VW`f) JZ[e USeW [e bW`V[`Y [` fZW K`[fWV IfSfWe ;[efd[Uf9agdf [` BSèSe) .55 <jZ[T[f @)


/

3) F` AS`gSdk ,-' -+,-' UagèW^ Xad fZW >K9 Jdgef eW`f S ^WffWd fa De)

9dWS_Wd SVh[e[`Y ZWd fZSf fZW 9^S[_ ZSV àf TWW` f[_W^k X[^WV S`V dWcgWef[`Y fZSf eZW ha^g`fSd[^k

i[fZVdSi fZW 9^S[_) IWW <jZ[T[f >) JZWdWSXfWd' De) 9dWS_Wd X[^WV S ^WffWd i[fZ fZW 9agdf S`V

idafW fZSf o>9> SYW`f Xad U^S[_e SYS[èf DC9 YShW _W U^S[_ !e Pe[UQ TWUSgeW TS`]dgbfUk àf

UâeWV kWf)p IWW <jZ[T[f ? Sf .)

0B6E=4>D

0% DOL 3HTHNLY CV[NOZ PU ZOL 2SHPT 0XL <PHIPSPZPLY 0YY[TLK I^ >L\ 6=

4) @X S` aT\WUf[a` dWXgf[`Y Sf ^WSef a`W aX fZW U^S[_ne WeeW`f[S^ S^^WYSf[aè

[e SeeWdfWV' fZW U^S[_S`f ZSe fZW TgdVW` fa VW_aèfdSfW fZW hS^[V[fk aX fZW U^S[_) .55 )> A5

+>5941 *C4"' /++ 8)H) .3/' .34 $8S`]d) I);)E)O) -++4%6 )> A5 $45<@891 &?==3E>B &?A@" ' 9Z) ,,

9SeW Ea) +-(/,2-4 $H<>%' -++2 8S`]d) C<N@I 11+ Sf &,0 $8S`]d) I);)E)O) =WT) -+' -++2%6 )>

A5 -?3;565<<5A &CA" ,A?@B" ' -2- 8)H) 0-/' 0.4 $8S`]d) I);)E)O) -+++%) MZWdW' Se ZWdW' S bSdfk

afZWd fZS` fZW VWTfad [e dWebaè[T^W Xad fZW U^S[_ Se S _SffWd aX ^Si' fZW U^S[_S`f US`àf _WWf

egUZ TgdVW`)

,+) GgdegS`f fa fZW 7_W`VWV S`V HWefSfWV DSefWd IS^W S`V GgdUZSeW

7YdWW_W`f $fZW _=HYZLX @[XJOHYL 0NXLLTLUZ` %' VSfWV Se aX Ag`W -1' -++4' Tk S`V S_a`Y

>W`WdS^ Dafade 9adbadSf[a`' ISfgd` CC9' ISfgd` ;[efd[Tgf[a` 9adbadSf[a`' 9ZWhda^Wf(ISfgd` aX

?Sd^W_' @Ù)' S`V EWi >D' EWi >D Seeg_WV S^^ o^[ST[^[f[Wep dW^SfWV fa WhW`fe aUUgdd[`Y a` ad

SXfWd Ag^k ,+' -++4 $fZW o0YY[TWZPVU 3HZLp%) IWUf[a` -).$S%$[j% aX fZW DSefWd GgdUZSeW

7YdWW_W`f eWfe XadfZ fZW WjfW`f fa iZ[UZ bdaVgUfe ^[ST[^[fk U^S[_e iWdW Seeg_WV Tk EWi >D)

@` bSdf[Ug^Sd' EWi >D Seeg_WV5

$[j% S^^ C[ST[^[f[We fa fZ[dV bSdf[We Xad VWSfZ' bWdea`S^ [`\gdk' adafZWd [`\gdk fa PbQWdeaè ad VS_SYW fa bdabWdfk USgeWV Tk _afadhWZ[U^We VWe[Y`WV Xad abWdSf[a` a` bgT^[U daSViSke ad Tk fZWUa_ba`W`f bSdfe aX egUZ _afad hWZ[U^We S`V' [` WSUZ USeW'


0

_S`gXSUfgdWV' ea^V ad VW^[hWdWV Tk PeQW^^Wde P$[)W' fZW ;WTfade%Q )) )iZ[UZ Sd[eW V[dWUf^k agf aX VWSfZ' bWdea`S^ [`\gdk ad afZWd[`\gdk fa PbQWdeaè ad VS_SYW fa bdabWdfk USgeWV Tk SUU[VW`fead [Ù[VW`fe X[def aUUgdd[`Y ?> ?A 16C5A C85 &<?B9>7 '1C5 S`VSd[e[`Y Xda_ egUZ _afad hWZ[U^Wen abWdSf[a` ad bWdXad_SÙW ) ) )

DSefWd GgdUZSeW 7YdWW_W`f r -).$S%$[j% $W_bZSe[e SVVWV%) JZW fWd_ oC[ST[^[f[Wep [e VWX[`WV [`

fZW dWU[fSê fa fZW DSefWd GgdUZSeW 7YdWW_W`f Se Xa^âie5

oC[ST[^[f[Wep _WSè S`k S`V S^^ ^[ST[^[f[We S`V aT^[YSf[aè aXWhWdk ][`V S`V VWeUd[bf[a` iZSfeaWhWd' iZWfZWd egUZ ^[ST[^[f[Wead aT^[YSf[aè SdW ]ài` ad g`]ài`' V[eUâeWV ad g`V[eUâeWV'_SfgdWV ad g`_SfgdWV' SUUdgWV' X[jWV' STea^gfW' Ua`f[`YW`f'VWfWd_[`WV ad g`VWfWd_[`ST^W' a` ad aXX(TS^SÙW eZWWf adafZWdi[eW' ad VgW ad fa TWUa_W VgW' [Ù^gV[`Y @`VWTfWV`Wee S`VfZaeW Sd[e[`Y g`VWd S`k CSi' 9^S[_' FdVWd' 9a`fdSUf adafZWdi[eW)

,,) JZ[e 9agdf ZSe egefS[`WV hSd[age aT\WUf[aè fa U^S[_e X[^WV Tk fZW ;WTfade

S`V*ad fZW >K9 Jdgef' TWUSgeW fZW U^S[_e dW^SfWV fa SUU[VW`fe fZSf aUUgddWV SXfWd fZW 7eeg_bf[a`

;SfW) .55! 5"7! FdVWd >dS`f[`Y fZW -/1fZ F_`[Tge FT\WUf[a`' ;aU]Wf Ea) ,+41/) De)

9dWS_Wdne U^S[_ [e à V[XXWdW`f) F` [fe XSUW' fZW 9^S[_ eWW]e dWUahWdk Xad VS_SYWe dWeg^f[`Y

Xda_ S` SUU[VW`f aUUgdd[`Y a` IWbfW_TWd -/' -++4' fia _a`fZe SXfWd fZW 7eeg_bf[a` ;SfW)

JZge Se S _SffWd aX ^Si' fZW 9^S[_ [e g`W`XadUWST^W SYS[èf fZW ;WTfade S`V De) 9dWS_Wd

US`àf eSf[eXk ZWd TgdVW`) 9aèWcgW`f^k' fZW 9^S[_ eZag^V TW V[eS^âiWV S`V Wjbg`YWV)

1% DOL 2SHPT FHY EUZPTLS^ 5PSLK

,-) <hW` [X fZW 9^S[_ iWdW S` aT^[YSf[a` aX fZW ;WTfade $iZ[UZ [f [e àf%' [f

eZag^V ef[^^ TW V[eS^âiWV S`V Wjbg`YWV a` fZW TSe[e fZSf fZW 9^S[_ iSe àf f[_W^k X[^WV) IWUf[a`

0+-$T%$4% aX fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 9aVW bdah[VWe fZSf' gba` fZW aT\WUf[a` aX S bSdfk [` [`fWdWef' S U^S[_

eZS^^ TW V[eS^âiWV fa fZW WjfW`f fZSf obdaaX aX egUZ U^S[_ [e àf f[_W^k X[^WV)p ,, K)I)9)

r 0+-$T%$4%) GgdegS`f fa 8S`]dgbfUk Hg^W .++.$U%$.%' S bdaaX aX U^S[_ [e àf f[_W^k X[^WV g`^Wee

[f [e X[^WV obd[ad fa S TSd VSfW WefST^[eZWV Tk adVWd aX S TS`]dgbfUk Uagdf)p )> A5 /+ &?==3E>!


1

)>3"' .+, 8)H) 23-' 24, $8S`]d) I);)E)O) -++.%6 =WV) H) 8S`]d) G) .++.$U%$.%) 7e S YW`WdS^ dg^W'

S`k UdWV[fad iZa XS[ê fa X[^W S bdaaX aX U^S[_ a` ad TWXadW fZW Sbb^[UST^W TSd VSfW oi[^^ TW

XadWhWd TSddWV fZSf [e' XadT[VVW` q Xda_ SeeWdf[`Y fZW U^S[_ SYS[èf WSUZ aX fZW ;WTfade S`V fZW[d

dWebWUf[hW WefSfWe)p %1A '1C5 +A45A VSfWV IWbfW_TWd ,1' -++4 Sf t 1)

,.) ?WdW' fZW 9agdf eWf S EahW_TWd .+' -++4 VWSV^[`W Xad X[^[`Y bdaaXe aX

U^S[_) >[hW` fZSf fZW 9^S[_ iSe X[^WV ahWd fia kWSde SXfWd fZW 8Sd ;SfW' S`V iW^^ SXfWd fZW

<XXWUf[hW ;SfW aX fZW G^S`' fZW XSUf fZSf fZW 9^S[_ iSe àf f[_W^k X[^WV bdah[VWe S`

[`VWbW`VW`f TSe[e a` iZ[UZ fa V[eS^âi S`V Wjbg`YW [f) -

2?>2<EC8?>

=ad fZW dWSeaè eWf XadfZ STahW' fZ[e 9agdf eZag^V W`fWd S` adVWd Wjbg`Y[`Y fZW 9^S[_

S`V YdS`f[`Y egUZ afZWd S`V XgdfZWd dW^[WX Se fZW 9agdf VWW_e \gef S`V bdabWd)

;SfWV5 EWi Oad]' EWi Oad]DSdUZ --' -+,-

#B# .C561>95 %9A2A?D5A (A55A000000

8Sddk E) IW[VW^ $8I(,4/0%IfWXS`[W 8[dTdaiWd >dWWd $I>(-343%

;@9BIJ<@E I?7G@HF CCG,1.. 8daSViSkEWi Oad]' EWi Oad] ,++,4(12+3JW^WbZa`W5 $-,-% -22(10++=SUe[_[^W5 $-,-% -22(10+,


- JZW >K9 Jdgef dWeWdhWe fZW d[YZf fa aT\WUf fa fZW 9^S[_ a` Ydag`Ve afZWd fZS` fZaeWbSdf[Ug^Sd^k eWf XadfZ [` fZ[e FT\WUf[a`' fa fZW WjfW`f fZW 9agdf VaWe àf YdS`f fZW dWcgWefWV dW^[WX)





C?ED74B> 38CDB82D ?5 >4F G?B;

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$]

/


/

=?D?BC <8AE830D8?> 2?=@0>G# #% "$!# / '.$+''), !B46"


/


/

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$]

?B34B 6B0>D8>6 ?1942D8?> D?

@B??5 ?5 2<08= >?% -()*. 58<43 1G =0B9?B84 0% 2B40=4B

Kba` fZW aT\WUf[a` fa bdaaX aX U^S[_ `g_TWd 2,-/4 $fZW o2SHPTp% X[^WV Tk

DSd\ad[W 7) 9dWS_Wd' VSfWV DSdUZ PQ' -+,- $fZW o?IQLJZPVUp%' aX fZW Dafade C[cg[VSf[a`

9a_bS`k >K9 Jdgef $fZW o6E2 DX[YZp%' Xad_WV Tk fZW STahW(USbf[a`WV VWTfade $Ua^^WUf[hW^k'

fZW o3LIZVXYp% [` Ua``WUf[a` i[fZ fZW ;WTfaden IWUa`V 7_W`VWV Aa[`f 9ZSbfWd ,, G^S`' VSfWV

DSdUZ ,3' -+,, $Se _Sk TW S_W`VWV' egbb^W_W`fWV' ad _aV[X[WV Xda_ f[_W fa f[_W' fZW o@SHUp%'

bgdegS`f fa eWUf[a` 0+-$T% aX f[f^W ,,' K`[fWV IfSfWe 9aVW $fZW o1HURX[WZJ^ 2VKLp%' eWW][`Y

W`fdk aX S` adVWd V[eS^âi[`Y S`V Wjbg`Y[`Y fZW 9^S[_ a` fZW TSe[e fZSf egUZ U^S[_ eWW]e

dWUahWdk aX S` S_ag`f Xad iZ[UZ fZW ;WTfade SdW àf ^[ST^W' S^^ Se _adW Xg^^k VWeUd[TWV [` fZW

FT\WUf[a`6 S`V VgW S`V bdabWd àf[UW aX fZW FT\WUf[a` ZSh[`Y TWW` bdah[VWV' S`V [f SbbWSd[`Y

fZSf à afZWd ad XgdfZWd àf[UW `WWV TW bdah[VWV6 S`V fZW 9agdf ZSh[`Y Xag`V S`V VWfWd_[`WV fZSf

fZW dW^[WX eagYZf [` fZW FT\WUf[a` [e [` fZW TWef [`fWdWefe aX fZW ;WTfade' fZW[d WefSfWe' UdWV[fade'

S`V S^^ bSdf[We [` [`fWdWef S`V fZSf fZW ^WYS^ S`V XSUfgS^ TSeWe eWf XadfZ [` fZW FT\WUf[a` WefST^[eZ

\gef USgeW Xad fZW dW^[WX YdS`fWV ZWdW[`6 S`V SXfWd Uaè[VWdSf[a` aX fZW ^WffWde X[^WV Tk De) 9dWS_Wd

bd[ad fa fZW X[^[`Y aX fZW FT\WUf[a` $<9= Eae) ,,.-1' ,,./0' S`V ,,/00' S`V%6 S`V SXfWd VgW

VW^[TWdSf[a` S`V egXX[U[W`f USgeW SbbWSd[`Y fZWdWXad' [f [e


-

FH;<H<; fZSf fZW dW^[WX dWcgWefWV [` fZW FT\WUf[a` [e YdS`fWV6 S`V [f [e XgdfZWd

FH;<H<; fZSf' bgdegS`f fa eWUf[a` 0+-$T% aX fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 9aVW' fZW 9^S[_ [e

ZWdWTk V[eS^âiWV S`V Wjbg`YWV6 S`V [f [e XgdfZWd

FH;<H<; fZSf' fa fZW WjfW`f De) 9dWS_Wd X[^We S`k XgdfZWd b^WSV[`Ye' U^S[_e' ad

afZWdi[eW fS]We SUf[a` SYS[èf fZW ;WTfade ad fZW >K9 Jdgef [` fZ[e 9agdf' `W[fZWd fZW ;WTfade

àd fZW >K9 Jdgef eZS^^ TW dWcg[dWV fa X[^W S dWebaèW ad fS]W S`k SUf[a` g`^Wee V[dWUfWV Tk fZ[e

9agdf6 S`V [f [e XgdfZWd

FH;<H<; fZSf fZ[e 9agdf eZS^^ dWfS[` \gd[eV[Uf[a` fa ZWSd S`V VWfWd_[`W S^^

_SffWde Sd[e[`Y Xda_ ad dW^SfWV fa fZ[e FdVWd)

;SfWV5 EWi Oad]' EWi Oad]RRRRRRRRR' -+,-

K`[fWV IfSfWe 8S`]dgbfUk AgVYW


#'$%"%& !

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-1 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit A Pg 1 of 6

09-50026-reg Doc 11326 Filed 01/18/12 Entered 01/19/12 12:31:26 Main Document Pg 1 of 509-50026-reg Doc 11535-1 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit A Pg 2 of 6

"&#$!$% !

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-2 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit B Pg 1 of 5

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTFOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS

MARJORIE A. CREAMER, ))

Plaintiff, ))

v. )) No. 11-4028-CM/DJW)

GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION, )et al., )

)Defendants. )

)

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer brings this action pro se and in forma pauperis against

defendants General Motors (“GM”) and Motors Liquidation Company (“MLC”), asserting product

liability and personal injury claims, as well as claims under the Americans with Disabilities Act

(“ADA”) and Kansas consumer protection laws. Defendants failed to appear or otherwise defend,

and the Clerk of the Court entered default against defendants on June 6, 2011. Plaintiff filed the

instant Pleading for Judgment Order and Dollar Amount Against Defendants (Doc. 10). She also

filed a document with the court in the form of a letter, which sets out a variety of assertions on a

variety of topics. (Doc. 9.) In her motion, plaintiff seeks damages in the amount of $2,000,000.

Defendants have filed a Notice of Bankruptcy (Doc. 11). For the following reasons, the court denies

the motion and dismisses the complaint.

I. Factual Background

According to the form complaint, plaintiff was injured in an accident on September 24, 2009

in her 2006 Chevy Cobalt. Although the complaint is unclear, it appears that the accident was


-2-

caused by a defective steering motor (which plaintiff alleges was subsequently subject to a recall in

March 2010), and that injury was caused by the failure of the airbags to deploy. Apparently, GM’s

Claims Department has been of “no help” to plaintiff. (Doc. 1, at 5.)

Plaintiff also filed a document with the court in the form of a letter, indicating that she is

incarcerated in the Smith County, Kansas, jail, “[b]eing held for no reason.” (Doc. 9, at 1.) She

believes the food is drugged. As to her case, she asserts that photographs of the accident and other

materials are in a safety deposit box, but she is unable to get them to the court at this time. She also

asserts her desire to “try and change case law” of Creamer v. Laidlaw Transit, Inc., 86 F.3d 167

(10th Cir. 1996) (sexual harassment case brought by plaintiff against her former employer, affirming

district court’s judgment in favor of defendant), stating that “[t]he cover-ups have got to stop.”

(Doc. 9, at 1, 2.) She notes that she has written a book entitled THE HUSH, which has “unfinished

chapters of injustices pounded and chained on me.” (Doc. 9, at 2.)

In her motion for default judgment, plaintiff asks for $2,000,000 “to compensate for

defendants not answering any of my letters” . . . and for the defective automobile. (Doc. 10, at 1.)

Defendant MLC has filed a Notice of Bankruptcy (Doc. 11), suggesting that any action taken

against defendant without obtaining relief from the Automatic Stay or the Plan Injunction from the

Bankruptcy Court may be void ab initio.

II. Judgment Standard

Generally speaking, once default is entered, a defendant is deemed to have admitted the

plaintiff’s well-pleaded allegations of fact. Olcott v. Del. Flood Co., 327 F.3d 1115, 1125 (10th Cir.

2003). Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 55(b), “[i]f the plaintiff’s claim is for a sum certain or

a sum that can be made certain by computation, the clerk – on the plaintiff’s request, with an


-3-

affidavit showing the amount due – must enter judgment for that amount and costs against a

defendant who has been defaulted for not appearing. . . .”

III. Discussion

There appear to be a number of problems with this case that prevent this court from granting

plaintiff’s requested relief. First, plaintiff’s complaint contains no claimed amount of damages. No

judgment by default can be greater in amount or different in kind from the demand contained in the

complaint. Rule 54(c). Specifically, courts have held that a plaintiff may not receive a default

judgment for more than the amount sought in the complaint. Silge v. Merz, 510 F.3d 157 (2nd Cir.

2007); Appleton Elec. Co. v. Graves Truck Line, Inc., 635 F.2d 603 (7th Cir. 1980). Plaintiff marks

a box indicating that she is seeking actual and punitive damages, but fails to set out any specific

damage allegations in her complaint. Indeed, in the section of the form directing her to “state the

amounts claimed” she merely reasserts her allegations that the defective steering motor caused her

September 2009 accident.

Further, and most importantly, the court is concerned that, even if judgment was proper, the

court lacks authority to enter judgment against an entity subject to an automatic stay in bankruptcy.

On June 1, 2009, defendant MLC (f/k/a/ GM) and certain subsidiaries voluntarily filed for

bankruptcy pursuant to chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy code in the United States Bankruptcy Court for

the Southern District of New York. Case No. 09-50026. The filing of the chapter 11 petition stayed

all pending and future litigation against defendant. 11 U.S.C. § 362(a)(1). Absent an order of the

bankruptcy court lifting the stay, plaintiff’s present action in this court is in violation of the

automatic stay. See, e.g. In re Motors Liquid. Co., No. 10 Civ. 4322 (JGK), 2011 WL 2462773

(S.D.N.Y. June 20, 2011). The court is to dismiss a case in which in forma pauperis status has been

granted if at any time the court determines the action is frivolous or malicious, fails to state a claim


-4-

on which relief may be granted, or seeks monetary relief against a defendant who is immune from

such relief. 28 U.S.C. § 1915(e)(2)(B)(1)-(iii). The court therefore dismisses plaintiff’s complaint

without prejudice.

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that plaintiff’s Pleading for Judgment Order and Dollar

Amount Against Defendants (Doc. 10) is denied, and plaintiff’s complaint is dismissed without

prejudice.

Dated this 15th day of July 2011, at Kansas City, Kansas.

s/ Carlos MurguiaCARLOS MURGUIAUnited States District Judge


#'$%!%& "

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-3 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit C Pg 1 of 4

FILEDUnited States Court of Appeals

Tenth Circuit

December 2, 2011

Elisabeth A. ShumakerClerk of Court

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

MARJORIE A. CREAMER,

Plaintiff - Appellant,

v.

GENERAL MOTORSCORPORATION; MOTORSLIQUIDATION COMPANY,

Defendants - Appellees.

No. 11-3358

ORDER

Before LUCERO, MURPHY and O’BRIEN, Circuit Judges.

This court lacks jurisdiction over this appeal because the notice of appeal

was filed out-of-time.

The last order issued by the district court was on October 13, 2011. The

plaintiff’s notice of appeal was filed more than 30 days later on November 29,

2011. Moreover, the appeal was filed more than 30 days after entry of the order

denying the first motion for reconsideration on September 20, 2011. See Fed. R.

App. P. 4(a)(4).

+;;3660=3 ,0<3* $$!&&') -91>738=* #$#$)('')%( -0=3 .5632* $%"#%"%#$$ /043* $09-50026-reg Doc 11535-3 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit C Pg 2 of 4

In a civil case, in which the United States is not a party, a notice of appeal

must be filed within 30 days of entry of the order being appealed. See 28 U.S.C.

§ 2107(a) (a notice of appeal in a civil matter must be filed within 30 days of

entry of judgment); Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(1)(A) (same). A timely notice of appeal

in a civil case is both mandatory and jurisdictional. See Bowles v. Russell, 551

U.S. 205, 209, 213 (2007).

Because the appeal was filed more than 30 days after entry of both the

district court’s September 20, 2011 and October 13, 2011 orders, this court lacks

jurisdiction. APPEAL DISMISSED.

Entered for the CourtELISABETH A. SHUMAKER, Clerk

Ellen Rich ReiterDeputy Clerk/Jurisdictional Attorney

2

+;;3660=3 ,0<3* $$!&&') -91>738=* #$#$)('')%( -0=3 .5632* $%"#%"%#$$ /043* %09-50026-reg Doc 11535-3 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit C Pg 3 of 4

Elisabeth A. ShumakerClerk of Court

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALSFOR THE TENTH CIRCUIT

OFFICE OF THE CLERKByron White United States Courthouse

1823 Stout StreetDenver, Colorado 80257

(303) 844-3157

December 02, 2011Douglas E. CresslerChief Deputy Clerk

Ms. Marjorie A. Creamer705 South MonroeSmith Center, KS 66967

RE: 11-3358, Creamer v. General Motors Corporation, et alDist/Ag docket: 5:11-CV-04028-CM-DJW

Dear Appellant:

Enclosed please find an order issued today by the court.

Please contact this office if you have questions.

Sincerely,

Elisabeth A. ShumakerClerk of the Court

EAS/klp

+;;3660=3 ,0<3* $$!&&') -91>738=* #$#$)('')&# -0=3 .5632* $%"#%"%#$$ /043* $09-50026-reg Doc 11535-3 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit C Pg 4 of 4

#'$%!%& "

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-4 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit D Pg 1 of 3

.>>6993@6 /3?6- $$!&&(+ 0=4A;6<@- #$#$+*)'&+) 03@6 18965- $%"$,"%#$$ 2376- $09-50026-reg Doc 11535-4 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit D Pg 2 of 3

0*(/%$!./"/%.!#+0-/!+&!",,%").

/%*/'!#(-#0(/

BOORLN!XO!]QN!5UN[T4a[XW!IQR]N!GWR]NM!E]J]N\!5X^[]QX^\N

6NW_N[$!5XUX[JMX!0(*-/"+(+#!0,,%+)-/

7UR\JKN]Q!3&!EQ^VJTN[!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!6X^PUJ\!7&!5[N\\UN[5UN[T!XO!5X^[]!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!5QRNO!6NY^]a!5UN[T

6NLNVKN[!*($!*())

@\&!@JSX[RN!3&!5[NJVN[

/(-!EX^]Q!@XW[XN!E]&

EVR]Q!5NW]N[$!>JW\J\!..1./

DN2!AX&!))%++-0$!5[NJVN[!_&!9NWN[JU!@X]X[\!5X[Y&

6NJ[!@\&!5[NJVN[2

FQR\!R\!RW![N\YXW\N!]X!]QN!YUNJMRWP!aX^!OX[`J[MNM!]R]UNM!b@X]RXW!8X[!DN_RN`!AN`

CJWNU!=^MPN\$c!`QRLQ!`N![NLNR_NM!QN[N!aN\]N[MJa&!!3\!aX^!TWX`$!]QN!S^MPN\!MNWRNM!aX^[

NJ[URN[![NZ^N\]!OX[!YX\]%]N[VRWJ]RXW![NURNO$!`QRLQ!`J\!LXW\][^NM!J\!J!YN]R]RXW!OX[![NQNJ[RWP$

XW!6NLNVKN[!0&!!FQJ]!X[MN[!WX]NM!]QN!LX^[]!`X^UM!WX]!JLLNY]!JWa!JMMR]RXWJU!YN]R]RXW\!OX[

[NQNJ[RWP&!!<W!N\\NWLN$!R]!JYYNJ[\!]QJ]!R\!`QJ]!aX^!J[N![NZ^N\]RWP!RW!]QR\!VX\]![NLNW]

\^KVR\\RXW&!!FQN!JYYNJU!QN[N!R\!WX`!LUX\NM$!JWM!]QN!LX^[]!`RUU!WX]!KN!]JTRWP!O^[]QN[

JL]RXW&!!C[XLNM^[JUUa$!aX^[![NLX^[\N!J]!]QR\!S^WL]^[N!R\!]X!LXW\RMN[!`QN]QN[!]X!\NNT

LN[]RX[J[R![N_RN`!RW!]QN!GWR]NM!E]J]N\!E^Y[NVN!5X^[]&!!FQN!JMM[N\\!]QN[N!R\!BWN!8R[\]

E][NN]$!A&7&$!IJ\QRWP]XW$!6&5&$!*(-,+&!!FQN!LX^[]!`RUU!WX]!KN!]JTRWP!JWa!JL]RXW!XW!]QR\

UJ]N\]!\^KVR\\RXW$!JWM!`RUU!WX]!JLLNY]!O^[]QN[!ORURWP\!RW!]QR\!LJ\N&!!IN!JYY[NLRJ]N!aX^[

^WMN[\]JWMRWP&!!

HN[a!][^Ua!aX^[\$

7?<E347F;!3&!E;G@3>7D

5UN[T!XO!5X^[]!

73E'UJK

.>>6993@6 /3?6- $$!&&(+ 0=4A;6<@- #$#$+*)'&+* 03@6 18965- $%"$,"%#$$ 2376- $09-50026-reg Doc 11535-4 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit D Pg 3 of 3

"&#$!$% "

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-5 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit E Pg 1 of 4

.=E=H8C +F;B=J

7=EJ@ *AH;KAJ *FKHJ F> (GG=8CI

*FKHJ F> (GG=8CI +F;B=J !' **&,,.1 +F;B=J=<' **(+2(+)**

7=HD=<' *+()+(+)**28JKH= F> 6KAJ' ,,/. ETà^]P[ >]Yc`f & E`^ScRb AXPQX[Xbf

8`TP\T` d' =T]T`P[ B^b^à 8^`_^`PbX^]% Tb P[

(GG=8C -HFD' J]XbTS HbPbTa 9Xab`XRb 8^c`b U^` bWT 9Xab`XRb Û @P]aPa & I _TZP

-== 6J8JKI' XU_ V`P]bTS

*8I= 7MG= /E>FHD8JAFE'

$# RXdX[

%# _`XdPbT

&# &

3HA?AE8JAE? *FKHJ /E>FHD8JAFE'

+AIJHA;J' *)1,&. 3 .3**&8K&)-)+1&8B&9?L

7HA8C 0K<?=' 8P`[â Bc`VcXP% &% J'H' 9Xab`XRb ?cSVT

+8J= -AC=<' ),(*.(+)**

+8J= 23( -AC=<' +8J= 5=;"< *3('

**(+2(+)** **(+2(+)**

4HAFH *8I=I'

),&*)*2

+8J= -AC=<' )*(*.(+)), +8J= +AIGFI=<' *)()+(+)), +AIGFIAJAFE' &

2-&*.2,

+8J= -AC=<' *+(+2(*22- +8J= +AIGFI=<' )/(**(*22/ +AIGFIAJAFE' &

*KHH=EJ *8I=I'

C^]T

48E=C (IIA?ED=EJ' C^b PdPX[PQ[T

B6G?DG>; 6' 8G;6B;G

E[PX]bXUU & 6__T[[P]b

BP`Y^`XT 6' 8`TP\T`

;\PX[3 bWTWcaW2*5W^b\PX['R^\

NCI8 E`^ HTO

<X`\3 01.(+.2&*-/)

0). H^cbW B^]`^T

H\XbW 8T]bT`% @H //2/0

d'

=;C;G6A BDIDGH 8DGEDG6I>DC

9TUT]SP]b & 6__T[[TT

BDIDGH A>FJ>96I>DC 8DBE6CM

9TUT]SP]b & 6__T[[TT

%%!'')* ,<273@ 6@@=?+##324"21%$"A?2<A>@?"5<B#29324#?3>B83@#0>1;?=<>@/<<9

% <4 ( '#%)#&$%& %+'( .-


B6G?DG>; 6' 8G;6B;G%

E[PX]bXUU & 6__T[[P]b%

d'

=;C;G6A BDIDGH 8DGEDG6I>DC4 BDIDGH A>FJ>96I>DC 8DBE6CM%

9TUT]SP]ba & 6__T[[TTa'

%%!'')* ,<273@ 6@@=?+##324"21%$"A?2<A>@?"5<B#29324#?3>B83@#0>1;?=<>@/<<9

& <4 ( '#%)#&$%& %+'( .-


**(+2(+)**+* _V% ++/'1. @7

N22++-//O 8XdX[ RPaT S^RZTbTS' E`T[X\X]P`f `TR^`S UX[TS' 96I; G;8;>K;93 **(+2(+)**' D`ST` ^] ><E

\^bX^] ScT *+(+2(+)** U^` SXab`XRb R^c`b' C^bXRT Û P__TP`P]RT ScT ^] *+(+2(+)** U^` BP`Y `XT 6'

8`TP\T`'

**(,)(+)**+ _V% -/'+* @7

N22++1,2O 9Xab`XRb R^c`b ^`ST` V`P]bX]V [TPdT b^ _`^RTTS X] U^`\P _Pc_T`Xa UX[TS'

*+()+(+)**, _V% ,+'** @7

N22+,/,.O ?c`XaSXRbX^]P[ 9TUTRb4 E`^RTSc`P[ bT`\X]PbX^] PUbT` ^bWT` YcSXRXP[ PRbX^]4 L`XbbT]% c]aXV]TS%

c]_cQ[XaWTS4 ?cSVTa AcRT`^% Bc`_Wf P]S D"7`XT]'

*+()/(+)**,, _V% *'/ B7

N22+-+-/O ETbXbX^] U^` `TWTP`X]V UX[TS Qf Ba' BP`Y `XT 6' 8`TP\T`' C^ RT`bXUXRPbT Û aT`dXRT'

*+()1(+)*** _V% /)'22 @7

N22+-2+/O D`ST` UX[TS Qf ?cSVTa AcRT`^% Bc`_Wf P]S D"7`XT] #T``$ R^]ab`cX]V P__T[[P]b"a *+(.(** [TbbT` Pa

P _TbXbX^] U^` `TWTP`X]V% P]S Pa a^ R^]ab`cTS% ST]fX]V bWT _TbXbX^] U^` `TWTP`X]V' IWT _TbXbX^]T` Xa eP`]TS

bWPb bWT R^c`b eX[[ ]^b PRRT_b P]^bWT` _TbXbX^] U^` `TWTP`X]V U`^\ bWT P__T[[P]b'

*+(*+(+)**+ _V% +1'10 @7

N22+.1-,O ;]b`f Û P__TP`P]RT `TRTXdTS U`^\ Ba' BP`Y^`XT 6' 8`TP\T`% Qcb ]^b UX[TS' HT`dTS ^]

*+()0(+)**' BP]]T` Û HT`dXRT3 JH \PX['

*+(*2(+)**+ _V% 2*'- @7

N22+01,1O !B^bX^] U^` GTdXTe CTe EP]T[ ?cSVTa! `TRTXdTS U`^\ Ba' BP`Y^`XT 6' 8`TP\T` Qcb ]^b UX[TS'

GTa_^]aT [TbbT` aT]b'

*+(+)(+)*** _V% -)'.2 @7

N22+1*)+O B^bX^] U^` PSSXbX^]P[ bX\T `TRTXdTS U`^\ Ba' BP`Y^`XT 6' 8`TP\T` Qcb ]^b UX[TS'

)*(),(+)*++ _V% *+1'00 @7

N22,**-*O GT&^_T] \^bX^] Û STUPc[b X] [êT` R^c`b `TRTXdTS U`^\ Ba' BP`Y^`XT 6' 8`TP\T`% Qcb ]^b UX[TS'

)*()2(+)*+, _V% 2*'2/ @7

N22,+/2)O +]S ETbXbX^] U^` `TWTP`X]V P]S WTP`X]V T] QP]R `TRTXdTS U`^\ Ba' BP`Y^`XT 6' 8`TP\T` Qcb ]^b

UX[TS'

%%!'')* ,<273@ 6@@=?+##324"21%$"A?2<A>@?"5<B#29324#?3>B83@#0>1;?=<>@/<<9

' <4 ( '#%)#&$%& %+'( .-


"'$%!%& #

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-6 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit F Pg 1 of 15

"'$%!%& #

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-7 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit G Pg 1 of 32

"&#$!$% #

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-8 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit H Pg 1 of 5

09-50026-reg Doc 11455 Filed 02/24/12 Entered 02/24/12 16:14:14 Main Document Pg 1 of 409-50026-reg Doc 11535-8 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit H Pg 2 of 5

"&#$!$% $

09-50026-reg Doc 11535-9 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit I Pg 1 of 4

U.S. District CourtDISTRICT OF KANSAS (Topeka)

CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 5:11−cv−04110−RDR−KGG

Creamer v. ESIS Claims Unit et alAssigned to: District Judge Richard D. RogersReferred to: Magistrate Judge Kenneth G. GaleDemand: $9,999,000Cause: 28:1331 Fed. Question: Auto Negligence

Date Filed: 09/15/2011Jury Demand: PlaintiffNature of Suit: 350 Motor VehicleJurisdiction: Federal Question

Plaintiff

Marjorie A. Creamer represented by Marjorie A. Creamer705 S. MonroeSmith Center, KS 66967785−259−1460Email: [email protected] SE

V.

Defendant

ESIS Claims Unit represented by Deanne Watts HayParker &Hay, LLP400 S. Kansas Ave., Suite #200Topeka, KS 66603−5736785−228−5736Fax: 785−228−5741Email: [email protected] TO BE NOTICED

Defendant

Annette Rigdon represented by Deanne Watts Hay(See above for address)ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Date Filed # Docket Text

09/15/2011 1 COMPLAINT (No Summons Issued) with trial location of Topeka filed byMarjorie A. Creamer.(mb) (Entered: 09/15/2011)

09/15/2011 2 CIVIL COVER SHEET: Re 1 Complaint by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer. (mb)(Entered: 09/15/2011)

09/15/2011 3 (NOTE: Access to document is restricted pursuant to the courts privacypolicy.)

MOTION for Leave to Proceed in forma pauperis by Plaintiff Marjorie A.Creamer(mb) (Entered: 09/15/2011)

09/15/2011 4 (NOTE: Access to document is restricted pursuant to the courts privacypolicy.)

FINANCIAL AFFIDAVIT by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer. (mb) (Entered:09/15/2011)

10/18/2011 5 MEMORANDUM AND ORDER taking under advisement 3 Motion for Leave toProceed in forma pauperis pending submission, on or before November 8, 2011, byPlaintiff of additional information identified in order. Signed by Magistrate JudgeKenneth G. Gale on 10/18/2011. Mailed to pro se party Marjorie Creamer bycertified mail. (df) (Entered: 10/18/2011)

+385) ()$$!49!#'$$#!1,1!.-- *8 76) #&"%#"%#$% #$)&# 0/ +,2 $ 76 &09-50026-reg Doc 11535-9 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit I Pg 2 of 4

10/18/2011 NOTICE Re: Pro Se Mailing. Document 5 Order on Motion for Leave to ProceedIn Forma Pauperis, mailed to Marjorie A. Creamer on 10/18/2011 by certified mail; Certified Tracking Number 70110110000213990922. (aa) (Entered: 10/18/2011)

11/07/2011 6 RESPONSE by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer re 5 Order on Motion for Leave toProceed In Forma Pauperis, (daw) (Entered: 11/07/2011)

11/07/2011 7 RETURN MAIL received re 5 Order on Motion for Leave to Proceed In FormaPauperis, addressed to Marjorie A. Creamer. Not remailed. (alm) (Entered:11/08/2011)

11/23/2011 8 MEMORANDUM AND ORDER granting 3 Motion for Leave to Proceed in formapauperis. The Clerk shall issue summons to the US Marshal or Deputy Marshal,who are appointed pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P. 4(c)(3). Plaintiff directed toIMMEDIATELY prepare and submit summon(s) to the Clerk for service. Signedby Magistrate Judge Kenneth G. Gale on 11/23/2011. (df) (Entered: 11/23/2011)

11/23/2011 SUMMONS ISSUED as to ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon. (This is a TEXTENTRY ONLY. There is no.pdf document associated with this entry) (mb)(Entered: 11/28/2011)

11/28/2011 9 MOTION for new judge by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer(mb) (Entered:11/28/2011)

12/02/2011 10 MEMORANDUM AND ORDER denying 9 Motion for Recusal. Signed byDistrict Judge Wesley E. Brown on 12/2/2011. (aa) (Entered: 12/02/2011)

12/21/2011 11 CLERKS ORDER EXTENDING TIME for Defendants Annette Rigdon, ESISClaims Unit to answer or otherwise plead. Signed by deputy clerk on 12/21/2011.(daw) (Entered: 12/21/2011)

12/26/2011 12 MOTION for default by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer(mb) (Entered: 12/27/2011)

01/05/2012 13 MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM by DefendantsESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon(Hay, Deanne) (Entered: 01/05/2012)

01/05/2012 14 MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT of 13 MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURETO STATE A CLAIM by Defendants ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon(Hay,Deanne) (Entered: 01/05/2012)

01/05/2012 15 INDEX OF EXHIBITS by Defendants ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon re 13MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM (Attachments: # 1Exhibit Complaint in this case, # 2 Exhibit GM case docket sheet, # 3 Exhibit GMcase Doc 1 Complaint, # 4 Exhibit GM case Doc 13 Order, # 5 Exhibit GM caseDoc 15 Motion, # 6 Exhibit GM case Doc 17 Motion, # 7 Exhibit GM case Doc 18Order, # 8 Exhibit GM case Doc 19 Motion, # 9 Exhibit GM case Doc 20 Order, #10 Exhibit GM case Doc 21 Motion, # 11 Exhibit GM case Doc 22 Order, # 12Exhibit GM case Doc 28 Appellate Order)(Hay, Deanne) (Entered: 01/05/2012)

01/06/2012 16 MOTION for Summary Judgment by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer(mb) (Entered:01/06/2012)

01/08/2012 17 RESPONSE by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer re 13 MOTION TO DISMISS FORFAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM (mb) (Main Document 17 replaced on1/10/2012) (mb). (Entered: 01/09/2012)

01/09/2012 18 RESPONSE by Defendants ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon re 12 MOTIONdefault (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Summons)(Hay, Deanne) (Entered: 01/09/2012)

01/10/2012 19 MEMORANDUM AND ORDER denying 12 Motion for Default ; dismissing 16Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by District Judge Wesley E. Brown on1/10/2012. Modified on 1/10/2012. This document was not mailed to Plaintiff.Plaintiff was notified via NEF (aa). (Entered: 01/10/2012)

01/11/2012 20 RETURN OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS upon Annette Rigdon mailed on11/28/2011 envelope has not been returned to USMS nor service has been made on1/10/12 (ck) Modified text on 1/12/2012 (mb). (Entered: 01/11/2012)

+385) ()$$!49!#'$$#!1,1!.-- *8 76) #&"%#"%#$% #$)&# 0/ +,2 % 76 &09-50026-reg Doc 11535-9 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit I Pg 3 of 4

01/11/2012 21 RETURN OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS Mailed on 11/28/11 upon ESIS ClaimsUnit. Envelope has not been returned to USMS nor service has been made on1/10/12 (ck) Modified text on 1/12/2012 (mb). (Entered: 01/11/2012)

01/12/2012 22 AMENDED RESPONSE by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer re 13 MOTION TODISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM (Attachment: # 1 Exhibits)(mb)(Entered: 01/12/2012)

01/12/2012 23 MOTION for New Judge, MOTION for Change of Place of Trial ( Responsedeadline 1/26/2012) by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer. (aa) (Entered: 01/13/2012)

01/20/2012 24 REPLY to Response to Motion by Defendants ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdonre: 13 MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE A CLAIM (Hay,Deanne) (Entered: 01/20/2012)

01/20/2012 25 RESPONSE by Defendants ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon re 23 MOTION forOrder MOTION Change of Place of Trial (Hay, Deanne) (Entered: 01/20/2012)

01/24/2012 26 MOTION for Summary Judgment by Plaintiff Marjorie A. Creamer(mb) (Entered:01/24/2012)

01/24/2012 27 RESPONSE by Defendants ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon re 26 MOTION forSummary Judgment (Hay, Deanne) (Entered: 01/24/2012)

01/26/2012 28 SUPPLEMENT to 26 MOTION for Summary Judgment by Plaintiff Marjorie A.Creamer. (Filed as supplement per chambers.) (aa) (Entered: 01/27/2012)

02/01/2012 29 MINUTE ORDER REASSIGNING CASE. Case reassigned to District JudgeRichard D. Rogers for all further proceedings. District Judge Wesley E. Brown nolonger assigned to case. Signed by deputy clerk on 2/1/2012.Mailed to pro se partyby regular mail (This is a TEXT ENTRY ONLY. There is no.pdf documentassociated with this entry.)(lak) (Entered: 02/01/2012)

02/16/2012 30 RESPONSE by Defendants ESIS Claims Unit, Annette Rigdon re 26 MOTION forSummary Judgment (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Index, # 2 Exhibit 1 − Civil Docketfor Creamer v GM Corp. No. 11−CV−4028, # 3 Exhibit 2 − Exhibit (Doc. 12 p. 1)in Creamer v GM Corp. No. 11−CV−4028)(Hay, Deanne) (Entered: 02/16/2012)

+385) ()$$!49!#'$$#!1,1!.-- *8 76) #&"%#"%#$% #$)&# 0/ +,2 & 76 &09-50026-reg Doc 11535-9 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12:30:34 Exhibit I Pg 4 of 4

09-50026-reg Doc 11535 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12...

Documents

Transcript of 09-50026-reg Doc 11535 Filed 03/22/12 Entered 03/22/12 12...