• Heavy user demand • Unrealistic user expectations • Lack of proper resources

33

description

• Heavy user demand • Unrealistic user expectations • Lack of proper resources • Wary of criticism...can’t do anything right. Withdrawing to the “IT Fortress:” Territorialism • Tendency for IT Organizations to build walls - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of • Heavy user demand • Unrealistic user expectations • Lack of proper resources

Page 1: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources
Page 2: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

• Heavy user demand

• Unrealistic user expectations

• Lack of proper resources

• Wary of criticism...can’t do anything right

Page 3: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources
Page 4: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Withdrawing to the “IT Fortress:” Territorialism

• Tendency for IT Organizations to build walls

• Easy to adopt a defensive stance/siege mentality

• Restrict the “peasants” in their freedoms

• Subtle feelings of superiority

Page 5: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

The reality of other “IT Kingdoms”

• Some units have a bad history with Central IT

• Mistrust of central authority due to past “misdeeds” (even ten years ago)

• Hired their own personnel to gain better control, not be dependent

Page 6: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

The reality of other “IT Kingdoms” (cont.)

• Result: Most Central IT Units in academia are not “stand alone”

• Pockets of IT Support scattered around the university or college

• Might range in size from larger units to pockets of one or two individuals

Page 7: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources
Page 8: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

The Struggle for Power • Many times there exists unhealthy competition between Central IT and these other “IT Kingdoms”

• Central IT is seen as domineering and inflexible • Imposing standards • Chargebacks • Irrational policies and procedures

• Tendency to conquer and control outside units

• Net result is that Central IT is sometimes viewed as the “Evilhearted Overlord,” who has come to tax and terrorize the countryside

Page 9: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources
Page 10: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Call a cease fire... embrace partnerships with units

outside of central IT and introduce

an atmosphere of open collaboration

while effectively utilizing the

collective strengths of all resources.

Page 11: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources
Page 12: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

WVU’s Office of Information Technology

• 175 person staff

• $30M budget

• Not a resource poor environment

Page 13: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

WVU’s Office of Information Technology(cont.)

Historically:

• Numerous IT resources outside OIT

• Politically stagnant

• Lack of IT leadership/vision

• No visibility/access

Page 14: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

The First Partnership – Admissions and Records

• Banner Student Information System

• Perfect example of competing units

• Finger pointing and worse

• No accountability for overall success of the project

• The idea of a strategic partnership

• Student Systems Development – a joint reporting unit

Page 15: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Immediate Impact – The Partnership between Student Affairs and OIT

• WVU Technology Support Center

• Student Connectivity Project

Page 16: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

WVU Technology Support Center (TSC)

• Established by OIT and Student Affairs to assist students, faculty, and staff with all technology needs.

• The TSC’s Program Coordinator joint- reports to the Director of OIT Customer Support and the Associate Director for Student Affairs Administrative Technology

• Merger of OIT’s Computer Service & Repair unit with Student Affairs’ Residential Network Consultants (RNCs)

Page 17: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

WVU TSC Services

• End-user support for ResNet users; the TSC handles on-site calls for Student Connectivity

• Computer hardware service and repair

• Software installation and support

• Pre-sales consulting for students wishing to purchase a new computer

• Students can purchase a new computer directly

from the manufacturer on a web site set up

for WVU

Page 18: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

TSC Vendor Agreements

• The TSC does not sell computers; however, the TSC worked with major computer manufacturers such as Dell, Gateway, IBM, and others to acquire significantly reduced prices on their business-class computers for student purchases

• Students can view demo models in the TSC, ask questions of the TSC staff, and even order a new computer on-line directly from the vendor

Page 19: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

TSC Locations

• Service & Repair area located in the Mountainlair, WVU’s student union, provides convenient access for students on the downtown campus

• “Sales” area located in the WVU Bookstore on the downtown campus allows students to purchase computer accessories and peripherals for their new or current computer at the Bookstore

• A new service, repair, and “sales” location in the Evansdale Residential Complex will provide convenient access to students living on the Evansdale campus

Page 20: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

First Big Test – The Student Connectivity Project

• The project’s purpose is to help students get connected to ResNet, the University’s residence hall network.

• First major effort of the combined

personnel of the Technology

Support Center.

Page 21: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

History of Student Connectivity

• Started in the Fall of 1997

• Prior to the fall of 2000, Student Affairs managed the project with 10 student employees under the direction of a full-time staff member.

Page 22: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

SC97 SC98 SC99 SC00

SC97

SC98

SC99

SC00

Unprecedented Growth in Student Connectivity

Page 23: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Results of the Unexpected Growth in 1999

• 127 complaints to the Parents’ Hotline

• Student Affairs did not finish connecting the “critical mass” of students until the 2nd week of October

• Available Student Affairs resources totally overwhelmed by student demand

Page 24: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

TSC Leads First Combined Effort to Address Problem

• In addition to TSC personnel, Student Affairs and OIT pooled resources to triage calls, provide advanced phone support, schedule appointments, and handle on-site visits.

• In total, almost 50 people from both organizations participated in Student Connectivity 2000. Many volunteered to work weekends and longer hours to ensure the success of the project.

Page 25: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources
Page 26: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

A University Pulling Together In addition to the resources provided by Student Affairs and the departments under OIT (i.e. Academic Computing, Customer Support, Information Systems,

and Telecommunications & Network Services), the following organizations contributed resources or offered their assistance to make Student Connectivity 2000 a success!

• Extension Service

• College of Business & Economics

• College of Agriculture, Forestry & Consumer Sciences

• College of Engineering & Mineral Resources

Page 27: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Results of the Connectivity Project

• NO complaints to the Parents’ Hotline

• Almost 3800 students connected in two weeks

Page 28: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Results of the Student Affairs/OIT Partnership

• WVU has added new or improved existing services to students through partnerships within the institution

• These collaborative efforts allow WVU to accomplish more with limited fiscal and human resources

Page 29: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Subsequent OIT Partnerships

• Extension Services

• Instructional Technology Resource Center

• Office of Research

• User Organizations

Page 30: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Dangers of Joint-reporting Operations

• Possible ambiguity in delineating roles

• Two supervisors giving conflicting instructions/directives

• Carving out a joint budget

• Us/them attitudes die hard

Page 31: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Benefits of Joint-reporting Operations

• Combined resources more effective

• Sense of ownership from all parties

• Decrease in competitiveness

• Presents one “face” to the university community

Page 32: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

Lessons Learned

• Attitude adjustment begins with me

• Executive leadership must be joined at the hip

• Strong SLAs

• Co-location of the new unit

• New leadership of the unit when possible

• Quickly erase all vestiges of “us/them”

• Keep on top of the partnership

• Get word out to the university community and set expectations

Page 33: •  Heavy user demand •  Unrealistic user expectations •  Lack of proper resources

For more information, contact:

Ken OrgillChief Information OfficerWest Virginia [email protected]

Amir MohammadiAssociate VP of Student AffairsWest Virginia University304-293-4409 [email protected]